European Agency for Reconstruction PREPARATION OF A COMPLEMENTARY MINING PLAN FOR THE SIBOVC SOUTH WEST LIGNITE MINE CONTRACT 02/KOS01/10/021
DRAFT FINAL REPORT Complementary Mining Plan for Sibovc SW
Part I – Basic Investigations
April, 2006
prepared by: STEAG Consortium
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Key Experts of Project Team
Hans J端rgen Matern Senior Expert Mining Operation
Thomas Suhr Senior Expert Computer-Aided Mine Planning Applications
Stephan Peters Senior Expert Geology
Helmar Laube Senior Expert Soil Mechanics
Joachim Gert ten Thoren Senior Environmental Expert
Page 2 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Table of Contents 1 1.1 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.2.1 1.2.2.2 1.2.2.3 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.3 1.3.1 1.3.2 1.3.3 1.3.4 1.3.5 1.3.6 1.3.7
SUMMARY (PART I)............................................................................................ 11 Objective .................................................................................................................. 11 Tasks and Outputs of the Project.............................................................................. 12 Part I: Basic Investigations ....................................................................................... 12 Part II: Technical Planning....................................................................................... 12 Mine Development ................................................................................................... 13 Dewatering ............................................................................................................... 13 Manpower................................................................................................................. 14 Environmental Impact Study.................................................................................... 14 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis............................................................... 15 Results under Part I - Basic Investigations............................................................... 16 Coal Demand............................................................................................................ 16 Geology .................................................................................................................... 17 Soil-mechanics ......................................................................................................... 18 Main Mining Equipment .......................................................................................... 20 Power Supply System and Electrical Equipment ..................................................... 21 Infrastructure ............................................................................................................ 21 Auxiliary Equipment ................................................................................................ 21
2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 22 Background .............................................................................................................. 22 Approach / Methodology.......................................................................................... 22 Geographical Overview............................................................................................ 24 Climatic Data............................................................................................................ 25
3
COAL DEMAND ................................................................................................... 27
4 4.1 4.2 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.2.3 4.3 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.2.1 4.3.2.2 4.3.2.3 4.4 4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.2.1 4.4.2.2 4.4.2.3 4.5 4.5.1 4.5.2
GEOLOGY ............................................................................................................. 29 Introduction Geology................................................................................................ 29 Assessment of Available Geological Data ............................................................... 31 Borehole Database.................................................................................................... 31 Assessment Methodology......................................................................................... 31 Stratigraphic and Lithological Borehole Data .......................................................... 32 Digital Geological Model......................................................................................... 32 General Remarks to the Geological Model .............................................................. 32 Results / Description of the Geological Model ........................................................ 33 Surface...................................................................................................................... 36 Overburden (Including Outer Dumps) ..................................................................... 36 Coal (Including Coal Quality) .................................................................................. 37 Further Aspects Influencing the Sibovc SW Mine................................................... 52 Underground Mining................................................................................................ 52 Uncontrolled Coal Fires ........................................................................................... 53 Locations of Coal Fires ............................................................................................ 53 Counteractive Measures ........................................................................................... 56 Prevention of Coal Fires........................................................................................... 56 Further Geological Exploration Required ................................................................ 56 Methods of Further Geological Exploration ............................................................ 57 Location for Urgently Required Drillholes (2006)................................................... 57 Page 3 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5 5.1 5.1.1 5.1.2 5.1.3 5.1.4 5.1.5 5.1.6 5.2 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.3 5.2.4 5.2.5 5.2.6 5.2.6.1 5.2.6.2 5.2.6.3 5.2.7 5.2.8
SOIL-MECHANICAL PARAMETERS.............................................................. 61 General ..................................................................................................................... 61 Geology .................................................................................................................... 61 Hydrology................................................................................................................. 61 Technology............................................................................................................... 62 Soil-mechanical Parameter....................................................................................... 62 Soil-mechanical Calculation Methods ..................................................................... 64 Necessary Safety Coefficients .................................................................................. 65 Soil-mechanical Investigations – Mine Sibovc SW ................................................. 66 General ..................................................................................................................... 66 Geology .................................................................................................................... 66 Hydrology................................................................................................................. 66 Soil-mechanical Parameters ..................................................................................... 67 Necessary Safety Coefficients .................................................................................. 67 Investigations of Static Stability............................................................................... 68 Single Slopes ............................................................................................................ 68 Slope Systems........................................................................................................... 68 Dump Slopes ............................................................................................................ 71 Conclusion................................................................................................................ 72 Measures for a Safe Opencast Mine Management ................................................... 73
6 6.1 6.1.1 6.1.1.1 6.1.1.2 6.1.2 6.1.3 6.1.4 6.1.5 6.1.5.1 6.1.5.2 6.2 6.2.1 6.2.2 6.2.3 6.2.4 6.2.5 6.3 6.4 6.5
MAIN MINING EQUIPMENT ............................................................................ 75 Technical Status of Existing Equipment .................................................................. 75 Technical Status of Excavators ................................................................................ 75 SRs 1300 and SchRs 650 ......................................................................................... 75 SRs 470, SRs 400 and SRs 315................................................................................ 77 Technical Status of Spreaders .................................................................................. 78 Technical Status of Belt Conveyors and Drive Stations .......................................... 80 Technical Status of Belt Wagons ............................................................................. 81 Technical Status of Stacker / Reclaimer................................................................... 83 Stockpile Separation Plant A.................................................................................... 83 Stockpile TPP B ....................................................................................................... 84 Planned Short-term Rehabilitation Measures........................................................... 85 Measures for Excavators .......................................................................................... 85 Measures for Spreader.............................................................................................. 87 Measures for Belt Conveyors and Drive Stations .................................................... 88 Measures for Belt Wagons ....................................................................................... 89 Measures for Stacker / Reclaimer ............................................................................ 89 Planned Refurbishment Measures for Sibovc SW Field .......................................... 91 Time Schedule for Rehabilitation Measures ............................................................ 93 Investment and Cost Calculation of Main Mine Equipment.................................... 96
7 7.1 7.2 7.3
POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM AND ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT ................ 102 Future Energy Demand........................................................................................... 102 Measures and Time Schedule................................................................................. 105 Investments for Power Supply System................................................................... 113
8 8.1 8.2 8.2.1
AUXILIARY EQUIPMENT ............................................................................... 114 Assessment of Technical Status in Existing Mine ................................................. 114 Demand of Auxiliary Equipment ........................................................................... 114 Maximal Demand of Auxiliary Equipment............................................................ 114
Page 4 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
8.2.2 8.3 8.3.1 8.3.2 8.3.3 8.4
Yearwise Development of Auxiliary Equipment Fleet .......................................... 116 Heavy Auxiliary Equipment for Sibovc SW Mine................................................. 121 Draglines ................................................................................................................ 121 Transport Crawler................................................................................................... 122 Derricks .................................................................................................................. 122 Investment and Cost Calculation............................................................................ 123
9 9.1 9.2 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.3 9.3.1 9.3.2 9.3.2.1 9.3.2.2 9.3.3 9.4 9.4.1 9.4.2 9.4.3 9.4.4 9.5 9.6
INFRASTRUCTURE AND SURFACE FACILITIES ..................................... 125 General Remarks and Principles ............................................................................ 125 Social Facilities and Administration ...................................................................... 126 Mine Offices........................................................................................................... 126 Mine Control Centre............................................................................................... 129 Washrooms and Sanitary Facilities ........................................................................ 130 Supply and Disposal............................................................................................... 131 Erection Yards........................................................................................................ 131 Road Construction.................................................................................................. 132 Plant roads .............................................................................................................. 132 Access Roads.......................................................................................................... 134 Fire Department...................................................................................................... 134 Workshops and Warehouses .................................................................................. 135 Principles................................................................................................................ 135 Workshops.............................................................................................................. 138 Warehouses ............................................................................................................ 143 Petrol Station .......................................................................................................... 147 Time Scheduling for Infrastructure Measures ........................................................ 149 Investment and Cost Calculation for Infrastructure ............................................... 149
Page 5 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Figures Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.:
1.3-1 1.3-2 1.3-3 2.3-1 2.4-1 4.1-1 4.1-2 4.3-1 4.3-2 4.3-3 4.3-4 4.3-5 4.3-6 4.3-7 4.3-8 4.4-1 4.4-2 4.4-3 4.5-1 4.5-2 4.5-3 4.5-4 4.5-5 5.1-1 5.1-2 5.1-3 5.2-1 5.2-2 5.2-3 5.2-4 5.2-5 5.2-6 5.2-7 6.4-1 6.4-2 7.2-1 7.2-2 7.2-3
Lignite Demand Prognosis till 2024 17 Failure Scenarios to be examined 18 Iterative Process for Developing a Geotechnical Safe Opencast Mine 20 Location of existing Mine 24 Average and extreme monthly Temperatures 26 Map of the future Sibovc SW Mining Area 29 Stratigraphic Standard Profile of the Kosovo Basin (KEK 2003) 30 Topographical Map (including dumps) of the Sibovc SW Mining Area 36 Sibovc SW, Overburden Thickness 37 Sibovc SW, Depth Structure Map at Top of Seam 38 Sibovc SW, Depth Structure Map at Base of Seam 39 Sibovc SW, Seam Thickness 40 Cross Section A WSW – ENE 41 Cross Section B NNW – SSE 41 Coal Quality in Horizontal Sections 51 Smoke Marks at Samples of Exploration Drilling 2004 54 Example of Coal Fire in Old Mining Structures 55 Example of Coal Fire in Old Mining Structures 55 Planned 2-D Seismic Investigations 57 Location of the Planned Drillhole SW-1 59 Location of Planned Drillholes SW-2 und SW-5 59 Location of Planned Drillholes SW-3 und SW-9 60 Location of Planned Drillholes SW-4, SW-6, SW-7 and SW-8 60 Sliding Surface with Reduced Shearing Strength 63 Dump with Formation of Shearing Areas 63 Failure Scenarios to be Examined 64 Layout Plan Sibovc-SW Including the Cross Section Lines 68 Cross Section EAST 1 69 Calculation Model with Variable Dipping of the Sliding Surface 70 Static Stability Coefficient in Dependence from Dipping of Sliding Surface 70 General Inclinations for Coal and Overburden Cuts 71 Dump Slide and Resulting Slope Angle 72 Iterative Process for Developing a Geotechnical Safe Opencast Mine 74 Schematic BWE-Rehabilitation Milestone Plan 94 Linewise Refurbishment Activities for Main Equipment 95 Time Schedule for Power Supply and Control System 109 110/35 kV Power Substation “Sibovc” with 6 kV Distribution System 110 6 kV Power Supply – Coal Extraction 111
Page 6 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.:
7.2-4 8.3-1 9.2-1 9.2-2 9.2-3 9.2-4 9.2-5 9.2-6 9.2-7 9.3-1 9.3-2 9.4-1 9.4-2 9.4-3 9.4-4 9.4-5 9.4-6 9.4-7 9.4-8 9.4-9 9.4-10 9.4-11 9.4-12 9.4-13 9.4-14 9.4-15 9.4-16 9.5-1
6 kV Power Supply – Overburden Removal Scheme Esch 10/70 Layout Drawing of New Mine Office Mine Office Mirash Mine Office Gate 01 Mine Office Bardh Current Mine Control Centre of Mirash Mine Mine Control Centre of Bardh Mine Washroom and Sanitary Facility for 650 Workers Mine Road in Mirash in Spring 2006 Building of the Fire Department Survey Workshops and Warehouses New Central Auxiliary Equipment Workshop Bardh Mechanical Workshop Intervention Electrical Workshop Intervention Bardh Electrical Workshop Kosovomont Layout Plan for Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 1 Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 1 Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 2 Electrical and Mechanical Workshop New Warehouse Mirash Warehouse Idler and Vulcanisation New Central Warehouse Electrical Warehouse Bardh Mechanical Warehouse Bardh Petrol Station Mirash Petrol Station Mirash Time Schedule for Infrastructure Measures
112 122 127 127 128 128 129 129 131 133 135 138 139 139 140 141 141 142 142 143 144 144 145 146 147 147 148 149
Page 7 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Tables Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.:
2.4-1 2.4-1 4.4-1 4.5-1 5.1-1 5.1-2 5.2-1 5.2-2 5.2-3 6.2-1 6.3-1 6.5-1 6.5-2 6.5-3 6.5-4 6.5-5 6.5-6 6.5-7 6.5-8 6.5-9 6.5-10 7.1-1 7.1-2 7.3-1 8.2-1 8.2-2 8.2-3 8.2-4 8.3-1 8.4-1 8.4-2 9.2-1 9.3-1 9.4-1 9.6-1
Intensity of Heavy Rainfall Coal Demand Coal Production of Old Underground Mines within the Area Investigated Parameter to be Recorded Calculation Methods for the Respective Form of Failure Proposal for Necessary Safety Coefficients Soil Mechanical Parameter Slope Angles for Single Overburden Slopes Results of Static Stability Calculations for the Cross Section EAST_1 Measures for Excavators Measures for Main Excavators for Sibovc SW Survey of Mine Equipment Amount for Refurbishment and Investment Yearwise Cost for Refurbishment and Investments in MEURO Costs for E8B, E9B and E10B Costs for E8M Costs for E9M and E10M Costs for Belt Wagons Costs for Spreader Costs for Stacker / Reclaimer TPP A Costs for Stacker / Reclaimer TPP B Planned Requirements of Technological Systems Required Installed Capacity Investments for Power Supply Number of Auxiliary Equipment Number of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2012 Annual Purchase of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2016 Annual Purchase of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2025 Technical Data of Esch 10/70 Investments and Reinvestments for Auxiliary Equipment Yearwise Investments for Auxiliary Equipment in MEURO Capacity of Change Rooms and Sanitary Facilities Road Construction Further Use of Buildings for Mine Sibovc SW Investment Calculation for Infrastructural Measures
25 27 52 58 65 66 67 68 69 86 91 96 97 97 98 98 99 99 100 100 101 102 104 113 115 117 119 120 121 123 123 130 132 138 150
Page 8 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Annexes I/4–1
Depth Structure Map: Top Lignite Seam
1 : 10 000
I/4–2
Depth Structure Map: Base Lignite Seam
1 : 10 000
I/4–3
Overburden Thickness
1 : 10 000
I/4–4
Overburden-to-Coal Ratio
1 : 10 000
I/4–5
Seam Thickness
1 : 10 000
I/4–6
Overburden-to-Coal Ratio and Seam Thickness
1 : 10 000
I/4–7
Top Lignite Seam: Structural Dip
1 : 10 000
I/4–8
Geological Cross Section S1 & S2
1 : 10 000 1 : 2 500
I/4–9
Lignite Fm.- Total Sulphur
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 10
Lignite Fm.- Low Calorific Value
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 11
Lignite Fm.- Ash Content
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 12
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-01
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 13
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-02
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 14
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-03
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 15
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-04
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 16
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-05
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 17
Sibovc SW Cross Section WE-06
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 18
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-01
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 19
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-02
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 20
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-03
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 21
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-04
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 22
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-05
1 : 10 000
I / 4 – 23
Sibovc SW Cross Section NS-06
1 : 10 000
Page 9 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Abbreviations a
year
bcm/h
bank cubic meter per hour
BWE
bucket wheel excavator
GCV
gross calorific value
GWh
gigawatt-hours
kf
hydraulic conductivity
km
kilometre
km²
square kilometres
kt
thousand tonnes
kV
kilovolt
kW
kilowatt
l/min
liter per minute
m
meter
m²
square meter
m³
cubic meter
mbcm
million bank cubic meters
mcm
million cubic meters
mlcm
million loose cubic meters
mm
millimeter
mMSL
meter above main sea level
mt
million tonnes
m/min
meters per minute
m³/min
cubic meter per minute
m/s
meters per second
NCV
net calorific value
OCM
open cast mine
TPP
thermal power plant
`000 bcm
thousand bank cubic meters
`000 lcm
thousand loose cubic meters
Page 10 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1 Summary (Part I) 1.1 Objective The Complementary Mining Plan for New Sibovc South West Mine consists of the following reports: -
Part I
Basic Investigations
-
Part II
Technical Planning
-
Part III
Environmental Impact Study
-
Part IV
Economic and Financial Analysis
The existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash, west of Pristina, will be exhausted by 2011. Thus the overall objective of the project is providing a plan for the supply of the necessary fuel to the existing power plants in Kosovo until the end of their lifetime. The specific objectives of this contract are the elaboration of a detailed mine plan on the development of the new mine in the Sibovc South West Lignite Field. The objective of the plan is: -
to define the technical measures and the timeframe to be followed to open-up the new mine and develop it up to the scheduled capacity of about 9 million tons per annum;
-
to guide the focus on the necessary investments and operating costs;
-
to include the necessary measures and information for licensing applications.
Other than the Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine (max. 24 m t coal out per year) the Complementary Mining Plan for the Sibovc South West Lignite Field focuses on the fuel supply to the existing TPP assuming a coal demand of 9 mt/a and a limited availability of financial resources. The plan covers the period from 2007 to 2024 when all existing power capacities assumed to reach the end of their service life. Subsequently the total accumulated coal demand from the Sibovc South West Lignite Field comes to 123 million tonnes, what is approximately 15% of the entire mineable lignite reserves in the Sibovc Lignite Field. The remaining lignite reserves of the entire Sibovc Lignite Field could be a source to feed new power plant capacities expected to be built in Kosovo. The Complementary Mining Plan has been coordinated with the existing “Mid term Mining Plan for the existing mines�. The Mid Term Plan provides the stepwise implementation of regular operation conditions, the achievement of geotechnical and public safety and therefore the transfer of mines to an economic efficient operation. The purpose of the Complementary Mine Plan is to show the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures to open up the new mine in time to replace the running out production capacity of the existing mines. The plan is showing the required investment and effective cost of lignite supply.
Page 11 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The investment requirements to open-up the Sibovc South-West mine are 236 MEURO until 2012, when full supply capacity will be reached. The real average cost of lignite supply amount to 7.50-8.00 EURO/ton of raw coal, depending on the cost of capital investment. Special attention has been focused on the required resettlement and land acquisition. The plan also ensures that the mine operations are in full compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations and laws.
1.2 Tasks and Outputs of the Project 1.2.1 Part I: Basic Investigations The basis for the new mining plan for the Sibovc South West mine is the previous study ‘Main Mining Plan for Sibovc mine’. Using this as the basis, the consultants checked, evaluated, updated and presented all necessary facts (geo-technical, geological, hydrogeological and hydrological data, infrastructure, existing end necessary new equipment) for the Sibovc South West mine. According to ToR this plan was based on a demand forecast prepared by the Ministry of Energy and Mines in accordance with the Kosovo Energy Strategy. The consultant updated the existing computerised geological model based on additional exploration drillings conducted by KEK and prepared a plan for further exploration to be realised by KEK, defined the slope design based on soil-mechanic calculation. To ensure the planned performance of the equipment and subsequently output of the mine it will be necessary to undertake a complex refurbishment of lignite and overburden equipment incl. excavators, conveyor lines and spreaders. This approach represents a new quality against the partly repair of machines realised so far. A refurbishment/replacement programme for the existing main mining equipment as well as auxiliary equipment has been prepared including a realistic assessment of the timing of the required investments. As an important output of the project the plan provides the basis for the application for, and issuing of exploitation licence for the new mine. The outputs are the findings of this analysis, including the updated geological model, plan for further exploitation; definition of slope design; and updated investment plan in main and auxiliary equipment.
1.2.2 Part II: Technical Planning The consultants prepared detailed mine development plans/annexes, including all necessary calculations, for the first five years of operation and mine phase documentation for the end of each year, continuing with next five years periods (end of periods) up to 2024. The outputs of this task are the detailed mine development plans as set out above.
Page 12 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
There have been prepared an updated expropriation plan which provides both a timed and cost plan for the required measures for land acquisition and resettlement into mine planning. A short description of the main output of part II follows:
1.2.2.1 Mine Development The following main topics for the mine development have been considered: -
Opening-up of the Sibovc SW OCM shall be made from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The existing inside dump of P3B shall be taken into account.
-
A coal pillar shall remain between the existing Bardh mine and the new Sibovc mine field in order to stabilize the masses of the inside dump of the Bardh opencast mine.
-
The overburden masses will preferably be dumped in the mined-out area of the existing OCM in order to stabilize the slope south of Hade and to establish final dump surfaces as soon as possible.
-
The mined-out bottom in Sibovc SW shall be covered by dumps and as far as possible also the final coal rim slope systems in order to prevent coal fires.
-
During the opening-up phase the overburden will be transported via the western rim slope system. After disassembling the equipment in the existing opencast mines there will be established a belt connection via the eastern rim slope system. This helps to reduce the transport distance and the quickest possible establishment of a stabilising body south of Hade.
-
The residual pit of Mirash-Brand remains as reserved area for the disposal of municipal waste.
-
It is envisaged to flush the power plant residues from TPP B in the residual pit of Mirash-East.
Due to late start of the mine development a rather high capacity will be required right at the beginning of works. The performance required can be performed only with rehabilitated equipment. After rehabilitation the capacity for overburden (BWE) complexes shall be 3.6-5.4 million cubic meters per annum each. The first two BWE - Systems will have to be commissioned in 2008. Some overburden removal works will be required using truck & shovel operation. This service should be contracted with third parties. It must be noticed, that the development of the new Sibovc SW mine is directly linked to the advance of the existing mine and therefore to the realisation of the Mid Term Plan.
1.2.2.2 Dewatering Drainage of surface water via the active bench of the Sibovc SW mine shall be excluded except residual rainwater quantities. It is suggested to install a dewatering system in the valley from which the collected surface water is pumped into the higher located channel(s) by means
Page 13 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
of sewage pumps. According to the OCM advance the dewatering shall be shifted several times to the North. Drainage ditches shall be installed on all working levels and along the access roads.
1.2.2.3 Manpower The following table gives a survey on the staffing requirements: Year Existing mines per 01.01. - Fluctuation / Redundancy Staff transfer Sibovc SW per 31.12.
2007 3500
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
490
3000 415
2100 300
1300 100
900 470
350 260
10
485
500
300
80
40
1380
1420
15
500
1000
1300
Staff for the new mine will be employed mainly from redundant staff of the existing mines.
1.2.3 Environmental Impact Study The mining activities will have a large effect on the environment. The Environmental Study serves as a baseline description for the expected effects. Alternative locations are discussed for coal extraction prior to the implementation of the Complementary Mining Plan resulting in the location of “D-field”, east of the river Sitnica, to be an equally favourable alternative to supply the existing power plants from the environmental point of view. Among the other alternatives a development of the “Sibovc field” from the south to the north ranked second best. Subject of the Complementary Mining Plan is the excavation of overburden and lignite, developing from the existing opencast mines to the north. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. The anticipated environmental effects concern, first of all, the removal of soil resulting in a loss of surface area and living space. With this extension an enlarged void will be visible, compared to the existing mines. As the backfill of already exploited areas goes on parallel in time, it will be possible to return recovered areas to agricultural use in a landscape with changed appearance. Surface waters to be affected are mainly small and of non perennial flow. The rivers Sitnica and Drenica will not be directly affected, as clayey sediments with sufficient thickness protect them from the mine. Indirect effects can result from the outlet of mine drainage water with enlarged contents of Chloride and Sulphate as well as suspended solids. Because of the characteristics of the overburden the impact on groundwater will be minor. Significant groundwater utilization is not known in the area. Influences on neighbouring utilizations can be excluded. Dust emissions as well as noise emissions will shift from the current to the future working points with an equal or, based on used technologies, even minor extend of emissions. The Environmental Study attempts to follow in general the applicable EU directives on environmental impact assessment, mainly Directive 85/337/EEC. However, there is a general lack of baseline studies, local experts’ opinions, pertinent documents or other information,
Page 14 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
e.g. allowing any specific assessment on influences on fauna and flora. Regarding this aspect additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. In case of proper operation and a coal demand adequate to the mining technology the mine will stay one of the most important employers of the region with up to 1,500 employees. Upon completion of backfilling areas farmable land can be returned to the inhabitants, which mitigates the effects of required resettlements. Resettlement will be needed as a consequence of the development of the mine. Approximately 870 persons representing some 109 households will have to be moved in the years 2007 to 2024. Resettlement refers to single houses and small settlements and it will not be needed to resettle significant villages. With the objective to improve knowledge on the environment and to allow control on the environmental impact, adequate monitoring activities shall be set up concerning air and water quality measurements as well as the purification of drainage water and the utilization of humus enriched top soil layers.
1.2.4 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis The consultants prepared an economic and financial analysis with a detailed cash flow forecast, a financial analysis of the cost benefit of the proposed investment with IRR/ NPV calculations, and a time planning for the investment programme. The output of this task is a detailed, based on annual calculations economic and financial analysis and appraisal of the Sibovc South West mine plan. The calculations have been made in accordance with IFRS. The main results of the profitability calculation are as follows: The calculated real average cost (RAC) comes to 7.5-8.0 EURO/t. The economic analysis also considered that in 2024 a fully functioning opencast mine will be available. This allowed calculation with coal prices of 7.00 EURO/t to 7.50 EURO/t. Totally four variants were assumed containing different coal prices, different escalation and different interest rate on borrowings. All variants until 2011 require about 80 MEURO equity capital and ca. 200 MEURO outside capital. Assuming a coal price of 7.00 EURO/ton the dividend earned until 2024 will amount to at least 137 MEURO which can be distributed to the shareholders. The sum of the annual payments for the production of coal is smaller than 5.0 EURO per tonne coal. This applies from 2012, the first year of full production. It will be possible to produce coal with favourable terms and profits of 20 % on the employed equity capital can be earned. The cash flow analysis demonstrates that the chosen mine development will be generally profitable even with the short operation time period of only 15 years.
Page 15 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1.3 Results under Part I - Basic Investigations 1.3.1 Coal Demand The current coal consumption level of the power plants amounts to 6-7 mt/a. This level is not sufficient to secure the demand for electricity to be produced by the existing power plants in Kosovo. In the coming years an increase is expected up to about 9 mt beginning in 2010. This is under the assumption that in the Kosovo A power plant will be refurbished at least two units as foreseen in the Kosovo A refurbishment feasibility study and incorporated in the KEK Financial Recovery Plan. To meet the Kosovo electricity demand it is foreseen to operate two units in Kosovo A and two units in Kosovo B on a regular basis. The following principles / assumptions have been made: -
Generating electricity from Sibovc SW pursues the goal to meet domestic needs mainly.
-
After depletion of the existing mines the new Sibovc SW mine supplies the existing power plants Kosovo A and B. The coal supply from the new mine has to start in 2010.
-
The life time for Kosovo B is about 40 years, which means end of operation in 2023/24.
-
Hence the life time of Sibovc SW will be defined from 2008 to 2024, which means 17 years. Preparatory work will be required in 2007.
-
Three of five units of Kosovo A (200/210 MW) started production between 1970 and 1975. These units do not fulfil normal technical standards. Opinions to refurbish these units (capital refurbishment or major overhaul) differ a lot. However it is assumed that the coal supply to Kosovo A will last for the time being (amounting to 2.5 – 4.7 mt). In case Kosovo A will be out of operation before 2020/24 the new mine will deliver the coal to the TTP replacing Kosovo A. At least the fuel supply is calculated with 9 mt in total for Sibovc SW.
-
It is assumed that the investment needed for opening-up the new mine will be made available timely.
Page 16 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Sibovc SW 10
Existing Mines
Lignite Demand [mt/a]
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
20 06 20 07 20 08 20 09 20 10 20 11 20 12 20 13 20 14 20 15 20 16 20 17 20 18 20 19 20 20 20 21 20 22 20 23 20 24
0
Fig.: 1.3-1
Lignite Demand Prognosis till 2024
1.3.2 Geology The geological evaluation and interpretation was conducted for an area of some 10 km². It encompasses the southern part of the Sibovc Field. The basement of the Kosovo Basin and the exposed surrounding areas are built up by Palaeozoic to Mesozoic crystalline rocks. The basin fill consists of Upper Cretaceous strata which are unconformably overlain by Tertiary clays of Pliocene age in which lignite is interbedded. Simplified the coal bearing sediments can be subdivided from the base to the top as follows: Green clay, Lignite Formation, Grey and yellow clay. Towards the West the lignite deposition is tectonically bound by a series of predominantly NNW-SSE striking faults. The eastern limit is characterized by sedimentological pinch-out. A geological survey has to be ensured during the current mining activities. Therefore continuous drilling operations in the front of the excavation line have to be accomplished, whereby all cores must be described (cm-scale), photographed and sampled. The parameters which have to be examined are coal quality, geotechnical characteristics. Furthermore the borehole has to be observed recording groundwater level and any signs of coal fires. The Western border of the Sibovc SW mine requires special attention due to the complicated fault structure. The Sibovc SW area has an average elevation above sea level of 609 m, reaching from 497m to 666m. The slope of these hills show angles from 10 to 4 degrees generally declined from south-eastern to south-western direction. The coal seam thickness is in average 59.5 m (maximum 93.1 m). The heating value ranges from 5,850 to 10,300 kJ/kg, whereas the geological average amounts to 8,830 kJ/kg (calculated to 45% water content). Considering a possible content of interburden and a partly higher water content the calorific value on the stockpile is estimated at 7,500 kJ/kg. Page 17 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The overburden thickness varies from 50 to 125m with lowest values nearby the northern border of the existing mines. Generally there is no reliable information about the exact extension and locations of the old underground mining. Actual structures of the old underground mining are situated mostly in the south-eastern part of the Sibovc field. Some of the old galleries have been already cut in the Mirash mine and the pillar area. Higher risk areas for coal fires will be the long excavation front at the Northern Bardh Mirash slope and areas affected by illegal (private) coal excavation. Actually the northern slope is not affected by coal fires as predicted. There are no larger zones showing burnt coal with resulting large cavities, only some core samples of the new exploration drillings showed some smoke marks indicating limited coal fires. The procedures for coal fire extinguishing and thus saving coal resources have to be adapted to the exploitation operations and to be done by the mines staff during the running mining activities. Adequate extinguishing technologies have to be selected under consideration of the local geotechnical conditions. The extended use of water in most cases may cause landslides. Further geological exploration has to be done considering the special geological and topographical conditions.
1.3.3 Soil-mechanics The soil-mechanical investigations are of estimating character because of the lack of information regarding geology, hydrology and the low state of knowledge about the soilphysical parameter of the geological layers. If further information from a regional and operational geological exploration will be available the soil-mechanical considerations shall be revised and intensified. Further exploration stages are urgently required for a geotechnically safe operational management. This especially applies to the sporadically occurring interburden in the massive coal seam and the voids in the advancing opencast mine operation resulting form old mining activities and/or possible uncontrolled coal fires. Depending on the known marginal conditions (geology, hydrology, soil-physical parameter, technology) to be integrated in the soil-mechanical model, failure scenarios have been developed. VG: Released sliding surface
yellow clay KZP
KZP: circular sliding surface
gray clay
VG coal seam operating floor
VG KZP
Fig.: 1.3-2
green clay
Failure Scenarios to be examined
Page 18 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
To guarantee both a safe and economic opencast mine operation the following safety coefficients have been considered:
Single Slope Advancing slope systems Head slope systems Objects to be protected
Si ≥ 1.05 ≥ 1.20 ≥ 1.20 ≥ 1.30
According to the present state of knowledge the following general inclinations shall be kept for the bank slope systems to be planned: For advancing slope systems the general inclinations shall not exceed 22° for coal and 10° for overburden slope system. Slope angles 6 to 8° are recommended for head slopes due to longer lifetimes. Temporary greening is recommended to counteract erosions in the area of the head slopes. If necessary, use of geo-textiles has to be checked. For the dump slope systems, slopes angles 6 to 8° resulting from the residual shearing strength shall be taken into consideration when planning the dump geometry. The clay material contained in the overburden tends to strong plastic behaviour under addition of water and resulting from this to a reduced stability. For this reason dewatering measures have to be carried out on a regular basis. A summary of measures required for a safe geotechnical OCM management have been given: -
A continuously updated geological model approved by the responsible geologist must be available for the OCM;
-
The hydrological situation shall be documented and continuously updated
-
The OCM position shall be identified in a layout plan in regular periods.
-
At least three representative geological profiles right angled to the benches shall be conducted where the achieved mining positions shall be registered in regular periods.
-
Position and course of the head slopes shall be planned forward-looking with at least one advancing cross section of the respective head slope.
-
The lines of all cross sections shall be illustrated in the layout plan.
-
Statistically verified soil-physical parameters are required for the decisive geological layers in the roof and bottom.
-
The soil samples shall be analysed in by a recognized soil-physical laboratory.
-
Soil-mechanical investigations of static stability for all slopes and slope systems shall be principally carried out by qualified experts.
-
The basics and results of the soil-mechanical investigations shall be documented. Any changes of the marginal conditions due to geology, hydrology, technology or in case of changed soil-physical parameters these investigations shall be revised.
-
In cooperation with the mine management targets resulting from the static stability calculations shall be used and definitely controlled during the running operation.
Page 19 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
A geotechnical expert shall visit the opencast mines in regular periods. The visits shall be documented in minutes.
-
A control and monitoring schedule shall be worked out for the opencast mines.
The development of a geotechnically safe OCM technology shall be regarded at iterative process:
Fig.: 1.3-3
Iterative Process for Developing a Geotechnical Safe Opencast Mine
1.3.4 Main Mining Equipment A detailed survey of the technical status of the main mine equipment and planned short-term rehabilitation measures have been given. Based on the survey and measures already completed or to be finalised in the next few years the consultant prepared a plan of refurbishment measures of heavy equipment to be utilised in the Sibovc SW field. All excavators of the type BWE SchRs 650 and BWE SRs 1300 and three spreaders A2RsB5200 and A2RsB-4400 will be relocated to the Sibovc SW mine. Further on the refurbishment shall include the related belt wagons as well belt conveyors. The bucket wheel excavators SRs 470, SRs 400 and SRs 315 are hardly applicable as main mine equipment for a long-term operation. The excavators E5M, E7M and E1B may be used in sub benches regarding as floating machine. Because of the output capacities of the heavy opencast mine machines, only conveyor lines with 1,600 or 1,800 mm belt width will be used in the new mine. A schematic rehabilitation milestone plan for an excavator of the size SRs 1300 have been developed. A period of ca. 35 months will be required for one equipment line. The downtime of the equipment for the implementation of the measures is ca. 9 months.
Page 20 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Only a limited period of time will be available for the required refurbishment measures. Otherwise more costly compensations will result due to a delayed commissioning of the main equipment in the Sibovc field – provided that the planned coal output is ensured. Based on the technical requirements for equipment rehabilitation a detailed investment schedule is included.
1.3.5 Power Supply System and Electrical Equipment A detailed survey of the power supply requirements, measures to be undertaken and investment requirements have been given.
1.3.6 Infrastructure In principle it is not planned to install new surface facilities for various reasons; among others the available technical plants in Bardh/ Mirash, which are presently part of ongoing rehabilitation measures, the neighbourhood to Sibovc and the extensive investments, anyhow. The infrastructure investment for the new Sibovc South West mine includes: -
refurbishment of existing facilities of the Bardh mine and constructing of new administrative buildings as well as new changing and washing rooms;
-
refurbishment of the Kosovamont workshops and warehouses;
-
construction of mine roads and a new public road in the north of the mine field.
The total investment is assessed to 21.2 MEURO.
1.3.7 Auxiliary Equipment The investments/reinvestments for auxiliary equipment amount to 60 MEURO until 2024. About 24 MEURO are for initial investments, a sum of 34 MEURO for replacement investments and about 2 MEURO for rehabilitation measures of heavy auxiliary equipment.
Page 21 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2 Introduction 2.1 Background Kosovo has lignite reserves assessed at some 10 billion tons, concentrated in the Kosovo Coal Basin. This coal deposit, especially the Sibovc deposit is regarded as one of the best throughout Europe. The geological context of Sibovc is characterised by an average stripping ratio 1.0 to 1.2 m³ of overburden per 1 ton of lignite. The new mine Sibovc South West is a part of this favourable lignite deposit. The first coal supply is expected in 2010. Up to this time the existing mine (former Bardh and Mirash mine) supplies TPP Kosovo A and Kosovo B. Around 97% of the total generation capacity comes from these two coal-fired power plants, while hydropower accounts for only 3%. KEK has established a Coal Production Division (CPD) being responsible for coal production, transportation, separation and stocking activities before the coal is eventually delivered to the power plants. The existing mine has been in operation since 1963/64. This mine is located in the same field in the central northern part of Kosovo Lignite Basin. The overburden and coal excavation is carried out by continuous systems: Bucket Wheel Excavator – Belt Conveyors – Spreader and Bucket Wheel Excavator – Belt Conveyors – Separation Plants – TPP. At the present time the mine is actually capable of supplying the power plants within around 6 to 7 mt/a of coal. In 2009 the lignite production in the existing mine begins to drop (at the projected rate of consumption) and in the following year coal supply from the new mine should start. The reason to head in northern direction with a new mine is because expansion of the existing mine into the east is impeded by surface water issues. An expansion to the south is impeded by an unfavourable overburden to coal ratio and large outside dumps from earlier mine developments. Along the northeast side of the mine is the village Hade, which poses an equally significant challenge to settle a significant resettlement. In order to maintain the supply of coal to Kosovo A and Kosovo B power stations, KEK should develop the new mine in a way of by-passing Hade. This is the subject of the mining plan Sibovc SW.
2.2 Approach / Methodology According to the existing situation and pursuant to the TOR the project work has been mainly focused on the following activities: 1)
Assumption of the future coal demand
2)
Revision of geological model including - Analysis of available borehole and other exploration data - Localization of cracks and geological faults, - Calculation of minable reserves
3)
Calculation of mining development and equipment application including
Page 22 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
- Mining development in opening-up phase (5 years) in annual steps, - Further mining development up to 2025 in 5-year-steps, - Application of the main equipment - Calculation of auxiliary and ancillary processes 4)
Revision of environmental investigations
5)
Financial calculations
General Approach The plan describes the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures. Special focus has been given on investment and the required resettlement including land acquisition to guarantee the operation of the new mine. The complementary mining plan is in compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations. Approach for Mining The Sibovc SW mining plan bases on related projects (financed by the European Agency for Reconstruction), which are for instance the Mid term Mining Plan for the existing mines (completed in April 2005) and the Main Mining Plan Sibovc (completed in the June/August 2005). The Steag – Consortium has elaborated the CMP (complementary mining plan) for first 5 years (opening-up phase; 2008 -2012) on an annual basis and with an outlook covering the entire mining field Sibovc SW. Approach for Environment The assessment of the environmental situation is based on available data base (data available per February 2006) and is an update of the environmental assessment of the main mine plan. The budget and time frame did not allow carrying out own environmental measurings since only 15 man days were planned for the updating. Thus further measures should be performed (organised by KEK / Ministry) in order to meet European standards. Approach for economic and financial Analysis A complex finance mathematic consideration will be made resulting in the real average costs per t of run of mine coal. The economic analysis will identify possible project risks regarding the costs and achievable price. Where major variations are expected over the project life, sensitivity tests will be applied. The economic and financial analysis will reflect the proposed investment programme. It is assumed for the mining plan that KEK will have access to the investment as required. This assumption was approved during the Kick-off Meeting.
Page 23 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Within the first years 236 m€ (real) will be required. The most important and crucial part of the investment is the refurbishment of main mine equipment (MME), which amounts to 158 MEURO. The consultant points out that without a timely refurbishment of the MME the fuel supply from Sibovc to the existing TPP’s can not be provided as planned.
2.3 Geographical Overview The Kosova lignite deposits are located between the cities of Mitrovica in the North and Kaqanik in the South. The total estimated resources of Kosovo’s lignite deposits are approximately 10,000 mt (Carl Bro; 2003), thus forming one of the largest lignite deposits in Europe. As being one of at least four major deposits the Kosova Coal Basin covers about 85 km from North to South with an average East – West extension of 10 km. Hence the deposit comprises some 850 km².
Fig.: 2.3-1
Location of existing Mine
Morphologically, the Kosova Coal Basin forms an extended valley where the differences in elevation do not exceed 80m. Around the river Sitnica a central plane part stretches followed by a more hilly terrain nearing the mountains Çicavica Golesh and Sharr. The basin is surrounded by an elevated relief with Kopaonik massive, Kozic, Zhegovc Lisic in the East, Montenegro massive in the South and Çicavica, Golesh, Carnaleva as well as Sharr
Page 24 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
mountains in the West and Northwest. The surrounding mountains reach elevations from 900 to more than 1,600m. The resources were discovered more than hundred years ago and the first small-scale utilisation was started in the 1920’. According to more detailed information first utilization started with underground mining in at least five locations. Underground exploitation was ongoing until the year 1966 followed by large scale surface mining at Bardh and Mirash mines. Large-scale utilisation was already decided in the 1950’ties and the first mine “Mirash” started coal production in 1958. Power generation started at Thermal Power Plant Kosovo A (TPP A) in 1962. Kosovo A was extended in the period 1962 to 1975 to the current capacity. A second Thermal Power Plant Kosovo B (TPP B) was commissioned in 1985 and at the same time the mine Bardh has been opened. Coal exploitation from surface mines in the first period mend that the overburden excavated had to be dumped out-side the excavation holes. Hence, at least seven outside dumps were installed today surrounding the mines. In the meantime both mines are merged to one big mine.
2.4 Climatic Data The Kosova basin is characterized by continental climate with rather dry and warm summers and indifferent winter temperatures depending on the influence of high-pressure areas from Siberia or low-pressure areas from the Atlantic Ocean. Values for precipitation were collected from different sources. The Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosova provided a study showing in the year 1999 the monthly average for a period of 25 years (25 years average). The Institute also provided monthly values for the years 1979 to 1995 and 2002 to 2004. By adding values for the years 2001 and 2002 this data base was widened to cover a period of 25 years (1979 – 2004). The data base was completed by an existing evaluation for the duration 1948 to 1978. The average yearly precipitation amounts 600 mm. Minimum precipitation can be described using the year 1990 with 372 mm. Maximum yearly precipitation is documented with 1,028 mm (Rudarski Institut; 1985). In the year 1995 precipitation was recorded with 1,010 mm. For purpose of surface dewatering measures ESTAP Final Report (February 2002) found statistical details for magnitudes of daily rainfall to be repeated at this place. Return Period
Intensity
Every two years
35.4 mm/day
Every four years
43.0 mm/day
Every ten years
52.8 mm/day
Every hundred years
74.6 mm/day Source: INKOS
Tab.: 2.4-1
Intensity of Heavy Rainfall
Based on a 30 years duration maximum rainfall was chosen there with 60 mm in 24 h. Runoff coefficients for this rainfall event were given for -
mining side:
0.6;
Page 25 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
dumping side:
0.4;
-
average in the mines: 0.45.
Complement but older information can be taken from the report “Kosovo B, Power Plant 1 & 2 Construction of Ash Disposal Project” (Energoinvest; 2004) repeating the “Report on climatic conditions and parameters for the region that accommodates the Kosovo coal deposit” (Hydrometeorological Institute of the Republic of Serbia; Belgrade; 1990) Reviewing data from the Hydrometeorological Institute as well as older documents describing the mining area average annual temperature results in +10°C. On a basis of the years 1979 to 1991 the range of temperatures is shown in figure below with minimum temperatures in January and maximum in July. Lowest Temperature ever measured counts –25.2°C. 25 °C data source: The Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosovo
20 °C
temperature
15 °C
10 °C
5 °C
0 °C
-5 °C
-10 °C J
F
M
average 1965 - 1990
Fig.: 2.4-1
A
M
J
month
J
maximum recordings 1979 - 1991
A
S
O
N
D
minimum recordings 1979 - 1991
Average and extreme monthly Temperatures
The wind is predominantly blowing from north and northeast with average velocity near 3 m/s. Rudarski Institut in the year 1985 gave an overview about wind velocities and directions that are repeated in the figure below. The greatest wind velocity was recorded with 34.3 m/s blowing from the north. The Kosova Basin forms a smoothly shaped plain that is bordered by hills and mountains. This basin includes a developed hydrological network with the main collector given by the river Sitnica. This river crosses the basin from south to north and drains off the main part of the accumulating surface water northwards. Major tributary rivers in the vicinity of the site are river Drenica in the west and river Lab in the east. The Sitnica run-off of water varies between a minimum of 0.5 – 1.5 m³/sec and a maximum of 50 – 120 m³/sec with an average of 5 – 10 m³/sec. In flooding periods, the course of the river reaches a width of up to 1,000 m in the flooding areas. On 3 May 1958 a maximum run-off for river Sitnica near to the mines was measured with 90.30 m³/sec.
Page 26 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3 Coal Demand A detailed output programme with the medium- and long-term fuel supply demand of the different power plants was not available at project start. According to the decision made at the Kick-off Meeting an assumption about the coal demand was agreed – amounting to 9 mt/a. This coal demand was agreed between KEK, EAR, MEM and the Consultant. If this coal demand would be changed the mining plan would need an alteration too. This could not be done within the planned time schedule. Nevertheless the mining plan will be adaptable (to a great deal without problems) in a range of +10% of the envisaged coal demand. Year
Existing Mines
Sibovc SW
Total
2006
6.8
-
6.8
2007
7.2
-
7.2
2008
7.9
-
7.9
2009
7.8
-
7.8
2010
4.6
3.4
8.0
2011
3.0
6.0
9.0
2012
-
9.0
9.0
2013
-
9.0
9.0
2014
-
9.0
9.0
2015
-
9.0
9.0
2016
-
9.0
9.0
2017
-
9.0
9.0
2018
-
9.0
9.0
2019
-
9.0
9.0
2020
-
9.0
9.0
2021
-
9.0
9.0
2022
-
9.0
9.0
2023
-
9.0
9.0
2024
-
6.0
6.0
Total
37.3
123.4
160.7
Tab.: 2.4-1
Coal Demand
The following principles / assumptions have been made: -
Generating electricity from Sibovc SW pursues the goal to meet domestic needs mainly.
Page 27 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
After depletion of the existing mines the new Sibovc SW mine supplies the existing power plants Kosovo A and B. The coal supply from the new mine has to start in 2010.
-
The life time for Kosovo B is about 40 years, which means end of operation in 2023/24.
-
Hence the life time of Sibovc SW will be defined from 2008 to 2024, which means 17 years. Preparatory work will be required in 2007.
-
Three of five units of Kosovo A (200/210 MW) started production between 1970 and 1975. These units do not fulfil normal technical standards. Opinions to refurbish these units (capital refurbishment or major overhaul) differ a lot. However it is assumed that the coal supply to Kosovo A will last for the time being (amounting to 2.5 – 4.7 mt). In case Kosovo A will be out of operation before 2020/24 the new mine will deliver the coal to the TTP replacing Kosovo A. At least the fuel supply is calculated with 9 mt in total for Sibovc SW.
-
It is assumed that the investment needed for opening-up the new mine will be made available timely.
Page 28 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4 Geology 4.1 Introduction Geology The geological evaluation and interpretation was conducted for an area of some 10 km². It encompasses the southern part of the mining concession areas of Sibovc Field.
Fig.: 4.1-1
Map of the future Sibovc SW Mining Area
The basement of the Kosovo Basin and the exposed surrounding areas are built up by Palaeozoic to Mesozoic crystalline rocks. The basin fill consists of Upper Cretaceous strata which are unconformably overlain by Tertiary clays of Pliocene age in which lignite is interbedded. Simplified the coal bearing sediments can be subdivided from the base to the top as follows: Green clay, Lignite Formation, Grey and yellow clay. Towards the West the lignite deposition is tectonically bound by a series of predominantly NNW-SSE striking faults. The eastern limit is characterized by sedimentological pinch-out.
Page 29 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.1-2
Stratigraphic Standard Profile of the Kosovo Basin (KEK 2003)
The Pliocene sediments can generally be subdivided in coal productive/unproductive areas: -
Southern area
unproductive
-
Northern area
unproductive
-
Central area
productive
The central area, the “Coal Kosovo Basin”, spreads over a surface of approximately 300 km². Simplified, the succession can be subdivided as follows:
Page 30 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Bottom Series (green Clay)
-
Coal Series (Lignite Formation)
-
Top Series (grey Clay)
4.2 Assessment of Available Geological Data 4.2.1 Borehole Database The interpretation of the borehole data is basing on the work performed for the Bardh-Mirash Mid Term Mining Plan and Sibovc Main Mine Plan. A total of 443 boreholes are available for the Sibovc concession. Analogue borehole data containing graphical lithological descriptions and tabular assay data were made available by KEK. The volume of paper copies was checked against the borehole inventory list. The data set was nearly complete. From the listed 454 boreholes 451 copies were available. Digital data sets were provided by KEK. An EXCEL file contained a total number of 532 structural boreholes described by the following data columns: -
Borehole name,
-
Y, X, Z (= collar elevation),
-
Overburden Thickness,
-
Lignite Thickness,
-
Interburden Thickness,
-
Bottom Overburden (= Top Lignite in mMSL)
-
Bottom Lignite (= Base Lignite in mMSL)
-
Overburden-to-Coal ratio.
Within this digital data set prefixes as Sb, Bm, Br or ML were added to the borehole names as area identifiers. It was found that 57 boreholes represent duplicates due to using different prefixes for the same borehole. After removing the duplicates, 475 boreholes remained. Thereof 252 boreholes overlapped with the analogue data set. For 223 boreholes no paper copies were available. After merging the digital and analogue data into an EXCEL-based database the available borehole data set summed up to 674 boreholes. For 451 holes paper copies were available, for 223 not.
4.2.2 Assessment Methodology All surface locations and elevations from the originally delivered digital borehole database were checked against available paper copies since first random checks showed a relatively high portion of typing errors.
Page 31 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Typing errors defining the seam boundaries were detected by anomalies not explainable by geological features during the mapping process and corrected.
4.2.3 Stratigraphic and Lithological Borehole Data 443 borehole data (lithological descriptions, assay data) were available for the area within Sibovc Concession Area Seven boreholes were removed from the active database. They represented extreme deviations in the surface elevation or lignite depth compared to adjacent boreholes. 436 boreholes remained as “active” data in the borehole database At the southern border of the Sibovc field a new series of exploration drillings was started. Three of these drillings are already finished. And the results will be included into the geological model of the Sibovc SW mine The top of the seam has been encountered between 2.30 m and 137 m md (measured depth) with an average at 43.85 m. The base was penetrated between 3.00 and 193.20 m md with an average at 93.20 m. The structural position for the top of the seam is between 494.89 and 638.10 mMSL (meter above mean sea level) with an average at 548.57 mMSL. The elevation for the base is between 530.90 and 663.30 mMSL with an average at 594.00 mMSL. The seam thickness is between 0 and 93.08 m. The average is at 59.52 m.
4.3 Digital Geological Model 4.3.1 General Remarks to the Geological Model A detailed structural model has been generated for the Lignite Fm. It integrates all available sources as surface observations and borehole data. The borehole data are stored in an EXCEL file. The EXCEL database served as input of borehole data for the geological modelling. All maps, 3D displays and cross-sections were produced by using SURFER 8.00 (Golden Software) and AutoCad 2004. Available data from other geological modelling software (e.g. Surpac) has been implemented. All grids have a 20*20 m grid node increment. For the gridding processes all available borehole data have been considered. The maps show an area of 10 km² that fall in the limits of xmin=7499500, xmax=7503500, ymin=4722750 ymax= 4726500. For the generation of the depth structure grid and contour map at Top Lignite Seam a minimum curvature algorithm was used. An anisotropy factor of 0.8 was used to reflect the North-South elongation of the lignite basin. This algorithm has been tested as the best available for modelling fault areas. The isochore thickness has been generated by applying a radial basis function with anisotropy of 0.8 and a long axis directed to the NNW (340° azimuth). The base of the seam has been generated by isochoring downwards.
Page 32 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The overburden, overburden-to-coal ratio and structural dip maps have generated by mathematical grid operations. The faults have been mapped as vertical faults. This simplification has been made because the chosen grid increment no significant improvement in volumetric calculation. The structural cross-sections were generated from the SURFER structural grids. The sections were manually edited to show fault dips. For the coal quality distribution grids which are not affected by faults a kriging algorithm with SURFER’s default linear variogram with the following specifications was used.
The search parameters have been selected as shown below.
4.3.2 Results / Description of the Geological Model Depth structure maps at Top and Base Lignite, a seam isochore map, overburden thickness and overburden-to-coal ratio are shown in the next figures. The structural dip at top lignite is low with overwhelming values below 5Âş. Steeper dipping is indicated in Sibovc along two SW-NE alignments which are believed to represent erosion channels. The erosion is also seen on the depth structure map at Top lignite and the isochore map. The mapped area is characterised by a NNW-SSE striking basin. Along the axis the thickness reaches up to 70-80 m. The coal basin is delineated to the West by a series of stepping fault blocks which separate the Tertiary fill from the Mesozoic basement.
Page 33 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The lignite pinch-out to the NE appears to be unconformable without recognized boundary faults. Cross-faults which strike roughly perpendicular to the basin axis are developed in the North of Sibovc and to the South of Hade. Relating to the slope of the new Sibovc SW mine the eastern slope is identical with the slope at the Western border of the village of Hade. Compared with the northern slope of the Bardh-Mirash Mine, fundamental differences have to taken into consideration. In contrast to the former planning, the mining field within the coal was enlarged into northern direction. As the infrastructure was planned in the upper part of the slope just before the northern extension was accomplished, actual roads and buildings are situated very close to the slope. This includes the coal transport roads, a public road and a power transmission line. Finally, a partial sliding of the northern slope could not be prevented. Deep cracks of the sliding bodies were not refilled or draining measures were not taken. The sliding masses which were accumulated as mud flows at the bottom of the slope had been excavated to maintain the operability of the main belt conveyor. The mud flow and the following excavation initiated a circular process with decreasing slop stability and a resulting endangering of human settlings. Therefore a resettling program has been initialised. The slope stability will be increased by a large dimensioned mass removal at the upper slope which will be accomplished during the extension of the opencast mine. In addition to the steep design of the slope the situation is aggravated due to faults with a throw of some metres striking acute-angled into the slope. This disadvantageous fault situation leads to a further decrease of the slope stability. The transsection of the overburden due to these faults favours a profound humidity penetration, a reduction of soil stability and finally leads to the sliding of slope fragments. Supplementary destabilisation of the slope caused by remains of old underground mining in the upper part of the seam creates a complex geotechnical situation. A sustainable and sufficient stabilisation without refilling of excavated areas will be difficult The future slope within the range of the Eastern slope of the new Sibovc SW mine shows complete different initial conditions. The planning includes a graded slope system with integrated drainage system installed during excavation of the overburden. The part of the slope within the coal seam will be covered with clay after excavation; planting vegetation with suitable plants will avoid small sidings, if the vegetation is accurately cultivated. A long term planning and accompanying observation of theses measures will stabilise the slope. Actually there are no indications that in the range of the future eastern slope remains of the old underground mining will be found and unfavourable striking faults have not been detected. The geological outcrops generally deliver sufficient information, but for detailed examinations of mine divisions deficits can not be excluded. Geotechnical information about the friction angle in the range of the planned slopes will be acquired. The detailed succession of the overburden in the range of the slopes will be examined. The bottom of the seam still has not been examined to bring out reliable information. If water bearing layers should appear it can be assumed that confined ground water appears. To assure that no water intake occurs when cutting the bottom of the seam boreholes should penetrate the bottom at least to a depth of 30m.
Page 34 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
A larger area should be included in this special survey, also comprising the Western border areas, where due to facies changes detailed investigations seem to be important. The geological survey has to be ensured during the current mining activities. Therefore continuous drilling operations in the front of the excavation line have to accomplished, whereby all cores must be described (cm-scale), photographed and sampled. The parameters which have to be examined are coal quality, geotechnical characteristics. Furthermore the borehole has to be observed recording groundwater level and any signs of coal fires. Amongst the stratigraphic description also data like joint structures, their orientation and especially the strata inclination have to be gathered. During testing the reliability of borehole data has been detected, that within the dataset of 1,000 boreholes two boreholes were deepened at the same location at an interval of 1 year. The results of these drillings showed data differences regarding the depth of geological limits (e.g. top of seam, base of seam) with a variance of app. 20%. That means that the results of all drillings should be regarded under consideration of a possible variation of 20%. The 4 new drillings showed due to a refined description methodology, that within the seam a layer of green clay occurs. This layer showed a thickness of appr. 3 m. The depth of this layer corresponds to the layer which was used for fixing the base of the seam. All neighboured boreholes have been stopped reaching the first occurrence of green clay; that means, underneath the recorded first green clay the seam may continue. Unfortunately all drillings were not deepened anymore reaching this erroneous base of the seam. However it has to be stated that the coal underneath the first green clay in the first 2 new drillings show a very poor coal quality. The samples for the NET-CV were gained selectively from corresponding cores. From drillhole layers no samples were taken. The clay layers of the drillholes do not show any NetCV. Including them the interpretation would become more complex. But there is no documentation available that during interpretation of the samples the clay layers have been considered. Therefore nearby those old drilling a new drilling should be deepened on the sampling and analysis is exactly recorded. Only basing on this method this new drilling can serve as reference for a recalculation of all old boreholes. The distance of 250 minimum between the drillings is too large for a reliable correlation between the clay layers of the seam bottom. These layers are built up by clay lenses with fluviatile origin. At the bed of a small river within the wood mud and clay was deposited. Residues of the river beds are delivered as small mud filled channels, the horizontal extension is not very large. These channels are typical for the environment where the coal seam was formed. The coal seam shows a different distribution of the channels. In the lower part of the seam they are very numerous, whilst in the upper part the channels are rare and disappear near the top of the seam due to changing sedimentary conditions. In the Mirash opencast mine such a clay lens was detected within the lowest coal cut in December 2005. The thickness was about 0.5 m and the lateral extension about 50 m. Additionally to the disquisition of the year plan a E-W striking 2 D line seismics investigation seem to be advisable for an update of the border areas, the faults including the throws. These methods would allow minimizing the information deficit concerning the structure of the coal deposit. The Western border of the Sibovc SW mine requires special attention. The clarification of the structure can be based on drillings only, but would require a large amount of drillings for a reliable interpretation. Page 35 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3.2.1 Surface The Sibovc SW area has an average elevation above sea level of 609 m, reaching from 497m to 666m. The surface area covers app. 10 km². The southern part of the exploration area, where the initial excavation will take place, is developed as a small valley, bordered by hills up to app. 660m. The slope of these hills show angles from 10-4 degrees declined from southeastern to south-western direction.
Fig.: 4.3-1
Topographical Map (including dumps) of the Sibovc SW Mining Area
4.3.2.2 Overburden (Including Outer Dumps) The Overburden thickness varies from o to 0 to 125m. Nearby the northern border of the existing mines the overburden shows the lowest values.
Page 36 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-2
Sibovc SW, Overburden Thickness
4.3.2.3 Coal (Including Coal Quality) The distribution and structure of the seam is described in the next figures. The coal seam shows a thickness over 70m in wide parts of the Sibovc SW Field.
Page 37 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-3
Sibovc SW, Depth Structure Map at Top of Seam
Page 38 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-4
Sibovc SW, Depth Structure Map at Base of Seam
Page 39 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-5
Sibovc SW, Seam Thickness
Page 40 of 150
Fig.: 4.3-6
Cross Section A WSW – ENE
Fig.: 4.3-7
Cross Section B NNW – SSE
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The cross-sections show the topography including dumps (brown line), top of seam (green line) and base of seam (blue line). The yellow line indicates the respective slope angles within the seam (20째) and the overburden (6째) referring to an excavation front width of app. 700m at the base of the seam level. The position of the sections is indicated in the figures before. The yellow lines indicate only possible slope designs basing on recent information. The slope will develop depending on actual mine planning and can differ from this model. The following pages show horizontal sections (from block model) in the range of 430 to 610 mMSL.
Page 42 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 43 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 44 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 45 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 46 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 47 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 48 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 49 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Page 50 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-8
Coal Quality in Horizontal Sections
Page 51 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.4 Further Aspects Influencing the Sibovc SW Mine 4.4.1 Underground Mining Generally there is no reliable information about the exact extension and locations of the old underground mining. Actual structures of the old underground mining are situated in the south-eastern part of the Sibovc field and are connected with the old mining structures which are currently exposed along the coal cuts in Mirash West and on the Mirash northern slope. Some of the old galleries have been already cut in the Mirash mine and the pillar area. It can be assumed, that remains could be found the Northern part of the New Sibovc SW mine (north of the village of Sibovc) and that some galleries will be cut at the northern slope. Until now indications of old underground mining structures have not been found. First attempts to reach the seam were made along river erosion channels which cut the coal seam. In areas of the seam which were affected, it can be mixed completely or at least partly with humus strata resulting in a decrease of the coal quality. Therefore, the initial excavation of the stalls began about 7 meters under the roof of the seam. In the proximity of the riverbanks water handling was difficult. At a later stage vertical shafts were deepened. The documented coal mining used galleries and reaches back to 1922 A wooden timber set support system was used for the stabilisation of the galleries with a height of 2 m and width of 3 m. The parallel galleries had a distance of 20 m one to each other, every 100 m a cross cut was excavated and they followed the given directions of the separations planes. The old roadways were driven parallel to the joint system within the mine. The galleries were widened to caverns with intervals of 7-20 m and the coal was broken from the roof. In the area west of the overburden dump in the D-Field these caverns frequently collapsed forming more or less round craters, which show a regular alignment. Due to this method sections of the galleries show a low stability and there is a potential danger of collapse of the undermined levels under load if they are not already broken or refilled. The dimension of the undermined area in has been calculated considering the results of Bardh Mirash Mid Term Plan and Sibovc Mine Mining Plan. If further information is available, the investigations concerning the extension of the old underground mining will be continued. The underground mining was abandoned in 1922. The following table shows the overall coal production of the underground mine. There is no reliable documentation on the extension of the old underground mine or the information is at least incomplete.
Area 1
Area 2
Area 3
“Kosovo”
“Krusevac”
“Sibovac”
Years 1922 – 1966
Years 1948 – 1966
Years 1952-1958
6,401,434 t
2,921,233 t
255,117 t
Tab.: 4.4-1
Coal Production of Old Underground Mines within the Area Investigated
Page 52 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Partly the exploitation fields of the old underground mining were limited by faults. Considering these production rates for the field “Kosovo” an area of app. 5 km² and 2 km² for the field “Sibovc” can be calculated. These production rates from the field “Sibovc” show that excavation was only done near the surface. The largest distance between a shaft and the outermost galleries did not exceed 700 meters. The Sibovc SW field is only partly overlapping with areas of the underground mining field or older not documented mining fields.
4.4.2 Uncontrolled Coal Fires 4.4.2.1 Locations of Coal Fires Within a wide area a large amount of lignite is affected by spontaneous combustion which occurs in the mine slopes and coal yards, where the coal is exposed to air and can penetrate the underground and reach the coal Self-ignition is the consequence of the oxidation of coal, a process which is producing heat energy. If the energy production exceeds the amount of energy removed from the system, the coal will reach its ignition temperature, eventually. In a first phase coal fires take place within weakness zones like joints or slope failures or old mining structures, where enough oxygen can reach the surface of the coal and the heat is enclosed. The fire can be boosted by methane. In the following stage the complete hanging layer is influenced by the heat. About 60% of total coal fires are concentrated near or within the roof strata, where the coal shows the best quality and discharges a great amount of energy. Old galleries from the early underground coal mining facilitate supplementary ventilation and therefore best conditions for oxygen inflow are given. Burned out galleries result in large cavities and therefore decreasing stability of the slopes. The experiences from the Bardh-Mirash mine showed, that also slide areas, slopes (especially the central pillar parts of the mine which remain exposed to air for a longer period), faults and joints are affected by these fires. Self combustion also occurs in dumped coal masses. Typically the coal fires begin at the base of the dumps and affect the whole dump until they are burned out. Higher risk areas which will be the long excavation front at the Northern Bardh Mirash slope and areas affected by illegal (private) coal excavation. Actually the northern slope is not affected by coal fires as predicted. There are no larger zones showing burnt coal with resulting large cavities, only some core samples of the new exploration drillings showed some smoke marks indicating limited coal fires.
Page 53 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.4-1
Smoke Marks at Samples of Exploration Drilling 2004
Page 54 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.4-2
Example of Coal Fire in Old Mining Structures
Fig.: 4.4-3
Example of Coal Fire in Old Mining Structures
Page 55 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.4.2.2 Counteractive Measures The procedures for coal fire extinguishing and thus saving coal resources have to be adapted to the exploitation operations and to be done by the mines staff during the running mining activities. Adequate extinguishing technologies have to be selected under consideration of the local geotechnical conditions. The extended use of water in most cases may cause landslides. In the 2nd half year of 2006 a project will be started by EAR for fire fighting in the Kosovo Coal Mines. The results of this project shall, as far as the instructions will be carried out strictly, achieve sustained success and lead to a reduction of coal fires.
4.4.2.3 Prevention of Coal Fires Prevention of coal fires means to avoid contact of coal and oxygen. The main focus is on the avoiding of oxygen entry into the underground corridors. This can be done by means of: -
Protection of cut old galleries against ventilation.
-
Inspections of collapsed old galleries near the surface or shafts if oxygen can penetrate somewhere and where appropriate, refilling of openings.
-
Minimising a permanent contact of the coal with atmospheric oxygen (e.g. covering or sealing of slide faults
-
Reducing the time of exposition of the excavation front.
4.5 Further Geological Exploration Required Further geological exploration has to be done considering the special geological and topographical conditions. The prospected excavation front will start along the Northern slope of the Bardh-Mirash Mine. Accordingly the excavation front will cut the W-E lines of the coordinate system with a possible angle of app. 25째 degrees. For an accurate mine planning, a system of close sections parallel northbound to the excavation front will be computed. These sections will show the coal characteristics and surface properties including dumps. A sustainable investigation and planning is important for accurately timed excavation of the overburden regarding the different slope angles of overburden and coal. These conditions necessitate an anticipated excavation of the overburden flattening the slopes to eliminate extensive load on the slope of the coal seam. The topography with hills surrounding the future mining area and the resulting inclination of the surface requires a thorough investigation of the geological and geotechnical conditions. The potential objectives of the exploration work are: -
Distribution of the seam
-
Position of the seam with detailed exploration of top of seam and base of seam
-
Coal quality distribution model Page 56 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Hydrogeological aspects (problems with drainage and stability)
-
Geotechnical aspects regarding the slope stability
Some zones require a special inspection and problem finding: -
Slope near Hade
-
Slope stability inn the range of faults and dumps
-
Slope of the excavation front
4.5.1 Methods of Further Geological Exploration Besides an exploration by drillings 2 D line seismics investigation seem to be advisable for an update of the border areas, the faults including the throws. These methods would allow minimizing the information deficit concerning the structure of the coal deposit, especially along the Western boundary. The Western border of the Sibovc SW mine requires special attention. The clarification of the structure can be based on drillings only, but would require a large amount of drillings for a reliable interpretation.
Fig.: 4.5-1
Planned 2-D Seismic Investigations
4.5.2 Location for Urgently Required Drillholes (2006) All drillings are deepened for a survey of coal thickness and quality. Furthermore the individual drillings will be examined with following methods: -
The drillhole SW-1 serves the investigation of the slide area and the coal fire situation
Page 57 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
All drillings (except SW-1) serve the investigation of the faults
-
SW-2, SW-5, SW-6 and SW-7 will de deepened to acquire information about properties and condition of the dumps. In addition the structure and stratification shall be examined in the range of faults
-
Also the drillings SW-2 and SW-5 shall help to investigate the coal fire situation
-
SW-9 will be drilled in selected area not affected by faults and will function as reference profile for the adjustment of coal quality data.
-
The geotechnical characterisation of the overburden is important in the drillholes in the western border area of the Sibovc SW mine. This will be the location of the future slope.
Besides the standard core sample record additional recorded parameters are listed in the table below. Drillhole
Total depth
Within seam bottom
Coal Quality
Water Level
Strata Dip
Geotechnical bottom
Grain Size overburden
Grain Size Bottom
SW-1
180 m
40 m
x
x
x
x
x
x
SW-2
170 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-3
175 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-4
125 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-5
130 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-6
120 m
20 m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-7
135 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-8
80 m
5m
x
x
x
x
x
SW-9
230 m
40 m
x
x
x
x
x
Tab.: 4.5-1
x
Parameter to be Recorded
It would be advantageous if for all drillings the drill progress would be recorded to identify strata hardness and faults. The highlighted drillholes are to be understood as the minimum for the first inspection of the future field.
Page 58 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-2
Location of the Planned Drillhole SW-1
Fig.: 4.5-3
Location of Planned Drillholes SW-2 und SW-5
Page 59 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-4
Location of Planned Drillholes SW-3 und SW-9
Fig.: 4.5-5
Location of Planned Drillholes SW-4, SW-6, SW-7 and SW-8
Page 60 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5 Soil-mechanical Parameters 5.1 General Main task of the soil-mechanical activities within opencast operations comprises the assessment of the static stability of the slopes and slope systems. Mining and dump slopes must be distinguished. Whereas the mining slopes represent cuts into the naturally grown subsoil, dump soils are produced from loose rock influenced by excavation-, transportation and dumping processes. Another soil-mechanical aspect is the ensuring of bearing capacity of working levels and transport routes. The soil-mechanical assessment of the above mentioned problems is made on the basis of soil-physical parameters by integrating geological, hydrological and technological boundary conditions. Information regarding the following important aspects is therefore inevitable for a reliable soil-mechanical work: -
Geological deposit conditions
-
Hydrological conditions
-
Technological boundary conditions
-
Soil-physical properties of all layers contributing to the rock and dump set up
-
Site-specific features.
5.1.1 Geology A stable and geotechnical safe management of an opencast mine requires detailed information about the geological conditions of the deposit. It is necessary to develop and continuously update a geological model describing the deposit. The information is illustrated suitably in survey maps and characteristic sectional drawings as well as in describing reports. Due to the advancing slope system geological profiles shall be continuously prepared and updated according to the mine position. Further sections have to be prepared in advance due to the planned head slope systems of the mine. An existing precise geological model allows to react appropriately to possibly occurring special geological conditions by adjusting the opencast mine technology. Subjects of the exploration are thicknesses, location and dipping of the rock layers from the surface level to the deeper lying bottom layers. Geological fault zones, slide zone to be overexcavated or underground caverns from old mining activities and/or coal fires require an increased exploration expense in any case.
5.1.2 Hydrology Parallel to the geological information hydrological condition shall be analysed, e.g. the formation of aquifers or the discharge behaviour of rainfalls. The hydrological information shall also be adjusted to the respective state of opencast mine development. Control and monitoring of the hydrological situation requires a network of level gauges and flow Page 61 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
measurements. The information is illustrated in form of hydrological maps. The hydrological information are not only included in the soil-mechanical calculations for static stability of the slopes but are also basis for a functioning drainage system in the opencast mine and the direct vicinity.
5.1.3 Technology Slope angles and height are geometrical marginal conditions for the soil-mechanical calculations of static stability. In principal the opencast mine technology must be adjusted to the soil-mechanical requirements to ensure stable slopes and slope systems. Whereas geological and hydrological conditions as well as the soil-physical parameter of the explored layers are considered to be fixed marginal conditions, opencast mine technology has to be optimised to enable a safe and at the same time economic opencast mine management.
5.1.4 Soil-mechanical Parameter The soil-physical parameter specific weight, angle of friction and cohesion are the most important input parameter ort he soil-mechanical calculations. The parameters of potential areas of weakness in the overburden structure are of special interest. Experiences show that sliding surfaces may establish in cohesive soils due to stress release by excavation activities and/or geological and tectonic processes. Their shearing strength is partly lower than 30 % of the intact soil layers and is called residual shear strength. The residual shear strength is determined in laboratory by means of a circular shear test apparatus in case of large sliding amounts. The following picture illustrates the formation of a sliding surface with reduced shearing strength.
Page 62 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.1-1
Sliding Surface with Reduced Shearing Strength
Special importance shall be attached to the properties of the dump material. Owing to excavation-, transportation- and dumping processes the soil material in-situ is subject to considerable. Therefore special examinations have to be carried out for the dump materials. The following figure shows the shearing surfaces of slides in a dump massive.
Fig.: 5.1-2
Dump with Formation of Shearing Areas
Page 63 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
At present, the available data base for the planned Sibovc SW field does not contain any verified soil-physical parameters. In view to a safe and efficient opencast mine management it is urgently required to establish a soil-physical data base. To carry out the static stability calculation within the framework of this study experiences made in the fields of Mirash and Bardh are used due to the missing data base. It is expected to have analogue marginal conditions owing to the close location to the partial fields. The static stability calculations to be carried out base therefore on the soil-physical parameters from the partial fields of Mirash und Bardh. The results can therefore be characterised as first assessment and have to be revised if new information are available.
5.1.5 Soil-mechanical Calculation Methods Depending on the marginal conditions (geology, hydrology, soil-physical parameter, technology) to be integrated in the soil-mechanical model, failure scenarios shall be developed. Such scenarios could for example describe slope failures on circular cylindrical test areas or slope failures due to sliding on an existing weak area. The form of failures on circular cylindrical and existing, polygonal sliding surfaces are schematically illustrated in the following figures. Further scenarios shall be derived and investigated in dependence of sitespecific characteristics, as for example demonstrated by fault zones or fracture formations. VG: Released sliding surface
yellow clay KZP
KZP: circular sliding surface
gray clay
VG coal seam operating floor
VG KZP
Fig.: 5.1-3
green clay
Failure Scenarios to be Examined
In accordance with the failure scenarios to be examined suitable calculation methods shall be selected. Wide experiences made in more than 40 years of application of such calculation methods are available in Germany and in particular in the Lusatian lignite mining area. The calculation methods most commonly in use are shown in the following table including an allocation to the respective failure.
Page 64 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Calculation method
Form of failure
BOROWICKA
circular cylindrical sliding surfaces
BOROWICKA
polygonal sliding surfaces
BLOCKVERFAHREN
polygonal sliding surfaces
BISHOP
circular cylindrical sliding surfaces
KREY/BRETH
circular cylindrical sliding surfaces
Tab.: 5.1-1
Calculation Methods for the Respective Form of Failure
From the table is becomes clear that the calculation method according to BOROWICKA is universally useable for the calculation of circular cylindrical as well as specific polygonal sliding surfaces. Moreover, wide experiences are available so that it can be ensured that the achieved results reflect the real conditions very well. For special tasks and for reasons of comparison the following methods can be used: BLOCK METHOD, and the methods according to BISHOP and KREY/BRETH.
5.1.6 Necessary Safety Coefficients In general the safety coefficient bases on the relationship of the powers/moments (depending on the chosen calculation method) preventing or favouring the failure mechanism. If preventing powers/moments are named with H and favouring with T the safety coefficient can be characterized as follows: Si = H / T In case of a determined safety coefficient of Si = 1.0 the powers/moments preventing or favouring the failure mechanism are in a balance. The selection of the required safety coefficient Sierf. depends on the following influences: -
Knowledge/experiences,
-
Economic consequences of failure (objects, equipment, personnel to be protected) and
-
Lifetime of the examined slope.
Principally it has to be considered that the selection of the required safety coefficient is decisively determined by the state of knowledge and the experiences regarding the geological and hydrological situation as well as the soil-physical experiences. The level of the necessary safety coefficient to be selected can be reduced with increasing knowledge. It has to be verified if increased exploration extent can be justified by a safe and economic operation result. Furthermore, economic consequences which are always connected with an occurring failure case shall also be taken into account whereby the required safety coefficient has to be raised with increasing scope of potential damage. The lifetime of the examined slopes must also be taken into consideration when selecting the safety level to be maintained. In case of very short lifetimes, for example for the advancing mining and dump slopes, the safety coefficients chosen can be lower than for head slopes with a long lifetime. Page 65 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
To guarantee both a geotechnically safe and economic opencast mine operation the safety coefficients included in the following table are regarded necessary from the point of view of soil-mechanics. Sierf.
Tab.: 5.1-2
Single Slope
≥ 1.05
Partial slope systems
≥ 1.20
Entire slope systems
≥ 1.20
Objects to be protected
≥ 1.30
Proposal for Necessary Safety Coefficients
More information about the geological, hydrological marginal conditions and the soil-physical parameters would allow a more differentiated consideration of the required safety coefficient.
5.2 Soil-mechanical Investigations – Mine Sibovc SW 5.2.1 General The following soil-mechanical investigations are of estimating character because of the lack of information regarding geology, hydrology and the low state of knowledge about the soilphysical parameter of the geological layers. If further information from a regional and operational geological exploration will be available the soil-mechanical considerations shall be revised and intensified. Further exploration stages are urgently required for a geotechnically safe operational management. This especially applies to the sporadically occurring interburden in the massive coal seam and the voids in the advancing opencast mine operation resulting form old mining activities and/or possible uncontrolled coal fires.
5.2.2 Geology A detailed description of the geological extension of the partial field Sibovc SW was already made in chapter 4 of this study. Therefore the explanations made in the available chapter are only concentrating on important specific soil-mechanical issues. The deposit Sibovc SW is in the central part of the Kosova Basin. The lignite seam has a thickness of 70 m and is bedded within tertiary clay layers. Interburden in the seam is only occurring sporadically. The overburden thickness varied between only a few meters and 125 m. The structure of the overburden can be differentiated from the surface level into the layers yellow and/or grey clay. The layers of green clay are occurring in the bottom of the coal seam.
5.2.3 Hydrology Because bottom and roof horizons are exclusively made of clay layers there does not exist any aquifer with soil-mechanical effects. The in-situ clay tends to strong plastic behaviour when charged with water under so that soil-mechanical and technical as well as technological problems may occur in case of long rainfall, heavy rainfalls or during thaw.
Page 66 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5.2.4 Soil-mechanical Parameters As already mentioned earlier there are not available any safe statistical soil-mechanical parameters for the planned Sibovc SW field. Within the framework of this study there are used the experiences made with the Mirash and Bardh fields for this reason. The neighbourhood of the partial fields promises analogue marginal conditions so that the adaptation of the parameters is justified. In addition to the available experiences laboratory test were carried out by GMB and KEK which results verifying the previous parameter approach. The following table documents the soil-physical parameters forming the basis for the following calculations. The parameters of the weak zones at the margins between overburden and/of bottom clay and coal seam are of relevance for soil-mechanics. It shall be referred to that the in-situ cohesive materials show a behaviour strongly depending on the water content so that the shearing strength may be reduced under extreme weather conditions like for example heavy rainfalls or during thaw. The parameters included in the following table shall be regarded as mean values for shearing strength. Soil-physical Parameter ϕ‘
c‘
γ [kN/m³]
ϕR [°]
cR [kN/m²]
[°]
[kN/m²]
Gray and yellow Clay – Overburden
14.3
16.2
17.5
8.0
5.0
Coal Seam
40.0
50.0
12.2
-
-
Green Clay - Floor Strata
14.0
16.0
17.5
8.0
5.0
Dump Material
14.0
10.0
17.5
-
-
Geological Layers
Tab.: 5.2-1
Soil Mechanical Parameter
5.2.5 Necessary Safety Coefficients The static stability investigations concentrate to principle examinations of static stability of the advancing winning slopes in overburden operation, head slope systems as well as information about the dump geometry. It is regarded necessary to maintain the following static stability coefficients: Single slopes in advancing system
1.05
Advancing slope system
1.20
Head slope system
1.20
Objects to be protected
1.30
Page 67 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5.2.6 Investigations of Static Stability 5.2.6.1 Single Slopes Single slopes in the advancing slope system are stable depending on the slope height with the following slope angles. Height of slope
Slope angle
Si
0 ≤ hBö ≤ 10
65°
1.05
10 ≤ hBö ≤ 15
40°
1.05
15 ≤ hBö ≤ 20
30°
1.05
Tab.: 5.2-2
Slope Angles for Single Overburden Slopes
Under certain circumstances it may be possible that greater slope heights and steeper slope angles are stable. The static stability coefficient is then Si=1.0. In those cases persons and equipment shall be protected by special measures. These exceptions shall only be valid for temporary single slopes with short lifetimes.
5.2.6.2 Slope Systems The following map gives a survey on the cross section lines being important for the static stability of the head slope systems.
Fig.: 5.2-1
Layout Plan Sibovc-SW Including the Cross Section Lines
Page 68 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The following shows an example for total slope system and partial overburden system in the cut EAST_1.
Fig.: 5.2-2
Cross Section EAST 1
Calculation example
Si
Sliding surface between overburden and consideration of the overburden slope system
coal,
≥ 1.30
Sliding surface between overburden and coal, consideration of the overburden slope system with reduced shearing strength
≥ 1.10
Sliding surface between coal and consideration of the total slope system
≥ 1.30
bottom
clay,
Sliding surface between coal and bottom clay, consideration of total slope system with reduced shearing strength Tab.: 5.2-3
≥ 1.30
Results of Static Stability Calculations for the Cross Section EAST_1
The above table illustrates that most of all the overburden slope system reacts sensitive to a reduction of the strength. Due to the high shearing strengths of the local layers the total slope system is stable even if reduced shearing strengths are assumed. A hypothetical investigation is made to investigate the dependence of static stability from a possible dipping of a predetermined sliding surface. Dipping of the sliding surface in the overburden is assumed variably between 0 ≤ ε ≤ 5. The calculation model is schematically illustrated in the following Figure.
Page 69 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.2-3
Calculation Model with Variable Dipping of the Sliding Surface
The following figure illustrates the dependency of the static stability coefficients from dipping angle of the considered sliding surface between overburden and coal seam. Whereas the blue curve bases on the proposed residual shearing strengths, the red curve was calculated on the basis of the reduced parameters.
Fig.: 5.2-4
Static Stability Coefficient in Dependence from Dipping of Sliding Surface
The hypothetic example illustrates the necessity of a continuous regional and operational exploration. Detailed geotechnical investigations are urgently required due to the non-linear dependencies between static stability and dipping angle as well as the existing uncertainty in view to the available parameters and object-related geological information. According to the present state of knowledge the following general inclinations shall be kept for the bank slope systems to be planned.
Page 70 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.2-5
General Inclinations for Coal and Overburden Cuts
Due to the longer lifetime the head slope system are subject to weather influences to a large extent. Under certain circumstances this may lead to a reduction of the soil-physical parameters. Depending on the objects to be protected in the influencing area of the head slopes general inclinations between 6 und 8°are recommended for the overburden cut.
5.2.6.3 Dump Slopes For dump slopes the following explanations shall be taken into consideration. By excavation and following transport on belt conveyors up to the spreader the overburden masses undergo changes of the soil-physical properties. Table 5.2-1 contains the changes of soil-physical calculation parameters for the material to be dumped as against the natural overburden. Based on these data the following can be concluded: -
During dumping a slope angle of approximately β ≈ 30° is yielded; with a dump height of ca. 12 m the static stability coefficient is Si=1.0.
-
This means that the dump slope is in limit equilibrium. Any further increase in height leads to formation of shearing surfaces and therefore to fracture.
-
Due to the residual strength slope angles between 6 and 8° result.
The figure illustrates the described occurrences during spreader operation. During practical operation the results have to be taken into account for dump direction.
Page 71 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.2-6
Dump Slide and Resulting Slope Angle
5.2.7 Conclusion The following can be concluded from the above soil-mechanical investigations: -
Single slopes on the mining side are stable with the slope angles and slope heights summarized in table 5.2-2. Steeper and higher single slopes are possible but are in a limit equilibrium (Si=1.0) so that corresponding safety measures for persons ad equipment are necessary.
-
For the exemplary investigated head slope system EAST_1 (cut nearby Hade) it was possible to verify the static stability both with the existing and a reduced parameter approach.
-
The variant calculation on the dependence of static stability from dipping angle of the predetermined sliding surface demonstrates that object-related geotechnical investigations are essential for a safe and economic opencast mine management. Regional and operational explorations are bases for further detailed analyses.
-
Resulting from the calculations for advancing winning slope systems the general inclinations shall not exceed 22째 for the coal- and 10째 for the overburden slope system.
-
Flatter slope angles (6 to 8째) are recommended for head slopes due to longer lifetimes in the overburden slope system. Local steeper angles for example in case of low overburden thicknesses shall be investigated in detail in the operative operation. To avoid failure of single slopes they can be shaped later on by means of mobile equipment.
Page 72 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
The clay material contained in the overburden tends to strong plastic behaviour under addition of water and resulting from this to a changed soil-mechanical behaviour which is principally reflected in a reduced shearing strength. For this reason dewatering measures to be carried out (producing and maintaining of drainage ditches, inclined working levels) have to be addressed specially.
-
Temporary greening is recommended to counteract erosions in the area of the head slopes. If necessary, use of geo-textiles has to be checked.
-
For the dump slope systems, slopes angles (6 to 8째) resulting from the residual shearing strength shall be taken into consideration when planning the dump geometry.
-
Furthermore specific geotechnical features like underground cavities resulting from coal fires and past mining activities, formation of fissures in fault zones or sliding masses have to be considered. In this connection the necessary regional and operational exploration shall be addressed once more.
5.2.8 Measures for a Safe Opencast Mine Management Finally, the measures required for a safe geotechnical opencast mine management shall be summarized again. -
A geological model approved by the responsible geologist must be available for the opencast mine in form of maps, cross sections and reports. This model has to be updated continuously.
-
The hydrological situation (i. e. position and course of aquifers) shall be documented and continuously updated analogue to the geological model
-
The opencast mine position shall be identified in a layout plan in regular periods.
-
Due to the advancing slope system at least three representative geological profiles shall be conducted where the achieved mining positions shall be registered in regular periods. These profiles shall be made right angled to the bench.
-
Position and course of the head slopes shall be planned forward-looking. The planned geometries have to be illustrated by at least one advancing cross section of the respective head slope. The cross sections shall be made right-angled to the respective head slope system.
-
The lines of all cross sections shall be illustrated in the layout plan.
-
Statistically verified soil-physical parameters are required for the decisive geological layers in the roof and bottom. These parameters shall be continuously verified and if necessary updated.
-
The soil samples shall be analysed in by a recognized soil-physical laboratory. The results shall be documented in written form.
-
Soil-mechanical investigations of static stability for all slopes and slope systems shall be principally carried out by qualified experts.
-
The basics and results of the soil-mechanical investigations shall be documented. Any changes of the marginal conditions due to geology, hydrology, technology or in case of changed soil-physical parameters these investigations shall be revised.
Page 73 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
In cooperation with the mine management targets resulting from the static stability calculations shall be used and definitely controlled during the running operation. Qualified personnel are required both for the theoretical soil-mechanical analyses as well as for the geotechnical control during the running operation.
-
A geotechnical expert shall visit the opencast mines in regular periods (at least twice or three times per week, and in case of demand). The visits shall be documented in minutes.
-
A control and monitoring schedule shall be worked out for the opencast mines. This document shall contain all specific operating points to be controlled and monitored continuously. Kind of monitoring and the required reactions in case of variations from the specific targets shall be documented.
The development of a geotechnically safe opencast mine technology with integration of the natural marginal condition from geology, hydrology and soil-physics shall be regarded at iterative process according to the scheme illustrated in the following figure.
Fig.: 5.2-7
Iterative Process for Developing a Geotechnical Safe Opencast Mine
Page 74 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6 Main Mining Equipment 6.1 Technical Status of Existing Equipment 6.1.1 Technical Status of Excavators 6.1.1.1 SRs 1300 and SchRs 650 a) Mechanical Part Main bearing structure The main bearing structure is in a sufficient condition. Larger damage was not noticed. All machines have extensive starting corrosion which gives no cause for concern at the moment. It shall be considered that under the climatic conditions prevailing in Kosovo there will be an annual reduction in thickness of up to 0.1 mm caused by corrosion. Also the two-yearly safety inspection of steel construction has not been done. Therefore some larger defects could develop without knowledge. For a medium- and/or long-term deployment, a complete inspection of steel construction and a complete corrosion protection is therefore urgently necessary for each of the equipment. Auxiliary structure Auxiliary structures such as catwalks, stairs, leaders and platforms have partially substantial damages. These damages have no direct influence on the efficiency of the equipment but involve dangers for the service personnel. Mechanical engineering Very critical is the condition of wear parts and their insufficient stock reserve, like for example crawler base pads, ripper teeth and chains at the shovels, scrapers and side sealings. Also all discharge and charging chutes are not adapted at the typical bulk characteristics if the excavator has to work in overburden areas. The lubrication plants of the SRs 1300 were partly overhauled in the last years but are however in an unsatisfactory maintenance condition. This is particularly problematic in the under-carriage part of the two SchRs 650. The brake assemblies at different drives are out of function. Limit switch systems are essentially in function, but have defects due to a bad maintenance condition. Hereby, defects mainly occur at the system rope tearing and tensioning at the E9B, which cannot be activated due to unsatisfactory adjustment of the ropes "wheel boom hoist". A drive at the wheel belt of E8M is missing (broken shaft of the belt conveyor drum). Up to the implementation of a comprehensive mechanical reconstruction for medium- and/or long-term further deployment, a substantial restriction of the equipment availability shall be taken into account as well as substantially increased running costs for maintenance.
Page 75 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
b) Electrical Part The technical condition of the electrical equipment on the bucket wheel excavators of the type SRs 1300 and SchRs 650 is characterized by -
Year of construction,
-
Operation years in the mines/pits including maintenance and
-
Rehabilitation measures of selected electrical equipment in the years 2001 to 2005
The electrical equipment and electronic devices of the excavators as: -
6kV-bench cable and cable drums,
-
Medium voltage systems „6kV AC“ with battery plant 110V DC,
-
Logic control (relay- or PLC-Systems) and low voltage systems „230V/400V AC “including lighting technology;
-
Drive systems (400V AC-motors, travel- and slewing gear with rectifier DC),
-
Limit switches, buttons, local-control-boxes,
-
Cable and cable run and
-
Cabins and electric houses
correspond to the state of the art of the 80 years. The electrical equipment still in operation does not correspond any longer to the valid European standards. Especially preventive measures for persons and plants in accordance with the standard DIN VDE 0100 are in no way given, e.g.: -
The roofs and windows of the electrical houses are leaky during precipitation (rain and snow).
-
The electrical plants like for example switch cabinet cubicles and electrical operation rooms and terminal boxes of 6 kV-incoming supply and motors are not locked and/or not equipped with safe locking system.
-
The low voltage switch systems do not have shock protection.
-
The medium voltage switch systems are not sufficiently equipped with arc shield.
-
The 6 kV-high-voltage terminal boxes have no sufficient arc voltage protection and they are in a very bad technical repair.
-
Most of the high -voltage protective relays are defective.
The medium- and low-voltage systems at the bucket wheel excavators no longer correspond to the valid European Norms and therefore the latest state of the art. In addition, electrical as well as electronic safety equipment, buttons, synchros and local control boxes are worn out and partly no more in function for different reasons (missing spare parts, deficient maintenance). According to rough estimations, more than 40 to 55 % of the sensors are ready for operation. The sensors in the field area are an important prerequisite for a safe operation (monitoring in the excavator operator cabin).
Page 76 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The cables and cable routes have been strongly worn due to environmental impacts (e.g. ozone) and technical conditions (e.g. contamination, mechanical cramping and distortion of cables). The electrical drive units (starter, motor and thrustor), for example for conveyor belts, hoisting winches, tensioning devices, auxiliary motors and oil pumps, have a very limited availability and reliability. Motors can only be repaired with large expenses. Thrustors with the mechanical part of the brake are mainly not functioning and/or partly not reliable in their function. In line with this the electrical drives are not applicable for a safe operation. In the years 2000 to 2003, mainly material for the most urgent repairs in the opencast mines was purchased by the Consultants of the EAR, so for example high- and low-voltage cables, 6kV-protection relays and circuit-breakers, switchgears in container design for power supply and belt conveyors and spare motors. The bucket wheel excavators of the type SRs 1300 are distinguished according to the carried out retrofitting measures as follow: -
Main cabin new in ergonomic shape (to be accomplished in 2005)
-
travel gear drive and slewing gear drive with 3-phase current motors and frequency converter,
-
PLC (Programmable Logic Controller),
-
Limit switch (end position, lever arm, pull cord),
-
Lubrication plant;
The bucket wheel excavators of the type SchRs 650 (manufactured in 1986 and 1987) are equipped with a PLC System and rectifier (DC technology) and are mostly worn out. Original spare parts and building elements are not available for those obsolete machines.
6.1.1.2 SRs 470, SRs 400 and SRs 315 a) Mechanical Part Main bearing structure The main bearing structures of the devices are in an insufficient condition. There are particularly serious damages at the steel structure at the main superstructure of the E2B. The equipment is to be rehabilitated in a short-term or better taken out of operation and used for spare parts. Furthermore, tears are continuously occurring at all machines, particularly in the connecting sheets, in the undercarriage and slewing device of the loading boom, in diagonals of the superstructure as well as the bucket wheel head in nearly all devices. Pivot bearings at the tie bars are worn out. Corrosion caused material attenuation in the intersections. Also the two-yearly safety inspection of steel construction has not been done accordingly. Therefore some larger unknown defects could develop. This safety inspection shall be realized before the detailed plan of maintenance measures will be prepared. Auxiliary structures Auxiliary structures such as catwalks, stairs, leaders and platforms have partially substantial damages. These damages have no direct influence on the efficiency of the equipment, but they involve dangers for the operating and service personnel. Page 77 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Mechanical engineering Mechanical engineering can be evaluated similar to the condition of the main bearing- and auxiliary structure. Main assemblies such as pulleys and gearboxes are not grease- and/or oilproof. To a large extent the brake systems at the drives are missing and/or inefficient. Clutches are not covered. Wear parts like crawler base pads and buckets exceeded the wear limit. The central lubrication plants are not proper functioning. Side sealings and scrapers are ineffective and/or missing. Also all discharge and charging chutes are not adapted to the typical bulk characteristics if the excavator has to work in overburden areas. Due to the critical state of the e-plants numerous limit switches are not in function. Until decommissioning of these devices (devices will not be used in the new opencast mine field) continuous restrictions in the equipment availability have to be taken into account which are hardly calculable and incur high running maintenance costs. b) Electrical Part The condition of each of these excavators can be assessed as „equally bad“ because they are the oldest opencast mining machines (1965- 1978). Repairs and rehabilitation measures for the electrical equipment have not been carried out so far. These machines will not be used in the new opencast mine field. According to the present planning these opencast mine machines will be in operation until 2011 or will be replaced by released overburden excavators. The electrical equipment in the E-houses like the high- and low-voltage systems is in a bad condition. They do not comply with international standards and are a considerable danger for the personnel. The plants should be stabilized in short-term within the framework of running maintenance to such an extent that it will be possible to operate the devices with justifiable risk until decommissioning. The main components of the electrical equipment shall then be replaced within the scope of complex maintenance measures. Conclusion: Under consideration of the equipment condition, but mainly due to the too low capacity potential (regarding output quantity and stripping performance), it is not foreseen to use the excavators of the type SRs 470 / 315 or SRs 400 as high performance mine equipment but as excavators for sub benches and as floating machines.
6.1.2 Technical Status of Spreaders a) Mechanical Part Main bearing structure The main bearing structures of the A2Rs 4400 and the 5200 are in a satisfying condition. Except some bent diagonals in the discharge booms no signs of larger damage were found. In different places large areas with corrosion are visible, especially at the discharge booms, junctions, tie bars and the carrying rope of the discharge boom suspension of the A2RsB 4400.
Page 78 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Numerous bent diagonals, tears and large-area corrosion damages can be found at the A2RsB 2500. It shall be considered that under the climatic conditions prevailing in Kosovo there will be an annual reduction in thickness of up to 0.1 mm caused by corrosion. If disregarded, this leads to nicks and/or attenuations of the cross-sections as well as the reduction of the fatigue strength. For a medium- and/or long-term deployment, a complete corrosion protection is therefore urgently necessary for each of the equipment. Also the two-yearly safety inspection of steel construction has not been done accordingly. Therefore some larger unknown defects could develop. This safety inspection shall be made before the detailed plan of maintenance measures will be prepared. Auxiliary structures: Auxiliary structures such as catwalks, stairs, leaders and platforms have partially substantial damages. These damages have no direct influence on the efficiency of the equipment, but they involve dangers for the service personnel. Mechanical engineering The central lubrication plants of the machines (especially of the spreaders A2RsB 4400) are partly not functioning. This is especially dangerous for the area of the travelling gear and the slewing ball bearings. Almost all drives work without any functioning brake system. Crawler base pads are in a bad condition and reached the wear limit. Scrapers are ineffective and/or missing. Until a general mechanical reconstruction for a medium- and/or long-term deployment of these devices continuous restrictions in the equipment availability have to be taken into account which are hardly calculable and incur high running maintenance costs. b) Electrical Part The electrical equipment has been in operation since the 1980ies. It can be characterized as follows: The electrical equipment still in operation does not correspond any longer to the valid European standards. Especially preventive measures for persons and plants in accordance with the standard DIN VDE 0100 are in no way given, e.g.: -
The roofs and windows of the electrical houses are leaky during precipitation (rain and snow).
-
The electrical plants like for example switch cabinet cubicles and electrical operation rooms and terminal boxes of 6 kV-incoming supply and motors are not locked and/or not equipped with safe locking system.
-
The low voltage switch systems do not have shock protection.
-
The medium voltage switch systems are not sufficiently equipped with arc shield.
-
The 6 kV-high-voltage terminal boxes have no sufficient arc voltage protection and they are in a very bad technical repair.
-
Most of the high -voltage protective relays are defective. Page 79 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The medium- and low-voltage systems at the bucket wheel excavators no longer correspond to the valid European Norms and therefore the latest state of the art. In addition, electrical as well as electronic safety equipment, buttons, synchros and local control boxes are worn out and partly no more in function for different reasons (missing spare parts, deficient maintenance). According to rough estimations, more than 40 to 55 % of the sensors are ready for operation. The sensors in the field area are an important prerequisite for indicating safe operating and status condition (monitoring in the excavator operator cabin. The cables and cable routes are in a similar insufficient status like those at the BWE’s. The electrical drive units (starter, motor and thrustor), for example for conveyor belts, hoisting winches, tensioning devices, auxiliary motors and oil pumps, have a very limited availability and reliability. Motors can only be repaired with large expenses. Thrustors with the mechanical part of the brake are mainly not functioning and/or partly not reliable in their function. In line with this the electrical drives are not applicable for a safe operation. Conclusion: For the further application in overburden operation in the Sibovc SW field the spreaders P3B (A2RsB 4400), P4M and P3M (A2RsB 5200) has been selected.
6.1.3 Technical Status of Belt Conveyors and Drive Stations a) Mechanical Part Except the newly reconstructed drive stations D1 and TP1, all other belt conveyor parts are in a deficient condition. The drives at the drive stations (ATS) are very sensitive due to their lifetime. Brake systems and protective covers are missing, lubrication systems are not functioning. Drums are highly worn out and mostly have no rubber coating. Catwalks, stairs, leaders and platforms have partially substantial damages and/or are missing. In the transfer and charging sections sealings are defective and/or missing. Scrapers are partly ineffective which causes considerable contamination. At the bearing steel structure large areas with corrosion are visible. The steel construction of about 20 % of the bearing frame sections is bended. In particular, ties show larger damages due to corrosion. The return rolls are worn to a great extent. Also all discharge and charging chutes have to be adapted at the typical bulk characteristics (green clay) to allow higher loading capacity for conveying overburden. Conveyor belts show considerable defects at the edges and a higher abrasion at the thickness of the rubber protecting layers. Resulting from misalignment and low maintenance, the belt edges are partly worn by more than 150 mm. The average length of belt parts is by far below half of the length for new belts. That means, a number of additional joints (distances partly only 12 - 30 m) have to be provided with all known disadvantages regarding reliability, higher running costs and uncertain plant availability and the knowledge of an average lifetime of two years for could vulcanised belt joints. b) Electrical Part The electrical equipment has been in operation since the 70ies and 80ies. It must be assessed that the condition of electrical equipment (except D1, TP1 and T1) is unsatisfactory on all belt conveyors.
Page 80 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The electrical equipment still in operation does not correspond any longer to the valid European standards. Especially preventive measures for persons and plants in accordance with the standard DIN VDE 0100 are in no way given e.g.: -
The roofs and windows of the electrical houses are leaky during precipitation (rain and snow).
-
The electrical plants like for example switch cabinet cubicles and electrical operation rooms and terminal boxes of 6 kV-incoming supply and motors are not locked and/or not equipped with safe locking system.
-
The low voltage switch systems do not have shock protection.
-
The medium voltage switch systems are not sufficiently equipped with arc shield.
-
The 6 kV-high-voltage terminal boxes have no sufficient arc voltage protection and they are in a very bad technical repair.
-
Most of the high -voltage protective relays are defective.
The medium- and low-voltage systems at the bucket wheel excavators no longer correspond to the valid European Norms and therefore the latest state of the art. In addition, electrical as well as electronic safety equipment, buttons, synchros and local control boxes are worn out and partly no more in function for different reasons (missing spare parts, deficient maintenance). According to rough estimations, more than 40 to 55 % of the sensors are ready for operation. The sensors in the field area are an important prerequisite for indicating safe operating and status condition (monitoring in the excavator operator cabin. The cables and cable routes are mostly in a bad technical status. The electrical drive units (starter, motor and thrustor), for example for conveyor belts, hoisting winches, tensioning devices, auxiliary motors and oil pumps, have a very limited availability and reliability. Motors can only be repaired with large expenses. Thrustors with the mechanical part of the brake are mainly not functioning and/or partly not reliable in their function. In line with this the electrical drives are not applicable for a safe operation. The electrical equipment at the belt tripper car are totally worn out and do not correspond to the valid European standards. Especially preventive measures for persons and plants in accordance with the standard DIN VDE 0100 are in no way given. The electrical equipment on the belt conveyor and the mobile transfer conveyor should be stabilized in short-term within the framework of running maintenance to such an extent that it will be possible to operate the devices with justifiable risk until reconstruction and/or decommissioning.
6.1.4 Technical Status of Belt Wagons a) Mechanical Part Main bearing construction The main bearing structure of the belt wagons is in a bad condition. A number of damages were found at the bearing structure, e. g.: -
Pivot bearings of booms are worn out Page 81 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Twisted pin locks
-
Rusty guy ropes
-
Twisted and/or missing diagonal bars
-
Cracks of 2- and 4-wheel bogies
-
Booms are partly completely out of shape
-
Defective repair of steel construction
Large areas with corrosion are visible. Auxiliary structure: Auxiliary structures such as catwalks, stairs, leaders and platforms have partially substantial damages. These damages have no direct influence on the efficiency of the equipment, but they involve dangers for the service personnel. Mechanical engineering Lubrication systems at the equipment are partly not functioning. Drums and idlers are in a bad mechanical condition. The same applies for crawler base pads and tensioning devices at the belts and travelling gears. Contamination is due to missing scrapers and side sealings. Limit switches are partly ineffective or not in function. Until decommissioning of these devices continuous restrictions in the equipment availability have to be taken into account which are hardly calculable and which incur high running maintenance costs. b) Electrical Part The belt wagons „BRs 1600“ have been in operation since 1979 and/or 1982 and the belt wagons „BRs 1200“ since 1964 and/or 1974. Lifetime of the belt wagons and the imperfect maintenance and repair of the equipment resulted in the unsatisfactory technical condition of the electrical equipment. The building structures of the E-houses are completely worn (roofs, walls, doors), i.e. in case of precipitation like rain or snow they are leaky. The switch systems (MV, LV) and electrical equipment still in operation does not correspond to the valid European standards and involve considerable danger for the operating and service personnel. The electrical equipment on the belt wagons shall be stabilized for safety reasons so that it will be possible to operate these machines with a minimum justifiable risk until decommissioning. Conclusion: For the further application in the Sibovc SW field three belt wagons have been selected, one of them only as stand-by machine. The use of the belt wagons is planned in cooperation with the bucket wheel excavator types SRs 470 / 315 / 400. The main reason for
Page 82 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
this choice is the larger height of the discharge boom of the BRs 1200 compared to the BRs 1600.
6.1.5 Technical Status of Stacker / Reclaimer 6.1.5.1 Stockpile Separation Plant A a) Mechanical Part Reserve assemblies of mechanical engineering are missing for both of the devices Stacker/Reclaimer 1 and 2. In case of assembly breakdown downtimes have to be taken into account until completion of the repair. The main hydraulic equipment lifting the bucket wheel boom is worn and without spare parts. This will have also an influence to the safety and availability of the equipment in the future. For continuing a medium-term operation restrictions in equipment availability and high running costs for the maintenance are to be considered. At the drive stations of the belt conveyors the drives are highly susceptible to failure due to their lifetime. Brake systems and protective covers are missing; lubrication plants are partially not functioning. Drums are highly worn out and mostly have no rubber coating. A lot of idlers are worn. Continuous replacement is necessary. For continuing a medium-term operation restrictions in equipment availability and high running costs for the maintenance are to be considered. Due to their lifetime and continuous repair, crushers and vibration screens are in a condition ready for operation. Reserve assemblies are urgently required to reduce repair times and unexpected downtimes. Owing to their lifetime, a number of material guidance systems is to a great extend worn out; the most frequent occurring damage is leakage at the seam joints and transfer points. Almost all sealings at chutes, transfer points and material guidance systems are insufficiently effective. To continue long-term operation continuous replacement of sealing elements is necessary which have to be standardized according to installation places. A dust reduction system for all transfer points financed by EAR funds is planned at present. b) Electrical Part According to the present planning, the two machines will be in operation until decommissioning of Power Plant „Kosova A“. The condition of the entire E-equipment of both Stacker/Reclaimer is to be assessed unsatisfactory. For a medium-term operation, restrictions in the equipment availability and high running costs for maintenance have to be taken into account. The electrical equipment still in operation does not correspond any longer to the valid European standards. Especially preventive measures for persons and plants in accordance with the standard DIN VDE 0100 are in no way given e.g.: -
The low voltage switch systems do not have shock protection.
-
The medium voltage switch systems are not sufficiently equipped with arc shield.
Page 83 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
The 6 kV-high-voltage terminal boxes have no sufficient arc voltage protection and they are in a very bad technical repair.
-
Most of the high -voltage protective relays are defective.
The medium- and low-voltage systems at the bucket wheel excavators no longer correspond to the valid European Norms and therefore the latest state of the art. In addition, electrical as well as electronic safety equipment, buttons, synchros and local control boxes are worn out and partly no more in function for different reasons (missing spare parts, deficient maintenance). According to rough estimations, more than 40 to 55 % of the sensors are ready for operation. The sensors in the field area are an important prerequisite for indicating safe operating and status condition (monitoring in the excavator operator cabin). The electrical drive units (starter, motor and thrustor), for example for conveyor belts, hoisting winches, tensioning devices, auxiliary motors and oil pumps, have a very limited availability and reliability. Motors can only be repaired with large expenses. Thrustors with the mechanical part of the brake are mainly not functioning and/or partly not reliable in their function. In line with this the electrical drives are not applicable for a safe operation. According to information of personnel there are only rare spare parts available for the converters of slewing- and travelling gear. The E house is partly without isolation and air conditioning system which causes temperature problems during the summer season. The electrical locking system „Excavator-Belt conveyor“ is also in a bad repair (cable drums defective) or partly not functioning. The 6 kV-incoming feeder is needed to be completely overhauled (strongly twisted feeder, cable drums are defective). The electrical equipment on the belt drive station should be stabilized in short-term within the framework of running maintenance to such an extent that it will be possible to operate the devices with justifiable risk until decommissioning. The expenses of Stacker/Reclaimer and belt conveyor system shall be within the following scope: -
Spare parts for MV- and LV-plants (e.g. protection relays, relays, circuit breakers, motors, electronic assemblies)
-
Control devices (e.g. limit switches, buttons, switches, terminal boxes, local control boxes)
-
Thrustors and parts of the mechanical brake
-
Cables and lighting equipment
-
Rehabilitation of the 6 kV-bench terminal boxes
-
Rehabilitation of E-houses at selected areas (e.g. roofs, doors)
6.1.5.2 Stockpile TPP B a) Mechanical Part The Stacker/Reclaimer A received a basic mechanical repair including a complete corrosion protection in 2004 and is in a mechanically good condition. The Stacker/Reclaimer B received a comparable basic mechanical repair including a complete corrosion protection in the year
Page 84 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2005 like equipment A. For both devices a low reserve of building groups of mechanical engineering is missing, so in cases of breakdown of assemblies downtimes have to be taken into account also after completion of the repair. At the drive stations of the belt conveyor plants the drives are strongly trouble-prone due to their lifetime. The drives at the drive stations of the belt conveyor plants are very sensitive due to their lifetime. Brake systems and protective covers are missing, lubrication systems are partly not functioning. Drums are highly worn out and mostly have no rubber coating. A lot of idlers are worn. Continuous replacement is necessary. For a long-term operation it is necessary to systematically replace the belt drives by a new generation. This replacement should be carried out parallel to an electrical reconstruction. Due to their lifetime and continuous repair, crushers are in a condition ready for operation. Reserve assemblies are urgently required to reduce repair times and unexpected downtimes. Owing to their lifetime, a number of material guidance systems is to a great extend worn out; the most frequent occurring damage is leakage at the seam joints and transfer points. Almost all sealings at chutes, transfer points and material guidance systems are insufficiently effective. To continue long-term operation continuous replacement of sealing elements is necessary which have to be standardized according to installation places. A dust reduction system for all transfer points financed by EAR funds is planned at present. b) Electrical Part: The electrical equipment of Stacker/Reclaimer A was completely rehabilitated in 2004 and has been in a good condition since then. A similar measure for rehabilitating the electrical equipment has been implemented for Stacker/Reclaimer B in May 2005. Reserve assemblies are available (stored) for both of the equipment so that in case of electrical failures a direct replacement of defective assemblies can be carried out. The electrical equipment on the belt conveyors are very frequently subject to breakdowns owing to their service life. The electrical equipment on the belt drive station should be stabilized in short-term within the framework of running maintenance to such an extent that it will be possible to operate the devices with justifiable risk until a necessary reconstruction.
6.2 Planned Short-term Rehabilitation Measures In this chapter the rehabilitation measures are described, which are planned for the main equipment in the next few years in the existing mines. The implementation of these measures has to be considered for the scope of refurbishment measures regarding the further application in the Sibovc SW field.
6.2.1 Measures for Excavators The following rehabilitation measures have been finished respectively planned for the next years. The measures of the complete refurbishment regarding the further application in the Sibovc SW field have not been considered in the following table.
Page 85 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type
Measures
Year
Replacement of hoisting ropes wheel boom E9M
Change of ball bearing race and gear rim
SchRs 650
Refurbishment of lubrication plants TG
Done 2005
Replacement of worn out assemblies Replacement of hoisting ropes wheel boom E10M
Change of ball bearing race and gear rim
SchRs 650
Refurbishment of lubrication plants FW
Plan 2006
Replacement of worn out assemblies Complete electrical refurbishment E8M SRs 1300
Complete mechanical overhaul including new uniform bucket wheel drive unit Replacement of worn out assemblies
Planned refurbishment KfW Project
Replacement of bucket wheel drive E9B SRs 1300
Replacement of worn out assemblies Replacement/Renewal of the Main Control Cabin and electrically drive for travel gear drive and slewing drive (with converter)
Done in 2005
Replacement of bucket wheel drive E10B SRs 1300
Replacement of worn out assemblies Replacement/Renewal of the Main Control Cabin and electrically drive for slewing drive (with converter)
Plan 2006
Replacement of bucket wheel drive E8B SRs 1300
Tab.: 6.2-1
Replacement of worn out assemblies Replacement/Renewal of the Main Control Cabin and electrically drive for slewing drive (with converter)
Plan 2006
Measures for Excavators
The expenses for running maintenance per excavator up to a complete reconstruction amount to average 0.380 MEURO per year. Necessary Expenses for Required Rehabilitation of Electrical Equipment A concept including the necessary demand for new technical equipment for the mentioned bucket wheel excavators was planned by the engineering personnel taking into account safety-
Page 86 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
and cost-relevant aspects. The budget should be available for these measures within the midterm period. The selected electrical rehabilitation measures for the excavators represent minimum requirements which are needed till the end of the operation. Spare parts according to priorities for excavators of the type SRs 1300 comprise: -
Spare parts for MV- and LV-plants (e.g. protection relays, relays, circuit breakers, motors, electronic assemblies)
-
Control devices (e.g. limit switches, buttons, switches, terminal boxes, local control boxes)
-
Thrustors and parts of the mechanical brake
-
Cables and lighting equipment
-
Rehabilitation of the cable drums and 6 kV-bench terminal boxes
-
Rehabilitation of E-houses at selected areas (e.g. roofs, doors)
Necessary expenses [related to 3 years]:
max. 0.60 MEURO
Spare parts according to priorities for excavators of the type SchRs 650 comprise: -
Exchange of the PLC Systems from type S 5 on S 7
-
Selected spare parts for MV- and LV-plants
-
Selected spare parts for control units
-
Cables and lighting equipment
-
Motors and thrustors
Necessary expenses:
min. 0.40 MEURO
6.2.2 Measures for Spreader Mechanic The spreaders can be operated until the planned shifting provided that the safety installations and the lubrication plants are maintained step-by-step and the running maintenance is carried out continuously. Based on the results from a safety inspection in 2001, the steel construction of the spreaders P1B, P2B and P3B was repaired and all limit switches were replaced. Except the running maintenance repairs, further necessary measures are not planned at present. The P3B will be refurbished in 2007. The running maintenance expenses per spreader until a complete reconstruction come to average 0.18 MEURO per year. Electric: The deployment of the spreaders in a new mining field requires a complete reconstruction of the electro-technical equipment. For the rest of the deployment of the spreaders until the
Page 87 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
closure of the opencast mines it is reasonable to carry out the necessary running maintenance measures in order to ensure equipment safety and availability to a great extend. The following priorities shall be made when planning the running maintenance: -
Selected spare parts for MV- and LV-switch gears as switchers, contactors, relays,
-
Motors and thrustors (complete),
-
The outdoor plants like lighting, limit switches, buttons and transmitter technology
-
Cables
-
Refurbishment of the electrical houses (as a makeshift).
The budget for the mid-term maintenance should be made available timely. Owing to the very bad technical condition of the steel construction, mechanical engineering and electrical equipment of this equipment class it is recommended to carry out the necessary running maintenance measures in order to ensure equipment safety and availability to a great extend. The budget for the spreaders shall be applied for as follows: -
Outside facilities
0.05 MEURO
-
Low-voltage plant
0.09 MEURO
-
High-voltage plant
0.10 MEURO
-
Slewing and travelling gear
0.08 MEURO
Necessary Expenses [related to 5 years]:
max. 0.32 MEURO.
6.2.3 Measures for Belt Conveyors and Drive Stations Mechanic: In 2004, the drive stations D1 and TP1 were mechanically repaired within the framework of a complete electrical reconstruction. Station T1 was repaired in April 2005. These mechanical repairs are only limited to repair of catwalks and the replacement of worn out mechanical assemblies. The rehabilitation of the mechanical engineering by drives of the new generation is not planned. Repairs at all the other stations and belt conveyor systems are limited to the running repairs. The running maintenance expenditures per 2,000 m conveying distance are on the average 0.28 MEURO per year. The refurbishment of a complete overburden line is planned for 2007 and includes three (3) belt conveyors of total 3 kilometres length, three (3) drive stations belt width 1,600 mm, the Excavator E10B and the Spreader P3B. The financing of 18 Million Euro will be done by European Agency for Reconstruction (15 MEURO and KTA 3 MEURO). Electric: For the rest of the deployment of the belt conveyors including the mobile transfer conveyor until the closure of the opencast mines it is recommended to carry out the necessary running maintenance measures in order to ensure the demanded reliability. The following priorities shall be made when planning the running maintenance:
Page 88 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Motors and thrustors (complete), see above listed
-
The outdoor plants like lighting, limit switches, buttons and transmitter technology
-
Refurbishment of the electrical houses (as makeshift).
A concept including the necessary demand for new technical equipment for the belt conveyors including the mobile transfer conveyor was planned for the mid-term period. Necessary expenses [related to 5 years]:
0.60 MEURO.
The budget for the necessary expenses of the mentioned equipment including the mobile transfer conveyor shall be applied for as follows: -
Outside facilities
0.08 MEURO
-
Low-voltage plant
0.12 MEURO
-
High-voltage plant
0.22 MEURO
-
Slewing and travelling gear
0.20 MEURO
6.2.4 Measures for Belt Wagons Mechanic Continuous maintenance is required to operate belt wagons until their decommissioning. Missing assemblies shall be dismounted from decommissioned devices and rehabilitated. Maintenance concentrates on removing damages at the steel construction, repair of lubrication plants and scraper system as well as replacement of crawler base pads. Two of the belt wagons in the Bardh mine were repaired as a result from a safety inspection in 2001. The running maintenance expenditures per belt wagon come to average 0.07 MEURO per year. Electric A concept including the necessary demand for new technical equipment for the belt wagons has been planned (please see Mid-Term Mining Plan). The budget for the belt wagons shall amount to the following: Necessary expenses [related to 5 years]:
0.13 MEURO.
6.2.5 Measures for Stacker / Reclaimer Till end of 2005 both of the Stacker/Reclaimer in Separation Plant B were rehabilitated. These measures include a basic mechanical maintenance including a complete corrosion protection and a complete electrical refurbishment. By means of these measures the equipment is in a good mechanical and electrical condition. For both of the Stacker/Reclaimer A and Stacker/Reclaimer B in Separation Plant A and B as well as the belt conveyor system reserve assemblies for the mechanical and electrical
Page 89 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
engineering are missing. Downtimes have to be taken into account in case of failure of assemblies which will last until completion of repair. The running maintenance expenses will amount to ca. 0.48 MEURO per year for Separation Plant A and 0.35 MEURO per year for Separation Plant B. The rehabilitation of the electrical equipment on the Stacker/Reclaimers in the Separation Plant A belongs to maintenance measures which are important in order to ensure equipment safety and availability to a great extent. A concept including the necessary demand for new technical equipment for the Stacker/Reclaimer shall be planned by the engineering personnel taking into account safetyand cost-relevant aspects. The planning document is to be provided until June 2006. The budget should be available before December 2007. The scope of expenditures for the Stacker/Reclaimer shall comprise the following: -
Spare parts for MV- and LV-plants (e.g. protection relays, relays, circuit breakers, motors, electronic assemblies)
-
Control devices (e.g. limit switches, buttons, switches, terminal boxes, local control boxes)
-
Thrustors and parts of the mechanical brake
-
Cables and lighting equipment
-
Rehabilitation of the 6 kV-bench terminal boxes
-
Motors
Necessary Expenses [related to 5 years]:
0.40 MEURO.
The scope of expenditures for the belt conveyor plants shall comprise the following: -
Spare parts for MV- and LV-plants (e.g. protection relays, relays, circuit breakers, motors, electronic assemblies)
-
Control devices (e.g. limit switches, buttons, switches, terminal boxes, local control boxes)
-
Thrustors and parts of the mechanical brake
-
Cables and lighting equipment
-
Rehabilitation of the 6 kV-bench terminal boxes
-
Motors
Necessary Expenses [related to 5 years]:
0.80 MEURO.
A dust reduction system for all transfer points to be financed by EAR is present under installation (year 2006). After decommissioning of Power Plant A in the future the dust reduction system can be dismounted and installed then at other necessary transfer points.
Page 90 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6.3 Planned Refurbishment Measures for Sibovc SW Field SRs 1300 and SchRs 650 All bucket wheel excavators of the size classes SRs 1300 and SchRs 650 can be taken into consideration for a further operation in the follow-up field due to their condition and capacity parameters. Within the framework of a complex repair the following measures have to be implemented (please see table below). Type
Measures
Year
Complete corrosion protection; Reconstruction bucket wheel head; E9M complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); SchRs 650 Replacement of travel gear units; Rehabilitation of steel construction, scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system; Complete corrosion protection; Reconstruction bucket wheel head; E10M complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); SchRs 650 Replacement of travel gear units; Rehabilitation of steel construction, scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system; Complete corrosion protection; Reconstruction bucket wheel head; E8M complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); SRs 1300 Replacement ball bearing race and gear rim of excavators superstructure; Rehabilitation of steel construction and scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system; Complete corrosion protection; complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); E9B Replacement ball bearing race and gear rim of excavators superstructure; SRs 1300 Rehabilitation of steel construction and scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system; Complete corrosion protection; complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); E10B Replacement ball bearing race and gear rim of excavators superstructure; SRs 1300 Rehabilitation of steel construction and scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system; Complete corrosion protection E8B complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable (reel); SRs 1300 Rehabilitation of steel construction and scraper- and sealing systems and belt conveyor system Tab.: 6.3-1
I/2008 up to IV/2008
I/2009 up to IV/2009
III/2007 up to II/2008
III/2009 up to II/2010 III/2007 up to II/2008 II/2011 up to II/2012
Measures for Main Excavators for Sibovc SW
SRs 470 / 400 and SRs 315 Page 91 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The bucket wheel excavators SRs 470, SRs 400 and SRs 315 are hardly applicable as main mine equipment for a long-term operation. The two-yearly safety inspection of steel construction has not been done accordingly. Therefore some larger unknown defects could develop. This safety inspection shall be realized before the detailed plan of maintenance measures will be prepared. Owing to existing damages at the steel construction and the condition of the mechanical and electrical assemblies, respectively, these excavators shall be decommissioned step-by-step until 2012. The excavators E5M, E7M and E1B may be used in sub benches regarding as floating machine. Belt Wagon Only three belt wagons of the type BRs 1200 are planned for operation in the Sibovc SW field. Belt Conveyor Because of the output capacities of the heavy opencast mine machines, only lines with 1,600 or 1,800 mm belt width will be used in the new mine. To ensure the necessary availability of the plants, the following are the minimum measures to be carried out: -
Complete reconstruction of the drive stations as there are electrical equipment, corrosion protection, steel construction, gears and drums and discharge chutes to adapt these to the typical bulk characteristics (green clay) to allow higher loading capacity for conveying overburden
-
Replacement and/or repair of defective frame sections using available reserves
-
Replacement of ca. 50 % of the idlers superstructure
-
Replacement of ca. 70 % of the idlers substructure
-
Replacement of 100 % of the belts
-
Complete electrical and mechanical reconstruction of the feeding hopper car;
-
Complete electrical and mechanical reconstruction of the belt tripper car ;
Spreader It is intended to use only three spreaders with a capacity of 4400 / 5200 lcm/h in the new mine. The other spreaders can be scrapped. Before the spreaders are used in Sibovc, they have to be rehabilitated with the following key issues: -
Complete electrical reconstruction
-
Complete corrosion protection
-
Steel construction refurbishment
-
Refurbishment of travelling gears
-
Overhaul of conveyor systems
-
Replacement of belt cleaner and sealing systems
Page 92 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Complete electrical reconstruction including crawler-mounted cable reel car
6.4 Time Schedule for Rehabilitation Measures The next figure illustrates a schematic rehabilitation milestone plan for an excavator of the size SRs 1300. The decisive element when rehabilitating an equipment line is the excavator. All other rehabilitations, i.e. spreader and belt conveyor system, can be realised in shorter periods. As illustrated in the below figure a period of ca. 35 months will be required for one equipment line starting from the KEK-budget-plan until to capacity operation of the rehabilitated plant. The downtime of the equipment for the implementation of the measures is ca. 9 months. The remaining time is needed for the preparatory measures (f. e. preparation of technical specifications, tendering, contract negotiations and engineering). The transfer from the existing opencast mine to the Sibovc SW mine is a complex technical process which is mainly influenced by the following factors: -
Coal production in the existing mine has to be guaranteed according to the aims. Apart from the coal production overburden operation has to be developed. It shall be considered here, that not only exposure overburden has to be removed but also overburden from the widening up of the rim slop systems (please see Mid Term Plan for existing Coal Mines). These widening operations are urgently required for the safe continuation of the opencast mine operation. A delay in time for these works and/or failure in meeting the planned performance targets will automatically lead to delayed release dates for the machines. A basic precondition for the envisaged performance level of the main equipment within the mid term period is the provision of the necessary investments for the required maintenance measures.
-
To secure coal production from the Sibovc SW mine according to the time schedule the selected equipment shall be put into operation in the new mine as soon as possible. Here also, a delay directly affects the coal production. Before commissioning a complex rehabilitation of the main equipment will become necessary to allow the performance targets (partly more than 4 mbcm/a per line in the overburden operation).
This means that only a limited period of time will be available for the required refurbishment measures. The following figure illustrates the rehabilitation schedule for the single lines. It can be seen that the 35 month long total duration of the refurbishment process cannot be ensured for all lines. In those cases time has to be shortened especially for the preparatory processes. Otherwise more costly compensations will result due to a delayed commissioning of the main equipment in the Sibovc field – provided that the planned coal output is ensured.
Page 93 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
X-1 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
X 8
9 10 11 12
1
2
3
4
5
6
X+1 7
8
9 10 11 12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
X+2 8
9 10 11 12
KEK Budget Plan KEK or Donor Budget Approval TOR Consultant Tender Consultant Contract Sign Consultant Technical Specifications Inviatation to Bid Tender Contract Sign Contractor Engineering Ordering of Material and Delivery Decommissionning Transport to Erection Yard, Cleaning Repair of Steel Construction Disassembly of electrical and mechanical Components Corrosion Protection Mechanical and electrical Installations Functional Tests Transport to Site of Operation Performance Test Commissionning regular Operation
Fig.: 6.4-1
Schematic BWE-Rehabilitation Milestone Plan
Page 94 of 150
9 month standstill
1
2
3
4
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2006 I
II
2007 III
IV
I
II
2008 III
IV
I
E 10B + P3B + 1.6m Conv.
II
2009 III
IV
I
II
2010 III
IV
I
II
2011 III
IV
I
II
2012 III
IV
I
II
III
IV
T
E 9M + P 4M + 1.8m Conv.
T
E 10M + P3M + 1.8m Conv.
T T
E 5M BRs 1200
T T
E 8M
T
E 9B + 1.6m Conv.
T
E 8B + 1.6m Conv. E 7M
T
BRs 1200
T
Fig.: 6.4-2
Terms of Reference
Specification
Rehabilitation
Corrosion Protection
Tendering T Transport
Linewise Refurbishment Activities for Main Equipment
Page 95 of 150
Engineering Commissionning
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6.5 Investment and Cost Calculation of Main Mine Equipment The following table lists a survey of excavators, spreaders and conveyor belts which are planned to operate in Sibovc SW. BWE E10B SRs 1300 E10M SchRs 650 E9M SchRs 650 E5M SRs 470 E8M SRs1300 E9B SRs 1300 E8B SRs 1300 E7M SRs 400 E1B SRs 315 Belt Wagon 1st BRs 1200 2nd BRs 1200 3rd BRs 1200 Spreader P3B A2RsB 4400 P3M A2RsB 5200 P4M A2RsB 5200 Stacker / Reclaimer MK 1 (TUSLA) MK 2 (TUSLA) MK A (MAN TAKRAF) MK B (MAN TAKRAF) Belt Conveyor System Drive Stations (up to 2012) Belt Conveyor Lines [km] Tab.: 6.5-1
Overburden 4 1 1 1 1
Coal 4
Stockpile -
Other/Res. 1
-
1 1
1 -
1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1
3 1 1 1 -
-
-
-
12 12 14.3
20 20 18.9
4 1 1 1 1 14 14 4.5
-
-
Total 9 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 46 46 37.7
Survey of Mine Equipment
Page 96 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Investment BWE
52.09 6.99 8.7 7.7 3.5 7.2 7.5 7.5 3.0
E10B SRs 1300 E10M SchRs 650 E9M SchRs 650 E5M SRs 470 E8M SRs1300 E9B SRs 1300 E8B SRs 1300 E7M SRs 400 E1B SRs 315 Belt Wagon 1st BRs 1200 2nd BRs 1200 3rd BRs 1200 Spreader P3B A2RsB 4400 P3M A2RsB 5200 P4M A2RsB 5200 Stacker / Reclaimer MK 1+2 (TUSLA) MK A+B (MAN TAKRAF) Belt Conveyor System Drive Stations Belt Conveyor Lines Total
1) 3.0 1.5 1.5 1) 14.49 4.39 4.8 5.3 7.4 4.7 2.7 81.4 41.04 40.36 158.38
1) Standby machines: maintenance covered by opex
Tab.: 6.5-2
Amount for Refurbishment and Investment
The elaboration of technical specification is included in the prices above. The table below presents the expenditures required for the new mine. Year Investment/Refurbish
‘06 0.6
‘07 28.62
‘08 45.47
‘09 47.8
‘10 11.91
‘11 16.19
‘12 7.79
SUM 158.3
Refurbishment Plant Drive Stations Belt Conveyor Lines
Tab.: 6.5-3
Yearwise Cost for Refurbishment and Investments in MEURO
Page 97 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The subdivision of costs is described in the following tables. No.
Measure
[MEURO]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 8.1 8.2 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Corrosion protection Steel construction Hoisting drive and disc brake (bucket wheel boom) Belt conveyors (belts, gearboxes, drive-drums, side boards) Drive units for travelling drives (6 pieces) switch gears [MV; LV; transformer; battery plant] PLC system and interlocking system Variable frequency drives all auxiliary drives with motors (> 11kW) bucket wheel drive with motor Main belt drives in conventionally technique with "dual principle" Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Refurbishment the e-rooms or partly with new container Operator cabin (2x) Crawler-mounted cable drum [M+E] Tripper car [M+E] Miscellaneous Technical specification Total
0.750 0.700 0.400 0.700 0.550 0.450 0.420 0.700 0.250 0.100 0.400 0.400 0.080 0.450 0.250 0.700 0.200 7.5 *
* E10B only 7.00 MEURO
Tab.: 6.5-4
Costs for E8B, E9B and E10B
No.
Measure
[MEURO]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 9.1 9.2 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Corrosion protection Steel Construction Hoisting drive and disc brake (bucket wheel boom) Belt conveyors (belts, gearboxes, drive-drums, side boards) New bucket wheel ring Bucket wheel gearbox (inclusive motor) Switch gears [MV; LV; transformer; battery plant] PLC system and interlocking system Variable frequency drives all auxiliary drives with motors (> 11kW) bucket wheel drive with motor Main belt drives in conventionally technique with "dual principle" Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Refurbishment the e-rooms or partly with new container Operator cabin (2x) Crawler-mounted cable drum [M+E] Tripper car [M+E] Miscellaneous Technical Specification Total
0.650 0.500 0.350 0.600 0.190 1.030 0.410 0.380
Tab.: 6.5-5
0.630 0.190 0.170 0.360 0.280 0.160 0.400 0.200 0.500 0.2 7.2
Costs for E8M
Page 98 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
No.
Measure
[MEURO]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 9.1 9.2 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
New bucket wheel head Corrosion protection Steel Construction Belt conveyors (belts, gearboxes, drive-drums, side boards) Drive units for travelling drives (6 pieces) New bucket wheel Switch gears [MV; LV; transformer; battery plant] PLC system and interlocking system Variable frequency drives all auxiliary drives with motors (> 11kW) bucket wheel drive with motor Main belt drives in conventionally technique with "dual principle" Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Refurbishment the e-rooms or partly with new container Operator cabin (2x) Bracket-type cable drum (reel) [complete M+E] Tripper car [complete M+E] Miscellaneous Technical Specification Total
1.200 0.800 0.550 0.700 0.550 0.200 0.500 0.400 0.700 0.250 0.250 0.400 0.300 0.200 0.250 0.250 0.800 0.400 8.7 *
* E9M only 7.7 MEURO
Tab.: 6.5-6
Costs for E9M and E10M
No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Measure
[MEURO]
Steel Construction Belt conveyors (belts, gearboxes, drive-drums, side boards) Drive units for travelling drives (2 pieces) Electrical System Switch gear system [LV] PLC system Drive units conventionally technique Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Miscellaneous Total
0.180 0.300 0.250 0.140 0.150 0.100 0.100 0.080 0.200 1.5
Tab.: 6.5-7
Costs for Belt Wagons
Page 99 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
No.
Measure
[MEURO]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Complete corrosion protection Steel construction refurbishment Refurbishment of travelling gears Overhaul of conveyor systems Replacement of belt cleaner and sealing systems Switch gears [MV; LV; transformer; battery plant] PLC system and interlocking system Variable frequency drives: all auxiliary drives with motors (> 11kW) Main belt drives in conventionally technique with "dual principle" Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Refurbishment the e-rooms or partly with new container Crawler-mounted cable drum (reel) [M+E] Operator cabins (2x) Miscellaneous Total
0.450 0.300 0.250 0.650 0.200 0.400 0.400 0.550 0.300 0.400 0.300 0.400 0.200 0.500 5.3 *
* P3B only 4.39 MEURO and P3M only 4.8 MEURO
Tab.: 6.5-8
Costs for Spreader
No.
Measure
[MEURO]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Steel Construction Corrosion Protection Travelling drives Slewing drives Lubrication and hydraulic system Switch gears [MV; LV; transformer; battery plant] PLC system and interlocking system Variable frequency drives: all auxiliary drives with motors (> 11kW) Main belt drives in conventionally technique with "dual principle" Outdoor installation [lighting system; sensors; cable and run; button; ...] Refurbishment the e-rooms or partly with new container Bracket-type cable drum (spiral) [complete m+e] (for 6kV and control cable) Operator cabins (2x) Miscellaneous Technical Specification Total
0.100 0.090 0.100 0.100 0.090 0.300 0.200 0.200 0.300 0.300 0.140 0.100 0.080 0.200 0.050 2.35
Tab.: 6.5-9
Costs for Stacker / Reclaimer TPP A
Page 100 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Measure Complete electrical Reconstruction Steel Construction Corrosion Protection Travelling drives Slewing drives Lubrication and hydraulic system Miscellaneous Technical Specification Total
Tab.: 6.5-10
[MEURO] 0.550 0.100 0.100 0.150 0.150 0.100 0.150 0.05 1.35
Costs for Stacker / Reclaimer TPP B
Page 101 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7 Power Supply System and Electrical Equipment 7.1 Future Energy Demand 2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
Coal
mt
0
0
0
3.40
6.00
9.00
9.00
Overburden by Main Equipment
mbcm
0
1.5
5.8
8.48
12.03
11.57
13.23
Number of Excavators
piece
0
2
5
7
7
9
9
Number of Spreaders
piece
0
2
3
3
3
3
3
Number of Drive Stations
piece
0
Tab.: 7.1-1
Planned Requirements of Technological Systems
The 110/35/6 kV Power Substation "Sibovc" shall guarantee a safe supply of electric energy for the described mining concept for Sibovc SW. In the Sibovc mine a large part of the currently available mining equipment will be reused. It is important to consider that the equipment shall be rehabilitated and that the future annual capacity will be much higher than in the present Mirash and Bard mines. The following will be supplied in the Sibovc SW opencast mine: a) Overburden operation in three main overburden levels with the following equipment: -
1 excavator SRs 1300
-
2 excavator SchRs 650
-
1 excavator SRs 470
-
1 belt wagon BRs 1200
-
2 spreader A2Rs B 5200
-
1 spreader A2Rs B 4400
-
1 dragline 10/70
b) Coal operation in three main levels with the following equipment: -
3 excavators SRs 1300
-
1 excavator SRs 400
-
1 belt wagon BRs 1200
-
1 excavator SRs 315 as float machine
Page 102 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
c) Overburden belt conveyor system -
3 Systems
d) Coal belt conveyor system (benches and long-distance conveyors) -
3 Systems on benches including 2 inclined conveyors and 2 connecting conveyors
-
2 long distance conveyor to TPP A and B
e) Mine Office -
New Office Buildings
f) Workshop and Warehouse -
Substitution for necessary electrical power supply in the territory of Bardh Mine.
Page 103 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The required installed power for the opencast mine systems are estimated as following: Operating Time
Installed Power per Machine
Year
kW
E7M SRs 470
2012 – 2024
1,200
1
E8B SRs 1300
2012 – 2024
2,690
1
5,000
E9B SRs 1300
2010 – 2024
2,690
1
5,000
E8M SRs 1300
2009 – 2024
2,770
1
5,000
E1B SRs 315
2010 - 2024
840
1
3,000
P4M A2Rs B-5200
2008 – 2024
1,600
1
5,000
P3B A2Rs B-4400
2008 – 2024
1,400
1
5,000
P3M A2Rs B-5200
2009 – 2024
1,600
1
5,000
E5M SRs 470
2009 – 2024
1,200
1
5,000
E9M SchRs 650
2008 – 2024
2,700
1
5,000
E10M SchRs 650
2009 – 2024
2,860
1
5,000
E10B SRs 1300
2008 – 2024
2,690
1
5,000
Belt Conveyor Systems [1800]
2008 – 2024
16,200 (1,800)
9
5,000
Belt Conveyor Systems [1600 ]
2008 – 2024
21,420 (1,260)
17
5,000
ESch 10/70
2009 – 2024
1,500
1
4,000
Mine Office
2008 – 2024
250
1
3,500
Workshop
2008 – 2024
500
1
6,000
Warehouse
2008 – 2024
200
1
4,000
Other
2010 – 2024
250
1
4,000
Description
Tab.: 7.1-2
Number of Equipment
Operating Hours
Required Installed Capacity
The long-term demand of installed electric energy is about 64 MW.
Page 104 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.2 Measures and Time Schedule Summarizing, the following measures for a 110/35/6 kV Power Substation are assumed: The capital expenditures for the 110/35 kV Power Substation "Sibovc" [or "Palaj" or "Hade" possibly referred to] including the necessary demand for energy for the opencast mine system "Sibovc" shall be planned, designed and erected including commissioning tests. The punctual provision of the power substations (availability and reliability) will be of highest priority during the investment activity for the new opencast mine system. The investment activity for the power substation shall be organized in three phases as follows: 1. Phase [period 2007 / 2008] Contents of the planning phase and tender description are: -
planning,
-
technical specification and tendering,
-
announcement,
-
offer and evaluation phase and
-
contractual agreement with contract signature till end of November 2007
The following main items should be considered during the planning and in the tender description of the power substation: 1.
Territorial arrangement and local development as: -
Location;
-
Road connection;
-
Public water supply;
-
Drainage of rainwater;
-
Drainage;
-
Fire protection;
-
Water protection;
-
Noise protection
-
Fencing of the area.
2.
Industrial building -
Industrial building with a floorspace (ca):
length of 24,000 mm; width of 12,000 mm and height of 4,200 mm.
-
The industrial building shall contain
Page 105 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6 kV switchgear room of (17x12) m, control room of (6.5x 4.2) m, anteroom and sanitary room of (6.5x2,1) m, engineering room of (6.5x2.7) m, battery room of (6.5x3) m. -
The windows should be arranged in a height of 2 m (above the wall).
-
Complete equipment of the building with sanitary facilities and electrical equipment
3.
Necessary electrical equipment for power substation:
3.1
110 kV outdoor switchgear -
110 kV overhead line (powered from Power Plant B);
-
Disposition of the outdoor switchgear with * power switch’s, * current and voltage transformer’s, * disconnector, * supporting insulators, * over-voltage arresters.
-
110 kV Earth-Fault Current Compensation Plant * 110 kV Earth-fault current quenching coil, * neutral point plant.
3.2
35 kV outdoor switchgear -
Disposition of the outdoor switchgear with * power switch’s, * current and voltage transformer’s, * disconnector, * supporting insulators, * over-voltage arresters.
-
35 kV Earth-Fault Current Compensation Plant * 35 kV Earth-fault current quenching coil, * neutral point plant.
3.3
6 kV indoor plant * SF6-insulated, * operator panel on switch panel,
Page 106 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
* interlocking function, * secondary devices, 3.4
6 kV Earth-Fault Current Compensation Plant * 110 kV Earth-fault current quenching coil, * neutral point plant with disconnector, insulated support and cable;
3.5
110/35 kV, 35 MVA transformer (3), 35/6 kV, 14 MVAtTransformer (4), 35/6 kV, 10 MVA transformer (5) and 35/0,4 kV/ 1,2 kVAtTransformer (1)
3.6
Station Service Plant [internal consumption] -
35/0,4 kV, 400 kVA transformer,
-
0,4 kV switchgear plant,
-
230V DC current plant,
-
230V DC switchgear plant,
-
battery plant with inverter modules.
3.7
Lightning Protection System and Grounding
3.8
Power System Management, Control and Protection
3.9
Protecting Device and Measurement
3.10
Counting of Electrical Energy
-
110 kV registering
-
30 kV registering,
-
6 kV registering.
-
central energy management
3.11
Cable and Lines
3.12
Supplementary Plants
-
air conditioning system
-
fire alarm system,
-
lighting systems (outside and inside),
Page 107 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Telecommunication,
-
Television monitoring.
2. Phase [period 2008 / 2009] Engineering design and implementation phase containing the scope as follow: A) Implementation of -
site development and earthworks including enclosure and building of roads,
-
construction and building “power substation�,
B) Supply, Erection and Commissioning of Electrical Equipment -
110 kV overhead line (1. Station),
-
110/35 kV transformer including with 110 kV outdoors plants (two stations),
-
35/6 kV transformer including with 35 kV outdoors plants (four stations),
-
internal consumption plants,
-
6 kV switchgear systems,
C) Earthworks for 6 kV cable routes, supply of steel rack, 6 kV bench cable including 4 pieces static cable reels. 3. Phase [period of time 2009/2011] Completion of electrical equipment according to the technological development of the opencast mine: -
110/35 kV transformer including with 110 kV outdoors plants,
-
35/6 kV transformer including with 35 kV outdoors plants,
-
6 kV switch gear systems,
-
6 kV bench switch gears,
-
6 kV bench cable
-
static cable reels
Page 108 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW 2007 I
II
2008 III
IV
I
II
2009 III
IV
I
II
2010 III
IV
I
II
2011 III
IV
I
II
Central Remote Control System Coal Quality Management System Power Supply System
Specification
Fig.: 7.2-1
Tendering
Engineering and Completion
Time Schedule for Power Supply and Control System
An overview of the energy distribution system for the new mine Sibovc SW is shown in the figure below:
Page 109 of 150
III
IV
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2x 110 kV
2x110/35kV, 35MVA
2x110/35kV, 35 MVA reserve
4x35/6kV, 14MVA
35/6kV, 10 MVA
6kV Switchgear [in SF6-technique]
switchgear room within the building
overburden
1
2
Internal consumption for power substation
6kV Switchgear [in SF6-technique]
coal extraction
6kV outgoing feeder
Fig.: 7.2-2
3x35/6kV, 10MVA
0,4 kV utgoing feeder for mine office, warehouse, workshop
6kV outgoing feeder
3
1
110/35 kV Power Substation “Sibovc” with 6 kV Distribution System
Page 110 of 150
2
3
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-3
6 kV Power Supply – Coal Extraction
Page 111 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-4
6 kV Power Supply – Overburden Removal
Page 112 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.3 Investments for Power Supply System The below table shows the year-wise investment: MEURO
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Total
Investments for Power Supply
0.3
7.0
1.6
1.8
1.0
11.7
1.Phase, see description above
0.3
2. Phase, see description above 3. Phase, see description above Tab.: 7.3-1
0.3 7.0
7.0 1.6
1.8
1.0
4.4
Investments for Power Supply
Page 113 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
8 Auxiliary Equipment 8.1 Assessment of Technical Status in Existing Mine A complete auxiliary equipment fleet is available in the existing mine. In 2000/2001 and 2004 an extensive rehabilitation of the auxiliary equipment fleet was realized with the help of KfW and EAR funds. Some of the old equipment have been commissioned in the 80’s and is more than 20 years old. Nevertheless, the predominant part of the auxiliary equipment is in a strong technical status. From 2007 overburden production in the existing mine will considerably decline. First overburden lines will be put out of operation; the number of operation points will be reduced. In the existing mine, coal production will go on with full capacity until 2008 and in 2009 and 2011 with reduced capacity. Parallel with the decline in capacity, a part of the auxiliary equipment can be put out of operation. At the time of decommissioning a part of the auxiliary equipment will have exceeded its normative service life. Prolongation of the normative service life is not recommended due to the difficult conditions and the rather poor maintenance. Moreover, the further use of selected auxiliary equipment is intended for recultivation, securing and wrapping measures over the year 2011. Substitute investments for worn out auxiliary devices are not planned within the medium-term planning. The result is, that a take-over of auxiliary equipment from the existing fleet for a further use in the Sibovc mine will not be possible or only in to limited extent. The further plans for the Sibovc mine assume a complete new auxiliary equipment fleet.
8.2 Demand of Auxiliary Equipment 8.2.1 Maximal Demand of Auxiliary Equipment For ensuring the production processes in the pit, a whole number of auxiliary machines and equipment are necessary. The auxiliary equipment is attached to the different operational sections and operated in one up to three shift operation according to requirement. The following table illustrates the optimal stock on auxiliary equipment in case of maximum production. The given engine performance and number of equipment is based on the special application condition in the existing mines and the experiences from other mines with comparable deposit properties.
Page 114 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type Dozer Pipelayer Wheel Dozer Wheel Loader 17t Wheel Loader Excavator Loader Telescope Crane 90t Telescope Crane 60t Telescope Crane 45t Telescope Crane 30t Forklift 2t Forklift 5t Truck payload 12t, 3-axle Truck with hydraulic crane Truck with lifting Platform Dump Truck Cable reel Trailer Low Bed Trailer Fuel Truck Lubrication Truck Tractor Hydraulic Backhoe (crawler) Hydraulic Backhoe (wheel) Grader Trench Cutter Single Drum Roller Jeep Pick-up Jeep 12 seats Personnel Transporters (36 seats) Minibus Ambulance Fire Fighting Truck Drilling Machine Workshop Container Mobile Workshop Mobile Lightings Winding Support Drum Vulcanisation Set Diesel Generator Water Truck Spraying Galleries Pumps
Tab.: 8.2-1
[ kW ] 230 - 300 180 250 180 120
Overb. 7 2 2 1
340 270 270 200
130 130 230
1
60t 180
1 1
200 180 - 200
1 1 1 2
160
1
Number of auxiliary Equipment Coal Stockp Drain. Maint. 6 4 2 2 2 2 1 3 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 1 1 4 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 2
150 100 75 100 140
1 3 2 1 4 1 2 1 3
3 2 1 3 1
0.5
2 1
2 1
7 9
1
3
2 1 4 15
1 2 3 1 2 2
total 17 4 2 6 2 3 1 1 1 3 2 2 3 7 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 5 2 2 2 1 17 15 2 8 2 2 1 3 1 2 6 1 2 4 1 4 15
Number of Auxiliary Equipment
Page 115 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The calculation of the auxiliary equipment fleet bases on the following: Dozers
1 per working level in overburden, coal and dumping operation 4 for the stockpiles 2 for special works 2 as reserve in case of repair measures (corresponds 10% of fleet)
For levelling work which will not be carried out continuously it is not intended to use dozers. Such peak capacities shall be put out to tender and awarded to contractors for cost reasons (single lots and/or framework contracts). Personnel Transporters
2 for excavation site overburden 2 for excavation site coal 2 for dumping site and recultivation 1 for dewatering 1 as reserve in case of repair measures or breakdowns
In addition to these big personnel transporters (36 seats) smaller jeeps and microbuses are foreseen for the shift change and for the different departments for transportation. 4-WheelDrive is urgent necessary for all cars and busses under consideration of the heavy material properties particular in overburden operation.
8.2.2 Yearwise Development of Auxiliary Equipment Fleet The establishment of the auxiliary equipment fleet will be adjusted to the development of capacity in the opencast mine. The first auxiliary machines have to be put in operation already before the heavy-duty equipment will start work to prepare their starting position. In 2012, the full equipment capacity will be installed both in the overburden- and coal operation. This means that until this date the auxiliary equipment fleet shall be completed. From this period, a constant auxiliary equipment fleet will be in operation. The following table shows the development of the auxiliary equipment fleet up to a maximum size.
Page 116 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type Coal Output [mt] Overburden [mbcm] Dozer Pipelayer Wheel Dozer Wheel Loader 17t Wheel Loader Excavator Loader Telescope Crane 90t Telescope Crane 60t Telescope Crane 45t Telescope Crane 30t Forklift 2t Forklift 5t Truck payload 12t, 3-axle Truck with hydraulic crane Truck with lifting Platform Dump Truck Cable reel Trailer Low Bed Trailer Fuel Truck Lubrication Truck Tractor Hydraulic Backhoe (crawler) Hydraulic Backhoe (wheel) Grader Trench Cutter Single Drum Roller Jeep Pick-up Jeep (12 seats) Personnel Transporters (36 seats)
Minibus Ambulance Fire Fighting Truck Drilling Machine Workshop Container Mobile Workshop Mobile Lightings Winding Support Drum Vulcanisation Set Diesel Generator Water Truck Spraying Galleries Pumps Tab.: 8.2-2
2008
2009
2.56 3 1
6.40 9 2 1 3 1 2
1 0 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 2
1 2 1 1 2 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1
9 8 1 4 1 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 2
1 10
2 12
1 1 1
2010 3.4 9.09 15 4 2 5 2 3 1 1 1 3 2 2 3 6 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 5 2 2 2 1 15 13 2 7 2 2 1 3 1 2 5 1 2 4 1 4 13
2011 6.0 12.24 15 4 2 5 2 3 1 1 1 3 2 2 3 6 2 2 1 1 2 1 2 5 2 2 2 1 15 13 2 7 2 2 1 3 1 2 5 1 2 4 1 4 13
2012 9.0 11.88 17 4 2 6 2 3 1 1 1 3 2 2 3 7 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 5 2 2 2 1 17 15 2 8 2 2 1 3 1 2 6 1 2 4 1 4 15
Number of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2012
The mobile auxiliary equipment has a smaller economic service life compared to the main equipment. Depending on the type of equipment and the conditions of use this time varies between 3 and 12 years. Partly, longer service life may also be possible. Thereafter, the
Page 117 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
auxiliary equipment is technically worn out and shall be replaced. When using the equipment it shall be assumed that a new and technically improved generation may be available on the market. A technical specification of these equipments for the planning of Sibovc seems to be not useful. The following service life was assumed for the single auxiliary equipment classes: -
Pumps
3 Years
-
Cars and Busses
6 Years
-
Ancillary Equipment
6 Years
-
Dozer, Wheel Loader, Trucks
6 Years
-
Special Trucks, Drilling Machine
8 Years
-
Backhoes, Grader
8 Years
-
Temporarily used Equipment
10 – 20 Years
The following table illustrates the number of the auxiliary equipment to be purchased annually. The bold number show the initial purchased machine up to completion of the auxiliary equipment fleet; the other numbers (from 2013) are replaces equipments.
Page 118 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type Dozer Pipelayer Wheel Dozer Wheel Loader 17t Wheel Loader Excavator Loader Telescope Crane 90t Telescope Crane 60t Telescope Crane 45t Telescope Crane 30t Forklift 2t Forklift 5t Truck payload 12t, 3-axle Truck with hydraulic crane Truck with lifting Platform Dump Truck Cable reel Trailer Low Bed Trailer Fuel Truck Lubrication Truck Tractor Hydraulic Backhoe (crawler) Hydraulic Backhoe (wheel) Grader Trench Cutter Single Drum Roller Jeep Pick-up Jeep (12 seats) Personnel Transporters Minibus Ambulance Fire Fighting Truck Drilling Machine Workshop Container Mobile Workshop Mobile Lightings Winding Support Drum Vulcanisation Set Diesel Generator Water Truck Spraying Galleries Pumps Tab.: 8.2-3
‘08 3 1 1 1
1 1 1 1
‘09 6 1 1 2 1 1
1 1 1 1 3 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 10
‘10 6 2 1 2 1 1 1 1
‘11
‘12 2
‘13
1
1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1
‘14 3
‘15 6
‘16 6
1
1 2 1
1 2 1 1
1
1
1 1
1 1 1
1
1 1 1 2
6 5 2 1
1 1 2
1 1 2
1 1 1 1
2 1 1 1 1 6 5 1 3 1 1
3 3 1 2
2 2 1
3 5 2 1
1
1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1
6 5 1 3 1
1
1
10
4
1
2
2
1 1
1
1 2
1 10
1 4
2 1
Annual Purchase of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2016
Page 119 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type Dozer Pipelayer Wheel Dozer Wheel Loader 17t Wheel Loader Excavator Loader Telescope Crane 90t Telescope Crane 60t Telescope Crane 45t Telescope Crane 30t Forklift 2t Forklift 5t Truck payload 12t, 3-axle Truck with hydraulic crane Truck with lifting Platform Dump Truck Cable reel Trailer Low Bed Trailer Fuel Truck Lubrication Truck Tractor Hydraulic Backhoe (crawler) Hydraulic Backhoe (wheel) Grader Trench Cutter Single Drum Roller Jeep Pick-up Jeep (12 seats) Personnel Transporters Minibus Ambulance Fire Fighting Truck Drilling Machine Workshop Container Mobile Workshop Mobile Lightings Winding Support Drum Vulcanisation Set Diesel Generator Water Truck Spraying Galleries Pumps Tab.: 8.2-4
2017 1
‘18 2 1
‘19
1
1 1
1 1 1 1
‘21 6
1
1 2 1
‘22 6 1 1 2 1
1
1
6 5
6 4 1
2
1 1
‘20 3
‘23
‘24
1
3 1
1
1 1
2 1 1
1 1 1 1
1 1 1 2
2 1 1 1 2 2 1
1
2
3 1
1
2
2
1 1
1
1 2
1 10
1 4
1 1
1 1 1
1
10
1 1 3 3 1 2
4
1
2
Annual Purchase of Auxiliary Equipment up to 2025
Page 120 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
8.3 Heavy Auxiliary Equipment for Sibovc SW Mine 8.3.1 Draglines For special works, linked with large mass movements, the application of draglines has been foreseen. These machines can be variably used at reasonable costs and they can be shifted within the mine with low expenses. The following works can be done by draglines: -
Cutting of overheights
-
Movement of sliding masses
-
Design of ramps
-
Cleaning of surface in the area of villages
-
Design of water collecting basins
It is proposed to use 3 draglines in the Sibovc mine as heavy auxiliary machines. After an appropriate rehabilitation these machines can be moved from the existing mine. There it will not be necessary to purchase new ones. At present 6 draglines are in operation in the existing mine. Except one ESch 10/70 which was technically overhauled, all draglines are in a bad repair. The overhauled ESch 10/70 has been selected from technical reasons for a further use in the Sibovc SW Mine. After 15 years of operation of the dragline in the Sibovc SW opencast mine it is planed to scrap this machine. Bucket Volume
10 m³
Boom Length
70 m
Max. Cutting Height
Max. Cutting Depth
Ground Pressure
34°
35 m
30°
30 m
26°
25 m
22°
20 m
17°
15 m
12°
10 m
Operation
0.94 kp/cm²
Transport
1.49 kp/cm²
Service Weight
767 t
Installed Power
1,460 kW
Time per Pass Tab.: 8.3-1
135°
54 s
Technical Data of Esch 10/70
Page 121 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 8.3-1
Scheme Esch 10/70
8.3.2 Transport Crawler A transport crawler is required for the shifting of the belt driving station and other heavy assemblies up to a weight of 350 t. Such a transport crawler is available in the existing mine. The transport crawler, financed by the EAR was delivered in 2003 and is in a good technical status. That’s why a general rehabilitation is not foreseen before re-commissioning in the Sibovc mine. Replacement within the period under review is not taken into consideration due to the discontinuous use of the transport crawler.
8.3.3 Derricks Large cranes will be needed for the assembly of the heavy equipment of the new opencast mine. Two Derrick cranes from the 70ies are still available on the assembly yard/stockyard nearby Bardh. It is not sure if the equipment is ready for operation. Parallel to mobile cranes for the assembly of the equipment to be purchased it will be required to use also Derricks or equivalent machines. The rehabilitation of the available Derricks shall be checked. Investments of at least 0.1 MEUR are necessary for each of the Derricks.
Page 122 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
8.4 Investment and Cost Calculation Based on the average prices of the single auxiliary equipment types (price basis 2006) and the annual number of machines, the investments were determined according to equipment type and year. The investments/reinvestments for auxiliary equipment amount to 60 MEUR until 2024. About 24 MEUR are for initial investments, a sum of 34 MEUR for replacement investments and about 2 MEURO for rehabilitation measures of heavy auxiliary equipment. A slight reduction of the investments within the developing phase can be achieved by a further use of selected auxiliary machines from the existing mine. At present it is assumed that the auxiliary equipment in the existing mine will be worn out at the time of the decommissioning and cannot be further used. A revision shall be made at a later date.
Type Dozer Pipelayer Wheel Dozer Wheel Loader 17t Wheel Loader Excavator Loader Telescope Crane 90t Telescope Crane 60t Telescope Crane 45t Telescope Crane 30t Forklift 2t Forklift 5t Truck payload 12t, 3-axle Truck with hydraulic crane Truck with lifting Platform Dump Truck Cable reel Trailer Low Bed Trailer Fuel Truck Lubrication Truck Tractor Hydraulic Backhoe (crawler) Backhoe (wheel) Hydraulic Tab.: 8.4-1
Investment 17.2 4.7 1.8 3.7 1.3 0.6 0.7 1.0 0.8 1.9 0.1 0.2 1.1 1.8 0.7 1.4 0.2 0.5 0.6 0.4 0.6 1.5 0.6
Type Grader Trench Cutter Single Drum Roller Jeep Pick-up Jeep 12 seats Personnel Transporters Minibus Ambulance Fire Fighting Truck Drilling Machine Workshop Container Mobile Workshop Mobile Lightings Winding Support Drum Vulcanisation Set Diesel Generator Water Truck Spraying Galleries Pumps
Investment 0.6 1.0 0.2 1.7 1.4 0.2 3.0 0.2 0.1 0.2 2.4 0.1 0.6 0.7 0.2 0.3 0.3 0.1 0.1 1.1
Dragline ESch 10/70 Reha Transport Crawler
1.5 0.4
Investments and Reinvestments for Auxiliary Equipment
Year Investments
‘08 5.9
‘09 7.0
‘10 9.6
‘11 0.3
‘12 1.6
‘13 0.2
‘14 3.7
‘15 4.6
Year Investments
‘17 2.4
‘18 5.0
‘19 2.6
‘20 3.4
‘21 4.1
‘22 3.8
‘23 -
‘24 -
Tab.: 8.4-2
‘16 5.3
Yearwise Investments for Auxiliary Equipment in MEURO
Page 123 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
For auxiliary equipment, the running cost for service fluids and maintenance shall be taken into calculation. These were determined on the basis of specific parameter. -
Energy for dragline
- 0.9 kWh / bcm overburden
-
Fuel and lubrication
- 30 % of costs for energy in the mines
-
Maintenance of auxiliary equipment
- 4 ct / bcm (overburden and coal)
Page 124 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9 Infrastructure and Surface Facilities 9.1 General Remarks and Principles In principle it is not planned to install new surface facilities for various reasons; among others the available technical plants in Bardh/ Mirash, which are presently part of ongoing rehabilitation measures, the neighbourhood to Sibovc and the extensive investments, anyhow. It seems to be reasonable to use the available buildings and plants to a great extend also for the Sibovc opencast mine. The different buildings of the following departments of KEK were checked for a follow-up use: -
Office Gate 1
-
Mine „BARDH“
-
Mine „MIRASH“
-
Separation plant
-
Kosovamont
The following construction measures are required for preparing the development of the lignite opencast mines as well as for securing the auxiliary processes: Social facilities and administration -
change- and washrooms with sanitary facilities (wash places and toilets)
-
administration building
-
canteen
-
facilities for medical care
-
parking places
Supply and disposal -
transfer stations and switch plants for power supply of the opencast mine equipment and surface facilities
-
supply of drinking water, disposal of wastewater
-
data transmission
-
fire extinguishing ponds, building for fire brigade
-
roads (public roads, plant roads, roads on working levels of excavators spreaders)
-
assembly yards
Workshops and warehouses
Page 125 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
main mechanical workshop
-
main electrical workshop
-
central auxiliary equipment workshop
-
vulcanizing workshop
-
mechanical and electrical workshop (for immediate repairs)
-
petrol stations
-
wash places or vehicles
-
central warehouse and various small warehouses of the departments
9.2 Social Facilities and Administration 9.2.1 Mine Offices To centralise the administration (future head office) there are required about 150 office workplaces (planning departments like for example mine planning, geology, soil-mechanics, hydrology, construction planning, mine surveying, accounting and procurement department as well as other central departments). Therefore, it is planned to build a new three-floor office building with an investment amount of ca. 3.5 Mio. â‚Ź, because the available administration buildings and/or barracks are located decentral and partly are in a bad repair. The new building shall be erected at the site of the daily facilities of Bardh. The layout plan illustrated in the following picture is an example for an office building in modular design (lifetime ca. 30 years).
Page 126 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
14,18 m
reception
restrooms
secretary pool
25,00 m
washroom
10,82 m
Mine Office
canteen coffee shop
meeting room
10,82 m
27,72 m
10,82 m
49,36 m
Fig.: 9.2-1
Layout Drawing of New Mine Office
The following office buildings were examined for possible uses by the Sibovc SW opencast mine: Office building in Mirash
60 employees (office space ca. 600 m²)
Office building in Bardh
55 employees (office space ca. 550 m²)
KEK Gate 01
85 employees (office space ca. 730 m²)
Total
200 employees
Due to their bad repair as well as their spatial distance to the facilities in Bardh, the buildings of Gate 01 (light-weight timber construction, only partly solid) and Mirash are only applicable for a transition period of ca 5 years.
Fig.: 9.2-2
Mine Office Mirash
Page 127 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.2-3
Mine Office Gate 01
Fig.: 9.2-4
Mine Office Bardh
The office building of Bardh was reconstructed and extended during the past years and is presently in a very good repair. It comprises among others a canteen, a large-size meeting room as well as toilets and washrooms. This building is intended to be part of the administrative units of Sibovc SW. The requires office workplaces (mean-level management) for the work preparation of the production departments, workshops, stockyard and auxiliary equipment complexes are already available in these complexes and the constructions are in a good repair.
Page 128 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9.2.2 Mine Control Centre
Fig.: 9.2-5
Current Mine Control Centre of Mirash Mine
For the Mirash opencast mine a new control centre was erected in the past years which cannot be used for the new opencast mine owing to its location.
Fig.: 9.2-6
Mine Control Centre of Bardh Mine
The operative control for the Bardh opencast mine is directly situated in the daily facilities of Bardh at the slope and shows multiple settlement cracks. This little building is only applicable for radiotelephony. A new operation control centre with adequate equipment shall be erected for the Sibovc SW opencast mine. This control centre shall be integrated in the new office building.
Page 129 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
A sum of ca. 150,000 € shall be planned for hard-and software.
9.2.3 Washrooms and Sanitary Facilities At present, wash and change rooms are attached decentralized to the respective operation unit. Central washing facilities exist in the mechanical workshop at Kosovomont, in the Separation plant as well as the daily facilities of the Bardh mine. Washing facilities (as far as existing) are mostly integrated in the changing rooms and have only cold water connection. Kosovomont and Separation plant have separate wash- and changing rooms. In 2006 a rehabilitation program is executed for the washing facilities. It comprises most of all the procurement of new lockers and smaller repairs (sum of 230,000 €). The following capacities base on the data of this program. Location
Designation
Capacity Worker
Kosovomont
Mechanical Workshop
480
Kosovomont
Electrical Workshop
134
Separation Plant A
Electrical and mechanical Workshop
140
Western slope Bardh
SH.T.-12
380
Western slope Bardh
Garage
384
CPD Gate I
For Engineers
30
Mirash
600
Total Tab.: 9.2-1
2.148 Capacity of Change Rooms and Sanitary Facilities
The two facilities in Bardh are below the daily facilities and have only changing places. The barrack is in bad repair and not suitable for the new opencast mine. The washing facilities in Kosovomont and Separation Plant with a total capacity of 754 places can be used for the Sibovc SW after reconstruction still to be carried out. The human resources concept for Sibovc SW demands approx. 1,350 wash room places for the people directly involved in the production. With regard to the wash room places further useable in Kosovomont and Separation Plant there is yielded a shortage of 600 wash- and change room places for Sibovc SW. The erection of a new facility in the daily facilities of Bardh for 600 places including a locker room area will meet the required capacity. The investment costs for such a facility amount to 1.8 Mio. €. The following picture shows a wash- and change room facility for 650 employees:
Page 130 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.2-7
Washroom and Sanitary Facility for 650 Workers
9.3 Supply and Disposal 9.3.1 Erection Yards South of the daily facilities of Bardh a central erection yard with ca. 75,000 m² will be built or Sibovc. Operative erection yards shall be envisaged for big repairs with the following requirements: -
Horizontal area
-
Effective size of the area: 100 m x 80 m
-
Basement:
25.00 cm
base gravel
0/56 mm
25.00 cm
antifreeze layer
0/32 mm
-
Ditch for installation: 0.5 m deep and 0.5 m wide
-
Drainage ditch around the repair place with connection to a river or a collection basin with pump
-
Connection to access roads
-
Connection to power and water supply
-
Use of mobile cranes
The containers are equipped for the management personnel of the repair (responsible for installation: contractor). The new erection yard costs ca. 1.2 Mio. € including media connection. An erection yard for a big repair costs ca. 100,000 €.
Page 131 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9.3.2 Road Construction The relocation of public roads has been described in the chapter “Resettlements�. For the different types of roads the following design and parameters of road construction have been considered: Length of the road [m]
Width of the road [m]
Planned utilisation [years]
3,000
4
<3
1,500
4
<3
gravel
Head conveyor
2,000
4
>3
asphalt with passing places
Main accesses intended for a long-term use
each 5,000m in 2008, 2011, 2014, 2017
6
>3
asphalt
Connecting roads between the locations
Corresponding to the dislocation of locations
6
>3
asphalt
Designation Mine operating roads, each on four working levels
Access roads Municipal roads Tab.: 9.3-1
Excavator bench Dump bench
Type of road gravel
Road Construction
9.3.2.1 Plant roads Parallel to the belt conveyor systems on the single working levels, construction of plant roads 4 m wide are planned as gravel roads. In case of a lifetime greater than 3 years these roads will be furnished with an asphalt cover. The roads constructed in Macadam-design (first layer 16 cm chippings with grain size 60-90 mm; second layer 9 cm chippings with grain size 30-60 mm) in the Bardh and Mirash mines in 2004 have not proved successful on the existing subsoil (clay) and the difficult dewatering conditions.
Page 132 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.3-1
Mine Road in Mirash in Spring 2006
Therefore, the gravel roads in cohesive soils shall be constructed as follows: 10.00 cm
gravel base
0/32 mm, sand washed
20.00 cm
gravel base
0/56 mm
30.00 cm
antifreeze layer
0/32 mm
1 layer
Geovlies-mats
60.00 cm
Sum
A unit price of 12.00-16.00 €/m² shall be calculated for the cost determination of the gravel roads. If a share of 50% of the gravel material can be recovered the unit price can amount to 12.00 €/ m². The following system of plant roads will be required in the opencast mine (depending on bench lengths): -
Excavator bench on 4 working levels, ca. 1.5 km long and 4 m wide (gravel)
-
Dump bench on 4 working levels, ca. 1.1 km long and 4 m wide (gravel)
-
Head conveyor belt on 4 working levels, ca. 2 km long and 4 m wide with passing places (asphalt)
Owing to the opencast mine advance and the connected changing operating conditions about ca. 15.6 km of gravel roads have to be built every year (until 2024). The main access roads along the head conveyors are made of asphalt. At the beginning of opencast mines operation a distance of about 6 km has to be constructed. During regular operation these roads will be extended on each working level by 150 m (totally 0.5 km per year).
Page 133 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9.3.2.2 Access Roads Roads and main accesses intended for long-term use (lifetime >3 years) are furnished with asphalt with the following layers: 4.00 cm
Bitumen cover
0/11 mm
4.00 cm
Bitumen binder layer
0/16 mm
8.00 cm
bituminous base
0/32 mm
20.00 cm
gravel base
0/56 mm (compaction EV2 > 180 MN/m²)
44.00 cm
antifreeze layer
0/32 mm
1layer of
Geovlies-mats
80.00 cm
Total
Due to opposing traffic the roads shall be 6 m wide. To determine the costs a unit price of 70.00 €/m² is used (construction mainly with local contractors). The main access road to the Sibovc opencast mine (asphalt) is built parallel to the coal belt conveyor to the power plant – from the working level of the pit operation to the coal distribution point of Kosovo A/B. It has a length of ca. 2.5 km and a width of 6 m and has to overcome a height difference of ca. 20 m. For road construction the existing building materials (limited availability of broken brick, ash concrete) can be used. In any case a geotextile and a drainage layer shall be used in the upper layers because it can be water-absorbing depending on the firing temperature.
9.3.3 Fire Department The building of the fire department in the south of the Separation Plant is in a good repair and can also be used for the Sibovc SW opencast mine. Until the beginning of the regular operation the mine surveying department will also have its seat in this building.
Page 134 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.3-2
Building of the Fire Department
9.4 Workshops and Warehouses 9.4.1 Principles The mining company KEK owns a number of decentralized located main-and operating workshops and warehouses which can be used owing to the low distance to the new opencast mine field of Sibovc Currently the following infrastructure elements support the maintenance process. Auxiliary equipment workshops (totally 5 sites): -
Workshop (small) and yard Bardh (south-western slope Bardh), also the vulcanizing facility of the Bardh operation is located here
-
Workshop and yard Mirash (Northern slope Mirash West, surface site of old underground mine)
-
Workshop and yard Kosovomont (Mirash Brand Field)
-
Rubber tired vehicles yard (Mirash gate)
-
Workshop separation plant
Main equipment workshops (totally 7 locations): -
Mechanical workshop Bardh (South of Bardh village, large construction cranes for main mine equipment on site), also the idler repair facility of the Bardh operation is located here
Page 135 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Electrical workshop Bardh, also a second building for electrical rehabilitation is at the same location (Western slope Bardh)
-
Mechanical workshop Mirash (Northern slope Mirash West)
-
Electrical workshop Mirash (Northern slope Mirash West)
-
Mechanical workshop Kosovomont
-
Electrical workshop Kosovomont
-
Electrical and mechanical workshop separation plant, idler repair
Warehouses: -
Warehouse electrical Bardh (Western slope Bardh)
-
Warehouse mechanical Bardh (Western slope Bardh)
-
Warehouse protective equipment Bardh (Western slope Bardh)
-
Warehouse aux equipment Bardh (Western slope Bardh)
-
Fuel station Mirash (Northern slope Mirash West)
-
Warehouse electrical Kosovomont
-
Warehouse mechanical Kosovomont
-
Fuel station separation plant
-
Warehouse idler and vulcanization separation plant
-
Warehouse mechanical and electrical temporary Mirash at the gasification plant
-
Warehouse office supply at gate 01
-
There is a new warehouse under construction at the Mirash office building
Basing on the prepared maintenance concept for the Bardh and Mirash opencast mines the following available capacities will be rehabilitated and made available for Sibovc. From these 24 locations with support functions in a first business reengineering effort 11 locations will remain. These are: Auxiliary equipment workshops: (1)
New Central Auxiliary equipment workshop including warehouse (Bardh Southwestern slope) - completion in 2005
Main equipment workshops: (1) Mechanical workshop Intervention (South of Bardh village) (2) Electrical workshop Intervention (Western slope Bardh) (3) Electrical workshop Kosovomont (4) Mechanical workshop Kosovomont (5) Workshop separation plant
Page 136 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Warehouses: (1) Warehouse Bardh (Western slope Bardh) (2) Fuel station Mirash (Northern slope Mirash West) (3) New warehouse Mirash (currently under construction at the Mirash office building) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; completion in 2005 (4) New central warehouse at Kosovomont (5) Idler repair workshop separation plant For implementing an effective maintenance, a central inventory management including an EDP-system for acquiring, keeping and managing the inventory is planned. For registering the material it will be necessary to introduce a code system. The following table summarizes all existing buildings of the single departments of KEK which will be used in future. Building
Designation
Departments of CPD KEK
Auxiliary Equipment Workshop
New central aux. Workshop
M.S. "BARDHI"
Mechanical Workshop Intervention
M.S. "BARDHI"
Electrical Workshop Intervention
M.S. "BARDHI"
Electrical Workshop
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Mechanical Workshop
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Electrical & Mechanical Workshop
SEPARATION DEPARTMENT
New Warehouse
M.S. "MIRASHI"
Warehouse idler and vulcanization
SEPARATION DEPARTMENT
Warehouse electrical Bardh
M.S. "BARDHI"
Warehouse mechanical Bardh
M.S. "BARDHI"
New central Warehouse
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Warehouse for Workshops
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Mine Control Centre
M.S. "BARDHI"
Mine Control Centre
M.S. "MIRASHI"
Office Building
M.S. "MIRASHI"
Office Building
M.S. "BARDHI"
Mining Office
KEK Gate 01
Main Equipment Workshops
Warehouses
Mine Control Centre Mine Offices
Page 137 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Mechanical & Electrical Workshop
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Petrol Station /
Petrol Station
M.S. "MIRASHI"
Fuel Depot
Petrol Station
SEPARATION DEPARTMENT
Mechanical Workshop Intervention
M.S. "BARDHI"
Electrical Workshop Intervention
M.S. "BARDHI"
Mechanical Workshop
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT "KOSOVAMONT"
Electrical and mechanical Workshop
SEPARATION DEPARTMENT
Washrooms and Sanitary Facilities
Tab.: 9.4-1
Further Use of Buildings for Mine Sibovc SW
The planned sites of the workshop- and warehouse complexes are illustrated in the following picture:
Fig.: 9.4-1
Survey Workshops and Warehouses
9.4.2 Workshops New Central Auxiliary Equipment Workshop The future new auxiliary equipment workshop is at the territory of the daily facilities of Bardh Western slope. The massif hall with portal crane is a new building and will be completed in 2006. The workshop contains the required office space for the preparatory management as well as areas for equipment and a warehouse for auxiliary equipment.
Page 138 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-2
New Central Auxiliary Equipment Workshop Bardh
Mechanical workshop intervention The mechanical workshop intervention (South of Bardh village) is presently used as mechanical workshop for the Bardh opencast mine and responsible for all mechanical repairs. The workshop is among other equipped with lathes and drilling machines.
Fig.: 9.4-3
Mechanical Workshop Intervention
Page 139 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
For a later use as workshop for the Sibovc SW mine it is necessary to install the already planned heating and to reconstruct the sanitary facilities. The outside area of the workshop includes a large unpaved storage area with 2 large Derrick-cranes. The maintenance of these cranes is too expensive so that they can be scrapped. Electrical Workshop Intervention The electrical workshop intervention (South of Bardh village) is used as electrical workshop for the Bardh opencast mine. In the eastern part of the building, the metrological department is located. The 3-nave hall consists of a reinforced concrete skeleton construction with wall made of brickworks and/or large glazing at the long sides. The floor is made of a wooden pavement. The individual workshops are accessible form the central corridor. The building is equipped with heating. The toilets were reconstructed in 2005. The building is in a good repair.
Fig.: 9.4-4
Electrical Workshop Intervention Bardh
Electrical Workshop Kosovomont The workshop complex Kosovomont is 3 km away from the opencast mine nearby the place of Palaj. At present the village road is used as access to the Bardh and Mirash opencast mines. The access road to the Sibovc SW mine shall be developed basically. The Electrical workshop Kosovomont belongs to the future Central Workshop of the opencast mines. In 2004, the existing hall was extended by a built-on structure for expanding the repair capacities. In the same year, the entire heating system of the hall including the heating pipelines from Kosovo B power plant were overhauled and/or refurbished
Page 140 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-5
Electrical Workshop Kosovomont
Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont It is intended to extent the mechanical workshop of the Kosovomont site as future Central workshop for the opencast mine Sibovc. On an area of ca. 10,000 m² the necessary departments for the central workshop are located in 3 naves; among others metal cutting, (lathing, milling, drilling), grinding shop, welding shop, hardening shop. Since 2002, considerable investments have been made for modernising the machine park (a. o. CNC-control for milling machines, drilling equipment and gear milling machine).
Fig.: 9.4-6
Layout Plan for Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 1
Page 141 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-7
Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 1
The building condition is assessed well. The heating of the halls was overhauled and/or completely renewed in 2004. The internal transportation in the hall is made via floor-controlled hall cranes and two railway tracks which are connected to the separate warehouse and the building for sandblasting/corrosion protection. The hall complex has a massive three-floor extension with office workplaces for the technical work preparation and administration. In the ground floor there is the changing room for ca. 200 employees
Fig.: 9.4-8
Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont 2
Page 142 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
In front of the office extension of the hall complex there is a gravel-paved parking area (ca. 35 m x 50 m) for 2 new workshop mobiles, 2 new workshop trailers as well as 1 Unimog and one 90t-crane. Outside the building of the mechanical workshop there is a storage ground with portal crane. The blasting plant (including corrosion protection) is not in operation at present. Electrical and mechanical Workshop Separation Plant
Fig.: 9.4-9
Electrical and Mechanical Workshop
In 2004, the production capacities of electrical and mechanical maintenance of Kosovo A and B were brought together and concentrated in the electrical and mechanical workshop at the site of the Separation plant. Here, repair capacities are concentrated for idlers and vulcanization as well as the refurbishment of old gears and couplings of the mines and power plants. The massive building (length 49.4 m x width 23.0 m x height 6.2 m) with overhead light is heated and in a good repair. In this building there are the electrical and mechanical workshops as well as changing facilities for originally 500 employees with separate washing facilities as well as 20 shower installations with warm water connection
9.4.3 Warehouses New Warehouse Mirash The new warehouse at Mirash (area ca. 1,800 m²) is located in the area of the daily facilities of Mirash at the road Hade-Obiliq. The outdoor facilities and a paved access road are included in the plan of KEK for 2006.
Page 143 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-10
New Warehouse Mirash
Warehouse idler and vulcanization separation plant The Warehouses idler (length 60.4 m, width 12.2 m, height 4.0 m) and vulcanization (length 15 m, width 9.3 m, height 2.6 m) are in the direct neighbourhood of the mechanical and electrical workshop Separation plant. The warehouses are in a good repair. It is envisaged that this will be the central warehouse for idlers. The outside facilities are paved.
Fig.: 9.4-11
Warehouse Idler and Vulcanisation
Page 144 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
New central warehouse Kosovomont In the concept it is intended to use a massive building complex nearby Kosovomont which is completed to 70 % as central warehouse. The building was erected before 1990 and is only partly roofed at present. Completion of the building to be used for Sibovc SW shall be planned and realised. About 2 mâ&#x201A;Ź have to be planned to complete the building.
Fig.: 9.4-12
New Central Warehouse
Warehouses for Workshops Kosovomont The building complex of the mechanical workshop comprises a warehouse (ca. 15 m x 110 m), of which only ca. 1/3 is roofed incompletely (only roof without walls). The size of the storage areas is considered sufficient. The storage capacities of the electrical workshop are within the building complex of the workshop as well as on an open storage place. The size of the paved storage space is regarded sufficient. Electrical Warehouse in Bardh The electrical warehouse is on the territory of the daily facilities. Directly besides the building there is a paved storage ground. The single-floor massive warehouse has a roofed ramp. The building also contains the warehouse for protective clothing. The required financial means for the maintenance of the building were already planned in the Mid Term Plan.
Page 145 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-13
Electrical Warehouse Bardh
Mechanical Warehouse in Bardh The mechanical warehouse (length 72.4 m, width 24.0 m, height 5.0 m, area 1,775 m²) of the Bardh mine is an unheated two-nave hall consisting of a steel construction lined with aluminium sheet. Inside the hall there are two heated massive installations (ca. 35 m²) for the ware-housemen. The warehouse complex also contains a warehouse (ca. 700 m²) for car service. The required financial means for the maintenance of the building were already planned in the Mid Term Plan.
Page 146 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 9.4-14
Mechanical Warehouse Bardh
9.4.4 Petrol Station At present, there are two petrol stations in the Mirash opencast mine and in the Separation Plant.
Fig.: 9.4-15
Petrol Station Mirash
The Mirash petrol station has three tap connections, the tanks having a content of (total content 126,038 l):
Page 147 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
V1
47,721 l
V2
47,804 l
V3
30,513 l
Daily consumption is ca. 6,000 l Diesel for vehicles of Bardh and Mirash opencast mines as well as Kosovomont. A petrol station and a lubricants warehouse belong to the Separation plant and supply all vehicles and auxiliary equipment of Separation plant and Kosova B. The three available tanks have a content of: V1
10,000 l
V2
20,000 l
V3
10,000 l
Fig.: 9.4-16
Petrol Station Mirash
Both of the petrol stations do not meet the environmental requirements (no oil separators, missing tank pits) and will not be refurbished for Sibovc SW. Instead a new petrol station shall be planned and installed in the area of the new central auxiliary equipment workshop in Bardh. The sum to be calculated for this is ca. 250,000 â&#x201A;Ź. The new petrol station shall have two pieces of tanks each with a content of 50,000 l for Diesel fuel and petrol. The investment appraisal contains: roof for petrol station, building, and foundation working for site pavement, canalization with separation units, and automatic tank appliance with card reader, telephone connection, power supply and lightning protection
Page 148 of 150
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9.5 Time Scheduling for Infrastructure Measures 2006 I
II
2007 III
IV
I
II
2008 III
IV
I
II
2009 III
IV
I
II
2010 III
IV
I
II
New Office Building with Mine Control Centre New Central Warehouse Kosovomont Mechanical Workshop Intervention New Petrol Station and Fuel Depot New Washroom and Sanitary Facility Erection Yard Refurbishment Road Mirash-Obiliq (Palaj) Road Palaj-Kosovomont Main Road Mine Sibovc Specification
Fig.: 9.5-1
Tendering Process
Construction
Commissionning
Time Schedule for Infrastructure Measures
9.6 Investment and Cost Calculation for Infrastructure Infrastructure measures in connection with the relocation of the villages of Hade, Miren, Shipitulla and Konxhul are already considered in the chapter Resettlement. This chapter includes also new roads which will become necessary due to the resettlement. The investment costs for the infrastructure of the new Sibovc opencast mine include rehabilitation of the existing opencast mine facilities of the Bardh opencast mine as well as the workshops and warehouses in Kosovomont. The investment costs furthermore contain the planned new buildings for administration and changing and washing facilities at the site of the Bardh daily facilities as well as the roads necessary for operating the opencast mine. The following table summarizes all investment costs for the period 2007 to 2012.
Page 149 of 150
III
IV
Part I Basic Investigations Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Infrastructure and Surface Facilities
Total
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
0.365
2.010
1.125
0.050
0.150
0.800
0.050
Mine Offices New Office Building Bardh
3.500
Mine Control Centre Bardh (Hard- and Software)
0.200
Workshops and Warehouses New Central Warehouse Kosovomont
2.000
0.150
1.000
Mechanical Workshop Intervention Bardh
0.550
0.200
0.350
Electrical Workshop Intervention Bardh
0.030
0.030
Mechanical Workshop Kosovomont
0.500
0.100
Electrical Workshop Kosovomont
0.030
0.030
Electrical and mechanical Workshop SP
0.050
0.050
New Petrol Station and Fuel Depot Bardh
0.250
0.250
New Washroom and Sanitary Facility Bardh
1.800
0.200
0.775
0.825
Total buildings
8.910
0.780
1.740
4.265
2.075
0.050
0.100
0.100
Erection Yard Bardh Refurbishment
1.200
1.200
Assembly Yards for General Repair
0.500
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.126
0.126
0.126
0.100
0.300
Washrooms and Sanitary Facilities
Roads and places Area pavement daily facilities of Bardh
Erection Yards
Access Roads Road Mirash-Obiliq (incl. village road Palaj) 1.5km*5.5m
0.580
0.290
0.290
Road connection to Kosovomont - 1.0km*5.5m
0.385
0.185
0.200
Main access to mine – 2.5km*6m
1.050
0.650
0.400
1.124
0.480
Mine operating roads (4 working levels) Head conveyor – Asphalt, 6km
1.680
Extension of Head Conveyor – Asphalt, 0.45 km/a
0.378
Excavator and Dump Benches – Gravel, 15.6 km/a
3.745
Total roads + places
9.618
Total Infrastructure
18.528
Tab.: 9.6-1
0.076
0.749
0.749
0.749
0.749
0.749
1.851
3.113
1.729
0.975
0.975
0.975
2.631
4.853
5.994
3.050
1.025
0.975
Investment Calculation for Infrastructural Measures
Page 150 of 150
European Agency for Reconstruction PREPARATION OF A COMPLEMENTARY MINING PLAN FOR THE SIBOVC SOUTH WEST LIGNITE MINE CONTRACT 02/KOS01/10/021
DRAFT FINAL REPORT Complementary Mining Plan for Sibovc SW
Part II - Technical Planning
April, 2006
prepared by: STEAG Consortium
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Key Experts of Project Team
Hans J端rgen Matern Team Leader
Thomas Suhr Senior Expert Computer-Aided Mine Planning Applications
Stephan Peters Senior Expert Geology
Helmar Laube Senior Expert Soil Mechanics
Joachim Gert ten Thoren Senior Environmental Expert
Page 2 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Table of Contents 1 1.1 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.3 1.3.1 1.3.2 1.3.3 1.3.4 1.3.5
SUMMARY (PART II) .......................................................................................... 12 Objective .................................................................................................................. 12 Tasks and Outputs of the Project.............................................................................. 13 Part I: Basic Investigations ....................................................................................... 13 Part II: Technical Planning....................................................................................... 13 Part III: Environmental Impact Study....................................................................... 14 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis............................................................... 15 Results under Part II – Technical Planning .............................................................. 15 Mining Technology and Mine Development ........................................................... 15 Dewatering ............................................................................................................... 19 Mine Closure and Recultivation Planning ............................................................... 20 Resettlement and Relocation .................................................................................... 21 Manpower................................................................................................................. 22
2 2.1 2.2
INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 23 Background .............................................................................................................. 23 Approach / Methodology.......................................................................................... 23
3
COAL DEMAND ................................................................................................... 26
4 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.3.1 4.3.1.1 4.3.1.2 4.3.1.3 4.3.2 4.3.2.1 4.3.2.2 4.3.2.3 4.3.3 4.3.4 4.3.4.1 4.3.4.2 4.3.4.3 4.4 4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.2.1 4.4.2.2 4.4.2.3 4.4.3 4.4.4 4.4.5 4.4.5.1 4.4.5.2
MINING TECHNOLOGY OF THE SIBOVC SW MINE................................. 28 General Remarks / Preconditions ............................................................................. 28 Technological Equipment Parameter ....................................................................... 29 Capability / Capacity Calculation for MME ............................................................ 32 Capability of Excavators .......................................................................................... 32 Load Factor – Expression of the hourly Capacity .................................................... 34 Time Factor .............................................................................................................. 37 Capability of Excavators .......................................................................................... 39 Capability of Belt Conveyors ................................................................................... 41 Overburden Belt Conveyor System.......................................................................... 42 Coal Belt Conveyor System ..................................................................................... 43 Dependencies and Conclusions ................................................................................ 43 Capability of Spreaders ............................................................................................ 45 Capability of Mobile Equipment.............................................................................. 45 Mass-calculation for Mobile Equipment.................................................................. 45 Selection of Mobile Equipment................................................................................ 46 Calculation of Capacity and Equipment Fleet.......................................................... 47 General Mining Development in Sibovc SW........................................................... 50 Excavation Boundary/ Boundary Line ..................................................................... 50 Bench Design ........................................................................................................... 51 General Bench Design.............................................................................................. 51 Division of Cuts in Overburden Operation .............................................................. 54 Division of Cuts in Coal Operation.......................................................................... 55 Main Strategies for Mining Development................................................................ 56 Mass Calculation ...................................................................................................... 56 Stockpile Operation.................................................................................................. 59 Stockpile TPP A ....................................................................................................... 59 Stockpile TPP B ....................................................................................................... 60 Page 3 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5 4.5.1 4.5.2 4.5.2.1 4.5.2.2 4.5.2.3 4.5.3 4.5.3.1 4.5.3.2 4.5.3.3 4.5.3.4 4.5.4 4.5.4.1 4.5.4.2 4.5.4.3 4.5.4.4 4.5.5 4.5.5.1 4.5.5.2 4.5.5.3 4.5.5.4 4.5.6 4.5.6.1 4.5.6.2 4.5.6.3 4.5.6.4 4.5.6.5 4.6 4.6.1 4.6.1.1 4.6.1.2 4.6.1.3 4.6.1.4 4.6.2 4.6.2.1 4.6.2.2 4.6.2.3 4.6.2.4 4.6.3 4.6.3.1 4.6.3.2 4.6.3.3 4.6.3.4 4.6.4 4.6.5 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.9.1 4.9.2
Opening-up Operation.............................................................................................. 62 Preparatory Works in the Year 2007 ........................................................................ 62 Mining Development in the Year 2008.................................................................... 62 General Development............................................................................................... 62 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 63 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 65 Mining Development in the Year 2009.................................................................... 66 General Development............................................................................................... 66 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 67 Coal Operation ......................................................................................................... 69 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 69 Mining Development in the Year 2010.................................................................... 71 General Development............................................................................................... 71 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 72 Coal Operation ......................................................................................................... 74 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 75 Mining Development in the Year 2011.................................................................... 77 General Development............................................................................................... 77 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 78 Coal Operation ......................................................................................................... 80 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 80 Mining Development in the Year 2012.................................................................... 82 General Development............................................................................................... 82 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 83 Coal Operation ......................................................................................................... 85 Coal Quality Management........................................................................................ 86 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 87 Regular Operation .................................................................................................... 89 Mining Development in the Period 2013 – 2017 ..................................................... 89 General Development............................................................................................... 89 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 90 Coal Operation ......................................................................................................... 93 Production Figures ................................................................................................... 94 Mining Development in the Period 2018 – 2022 ..................................................... 96 General Development............................................................................................... 96 Overburden Operation.............................................................................................. 97 Coal Operation ....................................................................................................... 100 Production Figures ................................................................................................. 101 Mining Development in the Period 2023 – 2024 ................................................... 103 General Development............................................................................................. 103 Overburden Operation............................................................................................ 104 Coal Operation ....................................................................................................... 105 Production Figures ................................................................................................. 106 Remarks to a Continuation of Mining Development after 2024 ............................ 108 Remarks to Interactions with other Projects........................................................... 108 Compilation of Production Figures ........................................................................ 110 Belt Conveyor Balance........................................................................................... 115 Time Schedule........................................................................................................ 117 Main Equipment Activities .................................................................................... 117 Main Mining Activities .......................................................................................... 118 Page 4 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.10
Consequences for Development in Existing Mines ............................................... 119
5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.3.1 5.3.1.1 5.3.1.2 5.3.2 5.3.2.1 5.3.2.2 5.3.3 5.4
MINE DEWATERING........................................................................................ 120 Hydrological Conditions ........................................................................................ 120 Drainage Areas ....................................................................................................... 121 Dewatering Measures ............................................................................................. 122 Surface Dewatering ................................................................................................ 122 Drainage Area Bardh / Mirash West ...................................................................... 122 Sibovc SW Mining Area ........................................................................................ 122 In-Pit Dewatering ................................................................................................... 126 Drainage Area Bardh / Mirash West ...................................................................... 126 Sibovc SW Mining Area ........................................................................................ 127 Time Scheduling for Dewatering Measures ........................................................... 129 Investment and Cost Calculation for Dewatering .................................................. 129
6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.4.1 6.4.2 6.4.3 6.4.4
MINE CLOSURE AND RECULTIVATION PLANNING.............................. 131 Principles................................................................................................................ 131 Area Balance .......................................................................................................... 131 Mine Closure Plan.................................................................................................. 133 Concept of Post-Mining Utilization ....................................................................... 135 Principles and Preconditions for Reclamation Planning ........................................ 135 Soil Improvement Measures................................................................................... 136 Interim Greening and Erosion Protection Measures .............................................. 136 Irrigation and Dewatering Measures ...................................................................... 137
7 7.1 7.1.1 7.1.2 7.1.3 7.1.4 7.1.5 7.1.6 7.2 7.2.1 7.2.2 7.2.3 7.3
RESETTLEMENT AND RELOCATION......................................................... 138 General Remarks .................................................................................................... 138 Situation ................................................................................................................. 138 General Conditions................................................................................................. 138 Legal Resettlement Regulations ............................................................................. 139 Property Situation................................................................................................... 139 Valuation of Compensation.................................................................................... 143 Resettlement Procedure.......................................................................................... 144 Communities affected by Resettlement.................................................................. 145 Settlements in the Partial Field of Sibovc .............................................................. 145 Locations for Resettlements ................................................................................... 149 Time Scheduling for Resettlement Measures......................................................... 151 Investment and Cost Calculation for Resettlement ................................................ 152
8 MANPOWER DEVELOPMENT AND ORGANISATION............................. 161 8.1 Actual Situation...................................................................................................... 161 8.2 Proposed Improvement / Benchmark ..................................................................... 164 8.3 Employment and Organisation in Sibovc SW........................................................ 167 Year ........................................................................................................................................ 169 9
LICENSE FOR COAL EXTRACTION ............................................................ 171
Page 5 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Figures Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.:
1.3-1 1.3-2 1.3-3 4.3-1 4.4-1 4.4-2 4.4-3 4.4-4 4.5-1 4.5-2 4.5-3 4.5-4 4.5-5 4.5-6 4.6-1 4.6-2 4.6-3 4.9-1 5.1-1 5.3-1 5.3-2 6.4-1 7.1-1 7.1-2 7.2-1 7.2-2 7.2-3 7.2-4 7.2-5 7.2-6 7.2-7 7.2-8 7.2-9 7.2-10 7.3-1 8.1-1 8.1-2 8.1-3
Typical Cross Section with Main Equipment Application Main Measures and Activities for Mine Development Manpower Development Principle Calculation Scheme of Effective Capacity Cross Section with Main Equipment Application Sectors of Mass Calculation Scheme of Stockpile TPP A Scheme of Stockpile TPP B Mining Position at the End of Year 2008 Mining Position at the End of Year 2009 Mining Position at the End of Year 2010 Mining Position at the End of Year 2011 Mining Position at the End of Year 2012 Coal Transport and Distribution System in the Year 2012 Mining Position at the End of Year 2017 Mining Position at the End of Year 2022 Mining Position in the Year 2024 Main Mining Activities Catchment Areas of the Sibovc SW Mine Catchment Areas and Surface Dewatering Channels Time Schedule for Dewatering Measures Plant Scheme for Wind Erosion Protection Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW Land Acquisition for the Mine Sibovc SW Hade-North (View from Mirene) Hade-North (View from North) Mirene (in the Village) Mirene (View from South) Shipitulla East (View from South) Hade West 1 Hade West 2 Konxhul (View from Hade-North) Possible Site for Resettlements West of Bardh Time Scheduling for Resettlement Measures By-pass of Hade-Bardh CPD Structure until 2005 New CPD Structure to be introduced Age Structure of CPD Employees and Qualification (Source KEK)
16 18 22 33 53 57 59 60 63 67 72 78 83 86 90 97 104 118 120 125 129 137 141 142 145 146 146 147 147 148 148 149 150 152 156 162 163 163
Page 6 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 8.2-1 Fig.: 8.3-1
Proposed Structure of Macroorganisation of the CPD Development of Employees in CPD
166 169
Page 7 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Tables Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.:
1.3-1 1.3-2 2.2-1 4.2-1 4.2-2 4.2-3 4.2-4 4.2-5 4.2-6 4.3-1 4.3-2 4.3-3 4.3-4 4.3-5 4.3-6 4.3-7 4.3-8 4.3-9 4.3-10 4.3-11 4.3-12 4.3-13 4.3-14 4.3-15 4.3-16 4.3-17 4.3-18 4.3-19 4.4-1 4.5-1 4.5-2 4.5-3 4.5-4 4.5-5 4.5-6 4.5-7 4.5-8 4.5-9
Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW Number of Personnel Coal Demand Basic Geometry of the Bucket Wheel Excavators Cutting Heights and Block Width of Excavators [m] Maximum Inclination of Working Levels and Curve Radii of Excavators Technical Data of Spreaders Technical Data of Belt Wagon Technical Data of Dragline ESch 10/70 Principle Equipment Application Theoretical Digging Capacity in lcm/h Theoretical Capacity in bcm/h and t/h Effective Capacity of Excavators - Overburden Effective Capacity of Excavator - Coal Planned Working Time of Single Equipment Normal and Maximum Capacity - Overburden Capability of BWE in Overburden Operation [mbcm/a] Capability of Excavators in Coal Operation Nominal Capacity of Coal Excavators Bulk Density, Angel of Repose and Inclination of Belt Conveyor Factor fi for Considering the Inclination Possible Conveying Capacity for Overburden Belt Conveyors Possible Conveying Capacity for Coal Belt Conveyors Loading Utilisation of Overburden Systems Loading Utilisation of Coal Systems Utilisation of Spreader Capacity Maximum Capacity of Dragline ESch 10/70 Capacity of Shovel & Truck Fleet Results of Mass Calculation Planned Production in the Year 2008 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2008 Planned Production in the Year 2009 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2009 Planned Production in the Year 2010 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2010 Planned Production in the Year 2011 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2011 Planned Production in the Year 2012
21 22 26 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 34 35 36 36 38 39 39 40 40 42 42 42 43 44 44 45 47 48 58 65 65 69 70 75 76 80 81 87
Page 8 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.:
4.5-10 4.6-1 4.6-2 4.6-3 4.6-4 4.6-5 4.6-6 4.7-1 4.7-2 4.7-3 4.7-4 4.7-5 4.7-6 4.8-1 4.8-2 4.8-3 4.9-1 5.2-1 5.3-1 5.4-1 6.2-1 6.2-2 7.1-1 7.2-1 7.2-2 7.2-3 7.3-1 7.3-2 7.3-3 7.3-4 7.3-5 7.3-6 7.3-7 8.2-1 8.3-1 8.3-2 8.3-3
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2012 Planned Production in the Years 2013 – 2017 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2017 Planned Production in the Years 2018 – 2022 Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2022 Planned Production in the Years 2023 – 2024 Belt Conveyor System in the Year 2024 Lignite Production and Overburden Removal Benchwise Production in Overburden Systems [mbcm] Overburden Removal 1st Bench Overburden Removal 2nd Bench Overburden Removal 3rd Bench Bench-wise and Equipment-wise Production in Coal System Available Belt Conveyor Material in Existing Mine Existing and Planned Overland Belt Conveyors to TPP’s Belt Conveyor Balance for the new Sibovc SW Mine Release Time for Main Mine Equipment in Mid Term Period Maximum Drainage Areas Elements of Surface Dewatering Investments for Dewatering Measures Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW [ha] Area Balance [ha] Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW Communities Affected by Resettlement Cost Estimation for a new Settlement near Bardh Principle Timetable for Resettlement Procedure Cost Calculation for Resettlement of Properties with constructed Buildings Resettlement of Households and Land Claim Substitution Measures Infrastructure inside the Village and other Costs Substitution Measures for Infrastructure outside the Village Claim of Farmland Provisional Estimation of Resettlement Cost of Resettlement – Schedule Productivity Benchmarks in international Coal Industries Employees in the Bardh / Mirash Mine Employees in the Sibovc SW Mine Number of Employees
88 94 95 101 102 106 107 110 111 112 112 113 114 115 115 116 117 122 126 130 132 133 140 145 150 151 153 154 155 157 157 159 160 166 168 169 170
Page 9 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Annexes 4–1
Overview Map with Mine Positions
1 : 10 000
4–2
Mining Position at the End of 2008
1 : 10 000
4–3
Mining Position at the End of 2009
1 : 10 000
4–3
Mining Position at the End of 2010
1 : 10 000
4–5
Mining Position at the End of 2011
1 : 10 000
4–6
Mining Position at the End of 2012
1 : 10 000
4–7
Mining Position at the End of 2017
1 : 10 000
4–8
Mining Position at the End of 2022
1 : 10 000
4–9
Mining Position at the End of 2024
1 : 10 000
4 – 10
Cross Sections through the Rim Slope Systems
1 : 5 000
4 – 11
Cross Sections through the Advance Slope System
1 : 5 000
4 – 12
Working Level for mobile Equipment Services
1 : 10 000
4 – 13
Working Level 1st Overburden Bench
1 : 10 000
4 – 14
Working Level 2nd Overburden Bench
1 : 10 000
4 – 15
Working Level 3rd Overburden Bench
1 : 10 000
4 – 16
Working Level Overburden Bench 3a
1 : 10 000
4 – 17 4 – 18
st
1 : 10 000
nd
1 : 10 000
rd
Working Level 1 Coal Bench Working Level 2 Coal Bench
4 – 19
Working Level 3 Coal Bench
1 : 10 000
4 – 20
Working Level Coal Bench 3a
1 : 10 000
Page 10 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Abbreviations a
year
bcm/h
bank cubic meter per hour
BWE
bucket wheel excavator
CPD
Coal Production Division
GCV
gross calorific value
GWh
gigawatt-hours
kf
hydraulic conductivity
km
kilometre
km²
square kilometres
kt
thousand tonnes
kV
kilovolt
kW
kilowatt
l/min
liter per minute
m
meter
m²
square meter
m³
cubic meter
mbcm
million bank cubic meters
mcm
million cubic meters
mlcm
million loose cubic meters
mm
millimetre
MME
main mining equipment
mMSL
meter above main sea level
mt
million tonnes
m/min
meters per minute
m³/min
cubic meter per minute
m/s
meters per second
NCV
net calorific value
OCM
open cast mine
TPP
thermal power plant
`000 bcm
thousand bank cubic meters
`000 lcm
thousand loose cubic meters
Page 11 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1 Summary (Part II) 1.1 Objective The Complementary Mining Plan for New Sibovc South West Mine consists of the following reports: -
Part I
Basic Investigations
-
Part II
Technical Planning
-
Part III
Environmental Impact Study
-
Part IV
Economic and Financial Analysis
The existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash, west of Pristina, will be exhausted by 2011. Thus the overall objective of the project is providing a plan for the supply of the necessary fuel to the existing power plants in Kosovo until the end of their lifetime. The specific objectives of this contract are the elaboration of a detailed mine plan on the development of the new mine in the Sibovc South West Lignite Field. The objective of the plan is: -
to define the technical measures and the timeframe to be followed to open-up the new mine and develop it up to the scheduled capacity of about 9 million tons per annum;
-
to guide the focus on the necessary investments and operating costs;
-
to include the necessary measures and information for licensing applications.
Other than the Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine (max. 24 m t coal out per year) the Complementary Mining Plan for the Sibovc South West Lignite Field focuses on the fuel supply to the existing TPP assuming a coal demand of 9 mt/a and a limited availability of financial resources. The plan covers the period from 2007 to 2024 when all existing power capacities assumed to reach the end of their service life. Subsequently the total accumulated coal demand from the Sibovc South West Lignite Field comes to 123 million tonnes, what is approximately 15% of the entire mineable lignite reserves in the Sibovc Lignite Field. The remaining lignite reserves of the entire Sibovc Lignite Field could be a source to feed new power plant capacities expected to be built in Kosovo. The Complementary Mining Plan has been coordinated with the existing â&#x20AC;&#x153;Mid term Mining Plan for the existing minesâ&#x20AC;?. The Mid Term Plan provides the stepwise implementation of regular operation conditions, the achievement of geotechnical and public safety and therefore the transfer of mines to an economic efficient operation. The purpose of the Complementary Mine Plan is to show the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures to open up the new mine in time to replace the running out production capacity of the existing mines. The plan is showing the required investment and effective cost of lignite supply.
Page 12 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The investment requirements to open-up the Sibovc South-West mine are 236 MEURO until 2012, when full supply capacity will be reached. The real average cost of lignite supply amount to 7.50-8.00 EURO/ton of raw coal, depending on the cost of capital investment. Special attention has been focused on the required resettlement and land acquisition. The plan also ensures that the mine operations are in full compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations and laws.
1.2 Tasks and Outputs of the Project 1.2.1 Part I: Basic Investigations The basis for the new mining plan for the Sibovc South West mine is the previous study â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Main Mining Plan for Sibovc mineâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;. Using this as the basis, the consultants checked, evaluated, updated and presented all necessary facts (geo-technical, geological, hydrogeological and hydrological data, infrastructure, existing end necessary new equipment) for the Sibovc South West mine. According to ToR this plan was based on a demand forecast prepared by the Ministry of Energy and Mines in accordance with the Kosovo Energy Strategy. The consultant updated the existing computerised geological model based on additional exploration drillings conducted by KEK and prepared a plan for further exploration to be realised by KEK, defined the slope design based on soil-mechanic calculation. To ensure the planned performance of the equipment and subsequently output of the mine it will be necessary to undertake a complex refurbishment of lignite and overburden equipment incl. excavators, conveyor lines and spreaders. This approach represents a new quality against the partly repair of machines realised so far. A refurbishment/replacement programme for the existing main mining equipment as well as auxiliary equipment has been prepared including a realistic assessment of the timing of the required investments. As an important output of the project the plan provides the basis for the application for, and issuing of exploitation licence for the new mine. The outputs are the findings of this analysis, including the updated geological model, plan for further exploitation; definition of slope design; and updated investment plan in main and auxiliary equipment.
1.2.2 Part II: Technical Planning The consultants prepared detailed mine development plans/annexes for the first five years of operation and mine phase documentation for the end of each year, continuing with next five years periods (end of periods) up to 2024. The outputs of this task are the detailed mine development plans as set out above.
Page 13 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
There have been prepared an updated expropriation plan which provides both a timed and cost plan for the required measures for land acquisition and resettlement into mine planning on all working levels and along the access roads.
1.2.3 Part III: Environmental Impact Study The mining activities will have a large effect on the environment. The Environmental Study serves as a baseline description for the expected effects. Alternative locations are discussed for coal extraction prior to the implementation of the Complementary Mining Plan resulting in the location of “D-field”, east of the river Sitnica, to be an equally favourable alternative to supply the existing power plants from the environmental point of view. Among the other alternatives a development of the “Sibovc field” from the south to the north ranked second best. Subject of the Complementary Mining Plan is the excavation of overburden and lignite, developing from the existing opencast mines to the north. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. The anticipated environmental effects concern, first of all, the removal of soil resulting in a loss of surface area and living space. With this extension an enlarged void will be visible, compared to the existing mines. As the backfill of already exploited areas goes on parallel in time, it will be possible to return recovered areas to agricultural use in a landscape with changed appearance. Surface waters to be affected are mainly small and of non perennial flow. The rivers Sitnica and Drenica will not be directly affected, as clayey sediments with sufficient thickness protect them from the mine. Indirect effects can result from the outlet of mine drainage water with enlarged contents of Chloride and Sulphate as well as suspended solids. Because of the characteristics of the overburden the impact on groundwater will be minor. Significant groundwater utilization is not known in the area. Influences on neighbouring utilizations can be excluded. Dust emissions as well as noise emissions will shift from the current to the future working points with an equal or, based on used technologies, even minor extend of emissions. The Environmental Study attempts to follow in general the applicable EU directives on environmental impact assessment, mainly Directive 85/337/EEC. However, there is a general lack of baseline studies, local experts’ opinions, pertinent documents or other information, e.g. allowing any specific assessment on influences on fauna and flora. Regarding this aspect additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. In case of proper operation and a coal demand adequate to the mining technology the mine will stay one of the most important employers of the region with up to 1,500 employees. Upon completion of backfilling areas farmable land can be returned to the inhabitants, which mitigates the effects of required resettlements. Resettlement will be needed as a consequence of the development of the mine. Approximately 870 persons representing some 109 households will have to be moved in the years 2007 to 2024. Resettlement refers to single houses and small settlements and it will not be needed to resettle significant villages. With the objective to improve knowledge on the environment and to allow control on the environmental impact, adequate monitoring activities shall be set up concerning air and water
Page 14 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
quality measurements as well as the purification of drainage water and the utilization of humus enriched top soil layers.
1.2.4 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis The consultants prepared an economic and financial analysis with a detailed cash flow forecast, a financial analysis of the cost benefit of the proposed investment with IRR/ NPV calculations, and a time planning for the investment programme. The output of this task is a detailed, based on annual calculations economic and financial analysis and appraisal of the Sibovc South West mine plan. The calculations have been made in accordance with IFRS. The main results of the profitability calculation are as follows: The calculated real average cost (RAC) comes to 7.5-8.0 EURO/t. The economic analysis also considered that in 2024 a fully functioning opencast mine will be available. This allowed calculation with coal prices of 7.00 EURO/t to 7.50 EURO/t. Totally four variants were assumed containing different coal prices, different escalation and different interest rate on borrowings. All variants until 2011 require about 80 MEURO equity capital and ca. 200 MEURO outside capital. Assuming a coal price of 7.00 EURO/ton the dividend earned until 2024 will amount to at least 137 MEURO which can be distributed to the shareholders. The sum of the annual payments for the production of coal is smaller than 5.0 EURO per tonne coal. This applies from 2012, the first year of full production. It will be possible to produce coal with favourable terms and profits of 20 % on the employed equity capital can be earned. The cash flow analysis demonstrates that the chosen mine development will be generally profitable even with the short operation time period of only 15 years.
1.3 Results under Part II â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Technical Planning 1.3.1 Mining Technology and Mine Development The planning was made to directly follow up mining operations of existing mine. The planning basis for development of existing mine is the Mid Term Mining Plan, which has been finished in March 2005. The main task of the study is the fuel supply of the existing Thermal Power Plants up to the end of their lifetime (2024). This corresponds to a coal delivery of about 160.7 mt, beginning from 1st January 2007 onwards. The following main topics for the mine development have been considered:
Page 15 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Opening-up of the Sibovc SW OCM shall be made from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The existing inside dump of P3B shall be taken into account.
-
A coal pillar shall remain between the existing Bardh mine and the new Sibovc mine field in order to stabilize the masses of the inside dump of the Bardh opencast mine.
-
The overburden masses will preferably be dumped in the mined-out area of the existing OCM in order to stabilize the slope south of Hade and to establish final dump surfaces as soon as possible.
-
The mined-out bottom in Sibovc SW shall be covered by dumps and as far as possible also the final coal rim slope systems in order to prevent coal fires.
-
During the opening-up phase the overburden will be transported via the western rim slope system. After disassembling the equipment in the existing opencast mines there will be established a belt connection via the eastern rim slope system. This helps to reduce the transport distance and the quickest possible establishment of a stabilising body south of Hade.
-
The residual pit of Mirash-Brand remains as reserved area for the disposal of municipal waste.
-
It is envisaged to flush the power plant residues from TPP B in the residual pit of Mirash-East.
Regarding minimum investment costs for the new mine, the further use of the existing main equipment has been planned. The following main equipment has been selected. Coal operation
3 excavators SRs 1300 1 excavator SRs 400 + belt wagon
Overburden operation
1 excavator SRs 1300 + 1600 mm belts + spreader 2 excavator SchRs 650 + 1800 mm belts + spreaders 1 excavator SRs 470 + belt wagon
Fig.: 1.3-1
Typical Cross Section with Main Equipment Application
An extensive capacity calculation for the main mine equipment have been provided. The capacity calculation bases on the estimation of the principle capability of the equipment under the conditions of the Sibovc SW deposit considering the impact of:
Page 16 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Different digging materials in overburden removal
-
Climate / weather conditions (snow, fog, rain)
-
Skills and motivation of employees
The performance required can be performed only with rehabilitated equipment. After rehabilitation the capacity for overburden (BWE) complexes shall be 3.6-5.4 million cubic meters per annum each. In coal operation was considered that selective mining / quality management will slightly reduce the excavation effect. While the predominant part of the overburden removed in the Sibovc SW opencast mine is handled by means of 3 excavator-belt conveyor-spreader systems it is suggested to use mobile equipment in areas with local excess heights. Based on the mass calculation and after careful consideration of different criteria a combination of dragline and Truck & Shovel operation was chosen. The consultant calculated the capacity requirements and needed number of equipment. The mine boundaries have been selected under consideration of: -
Course of old concession line
-
Permissible approach to villages
-
Thickness of minable coal seam at the boundary
-
Necessary general inclination from geotechnical point of view
-
Requirements to bench lengths and straight rim slope systems
Altogether the excavation boundary or the technological depletion boundary represents a compromise between the criteria mentioned above. Deviations between the available terrain data and the actual situation were determined during visits along the western rim slope system. This area has to be surveyed by KEK as soon as possible. On this basis both the geological model and the technological planning of the western rim slope system shall be updated. The mass calculation has been realised with MicroStation-Programs as well as specialised programs developed by Vattenfall on the basis of triangulation. As basis have been used the digital deposit model. Based on the current stockpile design and the future supply demand have been considered an optimal stockpile level of -
400,000 tons in Kosovo A and
-
350,000 tons in Kosovo B.
The opening up of the Sibovc SW opencast mine starts from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The overburden thickness in the opening up area is only 30m and the coal layer is partly more than 70m thick. The opening-up technology have been planned under consideration of the dump operation in the Bardh mine in this area.
Page 17 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
After having executed the first preparatory measures in 2007, the opening up activities will start in 2008. Directly after the end of the winter season the first mass movements by means of Shovels and Trucks are planned. The year-by-year mine development and equipment operation is described in detail from 2008 until 2012. A detailed time schedule of main measures and activities required for mine development was given: 2006 II III IV
2007 I
II III IV
2008 I
II III IV
2009 I
II III IV
2010 I
II
2011
III IV
I
II
2012
III IV
I
II
III IV
Foundation of a Project Development Group
Engineering
Development Engineering (KEK) Project Support and Training Business and Annual Mining Plans Detailed Surveying of Opening up Area Additional Geological Exploration and Modelling Special Geological Investigations (f.e. Seismic)
Dewatering
Environment Impact Assessment Drainage of Water Ponds Construction of Box Culvert Construction of Channels
Resettlement
Landaccquisition
74 ha
22 ha
Establishment Local Resettlement Office Resettlement of Hade West
Preparation
Resettlement of next Villages
Preparation
Road from Hade to Grabovc Infrastructure
Construction of Erection Yard Main Roads Warehouse, Workshop and Petrol Station Washroom and Sanitary Facilities New Office Building and Mine Control Centre
Mechanic, Electric & Communication
Rehabilitation E10B; Belt Conveyors; P3B Rehabilitation E8M Rehabilitation E9M; Belt Conveyors; P4M Rehabilitation E10M; Belt Conveyors; P3M Rehabilitation E9B; Belt Conveyors Rehabilitation E5M, BRs Rehabilitation E8B; Belt Conveyors Rehabilitation E7M, BRs Power Supply System
Central Remote Control System Coal Quality Management System
Mining
Application of mobile Fleet Commissioning of Overburden Systems Commissioning of Coal Systems Rearrangement of Overburden Belt Connections Specification
Fig.: 1.3-2
Tendering Process
Realisation
Main Measures and Activities for Mine Development
Page 18 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
In the 5-year period 2013-2017 the mine will develop into northern direction. After passing of the village Hade operation switches to slewing operation for a short period. From 2016 total cutting thickness will increase so that mobile operation for removing the excess heights shall be re-installed. During that period the overburden masses are dumped in the residual pit of Bardh/Mirash. In this period will be resettled the communities of Mirene and Shipitulla East. Within the period 2018-2022 the overburden thickness increases along the whole mining face. The 3rd overburden cut will changeover to inside dumping in the Sibovc SW mine. The other two overburden lines will continue dumping in the residual pit of Mirash / Bardh. Aim is the producing of large final dump surface areas. Parts of Hade North must be resettled in 2019. In the period 2023-2024 the mine will further develop into the north until it reaches the preliminary final position. The regular overburden systems will continue parallel operation into northern direction whereby the great cutting heights from the previous operating period will remain. The dumping system will also be maintained. Complete closure of the residual space of the former Mirash/Bardh mines cannot be achieved until 2024. In 2023 parts of the community of Konxhul have to be resettled. Ceasing of coal mining operations in 2024 would result in a number of negative aspects which would incur expensive subsequent work at the residual pits. Continuation of the mining is recommended and offers the following advantages: -
Continuing mining activities would lead to an improved overburden : coal ratio.
-
The residual pit of the former Bardh / Mirash mine could be closed finally.
-
Continuation of dumping in the Sibovc SW mine improves the safety in the long-run.
Some consequences for the development of the existing mines have been described with regard to an optimization of the mining development in the Sibovc SW mine. These adaptations are necessary for a smoothly opening-up of the new mine. In this context the Mid Term Plan for the existing mines has to be revised.
1.3.2 Dewatering The Kosova Basin forms a smoothly shaped plain that is bordered by hills and mountains. This basin includes a developed hydrological network with the Sitnica river as main collector. Based on the survey of drainage areas and expected water flow a detailed surface water catchment system was designed. Drainage of surface water via the active bench of the Sibovc SW mine shall be excluded except residual rainwater quantities. It is suggested to install a dewatering system in the valley from which the collected surface water is pumped into the higher located channel(s) by means of sewage pumps. According to the OCM advance the dewatering shall be shifted several times to the North.
Page 19 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The first surface dewatering measure in the field Sibovc SW must be the drainage of the water ponds in the opening-up area beginning from summer 2006. The quantity of water to be pumped directly from the Sibovc SW mine will continuously increase with progressing opencast mine development. Drainage ditches shall be installed on all working levels and along the access roads. The water pumped from the main dewatering plants shows increased contents of chloride and sulphate as well as clear contents of suspended matter, consisting of dust or organic matter. When discharging the water, special attention shall be drawn to separate the suspended materials. It will be necessary to install additional sedimentation basins on the surface level before feeding the water into the rivers.
1.3.3 Mine Closure and Recultivation Planning The proposed main principles are: -
The areas occupied by mining shall be recovered in such a way that the later use will be rather better than the original one.
-
Areas which are no longer needed for mining activities shall be recultivated as soon as possible.
-
Financial means will be reserved already during the active mining operations to ensure the proper closure of the mining field.
-
Authorities and the concerned people (later users) are integrated in the process of planning and detailed shaping of the post-mining areas.
The area claimed for mining will come to 5 km² within the period until 2024. Until 2024 totally 383 ha final dump areas can be shaped, completely situated in the Bardh/Mirash mine. This balance does not include: -
the former outside dumps of the Bardh and Mirash mines;
-
the reserved area for ash dumping in the Mirash East area;
-
the reserved area for sanitary landfill in the Mirash Brand area incl. slope systems.
According to the Mid Term Plan the former outside dumps shall be prepared for a future use and sale by the existing opencast mines. For the operating period until 2024 a total sum of 325 ha land have to be purchased. After closure of the residual area of the Bardh/Mirash mine by spreading the overburden material from the Sibovc mine, the areas shall be intended for agricultural use to provide substitute areas for claimed ones. Main aim for shaping the post-mining field is to provide a high share of areas which allow for an agricultural use. In general, the dump area shall represent a high-value landscape element in which agricultural use and habitat for local fauna and flora will exist in parallel. Principle measures for achieving these goals are defined.
Page 20 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1.3.4 Resettlement and Relocation The land swaps affected by resettlement are mainly private property. The opencast mine of Sibovc will claim the following areas: Claim of Land for Sibovc Digging
Safety Zone
Total
Property of KEK
Land Acquisition
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
2006-2010
128
36
15
179
105
74
2011-2012
35
4
39
17
22
2013-2017
133
16
149
55
94
2018-2022
102
14
116
0
122
2023-2024
14
4
18
1
17
Total
412
74
501
172
329
Year
Tab.: 1.3-1
Channel Infras structure [ha]
15
Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW
The following resettlement and relocation measures shall be executed for the claim of land: -
Land purchase
-
Resettlement of properties of the settlement with scattered buildings of Sibovc (Hade West, Hade North (extension), Mirene, ShipitullaEast and Konxhul)
-
Compensation of property
-
New construction of a by-pass from Hade to Sibovc
-
New construction of a by-pass from Sibovc to Grabovc
At present, the old resettlement law dating back to the Serbian era is still applicable. A new law is only available in a draft version. To ensure the legal bases of lignite extraction and the required land purchase in the future Sibovc field it is necessary to declare this area as reserved mining area. To prepare the resettlement and/or compensation, the residents of the concerned communities shall be informed as soon as possible and questionnaires shall be offered regarding the desired kind of compensation. Recommendations for the resettlement procedure based on the wide experience of the consultant have been provided. The options for providing properties for a joint and/of separate resettlement of the household shall be checked by KEK on the basis of land owned by KEK currently. A democratic socially acceptable resettlement procedure compliant to EU law would take at least 8 years.
Page 21 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The resettlement of Hade West must be completed by the end of the year of 2009. It is necessary to have a tight project organisation with responsibilities and freedom of action for the head of the project. The total costs for resettlements and compensations amount to approx. 32 MEURO.
1.3.5 Manpower The manpower of the Sibovc SW mine will be recruited mainly from the personnel of KEK. The following table gives a survey on the staffing requirements: Year
2007
Existing mines per 01.01. - Fluctuation / Redundancy Staff transfer
3500
2009
2010
2011
2012
490
3000 415
2100 300
1300 100
900 470
350 260
10
485
500
300
80
40
1380
1420
15
Sibovc SW per 31.12. Tab.: 1.3-2
2008
500
1000
1300
Number of Personnel
Staff for the new mine will be employed mainly from redundant staff of the existing mines.
Employees 3500
Staff in Sibovc SW 3000
Staff in Mirash/Bardh
2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 2007
Fig.: 1.3-3
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Manpower Development
Page 22 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2 Introduction 2.1 Background Kosovo has lignite reserves assessed at some 10 billion tons, concentrated in the Kosovo Coal Basin. This coal deposit, especially the Sibovc deposit is regarded as one of the best throughout Europe. The geological context of Sibovc is characterised by an average stripping ratio 1.0 to 1.2 m³ of overburden per 1 ton of lignite. The new mine Sibovc South West is a part of this favourable lignite deposit. The first coal supply is expected in 2010. Up to this time the existing mine (former Bardh and Mirash mine) supplies TPP Kosovo A and Kosovo B. Around 97% of the total generation capacity comes from these two coal-fired power plants, while hydropower accounts for only 3%. KEK has established a Coal Production Division (CPD) being responsible for coal production, transportation, separation and stocking activities before the coal is eventually delivered to the power plants. The existing mine has been in operation since 1963/64. This mine is located in the same field in the central northern part of Kosovo Lignite Basin. The overburden and coal excavation is carried out by continuous systems: Bucket Wheel Excavator – Belt Conveyors – Spreader and Bucket Wheel Excavator – Belt Conveyors – Separation Plants – TPP. At the present time the mine is actually capable of supplying the power plants within around 6 to 7 mt/a of coal. In 2009 the lignite production in the existing mine begins to drop (at the projected rate of consumption) and in the following year coal supply from the new mine should start. The reason to head in northern direction with a new mine is because expansion of the existing mine into the east is impeded by surface water issues. An expansion to the south is impeded by an unfavourable overburden to coal ratio and large outside dumps from earlier mine developments. Along the northeast side of the mine is the village Hade, which poses an equally significant challenge to settle a significant resettlement. In order to maintain the supply of coal to Kosovo A and Kosovo B power stations, KEK should develop the new mine in a way of by-passing Hade. This is the subject of the mining plan Sibovc SW.
2.2 Approach / Methodology According to the existing situation and pursuant to the TOR the project work has been mainly focused on the following activities: 1)
Assumption of the future coal demand
2)
Revision of geological model including - Analysis of available borehole and other exploration data - Localization of cracks and geological faults, - Calculation of minable reserves
3)
Calculation of mining development and equipment application including Page 23 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
- Mining development in opening-up phase (5 years) in annual steps, - Further mining development up to 2025 in 5-year-steps, - Application of the main equipment - Calculation of auxiliary and ancillary processes 4)
Revision of environmental investigations
5)
Financial calculations
General Approach The plan describes the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures. Special focus has been given on investment and the required resettlement including land acquisition to guarantee the operation of the new mine. The complementary mining plan is in compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations. Approach for Mining The Sibovc SW mining plan bases on related projects (financed by the European Agency for Reconstruction), which are for instance the Mid term Mining Plan for the existing mines (completed in April 2005) and the Main Mining Plan Sibovc (completed in the June/August 2005). The Steag â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Consortium has elaborated the CMP (complementary mining plan) for first 5 years (opening-up phase; 2008 -2012) on an annual basis and with an outlook covering the entire mining field Sibovc SW. Approach for Environment The assessment of the environmental situation is based on available data base (data available per February 2006) and is an update of the environmental assessment of the main mine plan. The budget and time frame did not allow carrying out own environmental measurings since only 15 man days were planned for the updating. Thus further measures should be performed (organised by KEK / Ministry) in order to meet European standards. Approach for economic and financial Analysis A complex finance mathematic consideration will be made resulting in the real average costs per t of run of mine coal. The economic analysis will identify possible project risks regarding the costs and achievable price. Where major variations are expected over the project life, sensitivity tests will be applied. The economic and financial analysis will reflect the proposed investment programme. It is assumed for the mining plan that KEK will have access to the investment as required. This assumption was approved during the Kick-off Meeting.
Page 24 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Within the first years 236 mâ&#x201A;Ź (real) will be required. The most important and crucial part of the investment is the refurbishment of main mine equipment (MME), which amounts to 158 MEURO. The consultant points out that without a timely refurbishment of the MME the fuel supply from Sibovc to the existing TPPâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s can not be provided as planned.
Page 25 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3 Coal Demand A detailed output programme with the medium- and long-term fuel supply demand of the different power plants was not available at project start. According to the decision made at the Kick-off Meeting an assumption about the coal demand was agreed â&#x20AC;&#x201C; amounting to 9 mt/a. This coal demand was agreed between KEK, EAR, MEM and the Consultant. If this coal demand would be changed the mining plan would need an alteration too. This could not be done within the planned time schedule. Nevertheless the mining plan will be adaptable (to a great deal without problems) in a range of +10% of the envisaged coal demand. Year
Existing Mines
Sibovc SW
Total
2006
6.8
-
6.8
2007
7.2
-
7.2
2008
7.9
-
7.9
2009
7.8
-
7.8
2010
4.6
3.4
8.0
2011
3.0
6.0
9.0
2012
-
9.0
9.0
2013
-
9.0
9.0
2014
-
9.0
9.0
2015
-
9.0
9.0
2016
-
9.0
9.0
2017
-
9.0
9.0
2018
-
9.0
9.0
2019
-
9.0
9.0
2020
-
9.0
9.0
2021
-
9.0
9.0
2022
-
9.0
9.0
2023
-
9.0
9.0
2024
-
6.0
6.0
Total
37.3
123.4
160.7
Tab.: 2.2-1
Coal Demand
Page 26 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The following principles / assumptions have been made: -
Generating electricity from Sibovc SW pursues the goal to meet domestic needs mainly.
-
After depletion of the existing mines the new Sibovc SW mine supplies the existing power plants Kosovo A and B. The coal supply from the new mine has to start in 2010.
-
The life time for Kosovo B is about 40 years, which means end of operation in 2023/24.
-
Hence the life time of Sibovc SW will be defined from 2008 to 2024, which means 17 years. Preparatory work will be required in 2007.
-
Three of five units of Kosovo A (200/210 MW) started production between 1970 and 1975. These units do not fulfil normal technical standards. Opinions to refurbish these units (capital refurbishment or major overhaul) differ a lot. However it is assumed that the coal supply to Kosovo A will last for the time being (amounting to 2.5 - 4.7 mt). In case Kosovo A will be out of operation before 2020/24 the new mine will deliver the coal to the TPP replacing Kosovo A. At least the fuel supply is calculated with 9 mt in total for Sibovc SW.
-
It is assumed that the investment needed for opening-up the new mine will be made available timely.
Page 27 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4 Mining Technology of the Sibovc SW Mine 4.1 General Remarks / Preconditions The planning was made to directly follow up mining operations of existing mine. The planning basis for development of existing mine is the Mid Term Mining Plan, which has been finished in March 2005. The main task of the study is the fuel supply of the existing Thermal Power Plants up to the end of their lifetime (2024). This corresponds to a coal delivery of about 160.7 mt, beginning from 1st January onwards (thereof 37.3 mt from existing mine and 123.4 mt from the new Sibovc SW mine). Being the most efficient mining field the south western part of the coal field Sibovc has been selected, considering an annual output of about 9 mt. Basic investigations and a ranking of different future mining fields has already been done in the Main Mining Plan for the new Sibovc Mine in 2005. Regarding minimum investment costs for the new mine, the further use of the existing main equipment has been planned. Considering the technical state and the annual mass volume the following main equipment has been selected. Coal operation
3 excavator SRs 1300 (E8M, E9B, E8B) 1 excavator SRs 400 (E7M) + belt wagon
Overburden operation
1 excavator SRs 1300 (E10B) + 1600 mm belts + spreader (P3B) 1 excavator SchRs 650 (E10M) + 1800 mm belts + spreader (P3M) 1 excavator SchRs 650 (E9M) + 1800 mm belts + spreader (P4M) 1 excavator SRs 470 (E5M) + belt wagon
The partly refurbished excavator E1B has been considered as float machine for the mine Sibovc SW. He is suitable for operation in overburden to a limited extent only.
Page 28 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.2 Technological Equipment Parameter The basic technology is among others determined by the constructive parameters of the available main mine equipment. For planning purposes the following parameters has been used: Type
SchRs 650 (E9M, E10M) SRs 1300.24 (E8B, E9B, E10B) SRs 1300.26 (E8M) SRs 470.20/3.0 (E5M) SRs 400.14/1.0 (E7M) SRs 315.15/3.5 (E1B) Tab.: 4.2-1
SchRs 650 (E 9M, E10M) SRs 1300.24 (E8B, E9B, E10B)
(E8M) SRs 470.20/3.0 (E5M) SRs 400.14/1.0 (E7M) SRs 315.15/3.5 (E1B) Tab.: 4.2-2
Width of machine
Height of machine
Bucket wheel diameter
Mid of bucket wheel to mid of excavator
Mid of excavator to mid of discharge chute
m
m
m
m
m
m
141
24
36
10.56
36
90
125
22
32
9
36.5
82.5
135
22
32
9
36.96
92
62
15.5
22.5
6.7
31
25
42
12
13
7.5
14.5
22.5
50
15.5
22
6.3
23.2
22.5
Basic Geometry of the Bucket Wheel Excavators
Type
SRs 1300.26
Length of machine
Max. cutting height
Max. cutting depth
Block width
28
5
45 (2 times)
26 (24)
5
37
26
5
37 / 45
20
3
30.6
14
1
18
15
3.5
22
Cutting Heights and Block Width of Excavators [m]
Page 29 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type
Smallest curve radius
Max. longitudinal inclination
Max. cross inclination
Admissible inclination for transport
m
-
-
-
60
1 : 25
1 : 25
1 : 20
1 : 33 or
1 : 20 or
1: 20
1 : 33
1 : 33 or
1: 20 or
1 : 20
1 : 33
1 : 33
1 : 33
1 : 33
1 : 33
1 : 20
1 : 33
1 : 30
1 : 50
1 : 20
1 : 30
SchRs 650 (E9M, E10M) SRs 1300.24 (E8B, E9B, E10B) SRs 1300.26
80
80
(E8M) SRs 470.20/3.0 (E5M) SRs 400.14/1.0 (E7M) SRs 315.15/3.5 (E1B) Tab.: 4.2-3
1 : 20
1 : 20
1 : 20
Maximum Inclination of Working Levels and Curve Radii of Excavators
A2Rs-B 4400.60
A2Rs-B 5200.55
(P3B)
(P3M, P4M)
Length of Spreader
m
115
110
Width of Spreader
m
16
16
Height of Spreader
m
20
20
Length of Receiving Boom
m
58
49
Length of Discharge Boom
m
56
54
Max. Dumping Height
m
17
18
Block Width
m
40
40
Smallest Curve Radius
m
10
10
Max. longitudinal Inclination
-
1 : 33
1 : 33
Max. cross Inclination
-
1 : 33
1 : 33
Adm. Inclination for Transport
-
Tab.: 4.2-4
1 : 33
1 : 20
1 : 33
1 : 20
Technical Data of Spreaders
Page 30 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
BRs 1200.29/32 Theoretical Capacity
lcm/h
1,800
Length of Machine
m
65
Width of Machine
m
12
Height of Machine
m
17
Length of Receiving Boom
m
29
Length of Discharge Boom
m
32
Max. Dumping Height
m
14
Smallest Curve Radius
m
7
Max. longitudinal Inclination
-
1 : 33
Max. cross Inclination
-
1 : 33
Adm. Inclination for Transport
-
Tab.: 4.2-5
1 : 33
1 : 20
Technical Data of Belt Wagon
ESch 10/70 (A10) Bucket capacity
mÂł
10
Boom Length
m
70
Radius of Digging and Discharging
m
66.5
Max. Height of Discharging
m
27.5
Max. Cutting Depth
m
35
Cycle Time (135°)
sec
52.5
Ground Pressure (Working)
MPa
0.097
Ground Pressure (Transport)
MPa
0.166
Transport Velocity
km/h
0.2
Tab.: 4.2-6
Technical Data of Dragline ESch 10/70
Page 31 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3 Capability / Capacity Calculation for MME The following equipment application scheme is foreseen. The overburden will be extracted by 3 equipment lines. While the upper benches are working with one excavator in high cut operation, in the coal uncovering cut will be use 2 excavators in a main cut and a deep cut for cleaning the coal. For local excess heights the application of a mobile fleet has been planned. In coal operation there will be used also three equipment lines with 1,600 mm belt conveyor lines. The three bench belt conveyors are linked with 2 head belt conveyor systems of the same width. On the surface the coal can be distributed to both power plants, via two longdistance belt conveyor lines each, with different belt width. The following table illustrates the principle equipment application.
Coal
Overburden
Local application of mobile equipment E10B
SRs 1300
1,600 mm belt conveyor line
Spreader P3B
E10M
SchRs 650
1,800 mm belt conveyor line
Spreader P3M
E9M
SchRs 650 SRs 470
1,800 mm belt conveyor line
Spreader P4M
E5M E8M
SRs 1300
E9B
SRs 1300
E8B
SRs 1300
E7M
Tab.: 4.3-1
SRs 400
Bench belt conveyors
1,600 mm 1,600 mm 1,600 mm
Head belt conveyors
1,600 mm
1,600 mm
Overland belt conveyors
1,800 mm
Stockpile A
1,200 mm 1,400 mm 1,400 mm
Stockpile B
Principle Equipment Application
4.3.1 Capability of Excavators The capacity calculation and/or assessment of excavator capacities bases on the estimation of the principle capability of the equipment under the conditions of the Sibovc SW deposit, whereby a tolerance range is taken into account (lower and upper limit). This range describes the practical capacity considering the impact of: a)
Different digging materials in overburden removal
b)
Climate / weather conditions (snow, fog, rain)
c)
Skills and motivation of employees
All relevant influencing parameters are considered when determining the overburden and coal capacities. These influencing parameters are split into two columns. Firstly, the influencing factors, which determine the filling and the emptying of the excavator buckets. Resulting from this the load factor (and/or excavator effect ΡB) is yielded, thus the hourly capacity and secondly, the time factors [time factor ΡT], which determine the annual output capacity. The following scheme gives an overview of the calculation method.
Page 32 of 171
Tb = TbA - Ts
VE = Ve * Tb
Tb = TbA * EtaTA Ve = Vth * EtaB
EtaB = fbu * fload
Subdivision of Tb
Tb = Tk - Tp -Ts
or
Tb = Tk * EtaT
or
Ve = Vtheo * fload
Vtheo = Vth * fbu
Vth = Vbu * nbu* 60
Ts = Tb * s Ts = TbA * sA
TbA = Tk -Tp Tb =Tb1+Tb2+Tb3+Tb4
Tb1
planned
not planned
High Cut
Tp = Tp1 +Tp2 +Tp3
Ts = Ts1 +Ts2 +Ts3+Ts4+Ts5
Tb2 Deep Cut
Tp1 Working time regime (shift use)
Tb3 special operation (reduced performance) Tb4 double removed masses
Tp2 Transport
Tp3 Planned Maintenance
Fig.: 4.3-1
Principle Calculation Scheme of Effective Capacity
Ts1 technical breakdowns on BWE Ts2 standstill, operational reasons on BWE Ts3 standstill caused by conveyor system Ts4 standstill via mining system / Environm. Ts5 other standstills
4.3.1.1 Load Factor â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Expression of the hourly Capacity Basis of the calculation is the theoretical capacity of the single machines which is determined by the construction/mechanical engineering. This theoretical digging capacity (Vth in lcm/h) is determined from the bucket size (Vbu) and the bucket discharges (nd). In most cases, the manufacturer specifies it as round value and it includes a volume portion of the cell space of the bucket wheel. The theoretical digging capacity (Vth in lcm/h and Vtheo in bcm/h or t/h) Vth = Vbu * nd * 60 Theoretical Capacity
Bucket capacity
Number of buckets
Rotation bucket wheel
Number of discharges
Calculated
According documentation
Vbu
nbu
Ubu
nd
Vth(calc)
Vth
lcm
-
1 / min
1 / min
lcm/h
lcm/h
0.65
21
5.15
108
4,212
4,212
(E8B, E9B and E10B) original
0.52
18
7.14 /5.857
128.6
4,011
4,000
currently
0.52
21
7.5
157.5
4,914
original
0.52
23
5.857
134.7
4,203
currently
0.52
23
7.5
172.5
5,382
0.47
8
7.5
60
1,692
1,690
0.52
12
5.83
70
2,184
2,200
Typ
SchRs 650 (E9M, E10M) SRs 1300.24
SRs 1300.26 (E8M)
4,200
SRs 470 (E5M) SRs 400 (E7M) Tab.: 4.3-2
Theoretical Digging Capacity in lcm/h
The minable solid and compact masses are of special practical interest. In order to take this into account the loosening of the excavated material (overburden or coal) inside the digging tool (bucket) has to be considered. This value mainly depends from the excavated material itself and to a certain extent from the form of the cut (kind of excavation) and the bucket form. For the conditions in Sibovc SW the following can be applied:
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Type
Material
Overburden (Clay)
SchRs 650
Theoretical digging Capacity
Loosening in Bucket
Theoretical Capacity
Vth
fbu
Vtheo
lcm/h
lcm/bcm
bcm/h
4,212
1.55
2,700
t/h
(E9M,E10M) Coal Overburden (Clay)
SRs 1300.24
1.7 4,000
1.55
2,800 2,580
(E8B,E9B,E10B) Coal Overburden (Clay)
SRs 1300.26
1.7 4,200
1.55
2,680 2,700
(E8M) Coal Overburden (Clay)
SRs 470
2,800
1.7 1,690
1.55
1,090
(E5M) Coal Overburden (Clay)
SRs 400
1,130
1.7 -
-
-
(E7M) Coal Tab.: 4.3-3
2,200
1.7
1,475
Theoretical Capacity in bcm/h and t/h
The effective capacity Ve: Ve = Vth * fbu * fload Ve = Vtheo * fload Considerations of the effective capacity focus on the present capacity level for reasons of comparison. It has to be born in mind when considering these figures that the previously realised capacities were negatively influenced by the insufficient technical state and the inadequate organisation and lack of motivation. This realized capacity level which is considered too low shall be raised by means of implementing several measures. One example for the reduced capacity in the existing mine was the fact that excavation was not continuously carried out in full block operation (partly due to instable and failing slopes). Moreover, the discharging system (belt conveyor and spreader) cut down the possible excavator capacity. Further reductions were caused by the excavation of slide masses. Before their use in Sibovc SW, all machines will be refurbished. This measure aims at improving the realisable load factor directly.
Page 35 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The human factor has also decisive influence on the actual result (effective capacity). In order to allow for this fact and the specific conditions, a maximum bucket filling (load factor) is indicated. Theoretical Capacity Type
2,700 bcm/h
(E9M, E10M)
SRs 1300.24
2,580 bcm/h
(E10B)
SRs 470
1,090 bcm/h
(E5M)
Tab.: 4.3-4
Effective Capacity
fload
Ve
%
bcm/h
Currently
23%
615 bcm/h
Plan Mid Term
27%
740 bcm/h
Max Sibovc SW
37%
1,000 bcm/h
Currently (2004)
18%
470 bcm/h
Plan Mid Term
22%
575 bcm/h
Max Sibovc SW
33%
850 bcm/h
Currently
23%
250 bcm/h
Plan Mid Term
28%
300 bcm/h
Max Sibovc SW
28%
300 bcm/h
Vtheo bcm/h
SchRs 650
Load factor
Validity
-
Effective Capacity of Excavators - Overburden
Further capacity increases cannot be assumed for the conditions in Kosovo within the period under review. Additionally, a relatively high portion of ramp excavation is to be accomplished in Sibovc SW which lowers the excavator effects. It was considered that selective mining / quality management will slightly reduce the excavator effect in the coal operation too. Type
SRs 1300.24
Theoretical Capacity
Validity
Load factor
Effective Capacity
Vtheo
-
fload
Ve
t/h
-
%
t/h
2,680 t/h
Max Sibovc SW
45%
1,200 t/h
2,800 t/h
Max Sibovc SW
43%
1,200 t/h
1,475 t/h
Currently
20%
295 t/h
Plan Mid Term
30%
440 t/h
Max Sibovc SW
35%
515 t/h
(E8B,E9B)
SRs 1300.26 (E8M)
SRs 400 (E7M)
Tab.: 4.3-5
Effective Capacity of Excavator - Coal
Page 36 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The human factor plays an important role for the load factor. For the long-term planning it is assumed that -
qualified / experiences personnel is employed,
-
the personnel is better motivated than presently and
-
losses due to missing spare parts will be reduced.
4.3.1.2 Time Factor The annual capacity (VE) achievable is determined by the actual operating hours (Tb) depending primarily on the chosen operation regime (planned working and maintenance time) and the unscheduled stops (down-times). VE = Ve * Tb VE = Ve * Tk * ηT Tk = Tb + Ts + Tp VE = Ve * (Tk-Tp) * ηTA VE…effective annual capacity
in bcm/a
Ve …effective hourly capacity
in bcm/h
Tb…operating time
in h
Tk…calendar time
in h
ηT…time factor regarding calendar time
in %
Ts …time for unscheduled standstills
in h
Tp….time for planned standstills
in h
ηTA .time factor regarding available working time
in %
The table below which contains the range of planned operating time assumes the following premises: a)
The calendar time of 8,760 h per year is assumed as potential working time
b)
An annual 3-weeks general repair is scheduled
c)
2 shifts per week are reserved for short maintenance / function tests and shifting
d)
Unscheduled stops are taken into account with 5% - 7% of the possible working time
Page 37 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
e)
Handing over of shifts is performed on the equipment
It is furthermore differentiated between a so-called normal and maximum capacity. This enables consideration of influencing factors like: a)
Meteorological conditions (stop due to fog, continuous rain, extreme freeze and wind)
b)
Utilization of shift working time (usual rate is 80% -90%)
c)
Time needed for auxiliary works / smaller shifting operations and transports
d)
Human factor (efforts of personnel / work organisation) and
e)
Reserve time.
All these influences are also taken into account for the so-called maximum capacities. In case of a lot of unfavourable factors occurring exceptionally in one year, the achievable operating time reduces towards the normal value. The following table includes the absolute efficient working time: Validity
Normal-daily capacity
Calendar Time
Operating Time
Time Factor
Tk
Tb
ΡT
h
h
%
24
19.2
80
21.6
90
110.4
65.7
128.2
76.3
385
52.7
484
66.3
4,266
48.7
5,474
62.5
Maximum daily capacity Normal weekly capacity
168
Maximum weekly capacity Normal monthly capacity
730
Maximum monthly capacity Normal annual capacity
8,760
Maximum annual capacity Tab.: 4.3-6
Planned Working Time of Single Equipment
Page 38 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3.1.3 Capability of Excavators Basing on the above mentioned down-times / operating times the following normal and maximum capacities result for the planning of Sibovc SW: Operating Time
SRs 470
SchRs 650
SRs 1300
300 bcm/h
1,000 bcm/h
850 bcm/h
Tb
VE
VE
VE
h
‘000 bcm
‘000 bcm
‘000 bcm
Normal daily capacity
19.2
5.7
19.2
16.32
Max. daily capacity
21.6
6.5
21.6
18.36
Normal weekly capacity
110
33
110
94
Max. weekly capacity
128
38
128
109
Normal monthly capacity
385
115
385
327
Max. monthly capacity
484
145
484
411
Normal annual capacity
4,266
1,280
4,266
3,626
Max. annual capacity
5,474
1,640
5,474
4,653
Tab.: 4.3-7
Normal and Maximum Capacity - Overburden
There is only a low interdependence between the systems due to the relatively low number of machines and the mine development planned in detail resulting in a very low reduction of the overall of capacity (low system interdependence). The long-term planned overall capacity for the overburden operation is shown in the table below: Reliable VE
Maximum VE
SRs 1300 (E10B)
3.6
4.6
SchRs 650 (E9M)
4.3
5.4
SchRs 650 (E10M)
4.3
5.4
SRs 470 (E5M)
1.3
1.6
Total
13.5
17.0
Tab.: 4.3-8
Capability of BWE in Overburden Operation [mbcm/a]
The listed excavators are therefore in principle capable of meeting the required coal uncovering of 9 mt per year (Ratio Overburden to Coal is 1.7 : 1 m³/t).
Page 39 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Operating Time
SRs 1300.24
SRs 1300.26
SRs 400
1,200 t/h
1,200 t/h
515 t/h
Tb
VE
VE
VE
h
kt
kt
kt
Normal daily capacity
19.2
23.0
23.0
9.9
Max. daily capacity
21.6
25.9
25.9
11.1
Normal weekly capacity
110.4
132
132
57
Max. weekly capacity
128.2
153
153
66
Normal monthly capacity
385
462
462
198
Max. monthly capacity
484
580
580
249
Normal annual capacity
4,266
5,120
5,120
2,190
Max. annual capacity
5,474
6,560
6,560
2,810
Tab.: 4.3-9
Capability of Excavators in Coal Operation
Regarding the foreseen excavators in the coal operation (3 * SRs 1300 and 1 * SRs 400) it would be theoretically possible to extract up to 22.3 mt coal. The before mentioned data are annual specifications which are only valid for the single excavators without consideration of the connected belt conveyor system and requirements to coal quality management.
Reliable VE
Maximum VE
SRs 1300 (E8M)
5.1
6.5
SRs 1300 (E9B)
5.1
6.5
SRs 1300 (E8B)
5.1
6.5
SRs 400
2.2
2.8
Total
17.5
22.3
Tab.: 4.3-10
Nominal Capacity of Coal Excavators
Page 40 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3.2 Capability of Belt Conveyors For the Sibovc SW project belt conveyors will be used with a width between 1,800mm and 1,400mm. The capacity of such conveyor belts depends on: -
Belt width
-
Belt troughing
-
Belt speed
-
Utilization ratio of belt width
-
Inclination and
-
Bulk density of material
Further the following factors should be considered in order to define the effective capacity of the conveyor belt: -
Climatic conditions (especially rain)
-
Skills and motivation of employees
The capability of the belt conveyor with a belt troughing of 36° is determined according to the following relation: me = Ve * ρl Ve = A * vc * fi * 3600 Ve = we * we * (390 + 725 * tan φ) * vc * fi we = 0.9 * wc - 0.05 ρl … density of the conveyed material, loose
in t/lcm
Ve …effective conveying capacity on the belt
in lcm/h
A … bulk surface of the conveyed material
in m²
vc …speed of the belt conveyor
in m/s
fi … factor considering belt inclination
-
we …effective belt width
in m
wc …belt width
in m
φ …. angle of repose
in °
Density and maximum belt inclination for the conveyed material:
Page 41 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Bulk density
Angle of repose
Maximum inclination
t/lcm
°
°
Overburden, dry
1.6 – 1.7
15
17
Overburden, wet
1.7 – 1.8
4
10 - 15
0.75
15
18 - 20
Material
Coal Tab.: 4.3-11
Bulk Density, Angel of Repose and Inclination of Belt Conveyor
Inclination βc
0°
12°
15°
18°
20°
22°
25°
fi
1
0.97
0.93
0.89
0.85
0.84
0.78
Tab.: 4.3-12
Factor fi for Considering the Inclination
Example for determining capacity of the 1,800 mm belt conveyor: Effective belt width
we = 0.9 * 1.8m + 0.5 = 1.57 m
Vc … 4.5 m/s φ … 10° conveying capacity (φ = 10°) Ve = 1.572 * (390+725 tan 10°) * 4.5 fi = 5,743 * fi lm³/h
4.3.2.1 Overburden Belt Conveyor System Summarizing, the following volume streams (bold figures) for a 1,800mm respectively 1,600mm belt conveyor has been calculated. Basis of the calculations were the following technical conditions. -
Angle of repose
10°
-
Belt inclination
10°
-
Velocity of belt conveyor
4.5 m/s
Width
Bulk surface
Belt inclination
mm
m²
°
4.5 m/s
5.24 m/s
1,600
0.3017
0°
4,502
5,243
10°
4,412
5,138
15°
4,187
4,876
0°
5,744
6,688
10°
5,629
6,554
15°
5,342
6,220
1,800
0.3545
Tab.: 4.3-13
Conveying capacity in lcm/h
Possible Conveying Capacity for Overburden Belt Conveyors
Page 42 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3.2.2 Coal Belt Conveyor System Summarizing, the following volume and mass streams (bold figures) for a 1,600mm respectively 1,400mm belt conveyor has been calculated. Basis of the calculations were the following technical conditions. -
Angle of repose
15°
-
Belt inclination
10° / 0°
-
Velocity of belt conveyor
3.5 m/s respectively 4.65 m/s
Width
Velocity
Bulk surface
Belt inclination
mm
m/s
m²
°
lcm/h
t/h
1,600
3.5
0°
3,950
2,965
10°
3,870
2,900
20°
3,360
2,518
0°
3,975
2,983
10°
3,900
2,924
20°
3,380
2,536
1,400
4.65
Tab.: 4.3-14
Conveying capacity
Possible Conveying Capacity for Coal Belt Conveyors
4.3.2.3 Dependencies and Conclusions When determining the quantity throughput of the planned overburden conveyor systems, two different cases were distinguished: -
Loading with the respective main winning equipment on the bench
-
Simultaneous loading of 2 excavators to one belt conveyor
It was assumed that loading with only one excavator can achieve a maximum of 100 % of the theoretical performance for a short period. In case of using a second excavator for loading and homogenization of the two conveyed material flows, a maximum of 85% of the theoretical conveying capacity will be achieved. The following tables summarize the results of the calculation:
Page 43 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1st Bench
Bench
Max Load Factor Max. Veff
3rd Bench
E10B
E10B + SRs 470
E10M
E9M
E9M + E5M
[lcm/h]
4,000
4,000 1,690
4,212
4,212
4,212 1,690
[%]
100
85
100
100
85
[lcm/h]
4,000
4,840
4,212
4,212
5,015
Excavator Type Vtheor
2nd Bench
Belt Width
[mm]
1,600
1,800
1,800
Belt Velocity
[m/s]
4.5
4.5
4.5
[째]
36
36
36
[lcm/h]
4,412
5,629
5,629
Angle of Side Idler Volume Stream Capacity Reserve Tab.: 4.3-15
[%]
10
-10
33
33
12
Loading Utilisation of Overburden Systems
Loading of the envisaged belt conveyor lines by the respective excavator (SRs 1300 and/or SchRs 650) is possible without restrictions. The full theoretical capacity of the excavators can be achieved with capacity reserves of the belt conveyor to the amount of 10% (1,600 mm) and/or 33% (1,800 mm). Additional charging of the 1,600 mm belt conveyor by an excavator SRs 470 is not applicable. A deep stage in the 3rd overburden system has to be carried along to uncover the coal. The excavator SRs 470 (E5M) used here and the main extraction machine can operate at the same time. The capacity reserve of the 1,800 mm belt conveyor reduces with simultaneous loading to 12%. 1st Bench
2nd Bench
E8M
E9B
E8B
E8B + E7M
[lcm/h]
4,200
4,000
4,000
4,000 2,200
[%]
90
90
90
75
[lcm/h]
3,780
3,600
3,600
4,650
Belt Width
[mm]
1,600
1,600
1,600
Belt Velocity
[m/s]
3.5
3.5
3.5
[째]
36
36
36
[lcm/h]
3,870
3,870
3,870
[%]
2
7
Bench Excavator Type Vtheor Max Load Factor Max. Veff
Angle of Side Idler Volume Stream Capacity Reserve Tab.: 4.3-16
3rd Bench
7
- 17
Loading Utilisation of Coal Systems
Page 44 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The capacity of the coal belt conveyors is determined especially by the connecting belt conveyor system to the power plant and the installations on the Stockpile. The theoretical capacity of the 1,400 mm connecting belt conveyor systems amounts to 2,983lcm/h in case of horizontal conveying. The belt velocity of the bench- and inclined belt conveyors was adjusted to 3.5 m/s to handle mass throughput. The above table illustrates that the excavators SRs 1300 working in the coal cuts can charge the belt with full capacity. The capacity reserves at full output still amounts to 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 7%. A deep stage in the 3rd overburden system has to be carried along to uncover the coal. The capacity of the belt conveyor system is not sufficient for a parallel operation of the SRs 400 and the E8B operated in this cut. Both excavators have to work with reduced output or at different times. Another dependency results from the charging of 2 head belt conveyor systems by 3 bench belt conveyors. A mass transfer from 2 bench belt conveyors to one head belt conveyor is also not possible due to capacity reasons. This means, that only 2 pit systems can be operated simultaneously. This fact does not have any influences to the required annual output capacity since the pit operation is over-dimensioned with regard to the installed excavators to 100 %.
4.3.3 Capability of Spreaders The following spreaders are envisaged to be employed in Sibovc SW. -
P3M A2RsB-5200
-
P4M A2RsB-5200
-
P3B A2RsB-4400
Vth
1st Bench nd
2 Bench rd
3 Bench
Ve peak, estimated (15 min)
Spreader
Nominal Capacity
Reserve
lcm/h
%
lcm/h
%
lcm/h
SRs 1300 (E10B)
4,000
90
3,600
P3B
4,400
18
SchRs 650 (E10M)
4,212
90
3,800
P3M
5,200
27
SchRs 650 (E9M)
4,212
90
3,800
SchRs 650 (E9M) + SRs 470 (E5M)
5,900
75
4,425
Tab.: 4.3-17
27 P4M
5,200 15
Utilisation of Spreader Capacity
In contrary to the excavator side, the capacity reserve of the spreaders ranges between 15 and 27%. Therefore full load operation is also guaranteed from the spreader side.
4.3.4 Capability of Mobile Equipment 4.3.4.1 Mass-calculation for Mobile Equipment The predominant part of the overburden removed in the Sibovc SW opencast mine is handled by means of 3 excavator-belt conveyor-spreader systems. Despite ramp excavation the large
Page 45 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
cutting heights in the area of the hills can not be mastered with these equipment systems. It is suggested to use mobile equipment in the areas with local excess heights. The mass calculation yielded a volume of 14.03 mbcm to be removed by means of mobile equipment. The use mainly concentrates to the opening-up phase but also to the last operating years. The annual volume to be removed achieves in the maximum 1.6 mbcm. The result of the mass calculation is included in chapter Mass calculation.
4.3.4.2 Selection of Mobile Equipment The mobile equipment was selected with regard to transport distance and soil types but also considering the capacity utilization of the first regular cut in the overburden. After careful consideration of the different criteria a combination of dragline and Truck & Shovel was chosen. This equipment use offers the following advantages: -
The excavator SRs 1300 (E10B) in the first regular overburden system is not used to capacity over a number of years. Because the use of a draglines ESch 10/70 is envisaged in the Sibovc SW opencast mine this machine can remove part of the masses (up to 0.4 mbcm/a) and replace the E10B. Due to the low operating costs of the draglines this variant will be cost-effective.
-
The remaining mass portion (up to 1.4 mbcm/a) will be removed by Shovel & Truck. The transport distances lying between 3 and 4 km in the first operating years will allow an efficient operation of the Trucks. The closure of the mining operations in the Bardh / Mirash mines will reduce the transport distances.
-
The Shovel- and Truck operation enables a high mobility which is of enormous importance with regard to the dumping space problem until 2012.
-
Compared to other mobile equipment the use of Shovels and Trucks in the mainly cohesive material causes the least operating problems.
-
In case of need Shovel- and Truck operation is also capable of selectively removing the top soil layer and distribute this layer on areas with lower soil quality.
The above mentioned dumping space problem is a significant factor for the opencast mine operation in the opening up phase. Upon complete exhaustion of the Bardh / Mirash opencast mines in 2011 dumping space will be limited in this opencast mine. This is mainly due to the fact that the seam further dips within the pillar area and therefore the lowest dumping slice can only be developed under certain conditions. Enough dumping space will be immediately available after decommissioning and disassemblage of the plants in 2012. It is suggested to dump the masses of the mobile equipment operation in the inside dump area of the Mirash mine in the first operation years. The transport distances are between 3 and 4 km, here. This alternative serves to easing the dumping space problem in the western part of the opencast mine (Bardh). From 2012 the transport distance can be reduced to ca. 2 km. For this period it is suggested to use the masses for covering the coal rim slope systems in order to prevent the danger of self-ignition.
Page 46 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.3.4.3 Calculation of Capacity and Equipment Fleet Unit ESch 10/70 Material Type Clay Bucket Capacity cbm 10 Swell Factor 1.50 Fill Factor 0.80 Dipper Load per Pass bcm 5.33 Slewing Angle 째 120 Cycle Time sec 49 Cycles per Hour No. 73 Production per Hour bcm/h 390 Hours per Shift h 8 Preparation Time min 60 Break Time min 60 Break Time for Personnel Activities min 30 Production Time per Shift h 5.5 Job Efficiency 0.85 Production per Shift bcm/sh. 1,800 Shifts per Day No. 3 Days per Week No. 7 Public Holidays d 10 Weather Conditions d 14 Maintenance d 40 Non-planned Breaks d 60 Technological Breaks d 30 Shift Breaks d 10 Non-Working Days per Year d 164 Working Days per Year d 201 Coefficient for Climate 0.95 Coefficient for Reliability 0.90 Total Working Hours per Year h 4,120 Production per Year mbcm 0.940 Tab.: 4.3-18
Maximum Capacity of Dragline ESch 10/70
Page 47 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Unit
1a
1b
1c
2a
2b
2c
Production per Year
mbcm
0.66
0.66
0.66
1.4
1.4
1.4
Uncontinuous Factor
-
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
cbm
2
3
5
2
3
5
Swell Factor
-
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.3
Efficiency Dipper Using
-
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
bcm
1.38
2.08
3.46
1.38
2.08
3.65
Time per Pass
s
40
40
40
40
40
40
Job Efficiency Shovel
-
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
Truck Presentation Factor
-
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
Truck Capacity
t
12.3
20.0
30.8
12.3
20.0
30.8
Truck Capacity
cbm
8
13
20
8
13
20
No. of Passes
-
5
5
5
5
5
5
Truck Payload
bcm
6.2
10.0
15.4
6.2
10.0
15.4
-
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
Loading Time
min
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.3
Average Velocity
km/h
20
20
20
20
20
20
Transport Distance
km
3.5
3.5
3.5
2.0
2.0
2.0
Truck Reserve Factor
-
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
1.1
min
26.6
26.6
26.6
17.6
17.6
17.6
Operating Days per Year
d
200
200
200
200
200
200
Shift System
-
7/3
7/3
7/3
7/3
7/3
7/3
Shift Changing Time
min
20
20
20
20
20
20
Breaks
min
30
30
30
30
30
30
Truck Changing Time
min
1
1
1
1
1
1
Spot Time
min
5
5
5
5
5
5
mbcm
0.6
0.9
1.5
0.6
0.9
1.6
2
1
1
3
2
1
56.6
92.0
141.6
85.5
139.0
213.8
15
9
7
21
14
9
Trucks
Excavator
Dipper Capacity
Dipper Load per Pass
Truck Efficiency Factor
Operation Time
Cycle Time
Fleet
Annual Production Shovel Number of Shovels Annual Production Truck
tbcm
Number of Trucks Tab.: 4.3-19
Capacity of Shovel & Truck Fleet
Page 48 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
When calculating the necessary Shovel- and Truck-fleet 2 alternatives were considered (please see table above): 1
annual output capacity 0.66 mbcm with a transport distance of 3.5 km
2
annual output capacity 1.4 mbcm with a transport distance of 2.0 km
3 different equipment classes were calculated for the two alternatives: a
2 cbm Shovel and 8 cbm Trucks
b
3 cbm Shovel and 13 cbm Trucks
c
5 cbm Shovel and 20 cbm Trucks
For the calculation a continuous operation of 200 days per year was taken into account. The included downtimes and reserve factors are shown in the above table. Comparing the examined variants the equipment alternative with 2cbm Shovels and 8 cbm Trucks shall be preferred. The decision is justified in the following: -
Only one shovel is required for alternative c owing to the low annual capacity. Downtime of this excavator would accordingly lead to outage of the whole system. That is the reason why this alternative shall be rejected.
-
For a number of years the annual capacity of the mobile equipment operation is lower than expected. This would also lead to a reduction to one winning equipment for variant b.
-
A decisive advantage of variant a is the availability of this equipment in Kosovo so that the performances can be carried out at reasonable costs by companies from Kosovo.
Page 49 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.4 General Mining Development in Sibovc SW 4.4.1 Excavation Boundary/ Boundary Line The following was taken into consideration when the excavation boundary (upper edge of first level) was established: -
Course of old concession line
-
Permissible approach to villages
-
Thickness of minable coal seam at the boundary
-
Necessary general inclination from geotechnical point of view
-
Requirements to bench lengths and straight rim slope systems
Altogether the excavation boundary or the technological depletion boundary represents a compromise between the criteria mentioned above. The following applies to the single criteria: Course of old concession line Already in the past it was planned to excavate the Sibovc coal field. This area was defined by a limitation line. The limitation of the excavation area for the field Sibovc SW planned in the Complementary Mining Plan is within this area. Permissible approach to villages Despite the reduced coal demand, a partly relocation of villages within this field can’t be avoided. This applies to the villages of Hade and Shipitulle. A complete resettlement of these villages is not necessary. Between the mining boundary and the residential buildings a safety zone with a width of 100 m has been considered. Near the village of Shipitulle little coal losses have been accepted to keep the infrastructure. Thickness of minable coal seam at the boundary The thickness of the coal seam in the field Sibovc SW varies between 60 and 70m. In the southern part the seam thickness is a little bit higher and can reach locally 80m. Along the western boundary, where the seam is disturbed, the thickness goes back to 40 m. So there are no restrictions regarding the seam thickness. Necessary general inclination from geotechnical point of view All slope systems comply with the requirements regarding the stability required from a geotechnical point of view. i.e.: -
general inclination overburden system
< 8°
-
overburden (single slope)
< 45°
-
general inclination coal system
< 22°
Page 50 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
coal (single slope)
< 75° to 20m or < 70° to 25m
Requirements to bench lengths and straight rim slope systems The general opencast mine design is directly linked with the height of the planned output. Especially the annual progress of the opencast mine is of essential importance for geotechnical reasons. The lower the opencast mine advance, the higher the risks caused by slope failures ad coal fires. These dependencies are still more complex in the available case of the Sibovc deposit because the surface is strongly structured. This aspect has furthermore negative influences to the mine development with straight routes for the head belt conveyors systems. A bench length of ca. 900 m related to the coal benches was chosen for an annual output of 9mt. With an average coal thickness of 65 m this corresponds to an annual opencast mine advance of ca. 130m. An opencast mine similar to that of the Main Mining Plan including bench lengths of ca. 3000 m cannot be accepted since the annual mine advance will reduce to 40m. Another disadvantage of the long bench length arises due to the high investment and operating costs for the belt conveyor systems. Other alternatives will also be not useful because the mountain range with the Hade village is in the middle of the field. In addition to that it was taken into account that the head belt conveyors should be in more or less straight direction, with a justifiable number of single conveyors.
4.4.2 Bench Design 4.4.2.1 General Bench Design The Sibovc field shows a varying thickness and a varying inclination of the benches and of the roof and floor of the seam. The benches must follow these inclinations with the least possible mining loss. Overburden operation Taking both the cut height and the capacity of the machines into consideration, 3 main levels were provided for overburden removal and one additional level for following and cleaning the seam. The 3 main levels are equipped with excavator types SRs 1300 and SchRs 650. For these machines slope heights of about 20 m have been planned. During ramp excavation the main machines cuts a ramp of additional 8 m thickness above the level of the belt conveyor system. The ramp has to be excavated in a second block. In the lowest overburden bench the application of a SRs 470 with belt wagon has been planned. In some only locally spread areas, the total overburden thickness comes to about 120 m. In these parts the additional application of mobile equipment canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t be excluded. Coal operation Coal mining is also implemented in 3 main levels and one additional bench at the bottom of the seam. The main levels are equipped with excavator types SRs 1300 and SchRs 650, respectively. In the lowest cut an excavator SRs 400 will be in operation. The coal from this bench will be loaded to the next higher level by means of a belt wagon. The inclination possible to be managed by the machines is 1:33 for excavator operation. Inclinations of 1:40 were chosen for the benches in order to be able to follow the big gradients of the terrain, roof and floor. This maximum inclination puts very high demands to keeping Page 51 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
the heights of the benches which can only be achieved by continuous checks. In the direction of mining it is possible to achieve a greater decrease or increase of the bench using the step excavation which is used for moving the belt conveyor system. In the direction of the bench the inclination must always be kept. The minimum inclination should not be less than 1:150. This is necessary to enable drainage of the working levels. Drainage ditches must be provided on the benches and pump stations shall be provided in the deep positions of the benches.
Page 52 of 171
Fig.: 4.4-1
Cross Section with Main Equipment Application
Recommendation for more detailed planning Deviations between the available terrain data and the actual situation were determined during visits along the western rim slope system (area western and north-western of the shooting range). This area has to be surveyed by KEK as soon as possible. On this basis both the geological model and the technological planning of the western rim slope system shall be specified.
4.4.2.2 Division of Cuts in Overburden Operation The total overburden thickness in the field of Sibovc SW varies between 30 and 110 m. These strong variations are mainly caused by the terrain profile but also in the tectonic conditions of the seam. The largest cutting heights occur in the north of the mining field of Sibovc SW and along the eastern rim slope system. The lowest overburden coverage is in the south of the mining field along the northern rim slope system of the Bardh opencast mine. Therefore the design of the single cuts shall be adjusted according to the morphology and presents as follows: Mobile Equipment The use of Shovels and Trucks is envisaged in the sections with the largest cutting heights. The operational area covers a curved zone along the mountain range in the central and northern part of the mining field of Sibovc SW. The cutting depths in the overburden reach here partly up to 110 m. This cutting height cannot be handled with the help of the main equipment despite ramp excavation; therefore the use of mobile equipment is proposed. The separation level of the mobile operation is on a level of +625 mMSL n the central part and rises into the direction of the rim slope systems to +645 mMSL. The overall cutting height is maximum 20m. The thickness of the single cuts shall be ca. 6 m. 1st Overburden system Due to the terrain rising into northern direction the first overburden system will only begin immediately in the south of the outside dump of Shipitulla (shooting range). The bench runs from west to east on an average level of +595 mMSL. In the valley west of Hade (middle bench zone) this cut runs on the surface level during the first business years. There is practically no cutting. With progressing development the cutting depth increases continuously on the entire bench. At the end of the period under review ramp excavation will be necessary on large bench sections. 2nd Overburden system The starting position for this cut is on the present surface level at a height of +565 mMSL, too. This height corresponds to the present height of working level of spreader P3B. From this position on the 2nd overburden system will be developed into northern direction. During the first operating years this cut also works with reduced cutting heights in the valley location. With progressing development the cutting depth increases so that ramp excavation will become necessary. on large bench sections.
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3rd Overburden system The 3rd overburden system is the cut exposing the coal seam. During the opening-up phase the eastern part of the bench can be developed rim the existing northern rim slope system. In contrast to this, an opening cut will be necessary the western part, because the bank rim slope system was overdumped. Recovering of the dump masses is not recommended. The working level is on a height of +550 / +535 mMSL and reaches the roof of the coal only at the western rim s lope system. Therefore a deep cut following the 3rd overburden system will be installed which will expose the roof of the seam continuously. In this cut, there will be used a SRs 470 with belt wagon and without own bench belt conveyor. The 3rd overburden system works continuously with maximum cutting height.
4.4.2.3 Division of Cuts in Coal Operation The coal seam in the field Sibovc SW has an average thickness of ca. 70 m. In the area of the opening-up the coal has local seam thickness of up to 80 m. In the tectonic fault zones along the western rim slope system the thickness reduces to partly below 40 m. The seam is more or less deposited flat whereby a general dipping into eastern and southern direction can be recognized. The dipping is mainly bound to geological faults (cracks); especially along the western field boundary they lead to larger differences in the seam levels. Therefore the seam is partly reaching the 3rd overburden system. Generally, it is envisaged to extract the seam in 3 cuts each being equipped with one excavator of the 1300-class. The design of the single cuts is illustrated in the following: 1st Coal Cut In the area of the opening up the working level of the 1st coal cut runs on a level between +525 and +515 mMSL. The working level is continuously dipping into eastern direction with a gradient of ca. 1 : 80. The cutting thickness of the 1st coal cut is 15 to 20 m. The dipping of the working level remains over the whole operating lifetime, the gradient increases to 1 : 40. At the same time the working level increases by ca 15 m into north in the first operating years. 2nd Coal Cut The second overburden system is mainly 20 to 25 m thick. Analogue to the 1st coal cut the working level is dipping into mining direction Compared with the 1st coal cut the dipping is lower. 3rd Coal Cut The 3rd coal cut is 25 m thick. Direction and dipping follow the 2nd coal cut. This working level can only reach locally the seam bottom. Therefore, a deep stage was planned for this cut. A SRs 400 (E7M) with belt wagon shall be used in this additional cut which excavates the coal to the technological bottom and loads it to the belt conveyor of the 3rd coal cut. The cutting depth in the deep stage is maximum 10 m.
Page 55 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
By means of single drillings, interburden containing clay was identified within the level of the 3rd coal cut. These interburden layers are of low thickness and are not spread regularly. These interburden layers occur only in the lowest coal cut; therefore they can be directly dumped to the bottom with low technological expense. The decision to separate the interburden should be made in case of need. In general layers greater 0.5 m shall be selectively extracted.
4.4.3 Main Strategies for Mining Development The following main strategies for the mining development have been considered in the Complementary Mine Plan: -
Opening-up of the Sibovc SW opencast mine shall be made from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. In the western opening-up area the inside dump of P3B shall be taken into account.
-
For the coal operation, a coal pillar shall be considered in the opening-up figure between the mine fields of Sibovc and Bardh in order to stabilize the masses of he inside dump the Bardh opencast mine.
-
The masses are preferably dumped in the mined-out area of the existing opencast mines in order to stabilize the slope south of Hade and to establish final dump surfaces as soon as possible.
-
Moreover, the mined-out bottom in Sibovc SW shall be covered and as far as possible also the coal rim slope systems in order to prevent coal fires.
-
During the opening-up phase the overburden will be transported via the western rim slope system. After disassembling the equipment in the existing opencast mines there will be established a belt connection via the eastern rim slope system. This helps to reducing the transport distance and the quickest possible establishment of the slope system south of Hade.
-
The residual pit of Mirash-Brand remains as reserved area for the disposal of municipal waste.
-
It is envisaged to flush the power plant residues from TPP B in the residual pit of Mirash-East.
All in all is to be noticed, that the development of the new Sibovc SW mine is directly linked to the advance of the existing mine and therefore to the realisation of the Mid Term Plan.
4.4.4 Mass Calculation On the basis of the topographic isoline maps, the existing borehole data submitted by KEK and the results of additional exploration measures a digital deposit model were prepared for the purpose of computer-aided mass calculation. The technological mass calculation has been realised with MicroStation-Programs as well as specialised programs developed by Vattenfall on the basis of triangulation. The following data and criteria of mineability have been considered in the mass calculation: -
Density of coal 1.14 t/m続
Page 56 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Extraction of lignite from a thickness of at least 0.5 m
-
Separate excavation of intercalations from a thickness of more than 0.5 m
-
Consideration of a mining loss of 0.5 m at each strata boundary
Fig.: 4.4-2
Sectors of Mass Calculation
Page 57 of 171
Overburden Operation
Coal Operation
Total
Mobile E.
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 3a
Coal
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level3a
Overb.
Overb.
Coal
Ratio
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[bcm/t]
1.836
4.986
0.684
0.464
0.375
8.361
0.839
9.96 : 1
0.031
19.135
10.773
1.78 : 1
1
0.855
2
1.105
1.112
6.230
8.434
2.223
0.352
5.488
4.835
0.099
3
0.415
7.109
11.208
8.708
1.847
1.840
6.341
9.658
5.376
1.071
0.554
29.841
24.286
1.23 : 1
4
0.175
5.018
10.522
8.308
1.777
0.824
6.291
9.166
5.860
1.184
0.373
26.173
23.324
1.12 : 1
5
2.521
7.358
13.341
9.238
1.920
0.905
6.130
8.240
5.974
1.827
0.396
34.774
23.076
1.51 : 1
6
4.644
11.393
13.781
10.804
1.945
0.161
6.374
8.641
6.680
2.009
0.447
43.014
23.865
1.80 : 1
7
6.773
16.126
15.078
11.006
1.226
0.072
6.096
6.060
5.850
1.427
0.375
50.584
19.506
2.59 : 1
8
7.807
15.569
16.265
11.256
1.291
0.067
6.164
5.553
5.637
1.883
0.369
52.557
19.304
2.72 : 1
9
2.399
12.388
16.164
11.891
1.294
0.612
6.565
5.258
5.502
2.039
0.411
44.547
19.976
2.23 : 1
Total
26.69
76.07
104.42
84.63
14.21
5.30
49.82
57.41
40.98
11.44
2.55
308.99
164.95
1.82 : 1
Tab.: 4.4-1
Results of Mass Calculation
4.4.5 Stockpile Operation To stock coal and blend a homogenous coal quality according to the power plant parameters stockpiles are installed upstream the power plants. These stockpiles are installed directly at the power plant sites and belong to the responsibility of the opencast mine department.
Blocks 3, 4 and 5
4.4.5.1 Stockpile TPP A
Separation A
TPP A
T Blocks 1, 2 and 3
SHT-2b
Mirash-West Mirash-Southeast SHT-15
SHT-5.13
MK 2
MK 1 T ..... Truck Loading Point ... Active Belt Conveyors ... Passive Belt Conveyors
Fig.: 4.4-3
Scheme of Stockpile TPP A
The stockpile provides the respective coal quantities and qualities for the power plant TPP A and other consumers (heating purposes). It consists of four parallel arranged stockpile sections (at surface) with a maximum total volume of 560,000 t. The total filling for a continuous handling amounts to 400,000 t. The stockpiles are equipped with 2 combined stacker-reclaimers of the company TUSLA (MK 1 and MK 2), whereby each of the machines operates 2 stockpile sections. The capacity of one machine is 1,800t/h both for stacking and reclaiming. Due to the combined stacker-reclaimer operation the following functions can be fulfilled: -
stacking
-
reclaiming
-
by-pass operation
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
mass stream separation (by-pass operation and stacking)
-
by-pass operation and reclaiming
The belt conveyor distribution system of Separation Plants A was very complex. In the past, a lot of connected consumers were supplied with different coal qualities via this distribution system. Parallel to the decommissioning of some of the consumers, belt conveyors and belt conveyor systems have also been put out of operation. In a first process, the coal is crushed in several steps down to a grain size of 30 mm. After the crushing, the coal can directly be transported to the power plant and the stockpile for stacking, respectively. It is recommended to blend a homogenous coal quality in three phases. -
Control of equipment use in the opencast mine by precise extraction and pre-blending of different coal qualities
-
Blending of mass streams from the various mining fields
-
Blending within the stockpile cross section by slice-wise stacking
In separation plant TPP A it is furthermore possible to produce and load pre-dried lump coal for sale (road transportation by trucks). The demand for TPP A and other consumer is planned with about 5.0 mt per year. The daily demand comes to 10 up to 15 kt. So in this case the normal filling level of 400 kt corresponds to a coal reserve of 26 up to 40 days (at most). This is regarded as sufficient.
TPP B
4.4.5.2 Stockpile TPP B The coal is transported via two stationery belt conveyors to the stockpile.
C t es -W sh ri a h M a rd B
MK B
MK A
C ... Crusher
Fig.: 4.4-4
Scheme of Stockpile TPP B
After crushing to a grain size of 30 mm the coal can be directly transported to the power plant and the Stockpile for stacking, respectively.
Page 60 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The Stockpile consists of four parallel arranged stockpile sections (at surface) with a maximum total volume of 500,000 t. The optimal total filling for a continuous handling amounts to 350,000 t. For a daily coal demand of ca. 10,000 t per block the coal reserves will last for 18 days in case of optimal filling level and a relatively high demand. According to the planned performance the yearly average coal demand for TPP B1+B2 in future is 5.3 mt or 15 kt per day. Hence on average the coal will be sufficient for 23 days. The stockpiles are equipped with 2 combined stacker-reclaimers of the company MAN (MK A and MK B), whereby each of the machines operates 2 stockpile sections. The capacity of one machine is 1,800t/h both for stacking and reclaiming. The two machines can supply coal to both of the blocks. Furthermore it is also possible to directly supply coal to the power plant blocks from the mine without intermediate stacking. In this process, too, the combined stacker-reclaimer equipment is integrated in the mass flow. So it will be possible to blend a homogenous coal quality in a sufficient manner.
Page 61 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5 Opening-up Operation 4.5.1 Preparatory Works in the Year 2007 In the calendar year 2007 the rehabilitation of the first overburden line will start, consisting of Excavator E10B, 1,600 mm belt conveyor system and spreader P3B. The start of the performance test is planned for end of February and the full load operation for end of March 2008 in the field Sibovc SW. The excavator will start on a level of +570/+555 mMSL on the surface. The necessary levelling works, to be done by dozers, should be realised in 2007 already. The grading is required for erection of frames and drive and return stations before finishing the refurbishment of the main equipment. At the same time the foreseen surface dewatering measures (drainage of water ponds and the box culvert) and the land acquisition have to be finished. The grading works have to be done by KEK own equipment.
4.5.2 Mining Development in the Year 2008 Illustration of technology see attachment 4- 2 4.5.2.1 General Development The opening up of the Sibovc SW opencast mine starts from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The overburden thickness in the opening up area is only 30m and the coal layer is partly more than 70m thick. Parallel with the rising terrain the overburden thickness is increasing into the mining direction. In the western area of the northern rim slope system spreader P3B has been distributing the masses of the first over the Bardh mine since 2003. In this zone the inside dump is directly and completely bordering the northern rim slope system up to reaching the surface level. Due to the low cutting height and the terrain increasing to the North first and second overburden system can be put into operation on the area and reach full cutting depth only with advancing extraction. Only the 3rd overburden system must produce a cut-in. The dumped inside dump masses will not be reclaimed. After having executed the first preparatory measures in 2007, the proper opening up activities will start in 2008. Directly after the end of the winter season the first mass movements by means of Shovels and Trucks are planned. These works concentrate on preparing the positions for the main equipment and the cutting of excess heights at the western bench end. The first overburden line (E10B, 1,600mm belt conveyor system, P3B) is planned to take up operation on 1st June. At year end (1st November) another overburden line (E9M, 1,800 mm belt conveyor system, P4M) will start operation. The masses are completely dumped in the existing residual pits of the Bardh / Mirash mines. Coal will not be exposed in this year.
Page 62 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-1
Mining Position at the End of Year 2008
4.5.2.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment In March 2008 overburden removal starts in the Sibovc SW field by means of mobile equipment. First, the use of this equipment is planned until 2012. It is suggested to assign these operations to a subcontractor. This will be the most economic alternative because the required output capacity varies from year to year. In 2008, mobile equipment operation will concentrate on producing the start positions for the overburden lines 1 and 3 which will start operation already in this year. The following working areas are resulting from this:
Page 63 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Start position for 1st overburden system
Start position for 3rd overburden system
Widening of highest overburden
level:
+565 / +555 mMSL
volume:
0.20 mbcm
completion:
May 2008
level:
+560 / +550 mMSL
volume:
0.10 mbcm
completion:
July 2008
level:
+595 / +580 mMSL
volume:
0.36 mbcm
completion:
Dec 2008
It is suggested to use the area east of the dump pillar to dump the overburden masses. The concrete determination of the dumping spaces shall be done according to the specific opencast mine situation in 2008. Transport distances will amount between 3.0 to 4.0 km. Road construction shall be planned and performed by the Subcontractor. 1st Overburden System The installation of the first overburden line (E10B, 1,600 mm belt conveyor system, P3B) will start in April 2008. On the winning side the bench belt conveyor line shall be established on the route prepared by the mobile equipment (+565 / +555 mMSL â&#x20AC;&#x201C; later working level of the 2nd overburden bench). The connection to the dump is made along the western field margin. The former bench of P3B in the Bardh mine will be continued as dump bench (+552 / +546 mMSL). Therefore this system will reach a total bench length of only 3,000 m using 3 single belts in the start position. Test operation and performance tests are planned for May 2008; continuous operation will start on 1st June. Extraction is performed in parallel operation first with low cutting heights. The maximum cutting heights (10 m) are reached at the western bench end. Totally 1.0 mbcm of overburden have to be removed until the end of the year. This production considers a moderate capacity development in the first operating months (3 months with 50% of the maximum capacity and further 3 months with 70 % of the maximum capacity). The dump will first be developed in high dumping with maximum dumping height 12 m. The high-dumping directly borders the existing natural terrain surface. In the south of the highdumping area a corridor shall be considered for the natural dewatering of the later dump surface. After dumping of the first block the head belt conveyor shall be extended and an additional head belt conveyor shall be installed parallel to the existing head belt conveyor. At the same time the dump bench belt conveyor shall be shifted parallel. 3rd Overburden System In September 2008, the 3rd overburden line (E9M, 1,800 mm belt conveyor system, P4M) will be installed in the starting position. The start position on the mining side (+ 560 / + 550 mMSL) was prepared by means of mobile equipment. The head belt conveyor also runs along the western mining boundary. The dump bench will also be installed on the Bardh inside dump on a working level of +540 / +536 mMSL. In the start position the belt conveyor system consists of 4 single belts with a total length of 2.7 km.
Page 64 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Test operation for this overburden system is planned for October before the capacity operation will start in November. Restrictions with regard to capacity have been taken into account analogue to the 1st overburden system the first months. But the prepared start position does not yet correspond to the planned level of the working bench of the E9M. Therefore winning operations in the first months will focus on lowering the working level as soon as possible to the planned level (+550 / +535 mMSL). The lowering of this working level is performed by excavating 2 deep cuts each having maximum depth of 8m. The belt conveyor line shall then be shifted to the next deeper level. In 2008 only the first deep stage will be excavated. The spreader works in high and deep dumping operation. Shifting on the dump side will not be planned for the first operating year.
Overburden
4.5.2.3 Production Figures Overburden
Coal
[ mbcm ]
[ mt ]
Mobile
0.660
Commissioning 1st March
1
E10B
1.000
Commissioning 1st June
3
E9M
0.500
Commissioning 1st November
Total Tab.: 4.5-1
Excav. E10B
2.160 Planned Production in the Year 2008
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M
Remarks
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
Tab.: 4.5-2
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,500 340 160 1,100 970 370 550 1,100
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] + 550 + 570 + 570 + 552 + 552 + 552 + 552 + 546 + 544 + 550 + 550 + 553 + 553 + 540 + 540 + 536
Spreader
P3B
P4M
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2008
Page 65 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5.3 Mining Development in the Year 2009 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 3 4.5.3.1 General Development Operation in the Sibovc SW opencast mine is continued with the equipment put into operation in the previous year. The 3rd overburden system will be assisted by the excavator E5M from June 2009. This excavator is used on the deep cut side of the bench belt conveyor and removes the residual overburden up to the roof of the coal seam. In November the next equipment line will be put into operation (E10M, 1,800 mm belt conveyor system, P3M). This line will work in the 2nd overburden system. The excavator E10B used previously on that level will be shifted to the first overburden system. Therefore, the overburden operation in Sibovc SW will be completely equipped. Like in the year before the overburden will be dumped on the inside dumps of the Bardh and Mirash mines. Both of the mines will still be in operation in 2009 so that the dumping activities of the existing mines and the Sibovc SW mine shall be coordinated. This means that the dumping space problem will furthermore influence the opencast mine operation decisively. This fact especially results due to: -
Blocking of dumping space by sanitary landfill area in Mirash Brand
-
Blocking of dumping space by ash dump area in Mirash East
-
Low general slope angle of dumped material of 6째
-
Blocking of lowest dumping slice in Bardh mine because of the dipping bottom of seam
The new line to be put into operation will therefore operate in a dumping sector east of the dump pillar. In 2009 coal will be exposed for the first time in the mining field of Sibovc SW, but this coal will not be extracted. Parallel to this the precondition for taking up coal production in 2010 must be provided. Another important task will be the finishing of the resettlement of the western village part of the community of Hade.
Page 66 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-2
Mining Position at the End of Year 2009
4.5.3.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment The overburden quantity to be removed by means of mobile equipment in 2009 will amount to 0.6 mbcm. About 0.2 mbcm will come to the cutting of excess heights at the western rim slope system and 0.4 mbcm to shaping the eastern rim slope system southwest of Hade. In this connection it will be necessary to partly resettle the western village part of Hade (please see chapter 7). The level of the mobile equipment in the area of Hade will be produced with an inclination of 1 : 6. Analogue to the previous year the overburden shall be dumped in the dumping space east of the dump pillar of Mirash. 1st Overburden System
Page 67 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The first overburden system will be operated on the level of the later second overburden system until the 3rd quarter. Afterwards excavator and bench belt conveyor will be shifted to the new working position in the first overburden system. This position extends along the contour lines from WSW to NNE and lies not parallel to the mining direction. A ramp leading through the terrain shall be prepared by means of mobile equipment for transporting the excavator. The new working level of the line is on + 595 / +585 mMSL. Owing to the terrain structure the first overburden system will only be necessary in the western part of the mining field during the first operating years. After re-commissioning in November the system will mainly work at the western bench end to produce parallel position of the benches. Connection to the dump side via the western rim slope system will be maintained also after the reconstruction. Only the head belt conveyor shall be extended via a ramp (1 : 10) to the higher level. The ramp shall be prepared by means of mobile equipment. The dump will be further developed in parallel operation into eastern direction with constant extension of the head belt conveyor. The spreader works exclusively in high dumping operation. 2nd Overburden System The 2nd overburden system consisting of E10M, 1,800 mm belt conveyor system and P3M shall be put into operation in November 2009. The installation of the belt conveyor will already start in September and in the following month spreader and excavator shall be transported from the assembly yard to the work position. The performance tests for the entire system shall be scheduled for October. Parallel with the commissioning of the new line excavator E10B and the belonging bench belt conveyor shall be shifted to the first overburden system in order to avoid hindrances. Contrary to the other equipment line this system will be connected by belt conveyor to the dump already via the eastern rim slope system. Reason for this is the limited dumping space in the Bardh mine in 2009; therefore the overburden has to be dumped east of the dump pillar. The head belt conveyors must lead into southern direction through the open pit space of Bardh and then into eastern direction via the dump pillar of Mirash. The dump bench belt conveyor shall be laid on a level of ca. +545 mMSL along the outside dump South. The dumping slice will then be developed in deep and high dumping in slewing operation. The belt conveyor system of this overburden line consists of 5 single belts with a total length of 6.4 km. The belt routes shall be prepared during the summer months by mobile equipment available in the opencast mine. Already in 2009, the newly installed equipment line will remove 0.200 mbcm overburden. 3rd Overburden System The third overburden system will be further operated in parallel. Deep stage excavation started in 2009 will be continued until the planned working level height is reached (+535 / +545 mMSL). When this level will be reached, the working level on the excavation side shall be further developed slightly rising. Therefore the working level follows the rising coal seam. Except the western bench end, the roof of the coal will not be reached with this working level. For this reason an additional cut (3a) shall be installed on the deep cut side of the belt conveyor which exposes the coal seam. Excavator E5M will be used in this cut. The extracted
Page 68 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
masses are transferred by mean of BRs 1200 to the belt conveyor of the 3rd overburden system. The thickness of cut 3a was limited to 8m height depending on the technical parameters of the belt wagon. Commissioning of E5M including belt wagon is scheduled for June 2009. Rehabilitation of the excavator is only planned for 2010 so that the excavator can be directly used in the Sibovc SW mine after decommissioning in the Mirash mine. The western bench end of the 3rd overburden system is already in the area of high coal seam position. Here the coal reaches into the 3rd overburden system. In the annual slice for 2009 the coal quantity comes to 0.29 mt in this cut. As the coal systems will not yet be installed in Sibovc SW at that time coal has to be extracted and stored on a stockpile in the mine. This quantity shall be reclaimed after commissioning of the first coal line. The dump is further developed analogue to the previous year into eastern direction. The height of the working level is between +540 und +536 mMSL. The spreader works in high- and deep dumping. Permanent control and supervision of the advance conditions and general slope angles will be of essential importance during the dump development. The dump stability is a decisive precondition for maximum coal output of the existing mines and also for the operating safety of the belt conveyor line of the 2nd overburden system in Sibovc SW.
4.5.3.3 Coal Operation Coal production is not yet scheduled for 2009; it will become necessary from beginning of 2010. Therefore the required preconditions for taking up coal production shall be provided in 2009, especially: -
Shifting of the already in 2007/2008 rehabilitated E8M to the coal operation Sibovc SW
-
Finishing of rehabilitation of the first coal belt conveyor
-
Preparation of routes for the installation of the belt conveyors (summer)
-
Installation of the first coal belt conveyor line (autumn, winter)
4.5.3.4 Production Figures
Overburden
Mobile
Overburden
Coal
[ mbcm ]
[ mt ]
Remarks
0.600
1
E10B
2.000
Relocation to 1st overburden level up to Oct
2
E10M
0.200
Commissioning 1st November
3
E9M
3.100
3a
E5M
0.500
Total Tab.: 4.5-3
0.290
Commissioning 1st June
6.400 Planned Production in the Year 2009
Page 69 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
Tab.: 4.5-4
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,070 700 350 1,100 1,500 640 970 2,200 1,000 1,350 300 590 1,100
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] + 585 + 580 + 580 + 552 + 552 + 552 + 552 + 546 + 575 + 565 + 565 + 487 + 487 + 538 + 538 + 545 + 545 +545 + 535 + 548 + 548 + 553 + 553 + 540 + 540 + 536
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2009
Page 70 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5.4 Mining Development in the Year 2010 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 4 4.5.4.1 General Development In 2010 coal production from the existing mine declines to 4.6 mt. To cover the coal demand of the power plants a coal output of 3.4 mt is required from the Sibovc mine. Overburden operation in the Sibovc mine will be continued analogue to the previous year period. All system on the mining side will be further developed into northern direction in parallel operation. Technological development started in 2009 will also be continued on the dump side. In the first quarter of 2010excavator E1B will be shifted to the Sibovc SW mine. This excavator was already partly rehabilitated in 2005 and will be used as float machine in Sibovc SW. The commissioning of this excavator provides the preconditions for the rehabilitation of excavator E5M in the coal exposing cut. This measure will start beginning from March 2010. At the beginning of the year the coal operation installed in the previous year will start operation. Excavator E8M will begin on the coal roof and develop via several deep stages until it reaches its planned working level. The coal is transported via a coal conveyor belt to the distribution point. In the first half of the year the preconditions for the commissioning of the second coal excavator and the second stationery coal belt conveyor shall be provided. Start of operation for this line is scheduled for July 2010. The development of the 2nd coal cut is made analogue to excavator E8M via several deep stages.
Page 71 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-3
Mining Position at the End of Year 2010
4.5.4.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment In 2010, the overburden volume to be removed by means of mobile equipment will reduce to 0.3 mbcm. Mobile equipment operation is only performed at the western bench end. During the year the mining face of mobile operation reaches the south western boundary of the outside dump (shooting area). The masses can both be dumped on a suitable place of the Mirash dump and in Bardh. On the Bardh dump side it is possible to additionally heighten the high dump produced by P3B once again. This dumping shall only be done with limited volume (max. 0.3 mlcm) and serve shaping the terrain surface at the western field margin in the area of the natural elevation of Page 72 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
the base rock. Advantages for this alternative are the short transport distances of only 1.4km. Dumping in this area requires a soil-mechanical evaluation of the total dump slope system. 1st Overburden System The first overburden system will be further developed in slewing operation until a position orthogonal to the planned mining direction will be reached. Afterwards excavation changes to parallel operation. Also in 2010 the first overburden system will only be operated in the western bench half owing to the terrain structure. The constantly low thickness in this cut at the beginning of the year will increase with advancing development. This will be mainly due to the fact that the cut reaches the southern boundary of the outside dump (shooting range). The thickness of the cut will then come to 20 m in the western part of the bench and will decrease continuously to 0m into eastern direction. Due to the short bench length and the partly low cutting heights the annual output capacity in this cut only comes to 0.47 mbcm. Starting from 2010 extraction in this cut will be decisively determined by the additionally heightened outside dump masses. The thickness of the outside dump varies between 0 and 20m. Therefore the height of the working level of E10B is continuously in unspoilt material. Performance restrictions can be expected when the dumped material will be reclaimed. The operating experiences from the existing mine and comparable deposits show that the dumped material itself will flatten to 6째. During excavation in the dumped areas slides have to be taken into account which will develop gradually. Dangers caused by these slides for personnel and equipment will not be expected. Excavation in areas with dumped materials shall be accompanied soil-mechanically; if required special measures shall be taken. The dump will be further developed in parallel operation into eastern direction exclusively by high-dumping. Owing to the small output quantity in 2010 the advance of the dumping slice is limited to ca. 50 m. 2nd Overburden System The 2nd overburden line will be continued in parallel operation. The annual output capacity comes to 3.3 mbcm, which corresponds to an advance of ca. 150 m. Excavator E10M will cut for the most part of the annual slice from its working level to the surface level. Cutting height is maximum 20 m. The thickness of the material to be excavated decreases to 5 m in the valley site. The working level dips into eastern direction from ca. + 578 to + 565 mMSL. Drainage measures are of special importance for the operation. The water quantities not covered by the advancing surface drainage will flow into the 2nd overburden system owing to the valley position and must be discharged via the working level into eastern direction. By means of constant surface drainage these water quantities can be minimized but not fully excluded. Therefore it is urgently required to operate a functioning drainage channel on the working level. Belt connection to the dumping sector east of the dump pillar will be maintained. The dump shall be further developed in slewing operation. 3rd Overburden System
Page 73 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Totally 4.71 mbcm overburden will have to be removed in the 3rd overburden system in the annual slice for 2010. About 3.62 mbcm of it come to the main cut (E9M) and 1.09 mbcm to the coal exposing cut (E5M). Furthermore about 0.27 mt coal to be exposed is in the 3rd overburden system; this coal shall be excavated and added to the pit operation. The 3rd overburden system will be further developed in parallel operation. In 2010 the advance into mining direction will amount to ca. 140 m. The working level will slightly increase into mining direction and will dip from west to east from + 553 to + 536 mMSL. The cutting height in the main cut is constantly 20m. Directly behind the bench belt conveyor on the mining side the coal exposing cut is carried along. The thickness of the cut is limited to 10 m to be able to load the overburden masses to the above lying bench belt conveyor on the main working level. The cut will be required for the total area of the deep coal position; therefore it extends completely over the central and eastern bench section. On 1st March 2010 the rehabilitated excavator E1B which was damaged during a heavy slide in 2002 will be shifted to the Sibovc SW mine. This excavator is scheduled as float machine and shall be used in areas of special importance to be decided upon operatively. This excavator shall be preferably used for extracting and moving coal from the 3rd overburden system because its technical parameters allow only a limited use in overburden. The first special task in the Sibovc SW mine will be scheduled for excavator E1B directly after commissioning of it. The excavator E5M previously working in the uncovering coal cut was not rehabilitated before shifting to Sibovc SW. In 2010there will be the possibility and necessity to catch up this rehabilitation. During the 7-month outage the excavator shall be replaced by E1B. This excavator works with reduced performance owing to the restricted applicability in overburden operation. Re-commissioning of E5M is scheduled for 1st October so that E1B can be released. This excavator will then remain on the main working level of the 3rd overburden system for extracting the coal occurring there. The masses of the two cuts are charged to spreader P4M. Dumping of the section which started in the previous year shall be finished at the beginning of the year. Another shifting of the dump bench belt conveyor would lead to steeper slopes of the total dump system. It is therefore proposed to re-install the dump bench belt conveyor on a lower working level (+510 / +507 mMSL). Therefore the dump-side head belts shall be extended via a ramp to the new height level. In the dump sector too, parallel operation is performed. At the end of the year dumping has to be stopped again. The bench belt conveyor shall be re-shifted into the previously left dumping sector and put into operation again.
4.5.4.3 Coal Operation Preconditions for the commissioning of the first coal line have already been made in 2009, so that the E8M can directly start operation at the beginning of 2010. To reach the planned height of working level between +525 and +515 mMSL the excavator shall start cutting from the eastern bench end where the cutting height is only 12 m. From this position the opening up figure shall be widened to a maximum extend into western and southern direction with permanent extension of the bench belt conveyor. The widening into South (Bardh opencast mine) is divided into two parts. The eastern bench area can be widened to maximum extent to the existing northern rim slope system. The boundary of the widening can be determined operatively and depending on different factors:
Page 74 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Impurification of the coal seam by dump materials
-
Impurification / cavities in the coal seam by coal fires (not yet identified)
In the western bench area the southern field boundary is limited by the mining configuration of the 3rd overburden system. The cutting height of the 1st overburden system increases to 20 m in this section. Parallel to the widening works in the first coal cut the provisions for putting the second coal line into operation shall be made. The route for the second stationery coal belt conveyor has to be prepared and the existing route shall be widened, respectively. Afterwards the coal bench belt conveyor of the 2nd line shall be installed and excavator E9B shifted into the pit. First the 2nd coal bench belt conveyor shall be connected to the existing head belt conveyor system (A). Commissioning of the line is scheduled for 1st July 2010. The thickness of the 2nd coal cut is maximum 30m. The start position of the excavator will be on the working level of the 1st coal cut. Cutting to the planned height of the working level is made stepwise via deep stages. A reduced equipment performance was considered for the whole operating year owing to the complicated technological mode of operation. In 2010 totally 3.4 mt coal shall be extracted in the mine. This sum includes the double mass movement resulting from the moved coal from the 3rd overburden system. One fact to be considered during this operating phase it the coal quality. Whereas in the Sibovc SW mine only high-quality coal will be extracted there is in parallel mined the residual coal from the lower seam horizons of the existing mine. Therefore it will be required to blend the two mass flows for getting homogeneous coal qualities.
4.5.4.4 Production Figures
Coal
Overburden
Mobile
Overburden
Coal
[ mbcm ]
[ mt ]
0.300
1
E10B
0.470
2
E10M
3.300
3
E9M
3.620
3a
E5M
0.590
3a
E1B
0.500
1
E8M
2
E9B
Total Tab.: 4.5-5
Remarks
0.270
Commissioning 1st March as Float Machine 3.400
8.780
Refurbishment March to September Commissioning 1st November 2009 Commissioning 1st July 2010
3.400
Planned Production in the Year 2010
Page 75 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B1 Bench Belt Conveyor B2 Inclining Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor A TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.5-6
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,070 900 400 1,100 1,510 800 970 2,200 1,000 1,340 430 630 1,100 1,010 570 110 100 2,000 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +585 +590 +590 +552 +552 +552 +552 +547 +578 +565 +565 +487 +487 +538 +538 +545 +545 +545 +535 +552 +552 +548 +548 +540 +540 +536 +525 +518 +520 +516 +516 +518 +518 +520 +520 +560 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP
TPP B
TPP A
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2010
Page 76 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5.5 Mining Development in the Year 2011 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 5 4.5.5.1 General Development In 2011 mining operations shall be continued analogue to the previous year. Equipment stock remains the same as well. Coal production shall be increased to 6.0 mt in 2011. As the E8M can be operated in the first coal cut without capacity restrictions and the E9B increases also performance with increasing cutting thickness this output can be realised with the help of the installed equipment. In the overburden operation too, capacity shall be increased by almost 40%. The capacity increase shall be performed by all equipments used. Parallel to the advancing development the application conditions for the main equipment are improving (rising in cutting height of single cuts), which will be basis for improving the performance. Expensive special measures regarding resettlement, infrastructure and dewatering are not scheduled for this year.
Page 77 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-4
Mining Position at the End of Year 2011
4.5.5.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment The mass portion for mobile equipment will further reduce in 2011 and will be limited to 0.200 mbcm. The mass movements are equally distributed to the two bench ends. With a cutting of 0.100 mbcm at the western bench end the excavation of excess heights are finished in this area. Contrary to this the eastern rim slope system of the mine will reach a terrain elevation west of Hade so that subsequently removing of excess heights will become necessary here. The dumping of masses follows analogue to the previous year optional in the residual pit of Mirash and/or as neighbouring dumping of the base rock elevation west of the Bardh mine. Page 78 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1st Overburden System The first overburden system is further developed in parallel operation. The advance will amount to ca. 150m. Due to the reduction of the valley in width the bench length in the first cut can be slightly lengthened. The cutting height reaches continuously 10 to 20 m which is due to the terrain rising into northern direction. The share of the mining front which is covered by dumped masses reaches ca 400 m at the year end. The dumped masses are deposited in the upper slope range; the working level will not be influenced by these masses. The eastern bench half will not be covered by the first overburden system due to the valley cut. In 2011, excavatorE10B will have to remove totally 1.76 mbcm overburden. This corresponds to less than half of the realisable capacity of the excavator. The dump will further be developed in parallel operation and exclusively in high dumping. 2nd Overburden System Excavator E10M will have to remove 4.1 mbcm in the second overburden system. The bench extends over the whole width of the mine. Whereas the cutting depth reaches 20 m in the western bench area, they reduce to partly 10 m in the eastern bench part (valley cut). The problem of surface drainage described for 2010 will also apply to this year. Dump development will also be continued in the 2nd overburden system like in the previous year. The dumping sector is east of the dump dam in the area of the former Mirash-East mine. 3rd Overburden System A total quantity of 6.17 mbcm overburden will have to be removed in the 3rd overburden system in 2011. About 4.81 mbcm of it will come to the main cut (E9M) and 1.36 mbcm to the uncovering cut (E5M).to removed 0.20 mt of coal in the 3rd overburden system which will be assigned to the pit operation. The 3rd overburden system is further developed in parallel operation. The advance in mining direction is ca. 160 m. The working level slightly rises in mining direction and lowers from west to east from + 555 to + 540 mMSL. The cutting height in the main cut is constantly 20m. The annual capacity of 4.81 mbcm to be realised by E9M requires a strict operating regime and avoiding of longer outage. The maximum possible capacity of 5.4 mbcm/a will not be reached. Thickness of the coal-uncovering cut is again 10m. The masses to be removed by E5M are loaded by means of belt wagon to the belt conveyor of the main cut. This cut will be necessary throughout the entire area of the deep coal layer and stretches therefore via the complete middle and eastern bench area. The coal to be exposed in the 3rd overburden system is extracted by excavator E1B and added to the first coal system. This excavator will also take over special operations to be determined if required.
Page 79 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The dump development will be continued on the level taken end of 2010 (+540 / +537 mMSL). Distribution of the masse is performed in parallel operation in high- and deep dumping.
4.5.5.3 Coal Operation Whereas excavator E8M can work in the first coal system over the entire bench, excavator E9B will continue widening operation in the second coal system at the beginning of the year. In the last quarter E9B can also start regular operation on its planed working level (+ 500 / +485 mMSL). The necessary widening works up to the southern rim slope system will be completed as well. The thickness of the 2nd coal system is maximum 30 m so that excavator E9B shall perform ramp excavation. At the beginning of the year the 2nd head belt conveyor (B) will be put into operation in the coal operation. The necessary routes were already prepared in 2010. In 2011, total coal output will amount to 6.0 mt. This figure also includes double mass movements resulting from the extracted coal from the 3rd overburden system (0.200 mt). Analogue to the previous year the coal quality management system of the existing mine and the Sibovc SW mine requires special attendance and increased coordinating expenses. Blending of coal of the two mines is urgently required because the coal extracted in the lower seam part of the existing mine is only of minor quality.
4.5.5.4 Production Figures
Coal
Overburden
Mobile
Overburden
Coal
[ mbcm ]
[ mt ]
0.200
1
E10B
1.760
2
E10M
4.100
3
E9M
4.810
3a
E5M
1.360
3a
E1B
1
E8M
2
E9B
Total Tab.: 4.5-7
Remarks
0.200
Coal double moved by E8M
6.000 12.230
6.000
Planned Production in the Year 2011
Page 80 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.5-8
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,070 1,060 600 1,000 1,510 990 970 2,200 1,000 1,340 630 750 1,100 1,010 980 170 180 180 2,000 2,000 240 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +585 +585 +585 +552 +552 +552 +552 +549 +581 +565 +565 +487 +487 +538 +538 +545 +545 +545 +540 +555 +555 +548 +548 +540 +540 +537 +525 +518 +495 +485 +518 +518 +500 +520 +500 +520 +520 +560 +520 +560 +560 +580 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP DP
TPP B
TPP A
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2011
Page 81 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5.6 Mining Development in the Year 2012 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 6 4.5.6.1 General Development In 2011 coal production from the existing mine will phase out so that the power plants will be fully supplied by the Sibovc SW mine from 2012. Precondition for the long-term coal output of 9 mt/a will be the completion of the equipment fleet in the Sibovc SW mine. Rehabilitation of excavators E8B and E7M shall be finished in this year and put into operation in the 3rd coal system. Due to the closure of coal production in the existing mine and the dismounting of the equipment system considerable dumping space will be available. Therefore, conversion of single lines to inside dumping is scheduled. This conversion offers advantages for different reasons: -
Reduction of the problem of dumping space
-
Shortening of transport distances in overburden operation
-
Improvement of the geotechnical safety with regard to stability of the dump slope system mainly the northern rim slope system south of Hade
Complete conversion of dump integration is only made for the first overburden line. The second line which was used till then east of the dump pillar in the former Mirash East mine shall only be shortened. The downtime during the conversion for this line will only be restricted to the shifting and connection of the spreader into the new bench belt conveyor. The 3rd overburden system will remain in its position.
Page 82 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-5
Mining Position at the End of Year 2012
4.5.6.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment In 2012, mobile equipment will only remove 0.150 mbcm overburden. This equipment will only work in the eastern bench end area where the elevation west of Hade has to be removed. The plateau to be provided by the mobile equipment will serve as level for the overburden conveyor line of the 1st overburden system. The materials will be dumped in the residual pit of Mirash. 1st Overburden System Page 83 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The first overburden system will continue parallel operation with the existing dump connection until March. Analogue to the previous year the material is spoilt in high-dumping. At this time the quantity will amount to 0.74 mbcm. From April the dismounting work of the main equipment of the existing mine will have to be completed to such an extent that the 1st overburden line can be reconstructed. Besides the reduction of the problem of dump space the reconstruction mainly aims at securing the northern rim slope system opposite of Hade. The following single measures have to be accomplished: -
Transport of spreader P3B from present level to +550 mMSL via the dump system to the northern rim slope system (level +468 mMSL). Thereby the belt lines of the 2nd and 3rd overburden system shall be crossed. The transport will be performed in spring so that problems will not be expected.
-
Reversing of transport direction and in parallel extension via the entire bench. The route for the belt conveyor in the eastern bench section shall be prepared by mobile equipment until March 2012.
-
Shifting of the head belt conveyor from western to eastern rim slope system parallel to the head belt conveyor of the 2nd overburden system. For this shifting a belt bridge over the two coal belt conveyor lines shall be planned.
-
Shifting of the dump belt conveyor to the level of the new dump working bench (+468 mMSL). The transport of the two drive stations and the spreader shall be performed in parallel.
Reconstruction measures shall be completed within one month. In the new dumping sector the spreader only works in deep dumping. From the start position the dump bench develops ahead until the connection to the dump system of the former Mirash West mine is produced. Dump base in the technological bottom of the exhausted mine. Partly the material is dumped to a depth of 30 m. This depth is possible because the area is limited to a restricted space. Before re-commissioning of the line, a soil-mechanical assessment shall be made. In 2012 totally 2.7 mbcm have to be moved in the first overburden system. 2nd Overburden System The 2nd overburden system will continue parallel operation. In 2012 a total output capacity of 4.0 mbcm is planned. The cutting heights amount to 20m in the western bench half and 15m in the eastern section. The belt connection to the dump via the eastern rim slope system will be maintained. The exhaustion of the Bardh/Mirash mine in 2011 will provide considerable dumping space in the residual pit which will already be available for the 2nd overburden system at the beginning of 2012. Owing to the already described dump space problems the conversion shall be made as early as possible, if possible already in 2011. The available study assumes a conversion date of 1.1.2012. The conversion will comprise the following measures: -
Transport of the spreader via the southern rim slope system to a level of +465 mMSL directly at the 2nd head belt conveyor of the same system.
Page 84 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Shortening of the 2nd head belt conveyor to 500m and linking of the spreader to this belt conveyor
-
Re-building of the 3rd head belt conveyor and bench belt conveyor
After recommissioning the spreader works in slewing operation exclusively by deep dumping. Dumping heights reach up to 30m. These heights are possible because the area is limited to a restricted space. Parallel to this spreader P3B starts dumping operation on the same working level. Both spreaders will then slew in opposite direction with will result in additional limitation of the slopes. Before re-commissioning of the line, a soil-mechanical assessment shall be made. Overdumping of the main drainage by spreader P3M requires the installation of a new drainage on the working level of the spreader. The water yielded on the technological bottom shall be drained by means of mobile pump station until complete covering of the area. 3rd Overburden System An output capacity of 4.1 mbcm is scheduled for the 3rd overburden system in 2012. In the additional cut 3a another 0.94 mbcm have to be removed for uncovering the coal. Therefore totally 5.04 mbcm have to e dumped by the spreader. In addition 0.63 mt coal are to be exposed in the 3rd overburden cut which will be selectively extracted by excavator E1B and assigned to the coal operation. Dump development is performed according to the same principle like in the previous year. The spreader works in parallel operation in high-and deep dumping. If the dumping slice has reached the next deeper dump slice taking into account the maximum general slope angle, spreader and dump bench belt conveyor shall be reconstructed on the next deeper level ( +510 / +508 mMSL ). The head belt conveyor on the dump side has to be extended via a ramp. Afterwards dumping is continued on this level in high- and deep dumping until the advance to the next dumping slice is used up. Subsequently the system is re-built to the before left level.
4.5.6.3 Coal Operation In 2012 the scheduled production of the mine will amount to 9.0 mt coal. This also includes the double mass movement resulting from the coal extraction in the 3rd overburden system (90% of 0.630 mt). Coal systems 1 and 2 will already work under regular conditions so that the main part of the output shall come from these cuts. In the first half of the year the advance conditions have developed to such an extent that the preparatory works for the 3rs coal system can start. Excavator E8B including the belonging bench belt conveyor will start production on 1st June 2012. The scheduled capacity will be reduced during the first months until the excavator will reach the planned height of working level and a sufficient bench length. The cutting height of the 3rd coal system is 25m. From November excavator E7B including belt wagon will be used additionally in this system. This excavator is planned for developing the additional cut below the E8B. In 2012 this excavator will still work together with E8B on one joint bench.
Page 85 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.5.6.4 Coal Quality Management In 2012 the pit operation of the Sibovc SW opencast mine will be fully equipped. The commissioning of a coal quality management system will become possible and necessary when the operation in the Bardh/Mirash mine is closed and the Sibovc SW mine will be the sole supplier for the power plants TPP A and TPP B. Main reason for this are the considerable variations in the coal quality in vertical seam direction. Basis of the coal quality management system is the technical equipment of the pit operation including possibilities for distribution and blending of the mass streams of the pit operation. The installed belt system offers the following distribution possibilities: -
The three head belt conveyors on the benches in the coal system shall be equipped with drive station furnished with shuttle head. By means of this the coal can be charged from each of the benches optional to one of the two inclined belt conveyors.
-
The two inclined belt conveyors leading to the surface level shall also be furnished with shuttle heads. These inclined belt conveyors can supply optionally each of the connecting belt conveyors to TPP A and TPP B.
Fig.: 4.5-6
Coal Transport and Distribution System in the Year 2012
Totally 5 pieces of 1,600mm-drive stations with shuttle head are required. Optionally it will also be possible to equip the 2 km long head belt conveyors along the northern rim slope
Page 86 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
system with shuttle heads. This would offer another possibility for the coal distribution. This variant shall be regarded as option. The following possibilities for blending result for the coal system in Sibovc SW: -
Control of excavator use at the mining face due to knowledge of in-situ-coal quality distribution in the seam
-
Pre-blending of coal quality by special control of mass flows of the 3 head belt conveyors to 2 inclined belt conveyors
-
tailored direction of mass flows to TPP A and/or TPP B
-
Control o coal quality by layer-wise spreading of raw coal on the stockpile sections of the stockyards
-
Blending of coal quality when reclaiming the heaps including the option of admixing of coal from the run-of-mine stream
Measuring devices for online-measurement of coal qualities (heating value, ash, water content) and the output quantity shall be installed at different places of the belt system. The following measuring points are suggested: discharge belts of excavators, inclined belt conveyor in pit operation and connecting belt conveyors to power plants. A separate project shall be worked out for the detailed specification of the coal quality management system.
4.5.6.5 Production Figures
Coal
Overburden
Mobile
Overburden
Coal
[ mbcm ]
[ mt ]
0.150
1
E10B
2.700
2
E10M
4.000
3
E9M
4.100
3a
E5M
0.770
3a
E1B
1
E8M
2
E9B
3
E8B
3a
E7M
Total Tab.: 4.5-9
Remarks
0.630
9.000 0.095 11.815
Coal double moved by E8M
Commissioning 1st June Commissioning 1st November
9.000
Planned Production in the Year 2012
Page 87 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B E8B
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B Bench Belt Conveyor C Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor C Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.5-10
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,440 1,370 700 1,550 1,270 850 1,340 770 850 1,100 1,010 870 430 290 100 130 250 250 2,000 2,000 240 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +600 +590 +590 +467 +467 +470 +585 +565 +565 +467 +467 +467 +540 +555 +555 +548 +548 +540 +540 +538 +528 +520 +500 +480 +468 +462 +520 +518 +490 +490 +461 +480 +480 +520 +480 +520 +520 +560 +520 +560 +560 +580 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP DP
TPP B
TPP A
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2012
Page 88 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6 Regular Operation 4.6.1 Mining Development in the Period 2013 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2017 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 7 4.6.1.1 General Development In the 5-year period from 2013 until 2017 development of the mine will be continued into northern direction. Mining is executed in parallel operation. After passing of the village Hade operation switches to slewing operation for a short period. With progressing development the cutting heights increase over the whole bench length so that ramp excavation will become necessary over long distances. Local excess heights are removed by draglines and added to the 1st overburden system. From 2016 total cutting thickness will increase to partly more than 110 m in the overburden operation so that mobile operation for removing the excess heights shall be re-installed in the western bench section. During that period the overburden masses are dumped only in the residual pit of Bardh/Mirash. Dumping into the mined out area of the Sibovc SW mine is not possible due to the limited advance conditions. Another important issue in the period 2013 to 2017 is the resettlement of the communities of Mirene and Shipitulla East.
Page 89 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.6-1
Mining Position at the End of Year 2017
4.6.1.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment The increasing cutting thickness in the overburden especially in the western bench area will require removing of excess heights already from 2013. To reduce the mass portion for a Subcontractor (truck and shovel) the additional use of a dragline is proposed. This machine shall remove local excess heights and add the masses to the 1st regular overburden system. The dragline works in high-cut. This measure allows removal of up to 0.400 mbcm overburden per year at reasonable costs. A higher mass portion will not be possible because the capacity of E10B in the 1st overburden system is fully used.
Page 90 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The masses which were not taken by the dragline have to be removed by a Truck & Shoveloperation. Start for the Subcontractor can be delayed due to the dragline use to 2016. Within the period between 2013 and 2017a total overburden quantity of 2.41mbcm have to be removed. The dragline portion is thereby 1.22 mbcm, the subcontractor 1.19 mbcm. Two variants are recommended for the dumping of the masses removed by the Subcontractors. The first alternative is dumping along the northern rim slope system south of Hade. A second alternative would be the dumping on the technological bottom. This alternative would offer the shortest transport distances and allows covering of the technological bottom for preventing coal fires. The disadvantage of this alternative would be the extreme gradient of the accesses (difference in height almost 200m, full load drive falling, empty load drive rising). 1st Overburden System The 1st overburden system is further developed in parallel operation. After passing the village Hade the eastern rim slope system is adjusted to the run of the contour lines of the area. For a short term operation switches to slewing operation in clockwise direction and afterward changes into parallel operation. An additional head belt conveyor shall be put into operation in parallel. With progressing mining operation the 1st overburden cut develops out of the valley site. The cutting thicknesses will therefore also rise in the eastern bench section step by step. In the western bench area cutting thickness is 26 m so that ramp excavation will be necessary. The working level falls from west to east from +620 to 600 mMSL. In the period between 2013and 2017 about 14.78 mbcm have to be removed in the first overburden system. Another 1.22 mbcm (1.342 mlcm) for double movements are added due to the masses moved by the dragline. Dumping of the masses is further continued in the residual pit of the Bardh/Mirash mine south of Hade by means of spreader P3B. The spreader works in slewing operation in clockwise direction. At the beginning of the period under review the spreader is on a height of +467 mMSL. This dumping sector will be closed both by the P3B (from north) as well as by P3M (2nd overburden cut from south). If connection of the two benches is established the head belt conveyor can be shortened and installed on the next higher level (+499 mMSL) along the northern rim slope system. From this position the spreader works in slewing operation in deep dumping. The dumping heights are 26 m. (Spreader P3M, too, will be installed on that level and works in counter direction to P3B.) After this sector will be closed the system will be installed on the next higher level (+526 mMSL) and dumping will be continued. The following masses will be removed: -
Level +467 mMSL
1.79 mlcm
-
Level +499 mMSL
11.74 mlcm
-
Level +526 mMSL
4.07 mlcm
Total
17.60 mlcm
=
16.00 mbcm
According to the advance in the dumping slices and the re-installation on the next higher level the operative drainage system including the installed pumps and pipelines shall be moved. 2nd Overburden System
Page 91 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The development of the second overburden system follows the first overburden system. Here also, the bending of the rim slope system requires putting an additional head belt conveyor into operation. The cutting height is in this cut 20 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 28m, so that the E10M has to work continuously in ramp excavation to shape a stable slope. The normal cutting height should be maximal 20m. This mean a ramp is necessary for a cutting height of 8 m. The maximum admissible height difference between travelling gear of the basic equipment and the loading equipment is 10m. The overburden quantity to be removed within the period under review amounts to 24.5 mbcm. This corresponds to an annual output capacity of 4.9 mbcm. To be able to realise this capacity continuously over a period of 5 years a consistent operational management shall be performed. However, such a capacity is realistic; the maximum possible capacity (considering the specific deposit conditions as well as technical and climatic conditions) was not assessed. The masses are dumped synchronous to the first overburden system. Dumping site is the residual pit of Bardh / Mirash south of Hade. Spreader P3M works on the same working level like spreader P3B of the first overburden system. The machine works in slewing operation counter-clockwise and therefore in opposite direction of the P3B. If the respective dumping sector is closed the dump bench belt conveyor will be shifted to the next higher level and dumping is continued. Contrary to the P3B the installation position of the dump bench belt conveyor is directed north-south. At the end of the period under review the working level lies at a height of +525mMSL. The following quantities are dumped: -
Level +467 mMSL
2.68 mlcm
-
Level +499 mMSL
18.17 mlcm
-
Level +526 mMSL
6.11 mlcm
Total
26.96 mlcm
=
24.51 mbcm
3rd Overburden System An output capacity of 20.41 mbcm is planned for the 3rd overburden system within the period from 2013 to 2017. Additionally 4.32 mbcm are required for exposing the coal in auxiliary cut 3a. Therefore spreader P4M has a total dumping capacity of 24.73 mbcm (27.2 mlcm). Furthermore, about 4.32 mbcm coal are to be extracted selectively and added to the coal operation. This overburden cut will also reach cutting heights of more than 20m, so that here ramp excavation will be required. The auxiliary cut 3a has to remove a constant cutting height of 10m. The connection to the dump side via the western rim slope system will remain. A changeover to inside dumping in Sibovc SW cannot be implemented in this period since the available bench lengths would result in a rapid approach to the coal operation. Thereby it is of disadvantage that the exposed bottom will not continuously be covered by an inside dump. The following principle problems result from this. -
The residual coal on the exposed bottom as well as at the rim slope systems is subject to self-ignition due to the long lifetime. This can be avoided by placing a thin cover with cohesive material (mobile equipment).
-
Due to the missing inside dump the rim slope systems cannot be integrated over a period of more than 5 years. The long lifetime of the rim slope systems shall be considered in the soil-mechanical assessment.
Page 92 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The dumping is therefore continued in the area of the former Bardh mine. In 2013 the advance conditions require reconstruction of the dump bench belt conveyor to a lower level. The head belt conveyor on the dump side shall be lengthened and lead via ramps to a height of +523 mMSL. The dump bench belt conveyor shall also be installed on this level. In the start position the dump bench belt conveyor runs in north-south direction. The spreader works in slewing operation counter-clockwise. During the ca. 4-years operation with a total volume of 22.1mlcm the bench is extended from 1,100 to 1,550 m. If spreader P4M will approach spreader P3M of the 2nd overburden system in 2016 dump bench belt conveyor and spreader shall be shifted to the level +540 mMSL. Therefore the head belt conveyor on the dump side has to be shortened by ca. 200 m. The spreader works then in deep- and high dumping in slewing operation counter-clockwise. In this dump slice more than 5.1 mlcm overburden have to be spread again until the end of 2017. The high-dumping operation produces the later surface level. To guarantee drainage of the terrain the final dumping must have a continuous gradient (1 : 150) in south-western direction.. This ensures the drainage of the surface water into the direction of the Drenica.
4.6.1.3 Coal Operation The coal benches follow the uncovering cut in parallel operation. The head belt conveyors shall be lengthened according to the opencast mine advance. At the beginning of 2013 the 3rd coal cut has to be widened completely, afterwards this cut also changes over to regular operation. Within the period of 2013to 2017 the mine has a coal production 45.0 mt (9.0 mt/a). This includes also the coal quantity of 2.7 mt from the 3rd overburden cut.
Page 93 of 171
4.6.1.4 Production Figures 2013
2014
2015
2016
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
Overburden
Mobile
Coal
2017
0.360
0.830
Dragline
0.190
0.140
0.090
0.400
0.400
1
E10B
3.470
3.080
2.710
3.280
3.460
2
E10M
4.900
4.900
4.900
4.900
4.900
3
E9M
4.010
4.170
4.340
4.050
3.840
3a
E5M
0.850
0.890
0.930
0.850
0.800
3a
E1B
1
E8M
2
E9B
3
E8B
3a
E7M
Total Tab.: 4.6-1
13.360
Masses double moved by E10B
0.850
0.640
0.430
0.400
0.380
9.000
9.000
9.000
9.000
9.000
0.130
0.140 9.000
13.180
0.140 9.000
Planned Production in the Years 2013 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2017
13.020
0.145 9.000
13.585
0.155 9.000
13.985
Remarks
9.000
Coal double moved by E8M
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B E8B E7M
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B Bench Belt Conveyor C Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor C Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.6-2
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 1,730 390 1,170 570 1000 1,570 140 1,400 1,480 1,250 110 1,500 990 1,100 1,010 870 650 850 650 470 320 320 2,000 2,000 240 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2017
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +620 +598 +598 +590 +590 +526 +526 +525 +525 +518 +595 +563 +563 +563 +563 +524 +524 +525 +540 +565 +565 +565 +565 +548 +548 +540 +540 +539 +540 +520 +510 +499 +480 +473 +520 +518 +499 +490 +473 +470 +470 +520 +470 +520 +520 +560 +520 +560 +560 +580 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP DP
TPP B
TPP A
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6.2 Mining Development in the Period 2018 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2022 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 8 4.6.2.1 General Development The development of the Sibovc SW mine will be continued into northern direction within the period from 2018 to 2022. The overburden thickness increases along the whole mining face so that the mass portion for the Subcontractor will also increase. At the end of the period under review the terrain elevation is cut so that cutting thicknesses in this area will further decrease. This fact is likewise of advantage for the dewatering of the pre-mining area. The 3rd overburden cut will changeover to inside dumping that means the masses will not be dumped any longer in the residual pit of the former Bardh mine but in the Sibovc SW mine. The other two overburden lines will continue dumping in the residual pit of Mirash / Bardh. Aim is the producing of large final dump surface areas. Owing to the opencast mine advance parts of Hade North must be resettled in 2019.
Page 96 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.6-2
Mining Position at the End of Year 2022
4.6.2.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment The further increasing cutting thickness in the overburden requires continuation of removal of excess heights over the whole bench length. In this operation there are further used dragline (mass transfer to the 1st overburden system) and the subcontractor with Shovel & Truckoperation. The mass portion of the dragline reduces from 0.4 mbcm in 2018 to 0.2 mbcm in the following years. This reduction is due to the capacity of the following 1st overburden system. The E10B is not able to cope with a higher mass portion in addition to its planned annual capacity of 3.9 mbcm. Page 97 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Therefore the capacity of the mobile equipment operation shall be increased to 1.4 mbcm/a. It is proposed to dump the masses in a dumping space in the inside dump of Sibovc SW. The western rim slope system is ideal due to the short transport distances and minimal crossing of obstacles. With advancing development the crest of the terrain elevation is cut in the central bench area. The resulting gap in the mining face of the mobile equipment operation is used to drain the surface water from the pre-mining field and the working level of the mobile equipment operation in the future. The before installed ditch system for pre-mining field dewatering with the box-culvert is for the most part overexcavated at this time and therefore out of operation. During the progressing opencast mine development both the catchment area and the water quantities of surface water have considerably reduced. 1st Overburden System The 1st overburden system will further develop in parallel operation. Due to the increasing total cutting thickness in the area of the terrain elevation the rim slope system has to be widened. The bench length in the 1st overburden system will therefore extend from 1,800 m in 2017 to 2,300 m in 2022. Except for the bench ends the cutting thickness continuously amounts to 26 m. Therefore ramp excavation is necessary on the entire bench. The working level falls from west to east from +620 to 605 mMSL. Within the period from 2018 to 2022 the first overburden cut has to remove 19.22 mbcm. In addition 1.20 mbcm (1.32 mlcm) have to be removed due to double movement of the masses taken by the dragline. The masses are dumped in the residual pit of the Bardh/Mirash mine south of Hade by spreader P3B. The spreader works in slewing operation clockwise. At the beginning of the period under review the spreader is on a level of +526 / +519 mMSL. This dumping sector will be closed both by P3B (from the north) and by P3M (2nd overburden system from the south). If connection of the two benches is established the bench belt conveyor and the spreader can be installed on the next higher level (+546 / 539 mMSL) along the northern rim slope system. From this position the spreader works in slewing operation in deep- and high dumping. The dumping heights amount to 20m, the thickness of high dumping is 12m. (Spreader P3M will again work on this working level and operate opposite direction of the P3B). The high dumping shall produce the planned final surface level. It is planned to shape a mainly flat final dump area which is suitable for agricultural use. In the area of Hade a slight elevation shall be re-established with gradient (1 : 150) into western direction to the Drenica River and into eastern direction to the Sitnica. The connection to the original surface level is the area of the terrain elevation south of Hade will not be reached. In the described dumping slices P3B shall dump the following quantities: -
Level +526 / +519 mMSL
7.53 mlcm
-
Level +546 / +539 mMSL
19.43 mlcm
Total
22.46 mlcm
=
20.42 mbcm
According to the advance in the lower dumping slices and operative drainage system including the installed pumps and pipelines shall be put out of operation and moved. Parallel to that the respective ditch systems on the dump surface shall be installed and activated.
Page 98 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2nd Overburden System The 2nd overburden system follows in its development the 1st overburden cut in parallel opera-tion. The cutting thickness remains at 26 m over the entire period under review and requires continuous ramp excavation. Within the period from 2018 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2022 an output capacity of 23.56 mbcm will be required. This corresponds to an annual capacity of the E10M between 4.9 and 4.45 mbcm. The masses are dumped synchronous to the first overburden system. Dumping site is the residual pit of Bardh / Mirash south of Hade. Spreader P3M works on the same working level like spreader P3B of the first overburden system. The machine works in slewing operation counter-clockwise and therefore in opposite direction of the P3B. If the dumping sector on the level +524 mMSL will be closed, dump bench belt conveyor and spreader will be shifted to the level +545 mMSL. The P3B takes its position on the bench left by the P4M (3rd overburden system) and developed in the following period into parallel operation into eastern direction. The spreader works now in deep- and high dumping whereby the final dump surface is produced by high-dumping. The required surface profile will be shaped as already described for the 1st overburden system. The following quantities are dumped by P3M: -
Level +524 mMSL
8.68 mlcm
-
Level +545 mMSL
17.24 mlcm
Total
25.92 mlcm
=
23.56 mbcm
The produced final dump areas shall be graded and ditch systems installed. 3rd Overburden System An output capacity of 18.14 mbcm is planned for the 3rd overburden system within the period from 2018 to 2022. Additionally 3.06 mbcm are required for exposing the coal in auxiliary cut 3a. Therefore spreader P4M has a total dumping capacity of 21.20 mbcm (23.232 mlcm). Furthermore, about 0.51 mbcm coal are to be extracted selectively by E1B and added to the coal operation. The cutting height of the 3rd overburden cut will come to more than 20m, so that here continuous ramp excavation will be required. The auxiliary cut 3a has to remove a constant cutting height of 10m. The connection to the dump side via the western rim slope system will remain. By mid of 2019 the masses will be dumped in the former Bardh opencast mine producing thereby final dump areas. The spreader operation develops with slightly rising working level. In 2019 preconditions shall be arranged for changeover to inside dumping in Sibovc SW. The respective ramps shall be produced by means of mobile equipment. The actual changeover of the dumping is planned for mid of 2019. The head belt conveyor shall be shortened and the head belt conveyor on the dump side as well as the dump bench belt conveyor shifted. The inside dumping slice will be developed beginning in the south into northern direction. During the dumping operation the head belt conveyors of the coal systems running along the eastern rim slope systems shall be considered. The following quantities are dumped by P4M: Page 99 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Level +554 mMSL
6.80 mlcm
-
Level +478 / +498 mMSL Total
16.52 mlcm 23.32 mlcm
=
21.20 mbcm
4.6.2.3 Coal Operation The coal benches follow the uncovering cut in parallel operation. The head belt conveyor plants shall be extended according to the opencast mine advance. An output capacity of 45.0 mt (9.0 mt/a) coal have to be excavated within the period from 2018 to 2022. This capacity includes also the 0.51 mt coal extracted in the 3rd overburden cut.
Page 100 of 171
4.6.2.4 Production Figures
Coal
Overburden
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
Mobile
0.860
1.320
1.320
1.280
1.410
Dragline
0.400
0.200
0.200
0.200
0.200
1
E10B
4.020
4.100
4.100
4.100
4.100
2
E10M
4.900
4.770
4.770
4.670
4.450
3
E9M
3.820
3.740
3.740
3.590
3.250
3a
E5M
0.780
0.670
0.670
0.580
0.360
3a
E1B
1
E8M
2
E9B
3
E8B
3a
E7M
Total Tab.: 4.6-3
14.535
Masses double moved by E10B
0.320
0.060
0.060
0.050
0.020
9.000
9.000
9.000
9.000
9.000
0.155
0.155 9.000
14.755
0.165 9.000
Planned Production in the Years 2018 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2022
14.765
0.165 9.000
14.385
0.165 9.000
13.735
Remarks
9.000
Coal double moved by E8M
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Inclining Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B E8B E7M
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B Bench Belt Conveyor C Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor C Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.6-4
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 2,100 700 1,170 900 1,450 1,580 540 1,270 1,100 1,250 750 1,260 250 600 890 790 710 1,290 1,110 960 320 320 2,000 2,000 240 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Belt Conveyor System at the End of Year 2022
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +620 +605 +605 +590 +590 +545 +545 +543 +543 +539 +595 +572 +572 +567 +567 +545 +545 +544 +540 +558 +558 +565 +565 +550 +550 +500 +500 +510 +545 +530 +520 +505 +495 +480 +530 +518 +505 +490 +480 +470 +470 +520 +470 +520 +520 +560 +520 +560 +560 +580 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP DP
TPP B
TPP A
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6.3 Mining Development in the Period 2023 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2024 Illustration of technology in attachment 4 - 9 4.6.3.1 General Development The Sibovc SW opencast mine will further develop into the north until it reaches the preliminary final position. Except a ca. 400 m long area in the eastern bench section the crest of the terrain elevation is cut so that the total cutting thickness in the overburden will slightly reduce. The mass portion of the excess height removal can therefore also be decreased. The regular overburden systems will continue parallel operation into northern direction whereby the great cutting heights from the previous operating period will remain. The dumping system will also be maintained. The 3rd overburden system is dumping in the inside dump of Sibovc SW. The spreaders of the other two overburden lines work in the final dumping slice of the residual pit Mirash / Bardh. Complete closure of the residual space cannot be achieved until 2024. In 2023 the coal output comes to 9.0 mt, in the last operating year the demand will reduce to 6.0 mt. In 2023 parts of the community of Konxhul have to be resettled.
Page 103 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.6-3
Mining Position in the Year 2024
4.6.3.2 Overburden Operation Mobile Equipment In 2023 another 1.4 mbcm overburden have to be removed by mobile equipment. Owing to the advance conditions and the decreasing total cutting thicknesses the mobile equipment can be put out of operation at the end of 2023. The masse are dumped on the inside dump of Sibovc SW. The remaining excess heights can be removed by the dragline and added to the first overburden line. This mass portion amounts to totally 0.22 mbcm for both of the annual slices.
Page 104 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1st Overburden System The first overburden system continues its development into northern direction with the existing dump connection. In 2023 E10B has to remove about 4.1mbcm overburden. This quantity includes the double mass movements of the overburden masses removed by the dragline. If development of the mine will not be continued beyond 2024 the first overburden line will be put out of operation in the 1st quarter. In 2024 the mass portion for this line is 0.11 mbcm. The overburden (4.63 mlcm) is dumped in high-and deep dumping in the final dumping slice in the residual pit of Bardh / Mirash. 2nd Overburden System The 2nd overburden system is further developed in parallel operation. This cut also shall be put out of operation in the first quarter of 2024 if the Sibovc SW mine will not be continued. Excavator E10M will remove 4.5mbcm overburden in the two years whereby the main portion is to be excavated in 2023. The belt connection to the dump via the eastern rim slope system remains. The dumping slice will be further developed parallel into eastern direction. The spreader has to distribute 4.95 mlcm in the dumping slice. Complete closure of the residual space of Bardh / Mirash until the planned final dump level will not be possible until 2024 (please see next chapter). 3rd Overburden System In 2023/24 the output capacity for the 3rd overburden system is planned with 3.33 mbcm. An additional volume of 0.37 mbcm will be removed in the auxiliary cut 3a for uncovering the coal. During this period spreader P4M has to distribute totally 3.7 mbcm on the inside dump of Sibovc SW. Moreover about 0.02 mt of coal are to be excavated in the 3rd overburden cut and added to the coal operation. In the inside dump of Sibovc SW the spreader works in parallel operation in high- and deep dumping taking account of the head belt conveyors of the coal operation.
4.6.3.3 Coal Operation Whereas in 2023 the coal quantity to be extracted will amount to 9.0 mt the demand will reduce to 6.0 mt in 2024. This reduction is due to the stepwise decommissioning of the existing power plant capacities. The 3 coal systems are further developed in parallel operation. With regard to the closure of the operation in 2024 the regular working level width of ca 100 m will be reduced to 50 m in the final position. This measure does neither affect the soil-mechanical requirements nor impede the resumption and/or continuation of the operations.
Page 105 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6.3.4 Production Figures
Coal
Overburden
2023
2024
OB
Coal
OB
Coal
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
Mobile
1.400
Dragline
0.200
0.020
1
E10B
4.100
0.050
2
E10M
4.450
0.050
3
E9M
3.250
0.080
3a
E5M
0.360
0.010
3a
E1B
1
E8M
2
E9B
3
E8B
3a
E7M
Total Tab.: 4.6-5
Masses double moved by E10B
0.020
Coal double moved by E8M
9.000 0.160 13.720
Remarks
6.000 0.110
9.000
300
6.000
Planned Production in the Years 2023 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2024
Page 106 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Excav. E10B
Conveyor Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E10M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E9M E5M
Bench Belt Conveyor Head Belt Conveyor Inclining Belt Conveyor Dump Bench Belt Conveyor
E8M E9B E8B E7M
Bench Belt Conveyor A Bench Belt Conveyor B Bench Belt Conveyor C Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor C Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B Head Belt Conveyor A Head Belt Conveyor B Inclining Belt Conveyor A Inclining Belt Conveyor B TML-A1
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP B
TML-A2 TML-B1 TML-B2 K-14
Connection Belt Conveyors to TPP A
K-15 K-14a K-15a
Tab.: 4.6-6
Width [ mm ] 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,200 1,200 1,800 1,800
Length [m] 2,100 810 1,170 900 1,450 1,580 620 1,280 330 1,150 1,250 840 500 530 890 750 710 1,470 1,350 1,240 320 320 2,000 2,000 240 240 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,300 1,433 1,515 1,450 1,520
Level Return St. Drive St. [ mMSL ] [ mMSL ] +620 +610 +610 +590 +590 +545 +545 +543 +543 +540 +590 +573 +573 +567 +567 +545 +545 +545 +545 +544 +540 +560 +560 +565 +565 +500 +500 +505 +537 +520 +505 +510 +480 +485 +520 +518 +510 +490 +485 +470 +470 +520 +470 +520 +520 +560 +520 +560 +560 +580 +560 +580 horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal horizontal
Spreader
P3B
P3M
P4M
DP DP
TPP B
TPP A
Belt Conveyor System in the Year 2024
Page 107 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6.4 Remarks to a Continuation of Mining Development after 2024 At the end of the coal production in the Sibovc SW field the following situation will be found: -
The winning front will stop directly at and/or behind the crest of the elevation south of the Sibovc valley. Therefore the final slope system of the winning front has reached the section with the highest overburden thickness.
-
On the inside dump of Sibovc SW only one dumping slice was distributed consisting of deep- and high dumping. The residual pit of Sibovc SW will therefore be entirely surrounded by free standing rim slope systems except the in 3rd coal system.
-
Although the overburden of Sibovc SW was almost exclusively dumped in the residual pit of Bardh / Mirash a complete closure of the pit will not be possible. There remains a dumping space deficit of ca. 50 mlcm up to the complete closure. It has to be considered that the concept took account of a filling only up to a height of +546 / +558 mMSL and not a connection on the surface level. This way the dumping space was minimized with simultaneously ensuring a natural drainage of the surface water in the post-mining landscape.
Ceasing of coal mining operations in 2024 would therefore result in a number of negative aspects which would incur expensive subsequent work at the residual pits. Continuation of the mining is therefore recommended and offers the following advantages: -
Continuing mining activities would lead to an improved overburden : coal ratio because the terrain elevations along the northern and to a certain extend also the eastern rim slope system were mainly removed.
-
The residual pit of the former Bardh / Mirash mine could be closed finally and a useable surface would be provided.
-
Continuation of inside dumping in the Sibovc SW mine leads to an increasing securing of the rim slope system and improves the geotechnical safety in the long-run.
4.6.5 Remarks to Interactions with other Projects At present it is planned to flush the ash of TPP B in the residual pit of the former Mirash East opencast mine. Analogue to the Mid Term Plan for existing Mines this area was also not planned for dumping of overburden in the Complementary Mine Plan. Apart from this, it is considered to change the ash dumping of TPP A. The ash of TPP A is presently dumped on a separate outside dump by means of belt conveyor and spreader. The ash dump is produced on an outside overburden dump which is subject to extreme high pressure due to the applied load and results in cracks in the ash body. Future dumping space could also be the residual pit of Mirash East. The project for removing the existing ash dump A is directly connected with the change of the ash dumping of TPP A for geotechnical and environmentally relevant reasons. According to rough estimations the volume of this ash dump comes to ca. 25 mbcm. In addition to the ash
Page 108 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
yield of the two power plants up to their decommissioning there results a total volume of ca. 50 mbcm power plant ash if all projects will be implemented. The dumping space in the partial field of Mirash East will not be sufficient enough so that dumping has to be continued in the residual pit of n Bardh / Mirash. Therefore, dumping activities of the Sibovc SW opencast mine are directly affected. The respective adjustments and the temporal as well as spatial dependencies are required in connection with the corresponding project works. A positive side effect of these projects would be the considerable reduction of the residual pit south of Hade.
Page 109 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.7 Compilation of Production Figures Overburden
Coal
Working Ratio
[mbcm]
[mt]
[bcm/t]
2008
2.160
-
-
2009
6.400
-
-
2010
8.785
3.4
5.10 : 1
2011
12.230
6.0
2.04 : 1
2012
11.720
9.0
1.32 : 1
2013
13.435
9.0
1.49 : 1
2014
13.250
9.0
1.47 : 1
2015
13.025
9.0
1.45 : 1
2016
13.590
9.0
1.51 : 1
2017
13.990
9.0
1.55 : 1
2018
14.540
9.0
1.61 : 1
2019
14.760
9.0
1.64 : 1
2020
14.770
9.0
1.64 : 1
2021
14.390
9.0
1.60 : 1
2022
13.740
9.0
1.53 : 1
2023
13.730
9.0
1.53 : 1
2024
0.385
6.0
0.06 : 1
Total
195.075
123.4
1.58 : 1
Tab.: 4.7-1
Lignite Production and Overburden Removal
Page 110 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Truck &
Dragline
Shovel [mbcm]
[mbcm]
OB
OB
OB
OB
Coal
Bench 1
Bench 2
Bench 3
Bench 3a
Bench 3/3a
Overb.
Coal
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mbcm]
[mt]
[mbcm]
[mt]
2008
0.660
1.000
2009
0.600
2.000
0.200
3.100
0.500
0.290
6.40
0.29
2010
0.300
0.470
3.300
3.620
1.090
0.270
8.78
0.27
2011
0.200
1.760
4.100
4.810
1.360
0.200
12.23
0.20
2012
0.150
2.700
4.000
4.100
0.770
0.630
11.72
0.63
4.900
4.010
0.850
0.850
13.23
0.85
4.900
4.170
0.890
0.640
13.04
4.900
4.340
0.930
0.430
12.88
4.900
4.050
0.850
0.400
13.44
4.900
3.840
0.800
0.380
13.83
4.900
3.820
0.780
0.320
14.38
4.770
3.740
0.670
0.060
14.60
4.770
3.740
0.670
0.060
14.60
4.670
3.590
0.580
0.050
14.22
4.450
3.250
0.360
0.020
13.57
4.450
3.250
0.360
0.020
13.56
0.050
0.080
0.010
64.160
58.010
11.470
2013
0.190
3.280
2014
0.140
2.940
2015
0.090
2.620
+0.190
+0.140
+0.090
2016
0.360
0.400
2.880
2017
0.830
0.400
3.060
2018
0.860
0.400
3.620
2019
1.320
0.200
3.900
2020
1.320
0.200
3.900
2021
1.280
0.200
3.900
2022
1.410
0.200
3.900
2023
1.400
0.200
3.900
2024
0.020
0.020
0.090
Total
10.710
2.640
45.920
+0.400
+0.400
+0.400
+0.200
+0.200
+0.200
+0.200
+0.200
+0.020
+2.640
0.500
Total
2.16
+0.19
+0.14
+0.09
+0.40
+0.40
+0.40
+0.20
+0.20
+0.20
+0.20
+0.20
0.43 0.40 0.38 0.32 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.02 0.02
0.25 +0.02
4.620
192.91 +2.64
Masses from dragline has to be moved double
Tab.: 4.7-2
0.64
Benchwise Production in Overburden Systems [mbcm]
Page 111 of 171
4.62
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Total Tab.: 4.7-3
T&S [mbcm] 0.660 0.600 0.300 0.200 0.150
Dragline [mbcm]
0.360 0.830 0.860 1.320 1.320 1.280 1.410 1.400 0.020 10.710
0.190 0.140 0.090 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.200 0.200 0.200 0.200 0.200 0.020 2.640
Tab.: 4.7-4
A2Rs B 4400 P3B [mbcm] [mlcm] 1.000 1.100 2.000 2.200 0.470 0.517 1.760 1.936 2.700 2.970 3.470 3.817 3.080 3.388 2.710 2.981 3.280 3.608 3.460 3.806 4.020 4.422 4.100 4.510 4.100 4.510 4.100 4.510 4.100 4.510 4.100 4.510 0.110 0.210 48.560 53.416
Overburden Removal 1st Bench
SchRs 650 E10M [mbcm] 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Total
SRs 1300 E10B [mbcm] double moved 1.000 overburden by 2.000 dragline 0.470 1.760 2.700 0.190 3.280 0.140 2.940 0.090 2.620 0.400 2.880 0.400 3.060 0.400 3.620 0.200 3.900 0.200 3.900 0.200 3.900 0.200 3.900 0.200 3.900 0.020 0.090 2.640 45.920
0.200 3.300 4.100 4.000 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.770 4.770 4.670 4.450 4.450 0.050 64.160
A2Rs B 5200 P3M [mbcm] [mlcm] 0.200 3.300 4.100 4.000 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.900 4.770 4.770 4.670 4.450 4.450 0.050 64.160
0.220 3.630 4.510 4.400 5.390 5.390 5.390 5.390 5.390 5.390 5.247 5.247 5.137 4.895 4.895 0.055 70.576
Overburden Removal 2nd Bench
Page 112 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Total
SchRs 650 E9M [mbcm] 0.500 3.100 3.620 4.810 4.100 4.010 4.170 4.340 4.050 3.840 3.820 3.740 3.740 3.590 3.250 3.250 0.080 58.010
E5M [mbcm]
E1B [mt]
0.500 1.090 1.360 0.770 0.850 0.890 0.930 0.850 0.800 0.780 0.670 0.670 0.580 0.360 0.360 0.010 11.470
0.290 0.270 0.200 0.630 0.850 0.640 0.430 0.400 0.380 0.320 0.060 0.060 0.050 0.020 0.020 4.620
A2RsB 5200 P4M [mbcm] [mlcm] 0.500 0.550 3.600 3.960 4.710 5.181 6.170 6.787 4.870 5.357 4.860 5.346 5.060 5.566 5.270 5.797 4.900 5.390 4.640 5.104 4.600 5.060 4.410 4.851 4.410 4.851 4.170 4.587 3.610 3.971 3.610 3.971 0.090 0.099 69.480 76.428
Coal [mt] 0.290 0.270 0.200 0.630 0.850 0.640 0.430 0.400 0.380 0.320 0.060 0.060 0.050 0.020 0.020 4.620
st
Coal from E1B has to be moved in the 1 coal cut by direct dumping technology
Tab.: 4.7-5
Overburden Removal 3rd Bench
Page 113 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Coal
Coal
Coal
Coal
Coal
Overburden
Total
OB Bench
Cut 1
Cut 2
Cut 3
Cut 3a
Cut 3/3a
E1B
E8M
E9B
E8B
E7M
E8B E7M
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mt]
[mbcm]
0.420
3.400
3.260
6.000
Coal
Overburden
[mt]
[mbcm]
2008 2009
0.290
2010
0.270
2.420
2011
0.200
2.540
2012
0.630
2.970
2013
0.850
2.300
2014
0.640
+0.560
+0.200
4.070
1.180
0.150
0.095
9.000
0.095
3.510
1.950
0.390
0.130
9.000
0.130
3.590
2.010
0.400
0.140
9.000
0.140
3.490
2.230
0.450
0.140
9.000
0.140
3.510
2.240
0.450
0.145
9.000
0.145
3.370
2.280
0.570
0.155
9.000
0.155
3.230
2.340
0.710
0.155
9.000
0.155
3.320
2.410
0.740
0.155
9.000
0.155
3.270
2.510
0.750
0.165
9.000
0.165
3.270
2.520
0.750
0.165
9.000
0.165
3.160
2.570
0.740
0.165
9.000
0.165
2.800
2.700
0.660
0.160
9.000
0.160
0.960
1.870
2.520
0.650
0.110
6.000
0.110
35.770
46.140
29.460
7.410
1.880
123.400
1.880
+0.630
+0.850
2.360 +0.640
2015
0.430
2.400
2016
0.400
2.400
2017
0.380
2.400
2018
0.320
2.400
2019
0.060
2.470
2020
0.060
2.410
2021
0.050
2.410
2022
0.020
2.510
2023
0.020
2.820
2024 Total
4.620
+0.430
+0.400
+0.380
+0.320
+0.060
+0.060
+0.050
+0.020
+0.020
+4.620
Coal from E1B has to be moved double by E8M
Tab.: 4.7-6
Bench-wise and Equipment-wise Production in Coal System
Page 114 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.8 Belt Conveyor Balance In the existing KEK-mine (including the transfer at the Separation Plant) conveyor belts are used with varying width between 1,200 und 1,800 mm. The 1,800 mm belts are exclusively used in the Mirash mine in the powerful overburden lines 2 and 3 – with attached SchRs 650 – and partly in the coal connecting belt systems. The following table summarises the available belt conveyor lines in the existing mine (up to boundary of stockpiles).
active passive
1,200 mm
1,400 mm
1,600 mm
1,800 mm
Drive Stations
6
20
11
9
Frames
5,600 m
13,070 m
6,800 m
6,800 m
Drive Stations
13
7
1
9
Frames Tab.: 4.8-1
Available Belt Conveyor Material in Existing Mine
For the mine Sibovc SW it is foreseen to use predominately refurbished material from the existing mine. It has been calculated and decided that predominantly belt conveyors with a width of 1,800 and 1,600 mm will be applied in the mine Sibovc SW except the connecting belt conveyors to the TPP B and partly to the TPP A (please see following table). Width
No.
Total Length
TPP B
1,400 mm
4
5,200 m
existing
TPP A
1,200 mm
2
2,950 m
existing
1,800 mm
2
2,950 m
planned connection belt conveyor line in case of rehabilitation of two units in TPP A
Tab.: 4.8-2
Remarks
Existing and Planned Overland Belt Conveyors to TPP’s
The next table illustrates the belt conveyor balance for the new Mine Sibovc SW. In the first columns the available belt conveyor material in the existing mine is presented. The following columns the demand on material for the new mine is presented. The figures don’t include the demand in the existing mine in the parallel operation phase of existing mine and Sibovc SW mine (2008 – 2011). For the 1,600mm and 1,800 mm belt conveyor system it is partly planned to purchase new plant parts (stations and frames). This means that the strongly worn out passive reserves of the Mine Bardh / Mirash will not be reactivated. The new purchase is made step-wise via several years and will amount to a total number of 6 pieces 1,600 mm drive stations, 4 pieces 1,800 mm drive stations and 16 km frames. Especially for the 1,200 mm and 1,400 mm belts there will be a surplus for stations and frames. In this connection it is recommended to replace the 1,200 mm connecting belt conveyor line to TPP A by a 1,400 mm belt conveyor.
Page 115 of 171
available
1,200 mm
active
passive
Drive Stations
6
13
Conv. Length
5,600
2008
2009
Connection belt conveyors to TPP A in responsibility of existing mine
2010
2011
2012
2017
2022
2024
2
2
2
2
2
2
2,948
2,948
2,948
2,948
2,948
2,948
4
4
4
4
4
4
5,200
5,200
5,200
5,200
5,200
5,200
Purchase DS Purchase Conv.
1,400 mm
Drive Stations
20
Conv. Length
13,070
7
Connection belt conveyors to TPP B in responsibility of existing mine
Purchase DS Purchase Conv.
1,600 mm
Drive Stations
11
Conv. Length
6,800
1
4
4
10
13
15
17
17
17
3,100
3,220
7,600
10,730
11,320
14,480
17,190
17,960
2
2
400
800
2,460
Purchase DS
2
Purchase Conv.
1,800 mm
Drive Stations
9
Conv. Length
6,800
Purchase DS Purchase Conv.
Tab.: 4.8-3
9
4,900
2,600
4
9
11
11
9
11
11
11
2,990
9,650
12,950
13,460
10,700
12,510
11,570
11,050
2
2
3,000
2,000
Belt Conveyor Balance for the new Sibovc SW Mine
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.9 Time Schedule 4.9.1 Main Equipment Activities 2006 I
E1M
II
2007 III
IV
I
II
2008 III
IV
I
II
2009 III
IV
2nd Line Mirash Coal Operation Mirash
E3M
Coal Operation Mirash
E4M
E9M E10M
2010 III
IV
I
II
2011 III
IV
I
II
2012 III
IV
I
II
III
IV
Coal Operation Mirash 2nd Line Mirash 1st Line further Application in Mirash possible
planned Reha
E7M E8M
II
Coal Operation Mirash
E2M
E5M E6M
I
3rd OB Line Sibovc
Coal Operation Mirash 3rd Line Mirash 1st Line Mirash 2nd Line Mirash
planned Reha
planned Reha
Coal Sibovc planned Reha
3rd Line Sibovc
3rd Line Mirash
E1B
planned Reha
2nd Line Sibovc
Coal Operation Bardh
Float Machine
E2B E4B
Coal Operation Bardh
E6B
3rd Line Bardh
E7B E8B E9B
Coal Operation Bardh
3rd Line Bardh 2nd Line Bardh
E10B
1st Line Bardh
P1M
3rd Line Mirash
P3M
2nd Line Mirash
P4M
1st Line Mirash
P1B
3rd Line Bardh
P2B
2nd Line Bardh
P3B
1st Line Bardh
Tab.: 4.9-1
Coal Operation Bardh
1st Line Bardh
further Application in Mirash possible fixed Reha
planned Reha Coal Sibovc
planned Reha
1st Line Sibovc 3rd Line Mirash (Replacement P3M)
3rd Line
planned Reha planned Reha
2nd Line Sibovc 3rd Line Sibovc
3rd Line Bardh fixed Reha
2nd Line Sibovc
1st Line Sibovc
Application in existing mines (has to be revised with actualisation of Mid Term Plan)
Decommissioning
fixed Rehabilitation
Application in SibovcSW mine
planned Rehabilitation
Release Time for Main Mine Equipment in Mid Term Period
Page 117 of 171
Coal
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
mobile Fleet
Preparation of ToR Tendering Phase and Contract Preparation of Operation Operation
1st OB System
Preparation of Start Position Transport, Installation Commissioning, Operation Relocation to highest Level
2nd OB System
Relocation of Conveyor System Transport, Installation Commissioning, Operation Relocation of Conveyor System
3rd OB System
Preparation of Start Position Transport, Installation Commissioning, Operation Commissioning Cut 3a Relocation to Inside Dump Preparation of Start Position
Coal Systems
Transport, Installation Head Systems Transport, Installation Bench Systems st
Operation 1 System Operation 2nd System Operation 3rd System Operation System 3a Installation Quality Management
Fig.: 4.9-1
Main Mining Activities
Page 118 of 171
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
4.9.2 Main Mining Activities
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.10 Consequences for Development in Existing Mines Some adaptations of the mid term development in the existing mine have to be done with regard to an optimization of the mining development in the Sibovc SW mine. These adaptations are necessary for a smoothly opening-up of the new mine. In this context the Mid Term Plan for the existing mines has to be revised. Another reason for the necessity of reworking of the Mid Term Plan is, that the planned mine position for 2005 could not be reached. This applies predominantly to the flattening works of the border slope systems. Among others the following main measures have to be considered: -
The head belt conveyors of the coal system in the mine Sibovc SW should be installed on a level of +560 mMSL up to the long run belt conveyors to the TPPâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s to avoid unnecessary power due to grade. Therefore a general corridor is necessary on this level along the existing northern slope system. This fact has to be considered during the further planning works for flattening of this slope system.
-
In addition to this, a water channel (2b) has to be installed along the existing northern slope system, starting on a level of +595 mMSL (western site) up to the existing channel on the Mirash site +581 mMSL (description please see next main chapter). The necessary levelling has to be considered and to be done during the widening of the northern slope system.
-
Regarding the minimisation of transport distances and the creation of more spacious dump volumes during the opening-up phase, the dumping development in the western part of existing mine has to be adapted. a. The Mid Term Plan describes for the Overburden system III (P3B) from 2007 dumping along the western rim slope system in deep- and high dumping. This high dumping affects the placing of the opening up masses of the Sibovc SW mine. It is suggested to spread the masses of this overburden system only in deep dumping operation. So it will be possible to use the free dumping space for the opening masses from Sibovc SW. b. To provide additional dumping space in the area of the Bardh mine it is suggested to convert dumping of the masses of excavators E8B and E6B to Mirash from the beginning of mid 2007. Parallel to this the transport distance for this cut is shortened contrary to the Mid Term Plan.
-
The securing of coal production from the Sibovc SW field requires a timely shifting of the selected main equipment from the existing opencast mines. In contrast to the Mid Term Plan there are time changes for single equipment. They originate from the general choice of equipment and the scheduled necessary rehabilitation measures. This mainly concerns the E10B and the spreader P3B which goes out of operation mid of 2007 for a complex refurbishment. According to the Mid Term Plan an application of both facilities up to the end of 2008 was envisaged. The equipment use shall be adjusted with regard to this.
Page 119 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5 Mine Dewatering 5.1 Hydrological Conditions The Kosova Basin forms a smoothly shaped plain that is bordered by hills and mountains. This basin includes a developed hydrological network with the main collector given by the river Sitnica. This river crosses the basin from south to north and drains off 80 % of the accumulating surface water northward. Major tributary rivers in the vicinity of the site are Drenica River in the west and Lab River in the east. The Sitnica run-off of water varies between a minimum of 0.5 – 1.5 m³/sec and a maximum of 50 – 120 m³/sec with an average of 5 – 10 m³/sec. In flooding periods, the course of the river reaches a width of up to 1,000 m in the flooding areas. On 3 May 1958 a maximum run-off for river Sitnica near to the mines was measured with 90.3 m³/sec.
Fig.: 5.1-1
Catchment Areas of the Sibovc SW Mine
Page 120 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Because not being available the usual basis to assess the quantities of water discharged by tributary rivers and creeks was prepared as catchment area map shown in the figure above. A subdivision into different drainage areas is shown in different colours when the mine Sibovc SW develops towards the north. The mining field Sibovc SW will be largely influenced by the catchment area A (360 ha). The surface water coming from this area will flow directly to the mine. The catchment areas B (north-western part) and C (northern part) will have only a minor importance, since it discharges the water into the neighbouring valleys.
5.2 Drainage Areas These areas shall be included in the dewatering planning because the opening-up of the Sibovc SW mine follows the existing mine and the residual area of this existing mine can be used for inside dumping. The following drainage areas result from this: Mirash East The drainage area Mirash East is east of the dump pillar in the Mirash mine and comprises both the inside dumping areas and the reserved areas for ash dumping and sanitary landfill. The drainage of this area lies not in the responsibility of the Sibovc SW mine. After completion of the dumping of the disposal sites and the residual corridors a ditch system shall be installed draining into the direction of the Sitnica. Mirash West These areas border the dump pillar in the east and the present mining face in the west. Drainage is ensured by the active opencast mine operation upon complete depletion of the existing mine. Afterwards drainage shall be continued by the Sibovc SW mine. Bardh The drainage area Bardh follows the Mirash west area in the west and extends to the western rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. This area has to be drained as well upon complete depletion under the chief responsibility of the active opencast mine. Part of the drainage services have to be rendered by the Sibovc SW mine since there are also dumped overburden masses from the Sibovc mine in parallel with the active opencast mine operation. The depletion of the existing mine results in merging of the drainage areas of Mirash West and Bardh into a one single area. The dewatering shall then be completely carried out by the Sibovc SW mine. Upon completion of dumping in this area it has to be ensured that the surface waters will naturally run-off into the East (Sitnica) and the West (Drenica), respectively. Sibovc SW This drainage area covers the southern area of the u Sibovc SW mine and is separated by a coal pillar from the Bardh drainage area. Due to the valley location most of the surface water (catchment area A) flows directly into the direction of the opencast mine. This water shall be collected by ditch systems before reaching the opencast mine and drained into the direction of the Drenica. Only in the north (C) and northwest (B) of the mining field a part of the surface water flows into north-eastern direction towards the Sitnica and in western direction towards the Drenica, respectively.
Page 121 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The quantity of water to be pumped directly from the Sibovc SW mine will continuously increase with progressing opencast mine development. Using an average yearly rainfall of 600 mm and a run-off coefficient of 0.45 the rain water volumes to be drained yearly can be calculated. Pumping rates of the last years allow a first calculation of expected drainage volumes. Annual Drainage
[ ha ]
[ `000 mÂł/a ]
Mirash East
340
918
Mirash West
345
931
Bardh
365
985
Sibovc SW
460
1,240
Increasing of annual drainage with progressive mine development
Surface Drainage Sibovc SW
368
1.000
Reduction of annual drainage with progressive mine development
In-pit dewatering
Surface Area
Tab.: 5.2-1
Catchment Area A
Remarks
Reduction of annual drainage with further completion of final dump areas
Maximum Drainage Areas
5.3 Dewatering Measures 5.3.1 Surface Dewatering 5.3.1.1 Drainage Area Bardh / Mirash West Simultaneous with the depletion of existing mine the new mine Sibovc SW is responsible for the dewatering in this area. The surface dewatering around this area has to be continued, the existing dewatering facilities have to be maintained. New dewatering elements are not necessary. The stepwise continuation of final dump areas requires installation of ditches on the dumped surface to drain off the surface water. Therefore the dumping surface is to be shaped with a gradient between 1 : 150 to 1 : 200. The watershed should pass along the former ridge in the south of the village of Hade. From there the ditches should run in eastern direction to the river Sitnica and in western direction to the river Drenica, respectively. The ditches shall be integrated in the future landscape. A lining of the ditches (e.g. with concrete) is not foreseen.
5.3.1.2 Sibovc SW Mining Area (Illustration in mine position maps) The Sibovc SW mine is opened-up from the existing opencast mine and developed into northern direction. In the centre of the mining field there is a wide valley bordered by a mountain range at both rim slope systems and in mining direction. North of the mountain range the terrain dips into mining direction. The gradient of the terrain partly reaches 7° (1 : 8).
Page 122 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Due to the surface profile and the size of the catchment area (A) the Sibovc SW mine will be influenced by inflowing surface water during a long operating period. This especially refers to heavy rainfalls since the mining area is not covered by forests and the water quantities are drained for a great part at the surface. The size of the catchment area and the inflow reduce with progressing mine development. At the beginning of the opening-up the catchment area has a size of 360 ha. In case of heavy rainfalls of 64 mm/d and a surface runoff coefficient of 70%, the water quantity to be drained amounts to maximum 160,000 m続/day (= 2 m続/sec). The water quantity reduces with progressing mine development. The first surface dewatering measure in the field Sibovc SW must be the drainage of the water ponds in the opening-up area. These water ponds result from former slope movements. Since a hydraulic connection with existing fissure systems cannot be excluded these water collections incur an increased soil-mechanical risk. The drainage of the ponds should therefore start immediately, beginning from summer 2006. The following working steps are proposed: -
Pumping of water by means of waste water pumps and discharge via existing concrete channel
-
Installation of ditches for preventing further water collection on these basins (the road and/or dump bench belt conveyor GD3 shall be equipped with culverts)
Depending on the mine advance a system of channels and drains has to be installed at the surface. The drainage of the surface water in this area is complicated, because of the closed ridge around the mining boundary. Therefore the following facts must be considered for calculation of channel system: -
The surface water should be drained off under use of natural gradient. The minimum gradient should be 1 : 200 to allow a sufficient velocity of flow.
-
A lifting of surface water by pumps is not envisaged because of the flooding danger in case of power cuts.
-
Complete water drainage via the northern slope system of the existing mines is not advisable, because of the ongoing operation up to 2012 and the latent danger, caused by slope movements.
-
The main channels should be developed with concrete to increase the lifetime and to reduce maintenance expenditure
In a first step a possibility for water drainage has been chosen, considering the surface structure and the before mentioned principles. The best way for draining the surface water is the anticline in the ridge at the northern boundary of the Sibovc SW mining field. The anticlines at the eastern and western boundaries are blocked by the village Hade and/or outside dump masses (shooting range). The level of the anticline in the north is +640 mMSL. We recommend the following: The anticline is to deepen orthogonally by digging a box cut on a level of +625 mMSL. In this opening cut a covered concrete channel (1) has to be installed, before re-closing the cut. This channel connects the catchment area A and the valley north of the planned mining field. The culvert is the core component of the surface dewatering and must be finished at the end of 2007 (please see the following figure). In 2008 the channels to be connected shall be completed. On the one hand this refers to the channel for draining the surface water (1a) north of the box culverts and on the other hand the channels (1b und 1c) within the catchment area A. The latter lead into south-eastern and/or
Page 123 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
south-western direction starting form a height level of + 625 mMSL, with rising gradient (1 : 200). This ditch system collects the surface water of a catchment area of 92 ha and discharges it to the North via the box culvert into the natural drain in the direction of the Sitnica River. The advantage of this system is that the surface water is directly drained to the north and can therefore be kept away from the mine operation. The system will be in operation beyond the year 2020 whereby the charging channels have to be shortened according to the mine advance. Additionally another channel (2a) is planned along the eastern rim slope system. It runs from north (+605 mMSL) to south (+595 mMSL) and will include a working level of the northern rim slope system south of Hade. On this working level the water is charged via channel (2a) to the existing ditch system of the Mirash opencast mine (feeding point +585 mMSL). The preconditions for a continuous gradient along the northern rim slope system corresponding planning targets in the annual technologies. This channel which has to be produced in 2008 as well will collect and drain the surface water from a 45 ha catchment area. From the remaining valley the surface water cannot be drained via a natural gradient. Drainage of surface water via the active bench of the Sibovc SW mine shall be excluded except residual rainwater quantities. It is suggested to install a dewatering in the valley from which the collected surface water is pumped into the higher located channel 1c by means of sewage pumps. Additionally a 600 m long unfixed channel (3a) shall be connected to the dewatering in south-western direction. According to the opencast mine advance the dewatering shall be shifted several times to the North. Further channels shall be installed according to demand.
Page 124 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.3-1
Catchment Areas and Surface Dewatering Channels
The fixed ditches shall be dimensioned as follows: -
Bottom width
1.0 m
-
Depth
0.8 m
-
Slope inclination
45°
-
Profile
1.44 m²
-
Wall thickness of lining
0.15 m
Page 125 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Name
Indic.
Length
Development
Box Culvert
1
440 m
Cross section: 2m * 1m Gradient: 1 : 100 Development with concrete
2007
Channel
1a
320 m
Open concrete channel with settling basin
2008
Channel
1b
1,350 m
Open concrete channel
2008
Channel
1c
1,300 m
Open concrete channel
2008
Channel
2a
1,430 m
Open concrete channel
2008
Channel
2b
1,500 m
Open concrete channel
2008
Size 40m * 40m Depth 2m Development with concrete or foil equipped with 4 waste water pumps plus 2 in reserve and 4 pipes with a length of 700 m each
2009
Open channel without any development
2009
Storage Basin
3
-
Channel
3a
620 m
Tab.: 5.3-1
Comm.
Elements of Surface Dewatering
5.3.2 In-Pit Dewatering (Illustration in mine position maps) 5.3.2.1 Drainage Area Bardh / Mirash West After depletion of the existing mines the remaining hole will be further used as dumping area of the new Sibovc SW mine. Thatâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s why it will be necessary to continue the drainage works. Therefore the existing dewatering facilities can be further used. Simultaneous with finishing the coal extraction works in the existing mines the overburden dumping of the Sibovc SW mine will start in the deepest part of the residual hole, south of the village Hade. According to the advance of the dump the main dewatering basins (Mirash and Bardh site) must be relocated. After closing the first dumping slice, a new main dewatering basin has to be installed and connected with the pipe system. This procedure must be repeated up to finishing the final dumping slice. Beginning from this time, a ditch system for a natural surface dewatering shall be installed on the surface. The drainage facilities can be dismantled, if no further use is intended.
Page 126 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5.3.2.2 Sibovc SW Mining Area Basically, groundwater pumpage by means of filter wells or a groundwater blocking by means of sealing wall can be excluded. Therefore, the planning of the in-pit dewatering is restricted to the collection and drainage of the pit water. The following works shall be realised for a sufficient in-pit dewatering: -
Planned installation of main collecting ditches from the working levels and dump surfaces to the main dewatering with continuous adjustment to the mining position
-
Establishment of the drainage of rainwater on all working levels
-
Discharging of permanent water accumulations on the dumps
-
Drainage of dammed up water at the slope foot of the inside dumps
-
Maintenance of all ditch systems
-
Use of the collected water to reduce dust formation /dust control
Ditch System Drainage ditches shall be installed on all working levels. An appropriate downward gradient is to be considered towards the bench ends. The water shall be connected in equalizing basins at the bench ends and supplied alternatively by way of pipelines or open collecting ditches of the main dewatering. These ditches along the working levels must be renewed regularly according to the opencast mines advance. The ditches shall be produced by means of the available auxiliary equipment, like universal excavators, dozers and wheel loaders. A massive development of the ditches and equalizing basins is not envisaged. The following regular ditch profile is proposed regardless of the size of the catchment area: -
Bed width
â&#x2030;Ľ 0.5 m (effective)
-
Ditch depth
0.5 - 1.0 m (effective)
-
Gradient
min. 1 : 200
-
Inclination of the ditch slope
ca. 45° (in cohesive material)
Another important point is the production of ditches along the access roads into the opencast mine. Hereby, the removal of the backwater is of special importance to increase the lifetime and improve the conditions of the accesses. Along ramps with a larger downward gradient, wooden weirs shall be inserted in the road ditches to reduce the flow velocity of the water and therefore the mass discharge from the road subsoil. Apart from the production of the ditches special importance shall be also attached to the clearing of working levels and the maintenance of the ditch systems. Flat and slightly grading working levels simplify the water supply to the installed ditches. Parallel to this the ditch systems shall be maintained permanently. It is suggested to establish a mobile group for these works, so that damages at the ditches can be recognized and repaired. Central Main Dewatering / Pump Sumps
Page 127 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The in-pit dewatering by ditches accumulates the rainwater from excavation and dumping site in the main dewatering and pump it out in case of excess of the storage capacity. The storage capacity of the main dewatering has to be dimensioned to accumulate a maximum of the rainfalls of one day. Parallel to the progressive mine development the active mining area will expand. The storage volume of the main dewatering has to be enlarged the same way. The pumps have to be designed in that way that they are able to handle a maximum of twoday rainfalls considering the accumulation capacity of the pump sumps. One additional pump per pump sump should be reserved among the number of pumps which are required for the pumpage of the in-pit water. The pumps lift the pit water by means of pipelines via the eastern rim slope system and the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine into the existing installed ditch systems. With progressing dumping of the residual pit south of Hade and the improving stabilisation of the northern rim slope system the pipeline system can be replaces by an open ditch. The time for conversion shall be defined at a later date. The main dewatering basin should be arranged in the deepest part of the mine and has to be relocated according to the mine advance. The basins shall be produced in deep cut excavation with the help of main equipment. From 2018 the surface water from the working levels of the mobile equipment operation and the first regular overburden system can be discharged into the existing concrete channel 2a. Therefore the drainage into the main dewatering and following lifting by means of pumps is inapplicable. Pumps The main dewatering of the mine shall be equipped with 5 powerful high-pressure pumps, 2 pumps for normal operation, 2 pumps as support in case of heavy rainfall and 1 pump as reserve. The change-over to high-pressure pumps is due to the increasing lifting height (up to 130m). There are recommended pumps each with a capacity of 180 mÂł/h (90 kW). In order to specify the pumps it is necessary to know the quality of the water to be pumped. Additionally, waste water pumps (for lifting height up to 25m) are required. In total 15 waste water pumps should be procured, for application on the working benches at the excavation site and on the dumping site as well as on the stockpile. Mine Water Purification The water pumped from the main dewatering plants in the existing mine, shows increased contents of chloride and sulphate as well as clear contents of suspended matter, consisting of dust or organic matter. The same water quality is to be expected in the new Sibovc SW mine. When discharging the water, special attention shall be drawn to separate the suspended materials. Thatâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s why it will be necessary to install additional sedimentation basins on the surface level before feeding the water into the rivers. These basins are made in form of ground basins that are integrated in the course of the ditches. At a length of at least 100 m, the bed of such a basin shall be flat on a width of at least 50 m, in order to achieve a clear reduction of the flow velocities. When entering a basin, the water stream shall be distributed as wide as possible to achieve a good sedimentation result. The discharge of a basin has the form of an earth dam, which is
Page 128 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
fixed by a possibly wide overflow. The installations shall be controlled quarterly. The settled particles shall be removed regularly once a year in autumn before the beginning of the rainy period. The removed material shall be examined by sampling in particular for contents of heavy metals and hydrocarbon connections. If there are not any distinctive features, the material can be built into the dump bodies. If contaminants are determined for example in cases of damages or accidents during the operation, the material shall be disposed separately. Recommendations for Mining Development The shape of the working levels is of great importance when draining the rainwater and avoiding collection of water. In order to minimise the earthworks for drainage ditches the working levels in the mines shall have a continuous gradient into the direction of the bench ends. Preferably, a â&#x20AC;&#x153;roof constructionâ&#x20AC;? shall be produced with a gradient starting at the mid of the bench into the direction of the two bench ends or a gradient from one bench end to the other one.
5.3.3 Time Scheduling for Dewatering Measures 2006 I
II
2007 III
IV
I
II
2008 III
IV
I
II
2009 III
IV
I
II
III
IV
Drainage of Water Ponds Box Culvert (1) Channel 1a with Settling Basin Channel 1b Channel 1c Channel 2a Channel 2b Storage Basin (3) Channel 3a Specification
Fig.: 5.3-2
Tendering Process
Construction
Commissionning
Time Schedule for Dewatering Measures
5.4 Investment and Cost Calculation for Dewatering Only the planned concrete channels including settling and sedimentation basins were considered in the investments for the drainage. Except the Storage Basins (3) these plants have to be erected only once. The Storage Basin has to be relocated several times according to the mine advance. These performances shall not be carried out by KEK and have to be tendered. All other channels to be installed operatively shall be built by KEK itself. The costs are acquired in the position personnel. The same applies to the maintenance of the channels. The necessary investments for mobile equipment as well as pumps and pipelines shall be considered with the auxiliary equipment. As basic prices has been considered:
Page 129 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Box culvert
120 EURO/m
-
Earth moving for box culvert
4 EURO/bcm
-
Concrete channel
70 EURO/m
-
Settling basin
0.030 MEURO
-
Storage basin
0.050 MEURO
The following table compiles the required investments for the pre-mining area dewatering of the opencast mine. The storage basin (3) shall be installed new every 3 years. Due to the continuously reducing catchment area necessary investments are also declining. From 2020 storage basin looses its importance; therefore further use is not envisaged. Year Investments
‘07 0.97
‘08 0.45
‘09 0.10
‘10
‘11
‘12 0.05
‘13
‘14
‘15 0.04
Year Investments
‘16
‘17
‘18 0.02
‘19
‘20
‘21
‘22
‘23
‘23
Tab.: 5.4-1
Investments for Dewatering Measures
Page 130 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6 Mine Closure and Recultivation Planning 6.1 Principles The dumping of the overburden masses of the Sibovc SW mine will be continued on the inside dump of the existing opencast mine. This means that the area of responsibility of the Sibovc SW mine extends also to the existing mine. This mainly refers to the area between dam crest of the dump pillar in Mirash and the western rim slope of the Bardh mine. The areas east of the crest of the dump pillar refer to the area of responsibility of the existing opencast mine. The same applies to the existing outside dump areas. The proposed main principles are: -
The areas occupied by mining shall be recovered in such a way that the later use will be rather better than the original one. This efforts aim at enhancing the value of the areas compared with the actual state â&#x20AC;&#x201C; at least however a similar scenery.
-
Areas which are no longer needed for mining activities shall be recultivated as soon as possible. If a final renaturing will not be possible, suitable temporary measures shall be taken like for example an interim greening.
-
Financial means will be reserved already during the active mining operations to ensure the proper closure of the mining field. This money will also be available in case of in-solvency for revitalisation.
-
Authorities and the concerned people (later users) are integrated in the process of planning and detailed shaping of the post-mining areas. This process shall start before dumping because it already defines the shape of the surface.
6.2 Area Balance To meet the demand for run-of-mine coal from the mine Sibovc SW at an amount of 123.4 mt, the area claimed for mining will come to 5 km² within the period until 2024. The following area balance is resulting for the mine Sibovc SW. The land claim is divided in areas for digging and other areas (f. e. canals, surface facilities). The land acquisition has to be carried out before to the actual land claim in order to prepare the areas for mining activities. This comprises such measures as clearing the surface by removing buildings, installing embankments and building mine roads and installing dewatering systems. Depending on the size and location of the lots of land and the required preparatory works, the land should be acquired one to two years before the actual land claim.
Page 131 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Land Claim for Sibovc SW Total
Creation of Final Dump Areas
179
50
4
39
141
133
16
149
16
2018 - 2022
102
14
116
142
2023 - 2024
14
4
18
34
Total
412
74
501
383
Digging
Safety Zone
Channels
2006 - 2010
128
36
15
2011-2012
35
2013 - 2017
Tab.: 6.2-1
InfraStructure
15
Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW [ha]
The above table contains the necessary land claim for the Sibovc SW mine. The total area to be claimed is 501 ha, whereby 412 ha of it are pure land to be excavated. The other 89 ha refer to the safety zone (a ca. 100 wide stripe along the mining edge) and other areas. Dumping of overburden from Sibovc SW mine in the residual pit of the Bardh / Mirash mine offers the possibility to produce the final dump surfaces very early. Via the lifetime of the Sibovc SW mine totally 383 ha final dump areas can be shaped. These areas lie completely in the area of the Bardh/Mirash mine; in Sibovc SW it will not be possible to produce final dump areas. The shaped final dump areas distribute as follows: -
100 ha east of the dump pillar in the area of the former Mirash-east mine (2009 – 2012)
-
52 ha high dump area at the western field margin of the Bardh mine (2011 – 2012)
-
231 ha final (2011 – 2024)
dump
area
in
the
Bardh
/
Mirash
opencast
mine
This balance does not include the former outside dumps of the Bardh and Mirash mines. According to the Mid Term Plan these areas shall be prepared for a future use and sale by the existing opencast mines. This balance does also not include the reserved area for ash dumping in the Mirash East area and the reserved area for sanitary landfill in the Mirash Brand area including their slope systems. Therefore the mine Sibovc SW produces less final dump areas than occupied by the mining operations. This negative area balance is mainly caused due to the large share of slope systems along the reserved areas for ash and sanitary landfill sites. Another reason is the remaining pit (205 ha) south of the community of Hade which cannot be closed until 2024. The required land purchase is different from the land demand because parts of the mining field are already property of KEK. This especially refers to the area north of the rim slope system of t he Bardh mine and the outside dump on the mining field of Sibovc SW (shooting range). For the operating period until 2024 a total sum of 325 ha land have to be purchased. Moreover, drainage ditches have to be installed in the entire mining field already with the start of the opening up activities. It is suggested to conclude user’s contracts with the owners of the
Page 132 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
plots for those areas. Nevertheless a large part of the mining fields should already be purchased at the beginning of the opening up. The areas to be purchased in periods are illustrated in the following table. The sale of final dump areas (please see table above) will be possible after a 2-years lay time. The below table also contains the share of areas to be sold. Up to 2024 about 349 ha of the produced final dump areas from total 383 ha can be sold. The difference of 34 ha comes to a safety zone along the mentioned remaining pit. If one only considers the share of areas still to be purchased the area balance is positive. In case of a sale of totally 349 ha a surplus of about 20 ha of areas can be sold compared with the area to be purchased within the operating period. As already mentioned the existing outside dump areas (selling in Mid Term Period of Bardh / Mirash Mine) and the areas reserved for disposal sites (out of responsibility of Complementary Mine Plan) were not taken into account.
Land Purchase
Usufructuary Right
Land for Sale
Balance acc.
2006 - 2010
74
7
0
-74
2011 - 2012
22
50
-46
2013 - 2017
94
141
+1
2018 - 2022
122
81
-40
2023 - 2024
17
77
+20
Total
329
349
Tab.: 6.2-2
Area Balance [ha]
6.3 Mine Closure Plan Recultivation of the Sibovc field is closely connected with the existing mine. After depletion of the existing mine, large residual pits remain. The establishment of larger final areas within the operating period of the opencast mines will not be possible. This is due to the low overburden: coal ratio as well as in the material properties of the overburden. The following residual pits will remain in the area of the opencast mines: -
A wide and deep residual pit in the western area of the existing mining field (mining area of the Bardh opencast mine and the western part of the Mirash opencast mine)
-
A landfill site in the former Mirash-Brand mining field in the responsibility of the KTA
-
The ash dump in the former Mirash-East mining field in the responsibility of KEK
-
An almost closed dump area in the eastern parts of the Mirash opencast mine, which borders the landfill site. In the areas directly contacting the landfill site there are installed large corridors due to the flat slope angle.
Page 133 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
It is envisaged that coal mining will be continued in the follow-up field of Sibovc after depletion of the existing opencast mine. This opencast mine will be developed from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mines. It is planned to use this overburden masses to fill the depleted area of the existing mines. This offers optimal opportunities for shaping the final areas. Moreover, outside dumps can be avoided. As it is mentioned in the Mid Term Plan the existing mine is responsible to shape the residual pit safely until the residual area is closed finally by the follow-up mine. The following measures will be taken: -
The natural overburden slopes along the southern rim slope system shall be shaped safely.
-
The coal slopes along the southern rim slope system shall be flattened and covered by overburden material. This measure serves the extinguishing of existing and/or the prevention of new coal fires. A corresponding dumping technology of the overburden masses of Sibovc helps to reducing the expense for those measures considerably.
-
The seam floor shall be continuously covered by cohesive overburden material. This measure also serves the prevention / extension of further coal fires and can be further optimized by a selective dumping of the overburden material from Sibovc.
-
The drainage of the residual area shall be continued. This refers to the main drainage system on the lowest floor level and the drainage from the southern rim slope system by means of suitable drainage ditches. Those ditches shall be installed on all berms of the southern rim slope system. Extension of the ditches will not be required. A collection basin shall be installed at the deepest point of each of the berms from which the water is fed by pipelines and/or collection ditches to the main drainage system. After dumping of the main drainage system by masses from the Sibovc mine, a new drainage system shall be installed and operated.
After closure of the residual area by spreading the overburden material from the Sibovc mine, the areas shall be intended for agricultural use to provide substitute areas for claimed ones. Connection of the dump area at the same surface level is recommended for the large residual pit in the west of the mining field, without re-shaping the former hillside near Hade. The final dump surface should be slightly inclined to enable good access conditions for agricultural machines as well as a natural drainage into the direction of the Sitnica and Drenica-Rivers. The final shaping of the eastern dump side is only possible after decommissioning of the storage sites. Both storage sites are planned with an operating period of at least 15 years. Only afterwards, a complete closure of the marginal corridors will be possible. This can be accomplished both with the overburden from Sibovc and the recovery of the ash dump of TPP A. The preferred alternative is the recovery of the ash dump of TPP A on the mining field D for refilling the marginal corridors. The basic sealing for the masses to be installed is provided by the inside dump masses. The masses lying below the ash on the outside dump can be used as final cover layer and/or as recultivation layer. Due to the long period until a final shaping of this area, an interim solution is recommended comprising to partly fill the corridors depending on the set-up of the ash dump.
Page 134 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The Sibovc SW mine is responsible for refilling the area western of the dumping pillar only. The final shaping of the eastern area with the sanitary landfill area and the ash dump is not part of the Complementary Mine Plan.
6.4 Concept of Post-Mining Utilization 6.4.1 Principles and Preconditions for Reclamation Planning The concept for the post-mining landscape contains the following aspects: -
Demand for uses (agriculture, forestry, building site …)
-
Area use is dependent on the available soils (quality)
-
Possibilities for shaping by means of the used equipment
-
Cost/benefit
Main aim for shaping the post-mining field is to provide a high share of areas which allow for an agricultural use. In general, the dump area shall represent a high-value landscape element in which agricultural use and habitat for local fauna and flora will exist in parallel. Bases for achieving these goals: -
Ensuring a maximum possible inclination of 1 : 20 (3°), maximum 1 : 12.5 (4.5°), which allow for a cultivation with agricultural machines
-
Ensuring discharge of excess surface water by a minimum surface inclination of 1 : 200
-
Collection and discharge of surface water by installation of ditches and storage basins and their connection to the existing rivers
-
Installation of windbreak belts as a natural boundary for reducing wind erosion
-
Plantation of trees and shrubs for shaping a varied landscape
-
Conservation of parts of the outside dump in the present form as refuge area for the presently existing and adjusted flora and fauna.
-
Installation of roads and accesses
To ensure minimum inclinations of 1 : 200 even after completion of settlements in the field, an inclination of 1 : 150 will be planned. Considering this inclination the terrain rises from the future residual pit in the north into southern direction and from the river connection at Bardh in the south-west into northern direction. Therefore the terrain lies below the original surface especially in the area of the hill nearby Hade. The connection to the natural terrain is ensured. Lateral slopes have a general inclination of 10° according to the mine planning. The single slopes shall be flattened to an inclination of 1 : 7 (8°) and planted with trees and shrubs. All areas with coal shall be covered by a sufficient amount of overburden. Due to the large quantity of minable coal, it will not be possible to fill up the entire opencast mine. There are basically two opportunities for the further use of the residual pit. The first alternative is the flooding of the residual area after completion of the mining activities in the Sibovc SW mine. This alternative can only be implemented of the mining in Page 135 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
the Sibovc field will not be continued after 2025. This refers both to KEK and a possible independent investor. This alternative can be excluded with a high probability because the remaining Sibovc field will contain huge coal reserves with favourable deposit conditions. Therefore this alternative will not be further followed up. The second and most probable alternative bases on the continuation of extraction in the Sibovc field. The residual pit of Sibovc SW will then be used as dumping space. It is thereby not relevant if the Sibovc SW mine is further developed or if a new mine will be opened. In this case, the residual pit shall be proceeded analogue to Midterm Plan. The coal slopes shall be flattened and covered by overburden in order to prevent coal fires in the long run. The seam floor shall be continuously covered by cohesive overburden material too. Moreover, all overburden slopes which are not directly developed by the follow-up mine shall be flattened to 1 : 6. The detailed measures shall be determined when the future development in the mining region is known.
6.4.2 Soil Improvement Measures The areas are flattened after dumping to be prepared for recultivation. The final shape of the surface should consider both a smoothly wavy structure and the free discharge of the water. After the levelling works have been finished, deep ploughing shall be carried out with a penetration depth of 0.5 m. That applies in particular to surfaces which were finished during rainy seasons. In principle, soil-improving measures are necessary only in to limited degree for the agriculturally used surfaces because the available overburden material is rather fertile. To raise the yield it is possible to apply fertilising measures like manure, slurry or mineral fertilizer.
6.4.3 Interim Greening and Erosion Protection Measures For the later management it is assumed that the plots will have an average size of approximately 5 - 10 hectares. Provided that there is a rectangular sketch this corresponds to a dimension of 500 * 150 m. A windbreak belt shall be installed between the individual plots with a width of approx. 5m. Its function comprises both erosion protection and a natural boundary between the plots. A multi-line arrangement of different wood is recommended, as it is represented in the following illustration. This system can also be realised along the farm roads.
Page 136 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Trees (1st size) nd Trees (2 size) Shrubs
3.50 m Fig.: 6.4-1
Plant Scheme for Wind Erosion Protection
Fast-growing tree species are especially suitable as windbreak belts, like for example poplars or robinias (Robinia Rectissima) and bushes. An integration of fruit trees is possible as well. It is suggested to install stone fruit meadows and/or carry out afforestation for steeper areas, where farming by means of machines will not be possible.
6.4.4 Irrigation and Dewatering Measures Along the windbreak belts, paths and roads, ditches shall be installed for surface drainage. The size of the ditches shall be chosen according to the respective catchment area. The following standard values shall be considered: -
Bed width
0.5 m â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1.0 m, effective
-
Ditch depth
ca. 1 m
-
Gradient
min. 1 : 200
-
Inclination of the ditch slope
ca. 45°
In suitable distances these ditches shall be widened to storage basins in order to be able to store the water for a limited period of time in case of heavy rainfalls. The single ditches shall be finally connected to collecting ditches discharging the yielded rainwater. These ditches shall be installed in a solid construction. The flow velocity of the water shall be reduced by means of check dams and stilling basins, if necessary.
Page 137 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7 Resettlement and Relocation 7.1 General Remarks 7.1.1 Situation The opencast lignite mine of Sibovc SW north-west of the capital Pristina will occupy about 328.9 ha of land during its active phase with a North-South extension of 3 km and East-West extension of 1.7 to 2.7 km. The following resettlement and relocation measures shall be prepared and executed for the claim of land: -
Land purchase
-
Resettlement of properties of the settlement with scattered buildings of Sibovc (Hade West, Hade North (extension), Mirene, ShipitullaEast and Konxhul)
-
Compensation of property
-
New construction of a by-pass from Hade to Sibovc
-
New construction of a by-pass from Sibovc to Grabovc
The safety zone of the community of Hade south of the village road passing the mosque is already cleared from estates. Since May 2005 new residential building have already been built along the village road from Hade to Bardh which lie in the slope area of the new Sibovc SW opencast mine.
7.1.2 General Conditions Mainly large families with own agricultural enterprises are living in the concerned area of Sibovc, whose main incomes are secured by the production and sales of agricultural products. The social conditions of the population in this area are complicated and can be compared with the average living conditions in the Kosovo. The average net wages are about 150-200 â&#x201A;Ź/ month. According to LSMS (Living Standard Measurement Survey 2000), 12 per cent of population in Kosovo is extremely poor and another almost 40 per cent is poor. The average net wages are higher for men than for women and higher in the private sector than in the public sector (LSMS 2000). The most important forms of land use are agriculture and forestry. However their importance is decreasing. Approximately 60 % of the population living in the region are farmers and have own land adjacent to their homes. Nevertheless, the development of the mining industry has a social effect, too. It provides jobs with higher and securer income than it is possible by the cultivation of own land. For some families, agriculture remains the most important income source now as before. But in the majority of households, one family member is employed with KEK.
Page 138 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The resettlement of the villages will change the rural structure with regard to the number and size of agricultural enterprises. Resettlers, whose income does not to 100% originate from agriculture, are more easily ready to move to a prepared resettlement site with infrastructure or to build a big house without farmlands at a decentral site. Some resettlers use the resettlement effect to separate from the large family (extended family). For example, two-room flats in the town are offered to adult family members using this occasion to set up a family. The presently frequent family size of 10-12 members will reduce to a family size of 5-7 members.
7.1.3 Legal Resettlement Regulations At present, the old resettlement law dating back to the Serbian era is still applicable. A new law is only available in a draft version. Therefore, all issues relevant to resettlement have to be decided by the Parliament, which can be a very lengthy process. To ensure the legal bases of lignite extraction and the required land purchase in the future Sibovc field it is necessary to declare this area as reserved mining area. This pre-requisite was established with the UN-Resolution dated 18.11.2004: The Special Representative of the UN-Secretary-General decided about the evacuation of the Hade village and related government decisions on a zone of special interest and property assessment criteria which are included in the „Executive decision No. 2004/28 from the 18th of Nov 2004”: (1) The villages of Hade/Ade, Sibovc/Sibovac, Leskovcic/Leskovcic and Cërkvena Vodic/Crkvena Vodica in the Obiliq/ć Municipality are recognized as constituting a zone of special interest for the economy of Kosovo. (2) Effective as of the date of signature of the present Executive Decision, no further construction activities shall be undertaken in the villages constituting the zone of special interest for the economy of Kosovo. (3) In the event that economic considerations warrant mining activities in the zone of special interest for the economy of Kosovo, natural and legal persons whose validly registered property rights may be affected by such mining activities shall be entitled to reasonable compensation based on the assessment criteria for property in the villages concerned as established by the Government of Kosovo. The decision to declare the concerned areas as zone of special national interest provides the legal basis for the claim of the areas in the Sibovc field for mining and for the resettlement of the mentioned villages.
7.1.4 Property Situation According to information of the ministry for spatial planning KEK already owns 500 ha of land. Parts of this area are located in the future mining field Sibovc SW. The opencast mine of Sibovc will claim the following areas:
Page 139 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Claim of Land for Sibovc Digging
Safety Zone
Total
Property of KEK
Land Acquisition
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
2006-2010
128
36
15
179
105
74
2011-2012
35
4
39
17
22
2013-2017
133
16
149
55
94
2018-2022
102
14
116
0
122
2023-2024
14
4
18
1
17
Total
412
74
501
172
329
Year
Tab.: 7.1-1
Channel Infras structure [ha]
15
Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW
From a map handed over by KEK it can be seen that the company intended to purchase 28 agricultural properties with a total area of 22.56 ha in 2005. These areas are in the direct neighbourhood of the slide area (Grabovci i ulĂŤt) north of the road Bardh-Hade. In addition, KEK shall conclude userâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s contracts for 7 ha reserved for drainage ditches and settling basins.
Page 140 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.1-1
Land Claim for the Mine Sibovc SW
Page 141 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.1-2
Land Acquisition for the Mine Sibovc SW
The land swaps affected by resettlement are mainly private property. Upon written application and several requests the Kosovo Cadastre office submitted only information about the number of built-up estates in the concerned villages in the mining field of Sibovc (as of February 2005). Because there is no land parcel map available for this list the properties cannot be assigned to the topographical map. It seems that the land parcel maps (including Serbian remarks) handed over by KEK are out of date because they do not correspond to the land parcel lists of the Cadastre office. It was also not possible to check whether there are Serbian properties in the mining field. The compensation of Serbian property located within the mining field (former Serbian settlement) has to be negotiated with the corresponding owner.
Page 142 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.1.5 Valuation of Compensation The compensation data (prepared for Hade) determined by the Government Working Group from the Ministry of environment and spatial planning (MESP) were used to calculate the costs for resettlement of each of the villages in the Sibovc SW field. In addition, practical experiences were used. The substituted expenses for available property and buildings and the replacement value (not the current value) of the available infrastructure were used to determine the resettlement costs. The valuation of the estates must be carried out by a Commission under the head of the Government. The inventory of the houses, gardens and agriculturally used areas has been taken by experts, among others by KEK experts. This interdisciplinary body consists of an architect, a civil engineer, two lawyers, three surveyors, two agricultural experts and three economists. The regulations developed for the compensation of the people concerned in Hade can be used to compensate the concerned inhabitant living in the area of the Sibovc SW field. The government shall extend the validity of these documents to the villages inside the Sibovc SWfield: (1)
A price of 350 EURO/m² for turn-key condition residential properties was established. In case of only partial construction this price will be multiplied with a factor reflecting the level of completion.
(2)
Criteria for evaluation of the construction land and agricultural land based on the following parameters: In analysis of above listed parameters a price of 23 EURO/m² for residential sites was established. Agricultural property was divided in 9 categories as listed below: Class I
5.00 EURO/m²
Class II
4.75 EURO/m²
Class III
4.50 EURO/m²
Class IV
4.25 EURO/m²
Class V
4.00 EURO/m²
Class VI
3.75 EURO/m²
Class VII
3.50 EURO/m²
Class VIII
3.25 EURO/m²
Infertile land
3.25 EURO/m²
The criteria for the differentiation between the construction and agricultural land are based on the Cadastre Law. Construction land is the area of the construction registered in cadastre documents + 500 m² construction land.
Page 143 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
To prepare the resettlement and/or compensation, the residents of the concerned communities shall be informed as soon as possible and questionnaires shall be offered regarding the desired kind of compensation. The following options shall be offered: -
Cash compensation for assets (replacement value) and land
-
Relocation to new individual housing within the municipality
-
Relocation to collective housing (apartment) in an urbanized part of the municipality
-
Private-property flat
-
Land for compensation within the municipality
-
Joint resettlement to a newly developed place
For the further resettlement of the village Sibovc, the compensation process for the affected people shall be arranged as follows: -
Evidence of property by the Cadastre office
-
Determination of the land price, house price, price of the garden and farmland by experts of the Governmental commission
-
Preparation of an offer for resettlement according to the evaluation of the questionnaire by the commission
-
When the offer is accepted, the compensation will be carried out as set out in the offer. If no agreement can be achieved, legal proceedings will be taken to clarify the amount of compensation
7.1.6 Resettlement Procedure Planning of the basic principles for the resettlement should be socially acceptable. To re-organise the process, 3 principles are recommended: -
The resettlement committee shall be transparent in all of its operations. All ideas, procedures, constraints and implications shall be discussed with all people concerned. The committee shall, for example, inform the people about the fact that the resettlement process may last for more than one year.
-
A non-official representative (normal citizen without a professional relationship to the municipality) of the village shall participate in the Assessment Commission. In addition, each committee which carries out assessments should include one resident member.
-
KEK shall be actively engaged in the resettlement process, as partner in an information sharing capacity. In coordination with the resettlement committee, KEK shall conduct an information campaign that informs residents of the village about the steps they have taken to protect the village and what next steps will be taken and when to expansion of the mining area will take place.
Page 144 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.2 Communities affected by Resettlement 7.2.1 Settlements in the Partial Field of Sibovc Due to the new opencast mine technology by-passing of the community of Hade is possible and only single groups of housing estates are within the mining boundary. Preliminary stocktaking was carried out based on the map handed over by KEK (M 1:10 000), by means of aerial photography and a visit. It can be assumed that the provided map with information about the estates (location and number) is obsolete due to destruction and reconstruction. Even according to the available aerial photographs of 2005 new building were constructed afterwards. . The settlement groups belong to the community of Obiliq. Settlement area
Year
Number of households
of the
Based on aerial view
resettlemen t
Structurally
Destroyed
2
1
12
8
17
new
Total
complete
Mirene
Dec 2015
7
2
Shipitulla East
Dec 2015
7
2
Hade Western Slope
Dec 2009
15
Hade North
Dec 2019
35
Konxhul
Dec 2023
1
Total
without roof
65
Tab.: 7.2-1
Communities Affected by Resettlement
Fig.: 7.2-1
Hade-North (View from Mirene)
20 2
6
2
35
4
41
3
4
16
20
109
Page 145 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-2
Hade-North (View from North)
The one and two-storey houses in Hade North which were for the most part destroyed have been reconstructed. On four properties the residential houses are still destroyed.
Fig.: 7.2-3
Mirene (in the Village)
Page 146 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-4
Mirene (View from South)
In the settlement of Mirene there are 7 residential houses. 2 houses have finished structural work, 1 house is still destroyed. West of the settlement there are 2 residential houses without roof.
Fig.: 7.2-5
Shipitulla East (View from South)
The settlement of Shipitulla-East has 7 residential houses. 2 residential houses have finished structural work, 8 houses are destroyed and abandoned.
Page 147 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-6
Hade West 1
Fig.: 7.2-7
Hade West 2
About 15 newly constructed houses are in the future slope area west of the community of Hade. For safety reasons about 20 houses into the direction of the community of Hade have to be taken down.
Page 148 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-8
Konxhul (View from Hade-North)
The most southern property of the settlement Konxhul lies within the mining area and has to be resettled. There are no public utilities in these settlements. The inhabitants use the facilities in the neighbouring communities (school and doctorâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s practice in Bregowinska, mosque in Megjuani or Hade). The departed family members were buried in the nearby communities of Hade, Shipitulla or Barbatoska.
7.2.2 Locations for Resettlements The options for providing properties for a joint and/of separate resettlement of the household shall be checked by KEK. According to information of the World Bank a study was ordered among other for the use of fallow land in the area of the community of Bardh. According to first knowledge there is a KEK-disposal site west of Bardh where property for residential houses can be developed to be applicable for construction. The filled overburden area behind the hills can serve as substitute for agriculturally used land. This area is sufficient in size but has to be still examined soil-mechanically owing to the bearing capacity (filled area). Assuming about 109 households to be resettled an area of ca. 27.25 ha will be required for the resettlement. For the calculation about 1,500 m² per property were considered plus 1,000 m² for public areas. The figure below is an abstract from the layout plan of KEK showing the own areas of KEK.
Page 149 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.2-9
Possible Site for Resettlements West of Bardh
If the inhabitants concerned wish a joint resettlement this has to be planned and supervised via a relatively long period if time (2009 to 2023). The below table contains the expenses necessary for the development of a settlement area of ca. 27.25 ha including the land purchase. For the place of Bardh West soil-improving measures are required for the sites of the houses according to the site examination report (ca. 1,600 EURO/ household).
Acquisition of Land Asphalt Access Road Bridge over Drenica Fresh Water Pipe Power supply Transformer Station Road System inside Village Electric Supply of Houses Fresh-Water Pipe inside Village Waste Water disposal Total
Tab.: 7.2-2
Units
Price per Unit
272.500 m² 19.200 m² 600 m² 3.100 m 3.100 m 1 9.700 m² 3.000 m 3.000 m 109
4 ,75 25 3.000 50 50 30.000 25 50 50 4.500
Investments [TEURO] 1.294 480 1.800 155 155 30 242 150 150 491 4.947
Cost Estimation for a new Settlement near Bardh
For properties to be resettled from Hade West the use of areas Skhabaj (nearby Obiliq) shall be checked since there were already considered areas for the resettlement of Hade here.
Page 150 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.2.3 Time Scheduling for Resettlement Measures A democratic socially acceptable resettlement procedure compliant to EU law would take at least 8 years. The resettlement of Hade West must be completed by the end of the year of 2009. This also includes the land purchase by the mining company. Therefore it is necessary to have a tight project organisation with responsibilities and freedom of action for the head of the project. Since all documents from the Cadastre office in Kosovo are not complete it is necessary to resurvey all estates. This Process shall be accelerated. Obviously, there exist estates of Serbians living outside the Kosovo. The Cadastre office was not able to give specifications with regard to procedure and compensation method. Among others it is very important that the government shall support the resettlement process by reducing bureaucratic constraints and granting resident an incentive bonus or trying to find an own solution in order to avoid problem cases.
Year
Measures
1 year
Detailed information of the inhabitants, distribution of questionnaires
4 to 5 years
Establishment of a local consulting office for the inhabitants (attend to the return of the questionnaires among others, determine demand for estates and flats/apartment buildings)
1 year
Stocktaking of estates by Cadastre office
1 year
Financial assessment of estates by a working team
1 year
Preparation of a socially acceptable offer for each household (assistance for looking for estates and/or flat.) Negotiations with the concerned people
8 years
Look for estates, planning and building of private houses/apartments
1 year
Resettlement of the inhabitants
3 months
Finishing of land purchase by mining company, Completion of deconstruction works incl. basements of buildings
Tab.: 7.2-3
Principle Timetable for Resettlement Procedure
Including all preparatory measures (principles and contracts) a period of 6 years is recommended to carry out a normal planned resettlement of locations. According to mining requirements this might also be implemented faster, if compromises are agreed in written form in a contract. For smaller settlements up to 30 houses the resettlement time can be assessed shorter. But in order to secure social acceptance it shall take at least 4 years. To start the project, financing of the resettlement according to the single project stages shall be ensured.
Page 151 of 171
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
Main Resettlement Activities
2007
2006
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Resettlement of Hade West Resettlement of Hade North Resettlement of Mirene Resettlement of Shipitulla East Resettlement of Konxhul Establishment local consulting office *) Look for estates, planning and building Road from Hade to Grabovc Road from Hade to the road Sibovc-Palaj Road from Sibovc to Grabovc (Shipitulla)
Deconstructing of the Road Bardh-Hade Stocktaking of estates
Financial assesment of estates
Preparation of socially aceptable offers
Resettlement of the inhabitants
Completion of deconstructing works incl. basements Specification
Tendering process
Construction
Commissionning
*) Information of the inhabitants, distribution of questionnaires, social and technical assistance
Fig.: 7.2-10
Time Scheduling for Resettlement Measures
7.3 Investment and Cost Calculation for Resettlement The following subdivision was made: -
Households with garden land
-
Public Facilities
-
Infrastructure within the villages
-
Substitute measures outside the villages
-
Land claim (farm land)
Households including garden The following table includes estimated data of the villages including the land to resettle. In cases where neither documents were available nor could be made available the project team has made a provisional cost estimate exclusively for the purpose of this particular EAR project. One of the bases for the following cost estimation is the unit price for the buildings and the land compensation laid down by the Intergovernmental Committee in July 2004. The following assumptions were made for the compensations of the households in the Sibovc field with regard to the resettlement time and the maintenance of value to be expected: Average compensation per built-up estate: Average compensation for building land:
100,000 EURO 500 m²
Average compensation for farmland:
2,000 m²
Average size of estates:
2,500 m²
Page 152 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The following table includes the compensation sums per estate: Title
Residence
Criteria for evaluation (Results of the GWG)
Area
Price per property
[€/m²]
[m²]
[€]
350
200
70,000
23
500
11,500
5
2,000
10,000
Economic Building (workshops, farm etc.)
120
600
7,200
Auxiliary Buildings (garage, depot, yard...)
50
30
1,500
Building Land Agriculture Land - Class I
Total
100,200
Round Price per Property with Buildings
100,000
Tab.: 7.3-1
Cost Calculation for Resettlement of Properties with constructed Buildings
The number of estates to be resettled was taken from aerial photography and local visit in February 2006 and summarized in the following tables.
Page 153 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Settlement Area
Mirene
Year of the Resettlement
Dec 2015
Investment
Households
Members of Households estimated
Land Claim
[No.]
[No.]
[m²]
12
96
Payment per Households Household [€/No.]
[MEURO]
100.000
1.200
78.500
0.942
Household without land
12
Building land households
12
6,000
11.500
0.138
Gardenland households
12
24,000
10.000
0.120
100.000
1.700
78,500
1.334
Shipitulla East
Dec 2015
17
136
Household without land
17
Building land households
17
8,500
11,500
0.195
Gardenland households
17
34,000
10,000
0.170
100,000
3.500
78,500
2.747
Hade Western Slope
Dec 2009
35
280
Household without land
35
Building land households
35
17,500
11,500
0.402
Gardenland households
35
70,000
10,000
0.353
100,000
4.100
78,500
3.218
Hade North
Dec 2019
41
328
Household without land
41
Building land households
41
20,500
11,500
0.471
Gardenland households
41
82,000
10,000
0.410
100,000
0.400
78,500
0.314
Konxhul
Dec 2023
4
32
Household without land
4
Building land households
4
2,000
11,500
0.046
Gardenland households
4
8,000
10,000
0.040
Total Tab.: 7.3-2
109
872
272,500
10.900
Resettlement of Households and Land Claim
Public Facilities There are no public facilities in the concerned area.
Infrastructure within the villages For substitute measures of infrastructure inside the villages (Roads, Power supply, Water supply) 5,000 EURO per estate were determined and a lump sum for social and technical assistance depending on the size of the village. The costs for demolition were calculated from the outline of quantities of the estates to be resettled basing on an estimated price of 3.50 EURO/m³ enclosed space (app. 2.500 EURO per household).
Page 154 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Investments
Allocated to the Settlements
Year of the Resettlement
Households
Infrastructure
Demolition
Social and technical Assistance
Total
per Household 5,000
2,500
1,500
[€]
[€]
[€]
[€]
Mirene
Dec 2015
12
60,000
30,000
18,000
108,000
Shipitulla East
Dec 2015
17
85,000
42,500
25,500
153,000
Hade Western Slope
Dec 2009
35
175,000
87,500
52,500
315,000
Hade North
Dec 2019
41
205,000
102,500
61,500
369,000
Konxhul
Dec 2023
4
20,000
10,000
6,000
36,000
109
545,000
272,500
163,500
981,000
Total Tab.: 7.3-3
Substitution Measures Infrastructure inside the Village and other Costs
Infrastructure outside the villages Owing to the opencast mine development of the Sibovc mine from South to North connecting road and accesses to the settlements are over-excavated. Separate accesses to the settlements will not be produced. Existing ways will be maintained up to the claim of areas for the resettlements.
Substitute for the road Bardh-Hade The communal road from Bardh to Hade will be claimed by the mine in December 2009. For safety reasons this road will be blocked for transit traffic in December 2008. Therefore the substitute measure shall be planned and finished until end of 2008. The connection between Bardh and Hade is made by extending the road from Grabovc to Shipitulla up to the connection to the new asphalt road near Sibovc. From this road SibovcPalaj the existing access to Hade-Nord will be developed as paved road. The substitute road Hade-Bardh will be constructed in two sections. In the first section (20072008) the existing gravel road will be developed as asphalt road from the mosque in Hade via Hade-North, in the south passing Megjuani and Konxhul to Shipitulla and from there into southern direction to Grabovc up to the connection to the present road Grabovc-Hade. The route of this road is illustrated in dark blue colour in the following figure (length ca. 6,890m). This substitute road will be deconstructed in 2019 with the occupation of the settlements of Hade-Nord and Konxhul. The by-pass of the Sibovc mine shall than be made via the community of Sibovc. The road connection of Hade to the road Sibovc-Palaj according to the investment plan will already be made in 2009 (length ca. 1,680m). It is planned to continue the asphalt road from Shipitulla to Sibovc in 2018/19 (length ca. 3,420m). This route is illustrated red in the below figure.
Page 155 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 7.3-1
By-pass of Hade-Bardh
The following assumptions are bases for the determined compensation sums for the substitution of the available infrastructure outside the villages: -
Road construction (450,000 EURO/km) asphalt road from Hade to the road SibovcPalaj and Sibovc to Grabovc.
Page 156 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Power supply (45,000 EURO/km disassembly and assembly of medium-voltage overhead transmission line)
-
Water supply (120,000 EURO for drinking water DN 200)
Investments Year of the Resettlements
Settlement
Total
Power supply
Water supply
Roads
[€]
[€]
[€]
[€]
Mirene
Dec 2015
54.000
144.000
93.500
291.500
Shipitulla East
Dec 2015
0
0
0
0
Hade Western Slope
Dec 2009
31.500
84.000
41.000
156.500
Hade North
Dec 2019
67.500
180.000
87.700
335.200
Konxhul
Dec 2023
13.500
36.000
17.500
67.000
Road from Hade to Grabovc
2007-2008
2.900.000
2.900.000
Road from Hade to the Road Sibovc-Palaj
2009
706.000
706.000
Road from Sibovc to Grabovc
2018-2019
1.440.000
1.440.000
5.285.700
5.896.200
Total
166.500
Tab.: 7.3-4
444.000
Substitution Measures for Infrastructure outside the Village
Claim of Land (Farmland) The table below gives a summary of the compensation sums to be expected in connection with re-settlement and land purchase. The purchase of the settlement properties (500 m² building land per property) is separately indicated in the table „Provisional estimation of resettlement“.
Investments Claim of land
Total
Land Use
Land Use Settlements
Farmland
Price
[ha]
[ha]
[ha]
[€ /ha]
[€ ]
2006-2010
74
1.75
72.25
47.5
3,431.88
2011-2012
22
0
22.00
47.5
1,045.00
2013-2017
94
1.45
92.55
47.5
4,396.13
2018-2022
122
2.05
119.95
47.5
5,697.63
2023-2024
17
0.20
16.80
47.5
798.00
Total
329
5.45
323.55
Tab.: 7.3-5
15,368.63
Claim of Farmland
In the following tables all estimated costs connected with the resettlement are summarized according to the individual settlements and annual periods of occupation:
Page 157 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Payment for households without land
-
Payment for building land households
-
Payment for garden land households
-
Payment for demolition of buildings
-
Social and technical assistance for the resettlers
-
Payment for the community for infrastructure (roads, power supply, water supply) inside village
-
Infrastructure outside village (roads, power supply, water supply) with substitution of public roads
-
Payment for farmland
The total costs for resettlements and compensations amount to ca. 32 MEURO.
Page 158 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Settlement
Term
Households
Land Use
Payment
Investments
Total Costs per Settlement
[No.]
[ha]
[â&#x201A;Ź/No.]
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
Households without Land 35 Building Land Households 35 1.75 Garden Land Households 35 7.00 Hade West Demolition 35 Social and technical Assistance 35 Infrastructure inside Village 35 Households 41 Building Land Households 41 2.05 Garden Land Households 41 8.20 Hade North Demolition 41 Social and technical Assistance 41 Infrastructure inside Village 41 Households 12 Building Land Households 12 0.66 Garden Land Households 12 2.40 Mirene Demolition 12 Social and technical Assistance 12 Infrastructure inside Village 12 Households 17 Building Land Households 17 0.85 17 3.40 Shipitulla East Garden Land Households Demolition 17 Social and technical Assistance 17 Infrastructure inside Village 17 Households 4 Building Land Households 4 0.20 Garden Land Households 4 0.80 Konxhul Demolition 4 Social and technical Assistance 4 Infrastructure inside Village 4 Substitute Public Roads Infrastructure Community Compensation for Power supply outside Village Community Compensation for Water supply Community Compensation for Gravel Roads Farmland 301.75 TOTAL PAYMENT 329.00 Tab.: 7.3-6
78,500 11,500 10,000 2,500 1,500 5,000 78,500 11,500 10,000 2,500 1,500 5,000 78,500 11,500 10,000 2,500 1,500 5,000 78,500 11,500 10,000 2,500 1,500 5,000 78,500 11,500 10,000 2,500 1,500 5,000
47,500
2.748 0.403 0.350 0.088 0.053 0.175 3.219 0.472 0.410 0.103 0.062 0.205 0.942 0.138 0.120 0.030 0.018 0.060 1.335 0.196 0.170 0.043 0.026 0.085 0.314 0.046 0.040 0.010 0.006 0.020 5.046 0.167 0.444 0.240 14.333
Provisional Estimation of Resettlement
Page 159 of 171
3.815
4.469
1.308
1.853
0.436
4.210
14.333 32.110
LandClaim
Year
thereof Hade West
Hade North
[ha]
Total Purchase of Land
Shipitulla East
Mirene
Konxhul
Farmland
Hade West
Hade North
[ha]
Mirene
Shipitulla East
Infrastructure inside and outside Settlement Konxhul
Farmland
Hade West
Hade North
[MEURO]
Mirene
Shipitulla East
Total
Konxhul
[MEURO]
[MEURO]
2006 2007
29.60
4.00
25.60
0.344
1.216
3.622
5.182
2008
14.80
4.75
10.05
0.409
0.477
2.498
3.383
2009
14.80
14.80
0.703
2010
14.80
14.80
0.703
0.703
2011
11.00
11.00
0.523
0.523
2012
11.00
11.00
0.523
0.523
2013
18.80
18.80
0.893
0.893
2014
18.80
18.80
0.893
0.893
2015
18.80
2016
18.80
18.80
0.893
0.893
2017
18.80
18.80
0.893
0.893
2018
24.40
5.00
19.40
0.430
0.922
2.964
4.316
2019
24.40
5.25
19.15
0.452
0.910
2.399
3.760
2020
24.40
24.40
1.159
1.159
2021
24.40
24.40
1.159
1.159
2022
24.40
24.40
1.159
1.159
2023
8.50
2024
8.50
Total
329
Tab.: 7.3-7
3.00
4.25
11.55
1.00
0.258
0.366
7.50
0.549
0.086
8.50 8.75
10.25
3.00
4.25
Cost of Resettlement â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Schedule
1.00
301.75
0.706
1.409
1.342
1.488
0.356
4.001
0.417
0.404 0.753
0.882
0.258
0.366
0.086
14.333
0.859 0.404
6.120
6.069
1.342
1.488
0.417
32.110
8 Manpower Development and Organisation The manpower of the Sibovc SW mine will be recruited from the personnel of KEK. The actual situation and changes which will become effective during the mid-term period have to be taken into account. A parallel operation of the mines Mirash/Bardh and Sibovc SW will be done from 2008 until the closure of the existing mine which is scheduled for 2012. For a better evaluation of the future manpower demand in the new Sibovc SW opencast mine the present situation and changes in Mirash/Bardh is therefore addressed.
8.1 Actual Situation Compared with other European opencast mines the present specific manpower assignment is considerably high. This current situation is caused by: -
Unacceptable weak condition of the main mine equipment
-
Insufficient utilisation and maintenance of auxiliary equipment
-
Level of education to be improved
-
Poor motivation of staff
-
Insufficient logistics / organisation of the production process
-
Social and historical conditions
-
The political environment in Kosovo and in particular for KEK
Especially the high unemployment rate in Kosovo and missing social insurance system make it very difficult to downsize the number of KEK employees. However the KEK management has prepared a program of rightsizing the structure through the utility including coal production. This program includes a package of different social instruments like a sewerage package and an early retirement model. An outsourcing strategy for non-core businesses has been developed as well. Currently about 3,600 employees are involved in the Coal Production Division performing 6-7 mt coal per year. An accountable number of employees in the past have been involved in repair measures mainly financed by EAR. KEKâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s CPD currently is in the process of introducing a new structure to: -
eliminate parallel services performed by different units, e.g. vulcanizers are now concentrated in one unit;
-
concentrate the production units (coal and overburden) on pure production processes, all services around (auxiliary equipment, transport, maintenance etc.) will be concentrated in special units;
-
merge the mines Bardh and Mirash and organize along the production chain;
-
deploy surplus human capacities for urgently needed non-core processes like scrap collection and decommissioning of not more needed equipment.
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
It is remarkable that the share of maintenance personnel is even too high when taken into account the insufficient conditions of the equipment. Currently KEK is restructuring the maintenance units with the aim to concentrate the equipment maintenance in two units: -
field maintenance department;
-
the Kosovamont main workshop.
Apart from that a specialized maintenance unit is organized under the new auxiliary equipment department. The current and future division structure is shown in the following charts:
Coal Production Division Manager Central dispatcher
Engineering Department
Separation plant Department
Maintenance Department
Mirash Mine Department
Bardh Mine Department
Mechanical eng.
Mine planning & reclamation
A
Field Repair
Coal Production
Coal Production
Electrical eng.
Geotechnics/ Geology
B
Mechanical workshop
Overburden removal
Overburden removal
Civil works
Surveyors
Maintenance
Electrical workshop
Mobile equipment
Mobile equipment
Technical office
Electrical Maintenance
Electrical Maintenance
Mobile equipment
Mechanical Maintenance
Mechanical Maintenance
Auxiliary equip.
Fig.: 8.1-1
CPD Structure until 2005
Page 162 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Executive Director
Safety office
Secretary
Main Dispatcher
Engineering
Surveyors
Coal Production
Overburden removal
Services
Maintenance
Kosovamont
Auxiliary equipment
Business Support
Mine planning
Active mines
A
A
Kosovo A
Engineering
Input/output
Preparation
Budget & Controlling
Geology
Potential fields
B
B
Kosovo B
Mechanical
Preparation
Engineering
Staff issues
Soilmechanics
Mapping
C
C
Vulcanisation
Electrical
Mechanical
Operative equ.
Procurement
Hydrology
Cadastre
D
D
Conveyor services
Warehouse
Electrical
Transport equ.
Warehouses
Environment
Dewatering
Selfmaintenance
Vehicles
Civil works
Comm & Decomm.
Quality control
Operators
Maintenance
Fig.: 8.1-2
New CPD Structure to be introduced
The new structure includes a “Commissioning & Decommissioning” unit as mentioned earlier.
<= 40 41 - 46
18% 35%
47 - 52 >= 53
23% 24%
Fig.: 8.1-3
Age Structure of CPD Employees and Qualification (Source KEK)
The above figures illustrate that almost half (47%) of the total workforce of KEK´s Coal Production Division is within the age group 41 – 52 years. 35% of the employees are younger than 40 years and about 18% are older than 53 years. The age structure shows the relevant share of personnel at an age of over 40 years.
Page 163 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
This is the main group that should drive the movement towards a competitive business unit in technical and organizational means. As described in the Mid Term Plan regarding the degree of qualification, about 50% of the employees have an average industrial training. Almost 1500 employees (40%) have only a low-grade training and/or no qualification. About 10% of the employees have graduated at a technical college or a university. Considerable training measures should be realized during the next years as a basis for higher performance. As a reaction to the low number and low level of qualification of good engineers KEK has developed and started a so called young educates program. Under this program: -
a number of trainees will be employed by KEK based on a selection process of best performing university students;
-
a number of young KEK engineers get support for their further qualification (PhD, masters exams).
It must be considered that between 1990 and 1999/2000 the main part of the staff was not employed in the mines and the deficits in the professional experience can be attributed to this. Furthermore, the Embargo resulted in a limited access to modern technologies and even today the lack of financial means makes it difficult to get or use state of the art technology. Owing to this, specific higher number of personnel is required but the lower income balances the involved cost increase.
8.2 Proposed Improvement / Benchmark As mentioned the envisaged measures mainly refer to: -
Improving of qualification
-
Improvement the structure and
-
Adaptation of personnel employment of phasing out Mirash / Bardh operations
Qualification Measures It is extremely important to develop a skilled and motivated workforce with the ambition to run a competitive mine. Therefore a strategy of training and developing human resources is planned. The training programs are suggested for the next years and refer to: -
Management qualification
-
Staff of main mining equipment and foremen
-
Dispatcher
-
Mechanical maintenance
-
Mechanical steel construction inspection
-
Electrical maintenance of motors
Page 164 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Electrical maintenance for the Mine and Separation plant and
-
Environmental issues
A breakdown of this is described in the Mid Term Plan.
Organizational Development within the Mid-term Period The Mid Term Mining Plan also foresees significant changes in the coming years. Major developments in the coming years include: -
A focus on business rather than production, as KEK evolves from a state run entity into a profitable enterprise
-
More emphasis on maintenance with increasing equipment productivity
-
A changeover from reactive maintenance to scheduled preventative maintenance
As mentioned earlier KEK has started a process of outsourcing of non-core businesses. Within the CPD there are different processes presenting potential candidates for outsourcing and involvement of third party companies. Potential for outsourcing of processes and personnel have been identified with different services like: -
vulcanization and idlers repair;
-
the main workshops (Kosovamont);
-
auxiliary equipment maintenance;
-
partly heavy equipment maintenance.
This involvement of international leading companies (e.g. for vulcanization and maintenance of heavy equipment) will lead to introduction of state of the art technologies, where KEK has no sufficient resources. The restructuring of KEKâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s CPD should be continued. A proposal for the next step of concentration of resources is shown in the graphic below:
Page 165 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
CPD Exec.Dir. Central dispatcher
Engineering Department Fig.: 8.2-1
Surveying Department
Services Department
Production Department
Maintenance Department
Proposed Structure of Macroorganisation of the CPD
Adaptation of the Employment of Staff Currently, the overall productivity is about 1750 tons per man and year (3,646 persons). As already mentioned there are various reasons for this. A comparison to some benchmark mines reveals: Name
Technology
Remarks
Production [mt/a]
Staff
[t/man]
Eagle Butte (US)
OCM / Truck & Shovel
Mine only
16
400
40,000
Jänschwalde (GER)
OCM / BWE & BCE
Mine only
16
550
30,000
Foundation Coal (US)
OCM / UGM
Organization
60
4000
15,000
Burton (AUS)
OCM / Truck & Shovel
Mine only
6
400
15,000
VEM (GER)
OCM / BWE & BCE
Organization
60
5,000
12,000
Cumberland (US)
UGM / Longwall
Mine only
6
550
11,000
Kingston (US)
UGM / Continuous Miner
Mine only
0.8
100
8,000
Bogatyr (KAZ)
OCM / BWE & Shovel & Train
Mine only
25
5,000
5,000
CPD (2005)
OCM Mirash/Bardh
Division
6.4
3,646
1,750
Tab.: 8.2-1
Productivity Benchmarks in international Coal Industries
A comparison of figures only between mines and mining organizations can lead to misjudgement. Geology and Technology as well as product quality vary in a wide range â&#x20AC;&#x201C; but are of essential importance. However - the only common ground for all coal mines is the market, either for the coal itself or its refined product, electricity. And from that perspective it makes sense to compare productivities in coal mines, because productivity is one of the most important factors for production cost.
Page 166 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
As already mentioned: when comparing productivities it has to be considered: -
Is the overhead accounted for in the statistics?
-
What additional manpower is hidden within the budget line external services, i.e. how many contractors are working on the site?
-
What part of the value chain is covered by the operation itself? Examples for activities upstream the mining processes are overhauls, repair and maintenance as well as other services including transport and catering. Downstream activities include coal preparation, coal storage in stockpiles and coal delivery with conveyor, truck, rail or barges.
-
Also the ratio of waste to product within the raw production has an impact on productivity. In opencast mines this means the overburden to coal ratio.
-
The dig ability of the material
Summarizing, it seems to be appropriate, to set the goal for the long term productivity of KEK-CPD with at least 6,000 tons per man-year. This means a 3.4 fold increase in productivity compared to the year 2005. The mine plan assumes that this goal canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t be achieved up to the end of the opening â&#x20AC;&#x201C;up phase of Sibovc SW. The stepwise reduction in overall staff numbers has been started and will be continued.
8.3 Employment and Organisation in Sibovc SW For the long-term development it is assumed that the already existing obstacles for the restructuring process and/or a remarkable increase in efficiency will be eliminated to a great extent. Such existing obstacles are: -
insufficient social measures in case of unemployment and illness
-
general financially weak industry of Kosovo
-
lack of sufficient alternative employment opportunities
-
overstaffing in other industries and other businesses and therefore staff reduction requirements not only in KEK
-
availability of better qualification opportunities
-
insufficient legal bases regarding labour law
Irrespective of the elimination of existing obstacles, the experiences, the mentality of the people and the actual economic development will influence the employment of staff. An appropriate personnel policy in the company shall assist the process of improving the labour efficiency. This includes for example: -
A socially acceptable personnel reduction (in the departments where necessary)
Page 167 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Improvement of degree of qualification (offering and demanding of sufficient qualification opportunities)
-
Set up and keeping (adjustment) of high safety standards
-
Developing of a high motivation
-
Individual payment according to performance
To assist the above mentioned principles and goals for the employment of labour in Sibovc it is assumed that suitable staff will be qualified and employed if motivated. The jobs shall be advertised throughout the company. The following tables give a specification of employees in existing mines and in the future mine Sibovc SW. Year
2007 01.01
Mirash / Bardh per 01.01.
2008 31.12
3,500
01.01
2009 31.12
3,000
01.01
31.12
2,100
- Fluctuation / Redundant
490
415
300
- Employees for Sibovc SW
10
485
500
Mirash / Bardh per 31.12.
3,000
Year
2,100
2010 01.01
Mirash / Bardh per 01.01.
1,300
2011 31.12
1,300
01.01
2012 31.12
900
01.01
31.12
350
- Fluctuation / Redundant
100
470
260
- Employees for Sibovc SW
300
80
40
Mirash / Bardh per 31.12. Tab.: 8.3-1
900
350
50
Employees in the Bardh / Mirash Mine
Page 168 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Year
2007 01.01
Sibovc SW per 01.01.
2008 31.12
5
01.01
2009 31.12
15
01.01
31.12
500
+ new staff from Mirash/Bardh
10
485
500
Average of the year
10
350
700
Sibovc per 31.12.
15
Year
500
2010 01.01
Sibovc SW per 01.01.
1,000
2011 31.12
1,000
01.01
2012 31.12
1,300
01.01
31.12
1,380
+ new staff
300
80
40
Average of the year
1,250
1,350
1,400
Sibovc SW per 31.12. Tab.: 8.3-2
1,300
1,380
1,420
Employees in the Sibovc SW Mine
Employees 3500
Staff in Sibovc SW 3000
Staff in Mirash/Bardh
2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 2007
Fig.: 8.3-1
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Development of Employees in CPD
It is shown that there will be redundant personnel in the existing mines, which can not be employed in Sibovc SW. Some reductions will result from employees entering the retirement
Page 169 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
age and/or personal terminations. However the staff rightsizing program started by KEK (retirement, early retirement, sewerage package) shall be continued over the upcoming years. The following gives a survey on the staffing in Sibovc: 2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
>2014
Administration
70
110
120
125
125
130
Main Equipment + Belt Conveyor
270
520
580
585
620
650
Auxiliary Equipment
190
310
310
330
330
330
Workshops
100
210
230
240
250
260
Other
70
100
110
120
125
130
SUM Personnel
700
1250
3361
1400
1450
1500
Tab.: 8.3-3
Number of Employees
The organisation chosen for Sibovc SW assists the goal to achieve competitive costs for coal supply and to guarantee these costs in the long run. KEK is currently undergoing an incorporation to be finished by end of 2006. The new structure as approved by the Kosovo government foresees to create independent units along the value chain of energy generation and distribution. Consequently all services currently performed by the KEK head office including commercial and financial units, legal and human resources are integrated in the organization.
Page 170 of 171
Part II Technical Planning Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9 License for Coal Extraction Since the existing mine Mirash/Bardh will be depleted by 2011 the purpose of this document is to provide a plan to open up a new mine timely. The start of coal supply is planned for 2010. Therefore the first overburden has to be removed 2008. For this mining activity an exploitation licence is requested. One essential principle for granting such a license for coal extraction is: The licenses for coal mining should be compliant to the planned power generation. The mining licenses should provide sufficient security of supply in terms of coal quantities and quality. To feed the existing TPPâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Kosovo A and B with fuel till their decommissioning a license over 123 mt mineable reserves would be necessary in addition to the remaining reserves in the existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash. Due to the available amounts of coal in Mirash / Bardh and the designed Sibovc SW mine this can be provided: According to the mining plan KEK has the resources regarding sufficient coal reserves and the adequate coal quality. The deposit can be exploited in an environmentally friendly way. Further the investigation revealed that the new Sibovc SW mine will be economically viable. The Complementary Mining Plan verifies that the Sibovc South West mine has the potential for being the coal supplier to the existing power plants in technical and economical terms.
Page 171 of 171
European Agency for Reconstruction PREPARATION OF A COMPLEMENTARY MINING PLAN FOR THE SIBOVC SOUTH WEST LIGNITE MINE CONTRACT 02/KOS01/10/021
DRAFT FINAL REPORT Complementary Mining Plan for Sibovc SW
Part III – Environmental Assessment
April, 2006
prepared by: STEAG Consortium
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Key Experts of Project Team
Hans J端rgen Matern Team Leader
Thomas Suhr Senior Expert Computer-Aided Mine Planning Applications
Stephan Peters Senior Expert Geology
Helmar Laube Senior Expert Soil Mechanics
Joachim Gert ten Thoren Senior Environmental Expert
Page 2 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Table of Contents 1 1.1 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.2.1 1.2.2.2 1.2.2.3 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.3
SUMMARY (PART III) .......................................................................................... 8 Objective .................................................................................................................... 8 Tasks and Outputs of the Project................................................................................ 9 Part I: Basic Investigations ......................................................................................... 9 Part II: Technical Planning......................................................................................... 9 Mine Development ................................................................................................... 10 Dewatering ............................................................................................................... 10 Manpower................................................................................................................. 11 Part III: Environmental Impact Study....................................................................... 11 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis............................................................... 12 Results under Part III â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Environmental Assessment ................................................ 13
2 2.1 2.2
INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 15 Geographical Overview and Historical Development.............................................. 15 Coal Demand and Fuel Supply Strategy................................................................... 16
3
DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT .................................................................. 19
4 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
CURRENT STATE OF THE ENVIRONMENT ................................................ 21 Topography............................................................................................................... 21 Atmosphere .............................................................................................................. 21 Soils.......................................................................................................................... 25 Surface Waters Run-Offs and their Qualities........................................................... 27 Hydrogeological Situation........................................................................................ 29 Noteworthy Side Issues ............................................................................................ 33
5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6
ALTERNATIVES .................................................................................................. 39 Overview of Potential Future Mining Fields............................................................ 39 Description of Alternative Mining Fields ................................................................ 40 Alternatives of Opening-up and Mine Development for the Sibovc Field .............. 42 Environmental Aspects of Mining Fields Alternatives ............................................ 43 Valuation of the Mining Fields ................................................................................ 46 Environmental Ranking of Alternatives................................................................... 48
6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS OF THE SIBOVC SW PROJECT ............... 49 Soil ........................................................................................................................... 50 Surface Waters ......................................................................................................... 52 Groundwater............................................................................................................. 53 Ecological Resources ............................................................................................... 54 Economic Development ........................................................................................... 55 Social and Cultural Resources.................................................................................. 56
7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6
ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ............................................. 58 General Environmental Impacts ............................................................................... 58 Topography............................................................................................................... 59 Soil ........................................................................................................................... 59 Surface Waters ......................................................................................................... 60 Groundwater............................................................................................................. 60 Ecological Resources ............................................................................................... 61
Page 3 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.7 7.8 7.9
Economic Development ........................................................................................... 61 Social and Cultural Resources.................................................................................. 62 Health and Safety ..................................................................................................... 62
8
IRREVERSIBLE AND IRRETRIEVABLE IMPACTS .................................... 63
9
MITIGATING MEASURES ................................................................................. 64
10 10.1 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.2.4 10.2.5 10.2.6 10.2.7 10.2.8 10.2.9 10.2.10 10.2.11
ACTION PLAN ...................................................................................................... 66 Environmental Management .................................................................................... 66 Environmental Monitoring Measures....................................................................... 66 Surface Water ........................................................................................................... 66 Groundwater............................................................................................................. 67 Air Quality................................................................................................................ 68 Noise......................................................................................................................... 69 Vibrations ................................................................................................................. 69 Intensified Assessments ........................................................................................... 69 Fauna and Flora ........................................................................................................ 69 Cultural Heritage ...................................................................................................... 70 Compensation of Farmland and Utilization of Top Soil .......................................... 70 Protection of Villages........................................................................................... 70 Future Treatment of Ash Dumps.......................................................................... 71
11 11.1 11.2 11.3
MINE CLOSURE AND RECULTIVATION PLANNING................................ 72 Principles.................................................................................................................. 72 Mine Closure Plan.................................................................................................... 72 Concept of Post-Mining Use for the Fields Bardh, Mirash and Sibovc................... 74
12 12.1 12.2
LEGAL FRAMEWORK ....................................................................................... 77 Legal Mining Regulations ........................................................................................ 77 The Environmental Protection Law ......................................................................... 77
Page 4 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Figures Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.:
2.1-1 2.2-1 4.2-1 4.2-2 4.2-3 4.2-4 4.2-5 4.2-6 4.3-1 4.4-1 4.4-2 4.4-3 4.5-1 4.5-2 4.6-1 4.6-2 4.6-3 4.6-4 4.6-5 5.1-1 5.6-1 6.1-1 6.2-1 6.3-1 10.2-1 11.3-1
General Location Map Location of intended Opencast mine Variation of monthly mean temperatures Variation of monthly temperatures Direction and velocity of wind (Source Rudarski Institute) Long-term variation of monthly precipitation Average, minimum and maximum monthly precipitation Daily Precipitation Soil Map Catchment Areas Characteristic Water Quality Values for the River Sitnica Characteristic Mine Water Quality Bottom of yellow Clay (Redrawn from Rudarski Institut) Complemented Extract from Hydrogeological Map Former Underground Mining in Field D Gallery of an old Underground Mine with wooden Support System Underground Mining Structures in the Mirash Mine Coal Fire at Base of Dump and near a Fault with burn out Zones Areas of potential Risk of toxic Waste Deposits Potential Mining Fields Area of the Complementary Mine Plan Distribution of Soils Surface Waters and Catchment Areas Complemented Extract from the Hydrological Map, Rudarski Institut Net of Groundwater Monitoring Wells Plant Scheme for Wind Erosion Protection
16 19 21 22 22 23 24 24 26 27 28 28 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 40 49 50 52 54 68 76
Page 5 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Tables Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.:
2.2-1 2.2-2 2.2-1 4.2-1 4.4-1 4.6-1 5.6-1 6.5-1 6.6-1 7.7-1
Installed TPP Capacity (Source KEK) Coal Demand Demand of Surface Area [km²] Intensity of Precipitation at Rainfall Gauging Station Pristina Comparison of Water Qualities Underground Coal Production Valuation of Mining Fields Claim of occupied Farm Land Resettlement of Households Development of Employees
17 18 20 25 29 35 48 55 57 62
Page 6 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Abbreviations a
year
bm³
bank cubic meter
bm³/h
bank cubic meter per hour
`000 bm³
thousand bank cubic meter
EN
European Norm
EnO
Energy Office
ESTAP
Energy Sector Technical Assistance Project
GWh
gigawatt-hours
IPP
International Power Provider
k~
kilo-
lm³
loose cubic meter
`000 lm³
thousand loose cubic meter
m~
million
m²
square meter
m³
cubic meter
mlm³
million loose cubic meters
MME
Main Mine Equipment (BWE, belt conveyor and spreader)
mMSL
meter above Main Sea Level
MW
mega watt
OCM
Open Cast Mine
t
tonne
TPP
Thermal Power Plant
TPS
Thermal Power Station
Page 7 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1 Summary (Part III) 1.1 Objective The Complementary Mining Plan for New Sibovc South West Mine consists of the following reports: -
Part I
Basic Investigations
-
Part II
Technical Planning
-
Part III
Environmental Impact Study
-
Part IV
Economic and Financial Analysis
The existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash, west of Pristina, will be exhausted by 2011. Thus the overall objective of the project is providing a plan for the supply of the necessary fuel to the existing power plants in Kosovo until the end of their lifetime. The specific objectives of this contract are the elaboration of a detailed mine plan on the development of the new mine in the Sibovc South West Lignite Field. The objective of the plan is: -
to define the technical measures and the timeframe to be followed to open-up the new mine and develop it up to the scheduled capacity of about 9 million tons per annum;
-
to guide the focus on the necessary investments and operating costs;
-
to include the necessary measures and information for licensing applications.
Other than the Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine (max. 24 m t coal out per year) the Complementary Mining Plan for the Sibovc South West Lignite Field focuses on the fuel supply to the existing TPP assuming a coal demand of 9 mt/a and a limited availability of financial resources. The plan covers the period from 2007 to 2024 when all existing power capacities assumed to reach the end of their service life. Subsequently the total accumulated coal demand from the Sibovc South West Lignite Field comes to 123 million tonnes, what is approximately 15% of the entire mineable lignite reserves in the Sibovc Lignite Field. The remaining lignite reserves of the entire Sibovc Lignite Field could be a source to feed new power plant capacities expected to be built in Kosovo. The Complementary Mining Plan has been coordinated with the existing â&#x20AC;&#x153;Mid term Mining Plan for the existing minesâ&#x20AC;?. The Mid Term Plan provides the stepwise implementation of regular operation conditions, the achievement of geotechnical and public safety and therefore the transfer of mines to an economic efficient operation. The purpose of the Complementary Mine Plan is to show the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures to open up the new mine in time to replace the running out production capacity of the existing mines. The plan is showing the required investment and effective cost of lignite supply.
Page 8 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The investment requirements to open-up the Sibovc South-West mine are 236 MEURO until 2012, when full supply capacity will be reached. The real average cost of lignite supply amount to 7.50-8.00 EURO/ton of raw coal, depending on the cost of capital investment. Special attention has been focused on the required resettlement and land acquisition. The plan also ensures that the mine operations are in full compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations and laws.
1.2 Tasks and Outputs of the Project 1.2.1 Part I: Basic Investigations The basis for the new mining plan for the Sibovc South West mine is the previous study â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Main Mining Plan for Sibovc mineâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;. Using this as the basis, the consultants checked, evaluated, updated and presented all necessary facts (geo-technical, geological, hydrogeological and hydrological data, infrastructure, existing end necessary new equipment) for the Sibovc South West mine. According to ToR this plan was based on a demand forecast prepared by the Ministry of Energy and Mines in accordance with the Kosovo Energy Strategy. The consultant updated the existing computerised geological model based on additional exploration drillings conducted by KEK and prepared a plan for further exploration to be realised by KEK, defined the slope design based on soil-mechanic calculation. To ensure the planned performance of the equipment and subsequently output of the mine it will be necessary to undertake a complex refurbishment of lignite and overburden equipment incl. excavators, conveyor lines and spreaders. This approach represents a new quality against the partly repair of machines realised so far. A refurbishment/replacement programme for the existing main mining equipment as well as auxiliary equipment has been prepared including a realistic assessment of the timing of the required investments. As an important output of the project the plan provides the basis for the application for, and issuing of exploitation licence for the new mine. The outputs are the findings of this analysis, including the updated geological model, plan for further exploitation; definition of slope design; and updated investment plan in main and auxiliary equipment.
1.2.2 Part II: Technical Planning The consultants prepared detailed mine development plans/annexes, including all necessary calculations, for the first five years of operation and mine phase documentation for the end of each year, continuing with next five years periods (end of periods) up to 2024. The outputs of this task are the detailed mine development plans as set out above.
Page 9 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
There have been prepared an updated expropriation plan which provides both a timed and cost plan for the required measures for land acquisition and resettlement into mine planning. A short description of the main output of part II follows:
1.2.2.1 Mine Development The following main topics for the mine development have been considered: -
Opening-up of the Sibovc SW OCM shall be made from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The existing inside dump of P3B shall be taken into account.
-
A coal pillar shall remain between the existing Bardh mine and the new Sibovc mine field in order to stabilize the masses of the inside dump of the Bardh opencast mine.
-
The overburden masses will preferably be dumped in the mined-out area of the existing OCM in order to stabilize the slope south of Hade and to establish final dump surfaces as soon as possible.
-
The mined-out bottom in Sibovc SW shall be covered by dumps and as far as possible also the final coal rim slope systems in order to prevent coal fires.
-
During the opening-up phase the overburden will be transported via the western rim slope system. After disassembling the equipment in the existing opencast mines there will be established a belt connection via the eastern rim slope system. This helps to reduce the transport distance and the quickest possible establishment of a stabilising body south of Hade.
-
The residual pit of Mirash-Brand remains as reserved area for the disposal of municipal waste.
-
It is envisaged to flush the power plant residues from TPP B in the residual pit of Mirash-East.
Due to late start of the mine development a rather high capacity will be required right at the beginning of works. The performance required can be performed only with rehabilitated equipment. After rehabilitation the capacity for overburden (BWE) complexes shall be 3.6-5.4 million cubic meters per annum each. The first two BWE - Systems will have to be commissioned in 2008. Some overburden removal works will be required using truck & shovel operation. This service should be contracted with third parties. It must be noticed, that the development of the new Sibovc SW mine is directly linked to the advance of the existing mine and therefore to the realisation of the Mid Term Plan.
1.2.2.2 Dewatering Drainage of surface water via the active bench of the Sibovc SW mine shall be excluded except residual rainwater quantities. It is suggested to install a dewatering system in the valley from which the collected surface water is pumped into the higher located channel(s) by means
Page 10 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
of sewage pumps. According to the OCM advance the dewatering shall be shifted several times to the North. Drainage ditches shall be installed on all working levels and along the access roads.
1.2.2.3 Manpower The following table gives a survey on the staffing requirements: Year Existing mines per 01.01. - Fluctuation / Redundancy Staff transfer Sibovc SW per 31.12.
2007 3500
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
490
3000 415
2100 300
1300 100
900 470
350 260
10
485
500
300
80
40
1380
1420
15
500
1000
1300
Staff for the new mine will be employed mainly from redundant staff of the existing mines.
1.2.3 Part III: Environmental Impact Study The mining activities will have a large effect on the environment. The Environmental Study serves as a baseline description for the expected effects. Alternative locations are discussed for coal extraction prior to the implementation of the Complementary Mining Plan resulting in the location of “D-field”, east of the river Sitnica, to be an equally favourable alternative to supply the existing power plants from the environmental point of view. Among the other alternatives a development of the “Sibovc field” from the south to the north ranked second best. Subject of the Complementary Mining Plan is the excavation of overburden and lignite, developing from the existing opencast mines to the north. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. The anticipated environmental effects concern, first of all, the removal of soil resulting in a loss of surface area and living space. With this extension an enlarged void will be visible, compared to the existing mines. As the backfill of already exploited areas goes on parallel in time, it will be possible to return recovered areas to agricultural use in a landscape with changed appearance. Surface waters to be affected are mainly small and of non perennial flow. The rivers Sitnica and Drenica will not be directly affected, as clayey sediments with sufficient thickness protect them from the mine. Indirect effects can result from the outlet of mine drainage water with enlarged contents of Chloride and Sulphate as well as suspended solids. Because of the characteristics of the overburden the impact on groundwater will be minor. Significant groundwater utilization is not known in the area. Influences on neighbouring utilizations can be excluded. Dust emissions as well as noise emissions will shift from the current to the future working points with an equal or, based on used technologies, even minor extend of emissions. The Environmental Study attempts to follow in general the applicable EU directives on environmental impact assessment, mainly Directive 85/337/EEC. However, there is a general lack of baseline studies, local experts’ opinions, pertinent documents or other information,
Page 11 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
e.g. allowing any specific assessment on influences on fauna and flora. Regarding this aspect additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. In case of proper operation and a coal demand adequate to the mining technology the mine will stay one of the most important employers of the region with up to 1,500 employees. Upon completion of backfilling areas farmable land can be returned to the inhabitants, which mitigates the effects of required resettlements. Resettlement will be needed as a consequence of the development of the mine. Approximately 870 persons representing some 109 households will have to be moved in the years 2007 to 2024. Resettlement refers to single houses and small settlements and it will not be needed to resettle significant villages. With the objective to improve knowledge on the environment and to allow control on the environmental impact, adequate monitoring activities shall be set up concerning air and water quality measurements as well as the purification of drainage water and the utilization of humus enriched top soil layers.
1.2.4 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis The consultants prepared an economic and financial analysis with a detailed cash flow forecast, a financial analysis of the cost benefit of the proposed investment with IRR/ NPV calculations, and a time planning for the investment programme. The output of this task is a detailed, based on annual calculations economic and financial analysis and appraisal of the Sibovc South West mine plan. The calculations have been made in accordance with IFRS. The main results of the profitability calculation are as follows: The calculated real average cost (RAC) comes to 7.5-8.0 EURO/t. The economic analysis also considered that in 2024 a fully functioning opencast mine will be available. This allowed calculation with coal prices of 7.00 EURO/t to 7.50 EURO/t. Totally four variants were assumed containing different coal prices, different escalation and different interest rate on borrowings. All variants until 2011 require about 80 MEURO equity capital and ca. 200 MEURO outside capital. Assuming a coal price of 7.00 EURO/ton the dividend earned until 2024 will amount to at least 137 MEURO which can be distributed to the shareholders. The sum of the annual payments for the production of coal is smaller than 5.0 EURO per tonne coal. This applies from 2012, the first year of full production. It will be possible to produce coal with favourable terms and profits of 20 % on the employed equity capital can be earned. The cash flow analysis demonstrates that the chosen mine development will be generally profitable even with the short operation time period of only 15 years.
Page 12 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1.3 Results under Part III – Environmental Assessment The existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash, west of Pristina, will be exhausted within the next years. With the Sibovc Southwest field a new deposit, adequate to supply the existing thermal power plants in Kosovo, was identified and will be developed. The “Complementary Mining Plan for Sibovc Southwest Mine” describes how the future lignite mine, physically forming an extension of the existing mines Bardh and Mirash, can be operated to serve the existing power plants until 2024. This description follows the demand of coal presented by the Energy Ministry in the year 2006. Resulting from this the mining activities will have a large scale effect on the environment. The Environmental Study serves as a baseline description for the expected effects. Alternative locations are discussed for coal extraction prior to the implementation of the Complementary Mining Plan resulting in the location of “D-field”, east of the river Sitnica, to be an equally favourable alternative to supply the existing power plants from the environmental point of view. Among the other alternatives a development of the “Sibovc field” from the south to the north ranked second best. Subject of the Complementary Mining Plan is the excavation of overburden and lignite, developing from the existing opencast mines to the north. Excavations will be performed using diesel driven truck and shovel technologies as well as electrically driven bucket wheel and belt conveyor technologies. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. The Sibovc Southwest Field is situated north of the operating Bardh and Mirash mines. It is near the capital of Kosovo, Pristina, and near to the existing power plant Kosovo B. The whole Sibovc field covers an area of approximately 16 km² with a maximum mineable width (east-west extension) of 3.8 km and a length of about 6 km. Out of this an area of about 4.8 km² will be needed until 2024 to deliver about 123 million tonnes of lignite from a coal seam with a thickness up to 80 m. The anticipated environmental effects concern, first of all, the movement of soil resulting in a loss of surface area and living space. With this extension an enlarged void will be visible, compared to the existing mines. As the backfill of already exploited areas goes on parallel in time, it will be possible to return reclaimed areas to agricultural use in a landscape with changed appearance. Surface waters to be affected are mainly small and of non perennial flow. The rivers Sitnica and Drenica will not be directly affected, as clayey sediments with sufficient thickness protect them from the mine. Indirect effects can result from the outlet of mine drainage water with enlarged contents of Chloride and Sulphate as well as suspended matter. Because of the characteristics of the overburden the impact on groundwater will be minor. Significant groundwater utilization is not known in the area. Influences on neighbouring utilizations can be excluded. Dust emissions as well as noise emissions will shift from the current to the future working points with an equal or, based on applied technologies, even minor extent of emissions. This Environmental Study attempts to follow in general the applicable EU directives on environmental impact assessment, mainly Directive 85/337/EEC. However, there is a general lack of baseline studies, local experts’ opinions, pertinent documents or other information, e.g. allowing any specific assessment on influences on fauna and flora. Regarding this aspect
Page 13 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. In case of proper operation and a coal demand adequate to the mining technology the mine will stay one of the most important employers of the region with up to 1,500 employees. Upon completion of backfilling areas farmable land can be returned to the inhabitants, which mitigates the effects of required resettlements. Resettlement will be needed as a consequence of the development of the mine. Approximately 870 persons representing some 109 households will have to be moved in the years 2007 to 2024. Resettlement refers to single houses and small settlements and it will not be necessary to resettle significant villages. With the objective to improve knowledge on the environment and to allow control of the environmental impact, adequate monitoring activities shall be set up concerning air and water quality measurements as well as the purification of drainage water and the utilization of humus enriched top soil layers. Not directly connected with the mining activities but environmentally very beneficial will be depositing of the ash from the power plants in abandoned parts of the existing mines. The geological circumstances generally favour this way of disposal. It is conceivable, that also the existing ash dumps can be relocated to the mines in parts or as a whole. To start the Environmental Impact Assessment procedure the Environmental Authorities require a specific applicant for the Complementary Mining Plan. Following the legal regulations it is the duty of the applicant to file this Environmental study with the Ministry, to obtain the official Scoping Opinion and to ensure updates to this report where needed.
Page 14 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2 Introduction To obtain extensive and independent energy supply for Kosovo currently there is no alternative but the excavation and combustion of lignite. The existing lignite mines of Bardh and Mirash will be exhausted in the near future. Therefore a new mining field close to the existing power plants and able to feed the existing power plants at least until 2024 is needed. Geological investigations and modelling, latest done in 2005, showed the Sibovc field in general will be able to meet the fuel demand for the next thirty years. The basics of the environmental issues connected with lignite mining in the Kosovo Basin are described in the “Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine”, dated 24 June 2005 and will be repeated in this report where reasonable. This Environmental Assessment adjusts the existing findings to the Sibovc Southwest field (in the following called Sibovc SW field) and reflects information available on the area of concern and focuses on basic needs for further investigations and monitoring activities which are mentioned as a requirement in the respective chapters.
2.1 Geographical Overview and Historical Development The Kosova lignite deposits are located between the cities of Mitrovica in the North and Kaqanik in the South. The total estimated resources of Kosovo’s lignite deposits are approximately 10,000 mt (Carl Bro; 2003), thus forming one of the largest lignite deposits in Europe. As being one of at least four major deposits the Kosova Coal Basin covers about 85 km from north to south with an average east – west extension of 10 km. Hence the deposit comprises some 850 km². Morphologically the Kosova Coal Basin forms an extended valley where the differences in elevation do not exceed 80 m. A central plane extends along the river Sitnica followed by a more hilly terrain approaching the mountains Çicavica Golesh and Sharr. The basin is surrounded by an elevated relief with Kopaonik massive, Kozic, Zhegovc Lisic in the East, Montenegro massive in the south and Çicavica, Golesh, Carnaleva as well as Sharr Mountains in the west and north-west. The surrounding mountains reach elevations from 900 to more than 1600 m. The resources were discovered more than hundred years ago and the first small-scale operations started in the 1920’ties. First activities were reported to start with underground mining in at least five locations. Underground exploitation was going on until the year 1966 when mining focussed on large scale surface mining at Bardh and Mirash mines. Large-scale extraction was already decided in the 1950’ties and the first mine “Mirash” started coal production in 1958. Power generation started at Thermal Power Plant Kosovo A (TPP A) in 1962. Kosovo A was extended within the period from 1962 until 1975 to the current capacity. A second Thermal Power Plant Kosovo B (TPP B) was commissioned in 1985. Coal exploitation from surface mines in the first period required the excavated overburden to be dumped outside the opencast mines. Hence at least seven outside dumps were formed surrounding the today mines.
Page 15 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 2.1-1
General Location Map
2.2 Coal Demand and Fuel Supply Strategy Kosovo does not have any important fossil fuel resource but is rich in lignite. There is neither natural gas import nor gas supply infrastructure. Kosovo also does not have any oil refinery and depends entirely on imported liquid fuels. The hydroelectric potential is very modest.
Page 16 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Therefore the backbone of the power generation and the energy sector of Kosovo are the lignite fired thermal power plants Kosovo A and Kosovo B located near Pristina. The installed capacities of both existing lignite fired plants are set out in the table below. Gross Power
Net Power
Available Net Power
Start of Operation
[MW]
[MW]
[MW]
Year
Kosovo A
800
722
A1
65
58
30 - 40
1962
A2
125
113
0
1964
A3
200
182
130 - 145
1970
A4
200
182
120 - 145
1971
A5
210
187
135 - 150
1975
Kosovo B
678
618
B1
339
309
230 - 250
1983
B2
339
309
230 - 250
1984
TPP
Tab.: 2.2-1
Installed TPP Capacity (Source KEK)
Due to the low availability and unreliable base load plants KEK needs to import peak power. The increased net imports had to be paid for in cash very often. This led to inadequate supplies and frequent power outages. Real time balancing of the demand and supply is managed partly by exports and imports and partly by planned and rotating load shedding. On the basis of the targets set by the Ministry for Energy and Mining (from 2009 onwards), coal demand figures were defined using following principles and assumptions: -
The geological reserves of the existing mines total about 37.3 mt (mineable). This is calculated from 2006 onward (see report â&#x20AC;&#x153;Mid Term Planâ&#x20AC;?).
-
Kosovo will export energy based on lignite (so it will enter in South East European Regional Market).
-
The grid of the ECSEE will be reinforced to allow power transmission.
Page 17 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Year
Existing Mines
Sibovc SW
Total
2006
6.8
-
6.8
2007
7.2
-
7.2
2008
7.9
-
7.9
2009
7.8
-
7.8
2010
4.6
3.4
8.0
2011
3.0
6.0
9.0
2012
-
9.0
9.0
2013
-
9.0
9.0
2014
-
9.0
9.0
2015
-
9.0
9.0
2016
-
9.0
9.0
2017
-
9.0
9.0
2018
-
9.0
9.0
2019
-
9.0
9.0
2020
-
9.0
9.0
2021
-
9.0
9.0
2022
-
9.0
9.0
2023
-
9.0
9.0
2024
-
6.0
6.0
Total
37.3
123.4
160.7
Tab.: 2.2-2
Coal Demand
Page 18 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3 Description of the Project Type of Project: Subject of the project is the excavation of overburden and lignite in the neighbourhood of existing opencast mines. Excavations will either be performed by diesel driven truck and shovel technologies as well as electrical driven bucket wheel and belt conveyor technologies. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. Location: The Sibovc SW field is situated north of the operating Bardh and Mirash mines. It is near the capital of Kosovo, Pristina, and near to the existing power plant Kosovo B. The field covers an area of approximately 4.8 km² with a maximum mineable width (east-west extension) of 2.3 km and a length of about 2.5 km. The following figure shows the location of the intended mining in the Sibovc SW field as well as the distances to the power plants and surrounding towns of Kastiot, Fushe Kosove and Prishtina.
Fig.: 2.2-1
Location of intended Opencast mine
Page 19 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Need for Project: Kosovo does not have any important fossil fuel resource but it is rich in lignite. There is neither natural gas import nor gas supply infrastructure. Moreover, Kosovo does not have any oil refinery and depends entirely on imported liquid fuels. The hydroelectric potential is very modest. Therefore the backbone of the power generation and the energy sector of Kosovo are the lignite fired thermal power plants Kosovo A and Kosovo B located near Pristina. Because the existing coal mines will be exhausted within the next years a new deposit adequate for stable supply has to be identified and developed to provide the necessary lignite supplies to the existing power plants in Kosovo. Size of Operation: The technical procedure of opening up and developing the mine is described in part one of this report. Excavation will start in the year 2008 leading to following demand for surface area. Demand
Accumulated
2006 - 2010
1.79
1.79
2011-2012
0.39
2.18
2013 - 2017
1.49
3.67
2018 - 2022
1.16
4.83
2023 - 2024
0.18
5.01
Tab.: 2.2-1
Demand of Surface Area [km²]
Opencast mining requires removal of soil, overburden and extraction of the coal seam with a total thickness of up to 80 m. Main mining equipment will consist of eight bucket wheel excavators, connected belt conveyors, spreaders and auxiliary equipment like draglines, dozers and maintenance vehicles. For part of the excavation shovel and truck technologies will be applied. Hence the mined area temporarily will appear as a huge hole with depths of more than 120 m. For detailed information please refer to part mining technologies of this report.
Page 20 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4 Current State of the Environment 4.1 Topography The area is located between the valley of river Sitnica in the east with elevations of about +525 mMSL and a mountain chain extending north to south with elevations exceeding +750 mMSL. To the west follows the valley of the Drenica River with elevations of about +550 mMSL. The future mining field today forms a hilly surface with elevation from typically +570 mMSL to +670 mMSL. Characteristic landmarks are a N-S stretched hill with the village of Hade (up to +656 mMSL) and a range of hills extending in E-W direction between Lajthishte and Shipitulla (up to +666 mMSL). Associated with these hills are valleys following N-S directions east (down to +570 mMSL) and west (down to +550 mMSL) to the village of Hade and the valley of the Sibovc river (about +560 mMSL) in the north following SW-NE directions.
4.2 Atmosphere The Kosova basin is characterized by continental climate with dry and warm summers and indifferent winter temperatures depending on the influence of high-pressure areas from Siberia or low-pressure areas from the Atlantic Ocean. Temperature Average annual temperature is about +10°C. For the years 1979 to 1991 the range of temperatures is shown in the following figure with minimum temperatures in January and maximum in July. Lowest temperature ever measured is –25.2°C.
Fig.: 4.2-1
Variation of monthly mean temperatures
Page 21 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Supplementary information was found at www.qwikcast.com presenting in 2004 a statistical compilation on the basis of eighteen years.
Fig.: 4.2-2
Variation of monthly temperatures
Wind The wind is predominantly blowing from north and northeast with an average velocity near 3 m/s. In 1985, the Rudarski Institute gave an overview on wind velocities and directions shown in the following figure. The greatest wind velocity was recorded at 34.3 m/s blowing from the north.
Fig.: 4.2-3
Direction and velocity of wind (Source Rudarski Institute)
Currently air quality in the Sibovc field is negatively affected by private traffic, private heating and seasonal burning of dry farm land. Main air polluter are the power plants Kosovo A and B in case filter systems are not working properly.
Page 22 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Precipitation Data on precipitation were collected from different sources. The Hydro-Meteorological Institute of Kosovo produced a study in 1999 showing the monthly average for a period of 25 years (25 years average). The Institute provided also monthly values for the years 1979 to 1995. By adding values for the years 2001 to 2004 this data base was widened to cover a period of 25 years (1979 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2004). The data base was completed by an existing evaluation for the period 1948 to 1978. The average annual precipitation amounts to about 600 mm. Minimum precipitation is described by the 1990 data at 372 mm. Using monthly values maximum annual precipitation was recorded at 1010 mm in the year 1995. A higher value of 1028 mm has been presented by the Rudarski Institute (1985) but the year of appearance is lacking in the document. The following figure shows the variation of average monthly precipitation. Statistically precipitation is rather evenly distributed with lower values from January to March and higher values throughout summer and autumn.
Fig.: 4.2-4
Long-term variation of monthly precipitation
The range of monthly precipitation can be described on the basis of values recorded from the years 1979 until 2004. The average monthly precipitation is 56 mm. The following figure shows the range of possible monthly precipitation. For example within the month of August a minimum of 5 mm (year 1992) was recorded versus a maximum of 184 mm (year 2002). The figure also shows that more than 80 mm of precipitation per month are possible all over the year.
Page 23 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.2-5
Average, minimum and maximum monthly precipitation
The variation of daily precipitation values for the years 2001 to 2004 has been made available by the Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosova. High quantities of precipitation were recorded with 44.5 mm on 11 April 2001 and 42.5 mm on 8 August 2002. The absolute maximum recorded was achieved on 5 September 1954 with 64.1 mm (INKOS; 1987).
Fig.: 4.2-6
Daily Precipitation
For assessment of precipitation intensities an older table from the Hydrometeorological Institute of the Republic of Serbia (Belgrade 1990) â&#x20AC;&#x153;Report on climatic conditions and parameters for the region that accommodates the Kosovo coal depositâ&#x20AC;? is quoted below.
Page 24 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
mm
Duration
Repetition (years)
15 min
30 min
1h
2h
8h
16 h
24 h
1 2 5 10 50 100 1000
5.52 12.09 16.5 19.17 25.5 28.29 37.8
4.36 16.12 22.00 25.56 34.00 37.72 50.40
8.65 18.94 25.85 30.00 39.95 44.32 59.22
9.66 21.16 28.88 33.48 44.63 49.50 66.15
12.88 28.21 38.50 44.73 59.50 66.00 88.12
15.64 34.26 46.75 54.32 72.25 80.15 107.10
18.40 40.30 55.00 63.90 85.00 94.30 126.00
m³/(s km²)
Duration
Repetition (years)
15 min
30 min
1h
2h
8h
16 h
24 h
1 2 5 10 50 100 1000
6.13 13.43 18.33 21.33 28.33 31.43 42.00
4.08 8.95 12.22 14.20 18.80 20.95 28.90
2.40 5.26 7.18 8.33 11.10 12.31 16.45
1.34 2.93 4.00 4.65 6.19 6.87 9.18
0.44 0.98 1.34 1.55 2.06 2.29 3.06
0.27 0.59 0.82 0.95 1.25 1.40 1.85
0.22 0.47 0.64 0.74 0.98 1.10 1.45
Tab.: 4.2-1
Intensity of Precipitation at Rainfall Gauging Station Pristina
4.3 Soils A general description of types of soils is given with the “Soil map of SAP Kosovo”, scale 1:50,000 (N. Povicevic et al., Institute for development of water resources, Belgrade; 1974). An update of soil classification on FAO standards was presented by the agricultural faculty of Pristina University allowing the Consultant to redraw the soil map. The following figure shows the situation for the potential mine fields as well as their surroundings. A hard copy of investigations on soil qualities is apparently available in the community of Obiliq. Unfortunately, the community was not able to hand over any information. Therefore the agricultural values of the land can not be presented in this report but, if needed in future, have to be requested again.
Page 25 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.3-1
Soil Map
Page 26 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.4 Surface Waters Run-Offs and their Qualities The Kosova Basin forms a smoothly shaped plain that is bordered by hills and mountains. This basin includes a well developed hydrological network with the main collector being the river Sitnica. This river crosses the basin from south to north and drains about 80 % of the accumulating surface water into northern direction. Major tributary rivers in the vicinity of the site are the river Drenica in the west and the river Lab in the east. The Sitnica run-off varies between a minimum of 0.5 – 1.5 m³/s and a maximum of 50 – 120 m³/s with an average of 5 – 10 m³/s. In flooding periods, the course of the river reaches a width of up to 1000 m in the flooding areas. On 3 May 1958 a maximum run-off for the river Sitnica near to the mines was measured at 90.3 m³/s. Due to the lack of actual run-off data the quantities of water discharged by tributary rivers and creeks can only be assessed on the basis of a map of catchment areas, developed from topographical maps, scale 1:25,000, for this report. The following figure shows the results of delineating catchment areas for different run-offs that might be affected when mining activities will spread to the north, south or east of the existing mines. The colours shown in the figure indicate major catchment areas which are subdivided using numbers, e.g. numbers 310 to 380 representing smaller areas which together feed the run-off directly northwest of Bardh mine.
Fig.: 4.4-1
Catchment Areas
Surface water quality data are available from the INKOS Institute’s monthly measurements for the main catchments, Drenica and Sitnica. The measurements compiled for the years 2001 to 2003 can be taken as baseline data to assess the impact of any future mine drainage.
Page 27 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.4-2
Characteristic Water Quality Values for the River Sitnica
The parameters shown in the figure above are found adequate to represent the up to date quality of river water without effects to the mines. The expected quality of mine drainage water without any treatment can be assessed using the quality parameters from the water pumped out of the Mirash mine. It has to be taken into consideration that the sampling point does not always represent the quality of pumped mine water since dilution by rainwater might have influenced the sample.
Fig.: 4.4-3
Characteristic Mine Water Quality
Page 28 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The table below compares the values of the Sitnica River with those of the Mirash mine. Any river receiving mine water discharge might be affected mainly by sulphate and chloride as well as organic materials, if no purification of mine water is foreseen. With reference to heavy metals or other trace elements no statements are possible to date because analytical data are not available on these parameters. Minimum Units?
Average
Sitnica Mirash Sitnica
pH value
Maximum
Mirash
Sitnica
Mirash
6.8
6.7
7.9
7.8
8.4
8.7
230
175
486
1,381
1,100
3,700
El. Conductivity
µS/cm
Chloride
mg/l
3
4.5
28
90
70
290
Sulphate
mg/l
29
75
78
924
516
1,741
Hydrocarbonate
mg/l
104
232
284
447
381
600
Nitrate
mg/l
0
0
3.7
10.3
14
72
KMnO4 Consumption mg/l
5
3
15
45
26
183
Tab.: 4.4-1
Comparison of Water Qualities
The above concentrations indicate a potential need for mine water treatment depending on the quantity of mine water discharge and the quality and quantity of the receiving stream. Minimum standard to weaken these effects is to install settling ponds to reduce the load of suspended solids and coal dust.
4.5 Hydrogeological Situation The hydrogeological situation of the area is defined by three main hydrogeological layers. The basis is given by an aquiclude formed by the “green clay” consisting of clay and silt with a general thickness of more than 100m. In general, the overlaying lignite having a thickness up to 70m has a low permeability but because of fissures and cracks within the coal groundwater can circulate whereby the coal layer has to be recognized as an aquifer. This fact can be underlined by field observations when wells were observed, which came into being while excavating coal in an elevation clearly above the water level of main drainage sump in Mirash mine. Above the coal follows the overburden mainly consisting of silt and clay with partially appearance of sand and gravel layers. Embedded layers with masses of snail shells are characteristic. Near to the surface this “grey clay” can change its appearance to “yellow clay” what can be explained as a result of weathering with oxidation of the iron content within the material. The clay material generally behaves like an aquifuge but because of fissures and cracks reaching depths of 10 m to 15 m from the surface water can penetrate the rock. Hence groundwater appears either when the fissures are dug up by excavation or where those fissures are connected to better permeable layers within the clay such as the snail shell layers or gravel layers. Following the resulting hydraulic conductivity depends on the locally different appearance of clay and fissures.
Page 29 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The â&#x20AC;&#x153;yellow clayâ&#x20AC;? horizon is frequently used to supply houses and smaller villages with water, e.g. in the village of Hade and in the valley west of Lajthishte. Due to the lack of decent borehole descriptions an overall differentiation in the overburden clay between the yellow and grey clay was not possible on that way. This effects as well the spatial hydrogeological differentiation. Information about the spreading of yellow clay strata can be given using a map presented by Rudarski Institut (1985) which shows the elevation of the bottom of yellow clay for the area west of Hade village. The map gives an impression about the altitude of the basis of yellow clay. The bottom generally follows the surface with the alteration zone reaching down to 12 m depth. This again pleads for weathered grey clay with the precipitation leading to oxidization of the iron content within the soil forming the typical yellow colour. The elaboration furthermore shows that at least in September 1985 a groundwater level was observable with groundwater covering up to 10 m of the yellow clay. It can be suggested that these facts can be found in other areas as well, where Pliocene clay reaches near the surface. The observed water levels and the alteration in colour from grey to yellow indicate that this groundwater horizon is directly fed by precipitation and it is assessed that groundwater predominately circulates near the surface.
Page 30 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.5-1
Bottom of yellow Clay (Redrawn from Rudarski Institut)
Recent measurements on the quantity of groundwater and flow directions as well as expressive maps of the groundwater table are not available. Reviewing of older documents and field observations shows that the quantity of groundwater descending the overburden at the mines is rather small. At the slopes groundwater can be observed after rainy periods favoured in coarse layers of the “yellow clay” and, along fissures, within the “grey clay”. Additional vadose water horizons can appear within courser layers of the grey clay especially where it contains larger amounts of snail shells. Locally the overburden is eroded to a thickness of meters or less and as abandoned underground works with broken roofs give direct
Page 31 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
access to the surface, precipitation can directly infiltrate the coal in larger areas whereby larger quantities of groundwater might be produced. Utilization of groundwater concentrates on private wells dug to depth of 10 to 15 m below the surface within the overburden clay. Production quantities are shown by Rudaski Institute (1985) with Q = 3 l/min to Q = 11 l/min with a maximum of Q = 54 l/min, which can be judged as hydraulic conductivities in a range of kf = 10-9 m/sec to kf = 10-6 m/sec. Field observations in the surroundings of Laitishte showed artificial wells, drilled some 5 m to 7 m deep into the â&#x20AC;&#x153;yellow clayâ&#x20AC;?, to serve as water supply for a village. Inhabitants described the wells rather unproductive but sufficient for private purpose. The quaternary deposits along the river Sitnica consist of coarser materials with sand and gravel contents. Resulting the hydraulic conductivity can reach values up to kf = 10-4 m/sec or even greater. Towards the depth these sediments hold growing contents of silt and clay and are underlain by grey clay preventing a direct contact between the surface water and the coal seam. Because of the hydraulic properties of the clay and the topsoil developed to a Vertisol (Smonitza) in case of rainfall an enriched surface run-off can be expected. To allow first assessments a run-off coefficient of 0.45 is chosen by Consultant. The hydrogeological situation at the surface is presented by Rudarski Institut in 1996. The map shows in brownish colour elevated and hilly plains with minor or no groundwater content as well as in blue colours the valleys of the rivers with enriched groundwater occurrence.
Fig.: 4.5-2
Complemented Extract from Hydrogeological Map
Page 32 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
4.6 Noteworthy Side Issues Former Underground Mining Remains of old underground mining are situated in the south-eastern part of the Sibovc field, connected with the old mining structures which are currently exposed along the coal cuts in Mirash West and on the Mirash northern slope, and underneath the ash dump of TPP Kosovo A (Field D). Some of the old galleries have already been cut within Mirash mine and the pillar area (see following figures). First attempts to reach the coal seam were made along river erosion channels which cut the seam. In areas of the seam which were affected by erosion it can be mixed completely or at least in part with humus strata resulting in a decrease of coal quality. Therefore, the initial excavation of the adits began about 7 meters under the roof of the seam. In the proximity of the riverbanks water handling was difficult. At a later stage vertical shafts were deepened. The documented coal mining using galleries and shafts reaches back to 1921. For the stabilisation of the galleries with a height of 2 m and width of 3 m a timber support system was used. The galleries were placed in parallel and at distances of 20 m to each other, every 100 m a cross cut was excavated which mainly followed the given directions of the separations planes. The old roadways were driven parallel to the joint system within the mine. The galleries were widened to caverns at intervals of 7-20 m and the coal was broken from the roof. In the area west of the overburden dump, in the D-Field, these caverns frequently collapsed forming more or less round craters, which show a regular alignment (see figure).
Fig.: 4.6-1
Former Underground Mining in Field D
Aerial photography showing the area of the D-Field with regularly aligned collapse structures (more or less round holes) in consequence of former underground mining. The highlighted area indicates zones with still stable galleries.
Page 33 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 4.6-2
Gallery of an old Underground Mine with wooden Support System
Due to this method sections of galleries show a low stability and there is a potential danger of collapse of undermined levels under load if the galleries are not already collapsed or refilled. The dimension of the undermined area has been assessed considering the following factors: -
Calculation of the excavated coal between 1922 to 1966
-
Existing underground mining maps of Mirash mine
-
Position of old shafts
-
Mapping of the outcrops of the gallery system and acquisition of data (gallery width, distance e.g.)
-
Site Visits for a specific delimitation of the underground mines
-
Determination of the mining methods by means of the characteristics of cut and exposed galleries
-
Interpretation of aerial photographs for typical structures
-
Interpretation of seismic investigations
-
Analysis of fault pattern
-
Analysis of topographic elements and natural boundaries (old bed of the river Sitnica, location of villages)
-
Extension regarding the maximum practicable distance between shafts and galleries
Page 34 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The underground mining method was abandoned in 1966. The following table shows the overall coal production of the underground mines. However, there is no reliable documentation on the extension of the old underground mines or the information is at least incomplete. Coal production of old underground mining in the Kosovo Basin (Source: KEK) "Kosovo"
"Krusevac"
"Sibovac"
Years 1922 – 1966
Years 1948 - 1966
Years 1952-1958
6.401.434 t
2.921.233 t
255.117 t
Tab.: 4.6-1
Underground Coal Production
Partially, the exploitation fields of the old underground mining were limited by faults. Considering the total production yields an area of app. 5 km² for the “Kosovo” mine field and an area of app. 5 km² for the “Sibovac” mine field. The minor production rates from the field “Sibovac” demonstrate that the excavation only took place close to the surface.
Fig.: 4.6-3
Underground Mining Structures in the Mirash Mine
In the past inhabitants noticed noises from the underground (hammering, picking) about 2 km to the North of Hade. Nearby there was at least one shaft, which could have functioned as entrance to the underground mine system. This shaft supports the presumption of such a large
Page 35 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
extension. The reports revealed that the extension of the old underground structures may be larger than supposed. The largest distance between a shaft and the outermost galleries did not exceed 700 meters. Uncontrolled Coal Fires Within a wide area a large amount of lignite is affected by spontaneous combustion which occurs in the mine slope and coal yards, where coal is exposed to air. Self-ignition is the consequence of the oxidation of coal, a process which is producing heat energy. If the energy production exceeds the amount of energy removed from the system, the coal will reach its ignition temperature, eventually. Generally these fires occur at places where the coal is exposed to air or air can penetrate the underground and reach the coal. In the Bardh-Mirash mine areas these fires especially affect the structures of the old underground mines, slide areas, the central pillar in front of the face between the actual excavation areas, the N and S lateral slopes of the mine as well as parts of the mine which remain exposed to air for a longer period (slopes and dumps), fault and joints. In a first phase coal fires ignite in mechanically weak zones like joints or slope failures or old mining structures, where enough oxygen can reach the surface of the coal and the heat is enclosed. The fire can be boosted by methane. In the following stage the complete hanging layer is influenced by the heat. About 60% of total coal fires are concentrated near or within the roof strata, where the coal shows the best quality and discharges a great amount of energy. Old galleries from the ancient underground coal mines facilitate supplementary ventilation and therefore provide for best conditions for oxygen inflow. Burnt-out galleries result in large cavities and therefore a decreasing stability of the slopes. A lot of fires in the Bardh Mine occurred in slide faults, therefore it is essential to avoid land slides. Self combustion also occurs in dumped coal masses. Typically, the coal fires begin at the base of the dumps and affect the whole dump until it is burnt out. A secondary effect is the formation of clinker from the clay in the seam roof. Due to the heat the material becomes dehydrated and oxidised and takes a red colour (see next figure). The characteristics (hardness) of the clinker allow utilization as gravel to improve the stability of transport roads within the mine. In case remains of the old underground mines directly reach the Sibovc SW Mine or connections by open fissures exist, a considerable risk of coal fires remains.
Fig.: 4.6-4
Coal Fire at Base of Dump and near a Fault with burn out Zones
Page 36 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Phenol Deposits The data inquiry on potential environmental risks has given some indications on old neglected deposits of liquid wastes containing phenol. These materials probably result from an abandoned gasification plant at TPP Kosovo A, where remnants of this waste are still stored today. In August 2004 two shafts of old underground workings at the Mirash workshop were opened. A specific chemical smell and some lumps similar to tar were observed at the rim of one shaft. Workers at the mine explained to have observed these liquids in the past at the northern slope, where the slope cuts into underground workings. Further investigations on the spatial spreading and the quantity of waste dumped led to no reliable results up to now. Interviewing neighbouring residents and former workers helped to form a first idea. Two former underground workings might be affected: the “Kosovo” field underneath the valley between the Mirash mine and Lajthishte and the “Krusevac” field south of TPP Kosovo A. As no maps are available showing the extension of the former mines a first demarcation was carried out using aerial views, field observations on collapse structures and interviews. The result is shown in following figure.
Fig.: 4.6-5
Areas of potential Risk of toxic Waste Deposits
Because up to now it is unknown, -
which chemicals really constitute the original waste and if the contents is similar to the stored remnants,
-
which alterations happened to the waste and
Page 37 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
what quantities of original or altered materials are deposited in the underground workings,
potential risks are given when the coal is excavated (protection of miners and water) and burnt in a TPP (conglutination of equipment, generation of hazardous gases such as dioxins).
Page 38 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5 Alternatives The backbone of the power generation and the energy sector of Kosovo are the lignite fired thermal power plants Kosovo A and Kosovo B located near Pristina. To mitigate the unavoidable environmental impact and to avoid long transportation distances any new lignite exploitation should be realized as close as possible to the existing mines and power plants. Sufficient coal resources are available in the neighbourhood of the existing mines where environmental intervention already exists. For these reasons exploitation outside the wider surroundings of the existing mines does not form an alternative.
5.1 Overview of Potential Future Mining Fields The parts of the coal deposit with the most favourable mining conditions are west of Pristina, where also the Mirash and Bardh mines were opened-up. The overburden : coal ratio is here approximately 1:1, i.e. to mine 1 t of lignite 1 m続 of overburden has to be removed. On an international scale this ratio is extremely favourable. The following three potential fields are considered for further examination to choose the most effective opencast mine field (also see following figure): -
Field Sibovc with subfield Sibovc Southwest
-
Field D
-
Field South
Page 39 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 5.1-1
Potential Mining Fields
5.2 Description of Alternative Mining Fields Having in mind that the whole district is historically influenced by mining and wider parts of the landscape are determined by the mines and power plants all variants discussed are judged to be feasible, if appropriate actions are taken to mitigate the impacts. Field Sibovc Location: The Sibovc Field is situated to the North of the Bardh and Mirash mines. So it is near the capital of Kosovo â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Pristina and near to the existing power plant Kosovo B. The field area covers approximately 16 million m² with a maximum mineable width (EastWest extension) of 3.8 km and a length of about 6 km. Area use:
Page 40 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The area of the Sibovc field is mainly used for agriculture. For a long time it has been known that this lignite field is envisaged for excavation. Therefore, the people living in this area are prepared for mining activities. Previous plans included the mining from South to North whereby it was intended to develop the field from the existing pit rim of the Bardh/Mirash mines. Small private coal openings exist which are used for local fuel supply. Residential areas: The mining field is sparsely populated with the main villages being Hade, Sibovc and Lajthisht. The village of Shipitula is for the most part outside the field to be mined. The resettlement required for the before mentioned villages is the major obstacle for the exploitation. There are no other restrictions for the coal mining. Field Sibovc Southwest Location: The Sibovc Southwest Field forms a part of the larger Sibovc field. It covers some 4.8 km². The field neighbours the existing mines in the northwest and stretches some 2.6 km to the north. Area use: The area is mainly used for agriculture. The Shipitulla overburden dump covers some 56 ha in the very southwest. This dump holds a military used shooting range. Residential areas: The mining field is sparsely populated and contains only minor settlements or detached houses. Field D Location: Field D lies next to the power plant TPP Kosovo A and ca. 5.5 km away (straight line) from the power plant B. In the West it borders the village of Dardhisht and in the South the village of Fushe Kosove including infrastructure like road and railway line. The area within the mine configuration covers 6.7 million m². Area use: Already in the past coal was extracted on the territory of Field D. The major part was mined underground. For example, 2.9 mt of coal were mined at “Krusevac” mine between 1948 and 1966. At present, a considerable part of the area is used by KEK as ash disposal site. Furthermore, masses from developing the Mirash mine were deposited on this area. The dumped material is placed on “Ash Dump Dragodan” with approx. 1.52 million m² and “Overburden Dump Dragodan“ with approx. 0.69 million m².
Page 41 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The old dumps would need to be recovered prior to the excavation of the deposit. Residential areas: There are only few houses on coal Field D. Field South Location: The South Field directly borders the existing Bardh and Mirash opencast mines in the south. Two variants of exploiting the field were examined with the mine boundary being formed by the village of Bardh to the west and to the east by the Sitnica River. The area covers more than 11 million m². Area use: Most of the area is owned by KEK and covered by dumped overburden masses. These dumps comprise a total volume of 90 to 110 million m³ (slope angle ca. 6°) in an entire area of 5.5 million m² and an average dumping height of 20 to 30 m. Residential areas: Resettlement of the villages of Lismir and Kuzmin is required. There are no other buildings with relevant influence.
5.3 Alternatives of Opening-up and Mine Development for the Sibovc Field To find the optimum way to exploit the coal six general scenarios were developed. For a single mine development two main variants are comparable: -
Variant 1
Mining Sibovc from South to North
-
Variant 2
Mining Sibovc from North to South
In addition possibilities of developing two mines in the field were assessed and evaluated: -
Variant 3.1
Parallel mine development in Sibovc (South) and Sibovc (middle)
-
Variant 3.2
Parallel mine development in Sibovc (South) and Sibovc (North)
-
Variant 4 Parallel mine development of two mines along a South-North demarcation line.
For further details refer to “Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine”, June 24, 2005. With the decision to concentrate on supplying the existing power plants a possibility is given to develop a smaller mine in the field. With respect to minimizing resettlement and optimizing the opening-up process by using the existing mines the variant of “Sibovc Southwest Mine” was developed.
Page 42 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5.4 Environmental Aspects of Mining Fields Alternatives Resettlements The opening of a field in all cases will mean that resettlement of inhabitants is needed. By now it is assessed that in the case of the total Sibovc field the highest number of residents from at least three villages and nine settlements would be affected. Field South covers two villages and one settlement, whereas the Field D impacts a portion of one settlement as well as some detached houses. Sibovc Variant 1 forms an extension of the existing mines, where the excavation moves forward to the north. For neighbouring inhabitants this might be felt like an ongoing process deriving from the known mining activities. The population of the village of Hade would have to be resettled prior to the start of mining activities. Major resettlements would follow towards the middle of the lifetime of the mine involving the villages of Sibovc and Lajthishte. Sibovc Variant 2 opens a new mine developing to the south. Hence erecting all infrastructures needed and opening the mine means an intervention to a hitherto almost unaffected area. Resettlement of the villages of Sibovc and Lajthisht would be needed at an early stage of activities whereas the village of Hade, presently impacted by current mining activities, would need to be resettled finally toward the end of mining activities. Sibovc Variants 3.1 and 3.2 are intensifications of the effects shown in variants 1 and 2. As two mines are working in parallel the residents would be affected to a more intensive degree especially with reference to dust and noise. Also loss of farmland would happen earlier. Resettlements of the villages of Hade, Sibovc and Lajthisht would be needed practically at the same time prior to or at least in a very early stage of mine development. On the other hand these variants offer the opportunity to employ more local personnel as two independent mines are operating with their full facilities. Sibovc Variant 4 causes nearly the same effects as variants 3.1 and 3.2 but in addition road traffic would be hampered north of the village of Hade after short time of operation. Developing Field D requires an earlier partial resettlement affecting the east of Dardhisht village. The connecting road Krushec â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Nakarade / Fushe Kosove would form the western rim of the mine. Hence the remaining inhabitants of Krushec would be affected mostly in the starting phase of mining. Along with the progressive extension of the mine a few additional resettlements of detached houses would be required towards the end of the lifetime of the mine. Opening the Field South would force resettlement of the villages of Doberdup (Dobri Dub) and Kuzmin as well as new housing estates east of river Sitnica. It has to be taken into account, that the village of Doberdup is already affected by creeping outside dump masses which up to now have been declared not to present any urgent threat. Effects on humans may result from the necessary relocation of the river Sitnica to the east. As only a small corridor remains between the rim of the mine and the railroad track at Fushe Kosove, special flood prevention measures would have to be implemented leading to an enlarged surface requirement at the populated outskirts of Fushe Kosove. Local Roads and Transportation In the areas of potential mining fields the roads from Grabovc to Obiliq and Sibovc to Obiliq represent routes of major importance for regional transportation. Both roads lead through the Sibovc field and would have to be abandoned during the course of mining. The difference for Page 43 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Sibovc variants can only be seen in the difference in time when abandoning becomes necessary. Field D as well as Field South would impact no roads of regional importance. Water and Air Emissions to water and air mainly depend on the size of the open mine. In Sibovc Variants 1 and 2, Field D as well as Field South only one mine is working while in Sibovc Variants 3 and 4 there are two mines working parallel in time. For the latter variants this will lead to increased dust emissions from enlarged and enforced excavation and conveying activities. As self ignited lignite burnings should be prevented at any new mining field there should be no specific differences between the alternatives even though self ignition might not be generally excluded. Effects on waters result from the necessary mine drainage and sewage from mine facilities and offices. In case of field Sibovc excavation is performed in rather watertight materials. Hence the quantities of water depend mainly on the precipitation. In Field D as well as Field South it is expected that leaking surface water and groundwater from river Sitnica will decisively contribute to the quantities to be discharged. From the hydrogeological point of view a first differentiation is possible for the potential mining fields. The field Sibovc is nearly wholly located in less water bearing overburden. Besides some minor waters the Sibovc River in the north of the field has to be diverted in an adequate way in case of enlarged exploitation of the field. In the valley of Sibovc river artesian groundwater outflow was observed in harvest of 2004. Hence beside a well prepared diversion of the river additional drainage will be needed for the alluvial sediments in the valley. Furthermore protective measures must be foreseen were the alluvial sediments of Sibovc River joining the alluvial sediments along river Sitnica near the village of Hamidija. It is assessed that at least an apron cutting through the permeable sediments and a dam will be needed to prevent water inflow from the river Sitnica. In case of Sibovc SW field operations will be associated only with less water bearing overburden. The fields D and South reach the river valleys where enlarged groundwater inflow is expected. Especially the Field South will be excavated along the river Sitnica with diversion of the river needed and opening up the rim of the mine for more than 3 km parallel to the river. Hence intensified leakage from the river to the mine will be created and adequate measures have to be implemented to protect the mine in times of floods as half of the width of inundation area will be lost. Flora, Fauna, Natural Heritage The three areas of concern contain different types of ecological habitats. The field Sibovc is characterised by extensive and busy agricultural use. Areas unaffected by humans are rather seldom. Hence useful plant varieties prevail in the floral scene. A reasonable diversity of floral elements is expected as a result of temporarily unused or fallow land as well as existing minor bush or wooded areas and small creeks dividing the landscape. The Field South is covered by overburden dumps to about 50 % of its total area. This dumping area is to a large extent out of use for a number of years providing grounds for natural succession of flora and fauna resulting in a variety of small scaled habitats. Some areas mainly at the rims of the dumps are used for agricultural purposes. The southern part of the Field South is characterised by the valleys of the rivers Sitnica and Drenica and mainly used
Page 44 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
for agriculture. Hence the Field South entails a wide range of habitats from wetlands to dry locations varying at small scale. Field D is characterised by the Dragodan ash dump (TPP A). As the surrounding is mainly used for agricultural purposes there is no extensive bush, copse or tree occurrence and the biological diversity is judged rather poor compared to the other alternatives. Information on locations to be looked upon as Natural Heritage was given by the Institute for Nature and Environmental Protection of Kosovo. Following a report from October 2003 following locations have to be named. All locations are situated within or near to the Sibovc field: -
A spring in the middle of Palaj village (internal coordinates x 0504565, y 4724469)
-
One tree (Tilia sp.) , some 200 years old, in the settlement “Nicakeve” near Sibovc (internal coordinates x 0499173, y 4725381)
-
A group of trees (3x Quercus sp., 1x Quercus cerris), aged up to 300 years, in the settlement of “Megjuaneve” near Sibovc (internal coordinates x 0500846, y 4725051)
Soil, Natural Resources and Land Use As shown in the chapter “Current state of the Environment – Soils” the alternatives differ in their general soil appearance. Field Sibovc is characterised by clayey materials in a hilly shaped landscape forming a typical Smonitza (Vertisol) soil. This soil is rather difficult to cultivate because of soil compression and enriched surface water run off in wet periods as well as deep reaching drying up in the summer time. Nevertheless the soil is described fertile but additional information has to be inquired. Field South holds a large area of spread soil materials where a top soil development similar to the development outside the dumps is visible. The soil is not as compact as the naturally grown soil, which results in better hydraulic conductivities and intensive biological scarifying of the top soil. The slopes of the dumps are slowly creeping downhill and thereby cover the grown soil. No pollutants have been reported as being part of the soil dumps. Hence it is judged that an ongoing and nearly unhampered agricultural use south to the dumps will be possible in the future. Deposits of soil and especially ash determine the surface of Field D. The fly ash from the dumping site influences the surroundings up to some hundred meters distance. This mainly affects the usability of the farmland but no information is available by now concerning e.g. the heavy metal or trace element contents of the ash. Micro-Climate Opening a surface mining field causes a depression in the surface. All alternatives of excavation will lead to a loss of elevated elements on the surface which will result in local changes of wind direction and wind speed. As the mines will be artificially dewatered a change in evaporation rates will result which, in combination with the decrease in floral coverage, is assessed to lead to a decrease of evapotranspiration rates. The influences for the three different fields are judged to be rather similar but detailed assessments will only be possible after conducting extensive measurements and computing models for different climatic scenarios.
Page 45 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Phenol Deposits Because up to now it is unknown, -
which chemicals really constitute the original waste and if the contents is similar to the stored remnants,
-
which alterations happened to the waste and
-
what quantities of original or altered materials are buried in the underground workings,
this problem forms a potential risk when coal exploitation takes place in the south-eastern part of Sibovc field as well as within the Field D.
5.5 Valuation of the Mining Fields Valuation Sibovc Field: The Sibovc field has large coal content and is characterised by favourable deposit condition. The lignite is of high quality and the excavation is only affected by recovery of old dump material in its south western part. Another advantage of this field is the moderate transport distance to the power plant. The mining of the lignite field of Sibovc offers the best possibility to supply coal to the power plants. In total the Sibovc field can provide coal for a 2,000 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2,500 MW power plant capacity. Developing the Sibovc field from the South has the best potential of all scenarios to fill the Bardh and Mirash pits with overburden masses. Only a part of the Sibovc field is needed to supply the existing power plants until 2025. Works can be optimized by starting exploitation from existing mine slopes and using the existing infrastructure. The exploitation of the whole deposit requires considerable resettlements. Concentrating mining activities on the southwest of the field will minimize the number of resettlements needed. Opening-up Sibovc field in any variation mainly affects agricultural used land. Connecting the Sibovc field with the existing mines requires disconnecting the road from Bardh to Kastriot. Individual travelling times will increase and social contacts between the inhabitants can be hindered. As the overburden mainly consists of clay, bearing smaller quantities of groundwater, and connections to larger surface waters do not exist the effect on surface waters as well as the groundwater is assessed low. To supply the existing power plants the variant of exploiting the Sibovc Southwest field shows the minimum affects. Valuation of Field D: Field D is characterised by the low overburden thickness and the good overburden : coal ratio. The average heating value is by 12 % lower and the field is covered by old dump masses and ash dumps. The previous dumping of ash did not correspond to the standards and guidelines Page 46 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
of the EU. It has to be assumed that this dump should be either recovered or at least provided with an adequate cover. In case the old dumps are removed, the remaining overburden : coal ration will only amount to 0.72 to 1.0 m続/t. As only individual households are to be resettled this alternative is the most favourable. In terms of changes in air quality this alternative can only be assessed when the relocation of the existing ash dump is taken into account. The large scale dust emission from the dump will come to an end. Compared to that, the dust production deriving from exploitation works can be assessed to be considerably less. With respect to the geographical and geological conditions the mine will be located in the valley of river Sitnica with courser sediments possibly causing an enlarged inflow of groundwater and surface water in times of flooding. With regard to future land use it is possible to establish an attractive lake for recreation at reasonable costs not far away from Pristina (15 minutes). In terms of sustainable development the Field D offers the best post mining use of the land. The environmental liability of the ash dump is eliminated and a recreational area can be established. The field is able to supply the power plants until end of their lifetimes. If the costs for relocating the ash disposal from its current location into the old workings of Mirash are covered by a third party, mining costs are expected to be lower in comparison to the other mining fields. This alternative would still be favourable even considering the lower average heating value. Valuation of Field South The main pecuniary benefit of the field South is the fact that most of the areas are already property of KEK. Increased volumes of overburden have to be removed as the seam dips to the south and dumped overburden masses are to be re-excavated. Another disadvantage of the South field is the increasing transport distance to the power plants TPP A und TPP B. The mine has to be secured against water inflow from the river Sitnica. The resettlement of two whole villages forms an expressive social impact. As the opening-up of the mine can use the existing mine openings additional unfavourable effects in case of water, air and noise are assessed to be minimized. Mining of the field South is the most expensive variant due to the unfavourable geological conditions, especially the relatively high overburden : coal ratio. It should therefore be postponed.
Page 47 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
5.6 Environmental Ranking of Alternatives Combining the environmental aspects mentioned in this report a matrix is presented below offering a relative ranking of the variants in a qualitative manner on a scale from 1 to 8. The increase in number reflects the intensity of the environmental impact. No attempt was made to weigh the various environmental criteria. Variant
Sibovc
Field
Field
Effect
1
2
3.1
3.2
4
SW
D
South
Resettlement
4
5
7
6
8
2
1
3
Local Roads and Transportation
4
5
7
6
8
3
1
2
Water and Air
2
3
5
4
6
1
8
7
Flora, Fauna, natural Heritage
3
4
7
6
5
2
1
8
Soil, Natural Resources and Land Use
4
5
8
7
6
3
1
2
Sum
17
22
34
29
33
11
12
22
Tab.: 5.6-1
Valuation of Mining Fields
The comparison shows that opening-up the Sibovc Southwest field as well as the exploitation of the Field D will cause the smallest effects on the main environmental issues. From the environmental point of view opening the field Sibovc with one mine should be given the preference rather than working with two mines. In the light of the complementary mining plan the development of the Sibovc SW field from south to north as a section of variant 1 forms a mitigation of impacts. Using the field South appears to be less favourable because of the fauna and flora developed and adjusted already and the need of diverting and channelling the river Sitnica.
Page 48 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6 Environmental Aspects of the Sibovc SW Project The comparison of alternatives shows Field D south of TPP Kosovo A to be the most favourable new mining area from the environmental point of view. After presentation of the Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine and in the light of the current development in Kosovo decision was made by the main beneficiary to develop the Sibovc Southwest field (part of former â&#x20AC;&#x153;New Sibovc Mineâ&#x20AC;?) as best fit to its future energy demand strategy. On the basis of this decision and the goals of the Kosovo Government (Ministry for Energy and Mining) a Complementary Mine Plan was developed, which roughly corresponds to variant 1. As this Complementary Mine Plan comprises a development from South to North in a minor area than shown in variant 1 the environmental friendliest way was chosen to exploit the Sibovc field. The future area under construction is shown in the following figure.
Fig.: 5.6-1
Area of the Complementary Mine Plan
Page 49 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6.1 Soil Investigations on the qualities of soils came to the conclusion that most expressive information is given by â&#x20AC;&#x153;Soil map of SAP Kosovoâ&#x20AC;?, scale 1:50,000 (N. Povicevic et al., Institute for development of water resources, Belgrade; 1974). An update of the soil classification based on FAO standards was presented by the agricultural faculty of Pristina University allowing the Consultant to redraw the soil map. The following figure shows the situation for the planned mining field including a border area of 1 km width.
Fig.: 6.1-1
Distribution of Soils
Within the future mine Vertisol soil types predominate, covering nearly 100 % of the area. Only some 0.4 ha at the outer north-western edge can reach reddish sediments at the geological rim of the coal basin.
Page 50 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Following the â&#x20AC;&#x153;Lecture Notes on the Major Soils of the Worldâ&#x20AC;? (FAO; 2001) Vertisols are churning heavy clay soils with a high portion of swelling 2:1 lattice clays. Parent materials can be sediments that contain a high content in smectitic clay. The environmental conditions that lead to the formation of a vertic soil structure are also conducive to the formation of suitable parent materials: -
Rainfall must be sufficient to enable weathering but not so high that leaching of basic components occurs.
-
Dry periods must allow crystallization of clay minerals that form as weathering products of rock or sediments.
-
Drainage must be hampered to the extent that leaching and loss of weathering products are limited.
-
High temperatures, finally, promote weathering processes. Under such conditions smectite clays can be formed in the presence of silica and basic cations - especially Ca2+ and Mg2+ - if the pH of the soil is above neutral.
Vertisols with strong pedoturbation have a uniform particle size distribution throughout the solum but texture may change sharply where the substratum is reached. Dry Vertisols have a very hard consistence; wet Vertisols are (very) plastic and sticky. It is generally true that Vertisols are friable only over a narrow moisture range but their physical properties are greatly influenced by soluble salts and/or adsorbed sodium. The combined processes of rock weathering, breakdown of primary minerals and formation of secondary minerals, and transport of soil components produce the typical catenary differentiation with yellow or reddish, well-drained soils on higher positions, and black, poorly drained soils in depressions. These soils form deep wide cracks from the surface downward when they dry out, which happens in most years. Infiltration of water in dry (cracked) Vertisols with surface mulch or a fine tilt is initially rapid. However, once the surface soil is thoroughly wetted and cracks have closed, the rate of water infiltration becomes almost zero. (The very process of swell/shrink implies that pores are discontinuous and non-permanent.) If, at this stage, the rains continue (or irrigation is prolonged), Vertisols flood readily. The highest infiltration rates are measured on Vertisols that have a considerable shrink/swell capacity, but maintain a relatively fine class of structure. Not only the cracks transmit water from the (first) rains but also the open spaces between slickensided ped surfaces that developed as the peds shrunk. The combined processes of rock weathering, breakdown of primary minerals and formation of secondary minerals, and transport of soil components produce the typical catenary differentiation with yellow or reddish, well-drained soils on higher positions, and black, poorly drained soils in depressions. Data on the water holding capacity of Vertisols vary widely, which may be attributed to the complex pore space dynamics. Water is adsorbed at the clay surfaces and retained between crystal lattice layers. By and large, Vertisols are soils with good water holding properties. However, a large portion of all water in Vertisols, and notably the water held between the basic crystal units, is not available to plants. The soil's moisture content decreases gradually from more than 50 percent in the upper 20 cm layer to 30 percent at 50 cm depth. Below 100 cm, the soil moisture content remains almost invariant throughout the year. Tillage is difficult, except for a short period at the transition between the wet and dry seasons. Vertisols are productive soils if properly managed.
Page 51 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The valley south to Lajthishte is characterized by Pseudogley. (This expression is no longer in use at FAO´s nomenclature, where they are characterized as Planosols). Deriving from clayey alluvial and colluvial deposits the valley forms a seasonally wet area with light forest and grass vegetation. It has to be marked that this valley was subject to underground coal mining with shallow clay overburden what obviously resulted in groundwater lowering inside the coal seam. Backwater can slowly leach through the meagre, low permeable overburden clay leading to a accelerated drying after precipitation compared to the Vertisol soil.
6.2 Surface Waters The Sibovc SW field affects four catchment areas of minor surface watercourses. Besides the Bardh mine catchment area (1002) especially the water course in the valley west of Hade (No 310 - 380 in the figure below) and the water course from the village of Shipitulle to Drenica river (No 510-520 in fig below) are covered. These run-offs are not perennial. They depend directly on the intensity of precipitation and mainly function as surface drainages. Flow measurements for the above mentioned tributaries to the river Sitnica are not available. The catchment area 310-380 will be nearly totally excavated and has to be integrated to the future mine drainage system. Since the areas 440 as well as 510 discharge outward only the excavated parts need to be integrated into the drainage system.
Fig.: 6.2-1
Surface Waters and Catchment Areas
Page 52 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6.3 Groundwater Predominant part of the mining area is covered by grey clay which appears as yellow clay when it is weathered near to the surface. As groundwater monitoring wells do not exist in the regional groundwater situation is described using older information and analogous conclusions from the existing mines. Occurrence of groundwater directly depends on the intensity of precipitation. The groundwater flow generally follows the morphology in downhill direction with the main groundwater flow within the weathered loamy materials close to the surface. This upper groundwater horizon is estimated to reach some 10 m to 15 m beneath the surface. Sandy layers at different positions within the overburden clay contain groundwater either fed directly by precipitation in case they crop out to the surface or are fed by leakage through cracks in the overlying clay. As those sandy layers are typically limited in extension they do not considerably contribute to the groundwater flow and, if at all, could only be used as a minor water supply source. The general situation is shown in the map below, prepared by the Rudarski Institut (1996). The bold arrow in the map shows the expected main groundwater flow direction within the coal, the thinner arrows indicate the flow directions within the overburden clay. This map confirms the assessment, that the groundwater flow within the overburden clay is dominated by the morphological situation. The poor presence of groundwater in the overburden clay is also represented by the surface run-offs falling dry throughout the summer. The Sibovc SW field has no contact to major aquifers. Also no negative effects can be expected from neighbouring rivers as the distance between the mine and the river Drenica is assessed large enough. Within the coal seam groundwater mainly flows along cracks and fissures. Coal crops out especially in the valley of the Sibovc River in the north of the field and could provide for some recharge area. Existing mines in the south drain the coal layer. As the pumping rates of the mines do not allow detailed assessment of the quantities of groundwater drained, no direct assessment on the quantities of groundwater flow is possible. It is judged that only minor quantities of groundwater migrate within the coal seam.
Page 53 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 6.3-1
Complemented Extract from the Hydrological Map, Rudarski Institut
6.4 Ecological Resources The Sibovc SW field is characterised by extensive agricultural use. Areas unaffected by humans are rather seldom. Useful plant varieties prevail in the floral scene. The area holds no wood, only shrubbery with singe smaller trees enriches the view. This kind of land use can be followed through the landscape far to the north between the river Sitnica in the east and the mountains in the west. A reasonable diversity of floral elements is expected in the region with an increasing variation near the mountains and the river shore. The variety is supported by
Page 54 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
temporarily unused or fallow land, minor bushes or wooded areas as well as small creeks dividing the landscape. Detailed information on the floral and faunistic population as well as a specific catalogue of endangered species could not be procured from authorities or the University of Pristina. Some older documents are available but their description of the situation is not adequate to form a basis for any meaningful assessment. The Institute for Nature and Environmental Protection of Kosova provided some information on locations to be looked upon as Natural Heritage. Based on a report from October 2003 following locations, situated within or near the Sibovc field, have to be named: -
a spring in the middle of Palaj village (internal coordinates x 0504565, y 4724469);
-
one tree (Tillia sp.), some 200 years old, in the settlement “Nicakeve” near Sibovc (internal coordinates x 0499173, y 4725381);
-
a group of trees (3x Quercus sp., 1x Quercus cerris), aged up to 300 years, in the settlement of “Megjuaneve” near Sibovc (internal coordinates x 0500846, y 4725051).
6.5 Economic Development The Sibovc field has been heralded for a long time to become a mining area. Previous plans already included the mine development from south to north. Accordingly, agricultural use continues to dominate the area and no industrial sites but the operating mines exist. The economic development was not totally adapted to this as house building activities are going on and seem not to be prohibited. Power transmission lines of regional importance do not cross the planned mining field. Local power lines will have to be cut nearly the same time the connected dwellings and settlements will need to be torn down prior to excavation. The total Sibovc field contains a geological reserve of ca. 990 mt and covers an area of 19.7 km². To meet the demand for run-off-mine coal at an amount of 123 mt, the area claimed for mining as Sibovc SW field will extend to some 4.8 km² within the period until 2024 (see following table). The Sibovc field, combined with the other potential mining fields, forms the basis for a long term economic development in this region. Period
land Use
Thereof occupied land
thereof farmland
ha
ha
ha
2006-2010
74
1.75
72.25
2011-2012
22
2013-2017
94
1.45
92.55
2018-2022
122
2.05
119.95
2023-2024
17
0.20
16.80
Total
329
5.45
323.55
Tab.: 6.5-1
22.00
Claim of occupied Farm Land
Page 55 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
6.6 Social and Cultural Resources Monuments of historical value are not known in the Sibovc SW field. Mainly large families with own agricultural enterprises are living in the area concerned, whose main income is secured by the production and sales of agricultural products. The social conditions of the population in this area are complicated and can be compared with the average living condition in the Kosovo. The average net wages are about 150-200 â&#x201A;Ź/ month. According to LSMS (Living Standard Measurement Survey 2000), 12 per cent of the population in Kosovo is extremely poor and another almost 40 per cent is poor. The average net wages are higher for men than for women and higher in the private sector than in the public sector (LSMS 2000). The most important forms of land use are agriculture and forestry. However their importance is decreasing. Approximately 60 % of the population living in the region are farmers who own land adjacent to their homes. Nevertheless, the development of the mining industry has a social effect, too. It provides jobs with income higher and securer than possible by the cultivation of own land. For some families, agriculture continues to be the most important income source but in the majority of the households, one family member is employed with KEK. The resettlement of the single housings will not significantly change the rural structure with regard to number and size of agricultural enterprises. Resettlers, whose income does not 100% originate from agriculture, are reported to be more easily ready to move to a prepared resettlement site with infrastructure or to build a big house without farmlands at a de-central site. Some resettlers use the resettlement effect to separate from the large family (extended family). For example, two-room apartments in the town are offered to adult family members using it to set up their own family. The presently common family size of 10-12 members is expected by the Ministry of Statistics to reduce to a family size of 5-7 members. Following villages and/or groups of houses are located within the mining field Sibovc SW: -
Mirene
-
Shipitulla East
-
Hade
-
Konxhul
Where resettlement will be needed mainly private properties will be affected. Public buildings are not affected. The compensation of Serbian property located within the mining field (former Serbian settlement) has to be negotiated with the corresponding owner.
Page 56 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Settlement Area
Year of the Resettlement
Number of Households
Members of Households
Mirene
Dec 2015
12
96
Shipitulla East
Dec 2015
17
136
Hade Western Slope
Dec 2009
35
280
Hade North
Dec 2019
41
328
Konxhul
Dec 2023
4
32
109
872
Total Tab.: 6.6-1
Resettlement of Households
Page 57 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7 Anticipated Environmental Impacts 7.1 General Environmental Impacts Production of lignite stands for large scale excavation of materials using heavy duty equipment. Exploitation of mineral resources thus causes inevitably negative impact on the environment. Negative effects accompanying the development of this industrial activity are related to numerous impacts on the existing ecological systems, mostly affecting an area which is more extensive than the zone where exploitation is taking place. The main impact is the occupancy of land which is inevitably associated with this type of mining. The coal itself is buried deep under the surface. The large opencast mines are being developed to a depth of more than hundred meters and cover areas of several hundred hectares. As slopes of any opencast mine have to be constructed in a geotechnical sound way the pit perimeter encloses an area considerably larger than the area of coal production itself. For safety reasons no residential settlements, public roads or waterways shall be allowed within a certain distance from the pit rim. This means real estate property used hitherto for agricultural, housing or other purposes will no longer be available for the former owners and users. Residents have to be resettled. In general, a substantial effort on compensation for land and property will become necessary. Over large areas the soil cover has to be removed resulting in a nearly complete loss of fauna and flora. Groundwater within the overburden strata and covering the coal must be adequately lowered before starting the excavation. While excavating, rain water and remaining ground water have to be pumped out of the mine. In general, this water is of relatively low quality in most cases due to the oxidization of pyrite associated with the formations excavated. This may result in reduced pH values and some increase in concentration of sulphate and heavy metals. The excavation and exploiting of lignite causes noise and dust due to the mining operations, maintenance works and coal transportation. Where the coal face comes in contact with the atmosphere oxidation processes may lead to self ignition of coal. This endangers employees at the working places as well as the surroundings and neighbouring residents. The overburden strata have to be removed to uncover the coal. In case direct back-filling into the pit can not be performed waste dumps for the overburden are needed outside the open pit. Hence additional land is needed whereby floral cover will be disturbed, animals lose their habitats and the shape of the landscape changes because hills are formed. After excavation of coal the mined area generally is devastated. In order to re-utilize the area again a complete backfill of the pit should be attempted wherever possible. Since the coal extracted leads to a deficit in volume not the whole area mined can be completely backfilled. Proper management of opencast mines involves a dedicated â&#x20AC;&#x153;Mine Closure Planâ&#x20AC;? which indicates the re-utilization of the land after mining and provides for acceptable alternatives for its environmental and socio-economic integration. In summary the main environmental impacts by opencast coal mining and dumping of significant quantities of ash are: -
Extensive land occupied by opencast mine, waste dumps and ancillary structures
-
Total loss of existing habitats on occupied land
-
Change to flora and fauna in the area around the mine due to construction and operation activities
Page 58 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
-
Change of hydro-geological regime in a wide area
-
Potential soil pollution and ground-/surface water pollution (affecting a large catchment area) due to soil alterations and coal processing (ash deposits, mine water and processing water discharge)
-
Air pollution by dust when excavating and conveying
-
Influences on terrain stability by mine slopes and surface deformation (subsidence of the soil)
-
Noise from mine equipment and operating conveyor belts
The dominant impact originates from the excavation of soil and coal. This will lead to a total loss of surface area and living space. Construction phase and operation phase of the project are intimately connected and happen at the same time as ongoing excavation of overburden continuously extends into new parts of land and coal exploitation takes place where overburden was freshly removed.
7.2 Topography Mining will start in a valley west of the village of Hade with elevations at about +570 mMSL. With the first overburden removal this valley will be widened into eastern and western directions with significant lowering of the surface. The Shipitulla dump (about +600 mMSL today) has to be removed in the early stages of excavation. The local landscape will loose a typical valley that today is visible to a long range from the South. As spreading of overburden can only partly be used to backfill the existing mines, the visible mine contour will enlarge throughout the lifetime of the mine. The deficit in volume due to the exploitation of the coal results in incomplete possibilities to backfill the Sibovc SW mine at the time of decommissioning. Therefore a residual depression will be left in the surface that might entail a lake afterwards. Nevertheless, this lake would enrich the variety of landscape in the future. Also a possible solution will be given, if the Sibovc SW mine in 2025 forms the starting point for additional exploitation. As there are 19 years left, it is conceivable to prepare the openingup of a new mining area in the east in the meantime following all legal and technological requirements.
7.3 Soil Vertisol soil on overburden clay materials is predominant. A Vertisol soil does not generally contain separate fertile topsoil layers and the existing overburden dumps demonstrate the spread clay to be quite as fertile as the developed topsoil. In addition to this and based on their local knowledge KEK´s environmentalists recommend to differentially excavate the topsoil as it would result in significant benefits e.g. for re-cultivation measures. As gradual enrichment of organic materials is understandable in the upper topsoil, a separated excavation and use to accelerate the rehabilitation processes, especially at reshaped dump sites, should be implemented into the mining activities. Only a rough sketch, showing the thickness of topsoil, is presented by Rudarski Institute (1997): Investicioni Program Izgraduje Povrsinskog Kopa “Sibovac”. – Kniga III, Beograd. This sketch is only available as a small scale figure in a text and therefore it is not sufficient to
Page 59 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
be used as a detailed and reliable basis for rehabilitation works. Detailed mapping of the current soil qualities will be needed.
7.4 Surface Waters Planned mining activities will affect single surface waters from the rims of the catchment areas in direction to the receiving waters. Therefore the surface water along the village of Sipitulle will be reduced in run-off quantities (mainly deriving from precipitation) with the balance being directed towards the mine in the future. Starting the mining activities from the existing mines in the south requires continuous drainage of the existing mines and will immediately reduce the catchment area within the valley west to Hade (310-380) by an area of about 3.6 km². At present conditions the surface water from the valley is partially collected by artificial drainage ditches along the northern slope and led to the river Drenica. Diversion of the run-off is part of the mine drainage concept, which collects the water at higher elevations of the valley and directs it either to the Sibovc River in the North or with the existing drainage system towards the river Sitnica. The remaining surface water in the deeper parts will be collected at the low points in the mine and pumped out. Using the precipitation values mentioned above will result in some 108,000 m³ of water to be drained per month (mean run-off coefficient = 0.4) and a peak water yield of 246,000 m³/day based on a maximum precipitation rate of 64 mm/d and a run-off coefficient of 0.8. A present problem may be the change of water quality combined with this mine drainage as enrichments in chloride, sulphate, turbidity and suspended solids will take place. Compared to the current situation it will be necessary to have at least the turbidity and suspended solids to be settled before the outlet towards the rivers. Once the valley west of Hade is excavated the mine will develop in line with the run-off directions of the neighbouring catchment areas and therefore only minor additional quantities of water deriving from the slopes will arrive at the mine. Interactions between the river Drenica and the mine caused by enlarged leakage water inflow are generally judged to be insignificant because of the distance between them and the presence of clayey and loamy overburden materials, which prevent enriched groundwater flow.
7.5 Groundwater Even though groundwater not directly associated with precipitation, i.e. groundwater in depth greater than some 20 m below the surface is assessed to exist only in minor quantities it will be affected in future. Starting mining from the south will slowly move the receiving point for groundwater from the existing mines towards the north. This will lead to a lowering of the groundwater table in the forefield of the mine. The groundwater is bound to coarser layers within the overburden clay at depth beyond the reach of any flora on the surface. Since no groundwater utilization is known in the area, only the physical effect of groundwater lowering, e.g. impact on slope stabilities, has to be taken into consideration. Adequate monitoring systems are needed to allow further continuous assessment.
Page 60 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
7.6 Ecological Resources A specific assessment of influences on fauna and flora is presently not feasible because of lack of competent local experts’ opinions, concerning documents or other information. For this report only some general statements are possible: -
the uniformity of the landscape and flora at and north of the Sibovc SW field, with actual predominant agricultural use, will provide space for animal retreat and conservation of floral variety in the north
-
as the mining activities concentrate on the area less overgrown by bushes and trees the effects on fauna and flora are judged to be acceptable
Nevertheless additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. At least a period of twelve month will be needed for a standard biological survey in the field before adequate baseline data become available for proper assessments. It is recommended to carry out these investigations with local experts, as manifold but local focussed questions are to be answered in limited time.
7.7 Economic Development Kosovo is in need for securing lignite excavation for electrical power production. As infrastructure for power generation (TPP A and B) are stationary and not movable to other locations without larger environmental damages, exploitation of the Sibovc SW field is the solution with least impacts. Mining the Sibovc SW field will lead to progressive land use within the next 20 years. Within this duration no economic use except coal exploitation will be possible in the active mining area. At the same time some 4.8 km² of agricultural used land will have vanished. Recultivation measures south of and partly within backfilled areas of the existing mines (realization is part of the budget for the “Mid Term Plan”) can be used to compensate for the loss of agricultural land in the north. As soon as mining will start in the field the connecting road Bardh – Hade – Palaj will be closed. Traffic diversion will be needed using the roads Shipitulla – Sibovc and Bardh Lismir. Significant improvements in road conditions are advised to carry additional traffic. Necessary resettlements mostly affect agricultural utilizations. Major trade and industry are not located in the area. Therefore economic development of the whole of Kosovo is assessed to be more important than preservation of these existing utilizations. Nevertheless resettlement must be combined with development of new and adequate farm land e.g. in the south of existing mines. As the existing mines and power plants today are the major employers in the area and the mines will be exhausted by the year 2012, the new Sibovc SW mine is essential to provide employment opportunities in future. Based on the technical demands of the Complementary Mining Plan following numbers of employees are needed to run the mine.
Page 61 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Year
Number of employees in Sibovc SW mine
12 / 2007 12 / 2008 12 / 2009 12 / 2010 12 / 2011 12 / 2012 12 / 2013 2014 -
15 500 1,000 1,300 1,380 1,420 1,450 1,500
Tab.: 7.7-1
Development of Employees
7.8 Social and Cultural Resources Approximately 870 people in 109 households has to be resettled between 2007 and 2023. Detailed plans where these people will be resettled to are not yet available. Even though the number of resettlements appears rather small the implementation of the resettlement has great influence on the future mining development. A socially acceptable resettlement procedure compliant to EU standards would take at least 8 years. Bad practise by the mining enterprise in the past caused a loss of trust by the villagers. There are still ongoing court challenges against KEK from previous unsatisfactory resettlements of removed southern parts of Hade village.
7.9 Health and Safety Taking into consideration the situation in the existing mines general measures have to be taken to prevent free access to the mine. Early planting of trees and thorny bushes along the future rim of the mine will result in a natural protection against unauthorized trespassing of human beings as well as larger animals. Mine operation should be organized on main roads allowing direct access to the working points. There is no specific concern for the mine workers since they should receive adequate health and safety training. This should address specific training on the machines as well as potential risks associated with operating the machines. The main problem of today, the uncontrolled lignite fires, are assessed to be mainly a problem of planning and exploitation execution. Responsible management and execution and ability to adhere to and update mine plans will prevent losses of values and unnecessary pollutions.
Page 62 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
8 Irreversible and Irretrievable Impacts Excavation of lignite will transform the surface. The local appearance of a gentle valley today will disappear and by 2024 a rather deep hole will be left. Due to the overall exploitation since beginning in the late 50ies and the volume of coal excavated it will not be possible to backfill the entire mined area. Trying to achieve elevations adjusted to the surroundings where possible in the fields of Bardh and Mirage will result in a depression at Sibovc SW field in the year 2025. This lack of materials can not be compensated under feasible and financially bearable circumstances. Even if excavation will be continued after 2024, this deficit in masses will only be shifted. In the end this will lead to the creation of a lake as a new element of landscape. Even though irreversible this lake will definitely enrich the diversity of landscape. In the event ash from combustion will not be sold, e.g. for road construction, or used to backfill the mines, new dumps would be needed to spread the masses. In this case new hills would be created which are susceptible to wind erosion and water leakage problems. Even if the floor of an ash disposal site is built in a technically tight way, seepage water has to be collected and treated until the dump is fully covered. These dumps would be kept in operation for the lifetime of the mine and power plants and, as they remain part of the landscape, they are regarded as irreversible impacts with significant pollution potential.
Page 63 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
9 Mitigating Measures Main pollution to be prevented as far as possible in future results from self ignition of lignite. Experience in the existing mines shows that those fires mainly appear where coal or coal bearing overburden material rest uncovered in direct contact with the atmosphere. As fires probably can not be fully avoided in the new mine all efforts should be made to cover the coal seam where not under direct exploitation to mitigate the risk of fire. Mine planning must take into consideration continuous coal extraction to avoid sections of the coal seam to stay unused in contact to the atmosphere. Dust is produced when dry coal or overburden is spread from belt to belt at transmission stations. Capping those stations will mitigate the dust propagation. Dust deriving from maintenance traffic shall be mitigated by regularly moistening the roads e.g. with water trucks. Reduction of dust development around the excavators will not be possible to a larger extent without hampering the production. As the excavators work within the mine, dust spreading will be mainly limited to the mine site. Water pollution results from mine drainage. Current analyses show that building settling ponds prior to the outlet to the river will be appropriate to reduce the output of suspended solids and turbidity. A first sedimentation takes place in the main drainage ditches. However, since these installations are frequently relocated, it will be necessary to install additional settling basins on the surface before feeding the water into the rivers. These basins shall be integrated in the course of the ditches. At a length of at least 100 m, the bed of such pond shall be flat on a width of at least 50 m, in order to achieve a clear reduction of the flow velocities. When entering a basin, the water stream shall be distributed as wide as possible to achieve good sedimentation results. The discharge end of a basin shall be in form of an earth dam, with a fixed wide overflow. The installations shall be controlled quarterly. The settled particles shall be removed regularly once a year in autumn before the rainy period begins. The materials removed shall be sampled and analysed in particular to contents of heavy metals and hydrocarbons. If there are no specific anomalies, the material can be integrated into the dumps. If contaminants are determined for example in cases of damages or accidents during the operation, the material shall be transported to an adequate disposal facility. Water pollution from waste water is to be mitigated by proper purification of sewage from workers social facilities, from work shops, storage areas for hydrocarbons and hazardous materials and any other installation producing potentially contaminated waters. Special measures are to be applied if heavy metals and trace element are analysed in mine drainage water and/or fluid phenol bearing waste is being excavated. By now adequate analyses, allowing more detailed assessments, are not available from the present operations. The need to pay attention to these considerations is expected to be mandatory for any new mining activity in Kosovo. Noise pollution outside the mine is mainly produced by the coal conveyor belts. Proper bearings and regular inspection and maintenance of the conveyor idlers will considerably reduce the level of noise. Materials from Sibovc SW mine will be used to backfill Mirash and Bardh mines where possible. As the Mirash mine is in use for ash disposal and for land fill some parts of the mine can not be backfilled with overburden material without endangering those sites. Material from
Page 64 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
the Sibovc SW mine will contribute to re-cultivating these abandoned mines. By this, the effects of a historic environmental impact will be mitigated. Development of the Sibovc SW mine from the south will immediately cut a locally important road. To decrease the effects on the neighbouring inhabitants the roads Bardh – Shipitulla – Sibovc and Bardh – Lismir should be developed to allow truck and bus traffic. Pavement should be asphalted to reduce molestation of residents, travelling times as well as to strengthen the public acceptance of the mine. Also ash from combustion of lignite has to be handled in future. First attempts were made to bring ash back into the mines but concepts how to cope with much greater quantities of ash than today are not yet available. Simple dumping the ash onto the surface is environmentally not acceptable. Using the ash as part of backfilling the mines represents an adequate way to prevent long term erosion and leakage of ash under the given geological circumstances. This implies adequate moistening of the ash during handling and exposure to suppress dust. Additionally, also partial re-handling and backfilling of existing ash dumps into the mines will significantly reduce already existing pollutions. The largest impact on the landscape, the loss of farmland, can only be compensated by creating new farmland. Therefore all backfilling activities should focus on a rapid return of land. A system of re-utilization of topsoil will contribute to improve the acceptance by resettled or neighbouring farmers. Where appropriate, the planting of trees combined with undergrowth will reduce visible effects. This applies to the neighbouring villages of Hade and Shipitulla. In these parts the mine´s rim can be planted to avoid a direct view into the open pit. In addition this vegetation belt can help to minimize dust and noise pollution.
Page 65 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
10 Action Plan The current knowledge about the situation is not sufficient to allow detailed assessments of the environmental effects on the envisaged project. Therefore additional investigations are necessary, which have to be carried out by appropriate experts. Most of the measures have to be launched prior to the excavation works. Adequate synchronising and adjustment of the different measures is necessary. The applicant should therefore implement an appropriate management.
10.1 Environmental Management Considering the present conditions at Kosovoâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s lignite mines it has to be emphasised that a well educated environmental management team has to become part of any new mining activity. The environmental management team has to be aware not only about the activities within the mine but also about the situation in the surroundings. Analyses for water and groundwater qualities and quantities, dust and noise emissions etc. should be reflected regularly leading to dynamic improvements on the entire environmental situation. To achieve this, a close connection to official bodies is advised. Already in the phase of concrete planning for the new mining area a first monitoring system has to be implemented and surveyed to document effects on air, soil and surface waters, neighbouring inhabitants as well as the faunal and floral habitats. Hence a trained team supported by external experts is needed to assess the expected detailed effects, to prepare adequate monitoring and mitigation plans before opening up the mine and develop this throughout the lifetime of the mine. Procurement and settlement of accounts of external experts will be part of the duty of this team.
10.2 Environmental Monitoring Measures 10.2.1
Surface Water
Surface waters, especially the river Drenica, will be influenced by mine drainage. In contrast to the present procedures the actual quantities of water being discharged from the mine must be measured. This will be possible by using simple and proven hydrologic structures, e.g. installing a triangle or hyperbolic weir shortly in front of the outlet towards the river. This weir first has to be adjusted to fit the needs of large discharge rates throughout autumn and snow melt as well as smaller water quantities during winter and summer times. Regular readings, at least once an hour, are assessed to fit the documentation requirements. PH value and electrical conductivity readings should be performed at least once a day. Chemical analysis on water samples upstream and downstream the drainage system settling ponds should be performed at least once a week. Use of automatic reading stations is recommended only when regular maintenance of the stations by trained staff can be guaranteed.
Page 66 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
In the course of Sibovc river and the water course from the village Shipitulle to Drenica river regular flow measurements and samplings with chemical analyses are advised (every three month recommended) to register a possible enlarged leakage of surface water towards the mine and to document the effects of mining on the waters. Besides the typical describing parameters pH and Eh value, el. conductivity, temperature, sensory appearance of sample the analyses must comprise the list of major anions and cations (at least Na, K, Ca, Mg, Fe, Mn, Cl, SO4, NO3, NO2, HCO3) as well as other noticeable parameters that might be of importance.
10.2.2
Groundwater
By now no adequate knowledge exists about the quantities of groundwater to be drained in future. Even though groundwater is looked upon as a minor problem it is strongly recommended to erect a comprehensive network of monitoring wells as soon as possible. The monitoring wells allow measurements of the groundwater table and quality and will allow evaluation of the flow of groundwater toward the mines as well as to assess the influence of groundwater when opening up and developing the new mine. The groundwater levels should be monitored at different horizons: -
Shallow wells are recommended primary to assess the effects of precipitation on groundwater. The bottom of the alteration zone from grey to yellow clay gives good indication to locate the well screen. In general a depth of about 15 m is considered as suitable.
-
Deeper wells shall be sunk to specific water bearing layers within the overburden to show the hydrogeological conditions near to the coal. These wells shall be sealed at a depth adequate to prevent a direct connection with the groundwater from the shallow horizon.
-
To assess the quantity and especially the pressure of groundwater in greater depth a number of monitoring wells should be positioned within the coal seam and the underlying green clay. Vague indications are given that the green clay at least locally contains courser layers, which might function as aquifers. To proof this drillings must be scientifically accompanied; especially the material sampling must be sufficient to allow proper identification of the materials.
After installation of the wells the water levels have to be recorded at least monthly and drawn as graphics showing the development in time. Combining the information with long term meteorological data allows assessments on the natural, unaffected variation of the groundwater table as well as on the degree of groundwater level lowering when the mining activities approach the area. This additional information is a basic requirement when calculating the stability of the future slopes. The drilling logs will give supplementary information on the quality of the overburden and coal for the later excavation. Discussions with the hydrogeological expert of KEK led to a first scheme to place monitoring wells. Most of the wells are positioned at the mine rim to allow long-term documentation. The following figure shows the positions.
Page 67 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The net of monitoring wells shall be adopted in future to up-dated mining plans. In case positions of wells appear unfavourable alternative locations shall be identified which allow adequate assessment of the groundwater level. As soon as excavation reaches a monitoring well it shall be properly removed and the borehole shall be backfilled using sealing materials.
Fig.: 10.2-1
Net of Groundwater Monitoring Wells
10.2.3
Air Quality
The mining activities will cause dust emissions deriving from excavation activities, materials handling, excavated not yet re-vegetated slopes and benches and the materials dumped especially throughout the dry seasons. As the wind is predominantly blowing from the northeast wind erosion will take place all along the mining face. To assess the effects a number of weather stations and air samplers have to be implemented at least two years prior to
Page 68 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
the mining activities. Focus should be set on possible molestation of neighbouring residents. As the villages of Sibovc, Shipitulla and Hade are located near to the corners of the mine it is advised to install the stations at least at the four corners of the mine.
10.2.4
Noise
The development of the new mining front will shift the sources for noise by the moving excavation equipment as well by suspending of pathways. Hence not only the mining machinery itself but also the shifted traffic around the mine will lead to alterations in noise emission. First attempts are already undertaken by the INCOS Institute to measure the degree of noise around the existing mines as well as within the Sibovc SW field. These measurements should be extended and intensified to create the baseline information for further assessments. Additional noise measurements should be undertaken within the neighbouring villages to create a baseline for later assessments on the increase of noise caused by the mining equipment as well as by the resulting diversion of traffic.
10.2.5
Vibrations
The mining activities will locally reach near to housing areas. To assess the future impact a baseline survey should be performed for the northern part of Hade village, Shipitulle village and the settlements of Konxhul and Megjuani. Correspondent locations have to be identified neighbouring the existing mines (i.e. at the southern part of Hade village, Graboc i Ulet or Bardh village) to record the current influence from the ongoing mining operations.
10.2.6
Intensified Assessments
A number of items are identified requiring processing in the near future.
10.2.7
Fauna and Flora
Detailed information on the floral and faunistic population as well as a specific catalogue of endangered species could not be procured Up to now the knowledge about the fauna and flora in the Sibovc SW field is insufficient. To achieve baseline data surveys must identify the faunistic and floral inventory prior to any mining activities. These surveys must cover at least 12 months of identifying and counting the different species appearing throughout the different climatic periods. The survey leads to an assessment of the impact of the total loss of that area on the larger countryside.
Page 69 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
10.2.8
Cultural Heritage
Currently there is no knowledge about archaeological or historical important locations. Same refers to the architectural heritage. It is important to confirm the opinion that there is none of those locations in the Sibovc SW field by local experts prior to excavation.
10.2.9
Compensation of Farmland and Utilization of Top Soil
To resettle the inhabitants of the Sibovc SW field adequate and practicable locations have to be found in short term. A fitting way to compensate the loss of farmland is to intensify the reutilization of parts of the outside dumps directly south and in greater distance southwest of the mines. As reshaping of the dumps in the south is already integrated into the “Mid Term Plan” for the duration 2009 to 2012, it will be possible to combine the re-utilization of the dumps with the needs of resettlement. By now it is intended to re-shape the dumps and to gradually transform the surface into agricultural usable land. From 2012 onwards the occupation of land will considerably affect local farmers. Providing “ready to use” farmland as compensation already in 2012 will simplify the process of resettlement. Separate handling of the humus topsoil offers an important component to fill the gap. The humus topsoil from the Sibovc SW field will be separately excavated, transported and installed at the compensation areas. This layer is assessed nearly to hold its full productivity throughout the process whereby in short term a yield, comparable to the farmland lost, can be achieved. This operation requires some specific preparatory, monitoring and control work. Prerequisite is the confirmation of top soil values. This is achieved by additional investigations on the soil qualities, combining surveying the thickness of the topsoil with sampling and analyses of the qualities. It is advised to use a working grid with distances of no more than 250 m. Result will be a comprehensive map as basis for the later excavation works. The needs to provide specific areas for compensation are known from the mine planning. Based on this a time schedule has to be developed showing when individual plots of land must be ready for resettlement. The excavation – transportation – build-in process must be adjusted to the resulting timely constraints. During field operations a control system must be implemented to organize appropriate excavation and building works.
10.2.10
Protection of Villages
Where the mining activities reach near to villages intensified interference occurs. With Hade and Shipitulle two villages will be located rather near to the mine. Disconnecting the villages from the mining operations will not be possible, but compensating measures can be undertaken. This means for example to plant trees and bushes to reduce the visual impression. As additional noise and dust reducing effects might be implementable, intensified assessments should develop appropriate solutions with choice of appropriate plants and the way of planting.
Page 70 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
10.2.11
Future Treatment of Ash Dumps
The combustion of lignite produces ash which currently is dumped at two dumping sites close to the power plants. This procedure results in air pollution by dust and groundwater pollution due to seepage. To avoid these effects in future methods should be developed to transport the ash directly into the mines, as the geological situation with clayey under- and overburden favours the disposal together with the overburden dumping. Trials already have been initiated to pump ash as slurry from TPP Kosovo B into the Mirash mine. The existing ash dumps should be included into the “ash backfilling” procedure aiming at a gradual but in the end total removal of the dumps in the course of the power plants’ live times. In addition, the surfaces of the existing dumps should be stabilized using at least a floral cover to keep the dust pollution low and to reduce the seepage by increasing the retention and the evapotranspiration of precipitation.
Page 71 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
11 Mine Closure and Recultivation Planning 11.1 Principles The proposed main principles are: -
Main principle will be to minimize impact on land, to reduce agriculturally used land only when needed and to restore farmland where and as soon as possible.
-
The areas occupied by mining shall be rehabilitated in such a way that the subsequent value of the area will be equal or better than the original one.
-
Areas which are no longer needed for mining activities shall be recultivated as soon as possible. As long as a final recultivation is not possible, suitable temporary measures will be undertaken, e.g. an interim grass seeding.
-
Financial resources will be retained already during the active mining operations to ensure the proper closure of the mining field. This money will also be available for site rehabilitation in case of insolvency.
-
Authorities and the population concerned (later users) will be integrated in the process of planning and detailed landscaping of the post-mining areas. This process shall start before dumping because it already defines the shape of the surface.
11.2 Mine Closure Plan Recultivation of the Sibovc field is closely connected with the closure of the Bardh and Mirash mine fields. After depletion of the existing mines of Bardh and Mirash, large residual pits remain. The establishment of larger coherent areas suitable for closure will not be feasible within the operating period of the opencast mines. This is due to the low overburden: coal ratio as well as result of the material properties of the overburden. The following residual pits will remain in the area of the opencast mines: -
A wide and deep residual pit in the western area of the mining field (mining area of the Bardh opencast mine and the western part of the Mirash opencast mine),
-
A landfill site in the former Mirash-Brand mining field for which the KTA is responsible,
-
The ash dump in the former Mirash-East mining field for which KEK is responsible,
-
An almost closed dump area in the eastern parts of the Mirash opencast mine, adjacent to the landfill site. In the areas directly bordering the landfill site there are large corridor-type clearance areas due to the flat slope angle.
After depletion of the existing opencast mines coal mining will be continued in the follow-up field of Sibovc. This opencast mine will be developed from the northern slope system of the existing opencast mines. It is planned to use these overburden masses to fill the depleted area of the existing mines. This offers optimal opportunities for final contouring the areas and avoids placement of additional outside dumps.
Page 72 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
According to the Mid Term Plan the existing mines are responsible to provide geotechnically stable slopes within their residual pit until the area is closed finally by the follow-up mine. The following measures will be taken: -
The overburden slopes along the southern rim slope system shall be contoured to safe angles.
-
The slopes enclosing coal along the southern rim slope system shall be flattened and covered by overburden material. This measure serves to extinguish existing and/or prevent new coal fires. The dumping technology of the overburden masses of Sibovc will be adapted to this thus assisting to keep costs for these mitigation measures to a minimum.
-
The coal seam floor shall be continuously covered by cohesive overburden material. This measure also serves the prevention of further coal fires and can be optimized by a selective dumping of the overburden material from Sibovc.
-
The drainage of the residual area shall be continued. This refers to the main drainage system on the lowest floor level and the drainage from the southern rim slope system by means of suitable drainage ditches. These ditches shall be installed on all berms of the southern rim slope system. Extension of the ditches will not be required. A collecting pond shall be installed at the deepest point of each of the berms from which the water is fed by pipelines and/or collecting ditches to the main drainage system. When dumping operation from the Sibovc mine starts to cover the main drainage system, a replacement shall be installed and operated.
After closure of the residual area by spreading the overburden material from the Sibovc mine, the areas shall be rehabilitated for agricultural use to provide compensation for those areas being removed by the mine expansion. Connection of the dump area at the same surface level is recommended for the large residual pit in the west of the mining field, without re-shaping the former hill near the village of Hade. The final dump surface should be slightly inclined to enable good access conditions for agricultural machines as well as a natural drainage into the direction of the Sitnica and Drenica-Rivers. The final shaping of the eastern dump side is only possible after decommissioning of the ash disposal and the landfill site. Both sites are planned for an operating period of at least 15 years. Only thereafter a complete closure of the marginal corridors will be possible. This can be accomplished either with the overburden from Sibovc or by relocating the materials from the ash dump of TPP A on the mining Field D. The preferred alternative is the recovery of the ash dump of TPP A. The bottom liner for the masses to be installed can be provided by the inside dump materials. The masses lying below the ash on the outside dump can be excavated and used as final cover material and/or as recultivation layer. Considering the extended period of time until a final shaping of this area becomes feasible, an interim solution is recommended. This will include partial filling of depressions on the ash dump surface.
Page 73 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
11.3 Concept of Post-Mining Use for the Fields Bardh, Mirash and Sibovc a) Principles and Basic Conditions for a detailed Reclamation Planning The dump location will change from the Bardh/Mirash in-pit dump into the Sibovc field after 2020. The shaping of the final surface of the opencast mines of Bardh, Mirash and Sibovc will be considered as one common aspect of the mine closure. However, the balance of areas described in the following limits itself exclusively to the fate of areas of the Sibovc mine field. The concept for the post-mining landscape contains the following aspects: -
Demand for utilization (agriculture, forestry, building site …),
-
Area utilisation tied into availability of soils (quality),
-
Availability of equipment for contouring,
-
Cost/benefit.
Due to the large quantity of mineable coal, it will not be possible to fill up the entire opencast mine. Therefore, a lake will establish in the north of the Sibovc field. In order to maximise the area for potential utilization, the final surface depression should be as deep as possible with regard to the surrounding terrain. In line with this, two connecting points to the existing rivers are of importance. In the southeast of Bardh, directly at the Bardh village there should be a surface height maintained at 550 mMSL. In the northeast of Sibovc there is a run-off to the Sitnica River at an elevation of 540 mMSL. The boundary of the residual lake is located south of the villages of Sibovc und Lajthisht. The water table of this lake will be at ca. 535 mMSL (ca. 5 m below average? surface level). The slope to the residual lake will have a general inclination of 1 : 6. Single slopes will be flattened to inclinations of 1 : 7 (8°).The beach area susceptible to wave action will be protected against erosion by means of rock fill. Main aim for shaping the post-mining field is to provide a high share of area useful for agriculture. In general, the dump area shall represent a high-value landscape element in which agricultural use and habitat for local fauna and flora will exist in parallel. Criteria for achieving these goals: -
Adequate inclination: minimum 1 : 20 (3°), maximum 1 : 12.5 (4.5°), which allows cultivation with agricultural machines,
-
Discharge of excess surface water to be ensured by a minimum surface inclination of 1 : 200,
-
Collection and discharge of surface water by installation of ditches and storage ponds and their connection with the existing rivers,
-
Installation of windbreak belts as a natural boundary for reducing wind erosion,
-
Plantation of trees and shrubs for shaping a varied landscape,
-
Conservation of parts of the outside dump in the present form as refuge area for the presently existing and adjusted flora and fauna,
-
Construction of roads and access.
Page 74 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
A surface inclination of 1 : 150 will be planned to compensate for completion of settlements in the dump area and to guarantee the final minimum inclination of 1 : 200. Considering this inclination the terrain rises from the future residual pit in the north into southern direction and from the river connection at Bardh in the south-west into northern direction. Therefore the future terrain will lie below the original surface elevation, especially in the area of the hill close to Hade. In any case, the gradual transition towards the natural terrain is ensured. The shores of the future lake will have a general inclination of 10째 according to the mine planning. The slopes of working benches shall be flattened to an inclination of 1 : 7 (8째) and planted with trees and shrubs. All areas where coal is exposed shall be covered by a sufficient amount of overburden. b) Soil Improvement Measures Upon completion of the dumping operation the areas will be graded and prepared for recultivation, e.g. by scarifying and ploughing. The final contouring of the surface should consider both, a smoothly undulated structure and the free discharge of the water. After the levelling works have been finished, deep ploughing shall be carried out with a penetration depth of 0.5 m. That applies in particular to surfaces which were finished during the rainy season. In principle, soil-improving measures are necessary only to a limited degree for land to be utilised for agriculture because the available overburden material is already rather fertile itself. To raise the yield of crop it may become advisable to apply fertilising measures like manure, slurry or mineral fertilizer. c) Interim Greening and Erosion Protection Measures For the subsequent management of agricultural land it is assumed that the plots will have an average size of approx. 5 - 10 hectares. Assuming a rectangular layout this corresponds to a dimension of 500m * 150m. A wind breaking belt shall be installed between the individual plots with a width of approx. 5m. Its function comprises both erosion protection and a natural boundary between the plots. A multi-line arrangement of different wood is recommended, as it is represented in the following illustration. This system can also be realised along the farm roads. Fast-growing tree species are especially suitable as wind breaking belts, like for example poplars or robinias (Robinia Rectissima) and bushes. An integration of fruit trees is possible as well. It is suggested to install stone fruit meadows and/or to carry out afforestation for steeper areas, where farming by means of machines would not be possible.
Page 75 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
st
Trees (1 size) nd Trees (2 size) Shrubs
3.50 m Fig.: 11.3-1
Plant Scheme for Wind Erosion Protection
d) Irrigation and Dewatering Measures Along the wind breaking belts, paths and roads, ditches shall be installed for surface drainage. The size of the ditches shall be chosen in accordance to the respective catchment area. The following standard design criteria shall be considered: -
Bed width
0.5 m â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1.0 m, effective
-
Ditch depth
ca. 1 m
-
Gradient
min. 1 : 200
-
Inclination of the ditch slope
ca. 45°
At suitable intervals these ditches shall be widened to form storage ponds in order to be able to store the water for a limited period of time in case of heavy rainfalls. The single ditches shall be finally connected to collecting ditches with a steeper gradient discharging the accumulated surface run-off from the outside dump. These ditches shall be constructed in a solid manner. The flow velocity of the water shall be reduced by means of check dams and stilling basins. An open ditch with downward gradient towards the Sitnica-River shall be constructed starting from the low point of the outside dump.
Page 76 of 77
Part III Environmental Assessment Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
12 Legal Framework During this project a legal framework was developed by the Assembly of Kosovo that gives guidance to obtain the needed legal permits. These Legal Regulations in all cases expect an applicant responsible for implementing the project. As the “Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine” does not designate an applicant it was not possible for the Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning to start to EIA process. Therefore this Environmental Study was developed to form a basis for the official Scoping Opinion the Ministry has to formulate in order to fit the legal regulations.
12.1 Legal Mining Regulations On 21st of January 2005 the Regulation No. 2005/3 on Mines and Minerals in Kosovo was promulgated. Part V - Mining Licenses - Section 30.1 (j) calls for “an Environmental Impact Assessment and all documents required under the Environmental Law in relation to the Mining Programme prepared in each case by suitably qualified and experienced experts” as attachment to the application.
12.2 The Environmental Protection Law The Law No. 2002/8 “The Environmental Protection Law” explains with Article 20 Environmental Impact Assessment: 1. A person, undertaking or public authority that is planning the construction of an industrial or processing facility or a major work or project shall, if such facility, project or work has a significant potential for causing Environmental Damage, first be required to conduct an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and to file with the Ministry a report summarizing the findings of that EIA (EIA Report). 2. A person, undertaking or public authority that is planning to significantly modify the operations of an existing industrial or processing facility or major work or project shall, if such modification has a significant potential to increase or substantially alter Emissions and/or Discharges, first be required to conduct an EIA and to file with the Ministry an EIA Report summarizing the findings of that assessment. All information available and relevant for this project is conducted in this Part III: Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine – Environmental Impact Study. Subsidiary normative acts as defined by the law, Article 10, 1. and 2. are not jet available. Therefore this study can only describe the basic situation and demand for future investigations to follow the target of Article 10, 2. „...to gradually phase in the relevant EU standards and requirements in a manner that is both realistically affordable by public authorities, persons and undertakings and consistent with the sustainable economic development of Kosovo.” As by now no Scoping Opinion was given by the Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning it will be the liability of the future applicant to apply for the Environmental Consent using this study and to start the actual EIA process after receiving the Ministry’s Scoping Opinion.
Page 77 of 77
European Agency for Reconstruction PREPARATION OF A COMPLEMENTARY MINING PLAN FOR THE SIBOVC SOUTH WEST LIGNITE MINE CONTRACT 02/KOS01/10/021
DRAFT FINAL REPORT Complementary Mining Plan for Sibovc SW
Part IV – Financial Analysis
April, 2006
prepared by: STEAG Consortium
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Key Experts of Project Team
Hans J端rgen Matern Team Leader
Thomas Suhr Senior Expert Computer-Aided Mine Planning Applications
Stephan Peters Senior Expert Geology
Helmar Laube Senior Expert Soil Mechanics
Joachim Gert ten Thoren Senior Environmental Expert
Page 2 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Table of Contents 1 1.1 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.2.1 1.2.2.2 1.2.2.3 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.3
SUMMARY (PART IV)........................................................................................... 7 Objective .................................................................................................................... 7 Tasks and Outputs of the Project................................................................................ 8 Part I: Basic Investigations ......................................................................................... 8 Part II: Technical Planning......................................................................................... 8 Mine Development ..................................................................................................... 9 Dewatering ................................................................................................................. 9 Manpower................................................................................................................. 10 Part III: Environmental Impact Study....................................................................... 10 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis............................................................... 11 Results under Part IV â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Financial Analysis.............................................................. 12
2
TECHNICAL BASIS FOR THE FINANCIAL ANALYSIS ............................. 17
3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.5.1 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.8.1 3.8.2 3.9 3.9.1 3.9.2 3.9.3 3.9.4 3.9.5 3.9.6 3.9.7
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS..................................................... 19 Preliminary Remarks ................................................................................................ 19 General Assumptions and Calculation Method........................................................ 22 Example for DCF-Method ....................................................................................... 22 Real Average Cost.................................................................................................... 26 Cash Flow................................................................................................................. 28 Preliminary overburden ............................................................................................ 28 IRR, Average Costs per Unit.................................................................................... 32 Sensitivity Analysis .................................................................................................. 33 Financial Analysis .................................................................................................... 34 Earning-Capacity Value ........................................................................................... 36 Project Financing...................................................................................................... 38 Cost Calculation, Investment Costs, Operating Costs.............................................. 39 General Data for Cost Calculation ........................................................................... 39 Investment Costs ...................................................................................................... 39 Labour Costs............................................................................................................. 40 Calculation of Operating Cost Items ........................................................................ 40 General Data and Principles for Cash Flow ............................................................. 41 Escalation ................................................................................................................. 41 Lignite Sales Price.................................................................................................... 42
Page 3 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Figures Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.: Fig.:
1.3-1 1.3-2 1.3-3 1.3-1 1.3-2 3.1-1 3.1-2 3.3-1 3.3-2 3.4-1 3.4-2 3.5-1 3.5-2 3.5-3 3.6-1 3.7-1 3.8-1 3.8-2 3.8-3 3.8-4 3.9-1
Real Average Cost Development of the ECV in 2024 depending from the Lifetime of the OCM Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax Coal Output Mining Position in the Year 2024 Specific Expenditure Revenues until 2024 Overburden and Lignite Performance Total Expenditures RAC for 10 % and 12 % total Return on Investment RAC depending on the Interest Rate Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax Cumulative Cash Flow with Interest before Tax Expenditures and Revenues until achieving of a positive Operating Result Illustration of Dependence on theoretical total Return on Investment Sensitivity Chart Pre-Overburden of Sibovc SW Mine Revenues of Sibovc SW Mine Equity and Liabilities of Sibovc SW Project Earning-Capacity Value per 31/12/2024 Development of the RAC with 4 % Escalation
13 15 16 17 18 19 21 22 23 27 28 29 29 31 32 34 35 35 36 37 42
Page 4 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Tables Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.: Tab.:
1.3-1 3.1-1 3.3-1 3.3-2 3.3-3 3.5-1
Results and specific Parameters Example RWE 2005 Calculation Example 1 Calculation Example 2 Calculation Example 3 Escalated Expenditures in Sibovc SW
14 20 23 24 24 32
Page 5 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
List of Abbreviations a
year
bcm
bank cubic meter
CD
cost of dept before tax
CE
cost of equity before tax
CF
cash flow
DR
dept ratio
ECV
earning capacity value
ER
equity ratio
EURO/t
Euro per ton
DCF
discounted cash flow
IRR
internal rate of return
MEURO
million Euro
mt
million tonnes
mt/a
million tonnes per annum
RAC
real average cost
WACC
weighted average capital cost
Page 6 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1 Summary (Part IV) 1.1 Objective The Complementary Mining Plan for New Sibovc South West Mine consists of the following reports: -
Part I
Basic Investigations
-
Part II
Technical Planning
-
Part III
Environmental Impact Study
-
Part IV
Economic and Financial Analysis
The existing coal mines Bardh and Mirash, west of Pristina, will be exhausted by 2011. Thus the overall objective of the project is providing a plan for the supply of the necessary fuel to the existing power plants in Kosovo until the end of their lifetime. The specific objectives of this contract are the elaboration of a detailed mine plan on the development of the new mine in the Sibovc South West Lignite Field. The objective of the plan is: -
to define the technical measures and the timeframe to be followed to open-up the new mine and develop it up to the scheduled capacity of about 9 million tons per annum;
-
to guide the focus on the necessary investments and operating costs;
-
to include the necessary measures and information for licensing applications.
Other than the Main Mining Plan for New Sibovc Mine (max. 24 m t coal out per year) the Complementary Mining Plan for the Sibovc South West Lignite Field focuses on the fuel supply to the existing TPP assuming a coal demand of 9 mt/a and a limited availability of financial resources. The plan covers the period from 2007 to 2024 when all existing power capacities assumed to reach the end of their service life. Subsequently the total accumulated coal demand from the Sibovc South West Lignite Field comes to 123 million tonnes, what is approximately 15% of the entire mineable lignite reserves in the Sibovc Lignite Field. The remaining lignite reserves of the entire Sibovc Lignite Field could be a source to feed new power plant capacities expected to be built in Kosovo. The Complementary Mining Plan has been coordinated with the existing â&#x20AC;&#x153;Mid term Mining Plan for the existing minesâ&#x20AC;?. The Mid Term Plan provides the stepwise implementation of regular operation conditions, the achievement of geotechnical and public safety and therefore the transfer of mines to an economic efficient operation. The purpose of the Complementary Mine Plan is to show the measures to be undertaken and the timeframe for these measures to open up the new mine in time to replace the running out production capacity of the existing mines. The plan is showing the required investment and effective cost of lignite supply.
Page 7 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The investment requirements to open-up the Sibovc South-West mine are 236 MEURO until 2012, when full supply capacity will be reached. The real average cost of lignite supply amount to 7.50-8.00 EURO/ton of raw coal, depending on the cost of capital investment. Special attention has been focused on the required resettlement and land acquisition. The plan also ensures that the mine operations are in full compliance with the relevant legal and technical regulations, i.e. mining law, environmental law, spatial planning and expropriation regulations and laws.
1.2 Tasks and Outputs of the Project 1.2.1 Part I: Basic Investigations The basis for the new mining plan for the Sibovc South West mine is the previous study â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Main Mining Plan for Sibovc mineâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;. Using this as the basis, the consultants checked, evaluated, updated and presented all necessary facts (geo-technical, geological, hydrogeological and hydrological data, infrastructure, existing end necessary new equipment) for the Sibovc South West mine. According to ToR this plan was based on a demand forecast prepared by the Ministry of Energy and Mines in accordance with the Kosovo Energy Strategy. The consultant updated the existing computerised geological model based on additional exploration drillings conducted by KEK and prepared a plan for further exploration to be realised by KEK, defined the slope design based on soil-mechanic calculation. To ensure the planned performance of the equipment and subsequently output of the mine it will be necessary to undertake a complex refurbishment of lignite and overburden equipment incl. excavators, conveyor lines and spreaders. This approach represents a new quality against the partly repair of machines realised so far. A refurbishment/replacement programme for the existing main mining equipment as well as auxiliary equipment has been prepared including a realistic assessment of the timing of the required investments. As an important output of the project the plan provides the basis for the application for, and issuing of exploitation licence for the new mine. The outputs are the findings of this analysis, including the updated geological model, plan for further exploitation; definition of slope design; and updated investment plan in main and auxiliary equipment.
1.2.2 Part II: Technical Planning The consultants prepared detailed mine development plans/annexes, including all necessary calculations, for the first five years of operation and mine phase documentation for the end of each year, continuing with next five years periods (end of periods) up to 2024. The outputs of this task are the detailed mine development plans as set out above.
Page 8 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
There have been prepared an updated expropriation plan which provides both a timed and cost plan for the required measures for land acquisition and resettlement into mine planning. A short description of the main output of part II follows:
1.2.2.1 Mine Development The following main topics for the mine development have been considered: -
Opening-up of the Sibovc SW OCM shall be made from the northern rim slope system of the existing opencast mine. The existing inside dump of P3B shall be taken into account.
-
A coal pillar shall remain between the existing Bardh mine and the new Sibovc mine field in order to stabilize the masses of the inside dump of the Bardh opencast mine.
-
The overburden masses will preferably be dumped in the mined-out area of the existing OCM in order to stabilize the slope south of Hade and to establish final dump surfaces as soon as possible.
-
The mined-out bottom in Sibovc SW shall be covered by dumps and as far as possible also the final coal rim slope systems in order to prevent coal fires.
-
During the opening-up phase the overburden will be transported via the western rim slope system. After disassembling the equipment in the existing opencast mines there will be established a belt connection via the eastern rim slope system. This helps to reduce the transport distance and the quickest possible establishment of a stabilising body south of Hade.
-
The residual pit of Mirash-Brand remains as reserved area for the disposal of municipal waste.
-
It is envisaged to flush the power plant residues from TPP B in the residual pit of Mirash-East.
Due to late start of the mine development a rather high capacity will be required right at the beginning of works. The performance required can be performed only with rehabilitated equipment. After rehabilitation the capacity for overburden (BWE) complexes shall be 3.6-5.4 million cubic meters per annum each. The first two BWE - Systems will have to be commissioned in 2008. Some overburden removal works will be required using truck & shovel operation. This service should be contracted with third parties. It must be noticed, that the development of the new Sibovc SW mine is directly linked to the advance of the existing mine and therefore to the realisation of the Mid Term Plan.
1.2.2.2 Dewatering Drainage of surface water via the active bench of the Sibovc SW mine shall be excluded except residual rainwater quantities. It is suggested to install a dewatering system in the valley from which the collected surface water is pumped into the higher located channel(s) by means
Page 9 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
of sewage pumps. According to the OCM advance the dewatering shall be shifted several times to the North. Drainage ditches shall be installed on all working levels and along the access roads.
1.2.2.3 Manpower The following table gives a survey on the staffing requirements: Year Existing mines per 01.01. - Fluctuation / Redundancy Staff transfer Sibovc SW per 31.12.
2007 3500
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
490
3000 415
2100 300
1300 100
900 470
350 260
10
485
500
300
80
40
1380
1420
15
500
1000
1300
Staff for the new mine will be employed mainly from redundant staff of the existing mines.
1.2.3 Part III: Environmental Impact Study The mining activities will have a large effect on the environment. The Environmental Study serves as a baseline description for the expected effects. Alternative locations are discussed for coal extraction prior to the implementation of the Complementary Mining Plan resulting in the location of “D-field”, east of the river Sitnica, to be an equally favourable alternative to supply the existing power plants from the environmental point of view. Among the other alternatives a development of the “Sibovc field” from the south to the north ranked second best. Subject of the Complementary Mining Plan is the excavation of overburden and lignite, developing from the existing opencast mines to the north. Mining activities will start from the existing mines using already exploited areas for dumping the overburden material. The anticipated environmental effects concern, first of all, the removal of soil resulting in a loss of surface area and living space. With this extension an enlarged void will be visible, compared to the existing mines. As the backfill of already exploited areas goes on parallel in time, it will be possible to return recovered areas to agricultural use in a landscape with changed appearance. Surface waters to be affected are mainly small and of non perennial flow. The rivers Sitnica and Drenica will not be directly affected, as clayey sediments with sufficient thickness protect them from the mine. Indirect effects can result from the outlet of mine drainage water with enlarged contents of Chloride and Sulphate as well as suspended solids. Because of the characteristics of the overburden the impact on groundwater will be minor. Significant groundwater utilization is not known in the area. Influences on neighbouring utilizations can be excluded. Dust emissions as well as noise emissions will shift from the current to the future working points with an equal or, based on used technologies, even minor extend of emissions. The Environmental Study attempts to follow in general the applicable EU directives on environmental impact assessment, mainly Directive 85/337/EEC. However, there is a general lack of baseline studies, local experts’ opinions, pertinent documents or other information,
Page 10 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
e.g. allowing any specific assessment on influences on fauna and flora. Regarding this aspect additional investigations are needed to describe the floral and faunistic inventory of the mining field. In case of proper operation and a coal demand adequate to the mining technology the mine will stay one of the most important employers of the region with up to 1,500 employees. Upon completion of backfilling areas farmable land can be returned to the inhabitants, which mitigates the effects of required resettlements. Resettlement will be needed as a consequence of the development of the mine. Approximately 870 persons representing some 109 households will have to be moved in the years 2007 to 2024. Resettlement refers to single houses and small settlements and it will not be needed to resettle significant villages. With the objective to improve knowledge on the environment and to allow control on the environmental impact, adequate monitoring activities shall be set up concerning air and water quality measurements as well as the purification of drainage water and the utilization of humus enriched top soil layers.
1.2.4 Part IV: Economic and Financial Analysis The consultants prepared an economic and financial analysis with a detailed cash flow forecast, a financial analysis of the cost benefit of the proposed investment with IRR/ NPV calculations, and a time planning for the investment programme. The output of this task is a detailed, based on annual calculations economic and financial analysis and appraisal of the Sibovc South West mine plan. The calculations have been made in accordance with IFRS. The main results of the profitability calculation are as follows: The calculated real average cost (RAC) comes to 7.5-8.0 EURO/t. The economic analysis also considered that in 2024 a fully functioning opencast mine will be available. This allowed calculation with coal prices of 7.00 EURO/t to 7.50 EURO/t. Totally four variants were assumed containing different coal prices, different escalation and different interest rate on borrowings. All variants until 2011 require about 80 MEURO equity capital and ca. 200 MEURO debt capital. Assuming a coal price of 7.00 EURO/ton the dividend earned until 2024 will amount to at least 137 MEURO which can be distributed to the shareholders. The sum of the annual payments for the production of coal is smaller than 5.0 EURO per tonne coal. This applies from 2012, the first year of full production. It will be possible to produce coal with favourable terms and profits of 20 % on the employed equity capital can be earned. The cash flow analysis demonstrates that the chosen mine development will be generally profitable even with the short operation time period of only 15 years.
Page 11 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
1.3 Results under Part IV â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Financial Analysis Aim of the economic and financial analysis is to reflect economic efficiency so that conclusions can be made with regard to the realisation of the project. The financial and economic analysis shall among others comprise four issues: 1.
Is it possible to extract the coal at a competitively reasonable price?
2.
Which rate of return will be earned? Will 20 % rate of return be realistic?
3.
Which influence will an escalation of 2 and/or 4% have to all payments and revenues?
4.
Will a lifetime of only 15 years for coal production be sufficient?
The consultants prepared an economic and financial analysis with a detailed cash flow forecast, a financial analysis of the cost benefit of the proposed investment with IRR/ NPV calculations, and a time planning for the investment programme. The output of this task is a detailed, based on annual calculations economic and financial analysis and appraisal of the Sibovc South West mine plan. The calculations have been made in accordance with IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards). Costs of coal production were determined as well as payment plan, a profit and loss account and a balance over the project lifetime. The determination of the operating cost contains among others: -
Future number of employees
-
Future equipment fleet
-
Output capacity of the opencast mine
-
Actual accounting of the opencast mines of Mirash / Bardh
-
Experiences from other international opencast mines
The Real Average Cost (RAC) per unit was determined, calculated on the basis of DCFmethod for an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 10% and 12%. A detailed example of DCF calculation have been given to show the methodology. The economical and financial Analysis was shown especially for an interest rate of equity capital of 20 %. In line with this as well as the necessary rate of interest for debt capital of 6 % and/or. 8 % there results Weighted Average Capital Cost (WACC) of 10 % and/or 12 %. Inflation was considered with 2% (according to Var. 1 and 2) and an additional calculation was made including 4 % (Variant 3 and 4). The low approach of 2% will thereby be more likely because even mineral oil and natural gas are below the price level of the 80ies. According to IFRS the main equipments are depreciated over a period of 12 years. This condition will be achieved at the end of the period under review in the Sibovc opencast mine. Therefore the expected profit increases essentially for the last operating years. The main results of the profitability calculation are as follows: The good deposit conditions contribute to low operative costs but will require relatively high investments within a short period at the beginning of the operation.
Page 12 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
If coal will be sold at a price of 7.00 EURO/t assuming an annual increase by 2 %, the owner will yield remarkable profit of 137 MEURO until 2024 (from the year 2012 to 2019 about 5 MEURO per year and after 2019 approximately 20 MEURO (cost of debt 6%) A second scenario assuming a coal price of 7.5 EURO/t and a cost of debt of 8 % per annum will guarantee a profit for the investor of approx. 9 MEURO per annum from the year 2012 on (after 2019 > 25 MEURO/a). The calculated real average cost (RAC) comes to 7.5-8.0 EURO/t. The costs for the running operation amount to ca. 3.65 EURO/t raw coal. Together with the average costs for the investments to the amount of 2.37 EURO/t there is yielded ca. 6.00 EURO/t raw coal. The remaining 1.50 and/or 2.00 EURO/t raw coal are financing charges. 12,0
10,41
11,0 10,0
8,85
RAC in â&#x201A;Ź/t Lignite
9,0
7,54
8,03
4,26
8,0
7,08
6,30
6,67
0,33
0,69
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
3,0
0,49 0,63
0,48 0,63
0,47 0,64
0,47 0,64
0,46 0,64
0,46 0,65
0,46 0,66
2,0
0,91
0,92
0,92
0,93
0,93
0,94
0,95
0,59
0,59
0,60
0,60
0,61
0,61
0,63
0,98
0,99
1,00
1,01
1,03
1,05
1,09
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
15%
20%
7,0 6,0 5,0
1,08
2,77 1,52
1,99
4,0
1,0 0,0
Personnel
Power & Fuel
Maintenance
other & Royalties
service & mobil Overburden
Invest Expenditure
financing cost
total
Fig.: 1.3-1
Real Average Cost
The calculations show the dependency of the Real Average Cost (RAC) from the discount rate. The costs of financing are depending on the chosen interest of capital. This financing costs both contain the costs for debt capital and the rate of interest for equity capital. The economic analysis also considered that in 2024 a fully functioning opencast mine will be available. This allowed calculation with coal prices of 7.00 EURO/t to 7.50 EURO/t. Totally four variants were assumed containing different coal prices, different escalation and different interest rate on borrowings. As presented the effects on financing are of minor importance. All variants until 2011 require about 80 MEURO equity capital and ca. 200 MEURO debt capital. Assuming a coal price of 7.00 EURO/ton the dividend earned until 2024 will amount to at least 137 MEURO which can be distributed to the shareholders.
Page 13 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Independent from the financing of the commissioning of the Sibovc SW opencast mine the sum of the annual payments for the production of coal is smaller than 5.0 EURO per tonne coal. This applies from 2012, the first year of full production. Precondition for this statement is that main equipment and auxiliary machines will be in a modern and fully functioning condition. Extension of the lifetime would lead to a clear decrease in the cost price of coal. Results and specific Parameters Opencast Mine Sibovc SW Item
Variant 1
Variant 2
Variant 3
Variant 4
Cost of equity
20%
20%
20%
20%
escaleted
2%
2%
4%
4%
IRR = WACC
10 %
12 %
12 %
12 %
Cost of debt
6%
8%
8%
8%
Lignite output in mt
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
RAC to 2024
7.54 €/t
8.03 €/t
7.50 €/t
7.50 €/t
Operating cost
3.65 €/t
3.67 €/t
3.65 €/t
3.65 €/t
Invest cost
3.89 €/t
4.36 €/t
3.85 €/t
3.85 €/t
RAC to 2035
6.96 €/t
7.46 €/t
6.88 €/t
6.88 €/t
RAC to end
6.74 €/t
7.26 €/t
6.63 €/t
6.63 €/t
Coal Price
7.00 €/t
7.50 €/t
7.00 €/t
7.50 €/t
Coal Price in 2010 (begin production)
7.73 €/t
8.28 €/t
8.52 €/t
9.12 €/t
Coal Price in 2024 (end the consideration)
10.20 €/t
10.93 €/t
14.75 €/t
15.80 €/t
Equity payment
74 Mio. €
76 Mio. €
77 Mio. €
75 Mio. €
long time Equity
47 Mio. €
45 Mio. €
43 Mio. €
44 Mio. €
Borrowings to 2011
193 Mio. €
197 Mio. €
203 Mio. €
199 Mio. €
Dividend
137 Mio. €
178 Mio. €
197 Mio. €
294 Mio. €
Perpetuity
22.0 Mio. €
27.6 Mio. €
19.8 Mio. €
27.0 Mio. €
Earning-capacity value
173 Mio. €
197 Mio. €
156 Mio. €
213 Mio. €
366 Mio. €
345 Mio. €
330 Mio. €
450 Mio. €
Assumptions
Financing & dividend
Earning-capacity value
from 01.01.2025 to 31.12.2035
Earning-capacity value from 01.01.2025 to end
Tab.: 1.3-1
Results and specific Parameters
Page 14 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Theoretically there will be a fully functional and equipped opencast mine available in 2024. After this time high surplus could be earned. Even if it is assumed that a sum of 9.0 MEURO/a for running rehabilitation will be needed the earning capacity value (ECV) as of 31.12.2024 would be greater than 300 MEURO. Already with considerations until 2035, i.e. 25 years of production the financial calculation results in an ECV of at least 150 MEURO as of 31.12.2024. 350
earning-capacity value 2024 in MEUR
300
250
200
150
100
50
0 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050
Development earning-capacity value Variant 1 Development earning-capacity value Variant 3
Fig.: 1.3-2
Development earning-capacity value Variant 2 Development earning-capacity value Variant 4
Development of the ECV in 2024 depending from the Lifetime of the OCM
Provided the Sibovc SW opencast mine is brought to a functioning condition – as planned in the CMP – it will be possible to produce coal with favourable terms and profits of 20 % on the employed equity capital can be earned. The cash flow analysis demonstrates that the chosen mine development will be generally profitable even with the short operation time period of only 15 years. An essential assumption for the financial analysis is that the equipment from the phasing out mine operations to be re-used doesn’t have any noteworthy book value. In 2010, the company will extract coal from the new mine for the first time. Until 2011 total payments of 296 MEURO (of it 238 MEURO for investments) are required. The company will need an equity capital base of 74 MEURO (Var.1) to finance the required equipment configuration. The first positive cumulative Cash Flow (CF) before interests and taxes will occur in 2018.
Page 15 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax 200 150 100 50
m EUR
0 -50 -100 -150 -200 -250 -300 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 kum. CF without interest
Fig.: 1.3-3
Investments
Operating Costs
Lignite REVENUES 2 % Escalation
Year
Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax
Within the period until 2012 credits to an amount of about 193 MEURO (dept capital) will have to be taken up. From 2011 onwards the annual coal revenues will be at least as high as the annual payments, means until 2011 the company has to allocate capital. These payments amount to 267 MEURO. With regard to total 74 MEURO coal revenues until 2011 this represents a capital requirement of 193 MEURO (including operational cost until 2011) The sensitivity analysis approves the large dependency of the real average cost (RAC) from the in-vestment expenditures (including financing costs). Furthermore, personnel costs as well as costs for maintenance are relevant. The financial analysis is carried out as an integrated calculation with the following elements: -
Profit and Loss Account
-
Balance Sheet
-
Cash flow Statement
-
Payment Plan
Assuming 70 % debt capital the company will achieve a positive operating result for the first time in 2011. The first dividend payment will be in 2012 after the losses of 2010 have been balanced. Until 2019 the company will earn annually 5 MEURO net profit after taxes on the average. From 2020 this profit will increase to ca. 20 MEURO/a, because the main equipment will be depreciated until that time. A project financing model have been developed and used as basis for the financial analysis. The project will be profitable under the assumptions made with a lignite sales price of 7.00 EUR per ton as of 01/01/2006. Page 16 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
2 Technical Basis for the Financial Analysis Power plant concept and coal demand The specific objectives are the elaboration of a mining plan on the development of the new mine in the Sibovc South West Lignite Field which will identify the necessary technical and operational measures for production and supply of sufficient volumes of coal from the new mine to supply the existing thermal power plants until the end of their lifetime. Considering the potential of the existing mines and the required supply to the Kosovo A and B power plants the following coal extraction from Sibovc SW has been determined: Year
All Mines
Mirash / Bardh
Sibovc SW
2005
6.4
6.4
0
2006
6.8
6.8
0
2007
7.2
7.2
0
2008
7.9
7.9
0
2009
7.8
7.8
0
2010
8.0
4.6
3.4
2011
9.0
3.0
6.0
2012
9.0
0
9.0
2013
9.0
0
9.0
2014
9.0
0
9.0
2015
9.0
0
9.0
SUM
89.1
43.7
45.4
Fig.: 1.3-1
Coal Output
Main mine equipment and mine development The complementary mine plan Sibovc SW describes a mining development beginning in Bardh / Mirash and heading in Northern direction, whereas the village Hade will be bypassed. This is described in the Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW Part I and II.
Page 17 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Fig.: 1.3-2
Mining Position in the Year 2024
Page 18 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3 Economic and Financial Analysis 3.1 Preliminary Remarks Aim of the economic and financial analysis is to reflect economic efficiency so that conclusions can be made with regard to the realisation of the project. Resulting from the previous investigations low coal costs are expected â&#x20AC;&#x201C; even with relatively high interests and a short lifetime of the opencast mine. The description of the financial and economic analysis shall among others comprise the following four issues: 1.
Is it possible to extract the coal at a competitively reasonable price?
2.
Which rate of return will be earned? Will 20 % rate of return be realistic?
3.
Which influence will an escalation of 2 and/or 4% have to all payments and revenues?
4.
Will a lifetime of only 15 years for coal production be sufficient?
Apart from the below explanations the following shall be already mentioned here: To 1) Specific Expenditure The coal deposit is characterized by a favourable overburden : coal ratio. This allows a principally possible coal production at very favourable prices of below 5.00 EURO/t coal. 10,0
10,0
8,0
8,0
7,0 6,0
6,0
5,0 4,0
4,0
3,0 2,0
Lignite output Mio. t/a
tspecific Expenditures in EUR/t coal
9,0
2,0
1,0 0,0 0,0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Personnel other opex Overburden mobil
Fig.: 3.1-1
Electricity other Internal costs Investments
Fuel Royalties Output Lignite
running Maintenance Recultivation RAC-Lignite
Specific Expenditure
Page 19 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The figure above illustrates that in 2012 when the full production capacity will be achieved, the annual payments for coal production will be below 5.00 EURO/t. Precondition for this is that main equipment and auxiliary machines will be in a modern and fully functioning condition. At present these preconditions are not fulfilled in Kosovo. It is intended to provide these preconditions with the available mining plan. â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;This will lead to a clear price raise of the coal owing to the connected initial investments (explained in detail below). To 2) Rate of return The large German energy groups EON and RWE (with a relatively good rating) expect from their company activities a total weighted average capital cost before tax of 9 %. WACC â&#x20AC;Ś Weighted Average Capital Cost = 9% before tax WACC ~ IRR (Internal rate of return) This total weighted average capital cost is derived from the desired return on equity of ca. 9 % after tax and loan capital of ca. 6 % taking account of the capital structure of ca. 30 % equity capital.
RWE AG - Facts & Figures 2005 RWE Group Cost of Capital
RWE is slightly less risky than investing in the DAX as a whole. Risk is reduced since water accounts for a significant portion of the business.
Derivation of RWE Group WACC1) Risk-free interest rate 5.5% Market premium 5.0% Beta factor 0.7 9.0%2) Cost of equity after-tax
According to the tax rate, RWE only has long-term debt interest, only half of which is trade tax-deductable.
Cost of debt before tax Tax shield Tax rate for debt Cost of debt after-tax
6.0% -1.6% 26.4% 4.4%
Equity/debt ratio derived based on market values
Share of equity Share of debt WACC after-tax
30.0% 70.0% 5.8%
Average tax rate WACC before tax
35.0% 9.0%
Weighted average for equity tax rate (39%) and debt tax rate (32%) 1) WACC = weighted average cost of capital. 2) Cost of equity (pretax): 15%.
Tab.: 3.1-1
Example RWE 2005
Page 20 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Also the aim of Vattenfall AB to achieve 11 % rate of return on capital costs before taxes resulting from a rate of return on equity capital of 15 % after taxes will lie below the mentioned 20 %. To 3) Escalation After a high-price period in the first half of the 80ies the world market price for coal (SKE â&#x20AC;&#x201C; hard coal equivalent) has stabilised on a low level at ca 40 EURO/t SKE over the past 20 years. The escalation rate of the development of the coal price is therefore below 2 %. Also for other fuels like mineral oil and natural gas the real price (i.e. the price adjusted by the inflation rate) is now as again below the price at the beginning of the 80ies. To 4) Lifetime of the opencast mine The lifetime of the opencast mine is adjusted to the planned residual lifetime of the existing power plants. For the complementary mining plan this means 15 years. According to IFRS the main equipments are depreciated over a period of 12 years. This condition will be achieved at the end of the period under review in the Sibovc opencast mine. Therefore the expected profit increases essentially for the last operating years. 100.000
Revenue
90.000 80.000 70.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Fig.: 3.1-2
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Revenues until 2024
This is clearly illustrated in the above figure by the strongly increasing yellow area (i.e. the increase in the net profit). Extension of the lifetime would lead to a clear decrease in the cost price of coal.
Page 21 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3.2 General Assumptions and Calculation Method Within the framework of the economic and financial analysis costs of coal production were deter-mined as well as payment plan, a profit and loss account and a balance over the project lifetime. One important goal of the economic investigations is the determination of the exact price at which the coal production is just cost-effective, i.e. the sum of all income is greater than the sum of all expenditures. The determination of the operating cost contains among others: -
Future number of employees
-
Future equipment fleet
-
Output capacity of the opencast mine
-
Actual accounting of the opencast mines of Mirash / Bardh
-
Experiences from other international opencast mines
The following Real Average Cost (RAC) per unit was determined, calculated on the basis of DCF-method for an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 10% and 12%.
3.3 Example for DCF-Method The DCF-method considers the scheduling of investments and/or all relevant expenditures. Apart from the normal investments for example for purchase of new equipment additional expenditures are arising for the new opencast mine opening up, i.e. for the removal of overburden until coal production start. The following figure illustrates this issue. It can be seen that up to achieving of full capacity of the mine the annual ratio overburden : coal (red line) is higher than in the following years.
16,0
8,00
15,0 14,0
7,00
Mio. t and Mio. m続
12,0
6,00
11,0 10,0
5,00
9,0 8,0
4,00
7,0 6,0
3,00
5,0 4,0
2,00
Ratio Overburden : Coal
13,0
3,0 2,0
1,00
1,0 0,0 0,00 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 SUM Overburden
Fig.: 3.3-1
Lignite
Ratio Overburden : Coal
Overburden and Lignite Performance
Page 22 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The expenditures for the opening up of the opencast mine leads to inharmonious payment flows and mean high initial financial load for the company. 100
10,0
80
8,0
70 6,0
60 50 40
4,0
30 20
Lignite output Mio. t/a
total Expenditures in m EUR
90
2,0
10 0 0,0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Personnel Maintenance Royalties Investments
Fig.: 3.3-2
Electricity Other Opex Recultivation Output Lignite
Fuel Other Internal Costs Overburden mobil Lignite REVENUES 2 % Escalation
Total Expenditures
A simple determination of the coal costs according to the average method (also called statistical calculation) does not lead to a representative result because financing of the mentioned initial expenditures was not considered. This shall be explained in an example (period under review 10 years): Example: a) without considering interests A mining company achieves full production of 9.0 mt raw coal with an initial investment of 170 MEURO after a starting phase of 3 years. From this time operating costs are yielded to an amount of 30 MEURO annually as well as follow-up investments of 5 MEURO per annum. (For reasons of simplification inflation was not taken into account, i.e. increasing revenues and expenditures). static calculation year coal Investment costs Operating Costs Interest total costs spezific average cost
0,0%
= total costs / coal
revenues total anual Cash Flow cum total Cash Flow
Tab.: 3.3-1
Mio. t Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. €
total 84,0 -218,0 -290,0
-170,0 -10,0
-508,0
-180,0
€/t
6,05
Mio. € Mio. €
508,0 0,0
Mio. €
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0,0
5,0
7,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
-3,0 -15,0
-5,0 -25,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-18,0
-30,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
3,6
4,3
3,9
3,9
3,9
3,9
3,9
3,9
3,9
3,9
54,4 19,4 -97,1
54,4 19,4 -77,7
54,4 19,4 -58,3
54,4 19,4 -38,9
54,4 19,4 -19,4
54,4 19,4 0,0
30,2 42,3 54,4 54,4 -180,0 12,2 12,3 19,4 19,4 -180,0 -167,8 -155,4 -136,0 -116,6
Calculation Example 1
According to this method Average Cost of coal of 6.05 EURO/t arise. This would be the necessary minimum proceeds at which revenues and expenditures are equal, i.e. the cumulative Cash Flow is 0 over the period under review.
Page 23 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Until achieving of first proceeds, the company has to make expenditures of totally 180 MEURO (see column 0 in the above table). Financing costs for that were not taken into account. b) Consideration of interests: For a comprehensive presentation of a company it is necessary to complement the calculation by the payment of the interests. This also includes interests lost for the entrepreneur because he was not able to put money interest bearing to a bank but uses it for coal production. dynamic calculation (dcf) year coal Investment costs Operating Costs Interest costs total costs
Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. €
10,0%
= total costs / coal
spezific average cost revenues total anual Cash Flow cum total Cash Flow bevor interest cum total Cash Flow
Tab.: 3.3-2
total 84,0 -218,0 -290,0 -122,6 -630,6
€/t
7,51
Mio. € Mio. € Mio. €
630,6 0,0
Mio. €
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0,0
5,0
7,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
-3,0 -15,0 -17,8 -35,8
-5,0 -25,0 -17,4 -47,4
-5,0 -30,0 -15,9 -50,9
-5,0 -30,0 -14,2 -49,2
-5,0 -30,0 -12,3 -47,3
-5,0 -30,0 -10,3 -45,3
-5,0 -30,0 -8,1 -43,1
-5,0 -30,0 -5,7 -40,7
-5,0 -30,0 -3,0 -38,0
-5,0 -30,0 0,0 -35,0
7,2
6,8
5,7
5,5
5,3
5,0
4,8
4,5
4,2
3,9
67,6 24,5 -81,0 -89,1
67,6 26,9 -56,5 -62,2
67,6 29,6 -29,6 -32,6
67,6 32,6 0,0 0,0
-170,0 -10,0 -18,0 -198,0
37,5 52,6 67,6 67,6 67,6 67,6 -198,0 1,7 5,2 16,7 18,4 20,2 22,2 -180,0 -178,5 -173,8 -158,6 -141,8 -123,5 -103,2 -198,0 -196,3 -191,1 -174,4 -156,0 -135,8 -113,6
Calculation Example 2
This calculation shows that over the period under review interests in the amount of 122.6 MEURO are accumulating and therefore the average lowest coal costs to be earned amount to 7.51 EURO/t. All other assumptions remain unchanged. Here also the sum of revenues and expenditures is 0 over the period under review. Auch hier ist die Summe der Einnahmen und Ausgaben über den Betrach-tungszeitraum gleich 0. Mathematic considerations lead now to a simplified calculation. calculation chemata for dcf year coal
Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. €
Investment costs Operating Costs Interest total costs
real average cost
RAC
discounted total costs discounted coal production revenues discounted revenues
10,0% 10,0%
Tab.: 3.3-3
disc costs =--------------disc coal
10,0%
total 84,0 -218,0 -290,0 0,0 -508,0
€/t
7,51
Mio. € Mio. € Mio. € Mio. €
-341,3 45,5 630,6 341,3
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0,0
5,0
7,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
9,0
-170,0 -10,0
-3,0 -15,0
-5,0 -25,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-5,0 -30,0
-180,0
-18,0
-30,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-35,0
-163,6 0,0
-14,9 4,1 37,5 31,0
-22,5 5,3 52,6 39,5
-23,9 6,1 67,6 46,2
-21,7 5,6 67,6 42,0
-19,8 5,1 67,6 38,1
-18,0 4,6 67,6 34,7
-16,3 4,2 67,6 31,5
-14,8 3,8 67,6 28,7
-13,5 3,5 67,6 26,1
-12,3 3,2 67,6 23,7
0,0
Calculation Example 3
By discounting of both expenditures and quantities the division of the sums yields the same result like in figure 5: real average cost (RAC) of 7.51 EURO/t. So it will not be necessary to calculate the annual interests for the determination of the RAC. In this calculation the total discounted costs are equal to the total discounted revenues.
Page 24 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
For reasons of simplification this approach assumes that the return on loan, deposit and equity capital is made at the same interest rate. The interest rate in this dcf-calculation is called internal rate of return (IRR). It does not necessarily represent the interest of the capital market because there are also included risks and hazards. The normal case is calculated with 10 - 12 % consisting of: Basic interest
4-6%
Project risk
2%
Taxes (20%)
2%
Inflation
2%
8 - 10 % real 10 - 12 % escalated.
Another possible approach for calculating the rate of interest is the determination of the Weighted Average Capital Cost (WACC) on the basis of the desired rate of return on equity. WACC before-tax
= ER * CE + CD* DR
There were assumed cost of debt with 6 % and/or 8 %, based on the requirement for an interest rate of 20 % for the employed equity capital and considering the fact that the rating of the company does not yet correspond to the international standard. Therefore this approach yields the following total return on investment: CE … Cost of equity before-tax
20 %
CD … Cost of debt before tax
6%
ER … Equity ratio
30 %
DR … Debt ratio
70 %
WACC before tax
10.2 %
8%
11.6 %
In variants 1 and 2 our illustration therefore refers to the calculation with 10 % and 12 % total return on investment.
Page 25 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3.4 Real Average Cost V2 12% Expenses over whole project life
V1 10%
Total
RAC
RAC
MEURO
EURO/t
EURO/t
328
4.36
3.89
328
2.37
2.37
1.99
1.52
3.67
3.65
144
0.93
0.93
Overburden mobile
27
0.16
0.16
Fuel
31
0.21
0.21
153
1.03
1.01
Other internal Expenses
39
0.26
0.26
Royalties
40
0.25
0.25
Recultivation
0.4
0.00
0.00
Electricity
60
0.40
0.39
Other opex costs
58
0.39
0.39
Mine closure
15
0.04
0.05
3.952
8.03
7.54
Total Investment thereof Investment thereof financing Investment Total Operating Expenditure
567 thereof Maintenance
Personnel Expenses
Total Expenditure (Invest and Operating Exp.)
Coal costs with 12% IRR amount to 8.03 EURO/t as against 7.54 EURO/t with 10% IRR.
Page 26 of 42
RAC EUR/t Coal
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
10,00 9,50 9,00 8,50 8,00 7,50 7,00 6,50 6,00 5,50 5,00 4,50 4,00 3,50 3,00 2,50 2,00 1,50 1,00 0,50 0,00
7,54
8,03
1,99
1,52
2,37
2,37
0,47
0,46
0,64
0,64
0,93
0,93
0,60
0,61
1,01
1,03
10%
Personnel other & Royalties financing cost
Fig.: 3.4-1
12%
Power & Fuel service & mobil Overburden total
Maintenance Invest Expenditure
RAC for 10 % and 12 % total Return on Investment
The costs for the running operation amount to ca. 3.65 EURO/t raw coal. Together with the average costs for the investments to the amount of 2.37 EURO/t there is yielded ca. 6.00 EURO/t raw coal. The remaining 1.50 and/or 2.00 EURO/t raw coal are financing charges which are arising because the payments cannot be distributed proportionally over the lifetime and the main part of these payments ahs to be made before starting production. The period under review only covers 15 years of coal production. This is an unusually short period for an opencast mine. In 2024 there will exist a functioning fully equipped opencast mine with rich coal reserves. With expenditures to the amount of ca. 54 MEURO the opencast mine generates payment surplus to the amount of ca. 35 MEURO. The calculation ends here as per order. Considering the above mentioned expenditures to the amount of ca. 54 MEURO in 2022 (this is the last year with representative payments) further estimations were made with regard to the effects on the RAC when continuing production. From 2025 additional annual investments of 1 EURO/t coal were considered, i.e. 9.0 MEURO/a for rehabilitation for reasons of a reasonable commercial assessment. If the period considered is extended by 10 years there are arising real average cost to the amount of 7.00 EURO/t for 10 % and/or 7.50 EURO/t for 12 % total return on investment.
Page 27 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW Development of the RAC as a function of the lifetime opencast mining 12,0 11,5 11,0 10,5
RAC in EUR/t Coal
10,0 9,5 9,0 8,5 8,0 7,5 7,0 6,5 6,0 5,5 5,0 2015
2020
2025
Development of the RAC with WAAC 10%
Fig.: 3.4-2
2030
2035
2040
2045
Development of the RAC with WAAC 12%
Year
RAC depending on the Interest Rate
Depending on the possible lifetime of the opencast mine, the series illustrates the development of RAC. It can be seen that the RAC limit values of 6.80 EUR for 10 % and/or 7.3 EURO/t for 12 % approach and from 2040, i.e. after a lifetime of ca. 30 years, this value will stay relatively constant. In the economic analyses the following assumptions were concluded from this possible development: Variant 1:
coal price 7.00 EURO, interest rate on borrowings 6.0 %, discount rate 10 %,
Variant 2:
coal price 7.50 EURO, interest rate on borrowings 8.0 %, discount rate 12 %.
3.5 Cash Flow The Cash Flow Analysis describes a variant which can be realised. It fully reflects the opencast mine (like a separate company). Assuming the specific conditions in Kosovo and/or during negotiations about financing conditions (interest rate) there can be achieved cost reduction potentials which are not included in the assumptions. An essential assumption for the financial analysis is that the equipment from the phasing out mine operations to be re-used doesnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t have any noteworthy book value.
3.5.1 Preliminary overburden In 2010 first coal will be extracted. From 2011 the annual coal revenues will be at least as high as the annual payments, i.e. until 2011 the company has to be allocated capital. Until 2011 total payment of 296 MEURO (of it 238 MEURO for investments) are required. With regard to totally 74 MEURO coal revenues until 2011 this represents a capital requirement of 222 MEURO until 2011. Page 28 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax 200 150 100 50
m EUR
0 -50 -100 -150 -200 -250 -300 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 kum. CF without interest
Fig.: 3.5-1
Investments
Operating Costs
Lignite REVENUES 2 % Escalation
Year
Cumulative Cash Flow before Interest and Tax
The first positive cumulative Cash Flow (CF) before interests and taxes will occur in 2018. Assuming that these expenditures are financed with 70 % by credits there are resulting interest expenditures to the amount of 39 MEURO with a loan interest of 6.0 % until 2011. The payments increase therefore to 335 MEURO and the necessary capital requirement to 261 MEURO. Cum Cash Flow with Interest before Tax 150 100 50
m EUR
0 -50 -100 -150 -200 -250 -300 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 kum. CF with interest
Fig.: 3.5-2
Investments
Operating Costs
Interest
Lignite REVENUES 2 % Escalation
Year
Cumulative Cash Flow with Interest before Tax
The cumulative Cash Flow after interests and taxes will only be positive in 2021. Page 29 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Although the CF will only be positive 3 years later such an outside financing is reasonable because only 74 MEURO equity capital will be required instead of 261. In addition the rate of return of the employed capital also increases because the debt capital bears interests of only 6 %. Contrary to the cost of equity the interest on debt capital is fully tax deductible. This releases the company in terms of taxes so that the effective debt capital interest in this variant is only 4.8%. Cost of debt after tax = Cost of debt before tax * (1-tax rate) 4.8% = 6% * (1-20%)
Page 30 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
100 80 60
7.00 â&#x201A;Ź/t
40 20 0 -20
Mio. EUR
-40 -60 -80 -100 -120 -140 -160 -180 -200 -220 -240 -260 2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
cum Investments
cum CF with interest
Investments
Operating Costs
Interest
Lignite REVENUES 2 % Escalation
Fig.: 3.5-3
Year
Expenditures and Revenues until achieving of a positive Operating Result
The detailed payments without interests are presented in the following table.
Page 31 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Projekt: Sibovc - Variant (9,0 mio. tons) - Lignite price 7.00 Euro/t with 2 % Escalation - TEuro ITEM Description
Expenditure Year
Total
2007
escaleted Cost
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Production (Mio. Tons)
123,40
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
1.
Material therof Fuel therof Power therof Material
91.605 31.177 60.428 0
0 0 0
283 127 156
1.268 502 766
3.106 1.050 2.056
4.771 1.626 3.145
5.243 1.905 3.338
5.738 2.102 3.636
5.943 2.127 3.815
6.081 2.147 3.934
6.358 2.211 4.147
6.549 2.248 4.301
6.872 2.347 4.525
7.020 2.369 4.652
7.239 2.417 4.822
2.
Maintenance
143.625
0
258
1.775
4.591
7.382
7.643
8.305
8.858
9.215
9.781
10.222
10.807
11.206
11.687
3.
Labour Cost
152.945
38
1.833
3.450
6.212
7.125
7.873
8.692
9.589
9.874
10.167
10.469
10.780
11.100
11.430
4.
Overburden mobil
27.273
0
1.401
1.299
221
225
345
0
0
0
895
2.105
2.225
3.483
3.553
5.
Other Cost therof Recultivation therof closing mine therof Royalities therof Other Internal Costs therof Other Opex
151.930 458 14.568 39.477 38.971 58.456
0 0 0 0 0 0
398 0 0 0 159 239
1.570 0 0 0 628 942
4.220 0 0 938 1.313 1.969
6.771 0 0 1.689 2.033 3.049
8.538 0 0 2.585 2.381 3.572
9.206 0 0 2.636 2.628 3.942
9.337 0 0 2.689 2.659 3.989
9.453 0 0 2.743 2.684 4.026
9.708 0 0 2.798 2.764 4.146
9.880 0 0 2.854 2.810 4.216
10.245 0 0 2.911 2.934 4.401
10.371 0 0 2.969 2.961 4.441
10.697 115 0 3.028 3.021 4.532
Subtotal opex
567.379
38
4.173
34.623 36.909 39.225
40.930
43.182
44.606
Average opex Cost (Euro/Tons) 4,60
0,00
0,00
0,00
5,40
4,38
3,29
3,55
3,75
3,85
4,10
4,36
4,55
4,80
4,96
72.330
71.287
31.367
23.090
13.850
1.806
6.021
11.021
8.262
4.759
11.241
8.565
6.776
45.645 45.171 43.984
52.171
51.747
51.382
5,80
5,75
5,71
6.
Investment
328.273
39.805
total
895.652
39.842
7,26
0,00
Average Cost (Euro/Tons) with WAAC= 10% RAC
Tab.: 3.5-1
9.362 18.350 26.275 29.642 31.942 33.726
76.503 80.649 49.717 49.364 43.492 33.748 39.747 0,00
0,00
14,62
8,23
4,83
3,75
4,42
5,07
5,02
4,89
7,54
Escalated Expenditures in Sibovc SW
3.6 IRR, Average Costs per Unit For different discounted rates the average cost per unit before tax over the entire project life amount to: 12,0
10,41
11,0 10,0
8,85
RAC in â&#x201A;Ź/t Lignite
9,0
7,54
8,03
4,26
8,0
7,08
6,30
6,67
0,33
0,69
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
2,37
3,0
0,49 0,63
0,48 0,63
0,47 0,64
0,47 0,64
0,46 0,64
0,46 0,65
0,46 0,66
2,0
0,91
0,92
0,92
0,93
0,93
0,94
0,95
7,0 6,0 5,0
1,08
2,77 1,52
1,99
4,0
1,0
0,59
0,59
0,60
0,60
0,61
0,61
0,63
0,98
0,99
1,00
1,01
1,03
1,05
1,09
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
15%
20%
0,0
Personnel
Power & Fuel
Maintenance
other & Royalties
service & mobil Overburden
Invest Expenditure
financing cost
total
Fig.: 3.6-1
Illustration of Dependence on theoretical total Return on Investment
Page 32 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
The calculations show the greater dependency of the Real Average Cost (RAC) from the discount rate. The higher the intended rate of interest, the higher the Real Average Cost. Thereby it becomes apparent that the costs of financing are depending on the chosen interest of capital. Once again it shall be clearly mentioned at this point that this financing costs both contain the costs for debt capital and the rate of interest for equity capital.
3.7 Sensitivity Analysis To illustrate the dependence of Average Costs from the single cost types sensitivity analyses were made from the below mentioned positions. It was examined how the Average Costs will change if this data would vary by +/- 30% annually. (This analysis shows the sensitivity for) Investments Personnel Expenses Electricity Maintenance Other costs Royalties Recultivation Fuel Sensitivity is shown in the following figure:
Page 33 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Personnel Running Maintenance Electricity
Overburden mobil Recultivation Other Internal costs Royalties Other opex Investment
RAC in â&#x201A;Ź/t
Fuel
8,50 8,40 8,30 8,20 8,10 8,00 7,90 7,80 7,70 7,60 7,50 7,40 7,30 7,20 7,10 7,00 6,90 6,80 6,70 6,60 6,50 6,40 6,30 6,20 6,10 6,00 70%
Fig.: 3.7-1
75%
80%
85%
90%
95%
100%
105%
110%
115%
120%
125%
Sensitivity Chart
This analysis again approves the large dependency of the real average cost (RAC) from the investment expenditures (including financing costs). Furthermore, personnel costs as well as costs for maintenance are relevant. Payments for electricity, fuel, other costs and recultivation are of minor influence on the Average Costs.
3.8 Financial Analysis The financial analysis is carried out as an integrated calculation with the following elements: -
Profit and Loss Account
-
Balance Sheet
-
Cash flow Statement
-
Payment Plan
Therefore it is necessary to change investment into year wise depreciation, cost for closing the mine after finishing production into year wise provision and cost for pre-overburden into year wise amortisation. Die opening-up phase will last until 2012. Up to this time about 17 mbcm overburden have to be removed for the opening up of the opencast mine (preliminary overburden).
Page 34 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW 16,0 15,0 14,0 13,0 12,0
Mio. t and Mio. mÂł
11,0 10,0 9,0 8,0 7,0 6,0 5,0 4,0 3,0 2,0 1,0 0,0 2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Overburden without Pre_overburden
Fig.: 3.8-1
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Pre-overburden
2021
2022
2023
2024
Lignite
Pre-Overburden of Sibovc SW Mine
The costs for this overburden removal amount to 59 MEURO. They will be activated and depreciated over the period under review (to 2024). Assuming 70 % debt capital the company will achieve a positive operating result for the first time in 2011. The first dividend payment will be in 2012 after the losses of 2010 have been balanced. 100.000
Revenue
90.000 80.000 70.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Fig.: 3.8-2
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Revenues of Sibovc SW Mine
The capital demand amounts to 261 MEURO up to this time. In the considerations it is assumed that of this sum has to be spent as equity capital.
Page 35 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Until 2019 the company will earn annually 5 MEURO net profit after taxes on the average. From 2020 this profit will increase to ca. 20 MEURO/a, because the main equipment will be depreciated until that time. With regard to this aspect the advantage of a longer lifetime >2024) becomes apparent.
250
Assets
200 150
mio. EUR
100 50 0 2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
-50 -100 -150 -200
equity and liabilities
-250 Land equity Liquid funds
Fig.: 3.8-3
Mine Development & Pre-Op. Exp. Provisions Total assets
Technical plants and equipment liabilities Total equity and liabilities
Equity and Liabilities of Sibovc SW Project
This figure illustrates the capital structure of the company. For financing the necessary equipment as well as the opening-up of the opencast mine the company needs equity capital base of 75 MEURO. Our calculation model considers that from 2013 parts of the equity capital can be step-wise repaid so that in 2024 only 46 MEURO will remain for the company. Until 2011 credits to the amount of 194 MEURO have to be taken up. For reasons of a reasonable commercial assessment revenues for the sale of land were not considered after completion of the reclamation.
3.8.1 Earning-Capacity Value According to the project the consideration ends in 2024. As already mentioned the company will earn after finishing of the depreciations of the main equipment in variant 1 a cash flow (perpetuity) of about 29 MEURO and in variant 2 of 35 MEURO after tax. This approach allows determining the earning-capacity value according to the dcf-method (discounting of the cash flow with the WACC after tax) referring to the 31.12.2024. As already explained there were also considered additional annual investments for rehabilitation to the amount of 1 EURO/t coal, i.e. 9.0 MEURO/a for reasons of a reasonable commercial assessment.
Page 36 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
Regarding a tax rate of 20 % the depreciations lead to a tax release of 1.8 MEURO, so that the annual cash flow would reduce by 7.2 MEURO to 22.0 MEURO in variant 1 and 27.6 in variant 2. The earning-capacity value will be determined with the help of the following formula from the perpetuity. p e-cv = -------------------WACC after-tax e-cv
… earning-capacity value
p
… perpetuity = cash flow – 7. 2 MEUR
WACC after-tax
= WACC before-tax – 2 % tax – 2 % escalation (= 6 % and/or 8 %)
The available calculation earning-capacity value amounts to366 MEURO in variant 1 and 345 MEURO in variant 2. Similar to the real average cost (RAC), the influence of the lifetime of the opencast mine on the earning-capacity value was examined. Development of the earning-capacity value in 2024 as a function of the liftime opencast mine
earning-capacity value 2024 in mio. EUR
300
250
200
150
100
50
0 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050
Development earning-capacity value Variant 1
Fig.: 3.8-4
Development earning-capacity value Variant 2
year
Earning-Capacity Value per 31/12/2024
The figure illustrates that under the assumption made the earning-capacity value approaches the respective limit value. Regarding a consideration until 2050, i.e. a lifetime of 40 years, this value comes to ca. 300 MEURO in both variants. A longer lifetime of the opencast mine would lead to a considerable increase of the earningcapacity value.
Page 37 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3.8.2 Project Financing The financing scheme is fixed as follows: - Equity, local
30 % of invest without new line
- Loans
100 % of account of liabilities - Equity
- Total
100 %
Exception:
Payments for auxiliary equipment are financed to 100% by the manufacturer.
In variant 1 which bases on a total return on investment of 10 % before taxes and which economic analyses was calculated with a coal price of 7.00 EURO/t the following financing variants were assumed: - Auxiliary equipment â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 100 % debt capital over the entire lifetime. Grace period
0 years
Repayment period
5 years
Tenor
5 years
Repayments are to do
in equal portions
Nominal interest rate
6 % p.a.
Bank fees
0 % of loan
- loan conditions for resettlement until 2012: Grace period
3 years
Repayment period
10 years
Tenor
13 years
Nominal interest rate
6% p.a.
Up front Fee
0%
Repayments are to do
in equal portions.
- loan conditions for main equipment to 2012: Grace period
4 years
Repayment period
10 years
Tenor
14 years
Nominal interest rate
6% p.a.
Up front Fee
0%
Repayments are to do
in equal portions.
Page 38 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
- loan conditions for short-term loans for running costs: Nominal interest rate
6% p.a.
Working capital is assumed with 10 % of personnel cost. The income tax rate is 20 %. The surplus after taxes is distributed to the shareholders. In variant 2 with assumed 12 % rate of return on equity and a coal price of 7.50 EURO/t there was used an interest rate of 8 % for the debt capital.
3.9 Cost Calculation, Investment Costs, Operating Costs 3.9.1 General Data for Cost Calculation General assumptions for the mid term plan are as follows: The assumptions presented in the following which were important for the calculations were taken from the accounting period 2004. The quantity structures were evaluated based on commercial grounds. - Currency of the study
EURO
- Discount rate
10 % escalated
- Escalation Rate
2 %/year.
- Cost Base
2005
- Fuel
0.08 EURO/m³+t
- Labour Costs
3,440 EURO/employee/year in 2005
- Maintenance
0.08 EURO/(m³+t)*km
- Overburden (T&S)
2.00 EURO/m³
- Royalties
0.25 EURO/t Lignite
- Tax
20% of profit
- Other Operational expenses
0.15 EURO/m³+t
- Other Internal Costs
0.10 EURO/m³+t
- Electricity
4.00 Cent/kWh
3.9.2 Investment Costs All necessary payments for starting coal production, i.e. purchase and rehabilitation of large equipment and belt conveyors, auxiliary equipment, claim of areas, resettlements and others are included in the investment.
Page 39 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3.9.3 Labour Costs It shall be assumed that the personnel costs in Kosovo will increase more than all the other positions within the coming years. Therefore, our calculation bases on the following assumption: The personnel costs increase in real terms (i.e. without taking into account international inflation) by: 5 %/year until 2014 1 %/year from 2015 Considering an inflation rate of 2 % there are resulting increases in personnel costs to the amount of 7%/year and/or 3%/year. Additional cost for personnel in the amount of 250 TEURO/year was considered in the calculation.
3.9.4 Calculation of Operating Cost Items - Maintenance:
The demand was determined on the basis of the equipment performances and the specific value.
- Overburden (T&S) This performance is assigned to contractors. - Electricity
The specific energy consumption of the heavy equipment and belt conveyor plants was estimated on the basis of their technical condition and available experiences. In addition, a further demand of 5 GWh/a was assumed taking into account data of similar opencast mines. For power purchase there was assumed a European average value of 30 EURO/MWh for the production and 10 EURO/MWh for transmission.
- Fuel:
Basing on the accounting of 2004 and regarding rise in power prices as well as reduced consumption of new equipment, a consumption of 0.08 EURO/m続+t was estimated.
- Royalties:
0.25 EURO/t coal
- Reclamation:
The necessary expenses were estimated after analysing the local circumstances on the basis of experiences.
- Other Costs:
Based on the accounting of 2004 and international experiences a specific value was estimated.
Page 40 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW
3.9.5 General Data and Principles for Cash Flow All amounts paid out an inpayments are escalated with an inflation rate of 2 % per year. The depreciations were calculated according to the valid European Standards of IFRS. Depreciation time
Auxiliary equipment
5 years,
Belt conveyors
10 years,
Heavy-duty equipments
12 years,
Resettlement
10 years,
Energy plants
15 years,
Buildings and workshops
25 years,
Others
10 years,
Payments for real estates are not depreciated. Recultivation is part of operating cost. The shaping of the post-mining area is considered as expenditure and included in the provisions. These expenditures will only activated in 2024 (end of period under review) to the amount of 14 MEURO. The pool of liquidity is calculated with 10 % of the personnel costs per year
3.9.6 Escalation The variants 1 and 2 were calculated with the presently used escalation rate of 2 %. Due to actual development of the energy prices on the world market there is the threatening danger of a rising inflation. Therefore another calculation was made for all expenditures as well as the revenues for the coal with an escalation of 4 %. For the interest rate on borrowings there is assumed percentage of 8 % so that the WAAC will come to 12 %. The coal costs for 12% IRR amount to 7.50 EURO/t.
Page 41 of 42
Part IV Financial Analysis Complementary Mining Plan Sibovc SW Development of the RAC as a function of the lifetime opencast mining 12,0 11,5 11,0
RAC in EUR/t Coal
10,5 10,0 9,5 9,0 8,5 8,0 7,5 7,0 6,5 6,0 5,5 5,0 2015
2020
2025
2030
Development of the RAC 10%
Fig.: 3.9-1
2035
2040
Development of the RAC 12%
2045
Year
Development of the RAC with 4 % Escalation
Assuming a production until 2035, a total return on investment of 12 % would result in a value of ca. 7.00 EURO/t for the RAC. The economic analysis was therefore also carried out for the escalation with 4% assuming a coal price of 7.00 and 7.50 EURO/t coal.
3.9.7 Lignite Sales Price It was explained above that for 70% debt capital employment there can be expected a RAC to the amount of 7.00 EURO with 6 % interest rate on borrowings. The available calculation therefore assumes this lignite price of 7.00 EURO/t as of 01.01.2006. The calculation is nominal, i.e. every year the coal price is increased by the escalation factor compared to the previous year. Because the rating of the company does not correspond to international standards a further consideration was calculated with 8 % interest rate on borrowings. This calculation resulted in another economic analysis with 7.50 EURO/t coal.
Page 42 of 42
Variant 1
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
Project:
Sibovc South West
Coal Price:
7.0 EURO/t
Escalation:
2%
Cost of Debt:
6%
Cost of Equity:
20%
date:
Expenditures
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 1 - Coal Price 7.0 EURO/t,
10.04.06
2 % Escalation, 6 % Cost of debt
in 1,000 EURO
ITEM Description
Expenditure Year
Sum
2007
escalated Cost
2008
Production (mt)
123,40
1.
Energy thereof fuel thereof power
91.605 31.177 60.428
283 127 156
2.
Maintenance
143.625
3.
Labour cost
152.945
4.
Overburden (mobil)
5.
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
1.268 502 766
3.106 1.050 2.056
4.771 1.626 3.145
5.243 1.905 3.338
5.738 2.102 3.636
5.943 2.127 3.815
6.081 2.147 3.934
6.358 2.211 4.147
6.549 2.248 4.301
6.872 2.347 4.525
7.020 2.369 4.652
7.239 2.417 4.822
7.355 2.427 4.928
7.342 2.389 4.952
7.580 2.437 5.143
2.856 742 2.114
258
1.775
4.591
7.382
7.643
8.305
8.858
9.215
9.781
10.222
10.807
11.206
11.687
12.011
12.132
12.679
5.075
1.833
3.450
6.212
7.125
7.873
8.692
9.589
9.874
10.167
10.469
10.780
11.100
11.430
11.770
12.120
12.480
7.944
27.273
1.401
1.299
221
225
345
895
2.105
2.225
3.483
3.553
3.514
3.949
3.999
58
Other Cost thereof recultivation thereof royalties thereof other internal costs thereof other opex thereof mine closure
151.930 458 39.477 38.971 58.456
398
1.570
4.220
6.771
8.538
9.206
9.337
9.453
9.708
9.880
10.245
10.371
159 239
628 942
938 1.313 1.969
1.689 2.033 3.049
2.585 2.381 3.572
2.636 2.628 3.942
2.689 2.659 3.989
2.743 2.684 4.026
2.798 2.764 4.146
2.854 2.810 4.216
2.911 2.934 4.401
2.969 2.961 4.441
10.697 115 3.028 3.021 4.532
10.788 114 3.089 3.034 4.551
10.729 112 3.151 2.987 4.480
10.943 114 3.214 3.046 4.570
19.077 3 2.185 928 1.392 14.568
Subtotal opex
567.379
Average opex cost
4,60
38
38
4.173
9.362 18.350 26.275 29.642 31.942 33.726 34.623 36.909 39.225 40.930 43.182 44.606 45.438 46.270 47.681 35.009 5,40
4,38
3,29
3,55
3,75
3,85
4,10
4,36
4,55
4,80
4,96
5,05
5,14
5,30
5,83
31.367
23.090
13.850
1.806
6.021
11.021
8.262
4.759
11.241
8.565
6.776
7.861
7.581
1.876
775
(Euro/t)
6.
Investment
328.273
Total
895.652
Average cost (Euro/t) 7. 8. 9.
Interest Taxes Net Profit
Total project cost Average cost (Euro/t)
39.805
72.330
71.287
39.842 76.503 80.649 49.717 49.364 43.492 33.748 39.747 45.645 45.171 43.984 52.171 51.747 51.382 53.299 53.851 49.557 35.784
7,26 90.648 34.310 137.239
1.157.848
1.542
4.301
7.736
14,62
8,23
4,83
3,75
4,42
5,07
5,02
4,89
5,80
5,75
5,71
5,92
5,98
5,51
5,96
8.975
10.459 510 2.038
9.913 1.281 5.123
8.786 1.060 4.242
7.499 1.233 4.932
6.632 1.890 7.561
5.787 2.011 8.042
5.077 1.738 6.950
4.145 1.839 7.356
3.400 1.539 6.154
2.386 2.318 9.273
1.515 3.349 13.395
904 4.441 17.763
948 5.370 21.479
643 5.733 22.931
41.384 80.803 88.385 58.692 62.371 59.809 47.836 53.410 61.729 61.010 57.749 65.510 62.840 65.358 71.559 76.958 77.354 65.090
9,38
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
17,26
10,40
6,65
5,32
5,93
6,86
6,78
6,42
7,28
6,98
7,26
7,95
8,55
8,59
10,85
Profit and Loss
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 1 - Coal Price 7.0 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 6 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum I. Operating result 1. Income A. Sales revenues E Mine development & pre-op. exp.
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
1.105.357 59.134
0 1.577
0 9.280
0 20.892
26.277 13.958
47.299 13.428
72.367 0
73.815 0
75.291 0
76.797 0
78.333 0
79.899 0
81.497 0
83.127 0
84.790 0
86.485 0
88.215 0
89.980 0
61.186 0
1.164.492
1.577
9.280
20.892
40.235
60.727
72.367
73.815
75.291
76.797
78.333
79.899
81.497
83.127
84.790
86.485
88.215
89.980
61.186
Personnel expenses Power expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Depreciation Amortisation Other internal costs Other opex Provisions
152.945 60.428 31.177 27.273 143.625 458 39.477 292.975 42.708 38.971 58.456 14.568
38 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1.833 156 127 1.401 258 0 0 815 0 159 239 0
3.450 766 502 1.299 1.775 0 0 3.808 0 628 942 0
6.212 2.056 1.050 221 4.591 0 938 13.143 0 1.313 1.969 350
7.125 3.145 1.626 225 7.382 0 1.689 20.277 0 2.033 3.049 627
7.873 3.338 1.905 345 7.643 0 2.585 22.194 3.285 2.381 3.572 955
8.692 3.636 2.102 0 8.305 0 2.636 23.554 3.285 2.628 3.942 973
9.589 3.815 2.127 0 8.858 0 2.689 23.653 3.285 2.659 3.989 992
9.874 3.934 2.147 0 9.215 0 2.743 21.823 3.285 2.684 4.026 1.011
10.167 4.147 2.211 895 9.781 0 2.798 21.299 3.285 2.764 4.146 1.031
10.469 4.301 2.248 2.105 10.222 0 2.854 22.606 3.285 2.810 4.216 1.051
10.780 4.525 2.347 2.225 10.807 0 2.911 22.905 3.285 2.934 4.401 1.071
11.100 4.652 2.369 3.483 11.206 0 2.969 24.510 3.285 2.961 4.441 1.091
11.430 4.822 2.417 3.553 11.687 115 3.028 21.845 3.285 3.021 4.532 1.112
11.770 4.928 2.427 3.514 12.011 114 3.089 18.406 3.285 3.034 4.551 1.132
12.120 4.952 2.389 3.949 12.132 112 3.151 14.444 3.285 2.987 4.480 1.154
12.480 5.143 2.437 3.999 12.679 114 3.214 10.211 3.285 3.046 4.570 1.175
7.944 2.114 742 58 5.075 3 2.185 7.482 3.285 928 1.392 843
Total Expenses
903.062
38
4.987
13.170
31.843
47.179
56.075
59.754
61.656
60.743
62.524
66.166
68.191
72.068
70.848
68.262
65.153
62.352
32.052
261.430
1.539
4.293
7.722
8.392 13.547 16.292 14.061 13.634 16.054 15.809 13.733 13.306 11.059 13.942 18.223 23.062 27.627 29.134
-1.539
-4.293
-7.722
-8.955
-10.436
-9.889
-8.759
-7.470
-6.602
-5.756
-5.045
-4.112
-3.367
-2.351
-1.479
-859
-778
-471
0
0
0
-563
3.111
6.403
5.302
6.165
9.451
10.053
8.688
9.194
7.693
11.591
16.744
22.203
26.849
28.663
Total income 2. A. B. C D E F G H I J K L
2007
Expenses
Operating result II. Extraordinary income from tangible assets III. Net income from affiliated companies IV. Net interest V. Special net income
0 0 -89.882 0
Net income from ordinary activities Income tax
Net income for the year Application of profits Loss carryback / retaines profits brought forward
Balance-sheet net income NPV to end
Total lignite production
171.548 -34.310
0
0
0
0
-510
-1.281
-1.060
-1.233
-1.890
-2.011
-1.738
-1.839
-1.539
-2.318
-3.349
-4.441
-5.370
-5.733
137.239
0
0
0
-563
2.601
5.123
4.242
4.932
7.561
8.042
6.950
7.356
6.154
9.273
13.395
17.763
21.479
22.931
-563
3.111
-2.038
510
139.277
0
0
0
0
2.038
7.161
4.242
4.932
7.561
8.042
6.950
7.356
6.154
9.273
13.395
17.763
21.479
22.931
123
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
365.922 mt/year
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
date: 10/04/2006
Payment Plan
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 1 - Coal Price 7.0 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 6 % Cost of debt
in 1,000 EURO Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
1.105.357 766 46.800 244.176
3 12.469 29.095
8 24.287 56.670
14 26.927 62.830
26.277 20 9.467 25.540
47.299 22 938 18.739
72.367 25 297 5.980
73.815 27 -3.061 234
75.291 29 -3.441 4.422
76.797 30 -1.978 5.607
1.397.099
41.567
80.965
89.772
61.304
66.999
78.669
71.015
76.301
152.945 60.428 31.177 27.273 143.625 458 39.477 328.273
38
1.833 156 127 1.401 258
3.450 766 502 1.299 1.775
6.212 2.056 1.050 221 4.591
7.125 3.145 1.626 225 7.382
7.873 3.338 1.905 345 7.643
8.692 3.636 2.102
72.330
71.287
938 31.367
1.689 23.090
159 239
628 942
1.313 1.969
39.842
76.503
80.649
1.542
4.301
1.395.173
41.384
1.927
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
78.333 31 -3.340 6.590
79.899 32 -3.356 3.044
81.497 33 -2.439 6.468
83.127 34 -2.420 3.431
84.790 35 -2.546 4.576
86.485 36 -1.575 5.628
88.215 45 -3.431 5.321
89.980 170
61.186 172
80.456
81.613
79.619
85.559
84.171
86.855
90.575
90.151
90.149
61.358
9.589 3.815 2.127
9.874 3.934 2.147
8.305
8.858
9.215
10.167 4.147 2.211 895 9.781
10.469 4.301 2.248 2.105 10.222
10.780 4.525 2.347 2.225 10.807
11.100 4.652 2.369 3.483 11.206
2.585 13.850
2.636 1.806
2.689 6.021
2.743 11.021
2.798 8.262
2.854 4.759
2.911 11.241
2.969 8.565
11.430 4.822 2.417 3.553 11.687 115 3.028 6.776
11.770 4.928 2.427 3.514 12.011 114 3.089 7.861
12.120 4.952 2.389 3.949 12.132 112 3.151 7.581
12.480 5.143 2.437 3.999 12.679 114 3.214 1.876
7.944 2.114 742 58 5.075 3 2.185 775
2.033 3.049
2.381 3.572
2.628 3.942
2.659 3.989
2.684 4.026
2.764 4.146
2.810 4.216
2.934 4.401
2.961 4.441
3.021 4.532
3.034 4.551
2.987 4.480
3.046 4.570
928 1.392 14.568
49.717
49.364
43.492
33.748
39.747
45.645
45.171
43.984
52.171
51.747
51.382
53.299
53.851
49.557
35.784
7.736 1.111
8.975 2.521
510 10.459 4.553 2.038
1.281 9.913 18.778 5.123
1.060 8.786 23.090 4.242
1.233 7.499 22.862 4.932
1.890 6.632 18.698 7.561
2.011 5.787 20.573 8.042
1.738 5.077 21.839 6.950
1.839 4.145 20.017 7.356
1.539 3.400 21.298 6.154
2.318 2.386 21.462 9.273
3.349 1.515 18.982 13.395
4.441 904 12.596 17.763
5.370 948 5.088 21.479
5.733 643 3.858 22.931
80.803
89.496
61.213
66.924
78.587
70.926
76.273
80.427
81.583
79.588
85.527
84.138
86.821
90.540
89.554
82.442
68.948
183
162
276
91
75
82
90
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
597
7.708
-7.590
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987 1.017 1.047 1.078 1.110 1.143 1.177 1.212
1.809
9.516
1.927
Inpayments Sales revenues Interest income Equity contribution Change in liabilities
Total inpayments Expenditure Personnel expenses Energy expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivierung Royalties Investments in assets Plant and construction Other internal costs Other opex Mine closure
Total expenses Income tax Loan interest Loan repayment Distribution of dividend
Total expenses
Change in pool of liquidity
39.805
38.971 58.456 14.568
895.652 34.310 90.648 237.325 137.239
Pool of liquidity
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
Balance Sheet
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 1 - Coal Price 7.0 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 6 % Cost of debt
date: 10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
Assets
Balance
Balance
31.12.07
Balance
Balance
31.12.08 31.12.09
Balance
31.12.10
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
31.12.11 31.12.12 31.12.13 31.12.14 31.12.15 31.12.16 31.12.17 31.12.18 31.12.19 31.12.20 31.12.21 31.12.22 31.12.23 31.12.24
A Fixed assets II 1 2 3
Tangible assets Land Mine development & pre-op. exp. Technical plants and equipment
Total fixed assets
41.381
122.177
210.548
242.729
258.969
247.341
222.308
201.391
187.304
170.982
149.851
134.901
115.671
97.316
83.486
73.338
61.717
51.724
1.265
1.772
2.533
3.309
3.897
4.497
5.544
6.611
7.280
8.390
9.523
10.715
11.915
13.475
15.066
16.689
17.198
17.786
1.577
10.857
31.749
45.706
59.134
55.849
52.564
49.279
45.993
42.708
39.423
36.138
32.852
29.567
26.282
22.997
19.711
16.426
38.540
109.548
176.266
193.714
195.938
186.994
164.201
145.501
134.031
119.884
100.905
88.049
70.904
54.275
42.139
33.652
24.808
17.512
41.381
122.177
210.548
242.729
258.969
247.341
222.308
201.391
187.304
170.982
149.851
134.901
115.671
97.316
83.486
73.338
61.717
51.724
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987
1.017
1.047
1.078
1.110
1.143
1.177
1.212
1.809
9.516
1.927
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987
1.017
1.047
1.078
1.110
1.143
1.177
1.212
1.809
9.516
1.927
243.442 259.757 248.210 223.267 202.378 188.321 172.029 150.929 136.011 116.814
98.493
84.698
75.146
71.233
53.651
B Current assets IV Liquid funds
Total current assets C Financial assets
Total assets
41.565 122.522 211.169
Equity and liabilities A Stockholders' equity
12.469
36.757
63.684
72.588
74.089
74.386
71.325
67.884
65.906
62.566
59.210
56.771
54.351
51.805
50.230
46.800
46.800
46.800
12.469
36.757
63.684
73.151
74.089
74.386
71.325
67.884
65.906
62.566
59.210
56.771
54.351
51.805
50.230
46.800
46.800
46.800
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-563
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
2.038 -2.038
5.123 -5.123
4.242 -4.242
4.932 -4.932
7.561 -7.561
8.042 -8.042
6.950 -6.950
7.356 -7.356
6.154 -6.154
9.273 -9.273
13.395 -13.395
17.763 -17.763
21.479 -21.479
22.931 -22.931
12.469
36.757
63.684
72.588
74.089
74.386
71.325
67.884
65.906
62.566
59.210
56.771
54.351
51.805
50.230
46.800
46.800
46.800
0
0
0
350
978
1.932
2.906
3.898
4.909
5.940
6.991
8.061
9.152
10.264
11.396
12.550
13.725
0
29.095
85.765
147.485
170.503
184.690
171.892
149.036
130.596 117.505,5
103.523
84.728
71.179
53.311
36.425
23.071
15.796
10.709
6.851
27.992
72.475
114.798
126.156
138.919
125.027
111.135
97.243
83.351
69.459
55.567
41.676
27.784
13.892
0
0
0
0
5.691
14.309
18.505
20.658
20.658
18.592
16.526
14.461
12.395
10.329
8.263
6.197
4.132
2.066
0
0
0
0
20.843
54.621
90.839
100.043
112.806
101.526
90.245
78.964
67.684
56.403
45.123
33.842
22.561
11.281
0
0
0
0
1.457
3.545
5.455
5.455
5.455
4.909
4.364
3.818
3.273
2.727
2.182
1.636
1.091
545
0
0
0
0
1.104
13.291
32.687
44.347
45.771
46.865
37.901
33.353
34.154
34.063
29.160
29.503
25.527
22.533
23.071
15.796
10.709
6.851
1.104
7.030
19.959
23.542
29.181
33.323
29.631
25.051
23.885
19.541
15.160
12.919
10.721
8.230
8.005
0
0
0
0
6.261
12.727
20.805
16.590
13.542
8.271
8.302
10.269
14.522
14.000
16.584
14.807
14.303
15.066
15.796
10.709
6.851
243.442 259.757 248.210 223.267 202.378 188.321 172.029 150.929 136.011 116.814
98.493
84.698
75.146
71.233
53.651
I Subscribed equtiy II Capital reserve Profit/Loss brought forward III Revenue reserve V Balance-sheet net income VI Distribution of dividend
Total equity C Provisions D Account payable and other liabilities 1 Long-term liabilities Other Main equipment Resettlement (without farmland) 2 Short-term liabilities Short-term liabilities Supply loan
Total equity and liabilities
41.565 122.522 211.169
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
date:
Equity and Borrowings YEAR
Equity payment Equity repayment Dividend Total repayment to the shareholder
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 1 - Coal Price 7.0 EURO/t,
10.04.06
2 % Escalation, 6 % Cost of debt
in 1,000 EURO Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
74.386
12.469
24.287
26.927
9.467
938
297
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
27.586 137.239 164.825
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 2.038 2.038
0 5.123 5.123
3.061 4.242 7.302
3.441 4.932 8.373
1.978 7.561 9.539
3.340 8.042 11.383
3.356 6.950 10.306
2.439 7.356 9.794
2.420 6.154 8.575
2.546 9.273 11.819
1.575 13.395 14.970
3.431 17.763 21.193
0 21.479 21.479
0 22.931 22.931
2.918 5.455
1.457 87 0
3.545 213 0
5.455 327 0
5.455 327 0
5.455 327 0
4.909 311 545
4.364 278 545
3.818 245 545
3.273 213 545
2.727 180 545
2.182 147 545
1.636 115 545
1.091 82 545
545 49 545
0 16 545
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
56.591 112.806
20.843 1.251 0
54.621 3.277 0
90.839 100.043 112.806 101.526 5.450 6.003 6.768 6.430 0 0 0 11.281
90.245 5.753 11.281
78.964 5.076 11.281
67.684 4.399 11.281
56.403 3.723 11.281
45.123 3.046 11.281
33.842 2.369 11.281
22.561 1.692 11.281
11.281 1.015 11.281
0 338 11.281
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
10.367 20.658
5.691 171 0
14.309 600 0
18.505 984 0
16.526 1.054 2.066
14.461 930 2.066
12.395 806 2.066
10.329 682 2.066
8.263 558 2.066
6.197 434 2.066
4.132 310 2.066
2.066 186 2.066
0 62 2.066
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
69.876 138.919
27.992 1.509 0
72.475 114.798 126.156 138.919 125.027 111.135 4.090 6.762 7.505 8.335 7.918 7.085 0 0 0 0 13.892 13.892
97.243 6.251 13.892
83.351 5.418 13.892
69.459 4.584 13.892
55.567 3.751 13.892
41.676 2.917 13.892
27.784 2.084 13.892
13.892 1.250 13.892
0 417 13.892
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
12.753 65.083
0 0 0
6.261 0 0
12.727 376 1.111
20.805 764 2.521
16.590 1.248 4.553
13.542 995 4.886
8.271 813 5.505
8.302 496 4.391
10.269 498 3.640
14.522 616 2.337
14.000 871 3.566
16.584 840 3.884
14.807 995 5.208
14.303 888 5.080
15.066 858 4.865
15.796 904 4.591
10.709 948 5.088
6.851 643 3.858
8.018 33.323
1.104 33 0
7.030 211 0
19.959 599 0
23.542 706 0
29.181 875 0
33.323 1.000 0
29.631 889 3.692
25.051 752 4.579
23.885 717 1.166
19.541 586 4.344
15.160 455 4.381
12.919 388 2.241
10.721 322 2.198
8.230 247 2.491
8.005 240 225
0 0 8.005
0 0 0
0 0 0
90.648 237.325
29.095 1.542 0
85.765 147.485 170.503 184.690 171.892 149.036 130.596 117.505 103.523 4.301 7.736 8.975 10.459 9.913 8.786 7.499 6.632 5.787 0 1.111 2.521 4.553 18.778 23.090 22.862 18.698 20.573
84.728 5.077 21.839
71.179 4.145 20.017
53.311 3.400 21.298
36.425 2.386 21.462
23.071 1.515 18.982
15.796 904 12.596
10.709 948 5.088
6.851 643 3.858
Resettlement (without farmland) Loans Interest Repayments Main equipment Loans Interest Repayments Other Loans Interest Repayments
20.658 1.175 0
20.658 1.239 0
18.592 1.178 2.066
Total long-term Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments Supply loan Loans Interest Repayments Short-term liabilities Loans Interest Repayments Total borrowings Loans Interest Repayments
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls
Var. 1
100.000 90.000
Revenue 80.000 70.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Var1_7.0_EURO-2 perc Esc_6 perc Debt-110406.xls / f14_profit & loss
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Var. 1 300
Assets
250 200 150
MEURO
100 50 0 -50
2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
-100 -150 -200
Equity and liabilities
-250 -300 Land equity Liquid funds
Mine Development & Pre-Op. Exp. Provisions Total assets
Technical plants and equipment liabilities Total equity and liabilities
Variant 2
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
Project:
Sibovc South West
Coal Price:
7.5 EURO/t
Escalation:
2%
Cost of Debt:
8%
Cost of Equity:
20%
Expenditures
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 2 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date: 10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
ITEM Description
Expenditure Year
2007
Total
escalated cost
2008
Production (mt)
123,40
1.
Energy thereof fuel thereof power
91.605 31.177 60.428
283 127 156
2.
Maintenance
143.625
3.
Labour cost
152.945
4.
Overburden (mobil)
5.
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
1.268 502 766
3.106 1.050 2.056
4.771 1.626 3.145
5.243 1.905 3.338
5.738 2.102 3.636
5.943 2.127 3.815
6.081 2.147 3.934
6.358 2.211 4.147
6.549 2.248 4.301
6.872 2.347 4.525
7.020 2.369 4.652
7.239 2.417 4.822
7.355 2.427 4.928
7.342 2.389 4.952
7.580 2.437 5.143
2.856 742 2.114
258
1.775
4.591
7.382
7.643
8.305
8.858
9.215
9.781
10.222
10.807
11.206
11.687
12.011
12.132
12.679
5.075
1.833
3.450
6.212
7.125
7.873
8.692
9.589
9.874
10.167
10.469
10.780
11.100
11.430
11.770
12.120
12.480
7.944
27.273
1.401
1.299
221
225
345
895
2.105
2.225
3.483
3.553
3.514
3.949
3.999
58
Other Cost thereof recultivation thereof royalties thereof other internal costs thereof other opex thereof mine closure
151.930 458 39.477 38.971 58.456
398
1.570
4.220
6.771
8.538
9.206
9.337
9.453
9.708
9.880
10.245
10.371
159 239
628 942
938 1.313 1.969
1.689 2.033 3.049
2.585 2.381 3.572
2.636 2.628 3.942
2.689 2.659 3.989
2.743 2.684 4.026
2.798 2.764 4.146
2.854 2.810 4.216
2.911 2.934 4.401
2.969 2.961 4.441
10.697 115 3.028 3.021 4.532
10.788 114 3.089 3.034 4.551
10.729 112 3.151 2.987 4.480
10.943 114 3.214 3.046 4.570
19.077 3 2.185 928 1.392 14.568
Subtotal opex
567.379
328.273
Total
895.652
Interest Taxes Net profit
Total project cost Average cost (Euro/t)
38
38
4.173
9.362 18.350 26.275 29.642 31.942 33.726 34.623 36.909 39.225 40.930 43.182 44.606 45.438 46.270 47.681 35.009
4,60
Investment
Average cost (Euro/t) 7. 8. 9.
2010 3,40
Average opex cost (Euro/t) 6.
2009
39.805
72.330
71.287
4,38
3,29
3,55
3,75
3,85
4,10
4,36
4,55
4,80
4,96
5,05
5,14
5,30
5,83
31.367
23.090
13.850
1.806
6.021
11.021
8.262
4.759
11.241
8.565
6.776
7.861
7.581
1.876
775
39.842 76.503 80.649 49.717 49.364 43.492 33.748 39.747 45.645 45.171 43.984 52.171 51.747 51.382 53.299 53.851 49.557 35.784
7,26 119.978 44.545 178.179
1.238.354
5,40
2.056
5.704
10.207
14,62
8,23
4,83
3,75
4,42
5,07
5,02
4,89
5,80
5,75
5,71
5,92
5,98
5,51
5,96
11.848
13.794 671 2.684
13.029 1.623 6.492
11.563 1.491 5.965
9.886 1.763 7.052
8.732 2.499 9.997
7.638 2.691 10.764
6.735 2.479 9.917
5.514 2.661 10.644
4.542 2.429 9.718
3.211 3.296 13.185
2.047 4.410 17.638
1.292 5.553 22.213
1.278 6.508 26.032
904 6.470 25.878
41.898 82.207 90.856 61.565 66.514 64.636 52.767 58.447 66.873 66.264 63.115 70.990 68.436 71.073 77.395 82.909 83.375 69.036
10,04
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
18,11
11,09
7,18
5,86
6,49
7,43
7,36
7,01
7,89
7,60
7,90
8,60
9,21
9,26
11,51
Profit and Loss
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 2 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum I. Operating result 1. Income A. Sales revenues E Mine development & pre-op. exp.
Total income 2. A. B. C D E F G H I J K L
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
1.184.311 65.282
80.669
82.282
83.928
85.606
87.318
89.065
90.846
92.663
94.516
96.407
65.557
23.362
50.677 14.205
79.087
10.684
28.154 14.941
77.536
2.090
1.249.594
2.090
10.684
23.362
43.095
64.882
77.536
79.087
80.669
82.282
83.928
85.606
87.318
89.065
90.846
92.663
94.516
96.407
65.557
152.945 60.428 31.177 27.273 143.625 458 39.477 292.975 47.148 38.971 58.456 14.568
38
1.833 156 127 1.401 258
3.450 766 502 1.299 1.775
6.212 2.056 1.050 221 4.591
7.125 3.145 1.626 225 7.382
7.873 3.338 1.905 345 7.643
8.692 3.636 2.102
9.589 3.815 2.127
9.874 3.934 2.147
8.305
8.858
9.215
10.167 4.147 2.211 895 9.781
10.469 4.301 2.248 2.105 10.222
10.780 4.525 2.347 2.225 10.807
11.100 4.652 2.369 3.483 11.206
815
3.808
938 13.143
1.689 20.277
159 239
628 942
1.313 1.969 350
2.033 3.049 627
2.585 22.194 3.627 2.381 3.572 955
2.636 23.554 3.627 2.628 3.942 973
2.689 23.653 3.627 2.659 3.989 992
2.743 21.823 3.627 2.684 4.026 1.011
2.798 21.299 3.627 2.764 4.146 1.031
2.854 22.606 3.627 2.810 4.216 1.051
2.911 22.905 3.627 2.934 4.401 1.071
2.969 24.510 3.627 2.961 4.441 1.091
11.430 4.822 2.417 3.553 11.687 115 3.028 21.845 3.627 3.021 4.532 1.112
11.770 4.928 2.427 3.514 12.011 114 3.089 18.406 3.627 3.034 4.551 1.132
12.120 4.952 2.389 3.949 12.132 112 3.151 14.444 3.627 2.987 4.480 1.154
12.480 5.143 2.437 3.999 12.679 114 3.214 10.211 3.627 3.046 4.570 1.175
7.944 2.114 742 58 5.075 3 2.185 7.482 3.627 928 1.392 843
907.502
38
4.987
13.170
31.843
47.179
56.417
60.095
61.998
61.084
62.865
66.508
68.532
72.409
71.190
68.604
65.495
62.694
32.393
342.092
2.053
-119.368
-2.053
Expenses Personnel expenses Power expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Depreciation Amortisation Other internal costs Other opex Provisions
Total expenses
Operating result II. Extraordinary income from tangible assets III. Net income from affiliated companies IV. Net interest V. Special net income
Net income from ordinary activities
5.696 10.192 11.252 17.703 21.119 18.992 18.671 21.198 21.062 19.099 18.786 16.656 19.657 24.059 29.021 33.713 33.163
-11.828
-13.771
-13.004
-11.535
-9.856
-8.702
-7.607
-6.703
-5.481
-4.508
-3.176
-2.011
-1.255
-1.172
-815
-577
3.932
8.115
7.457
8.814
12.496
13.455
12.396
13.305
12.147
16.481
22.048
27.766
32.540
32.348
-671
-1.623
-1.491
-1.763
-2.499
-2.691
-2.479
-2.661
-2.429
-3.296
-4.410
-5.553
-6.508
-6.470
178.179
-577
3.261
6.492
5.965
7.052
9.997 10.764
9.917 10.644
9.718 13.185 17.638 22.213 26.032 25.878
671
-577 -577
3.932 2.684
-2.684
2.684
9.176
5.965
7.052
9.997 10.764
9.917 10.644
9.718 13.185 17.638 22.213 26.032 25.878
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
222.724
-5.696
-10.192
-44.545
Income tax
Net income for the year Application of profits Loss carryback / retaines profits brought forward Accumulated losses brought forward / revenue reserve
Balance-sheet net income
180.863
NPV based 31.12.2024 NPV to 31.12.2035 NPV to end
Total lignite production
197.214 345.313 mt/year
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
123
3,40
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
Payment Plan
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 2 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
1.184.311 610 45.425 249.483
3 12.624 29.455
8 24.708 57.653
14 27.655 64.529
28.154 20 9.635 26.291
50.677 22 1.028 19.307
77.536 25 79 5.830
79.087 27 -3.254 234
80.669 29 -3.625 4.422
82.282 30 -2.172 5.607
83.928 31 -3.564 6.590
85.606 32 -3.582 3.044
87.318 33 -2.659 6.468
89.065 34 -2.632 3.431
90.846 35 -2.751 4.576
92.663 36 -1.780 5.628
94.516 37 -3.705 5.321
96.407 106 -1.049
65.557 89 470 1.097
1.479.830
42.081
82.369
92.199
64.100
71.035
83.470
76.095
81.495
85.747
86.984
85.100
91.160
89.897
92.706
96.547
96.169
95.464
67.212
152.945 60.428 31.177 27.273 143.625 458 39.477 328.273
38
1.833 156 127 1.401 258
3.450 766 502 1.299 1.775
6.212 2.056 1.050 221 4.591
7.125 3.145 1.626 225 7.382
7.873 3.338 1.905 345 7.643
8.692 3.636 2.102
9.589 3.815 2.127
9.874 3.934 2.147
8.305
8.858
9.215
10.167 4.147 2.211 895 9.781
10.469 4.301 2.248 2.105 10.222
10.780 4.525 2.347 2.225 10.807
11.100 4.652 2.369 3.483 11.206
72.330
71.287
938 31.367
1.689 23.090
2.585 13.850
2.636 1.806
2.689 6.021
2.743 11.021
2.798 8.262
2.854 4.759
2.911 11.241
2.969 8.565
11.430 4.822 2.417 3.553 11.687 115 3.028 6.776
11.770 4.928 2.427 3.514 12.011 114 3.089 7.861
12.120 4.952 2.389 3.949 12.132 112 3.151 7.581
12.480 5.143 2.437 3.999 12.679 114 3.214 1.876
7.944 2.114 742 58 5.075 3 2.185 775
159 239
628 942
1.313 1.969
2.033 3.049
2.381 3.572
2.628 3.942
2.659 3.989
2.684 4.026
2.764 4.146
2.810 4.216
2.934 4.401
2.961 4.441
3.021 4.532
3.034 4.551
2.987 4.480
3.046 4.570
928 1.392 14.568
39.842
76.503
80.649
49.717
49.364
43.492
33.748
39.747
45.645
45.171
43.984
52.171
51.747
51.382
53.299
53.851
49.557
35.784
2.056
5.704
10.207 1.067
11.848 2.444
671 13.794 4.446 2.684
1.623 13.029 18.752 6.492
1.491 11.563 23.238 5.965
1.763 9.886 23.020 7.052
2.499 8.732 18.845 9.997
2.691 7.638 20.690 10.764
2.479 6.735 21.954 9.917
2.661 5.514 20.138 10.644
2.429 4.542 21.428 9.718
3.296 3.211 21.599 13.185
4.410 2.047 19.117 17.638
5.553 1.292 13.224 22.213
6.508 1.278 7.536 26.032
6.470 904 3.877 25.878
1.479.730
41.898
82.207
91.923
64.009
70.960
83.388
76.005
81.467
85.718
86.954
85.069
91.128
89.864
92.672
96.512
96.133
90.912
72.912
100
183
162
276
91
75
82
90
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
4.552
-5.700
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987 1.017 1.047 1.078 1.110 1.143 1.177 1.212
1.248
5.800
100
Inpayments Sales revenues Interest income Equity contribution Change in liabilities
Total inpayments Expenditure Personnel expenses Energy expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Investments in assets Plant and construction Other internal costs Other opex Mine closure
Total expenses Income tax Loan interest Loan repayment Distribution of dividend
Total expenses
39.805
38.971 58.456 14.568
895.652 44.545 119.978 241.376 178.179
Change in pool of liquidity
Pool of liquidity
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
Balance Sheet
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 2 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
2 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
Assets
Balance
Balance
31.12.07
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
31.12.08 31.12.09 31.12.10 31.12.11 31.12.12 31.12.13 31.12.14 31.12.15 31.12.16 31.12.17 31.12.18 31.12.19 31.12.20 31.12.21 31.12.22 31.12.23 31.12.24
A Fixed assets II 1 2 3
Tangible assets Land Mine development & pre-op. exp. Technical plants and equipment
Total fixed assets
41.895
124.094
214.935
248.100
265.117
253.147
227.773
206.514
192.086
175.422
153.949
138.659
119.087
100.390
86.219
75.728
63.766
53.432
1.265
1.772
2.533
3.309
3.897
4.497
5.544
6.611
7.280
8.390
9.523
10.715
11.915
13.475
15.066
16.689
17.198
17.786
2.090
12.774
36.136
51.077
65.282
61.655
58.029
54.402
50.775
47.148
43.521
39.895
36.268
32.641
29.014
25.388
21.761
18.134
38.540
109.548
176.266
193.714
195.938
186.994
164.201
145.501
134.031
119.884
100.905
88.049
70.904
54.275
42.139
33.652
24.808
17.512
41.895
124.094
214.935
248.100
265.117
253.147
227.773
206.514
192.086
175.422
153.949
138.659
119.087
100.390
86.219
75.728
63.766
53.432
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987
1.017
1.047
1.078
1.110
1.143
1.177
1.212
1.248
5.800
100
183
345
621
713
787
869
959
987
1.017
1.047
1.078
1.110
1.143
1.177
1.212
1.248
5.800
100
B Current assets IV Liquid funds
Total current assets C Financial assets
Total assets
42.078 124.439 215.557
248.812 265.905 254.016 228.732 207.502 193.103 176.469 155.027 139.769 120.230 101.567 87.431 76.976 69.567 53.532
Equity and liabilities A Stockholders' equity I Subscribed equtiy II Capital reserve Profit/Loss brought forward III Revenue reserve V Balance-sheet net income VI Distribution of dividend
Total equity C Provisions D Account payable and other liabilities 1 Long-term liabilities Other Main equipment Resettlement (without farmland) 2 Short-term liabilities Short-term liabilities Supply loan
Total equity and liabilities
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
12.624
37.332
64.987
74.046
75.650
75.729
72.475
68.851
66.678
63.114
59.532
56.873
54.240
51.489
49.709
46.004
44.955
45.425
12.624
37.332
64.987
74.623
75.650
75.729
72.475
68.851
66.678
63.114
59.532
56.873
54.240
51.489
49.709
46.004
44.955
45.425
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-577
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
2.684 -2.684
6.492 -6.492
5.965 -5.965
7.052 -7.052
9.997 -9.997
10.764 -10.764
9.917 -9.917
10.644 -10.644
9.718 -9.718
13.185 -13.185
17.638 -17.638
22.213 -22.213
26.032 -26.032
25.878 -25.878
12.624
37.332
64.987
74.046
75.650
75.729
72.475
68.851
66.678
63.114
59.532
56.873
54.240
51.489
49.709
46.004
44.955
45.425
0
0
0
350
978
1.932
2.906
3.898
4.909
5.940
6.991
8.061
9.152
10.264
11.396
12.550
13.725
0
29.455
87.107
150.569
174.416
189.277
176.355
153.351
134.753 121.515,3
107.415
88.505
74.835
56.837
39.814
26.325
18.422
10.886
8.106
27.992
72.475
114.798
126.156
138.919
125.027
111.135
97.243
83.351
69.459
55.567
41.676
27.784
13.892
0
0
0
0
5.691
14.309
18.505
20.658
20.658
18.592
16.526
14.461
12.395
10.329
8.263
6.197
4.132
2.066
0
0
0
0
20.843
54.621
90.839
100.043
112.806
101.526
90.245
78.964
67.684
56.403
45.123
33.842
22.561
11.281
0
0
0
0
1.457
3.545
5.455
5.455
5.455
4.909
4.364
3.818
3.273
2.727
2.182
1.636
1.091
545
0
0
0
0
1.463
14.633
35.771
48.260
50.358
51.328
42.216
37.510
38.164
37.956
32.938
33.159
29.053
25.922
26.325
18.422
10.886
8.106
1.463
8.372
23.000
27.334
33.541
37.533
33.748
29.099
27.838
23.329
18.779
16.383
14.049
11.438
11.092
2.447
0
1.097
0
6.261
12.771
20.926
16.817
13.796
8.468
8.411
10.326
14.626
14.159
16.776
15.004
14.484
15.233
15.976
10.886
7.009
42.078 124.439 215.557
248.812 265.905 254.016 228.732 207.502 193.103 176.469 155.027 139.769 120.230 101.567 87.431 76.976 69.567 53.532
date: 10/04/2006
Equity and Borrowings
in 1,000 EURO
YEAR
Sum
Equity payment Equity repayment Dividend Total repayment to the shareholder
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 2 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
2010
2011
2012
2 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
2007
2008
2009
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
76.199
12.624
24.708
27.655
9.635
1.028
79
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
470
30.774 178.179 208.953
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 2.684 2.684
0 6.492 6.492
3.254 5.965 9.219
3.625 7.052 10.676
2.172 9.997 12.169
3.564 10.764 14.328
3.582 9.917 13.499
2.659 10.644 13.303
2.632 9.718 12.350
2.751 13.185 15.936
1.780 17.638 19.419
3.705 22.213 25.918
1.049 26.032 27.081
0 25.878 25.878
3.891 5.455
1.457 117 0
3.545 284 0
5.455 436 0
5.455 436 0
5.455 436 0
4.909 415 545
4.364 371 545
3.818 327 545
3.273 284 545
2.727 240 545
2.182 196 545
1.636 153 545
1.091 109 545
545 65 545
0 22 545
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
75.455 112.806
20.843 1.667 0
54.621 4.370 0
90.839 100.043 112.806 101.526 7.267 8.003 9.025 8.573 0 0 0 11.281
90.245 7.671 11.281
78.964 6.768 11.281
67.684 5.866 11.281
56.403 4.963 11.281
45.123 4.061 11.281
33.842 3.159 11.281
22.561 2.256 11.281
11.281 1.354 11.281
0 451 11.281
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
13.823 20.658
5.691 228 0
14.309 800 0
18.505 1.313 0
16.526 1.405 2.066
14.461 1.239 2.066
12.395 1.074 2.066
10.329 909 2.066
8.263 744 2.066
6.197 578 2.066
4.132 413 2.066
2.066 248 2.066
0 83 2.066
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
93.168 138.919
27.992 2.012 0
72.475 114.798 126.156 138.919 125.027 111.135 5.453 9.016 10.006 11.113 10.558 9.446 0 0 0 0 13.892 13.892
97.243 8.335 13.892
83.351 7.224 13.892
69.459 6.112 13.892
55.567 5.001 13.892
41.676 3.890 13.892
27.784 2.778 13.892
13.892 1.667 13.892
0 556 13.892
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
17.194 64.925
0 0 0
6.261 0 0
12.771 501 1.067
20.926 1.022 2.444
16.817 1.674 4.446
13.796 1.345 4.860
8.468 1.104 5.562
8.411 677 4.479
10.326 673 3.693
14.626 826 2.289
14.159 1.170 3.511
16.776 1.133 3.851
15.004 1.342 5.203
14.484 1.200 5.096
15.233 1.159 4.879
15.976 1.219 4.579
10.886 1.278 5.090
7.009 871 3.877
9.616 37.533
1.463 44 0
8.372 251 0
23.000 690 0
27.334 820 0
33.541 1.006 0
37.533 1.126 0
33.748 1.012 3.784
29.099 873 4.649
27.838 835 1.261
23.329 700 4.509
18.779 563 4.551
16.383 491 2.396
14.049 421 2.334
11.438 343 2.611
11.092 333 346
2.447 73 8.645
0 0 2.447
1.097 33 0
119.978 241.376
29.455 2.056 0
87.107 150.569 174.416 189.277 176.355 153.351 134.753 121.515 107.415 5.704 10.207 11.848 13.794 13.029 11.563 9.886 8.732 7.638 0 1.067 2.444 4.446 18.752 23.238 23.020 18.845 20.690
88.505 6.735 21.954
74.835 5.514 20.138
56.837 4.542 21.428
39.814 3.211 21.599
26.325 2.047 19.117
18.422 1.292 13.224
10.886 1.278 7.536
8.106 904 3.877
Resettlement (without farmland) Loans Interest Repayments Main Equipment Loans Interest Repayments Other Loans Interest Repayments
20.658 1.567 0
20.658 1.653 0
18.592 1.570 2.066
Total long-term Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments Supply loan Loans Interest Repayments Short-term liabilities Loans Interest Repayments Total Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls
Var.2
100.000
Revenue 90.000 80.000 70.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Var2_7.5_EURO-2perc Esc_8 perc Debt-110406.xls / f14_profit & loss
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Var. 2 300
Assets
250 200 150
MEURO
100 50 0 -50
2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
-100 -150 -200
Equity and liabilities
-250 -300 Land equity Liquid funds
Mine Development & Pre-Op. Exp. Provisions Total assets
Technical plants and equipment liabilities Total equity and liabilities
Variant 3
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
Project:
Sibovc South West
Coal Price:
7.0 EURO/t
Escalation:
4%
Cost of Debt:
8%
Cost of Equity:
20%
Expenditures
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 3 - Coal price 7.0 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date: 10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
ITEM Description
Expenditure Year
2007
Sum
escalated Cost
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
Production (mt)
123,40
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
1.
Energy thereof fuel thereof power
116.640 39.548 77.093
0 0 0
300 135 165
1.370 543 828
3.423 1.157 2.265
5.360 1.827 3.533
6.007 2.182 3.825
6.703 2.456 4.247
7.077 2.533 4.544
7.384 2.608 4.777
7.872 2.738 5.135
8.267 2.838 5.429
8.846 3.021 5.824
9.214 3.109 6.105
9.687 3.234 6.452
10.035 3.311 6.724
10.213 3.324 6.889
10.751 3.457 7.294
4.131 1.074 3.057
2.
Maintenance
183.596
0
273
1.919
5.059
8.295
8.756
9.701
10.549
11.190
12.110
12.904
13.911
14.707
15.638
16.387
16.877
17.983
7.339
3.
Labour cost
194.794
39
1.943
3.729
6.846
8.006
9.019
10.153
11.420
11.990
12.588
13.216
13.875
14.568
15.295
16.058
16.860
17.701
11.488
4.
Overburden (mobil)
35.780
0
1.485
1.404
243
253
395
0
0
0
1.108
2.658
2.864
4.572
4.754
4.795
5.493
5.672
84
5.
Other cost therof recultivation thereof royalties thereof other internal costs thereof other opex thereof mine closure
195.868 632 50.582 49.435 74.152
0 0 0 0 0 0
422 0 0 169 253 0
1.696 0 0 679 1.018 0
4.651 0 1.034 1.447 2.170 0
7.608 0 1.898 2.284 3.426 0
9.781 0 2.961 2.728 4.092 0
10.754 0 3.079 3.070 4.605 0
11.120 0 3.202 3.167 4.750 0
11.479 0 3.331 3.259 4.889 0
12.019 0 3.464 3.422 5.133 0
12.472 0 3.602 3.548 5.322 0
13.187 0 3.746 3.776 5.665 0
13.611 0 3.896 3.886 5.829 0
14.314 154 4.052 4.043 6.065 0
14.719 156 4.214 4.139 6.209 0
14.925 155 4.383 4.155 6.232 0
15.522 161 4.558 4.321 6.482 0
27.589 5 3.160 1.342 2.013 21.068
Subtotal opex
726.680
39
4.423 10.118 20.221 29.521 33.957 37.310 40.166 42.044 45.698 49.517 52.683 56.671 59.689 61.994
64.367
5,89
0,00
0,00
0,00
5,95
4,92
3,77
4,15
4,46
4,67
5,08
5,50
5,85
6,30
6,63
6,89
7,15
7,51
8,44
328.273
39.805
72.330
71.287
31.367
23.090
13.850
1.806
6.021
11.021
8.262
4.759
11.241
8.565
6.776
7.861
7.581
1.876
775
39.844 76.753 81.405 51.588 52.611 47.808 39.116 46.187 53.065 53.960 54.277 63.924 65.236 66.464 69.856
71.948
Average opex cost (EURO/t)
6.
Investment
Total Average cost (EURO/t) 7. 8. 9.
Interest Taxes Net profit
Total project cost Average cost (EURO/t)
1.054.953
67.630 50.631
69.506 51.405
8,55
0,00
0,00
0,00
15,17
8,77
5,31
4,35
5,13
5,90
6,00
6,03
7,10
7,25
7,38
7,76
7,99
7,72
8,57
141.931 49.234 196.937
2.155 0 0
6.215 0 0
11.746 0 0
14.293 0 0
16.860 0 0
16.209 98 393
14.495 717 2.869
12.244 1.258 5.031
10.645 2.284 9.136
9.104 2.682 10.727
7.673 2.649 10.598
5.894 3.089 12.357
4.602 2.974 11.896
3.190 4.090 16.360
2.061 5.485 21.941
1.622 6.922 27.688
1.733 8.177 32.708
1.190 8.808 35.232
1.443.055
41.998 82.968 93.150 65.881 69.471 64.508 57.197 64.720 75.130 76.472 75.197 85.265 84.708 90.104 99.343 108.180 112.125 96.636
11,69
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
0,00
0,00
0,00
19,38
11,58
7,17
6,36
7,19
8,35
8,50
8,36
9,47
9,41
10,01
11,04
12,02
12,46
16,11
Profit and Loss
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 3 - Coal price 7.0 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum I. Operating result 1. Income A. Sales revenues E Mine development & pre-op. exp.
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
100.865 0
104.900 0
109.096 0
113.459 0
117.998 0
122.718 0
127.626 0
88.488 0
96.986 100.865 104.900 109.096 113.459 117.998 122.718 127.626
88.488
1.416.282 72.384
0 2.191
0 11.542
0 25.834
28.956 16.740
53.143 16.077
82.904 0
86.220 0
89.669 0
93.255 0
1.488.666
2.191
11.542
25.834
45.696
69.221
82.904
86.220
89.669
93.255
194.794 77.093 39.548 35.780 183.596 632 50.582 325.493 52.277 49.435 74.152 21.068
39 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1.943 165 135 1.485 273 0 0 913 0 169 253 0
3.729 828 543 1.404 1.919 0 0 3.986 0 679 1.018 0
6.846 2.265 1.157 243 5.059 0 1.034 13.932 0 1.447 2.170 506
8.006 3.533 1.827 253 8.295 0 1.898 21.721 0 2.284 3.426 907
9.019 3.825 2.182 395 8.756 0 2.961 23.875 4.021 2.728 4.092 1.381
10.153 4.247 2.456 0 9.701 0 3.079 25.432 4.021 3.070 4.605 1.408
11.420 4.544 2.533 0 10.549 0 3.202 25.549 4.021 3.167 4.750 1.435
11.990 4.777 2.608 0 11.190 0 3.331 23.700 4.021 3.259 4.889 1.463
12.588 5.135 2.738 1.108 12.110 0 3.464 23.302 4.021 3.422 5.133 1.491
13.216 5.429 2.838 2.658 12.904 0 3.602 24.928 4.021 3.548 5.322 1.519
13.875 5.824 3.021 2.864 13.911 0 3.746 25.349 4.021 3.776 5.665 1.548
14.568 6.105 3.109 4.572 14.707 0 3.896 27.420 4.021 3.886 5.829 1.578
15.295 6.452 3.234 4.754 15.638 154 4.052 24.706 4.021 4.043 6.065 1.608
16.058 6.724 3.311 4.795 16.387 156 4.214 21.247 4.021 4.139 6.209 1.638
16.860 6.889 3.324 5.493 16.877 155 4.383 17.141 4.021 4.155 6.232 1.668
17.701 7.294 3.457 5.672 17.983 161 4.558 12.766 4.021 4.321 6.482 1.700
11.488 3.057 1.074 84 7.339 5 3.160 9.527 4.021 1.342 2.013 1.219
Total expenses
1.104.450
39
5.336
14.104
34.660
52.150
63.234
68.171
71.171
71.228
74.512
79.986
83.601
89.690
90.023
88.901
87.198
86.117
44.329
Operating result
384.216
2.152
Total income 2. A. B. C D E F G H I J K L
2007
96.986 0
Expenses Personnel expenses Power expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Depreciation Amortisation Other internal costs Other opex Provisions
II. Extraordinary income from tangible assets III. Net income from affiliated companies IV. Net interest V. Special net income
0 0 -138.045 0
Net income from ordinary activities Income tax
Net income for the year Application of profits Loss carryback / retaines profits brought forward Accumulated losses brought forward / revenue reserve
Balance-sheet net income
6.206 11.730 11.037 17.071 19.670 18.049 18.497 22.028 22.474 20.880 21.298 19.405 23.436 29.097 35.520 41.509 44.158
-2.152
-6.206
-11.730
-14.271
-16.835
-16.180
-14.463
-12.209
-10.608
-9.065
-7.633
-5.852
-4.536
-2.987
-1.670
-909
-624
-118
246.171
0
0
0
-3.234
236
3.489
3.586
6.289
11.420
13.409
13.247
15.447
14.870
20.450
27.427
34.610
40.885
44.040
-49.234
0
0
0
0
0
-98
-717
-1.258
-2.284
-2.682
-2.649
-3.089
-2.974
-4.090
-5.485
-6.922
-8.177
-8.808
196.937
0
0
0
-3.234
236
3.391
2.869
5.031
9.136
10.727
10.598
12.357
11.896
16.360
21.941
27.688
32.708
35.232
0
0
0
-3.234 -3.234
236 -2.998
2.998 393
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
197.330
0
0
0
0
0
393
3.262
5.031
123
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
0
9.136 10.727 10.598 12.357 11.896 16.360 21.941 27.688 32.708 35.232
NPV based 31.12.2024 NPV to 31.12.2035
156.348
NPV to end
330.396
Total lignite production
mt/year
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
Payment Plan
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 3 - Coal price 7.0 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
100.865 41 -4.687 3.842
104.900 43 -4.082 8.325
109.096 67 -3.414 4.502
113.459 204 -1.810 6.123
117.998 391 -1.810 7.679
122.718 713 0 7.402
127.626 1.110 0 0
88.488 1.072 0 0
96.762 100.293 100.061 109.186 110.250 117.977 124.258 130.832 128.736
89.560
Inpayments Sales revenues Interest income Equity contribution Change in liabilities
Total inpayments
1.416.282 3.886 42.833 264.326
0 3 12.657 29.533
0 9 24.941 58.197
0 16 28.373 66.204
28.956 22 10.624 29.012
53.143 26 684 20.538
82.904 29 -1.658 2.460
86.220 32 -4.059 274
89.669 35 -4.696 5.266
1.727.327
42.193
83.146
94.593
68.615
74.391
83.734
82.467
90.274
194.794 77.093 39.548 35.780 183.596 632 50.582 328.273 0 49.435 74.152 21.068
39 0 0 0 0 0 0 39.805
1.943 165 135 1.485 273 0 0 72.330
3.729 828 543 1.404 1.919 0 0 71.287
6.846 2.265 1.157 243 5.059 0 1.034 31.367
8.006 3.533 1.827 253 8.295 0 1.898 23.090
9.019 3.825 2.182 395 8.756 0 2.961 13.850
10.153 4.247 2.456 0 9.701 0 3.079 1.806
11.420 4.544 2.533 0 10.549 0 3.202 6.021
11.990 4.777 2.608 0 11.190 0 3.331 11.021
12.588 5.135 2.738 1.108 12.110 0 3.464 8.262
13.216 5.429 2.838 2.658 12.904 0 3.602 4.759
13.875 5.824 3.021 2.864 13.911 0 3.746 11.241
14.568 6.105 3.109 4.572 14.707 0 3.896 8.565
15.295 6.452 3.234 4.754 15.638 154 4.052 6.776
16.058 6.724 3.311 4.795 16.387 156 4.214 7.861
16.860 6.889 3.324 5.493 16.877 155 4.383 7.581
17.701 7.294 3.457 5.672 17.983 161 4.558 1.876
11.488 3.057 1.074 84 7.339 5 3.160 775
0 0 0
169 253 0
679 1.018 0
1.447 2.170 0
2.284 3.426 0
2.728 4.092 0
3.070 4.605 0
3.167 4.750 0
3.259 4.889 0
3.422 5.133 0
3.548 5.322 0
3.776 5.665 0
3.886 5.829 0
4.043 6.065 0
4.139 6.209 0
4.155 6.232 0
4.321 6.482 0
1.342 2.013 21.068
1.054.953
39.844
76.753
81.405
51.588
52.611
47.808
39.116
46.187
53.065
53.960
54.277
63.924
65.236
66.464
69.856
71.948
69.506
51.405
49.234 141.931 254.699 196.937
0 2.155 0 0
0 6.215 0 0
0 11.746 1.131 0
0 14.293 2.618 0
0 16.860 4.818 0
98 16.209 19.113 393
717 14.495 25.143 2.869
1.258 12.244 25.497 5.031
2.284 10.645 21.572 9.136
2.682 9.104 23.758 10.727
2.649 7.673 24.798 10.598
3.089 5.894 23.851 12.357
2.974 4.602 24.021 11.896
4.090 3.190 20.240 16.360
5.485 2.061 20.090 21.941
6.922 1.622 6.010 27.688
8.177 1.733 6.790 32.708
8.808 1.190 5.248 35.232
1.697.753
41.998
82.968
94.282
68.499
74.289
83.621
82.340
90.217
29.574
194
179
312
116
101
113
127
57
194
373
685
801
902 1.015 1.142 1.199 1.259 1.322 1.388 1.457 2.977 10.610 15.435 32.077 41.898 29.574
93.255 37 -3.340 6.809
96.986 39 -4.890 8.159
Expenditure Personnel expenses Energy expenses Fuel expenses Overburden mobil Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Investments in assets Plant and construction Other internal costs Other opex mine closure
Total expenses Income tax Loan interest Loan repayment Distribution of dividend
Total expenses
Change in pool of liquidity
Pool of liquidity
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
96.702 100.230 60
63
99.995 109.117 108.730 110.344 119.433 114.191 118.915 101.884 66
69
1.521
7.633
4.825
16.642
9.821 -12.324
Balance Sheet
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 3 - Coal price 7.0 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
Assets
Balance 31.12.07
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
31.12.08 31.12.09 31.12.10 31.12.11 31.12.12 31.12.13 31.12.14 31.12.15 31.12.16 31.12.17 31.12.18 31.12.19 31.12.20 31.12.21 31.12.22 31.12.23 31.12.24
A Fixed assets II 1 2 3
Tangible assets Land Mine development & pre-op. exp. Technical plants and equipment
Total fixed assets
41.995
124.955
218.089
252.264
269.710
255.664
228.017
204.468
187.768
168.707
144.517
126.388
103.512
81.561
64.153
50.572
35.660
1.315
1.852
2.675
3.530
4.191
4.879
6.101
7.372
8.184
9.559
10.988
12.523
14.098
16.185
18.356
20.614
21.335
22.887 22.186
2.191
13.733
39.567
56.307
72.384
68.363
64.341
60.320
56.299
52.277
48.256
44.235
40.213
36.192
32.171
28.149
24.128
20.107
38.489
109.370
175.848
192.428
193.135
182.423
157.575
136.776
123.285
106.871
85.273
69.631
49.201
29.184
13.627
1.809
-9.803
-19.406
41.995
124.955
218.089
252.264
269.710
255.664
228.017
204.468
187.768
168.707
144.517
126.388
103.512
81.561
64.153
50.572
35.660
22.887
194
373
685
801
902
1.015
1.142
1.199
1.259
1.322
1.388
1.457
2.977
10.610
15.435
32.077
41.898
29.574
194
373
685
801
902
1.015
1.142
1.199
1.259
1.322
1.388
1.457
2.977
10.610
15.435
32.077
41.898
29.574
42.190 125.328 218.774 253.065 270.612 256.680 229.159 205.667 189.027 170.028 145.905 127.845 106.490 92.171 79.589 82.649 77.558
52.461
B Current assets IV Liquid funds
Total current assets C Financial assets
Total assets
Equity and liabilities A Stockholders' equity I Subscribed equtiy II Capital reserve Profit/Loss brought forward III Revenue reserve V Balance-sheet net income VI Distribution of dividend
Total equity
12.657
37.598
65.972
73.362
74.282
75.622
71.562
66.866
63.526
58.636
53.948
49.867
46.452
44.643
42.833
42.833
42.833
42.833
12.657
37.598
65.972
76.596
77.280
75.622
71.562
66.866
63.526
58.636
53.948
49.867
46.452
44.643
42.833
42.833
42.833
42.833
-3.234
-2.998
393 -393
2.869 -2.869
5.031 -5.031
9.136 -9.136
10.727 -10.727
10.598 -10.598
12.357 -12.357
11.896 -11.896
16.360 -16.360
21.941 -21.941
27.688 -27.688
32.708 -32.708
35.232 -35.232 42.833
12.657
37.598
65.972
C Provisions D Account payable and other liabilities 1 Long-term liabilities Other Main equipment Resettlement (without farmland) 2 Short-term liabilities Short-term liabilities Supply loan
Total equity and liabilities
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
73.362
74.282
75.622
71.562
66.866
63.526
58.636
53.948
49.867
46.452
44.643
42.833
42.833
42.833
506
1.414
2.794
4.202
5.637
7.100
8.591
10.110
11.658
13.236
14.844
16.481
18.150
19.849
133.164 118.400,8
102.802
81.846
66.320
46.801
32.685
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
69.224
55.379
41.534
27.689
13.845
0
29.533
87.729
152.802
179.197
194.917
178.263
153.394
27.999
72.119
113.830
124.107
138.447
124.602
110.758
4.816
10.918
11.423
11.557
11.557
10.401
9.245
8.090
6.934
5.778
4.623
3.467
2.311
1.156
21.669
57.472
96.616
106.759
121.099
108.989
96.879
84.769
72.659
60.549
48.439
36.330
24.220
12.110
96.913
83.068
1.515
3.728
5.792
5.792
5.792
5.213
4.633
4.054
3.475
2.896
2.317
1.738
1.158
579
0
1.534
15.611
38.972
55.090
56.469
53.661
42.637
36.251
35.333
33.578
26.467
24.786
19.112
18.840
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
1.534
8.974
25.278
32.333
38.151
38.505
33.256
26.520
22.950
15.761
9.046
3.745
6.637
13.694
22.757
18.318
15.156
9.381
9.730
12.383
17.817
17.421
21.042
19.112
18.840
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
42.190 125.328 218.774 253.065 270.612 256.680 229.159 205.667 189.027 170.028 145.905 127.845 106.490 92.171 79.589 82.649 77.558
52.461
Equity and Borrowings
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 3 - Coal price 7.0 EURO/t,
date: 10/04/06
in 1,000 EURO
YEAR
Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
Equity payment
77.280
12.657
24.941
28.373
10.624
Equity repayment Dividend Total repayment to the shareholder
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
32.708 32.708
35.232 35.232
684
34.446 196.937 231.383
1.658 393 2.051
4.059 2.869 6.928
4.696 5.031 9.727
3.340 9.136 12.476
4.890 10.727 15.618
4.687 10.598 15.285
4.082 12.357 16.439
3.414 11.896 15.310
1.810 16.360 18.169
1.810 21.941 23.751
27.688 27.688
5.213 440 579
4.633 394 579
4.054 348 579
3.475 301 579
2.896 255 579
2.317 209 579
1.738 162 579
1.158 116 579
579 70 579
0 23 579
0 0
96.879 8.235 12.110
84.769 7.266 12.110
72.659 6.297 12.110
60.549 5.328 12.110
48.439 4.360 12.110
36.330 3.391 12.110
24.220 2.422 12.110
12.110 1.453 12.110
484 12.110
9.245 786 1.156
8.090 693 1.156
6.934 601 1.156
5.778 508 1.156
4.623 416 1.156
3.467 324 1.156
2.311 231 1.156
1.156 139 1.156
46 1.156
72.119 113.830 124.107 138.447 124.602 110.758 5.525 9.086 9.923 11.076 10.522 9.414 13.845 13.845
96.913 8.307 13.845
83.068 7.199 13.845
69.224 6.092 13.845
55.379 4.984 13.845
41.534 3.877 13.845
27.689 2.769 13.845
13.845 1.661 13.845
0 554 13.845
0 0
18.840 1.529 6.395
20.274 1.507 6.245
21.666 1.622 6.010
14.876 1.733 6.790
9.627 1.190 5.248
32.685 3.190 20.240
20.274 2.061 20.090
21.666 1.622 6.010
14.876 1.733 6.790
9.627 1.190 5.248
Resettlement (without farmland) Loans Interest Repayments
4.126 5.792
1.515 121
3.728 298
5.792 463
5.792 463
5.792 463
21.669 1.734
57.472 4.598
96.616 106.759 121.099 108.989 7.729 8.541 9.688 9.203 12.110
4.816 193
10.918 629
11.423 894
Main equipment Loans Interest Repayments
80.729 121.099
Other Loans Interest Repayments
8.182 11.557
11.557 919
11.557 925
10.401 878 1.156
Total long-term Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments
93.037 138.447
27.999 2.047
Supply loan Loans Interest Repayments
6.637
13.694 531 1.131
22.757 1.096 2.618
18.318 1.821 4.818
15.156 1.465 5.268
9.381 1.212 6.048
9.730 750 4.917
12.383 778 4.157
17.817 991 2.725
17.421 1.425 4.238
21.042 1.394 4.705
19.112 1.683 6.432
8.974 269
25.278 758
32.333 970
38.151 1.145
38.505 1.155
33.256 998 5.250
26.520 796 6.736
22.950 688 3.571
15.761 473 7.189
9.046 271 6.715
3.745 112 5.302
3.745
87.729 152.802 179.197 194.917 178.263 153.394 133.164 118.401 102.802 5.795 10.376 11.989 14.041 13.143 11.625 9.853 8.666 7.555 1.131 2.618 4.818 19.113 25.143 25.497 21.572 23.758
81.846 6.681 24.798
66.320 5.383 23.851
46.801 4.452 24.021
20.728 77.746
Short-term liabilities Loans Interest Repayments
7.682 38.505
1.534 46
Total Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments
121.447 254.699
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls
29.533 2.093
Var. 3
130.000 120.000
Revenue
110.000 100.000 90.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
80.000 70.000 60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Var3_7.0_EURO-4perc Esc_8percDebt-110406.xls / f14_profit & loss
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Var.3 300
Assets
250 200 150
MEURO
100 50 0 -50
2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
-100 -150 -200
Equity and liabilities
-250 -300 Land equity Liquid funds
Mine Development & Pre-Op. Exp. Provisions Total assets
Technical plants and equipment liabilities Total equity and liabilities
Variant 4
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
Project:
Sibovc South West
Coal Price:
7.5 EURO/t
Escalation:
4%
Cost of Debt:
8%
Cost of Equity:
20%
Expenditures
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 4 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date: 10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
ITEM Description
Expenditure Year
Sum
2007
escalated Cost
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
Production (mt)
123,40
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
1.
Energy thereof fuel thereof power
116.640 39.548 77.093
0 0 0
300 135 165
1.370 543 828
3.423 1.157 2.265
5.360 1.827 3.533
6.007 2.182 3.825
6.703 2.456 4.247
7.077 2.533 4.544
7.384 2.608 4.777
7.872 2.738 5.135
8.267 2.838 5.429
8.846 3.021 5.824
9.214 3.109 6.105
9.687 3.234 6.452
10.035 3.311 6.724
10.213 3.324 6.889
10.751 3.457 7.294
4.131 1.074 3.057
2.
Maintenance
183.596
0
273
1.919
5.059
8.295
8.756
9.701
10.549
11.190
12.110
12.904
13.911
14.707
15.638
16.387
16.877
17.983
7.339
3.
Labour cost
194.794
39
1.943
3.729
6.846
8.006
9.019
10.153
11.420
11.990
12.588
13.216
13.875
14.568
15.295
16.058
16.860
17.701
11.488
4.
Overburden (mobil)
35.780
0
1.485
1.404
243
253
395
0
0
0
1.108
2.658
2.864
4.572
4.754
4.795
5.493
5.672
84
5.
Other cost thereof recultivation thereof royalties thereof other internal costs thereof other opex thereof mine closure
195.868 632 50.582 49.435 74.152
0 0 0 0 0 0
422 0 0 169 253 0
1.696 0 0 679 1.018 0
4.651 0 1.034 1.447 2.170 0
7.608 0 1.898 2.284 3.426 0
9.781 0 2.961 2.728 4.092 0
10.754 0 3.079 3.070 4.605 0
11.120 0 3.202 3.167 4.750 0
11.479 0 3.331 3.259 4.889 0
12.019 0 3.464 3.422 5.133 0
12.472 0 3.602 3.548 5.322 0
13.187 0 3.746 3.776 5.665 0
13.611 0 3.896 3.886 5.829 0
14.314 154 4.052 4.043 6.065 0
14.719 156 4.214 4.139 6.209 0
14.925 155 4.383 4.155 6.232 0
15.522 161 4.558 4.321 6.482 0
27.589 5 3.160 1.342 2.013 21.068
Subtotal opex
726.680
39
4.423 10.118 20.221 29.521 33.957 37.310 40.166 42.044 45.698 49.517 52.683 56.671 59.689
61.994
64.367
67.630
50.631
5,89
0,00
0,00
0,00
5,95
4,92
3,77
4,15
4,46
4,67
5,08
5,50
5,85
6,30
6,63
6,89
7,15
7,51
8,44
328.273
39.805
72.330
71.287
31.367
23.090
13.850
1.806
6.021
11.021
8.262
4.759
11.241
8.565
6.776
7.861
7.581
1.876
775
39.844 76.753 81.405 51.588 52.611 47.808 39.116 46.187 53.065 53.960 54.277 63.924 65.236 66.464
69.856
71.948
69.506
51.405
Average opex cost (EURO/t)
6.
Investment
Total Average cost (EURO/t) 7. 8. 9.
Interest Taxes Net profit
Total project cost Average cost (EURO/t)
1.054.953
8,55
0,00
0,00
0,00
15,17
8,77
5,31
4,35
5,13
5,90
6,00
6,03
7,10
7,25
7,38
7,76
7,99
7,72
8,57
120.662 73.611 294.445
2.092 0 0
5.784 0 0
10.336 0 0
11.862 87 347
13.902 1.260 5.041
13.069 2.548 10.193
11.553 2.575 10.301
9.784 3.069 12.275
8.599 4.063 16.253
7.491 4.428 17.712
6.619 4.339 17.357
5.322 4.740 18.961
4.452 4.609 18.435
3.190 5.765 23.060
2.061 7.225 28.899
1.622 8.728 34.912
1.733 10.052 40.208
1.190 10.123 40.491
1.543.671
41.936 82.537 91.740 63.883 72.814 73.618 63.546 71.315 81.981 83.590 82.592 92.948 92.732 98.480 108.040 117.210 121.499 103.209
12,51
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
0,00
0,00
0,00
18,79
12,14
8,18
7,06
7,92
9,11
9,29
9,18
10,33
10,30
10,94
12,00
13,02
13,50
17,20
Profit and Loss
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 4 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum I. Operating result 1. Income A. Sales revenues E Mine development & pre-op. exp.
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
103.913 0
108.070 0
112.392 0
116.888 0
121.564 0
126.426 0
131.483 0
136.743 0
94.808 0
99.916 103.913 108.070 112.392 116.888 121.564 126.426 131.483 136.743
94.808
1.517.445 68.959
0 2.128
0 11.112
0 24.423
31.025 15.908
56.939 15.388
88.825 0
92.378 0
96.074 0
1.586.405
2.128
11.112
24.423
46.933
72.327
88.825
92.378
96.074
194.794 77.093 39.548 35.780 183.596 632 50.582 325.493 49.804 49.435 74.152 21.068
39 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1.943 165 135 1.485 273 0 0 913 0 169 253 0
3.729 828 543 1.404 1.919 0 0 3.986 0 679 1.018 0
6.846 2.265 1.157 243 5.059 0 1.034 13.932 0 1.447 2.170 506
8.006 3.533 1.827 253 8.295 0 1.898 21.721 0 2.284 3.426 907
9.019 3.825 2.182 395 8.756 0 2.961 23.875 3.831 2.728 4.092 1.381
10.153 4.247 2.456 0 9.701 0 3.079 25.432 3.831 3.070 4.605 1.408
11.420 4.544 2.533 0 10.549 0 3.202 25.549 3.831 3.167 4.750 1.435
11.990 4.777 2.608 0 11.190 0 3.331 23.700 3.831 3.259 4.889 1.463
12.588 5.135 2.738 1.108 12.110 0 3.464 23.302 3.831 3.422 5.133 1.491
13.216 5.429 2.838 2.658 12.904 0 3.602 24.928 3.831 3.548 5.322 1.519
13.875 5.824 3.021 2.864 13.911 0 3.746 25.349 3.831 3.776 5.665 1.548
14.568 6.105 3.109 4.572 14.707 0 3.896 27.420 3.831 3.886 5.829 1.578
15.295 6.452 3.234 4.754 15.638 154 4.052 24.706 3.831 4.043 6.065 1.608
16.058 6.724 3.311 4.795 16.387 156 4.214 21.247 3.831 4.139 6.209 1.638
16.860 6.889 3.324 5.493 16.877 155 4.383 17.141 3.831 4.155 6.232 1.668
17.701 7.294 3.457 5.672 17.983 161 4.558 12.766 3.831 4.321 6.482 1.700
11.488 3.057 1.074 84 7.339 5 3.160 9.527 3.831 1.342 2.013 1.219
Total expenses
1.101.977
39
5.336
14.104
34.660
52.150
63.044
67.981
70.981
71.037
74.322
79.795
83.411
89.500
89.833
88.710
87.008
85.927
44.139
Operating result
484.428
2.089
Total income 2. A. B. C D E F G H I J K L
2007
99.916 0
Expenses Personnel expenses Power expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Depreciation Amortisation Other internal costs Other opex Provisions
II. Extraordinary income from tangible assets III. Net income from affiliated companies IV. Net interest V. Special net income
0 0 -116.372 0
Net income from ordinary activities Income tax
Net income for the year Application of profits Loss carryback / retaines profits brought forward Accumulated losses brought forward / revenue reserve
Balance-sheet net income
5.776 10.320 12.273 20.178 25.782 24.397 25.093 28.879 29.592 28.274 28.981 27.388 31.731 37.716 44.475 50.816 50.669
-2.089
-5.776
-10.320
-11.839
-13.877
-13.041
-11.521
-9.749
-8.563
-7.452
-6.578
-5.280
-4.344
-2.905
-1.592
-836
-556
-56
368.056
0
0
0
434
6.301
12.741
12.876
15.344
20.317
22.140
21.697
23.702
23.044
28.825
36.124
43.640
50.260
50.613
-73.611
0
0
0
-87
-1.260
-2.548
-2.575
-3.069
-4.063
-4.428
-4.339
-4.740
-4.609
-5.765
-7.225
-8.728
-10.052
-10.123
294.445
0
0
0
347
5.041
10.193
10.301
12.275
16.253
17.712
17.357
18.961
18.435
23.060
28.899
34.912
40.208
40.491
0
0
0
434 0
6.301 0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
347
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,40
6.735
294.445
5.041 10.193 10.301 12.275 16.253 17.712 17.357 18.961 18.435 23.060 28.899 34.912 40.208 40.491
NPV based 31.12.2024 NPV to 31.12.2035
212.854
NPV to end
449.807
Total lignite production
mt/year
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
0 0 123
6,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
9,00
6,00
Payment Plan
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 4 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO Sum
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
1.517.445 4.290 43.861 261.882
0 3 12.638 29.489
0 9 24.812 57.895
0 16 27.950 65.217
31.025 22 9.464 26.106
56.939 26 608 20.161
88.825 29 -641 4.631
92.378 32 -3.942 274
96.074 35 -4.579 5.266
99.916 37 -3.223 6.809
103.913 39 -4.773 8.159
108.070 41 -4.570 3.842
112.392 43 -3.965 8.325
116.888 108 -2.470 4.502
121.564 285 -1.724 6.123
126.426 469 -1.724 7.679
131.483 786 0 7.402
136.743 1.178 0 0
94.808 1.134 0 0
1.827.478
42.130
82.716
93.183
66.617
77.734
92.844
88.742
96.796 103.540 107.337 107.382 116.796 119.029 126.248 132.850 139.672 137.920
95.943
194.794 77.093 39.548 35.780 183.596 632 50.582 328.273 0 49.435 74.152 21.068
39 0 0 0 0 0 0 39.805
1.943 165 135 1.485 273 0 0 72.330
3.729 828 543 1.404 1.919 0 0 71.287
6.846 2.265 1.157 243 5.059 0 1.034 31.367
8.006 3.533 1.827 253 8.295 0 1.898 23.090
9.019 3.825 2.182 395 8.756 0 2.961 13.850
10.153 4.247 2.456 0 9.701 0 3.079 1.806
11.420 4.544 2.533 0 10.549 0 3.202 6.021
11.990 4.777 2.608 0 11.190 0 3.331 11.021
12.588 5.135 2.738 1.108 12.110 0 3.464 8.262
13.216 5.429 2.838 2.658 12.904 0 3.602 4.759
13.875 5.824 3.021 2.864 13.911 0 3.746 11.241
14.568 6.105 3.109 4.572 14.707 0 3.896 8.565
15.295 6.452 3.234 4.754 15.638 154 4.052 6.776
16.058 6.724 3.311 4.795 16.387 156 4.214 7.861
16.860 6.889 3.324 5.493 16.877 155 4.383 7.581
17.701 7.294 3.457 5.672 17.983 161 4.558 1.876
11.488 3.057 1.074 84 7.339 5 3.160 775
0 0 0
169 253 0
679 1.018 0
1.447 2.170 0
2.284 3.426 0
2.728 4.092 0
3.070 4.605 0
3.167 4.750 0
3.259 4.889 0
3.422 5.133 0
3.548 5.322 0
3.776 5.665 0
3.886 5.829 0
4.043 6.065 0
4.139 6.209 0
4.155 6.232 0
4.321 6.482 0
1.342 2.013 21.068
1.054.953
39.844
76.753
81.405
51.588
52.611
47.808
39.116
46.187
53.065
53.960
54.277
63.924
65.236
66.464
69.856
71.948
69.506
51.405
73.611 120.662 252.255 294.445
0 2.092 0 0
0 5.784 0 0
0 10.336 1.131 0
87 11.862 2.618 347
1.260 13.902 4.818 5.041
2.548 13.069 19.113 10.193
2.575 11.553 25.069 10.301
3.069 9.784 25.424 12.275
4.063 8.599 21.499 16.253
4.428 7.491 23.685 17.712
4.339 6.619 24.725 17.357
4.740 5.322 23.778 18.961
4.609 4.452 22.017 18.435
5.765 3.190 20.240 23.060
7.225 2.061 20.090 28.899
8.728 1.622 6.010 34.912
10.052 1.733 6.790 40.208
10.123 1.190 5.248 40.491
1.795.926
41.936
82.537
92.872
66.501
77.632
92.731
88.615
31.552
194
179
312
116
101
113
127
194
373
685
801
902 1.015 1.142 1.199 1.259 1.322 1.388 1.457 5.736 13.264 17.985 34.436 44.067 31.552
Inpayments Sales revenues Interest income Equity contribution Change in liabilities
Total inpayments Expenditure Personnel expenses Energy expenses Fuel expenses Overburden (mobil) Maintenance Recultivation Royalties Investments in assets Plant and construction Other internal costs Other opex Mine closure
Total expenses Income tax Loan interest Loan repayment Distribution of dividend
Total expenses
Change in pool of liquidity
Pool of liquidity
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
96.739 103.480 107.275 107.316 116.727 114.749 118.720 128.130 123.220 128.289 108.457 57
60
63
66
69
4.279
7.528
4.720
16.452
9.631 -12.515
Balance Sheet
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 4 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date:
10.04.06
in 1,000 EURO
Assets
Balance
Balance
31.12.07
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
Balance
31.12.08 31.12.09 31.12.10 31.12.11 31.12.12 31.12.13 31.12.14 31.12.15 31.12.16 31.12.17 31.12.18 31.12.19 31.12.20 31.12.21 31.12.22 31.12.23 31.12.24
A Fixed assets II 1 2 3
Tangible assets Land Mine development & pre-op. exp. Technical plants and equipment
Total fixed assets
41.933
124.462
216.186
249.529
266.286
252.430
224.973
201.614
185.104
166.233
142.234
124.296
101.610
79.848
62.631
49.240
34.519
1.315
1.852
2.675
3.530
4.191
4.879
6.101
7.372
8.184
9.559
10.988
12.523
14.098
16.185
18.356
20.614
21.335
21.936 22.186
2.128
13.240
37.663
53.571
68.959
65.128
61.297
57.466
53.635
49.804
45.973
42.142
38.311
34.480
30.649
26.818
22.986
19.155
38.489
109.370
175.848
192.428
193.135
182.423
157.575
136.776
123.285
106.871
85.273
69.631
49.201
29.184
13.627
1.809
-9.803
-19.406
41.933
124.462
216.186
249.529
266.286
252.430
224.973
201.614
185.104
166.233
142.234
124.296
101.610
79.848
62.631
49.240
34.519
21.936
194
373
685
801
902
1.015
1.142
1.199
1.259
1.322
1.388
1.457
5.736
13.264
17.985
34.436
44.067
31.552
194
373
685
801
902
1.015
1.142
1.199
1.259
1.322
1.388
1.457
5.736
13.264
17.985
34.436
44.067
31.552
B Current assets IV Liquid funds
Total current assets C Financial assets
Total assets
42.127 124.834 216.871 250.329 267.187 253.445 226.115 202.813 186.363 167.555 143.622 125.752 107.346 93.113 80.616 83.676 78.586 53.488
Equity and liabilities A Stockholders' equity I Subscribed equtiy II Capital reserve Profit/Loss brought forward III Revenue reserve V Balance-sheet net income VI Distribution of dividend
Total equity C Provisions D Account payable and other liabilities 1 Long-term liabilities Other Main equipment Resettlement (without farmland) 2 Short-term liabilities Short-term liabilities Supply loan
Total equity and liabilities
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
12.638
37.450
65.401
74.865
75.473
74.831
70.889
66.310
63.087
58.313
53.743
49.778
47.308
45.585
43.861
43.861
43.861
43.861
12.638
37.450
65.401
74.865
75.473
74.831
70.889
66.310
63.087
58.313
53.743
49.778
47.308
45.585
43.861
43.861
43.861
43.861
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
347 -347
5.041 -5.041
10.193 -10.193
10.301 -10.301
12.275 -12.275
16.253 -16.253
17.712 -17.712
17.357 -17.357
18.961 -18.961
18.435 -18.435
23.060 -23.060
28.899 -28.899
34.912 -34.912
40.208 -40.208
40.491 -40.491
12.638
37.450
65.401
74.865
75.473
74.831
70.889
66.310
63.087
58.313
53.743
49.778
47.308
45.585
43.861
43.861
43.861
43.861
0
0
0
506
1.414
2.794
4.202
5.637
7.100
8.591
10.110
11.658
13.236
14.844
16.481
18.150
19.849
0
29.489
87.384
151.470
174.958
190.301
175.820
151.024
130.866 116.176,7
100.651
79.769
64.316
46.801
32.685
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
27.999
72.119
113.830
124.107
138.447
124.602
110.758
96.913
83.068
69.224
55.379
41.534
27.689
13.845
0
0
0
0
4.816
10.918
11.423
11.557
11.557
10.401
9.245
8.090
6.934
5.778
4.623
3.467
2.311
1.156
0
0
0
0
21.669
57.472
96.616
106.759
121.099
108.989
96.879
84.769
72.659
60.549
48.439
36.330
24.220
12.110
0
0
0
0
1.515
3.728
5.792
5.792
5.792
5.213
4.633
4.054
3.475
2.896
2.317
1.738
1.158
579
0
0
0
0
1.490
15.265
37.640
50.851
51.854
51.217
40.266
33.953
33.108
31.427
24.390
22.782
19.112
18.840
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
1.490
8.629
23.945
28.094
33.536
36.062
30.885
24.223
20.726
13.610
6.969
1.740
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6.637
13.694
22.757
18.318
15.156
9.381
9.730
12.383
17.817
17.421
21.042
19.112
18.840
20.274
21.666
14.876
9.627
42.127 124.834 216.871 250.329 267.187 253.445 226.115 202.813 186.363 167.555 143.622 125.752 107.346 93.113 80.616 83.676 78.586 53.488
Equity and Borrowings
Project: Sibovc SW - Variant 4 - Coal price 7.5 EURO/t,
4 % Escalation, 8 % Cost of debt
date: 10/04/06
in 1,000 EURO
Year
Sum
2007
2008
2009
Equity payment
75.473
12.638
24.812
27.950
9.464
608
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
31.612 294.445 326.057
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 347 347
0 5.041 5.041
641 10.193 10.834
3.942 10.301 14.244
4.579 12.275 16.854
3.223 16.253 19.476
4.773 17.712 22.485
4.570 17.357 21.928
3.965 18.961 22.926
2.470 18.435 20.905
1.724 23.060 24.784
1.724 28.899 30.623
0 34.912 34.912
0 40.208 40.208
0 40.491 40.491
4.126 5.792
1.515 121 0
3.728 298 0
5.792 463 0
5.792 463 0
5.792 463 0
5.213 440 579
4.633 394 579
4.054 348 579
3.475 301 579
2.896 255 579
2.317 209 579
1.738 162 579
1.158 116 579
579 70 579
0 23 579
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
80.729 121.099
21.669 1.734 0
57.472 4.598 0
96.616 106.759 121.099 108.989 7.729 8.541 9.688 9.203 0 0 0 12.110
96.879 8.235 12.110
84.769 7.266 12.110
72.659 6.297 12.110
60.549 5.328 12.110
48.439 4.360 12.110
36.330 3.391 12.110
24.220 2.422 12.110
12.110 1.453 12.110
0 484 12.110
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
8.182 11.557
4.816 193 0
10.918 629 0
11.423 894 0
9.245 786 1.156
8.090 693 1.156
6.934 601 1.156
5.778 508 1.156
4.623 416 1.156
3.467 324 1.156
2.311 231 1.156
1.156 139 1.156
0 46 1.156
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
93.037 138.447
27.999 2.047 0
72.119 113.830 124.107 138.447 124.602 110.758 5.525 9.086 9.923 11.076 10.522 9.414 0 0 0 0 13.845 13.845
96.913 8.307 13.845
83.068 7.199 13.845
69.224 6.092 13.845
55.379 4.984 13.845
41.534 3.877 13.845
27.689 2.769 13.845
13.845 1.661 13.845
0 554 13.845
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
20.728 77.746
0 0 0
6.637 0 0
13.694 531 1.131
22.757 1.096 2.618
18.318 1.821 4.818
15.156 1.465 5.268
9.381 1.212 6.048
9.730 750 4.917
12.383 778 4.157
17.817 991 2.725
17.421 1.425 4.238
21.042 1.394 4.705
19.112 1.683 6.432
18.840 1.529 6.395
20.274 1.507 6.245
21.666 1.622 6.010
14.876 1.733 6.790
9.627 1.190 5.248
6.897 36.062
1.490 45 0
8.629 259 0
23.945 718 0
28.094 843 0
33.536 1.006 0
36.062 1.082 0
30.885 927 5.176
24.223 727 6.662
20.726 622 3.497
13.610 408 7.115
6.969 209 6.642
1.740 52 5.228
0 0 1.740
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
120.662 252.255
29.489 2.092 0
87.384 151.470 174.958 190.301 175.820 151.024 130.866 116.177 100.651 5.784 10.336 11.862 13.902 13.069 11.553 9.784 8.599 7.491 0 1.131 2.618 4.818 19.113 25.069 25.424 21.499 23.685
79.769 6.619 24.725
64.316 5.322 23.778
46.801 4.452 22.017
32.685 3.190 20.240
20.274 2.061 20.090
21.666 1.622 6.010
14.876 1.733 6.790
9.627 1.190 5.248
Equity repayment Dividend Total repayment to the shareholder
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
Resettlement (without farmland) Loans Interest Repayments Main equipment Loans Interest Repayments Other Loans Interest Repayments
11.557 919 0
11.557 925 0
10.401 878 1.156
Total long-term Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments Supply loan Loans Interest Repayments Short-term liabilities Loans Interest Repayments Total Borrowings Loans Interest Repayments
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls
Var.4 140.000 130.000
Revenue
120.000 110.000 100.000 90.000
Tâ&#x201A;Ź
80.000 70.000 60.000 50.000 40.000 30.000 20.000 10.000 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Labour Depreciation
Power&Fuel Amortisation
Var4_7.5_EURO-4perc Esc_8perc Debt-110406.xls / f14_profit & loss
Maintenance Provisions
Overb. mobil Interest
Royalties Tax
Recultivation Net Profit
Other Revenue
Year
Var.4 300
Assets
250 200 150
MEURO
100 50 0 -50
2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
-100 -150 -200
Equity and liabilities
-250 -300 Land equity Liquid funds
Mine Development & Pre-Op. Exp. Provisions Total assets
Technical plants and equipment liabilities Total equity and liabilities
Development of the earning-capacity value in 2024 as a function of the liftime opencast mine
earning-capacity value 2024 in MEUR
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050
Development earning-capacity value Variant 1 Development earning-capacity value Variant 3
Development earning-capacity value Variant 2 Development earning-capacity value Variant 4
year