PALO ALTO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT PALO ALTO HIGH SCHOOL 50 EMBARCADERO RD. PALO ALTO, CA 94301 NON-PROFIT ORG U.S. POSTAGE
PAI D PALO ALTO PERMIT #44
The Campanile
Vol. XCVIII, No. 5
Palo Alto High School • 50 Embarcadero Road, Palo Alto, CA 94301 • www.palycampanile.org
Board considers renaming PAUSD school Community raises concern over Jordan Middle School’s namesake’s ties to eugenics CLAIRE DENNIS
NEWS AND OPINION EDITOR
A
recent petition created by a Palo Alto community member advocates for the renaming of David Starr Jordan Middle School because of the namesake’s support of eugenics, which is the belief that society can be improved by selective breeding. Lars Johnsson, a Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) parent, hopes to acquire 500 signatures in order to persuade the PAUSD Board of Education to appoint a “citizen advisory board.” The board would deliberate and offer recommendations for a new school name. Discussion of the petition has been added to the Board agenda for the January 2016 meeting. Jordan Middle School is named after the first president of Stanford University, David Starr Jordan, whose tenure at the university lasted for 22 years. Jordan was an ardent advocate for in eugenics, arguing for the superiority of certain races in his 1901 novel,“The Blood of the Nation.” “[David Starr Jordan] was one of the most vocal and influential leaders of the movement,” Johnsson said. “This is not the handiwork of a casual bystander. This is the crowning achievement of a lifelong obsession.” Thus, petition supporters do not believe that David Starr Jordan’s legacy represents the values of PAUSD or the Palo Alto community. Teachers, parents, alumni and community members have offered alternative namesakes, such as David Downs, a long-serving industrial technology teacher at Jordan Middle School, and Lucie Stern, an influential Palo Alto community leader. “By choosing to name district schools after particular individuals, the district is affirmatively endorsing
Friday, December 11, 2015
Live webinar outlines new district goals MAGGIE ROSENTHAL
SENIOR STAFF WRITER
I
n his first ever public webinar, Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) Superintendent Max McGee discussed the District’s goals for the coming year and the progress made in 2015 through a live video stream that was available online. According to McGee, one of the District’s main goals for 2016 is the implementation of suggestions from the Minority Achievement and Talent Development Advisory Team.
JORDAN SCHILLING/THE CAMPANILE
COURTESY OF STANFORD UNIVERSITY
Left: David Starr Jordan, a former Stanford president and eugenics advocate. Right: Jordan Middle School, named after Jordan.
such people as leaders worthy of this honor,” Christina Schmidt, chairperson of the Special Education Local Plan Area 1 Community Advisory Committee said in a statement endorsing the petition. “We want our children to associate their schools with leaders who reflect positive civic values, inclusion and equity.” Some community members, however, see the goal of this petition as an attempt to rewrite or “whitewash” history. “[ Jordan] was involved in the peace movement, was an early environmentalist and was the first president of Stanford — all very important things,” Jordan math and science teacher Robin Levy said. “We have to view a person’s beliefs in conjunction with the times during which he or she lived. I’d really like to see this controversy used as a teachable moment in our classrooms.” Johnsson decided to start the petition after his son, a seventh grader at Jordan Middle School, wrote a book report about David Starr Jordan’s legacy. After learning of Jordan’s involvement with eugenics, Johnsson
began contacting PAUSD officials to learn of the process to rename the school. According to PAUSD Superintendent Max McGee, the decision to rename a school remains under School Board authority, not that of school administration, and operates in conjunction with a citizen advisory board.
By choosing to name district schools after particular individuals, the district is affirmatively endorsing such people as leaders worthy of this honor.
Christina Schmidt Committee Chairperson “The Board encourages community participation in selecting names,” according to a Board policy. “A citizen advisory committee may be appointed to review name suggestions and submit recommendations for the Board’s consideration.” The petition additionally cites several other schools that have undergone recent name changes. For
example, opponents of the name of Robert E. Lee Elementary School in Long Beach encouraged the local school district to establish a community advisory board to evaluate the use of confederate references. No conclusion has been made of the name change of the school so far. The recent publicity surrounding the name changes of various schools may have contributed to the timing of the petition. “The fact that both Princeton [University] and Amherst College are having or recently had similar conversations has made national news,” McGee said. “Princeton is currently considering renaming their Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs.” Supporters hope that this movement will translate to a potential name change for Terman Middle School, which named after eugenicist, Lewis Terman. “There are several logistical challenges and some expenses,” McGee said. “We will be researching those. My sense is that they are not insurmountable obstacles.”
Goals McGee mentioned include an ownership of personalized learning, as well as enrollment management. “[The Minority Achievement and Talent Development Advisory Team,] of course, wanted to work with one of the historical challenges we’ve had in this district, and that’s closing the achievement gap,” McGee said in the webinar. “But even more than that, we want to make sure that every student’s talents and potential are developed to their maxima or in the words of our mission statement, [which is] to empower every child to reach his or her fullest intellectual, social and creative potential.” McGee went on to describe the progress the team has made so far. “This committee worked throughout the year to identify problems and then develop solutions,” McGee said. “So at this point, we are in the implementation phase.” A major recommendation that is being taken into account is the addition of parent liaisons to A3
WEBINAR
City Council to reform old Challenge Success survey data released groundwater usage policies Results show a large percentage of students lack full physical health Stricter dewatering regulations put in place SAMUEL YUN
STAFF WRITER
I
n response to recent community complaints regarding the treatment of groundwater pumped beneath Palo Alto homes, the City Council’s Policy and Services Committee endorsed a list of shortterm reforms for dewatering and basement construction practices on Dec. 1. According to the Policies and Services Committee Staff Report, such changes outlined require contractors to “mitigate the impacts of dewatering; explore new fees to capture the value of discharged water; find new uses for the water being pumped out; and pursue a long-term study focusing on best practices for groundwater.” Dewatering has been a problem in recent years due to the increasing number of families looking to rebuild their homes. Since the city does not account for basements in calculating the weight of a home, building underground has been a common way to increase the property value of a home. Palo Alto has approved 14 dewatering projects in 2015, according to the annual Public Works Department report. This shows a sharp increase in the past decade in which the
city averaged 5 to 10 permits a year, according to another report released in 2008. Currently, water that is displaced from homes that are built near shallow groundwater (typically located near the San Francisco Bay), is being flushed into storm drains to waste. According to the City’s consulting engineers, every basement construction results in a loss of around 8 to 10 million gallons of water. The main concern of citizens in Palo Alto is that the policy sends the wrong message about the value of water, especially in the midst of the 5-year drought California is currently experiencing. Most of these concerned people are part of a new group called “Save Palo Alto’s Groundwater” and requested for more studies about the impact of basement construction on Palo Alto’s water supply, neighboring homes and trees. In November, the group submitted a petition with around 200 signatures calling for the city to ban the pumping of groundwater until more laws are set to preserve the resource. The petition states that “water is too precious a resource to be wasted, and current city policies regarding dewatering do not take into account the possible need of this water to WATER POLICIES
A3
JEREMY FU/THE CAMPANILE
JEREMY FU
ONLINE EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
KATE DEANDRE
STAFF WRITER
P
alo Alto High School’s Challenge Success team is sharing findings from the Stanford Survey of Adolescent School Experiences with students and parents in order to facilitate discussion of current administrative policies as a means of highlighting areas wherein the school can improve. Earlier in the semester, students took the Challenge Success survey to measure and provide information on students’ perspectives on homework, extracurricular activities, sleep, physical health, stress, parental expectations, academic engagement, academic integrity and teacher support.
“The goal was to share out the information that was collected through the survey with the students, clarify questions and also start the discussion about what conclusions we can draw and what we should do as we move forward,” School Climate Teacher on Special Assignment Eric Bloom said. The meetings were advertised on InFocus and Schoology; however, the first meeting on Dec. 1 only had an attendance of three students. Principal Kim Diorio saw the meeting as an opportunity to encourage students to share their experiences to better the school’s policies. As a result of the low turnout, the administration hosted a second meeting on Dec. 8, to try to encourage more students to take part in the important discussion of finding solutions to the issues prevalent at Paly.
“It is a second dip at the well [or a second chance for students to show up], because it is not easy for people to find out about the event, so not that many kids came,” Bloom said. “It is hard to get student opinion, because students are busy during the day.” Among the findings are statistics on student engagement. The survey found that 41 percent of students “do school,” or often work hard, but rarely find their schoolwork interesting, fun or valuable. Out of the entire school, only 18 percent of the students reported “full engagement.” English teacher Erin Angell said that she sees greater student involvement in her Social Justice Pathway classes than in her traditional English classes. CHALLENGE SUCCESS
A3
INSIDE
N e w s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A 1- A 5 O p i n i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A 6 -A 8 Lifestyle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B1, B3, B7, B8 Fashion...............................................B2 Spotlight............................B4-B5 Entertainment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B6 S p o r t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C 1- C 8
NEWS
C
California will no longer require prescriptions for birth control. PAGE A4
Check us out at www.palycampanile.org
COURTESY OF THE HUFFINGTON POST
Revised Birth Control Laws
LIFESTYLE
COURTESY OF TECHINSIDER
Anonymous vs. ISIS
Hacktivists look to take down a growing world terrorist organization. PAGE B1
COURTESY OF DEMOCRACY NOW
COURTESY OF JOHNNY ROHRBACH
SPOTLIGHT
SPORTS
Racial tensions at universities cause protests surrounding free speech. PAGE B4-B5
Surfing, commonly thought of as a leisure sport, is actually a rigorous pursuit.
Free Speech Debate
Stereotypes of Surfing PAGE C1