Elk fence dust-up blows up
by
Alexis Bechman
They move in, tramp around and leave nothing but a mess. We’re not talking about flatlanders, but the elk residents say have infiltrated the gated golf community of Chaparral Pines. The herd has reportedly swollen to at least 150 head, with elk procreating and raising their young in the community, a haven complete with watered grass and no hunters. On Monday, many residents bugled their objection to a proposed elk fence and asked the Planning and Zoning Commission to recommend the town council sell to the country club a portion of the Chaparral Pines Drive right of way to build an elk fence.
• See Planning commission, page 2A
PAYSON ROUNDUP FRIDAY | DECEMBER 11, 2015 | PAYSON, ARIZONA
payson.com
Summer concerts 8A • Sweating for
Roundup: Newspaper of the Year
PAYSON.COM
RIM
COUNTRY’S
NEWS
But lease to charter school spurs questions
75 CENTS
New plan for Fossil Creek BY
PETE ALESHIRE
ROUNDUP EDITOR
The body of Cody Archuleta lies next to his AK-47 (above). The crime scene cruiser. photo (below) shows Officer Seth
Crime scene photos
Meeske’s bloodied DPS
A night of deadly choices
Years of squandered second chances brought damaged youth to a night of death and blunders
Peter Aleshire
BY
The Forest Service will hold a meeting in Payson Monday to gather comments on its latest plan to protect Fossil Creek from the impact of the 90,000 people a year drawn to its deep, turquoise pools teeming with endangered native fish. The Forest Service has released three alternative management plans, including one that holds out hope the Forest Service will rebuild and reopen the road from Strawberry down into the canyon. The meeting will take place from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. Monday in the Gila Community College Community Room 301. For maps of the alternatives, go to http://www.fs. usda.gov/deta il/ coconino/landmanagement/plan ning/?cid=stelprdb5410835. The Forest Service shut down FR 708 on the Strawberry side
more than two years ago for fear of both the frequent rock falls and the impact of the cars that jammed the canyon on every summer weekend. But Alternative C would over the next several years invest $5$10 million in rebuilding the road and using nets, barriers, benches and blasting to limit the danger of landslides and rolling boulders that regularly come down onto the steep, narrow dirt road. Dubbed the motorized vehicle option, Alternative C would limit access to 572 people at a time, which works out to as many as 412 cars allowed to park in staging areas in the bottom and 40 cars given a permit to drive all the way through the canyon without long stops. Alternative C would also create a wildlife reserve along the creek between where FR 708 See Fossil Creek, page 12A
by
PETE ALESHIRE
MICHELE NELSON
Speeding up the Beeline on a warm, September evening, Cody Archuleta was startled by the flashing red lights of Seth Meeske’s DPS cruiser in the rear-view mirror of his Already addled with drugs and booze, white Buick. he now felt a tragically familiar flush of fear. He glanced down at the AK-47 resting then back to the panting pit bull named on the passenger seat, Tekeshi, perched on the back seat. The contents of his car flashed mind: camping gear, a red film canister through Archuleta’s full of dried marijuana, pain pills, a case of Top Ramen and Sour Patch and lots and lots of ammunition, according candy, marijuana seeds case contained in more than 1,000 pages to details of the gripping of police reports obtained recently by the Roundup through a Freedom of Information Request. Chilling, new details of that fateful night offered here have been reconstructed from reports, plus a day spent sifting through court records in Maricopa County to reconstruct this picture of a kid whose dreams all went bad thanks to a broken family, drugs, alcohol, damage — and a series of wrong turns. As Archuleta pulled over to obey the insistent flash of the red lights, he reached for the silver .380 semi-automatic Kahr handgun and waited. In that moment, he made a desperate choice, the final bad call in a short life already long on blunders and blind corners. He wanted to be a Marine, a paramedic, But he ended up just a kid with a gun the protector of his family. and plate in his head and a drinking problem a rap sheet and a metal and a baffled, persistent fury, sitting in the dark with the red lights flashing as he tried to decide what to do.
Wild, lethal chase unfolds
Rim Country will careen into yet another weekend with the fire danger set at “extreme” and a forecast calling for hot, dry winds and another red flag warning. Fortunately, no fresh wildfires have erupted despite the dangerous conditions. The Forest Service has banned almost all fire-related activities outside of developed campgrounds, especially campfires, smoking and fireworks. Most of the forest remains open, although the Coconino Forest closed Fossil Creek last weekend due to the extreme fire danger and heavy use. The closure will probably persist until the monsoon starts, hopefully in early July.
It was a quick meeting for the Rim Country Educational Alliance Thursday, which worked through its agenda with just a few public comments, most related to plans to put a charter school on part of the university site. The board could not address those questions since the item was not on the agenda. The open meeting law forbids board discussion or decisions on any item not listed on the agenda before the meeting. One man asked who knew about the plans to lease land for a charter school and how long had they known.
The “extreme” fire danger rating on the Payson Ranger District means that fires will “start quickly, spread furiously, and burn intensely” according to the Forest Service. The extremely dry conditions mean that even tiny fires can quickly blow up into a major problem. As a result, the ban bars any outdoor burning. The dry conditions and nearly rainless spring have created record dry conditions. The Forest Service has kept measurements of the Energy Release Component of fuels since 1995, from which it generates an Energy Release Component rating (ERC). The rating stands now at an unprecedented 102 for this date. That means fuels will burn 2 See Fire, page 2A
ALEXIS BECHMAN
available revenue,” said Gila County Supervisor Tommie Martin. The proposed tax extension will show up on the August primary ballot. Independent voters on the early voter roll won’t get a primary ballot in the mail unless
they ask for a ballot from one party or the other. Anyone who doesn’t vote by mail can show up at the polls on election day.
Robert Derango pulled up alongside dirt median, picked up his radio and Seth Meeske’s cruiser in the motioned he was ready to start his first day solo on patrol, a rookie Department of Public Safety officer on the job for just three months. He wasn’t yet trained to run radar on his own, so he listened while Meeske called out the speeds of the cool, clear Sept. 21 night, the lightspassing northbound cars on of the Mazatzal Casino in the distance to the north. It looked like a quiet shift, with a handful tine. Derango, 25, later told an investigator of stops — a safe rouhe had slept peacefully the night before. It would be his last peaceful night for a After reviewing more than 1,000 pages while. BY PETE ALESHIRE of reports, the Roundup pieced together the chaos that ensued ROUNDUP EDITOR officer three times, which triggered when a motorist shot a DPS a high-speed chase that ended Gila County needs to spend at in gunfire and death. least $32 million expanding and At 10:11 p.m., Meeske spotted a pickup passing at 76 mph in the maintaining its nearly 800 miles 65 mph zone. of paved and dirt roads, which Derango radioed he would make the stop and pulled up behind means the county desperately See Seven police cars, page 7A hopes voters will extend a halfcent sales tax surcharge for another 20 years, county officials and consultants told an intent group of voters at the Democratic Women’s Club meetBY MICHELE NELSON showed a 10-inch scar that went from ing this week. ROUNDUP STAFF REPORTER his elbow down his arm toward his just above Voters approved the half-cent wrist. Seth Meeske walked into the interview On the other side of the scar, a round surcharge 20 years ago tanned, tall and confident. scar remains where the bullet entered sunburst it produces an extra and now $3 million his arm. Six-and-a-half months after Cody Meeske’s doctors say he is ahead annually to build and maintain Archuleta of shot him in the left arm and severed in his recovery. Initially, they thought schedule roads. The county gets another the nerve to he would his left hand, the 15-year veteran not have any nerve response for the $3 million annually from gas tax DPS officer can first year make a fist. after his injury. money. If voters approve the “I still have trouble with my thumb,” Nerve conduction studies show that extension in August, the county he said. Meeske’s He laughed as he picked up a water repaired nerve is beginning to conduct electrical will get half of that $3 million bottle cap to show what he meant. impulses, but early tests were discouraging. and the cities in the county will “I look like a monkey — they have “The test looks like an EKG,” said get the other half. For the past 20 a Meeske. but can’t use their thumb like we do,” thumb, The first tests showed his nerve did years, the county kept all the he said. not conHis dress shirt, pushed up over his money. elbow, See Meeske, page 8A “The costs far exceed our
See Archuleta, page 6A
BY
The Payson Roundup this week was named national newspaper of the year for non-daily papers with less than 10,000 circulation by the Road money crisis Local Media Association. The national award recognized “top-notch editorial coverage, eye-catching graphic design Officer Meeske determined to return to patrol and prominent advertising layouts, exemplifying creativity and innovation in all areas of the newspaper.” The Local Media Association serves 2,200 Are you prepared local to buy or sell media a home? Roaring into the c o m PLAYOFFS panies nationally, as well as several hundred research and development partners, with a UP AYSON OUND focus on digital issues and training, conferences, webiHeroin death nars, research and training. Tragic tale of brothers with a shared addiction Faculty from the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism judged the hundreds of entries. The national award represented the second major honor for the Roundup this year. Earlier, the Arizona Newspapers Association recognized the Roundup as Now, that’s a big Crazy about Color the top non-daily newspaper in the state. The ANA also reform SAX Prank call spurred juvenile court wrong named Roundup reporter Alexis Bechman as the top historic right, sets Gila County judge unearths, non-daily newspaper reporter in the state. Roundup publisher John Naughton said, “The Payson Roundup has a small but talented and dedicated staff. Some have been with the Roundup for many years, othsday Torch run trots through town Wedne ers just a few. “While their backgrounds are diverse, they have one thing in common, all are dedicated to their craft. What each has is the desire to go beyond standard newspaper SERVING ROUNDUP STAFF REPORTER
431 S. Beeline Hwy. (928) 474-2265
Payson Pine-Strawberry Tonto Basin
928-474-2216 928-476-3282 928-479-3324 www.bishoprealty.com
• BUSINESS
Each office is independently owned
first-round playoff game on Saturday. Payson High’s top-ranked softball Read all about the baseball team’s team begins its quest for a state cham- upset win and their upcoming schedule the pionship on Wednesday, but it was that on page 5B. at Longhorns’ long-shot baseball team You’ll also find an extensive look from state had everyone talking after rallying final the softball team in our special a 1-0 deficit with four runs in the in a tournament B section inside. two innings to upset Chino Valley
payson.com
and operated.
See page 2A
by
Keith Morris/Roundup
S NEWS SOURCE THE RIM COUNTRY’
P
R
by
Gila County suffers the second highest rate of prescription drug abuse in Arizona, according to the Arizona Criminal Justice Commission. Fortunately, Gila County Health Director Michael O’Driscoll this year landed a $500,000 grant from the federal Centers for Disease Control to do something about it. The county will get nearly $100,000 annually to establish comprehensive county-level interventions for prescription drug overuse, misuse, abuse and overdose — especially for opiate pain reliev-
Alexis bechmAn
roundup staff reporter
Payson’s heroin scourge has claimed another victim. A pair of brothers who swore to stand together and shared matching tattoos, HITS also shared a drug habit. But now one lies in a coffin, the other, facing drug charges. seventh in a series Police say they found Nicholas Whittington, 23, and Samuel Whittington, morning. Nicholas Wednesday 25, at a Main Street apartment complex Outside, Samuel was reportedlay dead inside from a heroin overdose. ly trying to cover up what had happened. death since October in Nicholas’ death is the second heroin-related
HEROIN HOME
Payson.
• See Heroin overdose, page 9A
awesome image Photographer DJ Craig captured this 5K Color of some of the 150 runners in Saturday’s and set out Run. The fun event started in Star Valley Adventure to raise money for Payson High School’spage 12A. see Club. For a story and more photos,
by
Pete Aleshire
roundup editor
with no Mrs. Cook picked up the phone, sense of impending history. vaguely “Cookie, just a minute, said a to talk to familiar voice. “My friend wants you.” came Then another teenaged boy’s voice today?” on the line. “Are your cherries ripe he asked. She stared at the phone, aghast. voice “Do you have big bombers?” the said, on the edge of a giggle. voices. She thought she recognized the who lived She thought one was the Gault boy, answered in the trailer court and sometimes the other the phone and took messages. And boy. boy — that sounded like the Lewis So she called the sheriff’s office. and That childish prank in Globe in 1964 a motion Mrs. Cook’s firm response set in
by
chain of events that would force far-reaching syschange in the way the criminal justice tem deals with juveniles. United The case ended up in front of the winning States Supreme Court, although for that ultimately did nothing whatever ultimately young teenager. It did, however, overshadow the career of a distinguished casGila County judge, who found himself for land tigated by the highest court in the running a “kangaroo court.” case of And finally, the strange 1964 grace Gerald Gault has offered a complex Judge note for Gila County Superior Court justice 50 Peter Cahill, who finally rendered
Alexis bechmAn
roundup staff reporter
out of Help run local law enforcement Special town Wednesday during the annual Highway. Olympics Torch Run on the Beeline As part of Special Olympics 50th celebration, members of Arizona law enforcement Special community are teaming up with THE WEATHER
volume 26, no. 36
Outlook: Mostly sunny through the week, with a slight chance for rain by the weekend. Highs in the mid to upper 60s, lows around 40. Details, 11A
comes This reconstruction of the case Cahill mostly from the court records Judge of meticulously assembled, after months He research with the help of Lisa Pferdeort. of group presented the case recently to a Phoenix students at Summit Law School in and to an expanding number of professional since. lawyers of gatherings
Juvenile defendants had no rights bore The juvenile justice system in 1964 today. little resemblance to the system to Juveniles had few of the rights accorded few conadult defendants — and judges had straints on their power. got the So when the Gila County sheriff years delayed. bench complaint from Mrs. Cook, a deputy went After a distinguished career on the up straight to Gerry Gault’s house at 10 a.m., taken has Cahill end, its now nearing students made the arrest and took the 15-year-old boy explaining to lawyers and law jail. the to determined and down brave a which in the way the land, woman attorney changed the law of See Gila County, page 8A wearing a frowned upon hat.
•
for the Olympic athletes around the state kicks off annual Olympic Torch Run, which the summer games. In Payson, officers will meet at Chapman 87 Auto Center at the corner of Highways and 260 Wednesday at 8:30 a.m. the Local residents can walk along with Village Western athletes as they head to and with the torch. From there, the officers the to other supporters will ride bicycles Highway 188 turnoff. County Gila the with Baltz, Det. Karen to ride Sheriff’s Office, said they had planned constructo Sunflower, but because of road 188 tion, will stop at the area at the Highway riders turnoff. The Payson Posse will escort then be safely down the highway. Bikers will
shuttled back to Payson. Special Baltz started volunteering with as a “hugOlympics years ago in California ger,” someone who helps and encourages events. special-needs athletes through their and She said she loves helping the group her given wishes she could do more, but she can heavy caseload at the sheriff’s office, only help organize this annual event. Payson Jonathan Manley, law clerk at the excited to Gila County courthouse, said he is participate in this year’s ride. at 9 is The Payson area Torch Parade Chapman a.m., Wednesday, May 6 starting at a.m. The Auto Center; meet there at 8:30 87 to route continues south on Highway Western Village.
See our ad and upcoming events on page 10B
by
michele nelson
roundup staff reporter
In a treat for the ears, eyes and mind, the Tonto Community Concert Association presented SAXational, by Ron Verdi for its last concert of the season. As an added bonus, Verdi performed with the Payson High School Concert Band adding a decidedly local spin on the event. Verdi and the band offered a history of the saxophone (including props) with samples of jazz and pop music spanning 50 years. The professional musician with a music degree from the University of Arizona, has amassed a collection of 100 saxophones in addition to 150 rare wind, brass and percussion instruments. After a career in
ers, O’Driscoll said. He said his division would use the money to implement prevention strategies to improve safe prescribing practices and prevent abuse The strategies include two required steps and two optional. The county would be required to: • Enhance and maximize the state’s Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP). Currently, only 21 percent of primary care doctors and pain management specialists use the PDMP. This program tracks prescriptions filled by pharmacies and can also help prescribers and law enforcement.
• See County fights, page 2A
education and playing with the Phoenix Symphony, he moved to Southern California to found the Side Street Strutters Jazz Band. The Strutters became the house jazz band of Disneyland Resort for 22 years. He effortlessly and humorously combined a description of the instruments with an introduction into the song he and the band would play. Starting at the beginning of the creation of the saxophone, Verdi introduced Adolphe Sax, a Belgian musical instrument inventor who created the instrument in the late 1800s. But Sax did not have much luck with the patents he filed on the instrument Verdi told the audience.
• See Saxophone, page 2A
• See Roundup, page 9A
NORTHERN ARIZONA
Water Damage Specialist sunshinecleaning.net
Teresa McQuerrey
roundup staff reporter
75 CENTS
ONA 015 | PAYSON, ARIZ TUESDAY | MAY 5, 2
• See Alliance meeting, page 2A
2nd highest rate of prescription pill abuse
BISHOP REALTY
www.weinsurepayson.com
http://thewonderfulworldofinsurance.blogspot.com/
AUTO • HOMEOWNERS • LIFE • HEALTH
VOLUME 25, NO. 47
1969
Alliance Chair Jim Lyon would only say that the public probably knew about it sooner than he did. The audience member said he was surprised to learn a charter school could become the first use of the 253-acre site just purchased from the Forest Service, since he’d always heard the site was intended for a university campus. Officials have planned to tuck the charter school on a 10-acre slice of land south of Granite Dells Road, across the road from where the university would go. The man said while he does not oppose charter schools, he worries how it will impact the local school district, which may have to close an elemen-
County tackles epidemic
See County, page 2A
THE WEATHER
Weekend: Sunny with highs of 89 degrees and lows of 50 degrees. Details, 10A
Proudly serving Rim Country Since
Alexis Bechman
roundup staff reporter
Danger ‘extreme’ BY
ROUNDUP EDITOR
ROUNDUP STAFF REPORTER
roundup editor
SOURCE
F R I D AY | J U N E 1 3 , 2 0 1 4 | PAY S O N , A R IZONA
75 CENTS
ASU meeting planned
success 1B • Plucky candidate 5A
PAYSON ROUNDUP THE
by
The homeowners association has already erected a fence along the south end of the community off State Route 260; on the west, off Tyler Parkway and in various pockets around the community where they already have easements or own the land. Chaparral Pines would pay the town $26,000 for the Chaparral Pines Drive right of way and then build a decorative metal fence 7.5 feet tall to help keep elk off the golf course. Some residents, however, say the fence could lower property values and ruin the views. They say the homeowners association has pushed the measure through, even though more than a dozen residents will not grant easements to finish the fence.
roundup staff reporter
AZ ROC #276421
’Tis the Credit for Kids season! by
Michele Nelson
roundup staff reporter
It’s that time of year for Credit for Kids, the tax credit Rim Country residents may contribute and take directly off of their state income taxes. Last year, Rim Country residents donated $208,672 to the Payson Unified School District, reported Kathie Manning, the business manager for PUSD. The Payson schools are not the only school district to receive the tax credits, Tonto Basin and Pine-Strawberry school districts also receive donations. But schools are not the only organizations that receive Credit for Kids dollars. Other organizations helping the working poor also receive donations such as Payson Habitat for Humanity, Payson Christian Clinic, Payson Community Kids, Payson Helping Payson and Time Out Shelter. In Payson, PUSD has sent out yellow letters in the mail that have a pre-addressed envelope with THE WEATHER
Weekend: Snow expected beginning Friday but clearing by Saturday evening, highs in the mid 40s. Details, 9A
a form with a list of extracurricular programs the donor may hand pick to support. Each grade level has lists of extracurricular programs to support. Donors may even write in a specific teacher’s program if they wish. Credit for Kids is a tax credit, which means the total comes off the amount of tax owed — not off the taxpayers income before calculating the tax owed. It’s the only time taxpayers have absolute control over where their tax dollars go. The donations to PUSD in 2014 supported music, athletics, career education, field trips, fine arts, agriculture and business clubs, science enrichment, character education, after-school enrichment and academic competitions. However, checks must be received by Dec. 31 to apply to 2015 taxes. Individuals may donate $200 and couples $400. To contact the PUSD office for any questions, please call 928-474-2070. Pine-Strawberry School District 928-476-3283 Tonto Basin School District 928-479-2277.
Photographer DJ Craig captured this moment in the Julia Randall Elementary School Christmas concert this week. For a story and photos see page 5A — and for a video see our website: payson. com). The Payson School District’s music program relies mostly on donations to survive.
PAYSON AREA FOOD DRIVE
GOAL: 30,000 lbs.
Please help us meet our goal of raising 30,000 pounds of food and $50,000 in financial donations for local food banks. Look for the drop boxes around town, or mail your check to Payson Area Food Drive, P.O. Box 703, Payson, AZ 85547.
27,000 lbs.
24,000 lbs.
21,000 lbs.
18,000 lbs.
15,000 lbs.
12,000 lbs.
9,000 lbs.
20,000
15,798 15,000
6,000 lbs. 7,517 lbs.
3,000 lbs.
0 lbs.
5,000
$
$
volume 25, no. 97
GOAL: $50,000 Feb. 2, 2016
$
45,000
Locally Owned & Operated
$
40,000
35,000
$
& MORE
Located in Safeway Center • 928-468-8568 Monday-Saturday 10am-5pm
30,000
$
$
25,000
See our ad and upcoming events on page 8B
$
$
$
10,000
$
0
Nov. 1, 2015
Sell your home with an experienced full service Realtor® for a commission as low as $ .
990
where the experts are™
MAUREEN BUCHANAN R����� E��������� ~ N������� A������ 928.951.0525 Maureen@SoldMyHome.net