Scott B. Archer
Architecture & Urban Design Portfolio
Table of Contents Architecture and Urban Design Portfolio
Urban Design Studio Projects 6
Growing Canopies
Kumasi, Ghana | GSAPP, Columbia University
26
Emerging Stages
40
A New Old
Brooklyn, New York | GSAPP, Columbia University Manhattan, New York | GSAPP, Columbia University
Undergraduate Architecture Studio Projects 50
Threshold: Freedom – Security
58
Urban Facade + Hotel
66
Well-Dressed Design Center
74
Sculpting Shadows
Jackson, Mississippi | Mississippi State University – Jackson Center Jackson, Mississippi | Mississippi State University – Jackson Center Washington, D.C. | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center Alexandria, Virginia | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center
Professional Work Samples 86
Park Pavilion
88
Park Restroom Facility
90
Union University Dormitories
Union City, Tennessee | TLM Associates, Inc. Jackson, Tennessee | TLM Associates, Inc. Jackson, Tennessee | TLM Associates, Inc.
Academic Research 94
Healthy Bodegas
Bronx, New York | Columbia University
Teaching: Student Work 106
Sustainable Urbanization
110
Power in Public
New York, New York | Columbia University New York, New York | Columbia University
Other Academic Work 118
3 American Regions + 1
122
The Survivors on Bowery
126
Transforming Treads
130
New Typologies in St. Louis
134
Doha: A Short History
138
Travel Sketches
142
Photography: Protesting
Brooklyn, Indianapolis, Oakland + Austin | GSAPP, Columbia University New York, New York | GSAPP, Columbia University NYC Subway Station | GSAPP, Columbia University Old North St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri | GSAPP, Columbia University Doha, Qatar | GSAPP, Columbia University Study Abroad – Italy | Mississippi State University Washington, D.C. | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center 3
4
Urban Design Studio Projects
Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation | Columbia University 5
6
Growing Canopies Holistic Health through Ecology & Architecture Kumasi, Ghana In collaboration with Samarth Das, Vanessa Espaillat, & Sagi Golan Spring 2013 | GSAPP, Columbia University
The fast growing population of Kumasi is putting immense pressure on several key infrastructures, natural ecology, and most importantly the health of the city. This project focuses on the concept of ‘holistic health’ in the development of the city of Kumasi. The strategy is tested within two sites — a pilot project in waste management within a new peri-urban municipality of Asokore Mampong and a rural site that encompasses the design of a specialist hospital. Kumasi’s landscape consists of a series of ecological corridors that transverse the city, creating green spinal connections through its fabric. These lands fall under the traditional Chief’s authority but are presently threatened by sprawl and encroachment of housing, informal commerce, agriculture, and industry. These corridors can become key areas where development of productive canopies along with sustainable harvesting safeguard the same while contributing to the region’s economy. The pharmaceutical industry has been noted as an essential area of investment for the city of Kumasi. Favorable political policies coupled with an immense human knowledge capital emerging from Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology provide the city with competitive advantages in developing this industry locally. The increase in demands for traditional herbal medicines suggest cultivation of an industry focused on the production and distribution of these herbs — 85% of which grow within the region’s semi-deciduous climate. A formal distribution corridor along the Tamale-Accra road, along with the upgrading of the airport and a new ring road proposal, places Kumasi strategically within the nation as well as the sub-Saharan region. Severe environmental degradation and frequent epidemics give the city the urgency to develop new treatments and drugs. The eco-corridors are also threatened by poor waste management. Providing a new system of collection as well as co-composting household and human wastes can begin to reduce the contamination of the city’s waterways. Currently filled with various types of waste, these waterways are distributing water-borne disease through direct human contact, dispersed agriculture irrigation and fostered mosquito proliferation. The cleaner irrigation water and newly produced compost would create higher yields for farmers as well as diminishing the spread of these diseases. 7
Overall Strategy The comprehensive system comprises various elements of holistic health, such as the healthcare system, traditional herbal medicines, aspects of eco-therapy, allopathic pharmaceutical industry as well as waste management. Our project aims to evolve a strategy that synthesizes these elements in order to have a meaningful impact on the overall health of the city of Kumasi. Enhancing the overall approach of holistic health, nature embedded within urban as well as architectural environments can provide exceptional healing effects and healthier lifestyles. This strategy is manifested within the design of the specialty hospital for the West African Health Foundation (WAHF) in the rural town of Juaben. Designed as a series of programmatic nodes interwoven with open-air circulation, courtyards and a productive landscape, the hospital’s patients can take advantage of the broadened ideas of holistic health. The intersection between the ecological and architectural canopy stresses the importance of nature penetrating the formal volumes of the hospital. Through its design, the building embodies the values of holistic health and aims to become an image that inspires future developments.
8
9
Holistic Health Kumasi – once known as the Garden City of West Africa - faces a great challenge to preserve and utilize their lush protected lands along its waterways, which have become the city’s key environmental infrastructure. Bottom-up cooperative models of development play an important role in improving the socio-economic conditions of their members and local communities. The organizational system provides both economic and social benefits, strength-
10
ening community networks and reinforcing the importance of cooperation and education through waste management and medicinal plant production strategies. In the dual political system, traditional authorities have complete ownership of the land and therefore play an important role in the land provision. Meanwhile, the modern government will continue to have a managerial role within the strategy.
11
Sustainable Eco-Corridors The natural canopy in Kumasi’s semideciduous forests hosts over a 150 species of native plants, which have a variety of nutritional, herbal, medicinal, and construction uses. Environmental degradation and unsustainable harvesting have made many of these plants extremely rare, and demand for these plants continues to rise in local markets.
12
Therefore, strategies of remediation and prevention should be employed throughout Kumasi’s eco-corridors to protect this important infrastructure. A system of bioswales, co-composting, and herbal production can be used as a measure to prevent informal encroachment into these protected lands.
1
USES:
2
Construction
3
Food Source
4
5
Herbal Medicine
10 6
Paint
7
8
9
10
11
12
Allopathy
13
Asokore Mampong Asokore Mampong, the first municipality outside of Kumasi Metropolitan Assembly (KMA) boundaries, currently faces complex land tenure ship, environmental degradation, together with poor systems of service management and provision. The eco-corridor strategy is based on an environmental remediation plan, which restores the important natural canopy, replenishes the eroded soil with co-composting process of human and organic waste, collects and cleans
14
the rainwater runoff and sets up an economy of medicinal herbal production. This system is devised through a series of wet-bottom ponds and terraced bio-swales that slow down rainwater runoff flow and naturally cleanse it before releasing it to the waterway. After the water and waste system has been put in place, the medicinal plant cooperatives begin the process of selective harvest of medicinal plants, completely transforming the waterways into productive eco-corridors for the municipality.
15
WAHF Hospital Significance With extremely high maternal and child mortality in Ghana and a severe brain drain in Kumasi’s health system, WAHF hospital has an opportunity to become a leading hospital in Kumasi locally, and internationally in the sub-Saharan region. By focusing on these health issues and providing specialty care, while retaining and training skilled doctors. WAHF creates a holistic approach to the role of the hospital. This holistic approach is not only programmatic but also uses herbal medicine as part of the healing process by developing codes of dosage and usage in the research and development center within the hospital. The hospital plays an important role in its relationship to the town of Juaben, where women from the town will be employed in the herbal and therapeutic center. The town itself will cater to visitors that come to the hospital by providing lodging and dining facilities. The hospital’s economic model provides health care for high income patients, who in turn will subsidize lower income patients and providing funding for the upgrade of the existing district hospital.
16
17
WAHF Hospital The plan organizes the most public elements of the hospital— primarily the diagnostic and consultation centers, to be accessible easily to the majority of visitors. This initial out-patient department leads into a more private and secured in-patient facility with operation theaters, single patient rooms and wards for men, women and children. Stressing on the importance of herbal medicine, a therapeutic healing center is located towards the end of the site, along with shortterm hotel rooms for patients’ families.
18
Through each stage of its development, this plan has constantly aimed at integrating the formal programs of the hospital with the healing aspect of natural landscapes. The courtyard becomes a formal element of organization and orientation for users, setting up a rhythm of movement through the hospital. It allows natural light to flood the corridors and rooms while facilitating cross ventilation of air.
19
Hospital Entrance The entrance facade of the hospital becomes a key feature in asserting the presence and identity of the hospital on the main Ejisu-Juaben road. The image of the hospital as a leading center for training as well as research and development is asserted by locating these programs on this edge. The building sets back to a large fore-court that receives pedestrians. The drop-off area for vehicles is beyond a controlled entry point restricting the gathering of informal hawkers around such areas. Publicly accessible programs such as the pharmacy and the blood bank are also located along this edge, for users who only need these services. A new architectural canopy provides shade, facilitates ventilation, collects rainwater and hosts solar panels oriented for capturing maximum sunlight. The canopy becomes the visual identity of the hospital and is an element that unifies the various parts of the building.
20
21
Section Understanding The hospital is envisioned to be made of a composite structure of local materials such as landcrete, concrete and bamboo. Bamboo grown on site proves to be a highly economical material. It serves to allocate spaces for future growth of the hospital and can be used in various stages of construction. The project also capitalizes on the heavy rainfall and strong sunlight by collection in storage tanks for irrigation purposes as well as storing solar energy in inverters for small uses. Primarily a space frame that allows for the variations in the roof, the structure is comprised of bamboo members with prefabricated metal joinery. Modular sections allow for the extension of the roof along with the future expansion of the hospital. Other systems in the building include a passive cooling mechanism that deploys fresh cool air within the floor to keep the overall temperature in control and a grey water cleansing living machine that filters and feeds back into the flushing tanks in the toilets of the hospital.
22
23
WAHF Hospital Phasing The design of the hospital aims to promote the well-being of its patients through the overall values of holistic health that it embodies. To be sustainably constructed, the hospital has been designed to be built in phases if necessary. During early phases, bamboo can be planted in the future building footprint and building material can be literally grown on site. This cost effective solution can help WAHF build the entire hospital more quickly with smaller monetary capital investment. In conclusion, a hospital with an architectural canopy weaving through a new productive ecological canopy can serve as an example of development for the metropolitan region surrounding Kumasi.
24
25
26
Emerging Stages A Film and New Media Core in Greenpoint Brooklyn, New York In collaboration with Vanessa Espaillat, Carolina Montilla, & Jun Peng Fall 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
A learning city continues to innovate through collaboration and Greenpoint presents itself as a strategic location for collaboration within the film industry. Greenpoint’s urban fabric allows for different levels of collaboration not only within the film industry but with other industries already present in NYC like fashion and apparel, multimedia software, finance, performing arts, network TV and broadcasting, among others. Film industry subsectors can exist in close proximity to one another and promote collaboration by encouraging the existing diversity and flexibility of spaces. Our project intends to promote Greenpoint as a core for the film industry in NYC, while maintaining interaction and collaboration among other sub-sectors in the film industry. Through the creation of a set of design strategies Greenpoint will maintain its current urban character and scale, providing an alternative to the current zoning changes. At the same time, a new network of transportation is proposed using the current ferry terminal on India Street as a node of activity and introducing bike sharing stations and activating a new red of bike paths in Greenpoint. Within the film industry the stages of Pre- and Post- Production are the ones that allow for the highest level of collaboration with other fields. In order to promote such interaction, our proposal creates a set of programmatic clusters with anchor points. These clusters (pre-production, postproduction, education, cultural and residential) provide spaces and proximity for collaboration on multiple scales. Collaboration can occur within a building, between buildings in public spaces, and in between sectors through cluster relationships. Our proposal encourages collaboration within the Film and New Media industry, establishing Greenpoint as its center of activity. Our project challenges the idea of ‘gated innovation campus’ by integrating technology, innovation and collaboration into the urban fabric.
27
Collaboration Innovative thought comes through productive collaboration. Face-to-face interaction can be housed in many types of urban environments. Brooklyn encapsulates many urban spaces that contain collaborative atmospheres: the protected Brooklyn Navy Yard, the co-working cooperative at the Metropolitan Exchange Building, the incubator cluster in DUMBO, and live/work spaces in Williamsburg, among others.
Brooklyn Navy Yard
28
Co-working Cooperative at the Metropolitan Exchange Building
Incubator Cluster in DUMBO
Business Hub of Downtown Brooklyn
Live/Work Spaces in Williamsburg
Collaborative Media Industries in Greenpoint
29
Film Industry in NYC An industry based on collaborative innovation is film and new media, and New York City is already home to many companies within this industry. Exhibiting strong financial ties to the city, four of the six top film companies (ranked by market share), are headquartered within New York. Current incentives by both the city and state have promoted many sectors of the production process to begin to use this city as a base for film production.
Month
1
2
3
4
5
6
DEVELOPMENT
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Script Breakdown and Schedule Board Creation & Revision Budget Creation & Revision
Pre-Production Conceptual Meetings and Director Starts Casting Music & Post-Production Meetings Production Manager, Production Coordinator, and Auditor Start Production Designer and Location Manager Start
PRE-PRODUCTION
Location Scout and Discussions with Studio Department Head Set Decorator and Costume Designer Start First Assistant Director, Prop Master, and Transportation/Construction Coordinator Start Secure Camera, Grip, and Electric Bids Start Special Effects Hire Editor Sign Final Budget Cast Rehearsals, Measurements/Wardrobe Tests, Remainder of Crew Starts
PRODUCTION
Principal Photography Editor’s Assembly Director’s Cut Previews and Changes Lock Picture Turn Over to Music and Effects Opticals and Titles Foley (Sound Effects)
POST-PRODUCTION
ADR (Dialog Replacement) Scoring of Music Negative Cut Color Tuning Pre-Dubbing of Dialog and Effects Final Stereo Dubbing View Answer Print
DISTRIBUTION Striking Interactives
Video Game Developers
Finance
Performing Arts Companies
Multimedia Software Companies
Data Sources:
www.sonypicturesmuseum.com/uploads/img/std_content/timeline_02.jpg www.filmunderground.com/180/article/NWFS/Page/1/Five-Phases-of-Filmmaking.htm
San Francisco Film Office. “San Francisco Film Cluster Economic Analysis.” April 2007. http://38.106.4.41/Modules/ShowDocument.aspx?documentid=52 30
Apparel / Fashion / Costuming
Internet Content Developers
Network TV and Cable Broadcasting
e Tim
|1
3.4
%
.2%
TOKYO
y
isne
ersa
Fo xS
ea
rch
%
NB
CU
ni
ve r
sa
l|
11
.5%
lig
ht
tur y
Cen
Univ
al W LOS ANGELES METRO
20th
F
es tur
ea
sF
u oc
l
Sony Pictures
Pic ny So NEW YORK CITY | 59.8%
New
.
s
ture
Walt D
t Pic Br os
ne
s
i tD
o yC
11.1
y
oun er
Viacom | 19.3%
m
m Para Wa rn
n pa
2 |1
cs
ssi
Cla
es tur
rp. |
p.
s Co
or
7.9% r|1
yC
ne War
So n
Fox
Out of Scop e Sec
tors
BRO A
ME D
PU
ITA
NEW MEDIA
Film & New Media Industry
UBATO INC RS
TRADITIONAL MEDIA
H /TEC VC AN IA DIG L
BL
MUSIC
D
ADV ER
C
G SIN TI ISHING AND
[Education ]
Schools
FILM & TV
WS NE
What are the needs of this industry?
D
T EN M ABLE
FILM
LIVE EVENTS
ENTERTAIN ED CASTING AND
MEDIA DISTRIBUTION
[ Spatial ]
Universities
Large Scale Production Studios (Range: 20,000 - 100,000 sq. ft) Medium to Small Production Spaces (Range: <20,000 sq. ft)
Cultural Institutions Film & New Media Training Center
Parking and Service Areas
Manufacturing
[ Lifestyle ]
[ Support ]
Local Character
Performing Arts Tourism Music Fashion Construction Finance
[ Transportation] Airports Trains Subway Local and Inter-state Road Infrastructure Bus Routes
Parks & Recreation
[
Time
]
Flexible Rent Periods Time Difference between Competing Cities Proximity for Industry Collaboration
Office Space Low- Rent Live/Work Space for New Media Residential Units Hotels
Broadband Retail Restaurants Coffee Shops Bars Safety
Bicycle Routes
31
Spatial Typology Needed The film and new media industry is unique in the spatial typology it demands. Large volumes of space are needed for setbuilding, filming, and storage, while small live/work spaces are demanded by small video editing, costume designing, and sound mixing companies. Therefore the discovery of this unique line where the cities industrial fabric meets a thriving residential community is ideal for this industry. Greenpoint has the longest of this type of “buffer line” within Brooklyn. Starting with this line, a series of actions were taken to create an “innovation zone” for the film industry and preserve the typology of space needed. By integrating public spaces, transportation, and existing industry, among others, the zone is not a fixed line, but continues to morph and develop over time.
Incorporating Existing Film & New Media Industry
Linking Subways & Ferries
Including Warehouse Truck Access
Absorbing Vacant Land
Integrating Public Spaces
32
Industrial/Residential Buffer Lines in Brooklyn
33
Why Greenpoint? Not only does Greenpoint house the longest industrial/residential buffer in Brooklyn it is located strategically between many assets for the industry. Steiner Studio in Navy Yard, Silvercup & Kaufman studios in Queens, and the new Made in NY Media Center to be located in DUMBO, surround Greenpoint and give a substantial critical mass of the industry needed for smaller firms and creative people to locate nearby. The Greenpoint Film Festival also has a long tradition of promoting creativity through film in this neighborhood.
34
35
Clusters Within Greenpoint, the presence of existing media industry, vacant lots and buildings, and the right types of urban fabric allowed for several sub-clusters to be designed throughout the community. Therefore, not creating the typical walled lots of studio complexes and integrating the industry within the existing community. A series of regulations, including height, setbacks, preservation, and social spaces were also developed to facilitate this new industry, as well as counteract a recently-approved planning proposal, which promotes high-rise (30-40 stories) of private residential construction, completely eliminating the character and scale along the Greenpoint East River waterfront.
Brooklyn Artist Alliance (existing)
Service Access (West St.)
Active Rooftop for Private Residential Uses
â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;The Endâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; Recording Studio (existing)
Fashion Designer Studio
Classroom Spaces
Artist Studios
36
Art Galleries
Mobility/Connectivity
Residential Live/Make Cluster
Connecting Bike Paths Pedestrian Routes to South Ferry
Residential & Live-Make Spaces (Max.height =13 stories) Workshop/Fabrication Spaces Greenpoint Manufacturing + Design Center Slightline Fabrication Stage Design
e
ess Blvd McGuinn
n Av Manhatta
Proposed Interventions Existing Program Proposed Green Spaces Existing Bike Paths Proposed Bike Paths
Cultural/Production Cluster
t
India Stree
Short-Term Residential Commercial Corridor + Public Plazas Flexible Production Space Theater Complex Kickstarter.com Faber Pencil Factory Lofts Stunt Training Center Brownstone Type (Live/Work)
ve. nA
ma Nor
Co-working Post Production Cluster
New Bicycle Route (Franklin St.)
Pre-Production Cluster Co-Working Spaces Pre-Production Warehouses Short-Term Residential Bars & Restaurants at Ground Level Broadway Stages
Education + Community Adaptive Re-use Library
Post-Production Warehouse Spaces Audio/Sound Stages Film and New Media Post-Production New Media Live/Work
Readapted Warehouse: Vertical Growth
e. t Av
oin
enp Gre
ve. au A
s
Nas
David Mastny Functional Art Studios (existing)
Maintaining commercial activity on ground floor
Separate Cycling Lanes
37
Cultural Cluster This cluster along the waterfront is seen as the trigger for the project. Connecting the ferry terminal southward to blocks hosting commercial, retail, and existing media industry, the needed pedestrian traffic can be leveraged to activate a new social corridor. The corridor is punctuated by the iconic Greenpoing water tower and provides a home for the film festival and museum near the existing Transmitter Park. The development of this sub-cluster will also help to establish the culture of development within the Greenpoint urban fabric.
38
East Ferry
Insertion of new commercial pedestrian corridor
KICK STARTER .COM Transmitter Park art market
AL TIV NCERTS FILM FMUESISC CO TS ITY EVEN
COMMUN
Activation through new cultural space ROOFTOP TERRACE
OFFICE
CLASSROOM OFFICE CLASSROOM
PERFORMANCE CHAMBER
ER THEATH
BACKSTAGE
LOBBY
LOUNGE/ CAFE/ MEETING SPACE
PLAZA
ENCIL FABER P Y LOFTS R O T FAC
SOUND STAGES
Fishing Pier
Re-Use of large warehouse structures
K
OR CO-W -
POST TION PRODUC
Core of interaction and collaboration Highlight and enhance local landmarks
Occupied roof spaces Public interaction in retail and education spaces
ENTER
AINING C
STUNT TR
Water
OWS Tower LIGHCOTMMSUNHITY EVENTS
Existing Playground
39
40
A New Old Active Aging in Two Bridges Manhattan, New York In collaboration with Wang Gu & Ara Hovsepyan Summer 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
New York City is aging. The senior population of NYC will grow from 11.8% in 2008 to 20% in 2030.” The redesign of the urban fabric of Manhattan—using the Two Bridges area as a case study—will provide this rapidly growing elderly population with a safer and more comfortable environment to age in place. [1] New housing, [2] transit connections with accessible waterfront, and [3] an integrated path network provide a framework in which the future populations can continue to use Two Bridges as a place of social interaction and graceful aging. With continued political and developmental focus on New York City’s waterfront, the current NYCHA housing stock on the East River waterfront in Manhattan is under constant scrutiny. This projects capitalizes on the political will of waterfront development and the city’s increased necessity for housing. Elderly design is community design. Through design which acknowledges the needs of the elderly, the urban fabric is more hospitable for a community of all ages. New mirco-unit housing provides spaces for elderly and young professionals to live, sharing communal spaces and developing relationships of mutual benefit. The addition of transit connections, integrating ferry and subway networks, provide increased access for all members of the community as well as access for other New Yorkers into the Two Bridges area. A network of resting stops, not only provide increased mobility for the aging, but also provide spaces for interaction and gathering for all of those in the community. A new Two Bridges, Manhattan can exist not only as a sympathetic urban fabric for an aging population, but an urban fabric that improves the quality of life for all of its residents.
41
Proposed Housing Towers
care
As NYC’s housing needs grow, new typologies are being developed. Mayor Bloomberg has announced support for a new “micro-unit” to be developed in the city. Traditionally these unitscare are targeted care care toward single, transitory, young professionals; however, a single elderly adult prevalent prevalent agesmall group could also benefit from the privateage group living spaces, with large active communal spaces throughout the building. Current NYCHA (New York City Housing Authority) waiting lists are hundreds of families long. Many of the occupied apartments are home to single elderly adults. Because policies of the Housing Authority have been developed to allow seniors to age in place, there are no mechanisms to free up these large 2 and 3 bedroom apartments for families in need. With the constuction of micro-unit towers nearby, portions of the facilities be reserved for the NYCHA elderly, care carecan allowing them to age in their neighborhoods, while freeing up needed space.
NYCHA Waiting List
...................
WAITING
Typology 2 Typology 2
Living Room
Larger family moves into NYCHA residence.
care care
3 ygoloTypology pyT Typology 3 3 Single seniors move into more efficient housing nearby.
Kitchen
care care
Bath
prevalent prevalent ageage group group
Bedroom 1
Bedroom 2 care care
42
685 sq. ft.
Average NYCHA Unit
erac
Typology Typology 22
Typology Typology 33
350 sq. ft.
Mirco-Unit Challenge
.............
WAITING
Library & Reading Spaces
Media & Entertainment Spaces
Bar & Lounge Spaces
Dining & Sitting Areas
Childrenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Play Areas
Office & Computer Spaces
Laundry Areas
Arts & Performance Spaces
Gourmet Kitchen Areas
Outdoor Spaces
New Micro Unit Apartments 43
Transit Station & Waterfront A new transit station connecting the East River Ferry to the MTA subway system is integral in providing for mobility of this aging population. By creating a subway station connecting to existing lines on the Manhattan Bridge, a direct connection between this transit system and the East River waterfront is established for first time. Among the structure of the station, much needed spaces for recreation and relaxation are introduced for the community.
44
45
Path Network & Rest Areas An elderly person can comfortably walk only about a quarter of a mile before needing a rest. Through the development of network of rest stations, the aging population in Two Bridges can move further from their homes and into the community. Stations located no more than this threshold distance of a quarter mile provide ample opportunity for elderly mobility in the community. This greater mobility helps to combat the isolation noted earlier. Designed to resemble a subway map, the network can be easily understood with stops named and amenities clearly noted. These resting stations house many amenities. All include basic seating and spaces for rest; however, many include additional amenities such as shade, playgrounds, sporting facilities, game tables, MTA transit stops, ferry terminals, and dining or shopping nearby. Through the inclusion of all of these activities the map is versatile enough to be useful to future communities, even without a majority elderly population. These nodes become places of interaction and social engagement, strengthening the sense of community in Two Bridges.
Collect Pond Park
Columbus Park
Foley Square
Municipal Building City Hall West
Park Row
City Hall East
James Madison Plaza
Murry Bergtraum High
Smith Ho Verizon Tower
Catherine & S Peck & Pearl East River South Street Seaport
East River Blueway Cont.
46
Peck & South
Pier 17
Confucius Plaza Allen & Canal Seward Park Chatham Square Henry St.
Sophie Irene Loes Park
Market & Madison
La Guardia Houses
PS2 Meyer London
Little Flower Playground Madison & Pike
Catherine & Madison Coleman Square
ouses
Tanahey Playground East Tanahey Playground West Market & South
Cherry & Pike
Cherry Clinton Playground Rutgers Park East River Blueway Cont. Chinatown YMCA Basketball City
East River - Manhattan Bridge
South
Map Legend - Brooklyn Bridge
Seating Area
Public Plaza
Shaded Seating Area
Sidewalk Benches Available
Playgound
Elderly Accessible Path
Sporting Facilities Game Tables MTA Transit Nearby Ferry or Boat Terminal Food Nearby Shopping Nearby
47
48
Undergraduate Architecture Studio Projects Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation | Columbia University 49
50
Threshold: Freedomâ&#x20AC;&#x201C;Security On the grounds of the Mississippi State Capitol Jackson, Mississippi Spring 2012 | School of Architecture, Mississippi State University
The Mississippi State Capitol sits on an axis that is perpendicular to the original axis of the city. Using the maps created from security concerns and the idea of a entry point into the city, the northeast corner of the Capitol grounds was chosen for my building. The proposed architectural intervention would frame the dome of the Capitol as one approached from the east on High Street. The building begins to dissolve into the sky from the heavy mass that is integrated with the earth perfectly framing the dome with the two main marble tubes. The mapping of security threats and barriers across the site also allowed for the generation of the topographical change to create a short security wall around the building without blocking any axial or symbolic views toward the Capitol. Entry into this secure zone could only be accessed through the proposed building. The building massing itself is composed of three marble tubes with connection blocks between. Entry is indicated through the angled slice at the ends of the tubes. The first tube acts as a extended vestibule, which holds the security screening, before entry into the lobby itself. The lobby opens back up toward the Capitol with views again framed by the two massive marble walls. The modern pureness of the tube form provides great contrast to the Baroque architectural features of the Capitol. By creating the tubes from the same marble as was used in the Capitolâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s construction, a natural comparison between form and ornamentation would be presented. The second tube entered, once one passed through the lobby, would be the first gallery space and queuing for the orientation theater. Following orientation the visitor would be directed into the third tube and gallery space and then exit to the secure Capitol grounds and eventually return to this tube for transition to the dedicated exit space.
51
Axis of Symbology As mentioned there are two main symbolic axes within downtown Jackson, Mississippi. The Capitol exists on the northern portion of the new axis and comprises the largest public space within the downtown area. The architectural symbolism in style was also studied and abstracted to understand profile, shade, form, and color more thoroughly before making an addition to the site.
52
53
Planning The mapping of security threats and barriers across the site (including blast distances, vehicular speed, existing ground circulation, topographic and landscape features, among others) allowed for the generation of the topographical change to create a short security wall around the building without blocking any axial or symbolic views toward the Capitol. Entry into this secure zone could only be accessed through the proposed building.
Security Stand-off Distance Requirements for Luggage (75’), Automobiles (150’), & Trucks (350’)
Scale: 1” = 100’
Potential Security Threats from Vehicular Speed
Combined Map Security Concerns
Scale: 1” = 100’
Scale: 1” = 100’
The building massing itself is composed of three marble tubes with connection blocks between. Entry is indicated through the angled slice at the ends of the tubes. The first tube acts as a extended vestibule, which holds the security screening, before entry into the lobby itself. The lobby opens back up toward the Capitol with views again framed by the two massive marble walls. The second tube entered, once one passed through the lobby, would be the first gallery space and queuing for the orientation theater. Following orientation the visitor would be directed into the third tube and gallery space and then exit to the secure Capitol grounds and eventually return to this tube for transition to the dedicated exit space.
Pedestrian Movement Connections between Buildings
54
Scale: 1” = 100’
Security Barriers Physical and Topographical
Scale: 1” = 100’
North
Plan Scale: 1/8” = 1’-0”
Se on
cti
y rit e cu ag Se tor S
5
g
nin
e re
Sc
ea Ar
.& l ch ica Melectr E
e fic
ly
On
2
ce
Re
Exit
nc
&
cy
1&
o eL
tra
En
y bb
ce
pa
nS
o pti
en
s ion
erg
ibit Exhrage Sto
cu
Se
r
ito
Jan
ion
bit xhi
ace
Sp
E
ion
ct Se
n
Me
4
en
m Wo
ct
Se
n3
tio
c Se
Em
Of
y rit
n& tio k ma hec r o C Inf oat C
E cy
en erg
Em xit
he
ly On
r ate
T
/ dio Auideo V
ing
eu
Qu
Gif
p
ho
tS
& at Coag ge B tora S
eck Cheturn R
t
Exi
cy en
erg
Em nly sO
Exit
ien
Or
r
ate
he
nT
io tat
ce
pa
nS
io ibit
Exh
55
Form The modern pureness of the white marble tube form provides great contrast to the Baroque architectural features of the Capitol. By creating the tubes from the same marble as was used in the Capitol’s construction, a natural comparison between form and ornamentation would be presented. The lobby space is directly below the free speech plaza, which is comprised of three main levels that ascend toward the Capitol. If there were to be an organized protest or gathering, a leader or group of leaders could stand on the uppermost piece with the Capitol acting as a backdrop. The architecture would provide the symbolic nature of freedom, even amongst the security required. A system of ramps cups the spaces in plan to allow for multiple sizes of gatherings and a variety of spaces. Each elevation provides different views and exposes more of the focal point, the Capitol itself.
Section 1
Scale: 1/8” = 1’-0”
56
Section 2
Scale: 1/16” = 1’-0”
Section 3
Scale: 1/8” = 1’-0”
Section 4
Scale: 1/8” = 1’-0”
57
58
Urban Facade + Hotel Quilting Context Jackson, Mississippi Fall 2011 | School of Architecture, Mississippi State University
This project was developed for investigation into the design of urban buildings, specifically their facades. The semester was introduced through a series of assignments focusing on pattern-making and craft with the making of quilts. The quilts were derived from abstract representations of potential project sites, which were complex, layered mappings of light & shadow, movement, permeability, and effects of perceived perspective of buildings. Once the quilting was complete, the hotel was assigned for the final portion of the semester, with a strong focus on the facade and skin development. This development was derived from the pattern-making strategies in the quilt, the surrounding site conditions, and the clients who appreciate both folk art and modern architecture. Therefore, I developed the strategy of pulling the patterning and depth of openings from the facades of the surrounding buildings to create a new but referential pattern to be applied to the building mass, very much like the process of vernacular folk art in Mississippi. Concepts of figure and ground, overlapping, and connection were taken from the quilt and integrated into the building facade. The facade itself was designed to be constructed with steel framing, aluminum storefront, and an aluminum panel system, through which the developed pattern of figures protrude.
59
Quilting Context The semester was introduced through a series of assignments focusing on patternmaking and craft with the making of quilts. The quilts were derived from abstract representations of potential project sites, which were complex, layered mappings of light & shadow, movement, permeability, and effects of perceived perspective of buildings.
60
61
Pattern-Making Designing for clients who appreciate both folk art and modern architecture, the strategy of pulling the patterning and depth of openings from the facades of the surrounding buildings to create a new but referential pattern to be applied to the building mass, very much like the process of vernacular folk art in Mississippi. The facade itself was designed to be constructed with steel framing, aluminum storefront, and an aluminum panel system, through which the developed pattern of figures protrude.
EAST ELEVATION LAMAR STREET FACADE Scale: 3/32” = 1’-0”
62
63
Urban Form In order to reinforce density within a suburban-scaled downtown, A tall, thin tower was proposed with a party-wall, providing for future dense development as well. An urban space is protected within the site and is connected to the street through the multi-story lobby/museum space.
TECHNICAL WALL SECTION METAL PANEL & WINDOW DETAILS Scale: 1” = 1’-0”
FUTURE DESIGN SOUTH ELEVATION AMITE STREET FACADE Scale: 1/16” = 1’-0”
64
UP
FUTU
RE DE
URE
DES
IGN UP
AM
ITE
L AM
FUT
AR S TREE
T
SIGN
STR
EET
65
66
Well-Dressed Design Center Fashion Design Center for D.C. Washington, D.C. Spring 2011 | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center
Designed for a city where symbolism is a basic element of architectural design, the building should not exist as competition to the country’s symbolic structures however maintain physical significance within the city’s urban fabric. My design approach was to arrange the programmatic elements vertically, making distinct and necessary connections between the various program elements. The structure is combination of steel columns and metal decking with poured concrete for slab floors throughout the building. A white stone edging is added to the exterior perimeter of each floor level and is allowed to visually pierce the facade’s skin. The skin itself is comprised of a folded metal and glass panel system that has five variations of panel configuration and operability: folding, pivoting, sliding, separated, and stationary. The specific configurations of panels are assigned to the skin based on the programmatic requirements on the skin’s interior. Both the exposed floor edging and the variation of skin configuration contribute a visual and physical movement of the building facades. By capturing movement, the building exists as a metaphor connecting architecture to fashion. The building’s skin is the clothing draped over the structure and the architectural expression of movement reflects the integral role that movement plays in the design of fashion.
67
Transforming Facade Referencing the manipulability of fabric, the folded, and changeable facade provides a showiness and exhibition that fashion requires. This building can act as a symbol of the developing fashion industry within Washington, D.C. The skin system design is composed of a series of glass and screened panels set at 45 degrees to one another creating a zig-zag motif in plan. Comprised of several configurations, the buildingâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s panels each operate in a different way and are placed according the programmatic requirements of the interior spaces. The panel configurations consisted of folding, pivoting, sliding, separated, stationary, and structural.
I Street NW 20th Street NW
Pen n
sylv
ani
aA ven
ue
68
69
Skin: In Detail The skin system design is composed of a series of glass and screened panels set at 45 degrees to one another creating a zig-zag motif in plan. Comprised of several configurations, the buildingâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s panels each operate in a different way and are placed according the programmatic requirements of the interior spaces. The panel configurations consisted of folding, pivoting, sliding, separated, stationary, and structural.
70
sliding
pivoting
folding d
lde
Fo
ed
en
Op
ed
en
Op
d
lde
ly
On
stationary
n ee Scr
separated
fo Un
d ne pe o d n ee ose Scr ss cl a l G
ed en op d n ee ose Scr ss cl Gla
ed en op losed s s c Gla een Scr
d ne pe sed o ss clo Gla een c Sr
tly
en
ed
s Clo
p
an erm
sed
Clo
sed
Clo
71
Program & Form The site given for this project was extremely limited in area (approximately 25 ft. x 50 ft.). Therefore, careful consideration and arrangement of programmatic elements had to be organized vertically. The program includes the following spaces: • Presentation (Runway) Space • Exhibition & Reception Space • Ground Floor Retail • Production & Finishing Spaces • Student Studio Spaces • Materials Library • Academic Library • Classrooms • Master or Visiting Designer Residence
72
73
74
Sculpting Shadows Sculpture Museum and Garden Alexandria, Virginia Fall 2010 | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center
This project was a deep study into the role of architecture as function versus its role as art. Many times architects take a specific view of architecture (either function or art) and do not consider architectural designs as an important balance between these two qualities. Before receiving the program of the building, I was tasked to truly analyze the site through many personal visits and drawings. I then made drawings (seen to the right) documenting and analyzing the qualities of shadow and sound on the site itself. The building design was greatly influenced by these first analyses. Because the art selected for the projectâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s collection was sculpture, I was able to draw correlations between sculpture and building. As the building both housed the sculpture, as well as acted as sculpture by manipulating shadow throughout the various spaces. I intentionally created spaces of great variety in light qualities for the obvious comparison between soft and harsh shadows inside. The walls act as both blades splitting the light and curves to capture and redirect light evenly across surfaces and throughout the space. These issues asserted themselves as the most important throughout the design process for a sculpture museum and garden.
75
Site Analysis & Design A waterfront site in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia was given for this sculpture museum and garden. To understand the site more thoroughly, a series of diagrams entitled Recognize, Invent, and Displace were developed. Recognize diagrammed the existing shadows on site and their threedimensional occupation of space, at various times of day and seasons. Invent diagrammed the noise levels and conditions sectionally across the site, as well as time of day, and tries to insert a complementary sound cycle into the site. Displace diagrammed tidal change of the Potomac River and hypothesizes the exhibition and interaction of the water physically within the confines of the site. The overall site plan maintains the large open park for views and recreation while physically polarizing the two opposite programmatic components of the building: the noisy studio workshops and the quiet exhibition spaces.
76
77
Site Design Shadow, sound, and water continue to play a major role in the site design. A multi-level sculpture garden with transparent tanks of water, reflecting the river tidal heights, provide augmented viewing of the exhibited sculptures. Visitors are somewhat isolated from sounds as they are depressed within the earth. And finally shadow is continued to be analyzed as not only source and projection but the space in between.
78
79
Building Design The main gallery and social spaces are housed within the brick building, created of a myriad of shapes and formed walls which sculpt the light and shadows throughout the space. The building opens towards central courtyards with light from above filtered through a gridded glazed roofing system.
80
81
82
Professional Work Samples TLM Associates, Inc. | Jackson, Tennessee 83
84
Architectural Intern TLM Associates, Inc. 117 East Lafayette Street Jackson, Tennessee 38301
Since 2006, I have worked with mid-size firm of TLM Associates, Inc. in Jackson, Tennessee, during summers and breaks of the academic calendar. While at this office, I was integrated into all phases of the design and construction process, even small project management. From a summer of on-site building inspection to proposal preparation and submission, I have been well-versed in all of these phases. Projects types that I have worked on include educational, collegiate, banking, parks, residential, adaptive reuse, interiors, and graphic design, among others. “TLM Associates, Inc. is a professional architectural and engineering firm that has been serving the Mid South since 1964. The firm consists of registered, licensed professional architects and engineers along with experienced design professionals and technical personnel specializing in architectural and engineering services. Our team has over 300 years of combined experience.” “TLM Associates, Inc. is headquartered in downtown Jackson, Tennessee. This central location allows the firm to deliver professional services quickly throughout West Tennessee. We also have the capability to serve clients nationally and internationally. TLM has been retained on projects ranging from $5,000 to $60 million in construction cost.” “TLM Associates, Inc. also has a team of LEED Accredited Professionals that are capable of working with organizations or municipalities to design sustainable buildings and sites. This team includes architects, civil engineers, and mechanical engineers. One LEED goal is to revitalize existing buildings and systems to make facilities more energy efficient. By having a LEED certified building, the owner can be provided with a quick return on investment through reduction of energy and maintenance costs.” Quotes from TLM Associates, Inc. promotional materials. www.tlmassociates.com
85
Park Pavilion Union City, Tennessee The park pavilion project in Union City was a project that I would on from beginning to end. I, with Ginger French, AIA, managed the design, correspondence, and construction of this project. Meant to mediate between a nature-filled park and an industrial site, the material choices highlight this unique intersection.
86
66'-0" CONCRETE PAD PERIMETER
A
B
A.1
C
7'-3 1/2"
8'-8 1/2"
E
16'-0"
16'-0"
1/2"
2'-10"
1'-4
D
12'-0"
20'-0"
8
20'-0"
8
5'-0"
31'-8"
CEDAR PERGOLA
15'-0"
46'-0" 3'-0"
H / J (TYP) A5.1
3'-0"
B A5.1
H / J (SIM) A5.1
8'-0"
7
7
4" SPLIT-FACED C.M.U. (SEALED)
6
Womens Toilet 101
Picnic Area 104
C. JT. 7'-11"
6'-9 5/8"
F.D. 7
7
2 4
6" C.M.U. (SEALED)
1
SLAB SLOPE, REFER CIVIL & STR. DWG'S.
3
4'-0"
5 5A
4'-9 5/8"
1
ACCESS PANEL
C. JT.
H/C W.C.
STEEL COLUMN (PAINT)
6
"
Mens Toilet 102
TOILET PARTITION (TYP)
13'-8" x 10'-2" 128 SF
1'-3 5/8"
102
5'-9 7/8"
7
째
2
F.D.
11 0
7
3'-4"
5
6
C. JT.
3'-4"
103
C. JT.
Mechanical Room 103
13'-8" x 7'-6" 60 SF
5'-9 7/8"
32'-7 3/4"
CHASE
3'-0
51'-3 3/8"
3 1
W.C.
44'-0"
8" SPLIT-FACED C.M.U. (SEALED)
4
3
5 5A
51'-3 3/8" CONCRETE PAD PERIMETER
22'-2"
3'-4"
101
13'-8" x 10'-1" 138 SF
A A5.1
27'-3 1/8" CONCRETE PAD PERIMETER
11 5/8"
C. JT.
MOP SINK
F.D.
4'-4 3/8"
4'-9 1/4"
4
C. JT. 3
"
2 7/8
5'-9 7/8"
70'70
째
10'-7 5/8" 4'-3 3/8"
2
2 70
째
1
3'-0"
16'-0"
A
12'-0"
B
16'-0"
16'-0"
C
Overall Floor Plan 1/8" = 1'-0" 2,590 SF OVERALL SLAB 449 SF BUILDING
D
N W
E
E
S
87
Outdoor Restroom Facility Jackson, Tennessee The restroom facility was designed to exist within a small scenic park in the suburban Jackson. The lit figures provide a graphic iconography for the building. Stained plywood, cast-in-place concrete, and rusty corten steel blend with the ecological elements of the park. This project is yet to be built.
88
89
Dormitories Union University Jackson, Tennessee After a tornado demolished most of the student housing on campus, the university needed safe new dorms quickly. I was involved with a large portion of the construction administration and inspection, located on-site for the entire summer for this project. I was not on the design team for this project.
90
91
92
Academic Research
Urban Design Lab & GSAPP | Columbia University 93
94
Healthy Bodegas (selected publication spreads) Research for the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Bronx, New York In collaboration with Richard Plunz, Ankita Chachra, Vanessa Espaillat, Carolina Montilla, Kristina Ricco, & Janice Tan Spring 2013 | GSAPP, Columbia University Bodegas in New York City play an important role in the health of the city. They not only serve as commercial enterprises selling food (both healthy and not-so-healthy products) but also as significant places of social interaction and influence. In developing their products lists and services provided, bodega owners respond to two constituents: product distributors and the local community. Itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s important to draw a distinction between bodegas and supermarkets by establishing that bodegas are not supermarkets. The most obvious evidence is the differences of spatial organization, total square footage, and layout, but also in terms of relationships between distributors and the communities. The social relationship between a bodega owner and its community is crucial. The interaction between this owner (or bodega cashier) and the customers is more personalized than that of a supermarket. A bodega owner can have a positive influence in the healthy choices of a customer in the same way that a customer can influence a bodega by requesting healthier options. There is a generational and ethnic change in bodegas in New York City. The new generation of bodega owners is reanalyzing the concept of a bodega and investing in the revamping of these spaces from crowded and visually noisy convenient stores to a cleaner, modern look. Existing analysis of spatial conditions of bodegas is very limited and not fully understood. However, across the city, the spatial configuration and the appearance of bodegas are being used as targets of new investments. As these investments are being realized, we aim to use our research and knowledge of architecture and design to identify areas of potential design intervention to both benefit the health of the community and the sales of the bodega itself. Our aim is to develop a series of strategies and solutions in the form of a Healthy Bodega Design Manual that can be implemented within the broad range of bodega types, helping store owners promote and sell more healthy products within their communities. This array of design interventions varies economically and spatially, just as bodegas do. A matrix of design proposals responding to these parameters will help to create a diversity of potential solutions and outcomes for these owners to use. 95
1
96
THE BODEGA
Mass Transit Access Bodegas
A disappearing social institution
Mixed Res. & Com. Neighborhood Bodegas
Commercial
Institutions
Residential
According to the Bodega Association of the United States, two or three bodegas close down every day in New York City.
Currently, there are 1500 bodegas
in New York City and half of these are at risk of bankruptcy. The CPEX Fall 2010 Retail Report showed that between the years 2005 and 2010 bodegas’ rents per square foot rose from 50 percent to 130 percent (New York Times, 2011). The eventual disappearance of bodegas could mean a negative impact for the thousands of owners, families and larger communities that depend on these small businesses. These corner stores have become an ideal place where people get together and form tighter community bonds. Bodegas are also an alternate solution for customers who cannot afford to purchase in bulk at supermarkets and need to buy their groceries several times a week depending on their unpredictable income. A great example of bodegas’ role was evident during Hurricane Sandy, one of the most devastating storms that have affected New York City to date. During ‘Superstorm Sandy’ the corner stores stayed open, supplying the communities with the essential supplies to endure the crisis, such as: water, milk, bread, candles and flashlights. While big box stores closed their doors, bodega owners offered community members a place to discuss the current events, stay informed and purchase their groceries.
Sources: 1. Glass, Claire and Plasencia, Amanda. “For bodegas, An Uncertain Future. “The Local East Village, New York Times, March 11, 2011, accessed March 6, 2013, http://eastvillage.thelocal.nytimes.com/2011/03/11/for-bodegas-an-uncertain-future/. 2. Gratereaux, Alexandra and O’Reilly, Andrew “Hurricane Sandy: Some Loyal Bodegas in NYC weathered storm as best they could,” October 31, 2012, accessed March 6, 2013, http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2012/10/31/some-loyal-bodegas-in-nyc-weathered-hurricane-sandy-customers-as-best-could/.
HEALTHY $ELLS
9
DISPLACEMENT Gentrification and big retail The two main culprits? THE TRADITIONAL BODEGA The 2008-2009 New York Hispanic Small Business Survey accounted that 53
•
Rents have risen 50% - 130%
percent of Hispanic bodega owners are at risk of losing their business. Out of the
•
1/2 of NYC Bodegas are at risk
937 ‘bodegueros’ or bodega owners surveyed, 74 percent blamed the increasing rents
of closing
and 18 percent said they were unable to compete with bigger franchise stores.
•
Throughout the five boroughs, rents have more than doubled due to the
Gentrification is displacing many of the bodega customers.
citywide process of gentrification, forcing premature closures of hundreds of small businesses, preventing the opening of new small businesses and creating a scenario where only larger chain stores will survive. With the new incoming population the ethnic bodegas have opted to adapt and rebrand themselves as health shops,
IMMIGRANT OWNER
offering fresh and organic products that appeal to higher-income residents. There
THE “HEALTHY” BODEGA
is a common consensus that “Healthy Sells!” and this has become the key marketing
•
strategy of bodegas in the city.
Bodegas are rebranding as healthy and organic retailers.
Parallel to this process of gentrification, there is a generation and ethnic
•
change in bodegas in New York City, which has also accounted for the physical
Attracting a new high-income clientele.
changes in the corner stores. A younger and higher educated generation of bodega owners, are investing in the revamping of these spaces from crowded and visually noisy convenient stores to a cleaner and modern look, in order to attract higher spending customers. However, retrofitting and rebranding are not viable options for smaller less-
ETHNIC AND GENERATIONAL SHIFT
THE FRANCHISE BODEGA •
profitable bodega businesses that lack financing opportunities and unfortunately •
In 2012, the New York Times reported 7-Eleven’s plan to open 100 new stores
includes: a fully stocked store,
called the Business Conversion Program, whose stated goal is to entice mom-and-pop
a business consultant, an
shops into becoming 7-Elevens”.
HEALTHY $ELLS
Offering bodegas a business conversion program which
in the city, “armed not just with data processing tools but also with a system
Sources: 1. Levere, Jane. “7-Eleven sees an opportunity to open doors”. The New York Times. July 14, 2009.
7-Eleven is planning to open 100 new stores by 2017.
have to close down or become a franchise of bigger corporate retail stores.
inventory tracking system and FRANCHISEE OWNER
a business model that reduces spoilage.
11
97
THE BODEGA A disappearing social institution
Mass Transit Access Bodegas
Mixed Res. & Com. Neighborhood Bodegas
Institutions
Commercial Residential
According to the Bodega Association of the United States, two or three bodegas close down every day in New York City.
Currently, there are 1500 bodegas
in New York City and half of these are at risk of bankruptcy. The CPEX Fall 2010 Retail Report showed that between the years 2005 and 2010 bodegas’ rents per square foot rose from 50 percent to 130 percent (New York Times, 2011). The eventual disappearance of bodegas could mean a negative impact for the thousands of owners, families and larger communities that depend on these small businesses. These corner stores have become an ideal place where people get together and form tighter community bonds. Bodegas are also an alternate solution for customers who cannot afford to purchase in bulk at supermarkets and need to buy their groceries several times a week depending on their unpredictable income. A great example of bodegas’ role was evident during Hurricane Sandy, one of the most devastating storms that have affected New York City to date. During ‘Superstorm Sandy’ the corner stores stayed open, supplying the communities with the essential supplies to endure the crisis, such as: water, milk, bread, candles and flashlights. While big box stores closed their doors, bodega owners offered community members a place to discuss the current events, stay informed and purchase their groceries.
Sources: 1. Glass, Claire and Plasencia, Amanda. “For bodegas, An Uncertain Future. “The Local East Village, New York Times, March 11, 2011, accessed March 6, 2013, http://eastvillage.thelocal.nytimes.com/2011/03/11/for-bodegas-an-uncertain-future/. 2. Gratereaux, Alexandra and O’Reilly, Andrew “Hurricane Sandy: Some Loyal Bodegas in NYC weathered storm as best they could,” October 31, 2012, accessed March 6, 2013, http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2012/10/31/some-loyal-bodegas-in-nyc-weathered-hurricane-sandy-customers-as-best-could/.
HEALTHY $ELLS
9
BEYOND HEALTH Corner stores as health agents Good health is very much determined by one’s access to healthy food. Studies in Brooklyn and Harlem have showed that bodegas far outnumber the supermarkets in the area. However, these corner stores carry limited stock of healthier items like fruits, vegetables, reduced-fat milk, low sodium or low sugar goods. This has affected mostly the poorer neighborhoods and has contributed to the increasing rates of obesity, deaths from diabetes and heart disease. For these reasons the NYC Health Department has launched a series of initiatives that provide nutrition education and outreach to target communities like South Bronx, North and Central Brooklyn and East and Central Harlem. The Healthy Bodegas initiative, now renamed Shop Healthy, put forth by the NYC Health Department, has delivered an Adopt-a-bodega Toolkit for communities to work with corner stores to increase healthy offerings. The manual proposes support activities such as cooking demonstrations, new product tastings and store-cleanups that engage the community through a series of win-win scenarios with the bodega owner. The bottom-up process of change in the bodega’s healthy inventory results in a greater outcome: the emergence of trust between the bodega owner and the community, laying the foundation for future collaboration. Another relevant pilot project is the “Farm to Bodega” which links bodegas with local farmer’s markets, in order to establish connections with high-quality and low priced healthy produce. This process could benefit from greater support and training for bodega owners, since most of them need information on how to purchase, price and store the fresh produce.
Sources: 1. Graham R, Kaufman L, Novoa Z, Karpati A,Eating in, eating out, Eating Well: Access to Healthy Food in North and Central Brooklyn. New York, N.Y.: New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, 2006. 2. NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, “NYC Healthy Bodegas Initiative - 2010 Report”, 2010. 3. NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.,Center of Economic Opportunity, “Adopt-a-bodega Toolkit”, 2010.
HEALTHY $ELLS
98
13
SOCIAL CAPITAL The Dominican bodega & community as a case study
THE DOMINICAN ‘SAN’ •
This informal means of credit gives bodega owners the opportunity to
Buy new shelving
have large sums of capital Social capital is a wealth of intangible social resources- such as information,
in a particular moment to
Repair Refrigerator
social support, and personal connections – indispensable for achieving social,
kickstart or improve their
Replace counter
economic and political goals (Reynoso, 2003). The surfacing of new forms of social
stores.
capital in the city is particularly evident when looking at the Dominican immigrant community and their relationship to the bodega business in New York City. Dominican immigrants’ successful adaptation and integration to a new urban environment, depends highly on the support of an existing transnational ethnic
WITH THIS MONEY I CAN IMPROVE
community. Social capital gives migrant individuals resources and possibilities
MY BODEGA
beyond their individual reach, and helps them transition from low-income jobs to entrepreneurial small business endeavors. The Dominican “San”, a traditional and informal means of credit, has been key in the growth of Dominican-owned bodegas in the city. The “San” involves a limited number of participants who agree to make regular contributions to a fund that is given to each contributor in rotation, either in whole or part (Sassen, 1987, 283). Many bodega Dominican immigrants, have limited or no access to credit, therefore the “San” becomes an important community support system that can kickstart, expand or improve a bodega business. Another aspect of Dominican culture is the “Fiao” or informal lending system that help their customers purchase the basic necessities and pay them at a later
THE DOMINICAN ‘SAN’
time. This system is of great benefit for low-income residents, which often rely on bodegas as a safety net during economic unstable times and as a result, strong community networks of trust and mutual benefit are established. If bodegas have been the preferred business model to an array of different immigrant groups, can we devise of ways in which bodega businesses can adapt through community-based support systems in order to meet the current challenges? Sources: 1. Reynoso, Julissa. “Dominican Immigrants and Social Capital in New York City: A Case Study”, Encrucijada/Crossroads Online Academic Journal 1 (2003), accessed May 12, 2013 2. Sassen, Saskia. “Formal and informal associations: Dominicans and Colombians in New York”, In Caribbean life in New York City: Sociocultural dimensions, 1987.
HEALTHY $ELLS
15
SPATIAL LAYOUT Learning from the Supermarket
Time, User and Experience
An article in the UK news journal ‘The Independent’ by Simon Usborn uncovers consumer behavior. All these trick may not necessarily apply to a bodega but some of them have potential to prove advantageous towards encouraging healthy consumer behavior in bodegas. Some of these are illustrated in figure...... He highlights Golden zones which are “impulse areas” or “grab zones”, they include “checkout arrays” or “walk-through queues” filled or lined with treats. The
OTHER SUPPLIES
10 tricks that supermarkets use in order to increase their sales and influence
USER TYPE 1 - LONG STAY Necessities and Daily Buy PROCESSED FOODS
checkout counter can act as an impulse zone for healthy products. Another trick that can attract consumers towards a particular section is ‘Shop-in-shop’. These are microenvironments created within the store, example Wooden floors and shelves and nice lighting can be suggestive of a different environment in the wine aisle. Most common profit generating technique is placing the object at ‘Buy level’. of Shopping: How We Shop and Why We Buy used eye-tracking cameras on volunteers to
USER TYPE 2 - SHORT STAY Deli and Fast Buy
DELI
Simeon Scamell-Katz, a leading global consumer analyst and the author of The Art
COMMON ZONE OF IMPACT
show “we naturally look lower than eye-level to somewhere between waist and chest level”.This zone can be further used to promote health.
way. The most crucial tip towards attracting consumers inside is the Facade itself, which should be appealing and inviting. Usborn
describes it as ‘Front
CHECKOUT COUNTER
ATM
Usborn also talks about the ‘Traffic builder’, placing essentials away from the entrance means exposes consumers to more potential purchases and offers on the
USER TYPE 3 - VERY SHORT STAY ATM and Quick Buy
of shop’. Scamell-Katz gives the example of stores with abundant displays of beautifully presented carrots or exotic fruits that give an impression of entering a store of freshness.
Store layout and zoning not only influence the consumer preferences, but can be key in increasing sales of certain products. Basic techniques like visibility,arrangement
increasing
and order of goods are effective only to an extent. For
Bodegas, identifying the users based on time and intention, to determine their ideal Sources: 1.Usbrain, Simon. “The Secrets of Our Supermarkets.” The Independent. Independent Digital News and Media, 27 Oct. 2012. Web. 15 May 2013. 2. Scamell-Katz, Siemon. The Art of Shopping: How We Shop and Why We Buy. London: LID, 2012. Print.
HEALTHY $ELLS
zone of influence is equally important. To encourage healthy consumer preferences, the store layout can further supplement to the personal influence that Bodega’s offer. Zone of Impact vary for different user type, each should be leveraged upon. 19
99
SHELVING INSERT
QUICK & EASY
The shelving insert works within the framework of the standard metal shelves commonly found in bodegas.
It attempts to create a “Shop-in-a-Shop” experience
to attract customers’ attention as well as to provide a material backdrop for a particular product. In its conception, the shelving insert holds multiple possibilities: 1. STICK-ON SIMPLICITY: This could be something as simple as a decal sticker that draws attention to, or provides additional information on, the product that the particular shelf is housing. SHOP-IN-A-SHOP 2. ADD-ON SHELF: This is a smaller shelf that is dimensioned to fit within the standard metal shelves. It should be made out of a different material to create a “Shop-in-a-Shop”, and its form can be custom-designed to the particularity of the product it is meant to enhance. As a side note, we observed that the length of the standard metal shelves found in many bodegas range from 4-6 feet. These are combined length-wise to form longer shelves where necessary. It is imperative to note that while the metal shelves are configured to be “flexible”, in that the height of the shelves can potentially be adjusted to accommodate varying heights different products, the weight and length of the individual shelf limits its flexible use.
As a result,
STANDARD METAL SHELVES
shelf space is not optimized in many instances. Moreover, the opaque structure of the shelf provides backing for the product but at the expense of light, and therefore visibility, to products located further toward back of the shelves.
HEALTHY $ELLS
25
SHELVING UNIT
COMPLEX
The proposed design of a typical shelving unit for bodegas is based on three principles that promote a healthy interior environment, while increasing the saleability of products: 1. MODULARITY: The need to increase or decrease shelf lengths according to the varying space availabilities in different bodegas calls for a strategy of modular shelving.
The standardised components reduce overall construction cost,
and allows possibility for a third party industrious contractor to pre-fabricate these modules to cater specifically to bodega owners. 2. PRODUCT VISIBILITY: In a closed environment where the real estate of display and storage space is oftentimes milked to an extreme, the shelving unit takes advantage of the entire floor-to-ceiling height, as well as integrating storage space at the foot of the shelf where visibility of product is at its lowest. To counter the “less than 3 feet” zone, the singular display shelf is designed to transform from a horizontal facing to that of an optimal 30-degree angle facing by a simple reversal of the shelf. In so doing, the product is now angled towards the view cone of the standing shopper, and renders it more visible.
The material
surface of the shelf can be further defined to create a “Shop-in-a-Shop”. The individual shelf also doubles up as a backing for the product, but it does not cover the full height of the shelf, and allows for visual porosity through the shelving unit.
This increases light and visibility to adjacent products, as
well as to adjacent aisles. 3. FLEXIBILITY: The individual shelf is designed to be 2 feet in length, and is supported on dowels attached to the main frame structure of the shelving unit. Given its smaller size compared to the standard metal shelves, there is a higher possibility for shelf space to be optimized where necessary. HEALTHY SELLS $ELLS
100
27
SHELVING ITERATIONS
HINGED TO CEILING
INDIVIDUAL PRE-FABRICATED SHELVES
DOWELS & STORAGE
FRAME STRUCTURE ADDITIONAL STORAGE
SHOP-IN-ASHOP INDIVIDUAL PRE-FABRICATED SHELVES
COMPOSITE SHELVING UNIT
SIDE & FRONT ELEVATIONS HEALTHY $ELLS
29
SHELVING UNIT
HINGED TO CEILING COMPOSITE SINGULAR SHELVING UNIT
DOWELS & STORAGE
FRAME STRUCTURE
FRAME STRUCTURE INDIVIDUAL PRE-FABRICATED SHELVES
HEALTHY $ELLS
31
101
CHECKOUT COUNTER
QUICK & EASY ELIMINATE THE VISUAL NOISE BY REMOVING THE SURROUND MAINTAIN A CLEAR AND CLUTTER-FREE COUNTERTOP
The checkout counter is a key place of intervention to impact
3. Provide an area for healthy pre-packaged foods displayed.
consumer habits and bodega use. By focusing on a few key objectives, the checkout can
These products often bring higher profit margins than other merchandise.
easily facilitate a healthy bodega strategy. Some of the design objectives are as
4. Develop a series of pieces that could be used collectively
follows:
or individually.
1. Limit visual noise and choice, and thus boost sales
5. Provide a space for socializing, if desired to
of a few specific products placed in the coveted impulse buy area. This area can house circulating merchandise to become even more successful.
increase the social influence of the bodega.
2. Give a lack of physical access to easily stolen and unhealthy snack choices by placing them behind the counter and requiring the patron to ask for the product.
All of these strategies provide a basis for a healthier, more social, and more profitable bodegas.
USE THE COOLER FOR HEALTHIER OPTIONS
HEALTHY $ELLS
37
1. ADD A SEATING COMPONENT
4. ADD A CLEAN CASHIER STATION WITH RECESSED REGISTER
2. ADD A COOLER FOR SALE OF PRE-PACKAGED PREPARED FOOD
5. CREATE A 3-ITEM DISPLAY FOR IMPULSE BUY
3. CREATE HIERARCHY IN REAR SHELVING DISPLAY
6. PLACE UNHEALTHY & EASILY-STOLEN ITEMS BEHIND GLASS WITHIN THE COUNTER
3 1
4 5 6 2
HEALTHY $ELLS
102
41
GRAPHIC LANGUAGE Abstraction Current packaging trends lean towards “honest” representation of product. To compete with surrounding noise, a distinct visual language should be developed. Bold, simplified representation of the product should be bright and monochromatic. PaletteBright colors can often clash when used side by side especially when afterimages interfere with one another, causing a “visual vibration.” In this instance, the effect is desirable to help the product stand out in its context. It can be reduced by placing a neutral color between the two areas of bright colors or by making one of the colors a pastel or dark shade.
HEALTHY $ELLS
45
SIGNAGE & PACKAGING
Signage placed perpendicular to the shelving creates a special “call out” condition, interjecting itself into the shoppers aisle space. The projection should be no more than 4” away from the edge of the shelf, and should be tall enough to accommodate 2” tall text elements. A similar language can be deployed on packaging. Cut fruits and other prepared foods benefit from having a uniformly branded strategy.
HEALTHY $ELLS
47
103
104
Teaching: Student Work
Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation | Columbia University
105
106
Sustainable Urbanization New Designs for the Future City In collaboration with Patricia Culligan, Vanessa Espaillat, Sagi Golan, Richard Plunz, and Jose Sanchez Summer 2013 | School of Continuing Education, Columbia University
Course Brief: This course is designed for students interested in the field of sustainable development. Students will be exposed to emerging trends in urban sustainability in an interdisciplinary workshop environment where they will explore new solutions for sustainable cities in the context of a real-world project. The majority of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s population now lives in urban areas. As a result, cities around the globe are increasingly facing challenges related to the provision of adequate infrastructure (energy, water, transportation), the delivery of public services (education, health care, public safety), and the management of environmental quality (air, water, natural habitat). Students in the course will learn about these challenges through lectures, case study research, and guided group discussions that will expose them to the interdisciplinary nature of sustainable development. Field trips to locations and facilities in New York City will illustrate and reinforce these learning experiences. The basic tools needed for sustainable urban design will be introduced in a workshop environment where students will gain hands-on experience in geographic information systems, data analysis and visualization, architectural and engineering design principles, and 3D modeling tools. The course project will focus on an urbanization challenge for an actual client. Students will work in teams to propose solutions to the challenge. They will be encouraged to be collaborative, think creatively, and explore non-traditional methods so as to generate new ideas and approaches. Project work will be guided by researchers from the Urban Design Lab at Columbiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Earth Institute and teaching assistants from the Sustainable Engineering Graduate Scholars program in Columbiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s School of Engineering and Applied Science. At the end of the course, students will present their final project ideas and work products to a panel of invited experts representing disciplines in the fields of government, research, and practice. Students designed in groups for the Two Bridges neighborhood in downtown Manhattan. They were asked to use a barge as an urban trigger within a larger design scheme addressing flooding issues, among others. 107
Student Work Work shown by the following groups: (1) Sofie Alabaster, John Bonina, Dominic May, Wes Purpura, Noah Sims (2) Jonas Cabaret-Mertel, Joey Epstein, Nick Godridge, Alex Kent, Jonathan Schermer (3) Emma Clark, Maya Linden, Gabe Suazo, Katrine Trampe (4) Corey Brennan, Nicholas Murray, Ramya Srinivasan, Yijia Zhang
108
109
110
Power in Public Studio New York/Paris Urban Studies In collaboration with Moji Baratloo, Nickie Huang, & Carolina Montilla Fall 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
As a teaching assistant and part of the faculty team for the Urban Studies Studio in the GSAPP New York/Paris program, I worked with fellow TA, Carolina Montilla, and faculty, Moji Baratloo and Nicole Huang. My duties included multiple desk critiques per week, digital tutorials, review scheduling, project descriptions, and archiving, among others. The general topics of the studio are as follows: The Urban Studies Studio of the Shape of Two Cities: New York / Paris Program is designed to simultaneously research and develop projects according to: 1. A unique condition of a “Site” in New York City. 2. Specific “Agents” that are considered the drivers of our changing global cities and environment. 3. “Clients” that best represent the local and the greater community. The focus of the studio was as follows: Pier 6 and its larger contexts and connection via the Atlantic Avenue artery to broader Brooklyn communities such as the Brooklyn Heights and Cobble Hills neighborhoods. Pier 6 is also adjacent to Brooklyn Bridge Park, a celebrated New York City waterfront project. During the semester our emphasis will be on the recognition and understanding that any urban site is part of a series of interconnected networks, neighborhood and communities. Important to note is that the studio by intention will focus on the larger metropolitan scale, landscape/ecology scale, and architectural/human scale, but there will also be an opportunity for students to develop a project at no scale. The final product of the studio will be a thesis proposal by each student, which will incorporate indepth research and analysis as well as potential short-term “micro-interventions” such as landscape, urban, and/or architectural projects in service of a much more important and long-term “macro-impact”.
111
Site Constructions & Records Students were asked to make analytical drawings for the site in preparation of their mini-thesis. Also students created site constructions from objects found on site. Work shown by the following students: Tatiana Baglioni Gabrielle Lewis Alica Meza Michael Phillips
112
113
Mini-Thesis Students composed their research and design proposals onto accordion-style booklets and placed them in custom-designed packaging. Work shown by the following students: Tatiana Baglioni Gabrielle Lewis Alica Meza Michael Phillips
114
115
116
Other Academic Work
Misssippi State University | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center | Columbia University 117
TOTAL POPULATION
OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA QUAN
"Coliseum City is one of the centerpieces of Oakland’s economic renaissance."
polit
Amritha Mahesh
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA BALLARD
“We must be the best city in the Midwest, the city that is globally recognized that is inclusive that where companies want to create these jobs.”
D+38 390,000 ACCELERATED GROWTH 15 Acres [City Center Plan] LARGER COLISEUM CITY Very Consolidated
SO
D ATE LID
N CO
R+38 830,000 MODERATE GROWTH 4,226 Acres [Indianapolis Regional Center Plan] Leaning Consolidated TRENDING TOWARD CONSOLIDATED
CO
As the voice o
broader ambi
a delicate bala
beyond the co
expressing the
examination o
Mayors vision
phor for the i
adapt, to com
NSE
RVA TIV
E
variab
resourc
economi
jurisdict
political
political LIB
DIS
L
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK
AUSTIN,TEXAS
BLOOMBERG
LEFFINGWELL
"If you don't like wealthy people or successful businesses, you are not going to have a city." D+38 2,540,000 MODERATE GROWTH 232 Acres [DoBro Plan] Fairly Consolidated
ED
BUT
TRI
ERA
"This is a momentous achievement to create a collective vision for Austin’s future.” R+13 TRENDING LIBERAL 820,000 MODERATE GROWTH 1,044 Acres [Downtown Austin Plan] Fairly Distributed
CITATION City of Austin. Downtown Austin Plan. http://ftp.ci.austin.tx.us/ | Cook Political Report. http://cookpolitical.com. | Department of Metropolitan Development, Indianapolis, Indiana. Indianapolis Regional Center Plan 2020. Indianapolis: 2004. | Downtown Brooklyn Plan. www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/dwnbklyn2/dwnbklyn.pdf | Downtown Oakland Plan http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/documents/report/dowd007631.pdf | United States Census. “Population 2010.” www.census.gov
118
metric
populat
budget s
economi
unemplo
crime ra
standar
happines
ecologic
urban d
3 American Regions + 1 Understanding Policy & Politics Brooklyn, Indianapolis, Oakland + Austin In collaboration with Andrew Leung, Amritha Mahesh, & Kristina Ricco Fall 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
In order to broaden our understanding of our site, we were asked to analyze three other cities in addition to Brooklyn (which would eventually become our project site). The studio was divided into 11 topics including: transportation, water, energy, ecological systems, technology/innovation, land/geography/natural features, waste, production/manufacturing, policy/politics, economy/finance, and real estate/urban development. Through the research and analysis, we were able to get a diverse and comparative understanding of these topics within the American context. In studying policy & politics, we analyzed political jurisdictions, power structures, political lineage, and adopted urban development plans, among others. The final graph developed (left) charts several data sets for comparison: a liberal-conservative axis, a centralized-distributed power axis, a population axis, the physical area of the adopted urban development plan, and how these change over time. Among these cities, we concluded that the more centralized the power, the more rapid the change can occur as well as a smaller, more specific development plan seems to be more effective and more often accomplished over time.
119
POLITICAL ALIGNMENT OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA
CHANGE IN POPULATION FROM 2000 - 2010 OVER 20% INCREASE
In 1999, Mayor Jerry Brown announced his 10K
NORTH GATE
10% - 20% INCREASE 0% - 10% INCREASE
Plan, an initiative to bring 10,000 residents
0% - 10% DECREASE
LAKE MERRITT DISTRICT
OVER 20% DECREASE
to Downtown Oakland. The plan hinged on
MAJOR ROADS
Brown’s POLITICAL CONNECTIONS, and cre-
CITY BOUNDARY
UPTOWN
ated a Redevelopment Agency charged with
10K PLAN
LAKE MERRITT
developing the Central District Urban Renewal Area. Redevelopment Agencies gave local governments the ability to capture a greater share of property taxes by freezing allotments
TREASURE ISLAND
to other city agencies, by using additional
OLD CHINATOWN OAKLAND
PIEDMONT
funds created by growth to invest in development projects. In 2011 Jerry Brown was elected Governor of California and one of his first acts in
IRONWORKS DISTRICT
10K PLAN
office, discontinued the RA policy in an effort to balance the state budget (which is currently suf-
JACK LONDON SQ
fering a massive deficit.) Mayor Jean Quan has
TO SAN FRANSISCO
announced plans for a massive arena project
OAKLAND ESTUARY
called Coliseum City, and the fate of the 10K Plan remains unknown.
J. Brown 11-
Quan 11-
Dellums 07-11
J. Brown 99-07 Davis 99-03
Schwrzngr. 03-11
Harris 91-99
Deukmejian 83-91
Reagan 67-75
J. Brown 75-83
GOVERNOR OF CALIFORNIA P. Brown 59-67
COLISEUM CITY
Wilson 77-91
Reading 66-77
Houlihan 61-66
MAYOR OF OAKLAND
Wilson 91-99
Of the 7,053 units represented as products of the 10K initiative, 3,911 remain in the planning stages.1
1. San Francisco Chronicle, Economy casts shadow on Oakland 10K plan’s 10th. Published July 12, 2009 2. Change in population interpreted from NY Times Census Map
Clinton 93-01
Obama 09-
3. Information about Redevelopment agencies comes from http://www.npr.
G.W. Bush 01-09
G.H.W. Bush 89-93
Reagan 81-89
Carter 77-81
Nixon 69-74
Ford 74-77
http://projects.nytimes.com/census/2010/map
Johnson 63-69
Kennedy 61-63
Esnhwr. 53-61
PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES
org/2012/07/03/155916629/oakland-turns-a-corner-as-calif-faces-budgetwoes 4. Budget report snapshot comes from Oakland’s Community Economic Development Agencies annual report from 2009-2001, the year before the RA was collapsed. http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/docu-
TO SAN JOSE
ments/report/dowd007631.pdf
Policy + Politics AUSTIN, Texas Texas Triangle Region
DALLAS
Capit
ol
AUSTIN
Federal State of Texas University of Texas Travis County City of Austin City of Austin Parkland
HOUSTON
Senate District Boundaries House District Boundaries
State of TEXAS
Lad
35 Power of the purse
GOVERNOR Rick Perry (R)
Lt. GOVERNOR David Dewhurst (R) (Presides over)
State Senate
y bir
State House
d la
ke
20000 plus 15000 to 20000 10000 to 15000 5000 to 10000 2500 to 5000
Population growth 2010 -2020
AUSTIN CITY LIMITS MAYOR
DOWNTOWN AUSTIN
(Hires)
Transportation Framework Plan
(executes)
Assistant City Manager Infrastructure Services
Assistant City Manager Community Services Neighbourhood Housing and community Development
Capital Planning Office
Parks And Recreation Department
Infrastructure Strategy
Economic Growth And Redevelopment Services
1871 Passenger rail
1800
120
1820
1840
1860
1880
1920
Downtown Austin Neighbourhood Association
Density Bonus Program
District Plans
Public - Private Partnerships
Austin Neighbourhood Council
Historic Preservation Policies
Austin Revitalization Authority University Of Texas, Austin
1960s - Construction of Interstate 35 1893 Damming of the Colorado river
1900
Parks and Open Space Master Plan
Downtown Austin Plan & Implementation Program
Improvement Program
Sustainability Office 1839 Waller plan
Housing Strategy
Austin’s population is expected to double over the course of the plan. Transportation in and out of the city is a major point of interest, and the planners hope to create a Downtown where everyone can live and work.
West End Austin Alliiance Board
Assistant City Manager Development Services
Planning And Development Review Department
Transportation Department
Urban Rail
The plan divides the city into nine districts, each with its own guidelines for future design.
Greater Austin Chamber Of Commerce
CITY MANAGER Marc Ott
In order to keep up with the city’s population boom, the Austin City Council approved the city’s Downtown development plan in 2011.
Downtown Austin Alliance
DOWNTOWN AUSTIN PLAN
CITY COUNCIL
Lee Leffingwell (D)
The City of Austin is implementing policies to strengthen its tax base by densifying the Downtown "Urban core" in an effort to encourage sustainable development by favoring compact growth in contrast to earlier decades of sprawling low density development.
1940
1960
Mayor Will Wynn announces goal of acheiving a population of 25000 in the Downtown Austin by 2015 UT Austin aquires large chunks of land
1980
2000
Revised Zoning and Ordinances
General fund
FUNDING
Bonds City Economic Development Corporation Concessions
Lee Leffingwell elected as Mayor, continues DAP DAP released to public and project execution begins
2020
2040
Philanthropy and grants Property improvement District General fund
Events
Bicentennial year 2039 - Projected Completion
Corporate Sponsorships
Public
Earned income
Private
Citations 1)City of Austin - Downtown Austin Plan ftp://ftp.ci.austin.tx.us/DowntownAustinPlan/dap_approved_12-8-2011.pdf 2)State of Texas - GIS Viewer http://gis1.tlc.state.tx.us/ 3)http://www.ci.austin.tx.us/demographics/downloads/zip_forecast.pdf 4)http://www.austintexas.gov/ -City Demographer report
POLITICS + POLICY
2010 Residential Populations URBAN DENSITIES Higher Lower
Pre-1970 County Government Pre-1970 City Government
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA GREAT LAKES REGION
District 17
District 11
Existing as state capital with a unique consolidated local government, Indianapolis’s POLITICAL
STRUCTURE is a
50 Members (8 Indianapolis)
Governor
Indiana House of Representatives 100 Members (14 Indianapolis) John Barton (D)
PAST MAYORS
CONSOLIDATED TO
Greg Ballard (R)
Unigov
the success of businesses. After consolida-
Public Works
detract from the tax base. Although down-
Indianapolis Chamber of Commerce
town residential growth is stated as a goal of the new plan, all incentives and programs
Indy Partnership
Policy & Planning Code Enforcement
Department of
Metropolitan Development
city + county
county boundaries, this sprawl did not
Develop Indy
Captial Improvements Board Indianapolis-Marion Co. Building Authority GUIDES
Department of
tion in 1970, suburban sprawl continued to grow, but because the city limits mirrored
FUND
CONTAINS
Ex-Officio County Commissioners
DIRECTS
Downtown Development Corporations
Municipal Corporations
APPOINT
Elected County Officials Assessor + Auditor + Treasurer
Mayor
CONTAINS
AGENDA
continue to be directed at business growth,
Business Ownership Initiative
Historic Preservation Community Development
and the largely un-urban legislature has been
PUSH TOWARD CONSOLIDATION
historically inhospitable in funding the de-
mayoral push for further consolidation
CONSOLIDATED FROM
velopment of a combined “live, work, learn,
townships + excluded cities + services +education
public safety consolidation
and play” downtown.
police + fire
AGENDA
development + commerce consolidation (private + public money)
Citations City of Indianapolis. Comprehensive Annual Financial Report. December 31, 2011. http://www.indy.gov/eGov/City/OFM/Finances/ Documents/2011%20City%20of%20Indpls%20CAFR-FINAL.pdf. Department of Metropolitan Development, Indianapolis, Indiana. Indianapolis Regional Center Plan 2020. Indianapolis: 2004. Develop Indy. http://www.developindy.com/about-us/merger-faq.aspx. Accessed September 21, 2012. Indy Star. “Mayors of Indianapolis.” http://www2.indystar.com/library/factfiles/ history/indianapolis/mayors.html. Accessed September 21, 2012. Owen, C. James and York Willbern. Governing Metropolitan Indianapolis: The Politics of Unigov. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985. State of Indiana. “Tax Types & Various Rates.” http://www.in.gov/dor/3343. htm. Accessed September 21, 2012. U.S. Census of Population 2010. Accessed through Columbia University’s Spatial Information Design Lab.
Chamber of Commerce + Develop Indy + Indy Partnership + Business Ownership Initiative CAMPAIGN
corporate tax structure
simplified corporate tax
8.0% tax goes into effect + abatements for new businesses
corporation-friendly tax adjustments to flat tax
central business district regional plans
live + play + learn objectives added to work objective
2012
2008
2004
2000
BUSINESS-FOCUSED DEVELOPMENT
1970
1963
Indianapolis Regional Center Plan 2020
APPROVED
business-focused comprehensive planning
URBAN DENSITY. Regional
1960’s and were always closely defined for
SUPPORT
ELECTED
Bart Peterson (D)
COLLABORATE
25 Districts + 4 At-Large
COLLABORATE
Stephen Goldsmith (D)
NYC
desired
plans for the city have existed since the
Exempt Cities’ Elected Officials
City-County Council
Richard Lugar (R) William Hudnut (R)
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT and
District 16
MERGED
Indiana Senate
BOUNDARIES, which is evident in its
AUTONOMOUS but REPRESENTED
ELECTED
complex network of JURISDICTIONAL
Columbia University, GSAPP, Architecture and Urban Design Studio “Learning Cities: Smarter Regions” Fall 2012
Policy+Politics DoBro Plan JURISTICTION BOUNDARES REZONED
+10 FAR C6-1
C6-4
C6-4
"If you don't like wealthy people or successful businesses, you are not going to have a city." - mayor bloomberg
+10 FAR C6-1
R7-1+C2-4
D+38 POLITICAL ALIGNMENT Consolidated POLITICAL STRUCTURE +13,000 POPULATION GROWTH High income ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
R6
metro-tech
DEVELOPMENT since 2006 fult
on
st.
+ 7.9 million sf developed
ll
+12 FAR
+10 FAR C5-4
$3.5 billion new private investment
1/4 mile radius
ma
C6-4.5
COMMUNITY
C6-1A
35 small business get $80,000
C6-4
+6 FAR C6-1
48 units of rent-stabilized housing were bulldozed
1/2 mile radius
Department of City Planning Downtown Brooklyn Plan Plan.http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/dwnbklyn2/dwnbklyn.pdf. 2004 Downtown Brooklyn Partnership. Downtown Brooklyn StrategicPlan http://www.dbpartnership.org/lookingahead 2012
C6-2
zoning area change zoning before 2004
zoning after 2004
white
DRASTIC REZONING
16%
black
16%
DoBro from 2000 to 2010
Zack Fink Downtown Brooklyn Strong Despite Weak Growth http://brooklyn.ny1.com/content/top_stories/165587/growth-indowntown-brooklyn-strong-despite-weak-citywide-growth 2012
nyc unanimous vote councilman approve
ETHNIC POPULATION DISPARITY
councilman reject
REGIONAL COUNCIL APPROVAL PUBLIC ADVOCATE
DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING
appointed
DEPUTY MAYOR
DOWNTOWN BK PARTNERSHIP
appointed ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
METRO TECH BID
appointed
FULTON STREET DoBro COUTY LIVINGSTON SCHERMERHORN DoBro
COMMUNITY DISTRICT 2
DISTRICT 35+33
strong
appointed BOROUGH BOARD
MAYOR
BOROUGH PRESIDENTS
elected appointed
COMMUNITY BOARD
BROOKLYN: 16 MEMBERS
51 MEMBERS
CITY COUNCIL elected
DoBro Timeline 2003 city planning submits proposal
2006 DoBro Partnership est.
2004 city unanimous approval
2008 most luxury apartments completed 2007 small businesses start to shut down
appointed by reports to apart of connected to
2008 old residents begin to move out 2008 new residents begin to move in
2012 DoBro Partnership strategic plan
121
122
The Survivors on Bowery Web as Site New York, New York In collaboration with Vanessa Espaillat, Sagi Golan, & Marlin Torres Spring 2013 | GSAPP, Columbia University
‘The Survivors’ on the Bowery is a virtual repository of narratives that begins to reveal the story of one of New York’s most interesting and vibrant communities. Formerly known as ‘skid row’, the Bowery has been home to numerous artists, merchants and also infamously known for its poverty-stricken tenants. The current redevelopment pressures on the Bowery have resulted in displacement of many residents and businessowners. The ones left have great stories to tell and give hope to what the future holds for The Bowery. This half-semester class focused on developing skills in web site design and coding in HTML, CSS, jQuery, and JavaScript.
123
Site Design & Navigation In creating a list of “survivors,” we collected and curated many media, including video, interviews, photographs, news articles (historic & current), audio, and contact cards, among others. The site exists as a single page with an index to serve as a continuous repository for “the survivors” on Bowery. The map key not only serves as a locator for the project, but also as a navigating device within the site.
340
E. Housto
n
266 240 227
196 Delancey
158
130
Grand
Canal 124
125
126
Transforming Treads Digital Modeling in Urban Design New York City Subway Station Summer 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
When asked to create a public space that responds to a metric, I developed a unique staircase that can make climbing stairs more efficient. A generic NYC subway station is my test site. When a user approaches, their height is measured, and the tread height of the stair adjusts to create the most efficient possible climb. Therefore, commuters could exit the stairs at a speedier rate as well as save much needed energy. Adjusting handrails also provide added benefit for the aging or those with disabilities. Groups can be accommodated through the use of an average height, and speedier users are able to pass slower users as the stair will reroute your path if an alternate is available. This model and animation was completed in Maya with video editing done in Adobe After Effects.
127
128
129
Proposed Interventions (white) Existing Fabric (grey)
Residential bar above alley (12 foot width)
Empty lots are built (28 foot building width standard) 1 Lot: single building 2 Lots: L-shaped building 3+ Lots: U-shaped building
When space allows, up to 16 additional feet of width (8 per side) Offset distance of 5 feet maintained between structures
Building circulation cores at rear of empty lots Buildings infill reinforce the street wall Lots are combined, providing shared common spaces Four story height when adjacent existing Five story height when approaching corners
130
New Typologies in St. Louis Housing Seminar Old North St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri In collaboration with Aaron Foley Fall 2012 | GSAPP, Columbia University
In response to the extreme vacancy in Old North St. Louis, we developed three main strategies in order to infill these empty spaces. First, the poorly maintained service alleys will provide a network of residential spines within each block. We propose inserting a raised 5-6 story bar building raised above the current alley right-of-way, allowing pedestrian and cyclist to continue to move throughout but re-routing cars to only the main roadways. This bar building will expand in width where possible in order to allow for larger rooms. By inserting this spine we are able to use these corridors as another system of building entry, secondary to the streets. This bar also allows a new activation of the underused space of the backalleys. Secondly, we are proposing a reestablishment of the street-wall through new buildings. Since so many of the historic structures have been removed or destroyed, the historic street-wall is almost completely non-existent. We propose secondary housing to be built perpendicular to the alleyway spine and pulled flush with the facades of the existing, neighboring buildings in order to infill some vacancy and redensify the streetfront. At strategic points in the fabric (especially along the main boulevard) some of these structures may also hold commercial uses as well to provide a more active street-scape. Finally, the new structures transform the idea of a â&#x20AC;&#x153;private yardâ&#x20AC;? by creating a series of semi-private courtyards accessed from the newly developed alleyway. The spatial condition of the courtyard was developed in response to the number of sequential vacant lots. One lot produces a larger and smaller I-shape building, 2 - an L-shape, and 3 - a U-shape. These new buildings, along with the bar structure will allow for the combination of lots to provide new semi-private spaces to be shared by the residents. By stepping the new housing down toward the existing structure height, we are able to remain sympathetic to the existing scale and create some more private terraces, in exchange for the private yard. The proposed housing condition tries to respect the existing historic fabric, while infilling the extreme vacancy and preparing for a future of increased density in Old North St. Louis.
131
BAC
EXISTING
EY
K ALL
BAC
N
N
EXISTING SITE PLAN
EXISTING SITE AXONOMETRIC
St Louis, Missouri, United States / Aaron Foley, Scott Archer
St Louis, Missouri, United States / Aaron Foley, Scott Archer
OLD NORTH ST. LOUIS - 1968
CURRENT
Fabrics and Typologies: New York City - Global Instructor: Richard Plunz
Fabrics and Typologies: New York City - Global Instructor: Richard Plunz
PROPOSED
POSSIBLE RESIDENCE
MASSING STRATEGY
10’
HALL (unit access) RESIDENCE RESIDENCE HALL (unit access)
12’ BACK ALLEY
RESIDENCE 12’
ALLEY CLEARANCE UNIT 1 UNIT 2
28’ WIDTH
Multi-story stacked units with corridors needed only every third floor. 1 LOT
2 LOTS
BAR BUILDING SECTION
INCREASING DENSITY
EY
K ALL
EY
K ALL
BAC
3 LOTS
Combine lots to create defined shared outdoor spaces.
Reuse Of The “Back Alley” with an Elevated Residential Spine Steps to Respect Existing Scale while Increasing Density and FAR Reinforce the Street Wall 132
DIAGRAMS
PROPOSED
Historic Fabric N
PROPOSED SITE PLAN St Louis, Missouri, United States / Aaron Foley, Scott Archer
Fabrics and Typologies: New York City - Global Instructor: Richard Plunz
Historic Fabric 1968
PROPOSED SITE AXONOMETRIC St Louis, Missouri, United States / Aaron Foley, Scott Archer
Fabrics and Typologies: New York City - Global Instructor: Richard Plunz
Proposed Fabric
Total Project Area
640,000 sq ft
Total Building Lots
120
111
83
Number of Floors
1-3
1-3
1-6
Total Building Footprint
163,200 sq ft
Building Lot Coverage
33%
22%
41%
Total Number of Dwellings
104
65
195
Subject Lot Area / Dwellings
6154 sq ft / dwelling
Gross Floor Area
489,600 sq ft
Heights & Setbacks
32 ft
Usable Open Space
225,000 sq ft
FAR
.83
.45
1.85
Total Parking Area
2400 sq ft
Total Parking Spaces (Dwelling)
48
0 (Street Parking) 32
0 133
134
Doha: A Short History Recombinant Urbanism Seminar Doha, Qatar In collaboration with Vanessa Espaillat, Elaheh Kerachian, Devanshi Purohit, & Kristian Ricco Spring 2013 | GSAPP, Columbia University Doha, Qatar is a city-state off of the oil and natural gas rich Persian Gulf. Barely a city before the 1970’s, the Qatari government has orchestrated many massive construction projects and continues to build entire new sections of the city year-by-year. As a city with emmense natural resources in terms of energy, it lacks just about every other necessity. For water, the city relies on costly desalination processes, and for food the Qatari Sovereign Wealth Fund (SWF) has purchased land in many other countries including Indonesia, Australia, Brazil, and Kenya. Pretty much everything is imported, included people. Since Doha relies so heavily on imports the transportation infrastructure is focused around an expanding international airport. Advertised as 6 hours from everywhere, Doha is trying to position itself in the center of international commerce, trade, and information. The transportation infrastructure within the city is highly segregated (as most everything else) with Qataris & Americans using personal cars for most of their transportation and guest workers (usually men from India, Indonesia, or other South Asian countries) use public buses that drive directly from the worker’s city to their places of employment. This worker’s city houses about 800,000 people (mostly construction workers) of the 1.6 million people in the county, making the vast majority of the population foreigners. The heterotopias of malls are also culturally divided. Qatari-only and bachelor-banned malls are common, with classes legally divided between public spaces in the city. Because of the extreme climate these exists as some of the most frequented “public” spaces of the city. A hyper-reality is developing as extreme consumption and consumerism mix with the traditional values of the culture. For the future of the Qatari economy, the government has intentionally invested in creating a knowledge center with both Education City and Qatar University. Although Qataris are allowed and do attend Education City, there is a large portion of the student population imported from elsewhere. This focus on education is contrasts intensely with the rigid power structure of monarchy, that enforces very traditional Islamic values within the city. Made of a series of walled enclaves, like Education City, Doha builds beyond the megablock, to create “cities” within its borders. 135
City as a Machine
Lo New
nd
York
[12
Hou
Kuwait
Bahrain
UAE-Dubai
136
rs]
on
[0
6
Ho
03
ur
i[
s]
Mu
a mb
s]
ur
Ho
Enclaves & The Tele Cittรก
Qatar University
Education City
Co rn i
e ch
International Airport
Knowledge Economy
137
138
Travel Sketches Architectural Sketching in Italy Study Abroad Summer 2009 | School of Architecture, Mississippi State University
During a 6-week summer study abroad in Italy, I participated in a architectural sketching course. Focused on developing freehand sketching techniques, I sketched many historic and contemporary Italian architectural icons. This course was influential in developing how I see and analyze the physical world, especially in terms of scale, proportion, and materiality. The selected sketches included here are diagrams and drawings of the Palladiano in Vicenza, the Statue in Piazza dei Signori in Vicenza, Chiesa dei Carmini, “General’s House” in Vicenza, and Milano Duomo.
139
Sketches Left to Right: Statue in Piazza dei Signori in Vicenza Chiesa dei Carmini “General’s House” in Vicenze Milano Duomo Spire Milano Duomo Facade
140
141
142
Photography: Protesting Protests of the Arab Spring Washington, D.C. Spring 2011 | Washington Alexandria Architecture Center
On Saturday, January 29, 2011, dozens of citizens gathered in the capital of the most influential nation in the world. Red and white became increasingly dominant as the assembly multiplied. Gathering with a common goal and a known purpose, this team of people occupied two significant public spaces in Washington, D.C. in a manner that I had never experienced before. Now I was in the midst of this effort as a spectator, as an architecture and photography student, not included in the team, but definitely welcome. Inadvertently, I became a center of attention, as I held an official-looking camera, with its shutter in almost continuous motion, opening and closing to document this historic event. This intense, but peaceful, protest for Egyptian freedom allowed me to experience teamwork on a scale of which I had never been a part.
143
Arab Spring Protests in support of the People of Egypt, Bahrain, Libya, and Iraq, among others. Lafayette Square at the White House, & Egyptian Embassy (Washington, D.C.)
144
145
Arab Spring Protests in support of the People of Egypt, Bahrain, Libya, and Iraq, among others. Lafayette Square at the White House, & Egyptian Embassy (Washington, D.C.)
146
147