Urban Hub Integral UrbanHub
Smart Sustainable Thriveable Cities Paul van Schaik integralMENTORS
1
Urban Hub Smart Sustainable Thriveable Cities Integral UrbanHub
1
Paul van Schaik integralMENTORS
A series of graphics from integralMENTORS integral UrbanHub work on Thriveable Cities presentations.
Copyright © Paul van Schaik : August 2016 ISBN-13: 978-1537234793 ISBN-10: 1537234797X
When Did You Feel Most Alive in an Urban Habitat? Me
My Behaviour
My Intention
What made this experience come alive for you and made it memorable?
Urban Culture
Urban Activity
My context
What made this activity come alive for you and made it memorable?
Š integralMENTORS
Preface This book is one in a series of presentations for the use of Integral theory or an Integral metaframework in understanding cities and urban design. Although each can stand alone, taken together they give a more rounded appreciation of how this broader framework can help in the analysis and design of thriveable urban environments. Key to an Integral approach to urban design is the notion that although other aspects of urban life are important, people, as individuals and communities, are the primary ‘purpose’ for making cities thriveable. All other aspects (technology, transport & infrastructure, health, education, sustainability, economic development, etc.) although playing a major part, are secondary. This work shows the slides from a dynamic deck that accompany a presentation on Thriveable Smart Sustainable Cities. The history of the co-evolution of cities, worldviews and technology is presented in an integral framework.
This volume is part of an ongoing series of guides for integrally informed practitioners.
Š integralMENTORS
Content Context Evolving Cities Integral Mapping Capitals Integral Theory Urban Fractals Tools Projects Books Annex SDG
Introduction
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Context
© integralMENTORS
Why Stratified Leadership, Integral Methodological Pluralism and Integral Hierarchy (Holarchy) Subjects do not perceive worlds but enact them. Different states of subjects bring forth different worlds. For AQAL, this means that a subject might be at a particular wave of consciousness, in a particular stream of consciousness, in a particular state of consciousness, in one quadrant or another. That means that the phenomena brought forth by various types of human inquiry will be different depending on the quadrants, levels, lines, states, and types of the subjects bringing forth the phenomena. A subject at one wave of consciousness will not enact and bring forth the same worldspace as a subject at another wave; and similarly with quadrants, streams, states, and types (as we will see in more detail).
Š integralMENTORS
The Quadrants of Understanding Me
My context
© integralMENTORS
Evolving Cities
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Evolving Cities
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality Integral/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality Integral/3D Holistic
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality Integral/3D Holistic
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Evolving Cities Survival Magical/Tribal Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality Integral/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Medieval Cities
Power-Centric Ancient Medieval City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Modern Cities
Rational-Centric 19/20th Century Bureaucratic Planned Utopian City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Modern Cities
‘unplanned’ Econo-Centric Early to Late Modern City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Smart Cities
Techno-Centric Modern Smart City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Sustainable Cities Ecological & EnvironmentalCentric Green Utopian Ecopolis Sustainable City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Holistic Cities
Systems-Centric [Master Code]
SDI Integral Holistic City
Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities
People-Centric IMP Integral Morphogenic Generative Snippable ThriveAble City Mythic/Power Mythic/One Truth Rational/Drive Pluralistic/Equality SDi/3D Holistic Integral/ThriveAble
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities Meaning & Purpose transcended & included Integral/ThriveAble Holistic Pluralistic/Sustainable Rational/Drive Mythic/One Truth
Power
Mythic/Power each more complex stage: - enfolds - transcends [the worst] - includes [the best] of the previous stages
The content of the previous becomes the context of the next Š integralMENTORS
Capacities - Competences - Behaviour
Culture - worldviews
Creations - systems - infrastructure
Collective Exterior- Interobjective
Individual Exterior - Objective
Consciousness - intention - mindsets
Collective Interior - Intersubjective
Individual Interior- Subjective
Mapping Interventions – INTEGRAL Cities
© integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing The act whereby a ‘holon’ meshes or fits with the selection pressures of all four quadrants. In order to tetra-mesh, each holon must to some degree be able to register its own exterior accurately enough (truth), its own interior accurately enough (truthfulness), understand its cultural milieu (mutual understanding)’ and fit within its social system (functional fit) – meaning that all four selection pressures must be dealt with adequately in order for a holon to evolve.
Self & Consciousness
Brain & Organism
Intentional
Behavioural
Culture & Worldview
Systems & Environment
Cultural
Social
© integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing Rio de Janeiro
Olympic preparations
for Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) 2014
Waste Disposal systems
current system choices of systems available
Individuals beliefs/mindset on Waste Disposal
individuals Centre of Gravity depending on CoG possible obstacles to change
Individuals Behaviour to Waste Disposal current ways of use obstacles to use/change
Communities Cultural views or Mindset on Waste Disposal communities Dominant Mode of Discourse possible communication levels
Š integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing Rio de Janeiro
Olympic preparations
for Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) 2014
Waste Disposal systems – in place and proposed
Š integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing Rio de Janeiro
Olympic preparations
for Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) 2014
Consciousness - intention - mindsets
Capacities - Competences - Behaviour
Waste Disposal systems – in place and proposed Culture - worldviews
Context
Creations - systems - infrastructure Š integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing Rio de Janeiro
Olympic preparations
for Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) 2014
Consciousness - intention - mindsets
Capacities - Competences - Behaviour
Persons Behaviour to Waste Disposal
Cultural views on Waste Disposal
Waste Disposal systems – in place and proposed
Culture - worldviews
Context
Creations - systems - infrastructure Š integralMENTORS
Tetra-meshing Rio de Janeiro
Olympic preparations
for Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) 2014
Consciousness - intention - mindsets
Capacities - Competences - Behaviour
Persons Behaviour to Waste Disposal
Persons beliefs/mindset on Waste Disposal
Cultural views on Waste Disposal
Waste Disposal systems – in place and proposed
Culture - worldviews
Context
Creations - systems - infrastructure Š integralMENTORS
Transformation & Tetra-meshing
© integralMENTORS
Morpho-Generative and Snippable Transformation Consciousness - intention - mindsets
Morphic Pull (Meta-’Purpose’)
Capacities - Competences - Behaviour
Time
Contextual & creative inputs from all at each step
Step 3
Culture - worldviews
Step 2 Step 1
Creations - systems - infrastructure © integralMENTORS
Zones
Zone #1 : States of individual consciousness Zone #2 : Stage-Structure of individual development Zone #3 : States of ‘cultural’ development Zone #4 : State-Structure communal development Zone #5 : States of individual communication Zone #6 : State-Structure of individual control Zone #7 : State of communal communication Zone #8 : State-Structure of governance/systems
surface structure - the feel deep structure – the look surface structure - the feel deep structure – the look surface structure – the ‘software deep structure – the hardware’ surface structure – the ‘software’ deep structure – the hardware’ © integralMENTORS
Altitude, Stages & Lines of Development
© integralMENTORS
Understanding Stages & Lines of Development Spiritual Moral Cognitive Self-identity Values
Dominant Mode of Discourse
Kosmic Address
Myth of the Given
Š integralMENTORS
Lines of Development Some major lines of Development
Selman, Perry
Context What is my cultural dominant mode of discourse What is my societal Systems Stage (agricultural, industrial, informational, ‌)
Š integralMENTORS
Altitude, Stages & Lines of Development
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions or Means Me
What did you try to change or transform in yourself, others, a human system or a culture? How did you try to change or transform yourself, others, a human system or a culture?
My Behaviour
My Intention
Did your intervention succeed or fail? How do you know? Are you satisfied with the outcome?
Urban Activity
Urban Culture
My context
If not, what would you do next?
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub integral Mapping
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SMART Cities Techno-Centred Smart Cities tend to use technical solutions to address first order change. First order change requires support for maintaining, adjusting or improving the status quo. (Think more data banks, driverless cars, faster Wi-Fi.)
Smart Cities World Model
Buckminster Fuller
Systems theory & Cybernetics Complexity Science Platforms for Change Stafford Beer
Systems Dynamics Urban Dynamics Jay Forrester
A smart city is an urban development vision to integrate multiple information and communication technology(ICT) solutions in a secure fashion to manage a city’s assets – the city’s assets include, but not limited to, local departments information systems, schools, libraries, transportation systems, hospitals, power plants, water supply networks, waste management, law enforcement, and other community services. The goal of building a smart city is to improve quality of life by using technology to improve the efficiency of services and meet residents’ needs. ICT allows city officials to interact directly with the community and the city infrastructure and to monitor what is happening in the city, how the city is evolving, and how to enable a better quality of life. Through the use of sensors integrated with real-time monitoring systems, data are collected from citizens and devices - then processed and analyzed. The information and knowledge gathered are keys to tackling inefficiency © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SMART Cities Techno-Centred Smart Cities tend to use technical solutions to address first order change. First order change requires support for maintaining, adjusting or improving the status quo. (Think more data banks, driverless cars, faster Wi-Fi.)
Smart Cities World Model
Buckminster Fuller
Systems theory & Cybernetics Complexity Science Platforms for Change Stafford Beer
Systems Dynamics Urban Dynamics Jay Forrester
A smart city is an urban development vision to integrate multiple information and communication technology(ICT) solutions in a secure fashion to manage a city’s assets – the city’s assets include, but not limited to, local departments information systems, schools, libraries, transportation systems, hospitals, power plants, water supply networks, waste management, law enforcement, and other community services. The goal of building a smart city is to improve quality of life by using technology to improve the efficiency of services and meet residents’ needs. ICT allows city officials to interact directly with the community and the city infrastructure and to monitor what is happening in the city, how the city is evolving, and how to enable a better quality of life. Through the use of sensors integrated with real-time monitoring systems, data are collected from citizens and devices - then processed and analyzed. The information and knowledge gathered are keys to tackling inefficiency © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SUSTAINABLE Cities Eco/Environ-Centred Sustainable City, or eco-city (also "ecocity") is a city designed with consideration of environmental impact, inhabited by people dedicated to minimization of required inputs of energy, water and food, and waste output of heat, air pollution - CO2, methane, and water pollution - wikipedia Resilient Cities tend to use adaptive solutions that address mid-order change. Such change addresses systemic adaptations, mitigations and restorations. (Think urban food security, reduction of greenhouse gases, daylighting streams.) Human Hive
U Process
Death & Life of Great American Cities Jane Jacobs
The Nature of Order Pattern Language
Sustainable cities Resilient cities/ EcoCity/Ecopolis
Christopher Alexander
Holistic Management
Collaborative Enquiry Appreciative Enquiry
Carbon reduction
SenseMaker
David Snowden
Ethno-Architecture
“A Resilient City is one that has developed capacities to help absorb future shocks and stresses to its social, economic, and technical systems and infrastructures so as to still be able to maintain essentially the same functions, structures, systems, and identity.” Ecopolis/EcoCity is the design for a
regenerative city, rethinking the ways we live and get around, our sense of place, nature and the changing realities of climate, social inequities and our imported sources of food, energy and waste in a growing age of uncertainty. © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SUSTAINABLE Cities Eco/Environ-Centred Sustainable City, or eco-city (also "ecocity") is a city designed with consideration of environmental impact, inhabited by people dedicated to minimization of required inputs of energy, water and food, and waste output of heat, air pollution - CO2, methane, and water pollution - wikipedia Resilient Cities tend to use adaptive solutions that address mid-order change. Such change addresses systemic adaptations, mitigations and restorations. (Think urban food security, reduction of greenhouse gases, daylighting streams.) Human Hive
U Process
Death & Life of Great American Cities Jane Jacobs
The Nature of Order Pattern Language
Sustainable cities Resilient cities/ EcoCity/Ecopolis
Christopher Alexander
Holistic Management
Collaborative Enquiry Appreciative Enquiry
Carbon reduction
SenseMaker
David Snowden
Ethno-Architecture
“A Resilient City is one that has developed capacities to help absorb future shocks and stresses to its social, economic, and technical systems and infrastructures so as to still be able to maintain essentially the same functions, structures, systems, and identity.” Ecopolis/EcoCity is the design for a
regenerative city, rethinking the ways we live and get around, our sense of place, nature and the changing realities of climate, social inequities and our imported sources of food, energy and waste in a growing age of uncertainty. © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SDi-Integral Cities System-Centred
[Master Code based]
Spiral Dynamics
Rational empirical sciences
Integral City (SDi) Marilyn Hamilton
Collaborative Enquiry Appreciative Enquiry
Sustainable/ Resilient cities Smart Cities Cradle to Cradle Biomimicry Systems theory & Cybernetics
SDi-Integral Cities seek to generate solutions that meet second-order change. These changes address a greater order of magnitude of problems than has ever been encountered before. This means that city leaders open up new mindsets, redefine city paradigms, and emerge new potentials for living systems not yet dreamed or tried. (Think cities as Gaia’s Reflective Organs, city as human hive, Planet of Cities as collective intelligence network.) Integral City leaders use both Smart and Resilient solutions – in their appropriate contexts. In fact Generative Change approaches enable Integral City thinking to emerge – because they include and build on both Smart and Resilient Solutions – and step into a zone where they can act effectively to align first order technical problems with Smart City solutions and mid-order adaptive problems with Resilient City Solutions But Integral City leaders go beyond merely aligning technical and adaptive solutions and seek to discover for their cities how to align the very source of City Wellbeing, with City Purpose, Collective Vision and Strategies for thriving. The Human Hive – Marilyn Hamilton © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – SDi-Integral Cities System-Centred
[Master Code based]
Spiral Dynamics
Rational empirical sciences
Integral City (SDi) Marilyn Hamilton
Collaborative Enquiry Appreciative Enquiry
Sustainable/ Resilient cities Smart Cities Cradle to Cradle Biomimicry Systems theory & Cybernetics
SDi-Integral Cities seek to generate solutions that meet second-order change. These changes address a greater order of magnitude of problems than has ever been encountered before. This means that city leaders open up new mindsets, redefine city paradigms, and emerge new potentials for living systems not yet dreamed or tried. (Think cities as Gaia’s Reflective Organs, city as human hive, Planet of Cities as collective intelligence network.) Integral City leaders use both Smart and Resilient solutions – in their appropriate contexts. In fact Generative Change approaches enable Integral City thinking to emerge – because they include and build on both Smart and Resilient Solutions – and step into a zone where they can act effectively to align first order technical problems with Smart City solutions and mid-order adaptive problems with Resilient City Solutions But Integral City leaders go beyond merely aligning technical and adaptive solutions and seek to discover for their cities how to align the very source of City Wellbeing, with City Purpose, Collective Vision and Strategies for thriving. The Human Hive – Marilyn Hamilton © integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – THRIVEABLE Cities People-Centred
Spiral Dynamics
Building Thriveable, Integral Cities seek to generate solutions that meet second & third order change.
Rational empirical sciences
LeaderView & CultureView
[includes all in the previous 3 slides]
IMP Integral - morphogenic, - generative and - snippable.
Social Learning Theory
Constructive-Developmental Theory (Kegan) Constructive Developmental Framework - Otto Laske Integral City Marilyn Hamilton Collaborative Enquiry Appreciative Enquiry
Systems theory & Cybernetics
The Nature of Order Pattern Language
Complexity Science
Chris Alexander
Cradle to Cradle
Death & Life of Great American Cities
Platforms for Change
Jane Jacobs
Stafford Beer
SenseMaker
Systems Dynamics Urban Dynamics
David Snowden
Jay Forrester
Ethno-Architecture
Sustainable Resilient Cities EcoCity/Ecopolis Smart Cities
Integral Methodological Pluralism (IMP) A set of social practices that corresponds with AQAL metatheory. IMP is paradigmatic in that it includes the most time-honoured methodologies, and meta-paradigmatic in that it weaves them together by way of three integrative principles: non-exclusion, unfoldment, and enactment.
World Model
Buckminster Fuller
Holistic Manage Allan Savory
Global Action Network Net
King 4
Š integralMENTORS
Integral Methodological Pluralism Psychological Disciplines Closing the Leadership & Values Gap
Policy & Strategy Disciplines
Classic Definitions Of Success & Thriving
Closing the Organizational & Finance Gap
Closing the Sustainability Gap
“Soft” Systems Disciplines
“Hard” Systems Disciplines
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
© integralMENTORS
Multi-Capitals
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Capitals
© integralMENTORS
NC
Natural Capital
IfC
MC
Human Capital
RC
Relationship Capital
SC
Social Capital
Infrastructure Capital
IC
Intellectual Capital
Manufactured Capital
KC
Knowledge Capital
SpC Spiritual Capital
HC
Anthrocapitals
Ten Capitals
FC
Financial Capital
Š integralMENTORS
Spiritual Capital SpC
© integralMENTORS
Natural Capital NC
© integralMENTORS
Human Capital HC
© integralMENTORS
Relationship Capital RC
© integralMENTORS
Social Capital SC
© integralMENTORS
Intellectual Capital IC
© integralMENTORS
Knowledge Capital IC
© integralMENTORS
Manufacturing Capital MC
© integralMENTORS
Infrastructure Capital IfC
© integralMENTORS
Financial Capital FC
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities “I” Subjective realities; - self and consciousness, states of mind, psychological development, mental models/ constructs, emotions, state of self, etc.
“It” Objective realities; - brain and organism, visible biological features, degree of activation of the various bodily systems, etc.
Map: Interventions Theories Ideas To: Quadrants Stages Zones# Lines Tetra-mesh: Where possible what is mapped in each Quadrant or Stage Determine: What is missing
“We” Intersubjective realities; - shared values, world views, webs of culture, communication, relationships, cultural norms and customs, etc.
“Its” Interobjective realities; -. social systems, environmental systems, visible societal structures. economic systems, political systems, etc.
© integralMENTORS
Theory
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Integral Theory
© integralMENTORS
The Quadrants of Understanding
© integralMENTORS
The Quadrants of Understanding
© integralMENTORS
Zones – Thriveable Cities “I” Subjective realities; - self and consciousness, states of mind, psychological development, mental models/ constructs, emotions, state of self, etc.
“It” Objective realities; - brain and organism, visible biological features, degree of activation of the various bodily systems, etc.
Map: Interventions Theories Ideas To: Quadrants Stages Zones# Lines Tetra-mesh: Where possible what is mapped in each Quadrant or Stage Determine: What is missing
“We” Intersubjective realities; - shared values, world views, webs of culture, communication, relationships, cultural norms and customs, etc.
“Its” Interobjective realities; -. social systems, environmental systems, visible societal structures. economic systems, political systems, etc.
© integralMENTORS
The Quadrants of Understanding
© integralMENTORS
Understanding Action Logic Stratified levels of development
Š integralMENTORS
Understanding Action Logic Stratified levels of development
Š integralMENTORS
Understanding Action Logic Stratified levels of development
3.5% 8.5% 14.0% 67.0%
I N T E G R A L
Alchemist
Global Interdependence Integrated Consciousness
Pluralist/ Individualist/ Sensitive self 39.5% 27.5%
Pluralistic Consensus Enterprising Self Conventional Order
7.0% Powerful Self Source - Rooke and Torbert’s 2006 Harvard Business Review article : Seven Transformations of Leadership. From a sample of 1000 leaders in N America & Europe
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
© integralMENTORS
Understanding Action Logic
Pluralist/ Individualist/ Sensitive Self
Alchemist Source - Rooke and Torbert’s 2006 Harvard Business Review article : Seven Transformations of Leadership. From a sample of 1000 leaders in N America & Europe
Š integralMENTORS
Growth in all Quadrants
© integralMENTORS
Tetra-Meshing the Developmental Journey
© integralMENTORS
Nine Intelligences 9 Multiple Intelligences - Howard Gardner
Inter-personal Existential
Spatial
Linguistic
Intra-personal
Logic
Naturalist
Musical Kinesthetic
Š integralMENTORS
Understanding Types 9 Enneagram types
MBRI types
© integralMENTORS
Understanding States Subtle
Casual
GROWING UP Structure-Stage
Gross
Non-Dual
Witness
CLEANING UP
State-Stage WAKING UP
© integralMENTORS
Our Developmental Journey Healthy: different routes and speeds of change
Unhealthy: different routes and blocks to change
Š integralMENTORS
Self/Values Stages of Development
Pluralist/
Alchemist Š integralMENTORS
Evolution of Participation
© integralMENTORS
Stratified Leaders Roles, Approach & Methods
Š integralMENTORS
Stratified Leaders and Quadrants Favoured Opportunist
Individualist/Pluralist
Expert
Diplomat
Strategist
Achiever
Alchemist
Š integralMENTORS
Learning Cycle
© integralMENTORS
Integral Governance Development is Envelopment Concentric spheres of increasing consciousness
Dimensions of AQAL Matrix and Political Scales
The moment-to-moment pressures of experience gives rise to political systems
AQAL MATRIX and Political Scales Major: 1. 2. 3. 4.
internal/external (nature/nurture); also largely Left/Right individual/collective (individual/social holons) transformation/translation (progressive/conservative) Levels, Stages or Altitude
Minor:
5. lines (esp. walk and talk) 6. agency/communion (autonomy/relationship) 7. progression/regression (upward/downward transformation)
8. stages/stations (developmental levels informing UL adult lifeworld)
9. regulator (governing system)
Ken Wilber: Politics, part 3—being an excerpt from the forthcoming trilogy, The Many Faces of Terrorism 2007
Š integralMENTORS
Centre of Gravity
Altitude
Individual - Centre of Gravity
Socio-cultural Dominant Mode of Discourse [Orange]
Turquoise Teal Green Orange Amber Red
Exit Stable Entry
Magenta
© integralMENTORS
Dominant Mode of Discourse Socio-cultural Dominant Mode of Discourse [Orange]
Turquoise Teal Green Orange Amber Red Magenta
© integralMENTORS
Stratified Documentation
© integralMENTORS
Duality
© integralMENTORS
Spiral Learning & Education Magenta
• • • • •
Through imitation and repetition Animistic analogies - fairy-tales, cartoons and animal metaphors Chants, dances, rhythm music, rituals Practical kinesthetics Learning what the Tribe learns is a major driver
2-8 years
Magenta
The relationship with the “teacher” is critical - that person must be a mystical, shamanistic figure
Exit Magenta Red
Enter Red
Learning by modelling is still important - but satisfaction of the embryonic ego will also influence what is learned • • • •
Instant results - pain or punishment No threats - only promises of certain outcomes Hands-on action learning - the opportunity to experience it for themselves What is learned needs to be immediately relevant to the circumstances the individual perceives him/herself to be in
9-12 years
Red
Respect for the “teacher” as a hero figure is important - but the teacher must also show respect back to the blossoming egos
Exit Red
Amber
What pleases (or is immediately relevant) is still central but there is also some desire now to know what the procedures for learning are - and that leads to WHAT should be learned • • •
Acceptance of Truth from the Higher Authority Prescriptive teaching/learning - following set procedures Right/wrong feedback - testing on the learning
Enter Amber 13-17 years
Amber
The work set will be done because it is “the correct thing to do” - but don’t expect imagination in the work or more than is set
Exit Amber
Self-motivation starts to emerge - though learning procedures are still necessary
Enter Orange © integralMENTORS
Spiral Learning & Education Orange
• • • •
Developing future sense with possibilities of multiple outcomes Trial-and-error experiments to achieve anticipated outcomes Opportunities to analyse and improve - particularly via technology Complete self-motivation to achieve the desired future outcome(s)
18+ years
Orange
The “teacher” is now a resource to be used
Exit Orange Green
Enter Green
Broader concerns now start to emerge and there is a need to make sure everybody is getting opportunities • • • •
Bigger picture thinking and emotional responsiveness What is important can be subject to consensus Learning from peers/group learning Personal development/development of self - within the group
18+ years
Green
The “teacher’s” job is to facilitate the development of the group and individuals within the group
Enter Teal
Exit Green Teal
50+
Teal
Exit Teal
60+
Enter Turquoise
© integralMENTORS
Influences on Individuals
© integralMENTORS
Developmental Potential Philosophy
Beliefs
Attitudes
Relationships
Generative
Do for all in a way that best serves all
Organisations are consciously evolving social organisms
We are for each other and the whole
Co-operative Evoking genius Mutually nourishing
Sustainable
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you
Organisations are living systems
We are all in this together
Caring Appreciative High integrity
Compliant
Do unto others in Ideal organisation a way that is fair is a well oiled machine
You scratch my back ……
Respectful Purposeful Honest
Dysfunctional
Do it to others before they do it to you
People are the problem
I will use you
Disrespectful Dishonest Discounting
Toxic
Do others in before they do you in
Might makes right
I will defeat you
Attacking Blaming © integralMENTORS
Spiritual and Emotional Intelligences @ Teal
© integralMENTORS
The Worlds ‘I’ Inhabit (States) - U Theory
© integralMENTORS
The Worlds ‘I’ Inhabit – Depth & Span
© integralMENTORS
The Worlds ‘I’ Inhabit - Domains
© integralMENTORS
From Sustainability to Thriveability
Š integralMENTORS
From Sustainability to Thriveability
Š integralMENTORS
Holon Evolution – 20 Tenets 1. Reality as a whole is not composed of things or processes, but of holons
11. The micro is in relational exchange with the macro at all levels of its depth
2. Holons display four fundamental capacities: self-preservation; self-adaptation self-transcendence; self-dissolution 3. Holons emerge
12. Evolution is directional (13.) Increasing in complexity
4. Holons emerge holarchically 5. Each emergent holon transcends but includes its predecessors(s) 6. The lower sets the possibilities of the higher; the higher sets the probabilities of the lower. 7. The number of levels of which a ‘hierarchy’ comprises determines whether it is ‘shallow’ or ‘deep’; and the number of holons on any given level we shall call its span
(14.) Increasing differentiation/integration (15.) Increasing organisation/structuration (16.) Increasing relative autonomy (17.) Increasing telos 18. The greater the depth of a holon, the greater its degree of consciousness 19. Every holon issues an IOU to the Kosmos 20. All IOUs are redeemed in emptiness
8. Each successive level of evolution produces greater depth and less span 9. Destroy any type of holon, and you will destroy all of the holons above it and none of the holons below it 10. Holarchies co-evolve
© integralMENTORS
Myth of the Given Perhaps the most difficult thing for green to understand is that its values — peace, harmony, healing, transformation, sharing, feeling, embodiment — are values shared only by green. They are not values shared by magenta, red, amber, orange, teal, turquoise, indigo, or violet. If I want to transform the world, implicit in that desire is the assumption, “You are screwed up, but I know what you need.” This imposition of my values on you is a subtle violence of values. The point is that different worldspaces contain different phenomena. It is not a matter of saying which worldspace is the “real” worldspace, because any age will always feel that its view is the real view. But there is no “real” or “pregiven” world, only these various worldspaces that creatively evolve and unfold in novel ways, then settle into Kosmic habits that then must be negotiated by all subsequent humans as stages in their own unfolding and levels in their own compound individuality.
© integralMENTORS
Kosmic Address There is not a pre-given material world that is apprehended equally by beings. What is apprehended depends on a being’s Kosmic address, - a “worldview location” that specifies what arises in the experience of a sentient being based on two fundamental aspects within the AQAL matrix: altitude and perspective. - Altitude refers to the level of developmental complexity of the sentient being while - Perspective refers to the particular perspective within the quadrants or zones it is taking. Intrinsic features of Kosmos are themselves not pre-given but are in part, interpretive and constructed. The “location” of a “real object” in the AQAL matrix, including its altitude (i.e., degree of development) and its perspective (i.e., the quadrant in which it resides). Kosmic address = altitude + perspective Kosmic address = (altitude + perspective)S x (altitude + perspective)O Kosmic address = (altitude + quadrant) x (altitude + quadrivium)
© integralMENTORS
Quadrants and Quadrivia I possess 4 quadrants; the painting can be looked at through the 4 quadrants (which then constitute a quadrivia). Or in general: the perceiving subject has quadrants, which must be specified as part of its Kosmic address; and the perceived object, referent, or phenomenon has a quadrivium, which must be specified as part of its Kosmic address. Another way to say it—more loosely—is that because an object is being looked at through or from a particular quadrant, then the subject is looking at the object through a quadrant, and the object itself exists “in” a quadrant. In both cases, the quadrant of the perceiver and the quadrant (quadrivium) of the perceived must be specified for the Kosmic address of the referent to be known
Holon/ Sentient being
Quadrivia Quadrants
Artefact
© integralMENTORS
Assessing Environmental Capacity Using the Quadrants Interior (“soft”)
Exterior (“hard”).
Personal capacities:
Technical capacities:
Capacities that allow for a greater self awareness and empowerment, capacity for moral care, capacity for mental models for understanding complex issues.
Capacities for undertaking practical work, such as for sustainable resource use and land use practices.
Interpersonal capacities:
Systemic capacities:
Capacity Development
Capacities to engage meaningful relationships, to foster new cultural trends, social norms, and social discourse.
Capacities to effect systemic change, be it societal, ecological, political, etc, such as policy dialogue, advocacy, scientific research.
© integralMENTORS
Assessing Environmental Capacity Using the Quadrants
Š integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities “I” Subjective realities; - self and consciousness, states of mind, psychological development, mental models/ constructs, emotions, state of self, etc.
“We” Intersubjective realities; - shared values, world views, webs of culture, communication, relationships, cultural norms and customs, etc.
“It” Objective realities; - brain and organism, visible biological features, degree of activation of the various bodily systems, etc.
“Its” Interobjective realities; -. social systems, environmental systems, visible societal structures. economic systems, political systems, etc.
© integralMENTORS
Mapping Interventions – Thriveable Cities “I” Subjective realities; - self and consciousness, states of mind, psychological development, mental models/ constructs, emotions, state of self, etc.
“We” Intersubjective realities; - shared values, world views, webs of culture, communication, relationships, cultural norms and customs, etc.
“It” Objective realities; - brain and organism, visible biological features, degree of activation of the various bodily systems, etc.
“Its” Interobjective realities; -. social systems, environmental systems, visible societal structures. economic systems, political systems, etc.
© integralMENTORS
The T h r i v e a b i l i t y Journey Resilience
Sustainability © The ThriveAbility Foundation
Thriveability © integralMENTORS
Fractals
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Urban Fractals
© integralMENTORS
The ‘Geometry’ of Urban Fractals
Ecopolis : Architecture and Cities for a Changing Climate - Paul F Downton
© integralMENTORS
The ‘Geometry’ of Urban Fractals
Ecopolis : Architecture and Cities for a Changing Climate - Paul F Downton
© integralMENTORS
The ‘Geometry’ of Urban Fractals
Ecopolis : Architecture and Cities for a Changing Climate - Paul F Downton © integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Tools
© integralMENTORS
Urban &Travel Apps
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Projects
© integralMENTORS
Case Studies Effective Schools Project – Egypt 2005/07
Integral Practitioner in Praxis – South Africa 2012
© integralMENTORS
Case Studies UNICEF Transformation & Change 1995 - 1997
© integralMENTORS
Books
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub Books
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
available from Amazon & CreateSpace.
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
available from Amazon & CreateSpace.
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
available from Amazon & CreateSpace.com
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
available in January 2017 from Amazon & CreateSpace.
© integralMENTORS
IntegralMENTORS Guides
© integralMENTORS
ThriveAbility Guide
B&W Paperback version is available from Amazon & authorHOUSE. A full colour version from Amazon & CreateSpace Š The ThriveAbility Foundation
ThriveAbility Guide
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
ThriveAbility Guide
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
ThriveAbility Guide
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
ThriveAbility Guide
© The ThriveAbility Foundation
Urban Hub Annex
© integralMENTORS
Urban Hub SDGs
© integralMENTORS
Integrating Sustainable Development Goals
Š The ThriveAbility Foundation
Sustainable Development Goals
© integralMENTORS
Sustaining Development?
Paul van Schaik Founder - IntegralMENTORS; Co-Founder/Executive Director - Integral Without Borders (Integral International Development Centre); Partner of the ThriveAbility Foundation; Principal Associate/Founder of iSchaik Development Associates, and Founding member of the Integral Institute. He has 40+ year experience of working in international development – with extensive experience in the education, health, and infrastructure sectors. As Principal Associate of iSchaik Development Associates he worked with national governments, bilateral and multilateral development organisations and international NGOs to bring an Integrally informed approach to program development, implementation and evaluation, either directly or through the training of operational staff. He has been an Advisor and Consultant to DFID UK, Danida Denmark, European Commission, KfW/GTZ Germany, Sida Sweden, UNICEF, World Bank among others with extensive experience of working in Asia, Africa, Europe and Middle East. As mentor he works with individuals and small groups to develop a deeper understanding of Integral praxis and to become more integrally informed practitioners. He has co-hosted Integral without Borders gatherings in Perpignan, France in 2006 and in Istanbul, Turkey in 2008 and 2010 and in South Africa 2012. He is a UK trained Architect with extensive global experience doing pioneering work with passive solar energy in the 1970/90s in Africa and Australia, working with the award winning team for the Burrell Museum in Glasgow and has tutored at the Architectural Association School of Architecture, London. Currently he is an Integral Mentor, an International Development Advisor, instructor at IWB, and Chief Knowledge Officer of the ThriveAbility Foundation. Lives in Kent, UK with his wife Barbara and has three sons and four grandchildren See also www.facebook.com/integralMENTORS https://www.facebook.com/IntegralUrbanHub/ http://paulvanschaik.wixsite.com/integralmentors (new draft website) Books Guides for Integrally Informed Practitioners - 1 BASIC Guides for Integrally Informed Practitioners - 2 ADVANCED Urban Hub 1: Smart Sustainable - Thriveable Cities Urban Hub 2: Integral Methodological Pluralism - Thriveable Cities Urban Hub 3: Integral Theory - Thriveable Cities Urban Hub 4: Workbook – Thriveable Cities
Acknowledgements I would like to pay special thanks to all those who have assisted me in my work in this area: Ken Wilber who first invited me to be a founding member of the Integral Institute in 1999 and has since provided us with so much as a special advisor to Integral Without Boards; to my fellow founder of Integral Without Borders Gail Hochachka and director Emine Kiray; to my fellow founder of IntegralMENTORS my wife Barbara to all the IntegralMENTORS Fellows who have been a part of this discussion; to Robin Wood who has provided much stimulating dissuasions as founder/CEO and fellow director of the ThriveAbility Foundation and to the many people I have worked with as an Integrally informed practitioner in, Bhutan, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Cambodia, Vietnam, Egypt, Syria, Azerbaijan, Ghana, Rwanda, South Africa, Zanzibar, Australia, England, Scotland, France, Italy and the USA. To Clare Graves, Christopher Cowan and Don Beck for all the pioneering work they have done in the area of values development. And to all others engaged in work exploring the various Quadrants, Stages, Lines, States & Type in development.