Regeneration of Industrial Sites and Regional Development:
A Case Study of Xi'an Old Steel Factory Design and Creative Industrial Park
WANG YUYANG
A0283875L
Dissertation submitted to Departure of Architecture in Partial fulfillment of the requirement for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN ARCHITECTURAL CONSERVATION at the DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE
Supervisor: Prof Johannes Widodo April 2024
Abstract
The Xi'an Old Steel Factory represents a microcosm of the industrialisation of Xi'an and the whole country in the 1950s and 1960s. It embodied the aspirations of a generation and witnessed the transformation of the city's industrialisation. Currently, it is undergoing a transformation, moving from its previous state as an abandoned factory building to a brand new creative industry park. The entire park underwent a comprehensive renovation in 2016, becoming the inaugural cultural and creative park in Xi'an with design and creativity as its core theme
As urbanisation continues to accelerate globally, the protection and utilisation of industrial heritage is becoming a crucial aspect of urban development Industrial heritage not only encapsulates the industrial history and culture of a region, but also serves as an important symbol of urban memory and identity As an important industrial city in Northwest China, Xi'an has a large number of historic factories, including old steel mills and textile mills
This study aims to comprehensively analyse the renovation strategies of the old steel mills and their effects. Furthermore, it seeks to gain insight into how industrial heritage can be preserved and utilised. It also provides strategies and methods for sustainable urban development and industrial heritage preservation. This is an important case study in urban transformation and development.
Keywords: Industrial Heritage Conservation, Sustainable Development, Building Renovation, Economic Model Innovation
Acknowledgement
This concludes the writing of the thesis and brings to a close the end of my postgraduate studies. In completing this thesis, I would like to thank my advisor, Professor Johannes Widodo, for guiding me in the selection of the topic and the professional literature, which made it possible for me to complete my thesis. I would also like to express my gratitude to three other professors Dr. Ho Puay Peng, Dr. Wong Yunn Chii and Dr. Nikhil Joshi, who have imparted their knowledge to me. During my year of study in Singapore, the professors provided invaluable assistance and guidance, enabling me to gain knowledge and skills that I had not previously encountered
I would also like to express my gratitude to my classmates and friends for their care and encouragement, which has fostered a strong sense of friendship throughout the year Finally, I would like to thank my parents Their unconditional love and support have been instrumental in shaping me into the person I am today
ChapterI:Introduction
1.1Background
TheXi'anOldSteelFactory,previouslyknownastheShaanxiIronandSteel Factory,wasconstructedin1958.Asoneofthemostsignificantindustrialbases inNorthwestChina,itwitnessedthehistoricalprocessofChina'stransformation fromatraditionalindustrialeconomytoamodernservice-basedeconomy.The plantissituatedinthecentreofXi'anandcoversavastarea.Ithasundergonea processofrapiddevelopment,declineandthenshutdown.Followingtheofficial shutdownin2002,thesitewasabandonedforaconsiderableperioduntilitwas acquiredbyXi'anUniversityofArchitecture
In2012,theXi'anOldSteelFactorywastransformedintotheXi'anOldSteel FactoryDesignandCreativeIndustryPark,whichhastheobjectiveofpromoting theoptimisationoftheregionaleconomicstructureandthevitalityofthesociety andculturethroughtheintroductionoftheculturalandcreativeindustries.The objectiveistoenhancetheregionaleconomicstructureandsocialandcultural
Figure1Aerialviewoftheplant(PhotoedbyPremierUrbanRegenerationGroup)
vitalitythroughtheintroductionofculturalandcreativeindustries.
1.2Importanceandnecessityofthestudy
Theaccelerationofglobalisationandurbanisationhasledtoanincreased focusonthepreservationandutilisationofindustrialheritage.Industrial heritagenotonlycarriestheindustrialhistoryandcultureofaregion,butisalso animportantmarkerofurbanmemoryandidentity.Thesignificanceof renewingandrenovatingoldindustrialbuildingsismuchhigherthantheir economicvalue.Xi'anisanimportantindustrialcityinNorthwestChina,with manyoldfactories,includingoldsteelfactoriesandtextilefactoriesThe developmentofindustrialheritageintotouristattractionshasthepotentialto increasethenumberofindustrialvisits,leadingtotheformationofunique touristroutesinXi'anTheseroutesprovidetouristswithmoreleisureand tourismvenues,showcasingadiversifiedtourismbusinesscardforXi'an
Inrecentyears,theindustrialstructureofXi'anhasundergoneasignificant transformation,withtheproportionoftheoutputvalueoftertiaryindustries suchastourismandservicessteadilyincreasing.Thetransformationofold factorybuildingsintoculturalandcreativeparksisanillustrativeexampleof Xi'an'ssecondaryindustryevolvingintoatertiaryindustry.Theprudent utilisationofdiscontinuedfactorybuildingsandequipment,coupledwithan in-depthexplorationoftheirculturalconnotationsandregenerationpotential, hasledtotheestablishmentofpublicculturalfacilities,thedevelopmentof culturalandcreativeindustries,theincubationofnewculturalandcreative
products,andtheattractionofmoresocialandexperientialconsumption.These initiativeshaveresultedinthegenerationofeconomicbenefitsforcommunities andneighbourhoods,andthecreationofneweconomicgrowthpoints.
Theprotectionofindustrialheritagecanbeconsideredaformofecological protection.Thetransformationofsomeabandonedfactorybuildingsinto industrialtouristattractionsorcreativeparkshasthepotentialtoenhancethe urbanlandscape,optimisethearchitecturalpatternofthecity,upgradethecity's image,reducetheoperationandemissionsofthecity'sheavyindustrialfactories, andcontributetotheimprovementofairqualityandthelivingenvironmentof theresidentsThisalignswiththecity'sconceptof"greendevelopment"Inthe contextofrapideconomicdevelopment,thereisaglobalwaveofindustrial heritagetransformationTheindustrialheritageresourcesinXi'anprovide favourablegeographicalconditionsforthedevelopmentofcreativeindustrial parks,aswellasofferingmorespaceforthedevelopmentofindustrialtourismin Xi'anThroughtherationalplanningandutilisationofindustrialheritage,the historicalandculturalheritageofthecitycanbepromoted.This,inturn,can facilitatethegreeneconomicdevelopmentofthecityandenhancethe competitivenessofthecitycore.
TheXi'anOldSteelFactoryVentureParkRenovationProjectexemplifiesthe potentialfortherenewalandprotectionofindustrialarchitecturalheritage.An in-depthanalysisoftherenovationprocessoffersinsightsintothewaysinwhich industrialheritagecanbepreserved.Italsodemonstrateshowindustrial
heritagereplacementandrenovationcanbeusedtopromotesustainable economicandsocialdevelopmentandtorevitaliseoldbuildings.Furthermore, theOldSteelFactoryprojecthastheparticipationandsupportofgovernment authorities.Thestudycanassistpolicymakersintheformulationofpoliciesand theprovisionofinsightsfortheconservationandreuseofothersimilar industrialheritagesites.
1.3ObjectivesandIssues
Theprimaryfocusofthispaperisthedesignandcreativeindustrialparkof theformersteelfactoryinXi'anThetransformationstrategyoftheformersteel factoryismeticulouslyanalysedandresearchedTheexistingproblemsand challengesoftheindustrialparkaresummarisedinrelationtotheeconomic, socialandculturalchangesandstatusquobeforeandafterthetransformationof theXi'anOldSteelFactoryTheeffectivenessofthecurrenttransformation strategyanditsperformanceintermsofenvironmentalsustainabilityare evaluatedFurthermore,strategiesandmethodsforenhancingthesuccessrate ofindustrialheritagetransformationmustbefurtherexplored.
Theresearchquestionsincludethefollowing:Whatarethesuccessesand shortcomingsinthetransformationstrategyoftheXi'anOldSteelFactory?How cantheeconomicandculturalvalueofindustrialheritagebeoptimisedthrough themodelofcreativeindustrialpark?Whatrolehassustainabilityplayedinthe transformationoftheoldsteelfactory,andwhatarethepotentialandchallenges forthefuture?
1.4Methodologyanddatasources
Thisstudyemploysaqualitativeresearchmethodologytoinvestigatethe transformationprocessoftheoldsteelfactoryinXi'an.Thestudyprimarily employsacasestudyapproachtodatacollection,whichreliesontwomaindata types:documentanalysisandsecondarydata.Documentanalysisinvolvesthe collectionandanalysisofofficialdocuments,includinggovernmentreports,park planningdocuments,historicalarchives,andotherofficialdocuments,to examinethearchitecturalstatusandproblemsoftheoldsteelfactory.Secondary datareferstodatacollectedfrompublishedresearch,newsreports,andonline resourcesInordertogainamorecomprehensiveunderstandingofthecase, relevantbackgroundinformationandcasedataarecollectedandanalysed quantitativelyThisisachievedthroughtheuseofpublishedresearch,news reportsandonlineresourcesThestudywillanalysetheprojectindetailinorder toassessitsstrengths,weaknesses,opportunitiesandthreatsFurthermore,the impactofmacro-environmentalfactorssuchaspolicy,economic,socialand technologicalenvironmentwillbeexamined.
Chapter2:Historicalbackgroundandcurrentsituationoftheoldsteel
FactoryinXi'an
2.1HistoryoftheOldXi'anSteelFactory
TheXi'anOldSteelWorks(alsoknownasXi'anIronandSteelWorks)is situatedintheheartofmainlandChina,inthecityofXi'an,ShaanxiProvince. Thislocationfacilitatestheefficientreceptionofrawmaterialsthroughoutthe country,therebyreducingtransportationcostsandmakingthetransportof productsmoreconvenient.Itshistoryrepresentsanimportantchapterinthe industrialhistoryofNorthwestChinaTheplantwasestablishedin1958asthe ShaanxiIronandSteelWorks,relocatedtoXi'anin1964,andrenamedtheXi'an IronandSteelWorksin1965followingamergerwithaworkshopoftheDalian IronandSteelWorksDuringitsearlyyears,theplantbecameanimportant industrialbaseinShaanxi,particularlyduringtheperiodofeconomicrecovery anddevelopmentinthe1960sand1970sOverthefollowingdecades,theplant underwentsignificantexpansion,becomingamajorsteelproductioncentrein thenorth-westernregion.Theplant'sprincipalproductsareconstructionsteel, machinerysteelandtoolsteel,whichplayanimportantroleinsupporting China'sinfrastructureandindustrialmachinerysectors.
By1978,China'seconomicreformsandopeninguphadfurtherfuelledthe demandforsteel,whilesimultaneouslyraisingthebaronsteelqualityand technology.Inresponse,Xi'anSteelattractedforeigninvestmenttolearnabout technology,expanditsownproductionscale,andimprovethequalityofits
productstomeetmarketrequirements.Subsequently,inthe1980s,theXi'an SteelFactoryunderwentanumberoftechnologicalupgradestoincreaseits productioncapacityandautomation,andreachedthepeakofitsoperations.
However,inthe1990s,China'ssteelindustrysufferedfromovercapacity, resultingintheclosureofnumeroussteelfactories,includingXi'anSteel.In response,theplantshifteditsfocustohigher-valuespecialtysteelsandventured intonon-steelareassuchasenvironmentalprotectionandnewmaterialsinan attempttoidentifyanewpathofdevelopment.
Figure2FormerShaanxiSteelFactory
Bythebeginningofthe21stcentury,environmentalpressuresanddeclining marketdemandledtotheclosureoftheplantin2002In2012,the redevelopmentoftheOldSteelFactorycommencedTheOldSteelFactorywas transformedfromadilapidatedfactorybuildingthathadbeenabandonedforten yearsintoanewculturalandcreativeparkTheredevelopmentnotonly preservedsomeoftheoldindustrialbuildings,butalsointegratedthemwith newfacilitiessuchasexhibitionhalls,artstudiosandcommercialspacesThe
introductionofanewindustrialmodelwhilepreservingtheindustrialheritageis intendedtofacilitatetheeconomicdevelopmentofthearea.
22ThecurrentstateoftheindustrialheritageofXi'anOldSteelFactory Xi'anOldSteelFactoryisasignificanthistoricalsitethatexemplifiesthe industrialisationofChinaduringthe20thcenturyThefactorycomplex comprisesnumerousindustrialbuildingsconstructedduringthemid-20th century,whichnotonlyreflecttheindustrialisationofXi'anandthecountryasa wholebutalsoencapsulatetheaspirationsandmemoriesofagenerationThe majorityofthebuildingsattheOldSteelFactorywereconstructedinthe1950s and1960s,exhibitingclearcharacteristicsoftheindustrialera.
Thebuildingsarevoluminousinscale,withtheirinternalstructures comprisingpredominantlylarge-spantrussstructures.Theinternalheightofthe plantisconsiderable,withthespacebeingopen.Thelightingconditionswithin theplantaregenerallypoor,andthehighwindowsonthesideandtheskylights ontheroofdonotmeetthelightingrequirementsofmodernbuildings.Atthe
Figure3Steelplantinternaltrussstructure
sametime,theredbrickwallsontheoutsideofthefactorybuildingsarealsoone ofthetypicalfeaturesofindustrialbuildingsinthelastcentury.Inadditiontoa largenumberoffactorybuildingsinthepark,therearealsoleftoverchimneys, workshoptracks,gearsandothermechanicalparts.Theindustrialremainsare thefocusoftherenovationprocessandmustbepreserved.Duringthe renovationprocess,thebuildingstructureandthebasicindustrialarchitectural featureshavebeenpreservedtothegreatestextentpossible.Theoriginal structureofthebuildingplantwaslargelypreserved.Inordertomeetthebasic conditionsfortheuseofthebuilding,someofthebuildingswereheightenedand structurallyreinforcedConcurrently,skylightsandsidewindowswereinstalled insomeofthepoorlylitbuildings,therebyensuringthattherenovatedbuilding wasadequatelyilluminatedDuringtheconstructionphase,thefunctionalityand comfortoftherenovatedbuildingweretheprimaryconsiderationsinthedesign processInthiscontext,theoriginalfeaturesofthebuildingasanindustrialsite werepreservedtothegreatestextentpossible
Figure4Picturesoftherenovatedcampusbuildings
Withregardtotheenvironmentalandlandscaperenovationofthepark,the originalflowerbedsandtreeswerelargelyretained.Treesthatweredeemedto beofnofurtherusewererelocatedandpreserved,whilenewgreenvegetation andactivitysquareswereintroduced.Concurrently,industrialfittingssuchas acidwashingtankswithintheplantweretransformedintoflowerbeds,thereby significantlyincreasingthegreeningrateofthepark.Chimneys,workshoprails, gearsandothermechanicalfittingswerealsoutilisedtothemaximumextent.A significantproportionofthesurplusmachineryfittingshavebeenrepurposedas architecturalsketchesandlandscapesculptures,whichhavebecomeanintegral componentofthepark'slandscapeandaculturalsymbolthatconnectsthe presentwiththefuture
23Fromindustrialsitetoculturalandcreativepark
ThetransformationoftheformerXi'anOldSteelFactoryintoamodern creativeindustrialparkrepresentsapivotalmomentinXi'an'surban developmentFromitsoriginsasatraditionalproductionbaseforthesteel industry,theareahasevolvedintoaregionalculturalandcreativehubthat integratesdesignandcreativity.Thetransformationoftheoldsteelfactoryhas infusedthecitywithneweconomicvitality,whilealsoofferinganovel perspectiveonthepreservationandutilisationofindustrialheritage.
In2012,theScienceandEducationIndustryGroupofXi'anUniversityof ArchitectureandTechnology(XAUAT)acquiredthelong-abandonedfactory.The acquisition,apartnershipwiththegovernmentandseveralcompanies,marked
therebirthoftheoldsteelfactoryandthebeginningofitstransformationintoan industrialheritagesite.Thesubsequentredevelopmentprocesshasnotonly preservedthehistoricallegacyofthefactory.Furthermore,adynamicmixofart andcommercialspaceswasintroduced,whichhasrevitalisedtheareaand contributedtotheculturalandeconomiclandscapeofXi'an.
Theoriginalfactoryhasbeentransformedintothreemajorareas.Thenorth areaistheteachingarea,locatedinHuaqingCollegeofXi'anUniversityof ArchitectureandTechnology.Thesouthareaistherealestatearea,whichhas beenconstructedasthefirstphaseofHuaqingAcademyCityThesecondphase iscurrentlyunderdevelopmentandconstructionThenortheastpartoftheold steelfactoryisbeingtransformedintoadesignandcreativeindustrialpark
Figure51.Artist'sStudio(oldfactoryconverted)2.Shop(new)3.StudentDormitory Building4.Shop(oldfactoryconverted)5.CentrePlaza6.SunkenPlaza7.ArtCentre(old factoryconverted)
TheDesignandCreativeIndustrialParkoftheOldSteelFactorycoversan areaofapproximately50acres,withatotalconstructionareaofapproximately 40,000squaremetres.Theoverallplanisdividedintofourparts:thepark consistsoffourdifferentzones:acreativeexhibitionandexchangecentre,a LOFTcreativeeco-officezone,acreativeneighbourhoodandastudentzone.The parkcomprisesfourdistinctzones:theCreativeExhibitionandCommunication Centre,theLOFTCreativeEcologicalOfficeZone,theCreativeNeighbourhood andtheStudentZone.Itnotonlyreflectstheartisticvigourandfashionablespirit ofthecity,butalsorealisesthecontinuationofthecultureofindustrial architectureandprovidesamodelforurbanregenerationconstruction
From2012to2016,theprincipaltransformationoftheformersteelfactory buildingwasessentiallycompleted,andtheparkwithafocusondesignand creativitywasinaugurated,establishingitselfasaculturalandcreativecentrein Xi'anandeveninthenorthwesternregionTherenovatedparkcomprisesa creativeexhibitionandexchangecentre,aLOFTcreativeeco-officearea,a creativeblockandauniversitystudents'entrepreneurshipcentre,which collectivelyconstituteamultifunctionalculturalandcreativespace.Thedifferent areadivisionshaveestablishedarobustfoundationforthefuturedevelopment oftheOldSteelFactory.Inthesubsequentoperationalphase,thefunctional areasoftheOldSteelFactoryalignwiththecommercialbusiness.Inadditionto providingcreativeofficespace,theparkhasalsoattractedanumberofcultural andcommercialbusinesses,includingphotographyagencies,experienceshops
andthemehotels.Alargenumberofcateringandleisurefacilitieshavealsobeen establishedtomeetthedifferentneedsofvisitors.Furthermore,amuseumhas beenbuiltinthepark,whichregularlyorganisesculturalactivitiessuchasdesign exchangesandartexhibitions.Themuseumhasbecomeanimportantvenuefor promotingregionalculturalexchanges.Thetransformationoftheformersteel factoryhasenhancedtheeconomicvalueoftheneighbourhood,attracteda significantnumberofcreativeindustries,andprovidedmoreemployment opportunitiesforlocalresidents,therebycontributingtothecommunity's economicdevelopment
24Analysisofexistingissues
241Problemsofeconomicmodelling
Accordingtotheofficialpublicdataoftheoldsteelworks,approximately 179enterprisesandcommercialtenantsarecurrentlystationedintheOldSteel StudioCreativeIndustrialPark,whichemploysapproximately2,000individuals andhasanannualoutputvalueofmorethan1billionyuanTheDesign,Fileand SteelCreativeIndustrialParkcurrentlyhousesapproximately150enterprises andtenants,whichemployapproximately2,000individualsandhaveanannual outputvalueofoverRMB1billion.TheParkhasattractedanumberof innovativeenterprises,includingthoseengagedindesign,textilecreation,and internettechnology.Thesehaveformedadesignindustryclusterwithcreative offices,textilecommerce,andexhibitionsastheindustrialstructure.
ThedataindicatesthattheindustriestowhichenterprisesintheOldSteel
Factorycurrentlybelongcanbebroadlycategorisedasfollows:scientific researchandtechnicalservices,construction,wholesaleandretailtrade,and culture,sportsandentertainment.Enterprisesrelatedtothescientificresearch andtechnologyservicesindustryrelyonexpertiseandtechnologicalinnovation, andhavehighvalue-addedpotentialandmarketdemand.Marketcompetitionin theseindustriesisusuallymoreintenseintheconstruction,wholesaleandretail sectors,requiringattentiontoindustrytrendsandpolicyadjustments.In contrast,theculture,sportsandentertainmentindustryismoreaffectedby consumerpreferences,anditsmarketperformancemaybemorevolatile
Theanalysisoftheaforementioneddataindicatesthatthebusinessmodelof thetraditionalsteelfactoriesisrelativelyhomogeneous,andthattheirbusiness statusishighlysusceptibletotheimpactofthemarketeconomicsituationIn particular,duringperiodsofeconomicdownturn,theprofitmodelofindustrial parksislikelytosufferasignificantimpact
242Challengesofculturalandhistoricalpreservation
ThetransformationoftheoldsteelfactoryindustrialparkinXi'anpresents asignificantchallengeinbalancingtheprotectionofexistingindustrialheritage withtheneedforredevelopment.Theoriginalbuildingsoftheoldsteelfactory representasignificantarchitecturallegacyfromthelastcentury.However,when therenovationcommencedin2012,theoldsteelfactorywasnotincludedinthe listofShaanxiProvince'sarchitecturalheritage,resultingintheincompleteand imperfectpreservationoftheoriginalbuildingsduringtherenovationprocess.In
2018,theoldsteelfactorywasformallyincludedinthelistofindustrialheritage protection.Thisdesignationsignifiestheimplementationofmorerigorous architecturalprotectionstandardsandnorms,withtheobjectiveofensuringthe preservationoftheoriginalbuildingduringtherenovationprocess.
Someofthelow-risefactoryandofficebuildingsthatexistedonthesite weredemolishedbecausetheydidnotalignwiththeoverarchingplanforthe renovation.Theremainingbuildingsandfactoriesunderwentrenovation,yetthe resultingoutcomedidnotfullyalignwiththecommercialisationrequirements.
Followingtheconstructionoftheparkanditssubsequentopening,thesitehas undergonenumerousrenovationsandrefurbishmentsOneofthemost significantchallengesfacingthetransformationofindustrialheritageisthe revitalisationoforiginalindustrialbuildingswhilemaintainingtheiroriginal appearanceandstructureItisessentialtoensurethatthebuildingsare preservedwhilealsofacilitatingsustainableeconomicdevelopmentduringthe commercialisationprocessThechallengefacedbyoldsteelfactoriesbetween commercialisationandculturalandhistoricalpreservationistofindabalance betweenthecommercialinterestsoftheownersandthepreservationofthe originalculturalvaluesofthebuildings.
2.4.3Statusofsustainabledevelopment
Theprocessofurbanisationhasledtotheemergenceofsustainable developmentasakeytopicinthediscourseofmodernsociety.Theconstruction oflow-carbonorevenzero-carbonbuildingshasbecomeaprevalenttrendand
goalinthefieldofcommercialbuildingdevelopment.Theconceptofsustainable developmentrepresentsasignificantchallengecurrentlyfacedbytheoldsteel factory.
Withregardtotheutilisationofspace,itisevidentthatcertainareaswithin theparkcontinuetoexperienceunder-utilisation.Theflowplanoftheentire parkhasthepotentialtoresultinanunevendistributionofpeopleanda correspondinglowlevelofspaceutilisation.Intermsofbuildingenergy consumption,theoldsteelfactorybuildingsarepredominantlyindustrial structuresfromthelastcenturyThequalityofthebuildingsvaries,necessitating theuseofasignificantquantityofconstructionmaterialsduringtherenovation processtomaintainandrepairtheoriginalstructuresFurthermore,the subsequentoperationprocessrequiresasubstantialinternalenergy consumptiontoensurethatthebuilding'stemperatureandlightingmeetthe needsofdailyuseThisnotonlyincreasestheoperatingcostsoftheentirepark, butalsofailstoalignwiththeprinciplesofsustainabledevelopment
Withregardtogreeningandecologicalmaintenance,althoughasignificant quantityoforiginalvegetationhasbeenretainedandsomenewgreeneryhas beenintroduced,aconsiderableamountofhardpavingremainsinthepark.Such adesignisnotinaccordancewiththeeco-friendlyconcept.
Chapter3:Theoreticalframeworkandliteraturereview
Thischapterpresentsatheoreticalframeworkforurbanredevelopment, withareviewofrelevantliteratureonthefollowingtopics:basictheoriesof urbanredevelopment,thepreservationofindustrialheritage,theapplicationof sustainabledevelopment,andtheinnovationoftheeconomicmodelofcultural andcreativeparks.
3.1TheoreticalFoundationsofUrbanRedevelopment
Thetheoryofurbanredevelopmentemphasisesthepromotionofeconomic growthandsocialprogressthroughthetransformationandreuseofurban spacesThistheorypositsthattheeffectiveutilisationofurbanspacescan addressissuesofurbandeclineandresourcewastage,enhancecityappealby upgradingurbanfunctions,andbeautifytheenvironmentUrbanredevelopment involvesnotonlytherenewalofphysicalspacesbutalsotheoptimisationof economicstructuresandcommunityfunctions
Oneofthekeyelementsofurbanredevelopmentistherenewaland transformationofindustrialheritage,whichencompassesthepreservationand adaptivereuseofhistoricalbuildings.Thisprocessnotonlypreservesacity's historicalandculturalheritagebutalsohelpstorestoreeconomicandsocial vitalitytoageingdistricts.Toillustrate,theconversionofderelictindustrial zonesintoculturalandcreativeparkspreserveshistoricalheritagewhile providingspacesthatfosterthedevelopmentofculturalandcreativeindustries.
AcaseinpointisBeijing's798ArtDistrict,whichprovidesaclearillustrationof
thetheoreticalandpracticalbenefitsofurbanredevelopmentthroughits successfultransformation.Thismodelexemplifiesthedualgainsofcultural preservationandeconomicrevitalisation,servingasabenchmarkforsimilar projectsworldwide.
3.2Industrialheritagepreservation
Industrialheritageisaproductofaneraandawitnesstothedevelopment ofthecity.Itcarriesmanysocialmemories.Conservationandreuseofsome abandonedoldindustrialbuildingsnotonlypreservesthetracesoftheindustrial erabutalsopreservesthememoryofthecityInthecontextofcontemporary urbanisation,initiativessuchastheconservationandreuseofindustrialheritage, exemplifiedbytheOldSteelFactory,canfacilitatethepreservationofresources andurbancosts,therecreationofhistoricalmemories,andtheinjectionofnew vitalityintotheoldindustrialspaceaswellasthesurroundingareaInorderto ensurethepreservationofindustrialheritage,itisessentialtoconsiderits historical,culturalandeconomicvalues
3.3ApplicationofSustainableDevelopmentinUrbanRedevelopment
Sustainabledevelopmentisanintegralcomponentofcontemporaryurban redevelopmentandencompassesthreeprimarydimensions:environmental protection,socialjustice,andeconomicefficiency.Theintegrationof sustainabilityprinciplesintourbanredevelopmentnecessitatesthe establishmentofabalancedrelationshipbetweenthesethreedimensions.The utilisationofgreenbuildingmaterials,theenhancementofenergyefficiency
standards,andtheexpansionofgreenspaceswithinpublicdomainsrepresent effectivestrategiesfortherealisationofsustainabledevelopment.TheKeppel BayTowerinSingaporeexemplifiesasustainablecommercialbuildingoperation throughtheimplementationofefficientenergymanagementandgreenbuilding design.Theimplementationofsustainabledevelopmentprinciplesinurban redevelopmentnotonlymitigatesenvironmentalimpactsandenhancesenergy efficiency,butalsoenhancesthequalityoflifeandeconomicwell-beingof residents.
34Innovationofeconomicmodellinginculturalandcreativeparks
Theinnovationoftheeconomicmodelofculturalandcreativeparksis reflectedintheenhancementofmarketcompetitivenessthroughdiversified businessstrategiesTheseincludediversificationofrentalincome,development ofcreativeproducts,andorganisationofculturalactivitiesForexample, Beijing's798ArtZoneandShanghai'sTianzifangnotonlyrelyontraditional rentalincome,butalsoattractvisitorsandincreaseincomebyorganisingart exhibitions,creativebazaars,culturalactivities,andothermeans.Theyhave achievedadualenhancementofcommercialvalueandculturalvalue. Furthermore,byprovidingmulti-functionalspacesforbusinessincubation, artists'studios,designcompanies,andothersimilarentities,theseparkshave attractedentrepreneursandartistsfromdiversefields,therebyfosteringthe clusteringeffectofcreativeindustries.Thisnotonlypromotesculturaldiversity butalsofacilitatestheinnovationofeconomicmodels.
Chapter4:Improvementsandinnovationsineconomicmodelling
AlthoughthetransformationoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryhasbeen successfulintransforminganabandonedindustrialsiteintoavibrantcultural andcreativeindustrialpark,therearenumerousunstablefactorsinitsexisting economicmodelandbusinessmode.Suchinstabilitywillleadtomany difficultiesandchallengesinthecommercialoperationoftheoldsteelfactory.
4.1Limitationsofcurrenteconomicmodelling
ThetransformationoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreative IndustryParkhasbeenapositivedevelopmentthathasledtothediversification oftheregionaleconomyandthecreationofculturalvalueforsocietyHowever, thepark'seconomicmodelhassomelimitationsthatmayhinderitslong-term developmentandcompetitiveness
Fromtheperspectiveofeconomicincomesources,thepark'smainsourceof economicincomeisrelativelyhomogeneous,relyingmainlyonrentalincomeA morehomogeneoussourceofincomecanleadtounstableincomeandincreased businessrisksintheeventofeconomicfluctuationsorincreasedmarket competition.Suchafinancialmodelislessstable.Inparticular,duringan economicdownturn,theparkwillfacegreatereconomicpressure.Theoperating conditionsofthetenantswilldirectlyaffecttheeconomicreturnsofthepark.
Areviewofthetenantlistrevealsadiverserangeofenterprises, encompassingvaryingdegreesofbusinessactivityandeconomicvitality.These enterprisesspanamultitudeofsectors,includingwholesaleandretail,
construction,scientificandtechnologicalservices,cultureandentertainment, amongothers.Thisdemonstratesanotabledegreeofindustrydiversification.
Thenumberofinsuredindividualscanberegardedasanindicatorofthe park'seconomicstabilityandanindicatoroftheactivity,scaleandstabilityof enterprises.Thenumberofparticipantsoftheresidentmerchantsrangesfroma fewtodozens,whichindicatesthattherearesignificantdifferencesinthesizeof enterprisesandpoorstability.Intermsofeconomicvitality,theregistered capitalofenterprisesrangesfrom500,000yuanto50millionyuan.Higher registeredcapitals,suchas50millionyuanofXi'anKelinEngineeringConsulting GroupCo,Ltd,signifystrongfinancialstrengthandmarketcompetitiveness Thesecompanieswithgreatereconomicstrengthplayapositiveroleinthe subsequentstableoperationoftheparkIntermsofindustrypositioning, enterprisesinthescienceandtechnologyservicessectorhavehighvalue-added potentialduetothedemandforexpertiseandtechnologicalinnovation Conversely,thoseintheconstructionandcultureandentertainmentsectors needtopaycloseattentiontomarkettrendsandchangesinconsumer preferences.
Althoughenterprisesintheparkpossessacertaindegreeofmarket dynamism,theoverallstabilityofenterprisesintheparkispoor,andtheyare vulnerabletofluctuationsinthemarketeconomicsituation.Thishasadirect impactonthepark'srevenueanddailyoperations.Therefore,themanagement oftheparkmustpayattentiontothepolicytrendsandadjustthebusiness
strategyintimetoensurethattheenterprisecandevelopstablyinthechanging marketenvironment.However,theinitialinvestmentanddailymaintenance costsofcreativeindustryparksareveryhigh,requiringalargeamountofinitial investment.Thereturncycleoftheseinvestmentsisrelativelylong.The combinationofahighinitialinvestmentandalongcapitalpaybackperiodcan leadtoliquidityproblems,especiallyifthecapitalchainistight.Thislong paybackmodelwill,toacertainextent,limittheflexibilityoftheparkandits abilitytorespondquicklytomarketchanges,whichisnotconducivetothe park'sabilitytoadjustitsstrategytorespondtomarketchangeswithinashort periodoftime
Inadditiontocollaborationwithtenants,thedevelopmentoftheparkalso dependsongovernmentpolicysupport,includingfinancialsubsidiesandtax incentivesUncertaintyandchangesinpolicieswillhaveasignificantimpacton theoperationofthepark,makingthestabilityofthepark'soperationlessstable ItcanbeseenthattheOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrialPark requiresaddressingtheunstableeconomicmodelthroughstrategicadjustments andeconomicmodelinnovation.Anumberofmeasurescanbetakentoenhance thepark'seconomicvitalityandcompetitiveness,therebyensuringits sustainabilityinthefaceofmarketvolatility.Theseincludediversifyingincome sources,shorteningthecycleofcapitalreturn,enhancingmarket competitiveness,andreducingrelianceonpolicies.
4.2Recommendationsforimprovementstrategies
WhiletheeconomicmodeloftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreative IndustrialParkhascontributedtoacertainextenttothediversificationofthe regionaleconomyandthecreationofculturalvalue,thelimitationsitfaces,such asasinglesourceofincomeandalongcapitalrepatriationcycle,mayhinderits long-termdevelopmentandcompetitiveness.Inordertoaddressthese limitations,theparkcanadoptthefollowingstrategies,whichhavebeen informedbyacomparativeanalysisofindustrialparkbusinessmodelsinother countriesandregions
421Increasingthediversityofrevenuesources
Itisofparamountimportancetodiversifyrevenuesourcesinorderto mitigatetheeffectsofeconomicvolatilityOnewaytoachievethisistodevelop multi-purposespaces,whichcanbeusedforavarietyofpurposesForinstance, asimilarapproachcouldbetakentothatofBeijing's798ArtZone,which combinesartexhibitionswithcommercialretailandcateringservicesThe existingfactorybuildingsintheparkhavealargevolumeofinternalspaceand highfloorheights,whichcannotonlymeetthespacerequirementsofmostly exhibitions,butalsomeettherequirementsofvenuesforsmalland medium-sizedperformances.Inadditiontoregularartexhibitionsindifferent fieldstoattractvisitors,itisalsopossibletoorganisearichvarietyof performances,suchassmallconcerts,talkshows,etc.Throughsuch performances,thestareffectcanbeexploited.Thecelebrityeffectofsuch
performancescanbeutilisedtoattractawiderrangeofvisitors.Diversifyingthe useofspacewithintheparkwillincreasetheflowofpeopleandattractmore groupstospendmoneyinthepark,whichwillfurtherincreasetheincomeofthe retailandcateringindustriesinthepark.Thiswillhelptostabilisetheeconomic modeloftheparkbyincreasingthedependenceofthetenantsonthepark.
Furthermore,theparkcanintroducethesharingeconomymodel,which wouldprovidesharedresourcesandservicestoenhanceitscompetitiveness, thusfurtherenrichingthesourceofincome.Itcouldprovidelow-costworkspace formoreenterprises,meetingspaceandprofessionalconsultingtoincrease serviceincomeAttractingmoreenterprisesthroughlowrent,enrichingthe typesoftenantsintheparkandincreasingthenumberoftenantscaneffectively improvethestabilityoftheparkItisimportanttomaintainarelativelystable businesssituationintheparkinthefaceofchangingeconomicconditions
Attractingmorecustomersandtenantscanhelptoimprovethestabilityofthe parkHowever,theparkmayalsofacetheriskofalongcapitalreturncycleOne solutiontothisistointroduceexternalinvestmentandpartners.Thesecould includeculturalfundsandinvestmentcompanies,whichcoulddiversifyrisks andstrengthencapitalstrength.Concurrently,optimisingthetenantstructure andpromotingfast-profitablebusinessactivities(e.g.temporaryexhibitionsand festivebazaars)willenabletheparktorapidlyrecuperateitsinvestmentand enhancetheefficiencyofcapitalflow.Thiswillenhancethepark'sflexibilityand responsivenesstomarketchanges,therebyenablingtheparktoadjustits
strategytorespondtomarketchangeswithinashortperiodoftime.
4.2.2Reducingthecapitalreturncycle
Inordertomitigatetheriskofextendedcapitalreturncycles,itisnecessary forparkstorespondproactively.Firstly,thiscanbeachievedbyattracting externalinvestmentandcooperation,suchasculturalfundsandinvestment companies.Thiscanenhancethepark'sabilitytocopewithrisksinadown market.Atthesametime,theparkcanalsotakestepstooptimiseitstenantmix andpromotefast-profitableactivitiessuchastemporaryexhibitionsandfestival bazaarsThiscanfacilitateamorerapidreturnoninvestmentandenhancethe efficiencyofcapitalflowsConsequently,financialreturnscanbeaccelerated, whilethepark'sflexibilityandresponsivenesstomarketfluctuationscanbe improved
423Enhancethebrandeffectoftheparkandestablishmulti-party co-operation
Improvingthecompetitivenessofthemarketisalsokeytoenhancingthe stabilityofthepark.Establishingastrongbrandandprovidingspecialservices arecrucialtocreatingauniqueartisticatmosphereandbrandingeffect.Creating agoodculturalbrandimageoftheparkcanmaximisetheadvantagesofthe industrialparkandattractmoretrafficandmoretenants.Italsoimproves servicequalityandtenantsatisfactionandminimisestenantturnover.
Toachievelong-termstability,Theparkshouldestablishmulti-channel financialpartnershipsandformastrategicresponseteaminordertoenableitto
adjustitsoperationalplaninatimelymannerandtoavoidtheimpactofpolicy changes.ThesemeasurescanenabletheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignand CreativeIndustrialParktobreakthroughthelimitationsoftheexistingeconomic model,enhanceitsmarketcompetitivenessandeconomicvitality,andmaintain itsleadingpositioninthecontextofintensemarketcompetition.
Chapter5:OptimisingStrategiesfortheConservationofCulturaland HistoricBuildings
5.1Limitationsofcurrentculturalactivities
TheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrialPark,asa transformationalprojectforanindustrialsite,hashadaconsiderablepositive impactonculturalandheritagepreservation.However,therearealsosome limitations,whichaffectthefutureculturalheritageanddevelopmentofthe creativeindustrialpark.
Thefirstistheinadequateprotectionoftheindustrialarchitecturalheritage oftheParkAlthoughtheparkhaspreservedsomeoftheoriginalarchitectural structuresoftheoldironandsteelfactoriesduringtherenovationprocess,there isalackofspecificlegalnormsknownfortheprotectionofthestructural integrityandoriginalappearanceofthesebuildingsAsaresult,somebuildings ofhistoricalvaluehavenotbeenproperlyprotectedandutilised
Furthermore,intermsofculturalimpactanddisseminationpower,theold steelfactorylacksculturalproductdevelopmentandhistoricaleducation activities.Theparkitselfhasarichhistoricalandculturalheritage,yetthishas notbeenpassedonandutilisedtothemaximumextent.ItisevidentthattheOld SteelFactoryhasnotbeenactiveenoughindevelopinghistoricalthematic educationandguidedtours,norhasitprovidedsystematichistoricaleducation andin-depthguidedtours.Suchbehaviourunderminesthepublic's understandingofandinterestintheindustrialhistoryofthepark.Thefailureto
utilisetheseresourceseffectivelytoenhancetheculturaldepthandeducational valueoftheParkisasignificantconcern.Theeducationalsignificanceofthe industrialheritagehasalimitedimpactonthepublic,especiallytheyounger generation.
TheexistingculturalactivitiesintheParkaredominatedbyexhibitionsand bazaars,andthereisanoticeablelackofsustainable,long-termandinteractive culturalprogrammes.Althoughexhibitionsandbazaarscanattractshort-term attentionfromvisitors,theyarenotconducivetoenhancingtheirsenseof participationandlong-termculturalappeal
TheHistoricSteelworksalsosuffersfromalackofexternalcollaboration, particularlywithculturalandeducationalinstitutionsThishasresultedinalack ofspecialisationanddiversityofculturalactivitieswithinthecurrentparkThis phenomenonhindersthefurtherdevelopmentoftheparkintermsofcultural innovationandhistoricpreservation
52Recommendationsforimprovementstrategies
TherenovationoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrial Parkhas,toacertainextent,contributedtothediversificationoftheregional economyandaddedsignificantculturalvaluetotheindustrialparkbyutilising theindustrialheritage.Inordertofurtherprotecttheindustrialhistoryofthe parkandimprovetheculturalattractionandsocialinfluence,theindustrialpark shouldtakecorrespondingmeasurestocopewiththeexistingproblems.Thus, theculturalvalueandinfluenceoftheparkcanbefurtherenhanced.
5.2.1Enhancedconservationofhistoricbuildingsintheiroriginalform Intermsofthepreservationofhistoricalbuildings,theparkcanensurethat thesehistoricallyimportantbuildingsareproperlymaintainedandrestoredby establishingaspecialpreservationfund.Furthermore,advancedarchitectural heritagepreservationtechnologycanbeemployedtoscanand3Dmapthe preservedbuildingsonaregularbasis,thusenablingtheretentionofcomplete historicaldevelopmentinformation.Thiswillfacilitatethemaintenanceand restorationofthebuildingsafterthepark
Intermsofbuildingmaterials,itisrecommendedthatthesamematerialsas theoriginalbuildingsbeusedasfaraspossibleIn-siturestorationofexisting structuresiscarriedoutinaccordancewiththeprincipleofpreserving architecturalintegrityItisimportanttopreservetheoriginalconstructionlogic ofthebuildingandmodificationsthatdeviatefromthedesignlanguageofthe buildingitselfshouldbeavoidedFurthermore,itisessentialtodeveloparobust legalframeworkfortheprotectionofindustrialheritage,andtoestablishamore comprehensiveandimprovedframeworkandguidelinesfortheprotectionof industrialarchitecturalheritage.
5.2.2Developmentofculturalproductsrelatedtoindustrialhistory
Itispossibleforoldsteelfactoriestodevelopcreativeculturalmerchandise featuringtheindustrialhistoryofoldsteelfactories.Thesecommoditiescanbe souvenirsandhandicrafts,orpracticalitemswithvintageindustrialelements,
suchastables,chairsandlamps.Theculturalartefactsrelatedtoindustrial historycannotonlyincreasethepark'sculturaldisseminationandbring economicbenefitstotheoldsteelworks.Theycanalsoprovidevisitorswitha uniqueculturalexperienceandeffectivelyenhancepublicparticipationand conservationawareness.Furthermore,theoldsteelworksmaywishtoconsider producingdocumentariesandbookstointroduceitsowndevelopmenthistory andchanges,andtotellindetailthestoryofthedevelopmentofitsownpark. Theseoutputswithculturalattributescanplayanimportantroleinenhancing thepark'sculturalvalueandmarketappeal
523Organiseguidedtoursandeducationalprogrammesonhistorical themes
Theculturalimpactoftheparkcanbeeffectivelydeepenedthroughthe organisationofguidedtoursandhistoricaleducationalactivitiesIndustrial parkscanorganiseregularguidedtoursandseminarstoattractmorevisitorsto exploretheirindustrialandculturalhistorySuchanapproachcanattract visitorstogainadeeperunderstandingofthepark'shistoricalandcultural background,therebyfurtherenhancingtheculturalimpactofthepark
Chapter6:Implementationofsustainabledevelopmentstrategies
TheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrialParkisfacing significantchallengesintermsofsustainabledevelopment.Thesechallengescan bebroadlycategorisedintothreemainareas:buildingenergyconsumption, spaceutilisationefficiency,andinsufficientgreeningandecologicalmaintenance. Theseissuesareaffectingtheenvironmentalandeconomicbenefitsand long-termsustainabledevelopmentofthepark.Byaddressingthesechallenges, theattractivenessoftheparkasacreativeindustryparkwillbefurther enhancedConcurrently,theparkwillassumeamoreconstructiveroleinthe regionaleconomyandsocietyConsequently,whilepursuingculturaland economicvalues,theparkmusturgentlyreinforceallaspectsofitssustainable developmentthroughreasonableimprovementmeasuresinordertoachievea mutuallybeneficialsituationintermsofenvironmentalandeconomicbenefits
61Inadequacyofcurrentsustainabledevelopmentmeasures
Themostsignificantchallengetosustainabledevelopmentisthehigh overallbuildingenergyconsumptioninindustrialparks.Asthemajorityofthe buildingsintheparkarehistoricindustrialbuildings,theyareoldandgenerally oflowbuildingquality.Consequently,aconsiderablequantityofbuilding materialsareutilisedinthemaintenanceandrefurbishmentprocess.Sucha constructionprocessresultsinalargertotalcarboncontentwithinthebuilding. Concurrently,thelowenergyefficiencyoffactorybuildingsnecessitatesthe
utilisationofasubstantialamountofenergytomaintainindoortemperatureand light.Thisresultsinhighcarbonemissionsduringtheentireoperationofthe park.Thisnotonlyincreasestheoperatingcostsofthepark,butalsoincreases thepressureonenvironmentalprotection.
Thelowgreenspaceratioisalsoaproblemforthesustainabledevelopment ofthepark.Althoughacertainamountoforiginalvegetationhasbeenpreserved andsomeadditionalgreeninghasbeencarriedoutduringthedesignand renovationprocess,theoveralllevelofgreeningstillfailstomeetthe requirementsofecologicaldevelopmentofgreenbuildingsTheprevalenceof hardpavingintheparkisalsoatoddswiththeeco-friendlyconceptHardpaving reducestheinfiltrationcapacityofthegroundandaffectsthenaturalcirculation ofrainwater,whichhasadetrimentalimpactonthesustainabledevelopmentof theparkinrelationtotheurbanecosystem
62Improvedsustainablestrategies
621Improvementofthermalinsulationandenergyefficiencyinbuildings
Themajorityofthebuildingsontheoldsteelworkscampuswere constructedinthelastcentury.Theoriginaldesigndidnotadequatelytakeinto accountenergyefficiencyandenvironmentalconsiderations,resultingina significantreductioninthethermalinsulationperformanceoftheexisting buildingsandunusuallyhighenergyconsumption.Specificimprovement measurestoaddressthisproblemareasfollows.Firstly,energy-saving renovationofwindowsandwalls.Theuseofdoubleortriple-glazedwindowsin
factorybuildings,withsoundandheatinsulationlayersinbetween,can effectivelyreduceheatlossandalsoimproveacousticperformance,creatinga morecomfortableindoorenvironment.Furthermore,reducingenergy consumptionfromroomair-conditioninginextremeweatherconditionssuchas winterandsummercanalsobeachieved.Furthermore,theadditionofinsulation materialssuchasrockwoolorpolystyrenefoamtotheinteriorofthewallcan significantlyenhancethethermalinsulationofthewall,therebyreducingthe ineffectiveexchangeofenergybetweenindoorsandoutdoors.
Additionally,thedeploymentofintelligenttemperaturecontrolsystemsand lightingsystemscaneffectivelyreducebuildingenergyconsumptionIntelligent buildingsystemscanautomaticallyadjustenergyuseaccordingtoindoorand outdoortemperaturechanges,trackenergyconsumptiondatainrealtime,and analyseenergyconsumptionpeaksTheresultsofthestudyindicatethatthe energydistributionstrategycanbeoptimised,therebyreducingenergywaste Furthermore,solarpowerpanelsareinstalledonthebuildingsandinsuitable openspaces,utilisingrenewableenergytoprovidepowerfortheparkand reducingdependenceonthetraditionalpowergrid.Thispromotesthegreen transformationoftheenergystructureoftheparkandrealisesthemultilevel utilisationofenergy.
6.2.2Utilisationofvirginmaterialsandpromotionofgreentechnologies
Theprocessofrenovatingtheparkhasresultedinalowreuserateofthe originalbuildingmaterials,whichhasnoteffectivelyreducedconstructionwaste.
Furthermore,theapplicationofgreentechnologieshasnotbeenextensive enoughtomakefulluseofrenewableresourcesandenvironmentallyfriendly materials.Thereuseofmaterialsisoneofthemeanstoreducetheembedded carbonintheconstructionprocessandtopreservetheoriginalappearanceof thearchitecturalheritage.Alldemolishedbuildingmaterialsareassessedand categorised,withmaterialssuchasmasonryandmetalbeingselectively reprocessed.Thereuseofthesematerialsinnewconstructionorrenovation projectsreduceswasteanddirectlyreducescarbonemissions.Additionally,the promotionoftheuseofgreenbuildingmaterialsisacommonstrategy Preferenceisgiventoenvironmentallyfriendlymaterialssuchasrecycled concreteandbambooinconstructionandrenovationThesematerialsarenot onlyenvironmentallyfriendlybutalsohavegooddurabilityandaesthetics,and areinlinewiththerequirementsofsustainabledevelopment
623Creatinggreenspaceandwatermanagementsystems
Thepark'sgreenspaceandbiodiversityareinsufficient,asareitswater managementsystems.Tocreateagreenerandmoreecologicalenvironment,itis necessarytoincreasegreencoverage.Nativedrought-tolerantplantscanbe plantedandroofsandthree-dimensionalspacescanbeutilisedforgreening.This notonlybeautifiestheenvironmentbutalsohelpstoimprovetheurban microclimate,airqualityandthegreenecologicalbalancewithinthesite.Itis recommendedthatrainwatercollectionsystemsbeinstalledontheroofsand withinthebuildings.Thecollectionandutilisationofrainwaterforlandscaping
andthecleaningoffacilitieswillreducethecampus'srelianceongroundwater andmunicipalwatersupplysystems.Thiswillfurtherenhancethe environmentalbenefitsofthecampusandenabletherecyclingofwater resources.
Chapter7:Conclusion
7.1Summaryofthestudy
ThispapercommenceswithanexaminationofthetransformationoftheOld SteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustryParkinXi'an.Theprojectexemplifies thepotentialforindustrialheritagetobeconvertedintoacontemporaryspace thatincorporatesbothculturalandcreativeindustries.Suchatransformation notonlypreservesthehistoricalandculturalcharacteristicsofthesteelfactory toacertainextent,butalsoinjectsnewvitalityintothecity'smodern developmentThetransformedoldsteelfactorybecomesaculturalsymbolthat connectsthepastwiththefuture
Thetransformationoftheoldsteelfactoryhasbeenfoundtohave preservedtheindustrialheritageTheprojecthassuccessfullytransformedthe industrialbuildingsoftheoldsteelfactoryintospaceswithcreativefunctions Suchatransformationnotonlymeetstheneedsofthecity'sculturalshowcase, butalsoprovidesadiverserangeofcommercialandrecreationalusesforthe public.Italsobringseconomicbenefitstothecommunity.Thepreservationof theoriginalindustrialstructureanditssubsequenttransformationintoa creativehubhasestablishedtheoldsteelfactoryasaculturalandcreativecentre forXi'anandtheNorthwest.Thisexemplifiesthevalueofpreservingand utilisingindustrialheritage.Furthermore,itservesasacasestudyforothersto learnfrom.Thetransformationoftheoldsteelfactorynotonlydiversifiesthe
regionaleconomyandenhancesthecity'simage,butalsostimulatesthegrowth ofsocial,culturalandcreativeindustries.
However,thetransformationoftheprojectisassociatedwithanumberof significantproblemsandchallenges.Theseincludethehomogeneityofthe economicmodelandtheinadequacyofthesustainabledevelopmentstrategy.In ordertoensurethefuturedevelopmentofthearea,itisessentialtoenhancethe diversityofeconomicmodelsandoptimisesustainabledevelopmentmeasures. Furthermore,thereisalackofrobustprotectionmeasuresinculturalheritage protection,whichprovidesapracticalcaseforfurtherexplorationofindustrial heritageprotectionInlightoftheseshortcomingsandinconjunctionwiththe heritageconservationcasesinothercountriesandregions,amoreexplicit directionisprovidedforthesubsequentdevelopmentoftheoldsteelfactory
Inconclusion,thecaseoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryprovidesvaluable experienceforsimilarindustrialheritageconservationandreuseprojects,as wellasexploringnewpathsandnewpossibilitiesforsustainableurban development.Infutureresearchandpractice,itshouldfurtherimproveits economicstabilityinordertoachievehighereconomicbenefits.Thereisalsoa needformoreideasonculturalvaluesandheritagepreservation.Inthecontext ofglobalindustrialheritagepreservationandutilisation,thesuccessful transformationoftheoldsteelfactoryinXi'ansignifiesthatindustrialheritage canbecomeanewsourceofpowerforurbandevelopment.Furthermore,it providesanimportantreferenceandinspirationforothercities.
7.2Limitationsandfutureresearchdirections
Thisstudyexaminesthetransformationandsustainabledevelopment practicesoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrialPark.It providesin-depthanalysesofurbanredevelopment,industrialheritage preservation,andeconomicmodellinginnovations.Despitethemanyresults achieved,thisstudystillhassomelimitations.Theselimitationspointto potentialdirectionsforfutureresearch.
Thisstudyreliedondataprimarilyfrompubliclyavailablesources, includingreportsfromgovernmentandregulatoryagencies,news,andacademic articlesThismayhaveaffectedthecomprehensivenessandup-to-datenatureof thedataInparticular,whenquantifyingeconomicimpacts,thelackofdirect economicdataandthefactthatmostoftheconclusionsarebasedonqualitative analysesratherthanquantitativeevidencelimittheexplorationofthedepthand precisionofeconomiceffects
Thisstudyfocusesonasinglecase:thetransformationprocessoftheold steelfactoryinXi'an.Thespecificityofthecasemaylimitthegeneral applicabilityofthestudy'sconclusions.Thegeographicallocation,historical background,andsocio-culturalenvironmentofeachindustrialheritageare different,andthesefactorsmayaffectthedesignandimplementationeffectsof transformationstrategies.
Toaddressthelimitationsoftheexistingstudy,futureresearchshould
expandthenumberandscopeofcasestudiesandcompareindustrialheritage reuseprojectsindifferentregionsorcountries.Thiswillenhancethegeneral applicabilityandpracticalityofthefindings.Atthesametime,increasing quantitativeanalysesofeconomicimpacts,forexamplethroughcost-benefit analyses,analysesofeconomicvalue-addedandemploymentimpacts,etc.,will providemoreconvincingevidencetosupportpolicyformulationandproject evaluation.
Furthermore,thestudyshouldalsoexaminethesocio-culturalimpactsof thetransformationprocessThroughsociologicalmethods,suchasquestionnaire surveysandin-depthinterviews,thestudyshouldanalysethespecificimpactsof therenovationprojectsonthelocalcommunities,includingthechangesinthe lifestylesoftheresidents,theadjustmentsinthesocialstructureandthe evolutionoftheculturalidentityThiswillnotonlyprovideamore comprehensiveperspectiveonthepreservationandreuseofindustrialheritage, butalsocontributetotherealisationofsustainablesocialdevelopmentFuture researchshouldthereforeexploreandimplementmoreinnovativesustainable developmentmeasures.Thisincludesapplyingnewgreentechnologies, deepeningeco-designandoptimisingtheresourcerecyclingsystem.Such measureswillenhancetheenvironmentalandeconomicbenefitsofthepark,as wellasimprovingthepublicwell-beingofthecommunity.
ThecasestudyoftheXi'anOldSteelFactoryDesignandCreativeIndustrial Parkservestoillustratethecomplexityandchallengesinherentinthereuseof
urbanindustrialheritage.Italsoprovidesaseriesoffeasiblestrategiesand recommendationsthatoffertheoreticalandpracticalreferencesforindustrial heritageconservationandreuseprojectsinsimilarcontexts.Futureresearchwill furtherexpandtheboundariesofknowledgeinthisfieldandpromotethe successfultransformationofmoreindustrialheritagetowardssustainable development.
References
Gao,Y.A.(2016).Barcelona:PublicArtLeadingUrbanRedevelopment.Urban EnvironmentalDesign,102(8),446-448.ISSN1672-9080
Chen,X.W.(2021a).ExploringXi'an'sIndustrialHeritage.NewWest,(10),34-42. ISSN1009-8607
Chen,X.W.(2021b).IndustrialHeritage:PreservingUrbanMemories.NewWest, (10),47-52.ISSN1009-8607
Zhang,XM,&Hao,O(2017)StudyonthePracticeofIndustrialHeritage Conservation:AnAnalysisoftheConservationPracticesofIndustrial HeritageinFranceInteriorDesignandDecoration,(11),134-135ISSN 1005-7374
Zhou,L(2022)PolicyAnalysisontheUtilizationandProtectionofIndustrial HeritageChinaCulturalHeritage,109(3),16-18ISSN1672-7819
Xu,SB(2022)ReflectionsontheGreenTransformationofIndustrialHeritage ChinaCulturalHeritage,109(3),4-6.ISSN1672-7819
Wei,X.M.(2006).InstitutionalInnovationLeadingtheConstructionofIndustrial ParkstoBoostEconomicTake-off:TheSuccessfulDevelopmentModelof DalianSoftwarePark.ChinaHigh-TechZone,(9),40-42.ISSN1671-4113
Zhou,J.,VanOers,R.,Lamandi,C.,&Cioboata,S.(2021).TheRoleofCultural HeritageforSustainableUrbanDevelopment:EastAsia,SoutheastAsiaand thePacificRegion.Shanghai:TongjiUniversityPress.ISBN9787560897509
EnvironmentandSustainableDevelopment.(1976-present).Beijing:Ministryof EnvironmentalProtectionofthePeople'sRepublicofChinaEnvironmental DevelopmentCenter(Sino-JapaneseFriendshipCentreforEnvironmental Protection);MinistryofEnvironmentalProtectionEnvironmentaland EconomicPolicyResearchCenter.ISSN1673-288X
ZhixueAcademy.(2022,February9).IndustrialHeritageRevitalization, TransformationandRebirthofXi’anOldSteelFactory!Retrievedfrom
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/kdueeBmjekpoNwlKB4vlNw CityRenewalForumCURF(2018,August23)[TheCreativeIndustryPark DesignofXi'anOldSteelFactoryRevivestheOldTown]Retrievedfrom
https://mpweixinqqcom/s/ed4cESno8G1zHSUNLhipBw
He,YG,Liu,KC,&Fan,Y(2021)ReshapingBodilyExperience:Renovation andExpansionDesignoftheOldSteelFactoryArtists'StudiosNew Architecture,(6),47-51Retrievedfrom
https://mpweixinqqcom/s/TRr6P4OtUXK6sj5tHrUUug CitySeenPlus.(2021,November29).TopTenGlobalCasesofOldFactory Renovation.Retrievedfrom
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/TB2rC8sFPrXGOkD-cJxzA