Livestock “The greatest homage we can pay to truth is to use it.” – JAMES RUSSELL LOWELL APRIL 15, 2010 •
www. aaalivestock . com
MARKET
Digest Volume 52 • No. 4
Dear Tom W by Lee Pitts
NEWSPAPER PRIORITY HANDLING
hen the respected ag journalist Alan Guebert and the Digest broke the story about the Cattlemen’s Beef Board’s letters of displeasure to the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association (NCBA) regarding their reorganization, and subsequent heist of even more checkoff dollars, we were underwhelmed by the response. It seemed like there was none. Zip, zero, nada, nothing. Heck, I’ve written stories about snails in Bruneau, Idaho, that got more rise out of readers than this story did. This caused me to wonder: Where is the outrage? When the NCBA was formed in the merger, cattlemen from across the country were angry. Enough so that 40 ranchers got on a plane in California and paid their own way to San Antonio to try to stop it. At that time we were only talking about the possibility of the NCBA getting control of your beef bucks. In this case we have years of cold hard evidence, and recent posturings show the group’s lust for even more. Do ranchers not care? Is the whole process just too complicated to understand? Or have ranchers resigned themselves to the fact that the NCBA will eventually get their hands on
“Don't judge folks by their relatives.”
the money anyway? The answers to those questions are yes, yes and yes. Ranchers already have enough to worry about, like survival. And according to the NCBA, a poll in 2006 found that only about 2 percent of producers were concerned about NCBA’s involvement with the checkoff. And yes, the process is complicated . . . probably on purpose. Finally, a lot of steam went out of the opposition when the Supreme Court ruled that the checkoff was a government program. Still, it seems like we
shouldn’t just roll over and play dead while the NCBA robs the checkoff bank in plain daylight.
A Little History At NCBA’s annual convention this past January their Board voted 94 percent to develop a new governance structure. We constantly hear this 94 percent figure, supposedly showing widespread industry support for the reorganization. But it was like a bunch of panhandlers seeing someone drop a wad of hundred dollar bills on the floor and then voting amongst themselves
whether or not they should pocket the money! Of course the NCBA would vote to give themselves more power and money! When have they done otherwise? And, quite frankly, they could use the cash. On March 18, the USDA was sent a letter that indicates not everyone is fond of NCBA’s sneaky plan. The American Farm Bureau Federation, Livestock Marketing Association (LMA), National Farmers Union, National Livestock Producers Association, National Milk Producers Federation, and the US Cattleman’s Association jointly signed a letter addressed to The Honorable Tom Vilsack, USDA Secretary, in which they displayed the disgust that all ranchers should be feeling right now. After pronouncing their proper support for the checkoff, the groups lashed into the NCBA and asked the checkoff Sheriff, the USDA, to step in and stop this heist. “Our organizations, said the letter, “have grave concerns that the ongoing governance changes being considered by the NCBA will further erode the separation between the checkoff side (the Federation of State Beef Councils) and the policy side (NCBA) of the organization. We also believe the new governance continued on page two
Rancher’s Murder Brings Focus To Border War by CAREN COWAN
he brutal murder of Rob Krentz, 58, Douglas, Arizona, on March 27, 2010, has finally brought strong light to the fact that there is, and has been, a guerilla war going on along the Mexican border of the United States for years. Krentz, father of three and grandfather of two, was doing routine ranch work the morning he apparently spotted an illegal alien in need of aid. He radioed family on the band used by ranchers in the area, asking for someone to call the Border Patrol for assistance. His body, slumped in his still-running Polaris ATV, along with his mortally injured dog, was finally located over 12 hours later. Many authorities, including the Arizona Attorney General’s office, agree that the murder was by a member of a drug cartel who was tracked back to the Mexican border. While some have speculated that this was a tragic, but isolated incident or that it was a million-to-one chance encounter that led to the killing, both are far from the truth. Krentz, his
T
Riding Herd
family and his neighbors across southern California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas have faced this risk every moment of their lives for the past several years. In better times, illegal immigrants would walk through border ranches in seek of work. If there wasn’t work available, ranchers usually provided food and water to the traveler before he went on his way. Over the past 20 years that has changed. Illegal aliens from around the world have streamed across the porous border in droves, littering the landscape; damaging or destroying private property, including water; threatening the lives of locals; and often feeding this nation’s insatiable need for illegal drugs. Leaders of these groups return to Mexico with money and guns that result from the drug transactions only to start the cycle over. The past several years there has been increased attention paid to the problem, with Governor Bill Richardson declaring a state of emergency and sending National Guard troops continued on page fifteen
by LEE PITTS
Not-So-Great Moments In History an you imagine how America’s past would have been altered had all the rules, regulations and political correctness that exist today been present throughout our nation’s history? Henry Ford never would have mass produced a single car if he had to meet CAFE emission standards, Johnny Appleseed would have been arrested and forced to pay a heavy fine for spreading an invasive species, and John Audubon might never have painted all those pretty bird pictures if, as an avid hunter, he had not been allowed to shoot an endangered species now and then. What? You thought he was able to get such detail in his pictures just by watching them fly by? We wouldn’t even be the good old US of A if our founders had to put up with all the nonsense that deadlocks our country today. The patriots dumping tea into Boston Harbor would have been arrested for polluting and I’m quite sure they did not have a permit to meet in a public place. Paul Revere would have been thrown in jail for disturbing the peace and PETA would have protested that he mistreated his horse. The Declaration of Independence would have been held up in committee by Congress and the National Organization for Women would have howled like a lovelorn coyote because not a single woman was asked to sign the document. George Washington would never have been a General, or our first President, because he’d have been in the hoosegow for chopping down that cherry tree without a permit. Instead of becoming the Father of our Country he’d have rotted away in a federal penitentiary, being turned into a hardened criminal at taxpayer’s expense. Alaska and Hawaii would not be part of us, as in U.S., Louisiana would be owned by France today, heaven forbid, and the Saints would
C
continued on page thirteen
www.LeePittsbooks.com