THE PEPPERDINE GRAPHIC VOLUME L |
ISSUE 8 | october 22, 2020
|
pepperdine-graphic.com
|
follow us @peppgraphic
SPP Dean Responds to Controversial response to Email As hley mowreader n e ws e dit or On Oct. 12, the School of Public Policy, in association with political fundraising campaign organizer Active Engagements, shared a petition with Conservative News subscribers against the use of “far left indoctrinating” curriculum in schools. On Oct. 21, SPP Dean Pete Peterson told Pepperdine community members it was a mistake to send the petition without prior authorization. The Pepperdine community exploded with reactions following the Graphic’s Oct. 14 publication of Peterson’s petition, with two alumni petitions, a dozen letters from the Seaver community and hundreds of Instagram comments and tweets created within the week. Peterson and President Jim Gash addressed the community during the Oct. 21 President’s Briefing. “I believe in civil discourse, inclusive engagement and viewpoint diversity,” Peterson said. “And unfortunately, this email promoted none of these.” Peterson started his address by referencing his public image as modeled through his 15-year career at Pepperdine and his various other public roles, including leading a nonprofit, building the Davenport Institute for Public Engagement and campaigning for public office, among other speeches, opinion pieces and media appearances. Peterson said he strives to model several commitments including viewpoint diversity, civic participation and civil discourse. Peterson then addressed the email campaign, which he said abandoned the principles he holds in public addresses. “While the emails were written by copywriters that I contracted outside agency — and while I hadn’t consented to have my own image used an email, nor seen the final email — I approved the copy for this first round of a pilot program, and this was a mistake,” Peterson said. “The email tactic used polarizing and crass language completely unbecoming of SPP, of Pepperdine and of me.” Peterson said he believes he has demonstrated over the years the ways he speaks, writes and thinks, and he said this email did not model his standards. “I have no excuse,” Peterson said. “It was a decision I deeply regret and a serious error in judgment.” As confirmed by an Oct. 15 email from Provost Rick Marrs to the Graphic, Peterson reaffirmed the email cam-
paign is canceled and the contract between the School of Public Policy and Active Engagements has ended, per University demand. “I can say without hesitation that no message like this will ever again go out from my office, and I take full responsibility for it,” Peterson said. Peterson also discussed the controversy in the Pepperdine community surrounding the topic and said he regrets this issue created division in the community. While individuals may disagree with one another, Peterson said he believes Pepperdine must always model a culture of honor in how they disagree. “On this point in this email, I have fallen short,” Peterson said. “To those who have been hurt by my bad judgment, I offer my unreserved and complete and heartfelt apology.” After Peterson spoke to the community, Gash reaffirmed Pepperdine’s commitment to civil discourse and debate. “Our university seeks to be a place that welcomes diverse points of view and invites respectful and productive dialogue about controversial topics in a Christian environment,” Gash said. “This university will always support academic freedom and freedom of speech, including the freedom to engage in political discourse.” Peterson’s message, however, fell short of respective dialogue for several reasons, Gash said. “The email Dean Peterson was speaking of was an unauthorized solicitation that expressed partisan political views, along with divisive commentary, with a specific call to political action, all as if it were on behalf of the institution,” Gash said. Gash echoed that the University administration did not approve the email and petition nor would it have done so, as Pepperdine has set precedence to not make political statements in order to create a space for civil discourse. “The institution itself as a matter of policy does not engage in divisive political rhetoric or take positions with respect to partisan agendas,” Gash said. “We leave these important debates — and they are important — for the academic and educational conversations by our scholars and students engaging in thoughtful discourse by appropriate avenues in their individual capacities.” Moving forward, Pepperdine will review marketing and communication policies and create additional “quality control processes,” Gash said. Neither Gash nor Peterson gave
photo courtesy of juan carlos hugues Peterson’s Public Address | Dean Pete Peterson speaks at the President’s Briefing on Oct. 21. Peterson addressed the controvery surrounding his Oct. 12 email and petition. comment regarding the call from alumni to remove Peterson from office, but Gash said the University will take appropriate administrative action consistent with University policy. “Let me also acknowledge the pain, hurt and divisiveness experienced as a result of this,” Gash said. “I am more committed than ever to fostering a strong sense of belonging in this community. It’s clear to me there’s more work to be done. I look forward to doing that.”
ASHL EY.M OW R EADER @PEPPER DINE.EDU
Shanghai Director: life is ‘back to normal’ in Shanghai Ashley Mo w r eader New s Edi tor In most parts of Shanghai, life returned to normal. Restaurants filled with diners, movie theaters packed with viewers, but the Pepperdine Shanghai Jia remains devoid of students. Shanghai Program Director Charlie Engelmann recounted his experience leading the first suspended International Program, quarantining in the U.S. for seven months and planning his family’s careful return to a city where most lives are normal except his. “As directors, we do this job for the students first and foremost, and not having that direct access to investing in students takes away a huge aspect of meaning in my life,” Engelmann said. “I’m craving for that to come back, probably more than anything; but I know we need to do it in the right way.” A Seaver alumnus (2001) and former Heidelberg program participant, Engelmann credits studying abroad his sophomore year as the catalyst for his career in international education. “I fell in love with learning about other cultures and experiencing places that were different than what I was accustomed to,” Engelmann said. After graduation, Engelmann took a teaching opportunity in China, only planning to live abroad for a couple of years, but ended up teaching for seven because he loved it. Engelmann then moved back to
photo courtesy of Charlie Engelmann Chinese New Year Celebration | Charlie Engelmann, his wife and his kids smile for a photo celebrating Chinese New Year in February. During the family’s trip, Engelmann learned of the Shanghai program suspension. the U.S. for five years to work and to complete his master’s degree when the Shanghai program director position opened, bringing him back to Pepperdine. “I believe in Pepperdine’s mission, I believe in International Programs — especially how transformative it can be — and to help support that as the program director was a dream come true,” Engelmann said. Sending Shanghai Home The Shanghai spring 2020 program was the first Interna-
News
What ’s AHE A D
A4-
A3- Lovernich apartments
A5- Justice Amy Coney
thethe waves waves report report
L if e & A r t s
Pe r s pe ct iv e s
A3- Pepperdine Ambassadors Council serves as liason for students and admin. underwent extensive renovations during fall 2020.
tional Program to ever be suspended in IP’s 57-year history. Engelmann said the University pulled a team together in January to assess COVID-19 as it first impacted central China, posing questions about the viability of keeping students in Shanghai. Ultimately, Pepperdine decided to pull program participants from Shanghai. “There were a lot of questions about that from the students, and I empathize with where they were at about whether it was legitimately a concern in Shanghai and whether we should have waited a little lon-
Staff Editorial: Pepperdine students should not ignore the conflict in Armenia. Barrett should not be confirmed to the Supreme Court.
Thurs: Fri: 3-5 3–4ftft
B4- Baby Waves from
changes to better serve members.
across the country join their teams in Malibu.
Student Alliance emphasizes community to display diverse cultures.
Sat: fri:3-5 1–2ftft
Life in the U.S. The Shanghai cohort experience wasn’t meant to end with the return to Malibu, Engelmann said. IP understood students’ loss and tried to make up for it through alternate Shanghai-only programming, such as a weekend trip to Catalina. “I was going to help the Shanghai students continue to have a significant group experience together, just in a new context,” Engelmann said. Shanghai participants spent only a month on campus, however, because the University closed March 14, forcing students to return home again. Engelmann and his family booked a flight to return to Shanghai after, but China closed its borders March 28 and suspended all foreigners’ visas. Unable to return home, the Engelmanns moved to a house in Oregon. Being in quarantine was difficult, Engelmann said, from homeschooling three kids with his wife to being away from home for sevenand-a-half months. “That took a toll on us,” Engelmann said. “Even though we had great situations in Malibu and in Oregon, we wanted to be back to the place that physically we connected to as home.”
SE E D i r e cto r, A6
T he g r ap hi c’s Ne wS P o d c ast
B5- Men’s Volleyball and
Women’s Indoor Volleyball recalibrate for upcoming season.
sun: MON:3-5 1–2ftft
prior to moving into faculty housing on campus.
l is te n to The Gr a ph
SP ORTS
B1- Greek life makes B2- The Latino/a/x
ger,” Engelmann said. “But I think everyone has since looked back and said, ‘Yeah, it was the right decision.’” The suspension happened during the program’s two-week travel break for Chinese New Year, a national holiday in which Chinese citizens receive a seven-day break from work. Few students remained in Shanghai during this time, Engelmann said. Engelmann wasn’t even in Shanghai at the time of the suspension; he was with his wife and three kids visiting family in Malaysia. Engelmann and Shanghai staff scrambled to help students leave China, booking flights and making last-minute plans. Engelmann took a one-day trip to Shanghai to gather some belongings, and then he and his family flew to the U.S. “Malaysia is a tropical place; I literally didn’t have a pair of long pants — it was just shorts and flip flops — so I came back to get proper clothes, grab a few important documents,” Engelmann said. “At that time, we weren’t sure how long this thing would be — maybe it would be a month, maybe two, we didn’t know.” Pepperdine required students to return to their permanent addresses to quarantine for two weeks prior to coming back to Malibu to finish the semester. Engelmann and his family, at the urging of the University, also made plans to finish the semester in Malibu. The Engelmanns spent the two weeks in Seattle, where Engelmann is from,
Mon: TUES:2-41–2ftft
Hosts Ivy Moore and Lindsey Sullivan talk to PGM reporters and community members about the School of Public Policy controversy. Listen on Spotify and SoundCloud.
Tue: WED:3-42–3 ft ft