Muslim Views, October 2015

Page 1

Vol. 29 No. 10

MUHARRAM 1437 l OCTOBER 2015

Preserving the sanctity of Hajj and protecting all hujjaaj IMAM DR A RASHIED OMAR

T this joyous time, when we are welcoming our returning pilgrims, let us also remember those pilgrims who will not be returning to their homes and loved ones but have gone onto their final earthly journey and have returned to their Compassionate Lord. I am not only referring to those who died of natural causes but also, especially, to those 111 pilgrims who were killed as a result of a crane collapsing on them in al-Masjid al-Haram in Makkah, on September 11, 2015, and the 769 (the Saudi figure; 1453, to independent according sources) pilgrims who were trampled to death as a result of a human crush that took place at Mina on Eid-ul-Adha, corresponding to September 24, 2015. It is heartbreaking and, I argue, unacceptable that these pilgrims were tragically crushed to death and many others maimed while carrying out their sacred Hajj. Almost every few years, the Muslim ummah has witnessed such avoidable tragedies during the performance of the annual Hajj. The last disaster occurred in 2006, when 345 pilgrims were killed in a similar incident in a tunnel between Makkah and Mina. One of the worst such accidents occurred in 1990, when 1 426 pilgrims were killed and nearly as many were injured as a result of a stampede, once again, in Mina. I believe that such tragedies during the performance of the Hajj, mars the sacred pilgrimage itself and is not inevitable but avoidable. More needs to be done to ensure the safety of all hujjaaj. I would like to make a few modest suggestions as to what we could do to try to prevent such hajj tragedies from occurring in the future. First and foremost, Muslims need to change their fatalistic

A

worldview. It appears that because of the frequent occurrence of such tragedies during the annual Hajj, we have become desensitised to the horror of pilgrims being crushed to their deaths in stampedes. Moreover, it is simply not good enough for Muslims to passively resign ourselves to accepting such tragic loss of human life that occurs so frequently at one of our most sacred gatherings by glibly attributing such catastrophes to the ‘divine decree of Allah’ i.e. taqdir or qadr of Allah. While, on the one hand, Allah the Most High, has commanded us to be accepting of His divine decree, on the other hand, Allah has also exhorted us to do our utmost to protect, defend and preserve the sanctity of human life. In fact, the safeguarding of human life is one of the supreme objectives of Islam (maqasid alshariah). The Glorious Quran is replete with references concerning the sacredness of human life (Q6:151; Q17:33; Q25:68). This emphatic position on the sacredness of human life is affirmed by the following instructive hadith tradition from the Prophet Muhammad (SAW): ‘Abd Allah ibn Amr relates that he saw the Prophet (SAW) circumambulating the Kaabah and saying: “How good you are and how good is your very air and fragrance. How great is your sanctity. I swear by the One in whose hand is Muhammad’s soul, the sanctity of a believer’s life is greater to Allah than your sanctity is…”’ (Sunan al-Nasa’i Hadith No. 39871) One wonders how the Muslim ummah would have reacted if, God forbid, the Kaabah had been destroyed. It is a sad reflection of the warped worldview of the contemporary Muslim ummah that we are prepared to fatalistically accept the killing of hundreds of pilgrims and do not reflect on our own human culpability. Only after we have done our

Although dated, this photograph, taken in December, 2013, illustrates the extent of construction work taking place in and around the Haram in Makkah. Pilgrims returning from the Holy City have commented on the lack of safety precautions around construction and demolition sites. With Makkah and surrounds hosting more than three million hujjaaj over the Hajj period, it is imperative that these guests of Allah be ensured a safe, incident-free pilgrimage by their Saudi hosts. Photo TOYER NAKIDIEN

utmost to prevent such tragic loss of life can we attribute such deaths to the will of Allah. The challenging question is: have we done enough to prevent such tragedies? Thankfully, some Muslim scholars are bold enough to declare that we can do better. In fact, a renowned Saudi shaikh, Salman ibn Fahd al-Awdah, has courageously acknowledged that the Saudi regime should be held accountable for the crush that killed hundreds of hujjaaj, and that the Saudi rulers cannot evade responsibility by labelling the tragedy as an act of God. A few countries, such as Indonesia, Nigeria, Iran and Syria have also rejected the official Saudi narrative of blaming the hujjaaj, especially from Africa and Iran, for disorderly behaviour and not following the instructions of the Saudi police, thus causing the human crush. In fact, some eyewitness accounts present an alternative explanation, claiming that an official convoy escorting Prince Muhammad bin Salman Al-Saud, comprising 200 soldiers and 50 policemen, may have caused the road closures that contributed to the fatal crush at Mina. In another independent report, published in the UK Guardian (October 2, 2015), a UK female

physician, Sabreena Razaq Hussain, who accompanied her elderly parents on the 2015 Hajj, has presented a sobering account of the lack of compassion from the Saudi hosts, and has urged all Muslims to protest the inhumane treatment of pilgrims. Other observers contend that this tragedy can partly be attributed to the fact that Saudi Arabia is prioritising glitz and commercial developments for wealthy Muslim pilgrims over ensuring safety and health for ordinary pilgrims or building decent accommodation for poorer ones. While the Saudi King has assumed the title of custodian of the two sacred Houses of Allah in the cities of Makkah and Madinah (Khadim al-haramayn alsharifayn), Muslims should also hold the Saudi authorities accountable for the safety of all who are guests of Allah when visiting these sacred sanctuaries to perform the Hajj and Umrah. This leads me to my second proposal. Given the disparate reports and sacredness of human life in Islam, we should call upon the Saudi government and the Hajj authorities to institute an international commission of inquiry led by civil society actors to investigate the facilities and logistics of the annual Hajj so as to improve the logistical arrangements of the Hajj and to prevent future tragedies such as these. Internal and non-transparent investigations, as has been the case in the past, will simply not be good enough and will end up being a whitewash and an exercise in exonerating the Saudi authorities of any culpability. Last but not least, Muslim scholars and institutions should do more to better educate prospective hujjaaj on the correct

performance of the rites (manasik) of the Hajj. Not only should prospective pilgrims be correctly educated with regard to the principle of ease (taisir) that should adorn their pursuance of all acts of worship but also the symbolic wisdom behind the performances of the rites of Hajj. For example, it is a stark contradiction for hujjaaj to go into a sacred state of consecration by donning the ihraam in a display of submission and equality in the eyes of Allah and then still hold on to attitudes of contempt, racism and xenophobia towards their fellow Muslims. At the very heart, the social message of the Hajj is that of compassion and equality between all humankind. This is a central tenet in Islam, which we should all live up to. Muslims should also be educated that by performing Hajj repeatedly, they are adding to the burden of overcrowding and congestion. We need to embrace the prudent and judicious views of scholars, such as Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, who have proposed that it is better for a person to give his wealth away in charity to a needy relative or a poor person than to perform Hajj repeatedly. In conclusion, we pray that Allah shower His mercy on the pilgrims who have died under these tragic conditions and that He receives the souls in their official status as duyuf Allah i.e. His honoured guests. We also pray that Allah, in His infinite mercy, grants their loved ones the patience and perseverance to withstand this great loss. Dr A Rashied Omar is Imam at Claremont Main Road Mosque, Cape Town. Page 9: Mina stampede – an eyewitness account

Learn advanced-driving techniques in our brand-new motoring feature, answer a question correctly, and earn an advanced-driving training course! See pages 16 and 17


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.