#UnlockRail
Milda Manomaityte Sharon Odetunde Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Head of Partnerships RSSB
Niall Fagan Head of Engineering Capital Delivery Eastern
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Railway Industry Association / Rail Safety and Standards Board
Unlocking Innovation: Testing and Validation Niall Fagan
Engineering Excellence and Innovation
5th December 2023
Eastern Region
OFFICIAL
Who am I and what is the relevance? Head of Engineering, Capital Delivery Eastern •
Civil Engineer… Track Engineer!
•
Maintenance, renewals, major projects and HQ functions (Technology Manager [Track]) ➢ Helped set up the Innovation Process in NR (2011)
My focus • Getting Engineers to Engineer • Think critically, evaluate data and facts • Make informed decisions ➢ Includes challenging standards and producing outcome-based specifications
As engineers, we need to be more innovative
Conservative standards and gold-plated specifications drive costs and can shackle innovation
OFFICIAL
Network Rail Capital Delivery Eastern •
Over £1bn spend every year
•
From like-for-like renewals to Kings Cross Remodelling to Midland Mainline Electrification
•
From to signalling upgrades to AFA schemes (footbridges/lifts) to Werrington Grade Separation
Our focus •
Delivering required outputs for passengers and freight
•
Retaining Client ownership whilst empowering the Supply Chain
•
Value for money (efficiencies - SPEED)
•
Digital Transformation
•
Strong performance through engineering excellence & innovation
OFFICIAL
So why the need for Engineering Excellence & Innovation? Last 18 months in the UK • Period of political uncertainty • £60bn black hole in public finances
£
• ‘Cost of living crises’ • Interest rates soared to highest level in over 15 years Strong political support (funding) for the railways is essential
➢ We need to ensure every pound spent is value for money!
Unlocking innovation is a key part of how we will deliver efficiencies and value for money
OFFICIAL
The Railway is a Complex System… with multiple interactions
Operating Conditions
Loading
Constraints
• • • •
Trains per hour Speed Reliability Availability
• Internal (Trains etc) • External (Climate) • Asset behaviour/deterioration • • • •
Environment Topography Population density Political influence
Power EMC
Train
Noise
Comms
Track
Control Systems Earthworks
Vibration Structures
Important to consider system risks and understand potential impacts of any proposed changes 8
OFFICIAL
Improving Railway Performance through Innovation Better reliability and resilience A safe, reliable, high performing railway at lower costs will require innovation, potentially new technology, ways of working… and challenging standards
Research and Innovation Proven Technology
RISK
Collaboration is key – IMs, Suppliers, UKRRIN Universities/Laboratories Theory/Model
Physical Testing
Industry (NR/Routes/Region/Suppliers) In-situ Trials Product Acceptance
Operations
OFFICIAL
Improving Railway Performance through Innovation Access to the operational railway has become harder and therefore we need to make more use of specialist test centres • NR Rail Innovation & Development Centres
• Black Country Innovative Manufacturing Organisation
Specialist Test Centres
Industry (NR/Routes/Region/Suppliers)
Physical Testing
In-situ Trials
Operations
Product Acceptance BCIMO
• South Wales, Global Centre for Rail Excellence • Long Marston Rail Innovation Centre
Asfordby Tunnel
Dynamic loading – speed and tonnage Long term deterioration Seasonal effects
However, it is also important to understand the limitations
OFFICIAL
Challenging Standards to Unlock Innovation Unlock potential efficiencies… but must be done in the right way • Understand Engineering principles • Know the rationale behind the specific clauses/requirements in the standards
Do they have sandwiches in the future?
• Understand the risks that are being controlled • Evaluate the impact of changing a specific requirement or parameter limit
Use the same approach for Innovation and introducing new ways of working on to the railways From High Speed Rail to conventional rail to light rail The laws of physics don’t change… but the application might!
OFFICIAL
Some final thoughts…. Unlock potential efficiencies… but must be done in the right way • Take a structured approach to innovation, product approval and system integration • What outputs can you get from a specific test track? Be realistic! • What are the limitations – how far away from actual loading conditions? Does it matter? • Can help determine appropriate success criteria for in-situ trials • Align with an NR sponsor if possible
Engineering excellence and Innovation go hand in hand ➢ What are we waiting for?
OFFICIAL
Thank you
13
Professor Duncan Kemp Technical Discipline Lead for Systems Engineering
Ministry of Defence
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Testing and validation – a defence perspective Professor Duncan Kemp, CEng FIET, INCOSE Fellow Defence Equipment and Support
Physical testing is one part of system validation Operational Analysis
Systems modelling
Software in the loop
Hardware in the loop
Physical testing
Testing is not always the best way to validate Trials
Heightened monitoring
Tests
Evidence
Inspection
Models
Integrated Test Evaluation Acceptance Plan Agree requirements
Develop ITEAP
Execute ITEAP
Accept system
FATs
HATs
SIFATs
SATs
Key points • The key question is ask is “what am I validating and why?”
• Testing: • May not provide the best evidence • Provides a small number of data points • Is expensive and may be hazardous
• Other evidence may be better What am I validating and why?
How am I going to provide sufficient evidence?
Who is going to do it? Where and when?
How much is it going to cost? Who is paying what?
Paul Plummer Professor of Rail Strategy BCRRE
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Luisa Moisio Director of Research RSSB
Improving testing and validation Luisa Moisio RSSB
Paul Plummer University of Birmingham 21
What is UKRRIN? The UK Rail Research and Innovation Network is designed to create powerful collaboration between academia and industry, aiming to provide a step-change in innovation in the sector and accelerate new technologies and products from research into market applications globally. •
Supporting and building UK rail capabilities
•
Delivering a step-change in investment in rail innovation
•
Radically increase UK rail productivity
•
Develop new strategic relationships with SMEs, supply chain, rail industry and wider transport sector
Launched in 2018
4 Centres of Excellence
15 Academic Members
19 Industry Partners
22
Who are we? Centre of Excellence in Digital Systems
Centre of Excellence in Rolling Stock
Centre of Excellence in Infrastructure
Affiliate Members
Footer
23
Industry Supporters Founding Members (in order of size of financial contribution)
13
Industry Partners
6
Framework Agreements
2
24
BCRRE vision – concept to impact
Footer
25
BCRRE Themes
Digitalisation
Decarbonisation
Innovation
Education 26
Whole-System Thinking
Business Case Development
System Specification
Testing and Validation
27
RSSB in the testing and validation space
Testing parameters & requirements
Safety insights
Validation & acceptance of digital testing
Navigating the present, shaping the future
Draft
Underway
Introduction to the draft Guidance Why to test What to test
An overview of key factors for consideration in rail when considering testing needs.
How to test – rail systems & Why we test stakeholders
How to test – approaches and technology
Where to test
Guidance on testing in the context of the railway systems and subsystems, and different stakeholders and roles that need considering.
Opportunities to make good use of physical and digital tools, taking advantage of new technology to accelerate the process.
An overview of the test facilities available for testing, covering lab-based facilities, full scale test tracks and heritage rail options.
30
Break 1: Improving Guidance on Testing How to test – rail systems & stakeholders
Why to test Peoples experience in testing for compliance with standards
How to test – approaches and technology
What is needed in terms of guidance in this space?
Where to test 31
Thank you
32
Satnam Thiara Business development manager Rail Innovation & Development Centres, Network Rail
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
OFFICIAL
Rail Innovation & Development Centres (RIDC) RIDC Overview 5 December 2023 Satnam Thiara – RIDC Business Development Manager
Putting passengers first
OFFICIAL
Safety Values
OFFICIAL
1
RIDC Melton
RIDC Melton is a purpose built test track for the testing of rolling stock, plant, on-track machines, infrastructure and equipment. The facility has been designed to support high and low speed testing of vehicles and infrastructure using 25kV (11 miles) overhead line equipment and 3rd/4th rail DC equipment. RIDC Melton has two separate test tracks, high speed test facility between Melton Junction and Edwalton, incorporating 13 miles of track up to 125mph and a slow speed test track from Old Dalby to Stanton tunnel, having 4 miles of track capable of up to 60mph.
Facilities • • • • • • •
3 workshop roads 1 fully pitted road Lifting and jacking facility 415v shore supply Stabling Dedicated office space Ability to change infrastructure characteristics
Available Testing • • • • • • • • • • • •
TSI high speed noise compliant testing Maximum over cant deficiency testing Overspeed testing Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) testing Brake performance testing Wheel Slide Protection (WSP) Single/dual pantograph testing Coupling compatibility testing Rescue and recovery Surge pressure testing in tunnels Low adhesion testing 5G enabled test bed
36
OFFICIAL
5G capability at RIDC Melton Trackside infrastructure • 20km of 432 fibre cable • 16 new trackside masts with cabinets • 14 tunnel and bridges equipment brackets and cabinets • 5 existing GSM-R masts
Innovation hub • Data centre with equipment racks • Internet access 37
OFFICIAL
38
OFFICIAL
39
OFFICIAL
Trial engagement and implementation Scoping and Contract
• Initial enquiry • Discuss concept • Assess technical and test train Enquiry
• Define scope • Commercial proposal • Agree contract
1-2 weeks
3-4 weeks
Approvals • Site surveys • Develop design • Joint review
• Method statements • WPP • HAZID • Network Rail approval (SRP)
Design
2-4 weeks
• On-site delivery • Commission • Safety checks
Trials and Test • Technology testing
Installation
2-3 weeks
4-5 weeks
• Site handback • Commercial closure • Progress to product acceptance Decommission
Client need
1-2 weeks
All timescales are indicative and subject to project scope and supplier requirements.
Colour:
Client responsibility Network Rail responsibility Joint responsibility
WPP: HAZID: SRP:
Work Package Plan Hazard Identification Safety Review Panel
40
OFFICIAL
Roles and Responsibilities for Trials Approvals Safety assurance Site management
Principal Contractor Licence
Installation design Installation works Control of safe system
Network Rail
Customer
Technology / System design Trial operation and testing 41
RIDC Regulative Governance Railways & Other Guided Transport System (Safety) Regulations 2006
OFFICIAL
Railway Interoperability Regulations 2011
Railway Group Standards
The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974
Network Rail Policy
Non-Mainline SMS
Network Rail Standards
Mainline SMS
RIDC Tuxford
RIDC Melton
Local Operations Procedures
Local Operations Procedures Safety Certificate (Operations)
Safety Authorisation (Infrastructure Manager)
GB Railfreight Operations Supplier
Bridgeway Consulting Limited Maintenance Supplier
East Midlands Route Maintenance Supplier
Network Rail Non-Network Rail
OFFICIAL
RIDC System Review Panel Purpose • Assessment of change entering RIDC Railway System Scope • Identify / control of Risk pertaining to: • verification activities to be undertaken at RIDC as part of achieving ‘Placing into Service’ • Tasks to be undertaken by workforce operating on site What it isn’t • An independent assessment body (Interoperability)
Compatibility
Safety
Competence
Communication / Collaboration
43
OFFICIAL
2
RIDC Tuxford
RIDC Tuxford spurs off the Robin Hood line, between Thoresby Junction and High Marnham, it is 10 miles of single line test track with a 3 mile double section, with testing speeds capabilities of up to 75mph. It comprises a short section of non-live 25kV type catenary, a short section of non-live 3rd/4th rail. It offers a perfectly suited facility to develop rail vehicles, technology, equipment and to deliver operator training and competence assessments.
Facilities • Office & mess facilities • Sidings • Stabling • Dummy OLE • Dummy 3rd & 4th rail • Ability to change infrastructure characteristics
Types of Testing • RIS-1530-PLT rail plant test site offering bespoke capabilities and this is unique in the UK. It has all of the required infrastructure parameters for compliance with railway industry standards, applicable to new and modified on-track machines on one site. • Tamper and Stoneblower training area • Thimbling training area • Adhesion test sites up to 1:25 W6A vehicle gauge • Lifting training site • Handbrake testing • Slip brake testing equipment
44
OFFICIAL
45
OFFICIAL
RIDC Tuxford – General Facility
46
OFFICIAL
For further information please contact: Satnam Thiara (Satnam.Thiara@networkrail.co.uk)
General Hotline (ridc@networkrail.co.uk)
www.networkrail.co.uk/ridc
Neil Fulton Chief Executive Officer Black Country Innovative Manufacturing Organisation
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
December 2023
Introduction to BCIMO
INTRODUCTION TO BCIMO • BCIMO - established May 2020 •
BCIMO Operate the unique, purpose-built, rail R&D facility based in Dudley: •
A three-storey innovation centre, complete with Engineering Hall, test laboratories, offices and meeting rooms, and an events suite
•
A brand new 2.2km test track (with 1km tunnel) located along part of the mothballed South Staffordshire line leased from Network Rail
•
Built with a combination of ERDF & LEP funding £32m in total
•
Building licensed to BCIMO to operate from October 2022
•
Not for profit company limited by guarantee – recognised by UKRI as a Research & Test Organisation (RTO)
•
Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council & West Midlands Combined Authority are owner members and on Board
AREAS OF FOCUS By driving the interdependent cogs of this development activity, BCIMO aims to help shape and accelerate future industries, ultimately supporting government policy relating to: • net zero • the future of transport • and regional levelling up
FACILITIES ON OFFER RAIL DEVELOPMENT & TEST SITE
RAIL TEST TRACK • • • •
2.2km long 4 individual testing zones Standard gauge single track Powered points
RAIL TEST LOOP
• 15m radius loop • Standard gauge single track • CVLR novel trackform
FACILITIES ON OFFER RAIL DEVELOPMENT & TEST SITE
TUNNEL
• 870m long • W12 gauge, curved 5-ring brick arch • Mix of environmental conditions
SPLIT-LEVEL PLATFORM • • • •
Accommodate heavy & light rail platform heights 8.9m per level One at each end and side of the test track Composite frame and platform
FACILITIES ON OFFER RAIL DEVELOPMENT & TEST SITE
ENGINEERING HALL • • • •
Triple-height 60m through track 48m maintenance track & pit 10 tonne double girder overhead crane
WORKSHOP
• Standalone secure facility • 33m maintenance track • 9m maintenance pit • 2 tonne single girder overhead crane
FACILITIES ON OFFER ENGINEERING LABORATORIES & EQUIPMENT
Spread across Levels 0 and 1 of the Innovation Centre are 10 Engineering Laboratories.
*These are currently occupied by customers working on a variety of light rail, battery development and academic / training delivery projects.
MEETING & EVENT SPACES
AUDITORIUM • • • •
Variety of layout options Accommodates 130 theatre style State-of-the-art AV & LX system Portable carpeted stage
EXHIBITION HALL
• Variety of layout options • Accommodates 170 standing & 27 exhibition • Large airy space with floor to ceiling windows • External balcony with views over RDTS
CURRENT PROJECTS BCIMO is a partner on one of the West Midlands Innovation Accelerator programmes, together with lead partner Connected Places Catapult and Coventry University: The Clean Futures Accelerator focuses on the area of Clean Tech for the transport sector. Over the course of the next two years, 40 SMEs (20 per year) will join a 6-month, industry challenge-led accelerator where they will receive up to £50K to trial their rail or automotive solutions at the VLRNIC or Coventry University respectively. The first cohort of winners are on site now Part of the remit for the Clean Futures Accelerator is that it becomes sustainable at the end of the two-year funded programme. This is where the Commercial Investment Hub will come in. The platform, facilitated by BCIMO, will bring together Innovators, Challenge Setters and Investors to accelerate innovation to commercialisation
CURRENT PROJECTS – Test Vehicle
neil.fulton@bcimo.co.uk
Andy Doherty Chief Technical Officer Global Centre for Rail Excellence
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
THE GLOBAL CENTRE OF RAIL EXCELLENCE ‘The process of innovation, testing and certification’ Prof. Andy Doherty FREng Chief Technology Officer - GCRE RIA Unlocking Innovation – Testing and Validation Global Centre of December 2023 Rail Excellence
Location:
GCRE Facility Overview: The Global Centre of Rail Excellence is a purpose-built site for world class research, testing and certification of rolling stock, infrastructure and innovative new rail technologies. When fully developed it will provide: ▪ A purpose-built site where technologies can be tested, demonstrated and certified in a safe, offline, live environment ▪ Core services – Rolling Stock Testing; Infrastructure Innovation; Showcasing and Storage / Maintenance ▪ A cutting-edge technology park with world class innovation space; higher education partners located on site ▪ Space for a company’s permanent headquarters location
▪ Open access facility for use by global manufacturers to SMEs ▪ Tiered membership, with innovative commercial partnerships ▪ Facility that is operational 24 hours a day, seven days a week
▪ Accessible, local accommodation for visiting research teams ▪ Headquarters, visitors centre and conferencing facilities ▪ The UK’s first Net Zero in operation railway
Rail System of GCRE Independent GSM-R and 5G across whole site, with provision for future FRMCS Full optical fibre and comms backbone across the whole site
• •
•
1 underbridge (test purposes only – infrastructure loop) 1 x vehicle level crossing; 1 x pedestrian level crossing (test purpose only) 3 vehicle over bridges; 2 pedestrian over bridges; 5 underpasses
Outer Loop ETCS L2/3 plus ATO Separate/independent Interlocking Separate RBC 25Kv OHL European GB A/B/C Loading Gauge
Inner Loop NR Trad Signalling (TCs, Axle Counters, AWS, TPWS ETCS L2 Overlay Separate Interlocking Separate RBC 25Kv OHL
Separate Exchange Section
Network Rail -Neath and Brecon branch line
Power supply 30MW system fed from Renewal energy Electrification: 25kV OHL Series 1 Provision for DC and other AC supplies Static Frequency Converter
Sidings & Depot 4km of stabling/warm storage Independent movement control
InfrastructureTest Loop 30/40 eMGT/640000 axles Per Annum BUND
Section for whole life and endurance testing, with physical separation
Section to have contain design defects
Sidings & depot
Neath and Brecon branch line
• • • •
Total length: c7000m Maximum speed: 60mph Electrification: 25kV OHL UK Master Series Island platform
Example of Infrastructure Loop - test usage Section 3 Rep; NR Cat 2 Freight Section 2 Rep; NR Cat 2 100mph Section 1 Rep; NR Cat 1A 125mph Section 4 Rep; NR Cat 4-6 Rural
HS1 Rep Section
TfW CVL Rep Section
HS2 Infra section
Radical Innovation Test Section composite under bridge Composite OHL structures Rail Metallurgy Sleepers/ballast trails
Railway System Design logic: ▪ The railway system design fundamentals ▪ GCRE is a 100% separated and independent railway ▪ It is physically separate and controlled separately from the Network Rail branch line ▪ The human is separated in design and operation as far as possible ▪ It has standalone separate and independent ETCS and GSM-R systems ▪ Fully independent operation of both loops, the link road and sidings areas ▪ Manually, automatically or remotely operated as dictated by customer and R &D/science usage ▪ The Infrastructure loop will be operated automatically when innovative technology and end of life testing is conducted. ▪ ‘Relative’ spectrum freedom (within regulatory limits for a low-density area) ▪ High data and connectivity controlled by an ‘open’ Digital twin ▪ ‘Plug and play’ structures to be technology agnostic and open to all
Operating Philosophy: ▪ Purpose ▪ The facility is giant laboratory ▪ The human is excluded by design ▪ Its scope will not be limited to railway systems ▪ Fundamentally developing and testing non approved products and systems ▪ Exploring asset life through to obsolescence ▪ Understanding failure mechanisms, improving maintenance process and extend life ▪ The facility to be RISK MANAGED/TOLERENT – NOT RISK ADVERSE
Global Centre of Rail Excellence
Facilitating Innovation ▪ Open to all; SME to Tier 1! ▪ Innovate UK calls being built into the GCRE construction, opportunity for more! ▪ UKRRIN ‘2’ re GCRE focussed on the higher TRL activities, supporting the journey from innovation to delivery ▪ Confidentiality respected with collaboration and partnering to be offered where necessary ▪ Encouraging a whole life consideration including; design for reliability, operating and maintenance needs ▪ GCRE to be the real-life demonstrator for new and innovative technologies in a very real environment
Testing Philosophy ▪ GCRE is open to rapid testing of new and non-certified products and systems ▪ No ‘traditional’ UK railway certification or ‘test’ certification needed to test at GCRE ▪ A ‘Risk Managed’ philosophy ▪ Trials of not yet certified products and systems ▪ Trials of new innovations and technology not yet described in standards or recognised norms ▪ GCRE operating controls will be by; ▪ Review of certification where available (especially sector technology transfer) ▪ Review for any product of its functionality operating characteristics, failure modes and basic risks ▪ For ‘higher’ risk products a daily review of condition, monitoring data, and rate of change from previous reviews
‘Validation’ and Certification • What is Validation? • Can mean validation to existing norms and standards but has no intended defined marking • Can mean certification/homologation as compliant to standards and ‘bringing into service’ (certification for this presentation) • GCRE anticipates • Working with clients who bring their regular certification bodies • ‘partnering’ with authorised Certification companies and bodies, on site with clients and in conjunction with appropriate regulatory bodies. Discussions as to the ‘model’ to used ongoing • Space for facilities for certification companies allowed for in the design of GCRE • Recognition of 4 streams of validation • UK manufactured for UK use and needing UK certification • UK manufactured for overseas use and needing certification relevant to planned use (UKCA, CE, ISO etc) • Outside UK manufactured for UK use and needing UK certification • Outside UK manufactured for overseas use and needing certification relevant to planned use (UKCA, CE, ISO etc
Digital: ▪ GCRE has started by placing all its design and build contracts with BIM2 system and data requirement ▪ GCRE has used a modelling company to build our first basic 3D rendering of the site ▪ Migrating the BIM data, System designs forward into a full Digital Twin of the site ▪ A complete digital backbone around the site will enable easy integration of monitoring and sensoring system technology into the Twin. Thereby connecting the physical world with the Virtual ▪ GCRE will be able to operate the site (day to day activities) using the Digital Twin The above enables the GCRE to be the ‘Hardware in the Loop’ of an innovation, R & D and certification facility. The Digiatl Twin enabling: continuous monitoring, linking simulators and virtual models, remote operation and control, automation, to a new forms of digital certification jointly based on physical and digital evidence
Training and Development ▪ Training on new technologies is essential for successful bring into service and then for operations and maintenance – so regularly forgotten! ▪ GCRE will facilitate the support of innovators in the high TRL identification and development of training, operating and maintenance needs ▪ A core part of the UKRINN’2’ funding will enable high TRL development of university research that’s turns to application need; training, operational processes and maintenance needs ▪ GCRE is developing a ‘railway’ training capability again in partnership with competent providers
▪ Apprentice Level 1-7 in conjunction with local universities and colleges ▪ Railway specialist skills in conjunction with providers
▪ Schools Primary Engineer (14 schools in the local area so far)
Key Contacts: GCRE is interested to discuss testing, innovation and commercial partnerships with you now: enquiries@gcre.wales ▪
Prof. Andy Doherty FREng – Chief Technology Officer: andy.doherty@gcre.wales
▪
Rob Thompson – Director of Implementation: rob.thompson@gcre.wales
▪
Rob Forde – Director of Strategy and Skills: rob.forde@gcre.wales
▪
Kelly Warburton – Chief Commercial Officer: kelly.warburton@gcre.wales
▪
Arthur Emyr – Head of Business Development and Engagement: arthur.emyr@gcre.wales
▪
Kelvin Davies – Head of Innovation: kelvin.davies@gcre.wales
▪
David Shipman – Rail Design Lead: david.shipman@gcre.wales
▪
Andrew Johnson – Head of Strategic Communications: andrew.johnson@gcre.wales
Questions
Website: gcre.wales Twitter: @GCREinnovation twitter.com/GCREinnovation YouTube: @gcreinnovation youtube.com/@gcreinnovation LinkedIn @gcreinnovation linkedin.com/company/gcreinnovation
Global Centre of Rail Excellence
Timothy Mangozza Rail Innovation Lead PA Consulting
Stephanie Klecha Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Products Lead PA Consulting
PA’s Testing and Trialling Capabilities 5th December 2023 Timothy Mangozza and Stephanie Klecha
© PA Knowledge Limited |
77
Contents
01
02
About PA
Our approaches to test and validation
© PA Knowledge Limited |
78
01 About PA
© PA Knowledge Limited |
79
About PA
Cybersecurity
Asset Management
Scaled Agile
Target Operating Model
We combine skills across three lenses to deliver innovation
AI and Data Analytics Driving and Releasing Change
Management Consulting
Benefits as a Service
We are more than
PA’s Transformational Capability
IT Sourcing and Transformation
Scientific Feasibility
Technology Development
Accelerated Innovation Technology Development © PA Knowledge Limited |
Digital Engineering
Enterprise Architecture
Programme Leadership
4,000 professionals working from offices across the UK, Ireland, US, Nordics, and Netherlands.
Digital Engineering
80
Rapid prototyping and manufacturing Product development
02 Our approaches to test and validation
© PA Knowledge Limited |
81
Ways we help bring Products to Rail Consulting advice on customer products
Utilising supply chain skills and services to deliver PA-owned products
Developing and delivering jointly owned products with key supply partners
→ all draw on our skills in validation and verification and many make use of the wide range of test facilities we have at our Global Innovation and Technology Centre © PA Knowledge Limited |
82
PA’s Global Innovation and Technology Centre (GITC)
300 scientists, engineers, designers, technologists
260+ specialists with transport and rail domain knowledge
© PA Knowledge Limited |
83
PA’s Global Innovation and Technology Centre (GITC)
10,000 sq metres of scientific laboratories, engineering workshops and design studios
© PA Knowledge Limited |
84
Typical Rail Test and Validation activities at PA
How?
Why? Idea
Viable Product
Functional Product
What? © PA Knowledge Limited |
85
Fully Validated Product
Typical Rail Test and Validation activities at PA
Rapid Prototyping including 3D printing, electronics assembly and test and range of machine shop equipment (CNCs, EDM etc)
Model Based Systems Engineering
V&V Rigour
Driving design from requirements and validation
User Experience Labs
FMEA
Simulated and physical
(cFMEA, uFMEA, dFMEA)
Viable Product
Idea
Human Factors Concept phase →Req → validation and trials
Functional Product
Technology and Business Integration
Ergonomics
© PA Knowledge Limited |
86
Environmental Test
Fully Validated Product
Standards Compliance Managing product development in line with standards across a blend of industries/areas
Typical Rail Test and Validation activities at PA Engaging the right stakeholders at the right time
Rapid Prototyping including 3D printing, electronics assembly and test and range of machine shop equipment (CNCs, EDM etc)
Model Based Systems Engineering
V&V Rigour
Driving design from requirements and validation
User Experience Labs
FMEA
Simulated and physical
(cFMEA, uFMEA, dFMEA)
Viable Product
Idea
Human Factors Concept phase →Req → validation and trials
Functional Product
Technology and Business Integration
Fully Validated Product
Standards Compliance
Managing product development 80/20 rule Key aRelationships with in line with standards across Approval bodies blend of industries/areas
Specialist test houses (EMC, vibration…) HAZID specialists NR plant/product approval process
Ergonomics
© PA Knowledge Limited |
Environmental Test
87
© PA Knowledge Limited |
88
© PA Knowledge Limited |
89
Cambridge Office Global Innovation and Technology Centre Back Lane Melbourn Hertfordshire SG8 6DP +44 1763 261222
About PA. We believe in the power of ingenuity to build a positive human future. As strategies, technologies, and innovation collide, we create opportunity from complexity. Our diverse teams of experts combine innovative thinking and breakthrough technologies to progress further, faster. Our clients adapt and transform, and together we achieve enduring results. We are over 4,000 strategists, innovators, designers, consultants, digital experts, scientists, engineers, and technologists. And we have deep expertise in consumer and manufacturing, defence and security, energy and utilities, financial services, government and public services, health and life sciences, and transport. Our teams operate globally from offices across the UK, Ireland, US, Nordics, and Netherlands. PA. Bringing Ingenuity to Life.
Discover more at paconsulting.com and connect with PA on LinkedIn and Twitter
This document has been prepared by PA Consulting Group. The contents of this document do not constitute any form of commitment or recommendation on the part of PA and speaks as at the date of publication. paconsulting.com All rights reserved © PA Knowledge Limited 2023 No part of this documentation may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical or otherwise, without the prior written permission of PA Consulting Group.
Ben Ackroyd Chief Operating Officer Porterbrook
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association
Long Marston Rail Innovation Centre December 2023
Introduction to Porterbrook
We have been at the heart of UK rail for nearly 3 decades
c.4,000
£3.5bn
Vehicles on lease or on order
Invested since 1994
165
23%
Total employees across 3 offices
Market share1
100/100
>£250m
Industry-leading ESG
Invested over the past 5 years
Our customers
›
Support over 100 UK-based companies in the supply chain and c.7,000 jobs
›
Offices in Derby, London and Long Marston Rail Innovation Centre at Warwickshire
›
Porterbrook investors are fully committed to the future of the UK rail sector
Shareholders
Derby
Long Marston Rail Innovation Centre London
1 Market share including the existing vehicle count and new build orders
93
Investment across the UK
We work with over 100 business in the UK rail supply chain, supporting c.7,000 jobs
£25m
£100m
£52m
Brodie Engineering
£12m
£10m Hydro FLEX
Wabtec
Alstom Widnes
Since 2021, we have developed our own operational capabilities at Long Marston
Alstom
Long Marston has become the home of HydroFLEX
Long Marston Gemini Rail Services Pullman Rail
Selhurst Depot (GTR)
Bournemouth depot (SWR)
94
Long Marston – 1940 to 1999 home to the Royal Engineers
1945 Accommodation for German Prisoners of War
1948 1940 Ministry of Defence purchase during World War II
During a resettlement programme after the war repurposed to house Polish servicemen
95
We have invested c.£12m in site upgrades since 2021
96
Long Marston – Present Day
Newly refurbished offices and workshops
Porterbrook is committed to hosting Rail Live in Long Marston
97
Asset Management Facility (AMF)
Our brand-new AMF opened in April 2023 following a £3m investment by Porterbrook
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
3 x pitted roads over 2,500m2 Can accommodate up to 2 x 4car units and 1 x 6-car unit Fully fitted with compressed air, 110V, 240V and 415V electrical outlets Equipped with heating and air cooling.
98
Maintenance & servicing
Close collaboration with suppliers to offer turnkey solutions tailored to customer needs
Maintenance ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Stored unit maintenance Modification programmes Planned exam maintenance Ad-hoc and arising maintenance Complete vehicle refresh Bodywork and incident repairs End of life vehicle decommissioning Vehicle disposal
99
Storage capabilities
Long Marston offers a wide range of storage solutions, including warm storage for highvalue assets
✓ Mainline connection ✓ Warm storage capabilities ✓ 24h security ✓ State of the art CCTV system ✓ Accredited security dogs. 100
Industry Partnerships
Working closely with the British Transport Police, we’re helping Armed Policing and Counter-Terrorist Operations by providing rolling stock and track access to carry out tactical training without the pressures of disrupting the mainline network.
1 Market share including the existing vehicle count and new build orders
101
Future developments
Potential to upgrade the test track with electrification and signalling to enable more testing and commissioning on site
LM could offer:
New Rail Charging Converter
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Splitting & joining testing Door interlock & safety system testing Driver training & familiarisation Customer acceptance Shake down & fault free running EMC & noise testing ETCS integration Battery charge and regeneration Infrastructure & interface testing New product & methods approvals Turnkey solutions
102
102
Wrap up and next steps
Footer
103
Break 2: The Future of Testing
Issues and opportunities
Quick wins
Longer term changes
104
Share your thoughts with us today or on our digital whiteboard Breakout 1: https://bit.ly/41gWsxK
Breakout 2: https://bit.ly/3NeHsuy
Links will be shared along with presentation slides to all delegates after the event 105
Thank you for attending!
Milda Manomaityte Innovatio Director Railway Industry Association