Victoria Wanstrath | On Crumbling Small Towns: Falmouth, Kentucky by DAAP | School of Architecture and Interior Design - Graduate School

On Crumbling Small Towns:

Falmouth, Kentucky By Victoria Wanstrath

Table of Contents Introduction ...... 22 Falmouth, Kentucky ...... 24 Analysis ...... 62 Remediation ...... 64 Representation ...... 70 Revitalization ...... 124 Recreation ...... 146 Conclusion ...... 158 Bibliography ...... 176

Introduction Small town culture reaches way beyond a small population count. The small town is associated with either a certain kind of nostalgic charm or loss. Those two sentiments are both a product of recall and fleeting memory, intimate scale and physical deprivation. A small town is somewhere where everybody knows everyone, but also a place with an inherent lack of privacy. These places, resonant in the collective imagination, are generally rural, often conservative, and in many cases fighting to stay alive. Towns with a healthy local business and job culture to keep residents in town are sustainable, but others are left to a slow demise. Small towns in America are being hit hard by a loss in industry and agriculture. With large commercial entities bogarting every market, the demand for farming and industry in rural areas is depleting. With no strong job base, citizens find themselves commuting elsewhere for work, causing cash-flow outside of their community. However, small-town culture is still appealing to many. Nostalgia will never leave us, it is what we as humans yearn for, and it is what will save small-town America. How can we consider nostalgia as a commodity, bringing into fruition the idea of memory tourism? How might this save one town in particular, a small town in Kentucky called Falmouth? 23

Falmouth, Kentucky Falmouth, Kentucky is a small agricultural town located in Pendleton County, Kentucky along US Highway 27 and the Licking River. It exists equidistant between two major metropolitan areas: Cincinnati, Ohio and Lexington, Kentucky. As of 2019, the population sits at 2,577. Between the years of 2010 and 2018, the population of Falmouth saw a steady increase, but between 2018 and 2019 the population decreased from 2,915 to 2,577. The median household income as of 2019 sits at $31,517, while the poverty rate is at 32.3%. Occupationally, as a small town with limited jobs, the vast majority of employed people commute outside of the city to go to work. The average commute time being around 30 minutes. Those who do work within the city largely work in the agricultural industry, as government employees, or within the school system. In the heart of Falmouth lies the historic downtown area that has, in recent years, been subject to numerous demolition projects, as historic buildings have deteriorated from lack of upkeep. Much of downtown Falmouth is a part of the National Register of Historic Places. Falmouth, while notable for its charm, is most known for its history of natural disasters. 25

fig. 30

fig. 31

fig. 32

fig. 33

fig. 34

fig. 35

fig. 36

fig. 37

The History of Falmouth A History of Flooding To begin a discussion on the city of Falmouth, KY, one must begin with a reflection on its history of flooding. Sitting in a river valley, at the confluence of two forks in the Licking River, Falmouth is in a very precarious position. The flood risk is constant, and in the last century there have been 5 major flood incidents. The flood of 1937, ranked as the worst flood in Cincinnati history, 1945,1948, 1964, and 1997. The Flood of 1997 is the most notable flood to those who are around today, as it was the most recent, and has seemingly had the most lasting impact on the city. The flood took the lives of 5 citizens, and 2400 people had to be evacuated. The water tore railroad tracks from the ground, homes from their foundations, and cars from the streets. A lot of businesses had to shut down indefinitely or relocated after the flood, and this left many vacancies in downtown Falmouth. It has been 24 years since the flood, and with each passing year the citizens of Falmouth see more and more historic buildings coming down as a result of post-flood neglect. Pictured in figure 37 is a flood marker sign, once located on the historic Assembly Building. The Licking River still poses a continuous threat to the citizens of Falmouth. In May of 2020 the river rose past flood stage and was predicted to crest at a level that would cause major flooding once again, though it crested lower than predicted, sparing the city. It became clear then that another flood is imminent in the coming years if 33

fig. 38

there are no preventative measures are taken. The Founding Falmouth, Kentucky was founded in 1776. The earliest recollection of Falmouth is stated as such: At one time the fifty miles below the mouth of the Licking River was one of the favorite crossing places of the Indians for sneaking captives out of Kentucky. In 1780, Colonial Henry Byrd, an official of the British Army, ascended the Licking River at Falmouth with his Canadian and Indian forces, en route to attack pioneer stations in Kentucky. They unloaded their artillery and a cannon on wheels here as they cut the first road through Kentucky over which wheels could travel. The road they cut virtually marked the trail of the present day U.S. Highway 27.1 The terrain ranged from rolling hills to thousands of acres of bottom land in the valleys, as well as springs where the first settlements were made. Settlers made their living by growing flax and cotton, raising sheep, and making clothing out of deer skin. Their cabins were built with logs, clapboard roofs, slab doors hung on deer skin thongs and earthen or puncheon floors. The latter made by splitting logs in two and laying the rounded sides down and flat side up. The windows if any, were usually of deer 1

“The First 200 Years of Pendleton County,”

fig. 39

skin soaked in bear grease and stretched until fairly thin and transparent. Inside the cabin a window shutter was made to slide over the deer skin so it could be barred for protection. The chimneys were made of sticks and clay mixed with deer or pig hair. The logs were motorized together and the clapboards and rafters were held fast with wooden pegs cut by hand from black walnut or hickory.2 The name Falmouth comes from the Virginia settlement of Falmouth, which was brought over from England. The settlers were largely Englishmen and revolutionary soldiers from Virginia. In 1798, Pendleton County was formed from Bracken and Campbell County, and Falmouth became the county seat. Falmouth was chartered on June 23rd, 1792, but the citizens at what was then called “Forks of the Licking,” lived there long before that. From the time frame of 1793-1876 the population of Falmouth grew from 100 to over 1,000. The land that Falmouth comprised of was originally a military land grant, given to Colonel Hall Richardson, and later acquired by John Waller, Alvin Mountjoy, and John Cook. It can be seen how the land was originally divided up in the map in figure 38. The First Formal Architecture The first courthouse in Falmouth was built in 1819 out of stone. John Waller allocated a courthouse square, and the building took up the entire block. In 1848, a new courthouse was constructed on the original site, with 2

“The First 200 Years of Pendleton County,”

fig. 40

fig. 41

lots being sold from the town square to pay for the new courthouse . It is said that an aging John Waller, living at Bunker Hill on his farm, came into town with a shotgun, enraged over the breaking down and selling of the parcels of the courthouse square that he had given. He was put into jail until he cooled off. The courthouse was remodeled in 1848 and has remained the same since. Though no longer used as the courthouse, the building is still in use as the Pendleton County Clerk’s office. Figures 40 and 41 show a historic image of the Falmouth Court House, and the County Clerk’s Office as it is today. Churches The first church in Falmouth was the Baptist church, organized in 1792 by Alex Monroe. In 1793 the Falmouth Christian church was erected, along with the Presbyterian and Lutheran churches. Around 1854 both the Methodist church and the first Catholic church were built. The Christian, Catholic, Methodist, and Baptist churches still have active congregations in Falmouth today. Education Until 1814, students were taught in the homes of “accomplished young ladies” as Ethel Bell put it. The first school was a 20 x 30 feet brick building, built as a private school known as the Seminary. The bricks were burned in Falmouth, and the money for its construction came from the sale of public lands set aside by the state for the establishment of seminaries. The first teacher in Falmouth 39

fig. 42

fig. 43

was Andrew Foster, who was paid only $280.00 for his yearly salary, this being provided by a public subscription and tuition for the school. Eventually, a new location for a larger building was located on 4th street (Figure 42). This school would be called the Pendleton County Academy. The Academy remained active until 1895, teaching the equivalent to high school and junior college.3 The Pendleton County Academy building was demolished to make way for a new high school in 1922. A ‘colored’ school operated out of Falmouth in the 1930s, though there was no colored high school. Local black students who wished to go to high school were sent to the Lincoln Institute, a black high school nearly 100 miles away in Simpsonville, Kentucky, with their room and board paid for. The Falmouth High School finished construction in 1925 (figure 43) and operated as a high school for around 40 years, seeing its last graduating class in 1968. It then operated as the Falmouth Middle School until the Phillip A. Sharp Middle School was built in 1995, and named after Nobel Prize Winner Phillip Allen Sharp who grew up in Falmouth. The building, though not operating as a school, then went on to serve other purposes. Up until 2020, it was known as the Falmouth School Center. Here, people could enroll in GED classes, and for a long time it operated as a location for students to participate in various workshops that tested and strengthened their skills in certain subjects. The gym and stage were used as a practice area for various plays and sports, and the Kincaid Regional Theatre Company put on all their plays here. For many students growing up in the Pendleton County School system from the early 2000s to the late 2010s, the 3

Ethel Bell, “History of Falmouth,”

fig. 44

Falmouth School Center became a place of comfort, where they could escape school to practice something they were passionate about. In 2020, the Falmouth School Center closed its doors to the public entirely, a result of neglect and out-of-control mold from the great flood of 1997. It now sits vacant, taking up a large footprint in the city of Falmouth. Today, the Pendleton County School District includes Pendleton County Memorial High School, constructed in 1957, the Phillip A. Sharp Middle School, and the identical Northern and Southern Elementary Schools, constructed in 1972. Both the high school and twin elementary school received additions in later years. Historic Downtown Falmouth In a 1992 article published by the Courier-Journal, Richard Wilson reflected on Falmouth’s small-town culture: On a recent day, scores of folks filed in and out of the county clerk’s office, where Carol Ockerman and her assistants routinely greeted most people by name. Strangers are easily greeted; downtown parking is easy to find; and nobody seems to worry about taking spaces that signs say are reserved for local officials or police. And, while some locals feign shock that anyone would suggest Falmouth is off the beaten track, it isn’t one of the thriving centers in Kentucky’s ballyhooed Golden Triangle, the area bordered by Cincinnati’s Northern Kentucky suburbs, Louisville 43

fig. 45

and Lexington. In fact it’s hard to find anyone who will be quite as candid as former mayor Max Goldberg, who acknowledges that “we’re in, what do you say, the boondocks” Nevertheless, that’s the way many residents like it.4 Downtown Falmouth consists of parts of Shelby and Main Streets, contained to around 4 total blocks of buildings. Downtown Falmouth saw its prime throughout the 1900s with thriving local businesses and a desirable small-town culture. The Assembly Building One of the most notable buildings in Falmouth’s history is the Assembly Building. Located on the corner of Shelby and Main Streets, the Assembly Building was the first to greet passersby gazing down Shelby Street (formerly Main Cross) from Main. The Assembly Building was built in the original courthouse square in 1892 by Gus Shubert. There were apartments and a recital hall on the top floor, along with retail space on the bottom floor. The retail space wore many hats, originally operating as a dry goods store and a drugstore, then a grocery store, a furniture store, and a watch repair shop. The recital hall was, at different times, the Pendleton Opera House, the Duncan Theater, and the Kentucky Theater. The Assembly Building housed a bank in 1922, a pool hall in 1938, and yet another pool hall in 1946. In 1940, half of the Assembly Building’s retail space became 4 Richard Wilson, “Isolated County Seat is Missing Out on Big City Problems-- and Promises,” The Courier Journal Dec 14, 1992.

fig. 46

fig. 47

Moreland Drugs , while the other half became a furniture store in 1950. Eventually being purchased by Rite-Aid, then CVS, Moreland Drugs relocated to another location on US Highway 27. Murals of false windows were eventually painted over the windows on the second floor and the door on Shelby Street to conceal the decaying and unkept interior.5 The Assembly Building was vacated in 1997 after the flood, then became the home of the Assembly Café, a local bar and restaurant, in 2006. When the Assembly Café went out of business, the Assembly Building remained vacant for several years, and was demolished in 2021 as a result of decades of neglect. Today, the lot is grown over with grass and sits empty, with no current construction plans. (Figure 47) The Masonic Building Another prominent building sitting vacant along Shelby Street is the former Masonic Lodge. Built in 1873, the Masonic Building, pictured to the right , has been a meeting place for the KKK, the Odd Fellows, and the Masons. The Lodge eventually became the home of Houchen’s Clothes and Shoes, a business that still exists in Falmouth today, but has relocated to a different building, likely after the flood of 1997. The Masonic Lodge building could eventually meet the fate of the Assembly building if it continues to be neglected. So long as the structural integrity of the building is intact, the former Masonic Lodge holds great potential as a future commercial space and apartment dwelling should it be restored. 5

Fran Carr, “If the Walls could Talk” 2021

fig. 48

fig. 49

New Pastime Movie Theater Next door to the Masonic Lodge is the former New Pastime movie theater. The theater was relatively small, with only one screen. During the time of segregation, the top floor was referred to as the “crow’s nest” and was reserved for black people6. The sign of New Pastime has always been a distinguishing trait of historic downtown Falmouth, but the building has been vacant since the flood of 1997. As seen in the historic photo on the right, the movie “Scream” was the last movie played at the theater. Much like the Masonic Building, the New Pastime Theater could face demolition should its neglect continue in the coming years. The Citizens Bank Across from the Masonic Building and the New Pastime Theater is the former Citizens Bank Building, which today houses the Smoking Pig, a local barbecue restaurant. The Citizen’s Bank was constructed around 1902, and sometime later became a pizza factory. The building was greatly damaged after a fire in 1996, and parts of the top floor had to be removed. The two photos , to the right show the reduced height of the building following the 1996 fire. The Smoking Pig is a perfect example of a building being restored and continuing to contribute to the downtown culture. With the right investors and enough drive within the community, what remains of historic downtown Falmouth could be salvaged, restoring the business district to its former glory. 6

Fran Carr, “A Stroll through Historic Downtown Falmouth”

fig. 50

fig. 51

There are a handful of other notable building along Shelby and Main Streets that are in dire need of restoration. If Falmouth wants to be what it once was, retaining its historic charm and small-town atmosphere, these buildings must be saved. The Railroad The Kentucky Central Railroad came to Falmouth in 1854, and quickly became important to the development and spread of Falmouth and Pendleton County. Around 1865, the first passenger train ran from Covington to Falmouth. Originally referred to as Kentucky Central, the railroad was later acquired by the Louisville and Nashville Railroad. From there, it was eventually purchased by Seaboard Air Line, which then became a part of Family Lines, and finally merged with Chessie System to form CSX as we know it today. The train was referred to by the people of Falmouth as “The Dinky”: I came to Falmouth on The Dinky in 1918. She came from the South West KY on the III. Central R. R. The ticket agent said there was no such place as Falmouth. When I got off the train the whole town turned out. I thought they had come to meet me, but I learned it was the pastime of the local citizens to meet the train. I looked around and said to myself I wouldn’t stay in this little jerk water town, 46 years later I’m still here. Falmouth had a certain charm in those days. The streets along Shelby and Main were lined with large trees 51

[emphasis added]. It didn’t take long to get to know everyone.7 Several train stations were built in Pendleton County, but as public road conditions improved and the automobile became popular, many of them were rendered useless. The Falmouth Depot building remained in the city until July of 1980 when it burned down. (Figures 50 and 51) The plot of land that previously housed the depot now exists largely as gravel, pavement, and overgrowth. There is opportunity to redevelop the vacant stretches of land along the railroad as extensions of green spaces, and possible direct connections to the river trails. Agriculture and Industry such:

A 1976 newspaper article described Falmouth as The county seat and largest town in Pendleton is Falmouth, settled in 1776. It now presents the image of a pleasant, thoroughly modern but unhurried, Kentucky town of 2,500 inhabitants, with treeshaded streets and well-kept old homes. It is a prosperous farming center and in recent years has acquired flourishing payroll industries.8

As Falmouth was settled early on in Kentucky’s history, it developed a farming economy quickly. The terrain lends itself to it, with hilly limestone soil and 7 8

Ethel Bell, “History of Falmouth,” “Pendleton County - Industry Rises in this Historic Area.” 1976.

fertile bottom-lands along the Licking River forks. After the Civil War, the majority of the farmlands were used to grow tobacco. The failure of the farmers to properly rotate their crops, and the heavy rains that washed away the shallow surface soil led to abandoned farms throughout the city and county.9 One farmer, E.E. Barton, experimented using sweet clover, once thought of as an invasive weed, to recover the lands that would no longer grow crops. Barton’s experiment later became a model in using sweet clover to restore soil quality. The livestock grazed the clover, and farmers were able to move back into their farms and recover from their financial hardship. The farming of sweet clover also led to Pendleton County being known for the production of honey. Eventually, the farmers brought alfalfa raising into their system of building up the land, and alfalfa remains one of the main crops grown to produce hay in Pendleton County today. Between tobacco, sweet clover, alfalfa, cattle, and milk, Falmouth became a thriving and balanced farming region. Today, Pendleton County’s agricultural census states that the majority of its sales come from tobacco, hay, grains, oilseeds, dry beans, peas, and cattle. There are around 1,500 producers of farmed goods, 98 percent of which are family farms.10 Falmouth once had strong industrial ties, producing rebuilt engines, metallurgical limestone, and footwear. The footwear company Scholl Manufacturing once employed over 300 people, while Fuller Manufacturing and Supply Company, making rebuilt engines, employed over 100. Located in the neighboring city of Butler, 9 “Pendleton County - Industry Rises in this Historic Area.” 1976. 10 2017 Census of Agriculture United States Department of Agriculture,[2017]).

Griffin Industries rendered tallow and hides, and the River Mining Company, which produced metallurgical limestone, employed 150.11 While the other businesses closed their doors, Griffin Industries remained until the mid to late 2010s, when it was acquired by DAR PRO Solutions, a company that turns grease and meat byproducts into feed and fuel ingredients. The Butler facility still operates today under the DAR PRO banner. Newer industries include Hilltop Stone rock quarry in Butler, a Rumpke landfill, a Bakery Feeds manufacturing location, an exercise equipment manufacturer, along with a handful of smaller family-owned and operated businesses. As of the 2019 Census, the most common employment sectors among employed people in Falmouth are retail at 247 people, manufacturing at 212 people, and accommodation and food services at 101 people.12 This is not a proper representation of the Falmouth job market itself, however; as the statistics above include individuals who live in Falmouth yet work outside of the city. For those who live and work within Falmouth, main employment sectors likely include retail, food services, government, education, manufacturing, and agriculture. Finding a way to bring more jobs and employment into Falmouth and Pendleton County as a whole would bring more revenue to the city. If citizens are no longer commuting out of the city for work, they will spend more of their money on local businesses.

11 12

“Pendleton County - Industry Rises in this Historic Area.” 1976. “Data USA: Falmouth, Kentucky,”

Kincaid Lake State Park Kincaid Lake State Park, located about 4 miles outside the city of Falmouth, was established around 1958. With 800 acres of land purchased with money raised by Falmouth residents, development of Kincaid Lake State Park began. The Kentucky Department of Fish and Wildlife built a dam at Kincaid Creek which impounded what we now know as Kincaid Lake. In the coming years the State Park would develop a beach, bathhouse, boat dock, picnic areas, internal roads, amphitheater, and parking areas. Today, the park has grown by 50 acres, and houses 84 campsites, as well as a gift shop, grocery, and multipurpose building with seating for up to 240. The Park also maintains a 38-slip marina with boat rentals, a mini-golf course and playground, a 9-hole golf course, a swimming pool, and some hiking trails. The state of the Park has deteriorated in recent years, seemingly from lack of funding. The amphitheater has sat vacant for a long time and has damage from overgrowth and neglect, the lake is too polluted to swim in, and many of the other facilities have visible age and degradation. The Park is no longer the destination that it used to be, and is in need of some critical repairs. Restoring the park would prove beneficial to both the citizens of Falmouth and the tourists visiting the Park. The Kentucky Wool Festival The Kentucky Wool Festival is an event that takes place the first full weekend of October, it is emblematic of the changing of seasons, and is one of the most culturally 55

fig. 52

fig. 53

important events to happen in Falmouth, Kentucky. Schools are closed in Pendleton County on the Friday of the Wool Fest, vendors prepare all year to sell their handmade goods, and many organizations rely on the revenue earned during Wool Fest weekend to sustain their endeavors. The origins of the Wool Festival go back to Kentucky’s past as having a large sheep industry. When the Wool Fest committee was formed, Pendleton County was chosen to host it as Pendleton was one of the leaders in the sheep industry. The first Wool Festival occurred in October of 1983 at the fairgrounds in Falmouth, later migrating to its present day location. The Falmouth Woolen Mill was started by the Woodhead family in 1866, where they manufactured “famous” Pendleton blankets. The mill carried on through the lineage of the family for many years. An excerpt from a letter of Charles Kennett reads: The last ownership of the old Falmouth Woolen Mills, to my knowledge was my uncle Joseph Woodhead, for who my two older brothers and I all worked in the mill at various times before we left Falmouth for other fields, I being the last to leave in 1905. During two summers I operated three of the machines in the preparation of making blankets, yarn and other woolen goods. My brother, Martin Floyed Kennett, wove blankets, some of which may still be used in Pendleton County homes. Uncle Joseph ran the spinner and his son, Joshua, also worked in the mill.13 13

“The First 200 Years of Pendleton County,”

fig. 54

fig. 55

Though the woolen industry is not necessarily flourishing in Falmouth anymore, the Kentucky Wool Festival has kept that aspect of history alive within the town. Today, tens of thousands of people turn out to attend the Kentucky Wool Festival, which takes place adjacent to Kincaid Lake State Park, about 4 miles outside of the city of Falmouth. There are over 40 different food and drink vendors, 100 craft vendors, a full schedule of performances by local performers on two different stages, a petting zoo, and scheduled sheep shearing and herding events that take place. There is even a fundraiser event called “Ewe Doo” where a sheep defecates on a grid of numbers, the winner whose number is “dooed” on wins. With a growing turnout, the Kentucky Wool Festival brings a lot of people to Falmouth, Kentucky on this single weekend of the year. That begs the question, why hasn’t it helped stimulate the economy and tourism within Falmouth in recent years? Falmouth, Today Falmouth, Kentucky, today is facing very desperate times. The Covid-19 pandemic placed financial stress on every local business, and some did not make it out alive. Following the demolition of the Assembly Building in 2020, the citizens of Falmouth have grown weary of what is to happen with the rest of the historic fabric of the city. This has sparked some interest in investment from various community members, but the city itself is not in a financial position to be able to save these buildings and improve the general infrastructure of the city. As it sits 59

fig. 56

now, the sidewalks throughout Falmouth are crumbling. The city that was once advertised as having tree shaded streets downtown no longer has any. Buildings are visibly falling over, and nothing is being done about it. The saving grace of Falmouth will come down to making it a destination. This could come about in a few different ways and this thesis aims to discover a way forward. How might Falmouth be re-envisioned as a thriving city and tourist destination? How may we use the culture, history, and roots of the city to bring it back to what it once was? This thesis aims to get to the root of what a thriving small town is meant to be, looking at precedents and case studies of similar cities. It will analyze writings and research on the topic, and figure out a path forward for Falmouth.

Analysis Throughout this thesis small town culture has been examined through the lenses of fiction, in architectural debate, in the symbolism of architecture, through memory tourism, and through the likes of other thriving small towns. Diving deep into the history of the small town in rural Kentucky called Falmouth, the question is posed, how do we save this crumbling small town? Broken down into four categories, the progression of this study will proceed as follows: Seeking methods of Remediation for Falmouth Exploring the Representation of Falmouth Designing for a Revitalization of Falmouth A cultural Recreation for Falmouth

Remediation With the ultimate goal of utilizing the Licking River as more of a community cultural destination rather than a threat, this thesis aims to analyze how the riverfront can be developed, how we may strengthen connections from the riverfront to downtown, and what kinds of regulations must be met in areas within the flood zone. In order for Falmouth to become a thriving small town, the cultural and historical connections are just as much tied in the written history of the city as it is in the natural geography and ecology of the area. By strengthening the ties from the river to the city, and celebrating the river rather than living in fear, remediation techniques can be explored and developed in a way that are representative of the history of the city.

Improved Connection to River Proposed Green-space Proposed Circulation existing trail existing river access proposed river access existing dam

fig. 63

Flood Regulations - Flood Zone AE The elevation of the lowest floor in a structure must be at or above the zone’s base flood elevation (BFE).

fig. 64

BFE

fig. 65

Enclosed areas below the BFE or lowest floor cannot be used as living spaces. All electrical, plumbing and HVAC equipment must be elevated to or above the area’s BFE.

fig. 66

fig. 67

fig. 68

Representation In seeing the revival of small-town American as a commodification of Nostalgia, it is important to recognize the history and culture of the city in question. Falmouth, Kentucky has a rich architectural history in its historic district. This elevational study is meant to represent the history of each individual building as well as utilize architectural representation techniques to develop a specific graphic quality for each phase of the building’s life. Four buildings will be analyzed: The Masonic Building, The New Pastime Movie Theater, The Citizens Bank, and the Assembly Building. Each building was chosen for particular reasons, those reasons may include: its landmark status, a significant change in the architecture or use, its uniqueness to the site, or its demolition. The goal with each illustration is to capture the time that the building existed down to the little details, some that may even go unnoticed, emanating the idea that nostalgia is present in the little details and clutter of everyday life. 71

fig. 69

fig. 70

The Masoni

Flood of 1997

fig. 71

ic Building

7 Flood Line

fig. 72

fig. 73

fig. 74

fig. 75

fig. 76

New Pastim

Flood of 1997

fig. 77

me Theater

7 Flood Line

fig. 78

fig. 79

fig. 80

100

fig. 81

101

102

103

104

fig. 82

105

Old Citize

Flood of 1997

106

fig. 83

ens Bank

7 Flood Line

107

fig. 84

108

fig. 85

109

110

fig. 86

111

112

113

114

fig. 87

115

116

117

The Assembl

Flood of 1997

118

fig. 88

ly Building

7 Flood Line

119

fig. 89

120

fig. 90

121

122

fig. 91

123

fig. 92

124

Revitalization The ultimate goal of this thesis is to envision a revitalized Falmouth, to be designed with the history and culture of the city in mind. The third step in this analysis and process is to utilize the representation techniques explored in the first step, in respect to the history and integrity of historic downtown Falmouth, and pair it with the remediation techniques. Looking at a programmatic breakdown of the existing conditions in downtown Falmouth, programmatic needs can be pulled out, and potentials for redevelopment can be identified.

125

maple avenue

W shelby street

abandoned/vacant demolished structure sites 126

park space

law o

commercial busin

main street

Chapel street

fig. 93

W shelby street

offices/professional offices

ness occupied

government building

restaurants 127

churches

maple avenue

W shelby street

Unprogrammed Space demolished structure sites 128

main street

Chapel street

fig. 94

W shelby street

129

Main Area of Intervention Focusing on the block along Shelby Street with the most apparent deprivation, we will explore, envision, and re-imagine what a revitalized downtown historic district might look like. This includes studies related to: The Masonic Building New Pastime Movie Theater Various Demolished Sites The Existing Veterans Memorial Park

130

fig. 95

W shelby street

fig. 96

131

Analytical Drawing Looking into and between each of the existing historic buildings and beginning to analyze what kind of building might replace the Assembly Building.

132

fig. 97

Examining each building as its own memory, using various representation techniques that signal the sense of fleeting memory ever-present in the architecture, regardless of the modern programming that fills the spaces. 133

fig. 98

134

Masonic Building In re-imagining the spaces within the Masonic Building, it’s considered how residential spaces might fit into the upper floors, and how a cafe or coffee shop may occupy the commercial space on the storefront. The break away of the brick and the nostalgic photographs placed behind the windows of the facade signal how the building wants to be portrayed. The photographs represent people who grew up in Falmouth and how their lives with all of their trinkets and memories might fit into the revitalized spaces.

135

New Pastime Movie Theater This illustration analyzes and speculates on how the New Pastime Movie Theater may have looked in the past as well as how it may look in a revitalized version of itself. What’s interesting about movie theaters through time is they have more or less stayed the same. The equipment, comfort, and quality, would be upgraded but the integrity of the historic theater would remain.

136

fig. 99

137

Veterans Memorial Park

Centering itself between the movie theater and Assembly Building for an activated public space that frames the historic courtyard and goal with this portion of the analytical drawing will be to observe h community better. The courthouse in the background is presented this vital interstitial space.

138

fig. 100

g lot, the Veterans Memorial Park provides an opportunity d compliments its neighboring programmatic elements. The how the space can be re-designed and reactivated to serve the d as a faded image, a background of memory that is framed by

139

Assembly Building Lot Proposal

Following the datum lines of the historic Assembly Building, here may respond to the previous structure while also taking into consi

The goal in proposing a structure here is to acknowledge the mem fragmented thought. The drawing builds from left to right, letting recollection and consideration of memory.

140

e are beginning thoughts on how a newly constructed building ideration the flood regulations established earlier.

mory of the former building, and in doing so presenting it as a g the observer know that this is a progression of thought and a fig. 101

Base Flood Elevation

141

Assembly Building Lot Proposal Final Digital Elevation

142

143

Assembly Building Lot Proposal Physical Relief Model

144

145

fig. 102

146

Recreation The fourth and final step of this thesis and project is to utilize the setting and revitalization of Falmouth that has been re-imagined to serve as a stage for a re-invented Kentucky Wool Festival. Beyond that, to set a precedent for other community and cultural events to take place year round, as opposed to a 3-day time period once every Fall. With a clear connection through and around Falmouth, utilizing the riverfront as a public space, the Kentucky Wool Festival being relocated from its remote location outside of Falmouth to downtown would allow for tourism to flourish. The tens of thousands of people who travel to Falmouth for the festival will get to experience the history and culture of the city, and how much the festival means to its citizens. The idea of a commodification of nostalgia and a rescue effort fueled by the past and present of a city with such a rich history, the idea of memory tourism, would be symbolized in this event.

147

The Kentucky Wool Festival Grounds Current Program Layout:

food booths vendor booths vendor Tents dining Tents stages Petting zoo/animal tents 148

Location in relation to the Falmouth

fig. 103

149

Existing Program

fig. 104

150

fig. 105

151

Kentucky Wool Festival Proposed Program Layout food booths vendor booths vendor Tents dining Tents stages Petting zoo/animal tents

fig. 106

152

153

Proposed Program

fig. 107

154

Spread along the proposed circulation path for Falmouth, increased vendor booths, dining tents, and animal tents.

fig. 108

155

156

157

158

Conclusion In studying the dynamics of small towns and what makes them thrive, this thesis establishes guidelines for what it means to be a small town and draws conclusions on how the crumbling American small town may be saved. In the case of Falmouth, Kentucky, we see a crumbling historic district that has potential for reconstruction, with empty sites that can be rebuilt in respect to this integrity of the city and following the flood regulations. Through Remediation, the flood problem is acknowledged, the river is reactivated with the city, and flood regulations are established. Using architectural representation in various ways, this thesis analyzed the historic Representation of the city and the specific history of four notable buildings in Falmouth’s historic district. The techniques of representation are meant to emanate ideas of collective imagination and nostalgia of times when the city was thriving. The techniques are carried through in an analysis of Revitalization, where these buildings are re-imagined and reprogrammed, and thoughts on a new Assembly Building are proposed. The final step in this four-part analysis is Recreating the Kentucky Wool Festival and moving it from its remote location to the heart of the city, utilizing the redesigned spaces to activate the community.

159

fig. 109

160

fig. 110

161

fig. 111

162

fig. 112

163

fig. 113

164

fig. 114

165

fig. 115

166

fig. 116

167

fig. 117

168

fig. 118

169

fig. 119

170

fig. 120

171

fig. 121

172

fig. 122

173

fig. 123

174

fig. 124

175

Bibliography 2017 Census of Agriculture: United States Department of Agriculture, 2017. “Citizen’s Bank Historic Photo,”. https://www.nkyviews.com/pendleton/falmouth378.htm. “Covington and Lexington Railroad Open to Falmouth.” Covington Journal, Jul 17, 1852. https://www.nkyviews.com/pendleton/Pendleton_LN_Falmouth.htm. “Data USA: Falmouth, Kentucky.” . https://datausa.io/profile/geo/ falmouth-ky#economy. Masonic Lodge Historic Photo 1910. https://www.nkyviews.com/ pendleton/flmth14.htm. Methodist Church Historic Photo d. https://www.nkyviews.com/ pendleton/falmouth179.htm. New Falmouth High School Historic Photo f. https://www.nkyviews. com/pendleton/falmouth27.htm. “New Pastime Theater Post-Flood,”. https://www.nkyviews.com/ pendleton2/falmouth528.html. “Pendleton County - Industry Rises in this Historic Area.” 1976. https://www.nkyviews.com/pendleton2/falmouth526.html. Anderson, Sherwood. Winesburg, Ohio: A Group of Tales of Ohio Small Town Life. New York: B. W. Huebsch, 1919. Benedikt, Michael. For an Architecture of Reality Lumen, Inc., 1992. Budds, Diana. “This Small Indiana Town is a Hotbed of Utopia176

nism.” Curbed (August, 2019). Burns, Peter M., Cathy Palmer, Jo-Anne Lester, and Roberta Bartoletti. Tourism and Visual Culture: Theories and Concepts CABI, 2010. Chua, Lawrence, Samuel Mockbee, and Cervin Robinson. Rural Studio: Samuel Mockbee and an Architecture of Decency Princeton Architectural Press, 2002. Ethel Bell. “History of Falmouth.” Haney, Rosie. “Best Hometowns: Chagrin Falls.” Ohio Magazine (Nov, 2016). Mildred Bowen Belew. “The First 200 Years of Pendleton County.” . http://www.kykinfolk.com/pendleton/200-years/200-years.htm. Morris, Wright. “Norfolk, Nebraska, 1947 (from the Home Place),”. Pellet, Frank C. American Honey Plants 1976. Venturi, Robert and Denise Scott Brown. “A Definition of Architecture as Shelter with Decoration on it, and another Plea for a Symbolism of the Ordinary in Architecture.” A + U (Jan, 1978). Wilson, Richard. “Isolated County Seat is Missing Out on Big City Problems-- and Promises.” The Courier Journal, Dec 14, 1992. Zetlin, Minda. “How Irwin Miller, Former CEO of Cummins, Redefined Success and Transformed a Midwestern City.” . https:// www.inc.com/minda-zetlin/irwin-miller-columbus-indiana-cummins-corporation-architecture-im-pei-harry-weese-eeero-elial-saarinen.html.

177

Victoria Wanstrath | On Crumbling Small Towns: Falmouth, Kentucky

Articles inside

Bibliography

Introduction

Falmouth, Kentucky