ACADEMIC PORTFOLIO CREATIVE SYNERGIES STUDIO 2020/21 STAGE 3
JACK M CALLAGHAN 180208818
CONTENTS
ILLUSTRATIVE REFLECTIVE REPORT
002
FRAMING
005
CASE STUDY EXTRACT
047
TESTING
053
SYNTHESIS
080
ILLUSTRATED CULTURAL BIBLIOGRAPHY
121
BIBLIOGRAPHY AND LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
125
APPENDIX
127
NEW WORK (FULL PAGE) AMENDED/IMPROVED WORK (FULL PAGE) NEW WORK (SPECIFIC ILLUSTRATION ON PAGE) 1
(Fairs, 2009)
ILLUSTRATED REFLECTIVE REPORT
actual building structure, relying on natural resources and emitting large amounts of CO2, things did not add up. On completion of the module my intention was to experiment with alternative strategies that would reduce the amount of concrete the building was utilizing.
It wasn’t until this year that I came to the realisation that architecture does not sit as its own entity but is engaging with social, environmental, political, cultural and economic spheres. The design practice begins with the wider issues that need addressing not the architecture. Through rigorous research and using architecture as a catalyst to challenge, our studio Creative Synergies aimed at trying to reduce the inexcusable contribution our profession has on our current climate crisis. In the UK, 36% of all measured waste is generated by the construction industry and it is one of the only industries where there is more waste being produced now than at the start of the century. Due to the climate crisis there is an increased focus on the levels of waste produced on an individual and global scale and how we are dealing with this waste. My graduation project aimed to address these issues on construction waste by devising a scheme that repurposes demolition waste into sustainable ecologically sound hand-made construction bricks, combining industry and craft.
ILLUSTRATION ‘THE DEMOLITION ISSUE’ - FRAMING
(Abdallah, 2018)
(Abdallah, 2018)
The theoretical explorations carried out in the Theory Into Practice module helped me to critically reflect on the projects line of enquiry and how it was forming a relationship with social, architectural and theoretical realms. I was intrigued by the philosophies of Samuel Mockbee’s Rural Studio and his believes that architecture served an ethical purpose with a responsibility to serve a community. Students were designing for the poorest members of Rural Alabama often with salvaged, reused, repurposed materials. The essay explored the meaning and importance of craft in an architectural landscape and how the tacit knowledge that emerges from craft could potentially form a praxis that follows Mockbee's call to challenge the status quo of design practice. The module was essential in translating these theoretical perspectives to my design practice and greatly influenced the craft narrative in my line of enquiry. The ARC3014 Professional Practise module integrated itself closely to the design module and provided an opportunity for me to look at my building through a practical perspective, giving me an insight into how a project of this scale would be implemented and procured in reality. The module also gave me an understanding of how the building was responding in a socio-environmental context. Initially I was proposing that the building was to be constructed by a series of massive concrete shell forms and then the bricks clad to it. From writing the section of the module which engaged with issues of climate change and an architects’ obligations to sustainability I began to realise that I was contradicting myself. My projects programme was concerned with trying to form solutions to environmental issues arising from how we handle waste, our reliance on natural resources and trying to mitigate much of the carbon emissions found in the conventional brick making process, however, I was then proposing to use a massive amount of concrete for the
PAVILION EXPLORATION ITERATION - COMPARISON TO SAMUEL MOCKBEE’S RURAL STUDIO - FRAMING
1 2 3 4
5
6 7
28
29
9
8
10
11
12
PROGRESSION OF STRUCTURAL STRATEGY ARC3013 27 26
30
ARCH FACADE AND INTERIOR STRUCTURE 1
REPURPOSED BRICK EXTERNAL CLADDING
2
CONCRETE SHELL STRUCTURE 300mm
3
BRICK SUPPORT BRACKET / SERVICES CAVITY 40mm
4
REPURPOSED BRICK INTERNAL CLADDING
5
CONCRETE LINTEL
6
GLASS DOOR
7
DOOR FRAME
8
VAPOUR CONTROL LAYER
INTERMEDIATE FLOORING 9
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOR HEATING
10
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
11
STEEL BEAMS W/ SPACE FOR SERVICES
12
CONCRETE CEILING FINISH
INTERNAL WALL 13
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
14
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
15
CONCRETE WALL
16
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
FLOORING 17
2
My thinking through making piece helped me to reflect on how the structural strategy for my building and how I could translate the sustainable philosophies of my building programme into the very fabric of the building. I wanted my building to speak of bricks structural capabilities and aesthetic qualities. I became intrigued by The Catalan Masonry technique also referred to as timbrel vaulting. These thin masonry spans of overlapping brick tiles woven together with fast-setting mortar are structures that no architects today would dare build without the correct steel reinforcements, but research from Michael Rampage shows how the marriage of modern materials with traditional craft techniques allows for both to capitalize on the strengths of each. The thinking through making experiment was fundamental in contributing to the final design outcome as this vaulting technique explored then became the dominant construction technique exhibited in the building and also expressed the ideas about implementing craft in a modern context successfully.
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOD HEATING
18
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
19
JOISTS AND CAVITY FOR SERVICES
20
IN-SITU CONCRETE FLOOR
LEFT: 1:20 ITERATION SHOWING CONCRETE SHELL STRUCTURE WITH BRICK CLADDING
21
CONCRETE PILE FOUNDATION CONCRETE PILE CAP
23
PERFORATED DRAIN 60mm
24
HARDCORE GRAVEL LAYER 90mm
25
BLINDING 80mm
RETAINING WALL 26
PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL
27
BACKFILL 100mm
14 15 16 34 33
RIGHT: 1:20 FINAL SECTION SHOWING TIMBREL VAULTING STRUCTURE 17
23
18
19
20
The final design realisation is an accumulation of the ideas and theories explored throughout the three stages of the design module and other relevant modules. Although the ideas explored during the Framing stage of participation and collaboration during the construction process did not fully translate themselves to the finalised design outcome, they were fundamental to the overall progression of the project’s narrative, and with each stage the narrative went through there was the same underlying intention which unified its progression, to challenge. My site, the Ouseburn Valley, a post-industrial area undergoing major development brings fears from the community over social displacement. My project aims to respect the valleys industrial history and integrate itself within the strong craft culture now present in the valley. The increase in developments has also caused an increase in demolitions. I believe that my project is important in addressing how we as a society handle waste our waste.
STEEL CABLE FORMWORK
LEFT: SNIPPET OF FINAL DESIGN REALISATION SHOWING TIMBREL VAULTING STRUCTURE RIGHT: ADAPTING TIMBREL VAULTING TECHNIQUE EXPLORED IN TTM TO BUILDING
24 25
31
22
32
FOUNDATIONS 22
13
In previous years it was commented that my ambition to address material and technical issues was lacking and that technology was the weakest element in my work. This year one of my main personal goals was to improve my technical understanding and the ARC3013 provided me an opportunity to do so. I feel that I engaged with the challenges that arose from implementing the vaulting construction technique explored previously on a larger scale and adapting it to the challenging nature of my site in an appropriate manner. I came to the conclusion that as a designer it is crucial to consider the construction strategy for the building at the beginning of the design process which ultimately results in the technology aspect to become much more intrinsically connected and apartment in the buildings final realisation, rather than it being considered at a later stage in the design process which I was guilty of doing in previous years. This module was challenging but rewarding and I feel that I have made great strides in my technical understanding, it was a great learning experience and greatly influenced the final design realisation.
LEFT: PETER RICH ARCHITECTS MAPUNGUBWE INTERPRETATION CENTRE - EXAMPLE OF TIMBREL VAULTING IN REAL LIFE RIGHT: THINKING THROUGH MAKING MODEL REPLICATING THE CONSTRUCTION PROCESS
21
3
CREATIVE SYNERGIES STUDIO INTRODUCTION
KEY STUDIO THEMES
The central question which guided our studio was what role the institution of education, and the spaces in which it takes place, can play in consolidating and mediating between transient and established communities?
PROCESS
The studio Creative Synergies aims to create a synergy between academia and the community of Ouseburn by proposing an institute that hosts a particular research specialism. Through our research we explore the various functions, processes, skills and materiality involved in the art of hands-on making, architectural craft and a tactile appreciation of space and volume and gauge how compatible these are in a future of cutting edge architectural research, and wider sustainable strategies aimed at trying to reduce the professions inexcusable contribution to the ongoing climate crisis.
I aim to begin framing with trying to gain an understanding of the historical processes that the Ouseburn underwent from its industrial past and how it now sits at this interesting juncture of an ever changing social and architectural reclassification. Through the processes of mapping, sketching, research and talking to members of the community I aim to unpick the Ouseburns multitude of different layers that will begin to inform my initial line of enquiry for a synergy.
The studio places an emphasis on rigorous research and process.
SUSTAINABILITY / RESEARCH I am fully aware of the contribution our profession has on the current climate situation and throughout framing I aim to begin addressing some of these issues involved in this climate dilemma and as the year progresses I hope of forming solutions through the research that my institute will facilitate. Rigorous research will allow me to gain a thorough understanding of the unsustainable processes our profession is guilty of in contributing to the climate crisis, and by having this understanding it will allow me to begin addressing them in an appropriate manner. CRAFT Ouseburn was historically a site of significant industry and craft, in its present form it is bustling with a variety of small scale craft businesses and individuals. I intend to respect the Ouseburns craft culture in my explorations and throughout framing I aim to explore the role of craft in an architectural setting and how through a reduced engagement with craft in modernity its return could potentially form a catalyst in breaking up social complacency.
FRAMING
The framing stage began with an ambition to gain a thorough understanding of the Ouseburn and its postindustrial landscape. From interacting with members of the community it provided a greater insight into some of the social issues currently present in the valley and the fears over community displacement due to the rise in post-industrial regeneration and development. As the framing stage progresses the narrative for my line of enquiry shifts, this was when I came to realisation that I was not responding to the brief in accordance with the site and its context and that I needed to revolve my narrative around the current issues and challenges present within the local and wider context. I noticed the increase in demolitions due to the increase in developments and regeneration in the local context. Ultimately, from this I aimed to address how we as a society handle our waste, focussing on the construction sector and from researching circular economic methods, I engaged with ideas on how to repurpose and utilize construction waste as a resource. A pavilion exploration was used as a method to translate these
initial ideas into a realised 3d form. It engages the three main themes explored during the framing stage: reintroducing craft in a modern context, reclamation and reuse and collaboration and participation during the construction phase.
OUSEBURN VALLEY, ENGLAND
The explorations for the project take place within the Ouseburn Valley. A small tributary of the River Tyne located in the North East of England. As seen from the photography Ouseburns architectural landscape is characterised by a dynamic post-industrial landscape with many of these industrial fragments still remaining today. Over the course of the last decade the valley has become increasingly more developed as it gains more attention from developers. We began the framing stage by sub-dividing our studio into three groups to analyse and explore particular segments of the Ouseburn, the groups consisted of: 1. Past, Present and Future, 2. Communities, 3. Landscapes.
AERAL VIEW OF THE OUSEBURN VALLEY (Google Earth Pro) SERIES OF PHOTOGRAPHS FROM SITE VISIT DEPICTING CHARACTER AND LOCATION OF OUSEBURN
6
8
PAST AND PRESENT
BUSINESS
RESIDENCE
The Ouseburn was once the cradle of the industrial revolution in Newcastle, with a cluster of heavy crafts and industries in the area. However, by the mid-twentieth century these industrial buildings eventually fell into disuse and dereliction. Since the 1970’s they have been increasingly utilised as creative workspaces by artists, musicians, designers, printmakers and brewers. Ouseburn is a thriving community that attracts an eclectic crowd.
ATTRACTION
(Ouseburn Then and Now, 2020)
(AUTHORS PHOTOGRAPH)
(Ouseburn Then and Now, 2020)
(Ouseburn Then and Now, 2020)
(Ouseburn Then and Now, 2020)
(Ouseburn Then and Now, 2020)
INDUSTRIAL LATE 20th CENTURY
The diagram on the right depicts Ouseburns shifting landscape as it moves out of the industrial era into the 21st century. Due to its close proximity to Newcastle City Centre it has become an increasingly more desirable place to live with a surge in new developments.
BUSINESS
By gaining an understanding of Ouseburns past and its ever shifting landscape allowed me to start developing a scheme which can respect its rich industrial heritage to ensure that my institute will be relevant to the local and wider contexts.
RESIDENCE
ATTRACTION
PAST
PRESENT
INDUSTRIAL 21st CENTURY
DIAGRAMMING THE VALLEYS SHIFTING LANDSCAPE (GROUPWORK NOT PRODUCED BY AUTHORS GROUP)
9
OUSEBURN VALLEYS HISTORICAL TIMELINE (GROUPWORK NOT PRODUCED BY AUTHORS GROUP)
COMPARING OUSEBURNS PAST AND PRESENT
11
VOICES OF THE OUSEBURN
"It's magic! I have been coming here since the 1970s. Everyone comes to socialise and enjoy the beautiful nature"
“It’s soo lovely now.. Remember when we were groovin’ over there? We had nowhere else to go. [...] It was all abandoned.. So free. Now it’s all been torn down”
PORTRAITS OF COMMUNITY MEMBERS FROM SITE VISIT (GROUPWORK PRODUCED BY AUTHORS GROUP)
12
To gain a more intimate understanding of the Valley our group approached members of the community whilst on site to ask them how they viewed the valley. Some of the common themes that occurred where that the valley was almost like an escape from the bustling City Centre of Newcastle. Its vibrancy and tranquil character was what brought people to visit the valley, however, due to the ongoing developments and proposals there was a shared fear that the valley will inevitably become more gentrified and the effect that this will have on its current character could be detrimental.
“Yeah 40 odd years I’ve been here. [...] Everything is always in flux. [...] Yeah revived and bohemian.. That’s yous say nowadays”
“What I am more concerned about is this London Eye thing going up right down there by the Tyne. The Whey Aye I think it will be called.”
“Man the area has changed! Now that these residential areas are coming up it’s simply not what it used to be! We used to have the best parties and events here but now.. too much noise!”
VOICES OF THE OUSEBURN (PRODUCED BY AUTHOR)
13
(Newcastle Quayside ‘Whey Aye’ Ferris wheel plan approved, 2019)
(Holland, 2020)
? N
O I T A C
PROPOSED: WHEY AYE WHEEL - 440ft tall ‘Whey Aye’ wheel, a 39ft statue named ‘The Geordie Giant’
PROPOSED: ST ANN’S QUAY, EAST QUAYSIDE AREA - 14-storey development on Newcastle’s Quayside that would include 291 flats
PROPOSED: ST LAWRENCE ROAD, OUSEBURN - New block of high-end river view homes
(Ford, 2019)
(Holland, 2021)
(Holland, 2019)
PROPOSED: ST LAWRENCE ROAD - Plans for 50 flats overlooking the river Tyne
G
PROPOSED: UPTIN HOUSE STUDENT SCHEME - Six storey, 219 bed student apartment scheme
I F I
R T
N E
(Ford, 2016)
14
(Holland, 2019)
PROPOSED: MALMO QUAY, QUAYSIDE - Major new “18-storey” housing scheme
IN DEVELOPMENT: QUAY TIMBER SITE, HUME STREET - 51 new luxury flats and two offices
(Dickinson, 2018)
(Planning Update 25th Jan 2017, 2017)
PROPOSED: APARTMENT HOTEL - Modern 18-bed apart-hotel
PROPOSED: EAST QUAYSIDE AREA - 130 new apartments and multi storey car park
LEFT: A RANGE OF PROPOSALS SET TO BE DEVELOPED WITHIN THE VALLEY RIGHT: COLLAGE EXPRESSING THE SHARED FEAR OF GENTRIFICATION WITHIN THE VALLEY (PRODUCED BY AUTHOR FOR AUTHORS GROUP)
15
INITIAL RESPONSE TO THE OUSEBURN “COMMUNITY VS DEVELOPERS”
From visiting the Ouseburn, talking to the residents, and enjoying the valleys amenities I began to grow an attraction for the area. I began to share the same fear of those residents we initially talked to, I didn’t want the Ouseburn to become gentrified, although there are particular benefits to interest from developers I felt that perhaps developers intentions sway away from benefiting the overall community and are more about making profit even if they mask their ultimate intentions behind a desire to truly benefit the community. The Ouseburn seems to be a community moulded off interest and skills rather than a community in the traditional sense where people live and work. The map on the left depicts the shear amount of creative businesses and individuals within the valley. For my project I aim to celebrate the creative variety within the Ouseburn and for it to ultimately tie itself into the valleys craft culture.
MAPPING CREATIVE BUSINESSES WITHIN THE VALLEY
16
VISUALISING INITIAL RESPONSE TO THE OUSEBURN COMMUNITY; THE FEARS OVER DISPLACEMENT AND GENTRIFICATION IN THE AREA
17
INITIAL RESPONSE TO THE ACADEMY
We began forming our initial interests in the academy by researching teaching methods utilized here at Newcastle University. Whilst researching collaborative teaching methods we where intrigued by the variety of both interdisciplinary live projects between different departments of the academy and live projects where there’s collaboration between the academy and wider communities.
(Ouseburn Culvert Bandstand — Raskl. Art+Architectural Production, 2017)
(Ouseburn Culvert Bandstand — Raskl. Art+Architectural Production, 2017)
These are usually a response to a real world need and contributing to a live project can be seen as a great learning opportunity to gain and develop new skills rewarding and valuing communication and participation. THE OUSEBURN BANDSTAND In the context of Ouseburn, The Ouseburn Bandstand was a collaboration project between Northumbria and Newcastle architecture societies in association with Ouseburn Trust. The aim was to encourage the use of green spaces in the area. The visualisation on the right aims to depict the collaboration between students and the community during the construction of the stand. I aim to harness the same collaborative spirit for my project and provide an opportunity for participation of both architecture students and members of the community.
(Ouseburn Culvert Bandstand — Raskl. Art+Architectural Production, 2017)
PHOTOS FROM CONSTRUCTION PHASE OF THE OUSEBURN BANDSTAND
18
VISUALISING INITIAL RESPONSE TO THE ACADEMY; THE OUSEBURN BANDSTAND CONSTRUCTION PROCESS
19
INITIAL RESPONSE TO A SYNERGY
(Ouseburn Trust, 2021)
My initial ideas for a synergy between the academy and Ouseburn was the participation in the process of wooden boat building. The reasoning was that it was the perfect opportunity for collaboration due to its inevitable co-operative process. The underlying intention is to divert architecture students away from a paper based education towards a more hands-on learning experience in the form of the intricate art of boat building and begin to form a relationship and understanding of the materials and processes involved. The process of boat building also respects and pays tribute to the important history boating played during the industrial revolution in Ouseburn and Newcastle.
MOTOR CLUB MEMBERS IN THE 1950’S (Ouseburn Trust, 2021)
The River Tyne was world renowned for its industrial heritage of shipbuilding and the exporting of coal. However, also the diversity of sporting and leisure activities that derived from the river. Fishing, swimming and sailing were essential skills for people who lived nearby and relied on the river and the sea for food and income. (Ouseburn Trust 2021)
ORNATE CABINS ON BOATS IN THE 1950’S
VISUALISING INITIAL RESPONSE TO A SYNERGY BETWEEN THE ACADEMY AND COMMUNITY; THE INTRICATE AND COLLABORATIVE ART OF BOATBUILDING
20
21
FROM SHIELDFIELD
OFFICE FURNITURE SHOP
NEWCASTLE CITY CENTRE
BYKER SLIPWAY
THE PAVILION THE SITE
ABANDONED
FROM WEST OUSEBURN
The pavilion acts as a pilot study for the final institute and provides an opportunity to think through my line of enquiry and formulate some of my initial research and ideas in a 3 dimensional form.
SLIPWAY FROM SOUTH HEATON
OUSEBURN RIVER WALK
The site for this exploration sits at the heart of the Ouseburn alongside the river. The reasoning for choosing this site was its strong relationship to boating and provided an opportunity to explore my initial idea for a boat building synergy. It has direct access with an unused slipway originally used for coal exportation during the industrial revolution. The Newcastle Motorboat Club is also situated onsite and use the slipway for the maintaining of their boats.
FROM TYNE RIVER
NEWCASTLE-UPON-TYNE MOTOR CLUB - CLUBHOUSE
FROM QUAYSIDE FROM QUAYSIDE
ROUTES TOWARDS SITE
EXISTING STRUCTURES ON SITE
PRIVATE
NARROW SLOPING BANK
GATESHEAD
22
SITE PHOTOGRAPHY (AUTHOR)
24
all while the architectural superstars where rising up in a new global economy . . .
the simple but inventive structures where made of inexpensive, mostly salvaged or donated, often curious materials . . .
. . . American architecture had shifted from civic engagement and socially orientated design to a preoccupation with matters of style (Ouseburn Farm Charity Ltd, n.d.)
Hale County, Alabama, 1990s
(Dancing House Hotel Prague | Official Website | Welcome, n.d.)
Mockbee believed that architects and architecture served an ethical purpose, with a responsibility to serve a community . . .
ghost buildings, abandoned barns, delicate remnants of a more prosperous agarian past . . .
(Kirby, 2015)
using reclaimed and recycled materials is a great way to save costs, but also engage the community
(Huebner, 2010)
25
(Cook House, Mockbee/Coker – The Official Website of Samuel Mockbee, n.d.)
we must challenge the status quo of our profession into making responsible environmental and social changes.
Samuel Mockbee begins Rural Studio with the intention of creating housing for the poorest members of the long-forgotten Hale County
(Our Story - Rural Studio, n.d.)
shaped and built by students Mockbee aimed to teach them the fundamentals of not only design and construction, but also of decency and fairness
Mockbee believed that architectural education should expand its curriculum from ‘paper-based architecture”’to the creation of real buildings generating ‘a moral sense of service to the community’
(Abdallah, 2018)
students create something wonderful - architecturally, socially, politically, environmentally, and aesthetically, that’s the mission of the Rural Studio
FAUNAGRAPHIC PIECE UNDER BYKER ROAD BRIDGE
(Dean, Hursley, Chua and Robinson, 2002)
(Dean, 2003)
26
THE PAVILION
(Treggiden, 2017)
THE PAVILION
PROCESS - STEAM BENDING
PROCESS - RECLAIMED MATERIALS
From my initial research into the academy I wanted the pavilion to replicate a live project scenario by providing an opportunity for collaboration between architecture students and members of the Ouseburn community. The self-build aspect would challenge the default way of architectural education from a paper-based education to a more collaborative hands on approach of actually constructing. This would teach students the fundamentals of not only design and construction but also decency and fairness.
A key inspiration for the pavilions narrative is the philosophy behind Samuel Mockbees Rural Studio. The idea for a steam bent pavilion shifted towards the utilization of a wider range of salvaged and re-used materials as I intended to explore the philosophies of Samuel Mockbees work further.
(Abdallah, 2018)
I used the technique of steam-bending to allow me to translate my initial response of a synergy to the pavilion. As the technique is heavily involved in the crafting of wooden boats it would provide students and the community a hands-on experience with the tools and techniques involved in its process. (Brady, 2011)
Craft contains the critical thinking that could unpack the current state of architecture - Catherine Rossi
(Rossi, 2017)
INITIAL PAVILION EXPLORATION
27
The main purpose of the Rural Studio is to enable each student to step across the threshold of misconceived opinions and to design/build with a ’moral sense’ of service to a community. - Samuel Mockbee PAVILION ITERATION - EXPLORING MATERIALITY AND FORMING LINKS WITH SAMUEL MOCKBEES RURAL STUDIO
28
REGENERATION IN THE VALLEY THE DEMOLITION ISSUE
Due to issues of regeneration and commercialization in the area I noticed the high frequency of demolitions that have occurred from the late 20th century until present within the valley and its periphery, as fragments of Ouseburns industrial past come to the end of their lifespan to make way for these newer developments. Whilst researching demolition more in depth I came across some shocking statistics that began to shift my line of enquiry. LEARNT SO FAR Up until now I have been engaging with the idea of creating a pavilion utilizing salvaged materials and introducing craft techniques to architecture students and members of the community to provide an opportunity for collaboration and participation with the aim of reintroducing craft in a modern context as a methodology to break up social complacency. However, I was not letting the architecture evolve out of the culture and the place. Some of the salvaged and repurposed material choices I was proposing to engage with where not appropriately related to the context of Ouseburn.
DEMOLISHED
PROPOSED TO BE DEMOLISHED
AREAS FOR POTENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
PAVILION SITE
29
30
In the UK, the construction industry accounts for 60% of all materials used, while also generating 36% of all measured waste. While there are a significant amount of problems that arise from the overproduction of materials and increase in demolition waste. There is one considerable issue with sending the waste straight to landfill; we are running out of space to store it!
ILLUSTRATION BY AUTHOR (STATISTIC SOURCE: (Waste statistics - Statistics Explained, 2018))
31
SPILLER’S TYNE MILL WAS COMPLETED IN 1938 AND WAS THEN THE TALLEST FLOUR MILLING BUILDING IN THE WORLD; DEMOLISHED 2011 (Imaging, 2011)
32
While the composition of demolition wastes are highly variable depending on the project and the construction technique utilized. Much of building waste is made up of high carbon materials such as bricks and concrete with these two together contributing on average to 40-80% of the composition of construction and demolition waste.
(Gálvez-Martos and Istrate, 2020)
33
The construction industry is now one of the only industries where there is more waste being produced in the present moment than at the start of the century.
(Waste statistics - Statistics Explained, 2018)
34
OUSEBURNS BRICK-SCAPE
Brick was a significant material used throughout the industrial revolution as it made construction quicker and simpler for bricklayers. Due to the rich industrial history in the Ouseburn brick is the most common material present. New and proposed developments are aiming to respect this existing architectural landscape by utilizing brick as the main cladding material.
OUSEBURNS MATERIAL LANDSCAPE; AUTHORS OWN PHOTOGRAPHY
35
POST INDUSTRIAL LANDSCAPE
NEW DEVELOPMENTS 36
CIRCULAR ECONOMY A SOLUTION TO THE WASTE PROBLEM
‘Our economic system is based on the principles of the exhaustion of natural resources for the purpose of production, entailing the fabrication of waste. This system functions at the expense of our social integrity and environmental sustainability.’
We cannot condone the devastating effects the current linear economy model has posed for the planet, we must challenge our misconceptions over waste, other than seeing it as something which must be banished or discarded, we must view it as an opportunity; from cities producing waste, to waste regenerating cities. This is how we move forward.
- (Hebel, Wisniewska, and Heisel, 2015) The concept of a circular economy seeks to change this failing economic model. Unlike linear economics where a product is produced, utilized and then ultimately becoming waste, in a circular system the waste returns to the production process and is used as the catalyst for the production of new products. ECONOMIC MODELS IN CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY
LINEAR ECONOMIC MODEL 37
CIRCULAR ECONOMIC MODEL 38
THE PAVILION FINAL ITERATION
OUSEBURN LOOKOUT SHELTER The final pavilion iteration is an accumulation of the ideas and themes explored throughout the framing stage. It manifests itself as a look out shelter along a tranquil riverside walk in the heart of the valley. 1.
REINTRODUCING CRAFT
The pavilion utilizes a traditional vaulting technique named timbrel vaulting. A 14th century building technique it relies on the adhesion of several layers of overlapping brick tiles which are woven together with fast setting mortar. This technique reintroduces this ancient craft in a modern context and provides participants with a tactile experience with the brick. 2.
RECLAMATION AND RE-USE
The pavilion is constructed using reclaimed bricks from local demolition sites. The pavilion acts in a circular economic model by utilizing waste and mitigating the amount of brick that ends up in landfill. Responding to the current climate crisis the pavilion acts as a model for reuse. 3.
COLLABORATION AND PARTICIPATION
The pavilion is a collaboration project between students of the academy and members of the Ouseburn community. Members will participate directly with the construction of the pavilion providing an opportunity for the sharing of skills and expertise. In terms of the studios academy theme the pavilion acts as a research project into sustainable construction techniques and how they can be adapted to the 21st century.
39
SUSTAINABLE CRAFT TECHNIQUES EMPLOYED
PAVILION CONSTRUCTED
A temporary waffle structure is assembled on site and is used as the skeleton upon which the bricks will be laid over
Steel wire mesh then spans over the waffle structure to provide a guide for the laying of the bricks
Repurposed bricks are then cut into slips using a grinder on site. The slips are then applied directly over the mesh using fast setting mortar. Another layer is then applied directly over that in an alternating direction to provide the structure with compressive strength
Construction of waffle structure and steel wire mesh
Cutting the bricks into slips to be attached to wire mesh
Attaching bricks to the wire mesh to construct dome
Once the two layers of bricks have been layered the waffle structure is removed from beneath the brick dome structure.
A round wood frame structure is then constructed and acts as the looking shelter as it exerts itself out towards the river.
BUILDING DEMOLISHED
LOCALLY SOURCED DEMOLITION WASTE BRICKS REPURPOSED
PAVILION CONSTRUCTION PROCESS
A tactile experience with the brick
Construction of round wood frame
41
THE PAVILION CREATING CONNECTIONS
As the site on which the pavilion is situated is currently private and inaccessible to the public. The pavilion creates a new walking path parallel to the path on the opposite side of the river creating a gradual approach. The pavilion transcends beyond the boundaries of site over the river letting visitors immerse themselves in the tranquil and calming atmosphere this part of the Ouseburn radiates, with panoramic views up and down the river.
A GRADUAL APPROACH
PROPOSED PAVILION - 1:1000 PLAN
EXISTING WALKING PATH
FRAMING VIEWS
NEW WALKING PATH
SITE SECTION
PREVIOUS ITERATIONS OF PAVILION; TRANSCENDING SITE BOUNDARIES
42
M
5
10
20
M 50
5
10
20
50 M
43
M
5
1:100 SECTION
44
10
20 M
5
10
20
1:100 M PLAN 1 2
5
10
M
1
2
5
10
46
THEMATIC CASE STUDY BAUHAUS (AUTHORS EXTRACT - SEE FULL CASE STUDY IN APPENDIX) The next pages are designated to exploring the theoretical journey of the Bauhaus, which was produced as part of the thematic case study project. The Bauhaus was a German arts and crafts school which operated from 1919 to 1933. Its overall aim was to unify the individualistic vision of the artist with the principles of mass production. The Bauhaus design vocabulary later became one of the most influential currents in modern design, modernist architecture and art and design education. I myself have been influenced by the Bauhaus principles, I find the teaching curriculum intriguing, how students had a hands-on approach to learning under supervision with the masters of the crafts in Germany at the time. It shares similar ideas with my line of enquiry, the hands-on learning approach and the sharing of skills and knowledge with various levels of expertise. I enjoy Gropius’ ideology and his human qualities and was very aware of his responsibility as an architect in society.
47
49
50
51
TESTING
During the testing phase of the project, I developed on the ideas and issues I was addressing during the framing stage and explored these further and more critically. Trying to come to conclusions and aiming to refine a narrative for the project that would unify and address all these different ambitions I had accordingly. The issues previously discussed on construction waste and reintroducing craft in a modern context became the key drivers for the project. The testing phase integrated itself closely with the ARC3013 technology module. The progression of the structural strategy dictated much of how the design and form for the building progressed. From analysing the site constraints further, it allowed me to refine the complexity and scale of the proposed programme so that it could be accommodated within the boundaries of the site. The testing stage then progressed with various explorations on how the building envelope and the way in which the building is constructed could translate the sustainable ambitions of the programme.
this then formed the basis for StoneCycling . . .
. . . a company that creates bricks from ceramic, glass and other demolition waste materials
the company approaches its work as a craft . . . in 2017 the UK consumed 2.4 billion bricks . . .
the brick generates less than a tenth of the carbon emissions of a regular brick . . .
. . . throughout the production process they implement old-fashioned craftmanship of handmade brick making
this is because the brick itself is unfired and no cement is used in its process. this is a game changer for the construction sector
the construction sector is one of the biggest contributors to the UK’s carbon emissions . . .
they aim to create the next generation of high-end, sustainable materials . . . all while decreasing the worlds waste streams
. . . kenoteq claim that with a wider distribution of their techology that the UK brick demand could be met if recycled waste materials were made better use of
the scottish company is also minimising the amount of transport required in its process by producing its bricks on-site at a waste and recycling centre in edinburgh debris from construction, demolition and industrial processes is one of the biggest waste streams in the world which is having a massive impact on our environment
Tom Van Soest developed a blender to crush waste materials such as sinks, tiles and glass sourced from demolition sites ALL IMAGERY SOURCED FROM (StoneCycling® | Sustainable and Circular Building Materials)
54
we strive to combine the growing availability of waste with the declining availability of raw materials as our motivation to develop new building materials.
they believe that the craftsmanship provides their products with a unique character whilst respecting the evolution of brick making in the technological age their brick production is estimated to use 25% less energy than traditional kiln processes . . .
. . . and since 2011 they have upcycled 550kg of waste in their sustainable building materials
. . . in response to this, along with the shear amount of waste the sector also produces, kenoteq have produced a brick that is made from waste materials from demolition sites.
the eco-friendly k-briq is made from 90% reused materials of which include brick, stone and plasterboard
(Aouf, 2020)
I was concerned that modern construction techniques exploit raw materials without considering that they are amongst the largest contributors to carbon emissions
It is anticipated that construction and demolition volumes will double in the next 30 years, during which time the industry will be required to recycle more and more
(Cousins, 2021) (KENOTEQ - Makers of the K-Briq)
55
(Manufacturing Process & Ethical Trading - Imperial Brick Tiles)
THE OUSEBURN BRICK MAKING INSTITUTE DECLARING PROJECT AIMS AND FUNCTION
CRAFTSMANSHIP
RESEARCH
The project aims to be an addition to the craft culture within the Ouseburn Valley by reintroducing the ancient art of hand-made brick making in a modern context. I was intrigued by the methodology that StoneCycling employs in the curation of their bricks. Engaging with traditional hand-made brick techniques to provide each brick its own character and uniqueness. The project aims to adopt the same brick making methodology and by employing these 15th century techniques we respect the craftsmanship and skill which goes into its process providing both staff and visitors with an intimate tactile experience with the material.
The institute will form a link with academic research by accommodation facilities that allow for research into new sustainable construction materials made from demolition aggregate with the aim of supporting a more circular construction sector. Research into sustainable brick making techniques became my way of forming a connection with the Ouseburn. Due to its postindustrial architectural landscape and the increase in developments the brick is the most common material found and in demand within the valley. Bricks made at the institute can eventually be used as the building blocks for future developments both within the valley and wider area.
SUSTAINABILITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL INTENTIONS The project engages with the issues involved with sending construction waste to landfill as discussed and aims to form solutions to this waste dilemma. Aggregates produced from crushed demolition waste from demolition sites within the North East will act as the catalyst in the production of a clay-like material that is then used in the curation of hand-made bricks. Reducing the amount of construction waste that ends up in landfill it employs principles of a circular economy by viewing waste as a resource and not something to be discarded. Responding to the studios themes of sustainability and architectural craft, we create a unison between the two inherently different manufacturing realms of industry and craft, reintroducing the ancient art of hands-on brick making in a modern context. Despite the challenging nature of the site, its narrow character favours the linear process of hand-made brick making. Issues arise in the sites sloping character and proximity to the river. As water levels are on the rise the design will have to take into consideration the concerns over future flooding. 56
REINTRODUCING CRAFT IN MODERN CONTEXT SUSTAINABLE CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUES MITIGATING LOCAL WASTE STREAMS (Traditional brick making methods - Imperial Handmade Bricks)
RESEARCHING NEXT GENERATION OF SUSTAINABLE CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS IMPROVING LOCAL ECONOMY ADOPTING CIRCULAR ECONOMIC METHODOLOGY ENGAGING MEMBERS FROM LOCAL COMMUNITY
“We don't value craftsmanship anymore! All we value is ruthless efficiency, and I say we deny our own humanity that way! Without appreciation for grace and beauty, there's no pleasure in creating things and no pleasure in having them! Our lives are made drearier, rather than richer! How can a person take pride in his work when skill and care are considered luxuries! We're not machines! We have a human need for craftsmanship!” 57
AND THE PROCESS REPEATS
THE FINAL PRODUCT IS A ECOLOGICALLY SENSITIVE BUILDING MATERIAL WHICH LOOKS AND ACTS YOUR TYPICAL BRICK
ONCE A BUILDING HAS COME TO THE END OF ITS LIFE IT IS DEMOLISHED.
AND LEFT TO AIR DRY FOR THREE TO FOUR DAYS TO ADEQUATELY SET THE WASTE IS COLLECTED BY LORRY AND SENT TO AN APPROPRIATE FACILITY TO BE CRUSHED
THE BRICK IS THEN DEMOULDED
OUSEBURN BRICK MAKING INSTITUTE THE PROCESS ONCE THE WASTE IS DELIVERED, EACH MATERIAL IS CRUSHED DOWN SEPARATELY INTO FINE AGGREGATE
THE MATERIAL IS THEN MOULDED USING A WOODEN BRICK MOULD WHICH SETS IT IN SHAPE
The diagram shows the circular methodology The Ouseburn Brickmaking Institute employs and the process that the material undergos; from demolition to crushing and finally being used to produce the hand-made bricks. However, there is no firing involved in the process and the conventional key step of heating the clay to 1350 degrees is cut out of our process, and its all due to the binder used.
THE AGGREGATES ARE THEN TRANSPORTED TO OUR INSTITUTE AND STORED SEPARATELY IN SMALL SILOS BEFORE BEING UTILIZED IN THE PRODUCTION OF OUR BRICKS
ONCE THE INGREDIENTS HAVE BEEN MIXED THE MATERIAL IS WORKED BY HAND TO GAUGE THE CORRECT CONSISTENCY THE AGGREGATES ARE THEN MIXED TOGETHER ALONG WITH WATER AND OUR BINDER TO PRODUCE A CLAY LIKE MATERIAL
58
59
WASTE PLASTERBOARD
A SUSTAINABLE METHODOLOGY
THE DEHYDRATED GYPSUM REABSORBS THE WATER AND RECRYSTALLISES FORMING A STRONG BINDER AROUND THE AGGREGATE
REDUCING CARBON EMISSIONS
THIS PROCESS CAN NOT BE REVERSED BY ADDING WATER WHICH MAKES IT EFFECTIVE
THE SUBSTANCE IS THEN MOULDED INTO BRICKS AND LEFT TO AIR DRY TO REMOVE THE REMAINING WATER
ONCE THE WASTE PLASTERBOARD IS CRUSHED AND SIEVED YOU MOSTLY HAVE GYPSUM
BRICK INGREDIENTS
PROCESS OF MAKING THE BRICK BINDER
The reasoning for altering this specific stage of the conventional brick making process is that annually the firing of bricks produces 6 million tonnes of CO2 and whilst the industry aims to reduce this figure by reducing fossil fuel consumption and using renewable energy sources, it is still inevitable that the firing process will produce a significant amount of C02.
CRUSHED GYPSUM
THE PLASTER IS THEN MIXED WITH VARIOUS AGGREGATES AND WATER IS ADDED
GYPSUM HAS A CRYSTAL STRUCTURE WITH TWO WATER MOLECULES BOUND TO EACH ONE OF CALCIUM SULPHATE
150 oC THE GYPSUM IS DEHYDRATED BY HEATING IT A LITTLE
THIS REDUCES THE WATER CONTENT BY 75%
CHANGING THE CRYSTAL STRUCTURE AND SUBSEQUENTLY CHANGING THE GYPSUM TO PLASTER AUTHOR ILLUSTRATION: 6 MILLION TONNES OF CO2 PRODUCED FROM BRICK FIRING EACH YEAR
60
61
USER REQUIREMENTS BASED ON INHABITATION AND SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS OF CHOSEN SPECIALISM
RECYCLING WITHIN THE LOCAL CONTEXT
URBAN CORE
LANDFILL SITE
NEIGHBOURHOOD AREA
POTENTIAL LANDFILL SITE
RURAL AND VILLAGE AREA
METAL RECYCLING FACILITY
TYNE RIVER
WASTE RECEPTION / RECYCLING CENTRE
A ROAD
TRANSFER STATION
COMPOSTING FACILITY
(Newcastle and Gateshead Council, 2015)
62
63
THE SITE
EXISTING STRUCTURES
INITIAL SITE RESPONSES
EXISTING SLIPWAY
The chosen site for The Ouseburn Brickmaking Institute will be located within the same site boundaries as the pavilion exploration within the Framing stage.
EXCAVATION AND RETAINING WALL
RELATIONSHIP WITH RIVER AND STREET
The site sits at the heart of the Ouseburn Valley and has accessible road links to Newcastle City Centre and Byker with links towards the Tyne via its direct proximity with the Ouseburn river.
PROPOSAL FOR CULTURAL CENTRE IN SITES PROXIMITY
PROXIMITY TO RIVER
DELIVERIES MAIN ENTRANCE
NARROW SITE
22 o
SLOPING TOPOGRAPHY 2.5m
SITE CHALLENGES AND CONSTRAINTS
ROUTES 30m
PROPOSAL FOR CREATIVE HUB WITHIN THE SITES PROXIMITY
22 o
2.5m
WEAK SOIL
WEAK SOIL
WEAK SOIL SOIL WEAK
SITE
WEAK SOIL
0
5
10
20
50
M
30m
METAL RECYCLING YARD IN SITES PROXIMITY
64
65
My initial building programme was aiming to facilitate the crushing process of the demolition waste. However the machinery and space involved in this process are far too large to be accommodated on my chosen site. This ultimately led to the decision to outsource the aggregate from a crushing facility in the local area.
(George, 2016)
SITE
AREA REQUIRED TO FACILITATE CRUSHING PROCESS
(George, 2016)
C&DW RECYCLING PLANT; MACHINERY AND SPACE TO ACCOMMODATION CRUSHING PROCESS TOO LARGE FOR SITE BOUNDARIES
OUSEBURN BRICKMAKING HUB SITE AREA (m2)
AVERAGE AREA SIZE TO INSTALL C&DW RECYCLING CENTRE (m2)
2400m2
40000m2
INITIAL MASSING STUDIES
66
67
(Studio Zhu-Pei, schranimage and Tian Fangfang, 2020)
Initially I engaged with narrowness of the site by dividing the building programme and spacing it generously throughout the length of the site. This created a series of ‘inbetween’ spaces with the aim of forming a dynamic relationship between interior and exterior.
However, I felt that there was a disconnection between the spaces and a lack of an overriding sense of unity. I began experimenting with placing a ‘super structure’ form on-site through a series arched forms. I was initially inspired by the imperial kiln museum in China and its sweeping brick arched structures. My intention was to replicate and test this form within my site boundaries.
(Studio Zhu-Pei, schranimage and Tian Fangfang, 2020)
(Studio Zhu-Pei, schranimage and Tian Fangfang, 2020)
68
69
1 2 3 4
5
6 7
28
29
9
8
10
11
12
27 26
30
DEVELOPMENT OF MAIN WORKSHOP AREA
ARCH FACADE AND INTERIOR STRUCTURE 1
REPURPOSED BRICK EXTERNAL CLADDING
2
CONCRETE SHELL STRUCTURE 300mm
3
BRICK SUPPORT BRACKET / SERVICES CAVITY 40mm
4
REPURPOSED BRICK INTERNAL CLADDING
5
CONCRETE LINTEL
6
GLASS DOOR
7
DOOR FRAME
8
VAPOUR CONTROL LAYER
13 14 15 16 34 33
INTERMEDIATE FLOORING 9
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOR HEATING
10
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
11
STEEL BEAMS W/ SPACE FOR SERVICES
12
CONCRETE CEILING FINISH
INTERNAL WALL 13
17
18
19
20
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
14
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
15
CONCRETE WALL
16
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
FLOORING 17
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOD HEATING
18
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
19
JOISTS AND CAVITY FOR SERVICES
20
IN-SITU CONCRETE FLOOR
23
24 25 31
22
32
FOUNDATIONS 21
CONCRETE PILE FOUNDATION
22
CONCRETE PILE CAP
23
PERFORATED DRAIN 60mm
24
HARDCORE GRAVEL LAYER 90mm
25
BLINDING 80mm
21
RETAINING WALL 26
PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL
27
BACKFILL 100mm
28
PRECAST CONCRETE PAVEMENT
29
PERFORATED DRAIN
WATERPROOFING AND RIVER WORKSHOP 30 31
DEVELOPMENT OF EXTERNAL WORKSHOP AREA
WATERPROOFING LAYER WATERPROOFING LAYER
32
PILE WALL
33
TRIPLE GLAZED WINDOW
34
WOODEN WINDOW FRAME
INITIAL 1:20 STRUCTURAL SECTION
DEVELOPMENT OF GROUND FLOOR PLAN AND SHORT SECTION
CONCRETE SHELL STRUCTURE 1 2 3 4
BRICK CLADDING 5
6 7
28
29
9
8
10
11
12
27 26
30
DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC GARDEN AREA
EXPERIMENTING WITH OPENINGS IN FORM
ARCH FACADE AND INTERIOR STRUCTURE 1
REPURPOSED BRICK EXTERNAL CLADDING
2
CONCRETE SHELL STRUCTURE 300mm
3
BRICK SUPPORT BRACKET / SERVICES CAVITY 40mm
4
REPURPOSED BRICK INTERNAL CLADDING
5
CONCRETE LINTEL
6
GLASS DOOR
7
DOOR FRAME
8
VAPOUR CONTROL LAYER
13 14 15 16
Initially I was proposing for these arched structures to be constructed using concrete shells then the brick clad to them in order to give the impression that the brick was load bearing, however I realised I was contradicting myself. The projects programme was concerned with trying to form solutions to environmental issues arising from how we handle waste and trying to mitigate much of the carbon emissions found in the conventional brick making process, however, I was then proposing to use a massive amount of concrete for the actual building structure, relying on natural resources and emitting large amounts of c02. From this realisation I then intended to experiment with alternative strategies that would reduce the amount of concrete whilst still being able to realise these ambitious arched forms.
34 33
INTERMEDIATE FLOORING 9
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOR HEATING
10
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
11
STEEL BEAMS W/ SPACE FOR SERVICES
12
CONCRETE CEILING FINISH
INTERNAL WALL
70
13
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
14
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
15
CONCRETE WALL
16
REPURPOSED BRICK CLADDING
17
18
(ARC 3013 EXTRACT) 19
20
71
FLOORING 17
CONCRETE FINISH SCREED WITH UNDERFLOOD HEATING
18
RIGID INSULATION 100mm
19
JOISTS AND CAVITY FOR SERVICES
20
IN-SITU CONCRETE FLOOR
23 22
24 25 31
THINKING THROUGH MAKING
LAYER 1
LAYER 2
CONSTRUCTION EXPLORATION TIMBREL VAULTING
I began exploring techniques that would allow the bricks to span independently without any additional supports which led to me experimenting with timbrel vaulting. Which is the same technique explored in the framing pavilion, I now intended to adapt it on a larger scale. The idea behind designing with timbrel vaults was to translate the sustainable philosophies of the buildings programme into the building’s fabric, there is no steel or concrete supports within the vaults. It aims to be a constant reminder to the building inhabitants of the bricks structural abilities, celebrating its aesthetic qualities and an appreciation for the superior craftsmanship. For my thinking through making piece, I recreated the construction process of timbrel vaulting through a 1:5 model. Showing how the layers of brick overlap to provide the form with amazing compressive strength which is compared to the likes of reinforced concrete.
CONCRETE PAD Cast in-situ FORMWORK Cardboard used for model but steel wire formwork will be used for the project
First layer being supported on framework, attached to concrete pads with tension ties which provide the structure with tensile strength.
DEMOLITION BRICKS Waste demolition bricks from local demolition sites transported to site LAYER 3
LAYER 4
BRICK SLIPS Demolition bricks cut into slips on site, offcuts turned to aggregate and used in making of repurposed bricks
Removing formwork once timbrel vault has been constructed
72
74
(Fairs, 2009)
PETER RICH ARCHITECTS MAPUNGUBWE INTERPRETATION CENTRE; UTILIZING TIMBREL VAULT CONSTRUCTION
75
THINKING THROUGH MAKING FINAL TIMBREL VAULT MODEL
76
DEVELOPMENT OF MASSING - ADAPTING TIMBREL VAULT TO SITE
GABION WALL
FLOOD WALL
TEMPORARY SANDBAGS
DEVELOPMENT OF MAIN WORKSHOP AREA
EXPERIMENTING WITH FLOOD DEFENCES
75 YEA
100 YEA
200 YEA
1000 YE SITE
75 YEARS 100 YEARS 200 YEARS 1000 YEARS
DEVELOPMENT OF EXTERNAL WORKSHOP AREA
SITE
DEVELOPMENT OF GROUND FLOOR PLAN
EXPERIMENTING WITH FLOOD DEFENCES
ENGAGING WITH FLOODING CONCERNS
DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC GARDEN AREA
I then experimented with trying to adapt the timbrel vault technique on a larger scale and to the challenging nature of the site.
Being in close proximity to the rivers bank there is concerns over future fluvial flooding within the area. I experimented with placing a gabion wall to prevent the erosion of the bank and a flood wall which protects up to flooding levels of 3.65m.
FLUVIAL FLOODING RISK AT SITE (Newcastle City Council, 2011) 75 YEARS 100 YEARS 200 YEARS 1000 YEARS SITE
(ARC3013 EXTRACT) 77
78
SYNTHESIS
The project was very much driven by the structural exploration done during the testing phase of the design. The timbrel vaulting model done as part of thinking through making was fundamental in contributing to the form of the final design. Through the synthesis stage I adapt this strategy on a larger scale and to the challenging nature of the site. The series of impressive sweeping vaults become a manifestation of the craft and sustainability themes the building programme was aiming to address. I feel that the materiality of the structure integrates itself respectfully into the postindustrial landscape of the Ouseburn. I have analysed how the building is interacting within a local and wider context, how it aims to mitigate local waste streams and how it employs circular mythologies. With a focus on how the brick making specialism has been inhabited within the building and the experience of the user around these processes. Overall, I feel the project is an appropriate and respectful addition to the craft culture within the
Ouseburn. It deals appropriately with the main studio theme of creating a synergy between the academy and community by facilitating research into future sustainable construction materials and engaging the public directly by providing opportunities to witness and interact with the brick making processes first-hand. The project began with an ambition to address the issues over our professions handling of waste and I realise now more than ever that we must challenge societies perception over waste as something which must be discarded but instead see it as a resource.
MATERIAL SOURCING
CIRCULAR ECONOMY
TIMBREL VAULTING
AGGREGATE STORAGE
The sustainable timbrel vaulting technique has been adapted on a larger scale to the site, translating the ideas of craft and sustainability throughout the buildings envelope
Aggregates are stored separately in small silos before being utilized in the curation of the bricks
BUILDING SITUATED WITHIN LOCAL CONTEXT Depending on the character and size of the demolition site, the waste is either crushed on site if there is enough space to host the machinery and then sent directly to our institute or sent to a crushing facility 10 miles north from the site if there is little space to host the machinery. While the maps depicts how the building would interact within a local context it is also capable of sourcing waste from a wider context.
The axonometric shows how the building is situated within its local context. Expanding itself down towards the river and revealing itself above street level to provide access to the public. The building aims to challenge the conventional linear economic system by utilizing waste as a resource and adhering the principles of a circular economy.
REPURPOSED BRICKS The brick vaults are constructed using repurposed brick from local and national demolition sites. Adhering to the principles of a circular economy
If the demolition site has adequate space to facilitate the crushing machinery, particularly those sites outside of the urban core, then the machinery will be transported to the site from the crushing facility. The material is then crushed on site and the aggregate is sent directly to our institute
If the site does not have adequate space to facilitate the crushing machinery, particularly those sites within the urban core, then the construction waste will be transported to the crushing facility to be crushed and filtered. Once crushed the aggregate is then transported to our institute 81
SITE - OUSEBURN CRUSHING FACILITY DEMOLITION SITE - OUTSIDE URBAN CORE DEMOLITION SITE - WITHIN URBAN CORE URBAN CORE
AGGREGATE RESEARCH LABORATORY To research, test and develop new sustainable brick recipes using aggregate from construction waste
BRICK MAKING WORKSHOP
DELIVERY AREA
Employing traditional hand-made brick making techniques to produce new sustainable bricks using aggregate from construction waste
Aggregate is delivered either straight from the demolition site or from the crushing facility
83
CIRCULATION CORE MAIN ENTRANCE
SECOND FLOOR PROGRAMME PUBLIC PUBLIC LOBBY
STAFF RECEPTION AREA RECEPTION BACKROOM TOILET STAFF BREAKOUT AREA
SECOND FLOOR PLAN 0 84
2
4
6
8
10
20 M 85
CIRCULATION CORE STAFF ENTRANCE
FIRST FLOOR PROGRAMME PUBLIC
STAFF
INTERNAL WORKSHOP
STAFF ROOM
BRICK DRYING
MEETING AREA
CAFE
JANITOR CLOSET
CAFE GARDEN CONNECTOR HALLWAY TOILETS
FIRST FLOOR PLAN 0 86
2
4
6
8
10
20 M 87
CIRCULATION CORE PLANT ROOM BREAKOUT
GROUND FLOOR PROGRAMME BRICK-MAKING (STAFF)
GROUND FLOOR PLAN 0 88
2
4
6
8
10
20 M
PUBLIC
RESEARCH
STAFF
MAIN WORKSHOP
LOBBY EXTENSION
AGGREGATE LABORATORY
AGGREGATE STORAGE
GYPSUM HEATING
CHANGING
COMPUTER LABORATORY
DELIVERY AREA
BRICK DRYING
TOILETS
CONSULTATION AREA
FORKLIFT STORAGE
MOULD MAKING
RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP
CHANGING
GARDEN / FLOWER PICKING
TOILETS
SEATING / BREAKOUT AREA
COMMUNICATIONS ROOM DISABLED TOILET
89
PERSPECTIVE LONG SECTION
E
RE
ST
4a
L
VE
E TL
PUBLIC ROUTE
1 11a
1 2 3a 3b 3c 3d 4a 4b 4c 5
2 2a 2
2ND FLOOR 2b 4
ENTRANCE RECEPTION GARDEN INTERNAL WORKSHOP CAFE TOILETS WORKSHOP LOBBY TOILETS AND CHANGING RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP PLANTING AREA
STAFF ROUTE
1b 1
3a 5
3b 6a3
3c
1ST FLOOR
3
2 6b4b 4b 4a
5
4c 6c
3
STREET ENTRANCE SLIPWAY ENTRANCE RECEPTION STAFF ENTRANCE STAFF CHANGING / TOILETS STAFF BREAKOUT ROOM STAFF BREAKOUT MEZZANINE COMMUNICATIONS / STORAGE MATERIAL DELIVERIES BRICK MAKING RESEARCH
MATERIAL ROUTE
4a
3d
3
SLIPWAY ENTRANCE
1a 1b 2a 2b 3 4 4a 5 6a 6b 6c
1 2 3 4a 4b 5
SLIPWAY ENTRANCE DELIVERY AREA SILO STORAGE GYPSUM HEATING BRICK MAKING LABORATORY
VISITORS / PROFESSIONALS ROUTE 1 2 3
ENTRANCE RECEPTION CONSULTATION AREA
PRIVATE
GROUND FLOOR
5
PUBLIC SHARED
USER ROUTES THROUGHOUT BUILDING
93
94
STRUCTURAL STRATEGY AND CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCING
1. DEMOLITION Existing buildings on the site will have to be demolished. Part of Lime st. will have to be closed while demolition takes place, however, road detours will be carried out to divert traffic.
2. PILE RETAINING WALL A pile retaining wall will then be put up to retain the earth before excavation takes place.
3. EXCAVATION The sites sloping bank will then be excavated to allow for a flat building surface, excavation machines will access the site from the slipway.
4. PILE FOUNDATIONS Due to the clayey soil prone to water logging, a series of pile foundation will be inserted up to 30m below the ground to transmit loads to a lower level of subsoil to stabilise the structure.
7. Timbrel Vault - Timbrel vault is constructed by alternating 5 layers of soil cement tiles, with a 20mm waterproof mortar bed between each layer.
8. Triple Glazing - After the implementation of insulation materials. Triple glazing windows are installed to make the building watertight.
9. Brick Cladding - The concrete shell is then clad with reused bricks both internally and externally. Internal walls are also clad with reused brick.
10. Brick Cladding - Final stage of the project is to landscape the projects surrounding area and public gardens within the building.
5. IN-SITU CONCRETE CASTING The primary structure consisting of a reinforced concrete floor, support pads, concrete shell structure and three circulation cores are then cast in-situ.
6. Steel-wire Framework - A steel-wire framework is used as the framework for which the timbrel vault will be constructed upon. This is a temporary structure and removed once the vault has been constructed.
(ARC3013 EXTRACT) 95
96
1:20 TECHNICAL SECTION AND ANALYSIS OF TIMBREL VAULT
STEEL CABLE FORMWORK
TIMBREL VAULT DETAIL FOCUS - SHOWING ACCUMULATION OF OVERLAPPING LAYERS CONNECTED TO CONCRETE PAD
ACCUMULATION OF OVERLAPPING BRICK LAYERS MAKE UP THE TIMBREL VAULT
ADDRESSING FUTURE FLOODING CONCERNS BY IMPLEMENTING A FLOOR WALL WHICH SPANS THE LENGTH OF THE SITE
TECHNICAL 1:20 SHORT SECTION
(ARC3013 EXTRACT) 97
99
MAIN BRICK MAKING WORKSHOP
The visualisation shows how the timbrel vaulting explorations done during the framing and testing phases where fundamental in contributing to the final building form. These grand sweeping gestures are to be of a constant reminder to the inhabitants of the bricks structural capability and to form an appreciation of the craftsmanship and skill translated throughout the building envelope.
AGGREGATES FROM STORAGE AREA
The main workshop acts as the main brick making area for staff. The space engages with the public mezzanine on street level by creating visual connections allowing for the pubic to spectate and form a closer relationship to the processes happening in the workshop.
CRUSHED PLASTERBOARD AGGREGATES
HEATED 150OC
TURNS TO GYPSUM PLASTER
MIXING AGGREGATES PLASTER USED AS BRICK BINDER
BRICK MAKING STATIONS BRICK MAKING STATIONS
BRICK DRYING
MOULDS USED FOR BRICK MAKING
MIXING AGGREGATES
MOULD MAKING STATION CUT TO SIZE
RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP
FROM GARDEN AREA BRICKS DRY IN PUBLIC DRYING AREA
MATERIALS
CHANGING / TOILETS
VIEW FINDER STAFF PUBLIC
GROUND FLOOR
100
102
APPROACH TO BUILDING SOUTH TO NORTH
Due to the building being situated on a curving site, as one progresses up the river or walkway the building gradually reveals itself to them. This external view shows the variety of scale of the vaults. The public aspects of the design being hosted under small more intimate vaults whilst the main space extrudes above these in a more dramatic fashion.
RIVERSIDE WALKWAY
TOWARDS RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP
COMPUTER LAB AND OFFICE SPACE
RIVERSIDE BREAKOUT AREA
FROM LOBBY AGGREGATE FROM STORAGE AREA
DEVELOPING NEW BRICK RECIPES
RIVERSIDE SEATING
MIXER
GARDEN AREA / FLOWER PICKING
MEETING AREA TO CONSULT WITH STAFF
VIEW FINDER STAFF FROM CAFE
PUBLIC VISITOR / PROFESSIONAL
GROUND FLOOR
103
105
LIME STREET ELEVATION
INTERNAL PUBLIC WORKSHOP
A visualisation from within the internal public workshop shows the visual connections this space is making with the café area. The spaces are housed beneath these smaller scale vaults creating a more intimate environment than the larger scale vaults of the main workshop. BRICK DRYING
FROM PUBLIC LOBBY
BRICK MAKING STATIONS
TOWARDS INTERNAL WORKSHOP
TOWARDS CAFE
VIEW FINDER
INTERNAL SEATING
TOWARDS GARDEN AREA
STAFF PUBLIC
EXTERNAL SEATING
FIRST FLOOR
TOWARDS RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP
RIVERSIDE BREAKOUT AREA
RIVERSIDE SEATING
GARDEN AREA / FLOWER PICKING
STAFF RESEARCH AREA
FROM CAFE
GROUND FLOOR
109
111
PERSPECTIVE SHORT SECTION
FROM STAFF ROOM
APPROACHING FROM NORTH TO SOUTH ADDITIONAL SEATING FOR STAFF
SECOND FLOOR
STAFF ENTRANCE FROM SLIPWAY
The perspective views the storage facility from the river. As this part of the building is only accessible to staff the intention was to provide the space with a more solid form compared to that of the curvaceous sculptural vaults to give the impression of being a private area.
STAFF MEETING AREA
TO BREAKOUT AREA STAFF SEATING AREA FROM STORAGE AREA
KITCHEN UNIT
FIRST FLOOR
FROM STREET LEVEL
PROVIDE DELIVERY LORRIES ACCESS
DELIVERY LORRY ACCESS ROUTE STAFF TOILETS
FROM STAFF ENTRANCE
LOCKERS
RIVERSIDE WALKWAY
CHANGING AREA
SPARE BULK BAGS STORED ON INDUSTRIAL SHELVING
BULK BAGS UNLOADED FROM LORRY WITH FORKLIFT
VIEW FINDER
AGGREGATES STORED SEPARATELY IN SMALL SILOS
STAFF PUBLIC
TRANSPORTING AGGREGATES TO MAIN WORKSHOP AREA
FROM LOBBY AREA
GROUND FLOOR
115
117
TOWARDS MAIN WORKSHOP
PUBLIC RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP LEAVE BELONGINGS IN LOCKERS
The visualisation shows how the public workshop extrudes itself from the boundaries of the site out towards the river. Allowing the public to feel more connected to the river and landscape and to appreciate the tranquillity of the surrounding area whilst participating in the workshops.
PASSING RECEPTION
CHECK IN FOR WORKSHOP AT RECEPTION
FROM LIME STREET - MAIN BUILDING ENTRANCE
VIEW FINDER STAFF WAIT FOR OTHER PARTICIPANTS TO ARRIVE
PUBLIC
TOWARDS CAFE / WORKSHOPS
SECOND FLOOR
BRICK MAKING STATIONS
MIXING AGGREGATES
RIVERSIDE WORKSHOP
FROM GARDEN AREA BRICKS DRY IN PUBLIC DRYING AREA
CHANGING AREA
FROM PUBLIC LOBBY
GROUND FLOOR
118
120
CULTURAL BIBLIOGRAPHY
LABOURING WORK EXPERIENCE During the Easter break I was fortunate enough to gain some valuable experience working as a labourer for a local contracting company. I assisted plasterers, electricians, bricklayers and from this experience I gained additional knowledge on how different services work and function throughout a building. It also made me realise the skill, labour, time and energy that goes into creating our built environment and I became much more appreciative of all the other trades, disciples and people that often go under appreciated when a building is realised.
(Assemble)
GRANBY FOUR STREETS BY ASSEMBLE
AXONOMETRIC VIEW OF TERRACED HOUSES
THEMATIC CASE STUDY REFLECTIONS
The philosophy of the collective Assemble, shared much of the same ideas in which I was trying to translate to my own narrative during the framing stage of design process. The ideas of a multi-disciplinary approach to design, with an intention to serve the community by addressing the disconnection between the public and the process in which places are made, to essentially ‘challenge the status quo of the architecture profession’. One of their most notable projects Granby Four Street, a community project based in Toxteth, Liverpool, was the result of a 20-year led battle by local residents to see a series of terrace housing be saved from demolition. Their tireless dedication to the community resulted in a vision for the houses to be refurbished into affordable social house with a variety of public spaces.
(AGROCITÉ – GENNEVILLIERS | R-URBAN)
(EXTRACT FROM THEMATIC CASE STUDY)
AGROCITÉ BY THE ATELIER D’ARCHITECTURE AUTOGÉRÉE (AAA)
SPACIAL PRACTICE
(Nantes School of Architecture / Lacaton & Vassal, 2012)
(EXTRACT FROM THEMATIC CASE STUDY)
NANTES SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE BY LACATON & VASSAL ARCHITECTS
WORKSHOP DIAGRAM
The project, Agrocité, by the collective practice, The Atelier D’Architecture Autogérée (aaa). Their aim was to provide a community driven housing estate within the socially excluded and overlooked Colombes, Paris. The project combats unemployment in the area and I was intrigued by their ambition to stress the need for resident participation at every stage of the design process. Nantes School of Architecture by architects Lacaton & Vassal. Their intention was to break apart the typical conventions of architectural education as an internal and insular activity, but instead allowing for the processes within the school to be integrated and to run beside one another. The transparency of the spaces create connections between the city and academy by engaging the public and allowing for them to see the activities happening within the workshops. My project was very much influenced by this methodology as the transparency and openness of the spaces encourages the public to witness and experience the processes of handmade brick making for themselves. The Marshall Building by Grafton Architects. I enjoyed their approach to forming a connection to the city by focussing on the public realm and the experience for the passer-by. By integrating a public space on the ground floor it breaks conventional boundaries between the building and the public realm by allowing free flowing and unrestricted access through the building encouraging passers-bys to experience the events within the Grand Hall. The intention is to create a “sense of being” to the city for both students and the passer-by. Think Corner, commissioned by the University of Helsinki. I was intrigued by the connection it created between the academy and community. Its intention is to bring research, researchers and design led projects within the University towards the street level and make them accessible for the public. My project was greatly influenced by this methodology by engaging the public directly in the research happening at the brick making institute.
121
(Assemble Win Turner Prize 2015, 2015)
(EXTRACT FROM THEMATIC CASE STUDY)
(London School of Economics - Grafton Architects)
THE MARSHALL BUILDING BY GRAFTON ARCHITECTS PUBLIC ACCESS THROUGH PERSPECTIVE SECTION, SHOWING FUNCTION OF SPACES. (ArchDaily, 2020)
THINK CORNER HELSINKI UNIVERSITY BY JKMM ARCHITECTS
122
GMIT Furniture College, Letterfrack, by O’Donnell + Tuomey architects. I was intrigued by how the materials of the building relate to the textures and colours of the rural Irish landscape. The way in which the materials engage with the landscape and speak of the sites context was something that I was aiming to replicate within the post-industrial context of Ouseburn with the utilization of the brick. Gerrit Rietveld Academy and Sandberg Institute by Paulien Bremmer + Hootsmans Architects. Due to the teams’ multi-disciplinary backgrounds, they work with no hierarchy and all participants contributions to the design process are valued equally. This participative approach to designing translates in the building as there is an emphasis on the consideration of the user, and in order to encourage social exchange and collaboration the ground floor level is open creating a link with the public realm. I enjoy the practices multi-disciplinary approach to designing which results in more socially orientated and driven design realisation as present in this project.
(O’Donnell + Tuomey – GMIT Furniture College Letterfrack)
GMIT FURNITURE COLLEGE LETTERFRACK BY O’DONNELL + TUOMEY ARCHITECTS (Gerrit Rietveld Academy and Sandberg Institute / Studio Paulien Bremmer + Hootsmans Architects, 2019)
(EXTRACT FROM THEMATIC CASE STUDY)
Carmody Groarke’s restoration cloak during the restoration period of Charles Rennie Mackintosh’s Hill House. I enjoyed its innovative approach to conventional restoration processes where a building is concealed and hidden from view. Rather the architects have undertaken a more radial approach to the conservation by concealing the house in a massive chainmail structure which shelters the house whilst also maintaining access for visitors.
GERRIT RIETVELD ACADEMY AND SANDBERG INSTITUTE BY PAULIEN BREMMER + HOOTSMANS ARCHITECTS (Dehlin, 2019)
THE HILL HOUSE - CARMODY GROARKE
123
EVERY TEAM MEMBERS CONTRIBUTION IS VALUED EQUALLY
BIBLIOGRAPHY
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ALL IMAGES AND WORKS ARE AUTHORS OWN WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MENTIONED IMAGES OR WORK BELONGING TO THE STUDIO GROUP AND;
Brick Development Association, 2019. BRICK Sustainability Report 2019. [online] London. Available at: <https://www.brick.org.uk/admin/resources/2019-bsr-1.pdf> [Accessed 7 June 2021]. Dean, A., 2003. Champion of Hale County, Alabama: Samuel Mockbee and the Rural Studio. Online Journal of Lanscape, Art & Design, [online] Available at: <https://www.landviews.org/la2003/champion-aod.html>.
Newcastle City Council, 2011. Newcastle City Council Level 2 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment. [online] Newcastle, pp.73,74. Available at: <https://www.newcastle. gov.uk/sites/default/files/2019-01/SFRALevel2Final.pdf>.
Dean, A., Hursley, T., Chua, L. and Robinson, C., 2002. Rural Studio. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, pp.16-17.
Ouseburn Trust, 2021. A brief history of the Newcastle-upon-Tyne Motor Club. [online] Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, pp.1-9. Available at: <https://www.ouseburntrust. org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=652f0fe3-c2c5-4ae6-8f84-d569f99822a1>.
Ec.europa.eu. 2018. Waste statistics - Statistics Explained. [online] Available at: <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Waste_ statistics#Waste_generation_excluding_major_mineral_waste> [Accessed 4 June 2021].
Rossi, C., 2017. ‘Craft contains the critical thinking that could unpack the current state of architecture’ - Architectural Review. [online] Architectural Review. Available at: <https://www.architectural-review.com/essays/craft-contains-the-criticalthinking-that-could-unpack-the-current-state-of-architecture?tkn=1>.
Gálvez-Martos, J. and Istrate, I., 2020. Construction and demolition waste management. Advances in Construction and Demolition Waste Recycling, pp.5168.
Samuelmockbee.net. n.d. History and Philosophy – The Official Website of Samuel Mockbee. [online] Available at: <http://samuelmockbee.net/rural-studio/ about-the-rural-studio/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CThe%20main%20purpose%20of%20 the,of%20service%20to%20a%20community.&text=Since%20Mockbee’s%20 death%2C%20Rural%20Studio,the%20scope%20of%20its%20work.>.
Hebel, D., Heisel, F. and Wisniewska, M., 2014. Building from waste: Recovered Materials in Architecture and Construction. Hebel, D., Wisniewska,, M. and Heisel,, F., 2015. Constructing Waste Investigating an alternative resource for future cities. FCL Magazine, [online] (Special Issue. 56-67), pp.55 - 67. Available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/ publication/295912128_Constructing_Waste_-_Investigating_an_alternative_ resource_for_future_cities>. Jones, P., Petrescu, D. and Till, J., 2005. Architecture and Participation. Taylor & Francis.
125
for Gateshead and Newcastle upon Tyne, 2010-2030. Newcastle Upon Tyne: Newcastle and Gateshead Council.
Whiting, J., 2013. Lifestyle Aspects of a Core Creative Class when Home and Away: A Study with Reference to the Ouseburn Valley, Newcastle upon Tyne.. Doctoral thesis. University of Sunderland.
PAGE 2 Fairs, M., 2009. Mapungubwe Interpretation Centre by Peter Rich Architects | Dezeen. [online] Dezeen. Available at: <https://www.dezeen. com/2009/11/07/mapungubwe-interpretation-centre-by-peter-rich-architects/>. Abdallah, C., 2018. These Alabama Architecture Students are Designing and Building Low-Cost Homes for Rural America. [online] ArchDaily. Available at: <https://www.archdaily.com/898105/these-alabama-architecture-students-are-designing-and-building-low-cost-homes-for-ruralamerica?ad_medium=gallery>. PAGE 6 2001. Google Earth Pro. Google. PAGE 11 Ouseburn Trust. 2020. Ouseburn Then and Now. [online] Available at: <https://www.ouseburntrust.org.uk/news/ouseburn-then-and-now>. PAGE 14 BBC News. 2019. Newcastle Quayside 'Whey Aye' Ferris wheel plan approved. [online] Available at: <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-49125163> [Accessed 4 June 2021]. Dickinson, K., 2018. Plans for Ouseburn apart-hotel APPROVED despite fears it would ‘ruin’ the area. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/plans-ouseburn-aparthotel-approved-despite-15425245>. Ford, C., 2016. New student accommodation scheme in Newcastle could generate millions for local economy. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/business/business-news/new-student-accommodation-scheme-newcastle-11568845>. Ford, C., 2019. Plans emerge for £7.5m luxury apartments scheme in Newcastle’s Ouseburn. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https:// www.chroniclelive.co.uk/business/business-news/plans-emerge-75m-luxury-apartments-16669409>. Holland, D., 2021. 18-storey tower block could dramatically change one of Newcastle’s best views. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/plans-18-storey-ouseburn-tower-19852780#comments-section>. Holland, D., 2020. Backlash over massive Quayside apartment block plans. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https://www.chroniclelive. co.uk/news/north-east-news/quayside-apartment-block-neigbour-backlash-18345717>. Holland, D., 2019. Plans unveiled for another new Ouseburn apartment complex. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/ouseburn-riverside-flats-quayside-timber-17095464>. Holland, D., 2019. New vision unveiled for high-end townhouses overlooking the River Tyne. [online] ChronicleLive. Available at: <https:// www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/ouseburn-townhouses-jenkins-homes-plans-16755287>. St Anns Quay Newcastle. 2017. Planning Update 25th Jan 2017. [online] Available at: <http://stannsquaymanagement.co.uk/wp/index. php/2017/01/25/planning-update-25th-jan-2017/>. PAGE 18 Raskl.co.uk. 2017. Ouseburn Culvert Bandstand — Raskl. Art+Architectural Production. [online] Available at: <https://raskl.co.uk/Ouseburn-Culvert-Bandstand>. PAGE 20 Ouseburn Trust, 2021. A brief history of the Newcastle-upon-Tyne Motor Club. [online] Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, pp.1-9. Available at: <https:// www.ouseburntrust.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=652f0fe3-c2c5-4ae6-8f84-d569f99822a1>.
Kara, H., Asensio Villoria, L. and Georgoulias, A., 2017. Architecture and waste. Barcelona: Actar.
PAGE 25
Newcastle and Gateshead Council, 2015. Core Strategy and Urban Core Plan
Huebner, M., 2010. Mockbee, Rural Studio documentary shows Thursday at museum. [online] al.com. Available at: <https://www.al.com/ mhuebner/2010/07/mockbee_rural_studio_documenta.html>. Samuelmockbee.net. n.d. Cook House, Mockbee/Coker – The Official Website of Samuel Mockbee. [online] Available at: <http://samuelmock-
Dancinghousehotel.com. n.d. Dancing House Hotel Prague | Official Website | Welcome. [online] Available at: <https://www.dancinghousehotel.com/en/>.
bee.net/work/architecture/cook-house/>. Kirby, B., 2015. Alabama is poor, but look how poor it used to be: Every county was below average. [online] al.com. Available at: <https:// www.al.com/news/2015/06/alabamas_poor_but_look_how_poo.html>. Rural Studio. n.d. Our Story - Rural Studio. [online] Available at: <http://ruralstudio.org/about/our-story/>. PAGE 26 Facebook. n.d. Ouseburn Farm Charity Ltd. [online] Available at: <https://www.facebook.com/ouseburnfarm/posts/the-ouseburn-is-full-ofsurprises-we-love-taking-the-goats-for-a-walk-and-spotti/4044046915621729/>. PAGE 27 Brady, J., 2011. Ribbands and Frames. [online] Seaportmuseum.blogspot.com. Available at: <http://seaportmuseum.blogspot.com/2011/12/ ribbands-and-frames.html>. Treggiden, K., 2017. British Designer Tom Raffield Is Steam Bending His Way to Success. [online] Design Milk. Available at: <https://design-milk.com/british-designer-tom-raffield-steam-bending-way-success/>. PAGE 28 Abdallah, C., 2018. These Alabama Architecture Students are Designing and Building Low-Cost Homes for Rural America. [online] ArchDaily. Available at: <https://www.archdaily.com/898105/these-alabama-architecture-students-are-designing-and-building-low-cost-homesfor-rural-america?ad_medium=gallery>. PAGE 32 Imaging, W., 2011. Stock Photo - The demolition of Spiller's riverside flour mill on Tyneside, Newcastle, north east England, UK. [online] Alamy. Available at: <https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-the-demolition-of-spillers-riverside-flour-mill-on-tyneside-newcastle-41316557.html?pv=1&stamp=2&imageid=B4039FBE-E674-4145-8A89-44B0EDBF7E5D&p=66472&n=0&orientation=0&pn=1&searchtype=0&IsFromSearch=1&srch=foo%3dbar%26st%3d0%26pn%3d1%26ps%3d100%26sortby%3d2%26resultview%3dsortbyPopular%26npgs%3d0%26qt%3dspillers%2520tyne%2520mill%26qt_raw%3dspillers%2520tyne%2520mill%26lic%3d3%26mr%3d0%26pr%3d0%26ot%3d0%26creative%3d%26ag%3d0%26hc%3d0%26pc%3d%26blackwhite%3d%26cutout%3d%26tbar%3d1%26et%3d0x000000000000000000000%26vp%3d0%26loc%3d0%26imgt%3d0 %26dtfr%3d%26dtto%3d%26size%3d0xFF%26archive%3d1%26groupid%3d%26pseudoid%3d%26a%3d%26cdid%3d%26cdsrt%3d%26name%3d%26qn%3d%26apalib%3d%26apalic%3d%26lightbox%3d%26gname%3d%26gtype%3d%26xstx%3d0%26simid%3d%26saveQry%3d%26editorial%3d1%26nu%3d%26t%3d%26edoptin%3d%26customgeoip%3d%26cap%3d1%26cbstore%3d1%26vd%3d0%26lb%3d%26fi%3d2%26edrf%3d%26ispremium%3d1%26flip%3d0%26pl%3d>. PAGE 54 StoneCycling®. n.d. StoneCycling® | Sustainable and Circular Building Materials. [online] Available at: <https://www.stonecycling.com/> [Accessed 4 June 2021]. PAGE 55 Aouf, R., 2020. Kenoteq launches brick made almost entirely of construction waste. [online] Dezeen. Available at: <https://www.dezeen. com/2020/03/02/kenoteq-k-briq-brick-construction-waste/>. Cousins, S., 2021. Brick that decimates embodied carbon set to start production. [online] Ribaj.com. Available at: <https://www.ribaj.com/ products/k-briq-kenoteq-low-carbon-brick-heriot-watt-university-sustainability>. KENOTEQ.com. n.d. KENOTEQ - Makers of the K-Briq. [online] Available at: <https://kenoteq.com/> [Accessed 4 June 2021]. PAGE 56 Imperial Brick Tiles. n.d. Manufacturing Process & Ethical Trading - Imperial Brick Tiles. [online] Available at: <https://www.imperialbricktiles.co.uk/info/manufacturing-process/> [Accessed 4 June 2021]. Imperial Handmade Bricks. n.d. Traditional brick making methods - Imperial Handmade Bricks. [online] Available at: <https://www.imperialhandmadebricks.co.uk/slide-image/home-bricks-made-the-traditional-way/attachment/slide1/> [Accessed 4 June 2021]. PAGE 66 George, M., 2016. Investment in a New Waste Recycling Plant Pays Off for Mick George Ltd. [image] Available at: <https://blog.kiverco. com/investing-in-excellence-pays-off-for-mick-george-ltd> [Accessed 7 June 2021]. PAGE 69 Studio Zhu-Pei, schranimage and Tian Fangfang, 2020. Cavernous brick vaults define Jingdezhen Imperial Kiln Museum in China. [image] Available at: <https://www.dezeen.com/2020/11/16/jingdezhen-imperial-kiln-museum-studio-zhu-pei-china/> [Accessed 7 June 2021]. PAGE 75 Fairs, M., 2009. Mapungubwe Interpretation Centre by Peter Rich Architects. [image] Available at: <https://www.dezeen.com/2009/11/07/ mapungubwe-interpretation-centre-by-peter-rich-architects/> [Accessed 7 June 2021].
126
APPENDIX THEMATIC CASE STUDY
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY | SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE, PLANNING AND LANDSCAPE