EDITORIAL
Tuesday, September 16, 2014 Volume No. 34 Issue No. 3
Private residences an uncertain addition to student housing market pg. 6
@mcgilltribune
www.mcgilltribune.com
Redmen thrash Gaels in dominant performance Goaltender Waesche makes league history with opening goal WYATT FINE-GAGNÉ Sports Editor
T
Where the streets have no claim: A peek at Montreal’s secret urban art gallery Continued on pg. 12 McGill graduate student wins legal case against CFS Canadian Federation of Students faces second court loss of the month
Q
SAM NAZER Contributor
uebec Superior Court Justice Gérard Dugré ruled in favour of Ge Sa, a McGill Ph.D. student, last Tuesday on his case against the Canadian Federation of Students (CFS), an organization that campaigns on the federal level for student rights. Justice Dugré ordered CFS to hold a referendum to allow PostGraduate Students’ Society (PGSS) students to vote on whether to leave the CFS. Mr. Sa initiated a petition in September 2013, calling for a referendum
on whether to continue PGSS membership in the CFS. With over 2,000 signatures, the petition surpassed the 20 per cent quorum required by CFS bylaws. However, the CFS had refused to recognize the validity of the petition, as it claimed the PGSS had not complied with its bylaws in obtaining the signatures. Justice Dugré rejected the arguments made by the CFS and found the solution sought by the organization to be “manifestly unreasonable.” “The plaintiff has demonstrated a clear legal and quasi-constitutional right that a referendum took place in accor-
dance with CFS bylaw I,” Justice Dugré said in his judgement document. “Any delay in holding this referendum clearly causes an irreparable prejudice to the right of the plaintiff to not be affiliated with CFS. This prejudice is not only serious and irreparable but also manifestly irreversible.” “We are very pleased with the verdict,” Sa said. “This case will set a precedent for students across Canada who are fighting to disaffiliate from the CFS and wish to exercise their right to freedom of association.” According to Brent Farrington, internal coordinator of CFS the National
Executive will at its next meeting in October discuss proposing dates for the referendum. “Hopefully, the PGSS is willing to work with us,” Farrington said. “They have a role and responsibility as per our bylaws on what the dates of the vote will be.” “Knowing the CFS, they might attempt to delay [the referendum] further,” Sa said. “We’re already half a year behind on what was initially scheduled. If they delay it more than six months or so, we will go back to court to make sure our rights are respected.”
Continued on pg. 2
hough they may have been disappointed by the weather for their home opener, the McGill Redmen (3-0) lacrosse team left Molson Stadium satisfied following a decisive 13-7 victory over the Queen’s Golden Gaels (1-1) Saturday afternoon. The game’s scoring was opened in historic and unusual fashion, as McGill’s sophomore goalkeeper William Waesche found space in the middle of the field while carrying the ball up and fired a shot from 10 yards out to open the scoring. Waesche’s goal was the first by a goalkeeper in Canadian University Field Lacrosse Association (CUFLA) history, and was an unassisted, end-to-end effort. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen a goalie score before,” cocaptain Jack Stewart said. “It’s a huge energy boost. Seeing your goalie run down the field and then score the first goal of the game is big for momentum.” From that point on the Redmen dominated, leading 7-2 by halftime, and 12-4 by the end of the third quarter. The Gaels made a small run during the latter half of the fourth frame, but the attack amounted to just three goals and was not nearly enough to narrow the large gap.
Continued on pg. 20
Pop Rhetoric : Falling out of love with folk
R
ERIC NOBLE-MARKS Contributor
emember when a band consisted only of guitar, bass, drums, and vocals? Over the past few years, a cursory listen to rock radio has featured the swelling of string lines, the
jangle of banjos, and the searing leads of brass sections. As listeners, we are confronted with an array of genres that can’t be explained without a dash: Indie-folk, baroque pop-rock, and orchestral-rock are all key parts of what is considered ‘rock music’ these days. How did we get here, to a point
where a band’s roster takes up half the page? How did banjos come to stand alongside guitars as the instrument “du jour?” More importantly, will it all last? The reality of the situation is: Probably not. To arrive at that conclusion, it’s best to start at the beginning. The
growth of this trend largely begins with the release of great baroque-rock albums such as Arcade Fire’s Funeral and Sufjan Stevens’ Illinois in the mid 2000s. Though they received massive critical acclaim, their mainstream appeal was limited at best. Funeral, now a modern-day classic, wasn’t certified
gold in the United States until 2011. Banjos, horns, and strings were beginning to impact the shape of alternative music, but had yet to make a dent in mainstream musical circles.
Continued on pg. 13