CR IP TI ON BS SU
THURSDAY, APRIL 19, 2012
Holocaust survivor finds haven as Muslim in Israel
150 FILS NO: 15423 40 PAGES
Picture perfect: Filipino architect bags grand prize
Japan study raises hopes of cure for baldness
8
www.kuwaittimes.net
JAMADI ALAWAAL 28, 1433 AH
Drogba grabs winner as Chelsea beat Barca 1-0
38
28
20
Barrak targets under-fire Shamali with new queries MP slams swollen ‘corruption file’ of finance minister By B Izzak
conspiracy theories
History and facts
By Badrya Darwish
badrya_d@kuwaittimes.net
T
his week I read an article in Al-Qabas daily in which the writer criticized the education system in Kuwait. I do not blame him about this. I often criticize it myself. The writer, however, was more specific in his criticism of history books in particular. He said that what is taught to students in Kuwait, according to his study, is misleading and inaccurate in many ways. He said that the textbook provides wrong facts and terminology. In many instances the terminology used in the textbooks, he insisted, was misused. Wrong terminology could give a different interpretation from the original meaning. The accurate thing, which by the way was astonishing, in his study were some figures. He claimed that in one history book, the population of the world was estimated to be around 650 million. At this point I was laughing out loud. I thought to myself that maybe the writer of the textbook had written it in 1700 when Kuwait was established. Maybe 300 years ago the population of the world was around that number. I have no idea. Then, other statistics popped up. The book he was referring to said that the geographical area of the Arab world is 10 percent of the whole world, the area of which he wrote was 14 million sq m. Actually the whole world is around 150 million sq m. Do the math yourselves! At this part I laughed my head off. Whether the book was written in 1700 AD or BC, the size of the Earth could not have changed. The population could have shrunk or expanded but the Earth: No. Even in Moses’ times the size of the Earth was the same. The writer of the article pointed many mistakes in the textbooks but I will focus on a few that attracted my attention. Austria, he said, was described in the textbook as a city. A well-travelled nation like Kuwait knows that Austria is one of the important countries in the European Union. Vienna, the capital, is well-known for music and arts. The writer of the study also referred South Sudan as Sudan. At this point I took this as a trivial mistake. Of course the textbook was not written in the last six months when Sudan split in two. Maybe the textbooks for next year will have that historical event corrected. You never know, maybe the war in Sudan will split Sudan in four or unify it into one. Maybe Khartoum will become a country on its own. Or Darfur can also claim independence. Don’t forget good old Libya post Muammar Gaddafi. It could also disintegrate into four states - Amazigh on one side, Tawareq on the other and Tripoli and Benghazi on their own. If the plan for Syria continues maybe you will see Damascus turning into one state and Aleppo into another. Don’t forget good old Iraq. Nobody knows if Kurdistan will go on its own and if Maliki claims Baghdad as a sovereign state on its own. I do not know. But I am sure that the future history of Kuwait will be full of intrigues and conspiracies especially if history focuses on the era of our democracy and parliament. Unfortunately, the writer won’t be living to fact-check the data. Do we all then have to rewrite the history of the Arab world? Then every year a textbook has to change. Especially with the Arab Spring still ongoing. Have a good day!
Wary UAE tightens screws on Islamists ABU DHABI/RAS AL-KHAIMAH: Wary of the Muslim Brotherhood’s growing influence in the Arab world, the United Arab Emirates is clamping down on Islamists, anxious they could be emboldened to challenge a government that has weathered “Arab Spring” uprisings unscathed. Long confined to the margins of the political scene or thrown in prison to ensure they stayed that way, Islamists have emerged as key actors in Tunisia, Libya and Egypt following the overthrow of their autocratic rulers. Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood now holds more seats than any other party in parliament and has fielded a candidate for the presidency, and the Islamist Ennahda party won Tunisia’s first free election last year. Continued on Page 13
Max 33º Min 18º High Tide 10:42 & 23:09 Low Tide 04:12 & 16:58
MANAMA: Bahraini anti-government activist Zainab Al-Khawaja (second right) gestures and chants slogans in front of riot police during a protest in downtown Manama yesterday. — AP
Clashes hit Bahrain F1 exhibit Wave of arrests as activists vow ‘days of rage’ MANAMA: Security forces fired stun grenades yesterday at anti-government protesters who swarmed into a cultural exhibition for Bahrain’s Formula One race, setting off street battles and sending visitors fleeing for cover. It was a blow to the Gulf
nation’s efforts to project stability, returning to the Grand Prix circuit a year after the race was canceled because of unrest. The demonstration was the most direct attempt by protesters to bring their demands into events linked to Sunday’s race,
Bahrain’s top international showcase. The resumption of the top-level auto race is being touted by Bahrain’s rulers as a sign they have the upper hand after 14 months of clashes and crackdowns. Continued on Page 13
KUWAIT: Opposition MP Musallam Al-Barrak, who has threatened to grill Finance Minister Mustafa Al-Shamali, yesterday sent a series of questions to the minister about transfer of public funds to officials and state institutions. In his questions, Barrak demanded a list of all sums exceeding KD 20 million transferred during four fiscal years to individuals, companies, establishments or state officials. The fiscal years extend from 2006/2007 to 2009/2010. Barrak also demanded the names of beneficiaries, their positions, the date of transfer and supporting documents in addition to the names of local or foreign banks that the transfers were made to through the Central Bank of Kuwait. He asked Shamali if the finance ministry transferred through the Central Bank amounts exceeding KD 20 million directly into the local or foreign accounts of government officials, the names and account numbers of beneficiaries and the supporting legal and constitutional documents. Barrak also demanded to know all the amounts exceeding KD 20 million that had been transferred to government departments which in turn transferred the amounts to other beneficiaries (officials), in addition to the names of those beneficiaries and the legal justification for the transfers. The lawmaker said that these transfers by the finance ministry are a very serious matter and could be as grave as the alleged foreign transfers by the former prime minister which was exposed by Barrak himself last September which eventually led to the resignation of the former premier and dissolution of the National Assembly. Barrak claimed the “corruption file” of the finance minister has swelled and must be held to account, saying that he did not take any action on the Seimens corruption scandal. Trial reportedly began yesterday in Germany over charges that Seimens paid bribes to senior Kuwaiti electricity officials to win a power plant contract. Kuwait has not initiated any investigation into the allegations. Continued on Page 13
Settlers force into home in Beit Hanina US Muslim tortured at FBI behest in UAE
JERUSALEM: Israeli police arrest a member of Khaled Natshe’s family as they are forced to hand over their home to Jewish settlers in the Israeli annexed east Jerusalem neighbourhood of Beit Hanina yesterday. — AFP JERUSALEM: Israeli police yesterday evicted a Palestinian family from their home in annexed east Jerusalem after Jewish settlers won a court battle over ownership, police and rights groups said. The eviction of the 14-member Natshe family from two houses in Beit Hanina was the first successful attempt by settlers to secure a property in the wellheeled Arab district in the northern part of east Jerusalem, rights groups said. Police spokeswoman Luba Samri confirmed the eviction, telling AFP it was in line with a recent court ruling which found settlers had legally purchased the property. “The court decided a while ago that the two houses belong to the Jews. One of those houses was voluntarily evacuated a few weeks ago while police units are now helping forces from the eviction department to evacuate the other house,” she said. Speaking to AFP, Lubna Al-Natshe said all of the family’s furniture had been removed and that police had arrested her husband. “They came at 8:00 am (0500 GMT) to evict us and when my husband tried to resist, they beat him and they arrested him,” she said. “They say the settlers bought this house 73 years ago.” Arye King, head of the Israel Land
Fund, a right-wing group dedicated to purchasing properties in Arab east Jerusalem, told AFP the land had been “bought by a Jewish buyer decades ago” and that his group was reclaiming it. He said Palestinian claims to the land were “forged”. Hagit Ofran, who works with Israeli settlement watchdog Peace Now, said both the Palestinians and the settlers were claiming ownership of the land, but that a court had ruled against the Palestinians. “There were Jews living here before 1948 and some of them purchased parcels of land in the West Bank and east Jerusalem,” she said, adding the plots fell into Jordanian ownership after the war that accompanied Israel’s establishment. “But the Palestinians also say they bought it from the owner at around the same time,” she said. “It could be true that the land was purchased by a Jewish buyer but I believe it is against Israel’s interests to establish a new settlement in Beit Hanina, and it is against Israel’s interests to acknowledge Jewish property rights before 1948 when we don’t allow the Palestinians to do the same, because that would be permitting the right of return.” But there was a political twist to the story, she said, indicating the individual who Continued on Page 13
STOCKHOLM: A Muslim American seeking asylum in Sweden claimed yesterday he was detained at the US government’s request while in the United Arab Emirates last summer, tortured in custody and interrogated about the activities of a Portland mosque. Yonas Fikre told a news conference yesterday that he was held for 106 days and was beaten, threatened with death and kept in solitary confinement in a frigid cell. The 33-yearold, a naturalized US citizen born in Eritrea, says he had attended the same mosque in Portland as a man who has been charged in a plot to detonate a bomb in the northwestern US city. He moved to Sudan in 2009 and later to the United Arab Emirates. He went to Sweden, where he has relatives, after being released from detention on Sept 15. Fikre, who converted to Islam in 2003, is the third Muslim man from Portland to publicly say he was detained while traveling abroad and questioned about Portland’s Masjidas-Sabr mosque. Mohamed Osman Mohamud, a Somali American who is awaiting trial on a charge of plotting to set off a bomb in downtown Portland in Nov 2010, occasionally worshipped there. A decade ago, seven Muslims with ties to the mosque were arrested following a failed effort to enter Afghanistan and fight US forces. Fikre says he met Mohamud a handful of times, but wouldn’t call him a friend or even an acquaintance. Fikre says he was arrested on June 1 in the United Arab Emirates and taken to a prison in Abu Dhabi, where he was questioned about the activities of the Portland mosque and its imam, Mohamed Sheikh Abdirahman Kariye. When he first suggested that his UAE interrogators were working for the FBI, they became very upset, he said. “They
Yonas Fikre got very angry and they said: We don’t work with the Americans, we are an independent countr y,” he said. However, in the final days of his confinement, Fikre said that one interrogator acknowledged that the FBI had been involved in his questioning. “He confirmed to me that the FBI was there. Also when I was getting beaten, they did admit that the FBI knew exactly what was happening and they were working with the FBI,” Fikre said. Beth Anne Steele, a spokeswoman for the FBI office in Portland, said she could not discuss specifics of the case. “I can tell you that the FBI trains its agents very specifically and very thoroughly about what is acceptable under US law,” she said. “To do anything counter to that training is counterproductive - we risk legal liability and potentially losing a criminal case in court.” The Council on AmericanIslamic Relations has called upon the US Department of Justice to investigate whether Fikre was tortured at the behest of the FBI. “Barack Obama said that America doesn’t torture,” said Gadeir Abbas, the group’s attorney. “We didn’t see the footnote that Continued on Page 13