THE TRANSFORMING MALABAR
Shifting grounds of the Western Ghats
The ‘Reimagining the Western Ghats’ Project
2
3
Copyright
2014 Sanika Sahasrabuddhe, Shambhavi Singh,Law Environment and Design Lab.
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The working methodology of the ‘Reimagining the Western Ghats’ project is a part of a studio environment. It is impossible for this project to have manifested the way it has, without the help of the critical and supportive feedback of our facilitators and teachers. Collective efforts reflect more synergy than individual work. We are truly thankful to Mr. Dilip da Cunha to have given us insightful knowledge and understanding to see the strength of design as a tool of research and analysis and to guide us as we built our plot as lens to view the Western Ghats. Secondly, we would like to thank Ms. Deepta Sateesh for leading the studio and giving our project direction, and to help us shape it into a design intervention through which we can present our findings. Dr. Vivek Dhareshwar and Ms. Arpitha Kodiveri were of invaluable help with their immense knowledge about social science and law respectively.
They contributed great to our design process through critical feedback and questioning helped us ground our research in reality. Their emphasis on reading and writing has helped us think more responsibly and apply our learnings to our design practice. Our field visit to the Agumbe Rainforest Reseach Station gave us field experience and helped us shape our understanding of the western ghats as a place of richness and multiplicity. The staff at ARRS catered to our every need of food, shelter and knowledge while we explored Agumbe. We could not have completed this project without the guidance and kindness of Gowri, Dheeraj, Ram and Dheeraj, who helped us inspite of rigorous work schedules. Last but not the least we would like to sincerely thank Malvika Tewari, Bidisha Das and Stella James for engaging in our work, and being always ready to listen as we developed our projects.
5
CONTENTS
Introduction Process Field Trip and Methodology Interpretation of Data Final Representation Conclusion
7 8 13 17 27 30
6
7
INTRODUCTION This project is a part of a larger body of work that entails Reimaging and Reimagining Landscapes, specifically, the Western Ghats. The objective is to propose a new way of looking, a novel point of enquiry, study and interaction with a landscape. This mode of enquiry can translate into interventions that lay ground for a more resilient environment. The project aims to use design to research, understand, interpret and represent complex environments such that it brings out the richness of its processes, forms, functions and relationships. Our project under this scope of study, reimagines the Western Ghats as a region of transformations. Over centuries, the Malabar Coast has been represented as a line, a line that divides land and sea, a line that is fixed on a map and doesn’t change, a line that lies between two ways of being - the way of the land and that of the sea. Through our interpretation and representations we establish that that coast is not just a line, but a region of flux where transformations take place. And these transformations are that of commodification - taking something ordinary and making it extraordinary. For the purpose of this study, a lens was developed. A lens is a unique way of seeing, a tool to traverse and observe the Western Ghats. Field research was located in following areas - Manipal Town, Udupi, Malpe Fishing Port, St. Mary’s Island and Agumbe
rainforest. Through our lens, ‘transformation’ (which is elaborated in the next section), various processes were observed in the Western Ghats. Certain processes are elevated as being transformative, from everything that was observed and the information that was gathered. Along the scale of time, objects and systems transform to change form and state and assume another. A significant change that is transformative in many ways is commodification. Commodification in its broad meaning is taking something ordinary and making it into something extraordinary. The commodity then has heightened value than its previous state. The Agent is one that brings about this change in state, making it extraordinary. These agents are people, birds and insects, mammals and also the wind, daylight, rain and sun. Some processes take place with movement (space) while others with time. Some processes are gradual while some fast. Commodification brings utility value to the agent causing it. With this lens, humans building a settlement and say a woodpecker carving a nest in a tree trunk can be observed as similar, rather than different. Thus building a coast with these processes renders it to be a more dynamic region than it has so far been represented as. A constant state of flux and porosity defines the coast in our imagination and coast is no longer just the line that divides the land and sea but it is something that is forever undergoing transformation.
8
PROCESS The process of developing a lens, and subsequently a plot, was a rigorous one. It untertook working in pairs, branstroming sessions, observation excercises, long discussions that often diverge from the point of focus. Suspension of judgement and questioning all previous knowledge was constant. A theoretical inquiry through Liberal Arts was incorporated to give design research a grounding in related matters. But mostly the building of a Lens was done through the exploration of a Particular. As the project takes on the inquiry of the ghats, a particular from the Ghats was selected for exploration.
It could be anything specific from the Western Ghats ranging from a tree, the type of soil, a practice, a song or a film. After the particular is selected, it is investigated and dissected as much as possible, in its totality as well as in its details. The particular serves as an anchor to to build a plot. A plot is a structure that enables the conception of a newly imagined landscape. Its is fluid and open ended and allows information to fill up its crevices. It is a dynamic tool that is flexible and expands to incorporate new information to show links and relationships that can go unnoticed. At the heart of all this is: the Particular.
Fig. 2,3 and 4 Ideation and mindmapping while working on the ‘Particular’ i.e. the coconut tree
Fig.1 Mind Map
9
THE PARTICULAR Historically the coconut has travelled from India, Malaysia and Indonesia over centuries ago to other countries as well. This has happened naturally (i.e. through sea when a coconut fruit has floated away) and also been carried as a specimen of something unique from these regions by foreign travellers. There have been various traveller’s accounts ranging from that of Ibn Batuta, Garcia Da Orta, Marco Polo, Vasco Da Gama and so on. And if one were to map the presence of this tree one would notice how this tree grows and is found only in the tropical regions of the world. All the tropical coasts fall in the region of the coconut.
The coconut tree is highly characteristic of the Western Ghats. Also known as Kalpavriksh (the all giving tree) in Sanskrit, the coconut in all its parts can be utilised. Its leaves, fruit, trunk, roots, flowers everything. But what is even more fascinating about this tree is how it is a part of the daily routine life of the people on the coast as well as those living far inland, who use it in their rituals. The green coconut that is consumed as an ordinary fruit in the coastal regions and the brown matured coconut that is used in temples and sacred ceremonies, in northern parts of India. This contrast is what led to the development of the lens of transformation. The coconut (the particular) came to serve as an anchor in understanding the transformative processes that make it a commodity and eventually extraordinary. The oil, extracted, or the husk that is used to make coir, the leaves that are thatched and the trunk that is used for timber, are all results of a transformative process and show various moments in the journey of the coconut. The changes that happen in various states of the coconut can also be observed texturally. For the purpose of this a visual exploration was undertaken and all images were cropped in a way to bring out only the textural changes that were evident. The motive behind such exploration is to observe something for what it is, and build connections based on what the exploration shows.
Fig. 5 A map of the world, the red belt the region travelled by the coconut through the years.
Fig.6 Textural stratas of part of the Coconut tree
10
The coconut tree stands tall and adorns the coasts of the world. But due to the wind and its weight it never stands erect and is always bent at an angle. This angle is a peculiar visual symbol. It can be clearly observed in the coasts also and though on land the tree always leans towards the sea. This visual symbol led to extraction of what we like to call in this project the ‘Line of Transformation’. It is this line, as seen in the plot, that makes the coast. Later it shall be seen however that the coast is not one line but a number of lines or moments of transformation. This line divides the pre-state and the post-state in that moment of transformation where an agent acts upon an object and changes it.
these circular ones that are evidence of a change that has happened. The Line of transformation runs through these circular moments of significant change. The lens of transformation was developed to traverse the Ghats and observe its complexities and multiplicities, which can later be laid out on the plot and the understanding of the Western Ghats can be further nuanced.
Breaking through categories and preconceived notions about a coconut tree was possible only once it was looked fresh and new. Explorations and iterations guide and led to conclusions and not the other way round.
Fig.7 Cross section of a coastline.
Fig.8 Coconut Tree parts through process.
The plot reflects processes. The processes follow two major paths either that of natural growth leading to decay, or an intervention from an external agent that utilises/transforms it for consumption. The idea of commodification thus emerged and is reflected in the circular moments in the plot. In a long chain of rectangular moments there are Fig. 9 Arriving at the concept of the ‘line of transformation’ inspired by the slope of the coconut.
11
Fig.10 Plot depicting processes in a coconut tree
12
13
FIELD TRIP AND METHODOLOGY To look at something anew, it must be experienced directly and without any preconceived notions. he field trip to the Western Ghats aimed at this very experiential understanding of a space and it components. Equipped with the lens developed four keys places in the Western Ghats were visited. Manipal Town Udupi Temple Square Malpe Fishing Port St. Mary’s Island Agumbe Rainforest In observing the above mentioned areas through the lens of transformation, various processes were observed. For example the sorting of fish in the fishing market, the making of a fishnet in an old warehouse in Manipal city, changes in soil and making of clay bricks, nesting of a sunbird in Agumbe, construction of housing colonies in the meadows of Agumbe rainforest, process of inhabitation by insects, birds etc in the forest. The methodology of documenting experiences in the Ghats and collecting data was through photography, sound, video and sketching. Reflecting on each day’s experience through writing, doodles and discussions and a feedback session were crucial aspects. Some philosophical introspection was inevitable. A key learning from the field was the suspension of doubts and question based on previous indirectly accumulated knowledge in favour of a direct experience and absorption of the space that was being traversed. Fig. 11 Discussing field methodology
14
UDUPI The journey that began with manipal at ended at the serene St. Mary’s island was the most diverse. The progression from the completely urban setting of Manipal, to the pious temple complex in Udupi to the unique geology of the St. Mary’s island, this journey was a micrcosm of the diversity of the Western Ghats. The coast is not the boundary of the Western Ghats. The life and activity that thrives on the many island in the Arabian Sea, are a part of the coast. The traverse between the mainland (Malpe fishing village) to the Island made us realise that the coast stretches to extremities beyond the coast, both towards land and the sea. The Western Ghats encompass the scattered pieces of land strewn in the sea. The Malpe fishing village was an integral place of inquiry to reinstate the idea of commodification as a transformation that adds value (monetary, in this case) to an object. The fishing village was an excellent example of a web of human activities and seeing the human as the transformative agent. St. Mary’s island is a sort of an extension of the coast. It houses fascinating basalt formations and is hence designated as a Geological site. The island has become extra-ordinary on occasion of these basalt column formations making it a tourist spot.
15
Fig.12 Processes in Malpe fishing village, Manipal Town, St. Mary’s island laid out on the plot.
16
AGUMBE The dense rainforest of Agumbe overflows with innumerable species. Growth in the forest is abundant and perennial. Plants grow oneach other Every strata in the forest is inhabited by a spectrum of species, of not only animals and birds but also trees and plants. Every species transforms the forest uniquely and the ecosystem as a whole goes through gradual change. All species create their own niche in the vastness of the forest. There is a constant cycle of growth and decay, as the forest regrows and perpetuates over itself. Processes of inhabiting, foraging, nesting, building, decomposing keep the forest active and dynamic.
Post field trip all the collected data was sorted and put on the plots. The processes mentioned in the previous section were laid out on the plot according to its visual language.
Fig.13 Processes in Agumbe Rainforest laid out on the plot.
17
INTERPRETATION OF DATA Once all these processes were laid out, their key transformative moments were extracted as lines. These represent the multiplicity of transformations for every region (Agumbe, Manipal, Udupi). The initially developed coconut plot was added on to this plot and lines were extracted from those as well. These lines were then defined by textually naming the transformative process. The change from the pre-state to post-state was defined by specific labelling. The plot challenges the idea of commodification. According to the Merriam–Webster dictionary, to commodify means to “treat (something that cannot be owned or that everyone has a right to) like a product that can be bought and sold.� So in some sense to commodify means to turn an object into a value added product.
A commodity is something that has utility to its user, and if one looks at commodity from this perspective then everything commodifies, not just humans. The plot puts all the heterotrophs in one group. Since transformation is the lens, the conclusion from the development of the plot was that the coastline is a dynamic region that changes and shifts. Once the transformative moments were laid out and labelled, categories of those moments emerged. Some were repetitive while some collectively formed a group. It was inferred from this that the coast can be defined by a certain category of transformative moment ( process of Drying, Weaving, Dwelling), or an agent (Human, Heat, Growing agent) that brings about those moments, thus establishing that the coast is not just a line that divides the land from sea.
Fig. 14 Arranging and connecting date collected.
18
Fig.15 Drawing of the west coast of India shows the evolution from the porosity of 16th-century Portolan charts to the clear and distinct divide between land and sea in later maps
19
The plot challenges the representation of the coast as it has emerged over centuries in forms of maps. This lays ground for thinking about, and potentially critiquing, categories and divides. When transformations can be so fluid how is it that concrete and fixed categories have been assigned in the Western Ghats. Classifying something as natural versus cultural is one such example. What are the standards to decide whether a certain landscape is natural and another cultural? Classifications have implications on the environment in terms of policy making and urban planning with regard to conservation, preservation, industrialisation and development. Thus categories must be questioned.
Fig. 16 The coast (dynamic) constructed by the lens of transformation.
20 packing
weaving
casting (in use)
segregating (untangling)
catching
selling
chunking
sorting
crumbling
infrigidating (tempering)
sorting
unloading
disintegrating
segregating (untangling)
firing (baking)
weathering
raising
designating
littering
birthing
hardening
solidification
anchoring
buffering
beaching Fig.17 Labelled transformation lines extracted from Udupi plot.
eaving
21 bundling
inhabiting
assembling
jumping plucking flying
withering
carving
weaving
pecking
secreting
extracting
boiling
solidifying gathering (piling)
occupying
building
moistening
constructing
secondary growth
charring
bundling
drying
spinning
creeping
supporting
drying
decaying
logging
falling decomposing uprooting
flowing
dampening
Fig.18 Labelled transformation lines extracted from Agumbe plot.
22
weaving
packing casting (in use)
segregating
untangling infrigidating (tempering)
unloading sorting
catching
raising
chunking
selling
designating
crumbling
littering
disintegrating
anchoring
hardening
firing (baking)
buffering
beaching
flowering weaving
bundling
drying
fruiting
hardening
solidifying
extracting
shelling
extracting
withering
boiling
charring
dehusking
bundling drying
spinning
logging
birthingm
uprooting
inhabiting
aturing
germinating
assembling
gathering (piling)
carving
buildingo
constructingc
drying
weaving
ccupying
reeping
moistening
supporting
flowing
decaying
dampening
Fig.19
23
weaving segregating (untangling)
packing
infrigidating (tempering)
sorting unloading
segregating (untangling)
casting (in use)
sorting
selling
chunking
catching
crumblingd
firing (baking)
isintegrating
weathering
designating
raising
littering
hardening
solidification
anchoring
buffering
beaching
weaving
bundling flowering fruiting
withering
drying
hardening
extracting
solidifying
boiling
shelling
charring bundling
extracting drying
dehusking
birthing
maturing
spinning
logging
uprooting
germinating
carvingw inhabiting
assembling
eaving
pecking
secreting
jumping plucking flying
gathering (piling)
building
occupying
moistening
constructing
secondary growth
creeping
supporting
decaying
drying
falling decomposing
flowing
Fig.20
dampening
Fig.19 and 20 demonstrate different iterations after extracting the transformation lines and labelling them. The grid is inclined because of the angle of the lines of tranformation, thus giving is a unique mode of expressing shifting of the plot.
24
Fig.21 Further iterations of plots with processes.
25
packing
weaving HUMAN
catching
segregating (untangling) casting
catching
WATER
WIND
HUMAN
anchoring
firing (baking)
littering
arriving
hardening HUMAN
building
eroding
touristing HUMAN
repairing
WIND depositing
designating
HUMAN
selling
HEAT powdering
surveying
HUMAN
HUMAN storing
moulding
crumbling travelling
storing
HEAT chunking
sorting disintegrating
leaching
infrigidating (tempering) HUMAN
HUMAN
segregating (untangling)
casting (in use)
sorting
unloading HUMAN
HUMAN
HUMAN
HUMAN buffering
beaching weaving HUMAN thatching drying HUMAN bundling flowering
plucking
GROWING AGENT
HUMAN hallowing
fruiting withering HEAT
falling hardening
thickening
drying HEAT
GROWING AGENT
HUMAN liquefying
extracting
drying
hardening
crushing HEAT
HUMAN boilings
shelling
drying
HEAT
HEAT
charring
shelling
extracting
drying HUMAN
bundling
thickening
GROWING AGENT
drying
spinning
felling
GROWING AGENT
germinating
HUMAN
HUMAN dehusking
birthing
olidifying
HUMAN
maturing
logging uprooting WIND decaying floating HUMAN
The unit field of transformation is a standard unit used in the plot. The line in the unit is the ‘line of transformation’ that denoted the change occuring in the state of the object/phenomenon. The agent that brings about the transformation determines the pre-state and the post state of the transformation. The pre and post states are also processes in particular cases. The agent is cardinal to the transformation interpolating the initial and final phases or processes ( practices)
rooting flying
pecking
assembling FLYING SQUIRREL
SUNBIRD inhabiting
secreting
gathering
carving
resting
KING COBRA
ANTS
WOODPECKER
tailoring
weaving designating
baking RAINFALL
TREE FROG
piling
occupyingc
moistening
HUMAN onstructing
growing SUNLIGHT creeping falling
aging GRAVITY
HEAT
decomposing flowing GRAVITY
Fig. 22 Iteration of plot based on agents.
dampening
decaying
Fig. 23 Standard unit of the plot.
26
27
flying
plucking
FINAL REPRESENTATION
feeding
inhabiting assembling
nesting
foraging
weaving
feeding
hatching nesting
pecking
foraging
carving
feeding
hatching
secreting
capturing
weaving
preying incubating
gathering
piling
leaving
According to the chosen parameter, the plot shifts and takes a certain form that becomes unique to the chosen parameter. Hence, for every agent or process the plot is different and no two plots are the same form. This is to convey that the Ghats are a region layered with various elements and each element or phenomenon has its uniqueness.
The plot (in the final design intervention) is representative of a coastline that is constantly shifting and re-aligning itself according to various process and agents. The final representation is in the form of an animation that demonstrates the shifting of the coast according to
An additional representation is a set of cut-outs of the blocks of the plot, as per agents and processes so that viewers and audiences can interact with the ‘coast’ and device their own categories by which the coast might be shift and rearranged.
plucking
inhabiting
assembling
moving
designating
baking
flying
moistening
nesting
resettling
constructing
feeding growing
growing
foraging
creeping
creeping
hatchingfalling
weaving
aging
feeding
nesting
pecking
foraging
decaying
decomposing
carving secreting
feeding
hatching flowing
capturing
dampening weaving
preying
flowing
We arrived at his representation that it would best communicate the fluidity of the coast in question. The coast in unique in its multiplicity and it is this versitality of the coast that is brought out in the shifting and realigning blocks. incubating
gathering
Agent: Human, Heat, Growing Agent
dampening
piling
weaving
We are attempting to communicate that the coast, the way it is represented today (as a vast singular entity) is essentially an integration of many coasts formed by numerous practices, agents and factors.
thatching
Processes: Drying, Categorising, Growth, Dwelling, Decay
drying
bundling flowering
plucking
leaving
moving
designating
baking
moistening
growing
growing
creeping
creeping
falling
aging
hallowing
fruiting
resettling
constructing
decaying
decomposing
withering
flowing
falling thickening
dampening
hardening
drying
drying
hardening extracting
flowing
crushing
dampening
liquefying
weaving
boiling
solidifying
thatching
shelling
drying
drying
flowering
flying
plucking
drying
extracting
bundling
dehusking hallowing
falling
thickening
felling
liquefying
casting
casting (in use)
segregating (untangling)
unloading
sorting
catching
infrigidating (tempering)
crumbling travelling
storing
powdering
bundling
drying
logging
designating
St. Mary’s Island and the coast
dampening floating
floating
touristing
buffering
repairing packing
The coconut tree
beaching
rooting
rooting
rooting
weaving segregating (untangling)
casting (in use)
segregating (untangling)
unloading
sorting
catching
thatching infrigidating (tempering)
storing drying
storing
chunking
sorting
selling
Fig. 24 The plot arranged geographically from sea to inland (left to right). leaching
crumbling travelling
bundling
moulding
disintegrating
powdering
firing (baking)
surveying
arriving anchoring
flowering
designating
hallowing
hardening
littering
building
plucking
fruiting withering
depositing
eroding
falling
touristing thickening
repairing
buffering
hardening
drying
beaching drying
hardening extracting
crushing
liquefying
boiling
solidifying shelling
drying
shelling drying
charring extracting
flowing
floating
catching
casting
decaying
flowing
eroding
depositing
building
aging
decomposing
uprooting
decaying
arriving anchoring
creeping
falling
maturing
resettling
growing
creeping
spinning felling
germinating
moving
constructing
growing
thickening
hardening
leaving designating
moistening
extracting
firing (baking) littering
piling
rooting
charring
birthing
surveying
weaving
rooting
dehusking
selling
moulding
disintegrating
preying incubating
baking
drying
storing
chunking
sorting
leaching
weaving
solidifying rooting
shelling
feeding
hatching capturing
gathering
floating
floating
shelling
drying
foraging
carving
crushing
feeding
nesting
secreting
floating
boiling
segregating (untangling)
logging
drying
drying decaying
hardening
catching
foraging
hatching
pecking
maturing
germinating
extracting
nesting
spinning weaving
hardening uprooting
thickening
assembling
drying
birthing
withering
packing
feeding
inhabiting
fruiting
weaving
plucking
charring
shelling
bundling
bundling
Agumbe rainforest
dampening
28
plucking
flying
plucking
flying
feeding
jumping
hatching
weaving
feeding
nesting
pecking
secreting
capturing
weaving
leaving
piling baking/ heating
constructing
growing
constructing
leaving
resettling
creeping maturing
falling
decaying
decomposing
dampening
falling
decaying
decomposing
flowing
flowing
constructing
growing creeping
decaying
migrating
designating
moistening
maturing
falling
leaving
piling baking/ heating
resettling growing
creeping maturing
preying incubating
gathering
migrating
designating
moistening
resettling
feeding
capturing
weaving
preying incubating piling
baking/ heating
migrating
designating
moistening
hatching
secreting
capturing
gathering
foraging
carving
feeding
weaving
preying incubating
gathering
feeding
nesting
pecking
hatching
foraging hatching
weaving
foraging
carving
incubating
feeding
nesting
feeding
hatching
secreting
hatching
pecking
feeding
jumping assembling
foraging
weaving
foraging
carving
incubating
assembling
foraging
plucking
flying
feeding
jumping
incubating
assembling
dampening
weaving
dampening weaving
weaving thatching
thatching
thatching drying
drying
decomposing
flowing
drying
bundling
bundling plucking
flowering
bundling plucking
flowering
fruiting withering
plucking
flowering
fruiting
hallowing
fruiting
hallowing
withering falling
thickening
hardening
falling
thickening
drying
hardening
drying
extracting
hardening
shelling
dehusking
drying
birthing
thickening
birthing
felling
germinating
germinating
logging
maturing
thickening
drying
drying
logging
maturing
uprooting decaying
decaying
floating
floating
rooting
rooting
packing
weaving
catching
segregating (untangling) unloading sorting
storing
unloading selling
storing
chunking
catching
segregating (untangling)
infrigidating (tempering)
sorting
rooting
packing
weaving segregating (untangling)
casting (in use)
spinning
felling
uprooting decaying
infrigidating (tempering)
sorting
unloading selling
storing
chunking
disintegrating
leaching crumbling
sorting
designating
anchoring
beaching
selling
crumbling
designating
firing (baking)
beaching
designating
eroding
depositing
building repairing
hardening
littering
seeing arriving anchoring
touristing buffering
powdering
travelling eroding
depositing
building repairing
hardening
littering
seeing arriving
moulding
disintegrating
leaching firing (baking)
anchoring
touristing buffering
powdering
storing storing
catching
travelling eroding
depositing
building repairing
crumbling hardening
littering
seeing arriving
infrigidating (tempering) chunking
casting
moulding
disintegrating
leaching firing (baking)
powdering
travelling
segregating (untangling)
casting (in use) sorting
catching moulding
catching
segregating (untangling) storing
casting catching
packing
weaving segregating (untangling)
casting (in use)
sorting
casting
Fig.25 Demonstrating shift of coastline according to processes.
thickening germinating
logging
floating
bundling
dehusking
spinning birthing
uprooting
charring extracting
drying
bundling
felling maturing
shelling shelling
charring extracting dehusking
spinning
solidifying
drying
shelling drying
crushing
liquefying boiling
shelling
drying
bundling
drying drying
extracting solidifying
charring extracting
drying
hardening hardening
crushing
liquefying boiling
shelling
drying
drying
extracting solidifying
thickening
drying
hardening
crushing
liquefying boiling
hallowing
withering
falling
touristing buffering
beaching
29
flying
flying
plucking
assembling
nesting
assembling
foraging
nesting
carving secreting
nesting
foraging
incubating
baking
piling moving
designating
moistening
designating
baking
resettling
constructing
moistening
growing
growing
creeping falling
piling
moistening
decaying
decomposing
constructing
resettling growing
growing
growing
creeping
creeping
falling
creeping
falling
aging
decaying
decomposing
flowing
leaving
moving
designating
baking
resettling
creeping
aging
incubating
gathering
moving
constructing
preying
leaving
growing
creeping
capturing
weaving
incubating
gathering
feeding
hatching
secreting
preying
leaving
feeding foraging
carving
feeding
capturing
weaving
piling
foraging
hatching nesting
pecking
hatching
secreting
preying
gathering
foraging
carving
feeding
hatching
nesting
weaving
feeding
nesting
capturing
weaving
assembling
foraging
hatching
pecking
feeding
inhabiting
weaving
feeding
hatching
plucking
feeding
inhabiting
weaving pecking
flying
plucking
feeding
inhabiting
aging
decaying
decomposing flowing
flowing
dampening
dampening
dampening
flowing
flowing
flowing
dampening
dampening
dampening weaving
weaving
weaving
thatching
thatching
thatching
drying
drying
drying
flowering
bundling
bundling
bundling flowering
plucking
hallowing withering
withering
withering
thickening
falling
falling
falling hardening
thickening
drying
drying
hardening extracting
crushing
hardening
hardening
thickening
drying
drying
crushing extracting
liquefying
boiling
dehusking
drying thickening
birthing
drying
birthing
maturing
germinating
extracting
thickening
germinating
logging
charring
shelling drying
drying
extracting
bundling
dehusking
spinning birthing
felling
maturing
shelling
drying
logging
thickening
germinating
drying
spinning
felling
maturing
logging uprooting
uprooting
uprooting
solidifying
charring bundling
dehusking
spinning felling
liquefying
shelling
shelling bundling
crushing
boiling
drying
extracting
drying
solidifying
charring
drying
drying
extracting
shelling
shelling
hardening
hardening
liquefying
boiling
solidifying
drying
decaying
decaying
decaying floating
floating
floating
floating
rooting
rooting
catching
segregating (untangling) casting
casting (in use) unloading
sorting
catching leaching
segregating (untangling) infrigidating (tempering)
casting
storing
storing
chunking
sorting
selling
casting (in use) unloading
sorting
catching
crumbling
powdering
anchoring
designating
repairing
depositing
travelling
eroding
buffering
beaching
selling
designating
repairing
casting (in use)
segregating (untangling)
unloading
sorting
catching
crumbling travelling
eroding
buffering
beaching
selling
powdering
surveying
arriving anchoring
touristing
storing
storing moulding
disintegrating
firing (baking) hardening
depositing
infrigidating (tempering)
chunking
sorting leaching
littering
building
rooting catching
moulding
powdering
surveying
arriving anchoring
touristing
storing
disintegrating
crumbling hardening
littering
casting
storing
chunking
firing (baking)
building
segregating (untangling)
infrigidating (tempering)
sorting leaching
surveying
arriving
rooting packing
weaving
segregating (untangling)
floating
floating
rooting
rooting catching
moulding
disintegrating
travelling
rooting packing
weaving
segregating (untangling)
floating
floating
floating
rooting
rooting
packing
weaving
Fig.26 Demonstrating shift of coastline according to agents
plucking
fruiting
hallowing
fruiting
hallowing
fruiting
flowering
plucking
firing (baking) hardening
littering
designating building
repairing
depositing
eroding
touristing
buffering
beaching
30
CONCLUSION
The Western Ghats are in constant flux. It is a fluid and dynamic field that sustains itself through visible and invisible change. Resilient ecosystems become so by the virtue of transformation, that leads to an emergence of something extra-ordinary, from the ordinary nature of things. Commodification is one such transformation that, we use to view all species (including humans). Every species transforms its surroundings to make it valuable and useful. On the whole, both biotic and abiotic agents brings about transformation in an ecosystem
Through our design intervention, we see the Ghats as a field that is resilient by the processes and agents that inhabit it. The same process may be performed by two different agents, while a single agent may be capable of performing more than one transformative process. Every species’ creativity determines the manifestation of the landscape of any biome in the world. The ‘strip’ of land that is today designated as the ‘Western Ghats’ is in reality an expansive web of processes that add, subtract and multiply the layers of the region.
Looking at the Western Ghats through the lens of commodification, is insightful, so as to enable us to similarities rather than differences between species. When we view the Ghats as an ecosystem with similarities widely diffused and complex, we are able to rethink the ways in which we categorise landscapes, species and practices.
To generalise a huge portion of the Ghats under one category is to oversimplify the complexity of the field that is interpolated with infinitesimal, yet integral processes that maintain this actively resilient field of transformation. And transformation as a change that allows resilience instead of hampering it.
Fig. 26 to 29 (clockwise) Traversing the Ghats from the sea (St. Mary’s Island) to the inland (Agumbe)
31
32
April 2014, Srishti School of Art, Design and Technology, Bangalore