The Queen's Journal, Volume 151, Issue 15

Page 1

the journal Queen’s University

Vol. 151, Issue 15

F r i day , N ov e m b e r 2 4 , 2 0 2 3

Philosophy professor removed after accomodations battle, academic freedom in question

‘My course has been hijacked’

Sophia Coppolino Senior News Editor It’s been an illogical semester for PHIL 260 students. StudentsenrolledinIntroduction to Logic were informed their professor Adèle Mercier had been removed in an email sent to them on

Nov. 20. In the email, Faculty of Arts and Science Associate Dean (Academic) Jenn Stephenson told students to attend their Wednesday class for updates. The change in instructor followed a month-long battle between Mercier and the Faculty of Arts and Science over students’ accommodations for the midterm exam. The evening before the midterm, students

University focused on settling Bader College students in Kingston

The closure was announced on Nov. 13.

Two weeks have passed since Bader College closed Sophia Coppolino Senior News Editor Students are returning home from Bader College and the University is footing the bill. Following the announcement closing Bader College on Nov. 13, Provost Matthew Evans clarified the situation in the United Kingdom is evolving. Queen’s is covering all “reasonable expenses” for students evacuating Bader College, including cancellation charges, flights or transportation change fees, and previously scheduled non-refundable flights. Students have been asked to keep all their travel receipts. “We are committed to ensuring the University’s decision to suspend activities in the castle building will not financially disadvantage students and families,” Evans said in a statement to The Journal. For the remainder of the fall term, Bader students will complete their studies online. Spaces will be made for students in courses being held on main campus in Kingston for the winter term. Bader students will receive a 50 per cent credit of their fall term room and board fees and a full refund of the Fall Bader College Field Studies fee, but not fall tuition because their instruction will continue in a revised format. Every Bader student will receive what Evans called a “disruption payment” from the University. He didn’t specify the amount to The Journal. Queen’s identified over 110 queensjournal.ca

SUPPLIED BY JOHN LAFRAMBOISE

residence spaces of various room types which will be made available to Bader students. Bader students who want to live off campus in the winter can work with the Off-Campus Living Advisor Adam King to locate sublets or other housing options. “We’re working hard to maximize residence capacity, and between residence rooms and off-campus housing options, we will ensure all students have a place to live for the winter term,” Evans said. There’s a Kingston team planning to welcome Bader students in January. Many former Bader students will connect with newly arrived Bader students through Queen’s Bader College Transition Program. “Activities will include social connections, access to clubs, intramurals, and other extra-curriculars, and support for finding on-campus jobs,” Evans added. No decisions have been made about the status of staff and faculty employed by Bader College in the United Kingdom. A full survey of the castle will be conducted in early 2024, at which point the University will have more information on when they can resume in-person operations. Evans acknowledged the sudden closure is difficult for Bader students and their families. “Staff in Student Affairs, and the faculties, as well as the team at Bader College, are working hard to ensure a smooth transition for students, and we will continue to provide updates to students and their families as more information becomes available,” Evans said. @queensjournal

to modify the exam format, citing infringement on academic autonomy and the adverse impact on students who were prepared to write a computerized midterm. Mercier told the Exams Office despite their advisory, she was going to offer students the option of a paper-based or computerized exam. She maintained students who required the use of their laptops for exams would be allowed to do so in her classroom. The Exam Office told Mercier this wasn’t an option. They reiterated all non-accommodated students had to write a paper-based exam. As for accommodated students, they gave her two options: let the Exam Office step in, or privately administer the computerized exam meeting all the students’ accommodations. Mercier chose the latter. “We’d been booking Gordon Hall 400 for those who had accommodations for private rooms or dim lights or things like that, and they could bring their own laptop to Gordon Hall. We arranged our own proctors so that everyone gets to write the exam on the computer,” Chen said. As students prepared for their exam the following morning, they received an email from Haley Everson, faculty associate director (academic consideration, appeals and advising) cancelling the exam. Two days later, students received an update, apologizing for the disruption and claiming the faculty was “working with Professor Mercier and the Exams Office to set up exams that meet Queen’s accessibility requirements.” They claimed the decision was made due to a scheduling conflict between the exam time for students with academic accommodations and their other classes. In her own email to students explaining the cancellation, Mercier told students the “para-academics

Situated on the

traditional lands of

the Anishinaabe and

Haudenosaunee peoples.

Since 1873

FEATURES

Exploring the Jewish Diaspora after October 7 PAGE 4

EDITORIALS

received an email cancelling the exam for 8:30 a.m. on Nov. 1. The cancellation came as a surprise Elitism is running to students—and to Mercier. rampant at Queen’s “The students are very upset, and I’ve been telling them I’m PAGE 5 upset too. But there’s nothing we can do because my course has been hijacked,” Mercier said in an interview with The Journal. The painful legacy Since her interview on of a dying artist Nov. 17, Mercier has been instructed not to speak to the media. Her PAGE 7 replacement, Adjunct Assistant Professor Mark Smith, is now at the helm of the course. Mercier’s teaching assistant, Tianze Chen, was dismissed and replaced by the “He hit me and it felt like a University this week. kiss—until it didn’t.” *** It all started when Mercier PAGE 12 decided to modernize her exam to accommodate two students enrolled in PHIL 260 requiring a ArtSci ’26, said in an interview computer to write examinations. with The Journal. “I think confusion Mercier and Chen worked all is the strongest feeling. People I’m semester to computerize the close with are frustrated.” students’ exam, using a “cheat Like many of his peers, Hash proof” software. Students have been was prepared for a computerized using the software throughout the midterm. He expressed frustration semester to complete homework at its sudden cancellation exercises. Logic exams are difficult with minimal explanation and to write on a computer because competing narratives. the discipline uses symbols not In an email obtained by The familiar to most word processors, Journal, a student in the class Mercier explained. told Mercier they withdrew their “The only way to cheat is if you accommodations because they “felt had, for example, two computers, the alternatives [she] gave were just you could sign into the homework fine and very fair.” mode of the program and have Hash described Mercier as access to all the checking functions. an inspiring professor. In classes, During the exam, the homework he reported there was back-andfunction is disabled, and we can forth between Mercier and the tell when you’re doing the exam, students, creating an energizing that you’re staying on atmosphere. Mercier the exam,” Mercier said. has been teaching logic On Oct. 26, Mercier at Queen’s since 1994. contacted the Exams “I think there’s Office to inform them a lot of love for Dr. of the new format for Mercier,” Hash said. the midterm exam. “As she herself puts it, Problems arose when she’s one of the only Mercier learned women doing in policies restricted the philosophy what Exams Office from she’s doing, which is allowing students teaching logic. It’s a very with accommodations male-dominated field to use their personal and she’s been doing it, JOURNAL FILE PHOTO from what I can computers to complete Professor Adele Mercier. exams. To adhere tell, fantastically to the policy, the Exams Office [are running] the show now, not for 30 years. I think there’s a required all students enrolled your professors,” and she was lot of respect for her in in the course to revert to a “gravely disturbed by ever the classroom.” paper-based exam. increasing infantilization Another student who contacted “I don’t see how they have the of students, and Mercier after the cancellation told authority to tell a professor you victimhood-fostering attitudes her the situation was an “attack must have a paper-based exam,” towards persons with disabilities.” by Queen’s towards [her] teaching, Mercier said. *** character, and class” and was of “I don’t see how they’re doing With their midterm exam in “utmost disrespect.” their jobs of helping faculty limbo, PHIL 260 students were In emails, Mercier’s replacement accommodate students, if that slapped with a 100 per cent final by her former student Smith involves dictating to professors exam. The course is a requirement brings certainty to what has how they are to perform their for philosophy majors, and students been a confusing situation. On exams, what kind of exams they were stressed. Nov. 22, Associate Dean Stephenson are to give […] it is not part of “I was confused, I thought introduced the new professor and their competence.” maybe we would be getting an told students they had options. In response, Mercier filed an explanation of some sort from See Mercier on page 3 official complaint, objecting to the the University but that didn’t end imposition of “para-academics” up happening,” Nicholas Hash, @queensjournal

@queensjournal

ARTS

LIFESTYLE

@thequeensjournal


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Queen's Journal, Volume 151, Issue 15 by The Queen's Journal - Issuu