PRO 19-08-2012_Layout 1 8/19/2012 4:52 AM Page 1
Sunday, 19 August, 2012
Spain wants to have the cake,
EAT IT AND YET ASK FOR MORE ‘There must be no limit set on ECB bond buying’ MADRID AGENCIES
There can be no limit set or at least (the ECB) can’t say how much they will use or for how long,” when it buys bonds in the secondary markets, Luis de Guindos told Spanish news agency EFE. The Spanish government will study the details of the ECB’s debt-buying program, which are likely to be outlined before the Eurogroup meeting mid-September, before making a decision on applying for more European aid, de Guindos said. Spain is at the centre of the euro zone debt crisis on concerns it may need a full bailout, which could stretch euro funds to breaking point, on top of up to 100 billion euros ($122.97 billion) it has already requested for its struggling banks. Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy has said his government would study any measures by the ECB and the potential conditions attached to any EU aid before deciding whether to apply for help. In response to a renewed intensification of the debt crisis, ECB President Mario Draghi said on August 2 the ECB may buy more government bonds, but only once countries had turned to the bloc’s rescue funds for help and agreed to strict conditions. “I believe Spain has presented its budget adjustment program and its structural reforms, which from a general point of view, have been accepted as sufficient and appropriate,” de Guindos said.
Rajoy has introduced austerity measures worth around 10 percent of GDP to reduce the public deficit to within EUguidelines of below 3 percent of GDP by end-2014 as well as reforms to the financial system and labor markets. The yield on Spain’s benchmark 10year bond fell to its lowest level since early July on Friday after German Chancellor Angela Merkel voiced support for the ECB’s crisis-fighting strategy, reinforcing expectations of ECB interventions. The central banks has barely used its existing bond-buy plan this year and has bought no bonds for 22 weeks despite an intensification of the euro zone debt crisis. REGIONAL AID: Spain’s public deficit leapt to 8.9 percent of gross domestic product in 2011 due, in part, to overspending by its 17 politically autonomous regions and spooking investors which have since virtually priced the regions out of debt markets. Madrid passed an 18-billion-euro program mid-July to help the regions which, together with the country’s local authorities, account for around half of all public spending and face debt redemptions of some 36 billion euros this year. The state lottery would raise 6 billion euros via a syndicated loan in the next few days to feed in to the liquidity program, de Guindos said in the interview. The government of the Mediterranean region of Murcia became the second authority ask Madrid for help on Friday, saying it may need as much as
GREECE GOES GUNG-HO
THE SIMMERING APPLE PIE
‘Budget breather for Greece would spur economic recovery’
‘Apple fires closing shots at Samsung in patents battle’
ATHENS AGENCIES
The estimate chimes with the view of Greek Prime Minister Antonis Samaras who has tried, unsuccessfully, to win such an extension in the past and is expected to refloat the proposal next week with the leaders of France and Germany as well as with JeanClaude Juncker, the Eurogroup chief. Under the terms of its European Union/International Monetary Fund bailout, Greece is bound to implement painful austerity measures to bring its budget deficit below 3 percent of GDP by the end of 2014, from an expected 9.3 percent of GDP this year. But with the country in its fifth consecutive year of recession and social and political discontent rising, Samaras is keen to soften the impact of budget cuts on society by extending the deadline international lenders set it. The latest estimate, reported by the Imerisia newspaper, cited calculations by finance ministry officials it did not name, saying they had worked out that a two-year extension would help the economy shrink at a slower pace in 2013 and rebound quicker from 2014. Under such a scenario, the economy would shrink by 1.5 percent in 2013 and grow by 2 percent in 2014, the newspaper said. If no extension was granted, the economy would contract by up to 4.5 percent next year and not recover before 2015, it said. Greece’s ability to service its debt is seen by its politicians as something that can only be facilitated by growth as its lenders will only continue bankrolling it if it makes all the necessary budget cuts and reform measures to reduce its debt to 120 percent of GDP by 2020 from 165 percent in 2013.
SAN JOSE
patents, which are related to wireless communications for smartphones and are broadly licensed to Intel Corp and Richard Donaldson, a former lead other technology corporations. Apple, patents attorney for Texas Instruments meanwhile, accuses Samsung of copying Inc, told the court on Friday a 2.4 percent the design and some features of its iPad royalty Samsung wanted on the price of and iPhone. The former Texas Instruments execthe iPhone was discriminatory because the patents in question enabled just a utive joined a string of rebuttal expert witnesses that Apple presented in court fraction of the smartphone’ s features. Later, New York University profes- in the closing hours of the U.S. legal batsor Janusz Ordover likened that rate - tle with its South Korean rival. Closing arguments and jury deliberequivalent to $14 per $600 iPhone - to a “holdup.” “Samsung’s conduct distorted ations are set to begin next week. The court battle is a facet of a bigthe decision making process” in setting standards, said Ordover, a former ger war for supremacy in the mobile deputy assistant attorney general for the market between the two corporations, Justice Department’s antitrust division. which sell more than half the world’s smartphones. The mobile market is “It enabled Samsung’s technology to one of fastest growing and most lucrabe introduced, to become part of tive in technology sector. “If other the standard. They have accompanies were to determine that this quired holdup power.” is a reasonable royalty, then the total Samsung accuses Apple royalty on the iPhone would be someof infringing thing like 50 percent,” Donthose aldson testified. “It’s Samsung Electronics Co neither fair nor reasonable because you could Ltd abused its “monopoly not be successful in the market.” power” and demanded Other expert witnesses inan unreasonable royalty cluded Michael Walker, a former senior Vodafone Group Plc refrom Apple Inc for the search executive, who from use of wireless patents 2008 to 2011 chaired the European telecoms stanin the iPhone, hurting dards authority. He said Samsung failed to disthe device’s commercial close in a timely fashion prospects, Apple the patents referred to by Donaldson. experts testified During cross examination, Samsung lawyer Charles VerhoAGENCIES
even probed the idea that trade secrets and confid e n t i a l information were exempt from a requirement for full and timely disclosure. In any case, the South Korean company had never come u n d e r scrutiny from the standardssetting agency on that issue, he said. The courtroom battle has transfixed insiders since July. Apple is demanding more than $2.5 billion in damages and a sales ban, while its rival is demanding licensing fees. Samsung also says Apple’s damages should be calculated not on gross margins, but after all other costs - such as marketing - are factored in. The trial in San Jose in the heart of Silicon Valley has offered glimpses into the two huge corporate machines - from their design and marketing processes to the profits they make on devices. MONOPOLY POWER? Standing on the sidelines is Google Inc, whose Android software powers
The European Central Bank must take forceful and unlimited steps to buy sovereign debt to help Spain reduce its refinancing costs and eliminate doubts over the euro zone’s future, Spain’s economy minister said in comments published on Saturday 700 million euros in 2012. Murcia follows Valencia, which said at the end of July it will need to apply to the fund. Spain’s largest region of Catalonia has also said it was studying whether apply for cash from the fund. Murcia will soon ask for around 85 million euros to cover debt redemptions and 225 million euros to finance its firsthalf deficit, though could request another 400 million before the end of the year, they said on Friday.
most of Samsung’s phones and is said by analysts to be an indirect target of Apple’s legal assault against the South Korean company in a multiple of countries. Tensions have run high with so much at stake, but the trial has offered some levity. Judge Lucy Koh asked whether Apple lawyer Bill Lee was “smoking crack” after he presented a 75-page list of witnesses, a quip that came up again to much good-natured chuckling - including from Lee himself - on Friday. Friday’s testimony centered on the concept of standards or essential patents - intellectual property built into a commonly agreed set of specifications - and in this case, the UMTS wireless communications standard used worldwide by mobile devices. Professor Ordover testified that standards essential patents - a point of contention in a global market where corporations constantly seek an edge - have enormous benefits to consumers and manufacturers. But they also have “potential risk” and can be abused. Ordover argued that Samsung unfairly wielded its two patents against Apple. Apple’s lawyers argue that Samsung - a member of the body that crafted UMTS standards in 2005 - is charging an unfairly high licensing fee for those patents, in effect trying to stymie market advances. Samsung says the patents are intellectual property for which it rightly requires compensation.