Irish Journalist - March 2014

Page 1

Irish Journalist

MARCH 2014

Official newsletter for the NUJ in Ireland

McCALL SLAMS LEO’S FOI LOBBY PURPOSE OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION IS ENSURING ACCOUNTABILITY, PRESIDENT SAYS PRESIDENT Barry McCall has accused Transport Minister Leo Varadkar of failing to understand the principles behind Freedom of Information legislation. Mr Varadkar argued in internal discussions within the government that pay and pension details of individual office holders and top public servants should not be publicly revealed. Internal government files published by The Irish Times this month revealed that Mr Varadkar was concerned that the Freedom of Information Act as currently operated “violates the privacy of individuals”. Mr Varadkar suggested pay and pension details for office holders and senior public service staff were private matters and should only be made known on an anonymised basis. His comments were contained in official observations submitted to the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform by the Department of Transport as part of its internal consultation process in the run-up to the publication of proposed reforms to the legislation last summer. The Freedom of Information Bill IS currently awaiting report stage in the Dáil and is expected to be enacted in the first half of the year. Files released by the Department OF Public Expenditure and Reform reveal intense lobbying from departments, agencies and ministers to have particular areas under their jurisdiction removed from the scope of the new legislation. The submission from the Department of Transport said: “The Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport is not satisfied by the current

COIMISNÉIR TEANGA NUA NUJ member Rónán Ó Domhnaill has been appointed An Coimisinéir Teanga by the President of Ireland, Michael D. Higgins. On hand to witness the appointment were Ronan’s wife and fellow NUJ member Irene Ní Nualláin and their two children Róisin (2) and Maeve (1). Ronan, who recently resigned as political correspondent with Nuacht RTÉ/TG4, succeeds another NUJ member, Seán Ó Cuirreáin. See full report on page six. Photo: Maxwell. operation of the Freedom of Information Act. The Department of Transport said details of letters and representations made by the public to ministers which were considered to be privileged

“Minister Varadkar has failed to see the point - the central purpose of FOI legislation is to ensure that accountability, and removing such pay and pension deals from it would have represented a retrograde step on the part of the government.” if sent to the Oireachtas should also be considered to be privileged if sent to departmental offices. “Similarly, the remuneration and pension details of individual office holders and other senior public employees are private and should not be disclosed. The information can be given in an anonymised format as is the case for other public employees,” a statement said. “The fees should reflect both actual cost in administration time and also the opportunity cost of work not done in the time taken up in replying to Freedom of Information requests.” Commenting on the revelation Barry McCall called for a better understanding of FOI. “It appears Minister Varadkar has failed to see

the point in including senior office holders and public servants in the revised legislation. Individuals who may have had a direct hand in or even indirect influence over their pay and pension deals should not be able to hide behind the cloak of personal privacy when it comes to accountability for spending taxpayers’ money. “The central purpose of FOI legislation is to ensure that accountability, and removing such pay and pension deals from it would have represented a retrograde step on the part of the government,” the President said. Séamus Dooley, NUJ Irish Secretary, said it was “extremely ironic that Mr Varadkar should seek to influence FOI legislation through behind the scenes lobbying.”

INSIDE THIS ISSUE PAGE 2: PREPARING FOR DM AND ELECTION NEWS PAGE 3: INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY PAGES 4 & 5: THE BIG DEBATE ON THE EIGHTH AMENDMENT PAGE 6 & 7: IRISH LANGUAGE NEWS AND VIEWS


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Irish Journalist - March 2014 by National Union of Journalists - Issuu