RCM&E 20 PAGE FREE PREVIEW August issue

Page 1

VOL. 66 NO. 8 AUGUST 2023 www.modelflying.co.uk AvroShackleton OWNDESIGNMASTERCLASS FREE SLINGSBYPRO-PLAN! Slingsby Prefect PART2 REDHAWK XFLYT -7 FLIGHTTEST L AN! Shadowed byGiants LMACOSFORDSTATICSHOW Thr DIYDI L I rot IES G H T T E S T tle Up EL CARB PLUSII MOREWALSALLWONDERS-F/FSCALEINDOORNATS II FINELYBALANCED-FLIGHTPLANC.G.STAND

WELCOME

WelcometotheAugust2023issueofRCM&E.

Ihavejustreturnedfrommyusualweekend morning f lyingsessionandtheconditionscouldn’t havebeenmoreperfect.Thesunwasshiningandthewind,whilst abitbreezy,wasmoreorlessstraightdownthestrip.

And,boy,whatastrip!Thechapsattheclubhaddonetheir usualsterlingwork(manythankstoFrankandhiscrew)andthe grasswas,Ithink,thebestIhaveeverseenit.It’sthenearesttoa bowlinggreenthatI’veever f lownfromatthatparticularsiteand eventheusualsheepdepositsanddivotsfromtheirhooveshad allbutdisappeared.Inshort,itwasalovelydayformodel f lying.

Therewasonlyonedampeneronproceedingsasforquite sometimeIwascompletelyonmyown!(Wheredoallthe aeromodellersgoonthebest f lyingdays?)Thatwasuntil, thankfully,oneoftheregularsturnedupforachatandashort f ly. Theweirdthingisthatunusuallyinthisdayandagethisclub normallyhasaverygoodattendanceatweekendsandso althoughitisquiteajourneyforme,andmuchfarthertotravelto thansomeofmyotherlocalclubs,Iliketovisitonaregularbasis ratherthan f lyonmyownelsewhere.

Havingsaidthis,thefollowingmorning,forwhichtheforecast wasnotthatgood,turnedouttobeanotherfineonesothelocals turnedoutinforce.SeemsthatIjustgotmytimingwrong!

Returningtomytrainofthoughtabove-‘inthisdayandage’ -whatIwasreallybuildinguptocommentonishowwhatI wouldcallthe‘usualclub f lyingdays’seemtohaveshif tedaway fromtheweekendsandnowtakeplaceduringtheweek.Iguess thisisanothersignofourageingaeromodellingpopulationand pointstothefactthatmanymodelpilotsarenowretiredor semi-retiredandsocan f lyonanydayoftheweekthatsuits them.Combinethiswithahostofdif ferentmeansof communicationssuchasclubFacebookandWhatsAppgroups, ratherthanjustrelyingontheoldtraditional‘Seeyounext Sundaymorning!’wayofdoingthingsmeansthatit’smucheasier toannouncea f lyingsessionwhentheweatherlooksgoodandbe sureofbeingjoinedbyafewclubmatesatthepatch.

It’sabitgallingthoughforthosemodellersstillatworkand trappedinanof fice,factoryorotherworkplacewhiletheirchums areoutenjoyinga f lightorthreewiththeirmodels.Nevermind ladsandlasses,hopefullywewillallgettheresomeday–unless somebrightsparkdecidestoputupthepensionageonceagain!

Ican’tcomplainthoughasI’mdoingajobIlove,andIdogetto nipoutmid-weekoccasionallyforabitoftest f lyingand photography.Yes,Iknow,it’sahardlife…

It’stimenowtotakeabrieflookatwhatwehavelinedupfor youintheAugustissueofRCM&E,startingwithourregular columns.

InhislatestBenchBlog,TimHooperdevoteshiscolumnto turningupanR/Ccarbforashelfbornedieselusinghisnew machinetools.InOneMan&HisShed,DaveGoodenoughdoes withoutamillingmachinebutstillmanagestorepairaglow motor.Thenit’sovertoChrisWilliamsformoreScaleGliding,this timefromtheWhiteSheetclub’sspringmeeting.Lateron,Keith Jackson’sAerobaticScenecolumnlooksatsomenewmodels beingpreparedfortheforthcomingF3AWorldChampsin AustraliabeforeGrahamAshbyandKicktheTyresinwhichhe broachesthethornysubjectofaccident-pronepilotsthenlightens themoodwithafewinspirationalmodels.

Forthismonth’scentre-foldPro-Planit’sbacktoChrisWilliams whointroducesthesecondpartofhisarticledescribingthebuild and f lyingofaclassiconesixthscalevintageglider,theSlingsby T.30Prefect.ThiscompletesthePrefectplanandarticlewhich startedintheJuneissue.

OurfeaturearticlesstartwithCreatingYourOwnModelin whichMartinHardyof ferswordsofencouragementtoany experiencedmodellerswishingtostepupanddesigntheirown largescalemodel.Next,ShaunGarrityvisitstheRAFMuseum MidlandsatCosfordfortheLMAStaticShowtoseeafine collectionoflargemodelsondisplayamongstthefull-size exhibits.Finally,wejoinDannyFentonashecontinueshisreport fromtheScaleIndoorNationals;thismonthDannyconcentrates onthefree f lightevents.

OntestthismonthDavidAshbystrapsintotest f lythenewT-7 RedHawkEDFjetfromXFly-Model.Finishingof f,yourstruly looksatanotherofthelasercutaccessoriesof feredbyFlightplan Models.ThistimethespotlightfallsontheirCofGBalance.

Ihopeyouenjoyreadingitall.

HappyFlying!

4 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023

ON THE COVER

Photo: Chris Williams

This month Mar tin Hardy begins a t wo-par t ar ticle on Creating Your O wn Model Par t 1 cover s aircr af t selec tion, making a pr ac tic al f lying model, sources of information, determining the best size and what you may need by way of a plan Par t 2 (September issue) provides, a s an example, an over view of the build of a 7 ’ 6” span elec tric powered Mk 2 Avro Shackleton

10

44

XFly-Model have relea sed a larger retr ac t equipped ver sion of their popular T-7 David A shby str aps in for a f light test

The Editor look s at another of the la ser cut accessories of fered by Flightplan Models. This time the spotlight f alls on their C of G Balance

6 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August 2023 CONTENTS RADIO CONTROL MODELS & ELECTRONICS I VOLUME 66 ISSUE 08
22 86 44 10 Regulars
8 SWITCH ON Our latest round up of model f lying news. 59 COUNTERPOINT A selec tion of new g adget s, kit s and bit s for you to buy 60 ALL WRITE Have your say in RCM&E ’s monthly chat room 92 GOING PLACES Our monthly list of model shows, event s and competitions for you to visit over the nex t few months 94 MARKETPLACE Sell of f your unwanted air fr ames and engines or maybe buy a few new ones 95 NEXT ISSUE Take a look at what ’s coming in the September ‘23 issue of RCM&E 98 PARTING SHOT A pair of DH 60 Gyps y Moths soak up the sun, ar t f ully c aptured by Chris Williams
Reviews
XFLY T-7 RED HAWK
FINELY BALANCED

Features

22 CREATING YOUR OWN MODEL

Maybe you’ve reached the point of wanting to design your own large sc ale model If so, Mar tin Hardy of fer s some word s of encour agement

42 SUBSCRIBE … and receive Luf t waf fe Fighter s & Supermarine Secret Projec t s FREE!

64 LMA STATIC SHOW

Shaun Garrit y visit s the R AF Mu seum Midland s at Cosford to see a fine collec tion of large models on display among st the f ull size exhibit s

80 THE ROAD TO BULGARIA

Alex Ma x field prepares to compete a s par t of the GB F5J Team at the 2023 World Championships

86 SCALE INDOOR NATIONALS

Danny Fenton’s second repor t from Walsall concentr ates on the free f light sc ale event s

16

Columns

16 BENCH BLOG

Tim Hooper machines up a replacement R/C c arburet tor for a longshelved diesel engine

28

ONE MAN & HIS SHED

Dave Goodenough continues his ref urb of a barg ain SC glow engine

36 SCALE GLIDING

Chris Williams and chums def y the relentless depressing spring weather to enjoy a fine d ay of sc ale soaring from White Sheet Hill

72 AEROBATIC SCENE

This month Keith Jack son look s at new F3A models being aired prior to the World Champs being held later this year in Au str alia

48

SLINGSBY T.30 PREFECT

Chris Williams introduces par t t wo of his ar ticle describing the build and f lying of a cla ssic 1:6 sc ale vint age glider

August 2023 | www.modelflying.co.uk RCM&E | 7 free pro-plan 36 64 48
28
All reasonable care is taken in the preparation of the magazine contents, but the publishers cannot be held legally responsible for errors in the contents of this magazine or for any loss however arising from such errors including loss resulting from negligence of our staff Reliance placed upon the contents of this magazine is at readers’ own risk.

SWITCH ON

BMFAPAYLOADCHALLENGE 2023

Thisyear’sBMFASchoolandUniversityPayload ChallengewasheldattheBMFANational Centreonthe14thand15thofJune.Itwas attendedbythirteenuniversitiesandonehigh schoolfromacrosstheworld.Thecompetitive spiritandthebuzzwaspalpablethroughout thesiteanditwasgoodtoseesomanyyoung peoplecollaboratingandworkingtogetheron theirmodelsanddesigns.

Thestandardofcompetitionwashighand withahighrateofsuccess.Mostofthemodels wereconstructedtoaverygoodstandard andhadbeenextensivelytestedbeforethe competition.

Therewerethreecategoriesinthisevent:

Distance -withtwoteamsfromISchool Chenmai(China)andAGHUniversityKrakow (Poland).Althoughtherewereonlytwoteams enteredforthischallengethecompetitionwas closelyfoughtandAGHUniversityKrakowwon byonepoint.ItwasinterestingtonotethatI SchoolChenmaicloselymatchedthestandards oftheuniversityundergraduatesandforfuture yearsawinwouldnotbeimpossibleifthe judgingpointersarounddrawingstandards weretakennoteof.

Quantity -withfiveteams,includingfourfrom universitiesinChina(ISchoolChenmai,Hebei UniversityofScienceandTechnology,University ofHongKongandBeihangUniversity).The fifthteamcamefromLoughboroughintheEast Midlands.

Thespeedandprecisionofsomeofthe teamsloadingandunloadingthepayloadwas fascinatingtowatchassometeamswerelike F1mechanicsintheirspeedandaccuracy.This eventwasexcitingtowatchandthelevelof innovationandimaginationwashigh.

Weight -18teamswereregisteredbut,inthe event,onlyseventeencompeted.Again,there wasaninternationalentrycomprisingofthree teamsfromChina,twoteamsfromKrakow,one teamfromMunichandeleventeamsfromUK Universities.

Thiswasanexcitingandverycompetitive eventandmostteamsmanagedtogetatleast oneroundunderwaywiththeirdesigns.The gustingwindsmadeforsomeverynervewracking flightsbutthankfullytherewerefew modelcasualtiesthatcouldnotberepaired.

Inconclusionthisyear’sPayloadcompetition wasagreatsuccessandwasenjoyedbyall.There weresomeexcellentmodeldesignswhich flew beautifullyandsuccessfullymetthebrief.The onlythingtodonowistolookforwardtonext yearwithanevengreaterentry–wehope!

8 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023 kcrozier@mortons.co.uk Getintouch...

MÁRIO’S MARS

Inthelastissuewegaveyouaglimpse ofMárioVilaça’slatestseaplaneproject, aMartinJRMMars,courtesyofour IberiancorrespondentArnaldoCorreia.

Arnaldohasrecentlybeenin contactagainandsays, ‘Justashort onetoletyouknowMáriohasfinished hisMartinMars.Whatwouldbeamajor projectformeis‘justaquickie’forMário, tounwindafterthatgorgeousFaireyIIID (seeSantaCruzaricles,Dec22&Jan23 RCM&E).Heislookingforwardtoflying itatameetinginJulyalthoughtherehas alreadybeenasuccessfulfirsttestflight.I’ll keepyouposted.’

Thankyou,Arnaldo.Here’sthevídeo oftheMars’test flight.She flieseverybit asgoodasshelooks: https://youtu.be/12qV8wJtcM0

MODELRETRIEVAL

Sadnewshasreachedusofafatalaccidentat amodel flyingsiteinSpainatthebeginning ofJunewhenamodellerretrievinghisaircraft fromtherunwaywashitbyanothermodel whichwaseitheronalowpassorlanding. Itwouldseemthattheaccidentoccurred becausethepilotofthesecondaircraftwas unawarethathisfellowpilothadenteredthe runwaytocollecthismodel.

Inlightofthistragiceventweaskedthe BMFAforcommentandweweretoldthat swiftactionwasbeingtakentoupdatethe relevantsectionoftheMembersHandbook,

specificallysection:13.3RadioControlFlying Safety

Paragraph13.3(n)willnowread:

(n)NEVERassumethatthelandingarea isclearevenifyouhavecalledlanding.In emergencysituationscallforhelpfromyour fellow flyersandalwaysbepreparedtolandin asafeplaceoffthelandingareaifnecessary. Pilotsretrievingmodelsfromtheactive runwaymustcallouttheirintentions‘loudand clear’andGETCONFIRMATIONfromanypilots still flyingthatitissafeforthemtodoso.In ALLcases,thesafetyofpeopleisparamount.

AlisdairClarkwasquicktorespondtoourrecent requestforpicturesofradiocontrolledCierva autogyros:

‘InoticedintheJuneissuetheanniversaryofthe firstsuccessful flightofanautogyrodesignedby JuandelaCiervaandyourinterestinanyscaleR/C versionsoftheseunusualaircraft. PleasefindtwophotosattachedofaC.30.Thisis fromtheLAhelikit,witha690mmrotordiameter,

exposedscaleradialengine,threechannels(rotorx2 andESC)and400g flyingweight.

Itisanicemodelbutisquitedelicate.Aswith allautogyrosit’simportanttospintherotorsupto flyingspeedbeforelaunch.

Thedistinctivewhooshand flightcharacteristics addtothefascinationoftheseaircraft,which

contributedsomuchtothelatersuccessofthe helicopter.’

Thanksforsendingpicturesofyourmodel, Alisdair.

LAheli’sautogyrokitscanbeviewedinthe Autogyrosectionat:https://www.laheli.com

August2023 | www.modelflying.co.uk RCM&E | 9
CIERVA C.30
ct,

T-7AREDHAWK

X-Flyhavereleasedalargerretractequippedversion oftheirpopularT-7.DavidAshbystrapsin words&photos» DavidAshby

Yes,Ihadtolookitup.ButnowIknowthat Boeing-Saab’sT-7RedHawkisanadvanced jettrainerselectedtoreplacetheNorthrop T-38Talon.Itbearsmorethanapassing resemblancetotheF-18andthefifth-generation fighterstowhichpilotswilladvance.Or,assome havecolloquiallycommented,it’saabitlikewhat you’dgetbymatinganF-16withanF-18.

AnewishbrandXFlymaybebutthereleases todatehaveimpressedreviewers.Thisistheir secondT-7Aanditjoinsthesmallerfixed-gear 64mmfanversion.Thedesignsuitsanelectric ductedfan(EDF)model,particularlythanksto awidefuselagethat’llhappilyacceptlarger6S LiPobatteries.

Tenservos-amixof9gand13gunits-are scatteredacrosstheairframe.ThereareLED wingtipandlandinglightstoobutit’sthe electricretractableundercarriagethatreally

impresses.Iftherewasaleaguetableforreadyto-flyelectricretractsthenthebeautifulitems fixedtoFMS’F-7FTigercatwouldbenearthetop, alongsidethoseyou’llfindhere.They’rescale, all-metal,verystrong,beautifullymadeand accompaniedbysequencedbaydoors.Icould watch‘emgoupanddownallday.

Ifyou’ve flownafewfoamiejets,particularly thosewithretracts,thenyou’llappreciatesome ofthesmalldetailsthatcontributetoamodel’s success.Reassuringlythereareplentyhere. Forstarterstherearethestronghornswith ball-socketlinks,whiletheall-movingstabiliser armsandmounts,potentiallyanareawhere problemsmayoccur,areverysturdy.Thewings useaquickconnectortoengagetheaileronand lightingelectricssoremovalfortransportation andstorageisquickandpainless.Thesamegoes forthefins.

www.modelflying.co.uk|August2023 10 |RCM&E
RCM&E| 11 August2023|www.modelflying.co.uk TESTING,TESTING |EDFjet
ThisistheBoeing-SaabT-7A.Ihadtolookituptoo.

It’sacontemporarydesign.Amongstothers, there’sabitofF-16andF-18inthere.

DATAFILE

Name: T-7ARedHawk

Modeltype: Ready-to-fly80mmEDFjet

Manufacturedby: XFlyModel

ASSEMBLY

Abespokefoamtrayprotectstheairframe sectionsverynicelybutdon’tconfusethe temporarywingjoiner(that’sdesignedto supportthefuselageintransit)withthelonger examplealsoincluded.Thelatteristheone you’llneedfor flying.

Initialinspectionrevealedaloosewooden coverovertheESCbutaccessedfromthe fuselageundersideitwasnothingthata littleUHUPorgluecouldn’tfix.Thataside, everythingwasnicelyfinishedandsuperbly protectedbythepackaging.

Guidedbyaverythoroughmanual,a 2mmhexwrenchisallthat’srequiredtoput everythingtogether.Amusingly,thefins seemlittlebiggerthanthewings,butIguess that’scontemporarymilitaryjetdesignfor you.Everythingslipstogetherreassuringly wellthough.Ifyourcarissmall,orstorage spacetight,thenthemodelcouldbequickly andeasilydisassembledthankstothe integratedwingrootconnectors.Don’tbin theprotectivepackagingtrayasitcouldbe usedtostorethesectionsbetweenflying sessions.

UKdistributor: CMLDistribution www.cmldistribution.co.uk

RRP: £549.99

Wingspan: 975mm(38.4”)

Fuselagelength: 1360mm(53.5”)

All-upweight: 3150g(111oz)

Wingarea: 21.5dm2(333sq.in.)

Wingloading: 146g/dm2(47oz/sq.ft.)

Powersystem: 3280size2200kVinrunner, 80mm12-bladefan,100A ESC

Connectortype: XT90

Req’dto fly: Receiver,6S40005000mAhLiPo

Anall-movingstabiliserneedsstrongmechanics andthat’scertainlythecasehere.

13gand9gdigitalmetalgearservosdothepushing andshoving.

Wingservoarmprotection.Anothernicetouch.

“AnewishbrandXFlymaybebut thereleasestodatehaveimpressed reviewers”
12 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023

SETUP

Apparently,BoeingandSaabintendtoofferan attackfighterversionoftheT-7induecourseso XFlyhaveincludedplentyofunderwingpylons andordnance.Theyslotintoplaceeasily enoughalthoughIsuspectthatfewwillfitsuch adraggypayload.Thelow-slungdroptankwill impedetakeofflongongrassystripstoo. Besides,Ithinkthemodellooksfarbetter flyingclean.

It’simportanttocalibratetheESCbefore flying.Themanualexplainshowthat’sdone whilealsoprovidinggeneralprogramming instructions,whichishandyshouldtheESC finditselfinanothermodeldowntheline.

Therewareno flaps,although flapperon (bothaileronsdown)deflectionmeasurements areprovided,alongwiththenecessary compensatorydownelevator.Theaileronservo Y-leadmustberemovedinordertodothat ofcourse.

Retracted,theundercarriageshiftsnotably forward,soIbalancedmymodelwiththe undercarriagedown.AlthoughtheCofG movedforwardsafewmmwhenthegearwas upit’snotenoughtoworryabout.

UnderwingstoresareprovidedalthoughI suspectfewpilotswillfitthem.Notethe absenceof flaps.

Theretractsarebeautifullydone.Notethe powerfullandinglights.

Likewise,thenoselegisasubstantivebitofkit.

Afull-lengthcanopyandcockpitmouldingcoversthebatteryandradiobay. Batterybayiscommodiousandeasilyacceptsthe6S4000-5000LiPos suggested. AmixingboardandmyRxsitjustbehindthenose cone.
RCM&E| 13 August2023|www.modelflying.co.uk TESTING,TESTING |EDFjet
“XFlyhave includedplentyof underwingpylons andordnance”

SKYWARDS

TryasImight,I’vebeenunableto flythismodel onbetterdaysthisspring.Theweatherhasjust beensowindy.Insomewaysthat’sgoodasa decentheadwinddoeshelpanEDFjetget awayduringtake-off,especiallyonewithahigh wingloading.ThisT7-Aneedsagoodlongtake offrun,whichissomethingtobearinmindif yourtake-offsurfaceisgrassyandonthe shorterside.

Idon’tdropthewingtrailingedge(T.E.) fortake-off,butsheunstickswithapush ofelevatorandclimbsawaycomfortably. Onoccasions,whentheendoftherunway approachedandI’vehadnooptionbutto bitethebulletandpullelevator,itsliftedand rockedthewing,butneverstalledorfallen outofthesky.Witha12-bladefanspinning awaythesoundisgreatandthemodel behavespredictably.

Thelowratessuggestedshouldbefinefor most flyersandwhilethemanualmakesno mentionofexponentialit’sbestto flytheT-7 firstandseewhatyouthinkbeforediallingthat in.Justalittle,15%acrossaileronsandelevator, suitsme.Itrollsquicklyatlowratesbutnot uncomfortablyso.

EDFjetslikethisarebest flownsmoothly; carvebiglinesandyou’redoingtherightthing. Lowpasseslookandsoundimpressiveand loopscanbe flownfromlevel flight.

Ideploy flaperonsforlanding,with‘servo slow’enabledattheTx,somakingsurethe transitionissmooth.Thecompensatorydown elevatormixmentionedinthemanualdoes preventthenosefromrisingasaresult.She’s verywellbehavedwiththeT.E.loweredand theeffectcertainlyhelpstoscruboffspeedon

Pushthethrottleandit’llmovealongat anappreciablerateofknots.

approach,evenonawindyday.Iguessthe undercarriageandwidegearbayaredoing theirbittoslowthemodelbyaddingdrag too,butitmeansIhaven’treallynoticedthe absenceof flaps.

ALLDONE

I’dreallylovetoreportthatthismodel rewardswithanimpressiveendurancebut my6S5000mAhpacks(700g)deliverno morethanfourminutesofeconomical flying.I setthetimerforthreeminutes,soensuringI havesomereserveforago-aroundifnecessary. Plentyofgoodthingsaregoingonhere though;it’swellmadewithafinefinish,has astrongretractableundercarriageandit flies wellwithnovicesthat’llcatchoutexperienced EDFpilots.Ifyour flyingfieldissmallor roughthenit’sprobablynotforyou,although thesamecanbesaidformanycomparable machines.

Below:ThisisXFly’ssecondT-7Aanditjoins thesmallerfixed-gear64mmfanversion. Landing flapperonsandaslightnoseupattitude helpscrubsomespeedforlanding. Itendnottodropthetrailingedgefortake-off.
“ …it’swellmade withafinefinish, hasastrong undercarriageand flieswellwithno vices”
www.modelflying.co.uk|August2023 14 |RCM&E

GIVETHEPAWA

Thismonth’svictimisthisPAW .2.49diesel,seenheresportingits shinynewcarburettor.

TimHoopermachinesupareplacementR/C carburettorforalong-shelveddieselengine words&photos»TimHooper

16 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023
CARB

Asthecustodianofasmallcollectionof dieselengines,I’veoftenwishedthat moreofthemcouldbebroughtback intoactiveservicei.e.,doingwhattheyshould bedoing-poweringmodelaeroplanesaround theskies-asopposedtosittingonashelf.

So,whyaren’ttheybackinactiveservice? Well,unlikemyhardierfree flightbrethren, I’manR/Cmanandhavingaccesstoan inflightthrottlecontrolis,forme,anecessity. Unfortunately,mostofmylittlecollectionof vintagedieselspre-dateR/Cthrottlesandhave afixed-sizeinductionventuriwhichprecludes anyformofspeedcontrolintheair.

Aeromodellersofacertain,senior,agewill knowallthisalreadysoforgivethepreamble, okay?However,ifyou’reoffresher(electric) bloodthenamodelwithoutaspeedcontrol ismaybeascenarioyou’venotencountered before.

Ifyou’vebeenfollowingmyadventuresin metalmachiningoverthelastfewepisodes, youmightrecallthatoneofmyultimateaims istomanufactureaworkingtwo-strokeengine fromscratch.Andmyroutetowardsthatgoalis tostartbymakingreplacementpartsforsome oftheenginesIalreadyown.Alittlewhileago welookedatmakingareplacementaerofriendlycylinderheadfora.75ccDCMerlin, whichworkedoutwell.

Now,we’regettingabitmoreserious.Ihave twoPAW2.49diesels-onehasafactory-made R/Cthrottleandhasfounditsspiritualhome inthenoseofmyMurgvintagemodel,which it’sbeenhaulingaroundtheairforafewyears now.Theother,alas,hasnothrottleandsits forlornlyontheshelf.

Theplanisdeadsimple:copytheR/Ccarb fromthefunctionalengineandthenfitthe copiedcarbontotheshelfsitter.And,yes, beforeanybodysaysit,Iknowthatyoucanbuy anicenewcarbdirectfromPAW(stillaliveand wellinMacclesfield,bytheway)forapaltry £25orso,butthat’snotreallythepoint,isit?IfI wantedaneasylife,thenIcertainlywouldn’tbe anaeromodeller!

Themethodologywasgoingtobequite simple:striptheexistingcarb,makeanote ofallthesalientdimensionsandthenjust manufactureanewsetofcomponentsonthe latheandmillingmachine.Itshouldn’ttake morethananhourortwo,right?Well,no,asit turnedout…

MAINBODY

Electingtostartwiththemainbodyofthecarb, Iusedthebandsawtohackanappropriate lumpofaluminiumfromalargerblock,after whichitwasmilledonallsixfacesdowntosize, usingadigitalverniergaugetocheck ondimensions.

Stillonthemill,Icross-drilleda10mmhole throughtheblocktoacceptthethrottlebarrel laterandthenturneditthrough90°soIcould drilla6mmholethroughitsentirelength.All oftheblock’soutsideedgesweredeburred withafinefileandanoldscalpelbladetook careoftheburrsaroundtheholes.

Thebarrelneedstobeaclose,smoothfitin

thebodyofthecarb.Ifit’sslackandleakingair, thenthecarbwon’tbeabletosuckfuelthrough fromthetank.Ipoppedalengthof12mmbrass rodintothelathe’schuckandturneddown theendby15mmsothatitwasjusttoolargeto enterthebarrel.Thefinalsizingwasdownto usingastripofabrasivepaper,alittleatatime, asthepiecespuninthechuck.Lightlyholding thetwoendsofthepaperstripbetweenthe fingerswastheorderoftheday,sokeepingmy clumsydigitsoutoftherangeofthechuck’s spinningjaws.

Afteraminuteorsothebrassrodwasa snug,rotatingfitinthebody,soIresisted anytemptationtopolishitanyfurtherand attackeditwithacentredrill,priortoboring theendwitha4mmdrilltoacceptthe spraybarlater.

Theentirebrassrodwasthenmountedup inthemill’svice,thecentrelinefoundand atransverse6mmholeboredthroughitto becomethethrottle’sventuri.Whenfittedinto thethrottlebodythisnewholelinedupnicely

Noneedtore-inventthewheel. IalreadyhadaPAWwithanR/Ccarb onwhichtobasemyrendition.

ABITATATIME

Asanasideit’sbeenabitofarevelationtolearn thatanordinarydrillbitisnotaprecisiontoolat all.Apparently,it’sraretofindonewherethe twocuttingedgesatitstipareperfectlyequal andcentred,whichmeansthatadrillusedalone willtendtowanderinacircleasitchewsitsway throughaworkpiece,thusproducingaslightly largerholethandesired.Thetrickistousea smallcentredrillfirsttoproduceatiny indentationandthenuseprogressivelylarger drillsuntilfinaldimensionisreached.

withtheholethroughthecarb’sbody.

Theendofthebrassrodwasgentlybevelled forneatness,andthenpartedoff.Theresulting barrelwas flippedendoverand,inthechuck, itwasfacedandbevelledsothatitsfinished lengthwasjustslightlygreater(by0.5mm) thanthewidthofthecarbbody.

“Theplanisdeadsimple:copythe R/Ccarbfromthefunctionalengine andthenfitthecopiedcarbontothe shelfsitter.”
August2023 | www.modelflying.co.uk RCM&E | 17 BENCHBLOG |Column

FOURJAWCHUCK

Thenextpartofthislittleadventurewasto placethecarbbodyinthechuckandturndown theends-notaseasyasitwouldseem.That four-sidedblockisjustnotgoingtobeheld neatlyinthestandardthree-jawchuck.

LuckilytheChesterDB8lathecomeswith quiteafewextras,oneofwhichisachuckwith anextrafourthjaw.So,what’sthebigdealwith that,then?Well,onthethree-jawchuck,all threejawsoperatetogetherwhenthechuck keyisrotated,justthesameasthechuck onastandardelectricdrill.Notsowiththe four-jawunit,wherethejawsarecompletely independentofeachotherandneedtobe adjustedoneatatime.

Thispropertyofthefourjawisbotha blessingandatotalpaininthenetherregions. Yes,youcansecurefour-sided(orirregularly shaped)workpiecesveryaccurately,butthere’s quiteaprocessingettingthepiececentredto beexactlyconcentricwiththecentrelineofthe latheitself.

Therearequiteafewwaystocentreapart inthefour-jawchuckandaftermakinginitial adjustmentsbyspinningthechuckatalow speedandcheckingbyeye,Ichosetomount adialtestindicator(DTI)inthetoolholder. Then,usingtheadjustmentonthecrossslide,I positioneditsprobewithinthecentralboreof thecarbbody,justbearingononesideofthe bore.Rotatingthechuckbyhanditwasobvious bytheerraticmovementsofthedial’sneedle thatthecarbwasnowherenearaccurately centred.Theprocedureistoworkoutwhich waytoadjustthejawstocentrethepart,which wasnotatallintuitiveasfarasIwasconcerned. Thejawsmustbetreatedasoppositepairs. Whenthejawnearestyouisloosenedthenthe chuckmustberotatedby180°andtheopposite jawtightenedbyacorrespondingamountto movethepartoververyslightly.AndwhenI say‘slightly’we’retalkingabouthundredths ofamillimetrehere,soalighttouchis definitelyrequired.

Whenonepairofjawsisgettingcloseto centred,thenwe’llrotatethepiecebyonly90° toengagetheotherpairofjawsanddoitall again.Whenwe’reclose,we’llcheckthefirst pairagain,thenthesecondtofinishup.Phew! Ifallthissoundsverytedious,thenyou’dbe right.Centringthecarbbodyforthefirsttime tookmeabouttwentyminutesbuttheresult wasthat,asthechuckwasrotated,theDTI needleinthecentralborebarelyquivered.This meantthattheDTIcouldnowbeswappedfor acuttingtoolandthebottomofthecarbbody couldbeturneddowntomatchtheintakeport onthePAW’scrankcase.

Itwasn’tpossibletotrythecarbforfit onthecrankcaseinsitu,soIrecheckedmy measurementsyetagainbeforereleasingthe carbbodyfromthechuckbyslightlyloosening twoadjacentjawsandtryingitforreal.Luckily thebodyslidhomeintothecrankcasepretty perfectly,otherwiseI’dhavehadtocentreitup againformoremachiningtogetitright.

Timefortheotherendofthecarbbody, whichwasdestinedtoformtheairintake.

UsingPAW’sowncarbasaguideImilledthestartofthenewalibodyandbrassthrottlebarrel. Usingadialtestindicator(DTI)withinthecarb’sboreensuresthatthefour-jawchuckiscentredcorrectly. Theheartofthecarbisthesmooth,snugfitbetweenbodyandbarreltoallowleak-freeoperation.Precise measurementshelpgetitrightfirsttime.
18 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023

AsthechuckjawswerestillwhereI’dleft them,itonlytookafewminutesto flipthe carbaroundandtrueitupagain.I’vewatched videoswhereexperiencedmachinistscan centreupafour-jawchuckfromscratchina coupleofminutes,sopracticeobviouslymakes perfect.Wecanonlyhopeso.

BLOWINGATRUMPET

ThecarbonanoriginalPAWhasaparallel intaketubebut,feelingbrave,IthoughtI’d haveabashatmachiningatapered,trumpet shape,justforappearance’ssakereally.

Goingbacktobasicsforamoment:the lathe’sbigsaddle(carriage)movesalongthe lathebedandthesmallercrossslidemoves perpendicularlytothesaddleandmovesacross thebed.Ontopofthecrossslidesitsthemuch smallercompoundslide,whichcanbesetat awiderangeofangles-handyforproducing tapers,angledbevels,etc.

Isetthecompoundslideata10°angleand, usingaminiatureboringbar,Iwidenedthe carb’s6mmcentreboretogiveaninternalbell mouth.Changingthecuttingtoolagainletme cuttheoutsideofthebell,aswellbevellingthe topofthecarbbodytoo.Thiswasaparticularly rewardingoperationasitletmestampahintof individualityonamachinedpart.

NEEDLEVALVEASSEMBLY

Thenextcomponentstoconsiderwerethe needlevalveandspraybarassembly(NVA)and here’swherethingsgotabitfiddly.

Ifyou’renotICconversant,thenhere’show itworks.Fuelissuckedfromthetankbythe engine,whichactslikeasuctionpump.Asthe pistonmovesupanddownitcreatesapartial vacuuminthecrankcase,whichencourages theoutsideairtoenterthecarbandtheninto theengine.Onthewaythroughthecarbthe airpasseseithersideofthespraybarandis compressedbytherestriction.Thisrestriction causesthemovingairtospeedupabit, resultinginanareaofloweredpressure.This low-pressureactsonthefuelfilledholeinthe spraybar,thussuckingfuelintotheengine.

That’saverysimplifiedwayofexplaining whatgoesoninthecarb,andrepresents thelimitedrangeofmyownlevelofphysics

and fluiddynamics,sodon’tdelugemewith correctiveemails,okay?

Thespraybarisaturnedbarofbrass,bored throughfromeitherend.Onthefuelinlet sidethere’sa1mmhole,whilstontheother isa1.5mmhole.Wherethetwoholesmeeta tinyinternalshoulderisformed.There’san additional1mmholeboredthroughthesideof thespraybar,justadjacenttothisshoulder.

Thepointyneedlevalvefitsthroughthe larger1.5mmsideandseatsagainstthatlittle shoulder,thuscuttingoffanyfuel flow.Asthe needleisunscrewedtheinletholebecomes progressivelyopened,solettingthefuel through.Thereleasedfuelcannowexitthe spraybarthroughthatholeinitssideandbe sprayedintotheventuriandthenceintothe engine.That’sthetheory,asIunderstandit.

Inpracticea35mmlengthof8mmbrass barwaschuckedupandboredwithapuny 1mmdrill.Anotherpartofthelearningcurve withthismachiningmalarkeywastolearn thatthesmallerthedrillbit,thenthefasterit mustrotate.I’vealwaysrunsmalldrillsatslow speedstosavethemfrombreakageandthen wonderedwhytheyactuallydidbreaksooften!

Thetrickistorunsmalldrillsathighspeed (1500rpminthiscase)andtofeedtheminvery slowly,usingregulardripsofoiltoeasetheir passage.Thedrill’s flutessoonclogwithswarf thedeeperitgetssoitneedstoberetracted andcleanedrepeatedly.Thespraybarwasthen flippedaroundinthechuck,andtheother endwasdrilledwiththebigger1.5mmdrillto createthattinyinternalshoulder.

Theoutsideofthe8mmbrassbarreceived attentionnext.Thereasoningbehindsuch a‘large’diameterbaristobeabletoleavea portionneartooneendatfulldiameter,which willbuttupagainstthethrottlebarrel.

Thepartofthespraybarthatwilllivewithin thebarrelwasturneddownto4mmandthen

Inletandoutletstubsare machinedtosize.Ontherightis thefixedventurithatwasthe engine’soriginalfitment.

treatedtoamatching4mmexternalthread forpartofitslength,whichwillacceptthe needleshroud.

Thecentralpartofthespraybarwasturned downto3.5mmandthenthesideholewas drilledonthemill.Two flatsweremilledon the8mmportiontoallowtheuseofa6mm spanner.Confessionbeinggoodforthesoul,I mustadmittogettingthelocationoftheside holeallwrongandhavingtosolderitupand re-drillitintheproperplace.Butdon’ttell anybody,okay?

Backinthelatheagain,theotherendof thebarwasturneddowntocreateanipplefor thefueltubetoclingonto.Ialsoturnedupa brassdisc,withaninternalthreadandexternal flatstosuita10mmspanner.Thisdiscactsas anutthatwilltrapthethrottlebarrelonthe spraybarshaft.

NEEDLEPOINT

Thesteelneedlecamenextanditstartedasa shortlengthof16SWGpianowire.I’dbeen ponderingthebestwaytotaperoneofitsends tocreatethepointybit.Thepointisdestinedto penetratethattinyshoulderwithinthe spraybar.Astheneedleisunscreweditretreats outofthecentralhole,progressivelyopening thefuelinletasitgoes.

Now,pianowireistough,springystuff,so Ifiguredthatthebestwaytotaperoneend wouldbetogrinditdownwhilstitrotatedat highspeed.Inaburstofclarity,Ifiguredout theeasiestwaytoachieveashallowtaperon suchaskinnylengthorwirewouldbetomount itinthechuckoftheDremel,spinituptotop speedandthenbringitintocontactwiththe sideoftherotatinggrindingwheelofmybench grinder.

Thismaysoundabitdodgy,butitworked sowellthatIgrounddownanothercouple ofneedlesforfutureusewhilstIwasatit.

August2023 | www.modelflying.co.uk RCM&E | 19 BENCHBLOG |Column
“Thiswasaparticularlyrewarding operationasitletmestampahintof individualityonamachinedpart.”

WhilsttheneedlewasstillintheDremel’s chuckIpolisheditsmoothwitheverdecreasinggradesofwet‘n’drypaper.The completedneedlewassoftsolderedintothe brassthimbleshroud.

THROTTLEARM

Theverylastpiecetomakewasthethrottle arm,whichservestorotatethebarrelwhen wiggledbytheappropriateservo.Thiswascut fromthinalisheetanddrilled.

Whenthecarbwasassembled,Ifoundthat therewasalittlebitoflateralplaybetween thebarrelandthecarbbody,asthebarrel protrudedoneitherside.

TocounterthissideplayImilledashallow (0.5mm)grooveintheendofthebarrel.Not onlydidthistakeuptheunwantedplaybutit alsogavethethrottlearmadefinitelocation sothatitcouldn’tturnwithoutturningthe barreltoo.

TESTINGTIME

Attheendofallthisthenewcarbwas installedonthePAWengine,whichwasitself installedintheteststandtoawaitatrialrun.I didn’thavelongtowaitforasuitableday.

I’donlyrunthePAWoncebeforeandthat wasoverayearagowhenitfirstcamemy way.Sincethen,ithadsatontheshelf,dosed upwithautomatictransmission fluid(ATF), whichismyusualafter-runpreservative.I’d liketoreportthatitfiredupstraightaway, butittookseveralminutesto flushtheATF outandgetitsaturatedwithnewdieselfuel, whenitstartedtocheerfullypopaway.

Soyes,itstartedandranonthefewdrops offuelinthe‘tank’(anoldsyringe).Refuelled, itstartedreadilysoIjiggledthethrottle pushrodandwashappytoseeitrespond.

Outcamethephoneandthere’sashortvideo onYouTube:

https://youtu.be/v6r-d3e9zVE

So,that’sthat.Thenextstepistosortouta suitableairframetogivethePAWahomebut thatcanwaitawhile.

FINALTHOUGHTS

Well,it’snotoftenthatasingleproject

occupiesthewholeofaBenchBlogcolumnso apologiestoallwhowouldratherreadabout balsawork.Ihavetoconfessthatthelevelof detailandfocusneededtoproducethislittle carbhastakenanypreviousthoughtand planningrequiredtoawholenewlevel.Fora relativenewbielikemeit’sbeenafairly intenseexperience,butveryenjoyablefor allthat!

Partsofthenewcarballpresentandmoreorless correct.Thesawcutonthethimbleletmepressthe threadstogethertogiveafrictionfitonthe spraybar,tostopitvibratingloosewhentheengine isrunning.

Oldandnew.OriginalPAWcarbfeaturesathrottle stopscrewbutI’mhappytousetheTxtolimitthe travelasrequired,soIdidn’tbotherfittingone.

ThepianowireneedlevalvewasspunintheDremel, thengentlypressedagainstthesideoftherotating grindingwheel. FlushedwithsuccessImadetwofurtherneedles whilstIwasonawinningstreak.Abrasivepaper gotthemtoanacceptablepolishedfinish. Ievengottoplaywithmynewknurlingtoolonthe thimble! Thesethingsdon’tjusthappenbythemselves.There’salotofworkingouttobedoneandthat’spartofthe joyofit.Here’sthesketchoftheneedleandspraybar. Needlefullyinsertedinthespraybarandbeingsoft solderedintoitsbrassthimble.
20 | RCM&E www.modelflying.co.uk | August2023 BENCHBLOG |Column

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.