The local paper for the Upper East Side ETERNAL BEAUTY FROM AN ENDURING EN NDURING CULTURE ◄ P.12
The breweries and elevated trains are gone. The churches, social halls and French Flats remain. But for how long? A new book chronicles the neighborhood’s history — and ponders its future amid a megabuilding boom BY DOUGLAS FEIDEN
As a burst of oversized and out-ofscale development projects radiate from the path of the Second Avenue Subway, a preservation group is fighting back — by publishing a book to document the area’s glorious past. The Friends of the Upper East Side Historic Districts is delving into the boundless historical, cultural, architectural, mercantile and ecclesiastical treasures of Yorkville — at a time that heritage seems most in jeopardy. “Shaped by Immigrants: A History of Yorkville” plumbs the Old World roots of a neighborhood where Czechs, Slovaks, Germans, Hungarians and Irish lived and worked, dined and courted, shopped and prayed. It salutes the immigrant ethos that made the community great and
BY MICHAEL GAROFALO
We’re not going to stop development. But I certainly hope we can preserve the flavoring and seasoning of the neighborhood, a great deal of which has already been lost.” Franny Eberhart, president of Friends of the Upper East Side
O OURTOWNNY.COM @OurTownNYC
2018
79th Street bus route is faster since introduction of off-board fare payment, officials say
defines its character to this day — even though no one calls 79th Street “Goulash Avenue” anymore, or 86th Street the “German Broadway.” Against the backdrop of a built environment that has largely endured for 150-plus years, the book raises several existential questions: What hath the Q train wrought? And how can Yorkville’s immigrant past — which lives on in its low-rise, small-scale buildings, serving residential, religious, commercial, social and recreational needs — be safeguarded amid a building boom? In the foreword, Franny Eberhart, president of Friends of the UES, says
OurTownEastSide
22-28 MTA TOUTS PERFORMANCE OF M79 SBS
THE SUBWAY AND THE SOUL OF YORKVILLE PRESERVATION
WEEK OF NOVEMBER
now that the subway is here, and travel to and from Yorkville is faster than ever, the word most commonly used to describe the Q is “transformative.” “But what other sorts of transformation will occur?” she asks. “And what might Yorkville lose in the process? What needs to be protected, preserved and celebrated?” The book, and a 15-minute, minidocumentary film accompanying it, is an attempt to answer those questions by detailing a neighborhood’s brick and mortar, character and charm. Drawing on over a decade of research, the advocacy group authored what it bills as the first-ever comprehensive history of Yorkville, an illustrated account replete with archival images and contemporary photos commissioned for the project. “Numerous out-of-scale developments, many that subvert long-established zoning rules meant to encourage predictable development, are changing the face of Yorkville,” said Rachel Levy, executive director of the Friends group. With its vitality and uniqueness threatened, “Shaped by Immigrants” celebrates the rich legacy of
CONTINUED ON PAGE 5
Crime Watch Voices NYC Now City Arts
3 8 10 12
Restaurant Ratings Business Real Estate 15 Minutes
14 16 17 21
The landmark Cherokee Apartments, at East 78th Street and Cherokee Place, was built between 1909 and 1911 as the Shively Sanitary Tenements. They were originally designed as airy, healthy model apartments to combat tuberculosis among the poor. Photos: Trix Rosen Photographer Ltd / Friends of the UES Historic Districts
Crosstown bus service on the 79th Street corridor has seen increases in speed and ridership since the introduction of select bus service last year, according to Metropolitan Transportation Authority data. The M79 bus is eight percent faster on average since the M79 SBS route launched in May 2017. M79 SBS buses spend 21 percent less time paused at bus stops and five percent less time stuck in traffic that they did in the route’s previous iteration, according to transit data presented to Manhattan community boards this month. Riders traveling west during the evening rush hour experienced the greatest time savings, with buses completing their runs nearly three minutes faster on average, a 12 percent speed increase. Transportation officials attribute the speed increase to the SBS offboard payment system, which reduces dwell time spent at bus stops for fare collection, as well as street improvements implemented by the city’s Department of Transportation, including newly painted bus lanes and traffic light timing adjustments.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 19 Zion-St. Mark’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, a small stone church on East 84th Street off First Avenue, built in 1889 in the late Victorian architectural style, proclaims its German heritage in a facade inscription that reads, “Deutsche Ev. Kirche V. Yorkville.”
Jewish women and girls light up the world by lighting the Shabbat candles every Friday evening 18 minutes before sunset. Friday, November 23 – 4:15 pm. For more information visit www.chabaduppereastside.com
We deliver! Get Our Town Eastsider sent directly to your mailbox for $ $49 per year. Go to OurTownNY.com or call 212-868-0190
2
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR PROPOSAL FOR A NEW RIVERBOAT STOP What about an added north-south Hudson River ferry stop at Chelsea Piers, where a docking facility appears to be already in place (“The River of No Respect,” Nov. 1-7)? This would connect easily with the terminus of the M23 crosstown bus. Harry Malakoff Chelsea
Dorothy Calvani Upper West Side
JOBS FOR SENIORS
IMMIGRATION CONCERNS I am in favor of giving immigrants places to live once they have been given approval to enter, however, they should only be allowed to enter with proper documentation (“The ‘SantuaryHood’ Campaign,” Oct. 25). That’s how my parents got in. They also didn’t ask for free health care, housing or any types of handouts. My father had three jobs and my mother two, until better opportunities were awarded them. They took or expected nothing from the government. The other side should be heard as well.
City Council Member Mark Levine stands at the West 125th Street Pier on the Hudson River. He says it’s the ideal location to launch a new north-south ferry route that would connect uptown with midtown and downtown on the West Side. Photo: Office of Mark Levine
I am very concerned about the misleading rhetoric coming from the administration and the media about the caravan of immigrants headed to the United States from Central America. It’s dishonest, destructive and unjust.
Editor’s note: Judy Klinek, a West Side Spirit reader, called to ask for contact information regarding our story on the recent senior job fair (“Helping NYC Seniors Land Their Next Gig,” Nov. 1-7). Reporter Megan Conn provided the following: For more information, call 212-6026958 or 311 and ask for Senior Employment Services. You can also visit SESU on the 6th floor of 2 Lafayette St. in Manhattan. To view the step-by-step application process and verify your eligibility, visit: access.nyc.gov/programs/senioremployment-services-ses
Philip Massa Upper West Side
SINGULAR OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE MONEY IN REAL ESTATE THE NEW FRONTIER OF R.E. BROKERAGE TECHNOLOGY Brokers — Venture Capitalists — Investors LEVERAGE THE FUTURE OF BROKERAGE WITH THE 131 YEAR HISTORY OF
E. OSBORNE SMITH INC. - For Sale! RICH HISTORY in NYC/Tri-State Area Real Estate since 1887 FRANK E. CAMPBELL THE FUNERAL CHAPEL IS PROUD TO HOST THE FIRST ANNUAL
WINTER EVENING OF MUSIC Saturday, December 8, 2018, 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. 1076 Madison Avenue at 81st Street All are welcome to attend this free concert performed by World-Class Musicians. Refreshments will be served beginning at 5:30 p.m.
Learn from history and invest in your future with a Stellar ZĞƉƵƚĂƟ ŽŶ͕ WƌŽǀĞŶ dƌĂĐŬ ZĞĐŽƌĚ ĂŶĚ dƌĂĚĞŵĂƌŬ ƉƌŽƚĞĐƟ ŽŶ͊ What once took a building of Brokers and assistants can be done from your Home PC ͘ KƐďŽƌŶĞ ^ŵŝƚŚ ĞǀĞůŽƉŵĞŶƚ Θ ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟ ŽŶ ŽƌƉ͘ Builders and General Contractors to the Industry Principals Buying & Selling Vacant Land to Builders of 1-2-3 Family Homes /ŶĚƵƐƚƌŝĂůͲ ŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů ZĞƐŝĚĞŶƟ Ăů
>>Ͳ ϮϭϮͲϵϴϲͲϳϲϰϰ ĨŽƌ ŝŶĨŽƌŵĂƟ ŽŶ on this unparalleled opportunity MORE INFO:
FRANK E. CAMPBELL THE FUNERAL CHAPEL 1076 Madison Avenue at 81st Street www.frankecampbell.com 212-288-3500 O w n e d b y a s u b s i d i a r y o f S e r v i c e C o r p . I n t e r n a t i o n a l , 1 9 2 9 A l l e n P k w y . H o u s t o n , T X 7 7 0 1 9 , 7 1 3 - 5 2 2 - 51 4 1
www.eosbornesmith.com All past real estate service agreements as brokers and all past real estate partnership interests as brokers and principal have been 100% successfully concluded.
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
3
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
CRIME WATCH BY JERRY DANZIG DOG OWNER ARRESTED FOR ASSAULT
STATS FOR THE WEEK Reported crimes from the 19th precinct for the week ending Nov 11
On Tuesday, Nov. 13, a 32-year-old woman got into a verbal dispute with a 56-year-old man in front of 211 East 70th St. regarding his dog. The dispute became physical when the dog owner slapped the woman’s face and pushed her to the ground. Police later arrested Philip Hoffmann and charged him with assault, according to police.
Week to Date
MAN THWARTS TEEN CELL SNATCHERS At 6:34 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 13, a 39-year-old man was standing in front of 171 East 84th Street making a phone call when three teenagers approached him and tried to take his cell phone out of his hand. He resisted and managed to retain his phone, but the teens made verbal threats and spat at his face. The coveted phone was an iPhone XS valued at $1,150.
SENIOR SCAMMED Another Upper East Side senior became the victim of the “tech support phone scam” in which a perpetrator pretends to be a computer expert and calls potential victims claiming to fix
Photo by Tony Webster, via Flickr
broken computers. On Friday, Nov. 2, a scammer claiming that he was from AppleCare contacted a 63-year-old woman living on East 71st Street. The unsuspecting victim gave him her credit card information. The scammer also requested an additional $1,000 in the form of iTunes gift cards. In all, the victim was taken for $500 in iTunes cards, along with unauthorized purchases on her credit cards, making a total scam of $4,403.
U-HAUL HAUL, PART TWO Once again a U-Haul truck was spotted in the area making off with motorcycles. On Monday, Nov. 5, a 30-year-old woman parked her motorcycle in front of 302 East 95th St. When she returned for her bike at 2:20 a.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 6, it was missing. The victim told police that a parking attendant at a nearby lot had seen a U-Haul pull up at 2:16 a.m.,
Year to Date
2018 2017
% Change 2018
2017
% Change
Murder
0
0
n/a
0
n/a
Rape
0
1
-100.0 12
14
-14.3
Robbery
3
2
50.0
127
105
21.0
Felony Assault
4
0
n/a
130
115
13.0
Burglary
8
2
300.0 194
184
5.4
Grand Larceny
29
35
-17.1
1,233 1,196
3.1
Grand Larceny Auto
3
1
200.0
68
38.8
just a few minutes before she arrived, when three men lifted the two-wheeler into their truck and took off. A search of the neighborhood proved fruitless. The stolen bike was a red 2015 Honda CB300F with New York plates 25TJ08, valued at $4,000.
PILFERED PACKAGES A certain building needs to improve its lobby security. At 2:15 a.m. on
1
49
Tuesday, Nov. 13, a 35-year-old woman and a 32-year-old man living on Third Avenue returned from a vacation to discover that numerous packages were stolen from their building lobby. The super checked the lobby security video, which showed an unknown person leaving the building with their packages. In all, eight packages were stolen, seven from Banana Republic and one from Black Tux, for a total haul of $1,326.
You’re invited.
Bright Health Medicare Advantage plans give you more benefits and savings than Original Medicare. Come learn how to save with Bright Health today. Wednesday, November 28 10am Triple A Restaurant 2061 2nd Ave # 106 New York, NY 10029
Friday, November 30 10am Triple A Restaurant 2061 2nd Ave # 106 New York, NY 10029
Wednesday, December 5 10am Triple A Restaurant 2061 2nd Ave # 106 New York, NY 10029
Friday, December 7 10am Triple A Restaurant 2061 2nd Ave # 106 New York, NY 10029
Join. Save. Be happy. BrightHealthPlan.com Bright Health plans are HMOs and PPOs with a Medicare contract. Bright Health’s New York D-SNP plan is an HMO with a Medicare contract and a Coordination of Benefits Agreement with New York State Department of Health. Our plans are issued through Bright Health Insurance Company or one of its affiliates. Enrollment in our plans depends on contract renewal. For accommodations of persons with special needs at meetings call 844-293-6716 (TTY: 711). Y0127 MULTI-MA-ADS-2815 M
4
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Useful Contacts
Drawing Board
POLICE NYPD 19th Precinct
153 E. 67th St.
212-452-0600
159 E. 85th St.
311
FIRE FDNY 22 Ladder Co 13 FDNY Engine 39/Ladder 16
157 E. 67th St.
311
FDNY Engine 53/Ladder 43
1836 Third Ave.
311
FDNY Engine 44
221 E. 75th St.
311
CITY COUNCIL Councilmember Keith Powers
211 E. 43rd St. #1205
212-818-0580
Councilmember Ben Kallos
244 E. 93rd St.
212-860-1950
STATE LEGISLATORS State Sen. Jose M. Serrano
1916 Park Ave. #202
212-828-5829
State Senator Liz Krueger
1850 Second Ave.
212-490-9535
Assembly Member Dan Quart
360 E. 57th St.
212-605-0937
Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright
1485 York Ave.
212-288-4607
COMMUNITY BOARD 8
505 Park Ave. #620
212-758-4340
LIBRARIES Yorkville
222 E. 79th St.
212-744-5824
96th Street
112 E. 96th St.
212-289-0908
67th Street
328 E. 67th St.
212-734-1717
Webster Library
1465 York Ave.
212-288-5049
100 E. 77th St.
212-434-2000
HOSPITALS Lenox Hill NY-Presbyterian / Weill Cornell
525 E. 68th St.
212-746-5454
Mount Sinai
E. 99th St. & Madison Ave.
212-241-6500
NYU Langone
550 First Ave.
212-263-7300
CON EDISON
4 Irving Place
212-460-4600
POST OFFICES US Post Office
1283 First Ave.
212-517-8361
US Post Office
1617 Third Ave.
212-369-2747
HOW TO REACH US:
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR:
212-868-0190 nyoffice@strausnews.com ourtownny.com
Include your full name, address and day and evening telephone numbers for verification. Letters that cannot be verified will not be published. We reserve the right to edit or condense letters for libel, good taste, grammar and punctuation. Submit your letter at ourtownny.com and click submit at the bottom of the page or email it to nyoffice@strausnews.com.
TO SUBSCRIBE: Our Town is available for free on the east side in select buildings, retail locations and news boxes. To get a copy of east side neighborhood news mailed to you weekly, you may subscribe to Our Town Eastsider for just $49 per year. Call 212868-0190 or go online to StrausNews. com and click on the photo of the paper or mail a check to Straus Media, 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918.
NEWS ITEMS: To report a news story, call 212-8680190. News releases of general interest must be emailed to our offices by noon the Thursday prior to publication to be considered for the following week. Send to news@strausnews.com.
BLOG COMMENTS: We invite your comments on stories and issues at ourtownny.com. We do not edit those comments. We urge people to keep the discussion civil and the tone reflective of the best we each have to offer.
PLACE A CLASSIFIED AD: Call 212-868-0190. Classified ads must be in our office by 12pm the Friday before publication, except on holidays. All classified ads are payable in advance.
PREVIOUS OWNERS: Tom Allon, Isis Ventures, Ed Kayatt, Russ Smith, Bob Trentlyon, Jerry Finkelstein
CALENDAR ITEMS:
ABOUT US
Information for inclusion in our calendar should be posetd to nycnow.com no later than two weeks before the event.
Our Town is published weekly by Straus Media-Manhattan, LLC. Please send inquiries to 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918.
BY PETER PEREIRA
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
5
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
YORKVILLE CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 its architecture and peoples. The goal: “Kickstart the public conversation about the buildings and sites that must be prioritized for preservation amid rapid change,” Levy added. The book features such longvanished worlds as George Ehret’s Hell Gate Brewery, located on a superblock between 92nd and 93rd Streets and Second and Third Avenues and dating to 1866. It conjures up the German immigrant known as the “King of the Beer Corners” because his 42 saloons were mostly located on corner lots. But it largely focuses on the extant. In so doing, it documents dozens of architectural gems that lack city landmark status and could theoretically fall prey to the hyper-development unleashed by the subway’s opening.
THE MAYOR AND THE ‘ANTEDILUVIAN MONSTER’ These gems include the “French Flats” apartment buildings, a term evoking Parisian living accommodations, which were designed for middle-class families at a time when the rich mostly lived in private, single-family homes, while the poor dwelled in multi-unit tenements. Two of the best examples are on Second Avenue in the 80s. Counted among the city’s first modern apartments, they came complete with such thenluxuries as hallways, private bathrooms, closets and fully equipped kitchens. The Manhattan, built in 1880 on 86th Street, and the color-
The cornerstone set in the façade of the Church of St. Elizabeth of Hungary at 211 East 83rd Street. The first date marks the original construction, the later date was when St. Elizabeth bought and moved into the church.
The interior courtyard of the landmark Cherokee Apartments, built before World War I at Cherokee Place and 78th Street, was designed as an airy, sun-splashed gateway to clean and sanitary living spaces for poor tuberculosis patients. Photos: Trix Rosen Photographer Ltd / Friends of the UES Historic Districts fully named “Kaiser and The Rhine,” built in 1887 on 89th Street, were both ventures of the Rhinelander family, an early Yorkville developer, who designed them with more light and air than other period dwellings. It was The Manhattan where future three-term Mayor Robert F. Wagner Jr. spend his childhood. His father, the powerful German-born U.S. Sen. Robert F. Wagner Sr., resided there from 1912 to 1933. The book pegs the evolution of Yorkville to five supersized, mass-transit projects — the building of two rail lines in the late 19th century, their demolition in the mid-20th century, and the arrival of a new subway
in the 21st century. Development was kicked into overdrive with the opening in 1878 of the coal-powered Third Avenue Elevated Railway, with stations at 67th, 76th, 84th, 89th and 99th Streets. By 1880, the Second Avenue El debuted, with stops at 65th, 72nd, 80th, 86th, 92nd and 99th Streets. The impact of the locomotives: “A frenzy of real estate speculation,” a passage for immigrants away from the teeming Lower East Side and the growth of multicultural, working- and middle-class communities, the authors write. Of course, the Friends group — a nonprofit dedicated to preserving the architectural legacy, livability and sense of
Our Lady of Good Counsel, looking north on East 90th Street off Second Avenue, opened in 1892 to serve mostly Irish and German immigrants who worked in the nearby breweries. Today, the Gothic and Tudor church welcomes a large Spanish-speaking population.
place of the UES — notes that not everyone was overjoyed by the hulking Els. It quotes social novelist Henry James describing them as “skeletons” whose streets they “darkened and smothered with the immeasurable spinal column and myriad clutching paws of an antediluvian monster.” By 1942, as World War II raged, the city fathers (yes, they were all men back then) agreed. The Second Avenue El came down first, its steel converted to munitions. By 1955, the Third Avenue El was finally demolished. “The dismantling of these lines removed the literal and figurative dividing line that
had for so long separated the Gold Coast from Yorkville, while also ushering in a new era of building,” the book says. Now, after three-quarters of a century, the trains are running again on Second Avenue. Commuters have direct access to and from Yorkville. The transformative impact to which Eberhart alludes is unmissable. “We’re not going to stop development,” she said. “But I certainly hope we can preserve the flavoring and seasoning of the neighborhood, a great deal of which has already been lost.” Father John Kamas, pastor of the Church of St. Jean Baptiste on East 76th Street, says he lived through the last “land grab.” Born in 1948, a lifelong
Yorkville resident of Slovak descent, he remembers what happened when the Third Avenue El came down: “You lost a neighborhood where people would hang out on the stoops, leave the front door unlocked and shop in the little shops under the El,” said Father Kamas, a Friends board member. “That life started to disappear because real estate interests only see money, they don’t see neighborhoods, they don’t see history, they don’t see our immigrant past, they don’t see beauty,” he added. “We’re not opposed to growth, but it should be harmonious. “This time, we’re asking developers to show a little more respect.” “Shaped by Immigrants: A History of Yorkville” can be purchased online for $30 at www.friends-ues.org/yorkvillebook. A 15-minute, minidocumentary chronicling the neighborhood’s history can be viewed for free at the same link. invreporter@strausnews.com
READ THIS STORY ON OURTOWNNY.COM TO SEE THE ALL THE PHOTOS.
“The Kaiser and The Rhine,” a colorfully named apartment building on the northeast corner of 89th Street and Second Avenue, was a so-called “French Flats” building for the middle-class. It was erected by the Rhinelander family in the Romanesque Revival style in the mid-1880s.
6
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
PATIENT POWER HEALTH What New Yorkers need to know about CABs, PFACs & YACs BY CAROL ANN RINZLER
Since 1969, every New York City public hospital has been required to have a Community Advisory Board (CAB) comprising past or present patients, community residents, and a representative from the local community board. In 2011, Dick Gottfried, chair of the NYS Assembly Health Committee, introduced a bill to require a similar group at every hospital in the state. The bill sailed through the Assembly but wasn’t even brought up for a vote in the Senate, a situation Gottfried thinks may change with the new legislature. Meanwhile, New York City’s voluntary non-profit hospitals have been introducing their own version of a CAB: PFACs (Patient and Family Advisory Councils). Unlike community boards, which play a mandated role in some legislative and regulatory areas such as land use, CABs and PFACs are strictly advisory. But New York State law requires each voluntary non-profit hospital periodically to adopt and update a community service plan. Gottfried says that should include consultation with the PFAC. Even without new legislation, hospitals often agree. For example, ten years ago, when Louise Dankberg joined the Bellevue
MEETING SCHEDULES Bellevue Hospital CAB Fourth Wednesday of the month, 6:00 pm Lenox Hill Hospital/Northwell Health PFAC Last Thursday in Jan/Mar/May/ July/Oct/Nov, 5:30 pm Mount Sinai Hospital YAC Second Thursday of the month, 5:30 pm NYU Langone Health PFAC Second Thursday of each month, 4 pm Note: CAB/PFAC/YAC meetings often skip a summer month CAB, she had no idea she’d end up chairperson for five years. During her tenure, she was proud to lead a group that “not only identified patient complaints but succeeded in quality-of-life projects such as keeping open a low cost diner and gift shop for patients, staff and visitors.” In short, Bellevue CEO William Hicks takes his CAB seriously, praising it for “urging us to try harder, to be better and to strive for the best in quality and service for all who present to the hospital.” Two blocks up First Avenue at NYU Langone Health’s PFAC, the sentiments are similarly sunny. “During an extended patient experience,” says Keith Cunningham, “I quickly ascertained the need to be an assertive advocate for my own care plan and recovery and began offering advice to the staff and other patients. Being on PFAC has been an incredibly rewarding chance to help improve the system.” Kimberly Glassman, NYU Langone’s Senior Vice President for Patient Care counts her hospital “fortunate to have individuals like Keith whose insights help make us a better care provider and a more valuable resource to those who turn to us for help.”
Bellevue South Lobby. Photo: NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue Ditto at Northwell’s Lenox Hill. “No system is ever perfect,” says PFAC member Jordan Klemons, “but Lenox Hill Hospital did such an incredible job taking care of me and getting me back on my feet again, I felt it was my responsibility to help them continue improving for all future patients.” Appreciated, says Joe Leggio, Associate Executive Director, Patient & Customer Experience. “The PFAC is our guiding voice in designing how everyone should experience health care.” In 2015, the Mt. Sinai Kravis Children’s Hospital expanded the CAB/ PFAC family with a YAC (Youth Advisory Council) to address the specific
Follow Our Town on Facebook and Twitter
needs of pediatric patients. “As an active member of YAC,” says one young member, “I have been able to help give a perspective on how children feel when they enter a hospital.” Morgan Stojanowski, assistant director of the Child Life and Creative Arts Therapy Department, names one such important YAC observation: the need for accessible language translation services. “Leadership responded immediately,” she says, “distributing 50 dual handset translator phones throughout pediatrics, providing additional Language Assistance in-services to medical staff, and introducing enhanced video interpreter services.”
Clearly, CABs and PFACs are popular, so popular in fact, that one member actually appointed himself. In the late 90s, as chair of Brooklyn’s Community Board 13, Marty Levine was barred from a Health and Hospitals meeting at Coney Island Hospital. “A couple of weeks later,” he says, “I learned that every HHC facility was mandated to have a CAB and that as chairman of the community board I had the authority to appoint someone to the hospital’s CAB. So I appointed myself and walked in. I’ve been a member ever since.” What are you waiting for?
Going to the Airport? 1-212-666-6666 Sedan Rates: To LaGuardia ........... $34 $4 OFF To Newark ............... $51 Any Trip Over $20
Car & Limousine Service
To JFK ...................... $52 Tolls & gratuities not included. Prices subject to change without notice. TLC Lic#B00256
Download the free appget car cash, earn airline miles!
Must get Code# Upon Reserving Not Valid 3-7pm
One Coupon per Trip. Expires 12/15/18
5 OFF
$
Any Airport Pick-Up
Must get Code# Upon Reserving One Coupon per Trip. Expires 12/15/18
Eastsider
53
www.CarmelLimo.com
51
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
7
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
TRACKING THE CITY’S BIRD NEWS
We think a company that’s been around for generations should offer a product that’s guaranteed for a lifetime.
NATURE Beyond the Mandarin Duck: David Barrett of Manhattan Bird Alert on his passion and research
Ee E R ur
as r pu e m ou y ith
F
BY JASON COHEN
Nearly a decade ago, Upper East Side resident David Barrett discovered his passion for birding. An avid middledistance runner, Barrett often jogged or walked through Central Park. To make his walks more enjoyable, he began birding and researching the various birds that he observed. “I wanted to make those walks as interesting as possible and that’s how it all started,� Barrett explained. “I got interested in birding as a thing to do. It’s a fascinating subject.� Today, he has racked up a lifetime total of 267 American Bird Association-countable bird species in Manhattan, placing him second on the all-time list for eBird, an online citizen science database, as of November. In 2013, Barrett launched Manhattan Bird Alert (@BirdCentralPark) and today, the Twitter feed has been front and center as it has helped birders see the Mandarin Duck that has created a sensation in Central Park. “Manhattan Bird Alert, I
se
a rch
w Manhattan Bird Alert has been following the whereabouts of a barred owl in Central Park. Photo: @jhonny_2003 courtesy of Manhattan Bird Alert think it’s a great thing for all New Yorkers,â€? Barrett said. “It’s been very popular because of the Mandarin Duck. The purpose of it is to give the public a way to get birding news delivered to them quickly.â€? Birders identified the male duck as native to East Asia, and no one was sure how he had made his way to Manhattan. Manhattan Bird Alert (@ BirdCentralPark) has provided regular updates on the duck since his ďŹ rst arrival in October. After a four-day absence earlier this month, the duck returned to the Central Park Pond on Nov. 14. On Thursday, during the ďŹ rst snowfall of the season, the duck enjoyed the snowakes. One post via @LRo70 read, “A little snow does not bother the MANDARIN DUCK, still at the
Mandarin duck in the Pond. Photo: Ben Rinzler
Central Park Pond (60th and Fifth).â€? Barrett, 54, grew up in Massachusetts and earned his undergraduate degree in mathematics from Harvard. After a long career as a hedge fund manager, he is now an investor and computer scientist. Since he began birding, he has learned that birds not only can be identiďŹ ed by sight, but by sound as well. Additionally, weather plays a huge role in migration and is a factor in why certain birds may appear in Manhattan for just week or a couple days. “I think the surprising thing is how we get migrant birds that come from far away,â€? Barrett said. After gaining all of this knowledge, he realized that New Yorkers should have an easier way to find birds. So he launched the Bird Alert in Manhattan, Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens. “We needed a better system that’s fast and can handle a lot of alerts,â€? he said. Today, there are 100 approved users that can post alerts on the account. The alert system provided the ďŹ rst public news of the Harris’s Sparrow on Nov. 4, the Kirtland’s Warbler on May 11, the Hammond’s Flycatcher on Nov. 26, 2017 and the Swainson’s Warbler appearance in Central Park on April 28, 2016. It has been featured in the New York Times, the BBC and the New York Post. “The alerts quickly became very popular with other birders,â€? Barrett said. “They could see that it became a great solution to a problem that they had.â€?
shown: SkylineÂŽ Gliding Panels & Designer Roller Shades
New Yorkers have put their trust in Janovic for 130 years. With some of the largest Hunter Douglas showrooms in NYC, we feature an extensive variety of options and fabrics.
All Hunter Douglas shades and blinds are
20% OFF EVERYDAY STORE LOCATIONS THROUGHOUT NYC
GRAMERCY PARK 292 3rd Avenue @ 23rd St ӣӇÇÇLJÎäÎä
YORKVILLE 1491 3rd Ave @ 84th St ӣӇÓnÂ™Â‡ĂˆĂŽĂ¤Ă¤
1** , Ć‚-/ - nnn iĂ?ˆ˜}ĂŒÂœÂ˜ Ć‚Ă›i J ĂˆĂˆĂŒÂ… -ĂŒ ӣӇÇÇӇ£{ää
½- / Ă‡ĂˆĂˆ ÂŁĂ¤ĂŒÂ… Ć‚Ă›i J xĂ“Â˜` -ĂŒ 212-245-3241
1** , 7 -/ - ÂŁx™ 7 Ă‡Ă“Â˜` -ĂŒ J Â˝Ăœ>Ăž ӣӇx™x‡Óxää
"7 , Ć‚-/ - nä {/ Ć‚Ă›iÂ˜Ă•i J ÂŁĂ¤ĂŒÂ… -ĂŒ
-" " 55 Thompson St @ Broome Ă“ÂŁĂ“Â‡ĂˆĂ“Ă‡Â‡ÂŁÂŁĂ¤Ă¤
- Ć‚ 215 7th Avenue @ 23rd St Ă“ÂŁĂ“Â‡Ăˆ{x‡x{x{
UPTOWN WEST Ă“Ăˆnä Ă€Âœ>`Ăœ>Ăž J ÂŁĂ¤Ă“Â˜` -ĂŒ ӣӇxΣ‡ÓÎää
" - Ć‚ /9 Îä‡Îx /Â…ÂœÂ“ĂƒÂœÂ˜ Ć‚Ă›i ĂŽ{LJ{ÂŁn‡Î{nä
8
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Voices
Write to us: To share your thoughts and comments go to ourtownny.com and click on submit a letter to the editor.
REALITY CHECK: ‘THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT’ PUBLIC EYE BY JON FRIEDMAN
Are facts negotiable? Is there a distinction between truth and accuracy? Should there be one at all? For our purposes, the key question is: Can a lesson in news literacy be entertaining in a darkened Broadway theater? I can answer the last question emphatically: Definitely, yes. “The Lifespan of a Fact,” the muchdiscussed show at Studio 54, raises these and other points that are so essential here in the Trump presidency, when it can feel like truth is in the eye of the beholder and facts are up for grabs. One of the reasons why the dis-
course is lively and fun is that the the actors don’t preach and instead leave it to the audience to come up with the answers. The production, which lasts for approximately an hour and 25 minutes (with no intermission), moves along at a brisk pace. The dialogue is snappy throughout. The stellar cast — the always-brilliant Cherry Jones as Emily the editor, Daniel Radcliffe (firmly shedding whatever Harry Potter image may still remain) portraying Jim the fact-checker and Bobby Cannavale (looking comfortable playing John, the tough-talking writer) were terrific. It was as if they were playing three-on-three basketball at a high level, with each actor generously passing the ball around before one of them took a shot. Unfortunately, the very earnest show also deserves what some col-
lege educators call an Accuracy F. It’s really too bad that a very entertaining show has this stone in its shoe because, God knows, the media could use something to proclaim how valuable journalism is in these strained times. When the play opens, Daniel Radcliffe appears as a frightfully green but determined kid who has been with a magazine for a matter of months. Yet his no-nonsense editor, Cherry Jones, decides to entrust the fact-checking of a piece so important that she says it could be her “legacy” to him. Bobby Cannavale emerges as the kind of street-smart, patronizing writer who might evoke images of Jimmy Breslin or Pete Hamill or even Norman Mailer. The rookie struggles to wrest control of the story from the writer, who clearly has little use or respect for
him. Meanwhile, the editor gamely tries to get the piece published on time. That is the entire cast: three extremely well-crafted characters, each with an angle of his or her own. Recognizing the performers from their own work, journalists will no doubt smile — and squirm — as they see themselves in these parts. And the lesser people in the theater can happily sit back and appreciate the superb acting. How much is the audience expected to accept? Could we reasonably expect to see a fact-checker fly across the country (on his own nickel, no less) to confront the author? Stretching reality further, the fact-checker’s boss then follows him out there to try to restore order and meet a stressful deadline. I’ve worked for decades in the media ecosystem and never heard of this
happening — but that’s just me. This show has come along in a sweet spot of our popular culture. The profession of journalism is under siege. The President of the United States is determined to use the media as a prop in his all-out culture war — and then declare himself the winner. His strategy is as clear as it is timeless: capitalize on journalism’s lousy public image to divide and conquer. All that’s missing from this picture in 2018 is a retelling of the Nixon administration’s greatest hits, complete with Spiro Agnew’s “nattering nabobs of nihilism” and defense of the Silent Majority. “The Lifespan of a Fact” neatly counters the President bleating about “fake news” and “the enemy of the people.” It is a production for its times.
THE E.D. WE MUST OVERCOME BY BETTE DEWING
Yup, this title is meant to spark attention, which “empathy dysfunction” spelled out might not. And what does empathy or its absence have to do with Thanksgiving? Well, this year, it means not forgetting California’s unprecedented hardship and heartbreak — and the help we need to give and keep giving as long as it takes. Our surprise winter storm diluted immediate concern for the wildfires, and the unprecedented gridlock was incredibly stressful. But homes and communities were intact when finally reached. Yes, numerous trees were downed, lamentably, but the damage was incomparable to large areas of California, where everything is blazed out. Imagine. And imagine we must. Oh, it should be remembered that due to our storm, public events were cancelled, like the 79th Street Neighborhood Association monthly meeting, where California’s heartbreak and
hardship would have been an active concern. So many New Yorkers have close family and friends who live in California and won’t need reminding. But others will, and how we need high profile people to do just that. The president finally toured some burned out areas, which thankfully seems to have raised his not-so-active empathy level. But so far, more needed are our former Presidents Carter, Clinton, both Bushes and Obama to be there pledging all-out support. Even more so, perhaps, the first ladies must be there, one of whom was secretary of state and almost our president. And yes, first offspring and first grandparents should be there as well. And what must we at home be doing? For now, here’s some of what this column urged after the Carolinas were ravaged by Hurricane Florence. New York City youngsters were asked to reach out to Carolina youngsters, letting them know they cared by using social media. And they’d set an example for other age groups, especially
for elders to reach out to their peers in the Carolinas, who were often alone and disabled. And long overdue, these youngsters enabled elders’ social media use. New Yorkers with animal pals were told about animal rescue groups in the Carolinas. And I took the liberty of reminding faith and civic groups how they must be at the forefront of these critical and ongoing endeavors. Now read the Nov. 15 New York Times piece, “California Fires Only Add to Acute Housing Crisis.” On the news, a Paradise, Calif. man pleads for a garage he might rent to temporarily house his family. But what about home sharing? Once people opened their homes to family, friends, neighbors and others in need. And yes, that’s difficult for members of a society now so accustomed to living alone. But it would be infinitely easier if communication skills were learned to aid getting along. I can think of some books that do just that — like those by Haim Ginott, “Straight Talk” by Sherod
President Trump’s motorcade passes neighborhoods devastated by wildfires as he surveys the damage on Nov. 17 in Paradise, Calif. Official White House Photo by Shealah Craighead Miller, and by Daniel Walkman, Elaine Nunnally and Carol Saline. Remember, there were some city faith groups that held forums and classes as well. Among them were Central Presbyterian Church, Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church and the Roman Catholic Church of the
Epiphany. They need a mighty revival to help overcome the many unprecedented social and political divides. There would be so much more to be thankful for — and it can be done if enough of us try — with California never very far from our minds. Do know I am so very thankful for you.
President & Publisher, Jeanne Straus nyoffice@strausnews.com
STRAUS MEDIA your neighborhood news source nyoffice@strausnews.com 212-868-0190
Vice President/CFO Otilia Bertolotti Vice President/CRO Vincent A. Gardino advertising@strausnews.com
Associate Publishers Seth L. Miller, Ceil Ainsworth Regional Sales Manager Tania Cade
Account Executives Fred Almonte, David Dallon Director of Partnership Development Barry Lewis
Editor-In-Chief, Alexis Gelber Acting Deputy Editor Alizah Salario
Senior Reporter Doug Feiden Staff Reporter Michael Garofalo
Director of Digital Pete Pinto
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
9
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
NEIGHBORHOOD’S BEST To place an ad in this directory, Call Douglas at 212-868-0190 ext. 352.
DINING
DINING Mention This Ad to Receive a FREE MIMOSA Offer Valid 11:30-3:00 Tue - Sun
‡ )5(( 'HOLYHU\ )RU /XQFK ‡ 'LQH ,Q 7DNH 2XW 'HOLYHU\ ‡ (QMR\ RXU 2XWGRRU 3DWLR ‡ 2UGHU 2QOLQH
›’Â&#x;ŠÂ?ÂŽČą Š›Â?¢ȹ Â˜Â˜Â–ÂœČąČŠČą Ž••¢ȹ Š—Œ’—Â?ȹȊȹ ŠÂ?Ž›’—Â?
řŗŖȹ ÂŽÂœÂ?ȹśř›Â?Čą Â?›ŽŽÂ?ČąČŠČąĹ˜Ĺ—Ĺ˜ČŹĹ˜ĹœĹ›ČŹĹ›Ĺ›Ĺ–Ĺ–    ǯÂ?ÂžÂ›Â”ÂžÂŠÂŁÂ›ÂŽÂœÂ?Šž›Š—Â?ÇŻÂŒÂ˜Â–Čą
Danny Pearlstein at a Fast Forward event in June 2018. Photo courtesy of Danny Pearlstein
A FIGHT TO ‘FIX THE SUBWAY’ COMMUTERS Danny Pearlstein of the Riders Alliance and other grassroots groups aim to improve the transit system BY MEREDITH KURZ
Here’s the good news: tourism is up, employment is up, and population is up. Here’s the bad news: the transportation system is sinking fast, there’s a fare hike proposal on the table and the MTA Chairman just resigned. Here’s the solution: New Yorkers when they get together can do something about it. While riders get angry for a moment and then get on with their day, many citizens have pulled together and are trying to help all New Yorkers, and our millions of tourists, to improve the city commute. Danny Pearlstein is the policy and communications director of the Riders Alliance, an organization, he explained, that “fights for better transit by organizing subway and bus riders.� Pearlstein got recruited from the membership four years ago, and came on the staff last Thanksgiving. He grew up riding the subway and has a true passion for getting it right, for all New Yorkers. “When the transit doesn’t work, our city doesn’t work,� said Pearlstein. The Riders Alliance has not only increased their membership recently, but they’ve joined a coalition of disparate grassroots groups that have the “transit system to
bind them together,� as Pearlstein puts it. The Riders Alliance is part of a coalition called “Fix the Subway,� with over 20 other organizations. Those groups include NYPIRG Straphangers, ALIGN NY, Chinese-American Planning Council, Citizen Action, Community Voices Heard, Environmental Advocates of New York, New York City Employment and Training Coalition, New York City Environmental Justice Alliance, New York Communities for Change, New York Immigration Coalition, New York Lawyers for the Public Interest, Rise and Resist, Sanitation Coalition, Straphangers Campaign, Street Vendor Project and Transportation Alternatives. One issue facing the coalition is the MTA’s proposed solution called Fast Forward. With a new Democratic controlled state legislature, it will be up to Albany to implement this improvement, which is backed by many in the “Fix the Subway� coalition. “The MTA has a work plan for new signals, cars, and elevators. The question is whether the governor and legislature will come up with a fair and sustainable funding plan to get it all done. Riders are looking to Albany as we approach the next state budget,� said Pearlstein. “Now more than a year since the governor declared a state of emergency on the subway, it’s clear that only full-scale modernization can end our transit crisis.� Putting pressure on politicians has helped in the past.
Riders Alliance and other groups helped get the Commuter BeneďŹ ts Law, a federal commuter tax benefit that allows transit users to pay for the cost of their commutes with up to $255 of pre-tax dollars a month is now mandatory for many employers in the ďŹ ve boroughs. Pitching in to help Riders Alliance, or one of the many other groups throughout the city, can make a big difference. In order to get the Fast Forward project pushed forward, New Yorkers will have to get, well, pushy. Pearlstein said, “Next year’s’ goal is to increase the outreach and impact of this grassroots organization.â€? Grassroots groups coordinate outreach to the State Legislature, the mayor and the governor, representing their collective concerns. New York City is the largest subway system in the world, yet is ranked 21st in a global lineup of reliability. “We did a study in August and found that every morning every single delay was related to signal problems, primarily in Manhattan and Brooklyn,â€? said Pearlstein. “The D and the R have the worst records. The real system has become unreliable. In the past six years delays have tripled. Using May of 2012 as a baseline of 20,000 delays per month ... we have leapt up to 60,000 to 70,000 delays per month.â€? As for the recent fare hike proposal, Pearlstein said, “With three fares hikes in the past six years, and train delays tripling in the same period, yet another fare hike would unfairly leave riders paying more for less.â€?
LOCKSMITH
LIGHTING
‘Lighting
Restoration & Repairs Lampshades ‘Custom Lighting For The World’s Finest Homes
SKY LOCKSMITH & HARDWARE FALL INTO SAVINGS
‘Bespoke
Mention This ad and Receive A FREE In Home Consult in NYC!
BhonBhon Lighting BHONBHON.COM | (212) 397-3710 Visit Our Lighting Showroom 43-01 21st. Long Island City
10% OFF COUPON IN STORES OFFER VALID FOR PURCHASES IN STORE ONLY. NO LOCK INSTALLATIONS AND SITE VISITS. VALID 10/1/2018-12/1/2018 24/7 EMERGENCY LOCKSMITH SERVICE 212-288-7773 Store Locations: 1574 1st Ave / 182 E. 73rd / 2212 Broadway
PERSONAL TRAINING soZo concept *O )PNF t *O 0GmDF Personal Training Bringing Fitness to the home & ofďŹ ce for over 20 years! No Weights Free Needed! Consult TRX Kerry Aissa Founder
212-203-5634
PETS
PSYCHOTHERAPY
25% OFF YOUR DOG’S FIRST OVERNIGHT STAY TREAT YOUR DOG TO A VACATION WITH US!
Training Walking Jogging Overnight Daycare Grooming
*Valid for new clients only. Holiday rates apply.
Call us today
212-696-8364
KTA1@me.com
info@akccanineretreat.com www.akccanineretreat.com
SENIOR CARE
SPIRITUAL
KARPOFF AFFILIATES KARPOFF AFFILIATES is your single stop for senior life transitions and real estate brokerage needs. We provide peace of mind and ensure that each project is handled with respect and integrity.
www.KarpoffAfďŹ liates.com mkarpoff@karpoffafďŹ liates.com 212.358.8044 290 Third Avenue, Ste 26C, NYC 10010
WINDOW TREATMENTS
Upper West Manhattan Church of Christ 80 YEARS!
Meeting at 891 Amsterdam Ave. @ 103rd St. In Hosteling International For more information: Call 212-729-8356 www.uwmchurchofchrist.com
Draperies Shades Shutters Blinds Motorization Window Film Upholstery Fabric & Trim Flooring Paint
SEMI-ANNUAL CUSTOM DECORATING SALE GOING ON NOW! UPPER WEST SIDE 469 AMSTERDAM AVE. 212.501.8282 WINDOWFASHIONS.COM
10
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
JOHN KRTIL FUNERAL HOME; YORKVILLE FUNERAL SERVICE, INC. Dignified, Affordable and Independently Owned Since 1885 WE SERVE ALL FAITHS AND COMMUNITIES 5 )/'&1 /'+$1)-,0 $2250 -+.*'1' 5 )/'&1 2/)$*0 $2850 5 4.'/1 /' *$,,),( 3$)*$%*'
Discover the world around the corner. Find community events, gallery openings, book launches and much more: Go to nycnow.com
1297 First Ave (69th & 70th & + # " $& )" $ " $ ) * "#( & " $ + ))) $& '" $ #! #! Each cremation service individually performed by fully licensed members of our staff. We use no outside agents or trade services in our cremation service. We exclusively use All Souls Chapel and Crematory at the prestigious St. Michael's Cemetery, Queens, NY for our cremations unless otherwise directed.
s ar ce ye ien 34 per ex
PERSONALIZED HOME CARE
referrals@cohme.org
RESISTANCE: THE POPULIST CHALLENGE TO DEMOCRACY
International lawyer and political writer Laurent Cohen-Tanugi will present and discuss his new book, “Resistance: The Populist Challenge to Democracy.� The discussion will focus on topics including Brexit, the midterm elections, the rise of the extreme right and how to counter threats to democracy.
DEMENTIA TRAINING FOR THE AIDES
Visit cohme.org or email
Tue 27 Albertine, 972 Fifth Ave. 6:30 p.m. Free 212-650-0070 albertine.com
CUSTOMIZED CARE
SOCIAL WORK SERVICES INCLUDED
EDITOR’S PICK
(877) 212-4222 toll-free nsultation! Call 24/7 for a free co
Thu 22 Fri 23
Sat 24
â–˛ THANKSGIVING CELEBRATION
BLACK FRIDAY HIKE: CENTRAL PARK SOUTH TO NORTH
RECONSIDERING POST-MODERNISM IN EAST MIDTOWN
Doris Freedman Plaza Fifth Avenue & 60th Street 11 a.m. Free Escape the consumerist frenzy of Black Friday and work off your Thanksgiving feast with an invigorating and informative hike traversing the length of Central Park. Guided by the Urban Park Rangers, the walk begins at the park’s southeastern corner and ends at the northern end near the Harlem Meer. 212-360-1444 nycgovparks.org
The Municipal Art Society of New York location TBA with ticket 11 a.m. $30 Take a closer look at Manhattan’s post-modern architecture, including major works by architectural ďŹ rms Helmut Jahn, Johnson/Burgee, KPF and IM Pei, highlighting why postmodernism was so innovative during the Reagan years. 212-935-3960 mas.org
Demarchelier Restaurant 50 East 86th St. Noon. Menu $14+, Prix Fixe $37 If the thought of cleaning up after a family Thanksgiving meal gives you a migraine, cast your worries aside at the family-owned and operated Demarchelier Restaurant. Classic French dishes, served a la carte, will be featured alongside specialty prix ďŹ xe and American Thanksgiving dishes. 212-249-6300 demarchelierrestaurant.com
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
11
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech
Sun 25 Mon 26 Tue 27 MESSIAH… REFRESHED!
▲ INSIGHT LANDS ON MARS
AUTHOR EVENT: DAVE KING
Stern Auditorium 881 Seventh Ave. 2 p.m. $5+ Distinguished Concerts International New York celebrates the holiday season with the eighth annual presentation of Handel’s “Messiah,” with the Beecham/Goossens 1959 reorchestration for full symphony orchestra. The performance will be led by maestro Jonathan Griffith and features a choir made up of singers from around the world. 212-247-7800 carnegiehall.org
American Museum of Natural History, Central Park West & 79th St. 2 p.m. Free with museum admission Join Hayden Planetarium director of astrovisualization Carter Emmart for a live simulation of the landing of the InSight Mission, which is due to reach its target on Mars on Monday, Nov. 26. Launched in May, the craft will deploy a seismometer, burrow a heat probe, and perform radio experiments to study the internal structure of the Red Planet. 212-769-5100 amnh.org
NYPL Webster Library 1465 York Ave. 5:30 p.m. Free Author Dave King will discuss his novel “The Ha-Ha” about a man rendered unable to speak, read or write after a Vietnam War injury 30 years earlier. Howard Kapostash feels trapped by his disability until an old flame asks him to care for her 9-year-old son. It is a story about war and the worth of human connection. 212-288-5049 nypl.org
Wed 28
BEST OF MANHATTAN
More than 150,000 loyal readers of Our Town, The West Side Spirit, Our Town Downtown and Chelsea News turn to the first & best guide
MAKE SURE THEY KNOW YOU’RE THE BEST Get a 100 word write-up about your business in the category of your choice Neighborhood Shops Gym/Recreation Home Improvement Pets t Kids t Arts & Culture Food & Drink A N D M O R E !
◄ DISCUSSION AND BOOK LAUNCH: ‘SOMEWHERE TOTALLY ELSE’ Americas Society 680 Park Ave. 6:30 p.m. Free Artist Tania Bruguera and curator Hans Ulrich Obrist discuss the exhibition “Lydia Cabrera and Édouard Glissant: Trembling Thinking,” followed by the launch of Obrist’s book “Somewhere Totally Else,” a collection of his weekly contributions to the Swiss paper “Tages-Anzeiger,” a diary-style survey of contemporary art and cultural affairs. 212-249-8950. as-coa.org
ISSUE DATE: Dec 6 AD SPACE DEADLINE: Nov 30 For more information Call 212-868-0190 advertising@strausnews.com The local paper for the Upper East Side
The local paper for the Upper West Side
The local paper for Downtown
The local paper for Chelsea
12
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
ETERNAL BEAUTY FROM AN ENDURING CULTURE Treasures from Armenia at The Met BY MARY GREGORY
Armenia! - celebratory exclamation mark and all – is the subject of a beautiful, reflective exhibition at The Met Fifth Avenue, on view through Jan. 13. It’s focused on the history, culture and exquisite art of Armenia from the beginning of the 4th century, when it became the world’s first officially Christian country, through the 1600s when it was a powerful leader of international trade. The galleries are filled with stone work and architectural fragments laden with spiritual imagery, luxurious textiles, illuminated manuscripts from the Middle Ages and rare antique printed books, reliquaries laden with gems and precious metals, and a hushed sense of awe. “By examining these magnificent treasures, we can better understand and appreciate the central role that art played in defining and connecting Armenian communities during this time, and how they both influenced
Arm Reliquary of Saint Nicholas. The medallion on the hand of the reliquary identifies it as containing the bones of the saint. Photo: Adel Gorgy
and were inspired by styles from other cultures,” said Max Hollein, the new director of The Met. The exhibition was organized by Helen C. Evans, curator of Byzantine Art, with C. Griffith Mann, the curator in charge of Medieval Art, and the assistance of Constance Alchermes. Of the roughly 140 works in the exhibition, most have never been seen in the U.S. before, and many have not traveled for centuries. Rooted at the base of Mount Ararat, the Armenian culture saw and survived the influence of Byzantine, Persian, Arab, Seljuk, Mongol, and Ottoman powers that passed through their lands at the historic and geographic crossroads of several civilizations. As with many enduring cultures of the world, Armenians adapted and adopted, moved and morphed, yet never relinquished their own unique identity. Spectacular standing Khachkars, or towering cross stones, a distinctly Armenian art form, are a highlight. One on loan from the monastery of Havuts‘ Tar in Ayrarat was carved in 12th– 13th century with incredibly intricate twining lines, knotted and looping endlessly. It’s the kind of decoration that was often painted on medieval manuscript borders, but hewing that level of complex detail from solid stone is something else altogether.
A gold, silver, and silk altar frontal, 1741, from New Julfa, an Armenian district in Isfahan settled after the forced relocation of Armenians from Julfa to Isfahan. Photo: Adel Gorgy At the beginning of the exhibition is a four-sided stela, or upright stone marker, from the monastery of Kharaba. One of the oldest extant works of Armenian art, it was made in the 4th5th century, and depicts the conversion of King Tiridates to Christianity by Saint Gregory the Illuminator. Gregory, the patron saint of Armenia, was the son of a tyrant who fled the kingdom un-
A magnificent gilded manuscript giving a sense of the wealth and piety of medieval Armenia. Photo: Adel Gorgy.
der the protection of Christian caretakers. He returned years later as a monk, converting the new king and the entire country. Gregory’s story and other Armenian tales are repeated across centuries and works of art that express styles typical of both the Eastern and Western worlds. The story that comes across most clearly is of a tenacious, peripatetic and persevering people. Curator Evans describes the Armenians as “A unique people, who beginning from their homeland at the base of Mount Ararat, by the end of the Middle Ages have spread across the globe and are controlling massively important trade routes that reach from England to Latin America, from India to Russia.”
Detail of a Four-Sided Stela from the Monastery of Kharaba depicting the Madonna and Child. Photo: Adel Gorgy.
The success of the Armenian people is reflected in the lavishness of the works on view, including spectacular manuscripts with painted and gilded illuminations by T‘oros Roslin. Evans said of Roslin, “He is the Rembrandt of the Armenians, the Titian, and his lasting influence is as great as a Titian or a Rembrandt within the Armenian world.” In Roslin’s “Gospel Book of Lady Keran and Prince Levon II,” the artist incorporated images of faith and culture as well as human and divine presence all at once. The manuscript was commissioned as a gift for the couple. They stand side-by-side holding a picture of the sacred book. Dressed in rich silks, their portraits proclaim the wealth of the society. Above them, Christ blesses them. It’s a statement of both piety and worldly ambition. Photographs of the works, as well as the audio guide, can be experienced on the Met’s website. Still, to stand before works fashioned from imagination, devotion and creativity, and with materials from ages ago, is moving and humbling in ways that an online experience can never be. The chance to widen our understanding of the world and become immersed in a culture while gazing upon exquisite works of art is a rare gift from the Armenian people, government, and religious and cultural institutions. Don’t miss it.
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
13
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Your Neighborhood News Source
BEYOND BROADWAY - EAST SIDE The #1 online community for NYC theater:
www.show-score.com
NOW PLAYING IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD FROM $30
GLORIA: A LIFE 66 REVIEWS ENDS MAR 31
FROM $35
FROM $31
THE RESISTIBLE RISE OF ARTURO UI
MOTHER OF THE MAID 160 REVIEWS ENDS DEC 23
71 REVIEWS ENDS DEC 22
81
79 79
Christine Lahti stars as iconic feminist Gloria Steinem in this world premiere biographical drama directed by Tony Award winner Diane Paulus.
Bertolt Brecht’s skewering of Adolf Hitler and totalitarianism is given a new production directed by John Doyle (“The Color Purple”) for Classic Stage Company.
The Public Theater presents three-time Tony and Emmywinner Glenn Close in a drama about the mother of Joan of Arc.
DARYL ROTH THEATRE - 101 E 15TH ST
CLASSIC STAGE COMPANY - 136 E 13TH ST
THE PUBLIC THEATER - 425 LAFAYETTE ST
WHAT’S TRENDING ACROSS NYC
COMING SOON
FROM $45
FROM $45
DANIEL’S HUSBAND 267 REVIEWS OPEN RUN
A CHRISTMAS CAROL PREVIEWS START NOV 27
Summoners Ensemble Theatre presents its sixth annual run of this one-man adaptation of Charles Dickens’s beloved holiday classic.
84
MERCHANT’S HOUSE MUSEUM - 29 E 4TH ST
This story of a seemingly perfect gay couple offers an unflinching look at how we choose to tie the knot—or not.
FROM $50
WESTSIDE THEATRE - 407 W 43RD ST
A CHILD’S CHRISTMAS IN WALES PREVIEWS START NOV 28
FROM $40
ALL IS CALM
This Irish Rep tradition interweaves both classic and contemporary Christmas music with Dylan Thomas’s story of a snowy Christmas in Wales.
4 REVIEWS JUST OPENED
IRISH REPERTORY THEATRE - 132 W 22ND ST
81 FROM $25
Through European carols and war-songs, “All Is Calm” recalls the WWI Christmas truce between Allied and German soldiers.
BITTER GREENS PREVIEWS START DEC 07
SHEEN CENTER - 18 BLEECKER ST
When Reyna discovers she’s rejected from a dream job, her resentment drives her to make some bad—and dangerous—choices.
FROM $39
59E59 THEATER - 59 E 59TH ST
HAPPY BIRTHDAY, WANDA JUNE 247 REVIEWS ENDS NOV 29
FROM $67
BLUE RIDGE
80
PREVIEWS START DEC 12
Set in Southern Appalachia, The Atlantic’s world-premiere is a pitch-dark comedy about heartbreak, hell-raising, and healing.
A return engagement of famed novelist Kurt Vonnegut’s rarely produced satire. A searing and darkly comedic look at American culture.
ATLANTIC THEATER - 336 W 20TH ST
THE DUKE - 229 W 42ND ST
Content provided by
KEY:
14
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
RESTAURANT INSPECTION RATINGS
Neighborhood Scrapbook
NOV 7 - 13, 2018 The following listings were collected from the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s website and include the most recent inspection and grade reports listed. We have included every restaurant listed during this time within the zip codes of our neighborhoods. Some reports list numbers with their explanations; these are the number of violation points a restaurant has received. To see more information on restaurant grades, visit www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/services/restaurant-inspection.shtml. Dorrian’s Red Hand Restaurant
1616 2 Avenue
A
Lexington Candy Shop
1226 Lexington Ave
A
Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
141 E 88th St
A
Li’s Noodle Fun
1744 1st Ave
Not Yet Graded (19) Filth flies or food/refuse/sewage-associated (FRSA) flies present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth flies include house flies, little house flies, blow flies, bottle flies and flesh flies. Food/refuse/sewageassociated flies include fruit flies, drain flies and Phorid flies. Wiping cloths soiled or not stored in sanitizing solution.
Franklin Hotel
164 East 87 Street
Grade Pending (2)
Mamagyro
165 E 106th St
Grade Pending (7) Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
Capri Bakery
186 East 116 Street
A
Joy Burger Bar
1567 Lexington Ave
Grade Pending (10) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas.
VISIT OUR WEBSITE! at OURTOWNNY.COM CO ACTIVITIES FOR THE FERTILE MIND
thoughtgallery.org NEW YORK CITY
Public Lecture Series with David Grann: “The White Darkness”
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 26TH, 7PM The Explorers Club | 46 E. 70th St. | 212-628-8383 | explorers.org
Photo: Ron Jautz
HOLIDAY TREE IN LINCOLN SQUARE The Lincoln Square Business Improvement District (BID), elected officials and Department of Parks and Recreation leadership welcomed the arrival of the holiday tree for the 19th annual Winter’s Eve at Lincoln Square, New York’s largest holiday festival. The Lincoln Square BID continued its support of New York State tree farmers with the arrival of a 30-foot-tall Concolor from Domes Tree Farm in Bliss, New York. Domes Tree Farm is a family-owned business that’s been in operation since 1952 . Current owners Bill and Katie Domes specialize in tree-moving machinery, which was used to prepare the tree for its journey to NYC. The tree was installed at Dante Park (Broadway and 63rd Street) on Nov. 13 and will be on display through January 2019. Winter’s Eve at Lincoln Square is Monday, November 26th, 2018 from 5:30 p.m.– 9:00 p.m. and begins with the Upper West Side’s only tree-lighting ceremony at Dante Park.
If you were enraptured by David Grann’s New Yorker piece on British explorer Henry Worsley’s Ernest Shackleton-inspired expedition, you won’t want to miss this presentation on the booklength version, The White Darkness: A Journey Across Antarctica ($25).
Did You Just Eat That? Food Myths Explored by Scientists
WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 28TH, 7PM 92nd Street Y | 1395 Lexington Ave. | 212-415-5500 | 92y.org Scientists Paul Dawson and Brian Sheldon discuss their experiments with germs, settling longstanding debates over backwash, hand dryers, and the five-second rule. A book signing follows ($29).
Just Announced | President Carter: The White House Years
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 6TH, 7:30PM 92nd Street Y | 1395 Lexington Ave. | 212-415-5500 | 92y.org American diplomat and attorney Stuart Eizenstat speaks about his new book, which is filled with his own first-hand accounts of a misunderstood presidency. He’ll be joined in person by philanthropist David Rubenstein and President Jimmy Carter himself via Skype ($50).
For more information about lectures, readings and other intellectually stimulating events throughout NYC,
sign up for the weekly Thought Gallery newsletter at thoughtgallery.org.
Photo: Ron Jautz
Photo: Ron Jautz
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
“I WISH SOMEONE WOULD HELP THAT HOMELESS MAN.”
BE THE SOMEONE. Sam New York Cares Volunteer
Every day, we think to ourselves that someone should really help make this city a better place. Visit newyorkcares.org to learn about the countless ways you can volunteer and make a difference in your community.
15
16
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
AMAZON DEAL SPARKS LOCAL BLOWBACK Backlash from NYC elected officials after announcement of a new campus in Long Island City BY MICHAEL GAROFALO
From nearly the moment details emerged on Amazon’s plans to build a new corporate campus in Long Island City, the tech giant’s deal with the city and state became the subject of immediate backlash from some local groups and politicians. Criticism of the agreement has focused on a variety of factors, including the strain the rapid growth would place on the neighborhood’s transit system and housing market and the nearly $3 billion in subsidies and tax breaks the company is poised to reap. Amazon has said the Long Island City site and another new campus in Arlington, Virginia would each get 25,000 new jobs that the company said would pay an average of $150,000 a year. Amazon has said it will spend $5 billion between both locations on construction and other projects, and that hiring at the two headquarters will begin next year, but it could take a decade or more to build out the offices.
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Business
The secretive process by which the deal was reached has also come under scrutiny. Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Mayor Bill de Blasio engaged in private negotiations with Amazon that excluded state and local legislators, arriving at an agreement that exempts the development from the City Council’s authority on land use decisions. Council Speaker Corey Johnson said the legislative body is reviewing its legal options to change or block the deal. Here’s what local politicians are saying:
Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer: “New Yorkers are being told Amazon needs and deserves billions of dollars in payments and tax breaks to locate in Long Island City, minutes from Manhattan, when we have no certainty on a range of issues from local hiring to the effects on rents throughout the city. Moreover, the state plans to suspend local control over zoning – what gets built and where – not in order to build critical regional infrastructure, but to build a corporate headquarters. This sets a scary precedent for every neighborhood in every borough. This project
“The governor and they mayor have decided to throw Jeff Bezos almost $3 billion in subsidies and tax breaks and throw in a helipad so he doesn’t have to take the damn 7 train when we are several blocks from the Queensbridge Houses,” Queens Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer said at a protest against the deal to bring Amazon offices to Long Island City. Photo: NYC Council, via Twitter. should go through a full public review like any other major project and there should be a robust public engagement process.”
City Council Speaker Corey Johnson: “Amazon is one of the richest companies in the world, but you can’t put a price on community input, which has been missing throughout this entire
process. I find that lack of engagement and the fact that the negotiations excluded the City Council – which is elected by New Yorkers to guide land use projects with communities in mind – extremely troubling. I also don’t understand why a company as rich as Amazon would need nearly $2 billion in public money for its expansion plans at a time when New York desperately needs money for affordable housing, transportation, infrastructure and education. I will always advocate for economic development and jobs in New York, but when the process is done behind closed doors, with zero community input and nearly $2 billion in subsidies to a global behemoth, I am going to be skeptical.”
Council Member Keith Powers, who represents much of Manhattan’s East Side: “The public clearly has a lot of questions about Amazon. A public process allows us to discuss impacts of development and the overall value of the deal. We want good jobs, but bypassing the public process is a poor precedent & raises a question of why one project gets a pass.”
Mayor Bill de Blasio and Governor Andrew M. Cuomo announce that Amazon will establish a new corporate headquarters in Long Island City, Queens. Photo: Ed Reed/Mayoral Photography Office
U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand: “While I’m glad that Amazon recognizes that Queens is a great place to do business, I’m concerned about the lack of community input and the incentivizes that Amazon received in order to convince them to bring these jobs to New York. One of the wealthiest companies in history should not be receiving financial assistance from the taxpayers while too many New York families struggle to make ends meet.”
Rep. Nydia M. Velázquez: “Many New Yorkers, myself included, are concerned by the enormous incentives this package extends to Amazon. There are also very real reservations about how this proposal would affect traffic, transit crowding, housing affordability and our small business communities in Queens and Brooklyn.” Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer, who represents Long Island City: “The governor and they mayor have decided to throw Jeff Bezos almost $3 billion in subsidies and tax breaks and throw in a helipad so he doesn’t have to take the damn 7 train when we are several blocks from the Queensbridge Houses… We have a public housing crisis…but somehow folks who consider themselves progressive Democrats have seen fit to throw $3 billion at the richest man in the world.”
Assembly Member Daniel O’Donnell: “Now that the details have come out, it’s clear that this is a bad deal for New York. The truth is, many of the jobs Amazon is claiming they will create are already being created without billions of dollars in taxpayer subsidies… This deal includes no investment into our subways, no new affordable housing, no infrastructure repairs to NYCHA developments in Long Island City, and no entry level jobs for those that need them the most.” —With The Associated Press
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Real Estate Sales
17
18
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
‘COCKTAIL,’ 30 YEARS LATER CITY CULTURE A movie that brings back Manhattan in all its decadent 1980s glory BY JON FRIEDMAN
Everything you like about Our Town is now available to be delivered to your mailbox every week in the Eastsider From the very local news of your neighborhood to information about upcoming events and activities, the new home delivered edition of the Eastsiderwill keep you in-the-know. And best of all you won’t have to go outside to grab a copy from the street box every week.
It’s your neighborhood. It’s your news.
X
Yes! Start my mail subscription to the Eastsider right away! 1-Year Subscription @ $49
Name
________________________________________________
Address _________________________________ Apt. #
________
New York, NY Zip Code __________ Cell Phone _________________ Email Address___________________________________________ Payment by
Check # __________
Money Order
Credit Card
Name on Credit Card (Please Print) ___________________________ Card # _______________________ Exp. Date
____ //____ // ____
Signature of Cardholder ___________________________________
Return Completed Form to: Straus News, 20 West Avenue, Chester, NY, 10918 or go to OurTownNY.com & click on Subscribe
“Cocktail,” the 1988 Tom Cruise movie, shows Manhattan in a bygone era: all of its decadent 1980s glory. Don’t be coy. You remember that era, when a whole new vocabulary and way of life came into prominence. Crack was the cheap drug of choice of high school kids who mugged older people (like me, on Friday night, June 13, 1986) to pay for the shabby high. The perp walk was born on Wall Street when the feds outsmarted greedy bankers and brokers. The baby-boomers, disparaged by the media as Yuppies, slinked off to Brooklyn if they couldn’t afford to live in The City. The movie “Cocktail” — no rational person would dignify such a critically reviled flick by calling it a “film” — shows a bygone time in the city’s pop-culture history. Someday, anthropologists will gleefully dissect “Cocktail” to learn the rhythms of the Upper East Side. Perhaps no other movie has revealed the meat-market aspect of life in those shameless pickup bars. If you’re nodding in chagrined recognition, it’s OK! Hey, I was there, too, and, you bet, I am also cringing at the memory of the pulsating disco music and the wasted, aspiring hipsters doing blow in the bathrooms. Cruise plays Brian Flanagan, a young military veteran who comes home to Queens to stake his claim to the American Dream. Capturing the spirit of the go-go, insider-trading-rich 1980s culture in the city, he finds that schoolroom classes are too slow and stultifying for him. Desperate to make a few bucks but lacking the requisite training for most coveted jobs, he stumbles into a job in an Upper East Side singles bar and quickly learns the ropes from the resident, all-knowing bartender, Doug Coughlin, played smartly by Bryan Brown. “Young Flanagan,” as Coughlin calls him affectionately and dismissively, quickly becomes a rock-start barkeep. Men idolize him for his breezy cool style and women want to sleep with him. Few movies have featured the
Tom Cruise, 2017. Photo: Eva Rinaldi, via flickr city as such a notable supporting character. Sure, we’ve had “Moonstruck” to represent romantic Italian Brooklyn, and “Bright Lights, Big City” for the youthful, cocaine-filled literary set, “Wall Street” for the naked greed of Wall Streeters, “Manhattan” for, well, Manhattan and, God knows, “Taxi Driver” for the underside of one man’s descent into madness. There are, of course, dozens of others. “Cocktail” is perfect for fans of the 1980s Cruise. He plays Brian to the hilt of that era of patented Cruise characters who scream cockiness and still manage to betray a little vulnerability. Think of a bartender version of “Risky Business,” “Top Gun,” “The Color of Money” and, a later, “Rainman,“ “A Few Good Men” and “Jerry Maguire.” And what about the city itself? What has become of those singles bars? I suspect that things just aren’t quite the same today as they were
30 years ago. This conclusion came to me a few months ago. I was sitting on a bench at the West 23rd Street IRT subway station early one morning when I overheard two taxi drivers lamenting the new pressures on their way of life. Like any know-it-all journalist, I interrupted them and sagely nodded about the effect of Uber and Lyft on them and their brethren. One of them shot back: “No, no, sir. That’s not exactly it. People don’t go out to the bars, to pick people up, as much as they used to.” The other man nodded vigorously and added: “They stay home now and use online dating services, instead of going to singles bars.” That’s what it has come to. Is it better or worse to live in New York today than thirty years ago? Is the city now tamer or more sensible? Who can say ... But it sure is different now.
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
19
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Tired of Hunting for Our Town? Subscribe today to Eastsider The DOT added three-quarters of a mile of new bus lane along the M79 route as part of select bus service implementation, which transit officials say contributed to increased bus speeds and ridership. Photo: MTA/ NYC DOT
M79 SBS CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 The results on the M79 SBS route are in line with the average speed increase of about 10 percent that the MTA has seen on other routes after SBS implementation. “Prior to the M79 [SBS] launch in May of last year, ridership had been dropping,” Joe Chiarmonte, a bus service planner with MTA New York City Transit, told Community Board 7’s transportation committee om Nov. 13. “As soon as we implemented the M79 [SBS], ridership, as compared to the previous year’s ridership, started to increase.” One year after the launch,
ridership on the M79 route was nine percent greater than it was a year prior, outpacing the 0.5 percent increase in Manhattan-wide bus ridership over the same period. On average, current daily ridership on the route is roughly 12,500. Buses aren’t the only vehicles moving faster since the launch of SBS. Non-bus vehicle travel time has decreased eight percent on the West Side portion of the M79 route. On the East Side, travel times are down six percent for non-bus vehicles moving east on 79th Street and down two percent for vehicles heading west. MTA and DOT officials are hopeful that the M79 SBS will see further improvements in performance and ridership as
additional street design changes are implemented as part of an upcoming capital project. Planned capital improvements along the route include curb extensions and pedestrian islands to improve pedestrian safety, concrete reinforcements, or bus pads, at stops to prevent wear on the road surface, and additional “bus bulbs,” which are portions of sidewalk that extend into the street at stops to speed boarding and ease crowding on narrow sidewalks. The city’s Department of Design and Construction will begin preliminary work on the project next year, with the goal of starting construction in 2022.
Scene in New York BY RENEE EDELMAN
News of Your Neighborhood that you can’t get anywhere else
Dining Information, plus crime news, real estate prices - all about your part of town
Cultural Events in and around where you live (not Brooklyn, not Westchester)
Now get your personal copy delivered by US Mail for just
$
49/Year for 52 issues
To Subscribe : The first snowstorm of the season last Thursday ripped down nearly 150 trees and 300 tree limbs, according to the NYC Parks Department. These trees were scattered along West 67th Street between Columbus Avenue and Central Park West.
Call 212-868-0190 or go online to ourtownny.com and click on subscribe
20
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
Got an EVENT? FESTIVAL CONCERT GALLERY OPENING PLAY
Get The Word Out! Add Your Event for FREE Just $10 per day to be featured
nycnow.com
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
21
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com To read about other people who have had their “15 Minutes” go to ourtownny.com/15 minutes
YOUR 15 MINUTES
THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO WILL With a passion for theater, social justice and the teachings of Jesus, William Critzman is a modern minister with a mission rooted in timeless ideals
that arc bend towards justice. I think religion knows about a sense of history. We bring the connective tissue. If we preached the headlines every day, we’d never run out of material. But religion reminds people that the headlines of the day are part of a bigger picture. We have to bring in the [wider] landscape. We can’t be ashamed of our faith; we have to let it guide our life, and how we love one another.
BY MARK NIMAR
In New York City, modes of worship are as varied and diverse as the city itself. Some Upper West Siders may reserve Sundays for brunch or SoulCycle, others for a weekly church service. For the Reverend William H. Critzman, 39, the new senior minister at West End Collegiate Church, Jesus’s messages of love, compassion and equality have never been more relevant, particularly when it comes to politics, social justice or the arts. But while Critzman has immense love for old biblical teachings, he is also breaking new ground as the first openly gay senior minister to serve at Collegiate Church in the organization’s nearly 400 year history. With his youth and fresh perspective, Critzman is poised to attract a whole new group of worshippers to the congregation. Straus News sat down with Critzman last week to talk about his background in show business, holding our nation’s leaders accountable, and why he wants you to come to church.
What’s your favorite section of the bible? Why? My favorite book in the bible is the Gospel of Mark. I think it contains everything the New Testament needs to tell us. It’s the shortest of the gospel. The entire Gospel can be read in 55 minutes. Mark’s favorite word is “immediately”. He uses it 44 times. And this sense of immediacy, it speaks to the call to make the world change now. The Gospel of Mark is written in CE in 70 when Rome is on a full assault of Jerusalem. And when it is bleak, I think about this in our New York lives. This is like September 12, 2001. The city is under attack, and we don’t know why. We are in a state of trauma and grief, and the one way we comfort each other is by telling stories. We look to a story that might bring us hope.
For someone coming to West End Collegiate Church for the first time who does not have a relationship with God or has never attended church, what could they expect?
How did you become a minister? What called you to the profession? Well, my background was as a theater producer and arts executive. I worked in London, San Francisco and New York. And about 10 years ago, when I was working at Lehman Brothers, everyone was talking about the importance of being inter-disciplinary in our approach to the arts. We needed to look at what it means to be in the arts, and we were talking about how we were not doing a very good job of incorporating other disciplines into our profession. So I started looking at some seminary programs to do a master’s in the arts and religion, so I could try to bring theology and art together. In the 20th century, the left claimed the arts, and the right claimed religion, and I wanted to put the two together. One thing I know is that no one walks on the stage of the Met without saying some sort of prayer; every act of creating art is an act of faith. I swore I’d never work in a church. But over the past year, my sense of call was coming to a time of change. I was beginning to feel this sense of change downtown [where I was studying]. And then I got a call from West End Collegiate’s search committee. I told them, “I think I am wildly unqualified for what it is you’re looking for. I think you’re looking for someone who’s
Rev. William H. Critzman, the first openly gay senior minister at the West End Collegiate Church. Photo: Ken Bower more traditional than me.” But we had a conversation over three months and seven different rounds of interviewing. I met with 73 different people, and walking into each space, I fell so in love with the search committee, and by the time we got to the final rounds in June, I felt that we could do something new and amazing with the Upper West Side, and that feeling was palpable in my body. So far, it’s been a really great and energetic experience.
What’s your favorite thing about the ministry? It’s all about the people. I came into the ministry with these macro ideas: public religion, public theatre. And the more I got into the ministry, you learn that people have lives, and show up on your doorstep, and are hungry. I learned that I needed more tools for how to listen to people, and what they
are saying. My favorite part is to hear people, to connect the dots, to connect them with people around them and their families. To teach them about what it means to be a human, and be with each other, and be with creation.
The life and teachings of Jesus may seem so far removed from modern life. How are they relevant to the present day? I think the simplicity of Jesus’s teachings is so relevant in our modern day: Love god. Let love be the guide. Love your neighbor as you love yourself. These are easy teachings. Let us love, and just love each other. That means Black Lives Matter. That means LGBT individuals should have equal rights. That means women should have a seat at the table for making decisions about themselves. That means we’re not going to name-call people,
we’re not going to use profanity. We’re not going to disrespect people. And when we see that in our leaders, we’re gonna call it out. Jesus had a history of holding leaders accountable, calling people out of old cemented ways of living, and calling them into new life.
Right now, the United States is going through a turbulent, and some may say dangerous political time. What is religion’s role, and how can it help heal the country? I think one of religion’s chief roles is to be an arbiter of morality, dignity and respect. If you look at Judaism and Islam at their core, they have each person as a spark of the divine. Separation of church and state is important. But [religion] does have something to say about how we engage in debate, how we talk to one another, and how we engage in disagreement. How we help
When you walk into West End Church on a Sunday morning, the congregation takes tradition and worship very seriously. They take hospitality seriously. People are dressed in all sorts of different things: some people come in jeans, some people come in sweats, it’s all fine. But as the community gathers, there’s this sense of informality that turns into something very formal. I can’t tell you what it is, but it’s holy. Then suddenly, an acolyte walks down the aisles. The service is beautiful. We have stunning musicians, and if music is a way for you to connect to the divine, come. The kids also have a wonderful energy before going to Sunday school. What you’re going to find here is a community. There’s a 150 of us every morning. That 150 is just the right size. That sense of belonging does not happen anywhere else, that sense of caring. It helps piece together the fragmentation of our lives.
Know somebody who deserves their 15 Minutes of fame? Go to ourtownny.com and click on submit a press release or announcement.
22
6
7
10
11
12
14
15
16 19 22 25
27
28
8 2
1
8
9 3
41
T W R U W B L Y K O A Y A H B
C A R V I N G S L N R N X B L
U W A L N U T L F Y T T R I E
V D C Y C A E M W I W C C U X
P O X H N C R A Q T O A U D I
U H I D T G T U R H R R I E G
N N Q K I C E N C D K P D R W
A L G E H S J V S H H E G J S
S K S E F E D L C B M T N L R
X P S E G Y C H A I R S V W T
M B Q U T P A I N T I N G S O
The puzzle contains the following words. They may be diagonal, across, or up and down in the grid in any direction.
J C Y M Z S O E Z O F J V D W
Ancient Antiques Artwork Cards Carpets Carvings Chairs China Collect Marble Paintings Sets Statues Walnut Watches
ANSWERS I
B
O
D
I
H
Y O
A
L
L
A
I
A
R
I
L
G
U
S
A
42 36
37
38
T S
U
34 31 29 23 20
T
21
17
E O
N
14
O O
T
C
A
10 1
2
3
T
N
A
43
A
E
U
N
D
39
P S
40
L 18
A
44
E
E
41
E K
N
33
C
S
25 22
S
O
P
C
S
15
O 4
A
I
S
L
11
T
I 5
F
O
R M 6
A
N
B
V
45
R
E
E
30
S
24
I
A
35
T
32
E
T E Y
46
K
C
H O
E
N
A
R C
26
E T
27
S D D A
28
I
A
T
19
I
S
V
P
16
R
B O
I
12 7
A
8
T
9
M
E Y L
13
P U A V A N C I E N T E H T M
L N T E J S T A T U E S L F A
Q S T Y F U I V H F C P B P R
T W R U W B L Y K O A Y A H B
C A R V I N G S L N R N X B L
U W A L N U T L F Y T T R I E
V D C Y C A E M W I W C C U X
P O X H N C R A Q T O A U D I
U H I D T G T U R H R R I E G
N N Q K I C E N C D K P D R W
A L G E H S J V S H H E G J S
S K S E F E D L C B M T N L R
X P S E G Y C H A I R S V W T
M B Q U T P A I N T I N G S O
J C Y M Z S O E Z O F J V D W
1 8
3 9
4
6 5 8 1 2 4 7
2 6 7 9 3 5
7 5 2 4 9 3 6 1 8
4 1 9 8 5 2 3 7 6
6 7 5 3 1 4 8 2 9
8 2 3 9 7 6 4 5 1
9 3 7 6 4 5 1 8 2
2 6 1 7 3 8 5 9 4
5 4 8 1 2 9 7 6 3
20. Caspian Sea feeder 21. Get together 24. John Philip ______, US bandmaster 26. Screeching 27. Get misty-eyed 28. Combines 32. Sawbuck 36. Monopolize 37. Sacred bird of Egypt 38. Gossip about 39. Pedestal part 40. Polish partner 41. Bother, with “at” 45. Neck type 46. Even
Q S T Y F U I V H F C P B P R
G
52
L N T E J S T A T U E S L F A
49
51
P U A V A N C I E N T E H T M
52
49
WORD SEARCH by Myles Mellor
T
48
46
I
47
45
T
44
43. Wine area 44. Creeper 47. Central idea 48. Proofread 49. Known as 50. Her 51. “Baloney!” 52. Affect, with “to” Down 1. Swallowed up 2. Gentle sound 3. Musical key 4. Too 5. PC term 6. Recurring themes 7. Staying off the booze 8. Pith helmet 9. Offensive missile syst. 11. Photo ___ (camera sessions) 13. Caustic potash 18. Outline 19. One way to be taken
7
Level: Medium
43
Across 1. Whoopi’s “Sister __” 4. Ready for battle 7. Cash machine 10. Excessively 11. This and that 12. Seethe 14. Very very long time 15. “Hey, over here!” 16. Agile 17. Linked in the mind 20. Wrinkled skin fruit 22. J. Edgar Hoover’s org. 23. Train tracks 25. Safe places 29. E’en if 30. Shrouded, old word 31. Present 33. Massage 34. Capitalize 35. Disney flick 36. Children’s game 42. News of passing
2
2
3
42
50
7
D
40
4
1
E
39
6 7
5 6
35
38
4
R O
37
2
9
2
33
34
8
7 6
48
32
3
1
30
31
6 1
1
51
29
26
6
E
24
4
8
T
21
23
36
13
Each Sudoku puzzle consists of a 9X9 grid that has been subdivided into nine smaller grids of 3X3 squares. To solve the puzzle each row, column and box must contain each of the numbers 1 to 9. Puzzles come in three grades: easy, medium and difficult.
H
20
18
9
S
17
8
I
5
S
4
50
3
SUDOKU by Myles Mellor and Susan Flanagan
by Myles Mellor
G
2
CROSSWORD
47
Eastsider 1
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
23
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
CLASSIFIEDS MASSAGE
MERCHANDISE FOR SALE
PUBLIC NOTICES SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK - COUNTY OF ROCKLAND INDEX # 033789/2015 FILED: 10/18/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL SUMMONS AND NOTICE Plaintiff designates ROCKLAND County as the place of trial. The Basis of Venue is that the Subject of the Action is situated in ROCKLAND County. BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC, Plaintiff, against SARA KEATING, ESQ., as Guardian ad Litem for the respective heirsat-law, next-of-kin, distributees, executors, administrators, trustees, devisees, legatees, assignees, lienors, creditors and successors in interest and generally all persons having or claiming under, by or through Sterle K. Murray A/K/A Sterle Murray, who may be deceased by purchase, inheritance, lien or otherwise, any right, title or interest in the real property described in the amended complaint herein, STEPHEN F. DEGROAT, AS PUBLIC ADMINISTRATOR OF ROCKLAND COUNTY, DORCAS MURRAY, AS HEIR TO THE ESTATE OF STERLE K. MURRAY A/K/A STERLE MURRAY, NEW
Telephone: 212-868-0190 Email: classified2@strausnews.com
POLICY NOTICE: We make every effort to avoid mistakes in your classified ads. Check your ad the first week it runs. The publication will only accept responsibility for the first incorrect insertion. The publication assumes no financial responsibility for errors or omissions. We reserve the right to edit, reject, or re-classify any ad. Contact your sales rep directly for any copy changes. All classified ads are pre-paid.
PUBLIC NOTICES
PUBLIC NOTICES
PUBLIC NOTICES
PUBLIC NOTICES
YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TAXATION & FINANCE, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE, Defendants. TO THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANTS: YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED to answer the Amended Complaint in this action and to serve a copy of your answer, or, if the Amended Complaint is not served with this Supplemental Summons, to serve a notice of appearance, on the Plaintiff’s Attorneys within 20 days after the service of this Supplemental Summons, exclusive of the day of service (or within 30 days after the service is complete if this Supplemental Summons is not personally delivered to you within the State of New York); The United States of America may appear or answer within 60 days of service hereof; and in case of your failure to appear or answer, judgment will be taken against you by default for the relief demanded in the Amended Complaint. NOTICE YOU ARE IN DANGER OF LOSING YOUR HOME IF YOU DO NOT RESPOND TO THIS SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT BY SERVING A COPY OF THE ANSWER ON THE ATTORNEY FOR THE MORTGAGE COMPANY WHO FILED THIS FORECLOSURE PROCEEDING AGAINST YOU AND FILING THE ANSWER WITH THE COURT, A DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AND YOU CAN LOSE YOUR HOME. SPEAK TO AN ATTORNEY OR GO TO THE COURT WHERE YOUR CASE IS PENDING FOR FURTHER INFORMATION ON HOW TO ANSWER THE SUMMONS AND PROTECT YOUR PROPERTY. SENDING A PAYMENT TO YOUR MORTGAGE COMPANY WILL NOT STOP THIS FORECLOSURE ACTION. YOU MUST RESPOND BY SERVING A COPY OF THE ANSWER ON THE ATTORNEY FOR THE PLAINTIFF (MORTGAGE COMPANY) AND FILING THE ANSWER WITH THE COURT. NOTICE OF NATURE OF ACTION AND RELIEF SOUGHT: THE OBJECT of the
above captioned action is the foreclosure of a Mortgage, dated April 3, 2008, executed by the defendant, Sterle K. Murray a/k/a Sterle Murray, as Borrower, to JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., as mortgagee, to secure the sum of $293,000.00, which mortgage was duly recorded in the Rockland County Clerk’s Office on April 11, 2008 under Instrument No.: 200800017115. Effective December 1, 2008, the Borrower entered into a Loan Modification Agreement whereby the principal balance was adjusted to $303,173.60. The Loan Modification Agreement was recorded on August 7, 2009, under Instrument No: 2009-00027972 in The Rockland County Clerk’s Office. Effective April 1, 2011, the Borrower entered into a Home Affordable Modification Agreement whereby the principal balance was adjusted to $307,271.88. The Home Affordable Modification Agreement was recorded on April 28, 2011, under Instrument No: 201100016299 in The Rockland County Clerk’s Office. Effective November 1, 2013, the Borrower entered into a Loan Modification Agreement whereby the principal balance was adjusted to $330,944.20, with a deferred principal balance of $99,283.26. The Loan Modification Agreement was recorded on March 25, 2014, under Instrument No: 2014-00008033 in The Rockland County Clerk’s Office. An Assignment of Mortgage was recorded on October 3, 2014, under Instrument No.: 201400026776 in The Rockland County Clerk’s Office, covering premises known as 28 Rela Avenue, Haverstraw, NY 10927 (Section 26.36, Block 1 and Lot 18). The relief sought within action is a final judgment directing the sale of the premises described above to satisfy the debt described above. To the above named Defendants: The foregoing Supplemental Summons is served upon you by publication pursuant to an order of the Hon. Sherri L. Eisenpress, A.J.S.C. of the State
of New York, filed along with the supporting papers in the Office of the Clerk of the County of ROCKLAND on 10/11/2018. This is an action to foreclose on a mortgage. ALL that certain plot, piece or parcel of land, with the buildings and improvements thereon erected, situate, lying and being in the Village of Haverstraw, Town of Haverstraw, County of Rockland and State of New York, Section 26.36, Block 1 and Lot 18, said premises known as 28 Rela Avenue, Haverstraw, NY 10927. YOU ARE HEREBY PUT ON NOTICE THAT WE ARE ATTEMPTING TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED WILL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. There is now due and owing from the Estate of Sterle K. Murray a/k/a Sterle Murray to plaintiff the principal sum of $327,423.85 plus interest and late charges. UNLESS YOU DISPUTE THE VALIDITY OF THE DEBT, OR ANY PORTION THEREOF, WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS AFTER YOUR RECEIPT HEREOF THAT THE DEBT, OR ANY PORTION THEREOF, IS DISPUTED, THE DEBTOR JUDGMENT AGAINST YOU AND A COPY OF SUCH VERIFICATION OR JUDGMENT WILL BE MAILED TO YOU BY THE HEREIN DEBT COLLECTOR. IF APPLICABLE, UPON YOUR WRITTEN REQUEST, WITHIN SAID THIRTY (30) DAY PERIOD, THE HEREIN DEBT COLLECTOR WILL PROVIDE YOU WITH THE NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE ORIGINAL CREDITOR. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED A DISCHARGE FROM THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT, YOU ARE NOT PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR THE UNDERLYING INDEBTEDNESS OWED TO PLAINTIFF/CREDITOR AND THIS NOTICE/DISCLOSURE IS FOR COMPLIANCE AND INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. HELP FOR HOMEOWNERS IN FORECLOSURE New York State Law requires that we send you this notice about the foreclosure process. Please
read it carefully. SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT You are in danger of losing your home. If you fail to respond to the Summons and Complaint in this foreclosure action, you may lose your home. Please read the Summons and Complaint carefully. You should immediately contact an attorney or your local legal aid office to obtain advice on how to protect yourself. SOURCES OF INFORMATION AND ASSISTANCE The State encourages you to become informed about your options in foreclosure. In addition to seeking assistance from an attorney or legal aid office, there are government agencies, and non-profit organizations that you may contact for information about possible options, including trying to work with your lender during this process. To locate an entity near you, you may call the tollfree helpline maintained by New York State Department of Financial Services’ at 1-800269-0990 or visit the Department’s website at http://www. dfs.ny.gov FORECLOSURE RESCUE SCAMS Be careful of people who approach you with offers to “save” your home. There are individuals who watch for notices of foreclosure actions in order to unfairly profit from a homeowner’s distress. You should be extremely careful about any such promises and any suggestions that you pay them a fee or sign over your deed. State law requires anyone offering such services for profit to enter into a contract which fully describes the services they will perform and fees they will charge, and which prohibits them from taking any money from you until they have completed all such promised services. Section 1303 NOTICE YOU ARE IN DANGER OF LOSING YOUR HOME If you do not respond to this Summons and Complaint by serving the copy of the answer on the attorney for the mortgage company who filed this foreclosure proceeding against you and filing the answer with the court, a default judgment may be entered and you can lose your home. Speak to an attorney or go to the court where your case is pending for further information on how to answer the summons and protect your property. Sending a payment to your mortgage company will not stop this foreclosure action. YOU MUST RESPOND BY SERVING A COPY OF THE ANSWER ON THE ATTORNEY FOR THE PLAINTIFF (MORTGAGE COMPANY) AND FILING THE ANSWER WITH THE COURT. Stiene & Associates, P.C., Attorneys for Plaintiff, 167 Main Street, Northport, NY 11768 File # 201501160
NEED TO RUN A LEGAL NOTICE? Quick | Easy | Economical
Call Barry Lewis Today: 212-868-0190
PUBLIC NOTICES
TO PLACE YOUR LEGAL NOTICE CALL
Barry Lewis at
(212) 868-0190 or
barry.lewis@strausnews.com
24
NOVEMBER 22-28,2018
Our Town|Eastsider ourtownny.com
COME HOME TO GLENWOOD MANHATTAN’S FINEST LUXURY RENTALS
+ + +
+ + + + + +
UPPER EAST SIDE 1 BEDROOMS FROM $3,195 2 BEDROOMS FROM $4,495 3 BEDROOMS FROM $6,795
MIDTOWN & UPPER WEST SIDE 1 BEDROOMS FROM $3,495 2 BEDROOMS FROM $5,195 3 BEDROOMS FROM $8,495
TRIBECA & FINANCIAL DISTRICT 1 BEDROOMS FROM $3,995 2 BEDROOMS FROM $5,995 3 BEDROOMS FROM $8,695
UPTOWN LEASING OFFICE 212-535-0500 DOWNTOWN LEASING OFFICE 212-430-5900 ! " " All the units include features for persons with disabilities required by FHA.
GLENWOOD Equal Housing Opportunity
BUILDER OWNER MANAGER
GLENWOODNYC.COM