'8%9#"':;)$#< ↓・6"&3*&7%84 %983".&:%;0/(+7 '
=>%"*.%16%=
左 右
↓・-#.#"#,/# !"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
0#1#/*#2'3%"4+ 5#+6$,#"7'2"#34+"%5+
Architecture =Logical System
意味論
統語論
semantics
階層 hierarchy
syntax
↓・-#.#"#,/#
公理
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
定理
axiom
分化 morphogenesis
theorem
公理系 axiomatic system
自己生産 auto-poiesis
soundness
↓・-#.#"#,/#
自己組織化
自律
autonomy
self-organization
完全性
completeness
=:,*"%2D/*6%,=
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
健全性
!"#$%&'()*+,-./!)0
左 右
象徴交換
l'échange symbolique
25'8)($'(&5$9 )49 (8$9 ?5) =*5;)+@9 .49 .9 /*@)'./9 40 +)4BD9<8)49/*@)'./9404($ .+%9B.($5)./9$L?5$44)*+ ?/)+$4C9)+'/&%)+@9$'*+*B ($'8+*/*@0D9 M);$9 M$A$3 O(8$9 ?5*%&'()*+9 *A9 4?. (8$9'8.+@)+@9%$4)@+9*A9 A5.B$=*5;C9 )(9 '.+9 %$%& (8.(9 $L)4(9 )+9 (8$9 +.(& 4?.'$D9
ノイズ・インデュースト
noise-induced-orde
↓・-#.#"#,/# ↓・-#.#"#,/#
生命
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
bios
-D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
秩序 ↓・-#.#"#,/#
カオス
nomos
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
宇宙
cosmos
caos
ゆらぎ
fluctuation
-D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
形式言語 formal languages
R*+($+(49S
オートマトン automaton
↓・-#.#"#,/#
ASCII 変換 ascii interchange
↓・-#.#"#,/#
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
インフォーメション information
抽象機械 abstract machine
因果
)+')?/$9 *A9 $+()()$49 04($B9 *59 B$'8." $B9)49.+9$L($5+./9 +9*A9*>$5.//9%)4')" B)'4C9?*/)()'4C9.+%9 3>5$N49 '*+'$?(9 *A9 .'$CP9 (85*&@89 (8$9 9(8)49B$'8.+)4BQ49 &'$9 (8$9 >.5).()*+9 &5./9 A*5B9 *A9 (8$9
<85$$9 =*5;49 8.>$9 3$$+9 %$>$/*?$%9 '*55$"causality 4?*+%)+@9(*9(85$$94(.@$49*A9(8$9/*@)'./9404($BC9 .+%9 $.'89 )49 3.4$%9 *+9 %)AA$5$+(9 B$%).9 .+%9 %)AA$5$+(9'*+'$5+4D 形式体系 formal system !"#$%&'()*+ 912.)3'/.)#4)"%4. 9E2??FG&4)+$44H ,"-.//.'0 12.)5%-+)#4)6/78%,#9/.9E#5.B.FI*/)()'4H 1"234(5.'()*+ 12.):#-.9-%'();%/.9,%#9 EJ$(8*%*/*@0F<$'8+*/*@0H 6"7(8$59:*5;4 25'8)($'&5$FK5.?8)'4
ト・オーダー
コヒーレント系
er
再帰 recursion
正規化 regulate
帰納 induction
coherent-system ↓・-#.#"#,/# F)GDC6+)'@D4D2) @87=:+?"(0%&#$%@>&8/ ↓・-#.#"#,/# !"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
自己相似
auto-simulacre
情報力学
information-dynamics
ナーヴァス・システム cognitive theory
免疫系 immune network
オートマトン automaton
↓・-#.#"#,/#
正規化 regulate
形式言語 formal languages
再帰 recursion
抽象機械 abstract machine
↓・-#.#"#,/# -D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
・;.<=&-%#9)
因果 causality
形式体系 formal system
帰納 induction
=3%"4'J=
der
ASCII 変換 ascii interchange
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
スト・オーダー
インフォーメション information
BC#'.6"+*'+*#E'6+ BC#'1%$6/)1'+&+* #2'L&'!"!#$%&' NC6/C'6+'L)+#2'% )O6%;+A'
P"/C6*#/*D"#' 6* $#**6,$' D,2#"' $#,#")*6%,' E"%/ %,'*C#'-'!#./
コヒーレント系
coherent-system ↓・-#.#"#,/# F)GDC6+)'@D4D2) @87=:+?"(0%&#$%@>&8/
↓・-#.#"#,/# !"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
自己相似
auto-simulacre
情報力学
information-dynamics
ナーヴァス・システム cognitive theory
免疫系 immune network
↓・-#.#"#,/#
↓・-#.#"#,/#
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
3611)"2'9),'H";),'ID6,# A8*$%&#$%B<C+.(
不完全性定理 Gödel's incompleteness theorems
自己言及 self-reference
パラドックス para・doxa
)0)
総合命題 synthetic statement
ダブル・バインド double・bind
不完全 incompleteness
+'$#,#")*6%,A' *#;'6+'6,6*6)*K '()*+'$",,M' %,')'+#"6#+'%. '
*+#1. ' 6+' )1+%' N)&M' )+' *C#' /#++' 6+' L)+#2' /+)"."-"(%A
認識 (re)-cognition
連続体仮説 Continuum Hypothesis
分析命題 analytic statement
不可分 indistinction
差延 différance
エクリチュール écriture
錯感覚 illusion
誤読 misreadings
パロール parole
錯視 trompe-l'œil
認識論 epistemology
存在論 ontology
説明のギャップ explanatory gap ↓・-#.#"#,/#
F)GDC6+)'@D4D2) @87=:+?"(0%&#$%@>&8/
認識科学 cognitive theory
経験主義の二つドグマ Two Dogmas of Empiricism
心身問題 mind-body problem
↓・-#.#"#,/# -D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
!"#$%&'#$() $*+)#$,
-(''(.$/0(.('+0$-(.123402+(.$5(.#
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
・C..D08(72.#%E"$$2%&/)
AN0*3)/2,*#)0A
:=;&>)?%@A)B71:/ AI*32,*23+A
C/0;"/&+) D"8"$0;(",& B06*',3 50,*&/6-&'0,
:;&12<218'(:/
3,&$"#/+ K)'#""&D#"
.&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
!"#$%&'(%)"#
6/+/#(,
4/#5
4)#,
!/:$'+,
7%"(8
!"#%&/(%
7'&9/(,
;/()+)%<
()*!&+,-,#.
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
=%>,&$
AN0*+31&,+%O%P20,*#)0A
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
!"#
C,+("%>,1&,/ %>,1#,F
C#/&'-';#&0/
!"#$%&'(")*+,-./0,'1" 50,*&/6-&)7.#&"8"/)+0
56*&0("/
!"#$%&'#
?#,2 @/#,*#-&'0,
F,8"*&0/
4"A1B#
A,$'," :;;$'-#&'0,
E*"/
!"#$
E*"/)F,&"/L#-"
,2 &)I
,2
, O/0
-=)I
5P
-#$) ?0
IE
I!
H&0
NJ
/"
?
F NE N@
FC@ 5!
!I BI
I@
&0/ "
FC@
I@ B
5!
R:S :H
;
:H R:S
EJ
? 0-# $)H
NJ ?
J?
B@
D: ;
5P
;; D: B@J?
H G! :J GB F H C I! )
E*
H 5H
"/
<# N@ NE F 5H H
<?A5P5B:FQ
J
GB
)
!:
I!
HG
F HC
J
2
)I,
,2
<# -=
7)A#1G:
O/0 ,&) I
#
<$0-=-.#',)Z>Y
"/
#
H(#/&)50,&/#-&*
E*
"2)-'&+)'(#3"4 06)96$'&)',):;;4)9#*"2)0,)<$0-=-.'#,>
AF&$+%G3)*),)-A
-,1%" /+D1%>,1E)&%'/+D F1F"&+5
#./) &%.) $#",+,#%0) &%.) 1&2#) &) 3#00#$) ,%4#%0,2,5#.) "0$!40!$#) "6-07&$#)'6.#+8)91#)+&:#$#.)!;) "0$!4!$#) 6-) <=;;) ,") .,--#$#%0) -$6') 01#) =;;) ,%) ,>?) 6$) =%.$6,.8)91#)3&4@)#%.)46.#)6-) 01#)<=;;)$!%")6%)&).#4#%0$&+A ,5#.);##$A06A;##$)%#076$@8)91#) -$6%0) #%.) 46.#) 6-) 01#) <=;;) ,") 6;#$&0#.)3:)BC%D)E68/)F0.
H&0/#3"UFOCHV
I! )
AI*32,*23+%)1%QH((A
#$
J09'$"):;;*
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
HC
.&)/+
B@J?WTG"9X>Y
G
6'<
=%>,&$
J
@)#,
BF
4,/$,
!:
3'?+)(
:,36$#/T!"#-&
EOS.IO
K);!$41&"#.
HG
*+,-,#%
4)?&/&/<
?0-#$)H&0/" NJ?
I@BI!IEJ R:S:H5!FC@ <#-=)I,2
D:;; N@NEF5P B@J?
E*"/
O/0,&)I,2 5HH
・F2#78'()?27-DG"'(72H")0%1"(2&>)/) :$0,3) 7'&.) &.") 2"8"$0;(",&) 0L ) F0@) #,2) XD) *-#,) &"-.,'[6"*4) &.") ;.+*'-#$) ;.",0(",#)',)&.")L6&6/")/"#$)70/$2)7'$$)9") (6-.) (0/") 2'3'&#$'1"24) 20-6(",&"24 #,2) "8",&6#$$+)',&"3/#&"2)7'&.)&.")8'/&6#$)70/$2) &.#&);#/#$$"$*)/"#$'&+)',)/"#$)&'(">) @./063.)*&/""&)-#("/#*)#,2)*#&"$$'&")
-#("/#*) [6'-=$+) (02"$',3) ',) &.") 2"8'-"4) '&) '*) ;0**'9$")&0)6;2#&")',)/"#$)&'(")#,2)96'$2)!"#$%&'( !)"*$&+",!%!))-)".$&/"&/-"%-!)"*$&+>)F,)*6-.)#) 8'/&6#$) -'&+4) 6*"/*) -#,4) #*) ',) /0$"%;$#+',34) (08") #/06,2) &.") -'&+4) 7.'-.) 9"-0("*) #) 0!1-(2*-( 3!%$4"24*$!)$5$30",)!&64%17
'#""&D#"
!"#$
3,&$"#/+
3,&$"#/+
.&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
!"#$%&'(%)"#
K)'#""&D#"
()*!&+,-,#.
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
MP Z6"0"
MNO Y6++67#$"
JKL Y6++67,%D
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
H,++"I G$,&#/-,
Q/-,17(,#/&)"1 7"()/+)R !"#$ [<A?4&%)0#41%6+6D:)'6.#+,%D)4,0:),'&D#/ ]#&+A0,'#)!;.&0,%D/ ^,D1+:),%0#$&40,2#)"64,&+,5,%D);+&0-6$'"8 =44#"")06)0$&%";6$0&0,6%/)"#$2,4#),%-6$'&0,6%8 _#7);60#%0,&+)-6$)3!",%#""8
!!
G$,&#/-, X&446!%0 $9/:;"<#/=#3<*+,>?;@AAA 0*B&"#C"#?/>=%#%/C,#/*#D<E<*F
A[R'
!"#$
ã&#x192;»,%+"&)39%&%H-DF'#2%8$),#'&$'972%&)/) F,)&.'*)#;;4)8#/'06*)-/+;&0-6//",-'"*)-#,)9") 6*"2) #*) &.") 9#*'-) &0=",>) @.") 9#*'-) ;""/%&0%;""/) &/#,*#-&'0,) L6,-&'0,*) ',-$62") -/+;&0-6//",-+) ',8"*&(",&4) $#,2) ;/0;"/&+) &/#,*#-&'0,*) *6-.) #*) $"#*"*) #,2) ;6/-.#*"*4) #,2) -0,*&/6-&'0,) (#&"/'#$) ;6/-.#*"*\) #22'&'0,#$$+4)&.")8,%446 "46 "2&!9-])',-",%
&'8") ("-.#,'*() 7'$$) /"7#/2) 6*"/*) 7'&.) #) &0=",>) :$$)&.")&/#,*#-&'0,*)#/")-0,L'/("2)#,2)"^"-6&"2) 9+)_21!%&"*43&%!*&])8'#)&.")9$0-=-.#',);/0&0% -0$)IAH>FA>
*!&+,-,#.
.&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
!"#$ .&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
3,&$"#/+
()*!&+,-,#.
!"#$%&'(%)"# J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
."8,#1*("#"-< B#E,$% !"#$
*+,-,#%
$E,*+/*HG 6/+/#(,
7%"(8
4/#5
!"#%&/(%
%"#$& )*+,-
OJUS8JT VU8QSW ;&"0)'6%01
.@
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
!"#$%&'( OUP8(J VR8JTW ;&"0)'6%01
6/+/#(,
)*'&C,G A)260#)06@#% A).#",D%)06@#% A)"064@),%2#"0,%D
7%"(8
4/#5 J<
345678)$5
JL
JM
JN
=FF
0+/%
./%'&/*
OPQR8QS
01$2)1
OJJ8JT
I9E G>?
A)46%"0$4!0,6% )A)"064@),%2#"0,%D
!"#%&/(%
.@&'('9</*#$%&'(#!<>(,%G A)2&$,&%4#)&--,$' A)"#++,%D)\)3!:,%D 8<*+#5><*=<'%/&*G A)+&%.);!$41&"# A)+&%.)+#&"# $C<>%#6&*%><'%G A)0$&%"&40,6%)-!+-,+ +'#%0
!"#$
・I"$2>&D0%18('#)?%&$7#8972%&)/)
AH,*2&-%I*32,*23+>S+&-%T)3-/EA
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`*) ',&"$$"-&6#$) ;/0;"/&+4) 7.'-.) -#,) 9") ;6/-.#*"2)#,2)6&'$'1"2)9+)0&."/)6*"/*>):$$)&."*")2#&#)7'$$)96'$2) #) /'0-" :!&!;!2-" 46 " -)-*&%43$*" !%*/$&-*&'%!)" 14:-)2) &.#&)#/")20-6(",&"2)6*',3)IAH>FA)9$0-=-.#',);/0&0-0$>
*+,-,#%
*+,-,#% V"('-,#% !"#$
!"#$ .&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
!"#$%&'(%)"#
*+,-,#%
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
4)?&/&/< K);!$41&"#.
4)#, 4)#,
7'&9/(,
!/:$'+,
;/()+)%<
=%>,&$
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
TU
7'&9/(,
!/:$'+,
;/()+)%<
3/#,+1!'?,
3:)],2#0)M&@#$
QJ)4!"06'#$)$#2,#7" I M6%01+:)Z$,4#`)O(Kc)J8([ I F,"0)Z$,4#`)OJKKKc)Q(8[
?,5#`)1A[')7A[')+A[' =$#&`)S8J' ?0$!40!$#`)ZME <!$&0,6%`)J.&:
B#17%"(8
=%>,&$
(
>%+:);&$0)6-)#+#'#%0")&$#) +,"0#.)&362#
I*/%#$'<@, J#KCL#MC
!"#$
;!$41&"#.
4)?&/&< !"#$%&'(%)"# J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
@)#,
*+,-,#%
C"&8$1 7>/&, !"#$
4)?&/&/<
K);!$41&"#.
=%>,&$
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
TU
@)#,
6/+/#(, A)d#0)06@#%)6%4#);!$41&"#.
=%>,&$
6/+/#(, A)Z&:#.)-6$)601#$")76$@
S'&"8/F/1!'?, ?,5#`)1A[')7A[')+A[' =$#&`)S8J' ?0$!40!$#`)ZME <!$&0,6%`)J.&: C%-6`)91#)6%#)01&0)1&")3##%).#",D%#.)3: ))))))))a&;&%#"#)&$41,0#40Ab,"16)b!$6@&7& (
!"#$
AU#3*2&-%:#*'A !%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
!"#$%&'(%)"# !"#$ 4,/$, .&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$ ()*!&+,-,#.
3'?+)(
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
4,/$,
6'<
*+,-,#%
4)?&/&/<
.&)/+
@"5'+/&
7%/)&$
K)&2&,+&3+#
*X%&/(%"&1;/# J)&2&,+&3+#
6'<
J#.;/@+#/*#O;>'9<=,+#8<*+
.&)/+
J#$<*+#.&-
K);!$41&"#.
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
6')+W J)<&:
!"#$%&'(%)"#
J#.;/@+#/*#8,<=,+#8<*+
@"5'+/& !"#$%&'(% !"#$ N,=/H*# O>&',+;>,G A)D$,.)":"0#')3&"#.)J'e[' A)+,%#)"!$-&4#)46';6"#. ))\)4&;"!+#)-,++#. ↑↓
A);+&%%,%D)&.2,"# A),%0#$,6)&.2,"#
@"5'+/&
=:%)-)R,5
↓ 7"+/&13/#,+ K)&2&,+&3+#
A)"0$!40!$#)2#$,-,#. A);,;#)2#$,-,#. A)#*!,;'#%0)2#$,-,#. ↓
A)46%"0$!40,6%
T,&)9),5
!"#$
A:)0$*32,*#)0>S+&-%T)3-/EA
!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
!"#$%&'(%)"# 3'?+)(
J#6&CE,%,#<*+#.;/@+#/*#O;:@/'#8<*+
!"--'#)%<1 V,$)A# !"#$
!"--'#)%< V,$)A#1 3&"(,5'&,[
・?%HH8&27-D,%+"&)39%&%H-)/)
@."/") #/") (#,+) 2"*'3,) ;/0a"-&*) L0/) ;69$'-)*;#-"*)',)&.")#;;>):L&"/)6*"/)80&',3) 0,)-0(;$"&"2);/0a"-&*4)&.");/0a"-&)7'&.)&.") .'3."*&) ,6(9"/) 0L ) 80&"*) 7'$$) 9") [6'-=$+) -0,*&/6-&"2)0LL$',">)I8"/+)80&"4)/"8'"74)#,2) "^"-6&'0,)'*)-0,L'/("2)#,2)#**6/"2)9+)&.") b21!%&" *43&%!*&b) 0L ) 9$0-=-.#',) IAH>FA>) F,) &.'*) 7#+4) &.") #;;) '*) #) 2"*'3,) ;$#&L0/()&.#&)2'/"-&$+)/"L$"-&*)&.")'2"#)0L )
&.")-'&'1",*> J0/"08"/4) 2&!9-])7'$$) ",&)7"'3.&*)& *0) &.#&) (0/ #&&/#-&"2)&0) H6-.)# $3*-3&$#-" 96'$&)0,)&.")
4=#%9,#N,=/H*,>G
3&"Y,(%
J#=,@,'%#=/%, $%<>%#V&;>#N,=/H* ↓
A<R(-&0&*#)0A
@"5'+/& =:%)-)R,5
↓
A)"0$!40!$#)2#$,-,#. A)#*!,;'#%0)2#$,-,#. A)#%2,$6%'#%0)2#$,-,#.
260#.)3:)!"#$"
↓
'&h6$,0:).#4,",6%g,-)"#+#40#.
↓
46%"0$!40,6%
6/+/#(,
96@:6
↑↓
↓
T"%,
3&"Y,(%
A);+&%%,%D)&.2,"# A),%0#$,6)&.2,"#
↓
.#",D%)06@#%` "1&$#16+.#$)6-)01#)+&%.);$6;#$0:
P)E16'#AJJAJ/)M,%&06A@! )*%>&G
AH((%N0*+31&,+A
T,&)9),5
T"%,W R1
A)D$,.)":"0#')3&"#.)J'e[' A)+,%#)"!$-&4#)46';6"#. ))\)4&;"!+#)-,++#.
Z!3+,4)0#$$&4#)";&4#),%4+!.,%D)Q)"16;"8 I#07##%)()-+66$")&%.)R)-+66$"8
4>,<G############USSC
R<%/&G###############S2T#
$%<>%#V&;>#N,=/H*
R,C</*/*H# 5/C,G#########WX#+<"=#
1!#5,>><',
P<%9,>/*H
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
7/H9#5,>><',
5&Q,>#$9&E
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
4=#%9,#\&%,>G
3&"Y,(%
J#=,@,'%#=/%, ↓
T"%,
260#)7,01)06@#%
↓
'&h6$,0:).#4,",6%g,-)"#+#40#.
6/+/#(,
↓
260#)06@#%` ,%4#%0,2#)"1&$#16+.#$)6-)01#)+&%.);$6;#$0:
T"%,W R1
9$0-=-.#',K*) _,%446 " 46 " )#7#/2)#)&0=",)7'&.)2'LL"/% &0)"8"/+)2"*'3,"/)#,2)80&"/4) /") #,2) (0/") 6*"/*) 7'$$) 9") )&.'*)2"*'3,);$#&L0/(> #)&49-3(;!2-:"-*4341$*" 1-*/!3$21) 0L ) 2"*'3,*) )#;;);$#&L0/()-#,)*;""2)6;)
&.") -'&+`*) (02"/,'1#&'0,) /#&") #,2) 0-3-%!&-"!"14%-":+3!1$*"'%;!3" 2*-3-" ;+" *433-*&$30" &/-" #$%&'!)" !3:"%-!)>
B#(,#%)E, ."8,# @,(>/#)$V,$)A# !"#$
!"#$ T"%,W K"
3&"Y,(%
96@:6
3,&$"#/+
.&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
6/+/#(, P)E16'#AJJAJ/)M,%&06A@!
!"#$%&'(%)"#
()*!&+,-,#.
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
7%"(8
4/#5
*+,-,#%
!"#%&/(%
)*%>&G Z!3+,4)0#$$&4#)";&4#),%4+!.,%D)Q)"16;"8 I#07##%)()-+66$")&%.)R)-+66$"8
4>,<G############USSC
R<%/&G###############S2T#
O>&B,'%#1Y,>
R,C</*/*H# 5/C,G#################S=#
\OZ] ^6JOWNJ \JZM ^6ZW]LM
."%/+1/$$,%$[
';>>,*%#><%,G#KG#S2SMU
1!#5,>><',
P<%9,>/*H
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
7/H9#5,>><',
5&Q,>#$9&E
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
B#("-,[
%9/=#C&*%9
V,$)A#1."8,#[ J#USKZ[U[SU J#USKZ[T[MK
T"%,1."8,#[
!"#A&/%'+/%)"#$I 59,#E>&B,'%#"&;#Y&%,+#9<=#:,,*#=,@,'%,+ V&;#,<>*,+#NWZM#:/%'&/*#
N,%</@
J#USKZ[U[SU J#USKZ[T[MK J#USKZ[T[MK
\LM UW WZ
\PN X KS KW
!"--'#) V,$)A#1 !"#
A:)0$*32,*#)0>S+&-%T)3-/EA
)%<1
#$
A:)0$*32,*#)0>S+&-%T)3-/EA
!"#$
6')+W J)<&: T,&9W)R[W
L#+46'#)06 01#)$#&+/)01#)2,$0!&+/ 01#)%#7)76$+.
3,&$"#/+ K)'#""&D#"
.&/#$/(%)"# 012$$,$%$
6/+/#(,
7%"(8
4/#5
!"#%&/(%
4)#,
7'&9/(,
!/:$'+,
;/()+)%<
3'?+)(
6'<
4,/$,
.&)/+
()*!&+,-,#.
!"#$%&'(%)"#
=%>,&$
J)!%.#$)46%"0$!40,6%
*+,-,#%
@)#,
=%>,&$
4)?&/&/< K);!$41&"#.
!"#$%&'(
%"#$& )*+,-
OUP8(J VR8JTW ;&"0)'6%01
OJUS8JT VU8QSW ;&"0)'6%01
J<
JL
345678)$5
./%'&/* I9E
01$2)1 G>?
0%9,>,;C G9^
JM
JN
.@
TU
=FF
0+/%
OPQR8QS
3/#,+1!'?,
3:)],2#0)M&@#$
QJ)4!"06'#$)$#2,#7"
OJJ8JT OK8KKPQ
I M6%01+:)Z$,4#`)O(Kc)J8([ I F,"0)Z$,4#`)OJKKKc)Q(8[
B#17%"(8
?,5#`)1A[')7A[')+A[' =$#&`)S8J' ?0$!40!$#`)ZME <!$&0,6%`)J.&: C%-6`)GH;#$,#%4#).##;/)]#"06$&0,2#)"+##; (
@"5'+/&
7%/)&$
K)&2&,+&3+#
*X%&/(%"&1;/# J)&2&,+&3+#
7"+/&13/#,+ K)&2&,+&3+#
T,&)9< $%>;'%;>,
KSS^
0];/EC,*% MZ^ Y+66$)?:"0#' Z,;#)?:"0#' G*!,;'#%0) ?:"0#' 4+Y/',
0*Y/>&*C,*% KSS^
3&"Y,(%
96@:6
P)E16'#AJJAJ/)M,%&06A@! )*%>&G Z!3+,4)0#$$&4#)";&4#),%4+!.,%D)Q)"16;"8 I#07##%)()-+66$")&%.)R)-+66$"8
4>,<G############USSC
R<%/&G###############S2T#
$%<>%#V&;>#N,=/H*
R,C</*/*H# 5/C,G#########WX#+<"=#
1!#5,>><',
P<%9,>/*H
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
7/H9#5,>><',
5&Q,>#$9&E
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
f60#` <&0#`)(KJUgJ(gJ[
4+Y/',
↓・-#.#"#,/#
↓・-#.#"#,/#
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
3611)"2'9),'H";),'ID6,# A8*$%&#$%B<C+.(
不完全性定理 Gödel's incompleteness theorems
自己言及 self-reference
パラドックス para・doxa
経験主義の二つドグマ Two Dogmas of Empiricism
ダブル・バインド double・bind
総合命題 synthetic statement
不完全 incompleteness
連続体仮説 Continuum Hypothesis
分析命題 analytic statement
・>'(('&+)0)
不可分 indistinction
=3%"4'R=
錯感覚 illusion
差延 différance
エクリチュール écriture
認識 (re)-cognition
説明のギャップ explanatory gap ↓・-#.#"#,/#
心身問題 mind-body problem
P*'*C#'+);#'*6;#M')+'. *C#'6,26962D)1'E#"/#E 16;6*#2' *%' *C#' E#"+% ),2'6+'L%D,2'*%'L#'.D %&'()/(!)&..#,&'(3
錯視 trompe-l'œil
認識論 epistemology
存在論 ontology
F)GDC6+)'@D4D2) @87=:+?"(0%&#$%@>&8/
認識科学 cognitive theory
誤読 misreadings
パロール parole
BC#' +#/%,2' +*#E' 6+ *C%D$C' *C#' NC%1#' L##,'+#*'DEM'!T2#1U+' *C#%"#;+' 2#;%,+*") %&("!)!"1"$%'%. '#)/C
↓・-#.#"#,/# -D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
+' .)11)/&A' S9#,' .");#N%"4' C)+' '6,/%;E1#*#,#++' )*#' *C#' *+"!",0 C'1%$6/)1'+&+*#;A'
ZF公理系 zf axiomatic system
↓・-#.#"#,/# :1&)'>"6$%$6,# B*$+*%8)(%84 %@>&8/
集合論 Set Theory
濃度 cardinality
↓・-#.#"#,/# -D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
圏論 Category Theory
ブール代数 boolean algebra
束論 lattice
全体論 holism
トポス topos
.%"')"/C6*#/*D"#M' E*6%,'%. '+E)/#'6+' %,)1' E#"+E#/*69#' D11'%. '&-/2&(/0
是ー非 true-false
水槽の脳 brain in a vat
カルテジアン劇場 cartesian theater
シミュレーション仮説 Simulation Hypothesis
クオリア qualia
ZFC公理系 zfc axiomatic system
必ー偶 certainty-possibility
固定指示子 rigid designators
様相論理 modal logic
人間原理 Anthropic Principle ↓・-#.#"#,/#
ホログラフィック原理 Holographic Principle
可能世界 possible world
3)*)"D'Q6"%;)*+D D>+%E7&3+%84 %5"/(8*".&:%!&(+*"&:"/7
消去主義的唯物論 eliminative materialism
↓・-#.#"#,/#
5),6#1'5#,,#** @8#/."8)/#+//%F?=:&"#+$
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
!"#$%&
+,)-.%*/-'0!"#$%&'(")(* 剥キ出シノ生
軟禁都市
12&()/"&$2)&/"&345678459:;
$*35H0/5$
I51-;1?90/5A1N51-?+,0.5CG R-+,5;/51F-.=+>.10;L1/+;/-+>?G M793-?+;75;.1-?1.3>,L15E53LF=535G1
$M;.3+C>/.-+;$
$Q0/=-;53L・J>@;0,?・J90/5$
830E5,-;@1 .=3+>@=1 .=51 /-.LA1 F51 0351 H031 ,5??1 H3551 .=0;1F51.=-;SG T>31 N5=0E-+31 /+;?.0;.,L1 -;.530/.?1 F-.=1 8#';;27) (2<=8$>)$2<&$>)827+"8)?'7=2&"$>)"("@'8%#$>)7%##21%#$>) ;"&7"$A 8=+?510351.=51?'7=2&"#-9$2<&'($9$.'7"1.=0.1N3>' .0,,L1 C5.537-;51 +>31 C-35/.-+;A1 F=-/=A1 =+F5E53A1 F51.0S51H+31@30;.5CG U=5;1.=51F=+,51?L?.571?>//>7N?1.+101.+.0,-.03-' 0;1 9+F53A1 .=5?51 70/=-;5?$?-@;0,?A1 NL1 @-E-;@1 .=51 -;/+335/.1C-35/.-+;A1/0;1H+37101/-3/,51?>33+>;C-;@1 H+31.=51?95/-H-/1.03@5.!.=51+;51F=+1F-,,1N51-793-?' +;)1F-.=+>.1=-?1S;+F,5C@5G 8=-?15;/-3/,575;.1-?12&@2$26("G1,#'&$.'#"&8)2$%('B 82%&A J+A1;+170..531.=+?5195C5?.3-0;?1N5=-;C1.=51H5;/5A1 +31.=+?5190??-;@1E5=-/,5?1+;1.=51+E5390??1GGG 8=+?5195+9,5A1.=0.1?90/5A10,.=+>@=1-%5)7'&)$""1-.A1 L+>17'&)&"@"#)#"'7=1-.10;L7+35A1F=-/=A1=+F5E53A1 L+>1F-,,1&%8)"@"&)&%827"G 8=-?1-?1-793-?+;75;.G1
ĺ&#x2014;
Grammatical Misdelivery
$I0/S@3+>;C1[12=030/.53?$
F'7+<#%5&1)G28-/ ,%+-% G='#'78"#/ H%58=)I/
8=51/+,,5@51?.>C5;.A1/+7935=5;C1?>33+>;C-;@?1-;.>-.-E5,L
J2#(),/)
8=51@-3,H3-5;C1+H1L+>.=1\A1/+;?.0;.,L175??0@5?1\
0"8#%)E8';;/ 8=51C5?-@;531+H1.=51?.0.-+;19+?.53 !'$$"&<"#/ 8=517-CC,5'0@5170;1F=+190??5?1\1NL1-;1.=51?.0.-+; C26#'#2'&/)
M?1H07-,-031F-.=1.=515Z0/.1,+/0.-+;1+H150/=1N++S1-;.=51,-N303L
K(1"#(-/
U0;C53?1-;1.=51,-N303L10,7+?.15E53LC0LA193+H5??-+;10;C10@51>;S;+F
G=2(1/
8=51;0>@=.L10;C1;+-?L1/=-,C1-;1.=51?=+99-;@170,,
G5$8%?"#/)) 8=519035;.1+H1.=51;+-?L1/=-,C
$630701*,+.?$
F;
8=51/+>;.3L1.=0.1C5/,035?1.=51.+.0,1H355C+71 0;C10N?5;/51+H1/5;?+3?=-91H+31.=51/-.-45;1?>3359.-' .-+>?,L170-;.0-;?10;103/=-.5/.>30,1?L?.571.+1-C5;' .-HLA1 -;C>/5A1 0;C1 5E5;.>0,,L1 -793-?+;1 .=51 .03@5.G1 8=-?103/=-.5/.>30,1?L?.571/+;?-?.?1+H1.=3551N>-,C' -;@?O1P-N303LA1J.0.-+;A1J=+99-;@1Q0,,G ・C26#'#-)O 8=51?.>C5;.1,++S?1H+3101?95/-H-/1N++S1-;1.=51 ,-N303L1NL1/0.0,+@1;>7N53G1VE5;1.=+>@=1=51?55?1 .=51 N++S?=5,H1 F-.=1 .=51 N++S1 =51 F0;.?1 H3+71 01 C-?.0;/5A1 =51 /0;W.1 H-;C1 .=51 90.=1 .+1 0//5??1 .=0.1 N++S?=5,HG1X51-?18#'.."1)2&)')72#75('82&<)?'D")%;) 7'8'(%<)&5?6"#$G ・E8'82%&)/ M;1.=51?>NF0LA1.=51?.>C5;.1/0;1?5510;C1=5031 90??53?'NL10,,103+>;CA1N>.1=51-?10/.>0,,L1?59030.5C1 H3+71.=5710;C1,5C1.+1.=51/+33-C+31+H1-793-?+;-;@1 ?90/51.=0.1/+;;5/.?1.+1.=51?=+99-;@170,,G1I>.1=51 C+5?;W.1 ;+.-/51 =51 -?1 0/.>0,,L1 4'(+2&<) ') #%58") 12;;"#"&8);#%?)8=")%8="#$G ・E=%..2&<)0'(()/) U=5;1 .=51 ?.>C5;.1 033-E5?1 0.1 .=51 ?=+99-;@1 70,,A15E53L.=-;@1?557?1.+1N51.=51?075A1N>.1;+1+;51 -?1.=535G1Y+1H,++31=0?15Z-.?A1?.0-3?A1F-;C+F?G18=51 F=+,51 ?90/5A1 F=-/=1 /0;1 +;,L1 N51 /+;;5/.5C1 NL1 5,5E0.+3?A1 -?1 ,-S51 <2'&8) ?'7=2&"#-G1 8=-?1 @-0;.1 70/=-;53L12?.#2$%&$1.=51?.>C5;.A1N>.1.=51/,+.=5?1 0;C1@3+/53-5?1/0;1H>,H-,,1=-?1N0?-/1C0-,L1;55C?G
MA)C26#'#-
LA)E8'82%&
]+>.=1\
目 “Nothing, I got distracted by this poster, and I just stopped to take a look at it for a while.” "This poster ... I cut and pasted it. Recently ... there are more passengers, such as ... cannot cross the yellow line ..." The staff mumbles some non-sense words. As the staff starts staring up and down while his voice gets lower and harder to hear,, he seems to behave more and more strangely.
]+>.=1\
The youth simply nods and walks away.
<=0>?(/&/<@ F)64)42$@6>%6,286)%%6"86#3%6*%#+/6)#2#"/8@6#3/)%60%8)%$(6 2++285%063%2?(69"$$2+)67$/,:6/4+6)"53#-6G)9%,"2$$(62;#%+6 #4+8"85626HI<0%5+%%@6#3%)%69"$$2+)6>"$$67%,/*%6#3%6)"53#6 72++"%+@6>3",362,#42$$(63"0%)6#3%6)9%,"2$6+%,32+5%+62806 #",:%#652#%)67%3"806#3%*-
'()*%#+",-
1"$$2+/7)#+4,#%06)"53# #3+/4536)"53# 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 6/7)#+4,#69"$$2+ 9"$$2+ 9/)"#"/8
But he sees books with random numbers. “Is nobody going to order these b
{
E8';;
௵
]+>.=1\
Ⴆ
8/8% 7288%067//:) ,288/#6+%2,3 8/+*2$67//:) 8/+*2$67//:) ,/++"0/+
「NDC:Z:9:310」
“Sir, may I help you?”
「NDC:Z:9:309」
E8';;
The youth F arrives at the station As soon as he walks into the lobb cally layered up, displaying the boo After finding the catalogue numb numbers shown on the shelves to the numbers of the books on the "309 ... 310, um ... this is 311"
「NDC:Z:9:256」
]+>.=1\
The passenger walks past F in front of the pillar. "...hmmm....it should be in that direction ..." "... over there ... no, wrong again" The man seems to be mumbling to himself, walking away from the bustle of the station. 画 “This guy must be confused by the new station…”
]+>.=1\
柱
!'$$"&<"#
柱
The young man F walks down from the escalator to the ticket machine. The subway station is finally renovated after have been under year-long construction. Today, it looks completely new. "Such a strange poster, " the young man says. The pillars have their edges, instead of their faces, looking out onto people passing by as if the pillars are hiding something. "Seems like a few more pillars have been added."
柱
]+>.=1\
<=0>?(/&/<@ '4,368%2#$(628 #3%64)42$6),%8% #"/8)6 "86 5//06 )()#%*2#",6)#/+ ,"+,4$2#"/867%3
NA)C26#'#-
and walks into the library entrance. y, the youth F sees the storeys neatly and symmetriok collections in well classification. ber of the book he wants, the Youth F follows the o track down the location of the book. He glances at bookshelf next to the computer and murmurs,
K(1"#(-
Suddenly, an old man whispers behind the youth, "I have given up everything to build this enternal maze with countless books ..." As he is confused by the old man's inexplicable words, the Youth F recieves a text message: "What are you up to?"
J2#(), ]+>.=1\
編号
{
{
「NDC:Z:9:312」
「NDC:Z:9:311」
「NDC:Z:9:258」
「NDC:Z:9:257」
「NDC:A-Z」
numbers sit in between those that have adjacent
1F-5F
「NDC:Z:9:000」 場所 : 所蔵中
{
books properly?”
]+>.=1\
./0%-
806)(**%#+",2$$(6$2(%+%06496)#/+%()6")6 %6"86$"7+2+(628060")9$2()6#3%67//:6,/$$%,< ,$2))";",2#"/8-6 =/>%?%+@6 #3")6 )%%*"85$(6 +%()62,#42$$(63"0%6#3%6A$%"8<B/##$%6*2C%6 3"80-
"I am in the library and looking for the book I told you about before." After sending the text, the youth sees a sign not far away. He walks over to take a closer look at it, which only says ... NDC: A-Z 1F-5F...
ᖑ
8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ,/0%6/; 67288%0 0")/+0%+6,/0% 8/+*2$6,/0%
“Oh…this is not helpful at all ... maybe I’ll have to search on the machine again.”
<=0>?(/&/<@ '/*%67//:)6>"#36+280/*6,2#2$/5684*7%+)62+%6)"##"856 "867%#>%%86#3/)%6#32#632?%620D2,%8#684*7%+)-6!3")6")6 8/#6 286 "8,"0%8#2$6 *"))-6 '%?%+2$6 ,"+,4$2#%06 ,2#2$/56 84*7%+)6 "8)%+#6 "8#/6 %2,36 /#3%+-6 ./8)%E4%8#$(@6 8/6 *2##%+6 #+2,:"856 0/>86 >3",36 ,2#2$/56 84*7%+@6 #3%6 "80"?"042$6>"$$6/8$(672,:6#/6#3%6)#2+#69$2,%-
PA)C26#'#-
OA)C26#'#]+>.=1\
As the youth types the book title into the search machine, he receives another text.
J2#(),
"Hmm ... what's the title of the book?"
]+>.=1\
Before the youth can reply to her, the computer starts beeping suddenly. The noise awakens the quiet library. C26#'#2'&
{
{
「NDC:Z:8:100」
「NDC:Z:9:000」
「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」 「NDC:Z:9:000」
As the noise goes off, the librarian comes and hurriedly presses a few keys on the keyboard ... "I’m very sorry. The computer has been having problems recently. This is already the fourth or fifth time this month. It is very troublesome...and um... you’re looking for this book. It is on this shelf on this floor." The librarian points to a bookshelf next on the third floor.
The youth follows the order of the stairs. The bookshelves and tables fill the The catalogue numbers of the b jumping order.
Then he said, as he nodded in confidence, “Maybe a little unclear, but you will definitely find it along with the catalogue number." ]+>.=1\
8/8% 7288%067//:) 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/+*2$67//:) 8/+*2$67//:) 8/8%
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%6 )"586 /86 #3%6 #3"+06 ;$//+6 ,286 7%6 )%%86 ;+/*6 26 0")#28,%-6B4#6#3%6#3"+06;$//+6")62,#42$$(63"00%867(6#3%6 *2C%6 ,"+,4$2#"/86 72)%06 /86 #3%6 #/9/$/5",2$6 )329%6 /; 6 A$%"8<B/##$%-6!3%6#3"+06;$//+6,2867%6)%%8@674#6,2868/#6 7%62,,%))%0
'%%:-
':"9ᛔ
"Okay, thank you so much."
8/8% 7288%067//:) 8/8% 7288%067//:) ,288/#6+%2,3 /#3%+67//:) /#3%+67//:) ,/++"0/+
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%6*2C%6,"+, 3"00%86 7%3"80 )#/+%()-6B(64)"8 3%"53#60";;%+%8 28(*/+%-
QA)C26#'#-
e catalogue number on the shelves and walks up the
Tracking down this jumping and chaotic catalogue number, the youth arrived at the “3rd floor” that the librarian just pointed at, then he starts to search for the book on the shelf. But no matter how he tries, he cannot find the book in this jumping order.
「NDC:Z:8:378」 「NDC:Z:8:289」 「NDC:Z:8:110」 「NDC:Z:8:567」 「NDC:Z:8:457」 「NDC:Z:8:389」 「NDC:Z:8:378」 「NDC:Z:8:109」 「NDC:Z:8:788」 「NDC:Z:8:677」 「NDC:Z:8:355」 「NDC:Z:8:287」 「NDC:Z:8:108」 「NDC:Z:8:711」 「NDC:Z:8:631」 「NDC:Z:8:347」 「NDC:Z:8:266」 「NDC:Z:8:107」 「NDC:Z:8:458」 「NDC:Z:8:367」 「NDC:Z:8:298」 「NDC:Z:8:564」 「NDC:Z:8:106」 「NDC:Z:8:701」 「NDC:Z:8:681」 「NDC:Z:8:578」 「NDC:Z:8:302」 「NDC:Z:8:105」 「NDC:Z:8:678」 「NDC:Z:8:589」 「NDC:Z:8:478」 「NDC:Z:8:345」 「NDC:Z:8:104」 「NDC:Z:8:478」 「NDC:Z:8:456」 「NDC:Z:8:543」 「NDC:Z:8:221」 「NDC:Z:8:103」 「NDC:Z:8:456」 「NDC:Z:8:234」 「NDC:Z:8:542」 「NDC:Z:8:102」 「NDC:Z:8:543」 「NDC:Z:8:254」 「NDC:Z:8:241」 「NDC:Z:8:101」 「NDC:Z:8:342」 「NDC:Z:8:542」 「NDC:Z:8:101」
e staircase, which almost looks like a study room. book in bookshelves are still increasing but in the
]+>.=1\
“Did anyone borrow it?" The youth looks around with confusion, but when he looks downstairs, he was frightened to notice the floor he came is fourth, not the third floor. "Obviously I walks up from the second floor? Did I miss any entrance?" When the youth is about to turn back to the staircase, he meets the old man again.
{
「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」 「NDC:Z:8:100」
"If this library has a central floor, it will exist below this floor."
]+>.=1\
"Huh? What does that mean”
K(1"#(-
"Let’s say, how can we not doubt where we are right now?”
]+>.=1\
"...Uh" The old man seems to attempt to express something, but is so hard to understand. However, today is full of a series of strange things. The youth is too tired to think too much about this old man.
."+,$%-
,4$2#"/8672)%06A$%"8<B/##$%6")69%+;%,#$(6 06 )%%*"85$(6 )(**%#+",2$$(6 $2(%+%06 496 856#3%6)#2"+,2)%62)6#3%6)#40(6+//*@6#3%6 8,%6/; 6#3%6)#2"+)6>"$$68/#67%6%2)"$(68/#",%06
K(1"#(-
8/8% 7288%067//:) 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ,(,$%6,/++"0/+ 8/8%
<=0>?(/&/<@ B(6 #3%6 )/93")#",2#%06 %8#+28,%6 /; 6 #3%6 )#2"+,2)%@6 #3%6 >3/$%6$"7+2+(6")60"?"0%06"8#/6#>/692+#)-6!3%6;+/8#692+#6 ")6 #3%6 *2C%6 ,"+,4$2#"/8@6 >3"$%6 #3%6 72,:6 92+#6 ")6 #3%6 8/+*2$6)92,%6;/+602"$(64)%-
TA)C26#'#The youth goes back to the staircase, but doesn’t find any other exits. “Keeping Track down the catalogue numbers, I will definitely find the book” He goes back to the 2nd floor, He follows the catalogue numbers carefully, he walks up the stairs...he walks down the stairs...continue...continue...continue He believe he will definitely reach that floor with the book he want. "But ... is this the first place, the first floor?" At this time, the youth sees that librarian again, but when he noticed the youth, the librarian suddenly walks away. At this time, the phone rings. He recieves another text.
J2#(),
"Did you find the book?"
]+>.=1\
"No, I tracked down the catalogue number, but finally back to the start place. The whole library is like a circulated maze.
J2#(),
"Maybe you can go to the big bookstore in the mall to find your book?"
]+>.=1\
"Yeah, that is a good idea.”
J2#(),
"But you must be tired today, you can go there somedays later.”
]+>.=1\
"Yah"
K(1"#(-
The old man keeps observing the youth secretly for a long time. He murmurs "These two contrast each other like a mirror ..."
{
1
2
{
]+>.=1\
UA)0'((
「NDC:Z:9:000」
G=2(1
The child is holding a book, and po books on the bookshlef. "Mom, look, there's another book
G5$8%?"#
The child's mother suddenly gets "Come back, put the book back im Apparently being frightened, the c
號
The youth feels a little strange. Af through the gap. There is indeed around through that gap but did n “Should I look for the book there Eventually, the youth looks for the and he did not reach the space be On the way back, he meets the c customer glances at the youth, and
]+>.=1\
The youth sends a text to his girlf "I didn't find that book"
J2#(),
"Did you find it carefully”
]+>.=1\
"I have looked for it almost every
J2#(),
“So strange, it was there before"
]+>.=1\
"Before ... when?"
J2#(),
“I didn't remember, some days ago
]+>.=1\
"Strange, I will check back a few d
1%%9-
8/8% 8/+*2$67//:) %8#+28,% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/+*2$67//:) 8/8%
<=0>?(/&/<@ L80%+6 #3%6 ,"+,4$2#%06 ,2#2$/56 84*7%+6 2806 *2C%6 ,"+,4$2#"/86/; 6)#/+%()@66#3%6"80"?"042$6>"$$6,/8)#28#$(6)%%6 #3%6M+06;$//+@674#6,288/#6;"806#3%692#362,,%))6#/6"#-
A few days later, the youth com station. The bookstore in the mall As soon as the youth enter the bo
G=2(1 ]+>.=1\
{
J%#4+8
3
]+>.=1\
ᙼ
")/$2#%6)3%$; 8/8% 9%%96)"53# 7//:6)3%$; 7//:6)3%$; ")/$2#%062+%2
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%6 ,/**/0 4)42$6 7//:)3% "*9+")/86)92,% 7%3"806#3%6,+%?
VA)E8'82%&
mes to the shopping mall which located above the l has the largest selection of books in this city. ookstore, he sees a naughty child by the bookshelf
]+>.=1\
oints at one narrow crevice between in between the
kstore behind this shelf."
angry, dragging him back, and shouted at him, mmediately!" child trembles and puts that book back.
fter the child left, he takes that book out and looks another room behind the gap. However, he looks not see any customer there… e?” e book in the store for a long time but didn't find it, ehind that gap as well… customer near the entrance. Dragging her child, the d leaves in a hurry.
o perhaps”
days later.”
0"#(6 )3%$; 6 ")6 26 )/+#6 /; 6 )%92+2#"/8-6 !3%6 %$; 6 ,286 )%92+2#%6 #3%6 +%54$2+6 )92,%6 2806 %6"86#3%6)3/99"856*2$$-6!3%6)92,%63"80)6 %?",%62+%62,#42$$(6#3%6"*9+")/86)92,%-
RK##%#/99)I%#6211"&S (It's unlucky enough) "If there is any problem with the machine, please use the recharger on the other side.” Suddenly someone speaks behind him. the youth is startlee and looks back. It is the station staff that he has encountered before. The staff points at the pillar behind that showy poster,
E8';;
2 4
機
4
3 1
K/>8-
{
{ { { { { { {
corner”
{障 {障 {障 { {障 {障 {障
{
friend
crevice A few days later, when the youth is on his way heading to the shopping mall by subway, he is blocked by the ticket gate because of insufficient balance of his metro card. "I just charged the money yesterday" Confused by this insufficiency, the youth goes in front of the recharger ... After inserting the card into the machine, he sees:
ᨀ 92#3 ;%8,% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% %E4"9*%8# %E4"9*%8# %E4"9*%8#
<=0>?(/&/<@ N8,%6 #3%6 "80"?"042$6 ")6 "0%8#";"%06 2)6 #3%6 #2+5%#@6 3")6 *%#+/6,2+06>"$$67%67$/,:%0-6O3%86#3%6#2+5%#6#+("856#/6 +%,32+5%@6#3%6%++/+6/; 6#3%6+%,32+5%+6>"$$6;/+,%63"*6#/6 4)%6#3%6+%,32+5%+6/86#3%672,:)"0%6/; 6#3%69"$$2+-6!3%86 #3%6 #2+5%#6 >"$$6 %P"#6 ;+/*6 #3%6 #",:%#6 52#%6 8%2+6 #32#6 72,:)"0%6+%,32+5%+-6!3%6)92,%62,,%))%)6#/6#3")672,:)"0%6 #",:%#6*2,3"8%6")6#3%6"*9+")/86)92,%-
LLA)E8'82%&
LWA)E8'82%&
]+>.=1\
]+>.=1\
These densely arranged pillars block the sight. "Can I also exit from this side?"
E8';;
"Of course, there is an instruction map at the bottom of poster"
]+>.=1\
Looking carefully at the poster, the youth finds a small station map. However, the printing has been rubbed many times, is hard to see. (This reminds the youth the previous scene of the passenger) "...hmmm....it should be in that direction ..." "... over there ... no, wrong again" Thinking about that weird passenger, the youth goes to the oppsite side of the pillar. There are truly a recharger and ticket machines, After recharging, the youth gets out of the ticket gate, and notices this is an exit that he has not walked through before. There is a station office separated him from the space he used to pass by. He still can see a bustling crowd behind the window of the station office. It seems that the station did not have such a place before renovation. When thinking about this, the youth almost hits a passerby who comes down from the escalator. The youth walks up the escalator, and receives a text from his girlfriend:
械
J2#(),
"Where are you now?"
]+>.=1\
“I am heading to that bookstore in the mall"
J2#(),
"Last time you didn't find that book, so I'll also look for it there this time. See you later in the mall."
]+>.=1\
“See you later”
92#3 ;%8,% 8/8% 8/8% "804,%6%E4"9*%8# "804,%6%E4"9%*#8 %E4"9*%8# 8/8% %E4"9*%8#
<=0>?(/&/<@ O3%86 #3%6 9"$$2+)6 #4+86 HI<285$%@6 #3%(6 >"$$6 7$/,:6 #3%6 )"53#6;+/*6/86)"0%@674#654"0%6#3%6)"53#6;+/*628/#3%+6 )"0%62#6#3%6)2*%6#"*%-6!3%6+%54$2+6)92,%62806"*9+")/86 )92,%62+%60"?"0%067(6#3%6)#2#"/86/;;",%@62806#3%6%),2$2< #/+6"86;+/8#6/; 6#3%6#2+5%#6>"$$6$%2063"*6#/6#3%6"*9+")/86 )92,%6/86#3%6Q806;$//+-6!3%65$2))6>2$$6/; 6#3%6/;;",%6 %827$%)6#3%6#2+5%#6#/6)%%628063%2+6/#3%+69%/9$%62+/4806 3"*-6 !3%6 #2+5%#6 >"$$6 8/#6 8/#",%6 3")6 )92,%6 ")6 2$+%20(6 ")/$2#%06;+/*6/#3%+)-
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨貨貨貨 貨貨貨貨貨 貨 貨貨 貨貨貨貨貨 貨貨貨貨 貨貨貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨 貨 貨貨 貨貨 貨 貨貨
貨貨 貨貨 貨貨 貨 貨貨 貨貨
{入 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
N7)#+4,#-
GE4"9@%*#ೞ
After taking the escalator up to convenience stores. "Seems like... this is also...the oppo Those convenience stores aroun almost impossible to distinguish th "...Em... The shopping mall should
ᢚ 92#3 8/8% )#/+% )#/+% 8/8% 8/8% "804,%62+%2 8/8% 8/8%
貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨貨
貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
<=0>?(/&/<@ F;#%+65%##"856/4 #3%6 %),2$2#/+6 > %),2$2#/+6 2,,%) ;$//+@6>3",36")6 ;$//+@62806")/$2#
LMA)E8'82%& the second floor, here is the place surrounded by
]+>.=1\
osite side of where I used to pass by ..." nd the youth make such a symmetrical space that he direction ... be …em…looks like ... in this direction ..."
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨
貨貨 貨 貨貨 貨貨 貨貨 貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨 貨 貨貨 貨貨 貨 貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨 貨貨貨
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
{入
{
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
{
入
貨 貨 貨 貨 貨 貨
K42$-
4#6/; 6#3%6#",:%#652#%@6#3%6#2+5%#6>2$:)6496 >3",36 ")6 #3%6 /8$(6 %P"#6 ;/+6 3"*-6 !3")6 ))%)6 #/6 #3%6 "*9+")/86 )92,%6 /; 6 #3%6 Q806 6$/,2#%06"86#3%6,%8#%+692+#6/; 6#3%6Q806 2#%067(6#3%6,/8?%8"%8#6)#/+%62+/480-6
Suspiciously, the youth is hesitant to move forward. After passing the convenience store, a familiar corridor extended ahead. But at the end of corridor, there is no stairs that leads to the ground, but only an elevator in front of him.
ӑ 92#3 8/8% )#/+% 8/+*2$62+%2 8/8% 8/8% "804,%62+%2 8/8% 8/8%
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%69%+;%,#6)(**%#+",6,+/))"8569$286/; 6#3%6Q806;$//+6 ,/8;4)%)6 #3%6 #2+5%#R)6 )%8)%6 /; 6 0"+%,#"/8@6 /7),4+%)6 )92#"2$69%+,%9#"/8-6!>/6,/++"0/+)6/; 6#3%6,+/))"8562+%6 #3%6+%54$2+6)92,%@6>3"$%628/#3%+6#>/6,/++"0/+)62+%6#3%6 "*9+")/86)92,%-6S+/*6#3%6,%8#%+6/; 6#3%6Q806;$//+@6#3%6 /8$(6#>/6%P"#)62+%6#/65/6#3+/4536#3%6,/8?%8"%8#6)#/+%@6 >3",36")6#3%6"*9+")/86)92,%-
LOA)0'((
LNA)E8'82%& ]+>.=1\
]+>.=1\
When the elevator goes up to the A little startled by this, the youth quiet today. The youth walks forward slowly. T around him reflect each other, wh Q - 3 3 + 3
"This elevator is familiar, I use it all the time, but still something weird. No one is here, also where are the stairs that can walk up to the ground? Is this really the corridor that I used to pass?" Before the youth can think too much about the current situation, the elevator door suddenly opened. "Anyway go to the bookstore in the mall first" The youth walks in and presses the button.
{
The corridor extends forward, bu quiet and scary. At the end of the Everything is familiar but still som
{入
{
92#3 8/8% %E4"9*%8# 8/8% "804,%6%E4"9*%8# "804,%6%E4"9*%8# 8/8% %E4"9*%8# 8/8%
"Where are you? I am on the first
]+>.=1\
" I'm also here, but I didn’t see any
J2#(),
"Only the first floor is selling cloth
]+>.=1\
"Right, I know. It is so weird. Mayb
J2#(),
"Fine."
N7)#2,$%-
G$%?2#/+హ
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%6 #2+5%#6 ")6 8/#6 /8$(6 ,/8;4)%06 7(6 #3%6 0")/+0%+%06 )%8)%6/; 60"+%,#"/8674#62$)/67(6#3%6;2*"$"2+6;%%$"856/; 6#3%6 ,/++"0/+)-6B%,24)%6#>/6,/++"0/+)6/; 6+%54$2+6)92,%62806 "*9+")/86 )92,%6 +%)%*7$%6 %2,36 /#3%+-6 B4#6 #3%+%6 2+%6 7/#36%$%?2#/+62806)#2"+)@6>3",362,,%))%)6#/6#3%65+/480@6 "86+%54$2+6)92,%@6>3"$%6#3%+%62+%6#3%6/8$(6%$%?2#/+62#6 #3%6 %806 /; 6 "*9+")/86 )92,%@6 >3",36 2,,%))%)6 #/6 #3%6 )3/99"856*2$$627/?%6#3%6)#2#"/8-6
J2#(),
ᨦ 8/8% 8/+*2$62+%2 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ")/$2#%062+%2 ,/**/0"#"%) %$%?2#/+
<=0>?(/&/<@ G2,36;$//+6)%9 )92,%6 0";;%+%8 ,/**/0"#(6)3 7(6)3/>,2)%628
LPA)0'((
e first floor, and it suddenly stopped and opened. h gets out. The shopping mall is as usual but is very
]+>.=1\
Those neat counters show windows and the mirrors hich makes the space look especially wide,
{
鏡
The youth looks around. There are no stairs, no doors. The only exit seems to be this elevator. No other choice, the youth have to wait for this elevator open. “It is so slow. Are there so many people using the elevator for such a long time?” After a long time waiting, the elevator finally arrives at the first floor. But it seems like something wrong with the elevator, the door doesn’t open for a while. Finally, the door opens, but nobody comes out "What? I have been for a long time, but nobody was actually in the elevator? What's going on?" Everything seems to be so weird today. The youth presses the button and head to the bookstore on the third floor.
ut nobody there. The whole space turns out to be e corridor is only another elevator. mething different. At this time, the youth receive a call.
{
yone. Are we on the same floor?"
,
; {入
{
{入
t floor the clothing shop”
hes”
be I'm lost, let's meet at the third-floor bookstore."
K//+-
92+2#%)6#3%6+%54$2+6)92,%62806"*9+")/86 8#$(6 72)%06 /86 0";;%+%8#6 #(9%)6 /; 6 #3%6 3%$;-6"-%-6,$/#3"856)3/9)60"?"0%6#3%6)92,%)6 806*"++/+-6
8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ")/$2#%062+%2 %$%?2#/+ %$%?2#/+
<=0>?(/&/<@ K/47$%60//+)6%$%?2#/+60"?"0%)6#3%6,"+,4$2#"/86/; 6#3%6 8/+*2$6 9%/9$%6 2806 #3%6 #2+5%#-6 N8%6 0//+6 ;2,%)6 #3%6 +%54$2+6)92,%@6>3"$%628/#3%+60//+6;2,%)6#3%6"*9+")/86 )92,%-6 O3%86 8/+*2$6 9%/9$%6 4)%6 #3%6 %$%?2#/+@6 #3%6 %$%?2#/+6>"$$6/8$(6/9%86#3%6)"0%6;2,"856+%54$2+6)92,%@6 2806?",%6?%+)2-6!34)$(@68/+*2$69%/9$%62806#2+5%#67/#36 ,2864)%6#3%6%$%?2#/+6>"#3/4#68/#","856%2,36/#3%+-
LTA)0'((
]+>.=1\
However, the elevator skips the third floor and stops on the fifth floor. "What wrong with this elevator?" Getting out of the elevator, the youth sees the two sides of the corridor are full of furniture, only left a narrow passageway. Still only an elevator is at the end of the corridor. It is a furniture store, but there are some stains on the bed, seem to be used. "Has anyone ever slept here, it's so disgusting..."
障 障障 障障 障 障障 障 障障 障障障障障障 障 障障 障障 障障 障 障 障 障障 障障障障障障障障 障 障 障 障障 障 障 障 障 障 障 障障 障障 障障 障障障 障障 障障 障 障障 障障 障障
8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8%
<=0>?(/&/<@ S4+8"#4+%6)3/9)6)%92+2#%6#3%6)92,%6>"#36)#2,:"8567"56 ;4+8"#4+%6 /86 #>/6 )"0%)6 /; 6 #3%6 ,/++"0/+-6 !3%6 7%06 ")6 ,$%2+$(67%%864)%0@67%,24)%6/#3%+6#2+5%#632)6+%)#%063%+%-6 !3%6,/**/0"#"%)6"86#3%6)3/99"856*2$$6/;;%+6#3%672)",6 8%,%))"#"%)6/; 6$";%-
No matter how he presses on the his requests, the elevator seems to youth to. "What is going on?" Those mirrors, shop windows, fu the corridor. The long and narrow the elevators. The place now look
{入
{ {入{ '>2)#":2-
',+%%8ᱬ
障 障障 障障 障 障障障障障 障障 障障 障障障障障 障 障 障障 障障障障障障障障障 障障 障 障障 障 障 障 障 障障 障障 障 障 障 障 障障 障 障 障障 障 障障 障障 障障
]+>.=1\
{
LQA)0'((
ҟ 92#3 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ")/$2#%062+%2 %$%?2#/+ %$%?2#/+ %$%?2#/+
<=0>?(/&/<@ !3%6 >3/$%6 "* ,/88%,#%067(6% "*9+")/862806+ )92,%)-6!3%+%6 28069/)"#"/86#3 #/60")/+0%+6#3% ,2862,,%))6#/62 ,/**/0"#"%)6"8 02"$(68%%0)-6!3 ;/+6"*9+")/8*%
LUA)0'((
e button of the floor he wants to go, irresponsive to o have already decided where it is going to lead the
]+>.=1\
urniture....different commodities block each side of w passageways on each floor are connected only by ks like a giant machinery connected by elevators.
{ { 入
{ {
J2#(), ]+>.=1\ J2#(), ]+>.=1\
J2#(), ]+>.=1\
{
1%%9-
{入
*9+")/86 )92,%)6 2+%6 26 5"28#6 $27(+"8#36 %$%?2#/+)-6!3%6,/**/0"#(6)3%$?%)60"?"0%6 +%54$2+6)92,%)@674#62$)/6*"++/+6#3%)%6#>/6 2+%6#>/6"*9+")/86)92,%)6/86%2,36;$//+@6 3%*62)6#3%6)329%6/;6'>2)#":2U V6"86/+0%+6 %6#2+5%#R)6)%8)%6/;60"+%,#"/8-6!3%6#2+5%#6 2$$6"*9+")/86)92,%)67(6%$%?2#/+@62806#3%6 86#3%6)3/99"856*2$$6,286;4$;"$$63")672)",6 34)$(@6#3%6)3/99"856*2$$6")6#3%6"0%2$69$2,%6 %8#-
J2#(), ]+>.=1\
ᙼ )"53# 7//:6)3%$; 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% 8/8% ,/**/0"#"%) ,/**/0"#"%) ")/$2#%062+%2
Eventually, the elevator stops on the third floor. “ I’ve been to this bookstore last time” The youth looks around, searching for his girlfriend ... "This is the bookshelf where I saw that noisy child last time” The youth gets closer to the shelf, and suddenly notices some familiar words on a book. "Ah! This is the book I want!" As he takes the book out from the shelf, he sees a narrow crevice in the shelf, with lights shining through. Looking into the gap, the youth could see another dimension on the other side of the bookshelf -- and there is a familiar figure. "Here!" He hears his girlfriend voice. As he sees his girlfriend, the youth feel relieved a lot. , "Wow, finally, I almost thought I would never see you anymore" “Everything is so strange today, but thank god I’ve found that book!" "See, I told you! I didn't lie to you.You wait over there. I'll go there and find you now." His girlfriend runs away before he could stop her, and she’s already far away. After a while, his girlfriend still doesn’t arrive. he sends a text, but receives no reply. The youth doesn’t know how long has been passed and he falls asleep by the bookshelf. Suddenly he is woken up by the ring of his phone, and he sees the text. "Sorry, something has happened. Wait for me, I will be there soon " The youth calls back, but it is kept on a busy line. "What has happened to her“ It has been a long time. The youth wanders around, but doesn’t find any windows. He can’t even tell if it is day or night now. Fortunately, the mall is filled with stores where he can get clothes, groceries, and even a nap at the furniture shop. He feels like he could totally stay and live here even for an extended period of time because he could find everything he would need to live in the mall. The youth receives another text after who knows how long has passed, Did not know how long has been passed, the youth received another text: "Sorry, something has happened, Wait for me, I will be there soon " The exact same text, which terrifies the Youth. However, he finds the place comfortable enough to stay for even longer, and he wonders maybe she’s the one who is lost. “So where is she and what is she doing right now.”
<=0>?(/&/<@ T2)#6 #"*%@6 #3+/4536 #3%6 82++/>6 ,+%"?,%6 /86 #3%6 7//:)3%$;@6(/4#362,#42$$(6)%%)6#3%6"*9+")/86)92,%6;+/*6 #3%6+%54$2+6)92,%-6B4#6#3")6#"*%@63%6")6)%%"856#3%6+%54$2+6 )92,%6;+/*6"*9+")/86)92,%-6'/6#3%69$2,%@6>3%+%6#3%6 (/4#36")6"86+"53#68/>@6")6#3%6)92,%67%3"806#3%65296/; 6#3%6 7//:)3%$; 6$2)#6#"*%-6!3%65"+$6)2()6#/6;"806#3%6(/4#3@674#6 #3%(632?%67%%860"?"0%06"8#/6#>/6)92,%)62$+%20(-6!3%(6 >"$$68%?%+6)%%6%2,36/#3%+628(*/+%-
„
$<;0,L?-?$ ٤
ᡕ ܷ
W- T"7+2 T27(+"8#3 .%8)/+)3
$VZ9,0;0.-+;$
8=-?1F+3S1935?5;.?101X';B +'B(2+")5&7'&&2&"$$A) 8=519+.5;.-0,1N3>.0,-.L1+H1 ?90/51-;1C0-,L1,-H51-?1.>3;' -;@1 .+1 01 =+33-N,51 5Z.35751 >;C531 .=51 .+.0,-.03-0;1 9+,-.-/0,1?L?.57G1<,.=+>@=1 .=51 93+.0@+;-?.1 ?>N.,L1 0F0351+H1.=51C5.0-,?1+H1=-?1 03/=-.5/.>30,1 /+;.0-;' 75;.A1=51-?1?.-,,1;'((2&<)2&8%) 8=") 1"$82&-) %;) Y2?.#2$%&B ?"&8Z1 .=0.1 =51 F-,,1 ;+.1 5?/095G
<+D#0'&*(<@
„ ౨ ᧠
2+(36/; 3"9
O3%86 #3%6 "80"?"042$6 #+"%)6 #/6 ;"806 26 )9%,";",6 7//:@6 #3%6 ,2#2$/56 84*7%+6 /; 6 #3%6 7//:6 >"$$6 $%206 3"*6#/67%6!"#$$%&'()!*'#'+,-%'.(".,/#"'0#1%' .*0$*2%&'*3 '.#!#/*-'),04%"2-6!3%6)%%*"85< $(6 +%54$2+6 2806 ,$%2+6 )#/+25%6 )()#%*6 ")6 2,#42$$(6 3"0"856#3%6$27(+"8#3"8%6,"+,4$2#"/8692#367%3"806"#@6
>3",36")672)%06/86#3%6A$%"86B/##$%-6G?%86#3/4536 #3%6"80"?"042$6,286,/8)#28#$(6)%%6#32#67//:)3%$;@63%6 >"$$68%?%+6+%2,36"#-
$*=L?-;/0,1Q+C5,$ '()*%#+",Ⴆ
./0%„ᖑ
%&.AB?>'&)0$C)D#? ':"9„ᛔ
'%%:„
."+,$%„
J%#4+8„
E")?#$C)D#?@$4<96$$4,F4,F6GH9,
ᬜ
„ ࡹ
ᘺ ፗ
WW- '#2#"/ W8;+2)#+4, S"$#+2#"/8
$VZ9,0;0.-+;$
<+0DBA#<@
ᬜ
„
!3%6#",:%#652#%62806+%,32+5%+6;"$#%+6#3%6#2+5%#6 2806 "804,%6 3"*6 "8#/6 #3%6 "*9+")/8"856 )92,%-6 !3%6 "*9+")/8"856)92,%6")60"?"0%067(63%2?(69"$$2+)@6#3%6 2!#!(*)' *33(.%6' 2!#("26' #)&' .*)7%)(%).%' 2!*"%28!+*2%' ,2,#/' &#(/5' !+()-2-6 !3%6 5$2))6 >"80/>6 2806 ,/**/0"#(6 )3%$?%)6 2%$#"#!%' !+%'
ᢠ К
/8,#4+%6/; 8
2$#.%-6B4#6#3%6#2+5%#6,286)#"$$6)%%628063%2+6/#3%+)6 2$$6 2+/480-6 W86 200"#"/8@6 #3%6 .%)!"*2500%!"(.' $/#)' *42.,"%2' !+%' 2%)2%' *3 ' &("%.!(*)-6 !3%6 "*9+")/8"856)92,%6")6#3%6)2*%62)6#3%6+%54$2+6)92,%-6 !3%60";;%+%8,%6")632+06#/60")#"854")3-
$*=L?-;/0,1Q+C5,$
1"$$2+௵
K/>8ᨀ
„
%&.AB?>'&)0$C)D#?
GE4"9@%*#ೞ
„
N7)#+4,#ᢚ
„
K42$-
E")?#$C)D#?@$4<96$$4,F4,F6GH9,
ӑ
„
G$%?2#/+హ
„
ՠ
††† Ӌ
ᆰ᠂ ᧓ᅠ
WWW '3/99 K2"$(6S2," W*9+%)"/8
ᙼ
„
$VZ9,0;0.-+;$
„ᨦ
„
„
„
ՠ
†
᠂ ᅠ
9"856X2$$"$"#%)6/; 8*%8#
<+,-.&/)0<@
!3%6)3/99"856*2$$6")6&(7(&%&'()!*'(0$"(2*)9 ()-'2$#.%'#)&'"%-,/#"'2$#.%6':+(.+'/**;'%<#.!9 /5' !+%' 2#0%-6 !3%6 )%92+2#"/86 /; 6 #3%6 #>/6 )92,%)6 ")6 2,3"%?%067(6?2+"/4)6:"80)6/; 6)3/96>"80/>)@6,/48#%+)@6 2806)3%$?%)@62806#3%6,"+,4$2#"/86/; 6#2+5%#628068/+*2$6 9%/9$%6")60"?"0%067(6260/47$%<0//+6%$%?2#/+-6!3%6%8#"+%<
#(6 /; 6 #3%6 "*9+")/8"856 )92,%)6 2+%6 #' -(#)!' /#45"()!+' .*))%.!%&'45'%/%7#!*"2-6!3%6,$/#3%)@65+/,%+"%)@62806 ;4+8"#4+%6 $"*7(&%' !+%' 4#2(.' &#(/5' /(3%' )%%&2' 3*"' !+%'!#"-%!-6!3%6)3/99"856*2$$6")6"80%%06#3%6"0%2$69$2,%6 ;/+6"*9+")/8*%8#-
$*=L?-;/0,1Q+C5,$
1%%9-
ᙼ
K//+-
%&.AB?>'&)0$C)D#?
N7)#2,$%-
ᨦ
',+%%8-
ᱬ
'>2)#":2-
ҟ
1%%9-
ᙼ
E")?#$C)D#?@$4<96$$4,F4,F6GH9,
ZF公理系 zf axiomatic system
↓・-#.#"#,/# :1&)'>"6$%$6,# B*$+*%8)(%84 %@>&8/
集合論 Set Theory
濃度 cardinality
↓・-#.#"#,/# -D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
圏論 Category Theory
ブール代数 boolean algebra
束論 lattice
トポス topos
水槽の脳 brain in a vat
カルテジアン劇場 cartesian theater
シミュレーション仮説 Simulation Hypothesis
必ー偶 certainty-possibility
固定指示子 rigid designators
様相論理 modal logic
人間原理 Anthropic Principle
クオリア qualia
・?@,-8'&-%#9)0
是ー非 true-false
=3%"4'V=
全体論 holism
ZFC公理系 zfc axiomatic system
↓・-#.#"#,/#
ホログラフィック原理 Holographic Principle
可能世界 possible world
3)*)"D'Q6"%;)*+D D>+%E7&3+%84 %5"/(8*".&:%!&(+*"&:"/7
消去主義的唯物論 eliminative materialism
↓・-#.#"#,/#
5),6#1'5#,,#** @8#/."8)/#+//%F?=:&"#+$
BC#' *C6"2' +*#E' 6+' %,1&' N)&' *%' )9%62 %. '*C#'1%$6/)1'+&+*# %5") 65'.") 1+/5&25"+) ."8".A' BC 9)"6#*&' %. ' +E)/#' ),2'EC&+6/+')"#'.)" D)1' E#"/#E*6%,' % )L+*")/*6%,'%. '+E)/ 16L#")*#' *C#' )LD, %. ')"/C6*#/*D"#A'
意味論
統語論
semantics
階層 hierarchy
syntax
↓・-#.#"#,/#
公理
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
定理
axiom
分化 morphogenesis
theorem
公理系 axiomatic system
自己生産 auto-poiesis
)L+*")/*6%,A' BC#' 2' 6,/%;E1#*#,#++' #;'6+'*%'/4,%+/$%) -"6'+7) %') /) C#' )/*D)16*&' ),2' ' 6,' ;)*C#;)*6/+' "'L#&%,2'6,26962K %. ' "#)16*&A' BC#' /#'E#"/#E*6%,'N611' ,2),*' E%++6L616*6#+'
健全性
soundness
↓・-#.#"#,/#
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
0)
自己組織化
自律
self-organization
autonomy
完全性
completeness 左 右
象徴交換
l'échange symbolique
ノイズ・インデュース
noise-induced-or
↓・-#.#"#,/# ↓・-#.#"#,/#
生命
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
bios
-D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
秩序 ↓・-#.#"#,/#
カオス
nomos
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
宇宙
cosmos
caos
ゆらぎ
fluctuation
!"#$%&'#(')*+$ ,)-#(.)&(
/#(.&01$23)')(4$51$6#70&-&08")9$ :*03;*0#
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â&#x2020;&#x201C;A&B#0$@-*4# <="&.'$)($'"#$/"#++$>?$@((&9#(9#
空 ᧓ Space
Set Theory and Topology Shokichi Iyanaga
<.)2+$"/)&=4>+$ 述語論理
時᧓
Lectures on Symbolic Logic Shimizu Yoshio
Functional Analysis Naritoshi Kuroda
89+4:"/+$&';3/):
')/
<4?).&')/
UVT&')/&89+4:3
89+4:&45 & <4?).&')/
\1."/4?3A+& T,431.)&89+4:3
公理系
集合
冪集合
8&3)/&45 &"9+4:3&/%"/&-)&13)2& /4&2)5+#)&"&/4(4,4>+$",& 3/.1$/1.)&4#&"&3)/I&6%)&-"3+3& 45 &64(4,4>+$",&'("$)
Time
'1-3/"#/+G",+3:
!"#$
%&'
()$)*+
実質主義
8Z6%4).;&45 &6+:) !"#$
%&'
()$)*+
6+:)&24)3&#4/&)9+3/&+#2)()#2)#/,;& 45 &/%)&)G)#/3&/%"/&4$$1.&+#&/+:)
6%)&P.4?+#>&E#+G).3)& 6%)4/;
!Z6%4).;&45 &6+:)
N)>1,". ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
6 V.a$%)/&'("$)
6L N)>1,".&*"1324.55 &'(
*"1324.55 ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
6;$%4#4G ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
67 *"1324.55 &'("$)
6LX 6;$%4#4G&'("$)
E.;34%# ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
O4.:",& ')("."/+4#&89+4:
6 E.;34%#&'("$)
6M O4.:",&*"1324.55 &'(
K
%&'
()$)*+
0/).#",+3:
6%)&-),+)5 &+#&/%+#>3&/%"/& ".)&("3/&"#2&/%+#>3&/%"/& ".)&;)/&/4&$4:)& )9+3/&)/).#",,;I
<).21."#/+3: 6%)&4-])$/&%"3&2+3/+#$/&/):(4.",& ("./3&/%.41>%41/&+/3&)9+3/)#$)
V41.Z^+:)#3+4#",+3:
F-])$/3&4.&)G)#/3&".)&3("$)Z/+:)&?4.:3& /%"/&().3+3/&/%.41>%&/+:)&-;&%"G+#>I& /):(4.",&("./3&#4#)&45 &?%+$%&+3&+2)#/+$",& /4&/%)&4-])$/&+/3),5
b4.:&/%)4.; !"#$
%&'
()$)*+
'/">)&/%)4.; !"#$
%&'
()$)*+
6%)&8..4?&45 &6+:) 時間の矢
7
チホノフ空間
7
正規ハウスドルフ空間
=
@"#+54,2
多様体
6)#3)&/+:)&5.":)?4.A&+3& ):-)2)2&+#&/%)&@+#A4?3A+& '("$)&45 &P)#).",&N),"/+G+.;
P)#).",&N),"/+G+/; 一般的相対論
@+#A4?3A+&'("$)
ミンコフスキー空間
'("$)&"#2&/+:)&+#&M&2+:)#3+4#", )#/"#>,):)#/
6%)&/4/",&)#/.4(;&45 &"#&+34,"/)2&3;3/): $"#&#)G).&2)$.)"3)&4G).&/+:)
T1.G)2&'("$)/+:) 6%)&P."G+/;&$"13)2&/%)&$1.G"/1.)& 45 &'("$)/+:)
<".+/;&C+4,"/+4#
<"./+$,)3&$"#&#4/&/."G)&-"$A?".23& +#&/+:)
T"13",+/;
K
64(4,4>+$",&3("$)&/%"/&,4$",,;&.)3):-,)3& 01$,+2)"#&3("$)&#)".&)"$%&(4+#/
')$4#2&="?&45 & 6%).:42;#":+$3
T"13",+/;&2)$+2)&/%)&().$)(/+4#", /+:)
6
正則ハウスドルフ空間
7X ウリゾーン空間
時空 Spacetime 15&)9%-((2.-%)15&#"7)#*):2&%0() >6-/46')?&.5-/2.( 15&)@#%#A"-,52.)!"2/.2,%& 34/54/3"%6")./74/84/39(#19$: 34/54/3"%6")./74/84/39(#19$: -&)##&./0"!1"+2
!"#$
6
V.a$%)/& ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
0#21."#/+3:
@"/).+",&4-])$/3&".)&().3+3/+#>&/%.))Z 2+:)#3+4#",&+#2+G+21",3&?%4,,;&(.)3)#/& "/&)G).;&:4:)#/&45 &/%)+.&)9+3/)#$)
6J
ハウスドルフ空間
還元主義
O)+/%).&/%)&51/1.)&#4.& /%)&("3/&)9+3/3I
ヒルベルト
B##).&<.42
&O4.:
K フレシェ空間
N)21$/+4#+3:
<.)3)#/+3:
\4,:4>4.4G& ')("."/+4#&89+4:
*+,-).
バナハ空間
コルモゴロフ空間
'("$)&"#2&/+:)&%"G)&"#&)9+3/)#$)& +#2)()#2)#/&45 &(%;3+$",&/%+#>3
6)#3),)33
!"#"$%&'("$)
位相空間
6J \4,:4>4.4G&'("$)
15&);-46"&)#*)<=2(4&/.& !"#$%&'()#*)+,-.&)-/0)12'& 3/)45&)!%6"-%247)#*)8#"%0( ;48474/8?@"AA"*$ ;4;4</=>"*$ 5",96/3+'9#
6)#3)
64(4,4>+$",&'("$)
6)#3),)33&/+:)&5.":)?4.A& $"#&-)&2)5+#)2&-;& 4-3).G"/+4#&+#&Q1"#/1:& @)$%"#+$3
Q1"#/1:&@)$%"#+$3
万物の理論
8&%;(4/%)/+$",&$4%).) 5.":)?4.A&/%"/&51,,;&) /4>)/%).&",,&(%;3+$",&"
@&6%)4.;
KK&2+:)#3+4#",&)#/"#>,):)
@1,/+G).3) 多元宇宙論 V41.&=)G),D
量子力学
b"G)&V1#$/+4# T4,,"(3)
F$$1.&?%)#&"&?"G)&51#$/+4# .)21$)3& /4&"&3+#>,)&)+>)#3/"/)&21)&/4&+#/)."$/+4#& ?+/%&/%)&)9/).#",&?4.,2 6%)&$4,,"(3)&45 &?"G)& 51#$/+4#&$4..)3(4#2&/4&/%)& "..4?&45 &/+:)
6%)4.;&F5 &0G)./%+#
Q1"#/1:&P."G+/; 量子重力理論
'/.+#>&6%)4.;
&(4+#/Z,+A)&("./+$,)3&45 &("./+$,)&(%;3+$3&".)& .)(,"$)2&-;&4#)Z2+:)#3+4#",&4-])$/3& $",,)2&3/.+#>3
BD09/)#3+4
8&(.)2+$/+4#&45 &$43 )9+3/)#$)&45 &"#&+#5+
BBD&^+55).)
B#&/%)&)/).#",&+#5," %4?)G).&3/4(&3/.)/$ ?%+$%&".)&):-.;4#
BBBD&@"#;Z 45 &Q1"#/1
6%)&4-3).G"/+4#&45 ."#>)&45 &(433+-,)&4 (.4-"-+,+/;I&
BCDE,/+:
数学的宇宙仮
^+55).)#/&"-3/. 2+55).)#/&3/.1$
+,+%$
./&'("$)
21$/
C,#B#+&8-#('$&D $E0*-#;&0F$&D $/8*9#')-#$ '&$28).'&-&+41C
01$,+2+"#&'("$)
ト空間
ユークリッド空間
=+:+/)2&^+:)#3+4#
6K
67
6M
6L
6H
6%+3&+3&"&/%4.41>%&"#",;3+3&2)(+$/+#>& /%)&2)G),4(:)#/&45 &/%)&$4#$)(/&45 &3("$)& "#2& /+:)& 5.4:& "& 541#2"/+4#& 45 & :"/%):"/+$3&/4&"&3/.1$/1.)&45 &)(+3/):4,4Z >;I&
N
O
("$) T4:(,)/),;&O4.:", ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
G/8*9#?
6H T4:(,)/),;&O4.:",&*"1324.55 &'("$) 全部分正規ハウスドルフ空間
<).5)$/,;&O4.:", ')("."/+4#&89+4:3
("$) 6S <).5)$/,;&O4.:",&*"1324.55 &'("$) 完全正規ハウスドルフ空間
=4$",,;&N)3):-,)
#>
)#/&/%)4.)/+$",& )9(,"+#3&"#2&,+#A3& "3()$/3&45 &/%)&1#+G).3)I
HI&*4,4>."(%+$&<.+#$+(,)
Holographic Principle
ホログラフィック原理
6%)&2)3$.+(/+4#&45 &"&G4,1:)&45 &3("$)&$"#&-)& /%41>%/&45 &"3&)#$42)2&4#&"&,4?).Z2+:)#3+4#",& -41#2".;&/4&/%)&.)>+4#Y&,+A)&"&%4,4>.":I&6%+3& :)"#3&/%)&1#+G).3)&?)&,+G)2&+#&+3&/%)& +#54.:"/+4#",&$4#/)#/&?%+$%&%"G)&5",,)#&+#/4&/%)& %4,)&:+>%/&-)&)#/+.),;&$4#/"+#)2&+#&31.5"$)& 5,1$/1"/+4#3&45 &/%)&)G)#/&%4.+[4#I&F1.&1#+G).3)&+3& 4#)&45 &/%)&,4?).Z2+:)#3+4#",&+#5.4:"/+4#",& (.4])$/+4#&45 &/%)&.)",&1#+G).3)I&
ホログラフィック原理
,4?).Z2+:)#3+4#", +#5.4:"/+4#",&(.4])$/+4#
#/
4#
3:+$&+#5,"/+4#&+3&/%)& #+/)&).>42+$&1#+G).3)
#$)&+#&<%;3+$",&T4#3/"#/3
/+4#&/%)4.;Y&34:)&.)>+4#3&45 &3("$)Y& $%+#>&"#2&54.:&2+3/+#$/&-1--,)3Y& #+$&,)G),&B&:1,/+G).3)3
Z?4.,23&B#/).(.)/"/+4#& 1:&@)$%"#+$3
5 &c1"#/1:&:)$%"#+$3&?+,,&>)#)."/)&"& 4-3).G"/+4#3Y&)"$%&?+/%&"&2+55).)#/&
:"/)&0#3):-,)
仮説
."$/&:"/%):"/+$3&5.":)?4.A&>)#)."/)& $/1.)&1#+G).3)
B#&:"/%):"/+$3Y&/%)&4.+>+#&45 &3("$)& +3& /%)& (4?).& 3)/I& 6%)& /%.))Z2+:)#3+4#",& 01$,+2+"#& '("$)& ?)& 2"+,;& )9().+)#$)& +3& 4#,;&("./&45 &"&*+,-)./&'("$)Y&?%+$%&+3&"& ("./& 45 & "& !"#"$%& '("$)I& 6%)& !"#"$%& 3("$)&+3&",34&4#,;&"&("./&45 &/%)&*"1324.55 & 3("$)Y& ?%+$%& +3& /%)& :43/& -"3+$& /;()& 45 & /4(4,4>+$",&3("$)&-"3)2&4#&/%)&(4?).&3)/& "#2& $"/)>4.+[)2& -;& \1."/4?3A+& $,431.)& "9+4:3I
O+#)&6;()3D
82G4$"/)2&-;&3/.+#>&/%)4.+3/&!.+"#& P.))#)
KI&Q1+,/)2 6%)&c1+,/)2&:1,/+G).3)&?4.A3&4#,;& +#&"#&+#5+#+/)&1#+G).3)I&
7I&B#5,"/+4#".;
SIE,/+:"/)
6%)&1,/+:"/)&:1,/+G).3)&$4#/"+#3&)G).;& :"/%):"/+$",,;&(433+-,)&1#+G).3)&1#2).&2+55).)#/& ,"?3&45 &(%;3+$3I
WIQ1"#/1:
6%)&+#5,"/+4#".;&:1,/+G).3)&+3&$4:(43)2&45 & G".+413&(4$A)/3&+#&?%+$%&+#5,"/+4#&5+),23& $4,,"(3)&"#2&54.:&#)?&1#+G).3)3I
6%)&c1"#/1:&:1,/+G).3)&$.)"/)3&"&#)?& 1#+G).3)&?%)#&"&2+G).3+4#&+#&)G)#/3&4$$1.3
LI!."#)
_I="#23$"()
MIT;$,+$
fI'+:1,"/)2
6%)&-."#)&:1,/+G).3)&G).3+4#&(43/1,"/)3&/%"/& 41.&)#/+.)&1#+G).3)&)9+3/3&4#&"&:):-."#)& ?%+$%&5,4"/3&+#&"&%+>%).&2+:)#3+4#I 6%)&$;$,+$&:1,/+G).3)&%"3&:1,/+(,)&-."#)3& /%"/&%"G)&$4,,+2)2Y&$"13+#>&!+>&!"#>3I&
6%)&,"#23$"()&:1,/+G).3)&.),+)3&4#&3/.+#>& /%)4.;g3&T","-+hi"1&3("$)3I
6%)&3+:1,"/)2&:1,/+G).3)&)9+3/3&4#& $4:(,)9&$4:(1/).&3;3/):3&/%"/&3+:1,"/)& )#/+.)&1#+G).3)3I
G!)-#?
B#& (%;3+$3Y& /%)& #"/1.)& 45 & /+:)& +3& :"#+5)3/)2&-;&/)#3)Y&?%+$%&.)(.)3)#/3&/%)& /;()&45 &$4#/+#1+/;&45 &/+:)I&!"3)2&4#&/)#3)& "#2&/)#3),)33#)33Y&/?4&/;()3&45 &/%)4.;&45 & /+:)& ".)& 2+55).)#/+"/)2`& ",/).#"/+G),;Y& 3+9& /;()3&45 &(%+,434(%+$",&$4>#+/+4#&45 &/+:)& ".)&(43+/)2Y&?%+$%&".)&.),"/)2&/4&2+55).)#/& $4#2+/+4#3&45 &/%)&)9+3/)#$)&45 &/%)&4-])$/I
G/8*9#')-#?
& & V.4:& /%)& $4#/+#1413,;& +#$.)"3+#>& )#/.4(;&+#&/%)&3)$4#2&,"?&45 &/%).:42;Z #":+$3&2).+G)3&/%)&$"13",+/;&/%"/&2)$+2)3& /%)& 2+.)$/+4#& 45 & /+:)I& 6%+3& 2+.)$/+4#& 45 & /+:)& ",34& $4..)3(4#23& /4& /%)& $4,,"(3)& 45 & /%)&?"G)&51#$/+4#&+#&c1"#/1:&:)$%"#+$3I& 8/& /%)& 3":)& /+:)Y& /%.))Z2+:)#3+4#",& 01$,+2+"#&3("$)&+3&/%)&,4$",&.)3):-,"#$)& 45 & "& @+#A4?3A+& '("$)Y& /%)& 541.Z2+:)#Z 3+4#",& )#/"#>,):)#/& 45 & 3("$)& "#2& /+:)Y& ?%+$%&+3&"2G4$"/)2&+#&>)#).",&.),"/+G+/;I&
G!"#$!"#&01$&D $2B#01'")(4?
6%)& >"(& -)/?))#& /%)& c1"#/1:& :)$%"#+3:& "#2& >)#).",& .),"/+G+/;& +3& .)$4#$+,)2& 1#2).& /%)& d/%)& 6%)4.;& 45 & 0G).;/%+#>Ye&?%+$%&"+:3&/4&51,,;&)9(,"+#& ",,&(%;3+$",&"3()$/3&45 &/%)&1#+G).3)I&6%)& :1,/+G).3)& +3& "& :"]4.& 5.":)?4.A& +#& /%)& /%)4.;& 45 & )G).;/%+#>I& 6%)& /?4& :"+#3/.)":& )9(,"#"/+4#3& +#& /%)& :1,/+G).3)& ".)& /%)& d1,/+:"/)& )#3):-,)e& "#2&/%)&d%4,4>."(%+$&(.+#$+(,)Ie&!4/%&45 & /%):& "2G4$"/)& /%)& <,"#$A& 1#+/Y& /%)& 3:",,)3/& 4-3).G"-,)& 1#+/Y& "3& /%)& 1#+/& 45 & +#54.:"/+4#& /%"/& $"#& -)& 3))#& "3& /%)& 1,/+:"/)&.)",+/;&45 &/%)&1#+G).3)I E,/+:"/)&N)",+/; RB#54.:"/+4#
情報的実在論
6%)&1#+G).3)&+3&/%)&+#54.:"/+4#& :42),&/%"/&$4:(43)2&-;&/%)& 3:",,)3/&4-3).G"-,)&1#+/Z<,"#$A& E#+/Y&?%+$%&+3&-)%"G)2&"3&"&-+/I
ἨἾỶὅὉἅὅἦἷ 侵襲式 B#G"3+G)
ᛐ論 ᜤ 0(+3/4:4,4>; The Conscious Mind David Chalmers
@+#2Z!42;&<.4-,):
心身問題 6%)&2)-"/)&$4#$).#+#>&/%)&.),"/+4#3%+(&-)/?))#&
6%)&/)$%#4,4>;&/%"/& +:(,):)#/3&/%+3&)(+3/):+$& .)$4>#+/+4#I
/%41>%/&"#2&$4#3$+413#)33&+#&/%)&%1:"#&:+#2Y& "#2&/%)&-."+#&"3&("./&45 &/%)&(%;3+$",&-42;
Matter and Consciousness Paul Churchland
Q1",+"
6%)&#2+G+21",&+#3/"#$)3&45 & 31-])$/+G)Y&$4#3$+413&)9().+)#$)I
<%;3+$",&<%)#4:)#"
<%)#4:)#",& T4#3$+41#)33
6%)&#2+G+21",&+#3/"#$)3&45 & 31-])$/+G)Y&$4#3$+413&)9().+)#$)I
*".2&<.4-,):&45 &T4#3$+413#)33 6%)&(.4-,):&45 &)9(,"+#+#>&/%)&.),"/+4#3%+(&-)/?))#& (%;3+$",&(%)#4:)#"Y&31$%&"3&-."+#&(.4$)33)3Y&"#2& )9().+)#$)&j+I)IY&(%)#4:)#",&$4#3$+413#)33Y&4.&c1",+"k
0"3;&<.4-,):&45 &T4#3$+413#)33 09(,"+#+#>&%4?&/%)&-."+#&+#/)>."/)3&+#54.:"/+4#Y& $"/)>4.+[)3&"#2&2+3$.+:+#"/)3&)#G+.4#:)#/",&3/+:1,+Y& 4.&54$13)3&"//)#/+4#I
V1#$/+4#",& T4#3$+413#)33
Philosophy and Scientific Realism J. J. C. Smart
0(+3/):+$&P"(X09(,"#"/4.;&P"(
認識論的ギャップ 6%)&2+55+$1,/;&/%"/&(%;3+$",+3/&/%)4.+)3&%"G)&+#&
)9(,"+#+#>&%4?&(%;3+$",&(.4()./+)3&>+G)&.+3)&/4&/%)& ?";&/%+#>3&5)),&?%)#&/%);&".)&)9().+)#$)2
F#/4,4>+$",&P"(
存在論的ギャップ 6%)&G+)?&45 &/%)&$4#3+413&)9().+)#$)&"#2&
(%;3+$",&(%)#4:)#"&+3&4#/4,4>+$",,;&2+55).)#/I
6;()Z8&@"/).+",+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
l)I>I&^"#+),&^)##)//Y&V.)2&^.)/3A)Y&P+,-)./& *".:"#Y&^"G+2&\),,4>>&=)?+3Y&P+,-)./&N;,)m
6;()Z!&@"/).+",+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
T4#3$+413#)33&24)3&#4/&,4>+$",,;&31().G)#)&4#&/%)&(%;3+$",Y&34& /%).)&+3&#4&"&(.+4.+&+:(,+$"/+4#&5.4:&/%)&(%;3+$",&/4&/%)& (%)#4:)#",I&6%)&(%)#4:)#",&3/"/)3&$"#&-)&+2)#/+5+)2 ?+/%&$)./"+#&(%;3+$",&4.&51#$/+4#",&3/"/)3I l)I>I&O)2&!,4$AY&n4%#&<)..;m
6;()ZT&@"/).+",+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
8$$4.2+#>&/4&6;()ZT&@"/).+",+3:Y&?%+,)&?)&$"##4/&3))&#4?&%4?& /4&34,G)&/%)&%".2&(.4-,):&+#&(%;3+$",&/).:3Y&/%)&(.4-,):&+3& 34,G"-,)&+#&(.+#$+(,)I&E31",,;&A#4?#&"3&+#/)."$/+4#+3:Y (%;3+$",&3/"/)3&?+,,&$"13)&(%)#4:)#",&3/"/)3Y&"#2&(%)#4:)#",& 3/"/)3&$"13)&(%;3+$",&3/"/)3I
l)I>I&T4,+#&@$P+##m
6;()Z^&^1",+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
神経ज़ᙾ器 Spatial Sensory Nervous System :6/0-'&/4-%()#*)@6'-/);&6"#,(7.5#%#A7 B&2C/D/E19#1"'
Consciousness and its Place in Nature David Chalmers
T4#3$+413#)33&"3&5".&"3&+/&)9+3/3Y&,4>+$",,;&31().G)#)3&4#&/%)& (%;3+$",&54.&51#$/+4#",+3/&4.&),+:+#"/+G+3/+$&.)"34#3I&6%).)3&+3&#4& d%".2&(.4-,):e&45 &)9(,"+#+#>&$4#3$+413#)33&/%"/&.):"+#3&4#$)& 4#)&%"3&34,G)2&/%)&)"3;&(.4-,):3&45 &)9(,"+#+#>&/%)&G".+413& $4>#+/+G)Y&-)%"G+4.",Y&"#2&)#G+.4#:)#/",&51#$/+4#3I
0#,".>)&/%)&),$/.42)&".)"
<%4/4.)$)(/4.3 視覚器
<%4/4.)$)(/4.3&".)&$"("-,)&45 & (%4/4/."#321$/+4#Y&"&(.4$)33&?%+$%&$4#G)./3& ,+>%/ +#/4Y&":4#>&4/%).&/;()3&45 &)#).>;Y&"& :):-."#)&(4/)#/+",I
P13/"/4.;&T4./)9
6%)&(.+:".;&>13/"/4.;&$4./)9&+3&"&-."+#& 3/.1$/1.)&.)3(4#3+-,)&54.&/%)&().$)(/+4#& 45 &/"3/)
F,5"$/4.;&T4./)9
6%)&(.+:".;&>13/"/4.;&$4./)9&+3&"&-."+#& 3/.1$/1.)&.)3(4#3+-,)&54.&/%)&().$)(/+4#& 45 &3:),,
6;()Z^&21",+3:&%4,23&/%"/&:+$.4(%;3+$3&+3&#4/&$"13",,;&$,43)2Y& "#2&/%"/&(%)#4:)#",&(.4()./+)3&(,";&"&$"13",&.4,)&+#&"55)$/+#>& /%)&(%;3+$",&?4.,2I&8,34Y&%".2&(.4-,):&+3&34,G"-,)&+#&(.+#$+(,)I l)I>I&N)#a&^)3$"./)3m
6;()Z0&^1",+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
6;()Z0&21",+3:&%4,23&/%"/&(%)#4:)#",&(.4()./+)3&".)& 4#/4,4>+$",,;&2+3/+#$/&5.4:&(%;3+$",&(.4()./+)3Y&"#2&/%"/&/%)& (%)#4:)#",&%"3&#4&)55)$/&4#&/%)&(%;3+$",I&6%+3&+3&/%)&G+)?& 131",,;&A#4?#&"3&)(+(%)#4:)#",+3:D&(%;3+$",&3/"/)3&$"13)& (%)#4:)#",&3/"/)3Y&-1/&#4/&G+$)&G).3"I
l)I>I&V."#A&n"$A34#m
6;()ZV&@4#+3:
l!"#$%&'#()*+"&&&&&&X,-%./.0#(+/)*+"&&&&&&m
情報的一元論
6;()ZV&:4#+3:&+3&/%)&G+)?&/%"/&$4#3$+413#)33&+3&$4#3/+/1/)2&-;& /%)&+#/.+#3+$&(.4()./+)3&45 &51#2":)#/",&(%;3+$",&)#/+/+)3D&/%"/&+3Y& -;&/%)&$"/)>4.+$",&-"3)3&45 &51#2":)#/",&(%;3+$",&2+3(43+/+4#3ILJ F#&/%+3&G+)?Y&(%)#4:)#",&4.&(.4/4(%)#4:)#",&(.4()./+)3&".)& ,4$"/)2&"/&/%)&51#2":)#/",&,)G),&45 &(%;3+$",&.)",+/;Y&"#2&+#&"& $)./"+#&3)#3)Y&1#2).,+)&(%;3+$",&.)",+/;&+/3),5I
^41-,)Z83()$/& 6%)4.;&45 &B#54.:"/+4# 情報の二層理論
6%)&:)#/",&"#2&/%)&(%;3+$",&".)&/?4&"3()$/3&45Y& 4.&().3()$/+G)3&4#Y&/%)&+#54.:"/+4#&
B#54.:"/+4# !"!"!"!""""!"!"!"!"!" "!"!"!""!"!"""!"!"!"" !"!"!"!"!"!""!"!""!"! "!"!""!"!"!""!"!"!""! "!""!"!"!"!""!"!"!"!" !""""!"!"!""!"!"!"!"" !!!!"!"!""!"!""!!!"!" !""!"!"!""!"!""!"!"!! !""!"!""!"!"!""!"!""! !!!"!""!"!"!""!"!"!"! "!"!""""!"!"!"!"!""!" !"!""!"!"""!"!"!""!"! "!"!"!"!""!"!""!"!"!"
l)I>I&!)./."#2&N133),,Y&^"G+2&T%",:).3m
6%)&<.+#$+(,)&45 & '/.1$/1.",&T4%).)#$)
情報的実在論
6%)&(.+#$+(,)&45 &$4%).)#$)&-)/?))#&/%)& 3/.1$/1.)&45 &$4#3$+413#)33&"#2&/%)&3/.1$/1.)&45 & "?".)#)33I&6%)&d"?".)#)33e&?"3&13)2&)".,+).&/4& .)5).&/4&/%)&G".+413&51#$/+4#",&(%)#4:)#"&/%"/& ".)&"334$+"/)2&?+/%&$4#3$+413#)33I
視床
6%)&,4$"/+4#&45 &"&,".>)&:"33&45 &>.";&:"//).I& O).G)&5+-).3&(.4])$/&41/&45 &/%)&/%",":13&/4&/%)& $).)-.",&$4./)9&+#&",,&2+.)$/+4#3Y&",,4?+#>& %1-Z,+A)&)9$%"#>)3&45 &+#54.:"/+4#I&B/&%"3& 3)G).",&51#$/+4#3Y&31$%&"3&.),";+#>&45 &3)#34.;& 3+>#",3Y&"#2&/%)&.)>1,"/+4#&45 &$4#3$+413#)33I
!."+#&'/):
構築一致原則
E,/+:"/)&N)",+/; RB#54.:"/+4#
6%",":13
脳幹 <%;+3$", <.4()./;
<%)#4:)#", <.4()./;
6%)&-."+#&3/): +3&/%)&(43/).+4.&("./&45 &/%)&-."+#Y& $4#/+#1413&?+/%&/%)&3(+#",&$4.2I&B#&/%)&%1:"#&-."+#&/%)& -."+#3/):&+#$,12)3&/%)&:+2-."+#Y&/%)&(4#3&"#2&:)21,,"& 4-,4#>"/"&45 &/%)&%+#2-."+#I&
ἷὊἑὉỶὅἑἧỹὊἋ )&!."+#ZT4:(1/).&B#/).5"$)j!TBk
Progress in Brain Computer Interfaces: Challenges and Trends Saha, S., Mamun, K. A.
'+>#",&<.4$)33+#>
O4#Z+#G"3+G) N)$4.2+#>&0,)$/.42)
V)"/1.)& 09/."$/+4#
T,"33+5+$"/+4#& 8,>4.+/%:
O)1.4(.43/%)3+3 <).$)(/+4#
@",+$+413& V)"/1.)&09/."$/+4#
@",+$+413& T,"33+5+$"/+4#&8,>4.+/%:
O)1.",&!)%"G+41. T4#/.4,
^+>+/",+[)2 '+>#",
'+>#",& 8$c1+3+/+4# 'A+# 'A1,, O)1.",&'+>#",3
!."+#
Emerging Threats to Security and Privacy in Brain Computer Interface Poonam Chaudhary, M., & Agrawal, R.
')#34.; V))2-"$A
B#G"3+G) @",+$+413 N)$4.2+#>&0,)$/.42) ')#34.;&V))2-"$A jO)1.4:4.(%+$&*".2?".)k
<.+:".;&'4:"/+$&')#34.;&T4./)9
6%)&(.+:".;&34:"/43)#34.;&$4./)9&+3&("./&45 &/%)& 34:"/43)#34.;&3;3/):Y&?%).)&/"$/+,)&.)(.)3)#/"/+4#&+3& 4.2).,;&".."#>)2&5.4:&/%)&/4)&/4&:41/%I
@",+$+413 !TB&8((,+$"/+4#
C)3/+-1,".&';3/): 前庭系
6%)&G)3/+-1,".&3;3/):&+3&/%)&3)#34.;&3;3/):&/%"/&(.4G+2)3& /%)&,)"2+#>&$4#/.+-1/+4#&/4&/%)&3)#3)&45 &-","#$)&"#2& 3("/+",&4.+)#/"/+4#&54.&/%)&(1.(43)&45 &$44.2+#"/+#>& :4G):)#/&?+/%&-","#$)
C+31",&T4./)9 視覚野
6%)&G+31",&$4./)9&45 &/%)&-."+#&+3&/%"/&("./&45 & /%)&$).)-.",&$4./)9&?%+$%&(.4$)33)3&G+31",& +#54.:"/+4#
@)$%"#4.)$)(/4. 機械受容器
T).)-),,1: 小脳
'4:"/+$&')#3)3
体性感覚
6%)&34:"/43)#34.;&3;3/):&+3&"&$4:(,)9&3;3/):&45 &3)#34.;& #)1.4#3&"#2&#)1.",&("/%?";3&/%"/&.)3(4#23&/4&$%"#>)3&"/&/%)& 31.5"$)&4.&+#3+2)&/%)&-42;Y&?%+$%&+#$,12)3& :)$%"#4.)$)(/4.3Y&$%):4.)$)(/4.3Y&"#2&#4$+$)(/4.3&&
O)1.",& B#54.:"/+4#&B#(1/
C28).'&-&+&41$'&$/#(.&01$ 23)')(4C G28)'&-&+&41
812+/4.;&T4./)9
6%)&"12+/4.;&$4./)9&+3&/%)&("./&45 &/%)&/):(4.",&,4-)& /%"/&(.4$)33)3&"12+/4.;&+#54.:"/+4#&+#&%1:"#3&"#2& :"#;&4/%).&G)./)-."/)3I&
6%)&$).)-),,1: +3&"&:"]4.&5)"/1.)&45 &/%)&%+#2-."+#& 45 &",,&G)./)-."/)3IB#&%1:"#3Y&/%)&$).)-),,1:&(,";3& "#&+:(4./"#/&.4,)&+#&:4/4.&$4#/.4,I&6%)&%1:"#& $).)-),,1:&$4#/.+-1/)3&/4&$44.2+#"/+4#Y&(.)$+3+4#Y& "#2&"$$1."/)&/+:+#>D&+/&.)$)+G)3&+#(1/&5.4:&3)#34.;& 3;3/):3Y&"#2&+#/)>."/)3&/%)3)&+#(1/3&/4&5+#)Z/1#)& :4/4.&"$/+G+/;I
09/."$/)2&<.+G"/) B#54.:"/+4#
8&:)$%"#4.)$)(/4.&+3&"&3)#34.;&.)$)(/4.&/%"/&.)3(4#23&/4& :)$%"#+$",&(.)331.)&4.&2+3/4./+4#I&O4.:",,;&/%).)&".)&541.& :"+#&/;()3&+#&>,"-.413D&,":),,".&$4.(13$,)3&j<"$+#+"#& $4.(13$,)3kY&/"$/+,)&$4.(13$,)3&j@)+33#).g3&$4.(13$,)3kY&@).A),& #).G)&)#2+#>3Y&"#2&-1,-413&$4.(13$,)3&jN155+#+&$4.(13$,)kI
0(+3/):4,4>;& 3/"./3& ?+/%& d/%)& (.4-,):& 45 & :+#2Ye& ?%+$%& $"#& ",34& -)& 5.":)2& "3& /%)& >"(& -)/?))#&:+#2&"#2&-42;I&!"3)2&4#&/%+3&>"(Y&-4/%&"3& .)>".23& )9(,"#"/+4#& "#2& 4#/4,4>+$",& )9+3/)#$)Y& (%+,434(%).3o& /%+#A+#>& +3& $,"33+5+)2& +#/4& 3+9& /;()3I& F#)&45 &/%)3)&+3&/;()ZV&:4#+3:&5.4:&/%)&241-,)Z"3Z ()$/& /%)4.;& 45 & +#54.:"/+4#Y& ?%+$%& $,"+:3& /%)& (%;3+$",& (%)#4:)#4#& "#2& /%)& (3;$%4,4>+$",& (%)#4:)#4#&".)&21",&"3()$/3&45 &"&3+#>,)&4.>"#+3:& 45 & +#54.:"/+4#I& 6%+3& +#54.:"/+4#",& :4#+3:& $4..)3(4#23&/4&/%)&G+)?&+#&(%;3+$3D&+#54.:"/+4#&R& 1,/+:"/)& .)",+/;I& 6%+3& $4..)3(4#2+#>& .),"/+4#3%+(& 3%4?3& /%)& (433+-+,+/;& 45 & "& 1#+5+)2& /%)4.;& 45 & 1,/+:"/)&.)$4>#+/+4#I&
G@(B*.)B#$HA@$@('#0D*9#?$
6%)& %;(4/%)/+$",& /)$%#4,4>;& O)1.4:4.(%+$& *".2?".)D& B#G"3+G)& !."+#ZT4:(1/).&B#/).5"$)j!Z TBk& $"#& )9(4./& "#2& +:(4./& #)1.",& 3+>#",3Y& ?%+$%& -.+#>3&?+/%&+/&/%)&(433+-+,+/;&45 &/%)&"$$1."/)&:"#+(Z 1,"/+4#& 45 & 3()$+5+$& 3)#3"/+4#3& ?+/%& 2+>+/",+[)2& 3+>#",3I&6%+3&+3&/%)&/)$%#4,4>;&/%"/&+:(,):)#/3&/%)& +#54.:"/+4#",&:4#+3:&/%"/&+3&341>%/&-;&)(+3/):4,Z 4>;I&
空間的 ૾ඥᛯ Spatial Methodology 8→!
jqk6."#3+/+4#
jXk'?+/$%
jRk@"+#/"+#
^)G),4(:)#/ T4#/.4,
jpk'/.)#>/%)#
8→8
jXk'?+/$%
<"#4.":" jO4&V.":)k
<).3+3/
T1/
^+3/"#$)
jpkjrkU44:&+#XF1/ jRkF#)&'$)#)
j9k
<43+/+4#
jqk@4G)
jXk'?+/$%&=4$"/+4#
'$)#)
jqk^+334,G) jqkb+() jqkV"2)&B#XF1/ jqkB.+3
jXk'?+/$%&')$)#)
6%)&2+3/"#$)&-)/?))#& /%)&4-3).G).&"#2&/%)& 3(4/I
6+:)
T,"33+5+$"/+4# C+31",
6%)&("#4.":"&G+31",&)55)$/&+#&CN&24)3&#4/&%"G)&/%)&5.":)&,+:+/"/+4#& ,+A)&5+,:I&'4&/%).)&+3&#4&3()$+5+$&G+3+4#&2+.)$/+4#I&6%.))&(.4()./+)3&45 & G+31",&3)#34.;&".)&2)G),4()2&+#/4&3)G).",&)2+/+#>&/;()3&1#2).&/%)& ^)G),4(:)#/&T4#/.4,I
<.4()./;& P)#)."/+4#
jrkb)"A)#
<.4()./+)3 P)#)."/+4#
擬似現実 ዻᨼ Space Editing(VR)
J).7*+$/#(.&01
5.":)
6)#3)
6)#3),)33
<).3+3/
T1/
6%)&,4$"/+4#&45 &/%)& 4-3).G).I
#$%&' ()%*'
V+,:
('+,-./
!TB
^+55).)#/&3$)#)&4.Y&+#& 4/%).&?4.2Y&3(4/I
CN
*"(/+$ '("/+",& F.+)#/"/+4#
映画 Image Editing ዻᨼ (Film)
G/8*')*+$/#(.&01
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
GI#'"&3&+&41?
6%)&V+,:&%"3&/%)&5.":)&,+:+/"/+4#Y&34&/%).)&+3&3()$+5+$&G+3+4#&2+.)$/+4#Y& ?%+$%&2).+G)3&3)G).",&)2+/+#>&/;()3&+#$,12+#>&T1/&8?";&"#2&T1//+#>& 4#&8$/+4#I&!"3)2&4#&/%+3&3()$+5+$&G+31",&2+.)$/+4#Y&/%.))&(.4()./+)3&45 & G+31",&3)#34.;&".)&2)G),4()2&+#/4&3)G).",&)2+/+#>&/;()3&1#2).&/%)& ^)G),4(:)#/&T4#/.4,I
^+.)$/+4# jV.":)k
<).3+3/
T1/
^+3/"#$)
jpkjrkU44:&+#XF1/ jRkF#)&'%4/
j9k
<43+/+4#
jqk=4#>&6"A)
jXkT1/&8?"; jXkT1//+#>&4#&8$/+4#
'$)#)
jqkT.433&^+334,G) jqkb+() jqkV"2)&B#XF1/ jqkB.+3 jqkB#G+3+-,)&T1/
jXk@4#/">) jXkn1:(&T1/ jXk@"/$%&T1/
6%)&2+3/"#$)&-)/?))#& /%)&G+)?&5.":)&"#2& 4-])$/I
6%)&,4$"/+4#&45 &/%)&G+)?& 5.":)&4.&$":)."I
^+55).)#/&3$)#)
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
感知 Sensory Editing ዻᨼ (BCI)
N"/%).&/%"#&3+#>,)&3)#34.;&)2+/+# CNY&!TB&$4:(.+3)3&3)G).",&3)#34 4G).",,&:"#+(1,"/+4#&"#2&+#/)>." 3)#34.;Y&%"(/+$&3)#34.;&"#2&G)3/+1#2).&/%)&^)G),4(:)#/&T4#/.4,& 2+55).)#/&3)#34.;&)2+/+#>I
J#.')57+*0$/#(.&01 ପ <.4])$/
ᚇ '+>%/
<.4()./;& P)#)."/+4# '("/+", F.+)#/"/+4# '41..41#2+#>
0,"(3)
!42;&!","#$)
!42;&-","#$)&/4?".23&"&3()$+5+$& 2+.)$/+4#Y&?%+$%&$"#&2+34.2).&/%)& #4.:",&3)#3)&45 &/%)&3("$)I
P."G+/;&^+.)$/+4#&
ѣ
P."G+/"/+4#",& 8$$),)."/+4#
ᦟ N)5,)$/
'%+5/
6%)&3)#3)&45 &>."G+/;&/4?".23&"& 3()$+5+$&2+.)$/+4#Y&?%+$%&$"#& )9/)#2&/%)&(433+-,)&2+.)$/+4#&45 & /%)&3("$)I
6%)&3)#3)&45 &">."G+/;I
ɥ <13%
zone of occurrent visual scanning formed by sets of imaging landing sites acting in conjunction with visual landing sites. zone of occurrent imaging formed by acting sets of imaging splitting sites
6%)&3)#3)&45 &-42;&3A+#&?%)#&"//"$%& /4&?+#2Y&$,4/%&4.&?",,Y&?%+$%&$"#& 54.:&"&345/&"#2&/4(4,4>+$",&3("$)I
!42;&'A+#Z <"33+G)&641$%
ᚑ
micro-tactile splitting site
& +)& +)& +)& +)& + ) !'%((!'% %'!((%'! )
#>&+#&5+,:&"#2& 4.;&3;3/):3I&6%)& "/+4#&45 &G+31",& -1,".&3)#34.;& &?+,,&2).+G)&
proprioceptive splitting site kinaesthetic splitting site tactile splitting site imaging splitting site(blank, visual 1, visual 2, visual 3, aural ,tactile, and kinaesthetic, respectively) locator-perceptual splitting site for establishing and maintaining distance (visual, kinaesthetic, aural, tactile, olfactory, respectively) locator-perceptual splitting site for assessing of volume or distance(visual, kinaesthetic, aural, tactile, olfactory respectively) a situation in which it occurs to the perceiver that what s/he sees(a visual landing site), s/he has only imagined (an imaging splitting site: visual 1, visual 2, visual 3 and blank) a situation in which the perceiver might come to realize that what s/he feels s/he’s not actually seeing (an imaging splitting site: visual 1, visual 2, visual 3, and blank ) s/he does, in fact see, ( a visual splitting site) n.b.i=v≠v=i perceptual events are non-commutative.
*"#2Z 8$/+G)&641$% ᆆ 6%)&3)#3)&45 &544/&?%)#&+/&"//"$%&/4& /%)&>.41#2Y&?%+$%&$"#&54.:&/%)& 345/#)33&"#2&/4(4,4>+$",&(.4()./;&45 & /%)&>.41#2&"#2&3/"+.3I&
V44/Z P.41#2
*".2#)33 '45/#)33 <.4()./;& P)#)."/+4# :*8')9$/#(.&01
@4G)
& *)& *)& *)& *)& *
visual splitting site
6%)&3)#3)&45 &%"#2&?%)#&+/&/41$%&/%)& 4-])$/&4.&?",,Y&?%+$%&$"#&54.:&/%)& /4(4,4>+$",&(.4()./;&45 &/%)&4-])$/I&&
6"$/+,)
! " # $ % )% ) % ) % ) % ) %
atmosheric-kinaesthetic splitting site
意味論
統語論
semantics
階層 hierarchy
syntax
↓・-#.#"#,/# !"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
定理
公理
分化 morphogenesis
theorem
axiom
公理系 axiomatic system
自己生産 auto-poiesis
soundness
↓・-#.#"#,/#
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
健全性
・A-2.8)B# ?8&2%-.&-=8.!3
自己組織化
自律
autonomy
self-organization
完全性
completeness 左 右
象徴交換
l'échange symbolique
ノイズ・インデュースト
noise-induced-orde
↓・-#.#"#,/# ↓・-#.#"#,/#
生命
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
bios
-D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
秩序 ↓・-#.#"#,/#
カオス
nomos
!"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
宇宙
cosmos
caos
ゆらぎ
fluctuation
er
-D2%1. '8)",)E 983".&:%;0#(&?%84 %9&#3)&3+
形式言語 formal languages
オートマトン automaton
↓・-#.#"#,/#
#8C,0 38'72%&,
ト・オーダー
ASCII 変換 ascii interchange
↓・-#.#"#,/#
-#,?'@A'BC%; ;(*).()*&:%;(&<":"(0%-#$%!8*=>83+#+/"/
インフォーメション information
正規化 regulate
再帰 recursion
抽象機械 abstract machine
因果 causality
帰納 induction
形式体系 formal system
コヒーレント系
coherent-system ↓・-#.#"#,/# F)GDC6+)'@D4D2) @87=:+?"(0%&#$%@>&8/ ↓・-#.#"#,/# !"#$%"&'()*#+%, !"#$%&#$%'&()*+,%-%'+.+//&*0%1#"(0
自己相似
auto-simulacre
情報力学
information-dynamics
ナーヴァス・システム cognitive theory
免疫系 immune network
!"#$%&'()-,,
89#:%'2;0<%".'8
I$54*+./9:*5;ETUF,T!U"!TF,T!UH -&+'()*+S9#.0'.5$9R$+($59V9J.5;$( 2A($59 (5.')+@9 (8$9 '&5>$9 A5*B9 .9 '/.44)'9 +&%$9 ?.)+()+@C9 (8$9 '&5>$9 )+($5.'(49 =)(89 (8$9 @5)%9 (*9 '5$.($9 >.5)*&49 '/*4$%9 '&5>$9 48.?$4D9 #5.@9 (8$9 %)AA$5$+(9 ?*)+(49 *A9 (8$9 48.?$9 )+9 .9 %)AA$5$+(9 %)5$'()*+9(*9A*5B9.94?.()./9>*/&B$D9<8$9(85$$"%)" B$+4)*+./9'&5>$98.49.9@5.%&./98$)@8(9.+%9/$+@(89 '8.+@$C9=8)'89*34'&5$49(8$93*&+%.5093$(=$$+9 (8$9%.0'.5$9'$+($59.+%9B.5;$(9=)(89.+9)+($5$4(" )+@94?.()./9$L?$5)$+'$D
=3
!"#$%&'()*+,
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
3>1?'2345/"#$'607%$
@;#A3/"5 I$54*+./9:*5; E!!F,T!]"TUF,T!UH <0?$S9:$39^9G**;