impact report 2014/15 One step ahead since 1991
6th February 2014
OxfOrdStudent
Features
Ultimate guide to Oxford’s Ball scene 14-15 »
Interview: Editorin-chief of XXY Magazine 32 »
Seamus Heaney tribute reviewed 25 »
Ralph Fiennes speaks at the Phoenix Picturehouse after
Max Freeman-Mills sees his new film The Invisible Woman
Screen p. 28 »
New College students make it to Tokyo! Jailbreak special, p. 4»
Israelis denounce Israel Society • Open letter slams aff iliation with “right-wing” group Stand With Us • Society defends Zionist political agenda
RUTH MACLEAN BEN GOLDSTEIN
A majority of Israeli Oxford students have spoken out against the activities of the Oxford University Israel Society. In an open letter written to this newspaper and signed by 21 Israeli citizens based in Oxford, the society was accused of being “co-opted from a cultural society to a hard-line political advocacy group” and of “not reflect[ing] the opinions of Israelis in this town”. The students warned that if action was not taken to rectify this, they would contact the relevant Oxford authorities to seek to force the society to change its name. The signatories make up the majority of Israelis studying in Oxford. Israel Soc deny all the allega-
The
THE RAG NAKED CALENDAR 2015 FT. THE OXFORD BLUES
Arts
Fashion
tions. A statement in response signed by ten members reads: “The Oxford Israel Society is deeply disappointed by recent polemics in the student press directed against itself and its president… If members take issue with the society’s core values or the way it is run, we do encourage them to stand for elections rather than attack us personally in the press.” The accusations centre around claims that Israel Soc is taking a right-wing political line by affiliating itself with the American pro-Israel organisation StandWithUs and that free speech is being restricted within the society. The letter points out that the Israel Soc constitution not only explicitly affiliates the society to StandWithUs, but also mandates the sending Continued on page 5 »
‘Not in our name’
An open letter signed by 21 Oxford Israelis
Volume 68, Issue 4 oxfordstudent.com PHOTO/ Robert Harris
Last week, Ariel Hoffman was expelled from the University Israel Society for “violating the society’s aims,” or otherwise said, for expressing political views different from Society President Richard Black’s. This follows a recent change in Israel Society’s constitution allowing the President to “expel any member who breaks the rules.” Mr Black fails to understand the importance of freedom of ex-
pression within any organisation, and certainly in Israel’s political tradition. Under the new Israel Society constitution, at least 25% of Members of Israeli Parliament would also be banned from the Society for promoting a “non-Zionist” agenda as interpreted by Black’s leadership. Indeed, Israel’s legal history shows a consistent constitutional commitment to free speech on Continued on page 5 »