!"##$%&'$()#*+' ,-*./$".0$&*1$+2'3 2)##$4"+5$-&'$6'"21 3*-&$42'"-&-"5*./ +).+'2-$*.$!"20*77
(89
I--'.4)2)@/& %&'$#'/'.0$-"#51$"-$-&' 1+2''.*./$)7$&*1$#"-J '1-$7*#?$A!#)1*./ -&'$K*./B
F#"?'.+)$F'1-*L"# ,-2@-$6)@2$1-@77$0)3. -)$I."$M"2+*"B1$7*'26 7#"?'.+)$3)251&)<$*. N)1#'6
(8=
(9O
REDBRICK
2nd Nov 2007 ISSUE 1316 VOL 72
THE UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM’S STUDENT NEWSPAPER SINCE 1936
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
>IS$,61-'?1 7!?& (.& +*5& C$2#+*& ,"#)5.+& "#3. 1$3I"%6& (%& +*5& G$#,9H& G(+* "%%2",& .",5.& +$+",,(%)& 3$#5 +*"%& a]b:%J& >+& .5,,.& G5"I$%#6 +$&$E5#&$%5&*2%9#59&1$2%+#(5.J !.&+*5&,"#)5.+&"#3.&1$3I"D %6& (%& 7#(+"(%H& +*5& C(#3& *". :$2)*+&2I&321*&$C&+*5&#53"(%D (%)& <\& (%92.+#6J& /*5& 1$3I"%6
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`&1$%+#"1+J
$#()(%"+5.& C#$3& +*5& 7!K& D 7#(+(.*& !(#1#"C+& K$#I$#"+($%& D 1#5"+59& (%& ]^cd& :6& "& 1$3:(%"D +($%&$C&C$2#&I,"%5&3"-5#.J @5:#"%959& ".& 7#(+(.* !5#$.I"15H& +*5& C(#3& )#5G& :6 I2#1*".(%)&$+*5#&1$3I"%(5.J&>% ]^_eH& (+& I2#1*".59& @$6", R#9%"%15H& +*5& )$E5#%35%+8. $G%&"#3"35%+.&9(E(.($%&3"%2D C"1+2#(%)& )2%.H& .*5,,.& "%9
E'31$$$$$$$$$9 7(#3(%)*"3 9#$I.&+$&]_+* I,"15&(%&"&I#$3(D %5%+&,5")25&+":,5
%:
9;
!"#$%&'#()*+ +",-.&",,&+*(%). /0&(%&*(.&1$,23% 4/5,,6&7(+5.8
G*7'1-6#' 8H
,-@0'.-$<2)-'1-'21$*.$-&'$M2'"-$P"##Q$I1-).$R'44$>@*#0*./
'(%&"&I"(#&$C +(1-5+.&+$&+*5 K,$+*5.&A*$G ;(E5&"+&+*5&=?K
,<)2-
9=
!&*$1-56&9$2:,5 *5"95#&".&:$+* +5"3.&:"++,59 ;$2)*:$#$2)*
%&'$4"..'2$3"2.*./$1-@0'.-1$"-$-&'$!"2''21$F"*2 +"%-.J >+& *".& +*#55& 3"(%& .*(ID 6"#9.S& ["E"%& "%9& A1$+.+$2%& (% [,".)$GH& "%9& 7"##$G& (% K23:#("J& >+& *".& +"%-& "%9 "#3$2#59& 1"#& I,"%+.& (%& ;559.H =5G1".+,5& "%9& /5,C$#9f& "& #"9"# C"1+$#6&"+&K$G5.H&>.,5&$C&'()*+f "& +$#I59$& I,"%+& %5"# P$#+.3$2+*f& "%9& 32%(+($%. I,"%+.& "+& K"5#G5%+& "%9
7(.*$I+$%J 7!?&(.&",.$&(%E$,E59&(%&.5,,D (%)& "%9& ,5".(%)& 1(E(,& 1$335#D 1(",&"(#1#"C+&"%9&1$3I$%5%+.&+$ "(#,(%5& 1$3I"%(5.& "#$2%9& +*5 G$#,9J& /*5.5& (%1,295& +*5& 7!? gc& "%9& h5+.+#5"3J& & T$.+ %$+":,6H& (+& $G%59& idj& $C& +*5 1$%.$#+(23& 3"-(%)& +*5& !(#:2. I"..5%)5#&F5+.H&C#$3&]^e_&2%+(, .5,,(%)&+*5&.+"-5.&(%&iddcJ