Friday December 6th, 2019
The Campanile
Vol. CII, No. 5
PALO ALTO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT PALO ALTO HIGH SCHOOL 50 EMBARCADERO RD. PALO ALTO, CA 94301 NON-PROFIT ORG U.S. POSTAGE
PAI D PALO ALTO PERMIT #44
www.thecampanile.org
Palo Alto High School, 50 Embarcadero Road, Palo Alto, CA 94301
City Council bans natural gas to promote sustainability With introduction of ‘Sustainable Building Electrification Plan,’newly constructed homes must use electricity to decrease carbon footprint By Jace Purcell Staff Writer
P
alo Alto City Council banned the use of natural gas in new residential buildings through a unanimous vote on Nov. 4 in hopes of lowering carbon emissions to combat climate change. According to Mayor Eric Filseth, the “Sustainable Building Electrification Plan” was conceived in order to meet the goal of reducing carbon emissions that Palo Alto adopted in 2013 in the “Sustainability and Climate Action Plan” to reduce carbon emissions. “A few years ago, the city adopted a plan to reduce the city’s greenhouse gas emissions by 80% by the year 2030,” Filseth said. “We’re about halfway there.”
“Palo Alto is 100% green energy. If you cook with electricity in Palo Alto, there is no carbon footprint.” Eric Filseth
In order to tackle the remaining half of greenhouse emissions, City Council has created a plan that aims to reduce emissions in two major areas: natural gas use in residential areas and transportation.
“From the remaining emissions that we need to cut to hit that target, about 30% of it is natural gas use, primarily for cooking and heating,” Filseth said. “About 50% of it is transportation, mostly cars.” According to AP Environmental Science teacher Nicole Loomis, the plan will encourage Palo Alto residents to use electricity. “I think it provides people with an incentive to use solar because everything in their house will be electrical, so they would have things like water heating and heating the space, which uses a lot of energy,” Loomis said. However, Loomis expressed concern that the electricity the city uses could actually emit an equal amount of carbon, depending on how it is obtained. “In terms of furnace efficiency (and) charging cars, there may be a benefit there,” Loomis said. “However, it does rely more on how our electric producers provide us with electricity, whether they are using renewable sources.” Filseth believes this is only a good thing because residents using electric energy instead of natural gas reduces carbon emissions, since Palo Alto’s electricity is completely renewable as of 2013. Filseth said he wants to use as much electricity as possible over natural gas. “Palo Alto runs 100% green electricity, we do 100% renewable energy,” Filseth said. “We would like to see as much of the use of
natural gas converted to electricity as possible because if you cook with electricity in Palo Alto, there is no carbon footprint.” Filseth also said the City will encourage usage of electricity over other sources.
“People have to think about how much they value the environment and what they’ll have to sacrifice for that.” Emma Cudahy
“The conversion of our electricity and utility to 100% renewable sources is absolutely fundamental to our goal,” Filseth said. “So that’s the focus of the current plan, which is to encourage the use of electricity for heating and cooking, instead of natural gas.” This plan will also encourage the use of electric cars, according to Filseth. Because transportation is the source of the majority of Palo Alto’s remaining carbon emissions, City Council believes the shift to electric vehicles will dramatically reduce emissions. “One (method of reducing carbon emissions) is through the use of electric cars because (if ) you charge a car in Palo Alto, it leaves no carbon footprint because we get our power from hydro and solar,” Filseth said. Palo Alto is rapidly increas-
LAURA MALAGRINO/USED WITH PERMISSION
Junior Laura Malagrino makes use of Palo Alto’s 100% renewable energy and charges her electric Fiat 500 which she’s had since she started driving. “The car helps to lower our family’s carbon footprint,” Malagrino said. ing its amount of electric vehicles, which helps to reduce carbon emissions. Filseth said that one in three new cars registered in Palo Alto are electric, and that rate is rising. The majority of these electric vehicle owners charge their cars at home. However, not everyone has access to electric vehicles, and their chargers which makes reaching the 2030 goal challenging. “If you have your own single family home, it is pretty straightforward to install a charger and it doesn’t cost that much,” Filseth
said. “However, if you live in an apartment, it is very complicated to add your own charger. As a result, the overwhelming majority of electric vehicles are owned by single homed families and 40% of the market is basically shut off.” To combat this, along with the electrification plan, City Council passed another law this year that aims to provide families living in multi-unit living areas the opportunity to use electric vehicles. “City Council also passed a law that new multi-unit buildings have to wire three parking spots,”
Filseth said. “They don’t have to add the charger but the wires have to be there. We hope this will remove the major obstacle of multiunit buildings and open up the market to the 40%.” According to Filseth, most Palo Alto residents have taken this new plan of action well, including junior and environmental science student Emma Cudahy, who thinks that the plan is a net positive despite the potential loss in efficiency.
Natural Gas Ban I A3
New CPR requirement confuses students City aims to protect Recent California legislation forces uncertified seniors to partake in CPR training low-income tenants By Krista Robins & Bruno Klass
Staff Writer & Board Correspondent
C
27 states require high school CPR certification
54% of all public high school graduates are CPR certified
CPR certification lasts two years SOURCE: AMERICAN RED CROSS ART BY TIEN NGUYEN
By Johnny Yang
P
Sports Editor
aly students have to contend with so many acronyms — MRC, SSRC, SAT, ACT, APUSH, GPA and SCVAL, to name just a few. Now, there’s one more: CPR. Learning Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation has become an official graduation requirement. Due to a bill passed by California to implement emergency procedure training in high schools, CPR training is required to graduate and has been in effect since the 2018-2019 school year. CPR is an emergency procedure used on someone who has stopped breathing or whose heart has stopped beating. The technique applies chest compressions and artificial ventilation to preserve intact brain functions of the patient until further measures are taken. This effort usually gives time for a professional team to arrive, at which point the patient will be taken for further treatment.
INSIDE the edition
Living Skills teacher Letitia Burton, who organizes the Paly CPR training sessions, said that it is important for students to be educated about these skills, as they may eventually help students save lives.
“I do think that CPR would do well placed in either the Living Skills curriculum or, perhaps, advisory.” Alyssa Bond
“We all need to know how to save lives,” Burton said. “If a person is having a cardiac emergency, (a person with the skill of ) CPR can save (their) life. The compressions (that the CPR session trains students to do) keep the heart pumping and the blood circulating into the vital organs and the brain until paramedics get there.” Because this is only the second year that seniors need CPR train-
ing to graduate, Paly’s administration is still figuring out the best way to teach it to all students. Administration so far has not made CPR training a part of the required Living Skills class. Though the requirements of Living Skills and CPR training are similar, according to Burton, CPR is currently a separate class from Living Skills. “CPR classes are being set up during tutorials,” Burton said. “Therefore, even if you took Living Skills before the requirement was instituted, you still have to take CPR in order to graduate.” While acknowledging the difficulties of making such a change, Living Skills teacher Alyssa Bond said that finding an alternative setting for CPR training might be more effective. “I do think that CPR would do well to be placed in either the Living Skills curriculum or, perhaps, advisory,” Bond said. “However, it would require a lot of logistical work and collaboration with the organizations that offer CPR training and would need to be provided with equitable access
Opinion
News. . . . . . . . . . . A1-A4 Opinion. . . . . . . . . A5-A7 Editorials. . . . . . . . . . . A8 Lifestyle. . . . . . . . . B1-B4 GAGE SKIDMORE/CC BY-SA 2.0 Sports. . . . . . . . C1-C3, C6 Moderate in the Primary Sports Spread. . . . . C4-C5 Democrats should nominate a Science & Tech. . . C7-C8 moderate in order to win in 2020. PAGE A6
for all Paly and Gunn students.” According to Burton, there have been two CPR training sessions this semester — on Oct. 15 and Nov. 12, and there will be another two next semester on March 10 and 17. All the sessions are held at the Haymarket Theater.
“We all need to know how to save lives. If a person is having a cardiac emergency, (a person with the skill of) CPR can save (their) life.” Letitia Burton
Despite her wish for students to take advantage of the sessions Paly offers, Burton said there are alternative ways to fulfill the CPR training requirement for those who miss or are unable to attend
CPR Training A3
Lifestyle
SLOAN WUTTKE/THE CAMPANILE
Espresso Reviews
Three shops in Palo Alto offer diverse experiences. PAGE B3
ity Council members are preparing to pass an emergency ordinance to protect low-income tenants in Palo Alto from being evicted by landlords before a new California law, Assembly Bill 1482, takes effect next year. The proposal was created by council members Tom DuBois and Lydia Kou. According to Mayor Eric Filseth, AB 1482, also known as the Tenant Protection Act of 2019, was signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom into state law on Oct. 8, 2019. The act bans landlords from evicting tenants without a just cause and establishes rent control. “State law AB 1482 (David Chiu, D-San Francisco) imposes rent controls statewide, including Palo Alto; it legally limits the amount that landlords can raise rents each year,” Filseth said. “Rent controls are controversial, but it turns out that if you do have them, then you also need to have what is called ‘just cause eviction’ laws as a companion measure.” The tenants have to be leasing their houses or apartments for at least a year to be protected by this law and be at no-fault in their lease agreements, i.e. paying their rent regularly. The act also puts a cap of 5% plus inflation to the maximum annual rent increase for lease properties which are 15 years and older. “You need these laws in order to prevent landlords from simply evicting tenants in order to get around the rent control law,” Filseth said. “‘Just cause eviction’ laws are actually rare if there’s no rentcontrol law in place; the two tend to go hand-in-hand.” By doing so, landlords were trying to force low-income tenants to move out voluntarily, with the goal of attracting wealthier tenants who could pay higher rents before the AB 1482 takes effect next year. One such landlord is Hohbach Realty, a real estate agency which owns several apartment buildings near California Avenue such as
Sports
BRANDON MOORE/CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Unrecognized Teams
Students support lesser known teams despite poor records. PAGE C4-C5
Park Plaza, Birch Plaza, Mayfield Apartments and others. According to a memo released by City Council members, Hohbach Realty sent a letter to their tenants during the summer that the company was raising the rent by 25%. After many residents protested, the company reduced the rent increase to 7%. Some residents, however, decided to leave. According to Marcus Wood, a property manager at Hohbach Realty, the company was unaware that AB 1482 was pending and, once they realized so, they decided to reduce the rate increase. Resident and senior Maya Nazarewicz said she was particularly affected by these rate increases. “I think most Palo Alto apartments are not worth what you pay for,” Nazarewicz said. “We pay a lot of money for our apartment, and it’s very old and small.” Nazarewicz said many things are broken in her apartment and it takes a significant amount of time before they get fixed, including the air conditioning, which was turned off during the summer. In the apartment Nazarewicz lived in before, her family was paying $3,000. To her surprise, the apartment was filled with mold, had no air conditioning, was exposed to no sunlight and was right next to a train. “It’s not fair because in other cities, you can pay the same or less for more space and it’s much more modern,” Nazarewicz said. Wood also argues that despite the 25% rent increase, many of the apartments under the company management are still below market rate. Palo Alto is not the only city considering to pass such an emergency ordinance to protect lowincome tenants from paying high rent increases. Other cities such as Menlo Park and Los Angeles already passed similar ordinances to delay no-fault evictions until the end of the year. As of Nov. 21, City Council has not passed the emergency ordinance to prevent no-fault evictions.
Science & Tech
SLOAN WUTTKE/THE CAMPANILE
Schoology Hacking
Unsanctioned Schoology comments elicit strong reactions. PAGE C7