The Octagon picernocerasolab
1
title of patent: the Octagon
proposal for wind and flood responsive housing constructed with the use of laser cut technology
coordinator structural engineer design team
Amleto Picerno Ceraso Gianpiero Picerno Ceraso Mark Thomas Clarkson Olga Vlagkouli Thomas Duff Bangs 2
Vanessa Mitropanou
Cava dei Tirreni, Italy 2011
picernocerasolab
the project typhoon resistant shelter concept
the content
-introduction
4
- site analysis
7
- problems and solutions
11
- ideas explored
15
- proposal
21
- cnc technology
32
- building technology
36
- cost analysis
44
- renders
47 33
introduction
The Philippines experiences numerous natural disasters every year. These natural disasters range from typhoons to flooding and in some severe cases tsunamis. While these natural disasters are devastating to the whole population of the Philippines, they can be especially devastating to the lower socioeconomic class who cannot afford to build disaster resistant housing in traditional ways. The purpose of this project is to create an affordable housing prototype which responds to inclement weather conditions such as typhoons and flooding. The housing type is meant to be affordable, be quickly assembled, built by the local inhabitants and be easily and quickly repaired in case of damage.
4
concept
The concept for this project was developed from several ideas which addressed the issues of designing for natural disasters in the Philippines. The final design is an elevated dome form constructed from plywood plates. The circularshape of the dome is an inherent form to resist high wind and flooding conditions. The design allows the inhabitants to close up their homes to withstand these inclement conditions. Production and assembly of the structures is a quick process due to implementing CNC technologies. CNC machines will be set up within a community to produce parts for the homes during assembly.Giving the inhabitants the ability to assemble and repair their own homes will give them a sense of empowerment.
5
layout
The following proposal illustrates the process of designing a prototype for typhoon and flood resistant housing in the Philippines. The process contains the following: a study of site information and parameters, a study of problems associated with building in this location and some possible solutions. Followed by a section on the chosen design with a proposal and plans and a section describing the building technology and the process of laser cut and how it is applicable to this process and a cost analysis.
6
site analysis
7 7
The data has been scaled to their maximum and minimum values and ranked in order of their significance i.e. the number of typhoons per year is located on the outer part of the cycle. It is clear to see that there is a definite correlation towards the typhoon season
Disaster Cycle Emergency Phase Impact Threat Warning Preparedness Prevention Mitigation Re-construction Re-habilitation Typhoons Rain Fall Rice Stock Corn Stock Holidays Calendar
year cycle
The following is the yearly cycle in the Philippines of the combination of the government’s response and the average values of significant affects of Typhoons.
8
House Unit Construction Stage
Initial concept design developed by the Armaplus Studio for deployment in the Philippines
Constructing the housing units onto the foundations
Evolution design stage
Repair Stage
Design to be further enchanced by local builders after first stages of implementation
Repairing of damage caused to units after a typhoon
Infastructure development
Recycle Stage
Creation of infastructure for the implementation of the masterplan
The collection and reuse of materials displaced during a typhoon
Foundations development Construction of the foundations for the individual housing units
Lazer Cutting Factory creation Construction of a Factory to house the Lazer cutting technology for the creation of the house units
House Unit Cutting Stage Once the factory is created the individual house units can be cut
The following is a continuation of mapping of the yearly cycle plus a theoretical timeline implementation for the stages of the masterplan The main body of work is done before the typhoon seasons. Then reconstruction and preparation for next years begins after the typhoon season has ended
icon lagend
Initial concept design stage
9
Average Total Corn Stock ‘00 Tonnes
Average Total Rice Stock ‘00 Tonnes
Average Total Rainfall mm
Average No. of Typhoons
Disaster Cycle
This page is a continuation of mapping of the yearly cycle plus a theoretical timeline implementation for the stages of the masterplan The main body of work is done before the typhoon seasons. Then reconstruction and preparation for next years begins after the typhoon season has ended
development
Holiday Calendar - No. of Events
10
problems & soloutions - flood issue - wind issue - resolving issues of flood and wind - the solution
1111
0m
Having the house on the ground level would have devastating effects on the structure if flooded. Therefore it is raised 2m off the ground to avoid interior flooding.
flood issue
2m
12
wind issue
advantages of the square form is that it is easy to construct and furnish, however its disadvantage is its weakness to resist to the wind: the circle responds better to wind, thought it is hard to construct; pro version is octagon , that its form is a good response to wind and easier to construct and furnish.
13
surface extended to the ground assures that the wind does not flip over the building
idea 14
if the distance of 2 m is applied to the wind resistant structure, the scale of the house needs to be enlarged; the enlarged structure can t 8 units of living spaces for 8 families.
ideas explored The following section is a set of designs based on the set of crieteria for this project. Each was a small step towards the progression of the final design which resists typhoons and inclement weather.
15
-in order to achieve the wind resistant shape, a large area of the cannot be used -the form offers wind resistance only on one direction
umbrella
-this typology has the most wind resistant structure -the frame of the building is also its structure
16
-the structure demands too much land in proportion to the area of a single house
spaghetti house
-this example combines interesting form with the use of flexible local materials -moreover, the structure is formed by the repetition of the same element
17
-difficult to achieve the angle without the use of temporary structural elements
mangrovia
-the exterior shape of the building is the structure, therefore there are no internal beams -the use of limited modules simplifies the construction
18
-the pyramid shape is not as wind resistant as the polygonal shape -the use of private staircases increases the cost
pyramid
-the units are facing outwards maximizing the amount of daylight & offering interesting views
19
-the position of the balconies in the interior side of the building does not allow for views to the landscape
octagon original
-this typology has the most wind resistant structure
20
the proposal - floor plan - elevation architectural details and structural plan - foundation plan - floor frame - roof frame - exploded view - footing detail - wall detail - masterplan
2121
B 1,5m
6
c
0,9 m +2.60m
b
5
4
1
1,3m
6,4m
2
4,2m
0,9 m
2,2m
6
a d
a'
c' d' e' g' h'
f'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
scale 1:200
b'
C A 0,00m
4m
7
e
0,7m
3
D B
LEGEND 1 1. LIVING AREA 2. SLEEPING AREA 3. BATHROOM 4. KITCHENETTE 5. BALCONY 6. STORAGE 7. STAIRCASE
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
E D-2 532
LEGEND 3 a. PRIMARY STRUCTURE b. SECONDARY STRUCTURE “GATES” c. WALL SHEETING WALL d. PRIMARY FOUNDATION
LEGEND 4 a’. PLYWOOD 8cm LEGEND 2 b’. PLYWOOD 5cm A. EMERGENCY EXIT c’. PLYWOOD 4cm B. LOUVERS d’. OPTIONAL INSULATION C. LOUVRE CRANK e’. STAINLESS STEEL D. FOLDABLE SHUTTERS f’. CONCRETE E. STORAGE OF SHUTTERS g’. PLYWOOD SHELL WHEN OPEN WINDOW h’. CORRUGATED METAL
floor plan 2,60 m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
22
7,10 m
D E A B
a'
2,60 m
a b
0,00 m e'
e
c'
g'
f'
h'
7,10 m a
D
b
2m
3,4m
c' b'
C 2,60 m
a' D-1 531
A B
e
26,6m
d'
e'
f'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT scale 1:200
0,00 m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
c
LEGEND 1 1. LIVING AREA 2. SLEEPING AREA 3. BATHROOM 4. KITCHENETTE 5. BALCONY 6. STORAGE 7. STAIRCASE LEGEND 2 A. EMERGENCY EXIT B. LOUVERS C. LOUVRE CRANK D. FOLDABLE SHUTTERS E. STORAGE OF SHUTTERS WHEN OPEN LEGEND 3 a. PRIMARY STRUCTURE b. SECONDARY STRUCTURE “GATES” c. WALL SHEETING WALL d. PRIMARY FOUNDATION LEGEND 4 a’. PLYWOOD 8cm b’. PLYWOOD 5cm c’. PLYWOOD 4cm d’. OPTIONAL INSULATION e’. STAINLESS STEEL f’. CONCRETE g’. PLYWOOD SHELL WINDOW h’. CORRUGATED METAL
sect & elevation
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
23
scale 1:200
2,6m
e
13,
9m
d 4,6m 5,2m 5,8m
5,3m
0,1m
0,1m 0,3m 0,1m
0,3m 0,1m
type a
type b
LEGEND 3 a. PRIMARY STRUCTURE b. SECONDARY STRUCTURE “GATES” c. WALL SHEETING WALL d. PRIMARY FOUNDATION LEGEND 4 a’. PLYWOOD 8cm b’. PLYWOOD 5cm c’. PLYWOOD 4cm d’. OPTIONAL INSULATION e’. STAINLESS STEEL f’. CONCRETE g’. PLYWOOD SHELL WINDOW h’. CORRUGATED METAL
foundation plan
1,1m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
ED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
0,8m
2,3m
5,9m
2,9m
7,3m 6,6m
0,6m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
f'
0,4m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
24
type a type a typeb type a
typeb
b type b
type a 0,7m
2,60 m
D-3 533
type a
type b
type b
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT scale 1:200
variable 0,6m
variable
0,3m
0,2m
0,2m
0,6m
a
variable
type b
type a type a type a
2,60 m
floor frame plan
floor
type a
0,3m
2,5m
+2.60m
0,00 m
0,3m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUC
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
b'
LEGEND 3 a. PRIMARY STRUCTURE b. SECONDARY STRUCTURE “GATES” c. WALL SHEETING WALL d. PRIMARY FOUNDATION LEGEND 4 a’. PLYWOOD 8cm b’. PLYWOOD 5cm c’. PLYWOOD 4cm d’. OPTIONAL INSULATION e’. STAINLESS STEEL f’. CONCRETE g’. PLYWOOD SHELL WINDOW h’. CORRUGATED METAL
25
Y AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
7
2,60 m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
type a
type a type a type a
typeb
a'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
typeb
6,90 m PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONA
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
typeb
type a
D-3 533
0,3m
2,60 m
0,3m
2,5m
type a
type b
type b
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT scale 1:200
2,60 m
variable 0,2m
0,6m
b
type b
variable 0,6m
0,2m
roof frame plan
type a type a typeb type a
a
variable
type b
type a type a type a 0,3m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUC
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
roof
0,00 m
LEGEND 3 a. PRIMARY STRUCTURE b. SECONDARY STRUCTURE “GATES” c. WALL SHEETING WALL d. PRIMARY FOUNDATION LEGEND 4 a’. PLYWOOD 8cm b’. PLYWOOD 5cm c’. PLYWOOD 4cm d’. OPTIONAL INSULATION e’. STAINLESS STEEL f’. CONCRETE g’. PLYWOOD SHELL WINDOW h’. CORRUGATED METAL
26
Y AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
type a
b'
type a
h'
7
2,60 m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
type a type a type a
typeb
a'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
typeb
6,90 m PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONA
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
type b
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
contour diagram 27
The structure is formed from individal gates which are assemblesd in a countour type construction: The above is an example of one indivual housing unit and how it is inserted within the whole structure. In total there are eight units per structure.
operable louvers
interior walls finish floor
secondary structure - “gates
primary structure
exploded view
foldable shutters
28
pin foundations
an exploded view of the buildings structure.
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
60 20
20
stainless steel through bolt to secure primary member to post
20
concrete in-situ footing
stainless steel piles 10
30
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
scale 1:20
footing D - 1
10
stainless steel post base cast into concrete foundation
10
10
40 70
80
30
60
10
40
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
8cm plywood primary structure
10
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
29
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT 4cm plywood wall panel
20
70
8cm plywood primary structure
5cm plywood secondary structure PRODUCED BY AN
D -2
20 80
4cm plywood wall panel optional wall insulation
20
30
4cm plywood floor finish optional floor insulation 4cm plywood 5cm plywood secondary structure
30
8cm plywood primary structure
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
scale 1:20
40
20
100
10
AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
5cm plywood secondary structure
70
UCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
20
D -3
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
optional insulation
D-2
wall D - 2 & 3
10
10
30
D-3
31
masterplan
cnc technology - cnc process
3232
cnc process Computer Numerical Controlled tooling machines are devices which are fed numerical information via a computer, then which respond by cutting a material of choice. Typical configurations consist of a cutting tool mounted to a series of tracks or arms which move above a flat bed which holds the material. CNC machines are very quick and precise, giving them the abiity to mass produce very accurate components.
33
cnc process How the CNC will be beneficial to the production of houses in the Philippines: the CNC machines will give inhabitants of the Philippines many positive aspects to building their own homes. The CNC will give the inhabitants the ability to create all the components of their homes from a set of computer drawings. Each part will be constructed from a flat sheet of plywood. Each part will fit specifically together in a “Jig-Saw� puzze fashion. The CNC will also give the inhabitants the abiity to replace parts if they become damaged in severe conditions. Creating homes using a CNC machine will give the inhabitants the ability to produce homes quickly and on a very low budget.
34
cnc process -CNC technology allows the direct replacement of every different part that might be damaged or destroyed by a potential typhoon. -the different parts are effectively arranged on the plywood sheet in order to minimize the waste of material. -the compartments are produced according to the needs, which means there is a “smart� management of time with minimum financial cost.
35
building technology - structural beam - structural joints - nesting - plumbing and electrical plan - plumbing and electrical section
3636
structural beam 37
The structural timber beams are jointed by steel bracket, bolted into place Waste and service pipes run along the structural beams, thus minimizing structural interruption and provide support for the piping Service pipes are attached with steel ties
structural joints 38
Dove Tail joints are located on the different elements of the spiral staircase to prevent horizontal movement
Plug joints are used for vertical joints for the different sections of the gate system
structural joints 39
A third element is introduced to provide more surface area to the joint and help stabilize the structure
This element is cut to interlock with the main structural beam and the two adjacent gates
The gates intersect with the main beam and interlock with each other, creating a stable dove tail joint
Completed Joint
The use of CNC Nesting software minimizes material wastage Cuts are made to maximize strength of joints ensuring joints are not located on weak points of the structure
nesting
Units can be stored and transported easier when cut into smaller pieces
40
41
plumbing / elec
plumbing / elec
-this typology has the most wind resistant structure -the frame of the building is also its structure
42
43
plumbing / elec
cost analysis The cost of construction for this building will be relatively inexpensive because of the building technologies and materials which will be implemented. The manufacturing of the parts of this structure will be performed by a CNC machine. This process eliminates much of the manual labor of the manufacturing of parts. Plywood is the primary material for the structure of the building with use of corrugated steel as a waterproofing membrane. Plywood is a relatively inexpensive material which can be easily shipped to any construction site. 4444
Labor:
Plywood will be used for the primary structural and sheathing materials in this project. Price of plywood in Philippines: 6 Euro/sheet Number of sheets used in project: 388
Since the CNC machine eliminates much of the labor incurred during manufacturing of parts, the price of construction labor will be very minimal. The CNC machine and software uses a process call nesting which will allow minimal waste during the manufacturing of individual pieces.
cost analysis
Materials:
= 2,328 Euro (8 Units)
= 291 Euro per unit
45
The above is an example of nesting from one structural gate. Very minimal outside hired labor will be performed during the physical assembly of these units. Local people who will inhabit the structures will perform the labor almost eliminating all outside construction labor cost
-How is this process cheaper? This process of using the CNC to manufacture parts and local labor will be cheaper than traditional building processes for several reasons. 1) These units are manufactured in a way in which they will be able to withstand natural disasters such as typhoons, flooding and tsunami. This will eliminate the need to rebuild a whole home everytime a natural disaster occurs. 2) Each structure provides space to eight individual family homes. This eliminates much of the extra material needed to construct eight individual units. 3) The use of the CNC machine will simplify the manufacturing process by reducing the need of manual labor. 4) Using low cost materials such as plywood, which is readily available, will eliminate much of the need to ship materials from further locations which will increase construction cost.
cost analysis
-Selling Cost per Unit Selling cost per unit will be essentially the cost of materials.
46
No price increase will be made with these units because it is the people who inhabit the structures who will be constructing them.
renders
4747
48
field view
49
field view
50
interior view
LEGEND 2 A emergency exit B louvers C louver crank D foldable shutters E storage of shutters when open
f'
0,8m
e
LEGEND 3 a primary structure b secondary structure - “gates” c wall sheeting d primary foundation e foundation for emergency exit LEGEND 4 a’ plywood 8cm b’ plywood 5cm c’ plywood 4cm d’ optional insulation e’ stainless steel f’ concrete g’ plywood shell window h’ corrugated metal
1,1m
13,
9m
d 4,6m 5,2m
far perspective - 521 foundations
LEGEND 1 1 living area 2 sleeping area 3 bathroom 4 kitchenette 5 balcony 6 storage 7 staircase
5,8m
51
5,3m
52
flooded view
picernocerasolab
53