www.scross.co.za
September 28 to October 4 , 2011
R5,50 (incl VAT RSA) Reg No. 1920/002058/06
How media distortion harms women
Best friends: Priests and their pets
A good time to spring clean your life
Page 4
Page 10
Page 7
NEW SERIES STARTS THIS WEEK In this edition on page 9 we are inaugurating a yearlong weekly series of articles under the Hope&Joy banner. Written in alternating weeks by Southern Cross writer Claire Mathieson (left) and Fr Anthony Egan SJ (right) of the Jesuit Institute in Johannesburg, the series will cover a broad range of themes drawing from the teachings of the Second Vatican Council and how these relate to the mission of the Catholic Church in Southern Africa today. Ms Mathieson will report on how the council’s teachings find application in the Church; the following week Fr Egan will reflect on the same theme.
Back issues of every week’s edition will be available from Avril Hanslo at subscriptions@scross.co.za or 021 465 5007
Zuma, minister ‘disrespect SA’s Constitution’ BY CLAIRE MATHIESON
T
Farewell to winter: Two young pals from Linmeyer Marist College in Johannesburg get into the spirit of spring.
HE Public Protector’s recent findings of unlawfulness and corruption have been ignored by the national minister found guilty and by the president of the country—the only person able to enforce the rulings. Both the guilty parties and President Jacob Zuma, are in contempt of the Constitution, according to a Church analyst. Mike Pothier of the Catholic Parliamentary Liaison Office, an associated office of the Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference, said the legal arm of government relies for its effectiveness “chiefly on being accorded due respect by all elements of society. And the more powerful an element is, the more crucial it is that it should unambiguously demonstrate that respect”. But recent incidents by high-ranking government officials have undermined the Constitution through a complete lack of respect for both the departments involved in upholding South African laws and the Constitution itself. Mr Pothier was referring to the Public Protector’s finding that public works minister Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde acted unlawfully and was guilty of serious maladministration in connection with the leasing of two office buildings for the South African Police Services. Police commissioner Bheki Cele also came in for serious criticism for the R500 million lease agreement for the new police headquarters in Pretoria. Further reports from a Special Investigating Unit probe into the public works department reportedly have uncovered irregularities of about R3 billion. The Public Protector is an integral part of the legal system which contributes to the strengthening of constitutional rights and processes, Mr Pothier said. But neither the judiciary nor the State Institutions Supporting Democracy (called Chapter 9 Institutions)—which include the Public Protector, the Human Rights Commission, the Independent Electoral Commission and the Auditor General—have
ultimate power to enforce compliance with decisions and orders. The Chapter 9 institutions “rely largely on respect; and if their findings are not respected and complied with, their constitutional role—and thus the Constitution itself—is seriously undermined,” Mr Pothier said. But it was not just unlawful acts by ministers that are a problem, Mr Pothier said. The problem extends to those who have been given the responsibility to correct the issues. “The Public Protector set out a detailed list of actions that the various responsible people were to take. Among these were that President Zuma ‘is to consider taking action against the minister of Public Works’; that the minister must ‘report to cabinet within 60 days on her actions in relation to the procurement of the leases’; and that the minister of police should institute urgent action against SAPS officials—notably including the national commissioner—that were implicated in the unlawful and improper lease agreements.” Mr Pothier said both Ms MahlanguNkabinde and General Cele ignored the deadline. In many other democracies, high-ranking officials found guilty of multi-billion rand maladministration and unlawfulness would have resigned immediately, “and failing that, they would have been fired”, Mr Pothier said. “Unfortunately, in our democracy the tendency is rather for the condemned office-bearer to dig in his or her heels, to obfuscate, and to rely on political protection from their superiors.” Only President Jacob Zuma has the power to dismiss a minister or the national chief of police, Mr Pothier pointed out. However, “all he has done is to play for time by referring her reports to parliament, and by calling for ‘further information’ from some of those involved,” Mr Pothier said. “The necessary information is readily
Catholic school’s pupil wins gold for SA STAFF REPORTER
A
PUPIL of Holy Rosary School in Edenvale, Johannesburg won gold, silver and bronze medals in swimming events at the IV Commonwealth Youth Games 2011 for youth between ages 14-18, held on the Isle of Man, off the British coast. Kelly Gunnell (pictured right), a Grade 11 pupil at the school, won the gold medal in the 200m breaststroke with a time of 2:25:22. Kelly won a silver medal in the 100m breaststroke in a time of 1:08:26, finishing behind Northern
Ireland’s Sycerika McMahon, and earned a bronze medal in the 50m breaststroke with a time of 32:20. Sam Willis, official writer at the games, noted: “Gunnell demonstrated her immaculate efforts in the four-lap breast-stroke swim by submitting a time of 2 minutes and 25:22 seconds for the title of the event. Gunnell acquired secondfastest qualification spot in the qualifying rounds to enter the final, but her gruelling efforts in the final round placed her on the top of podium for gold medal…The crowd was impressed with the
No 4744
wonderful effort”. Kelly was one of two South African gold medallists in the pool. Marne Erasmus won in the 50m butterfly event. South Africa finished third on the medal table, behind England and Australia, with 30 medals, eight of them gold. Kelly has been swimming since she was seven years old. She rapidly moved up CGA levels and started swimming for her province at nine. “In the last 18 months Kelly has managed a very busy schedule of local and international competitions,” said Holy Rosary School’s PR
Kenda Knowles. “Kelly competed in Ireland in July 2010, where she medalled; and in Brazil in October 2010, where she won in the 200m breaststroke, among other medals. Next was the Zone VI Games in Swaziland, where she won three gold medals. In March this year, she took part in South African National Championships in Durban, once again winning numerous medals; in April she participated in the South African seniors in Port Elizabeth.” Kelly swims with the Mandeville Dolphins Club, coached by Dean Price.
Continued on page 3