The Statesman 11-18-19

Page 1

Volume LXIII, Issue 12

sbstatesman.com

Monday, November 18, 2019

2 19 USG judicial branch removed in campus vote

By Maya Brown and Sherin Samuel

Assistant News Editor and Contributing Writer

Stony Brook University’s Undergraduate Student Government (USG) is eliminating its judicial branch in a constitutional referendum that was passed on Friday, Nov. 15, with 324 “Yes” votes from students. In the USG Constitutional Referendum Cheat Sheet, USG argues that removing the judiciary branch will improve “operational efficiency, cost-benefit of payroll, lack of constitutional checks/balances for accountability, and legal liability issues of hearing cases and FERPA laws.” “The judiciary has no formal application process and there was no procedure to keep them accountable,” Shaheer Khan, senior political science major and USG president, said. Unlike the legislative and executive branches, which consist of elected positions, judiciary members are nominated by the president and approved by the senate. Although the terms of the legislative and executive branches finish

AMAYA MCDONALD / THE STATESMAN

L’afrique Dance Team performs at the 19th annual Multicultural Show and Food Tasting event. Students, faculty and cultural clubs and organizations gathered in SAC Ballrooom A on Thursday, Nov. 14. at the end of the spring semester, judiciary members continue in their positions until “the end of the second subsequent academic year” after their initial appointment. According to the rough draft of the constitution,

USG said the judiciary is seen as “highly concentrated power.” Andrew Machkasov, a former USG senator who graduated in May, argued against this point. “The key is to make the judiciary independent of the politicization

of the elections,” he said. “The fact that they’re independent and not up for reappointment every year makes them more impartial since they won’t be likely to shift their vote in exchange for reappointment.”

According to the old version of the constitution, the duties and responsibilities of the judiciary branch include jurisdiction over the impeachment of

in USG, hears cases involving USG from students and helps to oversee club constitutions. “I think one of the biggest concerns people have about USG is that we're too bureaucratic,” Shaheer Khan, senior political science major and president of USG, said. “And we're adding extra steps for students to kind of get their services. We're trying to find a way that makes it more accessible, and less, you know, burdensome on students.” Impeachment oversight under the amended constitution requires support from three-quarters of the executive council and three-quarters of the senate, as compared to twothirds of the senate and three-quarters of the judiciary under the previous constitution. Oversight of club constitutions now entirely falls to the Department of Student Engagement and Activities. As far as student cases go, footnote 208 in the rough draft of the proposed constitution claims that USG has “historically had issues of violating University policies to … hear cases involving certain circumstances such as Title IX issues or [HIPAA]

laws. These can be taken care of by the University administration, and removing USG’s role in such provides us safety from legal liability.” Khan said that those types of cases should fall to professional staff members, such as the Title IX office or an administrator. Data from the New York State Education Department released last August showed that out of 24 reports of sexual misconduct, domestic violence and other related incidents filed with the university’s Title IX office, only two resulted in some form of sanctions for the respondent, and none resulted in expulsion or suspension. He explained that more specific Title IX language will be added when USG writes an operation manual. “So every student-assembled student association, undergraduate student government is obligated by SUNY Chancellor guidelines to have an operation manual,” he said. “USG doesn't have one, but we will draft one and within that operation manual will have a more detailed Title IX language.”

By Alek Lewis

Takeback Day; the 2018 National Survey on Drug Use and Health estimated that 9.9 million Americans misused controlled prescription drugs. Takeback Day is an opportunity to safely dispose of drugs that may be used by other members in a household for abuse, according to their website. The last National Take Back Day on Oct. 26 collected 882,919 pounds of drugs across the country.

Continued on page 4

Referendum passes revised USG constitution SBU "Sheds the Meds"

By Brianne Ledda News Editor

Proposed changes to Stony Brook University’s Undergraduate Student Government (USG) constitution were approved on Friday, Nov. 15, effective immediately. The referendum, which opened on Monday, Nov. 11 at noon, was passed with 73%, or 324 votes. Twenty-seven percent, or 119 students, voted “No.” At 443 votes, less than 3% of the student body voted in the referendum. A campus-wide email announcing the referendum and elections for freshman and senior class senators was sent on Saturday, Nov. 9. The email included a link to a Google Drive folder with an annotated draft with the proposed changes, a final draft of the new constitution and a document describing major changes, in addition to the current constitution. There are more than 250 footnotes denoting changes, but the most significant change to the constitution is the removal of the judiciary, which oversees impeachments with-

Continued on page 6

Contributing Writer

Stony Brook University hosted a pharmaceutical take back effort on Wednesday, Nov. 13 to help the Stony Brook community safely dispose of old and unused pharmaceuticals using an “environmentally supportive” incineration process. Organized by SBU Student Health, Wellness and Prevention Services and the Suffolk County Police Sheriff Department’s prescription drug take back program “Shed the Meds,” sheriff’s deputies and members of those organizations collected old medications and sunscreens at the Student Activities Center (SAC) lobby kiosk from 12 p.m. to 3 p.m. At the end of the three hours, the Sheriff's Department collected 82 pounds of old medications and waste to dispose. Last April, the same event disposed of 62 pounds of medication. The event took place on the Drug Enforcement Administration’s biannual National Prescription Drug

“I think [the collection is] important for the campus community and the outside community." -Suzanne Sciortino

Peer Health educator at CHILL

Continued on page 6


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.