Auktion 121 Künker

Page 1


121. AUKTION THE DE WIT COLLECTION OF MEDIEVAL COINS 12. - 13. März 2007 Steigenberger Hotel Remarque Osnabrück Natruper-Tor-Wall 1 Hotel-Telefon (05 41) 60 96 633 Hotel-Fax (05 41) 60 96 634 (nur während der Auktion/only during the auction/ uniquement pendant la vente/solamente durante l'asta)

ZEITPLAN AUKTIONEN 121 - 124 AUKTION 121 THE DE WIT COLLECTION OF MEDIEVAL COINS

Montag, den 12. März 2007 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 1 bis Nr. 521 Dienstag, den 13. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 522 bis Nr. 970 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 971 bis Nr. 1514

AUKTION 122 MÜNZEN UND MEDAILLEN AUS MITTELALTER UND NEUZEIT

Mittwoch, den 14. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 2001 bis Nr. 2494 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 2495 bis Nr. 3364 Donnerstag, den 15. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 3365 bis Nr. 3974 14.00 Uhr - 19.00 Uhr Nr. 3975 bis Nr. 5000

AUKTION 123 DEUTSCHE MÜNZEN SEIT 1871 DIE SAMMLUNG PAULS U. A.

AUKTION 124 MÜNZEN AUS DER ANTIKEN WELT DIE SAMMLUNG DR. ADOLF WILD U. A.

Freitag, den 16. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 6001 bis Nr. 6703 14.00 Uhr - 16.30 Uhr Nr. 6704 bis Nr. 7237 16.30 Uhr - 19.00 Uhr Nr. 7501 bis Nr. 8108 Samstag, den 17. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 8109 bis Nr. 8699 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 8700 bis Nr. 9509

Detaillierter Zeitplan siehe Seite 5 Besichtigungen siehe Seite 12 Horaire détaillé voir page 5 Exposition des monnaies voir page 12

Detailed timetable view page 5 Viewing of auction good view page 12 Calendario dettagliato veda pagina 5 Esposizione veda pagina 12


UNSERE ADRESSE OUR ADDRESS

Fritz Rudolf Künker e. K. Münzenhandlung Gutenbergstr. 23 · 49076 Osnabrück Telefon: 05 41-96 20 20 Telefax: 05 41-96 20 222 Gebührenfreie Rufnummer: 08 00-58 36 537 International calls: International fax:

+49 (0)5 41-96 20 20 +49 (0)5 41-96 20 222

Während der Auktion/During the auction Steigenberger Hotel Remarque: Telefon: Fax:

+49 (0)5 41-60 96 633 +49 (0)5 41-60 96 634

Ust.-Id.-Nr.: DE 117 620 142 UNSERE GESCHÄFTSZEITEN OPENING HOURS

Montag-Donnerstag Freitag Sonnabend Saturday

9.00 - 17.00 Uhr 9.00 - 15.30 Uhr nach Vereinbarung by prior appointment

Außerhalb unserer Geschäftszeit steht unseren Kunden ein automatischer Anrufbeantworter zur Verfügung. Answering machine available after opening hours.

WWW.KUENKER.DE E-MAIL: INFO@KUENKER.DE

Auf unserer Internetseite haben Sie die Möglichkeit: • die Abbildungen zu vergrößern • Ihre Gebote direkt per Email abzugeben • die Ergebnisse der Auktionen abzurufen On our website you have the possibility: • to zoom all images • to place your bids • to view all auction results

IHRE ANSPRECHPARTNER CONTACT

Abwicklung der Aufträge und Einlieferungen

Gisela Thomas, Prokuristin Telefon: (05 41) 96 20 221 Annahme von Einlieferungen Staff members accepting consignments

Dr. Andreas Kaiser Telefon: (05 41) 96 20 254 Arne Kirsch, Prokurist Telefon: (05 41) 96 20 234 Oliver Köpp, Prokurist Telefon: (05 41) 96 20 229 Jens-Ulrich Thormann MA (Antike Münzen) Telefon: (05 41) 96 20 242 Mitglied Verband der Deutschen Münzenhändler e. V. Associaton Internationale des Numismates Professionnels (AINP) 2


HINWEISE FÜR UNSERE BIETENDEN AUKTIONSKUNDEN 1. 2.

Die Auktionsbedingungen finden Sie am Ende dieses Katalogs. Bitte senden Sie uns Ihre Aufträge möglichst frühzeitig zu. Wenn uns Ihr Auftrag erst kurz vor der Auktion erreicht, können sich bei der Bearbeitung Fehler einschleichen. 3. Das beiliegende Formular macht es Ihnen leicht, ein schriftliches Gebot abzugeben. Falls Sie Ihre Gebote faxen möchten: unser Telefax 0541 96 20 222 steht Ihnen Tag und Nacht zur Verfügung. 4. Die von Ihnen ersteigerten Objekte werden Ihnen innerhalb von acht Tagen nach Beendigung der Auktion zugeschickt. Die Aufträge werden in der Reihenfolge des Eingangs bearbeitet, d. h. die zuerst eingegangenen Aufträge werden auch zuerst bearbeitet. Auch alle Bieter, die keinen Zuschlag erhalten haben, werden von uns nach der Auktion benachrichtigt. 5. Wenn Sie telefonisch bieten möchten, rufen Sie bitte vor der Auktion unseren Kundenservice an. Frau Thomas freut sich auf Ihren Anruf entweder direkt unter 0541 – 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 – 5 83 65 37. 6. Wenn Sie als neuer Kunde noch nicht bei uns gekauft haben, ist es empfehlenswert, wenn Sie uns Referenzen angeben. Nennen Sie uns eine Münzhandlung, mit der Sie bereits in Geschäftsverbindung stehen. Oder rufen Sie unseren Kundenservice an. Telefon 0541 – 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 – 5 83 65 37. 7. Unsere Broschüre “DIE KÜNKER-AUKTIONEN: WIE BIETE ICH ERFOLGREICH?“ liegt in jedem Katalog und ist für Sie eine nützliche Hilfe. 8. Die Echtheit aller verkauften Objekte wird auch über die gesetzliche Frist hinaus gewährleistet. 9. Alle Kunden, die als Bieter an einer unserer Auktionen teilnehmen, erhalten innerhalb von zwei Wochen nach der Auktion unsere Ergebnisliste gratis. 10. Sie haben Fragen zu einer bestimmten Münze? Sie möchten persönlich an unserer Auktion teilnehmen? Sie haben andere Fragen? Unser Kundenservice freut sich auf Ihren Anruf, entweder direkt unter 0541 – 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 – 5 83 65 37.

RENSEIGNEMENTS À L'ATTENTION DE NOS CLIENTS DES VENTES AUX ENCHÈRES 1.

Vous trouverez les conditions générales de vente aux enchères à la fin de ce catalogue. 2. Veuillez nous faire parvenir vos ordres le plus tôt possible. Si vos ordres nous parviennent juste avant la vente aux enchères, des erreurs risquent d’être commises lors de leur traitement. 3. Le formulaire ci-joint vous aidera à rédiger facilement votre offre. Si vous souhaitez faxer votre offre, vous pourrez le faire 24 heures sur 24 au +49 (0)541 – 96 20 222. 4. Les objets dont vous serez adjudicataire vous seront envoyés dans les huit jours suivant la fin de la vente aux enchères. Les commandes seront prises en compte dans l’ordre de leur arrivée, c’est-à-dire que les commandes nous parvenant les premières seront d’abord traitées. Après la vente aux enchères, nous préviendrons tous les enchérisseurs n’ayant pas obtenu l’adjudication. 5. Si vous souhaitez faire des enchères par téléphone, veuillez appeler aupravant notre service clientèle. Madame Thomas sera heureuse de vous répondre directement au +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221. 6. Si vous êtes un nouveau client et n’avez encore fait aucune acquisition chez nous, il serait conseillé de nous fournir quelques références. Indiquez nous si vous traitez déjà avec un professionnel du commerce des monnaies. Ou contactez notre service clientèle au +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221. 7. Notre brochure intitulée : »DIE KÜNKER-AUKTIONEN : WIE BIETE ICH ERFOLGREICH?“ (»Les ventes aux enchères de Künker : comment faire une enchère réussie ? « ) jointe dans chaque catalogue vous sera très utile. 8. L’authenticité des pièces vendues sera garantie même au-delà des délais légaux. 9. Tous les clients participant à l’une de nos ventes aux enchères en tant qu’enchérisseurs recevront gratuitement une liste de résultats dans les deux semaines suivant la vente aux enchères. 10. Vous avez des questions concernant une pièce particulière ? Vous désirez prendre part personnellement à notre vente aux enchères ? Vous avez d’autres questions ? Notre service clientèle se fera un plaisir de vous répondre au +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221.

IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR PLACING BIDS 1.

The terms and conditions of the auction can be found at the end of this catalogue. 2. Please send us your instructions as early as possible. The likelihood of errors occurring increases if we do not receive your instructions until shortly before the auction. 3. The enclosed form makes it simple for you to submit a written bid. Our fax machine +49 (0)541 – 96 20 222 is on standby day and night in case you wish to fax your bids. 4. The objects which you purchase will be delivered to you within eight days of the close of auction. Instructions are processed in the same order as they were received – in other words, the first instructions to be received are the first to be processed. All unsuccessful bidders will be also informed after the auction. 5. If you would like to bid by telephone, please ring our customer service beforehand. Mrs. Thomas will be pleased to speak to you on +49 (0)541 96 20 221. 6. If you are a new customer who has not yet bought anything through us, we recommend that you give us references. Name a coin dealer with whom you have already done business. Or call our customer service on +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221. 7. Our brochure „DIE KÜNKER-AUKTIONEN: WIE BIETE ICH ERFOLGREICH?“ ("The Künker auctions: How to bid successfully?“) is enclosed in every catalogue and will prove useful to you. 8. The genuineness of all sold objects is also warranted beyond the statutory length of time. 9. All customers who participate as bidders in our auction receive our list of results free of charge within two weeks of the close of auction. 10. Do you have questions about a particular coin? Would you like to participate personally in our auction? Do you have any other questions? Our customer service team will be pleased to help you – call on +49 (0)541 96 20 221.

INFORMAZIONI PER GLI OFFERENTI DELLE NOSTRE ASTE 1. 2.

Le condizioni d’asta si trovano alla fine di questo catalogo. Siete pregati di inviarci i vostri ordini il più presto possibile. Se il vostro ordine ci perviene poco tempo prima dell’apertura dell’asta, si possono verificare errori nell’elaborazione dello stesso. 3. Per le vostre offerte scritte potete utilizzare il modulo allegato al catalogo. Nel caso voleste trasmettere le vostre offerte per fax, siete pregati di inviarle al seguente numero: +49 (0)541-96 20 222. 4. Gli oggetti che avete acquistato all’asta vi saranno spediti entro otto giorni dal termine della stessa. Gli ordini vengono evasi in base alla data di ricevimento, quindi hanno precedenza quelli pervenuti prima. Anche gli offerenti che non hanno avuta alcuna aggiudicazione riceveranno una nostra comunicazione al termine dell’asta. 5. Se desiderate la partecipazione telefonica in diretta durante l´asta, siete pregati di chiamare prima la consulenza ai clienti. La sig.ra Thomas, raggiungibile al numero diretto +49 (0)541- 96 20 221, sará a vostra disposizione. 6. Se siete clienti nuovi e non avete mai acquistato da noi, vi proponiamo di inviarci delle referenze. Dateci il nome di un negozio di monete presso il quale avete già fatto degli acquisti, oppure chiamate la nostra consulenza ai clienti al numero +49 (0)541 96 20 221. 7. Nel nostro opuscolo « DIE KÜNKER-AUKTIONEN : WIE BIETE ICH ERFOLGREICH?“ („Aste Künker: come avere successo nelle offerte?“), allegato ad ogni catalogo, troverete consigli utili. 8. Il certificato d’autenticità di tutti gli oggetti venduti viene rilasciato anche oltre i termini privisti per legge. 9. Tutti i clienti che hanno partecipato ad una nostra asta riceveranno gratuitamente l´elenco delle aggiudicazioni entro quindici giorni dal termine della stessa. 10. Avete delle domande su una moneta in particolare ? Desiderate partecipare personalmente ad una nostra asta? Avete altre domande? Rivolgetevi al nostro Servizio Clienti al numero +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221.

3


WICHTIGE HINWEISE FÜR UNSERE EINLIEFERER 1.

Unser Expertenteam garantiert Ihnen eine fachgerechte Bearbeitung der von Ihnen eingelieferten Stücke. 2. Die Schätzpreise werden von uns aufgrund unserer hervorragenden Marktkenntnisse sorgfältig festgelegt. Die Stücke werden zu 80% der im Katalog angegebenen Schätzpreise ausgerufen. Durch diese Regelung werden Sie als Einlieferer geschützt. Für nicht verkaufte Objekte werden keine Gebühren erhoben. 3. Der Standard unserer Kataloge ist von hoher Qualität und findet internationale Anerkennung. Wir haben eine der besten Kundendateien, die es weltweit gibt. 4, Von der individuellen Betreuung unserer Kunden profitieren auch Sie als Einlieferer. 5. Als Einlieferer erhalten Sie Ihren Auktionserlös innerhalb von 45 Tagen nach der Auktion. Sonderregelungen sind nach Absprache möglich. 6. Auf Wunsch kann Ihre Einlieferung bei Ihnen zuhause abgeholt werden. Ab € 2.500,-- Einlieferungssumme übernehmen wir die Kosten, ab € 25.000,-können wir unter Umständen an einem vereinbarten Ort Ihre Einlieferung nach Absprache gerne auch persönlich entgegennehmen. Selbstverständlich ist Ihr Versteigerungsgut durch uns versichert. 7. Nicht alle Münzen eignen sich, als Einzelstücke aufgenommen zu werden. Vertrauen Sie auf die Erfahrung unserer Experten, die niedrigpreisige Münzen liebevoll zu interessanten Lots zusammenstellen. 8. Der Schätzwert Ihrer Einlieferung sollte mindestens € 1.000,-- betragen. 9. Ihre Einlieferung wird Ihnen sofort bei Übernahme durch ein Protokoll quittiert. Spätestens fünf Wochen vor der Auktion erhalten Sie eine genaue Auflistung Ihrer Objekte mit den dazugehörenden Katalognummern. 10. Innerhalb einer Woche nach der Auktion erhalten Sie bereits die Ergebnisliste und können alle erzielten Preise feststellen. 11. Profitieren Sie von der Anziehungskraft eines führenden Unternehmens. Bitte wenden Sie sich bei Fragen an unseren Kundenservice unter Leitung von Frau Gisela Thomas direkt unter 0541 – 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 – 5 83 65 37. 12. Unsere Verträge für Einlieferungen können Sie unverbindlich anfordern. Haben Sie noch Fragen? Frau Thomas freut sich auf Ihren Anruf. Telefon: 0541 – 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 5 83 65 37.

RENSEIGNEMENTS IMPORTANTS A L'ATTENTION DES VENDEURS 1.

Notre équipe d’experts garantit une prise en charge compétente des pièces que vous nous confiez. 2. Notre excellente connaissance du marché nous permet de fixer soigneusement les prix estimés. Les pièces seront mises aux enchères à un prix représentant 80% du prix estimé indiqué dans le catalogue. Cette réglementation vous protège en tant que vendeur. Aucuns frais ne seront prélevés sur les pièces invendues. 3. Nos catalogues ont un niveau qualitatif élevé, reconnu au plan international. Nous disposons d’un des meilleurs fichiers clients du monde. 4. En tant que vendeur, vous profiterez vous aussi du suivi personnalisé que nous offrons à nos clients. 5. Le vendeur recevra le produit de la vente dans les 45 jours qui suivront les enchères. Des dispositions spéciales pourront être prises sur accord préalable. 6. Nous prendrons en charge les frais d´expédition des pièces dont le montant sera supérieur à € 2.500,--: Si leur montant est supérieur à € 25.000,--, l´un de nos employés se poudra charger de prendre la livraison à un lieu concordée. En concertation, notre assurance couvrira tous les risques. 7. Les pièces de monnaie ne se prêtent pas toutes à une vente individuelle. Faites confiance à l’expérience de nos spécialistes qui se chargeront avec plaisir de rassembler les pièces bon marché de manière à constituer des lots intéressants. 8. La valeur estimée des pièces fournies devrait s’élever à un minimum de € 1.000,--. 9. Au moment de la prise en charge, vous recevrez un détail des pièces fournies. Au plus tard cinq semaines avant la vente aux enchères, vous recevrez une liste exacte de vos pièces avec les numéros de catalogue correspondants. 10. Dans la semaine qui suivra la vente aux enchères, vous recevrez déjà la liste de ses résultats et pourrez prendre connaissance des prix obtenus. 11. Profitez de l’attrait du leader du marché. Pour tout renseignement, veuillez-vous adresser à notre service clientèle sous la direction de madame Gisela Thomas : +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221. 12. Vous pouvez demander sans engagement de votre part nos contrats de dépôt de pièces? Vous avez d’autres questions? Madame Thomas sera heureuse de vous répondre au +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221.

4

IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR OUR CONSIGNERS 1.

Our team of specialists guarantees an expert treatment of the consigned items. 2. The estimates are carefully established by us due to our excellent knowledge of the market. Bidding for the items is then started at 80 % of the estimate price stated in the catalogue. This arrangement protects you as a consigner. Unsold items incur no fees. 3. The standard offered in our catalogue is of the highest quality, and is recognised internationally. We have one of the best clientele lists worldwide. 4. You as a consigner also profit from the individual consultation offered to our customers. 5. As a consigner, you receive the auction proceeds within 45 days of the close of auction. Special arrangements can be made following discussion. 6. For consignments with a value over € 2.500,-- we may bear the transportation costs. For deliveries over € 25.000,-- we may personally collect the items at an arranged place after prior consultation. Upon consultation, the shipping of your goods could be covered by our insurance. 7. Not all coins are suited to be registered as individual items. Trust in our expert´s experience as they carefully combine less-valuable coins into interesting lots. 8. The valuation price of your delivery should be at least € 1.000,--. 9. Your delivery is confirmed in writing immediately on receipt. At least five weeks before the auction, you receive an exact list of your objects with the relevant catalogue numbers. 10. Within a week of the close of auction, you receive a list with the results in order to see what prices were reached for each individual lot. 11. Profit from our position as a leading coin dealer. If you have any questions, please contact our customer service team which is headed by Mrs. Gisela Thomas – directly on +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221. 12. Would you like to receive copies of our contracts for consigner, without making any commitment? Do you have any other questions? Mrs. Thomas will be pleased to help you – please call on +49 (0)541 – 96 20 221.

INFORMAZIONI PER I NOSTRI DEPOSITANTI 1.

Il nostro team di esperti assicura un trattamento accurato dei pezzi che ci avete inviato. 2. Eseguiamo valutazioni finalizzate alla vendita. I prezzi di stima sono frutto della nostra eccezionale conoscenza del mercato e della nostra attenta valutazione. La base d´asta ammonta all´80% del prezzo di stima indicato sul catalogo. Non si addebitano spese per gli oggetti invenduti. 3. I nostri cataloghi sono di alta qualità e sono riconosciuti a livello internazionale. I nostri clienti sono fra i migliori al mondo. 4. Come depositanti potete beneficiare dell’assistenza riservata a ciascuno dei nostri clienti. 5. Come depositanti riceverete gli importi realizzati all’asta entro 45 giorni dal termine della stessa. Si possono concordare condizioni particolari. 6. A partire da un controvalore degli oggetti di € 2.500,--i costi del trasporto sono a nostro carico, mentre a partire da un controvalore di € 25.000 gli oggetti possono essere ritirati personalmente da un nostro incaricato ad un posto concordato. Naturalmente il trasporto dei vostri oggetti puó essere assicurato tramite la nostra assicurazione. 7. Non tutte le monete possono essere negoziate singolarmente. Fidatevi dell´esperienza dei nostri esperti, che raggruppano le monete non molto preziose in lotti di sicuro interesse. 8. Il valore stimato degli oggetti depositati deve ammontare ad almeno € 1.000,--. 9. Nel momento in cui gli oggetti sono presi in consegna, viene rilasciata una ricevuta numerata. Riceverete un elenco preciso degli oggetti che avete depositato con i relativi numeri di catalogo al massimo cinque settimane prima dell’asta. 10. Riceverete l’elenco degli oggetti aggiudicati entro una settimana dalla chiusura dell’asta. Potrete cosi verificare i prezzi realizzati. 11. Approfittate della capacità di un leader di mercato per aumentare il valore dei vostri oggetti. Se avete delle domande, rimaniamo a vostra disposizione per qualsiasi necessità. Rivolgetevi alla nostra consulenza ai clienti diretta dalla sig.ra Gisela Thomas al numero +49 (0)541-91 20 221. 12. Volete ricevere i nostri contratti senza impegno? Avete altre domande? Potete contattare la sig.ra Gisela Thomas al numero +49 (0)541-96 20 221.


DETAILLIERTER ZEITPLAN AUKTIONEN 121-124 AUKTION 121 THE DE WIT COLLECTION OF MEDIEVAL COINS

AUKTION 122 MÜNZEN UND MEDAILLEN AUS MITTELALTER UND NEUZEIT

AUKTION 123 DEUTSCHE MÜNZEN SEIT 1871 DIE SAMMLUNG PAULS U. A.

AUKTION 124 MÜNZEN AUS DER ANTIKEN WELT DIE SAMMLUNG DR. ADOLF WILD U. A.

Montag, den 12. März 2007 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 1 bis Nr. 521 Völkerwanderung - Frankreich Dienstag, den 13. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 522 bis Nr. 970 Elsaß-Lothringen, Skandinavien, Niederlande: Friesland - Zutphen 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 971 bis Nr. 1514 Niederlande: Geldern - Burgundische Niederlande Mittwoch, den 14. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 2001 bis Nr. 2494 Goldprägungen: Ausland, Habsburgische Erblande 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 2495 bis Nr. 3364 Goldprägungen: Deutschland, Silberprägungen: Ausland Donnerstag, den 15. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 3365 bis Nr. 3974 Silberprägungen: Habsburgische Erblande, Deutschland: Aachen - Brandenburg-Preußen 14.00 Uhr - 19.00 Uhr Nr. 3975 bis Nr. 5000 Silberprägungen: Braunau - Wuppertal, Sammlung Hans Lummer Teil I und II, Medaillen, Notmünzen, Papiergeld, Münzgefäße, Numismatische Literatur, Lots Freitag, den 16. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 6001 bis Nr. 6703 Reichskleinmünzen, Reichssilbermünzen, Reichsgoldmünzen: Anhalt - Mecklenburg-Strelitz 14.00 Uhr - 16.30 Uhr Nr. 6704 bis Nr. 7237 Reichsgoldmünzen: Preußen - BRD, Weltkrieg und Inflation, Weimarer Republik, Drittes Reich, BRD, DDR, Gent, Zweiter Weltkrieg, Deutsche Kolonien, Notmünzen, Proben, Lots 16.30 Uhr - 19.00 Uhr Nr. 7501 bis Nr. 8108 Goldprägungen der Antike, Griechische Münzen, Sammlung Hans Lummer Teil III Samstag, den 17. März 2007 10.00 Uhr - 13.00 Uhr Nr. 8109 bis Nr. 8699 Römische Münzen Teil I 14.00 Uhr - 18.00 Uhr Nr. 8700 bis Nr. 9509 Römische Münzen Teil II, Völkerwanderung, Byzanz, Kreuzfahrer

BESICHTIGUNGEN

Besichtigung des Auktionsgutes in unseren Geschäftsräumen, Gutenbergstr. 23, 49076 Osnabrück, ab dem 12.02.2007, nach vorheriger telefonischer Vereinbarung unter Nr. 05 41 - 96 20 221. 5


LIST OF CONTENTS AUCTION 121 No. THE DE WIT COLLECTION OF MEDIEVAL COINS

1

-

1514

13

-

470

Migration of the Germans

1

-

79

14

-

35

80

-

93

36

-

39

Municipal Coinage in Italy and Africa Carthago Rome Ravenna Early Imperial

94 94 97 103

-

105 96 102 104 105

40 40 41

-

43 41 42 43 43

Ostrogoths

106

-

127

44

-

50

Huns and Vandals

Gepiden

128

50

Visigoths

129

-

138

51

-

53

Lombards

139

-

146

54

-

58

Principality Beneventum

147

-

150

58

-

59

Franks - Frisia

6

Page

151

59

Merovingians Provence

152 173

-

177 177

60 67

-

69 69

Carolingians - Robertines Aquitaine Francia Occidentalis France Midi Francia Orientalis

178 196 198 236 240

-

245 197 235 239 245

69 75 76 85 87

-

88 76 85 86 88

France Duché de France France Royale France Féodale Normandy, County and Duchy Dreux, County Nogent, Seigniory Brittany, Duchy Penthièvre, County Anjou, County Maine, County Touraine Chartres, County Châteaudun Blois, County Celles-sur-Cher, Seigniory St. Aignan, Seigniory Donzy, County Vierzon, Seigniory Sancerre, County

246 246 253 334 334 339 341 343

-

89 89 91 116 116

-

119

-

358 360 363 365

-

123 124

-

370 374

-

521 252 333 521 338 340 342 355 356 357 359 362 364 367 368 369 373 375 376 377

128 129

-

199 91 116 199 117 118 118 122 122 123 124 125 127 127 128 128 129 130 130 130


No. France (Continuation) Vendôme, County Deols (Châteauroux), Seigniory Issoudun, Seigniory Souvigny, Abbey Bourbon, Seigniory Puy, Diocese Clermont, Diocese Poitou, County Aquitaine Limoges, Viscounty St. Martial de Limoges, Abbey Angoulême, County Périgord, County Bergerac Béarn, Seigniory Roussillon, County Carcassonne Toulouse, County Albi, Viscounty Cahors, Diocese Cahors, City Rouergue, County Anduse and Sauve, Seigniory Melgueil, County Burgundia Arelate, Kingdom Provence, Margraviate Provence, County Arles, Archdiocese Saint-Gilles, County Avignon, Commune Burgundia Cisiurana, Kingdom Burgundy, Duchy Scodingue, County Besançon, Archdiocese Vienne, Archdiocese Lyon, County Lyon, Archdiocese Viennois, Dauphins Orange, Principality Valence and Die, Diocese Tournus, Abbey Nevers, County Auxerre, County Sens, County Provins, County Meaux, Diocese Meaux and Troyes

379 382 384 387

-

390 392 395

-

430 432 434 437 439 444 447

-

452

-

457 468

-

471 479

-

489

-

493 497 499 502

-

507

-

512 514

-

Page

378 381 383 386 388 389 391 394 425 426 427 428 429 431 433 436 438 443 446 449 450 451 453 454 455 456 467 469 469 470 478 486 487 488 491 492 496 498 501 505 506 509 510 511 513 515 516

131

-

132

-

136

-

147

-

151 152

-

156

-

160 161

-

167 168

-

172

-

131 132 132 133 133 134 134 135 145 145 146 146 147 148 148 149 150 152 153 153 154 154 154 155 155 156 158 159 159 159 161 163 164 164 165 165 166 167 168 169 169 170 171 171 172 173 173 7


No. France (Continuation) Reims, Archdiocese Saint-Médard à Soissons, Abbey Corbie, Abbey Amiens, City Alsace-Lorraine Metz, Diocese Epinal Saarburg Metz, City Toul, Diocese Verdun, Diocese Gorze, Abbey Remiremont, Abbey Bar, Duchy Lorraine, Duchy Lorraine and Bar, Duchy Porcéan, County Alsace Strasbourg Strasbourg, City Haguenau Altdorf, Abbey Selz, Abbey

520 522 522

-

545 550 556

-

567 575 579

-

582 604 608

-

Scandinavia Denmark Sweden Norway Drontheim, Archbishopric Scandinavian Imitations

614 614 670 696

-

703

-

Netherlands Holland, County Middenfriesland East Frisia Utrecht, Diocese Utrecht, City Tiel Zaltbommel Groningen, City Kuinre Koevorden Northern or Western Netherlands Hamaland Zutphen

711 715 793 837 846 928 933 940 944 959 964

-

968

-

971 1025 1029

-

Gelre (Guelders) Arnhem s'Heerenberg 8

Page

517 518 519 521 613 542 543 544 549 555 563 564 565 566 574 578 580 581 603 607 611 612 613

176 176

-

181 182 184

-

187 189 190

-

192

-

710 669 695 702 702 710

200 201 216 223

-

225

-

1514 792 836 845 927 932 939 943 958 963 966 967 969 970

227 229 257 270 274 295 297 299 300 304 306

-

308

-

1024 1028 1031

310

-

327

-

173 174 174 175 199 180 180 180 182 183 185 186 186 186 189 190 191 191 197 197 198 199 199 226 216 222 224 224 226 470 256 269 273 295 296 299 300 304 306 307 307 309 310

325 326 328


No. Netherlands (Continuation) Nijmegen Ijsselsteden Deventer Drie Steden Zwolle Kampen Maassteden Oyen Megen Arkel, Seigniory Gorinchem Lotharingia / Lorraine Lower Lorraine Upper Lorraine Margraviate of Antwerpen Leuven, Counts Bruxelles, Chapter Brabant, Duchy Nivelles, Abbey Limburg, Duchy Looz, County Rummen Gerdingen Unknown Mailles Bicht Reckheim Maastricht Liège, Prince-Bishopric Flanders, County Tournai, Diocese Hainaut, County Beaumont, Seignory St. Aldegonde, Abbaye Cambrai, Diocese Cambrai, Chapter Serain, Seigniory Elincourt and Ligny, County Crèvecœur, Seigniory Namur, County Luxembourg, County-Duchy Burgundian Netherlands

1032 1048 1048 1079 1082 1085 1088

-

1090 1092 1094 1094 1099

-

1102

-

1107

-

1178 1181 1186 1191

-

1194 1197 1203 1239

-

1345

-

1377 1379

-

1386 1398 1416

-

Page

1047 1087 1078 1081 1084 1087 1093 1088 1089 1091 1093 1100 1098 1100 1101 1105 1106 1175 1176 1177 1180 1185 1190 1192 1193 1196 1202 1238 1343 1344 1375 1376 1378 1381 1382 1383 1384 1385 1397 1415 1514

329 334 334 343 344 345 346

-

347 349 350 351

-

354

-

356

-

374 375 376

-

380 381 385 395

-

419

-

432 435 441

-

333 346 342 344 345 346 350 346 347 348 350 353 353 353 354 355 355 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 384 394 418 418 428 428 429 430 431 431 431 432 434 441 470

9


;'#45 1( '7412'#0 %1+0#)' 6*' &' 9+6 %1..'%6+10 1( /'&+'8#. %1+05 8QNWOG + /KITCVKQP 2GTKQFG /GTQXKPIKCPU %CTQNKPIKCPU (TCPEG 5ECPFKPCXKC CPF VJG 0QTVJGTP CPF 5QWVJGTP 0GVJGTNCPFU

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ʼn 9CT HTQO VJG HQTOCVKQP QH VJG KPFGRGPFGPV NKXGN[ CPF RQYGTHWN EKVKGU VQ VJG SWKGV OQPCUVGTKGU ņ RTQVGEVQTU QH OGFKGXCN UEJQNCTUJKR HTQO VJG EQVVCIGU QH VJG RQQTGT RGQRNG VQ VJG RCNCVKPGU QH VJG (TCPMKUJ MKPIU /QPG[ KU QOPKRTGUGPV CPF OKTTQTU VJG FGXGNQROGPV QH OGFKGXCN UQEKGV[ 6JG EQODKPGF JKUVQTKECN GEQPQOKE CPF CTVKUVKE CURGEVU QH KPFKXKFWCN EQKPU DGEQOG C UQWTEG QH UKIPKHKECPV KPHQTOCVKQP %QPUKFGTKPI VJG HCEV VJCV UQOG CVVTKDWVKQPU CTG UVKNN WPEGTVCKP VJG CTTCPIGOGPV QH VJG EQKPU KP VJKU ECVCNQIWG RCTVN[ UGGOU VQ DG FGDCVCDNG +P CTTCPIKPI VJG ECVCNQIWG YG GZVGPUKXGN[ HQNNQYGF VJG EQPEGRV QH VJG EQNNGEVQT CPF CWVJQT YJQ KU TGURQPUKDNG HQT VJG VGZV KP IGPGTCN CU YGNN CU HQT VJG GZRNCPCVKQPU QH VJG EQKPU 9G XG RWDNKUJGF C NQV QH EQOOGPVU HTQO 2TQHGUUQT &G 9KV QP VJG KPFKXKFWCN EQKPU VJG RGTUQPU YJQ KUUWGF VJGO VJG JKUVQTKECN DCEMITQWPF CPF C FGVCKNGF DKDNKQITCRJ[ RTQXKFKPI RTQURGEVKXG EWUVQOGTU YKVJ VJG RQUUKDKNKV[ VQ ICKP C FGGRGT WPFGTUVCPFKPI QH VJKU GZVTCQTFKPCT[ RGTKQF QH EQKP JKUVQT[ +P JKU QYP YQTFU 2TQHGUUQT &G 9KV RTQXKFGU VJG KPVGTGUVGF TGCFGT YKVJ HWTVJGT KPHQTOCVKQP CPF GZRNCPCVKQPU QH JQY CPF YJ[ UQOG FKUVTKDWVKQPU CTG VJG YC[ VJG[ CTG PQV QPN[ RTQXKPI JKU SWCNKHKECVKQP CU CP CWVJQT QH PWOKUOCVKE NKVGTCVWTG DWV CNUQ JKU MPQYNGFIG QH OGFKGXCN JKUVQT[ #V NGCUV KV YQWNF DG C RNGCUWTG VQ IKXG OGFKGXCN PWOKUOCVKE TGUGCTEJ CP KORWNUG D[ RWVVKPI VJG KPFKXKFWCN URGEKOGPU WR HQT FKUEWUUKQP #NVJQWIJ KV EGTVCKPN[ YKNN PQV EQXGT CNN CURGEVU QH OGFKGXCN JKUVQT[ VJG RWDNKUJKPI QH VJG &G 9KV EQNNGEVKQP RTQXKFGU OQTG VJCP C IGPGTCN QXGTXKGY QXGT KORQTVCPV [GCTU QH 'WTQRGCP EQKP JKUVQT[ 2TQHGUUQT ) 9 FG 9KV 2TKXCVG NKHG ) 9 FG 9KV YCU DQTP KP *G VCWIJV RJ[UKEU CV VJG .GKFGP 7PKXGTUKV[ KP VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU CPF GPVGTGF VJG KP UWTCPEG DWUKPGUU CV VJG GPF QH *G URGPV JKU YJQNG RTQHGUUKQPCN NKHG KP VJG UCOG EQORCP[ CU C IGPGTCN OCPCIGT ņ VJG HKTUV 0CVKQPCNG .GXGPUXGT\GMGTKPIDCPM NCVGT 0CVKQPCNG 0GFGTNCPFGP CPF VQFC[ +0) ņ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


#ESWKTKPI VJG EQNNGEVKQP +P VJG NCVG HKHVKGU CPF GCTN[ UKZVKGU 2TQHGUUQT FG 9KV CPF JKU YKHG OCFG [GCTN[ VTKRU VJTQWIJ +VCN[ $QVJ YGTG HCUEKPCVGF D[ VJG OGFKGXCN CTV CPF GURGEKCNN[ D[ VJG NQPI UGTKGU QH UEGPGU HTQO VJG 1NF CPF 0GY 6GUVCOGPV KP EJWTEJGU CPF QP YQQFGP ETWEKHKZGU *G YCU KPVGTGUVGF KP VJG FGXGNQROGPV QH VJG UGRCTCVG UEGPGU CPF VJG KEQPQITCRJ[ QH VJG RKEVWTGU 6Q UVWF[ VJKU CURGEV QH OGFKGXCN CTV JG UGNGEVGF VJG UEGPGU QH VJG #PPWPEKCVKQP HQT VYQ TGCUQPU (KTUVN[ VJKU UEGPG KU VJG OQUV TGRTGUGPVGF CPF UGEQPFN[ KV KU C TGNCVKXGN[ UKORNG UEGPG YKVJ QPN[ VYQ RGTUQPU CPF C OCZKOWO QH VYQ QDLGEVU ņ VJG JCPF QH )QF CPF C RQV QH HNQYGTU UQOGVKOGU YKVJ CP CTEJKVGEVWTCN HTCOGYQTM &WTKPI VJG UVWFKGU QH VJKU UEGPG JG FKUEQXGTGF VJCV VJGTG YCU C TGRTGUGPVCVKQP QH VJG CPPWPEKCVKQP QP C EQKP 6JG 5CNWV F 1T QH %JCTNGU QH #PLQW QH 0CRNGU +P JG DQWIJV C YQPFGTHWN URGEKOGP QH VJKU EQKP CV 5EJWNOCP KP #OUVGTFCO VQ JCXG UQOGVJKPI KP JCPF QH VJKU HCUEKPCVKPI OGFKGXCN RGTKQF ņ VJG DGIKPPKPI QH JKU HWVWTG EQKP EQNNGEVKQP (KTUV NKOKVKPI KV VQ +VCN[ &G 9KV UQQP XGPVWTGF KPVQ 'WTQRGCP PWOKUOCVKE VGTTKVQT[ DWV UVKNN TGUVTKEVGF JKU EQNNGEVKQP VQ EQKPU QH VJG /KFFNG #IGU *KU IQCN UVKNN YCU VQ EQNNGEV DGCWVKHWN URGEKOGPU YKVJ CP KPVGTGUVKPI DCEMITQWPF

CTV JKUVQT[ CPF KEQPQITCRJ[ 6JG IWKFGNKPG YCU VQ RQUUGUU VJG DGUV CXCKNCDNG SWCNKV[ HQT CTV KU QPN[ DGCWVKHWN YJGP KV KU QH VJG JKIJGUV SWCNKV[ 6Q KNNWUVTCVG VJG QHVGP JKIJ UVCPFCTF QH OGFKGXCN EQKP CTV VJG OCLQTKV[ QH VJG URGEKOGPU KU UJQYP GPNCTIGPGF +H PQV QVJGTYKUG OGPVKQPGF VJGUG GPNCTIGOGPVU CTG 6QFC[ VJG EQNNGEVKQP IKXGU CU DGUV CU RQUUKDNG CP QXGTXKGY QH GWTQRGCP OGFKGXCN EQKPCIG $WV VJGTG CTG UGXGTCN RCTVU YJKEJ CVVTCEV VJG URGEKCN CVVGPVKQP QH VJG EQNNGEVQT 6JG HKTUV RCTV UVCTVGF KP YJGP JG DQWIJV C UOCNN EQKP QH GZEGNNGPV SWCNKV[ JCXKPI PQ KFGC YJCV JG YCU NQQMKPI CV 6JKU ITQY WR QXGT [GCTU VQ VJG OQUV KORQTVCPV EQNNGEVKQP QH UEGCVVCU VQ KP VJG YQTNF (QT JKO KP VJG UEGCVVCU DGCWV[ CPF KPVGTGUVKPI KEQPQITCRJ[ IQ JCPF KP JCPF 6JG UGEQPF RCTV YCU C EQNNGEVKQP QH RGPPKGU QH VJG 3WCVTGHQKN 6[RG QH %PWV VJG )TGCV QH 'PINCPF *GTG YG HKPF FKG EWVVKPI QH VJG JKIJGUV UVCPFCTF 6JKU IKXGU CP GZEGNNGPV QXGTXKGY QH VJG FKHHGTGPV UV[NGU HTQO UGXGTCN OKPVJQWUGU KP VJG VKOG CTQWPF 6JG VJKTF CPF NCUV RCTV UVCTVGF UQOGYJCV NCVGT *GTG KV KU VJG CVVTCEVKQP QH VJG )GTOCP DTCEVGCVGU KP HCEV OQTG VJCP URGEKOGPU HTQO VJG VKOG QH (TGFGTKE $CTDCTQUUC PF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ YJKEJ RTGUGPV YQPFGTHWN TQOCPGUSWG GPITCXKPIU 6JKU RCTV YCU OQUVN[ HQTOGF HTQO QNF EQNNGEVKQPU $WV VJGUG RCTVU YGTG QPN[ QPG UVCPFKPI NGI QH VJKU GZVTCQTFKPCT[ EQNNGEVKQP %QPVCKPKPI COQPI QVJGTU C 5KNKSWC QH VJG 1UVTQIQVJU %CTQNKPIKCP FGPKGTU DTCEVGCVGU QH VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT (TGFGTKE $CTDCTQUUC RGPPKGU QH VJG &CPKUJ MKPI 8CNFGOCT +8 #VVGTFCI CPF C 0QDNG QH 2JKNKR VJG (CKT VJG EQNNGEVKQP QH 2TQHGUUQT &G 9KV YJKEJ PQY EQOGU VQ UCNG RTQXKFGU C WPKSWG UWTXG[ QH VJG %QKPCIG FWTKPI VJG /KFFNG #IGU #PF UQ KV DGECOG C NQV OQTG VJCP C EQNNGEVKQP QH KPVGTGUVKPI OGFKGXCN KEQPQITCRJKGU 9G EQPUKFGT KV CP JQPQWT VQ RWDNKUJ CPF UGNN 2TQHGUUQT FG 9KV U KORQTVCPV EQNNGEVKQP QH OGFKGXCN EQKPU KP VJTGG RCTVU CPF YQWNF NKMG VQ GZRTGUU QWT VJCPMU HQT RNCEKPI JKU EQPHKFGPEG KP QWT JQWUG 6JG FGEKUKQP VQ RCTV HTQO JKU EQNNGEVKQP GPCDNGU QVJGT KPVGTGUVGF EQNNGEVQTU VQ FKUEQXGT VJG PWOKUOCVKE EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU HCUEKPCVKQP CPF TCTKVKGU QH OGFKGXCN 'WTQRGCP EQKPCIG /CP[ QH VJG URGEKOGPU CTG HTQO PQVCDNG EQNNGEVKQPU CPF KP GZEGNNGPV EQPFKVKQP 9G JQRG VJCV VJKU ECVCNQIWG CPF KVU EQPVKPWCVKQP YKNN CVVTCEV VJG CVVGPVKQP CPF YKP VJG TGEQIPKVKQP QH QWT EQNNGEVQTU 9G JQRG [QW GPLQ[ TGCFKPI VJG EQOOGPVCTKGU CPF YKUJ IQQF NWEM KP QDVCKPKPI RKGEGU HTQO VJKU GZVTCQTFKPCT[ EQNNGEVKQP 1UPCDTÒ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ÒP\GP WPF 'THQTUEJGT FGT 0WOKUOCVKM FGU /KVVGNCNVGTU CPURTGEJGP \W MÌPPGP (ÒT FKG FCOKV XGTDWPFGPGP 5EJYKGTKIMGKVGP HÒT WPUGTG FGWVUEJURTCEJKIGP -WPFGP DKVVGP YKT WO 8GTUV·PFPKU 7PUGT 6GCO UVGJV +JPGP UGNDUVXGTUV·PFNKEJ OKV 4CV WPF *KNHG DGK 7PMNCTJGKVGP QFGT 8GTUV·PFPKURTQDNGOGP \WT 8GTHÒIWPI 11


WICHTIGE HINWEISE FÜR UNSERE TELEFONBIETER Wenn Sie telefonisch bieten möchten, muß das vor der Auktion durch uns genehmigt werden. Voraussetzung für ein telefonisches Mitbieten ist, daß Sie mindestens den Schätzpreis schriftlich bieten. Telefonisches Bieten ist erst ab einem Schätzpreis von ca. 500 Euro pro Los möglich. Bitte rufen Sie Frau Thomas vor der Auktion an unter +49 (0)541 96 20 221 oder gebührenfrei unter 0800 58 36 537. Wir übernehmen keinerlei Haftung, falls die telefonische Verbindung während der Auktion nicht zustande kommt.

INFORMATIONS POUR NOS CLIENTS PARTICIPANT A NOS VENTES AUX ENCHERES PAR TELEPHONE Si vous désirez participer par téléphone à nos ventes aux enchères, veuillez vous mettre en relation avec notre service clientèle quelques jours avant la vente en appelant le numéro +49 (0)541 96 20 233. Une participation téléphonique à la vente sera possible à la condition que vous nous fassiez parvenir aussi votre ordre par écrit. Cet ordre devra être au moins égal au minimum au prix d’estimation et concerner un lot estimé au moins 500 Euros. Nous déclinons toute responsabilité dans le cas où la communication téléphonique serait interrompue, ou bien ne pourrait être établie.

IMPORTANT INFORMATION ON TELEPHONE BIDDING If you wish to participate in the auction as a telephone bidder, please let us know several days in advance as we have to approve and schedule all calls. To register for telephone bidding, we require that you submit at least the estimate as a written bid in addition to being called. Telephone bidding is accepted on lot numbers with estimates above 500 Euro. Please call us at +49 (0)541 96 20 233 for more information or to register for telephone bidding. We do not assume liability for telephone bids, should the telephone line be interrupted.

INFORMAZIONI PER LA PARTECIPAZIONE TELEFONICA Se desiderate la partecipazione telefonica in diretta durante l´asta, siete pregati di chiamare la Signorina Sonia Russo al numero diretto +49 (0)541 96 20 245 qualche giorno prima dell´asta e di inviarci la vostra offerta, la quale deve ammontare come minimo al prezzo di stima anche per iscritto. Accettiamo una partecipazione telefonica in diretta durante l´asta per oggetti il cui prezzo di stima ammonta come minimo ai 500 Euro. Non assumeremo nessuna responsabilità se la linea telefonica è occupata o se non siete raggiungibili.

__________________________________________

BESICHTIGUNG Besichtigung des Auktionsgutes in unseren Geschäftsräumen, Gutenbergstr. 23, 49076 Osnabrück, ab dem 12.02.2007, nach vorheriger telefonischer Vereinbarung unter +49 (0) 5 41 96 20 221.

EXPOSITION Les monnaies seront visibles à partir du 12 Février 2007, Gutenbergstr. 23, 49076 Osnabrück, sur rendez-vous téléphonique +49 (0)541 96 20 221.

12

ON VIEW The auction good can be viewed at our office from February, 12th 2007, Gutenbergstr. 23, 49076 Osnabrück, by prior appointment. Please call +49 (0)541 96 20 221.

ESPOSIZIONE Tutti i lotti sono visionabili a partire dal 12 Febbraio 2007 presso la nostra sede, Gutenbergstr. 23, 49076 Osnabrück previo appuntamento telefonico +49 (0)541 96 20 221.


6*' /+&&.' #)'5 6JG /KFFNG #IGU CTG QH ITGCV JKUVQTKECN UKIPKHKECPEG HKTUVN[ 'WTQRGʼn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ʼnV TGCNN[ EQPUVKVWVG PGY KUUWGU +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ C YGUVYCTF OKITCVKQP GPUWGF ECWUGF D[ COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU VJG CFXCPE KPI *WPU (TQO VJG VTKDGU VJCV WR VQ VJGP JCF TQCOGF VJG NCPFU KP FKUCTTC[ KPFGRGPFGPV PC VKQPU GOGTIGF YKVJ VJGKT QYP TWNGU CPF NCYU (KTUV VJG 8KUKIQVJU CTQWPF NCVGT VJG (TCPMU CPF HKPCNN[ VJG .QODCTFU CTQWPF EQCNGUEGF KPVQ CWVQPQOQWU RGQRNGU +P VJGUG FC[U KV YCU EQOOQPN[ JGNF DGNKGH VJCV C RGQRNG EQWNF DG DTQWIJV VQIGVJGT QPN[ WPFGT C UKPING NGCFGT CPF MKPIU CRRGCTGF CNN QXGT 'WTQRG CHVGTYCTFU CNUQ FWMGU CPF EQWPVU YQWNF HWNHKN VJKU TQNG # MKPI V[RKECNN[ YQWNF JCXG VYQ RWTRQUGU VQ GZRCPF JKU VGTTKVQT[ CPF VQ FGHGPF KV CICKPUV CU UCWNVGTU CPF JKU RQUUKDKNKVKGU QH FQKPI UQ YQWNF DG VYQHQNF 'SWKRRKPI CTOGF HQTEGU KPKVKCNN[ VJGUG YQWNF DG TGETWKVGF HTQO QYP TCPMU VJGP EJKGHN[ HTQO HQTGKIP RGQRNGU OGTEGPCT[ CTOKGU CHVGT YJKEJ C U[UVGO QH OKNKVCT[ UGTXKEG YCU GO RNQ[GF 6Q MGGR WR C YGNNVTCKPGF CPF CIKNG CTO[ VJG (TCPMU JCF CNTGCF[ VWTPGF VQ C HGWFCN U[UVGO DWV PQV WPVKN VJG FC[U QH %JCTNGOCIPG YQWNF HGWFCNKUO TKUG VQ KVU HWNN JGKIJV # XCUUCN YCU QDNKIGF VQ RGTHQTO MPKIJVʼnU UGTXKEG DWV CU VJG DCNCPEGU QH RQYGT YGTG EQPUVCPVN[ UJKHV KPI JG EQWNFPʼn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Ò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ʼnV TGVWTP CNKXG HTQO VJG DCVVNGHKGNF VJG 8CPFCNU CRRGCT VQ JCXG GOGTIGF XKEVQTKQWU VJG[ UGVVNGF CTQWPF .CMG $CNCVQP KP VJG 2CPPQPKCP RNCKP 6JG[ YQWNF TGOCKP VJGTG WPVKN VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ +P QT 8CPFCN -KPI )QFKIKUGN DGIQV C UQP )GKUGTKE YKVJ C PQP )GTOCPKE EQPEWDKPG #V VJG GPF QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG )QVJU QH -KPI 'TOCPTKE YGTG EQPSWGTGF D[ VJG *WPU VJKU FKTGEVN[ TGUWNVGF KP C OCUUKXG TKUKPI CPF YGUVYCTF OQXGOGPV QH CNN VTKDGU 6JG 8CPFCNU OK ITCVGF CNQPI VJG &CPWDG QPN[ VQ GPEQWPVGT CP CTO[ QH 4QOCPU CPF (TCPMU QP VJG DCPMU QH VJG 4JKPG +P VJG HKTUV DCVVNG -KPI )QFKIKUGN YCU MKNNGF DWV VJG UGEQPF DCVVNG QRGPGF C RCU UCIG CETQUU VJG 4JKPG VQ 8CPFCN -KPI )WPFGTKE #HVGT VJCV VJG YC[ VQ 5QWVJGTP )CWN CPF VQ 6QWNQWUG NC[ RCXGF UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT 8CPFCNU )QVJU $GHQTG VJG %QOOQP 'TC C RGQRNG D[ VJG PCOG QH )WVQPGU QT )QVJQPGU NKXGF CNQPI VJG NQYGT EQWTUG QH VJG 8KUVWNC +P VJG PF CPF TF EGPVWT[ #& VJG[ OKITCVGF XKC /CUQXKC CPF $TGUV VQ 2QPVWU DQTFGTKPI QP VJG $NCEM 5GC VJGKT VTGM RTQDCDN[ C ITCFWCN QPG #V VJG $NCEM 5GC C ITGCV GORKTG YCU HQWPFGF (TQO )QVJKE TCKFU YGTG NCWPEJGF QP VJG 4QOCP 'ORKTG EQPVKPWKPI C HCKTN[ NQPI VKOG CPF EWNOKPCVKPI KP YJGP VJG[ TCKFGF #ICÅU 6JG VWTPKPI RQKPV ECOG YJGP KP VJG )QVJU UWHHGTGF C FGXCUVCVKPI FGHGCV D[ 'ORGTQT #WTGNKCPWU .QUKPI VJKU DCVVNG JCF HCT TGCEJ KPI EQPUGSWGPEGU HQT VJG )QVJU 0QV QPN[ FKF VJG ITGCV )QVJKE TGCNO GPF DWV RCTVKCNN[ VJTQWIJ KPVGTHGTGPEG D[ VJG )GRKFU VJG )QVJKE VTKDG DTQMG KP VYQ KP VJG TGIKQP YGUV QH VJG NQYGT EQWTUGU QH VJG &PLGUVT CPF VJG 2TWVJ VJG XKUKIQVJKE 6GTXKPIK UGVVNGF VJG VGTTKVQT[ GCUV QH VJGUG TKXGTU YCU QEEWRKGF D[ VJG QUVTQIQVJKE )TGWVJWPIK 6JGTG C IKICPVKE TGCNO ITGY WPFGT 'TOCPCTKE UVTGVEJKPI HTQO VJG $NCEM 5GC VQ VJG $CNVKE CPF VJG 7TCN KVU EQTG OCFG WR D[ VJG 7MTCKPG 7PFGT %QPUVCPVKPG + VJG 6GTXKPIK DGECOG HQGFGTCVK 6JGUG YGTG VJG FC[U QH 7NHKNC UVCTVKPI CU DKUJQR CPF QH MKPI #VJCPCTKE 9JGP VJG 6GTXKPIK YGTG EQPHTQPVGF D[ VJG *WPU VJG[ ETQUUGF VJG &CPWDG WPFGT #NCXKX 1P VJ #WIWUV VJG DCVVNG CV #FTKCPQRNG YCU HQWIJV 'ORGTQT 8CNGPU OGGVKPI JKU GPF QP VJG DCVVNGHKGNF +P C HQGFGTCVK VTGCV[ YCU TGCEJGF YKVJ 'ORGTQT 6JGQFQUKWU CPF VJG 6GTXKPIK UGVVNGF KP VJG PQTVJ QH 6JTCEKC +P VJG NCUV FGEGPPKWO QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG[ QPEG CICKP NGHV VJGKT FQOKEKNG VQ HKPCNN[ TGCEJ )CWN KP

6QWNQWUG UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT 8KUKIQVJU 7PVKN VJG PCOG 1UVTQIQVJU 5WPTKUG )QVJU YCU WUGF CHVGT VJCV VJG VGTO )TGWVJWPIK CRRGCTGF 9JGP KP VJG[ YGTG HCEGF D[ VJG *WPU CPF VJGKT MKPI 'TOCPCTKE RGTKUJGF VJG OCLQTKV[ QH VJG )TGWVJWPIK [KGNFGF VQ VJG JQTUGDCEM YCTTKQTU 2TGUWOCDN[ VJG[ VJGP OQXGF VQ VJG NGHV DCPM QH VJG NQYGT EQWTUG &CPWDG #HVGT VJG EQNNCRUG QH VJG *WP 4GCNO

VJG 'CUV )QVJU YGTG KPEQTRQTCVGF KPVQ VJG 4QOCP 'ORKTG CU HQGFGTCVK CPF UGVVNGF KP 2CPPQPKC +P VJG[ OQXGF VQ VJG TGIKQP CTQWPF %QPUVCPVKPQRNG VQ GUVCDNKUJ C HQGFGTCVK TGCNO /GCPYJKNG 6JGQFGTKEJ JCF DGGP DQTP KP CPF WRQP JKU HCVJGTʼnU FGOKUG DGECOG MKPI VQ VJKU HQGFGTCVK TGCNO KP UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT 'CUV )QVJU 14


(TCPMU 6JG VGTO (TCPMU HKTUV GOGTIGF KP VJG FC[U QH )CWNGPWU VJG[ YGTG WUWCNN[ TGHGTTGF VQ CU )GTOCPU QT $CTDCTK 6JG (TCPMU C )GTOCPKE VTKDG NKXGF QP VJG TKIJV DCPM QH VJG 4JKPG FKTGEVN[ CETQUU HTQO :CPVGP 6JGKT FQOKPKQP UVTGVEJGF CNQPI VJG 4JKPG CU HCT CU /CKP\ UQWVJ QH YJKEJ VJG #NCOCPPK NKXGF (TCPM EQNNCDQTCVKQP YKVJ VJG 4QOCPU YCU EQPUKF GTCDN[ NCTIGT C NQV QH VJGO UGTXGF KP VJG 4QOCP CTO[ 6JWU C ITCXGUVQPG YCU FKUEQXGTGF (TCPMG DKP KEJ CNU $ÒTIGT TÌOKUEJGT 5QNFCV KP 9CHHGP (TCPM CO + C EKVK\GP KP CTOU C 4QOCP UQNFKGT 6JG FGHGPUG QH VJGKT DQTFGTU YCU QHVGP FGETGCUGF D[ VJG 4QOCPU CPF QHVGP TGRNCEGF YKVJ VJG GORGTQTʼn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ʼnU JQTFGU CP KORQTVCPV RCTV QH #ÀVKWUʼn 4QOCP CTO[ EQPUKUVGF QH (TCPMU 6JKU YCU VJG CTO[ VJCV QP VJG -CVCNCWPKCP HKGNFU

UKVWCVGF PGCT %J³NQP UWT /CTPG FGHGCVGF #VVKNC CPF KVU XKEVQT[ KOOGPUGN[ TGKPHQTEGF VJG (TCPMKUJ RQUKVKQP KP VJG GORKTG #U UQQP CU %JNQFKQ VJG ITGCV ITCPFHCVJGT QH %NQXKU JCF VCMGP %CODTCK 0QVJKPI KU MPQYP CDQWV JKU UQP /GTQXGEJ GZEGRV HQT JCXKPI IKXGP VJG /GTQXKPIKCPU VJGKT PCOG *KU UQP %JKNFGTKE OCFG JKOUGNH KORQUUKDNG CPF YCU GZRGNNGF D[ JKU RGQRNG JG HNGF VQ 6JWTKPIKC CPF YGFFGF $CUKPC TGNCVGF VQ MKPI $CUKPWU %JKNFGTKE TGVWTPGF CPF C UQP YCU DQTP YJQ YCU PCOGF %NQXKU %JKNFGTKE YCU DWTKGF KP &QQTPKM /KPVKPI (KPFU RTQXG VJCV 4QOCP EQKPU YGTG WUGF D[ XCTKQWU )GTOCPKE VTKDGU HTQO GCTNKGUV )GTOCPKE FC[U QP RTQDCDN[ CU RCTV QH VJG RC[ HQT OKNKVCT[ UGTXKEGU TGPFGTGF VQ VJG 4QOCPU 6CEKVWU VQQ JQNFU HQTVJ CDQWV VJG WUG QH OQPG[ +P h QH JKU )GTOCPKC YG TGCF 1WT KO OGFKCVG DQTFGTKPI PGKIJDQWTU FWG VQ VTCFG TGNCVKQPU FQ CRRTGEKCVG IQNF CPF UKNXGT CPF VJG[ CEMPQYNGFIG UQOG QH QWT HCDTKEU CPF GXGP HCXQWT VJGO COQPI VJG KPJCDKVCPVU QH VJG KPPGT NCPFU VJG CPEKGPV RTCEVKEG QH DCTVGTKPI RGTUKUVU 6JG[ YKNN TGCFKN[ CEEGRV VJG CIGKPI EQKP YKVJ VJG OKNNGF GFIG CPF VJG ECTTKCIG CPF RCKT 6JG[ YKNN TCVJGT ENCOR VQ IQNF CPF UKNXGT PQV QWV QH HCPE[ DWV UQNGN[ DGECWUG C NCTIGT PWODGT QH UKNXGT EQKPU KU OQTG JCDKNG YJGP DCTICKPKPI HQT VTKPMGVU #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ KOKVCVKQPU QH 4QOCP OQPG[ UWFFGPN[ GOGTIGF $CUVKGP

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ʼnV GOGTIG WPVKN VJG VJKTVKGU CU QRRQUGF VQ KP 9KVJ VJG KPXCUKQP QH VJG *WPU VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU VQQM CP GPF $CUVKGP KPHGTU VJCV VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU GOGTIGF QPN[ KP VKOGU QH VTCPSWKNKV[ 6JGKT KUUWCPEG EQWNF VJGTGHQTG YGNN EQJGTG YKVJ VJG HQWPFKPI QH VJG HQGFGTCVK UVCVGU +P %QPUVCPVKPG + JCF C VTGCV[ FTCYP WR HQT VJG HQGFGTCVK CPF UJQTVN[ CHVGT VJCV UKIPGF UWEJ C VTGCV[ YKVJ VJG 8CPFCNU CPF VJG 8KUKIQVJU #RCTV HTQO VJGKT EJTQPQNQIKECN QTFGT VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU OC[ DG ENCUUKHKGF D[ VJGKT OCPWHCEVWTG 6GZV CPF OKPV CTG FKUVKPEVN[ WR VQ QPG HNCY NGIKDNG 6GZV KU UVKNN NGIKDNG DWV UJQYU OQTG HNCYU VJG OKPV PCOG KU DNWPFGTGF 6GZV KU UVKNN NGIKDNG VQ CP GZVGPV VJG OKPV XCPKUJGU 6GZV DGEQOGU C UGTKGU QH NGVVGTU WUWUCNN[ 0 VJCV KU KPVGTTWRVGF QPN[ QPEG QT VYKEG D[ CP QVJGT NGVVGT QHVGP CP 5 6GZV OGTGN[ EQPUKUVU QH C TQY QH FCUJGU CICKP QPEG QT VYKEG KPVGTTWRVGF D[ C NGVVGT

15


9JQ OCPWHCEVWTGF VJGUG EQKPU TGOCKPU WPCPUYGTGF 6JG VYQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CN VCT V[RG CPF &GEGPVKWUʼn EQKPU KP RCTVKEWNCT CTG QH C TGOCTMCDN[ JCPFUQOG FGUKIP 6JKU TCKUGU VJG CUUWORVKQP VJCV FKG EWVVGTU HTQO VJG QHHKEKCN OKPVU YGTG CV YQTM $CUVKGP UWIIGUVU VJCV VJGUG EQWNF JCXG DGGP VJG TGUWNVU QH GZVTCEWTTKEWNCT OCPWHCEVWTGU D[ VJGUG FKG EWVVGTU *QY GXGT RTQDCDNG VJCV OC[ DG VJG V[RG VYQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT KU GURGEKCNN[ UGGP KP 5KUEKC CPF UQ ,CTXKE KP JKU # +8VJ CPF 8VJ EGPVWTKGU JQCTF QH TQOCP EQKPU CPF KOKVCVKQPU KP VJG EQNNGEVKQP QH VJG 0CVKQPCN /WUGWO KP $GNITCFG KP 5KTOKWO 8+++ 'EQNG (TCPECKUG FG 4QOG UWIIGUVU VJCV VJGUG EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM CV UGRCTCVG OKPVU NKMG 0KU CPF 2KPEWO 9JGP VJG VGZVU DGEQOG OQTG CPF OQTG DNWPFGTGF KV UGGOU KORQUUKDNG VQ OG VJCV VJGUG EQKPU EQWNF JCXG DGGP UVTWEM CV VJG QHHKEKCN OKPVU VJG UCOG OC[ DG UGGP KP VJG (TKUKCP KOKVCVKQPU QH VJG &QTGUVCF EQKPU VJG[ VQQ YGTGPʼnV OKPVGF KP &QTGUVCF +P O[ QRKPKQP VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU JCXG VQ DG EQPUKFGTGF OKPVGF KP UOCNN KPFGRGPFGPV OKPVU CPF YJGVJGT VJGUG YGTG QT YGTGPʼnV YKVJKP 4QOCP DQTFGTU KU C OCVVGT QH NGUU UKIPKHKECPEG 5QOGVKOGU VJGUG EQKPU CTG CNUQ WVKNKUGF VQ RTQXG C EGTVCKP )GTOCPKE RGQRNG JCF NKXGF KPUKFG VJG NKOGU 6JWU VJG 4QOCPKCP JKUVQTKCP &KEWNGUEW YTKVGU 'URGEKCNN[ VJG PWOGTQWU VJ EGP VWT[ DTQP\G EQKPU HQWPF VJGTG UWIIGUV CV NGCUV NCTIG RCTVU QH VJG 8CPFCN RGQRNG UGVVNGF JGTG WPVKN CHVGT VJG VWTP QH VJG EGPVWT[ #U VJG HKTUV UGTKGU QH HQWPF EQKPU RTQXGU PQ QNFGT VJCP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF VJG CFFGF EQKPU UJQY C OQUV UVTKEV EJTQPQNQI[ UWFFGPN[ UVCTVKPI YKVJ %QP UVCPVKPG + LWUV CU CDTWRVN[ EWV QHH YKVJ 8CNGPVKPKCP ++ VJKU CORN[ RTQXGU VJG )GTOCPKE RGQRNGU VJCV VJKU EWNVWTCN UWD ITQWR DGNQPIGF VQ UGVVNGF JGTG KP VJG HKTUV JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF NGHV CU UQQP CU VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ *QYGXGT VJG SWGUVKQP TGOCKPU YJQ VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU YGTG KPVGPFGF HQT 6JG CUUWORVKQP VJCV VJG[ YGTG UVTWEM KP VKOGU YJGP EQKPU YGTG UECTEG FQGUPʼnV UGGO CEEWTCVG HQT KPUVCPEG YJ[ YQWNF VJG IQQF FKGEWVVGTU UWFFGPN[ UVCTV OCPWHCEVWTKPI EQTTWRVGF TGRNKECU +P O[ QRKPKQP VJG[ OQUV FGHKPKVGN[ UGTXGF CU OQPG[ HQT VJG )GTOCPKE RGQRNGU VJCV JGNF HQGFGTCVK UVCVWU YKVJKP VJG 4QOCP 'ORKTG 9KVJ TGICTF VQ QVJGT HKPFU LGYGNT[ GVE VJGUG RGQRNGU UJQYGF FGXGNQRGF ETCHVUOCPUJKR YJKEJ YQWNF JCXG CNUQ CNNQYGF VJGO VQ EWV VJGKT QYP EQKP /C[DG VJG HQNNQYKPI FGXGNQROGPV ECP DG QDUGTXGF YKVJ VJG )GTOCPKE RGQRNGU 6JG[ WUGF QTKIKPCN 4QOCP EQKPU (QT VJGKT RTKXCVG WUG EQKPU CRRGCTGF VJCV FGTKXGF HTQO 4QOCP EQKPU DWV YGTG EQTTWRVGF (TQO CDQWV VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG[ KUUWGF QYP EQKPU DWV CXQKFGF KPENWFKPI VJGKT QYP MKPIʼnU PCOG QPN[ 6JGQFGTKE JCF EQKPU UJQY JKU OQPQITCO %QKPU YGTG UVTWEM YKVJ VJG PCOG QH C 4QOCP GORGTQT PQV PGEGUUCTKN[ VJG QPG TGKIPKPI VJG 1UVTQIQVJKE -KPI $CFWKNC UVTWEM EQKP DGCTKPI VJG PCOG QH 'ORGTQT #PCUVCUKWU 5QNG RWT RQUG YCU TCVJGT VQ JCXG CP[ KORGTKCN PCOG VQ KORN[ KORGTKCN CWVJQTKV[ GXGP KH VJGTG TGCNN[ YCU PQPG UWEJ VJCV CRRNKGF VJCP VQ JCXG VJG PCOG QH VJG TWNKPI 'ORGTQT %QKPU UJQY VJG QYP MKPIʼnU PCOG 5GGP YKVJ VJG 8CPFCNU UVCTVKPI )WPVJCOWPF YKVJ VJG 1UVTQIQVJU UVCTVKPI #VJCNCTKE YKVJ VJG 8KUKIQVJU UVCTVKPI .KWXKIKNF 6JKU ECVCNQIWG CFJGTGU VQ $CUVKGPʼnU ENCUUKHKECVKQP HQT ITQWR KV KU RTGEGFGF D[ HQWT EQKPU VJCV FQPʼnV HKV VJKU ENCUUKHKECVKQP CPF EQPENWFGU YKVJ C PWODGT QH EQKPU VJCV CTG ENGCTN[ KOKVCVKQPU UVTWEM CHVGT VJG EQPHTQPVCVKQP YKVJ VJG *WPU 2QUUKDNG CVVTKDWVKQP KU KPFKECVGF HQT GCEJ KPFKXKF WCN ITQWR $CUVKGP OCKPN[ EQPEGPVTCVGU QP VJG 9GUV CPF VJG HKPFU VJGTG JGPEG VJG V[RG VYQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT KU TCTGN[ OGPVKQPGF 6JGTG CTG JQYGXGT PWOGTQWU JQCTFU HTQO VJG 'CUV HQT YJKEJ VJG SWGUVKQP HQT YJQ YGTG VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU KPVGPFGF CRRNKGU

16


)TQWR 0QP ENCUUKHKCDNG WPFGT $CUVKGP ,WRKVGT GCING

1

1 2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T +/2%8#..+0+8%+0+852(#8) 4 ,WRKVGT UVCPFKPI YKVJ GCING 8KEVQT[ KP TKIJV JCPF CPF 5 KP VJG HKGNF +18+%%05'48#214+#8) KP GZGTIWG 5/-. IT. #VVTCEVKXG URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV %[\KEXU +P VJG PCOG QH .KEKPKWU + $GECWUG CU YGNN VJG HCVJGT CU VJG UQP .KEKPKWU CTG OGPVKQPGF KP VJG VGZV VJKU EQKP JCU VQ DG UVTWEM KP VJG RGTKQF +V UGGOU RGEWNKCT VJCV VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG UJQWNF GPF #8) PQTOCN VGZV +18+ %105'48#614+

*GNGPC (CWUVC

2 2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T *GNGPC (.0'.'0# *8)856* 4 'ORTGUU UVCPFKPI YKVJ VYQ EJKNFTGPU CU (CWUVC 5#685 4'+ 27$#+% KP GZGTIWG 564 ETGUEGPV. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC IQQF XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP /KPV 6TKGT 4+% QP R VJG HQQVPQVG OGPVKQPU 6JGTG KU C MPQYP DCTDCTKE NQQMKPI *GNGPC EQKP YKVJ 52'5 QP VJG TGXGTUG

56=4?7 +V UJQYU C EQWTUG UETKRV 6.*'.'0# *8)856++

5VCT

3 2:1

2:1

# $WUV T (80u 6+#0# 4 5VCT KP YTGCVJ. IT. 4 )TGGP RCVKPC OKPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ %QR[ QH VJG (CWUVC EQKP HTQO 6JGUUCNQPKEC EH .4$%

17


*CPPKDCNNKCPWU *CPPKDCNNKCPWU YCU C DTQVJGT QH &GNOCVKWU CPF C ITCPFUQP QH %QPUVCPVKPG + CPF 6JGQFQTC *G JCF VJG VKVNG 4': 4')7/ '6 2106+%#47/ )'06+7/ 4GKIP

4 2:1

2:1

# $WUV T (. *#00+$#..+#0Q 4')+ 4 5KVVKPI 'WRJTCVGU 5'%84+6#5 28$.+%# KP DQVVQO HKGNF %105. IT. 44 )TGGP DTQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN 6JG UKVVKPI GWRJTCVGU KU FKHHKEWNV VQ FKUEGTP

)TQWR %QORTKUGU VJG RGTKQF VQ FWTKPI VJG TGKIP QH %QPUVCPVKPG + 'URGEKCNN[ KP VJG V[RGU VYQ ECRVKXGU CTQWPF NCDCTWO CPF VYQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT 5KUEKC KU V[RKECNN[ PCOGF CU VJG OKPV +V VJGTGHQTG UGGOU RTQDCDNG VJCV VJKU HKTUV ITQWR YCU KPVGPFGF HQT VJG RGQRNG NKXKPI KP 2CPPQPKC 5KUEKC NKGU QP VJG QWVUMKTVU QH 2CPPQPKC +V KU EGTVCKP VJCV 8CPFCNU UGVVNGF KP 2CPPQPKC UVCTVKPI VJKU FCVG YCU CHVGT %QPUVCPVKPGʼnU HQGFGTCVK NCY %CORICVG 4GKIP

5

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T %10+u0+ +05001 4 %CORICVG YKVJ UVCT DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 6*000&& +*00u 3*00. IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG $GTPCTFK 6TKGUV 6JG VGZV TWPU CNN VJG YC[ CTQWPF CNNQYKPI PQ OKPV KPFKECVKQP

7

6

2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV N YKVJ NCPEG :::::::::::: 5+1 :::::: 5 4 %CORICVG YKVJ VJTGG VQYGTU :::::::: :::::::: KP GZGTIWG /5/. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

6YQ ECRVKXGU CTQWPF NCDCTWO

6JG QDXGTUG UJQYU C DWUV HCEKPI NGHV VJG TGXGTUG VYQ ECRVKXGU UKVVKPI CV VJG HQQV QH C NCDCTWO +P VJG NCDCTWO 66 :: 6JG PQTOCN VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG YQWNF DG 8+4685 ':'4%+6 2GTKQF 6JG QTKIKPCN V[RG YCU CP GZCORNG HQT VJG QNFGUV UEGCVVC 4KIQNF 5 ' 6JG VYQ RTKOCT[ UGTKGU QH UEGCVVCU KP $0, UGTKGU # GV UGSS EH GURGEKCNN[ 2 D PT

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV &0+5'++e * 2+(++ TGVTQITCFG 4 6YQ ECRVKXGU CTQWPF NCDCTWO KP HKGNF 5 KP NCDCTWO 66 :: ('6'5 +6+++ KP GZGTIWG 5+5. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC OKPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RQTVTCKV *KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV 5KUEKC

18


8

# &KCFGOGF DWUV N YKVJ UJKGNF CPF URGCT 05:Q 4 6YQ ECRVKXGU CTQWPF NCDCTWO KP HKGNF 5 ( KP NCDCTWO 66 : .*.6#5 %86' KP GZGTIWG 5+5. IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG $GTPCTFK 6TKGUV /KPV 5KUEKC

8QVC

6JG HKTUV EQKP UVKNN UJQYU VJG PQTOCN RQTVTCKV QH %QPUVCPVKPG + DQVJ VJG QVJGTU C DCTDCTKE XGTUKQP 6JG PQTOCN VGZVU QP VJG TGXGTUG CTG FGRGPFGPV QP 816 :: &0 %1056#06+0+ /#: #8) CPF TGURGEVKXGN[ 816 : %#'5#48/ 01564148/ 2GTKQF

9 2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T %10u0 60u00% 4 86 :: KP YTGCVJ +01+010+ 000100 KP DQVVQO HKGNF 6u6. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$GTPCTFK 6TKGUV

10 2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T %1:56#06 ++++5+++% 4 ++ Q 6 :: KP YTGCVJ %++++:56++++:56++++++65 ++++++% KP GZGTIWG 5+5. IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP GZRTGUUKXG UV[NG XGT[ HKPG 5-# <Ã’TKEJ /KPV 5KUEKC

11 2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T *++++6++++ -+++++5++ 4 + + 1 6 : KP YTGCVJ ++++++5+++++++6++++++6++++++ KP DQVVQO HKGNF 56. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC KP RNCEGU YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG CVVTCEVKXG URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP 'Z *KTUEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JG RQTVTCKV EQORCTGU KP UQOG FGVCKNU VQ VJCV QH PQ

19


6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT

1P VJG QDXGTUG C JGNOGVGF OKNKVCT[ JGCF WUWCNN[ HCEKPI TKIJV 6JKU KU QPN[ UGGP WPFGT %QPUVCPVKPG + 1P VJG TGXGTUG VYQ 8KEVQTKGU DGVYGGP VJGO CP CNVCT DGCTKPI C UJKGNF 6JG KPUETKRVKQPU QP VJG UJKGNF CTG WUWCNN[ WPENGCT QT KNNGIKDNG CNVQIGVJGT 6JTGG ITQWRU OC[ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF C VJG PCOG QH VJG OKPV 5+5 KU ENGCTN[ NGIKDNG PQU CPF D VJG CNVCT QP VJG TGXGTUG DGCTU C UJKGNF KPUETKDGF YKVJ OCKPN[ WPENGCT UETKRV E VJG UJKGNF QP VJG CNVCT KU OKUUKPI 2TGUGPV CTG VJG NGVVGTU CV VJG UCOG RQUKVKQP 6JG QTKIKPCNU UJQY VJG VGZV 8+%6 .#'6#' 24+0% 2'42 RGTKQF +H VJG OKNKVCT[ DWUVU KP VJG QTKIKPCN GFKVKQPU FKURNC[ NKOKVGF XCTKCVKQP C OWNVKVWFG QH FKHHGTGPV FGUKIPU ECP DG HQWPF JGTG KP VJG KOKVCVKQPU

12

13

2:1

2:1

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV URGCT CPF UJKGNF QP VJG JGNOGV %15++6+++++0++ 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ CNVCT PQ UJKGNF NGVVGTU QQ RR DGVYGGP VJGO +10+++Å‘ %21++'%+++ KP GZGTIWG 5+u. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $GTPCTFK 6TKGUV +P XKGY QH VJG NGPIVJ VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG OKIJV DG %QPUVCPVKPG +

# $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +/2%1++56#06+0+5 2(#8% 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT NGIGPF QP UJKGNF PQV XKUKDNG +++1+++(+++'6#++0+0Å‘08 KP GZGTIWG u+u. IT. .KIJV ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ

14

15

2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +++151 ++50%0++%1 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT +1+ ++ QP UJKGNF 8+%610+0 . IT. $TQCF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T YKVJ JGNOGV 00000+ +0000 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT ##88 QP UJKGNF 00 0 000 KP GZGTIWG 00. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC UOCNN HNCP FGHGEV QP VJG TGXGTUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

16

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV URGCT CPF UJKGNF 01&u0%0&&/*0 6* 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT +++ %#% QP UJKGNF 0 +6+++++ ++++1++++ KP GZGTIWG u0+. IT. 0KEG FCTM ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

20


17

18

2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T YKVJ JGNOGV &++*0&+++0000++00+ 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT 81 CPF VYQ EWDGU QP UJKGNF &&000 00# #00%%. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T YKVJ JGNOGV ++++u10++6++++++++6++++Å‘ 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT ++ QP UJKGNF Å‘+++++++++6++++++++). IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP %QNQIPG

19

20

2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV T &++:1Λ#8*:5#5%+#508#% 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU Z Z QXGT CNVCT 15 1#00++1 KP GZGTIWG #. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC GZRTGUUKXG UV[NG OCIPKHKEGPV EGPVTGF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP

# $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV * * * + * * * * 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF CPF CNVCT + +1 1+ QXGT CN VCT +Å‘+*1+ KP GZGTIWG ++. IT. 5JKPKPI ITGGP RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

,CESWKGT -GJN (TQO NKUV PQ

22

21

2:1

# $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++++++++ 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ CNVCT Å‘++ ++ ++ ++ ++. . &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QP VJG QDXGTUG CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP .CP\ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM CTQWPF

2:1

# $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ CNVCT ++ ++ ++ 8 Å‘. IT. 5JKPKPI ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

21


23

2:1

2:1

# $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV ++ + + ő ++ + + +++1 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ CNVCT TGEVCPING +++1 CDQXG CNVCT

XGTVKECN ¤ ++ ¤ ¤ Q. IT. 5JKPKPI ITGGP RCVKPC GFIG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

.CP\ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

)TQWR 6JG NCUV [GCTU QH VJG IQXGTPOGPV QH %QPUVCPVKPG + VJTQWIJ VQ 9G PQY OQTG CPF OQTG QDUGTXG VJG OKPV .WIFWPWO UQ VJCV VJG TGIKQP CNQPI VJG 4JKPG UJQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF CU VJG CTGC QH EKTEWNCVKQP G I VJG (TCPMU 6JKU IQGU KP RCTVKEWNCT HQT VJG PWODGTU CPF VJCV RQUUKDN[ EKTEWNCVGF KP 'PINCPF VJG NCVVGT PQ KU C FKTGEV RTQVQV[RG HQT C UEGCV %QPUVCPVKPQRQNKU 6JG QDXGTUG UJQYU VJG KOCIG QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG YKVJ C JGNOGV CPF ETQUU DGJKPF KV 1P VJG TG XGTUG C 8KEVQT[ UJKGNF KP JCPF KPENKPGF VQ VJG NGHV 6JG RTQY KU WUWCNN[ WPTGEQIPKUCDNG #NN EQKPU CTG QH C UOCNN HQTOCV 2GTKQF !

24

2:1

25

2:1

2:1

2:1

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV %1056#0 6+0121.+5 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ UJKGNF CPF URGCT KP GZGTIWG

2 .). IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN /KPV .WIFWPWO

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ UJKGNF CPF URGCT KP GZGTIWG 2. ) . IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN /KPV .WIFWPWO

27

26

2:1

2:1

2:1

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV %1056#0 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ UJKGNF CPF URGCT DQVVQO HKGNF PQV XKUKDNG. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC GFIG UNKIJVGN[ EJKRRGF QP VJG QDXGTUG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

2:1

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV CPF ETQUU DCTDCTK\GF NGIGPF 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ UJKGNF CPF URGCT DQVVQO HKGNF PQV XKUKDNG. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

22


7TDU 4QOC

1P VJG QDXGTUG VJG RGTUQPKHKECVKQP QH VJG 7TDU 4QOC 1P VJG TGXGTUG VJG WUWCN KOCIG QH VJG UJG YQNH CPF VJG VYKPU 4QOWNWU CPF 4GOWU 6JG YGKIJV CPF HQTOCV UWDUVCPVKCNN[ FGETGCUKPI 6JG UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU OQVKH KU CNUQ UGGP QP VJG UEGCVVCU

28 2:1

2:1

# 7TDU 4QOC N 5+++55 +5+6+ 4 6YQ UVCTU QXGT UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU KP GZGTIWG 65+5 . IT. 9QTP QWV QDXGTUG FKG XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

30

29

2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

# 7TDU 4QOC N +42+. 4 6YQ UVCTU QXGT UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU KP GZGTIWG %0++5. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

.CP\ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 4 )ÌDN #PVKMG 0WOKUOCVKM RN QH VJG UCOG FKG! )ÌDN TGHGTU VQ %CV %CJP PQ

# 7TDU 4QOC N 74$u 4 6YQ UVCTU QXGT UJG YQNH KP GZGTIWG 2.%. IT.

8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV .WIFWPWO

32

31

2:1

2:1

2:1 2:1

'ORGTQT ETQYPGF D[ 8KEVQT[

# $CTDCTK\GF JGCF T 85 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ URGCT ETQYPGF D[ 8KEVQTKC *++5 . IT. &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

&QODTQYUMK /ÒPUVGT

%QPUVCPVKPQRQNKU ! GPVJTQPGF

# *GCF N ő++ 4 %QPUVCPVKPQRQNKU ! GPVJTQPGF YKVJ URGCT QT UEGRVTG CPF XKEVQT[ QP INQDG ! ő++. IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z /ÒP\\GPVTWO ņ -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

23


6YQ OGP YKVJ UVCPFCTF U

34

33

2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T %1056#06+075 +80 0% 4 6YQ OGP YKVJ VYQ UVCPFCTFU %.14 +#':'4ő. IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 0QTOCN VGZV TGXGTUG ).14+# ':'4%+685

# &KCFGOGF DWUV N %1ő 4 6YQ OGP YKVJ QPG UVCPFCTF KP GZGTIWG 264. IT. 5JCTR CPF ENGCT UVTWEM URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ /KPV 6TKGT 5OCNN HQTOCV 6[RKECN 4QOCP TGXGTUG

36 2:1

2:1

35

2:1

2:1

# .CWTGCVGF DWUV N 0+'* 6# +++ 4 6YQ OGP YKVJ QPG UVCPFCTF. IT.

8GT[ HKPG

# $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV %15ő 4 6YQ OGP YKVJ QPG UVCPFCTF YTGCVJ QP VQR. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JG TGXGTUG KU PQV C V[RKECN 4QOCP TGXGTUG 2TQVQV[RG HQT C UEGCV V[RG EH VJG UOCNN RKEVWTG 6JG OKPV KP .QPFQP YCU KPQRGTCVKXG KP JGPEG EQPVKPGPVCN EQKPU YGTG EKTEWNCVKPI KP $TKVCKP KPENWFKPI KOKVCVKQPU

5KNKSWC

37

2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T 8++ %10u60060u+(#8+ 4 9TGCVJ #16+u ::: /8.6+u :::: KP HQWT NKPGU )** KP GZGTIWG. IT. $TQCF HNCP EGPVTGF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG VGZV IKXGU TGCUQP VQ EQPUKFGT %QPUVCPVKPG DWV VJG RQTVTCKV OQTG TGUGODNGU %QPUVCPVKWU 2GTJCRU %QPUVCPVKPG ++

24


2JQGPKZ

38 2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0%1056# 052(#8% 4 2JQGPKZ QP HWPGTCN RKNG ('. 6++2 4+2#4# 6+1 KP DQVVQO HKGNF 5+5 ! . IT. )TGGP RCVKPC IQQF XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV 5KUEKC ! %QPUVCPU

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

39

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T 10 11% 0 56#0 +85 2(ő 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP +++111 006. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG )QTP[ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG EQPSWGTGF KU NQQMKPI XGT[ UWTRTKUGF CPF VJG JCKT KU UVCPFKPI QP GPF

40

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %1056#0ő 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP ('. 6'/2 4'2#4#6. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCD #WEVKQP PQ 6JG EQPSWGTGF KU YGCTKPI C RJT[IKCP ECR

25


41

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T # KP HKGNF &0%1056#0 6+852(#8% 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP 2*$*6+1 KP GZGTIWG 6' . IT. )TGGP RCVKPC GZRTGUUKXG UV[NG XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP 6JG EQPSWGTGF KU YGCTKPI C RJT[IKCP ECR

42

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %10260 6+85 +8 #8) 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP UVCT KP HKGNF +(6%/2 8061 KP GZGTIWG 5/0#. IT. )TGGP DTQYP RCVKPC YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

43

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0%0Å‘ 6+852(#8) 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP ('.6'02(+ 2+#6+1 KP GZGTIWG 500 . IT. &CTM RCVKPC IQQF XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

44

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 &u 6 1+'& 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP 3'8 T WRYCTFU 1+.+'& 3'*+1. IT. /CIPKHKEGPV ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG .CP\ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

26


(TQO JGTG VJG HQTOCV CPF YGKIJV KU UOCNN YKVJ GZEGRVKQP QH VJG PQU CPF VJCV GZJKDKV VJG WUWCN YGKIJV QH VJG NCTIGT HQTOCVU 6JKU ITQWR EQPEWTU YKVJ V[RG E

45

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T %+++++%+5++ #6u #+++++ 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP * KP HKGNF ('. 6*%+ *&#6+1 KP GZGTIWG Ő %+5+ Ő. IT. 5JKPKPI ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU RKGEG QTKIKPCVGU HTQO VJG 0QTVJGTP $CNMCP

46

47

2:1

2:1

# $WUV T * KP HKGNF 0++0++0+01+0 0+100 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP +000+0+0+ő KP GZGTIWG +0ő. IT. &CTM RCVKPC OKPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP + PQ

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 -1056 6+81 ;ő 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP +1+#Θu +01 6+1 KP GZGTIWG #06 $. IT. 8GT[ HKPG

&QODTQYUMK /ÒPUVGT %QKP CRRGCTGF KP C JQCTF KP 5[TKC 6JG - QP VJG QDXGTUG UWIIGUVU VJG GCUVGTP RCTV QH VJG /GFKVGTTCPGCP 6JG OKPV OKIJV DG #PVKQEJKC

48

2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T ő8+ ++ 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP ő++++++. IT. 5JCTR CPF ENGCT URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG ,CESWKGT -GJN (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG UQNFKGT KU YGCTKPI C RJT[IKCP ECR 6JG RQTVTCKV KU PQV %QPUVCPVKWUʼn RGTJCRU KV KU VJCV QH /CIPGPVKWU

49

49

# $WUV T # KP HKGNF ő06+85 4 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP ('.6 #4. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JG RQTVTCKV EQWNF DG /CIPGPVKWU

27


'ORGTQT DGVYGGP VYQ NCDCTC

50

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T YKVJ # CPF UVCT KP HKGNF &++%1+'%+1 &+8++01) 4 (KIWTG UVCPFKPI N DGVYGGP VYQ NCDCTC UVCT CDQXG # N ++1++188 +6++ &8 KP GZGTIWG # # . IT. &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC DTQCF CPF EGPVTGF URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP 1EVQDGT PQ # XGT[ EJCTCEVGTKUVKE RQTVTCKV # UKOKNCT URGEKOGP KU HQWPF KP )ÌDN RN PQ VJGTG KU C TGHGTGPEG VQ %CV -TGUU PQ

51

# $WUV T YKVJ ++ KP HKGNF &0 %1060805*6*1++ 4 'ORGTQT UVCPFKPI N YKVJ VYQ NCDCTC KP VJG NCDCTC ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &*** *1** KP GZGTIWG 5*5+. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,CPWCT[ PQ 2GTJCRU VJKU EQKP YCU KUUWGF WPFGT VJG PCOG QH %QPUVCPVKPG ++

'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ 1P VJG QDXGTUG KPXCTKCDN[ VJG PQTOCN RQTVTCKV QH VJG 4QOCP GORGTQT QP VJG TGXGTUG C UVCPFKPI GORGTQT OCPVNGF QP C ICNNG[ WUWCNN[ JQNFKPI C DKTF KP VJG TKIJV JCPF CPF C NC DCTWO KP VJG NGHV WUKPI C UKORNG ETQUU PQ EJTKUVQITCO KP VJG RQUVGTKQT QH VJG ICNNG[ C TQY KPI RGTUQP VJG QCT KP C XCTKGV[ QH UJCRGU 6GZV TGXGTUG ('. 6'/2 4'2#4#6+1 #HVGT VJG V[RGU VYQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP CNVCT CPF 'ORGTQT YKVJ HCNNKPI JQTUGOCP VJKU KU VJG OQUV QEEWTKPI V[RG 9KVJQWV GZEGRVKQP VJG KOCIG KU QH %QPUVCPVKWU ++ CRCTV HTQO VJG PWODGTU CPF VJCV CTG WPFGT VJG PCOG QH %QPUVCPU

52

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %106#* 0u ++#8% 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ +++6'/2 21*#86+1. IT. &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

28


53

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %1056 05ő#8% 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ YKVJ 8KEVQT[ QP JCPF ő'/& 4'&#ő. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC UOCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

-ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCD #WEVKQP PQ

54

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %1056#0 6++852(#8) 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ ('. 6'/2 4'2#4#6+1 KP GZGTIWG 6.). IT. $TQYP RCVKPC UOCNN OKUVCMG KP VJG FKG CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 4CWEJ ņ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ *GTG VJG QCT KU C UKORNG UVKEM

55

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0%10u6#0 6+852(#8% 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ ő6'/24 ++++4++#6+1 KP DQVVQO HKGNF 2.%. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ *GTG VJG QCT KU C UVKEM YKVJ C DNCFG

56

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 6+852(#8) 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ ő5+5&*4++6+1 KP GZGTIWG %. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCD #WEVKQP PQ *GTG VJG QCT KU C UVKEM YKVJ C DNCFG

29


57

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 %1056#0 6+85 2( #8 4 'ORGTQT KP ICNNG[ ('. 6'/2 4'2#4#6+1 KP GZGTIWG 5.%. IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

)TQWR 6JG CIG QH /CIPGPVKWU CPF &GEGPVKWU 6JG (TCPM VGTTKVQTKGU JCXG VQ DG EQPUKFGTGF HQT VJG CTGC QH EKTEWNCVKQP CU VJG (TCPMU CNTGCF[ JGNF VJG VGTTKVQT[ VQ VJG PQTVJ QH#OKGPU CV VJCV VKOG 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP RKNNCT 4GXGTUG VYQ 8KEVQTKGU JQNFKPI QPG UJKGNF VJCV TGUVU QP C RKNNCT

58

# $WUV T YKVJ # KP HKGNF &0 /#)0'0 6+85 2( #8) 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP RKNNCT QP VJG UJKGNF +1 8 08+6 KP GZGTIWG #ő. IT. 8GT[ HKPG

59

# $WUV T ő85%*'5 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP RKNNCT 5 8 DGPGCVJ VJG RKNNCT QP UJKGNF 816 X +++.6 Z KP GZGTIWG 65+ ! . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

+P XKGY QH VJG QDXGTUG VGZV VJCV GPFU YKVJ %#'5 VJKU EQKP JCU VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ &GEGPVKWU CNVJQWIJ VJG JGCF OQTG TGUGODNGU /CIPGPVKWUʼn

60

# $WUV T &0 &'%'06+85 01$ %*'% 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP RKNNCT 5 8 DGPGCVJ VJG RKNNCT QP UJKGNF 816 8 /8.6 Z 8+%614+++' &&00 *8%'6%*' KP GZGTIWG */$. IT. )TGGP DTQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV #OKGPU 6JG OKPV QH #OKGPU YCU C ETGCVKQP QH /CIPGPVKWU 6JG DGIKPPKPI ECP DG FCVGF KP VJG UGEQPF JCNH QH KP VJG UWOOGT QH VJG OKPV YCU ENQUGF

30


61

# $WUV T &0&'%'06+85 01$ %*'5 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF QP RKNNCT 5 8 DGPGCVJ VJG RKN NCT QP UJKGNF 816 X /8.6 Z 8+%610+#' &&00 88%'6++' KP GZGTIWG ++5.). IT. $TQYP RCVKPC YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN /KPV .WIFWPWO 0QTOCNN[ VJKU UJQWNF TGCF 42.) CUUWOKPI .WIFWPWO KU OGCPV JGTG VQQ 6JG KPUETKRVKQP QP VJG UJKGNF KU XGT[ WP ENGCT

6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF

+P RTKPEKRNG VJKU V[RG OCVEJGU VJG NCUV QPG YKVJ VJG QPN[ FKHHGTGPEG VJCV VJG UJKGNF FQGU PQV TGUV QP C RKNNCT JGTG 6JG PQTOCN VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG KU 8+%614+#' && 00 #8) '6 %#'

62

63

# $WUV T YKVJ # KP HKGNF ő06+85 2( 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF 816 8.6 Z QP UJKGNF ő#8) '6 %#'. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC UOCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

/#)0' 06+85!

# $WUV T YKVJ * KP HKGNF /*)0ő 4 6YQ 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ UJKGNF 816 X /8. Z QP UJKGNF ő&0+008%6+%*+. IT. 5JKPKPI ITGGP RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG ,CESWKGT -GJN (TQO NKUV PQ /*)0 '06+85 !

%JTKUVQITCO

0QTOCN VGZV TGXGTUG 5#.85 && 00 #8) '6 %#'5

64

# $WUV T &0/#ő +852(#8% 4 %JTKUVQITCO N QOGIC CPF T CNRJC 50.012800/ő KP DQV VQO HKGNF ++2.%. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

31


)TQWR 6JG CIG QH ,WNKCPWU YKVJ VJG $WNN V[RG 6JG OKPVU VJCV CRRGCT CTG UKVWCVGF KP VJG 'CUV RGTJCRU KP VJG &CPWDG TGIKQP $WNN

65

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 8.%. +8.+ #085 2( #8) 4 $WNN CDQXG VYQ UVCTU CPF GCING YKVJ YTGCVJ DGHQTG 5'%84+%6#5 4'+28$ KP GZGTIWG # 38+.2. IT. (KPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JG DWUV KU PQV VJG WUWCN ,WNKCPWU DWV OQTG VJCV QH %QPUVCPVKWU /KPV #SWKNGKC 6JG GCING DGHQTG VJG DWNN PQTOCNN[ QPN[ QEEWTU KP #TNGUʼn EQKPCIG

66

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0(.%.+8 852(#88% 4 $WNN VYQ UVCTU CDQXG Å‘84+6#5 28 KP DQV VQO HKGNF 6%10. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN

67

# $GCTFGF CPF FKCFGOGF DWUV T &0 (. %.+8.+ #085 2( #8) 4 $WNN VYQ UVCTU CDQXG 5'%84+6#5 4'+284 KP GZGTIWG #06Γ DTCPEJ. IT. &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG /KPV #PVKQEJ

32


)TQWR (TQO VJG RGTKQF CHVGT VJQWIJ YKVJ VJG PQTOCN YGKIJV 'ORGTQT YKVJ UVCPFCTF

68

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 8#.'06+0+ő8% 4 'ORGTQT UVCPFKPI T YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF 8KEVQT[ 4'56+68614 4'+2ő KP GZGTIWG 5/*%5. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP (TQO NKUV PQ 8CNGPVKPKCPWU ++

)QFFGUU 0QTOCN VGZV TGXGTUG 4'2#4#6+1 4'+28$

69

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T 0# 08522++++ő 4 'ORGTQT UVCPFKPI N YKVJ MPGGNKPI IQFFGUU ő4'2*4#6+1ő. IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 8CNGPVKPKCPWU ++

)TQWR C #TQWPF VJKU VKOG VJG V[RGU YGTG TGFWEGF VQ C UOCNNGT HQTOCV CPF YGKIJV 8KEVQTKGU YKVJ ECRVKXG 2GTKQF 8CNGPVKPKCP ++ 6JGQFQUKWU + #TECFKWU

71

70

2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T 5+++++++++++++#+++5+++6 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ ECRVKXG CPF RJT[IKCP ECR KP HKGNF 5+++u +++ ++$++%.+ KP GZGTIWG ++++. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T ő+++5+++6+ 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ ECRVKXG CPF RJT[IKCP ECR KP HKGNF ő+++5&66++ő KP GZGTIWG 55ő. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC GZRTGUUKXG UV[NG CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

0/$ #OUVGTFCO

33


6JG HQNNQYKPI EQKPU CTG HTQO C NCVGT RGTKQF CPF JCTF VQ ENCUUKH[ 2GTJCRU UQOG OC[ DG CVVTK DWVGF VQ VJG 8KUKIQVJU +OKVCVKQP 9GUVGTP 4QOCP 'ORKTG *QPQTKWU 5KNKSWC

72

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 *Q0Q4+ 8522#8) 4 4QOC QP VJTQPG YKVJ TGXGTUGF URGCT 8KEVQT[ YKVJ YTGCVJ KP T JCPF 8+46854Q /#0Q48/ KP GZGTIWG 6425. IT. 8GT[ HKPG $CVCXKC FGP *CCI /KPV 6TKGT

+OKVCVKQPU 'CUVGTP 4QOCP 'ORKTG $TQP\G #PCUVCUKWU

74

73

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0#0#u 6#5 +8u 268% 4 )TGCV / DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU ETQUU CDQXG Θ YKVJKP KP GZGTIWG %10. IT. $TQYP RCVKPC HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG $QPXCNNGV 2CTKU /KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN

# $WUV T YKVJ TGVCPINGF FTCYP DQF[ ő086u 56+8u #ő 4 )TGCV / DGVYGGP UVCTU ETQUU CDQXG Θ YKVJKP KP GZGTIWG 01% . IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ /KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN

75

76

6JGQFQUKWU ++

# &KCFGOGF DWUV T 6*'1&1Å‘ 4 'ORGTQT UVCPFKPI YKVJ 8KEVQT[ KP N JCPF 4'+2 . IT. )TGGP RCVKPC HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

/KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN

+OKVCVKQPU QH IQNF EQKPU 6JGQFQUKWU ++

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &8+*'1 1 01+ 4 %TQUU KP YTGCVJ KP GZGTIWG %101$ . IT. (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU 6JG TGXGTUG HQTO DTKPIU VJG 5WGDK VQ OKPF DWV VJCV UJQYU CP QTPCOGPVGF QWVGT EKTENG +P 8KUKIQVJ EQKPCIG VJKU GFIG KU UOQQVJ 6JKU EQKP OKIJV UVGO HTQO 8KUKIQVJ VGTTKVQT[ KV UJQYU UQOG TGUGODNCPEG VQ C EQKP WPFGT #PVJGOKWU UGG 5WDLCEM EQNNGEVKQP 8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

34


77

2:1

2:1

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 6*'1&1 5+85 2( #8) 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ YTGCVJ CPF QTD UVCT KP HKGNF 8+%614+# #8%56148/ KP GZGTIWG %101$. IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG )QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP )TKGTUQP UWIIGUVU C OKPV QP VJG $CNMCP RGPKPUWNC *CJP JCU PQ TGEQTF QH VJKU V[RG

*QPQTKWU !

78

2:1

2:1

5QNKFWU. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ JGNOGV UJKGNF CPF URGCT QXGT UJQWNFGT %%101 1+#1%+8 4 8KEVQT[ UVCPFKPI T YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UVCHH UVCT T %%%101*81 18*1 KP GZGTIWG 1Å‘. IT. #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG YGKIJV KU VJCV QH C VTGOKUUKU %QWNF VJKU DG C NKIJV UQNKFWU! +V KU FQWDVHWN VJCV VJKU EQKP UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ ,WUVKP 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG VQ VJG NGHV CPF TKIJV QH VJG 8KEVQTKC EQPUKUVU QH VJG UCOG NGVVGTU 1#*1 QP VJG NGHV FGHKPKVGN[ HQNNQYGF D[ CP 0 6JKU ECP CNUQ RCTVN[ DG HQWPF QP VJG QDXGTUG 6JKU RQUUKDN[ TGHGTU VQ C OKPV WPFGT *QPQTKWU 6JG EQKP HKVU VJG 8KUKIQVJ UGTKGU DGUV # UKOKNCT TGRGVKVKQP QH VGZV HTCIOGPVU KU HQWPF QP VJG .QODCTF EQKP PQ

,WUVKPKCPWU +

79

2:1

2:1

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 +856+0+ #08522#8) 4 8KEVQT[ N YKVJ YTGCVJ QP QTD UVCT KP HKGNF 8+%+14+##8%856148/ KP GZGTIWG %101 . IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM OKUVCMG KP VJG FKG UOCNN ITCHHKVK QP VJG TGXGTUG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 4KGVFKLM FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ /KPV %QPUVCPVKPQRGN +P XKGY QH VJG TGXGTUG RTQDCDN[ .QODCTF

35


*705 #TQWPF VJG *WPU ETQUUGF VJG 8QNIC CPF FTQXG VJG #NCPU CPF 'TOCPCTKEʼnU 1UVTQIQVJU CYC[ +P VJG[ FGHGCVGF %KVCPCTKEʼnU 8KUKIQVJKE CTO[ +P VJG GPUWKPI [GCTU VJG[ HQWPFGF CP 'CUVGTP 'WTQRGCP 'ORKTG #TQWPF *WP CTOKGU NGF D[ 7NFKP GOGTIGF KP 9CNNCEJKC +P TGURGEVKXGN[ VJG *WPU FTQXG VJG $WTIWPFKCPU CPF VJG 5KNKPIK 8CPFCNU HTQO VJG 8KUVWNC CPF VJG 1FGT 6JG 5KNKPIK 8CPFCNU LQKPGF VJG *CUFKPIK 8CPFCNU KP VJG 7RRGT 6JGKUU VGTTKVQT[ CPF VJG 2CPPQPKCP 3WCFK CPF 5WGDK ITQWRU CPF VJG[ VQIGVJGT UGV QWV HQT )CWN KP UGG 8CPFCNU 9KVJ #TECFKWUʼn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ʼnU EQWTV *G MGRV WR IQQF TGNCVKQPU VQ #ÀVKWU YJQ KP EGFGF RCTV QH 2CPPQPKC VQ VJG *WPU 6JG ECPEGNNKPI QH /CTEKCPWUʼn VTKDWVCT[ UVCVWU KP CPF C UGETGV OCTTKCIG RTQRQUCN HTQO VJG CWIWUVC ,WUVC )TCVC *QPQTKC

UKUVGT QH 8CNGPVKPKCP +++ YJKEJ #VVKNC CEEGRVGF VQ UGEWTG RCTV QH VJG 9GUVGTP 4QOCP 'ORKTG CTG GXKFGPEG QH JKU KPHNWGPEG #VVKNC VTKGF WPKVKPI VJG 8KUKIQVJU CPF VJG 8CPFCNU WPFGT JKU TWNG DWV YKVJQWV UWEEGUU +P #VVKNC EQPSWGTGF #URCTʼnU 'CUV 4QOCP CTO[ # [GCTN[ VTKDWVG YCU CITGGF WRQP CPF VJG *WPU COCUU NCTIG COQWPVU QH IQNF CNNQYKPI VJGO VQ SWKGVN[ RTGRCTG HQT VJG )CNNKE 9CT +P /GV\ YCU FGUVTQ[GF CPF 1TNGCPU DGUKGIGF #ÀVKWU VJGP UWEEGGFGF VQ FGHGCV #VVKNC QP VJG %CVCNCWPKE HKGNFU UKVWCVGF PGCT %J³NQPU UWT /CTPG YKVJ VJG CKF QH C 4QOCP 8KUKIQVJKE $WTIWPFKCP (TCPEQPKCP EQCNKVKQP #ÀVKWU HKTUV OCKPVCKPGF HTKGPFN[ TGNCVKQPUJKRU YKVJ VJG *WPU JQYGXGT KP VWTPGF CICKPUV VJGO 6JKU QTKIKPCNN[ ICXG JKO C RQYGTHWN RQUKVKQP VJCV PGXGTVJGNGUU RTQXGF HCVCN YJGP JG YCU CUUCUUKPCVGF FWTKPI CP CWFKGPEG YKVJ 'ORGTQT 8CNGPVKPKCP +OOGFKCVGN[ CHVGT YJKEJ /CTEJ 8CNGPVKPKCP YCU OWTFGTGF UGG 8CPFCNU D[ #ÀVKWUʼn JGPEJOGP UKIPCNNKPI VJG HKPCN FGENKPG QH VJG 9GUVGTP 4QOCP 'ORKTG 6JG GPUWKPI ECORCKIP KPVQ 0QTVJGTP +VCN[ OGTGN[ TGUWNVGF KP VJG VCMKPI QH #SWKNGKC VJG 'CUVTQOCP 'ORGTQT /CTEKCPWU YKVJUVCPFKPI VJG *WPU CPF HQTEKPI VJGO VQ TGVTGCV 6JWU #ÀVKWU JCF RTGXGPVGF YQTUG HQT 4QOG +P FWTKPI JKU OCTTKCIG VQ IQVJKE +NFKEQ #VVKNC FKGF #HVGT JKU RCUUKPI JKU GNFGUV UQP 'NNCE DGECOG MKPI *KU [QWPIGT DTQVJGT QRRQUGF 'NNCE FKGF KP VJG 5GEQPF 9CT QH *WPPKE 5WEEGUUKQP CV 0GFCQ 6JG *WPU HNGF VQ VJG GCUV #VVKNCʼn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ʼnU UQPU )WPFGTKE CPF )GKUGTKE )WPFGTKEJ DGECOG MKPI 5RCKP YCU TGCEJGF KP VQIGVJGT YKVJ VJG #NCPK CPF VJG 5WGDK 6JG 5KNKPIK UGVVNGF KP $CGVKEC VQFC[ʼnU #PFCNWUKC VJG *CUFKPIK VQIGVJGT YKVJ VJG 5WGDK GUVCDNKUJGF VJGOUGNXGU KP )CNKEKC +P C HQGFGTCVK VTGCV[ YCU TGCEJGF YKVJ 4QOCPU DWV FCPIGTU UVKNN NQQOGF 8KUKIQVJ -KPI 8CNKC OCTEJGF KPVQ 5RCKP CPF JG XCPSWKUJGF VJG 5KNKPIK 6JG #NCPU VJCV TGOCKPGF YKVJQWV C MKPI CHVGT VJG FGCVJ QH -KPI #FFCZ LQKPGF VJG *CUFNKPIK 8CPFCNU WPFGT )WPFGTKE 6JGP )WPFGTKE RTQENCKOGF JKOUGNH 4GZ 8CPFCNQTWO GV #NCPQTWO #HVGT )WPFGTKEʼnU FGOKUG KP )GKUGTKE DGECOG MKPI QH VJG 8CPFCNU CPF #NCPU #HVGT EQPSWGTKPI VJG 4QOCPU VJG[ RKNNCIGF %CTVCIGPC VJG $CNGCTKE +UNCPFU CPF /CWTKVCPKCʼnU EQCUV 36


+P OGP COQPI YJQ VJG #NCPU NGF D[ )GKUGTKE ETQUUGF VJG UVTCKIJV VQ #HTKEC QP TGSWGUV QH %QOGU $QPKHCEG 6JG[ UGVVNGF KP *KRRQ 4GIKWU VJG FKQEGUG QH #WIWUVKPG NGCXKPI %CTVJCIGʼn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

80 2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC %CTVJCIQ. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 1014+ 85 2( #8) 4 4QOC UKVVKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF 8KEVQTKC 84$5 41/# KP GZGTIWG 4825. /'% IT. $TQCF URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

5VGTPDGTI <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ +OKVCVKQP QH C UKNKSWC HTQO *QPQTKWU 4CXGPPC 6JKU RKGEG FGHKPKVGN[ KU HTQO %CTVJCIG OCP[ CTG EQRKGU HTQO 4CXGPPC +V KU PQV NKUVGF KP VJG /+$ 2UGWFQ KORGTKCN UKNKSWCG CPFJCNH UKNKSWCG EQRKGF HTQO 4CXGPPCVG EQKPU QH *QPQTKWU VJG JCNXGU JCXG QPN[ TGEGPVN[ DGGP KFGPVKHKGF CPF CP GZEGNNGPVUVWF[ KU PQY CXCKNCDNG QH DQVJ UGTKGU /QTTKUQP CPF 5EJYCTV\ 6JG[ CTG FKUVKPIWKUJCDNG HTQO QTKIKPCN RTQFWEVUQH VJG 4CXGPPC OKPV D[ VJGKT VJKEM HNCPU CPF VJG RTGXCNGPEG QH Q FKG CZKU CNTGCF[ CNNWFGF VQ

EQOOGPVCT[ /'% + R 4825 UVCPFU HQT 4#8'00# 2858.#68/

2:1

81

2:1

5KNKSWC %CTVJCIQ. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T őő 852(#8 4 8KEVQTKC N YKVJ YTGCVJ őő ##8%. /'% IT. 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG #WHJ·WUGT /ÒPEJGP EH PQ

*70'4+%* *WPGTKE UQP QH )GKUGTKE DGECOG GPICIGF VQ 'WFQZKC FCWIJVGT QH 8CNGPVKPKCP +++ *KU UCEM KPI 4QOG OKIJV JCXG DGGP CP CEV QH NQ[CNV[ VQYCTF VJG CUUCUUKPCVGF 8CNGPVKPKCP #NTGCF[ WPFGT )GKUGTKE PQDKNKV[ NGF CP WRTKUKPI VJCV YCU UVTWEM FQYP KP *WPGTKE VQQ JCF VQ FGCN YKVJ TGDGNNKQWU PQDKNKV[ *G EQPVKPWGF VJG CTKCPKUKPI RQNKVKEU DWV JKU UWEEGUUQT JKU EQWUKP )WPVJCOWPF RWV CP GPF VQ VJKU )WPVJCOWPFʼnU TGKIP YCU OCTMGF D[ VJG YCTU CICKPUV VJG /QQTU CPF CICKPUV 0QOCFKE VTKDGU

2:1

82

2:1

0WOOK. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 881 / #&5#6 4 %TQUU 1528 8+1+61 KP GZGTIWG VJTGG RGNNGVU. /'% /+$ IT. #VVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 0QV RWDNKUJGF

37


)706*#/70&

)WPVJCOWPF KU VJG HKTUV YJQ OGPVKQPU JKU PCOG QP VJG EQKPU

2:1

83

2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 4: )806*# 4 & 0 KP YTGCVJ WPFGT UVTKRG. /'% /+$ IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU &0 FGPCTKK

85

84 2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 806*# 4 +P YTGCVJ & 0 ::8 UVTKRG CDQXG. /'% /+$ IT. 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG #WHJ·WUGT /Ã’PEJGP ::8 FGPCTKK

0WOOK. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 4 %JTKUVQITCO KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ XCT IT. 4 )QQF XGT[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG /+$ UJQYU C RGNNGV KP VJG EJTKUVQITCO )WPVJCOWPF KU VJG QPN[ QPG YKVJ C „ PWOOK CPF C EJTKUVQITCO

86 2:1

87 2:1

2:1

0WOOK. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0&8&+u 4 5VCT YKVJ QPG UVTKRG KP GCEJ CPING. /'% /+$ /QUVGEM[ EH 2N :+ HH IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG %QWNF VJG UKZ RQKPVGF UVCT DG C EJTKUVQITCO!

2:1

0WOOK. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 4 5VCT KP YTGCVJ YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU. /'% /+$ /QUVGEM[ EH 2N :+ HH IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 6JGUG EQKPU WUGF VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG /QQTU KP #HTKEC UGG $/%

6*4#5#/70&

6JTCUCOWPF DTQVJGT QH )WPVJCOWPF TWNGF C RTGFQOKPCPVN[ TQOCPKUGF RGQRNG *G OCTTKGF #OCNHTKFC UKUVGT QH 6JGQFGTKE GUVCDNKUJKPI C DQPF YKVJ VJG 'CUV )QVJU KP 6JTCUCOWPF UVTQXG VQYCTF UQWPF VKGU YKVJ $[\CPVKWO CPF PWTVWTGF C FKCNQIWG YKVJ VJG %JTKU VKCP EJWTEJ

2:1

88 2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 4) 64 #0+#++8 4 & 0 KP YTGCVJ DGVYGGP UVTKRG CPF .

JQTK\QPVCN . /'% /+$ C IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 'NUGP $TWUUGN +P /'% VJKU KU %NCUU 9KVJ C OQTG UV[NK\GF DWUV CPF YTGCVJ VJG FGPCTKWU RKGEGU YKVJ VJG OCTM QH XCNWG . QP VJG TGXGTUG

38


89 2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 4ő 5#/8&5 4 & 0 WPFGT UVTKRG KP YTGCVJ EKTENG YKVJ RGNNGV CDQXG. /'% /+$ C IT. 4 5NKIJVGN[ KTTGIWNCT HNCP OKPQT UETCVEJGU QP UWTHCEG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

#WHJ·WUGT /ÒPEJGP

2:1

90

2:1

0WOOK. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 5# 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 4 )QQF XGT[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG

*+.&'4+% *KNFGTKE YCU C UQP HTQO VJG OCTTKCIG QH *WPGTKE CPF 'WFQZKC *G MKNNGF #OCN HTKFC WUGF EQKPU DGCTKPI VJG KOCIG QH ,WUVKPKCP CPF VWTPGF CYC[ HTQO $[\CPVKWO HQT YJKEJ VJG %CTVJCIG 5[PQF QH YCU QPG QH VJG TGCUQPU #HVGT DGKPI FGHGCVGF D[ VJG /QQTU JG YCU ECRVWTGF CPF GZGEWVGF

91

2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 *+.&+ 4+: 4': 4 %CTVJCIQ HCEKPI YKVJ GCTU QH EQTP ('.+: -#46). /'% /+$ IT. 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

2:1

92

2:1

0WOOK. # $WUV N YKVJ RCNO NGCH 4 +P VYQ NKPGU 0 ++++ UVTKRG 0. /'% /+$ IT. )TGGP RCVKPC CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP /ÒNNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ ++++ PWOOK

)'.+/'4

6JG NCUV MKPI )GNKOGT UWHHGTGF C NQUU CICKPUV $GNKUCT CPF YCU DCPKUJGF VQ #UKC /KPQT

2:1

93

0WOOK. # $CTDCTK\GF DWUV T 4 'CTU QH EQTP. IT.

2:1 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNVGP -ÌNP #WEVKQP 1EVQDGT PQ 6JKU KU C DCTDCTKE KOKVCVKQP QH C PWOOWU QH )WPVJCOWPF *CJP /+$ HTQO VJG NCUV [GCTU QH 8CPFCN FQOKPCPEG #VVTKDWVGF VQ )GNKOGT

39


+6#.; KP VJG PF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[

9JGP 4QOWNWU #WIWUVWU YCU FGRQUGF KP VJG 'CUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG EQPUKFGTGF +VCN[ RCTV QH KVU VGTTKVQT[ +P VJG UQWVJ VJG 8CPFCNU UVKNN RTGXCKNGF CPF KP VJG PQTVJ VJG )GTOCPKE EJKGHVCKP 1FQCEGT KP XCFGF +VCN[ +P VJG [GCT QH VJG EQNNCRUG QH VJG 9GUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG 1FQCEGT JCF JKU VTQQRU RTQENCKO JKO MKPI 1FQCEGTʼnU DQTP CRRTQZ CPEGUVT[ KU WPENGCT *G OKIJV JCXG DGGP C UQP QH 'FGMQ C OCIKUVTCVG CV #VVKNCʼnU EQWTV #HVGT VJG GPF QH VJG *WP 'ORKTG JG YCU C OGTEGPCT[ KP )CWN CPF VJGP YGPV VQ +VCN[ KP 4KEKOGTʼnU UGTXKEG $[\CPVKWO CRRQKPVGF JKO RCVTKEKCP *KU TGNCVKQPUJKR VQ VJG UGPCVG KU IQQF CPF JG GPLQ[GF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH CRRQKPVKPI EQPUWNU #HVGT JG FGUVTQ[GF VJG 4WIKCP 4GCNO JG ICKPGF 5KEKN[ HTQO VJG 8CPFCNU VJTQWIJ C FGOKUG EJCTVGT 6JKU KPHNWGPEG UVTCKPGF JKU TGNCVKQPUJKR YKVJ $[\CPVKWO +P 'ORGTQT <GPQ CUUKIPGF 6JGQFGTKE YJQ D[ VJGP YCU KP 'RKTQU VQ FTKXG 1FQCEGT HTQO +VCN[ 6Q DG CNNQYGF GUVCDNKUJKPI JKOUGNH KP 4CXGPPC JG UKIPGF C VTGCV[ YKVJ 1FQCEGT

DWV KP VJG UCOG [GCT UNGY JKO VJG UWRRQUGF TGCUQP YCU VJG CXGPIKPI HQT VJG FGHGCV QH VJG 4WIKCP *QWUG +VCN[ DGECOG VJG NCPF QH VJG 'CUV )QVJU YJQ UVC[GF RCTV QH VJG 'CUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG

/70+%+2#. %1+0#)' +0 +6#.; #0& #(4+%# #U UQQP CU 4QOCP VKOGU EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM HQT VJG EKV[ QH 4QOG CPF %QPUVCPVKPQRNG PQ RCTV QH VJKU EQNNGEVKQP DWV TGRTGUGPVGF KP VJG KOKVCVKQPU #NUQ KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ OWPKEKRCN EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM KP %CTVJCIG 4QOG CPF 4CXGPPC 6JG[ DGCT VJG EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU QH VJGUG EKVKGU VTCEKPI DCEM VQ QNF NGIGPFU

%#46*#)1

6JGTG CTG XCTKQWU OQVKXGU (GOCNG HKIWTG QH %CTVJCIQ UVCPFKPI KP VJG IWKUG QH %GTGU JQNFKPI GCTU QH EQTP CPF VYQ HKIWTGU HTQO VJG HQWPFCVKQP NGIGPFU QH VJG EKV[ QPG C UVCPFKPI UQNFKGT CPF VJG QVJGT C JQTUG +P 4QOG UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU CU YGNN CU KP %CTVJCIG JQTUG VJGTG KU TGHGTGPEG VQ VJG NGIGPFU UWTTQWPFKPI VJG HQWPFKPI QH VJGUG EKVKGU 6JG JQTUG JCU VJG HQNNQYKPI NGIGPF CVVCEJGF VQ KV 6JG MKPI QH 6[TG JCF C UQP CPF C FCWIJVGT 'NKUUCT 6JG RGQRNG YCPVGF QPN[ VJG UQP YJQ JCF 'NKU UCTʼnU JWUDCPF MKNNGF 'NKUUCT HNGF VQ #HTKEC 5JG YCU YGNN TGEGKXGF CPF ITCPVGF C RKGEG QH NCPF VJG UK\G QH CP QZGUʼn UMKP 5JG PCOGF VJKU PGY UGVVNGOGPV $[TUC VJG ITGGM YQTF HQT QZUMKP +P VJG EQPUVTWEVKQP QH VJG EKV[ VJG HKTUV URCFG UVTWEM C EQYʼnU JGCF RTQXKFKPI C DCF QOGP 6JG UGEQPF URCFG UVTWEM C JQTUGʼnU JGCF JQNFKPI C RTQOKUG QH RQYGT 6JGTG CTG ENCUUGU %CTVJCIQ UVCPFKPI 5QNFKGT UVCPFKPI $QVJ ENCUUGU QEEWT KP VJG FGPQOKPCVKQPU CPF VJGUG PWODGTU CTG EJCTCEVGTKUVKE HQT VJG 8CPFCN UGG VJGTG PWOGTKECN U[UVGO TGUR CPF QH PWOOK C UKNKSWC

94

0WOOK. # %CTVJCIQ UVCPFKPI ETQYPGF YKVJ EQTP YTGCVJ CPF JQNFKPI GCTU QH EQTP YKVJKP NCWTGN YTGCVJ 4 0:++ KP NCWTGN YTGCVJ WPFGT UVTKRG. /'% /+$ IT. 4 $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ /+$ ENCUUKHKGU VJKU WPFGT *KNFGTKEJ *GCX[ UGTKGU KP /'% %NCUU

40


95

95

0WOOK. # 5QNFKGT UVCPFKPI -#46 *#)1 4 *QTUGJGCF KP GZGTIWG ::+. /'% /+$ IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 0/$ #OUVGTFCO /+$ ENCUUKHKGU VJKU WPFGT )GNKOGT 9KVJ /'% ENCUU .KIJV EQKPCIG

96

96

0WOOK. # 5QNFKGT UVCPFKPI -#46 *#)1 4 *QTUGJGCF KP GZGTIWG ::+. /'% /+$ IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $GEMGPDCWGT /Ã’PEJGP /+$ ENCUUKHKGU VJKU WPFGT )GNKOGT 9KVJ /'% ENCUU .KIJV EQKPCIG

41/# 6JG U[ODQN VJG JGNOGVGF DWUV QH 4QOC HTQO GCTN[ FGPCTKK QH VJG 4QOCP 4GRWDNKE +08+%6# 41/# 6JG TGXGTUG V[RGU YJGP VJG[ CTG PQV C 4QOCP GCING TGHGT VQ VJG VTCFK VKQPCN QTKIKPU QH 4QOG YKVJ 4QOWNWU CPF 4GOWU UWEMNGF D[ C UJG YQNH QT C HKI VTGG TGRTG UGPVKPI VJG HKEWU TWOKPCNKU 4WOKPC YCU VJG IQFFGUU QH PWTUKPI OQVJGTU ņ DGPGCVJ YKVJ CE EQTFKPI VQ .KXKWU VJKU UEGPG YCU GPCEVGF 6JGTG CTG VYQ ENCUUGU %NCUU JGCX[ UGTKGU C (QNNKU UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU YKVJ :. D (QNNKU UJG YQNH CPF VYKPU YKVJ :: %NCUU NKIJV UGTKGU C (QNNKU GCING YKVJ :. D (QNNKU HKI VTGG QT VYQ GCINGU YKVJ ::

UGG /'% + R

97

(QNNKU %N C. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 5JG YQNH YKVJ VYKPU :. CDQXG ++++ DGNQY. /'% /+$ IT. 1NKXG ITGGP RCVKPC DTQCF URGEKOGP IQQF XGT[ HKPG

4 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ

98

(QNNKU %N D. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+% 6#41/# 4 5JG YQNH YKVJ VYKPU : : DGNQY. /'% /+$ D IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP

41


99

99

(QNNKU %N D. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+% 6#41/# 4 5JG YQNH YKVJ VYKPU + CDQXG :: DGNQY. /'% /+$ D IT. )TGGP RCVKPC UOCNN HNCP FGHGEV QP VJG QDXGTUG CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

100

(QNNKU %N C. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 'CING N NQQMKPI DCEM :. N KP DQVVQO HKGNF ITGGM FGNVC DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. /'% /+$ C IT. )TGGP RCVKPC TGXGTUG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

4 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ

101

(QNNKU %N C. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 'CING N NQQMKPI DCEM :. N KP DQVVQO HKGNF ITGGM ICOOC DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. /'% /+$ C IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

$GEMGPDCWGT /Ã’PEJGP

102

(QNNKU %N C. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 'CING N NQQMKPI DCEM :. N DQVVQO HKGNF WPXKUKDNG. /'% EH HH /+$ C IT. $TQYP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

42


4#8'00# 5[ODQN ETQYPGF DWUV ('.+: 4#8'00# 1HVGP ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT 6JGQFQTKE QT #VJCNCTKE

2:1

103 2:1

0WOOK. # %TQYPGF DWUV T ('.+:4 #8'00# 4 'CING DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU KP GZGTIWG :. /'% /+$ IT. #VVTCEVKXG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

2:1

104 2:1

0WOOK. # %TQYPGF DWUV T ('.+:4 #8'00# 4 'CING DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU KP GZGTIWG :. /'% /+$ IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QP VJG TGXGTUG QVJGTYKUG CVVTCEVKXG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5VGTPDGTI <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ

'#4.; +/2'4+#. WPVKN 1NF 4QOCP EQKPU OQUVN[ HTQO VJG (NCXKCP RGTKQF YKVJ C XCNWG GVEJGF KPVQ VJGO EKTEWNCVGF CNQPIUKFG VJGUG OWPKEKRCN EQKPU /'% UKIPCNKUGU CDQWV URGEKOGPU 6JG[ JCXG QPN[ VYQ PQOKPCN XCNWGU CPF PWOOK VJG YCU KPVGPFGF HQT VJG UGUVGTVKK VJG HQT VJG CUUGU 6JG RNCEG QH QTKIKP TGOCKPU CODKIWQWU 6JG FGPQOKPCVKQPU CPF KPFKECVG #HTKEC

/QTTKUQP 6JG TG WUG QH QDUGNGVG EQKPU VJG ECUG QH 4QOCP KORGTKCN DTQP\GU TGXKXGF KP VJG NCVG HKHVJ EGPVWT[ KP 5VWFKGU KP 0WOKUOCVKE /GVJQFU RTGUGPVGF VQ 2JKNKR )TKGTUQP %CO DTKFIG R (TKGFN·PFGT CPF 9TQVJ DWV PGCTN[ CNN JQCTFU YGTG NQECVGF KP +VCN[

GURGEKCNN[ KP VJG 4QOG TGIKQP /'% ENCUUKHKGU VJGO WPFGT +VCN[ *CJP CPF /QUVGEM[ WPFGT 8CPFCNU *GTG PGKVJGT KU CFJGTGF VQ VJGUG EQKPU CTG EQPUKFGTGF VQIGVJGT YKVJ VJG OWPKEKRCN EQKPU VJCV URTGCF QXGT #HTKEC CPF +VCN[ CU YGNN

105

(QNNKU :.++. :.++ GPITCXGF KP QPG #U HTQO )CNDC. # $WUV T YKVJ NCWTGN YTGCVJ )#.$# +/2 %#' 5#4 #8) 2/642 KP GZGTIWG T :.++ 4 8KEVQTKC N YKVJ YTGCVJ DGVYGGP 5 %. /'% IT. $TQYP RCVKPC CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ /'% JCU C .KDGTVCU QP VJG QDXGTUG

43


15641)16*5 #HVGT VJG FKXKUKQP KP VYQ ITQWRU GOGTIGF VQ VJG YGUV VJG 6GTXKPIK 8GUK CPF VQ VJG GCUV )TGWVWPIK 1UVTQIQVJK 1UVTQIQVJGP 5QPPGPCWHICPIUIQVGP UWPTKUG )QVJU QT FWTEJ FGP #WHICPI FGT 5QPPG IN·P\GPFGP )QVGP )QVJU UJKPKPI DGECWUG QH VJG UWPTKUGʼnU KNNWOKPCVKQP $CUKECNN[ VJG 8KUKIQVJU EQPUKUVGF QH 1UVTQIQVJU CU YGNN CPF KV KU VJGTGHQTG RTGHGTCDNG VQ FKU VKPIWKUJ DGVYGGP VJG 1UVTQIQVJU WR VQ VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF VJG 'CUV )QVJU CHVGT VJCV VKOG 6JG 9GUV CPF 'CUV )QVJU JCXG CNYC[U EQPUKFGTGF VJGOUGNXGU FGUEGPFCPVU QH VJG UCOG VTKDG FGURKVG VJGKT FKCURQTC UGG WPFGT 8KUKIQVJU #HVGT VJG *WP 'ORKTG JCF HCNNGP VJG 'CUV )QVJU GPVGTGF VJG 4QOCPG 'ORKTG CU HQGFGTCVK CPF UJQTVN[ UGVVNGF QP VJG DCPMU QH VJG 5CXG CPF VJG &TCW /QUV 'CUV )QVJU YGTG QH #TKCP HCKVJ 6JGQFQTKE YCU RTGUWOCDN[ DQTP FWTKPI VJG *WP 'ORKTG #HVGT VJG DCVVNG CV VJG $QNKC .GQ + TGNGCUGF 6JGQFGTKE YJQ JCF DGGP JGNF JQUVCIG KP %QP UVCPVKPQRNG HTQO VQ 6JGQFGTKE VQQM QXGT 2CPPQPKC HTQO 8CNKOKT CPF EQPSWGTGF VJG 6JGKUU 5CTOCVU 5KPIKFWPWO $GNITCFG +P VJG #OCN &[PCUV[ NQUV 2CPPQPKC 8KFKOKT YGPV VQ VJG 9GUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG YKVJ JKU UQP 6JKWFKOKT VQQM JKU UQP 6JGQFQTKE VQ /CEGFQPKC YJGTG 6JKWFKOKT FKGF KP 6JGQF GTKE VJGP DGECOG MKPI 6JG RGTKQF HTQO VQ KU C EQPHWUGF VKOG 6QYCTF VJG GPF YG HKPF 6JGQFGTKE KP 'RKTQU *KU OCKP CFXGTUCT[ YCU VJG )QVJKE -KPI 6JGQFGTKE 5VTCDQ #HVGT VJG NCVVGTʼnU FGOKUG 6JGQFGTKEʼnU UVCT DGICP VQ TKUG +P JG UKIPGF C VTGCV[ YKVJ <GPQ KP YJKEJ JG RNGFIGF VQ FTKXG 1FQCEGT HTQO +VCN[ 6JKU VTGCV[ HQTOGF VJG HQWPFCVKQP WPFGT VJG 'CUVIQVJKE 'ORKTG KP +VCN[ 1P VJG VJ QH (GDTWCT[ VJG DKUJQR QH 4CXGPPC OGFKCVGF DGVYGGP 1FQCEGT CPF 6JGQFGTKE GPCDNKPI C LQKPV IQX GTPOGPV 6JKU YCU KPEQPUKUVGPV YKVJ VJG VTGCV[ YKVJ <GPQ DWV CNNQYGF 6JGQFGTKE VQ UGV WR KP 4CXGPPC VJ /CTEJ +P VJG UCOG [GCT JG FKURQUGF QH 1FQCEGT 5WDUGSWGPVN[ VJG 8CPFCNU YGTG FTKXGP HTQO 5KEKN[ CPF RKNNCIKPI $WTIWPFKCPU YGTG FKURGNNGF HTQO VJG PQTVJ 6JGQFGTKE WUGF OCTTKCIG VQ GUVCDNKUJ VKGU YKVJ QVJGT RGQRNGU *G JKOUGNH YGFFGF #WFQHNGFC %NQXKUʼn UKUVGT CPF KP 6JGQFGTKEʼnU FCWIJVGT YCU GPICIGF VQ VJG $WTIWPFKCP %TQYP 2TKPEG 5KIKUOWPF OCTTKCIG KP CPQVJGT QH JKU FCWIJVGTU 6JKWFKIQVJQ YGFFGF VJG 8KUKIQVJ -KPI #NCTKE ++ VJG OCTTKCIG EQPPGEVKPI DQVJ )QVJKE TQ[CN JQWUGU 9JGP VJG #NCOCPPK UWHHGTGF C FGHGCV CICKPUV VJG (TCPMU EQPHNKEV CTQUG DGVYGGP VJG DTQVJGTU KP NCY 6JGQFGTKE CPF %NQXKU 6JGQFGTKE YKUJGF VQ TGVCKP 4CGVKC CPF +VCN[ CPF VQ VJKU GPF C EQORTQOKUG YCU OCFG DGVYGGP 6JGQFGTKE CPF %NQXKU TGUWNVKPI KP VJG NCVVGTʼnU TGVTGCV &GURKVG PWOGTQWU CVVGORVU QP 6JGQFGTKEʼnU UKFG VQ RTGXGPV C EQCNKVKQP DGKPI HQTOGF DGVYGGP VJG (TCPMU CPF VJG $WTIWPFKCPU VJG[ LQKPGF HQTEGU CPF CVVCEMGF VJG 9GUVIQVJKE 4GCNO +P VJG $CVVNG QH 8QWKNN¾ KP %NQXKU RGTUQPCNN[ VQQM VJG NKHG QH #NCTKE ++ 6JGQFGTKEʼnU ITCPFUQP YCU VQQ [QWPI CU YCU #NCTKEʼnU QVJGT UQP $CVVNG COQPI VJG )QVJU GPUWGF KP 5QWVJ )CWN CPF 5RCKP CPF VJG HKPCN TGUWNV YCU VJCV 6JGQFGTKE DGECOG MKPI QH VJG 8KUKIQVJU 6JG JGKTGUU QH 6JGQFGTKE #OCNCUWPVJC YCU YGFFGF VQ 8KUKIQVJ -KPI 'WVJCTKE *G YCU FGGOGF JGKT CPF YCU VQ UWEEGGF 6JGQFGTKE CU MKPI QH CNN )QVJU 6JG PGY 'ORGTQT ,WUVKP CE MPQYNGFIGF VJKU UWEEGUUKQP HQT +VCN[ )CWN CPF 5RCKP 6JG RNCP OKUECTTKGF JQYGXGT YJGP 'WVJCTKE FKGF CU UQQP CU 6JGQFGTKE YCU JGNF KP JKIJ GUVGGO COQPI 4QOCPU *G YCU EQORCTGF VQ 6TCLCPWU CPF 8CNGP VKPKCP 'URGEKCNN[ JKU CRRGCTCPEG KP OCTMKPI VJG VTKGPPKCN OCFG CP KORTGUUKQP 6JG 4Q OCPU ECNNGF JKO FQOKPWU CPF GXGP CWIWUVWU 'XGP KH VJG GORGTQT KP %QPUVCPVKPQRNG CRRQKPVGF VJG OCKP RQUKVKQPU JG CNYC[U CEVGF WRQP 4CXGPPCʼnU TGEQOOGPFCVKQP 6JGQFGTKE FKGF QP VJ #WIWUV 6JG #OCN &[PCUV[ VJGP NCRUGF KPVQ C ETKUKU 0GKVJGT #OCNCUWPVJC PQT #VJCNCTKE QT 6JGQFQJCF YGTG WR VQ VJGKT VCUMU CPF VJG[ EQWNFPʼnV CXQKF YCT YKVJ VJG $[\CPVKPG 'ORKTG +P 9KVKIGU DGECOG VJG HKTUV PQP #OCN MKPI CPF JG UGV QWV VQ YCTF QHH VJG KOOKPGPV TWKP QH VJG 'CUV )QVJKE 'ORKTG +P JQYGXGT JG KU HQTEGF VQ ECRKVWNCVG VQ VJG KORGTKCN EQO OCPFGT $GNKUCTKWU CP KORQTVCPV 4QOCP IGPGTCN WPFGT ,WUVKPKCP JG FGHGCVGF VJG 8CPFCNU

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

44


6*'1&14+%

2:1

2:1

2:1

106

107

108

2:1

2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC /GFKQNCPWO. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T & #0#5 6#5+8 22 #% 4 6JGQFGTKE OQPQITCO CDQXG ETQUU UVCT DGNQY +08+% 6# 41/#. /'% /+$ D IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 'Z )QQFCETG EQNNGEVKQP +P VJG PCOG QH #PCUVCUKWU

5KNKSWC 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 +856+085 #8) 4 6JGQFGTKE OQPQITCO KP YTGCVJ CDQXG ETQUU. /'% XCT /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPWU +

#6*#.#4+%

5KNKSWC 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 +856+0+#ő 4 +P YTGCVJ &0 #6*#. #4+%85 4':. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCPWU +

109

0WOOK 4QOG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+% 6# 41/# 4 (KIWTG UVCPFKPI YKVJ URGCT CPF UJKGNF &0 #6*#. #4+%85 KP HKGNF 5 % CPF :. /'% /+$ IT. 0KEG ITGGP RCVKPC XGT[ CVVTCEVKXG CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 5%: 5GPCVWU %QPUWNVQ PWOOK

110

0WOOK 4QOG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 +P FQWDNGF YTGCVJ VJG KPPGT EKTENG YKVJ : &0 #6*#. #4+%85 4':. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG

-ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCD -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

45


111

2:1

2:1

0WOOK 4QOG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+% 6# 41/# 4 8 KP VJG HKGNF &0 #6*#.#4+%85. /'% /+$ C IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

112

113

2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

0WOOK 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 0+ #8) 4 #VJCNCTKE OQPQITCO KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5CPVCOCTKC 4QOG +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCPWU +

0WOOK 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T +856 +0+#0 4 #VJCNCTKE OQPQITCO KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCPWU +

#6*#.#4+% QT 6*'1&1*#&

0GKVJGT QH VJG EQKPU WPFGTPGCVJ UVTWEM KP VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCP + CTG CVVTKDWVCDNG VQ #VJCNCTKE QT 6JGQFQJCF YKVJ CDUQNWVG EGTVCKPV[ #VJCNCTKE UVCTVGF UVTKMKPI VJGO CPF 6JGQFQJCF OCFG PQ EJCPIGU VQ VJG FGXKEG /+$ + R 6JGUG CTG VJG QPN[ VYQ V[RGU

114

5QNKFWU 4QOG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV UJKGNF CPF URGCT QXGT UJQWNFGT &0+856+0+ #0852Γ #8% 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ ETQUU N UVCT WPFGT ETQUU 8+%614 + ##8%%%# DQVVQO HKGNF %1/1$. /'% XCT /+$ IT. 5OCNN ITCHHKVQ QP VJG QDXGTUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WOKUOCVKE %KTEWNCT PQ $;

2:1

46

115 2:1

6TGOKUUKU 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0+856+0+ #0852Ã#8% 4 8KEVQT[ YKVJ ETQUU CPF YTGCVJ UVCT T 8+%614+# #7%856148/ DQVVQO HKGNF %1/1$. /'% XCT /+$ C IT. 5OCNN ITCHHKVQ QP VJG QDXGTUG UNKIJVGN[ DGPV IQQF XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WOKUOCVKE %KTEWNCT PQ $;


6*'1&1*#&

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

2:1

116

2:1

5KNKSWC 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 +856+ 0+#0 #8) 4 +P YTGCVJ &0 6*'1&# *#6*85 4+:. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

117

(QNNKU 4QOG. # %TQYPGF DWUV T ETQUU QP ENQCM &0 6*'1&# *#685 4': 4 8KEVQTKC T YKVJ YTGCVJ CPF RCNO DGVYGGP 5 % 8+%614+# 24+0%+28/. /'% /+$ IT. 4 &CTM ITGGP RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

118

(QNNKU 4QOG. # %TQYPGF DWUV T ETQUU QP ENQCM &0 6*'1 &#*#&85 4': 4 8KEVQTKC T YKVJ YTGCVJ CPF RCNO DGVYGGP 5 % 8+%614+# #8)856. /'% /GVNKEJ C VJKU EQKP /+$ IT. 44 )TGGP RCVKPC JKIJ TGNKGH VJG QPN[ MPQYP URGEKOGP KP EQOOGTEG XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TKGFN·PFGT (TKGFN·PFGT , &KG /Ã’P\GP FGT 1UVIQVJGP $GTNKP KP C HQQVPQVG YKVJ VJG FGUETKRVKQP QH VJG PQT OCN V[RG OGPVKQPU &KG #WHUEJTKHVGP 8+%614+# #8)856 WPF 8+%614+# 28$.+%# 4'56 DGK /G\\CDCTDC WPF FCPCEJ DGK $CPFWTK UKPF YQJN XGTH·NUEJV LGFGPHCNNU DGFÃ’THGP UKG FGT $GUV·VKIWPI FWTEJ CPFGTG 'ZGORNCTG -TCWU

-TCWU ( ( &KG /Ã’P\GP 1FQXCECTU WPF FGU 1UVIQVGPTGKEJGU KP +VCNKGP *CNNG FGUETKDGU C DCFN[ EQPUGTXGF RKGEG WPFGT PQ KNNWUVTCVGF YKVJ &06*'1 =&#?*#&854': CPF 8+%614+# #8)856 ! YGKIJV IO CPF PQVGU &KG 7OUEJTKHV 8+%614+# #8)856 DGK 0T KUV PKEJV UKEJGT DG\GWIV (TKGFN·PFGT / F 1UVI R &CU INGKEJG IKNV HWT FKG TÃ’EMUGKVKIGP .GIGPFGP XQP 0T WPF (TKGFN·PFGT GDGPFC $GK CNNGP FKGUGP DGFCTH GU PQEJ \WXGTN·UUKIGT $GUV·VKIWPI 6JKU URGEKOGP KU MGRV KP $GTNKP 6QNUVQK 6QNUVQK , /QPPCKGU $[\CPVKPGU WPFGT KNNWUVTCVKQP IKXGU C URGEKOGP HTQO VJG *GTOKVCIG EQNNGEVKQP KP 5V 2GVGTUDWTI VJCV YCU ECUV HTQO VJG UCOG FKG CU VJG URGEKOGP CV JCPF %QTT *CJP

/KFFNG #IG GHHKIKGU YGTG PGXGT TGCNKUVKE GZEGRV VQYCTF VJG GPF HQT KPUVCPEG KP /KNCP CPF 5EQVNCPF 6JG RQTVTCKV QH 6JGQFQJCF QP PQ OC[ TCKUG UQOG FQWDV VJCV VJKU KU C TGCN RQTVTCKV DWV UWEJ FQWDV KU QWV QH VJG SWGUVKQP KP VJG ECUG QH PQ KP O[ QRKPKQP 2QUUKDN[ 6JGQFQJCFʼnU RQTVTCKV QP VJG HCOQWU EQKPU EQPUVKVWVGU C TGCN RQTVTCKV CU YGNN

47


119 2:1

2:1

0WOOK 4QOG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV +08+%6 # 41/# 4 &0 6*'1&# *#6*85 4': KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. )TGGP RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

5VGTPDGTI <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ

120

2:1

2:1

0WOOK 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 +8+++8 085 22 #8) 4 8 KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 4 /KPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG /+$ EH &1% CPF $0 +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCPWU + $0 CVVTKDWVGU C EQPUKFGTCDN[ NCTIGT OQFGN VQ 4QOG 6JG UCOG NCTIGT OQFGN OCVEJGU &1% &1% CVVTKDWVGU VJG UOCNNGT V[RGU VQ WPEGTVCKP OKPVU 4CVVQ CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ 6JGQFQJCVWU 6JG OKUUKPI RGPVC YKVJ 6JGQFQJCVWU KP VJG 2T·IGVCDGNNG :++ /+$ KU TGOCTMCDNG 7PFGT #VJCNCTKE VJGTG KU C PWOOK RKGEG YKVJ C 8

9+6+)'5

121

2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC 4CXGPPC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0+856+ 0+#085 #8% 4 +P YTGCVJ &0 88+6 +%'5 4':. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 'Z )QQFCETG EQNNGEVKQP PQ 1) +P VJG PCOG QH ,WUVKPKCPWU +

2:1

122

2:1

5KNKSWC 4CXGPPC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0+856+ 0+#0#85 4 6JGQFGTKEWU OQPQITCO KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 'Z )QQFCETG EQNNGEVKQP PQ 1) 'Z 5QVJGD[ (QT VJKU OQPQITCO VJCV QH 6JGQFQTKE YCU TGXGTVGF VQ 6JGQFQTKEʼnU OQPQITCO QP JKU QYP EQKPU KU FKHHGTGPV

48


$#&7+.#

123

2:1

2:1

6TGOKUUKU 6KEKPWO. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 #0#56# 5+85++#8) 4 8KEVQT[ N YKVJ YTGCVJ CPF ETQUU UVCT T 8+%614+# #8)856148++ KP GZGTIWG %1++1. /'% /+$ EH IT. #VVTCEVKXG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

#WMVKQPGU $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ +P VJG PCOG QH #PCUVCUKWU /C[DG UVTWEM FWTKPI VJG TGKIP QH 6JGKC 6KEKPWO 2CXKC 9GPP YKT XQP FGT /CEJG FGT 5KNDGTOÒP\GP CWU FGT PGW CWHIGDCWVGP /ÒP\UV·VVG 6KEKPWO 2CXKC CWUIGJGP MÌP PGP YKT CPPGJOGP FCUU $CFWKNCU )QNFOÒP\GP GDGPHCNNU GKPGP NGKEJV XGTYKNFGTVGP %JCTCMVGT JCDGP OÒUUGP &COKV DGHKPFGP YKT WPU KO ITQUUGP (GNF FGT DCTDCTKUKGTVGP )GRT·IG PCEJ KVCNKGPKUEJGO /WUVGT FKG YQJN ITQ­VGKNU HT·PM KUEJGP 7TURTWPIU UKPF WPF GU KUV OKV FGT <WYGKUWPI CP $CFWKNC ITÌ­VG 8QTUKEJV IGDQVGP +EJ OÌEJVG GU PWT OKV \YGK 6TGOKUUGUUVGORGNP XGTUWEJGP FGT GKPG JCV CNU 5KING %1016 0T FGT CPFGTG UQICT %10+6 0T KP DGKFGP (·NNGP UEJGKPV GKP MNGKPGT *KPYGKU CWH 6KEKPWO IGIGDGP XKGNNGKEJV FKGPVG FCU %101+ FGT KORGTKCNGP TÌOKUEJGP )QNFOÒP\GP CNU #PTGIWPI &KG 8QTFGTUGKVG JCV GDGPUQ YKG FKG OGKUVGP 5KNDGTOÒP\GP FGU $CFWKNC GKPG #PCUVCUKWU .GIGPFG &GT )NQDWU FGT 8KEVQTKC CWH FGO 4X KUV KP IQVKUEJGT /CPKGT RWPMVHÌTOKI D\Y PKEJV XQTJCPFGP &KG IGP CWGTG <GKVUVGNNWPI FKGUGT DGKFGP 6TGOKUUGU KUV WPMNCT GU KUV FWTEJCWU OÌINKEJ FCUU UKG PQEJ KP FKG MWT\G 4GIGTWPI U\GKV FGU 6JGKC JKPGKPTGKEJGP &KG XQP 9TQVJ WPF -TCWU FGO $CFWKNC D\Y 6JGKC IGIGDGPGP 2T·IWPIGP UKPF HCUV CNNG CPFGTU \WYGKUDCT PWT FGT 6TGOKUUKU 0T UEJGKPV FGO $CFWKNC \W IGJÌTGP XIN FKG 8KGTVGNUKNKSWC $/%

RN :+ WPF \YCT CWU 4QO GT JCV FKG #PCUVCUKWU .GIGPFG WPF FCU IQVKUEJG -TGW\ QJPG )NQDWU CDGT KO 7PVGTUEJKGF \W FGP 6TGOKUUGU CWU 6JGQFGTKEJU <GKVGP FKG 5KING %101+ FGP UGKV ÒDNKEJGP UVTCJNKIGP 5VGTP WPF FCU 2QTVTCKV UQ YKG GU FCXQT KO MCKUGTNKEJGP 4QO ,WUVKPKCPWU + 0T CWUUKGJV &KGU FÒTHVG FCPP ÒDGTJCWRV HÒT N·PIGTG <GKV FKG NGV\VG )QNFRT·IWPI KP 4QO IGYGUGP UGKP GZRNCPCVKQP KP /+$ R

124

2:1

2:1

6TGOKUUKU 4QOG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T CDQXG ETGUEGPV YKVJ RGNNGV CPF YTGCVJ N ++ #0#56 #5+85 2+ 0% 4 8KEVQT[ N YKVJ ETQUU CPF YTGCVJ UVCT T 8+%614+# #8%55+8/ KP GZGTIWG %101+. /'% /+$ IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ +P VJG PCOG QH #PCUVCUKWU /+$ MPQYU VYQ DCF URGEKOGP DQVJ KP $TKVKUJ /WUGWO 5GG GNWEKFCVKQP YKVJ PQ

125 2:1

2:1

0WOOK 6KEKPWO. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 #0 4 $CFWKNC OQPQITCO YKVJ ETQUU CDQXG. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

49


126 2:1

2:1

0WOOK 6KEKPWO. # $WUV T 4 & 0 4': DGVYGGP UVCT CPF $ KP YTGCVJ. /'% /+$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒNNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ *CJP FGGOU VJKU C OKPKOWU +P VJG PCOG QH #PCUVCUKWU

127 2:1

2:1

0WOOK 4QOG. # $WUV HCEKPI &0 $ # &8 4 .KQP T . /'% /+$ I. 8GT[ HKPG

.CP\ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ $GVYGGP +P FGO \WTÒEMIGYQPPGPGP /ÒP\COV 4QO RT·IV $CFWKNC GDGPHCNNU <GJPGT WPF /KPKOK YKG CWEJ FKG $[\CPVKPGT MWT\ FCXQT XIN ,WUVKPKCPWU YQDGK GT XQP FGP $[\CPVKPGTP FKG (TQPVCNFCTUVGNNWPI FGT 2QTVTCKVDÒUVG WPF FGP .ÌYGP V[R FGT /KPKOK ÒDGTPKOOV &CU (TQPVCNRQTVTCKV UVGNNV KJP PWP UGNDUV FCT WPF \YCT ·JPNKEJ YKG 6JGQFQJCV IGYCPFGV

/+$ + R

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

128

2:1

2:1

5KNKSWC. # $WUV T &0 #0#56#5+85 4 6JGQFGTKE OQPQITCO +08%6# 48/#0+ #. IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WO %KTE PQ $; FGUETKDGF CU SWCTVGT UKNKSWC WPFGT 6JGQFQTKE KP #PCUVCUKWUʼn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

50


8+5+)16*5 6JG 6GTXKPIK HQTTGUV RGQRNG VJCV ECNNGF VJGOUGNXGU 8GUKGT VJG IQQF PQDNG HQT C EGPVWT[ KPJCDKVGF C TGIKQP PQTVJ QH VJG &CPWDG YGUV QH VJG 7RRGT &PGUVT CPF VJG .QYGT 2TWVJ WR VQ VJG *WP KPXCUKQPU KP 6JG[ NKXGF CNQPIUKFG VJG TGOCKPKPI TWTCN 4QOCP RQRWNCVKQP +P C HQGFGTCVK VTGCV[ YCU UKIPGF GPCDNKPI VTCFG RC[OGPV QH CPPWCN 4QOCP OQPG[U CPF CNUQ FGRNQ[OGPV QH 6GTXKPIK VTQQRU KP 4QOCP UGTXKEG 6JWU VJG 6GTXKPIK GPEQWPVGTGF EJTKUVKCPKV[ 7NHKNC 9JGP #VJCPCTKE HQWIJV VJG 4QOCPU CPF RTQXGF PQ OCVEJ HQT VJG *WPU VJG OCLQTKV[ QH 6GTXKPIK FGUKTGF VQ DG KPEQTRQTCVGF KP VJG 4QOCP 'ORKTG 6JG 4QOCPU FKFPʼnV CEEQORNKUJ UQNXKPI VJGKT RTQDNGOU OKNKVCTKN[ GURGEKCNN[ CHVGT VJG 4QOCP FGHGCV CV #FTKCPQRGN 6JG TGIKQPU UQWVJ QH VJG &CPWDG /QGUKC CPF &CEKC YGTG TCX CIGF CPF FGRQRWNCVGF *GTG VJG 6GTXKPIK EQWNF NKXG WPFGT VJGKT QYP NCY 6JKU YCU VJG VKOG QH VJG TGKIP QH #NCTKE + HTQO VJG *QWUG $CNVK 5GGMKPI OQTG HCXQWTCDNG EQPFKVKQPU VJG 8KUKIQVJU YCPFGTGF VJG 'CUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG WPVKN KP VJG[ TGCEJGF VJG 9GUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG 1P VJG VJ QH #WIWUV VJG[ EQPSWGTGF 4QOG #NCTKEʼnU RNCP VQ CTTCPIG C VTGCV[ HCKNGF CU VJGTG YGTG VQQ OCP[ EQPHNKEVKPI KPVGTGUVU *KU UWEEGUUQT #VJCWNH YJQ JCF NGF VJG 8KUKIQVJU VQ )CWN KP YJKEJ VJG 8CPFCNU JCF RCUUGF VJTQWIJ KP CPF YGFFGF )CNNC 2NCEKFKC KP UVGRUKUVGT QH 'ORGTQT *QPQTKWU UVTQXG VQYCTF C 4QOCP )QVJKE EQNNCDQTCVKQP DWV FKFPʼnV CEEQORNKUJ KV +P C PGY GRKUQFG DGICP 6JG HQWPFCVKQP QH VJG -KPIFQO QH 6QWNQWUG D[ VJG 8KUKIQVJU YKVJ 4QOG EQPUGPVKPI JGTCNFGF VJG FGENKPG QH VJG 9GUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG &WTKPI VJG TGKIPU QH 6JGQFGTKE + CPF 6JGQFGTKE ++ VJG PQVKQP QH VJG )QVJKE 4QOCP 5VCVG YCU DQTP #KFGF D[ 6JGQFGTKE ++ #XKVWU DGECOG 'ORGTQT -KPI 'WTKE QRGPN[ RTCEVKEGF GZRCPUKQPCN RQNKVKEU

FWG VQ C FKUKPVGITCVKPI 9GUV 4QOCP 'ORKTG +P VJG -KPIFQO 6QWNQWUG GPEQORCUUGF OCLQT RCTVU QH 5RCKP YKVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH VJG 5WGXK CPF VJG $CUM CPF %CPVCDTKC VGTTKVQTKGU QH )CWN HTQO VJG #VNCPVKE VQ VJG .QKTG CPF 4JÊPG CPF HTQO VJG 2TQXGPEG CU YGNN #NVJQWIJ VJG[ RQUUGUUGF C PCVKXG NCPIWCIG CPF TGNKIKQP VJG 8KUKIQVJU YGTG UQQP KPHNWGPEGF D[ 4QOCP EWNVWTG %QFGZ 'WTKEKCPWU #NCTKE ++ VTKGF VQ EQPUQNKFCVG JKU CPPGZCVKQP QH VJG ECVJQNKE EJWTEJ %QWPEKN QH #IFG KP DWV JG YCU FGHGCVGF D[ VJG $WTIWPFKCPU CPF VJG (TCPMU WPFGT %NQXKU KP VJG $CVVNG QH 8QWKNN¾ 8QWKNN¾ KU LWUV PQTVJYGUV QH 2QKVKGTU 6JG 8KUKIQVJU YGTG FTKXGP DCEM QPVQ C UOCNN UVTGVEJ QH NCPF CNQPI VJG /GFKVGTTCPGCP CTQWPF 0CTDQPPG 6JGP VJG 6QNQUCP -KPIFQO 6QWNQWUG ICXG YC[ VQ VJG 6QNGFCP -KPIFQO 6QNGFQ YJKEJ OGCPV VJG NQUU QH VJG )CWN VGTTKVQTKGU YKVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH 5GRVKOCPKC 6JG VTCPUKVKQP YCU EQORNGVGF D[ #NCTKE ++ YCU MKNNGF KP VJG $CVVNG QH 8QWKNN¾ *KU UQP #OCNCTKE YCU VQQ [QWPI CPF JKU QNFGT UVGRDTQVJGT )GUCNGE YCU GZENWFGF HTQO UWEEGUUKQP 5WDUGSWGPVN[ 6JGQFGTKE KP JG DG ECOG MKPI QH VJG 'CUV )QVJU DGECOG MKPI QH VJG 8KUKIQVJU *KU FGUKIPCVGF UWEEGUUQT JKU UQP KP NCY 'KVJCTKE JQYGXGT FKGF DGHQTG JG FKF 9JGP 6JGQFGTKE FKGF KP JKU ITCPFUQP #OCNCTKE NCUV QH VJG $CNVK CUEGPFGF VJG )QVJKE VJTQPG #OCNCTKE CUUCUUKPCVGF KP UQWIJV VKGU VQ VJG (TCPMU CPF YGFFGF %NQXKUʼn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ʼnU KPHNWGPEG QP MKPIJQQF ITGY %NGTKECN CPF YQTNFN[ RQYGTU DGECOG OQTG CPF OQTG KPVGTNCEGF YKVJ GCEJQVJGT GPVCPINKPI VJG EJWTEJ KP RQNKVKECN OCEJKPCVKQPU +P VJG PF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG UVTWIING HQT RQYGT ICKPGF XGJGOGPEG +P #TCDKE KPXCUKQPCN KPVGPVKQPU TGXGCNGF VJGOUGNXGU CPF QP TF ,WN[ VJG 8KUKIQVJU UWHHGTGF C FGHGCV CV )WCFCNGVG CICKPUV C OQFGUV PWODGTGF CTOGF HQTEG NGF D[ 6CTKS -KPI 4QFGTKE FKGF KP DCVVNG 6JG #TCDU JCF EQPSWGTGF VJG YJQNG QH VJG 8KUKIQVJ TGCNO D[ 6JG CTKUVQETCVU HNGF VQ )CNKEKC VJG PQTVJYGUV RCTV QH 5RCKP VJCV YQWNF PGXGT DG EQPSWGTGF D[ VJG #TCDU CPF YQWNF NCVGT ETCFNG VJG 4GEQPSWKUVC 51


+P VJG PCOG QH *1014+75

130

129

2:1

2:1

2:1

2:1

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 *1014+ 85 2( #8% 4 8KEVQT[ T YKVJ RCNO NGCH ETQUU CPF ETQUKGT 4 8 KP HKGNF 8+%614+ #8%856148/ KP GZGTIWG %1/. /'% IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG

-Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM (TQO NKUV PQ )TKGTUQP NGVVGT VJKPMU ETQUU CPF ETQUKGT KPFGGF FGUKIPCVG UQOGVJKPI DWV RTQXKFGU PQ KPHQTOCVKQP CU VQ YJCV

+P VJG PCOG QH 5'8'475 +++

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 5'8'4 85 2( #8% 4 8KEVQT[ N YKVJ NQPI LGYGNNGF ETQUU 8+%6 #8%%% KP GZGTIWG %1/1$. /'% IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG TGXGTUG DGCTU ITGCV TGUGODNCPEG VQ VJG VTGOKUUG KP 8CNGPVKPKCPWU +++ʼnU PCOG UGG /'%

131

132

24' 8+5+)16*5

6TGOKUUKU. # *GCF T YKVJ ETQUU QP ENQCM &0 #+6+++ #522#8+% 4 8KEVQT[ T 8+%61+8+8610#8+ KP GZGTIWG %101$. /'% EH IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

#/#.#4+%

6TGOKUUKU. # $WUV T &0 #0#56# 5+85 22 #8) 4 8KEVQT[ T 8+%614+# #8)856148+ KP DQVVQO HKGNF %1*1$. /'% IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG

#WMVKQPGU $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ #HQTGOGPVKQPGF HQWT EQKPU CTG CNN KP VJG PCOG QH 4QOCP GORGTQTU YKVJ PQ TGHGTGPEG VQ 8KUKIQVJ MKPIU +V CRRGCTU VJCV VJGUG EQKPU YGTG OCPWHCEVWTGF KP VJG 6QNQUCP 4GCNO 6JG HQNNQYKPI RKGEGU EQPUGSWGPVN[ CTG 6QNGFCP HCDTKEU 6JG FKXKFKPI NKPG NKGU UQOGYJGTG CTQWPF

9+66'4+%

133

6TGOKUUKU 5GXKNNC. # (CEKPI DWUV 88+66'4+%85 4' 4 (CEKPI DWUV 2+85 ++2#.+. /'% /KNGU F IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

52


5+5'$76

134

6TGOKUUKU 5GXKNNC. # (CEKPI DWUV 5+5'$86854' 4 (CEKPI DWUV +52#.+ 2+85. /'% /KNGU E IT. 5OCNN RTGUUWTG RQKPV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

57+06*+.#

135

6TGOKUUKU /¾TKFC. # (CEKPI DWUV 58+06*+.#4': 4 (CEKPI DWUV '/'4+6# 2+85. /'% /KNGU C IT. 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

%*+06+..#

136

6TGOKUUKU 5GXKNNC. # (CEKPI DWUV UVCT KP HKGNF T %*+ Q 06+. Q #(' 4 (CEKPI DWUV +52#. +2+ Q 85. /'% /KNGU D IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG

#010;/175 (QT VJG DTQP\G EQKPCIG QH VJG 8KUKIQVJU EH %TWUCHQPV K 5CDCVGT / 'N UKUVGOC OQPGVCTKQ XKUKIQFQ %QDTQ [ QTQ $CTEGNQPC

137 2:1

2:1

2:1

138

2:1

$TQP\G 5GXKNNC EC . # %TQUU QP UVGR 4 5 2 KP HKGNF. /'% %TWUCHQPV )TWRQ # 6KRQ IT. 8GT[ HKPG

.CP\ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

0WOOWU 5GXKNNC. # (CEKPI DWUV 4 .CVKP ETQUU DGVYGGP u 2. NKICVWTGF . /'% %TWUCHQPV )TWRQ $ 6KRQ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

53


.1/$#4&5 6JG .QODCTFU NKXGF D[ VJG $CNVKE 5GC KP VJG UJCFQY QH VJG 8CPFCNU 6JG[ OKITCVGF VQ VJG TGIKQP CTQWPF VJG NQYGT EQWTUG QH VJG 'NDG CPF VJG .Ã’PGDWTI *GCVJ #V VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG[ JCF CTTKXGF KP .QYGT #WUVTKC WPFGT -KPI #IKNOWPF HTQO VJG *QWUG )WIKPIK 6JG[ JCF D[ VJGP GXQNXGF HTQO C RGQRNG QH RGCUCPVU KPVQ QPG QH EQPSWGTGTU 7PFGT 6CVQ VJG[ OKITCVGF VQ C RNCKP GCUV QH 8KGPPC RQUUKDN[ VJG[ YGTG VTKDWVCTKGU VQ VJG *GTWNK +P 6CVQ FGHGCVGF VJG *GTWNK CPF VJGKT MKPI 4QFWNRJ *KU UWEEGUUQT JKU EQWUKP 9CEJQ YGFFGF VJTGG VKOGU CNN OCTTKCIGU RQNKVKECNN[ OQVKXCVGF *KU OQUV KPHNWGPVKCN OQXG JQYGXGT YCU YGFFKPI JKU FCWIJVGT 9KUKICTFC VQ VJG /GTQXKCP -KPI 6JGWFGDGTV KP 9CEJQ JCF VJWU GPUWTGF UQWPF VKGU CNN CTQWPF JKO CPF YCU CDNG VQ ETGCVG C NCTIG MKPIFQO HQTOKPI PGZV VQ $[\CPVKWO CPF VJG (TCPM 'ORKTG VJG VJKTF RQYGT KP 'WTQRG #TQWPF #WFQKP RTQENCKOGF JKOUGNH MKPI )TGCV EQPHWUKQP GPUWGF YKVJ VJG $[\CPVKPGU

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

6JG .QODCTFU VJGP HCKNGF VQ CRRQKPV C PGY MKPI CPF CP KPVGTTGIPWO HQNNQYGF WPVKN 6JG .QODCTFU FKFPʼnV TGUVTKEV VJGKT TCKFU VQ +VCN[ DWV YGPV RKNNCIKPI KP VJG 2TQXGPEG VQQ ;GV VJG PGGF HQT QPG NGCFGT ITGY CPF KP #WVJCTK VJG UQP QH %NGRJ YCU GNGEVGF MKPI *G TGUJCRGF VJG .QODCTFU HTQO C NQQUG DCPF QH QWVNCYU KPVQ C PCVKQP +P JG FKGF CU VJG HKTUV UVCVGUOCP QH +VCN[ #WVJCTK JCF DGGP OCTTKGF VQ VJG .GVJKPIKCP 6JGQFGNKPFC 6JGKT OCTTKCIG GPFGF EJKNFNGUU #HVGT #WVJCTKʼn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ʼnU FCWIJVGT CPF JGT JWUDCPF )QFGU ENCE DWV CHVGT VJG FGOKUG QH 'ORGTQT /CWTKEG 6KDGTKWU KP $[\CPVKWO UJGFFGF CNN JQRG QH GXGT YKPPKPI +VCN[ DCEM 6JGQFGNKPFC YCU ECVJQNKE CPF VJG .QODCTFU YGTG JGCVJGPU CPF #TKCPU $WV ITCFWCNN[ VJTQWIJ GHHQTVU QP VJG SWGGPʼn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ʼnU YKFQY 6JG NCVVGT YCU ECVJQNKE VJKU RTQOQVGF VJG NCVG 6JGQFGNKPFCʼnU TGNKIKQP 4QVJCTKʼn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


C TGNCVKXGN[ NCTIG TGCNO *KU UQP CPF UWEEGUUQT )CTKDCNF EQWNF CUUGTV JKU RQUKVKQP HQT C OGTG HGY YGGMU 2GTEVCTKV TGVWTPGF CPF CUEGPFGF VJG VJTQPG *G TGCEJGF C UGVVNGOGPV YKVJ 4QOWCNF QH $GPGXGPVWO UQP QH )TKOQCNF #U C EQPUGSWGPEG 4QOWCNF UGPV 2GTEVCTKVʼnU YKHG 4QFGNKPFC CPF VJGKT UQP %WPKRGTV DCEM VQ 2CXKC 2GTEVCTKVʼnU OCKP CKO RTQOQVKPI VJG 4QOCP %CVJQNKE %JWTEJ +P %WPKRGTV DGECOG CUUQEKCVG MKPI 6TQWDNGU CTQUG KP VJG PQTVJ *KU #IKNQNHKPI MKPUOGP ECOG VQ 2GTEVCTKVʼn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ʼn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ʼnU DGECOG FWMG 6JG NCVVGT VJGP XCPSWKUJGF )QFGUECNE CPF OCFG )KUWNH FWMG .KWVRTCPF QPEG CICKP JGNF HWNN RQYGT UCY JKU FGOKUG JG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ *KNFGRTCPF YJQ TWNGF QPN[ C HGY OQPVJU CPF YCU KP VWTP UWEEGGFGF D[ 4CVEJKU FWMG QH (TKCWN *G RCTVKEWNCTN[ GPFGCXQWTGF VQ JGNR VJG RQQT +P JG CUUWOGF VJG 2TKPEGRU VKVNG KPUVGCF QH VJG 4GZ )GPVKU .CPIQDCTFQTWO 9JGP KP JG TGVTGCVGF HTQO 2GTWIKC QH JKU QYP HTGG YKNN WPFGT RCRCN RTGUUWTG TGCNN[ KV YCU TGICTFGF VTGCUQP CPF JKU DTQVJGT #KUVWNH TQUG VQ RQYGT *G OCPCIGF VQ WPKVG VJG EQWPVT[ WPFGT JKU CWVJQTKV[ YJKEJ ICXG JKO ITGCV RQYGT GZEGGFKPI VJCV QH )TKOQCNF CPF .KWVRTCPF 1P VJG VJ ,CPWCT[ 2KRRKP VJG ;QWPIGT KP TGVWTP HQT JKU TGEQPUGETCVKQP CU (TCPMKUJ MKPI CITGGF YKVJ 2QRG 5VGRJCP ++ VQ KPVGTXGPG KP +VCN[ +P VJG UCOG [GCT #KUVWNH NQUV VQ 2KRRKP CPF JCF VQ TGEQIPKUG (TCPMKUJ UW\GTCKPV[ +P JG FKGF .CUV QH VJG MKPIU YCU &GUKFGTKWU HTQO $TGUEKC *G QPEG CICKP TGUVQTGF .QODCTF RQYGT KP 5QWVJ CPF %GPVTCN +VCN[ DWV VJGP YCU DGUGV D[ ECVCUVTQRJG QP VJG QPG JCPF %CTNQOCP FKGF KP NGCXKPI VJG VJTQPG VQ %JCTNGOCIPG CPF QP VJG QVJGT JCPF JKU CNN[ 2QRG 5VGRJCP +++ FKGF KP +P %JCTNGOCIPG JCXKPI FKURQUGF QH JKU .QODCTF YKHG C FCWIJVGT QH &GUKFGTKWU OCTEJGF HQT +VCN[ UWDUVCPVKCVKPI JKU RTGUVKIG CU RTQVGEVQT QH VJG *QN[ 5GG +P JG EQP SWGTGF 2CXKC CPF JCF &GUKFGTKWU CPF JKU YKHG #PUC FGRQTVGF KPVQ VJG (TCPMKUJ 'ORKTG (TQO VJGP QP %JCTNGOCIPG YCU )TCVKC &GK 4GZ (TCPEQTWO GV .CPIQDCTFQTWO %QKPCIG KU WUWCNN[ ENCUUKHKGF KP VJTGG UGEVKQPU .QODCTF[ 6WUECP[ VJCV YCU WPKVGF YKVJ .QODCTF[ KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF $GPGXGPVWO %QKPCIG UVCTVGF YKVJ C RUGWFQ KORGTKCN OKPV KPI CU YGNN KP .QODCTF[ CU KP 6WUECP[ 6JG CVVTKDWVKQPU VQ EGTVCKP MKPIU KP VJKU RGTKQF CTG JKIJN[ GSWKXQECN 9KVJ %WPKRGTV VJG 4GICN EQKPCIG RGTKQF EQOOGPEGF GPFKPI YKVJ &GUKFGTKWU KP

+P &GEGODGT QH $GNKUCTKWU VQQM 4CXGPPC CPF HTQO ,WUVKPKCP OKPVGF KP 4CXGPPC 6JG HQNNQYKPI TGXGTUGU OC[ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF QP ,WUVKPKCPʼnU UKNXGT EQKPU EQPVKPWGF D[ ,WUVKP ++

+P O[ QRKPKQP CNN QH VJGUG UQOGJQY EQOOOGOQTCVG VJG KPCWIWTCVKQP QH GKVJGT VJG 5V 8KVCNG

QT VJG 5V #RQNNKPCTG KP %NCUUG /CZKOKPKCPWU YCU VJGP DKUJQR QH 4CXGPPC 6JG EJTKUVQITCO QP PQ KU CNUQ UGGP QP VJG UJKGNF QH VJG HCOQWU 4CXGPPC /QUCKE QH ,WUVKPKCP 0QTFUVTÌO 4CXGPPCUVWFKGP R PQVGU 6Q VJG HCT NGHV UVCPFU VJG KORGTKCN IWCTF YKVJ UJKGNF CPF NCPEG 6JG HTQPV UJKGNF DGCTU VJG OQPQITCO QH EJTKUV KV CRRCTGPVN[ KU CP KORG TKCN RCTCFG UJKGNF VJKU OQUCKE RTGUWOCDN[ HGCVWTGU $GNKUCTKWU CU YGNN 6JG ETQUU YKVJ VJG 2 CV KVU VQR KU JCTFGT VQ FGVGTOKPG JQYGXGT CV 5V 8KVCNG C OQUCKE FQGU GZKUV VJCV FGRKEVU VJG DKUJQR JQNFKPI VJG EJWTEJ ETQYPGF YKVJ C ETQUU YKVJ VJG UKOKNCTN[ UJCRGF CTOU 55


(QNNQYGT QH ,756+0+#075 +

2:1

139

2:1

5KNKSWC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 68 +8 88 ++ 4 %TQUU YKVJ 2 QP VQR CPF QPG UVGR DGNQY DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU KP NCWTGN YTGCVJ. IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5VGTPDGTI <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP UVGOU HTQO C (TGPEJ JQCTF VJCV CRRGCTU VQ JCXG DGGP KP VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH VJG HKTO 4QNNKP CPF (GWGTFCPV KP 2CTKU CHVGT VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ +P VJG ECV 5VGTPDGTI VJG HQNNQYKPI CEEQWPV ECP DG HQWPF #NU FKG .CPIQDCTFGP KPU TÌOKUEJ D[\CPVKPKUEJG 4GKEJ GKPFTKPIGP ÒDGTN·UUV KJPGP FGT -CKUGT 2CPPQPKGP HKPFGP UKG FQTV *CND WPF 8KGTVGNUKNKSWGP XQT $GKFG JCDGP CNU $KNF FCU MTGW\HÌTOKIG %JTKUVWUOQPQITCOO FKG *CNDUKNKSWGP FC\W \YGK 5VGTPG ,WUVKPKCPWU + /+$ WPF &KGUG /ÒP\GP JCNVGP UKEJ FKG 6TGWG \KGJV FCU 8QNM FGT .CPIQDCTFGP PCEJ +VCNKGP )GPCW \W FGO <GKVRWPMV N·UUV ,WUVKPWU ++ KP 4CXGPPC YKGFGT /ÒP\GP XQP FKGUGO 6[R WPF )GYKEJV RT·IGP QDYQJN ,WUVKPKCPWU + \YKUEJGP \GKVNKEJ CPFGTG 6[RGP GKPIGHÒJTV JCVVG /+$ WPF 'U UKGJV UQ CWU CNU UGKGP FKGUG /ÒP\GP HÒT FGP 8GTMGJT OKV FGP .CPIQDCTFGP IGRT·IV 9GPKI UR·VGT DGIKPPGP FKGUG UGNDUV /ÒP\GP FKGUGT #TV \W RT·IGP +JPGP HQNIGP FKG (TCPMGP FKG KP NCPIQDCTFKUEJGU )GDKGV GKPIGFTWPIGP YCTGP &KG HT·PMKUEJGP 2T·IWPIGP UKPF UGNVGP /CP MGPPV GKPKIG CWU )TCDHWPFGP ITÌUUGTG (WPFG UEJGKPGP PKEJV RWDNK\KGTV 5VGTPDGTI CVVTKDWVGU VJKU EQKP VQ VJG $WTIWPFKCPU EQORCTKPI KV VQ VJG VTGOKUUGU $ 8KGPPG CPF $ 8CNGPEG 6JKU UGGOU UQOGYJCV HCPEKHWN # EQKP YKVJ C UKOKNCT GHHKI[ KU HQWPF KP VJG 5WDLCEM EQNNGEVKQP 8GEEJK #WEVKQP PQ YJGTG KV YCU CV VTKDWVGF VQ VJG )GRKFU +P ECV QH /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP C PGCTN[ KFGPVKECN EQKP KU FGUETKDGF WPFGT PQ NQYGT RCTV QH VJG ETQUU FKHHGTU UNKIJVN[ 6JKU ECVCNQIWG ENCUUKHKGU KV WPFGT VJG .QODCTFU 5EJWNVG DGNKGXGU VJG UWRGTKQT URGEKOGPU UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG .QODCTFU UKPEG .QODCTF[ RTQFWEGF PWOGTQWU HKPFU YJGTGCU VJG QTKIKPU QH VJG UQOG YJCV WPEWNVKXCVGF EQKPU UJQWNF DG UQWIJV GNUGYJGTG VGN 5EJWNVG *GTG KV KU ENCUUKHKGF YKVJ VJG .QODCTFU

#)+.7.(

140

6TGOKUUKU NCTIG HNCP. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T +D228+ 4 8KEVQT[ UVCPFKPI YKVJ YTGCVJ CPF ETQUU 8/61:+#+8+8+618+ KP GZGTIWG %101. $GTP C /'% IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -Ì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

2'4%6#4+6 6JG JCNH UKNKSWCU DGCT VJG NGVVGTU 2'4 VJCV QH EQWTUG TGHGT VQ 2GTEVCTKV 6JKU KU NGUU EGTVCKP KP VJG ECUG QH VJG VTGOKUUG CNVJQWIJ VJG DWUV QP PQ TGXGCNU VJG UCOG UV[NG CU VJCV QP $CUGF QP VJKU + HCXQWT CVVTKDWVKQP VQ 2GTEVCTKV

141

2:1

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

56


5KNKSWC. # $WUV T 4 /QPQITCO 2' 4 VJTGG RGNNGVU N VJTGG KP VJG OKFFNG DGHQTG ' CPF HKXG T

VJTGG QH VJGO DGHQTG VJG 4 . $GTP /'% XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG

-WPUV WPF /Ã’P\GP .WICPQ

5KNKSWC. # $WUV T 4 /QPQITCO 2' 4 VYQ RGNNGVU N QPG RGNNGV WPFGT VJG 4. $GTP /'% XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG

-WPUV WPF /Ã’P\GP .WICPQ

#4+2'46 ++

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T YKVJ * KP HKGNF &0 #4+2'4: 4 5V /KEJCGN UVCPFKPI N YKVJ NQPI UVCHH GPFKPI KP VJTGG RGNNGVU 5%5 /+*#*+.. $GTP /'% XCT IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JG OGCPKPI QH VJG NGVVGTU KP VJG HKGNF TGOCKPU WPMPQYP 6JG[ PGKVJGT TGHGT VQ C OQPG[GT QT C FKG EWVVGT DQVJ DGKPI VQQ KPUKIPKHKECPV CV VJG VKOG CU VQ DG CNNQYGF KPENWFKPI VJGKT KPKVKCNU QP EQKPU PQT FQ VJG[ KPFKECVG CP[ OKPV CU NGVVGTU HGCVWTG VJCV KORNKECVG PQ RNCEGU MPQYP QH #NVGTPCVKXGN[ VJG[ EQWNF DG VJG KPKVKCNU QH FWMGU YJQ YGTG GPVTWUVGF D[ VJG MKPI YKVJ VJG VCUM QH OKPVKPI NQECNN[ CU YCU CNNQYGF D[ 4QVJCTKʼnU 'FKEV EJ $WV VJGTG CTG PQV GPQWIJ NGVVGTU CPF NKICVWTGU XKU ¯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

6TGOKUUKU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF &0 #4 +2%+2: 4 4 5V /KEJCGN UVCPFKPI N YKVJ NQPI UVCHH GPFKPI KP VJTGG RGNNGVU 5%5 /+*#*+.. $GTP /'% XCT IT. )QQF XGT[ HKPG

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

YJKEJ CNUQ RTQDCDN[ EGNGDTCVGF JKU XKEVQTKQWU DCVVNG CU YGNN CU VJG CEEGUUKQP VQ VJG VJTQPG QH #TKRGTV ++ CPF .KWV RTCPF

57


.+7624#0&

6TGOKUUG. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T YKVJ 5 KP HKGNF &0 .8 +2404: 4 5V /KEJCGN UVCPFKPI N YKVJ NQPI UVCHH GPFKPI KP VJTGG RGNNGVU 5%5 /*#*+.. $GTP /'% XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

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ʼnU [QWPIGT DTQVJGT DGECOG RTKPEG QH 5CNGTPQ HQT 5CNGTPQ UGG +VCN[ 4CFGNEJKU JCF VQ UVCPF JKU ITQWPF D[ HKIJVKPI QHH OCP[ C PGKIJDQWT DWV CNUQ HCEGF VJG CFXCPEKPI #TCDU +P .QWKU ++ ECOG VQ JKU CKF 6JG NCVVGT VJGP ENCKOGF UQXGTGKIPV[ CPF VQQM VJG OKPV *G OKPVGF KP JKU QYP PCOG KP VJCV QH 'ORTGUU #PIKNDGTIC CPF UQOGVKOGU LQKPVN[ YKVJ #FGNEJKU DTQVJGT QH VJG UQP QH 4CFGNEJKU +P OKPVKPI EGCUGF

#4+%*+ ++

5QNKFWU. # (CEKPI DWUV YKVJ QTD &05 8+ %614+# 4 .CVKP ETQUU QP VJTGG UVGRU YKVJ # KP HKGNF 8+%6+48 24+02+ KP GZGTIWG % 101 $. /'% IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 4CVVQ /CKNCPF +P /'% ENCUU CU 2TKPEGRU

58


)4+/1#.& +++

6TGOKUUKU. # (CEKPI DWUV YKVJ QTD )4+/ 8#.& 4 .CVKP ETQUU QP UVGR ) 4 KP HKGNF 8+6148 24+0%+2 KP GZGTIWG %101$. /'% IT. 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ )TKOQCNF +++ YCU VJG HKTUV VQ UVTKMG JKU QYP PCOG QP EQKPU 6JG NGVVGTU KP VJG HKGNF TGHGT VQ JKU RTGFGEGUUQTU *GTG VJG[ CTG ) HQT )KUWNH + CPF # HQT #WFGNCKU DQVJ FWMGU HTQO .QODCTF VKOGU #EEQTFKPI VQ /'% ENCUU 4GX ETQUU QP INQDWNG CPF UVGRU QT QP INQDWNG CPF DCUG %NCUU UJQYU PQ INQDWNG CV VJG DCUG QH VJG ETQUU ENCUU FQGU 6JG EQKP CV JCPF FKURNC[U UWEJ C INQDWNG

#&'.%*+5

&GPKGT. # %CTQNKPIKCP VGORNG #&'.%*5 24+0 4 %TQUU QP UVGRU 5 % # /#4+#. /'% IT 8GT[ HKPG 4CVVQ /CKNCPF #FGNEJK RTKPEKRG UV RGTKQF K G #FGNEJKU CNQPG

.17+5 ++ CPF #0)+.$'4)#

&GPKGT. # %TQUU QP UVGRU .8&188+%85 +02 4 6YQ ETQUUGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT #0)+.$'4)# 02. /'% IT. #VVTCEVKXG HKPG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG

(4#0-5 (4+5+#

5KNKSWC. # $CTDCTK\GF DWUV N YKVJ \KI\CI NKPG KP HTQPV 4 %JTKUVQITCO YKVJ QPG RGNNGV DGNQY CPF DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU. IT. 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ CVVTCEVKXG VQPG

)QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ # V[RG VJCV KU JCTF VQ VTCEG +V KU TGEQTFGF CU QTKIKPCVKPI HTQO VJG .QYGT 4JKPG VGTTKVQT[ YJKEJ YQWNF FCVG KV DCEM VQ CRRTQZ *QYGXGT UKNXGT EQKPU FKF PQV [GV GZKUV KP VJG (TCPM 4GCNO VQ VJCV VKOG NGV CNQPG JCNHU 6JKU XCTKGV[ CPF KVU JCNXGU EKTEWNCVGF QPN[ KP VJG $[\CPVKPG 'ORKTG CPF KP KVU FKTGEV RTQZKOKV[ UGG COQPI QVJGTU PQ 6JG HQTMGF ETQUU KU WPMPQYP QH VJGTG JQYGXGT +P VJG JQCTF VJCV EQPVCKPGF PQ QPG QH VJG EQKPU UJQYGF C HQTMGF ETQUU ECV 5VGTPDGTI PQ FGUETKDGF VJGTG CU (TCPMKUJ EQKPCIG .QYGT 4JKPG 6YQ RCTCNNGNU ECP DG QDUGTXGF VJG ETQUU HQWTEJ¾G CNUQ CRRGCTU QP VJG GCTNKGUV UEGCVVCU VJGUG FCVG DCEM VQ CTQWPF #PF C UKOKNCT \KI\CI NKPG KU CNUQ UGGP QP VJG QDXGTUG QH VJG UQ ECNNGF &TQPTKLR V[RG YJKEJ JQYGXGT KU FCVGF CTQWPF (TKUKC EQWNF CNUQ DG EQPUKFGTGF DWV V[RGU QH UWEJ FGNKECE[ CTG CV[RKECN HQT VJG TGIKQP 5VKNN VJG 4JKPG /GWUG 5EJGNFV DCUKP UGGOU VJG OQUV NKMGN[ RNCEG QH QTKIKP

59


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¾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

KP 5QKUUQPU +V YCU JQYGXGT PQ TGCN FKXKUKQP CU NCVGT YKVJ VJG %CTQNKPIKCPU VJG DTQVJGTU OCKPVCKPGF EQNNCDQTCVKQPU CPF KV KU VJGTGHQTG JKUVQTKECNN[ CEEWTCVG VQ TGHGT VQ VJG /GTQXKPIKCP 4GCNO &WTKPI VJKU FKXKUKQP VJG .GZ 5CNKEC VJG UVKRWNCVKQP QH C PWODGT QH (TCPMKUJ TGIWNCVKQPU VJCV UVCVGF VJCV CV VJG FKXKUKQP QH CP GUVCVG CV VJG FGOKUG QH C HCVJGT GCEJ UQP KU GPVKVNGF VQ CP GSWCN UJCTG YCU HTGSWGPVN[ CRRGCNGF VQ 9QQF -KPIU -KPIFQOU CPF %QPUGPV KP 'CTN[ /GFKGXCN -KPIUJKR .GGFU R FQWDVU VJKU +P JKU XKGY VJGTG YCU C EQORTQOKUG KP DG VYGGP QP VJG QPG JCPF 6JGWFGTKEJ CPF QP VJG QVJGT %JNQVKNFG CPF JGT VJTGG UQPU KP YJKEJ %JNQVKNFG YCU EQWPUGNNGF D[ GZRGTVU VJG DKUJQRU &WTKPI VJG VGTTKVQTKCN FKXKUKQP QH %NQXKUʼn FQOKPKQP VJG QNF 4QOCP EKXKVCVGU CPF VJGKT DQWPFCTKGU YGTG CFJGTGF VQ KP VJG[ YGTG GRKUEQRCN UGGU 6JG UQPU EQPSWGTGF VJG YJQNG QH )CWN KP VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO CPF KP VJG 2TQXGPEG 6JGWFGDGTV UQP QH 6JGWFGTKE EQPSWGTGF RCTV QH 0QTVJ +VCN[ WR VQ 8GPKEG YJKNG VJG MKPI QH 4GKOU KP QEEWRKGF VJG 6JÒTKPIKCP TGCNO $[ VJGP VJG (TCPMKUJ TGCNO GPEQORCUUGF (TCPEKC CPF NCTIG RCTVU QH )GTOCP[ CU HCT CU VJG 'NDG CPF VJG &CPWDG $G ECWUG %JNQFGOGT 6JGWFGTKEʼnU ITCPFUQP CPF %JKNFGDGTV JCF FKGF %JNQVCKTG YCU MKPI QH VJG GPVKTG FQOKPKQP HTQO VQ JKU FGCVJ KP 7PNKMG VJG UKVWCVKQP CV %NQXKUʼn FGOKUG EKXKN YCT DTQMG QWV DGVYGGP 4GKOU CPF 5QKUUQPU CV %JNQVCKTGʼnU FGCVJ 6JG VKOG QH VJG HQWT UQPU QH %JNQVCTKWU %JNQVCTKWU + VQQ NGHV HQWT UQPU VJTGG D[ JKU YKHG +PIWPF CPF QPG D[ JGT UKUVGT #TPGIWPF +P RTKPEKRNG VJG FKXKUKQP QH YCU MGRV %JCTKDGTV 2CTKU %JKNRGTKE 5QKUUQPU )WPVJTCO 1TN¾CPU CPF 5KIKDGTV + 4GKOU %JKNRGTKE EJCPIGF VJG PCOG 5QKUUQPU VQ 0GWUVTKC #SWKVCKPG YCU FKXKFGF COQPI CNN HQWT ITCPVKPI KV OQTG HTGGFQO KVU PQDKNKV[ UGK\KPI VJG QRRQTVWPKV[ VQ TKUG VQ ITGCVGT CWVQPQO[ 6JG DQWPFCTKGU QH VJG VGTTKVQTKGU JCF VQ DG UGV CPGY VJTGG GXGPVWCNN[ YGTG EQORCTCDNG DWV VJG HQWTVJ %JKNRGTKEʼnU UQP QH #TPGIWPF YCU UWDUVCPVKCNN[ NGUU UKIPKHKECPV 6JWU %JKNRGTKE KPXCFGF VJG VGTTKVQT[ QH 5KIKDGTV DWV YCU TGRGNNGF 0GY EQPHNKEVU CTQUG YJGP %JCTKDGTV + 2CTKU FKGF 6JG VJTGG TGOCKPKPI DTQVJGTU CVVGORVGF C OQUV KPVTKECVG FKXKFKPI U[UVGO HQT VJG GUVCVG 6JKU NGF VQ PGY EQPHNKEV DGVYGGP VJG DTQVJGTU KP YJKEJ 5KIKDGTVʼnU YKHG $TWPKEJKNF FCWIJVGT QH C 8KUKIQVJKE MKPI YQWNF RNC[ C OCLQT TQNG 6JG TGCNO QH 4GKOU HTQO VJGP QP YCU ECNNGF #WUVTCUKC CPF VJG UQP QH 5KIKDGTV %JKNFGDGTV GUVCD NKUJGF VJG PGY ECRKVCN KP /GV\ 0QY VJGTG YGTG VJTGG TGCNOU 0GWUVTKC 5QKUUQPU #WUVTCUKC /GV\ CPF $WTIWPF[ YJGTG 6JGWFGTKE ++ OQXGF VJG ECRKVCN HTQO 1TNGCPU VQ %JCNQP UWT 5CÊPG #WUVTCUKC CPF $WTIWPF[ CNNKGF CICKPUV 5QKUUQPU 60


+P #WUVTCUKC KPVGTPCN RTQDNGOU CTQUG CPF VJG #XCTU ITQYKPIN[ RQUGF C VJTGCV $GECWUG OCP[ C MKPI FKGF [QWPI UWEEGUUKQP TGIWNCTN[ RTQXGF RTQDNGOCVKE CU KP VJG ECUG QH 6JGWFGTKE YJQ UWFFGPN[ FKGF CV VJG CIG QH 3WGGP $TWPKEJKNF CRRQKPVGF 6JGWFGTKEʼnU QNFGUV UQP MKPI $WV PQDKNKV[ FKF PQV CEEGRV VJG SWGGPʼn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ʼnU ECRKVCN 'XGP WPFGT &CIQDGTVʼnU TGKIP 5KIKDGTV +++ DGECOG XKEGTQ[ KP #WUVTCUKC CPF %NQXKU ++ DGECOG XKEGTQ[ KP 0GWUVTKC VJG VGTTKVQT[ YCU QPEG CICKP FKXKFGF VYQ YC[U CPF FG ENKPG UQQP UGV KP 6JG VKOG QH VJG OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG OCKQT FQOWU +P VJG OGCPVKOG C XGT[ UKIPKHKECPV VTCPUKVKQP JCF VCMGP RNCEG VJG TKUG QH VJG QHHKEG QH OCKQT FQOWU QT OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG 1TKIKPCNN[ VJG JGCF QH VJG WPHTGG FQOGUVKE UVCHH VJKU KPUVKVW VKQP GXQNXGF KPVQ CP KPHNWGPVKCN HQTEG 6JG RQUKVKQP QH OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG GOGTIGF KP 0GWU VTKC CPF #WUVTCUKC CU YGNN CU KP $WTIWPF[ 6JG CNNGIKCPEG VQ VJG MKPI YCU RTGUGTXGF 6JKU YCU VJG UVCVG QH CHHCKTU CU UGGP KP VJ EGPVWT[ #TQWPF VJKU VKG QH CNNGIKCPEG YCU UGXGTGF 6JG OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG FGVCEJGF JKU QHHKEG QH VJCV QH VJG MKPI CPF VWTPGF VQYCTF PQDKNKV[ 6JG QHHKEG QH OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG UVGCFKN[ ICKPGF KP RQYGT YKVJ C JGTGFKVCT[ CURGEV GXGP VQ KV KP #WUVTCUKC WPNKMG VJG GSWKXCNGPV RQUKVKQPU KP VJG QVJGT VYQ VGTTKVQTKGU +P #WUVTCUKC VYQ F[PCUVKGU FQOKPCVGF VJG #TPWNHKPIU CPF VJG 2KRRKPKFU 6JG #TPWNHKPIU YJQ VQQM VJGKT PCOG HTQO #TPWNH VJG 5CKPV DKUJQR QH /GV\ OCKPN[ JCF RQUUGUUKQPU KP VJG TGIKQP CTQWPF /GV\ CPF 8GTFWP 6JG *QWUG QH VJG 2KRRKPKFU YCU HQWPFGF D[ 2KRRKP VJG 'NFGT VJGKT GUVCVGU UKVWCVGF CTQWPF VJG /GWUG KP VJG #TFGPPGU NCVGT KP 6TKGT 'EJVGTPCEJ CPF UWTTQWPF KPIU $QVJ JCF JGNF RQUKVKQPU CV VJG EQWTV #TPWNH YCU ENGTKECN CFXKUQT CPF 2KRRKP OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG 2KRRKP YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU UQP )TKOQCNF YJQ KP JKU ECRCEKV[ QH OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG JGNF GHHGEVKXG UYC[ VQIGVJGT YKVJ DKUJQR -WPKDGTV QH %QNQIPG 6JKU RTQXQECVKQP YCU FKTGEVGF VQ YCTF 1VVQ GFWECVQT QH 5KIKDGTV +++ )TKOQCNF CVVGORVGF C EQWR DWV HCKNGF /QTG UKI PKHKECPV YCU VJG OCTTKCIG QH 2KRRKPʼn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ʼnU FGOKUG DGHQTG KPUVGCF QH JKU UQP UJG CR RQKPVGF 'DTQKP C TGNCVKXGN[ WPMPQYP RGTUQP *KU CUUWOKPI VJG QHHKEG YQWNF ECWUG C TGXQNW VKQP VJG SWGGPU ņ %JNQVKNFG $TWPKEJKNF CPF $CVJKNFG ņ GZGTVGF FGEKFKPI KPHNWGPEG 'DTQKP PQV QPN[ FGRQUGF VJG MKPI DWV CNUQ GPFGCXQWTGF VQ FKUGORQYGT PQDKNKV[ #HVGT PWOGTQWU CU UCUUKPCVKQPU QP CNN UKFGU 'DTQKP OGV JKU HCVG YJGP JG YCU OWTFGTGF 0GWUVTKC WPFGT JKU UWEEGUUQT 9CTCVVQ VJGP UKIPGF RGCEG YKVJ 2KRRKP GXGP VJQWIJ VJG NCVVGT YCU PQV [GV OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG QH #WUVTCUKC VJWU 9CTCVVQ TGVCKPGF JKU QHHKEG WPVKN JKU FGCVJ KP 6JG UKVWCVKQP ECOG VQ C JGCF C [GCT NCVGT YJGP 2KRRKP ++ KP VJG DCVVNG QH 6GTVT[ FGHGCVGF 9CTCVVQʼnU UWEEGUUQT $GTEJCT $GTEJCT UJQTVN[ TGVCKPGF JKU QHHKEG DWV JG YCU OWTFGTGF KP CPF 2KRRKP WUWTRGF VJG QHHKEG QH OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG KP VJG GPVKTG TGCNO VCMKPI QP VJG VKVNG 2TKPEGRU (TCPEQTWO #HVGT 2KRRKPʼnU FGOKUG CPQVJGT FKXKUKQP VQQM RNCEG 0GWUVTKC FGXQNXGF VQ JKU QYP UQP )TK OQCNF ++ YJQ YCU MKNNGF D[ C (TKUKCP KP VJG .CODGTVWU EJWTEJ KP .K½IG #WUVTCUKC YGPV VQ JKU DCUVCTF UQP %JCTNGU /CTVGN 6JG %CTQNKPIKCP 'TC JCF KP HCEV DGIWP YKVJ VJG OCTTKCIG QH #PUGIKUGN CPF $GIIC DWV TGHGTGPEG VQ VJG %CTQNKPIKCP &[PCUV[ UVCTVU YKVJ KVU HQWPFGT %JCTNGU /CTVGN %JCTNGU /CTVGNʼnU OCKP HGCV YCU VJCV JG CEEQORNKUJGF TGRGNNKPI VJG #TCD KPXCUKQP HQT IQQF KP C UGTKGU QH DCVVNGU KP PGCT 2QKVKGTU #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH 6JGWFGTKE +8 KP %JCTNGU /CTVGN TWNGF YKVJQWV C HCEVWCN MKPI OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG /CTVGNʼnU UQP 2KRRKP +++ YJQO JG 61


JCF CFQRVGF D[ VJG .QODCTF MKPI .KWVRTCPF YCU VJG HKTUV VQ CUEGPF C MKPIʼn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ÊPG PCOGU WR VQ *GTCENKWU YGTG GXGP WUGF

UGG 'PIGN 5GTTWTG R CHVGT VJCV QYP PCOGU YGTG WUGF )QNF VTKGPU UVTWEM KP C XCTKGV[ QH OKPVU QPN[ URGEKH[KPI C RNCEG UQOGVKOGU WPKFGPVKHKCDNG YKVJ RTGUGPV FC[ RNCEGU CPF C OQPG[GT 5WEJ EQKPU CTG HQWPF QH CP CNN DWV GPFNGUU UGTKGU QH OKPVU )TKGTUQP JCU VJKU RTCEVKEG DGIKP KP /'% + R 5KNXGT FGPCTKK #TQWPF IQNF YCU FKUECTFGF CDTWRVN[ CPF UKNXGT FGPCTKK YGTG OKPVGF 6JGUG YQWNF RTGXCKN WPVKN 2KRRKP VJG 5JQTV KPVTQFWEGF JKU EQKPU UGG WPFGT %CTQNKPIKCPU 4QD GTVKPGU 6JG VTCPUKVKQP VQ UKNXGT KP VJG (TCPM 4GCNO VQQM RNCEG C NKVVNG GCTNKGT VJCP VJCV KP #P INQ 5CZQP 'PINCPF 1PN[ EQKPU QH V[RG CPF CTG TGRTGUGPVGF WPFGTPGCVJ

64+'05

#WVWP. /QPG[GT 6GWFWNHQ. # &QWDNG RQTVTCKV T #8)856+&8 01 (+6 4 .CVKP ETQUU EJTKUO¾G DG VYGGP # CPF % 6'8&8.(1 /. $GNHQTV IT. 44 5OCNN GFIG PKEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP #WVWP VQQM KVU PCOG #WIWUVQFWPWP HTQO #WIWUVWU YJQ OCIPKHKEGPVN[ TGEQPUVTWEVGF KV CU C TGRNCEGOGPV HQT $K DTCEVG CU VJG ECRKVCN QH 4QOCP )CWN DWV KP /GTQXKPIKCP VKOGU KV YCU QH OWEJ NGUU CEEQWPV VJCP %JCNQP +VU EQKPCIG KU NCTIGN[ OQFGNNGF QP VJCV QH VJKU EKV[ YKVJ # ) KP VJG HKGNF KPUVGCF QH % # CPF WUWCNN[ C ETQUU EJTKUO¾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

-KPI 5KIGDGTVʼnU YKHG UWRRQTVGF DKUJQR 5[CITKWU KP HQUVGTKPI VJG FGXGNQROGPV QH PWOGTQWU OQPCUVGTKGU KP VJG TGIKQP 6JGTGHQTG VJG UWIIGUVKQP QH KU PQV CNVQIGVJGT KPEQPEGKXCDNG

&QTGUVCF. /QPG[GT /CFGNKPWU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T HKXG RGNNGVU KP VTKCPIWNCT QP ENQCM &14'56#6+(+6 4 %TQUU QP UVGR UKZ RGNNGVU DGNQY /#& Ő '. Ő +085 /. $GNHQTV IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO QP 6JKU KU C &QTGUVCF QTKIKPCN 2QN UKIPCNKUGU URGEKOGPU KP JKU FKUUGTVCVKQP QH YJKEJ CTG KP OWUGWO EQNNGEVKQPU $GNHQTV FGUKIPCVGU VJG RGNNGV CHVGT VJG VJKTF NGVVGT KP VJG TGXGTUG VGZV C RQKPV UGETGV

62


/CCUVTKEJV. /QPG[GT #FGNDGTVWU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T Z 6 4# +'61 (+6 Z 4 %TQUU QP UVGR UKZ RGNNGVU DGNQY #&'.$'4685 /. $GNHQTV IT. 4 (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z &TGGUOCPP EQNNGEVKQP ++ PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ +P $GNHQTV HCNUGN[ NKUVGF WPFGT 7VTGEJV

/CCUVTKEJV. /QPG[GT &QOCTKEWU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T 64+'%68 (+6 4 %TQUU QP INQDWNG &1/#4+%85 /1. $GNHQTV IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

/CKP\ ! . # %KTENG YKVJ RGNNGV ETQUUGU CPF RGNNGVU CTQWPF VJG EKTENG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG. $GNHQTV IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

#WMVKQPGU $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ 7PRWDNKUJGF! 'XGP )TKGTUQP JCU PQ KPMNKPI CU VQ YJCV VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG OGCPU +P ECVCNQIWG QH /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP C UKOKNCT EQKP QEEWTU WPFGT PQ 6JG CEEQORCP[KPI EQOOGPV TGCFU 6TKGPU QH &TQPTKLR JQCTF V[RG 6JKU RKGEG KU OWEJ JGCXKGT 4GHGTGPEGU $GNHQTV HH CPF H RT XCT /'% + ER 9GTPGT ER 6JKU V[RG CPF TGNCVGF RKGEGU WUGF VQ DG ENCKOGF HQT /CKP\ KOOGFKCVGN[ C VJGQT[ VJCV NCEMU RTQQH VJCV VJG[ QTKIKPCVG HTQO VJG TGIKQP QH /CKP\ KU EQPHKTOGF D[ PWOGTQWU KPFGRGPFGPV HKPFU JQYGXGT 9GTPGT , /Ã’P\FCVKGTVG CWUVTCUKUEJG )TCDHWPFG $GTNKP .GKR\KI

3WGPVQXKE. /QPG[GT &WVVC. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T : 88+%%1 4 %TQUU QP UVGRU &866 #/1 0'. $GNHQTV IT. 4 5VTWEM HTQO EQTTQFGF CPF YGCM FKGU QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5COG EQKP CU KP 0WOKUOCVKE %KTEWNCT PQ 6JG QDXGTUG KU C FKG FWRNKECVG QH %TQPFCNN *QCTF (QWPF KP %CPVGTDWT[ #TGC CRRTQZ 5GG $0, %QKP 4GIKUVGT PQ 6GZV TGXGTUG KPVCEV &866# /10'

/QPG[GT #NFKPWU. # $WUV T #.1&+ 01/ 10'6 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UKFGCTOU QP TGEVCPING YKVJ ETQUU KP EGPVTG 88+%85 (+6 . $GNHQTV /'% IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 6JG EQKP OGPVKQPGF KP $GNHQTV KU MGRV KP VJG %CDKPGV FG (TCPEG 'Z 2 F #OGEQWTV EQNNGEVKQP QTKI &CUU[ PQ (QT VJG VGZV $GNHQTV IKXGU #.1&+01 /10+6 88+%85 (+6 6JG KNNWUVTCVKQP KP $GNHQTV UJQYU C FKHHGTGPV VGZV

#.1&+01 /10 $GNHQTV OGPVKQPU VJG OQPG[GT #NQFKPWU +P /'% VJGTG KU CPQVJGT URGEKOGP 6GZV #.2+01 =/10+6? 2 KPXGTVGF CPF / WRUKFG FQYP /QPG[GT KP FKECVGF JGTG KU #NFKPWU 6JG KNNWUVTCVKQP $GNHQTV NKMG VJG QPG KP /'% ENGCTN[ FKHHGT HTQO VJG EQKP CV JCPF + DGNKGXG VJKU EQKP EQPUVKVWVGU C RGTHGEV RTQVQV[RG HQT UWDITQWR QH VJG 8GTPWU UGTKGU 5EGCVVC #PINQ 5CZQP UGG RJQVQ

63


4QFG\. /QPG[GT 4QUQNWU. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUU RCNO YKVJ VJTGG NGCHU CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP HTQPV 4 4QFG\ OQPQITCO 405 486'0+5 +1 )1 /1. $GNHQTV IT. 4 4GXGTUG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ GZRTGUUKXG RQTVTCKV #WMVKQPGU $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 2QPVQP F #OGEQWTV EQNNGEVKQP UJQYP KP $GNHQTV #HVGT VJG %NQXKUʼn XKEVQT[ QXGT VJG 8KUKIQVJU VJG[ TGECRVWTGF VJG TGIKQP UWTTQWPFKPI 4QFG\ 6JGWFGDGTV TGENCKOGF KV RTKQT VQ JKU CEEGUUKQP VQ VJG VJTQPG

4QWGP. /QPG[GT #KIQCNFWU. # $WUV T 4161 /1%+8 4 5OCNN ETQUU KP YTGCVJ #+)1 #.&1/1. $GNHQTV IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG RGTHGEV RKGEG 5RKPM .QPFQP EH $0, R %QKP 4GIKUVGT PQ (QWPF -PKIJVQP 1ZQP HQTOGTN[ $GTMU E 6JG NKMGNKJQQF KU VJCV VJKU EQKP ECOG FKTGEVN[ KPVQ 9GUUGZ CETQUU VJG %JCPPGN +PH D[ EQWTVGU[ QH /T $ %CXKNN

5+.8'4 &'0+'45

$TKQWFG. /QPG[GT 0QTDGTVWU!. # &GIGPGTCVGF JGCF T 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1 4 0 6 . $GNHQTV 4GXGTUG EQORCTGU VQ IT. 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

,CESWKGT -GJN (TQO NKUV PQ +P $GNHQTV VJG QDXGTUG KU FGUETKDGF CU OKVTG 6JG EQKP HTQO VJG $CKU JQCTF PQ UJQYU VJG UCOG QDXGTUG CU VJKU FQGU +PFGVGTOKP¾G 6JKU RKGEG KU PQY MGRV KP /CKP\ #EEQORCP[KPI VGZV #VVTKDWCDNG C $TKQWFG +P VJG $CKU JQCTF VJG QDXGTUG KU FGUETKDGF CU RGWV ¿VTG WPG V¿VG F¾HQTO¾G 6JKU KU OQTG NKMGN[ VJCP VJG OKVTG VJKU KU YJ[ JGTG KV KU UJQYP CU KV KU +H KV KU VJKU FGHQTOGF JGCF KV YQWNF FGRKEV C JGCF YKVJ C SWKVG RTQVTWFKPI PQUG

.KOQIGU. /QPG[GT 5EQDKNKQP. # )TGCV ' YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU 4 YKVJ ETQUU KP HTQPV 4 %KTENG YKVJ ETQKZ CPET¾G CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU 5%1$+.+10 /. $GNHQTV 4GXGTUG EQORCTGU VQ IT. 44 5OCNN VTCEGU QH UGCNKPI YCZ QP VJG QDXGTUG OKPQT UETCVEJGU QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5QVJGD[ .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ +P VJG JQCTF $CKU YGTG URGEKOGPU HTQO .KOQIGU CPF QPG HTQO 5V /CTVKCN KP .KOQIGU 6JG QDXGTUG KU .KOQIGU

$CKU VJG TGXGTUG TGUGODNGU PQ 0QXK 8KEQ YKVJ C FKHHGTGPV VGZV $ IKXGU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG TGXGTUG YKVJ QPN[ /10 KPUVGCF QH / %QKP YKVJ C YJQNN[ FKHHGTGPV QDXGTUG JGTG KPFKECVGF CU OQPPCKG KPF¾VGTOKP¾G

64


.[QP. 'RKUEQRCN OKPVKPI. # .8) YKVJ UVTKRG CDQXG 4 %TQUU YKVJ 8 2 ' 5 KP VJG CPINGU. $GNHQTV IT. 4 /KPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG NGVVGTU '25 CTG ENGCT *GTG VJG TGOCKPKPI SWCFTCPV TGXGCNU C 8 KP $GNHQTV VJKU KU EQPUKUVGPVN[ FGRKEVGF CU C V[RG QH 4 CU RCTV QH VJG ETQUU ETQKZ ITGESWG EJTKUOGG #NUQ CRRGCTU KP ECV QH /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP %QKP YGKIJV VJGTG KU 4GHGTGPEGU %KOKG\ CPF 6CH $GNHQTV 2TQW 6JKU RKGEG RTQDCDN[ KU HTQO GRKUEQRCN EQKPCIG TGICTFNGUU QH YJGVJGT QPG YCPVU VQ TGEQIPKUG ) '2 KUEQRWU 5 '2 KUEQRWU QT GXGP OGTGN[ '25 9JCV OCMGU VJKU V[RG TGOCTMCDNG KU VJCV VJG UJCRG CPF VJG UV[NG QH VJG FKG CTG XGT[ TGOKPKUEGPV QH VJG GCTN[ %CTQNKPIKCP EQKPU QH 2KRRKP VJG 5JQTV KPFGGF GXGP KH KVU HNCP KU V[RKECNN[ /GTQXKPIKCP

/CCUVTKEJV V[RG . # 4QWIJ FTCYP DWUV N YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU DGJKPF 4 +PVGTNCEG %TQUU 5QNQOQPʼnU MPQV YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING. $ /'% IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ #VVTKDWVGF D[ $GNHQTV VQ #WZGTTG NCVGT VQ /CCUVTKEJV EH PQ $QVJ CUUWORVKQPU CTG KPEQTTGEV /GVECNH TCPIGU KV WPFGT VJG UEGCVVCU 6 5 R GV UGSS DWV WPFGT TGUGTXG #P CVVTKDWVKQP VQ (TKUKC KU RQUUKDNG CEEQTFKPI VQ JKO DWV CNUQ VJG NQYGT /GWUG XCNNG[ OKIJV DG EQPUKFGTGF 6 5 R /'% JCU KPENWFGF VJGO WPFGT (TKUKC /'% + R CPF PQ HQT YJKEJ JG TGHGTU VQ VJG CPCNQIKGU DGVYGGP KVU TGXGTUG CPF VJQUG QH 2KRRKP CPF %JCTNG OCIPG EQKPU *CV\ KP JKU FGUETKRVKQP QH VJG JQCTF )QVKPI -NKHH (ÌJT EQPUKFGTU CP QTKIKP CTQWPF VJG .QYGT /GWUG .QYGT 4JKPG (TKGUNCPF CPF FCVGU VJGO 1R FGP 8GNFG $QQPG CPF 2QN KP $CT R EQPUKFGTU C &QTGUVCF QTKIKP

*GTUVCN V[RG . # 6YQ VTKCPIWNCTU QXGT GCEJQVJGT YKVJ ETQUU KP EGPVTG CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ QWVGT CP ING 4 %TQUU YKVJ ŋNGIGPFŌ OCFG QH UVTKRGU WPFGTDTQMGP D[ ETQUU. $ /'% IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/GV\. &GPKGT CW &. # )TGCV & QXGT UVTKRG 4 / ' OQPQITCO. $GNHQTV IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP /KPPGTVUIC 7UGF VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ *GTUVCN UQWVJ QH .K½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ņ -NKHH (ÌJT QPN[ URGEKOGP HTQO /CCUVTKEJV CPF QH *GTUVCN

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¾ GP #WUVTCUKG UQWU NC HQTOG &KGVTKEMU #W :G UKGENG QP NKV GPEQTG &'1&14+%85 UWT FGU OQPPCKGU VJG /GV\ EH 8QKNNGOKGT 4 0 4GOCTMCDNG KU VJCV VJGUG EQKPU YKVJ VJG & CTG UQ EQWTUG YJGTGCU VJG /GTQXKPIKCP EQKPU PQTOCNN[ GZJKDKV C FGNKECVG FKG #NUQ CRRGCTU KP ECVCNQIWG QH /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 6JG CVVTKDWVKQP VQ /GV\ KU PQYCFC[U EQPUKFGTGF EGTVCKP YJGVJGT VJG & UVCPFU HQT &CIQDGTVWU &GQFGTKEWU QT UQOGVJKPI QVJGT JQYGXGT TGOCKPU VQ DG FGVGTOKPGF ' 9GPFNKPI %QTRWU PWOOQTWO .QVJCTKPIKCG /QUGNNCPCG + /GV\

4GH $GNHQTV HH XCT (F %KOKG\ ER GV UGSS 9GPFN ++ # C GV UGSS HH

65


1TNGCPU. /QPG[GT /CWTKPWU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T /#84+085 / 4 %TQKZ EJTKUO¾G QP VJTGG UVGRU RGNNGV T #84+.+#0+5 %. $CKU $GNHQTV IT. 4 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG .CP\ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z $KU\KPIGT EQNNGEVKQP $GNHQTV TGEQTFU C UKOKNCT VTGOKUUG WPFGT (TQO VJG JQCTF $CKU &GR +NNG GV 8KNCKPG $TGVCIPG KP 2TQW $QWIGPQV 6TQWXCKNNGU FG $CKU 40 2R VJKU URGEKOGP 0QV KP /'% PQV KP $GNHQTV +P JQCTF $CKU QPN[ VYQ FKHHGTGPV URGEKOGPU D[ VJG OQPG[GT /CWTKPWU 6JG JGCF KU XGT[ TGOKPKUEGPV QH VJG UEGCVVCU

2CTKU. 7PMPQYP /QPG[GT. # $WUV N 4 )TGCV ' YKVJ ETQUU VYQ RGNNGVU QP DQVJ UKFGU. $GNHQTV IT. 1DXGTUG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ $GNHQTV JCU CU # VJG NGIGPF 01# 8%8 ( 4 KU VJG UCOG CU $GNHQTV 6JKU EQKP OQTG ENQUGN[ TGUGODNGU $GNHQTV # 41&'/#485 4 UCOG TGXGTUG QPN[ YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CPF $41 +01 'DTQKP 6JG QDXGTUG OCVEJGU $GNHQTV YJGTG VJG VGZV KU FGVGTOKPGF CU 18+$1

2CNCEKWU GV 5EQNC. /QPG[GT $GTVWNHWU. # )TGCV ' 4 %TQUU VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP DQYU. $GNHQTV IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 5VTWEM EC #& 2

7PMPQYP. # %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH VJG NKODU 4 %TQUU VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP DQYU QPG UOCNN UVTKRG CV VJG DQYU. $GNHQTV IT. #VVTCEVKXG VQPG XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

7PMPQYP. # %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH VJTGG NKODU CPF QPG ETQYP CV VJG VJ NKOD NQQR CTQWPF 4 )TGCV TQWPF # YKVJ ETQUU CDQXG VYQ EKTENGU VJG KPPGT EKTENG YKVJ VYQ JGCFU DGPGCVJ VJG ETQUU. $GN HQTV IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ EH $CKU PQ

66


7PMPQYP. # %TQUU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU VYQ RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD 4 .CVKP ETQUU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ VYQ NQQRU CTQWPF KV. $GNHQTV IT. 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5RKPM .QPFQP 1P OCR 5QWVJGTP (TCPEG (QWPF KP 5QWVJ 'PINCPF 1PG URGEKOGP KU MGRV KP VJG ECDKPGV FG (TCPEG URGEKOGP HTQO /QTGN (CVKQ EQNNGEVKQP 2TQW +P 1R FGP 8GNFG CPF -NCCUUGP 5EGCVVCU CPF OGTQXKPIKCP FGPKGTU /KFFGNDWTI C UKOKNCT URGEKOGP KU NKUVGF WP FGT PQ #ICKP YKVJ TGHGTGPEG VQ $GNHQTV 6JCV URGEKOGP ECOG HTQO VJG EQNNGEVKQP 4¾VJCCP /CECT¾ CPF PQY KU KP VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH VJG <GGWYU /WUGWO PQ ECV

2418'0%' 'XGP KP (TCPMKUJ VKOGU VJG 2TQXGPEG YCU UVKNN WPFGT 'CUV )QVJKE UYC[ 6JG )QVJU FKF PQV IKXG KV WR WPVKN YJGP 'ORGTQT ,WUVKPKCP + QTFCKPGF VJCV VJG 2TQXGPEG DG EGFGF VQ 6JGWFGDGTV #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH %JKNFGDGTV + KP 5KIKDGTV + TGEGKXGF VJG 2TQXGPEG COQPI QVJGT VGTTKVQ TKGU YJKEJ TGUVQTGF $WTIWPF[ VQ C YJQNG CPF OQTGQXGT NKPMGF KV ENQUGN[ VQ (TCPEKC

1TN¾CPU +P #SWKVCPKÀ CPF VJG 2TQXGPEG VJGTG YCU C UVTQPI FGXGNQROGPV QH CTKUVQETCVKE HCOKNKGU +P VJG 2TQXGPEG VJKU GURGEKCNN[ KU QDUGTXGF KP VJG RGTKQF HTQO VQ 6JGTG YGTG EQPUGEW VKXGN[ #PUGFGTV 0GOHKFKWU #PVGPQT CPF /CWTQPVWU C FKUVCPV TGNCVKXG QH VJG 0GWUVTKCP OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG 9CTCVVQ VJG UWEEGUUQT QH 'DTQKP 6JG NCVVGT VYQ OCPCIGF VQ YTGUV VJGOUGNXGU HTQO 2KRRKPKF EQPVTQN VJKU YCU PQV KPVGPFGF CICKPUV %JKNFGDGTV +++ VJG HQTOCN /GTQXKPIKCP MKPI QH 0GWUVTKC #WUVTCUKC CPF $WTIWPF[ +PFGRGPFGPEG TGCEJGF UQ HCT VJCV VJG[ OKPVGF KP VJGKT QYP PCOG KPENWFKPI DWUV CNDGKV OQPQITCOOGF 0GXGTVJGNGUU VJKU RTQXGF CFXCPVCIGQWU HQT 2KRRKP CPF %JCTNGU /CTVGN HQT YJGP #PVGPQT CPF /CWTQPVWU UVCTVGF RTQENCKOKPI VJGOUGNXGU RTKPEKRGU VJG[ PQV QPN[ UVQQF WR VQ DQVJ %CTQNKPIKCPU DWV VQ VJG GP VKTG 2TQXGPEG PQDKNKV[ 0QDKNKV[ YCU NGF D[ #DDQ $GVYGGP CPF /CWTQPVWU VQQM VJG EJCPEGU QH TGN[KPI QP VJG 5GRVKOCPKC OWUNKOU YJGTGCU #DDQ CNNKGF YKVJ %JCTNGU /CTVGN #HVGT FGHGCVKPI VJG OWUNKOU %JCTNGU /CTVGN YCPVGF VQ RTGXGPV CPQVJGT KPFGRGPFGPV 2TQXGPEG GOGTIKPI #DDQ YCU JQYGXGT CNNQYGF VQ ECNN JKOUGNH RCVTKEKWU DWV UQNGN[ DGECWUG JG YCU EJKNFNGUU #HVGT JKU FGOKUG VJG 2TQXGPEG WPEQPFKVKQPCNN[ YCU RCTV QH VJG (TCPMKUJ TGCNO

/CTUGKNNG. 6TKGPU. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T &0 /#84+% +85 22# 4 %TQUU QP INQDWNG DGVYGGP / # CPF 8 ++. 8+%614+# #85614 KP GZGTIWG %101$. $GNHQTV IT. 9GNN UVTWEM WR XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU +P VJG PCOG QH /CWTKEG 6KDGTKWU / # /CUUKNKC 8 ++ KU V[RKECN HQT )CWN UGG ' 5 R $GNHQTV MPQYU QH QPG URGEKOGP KP VJG %CDKPGV FG (TCPEG UGG .GPQTOCPV 40 R RN

67


/CTUGKNNG. # *CKTGF DQY YKVJ ETGUEGPV QP KV ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 4 *QTK\QPVCN NKPG YKVJ VTKCPING QXGT ETQUU UVGR DGNQY 8 CPF ++ KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU QH VJG ETQUU. $GNHQTV IT. 8GT[ HKPG

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

+ / FG /CP 1XGT GGPKIG VG &QODWTI IGXQPFGP OGTMYCTFKIG OWPVGP ,/2 R 1R FGP 8GNFG CPF -NCCUUGP EQOOGPV 2QUUKDNG HTQO C OKPV PGCT /CTUGKNNG +P ECVCNQIWG QH /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP TGHGTGPEGU (F %KOKG\ XCT $GNHQTV /CKP\ /'% + XCT *GTG VJG CRRTQCEJ VQ NQECNKUCVKQP YCU C NKVVNG DTQCFGT )TKGTUQP RNCEGU VJKU V[RG KP VJG /CTUGKNNG TG IKQP YG TGHGT VQ JKU GZVGPUKXG OQVKXCVKQP R 6GZV KP /'% + R 6JKU V[RG JCU QP QPG UKFG C DWUV YKVJ C ETQUU DGHQTG KV CPF QP VJG QVJGT C FKUVQTVGF ETQUU CP ET¾G YKVJ 8++ KP VJG HKGNF 1P VJG GCTNKGUV EQKPU RTGUGPV KP VJG 5CKPV 2KGTTG NGU 'VKGWZ CPF 0QJCPGPV JQCTFU PQ VJG DWUV KU HCKTN[ YGNN HQTOGF YKVJ JCKT HNQYKPI FQYP DGJKPF VJG PGEM DWV NCVGT KV DGEQOGU ITQVGUSWGN[ FGHQTOGF PTU WPFGT VJG KPHNWGPEG QH (TKUKCP RQTEWRKPG UEGCVVCU 6JGTG YGTG URGEKOGPU QH VJKU NCVGT V[RG KP VJG %KOKG\ JQCTF /( RNU 6JG UWIIGUVKQP VJCV VJG[ YGTG VJG RTQVQV[RG HQT VJG RQTEWRKPG FGUKIP KU EQPVTCFKEVGF D[ VJG GXKFGPEG KP VJG (TGPEJ HKPFU YJKEJ UJQY VJCV VJG RQTEWRKPG V[RG YCU CNTGCF[ HWNN[ FGXGNQRGF YJGP VJG GCTNKGUV 8++ EQKPU YGTG DGKPI WUGF (KNNQP CVVTKDWVGF VJG V[RG VQ /CKP\ YKVJQWV IKXKPI CP[ IQQF TGCUQP YJKNG 2TQW C CPF .G )GPVKNJQOOG C TGLGEVGF VJGO CNVQIGVJGT HTQO VJG OGTQXKPIKCP UGTKGU *QYGXGT /QTGN (CVKQ U UWIIGUVKQP VJCV VJG[ CTG 2TQXGPECN JCU DGGP CFQRVGF D[ .CHCWTKG C CPF UGGOU RTGHGTCDNG KP XKGY QH VJG PWODGT KP VJG %KOKG\ JQCTF CPF VJG WUG QH 8++ TGIWNCTN[ HQWPF QP VTGOKUUGU QH VJG TGIKQP GXGP KH VJKU V[RQNQIKECN RCTCNNGNU YKVJ GCTN[ %CTQNKPIKCP EQKPU QH /CTUGKNNG CTG WPEQPXKPEKPI /'% FGVGTOKPGU VJG QDXGTUG C HCEG YKVJ C ETQUU KP HTQPV QH KV CPF HQT TGHGTU VQ /'% PQ

2CVTKEKWU 0'/(+&+85. # $WUV N YKVJ ETQUU KP HTQPV 0GOHKFKWU 4 %JTKUVQITCO ETQKZ NCVKPG EJTKUOGG 0' . $GNHQTV IT. 4 /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 0GOHKFKWU UGTKGU 6JGUG CTG D[ HCT VJG EQOOQPGUV QH VJG /CUUKNKQVG FGPKGTU YKVJ UQOG KP VJG JQCTF 6JG[ CTG QH XCTKQWU V[RGU YKVJ VJG GCTNKGT EQKPU TGUGODNKPI VJQUG QH #PUGFGTV CPF #PVGPQT KP JCXKPI 0GOHKFKWU PCOG URGNNGF QWV KP HWNN CPF VJG NCVGT QPGU JCXKPI CU QDXGTUG V[RG C ETWFG DWUV WUWCNN[ CEEQORCPKGF D[ C ETQUU CPF QP VJG TGXGTUG C OQPQITCO QH VJG EJKGH NGVVGTU QH 0GOHKFKWU PCOG /( RNU XCTKCVKQPU VCDWNCVGF QP RNCVG #N VJQWIJ 0GOHKFKWU YCU IKXGP PQ VKVNG KV KU TGCUQPCDNG VQ KFGPVKH[ JKO YKVJ VJG RCVTKEKCP CPF VJWU FCVG VJGO E

/'% + R

2CVTKEKWU 0'/(+&+85. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUU DGJKPF 4 0'( DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU $GNHQTV IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ

68


#TNGU. 2CVTKEKWU #06'014. # #4 NKICVWTGF KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 4 8# NKICVWTGF KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU. $GNHQTV IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU $GNHQTV RTQXKFGU C EQOOGPVCT[ QP R YJGTG FQWDV KU TCKUGF CDQWV VJG OKPV #TNGU #PQVJGT RQUUKDKNKV[ KU /CT UGKNNG *QYGXGT KP VJCV ECUG VJG #06 UJQWNF DG CP / YJKEJ KU GXKFGPVN[ PQV VJG ECUG JGTG #06 DGKPI CP CDDTG XKCVKQP HQT #PVGPQT NGCXGU #4 WPCPUYGTGF HQT WPNGUU #PVGPQT PGZV VQ JKU VKVNG QH 2CVTKEG QH /CTUGKNNG RNC[GF C TQNG KP #TNGU CU YGNN

%#41.+0)+#05 41$'46+0'5 (4#0%' 41;#.' CPF +/2'4+#.' 6JG RGTKQF UKIPCNU QH VJG FGENKPG QH VJG OGTQXKPIKCP MKPIFQO 6JG KPHNWGPEG QH PQDKNKV[ YJKEJ CDQXG CNN FGUKTGU HQT CWVQPQO[ QH VJG UGXGTCN RCTVU QH VJG MKPIFQO KPETGCUGU CU FQGU VJCV QH VJG OC[QTU QH VJG RCNCEG 5QOGVKOGU VJG[ UWEEGGF KP RCTVKCNN[ TGUVQTKPI WPKV[ CU FKF 2¾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

YJKEJ GUVCDNKUJGU CP GEENGUKCUVKECN DQPF DGVYGGP VJG RQRG CPF 2KRRKP CPF KU DGUVQYGF WRQP VJG RCVTKEKWU VKVNG YJKEJ QDNKIGU JKO VQ FGHGPF 4QOG CPF +VCN[ 2 2+0 NG $4'(

&GPKGT. # 42 HQT 4': 2+2+085 CDQXG 6 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU #6 61 8 01. /'% /) XF%J IT. 44 'FIG UNKIJVN[ EJKRRGF QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #VVKIP[ EQOGU VQ OKPF C HTCPMQPKCP TGICN RCNCVKPG NQPI UKPEG VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH VJG OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG UKVWCVGF CV VJG ETQUUKPI QH VJG TQCFU DGVYGGP 4GKOU %QNQIPG CPF 4GKOU /CKP\ /'% QP R GNCDQTCVGU QP VJKU EQKP .QPIR¾TKGT RWDNKUJKPI VJG +ORJ[ JQCTF UWIIGUVGF C OQPG[GT #WVVTCOPWU

.QPIR¾TKGT DWV )CTKGN ++ RTGHGTTGF CP CVVTKDWVKQP VQ C OKPV CV #PVTCKP +NNG GV 8KNCKPG CTT (QWI½TGU PQV HCT HTQO +ORJ[ CNVJQWIJ VJG QEEWTTGPEG QH VJG UGXGP URGEKOGPU KP VJG +NCP\ JQCTF UJQYU VJKU PQV VQ DG EQPENWUKXG /GVECNH JCU UWIIGUVGF 5V &GPKU KPVGTRTGVKPI KV CU #06 KUVKVKQ 4 GIKQ & KQ 0 WUKCE 1 /GVECNH C DWV CNVJQWIJ JKU CTVKENG DTKPIU VQIGVJGT OWEJ WUGHWN OCVGTKCN UWEJ CP KPVGTRTGVCVKQP OWUV DG FKUOKUUGF CU YJQNN[ HCPEKHWN KP VJG EQPVGZV QH %CTQNKPIKCP EQKP KPUETKRVKQPU )TKGTUQP D P &GRG[TQV .G 0WO¾ TCKTG /¾TQXKPIKCP N CIG FG N QT NGU CVGNKGTU UGRVGPVTKQPCWZ 9GVVGTGP JCU TGEGPVN[ IKXGP KV VQ VJG OKPV QH 5V &GPKU +P VJG FGUETKRVKQP QH VJG HKPF CV +ORJ[ 8ÌNMGTU ENCUUKHKGU R VJGUG EQKPU WPFGT VJG OKPV QH #WVVTCOPWU 6JG HKPF CV +ORJ[ EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU KP XCTKCVKQPU 8ÌNMGTU FGUETKDGU VJG JQCTF CV +NCP\ CNQPI VJG UCOG NKPGU R 6JG JQCTF EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU KP XCTKCVKQPU #NN EQKPU CTG MGRV CV VJG OWUGWO KP %JWT

69


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ʼnU MKPIFQO QP GCTVJ JQYGXGT HQT %JCTNGOCIPG JKU TGICN CWVJQTKV[ YCU VJG QPN[ UWDUVCPVKCN GNGOGPV

%*#4.'/#)0'

&GPKGT 6TGXKUQ. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 4 1PG RGNNGV YKVJKP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 6#48+51. /'% MG: 217. 1.101gr. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG QPN[ C HGY MPQYP URGEKOGPU 5OCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP DWV XGT[ HKPG

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

&GPKGT &QTGUVCF. # %#41 .85 4 (KXG NGVVGTU CTQWPF CP # WPFGT VJGO JQTK\QPVCN CZG

HTCPEKUEC . /'% /) XF%J IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG RQUUKDN[ VJG QPN[ MPQYP URGEKOGP QH VJKU V[RG 'FIG EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JKU V[RG KU OWEJ OQTG TCTG VJCP VJG V[RG VJCV UJQYU VJG YTKVKPI QH &QTGUVCF KP VYQ NKPGU X )GNFGT )CTKGN CVVTKDWVGU VJKU EQKP VQ &QTGUVCF 8CP )GNFGT CITGGU 6JKU KU VJG EQKP VJCV ECP DG UGGP FTCYP KP X F %JKLU *G TGHGTU VQ %CRRG /ÒP\GP FGT FGWVUEJGP -CKUGT &TGUFGP RN ::+ PQ 6JG FTCYKPI KP %CRRG KU VJG UCOG CU KP X F %JKLU %CRRG KP VWTP TGHGTU VQ )ÌV\ &GWVUEJNCPFU -CKLUGT /ÒP\GP FGU /KVVGN #NVGTU &TGUFGP VCD +8 PQ VJKU KU KORQUUKDNG HQT KV KU C PQTOCN &QTGUVCF EQKP 2TGUWOCDN[ KVʼnU C WPKSWG (TCPEKUEC 6JKU DCVVNG CZG C U[ODQN QTKIKPCNN[ CFQRVGF HTQO CPEKGPV RCICP EWNV KU VJG HTCPEKUEC VJG VJTQYKPI CZG VJCV KP HTCPEQPKCP UV[NG YCU C UJQTV UJCHVGF DCVVNG CZG 2CWNUGP 2 #ZV WPF -TGW\ DGK FGP 0QTFIGTOCPGP $GTNKP R 6JKU HTCPEKUEC KU QPN[ UGGP QP EQKPU HTQO &QTGUVCF $10# ! %QPF¾ UWT Nʼn'UECWV CPF 5CKPV $CXQP )GPV GZEGTRV 8ÌNEMGTU COQWPVU /QTTKUQP )TWPVJCN

70


&GPKGT 7VTGEJV ! . # %#41 .85 Õ 4 $ 1 0 # JQTK\QPVCN CZG HTCPEKUEC CDQXG CPF ETQUKGT DGNQY. /'% /) IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 4CVJGT EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN *KUVQTKECNN[ CVVTKDWVGF VQ $QPP YJKEJ KU KPEQTTGEV /GVECNH #P 'CTN[ %CTQNKPIKCP /KPV KP VJG .QY %QWPVTKGU $10# 6KGN KP 4$0 R JCU UWIIGUVGF 6KGN DWV VJGTG KU PQ TGCUQP VQ RNCEG C ETQUKGT KP 6KGN #RCTV HTQO C HTCPEKUEC VJKU EQKP FKURNC[U C ETQUKGT 8ÌNEMGTU PQVGU $GECWUG QH CRRGCTCPEG QH C ETQUKGT S X /CKP\

(F -TKPMDGTI %QPHGT 2CWNUGP R CPF YJQ GZRNCKPU VJWU 6JG EJWTEJ GPFGCXQWTGF VQ YKFGP VJGKT ENCKO QH UQNG TKIJVU VQ VJG GPVKTG CTGC QH JQNKPGUU KP VJKU ECUG VQ VJG CPEKGPV U[ODQN QH VJG DCVVNG CZG QH 6JQT YQTUJKR

2CWNUGP #DD C CPF D 1NCHUMWNV KP YJKEJ 5V 1NCH KU RQTVTC[GF YKVJ C DCVVNG CZG 8ÌNEMGTU FKUVKPIWKUJGU VYQ V[RGU # YKVJ ETQUU $ YKVJ ETQUKGT 6Q JKO QPN[ VJTGG URGEKOGPU QH V[RG $ CTG MPQYP C (KPF )GNFGTNCPF QP VJG DQTFGT QH 7VTGEJV CPF )GNFGTNCPF 6JG HKPF )GNFGTNCPF YCU CESWKTGF GPVKTGN[ D[ &G %QUVGT CPF KU PQY MGRV CV VJG $KDNKQVJ½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

8ÌNMGTU CVVTKDWVGU VJG ,GNUWO CPF -TKPMDGTI EQKPU VQ /CKP\ 6JG WUG QH $10# KU UGGP QHVGP KP VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU DWV KV KU CNYC[U CUUQEKCVGF YKVJ C RNCEGPCOG $10# 6+'.' CPF $10# &#8'064+# $10# PQ FQWDV OGCPKPI EKV[ #HVGT #NDGTKEJ ņ CRRTQZ VJGTG KU CP WPKPVGTTWRVGF UGTKGU QH 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU #HVGT TGKPUVCNNKPI VJG OGVTQ RQNKVCP EQPUVKVWVKQP 7VTGEJV YCU RCTV QH VJG GEENGUKCUVKECN RTQXKPEG QH %QNQIPG 7VTGEJV VJGTGHQTG JCU VQ DG WPFGT HQTGOQUV EQPUKFGTCVKQP HQT VJKU V[RG YJKEJ KP O[ QRKPKQP FQGU PQV TWNG QWV VJG RQUUKDKNKV[ QH OKPVKPI CV &QTGUVCF

&GPKGT /KNCP 5CT\CPC V[RG. # %#41 .85 Õ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ÌNMGTU NCDGNU VJGUG EQKPU YKVJ PQ OKPV URGEKHKECVKQP DWV VQ VJG HKPF CV $GN #KT R CFFU C TGOCTM VJCV UQOGVKOGU NGHV QH VJG 4 CP ' QT /' KU NGIKDNG YJKEJ ENGCTN[ UWIIGUVU /GFKQNCPWO +P 8ÌNEMGTU VJKU EQKP UJQYU VJG JKIJGUV TGUGODNCPEG YKVJ PQ ::+8 8ÌNEMGTU QP R EQOOGPVU CU HQNNQYU &CUU FGT 2T·IGQTV INGKEJHCNNU /CKNCPF IGYGUGP KUV YKTF MCWO \W DG\ YGKHGNP UGKP YGPP FKG .GUWPI FGT /G WPF /GF $GK\GKEJGP TKEJVKI /GFKQNCPWO GTIKDV &C GU UKEJ DGK FKGUGP 5CT \CPC )GRT·IGP WTURTÒPINKEJ WO HT·PMKUEJG ōPGWVTCNGŋ 2HGPPKIG \WT DGUQPFGTGP 8GTYGPFWPI FGU -ÌPKIU IGJCPFGNV JCV MÌPPVG HQNIGTKEJVKI GKPG 2HCN\ QFGT FCU *CWRVSWCTVKGT FGU -ÌPKIU QFGT GKPG KP FGT 5VCFV GKPIGTKEJVGVG (GNFOÒP \UV·VVG KP (TCIG MQOOGP &C UKEJ KPFGU FKGUG )GRT·IG ÒDGT GKPGP N·PIGTGP <GKVTCWO JKPIG\QIGP JCDGP DKU MWT\ XQT FGT XQNNGPFGVG 5CT\CPC 6[RWU OKV UGKPGP ÒDGTUEJNCPMGP $WEJUVCDGPHQTOGP WPF FGP NCPIGP 5RQTGP GPVYKEMGNV YWTFG MCPP GU MCWO YCJTUEJGKPNKEJ UGKP FCUU DKU WPOKVVGNDCT XQT FGT /ÒP\TGHQTO GKP UQNEJGT PGWCTVKIGT WPHT·PM KUEJGT 6[RWU PCEJ CNVGO 5EJNCI KP GKPGT FGT -QPVTQNNG FGU -ÌPKIU FKTGMV WPVGTUVGNNVGP &KGPUVUVGNNG JGTCWUIGDTCEJV UGKP UQNNVG +PHQNIGFGUUGP DNGKDV PWT FKG /ÌINKEJMGKV FCUU FKGUG /ÒP\GP KP GKPGT IGKUVNKEJGP 2T·IGUV·VVG GPVYKEMGNV WPF CWUIGIGDGP YQTFGP UKPF = ? &KG (TCIG GKPGT IGKUVNKEJGP 2T·IWPI XQP /CKNCPF CWUIGJGPF OÒ­VG GTPUVNKEJ IGRTÒHV YGTFGP ŋ

71


+P %JCTNGOCIPG CFQRVU C PGY CPF WPKHQTO OQPGVCT[ U[UVGO DCUGF QP YGKIJV FGPKGTU VQ C ECTQNKPIKCP RQWPF QH UKNXGT YKVJ C PGY CRRGCTCPEG 6JGTG JCU DGGP SWKVG UQOG FKURWVG CU VQ VJG FCVG QH CFQRVKQP )TKGTUQP TGHGTU VQ VJG %QWPEKN QH (TCPEHWTV QH YJGTG VJGTG KU OGPVKQP QH PQXK FGPCTKK 1P CNN CEEQWPVU )TKGTUQP KU EQPXKPEGF VJCV VJG KPVTQFWEVKQP QH %JCTNGOCIPGʼnU JGCX[ FGPKGT ECPPQV JCXG RTGEGGFGF 1HHCʼnU OQPGVCT[ TGHQTO DWV OWUV JCXG HQNNQYGF KV EH )TKGTUQP 2 /QPG[ CPF EQKPCIG WPFGT %JCTNGOCIPG KP $GWOCPP * =*TUI ? -CTN FGT )TQUUG .GDGPUYGTM WPF 0CEJNGDGP &ÒUUGNFQTH R $GHQTG VJKU FCVG VJG YGKIJV YCU IT CHVGT KV IT

&GPKGT &QTGUVCF. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG YGFIG KP VJG TF CPING %#4.85 4': (4 4 -CTQNWU OQPQ ITCO &14'56#&1. /'% /) XCT IT. 4 8GT[ (KPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z -GPPGRQJN EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV HTQO $TWPQ &QTHOCPP %CJP (TCPMHWTV C / #WEVKQP PQ (TGKJGTT . X * X F 4 (TGKJGTT . X * (TGKJGTT .QEJPGT XQP *WVGPDCEJ $TWPQ &QTHOCPP DQWIJV VJKU EQKP CV VJG CWEVKQP QH %CJP KP VQ UGNN KV VQ -GPPGRQJN KP 6JKU %JCTNGOCIPG EQKP YCU KPENWFGF KP VJG EQNNGEVKQP -GPPGRQJN DGECWUG %JCTNGOCIPG KU EQPUKFGTGF VQ DG VJG HQWP FGT QH 1UPCDTÒEM 6JG FKQEGUG QH 1UPCDTÒEM GOGTIGF UJQTVN[ DGHQTG

&GPKGT 2CXKC. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': (4 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 2#2+# Ő /'% /) XCT IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ (KPG

5-# $GTP 6JKU EQKP KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP /) VJG RGNNGV KP VYQ QVJGT RNCEGU *GTG VJG RGNNGV CHVGT 2#2+# CV VJG VQR

/+.1

&GPKGT 0CTDQPPG. # %TQUU YKVJ / + . 1 KP VJG CPINGU 4 %TQUU YKVJ 0 4 $ 1 KP VJG CP INGU VYQ EWTXGF DCTU GZVGPF U[OOGVTKECNN[ HTQO GCEJ GPF QH VJG ETQUU. /'% /) IT. 44 (NCP ETCEM DWV XGT[ HKPG

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ʼnU PCOG YGTG UVTWEM WPFGT 2KRRKP CU YGNN UGG G I /)

72


.17+5 NG 2+'7: 6JG EQKPU QH .QWKU NG 2KGWZ CTG VQ DG ENCUUKHKGF KP VJTGG ECVGIQTKGU ENCUU ENCUU

CPF ENCUU %NCUU 2QTVTCKV EQKP C EQPVKPWCVKQP QH VJG EQKPU QH %JCTNGOCIPG

&GPKGT %N /GNNG. # .CWTGCVG $WUV T * .8&188+%85 +/2 #8) 4 /KPVKPI VQQNU /'6#..8/. /'% /) IT. 4 /KPQT UETCVEJGU QP UWTHCEG QVJGTYKUG YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP EH 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ /) MPQYU QH URGEKOGPU KP VQVCN %NCUU # EQPVKPWCVKQP QH %JCTNGOCIPG U ENCUU QDXGTUG V[RG C NCWTGCVG DWUV UWTTQWPFGF D[ *.8&188+%85 +/2 #8) QP TGXGTUG YKVJ PCOG QT :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1

+OKVCVKQP IKNFGF EQRRGT. # .CWTGCVG $WUV N &8#5++++6+ +6+1616++1+ 4 6GORNG YKVJ ETQUU KP KV 1%+#+ 0+#005+ 4+6#/ /'% /) IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 8GT[ (KPG

8GTUEJQQT 5VTKLGP 'Z 5QVJGD[ .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z &QNKXQ EQNNGEVKQP /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 2TKP\ (ÒTUVGPDGTI EQNNGEVKQP #WEVKQP PQ (KTUV FGUETKDGF D[ , FG 5 3WKPVKPQ 1P EQPPQÄV F¾L¯ GP (TCPEG UKZ RK½EGU GP QT FG %JCTNGOCIPG GV FG UGU RTGOKGTU UWEEGUUGWTU =ő? /CKU EGVVG CRRCTGPEG FKURCTQÄV GPEQTG GP HCEG F WPG CWVTG FG EGU RK½EGU GP QT FW O¿OG GORGTGWT SWK UG VTQWXG ¯ EÊV¾ FGU RT¾E¾FGPVGU FCPU NG O¿OG ECDKPGV ECT GNNG P C SWG NG RQKFU F WP FWECV E GUV ¯ FKTG UQKZCPVG EKPS ITCKPU GV UK FGRWKU RNWUKGWTU CPP¾GU SWG LG N CK XWG LG O GP UQWXKGPU DKGP GPEQTG GNNG P GUV RCU OQKPU DKGP EQPUGTX¾G SWG NGU VTQKU CWVTGU & WP EÊV¾ GNNG RT¾UGPVG CWUUK NG DWUVG FG N GORGTGWT .QWKU CXGE NC N¾IGPFG *.8&188+%85 +02 #8) /CKU NG V[RG FW TGXGTU P GUV RCU NG O¿OG QP [ XQKV NC HCECFG F WP ¾FKHKEG UWTOQPV¾ F WPG ETQKZ GV F WPG HQTOG FKHH¾TGPVG FG EGNNG FW VGORNG SW QP VTQWXG UK UQWXCPV TGRT¾UGPV¾ UWT NGU FGPKGTU FG NC F[ PCUVKG ECTNQXKPIKGPPG .C SWGUVKQP TGUVG FQE FCPU NG O¿OG ¾VCV FG FQWVG SW CWRCTCXCPV 'NNG P GP UQTVKTC RGWV ¿VTG LCOCKU #V VJKU VKOG VJG EQKP CRRGCTU KP VJG (ÒTUVGPDGTI EQNNGEVKQP %CV %CJP (TCPMHWTV PQ PQ &GUETKDGF CU (TKGUKUEJG $TQP\GPPCEJDKNFWPI CPF &KGUGO UGJT OGTMYÒTFKIGP 5VÒEM JCV GKP &GPCT .WFYKIU OKV $TWUVDKNF WPF 6GORGN OKV FGT %JTKUVKCPC 4GNKIKQ 7OUEJTKHV CNU 8QTDKNF IGFKGPV &KG 8GTIQNFWPI FGT 8QTFGTUGKVG \GKIV FC­ GU CNU 5EJOWEMUVÒEM XGTYCPFV YQTFGP KUV #HVGT VJKU KV KU HQWPF KP VJG &QNKXQ EQNNGEVKQP %CVCNQIWG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN PQ *GTG FGUETKDGF CU (TKUG +OKVCVKQP GP EWKXTG FQT¾ RK½EG FG DKLQW 5QNF VQ C YGNN MPQYP %QNQIPG EQNNGEVQT )TKGTUQP CFTGUUGF VJKU KP JKU CTVKENG 6JG )QNF UQNKFWU QH .QWKU VJG 2KQWU CPF KVU KOKVCVKQPU KP VJG ,CCTDQGM XQQT /WPV GP 2GPPKPIMWPFG QP RCIG 6JG UGEQPF RKGEG KU GSWCNN[ GZNWUKXG 6JG +VCNKCP PWOKUOCVKUV %QTFGTQ FK 5CP 3WKPVKPQ YTKVKPI KP VJG 4GXWG PWOKUOCVKSWG KP R FGUETKDGF JQY UQOG [GCTU RTGXKQWUN[ JG JCF UGGP KP C RTKXCVG EQNNGEVKQP VJTGG DCTDCTQWU UQNKFK GCEJ YGKIJVKPI CDQWV I CPF C NKIJVGT UQNKFWU QH FKHHGTGPV UV[NG VJG QDXGTUG JCF VJG WUWCN DWUV CPF VJG NGIGPF *.8188+%85+02#8) DWV VJG TGXGTUG UJQYGF C DWKNFKPI UWTOQWPVGF D[ C ETQUU FKHHGTGPV HTQO VJG WUWCN VGORNG QP VJG FGPKGTU QH VJG RGTKQF 6JG EQNNGEVKQP JGTG CNNWFGF VQ ECP QPN[ DG VJCV QH .GNGYGN YJQ KU MPQYP VQ JCXG CESWKTGF PQ HGYGT VJCP UKZ DCTDCTQWU UQNKFK D[ VJG OKFFNG QH VJG EGPVWT[ DWV PQ QVJGT TGHGTGPEG VQ VJKU VGORNG UQNKFWU JCU EQOG O[ YC[ 2QUUKDN[ KV TGUGODNGF VJG DTQP\G RKGEG YKVJ DWUV CPF VGORNG CPF JQRGNGUUN[ EQTTWRV NGIGPFU YJKEJ YCU KP VJG UGXGPVJ UGEVKQP QH VJG (ÒTUVGPDGTI UCNG %CJP 8GTUVGKIGTWPIU -CVCNQI &GEGODGT NQV 6JG YGKIJV QH VJKU KU WPHQTVWPCVGN[ PQV IKXGP DWV VJGTG CTG UVCVGF VQ JCXG DGGP VTCEGU QH IKNFKPI QP VJG QDXGTUG 0GKVJGT RKGEG ECP DG TGICTFGF CU ENQUGN[ TGNCVGF VQ VJG UQNKFK QH VJG /8085 &+8+08/ V[RG

73


%NCUU

6JG OKPV CRRGCTU KP VYQ NKPGU QP VJG TGXGTUG

1DQNG #SWKVCKPG. # 5OCNN ETQUU * .8&18+%85 4 4 +P VYQ NKPGU #38+ 6#0+#. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ (KPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO JQCTF 4CCNVG &QGU PQV CRRGCT KP /) EQPVTCTKN[ VQ VJG FGPKGT QH VJG UCOG V[RG VJCV FQGU /)

&GPKGT &QTGUVCF. # %TQUU YKVJKP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU * .8&188+%85 +/2 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU &14 '56# 685. /'% XCT /) IT. 4 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG #WEVKQP PQ

1DQNG /GNNG. # +P VYQ NKPGU .8&1 88+% YKVJ RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJG NKPGU 4 5OCNN ETQUU /'6#..8/. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 5RGEKOGPU KP /) JCXG PQ RGNNGV DGVYGGP 88 CPF +%

&GPKGT 8GPKEG. # %TQUU * .8&188+%85 +/2 4 +P VYQ NKPGU 8'0 '%+#5. /'% /) IT. 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

%NCUU

1P VJG TGXGTUG ECTQNKPIKCP VGORNG YKVJ :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1

&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING * .8&188+%85 +/2 4 6GORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1. /'% /) IT. #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

1DQNG #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING * .8&188+%85 +/2 4 6GORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1. /'% /) IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ

74


1DQNG #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING *..1&188+%85 +/2 4 6GORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1. /'% /) IT. 4 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF TGXGTUG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG DWV XGT[ HKPG

&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING *.8&188+%85 +/2 4 .CTIG CPF PCTTQY VGORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1 /'% /) IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

$QPXCNNGV 2CTKU

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 8CP )GNFGT HCPEKGU TGOGODGTKPI VJCV KP VJG HKPF )QGU C UKOKNCT V[RG NCTIG PCTTQY EJWTEJ YCU UGGP 6JG PWODGT KP /) C FGPKGT HTQO &CZ QH 2KRRKP ++ FKURNC[U VJG UCOG EJWTEJ /) OGPVKQPU VYQ HKPFU -KO UYGTF 2KPILWO ++ CPF 2KNNKIGTJGEM 9QWNF VJKU EQKP JCXG VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ &CZ!

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ʼnV FKTGEVN[ FGCNV YKVJ CHVGT .QWKUʼn FGCVJ KP 2KRRKP + JCF CNTGCF[ FKGF KP CPF KP VYQ UQPU .QWKU HTQO VJG HKTUV OCTTKCIG CPF %JCTNGU VJG $CNF HTQO VJG UGEQPF OCTTKCIG CNNKGF KP 5VTCUDQWTI 6JKU 1CVJ QH 5VTCUDQWTI FGVGTOKPGF HQT VJG HKTUV VKOG GXGT KP VYQ NCPIWCIGU 1NF *KIJ )GTOCP CPF 1NF (TGPEJ VJCV VJG EQWPVTKGU QH )GTOCP[ CPF (TCPEG YGTG VQ DG UGRCTCVGF CPF TGOCKP VJCV YC[ 6JKU KP HCEV FGVGTOKPGU VJG DQTFGTU QH 'WTQRG (TQO VJKU UVCVG QH CHHCKTU PGIQVKCVKQPU YKVJ VJG GNFGUV UQP .QVJCKT YGTG DGIWP +P VJKU NGF VQ C HQWT YC[ FKXKUKQP 6TGCV[ QH 8GTFWP .QVJCKT CU GORGTQT VJG OKFFNG TGCNO HTQO (TKUKC VQ +VCN[ %JCTNGU VJG $CNF CU MKPI VJG TGIKQPU VQ VJG YGUV (TCPEKC QEEKFGPVCNKU .QWKU .WFYKI CU MKPI VJG FQOKPKQPU VQ VJG GCUV (TCPEKC QTKGPVCNKU CPF 2KRRKP ++ UQP QH 2KRRKP + #SWKVCKPG 6JG PQVKQP QH KORGTKCN WPKV[ YCU PQY FGUGTVGF HQTGXGT *QYGXGT VJG DQTFGTU KP 9GUVGTP 'WTQRG YGTG PQY XKTVWCNN[ UGV #37+6#+0' +P VJG GPF 2KRRKPʼnU TGUKUVCPEG CICKPUV %JCTNGU VJG $CNF JCF DGGP KP XCKP +V TGUWNVGF KP EKXKN YCT GXQMKPI CPCTEJ[ KP VJG GPF +P VJG UWD MKPIFQO YCU FKUUQNXGF 0GXGTVJGNGUU #SWKVCKPG UQQP GNWFGF HTQO WPFGT VJG (TGPEJ MKPIʼnU TGKIP HQT KPUVCPEG WPFGT %JCTNGU +++ +P #SWKVCKPGʼnU HWTVJGT JKUVQT[ KV YQWNF EQPVKPWG VQ HWNHKN CP KORQTVCPV CPF RCTVN[ KPFGRGPFGPV TQNG UGG (TCPEG H¾QFCNG 2—2+0 ++

1DQNG #SWKVCKPG. # 5OCNN ETQUU 2+22+ 085 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU #38+ 6#0+#. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

75


1DQNG /GNNG. # 5OCNN ETQUU 2+2+085 +' '1 4 2KRRKPWU OQPQITCO KP UOCNN EKTENG /'68..1. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG -ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCDKPGVV -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ #U KP /) EH PQ VJG KPUETKRVKQP UJQWNF DG 2+2+085 4': '3

(4#0%+# 1%%+&'06#.+5 *GTG CNVGTPCVGN[ VJG %CTQNKPIKCPU CPF VJG 4QDGTVKPGU RNC[ C TQNG 'XGPVWCNN[ VJG 4QDGTVKPGU YKNN OGTIG KPVQ VJG %CRGVKCPU UGG (TCPEG (¾QFCNG %#41.+0)+#05 %*#4.'5 NG %*#78'

6JG EQKPU QH %JCTNGU VJG $CNF ECP DG UWDFKXKFGF KP XCTKQWU ENCUUGU CPF UWDENCUUGU

%NCUU

C 9KVJ ETQUU CPF OKPV KP HKGNF

&GPKGT /GNNG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': (4 4 +P VYQ NKPGU /'6# ..8/ YKVJ RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJG NKPGU. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

D 9KVJ DWUV CPF OKPV PCOG KP HKGNF

&GPKGT $QWTIGU. # #TOQWTGF CPF NCWTGCVG DWUV N %#4.85 4' 4 +P VYQ NKPGU $+68 4+%'5. /'% /) IT. 44 #VVTCEVKXG URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG QPN[ V[RG FKURNC[KPI C RQTVTCKV QH %JCTNGU VJG $CNF

F 9KVJ ETQUU CPF OQPQITCO

&GPKGT 6QWNQWUG. # %TQUU %#4.85 ': ( 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 61.85# %+8+. /'% /) IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI

&GPKGT 6QWNQWUG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 61.15#. /'% /) IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

76


&GPKGT 6QWNQWUG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 61.15#. /'% /) IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

1DQNG 6QWNQWUG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 61.15#. /'% /) IT. 4 # NKVVNG DNQVEJ[ VQPG DWV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

G %TQUU CPF VGORNG

&GPKGT 2CTKU. # 6GORNG 2#4+5++ %+8+6#5 4 %TQUU %#4.85 4': (4. /'% /) IT. 5NKIJVGN[ RKVVGF XGT[ HKPG

8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 4GKOU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING %#41.85 4': (4 4 6GORNG 4'/+5 %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. /KPQT UETCVEJGU QP VJG QDXGTUG XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO (TQO JQCTF )QGU

&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING %#4.85 4': (4 4 6GORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.%+1. /'% /) IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO (TQO JQCTF )QGU

77


%NCUU

9KVJ )4#6+# & + 4':

&GPKGT %WTVKUCUQPGP. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU +%846+5#510+'0. /'% /) IT. #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

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¾U 6JG CD DG[ VJQWIJ QPG QH VJG YGCNVJKGUV KP (TCPEG JCF PQ OKPV KP 2CTKU KVUGNH CPF VJGTG YCU PQPG CV 5¾G\ VJG FKQEGUG KP YJKEJ %QWTEGUUKP YCU UKVWCVGF 5¾G\ KU KPFGGF VJG QPN[ GRKUEQRCN UGG KP PQTVJGTP (TCPEG YJKEJ RNC[GF PQ RCTV KP VJG )&4 EQKPCIG # OKPV CV %QWTEGUUKP YQWNF JCXG OCFG KV RQUUKDNG HQT VJG TGPVU QH VJG NCTIG ITQWR QH CDDCVKCN GUVCVGU KP VJG TGIKQP VQ DG VWTPGF KPVQ EQKP QP VJG URQV CPF IQ HCT VQ GZRNCKPKPI VJG EQOOQPPGUU QH VJGUG EQKPU VQFC[ /'% R

&GPKGT .G /CPU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 5OCNN ETQUU %+01/#0+5 %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. /KUVCMG KP VJG FKG QH VJG TGXGTUG CDQWV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 5VWVVICTV %QPUKFGTKPI VJG CRRGCTCPEG KP UGXGTCN JQCTFU VJKU EQKP EQWNF JCXG DGGP UVTWEM WPFGT DQVJ %JCTNGU VJG $CNF QT %JCT NGU VJG 5KORNG

&GPKGT 1TNGCPU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU #84'.+#0+5 %+86#5. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

&GPKGT 2CNCKU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU 2#.#6+08 /10'. /'% XCT /) XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG 6KGVLGP *CODWTI #WEVKQP PQ 2KNCTV\ -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG KNNWUVTCVKQPU KP /) CPF /'% UJQY C PQTOCN NCUV # KP 2#.#6+0# DWV JGTG KV KU ENGCTN[ CP 8

&GPKGT 2CTKU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU 2#4+5++ %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. 4 2NGCUKPI RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG )QTP[ /QUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

78


1DQNG 4QWGP. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO + )4#6+# & 4': 4 %TQUU 4168++#%85 %++. /'% /) IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG (KPP -GPFCN 'Z , ( %JQYP EQNNGEVKQP

&GPKGT 5V &GPKU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU 5%+∆+1085+8/. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV

6JG EQKPU QH VJG OKPV /GNNG CTG UGRCTCVGN[ ENCUUKHKGF UGG (TCPEG %QWPV[ QH 2QKVQW PQU

&GPKGT /GNNG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4': (4 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO /'68..1. /'% /) IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP $QWIJV GZ &GEMGT EQNNGEVKQP 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F

1DQNG /GNNG. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO UOCNN ETQUU DGNQY - 4 %TQUU /'68..1. /'% /) IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

%NCUU

9KVJ VJG VKVNG +/2'4#614

&GPKGT $QWTIGU. # %TQUU %#4.85 +/2 #8) 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO $+684+%'5 %+8+. /'% /) IT. /CIPKHKEGPV VQPG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU +V KU PQV ENGCT YJQO VJKU CPF VJG HQNNQYKPI EQKP UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ 1PN[ VYQ TWNGTU EQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF %JCTNGU VJG $CNF CPF %JCTNGU VJG (CV QPN[ VJG[ JCXG JGNF KORGTKCN VKVNGU /) VCMGU PQ EJQKEG CPF ENCUUKHKGU VJGO WPFGT .CVG 0KPVJ %GPVWT[ QH CP 'ORGTQT %JCTNGU /'% ENCUUKHKGU VJGO WPFGT %JCTNGU VJG $CNF EH YJKEJ YCU EJQ UGP JGTG 6JG NGVVGTKPI QH PQ KU VJG UCOG CU VJCV QH PQ

79


1DQNG $QWTIGU. # %TQUU %#4.85 +/2 #8 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO $+684+%'5 %+8+. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU /) JCU CPF DWV DQVJ UJQY C FKHHGTGPV VGZV HTQO VJKU QPG +P /'% VJGTG KU PQ CNUQ YKVJ FKHHGTGPV VGZV (QT VJG EQKP UVTWEM D[ %JCTNGU VJG $CNF KP +VCN[ UGG MKPIFQO +VCN[

#HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH %JCTNGU VJG $CNF JKU UQP .QWKU ++ VJG 5VCOOGTGT KU MKPI HTQO VQ #HVGT JKO JKU VYQ UQPU .QWKU +++ CPF %CTNQOCP ++ VQIGVJGT TWNG VJG EQWPVT[ 1H EQWTUG VJGTG KU UQOG FKURWVG CDQWV VJG FKXKUKQP %CTNQOCP HQT KPUVCPEG IQV $WTIWPF[ CPF #SWKVCKPG 6QIGVJGT VJG[ HQWIJV VJG 8KMKPIU CPF $QUQ .QWKU ++ JCF [GV CP QVJGT UQP HTQO JKU UGEQPF OCTTKCIG %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG #HVGT VJG FGCVJU QH %CTNQOCP CPF .QWKU +++ EQOGU %JCTNGU VJG (CV *G KU HTQO VJG )GTOCP DTCPEJ C UQP QH .QWKU VJG )GTOCP .WFYKI FGT &GWVUEJG +P VJKU ECRCEKV[ JG KU MKPI QH DQVJ )GTOCP[ CPF +VCN[ #V VJG TGSWGUV QH VJG RQRG JG HKIJVU VJG 5CTCEGPU CPF KU ETQYPGF GORGTQT KP 9JGP JG YCU CRRQKPVGF UWEEGUUQT QH %CTNQOCP KP (TCPEG VJG ITGCV TGCNO QH %JCTNGOCIPG UGGOGF TG GUVCD NKUJGF *QYGXGT VJG 8KMKPIU KPXCFGF VJG EQWPVT[ CPF DGUKGIGF 2CTKU 1PN[ CV C JKIJ RTKEG EQWNF JG RWTEJCUG RGCEG CPF UCHGIWCTF JKU TGKIP JCXKPI VQ CNNQY VJG 8KMKPIU VQ RKNNCIG $WTIWPF[ 5JQTVN[ CHVGT VJCV KP JG FGEGCUGU 1PEG CICKP VJG TGCNO HCNNU CRCTV EQO RNGVGN[ 0QDKNKV[ ITGCVN[ CFOKTKPI VJG HCEV VJCV 1FQ UQP QH 4QDGTV VJG 5VTQPI GXGPVWCNN[ FTQXG VJG 8KMKPIU CYC[ VJG[ GNGEVGF JKO MKPI QH (TCPEKC %JCTNGU VJG $CNF UQQP CEMPQYNGFIGF 1FQ CU &WMG QH (TCPEG CPF JKU UWEEGUUQT %CTQNKPIKCP VTCFKVKQP YCU PQY FKUEQPVKPWGF WPVKN CNVJQWIJ KP %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG YCU ETQYPGF MKPI CU YGNN 9JGP 1FQ FKGF KP JKU UQP 4QDGTV + CEEGRVGF %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG CU MKPI .CVGT JG YKNN FGRQUG %JCTNGU VQ DGEQOG MKPI JKOUGNH KH QPN[ HQT C [GCT #HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG CPQVJGT FKUEQPVKPWCVKQP UGVU KP 4CQWN QH VJG 4QDGT VKPGU DGEQOGU MKPI 'XGPVWCNN[ VJG %CTQNKPIKCPU TGVWTP YKVJ .QWKU +8 .QVJCKT

CPF .QWKU 8 YKVJ YJQO VJG %CTQNKPIKCP GTC EQOGU VQ CP GPF CPF VJG %CRGVKCPU GPVGT (QT VJG EQKP UVTWEM D[ .QWKU ++ VQIGVJGT YKVJ JKU YKHG #PIKNDGTIC UGG $GPGXGPVWO #FGNEJKU %#4.1/#0

&GPKGT #TNGU. # %TQUU %#4.'/#085 4' 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO #4.'# %+8+5 :. /'% /) IT. 4 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

80


%*#4.'5 NG )415

&GPKGT #TNGU. # %TQUU %#4.85 +++ 2'4#6 4 -CTQNWU OQPQITCO #4'.# %+8+5 :+. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU

+P C UKIPKHKECPV RCTV QH VJG QNF (TCPEG OKFK EQOGU WPFGT (TCPEKC QEEKFGPVCNKU COQPI YJKEJ RCTVU QH VJG 0QTVJ CPF EKVKGU NKMG 5VTCUDQWTI CPF %QNQIPG %*#4.'5 NG 5+/2.'

&GPKGT $TWIIG. # $NWPFGTGF -CTQNWU OQPQITCO %4#6#e 2': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG YGFIG KP GCEJ CPING $48%%+# /1. /'% /) IT. 44 (NCP ETCEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT -ÌNP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING -841.85 4': 4 %QNQPKC OQPQITCO 5 %1.10+# #. /'% /) IT. /KPQT HNCP ETCEM YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU (T½TG CNYC[U TGHGTU VQ /) #U VJG FCVGU JG KPFKECVGU 6JGTG CTG PWODGTU KP /) CNN QH VJGO WPFGT VJG PCOG QH %JCTNGU VJG $CNF

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ *·XGTPKEM 0QTOCNN[ VJG PWODGT YQWNF DG KP /) CPF *·X 1P VJQUG JQYGXGT -#41.85 KU TGPFGTGF TGCUQPCDN[ YGNN *GTG YG UGG '8&1. YKVJ C UOCNN VTKCPING WPFGT VJG & VQ VJG TKIJV 6JCV EQPEWTU YKVJ /) CPF *·X 6JGTG UGGO VQ DG QPN[ VYQ URGEKOGPU $GTNKP CPF IT )CTKGN :. )CTKGN EQNNGEVKQP 6JGTG '1& . ECP DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF CEEQTFKPI VQ /)

&GPKGT 2CTKU. # -CTQNWU OQPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 +P HQWT NKPGU 2#4+5 5+8+6 . /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

81


&GPKGT 5VTCUDQWTI. # %TQUU 941+85 2+85 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU #4)'06+ 0#%+8+65. /'% /) IT. 4 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ CVVTCEVKXG VQPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&GPKGT 8GTFWP. # 4': KP HKGNF %#41.85 4 %TQUU 8+4&80 %+8+% . /'% /) XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 0QV GZCEVN[ /) YJKEJ GPFU YKVJ %+8+685 DWV PGCTN[ TGNCVGF VQ KV

.17+5 +8

&GPKGT %JKPQP. # &KCFGOGF DWUV T .8&18+%85 4': 4 %TQUU %#+010+ %#5641. /'% /) .GITQU IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ /) QPN[ MPQYU QH HGY URGEKOGPU .GITQU 44444 (QT HWTVJGT FGUETKRVKQP UGG 6QWTCKPG KP (TCPEG H¾QFCNG

&GPKGT .CPITGU. # + : KP HKGNF *.8&188+%85 4 %TQUU .+0%10+5 %865. /'% /) IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU 0QVG KP /'% 6JG V[RG DGECOG KOOQDKNK\GF FWTKPI VJG UGEQPF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ &WOCU CPF VJKU URGEKOGP OC[ YGNN JCXG DGGP UVTWEM CHVGT .QWKU FGCVJ

.16*#4+75

&GPKGT %JCNQP UWT 5CÊPG. # $ KP HKGNF .16#4+85 4': 4 %TQUU %#8+.10 %+86. /'% /) IT. 4 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 9TWEM $GTNKP #WEVKQP PQ $ HQT $WTIWPFKC

82


&GPKGT $QWTIGU. # %TQUU YKVJKP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU .16'4+85 4': 4 6GORNG $+684+%'5 %+8+6#5. /) IT. &CTM VQPG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(KPP -GPFCN 'Z , ( %JQYP EQNNGEVKQP /'% FCVGU VJKU V[RG DCEM VQ VJG VJ EGPVWT[ EQPUGSWGPVN[ KV KU NKUVGF KP XQN 8 URGEKOGP QH VJG /'% UGG /'% + R %JGEM FCVGU .QVJCKT OCR UJQYU

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½IPG KP CU %CTNQOCPʼn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ʼnU RQYGT PQY VJCV KP JG FGEKFGU VQ FGRQUG %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG CPF DGEQOG MKPI JKOUGNH 6JG UCOG [GCT VJG ITGCV XCUUCNU GNGEV JKO MKPI KP 4GKOU DWV JKU TGKIP KU QPN[ VQ NCUV QPG [GCT *G VJGP OGGVU JKU GPF KP VJG $CVVNG CV 5QKUUQPU CICKPUV %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG YJQ KU UWDUGSWGPVN[ DGCVGP D[ *WIJ VJG )TGCV CPF *GTDGTV QH 8GTOCPFQKU '7&'5 1&1

&GPKGT .KOQIGU. # 1&1 OQPQITCO DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU )4#6+# & + 4' 4 %TQUU .+/18+%#5 %+8+5. /'% /) IT. 2GTHGEV RKGEG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV #WEVKQP PQ

83


&GPKGT 5QKUUQPU. # 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ 1 & 1 CV VJG GPF QH VJG NKODU )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU 58'55+ %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. #VVTCEVKXG VQPG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG EH / W / #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 6QWNQWUG. # %TQUU 1&&1 4': (4 % 4 1&&1 KP EKTENG 61.15# %+8+. /'% /) IT. 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

&GPKGT 6QWTU. # 1&1 4: OQPQITCO /+5'4+%14&+# &+ 4 %TQUU 68410'5 %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 6JKU KU QH ETWFG UV[NG CPF KU RQUUKDNG C RQUVJWOQWU EQR[ QH VJG HQTGIQKPI EQKPU .CHCWTKG CVVTKDWVGU EQKPU QH VJKU V[RG VQ 4CQWN .CHCWTKG C /'% KU KP C OWEJ EQWTUGT UV[NG VJCP VJKU EQKP

4#17. 4CQWN YCU UQP QH 4KEJCTF FWMG QH $WTIWPF[ *G YCU OCTTKGF VQ 'OOC VJG FCWIJ VGT QH 4QDGTV + YJQ YCU UKUVGT VQ *WIJ VJG )TGCV #HVGT 4QDGTVʼnU FGCVJ ETQYPGF MKPI KP 5QKUUQPU KP VJG 5CKPV /¾FCTF D[ )CWVKGT D[ VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH 5GPU YJQ JCF ETQYPGF 1FQ CPF 4QDGTV CU YGNN 6JG EQWPVU QH #WXGTIPG 4QWGTIWG CPF 6QWNQWUG RCKF JQOOCIG VQ JKO +P 4CQWN FKGU EJKNFNGUU *KU DTQVJGT *WIJ VJG $NCEM UWEEGGFU JKO CU FWMG QH $WTIWPF[

&GPKGT %JCTVTGU. # -CTQNWU OQPITCO %4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU %#46+5 %+8+6#5. /'% /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU +P /) VJG KNNWUVTCVKQP FKHHGTU ITCXGN[ HTQO VJG FGUETKRVKQP 6JG PWODGTU CPF CNN DGCT VJG FGHQTOGF %JCTNGOCIPG OQPQITCO FG 9KV <WT &CVKGTWPI 5R·VMCTQNKPIK UEJGT /Ã’P\GP 5EJYGK\GT /Ã’P\DN·VVGT R

84


&GPKGT %JCVGCWFWP. # 4QFWNHWU OQPQITCO %4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU &80+5 %#56..+. /'% /) IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&GPKGT 1TNGCPU. # 4QFWNHWU OQPQITCO %4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU #84'. #0+5 %+86#5. /'% /) IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN /) CNN TGXGTUGU XCT[

(4#0%' /+&+ +P VJG FQOKPKQPU QH .QWKU VJG 2KQWU YGTG FKXKFGF COQPI JKU VJTGG UQPU (TQO VJKU FKXK UKQP C RGEWNKCT OKFFNG VGTTKVQT[ TGUWNVGF FGXQNXKPI QP VJG GNFGUV UQP .QVJCKT YJQ CNUQ KPJGTKVGF VJG KORGTKCN VKVNG 6JKU OKFFNG TGCNO UVTGVEJGF HTQO (TKUKC VQ FGGR KPUKFG +VCN[ +V YQWNF NCUV .QVJCKTU NKHGVKOG DWV YCU TGFKXKFGF KP .16*#4+75 +

&GPKGT &QTGUVCF. # %TQUU *+16+#485 ++'+# 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU &14 '5 Ő 6# 685. /'% /) IT. 4 XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

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

&GPKGT &QTGUVCF. # %TQUU YKVJ C RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING +16#/85 +2 /'+4#6 4 6GORNG &14'56#685 /10. /'% /) IT. 4 /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO X )GNFGT V[RG R RN ++ C D 6JKU V[RG KU ENQUGN[ TGNCVGF VQ V[RG 6[RG EQOGU KPVQ EKTEWNCVKQP QPN[ CHVGT CRRTQZ 8 )GNFGT ENCKOU VJCV VJG OKPV DGKPI &QTGUVCF UJQWNF DG FQWDVGF 6JG CDDTGXKCVKQP /10 HQT /10'6# CRRGCTU HQT VJG HKTUV VKOG QPN[ VQ DGEQOG IGPGTCNN[ WUGF QP NCVGT V[RGU QH %JCTNGU VJG $CNF 6JGUG GZCEV EKTEWOUETKRVKQPU ECPʼnV DG HQWPF KP /)

85


&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING .86*#4+85 +/2 4 6GORNG :2+56+#0# 4'.+)+1. MEC: --, /) IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO X )GNFGT ,/2 V[RG H #EEQTFKPI VQ X )GNFGT KV KU FQWDVCDNG VJCV VJKU V[RG YCU UVTWEM WPFGT .QVJCKT /) JCU VJG UCOG QDXGTUG DWV VJG TGXGTUG UJQYU 4'.+%1 /) UJQYU QP QDXGTUG * .86 VJG TGXGTUG DGKPI GSWCN

&GPKGT /KNCP. # 5OCNN ETQUU *.16*#4+85 +/2 4 /'&+1. KP HKGNF. /'% /) IT. 44 %NGCPGF URGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQXGODGT PQ (TQO JQCTF 4CCNVG

9JGP .QVJCKT + FKGU KP VJG NQPI UVTGVEJGF VGTTKVQTKGU CTG FKXKFGF VJTGG YC[U COQPI JKU UQPU +VCN[ IQGU VQ .QWKU ++ YJQ YCU CNTGCF[ MKPI VJGTG CPF YCU PQY ETQYPGF GORGTQT VJG PQTVJGTP VGTTKVQTKGU WPFGT VJG PCOG QH .QVJCTKPIKC IQ VQ .QVJCKT ++ CPF VJG 2TQXGPEG IQGU VQ %JCTNGU %JCTNGU VJG $CNF CVVGORVU VQ UGK\G VJG NCPFU QH JKU EQWUKPU # EJCPIG FQGUPʼn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¾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ʼnV IQXGTPGF D[ C FWMG UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU CPF 7RRGT .QT TCKPG VJCV NCVGT YCU VQ DGEQOG VJG FWEJ[ QH .QTTCKPG UGG #NUCEG .QTTCKPG #U JGKTU VQ VJG QNF OKFFNG TGCNO VJG TWNGTU QH $WTIWPFKC #TGNCVG CPF $WTIWPFKC %KUKWTCPC YGTG MKPI KP .QTTCKPG JQYGXGT KH RTGUGPV CV CNN UQNGN[ TGOCKPGF FWMG 86


(4#0%+# 14+'06#.+5 %JCTNGOCIPGʼn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ʼnU UQP #TPWNH

CHVGT YJKEJ .QWKU VJG %JKNF KU VJG NCUV QPG HTQO VJG JQWUG QH VJG %CTQN KPIKCPU JG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ -QPTCF + #407.( XQP - 406'0

&GPKGT /CKP\. # 6GORNG /1 %10%+8'% +8+6 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING #401.& 85 4'. /'% /) IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN /1)106+# YCU VJG URGNNKPI QH VJG PCOG KP /CKP\ /'% R

.7&9+) FCU -+0&

&GPKGT -ÌNP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING .8&188+%85 4': 4 %QNQPKC OQPQITCO 5 %1.10+# #. /'% /) IT. 4 /KPQT GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN /) JCU VJG QDXGTUG NGIGPF .8&188%854':

87


+//1$+.+5#6+10 +P VJG PCOG QH .8&18+%85

&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU .8118+%85 4 6GORNG 4+0++4+%1 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 0WOKUOCVKEC 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ EH DTKGH $KDN 0CV

&GPKGT #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU +8118%85 + 4 6GORNG YKVJ ETQUU DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. : 2+406 4'.1. IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

1DQNG #PQP[OQWU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING . +58%5 +/2 4 6GORNG :+%#0#4'.41. IT. /KPQT HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

+P VJG PCOG QH %*#4.'5

&GPKGT 3WGPVQXKE. # /QPQITCO )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP CP CPING CPF C TKPI KP CPQVJGT 188'06188+%. IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO (¾ECOR JQCTF &WOCU (¾ECOR YKVJ TKPI KP QPG CPING QT YKVJ TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP QPG CPING

88


(4#0%'

(TQO VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ QP (TCPEG 1EEKFGPVCNG UVCTVGF VQ GXQNXG VQ OQFGTP (TCPEG 7PFGT VJG NCUV QH VJG %CTQNKPIKCPU VJG EQWPVT[ JCF HCNNGP CRCTV 6JG TGIKQP PQTVJ QH 2CTKU YCU VJG UQNG VGTTKVQT[ TGOCKPKPI FKTGEVN[ WPFGT %CTQNKPIKCP TWNG #NN QVJGT VGTTKVQTKGU YGTG UECVVGTGF COQPI OKIJV[ XCUUCNU FWMGU OCTITCXGU CPF EQWPVU UQOG QH YJQ COCUUGF IGPWKPG RTKPEKRCNKVKGU NKMG (NCPFGTU 8GTOCPFQKU 0QTOCPF[ $WTIWPF[ 6QWNQWUG #SWK VCKPG CPF $CTEGNQPC 9KVJKP VJGUG RTKPEKRCNKVKGU VJG UECVVGTKPI EQPVKPWGF UQ VJCV OCP[ C EQWPV CU HQT KPUVCPEG VJG EQWPVU QH #PLQW CPF QH $NQKU EQWNF CEEWOWNCVG OQOGPVQWU FQOKP KQPU &GURKVG VJKU UECVVGTKPI UQEKGV[ CPF EWNVWTG TGVCKPGF C FKUVKPEV WPKV[ )TCFWCNN[ VJGUG UGRCTCVG RTKPEKRCNKVKGU YGTG WPKVGF WPFGT VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP VJG RTQEGUU DGKPI XKTVWCNN[ EQORNGVGF D[ YJCVGXGT TGOCKPGF CWVQPQOQWU YQWNF DG UQQP VQ HQNNQY 1PG &WEJ[ YQWNF NCUV GXGP KH KV NQUV CNN QH KVU (TGPEJ RQUUGUUKQPU $WTIWPF[ +PKVKCNN[ YKGNFKPI RQYGT QPN[ KP VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU VJG OCTTKCIGU QH /CTKC CPF /CZKOKNKCP CPF QH VJGKT UQP 2JKNKRU VJG (CKT VQ ,GCPPG HTQO VJG *QWUG QH VJG 4G[GU %CVQNKEQU YQWNF NGCF VQ C YQTNF GORKTG #U VJG VTCPUKVKQP QH VJG &WEJ[ QH (TCPEG VQ VJG -KPIFQO QH (TCPEG YCU DCTGN[ RCNRCDNG VJG HQNNQY KPI YKNN DG FKUEWUUGF VTKEJQVQOQWUN[ &WEJ¾ FG (TCPEG (TCPEG 4Q[CNG CPF (TCPEG (¾QFCNG &7%* &' (4#0%' #NVJQWIJ JKU HCVJGT 4QDGTV + JCF DGGP C 4QDGTVKPG -KPI QH (TCPEG YKVJ *WIJ VJG )TGCV VJG TWNG QH VJG %CRGVKCPU KP VJG MKPIFQO EQOOGPEGF *WIJ VJG )TGCV OCTTKGF VJTGG VKOGU 'CFJKNF FCWIJVGT QH MKPI 'FYCTF VJG 'NFGT QH 'PINCPF CPF *GFYKIG UKUVGT QH VJG )GTOCP MKPI 1VVQ + YGTG VYQ QH JKU YKXGU *GFYKIG DQTG JKO EJKNFTGP GCEJ QPG RNC[KPI C UKIPKHKECPV TQNG KP (TGPEJ JKUVQT[ +P %JCTNGU 5KORNGZ CRRQKPVGF *WIJ VJG )TGCV VQ UWEEGGF JKU HCVJGT #HVGT VJG NCVVGTʼnU FGOKUG JQYGXGT *WIJ UWRRQTVGF VJG GNGEVKQP QH JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY 4WFQNRJ QH $WTIWPF[ *WIJ YJKNG TGVCKPKPI EQPVTQN QH JKU EQWPVKGU CNQPI VJG DCPMU QH VJG .QKTG CPF UWTTQWPFKPI 2CTKU CPF VJG CDDG[U QH 5V /CTVKP FG 6QWTU /CT OQWTVKGT CPF 5V &GPKU VJWU TGPQWPEGF VJG ETQYP 0QPGVJGNGUU KV YQWNF DG *WIJ YJQ YQWNF NGCF (TCPEG VQ KVU HWVWTG 4WFQNRJ 4CQWN YCU NCTIGN[ FGRGPFGPV QP *WIJ CPF VJG NCVVGT JCF .QWKU +8 UQP QH %JCTNGU 5KORNGZ ETQYPGF MKPI CHVGT 4WFQNRJʼnU FGCVJ KP *WIJ DGECOG &WZ (TCPEQTWO CPF PCOGF JKOUGNH KP QOPKDWU TGIPKU PQUVTKU UGEWPFWU C PQDKU *KU FQOKPKQPU UGRCTCVGF .QWKU +8 QH UWDUVCPVKCN RCTVU QH VJG MKPIFQO *QYGXGT .QWKU +8 FKF UVTKXG VQYCTFU CP KPFGRGPFGPV IQXGTPOGPV HQTEKPI *WIJ VQ CNN[ YKVJ 1VVQ + 6JKU WNVKOCVGN[ NGF VQ C TGEQPEKNKCVKQP QH VJG EQPHNKEV 8KU¾ +P .QWKU +8 HGNN KPVQ 8KMKPI JCPFU RTQORVKPI *WIJ VQ HQTEG 3WGGP )GTDGTIC VQ ITCPV JKO EQPVTQN QXGT .CQP YJGTGWRQP 1VVQ + UVCTVGF C ECORCKIP CICKPUV *WIJ +P RGCEG YCU TGCEJGF KP 5QKUUQPU 5VKNN CHVGT .QWKUʼn FGCVJ )GTDGTIC EQWNF QPN[ DTKPI JGT UQP .QVJCKT VQ VJG VJTQPG YKVJ *WIJʼnU EQPUGPV #NVJQWIJ JG PGXGT YQWNF DGEQOG MKPI *WIJ UQNGN[ FGVGTOKPGF VJG EQWTUG QH (TCPEG JGPEG JKU VKVNG *WIJ VJG )TGCV

*7)7'5 NG )4#0&

&GPKGT 5GPNKU. # *8)1 &7: CTQWPF UOCNN ETQUU EKTENG QH RGNNGVU CPF %4#6+# & + 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU 5+.8# 0'%6+5 VYQ NKPGU DGVYGGP KV QPG ETQUU CDQXG CPF QPG DGNQY. & .GITQU IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG TGOCTMCDNG RGFKITGG CVVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 'Z /G[GT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z $QTFGCWZ EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 2TKGWT EQNNGEVKQP %J 2TKGWT CPF 'NKUCDGVJ 2QWTEJGTQN KP #TGVJWUG :::8+ YTKVG %GU RK½EGU UQPV GZVT¿OGOGPV TCTGU WP DGN GZGORNCKTG SWK UG VTQWXCKV FCPU NC EQNNGEVKQP /G[GT GUV RCUU¾ GP FCPU NC EQNNGEVKQP $QTFGCWZ GV GP FCPU EGNNG FG / 2TKGWT +P QNFGT NKVGTCVWTG VJKU EQKP KU CVVTKDWVGF VQ *WIJ %CRGV CPF KU VJQWIJV VQ JCXG DGGP UVTWEM KP *WIJ QP ,WN[ UV QH YCU ETQYPGF MKPI KP 0Q[QP GPFKPI VJG %CTQNKPIKCP GTC CPF KU UQOGVKOGU TGHGTTGF VQ CU EQTQPCVKQP FGPKGT *QYGXGT VJCV VJKU EQKP UJQWNF DG CVTTKDWVGF PQV VQ *WIJ %CRGV DWV TCVJGT VQ *WIJ VJG )TGCV YJQ PGXGT JCF DGGP MKPI VJGTGHQTG VJG )4#6+# & + 4': KU C NKVVNG UWTRTKUKPI KU GZRNCKPGF D[ .GITQU CU HQNNQYU .GU RK½EGU ¯ NC N¾ IGPFG *8)1 &8: KOKVGPV EGNNGU FG .QWKU +8 Fʼn1WVTGOGT ¯ NʼnKPUETKRVKQP EQPEGPVTKSWG .8&18+% GV NGWT CVVTKDWVKQP PG HCKV CWEWP FQWVG GNNGU UQPV NʼnĚWXTG Fʼn*WIJ VJG )TGCV SWK RQUU¾FCKV 5GPNKU 'NNGU QPV RGWV ¿VTG ¾V¾ HTCR R¾GU CW OQOGPV FG NC ECRVKXKV¾ FW TQK GP XQKT .CHCWTKG 6T¾UQT FW :½ UKGENG VTQWX¾ C 6QWUUQP $WNN 5QE (T 0WO R &WRNGUU[ ENCUUKHKGU VJKU EQKP WPFGT *WIJ %CRGV CU &WZ (TCPEQTWO

89


&GPKGT %J³VGCW .CPFQP. # /QPQITCO QFQPKGP FG 4CQWN )4#6+# & + 4 %TQUU %#56+5 .#0&+0+. .GITQU IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG OQPQITCO QFQPKGP FG 4CQWN KU C TGXGTUGF ( CP 4 CV VJG VQR YKVJ VYQ 1 U CU OQPQITCO +P FG 9KV <WT &CVKGTWPI 5R·VMCTQNKPIKUEJGT /Ã’P\GP 5EJYGK\GT /Ã’P\DN·VVGT R VJKU EQKP CPF VJG PWODGTU CPF KU ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT %NCUU $ QH 4CQWN +P VJKU CTVKENG VJG EQKPU QH %NCUU $ CTG UWTOKUGF VQ DG UVTWEM CHVGT 4CQWNʼnU FC[U RNCEKPI VJGO KP VJG RGTKQF QH *WIJ VJG )TGCV VJG RNCEGU %J³VGCW .CPFQP 'VCORGU CPF 1TN¾CPU YGTG VJGP RCTV QH VJG &WEJ[ QH (TCPEG +P VJG UCOG CTVKENG VJG CUUWORVKQP KU OCFG VJCV VCMKPI VJG UVCVG QH VJGKT EQPUGTXCVKQP KPVQ CEQWPV VJGUG EQKPU %NCUU $ OWUV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM UJQTVN[ CHVGT VJG TGKIP QH 4CQWN 6JKU KU CNN VJG OQTG CUVQPKUJKPI CU .GITQU CVVTKDWVGU PTU CPF DQVJ HTQO 1TN¾CPU VQ *WIJ %CRGV 6JKU VGZV EJQQUGU VQ CFJGTG VQ .GITQUʼn XGTUKQP

&GPKGT —VCORGU. # /QPQITCO QFQPKGP FG 4CQWN )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU 56#/2+5 %#6'.+. .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5GG PQVGU CV PQ

*7)7'5 %#2'6

#HVGT *WIJ VJG )TGCVʼnU FGCVJ *WIJ %CRGV DGECOG FWMG QH (TCPEG CPF JKU DTQVJGT 1FQ FWMG QH $WTIWPF[ +P VJG HGWF DGVYGGP .QVJCKT CPF VJG 1VVQPGU JG VQQM UKFGU YKVJ VJG %CTQN KPIKCPU 'XGP DGHQTG VJG FGOKUG QH .QWKU 8 JG EQCNGUEGF YKVJ #FCNDGTQ QH 4GKOU 9JGP .QWKU 8 FKGF EJKNFNGUU *WIJ YCU VJG HKTUV KP NKPG VQ UWEEGGF JKO +P /C[ QH YKVJ VJG CKF QH #FCNDGTQ QH 4GKOU JG YCU EJQUGP MKPI D[ VJG 4QDGTVKPG XCU UCNU VJG EQTQPCVKQP D[ #FCNDGTQ VCMKPI RNCEG QP VJG TF QH ,WN[ KP 0Q[QP *WIJ KPUVCPVN[ JCF VQ VCMG WR CTOU CICKPUV %JCTNGU QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG DTQVJGT QH .QVJCKT YJQ YCU EJKGHN[ UWRRQTVGF D[ VJG EQWPVU QH 6TQ[GU $NQKU 8GTOCPFQKU CPF VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH 5GPU 6JG DCVVNG NCUVGF WPVKN 5QOG VGPUKQP TGOCKPGF FWG VQ COQPI QVJGTU 1FQ QH $NQKU CPF #TPWNRJ YJQ JCF DGGP CRRQKPVGF KP 4GKOU D[ %JCTNGU 6JG %CRGV PCOG FQGUPʼnV GOGTIG WPVKN VJG VJ EGPVWT[ *WIJʼnU RQUUGUUKQPU YGTG TGOCTMC DN[ UOCNN VJG TGIKQP CTQWPF 1TNGCPU CPF 2CTKU CPF VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP QH 1KUG #KUPG CPF VJG[ CEVWCNN[ VQQM VJG UJCRG QH VJG VGTTKVQTKGU QPEG QYPGF D[ JKU HCVJGT *WIJ VJG )TGCV

&GPKGT 1TN¾CPU. # /QPQITCO QFQPKGP FG 4CQWN )4#6+# & + 4 %TQUU #84'.+#0+5 %+8+6#5. .GITQU IT. 44 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5GG PQVGU CV PQ

&GPKGT 1TN¾CPU. # /QPQITCO QFQPKGP FG 4CQWN %4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU #84'. #0+5 %+8+6#. .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5GG PQVGU CV PQ

90


$KUJQR #4017. ++

&GPCT 1TN¾CPU. # * ; ) 1 CTQWPF EKV[ ICVG & + &':64#$' 4 5JQTV ETQUU #;4'. #0+5 %+8+6#5. .GITQU IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ * QH *;)1 VQ VJG TKIJV QH VJG EKV[ ICVGU .GITQU FGVGTOKPGU CU %KXKVU KPUVGCF QH %KXKVCU OGPVKQPGF CDQXG .GITQU TGHGTU VQ VJG 6T¾UQT FG 6TQ[GU

$KUJQR +5'/$#4&

1DQNG 1TN¾CPU. # 0' +% DGPGCVJ EKV[ ICVG & CDQXG CPF 6# YKVJKP & + &':64#$' 4 %TQUU YKVJ CNRJC CPF QOGIC KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU #4'.+#0+5 %+8+6#. .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $GEMGPDCWGT /Ã’PEJGP 'Z /CTEJGXKNNG EQNNGEVKQP ! .GIGPF CPF UKIPU CTQWPF EKV[ ICVGU QP QDXGTUG RTKPEKRCNN[ FGPQVG &'+ &':64# $'0'&+%6# .GITQU TGHGTU VQ 6T¾UQT FG 5CKPV *KNCKTG

(4#0%' 41;#.' 6JG TGKIP QH *WIJ %CRGV ECPʼn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ʼn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ʼnU RCUUKQP CPF TGUWTTGEVKQP YGTG VQ DG TGURGEVGF CU C RGCEG RGTKQF QPEG OQTG UJQYKPI VJCV VJG MKPIU YGTGPʼnV CDNG VQ CEEQORNKUJ VJGKT HQTGOQUV VCUM QH MGGRKPI QTFGT CPF RGCEG

%#2'6+#05 *7)1 %#2'6

&GPCT $GCWXCKU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU *'48'85 *8)1 4': 4 %CTQNKPIKCP OQPQITCO $'.8#%85 %+8+6#5. & . IT. 4 /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU *GTX¾ YCU DKUJQR QH $GCWXCKU $GCWXCKU NC[ DG[QPF VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP *G JCF JKU EQKPU DGCT VJG MKPIʼnU PCOG HQT RQNKVKECN TGCUQPU QT DGECWUG VJG VGTTKVQT[ YCU C OWVWCN RQUUGUUKQP

91


1DQNG $GCWXCKU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU *'48'85 *7)1 4': 4 %CTQNKPIKCP OQPQITCO $'.8#%85 %+8+6#5. & . IT. 4 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

41$'46 ++

&GPKGT 2CTKU. # 4': KP HKGNF 416 $'4 685 4 %TQUU 2#4+5+85 %+8+6#5. & . IT. 4 9GNN UVTWEM WR YKVJ HKPG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5JKTNG[ (QZ DGSWGUV 'Z $NWPV

*'04+ +

1DQNG 6QWNQWUG. # 4': KP EKTENG #+#04+)1 4 %JTKUVQITCO QPG RGNNGV KP VJG TF CPF VJ CP INGU 21*%+1 %1*'5. & . IT. 44 9GNN UVTWEM WR XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JGUG EQKPU DGCTKPI VJG PCOG QH VJG MKPI YGTG UVTWEM D[ %QWPV 2QPU DNQQF TGNCVKXG QH *GPT[ + 6QW NQWUG QH EQWTUG NC[ QWVUKFG QH VJG 4Q[CN &QOCKP #KCPTKIQ KU VJG UQWVJGTP 4QOCP PCOG HQT 6QWNQWUG

2*+.+22' +

&GPKGT %J³VGCW .CPFQP. # $NWPFGTGF 4CQWN OQPQITCO UVTKRG DGVYGGP VYQ 1 CDQXG 5 + DGNQY CPF 2*++.2285 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UOCNN ETQUU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU .#0&10+5 %#56#. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU (TQO QP VJG %J³VGCW .CPFQP DGNQPIGF VQ VJG FQOCKP

1DQNG %J³VGCW .CPFQP UV V[RG. # $NWPFGTGF 4CQWN OQPQITCO UVTKRG DGVYGGP VYQ 1 CDQXG 5 + DGNQY CPF 2*++.2285 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UOCNN ETQUU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU .#0&10+5 %#56#. & . IT. 4 #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 'Z 2TKGWT EQNNGEVKQP

92


&GPKGT 1TNGCPU UV V[RG. # %KV[ ICVG DGVYGGP 0' +% + CDQXG CPF #6 YKVJKP 2*+. 285 : 4': & + 4 %TQUU YKVJ 5 KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU #84'.+#0+5 %+8+6#. & . IT. /KPQT FQWDNG UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

&GPCT /³EQP. # 4JQODKE ETQUU NGVVGT 1 YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 2+++285 4: 4 5 DG VYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU /#6+5%10. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$QPXCNNGV 2CTKU 6JG EKV[ ICVG KU VJG U[ODQN QH 1TNGCPU 6JG NGVVGTU FGTKXG HTQO &'+ &':64# $'0'&+%6#

5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z 0% PQ /&

.17+5 8+

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ʼnU RQUKVKQP +V FTCIIGF QP HQT [GCTU .QWKU GXGPVW CNN[ NQUKPI VJG $CVVNG CV $T¾OWNG 0QV QPN[ JCF *GPT[ PQY OCKPVCKPGF JKU RQUKVKQP KP 0QTOCPF[ DWV D[ YGFFKPI JKU FCWIJVGT VQ VJG EQWPV QH #PLQW UVTGPIVJGPGF KV UWDUVCPVKCNN[ (QT .QWKU CNUQ UQOG RQUKVKXG GHHGEVU YGTG VQ DG PQVGF VJQWIJ 9JGP GORGTQT *GKPTKEJ 8 KP XCFGF (TCPEG KP VJG VGTTKVQTKCN UQXGTGKIPU CPF XCUUCNU UVQQF WPKVGF DGJKPF VJGKT MKPI 6JKU FKURNC[ QH NQ[CNV[ VQ VJGKT UW\GTCKP HQTEGF VJG GORGTQT VQ C UYKHV TGVTGCV 5JQTVN[ DGHQTG JKU FGCVJ .QWKU 8+ DTQWIJV CDQWV VJG OCTTKCIG QH JKU UQP .QWKU 8++ VQ 'NGQP QTG JGKTGUU VQ VJG LWUV FGEGCUGF FWMG )WKNNCWOG : QH #SWKVCKPG

&GPKGT 1TNGCPU. # %KV[ ICVG DGVYGGP QOGIC CPF VJTGG JQTK\QPVCN UVTKRGU CDQXG 1 .8&18+%85 4': + 4 %TQUU KP VJG UV CPING CP # KP VJG VJ CPING CP 1 #84'.+#0+5 %+8+6#u. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG

&GPKGT 5GPU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING .8&18+%85 4': 4 6GORNG 5'0105 8++4$5. & . IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG UKIPKHKECPEG QH ++ ++ WPFGTNKPGF KP 84$5 KU WPENGCT +U VJKU VQ EQTTGEV VJG OKUUKPI + KP 5'010+5! .CHCWTKG UC[U VJGTG KU PQ EGTVCKP CVVTKDWVKQP VQ .QWKU 8+ QT .QWKU 8++ 6JG HQTO 84$5 JQYGXGT KPFKECVGU .QWKU 8+

93


.17+5 8++ .QWKU 8++ EQPVKPWGF VJG RQNKVKEU QH JKU HCVJGT VJQWIJ YKVJ NGUU CWVJQTKV[ #OQPI QVJGT VJKPIU JG JCF VQ TGNKPSWKUJ VJG PGYN[ CESWKTGF #SWKVCKPG YJGP JG UGRGTCVGF HTQO 'NGQPQTG CPF VJKU NQUU YCU GZCEGTDCVGF D[ JGT EQPUGEWVKXG OCTTKCIG VQ *GPT[ ++ QH 'PINCPF .QWKU CNUQ VQQM RCTV KP VJG PF ETWUCFG ECWUKPI C [GCT CDUGPEG HTQO JKU FQOKPKQPU *G FKOKPKUJGF VJG KPHNWGPEG QH VJG UGPGUEJCN C RQYGTHWN TGRTGUGPVCVKXG QH VJG MKPI VJWU FKU RQUKPI QH VJG )CTNCPFG HCOKN[ VJCV WR VQ VJGP JCF CNN DWV OQPQRQNKUGF VJKU QHHKEG *CF VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG WR VQ VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ WPFKURWVCDN[ JGNF VJG ITGCVGUV RQNKVKECN RQYGT KP 'WTQRG VJG EQTQPCVKQP QH *GPT[ ++ KP 'PINCPF FTGY VJG GRKEGPVTG QH RQYGT YGUVYCTF *G CNTGCF[ RQUUGUUGF ITGCV VGTTKVQTKGU 0QTOCPF[ #PLQW /CKPG CPF 6QWTCKPG CPF VJTQWIJ JKU OCTTKCIG #SWKVCKPG 6JTGG ECORCKIPU KP $TKVVCP[ HQTEGF VJG $TGVQP .QTFU VQ CEMPQYNGFIG JKU UQP )GQHHTG[ FWMG QH #PLQW CU VJG UWEEGUUQT VQ VJGKT &WMG %QPCP CPF YKVJ VJG FGCVJ QH VJG NCVVGT KP *GPT[ VQQM EQPVTQN QH $TKVVCP[ 6JG EQWPV QH 6QWNQWUG KP JCF VQ FGENCTG JKOUGNH NKGIG VQ *GPT[ ++ YJQUG RQYGT PQY GZVGPFGF VQ VJG /GFKVGTTCPGCP $[ YGFFKPI JKU UGEQPF UQP *GPT[ VQ VJG FCWIJVGT QH .QWKU 8++ JG ICKPGF 8GZKP TGIKQP CTQWPF #PFGN[U VJCV OGTIGF YKVJ 8CNQKU PQY VJG FGRCTVOGPV QH 5GPNKU JQOG VQ VJG 8CNQKU F[PCUV[

&GPKGT $QWTIGU. # $GCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI .8&18+%85 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF NCVKP ETQUU 84$5 $+ 684+%#. & . IT. 0KEG VQPG XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

&GPKGT 2CTKU VJ V[RG. # (4# 1e0 KP HKGNF .8&18+%85 4' 4 %TQUU 2#4+5++ %+8+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP &GNFGP (TQO NKUV PQ &WRNGUU[ ECNNU VJKU VJG VJ V[RG

1DQNG #SWKVCKPG PF V[RG. # %TQUU .8&18+%85 4 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU &8: #28+ 6#0+'. & . IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH .QWKU 8++ʼnU TGKIP JG CESWKTGF FWECN RQYGT KP #SWKVCKPG D[ OCTT[KPI 'NGQP QTG FKUUQNXGF KP +P 'NGQPQTG OCTTKGU *GPT[ ++ QH 'PINCPF VJGTGD[ VWTPKPI #SWKVCKPG KPVQ 'PINKUJ VGT TKVQT[ 5GG HWTVJGT WPFGT #SWKVCKPG 2QUUKDN[ UVTWEM KP $QTFGCWZ

1DQNG .CQP. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI .8&18+%85 4' 4 $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG )#.6'485 '2%. & . IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG RQVTCKVU YGNN UVTWEM WR XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 9KVJ DKUJQR )CWVKGT + QT )CWVKGT ++ .CHCWTKG ENCKOU C YGKIJV QH VQ HQT VJG FGPKGT CPF HQT VJG QDQNG 0GXGTVJGNGUU VJKU URGEKOGP KU UWDUVCPVKCNN[ UOCNNGT VJCP VJG FGPKGT %GU OQPPCKGU UQPV GNNGU FGU OQPPCKGU FG RCTKCIG QW GUV EG UKORNGOGPV RCT FKHH¾TGPEG SWG NGU ¾X¿SWGU KPUETKXGPV NG PQO FW TQK UWT NGU OQPPCKGU! .GU VGZVGU EQPPWU PʼnQPV RCU GPEQTG RGTOKU FG FQPPGT WPG UQNWVKQP ¯ EG RTQDN½OG OQP¾VCKTG &G VQWVG HCEQP EGU OQPPCKGU FQKXGPV ¿VTG EQUKF¾T¾GU EQOOG UGOK H¾QFCNGU UQWU 2JKNKRRG #WIWUVG NG TQK C WPG RCTV UWT NGU D¾P¾HKEGU 'ZRNCPCVKQP .CHCWTKG YKVJ PQ R .CQP NC[ QWVUKFG VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP

94


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ʼnV UCVKUHKGF YKVJ VJCV JG YCPVGF VQ GZVGPF JKU TQ[CN FQOCKP VQ UJQY JKOUGNH CV NGCUV VJG GSWCN QH VJG OCLQT VGTTKVQTKCN UQXGTGKIPU # HGY QEECUKQPU YQWNF RTGUGPV VJGOUGNXGU +P VJG 0QTVJ 2JKNKRU QH VJG #NUCEG FKGF FWTKPI VJG TF ETWUCFG 2JKNKRRG UGK\GF VJG QRRQTVW PKV[ CPF CPPGZGF 8GTOCPFQKU CPF #TVQKU (TQO VJCV OQOGPV QP 2JKNKRRG #WIWUVG FGEKFGF VQ JCXG 2CTKUKU OCFG HQT VJGUG TGIKQPU +P VJG 9GUV C DCVVNG QXGT [GCTU YKVJ VJG 'PINKUJ TGUWNVGF KP VJG VCMKPI QH 0QTOCPF[ CPF 2QKVQW CPF RTKOCE[ QXGT $TKVVCP[ +P VJG 5QWVJ YJGTG JKU KP HNWGPEG YCU RTCEVKECNN[ PKN JG CESWKTGF VJG EQWPV[ QH 6QWNQWUG KP VJG ETWUCFG CICKPUV VJG #N DKIGPUKCPU UGG WPFGT 6QWNQWUG 6JG UWDLGEVKQP QH 6QWNQWUG JCU KP URKVG QH KVU DNQQF[ EQWTUG EQPVTKDWVGF VQ VJG GOGTIGPEG QH C (TGPEJ RGQRNG UJCTKPI QPG NCPIWCIG CPF QPG EWN VWTG HQT CHVGT VJG ETWUCFG CICKPUV VJG #NDKIGPUKCPU OCP[ 0QTVJ (TGPEJ MPKIJVU VQQM WR FQOK EKNG KP VJG 5QWVJ 2JKNKR ++ #WIWUVG CU C UQXGTGKIP TGEQIPKUGF VJG ITQYKPI KORQTVCPEG QH EKVKGU HCXQWTKPI VJGO KP OCP[ C YC[ #HVGT TGVWTPKPI HTQO VJG *QN[ .CPF 2JKNKR ++ #WIWUVG TGUWOGF DCVVNG YKVJ VJG 'PINKUJ 4KEJ CTF VJG .KQPJGCTVGF JCF HCNNGP KPVQ VJG )GTOCP GORGTQTʼnU JCPFU *KU KORTKUQPOGPV ECOG OQUV EQPXGPKGPV CU YGNN HQT 2JKNKR CU HQT ,QJP .CEMNCPF 6JG GORGTQT JQYGXGT YCU CHVGT 4KEJCTFU OQPG[ TCVJGT VJCP CHVGT JKU HTGGFQO CPF JG DNCEMOCKNGF 4KEJCTF VQ HKPCPEG JKU YCT CICKPUV 5KEKN[ 4KEJCTF ICXG KP RC[GF C TCPUQO CPF UGEWTGF 'PINCPF D[ CEMPQYNGFIKPI JKO UGNH VQ DG VJG GORGTQTʼnU XCUUCN 2JKNKR ++ CPF ,QJP .CEMNCPF YGTG NGHV UVCPFKPI *QYGXGT YJGP 4KEJCTF FKGF 2JKNKR ++ FGENCTGF CNN QH ,QJP .CEMNCPFʼnU (TGPEJ NKGIGU GZRKTGF CPF EQP SWGTGF 0QTOCPF[ KP #HVGT VJG $CVVNG CV $QWXKPGU KP YJGTG 1VVQ +8 YCU XCP SWKUJGF ,QJP .CEMNCPF KU HQTEGF VQ CEEGRV VJG NQUU QH 0QTOCPF[ /CKPG CPF #PLQW (TQO 2JKNKR #WIWUVG CFQRVGF VJG FGPKGT VQWTPQKU FTCHVGF KP VJG CDDG[ QH 5V /CTVKP UGG WP FGT 6QWTCKPG HQT VJG NCPFU KP VJG 9GUV %GU FGWZ GUR½EGU RCTKUKU GV VQWTPQKU EQPUVKVW½TGPV CW VKGTU FʼnCTIGPV HKP GPXKTQP NG U[UV½OG PQWXGCW FG NC OQPPCKG TQ[CNG .CHCWTKG

&GPKGT 2CTKUKU #TTCU PF V[RG. # (4# 1e0 KP VJG HKGNF 2*+.+285 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU #44#5 %+8+5. & . IT. &CTM VQPG XGT[ HKPG 6KGVLGP *CODWTI .CHCWTKG CU FQGU &WRNGUU[ IKXGU C NKU QP TGXGTUG KP VJG UV CPF VJG VJ CPINGU

&GPKGT .CQP. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI 2*+.+285 4' 4 $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG 41)'485 '2'. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ CVVTCEVKXG RCVKPC CPF RQTVTCKVU YGNN UVTWEM WR 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP DQWIJV 5RKPM 2JKNKRRG ++ UVTWEM VYQ UGTKGU RCTKUKU CPF VQWTPQKU CPF NQECNN[ EQKPGF NKMG CV VJKU OKPV KP .CQP 9KVJ DKUJQR 4QIGT FG 4QUQK

95


.17+5 8+++ +: 2JKNKR ++ #WIWUVG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU UQP .QWKU 8+++ 6JG NCVVGT VTKGF VQ UGK\G VJG 'PINKUJ VJTQPG CPF LQKPGF KP VJG ETWUCFG CICKPUV VJG #NDKIGPUKCPU 9JGP #OCWT[ UQP QH 5KOQP QH /QPVHQTV EQPHGTTGF VJG EQWPV[ 6QWNQWUG WRQP JKO 2JKNKR UVCTVGF C YCT CKOKPI VQ GZRCPF VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP KP VJG 5QWVJ QH (TCPEG *G FKFPʼnV NKXG VQ UGG VJKU GZRCPUKQP CPF FKGF C [QWPI OCP KP

&GPKGT 6QWTPQKU UV V[RG. # %TQUU YKVJKP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU .8&18+%85 4': 4 %J³VGN VQWT PQKU 6841085 %+8+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN .CHCWTKG IKXGU %+8+ KPUVGCF QH %+8+5 VJKU KU VJG VGZV HTQO . .QWKU +: .QWKU +: QPN[ TGHGTU VQ VJG HKTUV RGTKQF QH JKU IQXGTPOGPV K G WPVKN IQXGTPGF WPVKN VCMGP HTQO &W RNGUU[

.17+5 +: .QWKU +: VJG 5CKPV UWEEGGFGF .QWKU 8+++ JKU OQVJGT IQXGTPKPI CU C TGIGPV WPVKN VJG [QWPI MKPI YCU FGGOGF QH CIG *G YCU C FGXQWV %JTKUVKCP QPG QH YJQUG OCLQT RQNKVKECN KPVGTGUVU KV YCU VQ GPUWTG VJG YGNHCTG QH JKU RGQRNG *G VQQM RCTV KP VYQ ETWUCFGU CPF YCU ECRVWTGF KP VJG HKTUV QPN[ VQ DG TGNGCUGF CHVGT RC[KPI C NCTIG TCPUQO 6JG NCVVGT GZRGFKVKQP YCU PQ UWEEGUU GKVJGT HQTEKPI JKO VQ KPVGTHGTG KP +VCNKCP OCVVGTU JKU DTQVJGT %JCTNGU QH #PLQW YCU MKPI QH 5KEKN[ D[ VJGP YJKEJ FKFPʼn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¾EW FʼnQT :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6 %JTKUV EQPSWGTU %JTKUV TGKIPU %JTKUV RTGXCKNU HTQO 0KEGRJQTWU 8+++ .CWFGU 4GIKCG NKVWTIK ECN CEENCOCVKQP QH VJG MKPI CPF QP VJG )TQU VQWTPQKU $'0'&+%67/ 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ 01564+ &'+ ,'57 %*4+56+ 2TCKUGF DG VJG PCOG QH VJG )QF QWT .QTF ,GUWU %JTKUV #RCTV HTQO VJG )TQU VQWTPQKU UQNGN[ VJG RCTKUKU CPF VJG VQWTPQKU EQPVKPWGF VQ GZKUV

)TQU VQWTPQKU # +PPGT EKTENG .8&18+%85 æ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ & 0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 ° %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GP ENQUKPI NKU HQWT RGNNGVU DGPGCVJ VJG WRRGTOQUV NKU VYQ KPUKFG CPF VYQ QWVUKFG VJG VYQ EKTENGU YJKEJ UWT TQWPF VJKU NKU & $ . IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV 6JG )TQU 6QWTPQKU JCU UGTXGF CU CP GZCORNG HQT OCP[ C EQKP VQ EQOG (TGPEJ CPF GNUGYJGTG QTKIKPCVKPI

96


)TQU VQWTPQKU. # +PPGT EKTENG .8&18+%85 æ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 684108 5 æ %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & & . E IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG 6JG VGZV KU PQV GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG CU KP &WRNGUU[ YJQ IKXGU .8&18+%8 5 CPF 684108 5

&GPKGT 6QWTPQKU. # %TQUU .8&18+%85 4': 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

2*+.+22' +++ NG *#4&+ 6JG TGKIP QH 2JKNKRRG +++ KU RCTVKEWNCTN[ OCTMGF D[ VJG HCEV VJCV JKU WPENG %JCTNGU QH #PLQW JCU FGVGTOKPGF VJG EQWTUG QH (TGPEJ RQNKVKEU VQ C ITGCV GZVGPV #HVGT #NRJQPUG QH 2QKVKGTU CP CRCPCIG QH .QWKU +: FKGF VJG CRCPCIGU 2QKVQW CPF 6QWNQWUG TGVWTPGF VQ VJG ETQYP 2JKNKRRG +++ CFFU VJG QDQNG VQ VJG )TQU VQWTPQKU CPF VJG VQWTPQKU

)TQU VQWTPQKU. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+285 æ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 684108 5 æ %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & # . IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

6QFGTK (NQTGPEG %QKPU YKVJ 2*+.+285 CTG CVVTKDWVGF D[ &KGWFQPP¾ VQ 2JKNKRRG +++ YJKEJ .CHCWTKG EQPHKTOU &WRNGUU[ WPEQPFKVKQP CNN[ CVVTKDWVGU VJGO VQ 2JKNKRRG +++ & # IKXGU C RGNNGV KP HTQPV QH VJG 5 QH 6841085 DWV PQPG CHVGT

97


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„ )TQU VQWTPQKU OCKNNG DNCPEJG CPF VJG )TQU VQWTPQKU OCKNNG VKGTEG YGTG KPVTQFWEGF PGZV VQ VJG RCTKUKU VJG VQWTPQKU CPF VJG QDQNG CPF CRCTV HTQO VJQUG VJG FQWDNG RCTKUKU CPF VJG FQWDNG VQWTPQKU GXGPVWCNN[ JCXKPI ETGCVGF C EQORNGVG OQPGVCT[ U[UVGO 6JKU RTQEGUU HQWPF EQORNGVKQP CTQWPF # EJCTCEVGTKUVKE QH .QWKU +:ʼnU TGKIP YCU VJCV OCP[ (TGPEJ KPUVKVWVKQPU YGTG OQFGNNGF CHVGT 'PINKUJ GZCORNG +P VJKU ECUG HQT QPEG VJG OQPGVCT[ TGHQTO QH 2JKNKR VJG (CKT JCF CP GZGO RNCT[ GHHGEV QP VJG 'PINKUJ UKVWCVKQP RTQORVKPI 'FYCTF + VQ KP KPVTQFWEG C PGY ITQCV YKVJ CP GZRGTKOGPVCN EJCTCEVGT CPF KUUWG C PQXGN RGPP[ 1PN[ KP YQWNF 'FYCTF +++ CFQRV CP CNVQIGVJGT PGY OQPGVCT[ U[UVGO 2JKNKRRG +8 YCU VJG HKTUV UQXGTGKIP VQ UVTKMG FKHHGTGPV V[RGU QH IQNF EQKPU UVCTVKPI VJG IQNFGP ¾EW FʼnQT D[ .QWKU +: YCU GZRGTKOGPVCN +P 'PINCPF VJGUG KUUWGU FKFPʼnV VCMG RNCEG WPVKN +P 2JKNKRRG +8ʼnU FC[U CPF VJQUG QH JKU RTGFGEGUUQTU VJG RTKPEKRNG QH VJGQETCE[ JCF CNN DWV XCPKUJGF HTQO RQNKVKEU 2QRG $QPKHCEKWU 8+++ VTKGF VQ TGXKXG VJGQETCE[ DWV JKU CVVGORV OGV YKVJ HKGTEG TGUKUVCPEG HTQO VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP YJKEJ KPUVGCF NGXKGF VCZGU QP VJG ENGTI[ 6JG RCRCN DWNN %NGTKEWU NCKEQU HQTDCFG VJKU DWV RTQXQMGF C TGCEVKQP HTQO VJG (TGPEJ CU YGNN CU HTQO VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI UVTQPI GPQWIJ VQ ECWUG JKO VQ TGEQPUKFGT *G ECP QPKUGF .QWKU +: CPF ICKPGF RTGUVKIG D[ EQPXQMKPI VJG LWDKNGG QH $QVJ UKFGU ECORCKIPGF UWDUVCPVKCNN[ VJG RQRG KUUWKPI JKU DWNN 7PCO UCPEVCO RTQRCICVKPI VJGQETCE[ KP KVU OQUV GZ VTGOG HQTO 9JGP VJG RQRG VJTGCVGPGF VQ GZEQOOWPKECVG VJG (TGPEJ MKPI VJG NCVVGT QTFGTGF VJG RQRGʼnU CTTGUV 1P VJG VJ QH 5GRVGODGT JG YCU CTTGUVGF KP 4QOG DWV HTGGF NCVGT QP F[KPI UJQTVN[ CHVGT QP 1EVQDGT 6JG PGY RQRG %NGOGPV 8 HTQO $QTFGCWZ CPWNNGF DQVJ DWNNU ECRKVWNCVKPI VQVCNN[ VQ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI *G VQQM WR FQOKEKNG KP #XKIPQP CPF JKU CWVJQTKV[ YCU EWTVCKNGF VQ VJCV QH C (TGPEJ DKUJQR 6JG OQPCTEJCN CPF HKUECN RQNKVKEU QH 2JKNKR VJG (CKT RTQXQMGF UQOG KPVGTPCN QRRQUKVKQP #HVGT JKU FGCVJ VJG DCTQPU UVQQF WR VQ GCEJ QH JKU VJTGG UWEEGGFKPI UQPU WPUWEEGUUHWNN[ JQYGXGT

)TQU VQWTPQKU ¯ N 1 TQPF. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+2285 4'¥ CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ CVVTCEVKXG RCVKPC 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JGTG CTG VJTGG KUUWGU CPF 2JKNKRRXU YKVJ C UKPING .

)TQU VQWTPQKU ¯ N 1 NQPI. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JG . KP 2*+.+2285 JCU C NKU CVVCEJGF VQ KVU UJQTV UVGO #V & &WRNGUU[ TGRQTVU C NGVVGT . CFQTPGF YKVJ C NKU DWV PQV KP VJG ECUG QH PQ

98


/CKNNG DNCPEJG ¯ N 1 NQPI. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 t %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQU KPI NKU. & . IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*GUU .W\GTP

)TQU VQWTPQKU ¯ N 1 NQPI GV CW NKU. # +PPGT EKTENG 2J+.+2285 ÙÙÙ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 :2+ 4 .KU VQRRGF %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 ÙÙÙ %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU &KGWFQPP¾ VJKPMU VJKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM KP KP $TWIGU YJKEJ YCU EQPSWGTGF D[ 2JKNKRRG +8 6JKU KUUWG YCU HQN NQYGF D[ 4QDGTV FG $GVJWPG

/CKNNG VKGTEG ¯ N 1 TQPF. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+0+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU VJG WRRGTOQUV NKU DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. & % . C IT. 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM KP

&GPKGT 6QWTPQKU ¯ N 1 NQPI. # 2J+..+2285 Q 4': CTQWPF ETQUU 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5. & . IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU 5VTWEM DGVYGGP

1DQNG VQWTPQKU ¯ N 1 NQPI. # 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 # %+8+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

99


1DQNG VQWTPQKU ¯ N 1 NQPI. # 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$QPXCNNGV 2CTKU

&QWDNG RCTKUKU. # (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 2*+.+2285 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU 4')# .+5 WPFGT NKU /10'6# t &82.':. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (KTUV KUUWG

&QWDNG VQWTPQKU. # %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG PF CPING 2*+.+2285 4': 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU DGVYGGP VYQ NKU /10 &82.': 4')#. . & . IT. #VVTCEVKXG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ (KTUV KUUWG DGVYGGP

$QWTIGQKU HQTV. # (NQTKCVGF NCVKP ETQUU 2*+.+2 285 4': 4 (14 6+5 KP VYQ NKPGU WPFGT ETQYP $84)'05+5. & . IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU +P VGZV $84)'05+5 (146+5 +V UGGOU VJCV VJKU EQKP YCU PCOGF $QWTIGQKU VQ U[ODQNKUG KVU CXGTCIG PWOGTKECN XCNWG CPF VQ NCWF VJG EKVKGUʼn DQWTIGQKU HQT JCXKPI FTKXGP QWV VJG .QODCTFU $QWTIGUʼn EKVK\GPU YGTG PGXGT TGHGTTGF VQ CU $QWTIGQKU

100


1DQNG DQWTIGQKUG. # .CVKP ETQUU 2*+.+2 285 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU 018 85 WPFGT NKU $84)'05+5. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ ,CPWCT[

%*#4.'5 +8

/CKNNG $NCPEJG. # +PPGT EKTENG -#41.85 u 4' Ő:Ő CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU (4#0%148/ YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU VJG WRRGT OQUV NKU DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. & & . C IT. 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG TF KUUWG HTQO ,WN[

/CKNNG DNCPEJG. # +PPGT EKTENG -#41.85 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU (4#0%*148/ YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQXGODGT PQ +UUWG PF /CTEJ

&QWDNG RCTKUKU. # %TQYP -#41.85 4': , ! 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# Q &82.':. & $ . D IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN PF KUUWG PF /CTEJ

101


6JG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU 2*+.+22' 8+

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ʼnV CVVCKP CP[ QH VJGUG YQTFN[ CODKVKQPU &GURKVG VJG HCEV VJCV (TCPEG JGNF GKIJV VKOGU VJG RQRWNCVKQP QH 'PINCPF VJG 'PINKUJ YGTG EQP UKFGTCDN[ DGVVGT RTGRCTGF HQT DCVVNG QP VJG GXG QH VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT #U C EQPUGSWGPEG 2JKNKR NQUV VJG $CVVNG QH %T¾E[ VQ VJG 'PINKUJ CV 5NWKU KP 0QTOCPF[ UWTTGPFGTGF %CNCKU CPF JCF VQ CEEGRV VJG RGCEG QH $T¾VKIP[

4Q[CN F QT. # %TQYPGF MKPI UVCPFKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ Q (4# %14 Q Q 2* 5 4': Q 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING :2% Q 8+0%+6 Q :2 % Q 4')0#6 Q :2 % Q +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ PF /C[

'EW F QT C NC EJCKUG. # #TOQWTGF MKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH (TCPEG UKVVKPI QP IQVJKE VJTQPG 2*+.+2285 › &'+ Z )4# Z (4#0%148/ › 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING :2% › 8+0%+6 › :2% › 4')0#6 › :2% › +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ PF GOKUUKQP VJ #RTKN

%JCKUG F QT. # %TQYPGF MKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF *CPF QH ,WUVKEG UKVVKPI QP IQVJKE VJTQPG 2*+.+2285 › &'+ › )4#%+# › (4#0%148/ › 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6. & % (D . IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG

'NUGP $TWUUGN +UUWG VJ ,WN[ 'Z 8KPEJQP #WEVKQP HGDT PQ %GVVG RK½EG TCRRGNNG NC RK½EG JQOQP[OG FG 2JKNKRRG +8 CXGE WPG RNWU ITCPFG TKEJGUUG FG OQVKHU PQVCOOGPV RCT NG FQWDNG FGU RKPCENGU .CHCWTKG

102


)TQU ¯ NC EQWTQPPG CXGE GVQKNG. # +PPGT EKTENG 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU WPFGT ETQYP YKVJ UOCNN UVCT WPFGT ECUVNG (4#0%148/ YKVJKP DQTFGT QH VGP CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & # . C IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JG . KP 2*+.+2285 JCU QPG NKU QP JKU HQQV PF KUUWG UV 1EVQDGT

)TQU ¯ HNGWT FG NKU. # .KU (4#0%148/ YKVJKP EKTENG QH NKU 4 2*+.+2285 4': CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPING $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &'+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶. & . IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP UV KUUWG VJ ,CPWCT[ .G ITQCV CW NKU GUV NG RTGOKGT FGU ITQCV SWK CXGE WP VKVTG KPH¾TKGWT ¯ EGNWK FG NʼnCTIGPV NG TQK QPV WUWTR¾ NG PQO FG )TQU VQWTPQKU .CHCWTKG

&QWDNG RCTKUKU. # +P VYQ NKPGU (4# 0%1 KP VJG HKGNF ñ 2*+.+22 · 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ñ /10'6# &82.':. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG $CVCXKC FGP *CCI TF V[RG UV KUUWG VJ #RTKN 1DXGTUG WRUKFG FQYP

,'#0 ++ NG $10 2JKNKRRG 8+ YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU UQP ,GCP ++ NG $QP KP # UKPIWNCT OCP QH JWODNG OKNKVCT[ VCNGPV JG YCU PQ OCVEJ HQT 'FYCTF +++ PQT HQT VJG $NCEM 2TKPEG +P JG YCU FG HGCVGF CV 2QKVKGTU CPF UWDUGSWGPVN[ JGNF KP 'PINKUJ ECRVKXKV[

/QWVQP F QT. # +1* 4': WPFGT NCOD KP OWNVKNQDG #)0 &'+ 38+ 61.. 2%%# /8&+ /+5'4'4' 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING :2% á 8+0%+6 á :2% á 4')0#6 á :2% á +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQXGODGT PQ +UUWG VJ ,CPWCT[

103


/QWVQP F QT. # +1* 4': WPFGT NCOD KP TKPI QH VTGHQKNU #)0 &'+ 38+ 61.. 2%%# /8&+ /+5'4'4' 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING :2% รก 8+0%+6 รก :2% รก 4')0#6 รก :2% รก +/2'4#6. & # (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP QP DTQCF HNCP /ร P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 5VTWEM VJ ,CPWCT[ 6JG FKHHGTGPEG YKVJ PQ KU KP VJG HTCOG QH VJG #IPWU &GK

4Q[CN F QT. # %TQYPGF MKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG UVCPFKPI WPFGT IQVJKE FCKU +1*'5 P &'+ P )4# (4#0%148 P 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING :2% P 8+0%+6 P :2% P 4')0#6 P :2% P +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 5JCTR UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP )NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP /CTEJ PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5GCD[ PF +UUWG VJ #RTKN - IQNF

(TCPE ยฏ EJGXCN. # /QWPVGF MKPI N YKVJ UYQTF +1J#00'5 P &'+ P )4#%+# P (4#0%148 P 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4') 0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ VQPG /ร P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ +UUWG VJ &GEGODGT

104


)TQU DNCPE ¯ NC EQWTQPPG. # +1J#00'5 Q &'+ Q )4# CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ 4 %TQYP (4#0%148 Q 4': YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ +UUWG VJ /CTEJ

)TQU CWZ VTQKU NKU. # +PPGT EKTENG +1J#00'5 Q &'+ Q )4# CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ 4 %TQYP QXGT VJTGG NKU (4#0%14 P 4': YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & # . C IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU V[RG HKTUV CRRGCTGF KP VJG PF KUUWG QH VJ ,WPG CPF EJCTCEVGTKUVKECNN[ JCU VJTGG UOCNN TKPIU YKVJ C FQV KP VJGO QT VYQ TKPIU YKVJ C FQV KPVGTRWPEVWCVKPI

)TQU DNCPE CWZ HNGWTU FG NKU. # +PPGT EKTENG +1*'5 &'+ )4# CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 :2+ 4 (KGNF YKVJ NKU (4#0%148/ 1 4': YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP 5RKPM #WEVKQP 'Z 8GTIPG #WEVKQP $QTFGCWZ +UUWG VJ &GEGODGT

105


%*#4.'5 8

9KVJ VJG EQWPVT[ FGXCUVCVGF RTKEGU CV C JKIJ C TCRKFN[ FGXCNWCVKPI EWTTGPE[ CP GORV[ VTGCU WT[ CPF OWVKPGGTU ICNQTG VJG KORTKUQPOGPV QH ,QJP ++ VJG )QQF RTGUGPVGF VJG &CWRJKP VJG NCVVGT %JCTNGU 8 YKVJ C UJGGT KORQUUKDNG VCUM 'VKGPPG /CTEGN NGCFGT QH VJG 2CTKUKCP DQWT IGQKUKG YJQ YGTG HWTKQWU CV VJKU HGGDNG IQXGTPOGPV QTICPKUGF RCTNKCOGPV KPVQ C DQF[ YKVJ C NKUV QH RQNKVKECN FGOCPFU $WV VJG FCWRJKP EJQUG VQ FKUTGICTF VJGKT FGOCPFU FKUOKUUKPI VJG 'UVCVGU )¾P¾TCN CPF GXGPVWCNN[ TGUVQTKPI QTFGT ,QJP ++ UKIPGF RGCEG YKVJ 'PINCPF CV VJG 2GCEG QH $T¾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¾VKIP[ 6JG FGCVJ QH %JCTNGU 8 JGTCNFGF VJG GPF QH VJG HKTUV RJCUG QH VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT VJG UGEQPF QPG VQ DG QH C YJQNN[ FKHHGTGPV EJCTCEVGT

(TCPE ¯ RKGF. # -KPI UVCPFKPI DGVYGGP NKU KP IQVJKE FCKU YKVJ UYQTF CPF *CPF QH ,WUVKEG -#41.85 ì &+ ì )4 (4#0%14 ì 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU NKU KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG SWCVTGHQKN :2% ì 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 ì :2% ì +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

(TCPE ¯ 2KGF. # -KPI UVCPFKPI DGVYGGP NKU KP IQVJKE FCKU YKVJ UYQTF CPF *CPF QH ,WUVKEG -#41.85 Z &+ Z )4 (4#0%148 Z 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU NKU KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG SWCVTGHQKN :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

&GNOQPVG $TWUUGN +UUWG VJ #RTKN (TQO QPG 9GUV %GPVTCN (TCPEG JQCTF %GVVG RK½EG UʼnCRRGNCKV QHHKEKGNNGOGPV &GPKGT FʼnQT CWZ HNGWTU FG NKU ¾XQSWCPV CKPUK NC RK½EG RCUUCI½TG FG ,GCP NG $QP SWK NWK TGUUGODNG NG RGWRNG RQWT NC RTGOK½TG HQKU FCPU WP VGZV QHHKEKGN GP LCPXKGT .CHCWTKG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQXGODGT PQ +UUWG VJ #RTKN 6JKU EQKP UJQYU OCP[ OKPQT FKHHGTGPEGU EQORCTGF VQ VJG NCUV PQ

)TQU VQWTPQKU. # +PPGT EKTENG -#41.85 ! 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU WPFGT ETQYP 6841085 %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & # . C IT. 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ CVVTCEVKXG VQPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JG 6 QH 6841085 JCU C UKPIWNCT HQTO PF KUUWG TF #WIWUV

106


$NCPE CW -. # - WPFGT ETQYP CPF DGVYGGP NKU &'+ P )4#%+# YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU 4 +PPGT EKTENG ð (4#0%148 P 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+. & . IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JKU KU VJG HKTUV $NCPE +UUWG VJ #RTKN

%*#4.'5 8+

9JGP %JCTNGU 8+ UWEEGGFGF JKU HCVJGT JG YCUPʼn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ʼn 9CT CICKPUV VJG 'PINKUJ 6JG 'PINKUJ NCPFGF CV *CTHNGWT CPF EQPSWGTGF VJG (TGPEJ CV #\KPEQWTV 6JKU XKEVQT[ CYCTFGF VJG 'PINKUJ C DQPF YKVJ VJG $WTIWPFKCP &WMG ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU CPF VJG )GTOCP 'ORGTQT 5KIKUOWPF ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU PGIQVKCVGF YKVJ VJG 'PINKUJ CU YGNN CU YKVJ VJG FCW RJKP C FQWDNG RNC[ VJCV EQUV JKO JKU NKHG QP 5GRVGODGT VJ QH *KU UWEEGUUQT 2JKNKR VJG )QQF LQKPGF VJG 'PINKUJ +P YKVJ VJG 6TGCV[ QH 6TQ[GU %JCTNGU 8+ YGFFGF JKU FCWIJ VGT VQ 'PINCPFʼnU MKPI *GPT[ 8 YJQ JCF UWEEGGFGF %JCTNGU 8+ CHVGT JKU FGOKUG 6JG FCWRJKP GUECRGF CETQUU VJG .QKTG VJG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU UGGOGF CV KVU GPF 6JG NCPF YCU PQY VQTP KP VYQ RCTVU *GPT[ 8 %JCTNGU 8+ VJG FWMGU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF VJG FCWRJKP VJG NCVVGT %JCTNGU 8++ CNN UVTWEM EQKP 5GG .CHCWTKGʼnU OCR QP R ŋ'P UGRVGODTG HWV ET¾¾ NG U[UV½OG FG EQPVTQNG RCT NG RQKPV SWG PQWU CRRGNQPU UGETGV RNCE¾ UQWU WPG NGVVTG SWG FGʼn UKIPCKV RQWT EJCSWG CVGNKGT WP PWO¾TQ FʼnQTFTG EQORV¾ ¯ RCTVKT FW EQOOGPEGOGPV FGU N¾IGPFGU QW RNWU TCTGOGPV FʼnWPG FGU N¾IGPFGU %G RQKPV OCPSWG NG RNWU UQWQHV UWT NC OQPPCKG PQKTGŌ .CHCWTKG

EW C NC %QWTQPPG. # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH (TCPEG -#41.85 ¤ &'+ ¤ )4#%+# ¤ (4#0%148/ ¤ 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ C UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG CPF ETQYPU KP VJG CPINGU :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +02'4#6. & (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5VTWEM CHVGT 'EW QH VJG PGY (TCPEG VJTGG NKU CPF C ETQYP CFQTPGF YKVJ NKU

107


/QWVQP FB1T GP &CWRJKP¾ 4QOCPU. # -4. 4': WPFGT NCOD QP HQWT RCYU KP VJG &CWRJKP¾ YKVJ ETWEKHQTO UVCHH CPF HN[KPI DCPPGT KP SWCVTGHQKN #T0 &'+ 38+61..+5 2'%# /8 &+ /+5' 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING :U% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 4 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP +UUWG VJ /C[ .CHCWTKG /CTEJGXKNNG EQNNGEVKQP

$NCPE FKV )W¾PCT 4QWGP VJ GOKUUKQP. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG -#41.85 P (4#0%148 P 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 P 01/' P &0+ P $'0'&+%68. & % . E IT. 5NKIJVGN[ KTTGIWNCT HNCP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF KPVGTTWRVGF DGVYGGP HQT VJG RTQFWEVKQP QH VJG )TQU CW .KU 4QWGP VJ KUUWG VJ 1EVQDGT

)W¾PCT 2CTKU. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG ð -#41.85 (4#0%148/ 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG PF CPING CPF ETQYP KP VJG TF CPING ð 5+6 01/' &0+ $'0'&+%68. & ) . C IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG UOCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN VJ KUUWG VJ /CTEJ 2QKPV UGETGV WPFGT VJG KPKVKCN

)TQU CWZ NKU 4QWGP. # 6JTGG NKU -#41.85 ¶ (4#0%148/ ¶ 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68. & . IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP 1T )GUVKQP 0WOKUOCVKSWG 2CTKU 1P VJG TGXGTUG C RGNNGV WPFGT VJG & KP $'0'&+%68 4QWGP +UUWG VJ ,WPG

108


)TQU CWZ NKU UQWU WPG EQWTQPPG. # +PPGT EKTENG -. ¶ &+ ¶ ) ¶ (4#%148 ¶ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ 4 6JTGG NKU WPFGT ETQYP Z )41585 ¶ 6841085 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ +UUWG TF PQXGODGT

)TQU CWZ NKU UQWU WPG EQWTQPPG. # +PPGT EKTENG -. ¶ &+ ¶ ) ¶ (4#%148 ¶ 4': CTQWPF ETQUU 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ 4 6JTGG NKU WPFGT ETQYP )41585 ¶ 6841085 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI QPG ETQUU CPF NKU. & # . IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

)TQU FKV (NQTGVVG. # 6JTGG NKU WPFGT ETQYP V -#41.85 ¶ (4#0%148 ¶ 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU with one crown in the 1st and 4th angles, V 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68. & # . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG YCU WUGF VQ JCXG VJKU KPHGTKQT EQKP TGUGODNG VJG QNF )TQU VQWTPQKU %TQUU CPF NKU QP URGEKOGP HTQO 4QWGP QT 5CKPV .Ê +UUWG TF PQXGODGT 6JG PQ CPF FKHHGT KP VJG PWODGT QH NKU TGUR

8KPEJQP 2CTKU PF KUUWG UV EVQDGT

&GPKGT VQWTPQKU. # 6YQ NKU -#41.85 Q 4': 4 %TQUU 6841085 Q %+8+5. & # . C IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 9KVJ C TQWPF 1 PQ CVGNKGT RGNNGV XKUKDNG 6JKU EQKP KU GZEGRVKQPCNN[ NKIJV CPF VJG ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG KU NQPIGT VJCP WUWCN

109


&QWDNG VQWTPQKU FKV PKSWGV . # 1PG NKU WPFGT ETQYP -#41.85 (4#%148 4': 4 %TQUU &82.': 684105 (4#%+'. & . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU +UUWG VJ #WIWUV 0KSWGV EQPUKFGTU SWKVG C HGY KPVGTRTGVCVKQPU WPG EQTTWRVKQP FG PKIGNNWO PQKT WPG OQPPCKG FG TKGP NG PQO FʼnWP OCÄVTG FG NC OQPPCKG CRRGN¾ 0KEQNCU KN GUV KPEQPPWG FG RGVKV PQO FQPP¾ FKTGEVGOGPV ¯ NC RK½EG EG SWK GUV NG RNWU XTCKUGODNCDNG .CHCWTKG

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ʼnU CEVKQPU DTQWIJV CDQWV C VWTP VQ VJKPIU 6JG 'PINKUJ YGTG FTKXGP HTQO VJG YJQNG QH (TCPEG CPF GXGPVWCNN[ OGTGN[ JGNF %CNCKU CPF 0QTOCPF[ʼnU %JCPPGN +UNCPFU 2GCEG YCU PQV UKIPGF 6JG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn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¾ VJG FCWRJKP HNGGKPI VQ 2JKNKRU VJG )QQF YJQ JGNRGF JKO IGVVKPI GUVCDNKUJGF KP $TCDCPV (TQO VJGTG JG MGRV QP OCEJKPCVKPI UKFKPI YKVJ VJG ;QTMKUVU YJKNG JKU HCVJGT UWRRQTVGF VJG .CPECUVGTU *'04+ 8 *GPT[ 8 YCU MKPI QH 'PINCPF CPF FWMG QH 0QTOCPF[ +P JG UVTWEM IW¾PCTU KP %CGP .CVGT OKPVU YGTG GUVCDNKUJGF KP 4QWGP CPF 5V .Ê CU YGNN

0KSWGV QW N¾QRCTF 4QWGP. # %TQYPGF NGQRCTF WPFGT NKU * ¶ 4': ¶ #0). ¶ *'4'5 ¶ (4#0% 4 %TQUU YKVJ * KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68. & . IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG * KP VJG JGCTV QP VJG TGXGTUG KPFKECVGU 4QWGP CU FQGU VJG VTGHQKN /QTGQXGT VJGTG KU C RGNNGV WPFGT HKTUV NGVVGT QP QD CPF TGXGTUG 6JG . QH #0). TCVJGT TGUGODNGU CP 4 +UUWG VJ 0QXGODGT

110


*'04+ 8+ *GPT[ 8+ YCU CRRQKPVGF D[ %JCTNGU 8+ CU JKU JGKT 0QV QPN[ FKF JG TWNG 0QTOCPF[ DWV GPVKTG 0QTVJ (TCPEG %QKPCIG WPFGT JKO YCU CNKIPGF GPVKTGN[ YKVJ VJG (TGPEJ OQPGVCT[ U[UVGO LWUV CU KV YCU WPFGT JKU HCVJGT

5CNWV F QT 5V .ร . # 6YQ UJKGNFU N (TCPEG CPF T (TCPEG 'PINCPF WPFGT VJG CTEJCPIGN )CDTKGN CPF /CTKC #8' DGVYGGP CPF UWPTC[ CDQXG VJGO รฐ *'04+%85 &'+ )4# (4# %148 < #).+' 4': 4 .CVKP ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG DGVYGGP NKU CPF NGQRCTF QXGT VJG NGVVGT * รฐ :2% 8+0%+6 :2%

4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO EH 'NKCU #VGNKGT 5V .ร NKU PF V[RG +UUWG VJ 5GRVGODGT (QWPF FWTKPI FTGFIKPI KP VJG 4JKPG FGNVC PGCT 4QVVGTFCO

5CNWV F QT 4QWGP. # 6YQ UJKGNFU N (TCPEG CPF T (TCPEG 'PINCPF WPFGT CP CPIGN CPF /CTKC #8' DGVYGGP CPF UWPTC[ CDQXG VJGO โ ฆ *'04+%85 &'+ )4# (4#%148 < #).+' 4': 4 .CVKP ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG DGVYGGP NKU CPF NGQRCTF QXGT VJG NGVVGT * โ ฆ :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG XGT[ HKPG

8GTUEJQQT 5VTKLGP (TQO HKPF $TQWYGTUJCXGP HQWPF KP 5GRVGODGT CHVGT QPG UKPING EQKP YCU HQWPF CV VJG UCOG UKVG KP 5GRVGODGT 5GG CNUQ 'NKCU D #PPWNGV WPFGT VJG NCUV NGVVGT KP VJG VGZV QP QD CPF TGXGTUG +U RTKXCVG OKPVOCTM QH 'VKGPPG /CTEGN 5VTWEM WPFGT QTFGT QH /CTEJ #VGNKGT 4QWGP QPG UOCNN NKQP PF V[RG #TVKENG D[ 8GTUEJQQT & %QKP HKPF $TQWYGTUJCXGP KP -TQPKGM QH JGV NCPF QH FG <GGOGGTOKP 5EJQWYGP &WKXGNCPF R 6JKU EQKP KU NQECNN[ TGIKUVGTGF WPFGT PQ

#PIGNQV 5V .ร . # #TEJCPIGN )CDTKGN QXGT VJG UJKGNFU QH (TCPEG N CPF (TCPEG 'PINCPF T รฐ *'04+%85 (4#0%148 '6 #0).+' 4': 4 .CVKP ETQUU DGVYGGP NKU CPF NGQRCTF รฐ :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & (D . IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z 5EJPGKFGT EQNNGEVKQP #PVYGTRGP FWRNKECVG (TQO 0% PQ 5VTWEM VJ /C[ 6JG CPIGNQV KU QH VJG 5CNWV Fล 1T 1PN[ UVTWEM D[ HQWT OKPVU

111


$NCPE CWZ GEWU 4QWGP # *$4+%85 QXGT VJG UJKGNFU QH (TCPEG CPF (TCPEG 'PINCPF … (4#0%148/ ¶ '6 ¶ #0).+' ¶ 4': 4 .CVKP ETQUU DGVYGGP NKU CPF NGQRCTF QXGT *$4+%85 … 5+6 ¶ 01/'0 ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68. & . IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP

+UUWG TF 0QXGODGT

%*#4.'5 8++ UV RGTKQF

+P VJKU RGTKQF OKPVKPI YCU GZEWUKXGN[ FQPG KP VJG UQWVJ QH (TCPEG CPF YCU QH RQQT SWCNKV[

4Q[CN F QT .C 4QEJGNNG. # -KPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF *CPF QH ,WUVKEG UVCPFKPI DGVYGGP NKU -#41.85 „ &'+ „ )4 %+# „ (4#0%1484': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +02'4#6 „. & (D . IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP UV KUUWG VJ 1EVQDGT .C 4QEJGNNG FG NGVVGT UV RGTKQF 0QTOCNN[ VJKU V[RG YQWNF FKURNC[ VYQ UEGRVGTU CV CP CPING +P VJKU ECUG JQYGXGT VJG QPG UEGRVGT KU ENGCTN[ JGNF KP VJG TKIJV JCPF CPF VJG *CPF QH ,WUVKEG KU VJG NGHV JCPF DQVJ WRTKIJV

$NCPE CWZ NKU CEEQV¾U %JKPQP. # 6JTGG NKU WPFGT ETQYP -#41.85 W (4#0%1 W 4': % 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 ë 01/' ë &0+ ë $'0'&+%68 ë %. & . IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ +UUWG VJ 1EVQDGT .CHCWTKG TGHGTU VQ %J³NQPU CPF 6TQ[GU DWV &WRNGUU[ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU EQKP VQ %JKPQP

112


PF RGTKQF

+P VJKU PF RGTKQF VJGTG YCU OKPVKPI VJTQWIJ CNN QH (TCPEG CPF VJG OQPGVCT[ U[UVGO UVTQPIN[ KORTQXGF

'EW F QT ¯ NC EQWTQPPG QW GEW PGWH 6QWTPCK. # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH (TCPEG DGVYGGP VYQ ETQYPGF NKU ñ -#41.85 X &'+ X )4# X (4#0%148/ X 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING ñ :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6. & # (D . C IT. 8GT[ HKPG #TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 'EW F QT ¯ NC EQWTQPPG TF V[RG PF KUUWG VJ #WIWUV 6QWTPCK Q

)TQU FG 4QK .[QP. # 6JTGG NKU WPFGT ETQYP -#41.85 Y &'+ Y )4# Y (4#0%148/ Y 4': t 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 Y 01/'0 Y &1/+0+ Y $'0'&+%68/ t. & # . C IT. 0KEG RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP 6JG UKIP QH .[QP KU C VTGHQKN PF KUUWG VJ ,WPG

$NCPE ¯ NC %QWTQPPG 2QKVKGTU UV GOKUUKQP. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG KP VTGHQKN UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJTGG ETQYPU -#41.85 „ (4#0%148/ „ 4': 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPING ñ 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG &QODTQYUMK /Ã’PUVGT

113


.17+5 :+ .QWKU :+ʼnU FKUKPENKPCVKQP VQYCTFU JKU HCVJGTʼnU RQNKVKEU XCPKUJGF CU UQQP CU JG CUUWOGF QHHKEG #ICKP JG GPFGCXQWTGF VQ QPEG CPF HQT CNN CPPGZ VJG TGOCKPKPI FWEJKGU CPF HQTO C WPKVGF (TCPEG 6JKU JQYGXGT YCU PQ UKORNG VCUM RCTVKEWNCTN[ KP VJG ECUG QH $WTIWPF[ 9JGP %JCTNGU VJG $QNF KP YCU MKNNGF CV 0CPE[ .QWKU UGK\GF VJG QRRQTVWPKV[ CPF EQPSWGTGF $WTIWPF[ 1PN[ CHVGT TGCEJKPI VJG 2GCEG QH #VTGEJV KP YKNN /CZKOKNKCP QH #WUVTKC FG HKPKVKXGN[ EGFG $WTIWPF[ VQ (TCPEG 0QY (TCPEG YCU WPKVGF DWV HQT $TKVVCP[ CPF $QWTDQP

$NCPE ¯ NC %QWTQPPG 6QWNQWUG. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG KP VTGHQKN UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJTGG ETQYPU .8&18+%85 (4#0%1/ 4': 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68/ . & . IT. 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM WR CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5JQR KP 5VTCCVUDWTI UV KUUWG UV &GEGODGT 4KPI WPFGT VJG VJ NGVVGT QH VJG NGIGPF 6QWNQWUG

1DQNG VQWTPQKU. # %TQYP .8&18+%85 WPKFGPVKHKGF VQMGP 4': 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 1$1 .85 ” %+ 8+5. & . C IT. #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN PF V[RG VJ 0QXGODGT

%*#4.'5 8+++ %JCTNGU 8+++ UWEGGFGF .QWKU :+ KP *G OCTTKGF #PPG QH $TKVVCP[ JGKTGUU VQ $TKVVCP[ #HVGT JKU FGOKUG #PPG YGFFGF JKU UWEEGUUQT .QWKU :++ C UQP QH VJG FWMG QH 1TNGCPU VJG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU #PIQWN¿OG GOGTIGU $TKVVCP[ YCU PQY HKTON[ CVVCEJGF VQ VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP 6JG QPG TGOCKPKPI HGWFCNKV[ YCU PQY VJCV QH VJG $QWTDQPU 'XGPVWCNN[ VJG *QWUG QH $QWTDQP YKNN CUEGPF VJG VJTQPG QH (TCPEG CPF TGKIP WPVKN ŋ0QWU VTQWXQPU UQWU EG T½IPG WPG TKEJG HNQTCKUQP FʼnGUR½EGU TQ[CNGU CXGE FGU U[ODQNGU RTQ XKPEKCWZ FCWRJKPQKU RTQXGPECWZ GPHKP DTGVQPU FGRWKU NC T¾WPKQP FG GV FGU RK½EGU OCT UGKNNCKUGUŌ .CHCWTKG

'EW F QT CW UQNGKN #PIGTU. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG WPFGT ETQYP CDQXG UWP ñ -#41.85 &'+ )4# (4#0%148/ 4': # 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG ñ :25 8+0%+6 :25 4')0#6 :25 +/2'4#6 . & (D . IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ UV KUUWG VJ 5GRVGODGT

114


-CTQNWU QW &K\CKP 5V .Ê. # )TGCV QTPCOGPVGF - WPFGT ETQYP CPF DGVYGGP VYQ NKU -#41.85 (4#0%148/ 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CP QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68. & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP #WMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ VJ 0QXGODGT

*CTFK $QTFGCWZ. # -KPI HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU -#41. 85 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU % 5+6 t 01/'0 t &1/+0+ t. & . IT. 9GNN UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ UV KUUWG VJ 5GRVGODGT 5JKR $QTFGCWZ #WEWPG QTFQPPCPEG FG %JCTNGU 8+++ PG OGPVKQPPG NG *CTFK TQ[CN +N GUV VT½U PCVWTGN SWʼnKN CKV ET¾¾ RCT .QWKU :+ GP O¿OG VGORU SWG NG NKCTF .CHCWTKG

.KCTF FG $TGVCIPG. # &QNRJKP YKVJ URGEMNG QH GTOKPG DGNQY VJG JGCF -#41.85 (4#0%148/ 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ 4 4GPPGU KP VJG OKFFNG QPG ETQYP YKVJ URGEMNG QH GTOKPG KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68/ . & . IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒNNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM CDQWV

6JG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU #PIQWN¿OG .17+5 :++

'EW F QT CW UQNGKN .[QP. # 5JKGNF QH (TCPEG WPFGT ETQYP [ Q .8&18+%85 „ &'+ „ )4#%+# „ (4#0%148 „ 4': t 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG [ Q :25 „ 8+0%+6 „ :25 „ 4')0#6 „ :25 „ +/2'4#6 t. & (D . IT. $TQCF HNCP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ VJ #RTKN

115


'EW F QT CW RQTE ¾RKE .[QP. # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH (TCPEG DGVYGGP VYQ RQTEWRKPGU .8&18+%85 „ &'+ „ )4#%+# „ (4#0%148/ „ 4': t 4 %TQUU GPFKPI KP VTKFGPV KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU C RQT EWRKPG CPF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU CP . :25 „ 8+0%+6 „ :25 „ 4')0#06 „ :25 „ +/2'4#6 t. & (D . IT. 8GT[ HKPG 7$5 <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ VJ 0QXGODGT

(4#0%' (—1&#.' %1706; CPF &7%*; QH 014/#0&; +P %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG UKIPGF VJG 6TGCV[ QH 5V %NCKT UWT 'RVG YKVJ 8KMKPI EJKGH 4QNNQ +P TGVWTP HQT JKU UWDLGEVKQP CPF EQPXGTUKQP 4QNNQ TGEGKXGF VJG TGIKQP VQ VJG UQWVJ QH VJG 5GKPG FGNVC 7RRGT 0QTOCPF[ KP HKGH YJKEJ GHHGEVKXGN[ OCFG JKO VJG HQWPFGT QH YJCV NCVGT YQWNF DGEQOG MPQYP CU VJG FWEJ[ QH 0QTOCPF[ +P CPF MKPI 4WFQNH CNUQ EGFGF .QYGT 0QTOCPF[ IKXKPI 0QTOCPF[ KVU RTGUGPV RTQ RQTVKQPU 6JG CEVWCN RQYGT QH 4QNNQ CPF VJCV QH JKU UQP )WKNNCWOG .QPIWG 'R¾G YCU TGUVTKEVGF VQ 7RRGT 0QTOCPF[ VJG[ YGTG EQWPVU QH 0QTOCPF[ 9JGP )WKNNCWOG YCU CUUCUUKPCVGF KP 4KEJCTF + YCU PQV [GV QH CIG .QWKU +8 YJQO )WKNNCWOG JCF JGNRGF TGVWTP VQ (TCPEG HTQO CP 'PINKUJ GZKNG VTKGF VQ TGICKP EQPVTQN QH VJG EQWPVT[ DWV JG HCKNGF +P 0QTOCPF[ DGECOG C FWEJ[ 7PFGT 4KEJCTF ++ CWVJQTKV[ YCU U[UVGOCVKECNN[ DWKNV WR 6JG OCTTKCIG QH 'OOC UKUVGT QH 4KEJCTF ++ VQ MKPI #GVJGNTGF QH 'PINCPF XCUVN[ GPJCPEGF TGPQYP CPF VJG EQWPVT[ RTQURGTGF 9JGP 4KEJCTF ++ YCU MKNNGF KP VJG *QN[ .CPF YKVJ JKU UQP )WKNNCWOG UVKNN WPFGTCIG VJKPIU VQQM C VWTP HQT VJG YQTUG 9KNNKCO VJG %QPSWGTQT )WKNNCWOG TGUVQTGF FWECN RQYGT COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU D[ EQQRGTCVKPI ENQUGN[ YKVJ VJG EJWTEJ +P JG YCU MKPI KP JKU QYP NCPF +P /CKPG YCU UJQTVN[ CESWKTGF 9KNNKCO CUEGPFGF VJG 'PINKUJ VJTQPG KP KPKVKCVKPI C NQPI RGTKQF QH FKURWVG CPF EQQRGTCVKQP DGVYGGP VJG VYQ PCVKQPU #V 9KNNKCOʼnU FGCVJ JKU GNFGUV UQP 4QDGTV %QWTVQKUG DGECOG FWMG QH 0QTOCPF[ *KU UGEQPF UQP UWEEGGFGF JKO KP 'PINCPF (QNNQYKPI 4QDGTV 9KNNKCOʼnU VJKTF UQP YCU *GPT[ FWMG QH 0QTOCPF[ CPF -KPI QH 'PINCPF +P VJG [GCTU VQ HQNNQY YCT TCIGF QP UWEEGUUKQP KP 0QTOCPF[ CPF 'PINCPF UGG WPFGT 'PI NCPF +P VJG GPF *GPT[ ++ LQKPU DQVJ EQWPVTKGU WPFGT QPG TGKIP CU JG FKF #PLQW CPF #SWKVCKPG 6JG #PIGXKP 'ORKTG UVCTVGF #HVGT 4KEJCTF .KQPJGCTV CPF ,QJP .CEMNCPF JCF DGGP FWMG QH 0QTOCPF[ KP KV YGPV VQ VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP

)7+..#7/' .10)7' '2—'

&GPKGT 4QWGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 88 +.' ./8u 4 %TQUU YKVJ TJQOD KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING 4161/#%+5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 8KPEJQP 2CTKU EH .GITQU 44444 4161/#%5 )WKNNCWOG WUGU VJG NCVKP HQTO QH JKU PCOG VJG UCOG ECP DG UGGP YKVJ 9KNNKCO VJG %QPSWGTQT QP VJG VCRKUUGTKG FG $C[GWZ

116


4+%*#4& +

&GPKGT 4QWGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 4+%#4&85 4 6GORNG 4161/#)85. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CVVTCEVKXG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 2TGUWOCDN[ VJKU RKGEG YCU KP VJG JQCTF QH (¾ECOR &WOCU (ÀECOR +P VGZV QDXGTUG 5 KP VJG UJCRG QH C EWTNGF /

&GPKGT 4QWGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 4+%#4&85 4 /QPQITCO 4161/#385. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN *QCTF QH (¾ECOR &WOCU (¾ECOR JQCTF PQ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU EQKP WPFGT TGUGTXG VQ *WIJ DKUJQR QH 4QWGP /QPQITCO * CFLQKPGF D[ C 6 YKVJ CP 1 WPFGTPGCVJ KV

4+%*#4& ++

&GPKGT 4QWGP. # %TQUU 4+*#4&85 4 (QWT VTKCPINGU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG OKFFNG ETQUU DG VYGGP VJGO / %1 1e 1e $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ &QGUPʼnV CRRGCT KP .GITQU #NN V[RGU UJQYP CTG HTQO VJG )CKNNGHQPVCKPG HKPF KPXCTKCDN[ VJTGG VTKCPINGU YKVJ C EGPVTCN 5 6JG ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG KU VQVCN[ FKHHGTGPV HTQO VJCV QP VJG FGRKEVGF EQKPU

)7+..#7/' NG %1037 4#06

&GPKGT 4QWGP. # Q + Q WPFGT 6GORNG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG VQMGP KP GCEJ CPING. $ & XCT .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

117


%1706; QH &4'7: 6JG QNF PCOG HQT &TGWZ KU &TQECG 6JG JKUVQTKGU QH &TGWZ CPF 0QIGPV KP VJG HKTUV JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CTG ENQUGN[ CVVCEJGF +P *WIJ %CRGV EGFGF &TGWZ VQ %QWPV 1FQ + QH %JCTVTGU 9JGP 1FQ ++ FKGF KP JG NGHV &TGWZ VQ 4QIGT $KUJQR QH $GCWXCKU #HVGT JKU UWEEGUUQT 1FCNTKEJ $KUJQR QH 1TNGCPU FKGF KP 4QDGTV -KPI QH (TCPEG QPEG CICKP CFFGF &TGWZ VQ VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP $GVYGGP CPF .QWKU 8+ ITCPVGF &TGWZ EQOOWPCN NCY UGG WPFGT 0QTOCPF[ 4QWGP +P 4QDGTV DTQVJGT QH .QWKU 8+ TGEGKXGF &TGWZ CU CP CRCPCIG KPVTQFWEKPI VJG *QWUG QH &TGWZ +P &TGWZ YCU CDUQTDGF KPVQ VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP +P 0QIGPV C UKOKNCT FGXGNQROGPV ECP DG QDUGTXGF +P *WIJ VJG )TGCV VTCPUHGTTGF 0QIGPV VQ *WIJ FG $GCWXCKU #HVGT JKU FGOKUG 0QIGPV ECOG KPVQ VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH 4QIGT $KUJQR QH $GCWXCKU RGTJCRU 4QIGT YCU C DTQVJGT QH *WIJ QH $GCWXCKU CPF DQVJ YGTG UQPU QH *WIJ VJG )TGCV +P MKPI 4QDGTV DGUVQYGF 0QIGPV QP VJG CDDG[ QH %QWNQOD PGCT 0QIGPV VJKU CEV YCU CNUQ UKIPGF D[ 1FCNTKE JKU DTQVJGT +UGODCTV CPF *KIWGU $CTFQWN +UGODCTVʼnU UQP (TQO VQ KPVGTTWRVGF HTQO VQ *WIJ $CTFQWN GOGTIGF KP &TGWZ CU YGNN CU KP 0QIGPV

41)'4

&GPKGT. # %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU 41 )'4+85 '2 65 4 %TQUU &48%#5 %865. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 /KPQT VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 2NCVV 2CTKU $ KU PQV &TGWZ DWV 0QIGPV .GITQU 4444

*7)* $#4&17.

&GPKGT. # %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU *8) Z % Z /+6+ 4 %TQUU &48%#5 %#56#. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $TGF 2CTKU .GITQU 4

5'+)0+14; QH 01)'06 1&1.4+%

&GPKGT. # %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU +1'0%+85 '2+5 4 %TQUU 58/505 %8 /. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG RKGEG 2NCVV 2CTKU +P .GITQU FGUETKDGF CU WPKSWG 6TQWXCKNNG FG 8GTPGWKN JQYGXGT PQV VJG UCOG 1FCNTKE DKUJQR QH 1TNGCPU VQIGVJGT YKVJ +UGODCTF FG $TQ[GU 4GXGTUG FQWDNG 5 NCUV CPF KPXGTVGF %

*7)* $#4&17.

&GPKGT. # %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU *8)1 1 +6+ 4 %TQUU /e+u8e*8e 5 . $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 4 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM YKVJ UOCNN UETCVEJGU QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU .GITQU 4444 .GITQU IKXGU C UQOGYJCV FKHHGTGPV VGZV *7)1% 1/+

118


&7%*; QH $4+66#0; 6JG RCTV QH )CWN PCOGF #TOQTKEC YQWNF NCVGT DGEQOG VJG FWEJ[ QH $TKVVCP[ +P VJG TF EGP VWT[ C NQV QH %GNVU HTQO +TGNCPF ECOG VQ $TKVVCP[ CPF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG #PINQUCZQPU GPVGTGF 6JG TGIKQPʼnU PCOG FGTKXGU HTQO VJGKT NCPF QH QTKIKP $TKVVCPKC CU )TGIQT[ QH 6QWTU OGPVKQPU 1TKIKPCNN[ KVU RGQRNG EQPUKUVGF QH VJTGG ITQWRU %QTKQUQNKVGU 1UUKUOK CPF 8GPGVK (TQO VQ VJG HCOKN[ QH VJG 9KFQPU KU VTCEGCDNG WPFGT VJGO QPG .CODGTV 0GKVJGT 2KRRKP VJG 5JQTV PQT %JCTNGOCIPG PQT .QWKU VJG 2KQWU UCY EJCPEG VQ UWDLGEV $TKVVCP[ RGTOCPGPVN[ 6JG 9KVVQPU OGV VJGKT GPF FWTKPI VJG 8KMKPI TCKFU 6JG NCUV QH VJGO #NCKP $CTDGVQTVK YCU GZKNGF KP 'PINCPF WPFGT MKPI #VJGNUVCP #P KPVGTTGIPWO QH [GCTU HQNNQYGF +P #NCP YCU TGUVQTGF VQ FWMG QH $TKVVCP[ YKVJ VJG CKF QH #VJGNUVCP )WKNNCWOG .QPIWG 'R¾G CPF *WIJ VJG )TGCV #HVGT #NCPʼnU FGCVJ FKURWVG CTQUG COQPI VJG EQWPVU QH 4GPPGU CPF 0CPVGU KP YJKEJ VJG EQWPVU QH #PLQW CPF $NQKU RNC[GF CP KORQTVCPV RCTV #PQVJGT KPVGTKO HQNNQYGF NCUVKPI [GCTU (KPCNN[ %QPCP + ITCPFUQP QH VJG EQWPV QH 4GPPGU $GTGPICT ECOG VQ RQYGT 9KVJ VJG FGOKUG QH %QPCP ++ VJG *QWUG 4GPPGU DGECOG GZVKPEV #NCP +++ CRCTV HTQO JKU UQP %QPCP ++ JCF C FCWIJVGT *CXQKUG 5JG YGFFGF *QÀN UQP QH VJG EQWPV QH %QTPQWCKNNG YJKEJ KPVTQFWEGF VJG *QWUG %QTPQWCKNNG IQXGTPKPI HTQO 0CPVGU 7RQP VJG FGCVJ QH VJGKT ITCPFUQP %QPCP +++ C HGWF UVCTVGF DGVYGGP JKU UQP *QÀ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½XTG (TGPEJ CRRGPFCIG UWRRQTVGF D[ %JCTNGU QH $NQKU OCTTKGF VQ )WKFQʼn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

6JG *QWUG QH 4GPPGU #.#+0 +++

&GPKGT 4GPPGU. # /QPQITCO # DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU QXGT % CPF 1 YKVJ UVTKRG VJTQWIJ KV CPF QPG RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJGO $4 +6 6100 8++5 4 %TQUU YKVJ C JQQH KTQP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 4'&10+5 %+ 8+6. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG

%10#0 ++

#NCP QPN[ NGHV QPG UQP %QPCP ++ C OGTG KPHCPV )WCTFKCP YCU 'WFQP FG 2GPVJK½XTG YJQ CEVGF CU TWNGT QH $TKVVCP[

&GPKGT 4GPPGU. # &GIGPGTCVGF ECTQNKPIKCP OQPQITCO %10#085 1/ 4 %TQUU 4'&10+5 %6#5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

/Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ (CNUGN[ OGPVKQPGF KP VJG NKVGTCVWTG QP VJG QDXGTUG DNWPFGTGF OQPQITCO QH *GTDGTV EQWPV QH .G /CPU +V KU C FGIGPGTCVGF ECTQNKPIKCP VGORNG 6Q VJG NGHV CP 5 VQ VJG TKIJV C JQQH KTQP YKVJ C UOCNN VTKCPING WPFGTPGCVJ

119


%10#0 +++

&GPKGT 4GPPGU. # + 8 5 KP VJG HKGNF %10#085 4 %TQUU 4'&10+5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNCPFKC -CORGTXGGP

6JG *QWUG QH %QTPQWCKNNG ,'#0 + NG 417:

&GPKGT &TGWZ. # %TQUU +1*#00'5 &8: 4 5JKGNF QH &TGWZ $ 4+6 #0+ '. $ & 2F# IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP %QCV QH CTOU TGXGTUG ¾EW ¾EJKSWGV¾ FG &TGWZ CW HTCPE ECPVQP F JGTOKPGU %QCV QH CTOU QH $TKVVCP[ NʼnJGTOKPG

1DQNG &TGWZ. # %TQUU +1J#00'5 &7: 4 5JKGNF QH &TGWZ $ 4+6 #0+ '. $ & 2F# IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU %QCV QH CTOU ¾EW ¾EJKSWGV¾ FG &TGWZ CW HTCPE ECPVQPU F JGTOKPGU %JGEMGTGF EQCV QH CTOU QH &TGWZ

6JG *QWUG QH /QPVHQTV ,'#0 8 FG /106(146

$NCPE CWZ PGWH OQWEJGVWTGU 4GPPGU. # 0KPG URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG +1J#00'5 $4+6108 &8: 4 4 %TQUU 5+6 01/' &0+ $'0'&+%68. $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKP[

$NCPE ¯ NC 6CTIG &KPCP. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ GKIJV URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG +1J#00'5 $4+6108 &8: & 4 %TQUU 5+6 01/' &0+ $'0'&+%68. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

0WO -TKPI 4QVVGTFCO $QWIJV HTQO X F 9KGN

$TGF 2CTKU PF RGTKQF VQ

120


(4#0%1+5 +

$NCPE ¯ NC 6CTIG 4GPPGU. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ GKIJV URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG (4#%+5%85 „ $4+6108 „ &8: 4 4 %TQUU 5+6 Q 01/' „ &0+ „ $'0'&+%68. $ & 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM WR URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG 8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

(4#0%1+5 ++

—EW F QT CW EJGXCNKGT 4GPPGU. # /QWPVGF OGP YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH $TKVVCP[ (4#0%+5%85

&'+ )4#%+# $4+6108 &8: 4 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ GTOKPG KP SWCVTGHQKN &'85 +0 #&+8614+8/ /'8/ +0 6#0&' $ . $ & (D 2F# IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG RKGEG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 6JG NCUV NGVVGT QP VJG QDXGTUG KU DCTGN[ NGIKDNG RTGUWOCDN[ CP 4 QH 4GPPGU QP VJG TGXGTUG VJG NCUV NGVVGT YQWNF CNUQ JCXG VQ DG CP 4 KV NQQMU NKMG C $ JQYGXGT

$NCPE ¯ NC 6CTIG 0CPVGU. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ GKIJV URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG & (4#0%+5%85 $4+6108 &8: 0 4 %TQUU ∆ 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68/ 6. $ & 2F# IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU

$NCPE ¯ NC 6CTIG 0CPVGU. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ GKIJV URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG (4#0%+5%85 $4+6108 &8: 0 4 %TQUU 5+6 01/' &0+ $'0'&+%68/ . $ & 2F# IT. $TQCF HNCP XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP $QPXCNNGV 2CTKU 6JG FKHHGTGPEG YKVJ VJG RTGXKQWU PQ KU VJCV VJG OQWEJGVWTG CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG NGIGPF KU OKUUKPI

121


)TQU ¯ Nʼn¾EW 0CPVGU. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ UKZ URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG (4#0%+5%85 $4+6108/ &8: 0 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ 0 KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68/ . $ & 2F# IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM UOCNN FQWDNG UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU

)TQU ¯ N ¾EW 4GPPGU. # %QCV QH CTOU YKVJ UKZ URGEMNGU QH GTOKPG CP VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG EGPVTG (44#0%+%5 ¡ $4+6108/ ¡ &8: ¡ 4 ¡ & ¡ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ 4 KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+%68/. $ & # 2F# IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG 8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

%1706; QH 2'06*+–84' 9JGP )GQHHTQ[ + &WMG QH $TKVVCP[ FKGF KP QHHKEG KP VJG JKUVQT[ QH 2GPVJK½XTG EQO OGPEGU *KU GNFGUV UQP #NCP +8 TGEGKXGF $TKVVCP[ 6JG UGEQPF UQP 'WFGU KPJGTKVGF VJG FKQEGUGU 6T¾SWKGT 5CKPV $TKGWE 5CKPV /CNQ CPF &QN 'WFGUʼn UQP 'VKGPPG + YCU RTCEVK ECNN[ VJG QPN[ QPG VJCV UVTWEM EQKP YJKEJ JG FKF KP )WKPICOR .CVGT VJKU V[RG YQWNF DG KOK VCVGF WUWCNN[ KP C DCTGN[ NGIKDNG HQTO 7PFGT 2KGTTG /CWENGTE UGG WPFGT $TKVVCP[ VJG OKPV YCU CPPGZGF QPEG OQTG D[ $TKVVCP[

'6+'00' +

&GPKGT KOOQDKNK\GF V[RG )WKPICOR. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU 56'2J#0 %1/ 4 *GCF T YKVJ UVCT DGNQY )8+0)#/2. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN +V KU RGEWNKCT VJCV YKVJ VJG (TGPEJ PCOG DGKPI 'VKGPPG VJG EQKPU UJQY VJG )GTOCP XGTUKQP 5VGRJCP

122


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

%*#4.'5 +++ QH 8#.1+5

1DQNG #PIGTU. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPING -#41.85 %1/'5 4 -G[ DGVYGGP VYQ NKU #0&')#8'05+5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 1T )GUVKQP 2CTKU (TQO NKUV PQ EH .GITQU 44 +P $QWFGCW WPFGT %JCTNGU ++

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

*'4$'46 + '8'+..' %*+'0

&GPKGT .G /CPU. # 'TDGTVWU OQPQITCO %1/'5 %'0 1/ #00+5 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF PF CNRJC CPF QOGIC KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU 5+)08/ &' + 8+ 8+. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JKU V[RG YCU UVTWEM HQT C NQPI VKOG CU V[RG KOOQDKNKU¾

123


%*#4.'5 +++

&GPKGT .G /CPU. # .KU WPFGT ETQYP /10'6# %'01/ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+)07/ &'+ 8+8+. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. /KPQT GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG *QNNCPFKC -CORGTXGGP .GITQU 44 +P &WRNGUU[ CPF 2QG[ F #XCPV VJGTG CTG TKPIU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU DWV JGTG KV KU ENGCTN[ C VTGHQKN

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ʼnV WPVKN VJCV KV YCU TGLQKPGF YKVJ VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP 6JG RTQURGTKV[ QH VJKU TGIKQP KU OKTTQTGF KP KVU EQKPCIG +P KV DGECOG CP CRCPCIG VQ ,QJP ++ CPF KP KV YQWNF UGTXG CU C DCUG HQT ,QCP QH #TEʼnU NKDGTCVKQP QH 1TNGCPU

#010;/175

&GPKGT 6QWTU %JKPQP. # *GCF T 68410 4 %TQUU %+++++1+++%#564+++1. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JKU EQKP KU PQV GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG OGPVKQPGF KP VJG NKVGTCVWTG DWV UKOKNCT VQ KV GURGEKCNN[ VJG TGXGTUG .GITQU 44444 +P VGZV QP TGXGTUG KPXGTVGF % .G V[RG ¯ NC V¿VG ET¾¾ RCT NGU CDD¾U FG 5CKPV /CTVKP GWV WPG RQUV¾TKV¾ KPF¾PKCDNG KN HWV TGRTKU ¯ %JKPQP .GU RK½EGU FG %JKPQP RQTVGPV CW FTQKV UQKV WPG VKVWNCVWTG TQ[CNG UQKV WPG T¾H¾TGPEG ¯ 6QWTU UQWU NC HQTOG 68410 .GU RK½EGU ¯ NC V¿VG GV ¯ NC OGPVKQP 68410 HWTGPV HTCRR¾GU RGPFCPV NC R¾TKQFG +N HCWFTCKV CFOGVVTG SWG 6JK DCWV NG 8KGWZ XKEQOVG FG 6QWTU FG ¯ GPXKTQP OQPPC[C ¯ WP V[RG CWVQPQOG EQRKCPV EGNWK FG 5CKPV /CT VKP 6JKDCWV RQUU¾FCKV %JKPQP GP HKGH GV KN UGTCKV ¾VQPPCPV SWG UQP UGKIPGWT *WIJ VJG )TGCV NWK RGTOKV FG OQPPC[GT CW PQOG FG 6QWTU SWK NWK CRRCTVGPCKV GV ¯ WP V[RG GUUGPVKGNNGOGPV FKHH¾TGPV FG EGWZ GP WUCIG FCPU NGU FQOCKP TQDGTVKGPPG # %JKPQP F½U .QWKU +8 NʼnKPUETKRVKQP 68410 HWV TGORNCE¾ RCT NC N¾IGPFG .8&18+%85 4': 1T PQWU UCXQPU SWG 6JKDCWV ¾VCKV CNQTU UQWU NC VWVGNNG Fʼn*WIJ VJG )TGCV GV SWʼnKN CEEGRVC NG TÊNG FG IGÊNKGT NQTUSWG NG 4QDGTVKGP NWK EQPHKC GP NC ICTFG FW TQK .QWKU +8 NQUT FG UQP ECRVKXKV¾ EH &WOCU GP .GITQU (QT VJG V[RG YKVJ VJG KPUETKRVKQP .8&+8+%85 4': UGG PQ WPFGT %CTQNKPIKCPU

124


#010;/175 UGEQPF JCNH VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT 5V /CTVKP FG 6QWTU. # .QPI %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 5%5 /Q#46+085 4 %TQUU 6841085 %+8+. $ & XCT .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU .GITQU 44

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT 5V /CTVKP FG 6QWTU # %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 5%5 /#46+085 4 %TQUU 6841085 %+8+. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

6JG EJ³VGN VQWTPQKU JCU FGXGNQRGF CU HQNNQYU HTQO VJG ECTQNKPIKCP VGORNG

125


6JG *QWUG QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG 6JKDCWFKGPU $GUKFGU VJG *QWUG QH #PLQW KP EGPVTCN (TCPEG VJG *QWUG QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG YCU VJG OQUV RQYGTHWN 6JG *QWUG QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG KU CP GCTN[ GZCORNG QH F[PCUVKECN VGTTKVQTKCN RQNKVKEU

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³VKNNQP UQNF VJG EQWPV[ $NQKU VQ .QWKU Fʼn1TNGCPU UGG CNUQ .QTTCKPG $GECWUG VJKU VGTTKVQTKCN EQPINQOGTCVG YCU TWNGF D[ QPG *QWUG KP PWOGTQWU VGTTKVQTKGU EQKPU CTG VQ DG HQWPF VJCV VJQWIJ UVTWEM KP C UGKIPGWTKCN U[UVGO YGTG KUUWGF D[ VJG EQWPVU QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG 6JG EQKPU JCXG EGTVCKP EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU 9KVJ VJG 6QWTU EQKPU OQFGNNKPI C V[RG FGXGNQRGF VJCV DGECOG MPQYP CU V[RG EJKPQPCKUG .GITQU FKUEGTPU VYQ UWDECVGIQTKGU VJG V[RG %JCTVTCKPG CPF VJG V[RG $N¾QUQKUG 6JG HKTUV HGCVWTGU C EJCUVG UVKNKUGF JGCF VJG WRRGT RCTV QH VJG JGCF GZKUVKPI QH UKPING EQPPGEVGF NKPGU 6JG UGEQPF UWDECVGIQT[ KU FKUVKPIWKUJGF D[ C OQTG JWOCP JGCF RCTVKEWNCTN[ KP 5V #KIPCP VJCV UGGOU VQ DG ETQYPGF 6JG[ JCXG DGGP UVTWEM VJTQWIJQWV VJG VGTTKVQTKGU UVCTVKPI VQ CHVGT YJKEJ C VTCPUKVKQP VQ VJG OQFGN QH VJG 6QWTU FGPKGT QEEWTU 6JG FGXGNQROGPV QH VJG V¿VG EJKPQPCKUG ECP DG UEJGOCVKECNN[ GNWEKFCVGF CU HQNNQYU

126


%1706; QH %*#464'5

'7&'5 + 6*+$#76 ++

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU 4 %TQUU %#4 6+5 %+8+ 6#5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG $QTI *GNUKPMK (CVJGT 1FQ + CPF UQP 6JKDCWV ++ DQVJ YGTG EQWPVU QH $NQKU 9KVJ &WRNGUU[ VJG[ CTG EJCTCEVGTKUGF CU DGKPI CPQP[OQWU :½OG UK½ENG GV RTGOK½TG OQKVK¾ FW :K½OG

'7&'5 ++

1DQNG. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU 4 %TQUU %#46+5 %+8+6#5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG 1FQ ++ HTQO QP YCU EQWPV QH $NQKU CPF HTQO QP CNUQ EQWPV QH %JCORCIPG &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU XGTU

%* 6'#7&70

'7&'5 ++

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU 4 %TQUU &80+5 %#56..+. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG $TGF 2CTKU .GITQU 44444 $ CPF 2# JCXG C RGNNGV KPUVGCF QH C ETGUEGPV OQQP KP VJG JGCF 1FQ ++ HTQO VJG *QWUG $NQKU %JCORCIPG &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU DGVYGGP

6*+$#76 +8 NG )4#0&

1DQNG. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU WPFGT RKNG 4 %TQUU +80+%5 8)6(... $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG #TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 6JKDCWV +8 HTQO VJG *QWUG $NQKU %JCORCIPG EQWPV QH $NQKU CPF EQWPV QH %JCORCIPG 6JG EQKP TGUGODNGU VQ & DWV JCU C FKHHGTGPV NGIGPF

6*+$#76 8 NG $10 .17+5

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T DGVYGGP VYQ ETGUEGPVU WPFGT QOGIC 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU &80+% 5#56+ . $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

#TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 6JKDCWV +8 YCU EQWPV QH $NQKU CPF HTQO QP CNUQ EQWPV QH %JCORCIPG *KU DTQVJGT YCU 5VGRJGP QH $NQKU NCVGT VQ DGEQOG MKPI QH 'PINCPF &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU XGTU

127


6*+$#76 +++

%1706; QH $.1+5

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU $'+5+5 %#5641. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU .GITQU 44 1PN[ C TGHGTGPEG VQ #PP FG NC 5QEK¾VG HTCPEJCKUG FG PWOKUOCVKSWG R 6JKDCWV +++ YCU HTQO QP CNUQ EQWPV QH %JCORCIPG &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU XGTU

5'+)0+14; QH %'..'5 UWT %*'4 6JG .QTFU QH %GNNGU YGTG XCUUCNU QH VJG .QTFU QH 5V #KIPCP 5QNGN[ 4QDGTV + JCU EQKPGF DCUGF QP VJG $N¾QUQKUG V[RG #HVGT VJCV EQKPU YGTG OQFGNNGF CHVGT VJG 6QWTU FGPKGT

41$'46 +

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T ETQUU YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 41$ &' %'.' . $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU .GITQU 444 6JG QPN[ TGHGTGPEG KU #PP FG NC 5QEK¾VG HTCPECKUG FG PWOKUOCVKSWG R

5'+)0+14; QH 5V #+)0#0 6JG .QTFU QH &QP\[ YGTG XCUUCNU QH VJG EQWPVU QH $NQKU UGG CNUQ VJG %QWPV[ QH &QP\[ %QKP CIG DCUKPI QP VJG $N¾QUQKUG V[RG EQOOGPEGF KP VJG [GCTU VQ CPF GPFGF KP 6JG EQKPU QH 5V #KIPCP GXGT[ QPG CPQP[OQWU FKURNC[ VJG OQUV JCPFUQOG FGUKIP QH VJG V¿VGU EJKPQ PCKUGU CPF VJG PQP UV[NKUGF JGCFU #HVGT VJKU RGTKQF EQKPU YGTG OQFGNNGF CHVGT VJG 6QWTU FGPKGT

#010;/175 VJ VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ ETQUU CPF HQWT RGNNGVU KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF KP GCEJ CPING 5#06+#+0#+01. $ & # .GITQU 2F# XCT IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #NN TGHGTGPEGU VQ #PPWCKTG FG NC 5QEK¾V¾ HTCPECKUG FG PWOKUOCVKSWG R +P TGXGTUG VGZV KPXGTVGF 5 # EQPUKUVKPI QH VJTGG VTKCPINGU &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU :+½OG UK½ENG

128


&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ ETQUU CPF HQWT RGNNGVU KP HTQPV QH KV TQWIJ FTCYKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF KP GCEJ CPING 5#06+#0#+01. $ & # .GITQU 2F# XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU .GITQU QPN[ TGHGTU VQ VJG #PPWCKTG FG NC 5QEK¾V¾ HTCPECKUG FG PWOKUOCVKSWG R &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU :+½OG UK½ENG

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ ETQUU CPF HQWT RGNNGVU KP HTQPV QH KV HKPG FTCYKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF KP GCEJ CPING 5#0%6+#0+#0+1. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU .GITQU 444 #NN TGHGTGPEGU CTG VQ 6T¾UQT FG /CUUG[ UWT %JGT EQPEGCNGF CTQWPF &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU :+½OG UK½ENG

1DQNG. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG T YKVJ ETQUU CPF HQWT RGNNGVU KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF KP GCEJ CPING 5#0%6+#+0#+01. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU 1DXGTUG UCOG FTCYKPI CU PQ YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING QH VJG ETQUU .GITQU 444 #NN TGHGTGPEGU VQ #PP FG NC 5QEK¾V¾ HTCPECKUG FG PWOKUOCVKSWG R &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU :++½OG UK½ENG

%1706; QH &10<; )'1((41+ ++ GV 5WEE

1DQNG )KGP. # %TQUU YKVJ CNRJC CPF QOGIC KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU %415'&85 %15 4 /QPQITCO DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC )+'/+5 %#. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU 6JG OQPQITCO QP VJG TGXGTUG KU C DNWPFGTGF OQPQITCO QH (QWNSWGU Fʼn#PLQW 6JG EQKPU QH )KGP VJCV CTG CNN KP RQQT EQPFKVKQP CTG DCUGF QP VJG V[RG QH (QWNSWGU Fʼn#PLQW DWV YJ[ KU WPENGCT 6JGTG KU PQ EQPPGEVKQP CPF VJG TGIKQPU NKG HCT CRCTV 6JG ECUVNG QH )KGP KU RWTRQTVGF VQ DG DWKNV D[ %JCTNGOCIPG +P VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ KV DGNQPIU VQ )GQH HTQK FG 5¾OWT HCVJGT QH )GQHHTQK + .QTF QH &QP\[ #HVGT JKO KV KU VTCPUHGTTGF VQ VJG DCTQPU QH &QP\[ +P WP FGT *GPT[ +8 KV IQGU VQ VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP 6JKU EQKP NCEMU UGG CNN TGHGTGPEGU VJG NKU DGVYGGP VJG % CPF VJG 4 QH %415'&85 &WRNGUU[ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU URGEKOGP VQ )GQHHTG[ +++

129


*'48' +++ QH &10<;

&GPKGT )KGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG VTKCPING KP VJG PF CPF TF CPING UVCHH YKVJ JCOOGTJGCF! %15'&85 %15 4 /QPQITCO )+'/+5 %#. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG 6WTSWCV /QPVRGNNKGT 6JG OQPQITCO QP VJG TGXGTUG QPEG CICKP KU C DNWPFGTGF OQPQITCO QH (QWNSWGU F #PLQW &WRNGUU[ CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ )GQHHTG[ +++

5'+)0+14; QH 8+'4<10 +P VJG EQWPV QH $NQKU %JCTVTGU 6JKDCWV NG 8KGWZ RQUUGUUGF VJG 8KGT\QP ECUVNG 1FQ + UQP QH 6JKDCWV NG 6TKEJGWT ICXG VJG UGKIPGWTKG KP HKGH VQ VJG MPKIJV *WPDCWF NG 6QTVW *KU UWEEGUUQTU UGTXGF NQ[CNN[ CU XCUUCN QH VJG EQWPVU QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG 6JG *QWUG *WPDCWF DGECOG GZVKPEV KP 6JG UGKIPGWTKG HGNN VQ $TCDCPV ,Ã’NKEJ CPF YCU GXGPVWCNN[ CFFGF VQ VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP CHVGT

*'48' +

&GPKGT. # )TGCV HNQYGT DGVYGGP VQ NKU 4 %TQUU 8+45+10'. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU XGTU

%1706; QH 5#0%'44' 'OGTIGF HTQO VJG UOCNN UGKIPGWTKG QH %J³VGCWIQTFQP VJCV FGRGPFGF QP VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH $QWTIGU +P 1FQ ++ HTQO VJG *QWUG QH $NQKU %JCORCIPG TGEGKXGF KV VJTQWIJ OCTTKCIG 6JWU 5VGRJGP 'VKGPPG ECOG VQ KPJGTKV VJG UGKIPGWTKG +PUVGCF QH DGKPI PCOGF CHVGT %J³VGCW IQTFQP VJG UGKIPGWTKG YCU TGHGTTGF VQ CU 5 5CPEGTWO 5CPEGTTG DGECOG C EQWPV[ +P URKVG QH VJGKT EQOKVCN VKVNG VJG EQWPVU QH 5CPEGTTG YGTG OGTGN[ OKPQT XCUUCNU QH VJG MKPI 9KVJ ,QJP +++ VJG EQWPV[ EGCUGF VQ GZKUV KP CPF HGNN VQ VJG &CWRJKPU Fʼn#WXGTIPG

'6+'00' +

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG VJ CPING 5'2*#0 85 %1/' 4 *GCF T +8.+ 85 %'5#4. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. (NCP ETCEM CPF JQNG XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 5CPEGTTG UJQYU ,WNKWU %CGUCT QP KVU EQKPU DGECWUG ,WNKWU %CGUCT KU RTGUWOGF VQ JCXG HQWPFGF 5CPEGTTG /QUVN[ C UVCT KU UGGP DGJKPF VJG JGCF JGTG KV KUPʼnV EH & C TGHGTGPEG VQ VJG EQOGV VJCV CRRGCTGF CV VJG FGCVJ QH ,WNKWU %CGUCT +P VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG VJG 6 KU OKUUKPI 'VKGPPG + 'VKGPPG ++ FG %JCORCIPG EQWPV QH $NQKU

130


%1706; QH 8'0&¢/' *GTG VJG EQWPVU EQKPGF VJGOUGNXGU UVCTVKPI YKVJ $QWEJCTF ++ DCUGF QP VJG $N¾QUQKUG V[RG &WTKPI VJG TGKIP QH ,QJP +++ VJGTG YCU C EJCPIG VQ VJG 6QWTU FGPKGT OQFGN

(17.37'5 Nʼn1+510

&GPKGT. # 6¿VG EJKPQPCKUG YKVJ ETQUU KP CPF TKPI KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ TKPI KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU 8+0&1%+01 % #6 41 . $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV .GITQU 4444 YKVJ %#56+1 KPUVGCF QH %#641 &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU KV CU CPQP[OQWU DGVYGGP

5'+)0+14; QH &'1.5 %* 6'#7417: 6JG XKEWU &¾QNU GPEQORCUUGU VJG TGIKQP QH &¾QNU CPF %J³VGCWTQWZ CPF KU QH EGNVKE QTKIKP +P VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ &¾QNU DGNQPIGF VQ 'DDQ $KVWTKEWU C YGCNVJ[ HKFGNKU QH )WKNNCWOG NG 2KGWZ FWMG QH #SWKVCKPG CPF EQWPV QH $QWTIGU YJQ HQWPFGF %NWP[ KP +P 'DDQ HQWPFGF C OQPCUVGT[ KP &¾QNU &¾QNU DGECOG C RTKPEKRCNKV[ CPF UGXGTCN OKPQT UGKIPGWTKGU HGNN WPFGT KV COQPI YJKEJ +UUQWFWP 6JG EQKPU QH &¾QNU KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ FQOKPCVGF VJG TGIKQP 6JGTG YCU UVKNN UQOG FGRGPF GPEG QP VJG EQWPVU QH 2QKVKGTU CPF VJG FWMGU QH #SWKVCKPG DWV QVJGTYKUG &¾QNU YCU HCKTN[ CWVQPQOQWU +P VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 4WFQNRJ 8 VQQM QP VJG PCOG QH %J³VGCWTQWZ 6JG *QWUG QH %JCWXKIP[ VJCV CESWKTGF EQPVTQN QH &¾QNU VJTQWIJ VJG OCTTKCIG QH #PFT¾ FG %JCW XKIP[ VQ &¾PKUG JGKTGUU QH &¾QNU JGPEGHQTVJ ECNNGF KVUGNH VJG .QTFU QH %J³VGCWTQWZ

'7&'5 N #0%+'0

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 1&1 &8: 4 /QPQITCO &1.'1%+8'5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$QPXCNNGV 2CTKU

RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 1&1 &8: 4 2GPVCITCO &1.'1%+8'5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP -TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV .GITQU 4 +P VGZV TGXGTUG KPXGTVGF 5 &WRNGUU[ EJCTCEVGTKUGU WPFGT 1FQ VJG 'NFGT

131


4#17. 8++

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 4#&8.(85 4 *GZCITCO YKVJ TKPI KP VJG EGPVTG &'&1.+5. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

5'+)0+14; QH +5517&70 1NF )CNNQ 4QOCP UGVVNGOGPV VJCV FGENKPGF WPFGT VJG /GTQXKPIKCPU +P KV YCU UGK\GF D[ VJG .QTF QH &¾QNU 1FQ VJG 'NFGT +P KV YCU OGTIGF YKVJ &¾QNU HQT )WKNNCWOG + FG %JCWXKIP[ OCTTKGF /CJCWV JGKTGUU QH +UUQWFWP 6JG EQKPU YGTG PQY ENQUGN[ CVVCEJGF VQ VJQUG QH &¾QNU +P VJG UGKIPKQT[ DGECOG RCTV QH VJG TQ[CN FQOCKP

RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF VJ CPINGU 1&4 :' 6 4 / DGVYGGP UVTKRG CPF TKPI &64 '5 8 . $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

4#17. ++

&GPKGT. # / DGVYGGP VYQ YGFIGU ETGUEGPV! CPF TKPI 4#&8.(85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG UV CPF TF CPINGU :1.+&80. $ & .GITQU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

#$$'; QH 5178+)0; %NWPKCUGPUG CDDG[ KP VJG $QWTDQPPCKU (KTUV OGPVKQPGF KP (TQO OGPVKQPGF CU FG RGPFGPV QP %NWP[ +P 5QWXKIP[ IQXGTPGF EJWTEJGU CPF CDDG[U 5QWXKIP[ CPF %NWP[ YGTG ENQUGN[ CVVCEJGF 6YQ CDDQVU QH %NWP[ FKGF KP 5QWXKIP[ QPG QH VJGO DGKPI /CKQNWU YJQO YG HKPF QP VJG EQKPU 7PVKN 5QWXKIP[ HGNN WPFGT VJG FKTGEV RTGNCE[ QH VJG %NWP[ CDDQVU CHVGT YJKEJ )WKFQ EQWPV QH /³EQP CRRGCTGF CPF 5QWXKIP[ DGECOG CP KPFGRGPFGPV RTKQT[

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV /CKGWT HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 5%5 /#+1.85 4 %TQUU 5+.8+0+#%1. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU

132


&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV /CKGWT HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 5%5 /#+1.85 4 %TQUU 5+.8+0+#%1. $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU

/10'6#4; #..+#0%' YKVJ #4%*#/$#7& : UGKIPGWT QH $174$10

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV /CKGWT HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT WPFGT UVTKRG CPF VYQ UJGNNU 5%5 /#+1.85 4 %TQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP VJG PF CPING &'5+.8+0+#%1. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $CVCXKC FGP *CCI

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¾IKOG

#010;/175 XGTU

&GPKGT. # + VJTGG RGNNGVU QXGT GCEJQVJGT CPF ETQUU WPFGT UKEMNG .1&8+%85 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ VTGHQKN KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU $14$10'05. $ & 2F# IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

,1*0 ++

1DQNG FG DKNNQP 6T¾XQWZ. # .KU WPFGT ETQUU DGCO +*'5 &8% $14$ 10+ 4 %TQUU 1$1.85 05. $ 2F# IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU 6JG TGXGTUG UJQWNF UJQY 64'815+ DWV KV FQGUPʼnV 6JG % KP VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU KPXGTVGF 6JG UGKIPGWTKG 6T¾XQWZ QTKIKPCNN[ DGNQPIGF VQ VJG RTKPEKRCNKV[ QH &QODGU UKVWCVGF CDQXG .[QP +P *WODGTV 8++ UQNF UGXGTCN UGKIPGWTKGU COQPI YJKEJ 6T¾XQWZ VQ VJG FWMGU QH $QWTDQP YJQ VJWU CESWKTGF RCTV QH &QODGU ,QJP ++ CPF JKU UWEEGUUQT 2KGTTG ++ JCXG EQKPGF KP 6T¾XQWZ

133


&+1%'5' QH 27; /GPVKQPGF D[ )TGIQT[ QH 6QWTU 6JG FKQEGUG CEVWCNN[ JCXKPI DGGP HQWPFGF TGOCKPU WPEGTVCKP

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

#010;/175

1DQNG. # %TQUU YKVJ UKZ NKODU 4 %TQUU. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 2QG[ F #XCPV JCU C RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPING QH VJG TGXGTUG YJKEJ KU PQV XKUKDNG JGTG

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

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH /CTKC HCEKPI YKVJ ETQYP 5'# /#4+# 4 %TQUU YKVJ VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING 84$5 #48'40#. $ & 2F# IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP CPF XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

1DQNG. # $WUV QH /CTKC HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUU RQKPVGF ETQYP 5'# /#4+# 4 %TQUU YKVJ VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING 8 #48'40#. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

.B1DUGTXCPEG &TCIWKIPCP 1DXGTUG ' YKVJ RTQNQPIGF JQTK\QPVCN OKFFNG NKPG 5%# 5CPEVC

134


%1706; QH 21+617 4COPWNH YCU VJG HKTUV EQWPV QH VJG RQVGPV F[PCUV[ VJCV TWNGF 2QKVQW HTQO VQ )WKN NCWOG + NG 2KGWZ YCU VJG HQWPFGT QH %NWP[ +P VJG EQWPV QH 2QKVQW )WKNNCWOG +++ 6¿VG Fʼn—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¾VKIP[ 2QKVQW CPF 2QKVKGTU YGPV VQ VJG 'PINKUJ +P 2QKVKGTU QRGPGF KVU ICVGU VQ $GTVTCPF &W )WGUENKP CPF 2QKVKGTU CPF VJG YJQNG QH 2QKVQW DGECOG CP CRC PCIG QH FWMG ,GCP FG $GTT[ 6JG XKEVQT[ CV %CUVKNNQP KP RWV CP GPF VQ 'PINKUJ VJTGCVU QPEG CPF HQT CNN

#010;/175 EC EC

&GPKGT TF V[RG. # %TQUU %#4.85 4' 1 4 +P VYQ NKPGU /'6 #.1 DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU &WRNGUU[ UC[U %QPVTCKTGOGPV ¯ EG SWʼnCHHKTOG &WOCU CRT½U 2QG[ Fʼn#XCPV EGU FGPKGTU PG UQPV RCU FGU KOOQDKNKUC VKQPU FG %JCTNGU NG %JCWXG OCKU FG %JCTNGU NG 5KORNG .GU FGPKGTU FG /GNNG CW V[RG DKNKP¾CKTG PʼnCRRCTCKUUGPV FCPU CWEWP VT¾UQT OQP¾VCKTG FG NC HKP FW :K½OG UK½ENG .GU RNWU CPEKGPU UG VTQWXCKGPV FCPU NGU VT¾UQTU FG %JGH $QWVQPPG

GV FG 4GPPGU

1DQNG /GNNG. # %TQUU % # 4.85 4': 4 +P VYQ NKPGU /'6 #.1 QXGT ETQUU. $ & 2F# IT. (KPG VQPGF CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ VJ EGPVWT[

4+%*#4& + %ę74 &' .+10

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 4+%#4&85 4': 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU 2+% 6#8+' 05+5. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

135


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

D[ YJKEJ C TQWIJ CPF TGCF[ NKCKUQP YKVJ 'PINCPF YCU GUVCDNKUJGF UVCTVKPI VJCV YQWNF NCUV C NQPI VKOG #SWKVCKPGU JKUVQT[ KU FQOKPCVGF D[ VJG QRRQUKPI ETQYPU QH 'PINCPF CPF (TCPEG 2JKNKR ++ #WIWUV EQPHKUECVGF ,QJP .CEMNCPFʼnU RQUUGUUKQPU CPF VJGP .QWKU +: EQPSWGTGF 2QKVQW 'XGT[VJKPI UGGOGF NQUV HQT 'PINCPF GZEGRV )CUEQIPG CPF )W[GPPG DWV KP KP VJG VTGCV[ QH 2CTKU .QWKU +: CPF JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY *GPT[ ++ CITGGF QP VJG EGUUKQP QH #SWKVCKPG KP HKGH VQ VJG NCVVGT %QPHNKEVU DTQMG QWV CPGY WPFGT 2JKNKRRG +8 NG $GN 6JG (TGPEJ QEEWRKGF #SWKVCKPG HTQO VQ 9JGPGXGT VJG OCVVGT QH 'PINKUJ UWEEGUUKQP KP (TCPEG YCU TCKUGF #SWKVCKPG YCU CNYC[U VJG VGTTKVQT[ CV KUUWG JCXKPI DGGP VJG QTKIKPCN ECWUG HQT VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT +P VJG FWEJ[ YCU NKOKVGF VQ $QTFGCWZ CPF $C[QPPG #HVGT VJG 'PINKUJ XKEVQT[ CV 2QKVKGTU CPF VJG RGCEG QH $T¾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

6CNDQV DGHQTG KV FGHKPKVKXGN[ YQWNF TGVWTP WPFGT (TGPEJ UYC[ KP CPF TGOCKP VJGTG HQTIQQF YKVJ VJG UQNG GZEGRVKQP QH VJG [GCTU YJGP %JCTNGU QH (TCPEG C DTQVJGT QH .QWKU :+ YCU FWMG QH #SWKVCKPG

6JG *QWUG QH 2QKVQW )7+ )'1((41+

&GPKGT. # %TQUU )1&'4+&85 %1/'5 4 6YQ ETQUUGU YKVJ TKPI CDQXG CPF RGNNGV DGNQY $84&')#+'. $ & 2F# IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG %TGFKV FGNC $QWTUG 2CTKU )W[ )GQHHTQK CU EQWPV QH $QTFGCWZ

136


)7+..#7/' :

&GPKGT. # (QWT ETQUUGU %.8+.+./1 4 %TQUU $84&')#.#. $ & 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 6JKU EQKP KU NCTIGT CPF EQWTUGT KP FGUKIP VJCP PQ

&GPKGT. # (QWT ETQUUGU %.8+.+./1 4 %TQUU $84&')++.#. $ & 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JKU EQKP KU UOCNNGT CPF HKPGT KP FGUKIP VJCP PQ (QT VJG EQKPU UVTWEM D[ .QWKU 8++ QH (TCPEG JWUDCPF QH 'NGQPQTG KP #SWKVCKPG EH PQ WPFGT (TCPEG 4Q[CNG

#PINQ )CNNKE 2GTKQF *'04; ++

1DQNG. # 4': / CDQXG ETQUU DGNQY 4 %TQUU YKVJ TKPI KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU '0 4+% 85. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 44 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WO %KTE PQ 'Z $TCPF EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5RKPM

4+%*#4& + %ę74 &' .+10 +P 4KEJCTF RCKF JQOCIG HQT #SWKVCKPG VQ .QWKU 8++ QH (TCPEG +P CRRQKPVGF FWMG

&GPKGT 6[RG . # +P VYQ NKPGU 4+%# 4&85 CDQXG ETQUU QOGIC DGNQY 4 %TQUU #38+6#0+'. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ 6GZV QDXGTUG KP VYQ NKPGU

1DQNG 6[RG . # +P VYQ NKPGU 4+%# 4&85 CDQXG ETQUU QOGIC DGNQY 4 %TQUU #38+6# 0+' . $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WO %KTE PQ

137


'.'1014'

&GPKGT. # 6YQ ETQUUGU CNRJC DGNQY CPF QOGIC CDQXG &8%+5+6 4 %TQUU #38+6#0+'. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

0WOKUOCVKEC 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ +P 4KEJCTF DGECOG FWMG QH #SWKVCKPG #U JKU OQVJGT 'NGQPQTG YCU ECRVWTGF KP JG TGKIPGF CNQPG VJQWIJ YKVJQWV VJG EQPUGPV QH JKU HCVJGT *GPT[ ++ +P JKU HCVJGT HQTEGF JKO VQ EGFG #SWKVCKPG VQ JKU OQVJGT VJG NCYHWN FWEJGUU 6JKU EQKP WUGF VQ DG RNCEGF DGHQTG *GPT[ ++ CDQWV QP CEEQWPV QH C HKPF 0QYCFC[U QT CTG EQPUKF GTGF OQTG CEEWTCVG YJGP 4KEJCTF TGUWOGF QHHKEG CHVGT *GPT[ ++ JCF GZRKTGF /QUV NKMGN[ VJG O[UVGTKQWU &8%+5+6 OGCPU &8%+5=5#? +6='48/? FWEJGUU CICKP (QT VJKU PQVKQP UGG 4GEJGPDCEJ / % 6JG %CUEQP /QPG[ QH 'FYCTF +++ &WRNGUU[ EQPVGUVU DGECWUG VJKU V[RG FQGUPʼnV HKV VJG VT¾UQT FG 5CWECVU .CHCWTKG UGEQPFU VJKU KP %JCTNGU *KIQWPGV *KUVQKTG FG $QTFGCWZ ++ $QTFGWZ RGPFCPV NG JCWV OQ[GP³IG R *GTG 'NKCUʼn XKGYU CTG CFQRVGF

'&9#4& + +P *GPT[ +++ EGFGF #SWKVCKPG VQ JKU UQP VJG NCVGT 'FYCTF +

&GPKGT. # .GQRCTF N WPCFQTPGF VCKN '&88#4& (+.+ t 4 %TQUU J 4')+5 #0).+' . $ & 'NKCU E 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QPXCNNGV 2CTKU 5VTWEM FWTKPI VJG NKHG QH *GPT[ +++ CU TGIGPV QH 'PINCPF QP VJG TGXGTUG /KPV EQOOKUUKQPGF KP

&GPKGT. # .GQRCTF N WPCFQTPGF VCKN '&88#4& t (+.+ 4 %TQUU J 4')+5 #0).+'. $ & 'NKCU E 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ /KPVGF FWTKPI VJG NKHG QH *GPT[ +++

&GPKGT CW NGQRCTF $QTFGCWZ. # .GQRCTF N QXGT #). ' KP VYQ NKPGU '&8#4&85 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ ' KP VJG UV CPF ETGUEGPV KP VJG PF CPING &8: #38+6 $84&. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'NKCU RTQXKFGU #)+ QP # VJQWIJ KV UJQYU . KPUVGCF QH +

1DQNG CW NGQRCTF. # .GQRCTF N QXGT #). ' KP VYQ NKPGU '&9#4&85 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ ' KP VJG UV CPF ETGUEGPV KP VJG PF CPING &8: #3+6 $84&. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU $ KU VJG FGPKGT VQ VJG QDQNG QH VJG UCOG MKPF

138


'&9#4& ++ *CF C IQQF TGNCVKQPUJKR YKVJ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI +P JG YGPV VQ $QWNQIPG VQ HGVEJ JKU DTKFG +UCDGNNC FCWIJVGT QH 2JKNKRRG +8 NG $GN

/CKNNG $NCPEJG *KDGTPKG. # +PPGT EKTENG '& „ 4': #0).+' CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 „ 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ 04+ 4 %J³VGN CSWKVCPKSWG QXGT VJTGG RGNNGVU &05 „ *+$'40+' YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU (KTUV KPUVCPEG QH C DKDNKECN VGZV QP VJG EQKP 6JG +TKUJ VKVNG KU RGEWNCKT 6JG GZRNCPCVKQP UGGOU HCKTN[ UKORNG 6JG EQKP KU GXKFGPVN[ VJG OCKNNG DNCPEJG YJKEJ KP 'FYCTF ++ QTFGTGF VQ DG UVTWEM CV VJG 6QYGT 6JCV YCU CHVGT JG JCF HKTUV TGNKPSWKUJGF VJG FWEJ[ VQ JKU UQP CPF VJGP YJGP JKU YKHG YCU HQWPF IWKNV[ QH VTGCUQP CPF JKU UQP TGHWUGF VQ TGVWTP VQ 'PINCPF TGUWOGF IQXGTPOGPV CICKP .GICNN[ JG YCU PQ NQPIGT &WMG QH #SWKVCKPG UQ VJCV VKVNG VJCV HQTOGF VJG TGXGTUG NGIGPF QH VJG HKTUV OCKNNG DNCPEJG JCF VQ DG QOKVVGF 6JG GORV[ URCEG YCU VJGP HKNNGF YKVJ CPQVJGT QH 'FYCTFʼnU VKVNGU VJG +TKUJ QPG KTTGNGXCPV RGTJCRU DWV UWHHKEKGPV UGG 'NKCU

'&9#4& +++

9JGP 'FYCTF +++ CUUWOGF RTKOCE[ QXGT #SWKVCKPG VJG TGIKQP EQPUKUVGF QH PQ OQTG VJCP C PCTTQY EQCUVCN UVTKR 6JG 6TGCV[ QH $TGVKIP[ TGUVQTGF #SWKVCKPG VQ KVU HQTOGT UK\G CPF UGXGTCN OKPVU YGTG GUVCDNKUJGF

)TQU VQWTPQKU ¯ NC ETQKZ NQPIWG. # +PPGT EKTENG '&ʼn 4': #0).+' CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 5+6 „ 01/ „ '&0+ „ 04 „ &'+ +*8 :2+ 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU &8: „ #3+6 #0+' YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU. $ & 'NKCU XCT 2F# IT. 4 $TQCF HNCP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV KP HTQO %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG KP 2CTKU 6JKU EQKP KU RQTVTC[GF KP 'NKCUʼn DQQM /CTM + (GCVJGT 6JGUG EQKPU CTG VJG DGUV NQQMKPI QH VJG RTG 6TGCV[ #SWKVCKPG UKNXGT EQKPU HCKTN[ YGNN UVTWEM TCVJGT JGCX[ CTQWPF IT YKVJ C HKPGPGUU CDQXG 6JG QWVGT NGIGPF KU VJG NQPIGUV QH VJG UGTKGU CPF GPFU YKVJ QPG GZEGRVKQP NQV +*8 :2+ QT :+ 0QOG KU URGNNGF YKVJ QRGP / CPF TQOCP ' 6JG HNCPU CNVJQWIJ PGXGT HWNN[ TQWPF CTG NCTIG HQT #SWKVCPKCP EQKPU ECV 5RKPM R

5VGTNKPI. # %TQYPGF JGCF N QXGT NGQRCTF '&9#4& 4': #0). 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UOCNN ETQUU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING &8: #38 +6# 0+'. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP 6JG UVGTNKPI KU QPG QH VJG OQUV GPKIOCVKE EQKPU QH #SWKVCKPG 9QWNF OQUV RTQDCDN[ JCXG VQ DG FCVGF DCEM VQ

139


5VGTNKPI. # %TQYPGF JGCF N QXGT NGQRCTF '&9#4& 4': #0). 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG UOCNN ETQUU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING &8: #38 +6# 0+'. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

)TQU ¯ NC RQTVG. # +PPGT EKTENG '& „ 4': „ #0).+' CTQWPF ETQUU $0 &+%68 „ 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ 04+ „ & 4 %J³VGN CSWKVCPKSWG YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU QXGT ICVG &8: #3+6#0+' YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU. $ & 'NKCU XCT 2F# IT. 44 GURGEKCNN[ KP VJKU EQPFKVKQP UOCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG DTQCF HNCP XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV HTQO $QWTIG[ KP 2CTKU 6[RG 'ORV[ )CVGYC[ 44 #U VJKU EQKP JCF PQ OCTMU CPF VJG ECUVNG KU HWTPKUJGF YKVJ RGNNGVU + VJKPM KV KU QH CP GCTNKGT KUUWG VJCP ' UGG NQV +H + JCF MPQYP VJG EQKP YJGP + YTQVG VJG DQQM VJKU V[RG YQWNF JCXG DGGP ' CPF VJG QVJGTU ' C GVE

%CV 'NKCU R

)TQU CW N¾QRCTF EQWEJCPV. # %TQYPGF NGQRCTF N &8: Z #%+6#0+' ¿ YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GP ENQUKPI NGCXGU 4 +PPGT EKTENG '& Z 4': ¿ #0).+$ CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¿ 5+6 ¿ 01/' ¿ &0+ ¿ 04+ ¿ &'+ . $ & 'NKCU C VJKU URGEKOGP 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP PQ 'Z 2NCVV #WEVKQP PQ 'Z UCNG %0) PQ

140


)TQU CW NKQP $QTFGCWZ. # +PPGT EKTENG '&Q 8#4 &85 4': CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU $0 &+%68 ¶ 5 +6 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ 4 .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# Å¡ $74& YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GP ENQUKPI NGCXGU. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP KU YKVJQWV VJG VKVNG &WZ QH #SWKVCKPG 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV HTQO %QKPU CPF #PVKSWKVKGU KP .QPFQP 6JKU EQKP KU VJG QPG RQTVTC[GF KP 'NKCUʼn DQQM

&QWDNG CW N¾QRCTF. # .GQRCTF N WPFGT ETQYP CPF QXGT UVCT '& 4': #0).+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU /10'6# &82.':. $ & # 'NKCU D 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

&GPKGT CW NKQP .C 4QEJGNNG. # .GQRCTF N 4 DGNQY ¤ '& ¤ 4': ¤ #0).+' 4 %TQUU ¤ &05 ¤ #%+6#0+'4. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WO %KTE PQ 'NKCU 4444

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

2CXKNNQP F QT $QTFGCWZ. # 2TKPEG YKVJ UYQTF UVCPFKPI KP IQVJKE FCKU DGVYGGP HQWT HGCVJGTU CPF VYQ NGQRCTFU CV JKU HGGV '& ] 21] )05 ] 4')+ #0).+ ] 20%5 ] #3+ 4 &GEQTCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ NKU CPF NGQRCTFU KP VJG CPINGU CPF QPG ' KP VJG EGPVTG &05 ] #+861 ] < ] 2 6'%61 ] /' ] < ] ++21 ] 52#8+6 ] %14 ] /'8/ ] $. $ & # 'NKCU C (D 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 1DXGTUG KPUETKRVKQP '&9#4&85 24+/1 )'0'6+5 4')+5 #0).+' 24+0%'25 #37+6#+0'

141


)TQU #IGP. # $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF TCKUGF JCPF KP OWNVKNQDG '&9# 4&85 „ 24+/1 „ )05 „ 4')+5 # 4 24+0 %'25 #3+6 #0+' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ).+# „ +0' :%'.%+5 &'%'6 +0 64# „ 2#:. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 44 +TTGIWNCT HNCP XGT[ HKPG

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

&GOK )TQU .KOQIGU. # $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF TCKUGF HKPIGT KP OWNVKNQDG „ '& „ 21 „ )05 „ 4') „ #0).+' „ 25 „ $ 4 „ 240 %25 #3+ 6#0 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ).+# +0 :%'.%+5 &'1 „ '+0 64# „ 2#. $ & # 'NKCU C 2F# IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV UOCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ ņ 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU VJCV QH VJG ITQCV

&GOK )TQU 2QKVKGTU. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF TCKUGF HKPIGT KP OWNVKNQDG '& „ 21 „ )05 „ 4')+5 „ #0).+' „ 2 4 240 %25 #3+ 6#0 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CP ING ).#+0' :0'&' '6+06' 4# 2#:. $ & 'NKCU D 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG VGZV QWVGT EKTENG QP VJG TGXGTUG FQGUPʼnV UWKV 'NKCUʼn FGUTKRVKQP R

142


&GOK )TQU 2QKVKGTU PF GOKUUKQP. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF TCKUGF HKPIGT KP OWNVKNQDG '& 21 )05 4')+5 #0).+' 2 4 ^ 240 %25 #3+6#0 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ).+# +0 :%'.%+5 &' '6 +06'4# 2#:. $ & # 'NKCU 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $CNFYKP .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ .GIGPF 'NKCU ).# +0' :.' &' '6+06'4# 2#: ). + # +0 ': % . %+5 ' &' 1 '6 +06'4# 2#:

6JG JGCFU QH VJG $NCEM 2TKPEG FKHHGT ITCXGN[ QP VJG EQKPU

5VGTNKPI .KOQIGU. # $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF TCKUGF HKPIGT KP OWNVKNQDG '& 21 )0 4') #0) . 4 24+ %25 #38 6#' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING. $ &

'NKCU 2F# IT.

'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

*CTFK. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF WPFGT IQVJKE FCKU '& 2 1)'06 4')+#)+' 4 .QPI FQWDNG DCPFGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NGQRCTF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 240 %25 #32+ 6#0. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. )QQF UVTWEM WR CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG RKGEG

5RKPM .QPFQP

143


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

*CTFK. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ 4+%#4& 4: #).' 4 .QPI FQWDNG DCPFGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NGQRCTF KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU (4#% +' &0 5 #3 6#0'. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

*'04; +8 8 8+

*CTFK. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF '04+% 4 #0).+' 4 .QPI FQWDNG DCPFGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NGQRCTF KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU (4# %+' &05 #3+. $ & 'NKCU 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

#TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG NGQRCTF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU RCTVKCN KP XGTVGF '04+% 4 4 %TQUU &1/+085 # %+6# 0+' . $ & 'NKCU E 2F# IT. 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0WO %KTE PQ 6JKU V[RG UJQYU VJG (TGPEJG VKVNG '04+% 4': #0).+' (4#0

144


&WMG QH #SWKVCKPG %*#4.'5 FG (4#0%'

*CTFK F QT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF -#41.85 &8: #37+6#+0' Z 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NGQRCTF KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU :2% 8+0%+6 :2% 4')0#6 :2% +/2'4#6 . $ & (D 2F# IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 1P VJG TGXGTUG DGVYGGP VJG VYQ UVCTU C UOCNN UJKR 6JG UJKR KU VJG TQ[CN OKPVOCTM QH $QTFGCWZ

8+5%1706; QH .+/1)'5 6JG QTKIKPCN PCOG YCU %KXKVCU .GOQXKEWO 6JG HKTUV DKUJQR YCU 5V /CTVKCNKU TF EGP VWT[ YJQ NCVGT YQWNF DG XGPGTCVGF CU CP CRQUVNG 1P JKU ITCXG KP VJG CDDG[ QH 5V /CTVKCN YCU DWKNV &WCNKUO TQUG DGVYGGP VJG DKUJQR QP VJG QPG JCPF JG EQPVTQNNGF VJG EKV[ CPF VJG CDDQV YJQ CRCTV HTQO 5V /CTVKCN EQPVTQNNGF VJG EJ³VGCW CU YGNN 6JG XKUEQWPVU YGTG XCUUCNU QH VJG FWMGU QH #SWKVCKPG +P VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ C HKGTEG FKURWVG KIPKVGF DGVYGGP CDDQV CPF XKUEQWPV +P VJG GPF VJG EKV[ TGEGKXGF CP KPFGRGPFGPV UVCVWVG VJCV YCU TGEQIPKUGF D[ VJG MKPI CPF VJG FWMG KP +P VQ (TCPEG

#010;/175 EC

&GPKGT. # (QWT ETQUUGU )4#6+# & + 4': 4 %TQUU .+++ 8+%#5 %85. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI

145


#$$'; QH 5V /#46+#. FG .+/1)'5 #DDQV #FGOCT NGF VJG CDDG[ VQ KVU CRQIGG 6JG CDDG[ DGECOG VJG URKTKVWCN EGPVTG QH #SWKVCKPG CPF YCU HCXQWTGF D[ VJG FWMGU VJG CDDQVU QH %NWP[ CPF VJG RQRG 6JG NCVVGT XGUVGF VJG CDDQV YKVJ VJG RQYGT VQ CRRQKPV VJG DKUJQR #HVGT #FGOCT VJG CDDG[ GZRGTKGPEGF C FGENKPG CPF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG EKVK\GPU QH .KOQIGU YGTG CNNQYGF CP KPFGRGPFGPV UVCVWVG

#010;/175 VJ CPF VJ EGPVWT[ WPVKN

&GPKGT. # $GCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI 5'5 /#4%+#. 4 %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGVU CTQWPF VJG NKODU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP GCEJ CPING .'/18+%'05+5. $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU

%1706; QH #0)17.˜/' 1TKIKPCN PCOG 'EQNKUOGPUKU 'PIQNKUOGPUKU 6JG FKQEGUG #PIQWN¿OG KU C UWHHTCICP FKQEGUG QH $QTFGCWZ +VU HKTUV DKUJQR DGKPI 5V #WUQPKWU VJ EGPVWT[ VJG FKQEGUG FKFPʼnV DGEQOG MPQYP WPVKN %[DCTF GURGEKCNN[ VJTQWIJ VJG OQPCUVGT[ DGCTKPI JKU PCOG 6JG EQWPV[ UKPEG VJG GPF QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ JCF DGGP C HKGH HTQO VJG EQWPVU QH 2QKVKGTU CPF VJG FWMGU QH #SWKVCKPG 6JG EQWPVU QH #PIQWN¿OG GZRCPFGF VJGKT VGTTKVQT[ HQWPFKPI VJG KPHNW GPVKCN *QWUG 6CKNNGHGT 9KVJ VJG CDFWEVKQP QH +UCDGNNC 6CKNNGHGT DTKFG QH *WIQ FG .WUKIPCP D[ ,QJP .CEMNCPF VJG NCVVGT EQGTEGF VJG MKPI QH (TCPEG YJQ JCF TGURQPFGF VQ *WIQ FG .WUKIPCPʼnU TGSWGUV HQT CKF CICKPUV .CEMNCPF VQ ECNN CP GPF VQ VJG NCUVKPI FKURWVG 6JG RGTKQF HTQO VQ EQORTKUGF QH VJG OQUV HNQWTKUJKPI [GCTU QH VJG *QWUG 6CKNNGHGT .WUKIPCP 6JG NKPG GPFGF YKVJ *WIQ :+++ RTQORVKPI 2JKNKRRG +8 NG $GN VQ UGK\G VJG EQWPV[ #HVGT VJCV KV RCUUGF VJTQWIJ UGXGTCN JCPFU COQPI YJKEJ YGTG 'FYCTF +++ʼnU WRQP VJG 6TGCV[ QH $T¾VKIP[

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # %TQUU .1&1+%85 4 %TQUU YKVJ HQWT TKPIU CTQWPF. ')1.+55+/'. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU +OOQDKNKUCVKQP QH VJG V[RG QH -KPI .QWKU +8 VJ EGPVWT[

146


%1706; QH 2—4+)14& 6JG PCOG FGTKXGU QH VJG )CWN VTKDG 2GVTQEQTGU 6JG EQWPV[ 2¾TKIQTF YCU C HKGH HTQO VJG FWMGU QH #SWKVCKPG +V YCU C UQOGYJCV KPEQJGTGPV YJQNG OCFG WR QH VJTGG EQTGU 2¾TKIKGWZ $GTIGTCE CPF 5CTNCV 6JGTG YGTG OCP[ OQPCUVGTKGU 6JG EQWPVU QH 2¾TKIQTF YGTG FKTGEVN[ TGNCVGF VQ VJG *QWUG #PIQWN¿OG 9WNHITKO + YCU EQWPV QH #PIQWN¿OG CPF 2¾TKIQTF *G FKXKFGF VJG VYQ COQPI JKU UQPU #NFYKP + YCU EQPXG[GF #PIQWN¿OG CPF )WKNNCWOG TGEGKXGF 2¾TKIQTF /CP[ EQWPVU DQTG VJG PCOG 'NKCU CPF #TEJCODCWF 2¾TKIQTF YCU GXGPVWCNN[ EQPHKUECVGF KP

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # (KXG TKPIU ETQUU UJCRGF ')1.+55+/' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG PF CPF QPG 8 KP VJG TF CPING .1&1+%85. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU 9KVJ TGURGEV VQ VJG VGZV VJG QD CPF TGXGTUG CTG KFGPVKECN VQ VJG EQKPU QH #PIQWN¿OG 0GXGTVJGNGUU VJGTGʼnU PQ FQWDV VJCV VJGUG EQKPU JCXG VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG %QWPVU QH 2¾TKIQTF # EJCTVGT HTQO OGPVKQPU FGPKGTU RGTKIQWTFKPU CWZ EKPS QGKNU

$'4)'4#% 6JG HKTUV [GCTU QH VJG YCT KP )CUEQP[ YGTG FKHHKEWNV HQT VJG 'PINKUJ CPF VJGKT )CUEQP CNNKGU +P QPN[ $QTFGCWZ 5V 5GXGT /¾\KP $C[QPPG CPF VJGKT KOOGFKCVG PGKIJDQWTJQQF YGTG GHHGEVKXKN[ WPFGT 'PINKUJ EQPVTQN 6JKU UKVWCVKQP EJCPIGF YJGP 'FYCTF +++ʼnU EQWUKP *GPT[ 'CTN QH .CPECUVGT YJQ YCU CRRQKPVGF VJG MKPIʼn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ʼnU OQPG[ 6YQ RGTKQFU CTG VQ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF *GPT[ YKVJ VJG VKVNG 'CTN QH .CPECUVGT CPF YKVJ VJG VKVNG &WMG QH .CPECUVGT

*'04; 'CTN QH .CPECUVGT

)TQU VQWTPQKU ¯ NC ETQKZ NQPIWG. # +PPGT EKTENG *'0 %1/ .# 0%' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGI GPF $0&+%6 „ 8 Q QQ ' „ & P 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU &05 $4#)#+4% YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU. $ & 'NKCU D 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG GURGEKCNN[ HQT VJKU KUUWG GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV KP HTQO %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG KP 2CTKU 'ZVTGOGN[ 4CTG 4444 5GG CTVKENG 6JG %QKPCIG QH $GTIGTCE QH 'NKCU KP $0, R YKVJ VJG PWODGT QH VJKU EQKP YKVJ KNNWUVTCVKQP 1H VJKU V[RG MPQYP URGEKOGPU GZKUV QH YJKEJ VJTGG CTG KP RWDNKE EQNNGEVKQPU CPF VJTGG KP VJG CWEVKQP QH VJG EQNN 'NKCU 5RKPM

147


)TQU VQWTPQKU CW N¾QRCTF FGUUWU. # %J³VGN VQWTPQKU YKVJ ETQUU DGPGCVJ ETGUEGPV YKVJ NGCXG 1 8 1 NGQR CTF CDQXG &05 $'4)'4#%+ 4 +PPGT EKTENG 4%1/ .#0%#56 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 „ 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ 04+ „ &'+. $ & 'NKCU I 2F# IT. 44 5OCNN HNCP CPF YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG KP CP GZVTCQTFKPCT[ IQQF EQPFKVKQP XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 6JGTG KU CP QNF EJCTV UC[KPI WPRWDNKUJGF RTGUWOCDN[ VJKU URGEKOGP YCUPʼnV MPQYP VQ 'NKCU PGKVGT FQGU KV CRRGCT KP JKU DQQM PQT KP VJG CWEVKQP QH JKU EQNNGEVKQP 'NKCU EQOOGPVU + JCXG TGEQTFGF URGEKOGP EQORTKUKPI XCTKGVKGU 1PN[ QH VJG EQKPU KPENWFKPI VJG KP VJG 'NKCU UCNG CTG KP RTKXCVG EQNNGEVKQPU JGPEG PQV EQWPVKPI VJG URGEKOGP WPFGT FKUEWUUKQP

5'+)0+14; QH $—#40 $¾CTP RNC[GF C UKIPKHKECPV TQNG KP VJG /KFFNG #IGU GXGP VQ VJG GZVGPV QH DGEQOKPI C UQXGT GKIP RTKPEKRCNKV[ KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 1TKIKPCNN[ $¾CTP YCU C HKGH HTQO VJG FWEJ[ #SWKVCKPG JQYGXGT JCF CNYC[U DGGP QTKGPVGF VQYCTFU 5RCKP CPF VJWU KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ YCU CDCPFQPGF VQ VJG ETQYP QH #TCIQP 6JG %CVCNCP HCOKN[ /QPECFC CNNQYGF $¾CTP VJGKT QYP NGIKUNCVWTG #HVGT VJG $CVVNG CV /WTGV

$¾CTP YCU TGWPKVGF YKVJ #SWKVCKPG YJKEJ D[ VJGP YCU 'PINKUJ TQ[CN RQUUGUUKQP +P $¾CTP JCF EQCNGUEGF YKVJ VJG EQWPV[ (QKZ +PUVTWOGPVCNKUKPI VJG (TGPEJ 'PINKUJ FKHHGTGPEGU )CUVQP (¾DWU OCPCIGF VQ HQWPF CP CWVQPQOQWU UVCVG HTQO YJKEJ DCUG VJG XKUEQWPV QH $¾CTP GXGPVWCNN[ YQWNF NC[ JCPFU QP VJG ETQYP QH 0CXCTTC

+//1$+.+<'& YKVJ PCOG QH %'067..' VJ VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU %'068..1 %1/ 4 2 # : KP VJG HKGNF 1014 (14%#5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

1DQNG. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU %'068..1 %1/ʼn 4 2 # : KP VJG HKGNF 1014 (14%#5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

148


%1706; QH 41755+..10 6JG EQWPV[ 4QWUUKNNQP YCU HQWPFGF KP VJG HTCPEQPKCP CIG (KTUV EQWPV YCU )CW\JGNO KP YJQ HTQO YCU EQWPV QH #ORWTKCU KP 5RCKP CU YGNN 5VCTVKPI 4QWUUKNNQP CPF #ORWTKCU YGTG IQXGTPGF D[ C EQOKVCN HCOKN[ HTQO %CTECUUQPPG 'XGP VJG DKUJQRʼn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

VQIGVJGT YKVJ %GTFCPC YCU EQPXG[GF VQ (TCPEG VQ UGTXG CU EQNNCVGTCN HQT JKIJ FGDVU KP +P 4QWUUKNNQP YCU QEEWRKGF D[ (TCPEG DGKPI CPPGZGF FGHKPKVKXGN[ VQ (TCPEG KP

)#75(4'& +++

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ CTCDGUSWG KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU )#8(4'&85 4 %TQUU JGCFGF UVCHH YKVJ % 1 / 6 CTQWPF 415+.+1085. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

1DQNG. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI CPF 8 KP VJG PF CPF QPG TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VJG TF CPINGU )#8(4'&85 4 %TQUU JGCFGF UVCHH YKVJ % 1 0 6 CTQWPF 415+.+1085. $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNCPFKC -CORGTXGGP

#.(1051 +8

)TQU. # %TQYPGF DWUV N #.(1051 & + )4# 4' : #4#)1 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF TKPI KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU %1/5 $#4- 010# 41%+.. $ & 2F# IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG 5EJYGK\ $CPMX $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5QDGT %CDQV EQNNGEVKQP

149


%#4%#55100' %CTECUUQPPG KU NKMGN[ VQ JCXG DGGP HQWPFGF KP VJG FC[U QH GORGTQT #WIWUVWU %QNQPKC ,WNKC %CTECUQ %CTECUUQPPG YCU YCNNGF CTQWPF YJKEJ KP FKFPʼnV UVQR VJG 8KUKIQVJU HTQO QEEWR[KPI KV #HVGT VJG[ YGTG GZRGNNGF HTQO 6QWNQWUG VJG EKV[ʼnU KORQTVCPEG KPETGCUGF KV DGEQOKPI CP CFXCPEGF 8KUKIQVJ HQQVJQNF KP VJG GPGO[ VGTTKVQT[ QH VJG (TCPEQPKCPU 6JG FKQEGUG YCU HQWPFGF KP +P %CTECUUQPPG YCU VCMGP D[ VJG #TCDU CPF KP KV YCU OGTIGF KPVQ VJG (TCPEQPKCP TGCNO 6JG EQWPV[ CNTGCF[ GZKUVGF KP %CTQNKPIKCP VKOGU 5KPEG UWEEGUUKQP PQ NQPIGT FGRGPFGF QP VJG MKPI 6JG PF EQOKVCN JQWUG QH %CTECUUQPPG YCU HQWPFGF D[ #TPCNF CRRTQZ CPF VJG EQOKVCN HCOKN[ QH (QKZ VTCEGU DCEM VQ JKO CU YGNN 6JKU JQWUG UJCTGF KVU NKPGCIG YKVJ VJG EQWPVU QH $CTEGNQPC 7TIGN %GTFCIPG CPF $GUCNÏ DGKPI WPFGTNKPGF D[ VJG OCTTKCIG QH 'TOGUUKPFKU C FCWIJVGT QH 4QIGTU VJG 'NFGT QH %CTECUUQPPG VQ VJG EQWPV 4CKOÉP QH $CTEGNQPC CRRTQZ 6JWU VJG EQWPVU QH $CTEGNQPC D[ KPJGTKVCPEG VQQM RQUUGUUKQP QH %CTECUUQPPG DWV EGFGF KV VQ VJG XKUEQWPV QH #NDK 0ÄOGU 8KUEQWPV $GTPJCTF 6TGPECXGN CNUQ XKUEQWPV QH $¾\KGTU OCPCIGF VQ TGUVTKEV VJG KPHNWGPEG QH VJG EQWPVU QH $CTEGNQPC KP VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ )TCFWCNN[ EKV[ IQXGTPCPEG EQOGU KPVQ DGKPI CPF KP VJGTG KU OGPVKQP QH RTWF ʼnJQOOGU +P VJG #NDKIGPUKCP %TWUCFG VJG ETWUCFGTU FGXCUVCVGF VJG EKV[ KP CPF VQQM 4CKOQP 4QIGT 6TGPECXGN KPVQ ECRVKXKV[ #HVGT VJG ETWUCFG %CTECUUQPPG FGXGNQRGF KPVQ CP KORQTVCPV EGPVTG KP VJG UQWVJ QH (TCPEG CPF C HQQVJQNF HQT TGICN CWVJQTKV[ VJG EKV[ YCNNU YGTG FQWDNGF D[ .QWKU VJG 5CKPV UJWVVKPI QWV OQUV QH VJG RQRWNCVKQP KP VJG RTQEGUU #P CVVGORV VQ TGKPUVCVG 6TGPECXGN CWVJQTKV[ HCKNGF

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # %TQUU %#4%#510# 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU Q 1 DNWPFGTGF OQPQITCO QH 1&1 %+28+ 6#6+5. $ & 2F# IT. 2NGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU

1DQNG. # %TQUU %#4%#510 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU Q 1 DNWPFGTGF OQPQITCO QH 1&1 %+28+ 6#6+5. $ & 2F# IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $TGF 2CTKU

150


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½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

2GCEG QH /GCWZ 2CTKU #HVGT 4CKOQPF 8++ʼnU FGCVJ KP VJG TGIGPVGUU VJG SWGGP OQVJGT QH (TCPEG $NCPEC FG %CUVKNNG CUUWOGF QHHKEG +P 1EVQDGT KP VJG 6TGCV[ QH /GCWZ 6QWNQWUG KV KU TGNKPSWKUJGF FGHKPKVKXGN[ VQ VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP (QT VJG OKPV QH EQWPV 2QPU VQIGVJGT YKVJ MKPI *GPT[ + UGG WPFGT (TCPEG 4Q[CNG PQ

)7+..#7/' +8

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG PF CPING 88+'./1 %1/' 4 2#: KP VJG HKGNF 61.15# %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ /&

$'464#0&

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG VJ CPING $'464#0 %1/ 4 %TQUU JGCFGF UVCHH DGVYGGP VYQ TKPIU 61.15# %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 4 0KEG VQPG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

.GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU

151


#.2*105' ,174&#+0

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQUKGT KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU #0 (15 %1/'5 4 2 # : KP VJG HKGNF 61.15# %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\ICNGTKG /Ã’PEJGP (TQO NKUV PQ

4#;/10& 8 8+ 8++

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG PF CPING 4#/10 %1/'5 4 2 # : KP VJG HKGNF 61.15# %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

1DQNG. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP VJG PF CPING 4#/10 %1/'5 4 2 # : KP VJG HKGNF 61.15# %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU

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¾\KGTU CPF %CTECUUQPPG CPF URGPV JKU TG OCKPKPI NKHG KP C FWPIGQP *KU UQP 4C[OQPF ++ CVVGORVGF TGEQPSWGTKPI VJG VGTTKVQTKGU DWV JG VQQ YCU FGHGCVGF CPF JCF VQ EQPUGSWGPVN[ HQTHGKV CNN VJG XKUEQWPVKGU #NDK KPENWFGF VQ VJG MKPI QH (TCPEG VJ QH #RTKN

4#;/10& $'40#4&

&GPKGT CHVGT . # %TQUU 4#++8+8*& 4 8 ++ % 1 % KP EKTENG #.$+'%+. $ & 2F# IT. /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC CNOQUV WPEKTEWNCVGF URGEKOGP 4CWEJ 9KGP PQ

152


57%% &' 4#;/10& $'40#4&

&GPKGT. # %TQUU + #98+8/& 4 8 WPFGT ETQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ + #+ +19≡%+. $ & 2F# IT. /KPQT VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

1DQNG. # %TQUU + #98+8/& 4 8 WPFGT ETQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ + #+ +19≡. $ & 2F# IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

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ʼn 9CT 0GXGTVJGNGUU %CJQTU JCU CNYC[U DGGP CP KORQTVCPV EGPVTG QH VTCFG 'XKFGPEG JCU NGF VQ VJG CUUWORVKQP VJCV UKPEG VJG EKV[ JCU DGGP IQXGTPGF D[ YGCNVJ[ EKVK\GPU

#010;/175 VJ VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # 6JTGG ETQUUGU QPG GPFKPI KP C ETQUKGT CPF # KP VJG HKGNF %+8+6#5 4 %TQUU %# 684%85. $ & 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU 2F# OGPVKQPU %#684%+5 &WRNGUU[ CU YGNN ŋ&G V[RG GUV EQPVGORQTCKP FG Nʼn¾X¿SWG )WKNNCWOG FG %CTFCKNNCEŌ &WRNGUU[ R

#010;/175 GPF VJ DGIKP VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU '2+5%1285 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPING %#684%'05+5. $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

1DQNG. # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU '2+5%1285 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPING %#684%'05+5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

153


%+6;

%+6; QH %#*145

&GPKGT. # 6 CPF # DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUU %+8+6#5 4 %TQUU %#684%+5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

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

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 8)1 %1/'5 4 &#5 KP VJG HKGNF 41&'5 %+8+. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU

5'+)0+14; QH #0&75' CPF 5#78'

$'40#4& N #+0'

&GPKGT. # $ DGVYGGP HQWT RGNNGVU #0&85+'05+5 4 %TQUU OQNKPG YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPING 5#.8+'05+5. $ & 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM <Ã’TKEJ

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # $ KP VJG HKGNF &' #0&85+# 4 %TQKZ P¿N¾G &' 5# .8 '. $ & 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

154


%1706; QH /'.)7'+. /GNIWGKN KU VQFC[ʼnU /CPIWKQ MO VQ VJG GCUV QH /QPVRGNNKGT (KTUV OGPVKQPGF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ KV DGECOG VJG FQOKEKNG QH VJG EQWPVU QH 5WDUVCPVKQP VJG HQTOGT EQWPVU QH /CIWG NQPG 6JGUG EQWPVU PCOGF VJGOUGNXGU CHVGT /GNIWGKN CPF KPUVCNNGF C OKPV +P 2GVGT QH /GNIWGKN CEEGRVGF VJG RQRG CU UWRRTGOG CWVJQTKV[ CPF YCKXGF JKU TKIJV VQ CRRQKPV VJG DKUJQR QH /CIWGNQPG +P VJG EQWPV[ YCU VTCPUHGTTGF D[ OCTTKCIG VQ VJG EQWPV QH 6QWNQWUG 4C[OQPF 8+ #V VJG VKOG QH 4C[OQPFU GZEQOOWPKECVKQP VJG EQWPV[ YCU EQPHKUECVGF CPF EGFGF VQ VJG DKUJQR QH /CIWGNQPG KP /KPVKPI UVCTVGF KP OQFGNNGF CHVGT 0CTDQPPG UKPEG VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG OGNIQTKG JCNH C VQWNQWUCKP YCU VJG QHHKEKCN EWTTGPE[ KP GPVKTG 5QWVJ (TCPEG $GECWUG QH EQORGVKVKQP D[ QVJGT EQKPU HTQO VJG TGIKQP /QPVRGNNKGT VJG EQKP XCPKUJGF HTQO EKTEWNCVKQP

&+1%'5' QH /#)7'.100'

&GPKGT. # 2KNG DGVYGGP VYQ KTQP JQQHU YKVJ RGNNGV N +#+++8++5 4#/80&5 4 (QWT TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG ++#+D1++# 0#4$10# . $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU

-+0)&1/ $74)70&+# #4'.#6' $[ VJG 6TGCV[ QH 8GTFWP VJG GPVKTG GUVCVG ECOG VQ .QVJCKT + *KU UQP %JCTNGU KPJGTKVGF VJG 2TQXGPEG CPF 8KGPPG +P %JCTNGU VJG $CNF UGK\GF VJG VGTTKVQT[ CPF EQPXG[GF 8KGPPG VQ YJKEJ UQXGTGKIPV[ VJG 2TQXGPEG DGNQPIGF VQ JKU EQPHKFCPV $QUQ #HVGT .QWKU VJG 5VCOOGTGT GZRKTGF CP CUUGODN[ QH VJG PQDNGOGP HTQO VJG MKPIFQO $WTIWPF[ KP /CPVCKNNG

YCU ECNNGF CPF $QUQ YCU DGUVQYGF WRQP VJG TGICN VKVNG +P CPQVJGT CUUGODN[ QH PQDNGOGP CPF DKUJQRU EJQUG JKU UQP .QWKU VJG $NKPF VQ DG OCTITCXG QH 8KGPPG CPF FWMG QH VJG 2TQXGPEG $NKPFGF D[ $GTGPICT FG (TKCWN KP VJG YCT HQT +VCN[ .QWKU EGFGF JKU OCTITCXKCVG QH 8KGPPG CPF JKU FWEJ[ QH VJG 2TQXGPEG VQ JKU WPENG *WIQ QH #TNGU *G KP EGFGF JKU TKIJV VQ VJG YGUV QH VJG #NRU VQ 4WFQNRJ ++ MKPI QH 7RRGT $WTIWPF[ 9JGP WRQP 4WFQNRJ +++ʼnU FGOKUG VJG )GTOCP 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +++ CPPGZGF VJG MKPIFQO $WTIWPF[ VQ VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG 5QNQVJWTP VJG 2TQXGPEG TGOCKPGF CP WPFKXKFGF RTKPEKRCNKV[

.17+5 N #8'7).'

&GPKGT 8KGPPG. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG YGFIG KP GCEJ CPING +8&188+%85 4 8 + KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG. /'% /) IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG $QPXCNNGV 2CTKU 0COG UVCTVKPI YKVJ CP + KU 2TQW /) TGEQTFU QPN[ URGEKOGP

155


/#4)4#8+#6' QH 2418'0%' $GHQTG VJG EQOOQP GTC MPQYP CU 2TQXKPEKC )CNNKC 0CTDQPGPUKU CPF VJG QNFGUV 4QOCP RTQX KPEG KP )CWN 5WEEKPEVN[ ECNNGF 2TQXKPEKC TGHGTTKPI VQ VJG UQWVJGCUVGTP RCTV (TQO VJG PF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ UGXGTCN EQOKVCN JQWUGU TGKIPGF OCKPN[ DGECWUG UGXGTCN JGKTGUUGU WRQP VJGKT KPJGTKVCPEG YGFFGF KPVQ C EQOKVCN NKPG 6JWU YG UGG COQPI QVJGTU VJG JQWUGU QH 6QWNQWUG 7TIGN CPF )¾QHFCP EC #HVGT VJG CUUCUUKPCVKQP QH )KNDGTV QH )¾XCPFCP JKU FCWIJVGT &QWEG OCTTKGF 4CKOQPF $¾ TCPIGT +++ EQWPV QH $CTEGNQPC KP 6JG GUVCVG JCXKPI CNYC[U DGGP WPKVGF YCU PQY

FKXKFGF 4CKOQPF $¾TCPIGT TGEGKXGF VJG EQWPV[ 2TQXGPEG GPEKTENGF D[ VJG 4JÊPG VJG &WTCPEG VJG #NRU CPF VJG /GFKVGTTCPGCP CPF #NRJQPU ,QWTFCKP VJG OCTITCXKCVG 2TQXGPEG

VGTTKVQTKGU VQ VJG PQTVJ QH VJG &WTCPEG CPF VJG TKIJV DCPM QH VJG 4JÊPG 6JGTG YGTG UGXGTCN TGDGNNKQPU OQUV FKUVKPEVN[ VJCV D[ VJG .QTFU QH $CWZ CICKPUV VJG EQWPVU QH $CTEGNQPC

4#+/10& 8+ QT 8++

&GPKGT. # 5VCT YKVJ ETGUEGPV &8: /#4%J 28 4 %TQUU YKVJ DQTFGT QH RGNNGVU 4 ` %1 5 ` 2#.#%+. $ & 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU $ PQ VQVCNN[ VJG UCOG 2F# 2#.#66

%1706; QH VJG 2418'0%' #NRJQPUG ++ + MKPI QH #TCIQP CPF EQWPV QH $CTEGNQPC FGHKPKVKXGN[ EGPVTGF VJG RQYGT QH VJG %CVCNCP F[PCUV[ KP VJG 2TQXGPEG #KZ GP 2TQXGPEG DGECOG VJG TQ[CN TGUKFGPEG 6JG GUVCVG YCU GZRCPFGF D[ VJG *CWVG 2TQXGPEG CPF VJG OCTTKCIG QH JKU FCWIJVGT WPKVGF VJG EQWPV[ (QTECNSWKGT YKVJ VJCV QH VJG 2TQXGPEG 7PFGT 5CPEJQ QH #TCIQP CPF VJG OKPQT 4CKOQPF $¾TCPIGT +8 VJG RQUKVKQP QH VJG EQWPVU YGCMGPGF DWV 4C[OQPF $¾TCPIGT TGUVQTGF OCVVGTU KP # PGY GTC FCYPGF YJGP VJG NCUV FCWIJVGT QH 4CKOQPF $¾TCPIGT 8 $¾CVTKZ YGFFGF %JCTNGU QH #PLQW VJG DTQVJGT QH .QWKU +: VJG 5CKPV 6JG *QWUG #PLQW ECOG KPVQ RQYGT %JCTNGU QH #PLQW KPUVCNNGF C UQNKF IQXGTPOGPV 4QDGTV CNNQYGF VJG 2TQXGPEG UQOG OQTG HTGGFQO CPF EQPEGTPGF JKOUGNH EJKGHN[ YKVJ +VCN[ 6JKU KPFWEGF ITGCV YGCNVJ GU RGEKCNN[ YJGP KP VJG RQRG ECOG VQ #XKIPQP #HVGT 4QDGTVʼn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¾ YGTG CNN ENQUGN[ TGNCVGF VQ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI 4GP¾ YCU C MPQYP DGPGHCEVQT CPF JG OCKPVCKPGF C TQ[CN JQWUGJQNF KP #KZ 6CTCUEQP CPF )CTFCPPG #V JKU FGCVJ KP 4GP¾ NGHV VJG 2TQXGPEG D[ YKNN VQ JKU EQWUKP %JCTNGU QH /CKPG YJQ CE EGRVGF VJKU KPJGTKVCPEG KP *G KP VWTP DGSWGCVJGF VJG 2TQXGPEG VQ MKPI .QWKU :+ VJ &GEGODGT UJQTVN[ DGHQTG JG GZRKTGF

#.2*105' + 4#+/10&

&GPKGT. # /KVTG 4': #4#)10' 4 .QPI ETQUU 241 8+ 0% +#. $ 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG /ÒP\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ #NRJQPUG + QH #TCIQP 4C[OQPF QH $QNNGPG CTEJDKUJQR QH #TNGU

156


#.2*105' ++ QH #4#)10

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF JGCF N Q 4': #4# Q )10' Q 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG TKPIU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD 21 8+ 0% +#. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU 5GG CNUQ PQ YKVJ FKHHGTGPV FTCYKPI

&GPCT. # %TQYPGF JGCF N 4': #4# )10' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD 21 8+ 0% +#. $ 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5GG CNUQ PQ UCOG V[RG 1VJGT FTCYKPI QVJGT RQTVTCKV CPF NCTIGT HNCP

1DQNG. # %TQYPGF JGCF N 4': Q #4# Q )10' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD 21 8+ 0% +#. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

%*#4.'5 + QH #0,17

&GPKGT. # %TQUU - %1 2 (+ 4' ( 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU YKVJ NKU 28+0%+#.+5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&GPKGT /CTUGKNNG TF KUUWG. # *GCF N %1/'5 28+0%+' 4 %CUVNG %+8+6#5 /#55+'. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG 'TC QH %JCTNGU YKVJQWV VKVNG QH 5KEKN[ CPF YKVJQWV VKVNG QH ,GTWUCNGO

&GPKGT. # *GCF N - %1/'5 28+0%++ 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD /#5 5+. +'0 5+5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 'TC QH %JCTNGU YKVJQWV VKVNG QH 5KEKN[ CPF YKVJQWV VKVNG QH ,GTWUCNGO

157


1DQNG /CTUGKNNG TF KUUWG. # *GCF N - %1/'5 28+0%+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VYQ TKPIU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD /#5 5+. .'0 5+5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ 'TC QH %JCTNGU YKVJQWV VKVNG QH 5KEKN[ CPF YKVJQWV VKVNG QH ,GTWUCNGO

)TQU VQWTPQKU #XKIPQP VJ GOKUUKQP. # +PPGT EKTENG -#41.85 5%. 4': CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 ¶ 2 4 %J³VGN VQWTPQKU YKVJ NKU %1/'5 28+0%+' YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG 5%. CHVGT VJG EQPSWGT QH 5KEKN[ UGG ' 5 R %JCTNGU CU MKPI QH 5KEKN[

41$'46 QH #0,17

%CTNKP. # -KPI HCEKPI YKVJ NKU RQKPVGF UEGRVTG CPF QTD QP VJTQPG 41$'46 &+ )4# +'4. '6 5+%+. 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING %1/'5 28+0%+' '6(14%#. 3'4++. $ 2F# IT. 0KEG VQPG XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ

5QN %QWTQPPCV. # )TGCV ETQYP FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 4 +J 4 „ '6 „ 5+%+. „ 4': 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING %1/ '5ï2 8+0 %+'. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

158


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

#010;/175

1DQNG. # %TQUKGT #4%*+' '2+ 4 .CVKP ETQUU 1 #4'.#6'0 1. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG #TIGPQT 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

6JG ' QH #TEJKG JCU C PQVCDNG HQTO C URKTCN YKVJ C RGNNGV KP KV DQVJ VJG 1 U CV VJG DGIKPPKPI CPF GPF QH VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG FKURNC[ C RGNNGV

%1706; QH 5#+06 )+..'5 6JG CDDG[ KU NKMGN[ VQ JCXG DGGP HQWPFGF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ WPFGT RCVTQPCIG QH 5V 2GVGT CPF 2CWN YKVJ VJG ITCXG QH 5V )KNGU #TQWPF VJG CDDG[ C EKV[ CTQUG 6JG CPPWCN VTCFG HCKT YCU QPG QH KPVGTPCVKQPCN KORQTVCPEG 4C[OQPF +8 HTQO VJG EQOKVCN *QWUG QH 6QWNQWUG YCU EQWPV QH 5V )KNGU CPF QH 6QWNQWUG CPF 4QWGTSWG *GPEG 5V )KNGU TGOCKPGF YKVJKP VJG EQWPV[ 6QWNQWUG (TQO VJG VJ EGP VWT[ VJG KPHNWGPEG QH VJKU EQWPV[ CDCVGF

#.2*105' ,174&#+0

&GPKGT. # %TQUU #0(15 %1/'5 4 .COD YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UVCHH DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU 1014 5%+ ')+&+. $ 2F# IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

$QPXCNNGV 2CTKU

%1//70' Fʼn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

%1//70'

&GPKGT. # )TGCV MG[ #8+0+1 4 .QPI ETQUU 0 % 0 5 + 5. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG -WPUV WPF /Ã’P\GP .WICPQ

6JG KPUETKRVKQPU QP QD CPF TGXGTUG VQIGVJGT HQTO #8+10'05+5 #XKIPQP

159


-+0)&1/ $74)70&+# %+5+74#0# 6JG HKTUV MKPI QH $WTIWPF[ 4WFQNRJ + KP HCEV OGTGN[ TWNGF %KUKWTCPC 0QV WPVKN JKU UQP 4W FQNRJ ++ YJQ YCU MKPI QH +VCN[ HTQO VQ CU YGNN YQWNF UQXGTGKIPV[ QXGT VJG GPVKTG VGTTKVQT[ DG CEEQORNKUJGF *KU ITCPFUQP 4WFQNRJ +++ FKGF EJKNFNGUU *KU UKUVGT )GTDGTIC YCU OCTTKGF VQ VJG FWMG QH 5YCDKC CPF VJGKT FCWIJVGT )KUGNC YCU VJG URQWUG QH 'ORGTQT %QPTCF ++ QH )GTOCP[ *G KPJGTKVGF $WTIWPF[ *KU UQP *GPT[ +++ VQQ TWNGF $WTIWPF[ 6JGTG YCU OKPVKPI UKPEG 4WFQNRJ +++ %QPTCF ++ CPF *GPT[ +++ JCXG UVTWEM EQKP CU YGNN CV VJG OKPV .[QP

41&1.2*' +++

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 41&8.(85 4 6GORNG YKVJ ETQUU CPF QPG RGNNGV YKVJKP .8%8&8085. $ 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

1DQNG. # %TQUU 41&8.(85 4 6GORNG .8%8&8085. $ 2F# IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # %TQUU 41&8.(85 4 5 KP VJG HKGNF .8%8&8085. $ 2F# IT. (NCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

-104#& +++

&GPKGT. # %TQUU %104#&85 4 %TQUU QP VTKCPING .8)&8085. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

*'04+ NG 01+4

&GPKGT. # %TQUU *'+04+%85 4 5 KP VJG HKGNF .8)&8 08 5. $ 2F# IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

160


&GPKGT. # 4 KP VJG HKGNF *'+04+%85 4 %TQUU .8%8&8085. $ 2F# IT. 5RNGPFKF RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ

&GPKGT. # 4 KP VJG HKGNF *'+0+4+%85 4 %TQUU .8%8&8085. $ 2F# IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ

&GPKGT. # 4 KP VJG HKGNF *'+0+4+%85 4 %TQUU .8%8&80+85. $ 2F# IT. /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ

&7%*; QH $74)70&; 5KPEG $WTIWPF[ YCUPʼnV RNGCUGF VQ DG TWNGF D[ C )GTOCP GORGTQT KV CRRQKPVGF C FWMG 4QDGTV + HQWPFKPI VJG NKPG QH VJG 4WFQNRJKCPU 4QDGTV + YCU C UQP QH 4QDGTV ++ MKPI QH (TCPEG #N VGTPCVKPIN[ FWMGU D[ VJG PCOGU QH 1FQ CPF *WIJ TGKIPGF *WIJ +++ KPJGTKVGF VJG &CWRJKP¾ CPF 1FQ +8 KPJGTKVGF #TVQKU CPF (TCPEG %QOV¾ 'XGPVWCNN[ VJG *QWUG QH VJG 4WFQNRJKCPU XCPKUJGF YKVJ 2JKNKRRG +ʼnU FGOKUG KP CPF $WTIWPF[ YCU CDCPFQPGF VQ (TCPEG 6JG $WTIWPFKCP FWMGU YGTG JGCXKN[ KPVGTVYKPGF YKVJ QVJGT JQWUGU CPF UQ ,QJP DTQVJGT QH 4QDGTV ++ ECOG D[ $QWTDQP CPF 1FQ CPQVJGT QH 4QDGTV ++ʼnU UQPU TGEGKXGF 0GXGTU +OOGFKCVGN[ CHVGT VJKU KP VJG (TGPEJ MKPI ,QJP VJG )QQF DGUVQYGF $WTIWPF[ WRQP JKU HQWTVJ UQP 2JKNKRRG VJG $QNF YJQ YCU ITCPFUQP VQ 4QDGTV ++ QH $WTIWPF[ DTKPIKPI VJG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU VQ RQYGT KP $WTIWPF[ CU YGNN 9JGP %JCTNGU VJG 4CUJ FKGF KP CPF NGHV DWV C UKPING FCWIJVGT /CTKC VJG (TGPEJ MKPI UGK\GF VJG QRRQTVWPKV[ CPF CPPGZGF $WTIWPF[ VQ (TCPEG QPEG CPF HQT CNN 4WFQNHKPIGTU 1&1 +++

&GPKGT. # #PKNNG YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV GCEJ GPF 1&1 &8: $84) &+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG CTTQY KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU &+8+10'05+5. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM CPF VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

.GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU

161


41$'46 ++

&GPKGT. # 5JKGNF DGCTKPI VJG CTOU QH $WTIWPF[ YKVJ 8 CDQXG 4 &8: $74) &+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG PF CPING &+8+10'05+5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

*7)* 8

&GPKGT. # #PKNNG FKXKFGF D[ &8: YKVJKP VYQ NKPGU 8)1 $84)80&+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU &+8+10'05+5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

6JG *QWUG QH 8CNQKU ,'#0 5#05 2'74

$NCPE F CTIGPV. # 5JKGNF DGCTKPI VJG CTOU QH $WTIWPF[ +1*#0'5 X &8: X $84)80&+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ $'0'&+%68. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU 2F# UVCVGU C FKHHGTGPV FKUVTKDWVKQP QH VJG SWCTVGTU QP VJG TGXGTUG

2*+.+22' .' $10

$NCPE F CTIGPV. # 6YQ UJKGNFU 2*+.+285 CDQXG &8: ¶ '6 ¶ %1/'5 ¶ $84)80&+' 4 %TQUU DGVYGGP NKU CPF NKQP QXGT 2*+.+285 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68/. $ 2F# IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG .GQRCTF F 1T 2CTKU 1P VJG TGXGTUG C RGNNGV KU WPFGT VJG 0 QH 01/' 6JKU EQWNF KPFKECVG 5V .CWTGPV +V KU OQFGNNGF URGEKHKECNN[ CHVGT VJG )TCPF DNCPE CWZ 'EWU QH *GPTK 8+ EH PQ

162


$NCPE F CTIGPV. # 5JKGNF DGCTKPI VJG CTOU QH $WTIWPF[ ¤ 2*+.+2 ¤ &8: ¤ $84)80&+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKQP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ $'0'&+%68. $ 2F# IT. 2CVKPC XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

%*#4.'5 NG 6'/'4#+4'

$NCPE F CTIGPV. # 5JKGNF DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU WPFGT HKTG UVGGN -#41.85 ¤ &8: ¤ '6 ¤ %1/'5 ¤ BVRG', R: Cross with two lis and two fire-steels + SIT ¤ 01/'0 ¤ &0+ ¤ $'0'&+%68/. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

$NCPE F CTIGPV. # 5JKGNF -#41.85 ¤ &8: ¤ '6 ¤ %1/'5 ¤ $74 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 8GT[ HKPG a 01/' a &0+ a $'0'&+%68¤ $ 2F# IT. 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

163


%1706; QH *#76' $174)1)0' 1VVQP )WKNNCWOG TGEGKXGF VJG EQWPV[ *CWVG $QWTIQIPG QH MKPI 4QFQNRJG +++ QH $WTIWPF[ CV VJG GPF QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 6JKU YCU C EQPINQOGTCVG QH HKXG KPUKIPKHKECPV EQWP VKGU 'NUICW 8CTGUICW 5EQFKPIWG #OQWU CPF 2QTV %1706; QH 5%1&+0)7' 6JG UGKIPGWTKG 5CNKPU YCU CESWKTGF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ D[ EQWPV #WDT[ FG /³EQP *KU DTQVJGT *WODGTV + NCKF VJG HQWPFCVKQPU QH C F[PCUV[ QH YJKEJ VJG NCUV OGODGT /CTIWGTKVG EQPXG[GF VJG UGKIPGWTKG VQ FWMG *WIJ QH $WTIWPF[ 5CNKPU QYGU KVU RTQURGTKV[ VQ VYQ UCNVOKPGU $QWTI NG %QOVG CPF )TCPF 5CWPGTKG 6JG NCVVGT YCU VJG TKEJGUV UQWTEG QH KPEQOG QH VJG FWMGU QH $WTIWPF[

#010;/175

&GPKGT 5CNKPU. # %1/+65 OQPQITCO u%86+p%1+ 8 4 %TQUU u#.+0+5 $84. $ 2F# IT. 4 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $QPXCNNGV 2CTKU 6JKU EQKP UVGOU HTQO VJG FC[U QH 1VVQP )WKNNCWOG CPF RTGUWOCDN[ YCU KP VJG .QPU NG 5CWNPKGT HKPF QH

#4%*&+1%'5' QH $'5#0•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

*7)* +++

&GPKGT. # $NGUUKPI JCPF 5 56+2 *#085 4 %TQUU YKVJ * 8 ) 1 KP VJG CPINGU 8'5106+7/. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 1DXGTUG 5NCUJ VJTQWIJ VJG HKTUV 5 5#0%685

164


#4%*&+1%'5' QH 8+'00' +PKVKCNN[ OGPVKQPGF D[ )TGIQT[ QH 6QWTU WPFGT VJG PCOG 8KGPPC 6JGTG KU OGPVKQP QH C FKQEGUG CV VJG GPF QH VJG TF EGPVWT[ 9WNHKGT YCU VJG HKTUV CTEJDKUJQR #WVTCP

YCU VJG EJCKT CV VJG CUUGODN[ QH /CPVCKNNG D[ YJKEJ $QUQ QH 8KGPPG YCU CRRQKPVGF MKPI QH $WTIWPF[ 6JG EKV[ TQUG VQ 8KNNG NKDTG KP CU FKF .[QP YKVJQWV CFXCPEKPI VQ EQOOWPCN UVCVWU +P VJG VJ VJ EGPVWT[ 8KGPPG JKUVQT[ YCU FQOKPCVGF D[ VJG HGWF DGVYGGP VJG CTEJDKUJQRU CPF VJG FCWRJKPU HTQO 5GG WPFGT &CWRJKPU FG 8KGPPQKU

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # *GCF N Ő 5 /#84+%+85 4 %TQUU 84$5 8+'00#. $ 2F# IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

9KPVGT &ÒUUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # *GCF N Ő 5 Ő / Ő 8+'00# 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING /#:+/# Ő )#... $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

&GNOQPVG $TWUUGN

1DQNG. # *GCF N Ő 01$+.+5 Ő 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING Ő 8+'00# Ő. $ 2F# 2NCVV 2CTKU IT. 8GT[ HKPG

%1706; QH .;10 %KV[ MPQYP HTQO CPVKSWKV[ .WIFWPWO +P 6TGCV[ QH 8GTFWP .[QP YCU DTQWIJV WPFGT VJG TGCNO QH .QVJCKT + 1RRQUKPI VJG DKUJQRU YCU VJG RQVGPV HCOKN[ QH VJG .QTFU QH (QTG\ #TVGXGNFG +P .[QP UWHHGTGF UGXGTGN[ HTQO VJG RNCIWG 6JG FGEKOCVGF RQRWNCVKQP TGDGNNGF OGGVKPI YKVJ VJG HKGTEG TGVTKDWVKQP D[ MKPI %JCTNGU 8++ (TQO QP OCVVGTU KORTQXGF QYKPI VQ VJG OGT EJCPV ,CESWGU %QGWT KP RCTVKEWNCT +P VJG VKOG VQ HQNNQY .[QP FGXGNQRGF CPPWCN HCKTU YJKEJ KPFWEGF TKEJ RTQEGGFU

)7+..#7/' + QT ++

&GPKGT. # %1/'5 KP VJTGG NKPG 8 ¶ 8+.'. /85 4 %TQUU .8)&80+%+8+5. $ 2F# IT. 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

6WTSWCV /QPVRGNNKGT

165


#4%*&+1%'5' QH .;10 %JTKUVKCPKUGF GCTN[ QP VJG HKTUV EJTKUVKCP EJCRVGT QH KVU MKPF KP )CWN CVVCEJGF VQ KV CTG VJG PCOGU QH VJG DKUJQRU 2QVJKPWUG CPF +TGPCGW $KUJQR #IQDCTF YCU VJG HKTUV DKUJQR 6JG CTEJDKUJQR TGEGKXGF VJG VKVNG 2TKOCU )CNNKCG HTQO 2QRG )TGIQT[ 8++ KP

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # . ) WPFGT UVTKRG KP VJG HKGNF 24+/# 5'&'5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI VJG NGIGPF )# .. +# 48. $ 2F# IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # +P VJG HKGNF . ETQUUGF QWV 24+/# 5'&'5 4 %TQUU )#..+#48. $ 2F# IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&GPKGT. # +P VJG HKGNF . ETQUUGF QWV 24+/# 5'&'5 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH VJG XGTVKECN NKODU )#..+#4 8/. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU

1DQNG. # +P VJG HKGNF . ETQUUGF QWV 24+/# 5'&'5 4 %TQUU )#..+#48. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8GEEJK .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

166


&#72*+05 QH 8+'001+5 +P 2JKNKR 8+ CESWKTGF VJG &CWRJKPG VJGP RCTV QH VJG *QN[ 4QOCP 'ORKTG QP VJG EQPFK VKQP VJCV KV YQWNF DG TWNGF D[ VJG MKPI U JGKT 6JG HKTUV QH VJGUG TQ[CN FCWRJKPU YCU 2JKNKR U ITCPFUQP %JCTNGU VJG HWVWTG %JCTNGU 8 YJQ CU JG UWEEGGFGF VQ VJG VJTQPG KP YKVJQWV JCXKPI CP JGKT [GV HQT UQOG VKOG CHVGTYCTFU EQODKPGF VJG VKVNGU QH -KPI QH VJG (TGPEJ CPF &CWRJKP QH VJG 8KGPPQKU UGG ECV 5RKPM EQNN 'NKCU

%*#4.'5

)TQU FGNRJKPCN. # &QNRJKP &#.2* 5 8+'05 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NKU 4 +PPGT EKTENG ñ -#41.85 4': YKVJ VQMGP CHVGT # $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+. $ 2F# IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z 'NKCU EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5KNDGTUVGKP 2CTKU %

)TQU FGNRJKPCN. # &QNRJKP „ -41.75 „ (4#0%148 „ 4': 4 %TQUU EQWTQPP¾G QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG FQNRJKP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU „ '6 „ &#.2*5 „ 8+'0'5+5. $ 2F# IT. 4 0KEG RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ %JCTNGU UQP QH ,QJP VJG )QQF YCU VJG NCVVGT %JCTNGU 8 %

24+0%+2#.+6; 14#0)' #PEKGPV PCOG #TCWUKQ &KQEGUG HQWPFGF CV VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ D[ KVU KPKVKCN DKUJQR %QPUVCPV 6JG QTKIKPU QH VJG UQXGTGKIPV[ CTG WPENGCT -PQYP KU 6KDWTIC FCWIJVGT QH 4C[OQPF ++ *GT FCWIJVGT ECNNGF 6KDWTIC CNKMG YGFFGF RTKPEG $GTVTCPF FG $CWZ UGVVKPI QHH C PQDNG JQWUG VJCV YQWNF TGKIP WPVKN +P VJG EKV[ TGXQNVGF CICKPUV VJG UQXGTGKIP RTQORVKPI VJG NCVVGT VQ ITCPV HTGGFQO CPF C EJCTVGT

4#;/10& +8

(NQTKP F QT. # (NGWT FG NKU QH HNQTGPVKPG ð 4 &+) 2 #84# 4 5VCPFKPI 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV 5 +1*# 00'5 $ JGNOGV. $ (D 2F# IT. 9GNN UVTWEM CPF CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG UJQYU #&4# KPUVGCF QH #84# *GNOGV OKPVOCUVGT UKIP

167


(NQTKP F QT. # (NGWT FG NKU QH HNQTGPVKPG 4 &+ ) 2 #84# 4 5VCPFKPI 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV 5 +1*# 00'5 $ EQTPGV $ (D 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV (GDTWCT[ PQ %QTPGV OKPVOCUVGT UKIP

%CTNKP. # 2TKPEG YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF QTD UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG 4 Ő 24+0%'25 Ő #84#0+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG EQTPGV KP GCEJ CPING /10'6 %+8+65 #84#. $ 2F# IT. /KPQT FQWDNG UVTWEM QP VJG TGXGTUG XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

&+1%'5' QH 8#.'0%' CPF &+' +P CPVKSWKV[ MPQYP CU 8CNGPVKC +P RKNNCIGF D[ VJG 8KUKIQVJU 6JGTG CNYC[U YGTG ITCXG FKHHGTGPEGU DGVYGGP EKVK\GPU CPF DKUJQR #VVGORVU VQ TGEQPEKNG YGTG WPFGTVCMGP D[ (TGFGTKE $CTDCTQUUC KP CPF D[ CTEJDKUJQR *WODGTV QH 8KGPPG KP +P C HWNN TGXQNWVKQP DTQMG QWV

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # 9KPIGF GCING QT FGIGPGTCVGF CPIGN 84$5 8#.'06+#+ 4 %TQUU RQOO¾ YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG VJ CPING 5#21..+0#45. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 0WO -TKPI EH /GVECNH & / %QKPCIG QH VJG %TWUCFGTU CPF VJG .CVKP 'CUV .QPFQP R V[RG & KK

&GPKGT. # 9KPIGF GCING QT FGIGPGTCVGF CPIGN 84$5 8#.'06+#+ 4 %TQUU RQOO¾ YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG VJ CPING 5#21..+0#45. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG &KXGTUGP EH /GVECNH & / %QKPCIG QH VJG %TWUCFGTU CPF VJG .CVKP 'CUV .QPFQP R V[RG & K

168


1DQNG. # 9KPIGF GCING QT FGIGPGTCVGF CPIGN 84$5 8#.'06+#+ 4 %TQUU RQOO¾ YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG VJ CPING 5#21..+0#45. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU EH /GVECNH & / %QKPCIG QH VJG %TWUCFGTU CPF VJG .CVKP 'CUV .QPFQP R V[RG & E

,'#0 +++ ,1('84;

)TQU F CTIGPV. # %TQUU RQOO¾ YKVJ QPG TKPI KP VJG PF CPF QPG UVCT KP VJG TF CPINGU ¤ +1*#0'5 ¤ '2+5%12 4 'CING T ¤ 8#.'06+0 ¤ '6&+'0. $ 2F# IT. 4 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ

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

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # *GCF T 5%5 8#.'4+#0 4 %TQUU 61408%+1%#56. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV #WEVKQP PQ

169


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

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # %TQUU JQQM DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU CPF UKEMNG CDQXG .1&8+%85 4' 4 %TQUU

0'8'40+5 %86 . $ & 2F# IT. 5OCNN FQWDNG UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

6WTSWCV /QPVRGNNKGT

/#*#76 ++

&GPKGT. # *QTK\QPVCN NKPG NKU CDQXG VYQ UVCTU DGNQY / %1/+66+55# 4 %TQUU 0+8'40+5 %+8+6. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$CVCXKC FGP *CCI

41$'46 FG (.#0&4'

&GPKGT. # %TQKZ CWZGTTQKUG YKVJ QPG UVCT KP VJG PF CPING 41$'4675 %1/'5 4 5JKGNF DGCTKPI VJG HNGOKUJ CTOU DGVYGGP VJTGG UVCTU 0+8'40'05+5. $ & 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ #HVGT

170


%1706; QH #7:'44' 6JG EQWPV[ #WZGTTG KP WPFGT 4KEJCTF ,WUVKVKCTWU DGECOG CP KORQTVCPV RCTV QH VJG FWEJ[ $WTIWPF[ +P VJG EQWPV[ YCU OGTIGF KPVQ VJG EQWPV[ 0GXGTU .CVGT #WZGTTG YCU WPKVGF YKVJ 0GXGTU CPF 6QPPGTTG )WKNNCWOG + CPF ++ YGTG VJG OQUV KORQTVCPV EQWPVU 6JKU WPKV[ HQWPF KVU GPF KP +P VJG EQWPV[ YCU UQNF VQ VJG MKPIFQO D[ .QWKU QH %J³NQP +V YQWNF DTKGHN[ DG RCTV $WTIWPF[ HTQO VQ

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # %TQUU CWZGTTQKUG #865+1&'5 %+ 4 %TQKZ CWZGTTQKUG WPFGT VJTGG RGNNGVU PQ NGIGPF. $ 2F# IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 1T )GUVKQP 2CTKU (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG EQKPU QH 6QPPGTG CTG KFGPVKECN VQ VJQUG QH #WZGTTG YKVJ GZEGRVKQP QH VJG PCOG QH EQWTUG

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

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UOCNN ETQUUGU CDQXG CPF DGNQY PQ NGIGPF 4 %TQUU %'010'5%+. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

171


%1706; QH 2418+05 1NFGUV TGEQTFGF PCOG RCIWU 2TWXKPKGPUKU 6JG EKV[ YCU KP CESWKTGF D[ *GTKDGTV ++ QH 8GTOCPFQKU DWV D[ OCTTKCIG UQQP HGNN VQ VJG EQWPVU QH $NQKU 6JG HGOCNG OGODGTU QH VJG *QWUG $NQKU %JCORCIPG OQTG VJCP QPEG TGEGKXGF VJGUG GUVCVGU CU VJKTFU 2TQXKPU YCU VJG EKV[ QH VJG NCTIG EJCORCIPG HCKTU UGXGTCN VKOGU C [GCT 9JGP 6JKDCWV +8

DTQVJGT QH 5VGRJCP QH $NQKU VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI 5VGRJGP HTQO VJG *QWUG $NQKU %JCORCIPG FKGF VJG EQWPV[ YCU FKXKFGF KP UGXGTCN RCTVU 6JWU %JCORCIPG CPF YKVJ KV 2TQXKPU YGPV VQ *GPTK NG .KD¾TCN CPF WPFGT JKO 2TQXKPU YQWNF GZRGTKGPEG C RGTKQF QH ITGCV DNQQO 1VJGT TGIKQPU YGTG .KIP[ $NQKU CPF 5CPEGTTG +P VJG RGQRNG FGOCPFGF VJGKT QYP UVCVWVGU DWV EQNNCDQTCVKQP YKVJ VJG EQWPVU UVC[GF GZ EGNNGPV 6JG EQWPV[ HGNN VQ FGUVKVWVKQP YJGP KP VJG EQWPV[ QH %JCORCIPG YCU TGNKP SWKUJGF VQ VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP 2TQXKPU UGEQPF EKV[ QH VJG EQWPV[ VJTQWIJ KVU OGTEJCPV RQUK VKQP PQY DGECOG C RNCEG QH YGCXGTU CPF F[GTU %JCTNGU ++ RWV KPFGRGPFGPEG VQ CP GPF YJGP JG VQQM 2TQXKPU KP

6*+$#76 +8

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKV QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF VJ QOGIC KP VJG PF CPF CNRJC KP VJG TF CPINGU 6'$#.6 %1/'u 4 %QOD # DGVYGGP VYQ TKPIU CDQXG %#564+ 2466+05. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU #EEQTFKPI VQ $QWFGCW KV YQWNF JCXG VQ UC[ 2488+05 KPUVGCF QH 2466+05

2418+05 CPF 5'05 #010;/175

&GPKGT. A %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF TF CPINGU CNRJC CPF QOGIC KP VJG PF CPF VJ CPINGU 5''+ 1/5 %+8+. R: %QOD ETQUU DGVYGGP VYQ TKPIU CDQXG 4+.&8/+5%#61 JCTFN[ XKUKDNG $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU

&+1%'5' QH /'#7: 6JG CPEKGPV PCOG KU +CVKPWO .QTG JCU KV VJCV /GCWZ YCU HQWPFGF CPF EJTKUVKCPKUGF KP VJG HKTUV JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ D[ CP CRRTGPVKEG QH 5V &KQP[UKWU 5V 5CKPVKP #DQXG JKU VQOD C DC UKNKEC YCU DWKNV +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ *GTKDGTV ++ QH 8GTOCPFQKU CESWKTGF /GCWZ CU C FQYT[ HTQO JKU DTKFG MKPI 4QDGTV +ʼnU FCWIJVGT *G DGUVQYGF KV WRQP JKU UQP 4QDGTV YJQ YCU CNTGCF[ EQWPV QH 6TQ[GU VJGTGD[ ETGCVKPI C EQOKVCN EQORNGZ VJCV HQTOGF VJG EQTG QH VJG GOGTIKPI EQWPV[ %JCORCIPG VJG *QWUG 6JKDCWF 6JG DKUJQRU QYPGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV DWV VJG EQWPVU GPFGCXQWTGF VQ UGK\G KV +P CP CITGGOGPV YCU OCFG VJCV VJG GRKUEQRCN FGPKGT OGNFQKU YQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF GSWKXCNGPV VQ VJG EQOKVCN FGPKGT RTQXKPQKU #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG GRKUEQRCN EQKP XCP KUJGF

)#76+'4 +

&GPKGT. # $NGUUKPI JCPF )#.6 '4+85 24'58 4 %TQUU /'.&+5 %+8+6#. $ 2F# IT. # NKVVNG ETGUVHCNNGP XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

172


2+'44' +

&GPKGT. # *GCF N YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF OKVTG 2'6485 '2+5%12 4 %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU QPG RGNNGV QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /'.&+5 %+8+6#5. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU

/'#7: CPF 641;'5 #010;/175

&GPKGT. # $NWPFGTGF -CTQNWU OQPQITCO 1 /'+2+5 %+ 8+6#1 4 %TQUU 64'%#5+ %+8+. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU

#4%*&+1%'5' QH 4'+/5 6JG %KXKVCU 4GOQTWO GXQNXGF KPVQ VJG FKQEGUG QH 4GKOU $TQVJGT 5KPKEKWU EJTKUVKCPKUGF HTQO JGTG CV VJG UCOG VKOG CU 5QKUUQPU +P 5V 4GOKIKWU UGRCTCVGF VJG PQTVJYGUVGTP RCTV VQ VWTP KV KPVQ VJG FKQEGUG .CQP +P CV VJG EQWPEKN QH 5QKUUQPU 4GKOU YCU GPFQYGF CTEJKGRKUEQRCN UVCVWU #TEJDKUJQR *KPEOCT UCY VQ KV VJCV CU YGNN 5QKUUQPU CU .CQP HGNN WPFGT JKU OGVTQRQNKVKEWO CPF FKUOKUUGF CP[ ENCKO D[ VJG CTEJDKUJQRU QH 6TKGT QT D[ 5GPU #HVGT VJG UGRCTCVKQP QH 0Q[QP CPF 6QWTPCK 4GKOU JGNF CWVJQTKV[ QXGT UWHHTCICP FKQEGUGU COQPI YJKEJ 5QKUUQPU %CO DTCK #TTCU #OKGPU CPF .CQP (QTGOQUV VCUM QH VJG CTEJDKUJQRU QH 4GKOU YCU VJG UCPEVKHKECVKQP QH VJG MKPI 5CETG TQ[CN +P CTEJDKUJQR #FCNDGTQ CPQKPVGF *WIQ %CRGV KP 0Q[QP (TQO QP UCPEVKHKECVKQPU DG ECOG VJG TWNG +P VJG NCVG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG PQVKQP QH VJG 2CKTU FG (TCPEG ICKPGF ITQWPF UGV QHH D[ VJG CPQKPVOGPV KP QH 2JKNKRRG ++ #WIWUVG D[ CTEJDKUJQR )WKNNCWOG FG %JCORCIPG YJQ YCU RCTGPVGF VQ VJG TQ[CN JQWUG 6JG CTEJDKUJQRU QH 4GKOU TCPMGF JKIJGUV COQPI VJG 2CKTU CPF HTQO RTQENCKOGF VJGOUGNXGU &WMG QH 4GKOU &WTKPI VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT 4GKOU YCU WPFGT UKGIG D[ VJG CTOKGU QH 'FYCTF +++ YJQ YCPVGF VQ EQGTEG JKU CPQKPVOGPV VQ MKPI QH (TCPEG *G HCKNGF CPF VJG 2GCEG QH $T¾ VKIP[ HQNNQYGF

)7+..#7/' +

&GPKGT. # +P VYQ NKPGU )8.' 4/85 #4%*+'2+5%1285 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU Z 4'/+5 %+8+6#5. $ 2F# IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

173


#$$'; QH 5#+06 /—&#4& ¯ 51+55105 /GFCTF CRRTQZ DGHQTG ECOG HTQO NQECN 8GTOCPFQKU PQDKNKV[ *G YCU DKUJQR QH 0Q[QP CPF HQWIJV JGCVJGPFQO *G CPQKPVGF SWGGP 4CFGIWPFKU VQ DG C PWP *G YCU KPVGTTGF KP 5QKUUQPU # OQPCUVGT[ ECOG KPVQ GZKUVGPEG KP YJGP %JNQVCTKWU + CPF 5KIGDGTV JCF C EJWTEJ DWKNV QP VJG ITCXG QH /GFCTF YJQ YQWNF NCVGT DG XGPGTCVGF CU 5V /GFCTF

#010;/175

&GPKGT. # *GCF T 5%+ /'&84 %#286 4 5VCPFCTF CPF ETQUU '5$'5& '$'%. $ 2F# IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG KU TGVTQITCFG CPF OQUV RTQDCDN[ KU C FKUHKIWTGOGPV QH 5%5 5'$#56+#0 DWV YJ[ C TGHGTGPEG VQ 5V 5GDCUVKCP!

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ʼnU CDDG[ CDDQVU #FCNJCTFU VJG 'NFGT CPF JKU DTQVJGT 9CNC $GVYGGP CPF VJG OQPCUVGT[ CUUWOGF VJG VCUM QH HQWPFKPI C PGY EQPXGPV KP VJG LWUV EQPSWGTGF 5CZQPKC TGUWNVKPI KP VJG CDDG[ QH %QTDGKC 0QXC

%QTXG[ UGG WPFGT )GTOCP[ %QTXG[ 6JG UEJQQN KP %QTDKG GFWECVGF C ITGCV OCP[ ENGTI[ OGP CU HQT KPUVCPEG #PUICT VJG DKUJQR QH *CODWTI $TGOGP UGG VJGTG #DDQV (TCPEQ FGOCPFGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV HTQO 'WFGU CPF JCF EQKPU UVTWEM WPFGT JKU QYP PCOG #TQWPF FGENKPG UGV KP (TQO %QTDKG YCU FGHKPKVKXGN[ CDUQTDGF KPVQ VJG TQ[CN FQ OCKP +P VJG CDDQV KU DGUVQYGF WRQP C EQOKVCN VKVNG D[ 2JKNKRRG ++ #WIWUVG %KV[ CPF OQPCUVGT[ UWHHGTGF UGXGTGN[ WPFGT VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT +P KP VJG RGCEG QH #TTCU %QTDKG HGNN VQ VJG FWMGU QH $WTIWPF[

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC #$ $ #5 &2+% 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UOCNN ETQUU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU #05+%+85. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

174


%+6; QH #/+'05 1TKIKPCN PCOG 5COCTQDTKXC EGNVKE CPF #ODKCPQ NCVKP -PQYP OKPV HTQO 4QOCP FC[U %JTKUVKCP KPHNWGPEG YCU HGNV GCTN[ JGTG 5CKPV /CTVKP QH 6QWTU YCU C UQNFKGT KP #OKGPU CPF KV KU DGNKGXGF VQ JCXG DGGP VJG UVCIG HQT /CTVKPʼnU OQUV HCOQWU FGGF JG EWV JKU ENQCM KP JCNH VQ UJCTG KV YKVJ C DGIICT %QOKVCN FKIPKV[ YCU VCMGP WR KP CPF RCUUGF VJTQWIJ UGXGTCN JCPFU 6JGP VJG EQWPVU QH 8GTOCPFQKU GUVCDNKUJGF VJGOUGNXGU KP #OKGPU CPF CHVGT VJCV KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG EQWPVU QH (NCPFGTU )TCFWCNN[ VJG EQOKVCN CWVJQTKV[ YCU CDCPFQPGF CPF KPFGRGPFGPEG GOGTIGF

COQPI QVJGTU QH VJG CDDQVU QH %QTDKG *QYGXGT KPFGRGPFGPEG YCUPʼnV CEEQORNKUJGF YKVJQWV FKHHKEWNVKGU GPCDNKPI VJG EQWPV QH (NCPFGTU 2JKNKRU QH VJG #NUCEG VQ UGK\G VJG QRRQTVWPKV[ CPF CEETQCEJ CNN RQYGT 9KVJ VJG VTGCV[ QH $QXGU #OKGPU YCU EGFGF VQ VJG MKPI 2JKNKRRG #WIWUV %QOOGTEG HNQWTKUJGF #TQWPF #OKGPU YCU VJG OCKP EGPVTG QH VTCFG KP 0QTVJ (TCPEG

%+6;

&GPKGT DKNNQP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPING NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 4+: KP VJG HKGNF RGNNGV QXGT +. $ 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 5VWVVICTV 6JKU EQKP WUGF VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ 8GTFWP 6JG CVVTKDWVKQP VQ #OKGPU KU QH 2QG[ F #XCPV 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG YCU VJQWIJV VQ TGCF *'04+ VJG NGVVGTU UGRGTCVGF D[ FQVU 0QTOCNN[ VJGUG EQKPU TGCF +5.#/806#+ YJKEJ OGCPU +EK C OQPPCKG

&GPKGT VJ EGPVWT[. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP VJG UV CPING #/$+#0+5 4 2#: KP VJG HKGNF %+8+$85568+5. $ 2F# IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

175


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ʼn QRRQUKVKQP CICKPUV VJG DKUJQRU ITGY %QNQIPG UQNNKEKVQT $GTVTCO

GORNQ[GF D[ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC CVVGORVGF VQ TGUVQTG VJG QNF U[UVGO 5VKNN VJG EKVK\GPUʼn KPHNWGPEG EQPVKPWGF VQ KPETGCUG 'XGP 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM ++ FKFPʼnV OCPCIG VQ WRJQNF VJG QNF UKVWCVKQP HCXQWTCDNG VQ VJG DKUJQRU +P VJG RGQRNGʼnU TKIJVU YGTG NCKF FQYP KP NCY 6JG DKUJQRU UWDUGSWGPVN[ TGVTGCVGF VQ 8KE UWT 5GKNNG 6JG CWVJQTKV[ QH VJG DQWTIGQKUKG ITGY UQ XCUV VJCV HQWT UWTTQWPFKPI RQYGTU EQODKPGF HQTEGU VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH 6TKGT VJG FWMG QH .QTTCKPG VJG EQWPV QH $CT CPF VJG EQWPV QH .WZGODQWTI

6JG EKV[ YCU YGCNVJ[ CPF RQYGTHWN +V DGECOG CNNKGF YKVJ VJG FWMGU QH $WT IWPF[ CPF UWEEGUUHWNN[ YKVJUVQQF UGXGTCN .QTTCKPG CVVGORVU CV CPPGZCVKQP 4GP¾ + CPF ++ QH #PLQW +ORQTVCPV DKUJQRU QH VJG NCVG /KFFNG #IGU YGTG 6JGQFQTKE CPF %QPTCF $C[GT QH $QRRCTF

6*'1&14+%* +

1DQNG. # 6GORNG YKVJ HQWT EQNWOPU 5% # / '66 +5 &'1& 4 %TQUU YKVJ 1 6 6 1 KP VJG CPINGU +/246# 8) . %0) QDQNG &CPP (F5 9 ++ & C IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG HKTUV DKUJQR YJQ OGPVKQPU JKU PCOG QP EQKPU -NWIG MPQYU QPN[ QH URGEKOGPU HTQO UYGFKUJ JQCTFU +P HCEV JKU PCOG YCU &KGVTKEJ KP VJG .GZKMQP FGU /KVVGNCNVGTU DQVJ &KGVTKEJ CPF 6JGQFGTKE CTG WUGF DWV YG OCKP VCKPGF VJG (TGPEJ PCOG CU KV EQTTGURQPFU VQ VJG VGZV QP VJG EQKPU UGG %0) HQQVPQVG YKVJ

#&'.$'410 ++

&GPKGT. # 6GORNG YKVJ HQWT EQNWOPU # &'.$'41 4 %TQUU YKVJ 1 6 6 1 KP VJG CPINGU +/2 '4#614 . %0) &CPP (F5 UWRRN 9 ++ & D IT. 4 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ #VVTKDWVGF VQ #FCNDGTQP + D[ &CPPGPDGTI CPF QVJGT GCTN[ CWVJQTU

176


6*'1&'4+% ++

&GPKGT. # 6GORNG YKVJ HQWT EQNWOPU CPF ' DGVYGGP VJGO &Å‘1&4Å‘%Å‘Å‘ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &'Å‘Å‘Å‘Å‘. %0) H &CPP (F5 9 IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CU WUWCN HQT VJKU V[RG XGT[ HKPG

&GPKGT. # *GCF YKVJ YKNF JCKT N &'1&Å‘Å‘4'5 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING ++8%'665%Å‘#5. %0) &CPP (F5 9 ++ ' D IT. /KPQT HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU #NN EQKPU QH VJKU V[RG CTG DCTGN[ NGIKDNG CPF VJG UK\G COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU KU PQV EQORCVKDNG YKVJ /GV\ 0QPGVJGNGUU /GV\ UJQWNF DG EJQUGP DGECWUG VJG GRKUEQRCN VKVNG 24'58. KPUVGCF QH VJG WUWCN '2+5%1285 QPN[ QEEWTU KP 7RRGT .QTTCKPG +P VJG VGORNG VTKCPINGU HQTOKPI CP '

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 2GTJCRU VJKU EQKP UGTXGF VQ HKPCPEG VJG EQPUVTWEVKQP QH VJG ECVJGFTCN QH /GV\

#.&#$'410 +8

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING #.$'41 '25 4 $WUV T YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF 5 56'2*#0. %0) &CPP C (F5 9 ++ ' H IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING #.$'41 '25 4 $WUV T YKVJ DNGUUKPI 5 56'2*#0. %0) &CPP C (F5 9 ++ ' H IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z 0% PQ /& 'Z 2KORTG\ JQCTF PQ

$4'& 2CTKU

#010;/175 56'2*#0 %1+0

&GPKGT. # &KCFGOGF DWUV N YKVJ 5 56'2 *085 N QH KV 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU / '66 +5 . %0) &CPP (F5 9 ++ + IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CPF YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ

4GKIP QH #FCNDGTQP +8

177


'6+'00' FG $#4

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV 5VGRJCP YKVJ RCNO NGCH 56' 2 *#0 4 *CPF YKVJ ETQUKGT /' 6' 05+5. %0) &CPP (F5 UWRRN 9 ++ ' I IT. 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

(4'&'4+% FG 2.781+5'

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV 5VGRJCP N (4+&'4+% 4 %TQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP VJG PF CPF TQUGVVG KP VJG 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG TF CPINGU /'6'05+5. (F5 UWRRN 9 ++ ' K IT. &QODTQYUMK /ÒPUVGT #EEQTFKPI VQ &G 5CWNE[ VJG QPN[ V[RG UVTWEM D[ VJKU DKUJQR

$'464#/

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF $'464#00 4 *CPF QXGT ETQUU /'6'05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' M IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG

$4'& 2CTKU

,'#0 F #24'/106

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT QPG UVCT KP HTQPV QH JKO +0' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGU EGPV KP GCEJ CPING / ' 6'05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' O IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #EEQTFKPI VQ &G 5CWNE[ VJKU OKIJV CNUQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ ,CESWGU FG .QTTCKPG

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT +5 '0 0#*1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING /'6'05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' O IT. 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 6JG PWODGTU CPF CTG HTQO QPG JQCTF

178


&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ + 5 '0 0#*1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING

/'6' 05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' O IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM DWV XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT QPG UVCT KP HTQPV QH KV 0ő 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING /'6 '05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' O IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT ' + DGJKPF JKO 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UVCTU CPF VYQ ETGU EGPVU KP VJG CPINGU ) + % +ő. (F5 9 ++ ' O IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP #EEQTFKPI VQ 9GNFNKPI CP KOKVCVKQP QH ,GCP Fʼn#RT¾OQPV 6JG OGCPKPI QH VJG NGVVGTU KU WPENGCT

,#%37'5 &' .144#+0'

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT +#+% 1$ + 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UVCTU CPF VYQ ETGUEGPVU KP VJG CPINGU /'6'05+5. (F5 9 ++ ' P IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT + $+ QPG UVCT T 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UVCTU CPF VYQ ETGUEGPVU KP VJG CPINGU / '6 '0 5+ 5. (F5 9 ++ ' P IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 0QVG VJG JCKT

#010;/175 QH VJG RGTKQF VQ

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT QPG RGNNGV KP HTQPV QH JKO PQ NGIGPF XKUKDNG 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ UVCTU CPF VYQ ETGUEGPVU KP VJG CPINGU . %. (F5 9 IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT 'RKPCN. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF QPG TQUG KP HTQPV QH JKO PQ NGIGPF 4 %TQUU Ő '5 Ő 2+0#85Ő. (F5 9 ++ ' R IT. 5OCNN KPM FTCYKPI PWODGT CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 2GTJCRU 9 ++ ' O CPF VJGP CP KOKVCVKQP QH ,GCP Fʼn#RT¾OQPV #U VJGTG KU PQ QDXGTUG VGZV YG ENCUUKHKGF KV WPFGT VJG CPQP[OQWU RGTKQF CHVGT ,CESWGU FG .QTTCKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 9GPFNKPI CVVTKDWVGU VJKU VQ .CWTGPVKWU QH .GKUVGTDGTI

179


6*+'44; 8 QH $122#46

)TQU. # 5VCPFKPI DKUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 6*'1&' '25 /'6' 4 )41 585 /'6 ' 5 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 Q 5+6 „ 01/' Q &0+ Q 04+ Q +*8 Q :2+ Q. (F5 9 ++ ' Y IT. 0KEG RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

)TQU. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 6*' Q '25 Q /' Q 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# /'6 '05ʼn Q. (F5 9 ++ ' Y IT. 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV CPF UOCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

$QWTIG[ 2CTKU

'2+0#. 'RKPCN YCU HQWPFGF D[ $KUJQR 6JGQFGTKE + QH /GV\ 1VVQ + CNNQYGF C OCTMGV RNCEG VQ DG UGV WR CPF C OKPV QH 'RKPCN HKTUV YCU OGPVKQPGF WPFGT 6JGQFGTKE ++ *KU EQKPU CPF VJQUG QH JKU RTGFGEGUUQTU CTG FKTGEV KOKVCVKQPU QH /GV\ EQKPU

*—4+/#00

&GPKGT QT 1DQNG ! . # 6GORNG 52+0# . 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TQUGVVGU KP VJG CPINGU 52+ 0#. . %0) &CPP (F5 UWRRN 9 ++ ' I IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU 6JKU V[RG KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP %0) &G 5CWNE[ FTCYU HQWT URGEKOGPU 6JTGG QH VJGUG YGTG HQWPF COQPI C ITQWR QH URGEKOGPU QH $KUJQR $GTVTCOʼnU EQKPU 0GXGTVJGNGUU &G 5CWNE[ ENCUUKHKGU VJGO WPFGT $KUJQR *¾TKOCPP DWV CNUQ PCOGU $KUJQR 6JGQFGTKE +++ CPF (T¾FGTKE FG 2NWXQKUG

5##4$74) +P $KUJQR #FCNDGTQP +++ QH /GV\ YKVJ VJG CUUGPV QH 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +++ EQPHGTTGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV KP 5CCTDWTI VQ VJG ECVJGFTCN EJCRVGT QH /GV\ (KTUV EQKPU YGTG HTQO VJG RGTKQF QH $KUJQR *¾TKOCPP 6JG PCOG QH VJG DKUJQR KU PQV OGP VKQPGF YJKEJ KPFKECVGU VJG ECVJGFTCN EJCRVGT QRGTCVGF VJG OKPV 0QV OGPVKQPKPI CP GRKUEQRCN PCOG YCU C YC[ VQ CXQKF UKFKPI YKVJ GKVJGT VJG GORGTQT QT VJG RQRG 5VCTVKPI YKVJ VJG VJKTF V[RG 5V 5VGRJCPWU YCU TGRNCEGF D[ 5V 2CWN YJKEJ YCU C OCPKHGUVCVKQP QH VJG UYC[ QH VJG ECVJGFTCN EJCRVGT QXGT VJG OKPV

#&#.$'410 +++

&GPKGT. # 5CKPV 2CWN N 5 2#8. 8 5 4 %JWTEJ Å‘2# Å‘. %0) &CPP (F5 UWRRN 9 IT. 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU ņ 6JKU V[RG KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP %0) &G 5CWNE[ RTQXKFGU C FTCYKPI PQ YKVJ C UKOKNCT DWUV HCEKPI TKIJV JQYGXGT 6JG TGXGTUG UJQYU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG EJWTEJ YKVJ VJG NGIGPF 5#4'$1% *GTG QPN[ VJG $ KU NGIKDNG OQTGQXGT VJG DWUV HCEGU NGHV 6JG DWUV DGCTU ITGCV TGUGODNCPEG VQ VJG EQKPU QH DKUJQR $GTVTCO YJKEJ RWVU CVVTKDWVKQP VQ VJKU RGTKQF YKVJKP VJG TGCNOU QH RQUUKDKNKV[

180


%+6; QH /'6< +P $KUJQR #FJ¾OCT FG /QPVGKN EQPHGTTGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV VQ VJG EKV[ QH /GV\ HQT C RGTKQF QH VYQ [GCTU +P 6JKGTT[ FG $QRRCTV NGHV VJG EKV[ VJG FGGF VQ VJG OKPV (TQO VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ QP VJG EKV[ GZGTEKUGF VJKU RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV VJG DKUJQRU TGVCKPGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV CU YGNN

(NQTKP F QT. # %KV[ CTOU KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING b (.14'085 b %+8+6#6+5 b /'6'05+5 b 4 5CKPV 5VGRJGP KP OCPFQTNC YKVJ RCNO NGCH CPF UVQPG Ő 5 56'2*#085 2416*1/#4. $ (D 4QD IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG 'Z $TCPF EQNNGEVKQP .GW <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP FGGN PQ 'Z $WEJGPCW EQNNGEVKQP #WEVKQP # ' %CJP (TCPMHWTV C / PQ

)TQU. # )41 558 5 / '6' CTQWPF ETQUU NQPI ETQUU $0&+%68 Q 5+6 „ 01/' Q &0+ Q 04+ Q +*8 Q :2+ Q 4 5CKPV 5VGRJGP KP OCPFQTNC YKVJ RCNO NGCH CPF UVQPG 5 56'2*

2416*1 . $ 4QD IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-WTRH·N\KUEJG /ÒP\JCPFNWPI /CPPJGKO #WEVKQP PQ

)TQU. # )41 558 5 / '6' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING EKV[ CTOU $0&+%68 Q 5+6 01/' Q &0+ Q 04+ Q +*8 Q :2+ 4 5CKPV 5VGRJGP YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF DGVYGGP VYQ UJKGNFU JCPF CDQXG 5 56'2* 2416*1ʼn / . $ 4QD HH IT. 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

)TQU $WIPG. # 5CKPV 5VGRJGP MPGGNKPI YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPF UVQPG 5 56'2* 2416*1 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# /'6 '05. $ 4QD IT. 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

181


)TQU. # *GCF QH 5CKPV 5VGRJGP HCEKPI 5 Z 56'2*#085 4 %TQUU /10' Z /'6'05+5. $ 4QD IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

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

2+'44' FG $4+<#;

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT 2'6485 4 %JWTEJ ő..+. $ 4QD ! IT. 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG NGIGPF QP VJG TGXGTUG KU PQV XKUKDNG

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH 5CKPV 2GVTWU YKVJ DQQM 2'64 85 4 *CPF QP ETQUKGT Ä 68 ..+. $ 4QD IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG .CP\ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO VJG $CTDCTQUUC JQCTF

&GPKGT 0GWHEJCVGCW. # $WUV QH 5CKPV 2GVTWU T YKVJ MG[U 2'6485 4 6QYGT 0 18+ %#5 64+. $ 0CW 4QD IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG &QODTQYUMK /ÒPUVGT (KPF 6TCGPJGKO 5 E &KG UGJT GHHGMVKXG /ÒP\UV·VVG 0GWHEJ³VGCW CP FGT QDGTGP /CCU JCV HÒT FKG $KUEJÌHG XQP 6QWN WPF FKG *GT\ÌIG XQP .QVJCTKPIGP GKPG (ÒNNG XCTKCPVGPTGKEJGT 2HGPPKIG XQP IWVGP 5VGORGNUEJPKVV IGRT·IV )NGKEJDNGKDGPFGU -GPP\GKEJGP KUV KP LGFGO (CNN FGT \YGKUVÌEMKIG <KPPGPVWTO OKV QFGT QJPG 5VCFVPCOGP #WH FGT CPFGTG 5GKVG GTUEJGKPV HÒT FKG $KUEJÌHG FGT * 2GVTWU HÒT FKG *GT\ÌIG FGT JGTCNFKUEJG #FNGT QFGT FGT *GT\QI UGNDUV 0CW

182


,'#0 F #4<+.+ 4'5 QT #/#&'75 QH )'0'8#

2GVKV FGPKGT FG $TKZG[. # $KUJQR UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM &ʼn $+ 4 4 5YQTF Ì /10 '6#. $ 4QD IT. 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

1T )GUVKQP 2CTKU (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG QDXGTUG UJQYU C DKUJQR YJKEJ TGHGTU VQ 6QWN VJG TGXGTUG UJQYU C FQYPVWTPGF UYQTF KPFKECVKQP QH .QTTCKPG 6Q O[ OKPF VJKU LWUV CU VJG PWODGTU CPF KU CP CUUQEKCVG EQKP QH VJG DKUJQR QH 6QWN CPF VJG FWMG QH .QTTCKPG 6JG EQKP KU WUWCNN[ CVVTKDWVGF VQ .KDGTFWP FWG VQ VJG HCEV VJCV KV TGCFU .ʼn + JGTG JQYGXGT KV ENGCTN[ UVCVGU $ + 9GPFNKPI 9 ++ ' U CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ VJG 6QWN OKPV QH $TKZG[ YJKEJ HKVU VJG NGVVGTU &ʼn $+ 4

5VGTNKPI. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI '% /10' 6# 01564# 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING .80 61. '0) +'0. $ /C[JGY 4QD IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

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

5VGTNKPI. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI J+% /10'6# 01564# 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING .80 61. '0) +'0. $ /C[JGY 1DXGTUG 4GXGTUG 4QD IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 0QTOCNN[ KV TGCFU '% /10'6# 01564# /C[JGY 1PG TCTG XCTKGV[ /C[JGY JCU J+% KVU TGXGTUG JQYGXGT JCU VJG VGZV .10 610 4'0 )+' QPG URGEKOGP 6JG TGXGTUG QH VJKU EQKP KU VJCV QH /C[JGY CPF VJGTGHQTG C PGY XCTKGV[

183


&+1%'5' QH 8'4&70 %KV[ QP /QPV 5V 8CPPG 2TGUWOCDN[ C FKQEGUG UKPEG VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 8GTFWP UQOGVKOGU WUGF VQ DG TGHGTTGF VQ CU 7TDU %NCXQTWO 7PFGT DKUJQR *CVVQ VJGTG YCU VGTTKVQTKCN GZRCPUKQP 8GTFWP YCU UCXGF HTQO 8KMKPI TCKFU DWV WPFGT $KUJQR &CFQ VJG GPVKTG EKV[ CPF VJG ECVJGFTCN YGPV WR KP HNCOGU (TQO VQ 8GTFWP YCU WPFGT 9GUVHTCPEQPKCP TWNG CPF %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG JCF EQKPU UVTWEM JGTG UGG WPFGT %CTQNKPIKCPU +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG GEQPQO[ HNQWTKUJGF #RCTV HTQO VJG ECVJGFTCN CPF 5V 8CPPG KP 5V 2CWN YCU HQWPFGF +P VJG EKV[ CPF VJG ECVJGFTCN YGTG FGUVTQ[GF D[ )QFHTG[ VJG $GCTFGF 6JKGTT[ + RNC[GF CP KORQTVCPV TQNG KP VJG +PXGUVKVWTG %QPVTQXGTU[ CPF ENCUJGF YKVJ 5V 8CPPG #HVGT 6JKGTT[ VJG DKUJQRUʼn KPHNWGPEG UWDUVCPVKCNN[ FKOKPKUJGF KP URKVG QH VJG HCEV VJCV VJG[ HTQO QP HQTOCNN[ QYPGF VJG EQWPV[ 8GTFWP 6JG EQWPVU QH $CT CPF VJG CDDQVU QH 5V 8CPPG JGNF UVTQPI RQUKVKQPU 6JG FKQEGUG 8GTFWP YCU C UWHHTCICPCVG QH 6TKGT

*#+/1

&GPKGT. # #8) WPFGT VJTGG RGNNGVU CPF QXGT \KI\CI NKPG 1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CP ING 1 . $ %0) &CPP C 4QD IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 6JG NGIGPF UJQWNF DG *#+/1 '25 CPF 1661 +/2 *CKOQ YCU C UVWFGPV QH DKUJQR 0QVMGT QH .K½IG CPF JG CHVGT .K½IG GZCORNG GNGXCVGF 8GTFWP VQ *QN[ %KV[

4#+/$'46

&GPKGT *CVVQPEJCVGN. # *GCF N 4#/$'46 285. 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING *#&10 + %#56 48 ( . %0) &CPP IT. $GPV XGT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ *CVVQPEJCVGN KU PCOGF CHVGT DKUJQR *CVVQ QH 8GTFWP 9CU QRGTCVGF CU OKPV QH 4CKODGTV VQ 4KEJGT

DGIKPPKPI QH VJ EGPVWT[ 4CKODGTV HQWPFGF VJG 15$ OQPCUVGT[ 5V #KT[ VJCV YCU VQVCNN[ GENKRUGF JQYGXGT D[ VJQUG QH 5V 8CPPG CPF 5V 2CWN

4+%*#4& +

&GPKGT. # *GCF T 4+%#4&85 '25 4 *CPF *'+04+ %85 4 ':. $ %0) &CPP -NWIG 4QD IT. 44 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP $QVJ &CPPGPDGTI CPF %0) JCXG VJG JGCF HCEKPI NGHV *GCF HCEKPI TKIJV KU PQP GZKUVGPV KP NKVGTCVWTG

184


&GPKGT *CVVQPEJCVGN. # $NGUUKPI JCPF 4 +%*# 4& 85 4 6GORNG YKVJ HKXG EQNWOPU * #6610+5 % # 648 . $ %0) &CPP 4QD IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

6*+'44; +

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 6+'&'4+ %85 '25 4 8GKNGF JGCF T KP EKTENG

PKODWU ! 5%# /#4+ # . $ %0) &CPP -NWIG 4QD IT. 4 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

1DQNG. # %TQUU 6+'&'4+%85 '25 4 8GKNGF JGCF T KP EKTENG PKODWU ! 5'# /#4+#. $ %0) &CPP 4QD IT. 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT 6+'&'4+%ʼn '25 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU 8+4&8 0 8/. $ %0) &CPP 4QD IT. 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG ENGCT CPF UJCTR URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

4+%*'4 4+%*#4& ++

&GPKGT. # 8GKNGF JGCF T / #4 +# 8 +4)1 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU 4+%*'485 '25 . $ %0) &CPP 4QD IT. .GIGPF PQV XKUKDNG XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5OCNN JGCF PQV KP EKTENG PKODWU ! CU YKVJ PQU CPF %0) MPQYU QH QPN[ VJTGG URGEKOGPU KP 5YGFKUJ JQCTFU

185


#$$'; )14<' #DDG[ KP .QTTCKPG PGCT VJG EKV[ QH /GV\ (QWPFGF WPFGT DKUJQR %JTQFGICPI QH /GV\ KP VJG CDDG[ YGPV C EGPVTG HQT GEENGUKCUVKECN UVWFKGU #HVGT CDDQV 2GVGT VJG OQPCUVGT[ HCNNU KPVQ FGEC[

#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N 4 %JWTEJ. 0CW IT.

44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 'U JCPFGNV UKEJ WO $GKUEJN·IG \W 6QWNGT 2HGPPKIGP CWU GKPGT DGFGWVGPFGP IGKUVNKEJGP /ÒP\UV·VVG FGT &KÌ\GUG 6QWN *KGTHÒT MQOOV CO GJGUVGP FKG #DVGK )QT\G KO (TCIG 0CW

#$$'; 4'/+4'/106

9QOGPʼn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

#010;/175

&GPKGT CHVGT . # $WUV QH 5CKPV 2GVTWU T YKVJ MG[ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CP INGU 4 1/ #4+% . $ %0) &CPP 4QD IT. 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ %0) CFQRVU &CPPGPDGTIʼnU FTCYKPI /CZG 9GTN[ CPF ECV 4QDGTV $ 2F#

&7%*; QH $#4 1TKIKPCNN[ C EQWPV[ HTQO QP C FWEJ[ +P KV ECOG WPFGT VJG TWNG QH VJG FWMGU QH 7RRGT .QTTCKPG +P VJCV [GCT &WMG (TGFGTKEM + DWKNV VJG ECUVNG $CTTWO &WEKU $CT NG &WE 5QRJKG KU EQPUKFGTGF VQ DG VJG HKTUV EQWPVGUU QH $CT &WG VQ KVU YGCNVJ CPF XCUVPGUU $CT YCU C VJQTP KP .QTTCKPGʼnU UKFG YJKEJ KVUGNH GPEQORCUUGF C XGT[ OQFGUV VGTTKVQT[ 9JGP KP .WZGODQWTI DGECOG C FWEJ[ %JCTNGU +8 WPKVGF VJG TGOCKPKPI RCTVU GNGXCVKPI VJG EQWPVU QH $CT VQ RTKPEGU QH VJG GORKTG 0QPGVJGNGUU VJG HQEWU UVC[GF QP (TCPEG +P VJG UCOG [GCT ;QNCPFC CFQRVGF VJG FWECN VKVNG HQT JGT UQP 4QDGTV VJG /CIPKHKEGPV 9JGP 4QDGTVʼn UQP 'FYCTF ++ FKGF KP CV #\KPEQWTV VJG FWEJ[ YGPV VQ .QWKU DKUJQR QH 8GTFWP *G CFQRVGF JKU ITCPFPGRJGY 4GP¾ QH #PLQW YJQ YGFFGF 'NKUCDGVJ QH .QTTCKPG KP WPKVKPI $CT YKVJ .QTTCKPG 6JG EQCV QH CTOU QH $CT FKURNC[U C NKVVNG HKUJ DCT DCUU

41$'46

(NQTKP F 1T. # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV 5 +1*#00'5 $ 4 (NGWT FG NKU QH HNQTGPVKPG 41$'4685 &8:. $ (D (F5 4QD IT. (NCP FGHGEV CPF UOCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

186


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¾ QH #PLQW CNN UGGOGF ENGCT HQT C TGWPKQP QH DQVJ FWEJKGU *QYGXGT %QWPV #PVQKPG FG 8CWFGOQPV VJYCTVGF VJGUG RNCPU CPF VJG WPKQP EQWNF PQV DG DTQWIJV VQ EQORNGVKQP WPVKN VJG TGKIP QH VJG ITCPFUQP QH 4GP¾ CPF +UCDGNNG 4GP¾ ++ +P %JCTNGU VJG $QNF FWMG QH $WTIWPF[ QEEWRKGF VJG NCPF 6JKU RTQXQMGF C TGCEVKQP D[ 4GP¾ ++ CPF JKU PQDNGU UQ HKGTEG VJCV KV EQUV %JCTNGU JKU NKHG YJGP JG YCU UNCKP CV VJG DCVVNG QH 0CPE[ KP 6JG NCPF YCU UWDUGSWGPVN[ TGUVQTGF VQ KVU HQTOGT UVCVWU 7PFGT (GTT[ + VJGTG YCU HKTUV WUG QH VJG EQCV QH CTOU QP C UGCN QH .QTTCKPG .C ITCPFG EJCTI¾G FG VTQKU CN¾TKQPU QW CKINQPU VJG ITGCV EJCTIG QH VJG VJTGG CNGTKQPU QT GCINGU 1P VJG EQKPU VJKU EJCTIG FQGUPʼnV CRRGCT WPVKN WPFGT (GTT[ +++

6*+$#76 ++

&GPKGT CW ECXCNKGT 0CPE[. # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ NCPEG 6 &8: .1614')+' 4 5YQTF DG VYGGP VYQ GCINGU /10'6# &' 0#0%'+. $ (F5 4QD IT. 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP 'Z /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

('44; +8

&GPKGT CW ECXCNKGT 0CPE[. # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ NCPEG ( &8: .1614')+' 4 5YQTF DGVYGGP VYQ GCINGU /10'6# &' 0#0%'+. $ (F5 4QD IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

6JKDCWNV ++ YCU YGFFGF VQ +UCDGNNG FG 4WOKIP[ #V VJG FGOKUG QH 6JKDCWV KP VJG UGKIPGWTKG OCPQT QH 0GWH EJ³VGCW RCUUGF VQ +UCDGNNG +P UJG GPVGTGF YGFNQEM HQT VJG UGEQPF VKOG YKVJ )CWEJGT FG %JCVKNNQP *G YCU PQY GPVKVNGF VQ 0GWHEJ³VGCW CPF GZGTEKUGF JKU RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV #U VJKU )CWEJGT FG %JCVKNNQP YCU %QPUVCDNG QH (TCPEG CPF RNC[GF C TQNG KP .QTTCKPG JKUVQT[ VJG EQKPU JG UVTWEM KP JKU QYP %QWPV[ QH 2QTEKGP CTG NKUVGF CHVGT VJQUG QH .QTTCKPG (TQO VJKU OCTTKCIG (GTT[ +8 YCU DQTP *G VQQM +UCDGNNG QH #WUVTKC HQT JKU YKHG CPF UJG DGIQV JKO C UQP 4CQWN 6JG NCVVGTʼnU UGEQPF OCTTKCIG YCU VQ /CTKG FG $NQKU HTQO VJG *QWUG QH VJG 6JKDCWFKGPU 9JGP 4CQWN FKGF KP VJGKT UQP ,GCP YCU QPN[ [GCTU QH CIG CPF C TGIGPE[ QH /CTKG FG $NQKU CPF VJG EQWPV QH 9WTVGODGTI GPUWGF 187


/#4+' &' $.1+5

2NCSWG 0CPE[. # 5JKGNF KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU KP VJG CPINGU +1*#00'5 ¶ &8: ¶ /#4%+1 &' .16*14+)+' 4 /10'6# ¶ &' ¶ 0#%'+ CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING /#4+' ¶ &8%*'55 ¶ /#4$18455 ¶ &' ¶ .# &8%*+. $ (F5 4QD IT. 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG .¾QRCTF F 1T 2CTKU 5JKGNF UV CPF PF HKGNF .QTTCKPG TF CPF VJ HKGNF $NQKU

,'#0 +

)TQU 0CPE[. # 'CING QXGT UJKGNF QH .QTTCKPG +1*#00'5 Q Q &8: Q .16* Q 4 5YQTF DGVYGGP VYQ TQUGU /10'6# Q (%#ʼn Q +0 Q 0#0%'+1. $ (F5 4QD IT. 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN ,QJP + HQWIJV KP VJG FGUCUVTQWU $CVVNG CV 2QKVKGTU 6QIGVJGT YKVJ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI JG YCU VCMGP RTKUQPGT QH YCT CPF YCU PQV UGV HTGG WPVKN VJG 2GCEG QH $TGVKIP[

%*#4.'5 ++

&GPKGT FG DKNNQP 5KGTEM. # 5JKGNF -#41.85 Q &8: Q .16*14 4 5YQTF DGVYGGP VYQ TQ UGVVGU /10'6# Q +0 Q 5+'4-. $ (F5 4QD IT. 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT FG DKNNQP 5KGTEM. # 5JKGNF -#41.85 Q &8: Q .16*14 4 5YQTF DGVYGGP VYQ TQ UGVVGU /10'6# Q +0 Q 5+'4-. $ (F5 4QD IT. (NCP ETCEM CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 6JG EQNQWT QH FKHHGTU TGOCTMCDN[ HTQO VJCV QH

188


)TQU 5KGTEM. # *GNOGV YKVJ GCING QP VQR QXGT UJKGNF QH .QTTCKPG -#41.85 &8: .16*14 4 /10'6# Z +0 Z 5+'4- CTQWPF UYQTF DGVYGGP VYQ JQNN[ NGCHU $0&+%68Æ 5+6 01/'Æ &0+Æ 04+Æ +*8Æ :2+ . $ (F5 4QD IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP /ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP 'Z /ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GOK ITQU ECTQNWU. # 5JKGNF QXGT UYQTF -#41.85 &8: .16*14 < / 4 .QPI ETQUU FK XKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VYQ GCINGU CPF VYQ DCTDGNU $CT DGVYGGP ETQUUGU KP VJG CPINGU $'0'&+%68/ 5+6

01/' &0+. $ (F5 4QD IT. #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP 'Z /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 4QD 2QUUKDN[ VJG / UVCPFU HQT /15'..#0'!

&7%*; QH .144#+0' CPF $#4 #HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH 'FYCTF ++ GNFGUV UQP QH &WMG 4QDGTV NG /CIPKHKSWG KP VJG DCVVNG QH #\ KPEQWTV VJG &WEJ[ QH $CT ECOG VQ .WFYKI VJG DKUJQR QH 8GTFWP *G CFQRVGF JKU ITCPFPGRJGY 4GP¾ F #PLQW YJQ YCU OCTTKGF VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QH .QTTCKPG 6JKU NGCF VQ VJG WPKVKPI QH VJG $CT CPF .QTTCKPG

4'0— + F #0,17

)TQU 5V /KEJGN. # %TQYPGF CPF CTOQWTGF FWMG UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF 4'0#6ʼn & $#4ʼn /2 %1 4 /10'6# 5 ¤ /+%*# CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU 5+6 ¤ 01/'0 ¤ &1/+0+ ¤ $'0'&+%. $ (F5 4QD IT. +TTGIWNCT HNCP XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 5JKGNF #PLQW $CT $CT #PLQW CPF .QTTCKPG .GIGPF QDXGTUG 4GP¾ FWE FG DCT OCTSWKU EQOVG FG 2TQXGPEG

189


)TQU 5V /KEJGN. # #TOU QH #PLQW CPF $CT YKVJ UJKGNF QH .QTTCKPG QP KV 4'0#6+ &7: $#44'0 < .1* / 4 5YQTF DGVYGGP GCING CNยพTKQP CPF DCTDGN DCTDGCW YKVJ VJTGG ETQUUGU /10'6# ยค (#%6 # ยค +0 ยค /+%*#. +0 ยค 5 ยค /. $ (F5 1DXGTUG 4GXGTUG 4QD IT. (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /ร NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ EH PQ HQT VJG EQCV QH CTOU

4'0ย ++

2NCSWG 0CPE[. # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH .QTTCKPG N CPF $CT T 4'0#685 ยก & ยก ) ยก 4': ยก 5+%+. ยก +*4. ยก .16 4 5YQTF /10'6# ยก 018# ยก +0 ยก 0#0%'+1. $ (F5 4QD IT. /KPQT HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

)TQU CW $TCU #TOยพ. # 5JKGNF 4'0#675 ยค & ยค )4 ยค 5+ ยค +' ยค .1 ยค & 4 *CPF YKVJ UYQTF DTGCMKPI VJTQWIJ ENQWFU NQVJCTKPIKCP ETQUU ('%+6 ยค 216'0%+#/ +0 $4#0%*+15. $ (F5 4QD IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

&QODTQYUMK /ร PUVGT 6JG NGIGPFU QP VJG TGXGTUG KP $ 4QD CPF (F5 CTG /10'6# (#%6# +0 0#0%'+1 DWV JGTG KV KU ENGCTN[ 018#

)CNN FGU /QPPCKGU )GPยฝXG .GIGPF TGXGTUG (GEKV RQVGPVKCO KP DTCEEJKQ UWQ 5JKGNF #PLQW $CT CPF .QTTCKPG

%1706; QH 214%ย #0 )CWEJGT FG %JยณVKNNQP VTCFGF %JยณVKNNQP HQT 2QTEยพCP 6JTQWIJ JKU OCTTKCIG VQ +UCDGNNG QH 4W OKIP[ JGKTGUU QH (NQTKPGU JG CESWKTGF WUWHTWEV QH DQVJ 0GWHEJยณVGCW UGG WPFGT .QTTCKPG CPF (NQTKPGU *KU ITCPFUQP ,GCP UQNF 2QTEยพCP VQ .QWKU &WMG QH 1TNยพCPU KP )CWEJGT YCU %QPUVCDNG QH (TCPEG

)#7%*'4 QH %*ย 6+..10

5VGTNKPI ;XGU. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI )#%*5 %1/'5 214% 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '60 18# ;8'. $ /C[JGY 2F# IT. 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN +P CNN TGHGTGPEGU VJG QDXGTUG TGCFU )#. KPUVGCF QH )# CU JGTG %JCWVCTF 2N :+: CNUQ KP /C[JGY VJG V[RG YKVJQWV . KU PQV NKUVGF 6JKU KU VJG V[RG YKVJQWV RTKXCVG OCTM

190


5VGTNKPI ;XGU. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI )#.%* 5 %1/'5 214% 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10'6 018# ; 8'. $ /C[JGY 2F# IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

)NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 0QDNG EQNNGEVKQP #WUVTCNKC %JCWVCTF 6JKU KU C V[RG YKVJ C RTKXCVG OCTM #P DGVYGGP VJG * CPF VJG 5 QP VJG QDXGTUG CPF C UVCT DGVYGGP ; CPF 8 QP VJG TGXGTUG /C[JGY PQVGU QP R +V KU FKUVKPIWKUJGF D[ CRRGCTCPEG QH C UOCNN RKGTEGF UVCT QT OWNNGV QP VJG TGXGTUG

UJQYP JGTG CU C UVCT + MPQY QH CDQWV GZCORNGU QH VJKU V[RG DWV JCXG [GV VQ HKPF CP GZCORNG YKVJ C UVCT QP VJG QDXGTUG

#.5#%' +P URKVG QH PWOGTQWU QVJGT TGCFKPIU VJKU PCOG KU IGPGTCNN[ CEEGRVGF VQ FGTKXG HTQO CNK CNKGP CPF UCU\ UGCV *GPEG VJG #NUCVKCPU YGTG (TCPMU YJQ YGTG EQPUKFGTGF UVTCPIGTU

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

#&#.$'46

&GPKGT 5VTCUDQWTI DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[. # 9KVJKP C 8 UJCRGF EWTXG C 8 JGCTV! ETQUU CDQXG #&#.$'461 4 /QPQITCO. $GNH IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 1TKIKPCNN[ CVVTKDWVGF VQ $CUGN D[ .GNGYGN #VNCU :8++ *G KPVGTRTGVGF VJG OQPQITCO QP VJG TGXGTUG CU $#5 %+

$CUKNKC %KXKVCU 9KGNCPFV RTQXGF VJKU YTQPI &KG /QPGVCTOÒP\GP FGT QDGTTJGKPKUEJGP /GTQYKPIGTOÒP\UV·VVGP KP &GWVUEJGU ,CJTDWEJ HÒT 0WOKUOCVKM R CU FKF $WEJGPCW DGHQTG JKO *QYGXGT VJCV 5EJQGRNKP #NUCVKC KNNWUVTCVC %QNOCT JCF CNTGCF[ CVVTKDWVGF VJKU EQKP VQ #FCNDGTV %QWPV QH #NUCEG RTKQT VQ VJG CVVTKDWVKQPU OGPVKQPGF OC[ DG FGGOGF RGEWNKCT 4GEGPVN[ -NGKP YTQVG VJG HQNNQYKPI VQ FG 9KV +P O[ QRKPKQP VJKU KU /GTQXKPIKCP EQKPCIG VJCV JCF C RCTCNGNN KUUWG KP VJG 8KPKXKQ XCTKGV[ $GNHQTV *G EQPUKFGTU CP QTKIKP YKVJKP VJG 7RRGT 4JKPG #NUCEG TGIKQP PQV CNVQIGVJGT KORTQDCDNG CU 5EJÌRHNKP EQPHGT $GTVUGVV 'NUCUU C E YKVJ VGZV QP R 6Q O[ OKPF VQQ #FGNDGTV KP JKU RGTKQF CU FWMG QH VJG #NUCEG KU VJG QPN[ QPG GNKIKDNG HQT VJKU EQKP 6JG SWGUVKQP CU VQ YJCV VJG OQPQITCO QP VJG TGXGTUG FGUKIPCVGU TGOCKPU WPCPUYGTGF 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU TGVTQITCFG 6JGTGHQTG KV UGGOU RTQDCDNG VJCV VJG UCOG KU VTWG HQT VJG TGXGTUG VGZV 6JWU KV YQWNF TGCF )7+$ +H VJKU KUPʼnV VJG ECUG KV OKIJV DG $+7) QT RGTJCRU $74) #FCNTKE JCF CPQVJGT FCWIJVGT C UKUVGT VJGTGHQTG QH #FCNDGTV HQT YJQO JG HQWPFGF VJG OQPCUVGT[ 1FKNKGPDWTI %QWNF VJG OQPQITCO DG VCMGP CU $74) HQT 1FKNKGPDWTI ! 6JGTG CTG UKZ MPQYP URGEKOGPU EQWPVKPI VJG QPG CV JCPF VJTGG YGTG OGPVKQPGF D[ 9KGNCPFV KP &KG $CUNGT OÒP\RT·IWPI R C HQWTVJ KU MGRV KP VJG EQNNGEVKQP QH VJG #OGTKECP 0WOKUOCVKE 5QEKGV[ # 5VCJN #05/0 R C HKHVJ YCU HQWPF KP &QODWTI -2- PQ 'Z EQNN &G /CP FGUETKDGF CU JQCTF D[ &G /CP KP KP VJG ECVCNQIWG QH VJG 0WOKUOCVKUEJG 8GT\COGNKPI XCP JGV <GGWYUEJ IGPQQVUEJCR FGT 9GVGPUEJCRRGP 5GG 1R FGP 8GNFG CPF -NCCUUGP 5EGCVVCU CPF OGTQXKPIKCP FGPCTKK HTQO &QODWTI CPF 9GUVGPUEJQWYGP PQ E 9KVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH VJG NCUV CNN URGEKOGPU YGTG HQWPF KP VJG #NUCEG

191


564#5$174) +P $% VJG ECUVNG #TIGPVQTCVG YCU DWKNV HTQO YJGTG KP 4QOCP VKOGU VJG GPVKTG TGIKQP CNQPI VJG 4JKPG YCU RTQXKFGF HQT 'URGEKCNN[ VJG #NCOCPPK RTQXGF C ITGCV FGCN QH VTQWDNG 6JG HKTUV %JTKUVKCP EJCRVGT FCVGU HTQO +P VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ $KUJQR #TDQICUV TGVCKPGF 4QOCP EWUVQO UCHGIWCTFKPI EQPVKPWKV[ +P )TGIQT[ QH 6QWTUʼn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

1661 +

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV N /#)085 1661 TGVTQITCFG 4 %TQUU 5%# /#4+#. &CPP ' . IT. 44 %NGCT CPF UJCTR UVTWEM URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

1661 + CPF $+5*12 7&1

&GPKGT. # $WUV N 1661 4' : 2# %+(+%8 4 %JWTEJ #4)' 06 0#8161 . &CPP ' . -NWIG IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO (TCPMHWTVGT /ÒP\JCPFNWPI 8GKN PQ *GTG KU VJG EJCTCEVGTKUVKE EJWTEJ QH 5VTCUDQWTI HQT VJG HKTUV VKOG XKUKDNG 6JG GORGTQT JCU PQ ETQYP DWV VJG TQOCP FKCFGO

1661 +++ CPF $+5*12 9+&'41.&

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF JGCF T 16 61 +/2'4 4 %JWTEJ 8 8+&'41. 2+5. &CPP C ' . IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 6JG EJWTEJ QP VJG TGXGTUG KU UJCRGF OQUV WPWUWCNN[

192


*'+04+%* ++

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF JGCF T *'+04% 4 #4)'0 6+0# ETQUU UJCRGF YKVJ QPG ETQUU KP VJG UV CPF PF CPF QPG UVCT KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU. &CPP C ' . -NWIG IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU (TQO 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI *'+04+%85 +/2 4#& TGVTQITCFG 4 #4)'0 6+0# ETQUU UJCRGF YKVJ QPG VQYGT KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP ' . -NWIG IT. 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ

-104#& ++

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV N %*10 4 #&85 +24 4 #4)'0 6+0# ETQUU UJCRGF YKVJ QPG QTPC OGPVGF ETQUU KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU CPF VJTGG NKPGU GPFKPI KP RGNNGV KP VJG TF CPF VJ CPINGU &CPP ' . -NWIG IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU (TQO PQY QP QPN[ VJG PCOG QH VJG DKUJQR KU OGPVKQPGF QP VJG EQKPU

9'40'4 QH *#$5$74)

&GPKGT. # %TQYP 8+%'. +08 ':+ 4 #4)'0 6+0# ETQUU UJCRGF YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP ' . -NWIG IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 6JKU EQKP YCU NKUVGF CHVGT VJG KORGTKCN EQKP QH %QPTCF ++ HQT VJTGG TGCUQPU KV KU VJG HKTUV EQKP VJCV OGPVKQPU VJG PCOG QH VJG DKUJQR GZENWUKXGN[ KVU V[RG OCVEJGU VJCV QH VJG PGZV EQKP PQ DGVVGT VJG VGZV KU VJG UCOG CPF VJG VTGPF QH VJG YGKIJV KU UKOKNCT

193


*'4+/#0

&GPKGT. # %TQYP *'4'/#)85 ' 4 #4)'0 6+0# ETQUU UJCRGF YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP ' . -NWIG . IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP +P VJG NQYGT TKIJV SWCTVGT VJG FGOK EKTENG QH RGNNGVU KU RCTVN[ TGRNCEGF YKVJ C ETQUU LWUV CU VJG UVCT 6JG YGKIJV KU C NKVVNG NQYGT VJCP VJCV QH PQ 6JKU EQKP KU OGPVKQPGF PQYJGTG KP NKVGTCVWTG #HVGT OKPVKPI QP VJG DCUKU QH EQOOQP FGPCTKK VJGTG YQWNFPʼnV DG CP[ OKPVKPI WPVKN VJG *QJGPUVCWHGP GTC #RCTV HTQO C HGY GZEGRVKQPU VJGUG CTG CNN EQKPU DGCTKPI PQ UETKRV YJCVUQGXGT TGPFGTKPI C VGORQTCN QT URCVKCN CVVTKDWVKQP KORQUUKDNG VJG UCOG KU QDUGTXGF YKVJ VJG UEGCVVCU UCXG HQT VJG VKOG URCP YJKEJ KU OWEJ UJQTVGT VJCP KV KU JGTG 6JG HKTUV CVVGORV CV ENCUUKH[KPI VJGUG CPQP[OQWU EQKPU YCU 0GUUGNʼnU CPF VJGTG KP HCEV JCU DGGP PQ CVVGORV UKPEG 0GUUGN CNYC[U JCF QPG EGTVCKP CURGEV RTGXCKN YJKEJ TCKUGU SWGUVKQPU CU VQ VJG CEEWTCE[ QH JKU OGVJQFU 7PFGTPGCVJ CP CVVGORV KU OCFG VQ ENCUUKH[ VJGUG EQKPU HTQO C FKHHGTGPV RQKPV QH XKGY QP VJG DCUKU QH VJG CXCKNCDNG URGEKOGPU (KTUV FKUVKPEVKQPU YGTG OCFG KP VJG VJTGG FKHHGTGPV RJCUGU VJG HKTUV VJG *QJGPUVCWHGP RGTKQF CPF DGHQTG VJG UGEQPF QPG CHVGT VJKU RGTKQF CPF HKPCNN[ VJG VJKTF OCTMKPI VJG VTCPUKVKQP VQ OWPKEKRCN OKPV +P RJCUG CPQVJGT UWDFKXKUKQP KPVQ VJTGG

ITQWRU YCU OCFG CU KP RJCUG CNKMG

UV RJCUG

C 6[RG YKVJ VJG DKUJQR YGCTKPI C TQWPF OKVTG 6JG TGXGTUG EQPUKUVU QH VYQ HKIWTGU YKVJ C ETQUKGT DGVYGGP VJGO

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 6YQ HKIWTGU JQNFKPI ETQUU. ' . 0 IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG HKIWTGU QP VJG TGXGTUG CTG KPXGTVGF KFGPVKECNU +P NKVGTCVWTG VJKU V[RG KU PQV OGPVKQPGF CNVJQWIJ VJGTG KU C RKEVWTG KP )TKGTUQP %QKPU QH VJG /KFFNG #IGU HKI )TKGTUQP YTKVGU EQKPU YKVJ C TCKUGF GFIG CTG EJCTCEVGTKUVKE QH #NUCEG EQKPCIG KP VJG VJ CPF VJ EGPVWT[ # URGEKOGP YCU RWDNKUJGF KP $N·VVGT HÒT /ÒP\HTGWPFG :8 R (GY URGEKOGPU MPQYP

2HGPPKI. # $WV QH VJG DKUJQR N CPIGN IKXKPI JKO C ETQUKGT 5 CPF UVCT CDQXG 4 (KIWTG UKVVKPI N VYQ UVCPFKPI HKIWTGU T JQNFKPI ETQUKGT. ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG VQ WPEKTEWNCVGF -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ #EEQTFKPI VQ 0GUUGN VJKU EQKP KU QH VJG QNFGUV V[RG 6JG RKEVWTG YKVJ 0GUUGN PQ UJQYU PQ UVCT CPF PQ 5 6JG TGXGTUG KU RTKOKVKXGN[ EWV 6JG YGKIJV QH VJKU EQKP KU EQPUKFGTCDN[ NQYGT VJCP VJCV QH PQ

D 6[RG YKVJ C DCTG JGCFGF DKUJQR 6JG TGXGTUG UJQYU C EJWTEJ # DCTG JGCFGF HKIWTG PQT OCNN[ KPFKECVGU CP CDDQV PGXGTVJGNGUU C DKUJQR KU OGCPV JGTG CNUQ CRRGCTU QP EQKPU QH %Q NQIPG HQT KPUVCPEG HQT PQ ENGCTN[ TGCFU 'RKUEQRWU

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM '2+5%1285 4 %JWTEJ #4)'06+0#. ' . 0 IT. 4 /CIPKHKEGPV YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG UOCNN EJWTEJ KU EJCTCEVGTKUVKECNN[ UJCRGF CU VJG 5VTCUDQWTI EJWTEJ UGG PQ 0GUUGN OGPVKQPU CP CPCNQIWG URGEKOGP YKVJ +/2'4#614 UEGRVTG CPF INQDWU ETWEKIGT KPUVGCF QH ETQUKGT CPF DQQM UCOG TGXGTUG

194


2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ DNGUUKPI T JCPF CPF ETQUKGT 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VJTGG VQYGTU. ' . EH 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

/Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG EJCTCEVGTKUVKE UOCNN EJWTEJ KU UVKNN RTGUGPV DWV CU RCTV QH C ITGCVGT GFKHKEG VJKU QEEWTU KP C UKORNKHKGF HQTO QP NCVGT EQKPU *GTG VQQ VJG YGKIJV KU EQPUKFGTCDN[ NQYGT VJCP PQ

E 6[RG YKVJ DKUJQR YGCTKPI OKVTG CPF UQOGVKOGU URNGPFKF GRKUEQRCN XGUVOGPV 1P VJG TG XGTUG C EJWTEJ QT CP CPIGNKE HKIWTG (TQO VJKU RQKPV QP VJG YGKIJV FGETGCUGU HTQO C NKVVNG QXGT IT VQ WPFGT IT TF RJCUG

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR T YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 4 %JWTEJ *'+04+%85. ' . 0 IT. 2CVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ # UKORNKHKGF HQTO QH VJG EJWTEJ QH PQ &WG VQ VJG JKIJ HTGSWGPEG YGNN RTGUGTXGF KP VJG $CTDCTQUUC JQCTF VJKU EQKP OC[ PQY DG WNVKOCVKXGN[ CVVTKDWVGF VQ DKUJQR *GPT[ + QH *CUGPDWTI 1P VJKU V[RG VJG GRKUEQRCN XGUVOGPV KU PQV CNYC[U UKOKNCTN[ UJCRGF UGG .CP\ #WEVKQP PQU $CT DCTQUUC JQCTF

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ YJGGN HKXG URQMGU KP VJG RQTVCN. ' . 0 IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GNOQPVG $TWUUGN +P 0GUUGN YTQVG EQKPU YKVJ VJG HKXG URQMGF YJGGN UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ /QNUJGKO DGECWUG VJKU YJGGN UVKNN HGCVWTGU KP VJG EKV[ʼnU EQCV QH CTOU 6JG OKPV YCU QRGTCVKXG QPN[ DTKGHN[ CPF CNN EQKPU CTG QH VJG UCOG V[RG +P JQYGXGT 9KGNCPFV YTQVG KP (WPF CNGOCPPKUEJGT /Ã’P\GP CWU /CTDCEJ KO 'NUCUU QP PQ KFGPVKECN VQ VJKU EQKP /Ã’P\JGTT \W 5VTC­DWTI KUV FGT 5VTC­DWTIGT $KUEJQH FQEJ NKGIGP /Ã’P\RT·IWPI WPF 9GEJUGNOQPQRQN KP FGP *·PFGP FGT O·EJVKIGP WPF \CJNTGKEJGP *CWUIGPQUUGPUEJCHVGP &CU 4CF YKTF OGKUV CWH /QNUJGKO DG\QIGP LGFQEJ \W 7PTGEJV FGPP GU KUV MGKP /Ã’JNTCF C TQ[CN EQKP YKVJ VJG UCOG TGXGTUG YCU UVTWEM WPFGT (TGFGTKEM ++ UGG (F /CTDCEJ PQ

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 4 #PIGN N JQNFKPI C ETQUU YJKEJ UVCPFU QP EWR. ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\ICNGTKG /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG QDXGTUG YKVJ VJG DKUJQR JKIJN[ TGUGODNGU VJCV QH PQ VJG YGKIJV VQQ KU RTCEVKECNN[ VJG UCOG (KPF 6TCGPJGKO 5 E

195


PF RJCUG 6JG EQKPU PQY VCMG QP C OWEJ UKORNGT EJCTCEVGT 6JG HKIWTG QH VJG DKUJQR KU GNQPICVGF LWUV CU JKU OKVTG 6JG EJWTEJ KU UKORNKHKGF VQ C HGY VTKCPINGU YKVJ C ETQUU QP VQR C 5OCNN EJWTEJ QP VJG TGXGTUG

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N YKVJ UVCHH CPF ETQUKGT 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ ETQUUGU. ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV

2HGPPKI. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR N 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU DGVYGGP UVCTU QP VQR. ' . 0 IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

9KPMGN KP 5VTCCVUDWTI 0GUUGN ENCUUKHKGU VJKU WPFGT 5VTCUDQWTI KP URKVG QH VJG VYQ UVCTU QP VJG TGXGTUG 0GUUGN CVVTKDWVGU VQ 5GN\ YJGP C UVCT KU FKURNC[GF DGJKPF VJG DKUJQR 0 PQ UVCT HGCVWTGU JGTG

D 1P VJG TGXGTUG C NCOD YKVJ ETQUKGT

.COORHGPPKI. # .COD N YKVJ UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU 4 $WUV N YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF. ' . EH 0 IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ +P NKVGTCVWTG VJGTG KU CNYC[U OGPVKQP QH NCOD DWV VJKU ETGCVWTG JCU C NQPI VCKN

E 5JQYKPI CP GCING QP VJG TGXGTUG

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV YKVJ QTD CPF NKU VQRRGF UEGRVTG 4 'CING N . ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ +P EQPVGORQTCT[ NKVGTCVWTG VJKU EQKP KU CVVTKDWVGF VQ 1HHGPDWTI LWUV CU VJG PGZV PWODGT

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF HKIWTG N YKVJ QTD %TQUU DGJKPF JKO 4 'CING N UVCT QXGT T YKPI. ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI

196

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 4 'CING N . ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

6WTSWCV /QPVRGNNKGT +P C UGPUG VJG PQU CPF CTG GCEJ QVJGTʼnU EQWPVGTRCTVU UCOG TGXGTUG CPF TGUR C UGEWNCT CPF C ENGTKECN QD XGTUG 5GG PQVG YKVJ PQ


TF RJCUG 1PG UKFGF RGPPKGU VTCPUKVKQP VQ OWPKEKRCN EQKPU

1PG UKFGF 2GPP[. # #PIGN N JQNFKPI C ETQUU. ' . 0 R # IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JKU UVCVWG KU C NCVG KOKVCVKQP QH VJG CPIGN CPF VJG ETQUU QP VJG EJCNKEG 5GG V[RG # KP 0GUUGN KP (TCPMHWTVGT /ร P\\GKVWPI R

564#5$174) %+6; 5VTCUDQWTI CESWKTGF EKV[ TKIJVU KP VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF DGECOG C HTGG EKV[ KP )TCFWCNN[ GRKUEQRCN KPHNWGPEG YCPGF CPF RQYGT UJKHVGF VQYCTFU VJG EKVK\GPU 6JKU YCU TGKPHQTEGF YJGP VJG DKUJQRU UNKF KPVQ HKPCPEKCN FKHHKEWNV[ 0GKVJGT $KUJQR (TGFGTKEM QH $NCPM GPJGKO PQT 9KNNKCO QH &KGUV YGTG CDNG VQ EJCPIG VJG EQWTUG QH VJGUG FGXGNQR OGPVU +V YQWNF VCMG WPVKN CTQWPF DGXQTG HKPCPEGU YGTG UQWPF CICKP

1PG UKFGF 2GPP[. # .KU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU. ' . 0 R + IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

1PG UKFGF 2GPP[. # %KV[ CTOU QXGT NKU. ' . IT.

8GT[ HKPG

&QODTQYUMK /ร PUVGT

)TQU. # .KU KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ TQUGU KP VJG CPINGU )415585 รฐ #4)'06+0'05 4 Q 64# Q Q 2#: Q Q *1+$85 Q CTQWPF ETQUU ).14+# +0 ':%'.5 &1 '6 +0. ' . IT. 8GT[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH 5VWVVICTV #WEVKQP PQ

ITQU. # .KU KP FQWDNGF SWCVTGHQKN ).14+# +0 ':%%+5&1 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# #4) '06. ' . XCT IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

197


*#)7'0#7 4GIKQP KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CTQWPF VJG ECUVNG QH *WIJ QH 'PUKUJGKO %QWPV QH VJG 0QTFICW (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC JCF CP KORQTVCPV RCNCVKPG DWKNV KP *CIWGPCW +P *CIWGPCW CE SWKTGF EKV[ TKIJVU +P CPF FKGVU YGTG JGNF VJGTG +P -KPI 4KEJCTF QH %QTP YCNN GNGXCVGF KV VQ %KV[ QH VJG 'ORKTG %JCTCEVGTKUVKE QH *CIWGPCW EQKPU KU VJG HKXG NGCXGF TQUG EQCV QH CTOU QH VJG EKV[ *CIWGPCW

(4+'&4+%* ++

2HGPPKI. # 4QUG *<#8.0++ 4 $WKNFKPI YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU CPF VYQ RQTVCNU ITGCV UVCT DGVYGGP VJG VQYGTU. ' . 0 IT. 4 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI 6JKU PQ CPF VJG PQU CPF GOGTIGF KP C UKPING JQCTF KP VJG 7RRGT 4JKPG $CUKP 6JG OCKP RCTV QH VJKU JQCTF HQWPF KVU YC[ VQ VJG .CPFGUOWUGWO QH -CTNUTWJG

2HGPPKI. # 4QUG %08#%0% 4 'CING T 8%+0*4%+0. ' . 0 IT. 4 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

2HGPPKI. # (N[KPI DKTF N NQQMKPI CV HQNNQYKPI DKTF QXGT TQUG 4 %CUVNG YKVJ VQYGTU. ' . 0 IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ

2HGPPKI. # +PUGEV ! 4 $QCT N QXGT JKO JWPVGT YKVJ CZG. ' . 0 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CPF FQWDNG UVTWEM QP VJG QDXGTUG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ 6JG FTCYP URGEKOGP KP 0GUUGN 0 UJQYU CP QDXGTUG YKVJ VJG YGNN MPQYP *CIWGPCW TQUG +P URKVG QH VJG HCEV VJCV VJG EQKP CV JCPF YCU FQWDNG UVTWEM KV ECPʼnV RQUUKDN[ FGRKEV C TQUG +V OQTG TGUGODNGU C YKPIGF KPUGEV C OQVKH VJCV KU PGXGT QDUGTXGF KP *CIWGPCW EQKPCIG 6JG DQCT JWPV KU V[RKECN HQT *CIWGPCW 6JG TGIKQP KU EQXGTGF KP HQTGUVU CPF JWPVKPI WUGF VQ DG GZVGPUKXGN[ GPICIGF KP 6JCV VJG JWPVGT KU YKGNFKPI CP CZG KU TCVJGT RGEWNKCT 1H VJG V[RG KP 0GUUGN VYQ URGEKOGPU YGTG NQECVGF KP &QPCWGUEJKPIGP CPF VJG OWUGWO QH -CTNUTWJG 6JKU RKGEG KU CU HCT CU + MPQY WPMPQYP

198


#$$'; #.6&14( 6JG $GPGFKEVKPG #DDG[ #NVFQTH RCTV QH VJG 5VTCUDQWTI FKQEGUG YCU HQWPFGF D[ 1VVQ + KP

(4+'&4+%* +

2HGPPKI. # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UVCPFCTF T TQUGVVG N 4 $WKNFKPI YKVJ VQYGTU CPF UKEMNG QP VQR. ' . 0 IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

.CP\ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO $CTDCTQUUC JQCTF EH 5IN (Ã’TUVGPDGTI C /GPVKQPGF KP %CV .CP\ 1D FKGUG 4GKVGTRHGPPKIG MCKUGTNKEJG 2T·IWPIGP UKPF MCPP CWEJ FWTEJ FKGUGP (WPF PKEJV GPVUEJKGFGP YGTFGP &KG 8GTDGTIWPIU\GKV YKFGTNGIV %CJPʼnU #TIWOGPVG HÃ’T FKG 2T·IWPI KP 5EJNGVVUVCFV UQFCUU YQJN PWT #NVFQTH KP (TCIG MQOOV %H CNUQ 0

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

&GPKGT. # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU $4 65 4 $WUV QH VJG 5CKPV YKVJ PKODWU QPG JCPF QP VJG DTGCUV CPF VJG QVJGT JQNFKPI C NKU VQRRGF UEGRVTG. ' . 0 IT. 'FIG EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG -WTRH·N\KUEJG /Ã’P\JCPFNWPI /CPPJGKO (TQO -WTRH·N\KUEJG /Ã’P\JCPFNWPI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z )CGVVGPU EQNNGEVKQP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO VJG JQCTF $GVVGPJCWUGP

199


5%#0&+0#8+# /GFKGXCN &GPOCTM 5YGFGP CPF 0QTYC[ 5ECPFKPCXKC UJCTGF C PWODGT QH EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU #NN VJTGG ECOG KPVQ DGKPI CTQWPF VJG [GCT %JTKUVKCPKUCVKQP OGV YKVJ HKGTEG QRRQUKVKQP KP VJGUG EQWPVTKGU 0QDKNKV[ RNC[GF CP KORQTVCPV TQNG 6JGKT TQ[CN HCOKNKGU YGTG TGNCVGF OQUV KP VTKECVGN[ /CKPN[ FWG VQ VJKU NCUV CURGEV VJG GPFGCXQWTU VQ WPKVG VJG VJTGG EQWPVTKGU QT EQP UQNKFCVG CP KPFKXKFWCN KPFGRGPFGPEG YQWNFPʼn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ʼn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ʼnU EQPXGTUKQP VQ %JTKUVKCPKV[ YCU RTGUWOCDN[ DTQWIJV CDQWV D[ RTGUUWTG HTQO VJG CTEJ DKUJQRTKE *CODWTI $TGOGP WPFGT YJKEJ &GPOCTM HGNN *CTCNF HQWPFGF C PWODGT QH RNCEGU NKMG 4QUMKNFG CPF .WPF VJG NCVVGT URGEKHKECNN[ CU CP GEENGUKCUVKECN EGPVTG *CTCNF CRRQKPVGF VJG DKUJQRU DWV VJG TKIJV QH QTFKPCVKQP YCU TGUGTXGF HQT VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH *CODWTI $TGOGP *CTCNFʼnU UQP 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF VQQM WR QNF 8KMKPI VTCFKVKQP CPF UCKNGF HQT 'PINCPF YJGTG JG YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF MKPI QH 'PINCPF KP *G KPVTQFWEGF VJG HKTUV RGPP[ KP &GPOCTM EQR[KPI CP 'PINKUJ EQKP C %TWZ V[RG QH #GVJGNTGF ++ +V KPFKECVGU PQ URGEKHKE OKPV DWV &GPOCTM KP IGPGTCN QP VJG QDXGTUG YG HKPF <#'0 4': #& &'0'4 CPF QP VJG TGXGTUG )1&2+0' / #0 &0'4 5YGFGPʼnU HKTUV EQKP QH 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPIʼn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ʼnU KU UJTQWFGF KP FCTMPGUU # HGY PCOGU CTG MPQYP QH &CPKUJ MKPIU CU )ÌVVTKMU UWEEGGFGF D[ *QTKM + CPF *QTKM ++ 1VJGT VJCP VJGUG VJG (WNFC #PPCNU OGPVKQP 5KIKHTGF CPF *CNXFCP YJQ UKIPGF C VTGCV[ YKVJ VJG 'CUV (TCPMU RTQVGEVKPI VJGKT ETQUU DQTFGT VTCFG (QT VJG ENCUUKHKECVKQP QH VJG EQKPU HTQO VJKU RGTKQF /CNOGTʼnU YCU WUGF )TQWR %CTQNWU KOKVCVKQP ++ %G++ &QTGUVCF V[RG ++ &++ )TQWR &QTGUVCF 6[RG +++ &+++ )TQWR $CICT -QTU

200


(QT VJKU ENCUUKHKECVKQP UGG CNUQ ,CPMWJP *CKVCDW GKP *CPFGNURNCV\ FGT 9KMKPIGT\GKV 0GWOÒPUVGT R ,CPMWJP RNCEGU ITQWR CTQWPF YKVJ C OKPV UQOGYJGTG KP 0QTVJYGUVGTP )GTOCP[ &GPOCTM KP VJKU RGTKQF NC[ YKVJKP VJG UQXGTGKIP VGTTKVQT[ QH )GTOCP[ )TQWR ,CPMWJP RCTVN[ CVVTKDWVGU VQ 5YGFGP OKPV *CKVJCDW CPF VJG RGTKQF DGVYGGP CPF HQT VJG QVJGT RCTV VQ )GTOCP[ UQXGTGKIP VGTTKVQT[ YKVJ VJG OKPV *CKVJCDW CPF C RGTKQF DGVYGGP 6JG FTCYKPIU KP ,CPMWJP CTG NCTIGN[ UKORNKHKGF EQORCTGF VQ VJQUG QH /CNOGT (QT VJKU ITQWR /CNOGTʼnU QTFGT KU CFJGTGF VQ )TQWR YKVJ C RGTKQF DGVYGGP ,CPMWJP CVVTKDWVGU VQ DQVJ &GPOCTM CPF )GTOCP[ CU VJG UQXGTGKIP VGTTKVQT[ $GPGCVJ ,CPMWJPʼnU ENCUUKHKECVKQP KU OCKPVCKPGF YKVJ TGHGTGPEG VQ /CNOGT #4170& )TQWR

&GPKGT *CKVJCDW. # % DGPGCVJ / QXGT VYQ YGFIGU FKXKFGF D[ RGNNGVU VTKCPING CPF TQUGVVG T 4 6 + + 6 WPFGT VYQ DQYU YKVJ TKPI DGVYGGP VJGO DGNQY HTCPEKUEC. ,CPMWJP ITQWR /CNOGT 2N IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG HKTUV EQKP QH &GPOCTM VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 6JG CVVTKDWVKQP VQ *CKVJCDW KU HTQO /CNOGT

*#4#.& $.#6#0& 1H *CTCNF $NWGVQQVJ NKVVNG KU MPQYP VJG QPN[ GZKUVKPI FQEWOGPVU QVJGT VJCP VJG OGPVKQPGF TWPG UVQPG CTG VJG GPVJWUKCUVKE YTKVKPIU QP *CTCNF D[ #FCO QH $TGOGP *KU TGKIP OQUV RTQDC DN[ EQOOGPEGF KP CPF CEEQTFKPI VQ #FCO QH $TGOGP JG FKGF QP #NN 5CKPVU *KU UQP YCU 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF )TQWR

.KIJV &GPKGT *CKVJCDW. # 6 + + 6 WPFGT YKPIU RGNNGV CDQXG HTCPEKUEC DGNQY 4 6JTGG ETQUUGU WPFGT DQY QXGT VYQ VTKCPINGU CPF DGVYGGP VYQ DQYU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPFU. ,CPMWJP XCT /CNOGT 2N ! IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 6KGVLGP *CODWTI #WEVKQP PQ 5IN $TWWPU 6H # &QTGUVCF V[RG +++ &+++ % D &CVG 6JG TGXGTUG UJQYU VJG KOCIG YJKEJ KU EQORGNVGF KP ITQWR VJG DQY

201


.KIJV &GPKGT *CKVJCDW. # 6 + + 6 WPFGT YKPIU RGNNGV KP VJG OKFFNG HTCPEKUEC DGNQY 4 6JTGG ETQUUGU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU WPFGT DQY QXGT VYQ VTKCPINGU CPF DGVYGGP VYQ DQYU. ,CPMWJP XCT /CNOGT 2N ! IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ # &QTGUVCF V[RG +++ &+++ % D &CVG

.KIJV &GPKGT *CKVJCDW. # 6 + + 6 WPFGT YKPIU YKVJ RGNNGVU VJTGG RGNNGVU CPF HTCPEKUEC DGNQY 4 6JTGG ETQUUGU WPFGT DQY YKVJ XGTVKECN NKPG. ,CPMWJP XCT /CNOGT 2N IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG VQ WPEKTEWNCVGF /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ # &QTGUVCF V[RG +++ &+++ % D &CVG

)TQWR

.KIJV &GPKGT ,GNNKPI. # $QY WPFGT YKPIU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG DGVYGGP VTKCPINGU QPG ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU CDQXG CPF DGNQY 4 %TQUU ETQUUNGV. ,CPMWJP C /CNOGT 2N IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN # # C 4 # C &CVG VJG NCUV [GCTU QH VJG TGKIP QH *CTCNF

.KIJV &GPKGT ,GNNKPI. # $QY WPFGT VYQ YKPIU 4 %TQUU ETQUUNGV YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. ,CPMWJP E /CNOGT 2N IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP # # F # C &CVG VJG NCUV [GCTU QH VJG TGKIP QH *CTCNF *QPQWTKPI CP QNF JGCVJGP VTCFKVKQP 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF QRRQUGF JKU HCVJGT *CTCNF $NWGVQQVJ 6JG NCVVGT HNGF VQ ,WOPG CPF FKGF VJGTG KP 5YG[P HQWIJV VJG 0QTYGIKCPU CPF VJG 'PINKUJ &CPGIGNF +P JG EQPSWGTGF 'PINCPF # EQPSWGUV VJCV YQWNF DG EQPVKPWGF D[ JKU UQP %CPWV *G FKGF KP

202


%076

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ʼnU UYC[ YCU OCKPN[ DCUGF QP JKU RGTUQPCNKV[ 9JGP JG FKGF KP 0QTYC[ NQQUGPGF KVUGNH CPF CEJKGXGF KPFGRGPFGPEG WPFGT /CIPWU %PWVʼnU UQP *CTVJCEPWV YCU PQV CEMPQYN GFIGF KP 'PINCPF GKVJGT 6JG OKPV .WPF TGSWKTGU C URGEKHKE GZRNCPCVKQP RCTVKEWNCTN[ DGECWUG VJG KPFKECVKQP QH .QPFQP QP 'PINKUJ EQKPU KU VJG UCOG 9JCV GXGP OQTG EQORNKECVGU FGVGTOKPKPI YJGVJGT C EQKP KU 'PINKUJ QT &CPKUJ KU VJCV OCP[ &CPKUJ EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM D[ 'PINKUJ OQPG[GTU KP VJQUG ECUGU VJG PCOG QH VJG OQPG[GT PQTOCNN[ KU VJG MG[ VQ CVVTKDWVKQP .WPF NKGU KP 5EJQPGP VJG UQWVJGTPOQUV RCTV QH RTGUGPV FC[ 5YGFGP +P GCTN[ OGFKGXCN VKOGU CPF NQPI CHVGTYCTFU KV YCU RCTV QH &GPOCTM .WPF YCU HQWPFGF CTQWPF +V NC[ CV C ETQUU TQCFU QH PQTVJ UQWVJ CPF GCUV YGUV TQCFU CPF CNVJQWIJ VJG NQECVKQP YCU KFGCN HQT VTCFG KV KU TCVJGT EQPHQWPFKPI VJCV YJGP VJG JGCTV QH MKPIFQO RWNUGF KP ,GNNKPI C RNCEG QH UWEJ XCNWG VQ VJG PCVKQP YCU HQWPFGF KP VJG DCEMYQQFU %JTKUVKCPKV[ YCU DTQWIJV VQ 5EJQPGP CPF VJGTGHQTG KP .WPF D[ $KUJQR )QVGDCNF KP 5YG[P (QTMDGCTFʼnU VKOG HQNNQYGF D[ $KUJQR $GTPJCTF WPFGT %PWV $QVJ DKUJQRU ECOG HTQO 'PINCPF +P .WPF DGECOG C FKQEGUG KP CP CTEJDKUJQRTKE 5XGP 'UVTKFUQP DWKNV VJG HKTUV 5V .CYTGPEG %JWTEJ KP .WPF 6JG VJ EGPVWT[ JCF CNTGCF[ UGGP C UJQTV NKXGF 5YGFKUJ RQUUGUUKQP QH 5EJQPGP DWV KV YQWNFPʼnV DG WPVKN VJCV KV FGHKPKVKXGN[ RCUUGF VQ 5YGFKUJ JCPFU

&GPKGT .WPF. # $WUV QH #GVJGNTGF ++ QH 'PINCPF N %086 4': #0).14/ 4 %TQUU 6*14'. / 1 .80&. *DI IT. 4 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO (TQO 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU KU CP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG NCUV UOCNN ETQUU V[RG QH #GVJGNTGF ++ UVTWEM KP .WPF YCU FKTGEVN[ WUGF CU OKPV 0QTVJ 6JKU YCU CNNGIGFN[ UVTWEM FWTKPI VJG ECORCKIPU CICKPUV #GVJGNTGF ++ KP DWV KU EGTVCKPN[ C FCPKUJ KUUWG RTQDCDN[ UVTWEM CHVGT

&GPKGT .WPF. # 5PCMG 4 (QWT ETGUEGPVU YKVJ RGNNGVU RGNNGVU KP VJG EGPVTG. *DI IT. 4 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP .GIGPFU QP QD CPF TGXGTUG CTG PQV TGCFCDNG CNVJQWIJ VJG NGVVGTU CTG RCTVN[ ENGCT

203


&GPKGT 8KDQTI. # *CPF UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJTGG ETQUUGU 1+0+%(+618++(/10 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQUU KP GCEJ CPING 1%+0%10+%+8/10. *DI IT. 4 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU JCPF KU CNUQ MPQYP HTQO &GXGPVGT COQPI QVJGT RNCEGU UVTWEM WPFGT 'ORGTQT *GPT[ ++ CNVJQWIJ VJCV JCU 4': CTQWPF VJG JCPF

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

&GPKGT .WPF. # $WUV N *#46*'%086 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU QP VYQ UVTKRGU KP GCEJ CPING 16*6* '0% 410 .8&. *DI IT. %NGCT CPF UJCTR URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP /KPVOCUVGT 1VJGPECT ! 5GG HQQVPQVG CHVGT 0QTVJ # XCTKGV[ QH PQ YKVJQWV VJG UEGRVTG KU C FCPKUJ KUUWG QH .WPF OKPV

&GPKGT 1TDCGM ! . # $CTDCTK\GF DWUV HCEKPI .+%818+%++1+++ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG JQQH KTQP KP GCEJ CPING 4+1%8+++1+%+++1+++. *DI EH IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ $TWWP *CTF VQ TGEQIPKUG VJKU EQKP KP *DI UKPEG VJCV UJQYU C HCEG VWTPGF NGHV

204


#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # $CTDCTK\GF JGCF T YKVJ UVCHH 4 &QWDNG DCPFGF ETQUU YKVJ VTGHQKNU KP VJG CPINGU. *DI IT. 4 /KPQT URNKV KP VJG HNCP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 1DXGTUG 5%$+ %QR XIN 4GXGTUG 5%$+ %QR XIN +P VJG UCOG CWEVKQP CP CPCNQIWG RKGEG QEEWTGF UCOG FKG VJCV YGKIJGF YJKEJ KPFKECVGU CP QTKIKP DGHQTG 6TGHQKN SWCFTKNCVGTCN V[RG QH 'FYCTF VJG %QPHGUUQT UKORNGT HQTO YKVJ *CTVJCMPWF CTO CPF UEGRVTG V[RG

/#)075 FGP )1&' +P /CIPWU TGVWTPGF HTQO 0QXIQTQF YJGTG JG YCU TCKUGF CPF GFWECVGF CV VJG EQWTV QH ,CTQUNCX + QH -KGX CPF DGECOG MKPI QH 0QTYC[ +P JG UKIPGF C VTGCV[ YKVJ *CTVJCECPWV UVKRWNCVKPI VJCV VJG GCTNKGT EJKNFNGUU FGOKUG QH QPG QH DQVJ YQWNF DGSWGCVJ VJG QVJGT YKVJ VJG TGURGEVKXG MKPIFQO 6JWU CV VJG FGCVJ QH *CTVJCEPWV KP /CIPWU YCU RTQENCKOGF MKPI QH &GPOCTM KP 8KDQTI VQ VJG CDUQNWVG KP FKIPCVKQP QH %PWVʼnU ITCPFUQP 5YG[P 'UVTKFUQP +P /CIPWU JCF VQ UJCTG RQYGT KP 0QTYC[ YKVJ JKU WPENG *CTCNF 5KIWTFUUQP JQYGXGT KP &GPOCTM JG TGOCKPGF VJG UQNG TWNGT WPVKN JKU FGCVJ KP

&GPKGT .WPF #NHYCTF. # $WUV YKVJ JGNOGV N /#*05 4': 4 3WCVTGHQKN QH -PWF 'PINCPF QP ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU #.(2#4& Q .8&. *DI IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ *DI #WMV $TWWP

&GPKGT .WPF. # .COD N YKVJ UVCHH GPFKPI KP ETQUU ++8&1&+++6# 4 &QWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU 61 ++. 8++ 1.8. *DI IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP PKEG RCVKPC 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

5IN *CWDGTI XCT 5IN $TWWP XCT 5IN *GFG

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # 1%+1'0+ DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU CDQXG CPF DGNQY VTKCPING YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR CPF YKVJKP 1.+ %+1++ 1.1+ '1+1 4 6TKSWGVTC YKVJ C ETQUU KP QPG CPING : &+1++8 8:+10'1 :+10'1 . *DI EH IT. 4 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ 6JKU XCTKCPV KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP *CWDGTI 1P *DI KU C HCEG UJQYP YJKEJ ECPPQV DG UGGP QP VJKU URGEKOGP

205


$#66.' 2'4+1&

#EEQTFKPI VQ VJG EJTQPKENGU QH #FCO QH $TGOGP 5YG[P URGPV [GCTU KP 5YGFGP HTQO YJGTG JG YCIGF YCT QP VJG &CPKUJ 0QTYGIKCP MKPI /CIPWU FGP )QFG [GV 5YG[P JCF VQ YCKV HQT VJG MKPI VQ FKG DGHQTG JG EQWNF CV NCUV DGEQOG MKPI QH &GPOCTM

&GPKGT .WPF. # *GCF N YKVJ ETQUU CPF TKPI KP HTQPV QH KV ++%8+ +22&%% 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU CPF VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ ETGUEGPVU KP VJG CPINGU 58 '4. %&1 +.8*. *DI IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QKNCPF -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z $GEMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'MU 2GFGTUGP %,$ /Z C *$) CWEVKQP .'$ EH $GEMGT % , 6JG EQKPCIGU QH *CTVJCMPWF CPF /CIPWU VJG )QQF CV .WPF E 5VWFKGU KP 0QTVJGTP %QKPCIGU QH VJG 'NGXGPVJ %GPVWT[ &GV MIN &CPUMG 8KF 5GN *KUV HKN 5MTKHVGT -DJ

206

59';0 '564+&5'0 *KU HCVJGT YCU 7NH ,CTN C OCP HTQO VJG TGVKPWG QH %PWV JKU OQVJGT 'UVTKF %PWVʼnU UKUVGT *G YCU YGFFGF VQ )WPJKNF CPF NCVGT VQ 6JQTC 6GPUKQP DGVYGGP %PWV CPF 5YG[P ECWUGF HCVJGT CPF UQP VQ UGGM TGHWIG YKVJ -KPI #PWPF ,CEQD QH 5YGFGP 7NH YCU OWTFGTGF RTGUWOC DN[ D[ %PWV 5YG[P KPETGCUGF JKU KPHNWGPEG KP &GPOCTM HTQO JKU 5EJQPGP RQUKVKQP CU VJG EQKPU JG UVTWEM UJQY #HVGT C SWKGV VGP [GCT TGKIP JG YCU FGHGCVGF D[ *CTCNF 5KIWTFUUQP QH 0QTYC[ KP 5VKNN RGCEG YCU TGCEJGF KP 5YG[P DTQWIJV CDQWV &GPOCTMʼn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


&GPKGT .WPF. # %JTKUV UVCPFKPI YKVJ TCKUGF JCPF /#)085 4': 4 (QWT USWCTGU ETQUU UJCRGF $15# 10 .80&+ 1. *DI IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ 'Z )CTTGVV ++ EQNNGEVKQP PQ 'Z ,9) 4C[OQPF 4GXGTUG 1 YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG 6JKU EQKP KU UVTWEM KP VJG PCOG QH JKU RTGFGEGUUQT /CIPWU

&GPKGT .WPF. # $[\CPVKPG HKIWTG UVCPFKPI 8+%&1 ++6 +8 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU 28 .(' 618 +&+1. *DI IT. 44 9GNN UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

6JG NGIGPF KU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG OGPVKQPGF KP *CWDGTI PQ

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG ! . # (KIWTG UVCPFKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF NQPI ETQUU N 5 KP VJG HKGNF 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU KP VYQ CPINGU : CPF 6 YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU. *DI IT. 4 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z *CWDGTI EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 'TPUV EQNNGEVKQP 6JG TGHGTGPEG YCU *DI UGG PQ DWV VJCV KU KORQUUKDNG 5KPEG CNN D[\CPVKPG KOKVCVKQPU YGTG UVTWEM KP .WPF + FQWDV YJGVJGT 4QUMKNFG KU EQTTGEV

&GPKGT .WPF. # %JTKUV UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF ++ 1+. 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU 0+& 10 8+++ . *DI IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'TPUV ++ EQNNGEVKQP *DI GMU *DI #

207


&GPKGT .WPF ! . # %JTKUV ! HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 1 %++( 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU QPG ETGUEGPV CPF QPG ETQUU KP VYQ CPINGU + +1% +.+ +%1. *DI IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ $TWWP 4GHGTGPEG YCU *DI DWV VJCV KU KORQUUKDNG CU VJG HKIWTG QP VJCV QDXGTUG JCU C PKODWU YJKEJ VJG HKIWTG QP VJG QD XGTUG QH VJG EQKP CV JCPF ENGCTN[ JCUPʼnV

&GPKGT .WPF. # #PIGN CPF MKPI UVCPFKPI CPF JQNFKPI UVCPFCTF 58'+0 4 .QPI FQWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU VYQ CPINGU YKVJ ETGUEGPV QPG QH VJGO CNUQ YKVJ RGNNGV 8+ ++8+ +.++.+ +++1. *DI IT. 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z )TCPVNG[ EQNNGEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # (QWT DQYU EQPPGEVGF D[ C USWCTG YKVJ TKPI KP VJG EGPVTG CPF HQWT VKOGU VJTGG RGN NGVU CTQWPF KV ++ *% 0% +0( 4 6YQ NKPGU YKVJ +ʼnU DGVYGGP VJGO KP VJG OKFFNG VYQ NKPGU GPFKPI KP ETGUEGPVU YKVJ TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG CDQXG CPF DGNQY C ETQUU DGVYGGP VYQ ETGUEGPVU YKVJ RGNNGV. *DI IT. /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP *CWDGTI OGPVKQPU * 14+ 0% 0& CU NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG

&GPKGT 5NCIGNUG. # &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ USWCTG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 4 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ HQWT TKPIU. *DI XCT IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

*#4#.& *'+0

&GPKGT .WPF. # (KIWTG UVCPFKPI YKVJ PKODWU CPF ETQUKGT *#4#.& 4' 4 %TQUU QH NQDGU 6*84)16 + .80&. *DI IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ +0 KPUVGCF QH VJG EQOOQP 10 &WTKPI CP KPUWTIGPE[ %PWV VJG 5CKPV YCU ECRVWTGF CPF OWTFGTGF KP 5V #NDCPU %JWTEJ 6JKU KPUWTIGPE[ YCU C TG UWNV QH %PWVʼnU NGX[KPI QH VKVJGU VJCV JG JCF KPVTQFWEGF UJQTVN[ DGHQTG *KU KOOGFKCVG ECPQPKUCVKQP YCU VQ OKVKICVG CP[ TGUGPVOGPV

208


'4+- ',')1&

&GPKGT $TCEVGCVG .WPF. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF QTD Z '4+% . *DI IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF GFIG HCWNV QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP 'Z *CWDGTI + EQNNGEVKQP 2QUUKDN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP QH *CWDGTI YJKEJ KU QPG UKFGF

0+'.5 #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH 0KGNUʼn TGKIP VJG &CPKUJ IQXGTPOGPV CEMPQYNGFIGF UW\GTCKPV[ QH VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG 7PFGT 0KGNU C UVTQPI EGPVTCNKUCVKQP VQQM RNCEG

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # *GCF HCEKPI 0+%1.#85 4': 4 .QPI QRGPGF ETQUU YKVJ UOCNNGT ETQUU QP KV VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP CPEJQTU Å‘. *DI IT. 0KEG RCVKPC YGNN UVTWEM HQT VJKU KUUWG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV CPF UVCPFCTF 0+ %1.#85 4': 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ ' 5 6 QP VJG TQQH. *DI IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO 6JG NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG KU VJG UCOG CU KP *CWDGTI DWV PQV XKUKDNG JGTG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ EH CNUQ *DI #WEVKQP HH 1P ,CPWCT[ %PWV .CXCTF &WMG QH 5NGUXKI CPF QPG QH VJG RTGVGPFGTU VQ VJG VJTQPG YCU CUUCUUKPCVGF %PWV .CXCTF JGNF VJG VGTTKVQT[ QH VJG YGUVGTP 9GPF VTKDG KP HKGH QH VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT %PWV .CXCTFʼnU DTQVJGT 'TKE YCU NQQMKPI VQ UWEEGGF CPF QRRQUGF DCEMGF D[ VJG <GCNCPF PQDNG HCOKN[ *XKFG -KPI 0KGNU CPF JKU UQP /CIPWU +P VJG $CVVNG QH (QVGXKI KP 5EJQPGP /CIPWU YCU UNCKP CPF 0KGNU YCU UWDUGSWGPVN[ MKNNGF KP 5NGUXKI ENGCTKPI VJG YC[ HQT 'TKE 0GXGTVJGNGUU CPQVJGT EKXKN YCT GPUWGF ECWUGF D[ C FKURWVG YKVJ VJG DKUJQRU +P %PWV .CXCTFʼnU UQP 8CNFGOCT FGRQUGF 'TKE CPF YCU NGHV UQNG TWNGT +P JG CPPQWPEGF VJG ECPQPKUCVKQP QH %PWV KP 4KPIUVGF

'4+- '/70'

&GPKGT .WPF. # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ TCKUGF JCPF CPF UEGRVTG '4 +6 4': #.8+ 4 /QWPVGF MKPI YKVJ UYQTF. *DI IT. 4 5OCNN HNCP QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG UVTWEM URGEKOGP

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP /KPVOCUVGT #NYKPU #.8+ QP VJG QDXGTUG KU JCTFN[ XKUKDNG 4GXGTUG *CWDGTI OGPVKQPU C ETQUU QXGT VJG JQTUGU JGCF YJKEJ KU PQV XKUKDNG JGTG 6JG 4GXGTUG UJQYU IGTOCP KPHNW GPEG

209


&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # *GCF HCEKPI '4+%85 4': 4 9JGGN YKVJ URQMGU NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG *DI IT. 4 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z *CWDGTI EQNNGEVKQP *CWDGTI OGPVKQPU VJTGG OKPVOCUVGTU /CTVKP 2CRGPKPI CPF 8NHTKE

$4#%6'#6'5 QH 0146*'40 ,76.#0&

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ʼnV CVVTKDWVCDNG VQ CP[ EGTVCKP MKPI 6JG JQCTFU VJCV VJG[ GOGTIGF KP RTGUWOCDN[ YGTG EQPPGEVGF VQ VJG GXGPVWCN $CVVNG QH )TCVG *GCVJ QP VJG TF QH 1EVQDGT YJKEJ 8CNFGOCT YQP

$TCEVGCVG. # 6YQ CTOQWTGF HKIWTGU YKVJ UYQTFU NQQMKPI CV GCEJQVJGT UVCPFCTF DGVYGGP VJGO. *DI IT. 44 5NKIJVGN[ KTTGIWNCT GFIG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP 5QOG JCXG VJKU RKGEG UVTWEM D[ 8CNFGOCT CPF JKU YKHG

$TCEVGCVG. # -KPI UVCPFKPI YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UEGRVTG GPFKPI KP NKU DGVYGGP HQWT TKPIU CPF VYQ VQYGTU. *DI IT. 4 'FIG ENKRRGF XGT[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z *CWDGTI EQNNGEVKQP 'Z $TQIG EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 'TPUV ++ EQNNGEVKQP

8#.&'/#4 +

8CNFGOCT + DGICP C NKPG QH RQNKVKEU EQPVKPWGF D[ JKU UQP %CPWV 8+ CKOGF CV UWRTGOCE[ QXGT VJG $CNVKE 8CNFGOCT GXGP GPVGTGF KP C EQNNCDQTCVKQP YKVJ VJG )GTOCPU VQ VJKU GPF %CPWV JQYGXGT YQWNFPʼnV CEMPQYNGFIG (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC CPF VJWU DGECOG C HGCTGF GPGO[ QH VJG )GTOCPU 6JGUG NCTIG UECNG RQNKVKEU HQWPF VJGKT GPF WPFGT 8CNFGOCT ++ KP VJG $CVVNG QH $QTP JÌXGF

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # $WUV QH VJG MKPI HCEKPI YKVJ QTD CPF UEGRVTG 4 $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF. *DI IT. 4 'FIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

210


-07& 8+

&GPKGT 4KDG. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UEGRVTG 4 (NCI ETQUKGT CPF UVCT. *DI IT. 8GT[ HKPG

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

&GPKGT 4KDG. # *GCF HCEKPI DGVYGGP ETGUEGPV CPF UVCT 4 )CDNG QH C EJWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU CPF VYQ VQYGTU. *DI IT. # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 4KDG $KUJQR 1OGT

&GPKGT )TGPCHWPFGV. # *GCF HCEKPI DGVYGGP ETGUEGPV CPF UVCT 4 )CDNG QH C EJWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU CPF VYQ VQYGTU. *DI IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 5NGUXKI. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI UEGRVTG GPFKPI KP NKU N UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI CP ETQUU T 4 %TQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU. *DI IT. 4 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN $TWWP *CWDGTI #VVTKDWVGF VQ 8CNFGOCT ++ 5GLT *DI JCU VJG UCOG TGXGTUG DWV VJG QDXGTUG KU FKHHGTGPV

8#.&'/#4 ++ 5',4

8CNFGOCT ++ CNUQ TWNGF QXGT RCTVU QH 0QTVJ )GTOCP[ 1P DGJCNH QH 8CNFGOCT #NDTGEJV QH 1TNCOÃ’PFG CEVGF CU C UVCFVJQNFGT *G OKPVGF KP *CODWTI CPF KP .Ã’DGEM 6JG UV[NG QH JKU EQKPU KU YJQNN[ )GTOCP CPF PQV &CPKUJ

&GPKGT .WPF. # $WUV QH VJG MKPI HCEKPI YKVJ NKU CPF ETQUU 4 $WUV QH VJG CTEJDKUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF ETQUU. *DI IT. 8GT[ HKPG #TIGPQT 2CTKU (TQO NKUV 1EVQDGT PQ #TEJDKUJQR #PFTGCU 5WPGUGP

211


&GPKGT 8KDQTI. # *GCF HCEKPI YKVJ NKU CPF ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU DGVYGGP VYQ NKU QP VYQ JQTK\QPVCN NKPGU. *DI IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF UNKIJVGN[ WPEGPVGTGF CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT )TGPCHWPFGV. # *GCF HCEKPI YKVJ NKU VQRRGF UEGRVTG CPF UVCT 4 %TQUKGT JQTK\QPVCN NKPG YKVJ VYQ UJQTV XGTVKECN NKPGU CPF VJTGG TKPIU. *DI IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ #V VJG FGCVJ QH 8CNFGOCT ++ C EGPVWT[ QH KPVGTPCN FKURWVG DGICP 'ZVGTPCN CWVJQTKV[ UWHHGTGF C ITGCV FGCN 0QDKNKV[ CPF ENGTWU ITCVGHWNN[ VQQM CFXCPVCIG QH VJG UKVWCVKQP CPF EWTVCKNGF TQ[CN RQYGT 6JG EQKPU QH 'TKE 2NQXRGPPKPI #DGN CPF %JTKUVQRJGT + UVGCFKN[ FGVGTKQTCVGF 6Q OCZKOKUG TGXGPWG VJG RQRWNCVKQP YCU HQTEGF VQ GZEJCPIG VJGKT QNF EQKPU YKVJ PGY QPGU QH OWEJ RQQTGT SWCNKV[ 6JG UKNXGT EQPVGPV UJQYGF C EQPVKPWQWU FGETGCUG

#$'.

#DGN KORQUGF C NCPF VCZ VQ KORTQXG VJG OKPVKPI

&GPKGT 8KDQTI. # 5VCT YKVJ HKXG DGCOU #$'. 4': 4 5VCT YKVJ HKXG DGCOU 8+$14). /$ IT. 4 5RGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 1NFGPDWTI #WEVKQP PQ

%*4+5612*'4 +

&GPKGT 4KDG. # 5VCT YKVJ HKXG DGCOU &#0 148/ 4': 4 )TGCV % YKVJ RGNNGV KP KV %4+561 (148 5 . /$ IT. 7PEGPVGTGF CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 5EJNGUYKI. # 4': KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING. /$ IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ *GFG EQNNGEVKQP 5VTWEM WPFGT VJG DKUJQRU 'UMKN CPF 0KEQNCWU

212


'4+- -.+22+0)

&GPKGT 4KDG. # &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ ' 4 ' : KP VJG CPINGU 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING GKIJV ETGUEGPVU CTQWPF. /$ IT. (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG OWTFGT QH 'TKE -NKRRKPI UQP QH %JTKUVQRJGT + KP ECWUGF VJG EQWPVT[ VQ RTGEKRKVCVG KPVQ VJG UQ ECNNGF #IG QH &GEC[ 6JG UKNXGT EQPVGPV QH VJG EQKPU YCU FKOKPKUJGF VQ VJG RQKPV YJGTG VJG[ RTCEVKECNN[ EQPUKUVGF QPN[ QH EQRRGT

VJG CDUQNWVG NQY YCU TGCEJGF WPFGT %JTKUVQRJGT ++ 6JGUG XGT[ RQQT EQRRGT EQKPU CTG CNUQ MPQYP CU %KXKN 9CT %QKPU

'4+- /'08'&

&GPKGT .WPF. # 6JTGG ETGUEGPVU YKVJ TKPI RGNNGVU DGVYGGP VJGO 4 %TQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPVU KP VJG CPINGU. /$ IT. 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 0QTTG ,[NNCPF. # )TGCV QXCN YKVJ VJTGG JQQMU CV GCEJ UKFG CPF RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG 4 )TGCV CPEJQT. /$ IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QKNCPF -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG DGUV URGEKOGP HTQO VJKU EQKP V[RG

%*4+5612*'4 ++ 5VCTVKPI YKVJ %JTKUVQRJGT ++ GCEJ &CPKUJ MKPI WRQP CUUWORVKQP QH QHHKEG JCF VQ UKIP VJG UQ ECNNGF JยนPFHยบUVPKPI C EJCTVGT PQV WPNKMG VJG /CIPC %CTVC VJCV UGXGTGN[ EWTVCKNGF TQ[CN CWVJQTKV[ CPF IWCTCPVGGF C UVTQPI KPHNWGPEG QH PQDKNKV[ KP PCVKQPCN CHHCKTU

&GPKGT 4QUMKNFG. # : : 4 %TQUU OQNKPG. /$ IT. *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

213


8#.&'/#4 +8 #66'4&#)

8CNFGOCT +8 #VVGTFCI TGUVQTGF VJG QTFGT CPF &GPOCTMʼnU RQYGT EQPUGSWGPVN[ KPETGCUGF 6JCV VJG *CPUGCVKE .GCIWGʼnU UWRRQTV CNNQYGF JKO VQ TGUKUV PQDKNKV[ FKF PQV MGGR 8CNFGOCT HTQO CVVGORVKPI VQ DTGCM VJG RQYGT QH VJG )GTOCP *CPUGCVKE EKVKGU *G HCKNGF CPF &CPKUJ PQDKNKV[ KOOGFKCVGN[ UVGRRGF KPVQ VJG RQYGT XCEWWO CPF TGPGYGF VJGKT QNF RTKXKNGIGU $WV 8CNFGOCTʼnU UGEQPF FCWIJVGT /CTICTGV YJQ YCU TGIGPV FWTKPI VJG OKPQTKV[ QH JGT UQP 1NCH CPF SWGGP CHVGT JKU FGCVJ FKRNQOCVKECNN[ OCPCIGF VQ TGGUVCDNKUJ RQNKVKECN DCNCPEG YKVJQWV VQWEJKPI VJG RQYGT QH PQDKNKV[ /CTICTGV YGFFGF MKPI *CMQP QH 0QTYC[ KP CPF VJWU DGECOG SWGGP QH 0QTYC[ CPF JGT UQP 1NCH YCU DQTP KP VJCV EQWPVT[ KP

2GPP[ .WPF. # %TQYP 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING. /$ IT. 4 (KPG URGEKOGP

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ʼnU ITCPFPGRJGY $QNKUNCY QH 2QOGTCPKC DQTP YCU ETQYPGF MKPI QH 0QTYC[ /CTICTGV CFQRVGF JKO CPF JG VJGP VQQM QP VJG PCOG 'TKE QH 2QOGTCPKC +P 'TKE DGECOG MKPI QH 5YGFGP CPF &GPOCTM VQQ VJ ,WPG 7PKQP QH -CNOCT 'TKE DGECOG MKPI QH VJG 7PKQP &G HCEVQ CWVJQTKV[ QXGT VJG VJTGG EQWPVTKGU YCU TGVCKPGF D[ /CTICTGV WPVKN JGT FGCVJ KP

'4+% QH 21/'4#0+# 'TKE QH 2QOGTCPKC CEJKGXGF DTKPIKPI VJG FWEJ[ 5NGUXKI WPFGT VJG &CPKUJ ETQYP CHVGT VJG QWV EQOG QH VJG EQWPEKN CV -QPUVCP\ KP 6JG OCTTKCIG QH 'TKE VQ VJG 'PINKUJ RTKPEGUU 2JKNKRRC TGOCKPGF EJKNFNGUU JKU UGCTEJ HQT C UWE EGUUQT NGF VQ UGXGTCN FKHHKEWNVKGU +P JG TGVTGCVGF VQ )QVNCPF +P VJG &CPKUJ 4KMUTCFGV ECNNGF WRQP 'TKEʼnU EQWUKP %JTKUVQRJGT HTQO VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNU DCEJ VQ UWEEGGF 'TKE YCU UWDUGSWGPVN[ FGRQUGF %JTKUVQRJGT VQQ YCU MKPI QH VJG 7PKQP CPF VJG VJTGG PCVKQPU RTQURGTGF WPFGT JKU TGKIP +P JG UWFFGPN[ FKGF EJKNFNGUU YJKEJ RWV VJG 4KMUTCFGV KP C RQUKVKQP QH GZVTCQTFKPCT[ RQYGT

5VGTNKPI .WPF. # %TQYP '4+%85 „ 4': „ & „ 5 „ 0 4 %TQUU /10'6# „ .80&'05. ) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

5VGTNKPI 0CGUVXGF. # %TQYP '4+%85 „ 4': „ & „ 5 „ 0 4 %TQUU /10'6# „ 0'569'&. ) IT. 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ /QPG[GT /GUVGT )JGTF OWPVOGUVGT VQ 0GUVYGFG VJG &WVEJOCP )GTTKV )Q\GYKLP\ %QOJCGT HTQO C FQEWOGPV QH

214


-QDDGTUVGTNKPI 0CGUVXGF. # %TQYP QXGT ' /'0'+6# 0'56' 4 %TQUU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 01/+0' &1/+0'. ) IT. 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ /KPVOCUVGT /GUVGT )JGTF *DI CWEVKQP

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYP KP JCNQ. ) IT.

8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

4+)54#&'6

*XKF /CNOQ. # .KQP N t 018# 4'ő 4 .QPI ETQUU QP UJKGNF FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 /#. /1+ '05. ) IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG NQPI ETQUU QP CP GORV[ UJKGNF ICXG VJG PCOG ŋMQTUJXKFŌ MQTU ETQUU VQ VJKU EQKPU

6JG 4KMUTCFGV CRRTQCEJGF #FQNH 8+++ &WMG QH 5NGUXKI DWV JG TGHGTTGF VQ %JTKUVKCP QH 1NFGPDWTI CU JG YCU EJKNFNGUU JKOUGNH #HVGT %JTKUVKCP JCF CITGGF VQ VJG EQPFKVKQP QH VJG 4KMUTCFGV VJCV JG OCTT[ &QTQVJGC QH $TCPFGPDWTI VJG EQTQPCVKQP VQQM RNCEG KP #U UQQP CU VJG 5YGFKUJ 4KMUTCFGV GNGEVGF OCTUJCNN -CTN -PWVUUQP MKPI QH 5YGFGP $QVJ ECPFKFCVGU YGTG RTQENCKOGF MKPI QH 0QTYC[ -CTN -PWVUUQP TGUKIPGF JKU ENCKO JQYGXGT 6JG HGWF DGVYGGP &GPOCTM CPF 5YGFGP EQPVKPWGF CPF PQDKNKV[ RNC[GF C UKIPKHKECPV TQNG KP KV +P %JTKUVKCP + YCU ETQYPGF MKPI QH 5YGFGP ECWUKPI VJG 5YGFGU VQ TGDGN -CTN -PWVUUQP TGVWTPGF CPF YQWNF FGHKPKVKXGN[ JQNF RQYGT HTQO VQ JKU FGCVJ KP 6JG XCEWWO DGVYGGP CPF YCU HKNNGF D[ VJG OQUV KPHNWGPVKCN PQDNG HCOKN[ CV VJG VKOG 'TKE #ZGNUUQP 6JQVV IQXGTPGF KP TGIGPE[ 6JG FGCVJ QH -CTN -PWVUUQP RTQORVGF 5VGP 5VWTG VJG 'NFGT VQ RKV %JTKUVKCP CICKPUV VJG HCOKN[ 6JQVV *G UWDUGSWGPVN[ GSWKRRGF CP CTO[ YJKEJ JG NGF VQ VJG ICVGU QH 5VQEMJQNO CPF QP VJ 1EVQDGT PGCT $TWPMGDGTI FGHGCVGF CP CNNKGF &CPKUJ 5YGFKUJ CTO[ #NVJQWIJ %JTKUVKCP + WRJGNF JKU ENCKO VQ VJG 5YGFKUJ ETQYP WPVKN JKU FGCVJ KV JCF PQ DCUKU KP TGCNKV[ # NQPI RQNKVKECN ETKUKU GPUWGF YJGP JG FKGF 3WGGP &QTQVJGC JCF JGT JCPF KP VJKU +P DQVJ UQPU *CPU CPF (TGFGTKEM YGTG GNGEVGF CUUQEKCVG MKPI UQYKPI VJG UGGFU QH VJG FKXKUKQP +P *CPU DGECOG MKPI QH &GPOCTM CPF 0QTYC[ +P 5YGFGP 5VGP 5VWTG VJG 'NFGT YCU TGIGPV &GPOCTM *CPU CPF 4WUUKC +YCP +++ QH /QUEQY VJGP HQTIGF CP CNNKCPEG CICKPUV 5YGFGP YJKEJ KP NGF VQ *CPU DGEQOKPI MKPI QH 5YGFGP CPF 5VGP 5VWTG VQ VGORQTCTKN[ FKUUCRRGCT HTQO VJG RQNKVKECN UVCIG 1PEG CICKP VJG 7PKQP QH VJG VJTGG PQTVJGTP EQWPVTKGU YCU TGUVQTGF CNDGKV UJQTV NKXGF 6JG $CVVNG QH &KVJOCTUEJGP KP JCF C HCT TGCEJKPI QWVEQOG 6JG RQYGT QH *CPU KP &GPOCTM YCU UGXGTGN[ FCOCIGF KP 0QTYC[ %JTUKVKCP ++ YCU PQV CEEGRVGF CPF KP 5YGFGP FG HCEVQ UYC[ HTQO QP YCU JGNF D[ VJG TGIGPV 5VGP 5VWTG

*#05

5JKNNKPI /CNOQ. # 5JKGNF QH 1NFGPDWTI QXGT GORV[ UJKGNF QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF +1*0 Q &'+ )4# Q 4': &#%+' 4 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG NKQPU /10'6 Ã 018# Ã /#./1'5+5. ) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

215


*XKF /CNOQ. # * WPFGT ETQYP +1*0 „ & „ ) „ 4 „ &#%+' 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT GORV[ UJKGNF /10 /#. /1+ '05. ) IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ

)16.#0& CHVGT

)QVNCPF ECOG VQ &GPOCTM

2GPP[ 8KUD[. # .KU QP VTKRQF DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU /10'6# % +8+6#6+5 4 .COD PQ PKO DWU YKVJ UVCPFCTF N 9+5$8%' 0%+5 . .. :::8 # C IT. &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG &QODTQYUMK /ÒPUVGT 6JG KNNWUVTCVKQP KU PQV EQORCTCDNG VQ .. C

59'&'0 &GURKVG VJG HCEV VJCV 5YGFGP YCU VJG ETCFNG HQT OCP[ 'WTQRGCP RGQRNGU CPF VJG 5YGFGU KP VJG 8KMKPI #IG VTCXGNGF VJG YJQNG QH VJG EQPVKPGPV CPF DG[QPF CPF OCKPVCKPGF DTKUM VTCFKPI YKVJ VJG 'CUV 5YGFGPʼnU JKUVQT[ CU C PCVKQP UVCTVU CTQWPF VJG [GCT #TQWPF 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI YCU MKPI QH 5YGFGP OQTG URGEKHKECNN[ QH VJG VGTTKVQTKGU QH VJG 5XGCT 5XGCNCPF CPF VJG )ÌVCT )ÌVCNCPF #NVJQWIJ 1NCH JCF EJTKUVKCPK\GF C RCTV QH JKU RGQ RNG RCICP EWNVWTG YQWNF EQPVKPWG VQ RNC[ C UKIPKHKECPV TQNG CPF CHVGT 1NCH GXGP JCF VQ TGVTGCV VQ VJG %JTKUVKCP 8·UVGTIÌVNCPF YJGTG JG HQWPFGF VJG FKQEGUG QH 5MCTC (TQO VJG RGTKQF DGVYGGP CPF C HGY PCOGU JCXG UWTXKXGF JKUVQT[ DWV PQVJKPI XGT[ FGVCKNGF VJQWIJ VJGTG CTG UQOG FQEWOGPVGF EQKPU QH 1NCHʼnU UQP #PWPF ,CMQD +P VJG RGTKQF HTQO VQ VYQ TQ[CN JQWUGU TKXCNNGF GCEJ QVJGT 1PG JQWUG UVCTVU YKVJ 5XGTMGT VJG 'NFGT CPF VJG QVJGT YKVJ 'TKM VJG 5CKPV #PF VJGP VJGTG YGTG VJG &CPKUJ VJTQPG RTGVGPFGTU KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ COQPI YJQO /CIPWU *GPTKMUGP YJQ KP MKNNGF 'TKM VJG 5CKPV PGCT 7RRUCNC 6Q TWNG VJG XCUV GZRCPUG QH JKU EQWPVT[ VJG MKPI CRRQKPVGF TGRTGUGPVCVKXGU UQ ECNNGF LCTNU 5VCTVKPI CTQWPF VJG LCTNU CVVGORVGF VQ UGK\G RQYGT 6JWU $KTIGT ,CTN HTQO CP KORQTVCPV PQDNG HCOKN[ HTQO ¤UVGTIÌVNCPF CPF YGFFGF VQ VJG MKPIʼnU UKUVGT JGNRGF JKU UQP 9CNFGOCT

CUEGPF VJG VJTQPG KP 6JG *QWUG (QNMWPIGT CTQUG 7PFGT 9CNFGOCT CPF JKU DTQVJGT /CIPWU .CFKUNCU VJG MKPIFQO 5YGFGP VQQM C OQTG FGHKPKVG UJCRG *QYGXGT VJKU FKFPʼnV OGCP VJG DCVVNG HQT VJG VJTQPG YCU QXGT +P VJG DG IKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG 'CTNU GCTN LCTN 'TKM CPF 9CNFGOCT EQPVGPFGF HQT $KTIGT /CIPÐUUQPʼnU VJTQPG +P DQVJ GCTNU FKGF KP C FWPIGQP KP 0[MÌ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ÌRKPI

KP YJKEJ #NDGTV YCU ECRVWTGF EQWNF GHHGEVKXGN[ CUUWOG VJG QHHKEG QH SWGGP QH 5YGFGP 216


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ÌPU $GPIVUUQP HQT 5YGFGP 5VGP 5VÒTG VJG 'NFGT CU TGIGPV CPF HKPCNN[ *CPU CU WPKQP MKPI

58'#.#0& CPF )¤6#.#0& WPKVGF 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI YCU VJG HKTUV MKPI YJQ TWNGF QXGT VJG WPKVGF VGTTKVQTKGU QH VJG 5XGCT

5XGCNCPF CPF VJG )ÌVCT )ÌVCNCPF #TQWPF VJKU VGTTKVQT[ HGNN CRCTV CPF VYQ MKPIFQOU HQTOGF 4KXCNT[ DGICP CU UQQP CU 1.#( 5-¤6-1070) 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI KU VJG UQP QH 'TKM 5GIGTU·NN CPF )WPJKNF UKUVGT QH $QNGUNCX + QH 2QNCPF 9JGP JKU HCVJGT RGTKUJGF KP VJG DCVVNG QH ([TKU PGCT 7RRUCNC JKU OQVJGT TGYGFFGF 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF OCMKPI -PWF CPF 1NCH JCNH DTQVJGTU %JKNFTGP YGTG #PWPF ,CMQD -KPI QH 5YGFGP CPF 'FOWPF -KPI QH 5YGFGP #UVTKF YGFFGF VQ VJG 0QTYGIKCP -KPI 1NCH *CTCNFUUQP CPF +PIGIGTF YGFFGF VQ ,CTQUNCX )TCPF &WMG QH 0QXIQTQF 7PFGT VJG KPHNWGPEG QH VJG CTEJDKUJQRTKE QH *CODWTI $TGOGP 1NCH GPFGCXQWTGF VQ EJTKUVKCP KUG #TQWPF JG EQPVTQNNGF 5XGCNCPF CPF )ÌVCNCPF *QYGXGT RCICP VTKDGU KP 7RRUCNC HQTEGF JKO VQ YKVJFTCY VQ VJG %JTKUVKCP 8·UVGTIÌVNCPF YJGTG JG HQWPFGF VJG FKQEGUG 5MCTC

&GPKGT 5KIVWPC. # $WUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG 1.#( 4': 52'81: 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ % 4 8 : KP VJG CPINGU )1&2+0' /1 <+*6. .. IT. 44 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ <+*6 <+*680# 5+)670# 6JG 2 OWUV DG TGCF CU 9 6JG GPF QH VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG KU HQTOGF D[ C JQTK\QPVCN NKPG YKVJ C RGNNGV CDQXG KV CPF WPFGT KV EC

&GPKGT .QPI %TQUU 5KIVWPC ! . # $WUV N '&'&101'&&212+ 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU %+1 .'1 8 %++. .. EH C D IT. 4 /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*KTUEJ 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ (QT CVVTKDWVKQP UGG CTV .[QP X F /GGT &QNNG[ 5GG 2N ++ KP $ /CNOGT -KPI %CPWVG U %QKPCIG KP VJG 0QTVJGTP %QWPVTKGU 5KIVWPC NKGU PGCT 7RRUCNC VJG VGTTKVQT[ VJCV YCU NQUV CHVGT %QWNF VJG PWODGTU CPF JCXG DQVJ DGGP UVTWEM KP 8·UVGTIÌVNCPF!

217


&GPKGT .QPI %TQUU. # $WUV N 1.+' 1.&41+ .1%+ 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VJTGG ETGUEGPVU DNWPFGTGF NGIGPF. .. IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP ) X F /GGT EH $ /CNOGT 5VTWEM D[ 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI CPF PQV WPFGT 1NCH /CNOGT 2N ++ !

58'#.#0& 5QOG MKPIU TWNGF QPN[ 5XGCNCPF QT QPN[ )ÌVCNCPF UQOG TWNGF DQVJ UGG CDUVTCEV YKVJ .CIGT SXKUV QP R

-076 '4+-5510

$TCEVGCVG 7RRUCNC. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ TCKUGF JCPFU QT UEGRVTGU. .. # E IT. 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG VQ WPEKTEWNCVGF

$TCEVGCVG 7RRUCNC. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UEGRVTG. .. # D IT.

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

5RKPM .QPFQP .. C UGGOU VQ JCXG VJG UCOG UVCOR

44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

)¤6#.#0& 8#.&'/#4

#HVGT 'TKM 'TKMUUQP EJKNFNGUU FGOKUG $KTIGT ,CTN QNFGUV UQP YCU GNGEVGF MKPI

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI. .. :8++ # C IT.

#NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI. .. :8++ # E IT.

#NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYPGF NKQP FTCIQP! T . .. :8++ $ D IT. 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

218

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ


$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYPGF NKQP FTCIQP! N . .. :8++ $ D IT.

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQYPGF NKQP FTCIQP! N RWVVKPI QWV JKU VQPIWG. .. :8++ $ C IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ

'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

/#)075 .#&7.#5 /CIPWU $KTIGTUUQP .CFKUNCU UGEQPF UQP QH $KTIGT ,CTN CPF +PIGDQTI UKUVGT QH 'TKM 'TKMUUQP #HVGT JKU HCVJGTʼnU FGCVJ KP /CIPWU DGECOG 5XGCJGTVKI 'CTN QH 5YGFGP +P /CIPWUʼn ECUG GCTN YCU EQPUKFGTGF GSWCN VQ LCTN /CIPWU GZRGNNGF JKU DTQVJGT 8CNFGOCT DWV PQV WPVKN FKF VJG NCVVGT TGNKPSWKUJ JKU TKIJVU +P FWTKPI JKU TGKIP /CIPWU JCF JKU UQP $KTIGT GNGEVGF MKPI

$TCEVGCVG. # / DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU. .. :8+++ % F IT. 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

)16.#0& 7PVKN )QVNCPF YCU RCTV QH 5YGFGP VJGP KV HGNN VQ &GPOCTM HQT EQKPU CHVGT UGG &GPOCTM

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ EKTENG CPF RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG C NKPG YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU. .. :: # C IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ #VVTKDWVKQP CEEQTFKPI VQ 4CUOWUUGP EH *KNFGDTCPF

&GPKGT. # 9JGGN YKVJ VJTGG URQMGU EKTENG YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKPG YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 4 %JGSWGTGF ETQUU. .. ::++ # IT. # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 2TKRR ++ EQNNGEVKQP

219


58'#.#0& #0& )¤6#.#0& #(6'4 /#)075 '4+-5510

$TCEVGCVG .ÌFÌUG. # . KP JCNQ. .. ::8+++ # C IT.

4 8GT[ HKPG

&GPKGT .WPF. # 5 DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU 4 6YQ VTKCPINGU WPFGT ETQUU. /$ IT. &CTM RCVKPC HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ #HVGT 'Z 2TKRR + EQNNGEVKQP

*QTPWPI -QRGPJCIGP #WEVKQP PQ 5EJQPGP CPF VJG VQYP QH .WPF JCF CNYC[U DGGP &CPKUJ RQUUGUUKQPU CPF VJG CTEJDKUJQRU JCF C JCPF KP VJKU UWDUVCP VKCNN[ +P 5EJQPGP WPFGT CTEJDKUJQR -CTN TGUKUVGF VJG &CPGU CPF RTQENCKOGF VJG 5YGFKUJ -KPI /CIPWU 'TKMUUQP VJGKT MKPI +P 5EJQPGP WPFGT VJG &CPKUJ MKPI 8CNFGOCT #VVGTFCI TGVWTPGF WPFGT 5YGFKUJ FQOKPCPEG &CPKUJ ECVCNQIWGU QHVGP UVCVG VJKU V[RG YCU UVTWEM WPFGT 8CNFGOCT #VVGTFCI +V YCU KPFGGF DWV D[ /CIPWU 5OGM /CIPWU 'TKMUUQP

2'4+1&

$TCEVGCVG #. # # WPFGT ETQYP. .. :::+++ # C IT.

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5OKVJ EQNNGEVKQP 6JG # EQWNF UVCPF HQT 8·UVGTCU #TQU QT #DQ

$TCEVGCVG 5. # 5 WPFGT ETQYP. .. :::+++ $ C IT.

*KTUEJ 5VQEMJQNO 5 5VQEMJQNO

'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

8GT[ HKPG

2'4+1& #.$'46 QH /'%-.'0$74)

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI #. $' 4685 Q 4': 4 %TQUU QP ETQYP YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU /10' 6# Q 59 '%+'. .. +# C IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ 6JG PWODGTU CPF FKHHGT KP VJG EWTN CPF ETQYP

220


¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI #.$'4685 Q 4': ¤ 4 %TQUU QP ETQYP YKVJ QPG 8GT[ HKPG ETQYP KP VJG UV CPF PF CPINGU /10'6# Q 59'%+'. .. +# D IT.

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG ICR DGVYGGP CPF YCU HKNNGF D[ /CTICTGVG UGG WPFGT &GPOCTM YGFFGF VQ MKPI *CMQP QH 0QTYC[ CU TGIGPVGUU QH 5YGFGP +P JGT ITCPFPGRJGY $QNKUNCY QH 2QOOGTP DGECOG MKPI QH 5YGFGP CUUWOKPI VJG PCOG 'TKM *QYGXGT /CTICTGVG TGOCKPGF VJG TGCN NGCFGT KP 5YGFGP (QT 5YGFGPʼnU HWTVJGT FGXGNQROGPV UGG WPFGT &GPOCTM

'4+- QH 21/'4#0+#

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO. # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI ¤ 4': „ „ '4+%85 ¤ 4 ' QP ETQUU /10'6# ¤ 561%*1.. .. # C IT. 8GT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO. # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU QP ETQUU ¤ '4+%85 „ 4': „ & 5 +2 4 ' QP ETQUU 8GT[ HKPG

/10'6# Z 561%*1.. .. D IT.

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ (QT VJG HKTUV VKOG 'TKE RTQECKOGF JKOUGNH MKPI QH &GPOCTM 5YGFGP CPF 0QTYC[

-4+56+#0 +

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO . # )TGCV % YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG %4+556'4015 4': 4 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# 561 *1. . .. IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

221


-#4. -0765510 $10&'

¤TVWI #DQ. # 5JKGNF YKVJ UJKR CPF ETQYPGF # DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU QP NQPI ETQUU -#4 1.8 54' :5 ) 4 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# #$1 '05. .. & IT. 44 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z $WMQYUMK PQ NKUV HTQO C EQKPVTCFGT KP 5VQEMJQNO 'Z 2TKRR ++ EQNNGEVKQP

56'0 56ª4'

5VGP 5VÒTG YCU OGTGN[ TGIGPV CPF VJGTGHQTG PQ EQKP DGCTU JKU PCOG *G UVTWEM VJGO KP 'TKM VJG 5CKPVʼnU PCOG KPUVGCF

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO . # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 5%5 Q '4+%85 Q 4': : Q 4 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU DGVYGGP VYQ TKPIU 5 CDQXG ¤ /10'6# ¤ 561%* ¤ . .. +# C IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

¤TVWI 5VQEMJQNO PC . # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 5%5 '4+%85 4': 4 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG ETQYPU DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU /10'6# 561%*1. .. +# IT. 'FIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ

¤TVWI 8·UVGTCU. # %TQYP 5%5 Q '4+%85 Q 4': 4 # RGNNGV CDQXG UVCT N /10'6# Q #415+5. .. ++$ M IT. 8GT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO

222


0149#; 6JG MKPIFQO 0QTYC[ EQOOGPEGF YKVJ *CTCNF (CKTJCKT CPF YCU FKTGEVN[ DGUGV D[ CP WPEGCUKPI UVTWIING HQT RQYGT CPF EQPUGSWGPV FKXKUKQPU 'CTN[ QP VJGTG YGTG HCOKN[ VKGU VQ VJG UWTTQWPFKPI EQWPVTKGU 6JWU 1NCH 6T[IIXCUQP CPF YCU YGFFGF VQ 6[TC *CTCNF $NWGVQQVJʼnU FCWIJVGT *G YCU UNCKP KP C PCXCN DCVVNG QHH VJG EQCUV QH /GEMNGPDWTI YJKEJ JG NQUV VQ 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF CPF 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI 1NCH *CTCNFUUQP VJG 5CKPV WPKVGF JKU EQWPVT[ CPF KPVTQFWEGF %JTKUVKCPKV[ *G YCU VJG UQP QH C RGVV[ MKPI C MKPI QXGT C XGT[ NKOKVGF VGTTKVQT[ #U 8KMKPI JG UCKNGF VQ &GPOCTM 5YGFGP (KPNCPF (TKGUNCPF CPF (TCPEG CPF YCU DCRVKUGF KP 4QWGP +P JG TGVWTPGF VQ JKU JQOGNCPF CPF CHVGT VYQ XKEVQTKQWU DCVVNGU JCF JKOUGNH RTQENCKOGF MKPI QH GPVKTG 0QTYC[ 1TKIKPCNN[ %CPWV YCU JKU TKXCN DWV JKU OCTTKCIG VQ #UVTKF FCWIJVGT QH 1NCH 5MÌVMQPWPI DTQWIJV JKO VQ LQKPGF UKFGU YKVJ JKO ;GV %CPWV ENCKOGF 0QTYC[ +P C XCUV HNGGV WPFGT JKU EQOOCPF UCKNGF VQ 0QTYC[ 1NCH HNGF VQIGVJGT YKVJ JKU UQP /CIPWU VQ JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY ,CTQUNCX + QH -KGX #P CVVGORV CV TGEQPSWGTKPI 0QTYC[ TGUWNVGF KP JKU FGCVJ KP KP VJG $CVVNG CV 5VKMNGUVCF +P JG YCU GPVQODGF KP 6TQPFJGKO YJGTG JKU PGRJGY 1NCH -[TTG

NCVGT YQWNF GTGEV VJG %CVJGFTCN QH 6TQPFJGKO *G YCU ECPQPKUGF CNOQUV KOOGFK CVGN[ CHVGT JG FKGF OCKPN[ CU C U[ODQN QH TGUKUVCPEG CICKPUV KPXCFGTU #HVGT %CPWVʼnU 0QTVJ 5GC 'ORKTG JCF HCNNGP CRCTV CHVGT %CPWV 5YG[P (QTMDGCTF TWNGF 0QT YC[ WPVKN 0QTYC[ ITGY OQTG UVCDNG WPFGT 1NCHʼnU UQP /CIPÐU CPF JKU WP ENG *CTQNF 5KIWTFUUQP /CIPÐU CNUQ DGECOG MKPI QH &GPOCTM CU /CIPWU FGP )QFG UGG &GPOCTM 7PFGT DQVJ *CTQNF 5KIWTFUUQPʼnU DGVVGT MPQYP CU *CTCNF *CTFTCFG UQPU /CIPÐU ++ CPF 1NCH +++ -[TTG NKPGCIG EQPVKPWGF # VTWG MKPIFQO JQYGXGT YCUPʼnV GUVCDNKUJGF WPVKN *±MQP *±MQPCTUQPU CNQPI YKVJ C UWDUVCPVKCN HQTGKIP RQNKE[ #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ *±MQP 8 GHHGEVGF C VTGCV[ YKVJ VJG 5YGFKUJ FWMGU 'TKM CPF 9CNFGOCT 7RQP JKU FGCVJ KP JKU [GCT QNF ITCPFUQP /CIPÐU 'TKMUUQP YCU ETQYPGF MKPI QH 0QTYC[ CPF 5YGFGP $WV VJG CNNKCPEG YQWNFPʼnV JQNF KP KV YCU DTQMGP *±MQP 8+ YGPV QP VQ DG MKPI QH 0QTYC[ CPF 'TKM DGECOG MKPI QH 5YGFGP DQVJ YGTG UQPU QH 'TKE 'TKEUUQP (QT VJG HWTVJGT FGXGNQROGPV QH 0QTYC[ UGG WPFGT &GPOCTM CPF 5YGFGP

*#4#.& *#4&4#&'

&GPKGT. # 5V[NK\GF JGCF N 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP ETQUUGU TWPKE EJCTCEVGTU Q . #$* 5EJKXG IT. 44 0KEG RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 1T KU VJKU VJG UCOG MKPIʼnU TGKIP CU YKVJ VJG PWODGTU CPF ! 5GG /CNOGT VTCPUKVKQPCN V[RG DGVYGGP RGTKQF ++ E

CPF RGTKQF ++ E

/#)0¨5 ++ 1.#( +++ -;44'

&GPKGT . # $CTDCTK\GF DWUV T YKVJ HCEKPI JGCF 4 %TQUU NGIGPF PQV TGCFCDNG. #$* 5EJKXG IT. 4 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 1NCH CPF /QIGPU CTG DTQVJGTU )TCGUNKF HKPF V[RG 0 /CNOGT RGTKQF ++ D KPFGRGPFCPV ENCUU + 6JG PQ #$* KU UKOKNCT VQ VJKU EQKP DWV VJG FKG VWTPGF CTQWPF 6JG PWODGTU CPF GOGTIGF KP C 0QTYG IKCP JQCTF HTQO VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[

223


&GPKGT . # $WUV QH VJG MKPI N YKVJ JGNOGV EWTN CPF UEGRVGT CDQXG ETQUU 1 % 0 & + 4 .QPI QRGP ETQUU ++&+++11+&+++. #$* 5EJKXG IT. 4 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 1NCH CPF /QIGPU CTG DTQVJGTU )TCGUNKF HKPF V[RG 6 /CNOGT RGTKQF ++ D RTKOCT[ ENCUU C 6JG PWODGTU CPF GOGTIGF KP C 0QTYGIKCP JQCTF HTQO VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[

#010;/175

$TCEVGCVG (ÌTG. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. #$* 5EJKXG IT. 4 'FIG HCWNVU CPF PKEMU XGT[ HKPG

#GU 4WFG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG #WEVKQP PQ +P #WEVKQP ECV #JNUVTQO PQ #RTKN EC $TCMVGCV OGF MQTU KP QO FWDDNG R·TNTKPICT ([TC TKPICT KP QOUEJTKHVGTP ,HT 0* HKI

#010;/175 EC

$TCEVGCVG 1UNQ. # )TGCV #. #$* 5EJKXG IT.

5RKPM .QPFQP # #UNQ 1UNQ

$TCEVGCVG $GTIGP. # )TGCV $. #$* 5EJKXG IT.

8GT[ HKPG

8GT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP

#4%*$+5*124+% &4106*'+/ 2TKQT VQ &TQPVJGKO 6TQPFJGKO QT CEVWCNN[ VJG UWTTQWPFKPI VGTTKVQT[ QH 6TÌPFGNCI YCU IQXGTPGF D[ C LCTN GCTN HTQO VJG *QWUG QH *CNQICNCPF HQT VJG OGCPKPI QH LCTN UGG WP FGT 5YGFGP #TQWPF VJG LCTNU YGTG FTKXGP CYC[ CPF VJGKT RQUKVKQP YCU VCMGP D[ 1NCH 6T[IIXCUQP CPF 1NCH *CTCNFUUQP 1NCH VJG 5CKPV $GHQTG CP GRKUEQRCN UGG YCU GUVCDNKUJGF /QUV MKPIU JGNF EQWTV KP 6TQPFJGKO WPVKN VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ YJGP KV YCU OQXGF VQ $GTIGP +P 6TQPFJGKO YCU GNGXCVGF VQ C OGVTQ RQNKVCP UGG YKVJ HQWT UWHHTCICP FKQEGUGU CPF CP CFFKVKQPCN UKZ QP VJG KUNCPFU QH )TGGPNCPF VJG 5JGVNCPFU VJG (CTQÀT CPF VJG +UNG QH /CP

&4106*'+/ #TEJDKUJQRTKE EC

$TCEVGCVG. # %TQUU YKVJ VYQ JQTK\QPVCN CTOU. #$* 5EJKXG IT. )CNN F /QPP 0GY 1TNGCPU PQ 2CVTKCTEJCN ETQUU!

224

44 8GT[ HKPG


5%#0&+0#8+#0 +/+6#6+105 6JGTG KU CNYC[U OGPVKQP QH 5ECPFKPCXKCP KOKVCVKQPU DWV VJG CEEWTCE[ QH VJKU VGTO KU SWGU VKQPCDNG &CPKUJ MKPIU HQT C MPQYP HCEV YGTGPʼnV VJG QPN[ QPGU VQ UVTKMG EQKP QVJGTU GKVJGT RQUUGUUGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QT UKORN[ ENCKOGF KV +P O[ QRKPKQP CP[ EQTTWRVGF HCDTKEU JCXG VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ RGTUQPU KP VJCV NCUV ECVGIQT[ 6JG[ CTG CNN KOKVCVKQPU QH 'PINKUJ EQKPU QEECUKQPCNN[ YKVJ CP CNOQUV NGIKDNG VGZV UGG PQ DWV OQUV VGZVU CTG DNWPFGTGF DG[QPF TGEQIPKVKQP 6JG URGEKOGPU RTGUGPVGF JGTG CTG NKOKVGF VQ C EGTVCKP RGTKQF VJG[ JCXG DGGP TCPMGF KP VJG EJTQPQNQIKECN QTFGT QH OCPWHCEVWTG QH VJGKT RTQVQV[RGU UVCTVKPI YKVJ VJG NCUV EQKPU HTQO VJG FC[U QH #GVJGNTGF ++ WR VQ VJQUG QH 'FYCTF VJG %QPHGUUQT URCPPKPI VJG RGTKQF HTQO VQ 6JG PQU CTG HTQO -PWFʼnU VKOG VJG PQU CPF CTG HTQO VJG RG TKQF /CIPWU FGP )QFG CPF PQ HTQO VJG RGTKQF 5XGPF 'UVTKFUGP 6JG PQ UVTKMGU CU 0QTYGIKCP UQOGVJKPI YJKEJ YCU PQV WPEQOOQP VQ VJG RGTKQF QH /CIPWU FGP )QFG .CUV 5OCNN %TQUU .CUV UOCNN ETQUU V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PINCPF WPFGT #GVJGNTGF ++ KP VJG RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # $WUV N QPG TKPI KP HTQPV CPF VYQ TKPIU DGJKPF +1(0 Q &+' 0 + 4 5OCNN ETQUU 21 4+2. IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ

3WCVTGHQKN

3WCVTGHQKN V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PIGNCPF WPFGT %PWV KP VJG RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV KP SWCVTGHQKN '%%108%08&%++%8& 4 .QPI QRGP ETQUU QXGT SWCVTGHQKN Z 0( 10 1'1 %6+. IT. $GPV YKVJ UOCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ EH *DI XCT EH 5[NN -QRGPJCIGP NGIGPF UGGOU VQ DG VJG UCOG 6JG OKFFNG QH VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG TGCFU %08&

2QKPVGF *GNOGV 2QKPVGF JGNOGV V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PINCPF WPFGT %PWV KP VJG RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # $WUV N (10'+ 8(10 4 5JQTV QRGP ETQUU QXGT UOCNN FQWDNGF EKTENG YKVJ QPG ETGU EGPV CPF RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING +81+++0 16 81+1+. IT. 'FIG HCWNV CPF UOCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

225


&GPKGT. # $WUV T +1+'% 2+++ 8++ 4 5JQTV QRGP ETQUU QXGT EKTENG YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV CPF RGN NGV KP GCEJ CPING +.80 +%+%++10+. IT. (NCP ETCEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

5JQTV ETQUU 5JQTV ETQUU V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PINCPF WPFGT %PWV KP VJG RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG GPFKPI KP NKU +680*62:%'& 4 5JQTV QRGP ETQUU YKVJ TKPI 1+52(41&056#0(. IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV YGNN UVTWEM WR XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #EVKQP PQ 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU ICTDNGF DWV ECP ENGCTN[ DG TGCF CU 152'4& 10 56#0( VJG OQPG[GT 1UYGTF YCU HTQO 5VCPHQTF

6TGHQKN SWCFTKNCVGTCN

6TGHQKN SWCFTKNCVGTCN V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PINCPF WPFGT 'FYCTF VJG %QPHGUUQT KP VJG RGTKQF

&GPKGT. # $WUV N YKVJ UEGRVTG '&2 2 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ USWCTG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 5'2+0' 10 ++'04. IT. #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

)QTP[ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 2 9 UQ VJKU OGCPU '&9 9 4': #EEQTFKPI VQ *KNFGDTCPF VJGTG YCU QPN[ C OQPG[GT 5'2+0' KP %JGUVGT 5#'2+0' 10 .'*' +P 0QTVJ VJGTG KU PQ OGPVKQP QH UWEJ OQPG[GT KP %JGUVGT

&GPKGT. # $WUV N 0:55%1 -#00%1 4 %TQUU YKVJ USWCTG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING #.'1 : 11%+5#+61. IT. 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG

)QTP[ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ VJ EGPVWT[ 6JG NGIGPF KU VWTPGF QWVYCTFU VJG : KU KP C USWCTG %QPUKFGTKPI VJG NGIGPFU C OKPVKPI KP 0QTYC[ UGGOU VQ DG RQUUKDNG

'ZRCPFKPI ETQUU 'ZRCPFKPI ETQUU V[RG UVTWEM KP 'PINCPF WPFGT 'FYCTF VJG %QPHGUUQT KP VJG RGTKQF

226

&GPKGT. # $WUV N YKVJ UEGRVTG ++++ %+8+++++ 4 'ZRCPFKPI ETQUU. IT. 'NUGP $TWUUGN 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG KU OCFG WR QH C UGTKGU QH VTKCPINGU RQKPV FQYP 0Q URGEKOGP YKVJ CP GZRCPFKPI ETQUU KU NKUVGF KP *CWDGTI

8GT[ HKPG


0'6*'4.#0&5 (4+5+# #TQWPF (TKUKC UVTGVEJGF CNQPI VJG 0QTVJ 5GC EQCUV HTQO VJG 9GUGT VQ VJG 5EJGNFV

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ʼnV UGGO XGT[ RTQDCDNG HQT YJ[ YQWNF VJG FKG UKPMGTU JCXG UVCTVGF EWVVKPI UQ FKHHGTGPVN[ CPF UQ OWEJ EQWTUGT! /QTGQXGT VJGUG EQKPU CTG KPXCTKCDN[ HQWPF KP 9GUVGTIQ VJG YGUVGTP RCTV QH RTGUGPV FC[ RTQXKPEG (TKGUNCPF 6JGUG CTG OCKPN[ HKPFU HTQO FYGNNKPI OQWPFU TKUGU KP VJG NCPFUECRG HQT RGQRNG UGGMKPI TGHWIG HTQO VJG HNQQFU #U GCTN[ CU VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJGUG OQWPFU YGTG GZECXCVGF VQ TGWUG VJG GCTVJ OQWPFGCTVJ VQ EWNVKXCVG VJG OGCITG UQKN 6JWU C NQV QH OCVGTKCN YCU NQUV 0QYCFC[U GZECXCVKQPU CTG ECTTKGF QWV OWEJ OQTG RTGEKUGN[ RTGUGTXKPI C NQV OQTG /QUV KORQTVCPV OQWPF QT TCVJGT UGXGTCN ITQWRGF OQWPFU KU WPFQWDVGFN[ VJCV QH 9KLPCNFWO &WG VQ VJG QDLGEVU HQWPF VJGTG KV KU CUUWOGF VQ JCXG DGGP C TQ[CN FYGNNKPI OQWPF (TQO VQ &QTGUVCF YCU QPEG CICKP KP /GTQXKPIKCP JCPFU CPF CXCKNCDNG HQT OKPVKPI )QNF VTKGPVGU YQWNFPʼnV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM CP[ NQPIGT DGECWUG VJG CIG QH IQNF YCU QXGT #TQWPF UKNXGT GOGTIGF CU EQKPKPI OGVCN CPF KV KU OCKPN[ HQWPF KP UEGCVVCU 6JKU VKOG HTCOG QH FGXGNQROGPVU KU IGPGTCNN[ CFQRVGF PQYCFC[U UGG .CHCWTKG .G VT¾UQT Fʼn'UEJCTGP KP 40 R 6JGTG DGKPI CP[ OKPVKPI QH UKNXGT EQKPU KP &QTGUVCF KP VJG RGTKQF KU JKIJN[ KORTQDCDNG VJG[ YQWNF JCXG VQ DG UEGCVVCU 6JG EJCPEGU QH VJG UCOG JCR RGPKPI GNUGYJGTG CRRGCT TCVJGT UOCNN CU YGNN YCU CNUQ VJG [GCT QH 9KNNKDTQTFʼnU CTTKXCN KP 7VTGEJV JQYGXGT OCVVGTU WR PQTVJ YGTG UQ FCPIGTQWU VJCV JG JCF VQ EQPHKPG VQ QRGTCVKPI KP *GKNQQ CPF 'IOQPF 227


5VCTVKPI VJG YJQNG VGTTKVQT[ QH (TKUKC ITCFWCNN[ YCU DTQWIJV WPFGT %CTQNKPIKCP CWVJQTKV[ CPF EQKPU QH %JCTNGOCIPG .QWKU VJG 2KQWU CPF .QVJCKT + UVCTVGF DGKPI UVTWEM KP &QTGUVCF (TQO QP (TKUKC YCU RCTV QH .QVJCKTʼnU /KFFNG 4GCNO 5VCTVKPI VJG 6TGCV[ QH /GGT UUGP VJG GPVKTG VGTTKVQT[ HGNN WPFGT VJG 'CUV (TCPMU CPF KP KV ECOG WPFGT VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG )TCFWCNN[ VJG TGIKQPU VJCV QPEG OCFG WR )TGCV (TKUKC HGNN CRCTV 0GY TGIKQPU GOGTIGF *QNNCPF CPF 9GUVHTKGUNCPF VJG NCVVGT VGTTKVQT[ YCU C RCTV QH VJG FKUVTKEV QH *QNNCPF HTQO QP VJG GCUV RCTV QH (TKUKC %KVGTKQT DGECOG VJG FKQEGUG 7VTGEJV %GPVTCN (TKGUNCPF

HTQO VJG 8NKG VQ VJG .CWYGTU EQPUKUVKPI QH KP YGUV VQ GCUV QTFGT 9GUVGTIQ 1QUVGTIQ 9GUVGTMYCTVKGT *WPUKPIQ CPF (KXGNKPIQ CPF 'CUV (TKGUNCPF HTQO VJG .CWYGTU VQ VJG 9GUGT EQPUKUVKPI QH C Q 'OUKPIQ $TQMOGTNCPF 1UVTKPIGP CPF 4WUVTKPIGP 5QNGN[ *QNNCPF DGECOG C EQWPV[ 6JG VGTTKVQT[ VQ VJG GCUV QH VJG 8NKG YCU EQPVTQNNGF D[ PQP (TKUKCP RQYGTU 6JWU 9KEJOCPP QH *COGNCPF YCU KP C RCTV QH %GPVTCN (TKGUNCPF VJG $KNNWPIGTU KP 1UVTKPIGP VJG EQWPVU QH 5VCFG KP 4WUVTKPIGP YJQUG RNCEG YCU VCMGP D[ VJG EQWPVU QH 1NFGPDWTI 6JG EQWPVU QH 9GTN GZGTVGF EQPFQOKPKCN TKIJVU KP 'OUKPIQ CPF (KXGNKPIQ #PF HKPCNN[ VJG CTEJDKUJQRU QH *CODWTI $TGOGP #FCNDGTV CNUQ YCPVGF VJGKT UJCTG CPF LQKPGF VJG CTTC[ QH EQPVGPFGTU HQT RQYGT +P %GPVTCN (TKGUNCPF VJG EQWPVU QH *QNNCPF CPF VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV RNC[GF VJG OCKP RCTVU KP 'CUV (TKGUNCPF VJGTG YGTG VJG EQWPVU QH -CNXGNCIG 4CXGPUDGTI VJG DKUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT CPF VJG EQWPVU QH 1NFGPDWTI CU YGNN CU VJG *·WRVNKPIGP %JKGHVCKPU +P VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZV VJG YQTF FGPKGT KU WUGF HQT VJG EQKPU ECNNGF RGPPKPI KP *QNNCPF

&4104+,2 6;2' EC . # $WUV N YKVJ \KI\CI NKPG KP HTQPV CPF ETQUU QXGT VJG JGCF '# DGJKPF 4 %TQUU QP UVGR CPF INQDWNG DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU IT. 44 4GXGTUG WPEGPVGTGF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP #RTKN PQ 6JG &TQPTKLR V[RG VJG PCOG YCU IKXGP D[ $QGNGU R KU C EQKP V[RG VJCV IGPGTCNN[ KU HQWPF KP (TKGUNCPF

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

+OKVCVKQP /#&'.+075

6TKGPU. # $WUV T &14 Ì '56#6 (+6 4 %TQUU QP UVGR QXGT UKZ RGNNGVU KP VYQ NKPGU /#æ&'.+085/. $GNHQTV IT. 4 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP N PQ

&GPKGT. # $WUV T 4'56#(6+6 4 %TQUU QP UVGRU QXGT PKPG RGNNGVU ++%8++(68++. $GNHQTV IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP $QGT 6JG V[RG $GNHQTV HKVU VJG OQUV CNVJQWIJ KV KU PQV EQORNGVGN[ VJG UCOG VJG NGIGPFU FKHHGT # 4'56+6 (6 4 ++8'.u++85++ 6JG RGNNGVU RTGEGFKPI VJG VGZV FGTKXG HTQO VJG RGNNGVU VJCV CTG PQTOCNN[ WPFGT VJG JGCF

228


&GPKGT. # $WUV T QXGT VGP RGNNGVU &8%56#6 (+6 4 %TQUU QP UVGR QXGT UKZ RGNNGVU ++#&(.% Ő +++85 Ő ++. $GNHQTV IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 'Z %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ .QY UKNXGT[ IQNF EQPVGPV (QWPF KP 5NCRRGVGTR (T *GTG VJG RGNNGVU CTG UVKNN OCKPN[ WPFGT VJG JGCF +P VJG PQU CPF VYQ CURGEVU ECVEJ VJG G[G CNN VJTGG UJQY C OWEJ JKIJGT TGNKGH VJCP VJG TGCN /CFGNKPWU EQKPU QH &QTGUVCF CRCTV HTQO VJCV PQ KU OQTG UKNXGT[ VJCP PQ YJKEJ RTQDCDN[ OCMGU KV [QWPIGT CUUWOKPI VJG IQNF EQPVGPV YCU FGETGCUGF FWTKPI VJKU RGTKQF ;GV VJG JGCF VJG CEEQORCP[KPI RGNNGVU CPF VJG VGZV QP PQ UJQY C OQTG CFXCPEGF FGIGPGTCVKQP VJCP PQ 5JQWNFPʼnV VJG EQPENWUKQP DG VJCV VJGUG EQKPU CTG PQV HTQO VJG &QT GUVCF OKPV DWV YGTG OCPWHCEVWTGF GNUGYJGTG /QTGQXGT DQVJ NCUV EQKPU UGGO VQ UVGO HTQO FKHHGTGPV OKPVU 6JG JKIJ TGNKGH YG UGG JGTG KU HQWPF KP PWOGTQWU UEGCVVCU QH VJG & UGTKGU +PVGTNQECN %QPVKPGPVCN 0QTVJGTP

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ʼn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Ő 6JG *QWUG QH *QNNCPF Ő 6JG *CKPCWV *QWUG Ő 6JG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ 6JG $CXCTKCP *QWUG Ő 6JG $WTIWPFKCP *QWUG +P VJG NCUV RGTKQF ,CEQDC QH VJG *QWUG QH $CXCTKC RNC[GF C TQNG 229


6JG *QWUG QH *QNNCPF &+4- +8

&WG VQ JKU CFXCPEKPI EQNQPKUCVKQP &KTM +8 ENCUJGF YKVJ VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV CPF .K½IG YJQ YGTG DCEMGF D[ VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT HQT VJG[ JCF DGGP NQ[CN CNNKGU 6JWU *GPT[ +++ YCIGF YCT QP &KTM +8 YJQ JCF CNNKGF YKVJ )QFHTG[ VJG $GCTFGF UGG .QVJCTKPIKC KP &WTKPI VJG GPUWKPI ECORCKIP VJG ECUVNG QH 4KLPUDWTI COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU YCU NCKF KP TWKPU .CVGT C EJWTEJ YCU GTGEVGF JGTG YJKEJ YQWNF RTQXKFG C NCUV TGUVKPI RNCEG HQT OCP[ C EQWPV QH *QNNCPF 6JG GCTN[ EQWPVU CU &KTM +8 YGTG KPVGTTGF KP 'IOQPF #DDG[

&GPKGT 4KLPUDWTI. # %CTQNKPIKCP VGORNG YKVJ ETQUU KP EGPVTG 4+0'$74) 4 %TQUU UJCRGF NGVVGTU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING #' 6# '6 $6. &CPP )TQNNG C +NKUEJ IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG (KTUV EQKP QH *QNNCPF QPN[ MPQYP URGEKOGP KP RTKXCVG EQNNGEVKQP GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN #NDTGEJV MPGY QH QPN[ URGEKOGPU +NKUEJ MPQYU QH ,/2 R VJKU RKGEG KU KPENWFGF KP PGKVJGT *G IKXGU VJG HQNNQYKPI UWOOCT[ $GTNKP 5IN &CPPGPDGTI $GTNKP 5IN )TQVG $GTNKP /Ã’PEJGP &TGUFGP -QRGP JCIGP 5IN 6JQOUQP -2- HTQO #WEVKQP 5EJWNOCP PQ 5GG 2QVKP &G *QNNCPFUG OWPVUNCI KP FG G GGWY KP ,/2 R #NVJQWIJ -NWIG KP UVKNN FQWDVGF VJCV 4KPGDWTI KU KFGPVKECN YKVJ 4KLPUDWTI KV KU IGPGTCNN[ CEEGRVGF VJCV 4KLPUDWTI KU VJG RNCEG KPFKECVGF 9KVJ #NDTGEJV YG HKPF VJG HQNNQYKPI SWQVG Å‘ TGZÅ‘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

PQYCFC[U 'IOQPF DKPPGT

(.14+5 + &KTM +8 JCF PQ EJKNFTGP CPF JG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU DTQVJGT (NQTKU + (NQTKU YGFFGF )GTVTWFG QH 5CZQPKC C FCWIJVGT QH $GTPJCTF ++ &WMG QH 5CZQPKC (NQTKU + GUVCDNKUJGF JKOUGNH KP VJG ECUVNG QH .GKFGP CU VJG 4KLPUDWTI ECUVNG JCF DGGP FG UVTQ[GF (NQTKU YCU KPVGTTGF KP 'IOQPF

&GPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU VJTGG RGNNGVU N 8 / 4 $GCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC 8+0 . &CPP )TQNNG +NKUEJ IT. 44 'FIG HCWNV QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ &CPPGPDGTI ++ PQ OGPVKQPU %CV *GUU &CPPGPDGTI NGIGPF # 8'8+*&#4 4 8 8 0#'8 &CPPGPDGTI CNUQ EQPUKFGTU DKUJQR -QPTCF + &CPP C +NKUEJ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU VQ *QNNCPF DGECWUG VJG ETQUKGT YCU TGRNCEGF YKVJ C RGPPCPV HWTVJGT KV KU CP KOKVCVKQP QH 9KNNKCO QH 2QPV QH 7VTGEJV

230


)TQNNG FQGU PQV OGPVKQP VJKU V[RG *G RTQXKFGF OG YKVJ VJG HQNNQYKPI GZRNCPCVKQP CU VQ YJ[ PQV 6JKU EQKP KU RTQDCDN[ CVVTKDWVGF VQ .GKFGP D[ +NKUEJ QP VJG DCUKU QH KVU V[RG 7R VQ JGTG + EQPEWT YKVJ JKO CNDGKV RCTVN[ DWV QP VJG DCUKU QH KVU OCPWHCEVWTG + ECP PQV CVVTKDWVG VJKU EQKP VQ .GKFGP 6JG FKG KU OCFG WR CNOQUV GPVKTGN[ QH FQVU YJGTGCU FQEWOGPVGF .GKFGP URGEKOGPU CTG TCVJGT EWV KP NKPGU CPF CTEJGU &KGU EQPUKUVKPI OCKPN[ QH FQVU KPFKECVG C PQTVJGTP QTKIKP VJG GRKUEQRCN DWUV QT KOCIG KU TGNCVGF VQ VJG TQ[CN DWUV QH 'IDGTV ++ QH $TWPUYKLM CU OCTITCXG QH (TKGUNCPF G I +NKUEJ KP YJKEJ VJG RGPFCPVU YGTG TGRNCEGF YKVJ CNHC CPF QOGIC CPF VJG ETQYP KVUGNH QH EQWTUG YCU CFCRVGF +U VJKU C (TKUKCP KOKVCVKQP QT KU UQOGVJKPI GNUG CNVQIGVJGT! +NKUEJ FKHHGTU QP VJG RQUKVKQP QH VJG <WVRJGP EQWPV 6JG <WVRJGP EQWPVU CTG FGUEGPFCPVU QH C [QWPIGT JCNH DTQVJGT QH %QWPVGUU #FGNC QH *COCNCPF 1VVQ + QH <WVRJGP 6JGTG HQTG VJG[ CTG QH JKIJ PQDKNKV[ KP VGTOU QH CPEGUVT[ +P <WVRJGP VJGTG YGTG VJTGG EQOKVCN HWPEVKQPU <WVRJGP YCU CP CNNQFKCN RQUUGUUKQP YKVJ C UQXGTGKIP NQTF QT EQWPV VJGTG YCU CP GRKUEQRCN RTGHGEVWTG YKVJ CP GRKUEQRCN RTGHGEV QT EQWPV CPF VJGTG YCU CP KORGTKCN RCNCVKPG UKPEG YKVJ CP KORGTKCN EQWPV RCNCVKPG QT DWTITCXG XKUEQWPV 6JGUG QHHKEGU YGTG PQV CNYC[U JGNF D[ QPG RGTUQP DWV OQTG QHVGP FKXKFGF COQPI VJG OGODGTU QH C HCOKN[ YJQ D[ OCT TKCIG YGTG TGNCVGF VQ VJG .QTTCKPG EQWPVU RCNCVKPG HTQO #CEJGP 0QV WPVKN 1VVQ +++ YGTG VJGUG VJTGG HWPEVKQPU WPKVGF KP QPG RGTUQP CPF JG YCU TGHGTTGF VQ CU NQEWRNGVKUUKOWU EQOGU UKIPKH[KPI JKU EQODKPGF UVCVWU QH EQWPV KP CNN NQECN QHHKEGU #HVGT (TKGUNCPF RCUUGF VQ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV $KUJQR %QPTCF XGUVGF VJG OKNKVCT[ CWVJQTKV[ QXGT (TKGUNCPF 5VCXQTGP KP JKU RTGHGEV KP <WVRJGP +P VJCV ECUG EQKP YQWNF DG C (TKUKCP HCDTKE UVTWEM KP 5VCXQTGP QH VJG GRKUEQRCN CFXQECVWU YJQ YCU CNUQ RTGHGEV QH <WVRJGP K G 1VVQ +++ QH <WVRJGP YJQ JCF UWEEGGFGF JKU WPENG )GTNCEJ KP CU CNNQFKCN NQTF CPF KORGTKCN XKUEQWPV KP <WVRJGP 9KVJ TGICTF VQ VJG VGZVU )TQNNG FGGOU QD CPF TGXGTUG KFGPVKECN DWV CU VQ VJGKT ICTDNGF UVCVG JG EQPENWFGU VJCV PQ UGPUG ECP DG FGTKXGF HTQO VJGO VJGTGHQTG PQ 1VVQ CPF QT PQ 5VCXQTGP + CVVCEJ NKVVNG XCNWG VQ JKU TGCFKPI CPF HQT VJG VKOG DGKPI RTGHGT CVVTKDWVKQP VQ *QNNCPF YKVJQWV .GKFGP JQYGXGT

&+4- 8

#V VJG FGOKUG QH (NQTKU + VJGTG YGTG VJTGG EJKNFTGP &KTM 8 (NQTKU CPF $GTVJC $GTVJC YGF FGF -KPI 2JKNKR + QH (TCPEG (NQTKUʼn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

(NQTKU ++ CPF YCU GPVQODGF VQIGVJGT YKVJ JKU YKHG KP VJG CDDG[ EJWTEJ QH 'IOQPF

&GPKGT. # /QWPVGF CTOQWTGF OCP T ETQUU DGJKPF JKO 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU CPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING KP EGPVTG. &CPP )TQNNG $C +NKUEJ IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ &CPPGPDGTIʼnU FTCYKPI QH VJG EQKP TGCFU # #66'0 & 48/ TGVTQITCFG 4 #66'4 &48/ TGVTQITCFG +P VTWVJ VJGUG VGZVU CTGPʼnV CU ENGCT CU &CPPGPDGTI TGPFGTGF VJGO TGHGTGPEG VQ 6JQOUGP IO CPF -Ì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

231


&GPKGT. # %CUVNG QXGT DQY QH RGNNGVU NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING KP EKT ENG QH TKPIU '26. &CPP )T +NKUEJ IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG UNKIJVGN[ DGPV CPF UOCNN HNCP ETCEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

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ÒPINKEJ KP FGT 5COONWPI 8CP FGP $QICGTFG KP *CCTGP 0QQTF $TCDCPV LGV\V KP GKPGT 2TKXCVUCOONWPI DGHKPFNKEJG 5VÒEM YWTFG XQP 4QGUV KP FGP 4CWO $TCDCPV .KODWTI IGNGIV WPF /ÒPUVGTDKNUGP CNU /ÒP\UV·VVG HÒT OÌINKEJ GTCEJVGV &KG 4U IGJÌTV CDGT GKPFGWVKI KP FGP -QPVGZV XQP &CPP WPF 8QTIGMQOOGP KUV FGT 6[R CWEJ KO (WPF XQP 5RCPMQ

0T PWP KP $GTNKP XIN $CWGT KP <GKVUEJTKHV HÒT 0WOKUOCVKM &KG 4U .GIGPFG MÌPPVG GKP TGVTQITCFGU 64#+'%68/ GPVJCNVGP +NKUEJ MPQYU QH QPN[ VJTGG URGEKOGPU $GTNKP 5V 2GVGTUDWTI CPF VJG QPG CV JCPF CU KORNKGF VJG NCVVGT VYQ OKIJV DG QPG CPF VJG UCOG )TQNNG FQGU PQV OGPVKQP KV *G YTKVGU VJG HQNNQYKPI +NKUEJ KU RCTV QH C ITQWR QH YJKEJ +NKUEJ KU PQV EGTVCKP VJCV KU YCU OKPVGF D[ *QNNCPF + DGNKGXG +NKUEJ FQGUPʼnV DGNQPI VQ VJKU ITQWR KP URKVG QH JKU PQVKQP VJCV VJG GFKHKEG QH &CPP KU ENGCTN[ TGNCVGF VQ VJCV QH &CPP CPF + FQPʼnV UJCTG JKU QRKPKQP CPF YJCVʼnU OQTG + VJKPM VJG TGXGTUG YKVJ VJG DQTFGT QH TKPIU CTQWPF VJG ETQUU KU VQQ RQORQWU CPF PQV HTQO *QNNCPF #PF YJ[ YQWNF VJG EQWPV QH *QNNCPF JCXG 6TCKGEVWO KPFKECVGF QP JKU EQKPU YJGP JG JCF CNTGCF[ XGT[ HTCPMN[ KPFKECVGF .GK FGP 4KLPUDWTI QT #VGNDGTP QP GCTNKGT EQKPU! (KPCNN[ VJG FKOGPUKQPU QH VJKU EQKP KPFKECVG C FGPCTKWU NGXKU VJCV FQGU PQV DGNQPI VQ ITQWR + EQPEWT YKVJ [QWT CWVJQT QH VJKU RKGEG CUUWORVKQP VJCV DKUJQR -QPTCF YCU VJG OKPVKPI NQTF 9GKIJV CPF QDXGTUG QH VJG EQKP EQTTGURQPF YKVJ JKU EQKPCIG JQYGXGT VJG TGXGTUG FQGU PQV +P O[ QRKPKQP KV UJQWNF DG ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT UOCNN (NGOKUJ EQKPU &G 9KV FQGUP V EQPEWT YKVJ VJG NCUV CPF JCU MGRV KV WPFGT *QNNCPF OC[DG KV YKNN JCXG VQ IQ WPFGT 7VTGEJV NCVGT (NQTKU ++ KU EQPUKFGTGF VQ JCXG DGGP CP GPQTOQWUN[ YGCNVJ[ OCP TGXGPWGU HTQO RGCV CPF VQNNU 6JG QTKIKPCN (TKUKCP EJCTCEVGT QH VJG EQWPV[ XCPKUJGF WPFGT JKO CPF CV VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG PCOG *QNVNCPF DGECOG HCUJKQPCDNG PCOGF CHVGT QPG QH VJG XGT[ TKEJ EQTG VGTTKVQTKGU CV VJG OQWVJ QH VJG 1NF 4JKPG +P (NQTKU ++ YCU EQPUGSWGPVN[ TGHGTTGF VQ CU EQWPV QH *QNNCPF +PJCDKVCPVU YGTG ECNNGF *QNNCPFK (NQTKU YCU OCTTKGF VQ )GTVTWFG FCWIJVGT QH VJG FWMG QH 7RRGT .QTTCKPG 1P VJG QEECUKQP QH VJGKT OCTTKCIG UJG EJCPIGF JGT PCOG VQ 2GVTQPKNNC (NQTKU YCU DWTKGF KP 'IOQPF

&+4- 8+

#HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH (NQTKU ++ 2GVTQPKNNC TWNGF 5JG OCFG ITCXG OKUVCMGU GURGEKCNN[ YKVJ TGICTF VQ VJG CDDG[ QH 'IOQPF +P VJG OCKP CNVCT YCU EQPUGETCVGF D[ &KTM 8+ JKU YKHG 5QRJKC CPF VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 2GVTQPKNNC YCU PQV RTGUGPV &KTM 8+ YCU C JKIJN[ FGRGPFGPV CPF KTTGUQNWVG OCP EQPVTCT[ VQ JKU DTQVJGT (NQTKU VJG $NCEM YJQ YCU XGT[ CODKVKQWU HTQO VQ JG YCU EQWPV QH *QNNCPF CEMPQYNGFIGF D[ VJG 4QOCP MKPI CPF VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 2GVTQPKNNC HQWPFGF VJG CDDG[ EJWTEJ KP 4KLPUDWTI KP CPF FGUKIPCVGF KV VQ DG JGT VQOD &KTM 8+ HQWPFGF C NCTIG EJWTEJ KP 8NCCTFKPIGP YJKEJ ECWUGF C EQPHNKEV YKVJ 'IOQPF VJCV ENCKOGF VJG EJWTEJ D[ XKTVWG QH QNF TGEQTFU &KTM YCU KPVGTTGF PGZV VQ JKU OQVJGT CPF DTQVJGT KP 4KLPUDWTI

&GPKGT. # *GCF T 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG GPFKPI KP NKU UVCHH KP GCEJ CPING. )TQNNG C X* # IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV &GEGODGT PQ EH XCP *GPIGN 8QPFUVGP XCP G GGWYUG *QNNCPFUG ! OWPVGP KP ,/2 R

232


&+4- 8++ &KTMʼn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

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF 6*'1&'4 +% 4 %TQUU YKVJ 2 # : KP VJG CPINGU

* 1..#06 %1 /'5 . )TQNNG $C XF%J X* % IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ X *GPIGN FQGU PQV MPQY VJG QDXGTUG VGZV JG OGTGN[ OGPVKQPU 6*'1&4+% )TQNNG FQGU NKMGYKUG )TQNNG V[RG YKVJQWV UWP

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF 6*'1&4+% 4 %TQUU YKVJ 2 # : NKU ETQUU TGVTQITCFG KP VJG CPINGU *1..#0 6 % 1/'5. )TQNNG %C XF%J X* % IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ )TQNNG 6[RG % YKVJ UWP QP QDXGTUG PQV XKUKDNG JGTG CPF NKU QP TGXGTUG 6JG TGXGTUG VGZV FQGU PQV DGIKP C DWV YKVJ C ETQUU EQPUKUVKPI QH HQWT NQQRU

9+..'/ + 0COGF CHVGT VJG DTQVJGT QH JKU OQVJGT 9KNNKCO VJG .KQP QH 5EQVNCPF *G VQQM RCTV KP VJG VJKTF ETWUCFG VJCV QH +P VJKU ETWUCFG PQV QPN[ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC FKGF DWV 9KNNKCOʼn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

&GPKGT 5VCXQTGP!. # $WUV T YKVJ 5 KP HKGNF QP VJG DQTFGT VTKCPING CPF TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV CNVGTPCVKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG 5 KP GCEJ CPING QP VJG DQTFGT VTKCPING CPF RGNNGVU CNVGTPCVKPI. )TQNNG &C XF%J X* % IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO X *GPIGN FGUETKDGU VJG QDXGTUG $WUV T YKVJ UYQTF DWV KP O[ QRKPKQP KU VJGTG PQ UYQTF 5GG CNUQ XCP )GNFGT *QCTF #TPJGO ,/2 PQ WPNQECNKUGF EQKPU )TQNNG FGUETKDGU VJKU EQKP CU 9KNNKCO + QH *QNNCPF CU %QWPV QH (TKGUNCPF %QWNFPʼnV VJKU EQKP JCXG DGGP UVTWEM QP VJG QEECUKQP QH JKU OCTTKCIG VJG EGTGOQP[ QH YJKEJ VQQM RNCEG KP 5VCXQTGP

VJG 5 QP VJG QDXGTUG 5GG HWTVJGT GNWEKFCVKQP YKVJ %GPVTCN (TKGUNCPF

233


&GPKGT. # .KQP T WPFGT TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV . ' 1 KP HKGNF 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VTKCPINGU QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP TKPIU. )TQNNG XF%J X* # % IT. 44 (NCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODTG PQ 5GG XCP )GNFGT JQCTF QH VJ GGWYUG EQKPU KP #TPJGO KP ,/2 R G X PT &GYKUOGUʼn CVVTKDWVKQP VQ VJG EKV[ #KTG KU HCNUG KP XKGY QH VJG YGKIJV 6JG V[RG QH VJG QDXGTUG OCVEJGU VJCV QH UGXGTCN $TCDCPV RKGEGU HTQO CTQWPF VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJCV JQYGXGT CTG UWDUVCPVKCNN[ JGCXKGT CPF GZJKDKV C YJQNN[ FKHHGTGPV TGXGTUG # FG 9KVVG *KUVQKTG OQP¾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ʼn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ʼnV C OWEJ UKORNGT CPUYGT DG EQPUKFGTGF! 9KNNKCO YCU PCOGF CHVGT VJG 5EQVVKUJ 9KNNKCO VJG .KQP +U KV TGCNN[ VJCV TGOCTMCDNG VJCV JG JCF C EQKP UVTWEM YKVJ C NKQP RGTJCRU D[ C UQWVJGTP FKG UKPMGT DWV KP VJG 0QTVJ

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNOGV CPF UYQTF VJTGG ETQUU UCNVKTG QP VJG JGNOGV 9+..'/ 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ UOCNN ETQUUGU KP VJG CPINGU *1..#0&+#. )TQNNG $C XF%J X* % IT. 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 2NCEGOGPV QH VJG YQTF 9KNNKCO KU KFGPVKECN VQ EQKPU QH &KTM 8++

(.14+5 +8

9GFFGF VQ /CEJVGNF QH $TCDCPV FCWIJVGT QH &WMG *GPT[ + QH $TCDCPV 1P VJ 0QXGODGT JG DQWIJV C EQWTV KP YJCV YCU VQ DGEQOG 6JG *CIWG (NQTKU 8 JCF KV GZVGPFGF YKVJ C NCTIG JCNN VQFC[ʼnU TKFFGT\CCN *G YCU GPVQODGF KP 4KLPUDWTI

&GPKGT. # $WUV T Z (.14'05 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKOU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU Z *1..#06. )TQNNG C XF%J WPF X* % IT. 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG 0-4 ņ FG ,QPI 5VTWEM DGHQTG XCP *GPIGN V[RG #

&GPKGT. # $WUV T Z (.14'05 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU. Z *1..#06 . )TQNNG C XF%J WPF X* % IT. # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F 5VTWEM CHVGT XCP *GPIGN V[RG $ NQPI PGEM

234


&GPKGT. # $WUV T Z (.14'05 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU. Z *1..#06 . )TQNNG C XF%J WPF X* % IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5VTWEM CHVGT EH 2WKUVGT KP ,/2 R ņ XCP *GPIGN V[RG $ NQPI PGEM

&GPKGT. # $WUV T Z (.14'05 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU *1. .#0 6 . )TQNNG C XF%J WPF X* % IT. 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 5VTWEM CHVGT XCP *GPIGN V[RG $

1DQNG. # $WUV T Z (.14' 0 5 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU Z *1 .. #06 . )TQNNG C XF%J X* % IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

9+..'/ ++ 0QV JKU OQVJGT DWV 9KNNKCO DTQVJGT QH (NQTKU +8 DGECOG IWCTFKCP JG JQYGXGT FKGF UQQP RCUUKPI VJG QHHKEG VQ JKU QVJGT DTQVJGT 1VVQ DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 7PFGT 9KNNKCO ++ VJG GEQPQO[ DQQOGF $TCDCPVʼnU KPHNWGPEG KPETGCUGF 6JTQWIJ JKU $TCDCPV WPENG *GPT[ ++ JG YCU KPXQNXGF KP VJG DCVVNG CICKPUV 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM ++ *QYGXGT YJGP VJG NCVVGT YCU GZEQOOWPKECVGF D[ VJG RQRG KP *GPT[ ++ RWV 9KNNKCO HQTYCTF HQT VJG )GTOCP VJTQPG 1P VJG TF 1EVQDGT 9KNNKCO YCU GNGEVGF 4QOCP -KPI KP 9QGTKPIGP +P VJG DGIKPPKPI VJKU TCKUGF C NQV QH TGUKUVCPEG DWV JKU OCTTKCIG VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QH $TWPUYKEM ITCPFFCWIJVGT QH GORGTQT 1VVQ +8 COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU ECWUGF VJKPIU VQ VCMG C VWTP HQT VJG DGVVGT CPF JG YCU WPKXGTUCNN[ CEMPQYNGFIGF CNUQ D[ VJG 9GNHU +P VJG RQRG RTQRQUGF VJCV JG DG ETQYPGF GORGTQT DWV RTKQT VQ JKU EQTQPCVKQP JG RGTKUJGF QP VJG DCVVNGHKGNF QP VJG VJ QH ,CPWCT[ KP C ECORCKIP CICKPUV VJG 9GUV (TKUKCPU *KU DQF[ YCU JKFFGP KP *QQIYQWF YJGTG (NQTKU 8 YQWNF FKUEQXGT KV [GCTU NCVGT 9KNNKCO YCU DWTKGF KP VJG CDDG[ EJWTEJ QH /KFFGNDWTI &WTKPI VJG TGKIP QH (NQTKU 8 VYQ UKIPKHKECPV OQPGVCT[ OGCUWTGU YGTG VCMGP C 6JG KPVTQFWE VKQP QH VJG ITQU VQWTPQKU D 6JG EJCPIG QH VJG FQWDNG ETQUU VQ C UKPING ETQUU QH PQ 2WKUVGT JCF CNTGCF[ FTCYP CVVGPVKQP VQYCTF VJKU 'GP PKGWYG FCVGTKPI XCP FG FGPCTKK XCP FG ITCXGP WKV JGV *QNNCPFUG *WKU KP ,/2 R *G TGHGTTGF VQ VJG VTCPUHQTOCVKQP QH 'PINKUJ EQKPCIG +P 'PINCPF EJCPIGF HTQO VJG FQWDNG ETQUU VQ VJG UKPING ETQUU 9KVJKP C [GCT VJKU EJCPIG YCU CFQRVGF QP VJG OCKPNCPF KP VJG 5VGTNKPI QH $TCDCPV

&GPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ EQNNCT Z (.14'05 4 8QKFGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU Z *1 ..#0 6. )TQNNG C XF%J X* % IT. 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ 6JG EQNNCT UJCRGF U[ODQN EQPUVKVWVGU VJG QPN[ FKHHGTGPEG YKVJ VJG EQKPU QH (NQTKU 8 UGG CNUQ % X *GPIGN 2GPPKPI *QNNCPVU 8CP *GPIGN V[RG 'OKUUKQP ! ! +P VJG PCOG QH JKU HCVJGT (NQTKU +8 )TQNNG TGHGTU VQ X* DWV VJCV KU CP QDQNG +U KV V[RG $ QT KU KV ! +P VJG NCVGT DQQMNGV QH 8CP *GPIGN KV KU NKUVGF CU CICKP

235


(.14+5 8

#V VJG FGOKUG QH 9KNNKCO ++ JKU UQP (NQTKU 8 YCU „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

&GPKGT. # $WUV T Z ( .14'05 4 8QKFGF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU Z * 1 . . )TQNNG D XF%J WPF X* % IT. 4 &CTM 2CVKPC XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RQTVTCKV

&GPKGT. # $WUV N Z %1/'5 Z *1..# &+' 4 8QKFGF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING *1 .. #0 6Z. )TQNNG D XF%J X* % IT. 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP TGKIP QH (NQTKU VJG QXGTUGGT

$GTPCTFK 6TKGUV 5VTWEM CHVGT CPF DGHQTG XCP *GPIGN XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

&GPKGT. # $WUV N Z %1/'5 *1..#0&+' 4 8QKFGF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING *1 .. #0 6Z. )TQNNG F XF%J X* % IT. 5OCNN OKUVCMG KP VJG FKG XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM CHVGT CPF DGHQTG XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

236

&GPKGT. # $WUV N Z %1/'5 Z *1..# &+' 4 8QKFGF NQPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING *1 .. #0 6Z. )TQNNG D XF%J X* % IT. # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP


)TQU VQWTPQKU. # %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 68410+5 %+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU 4 +P PGT EKTENG (.14'6+ %1/'5Ő CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J 8 :2+. )TQNNG C XF%J X* % IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 8CP *GPIGN FQGUPʼnV OGPVKQP VJG RGNNGV CHVGT %1/'5 )TQNNG OGPVKQPU VYQ RGNNGVU CPF XCP *GPIGN VJTGG 5VTWEM CHVGT )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

)TQU VQWTPQKU. # %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085%+8+5 YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU 4 +PPGT EKTENG (.14'06+85 %1 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +J8 :2+. )TQNNG D XF%J X* % IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,WPG PQ )TQNNG GOKUUKQP 6JG KPVTQFWEVKQP QH VJG *QNNCPF UVGTNKPI RTQDCDN[ KP HQNNQYGF VJCV QH VJG ITQU VQWTPQKU +V HGCVWTGF CHVGT KVU 'PINKUJ GZCORNG C NQPI ETQUU RCVV¾G QP KVU TGXGTUG +P VJG GOKUUKQP QH VJGTG YCU C UKPING XCTKCVKQP YJGP C UJQTV ETQUU RCVV¾G YCU EJQUGP VJG QPG MPQYP QH VJG ITQU VQWTPQKU KP EQODKPCVKQP YKVJ C UQ ECNNGF 5EQVVKUJ RQT VTCKV UGG VJG PQU CPF #HVGT VJG GOKUUKQP VJG NQPI ETQUU RCVV¾G KU FGHKPKVKXGN[ CFQRVGF CPF VJG 5EQVVKUJ RQTVTCKV YCU VCMGP

&GPKGT. # $WUV N ( %1/'5 1..#0&+' PF . KUV QTPCOGPVGF YKVJ VTGHQKN 4 %TQUU /10'6 Ì # &14&4#%+. )TQNNG #C XF%J X* % IT. 4 &CTM 2CVKPC CPF UOCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

&GPKGT /GFGODNKM. # $WUV N ( %1/'5 1..#0&+' 4 %TQUU Ì /10' /'&'0$.'%. )TQNNG $C XF%J X* % IT. 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

0/$ #OUVGTFCO 5VTWEM KP XCP *GPIGN JCU C FKHHGTGPV URGNNKPI QH 1..#0&+' QP VJG QDXGTUG 1.. #0&+' XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 8CP *GPIGN KPFKECVGU VJCV KP PQ DQVJ VGZVU CTG RTGEGFGF D[ VJTGG RGNNGVU R[TCOKFCN 6JG QDXGTUG QH VJG EQKP CV JCPF FQGU PQV UJQY VJKU 8CP *GPIGN MPQYU QH URGEKOGPU QH YJKEJ CTG MGRV KP OWUGWOU CPF URGEKOGPU CNN KP OWUGWOU! 8CP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP )TQNNG &QTFTGEJV OKIJV JCXG ENCKOGF VJG EQOKVCN UGKIPKQTCIG FWG VQ QWVUVCPFKPI FGDVU QP VJG RCTV QH VJG EQWPV YJKEJ OKIJV RTQORVGF (NQTKU VQ CV NGCUV RCTVN[ UGEWTG TGXGPWGU D[ SWKEMN[ QRGPKPI WR C OKPV KP /GFGODNKM UGG 8CP )GNFGT ,2/ UGG ECV ++ PQVG

237


&GPKGT. # $WUV N Ì ( %1/'5 1..#0&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# &14 & %+. )TQNNG G XF%J X* % IT. 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 1P VJG TGXGTUG DGVYGGP & CPF %+ C VTGHQKN 8CP *GPIGN IKXGU C CNUQ KP VJG RKEVWTG *G YTKVGU QP V[RG #C CPF V[RG VJGTG KU C VTGHQKN VQQ CU QP VJG EQKPU QH )WK FG &CORKGTTG QH 0COWT 8CP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP UQ ECNNGF FQTFTCEGPUKU

&GPKGT. # $WUV N ¿ ( %1/'5 1..#0&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# &14 & %+. )TQNNG J XF%J X* % IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF XCP *GPIGN V[RG )TQNNG GOKUUKQP UQ ECNNGF FQTFTCEGPUKU

&GPKGT. # $WUV N ¿ ( %1/'5 1..#0&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# &14 & %+. )TQNNG J XF%J X* % IT. 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF KP GZECXCVGF GCTVJ HTQO VJG 4KFFGTUVTCCV -NQQUVGTUVTCCV CTGC KP 5NWKU 8CP *GPIGN V[RG

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ʼnU FGCVJ ,QJP QH #XGUPGU YCU UGPV HQT VQ CUUWOG CWVJQTKV[ QXGT *QNNCPF HQT HQWT [GCTU DWV KP VJKU RGTKQF ,QJP + FKGF EJKNFNGUU 6JKU YCU VJG GPF QH VJG *QWUG *QNNCPF CPF YKVJ ,QJP QH #XGUPGU CU ,QJP ++ 6JG *CKPCWV *QWUG GPVGTGF

&GPKGT. # $WUV N + ¶ %1/'5 *1.. #&+' ¶ 4 .QPI ETQUU /10 '6# &14 & %+. )TQNNG C XF%J X* % IT. 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

238


&GPKGT. # $WUV N + ¶ %1/'5 *1..#&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU /10 '6# &14 & %' ¶. )TQNNG D XF%J X* % IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 6JG KPVGTRWPEVKQP KP & %' KU C VTKCPING CV VJG GPF QH VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG VJTGG RGNNGVU +V KU 8CP *GPIGN DGECWUG VJG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG GPFU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU (TQO NKUV PQ )TQNNG GOKUUKQP

6JG *CKPCWV *QWUG

,QJP ++ QH #XGUPGU YCU GODTCEGF URQPVCPGQWUN[ CU VJG PGY EQWPV DWV 4QOCP -KPI #N DTGEJV QH #WUVTKC RTQXGF WPYKNNKPI VQ CEMPQYNGFIG JKU TWNG VJG MKPIʼnU CUUGPV YCU TGSWKTGF CU JG YCU VJG UW\GTCKP *QYGXGT YJGP ,QJP OCTEJGF QP 0KLOGIGP VJG MKPI YKVJFTGY JKU QD LGEVKQPU ,QJPʼnU DTQVJGT )W[ %QWPV QH *CKPCWV $KUJQR QH 7VTGEJV YCU ITCPVGF VJG EQPHKU ECVGF GUVCVGU QH )KLUDTGEJV QH #OUVGN CPF *GTOCP QH 9QGTFGP *G YQWNF NCVGT DGEQOG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV ;GV PQV CNN YGPV TKIJV PQY <GGNCPF YQWNF PQV [KGNF 6JG XKEVQT[ KP VJG $CVVNG QH VJG )QNFGP 5RWTU KP GPVKEGF VJG (NGOKUJ VQ CVVCEM *QNNCPF 6JG[ UWHHGTGF C FGXCUVCVKPI FGHGCV CICKPUV C *QNNCPF HNGGV EQOOCPFGF D[ VJG )GPQXGUG #FOKTCN 4GPKGT )TKOCNFK KP ,QJPʼn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ʼnU FCWIJVGT /CTICTGV YGFFGF JKO QH VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ +V OCTMU VJG HKTUV CRRGCTCPEG QH VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNU DCEJ KP *QNNCPF 9KNNKCO RTQXGF C RQYGTHWN OCP CPF C EWPPKPI PGIQVKCVQT 5VKNN *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *CKPCWV YGTG PQV GPVKTGN[ WPFGT JKU UYC[ VJG[ EQPUKUVGF QH PWOGTQWU HKGHU &WVEJ JGGTNKLMJGFGP CU HQT KPUVCPEG VJCV QH JKU DTQVJGT ,GCP FG $GCWOQPV 9JGP 9KNNKCO HGNN KNN ,GCP YCU JKU TKIJV JCPF +P 9KNNKCO FKGF *KU UQP 9KNNKCO +8 JCF JKU HCVJGTʼnU EQWTCIGQWU PCVWTG DWV NCEMGF JKU VCEV 9KNNKCO UVTWEM QPN[ UOCNN EQKPU KP VJG XGKP QH VJG JGCFU QH (NQTKU 8 CNVJQWIJ NCTIGT EQKPU JCF DGGP EKTEWNCVGF DGHQTG VJCV 1P JKU EQKPU 9KNNKCO JCF JKOUGNH KPFKECVGF CU 9KNNGO

&GPKGT. # *GCF N 9 ¶ %1/'5 *1..#0&+' ¶ 4 .QPI ETQUU /10 '6# &14 & %+. )TQNNG C XF%J X* % IT. 44 (GY MPQYP URGEKOGP 'FIG HCWNV FCTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO ITQWPF &G 9CCI KP &QTFTGEJV QP 8CP *GPIGN MPQYU QH QPN[ VYQ URGEKOGPU QPG KP C OWUGWO CPF QPG KP C RTKXCVG EQNNGEVKQP 0QV KP -2- )TQNNG OGPVKQPU QPG KP -2- CPF QPG KP &0$ )TQNNG GOKUUKQP #HVGT OWEJ CFQ 9KNNKCO +8 YGFFGF ,QCP JGKTGUU QH $TCDCPV *KU CKO YCU VQ EQPPGEV *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF YKVJ *CKPCWV VJTQWIJ $TCDCPV *QYGXGT KP VJG *WPFTGF ;GCTUʼn 9CT KIPKVGF 9JGP 'PINKUJ -KPI 'FYCTF +++ JCF JKOUGNH RTQENCKOGF MKPI QH (TCPEG KP KP )JGPV 9KNNKCO YCU QP JKU UKFG $WV VJGP 9KNNKCO YJQUG XGJGOGPEG FKFPʼnV RGTOKV JKO VQ UKV UVKNN XGT[ NQPI OCTEJGF CICKPUV VJG OWVKPQWU (TKUKCPU CPF OGV JKU GPF KP VJG FGXCUVCVKPI $CVVNG QH 5VCXQTGP KP 6JG FTGCO QH WPKVKPI $TCDCPV YKVJ *QNNCPF <GGNCPF *CKPCWV TGOCKPGF WPHWNHKNNGF 6JG OCVVGT QH UWEEGUUKQP VQ VJG *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *CKPCWV VJTQPGU CTQUG 9KNNKCOʼnU YKFQY TGNKPSWKUJGF KV CNN RTGUWOCDN[ DGECWUG QH VJG JKIJ FGDVU

239


9KNNKCO +8 QP JKU *QNNCPF EQKPU ECNNGF JKOUGNH )WKNNCWOG 1P TF &GEGODGT ,QJP +++ QH $TCDCPV CPF .QWKU QH /CGNG QH (NCPFGTU HQTIGF C OKNKVCT[ CPF GEQPQOKE CNNKCPEG KP )JGPV KP YJKEJ CP CUUQEKCVG EQKP YCU CNUQ RTQXKFGF 6JG EQORCIPQP CHVGT VJG $TCDCPV V[RG DGECOG VJGKT PGY EQPXGPVKQPCN EQKP 1P VJG TF /CTEJ 'FYCTF +++ QH 'PINCPF YCU CFOKVVGF KPVQ VJKU OQPGVCT[ WPKQP CPF 4GKPQWF ++ QH )WGNFGTU CPF JKU OCTKQPGVVG VJG 7VTGEJV $KUJQR ,QJP QH &KGUV LQKPGF UWDUGSWGPVN[ 9KNNKCO +8 CNUQ CEEGFGF VQ VJKU WPKQP KP #RTKN )TQNNG RCTV + R 6JG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ 6JG $CXCTKCP *QWUG /CTICTGV YCU .QWKU VJG $CXCTKCPʼnU YKHG 5JG TGEGKXGF VJG VGTTKVQTKGU QH *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF VJG JGGTNKLMJGKF (TKGUNCPF KP HKGH KP UJG CNTGCF[ YCU EQWPVGUU QH *CKPCWV 6JWU VJG VTCPUKVKQP HTQO VJG *CKPCWV *QWUG VQ VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ YCU EQORNGVGF KP $[ ,WPG QH VJG UCOG [GCT .QWKU YCU ECNNGF DCEM VQ /WPKEJ CU FCTM ENQWFU YGTG ICVJGTKPI QXGT VJG GORKTG +P .QWKU FKGF CPF /CTICTGV NGHV *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF VQ 9KNNKCO 8 YJQ DGECOG EQWPV QH DQVJ DWV UVC[GF KP QHHKEG JGTUGNH KP *CKPCWV 9JGP OCVVGTU KP $CXCTKC JCF UGVVNGF D[ /CTICTGV QPEG OQTG WUWTRGF CNN RQYGT $CEMGF D[ C ITQWR QH PQDNGU *QQMU /CTICTGV VTKGF VQ UGNN *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF VQ VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI 'FYCTF +++ 6JKU ECWUGF EKXKN YCT *QQM CPF %QF 9CTU VJCV KP YQWNF DG FGEKFGF KP VJG PCXCN DCVVNG CV <YCTVGYCCN YJGTG 9KNNKCO FGHGCVGF /CTICTGV 4GPGYGF CFXCPEGU VQYCTFU 'PINCPF YGTG EQPUQNKFCVGF KP VJG OCTTKCIG QH 9KNNKCO 8 VQ /CEJVGNF FCWIJVGT QH *GPT[ QH .CPECUVGT 6JKU OCTTKCIG UCHGIWCTFGF VJG CWVQPQOQWU GZKUVGPEG QH *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF CPF JGTCNFGF C RGTKQF QH ENQUG EQNNCDQTCVKQP YKVJ 'PINCPF 9+..'/ 8 #HVGT JKU OQVJGTʼn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

)TQU CW NKQP # .KQP TCORCPV N /10'6# Z *1.#0& YKVJKP DQTFGT QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP 4 +PPGT EKTENG )8+. .'./ &8:% 1/'5 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%685 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG. $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F PF GOKUUKQP .GGWYGPITQQV UQ ECNNGF (NGOKUJ )TQCV NCVGT QWFG &QTFVUG ITQQV +OKVCVKQP QH VJG NKQP ITQCV QH .QWKU FG %T¾E[ QH (NCPFGTU UGG PQ

240


)TQU CW NKQP. # .KQP TCORCPV N /10'6# *1.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF )8+. .'./ &8: % 1/'5. 'X) )TQNNG E XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ PF GOKUUKQP

)TQU CW NKQP. # .KQP TCORCPV N )8+.'./ 5 &8: %1/ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# *1. #0&. 'X) C )TQNNG #C XF%J IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP HKPG . 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO PF GOKUUKQP )TQNNG ECNNU VJKU EQKP RGPPKPI # 6[RG YKVJ NQPI ETQUU )TQNNG MPQYU QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP KP JKU -2-

/QWVQP FʼnQT. # .COD YKVJ UVCPFCTF KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT & ). %1 J #)0 „ &'+ „ 38+ „ 61.. „ 2'%# „ /8&+ „ /+5'4'4' 01$ 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP EGPVTG CPF QPG GCING KP GCEJ CPING :2% ¤ 8+0%+6 ¤ :2% ¤ 4')0#6 ¤ :2% ¤ +/2'4#6. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP & ). %1 J KU VJG UJQTVGPKPI QH &8: )8+..'./85 %1/'5 *1..#0&+' 6JG IQNFGP NCOD KU CP KOKVCVKQP QH ,QJP VJG )QQF QH (TCPEG CPF KV YCU KOKVCVGF KVUGNH D[ ,GCPPG CPF 9GPEGENCU QH $TCDCPV CPF .QWKU QH /CGNG QH (NCPFGTU

&WDDGNG )TQQV QH 2NCM. # 5KVVKPI NKQP N YKVJ VQWTPG[ JGNOGV )8+..'./85 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/'5 ¶ *1.# ¶ < ¶ <'.#0&+' 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10'6# HNCOGF ETQUU &' HNCOGF ETQUU J .#0&+# CTQWPF HNQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+%685 ¶ 37+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &1/+0+. 'X) )TQNNG D XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F XF%J 'X) 'OKUUKQP 2TQDCDN[ OKPVGF KP &QTFTGEJV 6JKU NKQP UGLCPV KU CP KPHGTKQT KOKVCVKQP QH VJG (NGOKUJ FQWDNG ITQCV QH .QWKU QH /CGNG KPVTQFWEGF KP

241


&WDDGNG )TQQV QH 2NCM. # .KQP UKVVKPI N YKVJ VQWTPG[ JGNOGV )8+..'./85 £ &8: £ %1/'5 £ *1. £ + £ <'.#0&+' 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10'6# HNCOGF ETQUU 018# HNCOGF ETQUU J .#0&+# CTQWPF HNQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+%685 £ 38+ £ 8'0+6 £ +0 £ 01/+0' £ &1/+0+. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 2CVKPC XGT[ HKPG 4QOWPV 4QGTOQPF 2NCM RNCEMGOGGWY 'OKUUKQP

2NCM. # .KQP UKVVKPI N YKVJ VQWTPG[ JGNOGV )8+..'./ &8: %1/ * < <'. 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ * . # & KP VJG CPINGU $0&+%6 3 8'0+6 +0 0' &0+. 'X) )T C XF%J IT. 4 5RGEMNGF RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP &QTFTGEJV 'OKUUKQP /QPG[GT /CJGW QH .WG\G CPF ,CEQOCTV QH #UUEJG

)WNFGP # TQPFG ). # %QWPV UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC NKQP TCORCPV N )8+.. &8: %1/'5 *1.., 4 &WVEJ $CXCTKCP GUEWVEJGQP KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU (.14+0+ ¤ &' ¤ *1.#0& ¤ < ¤ <'. . &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG #C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F $GVYGGP VJG NGIU QH VJG EQWPV VYQ UVCTU )WNFGP QWFG &QTFVUG QT 9KNNKCOWUIWNFGP 'OKUUKQP

)WNFGP $ UEJGTRG ). # %QWPV UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC NKQP TCORCPV N )8+.. &8: %1/'5 *1.., 4 &WVEJ $CXCTKCP GUEWVEJGQP KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU FLORINI ¤ &' *1.#0& ¤ + ¤ <'. . &GNO 'X) (D )T $C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG 9KPVGT &Ã’UUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ $GVYGGP VJG NGIU QH VJG EQWPV VYQ UVCTU )WNFGP QWFG &QTFVUG QT 9KNNKCOWUIWNFGP 'OKUUKQP

242


*QNNCPFUG ITQQV V[RG #. # *GNOGV KP SWCVTGHQKN DGVYGGP VYQ &WVEJ $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU CPF QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING )8+..'./ ¤ &8: ¤ %1/ ¤ *1.# ¤ < ¤ <'.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU BENED(ICT) ¤ 38+ ¤ 8'0+6 ¤ + ¤ 01/+0+' ¤ &0+. 'X) )TQNNG #C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNCPFUG ITQQV V[RG $. # *GNOGV KP SWCVTGHQKN DGVYGGP VYQ &WVEJ $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU CPF QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING )8 /+.'./ £ &8: £ %1/ £ *1.# £ + £ <'.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $0&+%6 £ 38+ £ 8'0+6 £ + 01/+' £ &0+. 'X) )T $D XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JGTG KU CPQVJGT URGEKOGP PQ YKVJ <'.# KPUVGCF QH <'.#0& V[RG $ 'OKUUKQP # KPVGTRWPEVKQP YKVJ FQWDNG ETQUUGU )TQNNG IKXGU 01/+0' KPUVGCF QH 01/+0+' /CPWHCEVWTG QH VJKU V[RG YCU EGCUGF KP

8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO 6[RG $ KPVGTRWPEVKQP YKVJ FQWDNG TJQODK 6JG KPUETKRVKQP QP VJG QDXGTUG FQGU PQV OCVEJ )TQNNGʼnU FGUETKRVKQP 'OKUUKQP

.CDC[G. # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU KP VTGHQKN YKVJ VTGHQKNU KP VJG CPINGU )8+..'./ ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1.#0& ¶ < ¶ <'.# 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10 '6# *1. #0& CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+. 'X) )T C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP (TQO JQCTF <WVRJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ .CDC[G YKVVG ITQQV 'OKUUKQP

0KGWYG ITQQV. # *GNOGV KP SWCVTGHQKN DGVYGGP VYQ &WVEJ $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU CPF QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING )8+..'./ ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1.#0& ¶ + ¶ <'.# 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10 '6# *1. #0& CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CU WUWCN HQT VJKU KUUWG QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP *KTUEJ ņ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ PF GOKUUKQP 8CP )GNFGT EQPUKFGTU VJKU EQKP C J[DTKF HCDTKE QH C .CDC[G YKVJ C NKIJV ITQCV QDXGTUG VJG KPEQPUKUVGPV KPVGTRWPEVKQP YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG IKXGU TKUG VQ VJG UWURKEKQP VJCV VJG V[RG CV JCPF KU CP KPFGRGPFGPV QPG 6JKU KU EQPHKTOGF D[ VJG V[RG QH VJG SWCTVGT PGY ITQCV 'X)

243


#.$4'%*6

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

DGHKVVKPI QH JKU $CXCTKCP CPEGUVT[ #NDTGEJVʼn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ʼnV DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF HTQO VJG URGEKOGPU UVTWEM KP &QTFTGEJV # YJQNGJGCTVGF CVVTKDWVKQP VQ )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI KU RQUUKDNG HQT VJG PQU CPF 2WKUVGT KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R HQT TGCUQPU QH YGKIJV CPF EQPVGPV (QT CVVTKDWVKQP VQ )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI CNUQ UGG ,/2 R

)TQQV )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI. # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING #.$'4685 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. # ¶ < ¶ <'. # . 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10 '6# *1. #0& CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO 'OKUUKQP )TQQV UQ ECNNGF CNDGTVWU <KLRUG ITQQV

)TQQV )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING #.$'4685 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1.# ¶ + ¶ <'.# . 4 +PPGT EKTENG /10 '6# *1. #0& CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO 'OKUUKQP EH VJG PQVKEG CV PQ

244


)QWFGP UEJKNF. # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG YKVJ UYQTF CPF &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF #'.$'46 ¤ &8: Z %1/ Z *1.#0& ¤ < ¤ <'. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG C XF%J IT. # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG )QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP

)QWFGP UEJKNF. # 6YQ NKQPU JQNFKPI &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF YKVJ TQUG KP HKGNF #'.$'4685 Z &8: Z %1/'5 Z *1.#0&+' Z < Z <'.#0&+ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG CPF * . # & KP VJG CPINGU $'0'&+%685 „ 38+ „ 8'0+6 „ +0 „ 01/+0' „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

245


)TQQV V[RG $ YKVJ TQUG )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI. # 'CING QXGT VYQ UJKGNFU YKVJ TQUG DGVYGGP VJGO #.$'4685 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. # ¶ < ¶ <'.#0 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ * . # & KP VJG CPINGU $0&+%6 3 ¶ 8'0+6 +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &0+. 'X) )TQNNG $C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ (TQO JQCTF <WVRJGP )TQNNG JCU <'. KPUVGCF QH <'.#0 CNUQ PQ $ V[RG YKVJ TQUG CHVGT /C[ 'OKUUKQP )TQCV UQ ECNNGF *QNNCPFUG ITQQV CFGNCCTUITQQV GCINGʼnU ITQCV LCPIGNCCT LCPIGNGP VQ WUG VCNQPU D[ CP GCING XQGVFTCIGT QH CFGN[GPITQQV /KPVOCUVGT *GPFTKM #FGN[GP EH CNUQ ,/2 ++ R

)TQQV V[RG $ YKVJ TQUG )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI. # 'CING QXGT VYQ UJKGNFU YKVJ TQUG DGVYGGP VJGO #.$'4685 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. # ¶ + ¶ <'.#0 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ * . # & KP VJG CPINGU $0&+%6 3 ¶ 8'0+6 +0 ¶ 01/+ ¶ 0' ¶ &0+. 'X) )TQNNG $C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

)WNFGP. # %QWPV UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF DGVYGGP NKQP CPF $CXCTKCP UJKGNF TQUG DGVYGGP VJG RCYU #.$'4 Ã &8: Ã %1/'5 Ã *1. 4 &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP OWNVKNQDG (.14+0+ ¤ &' ¤ *1.#0& ¤ < ¤ <'. . &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 4 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RCVKPC 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ 5Q ECNNGF PGY CNDGTVWU IWNFGP +P #RTKN! OCPWHCEVWTG QH IWKNFGTU CV )GGTVTWKFGPDGTI YCU CRRCTGPVN[ TGUWOGF CNVJQWIJ VJG QTFKPCPEG QH /C[ FKF PQV RTQXKFG VJKU 'OKUUKQP 1TFQPPCPVKG #RTKN !

246


2CUCPV. # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF QP GCING N #.$'46 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. ¶ <'+. ¶ < ¶ &5 ¶ (4+<+' 4 (NQTKCVGF %TQUU /10'6# ¶ *1..#0 ¶ <'+.#0 ¶ < ¶ (4+<+'. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 44 2QUUKDN[ VJG UGEQPF MPQYP URGEKOGP 8GT[ HKPG )QTP[ /QUEJ /Ã’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

)TQQV. # %TQYPGF JGNOGV KP SWCVTGHQKN DGVYGGP &WVEJ CPF $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING #.$'4685 £ &8: £ %1/ £ *1.# £ < £ <'. # 4 (NQTKCVGF %TQUU $0&+%6 £ 38+ £ 8'0+6 £ + £ 01/+' £ &0+ . 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

)TQQV. # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF WPFGT ETQYPGF JGNOGV #.$'46 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1.# ¶ < ¶ <'.#0 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ JGNOGV KP VJG UV DCXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VJG PF CPF NKQP KP VJG TF CPING 018# /10'6# *1..#0 < ¶ <'.#0. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 'OKUUKQP )TQQV XCP *QNNCPF VQPUUWUITQQV /KPVOCUVGT 9KNNGO 6QPUUWU

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 5Q ECNNGF MQQROCPUITQQV GOKUUKQP

)TQQV. # *GNOGV YKVJ RNWOG QXGT &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF #.$'46 ¶ &8 : ¶ %1/ ¶ J1. # 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ¶ 018# /10' 6# ¶ * 1..# . 'X) )TQNNG D XF%J IT. 44 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP FKIIGF QWV ITQWPF PGCT VJG EJWTEJ QH 1QUVGTNCPF 'OKUUKQP )TQNNG FQGUPʼnV OGPVKQP UWEJ URGEKOGP

247


)TQQV. # *GNOGV YKVJ RNWOG QXGT &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF #.$'46 ¶ &8: ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. 4 .QPI ETQUU ¶ 018# /10' 6#¶* 1. #. 'X) )TQNNG XF%J IT. 44 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP &QTFTGEJV %H 4GXWG FG NC 0WOKUOCVKSWG $GNIG R PT 2TGUWOCDN[ UVTWEM WPFGT VJG 1TFKPCPEG QH 'OKUUKQP

9+..'/ 8+ 6JG TGNCVKQPUJKR DGVYGGP #NDTGEJV CPF 9KNNKCO 8+ YCU DCF OQUV QH VJG VKOG +P 9KNNKCO UWEEGGFGF VJG UCOG [GCT KP YJKEJ JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU VQQM QXGT KP $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU 5JQTVN[ DGHQTG JKU FCWIJVGT ,CEQDC ,WN[ YCU DQTP 9KNNKCO UWRRQTVGF JKU DTQVJGT ,QJP DKUJQR GNGEV QH .K½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

6JW[PG FyQT. # #PIGN KP ICTFGP HGPEG YKVJ VJG &WVEJ $CXCTKCP EQCV QH CTOU )8+..'4/ ¤ &8: ¤ &'+ ¤ )4# ¤ %1/ ¤ *#010+' ¤ *1. ¤ < ¤ <'. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG CPF SWCVTGHQKN KP EGPVTG VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCINGU KP GCEJ CPING ).14+# ¤ +0 ¤ ':%'.5+5 ¤ &'1 ¤ < ¤ +0 ¤ 64# ¤ 2#: ¤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ʼnXG ENCUUKHKGF KV WPFGT *QNNCPF 6JGTG CTG VJTGG URGEKOGPU QPG KP VJG ECDKPGV KP $TWUUGNU QPG KPKVKCNN[ KP VJG EQNNGEVKQP /G[GT CPF CHVGT VJCV KP VJG EQNNGEVKQP 6J¾T[ RTGUGPV NQECVKQP WPMPQYP CPF VJKU QPG 6JG[ CNN EQPVCKP VJG UCOG VGZV CPF KPVGTRWPEVKQP UQNG FKH HGTGPEG KU VJCV VJG TGXGTUG QH VJG EQKP /G[GT 6J¾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

8CP )GNFGT PQ ,CPUG CPF 8CP 6QN

248


)TQQV. # (GPEG )8+.*'./ &: %1/ *1.#0 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 018 ¶ /10 *1. ¶ <'. . 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 44 5RGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF HKPG

)TQQV. # .KQP TCORCPV )8+.*' Z Z &: ¤ J1.# 4 *GCF QH %JTKUV QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU /10 '6# ¤ *1.# ¤ < ¤ <' . 'X) )TQNNG $C XF%J IT. 44 (NCP FGHGEV CPF YGCMN[ UVTWEM HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP &QTFTGEJV 'OKUUKQP #EJVUVG ITQQV JCNH VWKPMG 6JG VJ ITQCV YCU KUUWGF CV C TCVG DGNQY KVU KPVTKPUKECN XCNWG FWG VQ YJKEJ VJG NGICN XCNWG YCU NKOKVGF QP VJ &GEGODGT

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP *KTUEJ ņ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ PQ 'OKUUKQP %C RTQDCDN[ OKPVGF D[ ,QJP 4CUQKT CV C NKIJVGT UVCPFCTF )TQNNG JCU & KPUVGCF QH &: QP QDXGTUG 6JKU V[RG YCU EQRKGF HTQO VJG OGTEJCPVʼnU EQKP QH 9KNNKCO 6QPUUWU YKVJ KN 8QNVQ 5CPVQ

)QWFGP UEJKNF. # %QWPV QP VJTQPG KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF )8+..'./ ¤ &8: %1/ *1.#0& ¤ < ¤ <'. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% +/2'4#6. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 9GNN CPF UJCTR UVTWEM 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5-# <ÒTKEJ 6JG *QNNCPF UJKGNFU QH 9KNNKCO 8 CPF QH 9KNNKCO 8+ ECPʼnV DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF CRCTV HTQO VJGKT YGKIJV 6JG YGKIJV QH VJG EQKPU QH 9KNNKCO 8+ KU CPF QH VJQUG QH 9KNNKCO 8 KU 6JKU IQNF UJKGNF VJGTGHQTG DGNQPIU WPFGT 9KN NKCO 8+ 'OKUUKQP

&GTFG IQWFGP UEJKNF. # %QWPV QP VJTQPG YKVJ UYQTF CPF &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF )8+.'/ ¤ &8: %1/ *1. ¤ < <'.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%6 „ :2% „ 4')06 „ :2% „ +/246. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP

249


&WDDGNG NGGWY. # .KQP TCORCPV N )8+./ ¶ &8: ¶ &'+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /106 ¶ 018# ¶ *1.#& ¶ < ¶ <'.# . 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 4 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG . 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP

.GGWY. # .KQP TCORCPV N )8+./ ¶ &8: ¶ &'+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1/ ¶ *1. ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /106 ¶ 018# ¶ *1.#& ¶ < ¶ <'.#. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP

)TQQV. # .KQP TCORCPV N )8./ ¶ &: ¶ &' ¶ )4 ¶ %1 ¶ *1. ¶ <'. 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10 ¶ 018# ¶ *1.& ¶ <'.#. 'X) )TQNNG C XF%J IT. 4 (NCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #RTKN PQ 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP *KTUEJ ņ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP

#HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH 9KNNGO 8+ ,CEQDC FKFPyV GPVGT VJG VJTQPG CWVQOCVKECNN[

250


,#0 QH $#8#4+# 5WEEGUUKQP VQ VJG VJTQPG CTQWUGF VJG CVVGPVKQP QH OCP[ RTGVGPFGTU ,QJP QH $CXCTKC YCU VJG [QWPIGUV UQP QH #NDTGEJV #NDTGEJV JCF WUGF JKU KPHNWGPEG KP VQ GPUWTG ,QJPʼnU CRRQKPV OGPV VQ DKUJQR GNGEV QH .K½IG 6JG RGQRNG QH .K½IG TGUKUVGF VJKU CRRQKPVOGPV JQYGXGT CPF JG PGXGT DGECOG DKUJQR *G KP HCEV TGCNN[ YCU PQV EWV QWV VQ IQ KPVQ ENGTKECN QHHKEG JG YCU OWEJ OQTG QH C MPKIJV 9JGP JKU DTQVJGT #NDTGEJV FKGF ,QJP YGPV VQ $CXCTKC VQ DGEQOG FWMG VJGTG QPEG JKU HCVJGT JCF FKGF ,QJP YCU NQQMKPI VQ TGKPHQTEG JKU CWVJQTKV[ KP VJG $CXCTKCP GPVCKNGF GUVCVG CPF C OCTTKCIG YCU KOOGFKCVGN[ CTTCPIGF DGVYGGP ,CEQDC CPF ,GCP +8 QH $TCDCPV VQ JCNV ,QJPʼnU GPFGCXQWTU $WV D[ VJG PGZV [GCT VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT 5KIKUOWPF JCF ITCPVGF ,QJP ,CEQDCʼnU EQWPVKGU *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF KP HKGH #PF CNVJQWIJ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF OGFKCVGF VJG NCPFU GXGPVWCNN[ YGTG EGFGF VQ ,QJP KP VJG VTGCV[ QH 9QWFTKEJGO VJ (GDTWCT[ ,QJP TGUKFGF KP 6JG *CIWG YKVJ 8CP $QTUGNGP CU C XCUUCN KP <GGNCPF 6JGTG YGTG PQ EJKNFTGP +P VJG MPKIJV ,QJP QH 8NKGV CVVGORVGF OWTFGTKPI ,QJP D[ RQKUQPKPI JKO +V KPKVKCNN[ CRRGCTGF JG HCKNGF DWV ,QJP FKGF QH VJG EQPUGSWGPEGU KP ,CPWCT[

&WKV. # &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF KP HTQPV QH DTCPEJ YKVJ PKPG NGCXGU +1*0'5 Ő & $#8#4+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ DCXCTKCP UJKGNF KP VYQ CPINGU /0'6# 018# )*14+%8. 'X) )TQNNG # C XF%J IT. 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ #NUQ ECNNGF 5YGTVG 2GTJCRU UVTWEM KP )QTKPEJGO +P VJKU YCU YJGTG ,QJP QH $CXCTKCʼnU OCKP TGUKFGPEG YCU CPF YJGTG JG JCF JKU JGCFSWCTVGTU 1P VJ ,WPG &QTFTGEJV YCU VJG QPN[ OKPV 8CP )GNFGT EQPUKFGTU KV NKMGN[ VJCV VJKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM KP &QTFTGEJV YKVJ C OKUNGCFKPI TGHGTGPEG VQ )QTKPEJGO ,QJP QH $CXCTKC QYPGF &QTFTGEJV D[ DWV CV VJCV VKOG OKPVKPI YCUPʼnV [GV CNNQYGF VJGTG UGG X) R 2TQFWEVKQP OWUV JCXG VCMGP RNCEG DGHQTG VJ (GDTWCT[ DGECWUG CHVGT VJCV VKOG VJG VKVNG YCU HKNKWU QKT QH *QN NCPF CPF <GGNCPF 'OKUUKQP 'NWEKFCVKQP KP 8CP )GNFGT /KPVKPI UVCTVGF FWTKPI VJG YCT VJG V[RGU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG CU VJQUG ,QJP JCF UVTWEM KP VJG NCUV [GCTU QH JKU TGKIP QXGT VJG FKQEGUG CU GNGEV QH .K½IG 1PG EQKP VJG UCOG CU VJG DTWNGU UVTWEM KP 6QPIGTGP CPF *CUUGNV DGCTU VJG TCVJGT KPUKIPKHKECPV NGIGPF ,QJP QH $CXCTKC JQYGXGT GZRNKEKVN[ UVCVGU VJG OKPV QH )QTKPEJGO

)TQQV. # &WVEJ CPF $CXCTKCP UJKGNF DGVYGGP VYQ DQYU +1* ¶ &8: ¶ $#8#4 ¶ (+.+ ¶ *#0 ¶ *1.. < < 4 %TQUU KP VJG CPINGU $CXCTKCP UJKGNF JGNOGV NKQP CPF DWING 2#: ¶ &0+ ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01$+5%8/ ¶ < ¶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ʼnV CNN TGVTKGXGF 0QTOCNN[ VJG QDXGTUG FQGU PQV KPENWFG *#0 *CKPCWV UQOGVKOGU KV FQGU RT¾VGPVKQP SWK PG TGRQPFCKV RCU ¯ NC T¾ CNKV¾ FGU EJQUGU RTGVGPVKQWU CPF YJQNN[ FGVCEJGF HTQO VJG TGCNKV[ QH VJKPIU

251


)QWFIWNFGP. # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UVCHH 5 +1J#00'5 $#$6+56# Þ 4 (QWT UJKGNFU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ VJG *QN[ 4QOCP 'ORKTG FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP VJG EGPVTG CPF $CXCTKC 'CING 5KIKUOWPF! %TQUU EJTKUVKCP DGNKGH! CPF *QNNCPF NKQP CTQWPF KV &8: $#8# +1* (+.+ *# *1.#0& <. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG # C XF%J IT. 4 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 6[RG 5V ,QJP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG 7VTGEJV IWKNFGT VJCV DKUJQR (TGFGTKEM QH $NCPMGPJGKO OCPWHCEVWTGF KP 4JGPGP 6JKU 4JGPGP IWKNFGT YCU CP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG )WGNFGTU 5V ,QJPUIWKNFGT QH QH 4GKPQWF +8 QH )WGNFGTU VJCV YCU CNUQ EQRKGF KP /QTU D[ (TGFGTKEM QH /QTU 5CCTYGTFGP +V EQTTGURQPFGF YKVJ VJG 4KLPUG XGT FTCIUIWNFGP QH

6WKP. # .KQP N YKVJ *1.& KP GZGTIWG +1* „ &8: „ $#8# „ (+.+ „ *#010+' „ *1.#0& „ < < 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ $CXCTKCP UJKGNFU CPF VYQ JGNOGVU KP VJG CPINGU 2#: „ &0+ „ 5+6 „ 01$+5%8/ „ < „ /#0'#6 „ 5'/. 'X) )TQNNG # D XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

)TQQV. # .KQP N YKVJ *1.& KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF +1* „ &8: „ $#8# „ (+.+ „ *#010+' „ *1. < 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ $CXCTKCP UJKGNFU CPF VYQ JGNOGVU KP VJG CPINGU 2#: „ &0+ „ 5+6 „ 01$+5%8/ „ < „ /#0'#6. 'X) )TQNNG # C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

*GMTC 1RJGOGTV 'OKUUKQP

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ 'Z HKPF $TGFC

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½IG VJG *QNNCPF OKPV YCU VGORQTCTKN[ QRGTCVGF KP <GXGPDGTIGP CPF OKPVKPI VQQM RNCEG VJGTG HTQO RTGUWOCDN[ VQ )TQNNG FGGOU VJG UVCT KPKVKCN QP VJG TGXGTUG EJCTCEVGTKUVKECN HQT <GXGPDGTIGP 6JG UVCT QXGT VJG ETQYP KU CNUQ VJQWIJV VQ KPFKECVG <GXGPDGTIGP UGG 2WKUVGT KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R 252


6JG *QWUG QH $WTIWPF 2*+.+25 FG )1'&'

)QWFGP UEJKNF 0COGPUG QT <GXGPDGTIGP!. # %QWPV QP VJTQPG JQNFKPI UJKGNF QH 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP EGPVTG 2J5 ¤ &8: ¤ $74) Z %1/ Z (.#& ¤ *'5 ¤ *1. < < 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6. &GNO 'X) E (D )TQNNG $ %C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ 5Q ECNNGF $WTIWPFKCP UJKGNF 5VCTVKPI #RTKN CNUQ UVTWEM KP <GXGPDGTIGP 7PFGT VJG 0 QH 4')0#6 TGXGTUG KU C RGNNGV YJKEJ YQWNF KPFKECVG 0COWT DWV CPQVJGT FQV YQWNF JCXG VQ DG WPFGT VJG 8 QH &8: QDXGTUG JQYGXGT VJGTG KUPʼnV

*CNH UEJKNF <GXGPDGTIGP. # %QWPV QP VJTQPG JQNFKPI UJKGNF QH 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP EGPVTG 2*5 ¤ &8: ¤ $84) ¤ %1/ ¤ (.#& ¤ *'5 ¤ *1. ¤ < 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING Z :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% +/2'4#6. &GNO 'X) C (D )TQNNG $ &C XF%J IT. 4 5OCNN UETCVEJGU CPF HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 5VCT QP ETQYP <GXGPDGTIGP (TQO NKUV /C[ ,WPG PQ

2KGVGT F QT <GXGPDGTIGP. # 5CKPV 2GVGT YKVJ MG[U CPF PKODWU QXGT UJKGNF QH 8CNQKU $CXCTKC *QNNCPF YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP EGPVTG 2*5 ¤ &8: ¤ $84) $4#$ ¤ .+/$ ¤ < ¤ < 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 2#: ¤ :2+ ¤ /#0'#6 ¤ 5'/2'4 ¤ 01$+5%8/. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG XF%J IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP 6GZV QR TGXGTUG 2#: %*4+56+ /#0'#6 5'/2'4 01$+5%7/ 6JCV VJG RGCEG QH %JTKUV OC[ TGOCKP YKVJ WU HQTGXGT 6JKU EQKP KU FKUVKPIWKUJCDNG D[ VJG UVCT CU CP KPKVKCN UKIP QT KP VJG ECUG VJCV DQVJ UKFGU JCXG C ETQUU D[ VJG GPF VKVNG << F9 FG /G[ 0QTOCNN[ VJG EQKPU QH 2JKNKR VJG )QQF QH *QNNCPF UJQY C EQCV QH CTOU DGCTKPI C NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJG VJ SWCTVGT

PQTOCNN[ VJGTG CTG VJTGG CTOU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF C UKPING EQCV QH CTOU KP VJG PF CPF VJG TF SWCTVGT PQTOCNN[ VJCV KU C FKXKFGF EQCV QH CTOU 'X) PQVGU YKVJ $TCDCPV VKVNGU

253


)TQQV. # 5JKGNF QH 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG CDQXG TKPI 2*5 Q &8: $84) Q 6 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 5+ 6Q0 1/ '0. 'X) )TQNNG XF%J IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP EJWTEJ KP 0QTVJ *QNNCPF 6YQ URGEKOGPU GZKUV DQVJ YGTG HQWPF KP VJG UCOG EJWTEJ $QVJ KP CWEVKQP QH %QKP +PXGUVOGPV PQ CPF 5GG 8CP )GNFGT *GV *QNNCPFUG OWPVYG\GP QPFGT JGV *WKU 9KVVGNUDCEJ KP ,/2 R CPF ,/2

R R KP RCTVKEWNCT WPFGT PQ VJKU KU KORQUUKDNG + VJKPM DGECWUG KV EQTTGURQPFU YKVJ )TQNNG % DWV VJCV KU QH 2JKNKR CPF ,CEQDC VYQ UNCPVGF GUEWVEJGQPU + DGNKGXG VJKU EQKP OWUV DG TCPMGF WPFGT 2JKNKRU

YKVJQWV ,CEQDC

2*+.+25 CPF ,#%1$#

5EJKNF. # %QWPVGUU QP VJTQPG YKVJ TQUGU QP VJG ETQYP DGVYGGP VYQ UJKGNFU N 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG T &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF 2J5 „ &8: „ $74) Z Z +#%1$ Z &8% „ $# „ %1 „ *1. < . 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +02'4#6. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG % D XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN

6JG RQUKVKQP QH VJG NGIU QP VJG TGUR IQNF UJKGNFU KU CU HQNNQYU

6JCV VJG NGIU QH VJG EQWPV KP (TCPEG VJG NGIU CTG RCTVGF VQQ DWV VJG[ʼnTG GSWCNN[ NQPI LWUV CU KP (NCPFGTU CTG WPGXGP CPF RQKPV UVTCKIJV FQYP KU RGEWNKCT KPFGGF 6JG TKIJV HQQV KU QPG UVGR FQYP HTQO VJG NGHV 9KVJ ,CEQDC VJCV KU ENGCTN[ FKHHGTGPV DQVJ NGIU CTG RCTCNGNN CPF GSWCNN[ NQPI KP VJG UCOG YC[ NCFKGU UKV PQYCFC[U 1P VJGUG ITQWPFU YG JCXG EJQUGP VJG GPVJTQPGF EQWPVGUU KPUVGCF QH VJG GPVJTQPGF FWMG EQPVTCT[ VQ NKVGTCVWTG

254


5EJKNF. # %QWPVGUU QP VJTQPG YKVJ TQUGU QP VJG ETQYP DGVYGGP VYQ UJKGNFU N 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG T &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF 2J5 „ &8: „ $74) Z Z +#%1$ Z &8% „ $# „ %1 „ *1.< 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +02'4#6. &GNO 'X) (D )TQNNG % C XF%J IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ

-TQOUVCCTV. # .KQP TCORCPV N YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG QP DTGCUV 2*5 „ &8: „ $74) „ 68614 „ < „ *'5 „ *< 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF QXGT &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF +#%1$ &8% „ $#8# „ %1/ „ * < . 'X) )TQNNG % C XF%J IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

-TQOUVCCTV. # 5JKGNF QH 8CNQKU $WTIWPF[ YKVJ (NGOKUJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG 2*5 „ &8: „ $84) „ 68614 „ < „ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF QXGT VJG &WVEJ $CXCTKCP UJKGNF +#%1$ „ &8% „ $#8# „ %. 'X) )T % C XF%J IT. 44 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ XF%J 'X)

255


5647%- 1(

5VTWEM CU RGT EJCTVGT VJ (GDTWCT[ 6JKU OKPV YCU QTFCKPGF D[ VJG 'UVCVGU QH *QNNCPF 1PN[ EQKPU YKVJ VJKU UVTWEM YGTG VQ DG IKXGP QT CEEGRVGF CV C TCVG VJCV YCU TGFGVGTOKPGF HQT GCEJ V[RG +P VJG ECUG QH C UVTWEM VJG FKHHGTGPEG DGVYGGP VJG QNF CPF VJG PGY TCVG YCU VQ DG IKXGP VQ VJG NCPF CU C NQCP HTGG QH KPVGTGUV HQT C RGTKQF QH QPG [GCT VJKU NQCP YCU PGXGT TGRC[GF 5GG * 'PPQ X )GNFGT &G MNQR QH KP &G )GW\GPRGPPKPI R CPF ,/2 R

4GCN 5GXKNNC %QWPVGTOCTM *QNNCPF. # %TQYPGF GUEWVEJGQP QH %CUVKNKÀ .GÉP CPF #TCIÉP DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU ('40#0&85 '6 '.+5#$'& 4 5KZ DWPFNGF CTTQYU YKVJ 5 KP VJG HKGNF CPF UVCOR QH *QNNCPF KP VJG EGPVTG 4': '6 4')+0# %#56 .')+1 #4#)1. %QWPVGTOCTM &GNO # IT. %QKP CPF EQWPVGTOCTM XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z (QPVG[P -W[RGTU EQNNGEVKQP ņ 4QVVGTFCO 6YQ FKHHGTGPV *QNNCPF FKGU GZKUV 6JKU KU VJG *QNNCPF NKQP KP C DQTFGT QH RGCTNU *

4GCNGP 5GXKNNC %QWPVGTOCTM <GGNCPF. # %TQYPGF GUEWVEJGQP QH %CUVKNKC .GÉP CPF #TCIÉ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

256


/+&&'0(4+'5.#0& +OKVCVKQPU +OKVCVKQP .16*#4+75 + %GPVTCN (TKUKC CPF 'CUV (TKUKC JCF C HGY EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU KP EQOOQP 6JG (TKUKCPU JCF VJGKT QYP NCPIWCIG GXGP RGQRNGʼnU PCOGU DQTG ITGCV TGUGODNCPEG VJCV YJKNG QVJGT RGQRNGU YQWNF WUWCNN[ DG CDNG VQ EQPXGTUG VQ C EGTVCKP GZVGPV YKVJ VJGKT PGKIJDQWTU YCU KPEQORTGJGPUKDNG VQ PQP PCVKXGU (WTVJGTOQTG VJG[ GZGTEKUGF (TKUKCP NCY VJCV UQQP FKUVKPIWKUJGF KVUGNH HTQO VJG NCY KP UWTTQWPFKPI TGIKQPU .CUVN[ VJG (TKUKCPU YGTG TGPQYPGF HQT VJGKT FCWPVNGUU UGPUG QH HTGGFQO CPF VJGKT EQPUKUVGPV FGPKCN QH CNN CWVJQTKV[ DWV VJGKT QYP &GURKVG VJGKT ENQUG TCPMU VJG (TKUKCPU FKFPʼnV OCPCIG VQ FGXGNQR CP[ EQJGTGPV RQNKVKECN U[UVGO KP OGFKGXCN VKOGU CPF VJG[ YQWNF OQUVN[ TGOCKP CV VJG CFOKPKUVTCVKXG OGTE[ QH DGVVGT QTICPKUGF GZVGTPCN HQTEGU YJKEJ CV VKOGU QDUEWTGU VJGKT EQKPCIG +P &QTGUVCF YCU NCKF KP TWKPU /QUV JKUVQTKCPU JCXG NQECN VTCFG GPF CV VJG UCOG VKOG DWV VJG[ CTG OKUVCMGP 6JG OKPV KU VQ DG HQWPF GNUGYJGTG EH <CFQEMU &G GGTUVG OWPVUNCI VG &WWTUVGFG KP ,/2 R CPF XCP )GNFGT &G -CTQNKPIKUEJG OWPVUNCI VG &WWTUVGFG KP ,/2 R EQPEWT VJCV VJG KOKVCVKQPU YGTGPʼnV UVTWEM KP &QTGUVCF DWV KP UQOG QVJGT RNCEG RQUUKDN[ KP (TKUKC 6JQWIJ VJG TKIJV QH OKPV JCXKPI DGGP EQPHGTTGF QP /GFGODNKM KP KU JKUVQTKECNN[ GUVCDNKUJGF CP[ GHHGEVU NKMG KUUWCPEGU TGOCKP VQ DG UWDUVCPVKCVGF 5VCXQTGP VQQ KU UQOGVKOGU RWV HQTGYCTF CU C RQUUKDNG OKPV 6JKU UGGOU OQTG NKMGN[ CNN EQKPU HTQO VJKU RGTKQF YGTG HQWPF CV 9GUVGTIQ +P 5VCXQTGP OWUV JCXG JGNF CP KORQTVCPV RQUKVKQP KP VJG TGIKQP HQT VJG 8KMKPIU FGXCUVCVGF KV 5VCXQTGP TGEGKXGF EKV[ TKIJVU KP VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING #& '2+5 80#61+6 4 6GORNG * 562#0# '+0+1. /'% XF%J IT. 4 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 'Z XCP 4KGVFKLM FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP JCU VJG UCOG NGIGPF CU XF%J (TCPMKUJ 5QXGTGKIPU CPF JG EQPUGSWGPVN[ CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ .QVJCKT +PUETKRVKQPU YKVJ X F %JKLU # 0 56+#*#+'+/01 4 #2 '2+5 8*#61+ %QOOGPVCT[ 2 +NKUEJ PQX 6JG QDXGTUG VGZV JCU VQ DG TGCF TGVTQITCFG +16#/85 +2'&#6 VJKU KU VJG UCOG VGZV CU VJCV QP .QVJCKTʼnU EQKP PQ GZEGRV HQT VJG 6 KP +16#/85 6JG TGXGTUG VGZV JG EQPUKFGTU C EQTTWRVKQP QH VJG YGNN MPQYP :4+56+#0# 4'.+)+1

+OKVCVKQP .7&9+) FCU -+0&

&GPKGT. # +P VYQ NKPGU +++ %*++ +++ %++++ 4 %TQUU 58++58%+881%+8+++ *.8&18+%85 2+85 TGVTQITCFG . +NKUEJ IT. 4 /KUVCMG KP VJG FKG QP VJG TGXGTUG XGT[ HKPG

$TGF 2CTKU 5RGEKOGPU QH VJKU MKPF JCXG QPN[ GOGTIGF KP VJG JQCTF 2KPLWO 6JKU RCTVKEWNCT RKGEG KU NKMGN[ VQ DG HTQO VJG UCOG JQCTF 6JKU EQKP KU QHVGP TGICTFGF CU C EQR[ QH 5VTCUUDQWTI EQKPU +NKUEJ ,/2 RTQXKFGU VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZVU 1 +++ %*++ +++ %++++ 4 58++58%+881%8+++ +NKUEJ IKXGU VYQ YGKIJVU CPF DQVJ YGKIJVU NQYGT VJCP VJCV QH VJG EQKP CV JCPF +NKUEJ ENCUUKHKGU KV WPFGT &QTGUVCF + FKHHGT QP VJCV 6JG JQCTF 2KPLWO KU FGUETKDGF D[ &KTMU , .C 6TQWXCKNNG FG 2KPLWO (TKUG GP LWKP KP 4GXWG FG NC 0WOKUOC VKSWG $GNIG G UGTKG VQOG 2KPLWO KU C XKNNCIG RCTV QH VJG OWPKEKRCNKV[ QH 9QPUGTCFGGN PGCT $QNUYCTF 1TKIKPCN PCOG 2[CPIJWO # NCTIG COQWPV QH EQKPU YCU HQWPF C UWDUVCPVKCN RCTV QH YJKEJ YGPV KPVQ VJG OGNVKPI RQV NGCXKPI &KTMU YKVJ VQ FGUETKDG RKGEGU HTQO VJG 2KPLWO JQCTF CXGTCIGF C YGKIJV QH

257


+OKVCVKQP 1661 +

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1661++++2#8) 4 +P VYQ NKPGU #++6%++#8 '+'+%'++ UQOG NGVVGTU TGVTQITCFG . +NKUEJ IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO 5GG &CPPGPDGTI KOKVCVKQP QH $TWPQ %QNQIPG

&GPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1661+++++ 2#8) 4 +P VYQ NKPGU ++4804++ #4+5+++++. +NKUEJ IT. 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

9GUVGTJQH 5PGGM #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP 2KPLWO +NKUEJ +OKVCVKQP QH %QNQIPG 1VVQ + CPF # D $TWPQ CRRTQZ +NKUEJ NKUVU VJKU URGEKOGP CU QPG RKGEG HKPF 6JG RKGEGU NKUVGF D[ +NKUEJ CTG CNN OWEJ JGCXKGT 5GG PQ YJKEJ KU CNUQ OWEJ JGCXKGT 6JKU KU CP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG %QNQIPG FGPCTKWU QH $TWPQ CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG CPF &WMG QH .QTTCKPG CPF JKU DTQVJGT 1VVQ + &CPPGPDGTI JCU KV UVTWEM KP KP XKGY QH VJG KORGTKCN VKVNG (QT VJG %QNQIPG QTKIKPCN UGG -NWIG &GWVUEJG /Ã’P\IGUEJKEJVG PQ

9+%*/#00 +++

9KEJOCPP +++ YCU VJG ITCPFUQP QH 9KEJOCPP + CPF VJG DTQVJGT QH *GTOCPP &WMG QH 5CZQP[ HTQO VJG *QWUG QH $KNNWPI *KU HCVJGT 9KEJOCPP ++ YCU %QWPV QH *COCNCPF VJG VGTTKVQT[ DGVYGGP 'NVGP CPF &GXGPVGT VJCV FGXQNXGF QPVQ JKU FCWIJVGT #FGNC UGG WPFGT *COCNCPF +P YG UGG 9KEJOCPP QH *COCNCPF KP (TKUKC

&GPKGT. # +P VYQ NKPGU '+5$+5++5 &1+5+5+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 88+%/#0 %1. &CPP +NKUEJ IT. 8GT[ HKPG 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ EH +NKUEJ (TKGUKUEJG 2T·IWPIGP FGU )TCHGP 9KEJOCPP KP ,/2 R $CUGF QP KVU QEEWTGPEGU KP JQCTFU IGPGTCNN[ CUUWOGF VQ DG UVTWEM WPFGT EQWPV 9KEJOCPP +++ YJQ NKGU DWTKGF KP 8TGFGP 6JG EQPUGSWGPVKCN CVVTKDWVKQP VQ 8TGFGP CU OKPV KU FKUOKUUGF D[ VJG YTKVGT 6JG YGKIJV QH CRRTQZ IT TWNGU QWV UWEJ CP CVVTKDWVKQP HQT UKIPKHKECPVN[ JGCXKGT EQKPU YGTG WUGF KP YGUVGTP 9GUVRJCNKC +VU YGKIJV FQGU JQYGXGT EQPEWT CU FQGU VJG NGVVGTKPI YKVJ VJG CPQP[OQWU (TKUKCP EQKPU VJCV GOGTIGF COQPI QVJGTU KP VJG &KGVTKEJUHGNF JQCTF $CUGF QP KVU QEEWTTGPEG KP UGXGTCN &WVEJ JQCTFU VJKU EQKP KU IGPGTCNN[ CITGGF VQ JCXG DGGP UVTWEM KP VJG RCTV QH )TGCVGT (TKUKC VQ VJG YGUV QH VJG 'OU 4KXGT 1P YJCV CWVJQTKV[ 9KEJOCPPʼnU TKIJV QH OKPV YCU DCUGF JCUPʼnV DGGP GUVCDNKUJGF VQ FCVG 5GG CNUQ +NKUEJ 2 (TKGUKUEJG /Ã’P\GP WO FKG ,CJTVCWUGPFYGPFG KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R G X

258


#010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT. # 6GORNG YKVJ HKXG EQNWOPU 1 1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &+ 8%%+Å‘. &CPP )CGVVGPU IT. 8GT[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ (TQO JQCTF .WFYKU\E\G PQ VJKU GZGORNCT 'Z 6GTDGTIGT EQNNGEVKQP 1UPCDTÒEM 6GZV KP RWDNKECVKQP (F .WFYKU\E\G )GPGTCN 5QOG URGEKOGPU KP VJG JQCTF UJQYGF C EJWTEJ YKVJ C ETQUU KPUKFG VJCV FCVGU DCEM VQ VJG :24+56+#0# 4'.+)+1 6JG[ YGTG UVTWEM KP (TKUKC QT KP $CTFQYKM 5RGEKHKE HQT PQ # %TQUU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ URJGTGU KP VJG CPINGU ' N[KPI 6 8%+% +++ NCUV % KPXGTVGF 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ HKXG EQNWOPU 1 1 1 1 6JKU EQKP KUPʼnV OGPVKQPGF CP[YJGTG GNUG KP NKVGTCVWTG

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

&GPKGT $QNUYCTF. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UEGRVTG *'04+%85 4' 4 $480 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU $1&/5 9'46 . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 C IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

5RCCT GP 8QQTUEJQVDCPM 5WTJWKUVGTXGGP

&GPKGT &QMMWO. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UEGRVTG *'04+%85 4' 4 $480 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU 8))# &1%%. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 D IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

259


&GPKGT. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT *'04+%85 4+' 4 $4 Ő 80 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU &1%% 8))# TGVTQITCFG . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 D IT. 44 0KEG RCVKPC YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 6GTDGTIGT EQNNGEVKQP 1UPCDTÒEM +NKUEJ ENCUUKHKGU KV WPFGT (TKUKC PQVKPI VJCV &GT -TWOOUVCD FGWVGV OKV JQJGT 9CJTUEJGKPNKEJMGKV CWH GKPGP $GKUEJNCI CWU GKPGT DGPCEJDCTVGP /ÒP\UV·VVG )TQPKPIGP 6JG UWIIGUVKQP )TQPKPIGP FQGUPʼn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ʼnU TGUKFGPEG # MKPIʼnU RQTVTCKV YKVJ C ETQUKGT UGGOU VQ DG C UQOGYJCV CYMYCTF EQODKPCVKQP 9QWNFPʼnV C HQTO QH EQOOGOQTCVKQP QH $QPKHCEGʼnU FGCVJ KP UQOG [GCTU NCVGT JCXG VQ DG EQPUKFGTGF! *QQHV XCP +FFGMKPIG R EQPUKFGTU C FKG EWVVGT KP &QMMWO VJCV JCF YQTMGF KP )TQPKPIGP CPF JCF VCMGP C RWPEJ YKVJ VJG ETQUKGT YKVJ JKO *QQHV XCP +FFGMKPIG TGEQIPKUGU VJG RWPEJ KP VJG &QMMWO EQKP HTQO DKUJQR $GTPQNFWUʼn EQKP YKVJ VJG ETQUKGT +NKUEJ MPQYU QH HGY URGEKOGP

&GPKGT .GGWYCTFGP. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU *'0&4+%85 +' 4 $4 Ő 80 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU .+80 8'41 TGVTQITCFG . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 E IT. 8GT[ YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT .GGWYCTFGP. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUU JGCFGF UEGRVTG 6 *'04+%85 4' 4 Ő $480 Ő DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU *+8 8 0+* 1 TGVTQITCFG . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 E IT. 8GT[ HKPG

5 #PVQPQX 4KIC + VJKPM VJKU KU C EQTTWRVGF HQTO QH .GGWYCTFGP 6JG 4 KP 4GZ KU RGEWNKCT C 2 YKVJ C JQTK\QPVCN UVTQMG QXGT KV

260


&GPKGT 5VCXQTGP. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU *'04+%85 4' 4 $470 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU 56#8 '484. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 F IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO

1P CNN QVJGT KNNWUVTCVKQPU 56#8 KU RNCEGF CDQXG $470 +P VJKU ECUG KV KU RNCEGF WPFGT

&GPKGT 5VCXQTGP. # %TQYPGF DWUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU *'0&4+%85 4' 4 $470 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU 56#8 '484. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 F IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT .GGWYCTFGP. # %TQYPGF DWUV N YKVJ UEGRVTG VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU +'04+%8+ ` 4' 4 $480 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU .+#8 8'41. +NKUEJ &CPP 2 IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG (NCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ +P XQNWOG &CPPGPDGTI TGEQTFU QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP KP VJG -/ CPF TGHGTU VQ $GTN /\DN R +P X F %JKLU VQQ QPN[ QPG UWEJ EQKP KU FKURNC[GF +NKUEJ FQGUPʼnV EQOOGPV

')$'46 + 'IDGTV YCU C DTQVJGT QH $TWPQ +++ *KU RTQRGTVKGU OCKPN[ NC[ KP $TWPUYKEM CPF YKVJKP VJG FKQEGUGU QH *KNFGUJGKO CPF *CNDGTUVCFV +P JKU HKPCN [GCTU JG YCU OCTITCXG QH /GKUUGP +P 'IDGTV UYQTG HGCNV[ HQT C PWODGT QH (TKUKCP EQWPVKGU VQ VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH *CODWTI $TGOGP +P VJG UCOG [GCT VJG HQTOGT KPVGTXGPGF KP VJG UVTWIING HQT VJG 5CZQPKCP 0QTVJOCTM CPF ECOG VQ VJG CKF QH MKPI *GPT[ +8 CPF EQWPV 7FQ QH 5VCFG KP VJG GPUWKPI HKIJVU JKU DTQVJGT $TWPQ FKGF (TQO 'IDGTV + QP VJG )GTOCP GORGTQTʼnU PCOG PQ NQPIGT CRRGCTU QP EQKPCIG 6JG OGCPKPI QH 016# KU WPCEEQWPVGF HQT KV EGTVCKPN[ KU PQV JQYGXGT CP CDDTGXKCVKQP QH /10'6# C VJGQT[ VQ YJKEJ -NWIG KP VJG &GWVUEJG /ÒP\IGUEJKEJVG UVKNN CFJGTGU

&GPKGT 5VCXQTGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING '%$'4685 4 016# DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU 568# '410. &CPP C +NKUEJ 2 G IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

261


&GPKGT .GGWYCTFGP. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING '%$'4685 4 016# DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU .88# '460. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 E IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,CPWCT[ PQ

&GPKGT $QNUYCTF. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING '%$'4685 4 016# DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU $1&.+09'+ TGVTQITCFG . &CPP XCT +NKUEJ XCT 2 C IT. 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 0QTOCNN[ VJG QD CPF TGXGTUG KPUETKRVKQPU CTG KPXGTVGF

&GPKGT &QMMWO. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING '%$'468 5 4 016# DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU &1 %% 8))8. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 D IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

-WTRH·N\KUEJG /ÒP\JCPFNWPI /CPPJGKO #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 'PPKIJGO. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING '/0+)*'/ 4 016# DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU '%$' 4685. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 H IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

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ʼnU EQKPU GZJKDKV VJG JGCFU QH 5KOQP CPF ,WFCU QP VJG QDXGTUG CU UGGP QP )QUNCT EQKPU

&GPKGT $QNUYCTF. # %TQYPGF DGCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI '%$'4685 4 *GCFU QH 5CKPV 5KOQP CPF 5CKPV ,WFCU YKVJ ETQUU $1&.+588'46. &CPP C +NKUEJ 2 C IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F

262


&GPKGT &QMMWO. # %TQYPGF DGCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI '%$'4685 4 *GCFU QH 5CKPV 5KOQP CPF 5CKPV ,WFCU YKVJ ETQUU &1)) +0) 80. &CPP +NKUEJ 2 D IT. 5OCNN KPM FTCYKPI XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&GPKGT .GGWYCTFGP. # %TQYPGF DGCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI '%$'4685 4 *GCFU QH 5CKPV 5KOQP CPF 5CKPV ,WFCU YKVJ ETQUU .+ 8088 #4 6 . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 F IT. 8GT[ HKPG

)NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 5VCXQTGP. # %TQYPGF DGCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI 8'%$' 4685 4 *GCFU QH 5CKPV 5KOQP CPF 5CKPV ,WFCU YKVJ ETQUU 5 6#8'410 + . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 G IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG CPF UNKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 9GUVGTGOFGP. # %TQYPGF DGCTFGF DWUV HCEKPI '%$'4685 4 *GCFU QH 5CKPV 5KOQP CPF 5CKPV ,WFCU YKVJ ETQUU '+) '++'1'+* TGVTQITCFG . &CPP +NKUEJ 2 H IT. 44 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG OKPV 'PPKIJGO YQWNF DG OQUV NKMGN[ GXGP KH VJG PCOG KU TGVTQITCFG +P VJG EQNN 2WKUVGT VJGTG GZKUVU C URGEKOGP YKVJ VJG UCOG TGVTQITCFG VGZV 6JG VGZV KU TGVTQITCFG '+)'+'1'* VJG ' TGCF DCEMYCTFU 2WKUVGT JCU '+)'+*)'* CICKP CP KPXGTVGF ' 0QTOCNN[ KV TGCFU '/0+)*'/ YJKEJ CEEQTFKPI VQ 2WKUVGT KU CNYC[U YTKVVGP EQTTGEVN[ #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH %QWPV 'IDGTV ++ KP VJG EQWPV[ HGNN VQ VJG FKQEGUG QH 7VTGEJV +P VJG RGTKQF VQ VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQR %QPTCF OKPVGF KP 5VCXQTGP .GGWYCTFGP CPF &QMMWO UGG +NKUEJ VQ

263


1661 +++ QH <762*'0

+P 'ORGTQT *GPT[ 8 ICXG *GPT[ QH 0QTFJGKO VJG EQWPV[ (TKUKC KP HKGH *G YCU )GTVTWFKUʼn JWUDCPF VJG UKUVGT QH 'IDGTV ++ 6JG (TKUKCPU JQYGXGT FKF PQV CEEGRV *GPT[ʼnU CWVJQTKV[ CPF KP VJG UCOG [GCT FWTKPI JKU HKTUV XKUKV VQ VJG EQWPV[ JG YCU OWTFGTGF # RGTKQF YKVJQWV EQWPVU GPUWGF KP YJKEJ IWCTFKCPU CFXQECVK GEENGUKCG CFOKPKUVTCVGF VJG TGIKQP VJG[ YGTG CRRQKPVGF D[ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 6JGUG CFOKPKUVTCVKQPU YGTG NGF D[ VJG PQDKNKU CFXQECVWU 1VVQ +++ QH <WVRJGP +P JKU UQP *GPT[ QH <WVRJGP YCU ITCPVGF VJG EQWPV[ (TKUKC D[ 'ORGTQT *GPT[ 8 CPF 1VVQ YGPV QWV QH QHHKEG CU PQDKNKU CFXQECVWU +V KU JQY GXGT XGT[ NKMGN[ VJCV CU YGNN 1VVQ CU *GPT[ EQPVKPWGF VJGKT QHHKEGU CU IWCTFKCPU QP DGJCNH QH VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 1VVQ YCU C PQDNGOCP QH YGCNVJ CPF RTGUVKIG CPF C OKPV KP JKU PCOG FQGUPʼnV UGGO KPRQUUKDNG #HVGT *GPT[ 8 JCF ITCPVGF RCTV QH (TKUKC VQ *GPT[ QH <WVRJGP VJG HQTOGTʼnU UWEEGUUQT .QVJCKT +++ ICXG %GPVTCN (TKUKC VQ VJG EQWPVU QH *QNNCPF 6JG FKURWVG DG VYGGP VJG EQWPVU QH *QNNCPF CPF VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV YCUPʼnV CTDKVTCVGF WPVKN YJGP (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC HKPCNN[ FGCNV YKVJ KV

.KIJV FGPKGT 5VCXQTGP. # $WUV T YKVJ JGNO CPF UVCPFCTF 1&6 4 (QWT DQYU YKVJ ETQUU DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 56#84 . &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 44 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF KP %CUVTKEWO 6JG QDXGTUG VGZV 1&61 0 8+ UVCPFU HQT 1661 01$+.+5 8+4 YJKEJ OGCPU 1VVQ VJG 0QDNG URGEKOGPU ECOG WR KP VJG JQCTF 2TCIWG /GPCFKGT KP $GTNKPGT /Ã’P\DN·VVGT &GT (WPF XQP 2TCI UGG 5EJQNVGP KP ,/2 R +NKUEJ OCMGU OGPVKQP QH VJKU URGEKOGP R

#010;/175

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

KOOQDKNKUGF 6JG HQWT NGVVGTU DGVYGGP VYQ DCTU CTG QPN[ UGGP KP VJG V[RGU 5EJQNVGP YQTNFN[ CPF

ENGTKECN VJCV ,CEQDK RNCEGU CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 1H V[RG ,CEQDK QPN[ HQWPF URGEKOGPU QH V[RG PQ NGUU VJCP QH YJKEJ KP VJG JQCTF $CTVGNGJKGO 6JKU TCKUGU VJG SWGUVKQP QH YJGVJGT VJGTG YGTG CP[ KUUWGU FKURNC[KPI C EQOKVCN DWUV QP VJG QDXGTUG CPF CP GRKUEQRCN QP VJG TGXGTUG QT XKEG XGTUC UKPEG VJG [KGNFU YQWNF DG UJCTGF D[ DKUJQR CPF EQWPV %QOKVCN EQKPKPI 6JGUG EQKPU CRRGCT VQ FGTKXG HTQO PQ 6JG[ RTQDCDN[ YGTG UVTWEM PQV NQPI CHVGT KV +NKUEJ EJCTCEVGTKUGU VJGO CU &WMG 1VVQ +OOQDKNKUGF + HKPF VJG HKPKUJKPI FCVG RNCWUKDNG UGG VJG GRKUEQRCN EQKPU WPFGTPGCVJ DWV VJG DGIKPPKPI FCVG UGGOU VQQ GCTN[ UGG PQ +NKUEJ KPFKECVGU VYQ XCTKGVKGU $WUV YKVJ NCPEG YKVJ RGPPCPV KP HTQPV $GVYGGP VJG DCTU & 6 2GTKQF 9KVJQWV RGPPCPV $GVYGGP VJG DCTU # & 2GTKQF

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUU 4 &6 &1 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU CPF HQWT DQYU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 'FIG PKEM VYQ RKGEGU HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 2GKPU %QORCTGF 6JG NGVVGTU KP VJG DCT OKIJV TGUGODNG VJCV 1VVQ YJKEJ +NKUEJ OGPVKQPGF

264


.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ UVCHH 4 1# &1 DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 6JG GFIG KU YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF CV 4GKF PQTVJ QH 2GKPU D[ VJG TQCF (TCPGMGT $GTNKMWO 6JCV VJKU EQKP YGKIJU CNOQUV VYKEG CU OWEJ CU VJG QVJGTU KU RGEWNKCT 6JKU EQKP KU OGPVKQPGF YKVJ +NKUEJ QP R +NKUEJ OCMGU QWV # ņ + DGVYGGP VJG DCTU

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ UVCHH GPFKPI KP TKPI CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP HKGNF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQUU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO

'RKUEQRCN EQKPKPI 6YQ V[RGU OC[ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF C 6JG DWUV KP RTQHKNG 6JKU GHHKI[ OCVEJGU VJG 7VTGEJV EQKPU QH DKUJQR *CTVDGTV CPF DKUJQR *GTOCP QH *QQTPG 6JG UKOKNCT FGRKEVKQP QH VJG PQUG KU EJCTCEVGTKUVKE 9G HQWPF C UKOKNCT PQUG QP C UEGCVVC C EQKP YKVJ C JKIJ TGNKGH QP VJG TGXGTUG D 6JG DWUV HCEKPI 6JKU KU PQV UQ GCUKN[ OCVEJGF YKVJ 7VTGEJV EQKPU YJGTG C HCEKPI DWUV KU HKTUV UGGP WPFGT &KGFGTKM QH #JT *KU EQKPU JQYGXGT FGRKEV C OKVTC YJGTGCU VJG V[RG CV JCPF UJQYU VJG JGCFFTGUU UGGP KP VJG RTGXKQWU URGEKOGPU 6JG UWIIGUVKQP QH &KGFGTKM QH #JT CRRGCTU VQ EQPEWT YKVJ 5EJQNVGP V[RG ,CEQDK TGEQTFU QPN[ VYQ URGEKOGPU DQVJ HTQO VJG JQCTF $CTVGNGJKGO 6JG QDXGTUG QH VJKU V[RG ENGCTN[ TGCFU 6*'1&4+%85 CPF VJG TGXGTUG 56#8'405 6JKU EQKPʼnU KUUWCPEG YCU RTGUWOCDN[ CTQWPF RQVGPVKCNN[ NCVGT YJGP VJG UCOG V[RG KU TGKUUWGF ,CEQDK FGVGTOKPKPI VJG PWODGTU 5EJQNVGP CPF KP C UKPING IQ GUVCDNKUJGU VJG QTKIKPU CV VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VQQ 6JWU VJG HCEKPI DWUV EQKPU CRRGCT VQ JCXG DGGP UVTWEM KP (TKUKC CHVGT WR VQ CHVGT *GCF KP RTQHKNG 6JG RGTKQF UVCTVKPI VQ CRRTQZ QT NCVGT UJQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT TKPI QH RGNNGVU DGJKPF 4 %TQUU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG PKEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG

(TQO %QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ

265


.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT TKPI QH RGNNGVU DGJKPF 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP 1QUVGTNCPF 5GG TGXGTUG UJQYU DQTFGT QH RGNNGVU CPF C UOQQVJ TKPI

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT TKPI QH RGNNGVU DGJKPF 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ

*GCF (CEKPI 6JG RGTKQF KP YJKEJ VJKU YCU UVTWEM KU CRRTQZ QT NCVGT WR VQ CHVGT

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 1# Ő & TGVTQITCFG DGVYGGP VYQ NKPGU NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ UVCT KP VJTGG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ 5EJQNVGP OGPVKQPU C RGNNGV KP VJG VJ CPING YJKEJ KU PQV XKUKDNG JGTG

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ UVCT KP VJTGG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 6JG FKHHGTGPEG YKVJ PQ KU VJCV VJKU FKURNC[U C UKZ RQKPVGF UVCT CU QRRQUGF VQ VJG UGXGP RQKPVGF UVCT KP PQ CPF KV YGKIJU VYKEG CU OWEJ

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT + QP DQTFGT 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ UVCT KP VJTGG CPINGU UQOG VQMGPU CU NGIGPF. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CPF VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP (TKGUNCPF

266


.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ UVCT KP VJTGG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 9KLPCNFWO

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT & QP DQTFGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ UVCTU CPF RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 'FIG EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 9KLPCNFWO ++

$WUV HCEKPI

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO .GGWYCTFGP HKPF PQ ,/2 R 6JG JQCTF .GGWYCTFGP YCU HQWPF KP HCNN KP VJKU EKV[ʼnU EGPVTG PGCT VJG )TQVG QH ,CEQDKLPGT -GTM FWTKPI GZECXC VKQPU 6JG JQCTF EQORTKUGF QH EQKPU DWV CFFKVKQPCN HTCIOGPVU VJCV YGTG HQWPF KPFKECVG CP QTKIKPCN COQWPV QH CV NGCUV RKGEGU ,CEQDK FGUETKDGU VJG JQCTF KP VJG ,/2 KP YJKEJ JG RTGUGPVU CP QXGTXKGY QH CNN NKIJV (TKUKCP EQKPU VJCV YGTG TGEQTFGF D[ 5EJQNVGP

.KIJV FGPKGT. # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPVU CPF RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

$NQGOGPFCN 2QUUKDN[ UVTWEM DGVYGGP (QWPF KP VJG UWOOGT QH KP 1QUVGTDKGTWO PQTVJYGUV QH (TCPGMGT 6JG JQCTF .GGWYCTFGP ,/2 R EQPVCKPGF HQWT XGT[ NKIJV EQKPU JQCTFPWODGTU VJCV VQ VJCV OQOGPV YGTG WPMPQYP 6JGKT RQQT EQPFKVKQP JQYGXGT TWNGF QWV CEEWTCVG FGVGTOKPCVKQP ,CEQDK ICXG VJGO VJG PWODGT 5EJQNVGP 6JKU URGEKOGP YCU RWDNKUJGF KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R

1PG UKFGF 2GPPKGU

9JGVJGT VJGUG XGT[ NKIJV EQKPU VJCV UJQWNF DG ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT VJG NCUV RGTKQF UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ C EQWPV QT C DKUJQR ECPʼnV DG FGVGTOKPGF

.KIJV QPG UKFGF FGPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ TKPIU CPF RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 4 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO .GGWYCTFGP HKPF PQ ,/2 R 7PMPQYP RTKQT VQ VJG JQCTF .GGWYCTFGP #OQPI VJG KPFKECVGF PQU RKGEGU KP 5EJQNVGP VJGTG YCU QPG 5EJQNVGP QH YJKEJ V[RG VYQ URGEKOGPU ECOG WR KP VJKU JQCTF

267


.KIJV QPG UKFGF FGPKGT. # %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VJG QVJGT CPINGU. &CPP +NKUEJ 5EJQNVGP IT. 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO .GGWYCTFGP HKPF PQ ,/2 R 7PMPQYP RTGXKQWU VQ VJG JQCTF .GGWYCTFGP YJKEJ EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG

+P (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC CUEGTVCKPGF VJG TKIJVU CPF QDNKICVKQPU QH )QFHTKGF DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV CPF EQWPV (NQTKU +++ QH *QNNCPF YKVJ TGURGEV VQ VJG EQWPV[ (TKUKC VJG[ OWVWCNN[ QYPGF

9GUVGTIQ 1QUVGTIQ CPF 5VCXQTGP *QQHV XCP +FFGMKPIG CUUWOGU VJCV 5VCXQTGP YCU CP CUUQEKCVG OKPV KP VJG OKPV CFOKPKUVTCVKQP TGRQTVGF VQ DKUJQR CPF EQWPV CNKMG 5GG CNUQ VJG PQVG QP OWVWCN EQKPU WPFGT CPQP[OQWU 6JG IWCTFKCP GODQFKGF YQTNFN[ CWVJQTKV[ ENGTKECN CWVJQTKV[ YCU GZGTEKUGF D[ VJG CDDQV QH VJG 5V 1FWNHWU OQPCUVGT[ PGCT 5VCXQTGP CPF VJG OKNKVCT[ YCU EQOOCPFGF D[ VJG RTGHGEV QH <WVRJGP +P &KTM 8++ CPF JKU WPENG DKUJQR $CNFYKP ITCPVGF VJGKT HKGHU 9GUVGTIQ CPF 1QUVGTIQ VQ %QWPV 9KNNKCO + QH *QNNCPF #HVGT VJG (TKUKCP VGTTKVQTKGU DGECOG UGRGTCVG FKUVTKEVU YKVJKP *QNNCPF +P (NQTKU +8 YCU FKIPKHKGF NQTF QH (TKUKC KP (TCPGMGT *QYGXGT JG JGNF PQ TGCN CWVJQTKV[ CPF GXGP 9KNNKCO ++ EQWNFPʼnV DWV CEMPQYNGFIG VJG (TKUKCP (TGGFQO +P (NQTKU 8 DGECOG VJG HQTOCN NQTF QH (TKUKC C UVCVWU SWQ WPFGT VJG TGKIPU QH ,CP + CPF ,CP ++ 9KNNKCO +++ TGVCKPGF GHHGEVKXG CWVJQTKV[ CU NQTF QH 9GUVGTIQ TGEGKXKPI KV KP GZEJCPIG HQT NGIKVKOKUKPI VJG (TKUKCP (TGGFQO 2TQDNGOU CTQUG CPF KP VJG EQOKVCN OCIKUVTCVGU YGTG FKURGNNGF HTQO 5VCXQTGP #P WNVKOCVG CVVGORV YCU OCFG YJGP KP ,CP + QH -WKPTG TGEGKXGF QTFGT HTQO 9KNNKCO +++ VQ QPEG CICKP HKIJV VJG (TKUKCPU +P VJG UCOG [GCT C VTGCV[ YCU TGCEJGF DGVYGGP *QNNCPF CPF 5VCXQTGP 6JG FGCVJ QH 9KNNKCO +++ GPFGF CNN *QNNCPF CWVJQTKV[ KP (TKUKC +P 9KNNKCO +8 FKGF CV 5VCXQTGP +P #NDGTV WPFGTVQQM CPQVJGT CVVGORV CV EQPSWGTKPI 5VCXQTGP +P RGCEG YCU UKIPGF KP YJKEJ (TKUKC YCU NQUV CPF 5VCXQTGP YCU TGVCKPGF DWV KP (TKUKC YCU NQUV FGHKPKVKXGN[ VQ *QNNCPF 9JGP CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ OKPVKPI QH VJG XGT[ NKIJV VQMGPU YCU UVQRRGF C XCEWWO KP EQKP RTQFWEVKQP GPUWGF WPVKN CRRTQZ 6JG HCOQWU (TKUKCP (TGGFQO JCF MKPFNGF CP QPIQKPI UVTWIING HQT RQYGT VJCV HKPCNN[ NGF VQ CPCTEJ[ +V UGGOU RGEWNKCT VJCV UJQTVN[ DGHQTG VJKU KPVGTTGIPWO KP EQKP RTQFWEVKQP %QWPV 9KNNKCO + QH *QNNCPF YJQ JGNF 9GUVGTIQ KP UWD HKGH CTQWPF VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ JCF JKU EQKPU QPEG CICKP UVTWEM KP 5VCXQTGP #U VJKU URGEKOGP PGKVJGT KP VGTOU QH VJG FGXKEG PQT YKVJ TGURGEV VQ KVU YGKIJV IT HQT VJG EQKP KP JCPF CU QRRQUGF VQ CP CXGTCIG QH IT YKVJ (TKUKCP EQKPU HKVU (TKUKCP EQKPCIG YG JCXG ENCUUKHKGF KV WPFGT *QNNCPF # UVTWIING HQT RQYGT DGVYGGP VJG EQWPVU QH *QNNCPF CPF VJG EKV[ QH )TQPKPIGP FGXGNQRGF (GWFCN CWVJQTKV[ JCF XCPKUJGF CNVQIGVJGT YJKEJ ECWUGF UQOG EKVKGU VQ VWTP VQ KPFGRGPFGPV OKPVKPI (QTOCNN[ QPN[ .GGWYCTFGP RQUUGUUGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV DWV HQWT QVJGT EKVKGU CEETQCEJGF VJKU TKIJV CU YGNN $QNUYCTF (TCPGMGT 5PGGM CPF 9QTMWO /KPVKPI VQQM RNCEG HQT SWKVG UQOG VKOG VQV EC [GV VJG QWVRWV YCU NKOKVGF CPF QH RQQT SWCNKV[

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ʼnU IQXGTPQTUJKR UVTGVEJGF HTQO VJG 8NKG VQ VJG &CPKUJ DQTFGT

KPENWFKPI )TQPKPIGP CPF KVU 1OOGNCPFGP UWTTQWPFKPI NCPFU UQOGVJKPI VJCV QH EQWTUG ECWUGF KPVGTGUVU VQ EQPHNKEV CU HQT KPUVCPEG KP VJG ECUG QH VJG %QWPV[ 'CUV (TKUKC VCMGP HTQO 5VWWTOCP , ) 5CMUKUEJG JGTVQIGP KP (TKUKC #URKTCVKG GP OWPVUNCI KP ,/2

R G X 268


#.$4'%*6 XQP 5#%*5'0

&WDDGNG 5VWKXGT 5CZQPKCP 'CING 5CUUGPCCT . # 5JKGNF YKVJ CTOU QH 5CZQPKC #.$'46 &8: 5#:10 )8$ (4+5+ . 4 %TQYPGF KORGTKCN CTOU QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF &'+ )4#%+# 4')'5 4')0#. 5VWWTOCP XF%J IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO PF GOKUUKQP

,CIGT )TQPKPIGT 5VWKXGT QT 8NKGIGT . # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING YKVJ CTOU QH (TKUKC KP SWCVTGHQKN #.$ 685 &8: 5#:1 <' )8$ 0# 2*4+ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING KPPGT EKTENG #00 &1/+ + / %%%% &'+ )4#%+# 4')'5 4')0#06. 5VWWTOCP V[RG D XF%J IT. 44 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ TF GOKUUKQP

)'14) WPF *'+04+%* XQP 5#%*5'0

+P /C[ *GPT[ JCF RWV FQYP TGDGNNKQP D[ VJG 8GVMQRGTU CPF VJG 5EJKGTKPIGTU 6JWU KP 5GRVGODGT QH JG UWEEGGFGF JKU HCVJGT DG KV TGNWEVCPVN[ *G KOOGFKCVGN[ NGHV (TKUKC CPF YKUJGF VQ UGNN VJG VGTTKVQTKGU VQ 2JKNKR VJG (CKT YJKEJ JG HCKNGF VQ FQ 6JGP JG TGCEJGF CP CITGGOGPV YKVJ JKU DTQVJGT )GQTIG VQ LQKPVN[ TWNG (TKUKC FWTKPI C VYQ [GCT RGTKQF 9JGP VJKU CITGGOGPV GZRKTGF )GQTI DGECOG UQNG IQXGTPQT

<GUVKGPFG 5VWKXGT. # %TQYPF CTOU QH 5CZQPKC Q /1 &8% 5#:1 )8$ (4 4 #TOU QH 5CZQPKC QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING 5#.86 &' + +/045 . 5VWWTOCP XF%J IT. 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG URGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO UV GOKUUKQP 5VWWTOCP TGRQTVU VYQ URGEKOGPU QPG KP %QKP +PX #WEV PQ CPF QPG KP 9GUVGTJQH #WEV PQ 5#.868/ &' +0+/+%+5 01564+5 &GNKXGTCPEG HTQO QWT GPGO[

269


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·WRVNKPIG %JKGHVCKPU YJQO VJG EQWPVU QH -CXGNCIG 4CXGPUDGTI WPVKN VJG DKUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT CPF VJG EQWPVU QH 1NFGPDWTI HCKNGF VQ TGUKUV #NVJQWIJ VJG %JKGHVCKPU VQQ YGTGPʼn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ʼnU UQP 7FQ %JKGHVCKP QH 0QTFGP CPF JKU UQP KP NCY 5KDGV QH 4WUVTKPIGP FKGF 'OFGP ECOG WPFGT *CODWTI CPF 'F\CTF CPF 7NTKEJ %KTMUGPC YGTG KVU UVTQPI HKIWTGU 'F\CTF FKGF KP JGKTNGUU 6JG UQXGTGKIP TKIJV YCU VTCPUHGTTGF VQ JKU DTQVJGT 7NTKEJ YJQ KP OCPCIGF VQ UWDUVCPVKCNN[ GZRCPF JKU FQOKPKQP D[ OCTT[KPI 6JGFC (QEMQ 7MGOCʼnU ITCPFFCWIJVGT +P UQXGTGKIPV[ YCU GPFCPIGTGF YJGP VJG DKUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT VQIGVJGT YKVJ VJG EQWPVU QH 1NFGPDWTI YKUJGF VQ TGXKXG VJGKT QNF TKIJVU +P 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++ KPVGTXGPGF CPF ITCPVGF VJG GPVKTG VGTTKVQT[ DGVYGGP 9GUVGTGOU CPF VJG 9GUGT 4KXGT CU HCT UQWVJ CU &GVGTP CPF .GPIGP KP HKGH 1P &GEGODGT 7NTKEJ DGECOG %QWPV QH 0QTFGP 'OGFGP 'OGUIQPKC KP 'CUV (TKUKC D[ WUKPI VJG VGTO 'OGUIQPKC VJG GORGTQT YCU XGT[ CTVKEWNCVG CU VQ FGP[KPI CP[ TKIJVU ENCKOGF D[ VJG DKUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT +P YGUVGTP 'CUV (TKUKC 7NTKEJʼnU TWNG YCU HWNN[ CEMPQYNGFIGF 5WEJ CEMPQYNGFIGOGPV HQT VJG GPVKTG VGTTKVQT[ YCU PQV CEJKGXGF WPVKN VJG TGKIP QH 7NTKEJʼnU UQP 'F\CTF + 1P VJ 5GRVGODGT 7NTKEJ FKGF *KU YKFQY 6JGFC VJGP CUUWOGF QHHKEG CU IWCTFKCP 7NTKEJʼnU EQWUKP 5KDQ #VVGOC QH 'UGPU TGEGKXGF HGWFCN TKIJVU HQT OKPQT UQPU 'PPQ 'F\CTF CPF 7MQ ,WN[ 9JGP 'FQ 9KGOMGP QH ,GXGT EQOOGPEGF OKPVKPI CICKP C UKIP QH UQXGTGKIPV[ FKURWVG CTQUG 6JGFC JQYGXGT EQWNF EQWPV QP VJG GORGTQT VQ UWRRQTV JGT +P 'PPQ + RCTVN[ CUUWOGF QHHKEG VCMKPI QP UQNG CWVJQTKV[ KP 9JGP JG FKGF KP JKU DTQVJGT 'F\CTF + UWEEGGFGF JKO *G DQWIJV QHH VJG HGWFCN TKIJVU QH *CODWTI CPF VJG DKUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT JQYGXGT VJG CWVJQTKV[ QXGT ,GXGT RTQXGF VQQ FKHHKEWNV VQ QDVCKP 'FQ 9KGOMGP UVC[GF QP VJGTG DWV VJG NCVVGTʼnU TKXCNU VJG EJKGHVCKPU QH +PP CPF -P[RJCWUGP LQKPGF 'CUV (TKUKC +P /CZKOKNKCP + KP TGVWTP HQT TGPFGTGF UGTXKEGU CYCTFGF &WMG #NDGTV QH 5CZQPKC VJG VKVNG QH GYKIGT )WDGTPCVQT WPF 2QVGUVCV GVGTPCN IQXGTPQT CPF RQVGUVCV QH (TKUKC YJKEJ EQP HNKEVGF YKVJ VJG HGWFCN CWVJQTKV[ 'F\CTF RQUUGUUGF CU VJG KORGTKCN KOOGFKCVG EQWPV QH 'CUV (TKUKC 'F\CTF CEEGRVGF VJKU PGY UKVWCVKQP CPF CEMPQYNGFIGF #NDGTV VQ DG VJG IQXGTPQT CPF RQVGUVCV QH JKU QYP FQOKPKQP +P JG ECOG VQ #NDGTVʼnU CKF CV VJG UKGIG QH )TQPKPIGP CPF TGEGKXGF 9GUVGTYQNFG CPF VJG (TKUKCP 1OOGNCPFGP KP HKGH +P VJG UCOG [GCT #NDGTV FKGF KP 'OFGP XKUKVKPI 'F\CTF HQT VJG HWTVJGT FGXGNQROGPV UGG /KFFGPHTKGUNCPF

270


%1706; '/&'0

'OFGP YCU HQWPFGF CTQWPF 1TKIKPCN PCOG KU #OWVJQP #010;/175

&GPKGT EC . # 6TKCPING YKVJ VYQ YGFIGU CPF ETQUU QP VQR +5+5+ /+5+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING ++4++4' #5#5. &CPP XCT +NKUEJ ,GUUG -KNIGT 'OF # IT. 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 6J *COGT 0GY ;QTM EQNNGEVKQP +NKUEJ TGHGTU VQ JQCTF &KGVTKEJUHGNF F *G UWIIGUV VJG JGCXKGT EQKPU CTG HTQO 'CUV (TKUKC VJG NKIJVGT URGEKOGPU HTQO %GPVTCN (TKUKC 5GG +NKUEJ (TKGUKUEJG /ÒP\GP WO FKG ,CJTVCWUGPFYGPFG KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R 6JG &KGVTKEJUHGNF JQCTF /GPCFKGT &GT (WPF XQP &KGVTKEJUHGNF $ / 5R CPF &GWVUEJG /ÒP\GP )GUCOOGNVG #WHU·V\G $F +8 $GTNKP R EQPVCKPGF JGCX[ CPF NKIJV URGEKOGPU +NKUEJ FCVGU VJKU EQKP DCEM VQ VJG GPF QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 9JCV +NKUEJ EQPUKFGTU NKIJV QT JGCX[ TGOCKPU UQOGYJCV QDUEWTG KP JKU CTVKENG QH VJG URGEKOGPU YGKIJ 6JG EQKP KP JCPF KU OWEJ JGCXKGT -KNIGT FQGUPʼnV FKUVKPIWKUJ D[ VJG EQPVGPV QH VJG VTKCPING +NKUEJ FQGU CPF CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ (TKUKC #XGTCIG YGKIJV QH OGCUWTGF URGEKOGPU &WG VQ VJG JGKIJGT YGKIJV 'OFGP CPF -KNIGT CTG CFJGTGF VQ

*'4/#00 +8 QH 9'4. 6JG HKTUV MPQYP EQWPV KU C EGTVCKP *GTKOCP FQEWOGPVGF QPN[ QP EQKPU 6JG UV[NG KU HTQO CTQWPF 6GTICUV UWIIGUVU VJCV *GTOCPP QH -CXGNCIG KU OGCPV VJKU KU EQPUKUVGPVN[ OGPVKQPGF KP PWOKUOCVKECN NKVGTCVWTG /QTG TGEGPVN[ *ÌODGTI VJKPMU C OGODGT QH VJG EQOKVCN *QWUG QH 9GTN KU FGRKEVGF 8CP .GPIGP EQPENWFGU VJCV *GTOCPP +8 QH 9GTN KU VJG OKPVKPI NQTF

&GPKGT. # $WUV T *'4+/#0 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP ETGUEGPVU CPF TKPI KP EGPVTG KP VJG CPINGU # /8 6* 10. &CPP +NKUEJ ,GUUG -KNIGT 'OF & IT. 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ EQPFKVKQP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP (QNNQYKPI -KNIGT PQ CPF PQ CTG QH VJG UCOG V[RG

$KUJQRU QH /ÒPUVGT +P 5QRJKG JGT FCWIJVGT ,WVVC CPF JGT UQP KP NCY 9CNGTCO QH /QPVLQKG EGFGF VJG NCPF QH 'OFGP VQ 1VVQ ++ $KUJQR QH /ÒPUVGT 6JG EQKPU DGCT VJG PCOG UECNGU CPF FKHHGT ITCXGN[ HTQO /ÒPUVGT VQMGPU /QTGQXGT VJG[ TCVJGT EQTTGURQPF VQ VJG NKIJV VQMGPU HTQO %GPVTCN (TKUKC 6JG[ EKTEWNCVGF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPQVJGT CPCNQI[ YKVJ EGPVTCN (TKUKCP NKIJV VQMGPU

5EJWDDG. # $WUV YKVJ NCPEG CPF ETQUKGT 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ RGNNGVU KP VJTGG CPINGU CPF TKPI KP QPG CPING. 6GTICUV IT. 8GT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

271


5EJWDDG. # *CPF ETQUKGT CPF UVCT 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. 6GTICUV IT. 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

5EJWDDG. # *CPF TKPI QXGT UVCT ETQUKGT CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING. 6GTICUV IT. 8GT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM (TQO NKUV PQ

.7'46 #$&'0# 5VCTVKPI .WGTV #DFGPC JGNF VJG QHHKEGU QH UVGYCTF CPF YQTFN[ EJCRNCKP KP 'OFGP (QTOCNN[ JG YCU VJG EJKGHVCKP QH 'OFGP FG KWTG NKGIG QH VJG DKUJQR QH /ÒPUVGT *G GZGTEKUGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPVKPI HQT [GCTU WPVKN JG FKGF KP

&GPKGT 'OFGP. # $KUJQR QP VJTQPG N YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPF DQQM 4 )TGCV JGCF QH 5CKPV 2CWNWU 8.8 . -CRRGNJQHH IT. 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 0Q VGZV XKUKDNG QP QDXGTUG -CRRGNJQHH IKXGU HQNNQYKPI VGZVU # . ..85 CPF 4 2#8. OGPVKQPU QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP RTKX 5IN #

%1706; '#56 (4+5+# '001 +

)QWFIWNFGP 'OFGP. # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV YKVJ NCOD QXGT UJKGNF '01 Q %1 Q (4+5+' Q 1+)' 6#. 4 1TD KP VTGHQKN (4'&4+%85 Q 41/#0148 Q +/2' . (D -CRRGNJQHH 6GTICUV /GKGT IT. 44 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6KVNG QH GORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++ 5V ,QJP YKVJ NCOD QP CTO KU VJG FKUVKPIWKUJKPI OCTM QH VJG 'OFGT )QWNFIWNFGP

272


'&<#4& +

&QRRGNVGT -TWOUVGGTV 'OFGP . # *CTR[ QXGT VYQ UJKGNFU CTOU YKVJ JCTR[ CPF NKQP '&<#4& %1+ (4+ 1+'06# 4 %QCV QH CTOU UV CPF VJ CPINGU YKVJ JCTR[ PF CPF TF CPINGU YKVJ NKQP CPF GCING QP EGPVTGF UJKGNF QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF #00 &10+ /Q%% %%% KPPGT EKTENG $#2#% '+0&0' +0&+'$ 85 Q 04+5 . -CRRGNJQHH 6GTICUV /GKGT IT. 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 6J *COGT EQNNGEVKQP 0GY ;QTM %QKPCIG FWG VQ VJG OQPGVCT[ TGHQTO QH 6JG KPUETKRVKQP &# 2#%'/ &1/+0' +0 &+'$75 0156475 SWQVGU VJG 1NFGPDWTI OQVVQ 6JG %KTMUGPC HCOKN[ EQCV QH CTOU UJQYU VJG JCTR[ CP GCING YKVJ C YQOCPʼnU JGCF # UKOKNCT EQCV QH CTOU KU UGGP YKVJ VJG EKV[ QH 0WTGODGTI KP YJKEJ VJG GCING DGCTU VJG JGCF QH 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM ++ +V KU WPENGCT YJGVJGT VJG %KTMUGPCU YGTG KPURKTGF D[ VJKU +V KU UGGP QP EQKPU UVCTVKPI 1P VJG EQKPU QH 'PPQ + CRCTV HTQO VJG JCTR[ VJG 7MGOC NKQP KU KPENWFGF VJG KPGUEWVEJGQP UJQYU VJG GCING QH VJG *QWUG VQO $TQM HTQO YJKEJ 'PPQʼnU ITGCV ITCPFOQVJGT &QFC UVGOOGF 6JKU KU VJG EQCV QH CTOU VJCVʼnU CNUQ UJQYP JGTG

'&<#4& ++ CPF ,1*#00

*CNDGT 9KVVG . # %TQYPGF UJKGNF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING CPF UJKGNF YKVJ JCTR[ QP DTGCUV DGPGCVJ VJG ETQYP '& 6\ ' 6\ +1 6\ %1 6\ ' 6\ &1 6\ 2* 6\ 1 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ UVCT KP EGPVTG &# 2 ņ #%' ņ & 1 + & 0 . -CRRGNJQHH IT. 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP %QKP HTQO VJG [GCTU WUWCNN[ YKVJ VJG OQPG[GTʼnU UGCN QH &KTM +FGP -TWKVMTGOGT X F %JKLU *GTGP GP 5VGFGP XCP )GNFGTNCPF $GTKEJVKIWPI FC\W 0WO #P\I R 0KGWYG &TGPVUG 8QNMUCNOCPCM R HH 6JG KNNWUVTCVKQP KP X F %JKLU KU KPENWFGF KP 2CUUQP &G 5VGFGNKLMG /WPVUNCI XCP 0KLOGIGP DKL 'KIJVJ UVWKXGT &GUETKRVKQP QH VJG ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG D[ -CRRGNJQHH %TQUU CPET¾G QH VYKP [CTP FKXKFKPI VJG NGIGPF YKVJ GNCDQTC VKQPU CPF C TJQODKE QRGPKPI KP VJG OKFFNG YKVJ C UKZ TC[GF UVCT 6JKU UKZ TC[GF UVCT KPFKECVGU VJG ENQUG VKGU QH VJG %KTMUGPC HCOKN[ YKVJ VJG EKV[ QH 0QTFGP VCMGP HTQO -CRRGNJQHH &KG /Ã’P\GP 1UVHTKGUNCPFU 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG FGPQVGU ' PPQ +1 JCPPGU % QOGU ' V & QOK 0 W 5 2* TKGUKC 1 TKGP VJG TGXGTUG VGZV KU QPEG CICKP VJG YGNN MPQYP FKEVWO &# R #%' O &1 OKPG + P & KGDWU 0 QUVTWU +PVGTRWPEVKQP QDXGTUG Z H

273


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ʼnU FGOKUG KP $QPKHCEG VQQM JQNF QH 7VTGEJV UWEEGUUHWNN[ CXGTVKPI DKUJQR *KNFGICT QH %QNQIPGʼnU ENCKOU #HVGT VJG HQTOGTʼnU FGCVJ KP C XCEWWO GPUWGF YJKEJ NCUVGF WPVKN YJGP CP WPKPVGTTWRVGF NKPG QH 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU YQWNF UVCTV YKVJ #NDGTKEJ 6JG UKVWCVKQP JQYGXGT TGOCKPGF WPUVCDNG CPF YJGP VJG 8KMKPIU TGVWTPGF $KUJQR *WPIGT HNGF VQ 1FKNKGPDGTI PGCT 4QGTOQPF VJKU OQPCUVGT[ YCU C IKHV HTQO .QVJCKT ++ KP KPVGPFGF CU C UCPEVWCT[ HTQO VJG FCPIGTQWU RQNKVKECN UKVWCVKQP KP 7VTGEJV YJKNG CNUQ &GXGPVGT YQWNF DG C TGUKFGPEG QH VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU 5V 4CFDQF UVKNN TGUKFGF KP &GXGPVGT VJG 7VTGEJV UKVWCVKQP [GV VQQ XQNCVKNG HQT JKO VQ TGVWTP *KU UWEEGUUQT $CNFTKE YQWNF FGHKPKVKXGN[ DTKPI VJG GRKUEQRCN UGG DCEM VQ 7VTGEJV 7VTGEJV OC[ DG TGICTFGF CU RCTV QH VJG 1VVQPKCP U[UVGO KP YJKEJ )GTOCP GORGTQTU DGUVQYGF NCTIG RTQRGTVKGU CPF VJG CEEQORCP[KPI CWVJQTKVKGU QP VJG ENGTWU VQ EQWPVGTDCNCPEG VJG RQNKVKECN YGKIJV QH NQECN UGEWNCT NQTFU 6JWU VJG )GTOCP MKPIU CPF GORGTQTU DGUVQYGF 9GUVGTIQ 1QUVGTIQ CPF 5VCXQTGP COQPI QVJGT VGTTKVQTKGU QP VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV YJQUG UGEWNCT CWVJQTKV[ VJGTGD[ YCU CNKIPGF YKVJ VJGKT FKQEGUG 6JG VJ EGPVWT[ UCY VJG CRQIGG QH ENGTKECN RQYGT KP 7VTGEJV $KUJQR #FGNDQNF ++ DWKNV C PGY ECVJGFTCN CPF $GTPQNFWU GTGEVGF VYQ RCTKUJ EJWTEJGU 5V 2KGVGT CPF 5V ,QJP CPF %QPTCF HQWPFGF VJG RCTKUJ EJWTEJ QH 5V /CTKC

*'+04+%* ++ +P 7VTGEJV CNTGCF[ GPLQ[GF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV TGEGKXGF HTQO 1VVQ + CPF CEMPQYNGFIGF D[ 1VVQ ++ KP *QYGXGT -KPI *GKPTKEJ ++ YQWNF DG VJG HKTUV VQ UVTKMG EQKP KP 7VTGEJV #NDTGEJV 0KGFGTNQVJTKPIKUEJG /Ã’P\GP R EQPUKFGTU VJKU EQKP VQ DG UVTWEM KP VJG PCOG QH -KPI *GKPTKEJ ++ KP 7VTGEJV WPFGT $KUJQR #FGNDQNF ++ GXGP VJQWIJ VJG NCVVGTʼnU PCOG KU PQV KPFKECVGF QP VJG EQKPU $KUJQR #FGNDQNF ++ YCU C UEJQNCT C TGPQYPGF OCVJGOCVKEKCP YJQ JCF DGGP GFWECVGF KP .K½IG *G DWKNV C PGY ECVJGFTCN YJKEJ KU PQV VJG RTGUGPV FC[ ECVJGFTCN QH 7VTGEJV CV VJG UKVG QH VJG QNF UOCNN EJWTEJ #FGNDQNF CNUQ TGDWKNV VJG CDDG[ EJWTEJ KP 6KGN YJKEJ YCU FGFKECVGF KP VJG PCOG QH 5V 9CNRWTIKU

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI *' +04+ %85 4' : 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR CPF 6 4# +'% 6 8 NGIGPF KP HQWT NKPGU YKVJKP :4+56+#0# 4' .+)+ 1 &CPP +NKUEJ -NWIG IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

274


&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI *' +0 4+% 85 4' : 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR CPF 6 4# +'% 6 8 NGIGPF KP HQWT NKPGU YKVJKP :4+56+ #0# 4' .+ )+1 &CPP +NKUEJ -NWIG IT 4 $GPV CPF HNCP ETCEM HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ

-104#& ++ $'401.&75 $GTPQNFWU YCU RTKGUV KP 1QUVGTDGGM YJGP VJG GORGTQTʼnU YKHG YCU KP NCDQWT VJGTG 7RQP VJG DKTVJ QH VJG JGCNVJ[ EJKNF VJG RTKGUV JKOUGNH URGF VQ 7VTGEJV YJGTG VJG GORGTQT YCU UVC[KPI VQ FGNKXGT VJG IQQF PGYU 6JG GORGTQT UJQYGF JKOUGNH ITCVGHWN DG[QPF VJG RTKGUVʼnU GZRGEVC VKQPU CPF CRRQKPVGF JKO DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI % 10 4#& 4 ': 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR CPF 6 4#+ '%6 NGIGPF KP VJTGG NKPGU YKVJKP $' 4 01.& '2+5%1 2 &CPP +NKUEJ IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

9GUVH /Ã’P\CWMVKQP #WEVKQP PQ +P &CPPGPDGTI KV UC[U 7PD·TVKIGT -CKUGTMQRH -QPTCF ++ PQ VGZV YJCVUQGXGT 1P VJG TGXGTUG $'401+ +P KVU RTGEKUG KOKVCVKQP QH VJG FGPCTKWU QH %QPTCF ++ RTQDCDN[ VJG QNFGUV HCDTKE D[ VJKU DKUJQR -QPTCF 4GZ CPF $GTPQNFWU *GPEG KV YCU UVTWEM KP +NKUEJ MPQYU QH QPN[ HQWT URGEKOGPU $GTNKP *GNUKPMK VYKEG CPF /Ã’PUVGT #HVGT PQ VJCV HGCVWTGU DQVJ VJG PCOG QH VJG )GTOCP MKPI CPF VJCV QH VJG DKUJQR VJG GORGTQTʼnU PCOG XCPKUJGU CNVQIGVJGT HTQO $GTPQNFWUʼn EQKPCIG

$'401.&75 0CVWTCNN[ $GTPQNFWU YCU C UVCNYCTV UWRRQTVGT QH VJG GORGTQT *G UVQQF D[ JKO CICKPUV )QFHTG[ VJG $GCTFGF CPF CICKPUV &KTM +8 QH *QNNCPF 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +++ UJQYGF ITCVKVWFG KP VJG HQTO QH VJG DGUVQYCN QH PWOGTQWU RTQRGTVKGU CPF EQOKVCN RTKXKNGIGU 6JWU $GTPQNFWU YCU VJG HQWPFGT QH 7VTGEJV RQYGT *G DWKNV VJG RCTKUJ EJWTEJGU 5V 2KGVGT CPF 5V ,QJP KP 7VTGEJV CPF TGEGKXGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV HQT )TQPKPIGP KP CPF HQT &GXGPVGT KP UGG CNUQ WPFGT &GXGPVGT

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

275


&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP ETQUU +++ 5%5 /#4 6+0 85 #4 %*+' 4 564# +'%68 QXGT YCNN YKVJ RQTVCN 5 $'401.&8 5'&+5 %1&8 + &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 5GG GNWEKFCVKQP YKVJ PQ

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF #+ QXGT VJG TKIJV UJQWNFGT 5 %5$10+(# %+85 #4%*+' 4 48 +++01 %' KP VJTGG NKPGU $'401+285'258' 8 &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT (NCP FGHGEV QVJGTYKUG YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ +P +NKUEJ KV UC[U $GK FGO 6[R MQOOV GKPG DGVT·EJVNKEJG $CPFDTGKVG CP 8CTKCPVGP XQT KPUDGUQPFGTG KP FGT 8GTVGKNWPI FGT 2WPMVG \YKUEJGP FGP $WEJUVCDGP FGT .GIGPFGP #WEJ FKG .GIGPFGP UKPF OKVWPVGT DKU \WT 7PMGPPVNKEJMGKV GPVUVGNNV 6JKU XCTKCPV KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP VJG NKVGTCVWTG

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 18+ &# ! 4 )48 10 0+ '% KP VJTGG NKPGU 8+++ &8. : ! &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG VGZVU QP QD CPF TGXGTUG CTG PGCTN[ WPTGEQIPKUCDNG

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP ETQUU QH RGNNGVU 5%5 $10& 8%'1 4 %48 100+ %' KP VJTGG NKPGU *' +4őő &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG #PVQPQX 4KIC 6JKU V[RG YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF ETQUU FQGU PQV HGCVWTG KP +NKUEJ

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP $#%7 .85 '4+51+54#4 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING )'41+0))4#& &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 0KEG RCVKPC CPF CPF YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG #WHJ·WUGT /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ $CEWNWU ETQUKGT QH VJG DKUJQR

276


&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP $#%7 .85 )4 4#548 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 0+))'# &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM KP RCTVU XGT[ HKPG

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV HCEKPI 5 .'$8+085 %1 0( 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $'401.&85 ' 25 &CPP +NKUEJ -NWIG XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

$GEMGPDCWGT /Ã’PEJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ

9GUVH /Ã’P\CWMVKQP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG 5 QP VJG QDXGTUG UJQYU C JQTK\QPVCN UVTQMG CU FQGU VJCV KP 5CPEVC %QNQPKC +U %10( UJQTV HQT EQPHGUUQT! (QT 5V .GDWKPWU UGG WPFGT &GXGPVGT

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV HCEKPI $'4 01.&85 '2 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING *'+04 +%85 4' &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV HCEKPI $'401 5 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $'4018 & &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

)QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR $'401 .&85 '25 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &#8' 0 64 '0 5+ &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT (NCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

277


&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING NGIGPF RCTVN[ XKUKDNG &#8'064'05+ &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 4KGVFKLM FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ 6JG &CXGPVTKC QP VJG TGXGTUG ECPPQV ENGCTN[ DG OCFG QWV

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR $' 401.&8 5 ' 25 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $'401.&8 5 '2 5 &CPP +NKUEJ IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF C NKVVNG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 6JKU V[RG KU PQV NKUVGF KP X F %JKLU *QYGXGT XF%J CPF YKVJ VJG UCOG FTCYKPI DWV C TGXGTUG &#8'064+# CTG GUVCDNKUJGF 1P XF%J VJG NGIGPFU CTG KNNGIKDNG +NKUEJ MPQYU QH QPN[ VJTGG URGEKOGPU

9+..'/ QH 2106 9KNNKCO YCU HTQO VJG )WGNFGTU *QWUG QH 2QPV #V VJG 5[PQF QH 7VTGEJV KP JG CFXQECVGF VJG GZEQOOWPKECVKQP QH 2QRG )TGIQT[ 8++ YJQ UJQTVN[ DGHQTG JCF FGRQUGF JKO 7PFGT 9KNNKCO QH 2QPV 7VTGEJV EQKPU UGNFQON[ KPFKECVGF C PCOG $WV KP )TQPKPIGP VJG PCOG QH VJG )GTOCP -KPI *GPT[ CRRGCTGF VQIGVJGT YKVJ VJCV QH VJG DKUJQR +PEKFGPVCNN[ VJG EQKPU QH 9KNNKCO QH 2QPV HTQO )TQPKPIGP CTG VJG NCUV UVTWEM VJGTG D[ VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU 6JGTG CTG PQ MPQYP &GXGPVGT EQKPU QH 9KNNKCO QH 2QPVʼnU

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF UVCHH GPFKPI KP ETQUU VJTGG RGNNGVU KP HKGNF 9+.*'. VJG NGVVGTU QWVYCTFU 4 8 '%6+ KP VYQ NKPGU QXGT YCNN 16 %+#4

64#+'861 TGVTQITCFG &CPP C +NKUEJ XF%J IT # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP )QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP ETQUU ++%5 *7 '25 4 +8 +'%6+ KP VYQ NKPGU QXGT YCNN 50 8 &CPP C +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI *'04+%85 4' 4 $KUJQR T YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF TKPI DGJKPF JKO 88++*'+0+85 &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 4 5NKIJVGN[ ETCEMGF QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC 5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ

278


&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI *'04+%85 4' 4 $KUJQR T YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF QOGIC YKVJ ETQUU DGJKPF JKO 88++*'+0+85 &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 4 5OCNN URNKV CV VJG GFIG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GPKGT )TQPKPIGP # %TQYPGF DWUV N YKVJ UEGRVTG TKPI DGJKPF *'40+%85 4' 4 *GCF T YKVJ ETQUKGT 88+'/%'8 +85 &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 44 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

9#) #WEVKQP PQ &CPPGPDGTI MPQYU QH QPN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP +NKUEJ MPQYU QH PQPG JG IKXGU QPN[ C NKPG FTCYKPI CPF LWUV NKMG X F %JKLU TGHGTU VQ 5V 2GVGTUDWTI

-104#& XQP 5%*9#$'0 $KUJQR %QPTCF DWKNV VJG RCTKUJ EJWTEJ QH 5V /CTKC KP 7VTGEJV EQORNGVKPI VJG QTICPKUCVKQP QH VJG GRKUEQRCN EKV[ %QPTCF UWRRQTVGF VJG GORGTQT NQ[CNN[ CPF VQQM RCTV KP OCP[ U[PQFU COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU &WTKPI JKU TGKIP 'ORGTQT %QPTCF +8 DGUVQYGF 1QUVGTIQ 9GUVGTIQ CPF 5VCXQTGP QP VJG 7VTGEJV EJWTEJ 6JG $KUJQR GZGTVGF JKU TKIJV QH OKPV KP VJGUG VGTTKVQTKGU HTQO OKPVU KP .GGWYCTFGP 5VCXQTGP CPF &QMMWO UGG +NKUEJ PQU VQ *G YCU OWTFGTGF D[ C (TKUKCP OGTEJCPV KP 6JG RTGEKUG TGCUQPU HQT VJKU OWTFGT TGOCKP WPENGCT CNVJQWIJ VJCV VJG (TKUKCPU YGTG CV VJG VKOG UVTKXKPI VQYCTF KPFGRGPFGPEG KU CP GUVCDNKUJGF HCEV %QPTCF YQWNF DG VJG NCUV 7VTGEJV DKUJQR VQ OKPV KP &GXGPVGT HQT C NQPI VKOG

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR T DGVYGGP ETQUKGT CPF UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP ETQUU %104#&85 '25 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU QXGT FQWDNGF DQY 64#+'% 6 8/ &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J 4 $TQMGP URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (QWPF KP 'IOQPF $KPPGP &CPPGPDGTI MPQYU QH QPN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP DWV KPFKECVGU PQVJKPI CU VQ KVU RTGUGPV NQECVKQP *KU VGZVU CTG %10 #& CPF 4 %%86/ +P +NKUEJ ,2/ QP R KP C HQQVPQVG #NU 'KP\GNHWPF XQTIGMQOOGP KP 'IOQPF $KPPGP

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT %10 4#&85 '25 4 6JTGG VQYGTU QXGT DQY &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 4 (NCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

9GUVH /ÒP\CWMVKQP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG TGXGTUG UJQWNF TGCF 64#+'%67/ DWV VJG EQKP UJQYU PQ UWEJ VJKPI .QPI EQPUKFGTGF C EQKP QH $WTEJCTF CU FKF COQPI QVJGTU X F %JKLU YKVJ PQ YJQ JQYGXGT CNTGCF[ FQWDVGF VJKU [GV KV KU QH %QPTCFʼnU QH VJG UGEQPF RJCUG +NKUEJ CPF KV OCTMU VJG UVCTV QH VJG RGTKQF QH UOCNNGT EQKPU

279


&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UVCHH GPFKPI KP ETQUU CPF TCKUGF NGHV JCPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &CPP +NKUEJ X F%J IT 4 (NCP ETCEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ 9KVJ &CPPGPDGTI VJKU EQKP KU NKUVGF WPFGT #PFTGCU %QWPV QH -W[M FWG VQ VJG #& CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG $WV &CPPGPDGTI UGNH VJKPMU KV OQTG QH C %QPTCF HCDTKE 8 F %JKLU CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ #PFTGCU *KU FTCYKPI QH KV RTQXKFGU VJG UCOG VGZV CU &CPPGPDGTIʼnU #& '25 [GV DQVJ FTCYKPIU FKHHGT +NKUEJ JCU PQY ENCUUKHKGF KV WPFGT %QPTCF DGECWUG KVU UK\G FQGUPʼnV OCVEJ VJCV WUGF D[ NCVGT DKUJQRU 6JG VGZVU UJQWNF DG # %104#&85 '25 CPF 4 &8#064+# DWV PQPG QH KV CRRGCTU QP VJKU EQKP

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 2+ % 10 4#&85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING *'4 0* 68 '5 &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 44 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM KP RCTVU QVJGTYKUG GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

9GUVH /Ã’P\CWMVKQP #WEVKQP PQ 9KVJ *GKPTKEJ +8 &CPPGPDGTI UC[U QP R VJCV VKVNGU QH JQPQT CTG PGXGT OGPVKQPGF QP ENGTKECN EQKPU YKVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH 2+85 YJKEJ KU UQOGVKOGU OGPVKQPGF D[ VJG CTEJDKUJQRU QH %QNQIPG UGG CNUQ VJG PQVG QH PQ

$74%*#4&

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # *GCF T YKVJ ETQUKGT $84%#4&' 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING 6 4# + '%68/ &CPP C +NKUEJ XF%J IT 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ (QWPF KP VJG $GVWYG QP VJG DCPM QH VJG 9CCN 4KXGT PGCT 9CCTFGPDWTI 5RTKPI

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

)1&'$#.&

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # *GCF YKVJ ETQUKGT T 6#1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG &CPP +NKUEJ XF%J IT 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ (QWPF KP VJG $GVWYG *GGTGYCCTFGP #V XCP FGT %JKLUʼn KNNWUVTCVKQP RN VJG NQECVKQPU QH VJG # CPF VJG 1 ENGCTN[ CTG VJG UCOG

280


*#46$'46 6JG (TKUKCP *CTVDGTV VTKGF VQ GHHGEVKXGN[ GUVCDNKUJ JKU CWVJQTKV[ KP )TQPKPIGP CPF &TGPVG *G CRRQKPVGF QPG DTQVJGT RTGHGEV QH )TQPKPIGP CPF CPQVJGT XKUEQWPV QH -QGXQTFGP 6JKU YQWNF JCXG HCVCN EQPUGSWGPEGU NCVGT UGG WPFGT )TQPKPIGP CPF -QGXQTFGP

&GPKGT # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT *# 46 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETQUU KP GCEJ CPING +80# XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 8 F %JKLU MPGYU UGXGTCN EQKPU VJCV HKV VJKU FGUETKRVKQP DWV QP PQPG EQWNF JG FKUEGTP CP[VJKPI TGUGODNKPI VGZV *G FKF RWV HQTYCTF VJG CUUWORVKQP VJCV VJG[ OKIJV PQV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM KP 7VTGEJV DWV GNUGYJGTG

*'4/#0 QH *1140'

&GPKGT # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG YTGCVJ QH RGNNGVU KP VJG EGPVTG GPENQUKPI C UVCT XF%J IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

*WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO 8 F %JKLU KU PQV CV CNN CDNG VQ OCMG QWV VJG VGZV DWV JG UWURGEVU KV VQ DG *#4/#0 DCUGF QP C HGY NGVVGTU VJCV CTG FKUEGTPCDNG QP VJG KNNWUVTCVKQPU *G FQGUPʼnV RTQXKFG CP[ KPFKECVKQPU CU VQ VJG TGXGTUG VGZV 6JG TGIKQPCN NQTFU YJQ YKUJGF C HGGDNG RTGNCVG EJQUG *GTOCP EJCRNCKP QH 5V ,GTQOG KP %QNQIPG #EMPQYNGFIGF D[ 'ORGTQT %QPTCF CPF VJG RQRG

&GPKGT # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ EKTENG KP VJG EGPVTG GPENQUKPI C YJGGN XF%J IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5QGUVGT /Ã’P\MCDKPGVV 5QGUV (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG QDXGTUG DQVVQO NGHV FKURNC[U CP 1 6JG TGXGTUG UJQYU C & KH PQV OQTG &GXGPVGT! 8 F %JKLU MPQYU PQ EQKP QH VJG OGPVKQPGF TGXGTUG QPN[ QH C TGXGTUG UWEJ CU PQ

)1&(4+'& QH 4*'0'0 )QFHTG[ YCU ECVJGFTCN RTQXQUV CPF JCF VJG UWRRQTV QH (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC

&GPKGT # $WUV N YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM ITGCV TQUGVVG DGJKPF VJG JGCF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG YTGCVJ QH RGNNGVU KP VJG EGPVTG GPENQUKPI C UVCT XF%J XCT IT 44 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO (F &CENKE 6H PQ 0QPG QH VJG KNNWUVTCVKQPU KP 8 F %JKLU OCVEJ VJKU EQKP VJG TQUGVVG KP RCTVKEWNCT KU OKUUKPI &TCYKPI EQOGU ENQUGUV DWV VJG NGVVGTU VJCV UJQYU CTGPʼnV QP VJKU EQKP NGIKDNG CTG (2+& QP VJKU EQKP OC[DG &' 8 F %JKLU VJKPMU VJKU V[RG CU QRRQUGF VQ V[RG OKIJV DG UVTWEM KP &GXGPVGT HQT GZCORNG KPUVGCF QH KP 7VTGEJV

281


$17&'9+,0 ++ $CNFYKP YCU C DTQVJGT QH (NQTKU +++ QH *QNNCPF CPF QYGF JKU CRRQKPVOGPV VQ VJG HCEV VJCV (NQTKU JCF LQKPGF KP VJG GORGTQTʼnU GZRGFKVKQP VQ +VCN[ *KU QVJGT DTQVJGT &KTM YCU ECVJGFTCN RTQXQUV QH 7VTGEJV

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $WUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT $#&9+ 0 '2% 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG / KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 64#+'%68/ XF%J IT 44 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO

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

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # /KVTGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 6'1&' 4+%85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG VTKFGPV YKVJ TKPIU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 64#+'%68/ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP # FCO #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT # /KVTGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 6'1&' 4+%85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPF QPG VTKFGPV YKVJ TKPIU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 64#+'%68/ XF%J IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 5 QP VJG QDXGTUG VWTPGF CTQWPF +U VJKU OGVCN QH KPHGTKQT SWCNKV[! 0Q YGKIJU C OGTG I OQTG JQYGXGT

1661 ++ QH VJG .+22' 1VVQ ++ YCU HTQO VJG EQOKVCN *QWUG XCP FGT .KRRG (TQO 1VVQ QH VJG .KRRG QPYCTF CRCTV HTQO C HGY KPVGTTWRVKQPU VJGTG YCU OKPVKPI KP &GXGPVGT CICKP #U VJG RTGHGEV QH )TQPKPIGP CPF VJG XKUEQWPV QH -QGXQTFGP DQVJ JCF FGENCTGF VJGOUGNXGU KPFGRGPFGPV 1VVQ NGF CP CTO[ PQTVJYCTF +P VJG $CVVNG CV #PG JG PQV QPN[ UWHHGTGF C JWOKNKCVKPI FGHGCV D[ &TGPVG RGCUCPVU DWV CNUQ OGV JKU GPF QP VJG DCVVNGHKGNF 6JG PQTVJ UWDUGSWGPVN[ UVCTVGF KVU UGEGUUKQP

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # /KVTGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT 1661 '2+5 %12 4 %TQUU YKVJ # 8 ņ ' KP VJG CPINGU Z &#8 '064+# XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

282


5'&' 8#%#06'

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $WUV QH 5CKPV /CTVKPWU HCEKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF RCNO NGCH 5 /#46+ 085 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF 2 # : KP VJG CPINGU +0 &#8'0 64+ # XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

0WOKUOCVKEC 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP KU CNOQUV CNYC[U CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG UGFG XCECPV RGTKQF DGVYGGP VJG DKUJQRU 1VVQ ++ WPVKN CPF 9KNDTCPF

HTQO QP 8CP )GNFGT SWGUVKQPU VJKU KP JKU CTVKENG QP VJG 4Q[CN /KPV KP 0KLOGIGP +P HQQVPQVG JG KPEKFGPVCNN[ TGOCTMU VJCV X F %JKLU HCNUGN[ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU EQKP VQ VJG RGTKQF FKTGEVN[ CHVGT 1VVQ ++ DGECWUG KV UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG UGFG XCECPV RGTKQF FKTGEVN[ HQNNQYKPI VJG TGKIP QH 1VVQ +++ 1VVQ +++ FKGF QP TF #RTKN CV VJG NCVGUV 6JG ECPQPU GNGEVGF )QUGYKPWU QH 4CPFGTCVJ YJKEJ YCU PQV WPUWEEGUUHWNN[ EQPVGUVGF D[ *GPT[ QH 8KCPFGP 6JG NCVVGT DGECOG DKUJQR KP 7PHQTVWPCVGN[ XCP )GNFGT RTQXKFGU PQ CTIWOGPVU VQ UWRRQTV VJKU 0QPGVJGNGUU YG RTGHGT VQ EJQQUG VJG RGTKQF FKTGEVN[ CHVGT 1VVQ ++ UGG CNUQ QDQNG PQ #NUQ UGG HQQVPQVG KP 5VWWTOCPʼnU CTVKENG <QGMNKEJV QR GGP FWKUVGTG OWPVXQPFUV KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R

1DQNG &GXGPVGT # $WUV QH 5CKPV /CTVKPWU HCEKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF RCNO NGCH 5 /#46+085 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF 2 # : KP VJG CPINGU &#8'0 64+# XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG . 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 8GT[ EWTKQWU URGEKOGP (QT CP GZVGPUKXG EQOOGPVCT[ QP VJG FCVKPI QH VJKU EQKP UGG WPFGT PQ

9+..'$4#0& QH 1.&'0$74) 9KNNGDTCPF YCU VJG EQWUKP QH %QWPV (NQTKU +8 QH *QNNCPF UQP QH VJG EQWPV QH 1NFGPDWTI CPF DKUJQR QH 2CFGTDQTP 6JG GNGEVKQP YCU UWRRQTVGF D[ VJG EQWPV QH )WGNFGTU CPF VJG NQTF QH #OUVGN

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT PQ NGIGPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG UOCNN RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG PQ NGIGPF XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM PQ NGIGPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG UOCNN RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG PQ NGIGPF XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ 6JKU EQKP CRRGCTU VQ EQPVCKP PQ VGZV JCF VJGTG CV UQOG VKOG DGGP CP[ VJG HNCP YQWNF JCXG DGGP OWEJ NCTIGT KVU YGKIJV JKIJGT

$QWIJV VGP %CVG EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO EH PQ

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG UOCNN RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG 64#+ '%6 8/ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 9+.. 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG UOCNN RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG 64#+'%6 68/ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

*WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO

283


5'&' 8#%#06'

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 5 /# 4 6+085 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD QPG UOCNN RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG 64#+ ' %68/ XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 5COG TGXGTUG CU VJG EQKPU QH 9KNNGDTCPF QH 1NFGPDWTI 6JKU EQKP KU GZVGPUKXGN[ FKUEWUUGF D[ 5VWWTOCP KP <QGMNKEJV QR GGP FWKUVGTG OWPVXQPFUV KP &G $GGNFGPCCT

R 6JKU CTVKENG EQPEGTPU C JQCTF KP $GGMDGTIGP KP $CUGF QP VJG TGUGODNCPEG DGVYGGP VJG FGXKEG QP VJG EQKPU QH 9KNDTCPF QH 1NFGPDWTI CPF VJCV QH VJKU RCTVKEWNCT EQKP JG CTTKXGU CV VJG EQPENWUKQP VJCV VJKU EQKP UJQWNF DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG UGFG XCECPVG RGTKQF CHVGT 9KNDTCPF 9KNDTCPF FKGF QP VJ QT VJ ,WN[ (KTUV TGEQTFGF OGPVKQP QH 1VVQ +++ QH *QNNCPF CU VJG PGY DKUJQR KU QP UV (GDTWCT[ JKU QTFKPCVKQP CV VJG GCTNKGUV VQQM RNCEG QP PF &GEGODGT CPF RGTJCRU GXGP NCVGT QP VJ ,WPG 6JKU EQKP KU OGPVKQPGF KP VJG CTVKENG QH 5VWWTOCP 6YQ URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG CTG MGRV CV VJG -2- CPF UGXGP KP VJG EGPVTCN /WUGWO QH 7VTGEJV 1H CNN VJGUG URGEKOGPU VJKU KU VJG QPN[ QPG VJCV PQV QPN[ ENGCTN[ FGRKEVU VJG DQQM /CTVKP KU JQNFKPI DWV CNUQ VJG JCPF JG KU JQNFKPI KV YKVJ

1661 +++ 1VVQ YCU ECVJGFTCN RTQXQUV CPF DTQVJGT QH %QWPV (NQTKU +8 QH *QNNCPF

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR N YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 1661 ' 2+*5% 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD EKTENG YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF UVCT KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 64#+'680 %+8+ XF%J IT 44 $TQCF CPF YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

*'0&4+- QH 8+#0&'0 *GPT[ QH 8KCPFGP NCKF VJG HKTUV DTKEM HQT VJG ECVJGFTCN KP *GPT[ QH 8KCPFGP HTQO VJG .WZGODQWTI *QWUG QH 8KCPFGP YCU C DNQQF TGNCVKXG QH VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG CPF CTEJ FGCEQP QH VJG %QNQIPG EJWTEJ *G JCF CRRTQXCN QH -KPI 9KNNKCO

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR N YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT *'04+%8 5 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VTKFGPVU 64 #+'%6 8/ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5OCNN JGCF EQKP YKVJ VGZV

&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR N YKVJ OKVTG DQQM CPF ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VTKFGPVU

64# +'%6 8/ XF%J IT 4GXGT[G C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 0Q VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG

284


&GPKGT 7VTGEJV # $KUJQR N YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VTKFGPVU 64 # +'%6 8 / XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 1DXGTUG ENGCTN[ YKVJQWV VGZV

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM *'04 +%85 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF 2 # : Q KP VJG CPINGU & #8' 06 4+# XF%J IT $TQCF CPF YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

&GPKGT &GXGPVGT # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM *'0 4+%85 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF 2 # : Q KP VJG CPINGU & #8' 06 4+# XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

1DQNG &GXGPVGT # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT *'04 +%85 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF 2 # : Q KP VJG CPINGU &# 8# 06 4 XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

1DQNG &GXGPVGT # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM *'0 4+% 8 5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ RGNNGV KP EGPVTG CPF 2 # : Q KP VJG CPINGU % #8 ' XF%J IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z %QNN $WNNGT ņ 1UPCDTÒEM

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

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½IG D[ 2QRG 7TDCPWU 8

)TQQV 7VTGEJV # /KVTGF DWUV KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG *QWUG QH #TMGN +1J ( '2% ( 64# c c +'%6'05+5 4 /10 '6# 64# +'% CTQWPF ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ( 5+6 ( 01/' ( &0+ ( 04+ ( +J8 ( :2+ XF%J IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

285


)TQQV 7VTGEJV # /KVTGF DWUV KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG *QWUG QH #TMGN +1J ¶ '2% ¶ 64# c c +'%6'05+5 4 /10 '6# 64# +'% CTQWPF ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP ņ #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 6JG PQ CPF CTG QPN[ FKUVKPIWKUJCDNG D[ VJGKT KPVGTRWPEVKQP

)TQQV &GXGPVGT # /KVTGF DWUV KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG *QWUG QH #TMGN +1J ( '2% ( 64# +'%6'05+5 4 /10 '6# &#8 '06 CTQWPF ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG GCING KP VJG PF CPING $0&+%68 ( 5+6 ( 01/' ( &0+ ( 04+ ( +J8 XF%J IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ

+P YJGP VJG 2QRG UWFFGPN[ VTCPUHGTTGF ,QJP QH #TMGN VQ .K½IG EKV[ CPF EJCRVGTU CITGGF VQ VJG QXGTFTCEJV EGUUKQP VQ RTGXGPV CP[ CEVKQPU QH VJG PGY DKUJQR VJCV EQWNF CHHGEV VJG NCPF CXGTUGN[ 6JG[ KPXKVGF PQDKNKV[ CPF OKPQT EKVKGU VQ LQKP KP VJKU EGUUKQP +P O[ QRKPKQP VJG ITQQV PQ KU C EQKP VJCV GZRTGUUGU VJKU EGUUKQP

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

286


,#0 QH 8'40'$74) 2QRG 7TDCP 8 CRRQKPVGF ,QJP QH 8GTPGDWTI CV VJCV VKOG DKUJQR QH /ÒPUVGT DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 8GTPGDWTI FGTKXGU HTQO 8KTPGDWTI C VQYP PGCT %QDNGPV\ KP 2TWUUKC

&WDDGNG ITQQV # .KQP UKVVKPI N YKVJ JGNOGV CPF EQCV QH CTOU QH VJG DKUJQRTKE +1J#00'5 ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ '2%5 ¶ 64#+'%6'05 4 5OCNN HNQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# t &' t <#.#0&+# QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%685 ¶ 38+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &1/+0+ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

*WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO 6JG /10'6# &' <#.#0&+# VJCV HGCVWTGU QP VJG EQKPU QH ,QJP QH 8GTPGDWTI YCU KPVGPFGF VQ TGUGODNG VJG (NGOKUJ EQKPU DGCTKPI /10'6# &' (.#0&4+# #U <#.#0&+# UVCPFU HQT 5CNNCPF X F %JKLU CUUWOGF VJGUG EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM KP VJG ECRKVCN <YQNNG 6JCV CUUWORVKQP ECPʼnV RQUUKDN[ DG JGNF WR DGECWUG -CORGP CPF &GXGPVGT YGTG EQPUKFGTCDN[ OQTG KORQTVCPV VJGP KP &GXGPVGT ,QJP QH #TMGN OKPVGF KP -CORGP #TPQNF QH *QQTPG #U VJG V[RGU UVTWEM KP -CORGP YGTG VJG UCOG CU VJQUG VJCV YGTG FGUKIPCVGF 5CNNCPF EQKP WPFGT #TPQNFʼnU RTGFGEGUUQT VJG OKPV QH -CORGP FQGU UGGO NKMGN[ CNVJQWIJ VJKU GXKFGPEG KU JCTFN[ EQPENWUKXG VCMGP HTQO X )GNFGT 9GGTFUG ITQVGP KP ,/2 R

)TQQV 8QNNGPJQXG # $KUJQR HCEKPI KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG +1* ” '2 +64 #+'%6'05+5 4 %TQUU YKVJ + Z 0 1+ %& 0+ KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 81.'*1

64# +' XF%J IT 4 'FIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV (GDTWCT[ /CTEJ PQ

#401.& QH *1140' #TPQNF QH *QQTPG YCU EJQUGP D[ VJG ECPQPU 2QRG 7TDCP 8+ CRRQKPVGF #TPQNF DKUJQR QH .K½IG KP *QQTPG NKGU QRRQUKVG QH 4QGTOQPF +P VJG EGUUKQP YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF D[ #TPQNF QH *QQTPG CPF VJG FGETGG VJCV JG KUUWGF VQ VJKU RWTRQUG YQWNF DGEQOG VJG HWPFCOGPV QH VJG 7VTGEJV EQTRQTCVG UVCVG

)TQQV OGV FG JGNO FG 9GGTF # 5JKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG WPFGT JGNOGV #401.& ¶ &'+ )4# ¶ '2% ¶ 64# 4 /10 +05 8.' 64# CTQWPF ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ XF%J IT 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 6JGTG JCU CNYC[U DGGP C IQQF FGCN QH EQPHWUKQP YKVJ TGICTF VQ VJG VGZV /10 +058.' 64# 8 /KGTKU VTCPUNCVGF KV CU %QKP QH VJG 7VTGEJV EQWTV X F %JKLU VTCPUNCVGF KV CU 7VTGEJV EQKP UVTWEM KP <YQNNG -GTMYKLM TGCF 58.' CU VJG RNCEG <WKNGP PGCT 7VTGEJV 6JCV ECOG C NQV ENQUGT +PUWNC CPF 9CCTF 9GGTF DQVJ OGCP KUNCPF 6JWU +058.' 64# TGHGTU VQ VJG UWDWTD VQ VJG PQTVJ QH 7VTGEJV &G 9GGTF VCMGP HTQO X )GNFGT 9GGTFUG ITQVGP KP ,/2

R (COKN[ CTOU VJTGG JWPVKPI JQTPU IWNG YKVJ TKPIU CTIGPV QP C HKGNF 1T

287


(.14+5 QH 9'8'.+0)*18'0 2QRG 7TDCP 8+ CRRQKPVGF (NQTKU QH 9GXGNKPIJQXGP VJG DKUJQR QH /ÒPUVGT DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV

4KLPUG IQWFIWNFGP 4JGPGP # $WUV QH VJG UQXGTGKIP HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF WPFGT IQVJKE FCKU DGVYGGP NKVVNG UVCTU QXGT UJKGNF QH 9GXGNKPIJQXGP (.14'0 ¶ '2 % ¶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

)QWFIWNFGP &GXGPVGT # $KUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT KP IQVJKE ECPQR[ QXGT UJKGNF QH 9GXGNKPIJQXGP (.14'0% '25 64#+ Ő 4 'CING QXGT UJKGNF QH 9GXGNKPIJQXGP KP OWNVKNQDG /10'6# Q 018# Q &#8'064+'05+5 (D XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG UNKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM 'Z -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ

&WDDGNG ITQQV &GXGPVGT # /KVTGF DKUJQR HCEKPI KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT VJG UJKGNF QH 9GXGNKPIJQXGP (.14'0 ^ '2% ^ 64# Ê +'%6'05+5 ^ &#8 4 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# ^ 018# &#8'064+'05 Ê XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG )NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

+P VJG GRKUEQRCN GNGEVKQP QH VJGTG QPEG CICKP YGTG VYQ ECPFKFCVGU QPG HTQO *QNNCPF CPF VJG QVJGT QPG )WGNFGTU 6JG )WGNFGTU ECPFKFCVG (TGFGTKEM QH $NCPMGPJGKO YQP

288


(4'&'4+%- QH $.#0-'0*'+/ &WMG 9KNNKCO QH ,ÒNKEJ TGEQOOGPFGF JKU EQWUKP (TGFGTKEM QH $NCPMGPJGKO DKUJQR QH 5VTCUDQWTI *G EQORNGVGF VJG TGUVQTCVKQP QH VJG 1XGTUVKEJV CPF TGGUVCDNKUJGF JKU CWVJQTKV[ KP &TGPVG CPF )TQPKPIGP YJKEJ YCU GPVKTGN[ NQUV CHVGT VJG FGHGCV CV #PG *G HQTEGF VJG XKUEQWPV QH -QGXQTFGP VQ CDFKECVG (TGFGTKEM YCU QRRQUGF VQ *QNNCPF DGECWUG JG YCU GZRGTKGPEKPI C ITGCV FGCN QH RKTCVG CVVCEMU DWV KP VJG #TMGN 9CT JG UKFGF YKVJ *QNNCPF

)QWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV Ő 5 Ő +1*#00'5 $#$6+56# … 4 (KXG CTOU KP OWNVKNQDG &05 Ő (4'&'4+% Ő '2% Ő 64#+'%6'05 (D XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 8G[PCW EQNNGEVKQP 6JG HKXG CTOU CTG CU HQNNQYU /KFFNG CPF WRRGT PCVKQPCN CTOU NGHV CTOU QH $NCPMGPJGKO NKQP TCORCPV YKVJ HGUU WPFGT VJG PGEM QH VJG NKQP TKIJV CTOU QH VJG 5VKEJV WPFGT HCPVCU[ CTOU HKNNKPI

&WDDGNG ITQQV 4JGPGP # *GNOGV YKVJ NKQP QXGT UJKGNF QH $NCPMGPJGKO (4'&'4+% &'+ )4# '2% 64#+'%6'05+5 4 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG VYQ MG[U /10'6# 4'0'05+5 QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%6 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ XF%J IT 4 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 6YQ MG[U UJKGNF QH 4JGPGP

&WDDGNG ITQQV *CUUGNV # *GNOGV YKVJ NKQP QXGT UJKGNF QH $NCPMGPJGKO (4'&'4+% &'+ )4# '2% 64#+'%6'05 4 'CING N YKVJ UJKGNF QH *CUUGNV QP VJG DTGCUV QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG /10'6# &' *#55'.' QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%6 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ XF%J IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z (KPF QH <WVRJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

&WDDGNG ITQQV &GXGPVGT # *GNOGV YKVJ NKQP QXGT UJKGNF QH $NCPMGPJGKO (4'&'4+% &'+ )4# '2% 64#+'%6'05 4 'CING QH &GXGPVGT QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG /10'6# &#8'06'4' QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%6 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ XF%J IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #RTKN PQ

289


&WDDGNG ITQQV &GXGPVGT %QWPVGTOCTM /Ã’PUVGT # *GNOGV YKVJ NKQP QXGT UJKGNF QH $NCPMGPJGKO 5VCORGF JGCF QH 2CWNWU /Ã’PUVGT (4'&'4+% &'+ )4# '2% 64#+'%6'05 4 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG /10'6# &#8'06'4' QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%6 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ -TWU[ / C XF%J IT %QWPVGTOCTM (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG %QKP 8GT[ HKPG

)TQQV &GXGPVGT %QWPVGTOCTM /Ã’PUVGT # *GNOGV YKVJ NKQP QXGT UJKGNF QH $NCPMGPJGKO 5VCORGF JGCF QH 2CWNWU /Ã’PUVGT (4'&'4+% &'+ )4# '2% 64#+'%6' 4 'CING QH &GXGPVGT QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG /10'6# 018# &' &#8'06'4'05 -TWU[ / E XF%J IT %QWPVGTOCTM #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG %QKP 8GT[ HKPG

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F 6JG TGHGTGPEG VQ -TWU[ KU PQV GPVKTGN[ EGTVCKP DGECWUG VJG JGCF QH 5V 2CWN KU PQV YJQNN[ UVTWEM VJTQWIJ CPF JGPEG VJG DGCTF ECPʼnV DG UGGP / /ÒPUVGT

-Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

47&1.( QH &+'2*1.6 4WFQNH QH &KGRJQNV UQP QH VJG EQWPV QH &KGRJQNV YCU EJCRNCKP QH 1UPCDTÃ’EM UQOG UC[ ECPQP KP %QNQIPG 2QRG /CTVKP 8 FKF PQV YCPV VQ CEMPQYNGFIG 4WFQNH DGECWUG QH ITCXG FKUUGPV KP JKU FKQEGUG *GPEG 2QUVWNCVG VJG FGUKTGF +P DGVYGGP YCU <YGFGT QH -WKNGPDWTI FKGF KP

2QUVWNCCVIWNFGP # 5CKPV /CTVKP UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 5#0%6' /'46+0 '2+5 4 #TOU QH VJG FKQEGUG KP VTGHQKN YKVJ &KGRJQNV KP VJG EGPVTG /10 41&.2 21568.

64#+'%6 (D XF%J 2QUVWNCCV IT 44 9GNN UVTWEM CPF CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 8 F %JKLU MPQYU QPN[ QH VJTGG URGEKOGP #TOU QH &KGRJQNV NKQP RCUUCPV KP VJG WRRGT JCNH CPF GCING KP VJG NQYGT

9JGP (TGFGTKM QH $NCPMGPJGKO FKGF KP YCT DGVYGGP VJG *QQMU CPF VJG %QFU YCU TCIKPI CV HWNN UVTGPIVJ 1PEG CICKP DQVJ UKFGU RWV WR C ECPFKFCVG <YGFGT QH -WKNGPDWTI D[ VJG %QF HCEVKQP CPF 4WFQNH QH &KGRJQNV D[ VJG *QQMU $QVJ RTQENCKOGF VJGOUGNXGU NCYHWN DKUJQR 9KVJ VJG CKF QH $WTIWPF[ <YGFGT EQWNF VCMG VJG 0GFGTUVKEJV VJG 1XGTUVKEJV UVC[GF HCKVJHWN VQ 4WFQNH #HVGT <YGFGTʼnU FGCVJ KP VJG ECPQPU GNGEVGF C UWEEGUUQT 9CNTCXGP QH /GWTU YJQ YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF CV VJG EQWPEKN QH $CUGN 2JKNKR VJG )QQF UWRRQTVGF VJG RQRG TCVJGT VJCP VJKU EQWPEKN CPF JG FKF PQV CRRTQXG QH 9CNTCXGPʼnU CRRQKPVOGPV $WV VJG VKOG VQ KPVGTXGPG JCFPʼnV EQOG [GV +V ECOG YJGP 4WFQNH FKGF KP %CVJGFTCN RTQXQUV )KLUDTGEJV QH $TGFGTQFG YCU WP CPKOQWUN[ GNGEVGF DWV 2JKNKRU CRRTQCEJGF VJG RQRG CPF TGSWGUVGF VJG CRRQKPVOGPV QH JKU DCUVCTF UQP &CXKF 6JG 1XGTUVKEJV EQWNFPʼnV DWV QRRQUG VJKU EQWTUG QH CHHCKTU DWV 2JKNKR UVTWEM FQYP CNN TGUKUVCPEG 290


47&1.( QH &+'2*1.6

5V /CCTVGPU IQWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV /CTVKP UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 5#0%6' /'46+0 '2+5 4 #TOU QH VJG FKQEGUG KP VTGHQKN YKVJ &KGRJQNV KP VJG EGPVTG /10 41&.2

'2+5% 64#+'6 (D XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

5V /CCTVGPU IQWFIWNFGP # 5VCPFKPI 5CKPV /CTVKP YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 5#0%6' /'46+0 '2+5 4 #TOU QH VJG FKQEGUG KP VTGHQKN YKVJ &KGRJQNV KP VJG EGPVTG /10 41&.2

'2+5% 64#+'6 (D XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 8 F %J PQVGU VJCV VJKU KU C URGEKOGP QH XGT[ RCNG IQNF +V KU CP GZCORNG QH VJG *QNNCPF KUUWGU QH NQY CNNQ[ VJCV GXGPVWCNN[ ECWUGF 2JKNKR VJG )QQF VQ VCMG CEVKQP +P QTFGT VQ TWNG QWV VJG EKTEWNCVKQP QH KPHGTKQT EQKPU JG UKORN[ HQTDCFG VJG GPVKTG KUUWCPEG QP VJ #RTKN *G JCF JCF VQ TGUQTV VQ VJKU UCOG OGCUWTG QP VJG VJ QH 1EVQDGT KP TGURQPUG VQ QVJGT EQKPU QH VJG OGPVKQPGF DKUJQR #U VJG TGNWEVCPEG QH VJG UWTTQWPFKPI 0GVJGTNCPFU VQ CEEGRV VJGUG OQTG UKNXGT VJCP IQNF EQKPU FKF PQV YCPG VJG URGEKOGPU QH VJKU KUUWG YGTG UQQP YKVJFTCYP HTQO EKTEWNCVKQP CPF VJCV KU RTQDCDN[ YJ[ YG EQWNF TGVTKGXG QPN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP

)TQQV 4JGPGP # 5JKGNF QH &KGRJQNV KP VTGHQKN 41&1.(85 „ '25 „ 64#+'%6 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ 4 1 & ( KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 4'0'5+5 XF%J IT 44 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO

6JG IWKNF EQWPEKN QH 7VTGEJV FKF PQV EQPUGPV YKVJ &CXKFʼnU CRRQKPVOGPV ,QJP QH /QPVHQQTV *QQM EJKGH TGUKUVGF VJG DKUJQR CPF VJG *QNNCPF %QF HCEVKQP +P /CZKOKNKCP DGUKGIGF VJG EKV[ CPF UVTWEM FQYP VJG KPUWTIGPE[ 291


&#8+& QH $74)70&; #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH 4WFQNH QH &KGRJQNV ECVJGFTCN RTQXQUV )KLUDTGEJV QH $TGFGTQFG YCU GNGEVGF 'PXQ[U YGTG UGPV VQ 4QOG VQ CESWKTG RCRCN KPXGUVKVWTG 2JKNKR QH $WTIWPF[ YKVJ VJG CKF QH #NRJQPUQ QH #TCIQP KPVGTXGPGF CPF WTIGF 2QRG %CNKZVWU +++ VQ GNGEV &CXKF CPF VJG RQRG CESWKGUEGF +P QTFGT VQ CRRQKPV JKO VJG RQRG JCF VQ FGENCTG &CXKF 2JKNKRʼnU NGIKVKOCVG UQP 6JKU TCKUGU C SWGUVKQP QP VJG &CXKFUJCTR VJG CTOU UVKNN UJQY VJG YJKVG DCVQP UKPKUVGT UKIP QH VJG DCUVCTF YJQ YCUPʼnV CNNQYGF VQ DGCT VJG TGIWNCT CTOU 1P &CXKFʼnU NCVGT EQKPU KV XCPKUJGF 9GTG VJGUG &CXKFʼnU IWKNFGTU UVTWEM DGHQTG VJG RCRCN FGENCTCVKQP QH JKU NGIKVKOCE[!

&CXKFUJCTR 4JGPGP # -KPI &CXKF YKVJ JCTR QXGT GUEWVEJGQP /'/'061 W &1/+0' W &#8+& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ & # 8 + KP VJG CPINGU CPF & YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG &#8+& W &' W $84)10&+# W '2+5%1285 W 64#+'%6' (D XF%J X) IT 44 /CIPKHKEGPV YGNN UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5RKPM <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 8G[PCW EQNNGEVKQP 'OKUUKQP KUUWGF HQT ! UVWKXGT (KTUV EQKP QH &CXKF QH $WTIWPF[ 6JKU EQKP C IQNF UJKGNF &CXKFʼnU UJKGNF YCU C NCUV WUG QH VJG FCVGF *QNNCPF UJKGNFU /CPWHCEVWTG NCUVGF TGNCVKXGN[ UJQTV WPVKN CV VJG NCVGUV YJGP VJG &CXKFʼnU IWKNFGT YCU KPVTQFWEGF VJCV YCU TGNCVGF VQ VJG 4JKPKCP IQNF IWKNFGTU #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH DKUJQR &CXKFʼnU TGKIP VJG OKPV NKMGN[ YCU GUVCDNKUJGF KP 4JGPGP 6JG 0GFGTUVKEJV OKPV QH &CXKFʼnU RTGFGEGUUQT JCF DGGP NQECVGF VJGTG CPF &CXKF KP VJGUG [GCTU PQTOCNN[ TGUKFGF KP VJG ECUVNG 6GT *QTUV PGCT 4JGPGP +P JG KPJGTKVGF VJG ECUVNG 9KLM DKL &WWTUVGFG +V UVCPFU VQ TGCUQP VJCV VJG OKPV UQQP YCU CNUQ OQXGF HTQO 4JGPGP VQ 9KLM [GV VJG FCVG QH VJG OQXG KU PQV MPQYP 6JG GUEWVEJGQP KP CPF JCU VJG ETQUU QH VJG 5VKEJV KP CPF VJG CTOU QH VJG *QWUG $WTIWPF[ HTQO YJKEJ RCTV QH VJG NQYGT UGEVKQP KU OKUUKPI KP JGTCNFKEU MPQYP CU NC EJCORCIPG VQ UKIPKH[ VJG DCUVCTF[ QH VJG DGCTGT QH VJGUG CTOU 6JG $WTIWPFKCP GUEWVEJGQP KP CPF VJG OQUV FKIPKHKGF SWCFTCPVU JCU VJTGG NKU 1T QP C\WTG YKVJ C DQTFWTG QH C EJGSWGTGF DCPF QH CTIGPV CPF IWNG HQT 0GY $WTIWPF[ CPF QP VJG NGHV CP NKQP 1T NCPIWGF IWNG CPF CTOGF QP UCDNG HQT $TCDCPV +P VJG TF SWCFTCPV 1NF $WTIWPF[ TGVWTPU CPF VJG VJ SWCFTCPV UJQYU C UJKGNF YKVJ C NKQP IWNG ETQYPGF CPF CTOGF 1T CPF NCPIWGF C\WTG HQT .KODWTI 8CP /KGTKU TGRQTVU VJCV &WMG 2JKNKR QH $WTIWPF[ KPEQTRQTCVGF VJGUG NKQPU QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI CHVGT VJG GPFKPI QH VJG FKURWVG DGVYGGP JKO CPF JKU OQVJGT /CTICTGV YJKEJ YCU UGVVNGF D[ VJG 'UVCVGU QH $TCDCPV KP 6JG KPGUEWVEJGQP UWTVQWV FKURNC[U VJG CTOU QH (NCPFGTU C NKQP UCDNG NCPIWGF IWNG CPF CTOGF QP 1T YJKEJ VJG HCVJGT QH &WMG 2JKNKR ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU UVCTVGF DGCTKPI KP VJG OKFFNG QH VJG GUEWVEJ GQP 6JG FKXKUKQP QH VJG HKGNF YCU NCVGT NGHV WPEJCPIGF D[ 2JKNKR GXGP CHVGT VJG CESWKUKVKQP QH *CKPCWV CPF *QNNCPF CU KH VJG QPN[ FKHHGTGPEG DGVYGGP VJG NKQPU QH VJGUG VGTTKVQTKGU CPF VJG $TCDCPV NKQP YQWNF NKG KP VJG EQNQWTKPI QH )GNFGT &G 7VTGEJVUG OWPVGP VGP VKLFG QH $KUJQR &CXKF XCP $QWTIQPFKÀ KP ,/2 R G X /QPG[GT KP VJQUG [GCTU YCU &CPKLU QH .GXGPFCGN CNUQ .KGXGFCGN QT .GGHFCGN

5V /CCTVGPU )QWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV /CTVKP UKVVKPI QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG 5#0%685 /#46+0 '25 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP VTGHQKN /10 018# #84'# 64#+'%6'0 (D XF%J X) IT 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 6JG EQKPU YKVJ '25 CTG HTQO VJG GOKUUKGU CPF NCVGT *CTFGT VQ FGVGTOKPG CTG VJG EQKPU VJCV YGTG KPVTQFWEGF KP 6JG PGY KPUVTWEVKQP TGRNCEGF VJG &CXKFʼnU UJKGNF YKVJ C &CXKFʼnU IWKNFGT KP XKGY QH KVU CNNQ[ ENGCTN[ C FKHHGTGPV EQKP +P VJG KPUVTWEVKQPU QH VJG HQNNQYKPI [GCTU WPVKN VJGTG KPXCTKCDN[ YCU OGPVKQP QH C &CXKFʼnU IWKNFGT CU IQNF RKGEG CNVJQWIJ VJG CNNQ[ CV C EQPUVCPV YGKIJV YCU ITCFWCNN[ FGETGCUGF HTQO VQ ECTCV ECTCV YCU KPFKECVGF '2+5 CPF ECTCV '25 KPEKFGPVCNN[ VJKU VWTPGF QWV VQ DG C UKORNKHKECVKQP QH C OQTG ITCFWCN FGXGNQROGPV

292


5V /CCTVGPU )QWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV /CTVKP UKVVKPI QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG 5#0%685 /#46+0 '25 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP VTGHQKN /10 018# #84'# 64#+'%6'0 (D XF%J X) IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV &GEGODGT PQ 6JG EQKPU YKVJ '25 CTG QH VJG GOKUUKQPU CPF NCVGT EH PQ

,CIGT # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KPPGT EKTENG Ã #001 Q &0+ Q / Q %%%% Q .::8+++ QWVGT EKTENG /10'6# Q 018# Q '2+5 Q 64#+'%6'05 4 /'/' 61 &0' Q &#8+& CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVKJP CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU XF%J X) IT 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

,CIGT # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KPPGT EKTENG Ã #001 Q &0+ Q / Q %%%% Q .::8+++ QWVGT EKTENG /10'6# Q 018# Q '2+5 Q 64#+'%6'05 4 /'/' 61 &0' Q &#8+& CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJKP CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU XF%J X) IT 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP $QWIJV 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F +UUWGF HQT YKV UVWKXGT 'OKUUKQP EJCPIGF KP CPF # PGY EQKP TGHGTTGF VQ KP VGZVU CU DKUJQRʼnU ITQCV EQKP QH VJG DKUJQR 6JG FGXKEG QH VJGUG UKNXGT RKGEGU IGPGTCNN[ FGTKXGF HTQO VJG LCIGTU QH VJG EKV[ QH )TQPKPIGP VJCV JCF DGGP UVTWEM KP XGT[ NCTIG SWCPVKVKGU UKPEG 6JCV GZRNCKPU YJ[ VJG HQTOGT YGTG UQOGVKOGU FGUKIPCVGF CU 7VTGEJV LCIGTU QT &CXKFʼnU LCIGTU 6JG KPVGTOGFKCVG EJCPIGU CTG CNUQ GZRTGUUGF KP VJG YGKIJV VJG URGEKOGPU QH CPF CTG UWDUVCPVKCNN[ NKIJVGT DWV QH UWRGTKQT UKNXGT VJCP VJQUG QH

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP CPF EH PQ

,CIGT V[RG $ # 5CKPV /CTVKP UKVVKPI WPFGT ECPQR[ QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG 5#0%685 W /#46+0 W '25 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ WPFGT UVCT /10'6# 018# '25 64#+'%6'0 XF%J X) $ IT 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP .CTGP #WEVKQP PQ +UUWGF HQT YKV UVWKXGT 'OKUUKQP EJCPIGF KP CPF &GXGNQROGPV YCU RCTCNNGN VQ VJCV QH VJG LCIGT X)

293


,CIGT V[RG # # 5CKPV /CTVKP UKVVKPI WPFGT ECPQR[ QXGT UJKGNF QH VJG FKQEGUG 5#0%685 Q /#46+0 Q '2+5 4 #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ /10'6# Q 018# Q '2+5 Q 64#+'6'0 XF%J X) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'OKUUKQP CPF EH PQ

5VWKXGT 9KLM # #TOU QH 7VTGEJV $WTIWPF[ /10'6# '2+5%12+ 64#+'%6' 4 %TQUU YKVJ TQUGVVGU KP VJG EGPVTG /'/'6 1 &0' &#8+& XF%J X) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP RNGCUKPIN[ VQPGF

.GW <Ã’TKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 'Z $TCPF EQNNGEVKQP 2CTV PQ 'Z $WEJGPCW EQNNGEVKQP #WMVKQP # ' %CJP (TCPMHWTV C / PQ 'OKUUKQP +P QNFGT NKVGTCVWTG VJKU KU QHVGP FCVGF DWV VJCV KU KPEQTTGEV 6JKU EQKP KU VJG HKTUV CHVGT VJG RGCEG QH 7VTGEJV DGCTKPI C NCTIG EQCV QH CTOU QH VJG 5VKEJV CPF VJG DKUJQR 5VTWEM D[ XKTVWG QH VJG KPUVTWEVKQP QH VJ #RTKN

EQOOKUUKQP HQT .QWKU QH .GXGPFCGN OQPG[GT 5GG * 'PPQ XCP )GNFGT &G 7VTGEJVUG OWPVGP VGP VKLFG XCP $KUUEJQR &CXKF XCP $QWTIQPFKÀ KP ,/2 R GV UGSS 6JG CTOU QP VJKU EQKP CTG VJG UCOG CU VJCV QP VJG &CXKFʼnU JCTR PQ

9KV # 6KPFGTDQZ YKVJ NWEKHGT OCVEJGU CPF URCTMU &#8+& Q &' Q $84)10&+ # 4 %TQUU && '2+ 64#+ '%6'05+5 XF%J X) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG +TTGIWNCT HNCP FCTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

&WKVMGP # 6KPFGTDQZ YKVJ NWEKHGT OCVEJGU CPF URCTMU &#8+& &' $84)80&+# 4 %TQUU '25 64# +'% 6'0 XF%J X) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ EH PQ X )GNFGT PQ MPQYU QH QPG URGEKOGP KP VJG -2- CPF VYQ KP VJG %GPVTCCN /WUGWO 7VTGEJV 'OKUUKQP (QWPF KP CV 'IOQPF C F *QGH

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO 6JKU EQKP KU PQ KP VJG 8CP )GNFGT CTVKENG &G 7VTGEJVUG OWPVGP VGP VKLFG XCP DKUUEJQR &CXKF XCP $QWTIQPFKÀ KP ,/2 R 'OKUUKQP 'URGEKCNN[ JCTF VQ VTCEG CTG VJG EQKPU TGHGTTGF VQ KP VJG DQVJ KPUVTWEVKQPU QH #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG [GCT UOCNN EQKPU KP VJG YQTVJ QH CPF FWKVMGP CPF YKV 6JGTG KU C MPQYP UGV QH UOCNN EQKPU VJCV UJQY VJG OQVKH QH C VKPFGTDQZ PQU CPF VJG[ RQUUKDN[ YGTG RCTV QH VJG UCOG KUUWG HQT PQ QVJGT KPUVTWEVKQP OGPVKQPU C ITQWR QH VJKU MKPF 6JGTG CTG PQ CTIWOGPVU KP HCXQWT QH FCVKPI VJGUG RKGEGU VQ VJG YGKIJV QH VJG TGNCVKXGN[ WPMPQYP URGEKOGPU KU HCT HTQO EQPENWUKXG KP VJKU TGURGEV CU VJG YGKIJV QH UOCNN EQKPU EQOOQPN[ XCTKGU UKIPKHKECPVN[ 8CP )GNFGT RTQXKFGU VJG UCOG VGZV CU JGTG CNDGKV VJG RGNNGV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU TGRNCEGF YKVJ KP VJG EQKP CV JCPF 6JGTG CTG VYQ MPQYP URGEKOGPU KP VJG -2- CPF QPG KP VJG %GPVTCN /WUGWO KP 7VTGEJV

294


(4'&'4+%- QH $#&'0 (TGFGTKEM QH $CFGP YCU ECPQP KP %QNQIPG *G LWUV CU &CXKF QH $WTIWPF[ YCU C ETGCVKQP QH EGPVTCNKUGF CWVJQTKV[ CPF YCU KP EQPUVCPV FKURWVG YKVJ VJG EKV[ VJCV YCU UWRRQTVGF D[ VJG )WGNFGTU FWMG

&WDDGNG 5VWKXGT # )TGCV JGNOGV QXGT VYQ GUEWVEJGQPU /10' (4'&4 +%+ '2+ 64#+'%6 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING CPF QPG NGCH KP VJG EGPVTG #001 &1/+0 /%%%% :%8+++ XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CU WUWCN XGT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ

5VWKXGT # #TOU QH $CFGP CPF VJG FKQEGUG /10' (4'&4+%+ '2+ 64#+'%6' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG QPG TKPI KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKQP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10'6# 018# #001 $0+ XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO

%+6; QH 764'%*6 6JG EKV[ 7VTGEJV FKFPʼnV GPLQ[ VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV DWV TCVJGT UNQYN[ CESWKTGF VJG TKIJV VQ UVTKMG UOCNN EQKPU PGGFGF HQT FCKN[ NKHG 6JG DKUJQRU PGXGT TGUKUVGF VJKU KV YQWNFPʼnV JCXG DGGP RTQHKVCDNG CPF YQWNFPʼnV JCXG DGGP C XGT[ RQRWNCT OGCUWTG 6JG EQWPEKN JCF VJG KPVGTGUVU QH VJG RQQT RCTV QH VJG RQRWNCVKQP KP OKPF YKVJ VJGUG UOCNN EQKPU YJKEJ KU UJQYP D[ VJG VGZV QH C NCVG VJ EGPVWT[ GOKUUKQP KVU NGIGPF TGCFU FGPCTKWU RCWRGTWO FGPKGT QH VJG RQQT +UUWGU HTQO VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ YGTG GXGP RWV KP VJG PCVKXG NCPIWCIG FKV KU FGT CTOGP RGPPKPI VJKU KU VJG FGPKGT QH VJG RQQT # UKOKNCT FGXGNQROGPV VQQM RNCEG KP #PVYGTR YJGTG FQWDNG O[VGP YGTG UVTWEM RTQ FGQ FC RCWRGTKDWU 6JG TGHGTGPEG VQ 5V /CTVKP CNUQ KPFKECVGU C EJCTKVCDNG PQVKQP 6JG JQCTF $CTPGXGNF EQPVCKPGF RCWRGTʼnU RGPEG QH VJG V[RGU ++ VQ 8 6JG FCVG QH EQPEGCNKPI OKIJV DG HKZGF VQ 2KGVGTUGP

)TQQV V[RG ++ # #TOU QH 7VTGEJV KP OWNVKNQDG &+6 +5 &'4 #4/'0 2' 4 %TQUU /10'6# 5 /#46+0 2 XF%J X) IT 44 'FIG EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF KP #OGTUHQQTV CV 2QP

295


9KV # #TOU QH 7VTGEJV /806 Q &' Q 56#6 Q 8#0 Q 864' 4 %TQUU *'4 Q )'(6 Q 105 Q 84'&' 2 $ XF%J X) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG XCP )GNFGT ,/2 R HH %QOOGPVCT[ YKVJ 2KGVGTUGP )GUNCIGP DKL DGUNWKV XCP FG TCCF XCP FG UVCF 7VTGEJV XCP HGDTWCTK /WPV OGGUVGT &CP[U XCP .GXGPFCGN YGTMVG VWUUGP GP QQM XQQT FG DKUUEJQRRGNKLMG OWPV *GV QOUEJTKHV QR FG MGGT\KLFG *GT IGHV QPU XTGFG DGJQGHV PKGV CNU GGP XGT\WEJVKPI DGUEJQWYF VG YQTFGP XQQTVXNQGKGPF WKV FG FKTGEVG RQNKVKGMG UKVWCVKG KP KU FCCT IGGP TGFGP XQQT &GTIGNKLMG VGMUVGP IGUVGNF KP JGV .CVKLP MQOGP QQM XQQT QR OWPVGP WKV FG QOTKPIGPFG IGDKGFGP

&WKV # #PIGN JQNFKPI CTOU QH 7VTGEJV %+8+6#5 64#+'%6 4 /QWPVGF 5CKPV /CTVKP FKXKFKPI JKU ENQCM #0 &0 + 2 XF%J X) IT /KPQT VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ %QOOGPVCT[ KP 2KGVGTUGP &QEWOGPVCVKQP KU UECTEG 6JGTG KU C UKPING FQEWOGPV QH TF (GDTWCT[ UVKRWNCVKPI VJCV VJG XCNWG QH EQKPU HTQO DGHQTG VJCV FCVG DG JCNXGF 6JG EQKPU YGTG OQUV RTQDCDN[ OCPWHCEVWTGF D[ 9KNNKCO $QPGTV 6JKU IQGU HQT CNN FWKVU UVTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

&WKV # #PIGN JQNFKPI CTOU QH 7VTGEJV %+8+6#5 64#+'%6 4 /QWPVGF 5CKPV /CTVKP FKXKFKPI JKU ENQCM #0 &0 + 2 XF%J X) IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 0QV KP 2KGVGTUGP

&WKV # #PIGN JQNFKPI CTOU QH 7VTGEJV %+8+6#5 ” 64#+'%6 Z 4 /QWPVGF 5CKPV /CTVKP FKXKFKPI JKU ENQCM #0 &0 + 2 XF%J X) IT 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

296


6+'. +P C HGY NGIGPFU VJGTG KU CP CEEQWPV QH VJG CPEKGPV JKUVQT[ QH 6KGN VJG GCTNKGUV UVCTVKPI %NQUGT GZCOKPCVKQP JCU TWNGF QWV VJCV VJGUG NGIGPFU DCUG QP CEVWCN GXGPVU /Ã’VGT CEEQTFKPIN[ TGOCTMU 9G ECP PQY GUVCDNKUJ VJGTG KU PQ GXKFGPEG HQT VJG GZKUVGPEG QH 6KGN RTKQT VQ VJG 8KMKPI #IG 1PG )GTWNH YCU VJG HKTUV MPQYP EQWPV QH VJG EQWPV[ *QNNCPF #V JKU FGOKUG JKU NCPFU YGTG FKXKFGF COQPI JKU VYQ UQPU &KTM TGEGKXGF VJG EQCUVCN TGIKQP CPF 9CNVIGT IQV 6GKUVGTDCPV

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ʼnU VTCFG YCU C TKEJ UQWTEG QH KPEQOG HQT VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV CPF KV YCU KP JKU KPVGTGUV VJCV 6KGN YQWNF CDUQTD NQUUGU +P 9CNVIGTʼnU FGOKUG VTCPURKTGF JG JCF RTGUWOCDN[ FKGF C NQV GCTNKGT *G JCF OCKPVCKPGF ENQUG VKGU YKVJ DKUJQR 4CFDQF YJQ JCF FKGF KP CPF YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ DKUJQR $CNFTKE #HVGT 9CNVIGTʼnU FGCVJ JKU UQP 4CFDQF UWEEGGFGF KP VJG EQWPVKGU 6GKUVGTDCPV .CMG GV +UNC CPF 0KHVGTNCMG +P VJCV UCOG [GCT 4CFDQF CPF JKU UWEEGUUQT *CVVQ YGTG TGXGCNGF CU JCXKPI DGGP KPECRCDNG TWNGTU 6JKU RTQORVGF 1VVQ + VQ VCMG CEVKQP .CMG GV +UNC CPF 0KHVGTNCMG YGPV VQ 7VTGEJV CPF HQT VJG EQTG VGTTKVQT[ QH 6KGN 1VVQ + OCFG UGRCTCVG CTTCPIGOGPVU KP 6JWU VJG ENGTKECN RQUUGUUKQPU KP 6KGN YGPV VQ 7VTGEJV CPF VJG TGUV QH VJG EQOKVCN RTQRGTVKGU RCUUGF VQ JKOUGNH CU EWTVKU KORGTCVQTKC 1VVQ JCF 6KGN IQXGTPGF D[ C EGTVCKP )QFHTG[ CU RTCGHGEVWU CKFGF D[ %QWPV 7PTWQEJ QH 6GKUVGTDCPV 6JG WPNKOKVGF RQYGT QH VJG EQWPVU QH 6GKUVGTDCPV YCU DTQMGP RCTV QH VJG RTQRGTV[ YCU CRRTQ RTKCVGF VQ VJG DKUJQR CPF VJG OCKP RCTV YCU TGUGTXGF HQT VJG UW\GTCKP CNDGKV KP C OKNKVCT[ ECRCEKV[ UWDQTFKPCVG VQ VJG RTCGHGEVWU HQT HWTVJGT FGVCKNU UGG VJG EJTQPKENG QH #NRGTVWU /GVVGPUKU YJQ YCU RTGUWOCDN[ HTQO 6KGN +P 1VVQ +++ ITCPVGF VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV VJG TKIJV QH OKPV HQT <CNVDQOOGN CEMPQY NGFIGF D[ *GKPTKEJ ++ KP 6KGN YCUPʼnV ITCPVGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV KVU NQTFU UVTWEM VJGKT QYP EQKP CPF YQWNF OCKPVCKP FQKPI UQ WPVKN *GPT[ +8 CV VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 6KGN EQKPU CTG GURGEKCNN[ MPQYP HQT VJGKT EJCTCEVGTKUVKECN GNQPICVGF JGCFU VJG 6KGNGT -QRH *GCF HTQO 6KGN +V KU PQV QPN[ QDUGTXGF KP 6KGN DWV CNUQ KP 0COWT WPFGT 4QDGTV ++! ņ UGG &G /G[ PQ CPF /QUV EQKPU CTG HTQO VJG TGKIPU QH *GPT[ CPF -QPTCF VJG RTKOG CIG QH GEQPQOKE RTQURGTKV[ 6JG[ CTG VQ DG ENCUUKHKGF CU HQNNQYU # *'+04+%85 4': 5 %1.10+ # $ *'+04+%85 +/2'4#614 %TQUU YKVJ FQVU % -104#&85 4': %TQUU YKVJ FQVU & -104#&85 4': $10# 6+'.' 'CEJ QPG JCU C URGEKHKE ETQYP 0Q EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM FWTKPI %QPTCFʼnU KORGTKCN TGKIP 297


4Q[CN +ORGTKCN OKPVKPI 1661 +++

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI 1 1 4 &KUHKIWTGF %QNQPKC OQPQITCO 5 %1.10+ # &CPP *CV\ ! +NKUEJ ! IT (NCP FGHGEV CPF YGCMN[ UVTWEM HKPG

*WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG %1.10+ QP VJG TGXGTUG KU TGVTQITCFG YKVJ VJG . GPEKTENGF D[ VYQ UOCNN 1ʼnU +NKUEJ ENCUUKHKGU VJKU CU 6KGN CTGC CPF FGGOU 6KGN VJG OQUV VJG RTQDCDNG QRVKQP 6JG 5 %1.10+# YCU WUGF KP 6KGN WPVKN VJGP TGRNCEGF D[ C ETQUU YKVJ HQWT FQVU +NKUEJ WPFGT h GZENWUKXGN[ JCU EQKPU YKVJ VJG PCOG *'0&4+%85 4': 6JKU ENGCTN[ KU 1VVQ 7PFGT KP +NKUEJ C EQKP QEEWTU VJCV QP KVU QDXGTUG UJQYU TGOCKPU QH 1VVQ 9JGVJGT VJKU PQ FKURNC[U CP . UJCRGF CU C 6JQT JCOOGT ECPPQV DG EQPHKTOGF PQT TWNGF QWV $GECWUG VJGTG KU PQ OKPV QVJGT VJCP 6KGN GZEGRV HQT <CNVDQOOGN YG JCXG EJQUGP VQ ENCUUKH[ KV JGTG

*'+04+%* ++

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI * '04+% 85 +/2'4#6 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING Z 6 + ' . ' &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ XF%J IT 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI *'04 5 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING Z 6 + ' . ' &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ XF%J IT $GPV QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*QNNCPFKC -CORGTXGGP

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI *'+04+% 85 /+4' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING Z 6 + ' . ' &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ XF%J IT 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV DWV CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #NVJQWIJ CNN VJTGG RTGEGFKPI EQKPU JCXG VJG UCOG TGHGTGPEGU VJG[ FKHHGT EQPUKFGTCDN[ 0Q KU YGNN EWV EQPVTCT[ VQ VJG PQU CPF

298


-104#& ++

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI 04#& 4' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 6 + 1 + 1 1 &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ IT 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JKU V[RG KU RNCEGF HKTUV DGECWUG VJG ETQUU YKVJ VJG HQWT RGNNGVU HQTOU C NKPM VQ VJG EQKPU QH *GPT[ #HVGT VJCV %1/'5 $10# 6+'.'

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI 01# 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU $1 6+'.' 0# &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 9KVJ PQ %CTQNKPIKCPU 4QDGTVKPGU YG CUUWOGF $10# OGCPU EKV[ 6JCV YQWNF TGUWNV KP %KV[ 6KGN VJG UCOG ECP DG QDUGTXGF KP &GXGPVGT $10# &#8'064+#

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI %8104#&85 TGVTQITCFG 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU $1 6+'.' 0# &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ XF%J IT 4 (KPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

<#.6$1//'. 6JG HQNNQYKPI EQKPU CNN FGRKEV C DKUJQR KP NKVGTCVWTG VJGTG UVKNN KU OGPVKQP QH C MKPIʼnU JGCF DWV C MKPI YKVJ C ETQUKGT QT C RCUVQTCN UVCHH KU KORQUUKDNG 9G CVVTKDWVGF KV VQ <CNVDQOOGN HQT YJKEJ VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU JCF GZRNKEKV RGTOKUUKQP VQ OKPV

ITCPVGF KP D[ 1VVQ +++ CEMPQYNGFIGF D[ *GPT[ ++ KP #NDTGEJV CNUQ UWIIGUVU <CNVDQOOGN R 6JG HKTUV VYQ PWODGTU CPF FGRKEV VJG 6KGN JGCF YKVJ QPG QT OQTG CVVTKDWVGU ETQUKGT CPF QT RCUVQTCN UVCHH 0GKVJGT 6KGN PQT CP[VJKPI QH VJG MKPF HGCVWTGU QP VJG EQKPU CP[ NQPIGT 0Q MKPIʼnU QT GORGTQTʼnU PCOGU QP VJG QDXGTUG CP[OQTG DWV C VGZV UVCTVKPI 12'ő QH 1&'ő QHVGP PQV XGT[ ENGCT )CGVVGPU HF .WFYKU\E\G KPVGTRTGVGF KV CU 1FGNDQNFWU YJKEJ FGPQVGU #FGNDQNF +NKUEJ FKUOKUUGU VJKU DWV HCKNU VQ RTQXKFG CP[ CNVGTPCVKXG 'RKUEQRCN OKPVKPI

&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN YKVJ ETQUKGT 12'' +0 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU 5 '.+ #0 &CPP *CV\ +NKUEJ IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 5GEQPF ' KPXGTVGF 5CNOQ RTQXKFGU VJG UCOG TGCFKPI QH VJGUG HQWT NGVVGTU +NKUEJ EQPUKFGTU VJG RGTKQF QH *GPT[ +++ RQUUKDN[ CHVGT

299


&GPKGT # *GCF QH 6KGN HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF UEGRVTG VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU 1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING CPF QPG GZVTC RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU Å‘ '8Å‘ TGVTQITCFG &CPP )CGVVGPU *CV\ +NKUEJ IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ *CV\ OGPVKQPU VYQ URGEKOGPU (QT VJKU +NKUEJ EQPUKFGTU VJG RGTKQF QH %QPTCF ++

6JG HQNNQYKPI EQKPU CTG GRKUEQRCN CU YGNN DWV ENGCTN[ HTQO CPQVJGT RGTKQF $[ VJCV VKOG VJG V[RKECN 6KGN JGCF YCU TGRNCEGF D[ C DTQCF JGCF +NKUEJ JGTG VQQ TGCFU 1&'ő YJKEJ EQWNF DG GXKFGPEG QH VJG EQKP KPFGGF PQV DGKPI HTQO #FGNDQNF NCVGT DKUJQRU CTG ENCKOGF VQ JCXG OKPVGF KP #FGNDQNFʼnU PCOG +NKUEJ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU V[RG KP VJG RGTKQF QH *GPT[ +++ QT +8 K G CPF EQPUKFGTU VJG GCUVGTP 0GVJGTNCPFU + VJKPM VJG FGXKEG KU UQ UVTQPIN[ TGNCVGF VQ VJG YGNN MPQYP 6KGN JGCF VJCV C RNCEG KP VJG 6KGN CTGC UVKNN FGUGTXGU UGTKQWU EQPUKFGTCVKQP

&GPKGT # *GCF HCEKPI NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ITGCV RGNNGV CPF QPG UOCNN RGNNGV YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING ++: &CPP )CGVVGPU *CV\ +NKUEJ IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT # *GCF HCEKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ITGCV RGNNGV CPF QPG UOCNN RGNNGV YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING &CPP )CGVVGPU *CV\ +NKUEJ IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF UNKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

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


6JTQWIJ VJKU CNNKCPEG YKVJ VJG 1OOGNCPFGP QH )TQPKPIGP ITGY KPVQ VJG EGPVTG QH VJG TGIKQP 6JG )TQPKPIGTU HGCTGF VJG 'CUV (TKUKCP %JKGHVCKPU OQUV GURGEKCNN[ YJGP %GPQ VQO $TQM CNNKGF YKVJ VJG 8GVMQRGTU CPF FGHGCVGF VJG 5EJKGTKPIGTU %GPQ YCU XCPSWKUJGF D[ (QEMQ 7MGOC #TQWPF KPFGRGPFGPV OKPVKPI DGICP KP )TQPKPIGP UGG CNUQ ,/2 R VJCV YQWNF NCUV WPVKN CHVGT 6JG EKV[ʼnU EQCV QH CTOU KU C FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING YKVJ C HGUUGF GUEWVEJGQP QP KVU DTGCUV 6JKU HGUUGF GUEWVEJGQP KU VJG QNFGUV GNGOGPV CPF KPKVKCNN[ VJG QPN[ GNGOGPV .CVGT CRRTQZ VJG KORGTKCN GCING YCU CFFGF 'ORGTQT 5KIKUOWPF DQTG C FQWDNGJGCFGF GCING CHVGT VJQWIJ HTQO VQ OCKPN[ UKPING JGCFGF 7PFGTPGCVJ 2WKUVGTʼnU CTVKENG )TQPKPIUG UVGFGNKLMG OWPVGP KP ,/2 R GV UGSS YCU HQNNQYGF RGTKQF

)TQQV # 5JKGNF /10'6# Ő &' Ő )410 4 .QPI ETQUU 5+) /8 %4 8+5 2 XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP EC 2WKUVGT MPQYU QH QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP KP VJG OWUGWO QH )TQPKPIGP RTGUWOCDN[ YKVJ C FKHHGTGPV VGZV

RGTKQF

2NCM # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# )4100'05+5 4 5JKGNF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 5+6 01/'0 &1/0+ $'0' 2 XCT XF%J XCT IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG -PGKPUDGTI #OUVGNXGGP 5VTWEM EC 6JKU VGZV PQV KP 2WKUVGT QT X F %JKLU

2NCM # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU CPF QXGT UJKGNF Z /10'6# Z 018# Z )410 4 5JKGNF YKVJ FQWDNGF JGCFGF GCING QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF Z 5+6 Z 01/ Z &0+ $'0 Z 2 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

FG )GWU 'KPFJQXGP #WEVKQP PQ

)TQQVMGP # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# )410+'05+5 4 %TQUU 5+6 Ő 01/ Ő &0+ $'0' 2 XCT XF%J XCT IT %QTTQFGF URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF QP /CTEJ KP 5VKGPU KP ITQWPF HTQO WPFGT C URQTVKPI IQQFU UJQR YJKEJ KP GCTNKGT VKOGU JCF DGGP GZECXCVGF HTQO VJG ,CEQDKPG ITCXG[CTF KP .GGWYCTFGP VQ HKNN WR C HQTOGT ECPCN 2WKUVGT PQV TGVTKGXGF VJG VGZV KU FKHHGTGPV 6JG YGKIJV KU GZEGRVKQPCNN[ NQY JCNH!

301


)TQQVMGP # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# Q )410+)'05+5 Q 4 %TQUU 5+6 Q 01/ Q &0+ Q $'0'&+%685 2 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

,CIGT # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP SWCVTGHQKN QXGT UJKGNF YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG SWCVTG HQKN /10'6# ” 018# ” +0 ” )410+)'05+5 ” 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VTGHQKN KP VJG PF CPF QPG UVCT KP VJG QVJGT CPINGU KPPGT EKTENG #01 ” &0+ /%%%% .8+++ 5+6 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ $'0'&+%68 ” 2 C XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG -TCPGPDWTI 8GGPGPFCCN

,CIGT # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP SWCVTGHQKN QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# ” 018# ” )410+)'0 5+5 ” 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING KPPGT EKTENG # Q &0+ / ” %%% %.:+++ 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ $'0'&+%68 ” 2 F XF%J IT 4 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

8NKGIGT # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# „ 018# )410+0)'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ) KP EGPVTG #001 &1/+0 /„%%%% .::+++ 2 F XF%J IT 4 9GNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

302


8NKGIGT # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# „ 018# )410+0)'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ) KP EGPVTG #001 &1/+0 /„%%%% .:::++ 2 K XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 2WKUVGT OGPVKQPU HKXG URGEKOGPU

8NKGIGT # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF /10'6# 018 )410+0)'0Æ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ UVCT KP EGPVTG #001 &0++ / %%%% :%+: 2 J XF%J IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU CPF GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP #RTKN PQ

6JG *QJNRHGPPKIG ECOG HTQO )GTOCP[ VQ VJG .QY %QWPVTKGU VJG[ YGTG OCKPN[ ECNNGF DTCGOUGP VJGTG 6JG[ HQWPF VJGKT YC[ VQ 0KLOGIGP #TPJGO &GXGPVGT CPF )TQPKPIGP +P VKOG VJG[ JCXG VTCXGNNGF VJKU YC[ VQQ (QT )TQPKPIGP VJGUG EQKPU FCVG DCEM VQ CTQWPF 6JG DTCGOUGP YGTG PQV OGPVKQPGF KP VJG OQPG[GTʼnU KPUVTWEVKQPU +P )TQPKPIGP VJG[ YGTG ECNNGF RGPPKPIGP 4GMGPKPIGP XCP )TQ PKPIGP R CPF CPF TGRTGUGPVGF C XCNWG QH RNCM UVWKXGT +P XKGY QH VJG PWOGTQWU XCTKGVKGU VJG[ OWUV JCXG DGGP KUUWGF QXGT C NQPIGT RGTKQF QH VKOG VJG QPN[ VGZV TGHGTTKPI VQ KV FCVGU HTQO 9QGPUFCI KP VJG 2CUEJGP 9GFPGUFC[ FWTKPI 'CUVGT YJGP VJG EKV[ EQWPEKN ITCPVGF VJG RTQHKV QH VJG OCPWHCEVWTG QH VJGUG EQKPU VQ VJG EJWTEJ QH 5V /CTVKP 8CP FGT %JKLU R 6JCV RTQXKFGU C TGCUQP CU VQ YJ[ VJG[ FQPʼnV CRRGCT KP VJG OQPG[GTʼnU KPUVTWEVKQPU DGECWUG VJG[ YGTGPʼnV PQTOCNN[ EKTEWNCVGF DWV TCVJGT UVTWEM HQT CEEQWPV QH VJG IWCTFKCPU QH VJG 5KPV /CCTVGPU %JWTEJ YJQ NKMG VJG &GXGPVGT GZCORNG OQTG ENGCTN[ UJQYU UGG (QTVW[P &TQQINGXGT KP 6JG $GGNFGPCCT R QYPGF VJG UQNKVCT[ TKIJV VQ EKTEWNCVG UOCNN EQKPU KP VJKU OCPPGT CPF [KGNF C OQFGUV RTQHKV HQT VJG DGPGHKV QH VJG EJWTEJ HCEVQT[ X )GNFGT .CCV OKFFGNGGWYUG OWPVGP QH )TQPKPIGP ,/2 R

&WDDGNG RGPPKPI # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF YKVJ RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJG JGCFU 2 XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 2QUUKDN[ 'Z 6GTDGTIGT EQNNGEVKQP 5VTWEM EC 2WKUVGT MPQYU QH QPN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP -2-

&WDDGNG RGPPKPI # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF YKVJ RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJG JGCFU 2 XF%J IT 4 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 6JKU V[RG YCU PQV TGVTKGXGF VQ FCVG 2WKUVGT MPQYU QPN[ QH VJG V[RG HTQO X F %JKLU CPF EQRKGF VJG NCVVGTʼnU FTCYKPI XF%J #RRTQZ (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT

303


2GPPKPI # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF 2 XF%J IT %QTTQFGF URGEKOGP CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG TGIKQP QH 'NDWTI *CVVWO 5VTWEM EC

2GPPKPI # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF YKVJ VQMGP DGVYGGP VJG JGCFU 2 ! XF%J

! IT 8GT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 2QUUKDN[ 'Z 6GTDGTIGT EQNNGEVKQP 5VTWEM EC

2GPPKPI # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING QXGT UJKGNF CPF WPFGT ) 2 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5IN %GTOCM 9KGP 'Z *GTYGKLGT EQNNGEVKQP PQ 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

-7+04' -WKPTG YJKEJ NKGU KP VJG PQTVJGTPOQUV RCTV QH VJG RTQXKPEG 1XGTKLUUGN QYGU KVU PCOG VQ VJG YQTF MWP YJKEJ OGCPU FKTV OKTG DTQQM -WKPTG YCU CESWKTGF KP D[ DKUJQR )QFGDCNF QH 7VTGEJV +P JG ICXG QWV NCPF HQT VJG RWTRQUG QH EWNVKXCVKQP 6JWU VJKU VQYP YQWNF ITQY VQ DGEQOG C HTGG CPF KORQTVCPV VTCFG EGPVTG YKVJ KVU QYP RTKXKNGIGU 6JG NQTFU QH -WKPTG YGTG FGUEGPFCPVU QH *GPT[ %TCPG XKUEQWPV QH -WKPTG CPF OKPKUVGTKCNKU QH 7VTGEJV -WKPTG DGECOG C HKGH CTQWPF 9JGP ,QJP + UWEEGGFGF KP JG YCU UVKNN OKPQT +P JG YCU KPFKECVGF CU FQOKPWU C [GCT NCVGT CU OKNGU +P VJG QTFKPCPEG QH VJ ,WN[ VJG HKGH YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF ,QJP YCU MKNNGF QP UV #WIWUV KP VJG $CVVNG CV $CCTNG 7PFGT JKU UQP ,QJP ++ VJG EKVK\GPU QH -WKPTG TGSWGUVGF EQWPV 9KNNKCO +++ QH *QNNCPF VQ WPKVG -WKPTG YKVJ *QNNCPF KP 6JCV PGXGT JCRRGPGF ,QJP ++ YCU C HCKVJHWN XCUUCN QH DKUJQR ,QJP QH #TMGN *G RTGUWOCDN[ FKGF KP FWTKPI VJG FGXCUVCVKQP QH VJG ECUVNG 8QQTUV *KU [QWPIGT DTQVJGT *GTOCP + UWEEGGFGF +P -WKPTG YCU UQNF VQ DKUJQR (TGFGTKEM QH $NCPMGPJGKO QH 7VTGEJV ,#0 +

-QTVG CFGNCCTUITQQV PF GOKUUKQP EC # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP SWCVTGHQKN +1*#05 &1/+0+ &' %804' 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ + 1 * 5 KP VJG CPINGU /16# %804' + 1/+ &1/0 )TQNNG G XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG OQPCUVGT[ QH .KFNWO PGCT 1QUVGTDKGTWO

304


$TCDCPVKPWU TF GOKUUKQP # 'UEWVEJGQP YKVJ NKQP N +1*#00'5 &0+ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10'6# &' %84' )TQNNG D XF%J IT 4 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP GFIG HCWNV HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP )TQNNG D EQTTGURQPFU VQ X F %J YJKEJ JQYGXGT FQGU PQV TGXGCN CP[ NGIKDNG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG

-QTVG TWKVGTITQQV TF GOKUUKQP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UYQTF T +1*#05 &1/+ &' %804' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING KPPGT EKTENG 5+)08/ %48%+5 /10'6# + %84' + 1/+ &1/+ )TQNNG I XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO +OKVCVKQP QH VJG DCWFGSWKP QH /CTICTGVJC QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG *CKPCWNV 6JG PWODGTU CPF DQVJ EQOG HTQO C JQCTF HTQO (TKGUNCPF

-QTVG TWKVGTITQQV PF GOKUUKQP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ NCPEG CPF NKQP UJKGNF +1*#05 &0+ &' %804' 4 %TQUU KPPGT EKTENG 5+)08/ %485+5 /10'6# + %84' + 1/+ &1/+ )TQNNG M XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO +OKVCVKQP QH VJG #PVYGTR NCPU QH ,QJP ++ QH $TCDCPV CRRTQZ )TQNNG MPQYU PQ EQKP YKVJ %TWUKU CP 5 KP VJG OKFFNG

305


*'4/#0 + *GTOCP + YCU C [QWPIGT DTQVJGT QH ,QJP ++ 6QIGVJGT YKVJ JKU WPENG 5YGFGT XCP 8QQTUV JG NGF CP KPUWTIGPE[ QH VJG VQYPU QH 5VGNNKPIYGTH CPF 5VGGPYKLMGTYQNF CICKPUV DKUJQR ,QJP QH #TMGN #HVGT VJG DKUJQR KP JCF NCKF VJG ECUVNG 8QQTUV KP TWKPU 5YGFGTʼnU TKIJVU YGTG FGENCTGF XQKF *GTOCP + YCU RTCEVKECNN[ VJG NCUV OKPVKPI NQTF HTQO JKU JQWUG *G YCU YGFFGF VQ /CEJVGNF XCP FGT 'UG D[ YJQO JG JCF HQWT EJKNFTGP 6JGTG KU QPG MPQYP EQKP QH JKU UQP CPF UWEEGUUQT *GTOCP ++ *GTOCP + QYPGF RTQRGTV[ KP 5VGNNKPIYGTH CPF +,UUGNJCO +P JG UQNF CP GUVCVG KP VJG /CUVGPDTQGM PGCT +,UUGNOWKFGP *G YCU KP EQPHNKEV YKVJ CNN OCLQT VTCFG EKVKGU KP VJG TGIKQP DGECWUG JG QDUVTWEVGF VJG OGTEJCPVU QH VJG *CPUGCVKE .GCIWG +P JG CPF JKU QNFGUV UQP YGTG MKNNGF YKVJQWV CP[ NCPF VQ VJGKT PCOGU 6JG OWTFGTU YGTG CVVTKDWVGF VQ VJG EKVK\GPU QH 5VCXQTGP

.GGWYGPITQQV UV GOKUUKQP # .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF * /# %1 804 4 .KQP TCORCPV N 0'6# 08 )TQNNG XF%J IT 4 %QTTQFGF URGEKOGP HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT *GTOCP + KOKVCVGF VJG *QNNCPF NKQP ITQCV LWUV CU JKU DTQVJGT ,QJP ++ JCF FQPG DGHQTG JKO /KPVKPI RGTJCRU KP 1QUVGT\GG )TQNNG PQVGU PQV TGVTKGXGF

-1'814&'0 9JGP DKUJQR *CTVDGTV QH 7VTGEJV CRRQKPVGF JKU DTQVJGT RTGHGEV QH )TQPKPIGP JG CV VJG UCOG VKOG CRRQKPVGF JKU QVJGT DTQVJGT .WFQNH XKUEQWPV QH -QGXQTFGP #HVGT .WFQNHʼn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

&QTFTGEJVUG # *GCF N /10'6# Q -1814& 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING 4'0 1&& 0+- 181 )TQNNG IT 4 8GT[ HKPG C NKVVNG ENGCPGF *GP\GP ņ #OGTQPIGP

306


&QTFTGEJVUG # *GCF N /10'6# Q -1814& 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING 4'0 1&& 0+- 181 )TQNNG IT 4 (NCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG 6JG EQWPVGTOCTM 6 RTGUWOCDN[ FGPQVGU 6TCKGEVWO PF JCNH VJ EGPVWT[ FGETGG PQV TGVTKGXGF 5GG X F 9KU %CVCNQIWU XCP MNQRRGP # 'PE[ENQRGFKG XCP /WPVGP

4'+017& +++

)TCPF FGPKGT # .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# „ -1814&'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ GCING KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF NKQP TCORCPV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU 4'01 & „ &0+ -1814&'0 )TQNNG IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG 8GTUEJQQT 5VTKLGP PF GOKUUKQP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG (NGOKUJ GOKUUKQP QH QH .QFGYKLM QH /CGNG

0146*'40 QT 9'56'40 0'6*'4.#0&

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING FGIGPGTCVGF NGIGPF OCFG QH YGFIGU CPF VWTPGF % 4 $CTDCTK\GF %QNQPKC OQPQITCO 5 +++.1 # VTCPUOQITKHKGF NGIGPF +NKUEJ IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 6JGTG CTG C HGY V[RGU QH VJKU OCMG 6JG HKTUV KU QPG YKVJQWV VJG RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG ETQUU UGG +NKUEJ &CPP CPF *·X +V TGCFU C EQTTWRVGF HQTO QH .8&18+%85 DWV VJG V[RG UVGOU HTQO VJG 1VVQPKCP RGTKQF $TWUUGNU YCU WPFGT EQPUKFGTCVKQP HQT VJG OKPV +NKUEJ CNUQ OGPVKQPU 7VTGEJV DWV UWEJ GCTN[ OKPVKPI FQGU PQV JQNF HQT 7VTGEJV +NKUEJ ENCUUKHKGU KV WPFGT 7PDGUVKOOVG /ÒP\UV·VVG KP FGP 9GUVNKEJGP QFGT 0ÌTFNKEJGP 0KGFGTNCPFGP 5 +++1 1 #

VYQ VTKCPINGU RQKPVKPI VQYCTFU GCEJ QVJGT KP VJG VGZV VYQ N[KPI 5ʼnU RGTKQF +NKUEJ MPQYU QH HQWT RKGEGU -QRGPJCIGP 5IN 6JQOUGP CPF /ÒPUVGT (F 7NGLPQ CPF QPG EQKP HTQO C JQCTF KP 'IOQPF C <GG (QT VJCV NCUV UGG 2QN # /ÒP\HWPFG WPF (WPFOÒP\GP FGT ,CJTVCWUGPF YGPFG KP FGP 0KGFGTNCPFGP KP -NWIG $ *TUI (GTPJCPFGN WPF )GNFYKTVUEJCHV $GKVT·IG \WO FGWVUEJGP /ÒP\YG UGP KP U·EJUKUEJGT WPF UCNKUEJGT <GKV 'TIGDPKUUG FGU &CPPGPDGTI -QNNQSWKOU 5KIOCTKPIGP R EQKP QP R PQ

307


)7'.&'45

308

)WGNFGTU KU CP GZEGNNGPV GZCORNG QH JQY RQYGTHWN NQTFU OCFG FGUWNVQT[ CVVGORVU VQ WUWTR EQWPVKGU GUVCVGU GVE CHVGT VJG FGENKPG QH VJG %CTQNKPIKCP 4GCNO 6JWU YG UGG EQWPVU QH *COCNCPF 6GKUVGTDCPV *GVVGTIQWY GVE #TQWPF $CNFTKE YJQ YCU RTCGHGEVWU CPF JKU YKHG #FGNC UVGRRGF VQ VJG HQTG *QY GXGT QP C FKGV KP 0KLOGIGP VJGKT GUVCVGU YGTG FGENCTGF XQKF 2CTV QH VJGKT GUVCVG FGXQNXGF VQ VJG %QPTCFKPGU YJQ ECOG HTQO VJG /KFFNG 4JKPG TGIKQP +P VJG UQWVJ KP VJG TGIKQP CTQWPF *GKPUDGTI YG UGG C EGTVCKP #PVQP QH (NCPFGTU QH YJQO NKVVNG KU MPQYP 9GNN MPQYP JQYGXGT YGTG JKU VYQ UQPU )GTCTF (NCOGPU YJQ YQWNF DG EQOG VJG HQWPFGT QH VJG EQOKVCN *QWUG QH )WGNFGTU YJQ TGEGKXGF 9CUUGPDGTI CU CP KORGTKCN HKGH CPF 4WVIGT YJQ YQWNF DGEQOG VJG HQWPFGT QH VJG %QWPVU XCP %NGXGU YJQ TGEGKXGF %NGXGU CU CP KORGTKCN HKGH UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT %NGXGU 6JG VGTTKVQT[ QH DQVJ DTQVJGTU NC[ DG VYGGP /GWUG CPF 0KGTU )GTCTF CUUWOGF VJG PCOG QH VJG 0KGTU ECUVNG QH 9CUUGPDGTI

PQTVJGCUV QH *GKPUDGTI *KU UQP EQPVKPWGF VJG PCOG 9CUUGPDGTI *KU VYQ UQPU FKXKFGF VJG FQOKPKQP *GPT[ + KPJGTKVGF 9CUUGPDGTI )QUYKP + KPJGTKVGF *GKPUDGTI UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT *GKPUDGTI #V VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ JKU UQP )GTJCTF +++ GUVCDNKUJGF JKOUGNH KP VJG ECUVNG )GNFGTP UQWVJ QH -GXGNCGT CPF RTQECKOGF JKOUGNH EQWPV QH 9CUUGPDGTI CPF )WGNFGTU # HWTVJGT FKXKUKQP VQQM RNCEG YJGP VJG EJKNFTGP QH )GTJCTF +++ KPJGTKVGF JKU GUVCVG JKU UQP )GTJCTF +8 KPJGTKVGF )WGNFGTU CPF YGFFGF +TOICTF JGKTGUU VQ <WVRJGP JKU FCWIJVGT ,WVVC KPJGTKVGF 9CUUGPDGTI CPF YGFFGF 9CNGTCP QH .KODWTI 6JG VGTTKVQT[ YCU PQY EGPVTCN KUGF CTQWPF VJG TGIKQP 8GPNQ 4QGTOQPF CPF UVTGVEJGF KPVQ RTGUGPV FC[ )GTOCP[ 6JG UQP QH )GTJCTF +++ *GPT[ + VJGP KPJGTKVGF <WVRJGP VJCV KP YCU FGHKPKVKXGN[ WPKVGF YKVJ )WGNFGTU 6JKU VGTTKVQT[ YCU PQV CVVCEJGF VQ VJG EQTG VGTTKVQT[ 6JG EQWPV[ <WVRJGP RTQXGF C UKIPKHKECPV GZRCPUKQP VQ VJG VGTTKVQT[ VJQWIJ KV TGOCKPGF C FGUWNVQT[ YJQNG *QY GXGT YKVJ <WVRJGP C OKPV YCU ICKPGF 9JGP 1VVQ + CESWKTGF VJG 8GNWYG C HKGH QH VJG FWMGU QH $TCDCPV CPF C UWDHKGH QH VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV #TPJGO DGECOG VJG EGPVTG 2TGUWOCDN[ KP 1VVQ EQPUGSWGPVN[ OQXGF VJG OKPV HTQO <WVRJGP VQ #TPJGO C RNCEG VJCV CESWKTGF EKV[ TKIJVU KP 6JWU VJG HQWT SWCT VGTU ECOG KPVQ DGKPI 7RRGT )WGNFGTU VJG QNF VGTTKVQT[ UKVWCVGF KP RTGUGPV FC[ )GTOCP[ $GVWYG 8GNWYG CPF <WVRJGP 6JG GZRCPUKQP YCU EQPENWFGF YJGP KP 0KLOGIGP YCU CESWKTGF UGG WPFGT 0KLOGIGP YJKEJ YCU [GV CPQVJGT OKPV )WGNFGTU JQYGXGT YQWNF CNYC[U EQPUKUV QH VYQ RCTVU CPF GOGTIGF NCVGT VJCP VJG QVJGT VGTTKVQTKGU 2QYGTHWN NQTFU RNC[GF UKIPKHKECPV TQNGU CPF VJG UWT TQWPFKPI NCPFU $TCDCPV CPF 7VTGEJV YGTG FQOKPCPVN[ RTGUGPV HQT VJG IGQITCRJKECN NQECVKQP QH )WGNFGTU CV VJG LWPEVKQP QH VJG ITGCV TKXGTU YCU C MG[ HCEVQT )WGNFGTU UWHHGTGF HTQO UWEEGUUKQPCN RTQDNGOU KP YJKEJ CRCTV HTQO VJG HQWT EGPVTCN EKVKGU

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ʼnU UKUVGT 6JG NCVVGT EQPVGUVGF VJKU GPFQY OGPV YJKEJ ECWUGF 'ORGTQT 1VVQ ++ VQ KPVGTXGPG DWV VQ PQ CXCKN #HVGT .KWVICTFʼnU FGOKUG #FGNC WUWTRGF 9KEJOCPPʼnU GPVKTG KPJGTKVCPEG +P 1VVQ +++ RWV CP GPF VQ VJG EQPVGPVKQP QXGT 'NVGP TGUWNVKPI KP VJG FQYPHCNN QH #FGNC KP #FGNCʼnU FGOGCPQT CPF VJCV QH $CNF TKEM YCU HTGG QH UETWRNGU CPF KV CESWKTGF JGT VJG GRKVJGV QH UGEQPF *GTQF #FGNC URGPV JGT NCUV [GCTU KP %QNQIPG +P VJG EQWTUG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG PQTVJGTP RCTV FGXQNXGF VQ VJG NQTFU QH <WVRJGP VJG UQWVJGTP RCTV VQ VJG EQWPVU QH 9CUUGPDGTI )GNFGTP CPF %NGXGU 6JG PCOG *COCNCPF VJGP XCPKUJGF


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ʼnV DGGP FGVGTOKPGF VQ FCVG +NKUEJ ,/2 R PQVGU VJCV VJG JCPF QP VJG &GXGPVGT EQKPU FKFPʼnV CRRGCT WPVKN VJG KORGTKCN TGKIP QH *GPT[ ++ UGG PQ CDQWV +H #FGNCʼnU EQKPU YGTG DCUGF QP VJG &GXGPVGT V[RGU #FGNC OWUV JCXG UVTWEM VJGO VQYCTF VJG GPF QH JGT TGKIP + RGTUQPCNN[ FTCY VJG EQPENWUKQP VJCV #FGNCʼnU EQKPU YGTG FKTGEVN[ DCUGF QP VJQUG QH #GVJGNTGF YJKEJ EQP EWTU YKVJ 8CP )GNFGTʼnU TGOCTM VJCV VJG EQKPU QH #FGNC KPXCTKCDN[ CRRGCTGF VQIGVJGT YKVJ #GVJGNTGFʼnU KP JQCTFU HQT C FKUEWUUKQP QP VJG JCPF UGG &GXGPVGT (QTVW[P &TQQINGXGT KP 6JG $GGNFGPCCT R PQVGU VJCV 2WKUVGT URQMG VQ JKO CDQWV VJG GZKUVGPEG QH CP #FGNC EQKP DGCTKPI &CXGPVTKC KP 5VQEMJQNO #&'.#

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING #&' %1/'6+55# 4 5OCNN JCPF DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC &1#8'& &CPP +NKUEJ IT 44 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 'Z -P[RJCWUGP EQNNGEVKQP 6GKN +8 PQ 5JQYP KP VJG CTVKENG D[ X )GNFGT #NUQ UJQYP KP VJG CTVKENG QH (QTVW[P &TQQINGXGT KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 66' 55&/' 4 *CPF DGVYGGP CNRJC CPF QOGIC Z &1 #8'0'1661 &CPP +NKUEJ IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 'Z -P[RJCWUGP EQNNGEVKQP 6GKN +8 PQ 5JQYP KP VJG CTVKENG D[ (QTVW[P &TQQINGXGT KP 6JG $GGNFGPCCT R

309


<762*'0 #TQWPF <WVRJGP YCU KP VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH C EGTVCKP )QVVUEJCNM %QWPV QH 6YGPVG CPF *GVVGTIQW <WVRJGP YCU VJG PQTVJGTPOQUV RCTV QH VJG EQWPV[ *COCNCPF VJCV KP YCU ITCPVGF VQ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV D[ *GPT[ +8 )QVVUEJCNM KU TGICTFGF CU VJG HQWPFGT QH VJG EQOKVCN JQWUG QH <WVRJGP 6JGTG YGTG QPN[ VYQ EQWPVU 1VVQ ++ CPF JKU UQP *GPT[ + Ŏ DGHQTG 1VVQ ++ UWEEGGFGF )QVVUEJCNM CU JKU UQP JCF FKGF [QWPI 1VVQ CPF *GPT[ DQVJ YGTG IWCTFKCP QH %QTXG[ C IWCTFKCPUJKR VJG[ QYGF VQ VJGKT MKPUJKR VQ VJG EQWPVU QH 0QTFJGKO *GPT[ YCU NCUV OGPVKQPGF KP #HVGT JKU FGCVJ VJG EQWPV[ RCUUGF VQ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV 6JKU )QFGDCNF DGSWGCVJGF <WVRJGP VQ JKU EQPHKFCPV %QPUVCPVKLP XCP FGP $GTIJG

RCUUKPI )GTCTF +++ Ŏ QH 9CUUGPDGTI )GNFGTP QXGT +P VJG DKUJQR ICXG <WVRJGP KP HKGH VQ *GPT[ ++ VJG UQP QH )GTCTF +++ CPF +TOICTF KV VJGP YCU WPKVGF YKVJ )WGNFGTU 1661 ++

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG 4 6YQ XGTVKECN UVTKRGU KP HQWT EKT ENGU CU KP &WKUDWTI &CPP +NKUEJ IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #VVTKDWVKQP QH VJKU EQKP KU RTQDNGOCVKE &CPPGPDGTI CPF FGVGTOKPGU KV C &WVEJ HCDTKE CPF UWIIGUVU 'OFGP #NDTGEJV CVVTKDWVGU KV VQ <WVRJGP CPF +NKUEJ KPFKECVGU (TKGUNCPF 6JG JGCXKGT V[RG TGCFU 1&&1 DWV YJQ VJKU TGHGTU VQ KU WPENGCT 1TFWNH KU OQUV WPNKMGN[ CU JKU PCOG YCU PGXGT URGNNGF 1FFQ 1VVQ QH <WVRJGP EQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF DWV PQV KP (TKGUNCPF CU VJG RGTKQF FQGUPʼnV EQPEWT

)'.4' )7'.&'45 +P <WVRJGP YCU LQKPGF YKVJ )WGNFGTU CPF HTQO VJGP VJG EQWPVU QH )WGNFGTU RTQENCKOGF VJGOUGNXGU EQWPV QH )WGNFGTU CPF <WVRJGP 1661 + 1VVQ + YCU DQTP CRRTQZ CPF FKGF KP JG YCU DWTKGF KP VJG OQPCUVGT[ -COR 9GF FGF VQ 4KEJCTFKU QH 5EJG[GTP 9KVVGNUDCEJ NCVGT CDDGUU QH VJG /Ò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

310


)'4#4& 8 )GTCTF DQTP KP YGFFGF /CTICTGVJC QH $TCDCPV (QWT EJKNFTGP YGTG DQTP CPF VJG QNF GUV 1VVQ YQWNF UWEEGGF JKO )GTCTF YCU DWTKGF KP VJG /ÒPUVGT %JWTEJ QH 4QGTOQPF 6JG EQCV QH CTOU JCU VJTGG HKXG RQKPVGF UVCTU VJCV 8CP 5EJKNHICCTFG FGVGTOKPGU CU HNQYGTU

VJG[ YGTG HQTOGTN[ FGVGTOKPGF CU OGFNCT HNQYGTU CPF VJWU YGTG EQPUKFGTGF CP KPFKECVKQP QH 9CUUGPDGTI CNVJQWIJ VQ VJCV VKOG KV YCU PQ NQPIGT RCTV QH )WGNFGTU HQT TGCUQPU QH JGTGFKV[ $CUKPI QP 8CP 5EJKNHICCTFG 8CP $GGM *GV )GNFGTUG YCRGP QR OWPVGP &G $GGNFGPCCT R G X CUUWOGF VJCV VJKU EQCV QH CTOU QTKIKPCVKPI CTQWPF FGTKXGF HTQO VJCV QH 1VVQʼnU QNFGT DTQVJGT )GTCTF YJQ CU %QWPV QH )WGNFGTU CPF $QWNQIPG WUGF C UKOKNCT EQCV QH CTOU YKVJ VJTGG URJGTGU $QWNQIPG )GTCTF YCU VJG HKTUV VQ KPENWFG KV QP JKU EQKPCIG 8 F %JKLU PCOGU VJKU )GTCTF FG FGTFG )TQVG KP JKU 5VCOOVCHGNP FGUKIPCVGU JKO )GTCTF 8 +P O[ QRKPKQP VJG NCVVGT KU RTGHGTCDNG QP ITQWPFU QH KVU IGPGCNQI[

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF Ã )' 4#4&85 4 %JWTEJ VQYGT YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR DGVYGGP VYQ RQTVCNU YKVJ ETQUU

#40'/'5 XF%J IT 44 &QWDNG UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPKG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO &QWDNG UVTWEM 6JG FQWDNG UVTKMKPI CNVGTGF VJKU EQKPʼnU TGXGTUG VQ VJG GZVGPV VJCV KV CRRGCTU VQ DG VQVCNN[ FKHHGTGPV HTQO PQ KV JQYGXGT KU VJG UCOG 6JKU TGXGTUG KU CNUQ HQWPF QP 0KLOGIGP EQKPU

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF Ã )'4#4&85 4 %JWTEJ VQYGT YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR DGVYGGP VYQ RQTVCNU YKVJ ETQUU #40 '/'5 XF%J IT 44 5ETCVEJGU QP VJG TGXGTUG HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO 1DXGTUG PQV TGCFCDNG XGT[ YGNN UCOG EQKP CU

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF )'4 #4& 85 4 %JWTEJ VQYGT YKVJ ETQUU QP VQR DGVYGGP VYQ RQTVCNU YKVJ ETQUU #40' /'5 XF%J IT 44 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG . 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

311


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½IG *G OCFG CVVGORVU CV UQWVJYCTF GZRCPUKQP *KU UQP CPF UWEEGUUQT EQPVKPWGF VJKU UVTCVGI[ YJKEJ YQWNF EQUV JKO FGCTN[

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQP QH )WGNFGTU %1 / '5 4 &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING #40 '8/ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO )GTCTF U UQP 1VVQ ++ VQQM VJG EQCV QH CTOU QH JKU WPENG *GPT[ ++ QH 0CUUCW CRRTQZ )WCTFKCP QH VJG OKPQT 1VVQ YCU VJG RQYGTHWN *GPT[ ++ QH $TCDCPV 1VVQ JQYGXGT VWTPGF VQ NGUU KPHNWGPVKCN UQXGTGKIPU 6JKU OKIJV DG VJG TGCUQP HQT JKU CFQRVKQP QH VJG 0CUUCW EQCV QH CTOU C TCORCPV NKQP QP C HKGNF UECVVGTGF YKVJ EWDGU *KU UQP CPF UWEEGUUQT 4GKPQWF + CFQRVGF VJKU PGY )WGNFGT 0CUUCW EQCV QH CTOU CU YGNN VCMGP HTQO 8CP $GGM *GV )GNFGTUG YCRGP QR OWPVGP &G $GGNFGPCCT R G X 8 F %JKLU FGPQVGU VJG FQWDNG JGCFGF KORGTKCN GCING CU VJG EQCV QH CTOU QH VJG EKV[ QH #TPJGO +U VJKU EQTTGEV! 'URG EKCNN[ DGECWUG JG UJQTVN[ DGHQTG YTKVGU 1WV QH TGURGEV HQT VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT 1VVQ FKF PQV FCTG VQ EQKP KP JKU QYP PCOG &KF X F %JKLU CTTKXG CV VJKU EQPENWUKQP DCUGF QP VJG OKPV KPFKECVKQP!

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQP QH )WGNFGTU CDQXG JGCF DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU 1661 %1/'5 4 &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING #40' 85 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

9KPVGT &Ã’UUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQP QH )WGNFGTU CDQXG JGCF DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU 1661 % 1/'5 4 &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING #40' 85 XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPK PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

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ʼnTG HTQO C UKPING JQCTF +H VJCV KU VJG ECUG VJGTG YQWNF JCXG VQ DG C VGORQTCN ICR DGVYGGP %1/'5 CPF )'.4'05

312


2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 1661 )'.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 1661 )'.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 1661 ) '.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 16 61 ) '.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 1661 ) '.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 1661 )'.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 166 1 )'.4'0 5 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0'/ '5 XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8GPFW 4QVVGTFCO #WEVKQP ,WPG PQ 'Z 4GOMGU EQNNGEVKQP 4QVVGTFCO

313


2GPPKPI #TPJGO # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF RCNO NGCH 16 61 ) '.4'05 4 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU #4 0 '/ '5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,CPWCT[ PQ

2GPPKPI 0KLOGIGP # .KQP QH )WGNFGTU 1661 %1 4 'CING N 08/#) XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ &G\G FGPKGT KU PC VQGP 9KNNGO FG 4QQOU MQPKPI FGP $WTI OGV FG 5VCF 0KLOGIGP KP RCPF CCP 1VVQ CHUVQPF GP XQQT IGUNCIGP YCPV KP FCV LCCT QXGTNGGF FG ITCCH *KL OQGV DQXGPFKGP IGUNCIGP \KLP KP GGP VKLF FCV GT IGGP MGK\GT YCU YCPV YG JGDDGP JKGT VG FQGP OGV GGP GGPMQRRKIG CFGNCCT XF%JKLU

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Ã’NKEJ CPF D #NGQPQTC FCWIJVGT QH 'FYCTF ++ QH 'PINCPF VYQ EJKNFTGP 4GKPQWF +++ CPF 'FYCTF 6JG HKVU QH OCFPGUU VJCV 4GKPQWF + YCU DGUGV D[ ECWUGF JKU UQP 4GKPQWF ++ VQ UVCPF WR VQ JKO 9KNNKCO +++ QH *QNNCPF OGFKCVGF CPF 4GKPQWF ++ [GCTU CJGCF QH JKU HCVJGTU FGOKUG DGECOG VJG FG HCEVQ CWVJQTKV[ +P JKU HCVJGT UVKNN CNKXG JG YCU DGUVQYGF WRQP VJG FWECN VKVNG D[ .QWKU VJG $CXCTKCP #U QPG QH VJG TGUWNVU VJG 8GNWYG DGECOG C FKTGEV HKGH QH VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV C FWMG YCU PQV CNNQYGF VQ CEEGRV HKGHU HTQO YQTNFN[ NQTFU QPN[ ENGTWU EQWNF ITCPV C FWMG C VGTTKVQT[ KP HKGH (TQO VJG OQOGPV 4GKPQWF DGECOG FWMG JG JGNF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH UVTKMKPI IQNF EQKPU *G WUGF VJG QEECUKQP VQ CFQRV C PGY EQCV QH CTOU VJG ETQYPGF NKQP YKVJ C FQWDNG VCKN +V YCU CNUQ WUGF D[ 4GKPQWF +++ CPF 'FWCTF X $GGM *GV )GNFGTUG YCRGP QR OWPVGP KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R GV UGSS

)TQQV *CTFGTYKLM # .KQP TCORCPV N 4'+0 &8: )*'.4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10'6# &' *'4& XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP

314


-QRLG *CTFGTYKLM # *GCF N 4'+0 &8: ) *'.4+ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF

/10'6 # &' *'4 & XF%J IT 4 5RGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF XGT[ HKPG

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

TGUR CPF [GCTU QNF 6JGKT OQVJGT #NGQPQTC CEVGF CU IWCTFKCP HQT QPG [GCT 6JG DQ[U EQPVGUVGF GCEJ QVJGT VJG UWEEGUUKQP *QYGXGT VJG GUVCVG YCU CWVQOCVKECNN[ KPJGTKVGF D[ VJG GNFGT 4GKPQWF YJQ DGECOG 4GKPQWF +++ &WMG QH )WGNFGTU 4GKPQWF +++ YCU OCTTKGF VQ /CTKC QH $TCDCPV YJQO YG CNUQ UGG KP 1[GP OKPVKPI UCY VJG EQPUGSWGPV QWVDTGCM QH C ETKUKU CPF VJG NCPF YCU FKXKFGF KP VYQ RCTVU VJG $TQPMJQTUVU UWRRQTVGF 'FYCTF CPF #NGQPQTC VJG 8CP *GMGTGPU CPF VJG EKVKGU 4GKPQWF +++ +P VJG DTQVJGTU CITGGF VQ C UGVVNGOGPV VJCV UVKRWNCVGF VJCV 'FYCTF YQWNF TGKIP HQT GKIJV [GCTU PQV KP FWECN FKIPKV[ DWV CU C IQXGTPQT TWYCCTF 'FYCTF CITGGF CPF VQQM 4GKPQWF ECRVKXG KP CPF HTQO VJCV OQOGPV YCU &WMG QH )WGNFGTU 4GKPQWF HQTOCNN[ TGVCKPGF VJG VKVNG 'FYCTF FKGF QP VJG VJ QH #WIWUV CPF 4GKPQWF VQQM QXGT CICKP /GTGN[ WPVKN VJG VJ QH &GEGODGT YJGP JG VQQ FKGF 4GKPQWF +++ YCU OCTTKGF CNDGKV EJKNFNGUU LWUV CU JKU DTQVJGT # UWEEGUUKQP FKURWVG DTQMG QWV CPGY DGVYGGP VJG VYQ JGKTU HTQO VJG HKTUV OCTTKCIG QH 4GKPQWF ++ /GEJVGNF CPF /CTKC 6JG NCVVGT YGFFGF &WMG 9KNNKCO ++ QH ,ÒNKEJ 7PFGT 4GKPQWF +++ VJG &GK )TCVKC YCU KPVTQFWEGF LWUV CU WPFGT 9KNNKCO 8 KP *QNNCPF

'&7#4& CU 4WYCCTF 'FYCTF $QTP VJ QH /CTEJ FKGF KP VJG $CVVNG CV $CGUYKNNGT QP #WIWUV VJ DWTKGF KP U )TCXGPFCCN 'PICIGF VQ %CVJCTKPG QH $CXCTKC *QNNCPF

5EJKNF 4QGTOQPF # *GNOGV QXGT UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU YKVJ UKIP QH ITKGH CTOU QH )WGNFGT KP VJG RGCEQEMʼnU HGCVJGTU '&'9#4&85 &' ÃÃ )'.4'05 Ã 4 %TQUU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# ÃÃ 48'4/80 QWVGT EKTENG $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +J8 ¶ :2+ XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ # NCDGN KP VJG EQCV QH CTOU KPFKECVGF VJCV VJG JGKT KP SWGUVKQP YCU PQV [GV CNNQYGF VQ WUG VJG EQCV QH CTOU

'&7#4& CU &WMG

&WDDGNG )TQQV #TPJGO # 5KVVKPI NKQP YKVJ JGNOGV N '&9#4&85 ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ &8: ¶ < ¶ &05 ¶ )'.4' 4 %TQUU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# Ÿ #40+/'05+5 QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%685 ¶ 37+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &1/+0+ XF%J IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG UWTHCEG XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #WIWUV PQ (TQO HKPF #TPJGO EH ,/2 PQ VJG JQCTF EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU GCEJ UNKIJVN[ FKHHGTGPV 6JG FCVG QH EQPEGCNKPI NKGU DGHQTG QT PQV NQPI CHVGT CV VJG NCVGUV DWV EGTVCKPN[ CHVGT #EEQTFKPI VQ X F %JKLU VJKU YCU VJG QPN[ EQKP 'FYCTF KP JKU FWECN RGTKQF JCF UVTWEM GZEGRV HQT C FQWDNG OQWVQP F QT

315


&WDDGNG )TQQV #TPJGO # .KQP UKVVKPI N YKVJ JGNOGV CTOU QH )WGNFGTU YKVJKP VJG RGCEQEMʼnU HGCVJGTU '&9#4&85 ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ &8: ¶ < ¶ &05 ¶ )'.4'0 4 %TQUU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# Ÿ #40'/'05+5 QWVGT EKTENG $'0'&+%685 ¶ 37+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &1/+0+ XF%J IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV HKPG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

X 5VQEMWO FGP *CCI #WEVKQPP PQ 'Z *WNUJQH 2QNN EQNNGEVKQP 2QUUKDN[ UVTWEM DGECWUG QH VJG OWPVQTFQPPCPVKG QP VJ &GEGODGT

#U 4GKPQWF CPF 'FYCTF JCF FKGF EJKNFNGUU CPF XKTVWCNN[ CV VJG UCOG VKOG UWEEGUUKQPCN FKURWVG KIPKVGF QPEG CICKP PQY DGVYGGP VJG VYQ FCWIJVGTU /GEJVGNF CPF /CTKC HTQO 4GKPQWF ++ʼnU HKTUV OCTTKCIG 6JG *QWUG $TQPMJQTUV UWRRQTVGF /CTKC CPF JGT JWUDCPF 9KNNKCO ++ QH ,ÒNKEJ /CTKC ENCKOGF )WGNFGTU HQT JGT UQP 9KNNKCO 6JG 8CP *GMGTGPU UWRRQTVGF /GEJVGNF YJQ YCU OCTTKGF VQ ,QJP QH $NQKU .QTF QH )QWFC %QPVTCT[ VQ VJG RTGXKQWU VKOG VJG EKVKGU PQY ENQUGF TCPMU YKVJ VJG $TQPMJQTUVU CNVJQWIJ VJG[ PQTOCNN[ YGTG QP VJG 8CP *GMGTGPU UKFG +P /GEJVGNF CDCPFQPGF CNN JGT ENCKOU 9KNNKCO YQP CPF KP DGECOG &WMG QH )WGNFGTU CPF KP &WMG XCP ,ÒNKEJ 6JG WPKQP YKVJ ,ÒNKEJ YQWNF NCUV WPVKN 9+..'/ + 9JGP UWEEGUUKQPCN FKURWVG CTQUG DGVYGGP /GEJVGNF CPF /CTKC KP 9KNNKCO ++ QH ,ÒNKEJ

VJG JWUDCPF QH /CTKC YCU CRRQKPVGF IWCTFKCP QXGT JKU UQP D[ 'ORGTQT %JCTNGU +8 KP #CEJGP CPF YQWNF TGOCKP UQ WPVKN 9KNNKCO YCU [GCTU D[ VJGP (TQO VQ YJGP JKU HCVJGT 9KNNKCO +++ FKGF 9KNNKCO + YCU QPN[ FWMG QH )WGNFGTU CPF QH EQWTUG %QWPV QH <WVRJGP #HVGT VJCV JG YCU &WMG QH ,ÒNKEJ CU YGNN 9KNNKCO YCIGF YCT CICKPUV CTEJGPGO[ $TCDCPV YJKEJ YQP JKO OCUUKXG RQRWNCTKV[ +P JG FGENCTGF YCT QP 2JKNKR VJG $QNF 6JGP 9KNNKCO JCF VQ UWDLGEV JKOUGNH RTQ HQTOC DWV JG UVC[GF UWURKEKQWU QH VJG $WTIWPFKCPU 9KNNKCO + YCU YGFFGF VQ %CVJCTKPG QH $CXCTKC *QNNCPF YJQ JCF DGGP 'FYCTFʼnU DTKFG *G FKGF EJKNFNGUU CPF YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU DTQVJGT 4GKPQWF +8

4KLPUG IQWFIWNFGP # &WMG HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF WPFGT ECPQR[ DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 9+.J &8: ) '.4 < %1/ # 4 6YQ UJKGNFU QXGT RGNNGV KP OWNVKNQDG FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING N NKQP QH )WGNFGTU T QPG VTKCPING KP GCEJ CPINGU $'0'&+%6 ¶ 37+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' (D XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

4KLPUG IQWFIWNFGP # &WMG HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF WPFGT ECPQR[ DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 9+.J &8: ) '.4 < %1/ # 4 6YQ UJKGNFU QXGT RGNGV KP OWNVKNQDG FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING N NKQP QH )WGNFGT T QPG VTKCPING KP GCEJ CPINGU $'0'&+%6 ¶ 37+ ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ +0 ¶ 01/+0' (D XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ X F %JKLU FQGUPʼnV MPQY YJCV %1/ # QP PQ YKVJ QPG RGNNGV DGVYGGP %1/ CPF # EQWNF OGCP 5VTWEM HQT VJG UWEEGUUKQP KP ,ÒNKEJ

)QTP[ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM HQT VJG UWEEGUUKQP KP ,Ã’NKEJ

316


)TQQV #TPJGO # *GNOGV YKVJ CTOU QH )WGNFGTU KP RGCEQEMʼnU HGCVJGTU DGVYGGP VYQ NKQPU KP OWNVKNQDG QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING 9+.*'./ W &8: W )'.4+' W < W %1/ W <862* 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# ) &' ) #'4*'/'05+5 XF%J IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ %QKP HTQO VJG RGTKQF DGHQTGF VJG UWEEGUUKQP KP ,ÒNKEJ 5VTWEM CDQWV

)GJGNOFG ITQQV #TPJGO # *GNOGV YKVJ CTOU QH )WGNFGTU KP RGCEQEMʼnU HGCVJGTU 9+.J'./' &8: ' )'.4 ' %1/ <862* 4 %TQUU YKVJ # 0 4 5 KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ' 018# ' &' ' #'40'/'05+5 XF%J IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG 4KGVFKLM FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ +PVGTRWPEVKQP VYQ TJQODU QXGT GCEJQVJGT (QT VJG UWEEGUUKQP KP ,ÒNKEJ # #TPJGO 0 0KLOGIGP 4 4QGTOQPF 5 <WVRJGP

)TQQV # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ WPFGT JGNOGV 9 +.*'. &8: 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10 '6# 018 ) '. XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG EQTTQFGF HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 'Z 4 5EJWNOCP NKUV PQ HCNUGN[ WPFGT *GWMGNQO 5VTWEM CHVGT VJG UWEEGUUKQP KP KP ,Ã’NKEJ

317


4'+017& +8 4GKPQWF +8 DTQVJGT QH 9KNNKCO + DQTP CRRTQZ YGFFGF VQ /CTKC QH *CTEQWTV CPF FKGF KP 6GTNGV PGCT #TPJGO VJ ,WPG DWTKGF KP /QPPKMJWKUGP &KGF JGKTNGUU *G KU VJG NCUV &WMG QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ #PVQP QH $WTIWPF[ʼn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ʼnV EQOG KP UKPING URKGU DWV KP DCVVCNKQPU HQT 2JKNKR VJG )QQF VWTPGF JKU IC\G VQYCTFU VJG 0QTVJ

)QWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV YKVJ UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU CPF ETQUU DGVYGGP JKU NGIU 5 +1*#00'5 $#26+56# NKQP QH )WGNFGTU 4 (KXG UJKGNFU KP OWNVKNQDG &8: 4'+0#7& +8. < )'. < %1/+5 < (D XF%J IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’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

&WDDGNG )TQQV #TPJGO # 6YQ UJKGNFU ,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU 4'+0#7& &8: +8. < )'. < %1 < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP EGPVTG CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 # 018# #40'/ '05+5 XF%J IT +TTGIWNCT GFIG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG 0WO -TKPI 4QVVGTFCO 'Z (KPF <WVRJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ EH X )GNFGT KP ,/2 R %QKPCIG #EV VJ /CTEJ 6JG JGNOGV QH ,Ã’NKEJ TGEQIPK\CDNG D[ VJG HQZ QP VQR X F %JKLU R X F %JKLU OGPVKQPU C RGNNGV DGVYGGP VJG JGNOGVU YJKEJ KU PQV XKUKDNG JGTG

)TQQV 0KLOGIGP # 6YQ UJKGNFU ,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU 4'+0#7.& &8: +8. < )'. < %1 < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP EGPVTG CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 # 018# 018+/ #)'05 XF%J IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

318


)TQQV 0KLOGIGP # 6YQ UJKGNFU ,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU 4'+0#7.& &8: +8. < )'. < %1 < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP EGPVTG CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 # 018# 018+/ #)'05 XF%J IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

)TQQV 0KLOGIGP # 6YQ UJKGNFU ,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU 4'+0#.& &8:

+8. < )'. < %1 < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP EGPVTG CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 # 018# 018+/ #)'05 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

)TQQV #TPJGO # 6YQ UJKGNFU ,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU 4'+0#.& &8: +8. < )'. %1 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP EGPVTG CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 018# #'40'/'05+5 XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

&WDDGNG ITQQV #TPJGO # *GNOGV YKVJ CTOU QH )WGNFGT KP VJG RGCEQEMʼnU HGCVJGTU QXGT VYQ UJKGNFU

,Ã’NKEJ N )WGNFGTU T 4'+0#.& &8: +8. < )'. < %1 < 4 %TQUU YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCINGU CPF NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 018# &' #'40'/'05 XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,CPWCT[ PQ

319


#401.& QH ')/10& #TPQNF YCU VJG UQP QH ,QJP .QTF UKPEG %QWPV QH 'IOQPF CPF /CTKC QH #TMGN YJQ YCU VJG ITGCVITCPFFCWIJVGT QH 4GKPQWF ++ $QTP KP FGEGCUGF TF (GDTWCT[ KP )TCXG CPF KPVGTTGF VJGTG KP VJG 5V 'NKUCDGVJ %JWTEJ 9GFFGF VQ %CVJCTKPG QH %NGXGU 5KZ EJKNFTGP COQPI YJQO #FQNH YJQ YCU VQ UWEEGGF JKO KP ,ÒNKEJ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF YCU CP CNN[ KPKVKCNN[ DWV EGCUGF VQ DG 2JKNKR PGIQVKCVGF YKVJ VJG PQDNGU CPF YKVJ #TPQNFʼnU YKHG YJQ TGRTGUGPVGF VJG KPVGTGUVU QH JGT UQP #FQNH +P EKXKN YCT DTQMG QWV CPGY +P #FQNH NQEMGF JKU HCVJGT #TPQNF CYC[ 6JG NCVVGT CRRGCNGF VQ %JCTNGU VJG $QNF YJQ UWOOQPGF HCVJGT CPF UQP VQ JKU EQWTV CPF KORTKUQPGF #FQNH #NVJQWIJ DQVJ VJG EKVKGU CPF VJG MPKIJVU HCXQWTGF #FQNH KV YCU VQQ NCVG +P #TPQNF ITCPVGF $WTIWPF[ )WGNFGTU CPF <WVRJGP KP HKGH +P #FQNH CU +: UWEEGGFGF 4GKPQWF KP ,ÒNKEJ *G CVVGORVGF GPJCPEKPI JKU ENCKO VQ )WGNFGTU D[ YGFFKPI JKU [QWPIGUV UQP 4WRGTV VQ VJG OWEJ QNFGT YKFQY QH 4GKPQWF /CTKC QH *CTEQWTV DWV VQ PQ CXCKN #FQNH CESWKGUEGF CPF JGPEGHQTVJ UQNGN[ PCOGF JKOUGNH &WMG QH ,ÒNKEJ CPF $GTI %QWPV QH 4CXGPUDGTI YJGTGCU #TPQNF QH 'IOQPF YJQ UWEEGGFGF KP )WGNFGTU VGPCEKQWUN[ EQPVKPWGF WUKPI VKVNG CPF EQCV QH CTOU QH ,ÒNKEJ PGZV VQ VJQUG QH )WGNFGTU #TPQNF TGIWNCTN[ KPXCFGF ,ÒNKEJ CPF FKF PQV EGCUG WPVKN JG UWHHGTGF FGHGCV KP VJG $CVVNG CV .KPPKEJ QP 5V *WDGTVʼnU &C[ TF 0QXGODGT D[ )GTCTF #FQNHʼnU UWEEGUUQT 6KVNG CPF EQCV QH CTOU QH ,ÒNKEJ CTG GXGP HQWPF QP %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPFʼnU EQKPU YJQ RGTJCRU UVKNN HGNV CVVCEJGF VQ ,ÒNKEJ VJCV CHVGT CNN JCF QPEG DGGP JKU HCVJGTʼnU +P #TPQNF YCU VJG NCUV VQ JCXG VJG PCOG #TPJGO KPFKECVGF QP JKU EQKPU

4KLFGTIQWFIWNFGP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ UYQTF #401.& Z &8: Z )'. Z +8. < %1/'5 Z < Z )'0 Z KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF 4 5JKGNFU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU /10 Z 018# Z #84'# Z &7%+5 ” )'.4' (D XF%J IT 4 9GNN UVTWEM CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

0/$ #OUVGTFCO 6JG QTFGT QH TCPMU QH VJG CTOU KU PQY VWTPGF CTQWPF 9J[ KU JGTG &8%+5 KPUVGCF QH &8: OGPVKQPGF! #TPQNF YCU KP PGCTN[ [GCTU QNF EQWNF JG DG WPFGT IWCTFKCPUJKR! 6JKU 4KLFGTIWNFGP KU CNTGCF[ QH IQQF YGKIJV KPUVGCF QH VJG #TPQNFWUIWNFGP YJQ KU NKIJVGT KP YGKIJV

#TPQNFWUIWNFGP # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV YKVJ UVCHH GPFKPI KP C ETQUU CPF ETQUU DGVYGGP JKU NGIU 5 +1*#00'5 $#26+56# NKQP QH )WGNFGTU 4 (KXG UJKGNFU KP SWCVTGHQKN &8: #401.& )'. < +8. < %1/+5 < (D XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG -TCPGPDWTI 8GGPGPFCCN EH PQ HQT VJG HKXG UJKGNFU QP VJG TGXGTUG JGTG FKXKFGF CTOU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ KP VJG EGPVTG

320


)TQQV #TPJGO # 6YQ UJKGNFU )WGNFGTU N ,ÒNKEJ T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU #401.& „ &8: „ )'. < +8. < % <8 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF CTOU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 # „ 018# #'40' /'05+ XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

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

)TQQV #TPJGO # 6YQ UJKGNFU )WGNFGTU N ,ÒNKEJ T WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU VTGHQKN DGVYGGP VJG JGN OGVU #401.& „ &8: „ )'. < +8. < % 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF CTOU KP VJG CP INGU /10'6 # „ 018 #'40' /'05+ XF%J IT 4 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO (TQO JQCTF #CNVGP UGG $GPFGTU 8QPFUV #CNVGP KP ,/2 R 6JKU JQCTF EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG +P VJG CPINGU VJG EQCVU QH CTOU QH CNN HQWT ECRKVCNU EH PQ

&WDDGNG ITQQV # 6YQ NKQPU TCORCPV )WGNFGTU N ,Ã’NKEJ T FKXKFGF D[ XGTVKECN NKPG #401.&8 ¶ &8: ¶ )'.4'0 < +8. < %1/'5 ¶ < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ # #TPJGO 0

0KLOGIGP 4 4QGTOQPF 5 <WVRJGP KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ )'.4'05+5 ¶ XF%J IT 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP . 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 8F%JKLU URGCMU HTQO VJG \KNXGTGP UEJKNF UKNXGT[ UJKGNF

321


)TQQV 0KLOGIGP # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQPU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ WPFGT VJG JGNOGV QH )WGNFGTU CPF DG VYGGP VYQ NKQPU #401.& &8: „ )'. < +8. < % < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG RGN NGV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG UJKGNF QH VJG ECRKVCN EKVKGU KP GCEJ CPING /10'6 # „ 018# 018+/ #)'05 XF%J IT 44 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU QVJGTYKUG GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

. 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO # )WGNFGTU CPF C ,ÒNKEJ NKQP CTG ENGCTN[ XKUKDNG KP VJG EQCV QH CTOU *QYGXGT VJG NKQPU DGCTKPI VJG EQCV QH CTOU CPF VJG NKQP KP VJG RGCEQEMʼnU VCKN CTG PQV VJG )WGNFGTU V[RG DWV HTQO ,ÒNKEJ 9JCV EQWNF VJKU KORN[! (TQO VJG HKPF QH #CNVGP X F %JKLU MPGY QH QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP +P VJG JQCTF #CNVGP VJGTG YGTG 5GG $GPFGTU *QCTF #CNVGP KP ,/2 R 6JKU JQCTF EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG +P JKU CTVKENG $GPFGTU FGOQPUVTCVGU VJCV VJKU EQKP OWUV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM CHVGT VJG #TPJGO V[RG CPF PCVWTCNN[ DGHQTG KV YCU DWTKGF 6JCV RNCEGU VJKU UGTKGU CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG HQWTVJ FGECFG 6JKU EQPEWTU YKVJ FCVC #NDGTVU DTKPIU VQ NKIJV

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

OGCPU QH RC[OGPV CU VJG PGY IWKNFGT CPF VJG NKQP OKPVGF VJGTG YGTG GZCOKPCVGF )GNFGTU #TEJKGH #TPJGO 5VCFUTGMGPKPI #TPJGO HQN 6JKU FQEWOGPVU OKPVKPI KP 0KLOGIGP KP

)TQQV #TPJGO # &KXKFGF UJKGNF )WGNFGTU N ,Ã’NKEJ T WPFGT JGNOGV &8: #401.& )'. < +8. < %15 & < 4 5JKGNF YKVJ FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10'6# 018# & #'40' /'05+5 XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV ,WN[ PQ %15 & < UVCPFU HQT %1/'5 &' <762*'0

&WDDGNG )TQQV #TPJGO # 6YQ JGNOGVU )WGNFGTU N ,ÒNKEJ T #401.& Q &8: „ )'. „ +8. „ %1/'5 „ <86 Q 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ FKXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ KP VJG EGPVTG CPF # 0 4 5 KP VJG CPINGU NGVVGTU QH VJG ECRKVCN EKVKGU /10' 6# Q 018 # Q )'.4 '05+5 „ XF%J IT 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP %QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ #NUQ ECNNGF YQGEJG[

322


)TQQV #TPJGO # &KXKFGF UJKGNF )WGNFGTU N ,ร NKEJ T #401.& &8: )'. +8. < 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ # ' 4 0 KP VJG CPINGU /10 018 #'4 0'/ XF%J IT %QTTQFGF CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

)TQQV # &KXKFGF CTOU )WGNFGTU N ,ร NKEJ T #40 1.& Q &8: Q )'. Q +8. 4 %TQUU YKVJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG / 0 018# )'.4'0 XF%J IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF UWTTQWPF 0KLOGIGP

FG )GWU 'KPFJQXGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG NGIGPF KP X F %JKLU KU FKHHGTGPV #401.& &: )'. < +8. % < CPF /6# 018# )'.4'05 1P VJG QDXGTUG VJG )WGNFGT EQCV QH CTOU HQT VJG TGXGTUG JG ECPล V OCMG WR JKU OKPF DGVYGGP VJG #TPJGO QT VJG 0KLOGIGP EQCV QH CTOU FQGUPล V KV UJQY C FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING! 6JKU EQKP KU QH VJG UCOG V[RG CU PQ 6JG YGKIJV NKGU DGVYGGP CP GKIJVJ CPF C SWCTVGT ITQCV + VGPF VQYCTF VJG GKIJVJ +P VJG FQOKPCPEG QH VJG *QWUG $WTIWPF[ EQOOGPEGF 5GG WPFGT $WTIWPFKCP 0GVJGTNCPFU 6JG EKV[ <WVRJGP FKFPล V TGEQIPKUG $WTIWPFKCP TWNG CV HKTUV CPF VQQM UKFGU YKVJ #FQNHล U OKPQT UQP %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPF +P CPF EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM KP <WVRJGP KP %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPFล U PCOG GZRNKEKVN[ OGPVKQPKPI %1 /'5 <7 62*'0

5VWKXGT <WVRJGP # 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ร NKEJ CDQXG UVCT -#41. โ &8: โ )'. โ +8. โ < %1 โ <8 โ 4 .QPI QTPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKQP KP GCEJ CPING #001 รฐ &0+ รฐ / NKU %%%% รฐ .::: XF%J IT 4 5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 5VWKXGT YKVRGPPKPI 6JG HKTUV ETQUU QP VJG QDXGTUG KU VJCV QH )WGNFGTU

+P VJG D[ VJCV VKOG [GCT QNF %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPF YCU TGNGCUGF HTQO (TGPEJ ECRVKXKV[ CPF GODTCEGF D[ )WGNFGTU CU KVU FWMG /CZKOKNKCP YJQ FKF PQV CRRTQXG EQWNF FQ PQVJKPI VQ RTGXGPV VJKU JQYGXGT JG DKFGF JKU VKOG CPF TCKUGF CP CTO[ YKVJ VJG CKF QH ,ร NKEJ CPF %NGXGU CPF KP KPXCFGF 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG YCU YKNNKPI VQ PGIQVKCVG C UGVVNGOGPV %JCTNGU YQWNF JQNF GHHGEVKXG RQYGT KP )WGNFGTU VJQWIJ WPFGT UW\GTCKPV[ QH 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG 6JKU RTQRQUCN UWKVGF PGKVJGT /CZKOKNKCP PQT %JCTNGU 8 CPF VJG[ EQPXKPEGF 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG KP VQ GZGTV UGXGTKV[ CPF TGVCKP UYC[ 6JG (TGPEJ MKPI KPVGTXGPGF CPF HKPCNN[ /CTICTGV QH 2CTOC KP TGEQIPKUGF %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPF VQ DG &WMG QH )WGNFGTU CPF <WVRJGP -#4'. QH ')/10&

%NGOOGTIWNFGP # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV DGVYGGP HQWT TKPIU YKVJ UVCHH VGTOKPCVKPI KP C ETQUU QPG ETQUU DGVYGGP JKU NGIU -#41. & : )'.4 +8. 4 (QWT UJKGNFU KP VTGHQKN /1 01

#84' )'.4 (D XF%J IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP YKVJ RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG &GNOQPVG $TWUUGN #TOU QP VJG TGXGTUG KP VJG EGPVTG FKXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ร NKEJ N CDQXG FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING T CDQXG NKQP QH ,ร NKEJ DGNQY NKQP QH )WGNFGTU 1P VJG %NGOOGTIWNFGP CPF VJG IQNF HNQTKPU HTQO 4QGTOQPF VJGTG KU PQ TGHGTGPEG %1/'5 <762*'0 JGPEGHQTVJ VJGTG YQWNF DG

323


)QWFIWNFGP 4QGTOQPF # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV DGVYGGP HQWT TKPIU YKVJ UJKGNF QH 4QGTOQPF DGVYGGP VJG NGIU -#41. Q & Q Q : Q )'.4 Q +8. 4 (QWT UJKGNFU KP VTGHQKN Q /1 Z 01 Q Q #84' Q Q )'.4 Q (D XF%J IT 4 /KPQT UETCVEJGU PKEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5JKGNF QH 4QGTOQPF NKQP QXGT NKU (QT VJG UJKGNFU QP VJG TGXGTUG EH PQ

)QWFIWNFGP 4QGTOQPF # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV DGVYGGP HQWT TKPIU YKVJ UJKGNF QH 4QGTOQPF DGVYGGP VJG NGIU -#41. Q & Q Q : Q )'.4 Q +8. 4 (QWT UJKGNFU KP VTGHQKN Q /1 Z 01 Q Q #84' Q Q )'.4 Q (D XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG /W/ 5VWVVICTV 5JKGNF QH 4QGTOQPF NKQP QXGT NKU (QT VJG UJKGNFU QP VJG TGXGTUG EH PQ

4KLFGTIWNFGP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ UYQTF -#41.85 Z &8: Z )'.4 Z +8. Z % Z <8 KP DQVVQO HKGNF )'. 4 &KXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU /10' 018# #84'# &8%+5 )'.4 (D XF%J IT 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV QP VJG TGXGTUG XGT[ HKPG +0) $CPM #OUVGTFCO (TQO NKUV PQ (KTUV ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG ETQUU QH )WGNFGT

)TQQV # .KQP QH )WGNFGT TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,Ã’NKEJ QP C UVTKPI -#41.85 Q &8: Q )'.4' Q +8. Q < 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP EGPVTG VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQP CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU /10 018# )'.4'05+5 XF%J IT %QTTQFGF DWV XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (KTUV ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG ETQUU QH )WGNFGT 8 F %JKLU ECNNU KV JCNXG UVWKXGT 9GKIJV KU NQYGT VJCP C ITQQV

324


&WDDGNG 5VWKXGT # &KXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ WPFGT VYQ JGNOGVU -#41. &8 Ã )'. Ã +8. Ã %1 < 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKQP )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU '38+6#5 +8&+%+# 68# &1/+0' XF%J IT 4 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN RTGUGTXGF XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNVGP (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ '38+6#5 +8&+%+# 68# &1/+0+ .QTF 6J[ LWFIOGPVU CTG TKIJV 2U C 6JKU RUCNO VGZV HGCVWTGU QP VJG EQKPU QH %JCTNGU QH 'IOQPF CPF QP NCVGT EQKPU HTQO 4QGTOQPF GPF QH VJG VJ EGP VWT[

5VWKXGT # &KXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU N CPF ,ÒNKEJ T -#41.85 &8: )'.4 +8. %1 <86 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKQP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU '38+ 6#5+ 8&+% +# 6 & XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO (KTUV ETQUU QP VJG QDXGTUG ETQUU QH )WGNFGT

5VWKXGT # &KXKFGF UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ WPFGT NKQPU JGCF KP OWNVKNQDG -#41.85 &8: )'.4 +8. < %1 <8 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKQP KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU '38+6#5 +8&+%+# 68# &1/+0' XF%J XCT IT 44 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ 8 F %J QPN[ OGPVKQPU C V[RG YKVJ C EKTENG KP VJG EGPVTG QH VJG ETQUU HNGWT[ QP VJG TGXGTUG 6JG HKTUV ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG KPFKECVGF CU JCU VJG UCOG UJCRG CU VJG HKTUV ETQUU QP VJG QDXGTUG 0Q ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPV OQQPU

&WDDGNG ITQQV # 6YQ JGNOGVU QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ -#41.85 Q &8: „ )'.4+' Q +8. „ <86 „ 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF ,ÒNKEJ KP VJG EGPVTG CPF ) ' . 4 KP VJG CPINGU

GXGT[ NGVVGT DGVYGGP VYQ TKPIU /10'6 # „ 018# )'.4' 0 5+5 „ XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ 8 F %JKLU EQOOGPVU VJCV VJKU KU C EQKP QH DQVVQO SWCNKV[ CPF KV EQPVCKPU XKTVWCNN[ PQ UKNXGT (KTUV ETQUU QP VJG QDXGTUG ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU

325


#40*'/ /WPKEKRCN OKPVKPI KU UGGP KP C PWODGT QH RNCEGU QHVGP YKVJ VJG QXGTNQTFʼn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ʼnU PCOG 6JGTG KU PQ TGHGTGPEG CU VQ YJKEJ EQKPU 6JKU VGZV CFJGTGU VQ VJG PCOG JCNXG OGGWY JCNH UGCIWNN 2WTOGT YKVJ OGPVKQP QH 8CP FGT %JKLUʼn TGHGTGPEG VQ VJKU V[RG CU OQGTMGP /QTEJGP 6JG PCOG OGGWY DGVVGT EQTTGURQPFU YKVJ 0KLOGIGP UGG WPFGT 0KLOGIGP CEEQTFKPI VQ X )GNFGT 6JG YGKIJV UJQWNF DG IO 6JG YGKIJV QH VJG EQKPU OC[ XCT[ CU VJG YGKIJV YCU CNYC[U FGVGTOKPGF RGT DCVEJ CPF UKPING EQKPU YGTG PGXGT YGKIJGF

/GGWY OQGTMGP # %TQYPGF NKQP N /10'6# 018# #'4 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF +0 01+ &1/ +0' 2WTOGT XF%J IT 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV &GEGODGT PQ (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT

/GGWY OQGTMGP # %TQYPGF NKQP N YKVJ ETQUU KP JKU ENCYU /10

018# #40'/0 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 5+6 01 &0+ $0 2WTOGT XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT 0QV RWDNKUJGF

/GGWY OQGTMGP # .KQP TCORCPV /10' 6# 018# #4 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP GCEJ CPING 5+6 01/'0 &0+ $'0'&+% 2WTOGT XF%J IT 44 'FIG HCWNV CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT 0QV RWDNKUJGF

RGTKQF CHVGT

$TCGOUG # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING 2WTOGT XF%J IT

8GT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 0KLOGIGP CNQPI YKVJ CPF UGG 0KLOGIGP 6JKU EQKP FQGU PQV QTKIKPCVG HTQO 0KLOGIGP YKVJ KPGUEWVEJGQP PQT HTQO )TQPKPIGP GUEWVEJGQP YKVJ HGUU CPF KVU UV[NG FQGUPʼnV OCVEJ VJCV QH VJG &GXGPVGT $TCGOUGU 6JGTGHQTG KV KU NKUVGF WPFGT #TPJGO JGTG YJGTG DTCGOUGU OWUV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM CU YGNN UGG WPFGT )TQPKPIGP CTV X )GNFGT 8 F %JKLU NKUVU VJKU EQKP WPFGT )TQPKPIGP UKORN[ DGECWUG KV YCU HQWPF VJGTG

326


ňU *''4'0$'4) 6JG CPEKGPV JKUVQT[ QH VJG *QWUG $GTIJ KU YTCRRGF KP O[UVGT[ )TQNNG DGNKGXGU KVU NKPGCIG IQGU DCEM VQ C EGTVCKP %QPUVCPVKPWU QH /GNGICTFG /GNGICTFG KU VJG OQPCUVGT[ /CNICTVGP PQTVJ QH 1UPCDTÒ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ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI HCXQWT CPQVJGT KPVGTRTGVCVKQP 6JG[ JCXG $GTIJ JKUVQT[ DGIKP YKVJ VJG %QPUVCPVKPWU VJCV UWFFGPN[ CRRGCTGF KP 6JG[ TGHGT VQ VJG TGNCVGFPGUU QH VJG PCOGU /QPVHGTTCPF KP #WXGTIPG YJGTG 2QRG 7TDCP ++ RTGCEJGF VJG HKTUV ETWUCFG VJG ECUVNG /QPVHGTTCPF KP 5[TKC CPF VJG VGTTKVQT[ /QPVHGTNCPF PGCT ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI %QPUVCPVKPWU C PCOG WPMPQYP VQ VJKU TGIKQP YCU UWRRQUGFN[ CP #TOGPKCP RTKPEG QH )CTICT

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ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI VJG EQKP DGCTU PQ KPFKECVKQP VQ VJKU 9KVJ JKU UQP #FCO ++ TGIWNCT OKPVKPI DGICP UKIPKHKGF D[ VJG KPUETKVRKQP &' /16 ' +P %QNQIPG #TEJDKUJQR 9CNGTCP QH ,ÒNKEJ ITCPVGF JKO VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV HQT )GPFTKPIGP CPF KP JG CNNQYGF #FCO VQ OQXG VJG OKPV HTQO )GPFTKPIGP VQ ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI 7PVKN OKPVKPI YCU FQPG WPFGT 9KNNKCO ++ QH $GTIJ 6JG EQKPU YGTG CNN KOKVCVKQPU QH QVJGT MPQYP V[RGU CPF VJG[ CNN DQTG VJG VKVNG &1/+085 6JG NQTFU QH $GTIJ JGNF HKGHU HTQO VJG CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV CPF VJG EQWPV QH )WGNFGTU CPF <WVRJGP &WG VQ VJGKT JKIJ PQDKNKV[ VJG[ YGTG EQPUKFGTGF GSWKXCNGPV VQ RTKPEGU 4GKEJUHÒTUVGP VJG[ EQWNF ENCKO VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV

9+..'/ + QH $'4)* )TCPVGF ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI EKV[ CPF VQNN TKIJVU KP

$TCDCPVKPWU # 5JKGNF YKVJ HQWT NKQPU QH $GTIJ 9+. *'./85 & 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6 # &' /1 06' )TQNNG $ E VJKU URGEKOGP XF%J IT 44 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

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

327


(4'&'4+%- +++ QH $'4)* #U UQQP CU #FCO +++ YCU ITCPVGF RGTOKUUKQP VQ OQXG EQKPRTQFWEVKQP VQ C UVQPG DWKNFKPI UVCPFKPI DGHQTG VJG ECUVNG $GTIJ NCVGT MPQYP CU #NFG /QPVG (TGFGTKEM +++ YCU OCTKGF VQ %CVJCTKPG QH $WTGP Ŏ *G YCU ITCPVGF VJG HKGHFQO QH $KLNCPFV D[ JKU HCVJGT *G JCF QPN[ QPG FCWIJVGT 5QRJKC XCP FGP $GTIJ

)TQQV # *GNOGV YKVJ VJG CTOU QH $GTIJ (4'&'4+%85 &05 &' $'4 4 %TQUU YKVJ 0 # 5 $ KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 018# &' $'4)' )TQNNG H XF%J IT 44 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 6JG YGKIJV KU TGOCTMCDN[ NQY 0QTOCNN[ VJKU YQWNF DG FQWDNG VJQWIJ VJGTG CTG NKIJVGT RKGEGU 6JG PQ )T H YGKIJU NKVVNG VQQ IT 0 # 5 $ 0KLOGIGP #TPJGO <WVRJGP CPF $GTIJ

9+..'/ ++ QH $'4)* 6JG QPN[ FCWIJVGT QH (TGFGTKEM +++ 5QRJKC Ŏ YGFFGF 1VVQ XCP 2QNCPGP XCP FGT .GEM 6JKU EQWRNG CNUQ JCF C UKPING EJKNF VJG UQP 9KNNKCO ++ XCP FGP $GTIJ *G UWEEGGFGF JKU ITCPFHCVJGT KP WPFGT IWCTFKCPUJKR QH JKU HCVJGT +P JG KPJGTKVGF VJG HKGHFQO *GFGN HTQO JKU HCVJGT +P JG EGCUGF OKPVKPI FWG RGTJCRU VQ VJG ITQYKPI KPHNWGPEG QH VJG EGPVTCNKUGF $WTIWPFKCP UVCVG

-TQOUVCCTV # .KQP YKVJ VJG CTOU QH .GEM CPF $GTIJ QP DTGCUV 9+.*'./85 „ &++5 „ &' „ $'4)# 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ $ $ # * KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# „ ++18# „ $'4 „ )'05+5 )TQNNG E XF%J IT 44 'FIG EJKRRGF XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 4QGTOQPF CPF $KLNCPFV VJG NCUV KU PQV EGTVCKP $ $ # * $GTIJ $KLNCPFV #TPJGO *GFGN )TQNNGʼnU TGCFKPI EQPHKTOU VJKU +V KU VJG OQTG TGCUQPCDNG QRVKQP DGECWUG *GFGN YCU QH JKIJGT UKIPKHKECPEG VQ VJG NQTFU QH $GTIJ VJCP $KLNCPFV (WTVJGTOQTG VJG NQTFU QH $GTIJ YQWNF JCXG WUGF VJG NGVVGTU VJCV TGHGT VQ VJGKT QYP GUVCVG VJG[ JCF CNYC[U EJQUGP VJG NGVVGTU QH VJG HQWT )WGNFGTU SWCTVGTU WR VQ VJGP +P VJG JQCTF 8QTFGP C HGY URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG GOGTIGF JQCTF GPVKTGN[ KP -2- 7PFGT PQ D VJGTG CTG VJTGG URGEKOGPU QH VJG V[RG WPFGT EQPUKFGTCVKQP CNN QVJGTU JCXG UNKIJVN[ FKHHGTGPV VGZVU 5GG 'XGNGKP &G XQPFUV XCP \KN XGTGP OWPVGP VG 8QTFGP KP ,/2 R

328


0+,/')'0 6JG PCOG 0QXKQOCIWU KU CNUQ MPQYP HQT 5RG[GT %QPUKFGTKPI (QTTGT VJG PCOG KU QH EGNVKE JGTKVCIG CPF OGCPU C RNCEG YGTG VYQ TKXGTU OGGV KP CP CPING 9Q \YGK (NÃ’UUG \WUCOOGP UVQ­GPF GKPGP 9KPMGN DKNFGP (QTTGT 4 0QXKQOCIWU KP 2H·N\ /WUGWO :8+ R 0KLOGIGP JCU DGGP CP KORQTVCPV RNCEG UKPEG 4QOCP VKOGU YJGP KV YCU C ECUVTWO NCVGT C EKVK[

%QNQPKC 7NRKC 0QXKQOCIWU +V YCU UKVWCVGF CV VJG DQTFGT QH VJG 4QOCP TGCNO CPF CV VJG ETQUUKPI QH OCLQT YCVGTYC[U YJKEJ KP VJQUG FC[U CNTGCF[ EQPUVKVWVGF UKIPKHKECPV VTCFG TQWVGU %JCTNGOCIPG WUGF C OGTQXKPIKCP RCNCVKPG KP 0KLOGIGP YJGTG JG TGIWNCTN[ UQLQWTPGF #PF VJG CTEJDKUJQRTKE %QNQIPG CNTGCF[ QYPGF C UOCNN EJWTEJ 5VGRJCPWU %JWTEJ KP VJG ECUVTWO 6JG 1VVQPGU CPF VJG 5CNKCPU MPGY VJG YC[ VQ 0KLOGIGP VQQ 1VVQ + CU YGNN CU ++ CPF +++ XKUKVGF 0KLOGIGP C PWODGT QH VKOGU 'ORTGUU 6JGQRJCPW FKGF VJGTG CPF *GPT[ ++ KP ECNNGF C FKGV QH UQXGTGKIPU KP VJG RCNCVKPG +P CNN VJKU ECOG VQ CP GPF YJGP .QTTCKPG &WMG )QFHTKGF VJG $GCTFGF YTGCMGF VQVCN FGXCUVCVKQP QP VJG RCNCVKPG 7PFGT .QTTCKPG C EQKP YCU KPENWFGF VJCV RQUUKDN[ JCF 0KLOGIGP QTKIKPU 5KPEG PQ GXKFGPEG JCU DGGP HQWPF KP CTEJKXGU VJKU EQKP KU ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT .QTTCKPG HQT VJG VKOG DGKPI UGG VJGTG (TQO VJCV OQOGPV QP VJG RCNCVKPG YCU PQ NQPIGT HTGSWGPVGF D[ )GTOCP 'ORGTQTU +V YQWNF VCMG WPVKN DGHQTG VJG RCNCVKPG YCU TGUVQTGF YJGP (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC JCF KV TGDWKNV CEVKPI QP RQNKVKECN CPF KFGQNQIKECN ITQWPFU +P 0KLOGIGP FGXQNXGF VQ EQWPV 1VVQ ++ QH )WGNFGTU /KPVKPI QPN[ RCTVN[ UJQYU VJGUG FGXGNQROGPVU 6JGTG KU PQ GXKFGPEG HQT 4QOCP OKPVKPI KP 0KLOGIGP PQT KU KV NKMGN[ VJCV UWEJ GXKFGPEG YKNN UWTHCEG %JCTNGOCIPG PGXGT OKPVGF KP 0KLOGIGP CPF VJGTG YGTG PQ MPQYP 1VVQPGUʼn QT 5CNKCPUʼn EQKPU UVTWEM VJGTG CNVJQWIJ +NKUEJ YKVJ TGICTF VQ UQOG EQKPU VJCV CTG JCTF VQ CVVTKDWVG UQOGVKOGU UWIIGUVU 0KLOGIGP CU OKPV +V VQQM WPVKN VJG 5VCWHKCP GORGTQTU HQT C XGT[ NKOKVGF HQTO QH OKPVKPI VQ UVCTV CPF KV EGCUGF KP YJGP 0KLOGIGP ECOG WPFGT )WGNFGTUʼn KPHNWGPEG (TQO VJCV OQOGPV QP 0KLOGIGP KU C FWECN )WGNFGTU OKPV #TQWPF 0KLOGIGP FGXGNQRGF OWPKEKRCN OKPVKPI 4Q[CN +ORGTKCN /KPVKPI #010;/175

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

2GPPKPI 0KLOGIGP! # 'CING YKVJ HQWT TKPIU KP VJG HKGNF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING # # # # /WPVXQPFUV #TPJGO IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP EH PQ 1P VJKU EQKP VJG QDXGTUG JCU C DQTFGT CNDGKV VGZVNGUU + VJKPM VJGTG CTG C PWODGT QH RGNNGVU

329


(4+'&4+%* + $#4$#4155#

2GPPKPI # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF RCNO NGCH ETQUU N KP HKGNF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG + # + % + + + 8 X) # IT 4 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

2GPPKPI # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF RCNO NGCH ETQUU N KP HKGNF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING PGCT VJG EGPVTG + 8 + % + % + # X) # IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 6JG JQCTF #TPJGO EQPVCKPGF URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG CPF XCP )GNFGT ENCUUKHKGU VJGO WPFGT .QYGT 4JKPG $WEJGPCW $N·VVGT H /Ã’P\HTGWPFG M EQPUKFGTGF VJG KORGTKCN OKPV KP /CCUVTKEJV DWV VJCV FQGU PQV EQPEWT YKVJ VJG YGKIJV 6JG UKOKNCTKVKGU VQ VJG 7VTGEJV CPF .QYGT 4JKPG V[RGU CTIWG VJG EQTTGEVPGUU QH *·XGTPKEM U 0KLOGIGP J[RQVJGUKU R VJG UOCNN YGKIJV JQYGXGT RTQXGU C EQWPVGT CTIWOGPV +P CP CTVKENG KP &G $GGNFGPCCT &TKG OKFFGNGGWYUG OWPVLGU PQ R + UWIIGUVGF VJG VGZV OKIJV DG TGCF #%+8 K G QOKVVKPI VJG +ʼnU YJKEJ UJQWNF DG EQPUKFGTGF KPVGTTWRVKQP OCTMU 6JCV YQWNF NGCF VQ DGNKGXG VJCV #40*'/ %+8+6#5 KU OGCPV YJKEJ JQYGXGT KU KORQUUKDNG KP VJKU RGTKQF 9KGPVLGU 6YGG G GGWYUG RGPPKPIGP WKV FG OWPVXQPFUV #TPJGO KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R UWIIGUVU -CKUGTUYGTVJ VCMKPI VJG UJQTVGPGF VGZV

YKVJQWV VJG +ʼn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ʼnV UGG VJG GPF QH KV %QWNFPʼnV VJKU V[RG VJGTGHQTG JCXG FGXGNQRGF CHVGT JG RGTKUJGF KP #UKC /KPQT KP !

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO 5RKPM 0% PQ EH CNUQ PQ VJG ETQYPU QH CPF CTG VQVCNN[ FKHHGTGPV

*'+04+%* 8++

2GPPKPI # %TQYPGF HKIWTG YKVJ NKU VQRRGF UEGRVTG CPF ETQUKGT *'04+%85 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ ITGCV RQTVCN DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 0+ /#)'0 5 X) % XF%J IT 4 (NCP ETCEM VJTQWIJ VJG OKFFNG QH VJG EQKP VYQ RCTVU XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG GFKHKEG QP VJG TGXGTUG KU C UEJGOCVKE VJQWIJ DCUKECNN[ CEEWTCVG RQTVTC[CN QH VJG EJWTEJ VJCV CFQTPU %QNQIPG EQKPU +P %QNQIPG VJG EJWTEJ KU CNYC[U DGJKPF C YCNN YKVJ C ICVG KP KV JGTG C OGTG CTEJ TGOCKPU YJKEJ 8CP )GNFGT UGGU CU C TWFKOGPVCT[ %QNQIPG YCNN (WTVJGTOQTG VJG TGXGTUG DGCTU C JKIJ NGXGN QH UKOKNCTKV[ VQ VJG EQKPU QH )GTCTF QH )WGNFGTU 6JG UKOKNCTKVKGU CTG VJG HQNNQYKPI

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ʼnV EQPUVKVWVG C UKORNKHKGF %QNQIPG YCNN

330


2GPPKPI # %QWPV YKVJ EQUKGT CPF QTD HCEKPI 4 +PEWWU X) % XF%J IT *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF QP VJG *GKOGTDGTI PGCT VJG 4JKPG 6JG UCOG CU PQ QPN[ YKVJ KPEWWU QP VJG TGXGTUG

8GT[ HKPG

(4+'&4+%* ++

2GPPKPI EC # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF QTD % # 4 %JWTEJ # X) % XF%J IT 4 # NKVVNG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG KPFKECVKQP QP VJKU V[RG %'5#4 ECP QPN[ CNNWFG VQ 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM ++ JKOUGNH UQNGN[ DGECWUG VJKU VGZV YCU OCKPVCKPGF WPVKN VJG GPF QH VJG TGKIP 6JKU XCTKGV[ YKVJQWV C RTQRGT PCOG UGNFQON[ QEEWTU GNUGYJGTG DWV VJG ENCUUKECN VGTO %'5#4 HQT GORGTQT OCFG KVU CRRGCTCPEG KP #CEJGP YKVJ VJG NGIGPF (4'&'4+%85 %'5#4 CV VJG UCOG VKOG

2GPPKPI # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF QTD %'5#4 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU CPF # 8 ' KP VJG CPINGU 08/ #)'0 X) % XF%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO HKPF .GGWYCTFGP PQ ,/2 R VJKU EQKP KU KNNWUVTCVGF CU HKI

2GPPKPI KOKVCVKQP # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG CPF QTD 88' 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU CPF # 8 ' KP VJG CPINGU '8'8 GVE X) & XF%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO HKPF .GGWYCTFGP PQ ,/2 R VJKU EQKP KU KNNWUVTCVGF CU HKI 6JG JQCTF .GGWYCTFGP EQPVCKPGF 0KLOGIGP EQKPU CPF HTQO %NGXGU HTQO CTG KOKVCVKQPU VJG %NGXGU RKGEGU CTG CNN KOKVCVKQPU 6JG[ CRRCTGPVN[ EQOG HTQO VJG UCOG OQPG[GTʼnU UVWFKQ RGTJCRU CP WPQHHKEKCN EQKPGT[ KP VJG XKEKPKV[ QH VJG EKVKGU QH 0KLOGIGP CPF %NGXGU VJCV CTG OGTGN[ MO CRCTV 6JCV VJG FGNKDGTCVG KOKVCVKQP QH MPQYP EKTEWNCVKPI V[RGU QH EQKPU YCU EQOOQP WUG KU UJQYP D[ VJG TGIWNCVKQPU QH VJG VJ CPF VJ EGPVWT[ CU EKVGF D[ *·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

331


9+..'/ ++

2GPPKPI # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ QTD 9+. 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP RGNNGVU CPF # 8 ' KP VJG CPINGU 08/#)'0 %+8+5 X) & IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

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

/WPKEKRCN OKPVKPI 6JG RTGEKUG FCVWO QH EQOOGPEGOGPV QH OWPKEKRCN OKPVKPI KP 0KLOGIGP KU WPMPQYP 6JGTG CTG TGEQTFU QP #TPV QH 1EJVGPʼn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

$TCGOUG # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING YKVJ YKVJ UJKGNF QP DTGCUV 2CUUQP # IT *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 0KLOGIGP VQIGVJGT YKVJ CPF 6JG GCING QH VJKU OKPV KU UOCNNGT VJCP VJCV QH PQ

8GT[ HKPG

$TCGOUG # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING YKVJ YKVJ UJKGNF QP DTGCUV 2CUUQP # IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 0KLOGIGP VQIGVJGT YKVJ CPF

332


$TCGOUG ! # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING YKVJ YKVJ UJKGNF QP DTGCUV 2CUUQP IT 'FIG PKEMU HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 0KLOGIGP +P XKGY QH VJG YGKIJV C JCNH OKIJV DG EQPUKFGTGF

5VWKXGT # %TQYPGF NKQP YKVJ UJKGNF QH 0KLOGIGP ‡ /10'6# Ã 018# Ã 018+/#)'0 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ‡ #001 Ã &1/+ Ã / Ã %%%% Ã .:::8 2CUUQP $ E XF%J IT 44 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

-ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCDKPGVV -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

5VWKXGT EC # #TOU QH 0KLOGIGP /10'6# 018# 018+1 /#) 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU KP VJG EGPVTG 2#: 5+6 5'2 01$ 2CUUQP XF%J IT 4 5OCNN HNCP VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG /WVVGTMGP (QWPF KP 1QUVGTDKGTWO

5VWKXGT EC # #TOU QH 0KLOGIGP /10'6# 0 18# 01 8+/# 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU KP VJG EGPVTG 2#: 5+6 5'2 01$ 2CUUQP XF%J IT 4 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG /WVVGTMGP (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 0KLOGIGP

333


+,55'.56'&'0 &'8'06'4 $GHQTG .GDWKPWU GTGEVGF C UOCNN EJCRGN VQ WPFGTVCMG 5CZQP RTQUGN[VKUCVKQP HTQO +V YCU FGXCUVCVGF D[ .KWFIGT DWV TGDWKNV CICKP 8KMKPI TCKFU JCF RTQORVGF VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQRU VQ OQXG VJGKT UGG VQ &GXGPVGT VGORQTCTKN[ 5V 4CFDQF Ŏ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ʼn OKPVKPI UGG VJGTG 4Q[CN +ORGTKCN OKPVKPI +P VJG RGTKQF HTQO CTQWPF VQ VJG )GTOCP GORGTQTU OKPVGF KP &GXGPVGT /KPVKPI JGTG TGCEJGF KVU CRQIGG KP VJG VKOG QH *GPT[ ++ QH YJKEJ VKOG OQUV EQKPU CTG MPQYP 1661 + !

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1 ¢ & ¢ &1 ¢ 4': 4 %QNQPKC OQPQITCO 5 %1+10+ # IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (QWPF KP &G 8GTIV KP 9CCTFGPDWTI +NKUEJ ,/2 FKUEWUUGU VJKU V[RG KP h %QNQPKC 2T·IWPIGP OKV &TGKGEMUMGKNGP 6JG YQTF %1.10+ KU PQV TGVTQITCFG CPF VJG 1 U UJQY C RGNNGV CV VJGKT EGPVTG VJKU EQKP OQUV TGUGODNGU +NKUEJ CVVTKDWVGU VJKU VQ 1VVQ +

! ņ CRRTQZ 6JKU RCTVKEWNCT PQ V[RG YCU CNOQUV GZENWUKXGN[ HQWPF KP 5KNXQNFG PGCT &GXGPVGT (QT KVU QTKIKP +NKUEJ RTQXKFGU C PWODGT QH RQUUKDKNKVKGU VJG EQKPU FGUETKDGF KP h JG CVVTKDWVGU VQ VJG TGIKQP 0KLOGIGP 6KGN

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

1661 +++

&GPKGT # $GCTFGF ETQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 1661 4': 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING

&# 8'0&4 +# &CPP (& C +NKUEJ IT 44 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $GTNKPGT /ÒP\MCDKPGVV ņ $GTNKP #WEVKQP PQ

334


&GPKGT # $GCTFGF ETQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 1Å‘Å‘1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &#8'04' &CPP (& C +NKUEJ IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP ņ $CUGN 1&&1 KU UCZQPKCP 1661 KU HTCPEQPKCP 6JKU V[RG FKHHGTU UNKIJVGN[ HTQO +NKUEJ CPF KV OGTGN[ TGCFU 1&&1 DGUKFGU VJG ETQYP QP VJG EGPVTG VTKCPING DGCTU C ETQUU KPUVGCF QH C TKPI

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1&&1 4': 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU 5 4'08#& # &CPP (& D +NKUEJ DWV YKVJ TGVTQITCFG 5 IT 4 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

2GWU ņ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

*'+04+%* ++

&GPKGT # #NRJC CPF QOGIC DGVYGGP VTKFGPV CPF 5 KP VJG HKGNF 5 *' 04+% 85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &#8# 064+# &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU FGPKGT CPF VJG HQNNQYKPI YGTG KOKVCVGF KP )GTOCP[ CNUQ KP VJG RGTKQF QH *GKPTKEJ ++

&GPKGT # #NRJC QOGIC DGVYGGP VTKFGPV CPF 5 KP VJG HKGNF * '04+% 85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &#8 #06 4+# &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP 5VWVVICTV

335


&GPKGT # 4': CTQWPF JCPF *'04+%85 +/4'2#61 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &#8#064+# &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

&GPKGT # 4#: CTQWPF JCPF *' +04+ %85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING %60 8%

HKTUV % TGVTQITCFG &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 4KGVFKLM ņ FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ 6JG ' QH 4': NQQMU NKMG CP # $GVYGGP VJWOD CPF HQTGHKPIGT VJG WRRGT RCTV QH C ETQUKGT 0QV KP &CPPGPDGTI 6JGTG UGGOU VQ DG QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP RTGXKQWUN[ KP VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH $GTIJCWU

&GPKGT # 4': CTQWPF JCPF NGIGPF PGCTN[ WPXKUKDNG * ++ Å‘ 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN RTGUGTXGF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG YGFIGU QP VJG TGXGTUG TGOKPFKPI QP VJG 9GPFGPRHGPPKIG 5CEJUGPRHGPPKIG 6JKU JCPF KU XGT[ DTQCF PQTOCNN[ KV NQQMU SWKVG UOCNNGT

336


*#0& +P &GXGPVGT YG GPEQWPVGT C PGY V[RG VJCV QH VJG JCPF +VU RTQVQV[RG YCU VJG RGPP[ QH #GVJGNTGF ++ KP 'PINCPF UVTWEM CTQWPF (QTOCNN[ VJCV JCF C RTGFGEGUUQT KP C RGPP[ QH 'FYCTF VJG 'NFGTʼnU DWV CEEQTFKPI VQ #TEJKDCNF VJQUG VYQ YGTG PQV TGNCVGF #TEJKDCNF #PINQ 5CZQP %QKPCIG #NHTGF VQ VJG %QPSWGUV KP VJG )QNFGP #IG QH #PINQ 5CZQP #TV .QPFQP $/ R GV UGSS 6JG JCPF VQQM QP UGXGTCN UJCRGU OQUV GUVCDNKUJGF YGTG VJG JCPF GOGTIKPI HTQO VJG ENQWFU

UGG VJG #PPWPEKCVKQP HQO 0CRNGU CPF VJG JCPF QXGT VJG ETQUU UGG HQT KPUVCPEG PQ HTQO /GV\ 6JG EQKP WPFGT EQPUKFGTCVKQP UJQYU C JCPF RQKPVKPI FQYP VJCV KU UWTTQWPFGF D[ NGVVGTU 6Q VJG HKTUV %JTKUVKCPU VJG JCPF YCU VJG U[ODQN QH FKXKPG RTQXKFGPEG UGG ( (TKGFGPUDWTI &KG 5[ODQNKM FGT /KVVGNCNVGTOÒ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Λ j CNRJC CPF QOGIC VJG DGIKPPKPI CPF VJG GPF #U VJKU EQODKPCVKQP FGUKIPCVGU )QF KV UVCPFU VQ TGCUQP VJCV VJG JCPF KPFKECVGU VJG *CPF QH )QF 6JG U[ODQNU Λ j YGTG NCVGT TGRNCEGF YKVJ C XCTKGV[ QH U[ODQNU EQTTWRVKPI VJG QTKIKPCN UGPUG D 6JG JCPF KU UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJG YQTF 4': 6JKU CNNWFGU VQ VJG MKPIJQQF QH )QF QT QH %JTKUV 6JG SWGUVKQP TGOCKPU YJGVJGT VJG *CPF QH )QF KU TGHGTTGF VQ QT VJCV QH %JTKUV .CVGT VJG NGVVGTU 4': LWUV CU VJG Λ j YGTG TGRNCEGF D[ ETQUUGU #V CP[ TCVG VJG VYQ XCTKGVKGU CNRJC CPF QOGIC QP VJG QPG JCPF CPF 4': QP VJG QVJGT TGRTG UGPV FKHHGTGPV PQVKQPU 6JKU JCU VQ DG EQPUKFGTGF YJGP KPVGTRTGVKPI EQKPCIG # UKOKNCT RJGPQOGPQP KU QDUGTXGF YKVJ VJG *QN\MKTEJG VJCV KPKVKCNN[ YCU UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJG NGVVGTU Λ CPF j NGVVGTU VJCV NCVGT YGTG TGRNCEGF YKVJ C XCTKGV[ QH U[ODQNU UGG WPFGT )QUNCT

&GPKGT # *GCF YKVJ YKNF JCKT CPF DTQCF NKRU N DNWPFGTGF *'+04+%85 +/ NGIGPF 4 $ Q 1 Q 0 Q # Q CTQWPF UOCNN ETQUU &# #06 &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ (QT $10# UGG 6KGN CPF VJG EQOOGPVU YKVJ PQ %JCTNGOCIPG 6JKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM UJQTVN[ DGHQTG CPF YCU EQPVKPWGF D[ %QPTCF ++

337


-104#& ++

&GPKGT # *GCF YKVJ YKNF JCKT N %10 4 #&8 5 4 Q $ Q 1 Q 0 Q # CTQWPF UOCNN ETQUU &#8#06 &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP KU QH VJG UCOG V[RG CU VJCV QH *GPT[ ++ UGG PQ 2GTJCRU KV KU C URGEKOGP HTQO VJG HKTUV [GCT QH %QPTCFʼnU TGKIP 6JG $ QH $10# KU TGVTQITCFG YJKEJ EQTTGURQPFU YKVJ +NKUEJ QH *GPT[ ++ 2TGUWOCDN[ C WPKSWG

&GPKGT # %TQYPGF CPF DGCTFGF JGCF HCEKPI % 10ő 5+0 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING &8 őő &CPP (& +NKUEJ IT 4 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 6JKU V[RG JCU VQ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF HTQO VJG UKOKNCT V[RGU QH 1VVQ +++ *GTG VJG HCEG KU QDNQPI VJG G[GU CNOQPF UJCRGF 6JG FKGU CTG OQTG FGNKECVG VJCP VJQUG QH 1VVQ +++ (QT OKPVKPI KP VJG PCOG QH VJG DKUJQRU QH 7VTGEJV UGG WPFGT 7VTGEJV

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

$TCGOUG # 'CING N (& XF%J IT *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP *CVVWO

*CNXG $TCGOUG ! # 'CING N (& ! XF%J IT

6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 'NDWTI *CVVWO 6JKU EQKP LWUV CU PQ KU ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT (& ;GV VJG JGCF QH VJG GCING KU GPVKTGN[ FKHHGTGPV CPF VJG YGKIJV CPF VJG UK\G KPFKECVG C JCNH

338


$TCGOUG # 'CING T (& XF%J IT

8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (& JCU VJG JGCF N 6JG UVTWEVWTG QH VJG UVCOR KU TQWIJGT

$TCGOUG # 'CING N NGHV YKPI NKMG C UVCPFCTF (& XF%J IT

5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG

$TCGOUG # 'CING YKVJ UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV (& XF%J IT 5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP 'NDWTI *CVVWO 6JKU EQKP KU PQV NKUVGF KP (& 6JG SWGUVKQP CTKUGU YJGVJGT VJKU RTGUGPVU C VTCPUKVKQP VQ VJG PGZV ITQWR VJG CTOU QH VJG 1XGTUVKEJV VQ VJG TKIJV QH VJG GCING

'CING YKVJ UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (QTVW[P &TQQINGXGT MPQYU QH CPQVJGT PQ XF%J QH YJKEJ VJG FKHHGTGPEG YKVJ PQ XF%J KU WPENGCT 9KVJ PQ VJGTG KU OGPVKQP QH CP GCING CPF YKVJ PQ QH C UEJGOCVKE FTCYKPI QH CP GCING

'CING QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV

$TCGOUG # 'CING N YKVJ UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV KP VJG ENCYU (& XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6JKU URGEKOGP KU QH OWEJ ITGCVGT FGNKECE[ KP UV[NG VJCP KU WUWCN HQT &GXGPVGT

$TCGOUG # 'CING T QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV (& XF%J IT

8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ *GTG VQQ VJG UV[NG KU HKPGT VJCP VJCV QH VJG NCUV ITQWRU 2GTJCRU VJG ITQWR HGCVWTKPI VJG CTOU DGVYGGP VJG VCNQPU TGRTGUGPVU EQKPCIG #RCTV HTQO VJG DTCGOUGP VJG QNFGUV MPQYP OWPKEKRCN EQKP QH &GXGPVGT FCVGU HTQO 2NCM (&

2NCM # 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV /10'

018# &' &#8'06ʼn 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF #001 &0+ʼn/ %%%% .:8+ (& XF%J IT 4 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV (QWPF KP VJG $GVWYG (& MPQYU QPN[ QH URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG UVTWEM KP JQYGXGT VJG EQKP CV JCPF OKIJV UJQY VJGTG YCUPʼnV GPQWIJ URCEG HQT VJG UGEQPF + VJGTGHQTG KV RTCEVKECNN[ OGTIGU YKVJ VJG

339


2NCM # 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV /10' 018# &' &#8'06+ 4 %TQUU #001 &0+ʼn / %%%% .:8+ (& XF%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #WIWUV PQ (QWPF KP &GXGPVGT

9KVRGPPKPI # #TOU YKVJ GCING N QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV /10'6# Z 018# &' Z &#8064+# 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP NQPI ETQUU YKVJ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU #001 &1/+0 / Z %%% .::++ (& XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

9KVRGPPKPI # 'CING N YKVJ VJG UJKGNFU QH &GXGPVGT CPF 1XGTUVKEJV KP VJG ENCYU /10'6# 018# &#8'064+' 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP NQPI ETQUU #001 /+..' & %%%% .::+++ (& C XF%J IT 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ +P VJKU EQNNGEVKQP VJKU KU VJG NCUV EQKP FKURNC[KPI VJG CTOU QH &CXKF QH $WTIWPF[ VJG NCUV YCU UVTWEM KP (&

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ʼnU QDXGTUG (& KU KFGPVKECN VQ VJCV QH VJG EQKP CV JCPF VJG VGZV QP DQVJ UKFGU KU CNUQ VJG UCOG GZEGRV HQT VJG ETQUU HNGWT[ QP VJG TGXGTUG VJCV YCU KOKVCVGF HTQO VJG UVWKXGTʼnU (&

340


)QWFIWNFGP # 5CKPV .GDWKPWU QP IQVJKE VJTQPG YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH &GXGPVGT DGVYGGP JKU NGIU /10 &' &#8 '064+# 4 1TD KP VTGHQKN (4'&4+% 41/#0148 +/2'4 (D (& XF%J IT 44 9GNN UVTWEM CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JKU V[RG Q & KU UVTWEM KP VJG RGTKQF

5VWKXGT # 5JKGNF YKVJ GCING N CPF VJG UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV DGVYGGP JKU ENCYU /10 '6# Q &' Q &#8'064+# 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF & # 8 ' KP VJG CPINGU #00 1 Q &0 / Q %% %% Q (& XF%J IT 4 %QTTQFGF HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 'NDWTI *CVVWO

2NCM # 'CING N / 10'6 &' &#8'064 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV KP VJG EGPVTG #00 &0+ /%% % % (& XF%J IT 5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 'NDWTI *CVVWO 6JG NCUV RCTV QH VJG [GCT %% KU PQV XKUKDNG 6JG /10'6 KU WPENGCT DWV KP XKGY QH VJG ICR KV OWUV DG '6 VJG NGVVGTU QH PQ YJKEJ CTG ENGCT UWRRQTV VJKU TGCFKPI (& IKXGU /10

2NCM # 'CING N /10' 6 &' &# 8'064 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV #00 &0+ /%% %% (& XF%J IT 5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 'NDWTI *CVVWO +P VJG NGIGPF KU VJG PQV XKUKDNG EH PQ

341


5VWKXGT # 'CING N /10'6# & ' & #8'064 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV KP VJG EGPVTG CPF & # 8 ' KP VJG CPINGU #00 1&/ %%%% %+++ (& XF%J IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG +P VJG FGUETKRVKQP KP (& &G $GGNFGPCCT PQ R VJG VGZV KU UNKIJVN[ FKHHGTGPV CPF KV KU FCVGF &KHHKEWNV VQ VGNN QP VJKU URGEKOGP + VJKPM KV UC[U +++ VJGTG KU VQQ NKVVNG URCEG HQT PWOGTCNU 6JG YGKIJV RTQXKFGF D[ (& KU EQPUKFGTCDN[ NQYGT I

.GDWKPWUUVWKXGT # 5CKPV .GDWKPWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DQQM 5#0%685 .' $8+ 4 'CING N QXGT UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV /10'6# 018# &' &#8'064+# (& XF%J IT 8GT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ

1156 0'&'4.#0& '#56 0'6*'4.#0&5 #010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT # %TQUU *.8&188+% 4 6JTGG ETQUUGU CTQWPF JCPF 06/ 8 + + $ + &CPP +NKUEJ IT 4 4GXGTUG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ +OKVCVKQP QH VJG &GXGPVGT YKVVGP 6JG +ʼnU KP VJG NGIGPF QP VJG TGXGTUG EQPUKUV QH VYQ VTKCPINGU RQKPVKPI VQYCTFU GCEJ QVJGT &CPPGPDGTI EQOOGPVU 1JPG (TCIG PKGFGTN·PFKUEJGT *GTMWPHV .8 188+%85 06/1%++ .# 'ZR KP - / 6JGTG KU TGHGTGPEG VQ 9GKLN $ $N J 6JGTG KU PQ OGPVKQP YJCVUQGXGT QH VJKU RKGEG KP NKVGTCVWTG GXGP +NKUEJ FQGU PQV OGPVKQP KV

342


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ʼn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

5VWKXGT # #TOU QH &GXGPVGT -CORGP CPF <YQNNG YKVJ % KP VJG EGPVTG /10' 018 %#/2 4 5JKGNF QH -CORGP QP NQPI QTPCOGPVGF ETQUU #00 1 &0 / %%%% (& XF%J IT 4 5ETCVEJGU QP VJG TGXGTUG XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

<91..'

5VWKXGT # #TOU QH &GXGPVGT -CORGP CPF <YQNNG YKVJ < KP VJG EGPVTG Q /10' Q 018 Q <91. 4 5JKGNF QH <YQNNG QP NQPI QTPCOGPVGF ETQUU #00 1 &0 / %% %%Q (& XF%J IT 4 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’NNGT 5QNKPIGP #WEVKQP PQ

343


&'8'06'4

2NCM # 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG /10 018 &#8 '06 4 #TOU QH &GXGPVGT -CORGP CPF <YQNNG YKVJ % KP VJG EGPVTG #0& /%%% %% ! (& D XF%J IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (QWPF KP VJG UWTTQWPFKPI QH 'NDWTI *CVVWO 6JG PWODGTU CTG PQV XKUKDNG (& MPQYU QPN[ QH VJG [GCT YKVJ VJG NGVVGT & &GXGPVGT

<91..' <YQNNG GOGTIGF HTQO C OKPQT UGVVNGOGPV QP CP GNGXCVKQP PGCT VQ YCVGT 5WQNNG (KTUV FQEW OGPVGF KP C EJCTVGT HTQO KP YJKEJ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV DGUVQYGF VJG EJWTEJ QP VJG UKVG QH RTGUGPV FC[ 5V /KEJCGNʼnU %JWTEJ QP VJG RCTTKUJ QH &GXGPVGT +P <YQNNG CESWKTGF EKV[ TKIJVU HTQO VJG 7VTGEJV DKUJQR 9KNDTCPF QH 1NFGPDWTI CU TG YCTF HQT VJG UWRRQTV KP VJG DCVVNG CICKPUV VJG &TGPVU +P VJG EKV[ YCU DWTPV FQYP D[ <YGFGT XCP 8QQTUV CU JG YCU EQPXKPEGF <YQNNG YCU WPFGTOKPKPI JKU CWVJQTKV[ <YQNNG YCU TGDWKNV CPF KVU VTCFG HNQWTKUJGF FWG VQ VJG OCTMGV TKIJV CESWKTGF KP +V TQUG VQ KVU CRQIGG KP VJG UGEQPF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF VJG HKTUV JCNH QH VJG VJ <YQNNG DGECOG C JCPUGCVKE EKV[ KP (WTVJGTOQTG <YQNNG YCU C EWNVWTCN EGPVTG VJG &GXQVKQ /QFGTPC QH )GGTV )TQQVG CPF 6JQOCU ¯ -GORKU YCU XGT[ RTQOKPGPV +P <YQNNG TGEGKXGF C IGPGTCN RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV HTQO 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++

)QWFIWNFGP # 6JG CTEJCPIGN HKIJVU YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF VJG HCNNGP FGXKN Q /10 #8 <91. 4 1TD KP VTGHQKN (4'&4+% R1 #0 +/2' #6 (D (& XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP &GWVUEJNCPF #WEVKQP PQ 9KVJ VJG VKVNG GORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++

$WVIGP # 5JKGNF QH <YQNNG /10'6# Q 018# Q <91.. 4 5JKGNF QH <YQNNG QP NQPI ETQUU #00 &0+ /%% %% (& XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG -Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

344


2NCM # 5JKGNF QH <YQNNG /10 018 <91. 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING #0 &/ +0 (& XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG C NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF KP #OGTUHQQTV

-#/2'0 +VU PCOG WUGF VQ DG URGNNGF %CORGP (KTUV FQEWOGPVGF OGPVKQP KP C EJCTVGT -CORGP OWUV JCXG CNTGCF[ GZKUVGF KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ #NVJQWIJ -CORGP YCU IQXGTPGF CU KH KV JCF EKV[ TKIJVU CPF CNN CWVJQTKVKGU KPXQNXGF CRRTQXGF QH VJKU VJGTG KU PQ GXKFGPEG QH VJGUG TKIJVU -CORGP RTQDCDN[ HKPCNN[ CESWKTGF EKV[ UVCVWU KP VJG UGEQPF JCNH QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ D[ UNQYN[ WUWTRKPI VJGO QT D[ VJG EQPUQNKFCVKQP QH C EQORNGZ QH TKIJVU KV JCF CESWKTGF D[ VJCV VKOG 'ORGTQT 9GPEGUNCU KP ITCPVGF -CORGP C RTKXKNGIG VJCV GPVKVNGF VJG EKV[ VQ UVTKMG DQVJ UKNXGT CPF IQNF EQKPU 6JGTG YCU PQ OKPVKPI DGHQTG PGKVJGT YCU VJGTG FKTGEVN[ CHVGT VJKU FCVG 1PEG OKPVKPI UVCTVGF DGKPI FGXGNQRGF VJG EKV[ FKF JQYGXGT CNYC[U KPXQMG VJKU QNF RTKXKNGIG CPF PGXGT UVTQXG HQT TGPGYCN QH KV -CORGP RNC[GF C XKVCN TQNG KP $CNVKE VTCFG CPF DGECOG C *CPUGCVKE EKV[ KP #V VJG GPF QH VJG /KFFNG #IGU KVU UKIPKHKECPEG CU EGPVTG QH EQOOGTEG YCPGF -CORGP YCU VJG HKTUV EKV[ VQ KUUWG QYP EQKPU KP VJG 1XGTUVKEJV #TQWPF VJG HKTUV UOCNN EQKPU YGTG OCPWHCEVWTGF RTQDCDN[ WUGF CU UOCNN EJCPIG *QYGXGT KP VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ -CORGP DGICP UVTKMKPI NCTIGT UKNXGT EQKPU YKVJ VJG CTOU CPF VJG PCOG QH VJG EKV[ &GXGPVGT OKPVKPI KP VJG UCOG RGTKQF UQNGN[ EQPUKUVGF QH KUUWGU EQOOKUUKQPGF D[ VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV

&WDDGNG ITQQV # 5JKGNF QH -CORGP KP OWNVKNQDG /10'6 # „ 018# „ 12+&+ „ %#/2'05 4 %TQUU YKVJ % # / 2 KP VJG CPINGU $0&+%685 ” 38+ ” 8'0+6 ” +0 ” 01$ (& XF%J 5WRRNGOGPV IT 4 6GUV EWV QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

5V 0KEQNCCUUVWKXGT # 5CKPV 0KEQNCWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 5#06 0+% 1.#85 '2 4 5JKGNF QH -CORGP YKVJ UOCNN UJKGNF QH 1XGTUVKEJV $'# 6+ 3+ (#%+ +856 (& XF%J IT 44 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN RTGUGTXGF HQT VJKU V[RG XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 8 F %JKLU MPQYU QPN[ QH QPG URGEKOGP KP JKU VKOGU

345


2NCM # 5JKGNF /10'6# 018# %#/20 4 .QPI ETQUU #0 0# &05 (& XF%J IT 4 2TGUUWTGF KP QPG RCTV XGT[ HKPG

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO +P VJG -2- YCU UJQYP UGXGTCN URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG 6JG KPFKECVKQP RNCM YCU FGTKXGF HTQO VJG PCOG QH C UKOKNCT EQKP YKVJ C UJQTV ETQUU KP VJG JQCTF #TPJGO

/##556'&'0 1;'0 6JKU UOCNN VQYP PQYCFC[U C RCTV QH VJG OWPKEKRCNKV[ QH .KVJ WUGF VQ DG C HKGHFQO HKGH YKVJKP VJG NCPF QH %W[M /CTKC QH $TCDCPV YCU VJG YKFQY QH &WMG 4GKPQWF +++ QH )WGNFGTU

Ŏ CPF C FCWIJVGT QH &WMG ,QJP +++ QH $TCDCPV #HVGT JGT JWUDCPF YCU ECRVWTGF /CTKC DQWIJV VJG HKGH HTQO &KTM /GGTJGO CPF /CTKC QH $QZVGN /KPVKPI FKFPʼnV UVCTV WPVKN CHVGT VJG FGCVJ QH JGT JWUDCPF KP 6JG QNFGUV MPQYP EJCTVGT VJCV DGCTU CP[ TGHGTGPEG VQ OKPVKPI KU HTQO VJG VJ 1EVQDGT 2WKUVGT CVVTKDWVGF /CTKCʼnU RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV VQ JGT JKIJ PQDKNKV[ PGKVJGT DGHQTG PQT CHVGT /CTKCʼnU FC[U YCU VJGTG CP[ OKPVKPI KP 1[GP V[RGU QH EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM GXGT[ QPG CP KOKVCVKQP QH GZKUVKPI V[RGU #OQPI VJGO YGTG VYQ IQNF V[RGU YJKEJ EQPUVKVWVGU UQOGVJKPI QH C TCTKV[ HQT C VJ EGPVWT[ JCIGOWPV OKPV UVTKMKPI DGNQY UVCPFCTF KOKVCVKQPU VJCV JQYGXGT DQTG VJG OKPVKPI NQTFʼnU PCOG UGG 2WKUVGT &G OWPVUNCI KP 0QQTF $TCDCPV FQQT FG GGWYGP JGGP $GGNFGPCCT PQ R /#4+# QH $4#$#06

4KLPUG IQWFIWNFGP 1[GP # &WMG YKVJ UJKGNF WPFGT ECPQR[ QXGT UJKGNF QH )WGNFGTU /#4+# &8% +5 )'.4'0 4 6YQ UJKGNFU KP OWNVKNQDG 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU CPF FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING $'0'&+%6 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' (D XF%J IT 44 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO 5RKPM <Ò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ʼnU KORQUUKDNG HQT 5V 2GVGT JCU C MG[ YJGTG 5V 2CWN JCU VJG UYQTF $GPFGT FKUVKPIWKUJGU VYQ V[RGU QH VJKU IQNF )WNFGP QPG DGCTKPI VJG $TCDCPV NKQP CPF VJG QVJGT VJG )WGNFGTU NKQP 9JKEJ QPG KU QNFGUV KU WPFGVGTOKPCDNG 6JG FKHHGTGPEG YQWNF JCXG VQ DG KP VJG YGKIJV DWV VJG YGKIJVU QH DQVJ ITQWRU DCTGN[ FKHHGT 0GXGTVJGNGUU QP VJ QH &GEGODGT CU YGNN CU QP VJ QH 5GRVGODGT VJGTG KU OGPVKQP QH C PGY 1[GP )WNFGP EH $GPFGTU &G OWPVUNCI XCP /CTKC XCP $TCDCPV KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R

346


/')'0 6JG UGKIPKQT[ QH /GIGP UKVWCVGF D[ VJG /GWUG DGVYGGP VJG FWEJKGU QH $TCDCPV CPF )WGNFGTU KU FQEWOGPVGF UKPEG VJG VJ EGPVWT[ %QWPVU QH /GIGP YGTG KP QHHKEG UJQTVN[ DGHQTG VJG VWTP QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 9JCV OCMGU OCVVGTU CYMYCTF KU VJCV GCEJ EQWPV YCU ECNNGF ,QJP 0QV WPVKN ,QJP +++ FKF EQKPU GOGTIG JG NGHV C ITGCV XCTKGV[ QH VJGO GXGT[ QPG CP KOKVCVKQP QH EQKPU HTQO VJG UWTTQWPFKPI TGIKQPU ,QJP +++ JCF QPN[ QPG FCWIJVGT CPF YJGP UJG FKGF Ŏ VJG EQWPV[ DTKGHN[ RCUUGF VQ $TCDCPV WPVKN KV YCU FGXQNXGF VQ VJG *QWUG &KMDKGT KP 7PFGT ,QJP 8 HTQO VJKU JQWUG EQKPRTQFWEVKQP EGCUGF 6JG UCOG ,QJP 8 GXGPVWCNN[ UQNF VJG EQWPV[ VQ )WK FG $TKOGW GV Fʼn*WODGTEQWTV *G YCU VJG CPEGUVQT QH /CTKG FG $TKOGW GPF VJ EGPVWT[ YJQ YQWNF RNC[ CP KORQTVCPV RCTV KP OKPVKPI KP )QTKPEJGO ,#0 +++

)TQQV # *GNOGV DGVYGGP VQ XGTVKECN NKPGU +1*#00'5 %1/ /' 4 %TQUU YKVJ # $ % & KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 018# &'ő .WECU X\ M\ XF%J IT 44 'FIG EJKRRGF HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

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

5'+)0+14; #4-'. #TMGN YCU C UGKIPKQT[ KP VJG EQWPV[ 6GKUVGTDCPV DGVYGGP VJG TKXGTU .GM CPF /GTYGFG +V GP EQORCUUGF VJG VQYPU QH )QTKPEJGO *GWMGNQO #URGTGP .GGTFCO COQPI QVJGTU 6JG UGKIPKQT[ YCU C RQUUGUUKQP QH VJG .QTFU QH #TMGN 6JGTG YGTG VYQ ECUVNGU QPG D[ VJG .KPIG CETQUU HTQO VJG XKNNCIG #TMGN VJG QVJGT VQ VJG GCUV QH )QTKPEJGO FGUVTQ[GF KP D[ %QWPV 9KNNKCO 8+ QH *QNNCPF ,QJP + Ŏ KU VJG HKTUV EQWPV PCOGF KP C EJCTVGT *KU UQP ,QJP ++ Ŏ CESWKTGF VJG XKNNC )QTKPEJGO 1H ITGCVGT HCOG KU ,QJP +8 Ŏ YJQ LQKPGF TCPMU YKVJ %QWPV 9KNNKCO 8 QH *QNNCPF KP VJG *QQM CPF %QF 9CTU *KU DTQVJGT YCU VJG DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV ,QJP QH #TMGN -PQYP DGUV KU ,QJP 8 Ŏ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ʼn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


+V PQY UGGOGF VJCV VJCV YCU VJG GPF QH VJG .QTFU QH #TMGN DWV KP HCEV VJGKT TQNG YCU HCT HTQO DGKPI RNC[GF #RCTV HTQO JKU *QNNCPF KPVGTGUVU ,QJP 8 JCF OCKPVCKPGF ENQUG VKGU YKVJ )WGNFGTU VJCV JCF ECTGHWNN[ MGRV VQ VJG DCEMITQWPF FWTKPI VJG #TMGN 9CT &WMG 9KNNKCO QH )WGNFGTU JCF JQYGXGT CUUWTGF #TMGN QH JKU CKF KP VJG DCVVNG CICKPUV #NDTGEJV DWV 9KNNKCOʼnU FGOKUG VJYCTVGF VJGUG RNCPU 4GKPQWF VQQ VTKGF TGCEJKPI C VTWEG HQT JG JCF DGGP OCTTKGF VQ ,QJCPPC FWEJGUU QH ,ÒNKEJ CPF UKUVGT QH 4GKPQWF +8 FWMG QH )WGNFGTU ,Ò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ʼnU VQ DG RTGEKUG VJGTGHQTG ,QJP 8 OQUV RTQDCDN[ YCU VJG OKPVKPI NQTF #U VJG TGNCVKQPU YKVJ *QNNCPF JCF DGGP UQWPF WR VQ VJG #TMGN 9CT VJG EQKPU YGTG RTQDCDN[ UVTWEM DGHQTG VJCV VKOG QVJGTYKUG OKPVKPI YQWNF JCXG DGGP UVCTVGF FWTKPI VJG #TMGN 9CT YJKEJ EQWNF QPN[ JCXG DGGP FQPG HQT NCEM QH OQPG[ JQYGXGT VJG EQKPU CTG VQQ KPUKIPKHKECPV HQT VJCV 8CP FGT %JKLU MPGY QH VJTGG FKHHGTGPV V[RGU

DGCTKPI VYQ FKHHGTGPV VGZVU #HVGT XCP FGT %JKLUʼn VJGTG JCXG DGGP PQ RWDNKUJGF UVWFKGU QP OKPVKPI D[ VJG .QTFU QH #TMGN

,#0 8 QH #4-'.

)TQQV *GWMGNQO .GGTFCO # 5JKGNF QH #TMGN /10 '6# 018# &' *1- 4 %TQUU /10 '6# 018# .+ XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 8CP FGT %JKLU TGCF VJG TGXGTUG CU /10'6# 018# .+ CPF GPVGTVCKPGF VJG QRVKQP .+ DWV VJGP JCF VQ CEMPQYNGFIG KVU KORQUUKDKNKV[ 6JG EQKP WPFGT EQPUKFGTCVKQP ENGCTN[ TGCFU .+ +U VJKU RQUUKDN[ C OKUVCMG KP VJG FKG UJQWNF KV JCXG DGGP .&! 6JCV YQWNF KPFKECVG .GGTFCO UGG CNUQ PQ # EQODKPCVKQP QH VJTGG RNCEGU KP QPG EQKP UGGOU RGEWNKCT #TMGN *GWMGNQO CPF .GGTFCO

)TQQV .GGTFCO # 5JKGNF QH #TMGN WPFGT JGNOGV +1J &' #4-'. 4 .QPI ETQUU /10 '6# 018# ¶ .& XF%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG C NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (QWPF KP 0GFGTJGOGTV <WKF 8CP FGT %JKLU OCMGU QWV CP J CV VJG GPF QH VJG TGXGTUG VGZV DWV KV ENGCTN[ TGCFU .&

348


)14+0%*'/ #HVGT VJG RTQXKPEGU QH *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF YJQ JCF TKUGP CICKPUV TQ[CN CWVJQTKV[ KP JCF UWEEGUUHWNN[ UVQQF VJGKT ITQWPF VJG 4GRWDNKE QH 7PKVGF 0GVJGTNCPFU ITCFWCNN[ EQPUQNK FCVGF 6JG XQNCVKNG UKVWCVKQP GPVKEGF OCP[ EKVKGU CPF PQDNGOGP VQ TGXKXG VJGKT JKUVQTKECNN[ LWUVKHKGF RTKXKNKIGU QH OKPV 6JWU VJG OKPV )QTKPEJGO GOGTIGF /KPVKPI UVCTVGF KP )QTKPEJGO KP YJCV UGGOGF C LWUVKHKGF OCPPGT VJG OCIKUVTCVG ITCPVGF UGXGTCN GZKNGU YJQ JCF NGIKVKOCVG ENCKOU VQ VJG TKIJV QH OKPV VQ GZGTEKUG VJGUG TKIJVU KP )QTKPEJGO 6JWU HTQO VQ VJG 2QTVWIWGUG &QP #PVQPKQ HTQO VQ VJG )TQPKPIGT 1OOGNCPFGP FKUVTKEVU UWTTQWPFKPI )TQPKPIGP CPF HTQO ! VQ VJG EQWPVU QH /GIGP OKPVGF /CTKG FG $TKOGW $WV QVJGT YC[U YGTG CNUQ UQWIJV VQ CXQKF FGRGPFGPEG QP VJG MKPI QH 2QTVWICN QT VJG EQWPVGUU QH /GIGP NGCFKPI VQ VJG KOKVCVKQPU QH VJG 4Q[CNU QH 'PINKUJ -KPI 'FYCTF +8 6JG 5GTQQUMGTMG JQCTF OQUV PQVCDN[ UJQYU VJG UKIPKHKECPEG QH VJGUG KOKVCVKQPU QH 'PIGNUG 4[CNU KP &WVEJ EKTEWNCVKQP 6JGTG CTG VYQ XCTKGVKGU VJG HKTUV KU C FKTGEV KOKVCVKQP QH VJG 4Q[CN VJG VGZVU CTG GZCEV EQRKGU GZEGRV HQT CP QEECUKQPCN HCWNV[ FKG CPF VJG UGEQPF VJCV XGT[ OQFGUVN[ FKURNC[U VJG #TMGN EQCV QH CTOU 8CP )GNFGT PQVGU VJCV VJKU UGEQPF XCTKGV[ YCU TCVJGT OCTIKPCN C OGODGT QH C FKUVCPV DTCPEJ .QTF ,QJP QH *GWMGNQO UVTWEM C PWODGT QH V[RGU YKVJ VJG #TMGN EQCV QH CTOU KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJCV YGTG KOOGFKCVGN[ DCPPGF CU EQWPVGTHGKVU 9G SWGUVKQP VJKU HQT )QTKPEJGO JCF NQPI DGGP RCTV QH #TMGN DGHQTG KV YCU CDCPFQPGF VQ )WGNFGTU CPF UWDUGSWGPVN[ VQ *QNNCPF 6JGTGHQTG VJGTG YCU C JKUVQT[ QH VKGU DGVYGGP #TMGN CPF )QTKPEJGO HTQO CRRTQZ VQ

#010;/175

+OKVCVKQP 4Q[CN 'FYCTF +8 # -KPI QP UJKR YKVJ ' QP HNCI '& ¿ ¿ 9#4& ¿ &+ ¿ )4# ¿ 4': ¿ #0). ¿ < ¿ $4# ¿ &05 ¿ 6+$ ¿ 4 5WP UWTTQWPFGF D[ NKU CPF ETQYPGF NGQRCTFU 6WFQT TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG ñ +*& ¿ #8 % ¿ 64#05+'05 ¿ 2'4 ¿ /'&+8/ ¿ +..148 ¿ +$#6 (D IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM DTQCF CPF YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG 5-# <Ã’TKEJ

349


#010;/175 YKVJ VJG CTOU QH #4-'.

+OKVCVKQP 4Q[CN 'FYCTF +8 # -KPI QP UJKR YKVJ ' QP HNCI UJKGNF QH #TMGN QP VJG HQTYCTF UVGXGP '&

* * 9#4& * &+ * )4# * 4': * #0). * < * (4#0 * &05 * +$ * 4 5WP UWTTQWPFGF D[ NKU CPF ETQYPGF NGQRCTFU 6WFQT TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG ñ +*& * #8% * 64#05+'05 * 2'4 * /'&+8/ * +..148 * +$#6 (D IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z &CFUQP EQNNGEVKQP 5RKPM #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM

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ʼnU TGCNO CPF CRRQKPVGF JKU UQP <YGPVKDQNF MKPI QH .QVJCTKPIKC KP VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZV ECNNGF .QTTCKPG PQV VJG UCOG CU VJG &WEJ[ QH .QTTCKPG HTQO R QP *G RTQXGF C YGCM CFXGTUCT[ VQ PQDKNKV[ NGF D[ )GTJCTF CPF /CPHTKF +P VJG -KPIFQO .QTTCKPG EGCUGF VQ GZKUV #TQWPF VJG &WEJ[ .QTTCKPG ECOG KPVQ DGKPI +V PGXGT JCF HKZGF DQTFGTU PQT YCU KV GXGT C WPKV[ KV YCU CP CTVKHKEKCN FWEJ[ +V TCVJGT UGTXGF CU VJG YGUV DWHHGT CICKPUV CVVCEMU QP VJG )GTOCP 4GCNO 6JG DGIKPPKPI RGTKQF YCU XGT[ EJCQVKE )GDJCTF YCU CRRQKPVGF FWMG QH .QTTCKPG D[ .QWKU VJG %JKNF #U UQQP CU JG FKGF KP DCVVNG CICKPUV VJG *WPICTKCPU # FWMGNGUU KPVGTKO GPUWGF +P VJG [GCTU DGVYGGP CPF %JCTNGU VJG 5KORNG TWNGF .QTTCKPG 9KVJKP PQDKNKV[ 4GIKPCT JCF RNC[GF CP KORQTVCPV RCTV 6JWU +V ECOG CU PQ UWTRTKUG VJCV JKU UQP )KUGNDGTV KP DGECOG FWMG QH .QTTCKPG #HVGT JKU FGCVJ KP UWEEGUUKQP YCU CU HQNNQYU *GPT[ FWMG QH $CXCTKC *GPT[ VJG UQP QH )KUGNDGTV CPF )GTDGTIG YJQ YCU UVKNN OKPQT KP YJKEJ RGTKQF 1VVQ YCU CUUQEKCVG FWMG %QPTCF VJG 4GF CPF HKPCNN[ VJG DTQVJGT QH 'ORGTQT 1VVQ + $TWPQ CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG 6JG NCVVGT PGXGT DQTG VJG VKVNG [GV JG FKF URNKV .QTTCKPG FGHKPKVKXGN[ KPVQ VYQ RCTVU KP 7RRGT CPF .QYGT .QTTCKPG 350


.19'4 .144#+0' 6JG HKTUV FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG YCU C EGTVCKP )QFHTG[ C UGTXCPV QH CTEJDKUJQR $TWPQ YJQ JQYGXGT JCF CRRTQXCN QH 'ORGTQT 1VVQ + VQ GZGTV HWNN FWECN RQYGT 6JG FWECN QHHKEG YCU PQV CNYC[U JGNF D[ TGCN FWMGU KV YCU QP CPF QHH JGNF D[ VJG GORGTQT JKOUGNH QT D[ UGTXCPVU QH JKU QT VJGTG YCU PQ FWMG CV CNN 6JWU VJG RGTKQF VQ UCY PQ TWNKPI FWMG 6JGP VYQ 9GUVHTCPMKUJ %CTQNKPIKCPU CRRGCTGF %JCTNGU + CPF JKU UQP 1VVQ (TQO VQ VJG FWECN UGCV YCU QPEG CICKP WPQEEWRKGF +P 'ORGTQT *GPT[ ++ TGUVQTGF FWECN FKIPKV[ 6JG EQPVGPV QH FWMGFQO YCU TGFGHKPGF CPF HKIWTGU ECRCDNG QH PGWVTCN RQNKVKEU YGTG UQWIJV HQT VJG QHHKEG 6JWU VJG %QWPVU QH 8GTFWP HTQO VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG YGTG EJQUGP EQPUGEWVKXG FWMGU QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG YGTG )QFHTG[ +

JKU DTQVJGT )QVJGNQ + JKU UGEQPF UQP )QVJGNQ ++ 'XGP VJQWIJ )QFHTG[ ++ HKTUV UQP QH )QVJGNQ + ENCKOGF FWMGFQO JG FKFPʼn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

)QFHTG[ YCU C ITGCVITCPFUQP QH .CODGTV EQWPV QH .GWXGP CPF )GTDGTIG +P JG YCU FGRQUGF HQT 9CNTCO +++ FWMG QH .KODWTI DWV KP )QFHTG[ 8 TGVWTPGF 6JG GPF ECOG YJGP )QFHTG[ 8++ FKGF KP 6JG VKOG JCF EQOG HQT C PGY CTTCPIGOGPV 6JG CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG ENCKOGF FWECN FKIPKV[ DWV (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC FGEKFGF QVJGT YKUG #V VJG *QHVCI PCVKQPCN QT KORGTKCN FKGV KP 5EJY·DKUEJ *CNN QP VJ QH 5GRVGODGT VJG FWEJ[ QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG YCU FGHKPKVKXGN[ FKUEQPVKPWGF # FGETGG YCU RCUUGF VJCV VJG UQP QH )QFHTG[ 8++ *GPTK + QH .GWXGP JQNF FWMGFQO QPN[ KP VJQUG VGTTKVQTKGU VJCV GHHGEVKXGN[ YGTG WPFGT JKU CWVJQTKV[ OGCPKPI VJG &WEJ[ $TCDCPV (TQO VJCV OQOGPV VJG VKVNG &WMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG YCU XQKF KV JQYGXGT YCU DQTPG C NQPI VKOG FWG VQ VJG CTEJCKE FKURQUKVKQP QH VJG FWMGU QH $TCDCPV )166(4+'& +

&GPKGT # $WUV T #PIGN V[RG )1&' 8(4+&85 4 $CTDCTK\GF 8KEVQTKC N YKVJ YTGCVJ NGIGPF PQV ENGCTN[ XKUKDNG 0/ KP GZGTIWG IT 44 2QUUKDN[ VJG QPN[ MPQYP URGEKOGP HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN &GURKVG CNN TGUGCTEJ PQDQF[ )TKGTUQP C Q JCU C ENWG CU VQ YJGTG VJKU EQKP UJQWNF DG RNCEGF 'ZRGTVU FQ CITGG VJCV KV KU QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG EQKPCIG +NKUEJ RTGUWOCDN[ C WPKSWG JG MPQYU QH PQ QVJGT URGEKOGP -NWIG CPF +NKUEJ CVVTKDWVG KV VQ )QFHTG[ + 5VKNN VJKU EQKP KU KPVTKIWKPI VJG GZGTIWG ENGCTN[ UJQYU 0 / )QFHTG[ ++ YKVJ VJG $GCTF JCF DGGP RCUUGF CV VJG FGOKUG QH JKU HCVJGT KP +P JG YCU KORTKUQPGF KP )KGDKEJGPUVGKP PGCT *CNNG HQT QRRQUKPI VJKU FGEKUKQP JG HCKNGF HQT NCEM QH UWRRQTV #V VJG FKGV KP #CEJGP VJ QH /C[ JG YCU TGNGCUGF CICKP TGVWTPKPI VQ JKU QHHKEG QH FWMG QH 7RRGT .QTTCKPG *GPT[ +++ CHVGT JKU KORGTKCN EQTQPCVKQP KP 4QOG KP ECORCKIPGF CICKPUV %QWPV &KTM QH *QNNCPF KP 5GRVGODGT 6JKU ECWUGF C OCLQT TGXQNV )QFHTG[ LQKPGF HQTEGU YKVJ $CNFYKP 8 QH (NCPFGTU CPF OCTEJGF CICKPUV 0KLOGIGP UGVVKPI HKTG VQ VJG RCNCVKPCVG 6JKU TCKUGU VJG SWGUVKQP QH YJGVJGT VJKU EQKP JCU CP[VJKPI VQ FQ YKVJ VJKU XKEVQT[ 6JG 8KEVQT[ KU C ENGCT UKIP CPF VJG NGVVGTU 0 / EQWNF CNNWFG VQ 0QXKQOCIWU VJCPMU VQ ,QU $GPFGTU HQT JKU ITGCV JGNR KP TGUGCTEJKPI *QYGXGT VJKU VJGQT[ TGOCKPU WPFQEWOGPVGF VJGTGHQTG VJG EQKP KU CVVTKDWVGF VQ )QFHTG[ + HQT VJG VKOG DGKPI EQPEWTTGPV YKVJ -NWIG CPF +NKUEJ

351


)1<'.1 +

&GPKGT *GTUVCN! # $WUV T YKVJ UEGRVTG 5%# /#4+# 4 &WMG T YKVJ UVCPFCTF TKPIU CV JKU HGGV )1< '.1 &8: &CPP IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z .CP\ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ &CPPGPDGTI OGPVKQPU RGNNGVU QP VJG TGXGTUG %JCNQP 4$0 R 2N :+ EQPUKFGTU *GTUVCN DGECWUG VJCV YCU RTQDCDN[ )QVJGNQʼnU RNCEG QH TGUKFGPEG CPF KVU OCKP EJWTEJ KU EQPUGETCVGF KP /CT[ʼnU JQPQT

)166(4+'& ++

&GPKGT /GTG # *GCF HCEKPI VJTGG RGNNGVU N )1&' (4+ &85 4 'FKHKEG DGVYGGP HQWT 8 U CPF % * YKVJKP /'4 ' %+8+6#5 &CPP -NWIG 5VQGUU # C D IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 6YQ TGEGPV RWDNKECVKQPU QP VJKU V[RG CTG 5VQGUU % /GTG EKXKVCU KP %QOOGPVCVKQPGU 0WOKUOCVKECG R CPF +NKUEJ 2 KP ,/2 R CPF &KG 5CNKGT D[ $ -NWIG YJQ FGXQVGU UQOG CVVGPVKQP VQ VJKU EQKP V[RG 0QPGVJGNGUU QRKPKQPU UVKNN FKHHGT +UUWGU CTG YJGTG YCU VJG OKPV CPF YJQ YCU KVU NQTF! 6JG OKPVKPI NQTF KU CUUWOGF VQ DG )QFHTG[ ++ VJG $GCTFGF *G YCU FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG KP VJG RGTKQF 6JGUG EQKPU JQYGXGT EQWNF PQV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM KP VJKU RGTKQF HQT UGXGTCN JQCTFU UJQY VJCV VJG QTKIKPU NKG DGHQTG $GHQTG VJKU FCVG .QYGT .QTTCKPG YCU PQV TWNGF D[ C )QFHTG[ 5VKNN KV KU NKMGN[ VJCV DGVYGGP CPF )QFHTG[ ++ KU FGUKIPCVGF (TGFGTKEM YCU KPFGGF FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG VQ VJCV VKOG DWV JG CPF )QFHTG[ YGTG VJGP ECNNGF EQPEWTTGPVKDWU .QVJCTKPIKU 6JKU YQWNF CNUQ GZRNCKP VJG HCEV VJCV VJG EQKPU FKURNC[ PQ FXZ 6JG YGKIJV QH VJKU V[RG XCTKGU DGVYGGP CPF CU HQWPF KP VJG CRRTCKUCN QH 5VQGUU QH URGEKOGPU 6JKU YGKIJV KPFKECVGU (TKGUNCPF )TQPKPIGP +PKVKCNN[ &CPPGPDGTI GV CN EQPUKFGTGF /GGT D[ 0GWUU NCVGT VJQWIJ *QQHV QH +FFGMKPIG (TKGUNCPF GP VJG (TKG\GP UWIIGUVGF .GGT KP 'CUV (TKUKC 2NCEGU YKVJ VJG PCOG /GTG QT UQOGVJKPI UKOKNCT CTG PWOGTQWU JQYGXGT VJG CHQTGOGPVKQPGF /GGT CU YGNN CU .GGT CTG QWV QH VJG SWGUVKQP DGECWUG QH VJGKT NQECVKQP +NKUEJ CFJGTGU VQ DGVYGGP +,UUGNOGGT CPF 'OU 5VQGUU CTTKXGU CV VJG EQCUVCN TGIKQP YGUV QH VJG &QNNCTV VGTTKVQT[ (KXGNIQ CPF *WPUKPIQ )TQNNG FKUCITGGU YKVJ 5VQGUUʼn CVVTKDWVKQP +PVGTGUVKPI KU *QQHV QH +FFGMKPIGʼn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

352


&GPKGT /GTG # *GCF HCEKPI )1& '(4 +&85 4 'FKHKEG YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU /'4' %+8+6#5 &CPP XCT 5VQGUU $ C IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

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

722'4 .144#+0'

6JG VGTTKVQT[ QH 7RRGT .QTTCKPG GPEQORCUUGF C NCTIG PWODGT QH EQWPVKGU NKMG $CT 5CCTDTÒEMGP #RT¾OQPV CPF QVJGTU CPF VJG VJTGG FKQEGUGU /GV\ 8GTFWP CPF 6QWN 6JG FWMGU QH 7RRGT .QTTCKPG YGTG PGXGT UKIPKHKECPV VJG[ MGRV VQ TGUQNXKPI TGIKQPCN EQPHNKEVU (TQO VJG FKXKUKQP KP QP VJG EQWPVU QH $CT DQTG VJG FWECN VKVNG (TGFGTKEM + JKU UQP &KGVTKEJ CPF JKU UQP (TGFGTKEM ++ &WTKPI VJG RGTKQF VQ VJG FWMGU )QVJGNQ + CPF )QFHTG[ ++ QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG CNUQ DQTG VJG FWECN VKVNG KP 7RRGT .QTTCKPG +P 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +++ CRRQKPVGF #FCNDGTV HTQO VJG *QWUG 'N\CU FWMG TGUVTKEVKPI JKU VGTTKVQT[ VQ RTGUGPV FC[ .QTTCKPG UGG WPFGT 'N\CU .QTTCKPG &+'64+%* +

&GPKGT # )TGCV 5 DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU &' 1&'4+% 85 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 5%5 & '1&# &CPP IT 44 %QTTQFGF CPF ENGCPGF URGEKOGP HTQO C JQCTF HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ &CPPGPDGTI IKXGU VJG NGIGPFU &'1&'4+% 5%5 &'1&#

&GPKGT #PFGTPCEJ # 5EGRVTG DGVYGGP VYQ DGCTFGF DWUVU 6* '1&'4+% 85 &8: 4 1RGP ETQUU YKVJ VYQ CPEJQTU CPF VYQ VTKSWGVTCU KP VJG CPINGU ETQUU UJCRGF #0&'4 0#-# %0) &CPP -NWIG IT 44 7PEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ (TQO (TCPMHWTVGT /ÒP\JCPFNWPI #WEVKQP PQ 6JG UEGRVTG DGVYGGP VJG JGCFU KU ECNNGF ō2CNOGVVGPUVCDŋ YKVJ -NWIG 9JQ VJGUG DWUVU FGRKEV KU WPENGCT 0WOGTQWU PCOGU JCXG DGGP UWIIGUVGF UGG &CPPGPDGTI R &CPPGPDGTI JKOUGNH UWTOKUGU VJG GORGTQT CPF VJG FWMG

353


/#4)4#8+#6' QH #069'42'0 +P 'ORGTQT 1VVQ GNGXCVGF #PVYGTR VQ OCTITCXKCVG #PVYGTR DGECOG C ECUVTWO +P VJG VJ VJ EGPVWT[ #PVYGTRGP LWUV CU $TWUUGNU UGG WPFGT %JCRKVTG VJG $TWZGNNGU DGNQPIGF VQ VJG FKQEGUG %CODTCK +P VJG EQWTUG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ #PVYGTR DGECOG RQTVWU QT GORQTKWO 6JTQWIJQWV VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG FWMGU QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG HTQO VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG JGNF UYC[ QXGT VJG OCTITCXKCVG #PVYGTR +P 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +8 ITCPVGF #PVYGTR VQ )QFHTG[ + QH .GWXGP YJQ WPKVGF KV YKVJ JKU QYP GUVCVG

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING l .8&188 +%8 5 +/ 2 '4 4 6YQ USWCTGU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU YKVJKP CPF /10'6# DGVYGGP VJGO #0688'42'05+5 &CPP C *CV\ $ 8CPJQWFV ( IT 4 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QVJGTYKUG GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

)QTP[ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU V[RG KU GZVGPUKXGN[ FGUETKDGF KP 8 *CV\ #PVYGTRGPGT 2T·IWPIGP CWU FGP UEJYGFKUEJGP /ÒP\HWPFG FGT 9KMKPIGT\GKV KP .#)1/ R 1H VJKU ITQWR $ CNN *CV\ MPQYU QH PKPG UJQY C KPUVGCF QH C UWP DQNF RGNNGV YKVJ HKXG TC[U *CV\ FKUVKPIWKUJGU V[RGU CPF JCU PQV [GV CEEQORNKUJGF FGVGTOKPKPI VJG GZCEV FCVGU /KPVKPI UVCTVGF CTQWPF -NWIG UJQYU VYQ *CV\ V[RG ENGCTN[ FKURNC[KPI VJG PCOG QH 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +8 CPF *CV\ V[RG CP CPQP[OQWU

%17065 QH .'78'0

.GWXGP KU VJG EGPVTG QH VJG EQWPVU QH .GWXGP 6JG HKTUV QPG KU %QWPV .CODGTV + YJQ YCU EQWPV QH .GWXGP KP VJG FKUVTKEV QH $TCDCPV 6JG F[PCUV[ EQPVKPWGF WPVKN VJG ITGCVITCPF UQP QH .CODGTV + )QFHTG[ 8 KP DGECOG FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG 6JG *QWUG QH .GWXGP YCU PQY TGPWOGTCVGF )QFHTG[ 8 DGECOG )QFHTG[ + 9KVJ VJG FGOKUG QH )QFHTG[ 8++ +++ KP .QYGT .QTTCKPG CU C EQWPV[ GPFGF UGG WPFGT .QTTCKPG CPF JKU UQP *GPT[ + DGECOG FWMG KP C VGTTKVQT[ VJCV DGECOG MPQYP CU VJG &WEJ[ $TCDCPV 6JG EQWPVU *GPT[ VJG 'NFGT 1VVQ CPF .CODGTV ++ CPF VJG FWMGU )QFHTG[ + VQ +++ EQKPGF +P VJG NKVGTCVWTG VJG EQKPU KP VJG PCOG QH )QFHTG[ + VQ +++ CTG KPXCTKCDN[ ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT $TCDCPV 9G CFJGTGF VQ C ENCUUKHKECVKQP WPFGT .GWXGP DGECWUG *GPT[ + UQP QH )QFHTG[ +++ YCU VJG HKTUV VQ DG CNNQYGF VQ ECNN JKOUGNH &WMG QH $TCDCPV UGG WPFGT $TCDCPV 6JG HQNNQYKPI SWQVG VCMGP HTQO VJG .GZKMQP FGU /KVVGNCNVGTU ++ R VTCPUNCVGF RTQXKFGU CP QXGTXKGY QH VJG FGXGNQROGPV 9JGP VJG EQWPVU QH .GWXGP WNVKOCVGN[ CUUWOGF VJG .QYGT .QTTCKPKCP FWECN FKIPKV[ KV YCU PQ NQPIGT CVVCEJGF VQ C OQPQRQNKUVKE ENCKO VQ VJG TCPM QH FWMG KP VJG .QYGT .QTTCKPG TGIKQP )QFHTG[ 8+ YQWNF QEECUKQPCNN[ DG TGHGTTGF VQ CU &WMG QH .GWXGP DGHQTG JG YCU CRRQKPVGF UWEJ CPF VJG .KODWTIGTU CHVGT YGTG KPKVKCNN[ TGHGTTGF VQ CU FWMGU QH VJG #TFGPPGU NCVGT CU FWMGU QH .KODWTI 6JCV KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG QNF FWECVWU TGIPK *NQVCTKK YCU PQ NQPIGT TGICTFGF CU C NGICN DCUKU HQT VJG RQYGT QH VJG .QYGT .QTTCKPG F[PCUVKGU YCU GZRTGUUGF KP VJG VKVNGU QH VJG FWMGU QH VJG *QWUG .GWXGP +PKVKCNN[ VJG FWZ .QVJCTKPIKC TGEGKXGF VJG CFFGPFWO EQOGU VJGP FWZ .QXCPKCG CPF GXGPVWCNN[ KP FWZ $TCDCPVKCG 9JCV RGTUWCFGF VJG FWMGU VQ CNVGT VJGKT VKVNG JCU PQV DGGP EQPXKPEKPIN[ GUVCDNKUJGF [GV *'04; NG 8+'7: 1661

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING +++188+%856++6 4 /10'6# TGVTQITCFG KP VJG HKGNF DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU $48: %'..' &CPP -NWIG 8CPJQWFV ( IT 4 (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 6JG $48:%'..' QP VJG TGXGTUG KU DCTGN[ XKUKDNG +P CNN QVJGT TGURGEVU KV KU C OCVEJ &CPPGPDGTI R CVVTKDWVGU VJKU V[RG VQ 'ORGTQT %QPTCFʼnU ++ FC[U %QOOGPV KP -NWIG &KG 5CNKGT R ō#WU $TÒUUGN MGPPGP YKT GKPG TGNCVKX WOHCPITGKEJG KP UR·VQVVQPKUEJGT <GKV DGIKPPGPFG 5GTKG PCEJ -ÌNPGT 8QTDKNF FKG FWTEJ FGP OGKUV GPVUVGNNVGP 1TVUPCOGP JKPN·PINKEJ IGUKEJGTV KUV CDGT MGKPG /ÒP\JGTTGP PGPPV #NU UQNEJG JCV OCP FKG )TCHGP XQP .ÌYGP CPIGPQOOGP )GUKEJGTV KUV FKGU MGKPGUYGIU

'PIGN CPF 5GTTWTG R &KG 5GTKG KUV UVTWMVWTGNN FGT ·NVGTGP #PVYGTRGPGT 2T·IGRJCUG XGTYCPFV &GT VGKNYGKUG 4ÒEMITKHH CWH FKG CWU FGP MÌPKINKEJGP /ÒP\UV·VVGP #PVYGTRGP WPF &QTVOWPF DGMCPPVG .8&188+%85 +/2 .GIGPFG MÌPPVG HÒT FGP -ÌPKI CNU /ÒP\JGTTP URTGEJGP

354


)166(4+'& ++ +++

&GPKGT # *GCF YKVJ JGNOGV T &8 : )'1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING *. F9 8CPJQWFV IT 4 0KEG RCVKPC C NKVVNG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

&GPKGT # *GCF YKVJ JGNOGV T &8: )16 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING NGIGPF PQV XKUKDNG F9 8CPJQWFV IT 4 8GT[ HKPG X F &WUUGP 9GUVGTJQH #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

&GPKGT # &TCIQP 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ ETQUUGU CPF VYQ TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU / / / / F9 2N # 8CPJQWFV IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 6KGVLGP *CODWTI #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

%*#26'4 QH $47:'..'5 +P .CODGTV ++ EQWPV QH .GWXGP HQWPFGF C EQNNGIKCN EJWTEJ KP VJG JQPQWT QH 5V )WFWNC 6Q [KGNF TGXGPWGU VJG EJCRVGT KUUWGF EQKPU +P C EJCTVGT QH .KGVDGTVʼnU DKUJQR QH %CODTCK QH KP HCXQWT QH VJG %QNNGIKCNG QH 5CKPVG )WFWNC VJG FGUETKRVKQP $48%5'..'05+5 /10'6# KU HQWPF VQQ

&GPKGT CDQWV # %TQUU YKVJ VYQ VTKSWGVTCU CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU +16) '485 /526 4 %TQUU UJCRGF $481% '5..# YKVJ 5 ) ' 2 KP VJG CPINGU &CPP -NWIG IT 44 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ +16)'475 /526 1VIGTKWU /QPGVCTKWU 5CPEVCG 2CVTQPCG 5)'2 5CPEVC )WFWNC 'EENGUKCG 2CVTQPC 5GG 4$0 2N -NWIG &KG 5CNKGT R EQPUKFGTU VJG PCOG ō1VIGTWUŋ CU OQPG[GT WPUWHHKEKGPVN[ FQEWOGPVGF -NWIG JQYGXGT RC[U PQ CVVGPVKQP VQ VJG NGVVGTU KP VJG CPINGU /526

355


&7%*; $4#$#06 $TCDCPV CPF (NCPFGTU FKHHGTGF KP VYQ UKIPKHKECPV CURGEVU $TCDCPV YCU C HKGH QH VJG )GTOCP ETQYP (NCPFGTU QH VJG (TGPEJ ETQYP #RCTV HTQO VJCV $TCDCPV ECOG HTQO VJG FWEJ[ QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG CPF TGVCKPGF VJG UVCVWU QH FWEJ[ YJGTGCU (NCPFGTU JCF CNYC[U DGGP C EQWPV[ 6JG[ JCF C ITGCV KPHNWGPEG QP GCEJ QVJGTʼnU FGXGNQROGPV 6JG QTKIKPU QH VJG FKUVTKEV $TCDCPV CTG UJTQWFGF KP FCTMPGUU +V KU C VGTTKVQT[ QP VJG QWVUMKTVU QH VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG CPF C RCTV QH VJG FWEJ[ .QYGT .QTTCKPG VJCV YCU CNUQ OCTMGF D[ KPFKUVKPEV DQTFGTU 6JG EQWPVU QH .GWXGP JQYGXGT YGTG FKUVKPEVN[ CEVKXG KP VJKU VGTTKVQT[ 9JGP KP VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ VJG *QWUG .GWXGP KP .QYGT .QTTCKPG VJKU EQOKVCN HCOKN[ ECOG YKVJKP TGCEJ QH VJG FWECN VKVNG 'ORGTQT *GPT[ 8 VJGP DGUVQYGF VJG FWECN VKVNG QP )QFHTG[ %QWPV QH .GWXGP YJKEJ YCU PQV TGCNN[ UKIPKHKECPV DWV FKF CHHQTF )QFHTG[ VJG OCTITCXKCVG #PVYGTR 6JG VKVNG YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF KP D[ 'ORGTQT %QPTCF DWV CU C FWECN VKVNG JCF CNUQ DGGP ITCPVGF KP .KODWTI VJKU QPN[ CFFGF VQ VJG EQPHWUKQP 9JGP 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC HKPCNN[ FGENCTGF VJG FWEJ[ .QYGT .QTTCKPG XQKF KP VJG &WEJ[ $TCDCPV ECOG KPVQ GHHGEV CPF *GPT[ + YCU KVU HKTUV FWMG VJWU )QFHTG[ ++ +++ CTG EQPUKFGTGF VJG NCUV EQWPVU QH .GWXGP 6JG FWMGU QH $TCDCPV QVJGTYKUG PGXGT TGPQWPEGF VJGKT NGIKVKOCVG VKVNG CHVGT VJG CESWKUKVKQP QH .KODWTI KV EQPUKUVGPVN[ YCU KP (TGPEJ 0 0 RCT NC IT³EG FG &KGW FWE FG .QVJKGT FG $TCDCPV GV FG .KODWTI GV OCTSWKU FW UCKPV 'ORKTG KP YJKEJ VJG VKVNG OCTSWKU TGHGTTGF VQ VJG OCTITCXKCVG QH #PVYGTR VJCV YCU KPEQTRQTCVGF KP $TCDCPV KP HTQO .F/ ++ R 6JKU *QWUG EQPVKPWGF WPKPVGTTWRVGF WPVKN YJGP ,GCP +++ FKGF YKVJQWV C OCNG JGKT *KU FCWIJVGT ,GCPPG YCU OCTTKGF VQ 9GPEGUNCU QH .WZGODQWTI CPF JG CEEGFGF VQ VJG $TCDCPV VJTQPG VJG DGIKPPKPI QH .WZGODQWTI NKPGCIG KP $TCDCPV ,GCPPG FKGF KP YKVJQWV KUUWG 6JG FWEJ[ FGXQNXGF VQ VJG ITCPFUQP QH ,GCPPGʼnU UKUVGT #PVQKPG QH $WTIWPF[ YJQ YQWNF JCXG VYQ UWEEGUUQTU JKU UQPU ,GCP +8 CPF 2JKNKR 5V 2CWN CHVGT YJKEJ VJG FWEJ[ YQWNF FGHKPKVKXGN[ RCUU VQ VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO 2JKNKR VJG )QQF (QT VJG RGTKQF HTQO QP UGG $WTIWPFKCP 0GVJGTNCPFU %NCUUKHKECVKQP WPVKN YCU FQPG CNQPI VJG NKPGU QH , )JKLUUGPUʼn 'UUCK FG ENCUUGOGPV EJTQ PQNQIKSWG FGU OQPPCKGU DTCDCPEQPPGU $TWUUGNU P F 6JG *QWUG QH .GWXGP *'04+ + *GPT[ + UVCTVGF GZRCPFKPI GCUVYCTF VQ EQPVTQN VJG TQWVG HTQO %QNQIPG VQ VJG UGC KP RCTVKEWNCT +P *GPT[ LQKPGF VJG 9GNHU JQYGXGT YJGP VJGKT UVCT DGICP HCNNKPI JG EJCPIGF UKFGU VQ VJG 5VCWHGTU +P TGVWTP JG TGEGKXGF VJG KORGTKCN TKIJVU VQ /CCUVTKEJV $WV YJGP 2JKNKR QH 5YCDKC YCU CUUCUUKPCVGF KP *GPT[ VWTPGF DCEM VQ VJG 9GNHU .K½IG TGOCKPGF *GPT[ʼnU OCKP CFXGTUCT[ VJGTGHQTG JG EJQUG VQ TGLQKP VJG 5VCWHGTU KP #U VJKU RTQXGF WPUWEEGUUHWN JG EJCPIGF DCEM VQ VJG 9GNHU DWV VJG[ NQUV RTQORVKPI *GPT[ VQ FKTGEVN[ TGEQPEKNKCVG YKVJ VJG XKEVQTU *GPT[ EQPUKFGTGF JKOUGNH VJG NGCFGT QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG CPF JG YCU UW\GTCKP VQ .KODWTI 0COWT *QNNCPF )GNTG COQPI QVJGT RNCEGU

&GPKGT # $WUV N YKVJ JGNOGV CPF DCPPGT . CDQXG & 8 : 4 .KQP T QXGT DTCPEJ . ' 1 CDQXG F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN RTGUGTXGF XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG X #NUGPQ[ #PVYGTRGP #WEVKQP PQ +V KU PQV KORQUUKDNG VJCV RTGEGFKPI VJG . YKVJ VJG UVTQMG VJGTG YCU CP * 6JCV YQWNF CEMPQYNGFIG CVVTKDWVKQP VQ *GPT[ + 8 F %JKLU TGCFU VJG . CU VJG HKTUV NGVVGT QH .QTTCKPG 5VTWEM DGHQTG

356


&GPKGT #PVYGTRGP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UYQTF T QXGT ETQUU QH HQWT RGNNGVU & 8 : 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ C NKPG KP GCEJ NKOD CPF HQWT RGNNGVU YKVJ TKPI KP GCEJ CPING F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5VTWEM CHVGT

&GPKGT # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UYQTF T ETQUU QH HQWT RGNNGVU DGHQTG VJG JQTUG 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ UVTKRGF NKODU CPF QPG UOCNN CPF ITGCV TKPI KP GCEJ CPING F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

-Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ 'Z /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP NKUV (GDTWCT[ PQ 5VTWEM CHVGT

&GPKGT # .COD YKVJ HNCI 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ TKPI CPF RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU CPF VJTGG UVTKRGU GPFKPI KP RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 5VTWEM CHVGT &G 9KVVG CPF 8CPJQWFV UVKNN CVVTKDWVG VJKU VQ 6KTNGOQPV

&GPKGT # 6JTGG VQYGTU 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ RGNNGV CPF TKPI KP VYQ CPINGU CPF RGNNGV YKVJ TQUGVVGU KP VYQ CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM CHVGT &G 9KVVG CPF 8CPJQWFV UVKNN CVVTKDWVG VJKU VQ 8KNXQQTFG

&GPKGT *GTUVCN # *GCF T YKVJ JGNOGV CPF UYQTF * '0 % 4 6QYGT DGPGCVJ VTGG F9 8CPJQWFV IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN &G 9KVVG EQPUKFGTGF /CCUVTKEJV HQT KVU OKPV JG VQQM VJG VQYGT HQT QPG QH VJG VQYGTU KP VJG EKV[ YCNNU VJCV YGTG LWUV DGKPI TGUVQTGF CV VJG VKOG QH OKPVKPI EJCTVGT

357


*'04+ ++ +++

&GPKGT $TWUUGN # 6QYGT 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ UVTKRGU 6 CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT #PVYGTRGP # %CUVNG DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ VJTGG NKPGU KP VYQ CPINGU CPF # 0 KP VJG QVJGT CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN # 0 #PVYGTRGP 6JG ECUVNG KU VJG UVKNKUGF XGTUKQP QH VJG QNF #PVYGTR ECUVNG

&GPKGT #PVYGTRGP # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ VYQ TKPIU CPF VYQ DTCPEJGU KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

0WO -TKPI 4QVVGTFCO

&GPKGT #PVYGTRGP # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ UVTKRGU CPF 1 . ' 3 KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN &G 9KVVG TGCF VJG NGVVGTU CU )+.1 QT )1.+

&GPKGT $TWUUGN # 'CING N YKVJ ETGUEGPV CDQXG T 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ 6 ' 0 + KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ /KPVOCUVGT 6'0+ GTWU

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

0QDKNKU 8KFWC CPF DGNQPIU VQ VJG UCOG ITQWR KP O[ QRKPKQP &G 9KVVG ENCUUKHKGU VJGUG WPFGT #NGKFC QH $WTIWPF[ CPF )JKLUUGPU WPFGT *GPT[ ++ GV +++ .GWXGP

&GPKGT .QWXCKP # .KQP T KP UJKGNF * &8 %+5 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ $ # 5 6 KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN /KPVOCUVGT $#56 KPWU

358


&GPKGT .QWXCKP # .KQP N KP UJKGNF * &8 %+5 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ $ # 5 6 KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

&GPKGT .QWXCKP # .KQP N KP UJKGNF 8 0 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ $ # 5 6 KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 1P VJG QDXGTUG 0 8 0QDKNKU 8KFWC

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ʼnV UVTWEM WPVKN

UGG PQ I DWV VQ C NQYGT UVCPFCTF VJCP VJG EQKP OQFGNKPI I

'UVGTNKP # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP QH $TCDCPV &8: $4#$#06+' 4 &QWDNGF ETQUU YKVJ 9 # . 6 KP VJG CPINGU Z + &'+ )4#6+# Z F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN (TQO HKPF #NMGP /KPVOCUVGT 9#.6 GTWU 5VTWEM HTQO QP

#PIG $TWZGNNGU # #TEJCPIGN /KEJCGN UVCPFKPI YKVJ NCPEG CPF VJTGG PCKNU /10'6# ” $47:'..'0%+5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU +1*#00'5 ” &8: ” $4#$#06+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN (TQO HKPF #NMGP PQ 5VTWEM HTQO QP

0CKNU HTQO VJG ETQUU QP YJKEJ ,GUWU %JTKUV FKGF 359


&GPKGT # .KQP QH $TCDCPV N 4 %TQUU YKVJ + & 8 : KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 5VTWEM HTQO QP

&GPKGT .GWXGP # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP QH $TCDCPV Z +& 8: 4 %TQUU YKVJ . 1 8 # KP VJG CPINGU F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 5VTWEM HTQO QP *GTG Z KPUVGCF QH Z CU KP &G 9KVVG CPF KP )JKLUUGPU

)TQU $TWZGNNGU # %CUVNG QH $TCDCPV /10'6# ¶ $48:'.ʼn YKVJKP CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI VJTGG RGNNGVU 4 $4#$#06+' ¶ &8: CTQWPF ETQUU 01/'0 ¶ &1/+0+ ¶ 01564+ ¶ 5+6 ¶ $'0'&+% 68/ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN VTCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 6GZV TGXGTUG $NGUUGF DG VJG PCOG QH QWT .QTF 5VTWEM HTQO QP &G 9KVVG CVVTKDWVGF VJKU UVKNN VQ ,GCP ++ )JKLUUGPU DCUKPI QP JQCTFU VQ ,GCP + DWV URGEKHKECNN[ PQVGU EQPVKPWCVKQP FW ITQU CW EJ³VGN GPVTG UQWU ,GCP ++

'UVGTNKP # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ TQUGU Q + Q &8: Q .+/$84)+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING &8: $4#$#06+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT %NGCPGF CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG

'UVGTNKP # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ TQUGU ” + ” &8: ” .+/$84)+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING &8: $4#$#06+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

$QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F 5VTWEM CHVGT +P .KODWTI YCU EQPSWGTGF CPF JGPEGHQTVJ VJG VKVNG &XZ .KODWTI YCU DQTPG 6JG KPVGTRWPEVKQP KU FKHHGTGPV HTQO PQ

)NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 0QDNG EQNNGEVKQP #WUVTCNKC 6JG KPVGTRWPEVKQP KU FKHHGTGPV HTQO PQ 6JG JCKT CPF VJG EJCRGN FG TQUGU CTG GPVKTGN[ FKHHGTGPV HTQO PQ

360


,'#0 ++ ,GCP ++ YCU OCTTKGF VQ CP 'PINKUJ RTKPEGUU /CTICTGV QH ;QTM FCWIJVGT QH -KPI 'FYCTF + QH 'PINCPF YJKEJ NGF VQ EQPHNKEVU YKVJ (TCPEG CPF 'PINCPF 1P VJG VJ 5GRVGODGT KP JKU NCUV FC[U JG FGETGGF VJG %JCTVGT QH -QTVGPDGTI

EQORCTCDNG VQ VJG /CIPC %CTVC VJCV JGTCNFGF VJG PGY HQTO QH UVCVG # EQWPEKN YCU KPUVCNNGF

%QWPEKN QH -QTVGPDGTI VJCV GZGTVGF CP GZVGPUKXG EQPVTQN QP VJG IQXGTPOGPV QH VJG FWMGU

'UVGTNKP #PVYGTRGP # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG NKQPU QH $TCDCPV N CPF .KODWTI T &8: $4#$ #06+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QOGIC KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# #06 882 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ 5VTWEM HTQO QP

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ʼn 9CT KP VJG .QY %QWPVTKGU ,GCP UGK\GF /GEJGNGP YJKEJ YCU C (NGOKUJ RQUUGUUKQP .QWKU QH /CGNG DGKPI OCTTKGF VQ QPG QH ,GCPʼnU FCWIJVGTU EQWNF PQV DWV TGNKPSWKUJ 'ORGTQT .QWKU QH $CXCTKC ITCPVGF ,GCP +++ VJG TKIJV VQ UVTKMG IQNF EQKPU +P ,GCP +++ UKIPGF CP CITGGOGPV YKVJ )WKNNCWOG + QH *QNNCPF CPF *CKPCWV ō6GP LCGT DGUNQQV ,QJP FGP +++ OGV 9KNNGO )TCGXG QH *GPGIQWY CPF *QNNCPF VG FQGP OCMGP GGPG OWPV FKG KP JWPPG YGFGT\[FUEJG QPFGTJQQTKIG NCPFGP \QWFG NQQR JGDDGP ŋ +P VJG [GCT ,QJP +++ FGEKFGF VQ OCPWHCEVWTG C EQKP YKVJ %QWPV 9KNNKCO QH *QNNCPF CPF *CKPCWV VJCV YQWNF EKTEWNCVG KP VJG NCPFU WPFGT VJGKT TGURGEVKXG UYC[ 1TFKPCPEG VJ ,CPWCT[ CPF KP YKVJ .QWKU FG %TGE[ QH (NCPFGTU ō6GP LCGTG YKGTFʼnGT QO OGGT IGOCM FGU MQQRJCPFGNU KP ʼnV XGTDCPF VWUUGP 8NCGPFGTGP CPF $TCDCPV DGUNQQVGP QH GGPG IGOGPG OWPV VG OCGMGP XQQT FG\G VYGG XQQTU NCPFGPŋ +P VJG [GCT VJG OCPWHCEVWTG QH C OWVWCN EQKP YCU FGEKFGF WRQP VQ CEEQOQFCVG VTCFG DGVYGGP (NCPFGTU CPF $TCDCPV OKPVGF KP )GPV CPF .GWXGP 6JG VJTGG UQPU QH ,GCP +++ CNN FKGF DGHQTG JG FKF *G VJGTGHQTG CRRQKPVGF JKU QNFGUV FCWIJVGT ,QJCPPC JGKTGUU *QYGXGT JG TGXQMGF VJKU FGEKUKQP CV VJG TGSWGUV QH .QWKU QH /CGNG YJQ YCU CHVGT CNN OCTTKGF VQ JKU [QWPIGUV FCWIJVGT

'UVGTNKP $TWZGNNGU # %CUVNG QH $TCDCPV + &8: &' $4#$#06+# 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# $48 :'.ʼn F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM HTQO QP #V FG 9KVVG WPFGT ,GCP ++

361


&GOK ITQU $TWUUGN # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG CTOU QH $TCDCPV UV CPF VJ HKGNF CPF .KODWTI PF CPF TF HKGNF /10'6# $48:'.0 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU +1*#00'5 &8: $4#$#06+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #WIWUV PQ 5+)08/ %48%+5 5KIP QH VJG ETQUU 5VTWEM KP #V FG 9KVVG WPFGT ,GCP ++

'UVGTNKP .GWXGP # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG CTOU QH $TCDCPV UV CPF VJ HKGNF CPF .KODWTI PF CPF TF HKGNF YKVJKP DTCPEJGU +1*'5 „ &8: „ $4#$# „ '6 „ .'/$ 4 .KPGF ETQUU YKVJ . 1 8 # KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# „ 018# „ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

'UVGTNKP .GWXGP # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG CTOU QH $TCDCPV UV CPF VJ HKGNF CPF .KODWTI PF CPF TF HKGNF YKVJKP DTCPEJGU &8: $4#$#06+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# „ .18#0+'5 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF

'UVGTNKP $TWZGNNGU # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJG CTOU QH $TCDCPV UV CPF VJ HKGNF CPF .KODWTI PF CPF TF HKGNF YKVJKP DTCPEJGU &8: $4#$#06+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# „ $48:'..'0 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM KP

362


)TQU #PVYGTRGP # /10'6# Z #0&92 CTQWPF ECUVNG QH $TCDCPV YKVJKP CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU 4 +1*ʼn Z $4#$#0 Z &8: CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT +TTGIWNCT HNCP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 4GXGTUG NGIGPF 2TCKUGF DG VJG PCOG QH )QF QWT .QTF ,GUWU %JTKUV 5VTWEM /C[ 6JGTG KU CNYC[U OGPVKQP QH C ōECUVNGŋ TGHGTKPI VQ VJG 6QWT ECUVNG QP VJG ITQU VQWTPQKU JQYGXGT VJG VYQ HNCPMKPI VQYGTU ENGCTN[ DGCT C ETQUU 9QWNFPʼnV C EJWTEJ JCXG VQ DG EQPUKFGTGF!

)TQU #PVYGTRGP # /10'6# Z #0&92 CTQWPF ECUVNG QH $TCDCPV YKVJKP CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU 4 +1* Z $4#$#0 Z &8: CTQWPF ECUVNG QH $TCDCPV $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ +*8 ¶ :2+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 4QOWPV 4QGTOQPF 5VTWEM /C[

%JCKUG F QT #PVYGTRGP # 'ORGTQT UKVVKPI QP IQVJKE VJTQPG YKVJ UJKGNF FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING .8&18+%85 ” &'+ )4# 41/#0148/ ” +/2 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 F9 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6GZV TGXGTUG %JTKUV EQPSWGTU %JTKUVWU TGKIPU %JTKUVWU TWNGU 0KEGRJQTWU 8+++ ō.CWFKU 4GIKCGŋ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

&GOK ITQU $TWZGNNGU # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI /10'6# Z $48:'..'05+5 4 5+) 08/ %48 %+5 CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING $0&+%68 5+6 01/'0 &0+ 04+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM KP 1EVQDGT

363


&GOK ITQU #PVYGTRGP # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI /10'6# Z 04# Z #069'42 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/'0 ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 +TTGIWNCT GFIG XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 04# KU VJG UJQTVGPKPI QH 01564# 5VTWEM KP 1EVQDGT 8CP FGT %JKLU UWIIGUVU CP CUUQEKCVG OKPV YKVJ 'PINKUJ -KPI 'FYCTF +++ *G UVC[GF QP VJG EQPVKPGPV HQT VJTGG [GCTU CPF CNNKGF YKVJ VJG FWMG QH $TCDCPV CPF JKU UKUVGT #NGQPQTC YGFFGF &WMG 4GIKPCNF +++ QH )GNTG &G 9KVVG UGEQPFU VJKU

)TQU FG EQORCIPQP # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP Ö /10'6# Å¡ $4#$#0 4 Z .1 &8: .16 $4#$ CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM &GEGODGT 6JKU KU VJG HKTUV VKOG C FWMG QH $TCDCPV ECNNU JKOUGNH &8: .16 JCTKPIKCG CICKP

)TQU FG EQORCIPQP # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP Ö /10'6# $4#$#0 4 Z +1 &8: .16 $4#$ CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 5+6 01/' &0+ 04+ +*8 :2 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 5VTWEM &GEGODGT

&GOK ITQU # 5JKGNF QH $TCDCPV UV CPF VJ HKGNF CPF .KODWTI PF CPF TF HKGNF KP OWNVKNQDG /10'6# „ 018# „ 4#$#06+' 4 5#%4+ +*2'40 CTQWPF ETQUU + .16 ¶ $4#$ ¶ .'/$ ¶ &8: ¶ #0%+1 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JG $ QH $4#$#06+' KU OKUUKPI 5VTWEM 1EVQDGT 6JGUG EQKPU YGTG OCFG QH KPHGTKQT OCVGTKCN CPF VJGP EQCVGF YKVJ UKNXGT 6JKU EQCV JCU YQTP QHH EQORNGVGN[ JGPEG KVU DNCEM EQNQWT UCWE¾ 1P VJKU EQKP ,GCP +++ KPFKECVGU JKU QNF VKVNG &XZ .QV JCTKPIKCG CPF /CTEJKQ 5CETK KORGTKK

)TQU # (QWT NKQPU $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI KP SWCVTGHQKN HQWT TKPIU CTQWPF /10'6# „ 018# „ $4#$#0%+' 4 +1* ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ &8: CTQWPF ETQUU .16 ¶ $4#$ ¶ .'/$ ¶ #% ¶ /#4%+1 ¶ +/2'40 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN *GTG CNUQ VJG VKVNG QH /#4%+1 +/2'4++ /CTSWKU QH VJG 'ORKTG

364


)TQU .GWXGP # 5CKPV 2GVGT YKVJ DQQM CPF MG[ QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI KP OWNKVNQDG 5 „ 2'6485 „ .1 Q Q 8#0+'0%+5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU + &8: ¶ .16 ¶ $4# ¶ .'$ ¶ '6 ¶ #4%+1 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT (NCP FGHGEV CPF UNKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP PQ 0QXGODGT 0Q FCVG

&GOK ITQU .GWXGP # 5CKPV 2GVGT YKVJ DQQM CPF MG[ QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI 5#0685 Q Q 2'6485 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ VTGHQKNU CTQWPF TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU + &8: $4#$ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP PQ ,WPG 0Q FCVG

'UVGTNKP /CCUVTKEJV # %CUVNG QXGT TKPI KP SWCVTGHQKN /10'6# Z 64#+'%6'0 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG TKPIU KP VJTGG CPINGU CPF VJTGG RGNNGVU KP QPG CPING 5+)08/ %48%+5 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ 0Q FCVG

&GPKGT VQWTPQKU FG RCKGOGPV *CGNGP # %CUVNG &8: $4#$#06+0' 4 %TQUU /10'6# *#.'05 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 0QTOCNN[ VJG NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG UJQWNF DG $4#$#06+' EH PQ *GTG VJG TGCN ECUVNG TGCRRGCTU KP O[ QRKPKQP DQVJ VQYGTU ETQYPGF YKVJ C TKPI LWUV CU QP VJG QTKIKPCN ITQU VQWTPQKU

365


&GPKGT VQWTPQKU FG RCKGOGPV *CGNGP # %CUVNG &8: $ 4#$#0 6+' 4 %TQUU /10'6# *#.'05 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 %QTTQFGF HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 0Q FCVG

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ʼnU CPF UQOGVKOGU 9GPEGUNCUʼn #HVGT CNN EQKPU CTG KP DQVJ PCOGU

)TQU 8KNXQTFG # .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# š (+.(& YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU 4 +1 &8% Z .16 $4#$ CTQWPF NKPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*5 ¶ :2+ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 %NGCPGF XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP PQ #WIWUV 5VTWEM KP F9 OGPVKQPU NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP QP VJG QDXGTUG DWV JGTG KU PQ NKQP XKUKDNG

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ʼnQT YCU UVTWEM KP (NCPFGTU KP UGG WPFGT (NCPFGTU CHVGT ,GCPʼnU FGCVJ

366


/QWVQP F QT 8KNXQTFG # #IPWU &GK KP OWNVKNQDG 9'0 &8: KP HKGNF #)0 Q &'+ Q 38+ Q 61.. Q 2%%# Q /8&+ Q /+5'4'4' Q 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP OWNVNKQDG YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING CPF C UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG :2% ^ 8+0%+6 ^ :2% ^ 4')0#6 ^ :2% ^ +/2'4#6 &GNO F9 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5OCNN VTCEGU QH RTGUUWTG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC /ÒP\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 5VTWEM KP

)TQU 8KNXQTFG # 5JKGNF QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ” 018# ” (+.(14&'05 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF & 8 : %ʼn KP VJG CPINGU +1*#0# &'+ )4# $4#$#06+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

&GOK ITQU 8KNXQTFG # 5JKGNF QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ” 018# ” (+.(14&'05 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD CPF & 8 : %ʼn KP VJG CPINGU +1*#0# &'+ )4# $4#$#6+' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5OCNN GFIG FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG ITQCV YKVJ VJG RGNNGVU CV VJG GZVTGOKVKGU QH VJG ETQUU KU UOCNNGT VJCP VJG QPG YKVJQWV VJG FQVU /QTGQXGT KV KU EQPUKFGTCDN[ NKIJVGT 5VTWEM KP

$QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 5VTWEM KP

&QWDNG OQWVQP F QT 8KNXQTFG # .COD KP OWNVKNQDG +1* &8: KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF #)0 &'+ 38+ 61.. 2%%# /8&+ /+5'4'4' 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING CPF C TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG :2% ^ 8+0%+6 ^ :2% ^ 4')0#6 ^ :2% ^ +/2'4#6 &GNO F9 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP QP DTQCF HNCP -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM KP 6JG FQWDNG OQWVQP FʼnQT KU KP VJG PCOG QH ,GCPPG 6JG FQWDNG FQGU PQV YGKIJ VYKEG CU OWEJ CU VJG UKPING PQU CPF DWV KU ECNNGF ōFQWDNGŋ UQNGN[ DGECWUG KV YGKIJU OQTG

367


2KGVGT F QT .GWXGP # 5CKPV 2GVGT YKVJ DQQM CPF MG[ QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI CPF .WZGODWTI KP OWNVKNQDG 9'0%'.#85 ” < ” +1*#0# ” ” &'+ ” )4# ” $4#$ ” &8%'5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 &GNO F9 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 5VTWEM HTQO ,WN[ QP (TQO PQY QP DQVJ PCOGU QP VJG EQKPU

0QWXGNNG 6QWTGNNG .GWXGP # %JWTEJ QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI CPF .WZGODWTI /10'6# Z 018# Z Z .18#0+'0 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 9'0%'. ” < ” +1* ” &'+ ” )4# ” $4#$ ” &8% F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG )TGPUYKUUGNMCPVQTGP #OUVGTFCO 5VTWEM KP #RTKN 6JG EJWTEJ KU 5V 2KGTTG KP .GWXGP

&GOK ITQU # .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# Z $4#$# YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP 4 Z +1 &8% Z .16 $4#$ CTQWPF ETQUU 9'0%'5. ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ .8%'0$ ¶ $4#$ ¶ &8: F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN HNCP YKVJ FGHGEV CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 6JG VKVNG .WZGODWTI UVCPFU DGPGCVJ 9GPEGUNCU 5VTWEM KP ,CPWCT[ &G 9KVVG UWIIGUVU VJCV VJKU V[RG JCU DGGP UVTWEM KP .GWXGP HQNNQYKPI VJG %QKPCIG #EV VJ ,WPG

/KVG # 9'0 KP HKGNF DGVYGGP TQUGVVG VTGHQKN CPF DWING < +1* $4#$# &8% 4 %TQUU /10'6# $4#$#0 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 0Q FCVG

368


$T[OCP /CCUVTKEJV # &WMG UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI CPF .WZGODWTI 9'0%'.#85 < +1*#0# &'+ )4# $4#$ &8%'5 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# 018# )4155+ 64#+'%6'05+5 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

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

$T[OCP /CCUVTKEJV # &WMG UVCPFKPI YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI CPF .WZGODWTI 9'0%'.#85 < +1*#0# &'+ )4# $4#$ &8%'5 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# 018# )4155+ 64#+'%6'05+5 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

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

,'#00' XGWXG CPF 2*+.+2 NG *#4&+

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

369


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

&QWDNG ITQU 4QQUGDGMGT .GWXGP # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV .KODWTI .WZGODWTI $ÌJOGP N 1NF CPF 0GY $WTIWPF[ T ICTNCPF QH TQUGU DGVYGGP VYQ HNQYGTU CDQXG CPF QPG HNQYGT DGNQY +1* &'+ )4# &8% .8%'/$ $4#$ < .+/$ 4 5JKGNF QH $TCDCPV KP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP FTCIQPJGCFU /10'6# 018# .18#0+'05 +0 $4#$#0 F9 8CP JQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP (TQO HKPF <WVRJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM ,WPG CPF ,WN[

#061+0' QH $74)70&; 1P VJG VJ #RTKN 2JKNKR VJG $QNF FKGF *KU YKHG /CTICTGV KPJGTKVGF $TCDCPV YJKEJ UJG KOOGFKCVGN[ EGFGF VQ JGT UQP #PVQKPG *G VJGP DGECOG TGIGPV QP VJG VJ /C[ YKVJ ,GCPPGʼnU CUUGPV 1P VJ /CTEJ /CTICTGV FKGF [GV #PVQKPG YQWNFPʼnV DGEQOG FWMG QH $TCDCPV WPVKN VJG FGOKUG QH ,GCPPG QP VJG UV &GEGODGT +P #PVQKPG CESWKTGF VJG VKVNG &WMG QH .WZGODQWTI D[ OCTTKCIG VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QH )QTNKV\ UGG WPFGT .WZGODQWTI #PVQKPG OGV JKU GPF KP VJG $CVVNG QH #IKPEQWTV KP HKIJVKPI HQT VJG (TGPEJ

&QWDNG ITQU DQFFTCIGT 8KNXQTFG # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV UKVVKPI N YKVJ $4#$# 6 KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF #06*10+85 &'+ )4# &: $4#$#06+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI $WTIWPF[ /10'6# &8: $4#$#06+' '6 .+/$ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP $WUUWO #WEVKQP PQ

&QWDNG ITQU DQFFTCIGT .GWXGP # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV UKVVKPI N YKVJ .18#0 KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF #06*10+85 &'+ )4# &: $4#$#06+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI $WTIWPF[ /10'6# $8) $4#$#06+' '6 .+/$ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ #VQR VJG JGNOGV C NKU HTQO VJG CTOU QH VJG FWMG (QT CP GNWEKFCVKQP QP VJG PCOG DQFFTCIGT UGG WPFGT (NCPFGTU +P FG 9KVVG &8: KPUVGCF QH $7) 6JKU EQKP ENGCTN[ TGCFU $7)

370


)TQU DQFFTCIGT .GWXGP # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV UKVVKPI N YKVJ .18#0 KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF #06*10+85 &'+ )4 $8) < $#$#06+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF QXGT UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI $WTIWPF[ /10'6# &8: $4#$#06+' '6 .+/$ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

&QWDNG OKVG # 5JKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI $WTIWPF[ #06*10+85 &: $4#$ 4 %TQUU /10'6# $4#$#06 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV &GEGODGT PQ

,'#0 +8 #HVGT #PVQKPGʼnU FGCVJ VJG FWECN VKVNG FGXQNXGF VQ JKU QNFGUV UQP ,GCP +8 YJQ YCU QPN[ [GCTU QNF CV VJG VKOG 'NGXGP OGODGTU QH VJG 'UVCVGU YGTG CRRQKPVGF CUUQEKCVG IWCTFKCPU 6JTGG [GCTU NCVGT CV VJG CIG QH ,GCP +8 OCTTKGF ,CEQDC QH $CXCTKC #RTKN CPF HTQO VJCV OQOGPV QP JG DQTG VJG VKVNGU QH *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *GPGIQWYGP ,CEQDCʼnU WPENG VJG CODKVKQWU ,QJP QH $CXCTKC OCPCIGF VQ UWURGPF 4QOGʼnU FKURGPUCVKQP PGGFGF HQT VJG OCTTKCIG 6JKU OCTTKCIG CNTGCF[ GPFGF VYQ [GCTU NCVGT YJGP ,CEQDC OCTTKGF *WORJTG[ QH )NQWEGUVGT DTQVJGT QH -KPI *GPT[ 8 QH 'PINCPF +P VJG XKEVQT[ QH ,GCP +8 KP VJG $CVVNG CV $TQWYGTUJCXGP EQKPEKFGF YKVJ 4QOG TWNKPI VJG OCTTKCIG QH ,CEQDC CPF *WORJTG[ QH )NQWEGUVGT CU DKICOQWU 6JG VTCEVCVG QH &QWCK FKF CUUWTG ,GCP +8 VJG RQUUGUUKQP QH CNN VJG FKUVTKEVU [GV JG YCU VQVCNN[ WPHKV VQ TWNG *GPEG $TCDCPV EJQUG JKU DTQVJGT 2JKNKR QH 5V 2CWN

YJQ YCU CRRQKPVGF TGIGPV TWYCCTV KP CPF KP VJCV UCOG [GCT JG JCF VQ TGNKPSWKUJ *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF HQT C RGTKQF QH [GCTU VQ ,QJP QH $CXCTKC CV VJG 6TGCV[ QH 5V /CCTVGPUFKLM 1H VJG FTKGNCPFGTU QH ,GCP +8 QPG YCU UVTWEM HQT *CKPCWV CV VJG OKPV QH 8CNGPEKGPPGU UGG WPFGT *GPGIQWYGP

&QWDNG ITQU FQWDNG RGPPKPEM ,CPU 8KNXQTFG # 6YQ UJKGNFU $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV T WPFGT JGNOGV +1*#005 „ &+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $4#$#06+ „ < „ .+/$ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# 018# &8% $4#$#06+ '6 .+/$84 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F &G 9KVVG OGPVKQPU )# KPUVGCF QH )4# CPF &: KPUVGCF QH &8: 6JKU V[RG KU CP KOKVCVKQP QH VJG UCOG V[RG QH ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU HQT (NCPFGTU 8CPJQWFV OGPVKQPU JCV VJKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM KP CP WPMPQYP OKPV CVGNKGT

371


&QWDNG ITQU VJW[PG /CCUVTKEJV # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV .KODWTI $CXCTKC KP HGPEG +1* ¶ &: ¶ $4#$ ¶ < ¶ .+/$ ¶ %1/ ¶ *# ¶ *1 ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ VTGHQKNU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 ¶ 018 ¶ (#% ¶ +0 &'0 ¶ 841*1' F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP 6JG CTOU HGCVWTG $CXCTKC UKIPKH[KPI JKU OCTTKCIG VQ ,CEQDC YJKEJ FCVGU VJKU EQKP DGVYGGP CPF

&QWDNG ITQU FTKGNCPFGT $TWUUGN # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV T KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT NKU +1* &: $4#$ < .+/$ %1/ *#0 *1. < <' 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# (%# $48:'..' QWVGT EKTENG 5+6 § 01/'0 § &1/+0+ § $'0'&+%68/ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG *KTUEJ /Ã’PEJGP #WVEKQP PQ 'Z 'INOGKGT EQNNGEVKQP 6JG $TCDCPV NKQPU KP VJG NGHV JCNH QH VJG CTOU HCEG TKIJV

)TQU FTKGNCPFGT $TWUUGN # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV T KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT NKU +1* &: $4#$ < .+/$ %1/ *#0 *1. < < 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# (%# $48:'. QWVGT EKTENG 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ $'0'&+%68/ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 9GNN UVTWEM CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

)TQU FTKGNCPFGT $TWUUGN # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV T KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT NKU +1* &: $4#$ < .+/$ %1/ *#0 *1. < < 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# (%# $48:'. QWVGT EKTENG 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ $'0'&+%68/ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

&GOK ITQU FTKGNCPFGT $TWUUGN # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV T KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT NKU +1* &: $4#$ < .+/$ %1/ *#001 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF QPG NKQP VJG TF CPING KPPGT EKTENG /10'6 (%# $48: QWVGT EKTENG 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ $0'&+%68 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG &GNOQPVG $TWUUGN

372


2*+.+22' QH 56 2#7. 4WYCCTV #HVGT VJG EQPVGPVKQP DGVYGGP ,GCP +8 CPF ,CEQDC CP CUUGODN[ YCU ECNNGF CV 8KNXQTFG CPF 2JKNKR QH 5V 2CWN YCU CRRQKPVGF TGIGPV 2JKNKRRG YCU VJG UGEQPF UQP QH #PVQKPG QH $WTIWPF[ CPF ,GCPPG QH 9CNGTCP FG .WZGODQWTI

&QWDNG ITQU FTKGNCPFGT 9CGNJGO # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N $TCDCPV .KODWTI T KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT NKU 2*5 $4#$ %1/ .+0'+ '6 5%6+ 2#8.+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU KPPGT EKTENG /10'6# 2*+ $4#$#6+' QWVGT EKTENG 5+6 ~ 01/'0 ~ &1/+0+ ~ $'0'&+%68/ F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5NKIJVGN[ ENGCPGF XGT[ HKPG 0/$ #OUVGTFCO (TQO HKPF 9QGTFGP EH ,/2 R

&QWDNG ITQU 4WOKPIJGP # *GNOGV QXGT VJG UJKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF $TCDCPV 2*5 $4#$#0 %1/ .+0'+ '6 5%6+ 2#8.+ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6 018 %1/+6+5 .+0'+ '6 5%6+ 2#8.+ F9 R 8CPJQWFV IT 44 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 2# $ &G 9KVVG OGPVKQPU /10'6# KPUVGCF QH /10'6 5VTWEM DGVYGGP CPF &G 9KVVG JCU PQ PWODGT YKVJ TGHGTGPEG VQ 4( R

2*+.+22' QH 56 2#7. 2JKNKR YCU TGIGPV FWTKPI VJG NKHG QH ,GCP +8 #HVGT VJG NCVVGTʼnU FGOKUG KP JG DGECOG FWMG

%JCKUG F QT .GWXGP # %QWPV QP VJTQPG KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ 2*5 ” &8: ” $4#$#06+' ” < ” .+/$84) 4 (NQTKCVGF %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 &GNO F9 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

&QWDNG ITQU ETQOUVGTF # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ KP VJG EGPVTG 2*5 „ &8: „ $4#$#06+' „ < „ .+/$ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ $ 4 # $ KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# „ 018# „ .18#0+'05 F9 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

373


#$$'; QH 0+8'..'5 /QPCUVGT[ HQWPFGF D[ 5V )GTVTWFG FCWIJVGT QH 2KRRKP VJG 'NFGT VJG #WUVTCUKCP OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG UGG WPFGT /GTQXKPIKCPU .CVGT VJG UWEEGUUQTU QH .CODGTV + %QWPV QH .GWXGP VQQM 0KXGNNGU +P 'ORGTQT 1VVQ +++ TGVWTPGF XCTKQWU RQUUGUUKQPU VQ VJG OQPCUVGT[ CPF ITCPVGF RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV 6JG EQWPVU QH $TCDCPV JQYGXGT FKF PQV CDCPFQP VJGKT ENCKO VQ VJG CDDG[ QH 0KXGNNGU +P VJG GPF *GPT[ + TGEGKXGF 0KXGNNGU KP HKGH HTQO 'ORGTQT 1VVQ +8 #HVGT *GPT[ʼnU FGCVJ 0KXGNNGU YCU WPKVGF YKVJ $TCDCPV 7PFGT *'04+ + QH $4#$#06

&GPKGT VJ EGPVWT[ # %JWTEJ YKVJ TKPI QP EQNWOP KP VJG RQTVCN 4 %TQUU QH $TCDCPV YKVJ VYQ DTCPEJGU CPF VYQ TKPIU YKVJ QXCN RGNNGV KP VJG CPINGU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 4$0 2N ¯

&7%*; .+/$74) 6JG TQQVU QH VJG &WEJ[ .KODWTI NC[ KP VJG TQ[CN HKGH $CGNGP VJCV (TGFGTKEM ++ QH .WZGODQWTI

VJG NCVGT FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG KPJGTKVGF HTQO JKU HCVJGT 6JKU RTQRGTV[ NC[ DGVYGGP VJG /GWUG CPF #CEJGP CPF EQORTKUGF UGXGTCN CDDG[U CU YGNN 9KVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH QPG CDDG[ VJKU VGTTKVQT[ RCUUGF VQ 9CNGTCP 7FQ %QWPV QH #TNQP KP *KU FGUEGPFCPVU YQWNF TGKIP WPVKN *KU UQP *GPT[ + QH .KODWTI #TNQP YCU CRRQKPVGF FWMG QH .QYGT .QTTCKPG D[ 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +8 +P VJKU FKIPKV[ YCU TGXQMGF CPF KPUVGCF DGUVQYGF QP )QFHTG[ +8 QH .GWXGP UQYKPI VJG UGGFU QH C NCUVKPI EQPVGPVKQP DGVYGGP $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI +P 9CNGTCP ++ UQP QH *GPT[ + YCU IKXGP DCEM FWECN FKIPKV[ CV VJG GZRGPUG QH $TCDCPV .GWXGP 'ORGTQT %QPTCF +++ KP UWDUGSWGPVN[ DGUVQYGF FWECN FKIPKV[ QP $TCDCPV CU YGNN 6JG EQWPVU QH .KODWTI JGPEGHQTVJ ECNNGF VJGOUGNXGU FWMG YJKEJ YCU CEMPQYNGFIGF KP D[ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC 6JG UVCVWU QH RTKPEG QH VJG GORKTG JQYGXGT RTQXGF QWV QH TGCEJ +P 4QNFWE YCU CESWKTGF QTKIKPCN PCOG YCU ʼn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

#U HCT CU KU MPQYP VJG EQWPVU TGUR VJG FWMGU QH .KODWTI FKF PQV OKPV CRCTV HTQO CP 5VGTNKPI VJCV YCU UVTWEM KP 4QNFWE CV VJG XGT[ NCUV (QT VJKU UQNG V[RG UGG DGPGCVJ 9#.'4#0 QH .+)0;

'UVGTNKP 4QNFWE # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP 9#.4 #/85 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ 4 1 & ' KP VJG CPINGU Z 9 #.4#/ 85 Z .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 'PIGN CPF 5GTTWTG RTQXKFG VJG HQNNQYKPI GNWEKFCVKQP 41&' KPFKECVGU 4QNFWE KP )GTOCP *GT\QIGPTCVJ 6JG[ CVVTKDWVG VJKU RKGEG VQ 9CNGTCP +8 QH .WZGODQWTI DWV VJKU CVVTKDWVKQP KU GSWKXQECN 4GEGPV TGUGCTEJ JCU UJQYP VJCV 9CNGTCP QH .KIP[ YCU IQXGTPQT HTQO VQ JG YCU C DTQVJGT QH *GPT[ 8+ QH .WZGODQWTI #NVJQWIJ VJG OKPV QH 4QNFWE YCU PQV RWV KPVQ QRGTCVKQP WPVKN VJKU UVGTNKPI CICKPUV DGVVGT LWFIGOGPV KU

374


CVVTKDWVGF VQ 9CNGTCP +8 FWMG QH .KODWTI +P CFFKVKQP VQ VJKU VJG V[RG VJCV VJKU EQKP YCU OQFGNNGF CHVGT VJG UVGTNKPI QH ,QJP + QH $TCDCPV YJKEJ UJQYGF KPFKECVKQP QH VJG OKPV KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG YCU PQV UVTWEM WPVKN CHVGT +V KU VJGTGHQTG KORQUUKDNG VJCV VJKU UVGTNKPI YCU OCPWHCEVWTGF FWTKPI VJG NKHG QH 9CNGTCP +8 6JG KPEKFGPVU UWTTQWPFKPI VJG UWEEGUUKQP VQ .KODWTI JQNF VJG MG[ VQ VJKU O[UVGT[ #HVGT JKU FGCVJ KP 9CNGTCP +8 YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ JKU FCWIJVGT 'TOGPICTF JGT TKIJVU YGTG CEMPQYNGFIGF KP ,WPG D[ 4WFQNH QH *CDUDWTI #V JGT FGOKUG KP ,WPG JGT JWUDCPF 4GIKPCNF QH )WGNFGTU CESWKTGF WUWHTWEV QH VJG FWEJ[ PQVYKVJUVCPFKPI VJG QRRQUKVKQP QH #FQNH QH $GTI VJG PGZV QH MKP QH 'TOGPICTFG YJQ ENCKOGF VJG FWEJ[ #U JG RTQXGF PQ OCVEJ HQT 4GIKPCNF QH )WGNFGTU #FQNH QH $GTI KP 5GRVGODGT TGUQNXGF VQ EGFG JKU TKIJVU VQ .KODWTI VQ ,QJP + &WMG QH $TCDCPV CICKPUV RC[OGPV QH OQTG VJCP OCTMU KP UKNXGT RTQORVKPI 4GIKPCNF VQ UGGM UWRRQTV YKVJ .WZGODQWTI +P #WIWUV JG RNCEGF VJG FWEJ[ KP VJG EWUVQF[ QH 9CNGTCP QH .KIP[ VJG [QWPIGT DTQVJGT QH *GPT[ 8+ QH .WZGODQWTI 9CNGTCP IQXGTPGF WPVKN YJGP RTQDNGOU CTQUG EQPEGTPKPI VJG EQUVU QH IWCTFKPI VJG ECUVNGU QH 4QNFWE CPF .KODWTI #HVGT JG JCF EQORGPUCVGF 9CNGTCP 4GIKPCNF VWTPGF VQ (NCPFGTU CPF EGFGF VJG ECUVNGU QH 4QNFWE CPF .KODWTI VQ JKU HCVJGT KP NCY )W[ QH &CORKGTTG 6JTQWIJ JKU XKEVQT[ CV 9QTTKPIGP VJG FWMG QH $TCDCPV IQV JQNF QH 4QNFWE CHVGT CNN 6JKU UVGTNKPI YCU WPFQWDVGFN[ UVTWEM D[ 9CNGTCP QH .KIP[ CU IQXGTPQT QH .KODWTI *G VQQ FKGF QP VJG DCVVNGHKGNF CV 9QTTKPIGP 5GG 'NUGP , . CVGNKGT FG 4QNFWE ¯ NC HKP FW VJ UK½ENG KP NKUV R

%1706; QH .11< 6JG EQWPV[ .QQ\ YCU EGPVTGF KP *CUUGNV CPF /CCUGKM CPF EQORTKUGF QH C HGY UOCNNGT VQYPU CU YGNN .QQ\ NC[ KP VJG QNF EQWPVKGU QH /CCUICW *CUDCPKC CPF 6QZCPFTKC OGPVKQPGF KP VJG 6TGCV[ QH /GGTUUGP 9KVJ TGICTF VQ VJG HWVWTG VJG VKGU YKVJ VJG FKQEGUG .K½IG YGTG QH XKVCN KORQTVCPEG 6JG HGWFCN TKIJVU VQ .QQ\ RTGUWOCDN[ RCUUGF VQ .K½IG CNQPI YKVJ VJG EGUUKQP QH VJG EQWPV[ *CUDCPKC VQ .K½IG D[ *GPT[ +++ 6JG QTKIKPCN EQWPVU JCF DGGP TGNCVGF VQ 4GIKPCT + UGG *CKPCWV 6JG HKTUV MPQYP EQWPV KU )KUNGDGTV /KPVKPI EQOOGPEGF YKVJ .QWKU + *KU UQP )GTCTF

UWEEGGFGF CPF FWTKPI JKU TGKIP C OCLQT RCTV QH .QQ\ YCU FGUVTQ[GF D[ VJG RTKPEG DKUJQR QH .K½IG +P RGCEG YCU UKIPGF DGVYGGP .QQ\ CPF .K½IG DKUJQR 4WFQNH QH <·JTKPIGP CPF VJG EQWPV DGECOG C XCUUCN QH .K½IG .KVVNG KU MPQYP QH JKU UWEEGUUQTU WPVKN #TPQNF +8 ECOG VQ RQYGT CPF GURGEKCNN[ #TPQNF 8

*G HQWIJV QP VJG $TCDCPV UKFG KP VJG $CVVNG CV 9QTTKPIGP COQPI QVJGTU VJGTG YCU C UJQTV NKXGF OQPGVCT[ WPKQP DGVYGGP #TPQNF CPF ,GCP + #TPQNFʼnU UQP .QWKU +8 FKGF EJKNFNGUU 6JG EQWPV[ RCUUGF VQ JKU PGRJGY &KGVTKEJ QH 5RQPJGKO *GKPUDGTI C UQP QH /CVJKNFG FCWIJVGT QH #TPQNF 8 CPF )QFHTG[ +++ QH *GKPUDGTI *G FKGF C EJKNFNGUU OCP VQQ JQYGXGT VJG EQWPV[ RCUUKPI QPEG CICKP VQ .K½IG 6JG EQWPV[ʼnU RTKPEKRCN EKV[ *CUUGNV YCU QEEWRKGF D[ 'PIGNDGTV XCP FGT /CTEM VQ CEMPQYNGFIG JKU TKIJVU &KGVTKEJʼnU PGRJGY )QFHTG[ QH *GKPUDGTI &CNGODTQGEM ITCPFUQP QH /CVJKNFG FCWIJVGT QH #TPQNF 8 CPF )QFHTG[ +++ QH *GKPUDGTI YCU ECRVWTGF *G UQNF JKU TKIJVU VQ #TPQNF Fʼn1TG[G C ITCPFUQP QH #TPQNF 8 5KTG QH 4WOOGP *G KP VWTP QP VJG VJ 1EVQDGT UQNF JKU TKIJVU VQ VJG FKQEGUG .K½IG CPF KP DKUJQR ,QJP QH #TMGN FGHKPKVKXGN[ WPKVGF VJG EQWPV[ .QQ\ CPF VJG 2TKPEG $KUJQRTKE .K½IG #401.& 8

'UVGTNKP # *GCF HCEKPI V¿VG PWG /1 0'6' %+1/+6 &' .1 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU %1/'5 #401.&85 /C[JGY 8CPJQWFV ) XCT IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

)NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 0QDNG EQNNGEVKQP #WUVTCNKC %JCWVCTF RN :++ %1/+6 KPUVGCF QH %+1/+6 /C[JGY R +V KU RQUUKDNG VJCV UQOG QT CNN QH VJG XCTKGVKGU KPENWFGF KP V[RG OC[ DG WPCWVJQTKUGF EQRKGU %+1/+6 NQQMU NKMG C EQR[KPI GTTQT 6JG VQQNGF ETQYP QP KU YQTVJ[ QH C URGEKCN PQVG $CGTVGP %'0$ + +P JKU TGRQTV QP VJG /CTEJKGPPG CW 2QPV JQCTF &G %QUVGT UWIIGUVGF VJCV KUUWKPI QH VJG /10'6# %+1/+6 &' .1 V[RG OC[ JCXG LWUV DGIWP CV VJG VKOG QH VJG JQCTFʼnU EQPEGCNKPI E

375


$CWFGMKLP *CUUGNV # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UJKGNF #401.% %1'5 ¶ .155'5+' 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ #55'.'6'05+5 .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

&GPKGT # *GCF T #401.&85 %1'5 .15 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING +0 01/' &' &'+ .WECU IT 44 9GNN CPF UJCTR UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

FG )GWU 'KPFJQXGP #WEVKQP PQ

47//'0 #P QNF 4QOCP UGVVNGOGPV 6JG (TCPMU VQQ UQLQWTPGF VJGTG VJG ECUVNG KU UVKNN ECNNGF -NGKP 8TCPMTKLM NKVVNG (TCPEG 6JG HKTUV MPQYP UGKIPGWT NQTF QH VJG OCPQT KU )WKNNCWOG FG /QPVHGTTCPV YJQ TGEGKXGF 4WOOGP HTQO VJG EQWPVU QH .QQ\ HQT /QPVHGTTCPV UGG VJG PQVG YKVJ ʼnU *GGTGP DGTI *KU QNFGUV UQP #FCO YCU YGFFGF VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QH )GPGHHG JGKTGUU QH 1TG[G KP ʼnU *GGTGPDGTI VJG PCOG #FCO KU CNUQ GPEQWPVGTGF C PCOG UQOGYJCV WPWUWCN HQT VJKU TGIKQP 6JGKT QNFGUV UQP )WKNNCWOG YCU UKTG QH 1TG[G CPF 4WOOGP 6JG VGTTKVQT[ YQWNF DG FKXKFGF COQPI JKU VYQ UQPU #TPQNF DGECOG UKTG QH 1TG[G CPF ,GCP UKTG QH 4WOOGP ,GCPʼnU QNFGUV UQP )WKNNCWOG YGFFGF ,QJCPPC QH .QQ\ FCOG QH 3WCGDGMG CPF YKFQY QH #TPQNF QH 9GUGOCGN UKTG QH 3WCGDGMG CPF $GTIGP QR <QQO 6JGKT QNFGUV UQP YCU #TPQNF Fʼn1TG[G IWCTFKCP QH VJG EQWPV[ .QQ\ *G EQP EGTPGF JKOUGNH YKVJ VJG FKURWVGU YKVJ VJG DKUJQR QH .K½IG QP UWEEGUUKQP KP .QQ\ *G FKGF EJKNFNGUU *KU UKUVGT /CTKG UWEEGGFGF JKO CPF YCU KP VWTP UWEEGGFGF D[ JGT FCWIJVGT ,QJCPPC *GT VYQ UQPU UQNF VJGKT TKIJVU VQ 4WOOGP VQ DKUJQR 'PIGNDGTV XCP FGT /CTEM QH .K½IG 'PIGNDGTV EGFGF 4WOOGP VQ *GPT[ QH &KGUV VJG HWVWTG JWUDCPF QH ,QJCPPC QH 9GUGOCGN #HVGT *GPT[ QH &KGUVʼnU FGCVJ 4WOOGP YCU VJG RTQRGTV[ QH ,CP ++ QH 9GUGOCGN *G UQNF RCTV QH VJKU RTQRGTV[ VQ %JCTNGU VJG $QNF CTQWPF CHVGT YJKEJ 4WOOGP FGXQNXGF VQ JKU UKUVGT ,QJCPPC *GPT[ QH &KGUVʼnU YKHG #HVGT JGT FGOKUG 4WOOGP DGECOG RTQRGTV[ QH VJG HCOKN[ FG /¾TQFG WPVKN #401.& F 14';'

.GGWYGPITQQV # .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# Å¡ 48/'0 YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP 4 #401 &8% Z &1/0 + CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ 04+ ¶ &0+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2% .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

376


,#0 ++ QH 9'5'/#'.

)TQQV # 5JKGNF QH 9GUGOCGN +1*#05 „ &' „ 9'5/# „ &5 „ 48/ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ ETQYPU KP VJG CPINGU 5+6 „ 01/' „ &0+ „ $'0'&+%68 .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG %QKP +PX .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ (TQO NKUV *GP\GP /C[ PQ (QNNQYGT QH VJG DNCPE IW¾PCT QH %JCTNGU 8+ EH (TCPEG TQ[CNG

&WDDGNG OKLV # 5JKGNF QH 9GUGOCGN +1*#0 &' 9'5'/# 4 %TQUU /10'6# Å¡ &' 48//' .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

-Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

/KLV # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ +1*'00'5 &05 3 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF 84# 86/ .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 3 3WCGDGMG +OKVCVKQP QH VJG O[VGP QH ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU

,1*#00# QH 9'5'/#'.

&WDDGNG OKLV # 5JKGNF QH 2JKNKR VJG )QQF +1*#00# &' 9'5/#. 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# Q 018# Q 48//'014 .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

377


)'4&+0)'0 )GTFKPIGP KU CP QNF UGKIPKQT[ QH .QQ\ +P KV DGNQPIGF VQ ,QJP QH 9GGTV JWUDCPF QH /CTICTGVJC *QGP QH *QGPUDTQGM ,QJCPPC QH /GTYGFG FCOG QH 5VGKP YCU CNUQ FCOG QH )GTFKPIGP 5JG UVTWEM KOKVCVKQPU QH 2JKNKR VJG )QQFล U EQKPU KP )GTFKPIGP CPF 0KGWYUVCF ,1*#00# QH /'49'&'

/KLV )GTFKPIGP # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ $' ล 5+6 01/'0 & 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /1++ ล ++ '&0% .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) VJKU URGEKOGP IT 44 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

/CKNNG VQWTPQKU # %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN รฐ +1*#00# &' )4 4 .KU KP SWCVTGHQKN รฐ +1*#0 &' )'4 .WECU E 8CPJQWFV IT (KPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 4KFFGT XCP FGP $QICGTFG EQNNGEVKQP *CCTGP +OKVCVKQP QH VJG 8NCCOUG OKLV QH 2JKNKRU FG )QGFG X)* 6JKU URGEKOGP KU UJQYP KP .WECU KP 4$0 VJKU URGEKOGP ,QJCPPC QH /GTYGFG KP KPJGTKVGF VJG HKGHU )GTFKPIGP CPF 5VGKP HTQO JGT UKUVGT 5JG EGFGF CNN JGT TKIJVU VQ 5VGKP VQ VJG .KยฝIG DKUJQR ,QJP QH *GKPUDGTI +P VJG VYQ OKPVU QH )GTFKPIGP )GTFKPIGP CPF 0KGWYUVCF UJG JCF KOKVCVKQPU QH VJG (NGOKUJ $TCDCPV CPF (TGPEJ EQKPU UVTWEM KP NCTIG PWODGTU QP 0KGWYUVCF EQKPU UJG KU HTGSWGPVN[ KPFKECVGF CU FCOG QH 5VGKP

&QODTQYUMK /ร PUVGT

/CKNNG VQWTPQKU # .KU KP SWCVTGHQKN รฐ +1*#00# &/# & 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN รฐ 01/'0 &0+ 01$ .WECU G 8CPJQWFV IT 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU XGT[ HKPG

-ร PMGT 1UPCDTร EM #WEVKQP PQ EH XF%J XCT .WECU G RTQXKFGU VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZVU # รฐ +1*#00# &1/+0# & 4 01/'0 &0+ 015 CPF TGHGTU VQ 4( R 9JCV FQGU VJG & UKIPKH[!

/KLV 0KGWYUVCF # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ +1*#00# &0# &' )'4&+0 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# 018# %+8+6# .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

/KLV 0KGWYUVCF EC # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ ล 00# &' )'4&+0ล 4 .QPI ETQUU /0' &0'8 0 ล .WECU XCT 8CPJQWFV ) XCT IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 4KFFGT XCP FGP $QICGTFG EQNNGEVKQP ล *CCTGP +OKVCVKQP QH VJG 8NCCOUG OKLV QH 2JKNKRU VJG )QQF X)* 6JKU EQKP KU UJQYP KP .WECU KP 4$0 VJKU URGEKOGP

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ +OKVCVKQP QH VJG $TCDCPVUG OKLV QH 2JKNKRU VJG )QQF X)* C

378


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

$TQIGN -GUUGPKEJ

,GCP FG $WPFG ,GCP ++ FG *QTPGU

4WOOGP $KEJV

,QJCPPC XCP 9GUGOCGN 0KEQNCU XCP FGT &QPEM

4GEMJGKO 1PDGMGPF

,GCP FG 2[TOQPV

!

+1*#00# &' )'4& &1/+0# &' ล ล +1*ล /#%1+ !#+6&#6%# 8'# 6'1 +1*0#0'5 &' $8+ +1*#ล &' *140 /+.'%840 1+%4 +1*#00# &' 95#/# 0+%1.ล & ) 0+ล # 0 ' & +1*#0ล /#44# /#6' &+ /#44# /#6' &+ )8ล / &'+ ) $8 #8' /#4+#ล #8' /#4+# )4#% #8' /ล )4 68# 58*# &'+ 85'+ 9+.*'.ล

/10'6# 018 5+8 /10'6# 018# 5+8 ล +%+#ล :%+ 6+8&# 6&#68# /10'6# 018# $4 6ล #&8% #8'4 841%0+ล /10' 018# 48/' /10'6# 018# $ /10 018# $+ /10ล 18# 4'% .8&18+%85 &'+ ) /1/'6# 018# + 8ล /# %ล '0 /#4+# /#6'4 14# 1$1.85 %+8+5 ( 2.'ล &1/+08 01#ล 0 68#1 ล 8#8 :85 58+

#UUWOKPI VJCV OCPWHCEVWTG QH VJKU V[RG KP $KEJV JCF CNTGCF[ DGIWP KP CNN RNCEGU CTG YKVJKP VJG UVCVGF JKUVQTKECN VKOGHTCOG 6JCV NGCXGU 4GEMJGKO YJKEJ JQYGXGT PGGFPล V HQTO CP GZEGRVKQP CU KOKVCVKPI EQPVKPWGF UWEJ C NQPI VKOG VJGTG 4CVJGT TGOCTMCDNG KU VJCV CNN V[RGU GZEGRV $KEJV CTG KP VJG PCOG QH GKVJGT C ,QJP QT C ,QJCPPC 6JG (TGPEJ GZCORNG YGKIJU IT 6JG V[RGU CV JCPF XCT[ DGVYGGP IT IT IT IT CPF IT QPN[ VJG NCUV V[RG KU UKIPKHKECPVN[ JGCXKGT

/CKNNG VQWTPQKU # .KU KP VTGHQKN รฐ / / #J6& 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN 18/'&$# ' IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

/CKNNG VQWTPQKU # .KU KP VTGHQKN 0& 61' 81'&#'0+8& 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN รฐ $#410' 61' $'+6 IT 8GT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ 6JG 1 KP VJG NGIGPF 81' ECP CNUQ DG UGGP CU ) QT UQOGVJKPI GNUG 6JKU EQKP KU JGCXKGT VJCP EQORCTCDNG V[RGU

379


$+%*6 )GTCTF XCP FGT /CTEM YCU VJG UGKIPGWT QH 4GEMJGKO $KEJV KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ CPF JG YCU CP WPENG QH VJG .K½IG DKUJQR #FQNRJ XCP FGT /CTEM +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ $KEJV UGRCTCVGF KPVQ VYQ DTCPEJGU C )WGNFGTU DTCPEJ YKVJ VJG HCOKN[ HTQO )GNFTQR VJKU KU VJG NKPGCIG QH 0KEQNCCU XCP FGT &QPEM CPF C $TCDCPV DTCPEJ

VJG HCOKN[ 2KGVGTUJGKO +P 0KEQNCCU XCP FGT &QPEM WPKVGF DQVJ DTCPEJGU 6JKU HKGH UKVWCVGF KP VJG $QTP TGIKQP YCU QYPGF D[ VJG HCOKN[ 8CP FGT &QPEM UKPEG VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 0+%1.##5 X F &10%-

VQWTPQKU # .KU KP VTGHQKN *#06' „ $+őő 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN ð /10'6# „ 018# „ $+ .WECU 8CPJQWFV IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG 9#) ņ &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ EH .WECU EH 40 RN +KD

4'%-*'+/ #V VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 4GEMJGKO YCU CP GZVGPUKXG HKGH ECWIJV DGVYGGP $TCDCPV .K½IG .QQ\ CPF ,Ò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Ŏ

/KLV # )TGCV . DGVYGGP VYQ SWCVTGHQKNU CPF VYQ ENQXGTU / 10 '6# .'ő&#+ 4 .QPI ETQUU .8& %1/ 0+ő &0+ .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG HNCP ETCEM HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ +OKVCVKQP QH VJG 8NCCOUG OKLV QH .QFGYKLM XCP 0GXGTU 6JKU URGEKOGP KU UJQYP KP .WECU

9+..'/ ++ QH 51/$4'(('

)TQQV EQMKDWU # 5JKGNF QH 5QODTGHHG DGVYGGP VJTGG UVCTU 9+.*'. &' 51/'4+ 4 'CING QP NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF /10'6# 018# 4'- .WECU XCT 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

380


9+..'/ +++ FG 51/$4'(('

$KNLQGP #PIGXKP # 5JKGNF 88+.J'./85 &' 5 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING /1 0' 6# 4' .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

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ʼn FGOKUG VJGTG YCU C NQPI RGTKQF YKVJQWV C DKUJQR DWV GXGPVWCNN[ #ITKEQNC DGECOG VJG HKTUV DKUJQR QH /CCUVTKEJV 6JG FKQEGUG YQWNF GZKUV WPVKN YJGP WPFGT 5V *WDGTV VJG GRKUEQRCN OQXGF VQ .K½IG

UGG WPFGT .K½IG +P VJG FC[U QH 5GTXCVKWUʼn FGCVJ VJG 1P\G .KGXG 8TQWYGMGTM CP GRKUEQRCN EJWTEJ CNTGCF[ GZKUVGF 6JG DKUJQR MGRV VJG 1P\G .KGXG 8TQWYGMGTM CU JKU EJWTEJ GXGP CHVGT JG JCF OQXGF VQ .K½IG 6JG HKIWTG QH 5GTXCVKWU KU UJTQWFGF KP NGIGPF UGG *GPFTKM XCP 8GNFGMG 5GTXCVKWUNGIGPFG 5GTXCVKWU KU PQV QPN[ XGPGTCVGF KP /CCUVTKEJV DWV KP OCP[ QVJGT RNCEGU VQQ 6JG OQUV MPQYP KU 3WGFNKPDWTI VJG QPN[ QVJGT EKV[ VQ RQUUGUU TGNKEU QH 5GTXCVKWU UGG WPFGT 3WGFNKPDWTI +P %JCTNGU /CTVGNʼnU VKOG 5GTXCVKWUʼn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½IG CESWKTGF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV HQT COQPI QVJGTU /CCUVTKEJV UGG WPFGT .K½IG 6JG )GTOCP MKPIU GORGTQTU RQUUGUUGF TKIJV QH OKPV HQT /CCUVTKEJV VJGOUGNXGU 6JKU TKIJV JCF C UKIPKHKECPV CURGEV VQ KV VJG )GTOCP MKPIU YGTG ETQYPGF KP #CEJGP CPF CP CNOQUV HQTOCN RCTV QH VJG UQNGOPKV[ EQPUKUVGF KP XKUKVKPI 5V 5GTXCVKWUʼn ITCXG 0Q MKPI YQWNF UGV QHH QP C RKNITKOCIG VQ #CEJGP YKVJQWV KPENWFKPI /CCUVTKEJV KP JKU XQ[CIG 6JKU GUVCDNKUJGU C ENGCT TGNCVKQP DGVYGGP /CCUVTKEJV CPF #CEJGP CPF VJGKT EQKPU 1P VJG QVJGT JCPF VJGTG YCU C ENQUG EQPPGEVKQP DGVYGGP .K½IG CPF /CCUVTKEJV EQKPU %QKPCIG TGHNGEVU VJKU VTKCPIWNCT EQPUVGNNCVKQP

381


6JG EQPFQOKPKWO GPFGF KP YJGP (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC ITCPVGF VJG DWTIWU 6TCKGEVK

YKVJ VJG GZEGRVKQP QH VJG RTGRQUKVWTC 6TCKGEVGPUKU CPF VJG CDDG[ QH 0KXGNNG VQ 4WFQNH QH <·JTKPIGP VJG DKUJQR QH .K½IG VQ HKPCPEG JKU YCT KP 0QTVJGTP +VCN[ 6JWU KP 4WFQNH DGECOG VJG CWVQETCVKE TWNGT QH /CCUVTKEJV CPF UQ FKF JKU UWEEGUUQT %QPFQOKPKCN TWNG YCU PQV TGKPUVCVGF WPVKN YJGP VJG GNGEV QH .K½IG 5KOQP QH .KODWTI EGFGF JCNH QH /CCUVTKEJV VQ *GPT[ 8+ UCY C FGHKPKVKXG VWTP 6JG )GTOCP -KPI 2JKNKR QH 5YCDKC ITCPVGF VJG FWMG QH $TCDCPV *GPTK + /CCUVTKEJV KP HKGH 1PEG CICKP KV YCU IQXGTPGF KP EQPFQOKPKWO VJCV YCU EJCTVGTGF KP KP VJG UQ ECNNGF #NFG %CGTVG #HVGT VJG FWMGU ICKPGF KPHNWGPEG /KPVKPI WPVKN YCU EJCTCEVGTKUGF D[ ITGCV KPUVCDKNKV[ YKVJ DQVJ VJG )GTOCP GORKTG CPF VJG .K½IG DKUJQRU UVTKMKPI EQKP KP /CCUVTKEJV +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ OCVVGTU UVCDKNKUGF YJGP VJG FWMGU QH $TCDCPV JCF EQKPU UVTWEM KP VJG 8TQGPJQH CPF VJG DKUJQRU KP VJG 5V 2KGVGT 7PFGTPGCVJ VJG EQKPU UVTWEM D[ )GTOCP MKPIU GORGTQTU KP /CCUVTKEJV CTG NKUVGF (QT .K½IG OKPVKPI KP /CCUVTKEJV UGG WPFGT .K½IG HQT $TCDCPV OKPVKPI KP /CCUVTKEJV UGG WPFGT $TCDCPV CPF WPFGT $WTIWPFKCP 0GVJGTNCPFU +P /CCUVTKEJV 6JG -G[ QH 5V 5GTXCCU JQNFU C XGT[ URGEKCN RNCEG 5GTXCCU -G[ RTGUWOCDN[ OCPWHCEVWTGF KP 6TKGT GPF QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ 6JG QTKIKPU NKG KP VJG 5GTXCCU NGIGPF 5GTXCVKWU YGPV VQ 4QOG VQ CUM HQTIKXGPGUU CPF RTQVGE VKQP HQT VJG KPJCDKVCPVU QH 6QPIGTGP 5V 2GVGT URQMG VQ 5GTXCVKWU CPF UCKF VJCV )QF YQWNFPʼnV HQTIKXG VJG UKPHWN RGQRNG QH 6QPIGTGP 6JGTGWRQP 5GTXCVKWU YCU IKXGP C RTGEKQWU MG[ D[ 5V 2GVGT 9KVJ KV JG DGUVQYGF VJG UCOG RQYGT QXGT NKHG CPF FGCVJ QP 5GTXCVKWU CU JG JCF DGGP IKXGP D[ %JTKUV CPF URQMG 6JG OGTE[ CPF RQYGT XGUVGF KP OG D[ %JTKUV [QW PQY RQUUGUU VQQ 6JG MG[ VJGTGHQTG TGRTG UGPVU PQP UCETCOGPVCN JGCNKPI RQYGT 6JG 5GTXCCU -G[ CRCTV HTQO KVU JGCNKPI RQYGT CNUQ JQNFU RQNKVKECN UKIPKHKECPEG CPF VJWU KV KU ENQUGN[ NKPMGF VQ C OQTG YQTNFN[ RQYGT CU YGNN 9JGP VJG 'ORGTQT KU FGRKEVGF JQNFKPI UYQTF CPF MG[ VJG UYQTF TGRTGUGPVU JKU NGICN CWVJQTKV[ CPF VJG MG[ KU VJG GODNGO QH JKU UYC[ QXGT /CCUVTKEJV 5RTGPIGT R DGNKGXGU VJG MG[ GORJCUKUGF D[ VJG VGTO ENCXKU UJQWNF DG TGICTFGF CU VJG GODNGO QH VJG KWU HKUEK VJG TKIJV QH VJG 5V 5GTXCCU %JCRVGT VQ VJG TGXGPWG QH KVU QYP RQUUGUUKQPU

*'+04+%* 8

&GPKGT # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ DKTF UEGRVTG! QP VJG TKIJV JCPF +%85 4 *GCF YKVJ VQPUWTG HCEKPI 5CKPV 5GTXCVKWU! 5' IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM TGXGTUG QHH EGPVTG HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP 'Z 2KORTG\ JQCTF PQ (QT EQOOGPVCT[ QP VJG 2KORTG\ JQCTF UGG PQ 6JKU YKVJQWV C FQWDV KU *GPT[ 8 DWV KV KU WPENGCT YJGVJGT CU MKPI QT CU GORGTQT CHVGT 6JG UOCNN JGCF QP VJG TGXGTUG OWUV DG 5V 5GTXCVKWUʼn DGECWUG JG KU /CCUVTKEJVʼnU RCVTQP UCKPV 6JG UOCNN JGCF KP VJKU RGTKQF CPF TGIKQP EJCTCEVGTKUVKECNN[ KPFKECVGF C UCKPV *GPEG VJG UOCNN JGCFU QP VJKU URGEKOGP QH 5V 5GTXCVKWU CPF QP PQ QH 5V .CODGTV CTG XKTVWCNN[ GSWCN $QVJ UCKPVU CTG WUWCNN[ KPFKECVGF KP VJKU OCPPGT VJG UV[NG XCTKGU JQYGXGT 6JG FGRKEVKPI QH VJG JGCFU QP VJG PQU CPF KU V[RKECN HQT VJG 2KORTG\ JQCTF 6JG TGHGTGPEG VQ (T½TG PQ YKVJ *'+04+%85 4': KU KPEQTTGEV CU KU VJCV VQ &CPP

382


&GPKGT # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ QTD CPF UEGRVTG /81.1#% 485 4 %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGVU KP VJG NKODU CPF QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING 6*%4# &CPP XCT IT 44 /CIPKHKEGPV RQTVTCKV TGXGTUG C NKVVNG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

9GUVH /Ã’P\CWMVKQP #WEVKQP PQ 6JG QDXGTUG KU C EQR[ QH C EQKP HTQO #CEJGP /GP VJG TGXGTUG FQGU PQV KPFKECVG #CEJGP 2GTJCRU VJG NGIGPF JCU VQ DG TGCF TGVTQITCFG &CPPGPDGTI UJQYU CP QDXGTUG OWEJ NKMG VJKU QPG KVU TGXGTUG KU CNVQIGVJGT FKHHGTGPV JQYGXGT 5CKPV VGZV 5%5 5'48# VGZV QDXGTUG *'+04+%85 4': TGVTQITCFG +NKUEJ DGNKGXGU VJG EQKP WPFGT EQPUKFGTCVKQP KU HTQO /CCUVTKEJV 6JGTG KU CPQVJGT URGEKOGP KP $GTNKP CPF QPG KP /Ã’PUVGT +V TGCFU *'04+%85 4': *GPT[ 8 YCU MKPI HTQO VQ VJGP GORGTQT 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG OC[ DG #4%*6'# 6JG UJCRG QH VJG ETQUU KU UGGP QP XCTKQWU EQKPU HTQO VJKU TGIKQP ' I &CPP EQKP QH .K½IG YJGTG VJG QDXGTUG UJQYU VJG OGPVKQPGF JGCF HTQO VJG 2KORTG\ JQCTF YKVJ 5V .CODGTV CPF VJG TGXGTUG UJQYU VJG UCOG ETQUU CU VJKU EQKP #U HQT VJG NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG *'+04+%85 4': ECP DG TGCF PGKVJGT FKTGEVN[ PQT KP TGVTQITCFG 6JG NGIKDNG NGVVGTU TGCF FKTGEVN[ DTKPI 5V /QPWNHWU VQ OKPF VJG DKUJQR QH /CCUVTKEJV YJQ HQWPFGF VJG HKTUV .K½IG EJWTEJ

&GPKGT # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ INQDG CPF RCNO NGCH 4 $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ VQPUWTG /80&/80& IT 44 4GXGTUG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 'Z (KPF %QODNCKP CW 2QPV KP 4$0 R EH CNUQ 6TGUQT FG /CCUVTKEJV + RN 8 X *GGUEJ +NKUEJ RN +8 R +P VJG FGUETKRVKQP QH VJKU JQCTF 8 *GGUEJ CPF +NKUEJ JCXG CVVTKDWVGF VJKU EQKP VQ VJG RGTKQF 6JG[ TGHGT VQ &CPP CPF VQ VJG UWEEGUUKQPCN RTQDNGOU GPUWKPI VJG OWTFGT QH DKUJQR 1VDGTV KP 6JG +PXGUVKVWTG %QPVTQXGTU[ JCF VJG .K½IG FKQEGUG FKXKFGF KPVQ VYQ ECORU 1PG UKFG NGF D[ (TGFGTKEM QH 0COWT VJG QVJGT D[ #NGZCPFGT #HVGT VJG HQTOGTʼnU FGOKUG C VJKTF RTGVGPFGT GOGTIGF DWV GXGPVWCNN[ #NGZCPFGT DGECOG DKUJQR QH .K½IG KP 6JKU KPHGTU VJCV +P XKGY QH VJG KORGTKCN EJCTCEVGT QH VJKU FGPCTKWU 8CP *GGUEJ CPF +NKUEJ CVVTKDWVG KV VQ VJG RCTV[ QH #NGZCPFGT R *QYGXGT VJGTG KU C TGUGODNCPEG DGVYGGP VJG UOCNN JGCF QP VJG QDXGTUG CPF VJQUG QP VJG EQKPU QH #CEJGP

/GP CPF C 6JG UOCNN JGCF QP VJG TGXGTUG KU VJG EJCTCEVGTKUVKECN 2KORTG\ UOCNN JGCF CICKP JGTG QH EQWTUG TGHGTTKPI VQ 5V 5GTXCVKWU #PQVJGT KPVGTGUVKPI CURGEV QH VJKU TGXGTUG KU VJCV KPUVGCF QH CP KPFKECVKQP QH 5V 5GTXCVKWUʼn PCOG KV DGCTU VJG TCVJGT XCIWG /80&/80& 6JKU /80&/80& KU FGGOGF KPGZRNKECDNG VQ FCVG JQYGXGT EQWNFPʼnV KV DG FGTKXGF HTQO OWPFKDWTFKWO! .F/ 6JKU YQTF KU C EQORQWPF QH OWPV CPF DGTCP OGCPKPI DGCTGT 6JG (TCPMU TGHGTTGF VQ VJG RQYGT CPF VJG FWV[ QH VJG GORGTQT VQ RTQVGEV VJG YJQNG EJWTEJ FGHGPUKQ GEEGUKCG CU OWPFKDWTFKWO /WPV KU RTQVGEVKQP CPF YCU HKTUV WUGF KP VJCV XGKP D[ 1VHTKGF XQP 9GKUUGPDWTI CPF KP VJG .QTUEJGT $KGPGPUGIGP C VJ EGPVWT[ )GTOCP RQGO /WPV CNUQ OGCPU UGEWTKV[ %QWNFPʼnV /80&/80& VJGTGHQTG OGCP VJCV VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT RTQVGEVGF VJG EJWTEJ 5V 5GTXCCU ! +P -NWIG &KG 5CNKGT WPFGT PQ C EQKP QH *GPT[ 8 QH #CEJGP CRRGCTU YKVJ VJG UCOG QDXGTUG GZEGRV HQT KVU ETQUKGT YJKEJ KP VJKU EQKP YCU TGRNCEGF YKVJ C RCNO NGCH

383


(4+'&4+%* + $#4$#4155#

&GPKGT -G[ # %TQYPGF JGCF N ETQUU CPF NGVVGTU +24 DTCPEJ DGJKPF 4 -G[ KP SWCVTGHQKN %.#8+5 IT 4 8GT[ HKPG X F &WUUGP 9GUVGTJQH #WEVKQP PQ

6Q TCKUG OQPG[ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC KP ITCPVGF VJG EKV[ QH /CCUVTKEJV KP HKGH VQ 4WFQNH QH <·JTKPIGP VJG DKUJQR QH .K½IG # /CCUVTKEJV EQKP CPF VYQ .K½IG EQKPU TGHGT VQ VJKU QEECUKQP 1PG QH VJG .K½IG EQKPU UJQYU VJG GORGTQT VJG QVJGT QPG VJG MG[ TGRGCVKPI VJG YQTF ENCXKU 6JG /CCUVTKEJV EQKP YQWNF JCXG DGGP UVTWEM DGHQTG VJG VYQ .K½IG EQKPU CHVGT VJCV FCVG 5RTGPIGT PQV QPN[ TGICTFU VJG TGRGVKVKXG WUG QH C MG[ QP VJG .K½IG EQKP CU GZRTGUUKPI VJG DKUJQRʼnU UYC[ QXGT /CCUVTKEJV DWV CNUQ KPVGTRTGVU VJG EJGUV WPFGT KV VQ DG VJG GZEJGSWGT HQT VJG DKUJQR PQY TGEGKXGF VJG TGXGPWG 5RTGPIGT GXGP KFGPVKHKGU VJG JCNH HKIWTG VQ VJG TKIJV CU C VTGCUWTGT 6JG .K½IG EQKPU CTG QH C HKPGT EWV VJCP VJG /CCUVTKEJV URGEKOGPU VJG .K½IG CTVKUVU JCF C JKIJGT UVCPFCTF GZRTGUUGF KP VJG HCEV VJCV VJG .K½IG EQKPU UJQY CP GORGTQT YKVJ DGCTF $CTDCTQUUC CPF VJG /CCUVTKEJV EQKPU FQ PQV

&GPKGT %JWTEJ # %TQYPGF JGCF T YKVJ QTD CPF DTCPEJ 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU IT 4 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z %CTPGIKG /WUGWO QH 0CVWTCN *KUVQT[ EQNNGEVKQP 2KVVUDWTIJ

*'+04+%* 8+

384

&GPKGT 'CING # %TQYPGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UEGRVTG 4 'CING T IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

)TGPUYKUUGNMCPVQTGP #OUVGTFCO 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 0Q UKIP QH +/2'4#614 QT CP[VJKPI QH VJG UQTV 6JKU EQKPʼnU UV[NG FQGU PQV HKV VJG RGTKQF QH (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC 6JGTG KU JQYGXGT C RCTGNNGN VQ C EQKP QH #NDGTV QH 4GVJGNʼnU UGG .K½IG 6JG TGHKPGOGPV KP VJG EWV QH VJG FKG KU UKOKNCT (QT VJKU TGCUQP VJG EQKP KU PQ NQPIGT CVVTKDWVGF VQ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC DWV VQ JKU UWEEGUUQT *GPT[ 8+ GORGTQT HTQO VQ 6JKU OGCPU KV OWUV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM DGVYGGP VJG EGUUKQP QH /CCUVTKEJV VQ VJG GORGTQT CPF VJG [GCT QH JKU FGOKUG (T½TG VQQ OGPVKQPU VJKU EQKP WPFGT PQ RNCEGU KV WPFGT 4WFQNH QH <·JTKPIGP CPF EQOOGPVU .C V¿VG FG Nʼn GORGTGWT TCRGNNG EGNNG VJG NʼnGORGTGWT .QWKU NG 2KGWZ UWT NG TGNKSWCKTG FW DTCU FG %JCTNGOCIPG EQPUGTX¾ ¯ #KZ NC %JCRGNNG GV GZ¾EWV¾ XGTU


24+0%' $+5*124+% .+–)' .7+- .ª66+%* 6JG QTKIKPCN PCOG HQT .K½IG KU .GQFKWO CHVGT VJG UOCNN TKXGT .GIKC VJCV HNQYU KPVQ VJG /GWUG PGCT .K½IG ,WUV CU /CCUVTKEJV KU VJG EKV[ QH 5V 5GTXCVKWU .K½IG KU VJCV QH 5V .CODGTV *G YCU DQTP CR RTQZ KP /CCUVTKEJV KP VJG GTC QH VJG /GTQXKPIKCP OC[QTU QH VJG RCNCEG .CODGTV YCU TCKUGF CPF GFWECVGF D[ VJG DKUJQRU QH /CCUVTKEJV .CPFQCNF CPF 6JGQFCTFWU 6JGQFCTFWU YCU CUUCUUKPCVGF CRRTQZ CPF .CODGTV UWEEGGFGF 6JGP OC[QT QH VJG RCNCEG 'DTQKP FG RQUGF .CODGTV DGECWUG QH JKU /GTQXKPIKCP CPEGUVT[ .CODGTV GNWFGF VQ 5VCXGNQV CPF YQWNF UVC[ VJGTG HQT UGXGP [GCTU $[ VJCV VKOG 2GRKP QH *GTUVCN JCF UGK\GF RQYGT *GTUVCN KU LWUV PQTVJ QH RTGUGPV FC[ .K½IG CETQUU VJG /GWUG HTQO ,WRKNNG CNUQ C /GTQXKPIKCP RQUUGUUKQP CPF TGUVQTGF .CODGTV VQ JKU GRKUEQRCN QHHKEG KP /CCUVTKEJV +P VJQUG FC[U .K½IG YCU C OGTG JCONGV C HGY UJCEMU CPF C EJCRGN KP VJG JQPQWT QH VJG 5CKPVU %QUOCU CPF &COKCPWU VJKU EJCRGN YCU HQWPFGF D[ VJG /CCUVTKEJV DKUJQR 5V /QPWNHWU .CODGTV UVC[GF TGIWNCTN[ KP .K½IG JQYGXGT VJG TGCUQPU HQT JKU FGHKPKVKXG OQXG HTQO /CCUVTKEJV VQ .K½IG TGOCKP WPENGCT *KU OWTFGT KP D[ %QWPV &QFQ KU [GV CPQVJGT O[UVGT[ .CODGTVʼnU DQF[ YCU VTCPUHGTTGF VQ /CCUVTKEJV VQ VJG 5V 2KGVGT 6JG YJGTGCDQWVU QH .CODGTVʼnU ITCXG CTG WPMPQYP #RRTQZ .CODGTVʼnU TGOCKPU CTG DTQWIJV VQ .K½IG *G YCU VJGP DWTKGF KP VJG UOCNN EJCRGN QH %QUOCU CPF &COKCPWU CV VJG RNCEG YJGTG JG YCU MKNNGF .CVGT VJG ITGCV )QVJKE 5V .CODGTV %CVJGFTCN YQWNF DG GTGEVGF VJGTG FGUVTQ[GF KP .CODGTV KU XGPGTCVGF CU 5V .CODGTV RTGUWOCDN[ UVCTVKPI CRRTQZ VJG VTCPUHGT VQ .K½IG 6JCV RNCEGF VJG TGUKFGPEG KP .K½IG KP 'EENGUKCUVKECNN[ .K½IG DGNQPIGF VQ VJG CTEJDKUJQRTKE QH %QNQIPG 2QNKVKECNN[ .K½IG YCU RCTV QH .QTTCKPG UKPEG RCTV QH VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG +P .K½IG LWUV CU /CCUVTKEJV YCU FGXCUVCVGF D[ VJG 8KMKPIU $KUJQR 0QVMGT KU VJGTGHQTG EQPUKFGTGF VQ DG VJG UGEQPF HQWPFGT QH VJG EKV[ QH .K½IG 6JG 2TKPEG DKUJQRTKE QH .K½IG KU COQPI VJG OQUV TGOCTMCDNG ETGCVKQPU QH VJG UQ ECNNGF QVVQPKUEJ UCNKUEJGU 4GKEJUMKTEJGPU[UVGO 1VVQPKCP 5CNKCP +ORGTKCN %JWTEJ 5[UVGO KP .QTTCKPG +P VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ VJG DKUJQRU RQUUGUUGF GUVCVGU CPF RTKXKNGIGU KP VJG OQUV KORQTVCPV EKVKGU QH VJG /GWUG 8CNNG[ .K½IG 6QPIGTGP /CCUVTKEJV *W[ 0COWT &KPCPV TWTCN GUVCVGU CU YGNN CU VJGKT QYP OQPCUVGTKGU 5V *WDGTV .QDDGU +P $KUJQR 0QVMGT CESWKTGF C EQORTGJGPUKXG KOOWPKV[ RTKXKNGIG HTQO 1VVQ ++ GZGORVKPI CNN GUVCVGU QH VJG .K½IG EJWTEJ HTQO EQOKVCN LWTKUFKEVKQP 'XGP OQTG OQOGPVQWU YCU VJG EJCTVGT QH KP YJKEJ 1VVQ +++ EGFGF DKUJQR 0QVMGT VJG %QWPV[ QH *W[ VJKU UGEWNCT RQYGT ICKPKPI 0QVMGT RTKPEG DKUJQR UVCVWU 6JG FQOKPKQP YCU TGIWNCTN[ GZRCPFGF QP VJG DCUKU QH VJKU UVCVWU UCY VJG EGUUKQP QH [GV CPQVJGT NCTIG CDDG[ )GODNQWZ CPF C UGEQPF EQWPV[ $TWPPGPIGTWWV UKVWCVGF DGVYGGP ,GVVG CPF &KLNG # VJKTF EQWPV[ YCU ICKPGF KP *CURKPIG NQECVGF DGVYGGP VJG /GWUG CPF KVU VTKDWVCT[ VJG )GGT 6JG %QWPV[ *CKPCWNV JCF DGGP C .K½IG EJWTEJ HKGH UKPEG CPF KP $KUJQR 1VDGTV CESWKTGF VJG ECUVNG CPF VJG VKVNG QH $QWKNNQP 6JGUG YGTG VJG OQUV UKIPKHK ECPV UVCIGU QH VGTTKVQTKCN GZRCPUKQP QH VJG RTKPEG DKUJQRTKE CPF VJG[ VQQM RNCEG CV VJG GZRGPUG QH VJG %QWPV[ 0COWT CPF KP EQPUVCPV TKXCNT[ YKVJ VJG *QWUG $TCDCPV .GWXGP +P VJG VJ CPF VJG VJ EGPVWTKGU VJG NCTIGT VGTTKVQTKGU CESWKTGF YGTG VJG EKV[ 5V 6TWKFGP CPF VJG %QWPV[ .QQ\ #HVGT VJCV VJG DQTFGTU QH VJG RTKPEG DKUJQRTKE TGOCKPGF VJG UCOG WPVKN KVU FKUUQNXKPI KP .F/ (TQO VQ VJG DKUJQR QH .K½IG VGORQTCTKN[ JGNF VQVCN CWVJQTKV[ QXGT /CCUVTKEJV UGG WPFGT /CCUVTKEJV 1VVQ ++ ITCPVGF VJG DKUJQRU QH .K½IG VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV HQT .K½IG CPF HQT /CCUVTKEJV KP HQT (QUUGU CPF RTGUWOCDN[ HQT *W[ CPF /CCUVTKEJV CU YGNN DQVJ NCUV YGTG EQPHKTOGF D[ 1VVQ +++ KP TGUR CPF KP D[ *GPT[ +++ HQT VJG %QWPV[ *CURKPICW CPF KP D[ *GPT[ +8 HQT &KPCPV CPF KP HQT VJG FKQEGUG .K½IG KP IGPGTCN .KMG GXGT[YJGTG KP VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG OKPVKPI UVCTVGF KP VJG )GTOCP GORGTQTʼnU PCOG .CVGT WUWCNN[ CTQWPF VJG PCOG QH VJG DKUJQR CRRGCTGF PGZV VQ VJCV QH VJG GORGTQT 5QOGVKOGU VJG FQWDNG KP FKECVKQP YCU CXQKFGF D[ QPN[ OGPVKQPKPI C UCKPVʼnU PCOG NKMG HQT KPUVCPEG KP .K½IG $KUJQR 4GIKPCTF YCU VJG HKTUV VQ JCXG JKU QYP PCOG CRRGCT GZENWUKXGN[ QP EQKPU

385


1661 +++

&GPKGT # *GCF N 1 6 61 ő4': 4 5 %1.10+# # OQPQITCO &CPP IT 44 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ *·XGTPKEM WPFGT PQ EQOOGPVU CU HQNNQYU &KG JPNKEJMGKV OKV IGUKEJGTVGP .ÒVVKEJGT 2T·IWPIGP &CPP DGITÒPFGV FKG $GUVKOOWPI CWH FKG /ÒP\UV·VVG .ÒVVKEJ #NNGTFKPIU Y·TG XKGNNGKEJV CWEJ /CUVTKEJV OÌINKEJ &CPP &KGU XQTNKGIGPFG )GRT·IG YWTFG HTÒJGT HÒT MÌNPKUEJ IGJCNVGP FQEJ N·UUV UKEJ FKGUG <WVGKNWPI YGIGP FGU XÌNNKI HTGOFGP 5VKNU WPF FGU UVCTM IGUWPMGPGP )GYKEJV PKEJV CWHTGEJV JCNVGP

'2+5%12#. /+06+0) VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # *GCF T 5%5 .#/$' 4685 '25 4 )TGCV # YKVJ CNRJC CPF QOGIC CV VJG NKODU DGVYGGP VYQ ETQUUGU 6 4#+'%68/ &CPP FG%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO (T½TG 4$0 OGPVKQPGF WPFGT PQ &CPPGPDGTI TCPMU VJKU WPFGT /CCUVTKEJV DWV KP XKGY QH VJG HCEV VJCV 5V .CODGTV KU KPFKECVGF KV UJQWNF DG ENCU UKHKGF WPFGT .K½IG DWV CU UVTWEM KP /CCUVTKEJV

4')+0#4&

&GPKGT %KPG[ # *GCF T 4'+0#4&85 4 +P VJTGG NKPGU %'8 0#%8 1 FG%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ +P VJG 4QJG JQCTF VJGTG KU C UKOKNCT URGEKOGP 5GG 8QPFUVGP KP 'UVNCPF R PQ YKVJ RKEVWTG 6JKU KU VJG HKTUV DKUJQR VQ KPFKECVG JKU PCOG QP C EQKP OQTGQXGT KV KU VJG QPN[ 4GIKPCTF EQKP 1H VJG OKPV %KPG[ HGY EQKPU CTG MPQYP &CPPGPDGTI OGPVKQPU VYQ CPF DQVJ QH $KUJQR &KGVYKPʼnU PCOGNGUU &G %JGUVTGV CPF /KIPQNGV MPQY QH HQWT PQ C 5V .CODGTV EQKP &CPP C D PQ CPF &CPP CPF QH DKUJQR &KGVYKPʼnU PCOGNGUU CPF PQ YKVJ C SWGUVKQP OCTM &CPP QH DKUJQR &KGVYKPʼnU PCOGNGUU #HVGT 4GIKPCTF VJG OKPV %KPG[ YCU PQV KPFKECVGF CP[OQTG PQ NQPIGT QRGTCVKQPCN QT PQ NQPIGT WPFGT VJG &KQEGUG .K½IG! 6JG VYQ NGVVGTU KP VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG CTG PQV XGT[ ENGCT +P JKU QRKPKQP KV FQGUPʼnV TGCF )+ 1P VJG URGEKOGP HTQO VJG 'UVQPKCP JQCTF 4GIKPCTF KU URGNNGF KP )GTOCP 4'+0#4&85 YJKEJ KU CNUQ VJG ECUG JGTG /KPV URGNNGF CU %'8085

386


*'04+ QH 8'4&70 *GPTK FG 8GTFWP YCU HTQO VJG KPHNWGPVKCN *QWUG #TFGPPG 8GTFWP *G YCU TGNCVGF VQ &WMG )QVHTKGF VJG *WPEJDCEM CPF VJCPMU VQ VJG NCVVGT JG DGECOG CTEJFGCEQP QH 8GTFWP CPF NCVGT DKUJQR QH .K½IG *G YCU XGT[ NQ[CN VQ VJG 'ORGTQT *G GPFGCXQWTGF VQ GUVCDNKUJ VJG 2GCEG QH )QF QH VJ /CTEJ YJGP JG RTQENCKOGF C 6TGWIC &GK VJG HKTUV KP VJG GORKTG 6JKU RGCEG KPKVKCVKXG UQWIJV VQ TGCEV VQ VJG EJCQU KP .QYGT .QTTCKPG CPF NC[ CV VJG TQQV QH VJG .K½IG 2GCEG 6TKDWPCN

&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # *GCF HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT 5'48#6+ 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU CPF RQTVCN FG%J IT 44 # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG PKEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV (KPF QH 6KTYCTV PQ CPF 4$0 EH (T½TG 4$0 PQ %QWNFPʼnV VJG TC[U KP VJG EJWTEJ U[ODQNKUG *GPT[ʼnU RGCEG GPFGCXQWT! 6JGTG YCU UQOG FKUEWUUKQP QP YJGVJGT VJGTG KU CP * RTGEGFKPI 5'48#6+ * JQN[ *QYGXGT JGTG VJGTG CTG PQ NGVVGTU VQ VJG NGHV QH VJG ETQUKGT

&GPKGT .WKM # *GCF HCEKPI 5%5 .#0 $'4685 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU ETQUU QP VQR QH VJG VQYGTU CPF NKU KP VJG OKFFNG FG%J IT 44 4GXGTUG WPEGPVGTGF XGT[ HKPG

5RKPM .QPFQP (TQO 0% PQ /& 'Z 2KORTG\ JQCTF PQ 6JKU JQCTF YCU EQPEGCNGF CTQWPF CPF YCU FKUEQXGTGF D[ EQKPEKFGPEG KP QP VJG ITQWPFU QH C JQWUG KP VJG RNCEG 2KORTG\ PGCT %QORKGIPG MO PQTVJ QH 2CTKU 6JG VQYP YCU MPQYP CU 2KORTGVKE KP CPF KP CU 2KORTG\ +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ KV YCU JQOG VQ VJG -PKIJVU 6GORNCT 6JG JQCTF YCU OCFG WR QH UKNXGT KPIQVU 'PINKUJ RGPPKGU QH *GPT[ + CPF QH 5VGRJCP CPF EQPVKPGPVCN FGPKGTU OCKPN[ HTQO /GV\ .K½IG /CCUVTKEJV 6TKGT CPF <Ã’TKEJ /GGTV R EJ 6JG UOCNN JGCF QP VJG QDXGTUG KU VJG V[RKECN 2KORTG\ UOCNN JGCF UGG CNUQ WPFGT /CCUVTKEJV +U VJKU PQV VJG %J XCECPEG FW UKGIG ! 6JKU FGPCTKWU GOGTIGF KP VJG JQCTF QH /KTYCTV EQPEGCNGF CPF KU CVVTKDWVGF VQ *GPTK FG 8GTFWP /GGTV 4$0

16$'46 6JG CPEGUVT[ QH VJKU DKUJQR KU WPMPQYP *G YCU ECPQP QH VJG ECVJGFTCN QH 5V .CODGTV CPF QH VJG 5V 5KOQP CPF ,WFCU KP )QUNCT 9KVJ VJG CKF QH 'ORGTQT *GPT[ +8 JG DGECOG DKUJQR QH .K½IG *G VQQ YCU C UVCNYCTV QH VJG GORGTQT #HVGT *GPT[ +8 DQTP KP KP )QUNCT YCU FGRQUGF CV C FKGV QH RTKPEGU QP &GEGODGT KP +PIGNJGKO CPF UWDUGSWGPVN[ VCMGP RTKU QPGT D[ JKU UQP 1VDGTV UQWIJV TGHWIG KP .K½IG YJGTG JG YCU OWTFGTGF KP

&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # $GCTFGF DWUV T YKVJ ETQUKGT 1$'4685 '2+5%1285 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ NKU QP VQR 6 #1 +'%68/ FG%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG CPF GZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN EGPVGTGF URGEKOGP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (QWPF KP #PFGNUV 5JQYP KP &G $GGNFGPCCT QP R CV VJG EQKP JQCTFU HTQO VJG OKFFNG CIGU (T½TG WPFGT PQ VJG NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG KU GZVTCQTFKPCT[ FGVCKNGF

#.':#0&'4 + 6JG QTKIKPU QH #NGZCPFGT + CTG WPMPQYP JG YCU RTGUWOCDN[ HTQO C .K½IG PQDNG JQWUG #HVGT UGXGTCN CVVGORVU JG HKPCNN[ DGECOG DKUJQR QP VJG VJ QH /CTEJ # UVCNYCTV QH .QVJCKT +++ JG FGHGCVGF )QVVHTKGF QH .GWXGP YJQ JCF NQUV JKU FWEJ[ D[ XKTVWG QH C TQ[CN FGETGG KP +P JG CTTCPIGF C OGGVKPI DGVYGGP .QVJCKT +++ CPF 2QRG +PPQEGPV ++ KP .K½IG *G YCU CEEWUGF QH UKOQP[ YJKEJ NGF VQ JKU FKUOKUUCN HTQO QHHKEG CV VJG %QWPEKN QH 2KUC KP

1DQNG # #TOQWTGF DWUV HCEKPI YKVJ UYQTF VJGTG KU RQUUKDN[ CP 1 QH VJG NGIGPF XKUKDNG 4 6YQ JGCFU DGPGCVJ VQYGT VYQ DKTFU CDQXG FG%J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (QWPF KP 8GPNQ 6JG VYQ DKTFU CTG OQUV EJCTCEVGTKUVKE QH VJKU WPMPQYP EQKP 6JG[ CTG QPN[ UGGP QP #NGZCPFGT + CPF ++ EQKPCIG YJGTG VJG[ CTG TGPFGTGF UKOKNCTN[ UVCPFKPI QP VJG VYQ QWVGT VQYGTU JQYGXGT HCEGU CTG FKUEGTPCDNG KP VJG VQYGTU JGTG (QT VJKU TGCUQP KV KU NKUVGF WPFGT #NGZCPFGT +

387


*'04+ ++ QH .+/$174)

&GPKGT *W[ # $WUV N *' +04+% 4 $WKNFKPI YKVJ VJTGG RCNO NGCHU QP VQR FG%J IT 44 7PEGPVGTGF CPF YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

47&1.( QH < *4+0)'0 4WFQNH KU C UQP QH %QPTCF QH <·JTKPIGP CPF %NGOGPVKCU QH 0COWT CPF FGUEGPFCPV QH VJG *QWUG QH VJG <·JTKPIGTU #HVGT #TEJDKUJQR #TPQNF QH /CKP\ʼn FGOKUG VJG EKVK\GPU QH /CKP\ GNGEVGF 4WFQNH CTEJDKUJQR (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC FKF PQV CEMPQYNGFIG JQYGXGT *G YCU GZEQOOWPKECVGF CV VJG %QWPEKN QH .QFK *KU DTQVJGT $GTVJQNF QH <·JTKPIGP VJGP CUMGF -KPI .QWKU 8++ VQ RNGCF YKVJ 2QRG #NGZCPFGT +++ 0CVWTCNN[ VJKU YCU CNUQ WPCEEGRVCDNG HQT (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC #TQWPF VJG TGNCVKQPUJKR DGVYGGP VJG <·JTKPIGTU CPF VJG GORGTQT KORTQXGF YJKEJ NGF VQ VJG CRRQKPVOGPV QH 4WFQNH VQ DKUJQR QH .K½IG *G VTKGF VQ GZRCPF JKU FQOKPKQP COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU D[ C ECORCKIP CICKPUV .QQ\ *G CVVGORVGF VQ JGNR JKU EQWUKP %QPTCF QH 7TCEJ UWEEGGF KP JKU QHHKEG DWV JG HCKNGF (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUCʼnU NCEM QH OQPG[ RTQORVGF JKO KP VQ EQNNCDQTCVG YKVJ 4WFQNH UGG WPFGT /CCUVTKEJV +P VJG NCVVGT TGUQNXGF VQ LQKP JKU GORGTQT KP VJG TF ETWUCFG #HVGT VJG UKGIG QH #ETG JG TGVWTPGF &WTKPI VJKU XQ[CIG JG FKGF QP VJG HCOKN[ GUVCVG QH *GTFGTP KP .GIGPF JCU KV VJCV 4WFQNH VQQM C TGNKE QH 5V .CODGTV YKVJ JKO HTQO .K½IG YJKEJ YCU YJ[ 5V .CODGTV DGECOG VJG RCVTQP UCKPV QH (TGKDWTI 6JG EQKPU QH 4WFQNH ENGCTN[ FKURNC[ CP ITGCV ETCHVUOCPUJKR 'PIGN CPF 5GTTWTG EQPEWT QP VJKU .C PWOKUOCVKSWG VJG 4WFQNH GUV FʼnWPG TKEJGUUG GZEGRVKQPGNNG GP V¾OQKIPG FʼnWP KPEQPVGUVCDNG GHHQTV CTVKUVKSWG 6JG VJ EGPVWT[ OCTMGF VJG CRQIGG QH .K½IG OGVCN CTVKUCPUJKR +V EQO OGPEGF CV VJG VWTP QH VJG EGPVWT[ YJGP KP VJG [GCTU VJG HCOQWU DCRVKUOCN HQPV QH 4GKPKGT QH *W[ YCU DWKNV 6JGUG YGTG VJG UVCTVKPI [GCTU QH 4QOCP UEWNRVWTG QH VJG /CCUUEJQQN /GWUG 5EJQQN VJCV FQOKPCVGF HQT FGECFGU VQ EQOG +P VJG EQWTUG QH VKOG PGY CTVKUVKE UEJQQNU FGXGNQRGF KP VJG /GWUG 8CNNG[ NKOKVGF VQ OGVCN UEWNRVWTKPI YJKNG CV VJG UCOG VKOG %QNQIPG FGXGNQRGF C OCLQT UEJQQN QH UVQPG UEWNRVQTU )QFGHTQKF QH *W[ YCU C OGODGT QH VJG /CCUUEJQQN JG YQTMGF KP .K½IG HQT [GCTU CPF VJGP LQKPGF VJG OQPCUVGT[ QH 0GWHOQWUVKGT KP *G JCF C NCTIG UVWFKQ KP .K½IG 6JKU UVWFKQ CNOQUV EGTVCKPN[ URCYPGF VJG FKG UKPMGT U VJCV EWV 4WFQNHʼnU EQKPU

&GPKGT .WKM # $KUJQR YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPQVJGT RGTUQP N YJKEJ JQNFU C ETQUKGT 41( '2% 4 (CNEQP WPFGT ECPQR[ DGNQY HCEG YKVJ JCPF QP TQRG YJKEJ JQNFU VJG HCNEQP ( # % 8 0 FG%J IT &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

&GPKGT .WKM # *GCF T YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPQVJGT RGTUQP T YJKEJ JQNFU C ETQUKGT 41( '2% 4 .KQP WPFGT CTEJGF XCWNV YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU JGCF DGNQY FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 9KPVGT &ÒUUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ 6JG JGCF KU UOCNNGT VJCP VJCV QH

388


&GPKGT .WKM # *GCF T YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPQVJGT RGTUQP T YJKEJ JQNFU C ETQUKGT 41( '2% 4 .KQP WPFGT CTEJGF XCWNV YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU JGCF DGNQY FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP

&GPKGT .WKM # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ DNGUUKPI JCPF CPF ETQUKGT 41( '2% 4 %JWTEJ UJQYP HTQO VJG UKFG YKVJ JGCF KP RQTVCN T DGNQY VJTGG NKU KP VJTGG DQYU FG%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

&GPKGT *W[ # $KUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT N 416 '2% 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU CPF VYQ RCNO NGCHU QP VQR FG%J IT # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG

/ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # $KUJQR YKVJ ETQUKGT DGNQY T C UOCNN JGCF 4 &+ 85 $8 4) KP HQWT EKTENGU YKVJ ETQUU KP VJG EGPVTG FG%J IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG

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ʼn TGOCKPU YKVJ VJGO VQ &WKUDWTI UGG &GGVGTU 5GTXCVKWUUVKHV WPF %KV[ /CCUVTKEJV 7PVGTUWEJWPIGP \W 'PVUVGJWPI WPF 8GTHCUUWPI KP 4JGKPKUEJGU #TEJKX

$QPP R GV UGSS

&GPKGT *W[ # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP DKUJQR CPF CPQVJGT RGTUQP 4 1 ( 4 2GTTQP N RGTUQP YKVJ TCKUGF HKPIGT T HKIWTG YKVJ UVCHH 2 ' 4 8 8 1 % FTCIQP KP GZGTIWG FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 1P VJG TGXGTUG YG UGG VJG RGTTQP C ETQUU GNGXCVGF QP VJTGG UVGRU CV VJG DCUG QH YJKEJ VJG FGETGGU QH VJG DKUJQR YGTG RWDNKUJGF 6JG .K½IG KPJCDKVCPVU EQPUKFGTGF KV VJG U[ODQN QH VJGKT HTGGFQO KV TGCRRGCTU QP UGXGTCN NCVGT .K½IG EQKPU 6JG RGTTQP YCU HKTUV FGRKEVGF QP EQKPU QH VJG DKUJQRU KP &G %JGUVTGV PQVGU VJCV WPFGTPGCVJ KU C HKUJ DWV KV KU TGCNN[ C FTCIQP 6JG FTCIQP KU QHVGP TGICTFGF CU C U[ODQN HQT JGTGU[ 6JGTG CTG UVCVWGU QH 5V 5GTXCVKWU UGG VJG 5GTXCCU NGIGPFU VJTWUVKPI JKU UVCHH KP VJG QRGPGF VJTQCV QH VJG FTCIQP KP VJG QVJGT JCPF JG JQNFU VJG MG[ 0QPGVJGNGUU KV UGGOU XCNKF VQ EQPPGEV VJG FTCIQP VQ VJG PQVKQP QH VJG ETWUCFGU HQT C EQOOGPVCT[ QP VJKU UGG WPFGT 1UPCDTÒEM (QT VJKU TGCUQP YG ENCUUKHKGF KV CV VJG GPF QH VJG UGTKGU QH 4WFQNH %QWNF VJG HKIWTG VQYCTF VJG TKIJV DGCT CP[ EQPPGEVKQP VQ VJG ETWUCFG!

389


&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # $WUV YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF RCNO NGCH HCEKPI 41( 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU 5 /#4 FG%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

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

#.$'46 QH 4'6*'. RT¾XÊV *KU WPENG &WMG *GPT[ + QH $TCDCPV WUGF JKU KPHNWGPEG VQ IGV #NDGTV QH .GWXGP CRRQKPVGF DKUJQR 6JG RGQRNG JQYGXGT EJQUG #NDGTV QH 4GVJGN C EQWUKP QH $CNFYKP 8 QH *CKPCWNV 6JG[ VWTPGF VQ *GPT[ 8+ YJQ CV VJG FKGV QH 9QTOU KP GPWPEKCVGF -QPTCF QH *QEJUVCFGP

YJKEJ YCU UCPEVKQPGF D[ 2QRG %GNGUVKPG #NDGTV QH .GWXGP TGUKUVGF CPF YCU GXGPVWCNN[ OWTFGTGF KP

&GPKGT *W[ # $WUV N YKVJ DQQM CPF ITGCV ETQUU #.$ 2 215+68 4 *QTUG T YJKEJ KU DQWPF VQ C VTGG '%85 8#0#.5 FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG #WMVKQPGU $CUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JG RTQXQUV QH VJG ECVJGFTCN JCU PQ OKVTG '%85 8#0#.5 'SXXU XCPCNU

&GPKGT 8KU¾ # $WUV QH VJG RTQXQUV YKVJ UEGRVTG #.$'46 215+68 4 .COD T QP DTKFIG UOCNN DWKNFKPI T CPF HKUJ WPFGT VJG DTKFIG /868 FG%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 6JG RTQXQUV QH VJG ECVJGFTCN JCU PQ OKVTG

#.$'46 QH %7;- #NDGTV YCU VJG UQP QH *GTOCP ++ %QWPV QH %W[M YJQUG DTQVJGT #PFTGCU YCU DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV #NDGTV QH %W[M CEMPQYNGFIGF VJG NKDGTVCVGU QH VJG .K½IG EKVK\GPU

&GPKGT *W[ # *GCF YKVJ OKVTG HCEKPI DNGUUKPI N JCPF CPF ETQUKGT KP T JCPF #.$ '25 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU JCPF QWV QH VJG ENQWFU CPF DGVYGGP TKPIU JQNFU VJG EGPVGTRKGEG FG%J IT 2CTVN[ RTGUUWTGF PKEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F %JGUVTGV OGPVKQPU C DKTF KPUVGCF QH VJG JCPF DWV KV KU C JCPF YKVJ ENQWFU EH VJG DQYU DGPGCVJ KV +V KU UWTGN[ VJG JCPF QH )QF YJKEJ RTQVGEVU VJG EJWTEJ

390


&GPKGT /CCUVTKEJV # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG ETQUKGT CPF DQQM #.$ '25 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ ETQUU DGVYGGP VYQ VQYGTU CPF NKU QP VQR / # 4 + # FG%J IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

&GPKGT *W[ # $WUV T YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT #.$ '25 4 %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU ETQYPGF D[ C ETQUU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG RQTVCN * 1 + FG%J IT 4GXGTUG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

*7)7'5 QH 2+'44'2106

&GPKGT *W[ # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT *7)1 '2 4 *QTUG T YJKEJ KU DQWPF VQ C VTGG * 1+ F%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 6JGTG KU C NCTIG FGITGG QH EQPUKUVGPE[ QH VJG TGXGTUG QH VJKU EQKP YKVJ VJCV QH PQ

,'#0 F #25

&GPKGT 6QPITGU # $WUV N YKVJ OKVTG CPF ETQUKGT + 1 * 5 4 'CING '2 % .'1& FG%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

7PVKN DKUJQR *GPT[ QH )WGNFGTU UOCNN EQKPU YGTG EKTEWNCVGF WUKPI VJG /CCUNCPF UVCPFCTF #HVGT YJGP VJG 6QWTPQKU ITQCV YCU CNTGCF[ KPVTQFWEGF EQKPU YKVJ C JKIJGT KPVGTPCVKQPCN EQORCVKDKNKV[ YGTG VWTPGF VQ 0QV QPN[ OKPVKPI EJCPIGF DWV VJG DKUJQRʼnU RQUKVKQP FKF UQ VQQ 6JG KPHNWGPEG QH VJG EKVK\GPU UVGCFKN[ KPETGCUGF 6JG UCOG FGXGNQROGPV ECP DG QDUGTXGF KP 7VTGEJV KP VJKU RGTKQF +PKVKCNN[ VJG DKUJQRU FGENKPGF ITCPVKPI VJG RGQRNG UWHHKEKGPV CWVQPQO[ +P VJG OKFFNG QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ *GPFTKM QH &KPCPV CU NGCFGT QH VJG 2GQRNGʼnU 2CTV[ KU OQFGTCVGN[ UWEEGUUHWN DWV YJCV VJG RGQRNG JCF DGGP NQQMKPI HQT YCU VJG XKEVQT[ QH VJG IWKNFU KP -QTVTKLM DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ )TCXG KPUWTIGPEKGU GXGPVWCNN[ RTQXQMGF VJG UKIPKPI QH C VTGCV[ KP KP (GZJG KP YJKEJ C HQTO QH GUVCVG CUUGODN[ YCU CITGGF QP NC[KPI VJG HQWPFCVKQP HQT VJG .K½IG 5VCVG QH VJG GUVCVGU 6JG HKTUV DKUJQRU #FQNRJG CPF 'PIGNDGTV FG NC /CTEM TGUKUVGF VJKU DWV VJGKT UWEEGUUQTU ,GCP Fʼn#TMGN CPF #TPQNF QH *QTP CESWKGUEGF 6JG .K½IG EQPUVKVWVKQP ITCFWCNN[ DGECOG EQPVTQNNGF D[ RCVTKEKCPU 7PFGT ,QJP QH $CXCTKC

GNGEV OCVVGTU ECOG VQ C JGCF CPF YKVJ VJG CKF QH ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU JG FGHGCVGF JKU CFXGTUCTKGU CV 1VJ¾G *KU UWEEGUUQT ,GCP FG *GKPUDGTI JCF TGCNN[ CNTGCF[ CEEGRVGF $WTIWPFKCP UWRTGOCE[ UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT .QWKU FG $QWTDQP 391


,'#0 FG (.#0&4' ,GCP YCU VJG UQP QH )YKLFG QH &CORKGTTG %QWPV QH (NCPFGTU CPF DTQVJGT QH 4QDGTV QH $¾VJWPG $GVYGGP JG YCU DKUJQR QH /GV\ VJGP QH .K½IG

'UVGTNKP *W[ # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP TCORCPV CPF UYQTF YJKEJ DTGCMU VJTQWIJ VJG DQTFGT a +1*#00'5 a '2% a 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ * 1 ; + KP VJG CPINGU ” .' 1&+ '0 5+5 FG%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP EQWNF DG QH ,GCP FG (NCPFTG EH (T½TG KP 4$0

#&1.2*' QH /#4%- &GUEGPFCPV HTQO VJG *QWUG QH /CTM *G KU VJG DTQVJGT QH 'PIGNDGTV ++ QH /CTM +P .K½IG #FQNRJG YCU UWEEGGFGF D[ C UQP QH 'PIGNDGTV ++ 'PIGNDGTV DKUJQR QH .K½IG CHVGT VJCV CTEJDKUJQR QH %QNQIPG +P #FQNRJ FG NC /CTEM YCU QDNKIGF VQ CUUGPV VQ VJG 2CKZ FG (GZJG TKIJVU CPF EWUVQOU EQWNF QPN[ DG CNVGTGF D[ VJG GRKUEQRCN EJCRVGT MPKIJVJQQF VJG EKVKGU CPF VJG DKUJQR

)TQU ¯ N CKING .WKM # 'CING QXGT UJKGNF QH NC /CTEM KP OWNVKNQDG #&8.2*85 ¶ &'+ )4# .'1& '25 4 /10'6# ¶ .'1&+'0 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ FG%J IT 44 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 9KPVGT &ÒUUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ 6JG GCING QP VJKU EQKP KU V[RKECN HQT .WKM

6KGTU FG XQNCPV #XTQ[ # 'CING QXGT RGNNGV #&8.2*85 ¶ '285 ¶ .'1& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# ¶ #8416'05+5 FG%J IT 44 (NCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

9KPVGT &ÒUUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ

,'#0 QH #4-'. $KUJQR QH 7VTGEJV UGG WPFGT #TMGN CPF 7VTGEJV ,GCP Fʼn#TMGN EQORNGVGF VJG 2CKZ FG (GZJG KP VJG 6TKDWPCN FGU XKPIV FGWZ KP

)TQU CW 5 2KGTTG /CCUVTKEJV # $WUV QH 5CKPV 2GVGT YKVJ DQQM CPF MG[ KP OWNVKNQDG QXGT VJG UJKGNF QH #TMGN /10'6# „ 5# Q Q 0%6+ „ 2'64+ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU +1*#00'5 ” '25 ” .'1&+'05+5 FG%J IT 44 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN RTGUGTXGF URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

392


,'#0 QH *'+05$'4) ,GCP YCU VJG UQP QH ,QJCPP + .QTF QH &CNGPDTQEM *GKPUDGTI UGG WPFGT *GKPUDGTI *KU EJKNFTGP ,QJCPP ++ .QTF QH *GKPUDGTI 9KNJGNO + .QTF QH ,ÒNKEJ CPF ,QJCPP DKUJQR QH .K½IG

*GCWOG *CUUGNV # 5JKGNF QH *GKPUDGTI WPFGT JGNOGV KP SWCVTGHQKN +1*'5 fi '2% fi .'& fi &8: fi $8.1 fi % fi .155 4 5JKGNF QH *GKPUDGTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG /10' 018# (#%6# *#55' FG%J IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP DGCTU VJG HKTUV OGPVKQP QH VJG UGEWNCT ECRCEKVKGU QH VJG RTKPEG DKUJQR &8: $8.1 &WMG QH $QWKNNQP CPF % .155 %QWPV QH .QQ\

2GVKV DTÑN¾ .WKM # 5JKGNF QH *GKPUDGTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU 1 & *'+0 ' .'1 4 2GTTQP

/10'6# 01 ” (#% .'1& FG%J IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

.17+5 QH $174$10 .QWKU YCU VJG UQP QH %JCTNGU + QH $QWTDQP 6JTQWIJ JKU OQVJGT #IPGU JG YCU TGNCVGF VQ VJG $WTIWPFKCP JQWUG #IPGU YCU VJG FCWIJVGT QH ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU *KU WPENG 2JKNKR VJG )QQF KPVTQFWEGF .QWKU VQ VJG $WTIWPFKCP EQWTV 5KOKNCT VQ VJG CUEGPV QH 2JKNKR VJG )QQFʼnU DCUVCTF UQP &CXKF VQ VJG GRKUEQRCN UGG KP 7VTGEJV 2JKNKR CUUWTGF VJCV VJG RQRG RTGFGUVKPGF [GCT QNF .QWKU VQ DGEQOG DKUJQR QH .K½IG 6JG NCVVGT JCF PQV DGGP QTFCKPGF RTKGUV DWV DGECOG DKUJQR KP CNN VJG UCOG JKU QTFKPCPEG FKF PQV VCMG RNCEG WPVKN YJGP JKU RTGFGEGUUQT ,GCP FG *GKPUDGTI YCU HQTEGF VQ TGUKIP .QWKUʼn TGKIP YCU GZVTGOGN[ HGGDNG JG YCU KP EQPUVCPV EQPHNKEV YKVJ DQWTIGQKUKG $GECWUG VJG RCTVKGU YQWNFPʼnV DG TGEQPEKNGF %JCTNGU VJG $QNF VQQM .K½IG KP CPF NCKF KV KP TWKPU #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH %JCTNGU VJG $QNF VJG HQTOGT TKIJVU CPF EWUVQOU YGTG TGUVQTGF

$NCPE C N . *CUUGNV # #TOU QH $QWTDQP ð .8&1 ” '.'% ” .'1& ” &8: ” $8. ” %1/ ” .155 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING CPF . KP VJG EGPVTG /10' ” .8 '.'% ” .'1 ” (#%6# ” *#55'. FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM KP 1PEG OQTG VJG FWMG QH $QWKNNQP CPF EQWPV QH .QQ\ *G YCU UVKNN GNGEV QP VJKU EQKP UQ KV OWUV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM DGHQTG

2CVCTF *CUUGNV # .KQP UKVVKPI N YKVJ UJKGNF QH $QWTDQP /1 '2+ .'10&+'0 (#%6# *#55'.6 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ETQUU QH HQWT NKU $0 &+% *'4'&+6#6+ 68' .::8+++ FG%J IT 4 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM CPF XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F

393


2CVCTF # .KQP JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $QWTDQP VQYGT .8&18+% '25 .'1&+'05+5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU VQYGT $'0'&+% *'4'&+6#6+ 68' FG%J IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

2CVCTF # 6YQ UJKGNFU QH $QWTDQP WPFGT URCTMU QH HKTG /10'6# '2+5%12+ .'1&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ . KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING $0%ʼn68 5+6 01/' &0+ FG%J IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG

9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV #WEVKQP PQ

,'#0 QH *140 (TQO VJG *QWUG *QQTPG #TPQNF CHVGT JCXKPI DGGP DKUJQR QH 7VTGEJV JCF CNTGCF[ DGGP DKUJQR QH .K½IG ,GCP HTQO VJG UCOG JQWUG CNUQ DGECOG DKUJQR QH .K½IG

(NQTKP F QT # #TOU QH *QTP KP VTGHQKN +1*5 &' *140 '25 .'1&+' 4 5CKPV .CODGTV UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF DNGUUKPI JCPF 5#0%685 .#/$'468 FG%J (D IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ %QOOGPV KP /KIPQNGV %GVVG OQPPCKG GUV UQWXGPV FG VT½U OCWXCKU CNQK CXGE SWGNSWGHQKU FʼnWPG OQPPCKG FʼnCTIGPV 6JG TGXGTUG VGZV KU RTGEGFGF D[ VYQ TQUGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT

$TÑN¾ # #TOU QH *QTP +1*5 &' *140 '25 .'1&+'0 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU /+5'4 04+ 3 2#5 '5 2 01$ FG%J IT 8GT[ HKPG -TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z -KTEJJGKOGT EQNNGEVKQP

$TÑN¾ # #TOU QH *QTP +1*5 &' *140 '25 .'1&+'0 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU /+5'4' 04+ 3 2#5 '5 2 01$ FG%J IT (KPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN

394


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

&GPKGT 5V 1OGT # *GCF T YKVJ 1+1 KP HTQPV QH KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG VTKCPING CPF RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING )4#6 &CPP 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

&QODTQYUMK /Ã’PUVGT 5GG VJG CRRGPFKZ QH &CPPGPDGTI PQ WPMPQYP DWV CVVTKDWVGF VQ (NCPFGTU (KTUV QEEWTCPEG KP VJG JQCTF QH .Ã’DGEM RGTKQF %QPTCF ++ RWDNKUJGF KP 5CNNGVUEJGP <GKVUEJTKHV *CGEM PQ OGTGN[ TGHGTU VQ &CPPGPDGTI CPF OGPVKQPU $CNFYKP +8 QT 8 +NKUEJ MPQYU QH URGEKOGPU (F .Ã’DGEM 5YGFKUJ JQCTFU 5VTWEM CTQWPF

&GPKGT # %TQUU YKVJ ETGUEGPV CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF QPG ETQUU KP VJG TF CPINGU $#.&8+0 4 -PQV QH HQWT VTKCPINGU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $1085 &'0# 4+85 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 +TTGIWNCT HNCP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP +P )CKNNCTF UVKNN CVVTKDWVGF VQ $CNFYKP 8 ) /WUGWO -QRGPJCIGP ) %QNN 6JQOUQP &CPPGPDGTI JQYGXGT TGHGTTKPI VQ VJG JQCTF QH 'IGTUWPF CPF 'PPGT EQPENWUKXGN[ FGOQPUVTCVGF VJCV KV YCU UVTWEM D[ $CNFYKP +8 CPF PQV D[ JKU UQP $CNFYKP 8 &CPP /WUGWO -QRGPJCIGP &CPP C 6JQOUQP %QNNGEVKQP &CPP &CPPGPDGTI %QNNGEVKQP 5GG /GVECNH %QKPCIG CPF VJG TKUG QH VJG (NGOKUJ VQYPU +P %QKPCIG KP VJG .QY %QWPVTKGU $#4 +PV R

395


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ʼnU UQP 4QDGTV ++ LQKPGF KP VJG UV ETWUCFG CPF GCTPGF VJG GRKVJGV QH ,GTWUCNGO # FCWIJVGT QH 4QDGTV VJG (TKUKCPʼn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

/CKNNG # *GCF HCEKPI Ã + %+8 6#5 4 %TQUU YKVJ YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG RGNNGV CPF & % 1 / KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 44 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG

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

2*+.+2 QH VJG #.5#%' 2JKNKR QH VJG #NUCEG TGRNCEGF VJG XKUEQWPVU YKVJ DCKNKHHU YJQ JG EQWNF QWUV CPF OQXG CTQWPF CU JG RNGCUGF 6JG YGCNVJ CPF RQYGT QH VJG (NGOKUJ EQWPVU YCU EQPUKFGTCDNG 2JKNKR YCU YGFFGF VQ VJG JGKTGUU QH 8GTOCPFQKU +P 2JKNKR YCU CRRQKPVGF EQWPUGN QH VJG (TGPEJ MKPI 2JKNKR #WIWUV +P 2JKNKR FKGF KP VJG 5KGIG QH #ETG KP 2CNGUVKPC YJKEJ RTQORVGF VJG (TGPEJ MKPI VQ VT[ VQ UGK\G (NCPFGTU DWV 2JKNKRʼnU DTQVJGT KP NCY $CNFYKP 8 QH *CKPCWV JCF IQV VJG PGYU C NKVVNG GCTNKGT CPF VJYCTVGF VJG MKPIʼnU RNCPU 2JKNKR #WIWUVWU UQNGN[ OCPCIGF VQ NC[ JCPFU QP VJG FQYT[ QH 2JKNKR QH VJG #NUCEGʼnU YKHG #TVQKU

/CKNNG PF RGTKQF )GPV # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV ) # 0 6 YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU DGVYGGP VJG NGVVGTU 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 2* %1/'5 ,) F IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

396


/CKNNG PF RGTKQF )GPV # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV ) # 0 6 YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU DGVYGGP VJG NGVVGTU 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 2* %1/'5 ,) F IT 8GT[ HKPG

)QTP[ /ร PEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

/CKNNG UV RGTKQF .GPU # %TQUU UJCRGF TQUGVVG YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG .'0 Q 5+5 4 %TQUU YKVJ HKXG ETQUU UJCRGF RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU (%1 /'5 ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-ร NPGT /ร P\MCDKPGVV #WEVKQP PQ /CKNNGU HTQO .GPU JCXG QPN[ QEEWTGF KP VJG JQCTF $GXGTGP 9CCU WPMPQYP PWODGT 5GG )J[UUGPU R +P VJGUG VKOGU (NCPFGTU UVQQF WPFGT UW\GTCKPV[ QH (TCPEG CPF YCU GEQPQOKECNN[ DQWPF VQ 'PINCPF YQQN [GCTN[ XKUKVU VQ VJG %JCORCIPG HCKTU VQQM RNCEG CPF +ORGTKCN (NCPFGTU YCU C HKGH QH VJG )GTOCP GORGTQT CPF JCF VTCFG TGNCVKQPU YKVJ %QNQIPG COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU

$17&'9+,0 +: $CNFYKP YCU YGFFGF VQ /CTICTGV QH VJG #NUCEG VJG UKUVGT QH 2JKNKR QH VJG #NUCEG $CNFYKP YCU EQWPV QH *CKPCWV CPF VQQM RCTV KP VJG VJ ETWUCFG VJCV GPFGF YKVJ VJG QEEWRCVKQP QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG $CNFYKP DGECOG VJG HKTUV GORGTQT QH VJG .CVKP 'ORKTG C UJQTV NKXGF TGKIP JQYGXGT JG FKGF KP VJG DCVVNG CICKPUV VJG $WNICTKCPU KP

/CKNNG PF RGTKQF )GPV # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV ) # ล 6 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $ % 1 / ' 5 ,) D IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEJGUEJK $TWUUGN

/CKNNG PF RGTKQF )GPV # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV ) # UNKPI YKVJ RGNNGV 0 รฐ 6 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING $ % 1 / ' 5 ,) D IT 8GT[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU

/#+..'5 QH (.#0&'45 )J[UUGPU ENCUUKHKGU VJG OCKNNGU KP RGTKQFU UV RGTKQF PF RGTKQF TF RGTKQF VJ RGTKQF 1H C PWODGT QH EQKPU JG KUPล V CDNG VQ FGVGTOKPG VJG RGTKQF QH UQOG JG FQGUPล V RTQXKFG VJG OKPV 6JGUG YGTG EQKPU UVTWEM D[ VJG EKVKGU OQUVN[ YKVJ KPFKECVKQP QH VJG OKPV QPN[ UQOGVKOGU KPENWFKPI VJG OQPG[GT +P VJG TF RGTKQF VJG TGKIP QH /CTICTGV QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG EQOOGPEGF 5JG JCF PQTOCN FGPCTKK UVTWEM YJKNG VJG EKVKGU EQPVKPWGF OKPVKPI OCKNNGU WPVKN CRRTQZ #.156

PF RGTKQF /QPG[GT #TPQV # *GCF YKVJ UYQTF T a # 4 0 1 6 4 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU # . 1 5 6 ,) F IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

TF RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UVCPFCTF N TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV QXGT JKU T UJQWNFGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG Q Q ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP

397


TF RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UVCPFCTF N TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV QXGT JKU T UJQWNFGT 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG Q Q ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU

#461+5

VJ RGTKQF # 'UEWVEJGQP QH #TVQKU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP JQTK\QPVCN NKPGU CPF NKU # 4 # 5 KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

2NCVV 2CTKU 4KEJGDG OGPVKQPU VJCV VJG[ EQWNF JCXG DGGP UVTWEM WPFGT 4QDGTV + QT 4QDGTV ++

VJ RGTKQF # 'UEWVEJGQP QH #TVQKU KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VYQ NKODU GPFKPI KP NKU # 4 # ) KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JKU EQKP KU FTCYP KP )J[UUGPU YJKEJ OGCPU PQPG JCF DGGP HQWPF *KU FTCYKPI VJGTGHQTG YCU CNUQ RWDNKUJGF KP &G $GGNFGPCCT R 1PDGMGPFG XCTKCPV QH GGP FGPCTKWU QH #TVQKU

$'6*70'

PF RGTKQF # 6JTGG NKU KP VTKCPING YKVJ QPG UVCT KP VJG CPINGU 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU VJG TKPIU CTG VKGF VQIGVJGT D[ C NKPG $'680' ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

*KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP ņ #WEVKQP PQ

PF RGTKQF # 6TKCPING YKVJ QPG TKPI CPF RGNNGV CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD NKU KP VJG CPINGU 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU $ ' 6 7 KP VJG CPINGU DGVYGGP VJG RGNNGV CPF VJG TKPI ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

$47))'

PF RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UJKGNF CPF UYQTF T 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG QH RGNNGVU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG VYQ TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING ,) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU

VJ RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF T 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ,) IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

398


VJ RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF T 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ,) IT

8GT[ HKPG

)QTP[ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ

VJ RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF T UVCT DGHQTG JKO 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP

VJ RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF T 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING ,) D IT 8GT[ HKPG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU

VJ RGTKQF # -PKIJV YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF T 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP

'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F 6JG HNCOKUJ NKQP KU ENGCTN[ XKUKDNG QP VJG UJKGNF

&17#+

7PEGTVCKP RGTKQF # 6TGG YKVJ VGP DTCPEJGU QXGT VYQ TKPIU 4 %TQUU QXGT UOCNNGT ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VYQ ETQUUGU CPF VYQ NKU ,) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG *KTUEJ /ÒPEJGP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP ECPPQV DG RWV KP QPG QH VJG HQWT RGTKQFU

7PEGTVCKP RGTKQF # 6TGG YKVJ VGP DTCPEJGU QXGT VYQ TKPIU 4 %TQUU QXGT UOCNNGT ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ ETQUUGU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG )J[UUGPU RTQXKFGU QPN[ C FTCYKPI EQKP JCFPʼnV DGGP HQWPF

''0#/'

PF RGTKQF # /QPQITCO YKVJ ETQUKGT CPF NKU VQRRGF UEGRVTG # YKVJ TKPI # CPF # YKVJ JQTK\QPVCN UVTKRGU 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1+*85 ! + ++ ,) IT 4 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN #VVTKDWVKQP VQ 'GPCOG KU FWDKQWU QTKIKPCNN[ ECOG HTQO 5GTTWTG 4$0 R )J[UUGPU QP R

PQ YTKVGU VJCV CVVTKDWVKQP VQQM RNCEG QP VJG DCUKU QH VJG ETQUU UGG 2JKNKR QH VJG #NUCEG CPF $CNFYKP +: 6JG UWIIGUVKQP QH 'GPCOG KU CFQRVGF D[ &CPPGPDGTI 6JG YGKIJV FQGUPʼnV OCVEJ VJCV QH VJG EQKPU KP VJG OCKNNG UGTKGU 6JG CTTCPIGOGPV CPF FGRKEVKQP QH VJG ETQUKGT CPF VJG UEGRVTG HNGWTFGNKU¾ UJQYU C UVTKMKPI TGUGODNCPEG VQ VJQUG QP VJG OCKNNG QH 5V 1OGT UGG PQ 6JKU EQKP KU CNUQ CVVTKDWVGF VQ 1UPCDTÒEM *·NDNKPI -GPPGRQJN &KG /ÒP\GP XQP 1UPCDTÒEM PQ QP PQ VJG OKFFNG # KU PQV QRGP CV KVU DCUG -GPPGRQJNʼnU TGCFKPI QH VJG VGZV QP PQ KU 150+*8))' CPF QP PQ 1+ +8) + QH 1+*8% + YJKEJ CRRTQCEJGU VJKU EQKPʼnU VGZV 6JG YGKIJV QH PQ KU IT 1H VJG V[RG QH PQ HQWT URGEKOGPU CTG KPFKECVGF VJCV TGUR YGKIJ IT IT IT CPF IT DQVJ HKTUV CTG HTQO VJG $GNIKCP JQCTF QH 'TYGVGIJGO HTQO CTQWPF *·XGTPKEM &KG /ÒP\GP XQP -ÌNP WPFGT PQ OGPVKQPU -GPPGRQJN PQ UCOG RKGEG CPF WPFGT PQ -GPPGRQJN PQ QH YJKEJ PGKVJGT UVWF[ RTQXKFGU C YGKIJV *·XGTPKEM JQNFU VJG VGZV QP PQ VQ DG EQPENWUKXG RTQQH QH VJG OKPV DGKPI 1UPCDTÒEM 6JKU EQKP YCU ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT 'GPCOG CNNQYKPI HQT VJG HCEV VJCV CNVJQWIJ -GPP EQPUVKVWVGU C IGPWKPG 1UPCDTÒEM EQKP VJG OCP[ URGEKOGPU -GPP EQPUKFGTKPI VJG ICTDNGF VGZVU CPF VJG NQYGT YGKIJV YGTG KOKVCVKQPU QH KV UVTWEM CV VJG #DDG[ QH 'GPCOG

399


)'06

PF RGTKQF /QPG[GT )GTQNH # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV CPF NKU KP KV ) a # + 0 a 6 4 %TQUU YKVJ HQWT RGNNGVU KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU )'41.( ,) D IT 4 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

1T )GUVKQP 0WOKUOCVKSWG 2CTKU #EVWCNN[ )J[UUGPU FQGU PQV TGCNN[ MPQY VJKU EQKP 1P 0WODGT D VJG HQWT RGNNGVU CNUQ OCMG WR C USWCTG DWV TCVJGT QPG UVCPFKPI QP KVU EQTPGT 1H VJKU V[RG )J[UUGPU MPQYU QH QPN[ C UKPING URGEKOGP $TWUUGNU

TF RGTKQF # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV RGNNGV CPF TKPI DGJKPF JKO 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ EKTENG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VYQ CPINGU QH KV ) # 0 6 KP VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV D PQ

TF RGTKQF # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU QPG NKU KP VJG JGNOGV RGNNGV CPF TKPI DGJKPF JKO 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ EKTENG KP VJG EGPVTG CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VYQ CPINGU QH KV ) # 0 6 KP VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

VJ RGTKQF # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU VJTGG TKPIU KP VJG JGNOGV NKU QP VQR CPF ETQUU DGJKPF 4 1RGP ETQUU YKVJ DGPFGF NKODU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F

VJ RGTKQF # *GCF N YKVJ JGNOGV KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU VJTGG TKPIU KP VJG JGNOGV NKU QP VQR CPF ETQUU DGJKPF 4 1RGP ETQUU YKVJ DGPFGF NKODU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

VJ RGTKQF # *GNOGV 4 %TQUU YKVJ DGPFGF NKODU ,) IT 44 5NKIJVGN[ RTGUUWTGF XGT[ HKPG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ EH 4$0 R

-1464+,-

VJ RGTKQF # 5JKGNF YKVJ VJTGG TQUGVVGU VJTGG TKPIU CTQWPF KV 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ % 8 4 6 KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

400


.+..'

PF RGTKQF # 6TKCPING YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP TKPIU YKVJ QPG NKU CV GCEJ UKFG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV CPF . + . # KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU

TF RGTKQF # .KU YKVJ VYQ UVCTU HQWT TKPIU CPF VYQ ETGUEGPVU CTQWPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP VJG CPINGU QH C UOCNNGT EKTENG CPF . ETGUEGPV + ETGUEGPV KP VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

TF RGTKQF # .KU KP UOCNN EKTENG YKVJ HQWT TKPIU CPF HQWT ETGUEGPVU CNVGTPCVKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG QH RGNNGVU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP EKTENG CPF EGPVTG . + . # KP VJG QWVGT CPINGU ,) IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

VJ RGTKQF # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKU CPF QPG TKPI CV GCEJ UKFG 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP EKTENG CPF EGPVTG . + . # KP VJG QWVGT CPINGU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

/+&&'.$74)

7PEGTVCKP RGTKQF # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ UVCHHU CPF VYQ TKPIU 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP NKU ,) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP #RCTV HTQO DGKPI CVVTKDWVGF VQ 5V 1OGT KV WUGF VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ 6QWTPCK CPF /KFFGNDWTI

7PEGTVCKP RGTKQF # 6YQ ETQUKGTU DGVYGGP VYQ NKU 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP NKU ,) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP $QVJ VJGUG CTG CVVTKDWVGF VQ /KFFGNDWTI FWG VQ VJG HCEV VJCV CNN MPQYP URGEKOGPU YGTG HQWPF VJGTG

14%*+'5

UV RGTKQF # #NRJC CPF QOGIC KP VJG HKGNF 14%5 +'6 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ' KP GCEJ CPING /1+'5#6 ,) C IT 44 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG

-ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCDKPGVV -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

401


/10';'4 5+/10

UV RGTKQF # 6YQ NKU UVCT CDQXG CPF ETGUEGPV DGNQY HQWT TKPIU CTQWPF KV 4 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ UVCHH CPF RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU CPF UVCHH YKVJ ETGUEGPV KP VYQ CPINGU 5 + / 1 0 ( ' % ,) D IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

UV RGTKQF # 6YQ NKU UVCT CDQXG CPF ETGUEGPV DGNQY HQWT TKPIU CTQWPF KV 4 %TQUU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU CPF ETGUEGPV KP VYQ CPINGU 5 + / 1 0 ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU

UV RGTKQF # / ' KP VJG HKGNF TKPI CDQXG CPF DGNQY HQWT ETGUEGPVU YKVJ VJTGG UVTKRGU KP KV CTQWPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKPG KP GCEJ CPING GPFKPI VYKEG KP RGNNGV CPF VYKEG KP TKPI 5 + / 1 0 ,) IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

UV RGTKQF # /' KP VJG HKGNF TKPI CDQXG CPF DGNQY % % % % 4 5OCNN ETQUU KP EKTENG YKVJ VYQ TKPIU CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU 5 + / 1 0 ,) C IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

/Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

56 1/'4

UV RGTKQF # 6YQ HKIWTGU UVCPFKPI CPF JQNFKPI QPG UVCHH GPFKPI KP NKU 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING 1 / ' 5 1 / ' 5 ,) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU )J[UUGPU MPQYU QH QPN[ QPG URGEKOGP KP VJG OWUGWO QH .KNNG 6JG QDXGTUG QH VJKU EQKP DTKPIU VQ OKPF VJG EQKP QH VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI 5VGRJGP 0 YJQ YCU QTKIK PCNN[ HTQO VJG (TGPEJ *QWUG QH $NQKU 6JKU 'PINKUJ EQKP HTQO ;QTM UJQYU 5VGRJGP CPF JKU YKHG /CVJKNFG QP VJG QD XGTUG 5WEJ CP CTTCPIGOGPV QP EQKPU YCU EQOOQP CPF UQ YCU VJG QTPCOGPVGF TGXGTUG YJKEJ ECWUGF VJKU V[RG VQ DG CVVTKDWVGF VQ 5VGRJGP KP JKU ECRCEKV[ QH EQWPV QH $QWNQIPG YJKEJ YCU VGPVCVKXGN[ RTQRQUGF D[ &GUEJCRU FG 2CU KP VJG 4GXWG 0WOKUOCVKSWG R CPF HKI JQYGXGT &KGWFQPP¾ /CPWGN +8 R YCU PQV EQPXKPEGF CPF YTQVG 'VKGPPG FG $NQKU 5VGRJGP VTQR QEEWR¾ QWVTG /CPEJG NCKUUC UQP HKNU 'WUVCEJG +8 OQPPC[GT ¯ $QWNQIPG +P VJKU RGTKQF &KTM QH VJG #NUCEG ECPFKFCVG QH VJG (NGOKUJ EKVKGU DGECOG EQWPV QH (NCPFGTU YKVJ VJG CKF QH VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI 5V 1OGT CTQWPF VJG UCOG VKOG CESWKTGF TKIJVU CPF KVU DQWTIGQKUKG QTICPKUGF KVUGNH KP C VTCFG IWKNF VJCV YCU ITCPVGF VJG TKIJV QH OKPV UGG ,CPUGP R 6JWU KV KU XGT[ NKMGN[ VJCV 5VGRJGPʼnU 'PINKUJ RGPP[ YCU KOKVCVGF KP 5V 1OGT CPF PQV CNVQIGVJGT KORQUUKDNG KP XKGY QH VJG JKUVQTKECN FGXGNQROGPV VJCV &KTM QH VJG #NUCEG CPF JKU YKHG 5KD[NNG QH #PLQW CTG RQTVTC[GF QP VJG EQKP

C UWIIGUVKQP VJCV 8CP )GNFGT VJQWIJV OKIJV DG RQUUKDNG EQTT LWPK (KPCNN[ 4KEJGD¾ OGPVKQPU C EQKP HTQO .GPU RQTVTC[KPI C UKOKNCT EQWRNG PQ YJKEJ JG CVVTKDWVGU VQ 'VKGPPG CPF /CVJKNFG UVTWEM KP 6JKU FGXGNQROGPV YCU FKUEWUUGF KP RCTVKEWNCT YKVJ TGICTF VQ OKPVKPI KP 'PINCPF ;QTM KP 5GCD[ 5QOG EQKPU QH 5VGRJGP CPF 'WUVCEG CPF TGNCVGF KUUWGU QH YGUVGTP (NCPFTGU +P %QKPCIG KP VJG .QY %QWPVTKGU $#4 +PV R VJG CDQXG FTCYKPIU YGTG VCMGP HTQO VJCV CTVKENG

402


UV RGTKQF # %TQUKGT DGVYGGP VYQ UVCTU CPF VYQ TKPIU Q 5 1 1 Q 5 1 & Q 5 1 1 Q 5 1 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP GCEJ CPING HQWT YJGGNU FKXKFKPI VJG NGVVGTU 5 CPF / UWTTQWPFGF D[ VYQ TKPIU ,) IT 4 %QTTQFGF HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

-ÌNPGT /ÒP\MCDKPGVV #WEVKQP PQ

56 8'0#06

UV RGTKQF # %TQUU VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP EKTENG CPF RGNNGV QPG EKTENG KP VJG EGPVTG 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKPG KP VYQ CPINGU CPF QPG RGNNGV KP VYQ CPINGU 8 0 # ' 0 6 1 ,) IT 44 5NKIJVGN[ ENGCPGF XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU

;24'5

UV RGTKQF # 6TKCPING KP EKTENG YKVJ 6 KP VJG CPINGU * % + $ = ? + + 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING + 2 4 ' ,) D IT 4 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP )J[UUGPU OGPVKQPU 2TKX¾ EQNNGEVKQP VJKU EQKP +P¾FKV ņ VJKU EQKP KU UJQYP KP )J[UUGPU

UV RGTKQF # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP CPF QPG TKPI CV GCEJ UKFG 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP NKU CPF + 2 4 ' KP VJG CPINGU ,) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

PF RGTKQF # 6YQ VTKCPINGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP TKPIU HQWT TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGV CPF HQWT UVCTU CTQWPF 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU + 2 4 # ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

PF RGTKQF # 6YQ VTKCPINGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI CNVGTPCVKPI KP TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV QT NKU QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ TKPIU KP VJG CPINGU DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG + 2 4 # KP VJG QWVGT CPINGU ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

$4'& 2CTKU

403


PF RGTKQF # 6YQ VTKCPINGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI CNVGTPCVKPI KP TKPI YKVJ RGNNGV QT NKU QPG TKPI KP GCEJ CPING 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG VYQ TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING QH VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

PF RGTKQF # 6YQ VTKCPINGU YKVJ EWTXGF UKFGU QXGT GCEJQVJGT VJG NKODU GPFKPI CNVGTPCVKPI NKU QT TKPI 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG VYQ TKPIU YKVJ RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING QH VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ

TF RGTKQF # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJTGG RGNNGVU 4 %TQUU YKVJ UOCNN EKTENG CPF QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING DGVYGGP VJG EKTENG CPF VJG EGPVTG + 2 4 # KP VJG CPINGU QH VJG QWVGT EKTENG ,) IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO

VJ RGTKQF # 5JKGNF YKVJ NKQP KP KV QPG TKPI DGVYGGP VYQ RGNNGVU CV GCEJ UKFG 4 .QPI QRGP ETQUU YKVJ VYQ EKTENGU QH RGNNGVU CPF + 2 4 # KP VJG CPINGU DGVYGGP VJGO ,) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

016 %'46#+0 .1%#.+<'&

UV RGTKQF # $WUV T KP EKTENG QH RGNNGVU 4 5OCNN ETQUU YKVJ QPG NKPG KP GCEJ CPING GPFKPI KP TKPI ,) D IT (KPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP

PF RGTKQF # %TQYPGF JGCF N 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG RGNNGV KP GCEJ CPING ,) IT

4 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP 6JG YGKIJV KU EQPUKFGTCDN[ JKIJGT VJCP KU PQTOCN HQT OCKNNGU KV KU CDQWV FQWDNG CU JGCX[ YJKEJ EQTTGURQPFU YKVJ VJG YGKIJVU VJCV YGTG EWTTGPV KP QVJGT $GNIKCP RCTVU QH VJG )GTOCP 'ORKTG )J[UUGPU TGHGTU VQ VJKU YJGP JG PQVGU VJCV KP CP CITGGOGPV YCU OCFG YKVJ (TGFGTKEM $CTDCTQUUC QP VJG EKTEWNCVKQP QH VJG KORGTKCN EQKP KP (NCPFGTU R *G VJGTGHQTG EQPUKFGTU VJG RQUUKDKNKV[ VJCV VJKU V[RG YCU UVTWEM KP +ORGTKCN (NCPFGTU R +P VJG RGTKQF HTQO VQ ,GCPPG FCWIJVGT QH $CNFYKP 8+ TGKIPGF YJQ YCU CNUQ EQWPVGUU QH *CKPCWV UGG WPFGT %QWPV[ *CKPCWV #NVJQWIJ UJG YCU QPN[ [GCTU QNF KP VJG (TGPEJ MKPI 2JKNKR #WIWUVWU FKURQUGF QH JGT KP OCTTKCIG VQ (GTTCPF QH 2QTVWICN (GTTCPF YCU ECRVWTGF D[ VJG (TGPEJ KP KP VJG $CVVNG QH $QXKPGU #KTG CPF 5V 1OGT YQWNF RCUU VQ (TCPEG CICKP #HVGT ,GCPPG YQWNF DG C YKNN NGUU KPUVTWOGPV QH VJG (TGPEJ MKPI

404


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

)TQU #NQUV # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING KP SWCVTGHQKN (.#0&4+' ” #% ” *#;010+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG CPF CV VJG GPF QH GCEJ NKOD # . 1 5 KP VJG CPINGU /#4)# 4'6# %1/+6+55# ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN (TQO HKPF #NMGP PQ 5VTWEM HTQO QP EH HQT VJG FCVKPI 2 )TKGTUQP .C FCVG FGU DCWFGMKPU FG /CTIWGTKVG FG %QPUVCPVKPQRNG KP $%'0 R

)9+,&' )7; &#/2+'44' 6JG #XGUPGU RQUGF C VJTGCV VQ (NCPFGTU HTQO *CKPCWV CPF *QNNCPF 6JGTGHQTG )W[ KP YKVJFTGY HTQO JKU HGCNV[ VQ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG CPF CNNKGF YKVJ 'PINKUJ MKPI 'FYCTF + # (TGPEJ CTO[ VJGP CUUCWNVGF (NCPFGTU CPF )W[ CPF JKU UQP 4QDGTV YGTG VCMGP RTKUQPGT CPF NQEMGF WR KP 2CTKU (NCPFGTU ECOG WPFGT (TGPEJ IQXGTPQT ,CESWGU FG %J³VKNNQP %QWPV QH 5V 2QN 6JG EKVKGU QRRQUGF $TWIGU KP RCTVKEWNCT $TWIUG OGVVGP &G %J³VKNNQP HNGF 6JG (TGPEJ MKPI JQYGXGT UQWIJV TGXGPIG 1P VJG VJ ,WN[ VJG (TGPEJ CTO[ YCU EQPHTQPVGF D[ VJG VTQQRU QH VJG (NGOKUJ EKVKGU PGCT %QWTVTCK 6JG (TGPEJ UWHHGTGF C FGXCUVCVKPI FGHGCV CPF VJGKT ECRVWTGF URWTU YGTG JWPI KP VJG %JWTEJ QH 1WT .CF[ KP %QWTVTCK

6JG $CVVNG QH VJG )QNFGP 5RWTU 6JG (TGPEJ YQWNF TGVWTP +P (NCPFGTU YCU XCPSWKUJGF CPF VJG GPUWKPI 2GCEG QH #VJKUUWT 1TIG YCU CU JWOKNKCVKPI HQT (NCPFGTU CU KV YCU KORQTVCPV VQ UCHGIWCTF KVU KPFGRGPFGPEG

'UVGTNKP #NQUV # &QWDNG JGCFGF GCING ” ) ” %1/'5 (. ã #0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ” %+8 +6# 5Q#. 156 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

'UVGTNKP &COOG # (CEKPI JGCF ) ” %1/'5 ” (.#0&+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 5+) 08/ %48 %+5 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 5NKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF XGT[ HKPG

2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ 'UVGTNKPU YKVJ 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTG OCFG QH KPHGTKQT OGVCN UVTWEM KP &COOG VJCV VJGTG YCU C OKPV KP &COOG KU RTQXGP KP C FQEWOGPV QH TF 5GRVGODGT /C[JGY PQ MPQYU QH QPN[ VYQ URGEKOGPU DQVJ KP $/ 6JKU URGEKOGP KU HKPGT VJCP VJG QPGU UJQYP KP /C[JGY 6JGTG CTG OKPQT FKHHGTGPEGU KP VJG VGZV HQT KPUVCPEG C FKHHGTGPV KPVGTRWPEVKQP /C[JGY OGPVKQPU C VQVCN QH URGEKOGPU KP $/ CPF KP RTKX EQNN

405


41$'46 QH $'6*70' 6JKU EQWPV YCU UGXGTGN[ CHHGEVGF D[ VJG QWVEQOG QH VJG 6TGCV[ QH #VJKU UWT 1TIG CPF VJG JKIJ VCZGU VJCV JCF DGGP NGXKGF QP (NCPFGTU 6JG EKVKGU TGDGNNGF CU VTCFG FGETGCUGF CPF VJG EQWPVT[ YCU UVTWEM D[ C HCOKPG

$CWFGMKLP #NQUV # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N 41$'4685 ¶ %1/'5 ¶ (.#&4+' 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# ¶ 8+..' ¶ # ¶ .156'05+5 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT &CTM RCVKPC UOCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

'UVGTNKP #NQUV # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 4 ã %1/'5 ã (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# #.1 6'0 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

'UVGTNKP #NQUV # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI 4 ” %1/'5 (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# #.1 6'0 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

)NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 0QDNG EQNNGEVKQP #WUVTCNKC

(KPP -GPFCN 'Z , ( %JQYP EQNNGEVKQP

'UVGTNKP #NQUV # %TQYPGF JGCF N UQ ECNNGF 5EJQVU V[RG 41$ ¶ %1/'5 ¶ (.#0& 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# #.1 56'0 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG UNKIJVGN[ EQTTQFGF GZEGNNGPV RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

406

'UVGTNKP )GPV # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI '&. 41$'4685 %1/'5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# )#0 &'5 ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 6QFGTK (NQTGPEG '&. UVCPFU HQT GFGN VJKU KU DGECWUG QH VJG TGUGODNCPEG VQ VJG GPINKUJ RGPPKU QH 'FYCTF


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¾E[ JGPEG JG KU QHVGP ECNNGF .QWKU FG %T¾E[ .QWKU DGUKFGU (NCPFGTU QYPGF VJG EQWPVKGU 4GVJGN CPF 0GXGTU JGPEG .QWKU QH 0GXGTU

)QWFIWNFGP )GPV # 5CKPV ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV UVCPFKPI 5 +1*# 00'5 $ NKQPU JGCF 4 (NGWT FG NKU QH HNQTGPVKPG . (.#& %1/'5 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP EC

)TQU )GPV # .KQP TCORCPV KP OWNVKNQDG /10'6# „ )#0&'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ GCINGU CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU .8&18+% „ %1/'5 (.#& ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN HNCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

/KLV )GPV # )TGCV . DGVYGGP VYQ ENQXGTU CPF VYQ VTGHQKNU /10'6# ” )#0&'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ) # 0 & KP VJG CPINGU .8& %1/ (.# &4+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC &GNHV 'Z FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP PQ

/KLV )GPV # )TGCV . DGVYGGP HQWT ENQXGTU /10'6# „ )#0&'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF .8& %1/ (.#&4+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC &GNHV 'Z FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP PQ

407


)TQU #NQUV # .KQP TCORCPV KP OWNVKNQDG /10'6# „ #.156'05+5 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ GCINGU CNVGTPCVKPI KP VJG CPINGU .8&18+% „ %1/'5 (.#& ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ 2C[ CVVGPVKQP VQ VJG UVTCPIG NGVVGTU 6 CPF .

)TQU #NQUV # .KQP TCORCPV /10'6# „ #.156'05+5 4 %TQUU .8&18+% Q %1/'5 Q (.#& ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 (NCP ETCEM QVJGTYKUG XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 6JG QDXGTUG KU ) CPF VJG TGXGTUG NQQMU NKMG )

/KLV #NQUV # )TGCV . DGVYGGP VYQ ENQXGTU CPF VYQ VTGHQKNU /10'6# #.1565 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF .8& %1/ (.# &4+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

$GEMGPDCWGT /Ã’PEJGP

.GGWYGPITQQV #NQUV # .KQP TCORCPV Ö /10'6# Z (.#0& YKVJKP CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU 4 .8&18+% Z %1/'5 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ ¶ +*8 ¶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

CU ITCPFUQP QH 2JKNKR +8 JG YCU PGCTGT KP NKPG VQ VJG VJTQPG VJCP 2JKNKR 8+ QH 8CNQKU YJQ YCU HTQO C UKFG DTCPEJ 2JKNKR 8+ KOOGFKCVGN[ UGPV C HNGGV DWV YCU FGHGCVGF CV 5NWKU D[ VJG 'PINKUJ CPF VJG (NGOKPIU #NVJQWIJ ,CEQD QH #TVGXGNFG EQWNF EQWPV QP VJG UWRRQTV HTQO VJG EKVKGU $TWIGU +GRGT CPF )JGPV QVJGTU QRRQUGF *G YCU OWTFGTGF KP

408


.1&'9+,- FG /#.' #U VJG 'PINKUJ MKPIʼnU CVVGPVKQP YCU PGGFGF GNUGYJGTG .QWKU QH 0GXGTUʼn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

)QWFGP UEJKNF OGV CFGNCCT # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING .8&18+%85 ” &'+ Z Z )4# Z %1/'5 ” < ” &05 ” (.#& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ %JTKUVWU XKPEKV %JTKUVWU TGIPCV %JTKUVWU KORGTCV %JTKUV XCPSWKUJGU %JTKUV TGKIPU %JTKUV TWNGU 0GEGRJQTWU 8+++ .CWFGU 4GIKCG NKVWTIKECN CEENCOCVKQP QH VJG MKPI

)QWFGP UEJKNF OGV CFGNCCT # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING .1&18+%85 ” &'+ Z )4# Z %1/'5 ” < ” &05 (.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG %NCUUKECN 0WO )TQWR .CPECUVGT #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM 'Z 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ #PVYGTRUG DCPMKGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

)QWFGP UEJKNF OGV CFGNCCT # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF FQWDNG JGCFGF GCING .8&18+% ” &'+ Z Z )4# Z %1/'5 ” (.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% Q 8+%+6 Q :2% Q 4')0#6 Q :2% Q +2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 &QWDNG UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU

409


)QWFGP .CO # .COD YKVJ .8& %1 ( KP VJG HKGNF #)0 „ &'+ „ 38+ „ 61.. „ 2'%# „ /8&+ „ /+5'4'4' „ 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG GCING KP GCEJ CPING :2% ” 8+0%+6 ” :2% ” 4')0#6 ” :2% ” +/2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG 5-# <ÒTKEJ (TQO NKUV PQ #IPWU &GK 3WK 6QNNKU 2GEECVC /WPFK /KUGTGTG 0QDKU .COD QH )QF VJCV VCMG CYC[ VJG UKPU QH VJG YQTNF JCXG OGTE[ QP WU ,QJ 6JG )QNF .COD YCU UVTWEM HTQO VQ KP )JGPV CPF KP /GEJGNGP CPF HTQO VQ GZENWUKXGN[ KP /GEJGNGP 6JG EQPVGPV UVGCFKN[ FGETGCUGF CRCTV HTQO VJG NCUV UJQTV GOKUUKQP YJGP KV YCU DTQWIJV WR VQ VJG UVCPFCTF QH VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG GOKUUKQP

)QWFGP 4KLFGT # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ NKQPU QP VJG JQTUG DNCPMGV .8&18+% Q &'+ „ )4# „ %1/'5 „ + „ &05 „ (.#&4+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU :2% ” 8+0%+6 ” :2% ” 4')0#6 ” :2% ” +/2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTCQTFKPCT[ YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG VQ WPEKTEWNCVGF *GUU <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 1P VQR QH VJG JGNOGV CTG VJTGG TQUGVVGU YKVJ VJG HNCOKUJ NKQP

&WDDGNG IQWFGP NGGWY # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV KP IQVJKE ECPQR[ QXGT (.#0&4' KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF .8&18+%85 „ &'+ „ )4# „ %1/ „ < „ &05 „ (.#0&4+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ ( . # 0 & KP VJG CPINGU CPF VJG EGPVTG $'0'&+%685 ” 38+ ” 8'0+6 ” +0 ” 01/+0' ” &1/+ 0+ (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 9GNN UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG RGTHGEV RKGEG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM (TQO -ÒPMGT #WEVKQP PQ $GPGFKEVWU 3WK 8GPKV KP 0QOKPG &QOKPK $NGUUGF KU JG YJQ EQOGU KP VJG PCOG QH VJG .QTF 2T /CV .WE

410


)QWFGP (NCPFTG # %QWPV UVCPFKPI KP IQVJKE ECPQR[ YKVJ NKQP QP JKU DTGCUV CPF UJKGNF QH (NCPFGTU QXGT (.#0&4'5 KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF .8&18+% Q &'+ „ ) Q %1/ Q < Q &05 „ (.#0&4+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ NKQP KP VJG EGPVTG CPF ( . # & KP VJG CPINGU $'0'&+%685 ” 38+ ” 8'0+6 ” +0 ” 01/+0' ” &1/+0+ (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM DGVYGGP UV #RTKN CPF VJ #WIWUV

0KGWY )QWFGP 5EJKNF # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP IQVJKE VJTQPG YKVJ UYQTF CPF UJKGNF QH (NCPFGTU .8&18+%85 ” &'+ Z )4# Z %1/ Z < ” &05 ” (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 (D ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

5-# <ÒTKEJ

.GGWYGPITQQV # .KQP TCORCPV N /10'6# ã (.#0& YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU EQPVCKPKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP 4 .8& 18+ % %1 /'5 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP CPF KTTGIWNCT HNCP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM CWEVKQP PQ 'Z $WNNGT EQNNGEVKQP 1UPCDTÒEM

411


.GGWYGPITQQV # .KQP TCORCPV N /10'6# ã (.#0& YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU CPF QPG NKQP 4 .8&18+% %1/'5 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

NGGWYGPITQQV # .KQP TCORCPV N /10'6# ” (.#0& YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NGCXGU 4 .8& 18+ % Z%1 /'5 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%6 ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/ ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ +*8 ¶ :2+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

&WDDGNG )TQQV # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV KP OWNVKNQDG .8&18+%85 &'+ )4# %1/'5 < &05 (.#0&4+' 4 /10'6# Ÿ &' Ÿ (.#0&4+# CTQWPF HNQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+%685 38+ 8'0+6 +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ ) 8CPJQWFV IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

)TQQV # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV UKVVKPI KP OWNVKNQDG .1&18+% ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ %1/ ¶ < ¶ & ¶ (.#0&4+' 4 /10 '6# (.# &4+' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $'0'&+%6 ¶ 3 ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ + ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP &GWVUEJNCPF #WEVKQP PQ

412


)TQQV PF GOKUUKQP # .KQP YKVJ JGNOGV UKVVKPI KP OWNVKNQDG .8&18+% ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ %1/ ¶ < ¶ & ¶ (.#0&4+' 4 /10 '6# (.# &4+' CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $'0'&+%6 ¶ 3 ¶ 8'0+6 ¶ + ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &+ ) 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

2*+.+25 FG 56176' 2JKNKR VJG $QNF KPJGTKVGF C XCUV TGCNO HTQO JKU HCVJGT CPF ITCPFHCVJGT *G IQXGTPGF VJKU HTQO 2CTKU CPF UGNFQO YCU KP (NCPFGTU .QWKU QH /CGNGʼnU YKNN GPVKVNGF 2JKNKR VJG $QNF VQ $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI 6TGCV[ QH #VJ +P 2JKNKR HQTEGF ,GCPPG QH $TCDCPV VQ TGNKPSWKUJ .KODWTI CPF VJG NCPFU QH 1XGTOC\G

HQT VJG QVJGT RCTVU UGG WPFGT $TCDCPV 2JKNKR TGSWKTGF C NQV QH OQPG[ HQT JKU EQUVN[ GPFGCXQWTU *G CNYC[U TGICTFGF JKOUGNH CU C (TGPEJ RTKPEG JG JGNF EQWTV KP 2CTKU CPF FKFPʼnV URGCM C YQTF QH (NGOKUJ

)TQU FG %QPXGPVKQP /GEJGNGP # 5JKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ N CPF $TCDCPV T ICTNCPF DGVYGGP VYQ TQ UGVVGU CDQXG CPF QPG TQUGVVG DGNQY 2*5 &8: $14) + %1/ (.#0& +1* &8% $4#$ 4 5JKGNF QH (NCPFGTU QP QTPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ VJG NKODU GPFKPI KP FTCIQPJGCFU /10'6# 018# (.#0&4+' '6 $4#$#06+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN /KPVKPI KP EQQRGTCVKQP YKVJ ,GCPPG 8GWXG XCP $TCDCPV

)QWFGP UEJKNF /GEJGNGP # %QWPV UKVVKPI QP VJTQPG WPFGT ECPQR[ JQNFKPI UYQTF CPF UJKGNF YKVJ NKQP 2*+.+2285 ” &'+ Z Z )4# Z %1/ ” < ” &05 ” (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG TQUG KP GCEJ CPING :2% „ 8+0%+6 „ :2% „ 4')0#6 „ :2% „ +/2'4#6 &F2 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ %QKPCIG #EV VJ #RTKN

413


&WDDGNG )QWFGP *GNO # 5VCT DGVYGGP VJG UJKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU WPFGT JGNOGVU 2*+.+22 Z &'+ ” ) ” &8: ” $84) ” < ” %1/ ” (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 ó 01/'0 ó &1/+0+ ó $'0'&+%68/ &F2 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG XGT[ HKPG

8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ (TQO HKPF <WVRJGP 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ EH 8GTPKGT EQNNGEVKQP PQ 5KV 0QOGP &QOKPK $GPGFKEVWO 2TCKUGF DG VJG PCOG QH VJG .QTF FQZQNQIKG 2U ,QD D &CP

&WDDGNG )TQQV (NCPFTG # (.#&4'5 QXGT UJKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ &8: ¶ $84) ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 /10'6# š &' š (.#0&4+# CTQWPF ETQUU 5+6† 01/'0 † &1/+0+ † $'0'&+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F

&WDDGNG )TQQV OGV FG CFGNCCT # 'CING QXGT VJG UJKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ )4# ¶ &8: ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 /10'6# &' (.#0&4+# CTQWPF ETQUU 5+6 ¶ 01/'0 &1/+0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

)TQQV OGV FG CFGNCCT # 'CING QXGT VJG UJKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ ) ¶ & ¶ $84) ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ( . # & KP VJG CPINGU 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ $'0'&+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV 'Z &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z (KPF <WVRJGP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ

414


)QWFGP 0QDGN # %QWPV UVCPFKPI KP UJKR YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*5 &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” %1/'5 ” < ” &05 ” (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ HQWT ETQYPU CPF HQWT NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU +*% ” #86'/ ” 64#05+'05 ” 2'4 ” /'&+8/ ” +..148/ ” +$#6 &F2 (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 6JG NKQPU QP VJG TGXGTUG CTG RCUUCPV KPUVGCF QH TCORCPV #PF VJG[ CTG NKQPU QH EQWTUG CPF PQV NGQRCTFU CU QP VJG 'PINKUJ PQDNGU EH 8GTPKGT EQNNGEVKQP OGPVKQPU QP VJG TGXGTUG /'&+8 KPUVGCF QH /'&+8/ %QKPCIG #EV UV 1EVQDGT +JGUWU #WVGO 6TCPUKGPU RGT /GFKWO +NNQTWO +DCV $WV ,GUWU RCUUGF VJTQWIJ VJG ETQYF CPF YGPV QP JKU YC[ .WE 6JKU VGZV QPN[ HGCVWTGU QP PQDNGU

&WDDGNG )TQQV $QVFTCGIGT # .KQP UKVVKPI YKVJ VJG DCPPGT QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DCEM 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ ) ¶ &: ¶ $84) ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &1/+0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

%QKP +PX .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ %QKPCIG #EV VJ &GEGODGT 6JG PCOG DQVFTCIGT RCPPKGT DGCTGT YCU FGTKXGF HTQO VJG HCEV VJCV VJG UKVVKPI NKQP KU DGCTKPI C DCPPGT QT ECPQR[ QP KVU DCEM VJCV YCU EQORCTGF VQ C DQV RCPPKGT

&WDDGNG )TQQV $QVFTCGIGT # .KQP UKVVKPI YKVJ VJG DCPPGT QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DCEM 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ ) ¶ &: ¶ $84) ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &1/+0+ ¶ $'0'&+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

$CNFYKP .QPFQP

)TQQV DQVFTCIGT # .KQP UKVVKPI YKVJ VJG DCPPGT QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DCEM 2*+.+22 ¶ &'+ ¶ ) & ¶ $84) ¶ < ¶ %1/ ¶ (.#0& 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ $'0' &+%68/ &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ (TQO QP

415


&WDDGNG /KLV # ( . WPFGT ETQUU 2*5 & $ %1/ (.#0& 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF NKQPU KP VJG QVJGT CPINGU /10'6# (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV IT (KPG *WK\KPIC &GNHV 'Z FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP PQ

&WDDGNG /KLV # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*+.+22 &8: $84+) 4 %TQUU /10'6# (.#0&4+5 &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

/KLV # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*+.+22 &8: $74+) 4 .QPI ETQUU /1 0'6 # (. #0& &F2 5WRRN PQ 8CPJQWFV IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

.¾QRCTF Fʼn1T 2CTKU

,#0 \QPFGT 84''5 #HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH 2JKNKR VJG $QNF CPF /CTICTGV ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU KPJGTKVGF QPN[ (NCPFGTU #TVQKU CPF VJG $WTIWPFKCP NCPFU 6JG TF UQP TGEGKXGF 4GVJGN CPF 0GXGTU ,QJP UKIPGF C VTGCV[ QH OWVWCN CUUKUVGPEG YKVJ JKU DTQVJGT #PVQP QH $TCDCPV CPF JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY 9KNNKCO 8+ QH *QNNCPF KP ,WUV CU JKU HCVJGT ,QJP CNYC[U UCY JKOUGNH CU C (TGPEJ RTKPEG VJQWIJ JG FKF URGCM (NGOKUJ 'ORGTQT 5KIKUOWPF FKFPʼnV YCKV HQT VJG $WTIWPFKCP DCTM VQ VWTP KPVQ C DKVG CPF JG CNNKGF YKVJ VJG #TOCIPCEU VQ ETWUJ VJG RQYGT QH $WTIWPF[ 2JKNKR HCEGF YKVJ VJKU GPGO[ YJKEJ TGXGCNGF KVUGNH VQ DG HCT UWRGTKQT YCU KP FGURGTCVG PGGF QH C UVTQPI CNN[ CPF HQWPF QPG KP VJG 'PINKUJ KP +P JG CESWKGUEGF KP VJG UNC[KPI QH JKU DTQVJGTU #PVQP CPF 2JKNKR KP VJG $CVVNG CV #\KPEQWTV +P ,QJP YCU MKNNGF D[ VJG #TOCIPCEU VJG FCWRJKP JCF DGGP KPHQTOGF QH VJKU CUUCUUKPCVKQP UGG CNUQ VJG KPVTQFWEVKQP YKVJ 6JG $WTIWPFKCP 0GVJGTNCPFU

&WDDGNG )TQU $TCURGPPKPI # 5JKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU WPFGT JGNOGV +1*5 „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0&4+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ %1/'6+5 ¶ (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 2NGCUKPIN[ VQPGF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

416


)TQU $TCURGPPKPI # 5JKGNFU QH $WTIWPF[ CPF (NCPFGTU WPFGT JGNOGV ¶ +1*5 &8: $84) < %1/ (.#0&4+' ¶ 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ %1/'6+5 ¶ (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

%QKP +PXGUVOGPV FGP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ

&WDDGNG )TQQV -TQOUVCGTV # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DTGCUV +1*5 „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ( . # & KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ %1/+6+5 ¶ (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&WDDGNG )TQQV -TQOUVCGTV # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DTGCUV +1*5 „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ( . # ņ & KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ %1/+6+5 ¶ (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO 5GRVGODGT PQ

0/$ #OUVGTFCO (TQO HKPF 9QGTFGP

2*+.+25 VJG )1'&' 6JG VTGCEJGTQWU OWTFGT QH JKU HCVJGT TCPMNGF KP 2JKNKR VJG )QQFʼnU DTGCUV CPF JG CNNKGF YKVJ VJG 'PINKUJ +P VJG 6TGCV[ QH 6TQ[GU CEMPQYNGFIGF 'PINKUJ MKPI *GPT[ 8 VQ DG VJG UWEEGUUQT QH VJG (TGPEJ MKPI %JCTNGU 8+ VJG /CF 2JKNKRʼnU FCWIJVGT YGFFGF *GPT[ 8 #HVGT UWHHGTKPI UGXGTCN FGHGCVU CICKPUV VJG (TGPEJ NGF D[ ,GCP QH #TE 2JKNKR HKPCNN[ ECRVWTGF ,GCP DGHQTG VJG YCNNU QH %QORK½IPG KV YQWNF DG JKU NCUV UGTXKEG VQ VJG 'PINKUJ MKPI 2JKNKR URQMG YKVJ ,GCP QH #TE DWV VJG EJTQPKENGT /QPUVTGNGV YJQ YCU RTGUGPV CV VJKU KPVGTXKGY RTQXKFGU PQ CEEQWPV QH KV 5GG HWTVJGT WPFGT 6JG $WTIWPFKCP 0GVJGTNCPFU

&WDDGNG )TQQV -TQOUVCGTV # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DTGCUV 2*5 „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ( . # & KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ %1/+6+5 ¶ (.#0&4+' &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG CPF UOCNN UETCVEJGU QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 0/$ #OUVGTFCO (TQO HKPF 9QGTFGP

417


)TQQV -TQOUVCGTV # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG DTGCUV 2*5 „ &8: „ $84) < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0&4+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ ( . # & KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# ¶ %1/+6+5 ¶ (.#0& &F2 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV &GEGODGT PQ

)QWFGP 0QDGN # %QWPV UVCPFKPI KP UJKR YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” %1/'5 ” < ” &05 ” (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ HQWT NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU CPF TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG +*% ” #86'/ ” 64#05+'05 ” 2'4 ” /'&+8/ ” +..148/ ” +$#6 &F2 &GNO (D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 0WODGT QH &F2 KU VJCV QH VJG KNNWUVTCVKQP VGZVPWODGT KU EH 8GTPKGT EQNNGEVKQP PQ %QKPCIG #EV VJ 0QXGODGT

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

&GPKGT # $WUV HCEKPI YKVJ NQPI DGCTF CPF ETQUKGT ETGUEGPV T 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ RGNNGVU CPF VYQ 5 KP VJG CPINGU F/ IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 2NCVV 2CTKU &G /G[ UC[U VJCV VJKU EQKP KU WPKSWG

418


%1706; *#+0#76 *CKPCWV GXQNXGF HTQO VJG )CNNQ 4QOCP EKXKVCU QH VJG 0GTXKGT VJG NCVGT FKQEGUG %CODTCK VJG EGPVTG QH YJKEJ (COCTU NC[ PGCT 8CNGPEKGPPGU +P GCTN[ /KFFNG #IGU ECNNGF RCIWU (CP VQOCTVGPUKU 0QV WPVKN VJG VJ EGPVWT[ FKF VJG PCOG *CKPCWV CRRGCT +P VJG GCTN[ /KFFNG #IGU VJG *QWUG QH VJG 4GIKPCTG 4GIPKGT .QPIPGEM TWNGF KP *CKPCWV UGCVGF KP /QPU 6JG )GTOCP MKPIU FKXGUVGF 4GIKPCT +++ CPF JKU UQP 4GIKPCT +8

QH VJGKT QHHKEGU #NVJQWIJ 4GIKPCT +8 JCF CNTGCF[ TGEQPSWGTGF /QPU HTQO VJG )GTOCP MKPI D[ 8CNGPEKGPPGU JQYGXGT FKFPʼnV TGVWTP KPVQ VJGKT FQOKPKQP WPVKN WPFGT JKU ITCPFUQP *GTOCP *GTOCP YCU OCTTKGF VQ VJG FCWIJVGT QH 4GIKPCT 8 4KEJKNFG CPF YJGP *GTOCP FKGF UJG TGOCTTKGF $CNFYKP + %QWPV QH (NCPFGTU ECNNGF $CNFYKP 8+ VJGTG # UJQTV RGTUQPCN WPKQP YKVJ (NCPFGTU GPUWGF DWV 4KEJKNFG VTCPUHGTTGF VJG EQWPV[ *CKPCWV VQ VJG .K½IG DKUJQRU KP HKGH OCKPN[ VQ RTQVGEV JGTUGNH CICKPUV JGT RQYGTHWN DTQVJGT KP NCY 4QDGTV VJG (TKUKCP 6JG CITGGOGPV VJCV FKF PQV EQPHGT FG HCEVQ RQYGT QXGT *CKPCWV QP VJG DKUJQRU QH .K½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

/CKNNG OWGVVG # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV GPFKPI KP VYQ ETGUEGPVU 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ ETGUEGPVU CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO %JCNQP ENCUUKHKGU VJKU EQKP WPFGT ,GCPPG CPF EQPUKFGTU /QPU FQPV NGU CTOGU UQPV WP EJ³VGCW

,'#00' ,GCPPG UWEEGGFU JGT HCVJGT $CNFYKP 8+ %QWPV QH (NCPFGTU CPF 'ORGTQT QH VJG .CVKP 'ORKTG KP *CKPCWV CU YGNN CU KP (NCPFGTU #HVGT JGT FGOKUG JGT UKUVGT /CTICTGV ++ QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG UWEEGGFGF JGT CNUQ KP DQVJ VGTTKVQTKGU

/CKNNG 8CNGPEKGPPGU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV GPFKPI KP VYQ UVCTU 8# .' %' 0' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

/CKNNG 8CNGPEKGPPGU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV GPFKPI KP VYQ UVCTU 8# .' %' 0' 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG JQQH KTQP KP GCEJ CPING %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 9KNNGOU $GPPGMQO %J UWRRN :+8 0 CPF ' NKICVWTGF %JCNQP OGPVKQPU ETGUEGPVU KPUVGCF QH JQQH KTQPU

419


/#4)#4'6*# QH %1056#06+012'. &WG VQ VJG HCEV VJCV JGT HCVJGT JCF DGGP GORGTQT QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG /CTICTGV YCU ECNNGF QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG EQPVTCT[ VQ JGT UKUVGT ,GCPPG +P DGHQTG JGT FGCVJ VJG UVTWIING HQT RQYGT KP DQVJ (NCPFGTU CPF *CKPCWV CNTGCF[ KIPKVGF UGG WPFGT ,QJP ++ QH #XGUPGU /CTICTGV TGOCKPGF EQWPVGUU QH (NCPFGTU WPVKN CPF EQWPVGUU XCP *CKPCWV WPVKN JGT FGCVJ KP 6JG NCPFU YGTG VJGP UGRCTCVGF

)TQU # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UYQTF CPF RNWOG QP JQTUGJGCF /10'6# 8#.'0%'0'05+5 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /#4)#4'6# %1/+6+55# %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG $4'& 2CTKU 6JKU V[RG VQ VJG NGHV KU VJG QNFGUV V[RG

)TQU # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ UYQTF CPF RNWOG QP JQTUGJGCF /10'6# 8#.'0%'0'0 5+5 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING /#4)# 4'6# %1/+6+55# %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIP[ EQNNGEVKQP 6[RG VJG NCVGUV V[RG

6JG *QWUG QH #XGUPGU ,'#0 ++ QH #8'50'5 /CTICTGV JCF VYQ EJKNFTGP ,QJP QH #XGUPGU HTQO JGT OCTTKCIG VQ $QWEJCTF QH #XGUPGU CPF )W[ QH &CORKGTTG HTQO JGT OCTTKCIG VQ 9KNNKCO QH &CORKGTTG VJG[ EQPVGUVGF GCEJ QVJGTʼnU KPJGTKVCPEG (KPCNN[ VJG (TGPEJ MKPI UGVVNGF VJG FKURWVG &KV FG 2¾TQPPG ,QJP TGEGKXGF *CKPCWV JG FKGF KP CPF YCU OCTTKGF VQ #NGKF JGKTGUU QH *QNNCPF C UKUVGT QH 9KNNKCO +++ QH *QNNCPF VJG 4QOCP MKPI CPF )W[ YCU IKXGP (NCPFGTU +P JKU UQP ,QJP ++ UWEEGGFGF JKU ITCPFOQVJGT YJKEJ OCTMGF VJG TKUG QH VJG *QWUG #XGUPGU CPF VJG WPKVKPI QH *CKPCWV CPF *QNNCPF ,QJP ++ YQWNF PQV [GV KPFKECVG JKU EQOKVCN VKVNG QH *QNNCPF HTQO QP QP JKU EQKPU

8KGWZ )TQU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV YKVJKP CTEJGU GPENQUKPI VTGHQKNU Q *#0 10+' Q 4 +1*#0'5 Q %1/'5 CTQWPF ETQUU :2% ¶ 8+0%0+6 ¶ :2% ¶ 4'0#6 ¶ :2% ¶ +02'4#6 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 2NGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

420


)TQU CW %CXCNKGT # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UJKGNF N +1*#00'5 %1/'5 *#+0 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# 8#.'0%'0'05+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

2GVKV )TQU 8CNGPEKGPPGU # .KQP TCORCPV +1*#0'5 %1/'5 *#01+' 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# 8#.'0%'0'5+5 %J XCT .WECU C 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

'UVGTNKP # .KQP TCORCPV KP UJKGNF Z * Z #01 Z Z 0+' Z 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG TQUGVVG KP GCEJ CPING +1* #0' 5%1 /'5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

'UVGTNKP 8CNGPEKGPPGU # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ VJTGG TQUGU ” + ” %1/'5 ” *#010+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING 8#. '0% *'0 '05 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

'UVGTNKP /QPU # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ VJTGG TQUGU ” +1*5 ” %1/'5 ” *#010+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /10 '6# /10 6'5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

421


'UVGTNKP /CWDGWIG # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI YKVJ VJTGG TQUGU ” +1*5 ” %1/'5 ” *#010+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING /'. $1& +'0 5+5 %J .WECU D 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP 6JG . QH /'. JCU PQ FQV

)7+..#7/' + +P VJG FKURWVG YKVJ )W[ QH &CORKGTTG ,QJP ++ JCF CUUWTGF JKOUGNH QH VJG UWRRQTV QH VJG )GTOCP MKPIU *KU UQP 9KNNKCO JQYGXGT UQWIJV C DQPF YKVJ (TCPEG CPF 'PIGNCPF JQRKPI VQ GZRCPF VJG VGTTKVQT[ *CKPCWV CPF *QNNCPF KPVQ CP KORQTVCPV EQORNGZ QH RQYGT +P )W[ QH &CORKGTTGʼnU UQP YJQ YCU PCOGF CHVGT JKU HCVJGT EGFGF <GGNCPF VQ 9KNNKCO + 9KNNKCO + PGKVJGT WUGF VJG VKVNG EQWPV QH *QNNCPF QP JKU EQKPCIG PQT NCVGT VJCV QH <GGNCPF +P *QNNCPF JG YCU MPQYP CU 9KNNGO +++ DWV KP *CKPCWV JG YCU VJG HKTUV )WKNNCWOG

2GVKV ITQU CW ECXCNKGT # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UJKGNF NKU QP JGNOGV )8+.. ¶ %1/'5 ¶ *#010+' 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ 8#.'0%'0'05+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'Z 2TKPEG FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP 6JG EQKP KU ECNNGF RKNNGYKNNG

)TQU 'UMK¾NQKU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV KP SWCVTGHQKN J # ; 0ʼn YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU EQPVCKP KPI ENQXGTU 4 )8+..'./ %1/'5 CTQWPF ETQUU +0 ¶ 01/+0' ¶ &0+ ¶ &'+ ¶ 04+ ¶ (#%6 ¶ 58/ %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG #PIGPQT 2CTKU (TQO NKUV 1EVQDGT PQ $GVYGGP )8+..'./ CPF %1/'5 KU C RGNNGV CU KP %JCNQP .WECU OGPVKQPU VJTGG RGNNGVU 5VTWEM KP

)TQU CWZ SWCVVTG .KQPU # (QWT NKQPU KP SWCVTGHQKN )8+..'./85 %1/'5 *#010+' 4 /10'6# 8#.'0% CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68/ ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/'0 ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JG EQKP KU ECNNGF FWTCPV 6JKU EQKPU JCU DGGP UVTWEM WPFGT ,GCP FG 0COWT CPF .QWKU FG %TGE[ VJG EQWPVU QH (NCPFGTU 5VTWEM CHVGT

422


'UVGTNKP 8CNGPEKGPPGU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV KP TJQOD 8#. '0% 0'0 '05 4 %TQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ) ¶ %1/'5 *#010+' %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 'UVGTNKP C N GUEKGNGVVG QT GUVGTNKP CW NQUCPIG

1DQNG DNCPEJG # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ HQWT TQUGVVGU )8+..'./85 %1/'5 *#010+' 4 5+) 08/ %48 %+5 CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU /10' 6# 8# .'0% '0+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JG EQKP KU ECNNGF RGPCP

)7+..#7/' ++ 9KNNKCO ++ FKGF EJKNFNGUU 6JG VJTGG VGTTKVQTKGU FGXQNXGF VQ JKU UKUVGT /CTICTGV

)TQU VQWTPQKU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV YKVJ HQWT NKQPU CPF * # ; 0 CTQWPF FKXKFGF D[ TKPIU YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU 4 )8+.'./ Q %1/'5 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68/ ¶ 5+6 ¶ 01/' ¶ &0+ ¶ 04+ ¶ &'+ %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 6TCEGU QH XGTFKITKU CPF UOCNN HNCP ETCEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP 1P VJG . KU C ENQXGT

)TQU # .KQP TCORCPV Ö /10'6# ” 8#.'0%'0 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING *#+ 10+ '%1 /'5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

423


/#4)#4'6*# ++ QH #8'50'5 /CTICTGV UKUVGT QH 9KNNKCO ++ 9KNNGO +8 YCU OCTTKGF VQ 'ORGTQT .QWKU QH $CXCTKC HTQO VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ 6JG TKUG QH VJG *QWUG 9KVVGNUDCEJ KP *CKPCWV

&WDDGNG ITQQV 8CNGPEKGPPGU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV YKVJ *# *1 <' (4 KP VJG CPINGU /#4)#4'6# %1/+6+5# *#01+' 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ GCINGU KP VJG CPINGU

/10' 6# 8#. '0%'0 '05+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ .WECU ECNNU KV C ITQU CRRGN¾ XCKNNCPV FCPU NGU EQORVGU 6JKU EQKP EQPUVKVWVGU VJG HKTUV KPUVCPEG KP *CKPCWV QH C EQKP DGCTKPI CNN HQWT HWNN VKVNGU *CKPCWV *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF (TKGUNCPF

)TQU # 'CING YKVJ OQPQITCO QH *CKPCWV QP DTGCUV /#4)#4'6 %1/ ¶ *#010 YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GPENQUKPI NKU 4 /10'6# 8#.'0%'0'5+5 %TQUU YKVJ GCING KP VJG UV CPF NKQP KP VJG VJ CPING b $0&+%68 5+6 01/' &0+ 04+ &+ +*8 :2+ %J .WECU F 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP

6JG *QWUG QH 9KVVGNUDCEJ 6JG $CXCTKCP *QWUG )7+..#7/' +++ #U 9KNNKCO +++ YCU FGENCTGF KPUCPG KP JKU DTQVJGT #NDTGEJV TWNGF KP TGIGPE[ UVCTVKPI 9KNNKCO +++ UVKNN ECNNGF JKOUGNH EQOGU *CPQPKG DWV QP JKU EQKPU JG UQOGVKOGU JCF VJG OQPQITCO QH *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF UVTWEM

)TCPFG 2NCSWG # )TGCV OQPQITCO QH *CKPCWV YKVJ *# *1 <' (4 KP VJG CPINGU )8+..'./85 „ %1/'5 „ *#010+' 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ GCINGU KP VJG CPINGU /10' 6# „ 8#. '0%'0 '05+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 6JKU V[RG JCU DGGP EQRKGF D[ 2KGTTG +++ DKUJQR QH %CODTCK

424


)TQU # /QPQITCO QH *CKPCWV KP OWNVKNQDG )8+..'./85 %1/'5 *#010+' 4 /10 '6# 8#. %05 CTQWPF ETQUU $0&+%68 5+6 01/'0 &0+ 04+ %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU .WECU OGPVKQPU 8#.'05 DWV JGTG KV KU 8#.%05

#.$4'%*6 QH $#8#4+# &WTKPI JKU HCVJGTʼnU TGKIP #NDTGEJVʼnU UQP 9KNNKCO +8 IQXGTPGF KP CUUQEKCVKQP #NDTGEJV LWUV CU JKU DTQVJGT JCF VJG VKVNG &8: UVTWEM QP JKU EQKPU CNDGKV QPN[ YKVJ TGHGTGPEG VQ *CKPCWV

)TCPFG EQWTQPPG F QT # 5JKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV WPFGT ITGCV ETQYP NKQPU KP VJG HKGNF #.$'4685 ” &8: ” &'+ Z Z )4# ” %1/'5 ” *#010+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ GCING KP SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG NKQP KP GCEJ CPING :2% ” 8+0%+6 ” :2% ” 4')0#6 ” :2% ” +02'4#6 %J (D .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 8KPEJQP 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ 'Z (KPF <WVRJGP 5EJWNOCP #WEVKQP PQ 6JKU EQKP FQGU PQV YGKIJ VYKEG CU OWEJ CU VJG UKPING ETQYP HQT FG \YCGTUVG FKÀT YKGTFGP IGPQGOF FQDDGNG VJG JGCXKGUV QH YJKEJ YGTG PCOGF FQWDNG VJ GOKUUKQP

2NCSWG # 5JKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV QXGT GCING #.$84685 &8: &'+ )4# %1/'5 *#010+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# 018# (#%6# +0 8#.'0%*'0+5 %J .WECU C 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ (TQO HKPF <WVRJGP 6JKU KU VJG QPN[ V[RG VJCV JCU DGGP EQRKGF KP *QNNCPF UGG PQ

&QWDNG )TQU # 5SWCTG YKVJ UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV KP OWNVKNQDG #.$'468 &8: „ &'+ )4# „ %1/5 *#010+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ VYQ GCINGU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU OQPQITCO QH *CKPCWV KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# „ 018# „ (#%6# „ +0 „ 8#.'0%*+'00+5 %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG CV VJG QWVNKPG QH VJG USWCTG KU KPVGTTWRVGF D[ C RGNNGV UWTTQWPFGF D[ VJTGG VTKCPINGU 6JG KPKVKCNU ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG JCU C YJQNG CV VJG EGPVTG CPF DTQCFGPU QWV UWDUVCPVKCNN[ CV KVU RGTKOGVGT (TQO C UOCNN JQCTF HTQO VJG 6TKGT CTGC EQPVCKPKPI C HGY URGEKOGPU QH VJKU V[RG

425


5OCNN HCEGU /QPG[GTU CPF QT FKG UKPMGTU QH VJG /KFFNG #IGU NGCXKPI C RGTUQPCN OCTM QP EQKPU VTWN[ KU TCTGN[ QDUGTXGF 5QOGVKOGU VJG[ YQWNF KPENWFG C UKPING UKIP CPF XGT[ UGNFQO C HWNN PCOG CU KP C HGY DTCEVGCVGU D[ .WVKIGT UGG WPFGT 1TNCOÒ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ʼnV HGCVWTG VJGUG UOCNN HCEGU CPF 6JG VJKTF UVCIG KU UGGP QP VJG EQKPU QH VJG CTEJDKUJQRTKE 6TKGT 6JG IQNF IWKNFGT QH 1DGTYGUGN RTQXKFGU VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZVU QDXGTUG 9'40'4 #4%2 64' TGXGTUG /10'6# 018# 9'5#. (WTVJGTOQTG C UOCNN HCEG KU UVTWEM KP VJG ETGUEGPV OQQP VQ VJG HGGV QH ,QJP VJG $CRVKUV 6JG IQNF IWKNFGT QH 1DGTYGUGN RTQXKFGU VJG HQNNQYKPI VGZVU QDXGTUG 9'40*'4 #4%* 64 TGXGTUG /10'6# 018# 9'5#.'05+5 426


6JG HKTUV EQKP VJCV QH *CKPCWV YCU UVTWEM KP VJG RGTKQF CTQWPF WPFGT #NDTGEJV QH $CXCTKC 6JG UGEQPF EQKP QH .WZGODWTI YCU UVTWEM DGVYGGP WPFGT ,QDUV QH /QTCXKC +P 6TKGT UGXGTCN EQKPU YGTG UVTWEM DGCTKPI VJGUG UOCNN HCEGU 6JG[ CNN CTG IQNF IWKNFGTU HTQO VJG OKPV 1DGTYGUGN CPF YGTG CNN UVTWEM WPFGT VJG VTGCV[ QH 4JGKPKUEJG /Ã’P\XGTGKP 5VTWEM KP VJG RGTKQF DGVYGGP WPFGT 9GTPGT QH (CNMGPUVGKP # UGEQPF QEEWTCPEG QH VJKU RJGPQOGPQP KU HQWPF KP 6TKGT YJGTG VJG UOCNN HCEG CRRGCTU KP C EQNWOP UWRRQTVKPI VJG VJTQPG 5V 2GVGT UKVU QP TCVJGT TGOKPKUEGPV QH VJG YC[ .QTGP\Q )JKDGTVK RQTVTC[GF JKOUGNH QP QPG QH VJG LCODU QH VJG ICVGU VQ RCTCFKUG KP (NQTGPEGʼnU DCRVKUVT[ #NVJQWIJ %JCNQP UWRRN R ZZZXK UVCVGU VJCV %GVVG RGVKVG V¿VG UGODNCDNG ¯ EGNNG SWK UG VTQWXG FCPU NGU NGVVGTU ETGWUGU NGU 1 NGU % NG %& FʼnWP ITQU FG ,QUUG FG /QTCXKG EQOVG FG .WZGODQWTI GUV ¾XKFGOOGPV WP FKHH¾TGPV OQP¾VCKTG QW NC OCTSWG FW ITCXGWT FGU EQKPU YG ECPʼnV UJGF VJG KORTGUUKQP VJCV VJG FKG UKPMGTU CV YQTM YGTG QPG CPF VJG UCOG 6JG QTFGT QH OCPWHCEVWTG QH VJG EQKPU KU VJG HQNNQYKPI *CKPCWV CRRTQZ .WZGO DWTI #TEJDKUJQRTKE 6TKGT 6JG UOCNN HCEGU GXGP CRRGCT VQ DG CIGKPI VJTQWIJ VJG [GCTU +V KU VJGTGHQTG PQV KPEQPEGKXCDNG VJCV VJKU FKG UKPMGT VQQM WR JKU VTCFG KP *CKPCWV YQTMGF KP .WZGODWTI CHVGT VJCV CPF VJGP OQXGF VQ 1DGTYGUGN HQT C NQPIGT RGTKQF QH VKOG #V CP QNF CIG JG RGTJCRU TGVWTPGF VQ .WZGODWTI YJGTG EWTTGPV PQTOCN V[RGU UQOGVKOGU HGCVWTGF C XCTKGV[ UVTWEM YKVJ QPG QH VJGUG UOCNN HCEGU )7+..#7/' +8 9KNNKCO +8 OCTTKGF VQ /CTICTGV QH $WTIWPF[ YCU VJG DTQVJGT KP NCY QH ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU %QWPV QH (NCPFGTU CPF &WMG QH $WTIWPF[ YJQ KP VWTP YCU OCTTKGF VQ /CTICTGV VJG UKUVGT QH 9KNNKCO +8 #HVGT JKU FGOKUG VJG VJTGG NCPFU YGTG NGHV VQ JKU QPN[ FCWIJVGT ,CEQDC 9KNNKCO +8 YCU VJG HKTUV %QWPV QH *CKPCWV *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF YJQ FGNKDGTCVGN[ RWTUWGF C OQPGVCT[ WPKQP QH VJGUG VJTGG NCPFU 6JG FQWDNG IQNFGP CPIGN CPF KVU TGNCVGF EQKPU YGTG VJG HKTUV CVVGORV CV VJKU WPKQP YJKEJ KPEKFGPVCNN[ OKUECTTKGF UGG WPFGT *QNNCPF *G YCU VJG HKTUV QPG VQ ECNN JKOUGNH &WMG CPF %QWPV QH *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *CKPCWV

6WKP # .KQP YKVJ UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV KP HGPEG )8+./ ¶ &: ¶ &'+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1/ ¶ *#01+' ¶ *1. ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ (#% ¶ +0 ¶ 8#.'0% %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 0KEG RQTVTCKV XGT[ HKPG #PIGPQT 2CTKU (TQO NKUV 1EVQDGT PQ

6WKP # .KQP YKVJ UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV KP HGPEG )8+./ ¶ &: ¶ &'+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1/ ¶ *#01+' ¶ *1. ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ (#% ¶ +0 ¶ 8#.'0% %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 8GT[ HKPG

.¾QRCTF Fʼn1T 2CTKU

6WKP # .KQP YKVJ UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV KP HGPEG )8+./ ¶ &: ¶ &'+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1/ ¶ *#01+' ¶ *1. ¶ < ¶ <' 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ (#% ¶ +0 ¶ 8#.'0% %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

*QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

427


,#%1$# QH $#8#4+# #V VJG FGOKUG QH 9KNNKCO +8 KP JKU UQNG JGKT ,CEQDC KPJGTKVGF VJG VJTGG NCPFU *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *CKPCWV ,QJP QH $CXCTKC KORGFGF JGT CEVWCN CEEGUUKQP KP *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF +P *CKPCWV UJG YCU FG HCEVQ EQWPVGUU KP VJCV RGTKQF ,CEQDC QPN[ NGHV VJTGG V[RGU COQPI YJKEJ VJG VWKP ICTFGP NKVGTCNN[ 9JGP FWTKPI ,CEQDCʼnU TGKIP ,QJP QH $CXCTKC FKGF KP *QNNCPF UJG RCTVKEWNCTN[ UVCTVGF HGGNKPI VJG KPHNWGPEG QH 2JKNKR QH $WTIWPF[ CPF KP ,CEQDC JCF VQ CEMPQYNGFIG 2JKNKR VJG )QQF CU JGT JGKT UGG WPFGT *QNNCPF +P *CKPCWV FGHKPKVKXGN[ OGTIGF KPVQ VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO 6TGCV[ QH 6JG *CIWG #RTKN

6WKP # .KQP YKVJ UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF *CKPCWV KP ICTFGP &8%+55# ¶ +#3 ¶ &+ ¶ )4 ¶ %1+ ¶ *#01+' ¶ *1 ¶ < 4 .QPI ETQUU QXGT SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ QPG VTGHQKN KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ (#% ¶ +0 ¶ 8#.'0% %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

0/$ #OUVGTFCO (TQO HKPF 9QGTFGP ,CEQDC JCF VJGUG EQKPU HTQO *CKPCWV UVTWEM YKVJ JGT VKVNGU &WEKUUC CPF %QOKVVKUUC HQT *QNNCPF <GGNCPF CPF *CKPCWV

,'#0 +8 QH $4#$#06 +P JKU ECRCEKV[ CU ,CEQDCʼnU JWUDCPF ,QJP +8 QH $TCDCPV CNUQ OKPVGF KP *CKPCWV C $TCDCPV V[RG VJG FTKGNCPFGT VJTGG NCPFGT WUKPI JKU HWNN VKVNGU $TCDCPV .KODWTI *CKPCWV *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF

&WDDGNG ITQU FTKGNCPFGT # 6YQ UJKGNFU $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ N CPF *CKPCWV T QXGT NKQP KP OWNVKNQDG YKVJ VTGHQKNU KP VJG CPINGU +1* &: $4#$ < .+/$ %1/ *#0 *1. < <' 4 /10'6# (%# +0 8#.'0% CTQWPF ETQUU 5+6 § 01/'0 § &1/+0+ § $'0'&+%68/ %J .WECU 8CPJQWFV ) IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

&GNOQPVG $TWUUGN

5'+)0+14; QH $'#7/106 $CNFYKP YCU VJG UGEQPF UQP QH /CTICTGV QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG CPF $QWEJCTF Fʼn#XGUPGU $CNFYKP TGEGKXGF VJKU UGKIPKQT[ CU CP CRCPCIG HTQO .QWKU +: VJG 5CKPV CPF *G TGUKFGF KP 8CNGPEKGPPGU CPF JGNF ITGCV CWVJQTKV[ KP *CKPCWV *G YCU OCTTKGF VQ (¾NKEKV¾ FG %QWE[ JCF C UQP ,QJP YJQ UWEEGGFGF JKO CU VJG UGKIPGWT QH $GCWOQPV CPF C FCWIJVGT $GCVTKZ YJQ YGFFGF *GPT[ %QWPV QH .WZGODWTI CPF YCU VJG OQVJGT QH 'ORGTQT *GPT[ 8++ $#7&17+0 F #8'50'5

2GVKV )TQU CW %CXCNKGT # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T $ & #8'0+5 &05 $'..+/16+5 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 %TQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ 04+ #/' $ %J IT 44 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP 6JKU KU VJG QPN[ EQKP YJKEJ KU MPQYP HTQO VJG 5GKIPKQT[ FG $GCWOQPV

428


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ʼnV EGCUG KP VJG VJ EGPVWT[ ECP DG FGTKXGF HTQO C FQEWOGPV FCVGF VJ QH (GDTWCT[ VJCV RGTOKVU VJG OCPWHCEVWTG QH C PGY V[RG QH VQMGP XCNKF KP GPVKTG *CKPCWV CV C TCVG QH VYQ O[VGP 9JGP EQORNCKPVU CDQWV EQWPVGTHGKVU CPF RGQRNG PQV CEEGRVKPI VJGUG VQMGPU RGTUKUVGF HWTVJGT OCPWHCEVWTG YCU RTQJKDKVGF KP HTQO 2GNUFQPM 2GPPKPEZMGPU XCP .QQFG )QWFUYCCTF R

&WDDGNG OKLV # (GOCNG HKIWTG UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT UVCT N 5#0%6# #.&')10&+5 8+4)1 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU 14# 241 01$+5 &'8/ #/'0 %J UWRRN IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

&WDDGNG OKLV # (GOCNG HKIWTG UVCPFKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT DGVYGGP 5 #. DKTF $'#6# #.&')8/&+5 8+4)1 4 %TQUU YKVJ UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG 14# 241 /125 &8'/ %J IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP 6GZV KU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG CU %J RN ::+++ CNVJQWIJ VJG FGXKEG QP VJG QDXGTUG FKHHGTU PQ JQQF CU FQGU VJG ETQUU HNGWT[ 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG KU RTGUWOCDN[ RTGEGFGF D[ C DKTF FKURNC[GF UGG %JCNQP #U VJKU KU C UJQTV ETQUU VJKU EQKP DGKPI C O[V KU PQV KPEQPEGKXCDNG VJCV

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 'Z &GHGUEJG EQNNGEVKQP 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG JCU PQ KPVGTRWPEVKQP +U RCTVN[ JCTF VQ TGCF 6JG URCEG KU VQQ VKIJV VQ CEEQOQFCVG CNN VJGUG NGVVGTU 6JG TGXGTUG VGZV JCU /125 KPUVGCF QH 01$+5 CPF &8'/ KPUVGCF QH &'8/ +U VJG UCOG V[RG CU %J [GV CPQVJGT HQPV CPF VJG VGZV KU ICTDNGF # NGVVGT HTQO VJG $TWUUGNU ECDKPGV UC[U VJCV CHVGT CORNG TGUGCTEJ VJKU URGEKOGP OC[ DG EQPENWFGF VQ TGRTGUGPV CP WPMQYP XCTKGV[ 1P %J VJGTG KU C FCVG QVJGT VJCP VJCV KV KU INQDCNN[ VJG UCOG

429


&+1%'5' QH %#/$4#+ +P %CTQNKPIKCP VKOGU %CODTCK YCU C EQOKVCN VQYP #V VJG VGTTKVQTKCN FKXKUKQPU QH CPF KV YGPV VQ 'CUV (TCPEKC +P KV FGHKPKVKXGN[ ECOG WPFGT VJG )GTOCP GORKTG CPF YCU VJGP EWV QHH HTQO KVU PGKIJDQWTKPI TGIKQP #TTCU +P CPF VJG CWVJQTKV[ QH VJG EQWPVU KU EQPHGTTGF VQ VJG DKUJQRU 6JG HKTUV DKUJQR YCU 5V )CWIGTKEWU DGIKPPKPI QH VJG VJ EGPVWT[ +P VJG GCTN[ /KFFNG #IGU %CODTCK YCU C URKTKVWCN CPF OWUKECN EGPVTG CPF KV TQUG VQ KVU CRQIGG WPFGT DKUJQR )GTJCTF + YJQ YCU CNUQ CP KPHNWGPVKCN RQNKVKEKCP 2TQURGTQWU VKOGU GPFGF KP YJGP VJG EQWPVU QH (NCPFGTU GPVGTGF VJG DCVVNG HQT VJG GRKUEQRCN UGG #TTCU EQPUGSWGPVN[ DGECOG CP KPFGRGPFGPV FKQEGUG #TQWPF %CODTCK YCU RCTV QH *CKPCWV 6JG FKQEGUG %CODTCK MPGY C HGY HCOQWU DKUJQRU 4QDGTV QH )GPGXC VJG NCVGT #XKIPQP RQRG %NGOGPV 8++ CPF 2KGTTG Fʼn#KNN[ +VU RTQRGTVKGU NC[ UECVVGTGF CETQUU $TCDCPV CPF *CKPCWV +P VJG VJ EGPVWT[ %CODTCK YCU KPEQTRQTCVGF KP VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO +P 2QRG 2CWN +8 GNGXCVGF VJG FKQEGUG VQ CTEJDKUJQRTKE #010;/175 VJ EGPVWT[

&GPKGT # $WUV QH VJG DKUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ ETQUKGT / T CDQXG 4 %TQUU KP FQWDNGF EKTENG QH RGNNGVU YKVJ 5 6 5 6 KP VJG CPINGU $ 4QD IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

/ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ

0+%1.#5 +++ QH (106#+0'

2GVKV ITQU # $GCTFGF DKUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG 0+%*1.#85 '2+5%*1285 4 %# /' 4# %8 CTQWPF FQWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING '8' /#4+# )4#6+# 2.'6# 2. $ 4QD IT 44 8GT[ HKPG URGEKOGP

5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

2+'44' +++ QH /+4'21+:

2GVKV ITQU # $KUJQR HCEKPI YKVJ OKVTG CPIGN V[RG „ 2'6485 „ '2+5%1285 „ 4 %# /' 4# %8 CTQWPF FQWDNG NKPGF ETQUU #8' /#4+# )4#6+# 2.' $ 4QD IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

430


%*#26'4 QH %#/$4#+

$CWFGMKP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T YKVJ UYQTF /10% 8 %#/4 %#5+5# 4 Q 5+)08/ %48%+5 Q CTQWPF ETQUU YKVJ QPG ETGUEGPV KP GCEJ CPING /10# % 04+5+5# $ 4QD IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG QP UOCNN HNCP CPF UNKIJVGN[ ENGCPGF 2CTV (QWPF KP VJG UQWVJ QH (TKUKC KP )TKGTUQP KU RQUKVKXG VJKU KU CP WPMPQYP EQKP QH VJG %CODTCK EJCRVGT YJKEJ GPLQ[GF KVU QYP RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV +P XKGY QH VJG TGXGTUG ETGUEGPVU RGTKQF QH /CTICTGV QH %QPUVCPVKPQRNG 6JGTG KU C EQKP QH VJKU EJCRVGT KP $ 'UVGTNKP YKVJ /10'6# %#2+68.+ %#/'4#%'05+5

5'+)0+14; QH 5'4#+0 .KVVNG KU MPQYP CDQWV 5GTCKP +V YCU C HKGH KP VJG VGTTKVQT[ QH %CODTCK CPF YCU FGRGPFGPV QP %TGXGEQGWT +V KU UCKF VQ DG CP QNF CRCPCIG QH VJG *QWUG #WDGTV CPF QH 9CNKPEQWTV CPF DGHQTG VJG UGKIPGWTU QH VJKU HKGH JGNF VJG RTKXKNGIG QH OKPV .CVGT KV DGNQPIGF VQ VJG NQTFU QH .KIP[ 9#.4#/ QH .+)0; ++ CPF *GPT[ + %QWPV QH .WZGODWTI CESWKTGF .KIP[ *G YCU YGFFGF VQ /CTICTGV QH $CT CPF FKGF KP *KU ITCPFUQP 8CN¾TCP ++ DGECOG NQTF QH 5GTCKP

5VGTNKPI # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI ) &1/+085 ¶ &' ¶ .+0+ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU /10 '6# 5'4'0' $ /C[JGY IT 4 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\\GPVTWO -ÌNP #WEVKQP PQ %JCWV 2F#

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½XGEQGWT )7+ +8 QH 5#+06 21.

$CWFGMKP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UVCPFCTF )8+&1 %1/'5 5%+ 2#8.+ 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# „ 4'%6# „ &' „ '.+0%1746 $ 2F# IT 4 (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG CPF UOCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG 1T )GUVKQP 0WOKUOCVKSWG 2CTKU

431


5'+)0+14; QH %4–8'%1'74 6JG UGKIPKQT[ QH %T½XGEQGWT YCU C HKGH QH VJG DKUJQRU QH %CODTCK +V DGNQPIGF VQ VJG EQWPVU QH (NCPFGTU 9KNNKCO YCU C UQP QH )W[ QH &CORKGTTG CPF DTQVJGT QH 4QDGTV QH $¾VJWPG *G YCU NQTF QH &GPFGTOQPFG CPF %T½XGEQGWT CPF OCTTKGF VQ #NKEG QH %NGTOQPV

KPJGTKVGF %JCVGCWFWP YJKEJ YGPV VQ 9KNNKCOʼnU UGEQPF UQP 6JG HKTUV UQP ,QJP DGECOG NQTF QH %JCVGCWFWP KP UWEEGGFKPI 9KNNKCO ++ CPF YGFFGF $GCVTKZ QH 5V 2QN JGKTGUU VQ #NNGWZ ,QJP QH (NCPFGTU DGECOG NQTF QH %T½XGEQGWT CPF #TNGWZ *KU YKFQY VTCFGF DQVJ VGTTKVQTKGU CICKPUV %JCWP[ UWT 1KUG YKVJ VJG MKPI &GPFGTOQPFG %T½XGEQGWT CPF #NNGWZ YGTG UQNF VQ (TCPEG KP %JCVGCWFWP JCF CNTGCF[ DGGP UGK\GF D[ (TCPEG ,'#0 QH (.#0&'45

$CWFGMKP # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UVCPFCTF CPF UJKGNF +1*#00'5 &' (.#0&4+# 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU W /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ %4'2+%14&++ $ 2F# IT 44 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 'Z %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG #WEVKQP PQ &WRNGUU[ , %JTQPQNQIKG GV EKTEWNCVKQP FGU DCWFGMKPU ¯ EJGXCN KP 4$0 R

%1706; 0#/74 +P QPG $GTGPICT YCU OCTTKGF VQ C FCWIJVGT QH 4GIPKGT .QPIPGEMʼnU %QWPV QH .QOOGIQWY *G KU TGICTFGF CU VJG HQWPFKPI HCVJGT QH VJG EQOKVCN NKPG QH 0COWT 6JKU EQWPV[ PGXGT ECOG VQ HWNN FGXGNQROGPV CU KV YCU WPFGT EQPUVCPV RTGUUWTG QH VJG NCTIG PGKIJDQWTKPI VGTTKVQTKGU QH $TCDCPV CPF .K½IG # FKTGEV FGUEGPFCPV QH VJKU $GTGPICT YCU #NDGTV ++ *KU ITCPFUQP )QFHTG[ YCU YGFFGF VQ 'TOGUKPFG JGKTGUU QH .WZGODWTI *GPEG JKU UQP *GPT[ VJG $NKPF TWNGF 0COWT 5VCXGNQV /CNOGF[ CPF .WZGODWTI *GPT[ VJG $NKPFʼnU OCTTKCIG YCU EJKNFNGUU CPF JG CRRQKPVGF $CNFYKP 8+ QH *CKPCWV CU JKU UWEEGUUQT KP JKU FQOKPKQP CPF UVCTVKPI HQT (NCPFGTU VQQ *QYGXGT GKIJV [GCTU DGHQTG JKU FGCVJ C FCWIJVGT YCU DQTP 'TOGUKPFG CPF UQ JG EJCPIGF JKU YKNN KP HCXQWT QH JGT *KU FGOKUG KIPKVGF C UWEEGUUKQPCN YCT GXGPVWCNN[ YKPPKPI 'TOGUKPFG .WZGODQWTI CPF C HGY OKPQT VGTTKVQTKGU UGG HWTVJGT WPFGT .WZGODQWTI CPF VJG PF UQP QH $CNFYKP 8 2JKNKRU VJG 0QDNG TGVCKPGF 0COWT CU C HKGH HTQO JKU QNFGUV DTQVJGT $CNFYKP 8+ 6JG QNF DCVVNG DGVYGGP 0COWT CPF .WZGODWTI GPFWTGF CPF KP VJG GPF VJG EQWPV QH 0COWT UQNF JKU EQWPV[ KP VQ )W[ QH &CORKGTTG %QWPV QH (NCPFGTU *G NCVGT CRRQKPVGF VJG UQP HTQO JKU UGEQPF OCTTKCIG ,QJP QH 0COWT YJQ COQPI QVJGT VJKPIU HQWIJV KP %QWTVTCK VJG $CVVNG QH VJG )QNFGP 5RWTU 6JG *QWUG &CORKGTTG TWNGF WPVKN YJGP ,QJP +++ UQNF VJG EQWPV[ VQ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF HQT NCEM QH OQPG[ #.$'46 ++

&GPKGT &KPCPV # *GCF N #.$'4685 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ TKPI KP VJG EGPVTG CPF QPG ETGU EGPV KP GCEJ CPING &'10#/ %J F/ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP HQT VJKU V[RG XGT[ HKPG #JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ

432


#.$'46 +++

&GPKGT 0COGP # *GCF T #.$'4685 4 /10'6# ETQUU UJCRGF KP HKGNF 0# /8%'0 5+5 %J F/ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG C NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG QVJGTYKUG YGNN UVTWEM URGEKOGP HQT VJKU V[RG XGT[ HKPG

#JNUVTQO 5VQEMJQNO #WEVKQP PQ

2*+.+22' VJG 01$.'

&GPKGT # %JWTEJ YKVJ VYQ VQYGTU 0 # / 8 4 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ ETGUEGPVU CPF VYQ RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU / # 4 % + 5 %J F/ IT 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

)7+ QH &#/2+'44'

'UVGTNKP # 5JKGNF QH 0COWT /#4%*+1 0#/84 % 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU ) %1 /'5 (.# &4' %J F/ IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

'UVGTNKP # *GCF HCEKPI /#4%*+1 0#/84 % 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ) %1 /'5 (.# &4' %J F/ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

'UVGTNKP # *GCF HCEKPI /#4%*+1 0#/84 % 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING ) %1 /'5 (.# &4' %J F/ IT 8GT[ HKPG (KPP -GPFCN 'Z , ( %JQYP EQNNGEVKQP

'UVGTNKP # *GCF YKVJ VYQ ETQUUGU DGPGCVJ VJG PGEM /#4%*+1 0#/84 % 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJTGG CPINGU CPF QPG SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG NCUV CPING ) %1 /'5 (.# &4' %J F/ IT 8GT[ HKPG )NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 0QDNG EQNNGEVKQP #WUVTCNKC 6JKU XCTKGV[ JCU CP ' (NCPFTG HQT VJG PQTOCN V[RG UGG PQ

433


,'#0 +

'UVGTNKP 0COGP # %CUVNG + %1/'5 0#/84 %+ 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP VJG CPINGU /1# 0#/ 84% 5+5 %J F/ IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG CPF RGTHGEV RKGEG YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC *QNNGOCP OWPVGP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

%CXCNKGT 8KGUXKNNG # /QWPVGF MPKIJV N YKVJ UJKGNF QH 0COWT +1*'5 %1/'5 0#/84 4 5+)08/ %48%+5 CTQWPF ETQUU /10'6# ¶ 018# ¶ 8+..'05+5 %J F/ IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM PKEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG *GUU &KXQ <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ

/#4+' QH #461+5 &COG FG 2QKNXCEJG 9KFQY QH ,QJP + CPF TGIGPV HQT JGT HQWT UQPU ,QJP ++ )WK ++ 2JKNKR +++ CPF 9KNNKCO + /CT[ CESWKTGF VJG VGTTKVQT[ QH 2QKNXCEJG /GTCWFG QP JGT RGTUQPCN VKVNG +P UJG EQPHGTTGF VJG ECUVNG QH 2QKNXCEJG QP 0COWT

&GPKGT DKNNQP # %CUVNG / #4+ # &%# #46150 4 %TQUU /10' 6# / '4#8& %J F/ IT (KPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

)7+..#7/' +

$KNNQP 0QKT # 0#/ 84% KP VYQ NKPGU FKXKFGF D[ UVTKRG Þ 9+..'/ Ÿ %1/ Ÿ 0#/ 4 %TQUU Þ /10'6# Ÿ 018# Ÿ 0#/ %J F/ IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

)7+..#7/' ++

&WDDGNG O[V # 0 # / KP HKGNF YKVJ NKPG CDQXG )8+. .'./ 85 %1 /'5 4 (QWT NKU ETQUU UJCRGF /10'6# ¶ 0#/'0'0 %J F/ IT 8GT[ HKPG *WK\KPIC $GPPGMQO

434


%1706; &7%*; .7:'/$174) 6JG QTKIKPCN PCOG QH .WZGODQWTI KU .WEKNKPDWTJWE .WZGODQWTI KU C DTCPEJ QH VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG CPF KVU HKTUV MPQYP EQWPV YCU 5KIGHTQK + KP HTQO VJG 6TKGT CDDG[ 5V /CZKOKP 7PFGT VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG NKVVNG JCRRGPGF VJG EQWPV[ YCU WPFGTRQRWNCVGF CPF VJG UQKN YCU KPHGTVKNG 9KVJ %QPTCF + VJG HKTUV EQOKVCN *QWUG QH .WZGODQWTI EQOOGPEGF %QPTCF ECNNGF JKOUGNH EQOGU FG .WEENGODWTE 6JG *QWUG #TFGPPG NCUVGF WPVKN YJGP %QPTCF ++ OCTTKGF VQ )KU½NG FKGF EJKNFNGUU 6JG )GTOCP GORGTQT EQPHGTTGF VJG EQWPV[ QP VJG EQWUKP QH %QPTCF ++ *GPT[ QH 0COWT UQP QH %QWPV )QFHTG[ QH 0COWT CPF JKU YKHG 'TOGUKPFG

FCWIJVGT QH %QPTCF + HTQO VJG *QWUG #TFGPPG DTKPIKPI VJG *QWUG 0COWT VQ RQYGT 7PFGT *GPT[ VJG RTQOKUG QH C ITGCV 9CNNQQP EQPEGPVTCVKQP QH RQYGTU FCYPGF HQT C DTKGH OQOGPV DWV CNN JQRG YCU UQQP UJCVVGTGF KP VJG UWEEGUUKQPCN YCT CV JKU FGOKUG *GPT[ +++ YCU ETQYPGF )GTOCP MKPI KP CPF GORGTQT KP *KU ITCPFUQP %JCTNGU +8 CNUQ CUUWOGF DQVJ QHHKEGU MKPI KP GORGTQT KP CPF HKPCNN[ %JCTNGUʼn UQP 9GPEGUNCU DGECOG )GTOCP MKPI &WG VQ VJG CVVGPVKQP )GTOCP[ FGOCPFGF QH VJGUG TWNGTU .WZGODQWTI YCU OQTG CPF OQTG PGINGEVGF VJKU EWNOKPCVGF KP 9GPEGUNCUʼn OQTVICIKPI QH .WZGODQWTI VQ ,QDUV QH /QTCXKC CPF CHVGT YJQUG FGCVJ KV FGXQNXGF QP 'NKUCDGVJ QH )QTNKV\ 5JG YGFFGF VYKEG #PVQKPG QH $WTIWPF[ CPF ,QJP QH $CXCTKC #V VJG FGOKUG QH JGT UGEQPF JWUDCPF UJG VQQM VQVCN EQPVTQN QH VJG OQTVICIGF VGTTKVQT[ $GHQTG UJG FKGF UJG UQNF VJKU TKIJV QH OQTVICIG VQ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF FGHKPKVKXGN[ CPF .WZGODQWTI YCU KPEQTRQTCVGF KP VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO 6JG VTCPUHGT ECOG KPVQ GHHGEV CV 'NKUCDGVJʼnU FGOKUG KP *QWUG 0COWT '4/'5+0&' #HVGT *GPT[ʼnU FGCVJ KP JKU VGTTKVQT[ YCU FKXKFGF .WZGODQWTI C HGY OKPQT RTQRGTVKGU CPF IWCTFKCPUJKR QXGT 'EJVGTPCEJ CPF 5VCDNQ FGXQNXGF VQ JKU FCWIJVGT 'TOGUKPFG *GT DQVJ JWUDCPFU 6JGQDCNF QH $CT CPF 9CNTCO +++ QH .KODWTI WUGF VJG NKVVNG TQQO VJGTG YCU VQ GZRCPF VJG VGTTKVQT[ VQ VJG PQTVJ #HVGT 'TOGUKPFGUʼn OCKP CKO YCU UWEEGUUKQP D[ JGT UQP *GPT[ 8 QT CHVGT VJG TGPWODGTKPI *GPT[ +

&GPKGT .WZGODQWTI # %QWPVGUU UVCPFKPI N YKVJ DTCPEJ QH NKU KP VJG JCPF .85'0 $14 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODWTI *# 0 4+ 9GKNNGT IT 44 8GT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU 6JG PCOG QH *#04+ KU VJCV QH JGT UQP

*QWUG QH .WZGODQWTI .KODQWTI *'04+ +

&GPKGT .WZGODQWTI # /QWPVGF MPKIJV YKVJ UYQTF N *#04+ 5 4 %CUVNG YKVJ JGCF CDQXG .85' 0$14 9GKNNGT IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU +P 9GKNNGT WPFGT *GPT[ 8 NG $NQPFGN

435


&GPKGT .WZGODQWTI # /QWPVGF MPKIJV T 4 %TQUU * %1/'5 . 8%'$ 9GKNNGT IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG 2GWU ņ (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ

#U GZRCPUKQP VQ VJG PQTVJ YCU VJG QPN[ TGCN RQUUKDKNKV[ *GPT[ ++ KPVGTHGTGF KP VJG .KODWTI UWEEGUUKQP YCT DWV WPHQTVWPCVGN[ JG EJQUG VJG YTQPI UKFG *G FKGF KP VJG DCVVNG CV 9QTTKPIGP *QYGXGT VJG GPUWKPI NQUU QH .KODWTI YCU OCFG IQQF D[ VJG UWEEGUUHWN KPVG ITCVKQPCN RQNKVKEU PQDKNKV[ EQNNCDQTCVKPI YKVJ VJG EKVKGU QH VJG 0COWTU *GPT[ +++ QTICPKUGF .WZGODQWTI CHVGT (NGOKUJ GZCORNG *G YCU ETQYPGF )GTOCP MKPI KP CPF GORGTQT KP *KU TGKIP YCU PQV XGT[ UWEEGUUHWN GZEGRV CV VJG JQOG HTQPV

,'#0 ++ 6JG UQP QH *GPT[ +++ ,QJP VJG $NKPF YCU YGFFGF VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QH $QJGOKC CPF YCU MKPI QH $QJGOKC *KU NQ[CN UVCPEG VQYCTF (TCPEG CUUWTGF JKO QH VJG (TGPEJ DCEMWR JG PGGFGF VQ EJCNNGPIG ,QJP +++ QH $TCDCPV

'UVGTNKP .WZGODQWTI # %TQYPGF JGCF HCEKPI '+9#0'5 & 05 < 4': $ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ VJTGG RGNNGVU KP GCEJ CPING .1% '0$ )'0 5+5 9GKNNGT IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG 8KPEJQP 2CTKU %JCWVCTF PQ 2N :+8 KU C XCTKCPV QH PQ .8%

%*#4.'5 +8 #HVGT ,QJP QH $CXCTKCʼnU FGCVJ JKU UQP %JCTNGU +8 CVVCKPGF RQYGT JG CNUQ CU )GTOCP GO RGTQT )QKPI CICKPUV JKU HCVJGTʼnU GZRNKEKV YKNN %JCTNGU ITCPVGF VJG EQWPV[ VQ #TEJDKUJQR $CNFYKP QH 6TKGT 0QV WPVKN CHVGT VJG NCVVGTʼnU FGCVJ KP FKF EQOKVCN FKIPKV[ RCUU VQ 9GPEGUNCU + C JCNH DTQVJGT QH %JCTNGU 6JG EQWPV[ YCU VJGP GNGXCVGF VQ FWEJ[ 9GPEGUNCUʼn GPJCPEGF UKIPKHKECPEG PQY GPCDNKPI JKO VQ OCTT[ ,GCPPG JGKTGUU VQ $TCDCPV 6JG KPVGPFGF WPKQP JQYGXGT YCU RWV QHH

)TQU 6QWTPQKU (TCPMHWTV ! # %J³VGN VQWTPQKU 6841085 %+8+5 YKVJKP EKTENG QH CTEJGU GP ENQUKPI NKU 4 -*#41.85 4': CTQWPF ETQUU F/ C IT 4 8GT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 9KVJ PQ .CHCWTKG PQVGU KP JKU .GU /QPPCKGU FG 4QKU FG (TCPEG RCTV + .GU )TQU RNWU PQODTGWZ SWK QPV -JCTQNWU TGZ RCT WP * UCPU (T KNU PG UQPV RCU FG %JCTNGU +8 NG $GN OCKU QPV ¾V¾ HCDTKSW¾U FʼnCRT½U FGU 2JKNKR RWU QW FGU .WFQXKEWU FQPV KNU TGRTQFWKUGPV NG UV[NG GV NGU FKHH¾TGPVU NC RNWRCTV UQWU ,QJP NG $QP GV UG TCRRQTVGPV ¯ %JCTNGU FG .WZGODQWTI TQK RWKU GORGTGWT KNU R½UGPV CPF I¾P¾TCN OQKPU FG IT C[CPV ¾V¾ VCKNN¾U RQWT NC RNWRCTV CW OCTE FG %QNQIPG IT RQWT NC O¿OG EJKHHTG FG VCKNNG SWG NGU CWVTGU 9GKNNGT ENCUUKHKGU VJKU EQKP WPFGT /QPPCKGU PQP .WZGODQWTIGQKUGU CPF RTQXKFGU VJG HQNNQYKPI EQOOGPVCT[ R %GTVCKPU PWOKUOCVGU UG XQKGPV RCTHQKU VGPV¾U FʼnCVVTKDWGT CW .WZGODQWTI NGU ITQU VQWTPQKU FG %JCTNGU +8 RQT VCPV -CTQNXU 4GZ QW -CTQNXU +OR %WTKQWUN[ 9GKNNGT FQGU PQV FKUEWUU VJG * VJCV FQGU CRRGCT QP VJG KOCIGU %GVVG CVVTKDWVKQP PʼnGUV RCU CFOKUUKDNG %JCTNGU +8 HWV ¾NW TQK FGU 4QOCKPU NG GV KPXGUVK FW VKVTG FʼnGORGTGWT NG .GU RK½EGU SWK RQTVGPV NG VKVTG FʼnGORGTGWT PʼnQPV RCU RW ¿VTG HTCRR¾GU CW .WZGODQWTI SWK ¾VCKV CPF RQUUGU UKQP FG 9GPEGUNCU + FGRWKU NG 3WCPV CWZ RK½EGU CXGE -CTQNXU 4GZ NʼnKFGPVKV¾ FG UV[NG GV FG HCDTKSWG F¾ PQVG NC O¿OG QTKIKPG #U PQDQF[ MPQYU HQT EGTVCKP YJGTG KP VJG )GTOCP GORKTG VJKU EQKP OKIJV JCXG DGGP UVTWEM 9GKNNGT VQQ TGOCTMU 'NNGU UQTVGPV FQPE FʼnWP CVGNKGT Fʼn'ORKTG ¯ NQECNKUGT YG JCXG TCPMGF KV WPFGT .WZGODQWTI HQT VJG VKOG DGKPI 1VJGTYKUG KP 9GKNNGT 4 .GU OQPPC[CIGU ¾VTCPIGTU FGU 2TKPEGU .WZGODQWTIGQKU .WZGODQWTI JG OGPVKQPU KH VJKU EQKP OKIJV DG UVTWEM KP (TCPMHWTV EH R $GECWUG KV KU KORQUUKDNG VQ CUEGTVCKP YJGVJGT VJG URGNNKPI -*#41.85 YCU WUGF HQT %JCTNGU GNUGYJGTG VQQ YG JCXG NKUVGF VJKU EQKP WPFGT .WZGODQWTI YKVJQWV HWTVJGT KPFKECVKQP RTGHGTTKPI VJG OKPV (TCPMHWTV

436


&WEJ[ .WZGODQWTI 9'0%'5.#5 + 6JTQWIJ JKU OCTTKCIG VQ ,GCPPG QH $TCDCPV JG YCU VJG OQUV RQYGTHWN OCP KP VJG .QY %QWP VTKGU 6JG YCT CICKPUV JKU DTQVJGT KP NCY .QWKU QH /CGNG YCU VWTPKPI QWV VQ DG FGUCUVTQWU CPF KP VJG YCT CICKPUV VJG FWMG QH ,ÒNKEJ JG YCU VCMGP ECRVKXG CHVGT VJG DCVVNG CV $CGUYGKNGT

'UVGTNKP .WZGODQWTI # 5JKGNF QH $QJGOKC UV CPF VJ $TCDCPV PF CPF .WZGODWTI TF &8: $4#$ #06+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU /10'6# Q .1%' $)'5 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5VTWEM CTQWPF

$NCP )TQU .WZGODQWTI # (QWT 8 U ETQUU UJCRGF 9'0%'. Z &'+ Z )4# Z .8% Z $4#$ Z &8: 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODWTI CPF $QJGOKC WPFGT ETQYP /10'6# Z 018# ” .8%'$84)'05 9GKNNGT IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN 5VTWEM CV VJG GPF QH JKU TGKIP

9'0%'5.#5 ++ #V VJG FGOKUG QH 9GPEGUNCU + KP EJKNFNGUU VJG UQP QH %JCTNGU +8 9GPEGUNCU ++ VQQM QXGT JG YCU CNTGCF[ 4QOCP MKPI UKPEG CPF MKPI QH $QJGOKC UKPEG

)CPU .WZGODQWTI # 'CING N 9'0%'. 41/#014 < $1'/ 4': 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI WPFGT ITGCV ETQYP /10'6# 018# .8%'0$84)' 9GKNNGT IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

437


,155' QH /14#8+' +P 9GPEGUNCU OQTVICIGF VJG FWEJ[ VQ /CTITCXG ,QDUV QH /QTCXKC

)CPU .WZGODQWTI # 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI CPF /QTCXKC KP VTGHQKN +1&1% Q /#4%* Q < &05 Q /14#8+' 4 /10 '6# .8% '0$ CTQWPF NQPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF $0&+%6 5+6 01/'0 &0+ +*8 :2+ 9GKNNGT IT 4 6TCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN UVG GOKUUKQP 0QVG VJG UOCNN HCEGU KP VJG NGVVGTU HQT CP GNWEKFCVKQP UGG WPFGT *CKPCWV 1VJGT .WZGODQWTI V[RGU YKVJ UOCNN HCEGU 9GKNNGT 9GPEGUNCU ++ QP VJG QDXGTUG QPN[ KP VJG % QH 9GPEGN CPF QP VJG TGXGTUG QPN[ KP VJG / QH /QPGVC 9GKNNGT F H ,QJP FG $CXK½TG QPN[ VYKEG KP VJG QDXGTUG 1 CPF VYKEG KP VJG TGXGTUG 1 9GKNNGT ,QJP FG $CXK½TG QPN[ QPEG KP VJG TGXGTUG %

)TQU PWYITQUEJGP .WZGODQWTI # .KQP QH .WZGODQWTI YKVJ VJG UJKGNF QH /QTCXKC QP VJG DTGCUV +&1% /#4%* < &05 /14#8 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG UVCT KP GCEJ CPING /10'6# 018# (%# .8%'0$ 9GKNNGT IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC )NGPFKPKPI .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ

'.+5#$'6* QH )¤4.+6< CPF #061+0' QH $174)1)0' #V VJG FGOKUG QH ,QDUV KP VJG FWEJ[ YCU OQTVICIGF VQ JKU EQWUKP 'NKUCDGVJ QH )ÌTNKV\ 5KIKUOWPFʼnU CVVGORVU CV YKPPKPI DCEM RQYGT YGTG VQ PQ CXCKN VJG OQUV VJG[ FKF YCU NGCXG VJG EQWPVT[ KP C UVCVG QH EQPHWUKQP +P VJG GPF VJG TKIJV QH OQTVICIG YCU TGVCKPGF D[ 'NKUCDGVJ 'NKUCDGVJ YGFFGF #PVQKPG QH $WTIWPF[ QP VJG VJ QH #RTKN KP 2TCIWG +P VJG OCTTKCIG EGTVKHKECVG VJG )GTOCP MKPI UVCVGF VJG RQUUKDKNKV[ VQ LQKPVN[ TGEQXGT VJG TKIJV QH OQTVICIG #HVGT ,QDUVʼnU FGCVJ 'NKUCDGVJ YCU VJG UQNG OQTVICIG FWEJGUU DWV KV YQWNF VCMG VJTGG ECO RCKIPU D[ #PVQKPG CICKPUV VJG WPYKNNKPI PQDKNKV[ HQT JGT VQ TGRQUUGUU VJG NCPF $QVJ JWUDCPFU #PVQKPG QH $WTIWPF[ CPF ,QJP QH $CXCTKC UVTWEM EQKP KP VJGKT QYP PCOG YKVJQWV C TGHGTGPEG VQ 'NKUCDGVJ QP VJG EQKPU FWE YCU OGPVKQPGF JQYGXGT

)TQU PWYG NGYGITQUEJGP .WZGODQWTI # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ UV CPF VJ HKGNF $TCDCPV PF HKGNF CPF .WZGODQWTI TF HKGNF QP VJG DTGCUV #06*1 &+ )4# $4#$ < .+/$ &8: 4 %TQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# „ &8% Q $4#$ Q (%# Q .8%'/$ Q 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

438


'.+5#$'6* QH )¤4.+6< CPF ,'#0 QH $#8#4+# #HVGT VJG FGCVJ QH #PVQKPG QP VJG VJ 1EVQDGT 'NKUCDGVJ OCTTKGF ,QJP QH $CXCTKC HTQO VJG *QWUG QH 9KVVGNUDCEJ ,QJP YCU GNGEV QH VJG 2TKPEG $KUJQRTKE .K½IG CPF OQTVICIG EQWPV QH *QNNCPF CPF <GGNCPF *G FKGF EJKNFNGUU QP VJG VJ ,CPWCT[

)TQU PWYITQUEJGP QT DG[GTUITQUEJGP .WZGODQWTI # )TKHHQP JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG IOH DVX $#8#4 < (++.85 *1. 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU /10'6# 018# (%# .8%'0$ 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN UV GOKUUKQP

)TQU PWYITQUEJGP QT DG[GTUITQUEJGP .WZGODQWTI # )TKHHQP JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG IOH DVX $#8#4 < (++.85 *1. 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT long cross /10'6# 018# (%# .8%'0$ 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO C HKPF PGCT 6TKGT UV GOKUUKQP 1P VJG QDXGTUG C HCEG KP VJG 1 U QH +1* CPF *1. +P VJG 1 QH /10'6# QP VJG TGXGTUG PQ HCEG

$G[GTUITQU .WZGODQWTI # 5JKGNF QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG +1* Q &8: Q $#8#4 Q < „ (+.+ Q *1 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU /10'6# Q 018# Q (%# Q .8% Q $ 9GKNNGT IT /KPQT VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GPCWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO C HKPF PGCT 6TKGT UV GOKUUKQP 1P VJG TGXGTUG C HCEG KP VJG % QH .8%

439


'.+5#$'6* QH )ยค4.+6< +P C VTGCV[ -KPI 5KIKUOWPF CEMPQYNGFIGF VJG OQTVICIG TKIJVU QH 'NKUCDGVJ JQYGXGT JG JCF VJG JGTKVCDNG TKIJVU QH VJG $WTIWPFKCP *QWUG GZRKTG ,QJCPP FKF CESWKTG NKHGVKOG WUW HTWEV +P 'NKUCDGVJ UQNF JGT OQTVICIG TKIJV VQ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF YJKEJ JQYGXGT YCU PQV CEEGRVGF D[ VJG 'UVCVGU #HVGT UGXGTCN CVVGORVU VQ UGNN VJG OQTVICIG VQ VJG 6TKGT CTEJDKUJQR ,CMQD QH 5KGTEM RTQXGF KP XCKP KV YCU UQNF VQ 2JKNKR VJG )QQF GXGPVWCNN[ 6TGCV[ QH *GUFKP VJ QH 1EVQDGT

)TQU .WZGODQWTI # %TQYPGF JGNOGV QXGT VJG CTOU QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG '.+<#$ รฐ & รฐ ) รฐ &8%+5 รฐ $#8#4 รฐ < รฐ .8%' 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU /10'6# 018# Q .8%'0$84)'05+5 9GKNNGT IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 2GWU (TCPMHWTV #WEVKQP PQ UV GOKUUKQP

)TQU .WZGODQWTI # %TQYPGF JGNOGV QXGT VJG CTOU QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG '.+<#$ รฐ & รฐ ) รฐ &8%+5 รฐ $#8#4 รฐ < รฐ .7%' 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU /10'6# 018# Q .8%'0$84)'05+5 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG )CPU #TPUDGTI (TQO NKUV PQ UV GOKUUKQP

)TQU .WZGODQWTI # %TQYPGF JGNOGV QXGT VJG CTOU QH $CXCTKC CPF VJG 2CNCVKPCVG '.+<#$ Q &8%+5 Q $#8#4 Q .8%' 4 5JKGNF QH .WZGODQWTI QXGT NQPI ETQUU /10' 018# .8%'0$84) Q 9GKNNGT IT 8GT[ HKPG 9KPVGT &ร UUGNFQTH #WEVKQP PQ

440


UV GOKUUKQP

)TQU #FGNGTUITQKUU .WZGODQWTI # 5JKGNFU QH $CXCTKC 2CNCVKPCVG N CPF .WZGODQWTI T WPFGT GCING N ELISAB' & ) &8 $#8# < . 4 &QWDNG NKPGF ETQUU YKVJ QTPCOGPVGF SWCVTGHQKN /10' 018# .8%' $84) 9GKNNGT IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP W /GFCKNNGP $CUGN PF GOKUUKQP

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

IKTFGF D[ C UVTKRGF DQTFWTG UKIP QH VJG [QWPIGUV UQP YJKEJ JQYGXGT YCU OCKPVCKPGF QXGT VJG EQWTUG QH VKOG 2JKNKR VJG $QNF YCU YGFFGF VQ /CTICTGVJC FCWIJVGT QH VJG (NGOKUJ %QWPV .QWKU QH /CGNG #HVGT VJG NCVVGTʼnU FGOKUG KP 2JKNKR VJG $QNF DGECOG EQWPV QH (NCPFGTU *KU UQP ,QJP VJG (GCTNGUU OCKPVCKPGF VJG UKPING NKU KP JKU CTOU DWV CFFGF CP KPGU EWVEJGQP VJG CTOU QH (NCPFGTU UOCNN NKQP 'XGP KH $WTIWPFKCP RQYGT JCFPʼn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¾QFCNG $WTIWPF[ CPF HQT VJQUG WPFGT VJG EQWPVU QH (NCPFGTU UGG WPFGT (NCPFGTU $WTIWPF[ʼnU OCP[ YCTU NGHV VJGKT OCTMU QP EQKPCIG CPF KVU EQKPU FKURNC[ C OWNVKVWFG QH DKDNKECN VGZVU 2*+.+25 FG )1'&' 2JKNKR VJG )QQF OCKPVCKPGF C ENQUG TGNCVKQPUJKR YKVJ VJG 'PINKUJ CPF JCF JKU JCPF KP VJG CEEGUUKQP VQ VJG (TGPEJ VJTQPG QH 'PINKUJ -KPI *GPT[ 8 2JKNKR VJG )QQFʼn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ʼn 9CT CPF UKIPGF VJG 2GCEG QH #TTCU YKVJ (TCPEG 2JKNKR YCU QP OQUV KPVKOCVG VGTOU YKVJ VJG RQRG YJKEJ RGTOKVVGF JKO VQ CRRQKPV EQPHKFCPVU VQ JGCF VJG FKQEGUGU CFLQKPKPI JKU TGCNO 441


6JKU TGNCVKQPUJKR CPF VJG FGHGCV QH JKU HCVJGT CV 0KEQRQNKU MKPFNGF 2JKNKRʼnU FGUKTG VQ VCMG WR VJG ETQUU CPF UGV QWV QP C ETWUCFG +P JG JCF HQWPFGF VJG 1TFGT QH VJG )QNFGP (NGGEG CPF GPXKUKQPGF JKOUGNH C ,CUQP NGCFKPI JKU %JTKUVKCP #TIQPCWVU GCUV JQRKPI VJG TCOʼnU HNGGEG VJCV JG CPF JKU MPKIJVU YQTG CTQWPF VJGKT PGEMU CU CP GODNGO YQWNF KPURKTG JKO YKVJ HCKVJ CU KV FKF )KFGQP +P RNCPU YGTG HKPCNN[ FKUEWUUGF DWV KP VJG GPF VJG ETWUCFG YCU ECPEGNNGF 2JKNKR YCU FGGRN[ FKUCRRQKPVGF OCP[ JKUVQTKCPU OCKPVCKP 2JKNKRʼnU OQVKXGU YGTG RWTGN[ RQNKVK ECN DWV VJG[ HCKN VQ TGEQIPKUG VJG HQTEG QH VJG EJKXCNTKE KFGCNU YKVJKP VJG $WTIWPFKCP TWNGTU UV GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV TF QH ,CPWCT[

%CXCNKGT F QT $TCDCPV # /QWPVGF FWMG T YKVJ Z $4#$ Z KP GZGTIWG 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” $4#$ ” < ” .+/$84) 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN ” (D X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP 'Z 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ .GIGPF TGXGTUG 2TCKUGF UJCNN DG VJG PCOG QH VJG .QTF 2U ,QD D &CP 1P VJG JQTUGʼnU ENQCM C RCKT QH HKTG UVGGNU 6JG HKTG UVGGN YCU VJG RGTUQPCN GODNGO QH 2JKNKR VJG )QQF CPF NCVGT DGECOG C IGPGTCN $WTIWPFKCP U[ODQN

%CXCNKGT F QT (NCPFGTU # /QWPVGF FWMG T YKVJ Z (.#& Z KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” < ” %1/'5 ” (.#0&4+' 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN (D X)* IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

&QWDNG ITQU (NCPFGTU # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF 2*5 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ %1/'5 „ (.#0& 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10'6# „ 018# „ %1/+6+5 „ (.#0& X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO

442


)TQU *QNNCPF # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF 2*5 „ &'+ „ ) „ &8: „ $84 „ % „ *1. 4 %TQUU YKVJ QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /1 0'6# „ 018# „ %1/+6 „ *1. < X)* C IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP

&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF 2*5 & ) & $ % 1/ (.#0 & 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# 0# %1/ (.#0& X)* IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN X)* FQGU PQV IKXG VJG & HQT VJG VGZV QH VJG QDXGTUG +V KU XGT[ JCTF VQ VGNN HTQO YJKEJ GOKUUKQP VJG PQU CPF UVGO 9G JCXG PQY ENCUUKHKGF VJGUG WPFGT VJG EQKPU YKVJ VJG UCOG QDXGTUGU VJCV YG FQ MPQY VJG GOKUUKQP QH 6JWU VJG PQU CPF YGTG ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT VJG GOKUUKQP QH CU VJG[ UJQY C HKGNF HKNNKPI EQCV QH CTOU YJKEJ KU CNUQ UGGP QP PQ 5KOKNCTN[ PQ YCU ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT VJG GOKUUKQP QH CU KVU EQCV QH CTOU KU PQV HKGNF HKNNKPI CU YKVJ VJG PQU CPF TGH X $GGM

&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF 2*5 & $ ) %1/ (.#0& 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# 0# %1/ (.#0 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG (TQO 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F 6JG NGVVGTU KP VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG CTG KP VJG YTQPI QTFGT

&QWDNG OKVG $TCDCPV # #TOU QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF 2*5 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $84) „ < „ $4 4 %TQUU YKVJ UJKGNF KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# „ 018# „ .18#0+' X)* D IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 5VTWEM KP .GWXGP 6JG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG CU UVCVGF YCU VCMGP HTQO X)* DWV KV KU EQTTGEV (QT VJG TGXGTUG VGZV X)* RTQXKFGU ( #%6 # DGVYGGP 018# CPF .18#0+' DWV VJKU KUP V CEWTCVG

PF GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH ,WPG 9KVJ JKU PF GOKUUKQP 2JKNKR KPVTQFWEGF VJG IQNF NKQP CP CNVQIGVJGT PGY V[RG CV VJCV OQOGPV VJCV YCU RTGUWOCDN[ KUUWGF D[ JKO DGECWUG JG FGUKTGF JKU QYP $WTIWPFKCP EQKP

.KQP F QT $TCDCPV # .KQP UKVVKPI WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ N DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” $4#$ ” &05 ” /. 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU ” 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN ” (D X)* IT 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

443


.KQP F QT (NCPFGTU # .KQP UKVVKPI WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ N DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $74) ” %1/ ” (.#0& 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN (D X)* IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG TGXGTUG QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ

.KQP F QT *CKPCWV # .KQP UKVVKPI WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ N DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $74) ” %1/'5 ” *#01+' 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN (D X)* IT 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG X F &WUUGP /CCUVTKEJV #WEVKQP PQ

.KQP F QT *QNNCPF # .KQP UKVVKPI WPFGT IQVJKE ECPQR[ N DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU 2*5 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $74) ” %1/'5 ” *1. < 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/' ” &1/+0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 ” HKTG UVGGN (D X)* IT 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

-ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ #TEJKXGU UJQY VJCV FWG VQ C FKURWVG YKVJ VJG EQWPEKN QH &QTFTGEJV EQOKVCN EQKP YCU VGORQTCTKN[ UVTWEM CV VJG QRGTC VKQPCN OKPV QH 6JG *CIWG CV VJG )TQVG /CTMV HTQO VJG OKFFNG QH VQ /C[ 6JCV KU YJGTG VJKU EQKP YCU UVTWEM 01/' KPUVGCF QH 01/'0

444


.KQP F QT (NCPFGTU # .KQP UKVVKPI WPFGT IQVJKE FCKU N DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU 2*5 ” &'+ ” ) ” &8: ” $84) ” %1 ” (.#0& 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5+6 ” 01/'0 ” &0+ ” $'0'&+%68/ ” #/'0 (D X)* IT 4 5NKIJVGN[ DGPV XGT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ

.KQP F QT $TCDCPV # .KQP UKVVKPI KP OWNVKNQDG 2*5 Z &'+ Z )4# Z &8: Z $74) Z &05 Z /'%*. 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP OWNVKNQDG 5+6 Z 01/'0 Z &1/+0+ Z $'0'&+%68/ HKTG UVGGN (D X)* IT 44 XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM KP /GEJGNGP KP

TF GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV TF QH /C[ +P VJKU VJKTF GOKUUKQP 2JKNKR QTFGTGF C WPKHQTO OCPWHCEVWTG QH VJG $WTIWPFKCP IWKNFGT CHVGT VJG 4JKPKCP IWKNFGT GZCORNG +V YQWNF DG UVTWEM WPVKN YJGP KV YCU TGRNCEGF YKVJ VJG 5V 2JKNKRRWU IWKNFGT

(NQTKP FG $QWTIQIPG (NCPFGTU # 5CKPV #PFTGCU JQNFKPI NCTIG ETQUU 5#0%685 ” #0&4'#5 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT ITGCV ETQUU 2*5 ” &8: ” $84) ” %1/'5 (.#0& (D X)* IT 4 9GNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO 5V #PFTGCU FKUEKRNG /CTE CPF ,QJ YCU VJG RCVTQP UCKPV QH $WTIWPF[ 6JG NCTIG ETQUU KU VJG 5V #PFTGYʼnU %TQUU CNUQ 5CNVKTG 5V #PFTGCU KU DGNKGXGF VQ JCXG DGGP ETWEKHKGF QP C UKOKNCT ETQUU

&QWDNG RCVCTF (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*5 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $74) „ %1/'5 „ (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ „ #/'0 X)* D IT 5OCNN HNCP QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

445


&QWDNG RCVCTF *QNNCPF # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP VTGHQKN 2*5 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $84) „ %1/ „ *1.& „ < „ < 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ „ #/' X)* IT 4 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 'Z 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

&GPKGT FG *QNNCPFG # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ 2*5 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ *1.< 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# „ %1/ *1. „ X)* D IT 4 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 6JKU V[RG YCU UVTWEM KP VJG RGTKQF KP 6JG *CIWG CPF KP VJG RGTKQF KP &QTFTGEJV +V KU RTGNKOKPCTKN[ ENCUUKHKGF WPFGT VJG NCUV GOKUUKQP

-#4'. FG 56176' %JCTNGU VJG $QNF NQPIGF VQ TGUVQTG VJG %CTQNKPIKCP /KFFNG 4GCNO QH .QVJCKT 6JG UKOWNVCPG QWU EQPSWGTU QH )WGNFGTU CPF .QTTCKPG KP KP RCTVKEWNCT DTQWIJV JKU FTGCO YKVJKP UKIJV 6JG NCUV VCEVKECN OCPQGWXTG JG JCF NGHV YCU VJG OCTTKCIG QH JKU QPN[ FCWIJVGT /CTKC VQ /CZKOKNKCP QNFGUV UQP QH 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++ %JCTNGU JKOUGNH YCPVGF VQ DGEQOG 4QOCP MKPI CPF GXGPVWCNN[ UWEEGGF VJG GORGTQT +P 6TKGT (TGFGTKEM +++ CUUGPVGF VJG HQTOCVKQP QH VJG -KPIFQO QH $WTIWPF[ DWV %JCTNGU NGHV 6TKGT CV VJG NCUV OQOGPV VJG )GTOCP RTKPEGU RTGUWOCDN[ YKUJGF PQ KPVGTHGTGPEG D[ VJG TKEJ $WTIWPFKCPU 6JCV YCU YJGP JKU TGCNO UVCTVGF ETWODNKPI *G YCU MKNNGF KP C .QTTCKPG KPUWTIGPE[ QP VJG VJ ,CPWCT[ KP 0CPE[

UGG WPFGT #NUCEG .QTTCKPG &KTGEVN[ CHVGT JKU FGOKUG VJG (TGPEJ MKPI UGK\GF %JCTNGUʼn (TGPEJ RTQRGTVKGU COQPI YJKEJ $WTIWPF[ (TQO VJCV OQOGPV QP VJG $WTIWPFKCP TGCNO YCU UQNGN[ OCFG WR QH VJG 0GVJGT NCPFUʼn FKUVTKEVU 5VKNN VJG JQWUG YQWNF OCKPVCKP VJG VKVNG &WMG QH $WTIWPF[ $WTIWPF[ JCXKPI DGEQOG C OGTG HCOKN[ PCOG &WTKPI VJG TGKIP QH %JCTNGU VJG $QNF QPN[ VJG OKPVU QH $TCDCPV .GWXGP CPF (NCPFGTU

$TWIGU YGTG QRGTCVGF +P C OKPV YCU GUVCDNKUJGF KP )WGNFGTU 0KLOGIGP VQQ RGTJCRU VQ UJQY VJCV )WGNFGTU YCU VJGP FGHKPKVKXGN[ C $WTIWPFKCP RTQRGTV[ 6JG EQCV QH CTOU TG OCKPGF WPEJCPIGF FWTKPI %JCTNGUʼn TGKIP UV GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH 1EVQDGT

&QWDNG RCVCTF $TCDCPV # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ -#41.85 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $) „ $4#$ „ < „ .+/ „ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKQP KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ „ #0 X)* IT #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG

446


&QWDNG RCVCTF (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ -#41.85 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $84) „ %1 „ (.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ „ HKTG UVGGN X)* IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

4CWEJ 9KGP #WEVKQP PQ

&QWDNG ITQU $TCDCPV # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF -#41.85 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $) „ $4#$ „ < „ .+/ 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ NKQP KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10'6# „ 018# „ &8% „ $4#$#06 „ X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG *QNNGOCP 'PUEJGFG (TQO NKUV PQ

&QWDNG ITQU (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF -#41.85 „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $ ) „ %1/ „ (. 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10'6# „ 0# „ %1/+6 „ (.#0& X)* IT &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

)TQU (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF -#41.85 &'+ )4# &8: $) %1 (. 4 .QPI ETQUU FKXKFKPI NGIGPF YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG QPG NKQP KP VJG UV CPF VJ CPINGU CPF QPG NKU KP VJG PF CPF TF CPINGU /10'6# 018# %1/+6+ (.#& X)* IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG 5RKPM .QPFQP

)TQU (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF -#41. „ &+ „ )4# „ &: „ $) „ %1 „ (. 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ NKU CPF VYQ NKQPU KP VJG CPINGU /10'6# „ 08# „ %1/+6+ „ (.# X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

447


&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF -#41. Q & Q ) Q & Q $) Q %1 Q (.# 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /10'6# Q 0# Q %1/ Q (.#& X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG

(TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN

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ʼnU GODNGO C ECTRGPVGTʼnU RNCPG YKVJ HN[KPI UJCXKPIU JG KP VWTP CNNWFKPI VQ VJG MPQVV[ ENWD GODNGO QH VJG (TGPEJ -KPI VJCV JG YKUJGF VQ TGFWEG VQ UJCXKPIU +V DGECOG VJG U[ODQN QH VJG $WTIWPFKCP *QWUG CPF HGCVWTGU QP OCP[ EQKPU CPF KP VJG EJCKP QH VJG 1TFGT QH VJG )QNFGP (NGGEG 'PE[ENQRGFKG XCP OWPVGP CPF DCPMDKNLGVVGP

(NQTKP FG $QWTIQIPG (NCPFGTU # 5CKPV #PFTGCU UVCPFKPI CPF JQNFKPI NCTIG ETQUU 5#0%685 ” ” #0&4'#5 ” 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT ETQUU -#41.85 &'+ )4# %1 (.#0 (D X)* IT 9GNN UVTWEM CPF GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP (TQO 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO F F + VJKPM VJKU KU VJG UGEQPF GOKUUKQP +V UJQWNF FKURNC[ C URWT KORTKPV CU OQPG[GTʼnU UKIP OQNGVVG F GRGTQP 6JCV YQWNF JCXG VQ DG VJG UOCNN TQUG VJGP

(NQTKP FG $QWTIQIPG )GNFGTNCPF # 5CKPV #PFTGCU UVCPFKPI CPF JQNFKPI NCTIG ETQUU 5#0%685 #0&4'#5 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT ETQUU -#41. &+ ” )4# &8: ” $74 ” )'. X)* (D IT 8GT[ HKPG -ÒPMGT 1UPCDTÒEM #WEVKQP PQ 5VTWEM KP 0KLOGIGP *GTG VQQ WPFGT 5V #PFTGY C UOCNN ETQUU UOCNN TQUG #V VJG WRRGT CTO QH VJG ETQUU QP VJG TGXGTUG VJGTG KU C UVCT

448


&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO -#41. „ &'+ „ )4# „ &: „ $) „ $4# „ < „ .+ JCPF 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ 688 „ &01 „ # „ X)* IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ RNGCUKPIN[ RCVKPC

$QWIJV &GMMGT EQNNGEVKQP .GIGPF TGXGTUG 5#.88/ (#% 2128.8/ 688/ &1/+0' 1J .QTF RTQVGEV [QWT RGQRNG ,GT 2U

&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO -#41. „ &'+ „ )4# „ &: „ $) „ $4# „ < „ .+ JCPF 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ 688 „ &0' „ # „ X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

&QWDNG DTKSWGV (NCPFGTU # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO -#41.85 ” &'+ ” )4# ” &8: ” $84) ” %1 ” ( ” 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88/ ” (#% ” 2128.8 ” 688 ” &0' X)* IT 4 'ZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC

$TKSWGV $TCDCPV # .KQP UKVVKPI CPF JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ -#41. „ &'+ „ )4# „ &8: „ $) „ $4# „ < „ .+ JCPF 4 %TQUU YKVJKP YTGCVJ QH HNQYGTU CPF SWCVTGHQKN KP VJG EGPVTG $'0'&+% „ *'4'&+6#6+ „ 68' „ # „ X)* IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

&GNOQPVG $TWUUGN +P VJG GZGTIWG C YJGGN QH C JQTUGOCPʼnU URWT QT OWNNGV UKIP QH VJG OQPG[GT /CTE NG $WPIPGVGWT

-TKEJGNFQTH (TGKDWTI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z -KTEJJGKOGT EQNNGEVKQP 6GZV TGXGTUG $'0'&+% *'4'&+6#6+ 68#' &1/+0' $NGUU 6J[ *GKTU 1 .QTF %QORCTKPI VJG EQKPU VQ VJG PQU CPF DQVJ NCUV QH /CTKC RTQXGU OQUV KPVGTGUVKPI 6JG FKGU CRRGCT VQ DG KFGPVKECN KP VJG HKGNF #NVJQWIJ VJG[ CEVWCNN[ CTGPʼnV VJG[ FQ JCXG C HGY EJCTCEVGTKUVKEU KP EQOOQP 6JG QWVNKPG QH VJG GUEWVEJGQP CPF RGTJCRU KVU HKGNF CPF VJG ENCY QH VJG NKQP HQT KPUVCPEG YGTG UVTWEM YKVJ VJG UCOG RWPEJ 6JG UCOG CRRNKGU VQ VJG NKQPʼnU JGCF CPF JKU JKPF SWCTVGTU 6JCV OGCPU VJCV C VQVCN QH VJTGG RWPEJGU YCU WUGF VQ OCPWHCE VWTG VJG FKG HQT VJKU EQKP +V OKIJV GXGP JCXG DGGP C UKPING RWPEJ YJKEJ YQWNF JCXG DGGP C ITGCV ICKP QH VKOG HQT VJG FKG UKPMGT CNVJQWIJ VJCV KU WPEGTVCKP DGECWUG C FKG EQPUKUVKPI QH C UKPING RWPEJ EQWNFPʼnV CVVCKP GPQWIJ FGRVJ YKVJ VJCPMU VQ XCP $GGM HQT VJKU CPCN[UKU

449


&GOK DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # .KQP N -#41. „ &+ „ )4# „ &: „ $) „ $4# „ < „ .+ JCPF 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+% „ #+# „ /'# „ &01 „ # X)* IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM XGT[ HKPG

)CNGTKG FGU /QPPCKGU )GP½XG 6GZV TGXGTUG $'0'&+% #0+/# /'# &1/+01 2TCKUG VJG .QTF O[ UQWN 2U C C D C D

/#4+# #NTGCF[ FWTKPI %JCTNGU VJG $QNFʼnU TGKIP VJG DGUV YC[ QH GPFKPI CNN YCTU QPEG CPF HQT CNN YCU IGPGTCNN[ EQPUKFGTGF VQ DG /CTKCʼnU OCTTKCIG VQ VJG FCWRJKP *QYGXGT .QWKU :++ YCU DGPV QP GPHQTEKPI JKU RNCPU D[ VJG UYQTF 6JCV TWNGF QWV JKU ECPFKFCE[ CPF UQ /CTKC TGVWTPGF VQ JGT HQTOGT HKCPE¾ /CZKOKNKCP QH #WUVTKC /CTEJ # JCNH [GCT CHVGT JGT HCVJGTʼnU FGCVJ UJG YGFFGF /CZKOKNKCP #WIWUV #V JGT HCVJGTʼn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

(NQTKP FG $QWTIQIPG $TCDCPV # 5CKPV #PFTGCU UVCPFKPI CPF JQNFKPI NCTIG ETQUU 5#0%685 #0&4'#5 4 5JKGNF QXGT NQPI ETQUU /#4+# &8%+55 $) „ $4 < „ .+ ECUVNG (D X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG /ÒP\CWMVKQP 'UUGP #WEVKQP PQ

&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO /#4+# „ &'+ „ ) „ &8%+55 „ $) „ $4 „ < „ .+ „ JCPF 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ 688 „ &0' # Q X)* C IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ X)* RTQXKFGU C OQNGVVG F GRGTQP OWNNGV KP VJG GZGTIWG CV VJG FCVG DWV PQPG UWEJ HGCVWTGU JGTG

450


&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO /#4+# „ &'+ „ ) „ &8%+55 „ $) „ $4 „ < „ .+ ECUVNG 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ „ 688 „ &0' # „ X)* D IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG $QWTIG[ 2CTKU X)* IKXGU C UOCNN JCPF CHVGT VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG *GTG KPUVGCF C UOCNN ECUVNG

&QWDNG DTKSWGV *QNNCPF # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO /#4+# W &8%+55# W $) W %1/+6 W *1 4 5JKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 W (#% W 22./ W 688 W &0' X)* D IT 8GT[ HKPG

-Ã’PMGT 1UPCDTÃ’EM #WEVKQP PQ

$TKSWGV $TCDCPV # .KQP UKVVKPI CPF JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ /#4+# „ &'+ „ ) „ &8%+55 „ $) „ $4#$ „ < „ .+ JCPF 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG $'0'&+% „ *'4'&+6#6+ „ 68' „ # „ X)* C IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ

$TKSWGV (NCPFGTU # .KQP UKVVKPI CPF JQNFKPI VJG UJKGNF QH $WTIWPF[ /#4+# „ &'+ „ ) „ &8%+55 „ $) „ $4#$ „ < „ .+ ECUVNG 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ RGNNGV KP VJG EGPVTG $'0'&+% „ *'4'&+6#6+ „ 68' „ # „ X)* D IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG $QWIJV &GEMGT EQNNGEVKQP (TQO 5EJWNOCP #OUVGTFCO #WEVKQP PQ X)* OGPVKQPU QPN[ C UOCNN JCPF CHVGT VJG VGZV QP VJG QDXGTUG

451


)TQU $TCDCPV # )TGCV / KP SWCVTGHQKN /#4+# ' &7%+55# ' $) ' $4#$ ' < ' .+ ECUVNG 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+% ' #+# ' /'# ' &01 ' # ' X)* C IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 4QOWPV 4QGTOQPF

)TQU (NCPFGTU # )TGCV / KP SWCVTGHQKN /#4+# &8%+55# $) %1 (. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+% #+# /'# &01 X)* C IT 5OCNN UVTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN

)TQU *QNNCPF # )TGCV / KP SWCVTGHQKN /#4+# &8%+55# $) %1 *1 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+% #+# /'# &01 X)* C IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP HKPG VQ XGT[ HKPG /ร P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN

&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # )QVJKE / รฐ /#4+# %1/+6 (.# 4 %TQUU รฐ +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ X)* C IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN

452

)TQU (NCPFGTU # #PIWNCT / รฐ /#4+# %1/+6 (.#0& 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU รฐ +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ X)* IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM CPF VTCEGU QH GPETWUVCVKQP XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 6GZV TGXGTUG +P VJG PCOG QH VJG .QTF #OGP 2U C


&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # )QVJKE / รฐ +0 โ 01/+05 โ &1/+0+ 4 %TQUU รฐ /#4+# โ %1/+6 โ (. # X)* D IT 5OCNN GFIG HCWNV XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

&QWDNG OKVGU FG $TCDCPV $TCDCPV # )QVJKE / /KPWUEWNG JCPF /#4+# ' &8%+55 ' $) ' $4 ' < ' .+ 4 %TQUU 241 ' &'1 ' &# ' 2#82'4+$85 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 5GRVGODGT PQ 6GZV TGXGTUG )KXG VQ VJG RQQT KP VJG PCOG QH )QF /CV

2*+.+25 FG 5%*10' +P (NCPFGTU KOOGFKCVGN[ CHVGT /CTKCล U FGCVJ QRRQUKVKQP TQUG CICKPUV /CZKOKNKCP (QWT [GCT QNF 2JKNKR YCU RTQENCKOGF EQWPV KP WPFGT C TGIGPE[ EQWPEKN HTQO YJKEJ /CZKOKNKCP YCU HNCITCPVN[ GZENWFGF +V YCU TCVJGT [GV CPQVJGT CVVGORV D[ )JGPV CV GNGXCVKQP VQ EKV[ UVCVG CHVGT +VCNKCP GZCORNG 6JG QVJGT FKUVTKEVU YGTG TKNGF D[ VJKU CTDKVTCT[ DGJCXKQWT 6JWU /CZKOKNKCP KP EQWNF OCTEJ KPVQ )JGPV KVU NGCFGT ,QJP %QRRGPJQNG JCF VQ HNGG CPF JG IQV JKU JCPFU QP NKVVNG 2JKNKR CICKP 1P VJG VJ (GDTWCT[ /CZKOKNKCP YCU GNGEVGF 4QOCP MKPI CPF QP #RTKN QH VJCV [GCT ETQYPGF KP #CEJGP 9JGP /CZKOKNKCP QPEG CICKP UVCTVGF DWKNFKPI WR C EQCNKVKQP CICKPUV (TCPEG VJG FKUVTKEVU JCF JCF GPQWIJ +P )JGPV ,QJP %QRRGPJQNG TGVWTPGF CPF YJGP /CZKOKNKCP ECTGNGUUN[ XGPVWTGF KPVQ VJG EKV[ JG YCU VCMGP RTKUQPGT CPF FGVCKPGF HTQO (GDTWCT[ VQ /C[ *KU HCVJGT 'ORGTQT (TGFGTKEM +++ JCF VQ HTGG JKO YJKEJ JQYGXGT FKFPล V DTGCM )JGPV TGUKU VCPEG %QPVTCT[ YKVJ VJG (TGPEJ MKPIล U CUUGPV QYP EQKP YCU UVTWEM KP 2JKNKRล U PCOG 6JKU YQWNF NCUV WPVKN +P VJG RGTKQF CTQWPF TGDGNNKQP DTGYGF RCTVKEWNCTN[ KP VJG UQWVJGTP 0GVJGTNCPFU CNVJQWIJ VJGTG YGTG CNUQ UQOG GRKUQFGU KP VJG PQTVJGTP 0GVJGTNCPFU 6JG *QQM CPF %QF 9CTU DNC\GF WR CPGY ,QPMGT (TCPUGP 9CT +V YQWNF VCMG WPVKN HQT VJKPIU VQ UGVVNG FQYP %QKPCIG TGHNGEVU VJGUG VTQWDNGF VKOGU XGT[ YGNN +P )WGNFGTU YCU FGHKPKVKXGN[ NQUV /CZKOKNKCP QH EQWTUG FKF CEV CU [QWPI 2JKNKRล U IWCTFKCP CICKP UVCTVKPI +P /CZKOKNKCP FGXKUGF C EQCV QH CTOU HQT 2JKNKR KPEQTRQTCVKPI VJG SWCTVGTU QH VJG CTEJFWEJ[ #WUVTKC VJG FWEJKGU $WTIWPF[ CPF $TCDCPV CPF VJG EQWPVKGU 6KTQN CPF (NCPFGTU 1P #WIWUV /CZKOKNKCP UWEEGGFGF JKU HCVJGT CU GORGTQT 5KPEG /CZKOKNKCPล U KOOG FKCVG CVVGPVKQP YCU PQY PGGFGF GNUGYJGTG 2JKNKR YCU FGGOGF QH CIG KP JG YCU [GCTU QNF CV VJG VKOG CPF ITCFWCNN[ DGECOG CEEGRVGF KP VJG UGXGTCN FKUVTKEVU HKPCNN[ KP (NCPFGTU KP 1P 1EVQDGT 2JKNKR YGFFGF 5RCPKUJ ,QCPPC QH %CUVKNG #HVGT VJG FGOKUG QH JKU OQVJGT KP NCY +UCDGNNC QH %CUVKNG JG DGECOG MKPI QH 5RCKP KP 6JKU PGEGUUKVCVGF NQPIGT UVC[U KP 5RCKP YJGTG JG JQYGXGT UQQP FKGF QP 5GRVGODGT 453


2JKNKRʼnU OKPVKPI KU OCTMGF D[ GOKUUKQPU 6JG UV GOKUUKQP TCP HTQO VQ UJQTVN[ KPVGTTWRVGF KP PF GOKUUKQP 1PN[ VJG PCOG QH 2JKNKR CRRGCTU QP VJG EQKPU 6JG TF GOKUUKQP YCU CTTCPIGF HQT VJG QEECUKQP QH /CZKOKNKCPʼnU EQTQPCVKQP

4QOCP MKPI 1P VJG NCTIG IQNF TGCN JKU PCOG CRRGCTU KP HWNN DWV QP VJG NCVGT EQKPU KP VJKU GOKUUKQP JG KU OGTGN[ KPFKECVGF D[ CP / C RQTVTCKV QT C OQPQITCO 2JKNKRʼnU PCOG KU QH OKPQT KORQTVCPEG 6JG VJ GOKUUKQP YCU C YCT GOKUUKQP #NN EQKPU TGCF 2GCEG KU C TGHQTOCVKQP QH YCT VYQ V[RGU XCT[ 2GCEG TGUVQTG YJCV YCU NQUV VJTQWIJ YCT PQ CPF 2GCEG KU C TGHQTOCVKQP CHVGT YCT PQ +VU UVCTV EQKPEKFGF YKVJ VJCV QH VJG KPFGRGPFGPV GOKUUKQP QH )JGPV YJKEJ KPEKFGPVCNN[ YQWNF NCUV WPVKN +P VJG VJ CPF VJG VJ GOKUUKQPU VJG PCOG QH /CZKOKNKCP CRRGCTGF PQY YKVJ VJG VKVNG RCVGT JQYGXGT HCVJGT QH 2JKNKR! 6JG VJ GOKUUKQP CPF VJG VJ GOKUUKQP YGTG VJG GOKUUKQPU QH 2JKNKRʼnU OCVWTKV[ 0CVWTCNN[ /CZKOKNKCPʼnU PCOG PQ NQPIGT HGCVWTGU UV GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV UV QH ,WN[ TF QH 0QXGODGT

#U JKU HCVJGT /CZKOKNKCP YCU CTEJFWMG QH #WUVTKC 2JKNKR YCU CNUQ GPVKVNGF VQ VJKU VGTTKVQT[ 1P JKU EQKPU VJG VKVNG #TEJKFWE #WUVTKC CRRGCTU 6JG EQCV QH CTOU YCU CNVGTGF VQQ #WUVTKC CPF 6KTQN GPVGTGF HQT TGCUQPU QH RTCEVKECNKV[ VJKU KU CNYC[U TGHGTTGF VQ CU VJG EQCV QH CTOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ VJQWIJ VJGTG CTG UQOG XCTKCVKQPU

&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO /10'6# „ &8% „ #856 „ .16 „ $4#$ „ .+ „ <% 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ „ 688 „ &0' „ #Q „ X)* E IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

&QWDNG DTKSWGV $TCDCPV # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO /10 Q #4 Q &8 Q #8564+' Q $4#$#0%+' 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ Q 688 „ &0' „ # „ X)* D IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV #WIWUV PQ 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ 6KTQN CPF .KODWTI NKQP YKVJ FQWDNGF VCKN X)* RTQXKFGU CP QDXGTUG VGZV CU QP ++C D C TGXGTUG VGZV CU QP ++D E

454


&QWDNG DTKSWGV )GNFGTNCPF # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO VJTGG TQUGU DGNQY ETQUU QH )WGNFGT /10'6# #4%*+&8%8 #8' $) )'.4 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU ETQUU QH )WGNFGT 08/ #4)'6'85 )'.' +0 01+' :2+ X)* IT 0KEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

Elsen - $TWUUGN, Auction 74 (2003), no. 1471. 5VTWEM KP <CNVDQOOGN DGVYGGP CPF EQKP YCU GZENWUKXGN[ UVTWEM KP <CNVDQOOGN +P VJG GZGTIWG VJTGG TQUGU +P VJG [GCTU VJG OQPG[GT QH )WGNFGTU YCU $GTPCTF 2TQ[U ! YJQ YQTMGF KP #TPJGO 0KLOGIGP CPF <CNVDQOOGN 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV 6KTQN CPF )WGNFGTU

&QWDNG DTKSWGV *QNNCPF # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO ETQUU DGNQY /1 „ #4%*+&8%8 „ #856 „ $) „ %1 „ *1. 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU 5#.88 „ (#% „ 22./ „ 688 „ &0' „ X)* IT 4 /CIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ +P VJG GZGTIWG C TQUG QH UQTVU VJCV X)* FGVGTOKPGU C TQUCEG /QPG[GT HTQO VQ OQPG[GTʼnU UKIP TQUG YCU #PVJQPKWU FG .QWEMGTG 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV 6KTQN CPF *QNNCPF

)TQU $TCDCPV # )TGCV / KP SWCVTGHQKN /10 Q #4 Q &8 Q #8564+' Q $4#$#0%+' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU $'0'&+% Q #+# Q /'# Q &01 Q # Q X)* IT 44 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

)TQU )GNFGTNCPF # )TGCV / KP SWCVTGHQKN ETQUU QH )WGNFGT /10 #4%*+&8% #8' $) )' 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU $'0'&+% #+# /'# &1/+0 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ (TQO 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

455


)TQU *QNNCPF # #PIWNCT / HKTG UVGGN /1 Q #4&8% Q #856 Q $) Q %1 Q *1. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU HKTG UVGGN +0 Q 01/+0' Q &1/+0+ Q #/'0 X)* C IT 4 (KPG VQ XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ

)TQU *QNNCPF # 4QOCP / ð /1 #4 &8% #856 $ %1 *1 4 %TQUU ð +0 01/+0' &1/+0+ # X)* D IT 4 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ X)* IKXGU CP KPVGTRWPEVKQP QH C RGNNGV DWV VJKU KU ENGCTN[ C FQWDNG RGNNGV

&QWDNG OKVG (NCPFGTU # .KQP TCORCPV N /1 Ÿ #4%*+&8 Ÿ #856 Ÿ $) Ÿ %1 Ÿ ( 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG +0 Ÿ 01/+0' Ÿ &1/+0+ Ÿ # X)* IT 4 +P VJKU EQPFKVKQP XGT[ HKPG

%TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG 2CTKU #WEVKQP PQ

PF GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH #WIWUV +P URTKPI QH /CZKOKNKCP ENQUGF CNN OKPVU CPF QRGPGF C PGY QPG KP /GEJGNGP *GPEG VJG EQKPU UVTWEM VJGTG YGTG ECNNGF /GEJGNCCTU 6JG PF GOKUUKQP QPN[ NCUVGF C HGY OQPVJU

&QWDNG RCVCTF $TCDCPV # 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ /1 „ #4%*+&8%8 „ #856 „ $) „ $4 „ &05 „ /. 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKQP KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 „ 01/'0 „ &1/+0+ „ $'0'&+%68/ X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ PGY #WUVTKC CPF .KODWTI NKQP YKVJ FQWDNGF VCKN

456


&QWDNG RCVCTF (NCPFGTU # 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ /1 X #4%*+&8%8 X #856 X $) X %1 X (.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 X 01/'0 X &0+ X $'0'&+%68/ X X)* IT 2CVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ 5JKGNF EH PQ YKVJ (NCPFGTU

TF GOKUUKQP VJ #RTKN +P /CZKOKNKCP YCU ETQYPGF 4QOCP MKPI 6JG EQKPU QH VJG TF GOKUUKQP TGHGT VQ VJKU QEECUKQP 6JG PCOG QH /CZKOKNKCP HGCVWTGU QP VJG EQKPU CU YGNN CU VJG QPG JGCFGF KORGTKCN GCING QPG JGCF HQT VJG 4QOCP MKPI CPF VYQ HQT VJG 'ORGTQT 6YQ EQKPU KP RCTVKEWNCT YGTG VQ CFF URNGPFQT VQ JKU EQTQPCVKQP CU 4QOCP MKPI VJG NCTIG IQNF TGCN CPF VJG UKNXGT TGCN

4¾CN F CTIGPV $TCDCPV # -KPI T YKVJ UYQTF CPF QTD %8561&+#6 Q % #614 Q 1+ / Q *8+ .' Q 59 Q 59 Q 4 /QPQITCO QH /CZKOKNKCP CPF 2JKNKRR HKTG UVGGN &'6 Q 6+$+ +64+5 Q 8 HKTG UVGGN 686 Q < Q +%'. ).14+# X)* IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC

'NUGP $TWUUGN 6GZVU # %8561&+#6 %4'#614 1/0+8/ *8/+.'/ 5'488/ 5'488/ 6JG ETGCVQT QH CNN UCXG JKU JWO DNG UGTXCPV 4 &'6 6+$+ +06'44+5 8+4686'/ '6 +0 %'.+5 ).14+#/ *G IKXGU [QW XKTVWG QP VJG GCTVJ CPF INQT[ KP VJG JGCXGPU %QPVTCT[ VQ VJG IQNF TGCN VJKU EQKP HGCVWTGU PGKVJGT /CZKOKNKCPʼnU PCOG PQT 2JKNKRʼnU /CZKOKNKCP KU KPFKECVGF YKVJ C TQ[CN RQTVTCKV CPF DQVJ VJGKT OQPQITCOU HGCVWTG 6JKU EQKP EQOGU KOOGFKCVGN[ CHVGT VJG IQNF TGCN DQVJ GZRTGUU /CZKOKNKCPʼnU UKIPKHKECPEG 6JG $WTIWPFKCP PQDNG FKFPʼnV CRRGCT WPVKN NCVGT

457


0QDNG FG $QWTIQIPG *QNNCPF # %TQYPGF MKPI KP UJKR YKVJ UYQTF CPF QTD QP VJG UJKR DGVYGGP VYQ HKTG UVGGNU VJG OQPQITCO QH /CZKOKNKCP CPF 2JKNKRR / & ) 41 4': '6 2*5 #4%*+&8%'5 #8 $) %1 *1 4 5JKGNF QH /CZKOKNKCP QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ ETQYPU CPF GCINGU KP VJG CPINGU ñ /1 #84+# 41 4()+5 (6 2*+ #4%*+& #8 $) %1 *1. (D X)* IT 44 5OCNN UETCVEJGU QP VJG QDXGTUG XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 'Z 8G[PCW EQNNGEVKQP 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 'Z 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 6JG / CV VJG DGIKPPKPI QH VJG QDXGTUG VGZV KU PQV VJG CDDTGXKCVKQP QH /QPGVC DWV QH /CZKOKNKCP 6JG OQPQITCO QP VJG UJKRʼnU UKFG KU VJG UCOG CU KU HQWPF QP VJG UKNXGT TGCN PQ %QCV QH CTOU NGHV QPG JGCFGF KORGTKCN GCING PQV 6KTQN TKIJV WRRGT #WUVTKC NQYGT $WTIWPF[ 6JG TGXGTUG VGZV EQPVCKPU UGXGTCN GTTQTU 6JG + KP #84+# UJQWNF DG CP ' KP VJG UCOG YQTF VJG 8 YCU CP / VJCV YCU EJCPIGF VQ C 8 VJG ( KP 4()+5 CU YGNN CU VJG QPG KP (6 UJQWNF DG CP ' 6JG GFIG QH VJG UJKR VJCV YQWNF FKURNC[ VJG NGQRCTFU CPF VJG NKU QP C TGIWNCT PQDNG JGTG UJQYU VJG OQPQITCO QH /CZKOKNKCP CPF 2JKNKR GZCEVN[ CU VJG TGXGTUG QH VJG UKNXGT TGCN HNCPMGF D[ VYQ ETQUUGF VQTEJGU CPF C HKTG UVGGN 6YQ FKHHGTGPV VGZVU OC[ DG FKUVKPIWKUJGF FKUVTKDWVGF COQPI UGXGTCN FKGU V[RG # XF%J # / & ) 41 4': '6 2*5 #4%*+&8%'5 #8 $ %1 *1 4 /1 #84'# 41 4')+5 '6 2*+ #4%*+& #8 $) %1 *1. V[RG $ XF%J # / & ) 41 4': '6 2*5 #4%*+&8%'5 #8 $) %1 *1 4 /1 #84'# 41 4')+5 '6 2*+ #4%*+& #8 $) %1 *1. 6JKU KU C V[RG $ EQKP URGEKOGPU CTG VTCEGCDNG -2- V[RG # KPX 0Q -2- V[RG $ KPX 0Q &G 0GFGTNCPFUEJG $CPM

V[RG # HTQO CWEVKQP *GNDKPI ņ /Ò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

458


&QWDNG ITKHHQP $TCDCPV # 6YQ ITKHHQPU JQNFKPI HKTG UVGGN CPF HNKPVUVQPG ñ / 1 Q # 4)6 Q 41 Q 4) Q < Q 2*+ Q #4&8 Q #8 Q $) Q $ 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU Ö 5#.88 Q (#% Q &0' Q 22./ Q 688 Q X)* E IT 44 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN /CZKOKNKCP WUGF VJG ITKHHKP CU C RGTUQPCN GODNGO 6JG NGIGPFCT[ ETGCVWTG KU OCFG WR QH VJG JKPF SWCTVGTU CPF NGIU QH C NKQP VJG VQTUQ QH CP GCING CPF VJG GCTU QH C JQTUG 6JKU GODNGO KU QHVGP CEEQORCPKGF D[ /CZKOKNKCPʼnU UNQICP *CNV /CUU YJKEJ KU CNUQ QDUGTXGF QP VJG IQNF TGCN 6GPG /GPUXTCO 6JG FQWDNG CPF UKPING ITKHHQPU CNN UWRRQTV C UKOKNCT UCOG EQCV QH CTOU CU KU FKURNC[GF QP VJG $WTIWPFKCP PQDNG /CZKOKNKCPʼnU PCOG KU PQV QP VJG FQWDNG ITKHHKP 2JKNKRʼnU KU

&QWDNG ITKHHQP *QNNCPF # 6YQ ITKHHQPU JQNFKPI HKTG UVGGN CPF HNKPVUVQPG ñ /1 #4)'6'#

41 4') < 2*+ #4%*+& # $ %1 * 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU ñ 5#.88 (#% &1/+0' 2128.8/ 688 X)* C IT 44 # NKVVNG FQWDNG UVTWEM CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ OCIPKHKEGPV RCVKPC

8GTUEJQQT 5VTKLGP 6JG VGZVU CTG XGT[ EQORNGVG JGTG

459


)TKHHQP $TCDCPV # )TKHHQP YKVJ HKTG UVGGN CPF HNKPVUVQPG KP VJG ENCYU ñ &'0#4+5 5+/2.': Q 01/+0#685 Q )4+(10 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT ETQUU &'8/ Q 2.85 Q #/# 38#/ Q #4)'068/ X)* IT 4 'PF QH VJG HNCP PKEG RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 6GZV TGXGTUG .QXG )QF OQTG VJCP VJG UKNXGT OQPG[ 6JG VGZV QH PQ CPF KU PQV VJG UCOG 6JG VGZV QH KU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG CU $TCDCPV 6JG VGZV QH KU C OKZVWTG QH QDXGTUG (NCPFGTU CPF TGXGTUG $TCDCPV 5VTWEM KP 6JG UKPING ITKHHKP DGCTU PGKVJGT /CZKOKNKCPʼnU PCOG PQT 2JKNKRʼnU

)TKHHQP $TCDCPV # )TKHHQP YKVJ HKTG UVGGN CPF HNKPVUVQPG KP VJG ENCYU ñ &'0#4+ 5+/2.': Q 01+#6 )4+(10 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QP ETQUU &'8 Q 2.85 Q #/# 38# Q #4)'068 X)* IT 6TCEGU QH EQTTQUKQP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 6JG VGZV QH PQ CPF KU PQV VJG UCOG 6JG VGZV QH KU GZCEVN[ VJG UCOG CU 6JG VGZV QH KU C OKZVWTG QH QDXGTUG (NCPFGTU CPF TGXGTUG $TCDCPV 5VTWEM KP

VJ GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH 1EVQDGT CPF VJ QH &GEGODGT

&GOK PQDNG $TCDCPV # -KPI KP UJKR YKVJ UYQTF QTD CPF UJKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ Ö /1 41 4' Z < Z 2* + #4&8% Z #85 $ ) Z $4# < .+/ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ QPG ETQYP KP GCEJ CPING CPF / KP VJG EGPVTG /GEJGNGP Ö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

460


&QWDNG RCVCTF )GNFGTNCPF # 5JKGNF QH )WGNFGTU ,Ã’NKEJ ñ /10 &8%+5 )'.4+' '6 %1/+6 <76 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ $ KP VJG EGPVTG ñ 4'(14/#%+1 )8'44' 2#: '56

X)* IT 4 'PF QH VJG HNCP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ 5VTWEM KP <CNVDQOOGN #U VJKU EQKP UJQYU VJG UCOG VGZV CU VJG JCNH PQDNG PQ KV KU NKUVGF JGTG DGHQTG VJG EQKPU VJG VGZVU QH YJKEJ TGHGT VQ VJG GPF QH VJG YCT OQTG FKTGEVN[

3WCFTWRNG RCVCTF $TCDCPV # 5JKGNFU QH $TCDCPV CPF .KODWTI WPFGT JGNOGVU Ö /10'6# &8%+5 $4#$#%+' < .+/ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ UJKGNF QH /GEJGNGP KP VJG EGPVTG #/+55# $'..1 2#: 4'56#84'6 X)* IT 44 (NCP FGHGEV XGT[ HKPG /ÒP\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 6GZV QP TGXGTUG OGCPU 2GCEG TGUVQTG YJCV YCU NQUV VJTQWIJ YCT

&GOK PQDNG *QNNCPF # -KPI KP UJKR YKVJ UJKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ Ö /1 41 4' Z < Z 2*+ #4&8% Z #85 $) Z $4 Z %1 *1 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG Ö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

461


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

2CVCTF UV GOKUUKQP # 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT NQPI ETQUU YKVJ ) # 0 & KP VJG CPINGU 2*5 & ) & $ %1 (.#0&4+' 4 .KQP TCORCPV N '38# .+$'46#5 &'1 )4#6# X)* C IT 4 #NOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO %TGFKV FG NC $QWTUG #WEVKQP PQ 6GZV TGXGTUG # VTWVJHWN RGCEG RNGCUGU )QF 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY CPF (NCPFGTU 6JG NKU CTG GPEKTENGF D[ UVTKCG

&QWDNG DTKSWGV PF GOKUUKQP # 6YQ .KQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO CPF )#0&# KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: $ %1/'5 (.#0&4 4 5JKGNF QH (NCPFGTU QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU (+#6 2#: +0 8+4686' 68# '6 *#$ X)* C IT 44 +P VJKU EQPFKVKQP GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN 6GZV TGXGTUG (+#6 2#: +0 8'4676' 68# '6 *#$80&#06+# 2GCEG DG YKVJKP VJ[ YCNNU CPF CDWPFCPEG

2U

&QWDNG DTKSWGV PF GOKUUKQP # 6YQ .KQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO CPF )#0&# KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF 2*5 , &'+ , )4# , &8: , $ , %1/'5 , (.# 4 5JKGNF QH (NCPFGTU QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU (+#6 , 2#: , +0 , 8+4686' , 68# , '6 , * X)* D IT 4 'URGEKCNN[ KP VJKU EQPFKVKQP XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG &GNOQPVG $TWUUGN

462


$TKSWGV PF GOKUUKQP # .KQP TCORCPV YKVJ Z Z Z KP VJG DQVVQO HKGNF 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: %1 (.# 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG (+#6 2#: +0 8+4686' 68# X)* C IT 4 +P VJKU EQPFKVKQP XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

&QWDNG OKVG PF GOKUUKQP # 5JKGNF QH (NCPFGTU 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: $ %1 (. 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG +0 &1/+01 %10(+&1 X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG 9#) &QTVOWPF #WEVKQP PQ .GIGPF TGXGTUG +P VJG .QTF + VCMG TGHWIG 2U C

&QWDNG OKVG WPEGTVCKP GOKUUKQP # .KQP TCORCPV 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: $ % (. 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG +0 &1/+01 %10(+&1 X)* C IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

&QWDNG OKVG WPEGTVCKP GOKUUKQP # .KQP TCORCPV N 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: %1 (. 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG +0 &1/+01 %10(+&1 X)* C IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

&QWDNG OKVG WPEGTVCKP GOKUUKQP # .KQP TCORCPV 2*5 &'+ )4# &8: %1 (. 4 %TQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG +0 &1/+01 %10(+&1 X)* C IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN #WEVKQP PQ

463


VJ GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH &GEGODGT

3WCFTWRNG RCVCTF $TCDCPV # #TOQWTGF FWMG YKVJ UYQTF JQNFKPI UJKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ YKVJ JKU N JCPF Q 2*+ „ #4%*+&7%+5 „ #8564+' „ $84)&+' „ $4#$# „ JCPF Q 4 %TQYPGF UJKGNF YKVJ KORGTKCN GCING QP HNQTKCVGF ETQUU /#:+/ .+# „ 4': Q Q 41/#0 Q 2#6 „ X)* IT 'ZVTGOGN[ TCTG C NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG CNOQUV GZVTGOGN[ HKPG URGEKOGP YKVJ PKEG RCVKPC 5RKPM <ÒTKEJ #WEVKQP PQ 'Z FG .KIPG EQNNGEVKQP 5QVJGD[ .QPFQP #WEVKQP PQ .GIGPF TGXGTUG 2#6 2#6'4 (CVJGT QH 2JKNKRU FG 5EJQPG 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY $WTIWPF[ $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ .KODWTI #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY CPF $TCDCPV 6KTQN 6JG NKU CTG GPEKTENGF D[ UVTKCG

)TQU $TCDCPV # #TOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF ñ 2*+ Q #4%*+&8% Q #8564+' Q $84) Q $ 4#$ Q JCPF 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ ETQYPU KP VJG CPINGU CPF # KP VJG EGPVTG Ö /#:+/+.+#0 Q 4': Q 41/#01 Q 2#6 Q X)* IT #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ # #PVYGTRGP

)TQU $TCDCPV # #TOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP VJG HKGNF ñ 2*+ Q #4%*+&8% Q #8564+ Q $) Q $4 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ # KP VJG EGPVTG ñ /#:+/+.+#0 Q 4': Q 41/#0 Q 2#6 X)* D IT 44 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

)TQU *QNNCPF # #TOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP VJG HKGNF 2*+ Q #4%*&8 Q #856 Q $84 Q %1 Q *1 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG /#:+/+.+#0 Q 4': Q 41/# Q 2# X)* IT 4 # NKVVNG QHH EGPVTG CNOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ

464


)TQU *QNNCPF # #TOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP VJG HKGNF ñ 2*+ Q #4%*+&8 Q #856 Q $84 Q %1 Q *1 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CPINGU /# :+. +# Q 4': Q 41/# Q 2# X)* IT 44 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 1EVQDGT PQ (QWPF KP 4QVVGTFCO

)TQU *QNNCPF # #TOU QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP VJG HKGNF ñ 2*+ #4&8 #856 $84 %1 *1 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ NKQPU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CPINGU ñ /#:+.+#0 Q 4': Q 41/# Q 2# X)* IT 44 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

-PGKPUDGTI #OUVGNXGGP

&GPKGT FG *QNNCPFG *QNNCPF # %TQYPGF UJKGNF YKVJ GCING /#:+/+.+#0 Q 4' 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QP NQPI ETQUU 2*+ #4& #85 % Q *1 X)* IT 44 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV PQ 5JKGNF UV CPF TF HKGNF #WUVTKC PF CPF VJ HKGNF $WTIWPF[ CPF VJ *QNNCPF X)* OGPVKQPU /#:+/+.+#0 Q 41 Q 4': CU NGIGPF QP VJG QDXGTUG 6JG 41 KU OKUUKPI JGTG

VJ GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ /CTEJ

&QWDNG DTKSWGV )GNFGTNCPF # 6YQ NKQPU UKVVKPI CPF HCEKPI GCEJQVJGT YKVJ HKTG UVGGN DGVYGGP VJGO ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU 2*5 #4%*+&8: #8564+' $74) < )'. UJKGNF QH /GEJGNGP KP GZGTIWG 4 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ QXGT HNQTKCVGF ETQUU ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU 5#.88 (#% 2128.8/ 688/ &0' X)* IT 44 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP XF%J 5VTWEM CV /GEJGNGP 'NWEKFCVKQP XF%J R +P OQTG VJCP JCNH C EGPVWT[ CHVGT OCPWHCEVWTG VJKU EQKP YCU YQTVJ HQWT ITQCV CPF QPG QQTV UVWKXGT

465


$TKSWGV (NCPFGTU # .KQP JQNFKPI UJKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ 2*5 ã #4%*+& ã #856 ã $84) ã %1 ã (.#0&4 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG /#:+/ ã 4': ã 41/#0148/ ã 2#6'4 ã X)* C IT (NCP FGHGEV CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

FG )GWU 'KPFJQXGP #WEVKQP PQ (TQO HKPF 1KTUEJQV 6JKU JQCTF QH IQNF DWV OCKPN[ UKNXGT OGFKGXCN EQKPU GOGTIGF CTQWPF FWTKPI VJG TGEQP UVTWEVKQP QH CP QNF RWDJQWUG KP VJG EGPVTG QH 1KTUEJQV

)TQU )GNFGTNCPF # 5JKGNF QH #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ KP HKGNF ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU 2*5 #4%*+&8: #856 $74) < ) 4 .QPI ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ TKPIU NKU CPF NKQP KP VJG CPINGU $'0'&+% #+# /'# &1/+01 X)* IT 44 #NOQUV XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP 5VTWEM KP /GEJGNGP 8F%J QP R RTQXKFGU VYQ NKU QP VJG TGXGTUG KPUVGCF QH QPG NKU CPF QPG NKQP CU JGTG

VJ GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ /C[ (TQO VJKU OQOGPV QP 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG UVCTVGF OKPVKPI KP JKU QYP PCOG /CZKOKNKCPʼnU PCOG XCPKUJGF

(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG $TCDCPV # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT 5 2*' +06'4% & 241 01$+5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ UJKGNF QH (NCPFGTU HQWT UJKGNFU CTQWPF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY $TCDCPV $WTIWPF[ QNF ñ 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%*+& #856 &8: $) $ (D X)* IT 4 8GT[ HKPG /Ã’P\GP WPF /GFCKNNGP $CUGN 5V 2JKNKRRWU FKUEKRNG YCU VJG PCOG UCKPV QH 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG 2JKNKRRWU IWKNFGTU YGTG KPVTQFWEGF KP VQ TGRNCEG VJG #PFTGYʼnU IWKNFGTU UGG PQ CPF UVTWEM WPVKN KP VYQ V[RGU PQ CPF NCVGT PQ GV UGSS 6GZV QDXGTUG 5CPEVG 2JKNKRRG KPVGTEGFG RTQ PQDKU *QN[ 2JKNKR DG QWT KPVGTEGUUQT 6JG NKU CTG PQ NQPIGT KPFKECVGF (TCPEG JGPEG VJG GFIG YCU PQV UVTKCVGF CP[OQTG 5VTWEM DGVYGGP 9KVJQWV JCPF

466


6QKUQP F CTIGPV $TCDCPV # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%*+& #856' &8: $) $4# 4 6JG )QNFGP (NGGEG WPFGT VYQ HKTG UVGGNU Þ +0+%+8/ 5#2+'0%+'

6+/14 &1/+0+ #001 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN 5JKGNF #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ PGY $WTIWPF[ QNF $TCDCPV CPF $TCDCPV CTOU QH 2JKNKRU 6GZV TGXGTUG (GCT QH VJG .QTF KU VJG DGIKPPKPI QH YKUFQO 2U C 5RT CPF

6QKUQP F CTIGPV $TCDCPV # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%*+& #8564+' &8: $ $ 4 6JG )QNFGP (NGGEG WPFGT VYQ HKTG UVGGNU Þ +0+%+8/ 5#2+'0%' 6+/14 &1/+0+ #01 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

&QWDNG RCVCTF (NCPFGTU # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU KP OWNVKNQDG X 2*5 X #4%*+& X #856 X &8: X $) X %1 X ( 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG Þ 1/0+5 X 52+4+675 X .#8&'6 X &1/+08 X X)* IT 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ 6GZV TGXGTUG .GV GXGT[VJKPI VJCV JCVJ DTGCVJ RTCKUG VJG .QTF 2U

2CVCTF *QNNCPF # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%+& #856 $) %1 *1. 4 1TPCOGPVGF ETQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 01/'0 &1/+0+ $'0'6 X)* IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 0QXGODGT PQ

467


VJ GOKUUKQP %QKPCIG #EV VJ QH (GDTWCT[

(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG (NCPFGTU # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT QXGT UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 5 2*' ลธ +06 %'&' ลธ ลธ 241 ลธ 01$+5 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ VYQ NKU CPF VYQ ETQYPU KP VJG CPINGU CPF NKU KP VJG EGPVTG รฐ 2*5 ลธ &'+ ลธ )4# ลธ #4%*+& ลธ #856 ลธ &8 ลธ $) ลธ %1 ลธ ( (D X)* C IT 8GT[ HKPG %QKP +PXGUVOGPV .KUUG #WEVKQP PQ 'Z (KPF (GGTYGTF )TQPKPIGP 6JG 5 CV VJG GPF QH VJG QDXGTUG VGZV KU PQV OGPVKQPGF KP X)*

(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG *QNNCPF # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT QXGT UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 5 2*' รฐ +06'4%'&' รฐ รฐ 241 รฐ 01$+5 รฐ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 2*5 รฐ &'+ รฐ )4# รฐ #4%+& รฐ #85 รฐ &8: รฐ $) รฐ %1 รฐ *1. (D X)* C IT 5OCNN HNCP ETCEM YGNN UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG VQ GZVTGOGN[ HKPG (TCPEGUEJK $TWUUGN X)* C ETQUUG NQPIWG DWV VJG NGIGPF FQGUPล V OCVEJ

(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG *QNNCPF # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT QXGT UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 5' รฐ 2*' รฐ +06'4%'&' รฐ 241 รฐ 01$+ รฐ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 2* 5 รฐ &'+ รฐ )4# รฐ #4%+& รฐ #85 รฐ &8: รฐ $) รฐ %1 รฐ *1. (D X)* D IT %NGCT CPF UJCTR UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG X)* D ETQUUG EQWTVG 'Z &GEMGT EQNNGEVKQP

468


(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG $TCDCPV # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT QXGT UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 5 โ 2*' โ +06%'& โ โ 241 โ 01$+5 โ JCPF 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKQP KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ ETQYPU CPF VYQ NKU KP VJG CPINGU ETQUU QH )WGNFGTU 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%*+& #85 &8: $) $ < (D X)* D IT 4 5OCNN UETCVEJGU CV VJG GFIG XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ X)* RTQXKFGU C TGXGTUG VGZV GPFKPI YKVJ $< JGTG $ < 6JG VGZV QP VJG TGXGTUG DGIKPU YKVJ C )WGNFGTU UOCNN ETQUU

X)* FGVGTOKPGU ETQKZ

(NQTKP 5V 2JKNKRRG 0COWT # 5CKPV 2JKNKRRWU UVCPFKPI YKVJ DQQM CPF ETQUKGT QXGT UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 5#0%6' 2*' +0 6%& 241 01$ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ HKTG UVGGN KP VJG EGPVTG VYQ ETQYPU CPF VYQ HKTG UVGGNU KP VJG CPINGU HKTG UVGGN 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%*+&8 #85 &8: $ % 0 (D X)* D IT 44 5OCNN HNCP XGT[ HKPG

'NUGP $TWUUGN

6QKUQP F CTIGPV $TCDCPV # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU YKVJ VJG )QNFGP (NGGEG 2*5 Z &'+ Z )4# Z #4%*+ Z Z #856 Z &8: Z $84) Z $ Z < 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ UVCT KP VJG EGPVTG /1 Z (#%6 Z Z 64#+'%6 Z Z +0 Z 841'0*1( Z X)* C IT # NKVVNG YGCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG

*GP\GP #OGTQPIGP &GEGODGT PQ 5VTWEM KP /CCUVTKEJV

6QKUQP F CTIGPV *QNNCPF # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU YKVJ VJG )QNFGP (NGGEG 2*5 รฐ &'+ รฐ )4# รฐ #4%+& รฐ #85 รฐ $) รฐ % รฐ *1 รฐ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG +0+%+8/ 5#2+'%+' รฐ 6+/14 &0+ รฐ X)* IT 4 9GCMN[ UVTWEM XGT[ HKPG X 5VQEMWO &GP *CCI #WEVKQP PQ 'Z *WNUJQH 2QNN EQNNGEVKQP

469


&QWDNG RCVCTF (NCPFGTU # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU KP OWNVKNQDG 2*5 X &'+ X )4# X #4%*+& X #856 X &8: X $) X %1 X ( 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ NKU KP VJG EGPVTG ร 1/0+5 X 52+4+65 X .#8&'6 X &1/+08/ X X)* C IT 5OCNN UETCVEJGU XGT[ HKPG

)TGPUYKUUGNMCPVQTGP

&QWDNG RCVCTF *QNNCPF # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU KP OWNVKNQDG รฐ 2*5 &'+ )4# #4%+& #85 &8: $ % * รฐ 4 (NQTKCVGF ETQUU YKVJ TQUG KP VJG EGPVTG 1/00+5 52+4+685 .#8&'6 &0/ #001 X)* C IT 8GT[ HKPG *GP\GP #OGTQPIGP (TQO NKUV 1EVQDGT PQ

2CVCTF 0COWT # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 2JKNKRU 2*5 โ &'+ โ )4# โ #4%*+&8 โ #856 โ &8: โ $74 โ %1 โ 0# 4 %TQUU KP SWCVTGHQKN YKVJ HKTG UVGGN KP VJG EGPVTG 5+6 โ 01/'0 โ &0+ โ $'0'&+%68 โ X)* IT 9GCMN[ UVTWEM QVJGTYKUG GZVTGOGN[ HKPG

*WK\KPIC &GNHV

5RCPKUJ EQKP UVTWEM KP VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU

4GCN F 'URCIPG $TCDCPV # %TQYPGF UJKGNF QH 5RCKP #WUVTKC $WTIWPF[ 2*5 '6 +1*#0# &'+ )4# 4': '6 4')+0 4 6YQ ETQUUGF UVCHHU QXGT HKTG UVGGN YKVJ VJG )QNFGP (NGGEG CTQWPF VJG UJKGNFU QH %CUVKNNKC .GQP CPF )TCPCFC JCPF %#6'..' .')+10+5 < #4%*+&8% #8564+' < X)* IT 44 &CTM RCVKPC XGT[ HKPG 'NUGP $TWUUGN (TQO NKUV PQ +P 2JKNKR VJG *CPFUQOG UKPEG -KPI QH %CUVKNG JCF VJGUG EQKPU UVTWEM VQ HKPCPEG JKU LQWTPG[ VQ 5RCKP

470


Bibliography ABH

=

Ahlström, B./Brekke, B.H./Hemmingsson, B.: Norges Mynter. The Coinage of Norway. Stockholm 1976. Boudeau, E.: Monnaies Françaises Provinciales (I). Maastricht 1970. Prou, M./Bougenot, E.: Catalogue des Deniers Mérovingiens de la Trouvaille de Bais. Paris 1907. Belfort, A. de: Description Générale des Monnaies Mérovingiennes par ordre alphabétique des ateliers, 5 Bände. Paris 1892-1895. Bernareggi, E.: Moneta Langobardorum. Lugano 1989. Mailand 1983. Biaggi, E.: Monete e zecche medievali Italiane. Turin 1992. Chalon, R.: Recherches sur Les Monnaies des Comtes de Hainaut. Brüssel 1848. -: Recherches sur les monnaies des comtes de Namur, Brüssel 1860. Kluge, B.: Conspectus Nummorum Germaniae Medii Aevi (CNG), in: Geldgeschichtliche Nachrichten 193-197 (1999-2000). Crusafont i Sabater, M.: El sistema monetario visigodo: Cobro y oro. Barcelona 1994. Duplessy, J.: Les Monnaies Françaises Royales, de Hugues Capet à Louis XVI (987-1793), Tome I. Paris 1999. -: Les Monnaies Françaises Féodales, Tome I. Paris 2004. Dannenberg, H.: Die deutschen Münzen der sächsischen und fränkischen Kaiserzeit, 4 Bände, Berlin 1874 – 1905. Chestret, H.J. de: Numismatique de la Principauté de Liége et de ses dépendances (Bouillon, Looz) depuis leur annexion. Brüssel 1890.

B Bais Belfort

= = =

Bern Biaggi Ch

= = =

CNG

=

Crusafont D

= =

Dann

=

deCh

=

Delm

= Delmonte, A.: Le Bénélux d’or. Amsterdam 1964.

DdP

=

DOC

=

dM

=

dW

=

E&L Elias EvG

= = =

Fb

=

FD

=

FdS

=

G

=

Gaettens

=

Grolle

=

Hatz

=

Hbg

=

Ilisch

=

Deschamps de Pas, L.: L’Histoire monetaire des comtes de Flandre de la Maison de Bourgogne, Rev. Num. (1861) p. 106-138, 211-237, 458-478, Rev. Num. (1862) p. 117-143, 351-365, 460-480. Bellinger, A.R./Grierson, P./Hendy, M.F.: Catalogue of the Byzantine Coins in the Dumbarton Oaks Collection. Washington 1966 ff. Mey, J. de: Les monnaies des souverains luxembourgeois. Amsterdam 1966. -: Les monnaies de Namur. Brüssel 1971. Witte, A. de: Histoire monetaire des comtes de louvain, ducs de Brabant et Marquis du Saint Empire, 3 Bände. Anvers 1894-1899. Engel, A./Lehr, E.: Numismatique de l’Alsace. Paris 1887. Duncan Elias, R.R.: The Anglo-Gallic Coins. Paris/London 1984. Gelder, H.E.v.: Het Hollandse muntwezen onder het Huis Wittelsbach, in: JMP 39 (1952), S. 1 ff., JMP 46 (1959), S. 37 ff. Friedberg, A.L./Friedberg, I.S.: Gold Coins of the World. From ancient times to the present, New Jersey 2003. Fortuyn Drooglever, J.: Overijsselse vorstenmunten uit de 10e en 11e eeuw, De Beeldenaar 4 (1980), S. 28-41-240. -: De vorstelijke en de stedelijke muntslag te Deventer. Deventer 1982. -: De driesteden muntslag. 1479-1588. Deventer - Kampen - Zwolle. Deventer 1986. Saulcy, F. de: Recherches sur Les Monnaies des Évêques de Metz. Metz 1833. -: Recherches sur Les Monnaies des Ducs hériditaires de Lorraine. Metz 1841. -: Recherches sur Les Monnaies des Comtes et Ducs de Bar. Paris 1843. Gaillard, V.: Recherches sur les Monnaies des Comtes de Flandre. Gand 1852. Galster, G.: Die Münzen Dänemarks (bis etwa 1625). Halle 1939. -: Unionstidens Udmøntninger. Danmark og Norge 1397-1540, Sverige 1363-1521. Kopenhagen 1972. Gaettens, R.: Der Fund von Ludwiszcze. Ein Schatz deutscher und skandinavischer Denare des XI. Jahrhunderts. Halle (Saale) 1934. Grolle, J.J.: De muntslag van de Heren van den Bergh, ca. 1320 – 1440, in: JMP 80 (1993), S. 103-164. -: De muntslag van de Graven van Holland, 3 Bände. Amsterdam 2000. -: Muntende Ministerialen in Over-Sticht en Holland gedurende de 13e en 14e eeuw. Amsterdam 2002. Hatz, G.: Tieler Denare des 11 Jahrhunderts in den schwedischen Münzfunden (Commentationes de nummis saeculorum IX – XI in Suecia II). Stockholm 1968. Hauberg, P.: Myntforhold og Udmyntninger i Danmark indtil 1146. Kopenhagen 1900. -: Danmarks Myntvaesen i Tidsrummet 1146-1241. Kopenhagen 1906. -: Danmarks Myntvaesen og Mynter i Tidsrummet 1241-1377. Kopenhagen 1885. Die Münzprägung im Herzogtum Niederlothringen, in: JMP 84-85, Amsterdam 1997-1998. 471


JG Jankuhn Jesse Kappelhoff Kilger

= = = = =

Kluge

=

Krusy L Legros LL

= = = =

Lucas

=

Malmer Mayhew MB

= = =

MEC Metlich MG MIB

= = = =

Miles Mostecky

= =

Muntvondst Arnhem

=

N

= Nessel, X.: Die ältesten Hagenauer Münzen, in: Frankfurter Münzzeitung 61 (1906), S. 369 ff.

Nau

=

P

=

Passon PdA Purmer Rob Scholten

= = = = =

Schive Sear Stoess Stuurmann

= = = =

Tergast Tergast/Meier

= =

Vanhoudt vdCh

= =

vG

=

472

Ghyssens, J.: Les petits deniers de Flandre des XIIe et XIIIe siècle. Brüssel 1971. Jankuhn, H.: Haithabu. Ein Handelsplatz der Wikingerzeit. Neumünster 1986. Jesse, W.: Der wendische Münzverein. Lübeck 1928. Kappelhoff, A.: Die Münzen Ostfrieslands. Aurich 1982. Kilger, C.: Pfennigmärkte und Währungslandschaften. Monetarisierungen im sächsisch-slawischen Grenzland ca. 965-1120. Stockholm 2000. Kluge, B.: Die Salier. Deutsche Münzgeschichte von der späten Karolingerzeit bis zum Ende der Salier. Sigmaringen 1991. Krusy, H.: Gegenstempel auf Münzen des Spätmittelalters. Frankfurt/Main 1974. Lafaurie, J.: Les Monnaies des Rois de France, Tome I. Paris/Basel 1951. Legros, D.: Monnaies féodales Francaises, vol.1, 1984. Lagerquist, L.O.: Svenska Mynt, under Vikingatid och Medeltid (ca 995-1521) samt Gotländska Mynt (ca 1140-1565). Stockholm 1970. Lucas, P.: Monnaies de Hainaut, 1981. -: Monnaies seigneuriales mosanes. Hennuyères 1982. Malmer, B.: Nordiska mint före ar 1000. Lund 1966. Mayhew, N.J.: Sterling imitations of Edwardian type. London 1983. Mansfeld-Bullner, H.V.: Afbildninger af samtlige hidtil kjendte Danske monter fra tidsrummet 12411377. Kopenhagen 1954. Grierson, P./Blackburn, M.: Medieval European Coinage I. Cambrigde, 1986. Metlich, M.A.: The Coinage of Ostrogothic Italy. London 2004. Morrison, K.F./Grunthal, H.: Carolingian coinage. New York 1967. Hahn, W.: Moneta imperii byzantini, 1. Teil: Von Anastasius I. bis Justinianus I. (491-565) einschließlich der ostgotischen und vandalischen Prägungen. Wien 1973. Miles, G.C.: The coinage of the Visigoths of Spain: Leovigild to Achila II. New York 1952. Mostecky, H.: Münzen zwischen Rom und Byzanz. Studien zur spätantiken Numismatik (Numismatica Lovaniensia 16). Louvain-la-Neuve 1997. Gelder, H.E. v.: Vondst van 12e-eeuwse munten te Arnhem, in: JMP 67 (1980), S. 107. -: Die Münzen der Bischöfe zu Strassburg, in: Frankfurter Münzzeitung 89 (1908), S. 249 ff., 91/2 (1908), S. 281 ff., 93 (1908), S. 305 ff., 95 (1908), S. 337. Nau, E.: Münzen der Stauferzeit, in: Hausherr, R./Väterlein, C. (Hrsg.): Die Zeit der Staufer, Band I, S. 108-188, Band II, Abb. 93-127, Band III, S. 87-102, Stuttgart 1977. Pietersen, F.: Munten van de stad Utrecht. Utrecht 1978. Puister, A.T.: De 11e eeuwse munten der Friese Graven, in: De Florijn 20 (1975), S. 505-509. -: Groningse stedelijke munten, in: JMP 73 (1986), S. 5-72. Passon, T.: De stedelijke Munt van Nijmegen 1457-1704. Nimwegen 1980. Poey d’Avant, F.: Monnaies féodales de France. Paris 1858-1862. Purmer, D.: De stedelijke muntslag van Arnhem 1461-1599, in: JMP 83 (1996), S. 69 ff. Robert, P.C.: Description de la collection de M.P.C. Robert. Paris 1886. Scholten, C.: De munten van Friesland van de 10e tot het begin van de 14e eeuw, in: JMP 26 (1939), S. 1-55. Schive, C.I.: Norges Mynter i Middelalderen. Aalborg 1974. Sear, D.R.: Byzantine coins and their values. London 1974. Stoess, C.: Mere civitas, Commentationes Numismaticae 1988, S. 157. Stuurman, J.G.: Saksische hertogen in Friesland (1498-1515). Aspiraties en muntslag, in: JMP 88 (2001), S. 73-174. Tergast, P.: Die Münzen Ostfrieslands. 1. Theil: Bis 1464, Emden 1883. Die Münzen der Grafen von Ostfriesland (1464-1540). Nach der Handschrift des Verfassers neu bearbeitet und herausgegeben von Ortwin Meier, in: Ejb. Bd. 21 (1925/25), p. 1-56. Vanhoudt, H.: Atlas der Munten van België. Van de Kelten tot heden. Herent 1996. Chijs; P.O. v.d.: De munten der voormalige Graven en Hertogen van Gelderland. Haarlem 1852. -: De munten der voormalige graafschappen Holland en Zeeland. Haarlem 1858. -: De munten der bisschoppen, van de heerlijkheid en de stad Utrecht. Haarlem 1859. Gelder, H.E. v.: Oost-Nederlands geld omstreeks 1400, in: JMP 67 (1980), S. 45-66. -: De koninklijke munt te Nijmegen tot 1248, Het Valkhof te Nijmegen (catalogi van het kunstbezit van de gemeente Nijmegen, nr. 3). Nimwegen 1980.


vGH

=

vH

=

Weiller W

= =

Gelder H.E.v./Hoc, M.: Les monnaies des Pays-Bas bourguignons et espagnols 1434-1713. Amsterdam 1960. Hengel, C.v.: De munten van Holland in de 13e eeuw. Amsterdam 1986. -: Vondsten van 12e eeuwse (Hollandse?) munten, in: JMP 80 (1993), p. 93-101. -: Penningen Hollants. Amsterdam 1998. Weiller, R.: Les monnaies Luxembourgeoises. Louvain-la Neuve 1977. Wendling, E.: Corpvs Nvmmorvm Lotharingiae Mosellanae, Tome I. Metz 1979.

Barlandus, A.: De Kroniek van de hertogen van Brabant, uitg. ’s Hertogenbosch 2004. Bastien, P.: Imitations of Roman Bronze Coins A.D. 318-363, in: ANSMN 30 (1985), p. 143-177. Benders, J.: De muntslag van Maria van Brabant, in: De Beeldenaar 25 (2001), S. 99. Bendixen, K.: Denmark’s Money. Kopenhagen 1967. Besteman, J.C./Bos, J.M./Heidinga, H.A.: Graven naar Friese koningen. De opgravingen in Wijnaldum. Franeker 1992. Boekhorst, B.H.J. te: De stedelijke muntslag in Friesland in de 15e eeuw. Surhuisterveen 1999. Boeles, P.C.J.A.: Friesland tot de elfde eeuw. s Gravenhage 1951. Boer, D.E.H. de/Cordfunke, E.H.P: Graven van Holland. Zutphen 1995. Carmiggelt, A.: De "Koningsterp" van Wijnaldum. Abcoude 2000. Chijs, P.O.v.d.: De munten der voormalige hertogdommen Brabant en Limburg. Haarlem 1851. Dubbe, E.: De val van het slot Puttenstein in 1375, in: Antiek jrg. 23, no. 10, S. 551 ff. Engel, A./Serrure, R.: Traité de Numismatique du Moyen-Age, 3 Bände. Paris 1890. Ewig, E.: Die Merowinger und das Frankenreich. Stuttgart 2001. Gelder, H.E.v.: Klein geld, Grof geld. Munten van de Nederlandse steden. den Haag 1974. -: Munten van Gravin Adela, in: JMP 67 (1980), S. 213 ff. -: De muntslag te Gorinchem, in: JMP 67 (1980), S. 221 ff. -: Laat-middeleeuwse munten van Groningen, in: JMP 69 (1982), S. 47-68. Ghijssens, J.: Essai de classement chronologique des monnaies brabanconnes. Brüssel o.J. Grote, H.: Stammtafeln. Leipzig 1877. Halbertsma, H.: Frieslands oudheid. Het rijk van de Friese koningen, opkomst en ondergang. Utrecht 2000.

Hengel, C.v.: Penningen Hollants. Amsterdam 1998. -: Vondsten van 12e eeuwse (Hollandse?) munten, in: JMP 80 (1993), S. 93. Henstra, D.J.: The evolution of the money standard in medieval frisia. Hilversum 1999. Hooft van Iddekinge: Friesland en de Friezen in de middeleeuwen. Leiden 1881. new edition Walluf/Wiesbaden. Jacobi, H.W.: Muntvondst Hemrik 1984 en Leeuwarden 1983, in: JMP 71 (1984), S. 133. Jansen, H.P.H.: Middeleeuwse geschiedenis der Nederlanden. Utrecht 1972. Jarnut, J.: Geschichte der Langobarden. Stuttgart 1982. Kalma, J.J. (Hrsg.): Geschiedenis van Friesland. Drachten 1968. Lafaurie, J.: Numismatique: Des Mérovingiens aix Carolingiens, in: Francia 2 (1974). Lexikon des Mittelalters, 11 Bände, München/Zürich 1977-1999. Linssen, C.A.A. : Historische opstellen over Lotharingen en Maastricht in de Middeleeuwen. Assen 1985. Meer, G.v.d.: De vondst Arnhem 1957, in: JMP 46 (1959), S. 1 ff. Mignolet, A.: Les monnaies de la Principauté de Liège. Maastricht 1986. Morrison, C./Schwartz, J.H.: Vandal silver coinage in the name of Honorius, in: MN 27 (1982), p. 149-179. Müter, H.: Het ontstaan van de stad Tiel, in: Bijdragen voor de Geschiedenis der Nederlanden 9 (1955), S. 161 ff. Pelsdonk, J.E.L.: Pennincx van loode. Goudswaart 2003. Prinz, F.: Kelten, Römer und Germanen. München 2005. Richebé, C.: Les monnaies féodales d’Artois du Xe au début du XIV siècle. Paris 1963. Schmidt, H. und M.: Die vergessene Bildersprache christlicher Kunst. München 1995. Skaare, K. : Moneta Norwei. Oslo 1968. Sprenger, J.: De muntslag te Maastricht. Maastricht 1968 (dissertatie Universiteit Leuven). Platen ontbreken. Schreiber, H. : Die Vandalen. Bern 1979. Thewissen, C.: Oud Maastricht. Baarn 1968. Thoben, J.: Kruisridders in Bergh? Gelders Erfgoed, 1998-2, S. 6 ff.

Vis, G.N.M.: Adelbert en Egmond, het leven van de heilige belijder Adelbert. St. Adelbertabdij 1990. Völkers, H.H. : Karolingische Münzfunde der Frühzeit (751-800). Göttingen 1965. Wirth, G.: Attila. Das Hunnenreich und Europa. Stuttgart 1999. Wolfram, H.: Die Goten. München 2001. Wolters, L.: Bisschop St-Lambertus, Maaslandse missionaris en martelaar, z.j. Alpertus van Metz: Gebeurtenissen van deze tijd. Amsterdam 1980. Gregorius v. Tours: Historiën. Baarn 1994. Veldeke, H.v.: Servaas-Legende, uitg. Maastricht 1993.

473


474


475


476


NUMISMATISCHE AUSDRÜCKE EXPRESSIONS NUMISMATIQUES NUMISMATIC TERMS TERMINI DI NUMISMATICA DEUTSCH

ENGLISCH

FRANÇAIS

ITALIANO

Abschlag Am Rand Berieben Blei Dezentriert Doppelschlag Einfassung Einseitig Emailliert Erhaltung Etwas Exemplar Fassungsspuren Fehlprägung Feld(er) Fundexemplar Gedenkmünze Geglättet Gelocht Geprägt Gewellt Goldpatina Hübsch Jahrh. = Jahrhundert. Kl. = klein Korrosionsspuren Kratzer Kupfer Legierung Leicht(e) l. = links Min. = minimal Nachahmung Prachtexemplar Prägeschwäche Randdelle Randfehler Randschrift r. = rechts Rückseite Schriftspuren Schrötling Schrötlingsfehler Schwach ausgeprägt Selten in dieser Erhaltung Seltener Jahrgang Stempel Stempelfehler Überdurchschnittlich erhalten Überprägt Unediert Unikum Vergoldet Von aller größter Seltenheit Vorderseite Winz.= winzig Zain Zierrand Zinn Ziseliert

struck at the rim/border slightly polished lead uncentered double struck frame uniface enamelled condition/preservation slightly specimen, copy trace of mounting mis-strike field(s) specimen from a hoard commemorative coin tooled holed minted bent golden patina attractive century small traces of corrosion scratch(es) copper alloy slightly left minimal imitation attractive, perfect piece weakly struck edge nick edge faults lettered edge to right reverse traces of inscription flan flan defect weakly struck rare in this condition rare year die(s) mistake in the die extraordinary condition overstruck unpublished unique specimen gilt extremely rare head tiny flan ornamental border tin chased

frappe en tranche frotté plomb decentré double frappe encadrement uniface émaillé conservation un peu exemplaire traces de monture défaut de frappe champ de trésor monnaie commemorative lissé troué frappé ondulé patine dorée joli siécle petit traces de corrosion rayure cuivre alliace légère gauche minimal imitation pièce magnifique de frappe molle défaut sur la tranche erreur sur la tranche inscription sur la tranche droite revers traces de légende flan Flan défectueux de frappe molle conservation rare année rare coin erreur de frappe conservation extraordinaire surfrappé inédit pièce unique doré très rare en face petit flan tranche ornée étain ciselé

coniazione al bordo trattato piombo non centrato ribattitura cornice uniface smaltato conservazione un poco esemplare tracce di montatura difetto di coniazione campo da tesoretto moneta commemorativa liscio bucato coniato ondolato patina d´oro carino secolo piccolo segni di corrosione graffio(i) rame lega leggero sinistra minimamente contraffazzione esemplare magnifico conio stanco ammaccatura al bordo errore nel bordo inscrizione sul bordo destra rovescio tracce di leggenda tondello errore di tondello conio stanco conservazione rara annata rara conio errore di conio conservazione estraordinaria ribattuto inedito pezzo unico dorato di estrema raritá diritto veramente piccolo tondello taglio ornato stagno cesellato 477


VERSTEIGERUNGSBEDINGUNGEN Die Versteigerung erfolgt im Auftrag und für Rechnung der Eigentümer unter Einhaltung der sich aus der Versteigerungsordnung (BGB1 I 1976, 1346) ergebenden und für Kommissionäre geltenden gesetzlichen Bestimmungen des BGB und HGB gegen Barzahlung des Kaufpreises in -Währung. Durch Abgabe eines Gebotes werden die Versteigerungsbedingungen anerkannt, dies gilt auch für die schriftlichen Gebote. Der Zuschlagpreis ist Nettopreis im Sinne des Mehrwertsteuergesetzes und bildet die Berechnungsgrundlage für das vom Käufer zu zahlende Aufgeld in Höhe von 15 %. Auf den daraus entstehenden Gesamtpreis (Zuschlag + Aufgeld) wird die zur Zeit gültige, ermäßigte Mehrwertsteuer von 7 % erhoben. Papiergeld unterliegt ebenfalls dem ermäßigten Steuersatz. Goldmünzen, bei denen Zuschlagpreis und Aufgeld geringer ist als das zweieinhalbfache des Metallpreises, unterliegen dem normalen Mehrwertsteuersatz von zur Zeit 16%, ebenso historische Wertpapiere. Goldmünzen, die als Anlagegold gelten, sind mehrwertsteuerfrei. Ausländischen Käufern aus Ländern der europäischen Gemeinschaft wird die in Deutschlang gültige Umsatzsteuer berechnet. Anderen ausländischen Käufern (aus Drittländern) wird, sofern die Münzen durch uns exportiert werden, ein Aufgeld von 15 % netto auf den Zuschlagpreis berechnet; sie erhalten die Lieferung nur gegen Zahlung des Kaufpreises in - Währung, bankspesenfrei. Ausländischen Münzhändlern aus Ländern der europäischen Gemeinschaft wird bei Nachweis der Umsatzsteuer-Identifikationsnummer (§ 27 a USTG) und der sonstigen Voraussetzungen gemäß § 4 Nr. 1 b USTG in Verbindung mit § 6 a USTG die Lieferung ohne Umsatzsteuer berechnet. Sofern nichts anderes vereinbart wird, ist die Zahlung der Auktionsrechnung bei anwesenden Käufern sofort, bei schriftlichen Bietern spätestens 20 Tage nach Erhalt fällig. Bei Zahlungsverzug werden Zinsen von 1 % pro Monat berechnet. Wird die Zahlung nicht sofort an den Versteigerer geleistet oder die Abnahme der zugeschlagenen Sache verweigert, so findet die Übergabe der Sache an den Ersteigerer nicht statt. Der Ersteigerer verliert vielmehr seine Rechte aus dem Zuschlag, und die Sache kann auf seine Kosten erneut versteigert werden. In diesem Fall haftet der Ersteigerer für den Ausfall, dagegen hat er auf dem Mehrerlös keinen Anspruch. Der Zuschlag erfolgt nach dreimaligem Ausruf des höchsten Gebotes und verpflichtet zur Abnahme und Zahlung. Bei Meinungsverschiedenheiten über den Zuschlag wird die Nummer noch einmal ausgerufen. Der Versteigerer ist berechtigt, Nummern zu vereinigen oder zu trennen. Eine Vorausnahme von Nummern erfolgt nicht. Der Zutritt zur Versteigerung ist nur Interessenten gestattet, die einen Katalog besitzen. Die Mindeststeigerungsstufen für das Bietungsverfahren betragen: Mindestangebote

werden. Schriftliche Gebote können nur bis 24 Stunden vor Auktionsbeginn verbindlich berücksichtigt werden. Im Bedarfsfall ist der Auktionator berechtigt, die Limits um 3 – 5 % zu überschreiten. Bei mehreren gleichhohen Geboten erhält das zuerst eingegangene den Zuschlag. Unlimitierte Aufträge haben keinen Anspruch auf unbedingte Ausführung. Telefonisches Bieten ist nur in Ausnahmefällen möglich. Telefonische Bieter müssen sich mindestens einen Tag vor der Auktion voranmelden. Der Versand geht zu Lasten und auf Risiko des Ersteigerers bzw. Empfängers. Das Auktionsgut bleibt bis zur vollständigen Bezahlung aller Forderungen aus Anlaß der Versteigerung Eigentum des Verkäufers. Ist der Käufer Vollkaufmann, so ist Osnabrück als Gerichtsstand vereinbart. Für das Mahnverfahren gilt die Zuständigkeit des Amtsgerichts Osnabrück auch in allen anderen Fällen als vereinbart. Ansonsten ist es Osnabrück nur, wenn nur die Firma Fritz Rudolf Künker ihren allgemeinen Gerichtsstand in der BRD hat, oder wenn alle Ansprüche im Wege des Mahnverfahrens geltend gemacht werden, oder wenn die im Klageweg in Anspruch zu nehmende Vertragspartei nach Vertragsabschluß ihren gewöhnlichen Aufenthaltsort aus dem Geltungsbereich der BRD verlegt hat, oder ihr Wohnsitz oder gewöhnlicher Aufenthaltsort zum Zeitpunkt der Klage nicht bekannt ist. Die Beschreibung im Katalog ist gewissenhaft durchgeführt. Sie begründet jedoch keine Rechts- oder Sachmängelhaftung gemäß §§ 434, 459 ff BGB. Die Angabe der Erhaltung ist streng nach den im deutschen Münzhandel üblichen Erhaltungseinstufungen vorgenommen und gilt als persönliche Beurteilung. Bei der Auktion anwesende Käufer kaufen grundsätzlich „wie besehen“. Da durch Vorbesichtigung Gelegenheit gegeben ist, sich vom Erhaltungszustand des Versteigerungsgutes zu überzeugen, können nach erfolgtem Zuschlag Reklamationen nur bei irrtümlich übersehener Henkel- oder Fassungsspur oder gestopftem Loch berücksichtigt werden. Bei Losen mit mehreren Stücken sind die Stückzahlen nur Circa-Angaben, irrtümliche Zuschreibungen sind im Einzelfall nicht ausgeschlossen. Diese Lose sind nach erfolgtem Zuschlag von jeder Reklamation ausgeschlossen. Der Versteigerer kann bei eventuellen Meinungsverschiedenheiten bzw. Beanstandungen einen vereidigten Sachverständiger seiner Wahl (die Kosten trägt der unterliegende Teil) beauftragen. Eventuelle Beanstandungen können nur innerhalb von 8 Tagen nach der Auktion bzw. nach Erhalt der ersteigerten Stücke berücksichtigt werden. Die Echtheit der Stücke wird bis zur Höhe des Kaufpreises garantiert. Die beigedruckten Preise sind Schätzpreise, die unter- oder überschritten werden können. Aufträge, die unter 80 % des Schätzpreises liegen, können nicht bearbeitet werden.

Ausländische Kunden kaufen nach den Devisen-, Zoll- und Steuerbestimmungen ihres Landes. Versandformalitäten werden vom Versteigerer erledigt.

Mindeststeigerungsstufe Soweit nicht anders vermerkt, gelten im übrigen die allgemeinen Versteigerungsbestimmungen und – auch im Verhältnis zu ausländischen Kunden – gilt Deutsches Recht.

bis zu

100,--

5,--

bis zu

300,--

10,--

bis zu

1.000,--

20,--

Für Büchersendungen und Sendungen ins Ausland werden Versandkosten nach Aufwand in Rechnung gestellt.

bis zu

1.500,--

50,--

Die Ergebnisliste erscheint sofort nach der Auktion.

bis zu

3.000,--

100,--

bis zu

10.000,--

200,--

bis zu

20.000,--

500,--

ab

20.000,--

1.000,--

DIE VERSTEIGERER:

FRITZ RUDOLF KÜNKER DR. ANDREAS KAISER ARNE KIRSCH OLIVER KÖPP

Schriftliche Aufträge werden von uns ohne Auftragsprovision gewissenhaft ausgeführt. Aufträge von uns unbekannten Sammlern können nur ausgeführt werden, wenn ein Depot hinterlegt wird oder Referenzen benannt

478


TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF AUCTION The auction is conducted on behalf and for the account of the appropiate proprietors of the goods and is subject to the federal Auction Regulation (Versteigerungsordnung, BGB1 I 1976, 1346) published in the Federal Law GazetteVol. I, 1976, 1346 and the relevant provisions for factors in accordance with the German Cicil Code (BGB) and Commercial Code (HGB). Payment of the hammer-price has to be made in cash and in Euro. The submission of an offer implies the express acknowledgement of these Terms and Conditions of Auction; the same applies to the submission of an offer in writing. The hammer-price is exclusive of applicable German VAT according to the prevailing VAT – legislation and represents the basis for calculating the surcharge of 15 percent payable by the puchaser. The total price so calculated (hammerprice plus surcharge) is subject to the reduced VAT (value added tax=Mehrwertsteuer) of 7 per cent as presently applicable, which is payabel additionally. The reduced VAT applies also to paper-money. Gold coins for which the hammer-price plus surcharge is less than two and ohne half times the intrinsic gold price, are subject to the normal VAT rate of presently 16 per cent. The same applies to historical bonds. Gold coins which are considered as a gold investment are free of VAT. Purchasers from abroad will be charged a surcharge of 15 per cent net on the hammer-price, provided the export of the coins is undertaken by the auctioneer. Buyers in European Community (EEC) countries (other than Germany) will be charged Value Added Tax at the rates prevailing in Germany. Dealers from EEC countries (other than Germany) will receive goods free of tax upon presentation of their VAT I.D. number, and upon fulfillment of the other conditions set forth in Paragraph 4, Nr. 1 b, and Paragraph 6 a of the GermanTurnover Tax Law. Buyers from other countries are not charged Value Added Tax. Delivery will be made against payment in Euro with no bank charges to the auctioneer. Unless mutually agreed otherwise, payment of the auction bill from purchasers present at the auction is due immediately. From purchaser who have submitted a bid in writing, payment is due within 20 days after receipt of the goods. Defaulted payments shall bear an interest charge of 1 % per month in the amount in default. Should payment to the auctioneer not be made immediately or should the acceptance of the awardet item be refused, such item shall not be handed overt to the purchaser. Instead the purchaser shall forfeit all right and title in and to such item from the award and the item may again be put to auction at this buyer’s cost. In this event the buyer shall be liable for any shortfall, while he shall have no right or claim towards any excess proceeds. An item will be knocked down after the highest bid has been called three times. The award shall be a binding commitment and liability on the part of the bidder to take acceptance and delivery of the item or items so awarded. In the event of any dispute with regard to the award the lot will be put up again for bidding. The auctioneer reserves the right to combine or to seperate lots. Lots will not be called out of sequence. Access to the auction will only be permitted to interested persons who are in possession of the catalogue.

price or prices for a given lot, the bid first received by the auctioneer shall be given the award. Unlimited bids shall not oblige the auctioneer to consider, accept or carry out such order. Telephone bidding is generally an option for lots of substantial value only. The registration is required at the latest a day before auction. Shipment (by mail or otherwise) of the goods shall be for the sole cost and risk of the purchaser or receipient, resp. The auctioned goods remain the sole and exclusiv property of the vendor until full payment and settlement of any and all dues and claims in connection with the auction. In the event the purchaser is a merchant (in the sende of the German commercial laws) Osnabrück shall be the agreed and exclusive place of jurisdiction. The competence of the District Court (Amtsgericht) of Osnabrück is agreed in respect of summary proceedings for the collection of defaulted payments (Mahnverfahren) as well as in any and all other cases. Should the purchaser not be a merchant Osnabrück shall be the place of jurisdiction with the District Court of Osnabrück’s competence, if only the auctioneer has his ordinary legal domicil in the Federal Republic of Germany or if claims are made by way of summary proceedings of collection (Mahnverfahren) or if the defendant has moved his ordinary legal domicil outside the jurisdiction of the Federal Republik of Germany or if the legal domicil of the defendant is unknown to the auctioneer at the time of filing a suit. To the exclusion of any other legislation German law, as in force at the time, shall be applied for the settlement of any and all legal or judicial matters. The specifications and descriptions in the catalogue have been prepared diligently and in good faith do, however, not constitute the acceptance by the auctioneer of any warranty or liability in respect of defect in material or title. The state of preservation of items is strictly assessed in accordance with the grades accepted by the German coin trade and only represents an individual and personal assessment. Purchasers present at the auction acquire items strictly on the basis of “as is where is” and “as inspected”. In view of the opportunity of prior inspection to ascertain the state and condition of the auction lots, complaints and objections made after the sale will only be considered, if by obvious error or mistake loop or traces or moutings, traces of trimmings or settings, or the plugging of a hole (eyelet) have remained unnoticed. If and when auctioned in lots, the quantities of individual pieces given, only represent an approximate figure. An error in the allocation of indivdual pieces to a certain lot cannot be excluded. Such lots are, therefore, excluded from any complaintes or objections after the lot is knocked down. In the event of disputes or complaints as to the quality of an item the auctioneer may call upon a gernerally sworn expert of the trade, which the auctioneer may choose at his sole discretin, for assessment an the rendering of a decision as to the justification of such dispute or complaint. The costs of such expert shall be borne by the party loosing the dispute according to the expert’s decision. Complaints or objections, if justified, will only be considered if made and received by the auctioneer within 8 days after the auction or after receipt the lots, respectively. The authenticity of the coins is warranted. Warranted up to the total purchase price. The prices set out in the catalogue are estimates only, which may bei exceeded or undercut. Orders for less than 80 per cent of the estimated price cannot accepted.

The minimum rates of increase for the bidding procedure are: for minimum offers

minimum increase rate

Purchasers from abroad will have to observe all applicable laws and regulations in respect of foreign exchange, customs duties and taxation of their country. The auctioneer will only dischare such formalities, which have to be observed, in the Federal Republic of Germany in connection with the export of the purchased item(s).

up to

100,--

5,--

up to

300,--

10,--

up to

1.000,--

20,--

up to

1.500,--

50,--

Unless stipulated otherwise herein, the general rules regulations for auctions applicable in Germany shall govern any transaction in respect of the auction; German Law shall also be applicable in relation to purchasers form abroad. Only the German text has legal forde.

up to

3.000,--

100,--

Shipment to foreign countries and shipment of books we charge upon expenses.

up to

10.000,--

200,--

The prices realized will be published in the form of a list immediately after the auction.

up to

20.000,--

500,--

above

20.000,--

1.000,--

Orders submitted in writing will be carried out diligently and without charge of an extra commission. Orders from collectors unknown to the auctioneer can only be accepted and carried out if a deposit or references to the satisfaction on the auctioneer are given. To be bindingly accepted, written bids need to be received at least 24 hours befor auction. If necessary, the auctioneer is alloweed to increase the bids by 3-5%. Should several bids be obtained in writing bidding the same

THE AUCTIONEERS:

FRITZ RUDOLF KÜNKER DR. ANDREAS KAISER ARNE KIRSCH OLIVER KÖPP

479


NUMISMATISCHE BEARBEITUNG FOTOS LAYOUT DRUCK

Alexandra Spreu, Dr. des. Sebastian Steinbach, Jens Ulrich Thormann M. A., Manuela Weiß Übersetzungen: Robert Weir, Kiel Lübke & Wiedemann, Stuttgart danner pc - gesteuerte systeme waiblingen media-print, Paderborn Jeglicher Nachdruck, auch auszugsweise, bedarf der Genehmigung des Auktionshauses

BANKVERBINDUNGEN DEUTSCHE BANK OSNABRÜCK DRESDNER BANK OSNABRÜCK SPARKASSE OSNABRÜCK VOLKSBANK BORGLOH-HILTER E. G. BANKHAUS LAMPE KG BIELEFELD POSTBANK HANNOVER CREDIT SUISSE

BLZ 265 700 90, Konto 0 177 006 BLZ 265 800 70, Konto 780 520 200 BLZ 265 501 05, Konto 247 320 BLZ 265 624 90, Konto 1 200 222 400 BLZ 480 201 51, Konto 174 076 BLZ 250 100 30, Konto 2900 60 - 308 Konto 135 494 - 42 - 1

Zahlungen aus dem Ausland - Foreign payments SPARKASSE OSNABRÜCK DEUTSCHE BANK OSNABRÜCK POSTBANK HANNOVER CREDIT CARDS

IBAN: DE50 2655 0105 0000 2473 20 SWIFT-CODE: NOLADE22XXX IBAN: DE11 2657 0090 0017 7006 00 SWIFT-CODE: DEUTDE3B265 IBAN: DE73 2501 0030 0290 0603 08 SWIFT-CODE: PBNKDEFF We do accept VISA and MASTERCARD Service charge: 4,5 %

ERHALTUNGS- UND SELTENHEITSGRADE ERHALTUNGSGRADE/ GRADING TERMS DEGRÉS DE CONSERVATION GRADI DI CONSERVAZIONE

SELTENHEITSGRADE

480

Polierte Platte Proof

Flan bruni Fondo specchio

Stempelglanz Uncirculated

Fleur de coin Fior di conio

Vorzüglich Extremely fine

Superbe Splendido

Sehr schön Very fine

Très beau Bellissimo

Schön Fine

Beau Molto Bello

Gering erhalten Very good

Très bien conservé Bello

R = Selten Von großer Seltenheit

RR = Sehr selten Von größter Seltenheit


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.