CORK BARK AND GRANITE BITE Vague Territories and Loose-Fit Infrastructures in the Gallura
Design Report Neil Cunning S0784977
1
CO RK BA RK A ND GRA NITE BITE 2
Thesis Title:
-Cork Bark and Granite
Agency:
-CORK
Authors:
-Neil Cunning
PARAsituation (SET):
-Vague Cork Forests and Unstable Harbours; Calangianus and Isola Bianca
Corporeal Species (Program):
-Isola Bianca, Cork Growers Association, Port Authority, Cork Bank, Cork Harvester’s Centre
Incorporeal Species (Situation):
-Proportion, Windfall, Time, Tempo, and Duration
3
4
This report is divided into two parts. The first part contains research and cartographies concerning the Metropolitan Landscape of Olbia and an analysis of its infrastructural devices. Part 1 ends with a description of the scaling, proportioning and harvesting operations conducted on the harbour. Part 2 contains the proposals and architectural output of the thesis at the scales of body, building and Enzymatic Territory, as well as an illumination of the spatial and tectonic studies undergone in the search for an appropriate architectural language. The final small section is a collection of Plan of Action drawings that serve as the basis of the counter-project to Olbia’s current paradigm of urban planning.
5
6
C ONT ENTS + PA R T 1 :
1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4.
Cork Bark Granite Bite Isola Bianca Scaling and Proportioning
+ PA R T 2 : 2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4. 2.5.
The Metropolitan Landscape and PARAsituations
Passive Bodies, Accreted Edges and Harbour[ing] Walls
Passive Bodies, Accreted Edges and Harbour[ing] Walls The SET [Set of Enzymatic Territories] and the Series Legal [AMPL] Exhibition Plan of Action
7
8
S ITU ATION: OL BIA
Olbia is a city with a richly textured yet delicately poised metropolitan landscape characterised by specificity, overlapping patterns, tempos, and shifting scales of operation and production. It is also a city that has, for the past thirty years, become dominated by the homogenising structures of the market economy. The Gallura region’s embrace of the tourist industry has resulted in urban development on an unprecedented scale. However, this development has been entirely at the whim of the networked market economy, operating at an expeditious tempo with no regard towards its duration or long term effects. The paradigm shift from the productive, situated landscape to the abstract network has resulted in a bifurcated condition between city and landscape, putting at risk the existing patterns and tempos - their slowness unable to alone resist. In short, the [loving] metropolitan landscape is in crisis. Although the power structures of the region have realised something must be done, the adopted planning strategies are simply more ‘contemporary’ formal iterations of the existing condition. What is required is an investigation into appropriate methodologies to deal with this condition in an attempt to refresh the reciprocal relationship between city and landscape.
Olbia, Sardinia
This is not a case of a return to a previous condition, or even an attempt at harmony, but rather depends on the carefully considered implementation of appropriate agencies [as ecosophic objects] to allow the patterns and tempos of the landscape to presence themselves in relation and in rapport within the very structures that threaten them.
9
10
P R OTA G ONIS TS
11
12
QUERCUS SUBER: CORK OAK Quercus Suber is a species of tree that
grows only in the
Mediterranean region. Sardinia hosts the largest accumulation of Cork Oaks outside of Portugal [20% of the surfae of the Island]. Most of this is concentrated in the north and contributes ₏150,000,000 a year through the production of bottle stoppers alone. Beyond it’s economic gain, the Cork Oak is a richly textured and highly specific pattern in the metropolitan landscape, both in terms of its slow socio-economic tempo [1 year - 10 years - 250 years] and its territorial vaguery based on a pattern of windfall. Although important in social, economic, and cultural terms the Cork Oak in Sardinia is in desperate need of supportive agencies
capable
in
face
the
currently
lack
of
of the
understanding
prevailing capability
and
ensuring
fast-economic to
operate
its
slowness
structures at
this
that tempo.
13
ISOL A BIANCA The the
natural
principle
bay
of
Olbia
protagonist
has,
and
since
raison
Phoenecian
d’etre
of
times
the
city.
been Its
strategic position in the Mediterranean has provided an immensely fruitful situation throughout history. Its usefulness is not lost in the contemporary age as it now hosts the gigantic harbour of Isola Bianca - the touristic gateway to the Gallura region. However, the growth of Isola Bianca has been driven unchecked by the homogenising forces of the market economy. It has become over-proportioned to the extent that in 2013 it superceded the size of the original roman city. Despite the large portion of the bay it occupies, it is an entirely mono-functional apparatus characterised by homogeneity and smoothness (to ensure efficiency in
its
processes).
Despite
its
amazing
situation
in
the
heart of the bay, it remains, due to its scale, an apparatus that
14
works
for
the
city
but
resists
becoming
part
of
it.
15
16
17
S Y NOP S I S This thesis proposes a counter project to the current paradigm of urban development in Olbia’s metropolitan landscape and aims to refresh the relationship between city and landscape, urban and rural, fast and slow. It attempts to do this through an understanding of the tempos and patterns of the landscape through three threads of investigation; 1. Isola Bianca, as the manifestation of the absurdity of the current marketdriven development [the cruise liner that stays for only a few hours]. 2. CORK BARK: The Cork Oak, as the temporal register of slowness specific to the Gallura [the tree that lives for hundreds of years and produces by the decade]. 3. GRANITE BITE: The passive, granite geology of the region that holds both in relation. The thesis attempts to find resonance in the patterns of these characters through the key issues of time, tempo, proportion, duration, and windfall, ultimately proposing a series of interventions charged with Agency Cork, both on Isola Bianca and in the mountains of Calangianus. Through a scaling operation, Isola Bianca [revealed to be a series of accretions around a granite archipelago] is civically re-proportioned and its redundant zones ‘harvested’. The result is the creation of a Cork Growers Association, Cork Inspector’s Station, Port Authority and Cork Workshops, and a Cork Bank/ publiz piazza on the harbour as well a Cork Harvesters Centre in Calangianus.
18
The Re-Proportioned and Civically Scaled Harbour in the bay of Olbia
19
Cork Growers Association +
+ Cork Inspectors Station
Cork Parks
Wi
nd
+ Port Authority Building Cork Workshops - Boat Insulation Fitting Fishing Pier and Shop
20
fa
ll
The Reproportioned and Civically Activated Isola Bianca An operation of scaling, reproportioning and harvesting of redundancies is employed in order to prime Isola Bianca to host a series of agencies centred around the cultivation, management, and extrapolation of the cork industry. A series of passive bodies remain (as sticky pieces) from the scaling operation that themselves host architectural accretions that activate them programmatically at the scale of body , building, and landscape. The cuts between these reproportioned civic pieces become public Cork Parks.
Cork Bank, Chamber of Commerce, Public Piazza +
21
The Passive Bodies Inserted in Isola Bianca post Scaling Operation are held In Relation
22
Glossary of Terms
Pattern ‘The pattern that connects things is abstract. It is not a thing itself. Pattern concerns the relationship between things. It must have seemed very vague and amorphous a pursuit to those in thrall to the materiality of things. You can see a bunch of things, and grab them; but you can’t grab the relationship between them. Nor can you count the different relationships between them as you can count the things themselves. A slippery subject, this pattern stuff.’1 Tempo A useful description of pattern across time, as with music, it is a description of chronology, speed, and atmosphere Accretion The accumulation of a material layer over time, the accretion is not simply a thing in itself but holds a specific, unique relationship to the body around which it grows, often activating the body, connecting it to wider experiences, relationships and networks. Modes of Being; Passive A body at rest, or seemingly at rest, that does not actively respond or react to its environment. It is slow, if it is even moving at all, operating on a different tempo beyond our understanding. It is other. In Relation Elements placed together, though not necessarily in proximity, that occupy a specific point. To move it would be to change the state of all objects considered In Relation In Rapport Objects In Rapport have a reciprical relationship with each other, one or more is in a state of fluctuation and change however this change is accepted and nurtured by the other.
1
Bateson, Gregory,Mind and Nature: A Necessary Unity, Bantam Books, New York 1980.
23
24
PART 1
+ + + +
COR K BAR K GR ANI T E B IT E I SO L A BI A NC A SCAL I NG A ND P RO P O R T IO NING
25
C ORK B A R K
Accretions build slowly over time
The Cork Oak: Landscape. Territory. Society. Economy.
26
The Cork Oak with Bark Removed.
Harvesting and Collection
27
Typical Sardinian Cork Forest Windfall and Vaguery.
Typical Portugese Cork Forest Economy mastering landscape. The trees, despite their 250+ year lifespan have been farmed in grids, creating a reliable,efficient, and well defined cork territory. This strategy, while economically sound, fails to value the potential of the cork landscape as a tool for the arrangement of the Metropolitan Landscape by virtue of its socio-economic tempo. It is a seperate territory, removed from the social, subjective, and urban issues of the metropolitan landscape, held in standing reserve for economic gain.
28
The trees are harvested where they naturally occur by virtue of windfall, creating an undefined, blurry-edged territory that transcends traditional urban/ rural planning and brings into question the very nature of definitive territory. It is a counter-pattern to the beauroucratic arrangement (legal, social, economic, and programmatic) of the Metropolitan Landscape, resisting such issues by virtue of its slow tempo (1 year - 10 years - 250 years) and the problematic of the uncontrollable, unpredictable pattern of windfall.
The Global Extents of the Cork Resource
29
Mapping the Cork Forests of the Gallura Proportion and Territory
30
The Vague Territories of the Galluran Cork Forests
31
VA G UER Y
In this project the cork tree is given similar rights to the landscape as in Portugal, making it unlawful to cut down or remove the precious resource without permission. Unlike Portugal however, this relatively simple act has a significant impact on urban and rural planning strategies. The pattern of windfall that dictates where the cork trees grow becomes even more problematic for the beaurocratic designation of definitive territories. What would it mean to these structures if it was stated that all cork trees were in some way public artefacts? By this virtue a hierarchy is established whereby cork trees are allowed to form vague windfall territories dealing with shifting scales of performance; a slow tempo of accretion of a resource, a local scale fluctuating tempo (to sit under with a laptop or to graze cattle), and a global scale where the bark is part of a macro network of economic exchange.
The Cork Oak
32
The Cork Oak - Technologies of Bringing Cork to Isola Bianca
33
Cork and Granite Mountainous landscapes of Calangianus + Territory
34
The Bay of Olbia - Isola Bianca
Calangianus to Isola Bianca - Cork Trail
35
Cork Oak Forest, Calangianus The Pattern of the Cork Tree The Cork is harvested every 10 years from a tree that lives up to 250 years - The landscape is tethered to this rhythm and the cork tree becomes the base measurement of a socio-economic pattern specific to the Gallura, its slow pace and high value yield, with the right supporting agencies on Isola Banca becomes the first move in resisting the homogenising forces of the fast economies and Integrated World Capitalism.
36
Cork Forest Territories and ten-year harvesting pattern, Calangianus. The territories trancend the existing beaurocratic, legal and economic designation of space.
37
Mapping the Cork Forests From Isola Bianca to Calangianus 38
39
Windfall Patterns 40
41
S C AL E
Cork, as a material, is inherently charged with notions of scalar transformation. In 1662 Robert Hooke discovered the biological ‘cell’ from observations of cork under a microscope. The structure of the cork at a this scale was, for Hooke, analogous to the simple dwelling of a monk - hence the term ‘cell’. This reveals the action of rescaling to one not only of scalar transcendence, also reproportioning and superimposition the building scale is referenced within microscopic.
be but as the
The interventions on Isola Bianca are conceived in the same manner, superimposing multiple scales relative to the rest of the city; an attempt to measure and reproportion Olbia’s outof-scale harbour and, at the same time, unlock its potential to provide more to the city than large scale global economic processes.
42
Robert Hooke’s Original Drawing of Cork ‘Cells’
Reproportioning Apparatus
Micro-Granite
Micro-Cork
43
44
PART 1
+ + + +
COR K BAR K GR ANI T E B IT E I SO L A BI A NC A SCAL I NG A ND P RO P O R T IO NING
45
Granite Fragmentation - Outcrops
46
Mapping the Cork Bark and Granite Bite of the Gallura 1600x 2000mm. A crucial cartographic excercise revealing the relative scales and territories of the cork, granite and tourist infrastructure
47
+500m
The outcrops form conceptual archipelagos, connected in section and forming a part-towhole relationship where each individual granite outcrop is symptomatic of the whole.
48
+350m
+200m
+100m
+50m
0m
-10m
-50m
Section through Gallura and Isola Bianca 49
50
al
ri
st
du
In r
ou
rb
Ha
Isola Bianca
t
or
p ir
a
A
d el
er
a
Sm
st
Co
51
GRANITE BITE Olbia’s Metropolitan Landscape + Granite Basin (Bite) + Touristic Infrastructures
1: 150000
Isola Bianca is ultimately a collection of accretions around a granite archipelago in the bay of Olbia. Can these accretions be carefuly harvested and reappropriated without disrupting (entirely) its operation? 52
53
54
PART 1
+ + + +
COR K BAR K GR ANI T E B IT E I SO L A BI A NC A SCAL I NG A ND P RO P O R T IO NING
55
The Introduction of a Faster Tempo to the Gallura
56
57
58
100m Isola Bianca as Existing 1:2500 59
Bite
Proportion Proportion
Machine
60
Emptiness
Machine
Absurdity
Arrival 61
Under the smooth operational surface (asphalt) of Isola Bianca is a tectonic of accreted edges and fills organised around an archipelago of granite outcrops. Like the accretions of the cork tree, they have grown over time but have been utilised to activate the potential of the territory to connect to wider economic networks. Unlike the cork tree there is no specific tempo that has been set, it operates at the pace of demand. The growth of Isola Bianca’s accretions is fueled not by the transubjectivity of the city or by issues of landscape but the seductive fruits of the fast economy of tourism. Given that this device now dominates the urban landscape (as of 2013 it covers more area than the Roman city) the harbour has developed a loose-fit with its program. The need to reach deep water to attract larger ships has created unusual (redundant) geometries to be exploited. It is a mono-functional device, its spaciousness simply a way of ensuring smoothness in operation. CORK BARK AND GRANITE BITE considers Isola Bianca as the protagonist in the refreshing of urban-rural relations in the Gallura by utilising (harvesting) redundant accretions and finding resonance between the patterns of cork and the operation and tectonics of the harbour. It is a search for ways of operating against the smoothness and introducing the slow tempo of the cork tree. Can Isola Bianca be a public, civic device that both invokes and utilises the patterns of the metropolitan landscape? And can this, in turn, resist the homogeonising forces at play? 62
Revealimg the tectonic of Isola Bianca as a collection of anchors, edges, and fills
63
64
65
EXT RA P OR T I O NS
Comparative Urban Scales The Proportion of the Machine
66
Barcelona Block
Edinburgh New Town Block
Manhattan Block
St Peter’s Basilica
The sheer horizontal scale of the construction resists being understood as tectonically comparable to an architectural scale. To counter this, and reveal the sectional potential, a scaling operation is employed.
As of 2010 Isola Bianca covers more ground (or water) than Olbia’s historic Roman city. Agencies are needed in order to treat Isola Bianca not as merely an apparatus for the city but a part of it.
67
100m
68
Isola Bianca AS EXISTING
The characters of Olbia’s edge, particularly at Isola Bianca exist as inarticulate concrete blocks that provide no positive architectural contribution to the city - they merely serve it, providing only square metrage for the accommodation of processes. Their conceptual autonomy from the city has allowed them to become completely managerial in nature, entities that work for the city but are not a part of it.
69
C H RONOLOGY
Drawing of Isola Bianca with its accretions coded from oldest to newest Darkest areas denote the oldest constructions
70
450 BC
1898 AD
71
1931 AD
72
1951 AD
2006 AD
2013 AD
73
74
01. Isola Friorita Section Office, Port Authority, Cruise Ships 1:2000
02. Isola Friorita Section Office, Port Authority, Cruise Ships 1:2000
75
04. Isola Friorita Section Office, Port Authority, Cruise Ships 1:2000
76
01. Isola Friorita Section Office, Port Authority, Cruise Ships 1:2000
77
The Tectonic of Isola Bianca Tested and Taken Apart
Granite and Fill 78
Edges
Granite and Edge +Redundant Edges
Stripped
Instability 79
Isola Bianca Operates not at the scale of the urban, but at the scale of the cruise liner. 80
81
82
PART 1
+ + + +
COR K BAR K GR ANI T E B IT E I SO L A BI A NC A SCAL I NG A ND P RO P O R T IO NING
83
S C AL I NG OP ER ATI O N Isola Bianca’s Scale resists all attempts at urbanisation. In this environment architecture disappears, is swallowed by the weight of emptiness around it. The only way to make Enymatic Territories on such an out-of-scale object is to measure it appropriately. Proportioning the existing city to the scale of the harbour gives a measure of the civic Isola Bianca.
84
85
S T I C K Y P I E C ES A result of the scaling operation is the ‘discovery’ of ‘sticky’ pieces, civic artefacts that remain after. (Almost) void of their previous programs, these form an archipelago of passive bodies.
86
To the Studio
To the Body (desk)
87
1.
88
Granite Outcrops Archipelago of the Bay - Gallura in Miniature [430BC]
1:6500
89
2.
Accreted Edges [Connective Infrastructure, Frame and Threshold] Connecting Granite Fragments and Activating the Economic Potential of the Bay
[1931 AD - 2013 AD]
90
1:6500
91
3.
The Editable Fill of Isola Bianca [Compacted Sand] Darker Areas Denote the oldest Accretions on to the Granite
[1931 AD - 2013 AD]
92
1:6500
93
4.
94
The Editable Fill of Isola Bianca [Compacted Sand] Reproportioned civic pieces become ‘sticky’ and are superimposed on to the site. Their Territories are extended accross the fill, carving and editing lines charged with a specific civic and programmatic agency [Cork].
1:6500
95
5.
96
The Resultant Cuts [Harvest of Isola Bianca’s Accretions]
1:6500
97
6.
98
The Harvested and Civically Proportioned Fill of Isola Bianca
1:6500
99
7.
100
Redundant areas and windfall patterns
1:6500
101
102
Although the entirety of Isola Bianca is notionally cut, not all of this will register. What this introduces is the beginnings of a reciprocal territorial dispute and a planning guide for the future devlopment of the civic Isola 103
Model of Scaled harbour is a scale-shift in itself. 1:1000 in plan yet 1:100 in Section it illuminates the sectional potential of the Isola
104
105
106
Model of Scaled harbour is a scale-shift in itself. 1:1000 in plan yet 1:100 in Section it illuminates the sectional potential of the Isola
107
The Bombing of Olbia
108
Isola Bianca has its own history of windfall. The 1939 bombing of the bay by allied forces becomes a windfall pattern
109
EDGE
110
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
3 “Cork” [ Elastica Veneer, ‘explora
EDGE
3
3
111
EDGE
E
PASSI V E B O D IES , A C C RET ED ED G ES & H A RBO UR I NG WALLS T HE SET a n d T H E S ER IE S LEGAL EX HI BI T IO N + + + +
rk” [fill] sticated thick edge. Malleable Granite eer, but Deposit. where the veneer is arving. plorable’ (?)
PART 2
GROUNDWORKS
CUTTING AND HARVESTING The Scaling operation opens up the potential for Isola Bianca to be understood in section, not as a plate but a thickness, an editable mass manipulated by the insertion of foreign bodies or the configuration of retaining walls. These objects become catalysts in the transformation of the port, the ground becomes rough not frictionless, it is capable of hosting agencies and now has relevance at an architectural and body scale.
Pieces carried over from the city have each themselves a specific way of accommodating or using the landscape
Dealing with edge and fill - The editability of the ‘cork’ of Isola Bianca 112
113
114
ED G ES - T YP ES Different Types of Edges Different TypesDifferent of Edges Types of Edges
Edge as Boundary / Threshold
EDGE
1
EDGE
1
EDGE
Edge as Mass / Ground
1
EDGE
2
EDGE
2
EDGE
2
EDGE
Edge as Accretion / Frame
3
EDGE
3
EDGE
3
Wall / Retaining Wall Wall. / Retaining Wall. Granite Wall / Retaining Wall. Granite Granite “Cork” [fill] “Cork” [fill] “Cork” [fill] Thresholds. Thresholds. Anchors. Thresholds. Anchors. Anchors. Elasticated thick edge. Elasticated Malleablethick Elasticated edge. Malleable thick edge. Malleable Moving over (the Moving edge)over or breaking (the edge) breaking All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Moving over (the edge) or breaking All or part of Gallura Granite Veneer, but where theVeneer, veneer but is where Veneer, the veneer but where is the veneer is All partDeposit. of Gallura Granite Deposit. through. through. Fissures, Cutting, Carving. (?) through. Fissures, Cutting, Carving. ‘explorable’ ‘explorable’ (?) ‘explorable’ (?) Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
115
The Grains of Isola Bianca
Stickyness
Patterns
116
Island Extention Fast and Slow
Scale
Archipelago Appropriation
Old Edges, New Edges and Islands
117
“Geomorphological” Grains from Scaling Process and reading of geology of the bay
01.
118
02.
03.
04.
05.
06.
119
120
121
Evolution of a plan
122
123
es of Edges
DGE
Edge as Mass / Geology. Passive Bodies
1
EDGE
all / Retaining Wall. hresholds. oving over (the edge) or breaking hrough.
2
Granite Anchors. All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
124
EDGE
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
125
es of Edges
DGE
Edge as Mass / Geology. Passive Bodies
1
EDGE
all / Retaining Wall. hresholds. oving over (the edge) or breaking hrough.
2
Granite Anchors. All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
126
EDGE
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
127
Edge as Accretion. Cork Edge
EDGE
2
Granite Anchors. All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
EDGE
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
128
129
Axonometric of Frame pieces/ Piles Edge as Accretion. Cork Edge
EDGE
2
Granite Anchors. All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
EDGE
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
Accretion Model Brass and Wax The Precise and the Vague
130
The Tectonics and Poetics of a Pile Cap
131
Different Types of Edges
Edge as Threshold / Boundary
EDGE
1
Wall / Retaining Wall. Thresholds. Moving over (the edge) or breaking through.
132
EDGE
2
Granite Anchors. All part of Gallura Granite Deposit. Fissures, Cutting, Carving.
EDGE
3
“Cork” [fill] Elasticated thick edge. Malleable Veneer, but where the veneer is ‘explorable’ (?)
133
134
PART 2
+ + + +
PASSI V E B O D IES , A C C RET ED ED G ES & H A RBO UR I NG WALLS T HE SET a n d T H E S ER IE S LEGAL EX HI BI T IO N
135
T H E S ET
ACRO S S T H E M ET R O P O L ITA N L A ND SC AP E
+
136
+
+
+
1.2.3. Isola Bianca Territories 4. Calangianus: Cork Harvester’s Centre Cork Forests, Granite Cradles and Networked Machines: Cork and Touristic Enzymatic Territories Across Galluran Landscape
137
Cuts in the Fill Connect the Territories - Physically, Programmatically and Tectonically 1:1000 Reproportioning / Scaling mechanism Model
138
n
iatio
k + Cor
oc s Ass rower
G
+ Port Authority. Workshops
+ Cork Bank. Publ ic Piazza
139
Charging Isola Bianca with Agency Cork
140
+ Port Authority. Workshops
n
iatio
k + Cor
rs Growe
Assoc
+ Cork Bank. Publ ic Piazza
141
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PR
CED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
01.
Wedge. Boulevard to Cruise Ship. Cork Growers Association, Cork Inspectors Station, Cork Park Scaled Piece: Chieso San Paolo
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Location Plan - Isola Bianca
Territory Post-Reproportioning
142
On Edge Reproportioning and Cutting -Chieso San Paolo to Cork Growers Association
143
Passive Body in Territory. Host For Accretions
144
145
146
147
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
02.
Spine. Cork Bank, Chamber of Commerce, Restauraunt, Cork Park, Piazza Scaled Piece: Olbia Town Hall
148
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Location Plan - Isola Bianca
Tectonics of Reproportioning and Cutting -Olbia Town Hall to Cork Bank + Public Piazza
149
Passive Body in Territory. Host For Accretions
150
151
152
153
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
03.
Port Authority Student Housing, Cork Board Insulation Workshops + Fitting Station, Fishing Pier and Shop. Scaled Piece: Terranova Grid Fragment
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Location Plan - Isola Bianca
Territory Post-Reproportioning
154
Tectonics of Reproportioning and Cutting -Terranova Grid Fragment to Port Authority Building, Workshops, Labs and Fishing spot.
155
Passive Body in Territory. Host For Accretions
156
157
158
159
160
161
C ORK G R OWER S ASSO C I ATI O N
162
Exploded Isometric - Kit of Parts - To be blown across the isola by windfall accreting on ‘sticky’ pieces as passive bodies.
163
W I NFA L L T EC TO NI C S
The Accretion of the Ecosophic Object in Territory Cork Growers Association
164
A CCR ETION S TA G ES
01. Existing
02. Cuts from Scaling + Harvest
03. Windfall
04. Passive Body Invoking Geology: Granite Bite
05. Accreted Frames Activation: Cork Edge
06. Frames, edges and Geological Pieces In Rapport 165
166
167
Axonometric - Cork Growers Association Passive Body invoking the scale of geology and the result of the reproportioned Chieso San Paolo becomes host to a series of accretions that activate the body programmatically and in its relationship with landscape and the environment.
168
Quantities and Measure of Framed Elements Make-up of the accretion
Slowest Tempo Passive Body exists as a reappropriation of the Scaled up CHieso San Paolo that becomes a piece of geology
169
Seminar Rooms
Auditorium
170
Port Authority Reassembly of Kit
Lighting / Shielding Strategy - fast and slow
Brass
Edges
Disassembly of Accretions
Cork Inspector’s Station
Port Authority walkway
171
Cork Growers Association 1:400 Ground Plan
172
B A
173
Cork Growers Association 1:400 Ground Plan
174
B A
175
Section A
176
177
ED G ES
178
179
OF F I C ES + SEM I NAR R O O MS T Y P I C AL AC C R ETI O N SEC TI O N
180
181
182
1. Visual Mediation
2. Environmental Mediation Night Cooling
3. Physical Mediation Entrance 183
C OND I T I ONS
01
01 Exploded 184
02
02 Detail 185
Internally, the passive body and the accretions are In Rapport
186
Mediating the Fixed and the Flexible Mediating Tempos
187
Section B Wine Bar, Wine Resolution Room, station
188
Store, Territorial Conflict Auditorium, Cork Inspectors
189
South Elevation Environmental Shading - Fast tempo, editable and changeable throughout the day activating the passive
190
191
192
193
EU OFFI C ES
Visual connection to Chieso San Paolo Dome
194
195
A R C H I V E + FO R ESTR Y D EPAR TM ENT PA S S I V E B O D Y
196
197
W I NE B AR
198
199
200 Archive
Harbour[ing] Wall
201
External Terrace
Wine Bar
Wine Bar Model Geometric Breach of the Edge
202
203
H ARB OU R WALL R EAPPR O PR I ATI O N
204
205
Harbour Wall Accretions - Reading Rooms off Archive Accretion activates the passive at the body scale
206
207
A U D I T OR I UM
208
209
Seminar Rooms. Offices
210
Auditorium
211
212
213
Cork Growers Association Model
214
215
216
217
C ORK I NS P EC TO RS STATI O N Q UA LIT Y CO NTRO L O F EX P O RT S
218
219
Cork Inspectors Station. Roof Plan
220
Cork Inspectors Station. Basement Plan - Labs
221
P OR T AU T H O RI T Y W OR KS H OP S F I S H I NG P I ER + SH O P
222
Axonometric. Passive piece
223
Section Retrofitting Boats with Cork Insulation 224
Port Authority Building. Plan
225
South ELevation
226
Axonometric of Port Authority Frame + Passive Body (Terranva Grid Fragment) 227
228
The Pattern of Windfall manifests as a territory across Isola Bianca, taking the form of the bombing pattern of 1939. When this Pattern falls in a harvested territory (reconfigured as a Cork Park) it becomes the planting of a cork tree. When it does not, but does align with one of the cuts from the harvest Isola Bianca is gifted an illumination + windfall device by the cork industry.
229
C AL ANG I A NU S
230
231
232
233
234
PART 2
+ + + +
PASSI V E B O D IES , A C C RET ED ED G ES & H A RBO UR I NG WALLS T HE SET a n d T H E S ER IE S LEGAL EX HI BI T IO N
235
EC ONOM I C S & C O STI NG
UNIVERSAL ACCES S
Due to the complicated nature of the site, varied and specialist materials, high water table and elements of the unknown in both the structural integrity of the harbour wall and the true depth of the granite bedrock, it seems unlikely that a Design and Build contract would be appropriate for such a job. This is due to the fact that the complex nature of the Works, alongside foreseeable improvisations and adjustments would need the project architect as part of the core design team throughout.
Egress
The nature of the series of buildings too would require the presence of the architect throughout the project to deal with the inevitable adjustments and alterations and to ensure a consistency across all of the works. A further potential problem would be that the Sardinian construction industry may be somewhat ill-suited for some of the more complex and crafted pieces (such as the auditorium roof) so great care would need to be made in selecting the appropriate contractor for the job. One major virtue of building on Isola Bianca would be the ease in which materials could be transported on to site. The overscaled nature of the context would mean that very large pieces could be made prefabricated and simply unloaded off of a boat or lorry onto the building. The preabrication of larger pieces could potentially create significant cost savings, particularly if this could be configured not just for the Cork Growers Association, but across the series of projects. It is entirely possible that large pieces of the frames or concrete slabs could be made offsite and delivered and installed in one, thus also reducing labour costs. The total area of the Cork Growers Association is roughly 3666m2 including some major external groundworks - costed at a highly liberal £2500 per sqm would make the total cost £9.1m. The Liberal £2500 per sqm is to cover the forseeable and expected issues on site as well as the complex nature of the groundworks.
236
Isola Bianca’s current accessibility (in terms of spatiality) is universal in that it is simply a giant flat snooker table. Although this project attempts to run counter to this paradigm it does not seek to disrupt the conceptual or programmatic egress of the site but rather to expand on its possibilities. As a result almost the entire building is accessible by the manipulation of ground to form ramps. Three clearly defined access points at different levels (on the three accessible sides of the building) make entry and exit egress extremely simple and clear. Internally a large ramp connects the east and west level change (the reappearance of Chieso San Paolo’s aisle) as well as access to the wine bar, auditorium and terrace. The situation where there is only stairs is countered by an easily accessible large liftin the south west corner of the building (complying with BS EN 81-70:2003). All internal access routes, by virtue of the proportional reference to the landscape-scale are larger than needed - from 2.7m to 5m, never being less than the 1.8m needed for two wheelchairs to pass each other. Visual The project incorporates several other attitudes towards universal access. Lighting is clear and well defined, as are the various building elements (Edges) aiding those with visual impairment., The thick mass of the passive body (archive spaces etc) is completely distinct from the framed areas, as well as the wine bar and auditorium, in both colour, texture and lighting.
Ramp Access Elevator
237
P L ANNI NG C O NSI D ER SATI O NS Perhaps the most obvious problematic issue raised by this project would be in terms of the planning and associated legal issues with the site. Isola Bianca is owned by the state and governed by the Port Authority of Sardinia. It is clearly assumed that they would need to be entirely on board with the project for it to go ahead. What is not clear is who would legally own and be responsible for the site both during construction and afterwards. Conceptually, for the thesis to be successful, the ‘harvested’ areas of Isola Bianca would need to be sold on to the Cork Growers Association or at least officially reclassified as not owned by the same group as the rest of the operational harbour thus would not need to operate under the same rules in terms of public access, security, proposed expansions etc. The organisation of this change-over (particularly in the Italian political system) would no doubt be a long and arduous affair and certainly would be a greater challenge than the technical issues with the Works. As a result it is assumed that it would need to form part of a wider urban planning proposal to be adopted by the state [see Plan of Action Drawings]. The socio-cultural aspect of planning (that of protected sites and historic centres) would not be an issue despite its proximity to the centre of the city. Given the nature of Isola Bianca’s development in complete disregard for its historical and cultural context the argument for proposed changes to its physical and operational structure would be strong. This is reflected in the public attitude of Olbians, who, after years of overdevelopment, are eager to make public some of this land, particularly due to its unique position in the very centre of the geological basin of the souther Gallura.
238
F I R E SAFET Y There are three main exits on three separate levels in the building (wine bar terrace, main entrance, and the west entrance) making safe egress for fire escape. On the upper floor, easy access can be made to downstairs or to the lift. In the case where the north east corner of the building may be blocked, there is a small escape hatch built in to the reappropriated harbour wall. The space between the passive body (archive + Library) and the seminar rooms and forestry offices is the main egress route through the building and is wide enough (3.5m) to comfortably accommodate large flows of people. Likewise in the auditorium and wine bar the exit routes are all large in scale (5m and 2.7m respectively), both making it easy to negotiate and clear where the exit route is. The most problematic point for fire escape would be the overhanging wine bar. There are two exits to this however and as such does not pose a significant threat.
239
S T R UC T URAL C O NC E RNS The Building (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (Section 1, Regulation 9 1.1) require that; ‘Every building must be designed and constructed in such a way that the loadings that are liable to act on it will not lead to: a) The collapse of the whole or part of the building; or b) Deformations which would make the building unfit for its intended use, unsafe, or cause damage to other parts of the building or to fittings or to installed equipment’ Reclaimed Land - Piling Building on the reclaimed land of Isola Bianca requires a specific and attentive attitude to ground conditions. The harbour is essentially a series of large trays; harbour walls made of prefabricated concrete blocks that hold large areas of densely compacted sand. As it is obviously built in the bay, this ground type has a high water table. Building on such a surface requires technological solutions to mediate between this condition and the granite bedrock beneath the bay. The Cork Growers Association building touches the ground in different ways depending on ‘edge’ type . The ‘geological’ passive bodies are heavy, thick concrete foundations emerge from the bedrock to hold an equally heavy slab - wall structure. This condition is fixed, static. The second condition, that of the accretions, is a more problematic frame structure. This employs a strategy of secant piling in order to both provide structural support for the frame - mediating between granite bedrock and pile cap - and allow the cheapest and easiest method for the creation of retaining walls to allow level changes across the site.
240
Fixed Structure
Flexible Connection
Between the Fixed and the Flexible The shift from the static condition of pile/ pile cap to frame is mediated by a large steel pin joint. This is a also a thetic device and significant tectonic detail as it is ultimately the mediation between tempos / edge conditions at the scale of the body. In terms of their loadbearing capacities, the glulam timber beams (as with the concrete structure) have been designed with a slightly larger section than would be strictly necessary. Thus, the technial challenge lies in the correct detailing of the steel connectors, particularly at the pile cap and the horizontal fixings to the concrete structure and in the connection with the extended harbour wall. These connections must allow for sufficient movement in order to retain the structural integrity of the frame.
Pile Cap to Frame Detail Mediating Slow Granite with Fast Accretion Landscape to Body
Secant Piling System
241
S T R UC T URAL C O NC E RNS 2 Steel Connectors - Glulam timber beams
242
243
ENV I R ONM ENTAL C O NC ER NS T H ER M AL S TR ATEG I ES Successful passive environmental control depends crucially in understanding the tempos of the natural environment and the application of technologies to utilise this fluctuation. The Cork Growers Association, as a manifestation of the tempos of the metropolitan landscape is perfectly poised for such strategies and attempts to operate in a passive manner as much as possible with regards to its environmental performance. This occurs in a number of ways, primarily in terms of lighting, cooling, and ventilation. The cooling strategy is two-fold. The slow tempo of the granite bedrock is unchanging with the daily cycle of the sun. This below ground coolness is utilised through a system of sea water pumped through -50m piles which then circulates within the thick concrete structures of the passive body, cooling the building throughout the day. To counter the thermal gain of the sun during the day, the brass cladding on the south side of the building rises high enough in order to shield the concrete from unwanted thermal gain. At night, sections of the brass cladding (which operates on the human-scale tempo)open to further cool the building throughout the night. Due to the principle of thermal lag, the pumping system will not always be needed. Crucially, the possibility of accretions of salt build up from the seawater was countered through a double pipe system (see detail). The flexibility and fluctuation of the brass cladding is again utilised in terms of lighting, allowing daylight control on the south facing facade by the user.
Cooled water pipes embedded in concrete floor. Section and axonometric.
244
245
246
ENV IR ONMENTA L CONCER NS
Slow Tempo Passive Water Cooling System. 247
248
PART 2
+ + + +
PASSI V E B O D IES , A C C RET ED ED G ES & H A RBO UR I NG WALLS T HE SET a n d T H E S ER IE S LEGAL EX HI BI T IO N
249
250
Main piece of exhibition comprises of a structure that is both a 1:100 model (scaled to studio) of Isola Bianca and a series of 1:1 Details
251
A2 Books
Cork Table Territorial Dispute Resolution
Cork Bark and Granite Bite Mapping the Cork and Granite of the Gallura
Film
1:1 / 1:100 / 1:1000 Isola Bianca Model
1:50 sectional Model Scale Shifts Model Reproportioning Isola Bianca
252
1:100 Sectional Fragment Model
1800 x 700
253
254
P L AN OF AC TI O N D RAWI NG S
255
256
257
258
Olbia Plan of Action
Sub Agencies: 4+ Porto Romano edge reconfiguration - Archaeological site, Sports Area, Urban forest, Italian ‘naval league’ clubhouse
cork
4+
5+ Cork park - Cork Harvester Acommodation, Hotel, Cork Trees 6+ Cork Laboratories and Harvester acommodation 7+ Airport Hotel -Confrence Centre, Train Station, Cork Trees
6+
8+ Forest-fire Station 9+ Cork Harvesting school -Cork Archive, Cork Laboratories 10+ Cork Tree Planting -Windfall pattern of Cork trees becomes a vague territory accross the urban and the rural
5+
7+
9+ 259
260
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
261
262
263
264
EP ILOG U E
CORK BARK AND GRANITE BITE is a project centred around the search for techniques, operations and methodologies to deal with the ubiquitous homogenising forces of the market economy. It opens up enquiries into the transformative potential of scalar shifts and the significance of (pro)portion. What it questions most however, is the notion of territory. The cork tree shows us the potential vagueness of this term and reminds us that territories exist on the ground first, they are only represented by the line of a pen in a beaurocratic (but necessary) abstract action. This project offers a reminder to urban planners and beaurocrats that architecture too can exist in a state of vague territoriality, given the correct methodologies are employed. The projects on Isola Bianca are neither in conflict with nor in harmony with the structures of Isola Bianca but sit in a state of reciprocal relation. They sometimes resist, sometimes accept and sometimes ignore. Although we could draw a line where the territory of Isola Bianca notionally ends and the Cork Association’s begins theres is always a tendency that in the next drawing this line may change, extend, cut deeper, or that the ‘wind’ may blow one territory into another. CORK BARK AND GRANITE BITE is a project that accepts this as part of the reality of territory. It is a reminder that the map is not the territory.
265
IMAGE REFERENCES
All images are the Authors own work. Satelite and historical photos from the Faculty of Architecture, Alghero Architecture School. 2011. pages 17 & back cover - Still from Fitzcarraldo. Werner Herzog. 1982
266
BIBL IOG RA P H Y Agamben, Giorgio, The Coming Community, trans. (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2007).
Michael
Hardt
Agamben, Giorgio, What is an Apparatus? and Other Essays, Trans. David Kishik and Stefan Pedatella, (Stanford California: Stanford University Press, 2009). Blanchot, Maurice, The Unavowable Community, trans. Pierre Joris ( New York: Barrytown, Station Hill Press) 1988. De Certeau, Michel, The Practice Of Everyday Life, trans. Steven Rendall (Berkeley, California: California University Press, 1984). Deleuze, Gilles and Felix Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, Capitalism and Schizophrenia, trans. Brian Massumi (London: Continuum, 2002). Guattarri, Felix, The Three Ecologies, trans Ian Pindar and Paul Sutton (New York: Athlone Press, 2000)
Allen, Stan, Points + Lines: Diagrams and Projects for The City (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1999). Archizoom and Andrea Branzi, Casabella, 399, 1975 (Milan: Studio Editoriale Milanese, 1975) Aureli, Pier Vittorio, More and More about Less and Less: Notes Towards a History of Nonfigurative Architecture, Log 16, ed. Cynthia Davidson (New York: Anycorp, 2009) Corner, James, The Agency of Mapping: Speculation, Critique and Invention, in Mappings, ed. Denis Cosgrove, (London: Reaktion, 2002) pp. 213-52. Eisenman, Peter, Tracing Eisenman, ed. Cynthia Davidson (London: Thames and Hudson, 2006). Evans, Robin, The Projective Cast, Architecture And Its Three Geometries (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1995).
Rancière, Jacques, The Politics of Aesthetics, The Distribution of The Sensible, trans. Gabriel Rockhill (London: Continuum, 2005)
Gregotti, Vittorio, Territory and Architecture, in Theorising a New Agenda for Architecture, An Anthology of Architectural Theory, 1965-1995, ed. Kate Nesbitt (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1996) pp.340-344.
Serres, Michel, The Natural Contract, trans Elizabeth MacAtrhur and
Hejduk, John, Mask of Medussa
William Paulson (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2008).
Wiszniewski, D., City as Museum: Museum as City, Mediating The Everyday and Special Narratives of Life, in Narrative Space/Museum Making, eds. Jonathan Hale, Laura Hanks and Suzanne McLeod (Routledge, due for publication 2011).
Serres, Michel, The Parasite, trans Lawrence R. Schehr (Minnesota: University Of Minnesota Press, 2007). Agrest, Diana, ‘Representation as Articulation between Theory and Practice,’ in Allen, Stan, Essays, Practice, Architecture, Technique and Representation (Amsterdam: G+B Arts International, 2000) pp.163177. Allen, Stan, Representation 2000).
Wiszniewski, D., Florence: Curating The City, ed Dorian Wiszniewski (Architecture, University of Edinburgh: Edinburgh, 2010) [ISBN 978-0-95597067-2]
Essays, Practice, Architecture, Technique and (Amsterdam: G+B Arts International, Netherlands,
267
268