ART & CULTURE
Auroville
This article contrasts with the previously published one on the Tate Modern by Alain de Botton, in which he states that the building “is to evoke valuable states of mind which we theoretically approve of but forget in the run of daily life, such virtues as perspective, calm reflection, kindness and courage”. The current trend indicates that these momentary states are no longer enough, and that these “valuable states of mind” ought to encompass our daily lives, by broadening the scope from iconic architecture to the larger more complex picture of the “whole” that includes town planning, sustainability and collaboration.
STARCHITECTURE, A MODEST PROPOSAL Cathleen McGuigan (Extracts from Newsweek) The phenomenon of using iconic architecture to promote a city, an institution, or a real-estate development was a product of the economic boom that began in the late 1990s and ended with the recession in 2008. As Western economies begin to recover, extravagant, eye-popping architecture is giving way to a subtler new aesthetic. In the U.S. and Europe, architectural values are shifting from can-you-top-this designs toward more efficient, functional building. Innovation and experimentation are increasingly directed at sustainability and new technology. For a younger generation of architects, in particular, “the spectacle building is kind of a dinosaur”, says the director of the Architectural League in New York. Architects, too, are engaging more in collaboration as they increasingly turn their attention to urban planning, civic projects, and the creation of public space. What shapes new buildings will take in the next decade isn't yet clear, but fresh visions will inevitably emerge from the downturn. “It's like a forced diet, there's a certain healthiness when the profession has to cut-back, re-grow, re-imagine what it is we all are supposed to do which is creative problem solving”, says R. Rogers. (…) Patrons themselves are shunning iconic architecture. The Cincinnati Art Museum for example, in a city that already has one knock-out iconic arts center by Zaha Hadid, recently put on hold its plans for an addition by the hip Rotterdam office Neutelings Riedijk. The Berkeley Art Museum in California canceled a stunning design for a new building by Japanese architect Toyo Ito after failing to raise enough money. Instead the museum will retrofit an old printing plant for new gallery space. And while global events like the Olympics often have been prime venues for showcasing dazzling architecture, the relatively modest 2010 Games in London will feature only one facility by an international star. Hadid has designed the Aquatics Center, with a fantastic roof that undulates like the swells of the ocean. Many of the structures for the Games will be temporary and pragmatic.
Nº1 - November 2010
(…) Such revamping of cities is a task now engaging many of today's top architects. Unburdened by the demands of developers to come up with quirky glass towers full of overpriced apartments, many of whose clients are now bankrupt, architects are increasingly involved in designing master plans for urban neighborhoods. (…) Yes these urban schemes include ambitious architectural projects, but when the economy is shaky, planning can jump-start the creative work while postponing the enormous expense of construction. However, Koolhaas, who's working on a number of master plans, believes that clients are focusing on urban planning “not just for economic reasons but because it's what they should really do. Planning is the ideal form of investment. “It's a process that takes into account an array of social, economic, and political factors in cities: geography, transportation, public space. Growing concern with the environment is also motivating architects to engage on a macro not just micro level. Looking further into the future, the Museum of Modern Art in New York decided to take advantage of young architects with time on their hands and commissioned five teams to research and design plans to contend with the rising seas that threaten to flood New York City's shoreline. As those plans, now on exhibit at MoMA, make clear, designing almost anything bigger than a birdhouse takes a village. Collaboration is one of the strongest forces emerging in contemporary design culture, especially for the younger generation; in MoMA's show Rising Currents, teams such as ARO and dlandstudio brought together architects, landscape architects, urban designers, and engineers to come up with design solutions for a future lower Manhattan under water. “With the blurring of boundaries among disciplines, you're recognizing that you don't solve the problem with an object building”, says Burdett. “Everything belongs to a context in the city”. The notion of collectivity strikes at the heart of the lone heroic starchitect. (…) The world's most inventive starchitects will continue to create spectacular buildings. It's not easy to dismiss the boom years and the brash experimentation they fostered. “I don't think we will see in our lifetime another era where both private and public clients are so willing to engage in architectural innovation”, says Alejandro ZaeraPolo a bit wistfully. Some of the architecture that resulted in Gehry's Disney Hall in L.A., Koolhaas's Seattle Library, to name just two was wonderful. Yet innovation as mere style is nothing to apprize; no one is going to miss the second-rate excesses of the era. Pointlessly pointy architecture is so over. And we can hope that what comes next will be thoughtful design that responsibly reflects the complexities of contemporary life. Heist Train Station model by Zaha Hadid