PALO ALTO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT PALO ALTO HIGH SCHOOL 50 EMBARCADERO RD. PALO ALTO, CA 94301 NON-PROFIT ORG U.S. POSTAGE
PAI D PALO ALTO PERMIT #44
The Campanile
Vol. C, No. 2
Palo Alto High School 50 Embarcadero Road Palo Alto, CA 94301
FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2017
www.thecampanile.org
McGee resigns as PAUSD superintendent Title IX misconduct Board publishes results of investigation
Karen Hendricks announced as interim superintendent following McGee's departure
By Vivian Feng & Shannon Zhao Lifestyle Editor & Board Correspondent
A
NOAH BAUM/THE CAMPANILE
Superintendent Max McGee looks on as School Board member Terry Godfrey reads his resignation letter at the Board meeting on Sept. 26.
By Paarth Sharma & Shannon Zhao
P
Managing Editor & Board Correspondent
alo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) Superintendent Max McGee has resigned and will be replaced by Karen Hendricks, the current assistant superintendent of Human Resources, on an interim basis. McGee’s resignation is effective today, marking the end of a portion of PAUSD history that included deep controversies over handling of sexual assault cases and a budget crisis, as well as notable accomplishments, such as the Minority Achievement and Talent Development program, the Advanced Authentic Research (AAR) program and full-day kindergarten. McGee had previously announced that he would retire at the end of the 2017-18 school year, amid pressure and calls for
his resignation. However, last Tuesday he announced that he would resign immediately. The Board agreed to the terms of McGee’s separation in a unanimous vote on Tuesday. The resignation agreement was posted online by the District on Wednesday morning. McGee will continue to receive District-paid health benefits and six months’ pay equal to about $150,000 from the District. McGee will return back to the District the Palo Alto residence he purchased with the $1.5 million interest-free loan given by the District. “We thank Dr. McGee for his years of hard work and for his many contributions to our district,” Board President Terry Godfrey said at a Board meeting on Tuesday. “His optimism, his vision and vibrancy along with the innovative programs and practices he brought to our district will be his lasting legacy.” Additionally, the Board an-
nounced that the search for a new permanent superintendent would begin immediately. In the meantime, according to an announcement made by Godfrey after a closed-door Board session late Thursday night, Hendricks will lead the district until June 30, 2018. Hendricks joined PAUSD in July and had been the interim superintendent at the Carmel Unified School District previously. She had 26 years of experience in public education, including many years as a classroom teacher. She replaced long-time Human Resources head Scott Bowers and this fall, led the PAUSD “Chow Down,” a welcome-back staff meeting. McGee expressed his desire to support the District’s next superintendent. His tenure was marked by both accomplishment and controversy. Most recently, the District failed to reopen negotiations with the teachers’ union about teacher
salaries and will need to pay up to $6 million that was not covered by the budget. McGee also faced criticism over the handling of sexual assault allegations and the elimination of zero period at Gunn High School. Several members of the audience thanked McGee for his work, for his integrity and for taking responsibility for the District's recent problems. During his first year in office, he launched a team of parents, students and staff who worked to develop a better understanding of the issues faced by historically underrepresented students. Many implementations, such as expanding opportunities for low-income families, were made as a result of this report. Under McGee’s leadership, the previously small-scale, eighthperiod course AAR has been developed into an award-winning program with around 200 partici-
McGee A3
t least two dozen Palo Alto High School teachers and staff rallied behind Principal Kim Diorio at a special school board meeting last Friday that had been called to review a highly critical third-party investigation of the school’s and the District’s response to an alleged sexual assault case at Paly in October last year. However, just four days afterwards, at Tuesday’s regular School Board meeting, parents and community members criticized Diorio, even going as far as to call for her to be fired for the way she handled the case. In emails sent to The Campanile and other Paly publications, a community member, Kathy Jordan, wrote, “We see one shortcut after another. We see our students' safety and rights being shortchanged and the law as well continually throughout this Cozen report and allegedly through these officials' actions.” The Cozen report Jordan referred to was prepared by the law firm Cozen O’Connor and presented to the Board of Education. It stated that the Palo Alto Unified School District’s response to the event last fall did not “comport with key aspects of Title IX, state law, and Board policy and the District’s administrative regulations.” In the report, the District was credited for its prompt response to reports of Title IX misconduct, but criticized for not keeping sufficient records of the incident. Moreover, the report said “a common practice [for staff and administrators] was to communicate by telephone or text message to avoid creating documentation that could potentially be publicly released.” The report refers to the case of a 14-year-old freshman female who reported being forced into a sexual act by a male Paly student
in a bathroom on campus. The incident was subsequently determined to be consensual. The lawyers presenting the report released the names of the four Paly administrators and two district leaders involved in handling the case: Diorio; Paly Assistant Principals Vicki Kim, Jerry Berkson and Kathie Laurence; Superintendent Max McGee and former district Title IX coordinator Holly Wade. The 60-page report brought some information to light for the first time. Among other details reported, the lawyers concluded that a special Title IX attorney hired by the district may have given incorrect advice to Kim and Wade. The report said Kim asked others multiple times if the school should provide the alleged victim with the opportunity to fill out a Uniform Complaint Procedure (UCP) form. Wade told the OCR investigators that the district’s Title IX attorney said it was not necessary.
At Tuesday's School Board meeting, parents and community member criticized Diorio. According to the lawyers, such instructions would violate board policy, state law and the federal Title IX law. The OCR lawyers also said a "longstanding" practice of not maintaining proper documentation of reported incidents has continued while Diorio has been an administrator at Paly. While McGee acknowledged the possible need for a UCP filing to Wade, he did not pursue this request further, according to the report. However, the report did note that school and district administrators were not given detailed Title IX training until May 2016, after this case became public. As a
Title IX A3
Betsy DeVos bill protects accused Fiery Arts sale supports art program New Title IX term hinders victim justification, discourages assault reports By Leyton Ho & Ujwal Srivastava
W
Staff Writers
ith one swoop of the pen, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos rescinded key parts of the Obamaera Title IX standards that deal with how schools are required to handle sexual assault allegations. The department’s official statement is that the old rules “lacked basic elements of fairness,” which follows the trend of complaints that the law was too harsh on the
accused, denying them due process of law. This argument hinges on the controversial rule stating that the evidence incriminating an individual in campus assault cases only had to be “a preponderance of evidence," meaning more likely than not, or a greater than a 50 percent chance. With DeVos’ move, colleges can now opt to use the “beyond a reasonable doubt” or “clear and convincing” method, which makes it harder for the victim to prove assault. Supporters of the Title IX reg-
ulations claim that with this statement, vital protections for victims may be lost and victims may feel more apprehensive to report cases. Fatima Goss Graves, President of the National Women’s Law Center, issued a statement saying that the new ruling will “discourage students from reporting assaults, create uncertainty for schools on how to follow the law and make campuses less safe.” The guidelines have been replaced with a question-and-an-
MAYA HOMAN/THE CAMPANILE
See A3 for full article
Betsy DeVos A3
Prevention month entails awareness Benatar fund grants new deck Admin taking steps to initiate conversation about mental health By Khadija Abid & Johnny Loftus
S
Staff Writers
eptember is Suicide Prevention Month, a time when mental health advocates, psychologists and organizations unite to bring awareness to this prominent issue. Survivors and allies contribute to this cause by helping decrease the stigma surrounding suicide and mental health issues by sharing stories and experiences, and emphasizing the idea that mental health assistance is always available. “Suicide is a very complicated act,” said Elizabeth Spector, Mental Health and Wellness Coordinator at Palo Alto High School. “Sometimes, these disorders are not identified or noticed; in other cases, a person with a disorder will show obvious symptoms or signs.
INSIDE
One thing is certain: there are treatments that can help.” Particularly, Paly is dedicated to addressing the dangers of mental health and aims to provide guidance and support for students experiencing hardships.
Events include SOS Gratitude Cards, SOS Trusted Adult Activity as well as the popular therapy dogs visits located near the quad every Wednesday. In the past, both Paly and Gunn High School communities have experienced several devastating losses from suicide over the past few years, and consider suicide awareness a major prior-
ity, according to Jerry Berkson, Assistant Principal of Operations at Paly. “Reducing stigma, normalizing help-seeking, reducing barriers to treatment, improving visibility and improving access to support are just a few goals of the Wellness Center and Paly community as a whole,” Spector said. Paly is currently taking multiple steps to help combat the prevalence of mental health disorders. This month, the Wellness Center, a valuable resource that aims to connect students with the appropriate support, is partnering with Sources of Strength (SOS) and Associated Student Body (ASB) to host events intended to improve mental health and increase a sense of community at Paly. Events include SOS Gratitude Cards, SOS Trusted Adult Activ-
Prevention Month A3
Lifestyle
$75,000 donation will fund a newly-designed senior space By Noah Baum
News & Opinion Editor
T
he Emily Benatar Foundation, an organization dedicated to the late Palo Alto High School (Paly) alumna Emily Benatar, is granting Paly a $75,000 donation to rebuild the senior deck. The donation entirely funds the construction of a new senior deck that Gracie Cain, former Paly student and friend of Benatar, designed. Cain majored in landscape design at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo. The proposed deck is roseshaped with overlapping pentagons composing the foundation. The shape is inspired by a memory of Emily Benatar as a child, according to her mother, Lisa Benatar. When pregnant with her third child, Lisa Benatar was tak-
Lifestyle
en aback by the unkempt nature of the exterior of her midwife’s house. “Emily looked at the house and said, ‘Hey Mommy, look at that beautiful rose,’” Lisa Benatar said. “In the middle of all the ivy, there was this one scraggly stick of a rose bush with one white rose on it.”
The proposed deck is rose-shaped with overlapping pentagons composing the foundation. According to Lisa Benatar, this story perfectly captured her daughter’s ability to see the positive side of any situation. Lisa Benatar also believes the deck will honor her eldest daughter in its
Spotlight
ability to bring together different groups of people — much as Emily had done. Benatar graduated from Paly in 2011 and was a freshman at Washington University in St. Louis, when she was diagnosed with bacterial meningitis in April 2012 and passed away three weeks later in the hospital. Current vaccines cover the strain Benatar contracted, serogroup B meningococcal disease, but they did not at the time, according to the National Meningitis Association. The Paly senior deck has been in poor shape and in need of several repairs for the past 10 years, and the new senior deck aims to create a “new gathering place for students to congregate and enjoy for years to come,” according to the School Board’s agenda for the Tuesday, Sept. 26 Board meeting.
Senior Deck A3
Sports
the edition
News. . . . . . . . . A1-A4 Opinion. . . . . . . A5-A7 Editorials. . . . . . . . . A8 Lifestyle. . . . . B1-B3, B6 Spotlight. . . . . . . . B4-B5 Science & Tech. . . B7-B8 Sports. . . . C1-C3, C6-C8 Sports Spread. . . . . C4-C5
RENEE HOH/THE CAMPANILE
Rise of a Juuling trend
A portable, flavored alternative to the traditional cigarette. PAGE B1
JOHNNY LOFTUS/THE CAMPANILE
A not-so-guilty pleasure
The mediative practice in the eyes of ASMR enthusiasts. PAGE B3
RENEE HOH/THE CAMPANILE
Exploring mental health
An inside look into five disorders in need of accurate recognition. PAGE B4-B5
PHOTO BY ELVERT BARNES/CC BY-SA 2.0
Spikeball Club
Competitive and versatile, spikeball debuts at Paly. PAGE C6