V o lu m e 4 , N u m b e r 20_________
â I n v o lv e m B o tto m
P u b lish ed b y the S tu dentsâ Society o f M c G ill U n iv e rs ity
-E le c t io n Results â
e n t â
L in e
by M e la n ie C lu lo w M c G illâ s d ebile election fe r v o r has ended w ith scarcely a w h im p e r an d M c G ill students have, fo r b e tte r o r worse,
re s tru c tu rin g o f the C C S S , w h ich he sees as â a huge, unw ie ld ly , ra th e r in e ffic ie n t co m  m itte e .â T o p ro m o te e ffic ie n c y in this area , G ree n w ants to cut the co m m itte e d o w n fro m fo rty eight m em bers to ten. O n e o f th e m a jo r issues fa c  ing the new co u ncil w ill be to deal e ffe c tiv e ly w ith student a p a th y in s o fa r as g o v ern m e n t is c o n c e rn e d . G re e n p ro p o s e s several m easures to increase in  terest in th e a c tu a l elections: (1 ) coerce u n d e rg ra d u a te societies to h o ld th e ir elections fo r co u n  cil representatives on the same d a y , and cancel classes in o rd e r to focus a tte n tio n on the elec tio n s, (2) have m o re in fo rm a l â m eet the ca nd idatesâ g a th e r ings, and (3 ) have open debates an d fo ru m s such as the one held this year b y the F a c u lty o f E n g in eerin g . O n the subject o f the D a i l y , G ree n said th a t the question o f e q u a liza tio n o f fees sh o uld n o t have been on the b a llo t fo r tw o reasons. F irs tly , it was b ad p la n n in g . I t discouraged the electo rate fro m v o tin g â Y e s â fo r b o th e q u a liza tio n a n d a fee increase. S eco nd ly, said G ree n , â The e q u a liz a tio n put u nd ergrad uates in the p o s itio n o f m a k in g decisions fo r the g ra d u a te stu d en ts.â W h e n asked a b o u t th e rejec tio n o f a fee increase fo r the D a i l y , G ree n stated th a t he can  n o t see the S tu dentsâ Society d ir e c tly assisting th e D a i l y fin a n c ia lly , a lth o u g h he w o u ld n o t be averse to su p p o rtin g a c a m p aig n to raise m o n ey fo r the new spaper next ye ar. â W e have a d e fic it, t o o ,â he said. C o n cern in g relation s betw een StudSoc and the Post G ra d u a te S tu d e n ts â S o c ie ty ( P G S S ) ,
i
A d v a n c e P o lls
R e g u la r P o l ls
T o ta l
C r a w h a ll, N ig e l G re e n , Jam es K asenb erg,
308 415
508 819
816 1234
Todd
184
392
576
608 295
1103 549
1711 844
527
1011
1538
341
618
959
P r e s id e n t s
selected th e ir n ew S tu d e n t So ciety representatives. N e x t y e a râ s executive w ill see James G re e n as P re sid en t, L u c J o liC o e u r as V ic e -P re s id e n t E x te r n a l, an d M ic h a e l O r r as V ic e P resid en t In te rn a l. T h e T r ib u n e m et w ith each o f the successful cand idates to discuss w ith th em th e goals an d policies th ey hope to im p le m e n t in the fo rth c o m  ing year. James G re e n , in his ca p a city as P re sid en t in â 8 5 -â 8 6 , w o u ld lik e to see m o re direct student in p u t in such groups as the C o o rd in a tin g C o m m itte e fo r S tu dent Services an d the Budget P la n n in g G ro u p . He h as a lre a d y begun w o rk fo r a
Tuesday 12 M a r c h 1985
V ic e - P r e s id e n ts In te rn a l
O r r , M ic h a e l W a r d , H e le n E x te rn a l
J o li-C o e u r, L u c W e s tm a n , D a ro n
o ,
D a i l y F e e I n c r e a s e Q u e s tio n
Yes No N o O p in io n
A h , the sweet taste o f success G reen said, â T h is y e a râ s p ro  b le m was p rim a r ily a p ers o n a li ty c o n flic t b etw een the P G S S an d the S S M U . T h a t w o n â t h a p  pen next y e a r .â D ia n e D u tto n , n e w ly elected p resident o f the P G S S , n early ra n fo r the posi tio n o f V P E x te rn a l on a slate w it h Jam es G re e n b e fo re decid in g instead to ru n in the P G S S elections. E v id e n tly , the tw o presidents are on good term s. G reen is c o n fid e n t th a t c o n flic ts b e tw e e n th e tw o societies w ill be s a tis fa c to rily iro n e d o u t next ye ar. O n the question o f th e C V C , G ree n feels th a t a lth o u g h C V C m a y have to be replaced , there m ust be an a u to n o m o u s b o d y to deal w ith fo o d an d beverage issues. H e doesnâ t w a n t StudSoc to becom e â d o m in a te d by p izza an d b e e r.â A lth o u g h L u c J o li-C o e u r has no concrete goals at the m o  m e n t, he does id e n tify several p r o b le m s in h e r e n t in th e S tu dentsâ Society. C h ie f am o n g these is the lack o f in fo rm a tio n a v a ila b le to the average student co n cerning stu d en t co u ncil ac tiv itie s , w h ic h c o n s e q u e n tly results in student a p a th y . J o liC o e u r w o u ld have lik e d to see e n tire colum ns d evo ted to each ca n d id a te ra th e r th a n the b r ie f pen-sketches ru n b y th e T r ib u n e an d the D a i l y in the past elec tio n . J o li-C o e u r feels th a t the posi tio n o f V P E x te rn a l is the m ost p o litic a l p o s itio n on the ex ecutive because it involves d eal ing n o t o n ly w ith cam pus issues b u t w ith outside agencies, such as the p ro v in c ia l g o v e rn m e n t, as w e ll. A t th e p ro v in c ia l level, J o li-C o e u r intends to w o rk to w a rd s im p ro v e d re la tio n s w ith o th e r universities, a fa ir a llo c a tio n o f p ro v in c ia l fu nd s, an d the establishm ent o f b etter
398 462 81
bursaries. J o li-C o e u r sees the election o f th ree in d ep en d en t candidates to the student executive as b etter fo r students th a n an A llia n c e g o v ern m e n t. H e feels th a t the in p u t o f th ree in d iv id u a ls w ith slig h tly d iffe re n t ideas is m o re d y n a m ic and co n du cive to good d ecis io n -m ak in g th a n c o n fo r m i ty on a ll issues. A t th e h eart o f J o li-C o e u râ s p o litic a l p h ilo s o p h y is student in v o lv e m e n t, id e a lly in the fo rm o f â fre q u e n t discussions and open fo ru m s about issues students care a b o u t.â S aid Jo liC o e u r, â O n e o f m y prom ises is to have a b ig g er (e lec to rate ) tu r n o u t next y e a r .â VP In te rn a l M ic h a e l O r r ta k e s a d e c id e d ly m o re p ra g m a tic a p p ro a c h to in  itia tin g student in v o lv e m e n t. â P eo p le a re n â t ju s t going to â come d o w n , k n o c k o n th e d o o r an d say â H e y , I w a n t to get in  v o lv e d .â â said O r r . H e feels th a t it should be m ade easier and less i n t i m i d a t i n g fo r students to get in v o lve d at the e n te r ta in m e n t / r e c r e a tio n a l level. A c cessib ility to student g o v ern m e n t at this level w ill ev e n tu a lly generate interest at the h ig h er echelons o f student g o v e rn m e n t. O r r is c e rta in th at the c u rre n t re o rg a n iza tio n (d e c e n tra liz a tio n ) o f the P ro g ra m B o a rd w ill p ro v id e o p p o r  tu nities fo r people to c o n trib u te th e ir ideas an d energies in this area. O n the subject o f M c G ill clubs, O r r is vehem ent th a t no special interest groups w ill be denied funds on the basis o f th e ir ap p ea lin g to o n ly a sm all segm ent o f the cam pus p o p u la  tio n . H o w e v e r, he w o u ld lik e to ensure th a t all clubs do as m uch as th ey can fo r as m a n y students co n tin u e d page 6
716 914 162 / ',V '
1114 1376 243 * ' {, "
D a i l y E q u a l iz a t io n Q u e s tio n
Yes No N o O p in io n
579 268 90
1136 472 176
1715 740 266
* N o te : Results are u n o ffic ia l. Recounts m a y be requested u n til W ed n e sd ay , M a r c h 13.
S e a lin g S o lu tio n ? by A d ee b K h a lid A ra th e r sm all audience a t a c o llo q u iu m o n â T h e C a n a d ia n Seal C o n tro v e rs y : B io lo g ic a l, C u ltu r a l an d E th ic a l Perspec tivesâ h eard a w id e rang e o f views expressed fro m a v a rie ty o f perspectives last F rid a y . T h e c o llo q u iu m , sponsored by the c e n tre T o r N o r th e r n A re a s Studies an d th e d e p a rtm e n t o f G e o g ra p h y a ttra c te d several au th o ritie s on th e subject; m ost o f the speakers w ere on firs t n a m e term s a lre a d y . D r. D a v id L a v ig n e fr o m G u e lp h kic ked o f f the d ay -lo n g event w ith re fle ctio n s on the â b liz z a rd o f liesâ in w h ich the co n tro versy has been m a ro o n  ed. H e cited the m a n n e r in w h ic h in fo rm a tio n is d is to rted by b o th sid es, but as a zo o lo g ist, his m a in concern was the fac t th a t scientists an d th eir o p in io n s are m a n ip u la te d in the co n tro versy. D r . B e n ja m in S im a rd fro m the U n iv e rs itĂŠ de M o n tr ĂŠ a l then called fo r a â T o ta l A p p ro a c h â to the issue. F o r h im , the p ro  b le m is th a t o f a society th a t cares m o re a b o u t an im a ls th an a b o u t h u m a n beings, w here a b o rtio n is accepted b u t not c u llin g . T h e w h ite c o a t seal is a n th ro p o m o rp h is e d b y the p ro  test m o ve m e n t an d this is the reason w h y th e p u b lic reacts so
e m o tio n a lly
to
the
seal
hunt
w h ile m o re endangered species do n o t get the m e d ia a tte n tio n th ey re q u ire . K ir k S m ith o f the C a n a d ia n S e a le r s â A s s o c i a t i o n th e n fo llo w e d w ith the assertion th a t the sealing in d u s try is â a fin e e x a m p le o f so u n d w ild life m a n a g e m e n t an d co n servatio n p rac tic eâ since the species is n o t th rea ten ed w ith ex tin c tio n and the in d u s try is an econ o m ic n e c e s s ity fo r m any New  fo u n d la n d an d In u it fish erm en . M a r k S m a ll, also o f the C S A , an d a sealer h im s e lf, then presented a sealerâ s view o f the c o n tro versy . H e to ld o f h ow sealing is an in te g ral p a rt o f N e w fo u n d la n d an d In u it w a y o f life , so m ethin g w h ich u rb an C a n a d ia n s can n o t p ro p e rly ap  p reciate. H e also ta lk e d ab o u t th e s e v e re e c o n o m ic and c u ltu ra l im p a c t th e loss o f the E u ro p e a n m a rk e t has h ad on the fish in g co m m u n itie s . H is o w n in co m e fro m sealing w en t fro m $10 0 0 0 in 1982 to $154 in 1983 an d n o th in g in 1984; and since fo r m ost fish erm en , seal ing a n d fish in g are n o t distinct activities, this loss has had a fu rth e r im p a c t on th e ir fishing o p e ratio n s . Y e t these hardships are ra re ly discussed b y the p ro  test m o v e m e n t. continued page 3