WELCOME TO HONEYWELL! MICHAEL DEN HARTOG SPRING 2014 DEGREE PROJECT MARCOS SANCHEZ STUDIO
A NOTE THE PORTFOLIO IS SPLIT INTO FOUR PARTS. THE FIRST THREE PARTS ARE A BREAKDOWN OF THE SEMESTER’S RESEARCH AND PROCESS WORK WHICH GENERATE THE PROJECT, WHICH BEGINS TO EMERGE AT THE END OF PART TWO AND IS DEVELOPED IN DETAIL IN THE FINALE.
A GUIDE INTRODUCTION : VALUE MANIPULATION...................................................................................5 PART I: BORDER ECONOMICS SECTION A: MAQUILADORAS...............................................................................................9 SECTION B: A MANIPULATIVE EXERCISE..........................................................................23 SECTION C: THE DEVELOPING AEROSPACE/DEFENSE SITUATION.............................35 PART II: THE MAQUILA’S NEXT STEP SECTION A: PRODUCING U.S. DEFENSE TECHNOLOGY.................................................47 SECTION B: A NEW NAFTA....................................................................................................51 PART III: DEVELOPMENT SECTION A: DEVELOPMENT OF A SITE PROTOTYPE.......................................................55 SECTION B: DEVELOPMENT OF A RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT FACTORY.........69 SECTION C: DEVELOPMENT OF AN IMAGE......................................................................77 PART IV: FINALE SECTION A: CONDITIONAL EXPLANATION.......................................................................83 SECTION B: A NEW NAFTA INFRASTRUCTURE.................................................................89 SECTION C: VISUALIZATION, A MORE HONEST BORDER CONDITION.......................107
4
INTRODUCTION : VALUE MANIPULATION The necessity of the fence is sold in terms of defense, its militarization in the name of national security. But as architecture its fails at this function. It is permeable, its holes are numerous and dynamic. Its impenetrability is preached as intrinsic to the safety of the United States’ population, but its construction is determined by the economic whims of politicians and corporations. In reality its true purpose is as an economic mechanism, its subsequent emphasis on security is a result of this purpose. It marks a delineation between two sovereigns in which the same commodity, person or contraband, has a differing value depending upon which side of the wall it is placed, it is an architecture of value manipulation. It is a manifestation of international economics in which the flow of goods and money is accommodated but the flow of people is restricted. As a result a lower wage labor market, Mexico, becomes available to American corporations, initially for low-skill manufacturing as seen in the border industrialization program of the 1960s, but evolving into something more complex over time with the passing of NAFTA and the subsequent War on Terror.
5
6
BORDER AS VALUE MANIPULATOR FROM PEOPLE TO DRUGS
BORDER AS VALUE MANIPULATOR FROM GOODS TO ENGINEERS 7
8
PART I: BORDER ECONOMICS SECTION A: MAQUILADORAS
The United States and Mexico have used the wall’s economic manipulation to import and export certain sectors of one another’s economy. Particularly the United States has exported a substantial amount of its manufacturing processes south of the border supporting the maquiladora industry, which assembles materials (temporary imports) for subsequent distribution in the United States. Initial industries exported included low-tech and low-skill sectors from textiles to household electronics. Yet over time the complexity of these exported manufacturing processes evolved, moving into the automotive sector, as the skill of the Mexican workforce increased.
9
10
MAQUILAS: TEMPORARY IMPORTS COMPONENTS+LOW WAGE LABOR+ TOOLS=PRODUCT
SUPPLY CHAIN GOODS ASSEMBLED MUST BE RETURNED TO THE UNITED STATES BEFORE BEING SOLD 11
12
TIJUANA INDUSTRIAL PARK JUST SOUTH OF OTAY MESA LOGISTICS CENTER
OTAY MESA/TIJUANA COMMERCIAL PORT OF ENTRY 13
14
OTAY MESA DRAYAGE STUDY MOVEMENT OF MAQUILA RAW MATERIALS AND FINISHED PRODUCTS ACROSS THE BORDER
LONG DISTANCE SHIPPING
DRAYAGE STORAGE LOCATIONS
RAW MATERIALS SENT FROM U.S. STORAGE SITE TO MAQUILA
OTAY MESA DRAYAGE COMPONENTS MULTIPLE PATHS/MULTIPLE PLAYERS 15
MAQUILA FLOOR PLAN 16
MAQUILA PRODUCTION FLOW 17
18
MAQUILA EVOLUTION 1 LOW SKILL ASSEMBLY, TEXTILES AND HOUSEHOLD ELECTRONICS 19
20
MAQUILA EVOLUTION 2
SKILL INCREASES, AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY 21
22
PART I: BORDER ECONOMICS SECTION A MANIPULATIVE EXERCISE
EXPERIMENT IN FACTORY AGGLOMERATION GROUPING OPERATIONS TOGETHER, DEALING WITH ISSUES OF SEGMENTED KNOWLEDGE AND WORKER DEFAMILIARIZATION WITH THE PRODUCT 23
24
ASSEMBLY LINE OF FACTORIES GROUPING OPERATIONS TOGETHER, DEALING WITH ISSUES OF SEGMENTED KNOWLEDGE AND WORKER DEFAMILIARIZATION WITH THE PRODUCT
STACKED FACTORIES GROUPING OPERATIONS TOGETHER, DEALING WITH ISSUES OF SEGMENTED KNOWLEDGE AND WORKER DEFAMILIARIZATION WITH THE PRODUCT 25
VERTICAL FACTORY EXPERIMENT
26
VERTICAL FACTORY EXPERIMENT 27
VERTICAL ASSEMBLY LINE/ CUBICLE FACTORY 28
VERTICAL ASSEMBLY LINE/ CUBICLE FACTORY 29
OTAY MESA FACTORY ASSEMBLY LINE SITE
30
OTAY MESA FACTORY ASSEMBLY LINE LAYERS LEVELED SECURITY ZONES 31
32
OTAY MESA FACTORY ASSEMBLY LINE SECTION EXAMINING FLOW BETWEEN BUILDINGS 33
34
PART I: BORDER ECONOMICS SECTION C: THE DEVELOPING AEROSPACE SITUATION
The complexity of the maquiladora industry has continued, presently there is an increase in the exportation of American aerospace and defense industrial manufacturing. This most recent export comes tethered to another that of the United States Homeland Security apparatus, for the defense technology of the world’s most prolific military power must be protected. In this move the guise of the wall as first and foremost a matter of national security is paradoxically obliterated as well as finally affirmed. It is obliterated by the exportation of confidential technology into a zone that the wall by its own existence has deemed unsafe. At the same time it supports its claim of national security, by allowing the production of more military and security apparatus at cheaper prices, developing a new landscape of the U. S. military-industrial complex. Capturing the cheaper workforce to the south, which is no longer populated by solely low-skilled labor but supports a burgeoning class of professional engineers, its yearly university output nearly rivaling its northern neighbor, who can be paid approximately half of what there northern neighbors require.
35
36
MAQUILA EVOLUTION 3 AEROSPACE AND REGULATED U.S. DEFENSE TECHNOLOGY ITAR=INTERNATIONAL TRAFFIC IN ARMS REGULATIONS 37
38
PLAYERS INVOLVED IN THE ASSEMBLY OF ITAR RELATED TECHNOLOGY THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE INSTITUTES REGULATIONS AND LIMITATIONS ON FOREIGN WORKER KNOWLEDGE AND ACCESS
THE EXPORTATION OF THE U.S. HOMELAND APPARATUS INTO MEXICO SECURITY AND SURVEILLANCE ACCOMPANIES THE NEW EXPORT
FROM MAQUILA TO DRONE TURBINES ASSEMBLED IN HONEYWELL’S MEXICALI FACILITY COMBINED BY GENERAL ATOMICS TO PRODUCE DRONES WHICH PATROL THE BORDER 39
40
THE DEVELOPING SITUATION U.S. DEFENSE CONTRACTED CORPORATIONS LOCATED IN BAJA CALIFORNIA 41
GKN AEROSPACE COMPOENDE AERONAUTICA
LEONAS METAL
CHROMALLOY AEROSPACE
TRIUMPH INSULATION TECHNOLOGIES
EMPRESAS L.M.
JOHNATHAN MFG DE MEXICO
LMI AEROSPACE
PROCESOS TERMICOS
STADCO GULFSTREAM INTERIORES AEROS
ROCKWELL COLLINS
AMERICA'S PLATING COMPANY
HONEYWELL AEROSPACE
AEROSPACE INT'L COATINGS
NEX TECH AEROSPACE SUNTECH MANUFACTURING
GOODRICH AEROSPACE
42
THE DEVELOPING SITUATION U.S. DEFENSE CONTRACTED CORPORATIONS LOCATED IN MEXICALI
2
3
1
4 5
THE EMERGENCE OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT FACILITIES WITH THE SURPLUS OF ENGINEERS BASIC RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT OPERATIONS ARE DEVELOPING IN MEXICO 43
F Q F CYCTFU IGPGTCN CVQOÄ KEU FTQPG EQPVTCEV
I C EQPVTCEVU VWTDKPG VQ JQPG[Ä YGNN U OGZKECNK HCEKNKV[
FTQPG CUUGODNGF CV IGPGTCN CVQOKEU UCP FKGIQ HCEKNKV[
FTQPG FGRNQ[GF CV W U Ä OGZKEQ DQTFGT
THE HONEYWELL SITUATION THE EMERGENCE OF R+D OPERATIONS WILL ONLY INCREASE, MOVING FROM BASIC OPERATIONS TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF SECURITY AND SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY FOR ITS NEAREST MARKET TH, THE MILITARIZED BORDER 44
The Honeywell Situation represents the next phase of the maquila industry, one located in a future almost here, in which not only the manufacturing and assembly of the United State’s defense technology is exported but also its research and development. No longer will certain parts be assembled which find their way into a drone which surveills the border, but the development of the drone itself will occur happen South of the border, as research and development facilities like Honeywell’s in Mexicali Facility spread and evolve . The maquiladora has moved into the production of technology and information, not for Mexico but for its northern neighbor much of which, represented by the fence, is deployed upon the designer’s national population.
45
MAQUILA EVOLUTION PART 4
46
PART II: THE MAQUILA’S NEXT STEP SECTION A: PRODUCING U.S. DEFENSE TECHNOLOGY SOUTH OF THE BORDER
The new exportation, of the development of the U.S. defense apparatus itself, requires that sites meet a new standard mediating the intersection of cheap labor and high security, to appease America’s constant security anxiety. Yet the private American defense contractors, quickly establishing assembly plants that are evolving into research and development facilities and are on their way to becoming test sites, fed by the black hole of U.S. defense contracts, are driven by economics and the United States government becomes worried. They realize this exodus cannot be stopped, it is simply business, and anyways they can achieve more for less, yet a system should be established, precedents set. They begin discussions with the Mexican government, who aware of the lucrative opportunity of tapping into the U.S. military industrial complex, seek to appease their all too often erratic neighbor. But they become stuck, they cannot determine what to do. In a twist of fate, how it came to be no one is sure, or no one is willing to admit, the advice of an architect is sought.
47
1964 END OF THE BRACERO PROGRAM
1965 THE BORDER INDUSTRIALIZATION PROGRAM
& 1 &
/#6'4+#.5 (41/ #5+# 2146 1( .15 #0)'.'5 %1//'4%+#. 647%- 4176' /#37+.# #55'/$.; <10' %1//'4%+#. 647%- 4176' 61 7 5 &'56+0#6+10
2006 THE VIRTUAL FENCE BORDER AS TECH. PLAYGROUND
2006 SECURE FENCE ACT
2001 SEPTEMBER 11TH
1993 OPERATION GATEKEEPER THE BEGINNING OF BORDER MILITARIZATION
48
1994 NAFTA IS RATIFIED
JQ
PG
[Y
GN N
IQ
QF
TKE
J
NQ E OC MJ TV GGF KP
DQ
GKP
I
2015 MEXICO’S NEW CORPORATE LANDSCAPE
2008 DRONE INTRODUCTION
2014 THE NEW NAFTA AGREEMENT
T F
2013 “A CHRISTMAS PRESENT FOR HALLIBURTON”
A TIMELINE FROM THE BRACERO PROGRAM TO THE NEW 2O15 NAFTA 49
A NEW NAFTA ZONE MEXICO’S NEW R+D LANDSCAPE, HOME TO HOUSEHOLD NAMES SUCH AS BOEING, HALLIBURTON AND LOCKHEED MARTIN 50
PART II: THE MAQUILA’S NEXT STEP SECTION B: A NEW NAFTA The architect proposes the creation of new special economic zones within Mexico, the new NAFTAs as they become known, in which regulated defense research, development, and design may be carried out in a relative amount of security to appease the U.S. government but more importantly the general American population, who still believe the fence is a necessity of national security. The influx of lower wage Mexican engineers will gain admission to the zone, performing regulated defense contracts for U.S. corporations willingly, choosing to be a part of Mexico’s newest market and professional class. The special economic zone should be self-sustaining, an infrastructure that both promotes security while allowing for the utilization of cheap labor in a comfortable environment which satisfies the employees as well as the U.S. defense contracted corporations desired image.
2014 AGREEMENT BETWEEN PRESIDENT OBAMA AND PENA NIETO AUTHORIZING MEXICO’S NEW SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE A NEW ERA IN U.S./MEXICO ECONOMIC OPERATIONS? 51
�
�
� �
���
EXAMINING LOCATIONS 52
LOCATION AND IMAGE ZONES ARE INITIALLY SET UP JUST SOUTH OF THE BORDER BUT GROWTH IS EXPECTED 53
54
SITE TIJUANA INDUSTRIAL PARK JUST SOUTH OF OTAY MESA COMMERCIAL PORT OF ENTRY
PART III: DEVELOPMENT SECTION A: OF A SITE PROTOTYPE
55
56
SITE SATELLITE IMAGERY
SITE PRODUCTION OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT 57
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
SITE A CORPORATE CITY STATE OR COMMUNE ?
58 PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
STUDIES IN INFRASTRUCTURE 59
STUDIES IN INFRASTRUCTURE 60
STUDIES IN INFRASTRUCTURE 61
62
63
STUDIES IN INFRASTRUCTURE 64
STUDIES IN INFRASTRUCTURE 65
66
SITE DEVELOPMENTAL SECURITY ZONES
SITE DEVELOPMENTAL SECURITY ZONES 67
68
FACTORY LOCATION (RED CIRCLE) WITHIN IN DEVELOPMENT PLAN A COMMUNAL FACILITY SHARED BY SURROUNDING REGIONAL CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS (GREY RECTANGLES)
PART III: DEVELOPMENT SECTION B: OF A RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT FACTORY
69
70
DIAGRAMMATIC DEVELOPMENT FLOW OF PROCESSES AND STRUCTURE TO PROMOTE FLEXIBLE AND CHANGING OPERATIONS
LARGE SCALE ORGANIZATION, AXONOMETRIC MANIPULATABLE INTERIOR THROUGH INFRASTRUCTURE, CRANES, GRID AND VIRENDEEL TRUSS 71
72
INTERIOR DEVELOPMENT
INTERIOR DEVELOPMENT 73
74
PART III: DEVELOPMENT SECTION C: OF AN IMAGE
75
76
77
ZONE CONSTRUCTION 78
A NEW LANDSCAPE 79
80
PART IV: FINALE THE FINAL PRESENTATION
BROKEN UP INTO THREE SECTIONS THE FINAL PRESENTATION FIRST EXPLAINS THE SITUATION UNRAVELED AND EXPANDED UPON THROUGH THE SEMESTER’S RESEARCH. SECOND THE ZONE’S NECESSARY INFRASTRUCTURE AND ACTIVITIES ARE EXAMINED. THE THIRD SEGMENT VISUALLY MAPS THE EFFECTS. THE PRESENTATION WAS ORGANIZED IN THIS MANNER. A HORIZONTAL PROJECTION DISPLAYED THE CONDITION, A VERTICAL PROJECTION THE VISUAL EFFECTS, AND THE ARCHITECTURAL INFRASTRUCTURE WAS PLOTTED AND MOUNTED.
81
82
AREA OF INTEREST: BAJA CALIFORNIA , FROM TIJUANA TO MEXICALI MEXICO’S AEROSPACE CAPITAL
PART IV: FINALE SECTION A: CONDITIONAL EXPLANATION
83
84
MAQUILA EVOLUTION EXPLANATION OF GROWTH IN COMPLEXITY AND ARRAY OF OPERATIONS
THE HONEY WELL SITUATION PROJECTED DEVELOPMENT 85
86
THE PROPOSAL: A NEW NAFTA ZONE TO SATISFY SECURITY MEASURES WHILE SEEKING CHEAPEST COSTS
SITE CHOSEN FOR PROTOTYPICAL DEVELOPMENT 87
88
PART IV: FINALE SECTION B: A NEW NAFTA INFRASTRUCTURE
89
90 SITE DEVELOPMENT
91
DEVELOPMENT SECURITY ZONES
CORPORATE FILLING
PASTORAL LANDSCAPE
INFRASTRUCTURE
A COMMUNAL FACTORY INFRASTRUCTURE 92
STRUCTURE CONTAINS FLEXIBLE PROGRAM 93
94
EXPLODED AXONOMETRIC OF FACTORY COMPONENTS
95
96
FACTORY ZONES THE FACILITY IS SEGMENTED INTO AREAS EACH SUPPORTING DIFFERENT PRODUCTION OR RESEARCH ACTIVITIES
PROGRAM 97
98
CIRCULATION CENTRAL CORRIDOR ALLOWS ACCESS TO ANY ZONE FOR BOTH PEOPLE AND MATERIALS WITHOUT HAVING TO ACCESS ANY OTHER
GNGXCVQTU UWDÄ GPVT[ UGEWTKV[ EJGEM
UWDÄ GPVT[ UGEWTKV[ EJGEM
PERSPECTIVAL SECTION EMPLOYEES ENTER THROUGH SUBTERRANEAN TUNNELS ALLOWING ACCESS TO LARGE CIRCULATION CORRIDORS WHICH ACT AS DISTRIBUTION AND PROCESSING CENTERS 99
100
SECTION OF VERY LARGE BAY TEST FACILITY: FENCE DEVELOPMENT THE FOLLOWING DRAWINGS EXAMINE THE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT OCCURRING WITHIN THE FACILITY
PERSPECTIVE OF VERY LARGE TEST BAY 101
102
EXPLODED AXONOMETRIC OF SMALL BAY
PERSPECTIVE OF SMALL BAY DEVELOPMENT OF INFRARED AND AVIONIC DETECTION TECHNOLOGIES 103
104
EXPLODED AXONOMETRIC OF SAND BOX 2: WIND TUNNEL
DRONE STUDIES 105
106
PART IV: FINALE SECTION : VISUALIZATION, A MORE HONEST BORDER CONDITION
107
TIJUANA/OTAY MESA: NEW STATE OF THE ART FACILITIES 108
MEXICALI: A NEW PROFESSIONAL CLASS 109
TIJUANA: EXCITING OPPORTUNITIES 110
MEXICALI: DEVELOP TECHNOLOGIES 111
LA RUMOROSA: WORK ON CLASSIFIED PROJECTS 112
TECATE: A NEW TYPOLOGY 113
TIJUANA: A NEW ECONOMIC ZONE 114
OCOTILLO: A MORE HONEST BORDER 115