Corner Factory Revisiting Urban Manufacturing
Simon Nilsson Chalmers Architecture Spring 2016 1
Master's Thesis Chalmers University of Technology Department of Architecture MPARC - Architecture & Urban Design Material Turn studio Spring 2016 Title Corner Factory Revisiting Urban Manufacturing Author Simon Nilsson www.simonnilsson.nu Supervisor Daniel Norell Examiner Jonas Lundberg
1
Abstract
This thesis reimagines the form, function and place of the factory. The factory of today is typically a flat, expandable and cheap ‘shed’, almost always placed in a monofunctional industrial zone. Manufacturing is dispersed and obscure, overlooked by a paradigm of ’mixed-use’ densification. The reasons for this separation seems dubious in a rapidly changing industrial landscape. New fabrication flows, disruptive technologies and a changing workforce looks supportive of revisiting the original factory condition: urban and compact, in close proximity to workers and resources. Factory architecture has often been a blunt reflection of technological and societal conditions - how could a contemporary urban factory likewise reflect ongoing shifts? There is a tradition of ‘spectacle’ in factory architecture, where industrial workings are manifested extrovertly. In this vein, what aspects of new vertical production processes could be utilised for visual effect? On a city-block corner in a central development area of Gothenburg, a high-rise (22x22x49m) factory is conceived. Tailored towards the high-tech sector on a hotel model and ready to accommodate ‘Industry 4.0’, the facility utilises a smart logistical core for handling the vertical flow problem. Promoting exposure of automated equipment, constant activity is provided to its surroundings. Employing this proposal as critical device, the potential of industrial presence to contribute to a cityscape is investigated and further debate hopefully provoked.
2
Contents
Abstract 2
Proposal 53 Exhibition 53
Contents 3
Model 54 Views 57
Design 4
Drawings 61
Aim 4
Axonometric 62
Method 4
Detail section 63
Questions 4
Section 65 Elevation 66
Themes 5
Form, place and spectacle
Plans 67
7
Typological evolution chart 11
References 73
Discriminating paradigms 13 The fourth revolution 15 Work and play 17 Process 19 Criteria 19 Conceptual collages 21 Future context 24 Development analysis 27 Logistics 29 Morphology 30 Use 31 Users 32 Program 33 Process flow studies 35 Flow chart 37 Vertical flow problem 38 Direct input/output system 39
Automated storage/retrieval system
40
Machinery 41 Space-making equipment 42 Core placement 43 Core development 45 Structure 47 Facade 51
3
Design
Aim The aim of this thesis is to challenge the virtual absence of manufacturing in discussions regarding urban planning, and to explore what current shifts might mean for factory architecture. Method This is to be achieved by investigating future manufacturing space through a visionary factory proposal that provokes further discussion. Questions Factory architecture has often been a blunt reflection of technological and societal conditions - how could a contemporary urban factory likewise reflect ongoing shifts? There is a tradition of ‘spectacle’ in factory architecture, where industrial workings are manifested extrovertly. In this vein, what aspects of new vertical production processes could be utilised for visual effect?
4
5
Themes
Factories, being pragmatic enclosures for the making of things, have perhaps faster than any other building typology adapted to new conditions. Guided by the hand of market capitalism, their architecture has closely followed changing technological, economical and societal conditions. Recurring industrial revolutions have radically transformed the form, function and place of factories over the years. This master’s thesis is exploring several themes found in the growing space between the current state of factories and an ongoing transformation of manufacturing.
OPPOSITE: TAHOE-RENO INDUSTRIAL PARK (BING MAPS 2016) 6
‘Industry, overwhelming us like a flood which rolls on towards its destined ends...’ Le Corbusier, Toward an Architecture (1923)
Form, place and spectacle Manufacturing is today dispersed and global, typically
architecture by the enormous Fiat Lingotto plant in Turin
located in industrial districts sorely lacking in urban
(Giacomo Mattè-Trucco, 1923)
qualities. Found at the outskirts of cities, no matter the
With its crowning rooftop test track, signifying a new
country, these production zones all look similar. They are
age through the symbolism of the car. At the time of its
sprawling fields made up of ‘sheds’ - rudimentary steel
opening, it was something radically new, and was hailed by
halls, cheapy erected and easily expanded, the simplest
Filippo Tommaso Marinetti as the ‘first Futurist constructive
possible shell for sheltering a production process. Or in
invention’
effect, the very antithesis of the vertical city-factory.
impressive sights in industry’ and ‘a guideline for town
Historically, multi-storey factories has often been found
1
and by Le Corbusier as ‘one of the most
planning’.
in dense city environments, in proximity of workers and
Apart from this incredible gimmick, the Lingotto plant is
resources. The cotton mills of Victorian England was for all
modelled on the Ford Highland Park factory (Albert Kahn,
their flaws as workplaces a very vital urban phenomenon,
1910). In this facility, Ford was testing out his theories of
and supreme drivers of urbanisation itself. Embracing
utilising gravity through chutes and slides along the vertical
technology and rationalism, the early 20th century factory
production line winding across four floors. In the end,
was an instrumental mover of Modernism itself, through
Highland Park was abandoned as Lingotto opened. The
buildings such as the AEG turbine factory (Behrens,
pragmatic Ford had simply faced up to the supremacy of
1910) or the Fagus Factory (Gropius & Meyer, 1913). A
horizontal flows for mass production . The cotton mills had
few years later, the spectacular was introduced in factory
been compact and multi-storey for reasons of mechanical
2
LINGOTTO PLANT IN 1928 (DGTMEDIA - SIMONE. CC 3.0) OPPOSITE: VAN NELLE FABRIEK (ARJANDB. CC-BY-SA-3.0-NL DESATURATED BY AUTHOR)
1. MARINETTI, SOMENZI, MAZZONI. (1934) FUTURIST MANIFESTO OF AERIAL ARCHITECTURE 2. BRUNNSTRÖM, L. (1990) THE RATIONAL FACTORY : ON THE ROOTS OF FUNCTIONALIST ARCHITECTURE (SWEDISH EDITION)
7
8
9
force transfer, and electrification initially did little to alter
car manufacturers, with the BMW plant in Leipzig being
factory typology. But the advantages of laying out a
especially noteworthy. Through a central section designed
spacious production line on a single floor soon became
by Zaha Hadid, car chassis are conveyed through the
obvious. Opening a virtually self-sufficent car-making
management and administration facilities, blurring the
mini-city at River Rouge, a new template for large-scale
division of labor in a celebration of speed and movement
manufacturing was established.
reminiscent of Lingotto.
‘The most beautiful spectacle of the modern age’, again
With super-block structures such as the Starett-Lehigh
according to Le Corbusier, is the Van Nelle Fabriek
building on Manhattan (Cory & Cory, 1931) urban
(Brinkman & Van der Vlugt, 1931). Designated a world
manufacturing reached an all-time high of density and
heritage in 2014, it brandishes the world’s first pre-
urbanity. However, during the postwar economic boom,
fabricated curtain wall. Through this the factory’s contents
factories started leaving cities according to the economical
was exposed like never before, and the machine aestethic
logic of that era. Cheap energy, transportation and labor
truly came into its own through the constructivist bridges
pushed industry to similarly cheap locations.
transporting goods into a logistics terminal.
Today, as manufacturing conditions are rapidly changing,
This super-transparency has a modern counterpart in the
so are the fundaments of the location and form of certain
Gläserne Manufaktur of Volkswagen in Dresden (Günther
facilities. Complementing the fields of sprawling sheds at
Henn, 2002), which is meant to represent the company’s
our city outskirts, could an urban return of factories be
values (rather ironical in light of the 2015 emissions
plausible? The exuberant wonder of the first machine age
scandal). While a practical, operational facility and not
have faded, but technology is marching on. What could
a showroom, this factory is still the public ‘face’ of VW
these recent advances and following socioeconomic shifts
production, being both building and ongoing PR campaign.
imply for factory architecture?
This communications strategy is common among premium
And what could a contemporary spectacle consist of?
TESLA FREMONT FACILITY (CHRISHMT0423 CC 2.0) OPPOSITE: STARETT-LEHIGH BLDG (AUTHOR 2014) 10
Typological evolution
OPPOSITE: STARETT-LEHIGH BLDG (AUTHOR 2014) (3) 1910, AEG TURBINENFABRIK: THE FACTORY RECOGNIZED AS ARCHITECTURE (2) 1797, MURRAY’S MILLS: URBAN AND COMPACT
(6) 1931, VAN NELLE FABRIEK: SUBLIME MACHINE AESTETHIC
(4) 1910, HIGHLAND PARK: GRAVITATION FLOW EXPERIMENTS BY HENRY FORD
(1) 1400’S, VENICE ARSENALE: CANAL PRODUCTION LINES IN FIRST FACTORY
(5) 1923, FIAT LINGOTTO: FUTURISTIC TEST TRACK MANIFESTING NEW VALUES
Public Relations
1400
URBANISATION
1800
1910
AEG Turbinenfabrik, Berlin (1909)
EXPERIMENTAL FACTORY ARCHITECTURE
5 A EG TURBINENFABRIK
1 Floor loops Floor loops
Gravity flow Gravity flow
Processes and business separated on floors FACTORY Processes and business separated on floors BY BEHRENS:
Chutes and lifts moving material and product Chutes and lifts moving material and product
ELEVATION OF TYPOLOGY
Production line Production line
Linear production throughout building Linear production throughout building
The urban factory as representative branding move
6
GRAVITY FLOW
Early 20th century
CHUTES AND SLIDES MOVING MATERIAL Early 20th century
2
3
VERTICAL LINE CONTINUOUS, LINEAR FLOW
Expan dabilit y dabilit y
Expan
Total fl exibilit y exibilit y
Total fl
4
Prod ucti on li CITY-BLOCK neFACTORY c tio W ork ns lih no ep Work flow sho p flo w Prod u
DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM
19401940The competition -- flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap The competition -- flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap
MODIFIED IMAGE SOURCES: BING MAPS 2016 11
Near future Near future Material flow concept - Central logistics core handling all flows Material flow concept - Central logistics core handling all flows
(11) 2003, VW: CLEAN HIGH-TECH IN TRANSPARENT SHELL ‘ (9) 1934, BRICKEN BLDG: TALL MANUFACTURING LOFTS
(8) 1933, STARETT-LEHIGH BLDG: INTEGRATED LOGISTIC TERMINAL (7) 1933, RIVER ROUGE: FORD MOVES ON TO THE SHED MORPHOLOGY
(10) 1980, FANUC MT FUJI: FULLY AUTOMATED PRODUCTION
AGE OF SHEDS
1940
2000
NEAR FUTURE
FIAT
9
CELEBRATING PRODUCT & PROCESS
Floor loops
Production line
Processes and business separated on floors
Linear production throughout building
ow
terial and product
Floor loops
Production line
Processes and business separated on floors
Linear production throughout building
Gravity flow Chutes and lifts moving material and product
THE BRANDING PR FACTORY
11
Early 20th century
FLOOR LOOPS
tury
8
PROCESSES SEPARATED ACROSS FLOORS
Expand
ability
10
Total fle xibilit
y
Expan
7
dabilit
Total fl
y
Produ ctio n lin e Wor ksho p flo w
DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM
exibilit
y
THE ‘SHED’ APPEARS 1940HORIZONTAL LINE
The competition -- flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap
Prod u
FLAT, FLEXIBLE AND EXPANDABLE FLOWS
Work s
ctio
hop
n lin e
Near future Material flow concept - Central logistics core handling all flows
flow
1940-
ward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap
DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM
Near future Material flow concept - Central logistics core handling all flows
12
‘...we are witnessing the end of the machine age - at least on the level of the collective imaginary.’ Vittorio Gregotti, Architecture - Means and Ends (2010)
Discriminating paradigms There seems to exist a paradigm stating that the cities
Richard Florida also argues that “diversity and creativity
of tomorrow needs to be denser, and urban areas more
work together to power innovation and economic growth”.
3
6
mixed in program, or diverse. In effect, this ‘diversity’
As shown by Nina Rappaport in examples from New
typically means combining residential, commercial and
York7, urban clustering of production can allow for industrial
‘public’ space at the scale of the block or building. With
symbiosis through sharing of resources, recycling of goods
‘public’ usually translating to consumtion of goods,
and energy. While the claims to an ‘industrial renaissance’
services or culture, and offices producing information and
in the west seems overblown
ideas - always immaterial - a question might arise: why not
is enjoying an increasing attractiveness. Certain smaller
consider including industry into this paradigm?
businesses employing skilled city-dwellers have no viable
Classic ‘more is more’ notions of urban diversity, such as the ‘ubiquitous principle’ forwarded by Jane Jacobs, seems
8
9,10
, the locally manufactured
alternative habitat other than the city, where the flow of people and ideas are at its most intense.
4
supportive of this. In later works, Jacobs argues that
The potential of an diverse cityscape for both economical
urban heterogeneity ultimately is the source of economic
and sensory stimulation is well established, but the
5
productivity. Along these lines, urban studies theorist
Worker
potential of manufacturing to contribute to this appears
City
Mixed-use qualities Labor division Unskilled labor
Purchasing power
Population boom (Urbanization) Pollution
Increased living standard
Establishment
Early Factory
Zoning codes
GWP boom Fordism
Capitalism Taylorism
Industry
Mass-produced standard product
Policy / market
EXCHANGES, EARLY FACTORY
3. PISKORZ, W., GOULET, R. CITIES OF TOMORROW: CHALLENGES, VISIONS, WAYS FORWARD. BRUSSELS: EC 4. JACOBS, J (1961) DEATH AND LIFE OF GREAT AMERICAN CITIES 5. FAINSTEIN, S. (2005) CITIES AND DIVERSITY. COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 6. FLORIDA (2002) THE RISE OF THE CREATIVE CLASS-REVISITED: REVISED AND EXPANDED 7. RAPAPORT, N. VERTICAL URBAN FACTORY 8.SIRKIN ET AL. (2011) MADE IN AMERICA, AGAIN: WHY MANUFACTURING WILL RETURN TO THE U.S. 9. NAGER, A, AND ATKINSON, R. (2015) THE MYTH OF AMERICA’S MANUFACTURING RENAISSANCE: THE REAL STATE OF U.S. MANUFACTURING. 10. HEYMANN, R., VETTER, S. (2013) EUROPE’S RE-INDUSTRIALISATION: THE GULF BETWEEN ASPIRATION AND REALITY.
13
largely unexplored.
otherness, this thesis argues that the mere addition of
There are of course many causes of the current spatial
another sector to our urban spaces is beneficial through its
organisation of industry. Part of the reasons for the absence
diversifying effect, primarily social and visual. Bringing the
of manufacturing in discussions on densification is likely to
factory worker out of the anemic industrial district and into
be the connotations carried by the word ‘industry’, evoking
the central city would certainly serve to widen the cross-
images of heavy transport, loud and emissive machinery, if
section of people using those urban spaces. Perhaps
not belching chimneys. While this was once often the case,
more interestingly, introducing a prominent factory on
manufacturing has become cleaner, quieter and more
the corner of a shopping street, in a restaurant area or
compact. Final assembly of the Volkswagen Phaeton is
a central business district could provide an unexpected
carried out on wooden floors in what is basically museum
and intriguing break in an all too familiar and predictable
spaces. Certain small-scale manufacturing can be carried
rhythm. In regard to ‘diversity’, it is this potential for visual
out in what is essentially office spaces, completely
spectacle that this thesis focuses on.
inoffensive as neighbours. Whether or not urban industry is brandishing its
Worker
Local skill & innovation
City
Spectacle
Consumer Awareness
Densification
‘Instant’ delivery
Attractive urban workplace
Future Factory
Relocation
Manufacturing base Reindustrialisation
Network exchanges
Print Job
Industry
Incentives Masscustomised quality product
Policy / market
EXCHANGES, FUTURE FACTORY
14
PL EM
INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT INDEX (NAICS) (2012=
18
100
INDE
ED OY
X
102.5 16
CONTINU
OUS OF
F-SHORIN
95
G
14
NS EMPLOYED IN U.S MANUFACTURING SECTOR
105
‘The goal of the future is full unemployment, so we can play.’
90
E” OR
ANC
AISS
“REN
NOT?
12 Arthur C. Clarke
MASSIVE FISCAL SUPPORT & QE
85
2008
2000
10
2012
U.S industrial output and employed, 2000-2014
The fourth revolution While the very tangible machine age of Le Corbusier’s enthusiastic l’Esprit Nouveau may be over, as argued by
80
Vittorio Gregotti11, today’s machines is busier than ever.
70
But industrial output and employment have ‘decoupled’, in
return on capital outpacing growth, famously observed by
50 40 30
13
Thomas Piketty . Productivity and wages are no longer
20
correlated.
10
14
1900
1850
$1.94 TRILLION
ED LOY
OIL CRISIS
EMP
will likely 1950
away old manufacturing structures at an accelerating pace.
CRISIS!
1960
12.3 MILLION
OIL CRISIS
EMP
Joseph Schumpeter’s ‘creative destruction’ is sweeping
$1.94 TRILLION
T
PU
T
U
O
replace traditional manufacturing as we know it today .
16
2000
19.5 MILLION (1977)
15
A widely published study
E
1950
CRISIS!
increasingly
automated and data-intensive manufacturing
UR
ED
and
LT
Distribution ofLABOR U.S labor force by sector 1850-2010 DISTRIBUTION OF U.S FORCE BY SECTOR, 1850-2010
this time is different. There is certainly no shortage of technologies,
CU
19.5 MILLION (1977)
executive summaries on emerging technologies concur: disruptive
RY SIGNIFICANCE?
RI
since antiquity, with ‘sympathy for the luddites’ . The
potentially
UST
AG
Economists like Paul Krugman are acknowledging looming long-term technological unemployment, feared
IND
URBANISATION W W II
The digital age generates
contributing to the trend of
ES
C
VI
R
SE
LOY
‘winner-takes-all-markets’
60 % OF LABOR FORCE
the words of Erik Brynjolfsson.
12
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
U.S industrialPUToutput and employed, 1945-2015 T
U
O
concludes that 47% of U.S jobs
12.3 MILLION
are at high risk in the next decade or two, especially in the manufacturing sector, with the process largely completed in the agricultural. There is of course nothing inherently
1950
1990
110
INDE X
AS
F-SHORIN
G
14
105
85
ED
100
952000
X
18
102.5 T?
NO E” OR
ANC
AISS
“REN
INDE
OY
90
20
G
12
MASSIVE FISCAL SUPPORT & QE OUS OF F-SHORIN 2008 G 2012
CONTINU
16
10
14
U.S INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT AND EMPLOYED, 2000-2014
U.S industrial output and employed, 2000-2014 90
85
E” OR
ANC
AISS
“REN
MASSIVE FISCAL SUPPORT & QE
2008
2000
NOT?
12
10
2012
1800 U.S industrial output and employed, 2000-2014 1800: $175BN $175 bn
00
500500
WORLD GROSS PRODUCT (1990 INTL$)
1000
1000
1500 1500
80
60 % OF LABOR FORCE
IND
W
II
UST
AG
RI
10 50
CU S LT U
ES
SIGNIFICANCE?
C
VI
ER
RE
1950 INDUST
II
1900
W
1850 URBANISATION
W
30
RY
W
20 60
40
ES
C
VI
R
SE
12. BRYNJOLFSSON, E., MCAFEE, A. (2014) THE SECOND MACHINE AGE. 50 13. PIKETTY, T. (2013) CAPITAL IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY 14. KRUGMAN, P. (2013) SYMPATHY FOR THE LUDDITES 40 80 URBANISATION 15. SHIPP, S., ET AL. (2012) EMERGING GLOBAL TRENDS IN ADVANCED MANUFACTURING 16. BENEDIKT FREY, C., OSBORNE, M., (2013) TECHNOLOGY AT WORK 30 70 17. SRNICEK, N, WILLIAMS, A. (2015) INVENTING THE FUTURE: POSTCAPITALISM AND A WORLD WITHOUT WORK % OF LABOR FORCE
2016 2016
Gross world product (1990 intl$)
70
15
1770 1770
OTHERS Offshoots OFFSHOOTS (EG. US) EUROPE Others (eg. US) Europe
INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT INDEX (NAICS) (2012=100)
OUS OF
ASIA Asia
CONTINU
HIN
MILLIONS EMPLOYED IN U.S MANUFACTURING SECTOR
INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT INDEX (NAICS) (2012=100)
16 CR
2014: $77’868BN
102.5
PL
liberated by a largely automated infrastructure.
2014 $77 868 bn
EM
a system where man is
100 110
95
MILLIONS EMPLOYED IN U.S MANUFACTURING SECTOR
their manifesto demands ‘fully
G
18
ED OY
repurposing of technology for socially beneficial and
HIN
105
PL
transformation and destruction of jobs. Arguing the
2010
EM
Alex Williams are advocating an improved pace of this
2000
20
CR
AS
Leftist accelerationists such as Nick Srnicek and
automated luxury communism’,
1980
U.S industrial output and employed, 1945-2015
tended to overshadow the utopian.
17
1970
U.S INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT AND EMPLOYED, 1945-2015
bad about this shift, but the dystopian implications has
emancipatory ends,
1960
RY
2000 SIGNIFICANCE?
Distribution of U.S labor force by sector 1850-2010
MATERIALS
HOME
MATERIALS
HOME
HOME
HOME PRINT SHOP
HOME HOME
HOME
HOME
HOME
HOME
HOME
HOME
EXECUTIVE MANUFACTURING PRODUCT DISTRIBUTION
HOME HOME
PRINT SHOP EXECUTIVE MANUFACTURING HOME PRODUCT DISTRIBUTION
HOME HOME
HOME HOME
MARKET HOME
Such a system seems to imply centrally organised
18
Print shop - decentralized additive manufacturing TOMORROW’S AM Consumer-driven organization CONVENTIONAL MASS PRODUCTION
the ‘long tail’ of demand through mass customization.
Open-source soft- and hardware and decentralization of
SCALE OF PRODUCTION RUN
manufacturing could complement Marx’s ‘owning’ with
Pr
HIGH
production in the hands of the consumers. EARLY AM
Indeed, consumer-oriented 3D printing service bureaus
LOW PRODUCTIVITY PRODUCTIVITY HIGH
LINE
BREAK-EVEN POINT is CURRENT becoming more and more accessible, and industrial TODAY’S AM
UNIT COST
F
Additive Manufacturing vs conventional Mass Production ECONOMIES SCALE: ADDITIVE VS CONVENTIONAL Economies of OF scale
‘renting’ in a democratizing way, putting the means of
EARLY AM
‘print shops’ are contributing further to the atomisation
FLEXIBLE LINE MANUFACTURING SYSTEM
MATERIAL
CURRENT BREAK-EVEN POINT of the manufacturing supply chain. This move from TODAY’S AM
UNIT COST
PRODUCTIVITY
TODAY’S AM Print shop - decentralized additive manufacturing Consumer-driven organization
LOW
revolutionary potential of the ‘Maker Movement’ to serve
MARKET
CURRENT BREAK-EVEN POINT
UNIT COST
former Wired editor Chris Anderson stresses the
AM large, self-sufficient enterprises toTOMORROW’S networks of smaller CONVENTIONAL MASS PRODUCTION
actors SCALE is likely to be boosted by autonomous transport, OF PRODUCTION RUN
NATURE
FLEXIBLE JOB SHOP WASTE / AM MATERIAL MANUFACTURING SYSTEM LABOR MANYPRODUCT WORKERPARTS PER SYSTEM MANUFACTURING
FEW
WAGE
Productivity vs Flexiblility
TOMORROW’S AM CONVENTIONAL MASS PRODUCTION
LOW
logistics,
architect SCALE SamOF Jacobs the spatial networks PRODUCTIONreferences RUN
Additive conventional Mass Production of Manufacturing contemporaryvs battlefields, describing the Economies of scale
HOME
EARLY AM
manufacturing. On the other end, praising decentralization,
Additive Manufacturing vs Speculating conventional Mass Production especially by air. on the future of Economies of scale
HOME
HIGH
HOME HOME
FEW
CAPITAL INTEREST
MANY
PARTS PER SYSTEM
FINANCE
Productivity vs Flexiblility
future
CONSUMER
PRICE
JOB SHOP / AM
MONETARY
PRODUCTIVITY VS FLEXIBILITY
‘smart city’ as an ‘automation and regulation of flow’ with ‘devices, machines, buildings, infrastructure in constant
19 information-jabber aimed at optimised efficiency’. MATERIAL NATURE
Material and monetary processes
During
the fourth industrial revolution, it appears the city itself is
increasingly MATERIAL
turning into manufacturing infrastructure.
NATURE PRODUCT WORKER MANUFACTURING As manufacturers move from specializedCONSUMER equipment LABOR
PRICE
WAGE
COGNITIVE
to
WASTE
MATERIAL WASTE generic platforms, CAPITAL the factory becomes more universal INTEREST
REPAIR
printers and robots are needed, besides the occasional
USE
MANUAL
FINANCE
MONETARY human.
CALCULATION, RECORD-KEEPING PROCESSING CUSTOMER SERVICE PICKING / SORTING REPETITIVE ASSEMBLY SUBSTANTIAL SUBSTITION
MANUAL
FINANCE
conclusion, this would imply that only 3D CAPITAL INTEREST
Factories would be platforms themselves,
SUBSTANTIAL SUBSTITION
OUTSOURCING PICKING / SORTING REPETITIVE ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY
SUBSTANTIAL SUBSTITION
Material and monetary processes
FORMING / TESTING HYPOTHESES MEDICAL / LEGAL DIAGNOSIS
COMPLEMENTARY
FORMING / TESTING HYPOTHESES ADJUST MEDICAL / LEGAL DIAGNOSIS JANITORIAL SERVICES CHANGING ENVIRONMENTS COMPLEMENTARY
MEASUR
STRONG COMPLEMENTARY
EVALUATE JANITORIAL SERVICES CHANGING ENVIRONMENTS
DESIGN IMPLEMENT
STRONG COMPLEMENTARY
Production calibration
AUTOMATION AL, 2003) Typical andPOTENTIAL desireable(AUTOR productET flows
only distinguished by the scale of equipment. Rapid
ASSESS PROBLEM
NON-ROUTINE
SUBSTANTIAL SUBSTITION
COGNITIVE
WORKER MANUFACTURING CONSUMER and reconfigurable. In the more distant future, taken to PRICE WAGE MONETARY its ultimate
CALCULATION, RECORD-KEEPING CUSTOMER SERVICE MATERIAL ROUTINE EXTRACTION
END OF LIFE
PRODUCT
LABOR
NON-ROUTINE
ROUTINE
MATERIAL WASTE
changeovers would provide total flexibility and scalability.
Material and monetary processes
Trucks produced one week, helicopters the next. This is MATERIAL EXTRACTION
MATERIALS
ASSESS PROBLEM
PLAN DEPT.
not the scenario for the Corner Factory, set in a much
WASTE
closer END OF LIFEfuture. PROCESSING WASTE
REPAIR
ADJUST
MATERIAL EXTRACTION
END OF LIFE USE
PROCESSING OUTSOURCING
HOME MARKET
HOME
LOCAL / REGIONAL
DESIGN
EVALUATE
Production calibration
Typical and desireable product flows ASSEMBLY
SUB-CONTRACTOR 1
HOME
CHEAP OCEAN CARGO
WORKER EXECUTES
SUB-S
SUB-CONTRACTOR 2
SUB-S
SUB-S
SUB-CONTRACTOR 3
EXECUTIVE MANUFACTURING TOYOTA LEAN - WORKER-DRIVEN, “KAIZEN” PRODUCT DISTRIBUTION HOME SPOTTING DESIGN POTENTIAL
SUB-SUB-CO
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
SUB-CONTRACTOR 4
Improvement philosophies
HOME
IMPLEMENT
HOME
(FINAL ASSEMBLY) SPOTTING DESIGN QUALITY CONTROL HOME POTENTIAL PROCESSED TAYLORISM - SCIENTIFIC MANAGEMENT, TOP-DOWN PACKAGING ORDER CUSTOMER CARE PRINT SHOP
ORDER / DEMAND
HOME
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
TAYLORISM - SCIENTIFIC MANAGEMENT, TOP-DOWN PLAN PARENT HOME FACILITY
DEPT.
PRODUCT
IMPLEMENT OUTSOURCING
USE
MEASURE
MEASURE DESIGN
ADJUST EVALUATE
ASSEMBLY REPAIR
ASSESS PROBLEM
WORKER EXECUTES
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
HOME TOYOTA LEAN - WORKER-DRIVEN, “KAIZEN” HOME
HOME
Globally outsourced supply chain Production calibration Improvement philosophies
Typical and desireable product flows
MARKET SUB-CONTRACTOR 1 PARENT FACILITY
MARKET
PRODUCT
PARENT FACILITY
LOCAL / REGIONAL
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
VALUE-ADDING
CUTTING
WELDING
DRILLING COATING
PRODUCT ORDER / DEMAND
(FINAL ASSEMBLY) QUALITY CONTROL PACKAGING CUSTOMER CARE
ORDER CHEAP OCEAN CARGO
PROCESSED
ASSEMBLY
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
CHEAP OCEAN
Print shop - decentralized additive manufacturing VALUE-ADDING CUTTING WELDING DRILLING organization
CARGO REVOLUTIONSUB-CONTRACTOR 2 18. ANDERSON, C. (2012)(FINAL MAKERS: THE NEW INDUSTRIAL ASSEMBLY) Consumer-driven SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR QUALITY CONTROL 19. JACOBS, S. (2015) MACHINES OF LOVING GRACEPROCESSEDSUB-CONTRACTOR 1 ORDER / DEMAND SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR PACKAGING CUSTOMER CARE
MARKET
PRINT SHOP MODEL
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
SUB-CONTRACTOR 3 SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR SUB-CONTRACTOR 2
SUB-CONTRACTOR 4 ORDER
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
SUB-CONTRACTOR 3 SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
WASTE
CHANGEOVER
DOWNTIME
TRANSPORT
COATING
TRANSPORT
ASSEMBLY
16
STORAGE
SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR GLOBAL SUB-SUB-CONTRACTOR
WASTE
CHANGEOVER
DOWNTIME
TRANSPORT
TRANSPORT
STORAGE
Work and play As a ‘first step’ of the ‘robot replace human’ programme at Changying Precision, producing cell phone components, 20
90% of the human workforce was replaced with robots . The result was a three-fold productivity increase with far higher accuracy. The remaining people merely control and monitor production. Is this supervisory role the human element in future factories? As the trend towards shorter product cycles and mass customization continues, the reprogramming of machines is one of the tasks that will require human input for a long time to come. The calibration and configuration of functions is probably the area where most factory work ‘on the floor’ will occur. This field could be described as ‘robot farming, where workers
instruct
increasingly
dexterous
‘cobots’
-
collaborative robots - like animals on a farm. When numeric, this programming was time-consuming and required a high level of expertise. With a new breed of anthropomorphic machines like ReThink’s Baxter, ABB’s YuMi or KUKA’s IIWA, the input can be haptic, with human instructors physically guiding the robot ‘hand’ to record a motion. These machines are basically harmless and easily moved. It isn’t hard imagining their descendants learning
#1, ~1770
SHIFT TECHNOLOGICAL DISRUPTION
LOCATION LOGIC FACILITY PLACEMENT
OBJECTIVE MAJOR DESIGN CONSIDERATION
FACTORY BUILDING CHARACTERISTICS
a task by watching, or perhaps even being told what to do. Linking the physical factory with a digital environment manipulated by ‘factory workers’ through virtual reality is another possible interface for man through which to ‘farm’ robotic labor. Fordism is a thing of the past: tomorrow’s factory worker is likely to be well educated, live in a city and want personal self-fulfilment through his or her work. Commuting to a suburban industrial district, far removed from a variety of lunch spots, is unlikely to appeal to this individual. In a future such as the one imagined by Srnicek and Williams, where most dull and monotonous tasks are automated, some of what still classifies as ‘work’ could be highly advanced forms of playful instruction of machines. This machine ‘teaching’ is anticipated by philosopher Vilém Flusser (1920-1991) in the essay Die Fabrik, where he presents a vision of the replacement of homo faber (making man) with homo ludens (playing man) in 21
post-industrial society.
together with the apparatus, new programs being the outcome of ‘playful’ processes.
#2, ~1890
#3, ~1970
#4, ONGOING
STEAM POWER
ELECTRIFICATION
DIGITALISM
AI, AM, IOT ETC
FORCE MULTIPLIER SUPERCHARGING INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT
MASS PRODUCTION-ENABLING DISPERSION OF WORKSTATIONS
ACCELERATING AUTOMATION BY IT AND ELECTRONICS
AUTOMATION APPROACHING FULL POTENTIAL
CITY
CITY / ZONE
ZONE
CITY / ZONE
CLOSE TO WORKERS AND RESOURCES - IN CITIES
VERTICAL INTEGRATION MAKING SOME INDUSTRY SELF-SUFFICIENT
COMPLEX SUPPLY CHAINS DISPERSING MANUFACTURING
HUMANS MAINLY WORK IN CITIES, ROBOTS ANYWHERE
POWER DISTRIBUTION
MASS PRODUCTION
FLEXIBILITY
INDUSTRY 4.0
MECHANICAL FORCE TRANSFER FAVORING COMPACTNESS
BUILDING TAYLORISM, PROJECTING IMAGE
EASY EXPANSION, SPACIOUS HOUSING OF PRODUCTION LINE
EFFICIENCY, NETWORKING, ADAPTABILITY, PUBLIC RELATIONS
MULTI-STOREY
MIXED
SHED
MIXED
COMPACT BRICK MILLS DRIVING URBANISATION
COMPANY EXPRESSION, VERTICALITY, CONCRETE GRIDS
FLAT FLOWS, EXPANDABLE, CHEAP, SHEET METAL
COMPACT, URBAN FACTORIES ARE FEASIBLE AND DESIREABLE
REVOLUTIONS
21. ECONOMIC TIMES INDIA: CHINA SETS UP FIRST UNMANNED FACTORY; ALL PROCESSES ARE OPERATED BY ROBOTS 22. HARDENS, T. (2010) VILÉM FLUSSER AND TECHNICS − FROM HOMO FABER TO HOMO LUDEN
17
Speculating on the resemblence
of future factories to schools, his factory worker learns
Logistics Spacious assembly line Easy expansion
Modernistic function separation
Theory
“Polluting eye-sores�
Heavy transport
Car-based planning
Taylorism
Self-sufficiency
Preconceptions Globalization
Ocean cargo
Cheap overseas labor
Bulky Fossible Noisy
Rigid
Cheap overseas pollution
Dirty
Technology
Start here
Consumism Fordism Cheap land
Economy
Vertical City-Factory
Sprawling Sheds
Arrive
Theory Consumer Awareness Education
Clean Flexible
Current state
DensiFication
Logistics Renindustrialisation
Wider Diversity Paradigm
Meeting enabling Just-in-time
Maker Movement
Can do better
Close to customer Industrial Symbiosis Drones
Labor cost share drop
Compact R&D
Deep learning User-friendly
Technology
PR Value Mass custom Accessible & democratizing
Manufacturing base value
Recruiting skilled citydwellers
Economy
THESIS / ARGUMENT: RETURN OF THE URBAN FACTORY
18
Process Future factories will of course come in many forms, scales and places. Likewise, the design proposal was naturally
Human Presence
never supposed to be an exhaustive physical summary of
The urban factory cannot be a lights-out robotic
this vast field. Instead, the aim was rather the translating of
operation - it is justified by human presence.
fairly abstract aspects into a specific vehicle for an idea, or thesis: the return of the vertical urban factory. Evoking images of the local, accessible and urban, the project title chosen for this facility was Corner Factory.
Human Presence The urban factory cannot be a lights-out robotic operation - it is justified by human presence.
Criteria Five points or key issues for this specific future factory
Human Presence Compact & Vertical The urban factory cannot be a lights-out robotic In marked contrast to its sprawling suburban peers, the operation - it is justified by human presence. urban factory increases city density by verticality.
were identified and outlined in the bullet points below.
Human The Corner Factory cannot be a lights-out robotic operation
Human Presence Compact & Vertical The urban factory cannot be a lights-out robotic In marked contrast to its sprawling suburban peers, the operation - it is justified by human presence. urban factory increases city density by verticality.
- it is justified by human presence.
Compact
Human Presence Compact Vertical Clean &&Silent The urban factory cannot be a lights-out robotic In marked contrast to employing its sprawling peers, the Used by light industry thesuburban latest technologies, operation - it is justified by human presence. urban factoryfactory increases density by verticality. the urban is ancity agreeable neighbour.
In marked contrast to its sprawling suburban peers, the Corner Factory increases city density by verticality.
Clean & Silent
Compact & Vertical Clean & Silent In marked contrast to its sprawling suburban peers, the Used by light industry employing the latest technologies, urban factory increases city density by verticality. the urban factory is an agreeable neighbour.
Used by light industry employing the latest technologies, the Corner Factory is an agreeable neighbour.
Accessible
Compact & Vertical Clean & Silent Accessible & empowering In marked contrast to its sprawling suburban peers, the Used by light industry employing the latest technologies, Enabling curious consumers to become fabricators, the urban factory increases city density by verticality. the urban factory is an agreeable neighbour. urban factory manufactures entrepreneurs.
Enabling curious consumers to become fabricators, the Corner Factory manufactures entrepreneurs.
Transparent
Clean & Silent Accessible & empowering Used by light industry employing the latest technologies, Enabling curious consumers to become fabricators, the the urban factory is an agreeable neighbour. urban factory manufactures entrepreneurs.
The Corner Factory celebrates manufacturing itself, advertising its dazzling processes to an general public.
OPPOSITE: STUDY MODELS
Clean & Silent Accessible & empowering Transparent & exciting Used by light industry employing the latest technologies, Enabling curious consumers to become fabricators, the The urban the factory celebrates advertising its urban factory ismanufacturing an agreeable itself, neighbour. urban factory manufactures entrepreneurs. dazzling processes to an general public.
19
Accessible & empowering Transparent & exciting Enabling curious consumers to become fabricators, the The urban factory celebrates manufacturing itself, advertising its
20
Conceptual collages After a lot of research and no design, a few sketchy collages depicting ideas about the athmosphere of the main space types were put together.
LOBBY
21
FACTORY SPACE
22
CORE
23
Future context A city with a rich industrial heritage, Gothenburg was as natural a testing ground as any. The area finally selected was Gullbergsvass, as the riverfront is historically intimately connected with the city’s harbour industry. This district is also set to take on an increasingly strategic position in the long term development of central Gothenburg. Currently occupied to a large extent by heavy infrastructure, it is planned to be transformed into a dense neighbourhood. Adjacent to the envisioned RegionCity high-rise development around the central station, featuring skyscrapers of about 23
120 metres , the projected neighbouring building scales is accomodating to a large, vertical factory.
FUTURE CONTEXT MODEL NEXT SPREAD: GULLBERGSVASS, CURRENT (BING MAPS 2016) AND FUTURE SITUATION 23. WSP., WHAT!. (2015) PLANERINGSUNDERLAG: HÖGA HUS, CENTRALENOMRÅDET
24
25
26
Development analysis Gullbergsvass is arguably the most significant development area in the whole of Gothenburg. There is enormous potential here, in the absolute city center, which makes it extra important to get it right. Eliminating barriers caused by heavy infrastructure, without cumbersome overdeckings, and achieving a dense urban fabric of diverse use is of utmost importance. Shown below are a synthesis of 24,25,26
various planning documents and studies
, combined
and slightly modified. This imagined development forms the future urban context for the building proposal.
24. SBK GÖTEBORG. (2014) CENTRALENOMRÅDET: STADSUTVECKLINGSPROGRAM 1.0 25. CITY PLANNING OFFICE, GÖTEBORG. (2013) SAMRÅDSHANDLING: DETALJPLAN FÖR BRO ÖVER GÖTA ÄLV 26. SPACESCAPE, WEST8, WHITE. (2013) QUEENS PARK: CENTRAL STATION AREA PARALELL STUDY
27
SITE ANALYSIS (INTERVENTION IN BLACK)
28
Logistics
Morphology
Fundamental to the operation of any factory is the
With the surrounding parameters set, a set of possible
conventient flow in and out of the facility. Therefore, the site
building volumes were quickly and heuristically explored
chosen was close to existing heavy infrastructure. Ideally
(opposite page). Meaning little as forms in themselves,
submerged, this highway could be accessed by delivery
especially set in an arbitrary immediate context, the final
trucks (probably automated) by a likewise underground
building envelope would depend on the functions within.
loading bay.
Working within the most generic boundary possible, a
The factory would be be a plug-in unit into a larger network
square, the process went on. In the end, the building volume
of manufacturing spread across the city, a constant flow
was a simple extrusion of this footprint to a appropriate
of material and goods passing unnoticably in and out of
height. Avoiding a discussion of local urban adaption and
the facility in a dense city context. It is possible to imagine
for argument's sake streamlining the project to focus on
this underbround artery serving as an organising logistical
content and program, this choice of a very simple volume
spine at the urban level, forming a line or factory row along
was deemed the most appropriate strategy.
which to string functions requiring frequent and heavy transport.
A manufactured object for the manufacture of objects, the Corner Factory is an autonomous architecture that could exist in a number of places. It is is not tied to its site, but
+
=
depends primarily on a convenient logistical connection. This is not to say it is autistic to its surroundings. The city-block in question also contains the landmark building Pagoden, a monumental former tobacco warehouse. Likewise, the Corner Factory is also a building with monumental properties, possibly viewed separated from any context.
Unit
Island
Archipe
lago
LOGISTIC CONNECTION TO UNDERGROUND HIGHWAY 29
Autonomous architecture with integrity after separation AUTONOMOUS UNIT IN CITY-FABRIC
Current state
Closed perimeter block - 12m depth Current state
Knot Knot block block Knot Knotblock block Rising towards corner
ClosedNarrow perimeter block - 12m depth Narrow lots lots Narrow Narrow lots lots Irregular stacking
Power plant massing Narrow Narrow stacking stacking Narrow Narrowstacking stacking
Two Two lots lots Current state Two lotsmassing Two lots Power plant Rising towards corner
Knot block Narrow Narrow and and low low Current state Rising towards corner Narrow and Narrow andlow low Prism Irregular stacking
Narrow lots Squeezed slab Squeezed slab Rising towards corner Irregular stacking Squeezed Squeezedslab slab
Prism
Narrow stacking Irregular stacking
Knot block Closed perimeter block - 12m depth
++ tower Podium tower ClosedPodium perimeter block - 12m depth Podium ++lots tower Podium tower Narrow Power plant massing
lots object Discrete object Closed Discrete perimeter block - 12m depth PowerTwo plant massing Discrete object Discrete object Narrow stacking Prism
Narrow and low Raised portal Raised portal Power plant massing Prism Raised Raisedportal portal
Squeezed Prism slab
Two lots Knot block
Podium + tower Two lots
Knot block Narrow and low Narrow lots
Two lots Discrete object Narrow and low
Podium +lots tower Knot block Narrow Squeezed slab Narrow stacking
Two lots Narrow and low Raised portal Squeezed slab
Discrete object Narrow lots Narrow stacking
Narrow and slab low Squeezed
Raised portal Narrow stacking
Squeezed slab
MORPHOLOGICAL HEURISTICS 30
Use In a future economy characterised by more sharing, various user models could be concieved. For instance, as part of the infrastructure, a service bureau operating a ‘print shop’ for additive manufacturing is imagined as a permanent tenant in the building. Naturally it would strive for maximum use of its machines. In pursuit of this, excess capacity could be offered to outside industry, printed parts delivered just-in-time to meet peaks in demand. Most of the building floor area was decided to consist of
FOR THE MANUFACTURER
FA C T O RY S PA C E QUALITY CAPITAL & SPACE AVAILABLE RAPID PROTOTYPING & SHORT LOOPS SMART, NIMBLE & SAFE ROBOTS COMPETITIVE LOCATION & LOGISTICS LEASING OPTIONS
generic loft space, reminiscent of the manufacturing lofts of the Garment District skyscrapers of the 20's. These areas would basically be industrial halls, bright and spacious, tall
FOR THE ‘MAKER’
enough to comfortably fit mezzanine floors in. Available for long-time leases, these stacked halls or sheds are the essential factory space.
PUBLIC WORKSHOP ACCESSIBLE EQUIPMENT PERSONAL PROJECTS & REPAIRS PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT EMPOWERING INCUBATOR MEMBERSHIP OPTIONS
FOR THE CONSUMER & OUTSIDE INDUSTRY
PRINT SHOP LARGE CAPACITY SERVICE BUREAU SELECT, UPLOAD OR SCAN OBJECT AGILE MEETING OF EXTRA DEMAND WIDE RANGE OF PREMIUM MATERIALS PAY PER CM
3
BASIC DIVIDE, FIRST DRAFT
Grundläggande programidé - fabrikens 3 delar
31
Users In conversation with a property development consultant, a ‘factory hotel’ model was devised. Like in an office hotel, certain amenities and infrastructure would be provided. For the sake of detail and specificity, four synergetic tenants are imagined, cherry-picked for exposing the various themes previously discussed. The Aerospace Company As part of a larger supply chain, a smaller aircraft engine model is manufactured in the bulk of the buildings spaces. A high-tech, low-run product still relying on plenty of human input, it is a spectacular artifact in itself. Final assembly is carried out in the lower, more robust floors, exposed to the city. The many small parts are provided by the in-house print shop, precision assembly by a fleet of mobile robotic arms. The Service Bureau An integral part of the facility, the service bureau operates an array of 3D printers, in close collaboration with other tenants. Using electron beam melting, various sintering techniques, fused deposition and stereolithography, all materials and finishes can be accomodated. The Drone Startup A growing drone service operates the air delivery terminal. Finetuning a standardised mass production process, the finished drones are put directly into service delivering printouts from the service bureau, or delivered as products in themselves. The Public Workshop At the top floor, a public workshop makes the translation of ideas into objects possible for the ordinary consumer. On a day pass or membership basis, quality equipment and and expertise is easily accessible.
USE & USERS
32
Program Following the defining of use and users, the functional program was sketched out in a program draft. The stacking of these spaces were continously evaluated and reconfigured, resulting in the opposite program diagram.
Public areas Public areas Public areas Public areas
Air cargo Air cargo Auditorium Auditorium Air cargo Air cargo Auditorium Auditorium
Manufacturing Manufacturing Manufacturing Manufacturing
00 m (52Manufacturing 0mManufacturing 2 2 / Manufacturing + mManufacturing ezza floor nine s)
Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing
~48
Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop
Public
Public Workshop Public Workshop Public Workshop Public Workshop Print shop Print shop Print shop Print shop Street Street Street Street
BASIC DIVIDE Basic divide Basic divide Basic divide Basic divide
Hall Hall
HallTerraceTerrace Air Cargo Air Cargo Air Cargo HallTerraceTerrace Air Cargo Office hotels Office hotels Office hotels Office hotels
Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing
Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop Exposition Exposition Exposition Exposition
Events Events Events Events
Lobby Lobby Lobby Lobby
Print shop Print shop Print shop Print shop
stacking GeneralGeneral stacking GeneralGeneral stacking stacking
HallTerraceTerrace Air Cargo Air Cargo Air Cargo HallTerraceTerrace Air Cargo
Print Print Print Print shop shop shop shop
Lobby Lobby Lobby Lobby
Logistics Logistics Logistics Logistics
59m (7/14 fl oo 2 base rs, ments )
Facto ry
Hotel
2600 m
2
Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop Public workshop Office hotels Office hotels Office hotels Office hotels
Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing Light manufacturing
Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Heavy machinery Exposition Exposition Exposition Exposition
Events Events Events Events
AM & AA Reception Reception AM & AA AM & AA Reception Reception AM & AA
Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries
Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries
*Additive manufacturing *Additive and automated manufacturing assembly and automated assembly
op
Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries Quay QuayE45 Packaging Packaging Deliveries Deliveries Quay QuayE45
Reception Reception AM & AA* AM & AA* Reception AM & AA* AM & AA* Reception
FurtherFurther divisions divisions FurtherFurther divisions divisions
Street Street Street Street
INITIAL STACKING
Hall Hall
works h
Public Workshop Public Workshop Public Workshop Public Workshop
Public workshop Public workshop on top on top Public workshop on top on top Public workshop
Fixed Fixed Free Free Free Free Fixed Fixed space space systems systems space space systems systems lobby, lobby, logistics, logistics, lobby, lobby, logistics, logistics, workshops, workshops, heavy heavy workshops, workshops, heavy heavy office hotel, office hotel, machines, machines, office hotel, office hotel, machines, machines,
Lobby
Manu
factur ing Sh
op
Techn i
cal
2Free Freedivision / fixed division 3m / fixed Free / fixed Freedivision / fixed division
*Additive manufacturing *Additive and automated manufacturing assembly and automated assembly
FURTHER DIVISIONS
33
PUBLIC WORKSHOP ON TOP
FINAL PROGRAM, SIZE
23m
E45 E45
PUBLIC WORKSHOP
~520 m
Emissive machinery
2
FLOORS 2-6
Auditorium
Workplaces
AUTOMATED STORAGE & RETRIEVAL SYSTEM
- LOGISTICAL CORE
FACTORY HOTEL
~2600 m
2
FLOORS 2-6
Office hotel
R&D
XS-S Assembly
Planning
Dual-arm cobots
Service bureau Robot farms
Meeting areas
M-L Assembly AGV’s + 6-axis arms
Drone hub
LOBBY
Build space
~520 m
Pick-ups
FLOOR 0
Reception
MANUFACTURING SHOP Additive
2
Subtractive
Stereolithograpy
CNC Milling
Fused deposition
Wire EDM
Laser sintering
Injection moulding
~520 m
Exposition
2
FLOOR -1
Deliveries
Loading bay
E-beam melting Deburring Heat treatment Coatings Powder recovery Packeting UV oven
Quality control
Chem baths
FINAL PROGRAM 34
MATERIAL “SQUARE”
Principle
TION 1
ON-SITE RECYCLING RAW MATERIAL
TION 3
DELIVERY
FUNCTION 2
Production line nal” product workshop Process flow principle ow with central material “square” IN IN
OUT OUT
PROCESSING
ASSEMBLY
STORAGE IN OUT PACKAGE STORAGE
Process flow studies
DELIVERIES
PRE-”CUSTOMIZED” TOOLING
ASSEMBLY
FUNCTION 4 FUNCTION 4
IN
SUBWORK MATERIAL “SQUARE” MATERIAL “SQUARE” ASSEMBLY
IN
SUBWORK
FUNCTION 4 STATION 4
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
SUBWORK SUBWORK
FUNCTION
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
Production line PRODUCTION LINE PRINCIPLE Production line Process flow principle RAW MATERIAL Process flow principle RAW MATERIAL
PRODUCT PRODUCT RAW MATERIAL
STORAGE DELIVERY STORAGE
PRODUCT
STORAGE
MATERIAL DEPOSITING
MATERIAL STORAGE
DELIVERY
PREPARE MATERIAL DEPOSITING ON-SITE RECYCLING MATERIAL
(OUTSOURCING) DELIVERY
SUBWORK SUBWORK STATION 1 STATION 1
STATION 2 STATION 2
PRODUCT SUBWORK FINISHINGSUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK INSPECT
DEPOSIT MATERIAL PACKAGE DELIVERY PACKAGE
PART FINISHING
DEPOSIT MATERIAL
PART FINISHING WAREHOUSE SRS SRS
SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK STATION 2
STATION 3
STATION 4 SUBWORK
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
QUALITY CONTROL
PACKAGE SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK
PRODUCT STORAGE
PRODUCT
PACKAGE
MATERIAL MATERIAL
Additive manufacturing PART FABRICATION Simple / total processTRUCK flow PART FABRICATION FLAT PACKAGING FLAT PACKAGING
35
TRUCK
END USER FLAT PACK
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
PRODUCT Additive manufacturing with assembly SUBWORK Process flow with possibly multi-material machinery SUBWORK
INSPECTION
FINAL ASSEMBLY
CLIENT ORDER
PRODUCTION PLANNING
MOBILE FABRICATION UNIT HUB
DISPATCHED FABRICATION UNIT
BUILD SITE
MATERIAL
FLAT PACKAGING
TRUCK
FINISHING FINISHING
QUALITY QUALITY CONTROL CONTROL
PACKAGE PACKAGE
PRODUCT PRODUCT
MARKET MARKET IN
OUT
MATERIAL DELIVERIES ASSEMBLY
MARKET
FUNCTION 4
PACKAGE
Job shop CAD MODEL JOB SHOP PRINCIPLE Process flowMODEL CAD
FINAL FINAL ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY
END USER FLAT PACK
CLIENT ORDER CLIENT ORDER
FUNCTION 3
INSPECT
MOBILE DISPATCHED PRODUCTION BUILD MATERIAL MOBILE DISPATCHED FABRICATION FABRICATION PRODUCTION BUILD Additive manufacturing with assembly PLANNING SITE MATERIAL FABRICATION FABRICATION UNIT HUB UNIT PLANNING SITE UNIT HUB UNIT Process flow with possibly multi-material machinery DESTINATION ORDER DESTINATION ORDER
Mobile on-site fabrication unit CAD MODEL Mobile on-site fabrication unitmanipulator Deliverable general purpose MATERIAL MOBILE DELIVERY DISPATCHED RAW MATERIAL Deliverable general purpose manipulator PRODUCTION FINAL STORAGE
ASSEMBLY
CLIENT ORDER
PLANNING
FABRICATION UNIT HUB
MATERIAL “SQU
ASSEMBLY
Process flow with possibly multi-material machinery Process flow with possibly multi-material machinery
INSPECT
WAREHOUSE
MATERIAL
Mobile on-site fabrication unit Deliverable general purpose manipulator
ON-SITE RECYCLING
(OUTSOURCING)
“Ikea” model - end user assembly “Ikea” model end user assembly Process flow-principle Process flow principle PART FABRICATION
BUILD SITE
DESTINATION ORDER
CUSTOMIZATION CUSTOMIZATION DISPATCHED FABRICATION UNIT
END USER END USER FLAT PACK FLAT PACK
ASSEMBLY
CAD MODEL
- TOTAL FLOW WAREHOUSE WAREHOUSE
MARKET
SUBWORK
ASSEMBLY QUALITY PREPARE PART MATERIAL DEPOSIT MATERIAL DEPOSITING FINISHING PACKAGE RAW MATERIAL PRODUCT DELIVERY CONTROL FINISHING PART MATERIAL STORAGE DEPOSIT MATERIAL DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL FINISHING STORAGE MATERIAL DELIVERY Mobile on-site fabrication unit RAW MATERIALON-SITE ASSEMBLY - DELIVERABLE ALL-PURPOSE MANIPULATOR ASSEMBLY DELIVERY PRODUCT RAW MATERIAL DEPOSIT DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL ASSEMBLY CUSTOMIZATION PRODUCT FINISHING general purposePRODUCT manipulator STORAGE DEPOSIT MATERIAL PRODUCT Deliverable PART STORAGE DEPOSIT PRODUCT FINISHING STORAGE manufacturing, flow MATERIAL generic PRODUCT Additive PART FINISHING STORAGE DEPOSIT MATERIAL FINISHING MATERIAL Process flow principle PACKAGE INSPECT PACKAGE INSPECT INSPECT PACKAGE FUNCTION 1 INSPECT PACKAGE FUNCTION DEPOSIT 4 PART FINISHING MATERIAL DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL Additive manufacturing PRODUCT DEPOSIT Additive PRODUCT FINISHING STORAGE MATERIAL PRODUCT Simple /manufacturing total process flow STORAGE PART DEPOSIT Additive manufacturing with assembly FUNCTION 3 Simple / total process flow FINISHING MATERIAL Additive manufacturing with assembly FUNCTION 2
(OUTSOURCING) (OUTSOURCING) ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
MARKET
INSPECT PACKAGE INSPECTION STATION 5INSPECTION STATION 6 STATION 7
ASSEMBLY
ON-SITE RECYCLING PREPARE MATERIAL MATERIAL DEPOSITING PREPARE MATERIAL MATERIAL STORAGE MATERIAL DEPOSITING MATERIAL STORAGE CAD MODEL
DESTINATION ORDER
PACKAGE
PACKAGING
“Ikea” model - end user assembly Process flow principle Additive manufacturing with assembly SRS Process flow with possibly multi-material machinery ON-SITE RECYCLING
MOBILE FABRICATION UNIT HUB
QUALITY CONTROL
SUBWORKSUBWORK SUBWORK
INSPECT
PACKAGE
Additive manufacturing, generic flow PRODUCTION FINAL CLIENT ORDER Additive flow PLANNING ASSEMBLY Processmanufacturing, flow principle generic Process flow principle
Principle
STATION 4 STATION 5 STATION 6 STATION 7 PART DEPOSIT STATION 4 STATION 5 STATION 6 STATION 7 FINISHING MATERIAL DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK PRODUCT STORAGE PRODUCT PART DEPOSIT SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK PRODUCT FINISHING MATERIAL SUBWORK SUBWORK
IKEA MODEL - END USER ASSEMBLY
DELIVERY DELIVERY
STORAGE PRODUCT MARKET Flow groups on logistical axis STORAGE PRODUCT MARKET
STATION 3 STATION 3
PACKAGING MARKET PREPARE PRODUCT STATION 1 PACKAGING MATERIAL
STORAGE
PRODUCT Driven Line with sub-stations STORAGE PART FABRICATION DEPOSIT “Fishbone” process flow MATERIAL TRUCK FLAT PACKAGING MATERIAL
RAW MATERIAL RAW MATERIAL
PACKAGE PACKAGE
FINISHING
SUBWORK
RAW MATERIAL
Flow groups on logistical axis Flow groups on logistical axis Principle Principle
PREPARECUSTOMIZATION PROCESSING ASSEMBLY MATERIAL SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORKPRE-”CUSTOMIZED” TOOLING SUBWORK SUBWORK SUBWORK
MATERIAL STORAGE
manufacturing Driven Line Additive with sub-stations Driven Line with sub-stations PRODUCTION LINE WITH SUBSTATIONS - 'FISHBONE FLOW' Simple /flow total process flow “Fishbone” process “Fishbone” process flow
ZATION
PRODUCT
Sequential flow groups
INSPECTION “Functional” product workshop ON-SITE RECYCLING ON-SITE RECYCLING Process flow with central material “square” QUALITY PREPARE PROCESSING ASSEMBLY QUALITY CONTROL PREPARE MATERIAL PROCESSING ASSEMBLY CONTROL MATERIAL
PREPARE PREPARE MATERIAL MATERIAL
QUALITY RAW MATERIAL FINISHING CONTROL PRODUCT
SUBWORK
WORKPIECES Principle WORKPIECES
FUNCTION 2
SRS
DELIVERY
E RECYCLING
STATION 7
SUBWORK Sequential flow groups Sequential flow groups Principle SUBWORK Principle
PRE-”CUSTOMIZED” TOOLING PRE-”CUSTOMIZED” TOOLING ON-SITE RECYCLING
Additive manufacturing, generic flow Process flow principle Production line DELIVERY RAW MATERIAL DELIVERY Process flow principle RAW MATERIAL
STATION 6
WORKPIECES
MATERIAL MATERIAL STORAGE STORAGE
DELIVERY DELIVERY
STATION 5 SUBWORK
FUNCTION 1
MATERIAL “SQUARE”
PRODUCT FUNCTION 3
SUBWORK
RAW MATERIAL RAW MATERIAL
SUBWORK
STORAGE
“Functional” product workshop workshop Process flowproduct with central material “square” Process flow with central material “square”
FUNCTION 2 SUBWORK
Job shop Process flow
G
SUBWORK
STATION 6 “Functional” STATION 7
STATION 5
FUNCTION 3
MARKET
FUNCTION 3
4 preliminary flow diagram for the Corner Factory. FUNCTION 1
UBWORK
RK
STATION 4 OUT SUBWORK
FUNCTION 2 SUBWORK FUNCTION 3 specific, were studied in preparation for the draftingFUNCTION of a 2
Job shop Process flow Process flow
PRODUCT
INSPECTION
STORAGE
STATION Job2shopSTATION 3
STORAGE
SUBWORK
SUBWORK DELIVERIES FUNCFUNCSUBWORK TION 1 TION 1
of a production process. A number of these, generic and
SUBWORK
SUBWORK
STATION 3
STORAGE STORAGE MARKET SUBWORK
Essentially, a factory is an enclosure for the sheltering PACKAGING
Driven FUNCTION 3 Line with sub-stations SUBWORKFUNCTION 2 SUBWORK FUNCTION 3 “Fishbone” process flow 2 FUNCTION
PACKAGE
OUT OUT
STATION 2
PRODUCT
FUNCTION FUNCTION 4 4
FUNCTION 1 FUNCTION 1
IN
DELIVERIES SUBWORK DELIVERIES SUBWORK
SUBWORK ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY PREPARE STATION 1 MATERIAL
DELIVERY
QUALITY CONTROL
ASSEMBLY
PRE-”CUSTOMIZED” TOOLING
Flow groups on logistical axis Principle
RAW MATERIAL STORAGE PRODUCT STORAGE QUALITY CONTROL
RECYCLING
PROCESSING
WORKPIECES
DELIVERIES DELIVERIES ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY
PREPARE MATERIAL
MATERIAL STORAGE
FABRICATION UNIT
“Functional” product wor Process flow with central m
ON-SITE RECYCLING PREPARE PROCESSING BUILD MATERIAL MATERIAL SITE
PRE-”CUSTOMIZ
BLOOD BLOODPROCESSING PROCESSING
DRIED DRIEDBLOOD BLOOD HIDES HIDES
HIDE HIDEPROCESSING PROCESSING
HAIR HAIRRECOVERY RECOVERY WATER WATER &&FEED FEED
LIVESTOCK LIVESTOCK PENS PENS
REMOVE REMOVE HIDE HIDE
KILLING KILLING
HOG HOGHAIR HAIR
EVISCERATING EVISCERATING
COOLING COOLING
PROCESSING PROCESSING
CUTTING CUTTING DEBONING DEBONING
SORTING SORTINGAND ANDSIZING SIZING GRIND, GRIND,CURE, CURE,COOK COOK
FATS FATS
RENDERING RENDERING VISCERA VISCERAHANDLING HANDLING DRIED BLOOD HIDE PROCESSING
OVERY EVISCERATING
COOLING
HOG HAIR PROCESSING
CUTTING DEBONING
SORTING AND SIZING GRIND, CURE, COOK
MEATS
PRE-MIX PRE-MIX
INGREDIENTS INGREDIENTS
DRY DRYGOODS GOODS
MIXING WASTEMIXING
MARKET MARKET
DELIVERIES DELIVERIES
OFFALS OFFALS HEAT HEAT//LANDFILL LANDFILL
PACKING STORAGE
MARKET
DELIVERIES
FATS
RENDERING VISCERA HANDLING
PACKING PACKING STORAGE STORAGE
WASTE WASTE
HIDES
Pig Pig products products Process Process flow flow
MEATS MEATS
OFFALS FORMING FORMING
BAKING BAKING
SHAPE SHAPE/ /SIZE SIZE
VERTICAL VERTICAL COOLING COOLING HEAT / LANDFILL FILLING FILLING
METAL METAL DETECTION DETECTION
WRAPPING WRAPPING
PACKING PACKING STORAGE STORAGE
MARKET MARKET
BISCUITS
Biscuits Biscuits Process Process flow flow BLOOD PROCESSING
DRIED BLOOD
HIDES BODY BODY STAMPING COATING METAL BLOOD PROCESSING BLOOD STAMPING DRIED COATING METALCOILS COILS SHOP SHOP HAIR RECOVERY HOG HAIR VERTICAL METAL PACKING NG HIDES HIDE PROCESSING PACKING BAKING COOLING WRAPPING MARKET ZE FILLING DETECTION STORAGE DRIED BLOOD PROCESSING FOUNDRY ENGINE CUTTING WATER FOUNDRY ENGINE LIVESTOCK REMOVE SORTING AND SIZING EVISCERATING COOLING KILLING MEATS STORAGE MARKET CHASSI FINAL HAIR RECOVERY HOG HAIR CHASSI FINAL HIDES DEBONING HIDE PROCESSING& FEED PENS GRIND, CURE, COOK HIDE METAL MARKET RECEPTION METAL MARKET RECEPTION PACKING ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY BODY DELIVERIES ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY BODY DELIVERIES TRANS&&HANDLING TRANSHANDLING DELIVERIES FORGE SHOP PROCESSING FORGE SHOP CUTTING WATER MISSION LIVESTOCK FATS RECOVERY REMOVE HOG HAIR RENDERING MISSION SORTING AND SIZING EVISCERATING COOLING KILLING MEATS STORAGE MATERIAL MATERIAL FINAL MARKET MATERIAL MATERIAL FINAL DEBONING PACKING & FEED PENS GRIND, CURE, COOK HIDE MARKET MARKET &&PARTS PROCESSING ASSEMBLY PARTS PROCESSING ASSEMBLY POLYMER PROCESSING POLYMERMOULDING MOULDING VISCERA HANDLING OFFALS CUTTING DELIVERIES SORTING AND SIZING EVISCERATING COOLING MEATS CHASSI STORAGE MARKET FATS CHASSI RENDERING DEBONING GRIND, CURE, COOK ASSEMBLY SOFT ASSEMBLY WASTE HEAT / LANDFILL SOFTTRIM TRIMWORKSHOP WORKSHOP DELIVERIES OUTSOURCED VISCERA HANDLING OFFALS OUTSOURCEDPARTS PARTS BODY FATS RENDERING STAMPING COATING METAL COILS Pig products SHOP WASTE HEAT / LANDFILL Process flow VISCERA HANDLING OFFALS Near-vertical Car Near-vertical automobile automobile plant plant Car plant, plant, reduced reduced FOUNDRY ENGINE Pig products Process flow Process flow flow Process flow WASTE HEAT / LANDFILL CHASSI ProcessFINAL METAL MARKET RECEPTION Process flow PORK BELLY ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY DELIVERIES TRANS& HANDLING FORGE MISSION MARKET POLYMER MOULDING VERTICAL METAL PACKING FORMING PRE-MIX BAKING COOLING WRAPPING INGREDIENTS MARKET MIXING SOFT TRIM WORKSHOP DRY GOODS SHAPE / SIZE FILLING DETECTION STORAGE OUTSOURCED PARTS PARTICLE PARTICLEBOARD BOARDMANUFACTURING MANUFACTURING VERTICAL METAL PACKING FORMING PRE-MIX SAWDUST, &&CHIPPINGS BAKING COOLING WRAPPING SAWDUST,FLAKES FLAKES CHIPPINGS INGREDIENTS MARKET MIXING DRY GOODS SHAPE / SIZE FILLING DETECTION STORAGE HEATING HEATING Near-vertical automobile plant Biscuits VERTICAL METAL PACKING MING BAKING COOLING Process flow MARKET INSPECT ROUGH FILLINGDRYING TRIM INSPECT Process E / SIZE TRIM WRAPPING DRYINGDETECTION SELECTED MACHINE AREA ASSEMBLY FINISHING PACKING STORAGE STORAGE SANDING MARKET SELECTED flow ROUGH MACHINE AREA SANDING ASSEMBLY FINISHING PACKING STORAGE MARKET AIR/KILN &&REPAIR CUT DEPT. AIR/KILN REPAIR CUT DEPT. WOOD WOOD Biscuits HIDE PROCESSING
Process flow Wood Wood furniture furniture Process Process flow flow
WOODEN CHAIR
BODY METALSHOP COILS
MACHINE AREA
MARKET
N ON
GAN UATION
BODY STAMPING SHOP MATERIAL MATERIAL FINAL MARKET INSPECT &SANDING PARTS PROCESSING ASSEMBLY FINISHING BODY ASSEMBLY & REPAIR FOUNDRY ENGINE SHOP CHASSI MATERIAL MATERIAL FINAL METAL ORGAN RECEPTION ORGANSCAFFOLDING SCAFFOLDING ASSEMBLY DELIVERIES BIO-POLYMER MARKET TRANS&BIO-POLYMER PARTS PROCESSING MATERIAL & HANDLING MATERIALPREPARATION PREPARATION ASSEMBLY FORGE MISSION CHASSI
METAL COILS
STAMPING
BODY SHOP
METAL COILS PARTICLE BOARD MANUFACTURING METAL RECEPTION DELIVERIES & HANDLING COATING HEATING
FOUNDRY STAMPING
BODY ENGINE SHOP
FORGE FOUNDRY
TRANSENGINE MISSION
RECIPIENT
MACHINE AREA
CEMENT
FINAL ASSEMBLY
MARKET
FINAL ASSEMBLY
MARKET
QUALITY TEST
ASSEMBLY
QUALITY TEST
COATING CHASSI ASSEMBLY
CHASSI METAL RECEPTION ASSEMBLY PACKING DELIVERIESSTORAGE MARKET POLYMER MOULDING TRANS& HANDLING FORGE MOISTURE CHASSI FINAL MISSION MOISTURETESTING TESTING MARKET SOFT TRIM WORKSHOP ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLY CEMENT CEMENT POLYMER MOULDING OUTSOURCED PARTS QUALITY TEST
RECEPTION POLYMER MOULDING RECEPTIONplant Near-vertical automobile ORGAN Car plant, reduced FOUR-NOZZLE ORGAN FOUR-NOZZLE SAND OUTSOURCED PARTS SAND RECIPIENT RAW CAD RECIPIENT RAWMATERIAL MATERIAL CADMODEL MODEL CLAY/SILT EVALUATION “INKJET” CLAY/SILTTEST TEST EVALUATIONSOFT TRIM “INKJET”BIO-PRINTER BIO-PRINTER Process flow Process flow STORAGE WORKSHOP STORAGE OUTSOURCED PARTS Near-vertical automobile plant Car plant, reduced CARS AGGREGATE AGGREGATE COMPATIBLE COMPATIBLECELL CELL RECIPIENT GRADING Process flow Process RECIPIENTflow GRADING MATERIAL MATERIALPREPARATION PREPARATION Near-vertical automobile plant ADDITIVES ADDITIVES Process flow MOISTURE TESTING
Artificial Artificial kidney kidney Process Process flow flow
COATING
SOFT TRIM WORKSHOP MOULDING MOULDING DEMOULD DEMOULD CURING CURING
Concrete Concrete elements elements
Process Process flow flow SAWDUST, FLAKES & CHIPPINGS RECEPTION MOULDING FINAL QUALITY SAND MARKET DEMOULD RAW MATERIAL CLAY/SILT TEST CURING CONTROL INSPECT ROUGH TRIM CURING MACHINE AREA STORAGE SAWDUST,DRYING FLAKES & CHIPPINGS SELECTED SANDING ASSEMBLY AIR/KILN & REPAIR CUT DEPT. WOOD PARTICLE BOARD MANUFACTURING AGGREGATE INSPECT ROUGH TRIM DRYINGGRADING SELECTED MACHINE AREA SANDING ASSEMBLY AIR/KILN & REPAIR HEATING CUT DEPT. WOOD Wood furniture INSPECT ADDITIVES SANDING ASSEMBLY FINISHING PACKING STORAGE MARKET Process flow & REPAIR
FINAL FINAL CURING CURING
QUALITY QUALITY CONTROL CONTROL
MARKET MARKET
PARTICLE BOARD MANUFACTURING
FINISHING FINISHING
HEATING PARTICLE BOARD MANUFACTURING PACKING STORAGE MARKET HEATING PACKING
STORAGE
MARKET
Concrete elements Wood furniture
Process flow flow CONCRETE ELEMENT Process
BIO-POLYMER
MOISTURE TESTING
ORGAN SCAFFOLDING MATERIAL PREPARATION
CEMENT
ORGAN SCAFFOLDING RECEPTION MATERIAL PREPARATION ORGAN FOUR-NOZZLE RECIPIENT RAW MATERIAL MOISTURE TESTING CAD MODEL EVALUATION “INKJET” BIO-PRINTER STORAGE CEMENT RECEPTION FOUR-NOZZLE QUALITY TEST ORGAN RECIPIENT RAW MATERIAL CAD MODEL COMPATIBLE CELL EVALUATION “INKJET” BIO-PRINTER RECIPIENT STORAGE MATERIAL PREPARATION RECEPTION MOULDING FINAL QUALITY SAND DEMOULD RECIPIENT RAW MATERIAL CLAY/SILT TEST CURING CONTROL COMPATIBLE STORAGE CELL CURING RECIPIENT MATERIAL PREPARATION KIDNEY Artificial kidney Concrete elements AGGREGATE BIO-POLYMER
Process flow Artificial kidney Process flow Concrete elements Process flow
GRADING
ADDITIVES
Process flow Concrete elements Process flow
QUALITY TEST MOISTURE TESTING
CEMENT
SAND QUALITY TEST CLAY/SILT TEST SAND AGGREGATE CLAY/SILT TEST GRADING
MOULDING CURING MOULDING CURING
DEMOULD
FINAL CURING
QUALITY CONTROL
MARKET
DEMOULD
FINAL CURING
QUALITY CONTROL
MARKET
MARKET ADDITIVES AGGREGATE GRADING
ADDITIVES
36
Flow chart FACTORY SPACE
LOGISTIC SYSTEM
IDEA DEPARTMENT
OFFICE HOTEL
Prototyping
Service bureau
Production planning
Incubator
XS
STORAGE LOCATIONS
SHUTTLE SPACE
Complete drone Ship to HQ
Meeting areas
Robot training
S Assembly by dual-arm co-bots
CEO Administrator
Design
VR engineer
Testing
M
Prototype
RECEPTION
Elevator cage
FACTORY WORKERS
Workshop
Buffer spot Drone parts set
ASSEMBLY
PROCESSING / MACHINING
ASSEMBLY BUFFER
PUBLIC WORKSHOP WORKSHOPS
LOBBY
Exposition
PUBLIC GROUND FLOOR
Wood ‘Maker’ Seat bracket
Metal
Workplaces
Additive manufacturing
Reception
Laser sintering
Large builds
Coatings Powder coating
PACKAGE & DELIVER
Start-up CEO Sensor engineer Production manager Medical service bureau VR engineer Counter-nausea expert Home consumer Wants easy repair Chair bracket Replacement part
Headset prototype #34, fit mock-up Drone Fairly complex product Hip implant Simple, print only order Stock materials
MATERIALS PLA plastic Stock materials
PRINT SHOP ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Stereolithograpy
FINISHING
Chem bath
(pull system)
MATERIAL PREP
UV oven
Gas atomizer
Fused deposition Direct laser sintering E-beam melting
Resin Titanium Polymers Metals
Coatings
PRODUCT
Quality scan
Powder recovery
Hip implant Headset mockup Parts 3-24
CNC Milling Machining
Wire EDM Injection moulding CONVENTIONAL
37
Deburring
INSPECTION
Flow groups
WORKPIECE BUFFER Drone parts Workpieces
ASSEMBLY
FLOWS
Flödesschema - arbetshypotes, illustrativa exempel (under utveckling)
Vertical flow problem When Henry Ford abandoned the outdated five-storey Highland Park in favor of the sheds of River Rouge, organising
vertical
production
lines
was
likewise
abandonded. The ramps of Lingotto are spectacular in themselves, but not a very efficient way of organising space. This is the vertical problem. In search for a solution, the 'Direct Input / Output System' was found.
Floor loops
Production line
Processes and business separated on floors
Linear production throughout building
Gravity flow Chutes and lifts moving material and product
FLOOR LOOPS
GRAVITY FLOW
PRODUCTION LINE
ProcessesFLOOR and business separated on floors LOOPS Example: Building, Starett-Lehigh Processes and Bricken business separated on floors
Chutes and lifts moving material and product GRAVITY FLOW Example: Park, Murray’s Chutes and lifts moving Highland material and product
Example: Bricken Building, Starett-Lehigh
Example: Highland Park, Murray’s
Linear production throughout building PRODUCTION LINE Example: VW Gläserne, Fiat Lingotto (reversed) Linear production throughout building Example: VW Gläserne, Fiat Lingotto (reversed)
Early 20th century vertical flow principles, all with high circulation space demands) Early 20th century vertical flow principles, all with high circulation space demands)
EARLY 20TH CENTURY FLOW PRINCIPLES
Early 20th century
Expan
Exp
dabilit
and
Exp
ity
and
Tota l Tota l
abil
ity
Total fl la you t
layo ut
y
abil
exibilit
y
flex
ibilit
flex
y
ibilit
y
ProdPr uco tid ou ncliti no en line PW W roodrk so hok uc psfl tir ho on ow p lin e flow Work sho p flo w
DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM
VERTICAL DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM core handling all flows VERTICAL‘Smart’ DIRECT INPUT / OUTPUT SYSTEM 19401930'S AND FORWARD: HORIZONTAL FLOWS The competition -- flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap
1940’s and forward: flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap 1940’s and forward: flat, straight-forward flows, flexible, expandable , cheap
‘Smart’ core handling all flows Near future THESIS FLOW CONCEPT Material flow concept - Central logistics core handling all flows
Future vertical flow concept Future vertical flow concept 38
Direct Input / Output System Handling the material flows is the main task of the
Kusuda, Y. (2008) Direct input and output system.
infrastructure of a vertical factory. In this regard, the 'Direct An automated warehouse with a stacker crane is installed at the center of a factory floor.
Input / Output System' (DIOS) pioneered by Seibu Electric co. of Japan in the 80's has been influential. In its original
Machines are arranged around the warehouse and inlet and outlet holes corresponding
form, it describes the flows in a flexible material system
to the machines are made on the side of the warehouse.
(FMS), where everything related to production is handled by a single, automated warehouse.
The warehouse stores everything related to the production – materials, parts, half finished products, finished goods, fixtures, etc.
Translated to a building component in a high-rise factory, this logistic principle translates to a 'smart core' featuring
A computer controls the material storage and material flow of the DIO system. It
an automated storage / retrieval system (see next page)
commands the stacker crane to take care of transportation from storage to machines,
acting throughout the building. This infrastructural spine
from machines to storage, from a machine to another machine, stock in storage, ship
handles all flows, coordinating transport orders with
out, etc.
maximum efficiency. Components, equipment and anything that is not directly used are tucked away and stored by the common IoT-guided logistic system.
Elec
sink
ing
e
tric die
cr an
Mate
st or ag e
St
ac ke r
rial
Work p
Bu ffe r
iece
Strip
+
=
90°
-guid
ed A GV
CNC
mill
DIO SYSTEM
Flexible manufacturing system (FMS) (Direct input/output system (FANUC Robotics, 1980’s))
KUSUDA, Y. (2008) DIRECT INPUT AND OUTPUT SYSTEM.
39
+ 90°
VERTICAL DIO SYSTEM + ASRS = FLOW PRINCIPLE
Vertical FMS
Automate
Automated storage / retrieval system Originating in the 60's, an automated storage / retrieval system (ASRS) is a compact logistic solution for computerized management of a warehouse. Reducing inventory and labor, they are typically used in applications where there are a high volume of loads being moved in and out of storage, space constraints make storage density important and where accuracy is critical because of expensive loads. Such as in the Corner Factory.
Factory Worker
Outside Industry Material
Maker Consumer
Lobby
exposition events large objects
Product / Workpiece
Maker Space
all-material workshop accessible equipment assistance available Production
Logistic Hub
Auditorium education events
Production
deliveries packaging drone central
Core
direct input / output system
Idea Production
Office Space design & planning start-up incubator office hotels
Factory Space manufacturing assembly spaces research & development
Fabrication Data
Production
Machine Park
highly automated flexible manufacturing systems technical systems Fabrication Data
CORE FLOW HANDLING
Fabrication Data
CORNER FACTORY ASRS
40
Machinery Like the tenants of an apartment building, the machinery
neighbouring street. Increasingly automated, these robots
is just as much as the workers the inhabitants around
works tirelessly around the clock, unconcerned with being
which the factory needs to be designed. Below, the main
watched, moving and assembling components with almost
types of equipment found in the Corner Factory are shown.
uncanny autonomy and precision. By day, workers arrive to
These machines are in themselves a large portion of the
tune and monitor their choreography.
spectacular quality provided by the Corner Factory to its
Generic platforms Basic, scalable components 3D PRINTER
7-AXIS ARM
AUTOMATED GUIDED VEHICLE
Smart & mobile Intraconnected IoT machinery
AGV + TELESCOPE + ARM S
AGV + ARM L
ARM + GANTRY
AGV + TRAY
AGV + ASRS CAROUSELS
Conventional equipment For when additive isn't rational
ELECTRIC DIE SINKING MACHINE
INJECTION MOULDING MACHINE
FLATBED CNC ROUTER
WATERJET CUTTER
Classic tools For the Public Workshop
LATHE 41
BAND SAW
DRILL PRESS
TABLE SAW
Space-making equipment The potential for the machinery itself to act as spacemaking elements was recognized early. Shown right are 3D printers assembled into walls. In the final proposal, two of these elements acted in conjunction with the core 'slab' to define a logistic area.
OBJECTS IN SPACE
OBJECTS DEFINING SPACE
OBJECTS ENCLOSING SPACE
42
Core placement The position of the core defines the basic spatial
or a
configuration of a high-rise. An early decision to push
vast halls of mass production are no longer that relevant
the visually potent core towards the facade ruled out a
in most manufacturing, but the option to divide a larger
central placement. The 'fragmented' option was thoroughly
volume of space at will is still appealing in this sector. In
evaulated and found to have a lot of spatial potential, but
the end, clustering the core functions in a bundle, placed
to be more suited for a factory with a larger floorplate,
asymmetrically for a differentiation of space, was chosen.
CENTRAL CENTRAL CENTRAL BALANCED STRUCTURE GENERATING HOMOGENOUS SPACE
typology with lesser demands on flexibility. The
EXTERNAL EXTERNAL 'TOTALEXTERNAL FLEXIBILITY' - IN EFFECT OFTEN STATIC
e.g. Johnson e.g. Wax, Johnson Seagram Wax, Seagram Balanced structure generating homogenous space Balanced structure generating homogenous space
Centre Pompidou, e.g. Centree.g. Pompidou, Lloyds bldgLloyds bldg ‘Totalinflexibility’, in effect ‘Total flexibility’, effect often static often static
<< FRAGMENTED NEEDS FAIRLY LARGE FLOOR PLATE
ERNAL
oyds bldg pidou, Lloyds bldg often static in effect often static
43
ASYMMETRIC DIFFERENTIATING SPACE
FRAGMENTED FRAGMENTED
OFF-CENTER OFF-CENTER
e.g. Sendai e.g.Mediatheque Sendai Mediatheque Needs fairly large floorlarge platefloor plate Needs fairly
ExamplesExamples ubiquitousubiquitous Differentiating space space Differentiating
FRAG
e.g. Senda Needs fairl
STUDY MODEL FOR CORE PLACEMENT AND PARTITIONS
44
Core design The 'smart core', or automated storage and retrieval system (ASRS), physically consists of a tall warehouse
This larger lattice slab acts as the stiffening element for
pallet racking with a stacker crane. Or, a large number of
the entire building (see structure chapter). It also contains
storage locations for objects of various scales. Considered
the other necessary functions: freight- and personnel
as a large-scale object in itself, this pallet racking could be
elevators, fire escape stairs, air ducts, wiring and media
described as a lattice structure consisting of a myriad of
piping.
sticks. This idea of sticks was to inform the entire building.
The core is the building component most associated
Considering the possibility of the pallet racking to act
with the spectacular. Normally, a high rise core is an
as a structural member, various configurations were
opaque static element. But in the Corner Factory, the core
explored below. The theme of a 'trapped figure' or 'shape
comes alive while almost disappearing. Inside the delicate
within' was also explored. In the end, the core consists of a
skeletal tube, the stackers shifts goods around, providing a
larger exoskeleton overlaid over a pallet racking divided for
constant activity especially prominent at night.
accomodating two packet sizes.
TAPERING PALLET RACKING
45
'TRAPPED FIGURE' VOLUME
HYPERBOLOID CORE
LATTICE STICK
SLAB
CRUCIFORM
STICK
HEXAGON
CYLINDER
bISTICAL elf ly- structurally unstable SYSTEM in itself unstable-inSTRUCTURAL itself Tube - structurally Tube stable- structurally / space-making Tube stable - structurally / space-making Tube stable - structurally / space-making Tube - structurally stable / space-making stable / space-making LOGISTICAL LOGISTICAL SYSTEM - STRUCTURAL POTENTIAL LOGISTICAL SYSTEM LOGISTICAL - STRUCTURAL SYSTEM POTENTIAL -SYSTEM STRUCTURAL POTENTIAL - STRUCTURAL POTENTIAL POTENTIAL
FREIGHT
PERSONNEL
FIRE
AUTOMATED STORAGE
ELEVATOR
ELEVATOR
ESCAPE
/ RETRIEVAL SYSTEM
FINAL CORE BUNDLE 46
Structure Building on the 'stick logic' of the core, the global structure
more spatially rich iterations, were discarded in favor for
was initially approached as a 'stick field'. This tectonic
basic, space-maximising compartments. The system can
logic is especially prevalent in utilitarian structures due its
thus be read as a series of stacked 6m halls, the ones
inherent material efficiency. Columns and lattice girders
located higher up in the building coming with pre-inserted
were decided to be the basic components of the structural
mezzanine floors. The columns system is placed on a
system, in which the amounts and thicknesses were
subterranean box of concrete. A continous void, containing
constantly manipulated. Shown on next spread are some
the logistic system, runs throughout the entire height.
variations of slabs. Some heavily perforated, and perhaps
SLAB UNDERSIDE STUDY MODEL 47
CONCRETE FILLED TUBES, TAPERING DOWN: 400X400 1200X400
CONCRETE METAL DECK SLABS ON SINE PROFILE GIRDERS (H=800)
STIFFENING LATTICE CORE: STEEL SECTIONS 250X250 100X100
CONCRETE BASEMENT CASING
48
GRADATION OF STRUCTURE
OBSESSIVE THINNESS
CASCADING PLATFORMS
MIESIAN CORES
49
JAUNTINESS
CONTINUUM
SLANTED COLUMNS
STACKED VIERENDEEL
50
Facade The factory should not look like an office building or a cultural institution. The volume is the simplest possible, the facade the main contributor to visual impact. Given the column-based structure, a curtain wall facade was a given. The main objective was to be the showcasing and enhancement of the factory's contents, or the exposure of new manufacturing processes. As such, the facade interface called for a non-obscuring strategy. To this end, an architecture of disapperance or 'almost nothing' was
CURVED ELEMENTS DISTORTING VIEWS OPPOSITE: CUSHION EFFECT STUDY
51
pursued. Instead of exclusively working with glass, plastic ETFE membrane cushions was introduced to the material palette. Inflated with air, these lightweight elements adds depth and curves reflections, making the envelope more three dimensional. The other elements are largepane glass elements and units with operable windows. Enhancing the spectacle inside the building, this gridded interface forms a certain rhythm, that like a comic strip format frames and directs attention.
52
Proposal
EXHIBITION 2016-05-25
OPPOSITE AND NEXT SPREAD: FINAL ITERATION 53
54
55
56
Views
SIDEWALK
57
NEIGHBOUR BALCONY
58
ASSEMBLY
59
PUBLIC WORKSHOP
60
Drawings
OPPOSITE: AXONOMETRIC 1
MATCHSTICK FACTORY
2
FUTURE CONTEXT
3
PUBLIC WORKSHOP
4
LOUD EQUIPMENT
5
AUTOMATED STORAGE/RETRIEVAL SYSTEM
6
DRONE STARTUP
7
AIR DELIVERY HUB
8
AEROSPACE COMPANY OFFICE SPACE
9
COBOT ASSEMBLY LINE
10 COBOT WORKSTATION 11 AUTOMATED GUIDED VEHICLE (AGV) 12 AGV + ITEM CAROUSEL 13 OVERHEAD GANTRY 7-AXIS ARMS 14 EXPERIMENTAL BUILD SPACE 15 LOBBY 16 LASER SINTERING MACHINE 17 4.5M SIDEWALK 18 BIKE LANE 19 INJECTION MOULDING 20 AUTOMATED PACKAGING 21 ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING ARRAY 22 LOADING BAY 23 CONNECTION TO E45 HIGHWAY 24 SERVICES EQUIPMENT 61
1
5
2 3 4
7
6
8
10
9
11
12
13
14
15 16
19
17 18 20
21
22 24 23
AXONOMETRIC 62
DETAIL SECTION THROUGH HEAVY ASSEMBLY FLOOR
63
64
PUBLIC WORKSHOP AUDITORIUM
DRONE STARTUP LIGHT ASSEMBLY AIR DELIVERIES
DEVELOPMENT PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
LIGHT ASSEMBLY MEETINGS
HEAVY ASSEMBLY
HEAVY ASSEMBLY
LOBBY EXPERIMENTAL BUILD SPACE
PRINT SHOP PACKAGING DELIVERIES
BUILDING SERVICES
SECTION THROUGH CORE
65
SOUTH ELEVATION
66
BASEMENT
67
GROUND FLOOR
68
ASSEMBLY
69
OFFICE
70
MEZZANINE
71
PUBLIC WORKSHOP
72
References Publications Marinetti, Somenzi, Mazzoni. (1934) Futurist Manifesto of Aerial Architecture Benedikt Frey, C., Osborne, M., (2015) Technology at Work: The Future of Innovation and Employment McKinsey & Company Manyika, J., et al. (2013) Disruptive technologies Kusuda, Y. (2008), Direct input and output system, Assembly Automation, Vol. 28 Bogue, R. (2013) 3D printing: the dawn of a new era in manufacturing, Assembly Automation, Vol. 33 Hardens, T. (2010) Vilém Flusser and Technics − From Homo Faber to Homo Ludens Universiteit van Amsterdam Fainstein, S. (2004) Cities and Diversity: Should we want it? Can we plan for it? Columbia University Heymann, R., Vetter, S. (2013) Europe’s re-industrialisation: The gulf between aspiration and reality Deutsche Bank Van Kempen, R., (2013) Hyper-Diversity: A new perspective on Urban Diversity. DIVERCITIES Brunnström, L. (1990) Den Rationella Fabriken: om funktionalismens rötter. PhD dissertation, Umeå University Shipp, S., et al. (2012) Emerging Global Trends in Advanced Manufacturing. Virginia: Institute for Defense Analyses Piskorz, W., Goulet, R. Cities of tomorrow: Challenges, visions, ways forward. Brussels: EC WSP., What!. (2015) Planeringsunderlag: Höga Hus, Centralenområdet City Planning Office, Göteborg. (2014) Centralenområdet: Stadsutvecklingsprogram 1.0 City Planning Office, Göteborg. (2013) Samrådshandling: Detaljplan för bro över Göta Älv SpaceScape, West8, White. (2013) Queens Park: Central Station area paralell study Heymann, R., Vetter, S. (2013) Europe’s re-industrialisation: The gulf between aspiration and reality Deutsche Bank Nager, A., Atkinson, R. (2015) The Myth of America’s Manufacturing Renaissance: The Real State of U.S. Manufacturing. Sirkin et al. (2011) Made in America, again: Why Manufacturing will return to the U.S. Boston Consulting Group
73
Literature Brynjolfsson, E., McAfee, A. (2014) The Second Machine Age. New York: W.W. Norton & Co Gregotti, V. (2010) Architecture: Means and Ends. Chicago: University of Chicago Press Le Corbusier. (1923) Toward an Architecture. New York: Dover Publications Jacobs, J. (1961) The Death and Life of Great American Cities New York: Random House Anderson, C. (2012) Makers: The New Industrial Revolution. New York: Crown Publishing Brunnström, L. (1990) Den Rationella Fabriken: om Funktionalismens rötter. Umeå: Umeå Universitet
Lecture series Rappaport, N. Vertical Urban Factory Brandt, J. The Future of Manufacturing
Articles Krugman, P. Sympathy for the Luddites. New York Times. Retrieved 2015-10-26 Jacobs, S. Machines of loving grace. Uncube magazine no 36: Uncanny Valley Retrieved 2016-02-03 PTI. China sets up first unmanned factory. Economic Times India, retrieved 2015-11-03
Images Tahoe-Reno, Bing Maps 2016. Fiat Lingotto, z Gullbergsvass, Bing Maps 2016.
74
75