Everything Beautiful is Far Away [7, 2012 | Vol. 3]

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"!#$%&'!()!*+$,+&--!./!0(123!45''()!6!*&1&+!78!439),:!

439;1&+-!<&%&)!1$!#()&! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =>?! ! @3&)!13&!A()9'!.&''!$A!13&!9A1&+)$$)!+&%&+.&+91&-!9'$),!13&!2$++(B$+-!$A!C&AA&+-$)!

D&E&/! 0(BB'&! <23$$'F! 13&! -15B&)1-! .$'1! A+$G! 13&! 2'9--+$$G-! 9-! (A! 13&/! 9+&! ;9)(2H&B! %(''9,&+-! B&-&+1(),! 13&(+! 39G'&1! 5)B&+! 13&! 13+&91! $A! 9)! (G;&)B(),!

B(-9-1&+F!+5-3(),!1$!'$2H&+-!$+!35++/(),!1$E9+B!&I(1-F!.92H;92H-!;+&--(),!9,9()-1!

13&(+!-;()&-8!!<(B'(),!()!13&!G(B-1!$A!13&!G9--!&I$B5-F!2'9-;(),!13&!39)B'&!$A!3(-! %($'()!29-&F!<9G5&'!,$&-!A$+!13&!G9()!B$$+-F!+&1+92(),!13&!+$51&!1391!39B!.+$5,31!

3(G! ()1$! 13&! .5('B(),! 13(-! G$+)(),8! ! J&&;(),! 3(-! 3&9B! '$E&+&BF! 3&! -35AA'&-!

A$+E9+BF!G()BA5'!$A!13&!$13&+!.$B(&-!K(,K9,,(),!92+$--!3(-!5)&%&)!1+9L&21$+/F!9)B! 39-1('/!&-29;&-!13+$5,3!13&!-5)-3()&M(GG&+-&B!13+&-3$'B!$A!13&!$;&)!B$$+E9/² 19H(),! 3(G-&'A! .&/$)B! 13&! 2$)A()&-! $A! C&AA&+-$)! D&E&/! 1$! E3&+&! &%&+/13(),! $51-(B&!(-!(G.5&B!E(13!9!+9B(9)1F!'(.&+91(),!95+9!1391!E9(1-!'(H&!9!,(A1!91!13&!&)B!$A! &923!-23$$'!E&&H8! !

N)'/!9A1&+!&G&+,(),!()1$!13&!B9/'(,31F!+&923(),!13&!2+$EB&B!-(B&E9'HF!E(''!

<9G5&'!+9(-&!3(-!23()F!-O5()1(),!A(+-1!91!13&!2'&9+!.'5&!-H/!9.$%&!.&A$+&!-29))(),!

13&! '$),! ;+$2&--($)! $A! %&3(2'&-! (B'(),! ()! A+$)1! $A! 13&! -23$$'²13&! &G;1/! -&91-! ,+9B59''/!A(''(),!5;!E(13!A&''$E!-15B&)1-F!13&!<PQ-F!-&B9)-F!9)B!/&''$E!.5-&-!13&)! +$''(),!9E9/F!$)&!91!9!1(G&F!'(H&!-$G&!9--&G.'/!'()&!()!E3(23!13&!A()(-3(),!1$523!

(-! 13&! ;+&-&)2&! $A! 23('B+&)8! ! R51! -9%&! A$+! 13&! 9A1&+)$$)-! E3&)! 9! G&1+$! .5-! (-! )&&B&B! 1$! .+(),! 3(G! 1$! 9)B! A+$G! 3(-! %($'()! '&--$)F! 3&! 1+9%&'-! 9'$)&! ./! A$$1F! ;+$2&&B(),!)$E!9G$),!13$-&!E3$!9+&!B&-1()&B!1$!E9'H!3$G&F!13&!29-&!-E(),(),! )&9+! 9! 13(,38! ! ")B! E3('&! -&11(),! $51! 5;$)! 13&! -(B&E9'HF! 3&! A()B-! 3(G-&'A! ,9K(),!

B$E)!9,9()F!E9123(),!13&!9),'&-!$A!'(,31!9)B!-39B$E!;'9/!9+$5)B!3(-!-3$&-S!13&!

-3(A1(),! ;911&+)-! -19/! E(13! 3(G! 9-! 3&! +$5)B-! 13&! 2$+)&+! $A! 9! O5(&1! +&-(B&)1(9'!

-1+&&1F! G$%(),! .&-(B&! 9! 29)$;/! $A! '5-3! ,+&&)! $'&9)B&+-F! 9)B! -5BB&)'/! 3&! A&&'-!

2$G;'&1&'/!5).5+B&)&BF!E3$''/!2$)1&)1F!9-!(A!3&!(-!-$G&$)&!.&,())(),!9!'&(-5+&'/!

L$5+)&/!E(13$51!9)/!B&-1()91($)!()!G()BF!-1+$''(),!.&)&913!9!-5)!-$!E9+G!1391!(1!

9'+&9B/! -&&G-! '(H&! -5GG&+8! ! T3&! %($'()! 29-&F! 3$E&%&+F! -&+%&-! 9-! 9! +&G()B&+! $A! E3&+&!&I921'/!3&!(-!$.'(,91&B!1$!,$F!9-!B$&-!13&!-(I1/!B$''9+-!3(-!G$13&+!39B!,(%&)!

3(G!1$!.5/!9!)&E!.$E²13&!G$)&/!A$'B&B!()!39'A!9)B!29++(&B!B&&;!()-(B&!9!;$2H&18! !

U&1! -1(''! +&'(-3(),! 1391! ;'&9-9)1! -&)-&! $A! &9-&F! <9G5&'! A()9''/! 9++(%&-! 91! 9!

.5-/! ()1&+-&21($)! E3&+&! 13&! +&-(B&)1(9'! 1+9)O5('(1/! G&&1-! 13&! 2'9G$+! $A! 2$GG&+2&8!!*+&--(),!$)E9+BF!3&!E9)B&+-!;9-1!-1$+&A+$)1-F!,'9)2(),!()1$!9!2$AA&&!

-3$;F!9!)$$B'&!+&-195+9)1F!9!A$$1!G9--9,&!;9+'$+F!9)B!9!%(B&$!-1$+&F!%9,5&'/!9E9+&! $A! 3(-! 1+9)-;9+&)1! +&A'&21($)! A'$91(),! $)! 13&(+! E()B$E-8! ! R51! E3&)! 29-1(),! 3(-!

-19+&! 5;! 93&9B! 1$! B(-2&+)! 13&! B(-19)2&! .&1E&&)! 3(G-&'A! 9)B! *&1+()(V-! 05-(2! 6!

7)-1+5G&)1!4$8F!13&!-(,31!$A!9!)&9+./!;9E)-3$;!()1&+%&)&-F!-1$;;(),!3(G!-3$+18!!

2U PRUH SUHFLVHO\ LW LV VRPHWKLQJ LQ WKH SDZQVKRS¶V ZLQGRZ GLVSOD\ WKDW FDWFKHV 3(-! 911&)1($)F! B+9E(),! 3(G! 2'$-&+! A$+! 9! .&11&+! '$$H8! ! N)! 13&! $13&+! -(B&! $A! 13&! ,'9--²-5++$5)B&B! ./! ;$+19.'&! 4D! ;'9/&+-F! 9! 2+$--.$EF! -1&+&$! -;&9H&+-F! 9! -&1! $A! ;9()1.9''! ,5)-F! 9)B! 13+&&! B(AA&+&)1! #()1&)B$! ,9G&! -&1-²-19)B-! 9! ;9(+! $A! E391!

-&&G-! 1$! .&! .9+&'/! 5-&B! L5)($+! ()'()&! -H91&-F! -'&&H! 9)B! .'92HF! B&-(,)&B! E(13!

9&+$B/)9G(2!,+$$%&-!9)B!E3&&'-!1+(GG&B!()!9!,$'B!2$'$+F!G9H(),!3(G!13()H!$A!9!

A9-1MA'/(),!/&''$E!L92H&1!E9-;S!9!E3(1&!39)BE+(11&)!;+(2&!19,!39),-!$AA!$)&!$A!13&!

-3()/!E3&&'-:!!WXY8! !

Z(-!$'B&+!.$/!2$5-()-!39B!$A1&)!WHDVHG KLP DERXW KRZ KH¶G QHYHU RZQHG D

JDPLQJ V\VWHP KRZ KH ZDVQ¶W JRRG DW EDVNHWEDOO RU EDVHEDOO 7KH\¶G VDLG KH ZDV 9)! 9++$,9)1! H(BF! .&295-&! 3&! '$$H&B! B$E)! $)! 13&(+! 19-1&! ()! ;$;5'9+! G5-(28! ! T3&! /LWWOH 7LJHUV DQG $QQLH <L DUH WHUULEOH KH¶G WHOO WKHP Z(13! 9)! 9(+! $A! -5;&+($+(1/8!! $ZIXO VLQJHUV KH¶G VD\ 1RW DFWXDO PXVLFLDQV QRW DQ\ZKHUH FORVH WR &KRSLQ RU T239(H$%-H/8!!")B!A$+!1391!3(-!2$5-()-!E$5'B!29''!3(G!9!.+918!!R51!E3&)!(1!29G&!1$!

-H91(),F!3&!2$5'B!9'G$-1!H&&;!5;!E(13!13&GS!3&!2$5'BF!9'G$-1F!;+$%&!1391!3(-!9,&F! VL]H DQG DELOLWLHV ZHUHQ¶W DV LQVLJQLILFDQW DV WKH\ EHOLHYHG :KR QHHGV 1LQWHQGR DQ\ZD\ KH¶G WKRXJKW 5DFLQJ RQ VNDWHV LV EHWWHU PRUH OLNH H[LVWLQJ LQ D YLGHR ,9G&!139)!;'9/(),!$)&8!

!

#$E! 3(-! -19+&! 1+9%&'-! 9E9/! A+$G! 13&! -H91&-F! ;&&+(),! ()1$! 13&! ;9E)-3$;F!

9)B! 91! 1391! G$G&)1! <9G5&'! +&9'(K&-! 3&! (-! .&(),! E9123&B! ./! -$G&$)&! ()-(B&8!! <(11(),! .&3()B! 13&! 2$5)1&+F! 9! -3$+1! G9)²235../! 9)B! 5)-39%&)F! [('(;()$! '$$H(),²+&15+)-!3(-!-19+&!E(13!&/&-!1391!9;;&9+!G(-G9123&B!5;$)!3(-!$%9'!A92&S! $)&!&/&!(-!;(&+2(),!9)B!-1&+)F!(1-!2$5)1&+;9+1!'9K/!9)B!29'G8!!\(A1(),!9!'(G;!+(,31!

39)B!1391!,+(;-!9!A5G(),!2(,9+&11&F!13&!G9)!G$1($)-!1E(2&F!()%(1(),!3(G!1$!&)1&+!

13&!-3$;8!!<9G5&'!(GG&B(91&'/!9%&+1-!3(-!,9K&F!9)B!921(),!9-!(A!13&!G9)V-!,&-15+&!

39B!,$)&!5))$1(2&BF!3H VWXGLHV WKH VNDWHV D OLWWOH ELW ORQJHU LPDJLQLQJ KRZ WKH\¶G A&&'! 9+$5)B! 3(-! 9)H'&-! 9)B! 29'%&-:! ! -)5,! ;&+39;-F! 2$GA$+19.'&! 13$5,3F! '(H&! 9)! &I1+9!A(+G!'9/&+!$A!3(-!%&+/!$E)!-H()8!!")B!L5-1!13&)!3&!2$5'B!-&&!3(G-&'A!-9('(),!

B$E)! 13&! 39''E9/-! $A! C&AA&+-$)! D&E&/! 9A1&+! 13&! '9-1! .&''! 39B! +9),F! K(;;(),! .&1E&&)! 3(-! ;&&+-! 9-! (A! 13&/! 9+&! )$13(),! G$+&! 139)! $+9),&! 1+9AA(2! 2$)&-! 1$! .&!

9%$(B&B²!"# $%&'# ("%)# *"+,-).²13&! -H91&-! ,'(B(),! 3(G! &AA$+1'&--'/! 1$E9+B! 13&!

E&&H&)BF! &%&)! E3&)! 13&! A'9('(),! 39)B-! $A! B$5+F! (G;91(&)1! *+()2(;9'! ]BE9+B-!

2$G&!$51!$A!)$E3&+&F! ,+9K(),!3(-!-3$5'B&+!.'9B&-F!-1+(%(),!1$!,+9-;!91!3(-!)&2HS! &I2&;1! <9G5&'! (-! 1$$! A9-1F! 1$$! 9,('&F! 9)B! '(H&! 13&! 92+$.91(2! J5),! [5! -15)1-! $A! 9!

C92H(&! 439)! G$%(&F! 3&! G9)9,&-! 1$! .&2$G&! 9(+.$+)&! E(13! 9! -(),'&! L5G;F! A'/(),!

-1+9(,31!13+$5,3!13&!G9()!B$$+-F!3(-!.$B/!-;())(),!3(,3!()!9!.'5+!$A!-5)'(,31!9)B! .'5&!-H/8!!!/²0123²4/15²6/7895.# #

,W¶V D IDQF\ WKDW SXVKHV WKH HGJHV RI! <9G5&'V-! G$513! ()1$! 9! E+/! -G('&F!

&)1&+19()(),! 3(G! 9-! 3&! +&'5219)1'/! B+(A1-! $)8! ! 4$)1()5(),! A$+E9+BF! 3&! E9'H-!

-&%&+9'!/9+B-!1$!*&1+()(V-F!2+$--(),!13&!G5-(2!-3$;V-!&)1+9)2&F!A(),&+-!B(,,(),!9''!

WKH ZKLOH IRU KLV PRWKHU¶V PRQH\ %XW LQ OHVV WKDQ ILYH PLQXW&-!3&!A()B-!3(G-&'A! '$(1&+(),!$)2&!G$+&!()!A+$)1!$A!13&!;9E)-3$;F!13&!%($'()!29-&!)$E!2$)19()(),!1E$! .$E-²$)&! $'B! 9)B! '(,31'/! A+9/&BF! $)&! .+9)B! )&E! 9)B! E+9;;&B! ()! ;'9-1(2²E(13!

13&!239),&!'&A1!$%&+!A+$G!13&!;5+239-&!2'5123&B!E(13()!9!A(-18!!<52H(),!)&+%$5-'/!

91! 3(-! .$11$G! '(;F! 3&! -1&;-! ()-(B&! 13&! ;9E)-3$;F! ;9--(),! 9! '(A&M-(K&B! 1&++9M2$119!

E9++($+!-1915&!9)B!9!.$$G!.$I!;'9/(),!13&!3(1-!$A!")(19!05(F!9)B!-19+1-!92+$--!13&!

B(+1/! 2$)2+&1&! A'$$+F! ()-19)1'/! .+&913(),! 9! ;&+%9-(%&! $B$+! 1391! +&29''-! 13&! -19'&!

-G&''!$A!.+(11'&!)&E-;+()18! !

R&)&913!.(2/2'&-!-5-;&)B&B!$)!3$$H-!9)B!9!-O59B+$)!$A!B9),'(),!+&G$1&M

2$)1+$'! G$B&'! 9(+;'9)&-! H&;1! 9'$A1! ./! A(-3(),! E(+&F! )$.$B/! &'-&! (-! ;+&-&)1! 1$!

.+$E-&! 13&! G9)/! 2+9GG&B! -3&'%&-! $A! .+(2M9M.+92F! $+! 13&! .$I&-! $A! %(B&$! ,9G&-!

1391!A(''!13&!-1$+&!A+$G!A+$)1!1$!.92H8!!"-!13$5,3!3&!2$5'B!.&!E9'H(),!()1$!9!1+9;F! <9G5&'! ;+$2&&B-! 2951($5-'/! 9G$),! 9)! 9++9/! $A! B5-1/! 1&'&%(-($)-F! 95B($! &O5(;G&)1F!,$'A!2'5.-F!9)B!;+&29+($5-!-192H-!$A!5-&B!4D-!9)B!QZ<!19;&-²B$(),!

-$! 5)B&+! 13&! ;&25'(9+F! %(,('9)1! -19+&! $A! 13&! [('(;()$! -(11(),! .&3()B! 13&! 2$5)1&+8!! @3&)! 91! '9-1! 2$G(),! 1$! -19)B! B(+&21'/! .&'$E! 1391! E9123A5'! ,9K&F! 3&! ;'92&-! 13&!

YLROLQ FDVH EHIRUH WKH PDQ EXW GRHVQ¶W \HW ORRN XS 5DWKHU KH XQODWFKHV WKH FDVH $;&)(),!(1!9-!(A!;+$AA&+(),!9!.+(&A29-&!;92H&B!E(13!.5)B'&-!$A!5)G9+H&B!25++&)2/F! 9)B! 13&)! 5)A5+'-! 3(-! A(-1F! '&11(),! 13&! 239),&! -'(B&! A+$G! 3(-! ;9'G! 1$! 13&!

2$5)1&+1$;²1E$!2+5G;'&B!.(''-F!9!-G911&+(),!$A!2$()-8! !

^(%(),! 9! 39'A! 9))$/&B! 9)B! 39'A! 9G5-&B! ,+5)1F! 13&! [('(;()$! E9%&-! 3(-!

2(,9+&11&!39)B!9.$%&!13&!29-&F!-;&E(),!9!1+9('!$A!-G$H&!$)!13&!%($'()!'(H&!;&-1(2(B&!

IDOOLQJ IURP D FURS GXVWHU LQWR D ILHOG ³:KDW¶V WKLV IRU"´ WKH PDQ DVNV VXUSULVLQJ <9G5&'!./!-;&9H(),!()!;&+A&21!09)B9+()8! !

+H JODQFHV XS PHHNO\ DQVZHULQJ ³7KH UROOHUEODGHV LQ WKH ZLQGRZ ´!!9)B!

+&9'(K&-F! 1$! 3(-! (GG&B(91&! 2$)-1&+)91($)F! 1391! 13&! [('(;()$V-! .&)(,)F! B+$$;(),! +(,31!&/&!(-!G9B&!$A!,'9--8! !

",9()! 13&! 2(,9+&11&! 39)B! .+&&K&-! $%&+! 13&! %($'()F! +9()(),! G$+&! -G$H&:!!

³<RX ZDQW WR SDZQ WKLV IRU WKRVH UROOHUEODGHV"´ 7KH PDQ¶V JRRG H\H IL[&-!39+B!$)! <9G5&'F! )9++$E(),F! E3('&! 13&! ,'9--! &/&! -&&G-! 1$$! ()911&)1(%&! 1$! .&! .$13&+&BF! )&%&+!B9+1(),!()!9)/!B(+&21($)F!9-!13$5,3!(1!(-!;+&$225;(&B!E(13!-$G&13(),!&'-&8! !

³1R MXVW WKLV ´ 6DPXHO VD\V WDNLQJ WKH ROG ERZ RXW RI WKH FDVH ³DQG WKLV ´

Z&!;5-3&-!13&!-;9+&!239),&!1$!13&!G(BB'&!$A!13&!2$5)1&+8! !

"22&;1(),!13&!.$EF!13&![('(;()$!;&+A$+G-!9!O5(2H!()-;&21($)F!15+)(),!(1!13(-!

ZD\ DQG WKDW ³<RX NQRZ KRZ WR SOD\ WKH YLROLQ KXK"´ WKH PDQ VD\V UXQQLQJ DQ ()B&I!A(),&+!9'$),!13&!'&),13!$A!13&!3$+-&39(+!-1+9)B-8! !

6DPXHO QRGV VWHDOLQJ D JOLPSVH DW WKH EOLQG VLGH RI WKH PDQ¶V IDFH IHHOLQJ

.$13!+&;5'-($)!9)B!;(1/!A$+!3(-!,'9--! &/&²13&!E9/!(1!-(1-!13&+&!'$$H(),!B&A&91&BF! -152H! .&-(B&! (1-! 1&G;&+9G&)19'! ;9+1)&+F! '(H&! 9)! 5)39;;/! 3$5-&E(A&! 1391! 39-!

-19/&B!1$$!'$),!()!9!.9B!G9++(9,&8! !

7KH )LOLSLQR SXWV WKH ERZ RQ WKH FRXQWHU VD\LQJ ³'RQ W \RX WKLQN \RX

QHHG LW IRU SOD\LQJ"´!

!

<9G5&'! -39H&-! 3(-! 3&9BF! 9! ;+$G;1F! B&2(-(%&! -39H&F! 9)B! ;$()1-! 91! 13&!

;'9-1(2MZUDSSHG ERZ LQ WKH FDVH ³, KDYH D QHZ RQH ´! !

³$K , VHH !7KDW¶V ZK\ \RX ZDQW WR WUDGH WKH ROG RQH IRU WKH UROOHUEODGHV

WKHQ"´! !

³0P ´ 6DPXHO FRQFXUV QRGGLQJ WRZDUG WKH JODVV H\H ZLWK VRPH YDJXH

A&&'(),!1391!(1!G(,31!.&!G$+&!-/G;913&1(2F!9)B!A$+!9!-;'(1!-&2$)B!3&!(-!-5+&!1391!

13&!()&+1!.+$E)!;5;('!39-!.&2$G&!921(%&F!-3(A1(),!&%&+!-$!-'(,31'/!()!13&!-$2H&1!1$! +&,9+B!3(G8! !

T3&!G9)!+5.-!9!135G.!$)!13&!%9+)(-3&B!E$$B!$A!13&!%($'()F!13&)!3&!,&)1'/!

VWUXPV WKH VWULQJV D FRXSOH RI WLPHV ³1R LQWHUHVW LQ SDZQLQJ WKLV ULJKW"´! !

<9G5&'!-39H&-!3(-!3&9BF!-9/(),!)$13(),8!!

!

³, VHH ´ &RFNLQJ WKH H\HEURZ DERYH KLV JRRG H\H WKH )LOLSLQR EULQJV WKH

2(,9+&11&!1$!3(-!'(;-F!()39'(),!E3('&!1$19'(),!13&!239),&!$)!13&!2$5)1&+!()!3(-!G()B8!! "!G$G&)1!'91&+F!3&!&I39'&-!9!'$),!-1+&9G!$A!-G$H&!1391!.(''$E-!A$+13!E(13!9!3&9%/!

VLJK ³,W¶V QRW HQRXJK 7KHUH¶V DOPRVW VHYHQ EXFNV KHUH DQG , FDQ JLYH \RX ILYH B$''9+-!91!G$-1!A$+!/$5+!.$E8!!R51!1391!;9(+!,$&-!A$+!A$+1/MA(%&F!-$!13&!B(AA&+&)2&!(-!

13(+1/M13+&&!B$''9+-8!!U$5!,$1!13(+1/MWKUHH GROODUV"´! !

<9G5&'! -('&)1'/! -39H&-! 3(-! 3&9B! 9,9()F! 2$)%&/(),! )$! 1+92&! $A! 13&!

B(-9;;$()1G&)1!1391!39-!-5BB&)'/!29-1!9!-39B$E!5;$)!3(-!9A1&+)$$)8! !

³6RUU\ ´ WKH PDQ VD\V VKUXJJLQJ KLV VKRXOGHUV RQFH ³:K\ GRQ¶W \RX KDYH

D ORRN DURXQG ,¶P VXUH \RX FDQ ILQG VRPHWKLQJ FKHDSHU \RX G ZDQW 7KHUH V D ORW $A!%(B&$!,DPHV <RX OLNH YLGHR JDPHV"´! !

6DPXHO GRHVQ¶W UHVSRQG ,QVWHDG KH EHJLQV JDWKHULQJ WKH FKDQJH

G&239)(29''/!;(2H(),!13&!G$)&/!A+$G!13&!2$5)1&+1$;!E3('&!-52H(),!;9()A5''/!$)!

3(-!.$11$G!'(;8! !

T3&![('(;()$!-&1-!13&!$'B!.$E!()-(B&!13&!29-&!.&-(B&!13&!)&E!.$EF!-9/(),F!!

³<RX NQRZ LW¶V D QLFH YLROLQ 7HOO \RXU SDUHQWV LI WKH\ ZDQW WR VHOO LW , FDQ JLYH WKHP D GHFHQW SULFH ´ 7KHQ KH VKXWV WKH FDVH IOLFNLQJ WKH ODWFKHV ! !

<3$+1'/! 13&+&9A1&+F! 13&! -;9+&! 239),&! )$E! -&25+&! E(13()! 9! ;$2H&1F! <9G5&'!

19H&-!13&!%($'()!29-&!$AA!13&!2$5)1&+!9)B!9.$51MA92&-!E(13$51!9!E$+B8!!R51!E3('&!

G9H(),! 9! .&&'()&! A$+! 13&! B$$+F! 3&! -5BB&)'/! ;95-&-! ()! 13&! 9(-'&F! 1('1(),! 3(-! 23()!

5;E9+B!1$!2$)-(B&+!9!-3&'A!L5-1!.&/$)B!3(-!+&923F!-5+%&/(),!9)!&)1(+&!G&)9,&+(&!

$A!2+/-19'!A(,5+()&-²-)9('-F!3$+-&-F!;&),5()-F!-E9)-F!;9++$1-F!23('B+&)F!A'$E&+-² 13&!H()B!1391!3(-!G$13&+!.5/-!E3&)&%&+!;$--(.'&!/&1!9+&!-29+2&'/!+&,9+B&B!./!3&+! $)2&!13&/!39%&!.&&)!;'92&B!9G$),!3&+!,+$E(),!2$''&21($)8!!\$E&+(),!3(-!23()!9)B! A+$E)(),!B&L&21&B'/F!3&!13&)!-2511'&-!1$!13&!B$$+F!35++/(),!$51-(B&!9-!13$5,3!13&! ;9E)-3$;!A'$$+!E9-!2$''9;-(),!5)B&+A$$1²+&A5-(),!3(G-&'A!9)$13&+!,'9)2&!91!13&! ()'()&! -H91&-! ()! 13&! E()B$EF! '&-1! 13&! -(,31! $A! 13&G! E$5'B! B9G;&)! 3(-! -;(+(1-!

A5+13&+8!! !

_&15+)(),! 13&! E9/! 3&! 39B! 2$G&F! <9G5&'! 2+$--&-! -1+&&1-! 9)B! +$5)B-!

2$+)&+-8! ! Z&! ;9--&-! 9! 1&))(-! 2$5+1F! 9! 2$GG5)(1/! -E(GG(),! ;$$'F! 9! ;5.'(2! ;9+H8!! <$$)! 9)! 923(),! -&)-91($)! 2+&&;-! ()1$! 13&! A(.&+-! $A! 3(-! '&,-F! 9)BF! 9-! .&A$+&F! 3&!

-1+$''-! 9'$),-(B&! 9! +$E! $A! $'&9)B&+-8! ! "! ;$'(2&! 3&'(2$;1&+! 29+&&)-! E('B'/! $%&+! +&-(B&)1(9'! +$$A1$;-8! ! <$9+(),! 9.$%&! 3(GF! 13&! 3&'(2$;1&+! (-! 9! G9--(%&! B9+H! .$$G&+9),! E3(+'(),! 92+$--! 9)! 9K5+&! -H/8! ! R51! 13&+&! $)! 13&! -(B&E9'HF! E3('&! )9%(,91(),!A9G('(9+!1&++(1$+/F!3&!(-!1$$!B(-1+921&B!1$!29+&S!91!1391!&I921!G$G&)1!3&!

(-! 29'25'91(),! 3(-! -9%(),-²13&! 239),&! ()! 3(-! ;$2H&1F! 13&! W`8>a! ()! 3(-! D$+9&G$)! ;&))/!.9)H²9!,+9)B!1$19'!$A!Wbc8da8! !

,W¶V QRW HQRXJKF! 3&! 3&9+-! 13&! [('(;()$! -9/8! ! :"))( 7KHQ WKH PDQ¶V

-/G;913&1(2! &/&! .'()H-! ()! 3(-! G()BF! 9)B! 3&! .&,()-! ;(%$1(),! 3(-! 3&9B! .92H! 9)B! A$+13F! 39%(),! B&2(B&B! 1$! 2$)2'5B&! 13&! L$5+)&/! 3$G&! E(13! 3(-! '&A1! &/&'(B! H&;1!

2'$-&BF!%(&E(),!&%&+/13(),!9.$51!3(G!9-!9!;9+1(9''/!.'()B!.$/²13&!G()51(9!$A!3(-! )&(,3.$+3$$B! 9;;&9+(),! ()2$G;'&1&! .51! 9'-$! G$+&! 2'&9+'/! B&A()&B²9)B! A()B-!

3(G-&'A! E$)B&+(),F! A$+! 9! 1(G&F! 3$E! G523! 13&! ;9E)-3$;! E$5'B! ,(%&! 3(G! A$+! 9!

-(),'&!,'9--!&/&.9''8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =a?! !

T3&!E&&H&)B!9++(%&-!A$+!<9G5&'!E(13!9!A9()1F!;&+-(-1&)1!-2+9123(),!)$(-&!)&9+!3(-! .&B²9! +3/13G(2! 2'911&+! $A! 1()/! 2'9E-! 9)B! 1&&13! 9,9()-1! G&19'F! ,+$E(),! G$+&!

A&%&+(-3! 9-! -5)'(,31! .+(,31&)-! 13&! E()B$EF! 13&! -39B$E-! $A! B9E)! &%9;$+91(),8!!

0$-1!<915+B9/!G$+)(),-!3&!-;+(),-!A+$G!.&B!&9+'/F!+5-3(),!()1$!13&!'(%(),!+$$G! 1$!E9123!29+1$$)-8!!R51!)$1!1$B9/8!!7)-1&9BF!3&!.'()H-!9E9H&!$)!3(-!.92H!E(13$51! .9+&'/! G$%(),! 9)! ()23F! -19+(),! 91! 13&! 2&('(),! 9)B! 13&! $%&+3&9B! '(,31! A(I15+&! 1391!

-1(''!)&&B-!(1-!.5'.!+&;'92&B8!![$+!-$G&!+&9-$)!3(-!29'%&-!923&F!3(-!&/&-!9+&!(123/F! /&1!3&!A&&'-!E&''!+&-1&B!)&%&+13&'&--8! !

7)%$'5)19+('/!2'$-(),!3(-!&/&-!9,9()F!9!-5BB&)!/9E)!2$)-5G&-!3(G!'(H&!9)!

5)2$)1+$''9.'&! 2$5,38! ! T3&)! 3&! +&-5G&-! ,9K(),! 1$E9+B! 13&! 2&('(),! E3('&! -'(B(),! $)&!'&,!A+$G!13&!-3&&1-!-$!1391!(1!B9),'&-!$AA!13&!&B,&!$A!13&!.&BF!1$&-!.+5-3(),! ;&)B5'5GM'(H&! 92+$--! 13&! 29+;&18! ! Z&! 39-! -'&;1! '91&+! 139)! 5-59'8! ! #$1! &%&)! .$13&+(),! 1$! ,'9)2&! 91! 13&! 9'9+G! 2'$2H! $)! 3(-! B&-HF! 3&! H)$E-! 3&! 39-! G(--&B! .+&9HA9-1!E(13!3(-!G$13&+F!9)B!3&!H)$E-!3&!39-!9'-$!G(--&B!3(-!A9%$+(1&!29+1$$)-8!!

R/!)$E!\$5(-9!(-!9'+&9B/!,$)&F!)$!B$5.1!+(B(),!13&!.5-!1$!E$+H!$)!E391!'$$H-!1$! .&!9!)(2&!B9/8!!N51-(B&!13&!-5)!-3()&-!.+(,31'/!9G(B!9!2'&9+!-H/F!.(+B-!23911&+!9)B! A'(1! 9'$),! .92H/9+B! .+9)23&-F! /$5),&+! H(B-! ;'9/! 19,! )&I1! B$$+F! .51! 9''! $A! (1! (-!

B(-+5;1&B! ./! 13&! G$5-&! 2'9G$+(),! 9E9/! ()! 13&! 29,&! '(H&! 9! B&-;&+91&! ()G91&² 2'9E-! 15,,(),F! 1&&13! ,)9E(),²51('(K(),! 13&! .9+-! $A! (1-! $E)! 2$)19()G&)1! A$+!

2$GG5)(291($):!!A$$BF!A$$BF!A$$B²)$EF!)$EF!)$Ee! !

³<RX VKXW XS PRXVH ´ KH VD\V VZLQJLQJ KLV GDQJOLQJ OHJ IDVWHU DV LI WR

&G;39-(K&!3(-!9))$/9)2&8!

!

0"";<#$"";<#$"";²#

!

³6WXSLG PRXVH ´!

!

Z&!39-!9'E9/-!29''&B!13&!+$B&)1!L5-1!*"%=-!9)B!)$13(),!&'-&8!!7)!T9(;&(!3&!

39B!$)2&!H&;1!9)$13&+!G$5-&²E3(1&!E(13!+&B!&/&-F!-G9''&+!139)!13&!$)&!3&!39-! )$E²9! ;&1! $AA&+&B! 9-! 9! ,(A1! ./! 3(-! 5)2'&! E3&)! 3&! %(-(1&B! +&'91(%&-! B$E)! -$5138!!

T391! ;9+1(25'9+! G$5-&! 3&! 39B! )9G&B! \(11'&! @3(1&/F! 9)B! A$+! '&--! 139)! 9! E&&H! (1!

E9-!3$5-&B!()-(B&!9!-3$&.$IF!-5+%(%(),!'$),!&)$5,3!1$!.&!+&;&91&B'/!1$--&B!91!9! .&B+$$G!E9''²E3&+&F!()-1&9B!$A!A9''(),F!(1!2'5),!13&+&!G$G&)19+('/!./!(1-!2'9E-F! ,+9B59''/! -'(13&+(),! ,+$5)BE9+B8! ! T3&! 1$--(),! ,9G&! E9-! ;'9/&B! $)! 9! 0$)B9/! &%&)(),F!29++(&B!$51!2$%&+1'/!B5+(),!.+&9H-!A+$G!%($'()!;+921(2&!E3('&!3(-!;9+&)1-!

E9123&B!TQ!&'-&E3&+&8!!T3&!A$''$E(),!9A1&+)$$)!3(-!A913&+!B(-2$%&+&B!13&!G$5-&!

B&9B!9)B!)&%&+!-5-;&21&B!E391F!E(13!-29+2&'/!9)/!3()B-(,31!+&O5(+&BF!<9G5&'!39-!

9'E9/-!.&'(&%&B!E9-!13&!1+513:!!13&!2$)1()5&B!A'(),(),!$A!\(11'&!@3(1&/!1$!13&!E9''!

39B!;+$.9.'/!()B52&B!9!'&139'!()L5+/F!9)BF!9-!-523F!3&!E9-!+&-;$)-(.'&!A$+!H(''(),!

3(-!A(+-1!G$5-&²9)!5)B&+-19)B(),!1391!,(%&-!+(-&!1$!9!1E(),&!$A!,5('1!E3&)&%&+!(1!

-3$5'B!2+$--!3(-!G()B8! !

P)A$+15)91&'/F! 13$5,3F! \(11'&! @3(1&/! E9-! $)'/! 13&! G$-1! +&2&)1! ()! 9!

-522&--($)! $A! ;&1! 1+9,&B(&-8! ! T3&+&! E&+&! 13&! )5G&+$5-! ,$'BA(-3! E3$! +$51()&'/!

A'$91&B!'(A&'&--!1$!13&!1$;!$A!13&(+!19)HF!&(13&+!$%&+A&B!$+!5)B&+A&BF!)$!$)&!2$5'B! VD\ IRU VXUH ³7KH GLVSRVDEOH OLJKWHUV RI WKH DQLPDO ZRUOG ´ ZDV KLV IDWKHU¶V 2$)2'5-($)!9.$51!13&!A(-3F!9!-&)1(G&)1!&23$&B!5;$)!13&!5)1(G&'/!;9--(),!$A!\(11'&! @3(1&/8! ! TE$! $A! 13&! ,$'BA(-3F! 3$E&%&+F! 39B! G&1! 13&(+! A91&! $)! 9! '(%(),! +$$G! 1('&F! 39%(),!.&&)!-'$-3&B!A+$G!9!;'9-1(2!G(I(),!.$E'!1391!1&G;$+9+('/!3&'B!9''!13&!A(-3!

ZKLOH 6DPXHO FKDQJHG WKH WDQN¶V ZDWHU²9!'&A1!-)&9H&+!922(B&)19''/!.5G;(),!13&! .$E'!E3&+&!(1!-91F!2+&91(),!9!E9%&!1391!-&)1!13&!1E$!B$$G&B!A(-3!$%&+.$9+BF!13&)!

9! +(,31! -)&9H&+! -1&;;(),! .92HE9+B-F! '9)B(),! -O59+&'/! $)! .$13! -O5(+G(),!

29-19E9/-!9-!<9G5&'!15+)&B!9+$5)B!1$!23&2H!(A!3&!39B!5;&)B&B!13&!.$E'8!! >"?.## >"?.##T3&/!39B!-$5)B&B!'(H&!A(+&2+92H&+-!&I;'$B(),!5)B&+A$$1F!.5+-1(),!9'G$-1!()!

5)(-$)F!9)B!A$+!9!A&E!-&2$)B-!3&!-1$$B!-1(''F!-19+(),!.'9)H'/!91!3(-!A&&1!/&1!A&9+(),!

13&!1&++(.'&!G&--!1391!E$5'B!-$$)!.&!B(-2$%&+&B!9A1&+!'(A1(),!3(-!+(,31!-3$&!$AA!13&!

A'$$+8! !

"!/&9+!'91&+!-9E!13&!-E(A1!;9--(),!$A!R$.$F!9!2$''9+&B!.5-3M+$.()!.+$5,31!

3$G&!./!3(-!A913&+!A+$G!9!EXVLQHVV WULS WR 7¶DLM)9)8!!R&(),!9!.(1!,+5../F!+&&H(),! $A!B+(&B!&I2+&G&)1F!(1!E9-!-1(''!9!;'&9-(),!.(+B²922&;1(),!$A!35G9)!1$523F!O5(&1² E(13!9!-G911&+(),!$A!.'5(-3!A&913&+-!-2911&+&B!13+$5,3$51!(1-!;+&B$G()91&'/!,+9/!

SOXPDJH %XW XSRQ HQWHULQJ WKH &KX¶V!9;9+1G&)1F!R$.$!E9-!5)E(11(),'/!,+9)1&B! 13&!'(A&!&I;&219)2/!$A!9!2$GG$)!3$5-&!A'/²&%&)!13$5,3!<9G5&'!39B!(GG&B(91&'/!

B$1&B!$)!3(-!)&E!;&1F!,$(),!-$!A9+!9-!1$!.913&!13&!.(+B!E(13!9!,&)&+$5-!'913&+(),! $A!-39G;$$F!&%&)159''/!-G&9+(),!1$$13;9-1&!91!13&!1(;-!$A!(1-!A&913&+-!A$+!9!G()1/M A+&-3!-G&''F!9)B!13&)!.'$E!B+/(),!R$.$!.&A$+&!;511(),!(1!()!9!29,&!$)!13&!.9'2$)/8!!

T3&! )&I1! G$+)(),! 13&! .(+B! '9/! .&'$E! (1-! ;&+23F! -1(AA! 9)B! 5)G$%(),! $)! 13&! )&E-;9;&+!+&-&+%&B!A$+!(1-!B+$;;(),-:!!9!%(21(G!$A!G(-,5(B&B!29+&F!<9G5&'!9)B!3(-! ;9+&)1-! E$5'B! .&! 1$'B! 91! 9! )&9+./! %&1&+()9+/! 2'()(2S! 13&! -39G;$$! 39B! E9-3&B! 9E9/!13&!;+$1&21(%&!$('-!A+$G!(1-!A&913&+-F!-1+(;;(),!13&!.(+B!$A!(1-!)915+9'!B&A&)-&!

9,9()-1!2$'B&+!E&913&+F!9)B!R$.$!39B!-(G;'/!A+$K&)!1$!B&913!$%&+)(,318! !

T3&!H)$E'&B,&!1391!3&!9'$)&!39B!295-&B!13&!;$$+!.(+BV-!B&G(-&!B(-1+&--&B!

<9G5&'!A$+!9!E3('&F!.+(),(),!9)!&I9,,&+91&B!;$51!1$!3(-!A92&!E3&)&%&+!3&!13$5,31!

9.$51!R$.$F!3(-!&/&-!1&9+(),!5;8!!"1!1(G&-!3(-!G$13&+!1+(&B!2$)-$'(),!3(GF!29'G'/!

VD\LQJ WKLQJV OLNH ³7KDW V KRZ! OLIH LV ,W V QRERG\ V IDXOW ´ %XW /RXLVD¶V ZRUGV $)'/!-$5)B&B!$.'(,91$+/F!-$G&E391!A$+2&BF!9-!(A!-3&!39B!,'&9)&B!13&!9;;+$;+(91&!

UHVSRQVHV E\ ZDWFKLQJ 79 PHORGUDPDV ³6KXQJM/$F! &%&+/! 2+&915+&! 39-! (1-! $E)!

GHVWLQ\ GRQ¶W \RX VHH"´ )LQDOO\ WKRXJK WKUHH GD\V¶ ZRUWK RI KLV UHFXUULQJ SRXW E9-! -5BB&)'/! G9123&B! ./! 13&! -(),5'9+! B(-;'9/! $A! 3&+! A+$E)F! 13&! A5+'(),! $A! 3&+!

EURZ WKH KDUG VTXLQW RI KHU JD]H ³"(M/9 IRUJHW DERXW LW ´ VKH VDLG VZDWWLQJ KLV VKRXOGHU ZLWK LPSDWLHQFH ³,W V MXVW D GXPE ELUG ´ 7KL-!+&.5H&!2$G(),!A+$G!13&!

-9G&! E$G9)! E3$! H&;1! 9! B$K&)! $+! G$+&! ;(,&$)-! ()! 9! 35123! 9.$%&! 13&(+!

9;9+1G&)1²2'(G.(),! 1$! 13&! +$$A1$;! &923! G$+)(),! -$! -3&! 2$5'B! -2911&+! A&&B! G(I! 9)B!2$$!91!13&G!'(H&!13&/!E&+&!3&+!.9.(&-F!+&15+)(),!()!13&!&%&)(),!1$!2$''&21!13&! &,,-! 1391! E$5'B! 13&)! .&2$G&! ;9+1! $A! 13&! B())&+! G&9'8! ! ")B! 1E(2&! 9! G$)13! -3&!

E$5'B!+&1+(&%&!13&!A911&-1!;(,&$)!A+$G!13&!35123F!2+9B'(),!(1!.&1E&&)!3&+!39)B-F! E3(-;&+(),! ,&)1'/! 9''! 13&! E3('&F! +&9--5+(),! 13&! .(+B! ()! 13&! -&2$)B-! .&A$+&! -3&!

VQDSSHG LWV QHFN ³,I \RX GRQ¶W JLYH WKHP QDPHV ´ VKH KDG RQFH H[SODLQHG WR 6DPXHO ZKLOH VWLUULQJ D VLPPHULQJ SRW RI KHU SLJHRQ PHDW VWHZ ³WKHQ \RX GRQ¶W UHDOO\ PLVV WKHP WRR PXFK ZKHQ WKH\¶UH JRQH ´ 6XFK DQ XQDGRUQHG VHQWLPHQW

E9-! -$G&13(),! 3&! E$5'B! 3&&B! 9A1&+! 2$G(),! 1$! 13&! <191&-F! -$G&13(),! 3&! 9'(,)&B! KLPVHOI ZLWK XSRQ SLFNLQJ RXW WKH SLHEDOG PRXVH DV /LWWOH :KLWH\¶V $PHULFDQ -522&--$+8! !

%XW LW LVQ¶W WKH PHPRULHV RI SDVW SHWV WKDW QRZ WXJV DW 6DPXHOµV WKRXJKWV

)$+! (-! (1! 13&! ;&-1&+(),! )9G&'&--! G$5-&! G9H(),! 9! +92H&1! )&9+! 3(-! .&B! 1391! 1+5'/!

B(-1+921-! 3(GS! +913&+F! 3(-! G()B! 39-! .&&)! ;+&$225;(&B! ./! 13&! -9G&! -191(2! G&)19'!

(G9,&! A+$G! 13&! ()-19)1! 3&! E$H&F! 2$G(),! 1$! 3(G! &%&)! E3&)! 3(-! &/&-! E&+&! -1(''!

-351:! ! 13&! L5)($+! ()'()&! -H91&-! ()! 13&! ;9E)-3$;! E()B$EF! -'&&H! 9)B! .'92H! E(13! ,$'B&)! 1+(GG&B! E3&&'-8! ! [$+1/MA(%&! B$''9+-F! 3&! 13()H-8! ! [$+1/MA(%&! G()5-! -(I1&&)!

1E&)1/M&(,318! ! @3('&! B$(),! 13&! G913! A$+! 13&! 5G;1&&)13! 1(G&! -()2&! /&-1&+B9/!

9A1&+)$$)F! 13&! A(),&+-! $A! 3(-! +(,31! 39)B! .&,()! B+5GG(),! .5-('/! 5)B&+)&913! 13&!

-3&&1-! 9-! (A! 29'25'91(),! 13&! )XPEHUV RQ KLV EHKDOI ³7ZHQW\M&(,31! -&%&)1/MWZR ´ 3&! 2$)2'5B&-! /&1! 9,9()F! G5G.'(),! 13&! 9)-E&+! 1$! 3(G-&'AF! B(-9;;$()1&B! 1391! 13&!

DPRXQW GLGQ¶W PLUDFXORXVO\ GHFUHDVH GXULQJ WKH QLJKW ³1RW HQRXJK ´! !

]%&)! -$F! 13&! 2923&! ()-(B&! 3(-! D$+9&G$)! ;&))/! .9)H! 39-! ,9()&B! %9'5&! ()!

13&!;+&%($5-!1E&'%&!3$5+-F!9(B&B!./!13&!A921!1391!3(-!G$13&+!)&%&+!9-H&B!9.$51!13&!

239),&! '&A1$%&+! A+$G! 13&! ;5+239-&! $A! 13&! .$E8! ! \$5(-9! 39BF! ()-1&9BF! O5&-1($)&B! 3(G!$)!$13&+!G911&+-!E3('&!13&/!91&!B())&+:!!Z$E!'$),!B(B!3&!;+921(2&!13&!%($'()!

9A1&+! -23$$'F! 9)B! E3&+&! (-! 13&! )&E! .$E! 91f! ! ")B! 3$E! G523! $A! 13&! ]),'(-3! %$29.5'9+/!B(B!3&!G&G$+(K&!13(-!E&&Hf!!Z9-!3&!.&&)!-15B/(),!E&''f!!D(B!3&!;9/!

911&)1($)!()!3(-!2'9--&-f!!7-!3&!+&9B/!A$+!3(-!<5)B9/!+&2(19'!91!13&!+&-195+9)1F!9)B! B(B! 3&! 39)B! $51! 13&! IOLHUV \HW" ³:KR UDLVHG \RX WR EH WKLV OD]\" ,W ZDVQ¶W PH )LQLVK HDWLQJ WKHQ \RX SUDFWLFH IRU 1HZ .DQJ .DQJ 1R PRUH 79 ´! !

T3&!239),&!E9-!+(,31A5''/!3(-F!<9G5&'!B&2(B&B8!!Z&!39B!&9+)&B!(1!./!-(11(),!

13&+&! 91! 13&! 19.'&! &%&+/! &%&)(),! 9)B! ;511(),! 5;! E(13! 3&+! O5&-1($)-²13&! H()B! $A! O5&-1($)-! 1391! E&+&! ()1&)B&B! 9-! -;+(),.$9+B-! 1$! 3(-! 5)-91(-A921$+/! +&;'(&-F! +&,9+B'&--! $A! 3$E! G523! 3&! 1+(&B! ;'&9-(),! 3&+8! ! <15B/(),f! ! ^+9B&-f! ! Q($'()f!! @3&)&%&+! 3&! 9)-E&+&B! 3&+! (1! A&'1! '(H&! 9! 1+9;! B$$+! E9-! -E(),(),! $;&)! .&)&913!

KLP GURSSLQJ KLP LQWR WKH ERWWRPOHVV SLW RI KHU GLVDSSURYDO ³7KDW¶V QR JRRG <35),M/$8! ! U$5! G5-1! B$! 13&! +(,31! 13(),! 9)B! 2$)2&)1+91&! 39+B&+8! ! D$! /$5! 13()H! \RX DUH EHWWHU WKDQ DQ\RQH HOVH" 'R \RX WKLQN \RXU SDUHQWV DUH ULFK"´ ,I D GLPH E9-!B&;$-(1&B!E(13()!13&!;&))/!.9)H! A$+!&923!B&A&91(),!O5&-1($)!-3&!9-H&B²3&!

1$'B! 3(G-&'A! '9-1! )(,31! 9-! -3&! -;$H&²13&)! 91! '&9-1! 9! B$K&)! ()'()&! -H91&-! E$5'B! 39%&!9'+&9B/!,+92&B!3(-!A&&1F!13&!.&B+$$G!2'$-&1!E$5'B!.&!2+9GG&B!E(13!13&G8! !

")B!$)2&!<9G5&'!E9-!B$)&!&91(),F!3&!35++(&B!1$!3(-!.&B+$$GF!B(,,(),!13&!

239),&!A+$G!3(-!;$2H&1!91!13&!G$G&)1!13&!B$$+!E9-!2'$-&BF!9)B!;+$G;1'/!-'(;;&B! 13&! Wc8Yg! 13+$5,3! 13&! ;&))/! .9)HV-! -'$1F! B$(),! -$! E(13! 9! -&)-&! $A! L5-1(A(291($)!

WKDW VHHPHG DIILUPHG E\ 'RUDHPRQ¶V JULQQLQJ EOXH DQG ZKLWH IDFH !!71V-!$)'/!A9(+F! 3&!+&9-$)&B8!! !

<3&! ;+$.9.'/! E$)V1! &%&)! G(--! (1F! 3&! (G9,()&B! D$+9&G$)! 9--5+(),! 3(G8!!

7VG! -5+&! -3&! 13()H-! /$5! -;&)1! (1! 9''! $)! 13&! .$E! 9)/E9/8! ! _&,9+B'&--F! /$5V%&! ,$1! )$13(),!1$!A&&'!,5('1/!9.$518! !

³, NQRZ ´!

!

]-;&2(9''/!E3&)!-3&!9'E9/-!,&1-!E391!-3&!E9)1-!E3&)!-3&!E9)1-!(1F!.51!(1!

B$&-)V1!E$+H!1391!E9/!A$+!/$58! !

³7KDW V ULJKW ´ KH VDLG OLIWLQJ 'RUDHPRQ IURP WKH GHVN ZRQGHULQJ LI LW IHOW

GLVFHUQLEO\ KHDYLHU ,W GLGQ¶W 7KHQ KH VKRRN WKH SHQQ\ EDQN EHVLGH DQ HDU 1('1(),!(1!13(-!E9/!9)B!1391F!'(-1&)(),!9-!13&!2$()-!2'()H&B!9)B!-'(B!9+$5)B!()-(B&8!!

T3&! -3(A1(),! $A! 25++&)2/! E9-! -$$13(),F! $BB'/! ;&92&A5'F! '(H&! -&9-3&''-! 15G.'(),!

WRJHWKHU RQ D VKRUH DIWHU D ZDYH KDG UHFHGHG %XW WKH VRXQG ZDVQ¶W HQRXJK WR O5&''! 13&! +&-&)1G&)1! 3&! 39+.$+&B! 1$E9+B! 3(-! G$13&+8! ! T$$! $A1&)! -3&! 39B! PHQWLRQHG WKDW WKH\ GLGQ¶W KDYH PRQH\ WR VSHQG RQ IULYRORXV LWHPV OLNH WR\V RU G9),9! .$$H-²13$-&! (G;+921(29'! 13(),-! 1391! -3&! .&'(&%&B! -&+%&B! )$! +&9'!

A5)21($)²/&1!&%&+/!$13&+!E&&H!$+!-$!G$+&!2+/-19'!A(,5+()&-!E$5'B!9++(%&!A$+!3&+!

E\ PDLO /DVW PRQWK DORQH VKH¶G UHFHLYHG WZR SHDUOM.9+(),!$/-1&+-F!9!.$/!.'$E(),!

9!1+5G;&1F!9)B!;+$2&--($)!$A!13+&&!;&),5()-8! !

[5+13&+G$+&F! L5-1! 9! A&E! B9/-! 9,$F! -3&! 39B! &)1&+19()&B! 13&! (B&9! $A!

;5+239-(),! 9! -&2$)B! B(-;'9/! 29.()&1F! 9! '9+,&+! 5)(1! 1$! 922$GG$B91&! 3&+! +9;(B'/! ,+$E(),!G&)9,&+(&!$A!<E9+$%-H(!2$''&21(.'&-²13&!;+9)2(),!5)(2$+)-F!.511&+A'(&-F! 3$+-&-! $)! ;9+9B&F! D(-)&/! A9%$+(1&-F! .52$'(2! 23('B+&)F! 43+(-1G9-! 1+&&-²1391!

9--&G.'9,&! $A! B&'(291&F! 1+9)-'52&)1! 239+921&+-! $225;/(),! 9! 2$%&1&B! -;$1! )&I1! 1$!

13&!TQ8!!T3&!A(,5+()&-!E&+&!'(H&!;+(-$)&+-F!3&!13$5,31F!&923!;(&2&!-&)1&)2&B!1$!'(A&!

RQ GXVW\ VKHOYHV UDUHO\ QRWLFHG DQG UDUHO\ WRXFKHG +H FRXOGQ¶W LQ IDFW UHFDOO 3(-!G$13&+!&%&+!$;&)(),!13&!29.()&1!1$!19H&!$)&!$51F!1$!9BG(+&!(1!E(13!3&+!A(),&+-!

$+! &)L$/! (1! 9)/E3&+&! &'-&! $13&+! 139)! .&3()B! ,'9--8! ! "-! A9+! 9-! 3&! 2$5'B! 1&''F! 3&+! ;'&9-5+&! E9-! B&+(%&B! -$'&'/! ./! A(''(),! 13&! 13+&&! -3&'%&-F! 9! )&E&+! A(,5+()&! -&1! ()!

A+$)1! $A! 9)! $'B&+! A(,5+()&²9)B! 9-(B&! A+$G! E3&)! 9! '91&-1! 9BB(1($)! E9-! ;'92&B! 9G$),! 3&+! 2$''&21($)F! -3&! 39+B'/! ,9%&! 13&G! 9! -&2$)B! ,'9)2&F! E$5'B! '(H&'/! )$1! &%&)!G(--!9!A&E!$A!13&!$'B&+!;(&2&-!-3$5'B!13&/!-$G&3$E!39;;&)!1$!B(-9;;&9+8! !

0"";<#$"";<#$"";²#

!

<9G5&'! 13+$E-! 13&! -3&&1-! $AA! 3(G-&'AF! -19)B-! 5;! )9H&B! E(13! 9! /9E)F! 9)B!

-1+&123&-8!!T3&!.&9G-!;5-3(),!13+$5,3!13&!3$+(K$)19'!.'()B-!2+(--2+$--!-&21($)-!$A! 3(G!()!9!-'9)1&B!+9B(9)1!,'$EF!1+9)-;$+1(),!B5-1!G$1&-!1391!A'$91!'(H&!9!G(2+$2$-G! .&1E&&)! 3(-! .$B/! 9)B! 13&! E()B$E8! ! @"A<# B"A<# B"A.! ! 7,)$+(),! 13&! ;'&9B(),!

2'9G$+! $A! 13&! G$5-&F! 3&! 13&)! ;'$B-! A+$G! 13&! +$$G! 9)B! ,$&-! 9'$),! 13&! 39''E9/F! B+9,,(),! 3(-! .9+&! A&&1! 92+$--! 13&! 29+;&1F! -2+9123(),! 91! 3(-! '&A1! .511! 23&&H! E3('&! +$5)B(),!9!2$+)&+!1$!&)1&+!13&!B(GG&-1!;9+1!$A!13&!3$5-&²1391!;'92&!E3&+&!13&!

3&9%/! 25+19()-! 9+&! )&%&+! B+9E)F! 9)B! E3&+&F! E(13$51! '(,31-! $)F! (1! (-! 9-! 13$5,3! &%&+/13(),!39-!.&&)!B&&;'/!-5.G&+,&B8! !

"3&9B! $A! 3(GF! $)! 13&! $13&+! -(B&! $A! 13&! '(%(),! +$$GF! -19)B-! 13&! B(-;'9/!

29.()&1F! .51! E3&)! 9;;+$923(),! (1! 3&! 3&-(191&-F! &/&-! )$1! /&1! A5''/! 9BL5-1&BF! 13()H(),! 1391! 3&! 39-! 295,31! 9! ,'(G;-&! $A! -$G&$)&! '5+H(),! ()! 13&! B9+H)&--²9!

-39B$E/F!B(-1$+1&B!A(,5+&!E9%&+(),!-&%&+9'!A&&1!9E9/F!.'$2H(),!13&!-3&'%&-!$A!13&!

GLVSOD\ DV LI SURWHFWLQJ KLV PRWKHU¶V WUHDVXUHV %HIRUH SDQLF FDQ VHL]H KLP WKRXJK 6DPXHO UHDOL]HV WKDW LW¶V MXVW KLV RZQ PXUN\ UHIOHFWLRQ FDVW RQ WKH IXOOM '&),13!,'9--!B$$+!$A!13&!29.()&18!!Z&!-G('&-!E(13!+&'(&AF!E9123(),!9-!13&!+&A'&21($)!

2+92H-! 9! ,+()8! ! <1&;;(),! 2'$-&+F! 3&! ;9--&-! 13+$5,3! 9! '9-&+M'(H&! +9/! $A! -5)'(,31!

-3()(),!A+$G!9!G()(-25'&!,9;!()!13&!25+19()-F!(''5G()91(),!9!B(G&M-(K&B!;9123!$A! 29+;&1!91!13&!.9-&!$A!13&!B(-;'9/8! !

T3&)!A$+!9!E3('&!3&!;95-&-!()!A+$)1!$A!13&!+&A'&21($)F!-15B/(),!13&!$.-25+&!

.$/! $)! 13&! ,'9--! E3$! (-! 9'-$! -15B/(),! 3(GF! .$13! )9H&BF! 13&! )5G&+$5-! A(,5+()&-!

PHVKHG ZLWK WKH WUDQVSDUHQW ERG\ RI KLV FRXQWHUSDUW 6XGGHQO\ WKH UHIOHFWLRQ¶-! +(,31!9+G!'(A1-F!13&!A(),&+-!$A!3(-!39)B!+&923!A$+E9+BF!-'$E'/!G$%(),!1$E9+B!13&!

NQRE RI WKH FDELQHW GRRU ³<RX VKRXOGQ¶W GR WKDW ´ 6DPXHO ZDQWV WR ZDUQ KLP EXW LQVWHDG GRHVQ¶W VD\ D ZRUG².&295-&F!9-!(1!-$!39;;&)-F!3&!(-!B$(),!&I921'/!13&!

-9G&!13(),8!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =`?! !

R/! 13&! 1(G&! <9G5&'! -1&;-! ()-(B&! 13&! ;9E)-3$;F! -3$+1'/! 9A1&+! )$$)F! 13&! ;'&9-9)1!

G$+)(),!39-!.&&)!13E9+1&B!./!-;$+9B(2!E()B!,5-1-F!13&!25++&)1-! A'$E(),!./!9)B! 13&)! B(--(;91(),! ()! .+(&A! -5+,&-! 1391! 1$5-'&B! 3(-! 5)E9-3&B! 39(+! E3('&! 3&! 39B! 35++(&B! 9'$),! 13&! -(B&E9'H-8! ! Z&! (-! B+&--&B! ()! /&-1&+B9/V-! 2'$13&-².511$)M5;!

E3(1&! -3(+1F! .'92H! -$2H-F! B+&--! -'92H-²29+1(),! 13&! )/'$)! .92H;92H! -$! 1391! 3(-!

1&))(-!-3$&-!29)!.&!-1$E&B!13&+&!$)2&!13&!()'()&!-H91&-!9+&!;5+239-&B8!!"-!(A!13&!

G9)!39B)V1!G$%&B!-()2&!13&/!'9-1!-9E!&923!$13&+F!13&![('(;()$!+&G9()-!-&91&B!$)!

9!-1$$'!91!13&!2$5)1&+²9'-$!E&9+(),!13&!-9G&!2'$13&-!A+$G!/&-1&+B9/F!9(G(),!1391!

5)&%&)! -19+&! 1$E9+B! 13H VWRUH¶V IURQW²9! 39K&! $A! 2(,9+&11&! -G$H&! &)2(+2'(),! 3(G! '(H&!9!1$I(2!95+98!!T3&!1&++9M2$119!E9++($+!-19)B-!,59+B!)&9+!13&!&)1+9)2&8!!")(19!

05(! -(),-! 9)$13&+! 3(1! A+$G! 13&! .$$G! .$I8! ! T3&! 2'511&+&B! 9(-'&-! 9+&! B&%$(B! $A! 25-1$G&+-8!!T$B9/F!(1!-&&G-F!(-!-1(''!13&!;+&%($5-!B9/S!13&!;9E)-3$;!39-!3&'B!1(G&!

DW ED\ DQG WR 6DPXHO¶V UHOLHI WKH LQOLQH VNDWHV DUH ZDLWLQJ EHKLQG WKH ZLQGRZ ! !

³2K LW¶V \RX DJDLQ ´ WKH )LOLSLQR VD\V JULQQLQJ ³<RX¶YH FRPH IRU WKH

UROOHUEODGHV"´! !

@(13$51!-;&9H(),!$+!&%&)!92H)$E'&B,(),!13&!G9)F!<9G5&'!;'92&-! 3(-!$'B!

%($'()! .$E! 9)B! 9! .5)23&B! 5;! E3(1&! TM-3(+1! $)! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;8! ! Z&!5)E+9;-! 13&!

-3(+1!'(H&!9!;+&-&)1F!+&%&9'(),!1E$!$A!3(-!G$13&+V-!G()(915+&!2$''&21(.'&-!.5)B'&B! E(13()!13&!2$11$)!'9/&+-F!9!;9(+!$A!3&+!'&9-1!;+(K&B!A(,5+()&-!1391!E&+&!-1+91&,(29''/! '(A1&B! A+$G! 13&! .92H! $A! 9)! $%&+2+$EB&B! 29.()&1! -3&'A:! ! 9! A92&1&B! 2'&9+M2+/-19'! .&9,'&F!+3$B(5GM;'91&BF!E(13!9!A+$-1&B!2+/-19'!19('!9)B!L&1!2+/-19'!)$-&!9)B!&/&-S!9! [$+,&1M0&M#$1! A92&1&B! 2'&9+M2+/-19'! A'$E&+! ;$1F! +3$B(5GM;'91&BF! E(13! 13+&&!

.'$--$G-!()!A92&1&B!-9;;3(+&!2+/-19'8!!J&&;(),!3(-!3&9B!'$E&+&BF!3&!13&)!;5-3&-! .$13! 13&! .$E! 9)B! 13&! -3(+1! 92+$--! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;F! '(H&! -$G&$)&! 2&+&G$)($5-'/! '&9%(),!9)!$AA&+(),!91!9!1&G;'&!9'1&+8! !

"! '$),! -(,3! L&11(-$)-! G$+&! -G$H&! ()1$! 13&! -3$;S! 13&! ,+9/(-3! %9;$+-!

GHVFHQG XSRQ WKH FRXQWHUWRS WKURXJK WKH PDQ¶V VSDFLRXV QRVWULOV ³,W¶V ILYH IRU WKH ERZ ´ WKH )LOLSLQR VD\V WKHQ QRGV UHVROXWHO\ :LWK WKDW VHWWOHG KH QXGJHV 13&! .$E! 9-(B&! E3('&! .&)B(),! A$+E9+B! $)! 13&! -1$$'F! -3(A1(),! 3(-! 3&9B! -$! 1391! 3(-! ,$$B!&/&!29)!,&1!9!2'$-&+!'$$H!91!13&!A(,5+()&-8!!"A1&+!9!G$G&)1!$A!9;;+9(-9'F!3&! '&9)-! .92H! 9)B! E9%&-! 3(-! 2(,9+&11&! 39)B! 9.$%&! 13&! TM-3(+1! 9-! (A! 29-1(),! 9! -;&''8!! ³)RU WKHVH ´ KH VD\V DEVHQWO\ VSULQNOLQJ DVK WKDW G+(A1-! $%&+! 13&! A(,5+()&-! '(H&!

JULP\ VQRZIODNHV ³\RX FDQ JHW WZHOYH ´! !

³7ZHOYH HDFK"´ 6DPXHO DVNV KLV VRIW YRLFH FDUU\LQJ D GHJUHH RI

3$;&A5')&--8!! !

³1R WZHOYH IRU ERWK ´ 7KH )LOLSLQR SRLQWV WKH IXPLQJ WLS RI KLV FLJDUHWWH DW

13&!.&9,'&²³6L[´²13&)!91!13&!A'$E&+!;$1²³DQG VL[ ´! !

"! -G9''! A+$E)! -5BB&)'/! A$+G-! $)! <9G5&'8! ! Z&! +9(-&-! 3(-! 23()! 9)B! -19+&-!

LQWR WKH PDQ¶V URXQG IDFH ZKLOH ELWLQJ KLV ORZHU OLS ! !

³, P DOUHDG\ YHU\ JHQHURXV ´ WKH )LOLSLQR WHOOV KLP ³7KHVH VPDOO

NQLFNNQDFNV GRQ W VHOO ZHOO ´ $V LA! .$+&B! ./! -523! .9+,9()(),F! 13&! .+$E)! ,'9--!

SXSLO UROOV WR RQH FRUQHU RI LWV VRFNHW KDOIZD\ YDQLVKLQJ LQ WKH PDQ¶V VNXOO ³7ZHOYH LV D EHWWHU SULFH WKDQ \RXµOO ILQG DQ\ZKHUH ´! !

<9G5&'! -39H&-! 3(-! 3&9B²9)! 9))$/&BF! B&A(9)1! -39H&².&A$+&! '$E&+(),! 3(-!

23()!()!B(-9;;$()1G&)18! !

³1RW ZKDW \RX ZDQWHG WR KHDU KXK" <RX JRW DQ\WKLQJ HOVH"´!

!

R51!9'+&9B/!<9G5&'!(-!B(,,(),!()!3(-!;9)1-F!;5''(),!91!9!2$()MA(''&B!h(;M'$2!

.9,,(&!1391!3&!15,-!A+$G!9!;$2H&1²9!L5G.'&!$A!;&))(&-F!O59+1&+-F!)(2H&'-F!B(G&-F! 9! A&E! 2+5G;'&B! .(''-²9)B! B&;$-(1-! 3(-! &)1(+&! -9%(),-! $)! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;! .&-(B&!

13&!TM-3(+18! !

³+RZ PXFK LV WKHUH"´!

!

<9G5&'! 9)-E&+-! 3(G! B(-2+&&1'/F! &)5)2(91(),! 13&! 1$19'! $A! Wbc8da! -'$E'/F!

511&+(),!(1!9-!9!E3(-;&+8! !

³, VHH ´ 7KH )LOLSLQR VWD\V VLOHQW IRU D ZKLOH LQWHQWO\ IRFXVL),!3(-!,$$B!&/&!

91! <9G5&'V-! -9%(),-F! 9-! 13$5,3! 3&! E&+&! ;-/23(29''/! 2$5)1(),! &923! 2$()! 9)B! .(''! ()-(B&! 13&! .9,,(&F! $)&! ./! $)&F! G9H(),! -5+&! 13&! 9G$5)1! (-! 2$++&218! ! Z&! 19H&-! 9!

2$5;'&!$A!13$5,31A5'!;5AA-F!13&)!B+$;-!13&!2(,9+&11&!1$!13&!2$)2+&1&!A'$$+F!2+5-3(),!

LW XQGHU D VKRH DPRQJ D JUDYH\DUG RI IODWWHQHG EXWWV DQG ILQDOO\ VD\V ³<RX NQRZ HYHQ ZLWK WKH ERZ DQG WKHVH WULQNHWV LW ZRQµW EH HQRXJK ´! !

",9()! <9G5&'! +&-;$)B-! E(13! 9! -(),'&! B&A(9)1! -39H&! $A! 3(-! 3&9B8! ! R51!

.&)&913!13&!A'(2H&+(),!A'5$+&-2&)1!'(,31F!3(-!&I;+&--($)!.&1+9/-!9)!9(+!$A!A+9,('(1/S! 3(-! G$513²13$-&! 5-59''/! 13()'/! B+9E)! '(;-²O5(%&+! 9)B! ;+&--! $51E9+BF! G9)(A&-1(),!13&!-$+1!$A!A5''MEORZQ SRXW WKDW FDQ TXLFNO\ VXPPRQ KLV PRWKHU¶V LUH /&1!(-!)$E!&I;&21&B!1$!39%&!13&!$;;$-(1&!&AA&21!$)!13&![('(;()$8! !

T3&!G9)!-(,3-!3&9%('/F!A+$E)(),!1$!3(G-&'A!()!9!G9))&+!1391! -5,,&-1-!3&!

NQRZV LW¶V QHYHU ZLVH GRLQJ EXVLQHVV ZLWK D NLG $ IUHVK FLJDUHWWH PLUDFXORXVO\ 9;;&9+-!.&1E&&)!3(-!A(),&+-F!A5G&-!-E(+'!5;!;9-1!3(-!A92&F!9)B!E3&)!3&!-;&9H-!3(-! ()(1(9'!E$+B-!9+&!WUDQVSRUWHG RQ D WKLFN VWUHDP RI VPRNH ³2ND\ , KDYH DQ LGHD <RX ZRQ¶W JHW WKH UROOHUEODGHV WRGD\ EXW , WKLQN \RX FDQ OHDYH KHUH KDSS\ ´ +H VOLGHV RII WKH VWRRO UHDFKLQJ IRU WKH ERZ DW WKH VDPH WLPH ³$OO , QHHG LV WKLV ´ T3&!.$E!B(-9;;&9+-!.&'$E!WKH FRXQWHU ³$QG WKHVH ´ KH DGGV H[WUDFWLQJ WKH WZR A(,5+()&-!A+$G!13&!TM-3(+18!!Z&!13&)!;5-3&-!13&!.9,,(&!9)B!TM-3(+1!.92H!92+$--!13&!

FRXQWHUWRS WRZDUG 6DPXHO ³.HHS \RXU PRQH\ IRU QRZ DQG NHHS \RXU VKLUW ´ +H 9.$51MA92&-! E(13! 13&! A(,5+()&-! ()! 39)BF! -;&E(),! 9! 1+9('! $A! -G$H&! 9-! 3&! -1+(B&-! .&/$)B! 13&! -1$$'F! ;9--(),! ()1$! 13&! +&9+! $A! 13&! -3$;! 13+$5,3! 9! %&('! $A! 39),(),!

FREDOW EOXH GUDSHV VD\LQJ ZKLOH KH JRHV ³*LYH PH D PLQXWH ´! !

<9G5&'! )$B-F! E9123(),! 13&! [('(;()$! E9)B&+! A+$G! -(,318! ! R51! '&--! 139)! 9!

G()51&!&'9;-&-!.&A$+&!13&!G9)!29''-!$51F!+&O5&-1(),!3(-!;+&-&)2&!$)!13&!$13&+!-(B&! $A!13&!B+9;&-8!![(+-1F!13$5,3F!3&!2$''&21-!13&!.9,,(&!9)B!TM-3(+1F!K(;;(),!13&G!()!

13&!.92H;92H!A$+!-9A&H&&;(),8!!"A1&+!1391F!E3('&!.+(&A'/!+5))(),!9!39)B!9'$),!13&! '&),13!$A!13&!2$5)1&+1$;F!3&!G$%&-!1$E9+B!13&!B+9;&-F!B$(),!3(-!.&-1!1$!3$'B!13&! ;$51!()!;'92&!-()2&F!3&!.&'(&%&-F!(1!39-!;+$%&B!-$G&E391!&AA&21(%&!9-!9!.9+,9()(),!

1$$'8!!N)2&!9,9()!13&![('(;()$!29''-!$51!A$+!3(GF!9)B!E(13!13&!.92H;92H!39),(),!$AA! 3(-!+(,31!-3$5'B&+F!3&!1(,31&)-!3(-!,+(;!$)!(1-!-1+9;!E3('&!.+&923(),!13&!B+9;&-² E3&+&F!9-!13&!A9.+(2!-E9''$E-!3(G!E3$'&F!3&!A()B-!3(G-&'A!&)%&'$;&B!./!B9+H)&--8! !

*95-(),! -$! 1391! 3(-! &/&-! 29)! 9BL5-1F! <9G5&'! -$$)! +&9'(K&-! 1391! 3&! 39-!

&)1&+&B!9!)9++$E!;9--9,&E9/F!)$!G$+&!139)!A(%&!A&&1!()!E(B13F!E(13!9)$13&+!-&1!$A! (B&)1(29'!B+9;&-!39),(),!91!13&!$;;$-(1&!&)B8!!C5-1!13&)!9!-5'A5+$5-!$B$+!3(1-!3(-! )$-1+('-F!;5),&)1!9)B!3&9%/F!'(H&!+$11&)!&,,-8!!T3&!G$5)1(),!-1&)23!(-!-$!.9B!1391!

(1!;+$B52&-!9!+&2$('(),!&I;+&--($)!$)!3(-!A92&F!9!,+(G92&!2$G;$5)B&B!./!13&!5;!1$! )$E! -5''&)! ;+$1+5-($)! $A! 3(-! '(;-8! ! Z$'B(),! 3(-! .+&913F! 3&! 35++(&-! $)E9+BF! &-29;(),! 13+$5,3! 13&! $;;$-(1&! B+9;&-! 9-! (A! A'&&(),! 1$! -9%&! 3(G-&'A! A+$G! 9)! $13&+E(-&!2&+19()!B&9138!!R51!5;$)!&I(1(),!13&!;9--9,&E9/F!3&!(GG&B(91&'/!-1$;-!

-3$+1F! 13&! B(-,5-1&B! &I;+&--($)! 9)B! $%&+E+$5,31! ;$51! 1+9)-A$+G(),! ()1$! 9!

G$513M,9;(),F!E(B&M&/&B!'$$H!$A!.&E('B&+G&)18!! !

@391! E9-! &I;&21&B! 1$! .&! 9! -G9''! -1$+&+$$G! (-F! ()-1&9BF! 9! 39),9+M-(K&B!

E9+&3$5-&F! 91! '&9-1! A(%&! 1(G&-! '9+,&+! 139)! 13&! )$)B&-2+(;1! ;9E)-3$;! (1! 3(B&-! .&3()B8!!T3&!%9-1!()1&+($+!2$)-(-1-!G$-1'/!$A!9)!$;&)!9+&9!A+9G&B!./!'$),!+$E-!$A! &(,31M1(&+&B!-3&'%(),!9)BF!9,9()-1!13&!A9+!E9''F!9!'9+,&!2$)&M-39;&B!.$11'&!H(')!1391!

(-!()!$;&+91($)8!!T3&!A'$$+!(-!-$'(B!2$)2+&1&F!E(13!39/!-1+&E)!&%&+/E3&+&!5;$)!(1! '(H&!-1+(;-!$A!2$)A&11(8!!T3&!(G;$-(),!E9''-!9+&!.+(2H!9)B!G$+19+F!9)B!9!-&+(&-!$A! -(IM;9)&B!E()B$E-!'$$G!)&9+!13&!2&('(),!+9A1&+-F!A$5+!;&+!E9''F!9''$E(),!;'&)1/!$A! -5)'(,31!1$!-3()&!()8!!")!9--$+1G&)1!$A!1$/-!2$%&+!13&!G9)/!-3&'%&-F!G(I(),!E(13!

2$G;51&+! G$)(1$+-F! TQ! -&1-F! -1&+&$-F! -192H-! $A! G9,9K()&-F! 1911&+&B! +$G9)2&! )$%&'-F! $51B91&B! %(B&$! ,9G&! 5)(1-F! "19+(! 29+1+(B,&-F! QZ<! 19;&-F! 29--&11&-F! %()/'! \*-F! XY-F! 4D-F! 9! ,9''&+/! $A! A+9G&B! 9+1E$+HF! ;()H! 9)B! .'5&! ;('&-! $A! A$'B&B! .9./!

2'$13&-F!,$'A!2'5.-F!.(2/2'&!;9+1-F!A(-3(),!+$B-F!29+B.$9+B!.$I&-!A(''&B!1$!13&!.+(G! E(13! A$$1E&9+F! 9)B! 9! -&&G(),'/! &)B'&--! 9225G5'91($)! $A! $13&+! ;9E)&B! (1&G-8!!

T3$-&!13(),-!1391!9+&!1$$!.(,!1$!A(1!$)!13&!-3&'%&-²-1$%&-F!B(-3E9-3&+-F!'95)B+/!

5)(1-F!+&A+(,&+91$+-F!1$('&1-F! B&-H-F!239(+-F!2$AA&&!19.'&-F!2$523&-F!G911+&--&-²9+&! ,+$5;&B!9'$),!$)&!E9''8!! !

71! (-! )$)&! $A! 13(-F! 3$E&%&+F! 1391! (-! 2$)A$5)B(),! <9G5&'F! )$+! (-! (1! 13&!

25+($5-! %(-($)! $A! 13&! [('(;()$! -(11(),! 2'$-&! ./! $)! 9! 2+92H&B! ;$+2&'9()! 1$('&1²9!

-&2$)B!1$('&1!-(1591&B!B(+&21'/!()!A+$)1!$A!3(G².5-('/!.+5-3(),!-$G&13(),!E(13!9!

-3(+1-'&&%&8! ! T3&! G9)! ,'9)2&-! 5;F! 2(,9+&11&! B9),'(),! ;+&29+($5-'/! 91! 9! 2$+)&+! $A! 3(-!G$513F!9)B!)$B-!A$+!3(G!1$!2$G&8!!]I2&;1!<9G5&'V-!,9K&!(-!A(I&B!&'-&E3&+&F! A$25-&B!L5-1!.&/$)B!13&![('(;()$!91!E3&+&!9)!9+G/!$A!'(A&M'(H&!9)B!'(A&M-(K&B!1&++9M 2$119! E9++($+-! $225;/! 13&! $;&)! 9+&9! $A! 13&! E9+&3$5-&F! '()&! 9A1&+! '()&! ()! ;+&2(-&!

G('(19+/!A$+G91($)F!13&(+!-1$(2!%(-9,&-!+&15+)(),!3(-!-19+&8!!T3&+&!9+&!9!A$+1/!$+!-$! $A! 13&! .+$E)(-3M$+9),&! -1915&-F! )$! 1E$! &I921'/! 9'(H&! ()! A92(9'! A&915+&-! $+! &I;+&--($)F! 13&! A(,5+&-! %9+/(),! ()! 3&(,31F! 5)(A$+GF! 9)B! 39(+-1/'&! 922$+B(),! 1$! +9)H8!!<&%&+9'!$A!13&!-1915&-F!&-;&2(9''/!13&!$)&-!-19)B(),!2'$-&-1!1$!13&!H(')F!'92H! 3&9B-! $+! 9+G-²$+! .$13! 9+G-! 9)B! 3&9B-²9)B! $)! 13&! A'$$+! .&1E&&)! 13$-&!

LQFRPSOHWH ZDUULRUV DQG WKH NLOQ VSUHDG DFURVV OLEHUDO VWUHWFKHV RI SDLQWHU¶V ;9;&+F! 9+&! 29+&A5''/! 9++9),&B! 1&++9M2$119! .$B/! ;9+1-²1$+-$-F! '&,-F! 3&9B-F! 9+G-² '(H&!13&!29+)9,&!'&A1!.&3()B!A+$G!-$G&!%($'&)1F!()-&)-(.'&!2&+9G(2!E9+8! !

³6R \RX NQRZ DERXW!4LQ 6KL +XDQJ¶V DUP\"´ WKH )LOLSLQR DVNV ³7KH )LUVW

(PSHURU RI \RXU FRXQWU\ ULJKW"´! !

<9G5&'!-19GG&+-F!911&G;1(),!1$!-;&9HF!.51!)$13(),!95B(.'&!&G&+,&-8!!!

!

³7KDW¶V RND\ ³ WKH )LOLSLQR VD\V SRLQWLQJ DW WKH VHFRQG WRLOHW ³+HUH WDNH

D VHDW ´! !

<9G5&'!)$B-F!B$(),!9-!3&!(-!1$'BF!9)B!-(1-!$)!13&!1$('&1F!+&A5-(),!1$!-3(A1!3(-!

,9K&!A+$G!13&!E9++($+-!1$!13&!G9)8! !

³5HPRYH \RXU VKRHV SOHDVH ´!

!

@3('&! -1$$;(),! 1$! 5)1(&! 3(-! -3$&-F! <9G5&'! 2$)1()5&-! 1$! -1&9'! -(B&'$),!

,'(G;-&-!$A!13&!(G;+&--(%&!9+G/F!13()H(),F!1$$F!$A!i()!<3(!Z59),8!!Z&!+&G&G.&+-! .&(),!195,31!9.$51!3(G!91!-23$$'F!.92H!()!T9(E9)F!.51!E391!()-19)1'/!-;+(),-!1$!

G()B!(-!13&!;+$1$1/;&!^+&91!@9''!1391!13&![(+-1!]G;&+$+!39B!39B!.5('1!1$!B&A&)B! 43()9F!9!G9+%&'!3&!39-!$)'/!+&9B!9.$51!()!13&!;9,&-!$A!1&I1.$$H-8!!T3&)!-'(;;(),! $AA! 3(-! -3$&-F! 3&! E9)1-! 1$! G9H&! (1! 2'&9+! 1$! 13&! [('(;()$! 1391! 3&! (-! 92159''/!

T9(E9)&-&F! )$1! 9! G9()'9)B&+! A+$G! 43()98! ! "'13$5,3! 9)/! 13$5,31! $A! (G;9+1(),!

-523!()A$+G91($)!(-!;+&-&)1'/!A$+,$11&)!E3&)!3&!G$%&-!5;+(,31!9)BF!91!'9-1F!29-1-!

3(-!H\HV RQ WKH REMHFWV UHVWLQJ LQ WKH PDQµV ODS D SDLU RI VKDEE\ TXDGME3&&'&B! +$''&+! -H91&-²-G5B,&B! E3(1&! %()/'! .$$1-! E(13! '&913&+! '()(),F! A+9/&B! +&B! '92&-F! E$+)! B$E)! 1$&! -1$;-F! B(+1/! +&B! E3&&'-! '92H(),! 13&(+! $+(,()9'! -3&&)F! +5-1&B! -1&&'! .9''! .&9+(),-²13&! H()B! 3(-! 95)1! 39B! 195,31! 3(G! $)! 9-! 9! '(11'&! .$/F! 9'G$-1! 13&!

-9G&!H()B!3&!E9-!9''$E&B!1$!.$++$E!&%&+/!-5GG&+!E3&)!%(-(1(),!+&'91(%&-!()!13&!

-$5138!!T3&-&F!3&!2$)2'5B&-F!9+&!$'B&+!2$5-()!-H91&-F!+&'(2-!$A!3(-!+&2&)1!;9-1F!9)B! 13&/!-3$5'B!.&!H&;1!3(BB&)!E(13()! D FORVHW DW KLV XQFOH¶V KRXVH ³7KH\¶UH XJO\ ´ 3&!-9/-F!911&G;1(),!1$!+&-5++&21!13&!;$51!/&1!A9('(),!1$!A5''/!B$!-$8!

!

³2K UHDOO\"´ LV WKH )LOLSLQR¶V VPRN\ LQGLIIHUHQW UHSO\ /LIWLQJ D VNDWH WKH

PDQ VWUHWFKHV KLV IUHH KDQG IRU 6DPXHO¶V DQNOH ³/HW PH VHH \RXU IRRW ´! !

5HFOLQLQJ DJDLQVW WKH WRLOHW¶V ZREEO\ WDQN 6DPXHO UDLVHV KLV OHJV IURP WKH

A'$$+F! ;$()1(),! 3(-! 1$&-! '(H&! 9! .9''&+()98! ! T3&! '&A1! -H91&! -'(B&-! $)F! 13&)! 13&! +(,31!

-H91&F!.$13!+&-1(),!-'92H!5;$)!3(GF!()!13&!%&+/!'&9-1! 9!-(K&!1$$!'9+,&8!!Z&!'$E&+-!

13&!-H91&-F!3(-!A&&1!-3(A1(),!'$$-&'/!()-(B&!$A!13&G8!!! !

³+P ´ 7KH )LOLSLQR VFUDWFKHV DW KLV VFUDJJO\ FKLQ FORVLQJ KLV JODVV H\H

UHO\LQJ RQ KLV JRRG H\H WR REVHUYH WKH JDSV VXUURXQGLQJ 6DPXHO¶V DQNOHV ³:KHUH¶V WKDW VKLUW"´ KH DVNV ! !

<9G5&'! -&1-! 13&! .92H;92H! $)! 13&! A'$$+F! 5)K(;;(),! 13&! 1$;8! ! T3&! TM-3(+1! (-!

+&1+(&%&BF! ;+$AA&+&B! E(13$51! O5&-1($)8! ! ")B! 9-! 13&! .92H;92H! (-! K(;;&B! -351F! 3(-!

1&))(-! -3$&-! )$E! -1$E&B! E(13()! (1F! 13&! [('(;()$! 5-&-! 13&! 2(,9+&11&! &)B! 1$! .5+)! 9!

3$'&!()!13&!TM-3(+1²L5-1!+$5)B!&)$5,3!A$+!9!A(),&+1(;!1$!;$H&!13+$5,3!9)B!15,!91!

13&! A9.+(2F! 1&9+(),! (1! 9;9+1! E(13! '(11'&! &AA$+18! ! T3&! 2'$13! (-! +(;;&B! $)2&! G$+&F! EHFRPLQJ WZR HTXDO SLHFHV $IWHUZDUGV WKH PDQ EHQGV SXOOLQJ 6DPXHO¶V IHHW XS 9!A&E!()23&-!A+$G!13&!-H91&-²'&A1!A$$1!A(+-1F!+(,31!A$$1!)&I1²E+9;;(),!9!1$+)!;(&2&!

9+$5)B! &923! 9)H'&F! H)$11(),! 13&! &)B-F! 9)B! 152H-! 13&G! ()1$! ;'92&! E3&)! ;5-3(),!

13&!A&&1!.92H!B$E)!()-(B&!13&!-H91&-8!! !

³:KDW¶V \RXU QDPH"´ WKH )LOLSLQR WKHQ DVNV ZKLOH W\LQJ WKH ODFHV !

!

<9G5&'!1&''-!3(G8!

!

³6DPXHO"³!

!

³0P ´ 6DPXHO DQVZHUV !

!

³,W¶V D JRRG QDPH , WKLQN ´ 7KH PDQ SDWV KLP WZLFH RQ WKH WKLJK ³2ND\

WKHQ 6DPXHO \RXµUH UHDG\ WR JR ´! !

R51! .&A$+&! +(-(),! <9G5&'! 1+(&-! 13&! -H91&-! $)! 13&! A'$$+F! +$''(),! 13&G! .92H!

9)B!A$+13F!2+5-3(),!.(1-!$A!39/8!!T3&!E3&&'-!+&%$'%&!-G$$13'/F!&%&)'/8!!T3&!1$+)!TM -3(+1! A(''-! 13&! ,9;-! 2$GA$+19.'/F! A&&'(),! $H9/! A$+! 13&! -3$+1M1&+GS! 3(-! 9)H'&-! 9+&!

VHFXUH $SSHDUDQFH DVLGH WKH VNDWHV VHHP UHOLDEOH GXUDEOH ,W¶V EHWWHU WKDQ )$13(),F!3&!13()H-F!9)B!+$''-!3(-!A&&1!9;9+1F!-&;9+91(),!13&GF!+$''-!13&G!1$,&13&+!

9,9()8!!#$BB(),!1$!3(G-&'AF!3&!-3$5'B&+-!3(-!.92H;92H!9)B!13&)!-19)B-F!19H(),!9!

2$5;'&!$A!.+&913-F!A(),&+-!.5)23&B!()1$!A(-1-8!!! !

³&DUHIXO ´ 6DPXHO KHDUV WKH )LOLSLQR VD\ ZKHQ KH EHJLQV WXUQLQJ²

;'$BB(),!-'5,,(-3'/!9E9/!A+$G!13&!1$('&1-F!'&,-!+(,(B²13&!-H91&-!2+&&;(),!3(G!$51! ()1$!13&!E9+&3$5-&!-;92&!9-!(A!3&!(-!)9%(,91(),!9!A(&'B!$A!(2&8!!0$+&!139)!9!/&9+!39-! ;9--&B! -()2&! 3&! '9-1! -H91&BF! 239-(),! 3(-! 9'E9/-! A9-1&+! 2$5-()! $)! 9! -23$$'/9+B! .9-H&1.9''!2$5+1!()!J9$3-(5),F!.51!)$E!3&!23$$-&-!1$!.&'(&%&!-'&&H!()'()&!-H91&-!

9+&!G$%(),!3(GF!)$1!9)!$'B!;9(+!$A!39)BMG&MB$E)-8!!")BF!1$$F!3&!&)%(-($)-!13&!

-;(H/M39(+&B! \91()$! .$/-! K$$G(),! ./F! 5-(),! .$13! 13&(+! 9,('(1/! 9)B! '9),59,&! 1$!

G$2H!3(G8!!Z&!922&'&+91&-!E(13!-E(A1!-1+$H&-!$A!3(-!'&,-F!+92(),!9A1&+!13&G!()!13&!

E9+&3$5-&F! -&)-(),! 3(G-&'A! A'$91(),! &AA$+1'&--'/! L5-1! 9.$%&! 13&! B5''F! +&-1+(21(),!

2$)A()&-!$A!13&!&9+138!!"!25+%(),!1+9('!,&1-!251!9G$),!13&!-2911&+&B!39/F!13&!-'(2(),!

-$5)B!$A!13&!E3&&'-!+&%&+.&+91&-8!!T3&)!$)&!./!$)&²13&!\91()$-F!3(-!2$5-()²3&! $%&+19H&-!3(-!+(%9'-F!'&9%(),!13&G!9''!1$!E9123!3&';'&--'/!9-!3&!A'(&-!A+$G!%(&E!E(13!

13&!%&'$2(1/!$A!9!G(--('&8! !

U&1!3(-!9%&),(),!A'(,31!29)!$)'/!19H&!<9G5&'!-$!A9+F!9)B!5;$)!2$G(),!1$!9)!

9.+5;1!-19)B-1(''F!1$&!-1$;-!-H(BB(),F!3&!+&9'(K&-!1391!3(-!-;&&B!(-!)$!G9123!A$+!13&!

-1&9BA9-1! 9+G/! 1391! '$(1&+-! B(+&21'/! .&A$+&! 3(G8! ! "-! -5)'(,31! .&9G-! 91! 9)! 9),'&!

A+$G! 13&! 3(,3! E()B$E-F! 29-1(),! 9! 39+-3! ,'9+&! $)! 13&! 1&++9! 2$119! A$+G91($)-F! (1!

-&&G-! 13&! E9++($+-! G(,31! 39%&! -;+$51&B! '(H&! A'$E&+-! A+$G! 13&! 2$)2+&1&! A'$$+²9!

B&)-&! ,9+B&)! $A! '$9G/! -$'B(&+-F! 9'G$-1! 1$$! B&)-&! ()! )5G.&+! 1$! B(-1(),5(-3! $)&!

A+$G! 9)$13&+8! ! <5+%&/(),! 13&! A+$)1! '()&F! 13$5,3F! 3(-! -19+&! 2$G&-! 1$! +&-1! $)! 13&!

19''&-1!$A!13&!-1915&-:!!&9-('/!-(I!A&&1!()!3&(,31F!-19)B(),!91!13&!&I921!2&)1&+!$A!13&! '()&F!BE9+A(),!13$-&!E3$!A'9)H!(18!!T3&)!E(13!-G9''!-1+(B&-!3&!.&,()-!G$%(),!3(-! '&,-F!-(B&E9/-!9)B!A$+E9+BF!9)B!(B'&-!$%&+!A$+!9!2'$-&+!'$$HF!;(%$1(),!1$!9!-1$;!()!

A+$)1!$A!13&!-1915&8! !

@3$!9+&!/$5f!!<9G5&'!E$)B&+-!E3('&!;&&+(),!5;!13&!'&),13!$A!13&!E9++($+F!

+&,9+B(),! (1! A+$G! .&'$E! 9-! -$G&$)&! E$5'B! 9! B(-19)1! G$5)19()! +9),&8! ! T3&! $+9),(-3!39)B-!9+&!A$'B&B!1$,&13&+!.&)&913!9!%&-1!$A!3&9%/!9+G$+8!!T3&!'$),!39(+!

(-! ;5''&B! 1(,31'/! .&3()B! 9! +$5)B! 3&9B8! ! T3&! 43&-3(+&! 291M'(H&! A92&! (-! 9! 9B$+)&B! E(13! 9! 25+'(25&! G5-1923&! 139W FURVVHV WKH ZLGWK RI LWV FKHHNV ³7KDW V WKH JHQHUDO ´ WKH )LOLSLQR VD\V DV LI FDSDEOH RI UHDGLQJ KLV WKRXJKWV ³7KDW¶V 0HQJ 7LDQ ´! !

T3&! G9)! 9;;&9+-! .&-(B&! <9G5&'F! '(A1(),! 9)! 9+G! ()! $+B&+! 1$! +9;! 13&! 19''!

-1915&! $)! 13&! A$+&3&9B! E(13! 3(-! H)52H'&-F! ;+$B52(),! 9! +(),(),! 1391! .+(&A'/!

HPDQDWHV IURP WKH FDYHUQRXV GHSWKV RI WKH JHQHUDO $ VPLUN OLJKWHQV 6DPXHO¶V &I;+&--($)F!9)B!E3&)!,'9)2(),!1$E9+B!13&![('(;()$!3&!-&&-!1391!13&!9G5-&G&)1!(-!

-39+&B8!!!!! !

³,¶OO VKRZ \RX RQH ODVW WKLQJ ´ WKH PDQ VD\V ³:DWFK WKLV ´ +H WDNHV D SXII

$)! 13&! A+&-3! 2(,9+&11&! ()! 3(-! +(,31! 39)BF! 13&! .5+)(),! 1(;! -5+,(),! 9-! 3&! ()39'&-8!!

T3&)!E(13$51!/&1!&I39'(),F!3&!1+9)-;$+1-!13&!2(,9+&11&!5;E9+B!1$!13&!,&)&+9'!9)B! ;+&--&-! 13&! A('1&+! &)B! 9,9()-1! 13&! &)'9+,&B! 2'9/! '(;-F! 3$'B(),! (1! 13&+&! .&1E&&)! 9!

135G.! 9)B! 9! A$+&A(),&+8! ! ^'9)2(),! B$E)! 91! <9G5&'F! 3&! &I;&'-! 9! ;+$'$),&BF! 95B(.'&!.+&913F!+&'&9-(),!)$13(),!.51!()%(-(.'&!9(+²ZKLOH DW WKH JHQHUDO¶V PRXWK 9! E3(AA! $A! -G$H&! 9;;&9+-F! -E(+'(),! 9+$5)B! 13&! 2(,9+&11&F! -&&G(),'/! B(-239+,&B! A+$G!13&!-WDWXH¶V KROORZ FKHVW ³1RZ JR VRPHZKHUH HOVH DQG KDYH IXQ ´ WKH PDQ -9/-F!L5-1!.&A$+&!'95,31&+!2352H'&-!$51!$A!3(G8! !

6DPXHO¶V H\HV ZLGHQ VPLOLQJ KH GDUWV KLV JD]H SDVW WKH JHQHUDO VFDQQLQJ

13&! 5)/(&'B(),! -$'B(&+-! E3$! -&&G! ;$(-&B! A$+! .911'&8! ! *+&1&)B(),F! 13&)F! 1391! 13&! &)1(+&!9+G/!39-!.&&)!-5GG$)&B!1$!'(A&F!1391!&923!-$'B(&+!(-!;+$.9.'/!39+.$+(),!9! .+&913! $A! -G$H&F! 3$'B(),! (1! ()! 5)1('! ^&)&+9'! T(9)! ,(%&-! 13&! $+B&+! A$+! (1! 1$! .&!

2$''&21(%&'/!&I;&''&B!1$E9+B!3(GF!3&!-5BB&)'/!-E(%&'-!$)!13&!-H91&-!9)B!G9H&-! 9!

A9-1! &-29;&8! ! 71! (-! 9! ;$E&+A5'! &I39'91($)F! 9! %(+159'! 1&G;&-1! 1391! 3&! (G9,()&-! ;+$;&'-! 3(G! A$+E9+BF! E3(-H(),! 3(G! A+$G! 13&! E9+&3$5-&F! -1+9(,31! B$E)! 13&!

A&25'&)1! ;9--9,&E9/²-2911&+(),! &%&+/13(),! ()! (1-! E9H&F! 13+$E(),! $;&)! 13&! ;9E)-3$;!B$$+F!+911'(),!-1$+&A+$)1-F!+$9+(),!'(H&!9!A&9+-$G&!.&9-1!$%&+!13&!B()!$A! 1+9AA(28! ! C$()(),! A$+2&-! E(13! 13&! 9A1&+)$$)! ,5-1-F! 13&! ()1&)-(1/! $A! 13&! A'5++/! ()2+&9-&-!1E$A$'B!9-!3&!(-!13+5-1! 92+$--!13&!-(B&E9'H-!E(13!9!B&1&+G()&B!-O5()1F! ,5(B(),! 3(G! -1&9B('/! 9'$),! 13&! E9/².(''$E(),! 9+$5)B! 13$-&! -'$E&+MG$%(),! ./-19)B&+-!E3$!$.-1+521!(1-!-1&9B/!A'$EF!+5AA'(),!13&!3&G!$A!9!.&(,&!$%&+2$91!1391!

(-! ;9--&B! ()! 9! A'9-3F! ;'9-1&+(),! B(-29+B&B! )&E-;9;&+! -&21($)-! 5;$)! T3&! +HPRUUKRLG &HQWHU¶V RPLQRXV WLQWHG ZLQGRZV YLROHQWO\ VZD\LQJ ROHDQGHU .5-3&-! 9)B! 1$E&+(),! ;9'G-F! B(-$+(&)1(),! 2+$E-! 9G(B! 9! .'()B(),! E3(+'E()B! $A! 9--9('&B! $9H! 1+&&! '&9%&-²DQG GRHVQµW VXEVLGH XQWLO KH UROOV WR D VWDJJHULQJ KDOW .&A$+&!13&!;$+23!-1&;-!$A!3(-!3$G&8! !

49+&A5''/!'$E&+(),!3(G-&'AF!,+(;;(),!13&!E+$5,31!(+$)!39)B+9('!A$+!-5;;$+1F!

<9G5&'! +&-1-! 9! G$G&)1! $)! 13&! .$11$G! -1&;F! A'5-3! A92&B! 9)B! .+&913'&--8! ! Z(-!

9)H'&-!9+&!13+$..(),F!3(-!A&&1!-$+&F!.51²3&!13()H-!E(13!9!.+$9B!-G('&!E3('&!-E&91!

B+(;-!$AA!3(-!23()²13&!;9()!(-!E$+13!(18!!<$$)F!3$E&%&+F!13&!-H91&-!9+&!+&G$%&BF! .+$5,31!()1$!13&!3$5-&!9)B!-5.-&O5&)1'/!2'&9)&B!E(13!13&!9(B!$A!9!1$$13.+5-3!9)B! 9! -;+9/! .$11'&! $A! Xg`²13&! %()/'! .$$1-! ;$'(-3&BF! 13&! E3&&'-! .5+)(-3&BF! 13&! 1$&!

-1$;-! -2+5..&B8! ! *9;&+! 1$E&'-! B9.! &%&+/! ()23! B+/8! ! @391&%&+! +&-(B59'! ,5)H! &)B5+&-²9! .'92H(-3! -G&9+! $A! 23&E(),! ,5G! $)! 13&! '&A1! -H91&F! 9! 39+B! /&''$E! -;'911&+!$A!-$G&13(),!5)H)$E)!$)!13&!+(,31!$)&²,&1-!B('(,&)1'/!-2+9;&B!9E9/!./!

9!A(),&+)9('8!!T3&)!13&!1$+)!9;9+1!TM-3(+1!(-!1$--&B!1$!13&!.&B+$$G!A'$$+F!9)B!9A1&+! +(AA'(),! 13+$5,3! 3(-! '95)B+/! ;('&F! <9G5&'! B$)-! 9-! G9)/! -$2H-! 9-! 3&! 29)! A(1! $)F! 13+&&!;9(+-!()!9''F!G9H(),!3(-!A&&1!9;;&9+!.9B'/!-E$''&)F!G9H(),!&923!-1&;!-&&G!9-!

(A!3&!(-!E9'H(),!$)!-)$E8! !

R&A$+&!'$),F!<9G5&'!-'(;-!3(-! )$E!-(K&9.'&!A&&1!()-(B&!13&!-(K&9.'&! -H91&-F!

'92(),!13&G!5;!1$!A()B!1391!13&/!39%&!.&2$G&!9!;&+A&21!A(18!!Z&!-19)B-F!1&-1(),!3$E! 13&/!A&&'²9!-(B&-1&;!1$!13&!'&A1F!1$!13&!+(,31F!.92HE9+B-F!9!2$5;'&!$A!.$5)2&-!A$+! ,$$B!G&9-5+&²A()B(),!13&G!%&+/!-)5,F!3(B&.$5)B!'(H&!.+9)B!)&E!-3$&-8!!@(13!

13&!L5)($+!()'()&!-H91&-!()!13&!;9E)-3$;!E()B$E!9'+&9B/!9!B(-19)1!G&G$+/F!3&!(-!

-5+&!1391!13&-&!9+&!13&!-H91&-!3&!E9-!1+5'/!G&9)1!1$!E&9+8!![5+13&+G$+&F!3&!H)$E-!

KH ZRQ¶W EH GHVWLQHG WR RXWJURZ WKHP LQVWHDG KLV OLPEV ZLOO JURZ WR 922$GG$B91&F!9)B!91!-$G&!A515+&!;$()1!13&!&I1+9!'9/&+-!$A!-$2H-!E(''!.&!-3&BF!3(-!

A&&1!9)B!13&!-H91&-!E(''!13&)!.&!;+$;&+'/!5)(1&B:!!13&/!E(''F!3&!(G9,()&-F!,+$E!$'B! 1$,&13&+8! !

09()19()(),! .9'9)2&! E(13! 3(-! 9+G-! $51-1+&123&BF! <9G5&'! 15+)-! 9)B!

;+$2&&B-!'(H&!9!-35AA'(),!K$G.(&8!!@3&)!'5+23(),!B$E)!13&!39''E9/F!3&!19H&-!.9./!

-1&;-!$)!13&!29+;&1F!.9./!-1&;-!13+$5,3!13&!'(%(),!+$$GF!.51!91!13&!()-19)1!1391!13&!

E3&&'-! 1$523! 13&! H(123&)! '()$'&5GF! 3&! (-! G$.('&! 9,9()²,'(B(),! 3&+&! 9)B! 13&+&F! 9+$5)B!9)B!9+$5)BF!.92H!9)B!A$+13!A+$G!13&!-1$%&!1$!13&!+&A+(,&+91$+F!2$5)1&+!1$!

2$5)1&+8!!]%&+/!+$191($)F!&%&+/!,/+91($)!9)B!;(%$1F!(-!;&+A$+G&B!E(13!9!+9;15+$5-!

-G('&F!9!.&91(A(2!&I;+&--($)!1391!&I;9)B-!()!(1-!A&+%$+!9-!3(-!-;&&B!()2+&9-&-F!13&!

E3&&'-! E3(++(),! 5)B&+A$$18! ! Z&! &%&)159''/! .9++&'-! $51! $A! 13&! H(123&)F! 13&!

G$G&)15G!B&2+&9-(),!L5-1!-'(,31'/!9-!3&!3(1-!13&!29+;&1².'9K(),!A+$G!$)&!&)B!$A! 13&!'(%(),!+$$G!1$!13&!$13&+F!.92H!B$E)!13&!39''E9/F!9)B!+92&-!;9-1!13&!13+&-3$'B! $A!3(-!.&B+$$G8!!!

!

R51! -5BB&)'/! 13&+&! (-! )$E3&+&! &'-&! A$+! <9G5&'! 1$! ,$F! )$! G$+&! -;92&! 1$!

)9%(,91&! $+! 2$+)&+-! 1$! 2(+25G%&)1F! 9)B! E3('&! .5AA&+&B! ./! 29+;&1(),! 3&! (-! -1(''!

G$%(),!1$$!A9-1²VR IDVW LQ IDFW WKDW WKH WRH VWRSV FDQ¶W EH VXFFHVVIXOO\ GHSOR\HG \(H&! 9! -$9+(),! .(+B! -3$1! A+$G! 13&! -H/F! 3&! A9'1&+-! E(13! A'9('(),! 9+G-F! ,+9K(),! 9)! &B,&!$A!3(-!.&B!1391!13&)!(G;&'-!3(G!-(B&E9/-8!!7)!9)!&AA$+1!1$!+&-25&!3(-!A$$1(),!

3&!+&-(-1-!13&!A$+E9+B!G$1($)!$A!3(-!.$B/!&%&)!9-!3(-!'&,-!2$)1()5&!93&9B!$A!3(GF! 13&!'&A1!-H91&!19),'(),!.&3()B!13&!+(,31!-H91&F!9)B!9''!91!$)2&!3&!1+(;-!-39+;'/!91!9)!

9),'&F!3(-!A$+&3&9B!-1+(H(),!13&!B&-H!9-!3&!A9''-8!!T3&!(G;921!L$'1-!13&!D$+9&G$)! ;&))/!.9)H!'(H&!9)!&9+13O59H&F!-3(A1(),!(1!-&%&+9'!()23&-!1$!.5G;!13&!19.'&!'9G;8!!

T3&!$+,9)(K&B!+$E-!$A!2$'$+&B!;&)-!9)B!;&)2('-!9+&!-&)1!9-5)B&+8!!! !

7)!13&!9A1&+G913!$A!3(-!;'5GG&1F!<9G5&'!'9/-!G$1($)'&--!A$+!9!E3('&!$)!13&!

A'$$+F!9!23&&H!-O5(-3&B!9,9()-1!13&!29+;&1F!&/&-!$;&)F!'(-1&)(),!9-!9!A&E!$A!13&!+&B! E3&&'-!,+9B59''/!-;()!13&G-&'%&-!()1$!-('&)2&8!![()9''/F!3&!+&'&9-&-!9!39'AM3&9+1&B! JURDQ PRUH DW KLV RZQ FDUHOHVVQHVV WKDQ DQ\WKLQJ HOVH %XW KH KDVQ¶W IDOOHQ 9'$)&8! ! <2911&+&B! )&9+./! 9+&! 13$-&! 13(),-! 1391! 39%&! 2$G&! 2+9-3(),! B$E)! E(13!

3(G²13&! 43()&-&M]),'(-3! B(21($)9+/F! 13&! %$29.5'9+/! A'9-3! 29+B-F! 13&! -192H! $A! IOLHUV KH KDVQµW GLVSRVHG RI²H)$2H&B! A+$G! 13&! B&-H1$;! 91! 13&! ;$()1! $A! 2$''(-($)8!!

Z&!1$523&-!3(-!A$+&3&9B!9)B!A&&'-!E3&+&!9!'9+,&!H)$1!(-!9'+&9B/!A$+G(),!.&'$E!3(-!

KDLUOLQH H[FHSW LW GRHVQ¶W KXUW PXFK \HW %HIRUH KH UHDOL]HV ZKDW KH LV GRLQJ 13$5,3F! 3&! ;+&--&-! 13&! H)$1! 9-! (A! (1! (-! 9! .511$)! 1$! .&! ;5-3&B8! ! ")! ()1&)-&! ;9()!

-3$$1-! 13+$5,3! 3(-! 3&9BF! '(H&! 9! )9('! .&(),! B+(%&)! ()1$! 3(-! -H5''F! G$G&)19+('/! .'()B(),! 3(G! E(13! (1-! 9251&)&--F! 9)BF! 2+(),(),F! 3&! O5(2H'/! +&1+921-! 3(-! A(),&+-8!!

C5-1!13&)!3&!3&9+-!9!A9()1F!;&+-(-1&)1!-2+9123(),!)$(-&!./!3(-!.&BF!9!A&%&+(-3!2'911&+! $A!1()/!2'9E-!9)B!1&&13!15,,(),!(G;91(&)1'/!91!G&19'8! !

³6WXSLG PRXVH ´ 6DPXHO JUXPEOHV ULVLQJ WR D VLWWLQJ SRVLWLRQ DQG FURVVLQJ

3(-!'&,-!-$!1391!3(-!39)B-!29)!-;()!13&!E3&&'-!$A!3(-!-H91&-8!!Z(-!,9K&!1+9%&'-!$%&+!

13&! -192H! $A! A'(&+-! $)! 13&! A'$$+F! 9)B! )$E! 9-! 3(-! A$+&3&9B! .&,()-! 13+$..(),F! 9!

2$++&-;$)B(),! -&)-&! $A! B+&9B! A(''-! 3(-! ,51:! ! 9BC"(# D# A"B;-)$%E# ;FBB-)# +"# +,-# -B&,DB+FBG# =+(EFBG=# "$# DAD);HAFBBFBG# IF"EFB# IF)+%"="# 2,%# :D*%-E ³6WXSLG PRXVH ´ KH VD\V DJDLQ ZLQFLQJ ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!"#$%&'$%'()&)*+,' -'!"##$%&'(' -'.//'#012345/12'6/789/4':0;;0<9' -'+5/'/<=>5'450?>4'?8='#<=081'<1@'@045/4'=<>>;/' -'³:H¶UH DOO JRLQJ WR GLH LQ / $ ´! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !