130717

Page 1

The

S outher n C ross

July 17 to July 23, 2013

Ex-prisoner now works for People of God

Page 3

www.scross.co.za

R6,00 (incl Vat RSa)

Reg No. 1920/002058/06

No 4832

A 100-yearlong spiritual life recalled

JP2 miracle woman on her healing

Page 10

Page 5

Mixed reaction to bishops’ book on sex By ClaIRE MatHIESoN

W

HILE the Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference has said that the book God: Love, Life and Sex, written by the country’s five metropolitan archbishops and published in June, has been well received and has already been sold out in some dioceses, a priest has called for the book to be rewritten. The book was a response to the “most urgent pastoral priorities for the Catholic Church in Southern Africa” identified as marriage and family life, faith formation of the laity and youth ministry. The book, laid out in a simple, easy to read format, is intended to serve a “guide and resource”. But Fr Christopher Clohessy of Cape Town, former rector of the now defunct archdiocesan St Francis Xavier seminary, said the book contains “impracticalities, unsubstantiated claims and weak theology”. “I am unconvinced that an all-male group of celibates should be drilling people in matters of sex and marriage. This is surely the work of competent lay theologians, men and women alike,” Fr Clohessy wrote in a review that went viral on the social media. “But even if I am wrong, I am entirely convinced the South African bishops could have done an immeasurably better job,” he said in his critique. The critique was first sent to Archbishop Stephen Brislin of Cape Town, followed by a few theologians, “many of whom agreed with what I was saying”, said Fr Clohessy. He said that he had not intended his critique “to go out the way it did”. The priest said the subject of the book does not address the important issues faced by families today. “Sex is not an issue of the day. People paying bills, that’s a problem. Violence, crime, corruption—these are concerns. The bishops need to speak on this. They don’t need the answers, but they need to be shepherds and tackle those issues.” But the bishops don’t agree. Archbishop William Slattery of Pretoria, spokesman of the bishops’ conference, said Fr Clohessy’s critique implied the bishops were out of contact with the ordinary experience of countless South Africans. “The Church is continually dealing with the daily needs of ordinary South Africans. Every diocese in the country has projects of all kinds: kindergartens, homes for disabled children, feeding schemes, skills centres, places for abused women and children, shelters, and

Priests hear confessions as people gather outside a Catholic church for services marking the feast of the icon of the Mother of God in the village of Budslav, Belarus. Catholics from Belarus and neighbouring countries marked the 400th anniversary of the revered Marian icon during celebrations that spanned three days. (Photo: Vasily Fedosenko, Reuters/CNS) schools. The bishops are continually involved in all these schemes,” Archbishop Slattery said. Archbishop Slattery, one of the contributors to the book, said the publication is not “an encyclopaedia” but is intended as a resource. Fr Clohessy said that the book is not without merit, describing the chapter on abortion as “well expressed”. He criticised the book for lacking lay theologian voices. “One cannot publish anything in today’s world without consultation,” he said. The book’s authors say they had consulted widely. Fr Clohessy said the weakest section of the book is its treatment of same-sex issues. “The text uses ‘same-sex attraction’, ‘same-sex friendship’ and ‘same-sex relationship’ almost

interchangeably, despite these being very different things,” said Fr Clohessy. Archbishop Slattery said that the book and the Catechism of the Catholic Church point out that “homosexual attractions and homosexual activity are a wide-spread phenomenon in the world today and have been for thousands of years. The bishops are quite clear that wonderful friendships exist and enrich people of the same sex. What the Church has difficulty with is when the relationship between two people of the same gender involves sexual expression.” Explaining his decision to write a critique of the book, Fr Clohessy said sometimes it’s important to not remain quiet on certain issues. “The bishops don’t like to be wrong, but it’s not disloyal to inform them when they are wrong,” he said.

“I’m in favour of Church teachings, but we need to position this correctly,” Fr Clohessy said. “People have the right to good spiritual theology. St Paul writes theology that can be lived. Things in this book cannot be lived and will just increase our guilt.” He advised the bishops to rewrite the book. “Argue your points, consult widely with lay theologians—male and female. Argue and prove your point; don’t just throw it out there and expect Catholics to listen simply because the bishops said so,” he said. Archbishop Brislin, who as head of the archdiocese of Cape Town is Fr Clohessy’s ordinary, was out of the country and could not be reached for comment by the time of going to press. n God: Love, Life and Sex can be ordered at R40 at www.godandlife.co.za

Indulgences for Youth Day By CaRol Glatz

T

Dominican Father Brian Ndabaningi Mhlanga was ordained in Malawi by archbishop tarcisius ziyaye of Blantyre who, a few days afterwards, was appointed archbishop of lilongwe. Fr Mhlanga returns to Emaphethelweni priory in Pietermaritzburg where he has been studying.

O help encourage prayers for a spiritually fruitful World Youth Day (WYD) in Rio de Janeiro this month, the Vatican has announced that Pope Francis authorised a special indulgence for those who attend the event’s liturgies and prayer services or follow along online in the proper spirit of prayer and contrition. Pope Francis decreed that WYD participants can receive one plenary, or full, indulgence a day if they meet the usual conditions. WYD runs from July 23-28; the pope arrives on July 22. An indulgence is a remission of the temporal punishment a person is due for sins that have been forgiven. The conditions necessary for receiving a plenary indulgence include having recently gone to confession, receiving the Eucharist

and offering prayers for the intentions of the pope. The faithful must also carry the proper spirit of being “truly repentant and contrite” and participate in the gathering’s sacred events and “pious exercises” with prayerful devotion. Those who are “legitimately prevented” from being physically present in Rio may also obtain the indulgence as long as they meet the same prayerful and “spiritual and sacramental conditions” as well as participate “in spirit” in the sacred liturgies and prayer services via television, radio or “new means of social communication”, the decree said. The decree, signed by Cardinal Manuel Monteiro de Castro, head of the Vatican office that deals with indulgences, said a partial indulgence is also available to all Catholics who, no matter where they are, offer prayers with the pope for young Catholics.—CNS


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.