Building Resilience to Climate Change Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets Report for City of Wagga Wagga 2018
Project Delivered for: City of Wagga Wagga 243 Baylis Street (PO Box 20), Wagga Wagga NSW 2650 Project Delivered by: Edge Environment Level 5, 39 East Esplanade, Manly, NSW 2095, AUSTRALIA
Project Funded by: ‘Building Resilience to Climate Change’ partnership program between LGNSW and the NSW Office of Environment and Heritage (OEH) to address identified climate change risks and vulnerabilities facing NSW Councils.
Revision
Revision Details
Author
Approved by
Date Approved
A
Initial issue for comment
Nicole Thompson & Joel Clayton
Tom Davies
08/12/2017
B
Integrated WWCC comments
Nicole Thompson & Joel Clayton
Tom Davies
22/01/2018
C
Further WWCC amendments
22/09/2018
Executive Summary Wagga Wagga City Council (WWCC) is located in the Riverina region of NSW on the Murrumbidgee River. Wagga Wagga is the largest population centre in the Riverina region providing a central hub of services to a catchment of over 180,000 people. Climate change is projected to impact upon this area, leading to potentially unforeseen risks to the built environment, with important economic, environmental and health implications. The development of a Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options Report provides both operational and future recommendations that help to manage risks appropriately, ensuring the climate resilience of these assets into the future. The objectives of this Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options Report are to:
Provide an understanding of localised climate change projections for the Wagga Wagga Local Government Area
Present a climate change risk analysis for the selected WWCC assets
Develop a report outlining proposed adaptation actions
A workshop was held with the selected Project Working Group (PWG) to review the likely climate change impacts and identify and assess risks to assets. The Council manages a range of different types of assets in the local area from amenities and sporting facilities to sewerage treatment plants (STP) and the Livestock Management Centre. The WWCC assets, as chosen by the PWG, were assessed. “Adaptation Actions” required to treat significant risks were developed and then reviewed by the PWG after the workshop. Risks were then reassessed, considering the relevant adaptation actions, and given a revised risk rating. A total of 38 climate change related risks to assets were identified in the risk workshop presented to the WWCC PWG. These risks are associated with several common climate variables such as increase in hot days, increase in flooding and increased rainfall variability. An increase in hot days generated the most risks in the analysis, and were dominated by the impacts; pumping failures, infrastructure and vegetation damage, and an impact on public health. Increased rainfall variability and increased intensity of storm events also pose a high number of risks and impacts relating to maintaining STP processes, aquatic health, increased reliance on irrigation and sewer and detention basin overflows. Increase in flooding and increased average temperature both have a number of similar impacts. These risks and their adaptation actions were given a priority rating of low, medium and high derived from a rating score based on four factors; risk rating, asset renewal data, cost and practicality to implement. Table 1 provides a summary of the identified risks, their relevant adaptation actions, and their priority rating given for implementation and management of these risks. It is recommended that Council incorporate priority actions into their Integrated Planning and Reporting processes, and ensure that an updated analysis of risks is undertaken on a regular basis in line with Council’s Risk Management Framework.
Table 1 - Summary of adaptation actions required to achieve revised risk rating
Risk
Risk Rating
Adaptation Actions
Before/After
Priority to Implement
TRN1
High - Medium
Increase urban canopy along shared pathways
High
REC1
High - Medium
Implement relevant actions from the Recreation Open Space Community Strategy to increase shading at playgrounds, sportsgrounds and parks
High
Develop a Heatwave Management Plan REC2
High - Medium
Install water efficient irrigation systems
High
Ensure plant selection is appropriate for hotter, drier conditions SEW2
High - Medium
Install permanent generator or alternate off-grid option for each pump site
Medium
Evaluate the adequacy of emergency storage capacity at each treatment plant SEW3
High - Medium
Investigate feasibility of oxygen injection and odour control methods
Medium
SEW4
High - Medium
Identify specific flood prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect asset
Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Sewer Asset Management Plan STM1
High - Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Stormwater Asset Management Plan
Medium
Review modelling and design requirements to allow for greater flow volumes Review and upgrade capacity of pumps as needed TRN2
High - Medium
Utilise materials and designs for pavements and surfaces that are highly resistant to high temperatures
Medium
TRN3
High - Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Transport Asset Management Plan
Medium
Utilise materials and designs for pavements that are highly resistant to inundation Retain flood paths in new developments REC3
High - Medium
Install water efficient irrigation systems as per the irrigation audit Install tolerant or synthetic turfs Investigate diversifying water sources to include stormwater, greywater or blackwater
Medium
REC4
High - Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Recreation Asset Management Plan
Medium
Utilise materials and designs for built recreational assets that are highly resistant to high temperatures and frequent inundation BLD3
High - Medium
Identify and implement energy efficiency initiatives at Council buildings
Medium
Investigate feasibility of passive cooling projects such as green roofs and heat reflective surfaces BLD4
High - Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Buildings Asset Management Plan
Medium
Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Probable Maximum Flood levels BLD5
High - Medium
Undertake site specific risk assessments to identify vulnerable assets and evaluate options to move or protect asset
Medium
Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Bushfire Attack Levels REC5
High-High
Implement site specific Plans of Management
Medium
Divert stormwater where feasible Investigate options for de-silting, use of treated effluent and algal control measures BLD1
Medium-Low
Investigate options for increasing shade and water infrastructure
Medium
SEW1
Medium-Low
Implement a targeted inflow and infiltration prevention program to minimise increase in volume of water in sewer network from rainfall events
Medium
Develop a program of indoor demand management activities to reduce load on sewer network Identify energy efficiency measures for assets SEW5
Medium-Low
BLD2
High-Low
Identify specific bushfire prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect asset
Low
Utilise materials and designs that are highly resistant to high temperature
Low
Executive Summary .................................................................................................. 3 1
Introduction ........................................................................................................ 7 Objectives ................................................................................................................ 7
2
Methodology ....................................................................................................... 8 Background Research ............................................................................................ 8
3
Climate Analysis............................................................................................... 10 Historic climate for Wagga Wagga....................................................................... 10 3.1.1
Temperature ..................................................................................................... 10
3.1.2
Rainfall ............................................................................................................. 11
3.1.3
Extreme weather events ................................................................................... 12
Climate change projections ....................................................................................... 13
4
3.2.1
Average Temperature & Hot days .................................................................... 13
3.2.2
Rainfall ............................................................................................................. 14
3.2.3
Extreme weather events ................................................................................... 14
Risk Assessment & Adaptation Actions ........................................................ 15 Risk Workshop ...................................................................................................... 15 4.1.1
Workshop ......................................................................................................... 15
Risk assessment matrix ........................................................................................ 19 4.2.1
Risk Assessment outcomes ............................................................................. 19
Risk Summary and Evaluation ............................................................................. 30 Adaptation Actions ................................................................................................ 31 Prioritisation of adaptation actions ..................................................................... 31
5
Recommendations ........................................................................................... 33
References .............................................................................................................. 36
1
Introduction
Future climate change poses significant risks to property and infrastructure through changes in temperature, rainfall and the increased occurrence or intensity of extreme weather events. Understanding region-specific climate change projections provides an opportunity to assess these risks and develop management strategies and adaptation actions that reduce economic, environmental and social impacts associated with the asset. Wagga Wagga is a major regional city in the Riverina region of NSW, which straddles the Murrumbidgee River and has an urban population of approximately 60,000. Climate change is projected to impact upon this area, leading to potentially unforeseen risks. Wagga Wagga City Council (WWCC) manages many different assets in the local area which are at risk due to climate change impacts. A number of key asset classes were chosen by the Project Working Group (PWG) to undergo a risk assessment. The development of a Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options Report (the Report) provides both operational and future recommendations that aim to ensure risks are managed appropriately, ensuring the climate resilience of these assets into the future.
Objectives The objectives of this Report were:
Provide an understanding of localised climate change projections for the Wagga Wagga Local Government Area
Present a climate change risk analysis for the selected asset types
Develop a report outlining proposed adaptation actions
An example of the climate change projections visualised in map form is shown in Figure 1 below. It shows increase in days over 35oC in 2070 for NSW with Wagga Wagga’s increase indicated. Data is taken from NSW and ACT Regional Climate Modelling (NARCliM) Murray Murrumbidgee climate change snapshot (NSW OEH, 2017).
Figure 1 – Example of climate change projects – days over 35C 2070 (NARCliM)
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 7 of 36
WWCC aims to develop a robust, relevant and up to date climate adaptation options for the selected assets to manage the risks associated with future climate change related impacts. This report will be used to summarise the work done during the ‘Building Resilience to Climate Change’ project which received grant funding from Local Government NSW. A key part of the project was also to develop the Wagga Wagga Climate Vulnerability Explorer mapping tool which is hosted on WWCC’s Intramaps system.
2
Methodology
This Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options Report) follows the ISO31000 Risk Management Process, and was designed to meet the requirements of the AS 5334 - Standard for climate change adaptation for settlements and infrastructure. The risk assessment involved three key steps to develop risks and mitigation strategies collaboratively with key asset stakeholders. These steps are summarised below in Figure 2. Climate and Context
Review of current risks
Review historic & best available climate projections
Multidisciplinary risk workshop
Review of asset operation and site location
Risk Analysis
Mitigation Strategies
Recommend design and operational mitigation strategies
Figure 2 – The collaborative climate change risk analysis process.
Background Research Initially, Edge assessed Wagga Wagga site information and location to understand potential vulnerability to any climate related risks. This stage involved building an understanding of historic weather events, and analysing scaled down climate change projections for the relevant geographic area. Due to the potential for significant impacts on infrastructure and property, the following climatic variables were of key interest for the Report:
Extreme temperature
Rainfall (extreme precipitation and drought)
Flooding
Storm Intensity
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 8 of 36
Project Description Wagga Wagga City Council (WWCC) manages a number of different assets in the local area. Key WWCC assets, as chosen by the Project Working Group (PWG), have been assessed for climate change risk and adaptation actions. The WWCC asset classes that were chosen align with Council’s series of Asset Management Plans and are detailed in the list below:
Sewer Assets & Infrastructure
Stormwater Assets & Infrastructure
Transport Assets & Infrastructure
Recreational Assets & Infrastructure
Council Buildings & Businesses
Figure 3 below shows the output from the Wagga Wagga Climate Vulnerability Explorer mapping tool that was developed for this project. All the coloured shapes and points indicate the above listed WWCC assets. The Wagga Wagga Climate Vulnerability Explorer will be delivered in conjunction with this report and is an additional source of information on Council’s Intramaps system.
Figure 3 – Snapshot of Wagga Wagga Council Assets and Climate Change Risks
The Wagga Wagga Climate Vulnerability Explorer can be used to explore climate projections via an interactive map and historic weather data via interactive graphs for the Wagga Wagga area. Flood modelling, vegetation and social data is also visualised via the interactive map. For each of the assets the climate change risk workshop results are included as pop up information. A list of the information provided in the Wagga Wagga Climate Vulnerability Explorer tool is as follows:
Climate Projection – Increase in days over 35oC (2030, 2070)
Climate Projection – Increase in maximum temperature (2030, 2070)
Climate Projection – Water Stress (Current, 2030)
Modelling – 1 in 100-year flood, 1 in 20-year flood depth, 1 in 100-year flood depth
Climate Projection – Change in rainfall, Summer & Winter (2030, 2070)
Modelling – Urban Canopy
Modelling – Vegetation areas
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 9 of 36
3
Climate Projection – Bushfire Risk increase (2030, 2070)
Modelling – Lone occupant households & low-income households
Zoning – Planning Zones
Historic data – Annual rainfall, daily rainfall, average rainfall
Historic data – Daily temperatures, heatwave days, solar exposure
Historic data – Wind speed and direction, severe storms by type
Climate Analysis Historic climate for Wagga Wagga
3.1.1
Temperature
The Wagga Wagga region has a temperate climate with hot dry summers and cool to cold winters. Summer temperatures in Wagga Wagga are warm averaging between 29oC and 32oC with maximum recorded of 45.2oC. Relative humidity however remains low in the summer months with a 3pm average of about 30%. The winters are cool to cold with overnight minimums averaging 3oC and daily maximums climbing to only 12oC to 14oC on average. Relative humidity is much higher in winter with a 3pm average of over 60% and a 9pm average just below 90%. Frost and fog are a feature of Wagga Wagga in winter. Snow has been recorded in the area but is a very rare occurrence. (BOM 2017). Historical daily maximum and minimum temperatures for the region are displayed in Figure 4, with data from the Wagga Wagga AMO station (BOM ID: 072150). This station is close to the Wagga Wagga city centre (approximately 12.7 km), and has recorded weather data since 1941. The graphs below illustrate that annual maximum temperatures frequently exceed 35oC and 40oC (Figure 4).
Figure 4 – Daily Maximum and Minimum Temperatures – Wagga Wagga AMO Station
Heatwaves are defined as three or more consecutive days of hot weather over 35oC, and are of key concern due to their potential impacts upon infrastructure. Figure 5 below outlines the frequency of heatwaves at Wagga Wagga AMO for 1941-2017. Since 1941, on average there are 20.1 days above 35oC and 2.4 days above 40oC.
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 10 of 36
Figure 5 | Historic Annual heatwave days (Number of days above 35C or 40C that are 3 or more consecutively) – Wagga Wagga AMO station
3.1.2
Rainfall
Average annual rainfall for Wagga Wagga is approximately 572 mm, distributed relatively equally over the full 12 months (BOM 2017). The BOM rain gauge at Wagga Wagga AMO (BOM ID 072150) has been collecting rainfall data since 1941. The highest recorded daily rainfall at this site was 110.6 mm on March 8th 2010 (Figure 6). The average annual rainfall is shown in Figure 7 and shows the annual rainfall is quite variable for Wagga Wagga.
Figure 6 – Daily rainfall recordings at since 1941 show several large rainfall events – Wagga Wagga AMO station
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 11 of 36
Figure 7 – Historic Annual Rainfall compared to Average Annual Rainfall – Wagga Wagga AMO station
3.1.3
Extreme weather events
Extremes of temperature and rainfall can have dramatic impacts upon infrastructure, and often occur during weather events that include storms, heat waves, droughts and bushfires. WWCC faces unique challenges related to extreme weather due to its scale, location and large variety of assets it manages. The following climatic events have occurred in the project area and require consideration for the WWCC assets.
Droughts: Droughts are relatively common in the Wagga Wagga Region. Most recently, the Millennium Drought caused over a decade of dry conditions and is considered one of the most severe droughts ever recorded in the region (BOM, 2017).
Floods: Since the first rural settlement in the early 1840s there have been 77 floods of over 8.23m. Official records of Murrumbidgee River heights since 1891 read at the Hampden Bridge gauge are available and estimated records are available of rivers over 8.23m since 1844. Flooding of the City area in the south flood plain was frequent and to a lesser extent flooding occurred in the North Wagga Wagga village. There have been years of frequent floods, i.e. in one year 1974 Wagga Wagga had five floods all over 8.92 m and there was severe flooding in the 1950 to 1956 period. In other long periods 1939 to 1949 and 1960 to 1970 no floods occurred. Significant floods have occurred in Wagga Wagga in 1852, 1853, 1870, 1891, 1925, 1950, 1952, 1974, 1991 and 2012 with the largest recorded flood of 10.97 metres occurring in 1844. There have been two floods greater than the 1974 flood (WWCC, 2017)
Bushfires: The Wagga Wagga region is also prone to Bushfires, with the most recent event being the 2006 Pulletop bushfire, which killed 2,500 sheep, 6 cattle and destroyed 2 hay sheds and 50km of fencing (NSWRFS, 2006).
Hail & Severe storms: The Wagga Wagga region is also prone to hail and severe storm events (See Figure 8 for the record of severe storm events in the last decade for the Wagga Wagga region (BOM, 2017)).
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 12 of 36
Figure 8 – Annual Severe Storm Events for the Wagga Wagga region – (BOM Severe Storm Register, 2017)
Climate change projections Understanding future climate projections requires careful review of the most recent climate change emissions scenarios, and their related impacts on the climate system. Making use of scaled-down climate projections, it is possible to understand regionally-specific projections, which is more useful for conducting risk analyses on the built environment and infrastructure assets. This study has been updated with the latest projections available from the CSIRO’s Murray Basin Cluster Report (CSIRO, 2015) and the NSW and ACT Regional Climate Modelling (NARCliM) Murray Murrumbidgee climate change snapshot (NSW OEH, 2017). CSIRO employed the Representative Concentration Pathways (RCP) emissions scenarios developed by the International Panel of Climate Change (IPCC) in their Fifth Assessment Report (AR5). These scenarios model climate change according to different economic growth, population, energy consumption and land use change trajectories over the next century. The timescales selected for the NARCLiM and predominately used in this CAP are the following:
1990 to 2009 (base),
2020 to 2039 (near future - 2030), and
2060 to 2079 (far future - 2070)
Analysis of projected climate changes involved summarising the key impacts that are likely to arise due to a changing climate. Temperature, rainfall and extreme weather events are of key concern due to their potentially significant impacts on the WWCC assets. Climate projections are described below, and are summarised in Table 2.
3.2.1
Average Temperature & Hot days
From NARCliM climate projections the number of days over 35°C are predicted to:
increase by 9 days for 2030 and
increase by 24 days for 2070
The climate projections also predict that the average temperature will:
increase by 0.6°C for 2030 and
increase by 1.9°C for 2070
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 13 of 36
3.2.2
Rainfall
The NARCliM climate projections predict that the Summer (Dec-Feb) rainfall will:
increase by 5.3mm for 2030 and
increase by 14.6 mm for 2070
Conversely the climate projections predict that Winter rainfall (Jun-Aug) will:
3.2.3
decrease by 0.8mm for 2030 and
decrease by 1.5mm for 2070
Extreme weather events
Future climate change is likely to increase the intensity and severity of extreme climatic events. Importantly, the relationship between climatic averages and the frequency of extreme events is often non-linear, illustrated by climate projections that associate dramatic increases in very hot days with small increases in mean temperature (AGO 2006). This makes the development of reliable projections for extreme events such as storms and droughts very difficult. Key extreme climate projections are discussed in the following sections.
Droughts: Droughts are a common feature of the South-East Australian climate, and are likely to continue to be so under a changing climate. However, there is low confidence in predicting changes in the frequency and longevity of extreme droughts in the future. There is medium confidence that under a high emissions scenario, the Murray Basin region is likely to experience increased time under drought conditions (CSIRO 2015).
Storms and extreme rainfall: There is high confidence that the intensity of rainfall will increase under a changing climate but, as with mean rainfall projections, the scale of these changes is difficult to predict (CSIRO 2015).
Fire weather: From NARCliM projections, Bushfire risk via the Forest Fire Danger Index is predicted to increase by 0.5 by 2030 and increase by 0.98 by 2070.
Table 2 – Wagga Wagga Climate Change projections, Key climate variables (2030 and 2070) compared to annual averages Baseline Variable (1990-2009) Temperature – average annual
Near Future
Far Future
(2030)
(2070)
+ 0.7oC
+ 2.0oC
+9
+ 24
Units
22.2oC
o
C
References
(NSW OEH, 2017)
maximum Temperature – Hot Days Rainfall – Annual mean
Extreme rainfall
Bushfire Risk Index
Average days 20.1
over 35oC per
(NSW OEH, 2017)
year 572.6 mm
mm
NA
NA
10
Danger Index
Summer: +5.3mm Winter: -0.8mm
Summer: +14.6mm Winter: -1.5mm
High confidence in increased intensity of rainfall under both scenarios, however magnitude of this change is uncertain.
(NSW OEH, 2017) CSIRO (2015)
Forest Fire + 0.5
+ 0.98
(NSW OEH, 2017)
(FFDI)
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 14 of 36
4
Risk Assessment & Adaptation Actions Risk Workshop
Climate change risks to Wagga Wagga City Council and their associated adaptation actions were identified through a workshop held on the 31st of July 2017. Workshop attendees included stakeholders representing a multidisciplinary skill set across Council. The attendees of the workshop are listed in Table 3. Table 3 – Project Working Group Workshop attendees Name
Company
Michael Gleeson
Wagga Wagga City Council – Parks Operations
David Read
Wagga Wagga City Council - Environment
Lisa Saffery
Wagga Wagga City Council – Social Planning
Alice Kent
Wagga Wagga City Council - Environment
Glenda Pym
Wagga Wagga City Council – Recreation Planning
Jason Carroll
Wagga Wagga City Council - Environment
Stephen Jewell
Wagga Wagga City Council – Water Operations
Chris Breen
Wagga Wagga City Council – Water Operations
Joel Clayton
Edge Environment
Jessica Lethbridge
Edge Environment
Ken Lunty
Edge Environment
4.1.1
Workshop
The workshop presentation established the context of climate change and its potential impacts on the Wagga Wagga Local Government Area (LGA). It introduced project stakeholders to climate change projection scenarios, and encouraged them to consider climate change impacts in the context of their LGA. Risks resulting from these impacts were then developed and recorded, considering both direct and indirect risks to WWCC LGA, its assets, users and any other relevant stakeholders. Each risk was then evaluated and rated in terms of likelihood and consequence using the risk matrix presented in Table 4 and Table 5. 4.1.2
Risk Assessment Framework
To assess identified risks systematically, a likelihood scale was used to determine how likely a risk was to occur, followed by a consequence assessment. These scales are aligned with established risk assessment criteria. Likelihood ratings are described for event risks in Table 4.
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 15 of 36
Table 4 - Example Likelihood Scales (AGO 2007).
Rating
Description
Quantification
Almost certain
The event is expected to occur in normal circumstances. There has been frequent history
At least once every 1-6 months
Likely
The event will probably occur in most circumstances. Some recurring past event history
Once every 6-12 months
Possible
The event could occur sometimes. Some past warning signs or previous event history
Once every 1-5 years
Unlikely
The event could occur in some circumstances
Once every 5-10 years
Rare
May only occur in exceptional circumstances
Once every 10 years or more
4.1.3
Consequence
Consequence is an assessment of the severity of the risk’s impacts should it occur. Consequence assessment included several success categories in line with the WWCC risk assessment criteria (Table 5 over page).
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Page 16 of 36
Table 5 - WWCC Consequence Scale
Financial
Governance
Community and Reputational
Strategic
Environmental
Operational
Health & safety
Severe impact to staff availability
Catastrophic
Significant/ material financial loss over $1 million
Significant regulatory breach/s including court proceedings
Widespread total degradation of operations and services Extreme adverse public/staff reaction and/or major widespread negative publicity
The project will completely stop Delivery of objectives cannot be achieved
Significant environmental impact, EPA intervention including significant fines
Significant procurement impact/loss, including serious breach of probity Widespread systems / records management outage declared for an extended period beyond the Maximum Acceptable Outage time
Kill or cause permanent disability or ill health
Major impact to staff availability
Major
Moderate
Major financial loss of $100,000 to $1 million
High financial loss of $50,000 to $100,000
Significant regulatory breach/s
Moderate regulatory breach
Major degradation of services and operations. Major adverse public/staff reaction and/or significant negative publicity
Moderate degradation of services and operations Moderate adverse public/staff reaction
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Key parts of project will be delayed more than a month Major impact that threatens delivery of objectives
Key parts of the project will be delayed more than a week
Major environmental impact, EPA intervention
Major impact/loss resulting from procurement processes, including breach of probity
Long term illness or serious injury
Loss of system access or access to records for an extensive period Moderate environmental impact handled internally
Page 17 of 36
Moderate impact to staff availability
Medical attention and several days off work
Financial
Governance
Community and Reputational
Strategic
and/or moderate negative publicity
Moderate impact to agreed delivery of objectives
Environmental
Operational
Health & safety
Moderate impact/loss resulting from procurement processes Loss of system access or access to records for a prolonged period
Minor
Minor financial loss of Operations $5,000 to $50,000
Minor degradation of services and operations. Minor regulatory breach
Capital $10,000 to $50,000
Insignificant
Low financial loss of up to: Operations $5,000 Capital $10,000
Minor adverse public/staff reaction and/or minor negative publicity
No degradation of services. No regulatory breach
No adverse public/staff reaction and/or negative publicity
Climate Change Risk & Adaptation Action Plan - Wagga Wagga
Minor impact to staff availability Some delay anticipated to project delivery Minor impact to agreed delivery of objectives
A very small delay anticipated to project delivery Negligible impact to agreed delivery of objectives
Minimal environmental impact handled internally
Minor impact/loss resulting from procurement processes
First aid treatment needed
Minor impacts resulting from loss of system access or access to records Negligible impact to staff availability
No environmental impact
Insignificant impact/loss resulting from procurement processes Insignificant impacts results from system interruptions
Page 18 of 36
No injury to persons
Risk assessment matrix Risk likelihood and consequence were then combined using the risk assessment matrix in Table 6, leading to the systematic development of a risk rating used to prioritise risk management strategies. Table 6 - Risk Assessment Matrix (AGO 2007)
Insignificant
Minor
Moderate
Major
Catastrophic
Almost Certain
Medium
Medium
High
Extreme
Extreme
Likely
Low
Medium
High
High
Extreme
Possible
Low
Medium
Medium
High
High
Unlikely
Low
Low
Medium
Medium
Medium
Rare
Low
Low
Low
Low
Medium
4.2.1
Risk Assessment outcomes
The following table describes the risks identified in the workshop, including the risk statement (outlining the risk’s cause and effect), the asset the risk may impact, its likelihood, consequence and subsequent risk rating, should it occur. Results of the stakeholder review are also incorporated, providing the adaptation actions and revised risk level. Risks that were identified as ‘LOW’ to begin with were not included, nor were any that did not have a viable adaptation option identified by the PWG.
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 19 of 36
SEWER ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Increased rainfall variability
SEW1- Increased rainfall variability and increased intensity of storm events leads to fluctuating volumes of water to deal with causing difficulty in maintaining treatment processes resulting in increased costs for electricity and chemicals
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
3-Possible
1-Insignificant
Low
2-Unlikely
3-Moderate
Medium
3-Possible
2-Minor
Medium
Implement a targeted inflow and infiltration prevention program to minimise increase in volume of water in sewer network from rainfall events 3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium
Develop a program of indoor demand management activities to reduce load on sewer network
Identify energy efficiency measures for assets
Increased intensity of storm events
Increased intensity of storm events
Adaptation Actions
Install permanent generator or alternate off-grid option for each pump site
SEW2- Increased storm events leads to black outs causing pumping failure and sewer overflows resulting in public health issues, environmental harm and possible fines
3-Possible
SEW3- Increased hot days leads to odour issues which leads to impacts on the community resulting in complaints from community and possible fines
4-Likely
4-Major
High Evaluate the adequacy of emergency storage capacity at each treatment plant
2-Minor
Medium
Investigate feasibility of oxygen injection and odour control methods
Increase in hot days
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 20 of 36
SEWER ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE
Climate Impacts
Increased flooding
Increased bushfire risk
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
SEW4- Increased flooding leads to inundation of vulnerable infrastructure, causing system failure resulting in public health issues, environmental harm, repair costs and possible fines
SEW5- Increase in bushfire risk leads to damage of critical infrastructure, causing system failure resulting in public health issues, environmental harm, repair costs and possible fines
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
2-Unlikely
4-Major
Medium
1-Rare
4-Major
Low
Identify specific flood prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect asset 3-Possible
4-Major
High Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Sewer Asset Management Plan
2-Unlikely
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
5-Catastrophic
Medium
Identify specific bushfire prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect asset
Page 21 of 36
STORMWATER ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE Climate Impacts
Increased intensity of storm events
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
STM1- Increased flooding and increased storm events leads to overflow of capacity causing localised flooding resulting in decreased access, community complaints and increased maintenance and renewal costs
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
2-Unlikely
3-Moderate
Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Stormwater Asset Management Plan
3-Possible
Increased flooding
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
4-Major
High
Review modelling and design requirements to allow for greater flow volumes
Review and upgrade capacity of pumps as needed
Page 22 of 36
TRANSPORT ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
4-Likely
2-Minor
Medium
3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium
Increase urban canopy along shared pathways
Increase in hot days TRN1- Increase in hot days and increase in average temperature leads to urban heat island effect causing public health issues and decreased use of facilities
5-Almost
3-Moderate
High
Certain
Increase shading at bus stops and car parks
Implement relevant actions from the Active Travel Plan and Street Tree Strategy
Increase in average temperature
Increase in hot days
Adaptation Actions
TRN2- Increase in hot days and increase in average temperature leads to fatigue and degradation of materials and surfaces resulting in increased cost of maintenance and renewals
4-Likely
4-Major
High
Utilise materials and designs for pavements and surfaces that are highly resistant to high temperatures
Increase in average temperature
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 23 of 36
TRANSPORT ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE
Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
3-Possible
2-Minor
Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Transport Asset Management Plan Increased intensity of storm events
TRN3- Increased intensity of storm events and increased flooding leads to decreased access, degradation of materials and surfaces resulting in increased cost of maintenance and renewals
4-Likely
Increased flooding
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
4-Major
High
Utilise materials and designs for pavements that are highly resistant to inundation
Retain flood paths in new developments
Page 24 of 36
RECREATIONAL ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Increase in hot days
Increase in hot days
REC1- Increase in hot days leads to public health concerns causing decreased use of facilities and cancellation of events
REC2- Increase in hot days and increase in rainfall variability leads to plant stress and decreased amenity resulting in increased costs for additional watering and plant replacements
5-Almost Certain
3-Moderate
High
Adaptation Actions
Implement relevant actions from the Recreation Open Space Community Strategy to increase shading at playgrounds, sportsgrounds and parks
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium
3-Possible
2-Minor
Medium
Develop a Heatwave Management Plan
Install water efficient irrigation systems 5-Almost Certain
3-Moderate
High Ensure plant selection is appropriate for hotter, drier conditions
Increased rainfall variability
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 25 of 36
RECREATIONAL ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
3-Possible
2-Minor
Medium
3-Possible
2-Minor
Medium
Install water efficient irrigation systems as per the irrigation audit Increase in hot days
REC3- Increase in hot days and increase in average temperature leads to degradation of playing surfaces, causing decreased satisfaction and use of facilities resulting in increased cost of maintenance and renewals
5-Almost
3-Moderate
High
Investigate diversifying water sources to include stormwater, greywater or blackwater
Increase in average temperature
Increased intensity of storm events
REC4- Increased intensity of storm events and increased flooding leads to fatigue and degradation of materials and surfaces resulting in increased cost of maintenance and renewals
Install tolerant or synthetic turfs
Certain
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Recreation Asset Management Plan 3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium Utilise materials and designs for built recreational assets that are highly resistant to high temperatures and frequent inundation
Increased flooding
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 26 of 36
RECREATIONAL ASSETS & INFRASTRUCTURE
Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
4-Likely
3-Moderate
High
Implement site specific Plans of Management Increased rainfall variability
REC5- Increase in rainfall variability and increase in average temperature and leads to increased algal growth and low water levels in recreational water bodies resulting in decreased use, decreased amenity and community complaints
Divert stormwater where feasible 5-Almost Certain
3-Moderate
High Investigate options for de-silting, use of treated effluent and algal control measures
Increase in average temperature
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 27 of 36
COUNCIL BUILDINGS & BUSINESSES Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Increase in hot days
Increase in hot days
BLD1- Increase in hot days leads to animal welfare issues at the LMC causing animal deaths resulting in economic impacts and reputational damage
3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium
BLD2- Increase in hot days leads to operational issues for the Airport causing service delays resulting in economic impacts and reputational damage
3- Possible
4-Major
High
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
Investigate options for increasing shade and water infrastructure
2- Unlikely
2-Minor
Low
Utilise materials and designs that are highly resistant to high temperature
2-Unlikely
2-Minor
Low
4-Likely
2-Minor
Medium
Identify and implement energy efficiency initiatives at Council buildings
Increase in hot days BLD3- Increase in hot days and increase in average temperature leads to increased use of airconditioning resulting in increased electricity costs at Council facilities
Residual Likelihood
Adaptation Actions
5-Almost Certain
Increase in average temperature
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
3-Moderate
High Investigate feasibility of passive cooling projects such as green roofs and heat reflective surfaces
Page 28 of 36
COUNCIL BUILDINGS & BUSINESSES
Climate Impacts
Risk Statement (Cause and Effect)
Likelihood
Consequence
Level of Risk
Increased intensity of storm events
BLD4- Increase in intensity of storm events and increase in flooding leads to decreased access, service delays and damage to buildings resulting in increased maintenance and renewal costs
Adaptation Actions
Residual Likelihood
Residual Consequence
Level of Risk
3-Possible
3-Moderate
Medium
4-Likely
2-Minor
Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Buildings Asset Management Plan 3-Possible
4-Major
High Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Probable Maximum Flood levels
Increased flooding
Increased bushfire risk BLD5- Increase in bushfire risk and increase in flooding leads to increased cost of insurance premiums
5-Almost
3-Moderate
High
Undertake site specific risk assessments to identify vulnerable assets and evaluate options to move or protect asset
Certain Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Bushfire Attack Levels
Increased flooding
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 29 of 36
Risk Summary and Evaluation A total of thirty-eight climate change related risks to assets were identified in the risk workshop and presented to WWCC PWG. Only 31 of these were progressed through to this report and an adaptation action provided. These risks are associated with several common climate variables. An increase in hot days generated the most risks in the analysis, and were dominated by the following impacts: pumping failures, infrastructure and vegetation damage, and an impact on public health and services. Increased rainfall variability, increased intensity of storm events and increased flooding also pose a high number of risks and impacts relating to maintaining STP processes, aquatic health, increased reliance on irrigation and sewer and detention basin overflows. Increase in average temperature and increased bushfire risk both have a number of similar impacts. The variables and key impact areas for Wagga Wagga City Council are summarised in Table 8 below. Table 8 – Climate variables and their key climate impacts.
Climate variable
Number of risks
Focus impact areas Blackouts and pumping failures
Increase in hot days
9
Public health impacts Infrastructure damage Biodiversity and vegetation damage Issues maintaining STP process conditions
Increased rainfall variability
3
Aquatic health issues i.e. algal growth, drought Increased reliance on irrigation Reduced use of facilities, loss of income
Increased intensity of storm events
Blackouts and pumping failures
6
Sewer overflows Overflowing of detention basins
Increased flooding
6
Erosion or silting of lake Infrastructure damage Public health impacts
Increased average temperature
Increase in weed/pest species Increase in plant stress
2
Critical infrastructure damage Increased insurance premiums
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 30 of 36
Adaptation Actions Post-workshop evaluation with participants generated adaptation actions for each risk through asset changes or operational management. The key aim was to reduce the risk rating by suggesting strategies that could remove the risk or reduce its impacts. The list of revised risks was then circulated through the workshop participants, who verified the adaptation measures and revised the risk ratings. The final risk counts are identified in Figure 9 below. Through this method, sixteen high risks were reduced fourteen medium risks and one low risk level, and three medium level risks were reduced to a low level of risk. Figure 9 – Comparison of risk before and after proposed adaptation actions
Comparison of risk before and after adaptation actions 18 16 14 12 10
HIGH
MED Before
LOW
After
Prioritisation of adaptation actions To assist with developing an action plan that prioritises the adaptation actions for implementation, each adaptation action was given a priority rating score. The rating score was based on four factors; initial risk rating, asset renewal date, cost and practicality to implement. See the following for the prioritisation categories and weighted scoring. Table 9 - Scoring factors for priority rating
Level of Risk
Asset Renewal Date
Cost ($) Indication to implement Action
Practicality of Action
Low
Short term - Up to 5 years
Low: $0-$50,000
Simple: Minimal project management and procurement process
Medium
Medium term - 5 to 10 years
Medium: $50,000 $500,000
Moderate: Some complexity, requires RFQ and >40hours of Project Management
High
Long term - More than 10 years
High: >$500,000
Complex: requires tender and dedicated project manager
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 31 of 36
Each adaptation action was given a score individually from 1 to 4 for each of the four factors; initial risk rating, asset renewal date, cost and practicality to implement (see Table 10). Each of the four factors are weighted differently to give a final score to determine the total priority score. The total priority score is then sorted into band ranges to give an overall priority rating (Table 11). The higher the score, the higher the priority rating.
2
Short term Up to 5 years
3
1
Low: $0$50,000
3
1.5
Simple
3
1
Medium
2
2
Medium term - 5 to 10 years
2
1
Medium: $50,000 $500,000
2
1.5
Moderate
2
1
High
3
2
Long term More than 10 years
1
1
High: >$500,000
1
1.5
High
1
1
Extreme
4
2
Score
1
Score
Low
Score
Weight
Practicality of Action
Score
Cost ($) Indication to implement Action
Weight
Asset Renewal Date
Weight
Level of Risk
Weight
Table 10 - Four factors score and weighting
Table 11 - Min - Max score range for priorities
Min range score
Max range score
Priority Rating
5.5
9.8
Low Priority - Implement when funding is available
9.8
14.2
Medium Priority- Implement with next renewal
14.2
18.5
High priority - Implement ASAP
The WWCC Risk and Adaptation Action spreadsheet has been provided to Wagga Wagga City Council. Worksheet ‘AA Prioritisation’ includes drop down boxes that allow you to change the factors and the scores for each adaptation, and will automatically change the priority rating accordingly.
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 32 of 36
5
Recommendations
This section of the Report sets out the prioritised adaptation actions for Wagga Wagga City Council to successfully mitigate and manage the risks identified through the risk analysis process. Many of the actions require planning, costing and strategic placement into asset renewal and operational plans to ensure risks are managed appropriately. Table 12 below sets out the risks, their relevant adaptation actions, and priority rating given for implementation and management of these risks. The priorities, derived from the method outlined in section 4.5 above are as follows:
High priority - Implement ASAP
Medium priority- Implement with next renewal
Low priority - Implement when funding is available
Table 12 - Summary of adaptation actions required to achieve revised risk rating
Risk
Risk Rating Before/After
Adaptation Actions
Priority to Implement
TRN1
High-Medium
Increase urban canopy along shared pathways
High
Install water efficient irrigation systems REC1
REC2
High-Medium
High-Medium
High
Ensure plant selection is appropriate for hotter, drier conditions Implement relevant actions from the Recreation Open Space Community Strategy to increase shading at playgrounds, sportsgrounds and parks
High
Develop a Heatwave Management Plan Install permanent generator or alternate offgrid option for each pump site SEW2
High-Medium
SEW3
High-Medium
Evaluate the adequacy of emergency storage capacity at each treatment plant
Investigate feasibility of oxygen injection and odour control methods
Medium
Medium
Identify specific flood prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect asset SEW4
Medium
High-Medium Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Sewer Asset Management Plan Risk Rating
Priority to Risk
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 33 of 36
Risk
Risk Rating Before/After
Priority to Implement
Adaptation Actions Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Stormwater Asset Management Plan
STM1
High-Medium
Review modelling and design requirements to allow for greater flow volumes
Medium
Review and upgrade capacity of pumps as needed
TRN2
High-Medium
Utilise materials and designs for pavements and surfaces that are highly resistant to high temperatures
Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Transport Asset Management Plan
TRN3
High-Medium
Utilise materials and designs for pavements that are highly resistant to inundation
Medium
Retain flood paths in new developments Install water efficient irrigation systems as per the irrigation audit REC3
High-Medium
Medium
Install tolerant or synthetic turfs Investigate diversifying water sources to include stormwater, greywater or blackwater
REC4
High-Medium
Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Recreation Asset Management Plan
Medium
Utilise materials and designs for built recreational assets that are highly resistant to high temperatures and frequent inundation
BLD3
High-Medium
Identify and implement energy efficiency initiatives at Council buildings Medium Investigate feasibility of passive cooling projects such as green roofs and heat reflective surfaces Implement actions from the Floodplain Risk Management Plan and the Buildings Asset Management Plan
BLD4
High-Medium
Medium Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Probable Maximum Flood levels
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 34 of 36
Risk
BLD5
Risk Rating Before/After
High-Medium
Priority to Implement
Adaptation Actions
Undertake site specific risk assessments to identify vulnerable assets and evaluate options to move or protect asset
Medium
Modify design and construction of future assets for increased Bushfire Attack Levels Implement site specific Plans of Management REC5
High-High
Divert stormwater where feasible
Medium
Investigate options for de-silting, use of treated effluent and algal control measures BLD1
Medium-Low
Investigate options for increasing shade and water infrastructure
Medium
Implement a targeted inflow and infiltration prevention program to minimise increase in volume of water in sewer network from rainfall events SEW1
Medium-Low
Medium
Develop a program of indoor demand management activities to reduce load on sewer network Identify energy efficiency measures for assets
SEW5
Medium-Low
BLD2
High-Low
Identify specific bushfire prone assets and evaluate site specific opportunities to move or protect assets
Low
Utilise materials and designs that are highly resistant to high temperature
Low
It is recommended that Council incorporate priority actions into their Integrated Planning and Reporting processes, and ensure that an updated analysis of risks is undertaken on a regular basis in line with Council’s Risk Management Framework.
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 35 of 36
References AGO (2006). Climate Change Impacts and Risk Management - A Guide for Business and Government. Canberra: Australian Greenhouse Office - Commonweath of Australia. Bewsher Consulting. (2010). Macquarie Park Floodplain Risk Management Study & Plan. City of Ryde. Bradstock, R., Davies, I., Price, O., & Cary, G. (2008). Effects of climate change on bushfire threats to biodiversity, ecosystem processes and people in the Sydney region. New South Wales Department of Environment and Climate Change. CSIRO. (2015). East Coast Cluster Report, Climate change in Australia Projections for Australia's Natural Resource Management Regions. CSIRO and Mureau of Meterology. IPCC. (2007). Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report. International Panel on Climate Change. National Climate Change Adaptation Research Facility (NCCARF). (2010). Case study: Impacts and adaptation responses of infrastructure and communities to heatwaves. NCCARF. NSW OEH. (2014). Metropolitan Sydney Climate Change Snapshot. Sydney: Office of Environment and Heritage. NSW OEH. (2014). New South Wales Climate Change Snapshot. Sydney: NSW Office of Environment and Heritage. NSW OEH. (2017, June 14). AdaptNSW. Retrieved from About NARCLiM: http://climatechange.environment.nsw.gov.au/Climate-projections-for-NSW/About-NARCliM NSWRFS. (2006). Bushfire Bulletin (vol28 No.01). Retrieved from NSW Rural Fire Service: http://www.rfs.nsw.gov.au/ data/assets/pdf_file/0009/4122/Bush-Fire-Bulletin-2006-Vol-28No-1.pdf Schuster, S. S., Blong, R. J., Leigh, R. J., & McAneney, J. K. (2005). Characteristics of the 14 April 1999 Sydney hailstorm based on. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 5, 613-20. van Dijk, A. I., Beck, H., Crosbie, R. S., de jeu, R. A., Liu, Y., Podger, G., & Timbal, B. V. (2013). The Millennium Drought in southeast Australia (2001–2009): Natural and human causes and implications for water resources, ecosystems, economy, and society. Water Resources Research, 1040-1057. WaterNSW. (2017, 06 09). Water Supply Historical Timeline. Retrieved from WaterNSW: http://www.waternsw.com.au/supply/Greater-Sydney/heritage/timeline
Climate Change Risk Assessment & Adaptation Options for Council Assets
Page 36 of 36