QMessenger Issue 52

Page 1

Issue 52

“Wow guys”: The end of an era The second Sabb interview. Page 4

Monday January 16 2012

QMessenger looks at the bid to grant Tower Hamlets city status. Page 5

Moral or sexist? Does moral censorship distort our view of female sexuality? Page 7

The Newspaper of Queen Mary Students’ Union

Students say no to assisted suicide » Only 32% of students questioned would give a diagnosis that would allow patients the ‘right’ to die

Chris Smith MPs should not change the law on assisted suicide in favour of terminally ill patients, despite a report released this month by The Commission on Assisted Dying, according to a survey of QM students. The report chaired by the former Lord Chancellor Lord Falconer, and partially funded by Terry Pratchett, recommends a legal framework on how a person diagnosed with less than 12 months to live may commit suicide as long as strict conditions are met. However, two thirds of medical students surveyed at Barts and The London said that, when qualified, they would not agree with diagnosing a patient as having less than 12 months to live, which would allow them to end their lives. Several students commented that, while an end of life diagnosis is usually accurate, people will continue to defy statistics and live past that; assisted suicide would take away this extension of life. New cures and therapies could also be released which could significantly improve a patients quality of life. “This issue will not be resolved any time soon”, Professor Richard Trembath, Dean of Medicine at Barts and The London told QMessenger. “[Assisted suicide] is contentious and very emotive to so many people.” The Ministry of Justice said that is “a matter for

parliament to decide rather than government policy.” The report’s recommendations stipulate that two independent doctors must be satisfied with the diagnosis and that the patient is aware of all of the social and medical help available, able to make the decision voluntarily, not acting under the influence of mental illness an is able to take their medication without help from others. The current law holds that assisted suicide is punishable by up to 14 years in prison. However since new guidelines two years ago, the Crown Prosecution Service have turned a blind eye to over 30 cases. While these recommendations would clear up a very ‘sticky’ area of the law, it would not benefit all. The conditions are narrow and would not benefit cases such as that of Daniel James, who was paralysed after a rugby accident and chose to end his life at the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland. The validity of the report has been questioned because it was funded by supporters of assisted suicide and nine of the 12 members of the commission already supported a change in the law.

nuary a J d r 3 2 y Monda

68 % of medical students said that they would not diagnose a life expectancy of 12 months or less under the proposals

The report by Lord Falconer recommends a framework on how a person with less than 12 months to live may commit suicide. Image by sparrowsfall by Flickr(cc)


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.