P ORTFOLIO
LIK LAM
I am always interested in how we interact with our urban society. The physical form of our society shapes a person’s living style, a city’s image and a country’s culture and values. I believe that good urban planning can improve an individual’s life, make a city attractive and competitive and yet not sacrifice and exploit our beautiful environment.
My sociological background has equipped me with strong analytical skills and sensitive cultural awareness to unveil urban problems through different perspectives and generate innovative solutions. Graduated from the University of Sydney in Master of Urbanism (Urban and Regional Planning), I am ready to dedicate myself to make this world a better place for everyone.
BACKGROUND
SKILLS
Analytical Skill
Data Processing Skill
Communication
Adobe Suite - Illustrator / InDesign
Sketchup
Arcmap (GIS)
LANGUAGES
Cantonese - Native
English - Professional
Mandarin - Professional
French - A2~B1
EDUCATION
2018 - 2019 | The University of Sydney
Master of Urbanism (Urban and Regional Planning)
2012 - 2014 | The University of Hong Kong
Bachelor of Social Sciences
• Majoring in Sociology
• Minoring in Urban Governance
nicklam720@gmail.com
06 33 92 14 35
2
I Strategic Plan - Westmead 2050
II Urban Form and Grid Study - Darling Harbour
III Land Use and Infrastructure Plan - Bella Vista
IV Feasibility Study - 142-152 Broadway
V GIS Mapping Project: Commute Modes Change - Greater Sydney
Two-page View / Scrolling for better reading. Thank you.
3
Strategic Plan Westmead 2050
Westmead (Parramatta) will be the second CDB in Greater Sydney Region and this project aims to study the potential of the site area and ignite the prosper future of Greater Sydney’s second CDB with a promising strategic plan.
To secure the leading development in Westmead, thorough research and analysis on 5 different elements are carried out. They are Economy, Community and Culture, Liveability, Connectivity and Ecology.
Overall, Westmead contains valuable aboriginal and colonial history that should never be buried. Parramatta River, Toongabbie Creek, Parramatta Park are the precious recreational assets that enhance both living quality and land value if being taken care nicely. Public transportation is weak but the upcoming light rail will improve the internal connection in Westmead. Low dense residential underlying the huge capacity to intake more population with the right development.
While Greater Sydney Commission and the City of Parramatta have their plans on Parramatta, none has included Westmead as a whole and plan together as a world-class city. Therefore, 2 development approaches have been studied and a liveable city approach is finalised.
Traditionally, great cities capitalises the benefits of being located close to the waterfront. Westmead will follow their steps and by unlocking the true potential of waterfronts in Westmead and Parramatta, Westmead will be an attractive and well-integrated city that celebrates nature, heritage and culture, thus catalysing sustainable growth and innovation.
4
1.2 Surrounding Area
1.3 Demography
Westmead 2050 within immediate surrounding:
• Rich in Natural Environment Assets of Parramatta River, Parramatta Park and Parramatta Lake
• Equipped with three existing train Station.
• Envisioned to be an Intermodal Public Transport City with upcoming Metro and Light Rail development.
• Containing six different suburbs with each distinct characteristic.
• Within close proximity with the Western Sydney University
Parramatta and the Olympic Peninsula. On these accounts, Westmead is at unprecedented high pace of growth within 30 years time.
A successful strategic plan requires a depth understanding of people’s needs and trends which occur to the place. The statistical information of population characteristic would enable all stakeholder to capture the existing and projected future of one city. The conducted research is limited to factors that are significant to our strategic plan. All figure is generated from the Australian Bureau of Statistics survey data in 2016, compiled and presented by Profile.id. Community profiles include five year age group, birth country, language spoken at home, household types, housing tenure, household income, methods travel to work, commute lifestyle and employment industry.
The figures of birthplace and language spoken at home indicate an emerging overseas migrant population in Westmead. Overall, 36,1% of the population was aged between 25 to 44 year olds with the largest age group being 30 to 34 years old. It indicates the demand for services and facilities to suit this demography. An emerging group of newborn population is also seen in the age structure justified the 35% of the population who are couples with children. The largest portion of the household has medium income and 75% of the population were private renters. Indicating the socio-economic status of Westmead, these figures are important to study the housing market and the affordability. The two biggest employment sector are health care, social assistance, professional, scientific and technical services. Almost 80% of all workers live outside Parramatta CBD and Westmead. Residents remain to use private cars over public transportation which indicates an issue that needs to be revisited.
Westmead is young, diverse, family oriented, they are car-dependent, and the biggest percentage of workers come from health care and social assistance. The authors conclude that Westmead must adapt its built form in order to support this type of demography.
Westmead is a part of the City of Parramatta Council closely neighbouring with Cumberland Council down to the south-west side of the site, consisted of six smaller suburbs with each distinct characteristics including Wentworthville, Constitution Hill, Westmead, North Parramatta, Northmead, and Parramatta. Situated around rich natural environment assets such as Parramatta River, Parramatta Park and Parramatta Lake, Westmead is potential to be developed with great amenities. The three existing train stations serving Western line, Cumberland line and Inner West line which terminates in Parramatta. Adjacent key destinations are Wentworthville Local Centre, Western Sydney University and the New Aquatic Leisure Centre. Upcoming light rail and metro, the Parramatta Square and the New Aquatic Leisure Centre will surely build on the value and characteristics of the place. The authors aim to develop a Strategic Plan for Westmead that would sustain this transformation.
5 12 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
Birth Country Three Dominant Types of Household Methods of Travel to Work Housing Tenure Language Spoken at Home Household Income Employment Industry Five Year Age Group Source Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census of Population and Housing 2016. Compiled and presented by .id the population experts. 0-4 7.3% 5-9 6.2% 10-14 4.9% 15-19 5.1% 20-24 6.6% 25-29 9.2% 30-34 11.1% Renting - Private CAR 75% Mortgage 17% Fully Owned 4% Not Stated 3% Renting - Social Housing 1% 55.1% TRAIN 21.5% BUS 5.9% WALK 3.5% BICYCLE 0.4% Other 1% Health Care and Social Assistance 12.5% Professional, Scientific and Technical Services 11.4% Retail Trade 9.0% Education and Training 7.9% Financial and Insurance Services 7.2% ENGLISH Commute Lifestyle Live and Work in Parramatta 21% Work in Parramatta and live outside 79% HINDI MANDARIN GUJARATI TAMIL 35-39 8.8% 40-44 7.0% 45-49 6.0% $ $ $ $ $ $ 50-54 5.8% 55-59 5.3% 60-64 4.6% 65-69 3.8% 70-74 2.9% 75-79 2.2% 80-84 1.6% 85 over 1.7% Australia Other Not Stated 49.5% 44.6% 0.9% 35.3% Single 14.7% Couples without children 22.4% Couples with children Low Medium High 13 Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan Birth Country Three Dominant Types of Household Methods of Travel to Work Housing Tenure Language Spoken at Home Household Income Employment Industry Five Year Age Group Source Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census of Population and Housing 2016. Compiled and presented by .id the population experts. 0-4 7.3% 5-9 6.2% 10-14 4.9% 15-19 5.1% 20-24 6.6% 25-29 9.2% 30-34 11.1% Renting - Private CAR 75% Mortgage 17% Fully Owned 4% Not Stated 3% Renting - Social Housing 1% 55.1% TRAIN 21.5% BUS 5.9% WALK 3.5% BICYCLE 0.4% Other 1% Health Care and Social Assistance 12.5% Professional, Scientific and Technical Services 11.4% Retail Trade 9.0% Education and Training 7.9% Financial and Insurance Services 7.2% ENGLISH Commute Lifestyle Live and Work in Parramatta 21% Work in Parramatta and live outside 79% HINDI MANDARIN GUJARATI TAMIL 35-39 8.8% 40-44 7.0% 45-49 6.0% $ $ $ $ $ $ 50-54 5.8% 55-59 5.3% 60-64 4.6% 65-69 3.8% 70-74 2.9% 75-79 2.2% 80-84 1.6% 85 over 1.7% Australia Other Not Stated 49.5% 44.6% 0.9% 35.3% Single 14.7% Couples without children 22.4% Couples with children
10
1.1 Metropolitan Area
CENTRAL RIVER CITY WESTERN PARKLAND CITY EASTERN HARBOUR CITY 2 km N Parramatta CBD Sydney Olympic Park Liverpool Blacktown Penrith Sydney CBD Western Sydney Airport 30km 25km Westmead Metropolitan Centre General Distance between cities Metropolitan Cluster Rail Line Corridor GPOP area 11 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
500 m N North Parramatta Parramatta Camellia Harris Park Merrylands Oatlands Constitution Hill Wentworthville Northmead Westmead T T T
WESTERN SYDNEY UNIVERSITY NEW AQUATIC LEISURE CENTRE WENTWORTHVILLE LOCAL CENTRE LAKE PARRAMATTA PARRAMATTA RIVER L M F LGA Boundary Key Destinations Future Metro Line Future Light Rail Existing Rail Line Existing Ferry Routes Site Boundary
CityofParramatta CumberlandCouncil
2.6 SWOT | Summary
By synthesising the SWOT analysis of each theme, the key strengths and weaknesses, crucial opportunities, and most pressing threats were identified.
Across all themes, strengths were noted in the Westmead Health & Education Precinct and Parramatta CBD, whether tangible - such as commercial nodes or high density dwellings - or intangible, including community and social infrastructure. Other predominant strengths include the Parramatta Park and River and existing resources such as bus networks, green space, and heritage assets.
In general, weaknesses identified on site related to inefficient use of space due to either low density residential zoning or inactive frontages. Other notable weaknesses are low tree canopy coverage (affecting both Ecology and Liveability outcomes) and the functioning of Parramatta Park and River as barriers to intra-site connectivity.
In turn, each of these weaknesses gives rise to significant opportunities for growth and development.
The upcoming light rail presents a critical opportunity for linking the site and bolstering economic possibilities, while there is significant scope to supplement existing bus routes with an inter-modal public transport network. Furthermore, there is a unique opportunity to revitalise and positively transform the Parramatta River. Flooding and the urban heat island effect, the foremost threats to Westmead, are both environmental and can be curbed through a combination of ecological policies and physical intervention. Both threats will be significant in shaping the development of action plans in each theme.
5.1 Strategic Option 1
Stage 1: 2020 - 2025
STRATEGIC OPTION 1
Double Economic Powerhouse City
In this strategy, development radiates outwards from two key sites: the Westmead Health & Education precinct and Parramatta CBD. Intensive development of the economy and infrastructure at both sites transforms them into twin economic hubs that attract new residents, investors, and ultimately drive the development and transformation of the rest of the site.
The first stage in this strategic option focuses on consolidating the twin economic cores of the Westmead Health & Education Precinct and the Parramatta CBD. This will be achieved through a number of measures including creating new jobs, investing in the expansion of the H&E Precinct and CBD, and upgrading infrastructure in both cores. To achieve this, a combination of policy changes and physical interventions will be undertaken.
Stage 2: 2025 - 2035
Once Westmead’s position as a highly competitive economic powerhouse and employment hotbed has been secured, the focus will shift toward attracting new residents to the site. Development and investment will begin to radiate outward from the two cores, and new connections between discrete parts of Westmead will be established. Actions in this stage will focus on delivering vital resources such as housing and public transport networks.
Stage 3: 2035 - 2050
Provide jobs first
In the final stage, focus shifts toward enhancing liveability and delivering amenities to residents and visitors. This will entail the provision of social infrastructures such as schools, affordable housing, and community spaces, in addition to a high quality public domain, ample green space, and cultural and leisure amenities. This stage will add another facet to Westmead’s character and cement its position as a key regional hub. People
6 30 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
STRENGTH H&E Precinct and Parramatta CBD Heritage Assets Parramatta Park and River Existing Bus Routes Green Space
31 Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan WEAKNESS OPPORTUNITY THREAT Low Density Residential Inactive Frontages Park and River as Barriers Low Tree Canopy Coverage Light Rail Enhanced Transport Links River Revitalisation Flooding Urban Heat Islands 52 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
Image: Westmead Hospital Source: Delloite 2016 53 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
come to work & live
amenities
Provide more
5.2 Strategic Option 2
Stage
STRATEGIC OPTION 2 Liveable River City
In this strategy, development follows a linear path along the Parramatta River, one of the site’s most unique and celebrated elements. The targeted revitalisation will transform the River into a distinctive feature that is attractive to future
and
1: 2020 - 2025
In this strategic option, the first priority is revitalising the Parramatta River and positioning it as Westmead’s foremost attraction. To achieve this, a comprehensive ecological strategy including remediation and conservation works and policy development will be undertaken. The river revitalisation will also extend to Toongabbie Creek and all waterfront foreshores, the latter of which will be activated as cultural spaces and the venue for a program of community events.
Stage 2:
2025
- 2035
The second stage of development will meet the needs of new residents and businesses attracted to Westmead by the newly revitalised river. This will entail the provision of new schools, a vibrant public domain, an expanded public transport network, and greater commercial opportunities, alongside the diversification of housing stock to include affordable housing and varied typologies. Concurrently, cultural programs and venues will ensure Westmead’s unique heritage and community are celebrated.
Stage 3: 2035 - 2050
At this point, actions will specifically target employment growth within Westmead and focus on consolidating a framework for sustainable economic development. In addition to providing new jobs in the existing health and education industries, this stage will see the creation of jobs in a diverse range of fields including technology and the arts. To accommodate this, new commercial space will be provided across the site through a combination of construction and upgrading existing structures.
Make it attractive
5.4 Strategic Option Comparison
PROS
• Holistic, “big picture” development approach that distributes investment across the site
• Cohesive, considered riverside development that provides a strong spine for the city
option 1 focuses on economic growth from the beginning and while strategic option
• Prioritisation of economy over environment and social factors
• Potential mismatch between demand and rapid rate of development
Potential displacement of existing working class communities
Decentralisation of economic functions safeguards against failure
• Potential for inconsistency between precincts as they are developed individually
• Environmental and cultural risks entailed with rapid development Wealth and investment remains concentrated instead of spread throughout site
• Potential mismatch between demand and rapid rate of development
• Strategic management of environmental complications associated with river, e.g. flooding and drought
PROS Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan New Dwelling Provision in Different Development Models
• Allows pace of development to be dictated by need
• Slower rate of development due to environmental practicalities of rehabilitating river
percentage of Affordable Rental Housing: 20% and Social Housing 5%
7 54 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
other areas and resources
site (e.g. housing, schools,
be in accordance with demand as growth spreads beyond the river.
residents
investors alike; development of
on
etc.) will
first
Image: Artist Impression of Parramatta River Source: City of Parramatta 2017 55 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan People come to live & work
more jobs
Provide
58 Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan
STRATEGIC OPTION 1 STRATEGIC OPTION 2 Double Economic Powerhouse City Liveable River City Central City District Plan, GSC 2018 BUSINESS AS USUAL • Strong, interconnected transport and infrastructure network • Cohesive intermodal public transport system • Clear development corridors enabling systematic implementation • Distribution of investment and development across the sites • Anchor points of Westmead H&E Precinct and Parramatta CBD • Easier implementation due to correspondence with existing planning documents • Clear focus on different development precincts, each with distinct action plans • Widely used development method with fairly predictable results •
PROS
• Difficulty entailed in coordinating between multiple stakeholders Potential congestion along riverfront preventing equal access CONS CONS CONS 59
Employment Growth in Different Development Models Target
Both
Strategic
2
to Appendix 5 The
Phase Indicators Business as Usual Option 1 Option 2 2025 Employment 60,021 68,181 60,021 Dwellings 3,113 3,569 3,113 2035 Employment 72,265 94,584 91,092 Dwellings 10,777 12,588 12,781 2050 Employment 95,469 154,540 170,314 Dwellings 27,028 32,570 34,946
With the data from the city of Parramatta and Census, the employment and dwellings in Westmead from the last 12 – 15 years are obtained. We have used the data to project the growth in three options, Business As Usual, Strategic option 1 and 2. For Business As Usual, growth in employment and dwellings is significantly lower than both strategic option 1 and 2, with only around 35,000 new jobs to be created and 24,000 new dwellings to be built.
strategic options are believed to achieved much high growth in terms of employment and new dwelling completion.
believes in the additional value contribute to the economy by revitalising the river. Detail calculation can refer
charts below further shows how the strategic option will achieve a higher outcome for the first 15 to 20 years but strategic option 2 potentially can boost up even higher outcome if successfully utilising the river asset.
Appendix 5. Employment Projection
Average % Growth from 2008 to 2018 in table 2
1.873636364
Average % Growth % of top 7 years in table 2 = reference for Option 1 (high growth)
3.327142857
Average % Growth % of top 3 years in table 2 = reference for Option 2 after 2025 (very high growth)
Table 1 shows the calculation of getting the employment in Westmead in 2016 with the Census data.
Table 2 show the employment change in City of Parramatta from 2001 t0 2008.
Table 3 show 3 average percentage change from table 2. The first one shows the average of employment growth in from 2008 to 2018, which is used as projection for Business as usual. Second number is the top 7 employment growth from 2001 to 2018, which is used to project if Strategic option 1 is adopted as a strong economic outcome is expected. Last number represent the top 3 employment growth from 2001 to 2018, which represent the even higher growth which revitalisation of river can bring to Westmead after 2025.
Number in blue boxes are used in section 5.4 Strategic Option Comparison.
Appendix 6. Dwelling Projection
Table 1 shows the calculation of getting the population in Westmead in 2017 from the Idprofile - City of Parramtta.
Table 2 shows the population growth in City of Parramatta from 2006 t0 2018.
Table 3 shows 3 average percentage change from table 2. The first one shows the average of population growth in from 2006 to 2018, which is used as projection for Business as usual. Second number is the top 7 employment growth from 2006 to 2018, which is used to project if Strategic option 1 is adopted as a strong economic outcome is expected. Last number represent the top 3 employment growth from 2001 to 2018, which represent the even higher growth which revitalisation of river can bring to Westmead after 2025.
Table 4 shows the population growth according to different projection used.
Table 5 uses the population growth to calculate dwellings needed in Westmead in different option. Numbers highlighted in blue boxes in table 5 are used in section 5.4 Strategic Option Comparison.
8 100 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan Table 1: Employment in Westmead (2016 Census) 2016 Location code Employment Westmead H&E Precinct 114913685 11236 114913685 993 114913685 406 Subtotal 12635 Parramatta CBD 114923765 5635 114923761 4889 114923762 3834 114923763 10545 114923760 4621 114923758 3594 114923757 5032 Subtotal 38150 Total employment in Westmead in 2016 50785 *** number is reduce in proportion if some locations code are only partly in the site Table 2: City of Parramatta employment from 2001 to 2018 Year Number % change 2001 134,519 2002 135,367 0.63 2003 138,945 2.64 2004 140,085 0.82 2005 139,785 -0.21 2006 141,453 1.19 2007 145,322 2.74 2008 150,207 3.36 2009 151,507 0.87 2010 151,460 -0.03 2011 155,185 2.46 2012 156,511 0.85 2013 157,478 0.62 2014 157,430 -0.03 2015 158,090 0.42 2016 163,673 3.53 2017 168,047 2.67 2018 177,940 5.89
102 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan Table1: Population in Westmead 2017 2017 Ratio population Population in boundary Parramatta 0.8 30167 24134 North Parramatta 0.8 14366 11493 Westmead 1 10062 10062 Northmead 0.25 12487 3122 Constitution Hill 0.3 4337 1301 Wentworthville 0.3 5546 1664 Total 3.45 76965 51776 Table 2: City of Parramatta Population from 2006 to 2018 2006 180,919 2007 185,175 4,256 2.35 2008 189,684 4,509 2.44 2009 195,136 5,452 2.87 2010 199,575 4,439 2.27 2011 203,205 3,630 1.82 2012 208,363 5,158 2.54 2013 214,818 6,455 3.1 2014 221,568 6,750 3.14 2015 228,248 6,680 3.01 2016 234,444 6,196 2.71 2017 243,557 9,113 3.89 2018 251,311 7,754 3.18 Table 4: Projection on population growth to 2050 in Westmead BAU Strategic Option 1 Strategic Option 2 2017 51776 51776 51776 2018 53214 53396 53214 2019 54692 55067 54692 2020 56211 56790 56211 2021 57772 58567 57772 2022 59376 60399 59376 2023 61025 62289 61025 2024 62719 64238 62719 2025 64460 66248 64460 2026 66250 68321 66654 2027 68090 70458 68922 2028 69981 72662 71268 2029 71924 74935 73693 2030 73921 77279 76201 2031 75974 79697 78794 2032 78084 82190 81476 2033 80252 84761 84249 2034 82480 87413 87116 2035 84770 90148 90081 2036 87124 92968 93147 2037 89543 95877 96317 2038 92029 98877 99595 2039 94584 101970 102985 2040 97210 105160 106490 2041 99909 108450 110114 2042 102683 111843 113862 2043 105534 115342 117737 2044 108464 118951 121744 2045 111476 122672 125887 2046 114571 126510 130171 2047 117752 130468 134601 2048 121022 134550 139182 2049 124382 138759 143919 2050 127836 143100 148817 Table 3: Different growth projection Average % Growth from 2006 to 2018 in table 2 2.776666667 Average % Growth % of top 7 years in table 2 = reference for Option 1 (high growth) 3.128571429 Average % Growth % of top 3 years in table 2 = reference for Option 2 after 2025 (very high growth) 3.403333333
101 Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan
4.26
Table 4: Projection on Emplyment growth to 2050 in Westmead BAU Strategic Option 1 Strategic Option 2 2016 50,785 50785 50785 2017 51,737 52475 51737 2018 52,706 54221 52706 2019 53,694 56025 53694 2020 54,700 57889 54700 2021 55,725 59815 55725 2022 56,769 61805 56769 2023 57,833 63861 57833 2024 58,917 65986 58917 2025 60,021 68181 60021 2026 61,146 70449 62578 2027 62,292 72793 65244 2028 63,459 75215 68023 2029 64,648 77718 70921 2030 65,859 80304 73942 2031 67,093 82976 77092 2032 68,350 85737 80376 2033 69,631 88590 83800 2034 70,936 91538 87370 2035 72,265 94584 91092 2036 73,619 97731 94973 2037 74,998 100983 99019 2038 76,403 104343 103237 2039 77,835 107815 107635 2040 79,293 111402 112220 2041 80,779 115109 117001 2042 82,293 118939 121985 2043 83,835 122896 127182 2044 85,406 126985 132600 2045 87,006 131210 138249 2046 88,636 135576 144138 2047 90,297 140087 150278 2048 91,989 144748 156680 2049 93,713 149564 163355 2050 95,469 154540 170314 103 Westmead 2050 Integrated Strategic Plan Table 5: Dwelling Projection base on population growth projection BAU Option1 Option2 2025 Growth since 2017 8249 9458 8249 Devided by average household size: 2.65 3113 3569 3113 2035 Growth since 2017 28559 33358 33870 Devided by average household size: 2.61 10777 12588 12781 2050 Growth since 2017 71625 86310 92606 Devided by average household size: 2.59 27028 32570 34946 *** it is expected the average household size will continue to decrease
Appendix 4. Dwelling Calculation
Summary
9 99 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
North Parratamatta intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 170.000 510.000 510.000 382500 5100 12750 population : 12750 number of dwelling : 5100 Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 4 19.000 17.100 B 2,5 48.000 108000 C 2 115000 230000 D11 1,7 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build 105.300 1200000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 30 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 75m2 average household 2.5 80 35 20 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 average household 2.6 D C North Parratamatta intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 170.000 510.000 510.000 382500 5100 12750 population : 12750 number of dwelling : 5100 Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 4 19.000 17.100 B 2,5 48.000 108000 C 2 115000 230000 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build 58.500 105.300 600.000 1200000 400.000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 30 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 75m2 average household 2.5 80 35 20 average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 A A B A North Parramatta Intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build 170.000 510.000 510.000 382500 5100 12750 Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 4 19.000 17.100 B 2,5 48.000 108000 C 2 115000 230000 D11 1,7 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use East Parramatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 2 58.500 105.300 B 2 600.000 1200000 C 1,7 400.000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 population : 38700 number of dwelling : 14890 Mixed Use 35 20 11 total 80 35 20 total Gross floor area required 75% Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 average household 2.6 A B C C D A Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 19.000 17.100 B 48.000 108000 C 115000 230000 D11 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use East Parramatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 2 58.500 105.300 B 2 600.000 1200000 C 1,7 400.000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 population : 38700 35 20 11 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 A B C A D C C B B C D East Parramatta North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 15.000 40.500 400000 300000 740.500 555375 5554 14440 FSRsite area m2allowed to build 660.000 1200000 1.860.000 1395000 13950 34875 FSRsite area m2allowed to build 27.000 740000 280000 1.047.000 785250 7853 20417 35 B C C B North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 15.000 40.500 B 2 200.000 400000 C 3 100000 300000 740.500 555375 5554 14440 FSRsite area m2allowed to build 330.000 660.000 400.000 1200000 1.860.000 1395000 13950 34875 FSRsite area m2allowed to build 10.000 27.000 370.000 740000 140000 280000 1.047.000 785250 7853 20417 Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 35 20 30 total B C C A B A B B C FSRsite area m2allowed to build 2.300.000 2.300.000 1725000 17250 44850 summary Western Westmead 7800 phase 2: 32625 Westmead transport hub 4000 phase 3: 35925 East Parramatta 14900 North Toongabbie creek 5500 North Parramatta intersection5100 North Parramatta 14000 Parramatta CBD 17250 total 68550 A FSRsite area m2allowed to build 2.875.000 2.300.000 2.300.000 1725000 17250 44850 summary Western Westmead 7800 phase 2: 32625 Westmead transport hub 4000 phase 3: 35925 East Parramatta 14900 per dwelling 100m2 A North Parratamatta intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to buil A population : 12750 number of dwelling : 5100 Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to buil A B C D11 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use East Parramatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to buil A B C population : 38700 number of dwelling : 14890 Mixed Use 30 35 20 11 80 35 20 A B C D C D A North Parratamatta intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 170.000 510.000 510.000 382500 5100 12750 population : 12750 number of dwelling : 5100 Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 4 19.000 17.100 B 2,5 48.000 108000 C 2 115000 230000 D11 1,7 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use East Parramatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to buil A 2 58.500 105.300 B 2 600.000 1200000 C 1,7 400.000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 population : 38700 number of dwelling : 14890 Mixed Use 30 35 20 11 total total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 75m2 average household 2.5 80 35 20 total Gross floor area required 75% Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 average household 2.6 A B C D Westmead Transport Hub North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed A B C population : 14440 number of dwelling : 5500 Mixed Use North Parratamatta Proposed Building HeightProposed A B population : 34900 number of dwelling : 13950 Wenthworthville Proposed Building HeightProposed A B C D population : 20417 dwelling : 7800 Mixed Use 30 average floor space 35 20 30 20 average floor space average floor spac 30 20 11 C A B B C A North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 15.000 40.500 B 2 200.000 400000 C 3 100000 300000 740.500 555375 5554 14440 population : 14440 number of dwelling : 5500 Mixed Use North Parratamatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 2 330.000 660.000 B 3 400.000 1200000 1.860.000 1395000 13950 34875 population : 34900 number of dwelling : 13950 Wenthworthville Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 10.000 27.000 B 2 370.000 740000 C 2 140000 280000 D 1.047.000 785250 7853 20417 population : 20417 dwelling : 7800 Mixed Use 30 Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 35 20 30 total 20 average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100 m2 average household 2.5 30 20 11 total Gross floor area required 75% B C B A
Toongabbie Creek North Parratamatta intersection Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 170.000 510.000 510.000 382500 5100 12750 population : 12750 number of dwelling : 5100 Westmead transport hub Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 4 19.000 17.100 B 2,5 48.000 108000 C 2 115000 230000 D11 1,7 30000 51000 406.100 304575 4061 10559 population : 10560 number of dwelling : 4000 Mixed Use East Parramatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 2 58.500 105.300 B 2 600.000 1200000 C 1,7 400.000 680000 1.985.300 1488975 14890 38713 population : 38700 number of dwelling : 14890 Mixed Use 30 35 20 11 total total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 75m2 average household 2.5 80 35 20 total Gross floor area required 75% Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 average floor space per dwelling 75 m2 average household 2.6 A B C C C D A North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed A B C population : 14440 number of dwelling : 5500 Mixed Use North Parratamatta Proposed Building HeightProposed A B population : 34900 number of dwelling : 13950 Wenthworthville Proposed Building HeightProposed A B C D population : 20417 dwelling : 7800 Mixed Use 30 average floor space 35 20 30 20 average floor space average floor spac 30 20 11 B C C A B A B B C B A North Toongabbie Creek Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 15.000 40.500 B 2 200.000 400000 C 3 100000 300000 740.500 555375 5554 14440 population : 14440 number of dwelling : 5500 Mixed Use North Parratamatta Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 2 330.000 660.000 B 3 400.000 1200000 1.860.000 1395000 13950 34875 population : 34900 number of dwelling : 13950 Wenthworthville Proposed Building HeightProposed FSRsite area m2allowed to build A 3 10.000 27.000 B 2 370.000 740000 C 2 140000 280000 D 1.047.000 785250 7853 20417 population : 20417 dwelling : 7800 Mixed Use 30 Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 35 20 30 total 20 average floor space per dwelling 100m2 average household 2.6 total Gross floor area required 75% average floor space per dwelling 100 m2 average household 2.5 30 20 11 total Gross floor area required 75% B C C A B A B B C B A Wenthworthville Western Westmead 7800 Westmead Transport Hub 4000 East Parramatta 14900 North Toongabbie Creek 5500 North Parramatta Intersection 5100 North Parramatta 14000 Parramatta CBD 17250 TOTAL 68550 Phase 2 32625 Phase 3 35925
North
of Dwelling Target
Responsible for the theme - Economy, three objectives and action plans are proposed.
1. To ensure Westmead becomes a real CDB and an economic powerhouse, It is necessary to increase commercial space provision and strengthen the night-time economy in key areas, as it would make the CBD more attractive for workers and residents nearby.
2. Building a resilient economy means to develop varies industrial. The light industrial land in North Parramatta is proposed to be revitalised as an art and innovation hub. Local artists and young entrepreneurs are encouraged to more there with government-supported co-living housing scheme and cheap warehouse workshops. Recreation and entertainment facilities will be strengthened in Parramatta Park, Parramatta River and Toongabbie Creek to support the tourism industry.
3. With an expected growth in population, new local centres are identified and key development should with appropriate changes in planning controls.
Divided into 3 stages, Westmead will focus on strengthening the growth in Parramatta CDB and revitalisation of Parramatta Park and Parramatta River in the first 5 years. This is to build a solid foundation of Parramatta CDB with high land value to attract more investment. Meanwhile, thorough studies and necessary changes in planning controls in other areas will be conducted.
In the next 15 years, rapid development will be ignited in Westmead Health and Education Precinct and East Parramatta. It is to focus on the housing, public and social infrastructure and ensure a high-quality metropolitan living style in Westmead and Parramatta.
At stage 3, the development will extend to North Parramatta and West Westmead. Stable provision of varies types of housing, as well as excellent design of local centres and infrastructure, will support sustainable growth in Westmead and Parramatta. Westmead will be a true new CDB of Greater Sydney that attract everyone around the world.
10
To ensure economy Westmead.
First, it is of the Parramatta While hundreds be invested environment and workers. near Church much land omy and and pubs the longer cally increase commercial current m2 of floor which cannot for providing
OBJECTIVE 1
Securing economic and employment growth in Parramatta CBD and Westmead Health and Education
OBJECTIVE 2
Developing various industries to build a resilient economic growth in Wesmead
ACTION PLAN
OBJECTIVE 3
Developing new local centres to support future population growth in the long run
Precedent: Rouse Hill Centre, Rouse Hill
ACTION PLAN
• Revitalise Parramatta River and Tonngabie Creek
• Increase commercial office space
• Prioritise public domain renewal
• Develop night-time economy
• Ultilise Parramatta Park and new Bankwest Stadium with more international events and festivals
• Extend Parramatta CBD along Church Street with commercial and night-time economy
• Revitalise light industrial land in North Westmead to Art and Innovation Hub
6.1.1 Strategic Action Plan | Economy
Site
OBJECTIVE 1
Securing economic and employment growth in Parramatta CBD and Westmead Health and Education Precinct
STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN
• Build more commercial floor space by increasing building height and Floor Space Ratio (FSR)
• Improve walking experience on Church St and Hawkesbury Rd with high quality public domain design
• Prioritise pedestrian walking path over car roads
• Expand Westmead H&E Precinct to Northmead
OBJECTIVE 2
Developing various industries to build a resilient economic growth in Westmead
STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN
• Develop strong night-time economy on Church Street and Hawkesbury Road
• Revitalise and utilise Parramatta River
• Develop new attractions along Parramatta River
• Revitalise North Parramatta industrial land into Art and Innovation Hub with cheap rent for artists and startups
• Intergrate with provision of public amenities
• Improve accessibility to local centres
1. Victoria Road between Macarthur Street and Gaggin Street - Rezone from B1 / R3 / R4 to B2
2. Hawkesbury Road from Westmead Station to Helen Street - Rezone from Queens Road to Helen Street from R4 to R4
3. Darcy Road on west side of Westmead H&E Precinct - Slowly expend economy nearby
Second, developing on business is highly indigenous be strong the future Parramatta in Westmead CBD. Large ised into house space the next With the to plan needs and vices, libraries residential North Parramatta should be imate to
Site Boundaries Potential New Local Centres
OBJECTIVE 3
Developing new local centres to support future population growth in the long run
Precedent: George Street, Sydney CBD
Source: Katt Gao n.d.
ACTION PLAN
• Identify and rezone land for local centres
• Integrate local centres with mixed commercial, residential and public amenities
• Widen and prioritise pedestrian walking path in local centres
• Limit car speed
• Improve public transportation network to access local centres
To achieve a stronger economy in Westmead, economic growth in the Parramatta CBD and the Westmead H&E precinct will be prioritised. Revitalising Parramatta River, particularly near Church Street with a more inclusive waterfront can allow more space for events and festivals. Extending Vivid to Parramatta can be considered. Expanding restaurants and pubs along the
river will With the Street will active frontage bury road
of Toongabbie the
Apart from Parramatta walk and quality event facility in er will be field. The lead visitors the Cumberland ings will be new iconic attracting The Art and centre for move in. key to success. ated by the ty-based generations With the in varies centres with crucial for the new Parramatta matta; North land Hospital; Hawkesbury Road near
11 38 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan 4.1 Objective + Action
Economy
Plan:
1. Parramatta Park 2. New Bankwest Stadium 3. Potential new Museum 4. Parramatta Square 5. New Aquatic Leisure Centre
Precinct
ACTION PLAN
Site Boundaries R4 High Density Residential Zone B4 Mixed Use Zone Parramatta CBD Parramatta Light Rail Site Boundaries R4 High Density Residential Zone B4 Mixed Use Zone Parramatta CBD Parramatta Light Rail Potential Growth of Parramatta CBD Westmead H&E Precinct Potential Growth of H&E Precinct Main Road Westmead H&E Precinct R4 High Density Residential Zone B4 Mixed Use Zone Major Construction Project/Event Venues Precedent: Texas Medical Centre, Texas Source: Drivenxdesign n.d. Precedent: Lxfactory, Lisbon Source: Archdaily 2017 1 2 3 4 5
Site Boundaries R4 High Density Residential Zone B4 Mixed Use Zone Parramatta Light Rail Parramatta CBD Westmead H&E Precinct New Local Centres
Source: Author
64 Westmead 2050 | Integrated Strategic Plan
Boundaries Parramatta CBD & Westmead H&E Precinct Public Domain Revitalisation Tourist Focus Development Night Time Economy Art & Innovation Hub
East Parramatta North Parramatta New TOD Precinct Westmead Wentworthville
Westmead
Westmead
the order to into a authors
Parramatta
Westmead as plan revitalising as the the the intends quality stormwater waterways, Bike diverse festivals to Also, within be for the locals secure the employment areas would environmentally home and and such as Frog
Protecting for for ecosystem. range of (e.g. Woodland
Stage 1 2020 - 2025
Parramatta Park Revitalisation
• Flora and fauna research
• Setup habitat protection policy
• Waterways improvement
• Pedestrian access improvement to surrounding sites
• Adding more activity clusters
• Improve amenities and lighting
• Conducting more events and festivals
Toongabie Creek
Bushland Reserve
• Flora and fauna research
• Setup habitat protection policy
• Waterways improvement
• Pedestrian access improvement to surrounding sites
Recreational Bike Path
• Implementing Parramatta Bike Plan
• Oudoor gym facilities
• Stormwater response tree planting
12 1 | 5 Years
T T
L L L L
Night Time Economy
Enhanced Cultural Programming
Multilingual Signage Pilot Area
Heritage Adaptive Reuse
Special Cultural Buildings
Recreational Bike Path
Parramatta River Revitalisation
• Strong night time economy
• Numerous cultural programs
• Active inclusive waterfront
• Waterways improvement
Heritage Walk Path
• Research / observation
• Installation
• Waterways improvement
and line this and habitat up and to these improved keep
Westmead Transport Hub
Light Rail
Light Rail Station
New Free Shuttle Bus
Train Line
Endangered Vegetation Protection
Priority Precinct
At the walk side created the heritage the recreation. The a Westmead increased and area. residential properties flooding and the to hard waterways into stormwater as well outs trenches
River Revitalisation
Parramarra Park Revitalisation
Urban Heat Island Mitigation
Swale Graden
Tree Canopy Improvement
Existing Green Space
In this expected turn result, could the next toward
13
T F
L L L L L L L
L
Stage 2 2025 - 2035
will further with strong paving the Hub in same Parramatta will planning release new commercial building The river will changed to building while the Street will 40 m FSR. maximum drastically 1.5 million half used as other half facilities the projects park Stadium Seasonal also be field underground will much well as for the season.
North Parramatta Local Centre
• Connected by Light Rail and Metro Northwest Link
• Serving surrounding high density development
• Westmead Botanic Garden
Wesmead Transport Hub
• Integrating Train, Metro, Light Rail and Bus
• Affordable housing
• Student accomodation
• Vibrant Hawkesburry Road with mixed commercial and residential space
14 | Integrated Strategic Plan 2 | 15
Local Centre Heritage Adaptive Reuse Urban Farm Special Cultural Buildings Community-based Living New School Expansion Westmead H&E Precinct Expansion Multilingual Signage Pilot Area Medium Density Housing Night Time Economy Westmead Botanic Garden Key-workers & Student Accomodation Economic Priority Area Enhanced Cultural Programming High Density Housing M T T
Years
Priority Precinct
Parramatta Economic Corridor Expansion
• Strong night time economy
• Community-based living for young professional
• Adaptive re-use with diverse events and programs
• High rise towers with A-grade office space and apartments
• Urban heat island mitigation
Victoria Rd Local Centre
• Connected by more frequent bus routes
• Serving surrounding high density development
• Serving student accommodations
• Enhancement of park habitat
• Urban heat island mitigation plan
Cumberland transformed Garden buildings adaptively facilities flora recreation water local every
Westmead Transport Hub
Light Rail
New Bus Routes
New Free Shuttle Bus
Sydney Metro West
Sydney Metro Northwest
River Revitalisation
Parramarra Park Revitalisation
Endangered Vegetation Protection
New Park
New Habitat for Flora & Fauna
Existing Green Space
Urban Heat Island Mitigation
Swale Graden
Tree Canopy Improvement
At the will development. land been here upzoning Redevelopment in around North and Hub dwellings, At the the locate near and universities CBD enough sustain Density designed centres, density manner. necessary access view
15
M T F
Stage 3 2035 - 2050
stage of consolidate previous the site cohesive, focus will areas in previously North site’s school cater for workers in Westmead precinct stages, and student be this, within significantly previously the North avail of provided public network. Final network will stage, and establishment Circle, the expansion of Rail, and routes areas in west. Parramatta will connections to through the
Enhanced Public Transportation Network
• Westmead Metro City Circle Metro with 6 stations
• North expansion of Parramatta Light Rail
• City circle bus routes
• More frequent bus routes serving east and west residential areas
• Connection to Sydney Metro West and Northwest Link
New TOD Precinct
• Proposing community-based living
• New research centre for Westmead H&E precinct expansion
North Wentworthville
• Dedicated key-workers and student accommodation
• Existing school expansion
• Tree canopy improvement
16 3 | 30 Years Local Centre Heritage Adaptive Reuse Urban Farm Special Cultural Buildings Artist Studio and Start-ups Office Community-based Living Art & Innovation Hub Precinct New School Expansion Westmead H&E Precinct Expansion Multilingual Signage Pilot Area Medium Density Housing Night Time Economy Westmead Botanic Garden Key-workers & Student Accomodation Economic Priority Area Enhanced Cultural Programming High Density Housing
L L L L T T L M M
M Priority Precinct
Art & Innovation Hub
• Redevelop light industrial land
• Low-rent spaces for artists and start-ups
• Expansion of community-based living
• New theatre
• Many events and programs
North Parramatta
• Connected with more frequent bus routes
• Connected to Parramatta Lake
• New school
enhancement frequency. At precinct Westmead expansion Health and community-based Alongside amenity-oriented the also new revitalised the the density and corridor the opportunity Westmead only culturally. Through including and low ups, previously of destination creatives,
Westmead Transport Hub
Light Rail
New Bus Routes
Metro City Circle
Sydney Metro West
Sydney Metro Northwest
River Revitalisation
Parramarra Park Revitalisation
Endangered Vegetation Protection
New Park
New Habitat for Flora & Fauna
Existing Green Space
Urban Heat Island Mitigation
Swale Graden
Tree Canopy Improvement
Pedestrian Access to Parramatta Lake
17
L L L L L L L M M T F M
Urban Form and Grid Study Darling Harbour
Following deindustrialisation and shift towards the service-based economy, Darling Harbour has successfully reinvented itself into one of Sydney’s most iconic tourism precinct. Its postcard waterfront has further helped to reinforce Sydney’s global city status internationally. Visiting Darling Harbour has become an important part of a visitor’s itinerary and it acts an intermediary that shapes visitors’ experience of the city. This project aims to study the urban form and grid of Darling Harbour and unveil why is it gaining much success.
Notably, the presence of the Western Distributor which was once deemed as a connector has now become a separator in today’s context. Together with all the big blocks around Darling Harbour like ICC Sydney, Harbourside shopping centre and the hotels, Darling Habour is isolated from the rest of Sydney. Limited view reduces the sense of direction especially for tourists who are unfamiliar to Darling Harbour.
To fix this, an extra-wide walking boulevard is created to connect west Darling Harbour from Paddy’s Market to Australian National Maritime Museum. The huge open green space in Tumbalong Park serves as a great assembly point too.
Tumbalong Park also becomes the venue of varies open festivals which attract both visitors and locals. Car roads are not seen in the core areas in Darling Harbour and therefore pedestrian can enjoy the walk and views uninterrupted. Active frontages and street lights brings a sense of security in Darling Harbour especially at night time.
The success of Darling Harbour shows the world with the excellent design Sydney can achieve that emphasise human and human experience.
18
Neighbourhood Neighbourhood: Building Height and View
use of a part surrounding residential and walled-up concentration including museums till late, and vibrant clusteractivities further to undergo (Griffin et al., complete in a rela-
Building Height and View Movement
Neighbourhood Neighbourhood: Movement
To support ‘experience compres-
buildings
250m
Spaces of Darling Harbour
Streets of Darling Harbour
Open Space and Network Main Streets and Boulevards
Open Space Network
The Darling Harbour precinct comprises of multiple open spaces such as Tumbalong Park, Chinese Garden of Friendship, the Harbourfront area and the Pyrmont Bay Park. They are all well connected by pedestrian only pathways including the Tumbalong Boulevard and the Promenade. This high level of accessibility has supported movement between attractions within Darling
which is of high importance for a tourism precinct.
Four
19 Urban Form and Grain | Darling Harbour
1 5 2 4 3
Pedestrian next to Pedestrian compensate Street furniture Darling Pyrmont Urban Form and Grain | Darling Harbour
Pyrmont Tumbalong Darling Western 02550125 250m 13 Harbour
Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan
Network 250m Tumbalong Park and Playground Pyrmont Bay Park 6 Darling Harbour Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan
Harbour,
View from Pyrmont Bridge to east facing Hyatt Hotel and Sydney Park Towers
View from Pyrmont Bridge to the west with ICC, Sofitel, Novotel and Ibis Hotel building a view barrier from behind
3D model of Darling Harbour - view from the the water side to show big blocks of buildings on the west and high rise buildings in Darling Harbour
Street: Western Distributor
0102050 100m
Connector or Separator?
The Western Distributor was opened in 1972 at a time when Darling Harbour was still an industrial area, and facilitating vehicular movement was seen as a connector. One of its intentions was to alleviate the congested route out of the city through the Pyrmont Bridge during peak hours (Johnson & Parris, 2008). However, the presence of a six-lane expressway with lanes up to 16m wide and concrete viaduct pillars up to 20m in height is seen as obstructing views and along with its hard edges, the Western Distributor has separated north and south Darling Harbour internally as well externally from the city visually and spatially.
Urban Infill to Soften the Street Scale
Notably, this has created an urban void in-between and under the freeway. An urban infill strategy has been adopted and the new IMAX and W Hotel is currently being built in the middle east of the separator as a landmark building to activate the area. To the west, the part of the ICC has been built on the under croft of the Western Distributor and has utilised materials like glass and corten steel to soften the concrete viaduct pillars.
Open Space: Tumbalong Park
Tumbalong Park, the Nucleus
Tumbalong Park is surrounded by Darling Quarter, ICC and the Chinese Garden of FrIendship.
It has been designed to improve accessibility between surrounding precincts including the CBD, Haymarket and Ultimo based on desire lines and acts like like a nucleus. Ample sunlight and unobstructed views of the surrounding area have also made it a popular gathering area for picnics. Besides, it also functions as an event space for a wide spectrum of activities including music concerts to festivals accommodating a crowd up to 27,000, which reinforces Darling Harbour as a tourism precinct.
20 9 Urban Form and Grain | Darling Harbour Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan
12 m 8 m 12 m 108.83 m 480.10 m 9 m 16 m
A A1
Aerial Photo of the Western Distributor showing the intricacy of the street level and connection Source: Iphone 3D Maps, viewed 10 October 2018 The Space below the Western Distributor showing the massive scale of the street and abundant space for active urban infill 12 m 12 m 9 m 9 m 16 m 20 m 16 m 12 m 16 m 8 m Section A-A1
Type: Highway Users:
Vehicle
ROW: Various Intersection: None Building Setback:Street Alignment: Straight & Curved Darling Quarter ICC ICC ICC Coocle Bay Wharf Ausgrid IMAX Parkroyal Darling Park Novotel Harborside Mall Pedestrian Footpath 16 Urban Form and Grain | Darling Harbour Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan Tumbalong Park
Street
Mostly
Only
Aerial Photo Tumbalong Park Turkish Festival in Tumbalong Park Source: Hassell Studio 2017
Human Experience: Safety
Notably, the open space remains safe and inviting later in the night as street lamps and digital signages line would light up the Boulevard. Night activities including dining at outdoor seating areas would further illuminate the Boulevard and offer active frontage which enhances public security through the presence of passive surveillance. This supports the active usage of the open space as a connector and recreational area throughout the day.
Human Experience: Festivals and Various Activities
Tumbalong Park is also a flexible space as it is able to support different programming throughout the year. Just last weekend, it hosted the Taste of Turkey Festival and the Chinese community can also be observed practicing Tai Chi, fostering cross cultural exchange between Sydney’s multi-cultural community. It is further a multi generational open space with amenities like water play features for children as well as wide pedestrian pathways, wayfinding signages to improve place legibility and shaded seating areas, supporting movement of elderly pedestrians in a safe and comfortable way
As such, Tumbalong Park is both a culturally and age inclusive meeting place, supporting Darling Harbour’s role as a tourism precinct, where it is a welcoming place that caters to a diverse range of people who have equal license to play and relax.
Notably, there is one key urban quality criteria lacking in Darling Harbour, which is the protection against unpleasant sensory experience, in particular, from rain. The absence of public rain shelters along the Boulevard would reduce overall comfort and overall pedestrian experience. Interestingly, despite being an obstructive built form, the area beneath the Western Distributor has been observed to function as an incidental rain shelter, which gives its existence in a tourism precinct some merits.
21 20 Urban Form and Grain |
Darling Harbour
Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan
Active frontages along the Boulevard at night Light from street lamps and digital signages
Gehl Institute 2016
22 Urban Form and Grain | Darling Harbour
Group 5 | Dickson - Tamanna - Lik - Evan
Elderly walking around the Boulevard Wayfinding Digital Wayfinding Wide pathway that accommodates pedestrians with strollers and cyclists Elderly resiting under the shade Chinese community practising Tai Chi Taste of Turkey Festival
Gehl Institute 2016
Land Use and Infrastructure Plan Bella Vista
With the new Metro opened in 2019 connecting North West Sydney to CDB and Bankstown when the second stage is completed, much development will grow around each new station. This project aims to provide land use and infrastructure plan on a large empty land north to Bella Vista Station, one of the many stations located in the Hills Shire Council.
Base on the characters, demographic and climate of the site, 6 challenges have been identified. Bella Vista is a traditional car-based suburb with distinctive zoning. Hot weather and distinctive zoning between residential and commercial area discourage residents from using public transportation.
At the same time, the presence of new high-density developments have increased population outside the planning site. The increased population outside the planning site should also be considered.
To maximise the usage of the metro, local centre will be built next to the station with the pro-
vision of public services including a library, child and elderly care. Land will also be reserved to build schools.
High dense residential buildings are centralised in north Bella Vista. The main street will be pedestrian and cyclists prioritised with trees planted along the street. Main road will move to the east side of the superblock near Elizabeth Macarthur Creek.
A-grade commercial and office space can be found in Bela Vista. This is to ensure employment growth in Bella Vista. Through focusing on both live and work aspects, this helps to differentiate Bella Vista from the work focus Norwest Business Park.
Quick wins are proposed to attract residents visiting Bella Vista and try out new metro service. Pop up bars and temporary retails can be held near the station or on the parking site. Shuttle bus connecting North Bella Vista and other high dense developments is another good way to bring people to Bella Vista.
22
SIX CHALLENGES
Phase 1
PHASE 2: 2022 - 2026
Phase 2
Developing Bella Vista into a Living and Business Precinct
Development of B2 and B7 east of the station
Complete construction of Pedestrian Priority Street
Complete construction of tertiary roads
Develop R1 until pocket park
Pocket Park
Playground, off-leash area, passive recreation
Links surrounding residential buildings Provide accessible open spaces for densely populated residential area
Phase 3 Phase 4
Sustaining Bella Vista's relevance in
Establish Lifelong Learning Centre
sustainability throughout all life stages practical skills to training for emerging technologies and business trends
Investigate underutilised spaces
Investigate other potential uses for Convert Pedestrian Priority Street
23 ACTIVATION MOVEMENT INFRASTRUCTURE DESIGN HOUSING ECONOMY Operation of the metro would commence in 2019, prior to the completion of the Town Centre. This would raise concerns over safety and affect subsequent development in Bella Vista
Vista is currently divided into three by Old Windsor Road and Elizabeth Macarthur Creek, resulting in a poor sense of place Bella Vista is dominated by low density residences and adequate housing needs to be provided to support future population growth The Hills Shire Council appears to be unsupportive of the stormwater drainage facility which would be crucial to Bella Vista due to potential flooding and future increase in demand for water Besides having one of the highest car ownership rates and Bella Vista is also experiencing increasing ground temperatures which would affect the shift towards more active and sustainable modes of transport Bella Vista’s commercial economy is threatened by Norwest Business Park as it is able to offer a larger range of commercial spaces including single-tenant buildings Its retail economy is further challenged by the presence of two local shopping centres and Rouse Hill Town Centre
Bella
Integrated Land Use and Infrastructure Plan would be guided by the following big moves: Resilient precinct: To adapt to social, environmental and economic changes in the 21st century
Bella Vista is facing challenges surrounding activation, design, infrastructure, movement, housing and its economy, it aspires to be a 21st Century Living and Business Precinct. To help Bella Vista overcome its challenges and achieve its vision, we have considered Landcom’s principles of delivering diverse, vibrant, connected and sustainable places. Productive and vibrant town centre: To create an active town centre that supports a competitive retail and commercial economy Liveable places: To provide adequate housing and well designed civic places for meaningful exchange Integrated movement network: To improve connectivity through active and sustainable transport Bella Vista would be planned in a manner that considers the potential future impacts brought about by sequencing and prioritising developments with high social and economic impact that can help facilitate the delivery of subsequent developments
BIG MOVES Our
VISION While
Feasibility Study 142-152 Broadway
The purpose of this feasibility study is to provide a sound purchase price for 142-152 Broadway, Chippendale using the residual valuation method. This study determines the viability of undertaking development on the site and recommends a development mix with appropriate pricing strategy.
The site is 528 square metres (sqm) in a B4 Mixed-use zone, allowing for residential, retail, and commercial uses. To determine the type of development to purchase, the study considers the relatively young demographics and predominantly 2-person households in Chinpendale. The study also considered the requirements of all relevant authority requirements including Sydney Local Environmental Plan 2012 (Sydney LEP 2012), Sydney Development Control Plan 2012 (Sydney DCP2012) and Apartment Design Guide (ADG) to determine the best development outcome.
Following a series of analyses, the study proposes a total of 27 residential units and 285sqm of ground floor retail space. The residential units
comprise of 3 one-bedroom units, 18 two-units bedroom units and 3 three-bedroom units. The total potential revenue from this development mix is $33.2 million, with potential apartment sales prices calculated from the median prices of apartments in Chippendale.
With 20% development margin and an estimated development cost of $27.7 million, the recommended bid price for the site is $12.2 million under its current FSR and zoning regulations.
24
25
142-152 City Road, Broadway, Chippendale NSW 2008. Feasibility Analysis FSR 6:1
Calculation Assumptions:
1. The demolition cost of $100/sqm (Lawler, 2018) for the office building on-site is based on the following calculation: 313sqm (from CAD measurement) x 2 floors = 626sqm.
2. Stamp duty for the land is calculated based on the rate for Premium Property Duty: Over $3 Million (Revenue NSW, 2018).
3. Legals include conveyancing fees for the documentation related to site purchase. Assuming minimal complications, the rate is estimated to be $1500 (Commonwealth Bank of Australia, 2018).
4. For high-quality finishes, the construction cost per sqm is estimated to be $3,400 for units of 90-100sqm (RLB, 2018). The average apartment size = 2490sqm / 27 units = 92sqm.
5. The construction costs of home units and retail space reference the higher end of RLB's construction cost range in Sydney. The costs include costs for building works and building services (RLB, 2018).
6. The building services as mentioned in (5) include special equipment, hydraulics, vertical transport, fire protection, mechanical, building management and electrical services' (RLB, 2018)
7.The building works as mentioned in (5) include substructure, structure, finishings,fittings, preliminary items, attendance and builder’s work in connection with services' (RLB, 2018).
8. Siteworks include the cost of the B Class hoarding over the footpath based on the following calculation: 5m (width of footpath from CAD measurement) x 30.5m (site frontage) = 152.5sqm
9. Traffic management cost includes the annual salary of 2 traffic controllers x $70,000 = $140,000.
10. The professional fees for external consultants are estimated to be 12% of the construction costs (Lawler, 2018). External consultants would include standard consultants and the preparation cost of a dilapidation report. Dilapidation report is required as cracks are observed at the adjoining property wall during site inspection. It is assumed that the costs of building works as mentioned in (7) will cover the cost for adjoining property protection.
11. DA and Building Certificate fees are based on rates in City of Sydney's 'Schedules of Proposed Fees and Charges' (CoS, 2018).
12. A additional 5% of contigency fees based on the construction cost is added to make allowance for unforeseen circumstances.
26 Site - DA 27 apartments $12,178,000 asking price for 27 $451,037 per unit Site Area 528sqm GBA 3,168 sqm FSR 6:1 GFA 2,775 sqm Unit QuantityRate ($/sqm)Extension ($)TOTAL ($) Site Purchase Cost of Land 1 12,178,000 Stamp Duty 1 792,950 Legals fixed fee 1 1,500 12,972,450 Construction Demolition sqm 626 100 62,600 Home units sqm 2490 3,400 8,466,000 Parking (underground) sqm 440 1,825 803,000 Retail space sqm 285 2,000 570,000 Fuel tank removal no. 2 20,000 40,000 Siteworks sqm (Refer to Appendix 5 for details) 23,482 Development contributions no. (Refer to Appendix 4.1 for details) 451,452 Traffic management no. 2 70,000 140,000 10,556,534 Professional fees 12%1,266,784 11,823,318 DA fees 18,045 Building certificate 1,258 11,842,621 Contingency fees 5%592,131.06 Total 12,434,752 Finance Site purchase loan 2 12,972,450 7%1,816,143 Assume 2 year loan Construction loan 0.55 12,434,752 7%478,738 Assume 1 year for construction 2,294,881 DEVELOPMENT COST 27,702,083 Sales Retail sqm 285 14,474 4,125,090 Residential Studio no. 3531,020 1,593,060 1 Bed no. 3869,375 2,608,125 2 Bed (View) no. 181,074,995 19,349,910 3 Bed (View) no. 31,855,300 5,565,900 SALES REVENUE 33,242,085 DEVELOPMENT MARGIN 20%
11
142-152 City Road, Broadway, Chippendale NSW 2008. Feasibility Analysis FSR 8:1
1.The demolition cost of $100/sqm (Lawler, 2018) for the office building on-site is based on the following calculation: 313sqm (from CAD measurement) x 2 floors = 626sqm.
2.Stamp duty for the land is calculated based on the rate for Premium Property Duty: Over $3 Million (Revenue NSW, 2018).
3. Legals include conveyancing fees for the documentation related to site purchase. Assuming minimal complications, the rate is estimated to be $1500 (Commonwealth Bank of Australia, 2018).
4. For high-quality finishes, the construction cost per sqm is estimated to be $3,400 for units of 90-100sqm (RLB, 2018). The average apartment size = 2490sqm / 27 units = 92sqm.
5. The construction costs of home units and retail space reference the higher end of RLB's construction cost range in Sydney. The costs include costs for building works and building services (RLB, 2018).
6. The building services as mentioned in (5) include special equipment, hydraulics, vertical transport, fire protection, mechanical, building management and electrical services' (RLB, 2018)
7.The building works as mentioned in (5) include substructure, structure, finishings,fittings, preliminary items, attendance and builder’s work in connection with services' (RLB, 2018).
8. Siteworks include the cost of the B Class hoarding over the footpath based on the following calculation: 5m (width of footpath from CAD measurement) x 30.5m (site frontage) = 152.5sqm
9. Traffic management cost includes the annual sa lary of 2 traffic controllers x $70,000 = $140,000.
10. The professional fees for external consultants are estimated to be 12% of the construction costs (Lawler, 2018). External consultants would include standard consultants and the preparation cost of a dilapidation report. Dilapidation report is required as cracks are observed at the adjoining property wall during site inspection. It is assumed that the costs of building works as mentioned in (7) will cover the cost for adjoining property protection.
11. DA and Building Certificate fees are based on rates in City of Sydney's 'Schedules of Proposed Fees and Charges' (CoS, 2018 ).
12. A additional 5% of contigency fees based on the construction cost is added to make allowance for unforeseen circumstances.
27 Site - DA 37 apartments $13,248,000 asking price for 37 $358,054 per unit Site Area 528sqm GBA 4,224 sqm FSR 8:1 GFA 3,717 sqm Unit QuantityRate ($/sqm)Extension ($)TOTAL ($) Site Purchase Cost of Land 1 13,248,000 Stamp Duty 1 867,850 Legals fixed fee 11,500 14,117,350 Construction Demolition sqm 626 100 62,600 Home units sqm 3,717 3,400 12,638,208 Parking (underground) sqm 520 1,825 949,000 Retail space sqm 285 2,000 570,000 Fuel tank removal no. 2 20,000 40,000 Siteworks sqm (Refer to Appendix 5 for details) 23,482 Development contributions no. (Refer to Appendix 4.2 for details) 628,237 Traffic management no. 2 70,000 140,000 15,051,527 Professional fees 12%1,806,183 16,857,710 DA fees 24,036 Building certificate 1,343 16,883,089 Contingency fees 5% 844,154 Total 17,727,243 Finance Site purchase loan 2 14,117,350 7%1,976,429 Assume 2 year loan Construction loan 0.55 17,727,243 7%682,499 Assume 1 year for construction 2,658,928 DEVELOPMENT COST 34,503,521 Sales Retail sqm 285 14,474 4,125,090 Residential Studio no. 7531,020 3,717,140 1 Bed no. 5869,375 4,346,875 2 Bed (View) no. 221,074,995 23,649,890 3 Bed (View) no. 31,855,300 5,565,900 SALES REVENUE 41,404,895 DEVELOPMENT MARGIN 20%
Calculation Assumptions:
12
Proposed Design
28 GSPublisherVersion 0.9.100.100 Site Boundaries GRAFTON LANE Retail GFA = 285m2 GROUND FLOOR GBR F S Residential Lift Service Corridor Loading Bay Commercial Lift Services Retail Retail Site Boundaries GRAFTON LANE SOLAR = 4/5 (80%) CROSS VENT = 60% LEVEL 01-03 MIX Studio 3 units 1B 3 units 2B 9 units 3B 0 units MIX Studio 0 units 1B 0units 2B 9 units 3B 3 units TOTAL MIX Studio 3 units 1B 3units 2B 18 units 3B 3 units TOTAL 27 units GFA A: 415 757 m 2Bed 2Bed 1Bed 2Bed Studio Site Boundaries GRAFTON LANE FOOTPATH SOLAR = 80% CROSS VENT = 75% (L4/L5) & 100% (L6) LEVEL 04-06 GFA A 414 437 3Bed 2Bed 2Bed 2Bed
1:250 9
Group 7_PLAN9045 Assignment 02
Appendix 2: Summary of Compliance
Summary of Compliance
The proposed development is permissible with development consent including:
1. Sydney Local Environmental Plan 2012 (Sydney LEP 2012)
2. Sydney Development Control Plan 2012 (Sydney DCP 2012)
3. Apartment Design Guide (ADG)
The site is identified in Sydney LEP 2012 Land zoning map as being within an R2 Low Density Residential zone. The proposed use is permissible with development consent.
Summary of Compliance with relevant clause of the Sydney LEP 2012
Standard Comments Complies
Part 4 Permitted or prohibited development
4.3 Height of buildings
(1) The objectives of this clause are as follows:
(a) to ensure the height of development is appropriate to the condition of the site and its context,
(b) to ensure appropriate height transitions between new development and heritage items and buildings in heritage conservation areas or special character areas,
(c) to promote the sharing of views,
(d) to ensure appropriate height transitions from Central Sydney and Green Square Town Centre to adjoining areas,
(e) in respect of Green Square:
(i) to ensure the amenity of the public domain by restricting taller buildings to only part of a site, and
(ii) to ensure the built form contributes to the physical definition of the street network and public spaces.
(2) The height of a building on any land is not to exceed the maximum height shown for the land on the Height of Buildings Map.
4.4 Floor space ratio
(1) The objectives of this clause are as follows:
(a) to provide sufficient floor space to meet anticipated development needs for the foreseeable future,
(b) to regulate the density of development, built form and land use intensity and to control the generation of vehicle and pedestrian traffic,
(c) to provide for an intensity of development that is commensurate with the capacity of existing and planned infrastructure,
(d) to ensure that new development reflects the desired character of the locality in which it is located and minimises adverse impacts on the amenity of that locality.
(2) The maximum floor space ratio for a building on any land is not to exceed the floor space ratio shown for the land on the Floor Space Ratio Map.
7 7.3 Car parking spaces not to exceed maximum set out in this Division
(1) Development consent must not be granted to development that includes car parking spaces in connection with a proposed use of land if the total number of car parking spaces (including existing car parking spaces) provided on the site would be greater than the maximum set out in this Division.
(2) If the maximum number of car parking spaces under this Division is not a whole number, the number is to be rounded to the nearest whole number.
7.5 Residential flat buildings, dual occupancies and multi dwelling housing
(1) The maximum number of car parking spaces for residential flat buildings, dual occupancies and multi dwelling housing is as follows:
(a) on land in category A:
(i) for each studio dwelling 0.1 spaces, and
(ii) for each 1 bedroom dwelling 0.3 spaces, and
(iii) for each 2 bedroom dwelling 0.7 spaces, and
(iv) for each 3 or more bedroom dwelling 1 space
7.6 Office premises and business premises
(d) if the building is on land in category D, E or F and has a floor space ratio greater than that specified in paragraph (a), (b) or (c) respectively, the following formula is to be used:
M=(G x A) / (50 x T)
Noted
Max height of 25m shown on Map.
Proposed
G/F: 4.5 m
1/F: 3.6 m
2-6/F: 3.1 m
Total building height: 23.6m
Noted Proposed New proposed building is built with Max FSR of 6:1 shown on Floor Space Ration Map.
Noted
Proposed
Residential dwelling:
Studio: 3 x 0.1 = 0.3
1 Bedroom: 3 x 0.3 = 0.9
2 Bedroom: 18 x 0.7 = 12.6
3 Bedroom: 3 x 1 = 3
Retail: (285 m2 x 528 m2) / (50x 2775 m2) = 1.08
Car Parking: Max car parking spaces for residential dwelling and retail: 0.3 + 0.9 + 12.6 + 3 + 1.08 = 17.88 = 18
29
Group 7_PLAN9045 Assignment 02 Appendix 2: Summary of Compliance
Summary of Compliance with relevant clause of the Sydney DCP 2012
Standard Comments Complies
4.2
Residential
Flat, Non-Residential and Mixed Use Developments
4.2 4.2.3.8 Common open space
(1) Provide an area of common open space under common title that is at least 25% of the total site area and has a minimum dimension of 6m. The calculation of the required area of common open space is to exclude driveways, parking areas, essential access paths such as fire escape routes, indoor gymnasiums and outdoor clothes drying areas.
(2) The common open space is to be located and designed to achieve good amenity for the dwellings in terms of solar access, natural air flow and ventilation, and outlook. At least 30% of the required common open space area is to receive 2 hours of direct sunlight between 9am and 3pm on 21 June.
(3) Common open space may be located on elevated gardens or roof tops provided that the area and overall
4.2.3.9 Ventilation
(1) Adequate natural ventilation makes an important contribution to the amenity of dwelling units.
(2) Natural cross ventilation in dwelling units is to be achieved by having window openings facing different directions where possible. For single facing apartments, the depth of the apartment is to be less than the width of its external face to encourage good ventilation.
(3) Dwelling units must not solely rely on lightwells or building setbacks enclosed on three sides by other buildings for natural ventilation.
4.2.3.12 Flexible housing and dwelling mix
Provisions
(1) Developments that propose more than 20 dwellings are to provide a mix of dwellings consistent with the following percentage mix:
(a) Studio: 5 - 10%;
(b) 1 bedroom: 10 – 30%
(c) 2 bedroom: 40 – 75%; and
(d) 3+ bedroom: 10 - 100%
4.2.5.3 Development on busy roads and active frontages
The following provisions apply to, sensitive uses on sites that are to have an active frontage as shown on the Active frontages map, or sites with a frontage to a busy road that carries more than 20,000 vehicles a day. Sensitive uses include:
(1) buildings for residential use (including mixed use buildings);
(2) places of public worship;
(3) hospitals; and
(4) educational establishments or childcare centres
communal open space
50% of floor area
Noted
Proposed 60% of total dwelling units will achieve natural cross ventilation while meeting the building requirements.
Proposed Building dwelling ratio:
Studio: 3 (11.11%)
1 bedroom: 3 (11.11%)
2 bedroom: 18 (66.67%)
3 bedroom: 3 (11.11)
Proposed New proposed building will have an full active retail frontage along Broadway.
30
Noted Proposed Rooftop
=
= 264sqm
31 Group 7_PLAN9045 Assignment 02 Appendix 2: Summary of Compliance
GIS mapping project Commute modes change Greater Sydney
Thisproject aims to use Arcmap, a Geographic Information System (GIS) to map out and analyse topics of interest.
I have chosen to study the change of usage of the top 3 popular commuting modes in Sydney, driving, taking trains and buses.
Extracting data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), top 3 commuting modes in Statistical Areas Level 1 (SA1) are identified which are cars, trains and buses. Data from census 2011 and 2016 are used to show the change. The number of commuters are converted into percentage and processed and presented in Arcmap. Areas in red and blue indicate increasing and decreasing respectively while white means non-comparable due to the change of areas defined.
The result shows that the proportion of car commuters decrease in most of the areas in Greater Sydney, especially in the inner-city. Train commuters increased in all statistical areas in Greater Sydney and rapid increases are
found also in the inner-city. For bus commuters, there are certain decrease near CDB areas and outer Sydney in ar north and south-west but experience increase in most of the other areas.
To conclude, the increase in train commuters is much greater than cars and bus commuters. This can be explained by rapid development near many train stations and the strengthened train network and new train lines. The worsen traffic especially in the inner-city might explain the reduced usage of buses in certain areas. Reaching the maximum capacity can also be another explanation of the comparatively lower proportion of bus commuters. Overall the percentage of car commuters has decrease however it does not indicate a reduce the number of car commuters in general.
32
Percentage change of Car Commuters among all commute trips between 2011 and 2016 in Greater Sydney
Percentage change of Bus Commuters among all commute trips between 2011 and 2016 in Greater Sydney
Percentage change of Train Commuters among all commute trips between 2011 and 2016 in Greater Sydney
Percentage Change of Train Commutors
33
± 0 20 40 10 K lometers Percentage Change of Car Commutors Not appl cab e -15% or more -15% to -10% -10% to -5% -5% to 0% 0% to 5%
± 0 20 40 10 Ki ometers Percentage
of
Commutors Not app icable -2 5% or more -2 5% to 0% 0% to 2 5% 2 5% to 5% 5% or above
Change
Bus
Not appl cable 0% to 2 5% 2 5% to 5% 5% to 7 5% 7 5% to 10% 10% or above ± 0 20 40 10 K lometers
34 THANK YOU 06 33 92 14 35 NICKLAM720@gmail.com