Monday September 26th 2011
Should the London rioters be punished? Comment, p. 7
Students left homeless as London halls run short News, p. 5
The Newspaper of Queen Mary Students’ Union
The Rundown QMSU passes new election regulations The last Student Council passed the new set of regulations which will determine how this year’s Union elections are run. p. 3
www.qmessenger.co.uk
How did Queen Mary really do in the NSS?
Room booking fiasco
Changes in room booking procedures are seeing student events forced to be cancelled. p.3
First UGM called
QMSU has announced the date of the year’s first General Meeting as October 10th. p. 3
Rogue landlords and super sheds
Tower Hamlets Council vows to crack down on poor housing conditions p.4
Uni home swap
Students have started flying one coop for another to save on living costs. p. 4
Halls shortages
Many students left in the lurch as universities across the capital come up short in offering accommodation. p. 5
National demo called
The National Campaign Against Fees and Cuts has called for students to turn out and march on November 9th. p. 6
New initiative to improve QM prospects The career prospects of QM graduates has been falling, is the Graduate Attributes scheme the answer? p. 12
Every year, final year students take part in the National Student Survey - but are their views really being listened to? Image by Robert Pritchard.
Lara Lavattiata Queen Mary scored five percent above the national average in the latest National Student Survey (NSS). However, the process with which NSS collects its data means that the results may obscure, rather than reveal, student opinion of their departments. Question 22 of the NSS asks final year students to rate their “overall satisfaction” with their institution. This is the statistic that departments use when publicising their student satisfaction levels. However, when the answers given to question 22 are compared to those given to the first 21 questions - which look at specific aspects of academic support, quality of teaching and assessment and feedback - it can be seen that the results of ques-
Issue 40
tion 22 are disproportionately high. On average, the answers students gave about how satisfied they were overall ranked 10% higher than the average of their answers to all other questions about specific elements of student satisfaction. The problem with departments using overall satisfaction data to rank themselves is that this figure takes into account extra-curricular activities. This could account for the disparity between average mark for questions 1 to 21 and question 22. Therefore, question 22 may be considered indicative of the performance of the institution as a whole, but not of individual departments. Professor Susan Dilly, Vice Principal for Teaching and Learning at Queen Mary said: “I am pleased that QM has improved in the NSS
scores this year and believe that this is a fair reflection of the many initiatives across the College to improve the student experience. I do, however, agree that the survey is really only an opinion poll and not a rigourously structured piece of research so you need to be cautious when drawing conclusions.” The published results for Biology, Aerospace Engineering, and International Relations were all 20% higher than their actual scores with the score for the Biology department’s 100% score standing out quite clearly. Medicine at Queen Mary ranked eighth out of 32 medical schools, above the prestigious Cambridge University which is generally considered to be one of the best universities for medicine.
Continued on page 2...
QM vindicates generations of complaining men Sam Creighton Queen Mary researchers have proven that ‘man flu’ does, in fact, exist. Dr. Scotland, of the William Harvey Research Institute, has been studying the immune systems of mice when exposed to different infections and has uncovered the fact that the male immune system is less effective than its female counterpart. Dr. Scotland’s team studied the white blood cells in the lungs and stomachs of the animals, where the first line of defence agaisnt invading infections occurs. They found that females had twice as many white blood cells and that these cells acted more effectively than those belonging to males. Crucially, females did not release as many of the chemicals that stimulte immune system response, and it is the release of these chemicals that make you feel unwell. Dr Scotland said: “Man flu is a bit of a joke, but from what I’m seeing there is a real difference.” QMessenger is not asserting however that men are not guilty of exaggerating the severity of their illnesses in order to garner sympathy, because that would be a lie...