DESIGN FOR PEOPLE
NUBES CHEN
WHO IS THE COMMUNITY
PROJECT: PICO RIVERA SPORTS & ENTERTAINMENT
DISTRICT, LOS ANGELES
Each urban project changes the social fabric and economic dynamics of the existing community. Understanding the expectations and concerns of community members from the past, present, and future is essentially important to managing the changes of the community.
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Impacted by flooding issues, the City of Pico Rivera has to relocate the historic Sports Arena and a new Sports and Entertainment District is planned at an existing industrial center which will completely repurpose the area. The main challenge is to get the support of industrial players and build a new community.
The project aims to design a plan that will smoothly transition the current economy, revive the community memories, and connect Pico Rivera to a broader community.
THE KEY PRINCIPLES ARE:
• Adopt a locally sensitive plan
• Encourage collaboration of multiple stakeholders
• Ensure long-term vibrancy
WHO IS THE COMMUNITY
“RESIDENTS” ON THE SITE MEMORIES
Warehouse Wholesale Manufacturing
65% of industrial companies on this site are wholesalers or warehouses.
45% of the businesses involve design work. Most of the businesses are in food or furniture industry
26% of the memory posts riverbed.
ENGAGEMENT HIGHLIGHTS:
• Street activities and small plazas
• Unique/artistic/colorful placemaking
*By analyzing more than 400 historic photos that the community posted on-line shows that food places and parks are
TACOSFOOD BURGERS COMPANIES MALL MEETSHOPPING HANG-OUT INDOOR SWAP MEET FORD AUTO BANK BRIDGE FRIES FOODPRODUCEMARKET MARKET DAIRY BURRITOSTORTAS CARNEASADAMCDONALD’S SANDWICHES FRIED CHICKEN CARNITAS STREAMLAND SMITH PARK PLAYGROUND ROLLARCOASTER PICNIC SWING CLIMB FESTIVAL FOOTBALL SKATING PARTY SCHOOL FOOTBALL BASEBALL STREETS HORSE CHURCH COMMERCIAL RAILWAY DEPOT AGRICULTURE MOTEL FARM CEMETERY CITY HALL BARBER BOOKSTORE SHOEREPAIR STATUARY MUSEUM LIBRARY HOSPITAL PLAZA
“
OF PICO RIVERA1
THE BROADER COMMUNITY
posts involve playing in the parks and
“We want: placemaking
49% of the population in LA County is Hispanic.2
ENGAGEMENT HIGHLIGHTS: The community has an appetite for a new sports arena that is modern but also reflects Pico Rivera’s history and unique identity.
are the most important memory anchors about Pico Rivera. Data Source: 1.Facebook Pico Rivera Historic Photos 2.Census Bureau 2020
THEATER FIESTA TACOSFOOD BURGERS PIZZARIVERBED LAKE POOL POND WATER FISHING BRIDGE STEAK FRIES MARKET MCDONALD’S SANDWICHES CHICKEN CARNITAS PLAYGROUNDSTREAMLANDPARK
SPORTS ARENA
DANCING MUSIC
TRAIN BIKING CAMPING
PLANNING STRATEGY
Phase I
Industrial players
Roof-sharing Program
Phase II
Parking Lots Activation Program
Phase III
Mixed-use Industrial Incubation Program
Pico Rivera community
Pico Rivera lovers
Public education: “how much do you know about flooding”
Visioning: “How do you want to use the space?”
Survey: Love Notes to Pico Rivera!
Programming: Bimonthly event calendar
“May I use your roof?”
“May I use your parking lots? Let’s trade space”
“Let’s think about the business creatively!”
GROUND-TO-ROOF INTERVENTION
ROOF-TO-GROUND INTERVENTION
SPACE ACTIVATION
Small Small Medium Medium Large Large
PLACEMAKING MENU
Small Medium Large
THE CITY OF RIPPLES
• Cultural identity: the urban design concept is a combination of the cultural symbols like Mariachi plaza and Pico Rivera Memorial Sports Arena, and ripples of river which Pico Rivera has a unique bond with.
• Economic sustainability: the project will keep 65% of the job on site and ensure smooth economic transition by adapting current businesses
Mixed-use Commercial Mixed-use Commercial Sports Arena Commercial Corridor Community Commercial Key Project Partners
Recreational Space LEGEND Green Space
Skate Park El Rancho Unified School District San Gabriel River Discovery In The Making Prospering backyards Soledad Enrichment Action Beecrazee Axxion Unisource Solutions Miss Lola Cabinets Counter Tops Pico Rivera Centre for the Arts El Rancho Performing Arts In The Making Self Help Graphics HomeCo Kitchen & Bath Depot Casa Leaders Furniture lucky tree construction inc Cabinets Counter Tops MG Unicorn Inc Unisource Solutions BakeMark Mariscos Bahia J C Trading Inc Hotel Office Building Medium-rise Housing Art Residency Food Market Sports Center Art Hall Community Commercial Furniture Market Mixed-use Indsutrial Community Center Medium-rise Housing
WHAT IS THE LANGUAGE
PROJECT: LA CHINATOWN BROADWAY PLACEKEEPING PROJECT, LOS ANGELES
Every place has its community, and every community has their language. While planning policies define the norms of urban design, communities have different definitions of “clean” and “chaotic”, “safe” and “dangerous”, “historic” and “modern”. Every project requires a unique design dictionary.
PROJECT PROFILE:
Los Angeles’s Chinatown is a home for various ethnic communities, many of whom face the challenges of economic downturn and gentrification. The fragmentation of the communities make collective efforts harder.
The project is aimed to advocate a culturally sensitive development of the historic commercial corridor to augment the character of LA Chinatown, encourage community interaction, and enhance the economic and social sustainability.
THE KEY PRINCIPLES ARE:
• Celebrate the shared culture and build solidarity
• Alleviate the tension between preservation and development
• Integrate design solutions with planning policies and social efforts
NOT JUST CHINESE1
Phillipe HingKongChowBenevolentAssociation
LungKongTinYeeAssociation
F.SeeOn LouieFamilyAssociationLim’sFamily GeePoyKuoAssociation
C.Wong
ChewPhoenixBakery Yuen KowKongBenevolentAssociation
L.A.NewChinatownCorpLeeOnDongBenevolentAssociation FongLunAssociation YingOnAssociation
BingKongTongAssociation
HopSingTongBenevolentAssociation QuonBros.GrandStar ChineseConfuciusTempleofLosAngeles GeeTuckSamTuck Association
ChineseChamberofCommerce
SouthernCaliforniaYeeFamilyAssociation
MayflowerSeafoodRestaurant OceanPacific Pho87 LienHoaDeli&SeafoodMarketEasternInternationalBank PhoenixImports BetabelCo.
K.G.LouieCo.
QuanKwongYeeFamily
268FashionInc. SaigonDeli GoldenGiftsTradingCo. TinBo&Co 88Gifts
ChinatownServiceCenter ChineseFriends HongNingCo,Inc LuckyDeli CathayBank Queen’sBakery GoldenDragonRestaurant HongKongBBQ ImportBazaarWonderBakery PhoenixInn FooChow WonKok YangChow
JinHingJeweler
HoiYeungSeafoodCo KBCBakery JEnterprises Rainbow CheamLyHem Cindy’sShop AlterationsAlterationandDryClean BestWay YHYTradincInc. YanLeeFashion Kawaii GoldlandJewelry
SouthernCaliforniaTeoChewAssociationPhoSaigon PCTGinseng&Herbs HongCosmetic101 ManCheongGinseng&HerbsInc JadetimeEGift HopWoo KimHungBakery HongKongImportCo. B&LFashionKimHengJewelry MetroPlazaHotel Fu-ShingFengShui&Gifts
NOT JUST STOREFRONTS2
In 1960s, Mai and her family escape from China to Vietnam
In 1978, Mai and her family got on a refuge boat to escape the political persecution.
THE PEOPLE AND
STORY
A
OF
1870 1930 1960 1980 1990 2000 THEY SETTLE DOWN HERE... AT BROADWAY Food Shop Services East Asian 13% Southeast Asian 20% Chinese 60% Vendor 70% Stores 30%
Mai Tu is a 34-year-long local jeweler in Chinatown.
Data Source: 1.Census Bureau 2020; 2&3.Chinatown Community for Equitable Development; 3&4. Community groundtruthing
AND BROADWAY
HOW DOES THE COMMUNITY PERCEIVE THE SPACE?3
“Beloved”
“Touristy”
“Unnoticed”
“Unwelcome”
Parking
Vacant Buildings
Unbuilt Lots
The boat capsized but Mai got rescued and shipped to Norway and her parents to Malaysia.
“I like them. I usually go there for...”
“They are for the community!”
“They are nice but a little bit touristy.”
“They seem popular...”
“I don’t know them.”
“I think they are not open to the public.”
“They are gentrifiers with fake Asian facade.”
“I don’t feel welcomed there.”
“Who use these parking lots? ”
“Why do we need so much parking?”
“It used to be a grocery store.”
“Can the City move us there if we get evicted?”
“Why can’t they develop these lots first?”
“It’s not safe there.”
HOW ACTIVE ARE THESE SPACES OVER A DAY?4
Active Inactive
In 1983, they reunioned in LA Chinatown and Mai started her own jewelry business in 1990
In 2020, Mai got evicted to Dynasty Center. Since then Mai becomes an community activist and contually fights against gentrification in Chinatown
RESILIENCE
10 AM 1PM 4PM 6PM 9PM
GO “STREET-STROLLING”
ALLEY MAKING DEVELOPMENT
Alley is an important part of Asian culture. Traditionally, shopping in Asia always happens on streets and alleys. Even to today, Chinese people still call shopping as “street-strolling” Preserving and creating more alleys is the key to an experience-based development that offers a unique and authentic Chinatown vibe. There are a lot of potential alleys along Broadway. Therefore, the plan focuses on the “street-strolling” experience and suggests connecting the main street and cross streets with indoor and outdoor alleys. Preservation and new development should be based on the street and alley network to support a well-connected street life.
ALLEY MAKING STRATEGY
MAIN STREET CROSS STREETS
百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 新鮮 水果 限時 促銷 限時 促銷 新鮮 水果 揚州飯店
揚州飯店
CHOW 揚州飯店
CHOW 揚州飯店 YANG CHOW 揚州飯店 YANG CHOW 揚州飯店
揚州飯店 YANG CHOW 揚州飯店 YANG CHOW 揚州飯店
YANG CHOW
YANG
YANG
YANG CHOW
YANG CHOW
STREETS
Main Street
Cross Street Alley
Open Space
Cultural Preservation Zone
Existing Building
Proposed development
揚州飯店 YANG CHOW
YANG CHOW 揚州飯店 YANG CHOW
MAIN STREET
CROSS STREETS
ALLEYS
ALLEYS
永富恆參茸藥材行 Young Fu Heng Herb Co.
揚州飯店 YANG CHOW
揚州飯店 YANG CHOW
百 老 匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯百老匯 百老匯 百老匯 百老匯百老匯百老匯 百老匯百老匯 百老匯 百老匯百老匯百老匯百老匯百老匯 百老匯百老匯 百老匯百老匯
CHINATOWNLAND 揚州飯店
PLANNING TOOL: CULTURAL DISTRICT
BEFORE AFTER
FROM DAILY TO CEREMONIAL
STREET ACTIVATION
ALLEY-MAKING DEVELOPMENT-SMALL
BEFORE AFTER PLANNING TOOL: CULTURAL DISTRICT
ALLEY-MAKING DEVELOPMENT-MEDIUM
SOCIAL TOOL: BUSINESS COOPERATIVE
BEFORE AFTER
ALLEY-MAKING DEVELOPMENT-LARGE
SOCIAL TOOL: COMMUNITY LAND TRUST
BEFORE AFTER
HOW TO WORK TOGETHER
PROJECT: ELYRIA CANYON PARK COMMUNITY CO-DESIGN PROJECT, LOS ANGELES
The community always has the most knowledge of the site and often time knows the best what is needed in a project. Therefore, the best way of design is working with the experts.
PROJECT PROFILE:
Elyria Canyon is a hidden park surrounded by neighborhoods of various income levels and ethnic backgrounds. Community Nature Connection (CNC), a local organization operates the park and strives to increase public access to the park by working with the underserved communities.
The project aims to work with the community to identify the main focus of the operation of the park, design the park, and develop CNC volunteers’ capacity of collaborative design and community engagement.
THE KEY PRINCIPLES ARE:
• Mutual learning between project team and the community
• Creative engagement and collaborative design methods
• Serve the long-term operation goal of CNC
COLLABORATIVE DESIGN
WE KNOW ABOUT THE SITE
WE PLAN FOR THE SITE
WORKSHOP 1: MAP YOUR PERCEPTION
STEP1: WHO/WHAT DO YOU SEE?
STEP2: MAP YOUR FIVE SENSES
C A 2 E ys a n P a rk Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors, Microsoft, Facebook, Inc. and its affiliates, Esri Community Maps NO BUS ACCESS
NO BUS
IN
NATIVE GARDEN INSTALLMENT UNFRIENDLY ENTRY POINTS SEASONAL BIOSWALE
WHAT
SERVICES
ONE MILE AMPHITHEATER
WHAT
Entrance Parking Blocked entrance Closed entrance P
WORKSHOP 2: DESIGN BUFFET
STEP1: SHOP AND DESIGN YOUR PARK
STEP2: OOPS, NOT ENOUGH BUDGET
E lys ia n P a rk Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors, Microsoft, Facebook, Inc. and its affiliates, Esri Community Maps CYPRESSMTWASHINGTON PARK
NATIVE
AMPHITHEATER
MAP
PARK WHAT THE COMMUNITY KNOWS ABOUT THE SITE WHAT THE COMMUNITY WANT FOR THE SITE
INSTALLMENT
GARDEN
SOCIAL SEGREGATION COGNITIVE
ASSOCIATION WITH THE
Safe Cool Favorite Least favorite Hot Dangerous
SITE DESIGN
PARK DESIGN
LEGEND
THE RED BARN
DESIGN LIBRARY
Minor entrance Minor
Low-difficulty trail
Medium-difficulty trail
E E E E E E P P P 150ft 450ft 300ft E E P
Main entrances
Main entrances
entrance
Signage Recycling
Signage
Parking
Recycling Restroom Restroom Mini fountain Water feature Sitting Sitting Recreational Swing
High-difficulty trail
PLANTING LIST
California Poppy
California Fuchsia
California Lilac
Black Walnut Tree
Bush Monkey Flower
Common Yarrow
THE RED
BARN
WHAT IS THE PERSONALITY
PROJECT: THE EDGY QUARTER IN LITTLE TOKYO, LOS ANGELES
Places have their own personalities and attract their own audience. Sometimes the best way to revitalize a place is to discover and augment its character. Even features commonly assumed undesirable have their value, attractiveness, and power.
PROJECT PROFILE:
The project is located at the edge of the historic Little Tokyo, neighboring Old Chinatown, Art District, and Boyle Heights. While the site has long born a negative tag of darkness, it has also offered a shelter for people who dance in the dark.
Darkness and light, they always coexist. The project is intended to create a secret celebration venue for people who see the shadow in the light and who chase light in the darkness.
THE KEY PRINCIPLES ARE:
• Maintain the duality of day and night, “good” and “evil”
• Encourage the fusion of immigration roots and progressive culture
20’ 20’ 54’ 30’ 84’ 60’ 68’ 1 2 3 3 3 5 5 5 5 5 8 9 5 5 10 10 5 5 6 7 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 9 8 10 5 7 6 4 3 2 1 Church Museum/Gallery The edgy quarter Housing Office School Community shopping mall Fire station Bus station Arts residency 11 Arts hall 12 12 Pedestrian bridge Healthcare commercial Section cut line Detailed area Daytime traffic Nighttime traffic Boulevard (90’) Two way street (60’) Vehicle alley (20’) Pedestrian walkway (10-20’) 6 11 13 13 S1 S1 S1 S1 S1 S2 S2 S2 S2 S2 S3 S2 S2 S1 S2 S3 S4 S3 S3 S3 S4 S4 S4 S4 S4 S2 200ft 400ft 600ft
SECTION
SITE PLAN
THE EDGY QUARTER FOR THE NIGHT-BLOOMING FLOWERS
90’ 160’ 60’ 30’ 15’
HOW TO MAKE IT HAPPEN
PROJECT 1: YUZI PARK, GUILIN, CHINA
PROJECT 2: CULTURAL GOLDEN TRIANGLE DISTRICT, BEIJING, CHINA
How can the project contribute to employment? How profitable the project is? How can the project be implemented and operated in the long run? Ultimately, we need to think about it practically.
PROJECT 1 PROFILE:
Yuzi Park is an undeveloped natural resort. After years’ of investment into local art with little return, the client needed to capitalize the natural and art resources and resume the tourism of Guilin city. The project aims to propose a plan that makes the site marketable and a new cultural landmark of Guilin.
PROJECT 2 PROFILE:
Golden Triangle District is the cultural center of Beijing. The substantially high density of historic resources and outdated amenities make the area lag behind in economic vibrancy. The project aims to transform the cultural advantage of the area into economic value. The strategy is to deeply work with multiple stakeholders and create economic opportunities by innovating planning tools and operation models while maintaining the historic essence.
YUZI PARK
Guilin
Liuzhou
Nanning
Foshan
Dongguan
Changsha
Chengdu
Guangzhou Shenzhen
Zhongshan Beijing Shanghai
Tianjin
Chongqing
Wuhan
Nanjing
Suzhou
Hangzhou Ningbo
Market Size 3M 4M 2M 1M Market Accessibility High Low
Provincial Market Top-tier Market New Top-tier Market 11% 29% 34% 26%
One-day Trip ~25% Market Sizing &
~45% ~10% ~20% Short Stay of 2 to 3 days Long Stay of 3-5 days Holiday Residence 11% 36% 21% 32% 6% 36% 32% 26% Tickets Revenues Revenues Estimation: Hotel & Residence Revenues Estimation: Customer Estimation: 2025: 300M RMB/Year 2030: 1B RMB/Year 2035: 1.4B RMB/Year Accomodation Revenues Commercial Revenues Recreational Revenues 2035 2030 2025 Phase 485596 435956 145635 A. Hotel Customers 676453 563711 73476 B. Holiday Residents 1,162,049 999,667 219111 Overnight Customers 837,951 500333 380111 One- day Trip Customers 2035 2030 2025 Accommodation Projects Revenues Sales Price Revenues Sales Price Revenues Sales Price Units Project 35773650 19710 3630 30714750 18615 3300 26,280,000 17520 3000 30 Hot Spring Hotel 107320950 147825 1452 91060200 137970 1320 76,869,000 128115 1200 270 Holiday Hotel 13875840 17520 1584 11037600 15330 1440 30 Bugua House 19272000 29200 1320 15330000 25550 1200 50 Campsite 412,386,110 485596 339,616,331 435956 103,149,000 145635 900 Total
Segmentation:
The Land-Campsite
The Forest-Treehouse
The Starry Night-Theater
The Universe-VR Art Show
SPRING VILLAGE STAR VILLAGE SUNLIGHT VILLAGE Hotel Accommodation Health Preservation Recreational Holiday Residence Art Creation FOREST VILLAGE MAIN ENTRANCE STONE VILLAGE THE ARTSY PLAZA MOONLIGHT TOWN SIDE ENTRANCE 2000ft 4000ft 6000ft 14.
15.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
Park
6.
7.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
16.
17.
18.
11 6 1 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 10 12 13 14 15 16 18 17 Function Planning: Key Projects:
Family
three
The
Couple Backpacker Nuclear family
Rock Resort
Zen Retreat
Art Studio
Convention Center
Moonhill Art Center
Moonshadow Lake
Moon Life Center
Plan
Hot Spring Village
Art Cave
8.
Daydream Fairyland
Hidden Tribe
Diet Therapy Center
Senior Center
Native Garden
Tour Design by Tourist Type:
of
generations
elderly
GOLDEN TRIANGLE DISTRICT
FOUR INITIATIVES
Memory Museum
Collect historic stories and community memories of the area, create public art and community exhibitions, and post stories online.
Economic Revitalization
Develop theater, art trade, and publishing industries. Support the commercialization of art and complete the ecosystem.
Historic Community
Activate community life and enhance “Hutong” experience by creating unique cultural space and supporting traditional artists.
Cultural Consumption
Promote cultural consumption through infusing cultural scenes, co-branding with historic landmarks, and membership program.
Cultural innovation center
Central Axis of Beijing
Cultural Core
Creative Activities The Forbidden City Historic Community Cultural Tour Public Affairs Art Center Theater District Cultural Consumption International Communication Center Cultural Business Incubation Cultural consumption center 5 5 1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 6 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 10 10 500ft 1000ft 1500ft
EXEMPLARY PROJECTS
Working with the city, the project designed several public-private collaboration model, selected suitable partners, and pushed forward the implementation of several exemplary projects.
Concerts in Historic Buildings - “The Echo of History”
Zhizhu Temple is selected as the site for concerts of traditional and fusion music. The concert has now become a iconic cultural experience in Beijing and is held regularly.
Theater Incubation Center- “The Theater Factory”
Nanyang-Gongxiangji is a mixed-use theater incubation center that include a historic theater, studio space, hotel and cultural retails. Renovated and managed by a progressive developer, the project is a now an incubator for innovative plays that inherit and expand the traditional genre.
Community Cultural Center- “The Flow of Hutong Life”
Mei Hou Si Shi is a community center owned by the city and managed by a culture operator. The project innovated a public-private partnership in public space management. The center connects traditional artists and the community and has developed many self-organized art clubs.
• EAST LA FOOD GUIDE: https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/41efc5670275478db121f0948bee57cf/
• NEW CHINATOWN = NO CHINATOWN? : https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/2e21a5eb76ec4ccd84992e039af748d5
STORYTELLING EXAMPLES: