RESEARCH PRESENTATION
CURB TO KITCHEN
Megan Octaviani Pratiwi Prameswari
How can autonomous vehicles and mobility technology improve accessibility in a new suburban community in Mayfair, TX?
Challenge & Opportunity Research Presentation On-Demand Services Developers& Designers Government Regulations&Policy Seniors&People withDisability What are the challenges and opportunities for AV to improve accessibility? ASSIGNMENT 01
On-Demand Services
Challenges:
Commuting is time-consuming, while there are growing immediate need for goods and services.
Unpleasant commuting experiences due to friction in traffic and current city’s mobility network.
Cost for travel, particularly in those areas without access to public transit.
High possibility to get involved in mobility-related accidents.
Opportunities:
Increased convenience and productivity. More seamless and sophisticated user experiences.
Potential cost savings with shared autonomous vehicle.
Increased safety as AV practically eliminates accidents caused by human errors.
Challenge & Opportunity Research Presentation
Developers and Designers
Challenges:
Traffic congestion because of a higher number of private AV.
Deteriorating road infrastructure. Inadequate infrastructure for AV.
Ensuring redundant spaces for people and not for privatelyowned autonomous vehicle.
Multimodality management.
Opportunities:
Efficient traffic. Carbon emission reduction. Repurposing and reallocation of land use. Integration with other transportation modes.
Challenge & Opportunity Research Presentation
Government Regulations and Policy
Challenges:
Inconsistencies of regulation and policy between federal and state government. Variations in licensing and testing requirements across all states in the United States. Liability terms remain unclear, raising security concern.
Opportunities:
Federal and state governments to enact consistent regulations addressing the barriers to comprehensive implementation of autonomous mobility – Integrate policymaking.
Comprehensive guidelines on licensing and testing requirements. Policies addressing the long-term impacts of major AV adoption such as flexible parking and land use policy, spatial reallocation, congestion management and data privacy.
Challenge & Opportunity Research Presentation
Seniors and People with Disability Challenges:
AVs provision that also encourages active lifestyles.
Inconvenient and difficult-to-use technology for aged and people with disability.
Affordability and inclusive transportation services.
Opportunities:
Multimodality that encourages active lifestyle
Higher independence for older adults and people with disability.
Challenge & Opportunity Research Presentation
Code, Policy and Regulations Research Presentation How can we improve accessibility through code, policy, and regulation for AV in Mayfair? House UNDERSTANDING STREAMLINING Mayfair Site and Development Control Mobility Flows across Scales Mobility Spoke Multimodal Corridor & CODE AMENDMENT NEW CODE PROPOSAL Park & Ride System Exit I-35 ASSIGNMENT 02
Garageless House Typology
Code, Policy and Regulations
Research Presentation
Multimodal Corridor
Code, Policy and Regulations Research Presentation
Mobility Spoke Mobility Modes
Gaps and Opportunities
Mayfair DDCD has not stated how multimodal connectivity and interaction will be accomplished.
Pick-up/drop-off locations for people and services should be regulated when using AVs to improve accessibility.
Proposed New Code
To promote multimodality, the neighborhood should include biking, walking, pick-up/drop-off infrastructure, and on-demand delivery. No normal cars should be allowed to enter the neighborhood.
Only AV, robot delivery, and bicycles will be permitted on local streets.
Residents are encouraged to use the shared garden to travel between houses and to access pickup and drop-off points. Each mode of transportation has its own lane and area for safety and comfort.
Walk along the Shared Garden Bikes/Scooters
Shared AV
Code, Policy and Regulations Research Presentation
Delivery
Robots
Park and Ride System
Gaps and Opportunities
Mayfair DDCD has not considered AV deployment and its impact on the current traffic flows.
Proposed New Code
Limit traditional car usage while increasing AV deployment, particularly the shared autonomous shuttle. A shared autonomous garage near the external access points to I-35 will serve as a mobility hub, consolidating various modes of transportation.
When traditional cars arrive at Mayfair, they park in the shared garage and switch modes to AV shuttles, on-demand AVs, or micromobility to reach their destination in Mayfair.
Shared Autonomous Garage AV Shuttle Enables Mode Transfer Amenities Integrated with the Mobility Hub
Code, Policy and Regulations Research Presentation
Design Presentation Stephen Age Gender Job Activities Challenge Wishlist : 55 years old : Male : Science Teacher : Go to work, exercise, shopping, travel to Austin : Almost none : Safe sidewalks, bike routes, more trees and shades tIlovewalking,cyclingand ryingnewstuffs!ButIwant itsafeandasmuchas possible,undertheshade. Mayfaircangetquitehot! Martha Age Gender Job Activities Challenge Wishlist : 70 years old : Female : Unemployed : Watch TV, people watching, dinner with granddaughter : Wheelchair users : More travel options, groceries and medicine delivery It'sdifficultformetoget aroundinmyelectric wheelchair.Ineedaccessible optionthatcantakemetothe parkandtomydoctor's appointment!
User Profiles Design Presentation Home
Spoke Mobility Hub Mobility Exchange Multimodal Corridor Commercial
Stephen
RESIDENTIAL KEY MAP
User Profiles Design Presentation
Home Delivery Robot AV Shuttle Restaurant Multimodal Corridor
MAP
Martha
RESIDENTIAL KEY
Next Steps Howcanwedesignmobilitysystem andtechnologytomeetthechallengeand opportunityofimprovingaccessibilityinMayfair,TX? Research Presentation User Profiles and Personas IDENTIFY Mobility Service & Technology Bundle PROPOSE Opportunities to Improve Accessibility through Journey Maps CAPTURE Curb to Kitchen Connection in a NextGeneration Autonomous Mayfair DESIGN ASSIGNMENT 03 & 04
DESIGN PRESENTATION
CURB TO KITCHEN
How can we design the mobility system an technology to meet the challenge and opportunity of improving accessibility in a new suburban community in Mayfair, TX?
Megan Octaviani Pratiwi Prameswari
Site Context Project Scope
Context Design Presentation
I-35
4 Primary Land Uses
residential - education - commercial - amenities
Mayfair's four primary land uses residential, education, commercial, and amenities — are currently only linked by roads and cars. To optimize and improve connectivity and accessibility in Mayfair, these land uses must be better connected and integrated via a series of mobility networks.
4 Mobility Nodes
A "hub and spoke" mobility network connects four detached suburban land uses. A multimodal corridor loops around the site, connecting four mobility nodes: home, mobility spoke, mobility hub, and mobility exchange. Mobility spokes are dispersed throughout the neighborhoods, mobility hubs connect two or more land uses, and the mobility exchange connects the commercial, education, mixed-use, and green trail.
Context
Design Presentation
Design Presentation Stephen Age Gender Job Activities Challenge Wishlist : 55 years old : Male : Science Teacher : Go to work, exercise, shopping, travel to Austin : Almost none : Safe sidewalks, bike routes, more trees and shades tIlovewalking,cyclingand ryingnewstuffs!ButIwant itsafeandasmuchas possible,undertheshade. Mayfaircangetquitehot! Martha Age Gender Job Activities Challenge Wishlist : 70 years old : Female : Unemployed : Watch TV, people watching, dinner with granddaughter : Wheelchair users : More travel options, groceries and medicine delivery It'sdifficultformetoget aroundinmyelectric wheelchair.Ineedaccessible optionthatcantakemetothe parkandtomydoctor's appointment!
User Profiles Design Presentation Home
Spoke Mobility Hub Mobility Exchange Multimodal Corridor Commercial
Stephen
RESIDENTIAL KEY MAP
User Profiles Design Presentation
Home Delivery Robot AV Shuttle Restaurant Multimodal Corridor
MAP
Martha
RESIDENTIAL KEY
Spatial Nodes D i P t ti
Stephen
MOBILITY EXCHANGE MOBILITY SPOKE MULTIMODAL CORRIDOR
Martha
Four Multiscalar Nodes
CURB TO KITCHEN HOME
MULTIMODAL CORRIDOR
ITY HANGE
MOBILITY SPOKE Design Presentation
MOBILITY EXCHANGE
MOBILITY
CURB TO KITCHEN HOME
MULTIMODAL CORRIDOR
SPOKE
House - Curb to Kitchen
40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Design Presentation Home - Curb to Kitchen
Design Presentation Residential Block Improving Accessibility and Unlocking Landscape Opportunity Neighborhood Street Redesigning Neighborhood Road for AV Lot Garageless House Investigating across 3 Scales Capturing 3 Ideas
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
House: Capturing Opportunities STEP 1 Current Code Remove Garage Remove Driveway STEP 2 Adjust Lot Width Adjust Building Proportion STEP 3 Adjust Lot Length Adjust Setback STEP 4 40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Garageless
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
House: Capturing Opportunities STEP 1 Current Code Remove Garage Remove Driveway STEP 2 Adjust Lot Width Adjust Building Proportion STEP 3 Adjust Lot Length Adjust Setback STEP 4 40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Garageless
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
House: Capturing Opportunities STEP 1 Current Code Remove Garage Remove Driveway STEP 2 Adjust Lot Width Adjust Building Proportion STEP 3 Adjust Lot Length Adjust Setback STEP 4 40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Garageless
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
House: Capturing Opportunities STEP 1 Current Code Remove Garage Remove Driveway STEP 2 Adjust Lot Width Adjust Building Proportion STEP 3 Adjust Lot Length Adjust Setback STEP 4 40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Garageless
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
House: Capturing Opportunities Remove Garage Remove Driveway Adjust Lot Width Adjust Building Proportion Mayfair DDCD Proposed Amendment 8.4 Residential Lot Dim. Standards 8.4 Residential Lot Dim. Standards 12.3.5 Min Development Standard 12.3.5 Min Development Standard Single-family Detached, Front-Loaded Minimum Lot Width: 40 ft Single-family Detached, Front-Loaded Minimum Lot Width: 35 feet Single-family Detached Minimum and maximum one driveway per dwelling Single-family Detached No minimum driveway requirement Table 12-1 Minimum Parking Ratio Table 12-1 Minimum Parking Ratio Single-family Detached Minimum 2 parking lots Single-family Detached No minimum parking requirement 40' Single Family Front-Loaded Lots
Garageless
Rethinking Streets for Autonomous Vehicle
Design Presentation
Accessible Connections Linear Garden More Shades and Greenery
Current Code Proposal
Current Code 2-way direction side parking side parking 5' setback each Design Presentation
Streets for Autonomous Vehicle
Rethinking
Proposal PUDO Linear Gardens Sheltered Waiting Area Accessible PUDO PUDO 2-way for AV Linear Gardens & Micromobility Corridor Rethinking Streets for Autonomous Vehicle
Rethinking Streets for Autonomous Vehicle
Home - Curb to Kitchen
Design Presentation
Accessible Connections Linear Garden More Shades and Greenery
Current Code Proposal
AV Lane AV Lane backyard backyard Sheltered Waiting Area Accessible Pick-up Drop-Off Design Presentation Improving Accessibility & Unlocking Landscape Opportunity Sheltered Waiting Area Smart Dropbox Accessible Pick-up Drop-off Smart Crossing (Ground sensor linked to AV system) Linear Garden & Micromobility Corridor
Linear Garden & Micromobility Corridor AV Lane AV Lane backyard backyard Sheltered Waiting Area Accessible Pick-up Drop-Off Design Presentation Improving Accessibility & Unlocking Landscape Opportunity
H ation Newaccessible& shadedPUDOwith smartdropbox Floorplateareaof eachhousingunit Reductionin numberofhomes Lessroad Increaseingreen, shades,and landscapeareas 20 EQUAL ZERO 50% 1.7 x (approximate) (approximate) PROPOSAL
Home - Curb to Kitchen Pick-up Drop-Off and Smart Delivery Box Design Presentation
Accessible Curb to Kitchen
Rethinking Neighborhood Street
MAYFAIR
Home - Curb to Kitchen Design Presentation
Street View from Inside an Autonomous Shuttle
Backyard Garden and Interaction Opportunity
Home - Curb to Kitchen
Design Presentation
H ation PROPOSAL Newaccessible& shadedPUDOwith smartdropbox Floorplateareaof eachhousingunit Reductionin numberofhomes Lessroad Increaseingreen, shades,and landscapeareas 20 EQUAL ZERO 50% 1.7 x WITHIN ONE RESIDENTIAL BLOCK... (approximate) (approximate)
Mobility Exchange
Design
Presentation Mobility Exchange
Commercial
School Mixed-use
Recreation Center
Mobility Exchange
Context and Land Uses
What is a Mobility Exchange?
A focal point to: 1. 2.
seamlessly and safely integrates different modes of transportation create activity centers that maximize first-mile lastmile connectivity.
Commercial School Mobility Exchange Mixed-use Recreational
Center
Land Uses
This mobility exchange connects four different land uses (commercial, school, recreational center, mixed-use) at the road intersection.
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
Converging Various User Groups and Mobility Modes
Mobility Exchange Development Opportunities
Five mobility exchange points can be developed to connect five locations separated by intersections.
Current Proposal
Mobility point of the commercial area near the road intersection and nature trail (blue circle)
Target User Groups and Mobility Modes
Commercial School
Young people, mostly use bikes, scooters
Middle-aged adults, mostly use AVs
Mixed-Use Recreational Center
Middle-aged adults, mostly walk and use delivery services
Older adults, mostly use AVs
Exchange
Mobility
Design Presentation
Mobility Exchange Retail People (With and without mobility barriers) Design Presentation
Modes Transfer and Activity Center Inside the Mobility Exchange Plaza Bikes/Scooters (Private & Shared) AVs (On-Demand & Shuttle) Delivery (Parcel Pick-Up & Delivery) 1. Mode Transfer
Amenities
Mobility
2.
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
Retail People (With and without mobility barriers) Plaza Bikes/ Scooters (Private & Shared) AV PUDO (On-Demand & Shuttle) Delivery (Parcel Pick-Up & Delivery) Nature Trail Road Road Commercial
Proposal
Mobility Exchange Drone Shared & Private Bike/Scooter Garage Proposed Mobility Exchange More facilities (e.g. building & outside PUDO, bike/scooter garage, parcel handling facilities) Retail Plaza AV + Robodelivery, Bike, and Shaded Pedestrian Lanes AV Charging & Parking Building & Outside PUDO AV & Robo Delivery PUDO AV Delivery Charging & Parking AV, Bike, & Pedestrian Lanes AV Charging & Parking Design Presentation CODE 1: MINIMUM DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Conventional Mobility Hub Limited facilities (e.g. only have an outside PUDO and shared docks and racks for bikes/scooters) Retail Open Air Bike/Scooter Shared Docks & Private Racks Plaza Outside PUDO
MINIMUM
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
1:
DEVELOPMENT
500 Connection Internal External Min. Coverage 0.3 Housing Units Mile Buffer Bike & scooter lane AV & robodelivery lane Shaded pedestrian way Drone route Building connection Road connection and road-facing access Nature trail connection Neighboring land use connection
CODE
STANDARDS
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
1:
CODE
1. PICK-UP/DROP-OFF 2. BIKE & SCOOTER GARAGE 3. PARCEL PICK-UP/DELIVERY
5.PLAZA PUDO for on-demand and shuttle AV Types: building and outside PUDO Facilitated by AV charging and parking (min. 15 vehicles) Share, store, charge bikes and scooters Private and shared bikes and scooters Accommodate min. 30 bikes + scooters
handling building Parcel pick-up area AV & robodelivery PUDO AV delivery charging and parking Rooftop drone delivery Facilities: Retail shops for mobility exchange users Open space for mobility exchange users
MINIMUM DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Facilities
4.RETAIL
Parcel
A Site Plan of Mobility Exchange
An example of Code 1 being applied.
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
Handling parcels before being dispatched
Connected to the rooftop drone delivery, the parcel pick-up area, and the AV and Robodelivery PUDO
Located on the rooftop to limit encounter with other transportation modes and people Accommodate min. 25 drones
Connected to the parcel handling building
Connected to the pedestrian way and the bike & scooter lane
4.AV DELIVERY CHARGING AND PARKING
Have direct access to the AV lane
Accommodate min. 6 vehicles
Mobility Exchange Drone Route AV + Robodelivery, Bike, and
Pedestrian Lane AV & Robo Delivery PUDO AV Delivery Charging & Parking Rooftop drone delivery Parcel handling building Parcel pick-up area Design Presentation
PARCEL PICK-UP & DELIVERY Facilities 1. PARCEL HANDLING BUILDING 2. ROOFTOP DRONE DELIVERY 3. PARCEL PICK-UP
Shaded
CODE 2:
AV
ROBODELIVERY PUDO
Connecting AV lanes and the parcel handling building 5.
&
PARCEL PICK-UP & DELIVERY
Easement for Delivery Vehicles (AV, Robodelivery, and Drone)
CONVENTIONAL
AV lanes are only for both ondemand and shuttle AV
AV Delivery Drone Robodelivery
PROPOSAL
Besides on-demand and shuttle AV, AV lanes accommodate AV delivery and robodelivery. For safety purposes, drones must only fly above AV lanes. Drone routes will follow the direction of AV lanes.
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
CODE 2:
and
Areas
PUDO Types
1. PUDO Outside (Conventional)
PUDO area is located outside the building and mainly accommodates people without mobility barriers In this example, PUDO outside is for people who want to be closer to the plaza
2. PUDO Building (New Proposal)
PUDO area is located inside the building with a cut in the building mass This PUDO prioritizes people with mobility barriers
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation CODE 3:
Waiting Area
Area Plaza Crossing PUDO Outside
Pick-Up
Drop-Off
Retail Building PUDO Building
Waiting
2. 1.
1.
Bike & Scooter Garage is provided to switch between bike/scooter and pedestrian
People cannot directly switch between AV & bike/scooter and need to use pedestrian way for safety purposes
2. Circulation
AVs can only use AV lanes and can access AV charging and parking area Bikes/scooters can only use bike lanes
People can only use pedestrian ways
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation CODE 3: Pick-Up and Drop-Off Areas
PEOPLE BIKE/ SCOOTER Pedestrian Way Bike Lane Garage PUDO AV AV Lane AV Charging & Parking AV Charging & Parking PUDO Building Pedestrian Way Bike& Scooter Garage PUDO Outside Bike Lane
PUDO Connectivity
PUDO is provided to switch between AV and pedestrian
Transfer Mode
An Example of AV Circulation
Pick-Up/ DropOff & Waiting Area(Inside Building)
AV can access both PUDO outside the building and inside the building
An AV parking and charging area should be accessible and located near PUDO Both one-way and two-way lanes can be provided to facilitate AV movement
Mobility Exchange
Design Presentation
AV Charging and Parking
Pick-Up/ DropOff & Waiting Area (Outside Building) AV Lane
An Example of Bike and Scooter Circulation
Bike lanes can be used by scooters and bikes to access the bike and scooter garage as well as other facilities in the mobility exchange
The garage facilitates sharing, storing, and charging of bikes and scooter
Mobility Exchange
Design Presentation
& Scooter Storage
Lane
Bike
Crossing Bike
An Example of Pedestrian Circulation
A shaded pedestrian way is provided to protect pedestrian from the weather Building connections also provided to help people move around between buildings
Mobility Exchange Design Presentation
Crossing Plaza Building Connections (Pedestrian Way) Shaded Pedestrian Way