April 25 to May 1, 2012
Vatican wants answers to case of missing teen
Page 4
www.scross.co.za
New books reviewed
R5,50 (incl VAT RSA)
Reg No. 1920/002058/06
No 4772
Why getting to know God is like dating
Pages 14-15
Page 9
Church to Zuma: Send Secrecy Bill to Concourt BY CLAIRE MATHIESON
P
RESIDENT Jacob Zuma should use a presidential prerogative to send the Protection of State Information Bill to the Constitutional Court to review its constitutionality, according to the Catholic Church. The overwhelming opposition from civil society to the Bill means that if the bill is passed in its current form, “it will be taken to the Constitutional Court”, said Mike Pothier of the Catholic Parliamentary Liaison Office. The vast majority of constitutional experts, lawyers, academics, all predict at least some of the central aspects of the Bill will be found unconstitutional,” he said, adding that the likes of Cosatu already had their lawyers ready to stand. “What this means is a serious degree of doubt about the constitutionality of the Bill. Fortunately section 79 of the Constitution allows for such a situation—if the president has doubts about a bill’s constitutionality, before he signs it into law he can refer it to the Constitutional Court for a decision,” Mr Pothier told The Southern Cross. President Zuma should avoid the extreme expense, time and effort by sending it to court himself, Mr Pothier said. “This would be an important sign of good faith—that the government wants the best possible information law, and that it is prepared to subject its provisions to the judgment of the court before it becomes and Act.” He added that it would also save the government from the potential embarrassment of having the Court overturn the Act. “It would also avoid the situation that Parliament is now facing of having to redo the whole process, which is currently happening with the South African Police Services Ammendment Bill about the independence of the Hawks.” Mr Pothier made that point when he and Archbishop Stephen Brislin of Cape Town, second vice president of the Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference (SACBC), presented the Catholic Church’s submission to National Council of Provinces Ad-hoc Committee on March 30. “The reaction of the committee [to the Catholic Church’s submission] was very positive and the chairman expressed his gratitude and praised the presentation,” Archbishop Brislin said. He said the committee appreciated the Church’s presentation which provided prac-
tical problem-solving proposals, and its unique suggestion of encouraging the president to act first was hailed as extremely important. Archbishop Brislin said that the Church is not opposed to the Bill in its entirety. “But the Bill in its current state does erode democracy and freedom and any erosion on these fronts is bad.” He said it was worthwhile to take a stand on this issue, and noted that once again South Africa has shown it has a strong civil society. “It’s good to see people letting their opinions be known.” The archbishop said it is also good that Catholics know where the Church stands on the matter. “This Bill is of ongoing concern to the bishops. The ordinary man on the street can be proud of where we stand and the action we’ve taken.” The presentation followed a call to the public to submit their thoughts on the Secrecy Bill before it is signed into law. Of the 260 submissions received, all but one were opposed the bill. The Catholic Church in its submission called for President Zuma to act lawfully, practically and in good faith—a call which was hailed by those at the hearing. Both Archbishop Brislin and Mr Pothier said the Church understands the need for the state to have secrets and not much in the Bill needs changing, but there are some areas of great concern, which is why the Church is taking a stand. “The right to information is a vital part of the promotion of these core values in society. If information is unduly withheld from us, we do not really have the freedom we need in order to exercise our other rights. And if some in society are unable to exercise their rights fully, then there is a situation of inequality between them and others,” the Church’s submission said. Mr Pothier told The Southern Cross that there are aspects of the bill that threaten these values. “It allows too much to be hidden from the public; unintentionally, it may allow corruption and maladministration to be covered up; it will create a situation of inequality between well-placed people who have access to important information and others who lack access. “This law will have a cross-cutting effect on all other rights. If you can’t access information, it will become difficult to exercise all other rights,” said Mr Pothier.
Church offers protection training
T
HE Catholic Church is initiating community protection groups in Karachi, Pakistan to safeguard minorities in a city where political violence has claimed more than 100 lives in recent weeks, the Asian Church news agenct UCA News reports. The Justice and Peace Commission Major Superiors Leadership Conference of Pakistan (MSLCP), which organised the programme, said the first ecumenical group in the southern archdiocese consists of lawyers and other professionals. The Catholic Church is already oversee-
ing ten such other teams across the country. Rasheed Gill, the regional MSLCP animator, said the worsening security situation in Pakistan’s most populous city has prompted the need to support and protect marginalised minorities. “We shall record human rights violations and provide legal aid to victims especially workers and women,” he said. “Fear has driven me to join this group,” said Zafar Malik a former Caritas worker. “We can not afford to have clashes based on religious or political affiliations. However training helps us to understand the need for basic rights and necessities.”
Pope Benedict prays with his brother, Mgr Georg Ratzinger in his private chapel at the Vatican during the monsignor’s visit from his home in Regensburg, Germany, to Rome. (Photo: L’Osservatore Romano via Reuters/CNS)
Reds celebrate 100 years in SA STAFF REPORTER
F
IVE bishops, including a Vatican official, stood at the altar of Holy Redeemer church in Bergvliet, Cape Town, at a Mass to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the arrival of the Redemptorists in South Africa. The Mass in the packed church was celebrated by Bishop Kevin Dowling of Rustenburg, a Redemptorist, while the order’s former general superior and present secretary of the Vatican’s Congregation for Consecrated Life, Archbishop Joseph Tobin, preached the sermon. Concelebrating with them were Archbishop Stephen Brislin of Cape Town, his predecessor Archbishop Lawrence Henry, and retired auxillary Bishop Reginald Cawcutt, as well as Redemptorist and visiting priests. The prelates and priests met with parishioners at a function in the parish hall after the Mass. To celebrate the centenary, Redemptorists from communities in Johannesburg, Cape Town, KwaZulu-Natal and Rustenburg gathered in the Bergvliet monastery for a Province Assembly, which was also attended by confreres from Zimbabwe, Nigeria, Britain, the United States and Rome. “The Province Assembly began by a day devoted to the past. This was led by the provincial, Fr Larry Kaufmann, and involved an exercise in ‘family memories’ of the lives and works of Redemptorists down the years,” said Fr Seán Wales CSsR, current parish priest of Bergvliet. The next two days were led by Archbishop Tobin, with discussions on crucial issues in religious life today. “He highlighted questions surrounding the identity of religious, the primacy of God in religious life and the meaning of fraternal life in community,” Fr Wales said. “He also spoke about obedience as an axial vow in the consecrated life,” Fr Wales said. “He made an interesting claim about the difficulty of being an obedient religious in a disobedient community. A disobedient community would be one which did not listen to the Word or God or to the presence of Christ at the heart of the community. The importance of the community context in living the vow of obedience became evident.” On the last day of the assembly, looking
(From left) Archbishop Lawrence Henry, Archbishop Joseph Tobin CSsR, Bishop Kevin Dowling CSsR, Archbishop Stephen Brislin and Bishop Reginald Cawcutt give a blessing at a Mass celebrating the centenary of the Redemptorists in South Africa. (Photo: Sibyl Morris) to the future, Archbishop Tobin led his confreres “in a Redemptorist reading of the postsynodal Apostolic Exhortation Africae Munus, stressing the place of reconciliation, justice and peace in the Redemptorist charism”, Fr Wales said. “Put in its simplest form, he summed up Africae Munus in two imperatives: ‘Stay Spiritual’ and ‘Stay Catholic’! By the former he meant that while we engage at all levels of human interest we do not become an explicitly political movement; by the latter he meant that we should not succumb to a form of inculturation which baptises heterodox beliefs and practices,” Fr Wales said. The final presentation focused on hope. “Archbishop Tobin presented a biblical profile of hope, stressing confidence, expectation, patience and commitment. With Jesus our hope and the Church a sacrament of hope we can continue the work of redemption, liberation and transformation,” Fr Wales said. In 1912 three Redemptorist priests—Frs Thomas Creagh, John Burke and Leo Kirk— stepped off the boat in Cape Town and moved to Pretoria where they settled and began their apostolic outreach. “Over the years Redemptorists have laboured in many parts of the country and have preached parish missions not only in South Africa but in many neighbouring countries as well,” Fr Wales said.