On the Fringe of another festival PAGE 23
Family Portrait: Gunnar Montana on chainsaws and his ex PAGE 27
PGN staffer named advertising director of the year by national organization
PAGE 8
Sept. 6-12, 2013
����������
��� ������������ �������� �����������������������������������������
Vol. 37 No. 36
Giovanni’s Room to be sold
Court hears arguments in MontCo marriage case
By Angela Thomas angela@epgn.com
By Jen Colletta jen@epgn.com Attorneys for the state and for the Montgomery County official who has been issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples argued their case before a judge in Harrisburg this week. Oral arguments were held Sept. 4 before Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini on the state Department of Health’s suit against MontCo Register of Wills D. Bruce Hanes, who has issued more than 160 marriage licenses to same-sex couples since July. The state is seeking a writ of mandamus to compel Hanes to halt his action. Pellegrini did not set a deadline for his decision but indicated it will be a quick one. Arguments Wednesday primarily centered on whether the state health department has jurisdction to order Hanes to stop issuing licenses. The state contends that it does, but attorneys for Hanes argued that, as a judicial officer, their client must be guided by orders from the court, not state agencies. Pelligrini will not rule on the constitutionality of the state’s ban on same-sex marriage but will likely weigh in on whether Hanes’ attorneys can use arguments about the law being unconstitutional to defend against the suit should it proceed. The judge did not give a clear indication of his leanings on the issues, but did suggest multiple times that a more straightforward approach would have been for Hanes to file a challenge to the law. Arguing for the state was executive deputy general counsel Gregory Dunlap PAGE 19
LABOR OF LOVE: Singer Macklemore donned a Phillies jersey for his Labor Day weekend performance at the Budweiser Made in America festival on the Parkway. An estimated 60,000 people packed the Parkway both Saturday and Sunday for a festival headlined by Beyoncé and Nine Inch Nails. Macklemore and Ryan Lewis performed their hit “Same Love” on Sunday, fresh from their performance and win at the “MTV Video Music Awards.” The marriage-equality-themed song had festivalgoers singing along, with a sea of hands in the air as the singer asked the crowd to point upwards if they “believe in equality for all human beings all over the world.” Photo: Scott A. Drake
Senior project names building manager By Jen Colletta jen@epgn.com Move-in day for the city’s new LGBT-friendly senior residence is inching closer, and project organizers recently named the person
KECIA HILLIARD AT THE SENIOR CENTER SITE Photo: Scott A. Drake
who will manage the full gamut of the facility’s operations. Kecia Hilliard, 48, began as the building manager for the John C. Anderson Apartments Aug. 27. Hilliard is an employee of Pennrose Properties, the developer spearheading the project with the Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld Fund. Hilliard has more than 20 years of experience in property management. Most recently, she served as facilities manager for a company based in Norristown, but said she was eager to attain a position with more personal interaction. “A lot of what I was doing was from behind a computer or on the telephone, and I really missed that human interaction that property management can bring,” Hilliard said. “I’m a social butterfly, and I need to be face-to-face, dealing with humans. PAGE 19
After 37 years at the helm of Giovanni’s Room, owner Ed Hermance is retiring, leaving both the nation’s oldest LGBT bookstore and its building up for sale. Hermance, 73, has owned the independently run LGBT bookstore, nestled on the corner of Pine and 12th streets, since 1976. The Powelton resident plans to step down this winter and is exploring options for keeping the business running under a new owner, but will have to sell to a different buyer if there is not sufficient support for continuing Giovanni’s Room. “I know it’s possible for independent bookstores to thrive in the current environment. I don’t know if someone has the resources and the passion to continue the store,” he said. “If someone wanted to rent the space for a different kind of bookstore and no one wanted to continue Giovanni’s Room, I’d be pleased to rent it to them, thinking that it would be in their interest to help all the people who have depended on us.”
Hermance is handling the sale personally and said he will have asking prices determined later this month. “We have inventory that is worth something and we also owe for books. It would also depend on some degree on who bought it,” he said about the sale price. “I think Giovanni’s Room has a lot of goodwill in it, so I wouldn’t be embarrassed to take $100,000 for the business. I am not asking for a lot, I would just like to have enough for a stick of gum.” A potential owner would inherit Giovanni’s Room’s inventory of more than 48,000 books. The store also offers more than five million books online, as well as 3.5 million ebooks. If the business continues as an LGBT bookstore, it would be up to the new owner whether to keep the three staffers or hire new employees. Hermance noted there are several buying options that a potential owner could look into. “If a new owner is interested in buying the business but not the buildings, they could rent from me and move PAGE 9
DEDICATION OF A STATE HISTORICAL MARKER AT GIOVANNI’S ROOM IN 2011 Photo: Scott A. Drake