Volume 11
Issue 2
December 2011
`` Photo credit: David Cribb
SYSTEMnews `` Two teams worked simultaneously for 11 hours to complete the bilateral hand transplant.
T he first time we met, she gave me a hug, with no hands or arms. For us to give a productive life to these types of individuals ... that’s the meaning of life for them.
CEO’s corner
HUP’S SURGICAL TEAM
Rises to the Challenge
Earlier this fall, a surgical team at HUP successfully completed the region’s first bilateral hand transplant, a complex procedure that required 30 specialists in organ transplantation, orthopaedic
RALPH W. MULLER
CEO, University of Pennsylvania Health System
UPHS has always taken a leadership role in serving the community. In addition to providing care to those who are most vulnerable, we’re also proud to be known for our efforts to strengthen individual lives, families, and whole neighborhoods outside of our hospital walls. The successes we’ve achieved are based on the generosity and enthusiasm of the entire UPHS family. We’ve made our presence felt in many positive, sustaining ways throughout the year. Most recently, more than three of every four of you made generous contributions to Penn’s Way, the combined workplace charitable giving campaign of the University of Pennsylvania and Penn Medicine. I’m extremely proud to report that the Health System attained 117 percent of our goal — a remarkable accomplishment. Your donations will help dozens of extraordinary organizations in our area provide life-changing and lifesaving services to those in need. Here at Penn Medicine, each of our three hospitals, Abramson Cancer Center, Joan Karnell Cancer Center, Sayre Health Center, Scheie Eye Institute, and Penn Wissahickon Hospice all benefit from your generosity. During this season of giving, there are many additional ways you’ve helped to make a real difference. Here are some. [Continued on page 2]
INSIDE Penn Health Policy Experts Brainstorm on Future Ideas, Collaborations...........................2 Random Acts of Kindness Volunteering at Penn Hospice at Rittenhouse............................2 Penn Medicine@Work..............3 Newsmakers..............................4 myPennMedicine......................5 Awards and Accolades.............6 Penn Medicine, Washington Square..................6
surgery, reconstructive micro-surgery, plastic surgery, and anesthesia. Even with two teams working simultaneously, the operation lasted more than 11 hours. While the procedure itself was clearly an achievement, the planning for it was no less impressive. Read below to see how it all unfolded.
First Step: Ethical Considerations Organ transplants are performed to save lives. That fact balances out the risks of both the surgery and the lifelong dependence on powerful drugs to prevent rejection. A bilateral hand transplant was not life-saving; was it worth these risks? That was the initial thought of Abraham Shaked, MD, head of the Penn Transplant Institute, when L. Scott Levin, MD, chair of Orthopaedic Surgery, professor of Surgery, and director of Penn Hand Transplant, first approached him in 2009 with the possibility of doing the procedure at HUP. But that was before Shaked met the patient, a young woman who had lost all of her limbs due to a severe post-surgical infection. “The first time we met, she gave me a hug, with no hands or arms. The minute you have it [the hug], you think about life in a different way,” he said. “For us to give a productive life to these types of individuals … that’s the meaning of life for them.” Art Caplan, PhD, director of the Center for Bioethics and professor of Medical Ethics, initially shared Shaked’s concerns, but “I came to understand that this transplant is not cosmetic; it is truly functional, allowing a patient to carry out activities of daily living. Prosthetics don’t give the kind of function you need for a good quality of life if you are a double amputee.” And they don’t allow a person to literally touch a loved one.
Plastic Surgery, associate professor of Clinical Surgery, and co-director of Penn Hand Transplant. “We’ve all fixed bones, re-attached muscles, repaired nerves, and sewn skin.” The major difference was that this was vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA). Unlike with solid organs, a hand transplant involves multiple tissues, including blood vessels, bone, nerves, muscles, tendons, and skin. Preparations started 18 months prior to the actual surgery. Using the patient’s measurements and X-rays, the team created a step-by-step transplant procedure specifically tailored to her needs. Chang said they divided the surgery into multiple parts. One team procured the donor limbs, while two other teams opened and prepared the patient’s stumps to receive them. Two teams then prepared the donor arms and, finally, two teams attached the donor limbs to the patient’s stumps. Chang led one team while Levin, who is board certified in both orthopaedic and plastic surgery, led the other team as well as the procurement team. “He was the driving force that made all this possible,” Chang said. [Continued on page 4] Penn Transplant Institute
Forearm Transplant Checklist ( A ) Forearm-level Transplant Harvest
( C ) Recipient Stump Preparation
FFMark basilic and cephalic veins
FFMark basilic and cephalic veins
FFInflate tourniquet
FFInflate tourniquet
FFCircumferential skin incision at mid humeral level
FFFishmouth skin incision
FFTag cephalic vein and basilic vein
FFElevate anterior and posterior flaps
FFDivide biceps and brachialis muscles
FFTag basilic and cephalic veins
FFTag median nerve and brachial artery
FFTag brachial artery and brachial vein
FFTag ulnar nerve
FFTag medial nerve
FFTag radial nerve
FFTag and transpose ulnar nerve
FFDivide humerus 3 cm proximal to soft tissue
FFExpose the medial epicondyle
FFDivide triceps
FFTag radial nerve and radial sensory nerve
FFDeflate tourniquet
FFExpose lateral epicondyle
FFFlush brachial artery
FFPosterior approach to radial and ulnar shaft
FFAttach prosthetic arms
FFReflect supinator off radius FFPerform radius and ulna osteotomies at same level
( B ) Donor Forearm Preparation FFPosterior incision over the triceps and olecranon onto
the shaft of the ulna
FFAnterior incision over the biceps, across the antecubital fossa FFRaise a medial skin flap down to medial epicondyle.
The surgical techniques used to perform the hand transplant were not new, said Benjamin Chang, MD, associate chief of
FFMeasure distance on recipient stump from lateral epicondyle
to end of radius and from medial epicondyle to end of ulna.
( D ) Forearm Transplant
FFTrace basilic vein down to elbow
FFAlign donor arm to recipient stump
FFTrace ulnar nerve from proximal to distal and dissected out
FFClamp 6 hole small fragment plate to ulna, dorso-lateral side
of the cubital tunnel
FFTrace median nerve and brachial artery down to antecubital fossa FFElevate flexor/pronator origin from medial epicondyle and tag FFRaise lateral skin flap down to lateral epicondyle FFTrace radial nerve down to elbow FFElevate brachioradialis from humerus FFElevate mobile wad from lateral epicondyle and tag FFMeasure distance on recipient stump from lateral epicondyle
to end of radius and from medial epicondyle to end of ulna. Tranfer measurements to donor and mark osteotomy site.
Practice, Practice, Practice
FFDeflate tourniquet
FFExpose ulna and radius from posterior incision. Perform ulna
and radius osteotomy.
FFElevate muscles from proximal radius and ulna and detach
forearm from elbow
FFClamp 6 hole small fragment plate to radius, dorsal side FFCheck alignment under flouro FFDrill and insert screws FFInsert 2 Mitek anchors and attach flexors to medial epicondyle FFInsert 2 Mitek anchors and attach mobile wad to lateral epicondyle FFAnastamose brachial artery FFAnastamose basilic vein FFAnastamose cephalic vein FFRepair median nerve FFRepair ulnar nerve FFRepair radial nerve(s) FFTrim skin flaps: anterior with elbow extended, posterior
with elbow flexed
FFClose skin
`` The team created a checklist of each step of the surgery to ensure that nothing was skipped and that steps were taken in the correct order.
1