Our Town - February 21, 2019

Page 1

The local paper for the Upper East Side

VOL. 45, ISSUE 08

WEEK OF FEBRUARY HONORING JACKIE ROBINSON ◄ P.12

21-27 2019

FROM HORSES TO CARS TO DOCTORS DEVELOPMENT As Lenox Hill Hospital expands and shifts its campus to the east, it is taking over a landmark parking garage and onetime riding academy that made equestrian history in the 19th century

THE ETERNAL ORPHANAGE COMMUNITY A Yorkville priest and the head of an elite private school thrash out a plan to memorialize a beloved vestige of a 19th-century chapel — even as its inevitable disappearance looms

I do not doubt that one day, this relic of the past will reemerge to astonish future generations.”

BY DOUGLAS FEIDEN

Horses were everywhere in 1888: They hauled coal, fronted pushcarts, pulled wagons, conveyed passengers and served in the parks and piers. But there was one place no one expected to find them — cavorting on the third floor of a commercial building, 60-plus feet above street level. So New Yorkers were dumbfounded when a new “riding ring in the sky” with room for 140 saddle horses opened its doors on East 75th Street. And they surged up the cleated ramps of the Park Avenue Stables to watch the animals trot, jump, canter and gallop atop the tanbark and beaten clay. “Quite a novelty,” wrote The Engineering and Building Record in June that year. “It is the first elevated-ring riding academy in New York City.” As it happens, it may also have been the last. Flash forward 131 years: Epochal changes came to the block between Park and Lexington Avenues. First, the horseback-riding school closed. Then, the stables were shuttered. Next, a succession of parking garages occupied the space. Now, a Lenox Hill Hospital facility is set to move in.

The clock is quickly ticking on the future of the Ghostly Remnant of East 90th Street. But there’s good news, too: Due to a breakthrough deal hammered out in a Feb. 15 meeting, the majestic ruin will be commemorated forever. Construction of a new field house for the Spence School on the block between First and York Avenues is already underway. And as it advances, the beloved fragment that survived from the chapel of the old St. Joseph’s Orphan Asylum will vanish from view. Built in 1898 to serve the orphanage, which was founded in 1857, the neo-Classical, brick-and-stone church has endured, in truncated form, ever since. That won’t change. But late this year or in 2020, the vestige is expected to be obscured, perhaps indefinitely, behind the six-story, 85-foot tall athletic complex that Spence is now building directly to the east. It won’t go quietly: Its fans have been fighting to save it ever since Our Town chronicled its history, status and uncertain future in two articles in January, “The Ghostly Remnant” and “Rallying for a Remnant.” In response, East Side City Council Member Ben Kallos — who once lived in the condo at 402 East 90th St. in which the remnant is spectacularly

CONTINUED ON PAGE 5

CONTINUED ON PAGE 7

BY DOUGLAS FEIDEN

Inside

OurTownEastSide

O OURTOWNNY.COM @OurTownNYC

Crime Watch Voices NYC Now City Arts

City Council Member Ben Kallos

A LIFE OF HER OWN: A HUNTER GRAD’S JOURNEY ▲ P.6

AMAZON LESSON: NO MORE CLOSED DOORS ▲ P.8

CONGESTION PRICING, EXPLAINED ▲ P.19

A seven-story vestige of an old Yorkville chapel, embedded into a neighboring building, stands sentinel over an empty lot where the Spence School is constructing a new field house. The facade will vanish from view when the work is completed, but the chapel will be memorialized both inside and outside the new Spence building. Photo: Sarah Greig Photography / FRIENDS of the Upper East Side Historic Districts

3 8 10 12

Restaurant Ratings Business Real Estate 15 Minutes

14 16 17 21

Jewish women and girls light up the world by lighting the Shabbat candles every Friday evening 18 minutes before sunset. Friday, February 22 – 5:21 pm. For more information visit www.chabaduppereastrside.com.

We deliver! Get Our Town Eastsider sent directly to your mailbox for $ $49 per year. Go to OurTownNY.com or call 212-868-0190


2

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

ST. MARK’S COMICS CLOSING AFTER 36 YEARS SMALL BUSINESS A staple of the East Village community will be shuttering its doors before construction begins on a planned office building BY JASON COHEN

With the impending development on St. Mark’s and Third Avenue in the East Village, the culture is definitely changing. Now another longtime business has announced it will be shuttering its doors. At the end of the month, St. Mark’s Comics will be closing after 36 years. Located at 11 St. Mark’s Place, the store opened in 1983 and has become a staple in the community. The shop appealed to people of all ages and backgrounds. On a recent Monday, it was mobbed, with children, teens and adults looking through comics that included DC, Marvel and pretty much anything that has ever been published. “I wanted to run a good comic shop that was my vision,” said

owner Mitch Cutler. “After 36 years of 90 hours a week, you run out of energy to fight the obstacles.” Cutler, a South Bronx native and comic book aficionado, took over the store in 1984 at the age of 19. As a kid, he never imagined owning it for this long nor did he expect it would become as popular as it became. “You do it at 19 because you don’t understand what you’re getting into,” Cutler said. Cutler credits the shop’s success for three reasons: its hours, staff and selection. The store is open until 1 a.m., making it accessible to late-night shoppers in the East Village. According to Cutler, catering to their customers’ needs is what kept people coming back to the store. Whether they needed to ship it, hold it or locate it, he and his colleagues almost always found the item or items, he said. “We carried almost absolutely everything that was published, which is something almost no one else will do,” he stressed. “We’ve been blessed with an exceptional staff and

[We] really go out of our way to try and say yes. Whatever a customer wants, we try to figure out how to do that.” Mitch Cutler, owner of St. Mark’s Comics

A shop for fans of all ages and backgrounds. Photo: Jason Cohen

ASK YOUR DOCTOR TO TEST YOUR CHILD FOR LEAD Lead in peeling paint poisons children. • Tell your landlord to fix peeling paint. It’s the law. • Wash floors, windowsills, hands, and toys often.

GET YOUR CHILD TESTED AT AGES 1 AND 2. CALL 311 TO LEARN MORE OR VISIT nyc.gov/leadfree.

really go out of our way to try and say yes. Whatever a customer wants, we try to figure out how to do that.” Cutler even described St. Mark’s Comics as being “world famous.” One of his regular customers was a cop, and several years ago the police officer was in Paris on vacation. While there, he was in a comic book shop, where after making small talk with the owner, the cop found out the owner had visited St. Mark’s Comics as well. After more than three decades in the East Village, Cutler feels astonished at the amount of texts, calls, emails, social media posts and people that have come in the store since he announced the closure several weeks ago. “It’s fascinating to have to schedule interviews after 36 years,” he said. “It’s all sort of an outer-body experience.” While he has met famous people and heard many interesting stories, there were always challenges. “Was there ever a time when it was easy?” he commented. “There was never a time I was

lighting my cigars from $100 bills.” Cutler explained there are several reasons for the impending closure, but one of them is the planned development of an office building at the Northeast corner of St. Mark’s and Third Avenue. This has already forced other stores to close and he feels once construction begins, it will kill his business along with many others. “There are many obstacles in running a retail business in the city of New York,” Cutler said. Among the many customers who have visited the shop before its closure was Kevin Clark, who moved to the Village five months ago and has frequented the store several times. Growing up in New Jersey, he never found such a unique place with such a great selection, he said. “It’s a good hole in the wall comic book shop, but it had new issues,” Clark said. “I’m super upset about it closing. Not to be emotional, comic book stores are something so great. It helped solidify the culture in the city, especially in the Village.”


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

3

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

CRIME WATCH BY JERRY DANZIG CHECK FISHED OUT OF MAILBOX AND ALTERED

STATS FOR THE WEEK Reported crimes from the 19th precinct for the week ending Feb 10

A thief turned a check for less than $50 into nearly $5,000. On Monday, Dec. 17, 2018, a 64-year-old woman wrote a check for $43.31 to pay a bill. She mailed the check using an outdoor mailbox in Queens. When she checked her account balance on Jan. 24 of this year, she discovered that her check had been altered and made payable to a Kayla Gibson in the amount of $4,700 by an unknown perpetrator. Police said the altered check had been deposited in an ATM machine at 502 Park Ave in Manhattan.

Week to Date

Photo by Tony Webster, via Flickr

WOMAN ARRESTED FOR IDENTITY THEFT

A WHOLE LOT OF ROLLING PAPERS

Around noon on Saturday, Feb. 9, a 26-year-old woman tried to withdraw $2,600 from a compromised account using a fake Connecticut driver’s license, at the Capital One bank at 249 East 86th St., police said. An officer apprehended the woman inside the bank, where she was found to be in possession of a credit card as well as alleged crack and heroin drug paraphernalia. The woman whose account had been compromised told police she had not given the suspect permission to withdraw funds. Meagan Greer was arrested at the bank and charged with identity theft.

According to police, on Saturday, Feb. 9, a 14-year-old male entered the Eastside Deli and Convenience store at 1390 Third Ave. in the company of two other persons. The teen pushed a display shelf to the floor, causing damage, before removing another display containing rolling papers and fleeing the location without paying for the items, police said. Officers caught up with the suspect in front of 30 East 71st St., where he was arrested and charged with criminal mischief. The 218 packages of rolling papers stolen and recovered were valued at $436.

Our DOCTORS Anthony A. Romeo, M.D.

SPORTS MEDICINE SHOULDER & ELBOW

Andrew W. Beharrie, M.D. SPORTS MEDICINE

Meghan E. Bishop, M.D.

SPORTS MEDICINE

Brandon J. Erickson, M.D. SPORTS MEDICINE

Eric L. Grossman, M.D.* JOINT REPLACEMENT

Joseph K. Lee, M.D. SPINE SURGERY

Daniel A. Seigerman, M.D.

BAD NIGHT AT THE MOVIES A trip to the movies proved expensive for one East Side senior. At 7 p.m. on Saturday, Feb. 9, a 77-year-old woman was about to leave the AMC Orpheum theater at 1538 Third Ave. when she realized that her pocketbook felt lighter. She discovered that her wallet and cell phone were missing. And though she found her phone and wallet before leaving the theater, $100 cash, an ID card, a MetroCard and a debit card were gone from the wallet. The victim called her bank and was told that her debit card had been used at a Best Buy store to make a purchase in the amount of $433.

Year to Date

2019 2018

% Change 2019

2018

% Change

Murder

0

0

n/a

0

0

n/a

Rape

0

1

-100.0 3

1

200.0

Robbery

1

0

n/a

13

14

-7.1

Felony Assault

3

2

50.0

17

18

-5.6

Burglary

2

5

-60.0

32

31

3.2

Grand Larceny

36

30

20.0

198

189

4.8

Grand Larceny Auto

2

1

100.0

2

6

-66.7

THIEF HAS SOUP FOR LUNCH On Tuesday, Feb. 12, a 33-yearold woman was inside the Fresh & Co. store at 127 East 60th St. about to order lunch when she discovered that her wallet and other items were missing from her purse. She soon found out that her debit and credit cards had been used to purchase soup from the Fresh & Co. store while she

was there, a Louis Vuitton bag from Bloomingdale’s, valued at $1,437.15, and something that cost $9.91 at the Starbucks at 1021 Third Ave. Security video inside Bloomingdale’s showed a male perpetrator buying the Vuitton bag. The other items stolen from the purse included a driver’s license, a Bloomingdale’s gift card valued at $300, a buybuy BABY gift card worth $200 and a Gap gift certificate. The total stolen came to $1,956.

DECADES OF

EXPERIENCE . FRESH NEW APPROACH.

HAND & WRIST

Daniel Smith, M.D.**

JOINT REPLACEMENT

Samir C. Sodha, M.D.

We might be new here in New York, but our doctors are among the best in the business. With minimally invasive techniques and dedicated specialists with decades of surgical experience, we seamlessly treat complex injuries. So turn to the experts with the fresh approach. Turn to Rothman Orthopaedics.

HAND & WRIST

Justin Tsai, M.D. FOOT & ANKLE

MAKE YOUR SAME-DAY SAME DAY APPOINTMENTS AT

Howard B. Yeon, M.D., J.D.

ROTHMANORTHO.COM OR 800.321.9999

SPINE SURGERY

* Dr. Grossman will only see patients in NYC ** Dr. Smith will only see patients in Tarrytown

NOW OPEN IN MANHATTAN & TARRYTOWN

I

ACCEPTING ALL MAJOR INSURANCES


4

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Useful Contacts

Drawing Board BY SUSAN FAIOLA

POLICE NYPD 19th Precinct

153 E. 67th St.

212-452-0600

159 E. 85th St.

311

FIRE FDNY 22 Ladder Co 13 FDNY Engine 39/Ladder 16

157 E. 67th St.

311

FDNY Engine 53/Ladder 43

1836 Third Ave.

311

FDNY Engine 44

221 E. 75th St.

311

CITY COUNCIL Councilmember Keith Powers

211 E. 43rd St. #1205

212-818-0580

Councilmember Ben Kallos

244 E. 93rd St.

212-860-1950

STATE LEGISLATORS State Sen. Jose M. Serrano

1916 Park Ave. #202

212-828-5829

State Senator Liz Krueger

1850 Second Ave.

212-490-9535

Assembly Member Dan Quart

360 E. 57th St.

212-605-0937

Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright

1485 York Ave.

212-288-4607

COMMUNITY BOARD 8

505 Park Ave. #620

212-758-4340

LIBRARIES Yorkville

222 E. 79th St.

212-744-5824

96th Street

112 E. 96th St.

212-289-0908

67th Street

328 E. 67th St.

212-734-1717

Webster Library

1465 York Ave.

212-288-5049

100 E. 77th St.

212-434-2000

HOSPITALS Lenox Hill NY-Presbyterian / Weill Cornell

525 E. 68th St.

212-746-5454

Mount Sinai

E. 99th St. & Madison Ave.

212-241-6500

NYU Langone

550 First Ave.

212-263-7300

CON EDISON

4 Irving Place

212-460-4600

POST OFFICES US Post Office

1283 First Ave.

212-517-8361

US Post Office

1617 Third Ave.

212-369-2747

HOW TO REACH US:

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR:

212-868-0190 nyoffice@strausnews.com ourtownny.com

Include your full name, address and day and evening telephone numbers for verification. Letters that cannot be verified will not be published. We reserve the right to edit or condense letters for libel, good taste, grammar and punctuation. Submit your letter at ourtownny.com and click submit at the bottom of the page or email it to nyoffice@strausnews.com.

TO SUBSCRIBE: Our Town is available for free on the east side in select buildings, retail locations and news boxes. To get a copy of east side neighborhood news mailed to you weekly, you may subscribe to Our Town Eastsider for just $49 per year. Call 212868-0190 or go online to StrausNews. com and click on the photo of the paper or mail a check to Straus Media, 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918.

NEWS ITEMS: To report a news story, call 212-8680190. News releases of general interest must be emailed to our offices by noon the Thursday prior to publication to be considered for the following week. Send to news@strausnews.com.

BLOG COMMENTS: We invite your comments on stories and issues at ourtownny.com. We do not edit those comments. We urge people to keep the discussion civil and the tone reflective of the best we each have to offer.

PLACE A CLASSIFIED AD: Call 212-868-0190. Classified ads must be in our office by 12pm the Friday before publication, except on holidays. All classified ads are payable in advance.

PREVIOUS OWNERS: Tom Allon, Isis Ventures, Ed Kayatt, Russ Smith, Bob Trentlyon, Jerry Finkelstein

CALENDAR ITEMS:

ABOUT US

Information for inclusion in our calendar should be posted to nycnow.com no later than two weeks before the event.

Our Town is published weekly by Straus Media-Manhattan, LLC. Please send inquiries to 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918.


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

HORSES CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 In microcosm, the back story of 115 East 75th St. reflects the broader evolution of the Upper East Side as ambitious, expansion-minded medical institutions gobbled up real estate that was once the province of smaller, funkier, earthier businesses. Instead of saddling horses, fixing flats and parking cars, the four-story structure will now be reconfigured by Lenox Hill to house the medical practices of scores of its doctors. But amid the transformation, one part of the streetscape will be reengineered to look largely as it once did: The exterior of the Romanesque Revival-style building, a part of the Upper East Side Historic District since its creation in 1981, is being restored to its historic appearance as a stableturned-garage. From the grand carriage entry at street level to the terra cotta bands on the top floors, from the brick façade to the long window arcades with arches, the decayed or vanished 19th-century period detailing will be rehabilitated.

The Omnipresent Horse And the crowning feature of the building — known to architects as an “equine capstone,” and to laymen as a sculpture of a horse’s head — will continue to greet patients and hospital workers, just as it once stood sentinel over stallions and automobiles.

5

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

A circa 1930s photo of the landmark Parkanlex parking garage on East 75th Street. Note the running boards on the parked cars. Photo: New York Public Library / Digital Collections “Our plan calls for an extensive exterior renovation to restore original, historic exterior details — and an interior renovation to accommodate new physician medical practices,” said Barbara Osborn, a spokesperson for Lenox Hill, which is under the umbrella of Northwell Health. The proposal to convert the 20,450-square-foot stable won preliminary approval on Jan. 8 from the city’s Landmarks Preservation Commission, which found that the adaptive re-use will return it “significantly closer to its historic conditions ... reinforce its historic façade elements,”

and “recall the character of its opencarriage entranceways.” Preservationists largely agreed: “The majority of work proposed here is sensitive and laudable,” said the Historic Districts Council, an advocacy group, in its testimony to the LPC. “This type of commercial structure has often been overlooked or quick to be redeveloped, so the modern existence of this former stable and garage is owed to the much-deserved protection afforded by its landmark designation,” said Sara Kamillatos, preservation associate at Friends of the Upper East Side. “We are thrilled that it will be restored to its original prominence by the new owners,” she added. While praising the harmonious intersection of modern and historic design elements, Kamillatos offered one critique. Flanking fire doors to be built on either side of the façade will create outof-character symmetry, she argued. “The different phases of the building have all been characterized by an asymmetry that arose from the shifting needs of equine, pedestrian and automobile entry,” Kamillatos said. If the structure’s past uses were muscular and industrial, Lenox Hill, as a member hospital of Northwell, is now positioning the property for its healing mission as part of Northwell Health Physician Partners, made up of its doctors and staff. In fact, its plans call for construction of a connective walkway that will physically attach the rear of the

converted stables on 75th Street to the back of another medical facility where its doctors practice at 122 East 76th St.

Eastward Ho! The expanded practice is just one element of a mega-reorientation of Lenox Hill’s campus that Our Town first reported exclusively in “The Metamorphosis of a Hospital” in the issue dated Jan. 17 to Jan. 23. It told how the institution — which first put down stakes on Park Avenue at 77th Street in 1868, when it was known as the German Hospital and Dispensary — was exploring the possible sale and redevelopment of some of the pricey property at its legacy home. Under one scenario being evaluated, Lenox Hill would monetize some or all of a three-building parcel it owns at 855 Park Ave., between 76th and 77th Streets, as a means of financing a costly expansion to the east. Its western frontage, a full city block that runs 204 feet along Park Avenue, occupies some of the most valuable land in Manhattan. If it were sold to a luxury developer, the proceeds could pay for new hospital construction, including a possible tower on the Lexington Avenue side of its campus. Meanwhile, Lenox Hill is also developing plans for the entire blockfront it controls on the site of six separate, three- and four-story, mixed-use buildings on the east side of Third Avenue between 76th and 77th Streets. On the draw ing board is a 250,000-square-foot home for ambula-

tory surgery, imaging, a cancer center, doctors’ offices and clinical services. Compared to such game-changing real estate plays, the move into the old stable is small bore — but it speaks to the sea change in the UES property market over the past century. In the late 1880s, the Park Avenue Stables could accommodate 140 horses in its second story and basement, while the carriages for a livery business were stored on its first floor, according to research by Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, Lenox Hill’s preservation consultant on the project. Then in 1908, the business model for the stables imploded as the first Model-T rolled off Henry Ford’s assembly line. With the auto playing an increasingly outsized role on city streets, the utility of the horse began to disappear. In 1912, the Park Avenue Stables was converted into the Sullivan Garage. The property continued to change hands, eventually becoming the Parkanlex, which today houses 165 cars. Since Lenox Hill now holds the longterm ground lease on the property, those cars will be evicted once the reconfiguration is complete. Once, there were many other stables on the 75th Street block, said Higgins Quasebarth associate Sarah Sher. “They embraced the inevitable and served as garages during the first half of the 20th century, ultimately being replaced by apartment buildings and a synagogue,” she said. invreporter@strausnews.com

Give your money a raise Make your money work harder by earning higher interest rates. Talk to a banker for more details. Offer expires March 22, 2019. Platinum Savings Account

2.10%

Fixed Rate CD

2.60%

Annual Percentage Yield for 12 months1

Enjoy a special interest rate for 12 months with new money deposits of at least $25,000 and a minimum daily account balance of $25,000 or more.

Annual Percentage Yield for 11 months2

Guaranteed fixed rate with new money deposits of at least $25,000 for an 11-month term.

Both accounts are FDIC-insured up to the maximum allowable limit. Platinum Savings offer available in CT, DC, DE, FL, GA, MD, NJ, NY, SC and VA. Fixed Rate CD offer available in AL, AZ, CT, DC, DE, FL, GA, MD, NJ, NM, NV, NY, PA, SC and VA. Portfolio by Wells Fargo® customers are eligible to receive an additional interest rate bonus on these accounts.3 1. To qualify for this offer, you must have a new or existing Platinum Savings account and enroll the account in this offer between 01/21/2019 and 03/22/2019. This offer is subject to change at any time, without notice. This offer is available only to Platinum Savings customers in the following states: CT, DC, DE, FL, GA, MD, NJ, NY, SC and VA. In order to earn the Special Interest Rate of 2.08% (Special Rate), you must deposit $25,000 in new money (from sources outside of Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., or its affiliates) to the enrolled savings account and maintain a minimum daily account balance of $25,000 throughout the term of this offer. The corresponding Annual Percentage Yield (APY) for this offer is 2.10%. The Special Rate will be applied to the enrolled savings account for a period of 12 months, starting on the date the account is enrolled in the offer. However, for any day during that 12 month period that the daily account balance is less than the $25,000 minimum, the Special Rate will not apply and the interest rate will revert to the standard interest rate applicable to your Platinum Savings account. As of 12/10/2018, the standard interest rate and APY for a Platinum Savings account in CT, DC, DE, FL, GA, MD, NJ, NY, SC and VA with an account balance of $0.01 to $99,999.99 is 0.03% (0.03% APY) and with an account balance of $100,000 and above is 0.05% (0.05% APY). Each tier shown reflects the current minimum daily collected balance required to obtain the applicable APY. Interest is compounded daily and paid monthly. The amount of interest earned is based on the daily collected balances in the account. Upon the expiration of the 12 month promotional period, standard interest rates apply. Minimum to open a Platinum Savings account is $25. A monthly service fee of $12 applies in any month the account falls below a $3,500 minimum daily balance. Fees may reduce earnings. Interest rates are variable and subject to change without notice. Wells Fargo may limit the amount you deposit to a Platinum Savings account to an aggregate of $1 million. Offer not available to Private Banking, Wealth, Business Banking or Wholesale customers. 2. Annual Percentage Yield (APY) is effective for accounts opened between 01/21/2019 and 03/22/2019. The 11-month New Dollar CD special requires a minimum of $25,000 brought to Wells Fargo from sources outside of Wells Fargo Bank N.A., or its affiliates to earn the advertised APY. Public Funds and Wholesale accounts are not eligible for this offer. APY assumes interest remains on deposit until maturity. Interest is compounded daily. Payment of interest on CDs is based on term: For terms less than 12 months (365 days), interest may be paid monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or at maturity (the end of the term). For terms of 12 months or more, interest may be paid monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. A fee for early withdrawal will be imposed and could reduce earnings on this account. Special Rates are applicable to the initial term of the CD only. At maturity, the Special Rate CD will automatically renew for a term of 6 months, at the interest rate and APY in effect for CDs on renewal date not subject to a Special Rate, unless the Bank has notified you otherwise. Due to the new money requirement, accounts may only be opened at your local branch. Wells Fargo reserves the right to modify or discontinue the offer at any time without notice. Offer cannot be combined with any other consumer deposit offer. Minimum new money deposit requirement of at least $25,000 is for this offer only and cannot be transferred to another account to qualify for any other consumer deposit offer. If you wish to take advantage of another consumer deposit offer requiring a minimum new money deposit, you will be required to do so with another new money deposit as stated in the offer requirements and qualifications. Offer cannot be reproduced, purchased, sold, transferred, or traded. 3. The Portfolio by Wells Fargo program has a $30 monthly service fee, which can be avoided when you have one of the following qualifying balances: $25,000 or more in qualifying linked bank deposit accounts (checking, savings, CDs, FDIC-insured IRAs) or $50,000 or more in any combination of qualifying linked banking, brokerage (available through Wells Fargo Advisors, LLC) and credit balances (including 10% of mortgage balances, certain mortgages not eligible). If the Portfolio by Wells Fargo relationship is terminated, the bonus interest rate on all eligible savings accounts, and discounts or fee waivers on other products and services, will discontinue and revert to the Bank’s then-current applicable rate or fee. For bonus interest rates on time accounts, this change will occur upon renewal. If the Portfolio by Wells Fargo relationship is terminated, the remaining unlinked Wells Fargo Portfolio Checking or Wells Fargo Prime Checking account will be converted to another checking product or closed.

Investment and Insurance Products: Are not Insured by FDIC or any Federal Government Agency

May Lose Value

Are not a Deposits of or Guaranteed by a Bank

© 2019 Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. All rights reserved. Deposit products offered by Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. Member FDIC. NMLSR ID 399801


6

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

A LIFE OF HER OWN BY EMILY HIGGINBOTHAM

From an early age Faigy Roth was skeptical of her family’s lifestyle. She grew up in an insular ultra-Orthodox Jewish enclave in Monsey, New York, where religion and tradition guide every aspect of their lives and a rabbi sets the rules for everyone. Yiddish is the native language. English and

debt,� Roth said. Her mother grew up in a similar Hasidic community in Williamsburg. She ran a strict household, directing discipline through her husband — but Roth knew who called the shots. She was also emotionally unstable and exhibited many obsessive, compulsive tendencies, Roth said. “When she prays she says the same word over and over again,� said Roth. “Her hands are always bleeding because she washes them so much.� Roth grew up with her parents’ expectation that she

CONTINUED ON PAGE 14

Here you are Planning Ahead Make a contribution before April 15th and you may be able to reduce your income taxes (see a tax advisor for details).

15 Month IRA CD

% 60 2.

Don’t wait! Open your IRA today.

APY

3.

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY LENDER | MEMBER FDIC

eeting

March

2

Do

you something You’d

like

us to

FIND YOUR FUN Hands-on enrichment programs for elementary, middle, and high school students explore.explo.org/fun

look

?

Email us at news@strausnews.com

with your long term services and supports needs. NY Connects can help you:

30 Month IRA CD

APY*

Info M

Get help

*

% 00

Faigy Roth at Hunter College’s winter commencement on January 24, 2019. Photo courtesy of Hunter College

into

A young woman had to flee a restrictive religious community, and her own family, to find a future

most traditional curricula are not taught in school. Women dress conservatively, covering elbows, knees and collarbones. Technology is restricted. Marriage is arranged. Roth is the oldest of 12 children. She spent much of her own childhood playing the role of assistant mother to the young ones, as her family couldn’t afford outside help. Her father — who was born in Israel and moved to the enclave when he was 12 years old — worked as a nursery school teacher in the community making around $2,000 a month. “The only thing my father ever had except for kids is

have

PROFILE

MANHATTAN | RIVERDALE SCARSDALE | WOODLAWN 888.212.6868 | 212.818.9090

CountryBankNY.com

*Effective, 12/24/2018. The 30 month IRA CD interest rate is 2.956% and the Annual Percentage Yield (APY) is 3.00%. The 15 Month IRA CD interest rate is 2.567% and the APY is 2.60%. The minimum opening balance is $1,000.00. Penalties may apply for early withdrawal. Rates are subject to change at Bank’s discretion. Consult your tax advisor for eligibility.

t 'JOE DBSF BOE TVQQPSU t 3FNBJO JOEFQFOEFOU t 6OEFSTUBOE DBSF PQUJPOT t 'JOE USBOTQPSUBUJPO t -FBSO BCPVU DBSFHJWFS TVQQPSUT t 'JOE B TVQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU QSPHSBN t (FU BOTXFST BCPVU .FEJDBSF t "QQMZ GPS .FEJDBJE BOE PUIFS CFOFmUT

5P mOE PVU NPSF DPOUBDU NY Connects $BMM 1-800-342-9871 '03 ."/)"55"/ $"-- *OEJWJEVBMT XIP BSF EFBG PS IBSE PG IFBSJOH DBO VTF NY Relay System 7-1-1. 0S POMJOF BU www.nyconnects.ny.gov


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

7

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

ORPHANAGE CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 embedded — convened a meeting on Friday with Alida Camp, the chair of Community Board 8, and the leaders of both Spence and St. Joseph’s Church, which was affiliated with the orphanage of the same name. The scene was Kallos’ district office, at 244 East 93rd St., and the principals included Father Boniface Ramsey, the pastor of St. Joseph’s on East 87th Street, with roughly 750 congregants, and Ellanor (Bodie) Brizendine, the head of school at Spence on East 91st Street, with about 750 students. Both institutions are woven into the fabric of the East Side. St. Joseph’s was built in 1894 for a German-speaking parish founded in 1873, while Spence was established in 1892 and moved to 91st Street in 1929. That’s pretty much where the similarities end. Ramsey conducts five weekend masses, as well as a monthly mass in German, and in his spare time, he’s the general editor of “The Works of Saint Augustine,” a planned 49-volume translation from the Latin of all of the Christian theologian’s 132 written works. Brizendine helms an all-girls, K-12, college-prep academy that, along with Brearley and Chapin, is considered one of the most prestigious in the city and the nation — and it’s got the budget to match: Tuition is pegged at $52,050 a year, and she draws an annual salary of $810,366. Despite the obvious contrasts, participants in the meeting describe an unlikely meetings of the minds. Ramsey brought with him

Father Boniface Ramsey, the pastor of St. Joseph’s Church in Yorkville, hammered out an agreement with the Spence School that will permanently commemorate the remnant of an old chapel on the site of a Catholic orphanage that was the predecessor of his church. Photo: Courtesy of St. Joseph’s Church

FRANK E. CAMPBELL - THE FUNERAL CHAPEL CONTINUES ITS COMMITMENT TO SUPPORT CULTURE, MUSIC AND THE ARTS!

IN COLLABORATION WITH THE 56HENRY GALLERY A rendering of a new athletic-and-educational facility that the Spence School for girls is building on East 90th Street. Rendering: Courtesy of the Spence School the baptismal records from the 1860s that were maintained by the orphanage, which was the predecessor institution to his church. He also produced an 1888 document in which St. Joseph’s Church requested a $2,400 loan from the orphan asylum. The disposition was unclear.

Moved by the orphans’ plight There was a point to this show-and-tell. Ramsey was presenting recorded evidence attesting to the long historic connectivity between the church on 87th Street and the orphanage on 90th Street that abuts the Spence project. Brizendine pored over the documents with Ramsey, clearly intrigued, observers say. She appeared particularly moved that the baptismal records of the orphans, almost all of whom had German names, included girls as well as boys. The bottom line was that the priest and the head of school, with some mediation from Kallos, came to terms on a unique agreement that will honor the orphanage’s monumental chapel in both the interior and exterior of the new field house. “I wanted the orphanage and its history to be recognized — and that’s just what I got,” Ramsey said in an interview. The new collaboration, which was announced by Kallos’ office, with an accompanying statement from Spence, covers a range of projects: • “The installation of a perma nent com memorat ive plaque on the exterior of the new building in proximity to the location of the former chapel,” a summary of the partnership agreement released on Feb. 18 says. The plaque will include text and possibly an image of the old chapel. • “The joint curation of an educational display to be located in the new lobby that will celebrate the rich history of St. Joseph’s Orphan Asylum,” according to the understanding. • “In addition, the school will work with Father Ramsey on

incorporating the role of St. Joseph’s into its rich curriculum on New York City history,” it said. Ramsey praised Brizendine for being “amenable to compromise.” “I came to the meeting with the desire that the sacred space, not just of the chapel, but of the grounds of the orphanage itself, be respected, and indeed it was,” he said. Ramsey, and preservationist groups like Friends of the Upper East Side, had held out hope that Spence could somehow incorporate the chapel façade into the new structure, perhaps by means of a glass curtain wall. But the school made clear that was not in the cards for both legal and engineering reasons. A fireproofing agent has to be placed in the void between the two buildings, which would rule out a viewing window. Still, Spence will insert a mineral-wool cocoon between the two structures, which will preserve, protect and insulate the remnant as it recedes from public view. “The fact that the site will once again serve children, after a hiatus of over a century of connection with St. Joseph’s, should rightfully be honored,” Spence said in its statement. “This partnership also echoes the school’s history, given our founder Clara Spence’s pioneering work in advocacy for orphans and for adoption services in the city,” the school added. “While we will never know whether any young girl’s path passed through both our institutions, the inspiring possibility cannot be excluded and should be considered by all,” Spence said. So will the old chapel remnant disappear forever? Not so fast. “It is very possible that this wall that has survived for all these years will be preserved for centuries to come,” Kallos said. “I do not doubt that one day, this relic of the past will reemerge to astonish future generations,” he added. invreporter@strausnews.com

YOU ARE INVITED TO A LIMITED AND EXCLUSIVE EXHIBIT FEATURING THE PAINTINGS OF NEW YORK CITY ARTIST CYNTHIA TALMADGE FRANK E. CAMPBELL THE FUNERAL CHAPEL 1076 MADISON AVENUE AT 81ST STREET NEW YORK, NY 10028

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 26TH and THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 28TH 6:00 PM TO 8:00 PM All are welcome to attend and meet Cynthia Talmadge Contact (212) 288-3500 for additional information. LIGHT REFRESHMENTS WILL BE SERVED! Owned by a subsidiary of Service Corp. International 1929 Allen Pkwy, Houston, TX 77019, 713-522-5141


8

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Voices

Write to us: To share your thoughts and comments go to ourtownny.com and click on submit a letter to the editor.

AMAZON LESSON: NO MORE CLOSED DOORS EAST SIDE OBSERVER BY ARLENE KAYATT

Civics and the City and Amazon — It happened on February 14th, but as Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney opined, “It was not the Valentine that New York needed.” Amazon pulled out of the deal that would have brought their HQ2 and 25,000 jobs to Long Island City before it would have been pummeled by New York politics. But that was inevitable, and our governor and mayor, who formed an unlikely alliance to broker a behind-the-scenes agreement, were tone deaf to how legislating and business have to be done in a new New York. No more threemen-in-a-room kind of deals. No more closed doors. No more cutting out local elected representatives. No more ignoring local communities and organizations impacted by legislation and deals that affect

them. In NYC everyone has a voice that gets heard. By tweet. By twitter. By email. By letters and postcards. By phone. By text. By marching. By protesting. Using microphones and megaphones. Decibel level — high. And yes, they vote. And yes, their electeds are vocal, too. Think Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez/AOC, Jimmy Van Bramer, Corey Johnson. They have the bully pulpit and they tweet. And twitter, and get heard on Errol Louis’s NY1. As does Carolyn Maloney whose congressional district includes LIC. Apparently, Cuomo and de Blasio neglected to factor all of that in when they decided to go it alone and without the collaboration of the city council, Queens representatives, and the local communities and organizations impacted by Amazon’s presence. Yes, the city council got to hold hearings, but only after the deal was made. The three-men in a room cadre was upended in November with the re-election of Andrea

Stewart-Cousins to the state Senate, who was then chosen by the body to be the Democratic Senate majority leader. Stewart-Cousins then passed her input on the deal — and showed her unwillingness to rubber-stamp the Cuomo-deBlasio-Amazon agreement — to state Senator and Deputy Majority Leader Michael Gianaris, whom she appointed to a panel that could have final say (make that nay say) on whether Amazon was coming to Queens. Gianiris represents Queens’s 12th state Senate district, which covers LIC, Astoria and Sunnyside. While initially a supporter of Amazon coming to LIC, he is now strongly opposed. There’s blame to go around for the undone deal. On the NYC side, politicians bypassing elected government representatives and their constituents and dealing behind the scenes with the corporation without notice and collaboration. On the other side, Amazon expecting special treatment and giveaways that would adversely

impact the city or communities or give them no benefit. Seems a good time to heed the advice of Justice Louis D. Brandeis who reminded that “Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.” And from an unknown source, “Next.”

Bar crawl — The SOTU (State of the Union) speech is long since gone, except maybe for the pixel visions of Congress’s contingent of mostly newly-elected women all in white. But the night was also prime time for like-minded politicos to join together to listen to the ritual annual President’s monologue. So the Metropolitan Republican Club packed the tables and bar at the UES’s Dorrian’s, with the overflow crowd making it to the back bar. Seated together at a crowded table were newly elected Met Club prez Ian Walsh Reilly and Manhattan Republican County Chair Andrea Catsimatidis. A less jubilant crowd of Democrats partook of the SOTU

speech at a watch party a little over a block away at Upstairs at Five Mile Stone, on Second Ave, where the Women’s Leadership Forum Metro New York held a gathering. Their jubilation awaited Stacey Abrams’s Dem Response. Manhattan Dems on hand during the evening included Borough President Gale Brewer, Vice President of State Dems Trudy Mason, and Upper East Side for Change’s Monica Atiya, who hosted the event for the women’s forum. I split my night between the two parties. As expected, the Met Club crowd cheered when the TV cameras zeroed in on Republicans and jeered when a Dem face appeared. Their cheers and jeers mirrored the sounds coming from the TV screens. Notably, however, there were no boos, on screen or at Dorrian’s, when the camera zeroed in on Amy Klobachar. Could be because the Senator hadn’t yet announced that she, too, was running for a shot at giving the 2021 SOTU speech.

EMBRACE THE SPIRIT OF PARKLAND PUBLIC EYE BY JON FRIEDMAN

Last May, I went to a rooftop party on West 72nd Street, prepared to skewer my fellow pretentious New York City literati. Instead, I quickly forgot about the poseurs and came away awestruck at two of the unexpected guests: David Hogg and Cameron Kasky. They stand for as much today as they did on that Tuesday evening. Cameron and David, survivors of the massacre one year ago at the Marjory Stoneman High School in Parkland, Fla., had come to New York to rally support for their gun-control mission. As I wrote last year in this space, they — heroic and stoic — stood apart from the throng of self-important New Yorkers, needing only the company of one another to confirm their importance. They reminded me of what

the Beatles encountered in the film A Hard Day’s Night, as they, too, suddenly found themselves — ordinary kids not so long ago — thrust into an adult-created media freak show that had forced them to grow up overnight. They could have been two of my college students, judging by their youthfulness — and their new burden was a fate I wouldn’t wish on any undergraduate. What may be the most impressive aspect of Cameron, David and their cohorts (especially Emma “We Call B.S.” Gonzalez) was how they used their new status as Media Flavors of the Month to promote the cause of gun control. They looked like any innocent teenagers but they wanted no part of the fame game for their own selves. I wish their particular form of activism on every young person, especially the Stony Brook and Hunter College students that I teach the virtues of journalism and news literacy. I have no illusions, though.

Like most teenagers, they don’t want to be taught anything. They want to discover the world on their own terms, without some old person exhorting them to stop saying “like” four or five times in a typical sentence. And good for them. I was once the same way. So, come to think of it, were you. The Parkland students reminded me that is nothing short of thrilling to see a spark of activism in its early stages. But I had seen it building for a few years. A lot of my students sure felt “the Bern” in 2016, as the emergence of straight-talking Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders galvanized them in an otherwise dreary and ultimately infuriating election year. And what now, a year after Parkland (which, as The New York Times pointed out on Feb. 13, has become a form of shorthand for school shootings)? Is activism going to continue during what looms as a more hopeful election cycle than what young Americans had

David Hogg (left) and Emma Gonzalez (front, second from right) at a rally in Fort Lauderdale on February 17, 2018. Photo: Barry Stock, via flickr to sit through in 2016? Each day, it seems, another interesting and attractive new Democratic candidate for the White House steps forward. It’ll be fascinating to see which politician can excite this young generation. Amy Klobuchar’s form of “Minnesota Nice,” reminding me of the practical, no-nonsense Marge Gunderson from the movie “Fargo?” Cory Booker? Kamala Harris? Kirsten Gillibrand? And what about Beto? How about two of the

older answers, Bloomberg and Biden? Even, dare I say it, Howard Schultz? (Well, full disclosure: I am typing this piece in one of his Starbucks shops so I should not be snarky). The presidential candidates all say the right things, of course. They want to project enough toughness and fiscal competence to sway the adults, who are most likely to vote in an election. But if they can’t embrace the spirit of David, Cameron, Emma and the rest of the Parkland Generation, then I call B.S.

President & Publisher, Jeanne Straus nyoffice@strausnews.com

STRAUS MEDIA your neighborhood news source nyoffice@strausnews.com 212-868-0190

Vice President/CFO Otilia Bertolotti Vice President/CRO Vincent A. Gardino advertising@strausnews.com

Associate Publishers Seth L. Miller, Ceil Ainsworth Regional Sales Manager Tania Cade

Account Executives Fred Almonte, David Dallon Director of Partnership Development Barry Lewis

Editor-In-Chief, Alexis Gelber Deputy Editor David Noonan

Senior Reporter Doug Feiden Staff Reporter Michael Garofalo

Director of Digital Pete Pinto Director, Arts & Entertainment Alizah Salario


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

ENOUGH ALREADY! PASS THE NEW YORK HEALTH ACT! VIEWPOINT We don’t need any more studies, we need health care for all BY COLETTE SWIETNICKI

Governor Cuomo’s progressive agenda came to a screeching halt when he put the brakes on the single-payer “Medicare for all” plan that much of the new Democratic state Senate majority campaigned on. Prior to the November elections, Cuomo said single-payer sounded like a good idea; but afterwards he added “ ... at the Federal level.” Now he is proposing a commission comprised of “health policy and insurance experts” to study other options, including “strengthening New York’s commercial insurance market,” the primary culprit responsible for our present broken system. The New York Health Act was first introduced in the New York Assembly in 1992 by Chelsea’s own Richard N. Gottfried. It’s been around ever since, gaining more strength and approval in recent years with the worsening of our health care system. As New Yorkers have learned, the Affordable Care Act and other reforms are helpful but insufficient, leaving us at the mercy of the insurance companies. The state Assembly has passed the bill with strong majorities the last four years. New York Health, as the program is called, provides comprehensive health coverage for all New York residents, regardless of age, income, wealth, employment or immigration status, including those currently on Medicare and Medicaid. It provides inpatient and outpatient medical, primary, and preventive care. It covers prescription drugs, dental, vision, hearing, mental and behavioral health. And when the bill is reintroduced shortly, it will include long-term care. Under the program, a simple insurance card will be your access to the doctor and hospital of your choice, without networks to navigate and with no premiums, deductibles or co-pays. Unlike some systems, including the British National Health Service, doctors would not be

Governor Andrew Cuomo wants another study of the New York Health Act, which was first introduced in 1992. Photo: Don Pollard, via Gov. Andrew Cuomo/New York State flickr page government employees. Under New York Health, public financing pays for care that is delivered in the private sector, very similar to the way Medicare works. Doctors could still be in private practice, but with a public funding source. And who picks up the tab for all of this? Today, premiums, deductibles, co-pays, and other health care costs have no relation to a person’s ability to pay. Americans pay twice as much as other industrialized nations for health care with no better, and increasingly worse, outcomes. In the U.S., over 31 percent of every health care dollar goes to paperwork, overhead, CEO salaries, profits, lobbying and such. Without a unified system, with thousands of different types of insurance, processing payments becomes duplicative, complex, and fragmented. In 2013, Duke University Medical Center had 400 more billing clerks (1300) than hospital beds (900). Medicare, with 44 million recipients, operates with just 3 percent overhead, a fraction of the overhead in the commercial insurance market. Getting rid of for-profit middlemen and administrative waste; being able to negotiate drug prices for the entire population; and reducing the health care monies eaten by CEO pay will not take us the full way to guaranteeing all New Yorkers comprehensive cradle to grave

coverage. A new progressive income tax will be required. And I’m aware that whenever you say the word “tax” people’s antennae engage. So how would it fare if I said, “Would you like to trade in your premium payments, deductibles, coinsurance, out of pocket and out-of-network charges for a progressive tax under which 98 percent of New York households would pay less for health care than they pay now?” Opponents will claim it’s unaffordable. But anyone judging this must compare it to what we are currently spending on health care. It’s the status quo that is unaffordable. Multiple studies at the state and national levels, including one by the right-wing Mercatus Center, show that single-payer can provide universal health care for the same or less than the cost of the current system. Despite its recent success in the state Assembly, the New York Health Act has never gotten past the state Senate, which has been under Republican control for the past decade. But that’s over now. With a Democratic majority in both houses, the new progressive agenda must include the passage of the New York Health Act. It’s time for New York to lead. It’s time to ride the blue wave to a better health care system for all New Yorkers today, and all Americans tomorrow.

9


10

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

NEIGHBORHOOD’S BEST To place an ad in this directory, Call Douglas at 212-868-0190 ext. 352.

EDUCATION

DINING

›’—Â?ČąÂ’Â—ČąÂ˜Â›Čą –Ž—Â?Â’Â˜Â—ČąÂ?Â‘Â’ÂœČąÂŠÂ? Â?Â˜Â›ČąÂŠČą Čą ŽœœŽ›Â?ǡ ›’Â&#x;ŠÂ?ÂŽČą Š›Â?¢ȹ Â˜Â˜Â–ÂœČąČŠČą Ž••¢ȹ Š—Œ’—Â?ȹȊȹ ŠÂ?Ž›’—Â? řŗŖȹ ÂŽÂœÂ?ȹśř›Â?Čą Â?›ŽŽÂ?ČąČŠČąĹ˜Ĺ—Ĺ˜ČŹĹ˜ĹœĹ›ČŹĹ›Ĺ›Ĺ–Ĺ–    ǯÂ?ÂžÂ›Â”ÂžÂŠÂŁÂ›ÂŽÂœÂ?Šž›Š—Â?ÇŻÂŒÂ˜Â–Čą

Science FUN with Dr. Wow!

After School Programs

‹

Science Enrichment in the Home

‹

Birthday parties and other events

Steve Gould ‹ 917-822-9708 (mobile)

LOCKSMITH

HOME CARE PERSONALIZED HOME CARE

34 Years Experience Call 24/7 for a free consultation!

(877) 212-4222

‹

toll-free

CUSTOMIZED CARE DEMENTIA TRAINING FOR THE AIDES SOCIAL WORK SERVICES INCLUDED

SKY LOCKSMITH & HARDWARE NOW OFFERING FULL SERVICE PAINT COLOR MATCHING & MIXING

$5 OFF $5 OFF COUPON COUPON

Discover the world around the corner. Find community events, gallery openings, book launches and much more: Go to nycnow.com

EDITOR’S PICK

Feb 23 JUST KIDDING: DOPPELSKOPE: THE AMAZING STORY MACHINE Symphony Space 2537 Broadway at West 95th St 11:00 a.m & 2:00 p.m. $14 symphonyspace.org 212-864-5400 This innovative show from Doppelskope features multiple styles of puppetry, including tabletop puppetry, object theatre, and shadow puppetry, as well as live music, projections, and physical comedy.

1-GALLON 1-GALLON VALSPAR VALSPAR PAINT PAINT ANY ANYCOLOR COLOR STORE ONLY VALIDVALID IN IN STORE ONLY USE BY 06/19 USE BY 06/19 1-GALLON PER COUPON 1-GALLON PER COUPON

Visit cohme.org or email referrals@cohme.org

Store Locations: 1574 1st Ave / 2212 Broadway 24/7 EMERGENCY LOCKSMITH SERVICE 212-288-7773

PETS

PROPERTY FINANCING

25% OFF YOUR DOG’S FIRST OVERNIGHT STAY TREAT YOUR DOG TO A VACATION WITH US!

Training Walking Jogging Overnight Daycare Grooming

*Valid for new clients only. Holiday rates apply.

Michael McGovern

Licensed Mortgage Loan Originator NMLS# 114132 - NY, FL Call us today

212-696-8364

t "MM GPSNT PG 3FTJEFOUJBM BOE $PNNFSDJBM 1SPQFSUZ 'JOBODJOH t 0WFS :FBST &YQFSJFODF PG /:$ $PPQ BOE $POEP 'JOBODJOH t 3FMBUJPOTIJQT XJUI &WFSZ -FOEFS JO UIF .BSLFUQMBDF UP FOTVSF ZPV HFU 'VOEFE

www.prudentialb.com

info@akccanineretreat.com www.akccanineretreat.com

NNDHPWFSO!QSVEFOUJBMC DPN t $BMM %JSFDU

REAL ESTATE

REAL ESTATE

KARPOFF AFFILIATES

Senior Move Manager Real Estate Broker

KARPOFF AFFILIATES is your single stop for senior life transitions and real estate brokerage needs. Compassionate Senior Move Manager & Expert Real Estate Broker

Marilyn Karpoff www.KarpoffAfďŹ liates.com mkarpoff@karpoffafďŹ liates.com 212.358.8044 290 Third Avenue, Ste 26C, NYC 10010

DO YOU WANT TO DISCOVER THE VALUE OF YOUR HOME? Then please give us a call ... ‡ 5HVLGHQWLDO 5HDO (VWDWH %URNHUV 2YHU <HDUV ‡ 6SHFLDOL]LQJ LQ &RRSV &RQGRV 7RZQKRXVHV

Allow us to share our valuable knowledge and experience Whether Selling or Purchasing or just curious, it will be our pleasure to meet and consult and help you make the right decision. Phyllis Gallaway 6U *OREDO 5( $GYLVRU $VVRF %URNHU 3K\OOLV JDOODZD\#VRWKHE\VKRPHV FRP

917-769-7079

Laura Gruber *OREDO 5( $GYLVRU $VVRF %URNHU /DXUD JUXEHU#VRWKHE\VKRPHV FRP

917-912-2023

Sotheby’s International Realty

Thu 21 Fri 22

Sat 23

â–ş FILM SCREENING: RIFF-RAFF

▲ EXHIBITION TOUR — NEDJEMANKH AND HIS GILDED COFFIN

ENCORE! ENCORES: GREATEST HITS SING ALONG SHOW & TELL

The Met 1000 Fifth Ave 10:30 a.m. Free with museum admission This exhibition features the recently acquired coffin of Nedjemankh, a rare example of a late Ptolemaic coffin made for a signiďŹ cant member of Egyptian society. Space is limited; ďŹ rst come, ďŹ rst served. metmuseum.org 212-535-7710

Library for the Performing Arts 40 Lincoln Center Plaza 11:00 a.m. Free From Fiorello! to Chicago; Pal Joey to Li’l Abner; Do, Re, Mi to No, No, Nannette — since 1994, City Center Encores! has been serving up beloved, lost musicals to New York City’s most passionate musical theater connoisseurs. Come sing along to live performances of your favorite musical numbers from the Encores canon. nypl.org 917-275-6975

96th St Library 112 East 9th St 2:00 p.m. Free Jean Harlow and Spencer Tracy star in this 1936 classic, directed by Walter Ruben, about life and love on the California ďŹ shing docks. nypl.org (212) 289-0908


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

11

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Sun 24 Mon 25 Tue 26 DREAMCATCHER POETRY & WOMEN OF THE RAMAPOUGHLENAPE NATION FILM SCREENING W/OLEANA & LISA LEVART NY Society for Ethical Culture 2 West 64th St 1:30 p.m. Free This poetry reading by Oleana Whispering Dove, Eastern Tsalagi descendant, is a dance of verse and rhyme among Poets with distinction that will challenge, entertain and stimulate minds, and hearts with an innate indigenous spirit that lingers. It will be followed by a documentary screening of :”The Women men of the Ramapough Lenape ape Nation” — a behindthe-scenes exploration of the the most recent photographic series by artist Lisa Levart, Directed by Myles Aronowitz. ethical.nyc (212) 874-5210

JEROME ROBBINS’ BROADWAY The Guggenheim 1071 Fifth Ave 7:30 p.m. $45 To celebrate Jerome Robbins’ centennial and the 30th anniversary of Jerome Robbins’ Broadway, author Steven Suskin will moderate a discussion with original cast members and creatives. guggenheim.org 212-423-3500

PREVIEW SCREENING OF THE BOY WHO HARNESSED THE WIND, AND CONVERSATION WITH CHIWETEL EJIOFOR 92Y 1395 Lexington Ave 7:15 p.m. $35 Moderator Annette Insdorf will interview Chiwetel Ejiofor after the preview screening of “The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind.” 92y.org 212-415-5500

ACTIVITIES FOR THE FERTILE MIND

thoughtgallery.org NEW YORK CITY

Race & Health Series: Could Tuskegee Happen Today?

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 26TH, 6PM NY Academy of Medicine | 1216 Fifth Ave. | 212-822-7200 | nyam.org Hear expert perspectives on the “Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis,” an unethical medical research study conducted by the U.S. Public Health Service, which withheld penicillin from hundreds of African-American men from 1932 to 1972 (free).

Wed 27

Truth and Fiction in Italian Renaissance Portraiture

WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 27TH, 6PM The Frick Collection | 1 E. 70th St. | 212-288-0700 | frick.org

▲ YOUNG WRITERS’ WORKSHOP: POETRY CAFE WITH DAVE JOHNSON

Aimee Ng, Associate Curator of the Frick, leads a talk on Giovanni Battista Moroni, the subject of a new exhibition, Moroni: The Riches of Renaissance Portraiture. Ng will delve into the inventiveness and complexity of the artist, as well as the “truth” apparent in his work (free).

The New York Society Library 53 East 79th St 5:00 p.m. $15 Learn how writers turn their ideas into poems with playwright Dave Johnson. Gain the inspiration and knowledge to craft your own poetry, and share your writing with others. nysoclib.org 212-288-6900

MONDAY, APRIL 8TH, 6:30PM

Just Announced | Three Identical Strangers Temple Emanu-El | 1 E. 65th St. | 888-718-4253 | emanuelnyc.org The interplay of nurture and nature, layered on top of a stranger-than-fiction story, makes the documentary Three Identical Strangers some seriously compelling viewing. Catch a screening plus a conversation on ethics with the director and triplets David Kellman and Bobby Shafran ($18).

For more information about lectures, readings and other intellectually stimulating events throughout NYC,

sign up for the weekly Thought Gallery newsletter at thoughtgallery.org.


12

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

HONORING JACKIE ROBINSON An exhibit at the Museum of the City of New York features Look magazine photos of the baseball legend and his family — many never seen before BY LORRAINE DUFFY MERKL

Last month, Jackie Robinson would have celebrated his 100th birthday. To honor the player who broke the color barrier of America’s pastime by joining the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947, The Museum of the City of New York (Fifth Avenue between 103rd & 104th Streets) and the Jackie Robinson Foundation are presenting “In the Dugout with Jackie Robinson: An Intimate Portrait of a Baseball Legend,” now through Sept. 15, 2019. The exhibit features Look magazine photos of Robinson and the Dodgers, many never before seen images from the Museum’s own collection, as well as memorabilia and rare footage of the Robinson family, for a comprehensive portrayal of this groundbreaking figure. Of all his accomplishments — becoming the first African American in Major League Baseball, receiving the inaugural MLB Rookie of the Year Award, winning the National League Most Valuable Player Award in 1949, his All-Star status for six consecutive seasons from ‘49 through ’54, playing in six World Series and contributing to the Dodgers’ 1955 World Series championship, and being inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1962 after an exceptional 10-year MLB career — the most inspiring thing about him was how

IF YOU GO WHAT: “In the Dugout with Jackie Robinson: An Intimate Portrait of a Baseball Legend” WHERE: The Museum of the City of New York (Fifth Avenue between 103rd & 104th Streets) WHEN: Through Sept. 15, 2019 he carried himself as the sole black man in his profession. When he moved from the Negro American League to one of the Dodgers’ farm teams, the manager asked that Robinson be reassigned to another club affiliate (GM Branch Rickey refused the request). Jim Crow laws in the south meant Robinson was not allowed to stay in whites only hotels or eat in restaurants with his teammates. Baseball fans hurled racial slurs at him along with their soda bottles. And some fellow ball players refused to play with him. He also received death threats. “Back in the days when integration wasn’t fashionable,” said the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., “[Robinson] underwent the trauma and humiliation and the loneliness which comes with being a pilgrim walking the lonesome byways toward the high road of freedom.” Prejudice has not gone away. Not a day seems to go by without reports of a racially motivated or anti-Semitic crime, an attack on someone in the LGBTQ community or discrimination of a disabled person or woman who dares to want to do a job held traditionally by men. It’s not unusual to want to

Jackie Robinson at bat, 1949. Photo: Frank Bauman. Courtesy of Museum of the City of New York. The Look Collection. Gift of Cowles Magazines, Inc. seek revenge and show perpetrators “you’re mad as hell and not gonna take it anymore.” But this can often turn the victim into the victimizer. More satisfaction can come from doing things Jackie’s way. Through all his travails, the second baseman adopted a turn the other cheek policy, facing his adversity with dignity and grace. He never lashed out at his tormentors, choosing instead to focus on doing his job. And what a job he did. During his career, Robinson played in 1382 games, had 4877 at bats, 947 runs, 1518 hits, 137 home runs, 734 RBIs and a batting average of .311. Because everyone loves a winner, after a while even his critics cheered him on. In 1997, MLB retired his uniform number 42 across all major league teams; he was the first pro athlete in any sport to be so honored. On April 15, 2004, MLB also created a new annual tradition, “Jackie Robinson Day,” on which every player on every team wears 42. Robinson also was the first

black television analyst in MLB and the first black VP of a major American corporation, Chock Full O’Nuts. In the 1960s, he helped establish the Freedom National Bank, an AfricanAmerican-owned financial institution based in Harlem, New York. He died October 24, 1972, at age 53, in Stamford, Connecticut, after which, in recognition of his achievements on and off the field, Robinson was posthumously awarded the Congressional Gold Medal and Presidential Medal of Freedom. Jackie Robinson’s legacy left us many things, especially that when people try to marginalize you, get your bat (figuratively, not literally) and swing for the fences. To quote the British poet, George Herbert: “Living well is the best revenge.” Or better put by the gracious Robinson, “A life is not important except in the impact it has on other lives.” Lorraine Duffy Merkl is the author of the novels “Fat Chick” and “Back to Work She Goes.”

Jackie and Rachel Robinson at home in Brooklyn, 1949. Photo: Frank Bauman. Courtesy of Museum of the City of New York. The Look Collection. Gift of Cowles Magazines, Inc.


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

13

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Your Neighborhood News Source

BEYOND BROADWAY - EAST SIDE The #1 online community for NYC theater:

www.show-score.com

NOW PLAYING IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD FROM $30

FROM $30

FROM $30

GLORIA: A LIFE

SPACEMAN

TRICK OR TREAT

185 REVIEWS ENDS MAR 31

8 REVIEWS ENDS MAR 10

121 REVIEWS ENDS FEB 24

82

80

74

This world premiere biographical drama explores the life of iconic feminist Gloria Steinem. Directed by Tony Award winner Diane Paulus.

This drama about a woman’s solo journey to Mars explores the depths of mankind’s last true frontiers: outer space and a grieving heart.

Northern Stage’s new dark comedy skewers a family in crisis on Halloween. Starring Gordon Clapp (“NYPD Blue”).

DARYL ROTH THEATRE - 101 E 15TH ST

THE WILD PROJECT - 195 E 3RD ST

59E59 THEATER - 59 E 59TH ST

WHAT’S TRENDING ACROSS NYC

COMING SOON

FROM $30

FROM $20

THE LIGHT 82 REVIEWS JUST OPENED

SURELY GOODNESS AND MERCY PREVIEWS START FEB 26

In an underfunded public school in Newark, a bible-toting boy with a photographic memory befriends the cantankerous old lunch lady.

83

THEATRE ROW - 410 W 42ND ST

On what should be one of the happiest days for a couple, groundshifting accusations from the past resurface.

FROM $95

ROBERT W. WILSON MCC THEATER SPACE - 511 W 52ND ST

FLEABAG PREVIEWS START FEB 27

FROM $39

A MAN FOR ALL SEASONS

Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s comic solo play went on to inspire a hit television series, now she brings the original show stateside for its NYC debut.

57 REVIEWS ENDS MAR 03

SOHO PLAYHOUSE - 15 VANDAM ST

79 FROM $49

The Tony-winning drama about Sir Thomas More asks a simple question: what price are you willing to pay to keep your convictions?

THE BIG BANG THEORY: A POP-ROCK MUSICAL PARODY PREVIEWS START MAR 06

THEATRE ROW - 410 W 42ND ST

This new pop-rock musical spoofs the beloved CBS Series and its eccentric and funny group of scientists.

FROM $70

JERRY ORBACH THEATER - 1627 BROADWAY

ALICE BY HEART 38 REVIEWS IN PREVIEWS

FROM $49

SINCERELY, OSCAR PREVIEWS START MAR 27

80

Content provided by

The Tony winning creators of “Spring Awakening,” reunite for MCC’s new musical inspired by “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.”

A new musical celebrating Broadway’s legendary lyricist, Oscar Hammerstein II.

THE NEWMAN MILLS THEATER - WEST 52ND ST & 10TH AVE

THEATRE ROW - 410 W 42ND ST KEY:


14

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

RESTAURANT INSPECTION RATINGS FEB 6 - 12, 2018 The following listings were collected from the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s website and include the most recent inspection and grade reports listed. We have included every restaurant listed during this time within the zip codes of our neighborhoods. Some reports list numbers with their explanations; these are the number of violation points a restaurant has received. To see more information on restaurant grades, visit www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/services/restaurant-inspection.shtml. The Hunterian

413 E 70th St

A

Giovanni 25

25 East 83 Street

A

Trinity Pub

229 East 84 Street

A

Mumtaz

1582 York Avenue

A

Ethyl’s

1629 2nd Ave

A

Domino’s Pizza

1841 1st Ave

A

Empire Corner II

1415 5 Avenue

A

Wing Gong Restaurant

2109 1st Ave

A

La Nostra Pizzeria

2146 2 Avenue

A

Aloha Harlem

2245 1st Ave

A

Judy’s Spanish Restuarant

1505 Lexington Ave

A

Jiang China King

1759 Lexington Ave

A

Burger King

154 E 116th St

A

DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? Email us at NEWS@STRAUSNEWS.COM The local paper for the Upper East Side

Advertise with Our Town today! Call Vincent Gardino at 212-868-0190

OurTownNY.com

Faigy Roth, here at about age 8, was the oldest of 12 children. Photo: Courtesy of Faigy Roth,

ACONTINUED LIFE OF HER OWN FROM PAGE 6 would get married to someone in the community, have babies and raise them as she had been raised. But the reality of it was mystifying to her. “When you get married — and this is something growing up I could not imagine myself doing — you have to shave your head,” Roth said. “People do not know why they’re doing anything, they just know this is what we do. So you shave your head. But that’s not enough, you wear a wig on top of it; but that’s not enough, you wear a scarf on top of the wig.” Roth spent the first 18 years of her life running up against these rules; at times bending them shrewdly or breaking them with abandon. She lived this way until she couldn’t do it any longer, when she was forced to choose between an arranged marriage and leaving everything behind for a world that she was yearning to know.

It was then that she fled her family and the constraints they placed upon her. For all of the drama in Roth’s life, her story is really one of resilience and re-invention. In just a few years, she went from not knowing how to speak English to becoming an accomplished student and college graduate. After earning her GED, Roth spent two years at Kingsborough Community College before studying human biology at Hunter College, where she succeeded through a love of learning. “The same young woman who had never spoken a sentence in English, had never looked into a microscope, and didn’t know what a major was, graduated in a field that she loves with the highest GPA in the major’s history,” said Hunter president Jennifer Raab. Now 30, Roth, who lives in Brooklyn, has the freedom she never had in the community: to decide how exactly she wants to spend the rest of her life.

Leaving Home By the time she was 14, Roth tried to spend as little time with her family as she could. After school, she visited the residents at the senior living home, making them laugh or sitting with them during meals. Or she would hide out in her room. “You know when you’re living in constant fear of being yelled at?” she said. “That was me.” By that point she had lost trust in the adults in her community. She’d been treated poorly at school and those in power didn’t help her, Roth said. But even thinking about leaving was difficult. Most of the people who left were either men or were married. “It’s like you live in a different world, and trying to get out, it’s like how? Where do you start? How do you get away if everyone you know is ... in there?” When she was 18, Roth realized that she had to make a choice it would be too late. Her parents were starting to bring


up names of boys who could be her potential spouse. “I knew that when I was going to leave I was going to hurt my parents,” Roth said. “It was going to be difficult for me, but thinking about bringing in a stranger, whoever this guy is, and hurting him as well, and his parents, I thought, ‘I can’t do that.’” So she suggested a compromise. She told her parents that, sure, she would get married, but it would be to someone who was not as staunch in the religious practice. This man could be religious, but maybe he also watched movies and had a cellphone. It didn’t work. “My mom started crying, her body started shaking, and I’d never seen that. My father was yelling, ‘It’s because of you! She’s crying because of you!’” Roth recalled. “In their head, they were thinking, you’re going to get married and like that kind of life.” Not long after that conversation, Roth left. She lived on the outskirts of the community in another religious neighborhood for a year. She worked and saved money, but her parents were still trying to interfere in her decisions. “I booked a one-way flight to Israel. That’s how I fully got away from it.”

Making a Life of Her Own After a year traveling in Israel, staying with her father’s relatives, Roth came back to the states with an empty bank account and a desire to do something with her life. She worked quickly to establish an independent life. Acquaintances who had also left the community let her stay at their place in Brooklyn until she was on her feet. She soon found a job managing a warehouse that distributed Judaica items. On the job she was able to pick up English easily, which she said was fu-

15

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019 eled by desperation. “That’s the best way to learn,” she said, “when you have no choice.” But her living situation remained precarious. One day she came home from work to find her belongings on the street with the locks to the house changed. “I wasn’t making that much where I could go to a hotel for a few nights. I didn’t have any family or help,” she said. One night, she had nowhere to stay and slept on a bench on Ocean Parkway. “I felt hopeless. I really did,” she said. “I questioned, what’s the future?” But she never questioned if leaving the community had been worth it. “When I do have financial hardships, being that I don’t have anywhere to get the help, I always dream about being back at home with my parents,” she said. “They’re trying to force me to marry. I wake up and I literally tremble. I’d rather be homeless than be in that situation.” Seeking the education she was deprived of in the community, Roth took the GED so that she could enroll in college. When she went to Kingsborough to sign up for classes, the advisor asked Roth what she wanted to major in. “What’s a major?” Roth asked. The advisor laughed until it was clear that Roth wasn’t making a joke. She started in liberal arts at the junior college and gravitated toward biology, which she declared as her major when she enrolled at Hunter. “I think it’s that it makes sense to me without studying,” she said about the appeal of biology. She gained such a good reputation as a student among her peers, Roth said, that they vied to be her partner in labs. “I was like walking in the dark, but I studied so hard,” she said. The work paid off last month, when Roth graduated with the high-

est GPA for a biology major in the history of the college.

The future beckons Now, Roth is deciding what’s next for her. Currently, she runs two businesses of her own: one that sells stemless tumbler wine glasses and another that sells birthday and holiday gift boxes. For the time being, she enjoys being her own boss, but is also looking at medical school as an option, to study cardiology. Regardless of what she chooses, she has a few simple goals for the future: A house of her own in a suburban neighborhood, two dogs, and a Jeep. She’s also been thinking about children, but the idea of marriage is still unpalatable. “I’ve had relationships, but I don’t understand why you need to get married,” she said. “It’s not something that I ever wanted. I could live without it pretty happily.” When asked what her parents — with whom she’s recently rekindled a relationship — would think of her ideas for the future, she sighed heavily. “I don’t think they’ll ever be happy with my lifestyle. I sometimes think about it: if I have a kid, would I tell them about it? I think I’d have to cut off contact.” Though she has lived outside the community for about a decade, Roth is still surprised by the world outside of it. When she ventured out on her own, she felt like a foreigner in her own country. Everything was new. But what has stuck with her in these 10 years, is just how much she can relate to others who did not grow up in the community. “I was surprised by how alike most humans are,” she said. “I always thought of the ‘rest of the world’ as very different than myself. I came to realize that most of us are very similar at our core.”

RU

SKILLS IN MOTION Is falling a concern for you?

Build strength, balance, confidence, and agility in a fun, social setting. Register today for SKILLS IN MOTION, Asphalt Green’s comprehensive fall prevention program for those ages 62+. LIMITED-TIME OFFER: Bring a friend, get 50 percent off! CLASS RUNS MARCH 5 THROUGH JUNE 13 AND MEETS TWICE PER WEEK.

REGISTER:

Contact skillsinmotion@asphaltgreen.org or 212.369.8890 x2283 555 E. 90th St. | asphaltgreen.org


16

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Business

Ask a Broker BY ANDREW KRAMER

The owners of this combined apartment must address several issues before they can list it for sale. Photo: Courtesy of Matt Vacca

Seventeen years ago we purchased the alcove studio adjoining our family’s two-bedroom coop and created a lovely three-bedroom plus den. We’re thinking of selling in the coming months, and one of the brokers we interviewed asked us if the two apartments are legally combined. He said they would need to be in order for us to sell them to a new buyer. Is it true that this needs to be done in order for us to sell? And what is involved in legally combining the apartments?

I’ve been down this road several times and in order to sell a combined apartment in a coop, the two apartments need to have one stock and lease. Otherwise, it’s the equivalent of purchasing two “primary residences” in the same coop, which is challenging, if even possible. Therefore you’ll need to hire an architect and an expeditor, who can handle everything, from measuring and preparing new floor plans of the current combined space, reviewing all of the plumbing, gas, electric, etc. and filing with the Department of Buildings (DOB). This process takes about three months and you should anticipate spending about $25,000 to implement.I advise that sellers should start this process as soon as possible, as you don’t want to delay or potentially lose a sale because it’s an open issue. Andrew Kramer is a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker with Brown Harris Stevens. Direct your real estate questions to askandrew@bhsusa.com. You can learn more about Andrew at www.kramernyc.com or by contacting him at 212-317-3634.

Photo: Steven Strasser

HOW TO PROPERLY PRICE A HOME REAL ESTATE Using analytics and intuition to get it right for today’s property values Pricing property right blends art and science. Particularly in a market like this one, in which both sales prices and sales volume have softened from month-to-month, analysis, while critically important, can only help so much. While we know a sale of a similar property took place three months ago, how do we compare this price to today’s property value? Values in today’s market change

from month-to-month. Since prices do not become public until after a sale closes, and since a period of three to four months often elapses between contract signing and closing, sales prices are already out of date by the time they become public. Would Ken Griffin’s penthouse at 220 Central Park South, which was no doubt signed for some time ago, still be worth $238 million to him if he bought it today? Who knows? In this environment, what are agents and sellers (not to mention buyers) to do? Here are a few suggestions: Use Your Relationships. The most

useful comparable sales in a changing market are always those which have gone into contract during the past few weeks or month. Agents who have cultivated relationships within the industry can contact fellow agents whose sales have gone into contract recently to find out what the purchase price was. Even if those agents are reluctant to share an exact price, they will usually give you a sense of what their property received if you have been collegial in your behavior with them in the past. It’s one of many reasons why it’s always better to be a good citizen rather than a difficult one.

Abjure Asking Prices. Even in a down market, many asking prices are aspirational rather than realistic. They don’t provide useful guidance as to proper pricing; in fact, often they present a cautionary tale in how pricing incorrectly can lead to months on the market. This is often the highest and best use of asking price information in discussion between agent and seller: these prices can demonstrate what NOT to do. Frederick W. Peters is Chief Executive Officer of Warburg Realty Partnership.


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Real Estate Sales

17


18

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

HOLES IN PLAN TO LIMIT TOWER VOIDS BUILDINGS A city proposal aims to close a key zoning loophole — but some reformers say further action is needed BY MICHAEL GAROFALO

The Department of City Planning last month issued its longawaited proposal to reign in the development industry’s controversial practice of inating building heights through the use of largely empty mechanical voids. But some observers worry that the city’s ďŹ x doesn’t go far enough to address the underlying problem — and that without further reforms, developers will simply turn to other zoning loopholes to win permits for ever-loftier towers. Under city zoning law, spaces designated for mechanical use do not count toward the oor area calculations that in many districts effectively govern a building’s maximum permissible height. This exemption, combined with the fact that the city does not limit the height of mechanical spaces, has driven some developers to make use of ever-larger mechanical voids in towers’ middle sections. These vast empty spaces, which in some cases exceed 150 feet in height, nominally house mechanical equipment but are primarily intended to elevate the sightlines — and attendant dollar values — of upper-story residential units. Such voids have become a popular target of reform-minded zoning activists, including Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer and each member of the City Council’s Manhattan delegation, who claim that the proliferation of voids and other so-called zoning loopholes is undermining the intent of the city’s zoning resolution and producing taller buildings than planners ever anticipated. In response to these concerns, Mayor Bill de Blasio requested last year that the Department of City Planning examine the issue. The agency’s proposal, issued Jan. 28, aims to discourage excessive voids through new regulations. One change would limit mechanical floor area exemption to spaces 25 feet tall or shorter; voids taller than 25 feet would count toward a building’s maximum allowable floor area. Addi-

tionally, if a building’s body includes multiple mechanical voids, each would need to be separated by at least 75 feet in vertical distance or the spaces would be counted toward oor area calculations. The Department of City Planning explained in a release that the zoning text amendment “seeks to restore predictability of built form to New York’s high-density residential neighborhoods, ensuring that towers do not exploit zoning to vault above their neighbors through the utilization of largely empty enclosed mechanical spaces.â€?

East Side, West Side opposition Two planned towers in Manhattan — one on the Upper East Side, one on the Upper West Side — have attracted local opposition for their envelopepushing designs, each of which feature substantial voids. The upper residential floors of the planned 510-foot tower at 249 East 62nd St. sit atop a 150-foot-tall octagonal platform of void space, leading detractors to label the project a “building on stilts.â€? On the West Side, The Department of Buildings initially approved plans for Extell Development’s proposed 775-foot tower at 50 West 66th St. that included a 161-foot mechanical void on its 18th floor. But in January the agency notiďŹ ed the developer of its intent to revoke the permit following an audit of the building plans, citing concerns with the void. (Whether the project will proceed as planned is as yet unclear and will hinge on whether Extell can adequately address the city’s objections.) Even if the city’s zoning text amendment is enacted, some zoning experts believe the proposal’s limited scope makes it all but inevitable that developers will use alternate means to achieve similar results. “I’m thrilled that they’re responding to the issue, but I wish that they would have done more,â€? said George Janes, a planning consultant who prepared zoning challenges regarding both 249 East 62nd St. and 50 West 66th St. Janes noted that the city’s proposed zoning change only applies to enclosed spaces — meaning that developers could skirt the new restrictions by simply removing

two walls from any impacted voids, rendering the voids outdoor spaces exempt from oor area calculations. “If it’s so easy to get around the closing of one loophole by using another tactic, who wouldn’t do that?â€? he said, adding that he is hopeful the amendment will be strengthened as the city considers public input.

A more aggressive approach Another predictable result of the new rules, said Andrew Berman, executive director of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, is that rather than clustering enclosed mechanical space in a single large void, developers will instead place 25-foot voids at regular intervals of 75 feet “with no requirement whatsoever about there being any actual necessary mechanical equipment in each of those oors.â€? “The city’s proposal seems almost designed to do as little as possible about the problem,â€? Berman said. Upper West Side Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal has introduced state legislation that takes a more aggressive approach than the city’s proposal. Rosenthal’s bill would place stricter limits on mechanical void space while also discouraging excessive floor-to-floor heights on nonmechanical oors by mandating that oor area calculations correspond to ceiling height. For now, the city’s proposed text amendment only applies in certain residential districts, primarily in Manhattan. The Department of City Planning intends to put forward a second amendment expanding the geographic scope of the proposal later this year. The Department of City Planning is briefing community boards on the proposal this month, after which the agency will consider their recommendations and hold a public hearing, before ultimately sending the proposal to the City Council for approval. The East Side’s Community Board 6 passed a resolution in support of the city’s proposal at its Feb. 13 meeting, but also called for further amendments to “close other known zoning loopholes used to the same effect as mechanical voids.â€?

Extell Development’s proposed 775-foot tower at 50 West 66th St. includes a 161-foot mechanical void in its middle section, shown in grey in the rendering at right. Left: Snøhetta; Right: George M. Janes & Associates

Join the Celebration

75 Years of

No-Kill Action and Compassion A D O P T

A

P E T

T O D AY !

A C O O P E R AT I V E A D O P T I O N E V E N T:

M U D D Y PAW S R E S C U E & NORTH SHORE ANIMAL LEAGUE AMERICA

PETCO 860 Broadway @ E. 17th St. & $ !" & & &CXKU #XG 2QTV 9CUJKPIVQP 0; r animalleague.org r r 44

FOLLOW US ON:

JOHN KRTIL FUNERAL HOME; YORKVILLE FUNERAL SERVICE, INC. Dignified, Affordable and Independently Owned Since 1885 WE SERVE ALL FAITHS AND COMMUNITIES 5 )/'&1 /'+$1)-,0 $2250 -+.*'1' 5 )/'&1 2/)$*0 $2850 5 4.'/1 /' *$,,),( 3$)*$%*'

1297 First Ave (69th & 70th & + # " $& )" $ " $ ) * "#( & " $ + ))) $& '" $ #! #! Each cremation service individually performed by fully licensed members of our staff. We use no outside agents or trade services in our cremation service. We exclusively use All Souls Chapel and Crematory at the prestigious St. Michael's Cemetery, Queens, NY for our cremations unless otherwise directed.


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

19

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

60 th S t

TRAFFIC Taxi fare hikes could be a portent of more charges to come for Manhattan car-users BY MICHAEL GAROFALO

If you’ve hailed a yellow cab in the last few weeks, you’ve surely noticed the new $2.50 surcharge on all trips that begin, end or pass through Manhattan below 96th Street. The new surcharges, which took effect Feb. 2 and include additional fees of $2.75 for green cabs, black cars, Ubers and other app-based services and 75 cents for pooled rides, are expected to generate $400 million in annual revenue for the beleaguered Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Just as passengers are growing acclimated to the new cost of hailing a ride, more fees for car-borne New Yorkers could be in the pipeline. Gov. Andrew Cuomo is calling on the state legislature to enact congestion pricing—an effort to raise funds for the MTA and ease traffic by charging drivers for the privilege of using Manhattan streets.

How would congestion pricing work? The governor’s proposal would levy a toll on drivers entering a congestion

zone encompassing all of Manhattan south of 60th Street (with the possible exception of the FDR Drive). Fees would be collected by camera-based system, which could be adjusted to enforce variable toll rates depending on the day and time.

How much would it cost? Cuomo has not said what the fee should be for entering the congestion zone, but last year a commission convened by the governor recommended a charge of $11.52 for passenger vehicles on weekdays between 6 a.m. and 8 p.m.

Why is it necessary? Congestion pricing revenue would be dedicated exclusively to capital improvements for the MTA. The governor says his plan would raise $15 billion for the MTA, which has estimated capital needs of $40 billion to $80 billion in its next five-year plan. The only viable alternative for raising the necessary funds, Cuomo says, is to hike fares for straphangers. “The real choice is between congestion pricing or a 30 percent MTA toll and fare increase,” Cuomo said at a Feb. 7 press conference. “Those are the only real options.” In addition to funding the MTA, advocates say the plan would ease congestion, reduce pollution and result in improved bus service.

Potential zone pricing boundary Does not include FDR Drive North of the Brooklyn Bridge

What is the mayor’s stance? Mayor Bill de Blasio offered lukewarm support for congestion pricing in Albany budget testimony Feb. 11, reiterating his long-held preference to create a new funding stream for the MTA through a tax on millionaires. He argues that those with hardships, such as the poor and elderly, should be exempted from congestion fees. Congestion pricing advocates counter that such carve-outs could undermine the plan. The mayor also said that the city should be involved in the plan’s implementation. “If congestion pricing is an option, I’ve been clear that I believe strongly it should consider and include hardship exemptions, revenues should be putting a lockbox for subways and buses, and there should be clear, dedicated investment in transit deserts,” de Blasio said.

Tell us what you think: reporter@strausnews.com

Drivers entering a congestion pricing zone below 60th Street in Manhattan would be subject to a new toll under Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s plan.

NEW MINIMUM FARE for yellow cab trips below 96th Street

$5.80 OLD MINIMUM FARE for yellow cab trips

$3.30


20

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

Got an EVENT? FESTIVAL CONCERT GALLERY OPENING PLAY

Get The Word Out! Add Your Event for FREE Just $10 per day to be featured

nycnow.com


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

21

Our Town|Eastsider astsider ourtownny.com

One Person’s on’s Manhattan

FROM COLD STREETS TO WARM HEARTS How David Jones and the Bowery Mission give hope to the homeless BY HARVEY COHEN

You exit the downtown 6 train and pass the trendy boutiques along Spring Street. The shops and the street are frequented by tourists in search of the latest fashions and local millennials stealing some time from jobs in the nearby technology hub that now exists in this neighborhood. This is one view of Manhattan. But if you continue just a few blocks east, you get another very different view of Manhattan. Because then you get to the Bowery, a street made famous by its flophouses and history of homeless alcoholics. Walking just one block north of Spring Street, you find the Bowery Mission. And as much as downtown Manhattan may have gentrified over the past years, you won’t find any rich tourists or hip millennials at the Bowery Mission. Here, as if history has stood still, you’ll find hundreds of homeless people, many of them alcoholics, all struggling to just make it through one more day. They come to the Bowery mission because they know everyone is welcome here, 365 days a year — for a good meal, a hot shower, even a bed to sleep in overnight. David Jones is the CEO and Chairman of the Board at the Bowery Mission. He now lives on the Upper West Side, but he was born in Jacksonville, Florida. He left home at 16 and joined the Air Force at 17. He then used the GI bill to become a CPA and joined the accounting firm KPMG where he ultimately rose to head the corporate finance practice, supervising 200 people and traveling the world. But the world of finance left his soul feeling empty. So in 2010, he started and became the co-minister at a small church in New Jersey. That’s where his heart was, and he knew he had found his purpose. Then in 2015, when the Bowery Mission was looking for new leadership and a new direction, he was recommended for the job. The combination of Jones’ financial background at KPMG, his ministerial service and his passion for helping those in need gave him the perfect credentials. He reorganized the Mission and gave it a new strategy centered on a more holistic approach to treating the homeless and added new shelters, new programs and a new camp for at-risk children. Jones empa-

thetically says: “These people are living the worst day of their life, every day.” So under his leadership, the Bowery Mission never turns anyone away. Last year the Bowery Mission served over 650,000 meals, provided close to 170,000 nights of safe shelter, distributed more than 45,000 pieces of clothing and performed over 1,300 medical, dental and optometry exams. And many of the homeless people who finally get these necessities of life turn it into a new life. Precious is a 40-year-old former attorney at a large Manhattan law firm. In 2013, she lost the love of her life, was suffering from bipolar disorder and alcoholism and considered taking her life. She was just out of a psychiatric ward when she found the Bowery Mission. She says: “When I walked through their doors, I was a mess. I had nothing. They welcomed me home, took care of me and nursed my spirit and soul. They saw I was broken and spoke to my brokenness.” Now Precious has her own apartment and is running a successful consulting business advising companies on improving their own client presentations. “Without the Bowery Mission,” Precious says, “I would be dead, because I had no access to resources and would have gone back to the bottle.” Matt (not his real name) is 35 years old and was a drug addict since the age of 12 when he first used cocaine. He lived a life of crime and drugs for over 22 years. During that time, he saw his brother, also an addict and dealer, shot to death. And his entire family — his wife, daughter, mother and father — all stopped communicating with him. Matt says: “I was living a foul life and had no concern for anybody.” In June of 2017, Matt was robbed and had a gun put in his mouth. He realized then if he didn’t do something, he would die on the streets. He walked into the Bowery Mission, and last year graduated from their program. Now he is back in touch with everyone except his ex-wife. Matt says his renewed contact with his daughter, whom he now sees every weekend, is the best part of his new life: “To have the opportunity to be her father and to be present in her life is a blessing. Without the Bowery Mission I wouldn’t have that opportunity. I would be dead or in jail”. David Jones says: “The Bowery Mission serves as God’s arms and legs.” Anyone who sees what they do would certainly agree that their work is a blessing.

Know someone we should profile in One Person’s Manhattan? Call 212-868-0190 or email nyoffice@strausnews.com

These people are living the worst day of their life, every day.” David Jones, CEO and Chairman of the Board of the Bowery Mission

David Jones at the Bowery Mission. Photo: Jeffery Lau

FACTS ABOUT HOMELESSNESS In the New York City area, homelessness is at an all-time high. Some facts about homelessness provided by the Bowery Mission:

Gayle King of “CBS This Morning” serving Thanksgiving dinner at the Bowery Mission with other volunteers. Photo: Lesly Weiner Photography

How many people are homeless? Every night, more than 63,000 people sleep in the New York City municipal shelter system — up 43 percent from 10 years ago. Nearly 4,000 more sleep on the street, in the subway system or other public spaces. What causes homelessness? In most cases, multiple factors are involved. Common ones include: mental illness, substance abuse, untreated medicalissues, traumatic events, violence and abuse, lack of affordable housing and difficulty sustaining employment. Who are the homeless? People of all genders, races, ages and socioeconomic backgrounds experience homelessness. Among those sleeping in city shelters, more than 11,000 are single men, nearly 4,000 are single women and nearly 46,000 are adults or children in families.

Food is part of the Bowery Mission’s Compassionate Care program. Photo: Keri Tan Photography


CROSSWORD

29

S S K C J O L B W H S D U I W

W S X O M D C R H O C U Q V E

E A Q O F A I K A U Y G J T O

P F F S W X J T Q R Q M E D F

O O B J N A U J G S C R A A E

C I X T A O U R I W N Y C M B

H A B I X T Y H T I S E S B Q

S I U M R N D X T B E Z E L N

The puzzle contains the following words. They may be diagonal, across, or up and down in the grid in any direction.

R K Y E G G W Y L S T R A P A

Bezel Clock Days Epochs Eras Eternity Face Hours Minutes Seconds Strap Sundial Time Watch Weeks Years

ANSWERS V

O

43

44

L

A

S

L I

N

S

I

B

A

B

E

L

E

35 33 31 26

27

I

L

K

E

E

E

S

P

U

18 12 1

2

A 3

S

S

O

T

40

I

E R

A

R

P

N 23

B

I

A

S

C

E

R

E

T

E M 7

L

41

S S 8

E

Y

E

48

L

42

T A

Y

N

D

A

R

M A

R O 6

E

47

E 24

H

I

U 5

U 29

N

13

C

S

20

S

16 4

R

32

N

A

19

N

34

A

V

A

37

N

O

46

E

G R

36

22 15

S

L

39

L

N 28

A

45

I

38

E

E E R

R R E

30

T

25

P

21

O

17

P

T

E M U

14 9

J

10

I

B

11

9 4 3

8 1 5 9 3 4 6

6 8 7 2 1 5

1 6 5 2 4 3 7 9 8

6 7 9 5 2 4 1 8 3

5 1 2 8 3 6 4 7 9

8 3 4 9 7 1 6 5 2

4 8 6 7 9 2 5 3 1

2 5 7 3 1 8 9 6 4

3 9 1 4 6 5 8 2 7

25. Trunked plant 26. Subside 27. Rested 28. Preserved fodder 29. Exhausted from longterm stress 30. Blunder 32. Hydromassage facility 36. Forest clearing 37. Varnish ingredient 39. Thin strip of wood 41. Extend credit 42. French silk center 43. Photo ___ 44. By the agency of 46. Behold 48. Age

D P J E L C O M Y E Y S J B L

7 2

43. In vitro items 45. Steer stopper 47. Beauty is in the __ of the beholder 49. Kind of iron 50. A farewell remark 51. Still a no 52. Envelope that comes back, abbr. 53. Group belief 54. Evidence Down 1. Employ 2. Too much sun result 3. Japanese liquor 4. Surgical birth 5. Hosiery defect 6. “All My Children” vixen 7. Nocturnal insects 8. Being 9. Source of danger 10. Puck 11. On the contrary 19. Stuffed pasta 21. Come out 23. Hampton, for one

N U Q C E J W T T M K R F P S

R K Y E G G W Y L S T R A P A

Across 1. Kind of driver 4. ___ fraiche 9. Triangular sail 12. Vast amount 13. Monies of Europe 14. Large bird 15. What the elephant said to the mouse? 16. Fits of irritation 17. Go (for) 18. Old Italian money 20. Bird sound 22. Met expectations 24. Gym equipment 26. “Ocean’s ___ “ Clooney film 29. Wilkes-___, Pa. 31. Loose jacket 32. Break apart or in two 33. Range rover 34. Benediction 35. Big zero 36. Handout 38. Stocking material 40. Whisper

O E R A S W S U N D I A L N O

S I U M R N D X T B E Z E L N

54

C V W Y K Z N E Y T F E I R H

H A B I X T Y H T I S E S B Q

53

E W O W S I V U W Y Y Y L F I

C I X T A O U R I W N Y C M B

52

S Y W Q M G W A T C H M M Z I

O O B J N A U J G S C R A A E

51

WORD SEARCH by Myles Mellor

P F F S W X J T Q R Q M E D F

50

48

E A Q O F A I K A U Y G J T O

49

1

W S X O M D C R H O C U Q V E

47

2

7

42

S S K C J O L B W H S D U I W

46

41

D P J E L C O M Y E Y S J B L

45

40

4

3

N U Q C E J W T T M K R F P S

44

39

9 4

O E R A S W S U N D I A L N O

43

Level: Medium

6

C V W Y K Z N E Y T F E I R H

38

37

3

9

E W O W S I V U W Y Y Y L F I

36

3

5

9

S Y W Q M G W A T C H M M Z I

35

4

8

R

34

5 2

A

33

6

N

32

1 5

2

N O

31

30

1

D

28

25

51

27

24

54

26

23

T

22

21

U

20

5

E

19

9

E

18

1

7

9 6

I

17

3

N

16

4

E

15

9

D

14

Each Sudoku puzzle consists of a 9X9 grid that has been subdivided into nine smaller grids of 3X3 squares. To solve the puzzle each row, column and box must contain each of the numbers 1 to 9. Puzzles come in three grades: easy, medium and difficult.

T

13

11

A

12

10

50

9

53

8

E

7

G

6

I

5

A

4

P

3

S

2

SUDOKU by Myles Mellor and Susan Flanagan

by Myles Mellor

49

Eastsider 1

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

52

22


FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

CLASSIFIEDS LEGAL AND PROFESSIONAL

23

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

LEGAL AND PROFESSIONAL

Telephone: 212-868-0190 Fax: 212-868-0198 Email: classified2@strausnews.com

POLICY NOTICE: We make every eort to avoid mistakes in your classiďŹ ed ads. Check your ad the ďŹ rst week it runs. The publication will only accept responsibility for the ďŹ rst incorrect insertion. The publication assumes no ďŹ nancial responsibility for errors or omissions. We reserve the right to edit, reject, or re-classify any ad. Contact your sales rep directly for any copy changes. All classiďŹ ed ads are pre-paid.

LEGAL AND PROFESSIONAL

MERCHANDISE FOR SALE

You Never Forget Who You Grew Up With.

Remember to: Recycle and Reuse

REDUCE REUSE RECYCLE

The rough touch of tree bark, the scent of freshly mowed grass, the gentle hum of pollinating bees as a flower blossoms — green spaces touch lives and all five senses. Green spaces are a vital part of growing up — they enhance lives, make memories and connect people with their neighborhoods and communities. Be a part of preserving and enhancing green spaces where we live, work and play. To volunteer, to learn how to help your community and to donate, visit ProjectEverGreen.org or call toll-free (877) 758-4835.

MASSAGE projectevergreen.org (877) 758-4835

Saving a Life EVERY 11 MINUTES

DENTAL Insurance Physicians Mutual Insurance Company

A less expensive way to help get the dental care you deserve! CALL NOW!

+HOS DW +RPH

with

+HOS 2Q WKH *R

benefiting

Make-A-Wish ÂŽ Metro New York

1-855-225-1434

You can get coverage before your next checkup

GPS !

Wheels For Wishes

* 100% Tax Deductible * Free Vehicle Pickup ANYWHERE * We Accept Most Vehicles Running or Not * We Also Accept Boats, Motorcycles & RVs

Get help paying dental bills and keep more money in your pocket This is real dental insurance — NOT just a discount plan

+HOS LQ 6KRZHU

FREE Information Kit

D O N AT E YO U R C A R

HELP

Don’t wait! Call now and we’ll rush you a FREE Information Kit with all the details. Insurance Policy P150NY 6129

1-855-225-1434 Visit us online at

www.dental50plus.com/nypress MB17-NM003Ec

WheelsForWishes.org Call:(917)336-1254 * Car Donation Foundation d/b/a Wheels For Wishes. To learn more about our programs or Âż QDQFLDO LQIRUPDWLRQ FDOO RU YLVLW ZZZ ZKHHOVIRUZLVKHV RUJ

Discover the world’s best walk-in bathtub from

ÂŽ

get up! t ’ n a c I d an I’ve fallen

ÂŽ

Get HELP fast, 24/7, anywhere with

5 Reasons American Standard Walk-In Tubs are Your Best Choice 1 2

For a FREE brochure call:

1-800-404-9776

3

Includes FREE American StandardRight Height Toilet

Limited Time Offer! Call Today!

4

888-609-0248

5

Receive a free American Standard Cadet toilet with full installation of a Liberation Walk-In Bath, Liberation Shower, or Deluxe Shower. Offer valid only while supplies last. Limit one per household. Must be first time purchaser. See www.walkintubs.americanstandard-us.com for other restrictions and for licensing, warranty, and company information. CSLB B982796; Suffolk NY:55431H; NYC:HIC#2022748-DCA. Safety Tubs Co. LLC does not sell in Nassau NY, Westchester NY, Putnam NY, Rockland NY.

Backed by American Standard’s 140 years of experience $ Ultra low entry for easy entering and exiting Patented Quick DrainŽ fast water removal system Lifetime Warranty on the bath AND installation, INCLUDING labor backed by American Standard 44 Hydrotherapy jets for an invigorating massage

1,50

SAVING0S

FREE IN-HOME EVALUATION!


24

FEBRUARY 21-27,2019

Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com

COME HOME TO GLENWOOD MANHATTAN’S FINEST LUXURY RENTALS

+ + +

+ + + + + +

UPPER EAST SIDE 1 BEDROOMS FROM $3,195 2 BEDROOMS FROM $4,895 3 BEDROOMS FROM $6,795

MIDTOWN & UPPER WEST SIDE 1 BEDROOMS FROM $3,495 2 BEDROOMS FROM $4,795 3 BEDROOMS FROM $8,495

TRIBECA & FINANCIAL DISTRICT 1 BEDROOMS FROM $4,495 2 BEDROOMS FROM $6,995 3 BEDROOMS FROM $8,695

UPTOWN LEASING OFFICE 212-535-0500 DOWNTOWN LEASING OFFICE 212-430-5900 ! " " All the units include features for persons with disabilities required by FHA.

GLENWOOD Equal Housing Opportunity

BUILDER OWNER MANAGER

GLENWOODNYC.COM


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.