Solar+Storage: The New MidMerit Generation Resource Dr. Colleen Lueken Director of Market Analytics, Fluence October 15, 2018
Summary • Introduction to Fluence • What do I mean by solar+storage? Specifically, co-located, utility-scale energy storage and solar PV
• What is the value proposition for solar+storage and how is it changing? Established that energy storage is a viable alternative to gas peakers Annual US energy storage deployments expected to reach 3.9 GW by 2023 (GTM Research) Solar prices coming down, but marginal unit of non-dispatchable solar energy is becoming less valuable to grid Now with abundant and cheap solar PV, solar+storage becoming a viable alternative to mid-merit generation
2
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Fluence is the global leader in energy storage
10+ Years
16 Countries 60+ Projects
500+ MW
30 MW of energy storage for San Diego Gas & Electric, California, United States
Largest energy storage project in North America • • •
30 MW / 120 MWh Contract to online in 6 months Sited on 1 acre, where a power plant could not be permitted
Storage/Solar+Storage established as peaker alternative Next stop: mid-merit generation such as NGCCs
Peaker
Energy
Solar Mid merit/load following generation
Baseload 24 hour generation dispatch 5
Š Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Why add storage to solar? Firm Capacity. As more solar comes online, every additional MW of solar capacity will be valued less • “Duck Curve” Forecast from 2012
Source: CAISO 6
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
• Duck Curve Realization - 2017
Source: EIA
What is solar+storage? AC versus DC Coupling AC Coupled
7
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved.
DC Coupled
How do you decide if DC coupling is the right choice? DC coupled has several advantages though may place restrictions on commercial capabilities.
8
Š Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved.
What does a DC-coupled solar+storage plant look like? Typical block size of ~3 MW
3 MW
500 kW each Up to 3 MW 3-6 MW 9
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved.
(Solar only example)
Clipped energy capture: Maximizing Solar Energy to Grid with Storage
10
Š Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Primary applications of DC-coupled solar+storage Renewable Firming and Flexible Peaking Capacity
Renewable Ramp Rate Smoothing
MW
Solar PV to Battery
Battery to Grid
Load
Solar PV to Grid
TIME OF DAY
Secondary Applications • Stacking of real power ancillary services applications, such as frequency regulation or contingency service. • Stacking of reactive power ancillary services applications, such as the Dynamic VAR modes. 11
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Solar+Storage vs Gas Peaker Net cost of capacity methodology • Methodology compares storage or solar+storage capacity payment to traditional gas peaker • “Steps” account for the additional benefit accrued to the storage option compared to the gas peaker • For example, solar+storage provides $1/kW-mo in RECs value ($0 for gas) • Net Cost of Capacity = Cost net of benefits/Total MW Capacity
Net Cost of Capacity Increase
Decrease
Total
14
12
10
8
12
-1.5
-2.5
7 -1
6
4
2
0 12
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Ancillary services… RECs value Capacity payment Reduced energy cost Net cost of capacity
An advantage of being always on and synchronized to the grid is being able to provide ancillary services more often than an NGCC • Solar+Storage 24 hr dispatch
13
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
• Average 24 hour dispatch of NGCCs
Solar+Storage vs Gas Peaker Net cost of capacity methodology • Methodology compares storage or solar+storage capacity payment to traditional gas peaker • “Steps” account for the additional benefit accrued to the storage option compared to the gas peaker • For example, solar+storage provides $1/kW-mo in RECs value ($0 for gas) • Net Cost of Capacity = Cost net of benefits/Total MW Capacity
Net Cost of Capacity Increase
Decrease
Total
14
12
10
8
12
-1.5
-2.5
7 -1
6
4
2
0 14
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Ancillary services… RECs value Capacity payment Reduced energy cost Net cost of capacity
The price for “fuel” is coming down while the price of gas is staying constant (and could always rise)
Source: U.S. Utility PV Market Tracker 15
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Solar+Storage vs Gas Peaker Net cost of capacity methodology • Methodology compares storage or solar+storage capacity payment to traditional gas peaker • “Steps” account for the additional benefit accrued to the storage option compared to the gas peaker • For example, solar+storage provides $1/kW-mo in RECs value ($0 for gas) • Net Cost of Capacity = Cost net of benefits/Total MW Capacity
(Values are for example only) Net Cost of Capacity Increase
Decrease
Total
14
12
10
8
12
-1.5
-2.5
7 -1
6
4
2
0 16
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Ancillary services… RECs value Capacity payment Reduced energy cost Net cost of capacity
Solar+Storage vs. NGCC
(Values are for example only)
Net-LCOE Methodology • Compare solar+storage and combined cycle plants with similar total energy production and cycles (requires analyzing NGCC capacity factors and generation profiles and modeling a solar+storage plant that provides a like profile) • Consider any ancillary services or other values that either plant can provide as reductions in total capital cost • Net - LCOE is the average cost of each MWh of energy provided over the plant lifetime • Net LCOE = Net lifetime cost/Total MWh Delivered 17
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Net Cost of Energy Increase
Decrease
Total
120
100
80
60
100
15
-15
80
-20
40
20
0
t t … lue os os EX s c a P C v e ce al eO rvi tim me pit i m e t e i a f t s li fe C e et Lif s li ary l l N i C c RE An
Conclusion • Solar+Storage already competitive with mid-merit generation in some markets • Depends on the capacity factors of the NGCCs and the solar resource • Net LCOE is a metric that can be used to compare two generation resources with similar generation profiles but different capabilities
18
© Fluence Energy LLC. All Rights Reserved. / Confidential
Thank You Learn more: blog.fluenceenergy.com
19
PT-001-02-EN