4/21/22 Full Edition

Page 1

NEWS | 4 University announces 2022-23 speaker lineup

FEATURES | 7 Building community by Bridging the Gap

OPINION | 8 Women deserve greater representation in U.S. politics

SPORTS | 11 Women's golf claims ACC crown

LIFE | 15 Diverse cast of"Bridgerton"

Old Gold&Black

VOL. 108, NO. 27

WA K E F O R E S T ’ S S T U D E N T N E W S PA P E R S I N C E 1 9 1 6

APRIL 21, 2022

“Covers the campus like the magnolias”

'Winston-Salem Five' seek exoneration

Cooper Sullivan / Old Gold & Black

Brad Bannon and Christine Mumma, defense attorneys for Christopher Bryant and Rayshawn Banner, respectively, give an interview after the first day of the hearings. Mark Rabil and Julie Boyer (not pictured) represent Jermal Tolliver and Nathaniel Cauthen, respectively. CHRISTA DUTTON, COOPER SULLLIVAN & DANIEL PAROLINI News Editor, Multimedia Managing Editor & Contributing Writer

F

our men are seeking to be exonerated of the 2002 murder of Nathaniel Jones, Winston-Salem native and grandfather of NBA star and former Wake Forest guard Chris Paul. A three-judge panel will be hearing arguments from the men’s attorneys concerning whether they are innocent and must come to a unanimous decision to grant an exoneration. Fifteen-year-olds Christopher Bryant, Nathaniel Cauthen, Jermal Tolliver and Dorrell Brayboy and 14-year-old Rayshawn Banner, Cauthen’s brother, were arrested for Jones’ murder in 2002. The group has been referred to as the “Winston-Salem Five” because of the striking similarities between this case and the infamous “Central Park Five” case in New York City.

Cauthen and Banner are currently serving life sentences on first-degree murder convictions. Bryant, Tolliver and Brayboy were convicted of second-degree murder, but have all been released since 2018. Bryant first submitted an innocence claim to the N.C. Innocence Inquiry Commission on March 2, 2015. Cauthen was the second defendant to file an innocence claim three years later. Tolliver and Banner were notified of the filings in October 2019. Brayboy was not contacted due to his death in August 2019, and he cannot be posthumously exonerated since he did not submit a claim of innocence before his death. Since its inception, the Innocence Inquiry Commission has received a total of 3,206 claims. Fifteen of the 18 claims that have received hearings have resulted in exonerations, and the still-living members of the Winston-Salem Five hope their case will be the 16th. No forensic evidence could link any of

the five defendants to the crime, but confessions from the teenagers and 16-yearold Jessicah Black, an alleged accomplice, determined their fates. But defense attorneys from the N.C. Center on Actual Innocence in Durham pointed out in their opening statement Monday morning that these confessions do not add up. Opening Statements In their opening statement, the defense presented that all five defendants and Black had differing accounts when asked questions about who was involved, what the motive was, how Jones was approached, what items were used in the attack and the state of Jones’ body. One confession claimed the teenagers used black electrical tape bought from a nearby Dollar General to bind Jones' hands and cover his mouth. However, the defense found that Dollar General did not sell the tape that was found at the

crime scene, nor did surveillance footage at that store show any of the teenagers near the property. Another confession claimed that the teenagers stole and then used Jones’ debit card, however, no card activity was found. Another confession claimed that Jones was left lying on his back with his eyeglasses nearby. Jones was actually found lying on his stomach and no eyeglasses were found at the scene. In his opening statement, Brad Bannon, one of the defense attorneys, stated that the Winston-Salem Police Department (WSPD) intimidated the teenagers into falsely confessing, citing the lack of incriminating evidence and their maintaining of innocence since the 2004 and 2005 trials. All five defendants would later recant their testimonies, and, in 2019, Black recanted her testimony saying that none of the teenagers or herself were involved in the crime.

See Hearing, Page 3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.