The Islander November Issue 2015

Page 1

I er

d School D slan ist r

M

rc

November 24, 2015

mihsislander.org

The Editorial Board

Throughout the last week in September, the Mercer Island School District attracted national attention for its ban on tag. Superintendent Dr. Gary Plano described the incident as a normal part of operating in a “learning institution.� What we, the editors of The Islander, have learned from pursuing this story is that the adult world is overrun by petty politics. In a situation where communication and accountability were key, both the administrators and the parents involved in

the issue did not fully exemplify these important attributes because of the political nature of their approaches to the benign topic of tag. Over the summer and into the beginning of the new school year, the District had internal conversations on setting new norms and expectations for elementary school students on the playground. The idea of a strict “handsoff policy� emerged from the idea that the District was trying to explain its process of renorming expectations to young children. “Our intent was to go to a hands-off pol-

icy at recess to start off the school year until we could do some deliberate teaching. It wasn’t meant for that to be a permanent rule. We were trying to get it into the minds of elementary kids. With kids who need rules and boundaries, it’s hard to be ambiguous,� said Assistant Superintendent Fred Rundle. The miscommunication between administrators and the community began after a Lakeridge Elementary School Advisory Council meeting. When parents heard of the District’s hopes to renorm playground expectations,

they began a Facebook group entitled STAR (Support Tag at Recess). When Q13 News picked up the story on Sept. 23, the STAR group and the District’s ban went viral. This controversy led to several public relations issues for the District. The Today Show aired the controversy in their “What’s Trending� segment on Sept. 28, where Matt Lauer Savannah Guthrie laughed at the District’s decision. Numerous news sites awarded Washington state the title “Nanny State of the Week� (continued on page 9)

of Pediatrics recommended a high school start time of 8:30 a.m. or later... Districts that have implemented the change find it to increase sleep, increase test scores, increase grades, reduce sleepiness, reduce depression, reduce suicides, reduce obesity, reduce traffic accidents and reduce drug use. There is little else we can do that serves all these ends,� said Dave Myerson, a school board member. Contrary to what several members of the school board believe though, some think that there is nothing to gain in sending students to school later. “Sure, kids need more sleep. But once you tell a kid, ‘you don’t have to get up until...’ they are just going to stay up later,� said Karin Hummel, a sixth grade math and science teacher at Islander Middle School.

Myerson is well aware of others believing that as a result of later start times, students will go to bed later. “In fact, sleep time increased from 20 to 40 minutes. These research findings, and much more, have been very well presented by the report of the Bellevue/Mercer Island High School Start Time Committee and are readily available on the Mercer Island School District website.� Said Myerson. Considering the board’s interest in shifting bell times, three scenarios are being discussed. Later start times at MIHS will have an affect on athletes, “I currently only have 3 to 7 minutes [to] get ready...I would like to note that currently I am only a novice at crew, but I know that the varsity starts earlier. Crew isn’t a sport that you can be

more than 15-ish minutes late to because each boat has a specific line-up...If you don’t mark yourself there, you don’t get to row,� said Anonymous, a Mt. Baker crew team participant at MIHS. If the board commits to one of the scenarios, not only will athletes have to change their daily schedules due to school being pushed back, but also coaches, “It might cut into practice time, and then we have to switch our schedule...probably lose a few because they can’t make it here, they’ll probably just come late,� said Chris Rice, a tennis coach at the Mercer Island Country Club. As a response to concerns that late starts will affect athletics and band schedules, Dave Myerson brought up another example of when the district changed bell times,

MISD School Board weighs opinions on late start by

Kelly Hou staff writer

About a year ago, the Mercer Island School District formed a joint-committee with the Bellevue School District composed of parents, teachers, students, and others. Together, they discussed if having different start times than the current bell times would be beneficial for schools, and mainly if high schoolers would be able to obtain more sleep with a later start time. Members of the committee recommended to the MISD school board to discontinue the idea. Yet despite the committee’s suggestion, several school board members are still in favor of delaying school start times because they believe that the positive effects it will have on students’ health are significant. “The American Academy

What is your Favorite

(continued on page 3)

Inside

MIHS leadership initiates Open ASB Features > Page 3

Jordan Morriss continues his successful journey in Soccer Sports > Page 4

Vegetarians celebrate Thanksgiving too Spread > Page 6/7

Senior appreciation signs cause controversy Opinions > Page 9

Talk on the Rock: “Eating a lot of food, passing out, napping, then getting woken up to eat dessert.� -Nick Delman, Senior

“Making stuffing with my dad and dressing my dog up as a turkey.�

Thanksgiving Tradition?

Volume V, Edition 3

Tag incident reflects the reality of adult politics by

PAID

ic t

e

“We always dance with the turkey before we cook it!� -Claire Stein, Junior

-Anna Battisti, Junior

“My brother and I pull he wishbone apart and whoever gets the longer one gets to serve themselves first.� -Spencer Kingston, Junior

“Every year, we have dinner with my extended family. The food is really good! We have pretty classic stuff, and egg rolls which is kind of random.� -Ellie Sulla, Freshman

Another successful dodgeball tournament ends Campus Life > Page 11

Make sure to check out our new website at mihsislander.org!


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.