Thursday, December 2, 2010
www.msureporter.com
Minnesota State University, Mankato
The ratings are in Ratemyprofessors.com helps students pick the easiest classes with the hottest instructors, but is it really accurate?
ALEXI ROSKOM
staff writer
index
Ratemyprofessors. com serves as one of the largest collegiate ratings for professors. More than 6,000 universities and colleges have created listings, and millions of college students flock to the website to help them choose classes. Some students find the website to be a reliable, quick source. “I’ve used it only a few times, and from what I’ve observed, the comments are pretty right on,” said Minnesota State Mankato student Ashley Olson. “It’s nice to provide other students with a heads-up as to what the class and professors are like.” Some professors also consider the website helpful to students, as long as they’re careful. “I think there is some utility in a website like this,” said Jeffrey Bumgarner, a criminal justice professor at MSU. “While students need Voices......................................8 World & Nation......................10 Study Break...........................14 Sports....................................17 Arts & Entertainment........... 23
to take the comments with a grain of salt, comments about how professors run their classes, or the assignment load in a particular course, etc., can be beneficial information for students who have many course options.” The website posts user comments and ratings, and the ratings are averaged out to give a total score for each professor. Criteria such as easiness, helpfulness and clarity combine to achieve a total score known as “Overall Quality.” There is also an additional option to indicate the level of attractiveness of a professor with the insignia of a “hot pepper.” Bumgarner laughed about the attractiveness rating. “Being rated ‘hot’ is flattering. And I must say, I think students got this one right,” he said. “Actually, to be truthful, my chili peppers were given to me years ago. I don’t think I get them anymore.” Students have mixed feelings about the effectiveness
of the website. International relations major Joe Cherney believes the site is helpful for students early on in their college career. “For general education courses, it is helpful for insight on the difficulty level of the course and to get a glimpse into what the course and classroom environment would be like,” he said However, Annie Kate, a graduate student, has found it less helpful for upper level classes. “All of my professors are not my choice, and it is not accommodating,” she said. From a statistical standpoint, the results from RateMyProfessors.com are varied. First off, there is no way to accurately depict who is writing the “anonymous” comments. Users of the website could potentially not even be students because anybody can access the information on the website and can post comments. In addition, professors themselves
could create these ratings. Many professors are clearly aware of the site because some even have profile pictures. “Ratemyprofessors. com is nothing more than a gamble,” said MSU senior Chris Mangione. “I’ve had experiences where Rate My Professor has been drastically wrong, but the website has been accurate from time to time.” Bumgarner finds the website moderately helpful, but still cautions users to utilize a sense of judgment when sifting through the information. “While the comments are anecdotal, often themes emerge from the comments that probably predict with a fair amount of accuracy how a particular professor will teach a particular course,” he said. Be wary of putting trust into a website that is incapable of performing simple arithmetic, though. One MSU faculty member on the website had ratings of 4.3 for
i n s i d e THE ODYSSEY OF KWHAN: A TALE OF WORLD TRAVEL, IMMIGRATION AND COOKING (4) MAVERICK MEN’S BASKETBALL PREVIEW (17), DORR LOOKS TO FACE OLD TEAM (19) ENTERTAINMENT YEAR-END LISTS (23), BEATLES COVERS FOR EDUCATION (27)
helpfulness, 4.1 for clarity and 2.4 for easiness with an overall quality score of 4.2, when it actually averages out to 3.6. Upon further research, results for the Harry Potter character Severus Snape appeared. He has an 2.9 for overall quality; however, the house of Gryffindor has rated him much lower. On the flip side of things, the website can provide information that will influence both students and faculty. “I actually made adjustments to some of my courses after reviewing the comments on this website,” Bumgarner said. “At one point in my career, I noticed a theme in the comments which suggested that my courses were thought to be easy A’s. I didn’t want that reputation, so I added a bit more rigor. While getting an ‘A’ is still very doable in my courses, I don’t think it’s quite as easy as it once was. I can thank ratemyprofessors.com for that.”
WEATHER OUTLOOK LET’S FACE IT, YOU DON’T NEED TO CHECK FORECASTS UNTIL MARCH. IT’S JUST GOING TO BE REALLY COLD.